<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<itemContainer xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/browse?collection=65&amp;output=omeka-xml&amp;sort_field=added" accessDate="2026-11-20T20:48:19+00:00">
  <miscellaneousContainer>
    <pagination>
      <pageNumber>1</pageNumber>
      <perPage>20</perPage>
      <totalResults>132</totalResults>
    </pagination>
  </miscellaneousContainer>
  <item itemId="2494" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3475">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/2e011644a81d9b5d1f5098b368067d62.pdf</src>
        <authentication>f9cfd6de124fa208933a40170527aef4</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12338">
                    <text>THE OLD-TIME
HERALD

A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED
VOLUME 5.

IN

THIS ISUES:

ZWIGOFF/N.C.

BOWING
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

TO

OLD-TIME MUSIC

FALL

NUMBER

1,

"POCKETS OF

ECCENTRICITY"--

1995

FIDDLER BENTON FLIPPEN/25

WORKSHOP/REVIEWS/ISSUES/DANCE

$5.00

WITH TERRY

AN INTERVIEW

ESSENTIAL RECORDINGS/

BEAT/&amp;

MORE

�MARIMAC

Continuing traditions

NEW RELEASES

MORE OF THE BEST IN OLD TIME MUSIC

Tracy Schwarz

Ginny Hawker

&amp;

Deep Hollows and High Ridges

Breathtaking, lovely, powerful --like the mountains in which
they live. Ginny and Tracy sing the southern mountain styles
"

mixture of joy and
Together they bring forth
and
a
that
the
sadness,
ray of hope
uplifts
spirit... like an old
the
singer has
song that keeps on singing, long after
they love.

a

gone. "--Hazel Dickens.

Compact disc: 9063D... .$15.00

Andy Cohen
Grinnin

'

Cassette: 9063C....$9.00

&amp;

Dave Rice

In Your

Bruce Hutton

Face

a

few tunes.

$9.00

a gifted solo performer and a member of the Double
Decker Stringband, is joined by more musical talent in this
renaissance performance of old time and jug band music.
Cassette: 9032C....$9.00. (Also to be released on CD)

Bruce,

Free catalog:

a complete
list of our recordings including
old-time music, old-time reissues, early bluegrass, early
country blues, Celtic, Cajun, and contemporary folk.

Fax

The Rhythm Rats
PRETTY CROWIN' CHICKEN
play and sing southern mountain music in fine old-time style-- rich
harmonies and driving fiddle tunes. Paula Bradley, Kenny Jackson,

219-662-6880

in

order

Please send check for recordings plus shipping
Marimac Recordings, Inc.
P.O. Box 447, Crown Point, IN 46307

Shipping and handling:
USA: $2 for 1-2 items, $3 for 3-5 items, $4 for 6+ items.
Non USA: Add $2 per item (minimum of 2 items).

Indiana residents must add 5% sales tax.
Prices subject to change without notice.

sense of a thriving old-time music
which people trade tunes.. "MAR9061C...$9.00.

Jim Bowles
RAILROADING THROUGH THE ROCKIES
treasury of 23 years of historical (some rare) recordings of Jim
Bowles (1903-1993), a well-known, south-central Kentucky fiddler
and fretless banjo player. His wife, Zelma, plays a lovely fretless
banjo on some of the earlier cuts. Generous, informative notes by
Jim Nelson. Jim Bowles was featured in the Spring 1994 issue of
A

OTH.

finesse.

"Among my all time favorite

"--Kerry Blech

to:

fiddlers... power tempered

MAR 9060C.

with

$9. 00.

Lynn "Chirps" Smith
MIDWEST HARVEST
Chirps and a Midwest cast of old-time talent serve up a bounty of
fiddle tunes unique to the Midwest. Fiddle solos, duets, and larger
ensembles with a variety of backup instrumentation. A must
addition for any collection. "This is an absolute sonic treat and
it's nirvana for seekers of new tunes. This is not just a Chirps
album, it is a statement about midwestern old-time music and its
time has arrived. "--Kerry Blech

MAR 9059D

To

HOEDOWNS, AND HOKUM

"

community

Roll Out The Carpet

Phone 800-628-4507

HORNPIPES,

Charlie's superb skill with a fiddle is perfectly complimented by
Patt's eloquent piano. This is a duo to be reckoned with. Collectors
"The
will also appreciate the complete documentation of the tunes.
cassette will be of interest to everyone: it is highly recommended.
Stephen Davis. MAR 9062C. $9. 00.

Whit Mead. From OTH "..a

Revisit the early days of blues and gospel with Andy (guitar,
autoharp) and Dave (harmonica)-- their intuitive playing is
reminiscent of such classic players as DeFord Bailey, Son
House, Reverend Gary Davis, Big Jack Kennedy to name a
few. Lynn "Chirps" Smith (fiddle) joins in on
Cassette only. 8008C

Charlie Walden and Patt Plunkett

$15.00

MAR 9059C.

$9.00.

Bob Bovee and Gail Heil
COME OVER AND SEE ME SOMETIME
to the tradition and respectful of the integrity of the vintage
music they most enjoy, Bob and Gail play for our pleasure and for
theirs,-- such tunes as Walk Along John and Down On Penny's
Farm, "...these music partners have settled well into each other's
playing, they 're tight, they 're good, and it sounds like they 're
having fun too. They know that good old-time music doesn't have to
True

decorated

just played well, with affection and
$9.00
respect. "--Molly Tennebaum MAR9045
be

up,

We are grateful for your support as we continue to provide the fine quaCity music you have come to expect from

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

us.

�COMING IN THE NEXT
ISSUE OF THE OTH
Art Rosenbaum
West Virginia's Wilson Douglas

Rounder's 25th Vol.
Lauchlin

Shaw--

II

Old-Time

N. C. Fiddler
Reviews/Dance

Beat

...

&amp; More!

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�THE

OLD-TIME
LD-TIME HERALD
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
1812 House Avenue

Durham, NC 27707
Phone &amp; Fax: 919-416-9433
E-mail:

agerrard@nando.net
EDITOR

Alice Gerrard
ASSOCIATE EDITOR

Bill Hicks
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS

Phil Jamison,

Bob Smakula, Bob Carlin

ADVISORY BOARD

Ray Alden, Mac Benford, Hazel Dickens,
Hilary Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher, John Hartford,
Linda Higginbotham, Ramona Jones,

Garrison Keillor, Pete Kuykendall,
Brad Leftwich, W.

K.

Lee Smith, Pete Sutherland,

McNeil,
Charles Wolfe

OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Philip Gura, Tom Hargrove,
Dave Sheppard, Jim Watson,
Helen Whiting, Kathy World

Bob Cantwell,
Art Menius,

STAFF

Deb White
ADVERTISING

Rebecca Newton
No part of this magazine may be reproduced in
any form without written permission from the
publisher. Not responsible for loss or non-re
turn of

unsolicited photos

or

manuscripts.

1995 the Old-Time Herald.

The Old-Time

Herald (ISSN 1040358) (USPS
002672) is published quarterly the first of Au
gust, November, February, and May by the Old
Time Music Group, Inc., 1812 House Ave.,

Durham, NC 27707. Subscription rates payable
advance. Until Oct. 1 (see subscription form

in

on page 5): one
tions-$21 U.S.).

$18 (foreign

subscrip
Library/Institutional rate: one
year--

Classified ads cost 35 cents per
$21.
word, minimum of $5. Any grouping of letters
or numbers is counted as one word. All classi
year--

fied ads must be received

by the first of the

month, two mon ths prior to publication. Second
Class postage paid at Durham, NC 27701.
Postmaster: Send change
Time Herald, P.O. Box 51

8

of
12,

address
Durham,

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
profit,

to the

Old

NC27717.

is a

not-for

corporation under section
the Internal Revenue Code.

tax-exempt

501 (c) (3) of

The OTMG educates the public about, and
nurtures the development of, traditional and
neo-traditional music.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Response To Reviews
I

was glad to see The Spring of Sixty-Five:

Joseph Spenceand The Pinder Family included
for review in the OTH. However, I was

disappointed by the lack of substance in
the actual review and dismayed by the
misinformation included therein. None of
on this col
lection have everbeen released before, any
where.

the 13 recorded performances

Jody Stecher
San Francisco, CA

A

couple of days back

I

received

a

call from

friend and expert dancer from Chapel
Hill who telephoned me to report that a
an old

review had been published in the OTH
regarding a release of my Colorado field
recordings entitled A Calling Card for Friend
ship. This release centered upon field re
cordings that I made between the years
1982-1987 during my tenure as State Folklorist in Colorado. The reviewers, Jon and
Marcia Pankake, brought forth a few issues
which I think should be addressed, not
only because their reflections apply to that
review, but because they bring forth larger
issues that are relevant as we all approach
a new
millennium; a historic period in
which the lines between folk, popular, and
elite cultures are yet increasingly blurred,
and cultural traditions (as well as people)
continue to become more global, non-iso
lated, and constantly in motion.
First, I was very much amused by their
comments regarding cowboy poetry. Cow
boy poetry took formation in the West
during the mid to later 19th century. The
poetry was a way for working cowboys to
express their activities; their loves, their
fears, their lives, and their work. The con
cept

of

relaying

cultural information

through spoken, rhymed verse came from
earlier bardic traditions. It is time honored,
going back literally centuries in places such
as Africa (as done by Griots) and Europe.
Certain ballad scholars claim that such in
dividual bards were creators of some of the
ballads as included in the Francis James
Child compilation, The English and Scottish
Popular Ballads, while other scholars as

"communal" theory in which the
ballads were the creation of many persons
over time. Thus cowboy poetry should not
cribe to

a

"new" or an isolated, inde
pendent phenomenon. It is but one link in
a
long chain of rhymed narrative verse
be

viewed

as

a

which originally pre-dated the printing
press and harkens to a time when oral

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tradition was the only method of transmit
ting information from person-to-person

their lives over the airwaves of the "X"
radio stations from Mexico. The Pattersons

the review the Pankakes stated: "We

perform a repertoire and style of music that
some might only associate with Appala

and culture-to-culture.
In

must announce in advance our bias against
what Bose(sic) calls 'cowboy poetics.' Origi
nal recitations by aspiring cowpoke bards
inevitably strike us as pretentious dog

gerel, as hollow as a barroom set in a Re
public western and as relentless as the
Marlboro commercials in promoting the

tiresome stereotype of the self-conscious,
endlessly self-celebrating cowboy."
It is indeed true that a certain amount of
contemporary cowboy culture is self-con
scious and self-celebratory. Yet, that's also
true in bluegrass music, "old-time"

Appa

plethora of other cul
tural traditions throughout the world. Since
the nature of any tradition is based upon
lachian music, or

a

past models, then the carrying forth of any
tradition is intrinsically self-celebratory. I
seriously doubt that the Pankakes have
ever left the comfort of their upper
midwestern home to rub elbows with con

temporary working cowboys, but I have a
sneaking suspicion that most cowboys
would find the music favored
and/or per
formed by the Pankakes to be equally selfconscious and self-celebratory. As for the
statement that cowboy poetry is "doggerel,"
can only state that the uninformed or
uninitiated will always claim such state
I

ments about traditions with which they
have little contact. Symphonic violinists
may think that all fiddle times sound alike.
Fans of "Bing Crosby-like" crooners in the
1950s stated that all rock and roll

late

sounded

alike, etc. The fact that the
Pankakes would use a term such as "dog
gerel" for an extremely celebrated and cen
turies-old tradition that they have had little
direct contact with is, in the end, wildly
elitist and remarkably provincial for people
who have been given the task of reviewing

body of multi-cultural performances in a
(hopefully) intelligent and broad-minded
manner.
The Pankakes continued their review by
stating that some of the performers repre
sented in the collection have an "unclear
a

relationship"

to

Colorado, other than the

chia

and/or the southeastern United States.

and bred
south westerners
who learned part of their music from the
same "border radio" broadcasts that aired
early Carter family and Uncle Dave Ma
con. Ray and Ina left Texas and New Mexico
to make their home in Colorado many de
cades ago, yet the Pankakes seem to feel
that their relationship to that state is
Yet,

they are born

unclear,

as if

Anglo-American "country"

"old-time" music could not exist in
that state. Perhaps the Pankakes would
rest easier if Ray and Ina had no formalized
education, lived in rural North Carolina,
and wore bibbed overalls while making
and/or

their living hunting possum. Then, per
haps, certain stereotyped and romantically

mythical paradigms might "compute."
The Pankakes also question fiddler Eddie
Henson, who they state "learned his fid
dling in Illinois." While it's true that Eddie
Hensen was born in Illinois, he moved to
Colorado in 1937. That fact is stated in the
book that accompanied the release.
I recorded
Eddie, he had
been living in Colorado for over 50 years.
48-page

At the time that

That means over 50 years worth of trading
musical and cultural licks with his friends
and neighbors. To even the most conserva
tive, 50 (+) year's worth of residence in a
state should make anyone "fair game" from
which to collect cultural data. It is a fact that
Anglo-American people did not settle in
Colorado until late in the 19th century.
Prior to that, Anglo peoples who were in
Colorado were there to work temporarily

mines, as fur trappers, on cattle drives
which went through that state, and the like.
In short, Eddie Henson lived in that state
about 50% of the time period in which there
has been permanent Anglo settlement. The
same is true of other Anglo-American
musicians such as H. L. Hayes and Dan
Cormier who the Pankakes also questioned
in terms of a relevance to Colorado. Hayes
and Cormier, also, have been long-time
residents who brought musical abilities
with them many decades ago upon their
in the

fact that they were

movement

and Ina were born in the states of Texas and

Curiously, the Pankakes did not allow
for the free and open migration of Spanish
speaking people and their traditions. In
their review the Pankakes pay homage to

present in that state
when I recorded them. For example, the
Pankakes directly question Ray and Ina
Patterson's relationship to Colorado. Ray
New Mexico, states which rest in close
proximity to, and share borders with, Colo
rado. They heard "country" music early in

"an

to that state.

evolving (Spanish speaking peoples)

tradition which passes back and forth across
(continued on next page)

�ex

beautiful, meaningful, and relevant tradi

ample, A Calling Card for Friendship fea
tured the music of two brothers, Tony and
Pablo Zamarripa, who play a style of music

tions, and they all had a place "in the mix."
Therefore, their traditions were shared and

state and national borders." As one

called huapangos from the region of San
Luis Potosi, Mexico, which is their birth
place. It doesn't bother the Pankakes that

Tony and Pablo are from Mexico and now
live in Colorado, yet they question many

Anglo-American's relevance to that state,
although each of the aforementioned Anglo
persons have lived in Colorado longer than
eitherTony or Pablo. In short, the Pankakes
feel that in-migration

and importation

of

as equal partners in the citizen
ship of that great state, and I viewed their
multi-cultural traditions as a fine stew, each
individual part adding a little spice and

celebrated

flavor to the whole within the geo-political
boundaries of the state.
Finally, I would like to mention that the
Pankakes consistently spelled my name
incorrectly throughout their entire review.
My name is David A. Brose, not "Bose." At
I
thought "no big deal." As my name

first,

traditions from other regions is okay for
the Spanish speaking people, but not the
Anglos.
In the end life, culture and folk tradition,
anywhere is based upon in-and-out mi

appeared many times throughout the book
let that accompanies this release, and as it
was always spelled correctly in that book
let, one must wonder how thorough the
Pankakes were in their seemingly rushed

gration and related syncretisms. We have
Tex-Mex music because, among other fac
tors, Mexican people met with Germans in
Texas, got the accordion from them, and
applied it to their own music. If the
Pankakes were given the task of reviewing
a Tex-Mex musical release, would they be
so provincial as to state that the Mexican-

and

American/ Anglo-American

syncretisms

Texas, because the Ger
man folk were not originally from there.
And what of the five-string banjo? Do they

relevant

are not

to

it is not relevant to North Carolina
Virginia mountain tradition because it
came from Africa, and is therefore not origi
nally indigenous to the mountains?
Many world cultures first migrated from
somewhere, and are further headed for

feel that

or

someplace.

Traditions do indeed

boundaries/countries/continents

skip
and

world cultural groups, and the "gray ar

eas" thus created are what comprise much
of folklore. Colorado, like anywhere, has a
true cultural diversity because of the people

who have chosen to live there.

If

Colorado's

citizenry are residents, if they pay taxes
there and have chosen to raise their chil
dren and make their homes in that state,
then they are Coloradans. During my ten
I feel that I was wise

ure as State Folklorist,
in not

differentiating between those who

were in that state "early on" (such as the

American

Indian

or

Spanish-Colonial
in the settle

people), those who continued

ment of that state in the later 19th century
(like the Irish,

Slovenians, German-Rus

sians and African

Americans)

and those

who came late in the 20th century (like the
H'mong and other Southeast Asian immi
grants after the American War on Viet
nam). To me, all of Colorado's people had

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ill-conceived investigation of these

admittedly diverse traditions, cultures, and
the man who documented them.
David A. Brose

Manager/Folklore and Development
Programs
John C. Campbell Folk School

Brasstozvn, North Carolina
The

discrepancy

in the

spelling of Mr. Brose's

name should have been caught during the
ed.]
ing. I apologize for the error.

edit

�SUPPORT THE FOLKS WHO ADVERTISE IN THE OLD-TIME
HERALD and tell them you saw their ad in our magazine.
PLEASE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

THE

n-year

HERALD

OLD-TIME

$18

*2-years $34
PO Box 51812

Durham, NC 27717
919-416-9433 phone

&amp;

'Foreign: $21
&amp;

FAX

*Note: Price increase as of Oct.

e-mail: &lt;agerrard@nando.net&gt;

$20

&amp;

$38; Foreign $25

&amp;

EH

$40 U.
1,

1995 to

$48.

(Please Print)
by: VISA EH

Payment
Name (as

it

MasterCard EH

Check EH

appears on card)

Address
City, State, Zip
Credit Card Number

Expiration Date
Signature
Day Telephone
If

this is

a

gift, fill in recipient's name

&amp;

address here:

S.

Other EH

�Here &amp; There

by John

Currie

Events
The Goldsboro

(NC) Community Arts
Council announces their First Annual Folk

Festival on Saturday, Sept. 16 in Herman
Appearing will be old-time string
band The Floyd Pond Ramblers, old-time
Park.

Rachel Nelson,

fiddler/banjo player

bluesman Scott Ainslie, Mike Casey &amp; Dave
DiGiuseppi, storyteller Gran'daddy Junebug
(Mitch Capel), bluegrass band Ric-O-Chet
and the Cultural Movement African Dance
Company. INFO: 919-736-3300.
Bob

Livingston of Middletown, CT, re

ports that square dancing to live music is
alive in central Massachusetts, with regu
lar dances in Heath and Bernardston. INFO:
Bob

Livingston,

Middletown,

1029

Long

Hill Rd.,

CT 06457.

The Santa Barbara Society for Traditional
Music announces its 24th Annual Old Time

Fiddlers' Convention
Oct.

8,

to be

held Sunday,

1995. This event, one of the oldest in

California, will feature competition in
fiddle, old-time banjo, string band, oldtime singing, and miscellaneous instru
ments. The event will be held on the
grounds of the Stow House in Goleta, CA.
INFO: 805-962-0830.
Meadowfest, an all-day celebration of
community, music, dance, storytelling,
and the environment happens on Sat. Sept.

Saxapahaw, NC 15 miles west of
Chapel Hill. INFO: Haw River Assembly
919-542-5790.
29-30
the 2nd Annual
On Sept.
Carolina's Homecoming will take place at
Paramount's Carowinds Campground in
Charlotte, NC and will include fiddle and
9

in

singer-songwriter

contests. INFO: Rose

Spinks 704-393-3881 (lv. msg.)
The Museum of Appalachia's 16th An
nual Tennessee Fall Homecoming is
scheduled for Oct. 12-15 at the Museum in
Norris, TN. The event includes old-time
music as well as craft &amp; trade demonstra
tions. INFO: 615-494-7680.

Some of the workshop leaders at Clifftop
(Camp Washington Carver, Clifftop, WV,
Aug. 3-6) are J. P. Fraley, Wilson Douglas,

Melvin Wine and Ralph Blizard. The fea
tured performers for the Sunday concert
are Molsky, Stefanini and Smith.
On May 6 &amp; 7, there was a birthday party
and memorial to Larry MacBride, spon
sored by Marimac Records, the company
he

founded.

Berea (KY) College's 22nd Annual Cel
ebration of Traditional Music will feature

symposium on legendary fiddler Ed Haley
presented by John Hartford. The Celebra
tion (Oct. 27-29) will also include perfor
mances by John, J. P. &amp; Annadeene Fraley,
Ginny Hawker &amp; Kay Justice, the Rabbit
Hash String Band, Carl Rutherford and
a

others. INFO: 606-986-9341, ext. 5140.
The Abingdon (VA) William King Re
gional Arts Center has added the Living

Traditions Series to its lineup. Performers
have included Ray Hicks, Mike Seeger, the
Konnarock Critters, and Kay Justice; still to
come are Ralph Stanley (Aug. 5), John Jack
son (Aug. 13), and Sheila Kay Adams, Jim
Taylor, Doug &amp; Jack Wallin, and Johnny
Ray Hicks (Sept. 17). INFO: 703-628-5005.
The Ryman

Auditorium

in

Nashville,

ful, but

well-attended, with about

300

ad

missions. The festival included concerts,
music and dance workshops, and string
band, fiddle and banjo competitions. Robin
Gillam of Wales won 1st place in both
instrument contests. Tom &amp; Ben Paley and
Sara Grey were the featured artists for the
festival and provided leadership for some
appears to have been
determined group of
old-time musicians and we wish them the
of the
a

workshops.

It

very good start for

a

very best.
A

mini-festival of old-time music and

dance will be held on Nov. 4 at the Stone
Soup Coffeehouse at the Gloria Dei
Lutheran Church in Providence, RI. Per
formers and workshop leaders will include
Jean Ritchie, Cari Norris, Chris Bischoff,
and Lorraine Lee Hammond. INFO: 401-

826-7743/781-0061.
Lake Genero in northeastern PA will be
a "festival without a stage" to be
held on Sept. 1-4. In addition to the jam
sessions there will be clogging demonstra

the site of

TN, is the site of another series of bluegrass

tions and workshops, a Saturday night
dance, and fiddle, banjo, and guitar work

Watson, The Cox Family and Ralph Stanley.
The Lake Eden Arts Festival will be held

shops. INFO: Appalachian Friends of OldTime Music, PO Box 201, Lake Hill, NY
12448-0201, or Ross West 914-232-4657/

concerts this summer, including Doc

at Camp Rockmont in Black
Gor
Mountain, NC. Performers will include

Oct. 20-22

don Freeman, Rich Hartness, Alice Gerrard,
Steve Riley &amp; The Mamou Playboys, Patrick

Cathy Sky, Lightning Wells, Algia Mae
Willett Hinton, Wild Asparagus, and
others. INFO: 377 Lake Eden Rd., Black
&amp;

&amp;

Mountain, NC 28711; 704-684-8742; email
&lt;leaf@mercury.interpath.net&gt;.
PoorFarmers Farms in Stuart,

VA,

owned

operated by Felicia Shelor presents mu
sic on the weekends. Recently, Benton
Flippen &amp; the Smokey Valley Boys were
&amp;

the featured artists. The Stuart area seems

with old-time mu
group called the Second

Send items for inclusion in Here &amp; There to:
Here &amp; There, The Old-Time Herald, PO Box

determined

51812, Durham, NC 27717.

Generation Dry Hill Draggers.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

In the last issue of OTH we noted a
festival put on by the Friends of American
Old-Time Music and Dance in
Gainsborough, England. Well, it seems that
the event was not only musically success

to carry on

sic; there's now

a

679-6170.
The 3rd

Annual Western New England

Old Time &amp; Bluegrass Music Champion
ships will be held on the campus of the
Berkshire School in Sheffield, MA on Aug.
26. INFO: Paul Kleinwald 413-528-4252/
528-2553
The annual Folkfest at the Fort will take
place on Aug. 19 at the Fort Omaha Cam

pus of Metropolitan

Community College
Omaha, NE. Performers will include
Odetta, Cathy Barton &amp; Dave Para,
Rivertown String Band, Mariachi Zapata,
Beseda Czech Dancers, and others. INFO:
Debra Emery 402-449-8414.
There will be a benefit concert on Nov. 3
in

�Appalachian Regional Music Col

West Virginia Univ.-a
but
underfunded
collection
of
field
great

Sweetest Gift" from their Rounder LP was
played during the recent network TV mini
series dramatization of the Judds' lives and

recordings, photos, and literature centered

careers.

for the

lection located

at

around Appalachia. Featured performers
will be Melvin Wine, Wilson Douglas, Dave

Bing &amp; Friends, and Ginny Hawker &amp;
Friends. It will be held on the WV Univ.

Campus
Morgantown. INFO: Chris
Haddox 304-296-2415, or Leslie Green
304-291-0174 or 292-1129.
in

Artists

&amp;

Agents

The Heartbeats

Rhythm Quartet

is

pur

suing an active touring schedule this sum
mer, recently appearing in Asheville,

Greenville and Nashville (NC, SC

&amp;

TN,

Even if you don't live in a
"ville," watch for them in your area!
Cliff Perry &amp; Laurel Bliss, a Seattlebased old-time duo, performed for the

respectively).

Charlotte (NC) Folk Music Society and at
Carter Fold with the
Wayne Henderson
Band in May.
OTH editor Alice Gerrard and Hazel

the

Dickens performed "The Sweetest Gift,

A

Mother's Smile" as a surprise for host
Naomi Judd at Fan Fair in Nashville on
June 9th. The Judds have often credited
Hazel &amp; Alice's recordings as important
influences on their singing style, and 'The

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Bad Livers

days on

a

are on the road

tour which stretches from

El

these
Paso

Austin by way of Phoenix, L. A., Se
attle, New Orleans, and Atlanta. Interest
ing sense of direction, what? Incidentally,
the Bad Livers is (are?) online now at
to

&lt;banjo68660@aol.com&gt;.
This year's Adams Ave. Roots Festival in
San Diego (CA) featured Mike Seeger, Jody
Stecher &amp; Kate Brislin, Frank Proffitt, Jr.,
the Kenny Hall Band, Bob Bovee &amp; Gail
Heil, Glenn Ohrlin, and the Iron Mt. String
Band.

David Holt will be appearing

at a

num

ber of storytelling festivals this fall, includ
ing Mansfield, PA, Sullivan's Island, SC,
Anchorage, AK and Jonesboro, TN, in ad

dition

to his concert appearances.
Bob Carlin and John Hartford have just
completed a week-long tour of Japan, ap
pearing at three clubs and a festival. Bob

that, while the old-time interest
is
not large, it is very enthusiastic
group
and that they had "a really great time."
Among his other activities, Bob is set to do

reports

a

video for Homespun sometime

in July.

The Mountain Music Jamboree at Bur
gess' Barn in Laurel Springs, NC, has show

cased many local bands in their concert
and dance series including the Grayson

Band, Wayne Henderson &amp;
Konnarock
Friends,
Critters, Fox Creek
Ramblers and Larry Sigmon &amp; Barbara

Highland

Poole. INFO: Arvil Scott 910-384-4079.
The

Hemrick Family, of Rural Hall, NC,

recently appeared on a segment of "The
American Skyline" on TNN. They have
performed in the Piedmont area of North
Carolina for many years.

Among

those

performing

at

the

Wheatland Traditional Arts Camp in
Remus, MI were Chirps Smith, Dot
Kent, the Bone Tones, Robin &amp; Linda Wil
liams, and Ron Buchanan.
Among those who have performed for
their supper and tips at the Rock Cafe in
Marshall, NC are Alice Gerrard, Hilary
Dirlam, Gail Gillespie, Malcolm and
Vicky Owen, Don Pedi, and the Sim Top
Ramblers. The Rock Cafe features gour
met cooking and a pleasant and low-key
atmosphere. INFO: 704-649-3810.
The

University of California Riverside
a series of fall concerts
including

will host

Jody Stecher and Kate Brislin on Oct. 8, a
(continued on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

but

a

Out!."

1

2-page "Thumbnail History of Sing
The

issue

is a

vailable

for

$200

from

Sing

Out! Reprint, PO Box 5253, Bethlehem, PA

18105.
The Blue Ridge Institute

at

Ferrum Col

notes the restoration
lege
and display of a painting entitled The Fifth
String, depicting Council &amp; John Cruise of
in Ferrum, VA,

Damascus, VA, playing banjo on a front
porch. The Cruises were performers at the
Grayson Co. White Top Folk Festival in the
1930s. Painted in 1932 by noted VA artist
Berkeley Williams, the painting was
the Institute from Judith Jesse

a

gift to

&amp;

John

McCarthy.
In the spring issue of Dulcimer Players
News (PO Box 2164, Winchester, VA 22601)
there is a very nice memorial tribute to
North Carolina dulcimer maker Edd
Presnell, who died last August.
The Missouri State Old-Time Fiddlers'

very informative newsletter,
Quarterly. The spring issue
contains an article on rattlesnake buttons,
rehairing bows and a calendar of every
fiddle contest in the state (40+) through
Assn. has

a

the MSOTFA

early 1996.

MSOTFA, PO Box 7423, Co

lumbia MO 65205.

Tribute

to

Woody Guthrie on Nov.

Martin Carthy, Norma

Waterson,

and

Carthy on Dec. 12. For info, and
listing: 919-416-9433.

a

5,

and

Eliza

complete

Among those appearing at the Winfield,
KS 24th Annual Walnut Valley Festival on
Sept. 14-17 will be Tim &amp; Mollie O'Brien
&amp; The O'Boys, Mike Seeger, Biyan Bow
ers, and John

McCutcheon. INFO:

245F, Winfield

KS

PO Box

67156; 316-221-3250

From Julie Mangin, editor and publisher
of

Washington, DC's

The

Daily Clog

&lt;jmangin@access.digex.net&gt;, we hear that
the Clog Palace in Wheaton, MD, is looking

bands for their semi-monthly dances.
Besides Internet, call 301-495-0082 if you
for

can help.

&amp;

Win

Grace
August Missourians
&amp; Family will perform at Lincoln Center in
New York City for the Roots of American
Paul

In

Music Festival, and will appear in Indiana,

Texas,

Missouri,

and

Pennsylvania

throughout Sept.
In

Print

&amp;

In

School

Sing Out!, the magazine of folk music, is
celebrating its 45th year of publication with

of vol.
special commemorative reprinting
which
not
no.
includes
1,
1,
only songs
and commentary of the times (1950),
a

Victory Music, the Washington statebased acoustic music monthly, gave the
spring issue of OTH a glowing review in
their May issue (PO Box 7515, Bonney Lake,
WA 98390). Whole Earth Review, summer
1995 (27 Gate Five Rd., Sausalito
CA 94965)
also reviewed the OTH, citing

it as

"hand

some

features some very good writing.
not just a good music magazine, but a
good history source as well." Thanks-you folks do good work, too!!
The March 1995 issue of the California
Retired Teachers' Assn. Newsletter, Con
tact, contains an article which includes the
To Sharpen Your Mind-musical instrument. This
visual, muscular and mental task requires
concentration. Memorizing the musical
pieces is an added boost." Gee, what a

following; "Ways
Learn to play

a

concept!
Recordings, Instruments

&amp;

Labels

Finally, someone has made a video of
bluesman John Jackson's guitar style!
Homespun has put together a 60-minute
teaching video of some of his best songs
combined with some of his famous stories.
Also featured is Roy Bookbinder, another
finger-style favorite.
Art Stamper, fiddler who played for the
Stanley Brothers in their early days, and is
now with Ralph Stanley, has a reissue CD

�out on County called The Lost Fiddler. He
uses both Scruggs-style and clawhammer
banjo (alternately) and plays some fine old-

time tunes, including some he learned from
Snake Chapman.
Bob Carlin &amp; John Hartford's recent CD

2 CD which will appear in June
19% at the Old-Time Music On The Radio

Air Vol.

Conference. Submissions may be sent to:
Susan Madden, PO Box 28322, Seattle, W A
98118

some good reviews, notably in the Raleigh
(NC) News &amp; Observer and Bluegrass Music

Mercury Nashville announced the re
lease in June of a Stanley Brothers compila
tion-Angel Band: The Classic Mercury
Recordings, recordings made between 1953

News.

and 1957.

The Fun of Open

Discussion has garnered

known

better

Heritage Center has re

The Augusta

Lynn Morris,
bluegrasser, has recorded two clawhammer
teaching videos for The Murphy Method.

leased a civil war tape taken entirely from
field recordings made throughout West

available, no release date set for Vol. 2.
Luthier Steve Gillham, of Wrightsville
Beach, NC, has developed a prototype gui
tar based on the 1930s Martin dreadnought
models. His new model, which he calls the

Virginia between 1976 and 1994. Among
those featured on the recording are fid
dlers Melvin Wine, Wilson Douglas, and
Harvey Sampson, and ballad singers Maggie
Hammons Parker, Homer Sampson, and

"cannon," has been highly praised by play

Dwight Diller. INFO: 304-636-1903.

Vol.

1

ers; it

as

a

is

should be available sometime within

the year.
The Missouri

State Old Time Fiddlers
Assoc. and St. Mary's Church of Wien, MO
held an all-day jam session and evening
dance on May 20 to celebrate the release of
new recording by Nile Wilson of Bucklin,
MO (see OTH vol. 4 no. 6). Entitled Nile
a

Wilson, Tie Hacker Hoe-Down, the record
ing features old-time fiddle tunes native to
north central Missouri. MSOTFA, PO Box
7423, Columbia, MO 65205
CMH has released a CD called

Dogyou might
Country, featuring,
guess, dog songs. The interesting part is
that the artists include A1 Hopkins &amp; the
Bucklebusters, The Hoosier Hotshots,The Skil
as

Gone

let Lickers and

Tannehill

Grandpa Jones, among others.

Historical State Park,

McCalla, AL, has re-released

bum Possum Up

A

the 1988

in

al

Gum Stump: Home,

Commercial

Field,
Recordings of
Alabama Fiddlers (reviewed in OTH vol. 1
&amp;

no. 5) on

and
M.

a

CD/cassette with

6

extra tunes

booklet. INFO: 205-477-9400.
Lee Murrah

of Cedar

informs us that he saw

a

Rapids, IA,
Swedish rock

group called Rednexx on MTV doing a
"hopped-up version of the old fiddle tune
Cotton-Eyed Joe." He says he's heard it on
rock radio locally and "wonder(s) what
this means in the grander scheme of
things?"

Sometime this year Rounder should re
lease Young Fogies 2, the next volume in
Ray Alden's

ongoing documentation

of

old-time music. OTH reviewer and YF2
contributor Kerry Blech described the twoday Seattle recording session in a recent
Victory Review.

There will be an Old-Time Music On The

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Organizations
The Folk

Alliance has moved

head

its

quarters from Raleigh, NC to Washington,
DC. The new office is located at 1001 Con

necticut Ave., NW, Ste. 501, Washington,
DC 20036. 202-835-3655; fax 202-835-3656.
Art Menius will remain full-time as Con
ference Manager and Newsletter Editor
and can be reached at PO Box 5010, Chapel
Hill, NC 27514; 919-542-3997; fax 919-5424487. The next annual Folk Alliance Con
ference is scheduled for Feb. 15-18 in Wash
ington, DC.
The

Birmingham Country Dance

Society will sponsor a dance weekend at
Camp Saddlerockin Mentone, AL Aug. 19&amp; the New
21 featuring Ralph Blizard
Southern Ramblers. INFO: 205-918-0331.
Austin (TX) Friends Of Traditional Mu
continuing success of the
Wednesday night Barn Dances and invite
old-time musicians to stop by and play.
sic notes the

They also run

a

monthly open mike night

and encourage old-time music, so if you're
in the area
On The Air

NAIRD has announced that

a

new

organization, CCPB (Citizen's Committee
for Public Broadcasting), is working with
individuals and organizations to unify and
a
grassroots campaign to advocate for
the continued federal funding for public
broadcasting. INFO: 202-463-0020; fax 202223-9579; e-mail &lt;ccpb@essential.org&gt;.

build

Gene Boyer of Appalshop reports that

their

radio service,

Whitesburg,

WMMT-88.7

in

KY, now airs two old-time

music shows, From The Roots (with
Charlie Geezer &amp; Sally Goodin aka
(continued

on next

page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&amp; Beverly May), and Deep
Tradition, hosted by Buck Maggard.

Gene Boyer
In

Appalshop also hosts monthly open oldtime jams. INFO: 606-633-0108.
Texas Country Roots is a 13-part radio
series covering various aspects of country
music and its evolution in Texas. INFO:
Texas Folklife Resources, PO Box 49824,
TX 78765.

Austin,
KCHO 91.7 FM Chico, and KFPR 88.9
FM Redding, CA broadcast a weekly pro
gram The Good Old Fashion Folk Music
Show on Sundays from 1-3 pm which in
cludes old-time music.
Shady Grove is the name of a weekly
Saturday night 2-hour radio show on
KMUN-FM 91.9 in Astoria, OR. With a
revolving roster of hosts including Susie
McLerie, the show features old-time as well
as

bluegrass and Cajun music.

Congratulations
The Grand Old Opry inducted dobroist

Bashful Brother Oswald to membership

this year. He has been an Opry member
with Roy Acuff's band since 1939, but now
has his own star. He is, incidentally, the

oldest new member ever inducted.
Jack Tottle, who introduced the Bluegrass
Program at East Tenn. State University in

1982, has accepted a full-time faculty posi
tion with ETSU's Dept. of Music and the
Center for Appalachian Studies &amp; Services.
The 1995 N.

C.

Folk Heritage Awards

were presented on June 6 and included
gospel singers The Branchettes, Piedmont

blues musician Richard "Big Boy" Heniy,

bluegrass fiddler Jim Shumate, and
fiddler and dancer Ora Watson.

The 1995 Florida Folk Heritage Award

recipients include African American gos
pel steel guitarist Willie Eason of St. Pe
tersburg. The awards were presented at a
ceremony on May 27 during the 43rd an
nual Florida Folk Festival.
The 1995 National Heritage Fellowships
will be celebrated in Washington, DC at a
public ceremony during the week of Sept.
25, with

a

free concert

to be

held in the

Lisner Auditorium

at George Washington
University. Among the recipients are Mis

owner Dave Freeman
three
four-CD boxed sets
release
plans
this year, and began with a Ralph Stanley
35th Anniversary,
to

box in July. A Rebel retrospective
scheduled for release later this fall.
Final Notes

Carroll Best, of Clyde, NC, was killed on
May 8, 1995, following an argument with
his brother. Hilary Dirlam writes: "Carroll,
kind and gentle man, as well as a worldclass banjo player, was killed near his home
in the Crabtree community, in Haywood
County. Carroll, who once described him
self as a 'fiddler who plays the banjo' was
a

happy to share his unique and beautiful
up-picking style with everyone who wanted
to listen.
Carroll was born in 1931 in the house
where he lived with his wife Louise at the
time of his death. Throughout his life, while
he worked and farmed full-time, and raised
a family, Carroll played the tunes he learned
from both sides of his family: Carroll's
father played a three-finger style and his
mother was a clawhammer banjo player.
Both parents learned banjo from their moth
ers. Though Carroll learned a wide-rang
ing selection of material, including more

modern times, he ultimately chose to stick
to the traditional repertoire he heard grow
ing up.
Carroll received the North Carolina Heri
tage Award in 1994. He was a featured
performer on the national Masters of the
Banjo Tour, and was on the faculty of the
1990 Tennessee Banjo Institute. Hereceived
many other award s and prizes, but through
out his musical

career, he maintained a
of spirit that was

modesty and generosity

inspiration to all who were fortunate
enough to know him.
Although Carroll played music with
many local traditional musicians, his con
stant musical companion was Danny John
an

son, an outstanding guitar player living in
Etowah, NC. Their music has been pre
served by banjo player Jack Hatfield, who

generously started a fund to help
Carroll's family through this tragic time. If
and
you would like to make a donation
has

wonderful tape

souri fiddler Lyman Enloe (see OTH vol. 4
no. 5), Virginia guitarist and guitar maker

receive

guitarist, and Buck Ramsey, cowboy poet
and singer from Texas. INFO: 202-682-5570
1995 marks the 35th Anniversary of the
oldest bluegrass record label in the world,
Rebel Records. To commemorate Rebel's

Dr., Pigeon Forge, TN 37863.

Wayne Henderson, Ohio's Robert Jr.
Lockwood, African American Delta blues

set is

a

of Carroll and

Danny playing favorite tunes, please send
order to: Carroll Best
a check or money
Fund, c/o Jack Hatfield, 325 Laurelwood
Your donation will be forwarded to the
family and Jack will send you a tape. This is

wonderful way for us
honor Carroll Best."
a

to

remember and

�Robert Franklin "Frank" Flicks died on
July 1 of leukemia and prostate cancer.
Born in 1922 in Fresno, Calif, he played

rhythm guitar with such bands as Tommy
Dorsey, Duke Ellington, and Les Brown,
and had his own western swing band in the
'30s
Floyd Hodges and the Texas Torna
does. During the 1960s folk music revival
he started The Sweet's Mill Mountain Boys

with legendary local fiddler Ron Hughey,
Kenny Hall, and Pete Everwine. He re
corded the album We Ain't Misbelwvin' on

Arhoolie Records with jazz violinists Joe
Holley and Paul Anastasio. Tribute was
paid to him by many fellow musicians and
friends, among them Kenny Hall: "A lot of
people thought he was just a good western
swing guitarist but he was also a good oldtime musician with a very good ear"; and
Evo Bluestein: "There won't be another
player like him. His talent and style were
."
truly unique.
Bruce Greene wrote the following:
"Grover Cleveland Salyer, oldest son of

legendary eastern Kentucky fiddler John
Salyer, passed away on Nov. 28, 1994 at the
age of 84. In the early 1940s Grover had the
foresight and devotion to record his father's

music

extensively

at

their home

in

Salyersville, not

knowing that 50 years later
he would be giving it as a rare and beautiful
gift to lovers of American traditional

mu

Salyer's fiddling was
released through Berea College in 1993
[reviewed in OTH vol. 4 no. 6].
Grover was a fine musician himself, and
could play a number of his father's pieces
sic. A tape of John

fiddle, French harp, and banjo. Al
though quite modest about his musical
abilities, he could handle a bow very much
like his father, and Kerry Blech has written
on the

that his 'guitar playing.

is

perhaps the

best old-time guitar accompaniment I ha ve
ever heard.'
As for myself, I will remember Grover as
a

friend, mentor, and

a

gentleman of great

pride and dignity."

John Currie is

a

musician and singer and

is the

host of "Music From Under The ShadeTree" on
WHQR-FM in Wilmington, NC. He plays

fiddle with The Floyd Pond Ramblers.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Dance Beat

Ora Watson: Old-Time Buckdancer and Fiddler

by

Phil Jamison

year the North Carolina Arts Council awards the North
CarolinaFolk
Heritage Award to a small number of folk artists
Each
in recognition of their contribution to the cultural heritage of the
state. For the second year in a row a traditional dancer from Sugar
Grove in Watauga County has been among the nonorees. Last year
it was Robert and Myrtle Dotson [see OTH vol. 4 no. 4]. This year7 s
honorees include Ora Watson, who besides being a traditional
dancer, is also an old-time fiddler.
I first met Ora Watson at the Cove Creek Senior Center in 1993,

North
of an

found
music

a matter of minutes, we had a jam session going there
the senior center, and before long she put down her fiddle and
was out on the floor flatfooting. Some of the other senior citizens

and dance. In
at

looked on

in

awe, but others seemed to be used to

it.

For over 10

years, Ora has been performing at area senior centers as a volun
teer. Now at age 84 she still is fiddling and dancing and has just

recorded

tape of her music. She admits that it is her dancing that
keeps her fit and looking 20 years younger than her actual age.
Ora Watson was born in 1911 on Isaacs Branch in Cove Creek,
not far from Sugar Grove in Watauga County, North Carolina. She
learned her music and dance from her parents, Arthur and Mary
Isaacs. Her father was a skilled dancer who played old-time fiddle
and fretless banjo. Her mother was a church-going woman who
a

liked to sing gospel songs as well as ballads and folksongs. Ora has
always been a dancer. She says that when she went to church with
her mother, she would dance on her mother's lap when the piano
played, even before she could walk. Like many dancers of her

generation, she is self-taught, having picked it up by watching
others, most notably her own father. Ora's musical career also
began

at an

early age. When she was

11

years old she started to

learn to play the fiddle from her cousin Charlie Isaacs,

a legendary
she
a
band
with her
fiddler.
At
formed
14,
Watauga County
age
sister, Emma, and a cousin, Earle Isaacs. They called themselves

mandolin and Earle played guitar,
while Ora fiddled They played for parties and cakewalks and also
competed at fiddlers conventions where they would often win a
prize for the best string band and Ora would often win best fiddler
and buckdancer. As a teenager, Ora also won dance contests for
dancing the Charleston, which was popular at that time.
the Isaacs Sisters. Emma played

Democrat Watauga
Sheffield,

Bill

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

while I was searching out traditional dancers to film a
Carolina Arts Council documentary project. I had heard
elderly woman who was a dancer and a fiddler and what I
was an energetic 82-year-old who was eager to share her

age 17 Ora married for the first time and started a family.
When her husband died tragically in 1942, she was left with three
children to care for and she was pregnant with a fourth. She gave
At

up performing music long enough to raise her children and when

(continued

on page 15)

�25 Essential
by Lynn

"Chirps"

Smith

was asked to come up with this list
and agreed to do it, figuring

I

it

would

be

relatively easy to accomplish. Boy,
I
wrong! Try it yourself some
time. I decided to forgo listing some of the
more obvious essential recordings, such
as, the County 500 series, the Columbia
was

15000

Jarrell, Creed, Cockerham,
etc., and list some of the recordings I have
really enjoyed and from which I have

series,

learned, One must keep in mind that

I

am

fiddler and mandolinist with a strong
attachment to instrumental dance music.
a

So with that said, here

goes the list (in no

particular order).
of the

the

the volume and number of the issue.--

ed.]

American Fiddle Tunes (Library of Con
gress LP AFS-L62; vol. 2 no. 7). These LOC
recordings and the accompanying tome by
Alan Jabbour were (and still are) an inspi
1.

ration
a wonderful view into the
breadth of American fiddle styles. [See Is
to me. It's

2.

In

Old-Time Music page 33.]

Lotus Dickey:

Summers: Indiana Fiddler
(Rounder LP-0194). I never got to meet Mr.
Summers, but Art Rosenbaum and others
did, thank goodness. Mr. Summers was
one of the finest old-time fiddlers in the
midwest.
4.

W.

John

Buddy Thomas: Kitty Puss (Rounder
LP-0032). Fabulous Kentucky fiddling from
a fiddler that
departed this life too soon.
5.

Da Costa Woltz's Southern Broadcast
ers (County LP 524). I couldn't resist in
cluding this item from the 500 series. This
was the first real old-time music record I
6.

remember hearing.

I

was hooked from that

point on.
have been reviewed in

[Many
following
OTH. When appropriate we have indicated

sues

Old-Time Recordings

Fiddle Tunes from Orange

County Indiana, Volumes 1/2 (Marimac
Cassettes 9029/9030C). Lotus was a friend
and mentor to many younger fiddlers such

Minstrel Banjo Style (Rounder CD-0321;
vol. 4 no. 7). I love the old 19th century
banjo style and this compilation features
7.

the best proponents

of the style playing
Give
it a listen and then
today.
get all their
other recordings.

Puncheon Camps
Clyde Davenport:
Center
Cassette
AC002; vol.
(Appalachian
3 no. 7). I love Clyde
Davenport's fiddle
tunes and style. Not only is he a great
fiddler and banjoist, but is, quite possibly,
the first old-time fiddler with a WWW
Home Page.
8.

John Morgan Salyer: Home Recordings
1941-1942 (Appalachian Center Cassette
AC003; vol. 4 no. 6). Beautiful and rare old
9.

as myself. This set, and the informative
booklet by Dr. Paul Tyler, gives insight into
one man's love and respect of old-time

eastern Kentucky fiddle tunes. The record

fiddling.

ings are

3.

Dan Gellert&amp;Brad Leftwich: AMoment

(Marimac Cassette 9038C; vol. 4
no. 5). And what a moment it was. You
don't get a much better duet than this. It's
fiddle and banjo heaven.
in Time

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

bit rough but the music makes up

for it.

Greene: Vintage Fiddle Tunes
(Private Release; vol. 1 no. 2). Bruce Greene
combed the hills of Kentucky and
10. Bruce

found hundreds of exceptional tunes

and performers (including the

J.

M. Salyer

recordings mentioned above, I believe).
He learned a lot from these folks and shares

knowledge on this recording.
11. Edden Hammons Collection (Sound
Archives LP 001; vol. 1 no. 3). These re
cordings of Edden Hammons (of the fa
mous Hammons family of West Virginia)
his

made in 1937 contain some of the best oldtime West Virginia fiddling I've heard. The
tunes are stunning, especially one entitled,
Queen of the Earth, Child of the Stars.
12. Seems

Like Romance

to Me:

tional Fiddle Tunes from Ohio

Tradi

Gambier

Folklore Society LP GFS-901; vol. 1 no. 2).
This is a fine sampling of Ohio fiddling by
Jeff &amp; Susan Goehring &amp; Howard &amp; Judy
Sacks. Field recordings from eight Ohio
fiddlers are presented.
13. Great Big Yam Potatoes: Anglo-Ameri
can Fiddle Music from Mississippi (MS

Dept. of Archives &amp; History LP AH-002;
vol. 1 no. 3). I love the old Library of Con
gress recordings and I love Mississippi fid

dling. This LP has both!
performances by around
great sampling

It

10

contains
fiddlers.

42
A

of Deep South fiddling.

Possum Up a Gum Stump: Home, Field,
Commercial Recordings of AL Fiddlers,
Past &amp; Present (Alabama Traditions CD
14.
&amp;

103-CD; vol.

gives

us

a

no. 5). This fine recording
sample of Alabama fiddling. It
1

was put together by Joyce

&amp; Jim Cauthen.
information on Alabama fiddling,
you might want pick up a copy of Joyce's
book, With Fiddle &amp; Well-Rosined Bow.

For more

(continued

on

page 15)

�VJIj

riin&amp;(g
O
1833

EST.

Official Sponsor

Tentative Lineup
Jim &amp; Jesse and The Virginia Boys

The Del McCoury Band
Laurie Lewis
Doc Watson &amp; Jack Lawrence
Third Tyme Out

Doyle Lawson &amp; Quicksilver
The

Section with Illegible Text

Nashville Bluegrass Band
The Lonesome River Band

The Whites with Jerry Douglas
Lou Reid, Terry Baucom &amp;

More than thirty of the finest acts in bluegrass today donate
their talent to this fund raiser for the Bluegrass Music Trust
and IBMA. The Trust is established to assist bluegrass
music professionals in time of dire need while IBMA is a
non-profit organization whose mission is the ongoing
success of bluegrass music.

Carolina
The Lynn Morris Band
The Isaacs
Larry Stephenson
The Sidemen
US Navy Band Country Current

Pete Wernick with
Jody Stecher

&amp; Kate

Brislin,

ant

i

Chris &amp; Scott Thile
Salt Licks

1

Leroy Troy
Blue Mule (Canada)
Is

Greener

THREE DAY
THREE DAY

S

and many more!

Section with Illegible Text

The Grass

mberS
th

f

AUgUSt Ist)

f

t

ONEDAY(FraorerSa1)gUStISt)

Master's Workshops
Youth Entertainment
Ohio River Cruises

_) Limited RV parking OJKr
thrCe

CHILDREN

C

$35
$45

THE DAY
(Sun.)

Also Featured

S

^""-Members

$45

fC

$15

f

g

$20

t

UNDER?6dFRE^hac'

WUhaccomPanying adult.

C

Lineup subject to change
G

lY/iildnrio

A raffle for

Martin HD-28 Guitar

will be held during the event.

Official Sponsor

IBMA

a

FOR

INFORMATION ON ALL IBMA WORLD

OF

BLUEGRASS EVENTS OR

IBMA MEMBERSHIP, CONTACT:

BLUEGRASS FAN FEST
International
Bluegrass Music

Association

This advertisement supported by the
Owensboro-Daviess County Tourist Commission.
14

THE OLD-TIME HERALD

FALL 1995

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

207 East Second Street

Owensboro, Kentucky, USA 42303

502-684-9025

95

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

Washington and elsewhere. She and

played music with old-time
fiddler Gaither Carlton, Doc Watson's fa
ther-in-law with whom they recorded a
locally produced 45 rpm version of "Lost
Arlie often

John" in the 1970s.

Since Arlie's death in 1979, Ora has con
tinued to keep busy playing in the Boone
area with various bluegrass and old-time
groups which have included Doc Watson
and others. In addition to the fiddle, Ora
also plays guitar and clawhammer banjo
and sings some of the old ballads that she
learned from her mother. In recent years
she has been performing with the Laurel
Creek String Band, which consists of Mary

Greene on guitar, Cecil Gurganus on banjo,
and Rick Stone on

mandolin. They have

recently recorded a self-produced tape.
Ora learned to dance by watching her
father. She calls her style flatfoot dancing
or buck dance and she describes
clogging
as a faster dance which uses a lot of
steps
different from the old-time buck dance.
Besides the Charleston dance contests
which she won in her youth, she has won
numerous old-time buck-dance contests
more recently at area fiddlers conventions
in

Watauga County, Avery County, and
Mountain City, Tennessee. Like most danc

ers of her generation, she is an advocate for
leather-soled shoes without taps. Her feet

slide on the floor
style with

a

in

a

smooth flat-footed

lot of the Charleston blended

reserved or stiff when she
dances, but she throws her whole body
into it and is amazingly limber and ener
In a lifetime of
getic.
dancing and fid
Ora
has
also
mastered
dling
something
that very few other musicians have been
in. She is not all

able to accomplish with equal grace.That is
to play the fiddle and dance at the same
time. When she does this, she is not just

Ora Watson
continued from page 12

they were grown, she began playing again
with various local musicians including
Arlie Watson, a singer, guitarist, and

songwriter (no known relation

to

Doc

keeping time with her feet, but actually
dancing. Last year at Fiddlers Grove she
was given a special award for this feat.
At age 84, Ora Watson remains active
with her dancing and music and she is
eager to share her talents and good humor
wherever she performs.
Ora Watson's tape is available from The
Appalachian Cultural Museum, Appala
chian State University,
Boone, NC 28608.

University Hall,

Watson).
In 1969, she and Arlie were married and
over the next 10 years, they performed
locally as well as traveling to perform at the

Smithsonian's Festival of American Folklife

Phil Jamison is OTH dance editor. He is a
member of the Green Grass Cloggers, plays oldtime banjo, fiddle, and guitar, and
of The New Southern Ramblers.

is a

member

�the Flippen

Through
The Life, Times,

by

Filter

Tunes of Benton Flippen

&amp;

Paul Brown

County, North Carolina
the late 1940s was

a

in

fairly rough

place. Many of the
main roads were dirt. The two lane
highway from the biggest town, Mount
and

Surry

rugged

Airy, to the much larger city of WinstonSalem in adjoining Forsyth County wound
its way around the hills through Pinnacle,

King, and Rural Hall. For an emergency
trip to a hospital in Winston
life-or-death gamble. Knife and
gun fights at square dances occasionally
made such a trip necessary.
Mount Airy was then, as it remains to

patient,
could be

a

a

day, the trading center for Surry, parts of
neighboring Stokes County, and the Blue
Ridge Mountain counties of Carroll and
Patrick in Virginia. When Ralph Epperson
of nearby Ararat, Virginia decided to start
the first radio station in the area, he wisely
chose Mount Airy. On a hill north of town,
he and his father Harry hand-built WPAQ
out of brick and timber. Supplies were
short in 1947, and theycouldn't get grooved
panelling for the walls. So they cut the
grooves in the wallboard themselves. They
fashioned joists and rafters and sound
proof studio doors from trees felled on
their farm. When

it

came time

to test

the

transmitter before officially signing on in
February of 1948, they called on local mu
sicians. People who were there say it was
exciting time. The performers had to
come in early, after midnight but not by
an

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

much,

and

workdays

in

then move on to start their
factories and on farms. One of

them was a tall, young, quiet banjo picker
named Benton Flippen.

WPAQ has continued remarkably un
changed since with offerings of bluegrass,
old-time and gospel music, announcements
of lost and found pets, and a healthy daily
dose of religion. The station also continues,
47 years later, to offer its listeners the music
of Benton Flippen, live and recorded, mostly
on fiddle now but sometimes on banjo.
In the intervening years, Benton has won
numerous fiddle and string-band prizes,
and received the North Carolina Folk Heri
tage Award in 1990. He has become widely

appreciated locally and, due to his distinc
tive and idiosyncratic style, something of a
cult figure among old-time musicians from

elsewhere.

Benton is a reflection of the changing
times in which he grew up, but he's also a
uniquely gifted musician who took what

molded it to suit
himself. His music, on banjo and fiddle,
owes a debt to early bluegrass and an
equally large debt to the powerful old-time
musicians of the area. In Benton's fiddle
tunes one finds hints of national stars such
he heard around him and

Arthur Smith, Tommy Magness and
Kenny Baker. Also there are echoes of local

as

old-timers Tommy Jarrell, Esker Hutchins,
Pate Martin, Fred Cockerham, and Earnest
East.

Benton educated himself, in music as in
most other things. He listened to a fiddling
uncle who would come to visit from
Thomasville, North Carolina. His father
and two brothers were banjo and fiddle

players. He describes listening intently to
the late Esker Hutchins, a highly respected
local fiddler and banjo picker with whom
he played for several years on radio and at
fiddlers conventions. He heard fiddlin'
Arthur Smith on the radio from Nashville,
and added his own bluesy slides to Smith's
tunes including "Red Apple Rag" and

"Fiddler's Dream." He listened to
clawhammer banjo picker Kyle Creed and
bluegrass innovator Earl Scruggs, then fol
lowed neither of them past a certain point.
And when he decided to play fiddle again
lapse of about a decade, Benton
began visiting his older neighbor Tommy
after

a

Jarrell,

whose archaic, bow-rocking style

was worlds different from Benton's in
technique, yet remarkably similar in en
ergy and overall drive.
His family musical history is perhaps
less important than with some other tradi
tional musicians because Benton has gone
so convincingly in his own direction. Like
wise, though his repertoire and style are

solidly within the hard-driving Surry

County tradition, his own sounds on banjo
and fiddle are equally important.
James Benton Flippen was born in 1920,
the seventh of eight children of Sam and

�Luticia

Boles

F.

sold the family farm

where along the line
the

spelling
last

family's

changed.)

for a small price and
has many times men

of the

name
Benton

tioned how he wishes
he'd held onto

recounts that, grow
ing up on a tobacco
farm in northern
Surry County,
started playing

the

he

years

twen

even sang the oc
casional song when
they were courting.
he

large boards of socks

broth

through

congregation
in

day

a

In the

him

musicians

result of

home

Benton Flippen

ca.

lieve in eyeglasses," he recently said of his
family "They thought glasses weren't good
for you."
He started to drive a car only
after he had obtained his first set of glasses,
when he was in his twenties. Since then,
he's been pretty much of a Chevrolet man,
and his two-tone green window van with

striped curtains is an immediate sign that

music at a
square dance.

there will be some good
or

such as
Ernest, Wayne, and

1950. Courtesy Lois Flippen collection.

from
school. He didn't wear eyeglasses until he
was an adult. "Those old-timers didn't be

fiddlers convention

con

tinued as before, play
ing square dances at
people's homes with

Perhaps

this, his family kept

one

early years of

his marriage, he

nearly blind in
a

chuckle

evening.

singing.
Benton's eyesight
was poor; he claims

partly as

to be in

room with the whole

hand

prayer and

one eye.

drying

pile of 'em now," he
allowed with an off

a

to

unaccompanied

to be

a

oven. "I'd hate

preachers,

and one still leads

in

paring and sending

were Primitive

Baptist

in

Through most of those
years, he performed
the hot, tedious, and
strenuous job of pre

picking style, and his
wife Lois recalls that

ers

it

hosiery mills, com
ing out as he went in:
an hourly worker with
no retirement fund,
no medical coverage,
and
no
pension.

two-finger

At least two

for

it,

which

cal

ties. He also played
guitar from time to
a

in

He spent 37
non-union lo

years.

the

the fiddle in his late

time, in

area

was located has been
rising in value over the

banjo in his early
teens, and picked up
teens or early

Mount Airy. He

in

(Some

Flippin.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

At

home, he heard the radio, which

brought him tunes and songs from the
Grand Ole Opry in Nashville and from
other locations. He heard some of his

community's finest players at local events,
and started to join them. And with all these
influences around him, he figured out on
his own how to play banjo, fiddle, and
guitar.
Benton married Lois Arrington in 1944,
and

the couple

embarked,

as

did

thou

sands of others, on careers as textile workers

Ralph Creed (no re

lation

banjo picker Kyle Creed, and fine
guitarists and bassists in their own right).
Having helped WPAQ onto the air, he be
came

to

a

regular

radio station, per
banjo with fiddler Esker

at the

at first on

forming
Hutchins and guitarist Leak Caudle, and
also with Glen McPeak's Green Valley Boys
Disc recordings were made of some of these
sessions, and they reveal an era of transi
tion and bold energy.
The energy was rooted in community
(continued on next page

�recording from the early days of WPAQ
reveals community fiddlers who main
tained the focused intensity of these oldtimers while using a longer bow and less
d isc

self-accompaniment. The sharp attack at
beginnings of phrases was still there, as
was the syncopation which drove the mu
the

sic
and dancers
forward But notes were
often longer and made more cleanly, and

these fiddlers used slides for rhythmic
emphasis as much as their forebears used
percussive effects and bass strings. Fid

courtesy

Lois

Flippen

collection

dlers including Esker Hutchins, Wayburn
Johnson, Glen Neaves, and Pate Martin all

L-R: John Vogler, Benton

Flippen, Glen McPeak,

ca.

1950.

played this way, as did Otis Burris of nearby
Galax, Virginia [see OTH vol. 1 no. 7], Even
Fred Cockerham, who credited Ben Jarrell
as a fiddle inspiration,
began modifying
his style after hearing Arthur Smith, even
tually arriving at an exciting and attractive
old /new hybrid approach which hasn't
been heard again.
As did Fred Cockerham, Benton Flippen
heard the radio stars of his day and lis

tened to his own collection of 78 RPM
records. He tried bluegrass as well as oldtime

tunes, and as bass player Wayne
"started as a bluegrass
musician." But that statement is correct
Creed has said,

point, for Benton, as much as
wanted to keep up with the
was also steeped in the old tradi

only up to

a

he may have

times,

tions of the area. He loved the old tunes,
and was independent and creative enough
to

come up with his own way of playing

them.
The Green Valley Boys, under leader
Glen McPeak, performed contemporary

old-time country music, gospel songs,
some
bluegrass songs and
instrumentals. They were a local reflection

courtesy

Lois

Flippen

collection

and

The Green Valley Boys at WPAQ
Harold Coins, Elbert Williams.

and

a

ca.

1950. L-R: John Vogler, Benton Flippen, Glen McPeak,

community

Although

of current

developments

in

country music,

and probably fairly typical of many groups
performing on small radio stations through
out the South

immediately after World War

With this group, Benton primarily played
banjo, although a classic portrait of the
II

ensemble

in WPAQ's Studio A shows him
with both banjo and fiddle. Some disc re

tradition of music which reflected
life.

and

evidence

is

sketchy, the transition seems to have in
volved new influences, the impact of musi
cians such as Tommy Magness, Arthur
Smith, Bill Monroe, Roy Acuff, Ernest Tubb,
and others.

Many people who have heard record
ings byTommyand BenJarrellandbyFred
Cockerham, musicians made justly famous
by County Records in the label's early days,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

assume from their playing that the prevail
ing fiddle style in Surry County included
lots of short bow strokes and rocking of the
bow to create accompaniment on the bass
strings and to supply rhythmic drive. But
these Round Peak musicians and others
like them in the area may already have
been

somewhat anachronistic by 1950.

While a number of older local musicians
were certainly playing in a short-bow style
after World War

H,

nearly every available

cordings survive, among them "I'll Be
Somewhere Listening," with Benton back

ing the group on fiddle. But Benton's repu
tation as a banjo player was firm enough in

people's minds that some, including Ralph
Epperson of WPAQ,
he played fiddle until
appearing on radio.
calls Benton standing

say they had no idea

years after he started

Epperson fondly re
in Studio A, straightfaced, silent and still as a statue, only his
hands and fingers moving as banjo breaks

�crackled out over the air. During this pe
riod, Benton's banjo repertoire ranged from
current bluegrass hits such as "Train 45"
and "I Don't Love Nobody" to old-time

tunes such

and
as "Eighth of January"
other
to
of
Creek"
reworkings
"Cripple
instrumental parts for banjo. For example,
hecame up with an oddly syncopated banjo
interpretation of Roy Acuff's "This World
Can't Stand Long." A WPAQ disc of this

number with Leak Caudle singing pro
vides a poignant moment between some of
the breakdowns and country songs which
also survive.
One of the most popular fiddlers of this
period on WPAQ was Esker Hutchins of
the Dobson area, who during the late 1940s
and early 1950s had

a

regular weekly pro

gram. Performing with Esker and guitarist
Leak Caudle was a great joy for Benton.

a fine clawhammer banjo
was his fiddling which gained
him wide appreciation from WPAQ' s au
dience, from other musicians, and from

Hutchins was
player, but

attendees

it

at

fiddlers conventions. Benton

still speaks of him almost with reverence,
and Hutchins' influence on Benton's fid

clear. Although Hutchins used all
four fingers of his left hand to note, which
Benton rarely does, much of his phrasing,
choice of notes and use of slides rubbed off
on his young protege. Hutchins was a very

dling

is

smooth fiddler, but his phrasing, attack,

Clifton

collection

and repertoire left no doubt that he was an
old-time musician. An eerily quiet man by
all accounts (as Benton can also be at times),

square dances, and at fiddlers conventions.
He picked banjo and soaked in the fiddle
tunes, the motions and approaches to

courtesy

Larry

Esker Hutchins spoke loudly through his
music, preferring euphoric square-dance
breakdowns to any kind of slow tune or
sentimental song. For several years, Benton
stood by Hutchins' side in radio studios, at
The Camp Creek Boys, 1968. Back row, L-R: Kyle Creed, Benton Flippen, Verlen Clifton. Front
row, L-R: Paul Sutphin, C. F. Collins.

melody and phrasing which he incorpo

rated into his own playing. Benton even
kept some of Hutchins' trademark wind-

tunes, and hearing discs of the group
can make a listener shiver at some of the
ups to

similarities.
Hutchins' ensemble broke up in the mid
1950s, not long before Benton and Lois' son
Larry was born. For the next 10 years or so,

Benton didn't play much music, as work
and family responsibilities predominated.
About his fiddle, he told Bill Hicks in a 1973

interview that when he laid it up he "didn't
ever intend to play it no more." But other

As the New Lost City Ramblers spread
the word in northern cities and on college

campuses about Appalachian string-band

music, the old-time string-band tradition
in Surry County and neighboring Virginia
continued with remarkable strength. Al
though bluegrass and country music had
grabbed the attention of many listeners
and musicians, traditional schoolhouse fid
dlers conventions continued. When the

community and

rewed-up tempos and showmanship of
bluegrass performers made it difficult for
old-time musicians to win prizes, conven

around the nation ensured that he would.

tion organizers eventually began separating

developments

in the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

old-time and bluegrass contestants into
their own categories. In doing so, they dem
onstrated that people in the area valuedoldtime music and understood that it belonged
to a earlier and slightly different yet legiti
mate esthetic than its descendants.
One old-time band, however, was so
intense and unforgettable that it sometimes
won at fiddlers conventions before the new
categories were created. The Camp Creek
Boys, with either Fred Cockerham, Earnest
East or Kyle Creed fiddling, Fred or Kyle

performing

mandolin,

on banjo,

and

Paul

Collins on guitar, had

a

Verlen Clifton on

Sutphin and G.F.
stunningly focused

(continued

on

next page)

�uplifting sound.

For many people, this
defined
what
old-time
music should
group
sound like as the nationwide revival of
interest in the music built up more steam.

and

The rise of the Camp Creek Boys and the
popularity of their LP on the County label
coincided with the "discovery" of fiddler

Tommy Jarrell by folklorist Alan Jabbour
and the final recordings of old Virginia
musicians such as Wade Ward. The dra
matic increase in interest in old-time music
among young people on college campuses
around the country, sparked in part by the
New Lost City Ramblers, was often fo
cused on Surry County, North Carolina
and the accessible Tommy Jarrell. It was
strengthened by part-time and full-time
so-called revivalist bands such as the Hol
low Rock String Band, the Fuzzy Mountain
String Band, the Highwoods String Band,
and the Red Clay Ramblers while it simul
taneously helped nourish their careers.
Two streams of energy were meeting
augmenting each other: that of young

and

enthusiasts from around the country, and
that of the local Surry County musicians in
a distinct
combination
sound
The
traditional
helped
boost interest nationally in old-time music
through the 1970s, and began to increase
attendance at area fiddlers conventions
which had been somewhat stagnant. It gave
local musicians such as the Camp Creek
Boys and Tommy Jarrell additional self-

courtesy

Lois

Flippen

collection

their prime who were continuing

The Smokey Valley Boys, early 1970s.

Back row L-R: Paul Sutphin, Benton Flippen, Larry Flippen.

As all this was going on, Benton Flippen
had begun to play fiddle again, partly at
the urging of his mandolin-playing friend

Front row L-R: Gilmer Woodruff, Curtis Spurlin.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

respect and the impetus to play their music
with even more intensity.

Hoyle Jones. To get back into practice on
old-time local tunes, he had started with
his son Larry to visit older fiddler Tommy
Jarrell nearby. At the same time, Fred
Cockerham's health was failing and Ear
nest East was ready to form his own oldtime band, the Pine Ridge Boys.
The result was that Benton found him
self fiddling, starting in 1967, with the stel
lar Camp Creek Boys. They were success
ful at fiddlers conventions, and the few

poor-quality home recordings of them show
their music to be as exciting as ever, but
this incarnation of the Camp Creek Boys
didn't last long. Banjoist Kyle Creed quit
the band around 1969 and took the name
with him.

organized

Paul

Brown

Guitarist Paul Sutphin

L-R: Paul

Sutphin and Benton Flippen.

the

�Smokey Valley Boys with Benton, Hoyle
Jones on mandolin, Gilmer Woodruff on
banjo, and Larry Flippen on lead guitar. As
the Camp Creek Boys had done before
them, the Smokey Valley Boys dominated

fiddlers conventions from Union Grove to
Galax with a sound that commanded the
attention of old-time and bluegrass enthu
siasts alike. The Smokey Valley Boys re
leased a record of dance tunes on the
Rounder label in 1973, performed at the
Brandywine Mountain Music Convention
in 1978 and 1 983, the 1 982 Knoxville World's
Fair, and appeared at numerous other fes
tivals and camps. The group took first place
seven times at the Union Grove, North
Carolina fiddlers convention and won nu

merous times

at Galax, Virginia, Mount
Airy, North Carolina, Dublin, Virginia and
at many other conventions. Benton himself

swept fiddle competitions

at

conventions

large and small, racking up seven first-place
wins at Galax alone. The group also played
for the Green Grass

Ears

in

1985

Cloggers' LP Through the
[OTH vol. 1 no. 8],

Hoyle Jones eventually dropped out of

the band, as did Gilmer Woodruff. Along
the way Curtis Spurlin played mandolin
for a while, and then Verlen Clifton re
a stint in G.F. Collins'
Blue
this
Entertainers.
Carlie
Marion
and
Ridge
writer played banjo with the group through
the next several years, and guitarists in

turned from

Mac

Snow, Grady

Largen, and Foster Murray.

In

collection

cluding Frank Bode,

1984 the

performed with a group called the Dryhill
Draggers. Most recently he and Paul
Sutphin have revived the Smokey Valley
Boys with a variety of personnel. The 1 980s
version of the band has been touring as
well to festivals and concert dates. Benton
still gets together with friends at home for
a tune. "I guess I'll keep draggin' the bow

until I just can't do it anymore," he said
one day, sitting in his den with a wall of
fiddling trophies behind him. In 1994, a 40-

Paul
courtesy

pearing at the National Folk Festival, and a
remarkable era in string-band music was
over. But Benton, his band and its prede
cessors had touched thousands of people
around the world.
From the mid-1980s until 1994, Benton

Brown

Smokey Valley Boys disbanded after ap

The Smokey Valley Boys on the steps of

WPAQ, 1984. L-R: Paul Sutphin, Benton Flippen, Verlen

Clifton, Paul Brown, Frank Bode.

leaning heavily towards old-time. More
than anything, though, it's defined by its
creator, much as are the styles of many socalled revivalist musicians and bluegrass
or jazz

players.
teenager

in 1935, Benton bought a
went
back
to town and swapped it
guitar,
for a .22 rifle, shot a box of cartridges,

As

a

year retrospective CD of Benton's music
appeared on the Rounder label, titled Old-

decided he didn't care about that, and re
turned to town once again to swap the rifle
for a brand new Kalamazoo banjo with
resonator. The banjo cost $22.50. He still

Time, New Times [OTH vol.

has

4

no. 7],

style, Benton Flippen's music falls some
where between old-time and bluegrass,
In

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

though he plays
sionally.
it,

He says he found

it

today only occa

wasn't quite for him. So he came up with
own heavily syncopated two-finger
picking style. He adapted it to old-time
tunes such as "June Apple," created his
own interpretation of Earl Scruggs' ver
sion of 'Train 45," and used it to make the
his

banjo an unexpectedly successful and fas
cinating lead instrument in Roy Acuff's
"This World Can't Stand Long." He leads
on some banjo tunes with the thumb, on

others with theindexfinger;onmany tunes,
Benton switches leads as the phrasing and

melody require.
He trusted

it

difficult

to

play
clawhammer banjo, and though he liked
hearing it, the three-finger bluegrass style

himself on fiddle,

as

well.

Benton's hands are very large.
discovered the best way to get around

He
the

continued on next page)

�tune from certain formulaic patterns he

devised

to

s

accommodate his fingering and

bowing techniques, and

at

others he will

tune around until it suits his
sense of what it should be. Comparisons of
his settings of common tunes such as "Lib
erty," "Katy Hill," "Sally Ann," or "Break
ing Up Christmas" to those of other fid
dlers typically leave new listeners and ob
servers stunned and thinking about music
in new ways. His more obscure tunes can
sound yet more exotic and exciting. He has
made up numerous pieces over the years,
such as "Benton's Dream" and "Sally in
simply work

a

the Turnip Patch," and transposed
to

different keys

others

made up new parts,

or

as

Paul

Brown

with his "Leather Britches" in the key of D.

Paul Sutphin

(L) and Benton Flippen conduct

banjo workshop at Jay Unger and Molly Mason's

a

nearly simultaneously slides down
with another. It's dizzying to watch, and

as he

unforgettable to hear. As fiddler Brad
Leftwich aptly remarked, "It looks so
strange to see those great, long fingers arch
ing over the fingerboard, like some big
insect's legs, landing in all sorts of odd
places." Benton is quick to point out that he
does use his ring and fifth fingers for some
tunes
just not many.
His bowing, though not as complex as
that of either his musical companion Esker
Hutchins or of Fred Cockerham or Tommy

interesting nevertheless for its
unorthodox technique. Although settings
is

shuffle
bow
fairly long
ap
proach distinguished by direction changes
in places most of us would not think of. The
late Earlie Jarrell, who judged many fid
dlers conventions in the 1970s, remarked
of

some of his tunes are based on

Paul

Brown

stroke, most utilize

Gilmer Woodruff (L) and Benton Flippen

did, including his mentor Esker Hutchins.
Where most of us make a D chord on the
fiddle with index and ring finger, Benton

does

it

with index and middle finger.

In

addition to long, slippery slides covering
several notes, he can slide crisply with a
single digit from one note to the next up or
down the scale. It sounds close to normal
but

oddly different. On some

fingering,
tunes, he slides up the neck with one finger

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

a

that the Smokey V alley Boys had "the most
unusual timekeeping of any band."

neck was to slide his index and middle
fingers a lot, rather than note up and down
the scale with all four fingers as most people

Benton's unexpected phrasing accents

added to an unusual fingering technique
combine with two other distinguishing
choice of notes and tone
characteristics
to create his trademark sound.
Whether due to fingering or bowing pe
culiarities, or simply on account of how
Benton Flippen hears tunes and thinks

about them, the important notes in a tune
different for him than for

are often quite

other fiddlers. At the same time, he doesn't
lose the landmark notes which identify

melodies. Sometimes he will construct

Benton extracts

a

a

clear, wailing sound

fiddle which many listeners find
fascinating, and some few genuinely dis
like. Whatever people's opinions may be,
this siren-like tone drifting far over the
grounds of fiddlers conventions in North
Carolina and Virginia has lent a certain
excitement to the events for several de
from

Fiddle &amp; Dance Camp, Ashokan, NY.

Jarrell,

Every tune he plays passes through what
this writer has come to call "the Flippen
filter," and emerges as something new.
a

cades and is not likely to be duplicated.
Without necessarily intending to, Benton
Flippen has stretched and sometimes burst

through the boundaries of how most people
consider individual tunes, old-time music
and music in general. In this respect, he has
as much in common with younger "new
and with bluewave" old-time musicians
as he
grass innovators of the postwar era
does with the old-timers he admires. At
first listen, his style may seem more mod
ern than those of some of his forbears in the

area, and some old-time
music devotees have placed lower value
on what he does as a result. Others defend

Surry County

him energetically, saying he embodies the

old-time music tradition and moves the
music forward. This controversy is prob
ably appropriate, since Benton is a product
of his time, a time in which musical tastes,
social pressures, and a variety of influences
were transforming the sound of rural coun
try music. Benton Flippen himself insists
that he is
but

definitely an old-time musician,

what he

is

called probably doesn't

matter. Basically, he has been honest with
himself in playing music that he likes, the
way he wants to, learned from sources

around him. He

is

a

one-time musical

phenomenon. AsWashington

Post

(continued

reviewer

on page 60)

�Section with Illegible Text

OFFER

Subscribe
Acoustic

I

a

rcrar:

Ri

i

ii

re

MUSICIAN,

Musician today
and receive vour

NECHVILLE
MUSICAL

FREE Blue Ribbon

PRODUCTS,

featuring a great banjo lineup and
your automatic entry in the
drawing for a brand-new Nechville

Banjo CD

and

ROUNDER
RECORDS

NEXTAR Banjo
The Nextar Banjo features include a slanted, in-line
peghead, radiused fingerboard with beautiful motherof-pearl Cascade inlay design, Nechville Enterprise
bridge, black Heli-mount frame, and Price tailpiece.
The banjo comes with a professional, fabric-covered
hardshell protech case and designer Webb strap. If
desired, the winner may select a Nechville Bantar six-

Blue Ribbon Banjo CD
We are pleased to offer this new release, a part of the
25th anniversary celebration for Rounder! The disc
includes a wide range of banjo styles from J.D. Crowe,
Scott Vestal, Bill Keith, Bela Fleck, William Ball, Tony
Trischka, and five more!

string (guitar) neck or the Nextar five-string

neck.

No

to

to enter banjo drawing. Drawing to be held September
Kentucky. CD offer expires 9/30/95. All orders must be postmarked

purchase necessary

21

1

(banjo)

995, in Owensboro,
date.

by that

SUBSCRIPTION FORM

ACOUSTIC

MUSICIAN

P.O. Box 1349,

New Market, VA 22844 -1349

Name
Address
State

City

Card Number

Please charge my
VISA
Mastercard
New

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Exp. Date

Signature

Renewal
One-Year Subscription
Two-Year Subscription

Ph.

Zip

Outside the U.S., please add $10.00 per year (U.S. funds only, please)

$22.50
$42.00

Acoustic Musician

is

published

by

Border

Crossing Publications,

Incorporated.

acm8/95

�"Pockets

of Eccentricity"

An Interview with

by

Terry

Marshall Wyatt

First in

a

Series of Conversations with Record Collectors

interview initiates a projected
series of conversations with
record collectors, in particular

This

those who collect country music
that was recorded during the great Depres
sion and before, the era most often used to
define "old-time." These talks will attempt
to shed light on the methods and motives

collectors, their importance to the world
music, and the complex and sometimes
contradictory roles they assume-- be it ar
chivist, artist, historian, entrepreneur, entertainer,
or educator. Record collectors
will have a chance to describe their acqui
sitions, discuss their philosophy, air their
of

of

grievances, reveal their obsessions, or sim
ply tell their stories.
Terry Zwigoff did almost all of that when
with him over a can of Coke in
I sat down
the kitchen of his Bernal Heights home in
San

Francisco

in July of 1994.

Zwigoff

is

informed, opinionated, and funny. A film
maker and musician, he is also an inveter
ate collector, as a visit to his house makes
apparent. The gleaming white enameled
GE

Zwigoff

monitor-top

Jug Band

refrigerators,

the sack of

Flour, the original 1920s floral

wallpaper, the assortment of antique funnymost ex
paper figurines, and the world's
tensive array of Valmor Products (a line of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

novelties and cosmetics aimed at black con
sumers in the 1930s) all attest to his col
lecting fervor. Rows and rows of 78 rpm
records in green or tan sleeves fill a custombuilt shelf that dominates an entire room
devoted to vintage musical artifacts. Terry' s
girlfriend, Missy Axelrod, lives with him
in this house where virtually everything
predates World War II.
Zwigoff himself was born a few years
after the war, in a small town in Wisconsin
called Weyauwega (population 1,207),
where his uncle and grandfather were dairy

Zwigoff still performs as a Cheap Suit
Serenader although appearances by the
band are infrequent. When he's not im
mersed in a film project, Zwigoff can often
be found playing his vintage Gibson banjomandolin with a San Francisco instrumen
tal trio known as the Excitement Boys,
which also includes fiddler Rob Kerwin
and guitarist Craig Ventresco.
At the time of this interview, Zwigoff
had just completed editing his new film
entitled Crumb, a serious look at fabled
underground cartoonist Robert Crumb that

attended the University of Wisconsin at
Madison before migrating to San Francisco
in 1970, where he soon took up cello and

explores the psychological factors and fam
ily dynamics that have shaped Crumb's
singular artistic vision. (R. Crumb, by the
way, is also a musician and record collec
tor.) The subsequent success of the film
prompted a follow-up interview with

mandolin, joined the newly-formed Cheap

Zwigoff by telephone

Bluie, profiled Howard Armstrong, one of
the last remaining black musicians to play
in the old-time string-band tradition. The

val, Crumb was hailed by New Yorker critic
Terrence Rafferty as "the best American

farmers, "probably the only Jewish farm
ers in Wisconsin." His family moved to
Chicago when he was five; in the late 1960s
he

Suit Serenaders, and became involved with
filmmaking. His 1985 documentary, Louie

film was warmly received by critics but
met with limited commercial success. A

second documentary, never released, fea
tured veteran Hawaiian musician Tau Moe
and his family.

in February of 1995.
Winner of the Grand Jury Prize for best
documentary at the Sundance Film Festi

film of the year," and has been released
nationally, a rare feat for any documen
tary.

Here then is Terry Zwigoff giving his
views on record collecting, movie making,
string-band music, the Dallas Police

�Department, and the ongoing quest to track
down those obscure remnants of bygone
American culture, those "pockets of eccen
tricity," as he puts it, that have given us
some of our finest music. Interviewer is in
italics.]

What does the term "old-time music" mean

There are so few of them that ever re
corded, but the few I've heard are great.
I have this
argument with other collec
tors like Richard Nevins
he loves groups
like Crockett Ward doing "Deadheads and
Suckers" and I personally find that record

really tedious, monotonous, really nothing
going on. But probably that record's more

representational of authentic white coun

try music. The music

I like has more of a
black influence combined with country

(continued

on

next page)

to

you

means pre-1933, with a few
collect country records from
exceptions.
1926 to 1932 mostly. I tend to think that a lot
of these records represent music that was
unchanged since the turn of the century.
Old-time music to me infers that it's pure
and in some regards unsullied by outside
influences, even though that's really im
To

me

it

I

possible.
Do you regard this period as the "Golden Era"
of recorded music?
Oh yeah, the late 1920s. To me, that's oldtime music. And past that, well, if I hear a
Milton Brown record from the mid-'30s I
might really like it, but I don't consider it

old-time music. It's just been too influ
enced by the modern age. The older music
is more backwoods and I think of it as
representing real isolated pockets of ec
centricity,
WTwf happened to thai
I

see radio, or mass

eccentricity?

communications

in

ruining that isolation, which to
general,
me is what's most interesting about it.
as

People started imitating. People would hear
Bing Crosby on the radio, so they'd all try
to sound like him instead of having enough
faith in their own

weirdness

to

keep

it

going.

think of

it mostly as meaning country
which to me would also include
country blues and jug bands. It wouldn't
include jazz unless maybe it was some
really small town territorial type of group.
I think
of black string bands as old-time
I

Wyatt

Does old-time music mean only white rural
music or does it include more?

music. Certainly the Baxter Brothers and
bands like the Tennessee Chocolate Drops.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Marshall

music,

at

"Easy Winner" was the tune that sparked his
interest in old-time music. Recorded in 1928, "Easy Winner" was performed by Nap Hayes on
guitar and Matthew Prater on mandolin. Although the musicians were black, the record was released
Terry Zwigoff

home with his record collection.

on OKeh's white hillbilly series as by The Blue Boys.

�music so that the syncopation or the rhythm
more interesting or the musician playing

is

lead has some different way of playing

it.

That just makes it more interesting to me.
Some of those records are so repetitive and

that's the negative connotation of
A lot of tunes don't have
chords,
many
usually just three chords,
and they generally don't have that circle of
fifths ragtime sort of progression. It's more
to me

old-time music.

like country dance music, which would be
a dance, but I wouldn't want to

fun for

listen to

it on a

record over and over again.

Can you

give me a general description of your
record collection?
As

I

said,

I

generally collect records from

the late '20s, mostly country, jazz, and blues,
but have a smattering of ethnic records,

favorite record? What's the record you want
most in the world?" And I said "Easy Win

that Whistler's Jug Band film, with a good
soundtrack, than listen to that record. It's

ner" by Nap Hayes and Matthew Prater,
and he was delighted because it was so

just

common compared

to

what he wanted.

Why not just collect tapes

records. As far as country goes, I
try to get those records that have an inter
esting syncopated rhythm section. And
since I play mandolin and cello I started
the East
early collecting those records
Texas Serenaders that had cello on them,
lot of jazz

Mississippi

Possum

Hunters,

George

Edgin's Corn Dodgers, and almost any
body with a mandolin, like the great Coley
Jones. I wanted to learn that music, and I
didn't have any other place to hear it.
What first started you collecting records? What
made you want to do it?

must have been in the early '70s, I
a reissue of "Easy Winner." It was on

It

heard

an LP that Joe Bussard released. It was a
collection of stuff, mostly music that he had
put out with his own jug band, but in the
middle of all these cuts on the LP he sneaks

only life were that simple! If only we
were that sane! (laughter) If you have mil
lions of dollars it seems legitimate to collect
originals but if you're poor and have a real

compulsory mind

it

gets sort of ridiculous.

With tapes and LPs the sound quality
just never compares. I've made tapes where
the sound quality is fine but there's always
some kind of problem the tape gets de

stroyed or eaten up

in

some machine.

"What's the record you
want most in the
world?" And I said
Easy Winner" hy Nap
Hayes and Matthew
Prater.
have tapes that are 20 years old and the
surface is literally flaking off the tape. And
LPs, they warp, they scratch a lot easier. 78s
are the most durable. I'm set up to play
them easier,
them. And

I
I

have

a

good system to play

feel one step closer

to the

this cut seemed totally different to me and
I wasn't sure
why. They had filtered out a

and I'm listening to some old record, gee, I
wish there was a film that existed of this

lot of the surface

of

it

noise but there was enough

there that you could tell

from an old record.

when

I

heard that,

sion on me
Later I think

was taken

just sat bolt

I

it

it

made

a

upright
deep impres

heard the original 78 at
somebody's house, but I didn't find a copy
until 10 years ago, and that was through
I

Richard Nevins. I'd found
that he really wanted,
rare a Carter Brothers
the only known copy.
get that record," and

a

it
&amp;

I

a

long while

a

film will turn

like the
up, beyond my wildest dreams
film of Whistler's Jug Band. I saw that and

thought, this is the greatest day of my life!
But I'm so neurotic, as soon as the film was
over I thought, gee, I wish I could see that
band live! And then I'm sure if I saw the
band live I'd be unhappy because I'd want
play like the mandolin player.

country record

to be able to

You can't win with my way of thinking,

Nevins said,

"I

gotta

said "Forget it." So

he said "Well, I'll trade you

band. Once in

was incredibly
Son Vocalion,

what's your

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

s

general and always having been. And
being happy to find some music that no
body else likes. As petty as that may sound,
I know that's
part of the appeal for me. I
have such alienation towards most people
in

find

hard to like anything they like.
want my taste to be more than
simply a reaction to theirs, but I know that
the alienation has influenced me. I hated
everybody in high school and at the time I
that

I

it

Of course

I

just couldn't separate the music they

thing about old-time music at the time, but

Winner" by Nap Hayes and Mat
thew Prater. It was a guitar and mandolin
duo and it was great! I didn't know any

I

a
bygone, better
therean element of nostalgia foryou?

Is

don't think for me that's true. For me
just a question of being really alienated

I

it'

If

music and the people who made it by own
ing those records rather than having a tape.
It's hard to explain why, because you really
can't rationally explain it, but when I listen
to those 78s I feel that much closer to the
original experience. And often I have the
feeling, when I'm really in a neurotic mood

in "Easy

world?

or LPs

I

some Italian string bands, and some Irish.
I
mostly like string bands, but I do have a

Do you feel that 78s represent

Why do you feel like you have to collect the

original 78s

much more intense experience.

a

(laughter)
But having that record

lis

tened to from them. I hated it. But I didn't
know anybody who listened to this older
music, so that had an appeal for me. Pretty
sick reason! (laughter)
How did you go about building up your collec
tion? Where

When

through

do you

find these records?

first started, I used to just dig
piles and piles of hundreds of

I

thousands of records. And quickly learned

it wasn't worth the time and trouble,
around here anyway in California. I started
to collect in about 1970 when I moved to

that

San Francisco.
Would

look

you

in

places like the Salvation

Army stores?
Yeah, there, and even at record stores I' d
go to Jack's Record Cellar or I'd go to some
store out in Stockton or Modesto thinking,
Oh boy, they have like a hundred thousand
78s
but they'd been picked through for 20

years. Oh, occasionally you'd find some
mediocre record, but it wasn't really worth
it. So I started discovering auction lists and

discovered that
bucks for

a

it was cheaper to
pay twenty
record without putting in like

2,000 hours of labor, and do
And I started trading. I found

it

that way.

a

lot of jazz

records and then

I
bought a jazz collection
guy in Oakland, and there were a lot
of records I already had or didn't want so
I'd end up trading them for country records
or blues records.

from

a

Do you think that all of the really good
ible records are already in the hands of

collect
collec

tors?

think

huge percentage of them are. I
tend
think maybe two percent are still
out there
maybe more like one percent
I

a

to

least makes me
feel that much closer, and ideally I'd have
a film of each band. I'd much rather watch
at

from personal experience from digging
through attics and flea markets. Every now

�something turns up, but

and again

it's

gen

erally when some collector dies. I don't see
too many good records coming from homes
these days, certainly not here. I don't know
what it's like in the South.
I made
a
couple of trips through the
South in the '70s looking for records. One
trip was in 1974 and it was one of the most

miserable experiences of my life. I went
another record collector, Sherwin
Dunner. He's my cousin. He had a van but
with

we had no money. We had a couple of air
in the back of this van and our

mattresses

smart idea was to go in July and August! It
was unbearably hot and the police were

harassing us everywhere.
We started from Dallas. I flew in from
San Francisco and Sherwin picked me up at
the Dallas airport. He picked me up at 6
o'clock at night, I got into the van, put my
suitcase in the back, and three minutes
later we were pulled over by

a
plain clothes
Dallas Police car. Within 10 minutes of that
there were 20 police cars with their lights

and sirens on, and they started ransacking
our possessions! We were in downtown

said, "Boys, you gonna spend 40 years to
life in jail we find so much as one seed of

marry- wanna here." But they finally had to
let us go. But before they did they gave us

big lecture on the Kennedys. They still
hated Kennedy and they were really proud
because we were right near where Oswald
a

shot Kennedy. They said, "See that up there,
that is a state landmark 'cause that's where
that sonuvabitch
got his head

pinko commie Kennedy

blowed off!" And we were

thinking, oh man, welcome to Texas!
We got harassed all through the trip.
And I don't think there's a single record I
kept from all the records we found. I don't
have a single one of those records today. I
thinkthe best record we found was a badly
cracked Robert Johnson record. We saw a
lot of great records but they were all just
to

death. We knocked on doors in

played
poorblack neighborhoods and white neigh
borhoods as well. We were warned by a
couple

of

people that this was very

ous thing to do. But

it

danger

didn't seem dangerous

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Marshall

our stuff. They found a plastic bag that
Sherwin had wrapped his toothbrush in,
and they were convinced it held pot or
something. They were sure they'd made a
big dope bust. All this after I'd taken the
precaution of cutting my hair real short!
One cop took us aside with a really men
acing sort of sleazy southern accent and

Wyatt

Dallas and they just dumped out suitcases
into the street and started kicking through

L:

Terry Zwigoff, banjo-mandolin;
Patrick's Day, March 17, 1989.

Robert Crumb, guitar. Dovre Club, San Francisco, St.

R:

time. We didn't have any trouble
from people, we only had trouble from

at the

police.
I remember
going to see a man in Tyler,
Texas. He had something like a million
records in a corrugated iron barn behind
his house. They were in no order, there
were heaps of them, they were broken un
der your feet. The first record I pulled out
was a really good country record, it was the

"Donald Rag" by the Martin Melody Boys.
was in decent shape and he wanted a

It

dollar for that. So

I

was thrilled,

I

though,

oh boy, this is it, I've hit it now! And we
stayed there for eight hours and there was

nothing else that

I

would have taken for

free! It's hard to find
Is

there

good records.

turnover in your collection?
collection change as your tastes

much

Does you
change?

My tastes have pretty much stayed the
same after I'd been collecting a couple of
years and developed an ear for what

interested in.

listening

to

I

was

County LPs. I started to do my home
work
how do I find these records and
what label are they on? I'd hear

a

record on

the LP and then I'd look for the 78 and

advertise for it. Or eventually I'd find it on
an auction list in sort of rough shape, then
it by a trade or by
on
another
bidding higher
copy.

10

years later upgrade

Would

you describe

record

collecting as an

addiction?

(laughter) That's certainly part of it for
something you can really ratio
nalize. I don't know if I feel like I need a fix
I used to have that
every so often
feeling
more than I do now. Now I'm more inter
ested in the music.
I'd feel less addicted to owning the 78s if
all that music came out on CD, if
things
were reissued in really good shape and
me. It's not

an ear by

mainly developed
those County LPs of Dave
I

Freeman's. That was the music I liked more
than anything else I'd heard on other LPs.
Harry Smith with Folkways put out some
great stuff too, but it was mostly those

(continued

on

next page)

�L:

Original drawing

by Robert Crumb

1985 San Francisco premier

for the

of Zwigoff's

film

Louie Bluie.

with the Cheap Suit Serenaders

back

in

the

1970s?

Bluie

Louie

I think
they're better than most, which
isn't saying much. I think they compare
miserably with the sound of the age that we
were trying to copy. We weren't trying to
copy them note for note, we were trying to

get the feel of these records, and to me that
would have been success. To get that same
feel that the records had, or that same emo
tion or whatever

it

is.

I

think we failed

miserably, although with a few exceptions.
In a few cases I was pretty happy with what

happened, but it's hard, it's hard

to do.

I

have an inkling of why that is-- the level of
musicianship in the '20s was on a par prob

ably with the level of craftsmanship in
building a cabinet or a chair or a home, and
it's just unheard of today. And people tend

disregard it, this old-time music. They
think, oh, there's nothing to it, it's just three
chords. I saw David Grisman once in con

to

cert and he was really talking

you knew they weren't going to disinte
grate on you. I'm not all that sold on CDs,
but they're acceptable to me. Of course

there's almost no country music available
on CD-- only a few things like Jimmie
Rodgers and the Carter Family. And some
people say that CDs will go bad after 20
years. 78s are still the most dependable.
What do you think of current bands that play

old-time music?

don't hear too many of them. My first
exposure to old-time music was from 78s
almost entirely and then I heard the bands
later. I heard the New Lost City Ramblers
doing a Charlie Poole song and I thought
they were terrible. But of course anybody
would be, I can't imagine anybody being
I

able to pull that stuff off. And it's not just
the fault of the musicians, it's a factor of the

recording
hundred-dollar

engineer.

They

put

a

microphone about

twelvean inch

from the sound hole and their gauges all
line up on their meters and they artificially

blend the different instruments together.
They're all recorded separately, either at

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

different times or

in

a

room with baffles

and then they mix them at whatever level
they want the mix to be. And it's very

artificial to me, it's not what my ears hear
when I listen to music live. When you go
hear a band you're not going to stick your
ear two inches from the guitar sound hold!
I don't
see why they don't back up, put a
band in a live room, not totally deadened

with

soundproofing

get some

and

real

sound bouncing off the walls which is what
you hear in real life. In these new record
ings you hear less music and more things
like the guy's fingers actually sliding on the
strings as much as you can hear a note of

music. It's ridiculous. It's technical over
kill. It's not appropriate for music.
Those old 78s were certainly recorded

better feel for what the music really
sounded like. They certainly sound more
with

a

real to me, it's a more natural sound. But
it's also a way of life and a part of this

culture that's impossible

to

recreate. And

it's sort of crazy to try.

How

do you feel about

the records

you made

patroniz

ingly about some old-time band that had
just gotten off the stage. He said, "Oh yeah,
I used
to play that three-chord stuff my
self." The thing is, he couldn't play it any
better than they could. He would have the
technical chops of course, but not the feel.
Only a few musicians I've met really
have that sound down, that quality that
appeals to me in old-time music. One of the
few guys that comes to mind is Tom Marion.
He's an Italian guitar player, his parents
were Italian, they were musicians and he
started learning when he was three. He
lives in L. A. now. He's so out of it, he's so

culturally separated from most people and

something to do with it.
And he's spent so much time alone, he's
put in so much practice time. He's such a
I'm sure that has

good musician.

I

know

a

lot of good

musi

cians, but I've never met anybody close to
his ability to accompany old-time music or

blues

or

even jazz for that matter. And it's

subtle, what he does is very subtle. If you
listen to Cannon's Jug Stompers and you

listen to the guitar player, even though
there's three chords, his phrasing is very
subtle, the bass runs are very subtle. And
Tom Marion is the only guy I know of who
can do that today, get that same sort of feel.
Part of it is technical, part of it is being able
to hear what to do. Most musicians might
miss the subtlety and think, oh, close

�Excitement Boys Old-Time
String Band are Craig Ventresco on
guitar, Rob Kerwin on fiddle, and Terry
R: The

Zwigoff

on

musicians

banjo-mandolin. All three
collectors and

are avid record

their repertoire consists of tunes learned
from old 78s. Drawing by Marshall

Wyatt, 1992.
I'll just

enough,

play this C-7th chord

here. They just don't pick up on it.
But T ommy gets it down just exactly
and you think, oh, that's what that
guy was doing on the record.

Tom Marion learned country

mu

sic from 78s, but he got his guitar

accompaniment ability from his
uncle and grandfather.

I

the

a

once had

home re
hearing
them
drunk at
cording
a
These
were
done
recordings
party.
sometime in the 1940s, and they were
as good as any old-time American
country record that I ever heard,
they just happened to be singing in

privilege

of

of the two of

Italian.

was great,

It

it

was abso

lutely great. They were playing all
types of dance music and ballads.
They had the same feel as Cannon's Jug
Stompers or Charlie Poole or any of these
other great musicians. I don't know exactly
what it is. To me it's always been syncopa
tion and rhythm that makes any perfor
mance better than the next. And Tom
Marion has the innate feel for it.

So yeah, it's definitely sick,
sick club of losers! (laughter)

a

sick club,

a

Missy Axelrod enters the kitchen briefly

to

Excitement Boys.)

Missy, why don't women collect 78s? Why

is it

always men?

Oh man, I don't know if I dare answer
that question! Well, obviously to some de

think men are just more compulsive
about obtaining things, about hoarding
things. It's a way for men to decorate their

gree

it is.

There's some quality about the

bragging and boasting and the lording and
the envy and the jealousy. It started for me
always had that side to my
from
collecting comic books as
personality
a kid. I always had this incredibly
strong
rivalry about collecting with my cousin
Sherwin Dunner, who's now one of the
major record collectors in the country. We
were both collecting the same comic
books, these Donald Duck comic books, and
if one of us found one that the other one
didn't have we'd never hear the end of it!
as

a

kid.

I

Oh, this is the greatest! This one has got the
best story in it! And we were totally into the
the first thing we tried to do was
decipher the sort of Byzantine numbering
system. Why does this Donald Duck #12

numbers

higher number in 1 952 than the one in
a lower number? That aspect al
ways fascinated me, serial numbers and stuff.
have

a

1954 with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

lives

maybe they're trying to attract
mate, like those birds we saw.
We saw

a

nature documentary the
other day about how most animals fight it
out, the strongest male gets to mate with
TZ:

a

the female. But there's this one bird who's

collector. The male collects twigs and
a
display, not a nest, but a display
like a big arch. Whichever male builds the
display that the female deems most attrac
like

a

builds

tive, she mates with him. It's definitely an
exception, an oddity in the animal king
dom.
It

seems with humans not all male collectors are

successful

in

attracting

a

mate.

Yep, that's true. It's the same with most
record collectors,
groups of collectors
postcard collectors, comic book collectors

there's always

an

What

is

the

importance

of

record

collecting

beyond your own personal gratification?

Are 78s collectors an elite men's club?

MA:

It

women who

remind Terry that it's nearly time to head over
to the Haight-Aishbury for a sidewalk gig with
the

seems like there'd be a few neurotic
also collect that kind of stuff,
but they don't for the most part. There
might be some but not nearly as prevalent
as men. I don't get it. Keep asking that
question, that has interest for me.
men.

element of lonely single

My personal experience has been that
impossible to get any of these so-called
archives to be very cooperative. If you're
doing research on a film or a book or what
ever, just try to get them to cooperate
it's

enough

to

get

a

tape out of them or some

music that you want to hear, to study, to do
anything with. A lot of these curators con
sider it their own private fiefdom or their
own private record collection, and they're

notoriously hard to deal with and stingy
uncooperative.

and

On the other hand, most private

collec

tors are more than happy to make you

a

tape. Most guys will doit very freely. Some
may charge you a nominal fee to do it,
which is fine. It's the way to go to have

access to that stuff.
So to answer your question, I think that
private collectors are just about solely re
sponsible for having this music alive at all.
A lot of people would argue, oh, these folk
(continued on next page)

�Howard Armstrong

R:

("Louie Bluie") and Ted

Terry Zwigoff's Top Ten

Bogan recorded four sides
for Bluebird in 1934,

including "State Street
Rag,"

a

(actually 14)

Old-time String-band 78s

mandolin and

guitar instrumental. The
two musicians were still

(in

no particular order)

partners 50 years later
when Terry Zwigoff
in his film

featured them

documentary Louie
Bluie. "That record took
on

a

"There are so many
great records I could
hardly limit it to ten--

certain mystique for

me. It's very subtle and

and this doesn't even

totally effortless sounding.

include jug bands! But
these are records I
would never sell,

Slight variations on the
same theme, but they're
all great."

you'd have

to pry

them out of my hands
as I'm dying!"--

festivals and live music
festivals keep it alive.
I've never gone to

a

T. Z.

folk

festival that had any
kind of music that
seemed like the real
music

I've heard

off

Old Pal Smoke Shop Four
Fiddlin' Bob Larkin

"Lindy"
"Dallas Rag"
"Broken Bed Blues"
"Black Cat Blues"

Columbia
Columbia
Vocalion
Vocalion

"Saturday Night Waltz"

connection with that old
music which was part

Carter Brothers &amp; Son
Prince Albert Hunt

"Nancy Rowland"
"Houston Slide"

Okeh 45229
Vocalion 5349

of

Earl

these old records. Some
bands come closer than

Proximity String Quartet
Dallas String Band
Kansas City Blues Strummers

others, but modern
culture's too screwed
up, there's just

a

a

broken

culture that just

doesn't exist anymore.
know you've known a
number of musicians from
I

"Tail of

Victor 23722

"K.C. Railroad Blues"

Victor 20962

Louie Bluie
Burnett &amp; Rutherford

"State Street Rag"
"All Night Long"

Bluebird 5593
Columbia 15314

The Blue Boys (Hayes

Louie Bluie about the life
of Howard Armstrong.

couldn't
get him to play his music right! "Howard!
You're not playing your music right!"
I

(laughter)
When I first got together with him and
Ted Bogan they'd been playing together
since the '20s. I told them I wanted to do a

movie about them and
hear them play together.

I
I

was curious to
guess this was in

the early '80s. Unlike most people

at

the

time, I wasn't even aware there was a band
Martin, Bogan &amp; Armstrong. So they took
out their instruments and started playing
and they were a world away from what I'd
heard by them

on

78s.

&amp;

Prater)

They had modernized

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

better musicians technically maybe but to

ears they were just doing what
amounted to a sort of lounge act, a schlocko
lounge act. And it was a struggle through
that whole movie to get those guys to play
in an older style. I would have to keep
my

cutting and say, "Ted, can you just play in
first position?" The tune he was playing
had three chords and he'd go way up the
neck and it didn't sound right. Ted fought
me through the whole movie because I
guess he didn't want to appear like he was
regressing. It was like, OK, I learned this
stuff as a kid and know I'm a better musi
cian and

I

Columbia 15565

Okeh 45314

"Easy Winner"

their sound and Ted Bogan was playing
diminished 13th chords and they'd become

What was that like?

even had trouble with him!

1046

Happy Hayseeds
Bentley Boys
Jim &amp; Andrew Baxter

that older generation, and
course
you
made the film
of

I

1048

Okeh 45446
Okeh 45223

"Mississippi Jubilee"
Haley's Comet"
"Henhouse Blues"

Johnson

15533
14290

don't want to play

it.

And

I

guess

over the years they'd gotten a lot of flack
about this being country bumpkin music,
only rubes play this. And they were more

sophisticated these days and wanted to
come off that way.
But Howard Armstrong, to his credit,
had enough pride in that old music that he
knew what I was talking about, and he
would help with Ted to get him to play in
an older style. Sometimes it worked. I feel
that the music in that movie is somewhere
in between what they were capable of in
the old days and what they're doing today.
I like it better than most of the stuff
they do

today. Of course, when I'm 751 doubt
even be able to tune my instrument.
barely tune

it

now!

if I'll
I

can

�What was the original inspiration for making
the movie
I

Louie Bluie?

found that record. That Bluebird record

of "State Street Rag" by Louie Bluie. And
I heard it I wasn't
actually that
with
it.
I
impressed
thought, oh, this is sort
of monotonous and repetitive. He's doing
the same thing over and over again. Then
five years later I sat down and tried to learn

the first time

on the mandolin.

listened
recorder
and
slowed
put
tape
it down, tried to hear every nuance. I real
ized what he was doing was so incredible,
it's hard to describe. If you listen to that
record really carefully you'll get some ap
preciation of what a great musician that
sat there and

Armstrong

I

Robert

it on a

I

courtesy

to it.

Yoni,

it

sounding. Slight varia
tions on the same theme, but they're all
great. He just has this feel that's unbeliev
able. With "State Street Rag" the more I sat
and listened to that record the more respect

totally effortless

gained for it. I realized it's easy enough to
play some half-assed version of this thing
but to play it the way he does it!
I

That record

took on

for me after

a

certain kind of

listened to

it

that

mystique
much. Because of this mystique I said, who
is this guy Louie Bluie? It's obviously a
pseudonym. He was mentioned on the liner
notes of an LP that Nick Perls put out,
String Ragtime, but the notes avoided the
whole subject of who this guy really was. I
I

Photo

by

guy was. And it's exactly the same if you
listen to his fiddle record with the Tennes
see Chocolate Drops. It's very subtle and

The Cheap Suit Serenaders,

York Theater, San Francisco, CA 1978. L-R: Robert Armstrong, Bob

Brozman, Allan Dodge, Robert Crumb, Terry Zwigoff, Tom Marion.

these guys and interviewed them and
filmed them? I just thought Armstrong
was incredible. He certainly had me laugh
ing harder than just about anybody ever
had and he started talking about old music
and he had answers to just about anything
you'd want to know. He was over here

down with

once and

I

sat him

questions

a

mile long.

I

had

a

a

list of

record of

by Leecan &amp; Cooksey
record by the Old Pal Smoke Shop
Four that talks about boning a black cat and
"Black Cat Bone"

really liked off old 78s and

and

player named David Boeddinghaus per
form it. I was forced to choose tunes that
were composed or published before 1918
so it would be in the public domain and
since he was performing it I wouldn't have
to pay any sort of synchronization license
fee, so it was essentially affordable to do it

I

a

asked, what

is that all

that mean? Am

about? What does

New Orleans Jazz Festi

hearing the lyrics right?
And he'd tell you all the implications of
what it meant to bone a black cat! He knew
all that stuff. Fascinating guy.

was watching because I knew Carl
Martin was in this group and I'd heard his

Your new movie, Crumb, has been receiving
accolades from all sides. What can you tell us

had no idea

was the guy in Martin, Bogan
&amp; Armstrong because I'd never heard them
Well, actually I did see a brief clip of them
it

on TV once at the

val.

I

guitar playing from the '20s and '30s and it
was incredible. So I was watching him and
he was interesting but I hated the fiddler

though that guy was

really jive
thought, who is this guy?
Turns out it's Louie Bluie!
That's how I got interested in making the
movie. After I got hooked on the record, I
player!

I

fiddle player.

made

it a

Bogan

&amp;

a

I

point to go see him with Martin,
Armstrong. I think it was the last

I

about the film?
I'm so close to the
I

can talk about

it

movie

I

objectively.

don't know
I

about the movie but I can vouch for the
music because I feel objective enough about
I have no
qualms about endorsing the
soundtrack.
The music was determined pretty much

that.

job Carl Martin
in

nal dream was to have the entire

impact on me as a larger-than-life character
with incredible charisma and I was shocked
that nobody had really noticed him until
then. Why hadn't people who knew about
Martin, Bogan &amp; Armstrong sat down with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

if

don't know

by monetary compromises, as most
sions in the movie industry are. My

played with them out here
California before he died. And this time
Howard Armstrong immediately had an

My Type" and "I Must Have It," these great
tunes that I wanted to use for background
music in the film but when I approached
RCA Victor about it they were adamant
$5,000 apiece for those tunes and I just
couldn't afford it. I actually used one King
Oliver record in the whole film, and for the
rest I was forced to come up with a cheaper
way to do the music. So I found music I

deci

origi

soundtrack

of King Oliver Victor records. There are
three or four in particular, records that

King Oliver and his Orchestra recorded on
Victor in the late '20s that have a certain
sound on them. The tunes were less hot
and more sweet really. Tunes like "You're

I

had

I had
hoped to have
orchestrated kind of music, but

that way.

a

a

piano

big band,

ended up
on
most
cuts, piano and
being just piano
But
he
did
an
incredible
job, the
guitar.
it

music's great.
David Boeddinghaus is a piano player
who lives in New Orleans and plays with a
number of different bands including Banu
Gibson's band. He used to tour with Leon
Redbone. He's an extremely gifted piano
player; he's been into Jelly Roll Morton
since he was just a kid. For the soundtrack
we discussed him playing a version of

"Frog-I-More Rag" by Morton that was
in the '20s but published
before that. I asked him if he knew it and he
said he did, and it's an obscure tune, not
many piano players play it. But when
David came to San Francisco he had the
first recorded

(continued

on

next page)

�music all written out and I said, "Great,
thanks for going to all that trouble," and he
said, "Oh, I wrote that out a long time ago."
And I looked at the piece of paper and it
was really yellowed and brittle, so I said,
"How long ago did you write that out?"
And he says, "The sixth grade!" And it's a

street playing electric guitar through a little
amplifier. It was Craig and he was playing
absolutely incredible music. I went up and
gave him some money and waited until he

can't get rid of, clicked jingles
and TV commercials, all that stuff gets all
jumbled up and ruins any sort of original
sound you might have. I've just heard too

hard tune, there's a lot going on. I can just
see him sitting in the back of study hall! Its'

We started playing music together and
still play music with him today.

I

my own feelings as a musician to feel like I
should have the right or the nerve to try
and put myself over. It's fun to play this old
music but I would never pretend to do

sort of amazing.
Who

plays guitar

on the

soundtrack?

Craig Ventresco. He lives in San Fran
cisco and I'd first heard him playing on the
street.

was walking down the street one day
and heard an old Blind Blake tune, I think
"Southern Rag." I thought, oh,
it was
somebody's playing a tape of Blind Blake
I

I

Suddenly the music shifted to a
Buddy Boy Hawkins tune, "Snatch It and
tunes.

started looking around to see
where this music's coming from and I saw

Grab It."

I

this young kid

in

his early 20s sitting by the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was done and talked to him and it turns out
he knew all about Louie Bluie, it was his
favorite film, and he was a big fan of mine.

When did you first meet Robert Crumb and how
the two of you interacted in terms of

have

music?
I've known Crumb for almost 25 years. I
met him through one of my roommates at

the time in San Francisco. He'd show up at
for a couple of days and
our

apartment

was just getting
interested in old 78s at the time and he
knew a lot more about them than I did. He
helped me with figuring out what labels to
look for, what series were interesting, what
hang around there and

I

were good, and compare notes. Even
tually he formed a band with two other
friends of his, A1 Dodge and Bob
band

s

Armstrong, and he encouraged me to take
up an instrument to play music with them.
And one of them had
had left behind

at

a

cello that someone

their house, so

I

had

a

wanted to learn how to play it
how to play cello in this oldI tried to learn
fashioned style like they used in some fiddle
bands like the East Texas Serenaders and
free cello if

I

the GradyFamily,

wheretheyusedabowed

bass part almost. And so I
playing with the Cheap Suit

cello to imitate

started
Serenaders

a

in the

early '70s.

Was this your first experience

playing music?

Well, I'd played guitar a little bit before
that when I was a kid, I'd try to work out
the latest Buddy Holly tunes on the guitar,
but

I

music

was never that crazy about any of the
I heard. What was really
popular at

the time was Jerry Lee Lewis and Little
Richard, that kind of stuff, but it never sent
me to the point where I was passionate
about learning the music or devoting my
self to be a musician. It wasn't until the
early '70s that I heard any of this old-time

music for the first time, and I'm not saying
I'm any

at

it. It's

hard to play that

good
just doesn't make any sense to try
and note-for-note imitate that old sound.
Unless you grow up in that culture and
music,

head that

I

much music in my life, all these different
types, and I don't really feel genuine about

anything but instrumentals, I couldn't at
tempt to sing that stuff. I'm some Jewish
guy raised in the '50s in Chicago! It's ri
diculous!
onto a group of musicians
I stumbled
when we were shooting Louie Bluie. I think
it

was in Clinton, Tennessee

there was

a

barn every Saturday, a getgathering
where
20 or 30 fiddlers and guitar
together
in

a

ists and banjo players would come and all
jam together. There was some great music
there! One of the guys playing there was

the fiddler from the Roane County Ram
blers Jimmie McCarroll. He was about
he was great! Absolutely great!
These fiddle players, these old guys, had
kept exactly the old style. It was incredible.
And I was walking around this barn in dim
95. And

light and I'd hear somebody playing a waltz
ten feet to my left and simultaneously

somebody's playing

a

hot

breakdown ten

feet to my right. The music

I

heard there

sounded absolutely great.

few films of musicians
I saw a docu
did
for Houston
that
somebody
mentary
Public Television in the 1970s about Prince
And I've seen

a

who were also incredible.

Hunt. There's a scene of Oscar
Harper playing "Beaumont Rag" on fiddle
Albert

was great! Absolutely great! I re
cently heard Oscar Harper's original ver
sion of "Sallyjohnson" on Vocalion. Iheard
it for the first time recently at Richard

and

it

a mint copy of it.
Extremely rare record, it's never been reis
sued. I said, "Oh, what's this sound like?"
And Nevins of course says, "It's a master

Nevins' house. He had

it on, and yeah, it was a
the most intense fiddle
About
masterpiece!

piece." He puts

record I've ever heard.

It

was about the

greatest. You gotta hear that.

it

spend the day plowing a field in the hot
sun, I don't know if you're going to sound

like those guys. I don't know what it
takes, but there' ve certainly been too

many influences

in

my brain.

I

have all

these Beatles tunes running through my

Marshall Wyatt
living

in

is an

artist and record collector

North Carolina.

�Issues In Old-Time Music

Action Needed To Save the American Folklife Center and the

Archive of Folk Culture

67 years, as Tom Adler of the

Inter

Fornational Bluegrass Music Museum put
it, the Archive of Folk Culture at the Li
brary of Congress "has been a repository
recordings, photos, videos, etc. used by
hundreds of scholars, folklorists, and
documenters of folk culture. Much mate
rial related to old-time and bluegrass music
for

is

deposited there. The ongoing pro

grams of the American Folklife Center are
very valuable and groundbreaking forays
into the deliberate

documentation of Ameri

can folk culture."

With only

to use for another purpose. The
action was an amendment to the budget of

Congress

the Library introduced

by Rep. William
and
Clinger Pennsylvania
part of a larger
bill.
House
members
advo
appropriations
of

cating the amendment suggested that the
Center and its nearly 70-year old Archive

Culture should seek private funds.
Opponents of the action defended the role
of the Center and its archive in American
of Folk

culture. The vote was 260 to 159.
"The Folklife Center's current funding
and authorization ends Sept. 30th. A two-

couple of days notice, the
House of Representatives voted to elimi
nate funding for the American Folklife
Center, which includes the Archive of Folk

year reauthorization

Culture. The amendment to H.R.I 854 was

for them to raise

a

sponsored by Congressmen

Davis-VA,

Condit-CA, Clinger-PA, and Portman-OH.
The following letter was written and posted

has been

proposed

and is proceeding through Congress. How
ever, if the Center loses its funding and its
staff as of Sept. 30th, it will be impossible

funds

"The collections

Culture

include

in

order to continue.

of the

Archive of Folk

ethnographic

and

ethnomusicological documentation from

currently working
Washington,
canvass material for issue in the "endan

every state and from many foreign coun
tries as well. It includes the recordings of
Leadbelly, Woodie Guthrie, and Jelly Roll
Morton. Its collections of early wax cylin
der recordings of Native American music

gered music series" by Rykodisc, produced

and song are the largest

over the internet by Ken Bilby, and we
received permission to print it here. Bilby is
an

ethnomusicologist/linguist

based

in

D. C. He is

to

by Mickey Hart.
"The national

in the country.
Famous fieldworkers such as John and
Alan Lomax, Zora Neale Hurston, and
Herbert Halpert have entrusted their col
lections to the care of the nation in this

music
and culture, the Archive of Folk Culture
and its administrative offices at the Ameri
can Folklife Center at the Library of Con
gress, are threatened with the loss of their
public funds, which would take effect Sept.

"This action not only threatens our na
tional archive for folk traditions, but has
dire implications for all archives and li

30, 1995!

braries

repository

for folk

une 22, the House of Repre
sentatives voted to take the funds of the
"Y esterday,

J

American Folklife Center
The Issues

in

established as

supported

by public funds. Al

though there was an outpouring of sup
port for the Center and its collections from

the Library of

constituents, supporters of the amendment
merely cited this as evidence that the Cen

Old-Time Music column was

ter can raise public funds. The fact that
most of the public programs of the Center

for tire

at

expression of ideas

forum
and points of view, some of which may be
controversial. Points of view expressed in this
a

repository.

column are not necessarily those of The Old-

Time Herald.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

are already supported by private funds
($330,000 raised in 1995) while the public

funds mainly support reference, acquisi
tions,

and

processing

for its

collections

was also discounted. These same argu
ments could be used to remove federal and

state funding from any

of our public

reposito

ries.

immediate action! Contact your
Senators and tell them why the Folklife

"Take
U.

S.

collections must be sup
ported."
[Urge them to support
reauthorization and funding.]

Center

and

its

Articles about the Center and the amend
ment appeared in The Washington Post, June
23, pg.

F1

and mTheNew York Times,

J

une 24

All.

pg.
For

those of you using the regular mail,
phone, or fax you may: write your Senator:
(Name), c/o U. S. Capitol, Washington, D.
C. 20510; telephone the U. S. Capitol switch
board (202-224-3121), ask to speak to your
Senators' legislative aide, and express your
opinion; each Senator's office has its own
fax number; get these through their offices.
The American Folklife Center (address
below) is requesting copies of any faxed or
written opinions given to Senators or com
mittees. They will keep them to help in
further lobbying efforts. The Archive fax
number is 202-707-2076.
If you are on the internet and need con
gressional phone or fax numbers, or mail
ing addresses, you may find these by using
the Library

of

Gopher server
as

Congress's LC MARVEL
&lt;marvel.loc.gov&gt; (login

at

marvel). Choose /Government/Federal

Government/Legislative Branch Directo
ries.
You may also visit the Center's Gopher
site on LC MARVEL at

&lt;marvel.loc.gov&gt;

(login as marvel); choose /Research and
Reference/Reading Rooms of the Library
of Congress/ American Folklife Center, or
visit the World Wide Web site

at

&lt;httv.//

lcweb.loc.gov/ folklife&gt;.
If you wish to learn more about the
American Folklife Center and its collec
tions, you may write to them at the Library
(continued

on

page 60)

�BENTON FLIPPEN. Old Time,
I

New Times

Rounder 0326
"For the fan of

traditional old-timey music, you'll find nary
on this disc. -Narragansett Times

a

weak track

"

High Atmosphere: Ballads and Banjo Tunes from
Virginia and North Carolina Collected by John Cohen
November of 1965

In

Rounder 0028

Celebrates the particular riches of the Appalachian musical tradition. This
album is essential material for any old-time music library and is reissued
here for

a

new generation of musicians and listeners, with almost

hour of additional recordings from the original sessions.

Mountain Strina Band

The Fuzzv

Rounder

1

1

571

One of the seminal "young fogey" bands of old-time music's revival.
Their rich repertoire of southern Appalachian tunes is reissued here for
the first time.

JODY STECHER AND KATE BRISLIN. Stav

Awhile

Rounder 0334
An

of

album rich

in

traditionally-based

old-time music featuring plenty
beautiful duet singing, all per

mandolin, banjo, fiddle,
formed with emotion and elegance.
guitar and

DON STOVER. Things

In

Life

Rounder 0014
The first solo album by one of the most
ers of

energetic performers and promot
Originally released in 1972,
timeless snapshot of an authentic artist at his best.

bluegrass, old-timey, and country music.

Things

In

Life

is

a

Hazel

&amp;

Alice

Rounder 0027
A classic collection of old-time and bluegrass music by Alice Gerrard and
Hazel Dickens. Their gorgeous country harmonies were a strong influence
on Emmylou Harris, the Judds, and others, as was their heartfelt mixture of

country music and feminism.

Brother Oswald
Rounder 0013
Originally released in 1972 and available for the first time on compact disc, this
Brother Oswald's first solo album featuring the Dobro, the instrument he pop
ularized and his greatest claim to fame.

is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

__

a

half

�Rounder

Is 25!

The Early Days of Rounder:

Vol.

I

by Charles Wolfe

November, 1970, fans of old-time
and

music received their

bluegrass
regular newsletter from County Sales
in Floyd, Virginia. Number 39 it was,
and most of the vinyl LPs listed sold for
$3.75. The big news on the front page was
that, for those fans who had been living in
caves, the Country Music Hall of Fame in
Nashville had voted to induct Bill Monroe

In

well as The Original Carter Family. The
featured album was A. P. Carter's Clinch
Mountain Ballads, a set taken from Acme
masters and radio shows; other titles in
cluded Dan Crary's Bluegrass Guitar, Vassar
Clements' Southern Country Waltzes, and
as

one of Flatt and Scruggs' last albums, Break
ing Out. But among the new albums dis

cussed was one called simply George Pegram.
A new label makes its appearance here,"
Dave Freeman wrote, "with an attractively

produced album by one of the great char
acters of the southern mountains. It's been

many years (close to 15) since Pegram had
a fine LP out on the old Riverside label.
Anyone who's seen Pegram knows he's off
in a world of his own, and I guess the music
should be judged accordingly." Freeman

went on to compliment Pegram's two-fin
ger banjo style and "vocal touches," and to

conclude that "all in all it's an enjoyable
LP." The new label Freeman welcomed
was one coming out of the Boston area and

bearing the unlikely name of Rounder.
It was a
pleasant, if not auspicious, be
for
a label that was to have a major
ginning
on
American music for the next
impact

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

quarter century. Acknowledged by most
today as one of the country's leading inde

pendent labels, Rounder has grown to the
point where it embraces virtually every
style of traditional music and a rich variety
of their popular offshoots. In addition to its
original base in old-time, bluegrass, blues,
now embraces
mainstream country, modern folk, reggae,
Zydeco, protest music, and world music
from African to Hawaiian. Working with a
staff of over 80, the company now releases
over 100 albums a year, and is home to such
figures as Alison Krauss, Ricky Skaggs,
Mike Seeger, Norman Blake, and Hazel
Dickens. This year, feature writers from
Boston to Louisiana have been celebrating
and Cajun, the company

the 25th anniversary of the label, and the
distinguished filmmaker Robert Mugge has

chronicled its music and history in a docu
mentary called True Believers: The Musical

Family of Rounder Records. For readers of the
Old-Time Herald, however, it is worth not
ing that the ultimate roots of Rounder are

found

in

a

devotion

to

old-time and blue-

a fact that the company itself cel
grass
ebrated by recently reissuing on CD that
very first Rounder album by the eccentric

Appalachian banjo player George Pegram.
[See review on page 47]
As most true believers already know,
Rounder has been and continues to be the
brainchild of three people: Ken Irwin,
Marian Leighton Levy, and Bill Nowlin.
Ken and

Bill met

in

the early

when they were assigned

to be

1960s,
freshmen

roommates

at

Tufts University. Ken

had graduated from the suburban
Westchester High School, just north of New
York City, where he was voted "best
dancer" in his yearbook.

Lexington,

Bill

grew up

Massachusetts, where

worked summers as

a

guide dressed up

in

he
in

War clothes.

During the
summer before classes started, they wrote,

Revolutionary

introducing themselves. "When

I first
got
Bill's letter, he asked mainly about poli
tics," recalls Ken. "I wrote back that I was
into the Dodgers and folk music like The

Tokens and The Chad Mitchell Trio." It
turned out that Bill, too, was interested in
the folk revival, and the pair of roommates
began spending a lot of their spare time at
the Club 47 in Cambridge, and at the slightly
raunchier Hillbilly Ranch in Boston. The
summer of their freshman year, they at
tended a 72-hour "hootenanny" to raise
money for a local clinic. "They were giving
away a nice guitar case to the people who
played the longest," Ken recalls. "Peter
Stampfel and Steve Webber, who later be
came The Holy Modal Rounders, came up
and played; they did some speed and stayed
up and played for hours and hours, and
played all the Charlie Poole things. That
was largely our major introduction to oldtime music."
Marian came into the picture in 1967.
Ken, who had been a psychology major,
had taken a job working with disturbed
children at a camp/ school near Portland,

(continued

on next

page)

�L-R: Ken,

Marian, and Bill, Somerville, MA

1971

Now

it

was decided that if they could tape
it would make a perfect first

this concert,

release from a Boston-based company de
voted to folk and bluegrass. "We got per
mission from everybody," recalls Ken. "We
even lined up a two-track Tandberg tape

Everything was set. Then, the
day before the concert, Everett's son (Jiles)
was killed in a motorcycle accident. The
show went on, and we taped it, but it was

Carl

Fleischhauer

recorder.

Maine. One day, while he was sitting at a
coffeehouse reading Paul Oliver's Mean
a
ing of the Blues, he was approached by

young woman who came up and asked

if

he was "talkable." He was, and soon learned

that Marian was

a

native of rural Maine

from Cherryfield, in the easternmost county
in the United States. She had grown up in

poverty-stricken part of the state, a region
where blueberry raking, hunting, and tour
she
guiding were common jobs. In college,
discovered both folk music and radical
politics, and after she transferred to Clark
a

in Wooster, she began to hang
around more and more with Bill and Ken.
During the late 1960s, in the midst of the

University

Vietnam era, and as hootenannies gave
way to bluegrass festivals and major fid

dling contests, the three began to travel to
Bean Blos
places like Union Grove, Galax,

som, Berryville, and Wolf Trap. Here they
heard and met many of the veterans of oldtime music and blues who were making

new generations who
sought to learn and interpret the music. It

comebacks, as well

trip that the idea for starting
record company was born. Ken and a

was on such
a

as

a

friend were hitchhiking back from Galax
one summer and were picked up by Ken
Davidson and his wife. The Davidsons were

then living in Charleston, and Ken had
started his own record label called Kanawha
to document some of the West Virginia
artists with whom he had been working.

particular day, the Davidsons in
vited Ken to stay the night with them, and
the next day took him over to meet two
On that

Kanawha artists, singer Gilly Cox and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddler Clark Kessinger.
pressed

with all of

it.

"I

was im
came back to

Ken

Boston and said to my roommate, 'Hey,
even
a record company
have
he
doesn't
any designers or
though
write
liner notes. Why
can
who
anybody
don't we start a record company'? And Bill

incredibly heavy. It was just too personal to
even consider issuing." (It also marked the
end of the Lilly Brothers' work in Boston;
that same year they returned to West Vir
ginia.)

Later that year, Ken was on his way back
from Mardi Gras when he stopped in to
visit his friend Ken Davidson, who had by

now pretty well abandoned Kanawha and
moved to Florida. "We were talking and
listening to music," Ken remembers. "He

this guy started

played us this George Pegram tape he had;
he had no interest in putting it out, and we
expressed interest. He told us to get hold of
Charlie Faurot, who had recorded it, and

good idea."
reasons was that by then the
the folk music revival, and a
was
off
bloom
small
labels that had chronicled it
lot of the

we did, and we bought it for $125." Faurot,
who had recorded a number of the early
County albums, had recorded the tape origi

said

it

was

a

One of the

were going under. "Records that we were

collecting ourselves became unavailable,"

Bill recalls. "And there was so much music
we liked, but couldn't buy a record of."

Marian adds that "we saw our company as
a successor to and, in some ways, a con
tinuation of the early '60s folk boom." The
name "Rounder" was easy enough to agree
it came in part from the 72-hour hootenanny and the music of the Holy Modal
Rounders. "Plus we were always traveling
around in our VW bus in those early years,"
recalls Ken. "We sort of associated with
rounders, who were sort of hoboes. And

on:

then of course, records are round."
on their
By late 1969 the trio had decided
first project. The Lilly Brothers, Bea and

Everett, West Virginia singers who had
started on southern radio in 1939, had
moved to Boston and become fixtures at
the Hillbilly Ranch. In January, 1970 they
had decided to celebrate their 20th anni

special concert featuring
themselves and the Charles River Valley
Boys. The Rounders had been long-time
fans of the Lilly Brothers, and had tried in
vain to get other labels to record them.

versary with

a

nally for Davidson. Graced with a wrap
around cover, a la the old Folkways LPs,
the Pegram tape became Rounder 0001.
During this same summer, the crew had

visited Union Grove, and watched as a
young band from Massachusetts won first
place. The band was The Spark Gap Won

der Boys, and included David Doubilet, an
underwater photographer for the National

Geographic, who later won national fame
for his work in Hollywood; Neal Rossi, an

student; and George Nelson, a me
chanic. Though reviewers compared the
band to the New Lost City Ramblers, they
had an unusual repertoire that ranged from
"Take A Drink On Me" to "Happy Trails to
You." "We figured that any band that won
first place at Union Grove would be del
MIT

uged with offers to record," Ken says. "We
finally got up the nerve to ask them, and
they said, "Sure." they were Cambridge
based, and we recorded the tracks mostly
at local radio stations." And unlike the
Pegram album, the Spark Gap set came
with a lengthy set of liner notes.
Both LPs were actually released on the
October 20, 1970, and the pair
same day
ing was in

a

way, curiously symbolic of the

�Photo top R: Ken Irwin and Marian Leighton of
Rounder Records sell albums at the Bluegrass
Unlimited festival at Indian Springs, MD in
the summer of 1973.

Photo bottom

R:

George Pegram flourishing

pen, preparing to autograph album just given
him by Bill Nowlin at the Union Grove Fiddlers

Convention, 1971.

Rounder philosophy. One was a carefully
produced field recording of a well respected
traditional musician; the other was a care
fully produced field recording of young
revivalist musicians who were carrying on
this tradition. In later years, other compa
nies would focus on doing one direction or
another, but Rounder would manage to
successfully straddle the fence, and rede
fine old-time music in a refreshingly broad
sense.
They soon found, though, that actually
recording and pressing records was the

easy part. Next came distribution.
big day when County Sales ordered

It
a

was

a

whole

box of Pegrams, and when they got an
order of 25 from Jack's Record Cellar on the

west coast. "But," Bill recalls, "when we
walked into record shops with our first

nobody really wanted to
of albums from us as a

They said, 'Who's your

nies in this same dilemma. So we started off
representing six very small companies."

Through

complicated

a

series of good

Fleischhauer

we said, 'We are.' And

chey said, 'But you only have two records.'
We realized there were other small compa

Carl

couple of albums,
buy those couple
separate vendor.
distributor'? And

breaks, the company soon found itself suc

ceeding as

a

distributor as well

facturer.
Other releases soon followed
One Morning

in

as

a

manu

0003 was

May by Joe Val and the

New England Bluegrass Boys. It too, was
recorded partly in homes, partly in local
radio stations, "joe never really toured be
yond New England," Ken recalls, "but he
kept bluegrass alive there after the Lilly
Brothers left. And it was a better seller than
the first two. It found a niche, and it got a
four or five star rating in Bluegrass Unlim
ited, which was pretty influential." The Val
set was

a

rich

combination

of

bluegrass and

old-time duet singing. And in the summer

of 19 71, the group decided to do a new
collection by the legendary fiddler Clark

on page 60)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Carl

(continued

Fleischhauer

Kessinger. Ken Davidson had already done

four LPs by him, but by now Kanawha was
pretty much defunct. "We came down to

�Workshop

Evolution Versus Creation Of My PA System
Smakula

by Bob

there was the Shure
"Eeww Gross."
Yeah--

and there, the advance in tone quality was

when Pops and I were doing a
of performing we broke
amount
regular

another friend was using
another PA system for concerts and dances.
Dick would come in his sub-compact car

The Beginning

InVocal

Master.

But in 1976

the bank to scrape up the $800 for the Vocal

Master

6

channel mixer with built-in amp,
and two huge

Sure SM-57
and heavy

was the right PA for the time, but
now every time I think about it, I say
"Eewww Gross."
The Shure SM-57 mics were the high

light of the system. They are durable, de
cent sounding mics. I am still using those
particular mics now even though they are
20 years old. I limped along with that sys
for 10 years

knowing

I

should up

grade.
My biggest stroke of luck in PA land was
when a Rock and Roll guy came to work in
my music store. When he made fun of my

vintage PA gear I got the bug to upgrade.
He guided and goaded me to decent equip
ment.
First

I

bought

a

pair

of Electro-Voice

(EV) S3-15 main speaker cabinets. The
model number means that the cabinet has

speakers with the largest being 15". The
speakers in the cabinet are connected to an
electronic gizmo called a crossover. The
crossover sends the right signal to the right
3

speaker. The bass to the 15" speaker, the
mid-range to the mid-size speaker and the

highs to the tweeter. They were big and
heavy but sounded great. This board re
quired a separate power amp. As luck
would have it, an Ashly FET-500 for the
mains and an Ashly FET-200 for the moni
tors showed up in the classified ads.

great power amp for the moni
needed great monitors. A pair of EV

With
tors,

I

it.

At the time

speakers with
AUDIO PRO SP-8 powered

with two EV Entertainer

stands,

an

microphones,
homemade speaker boxes. Section with Illegible
mixer,
Text necessary mics, cables and stands

it

tem

worth

a

FM 12-3s did the trick.

I

have

to

admit, this

system sounded great. Although it was
bulky and required running wires here
PA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and within

1

5

minutes he would have great

sound. I, on the other hand, had to coerce a
band member to drop by and help load the
stuff into the van, unload it at the hall, and
spend 45 minutes connecting different parts
of the PA. What was

When

I

moved

to

I

missing?
that
I realized

Elkins

moving heavy equipment was getting old
knew then it was time to
and so was I.
move on to a compact system long before I
1

hit 55.

traded the EV S3-15 speakers for a
guitar. Then traded the guitar for a pair of
EV S-200s. The EV S-200 cabinets have two
speakers enclosed in a plastic case. The
I

bottom line for me was to not sacrifice tone,

but the weight of each speaker is only 36
a
step
opposed to 105 pounds-direction.
I
worked with a AUDIO PRO SP-12
board. It sounded great and had a great
two-year unlimited warranty.

pounds

as

in the right

I sold
my EV-Tapco board and the Ashly
FET-500 power amp to a thrasher rock 'n'
roll band, I immediately went to my local
AUDIO PRO dealer and bought the latest

version of the SP-12.
My AUDIO PRO 512 has everything I
could possibly want. The built in power
amps are 250 watts each (that's plenty loud).
Each channel has three separate Eqs, two
monitor channels, one built-in effects chan
nel, one outboard effects channel, stereo
and phantom power for mics that draw
current.
The last thing to trade off was

my

80

pounds (each) of EV floor monitors. At the
Augusta [Elkins, WV] concerts we had been
using four Toa SM-75 monitors. Because of

their small size, about 1 3"x6"x7" and weigh
ing about 11 pounds, they do not have the
bass response of the FM 12-3s, but they still
have plenty of kick. I liked them enough
that

I

bought

a

pair.

What about Mics? I still have the six
Shure SM-57s that came with my original
system. Since I often need to use all 12
channels of my board, I bought a few Shure
SM-58s and more SM-57 mics. There are
many other mics out there that would prob
ably be better for specific applications, bet
sound for guitar, or fiddle for example,
but I am fond of the Shures because of their
ter

good sound and durability. Durability is
an important factor as I rent out my PA
from time to time.
Along with the guts of

a

PA system I've

had to buy plenty of other odds and ends to
make the PA work well: speaker and mic
cables for one. I have an assortment of mic

cables from 20 to 30 feet long, and speaker
cables from 30 to 50 feet long. Most of the
mic and speaker cables I see in shops are

manufactured by Conquest or Rapco. Both
are excellent brands.
One word of advice on speaker cables.
Do not buy cables made of thin wire. A
heavier cable will sound better: 14 or 12
gauge works fine for old-time music power
loads.
Mic stands? My original system's stands
were the Atlas brand. They had heavy de
tachable metal bases. After forgetting ei
ther the bases or the stems at home

a

few

bought tripod stands. Boom arms
on the stands help adjust the mic, and I
consider them essential.
Speaker stands are essential items as well.
times,

I

Having the speakers up in the air helps
balance the sound so the back row can hear

�well as the front row. My favorite speaker
stand is made by Ultimate Support. Made

as

a
ridged tubular aluminum, they feel
solid even when your 36-pound speaker is
8 feet in the air. They also score big points
in the save Bob's Back Contest. I own the

of

33-T
of

5

speaker stands that have
9 feet, 2 inches.

a

height range

feet to

My current PA is

a

culmination of years

experience and rubbernecking at every
PA system. I highly recommend talking to
your musician friends about their likes and
dislikes concerning their own equipment,
of

and

I

recommend going

sic store as

to

your local

mu

resource for service and ad

a

vice about equipment.
I am
experienced with the brand names

Shure Brothers

Inc., 222 Hartrey Ave.,
60202; 708-866-2200
Toa Electronics, 601 Gateway Blvd. #300
South San Francisco CA 940080; 415-588-

have mentioned. However,
more are available. By way of competition,
all of the PA manufacturers are constantly

Evanston,

redesigning their products

2538

and models

I

to make them

IL

Ultimate Support Systems,

better, lighter, more efficient, and less costly.
So don't be afraid to try other brands of

Zurich Dr, Fort Collins, CO 80524

equipment.

800-525-5628.

There are a lot of PA details I have left
out. The more you learn the more you need
to learn. Terms like impedence, speaker
load, in and out of phase, graphic EQ, and
Mos-Fet can make you go "Huh?" the first
time you hear them. I've found the Yamaha
Sound Reinforcement Handbook, published
by Hal Leonard, to be most helpful in deci

phering PA-speak and running your PA
efficiently.
On a final note, I talked to the EV folks
recently and found out that the S-200 and
the S-100 (Entertainer) speaker cabinets
have been discontinued. The redesigned
speakers are the SX-200 and the SX-100.
They were described as being more effi
cient, more sound with less power. Hmmmm,
it might be time for my PA to evolve again.
For more information on the products
mentioned in this article or the name of
your local dealer contact the following
manufacturers:

Ashly Audio Inc., 100 Fernwood Ave.,
Rochester, NY 14621; 800-828-6308
Atlas Soundolier, 1859 Intertech D.,
Fenton, MO 63026; 314-349-3110
Audio Pro Sound Inc., 4625 Witmer Rd.,
Niagara Falls, NY 14305; 716-297-2020
Conquest Sound Co., RR 2 Box 1AB PO
Box 268, Monee, IL 60449; 800-323-7671
Electro-Voice, Mark IV Industries, Inc.,
600 Cecil St., Buchanan, MI 49107; 800-6951010
Rapco International, Route

1,

Box 50, Jack

son, MO 633755; 800-325-0266

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

An active old-time musician
Co., WV, Bob

is

and

Inc.,

2506

resident of

the proprietor

Randolph
of
Smakula Fretted Instruments, specializing in
the restoration and sales of vintage stringed

instruments.

�Workshop

Bowing Workshop No.
by Brad

Leftwich

worked our way up through
some pretty complicated bow licks

We've
in

the last few

workshops,

so

I

thought

was time to get back to basics.
Complex licks are nice to know, and they
give you greater depth and flexibility, but
maybe

it

traditional fiddling can be interesting and
exciting without much more than a few
simple bow licks.
"Blackeyed Susie" can be played about

as

simply

as you

want. Here's

a

way of

using nothing but sawstrokes,
and for the sake of variety I've included an
alternate high part that uses shuffle strokes.
playing

9

it

This is not strictly a beginner's version
of the tune; I know experienced, older
fiddlers who play it very much like this.
For those of you who missed the first

bowing workshops,

a

sawstroke

is

the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddle tune (except for waltzes and
jigs), there's normally time to play four
notes between every foot tap. You don't
always play four notes, because some notes
are held longer than others, but you can fit

simplest

of bow licks. You pull your bow
then
down,
push it up, down and up, down
and up, in nice, even strokes, as though you
were pulling a saw back and forth. Each
stroke takes the same amount of time.

to

Notice the order, though: first down,
then up. As you tap your foot (you do tap
your foot, don't you? You should!), you'll
always be pulling your bow arm away
when
a downbow stroke
from the fiddle
of the
is
one
This
the
foot
hits
ground.
your
characteristic features of the classic South
ern "downbow" style of fiddling used by

a

musicians such

as

Melvin Wineand Tommy

Jarrell.

There

are

several

different

kinds of

use two of them in
what I call short and
Susie"
"Blackeyed
When
sawstrokes.
you tap your foot
long

sawstrokes.

We'll

a

maximum of four notes in the tune for
every time your foot hits the ground (not
counting grace notes, triplets, and other
"extra" ornamental notes).

With short sawstrokes, you have four

down-up-down-up
equal bowstrokes
for every foot tap; in other words, a sepa
rate bowstroke for each note.
With long sawstrokes, you have two

forevery tap;
equal bowstrokes-down-up
in other words, it's possible to put two
notes on each bowstroke.
Short and long sawstrokes are illustrated

�in

examples

1

and

2. If

you're not already

familiar with my notation here, it's
of "graph" of the

a

kind

bow strokes. The vertical

lines divide the time up into the groups of
four notes that you can play for each tap of
your foot; the tap comes on the first note of
each group of four (marked by the heavy

vertical lines).

Where the graph slants

downward (reading from left to right), it
represents a downbow stroke. Where the

graph slants upward, it represents an
upbow. I know this is awkward and con
fusing;
I

I

wish you were sitting

in front of

me so

could just show you the bowing in person.
I've shown an alternate way of bowing

the first line of the high part, using the
shuffle stroke (continuing the shuffle any

the strings of your fiddle, and the numbers

farther than that won't work). The shuffle,

represent your fingers

illustrated in example 3, is just a long
bowstroke (two notes' worth) followed by
two short bowstrokes (one note's worth
each). Unlike the sawstrokes, which must
be on downbows when you tap your foot,
the shuffle by nature goes both ways. If you
start the first shuffle on a downbow, the
next shuffle will begin with an upbow.
Except for the first line in "Blackeyed
Susie," long and short sawstrokes will be
mixed together: a pair of long sawstrokes
followed by four short sawstrokes, followed
by four more long sawstrokes (see example 4).
So here's the tune. The spaces represent

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(0

means no finger

an open string). The notes under

a

line are played

ward-sloping

downbow, and the ones under

down
on

a

an

upwardsloping line are played on the upbow. Good
luck.
played with the Plank Road

Brad Leftwich

String
Humdingers, and Leftwich &amp;
is a noted performer and
He
Higginbotham.
teacher of traditional southern fiddle aiul banjo
Band, the

music, and has

video on the Homespun label
entitled Learn To Play Old-Time Fiddle re

viewed

in

a

OTH vol.

quesiionsor suggestions

4 no.
to

8.

You can send

Brad in careoftheOTH.

Now

is the

time

to

buy

a

Holiday Gift Subscription

for

your friends who haven't yet
sampled the pleasures of the
Old-Time Herald or perhaps for
someone who needs some back
issues. We would be happy to
send you a back issue list.
Don't Forget
the rates will go
as
of
October
1, so act now!
up
There is
page

a

5, or

subscription form

on

you can call or fax us

919-416-9433. You may email
to &lt;agerrard@nando.net&gt;
(please refer to OTH, and be
sure and give us your mailing
address). We accept Visa and
Mastercard.
at

Has Your Address Changed??
Notify us as soon as possible or

you will not

receive your magazine!

�June Apple
Key of A

as

(a E A C# E)

played

by Benton

Discography:

Flippen

on

5-string banjo

Rounder0326-Benton

tablature by Paul Brown

Flippen:

Old Time, New Times

a

Flippen's
Here's

fine example

of Benton

two-finger banjo picking.
straightforward enough for beginners
to grab onto, yet it contains enough quirky
syncopations and fingering to make it a
distinctively Flippen product. Notice that
the lead changes from index fingerto thumb
depending on the needs of the melody.
The figure showing 4th-fret fingering on
both first and second strings (4th measure,
Part A) is correct, giving the phrase just the
It's

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

right banjo whine. Also correct

is the figure
index
the
finger striking two
showing
on
in
succession
eighth notes, cross
strings
6th
to
measure in Part B.
the
5th
from
ing
And yes, Benton does strike one string in

succession with the thumb and index fin
ger as shown in Part

B, 3rd

measure.
--Paul

I

time
When

first

became interested

banjo, the playing

Brown
in

old-

of Kyle

Creed really caught my attention. The bare
bones simplicity, galloping coconut shells
tone, and rock steady time summed up
what I hoped to someday sound like.
After meeting Kyle a few times he in
vited me to his house in the spring of 1976.
I
happened by when he was in the midst of
some hot instrument trading with Dix Free
man, another old-time musician. Kyle in
terrupted the trade, handed me a banjo and
told me to play

a

tune.

�Soldier's Joy
Key of D

as played by Kyle Creed on

(aDADE)

tablature

hacked out my idea of "Soldier's Joy" a
Kyle. It must have borne some resem
blance. Later, a mutual friend asked if Kyle
I

la

had called. He said Kyle had told him that
he was going to ask me if I wanted to be a

Camp Creek Boy, claiming that
good time and seemed polite."
The tablature

below

is

I

"kept

transcribed from

the Camp Creek Boys, County 709. The
high A notes on the second part are one of
the hallmarks of Kyle's style: "why slide all
the way up to the fifth fret on the first string

when you got that note right there on the
fifth string? I try not to do any more work
than I have to."

Using the fifth string instead of the first
string fifth fret seemed like a game of dex
terity Kyle played. I've differentiated
melody notes on the fifth string by using an
X

rather than O.

remember, fifth string instead of first
string fifth fret, keep good time, and above
all, be polite.
So

--Tom

Mylet

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

by

Tom

Mylet

5-string

banjo;

X on 5th

source: Camp Creek Boys, County 709

string= melody note; O

on 5th

string= drone note

�Classified
Musical Instruments
INSTRUMENTS FOR SALE; Guitars, 1942 Vega
C-26 archtop, $675: 1954 Gibson J-50, $1,100;
Mandolins; 1939 Gibson A-50, $750; 1925 Regal,
koa back and sides, $250; Banjos; 1939 Gibson
Kalamazoo, $400; 1870's Buckbee fretless with
eagle shoes, $500; Many banjo ukes priced from
$100 to $200. Send SASE for complete instru
ment list. Smakula Fretted Instruments, PO Box
882 Elkins, WV 26241. 304-636-6710.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

MARTIN GUITARS, DOBROS, FLATIRON
MANDOLINS. Find out why we're the world's
largest fretted instruments store. Free discount
catalog. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.

Washington,

14210-DX34,

POB

Lansing,

MI

CLASSIC BANJO tape now available: A Summer
Night, by Black-Tie Banjo. Banjo and piano duets

by Morley, Cammeyer, Grimshaw, others. $7 to

USA,

L5

to

UK,

postage included.

Black-Tie

Banjo, PO Box 47, Arlington, MA 02175.

48901 517-372-7890.

BANJO; Made by David Forbes, serial no. 21, 12"
pot, 25 1 /2" scale, fancy inlays, HSC, $750 firm.
Dave Shombert, 26 Pineview Dr., Elkins, WV

TWO GREAT RECORDINGS! 67 minutes of

26241. 304-636-8083

postpaid. Ray Alden, 124 Quaker Bridge, Cro-

The

Appalachian String Band Festival (Clifftop), The
Volume I. $13-CD, $10-cassette,
Young Fogies
ton, NY 10520.

BANJOS, MANDOLINS, GUITARS, FIDDLES.
Subscribe now to our monthly used and vintage
instrument list with hundreds of quality instru
ments at down-to-earth prices. $12.00/year
($25.00 overseas). Current issue free on request.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N. Washing
ton, POB 14210-DX34, Lansing, MI 48901 517-

372-7890.

STRINGED INSTRUMENT COLLECTION,
send SASE. Really hear recordings! Superb small
HI-FI speakers, $135 pair plus shipping. 48 hour
approval. Ray Alden, 124 Quaker Bridge, Croton, NY 10520

CUSTOM, OPEN-BACK
fretted or fretless w/11"

BANJOS.

COMPACT DISCS, CASSETTES, LPS, VIDEOS!
NEW FREE DISCOUNT CATALOG with over
10,000 titles. Bluegrass, folk, blues, jazz, old time
country, and much more, listed by category of

music and by artist. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS
100 N. Washington, POB 14210-DX34, Lansing,
MI 48901 517-372-7890.
1

FOUR GREAT RECORDINGS! The Young Fogies
Volumes II and I, Appalachian String Band Festival,

(Clifftop), The American Fogies Volumel. $13-CD,
$10-cassette, postpaid. Ray Alden, 124 Quaker
Bridge, Croton, NY 10520.

Available

or 12" rims. Cases for

"PLAY TENOR BANJO" (4-string) immediately.
No music to read. Play
actual melodies, not just backup chords. $7.00 to

11" &amp; 12"

open-back banjos also available. Call
301-595-0373 or send a business SASE: Enoch

Fret number method.

Instruments, 6-C Hillside Rd., Greenbelt, MD

Frank Tabor, 2817 NE 292nd Ave. Camas, WA
98607.

20770.

INSTRUCTIONAL

Recordings, Books, Instruction
delightful collection
Old-Time, Celtic,
and New England styles. Challenging tunes,
TUNES FROM HOME
of

1

00

A

irresistible dance tun

es in

add
Zesty music! Book: $12.95, Tapes: $8.98,
Order
add
6%
tax.
residents
CA
$2.00 shipping;
from Daniel Engle/Tunes From Home, 6984

McKinley #148, Sebastopol, CA 95472.
FIDDLE TUNES: OLD TIME MUSIC POEMS,
ALASKA-STYLE.

Good-looking, good-reading

contemporary poetry chapbook. 40 pages of
poems. 4 pages of gossip. Some titles: "Old-time
Fiddle Lesson," "Village Fiddle," "Cajun Accor
dion Music," "Kentucky Fiddle Music-for Bruce
$8.95 includes p+h. Ken Waldman/
TheNomadic Press, Box22498, Juneau, AK 99802.
Greene."

SLAP BASS, THE UNGENTLE ART (VIDEO).
Mark Rubin and Kevin Smith show you how to
play single, double and triple slaps on Bluegrass, Blues, Swing and many other styles of
popular music. Close up and slowed down ver

sions make

learning

easy.

Ridgerunner, Department OT-1 05,
Drive, Driftwood, Texas 78619.

$33.45

ppd.

84 York Creek

BOOKS, VIDEOS, CAS

SETTES, and much more. Free discount cata
logs. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS, 1 100N. Wash

ington, POB 14210-DX34,
517-372-7890.

Lansing,

MI

48901

FIVE GREAT RECORDINGS! The Young Fogies,
Volumes II and I, Appalachian String Band Festival

(Clifftop), The American Fogies Volumes I and II.
S13-CD, $10-cassette, postpaid. Ray Alden, 124
Quaker Bridge, Croton, NY 10520.

Equipment
ODD SIZED FIBERSKYN BANJO HEADS.
Many sizes from 10" to 12", $18 to $20. Gut
banjo strings, $18. Everest banjo cases, 11"

$85, 12" $100 plus shipping. Smakula Fret
ted Instruments, PO Box 882, Elkins, WV

26241, 304-636-6710.
The

Old-Time Herald will accept classified

ads at

the cost of 35 cents per word, minimum $5.00. Anygrouping of letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the first of the

month,

2

months prior

to

publication.

�Vestapol
Doc Watson
This collection

Videos

Rare Performances 1963-1981

illustrates the power and range of Doc's talents and the evolution of his
performance style. His music ranges from flatpicking guitar instrumentals, a harmonica solo, a cappella gospel singing, frailing
banjo to fingerstyle guitar and warm vocals. The tapestry of sounds Doc wove during his first two decades performing outside North
Carolina
the Big Picture
unfolds in these enduringly and inspiring performances.
Tunes include: Deep River Blues, Nine Pound Hammer, Daniel Prayed, St. James Hospital, Shady Grove, Black Mountain
Wish
Rag, Stack O' Lee Blues, Tom Dooley, Southbound, Way Downtown, Lonesome Road, Medley: Nancy Roland/Salt Creek,
Was A Mole In The Ground, Sweet Georgia Brown, Peach Pickin' Time Down In Georgia, Will The Circle Be Unbroken, Raincrow
Bill, Tennessee Stud, Medleu: Biq Sandy/Bill Cheatham, A Rovinq On A Winters Niqht and Black Mountain Raq.
Vestapol 13023 $24.95
seen video performances

of rarely

I

I

Rare Performances 1982-1993

Doc Watson

video's opening performance, Doc Watson had already been performing for urban audiences for more
than 20 years. Doc's accompanists as well as his songs here are an eclectic group ranging from his 1950s musical partner,
pianist Jack Williams, to his son Merle (seen playing exquisite slide guitar), to Ricky Skaggs (singing and playing mandolin in
a Monroe Brothers style set) to a stellar stringband featuring
Mark O'Connor, Tony Rice, Bela Fleck, David Grisman and Jerry I
Douglas. This collection ends with a solo set from Doc which brings his music full circle.
Tunes include: New River Train, Shady Grove, Going To Chicago, Blue Yodel No. 12, Sleep Baby Sleep, You Must Come In
At The Door, Dear Old Sunny South By The Sea, Amazing Grace, Foggy Mountain Top, What Is A Home Without Love, Nine I
Pound Hammer, Riding On That Midnight Train, Fire Ball Mail, Shake Rattle &amp; Roll, Make Me Pallet, In The Jailhouse Now, I
Vestapol 13024 $24.95
Going To Chicago and Life Gets Tee-jus, Don't It
By the time of this

1

Doc

&amp;

Merle Watson

In

Concert

joined by his son Merle on guitar and banjo and T. Michael Coleman on bass in this concert
recorded in 1980. Their performance is a showcase of native folk traditions and a display of distinctive
stylistic inventions. Doc and Merle Watson's repertoire encompasses country ballads, bluegrass,
gospel, jazz standards, contemporary songs and blues. A visit with Doc and Merle at home in Deep Gap,
North Carolina and in concert in Rock Hill, South Carolina is also included.
Tunes include: Way Downtown, Sadie, Frosty Morn, Medley: Big Sandy/Old Joe Clark, Don 't
Think Twice, It's Alright, Summertime, Smoke, Smoke, Sweet Georgia Brown, Pallet On Your Floor,
Streamline Cannonball, Wild Bill Jones, Natural Born Gamblin Man, Got The Blues Can't Be Satisfied,
Vestapol 13030 $24.95
You, 'Rangement Blues and Medley: Yankee Doodle/Dixie.
Doc

is

Merle Travis

'

I

Miss The Mississippi And

Rare Performances/1946-1981

Merle Travis could write you a hit song and sing it; he could draw you a cartoon; he could play
you a great guitar solo; or he could fix your watch... I'd probably be looking at the rear end of a mule if it
weren't for Merle Travis... If you can say there is a certain style to my way of playing, then you have to
CHET ATKINS
recognize it as the influence of the guitar pickin' of Merle Travis."
This video captures 35 years of rare film and television performances by one of the all-time great American musicians. The
music and guitar playing of Merle Travis has been a seminal influence on the American music scene. There is not a fingerstyle
guitarist whose playing has not been touched by Merle's style and technique. A 36 page booklet is included with this video that
presents an interview and biographical essay as well as many rare photographs of Merle Travis.
Tunes include: No Vacancy (1946), Nine Pound Hammer (1951), Mus'rat (1951), I'm A Natural Born Gamblin' Man (1951), Too
Much Sugar For A Dime (1951), Spoonin' Moon (1951), Lost John (1951), Dark As A Dungeon (1951), Petticoat Fever (1951), Sweet
"

Temptation (1951), John Henry (1951), I'll See You In My Dreams (1960
Midnight Special (1968), Cannonball Rag (1970), I Am
I'll See You In My Dreams (1981
Pilgrim (1971), Sixteen Tons (1977), Smoke, Smoke That Cigarette (1977), Barbecue Rag (1981

A

Vestapol 13012

Legends Of Old

$24.95

ime Music
featuring Clarence Ashley. Roscoe Holcomb, Doc Watson, Sam McGee,
Tommy Jarrell, Pete Steele, Jean Ritchie, Clint Howard, Fred Price and others.
l

Tunes include: Roscoe Holcomb Across The Rocky Mountain
Clarence Ashley Free Little Bird, The Cuckoo Sam
McGee Wheels, Mississippi Sawyer
Doc Watson, Clint Howard &amp; Fred Price Way Downtown, Daniel Prayed, Lee Highway
Blues
Pete Steele Pay Day At Coal Creek, Coal Creek March, Galilee Sommers, Young &amp; Holcomb Red Apple Rag Tommy
Jarrell John Henry, Drunken Hiccups Roscoe Holcomb Little Birdie, Graveyard Blues, Little Grey Mule Sommers, Young &amp;
Holcomb Bile Them Cabbage Down
Corbett Grigsby Pretty Polly Jean Ritchie The Cuckoo Tommy Jarrell John Brown's
Dream The Walker Family Bowling Green, Hangman, Rollie True Love, I'll Be Somewhere Listening
Roscoe Holcomb ohn
Jean &amp; Edna Ritchie My Pretty Little Miss, The Four Marys
Sommers, Young &amp; Holcomb Grey Eagle
Hardy
Vestapol 13026 $24.95

Also Available:

Legends Of Traditional Fingerstyle Guitar (Vestapol 13004) $24.95
Legends Of Country Blues Guitar (Vestapol 13003) $24.95
Legends Of Country Blues Guitar Volume 2 (Vestapol 13016) $24.95
Elizabeth Gotten (Vestapol 13019) $24.95

Make checks payable

P. O.

Special: Any THREE Vestapol videos for $64.95 (postage/handling

included).

Stefan Grossman's Guitar Workshop. Visa/Mastercard Orders Accepted.
Write for our FREE 64 page catalog.
USA/CANADA Postage/Handling: $5.00 for first video and $1 .00 for each additional video.

to

STEFAN GROSSMAN'S GUITAR WORKSHOP
Box 8()2, Sparta, NJ 07871
Tel: 2Q1/729 5544 Fax: 201/726 0508

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�County

BOOKS
VIDEOS
CDs
READY FOR SHIPMENT

TAPES

Sales

ALL

IN

STOCK

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDINGS
IBMA
Association

NEW RELEASES

MEMBER

International
Bhjegrass Music

1
1

CD

Road Great- 1930's Bluebirds- 16tracks
974 set now on CD -33 tracks -E. C. Ball, Wade Ward, etc
HIGH ATMOSPHERE
DARBY &amp; TARLTON Complete Recordings 3-CD boxed set with booklet
DELMORE BROTHERS Brown's Ferry Blues 8 tracks 1930's Bluebirds Excellent
KIRK SUTPHIN Old Roots &amp; New Branches Excellent old-time fiddle and banjo
DOC WATSON FAMILY From recordings made in the early 1960's- nice old-time
BROTHERS OSWALD 1972 release now on CD -with Charlie Collins. Norman Blake, etc.
CHESTNUT GROVE QUARTET The Legendary... Reissue lovely unaccompanied singing
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Alabama fiddlers of the 9th &amp; 20th centuries now on CD
ROOTS AND BRANCHES Various artists collection with Robin Kessinger, Alan Freeman, etc.

UNCLEDAVE MACON Traveling Down

CCS-115
ROU-0028

The

1

BCD- 15764

CCS-116

1

CO-2711

SH-3829
ROU-0013
CO-2709
AT-103

1

JMP-0021

$13.00
$13.00
$70.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00

CS
$8.00
$8.00
N/A

$8.00
$8.00
$8.00
N/A

$8.00
N/A
N/A

BESTSELLERS
BONNIE RUSSELL Mountain Dulcimer Galax Style Great 1970's instrumental
&amp; NANCY BLAKE While Passing Along This Way Fine set of old-time tunes

CO-2710
SHAN-6012
BOS-4523
BEE-301
HER-110
MT-103
MT-104
CC-0125

NORMAN

LEROY TROY Son Of The South Fine old-time banjo playing and singing
WILL KEYS BARBARA KUHNS DOUG SMITH Sweet Marie Old-time banjo, etc
GOLD HILL BAND Going Down This Road Old-time music from southwest Virginia
930
YEARLINGS IN THE CANEBRAKE Texas fiddle tune from 924
WHERE THE SOUTHERN CROSSES THE DOG Mississippi Fiddle Music 1928 -1935
BLUE SKY BOYS Farm &amp;Fun Time Favorites Vol 1 Great 1949 radio -many rare songs

N/A
N/A

1

00-2

MOLEHILL HIGHLANDERS

ROU-0313
CO-3503
ROU-0326

Volume One

1

970 recordings of Charlotte, NC OT band

MIKE SEEGER Third Annual Farwell Reunion with Ralph Stanley, Bob Dylan, etc
DARBY &amp; TARLTON On The Banks Of A Lonely River Reissue of their classic 920's sides
BENTON FLIPPEN Old Time, New Tunes Old-time music from the Mt. Airy, NC area
BLUE SKY BOYS Farm &amp; Fun Time Favorites Vol 2 More radio with Leslie Keith
NEW LOST CITY RAMBLERS Old-Time Music Live from Newport 1963-1965
WALT KO KEN Banjonique Clawhammer banjo tunes, both old and new
RURAL STRING BANDS OF VIRGINIA Excellent reissue of 920's 30's material
DOC WATSON CLARENCE ASHLEY Original Folkways Recordings 2-CD set 960-62
CLIFF PERRY LAUREL BLISS Old Pal Carter Family songs with guitar and dobro
JOHN MORGAN SALYER Home Recordings 1941 1942 Kentucky old-time fiddle/banjo
MASTERS OF THE BANJO Featuring R.Stanley, Will Keys, Kirk Sutphin, etc
ROUGH RIDERS Lively old-time North Carolina band
KIRK SUTPHIN Fiddlin' Around Nice old-time string band from Mt. Airy. NC area
BOBFLESHER Old-time Clawhammer Banjo Good tunes, great playing
BANJO MELTDOWN Two hour video of the 1992 Tennesse Banjo Institute
TOMMY JARRELL-FRED COCKERHAM Best Banjo &amp; Fiddle Duets 21 songs -nice
CARTER FAMILY Clinch Mountain Treasures Great 20-song set of 940's cuts
WHITE COUNTRY BLUES 2-CD set with Poole, F.Hutchison, Darby /Tarlton, etc
CLYDE DAVENPORT Puncheon Camps Excellent old-time fiddle and ban jo
FRANKLIN GEORGE Traditional Music For Banjo, Fiddle &lt;4 Bagpipes Great!
WILL KEYS Evergreen Fine old-time two-finger banjoist from Tennessee
TIMES AIN'T LIKE THEY USED TO BE Super 70 minute video w/JimmieRodgers, etc
1

CC-0 126

VAN-77001
ROU-0337
CO-3502

1

SF-40029/30
TM-0707
AC-003
ARH-421

CLOUD-6310
FC-023
FLESH-401
VIDEO
CO-2702
CCS-1

$13.00
$13.00
N/A
N/A
N/A

12

1

1

CBS-47466
AC-002
CO-2703
CLOUD-006
YAZr512

$13.00
N/A

$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$20.00
$13.00
N/A

$13.00
N/A

$8.00

$8.00
$8.00
$8.00
$8.00

$8.00
$8.00
$8.00
$8.00
$8.00
N/A

$8.00
$8.00
$8.00
$8.00
N/A

$12.50
$8.00
$8.00
N/A

$8.00

N/A
N/A

$8.00
$8.00

video

$25.00
$8.00
$10.00

$13.00
$13.00
$20.00

N/A

N/A

$8.00
$8.00
$8.00

video

$20.00

N/A

$13.00

USA ORDERS: Please add $3.00 for first 1 to 3 items, add $4.00 for 4 or more items
&amp; HANDLING:
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Minimum shipping charge is $4.00. CD's and cassettes are

POSTAGE

$1.50 each and LPs

are

$2.00 each.

MINIMUM FOREIGN

order

is 2

items.

CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U. S. Dollars only.
DEPT. H BOX 191
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES
FLOYD, VA 24091

703-745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Minimum credit card order

is

$15.00

(Fax)

703-745-2008

�Reviews

in the CD format, with 6 addi
tional and previously unissued selections, with

been reissued

George
Pegram

extensively researched and entertaining notes
by Bob Carlin. I don't think that Pegram 's music
is for everyone, but if you are a true fan of real,

Rounder 0001

traditional old-time music, you should enjoy his

(CD reissue

1970-71
release of
of

sometimes raucous approach. His three-finger

LP

picking (thumb lead) is inspirational and very
representational of his home area. His singing

1969 session)

and phrasing are strong and entertaining.
George Pegram-banjo, vocals; Clyde Isaacs-mando
lin; Fred Cockerham-fiddle; Jack Bryant-guitar.

Mississippi

Sawyer/Workin'

on

Building/

a

Little Old Log Cabin in the Lane/John Henry/
Where Could I Go But to the Lord?-Wildwood

Flower/Never

Grow

Old/Reuben/What

A

Friend We Have in Jesus/Mountain Sally Ann/
Old Time Religion/Johnson's Old Grey Mule/
In the Sweet Bye and
Bye/Cumberland Gap/
Are You Washed in the
the
try

Blood?/Bury

Me 'Neath

Waltz/Old Coun
Church/Just Because/Will the Circle Be

Willow/Over

the Waves

Unbroken.
George Pegram was born in 1911 in Guilford
Co., N. C. and died in 1974, but not before he
regaled thousands with his finger-picked oldtime banjo, his singing and his entertaining tal
ents. While George never was a full-time profes
sional musician, he spent much time in the lime
at shows, competing at fiddlers
conventions, and the like. He became a

light, performing

favorite

of Bascom Lamar Lunsford, appearing
many of the music and dance festivals that
Lunsford promoted throughout North Carolina.
George also lived for a time near Galax, Va. and
at

won many prizes for his playing, singing, and
antics at the Galax and Union Grove Fiddlers

Conventions. His music so intrigued and as
tounded the young Rounder Records collective
(Ken Irwin, Marion Leighton, and Bill Nowlin)
that they decided in 1970 to issue a tape they
Ken Davidson (of Kanawha
very first Rounder LP. don't
know how big a seller it has been, but it was
pretty popular in my neck of the woods. In
celebration of Rounder's 25th anniversary, it has

acquired

from

Records)

as the

Please send all items for review--

I

PLUS

an

extra

copy,j-card, or insert of recordings only to: OTH, PO
Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717. If we do not have the
extra cover we cannot publish a photo with the re
view. Addresses of often-reviewed labels are listed at
the back of the review section. Otherwise theordering
information is given at the end of the review.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

believe that this

I

like

example or cross-section
of Pegram's repertoire, with traditional songs,
tin pan alley numbers, and breakdowns, mel
lowed out by sacred numbers. Having Fred
Cockerham fiddle on a few cuts is an added
to

is an

bonus, although I have heard Fred in much
better form. The extra beats and vestigial pas
sages

in

the opening

"Missississippippi Saw

yer" should drive those weaned on contra dance
tunes stark raving mad. I just love it. What a way
to kick off a label! I like to imagine that Rounder

was planning

since

it

on

deserves

reissuing this gem anyway,
own merits. But

it on its

happy birthday, Rounder, and thanks, George,
for the great music, wherever you are.
KERRY BLECH

�repertoire of perfect tunes. Of course,

it is his

one
playing that makes the tunes perfect, each

between melody and arpeggiated

balanced

chord-patter, each one a silvery shape of music.
On this new tape, his playing is accompanied
by

fiddle and guitar. Having enjoyed the solo

al

playing on Evergreen, was not sure
in the
ready perfect thing should be cluttered up
wasn'tsure
trio.
of
a
busier context
string-band
whether a style as distinct and beautiful as Keys's
if this

I

I

band without distracting from it,
and was worried that I'd be irritated when other
instruments covered up his banjo work. It turns

could

be in

a

out that this trio works extremely well. Kuhns
and Smith are accomplished players who know

how

blend. Kuhns, on the fiddle, provides

to

mostly single-string melodies (her tone is very
double stops might be too lush) that match
rich
the banjo lines. Smith's guitar offers a solid
rhythm, with clean minimal bass runs and light
treble strums.
The overall sound of this tape is sweet. Even
tunes that are usually tough, such as "Florida
Blues" and "East Tennessee Blues," are not tough
but toughness and drive are
or hard-driving

not the point here. The point is to enjoy pretty
melodies and rich tones. Yes, there are blue
in "Florida Blues," and some wonderful
tense intervals in the banjo part, but I wouldn't
call it grit. I'd call it peppy and cheerful. Fortu

notes

some tunes
nately, the band avoids drippiness
are already sweet enough, such as "Tombigbee
Waltz" and "Sail Away Ladies" (the J. P. Fraley
version). The band realizes that you don't have
to do

anything but play them

as they are.

The style of fiddling that Kuhn represents has
not generally had much appeal to me: it's linear

rather than densely textured, and it has a slight
classical tone there's even some vibrato here
and there-- but in this setting, I wouldn't want
anything else. What's wanted is something

smooth and uncluttered.
musical strands, when one

Three uncluttered

of them is Will

Keys's
crystalline and deceptively simple banjo play
ing, add up

to

quite

a

lot.

The singing, mostly by Doug Smith, is good:

he's got

a

strong in-time voice. Again though,

the song is not the point. On "I'm Getting Ready
To Go," for exam pie, the poin t seems to be for the
to make their individual
ways
around the lively tune, for thebanjo to define the
to
shape of the tune, for the fiddle and banjo

instruments

gether
verses

to
to

the sung
get snaky on the fills, and for
of an
middle
in
the
a
space
open out

otherwise very complicated area.
The selections are from a variety of sources,
the Carter Family and Arthur Smith among oth
ers. get the impression that each band member
I

contributed

a

few favorites. Whether

or

not that

was the actual intent, the tape certainly has the
"old favorite" sound, in that the tunes have
found their natural polish, their sure shapes. I
ve gained some new favorites here: "The
Dead March," "Maggie and Me," and the title

know

T

cut, "Sweet Marie."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

If you've seen Will Keys, you might have
remarked on the way any session he's in seems
to last for hours, andhe never seems to wear out.
You might have noticed that he's always got

another tune. You might find yourself wonder
his playing so
ing how he could be so tireless,
are on this
the
answers
It's
infinite.
possible
be
never
deliberate,
play the best
hurry,
tape:
tunes the best wav that you can.
MOLLY TENENBAUM

To order: Bee Balm Music,

Rd., Med way, OH 45341.

2582Medway Carlisle

�Down East Fiddling
Gerry Robichaud

Voyager 310 (cassette
reissue of 1973 LP; 31
minutes)

Gerry Robichaud-fiddle; Chuck LeBlanc-piano

Art

Richard-bass.

Slope

Road

Jig/Golden

Wedding

Reel/Mother's

Day Waltz/Sandra's Jig/Ottawa Valley Reel/
Uncle Louie's Clog/Don Tremaine's Jig/Grand

Valley Waltz/Rocket Richard's Reel/Prince
County Jig/Centennial Waltz/Dickie Rogers/
Peace River Jig/Daffodil

Waltz/David's Jig/

Twin Sisters.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Steve Green recorded Walter in 1992 and, al
though Walter has played for most of his fid
in bands and prefers backup, Green
requested that Walter play unaccompanied. With
hindsight, that was an excellent choice, as

dling career

McNew'stimingis remarkable and

we

are

treated

bowing and tonal nuances that might
otherwise be overpowered with even the most
subtle and sensitive accompaniment. This is a
fine mixture of hymns, Doc Roberts'-style play
to all the

ing, and Walter's earlier family repertoire. He
speaks about nearly every piece and offers some
of his

philosophy

the commentary,

in

perfectly sets the mood and
niscent

of the

is

which

somewhat remi

Tommy Jarrell album,

Sail Away

Ladies. Both 'Tine Top" and "Blackjack Grove"

are

a

seems

bit unusual
to

and quite rare. "Lost Girl"
have been better known as repertoire

from farther east in Magoffin County where a
number of fiddlers have been collected playing
it,

but Walter's version

is

unique

in that it is in

the key of C rather than in the more common

setting

of G. Walter is

a

superb waltz fiddler and

this facet of his talent is well represented here,
but it would appear from the sheer volume of

Doc Roberts pieces on this tape that Doc was his
favorite player. Walter certainly does him proud.
This is a lovingly assembled, excellent release of
a fine, if little known,
Kentucky fiddler. His
as
should
more people become
reputation
grow
aware of Walter McNew through this tape.
KERRY BLECH

Walter McNew-solo fiddle and commentary.

To order:

Appalachian Center, CPO Box 2336,

Berea KY 40404.

Land of

Beulah/Introduction/Blackjack

Pine Top/Rickett's Hornpipe/Cluck
Lost Girl/The
Cat Came Back/Georgiana

Eared

/Flop

Mule/Old

Hen

Grove/

Old Hen/

Moon

Cackle/

I've
Waynesburg/Mamie Potts' Schottische/All
Got's Done Gone/Martha Campbell/Goodnight

Waltz/Brickyard Joe/Calahan/Billy In
Left Behind/Closing
Lowground/The Girl

the

I

Comments.

McNew was born in 1912 in Wildie,
Kentucky, about 50 miles south of Lexington,
and curren tly resides in Mount Vernon, which is
very close to Renfro Valley in Rockcastle County.
Walter

Walter grew up listening to his father, John, play
the old-time fiddle and also listening to another
area fiddler, Uncle Garret Bow, from whom his

dad learned the tunes "Blackjack Grove" and
"Pine Top." Other fiddlers influenced Walter's

playing in his formative years, including Doc
Roberts and Van Kid well, who were from neigh
boring Madison County, and Clayton McMichen,
the former Skillet Licker, whose 1930s band, The

Georgia Wildcats, regularly played on the radio
excellent
Green's
Louisville. To quote Steve
card notes, "Although he inherited a core reper
tory of old-time fiddle tunes from his father-in

tunes that for the most part feature rhythmic
wingand double-stopped notes, Walter tends

bo
to

favor

teristic

a

of

single-string approach more charac
the style of Fiddlin'

Doc Roberts."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�verse by Elizabeth Cotten; "Flame in My Heart/'
by George Jones, on which we get to hear Gerrard
sing tenor to John Worthington's lead. Also
"Life's Other Side Coining Down," "There Ain't

No Ash Will Burn," and "When I Grow Too Old
To Dream." "life's Other Side" matches tough
singing with tough truths; "There Ain't No Ash"

I've heard lots of covers of, but this one is defi
nitely the best. "When Grow Too Old" is sweet
and lovely, so can see why Gerrard had to write
a second verse to make the
song last a little
I

I

longer.
All the members of the band assembled for
this album deserve praise, but Kay Justice and
Kate Brislin deserveparticularappreciation. They
do more than add harmony: if s out of the blend
they make with Gerrard that the mood of each

song arises.
I'm glad that Gerrard managed to tear away
from this magazine and her other projects long
enough to record Pieces of My Heart. From tradi

tional to contemporary, from the old-time end to
the folksinger end, the world of country music

needs

to be

reminded that

it can go

anywhere
supported by a
sensibility with talent, knowledge, and a sense
of where the music has come from: a sensibility
and do anything, as long as it is

like Alice Gerrard's.
MOLLY TENENBAUM

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�harmony, or on the tape's one solo piece, the
Woody Guthrie version of "Buffalo Skinners."
Young seems to be less decisive about what
direction

with her singing. Though pos
voice
and obvious control over
sessing strong
it, she tends to sing much of the time in a style
to take

a

heavily influenced by Nashville country-west
ern recordings. This may be fine on modern
country pieces like Merle Haggard and Bonnie
Owens 'Today Started Lo ving Y ou Again," but
it is less appropriate on the traditional "In the
Pines" or even "Long Black Veil," a commercial
I

country composition, but one that has been
adopted by the old-time/folk community be
cause of its old-fashioned feel. After all,
Harrington and Young say in their liner notes
that "they embrace the simple older style of two
in harmony." The duo is its best on older

voices

gospel material and especially nice is their sing
ing of the lovely title song "My Long Journey"
"
and
Drifting Too Far From the Shore."
The sole

accompaniment throughout

Harrington's guitar. He's

a

is Dick

more than adequate

player, but he sounds a bit stiff, as if the studio
experience caused him to play with more care
than passion. On three cuts they have overdubbed extra harmony parts. don't knowif this
is an attempt at variety or if it betrays some lack
of confidence in their own two voices carrying
I

the songs. In any case, it seems unnecessary to
me; good duets are complete in themselves. I

also find the balance too heavy toward the har
mony singing on several selections.
I'd like to hear these two live and expect I'd
enjoy it a lot. I'm sure the tape is a pleasant
reminder of a performance for audience mem
bers who take it home. Still,

I

feel that Dick and

in the four years
been
singing together. The promise is
they've
there and I look for more satisfying releases in

Victoria's sound hasn't jelled

the future.
BOB BOVEE

To order:

Hilltop Productions, 1335 Hilltop Rd.,

Charlottesville VA 22903

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�And again,

I

grumble, as so often lately, about

the lack of notes. We are given only song names,

personnel and composer/source credits. Three
songs are just listed as "traditional" with no
sources included. I'd like to know more about
the original songs, too, such as whether Peter or
what they do a continuation of

Janet consider

old-time music or a type of contemporary music
with old-time instrumentation
BOB BOVEE

To order:

Encounter Records, PO Box 8132, Phila

delphia PA 19101.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�have been, but when he crooned, his audience
If your livelihood is on the line, you
offer something that people will buy.
After all, he had a wife and two children to

loved him.
have

to

support.

The liner notes are correct when they say that
Pete "always managed to wring every ounce of
emotion possible from any song he chose to

sing/'They are wrong, however, in identifying
it
the Blue Network as the forerunner of NBC
renamed itself ABC sometime around the end of
World War

II.

Lyle Lofgren

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�with

a

traditional jig for the melody, could have

come from Francis Child's collection
say that as

a

cluded

a

as

and

I

do

compliment. The last one I've in
"contemporary" composition is

Get Home I'm Gonna Be Satisfied," a
stirrine gospel number from the great F. C. Rail

"When

I

The notes are meager and could have been
more accurately researched. Although most of
us would casually call "Mississippi Moon" a

Jimmie Rodgers piece, the words were actually
written by Elsie McWilliams with Jimmie add
ing the music. And the songs credited

to Charlie
Poole include "The Girl Left in Sunny Tennes
see," written by Harry Braisted and Stanley
Carter in 1899, "Liza Jane" ("Goodbye Sweet
I

Liza Jane") by Andrew Sterling and Harry Von
Tilzer, "Charlie Poole's Ramble" ("He Rambled"
or "Didn't He Ramble") with a 1902
copyright
by Will Handy but based on an older song, and
"Sweet Sunny South" which goes back at least to
the 1860s.
suppose I'm nitpicking. Most of us
learned these numbers from Poole's 78s and
consider him a pure source, but, like most of us,
Charlie borrowed good songs wherever he found
them and perhaps credit is due.
My favorite cuts are the spirited "Glendy
I

Burke,"

the parlorish

"Hale's Rage," and the

aforementioned "Brothers From York." Debbie
previously recorded several Robert Service
poems that she has provided with musical set
tings and "Ballad of Soulful Sam" from Rhymes
has

of
a

a

Red Cross Man

continues this practice

and

delightful story it is.
There is a gentle approach

here, and

a

to old-time music
sparseness that sometimes leaves

you wishing for a full string band to back the
songs. Still, Debbie's playing is always solid and
carries the songs. Maybe hard-core old-time lis
teners won'tfind this recording to their taste, but
a fine
outing from a one-of-a-kind performer.

it's

Bob Bovee

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�appearing

withKateMacKenzie and Gar

on TV

rison Keillor

the Hopeful

Gospel Quartet,
Robin &amp; Linda Williams and their Fine Group
have tackled their first gospel CD and produced
their strongest release to date. They have al
ready been making inroads on bluegrass radio
as

with 'Tan American Boogie" from their Live

in

different ways Robin &amp; Linda Williams, with
Robin taking the heaviest vocal load, make each
song their own. Few titles could be considered
familiar. Some will recall "Sinner Man" or the

Carter

Family's

"Little

David

Moses."

McLaughlin's fiddle riffs somehow lend a vague
Nashville Bluegrass Band groove to a magiste

Holland CD. A gospel

rial reworking of "I've Just Seen the Rock of
Ages." They turn that and "Good News" into
memorable, meticulously crafted pocket sym

material.

phonies. The rest of the disc contains two Robin
&amp; Linda originals and covers from sources as far
ranging as Townes Van ZandtandBobNolan. It
all works together because of Robin &amp; Linda

disc far expands their
horizons, since those who must define and cat
egorize prove much more lenient with sacred
This excellent disc of thoughtful arrangements,

tasteful accompaniment, and strong vocals on a
diverse set of songs will drive those topologists
crazy. Influenced primarily by bluegrass gospel
vocal stylings and older mainstream country
(i.e. Roy Acuff) instrumentation, and featuring
mostly strong, but lesser known material from
both African and European- American traditions,
Good News sparkles with a number of songs that
achieve a paradoxically contemporary acoustic

country groove thanks to Kevin Maul's classy
Dobro and Peter Madcat Ruth's harmonica.
That's

a

roundabout way

to

say that Robin &amp;

Williams

&amp; Their Fine

Group's well developed

and hard-earned sense of style, and their ability
to shape pieces of traditions into their own per
sonal method. Although Linda does frail the
banjo a bit here and there, and most of the songs

a

lovely statement

of their fully

individual style based upon

new. "Two Hands," their arrangement of a pub
lic domain song, employs both African-Ameri-

triumphant outing

a

clapping and Bill and Charlie era Mon
roe-style mandolin. Indeed most of Good News
comes from group arrangements of a variety of

American musical traditions.

The joy of the project

is to

appreciate

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the

a

blend
Good

for the veteran

of

mature
North

News is

a

husband and

wife and their fine group.

can hand

compositions by "Trad."

of Good

brother duets or bluegrass gospel. The CD pro

vides

Sugar Hill release, exploring
the rich demilitarized zone between old and

Linda's latest is

music

are traditional, the string-band

News hardly resembles the Galax, Mt. Airy, or
Highwoods sounds, nor is it much closer to

ART MENIUS

To order: Sugar Hill Records;

Durham, NC 27717-5300).

P.O. Box 55300;

�Texas fiddling. John's banjo adds an unusual
texture as a Texas backup instrument, usually

eschewing the stereotypical Texas sock-moving

chord backup. To me, sometimes it works, some
times it doesn't, but it never overpowers Shorty's

fiddling. Ah, the fiddling, you ask. It is Texas all
the way, in the classic sense. It seems like the
release sequencing may have actually been the
recording order, as Shorty begins rather tenta
tively, playing it very straight, clean, full.
"Liverpool Hornpipe" even sounds like he is

sight-reading from Cole's 1000. Then he gets

to

Eck's "Pretty Polly Anna," tuned in AEAC# and
he gets down to business. His rendition of

Benny's warhorse (written by his father, Luke
Thomasson) "Midnight on the Water" is one of
the best

renditions I've ever heard. Oh, and it's

non-standard

tuning too (DDAD). The rest

of

them cook. Some more far out in West Texas
than others. By that

I

mean creating variations

that stray far away from the essential melody
line while retaining the chordal structure of the

tune. That's not

a

technique

or trend

I

particu

prefer more subtle variations.
Fortunately, Shorty does not depart to Never
Never Land very often. I think those who appre
larly enjoy, as

I

ciate Texas fiddling already will really enjoy this
CD. Those who love good fiddling in general
may want to sample one of Texas' finest. If you

unfamiliar with Texas style and prefer other
old-time fiddlistics, you may want to call your
local radio station to play a cut or two and maybe
are

to give this one a
listen.
I'm
a
died-in-the-wool
southeast
longer
ern style fan (I love Earl Johnson and George C.
Nicholson, for instance), but this one grew on

you just might be persuaded

me.
KERRY BLECH

To

order: Small

Dog-a-Barkin',
Madison TN 37116

PO

Box 443,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�directed by Walt Lowe, written by Edward
Cohen
Yazoo VHS Stereo and Hi-Fi

more elusive than those of his European
dants. The performance is less of an icon

descen

and more of an intimate reaction

specific

cadences
Good Mornin' Blues, an

hour-long documentary
by Mississippi Educational
produced
TV, traces the migration of country blues from
1978

in

the

Mississippi Delta

the clubs

of the turn of the cen tury to

and dance halls of modern

cities.

Though its subject is big, the film has the look
and feel of oral history with a no-frills produc
tion style that bypasses the sentimentality of
slicker treatments of the subject. The heart of the
film is its rare footage of late performances by
blues greats such as Sam Chatmon, Nathan

Beaureguard, Son House, Willie Brown, Hous
ton Stackhouse, Bukka White, Furry Lewis, Big
Joe Williams, Ma Rainey II, Bessie Smith, Mem
phis Minnie, along with lesser known (but enduringly important) artists like Hayes McMullen,
Hacksaw Hurney, and Gus Cannon. Some of
these artists were photographed only months
before their deaths, giving us the sense that the
film was made "just in time." We are thus fortu
nate to have

a

visual record of the individuals

whose visionary impulses became the bedrock
of modern popular culture. The film's perfor
mances are punctuated by still photos from The
Library of Congress, from university archives in
Mississippi, New Orleans, and Chicago, as well
as private collections in Memphis. These photo
graphs avoid the haunting mystique of the Delta
landscape, focusing instead on body language

and close-ups of faces that render more effec
tively the psychological dimensions of the blues

experience. Most importantly, the film's story is
in
told from the point of view of an "insider"
this case, B. B. King, a native of the Delta and one
who has lived much of the history he is talking
"Wherever the blues went," says King,
"this is where they came from."

of the

situation

at

to the

in

itself

hand. Another case

point is Furry Lewis' performance of
"Brownsville Blues" probably the best of this
artist ever committed to film. The producers
in

take their time with Lewis, allowing him the
line gets a

longest set. His single-string melody
chance to soar past the ballad-like
familiar to students of acid rock and
blues, coming around full-circle to

wailing so
English art
the didley
instrument

bow, that single stringed African
that found its way to the Delta in the form of
piano wire nailed to the side of a house. Lewis'
music is packed with these memories and with
poetic affinities that convert the English lan
guage into something new. As a teenager grow
ing up in Memphis, often heard it said that you
could memorize all of the techniques of these
I

musicians, but you would never be able to get
their "timing." Consider Lewis' and Williams'
performances as compelling evidence of this.
Good Mornin' Blues also shows how, when the
center of the music moved
1930s, its existential

to Chicago in the
ambience dissolved into

group performing. Johnny Shines, Honeyboy
Edwards, and Walter Horton offer a version of
"Love of Mike" that serves as a bridge between
the country blues and the big-time sounds of
Muddy Waters, John Lee Hooker, and B.B. King.
With the exception of Ma Rainey II and an
un credited singer in the tradition of Bessie Smith,
few blues women were still living at the time the
film was made in 1978. Nevertheless, if there is
problem with the film it is in its scarcity of
women performers. Where is Little Laura Dukes
who was still singing nightly at Blues Alley in
Memphis when the film was made? What about
a

about.

Evelyn Young, the enigmatic saxophone player
who also lived in Memphis at that time? The film

King takes us back to the beginning with the
field holler
"the solitary song of one man alone

implies that women fared better in groups than
on their own, mediating greatpiano translations
of guitar work (and vice versa). Perhaps these
lapses occur because the film's primary focus is

in the

fields from sun up

to

sun down"

and on

the work

songs of plantation-style prisons
such as the infamous Parchman Farm, Butit was
the Delta jukes and honkey tonks that nurtured
the independence of the blues masters and took
to

the sound down river to

New Orleans

to

fertilize

jazz, and up Highway 61 to Memphis, a stepping
stone to St. Louis and Chicago where the music
went electric after World War II. King keeps

reminding us that for every famous bluesman
and woman whom we know, there were literally

hundreds who remained obscure.
But the film is primarily about the structures

and nuances of the music itself. When we hear
Big Joe Williams

string guitar

in a

playing his custom-made nineCrawford, Mississippi juke, we

country blues, whereas most women perform
ers worked in cities.
Regardless of these and a few other question
able

ing of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Mississippi Fred
of the

Mornin' Blues

brilliant

is that

instruments for playing blues. The short seg
ment on Gus Cannon, for example, hints at the
latent possibilities of the banjo. Listening to the
sound of modal tunings and bottle neck "slide"
guitar work establishes affinities with a host of
African instruments, such as the kora, now ar
riving

improvisations are

is

lingering effect

they
performances
point to new possibilities for expanding the
range of the form, including discovering new

later become rock 'n' roll. But what is interesting
here is not what was later adapted by Eric Clapton
or the Rolling Stones, but what the rock 'n'
rollers left out. Bearing down on "1 Believe My

Done Lied,"Wlliams'

a

in Good

recognize the phrases and chords that would

Baby

omissions (where

MacDowell?),

America via Afro-Pop and the record
blues-influenced African artists such as

in

Ghana's Ali Farka

T oure.

As Americans become

more acquainted with these instruments and
artists, perhaps today's revival of the blues poin ts
to the future as well as the past. All of which

makes this

an excellent time to go out and get a
copy of Good Mornin' Blues and discover what it
has to say in the light of these recent develop
ments. The film may be 14 years old but, as you
will see, the music is up to the minute.
JUDITH

McWILLIE

�what is important in traditional art and culture:
love of life, beauty, and creativity.
You may not learn a whole lot about how to

a

hold

a

bow

or

play

a

particular tune through

these films.

But you will be able to visit with
people who are now gone, in their own environ

ments, essentially on their terms, and experience
a time that is recent yet
palpably different from
the present. Definitely worth the price of admis
sion.
PAUL BROWN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Gambier Folklore Society, Kenyon College
Gambier, OH 43002
WV University Press (Sound Archives 001),
C. Wise, Jr. Library, PO Box 6069,
Morgantown, WV 26506-6069

Charles

Brothers, 3428 Brookwood
Charles, MO 63301-4108

Buckhannon
Circle,

Additional Addresses for 25 Essential

Recordings:
John Hermann, 107 Ingle
NC
Rd., Asheville,
28804; 704-258-8840

Yodel-Ay-Hee,

Creek Delta Boys, c/o Garry
Harrison, Box 473, Oakland, IL 61943
Indian

Missouri State Old Time Fiddlers Associa
tion, PO Box 7423, Columbia, MO 65205
Tannehill State Park (Alabama Traditions
103-CD), 12632 Confederate Parkway,
McCalla, AL 35111
The Appalachian
Berea, KY 40404

Center,

Berea College,

Library of Congress, Recorded Sound Di
vision, Washington, DC 20540
Bruce Greene, Rt.
28714

Box 34, Burnsville, NC

5

Grey Eagle Records, Extension Publica
tions, 115 S Fifth St., Columbia, MO 65211
#M138)
(ask for item

Mississippi Dept.

of

Archives

&amp;

History

AH-002; No address given on LP jacket.
Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box 290, Galax, VA
24333; 703-236-9249.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

St.

�you can hear authentic old time Appalachian

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

DOUG

JACK

AND

FAMILY
SONGS AND STORIES FROM
THE NORTH CAROLINA MOUNTAINS

Doug Wallin is "...simply the finest living singer of unaccompanied
British ballads in southern Appalachia. ."
-National Endowment

for the Arts

The
19 ballads and stories performed with fiddle, banjo, and guitar accompaniment.
brothers from Madison County, North Carolina recorded these tracks in 1992-1993.
Package includes artist biographies, song notes, lyrics, complete bibliography, discography, and stunning photos.

Produced in collaboration with The North Carolina Arts Council, Folklife Section.
Available on compact disc and cassette, catalogue no. sf 40013

Smithsonian
Folkways

catalogue

request

line:

202.287.3262

mail

order information:

30 1.443.23

14

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Z6
23

VS
#1

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12027">
                <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 5, Number 1 (Fall 1995)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12028">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12029">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 5, Number 1 (August-October 1995).&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Featured articles:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“25 Essential Old-Time Recordings,” by Chrips Smith&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Through the Flippen Filter: The Life, Times, &amp;amp; Tunes Of Benton Flippen,” by Paul Brown&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘Pockets of Eccentricity: An Interview With Terry Zwigoff,” by Marshall Wyatt&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Rounder’s 25th,” by Charles Wolfe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” includes obituaries for Carroll Best; Robert Franklin “Frank” Hicks; and Grover Cleveland Salyer.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12030">
                <text>1995</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="999">
        <name>1990s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="3015">
        <name>1995</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5421">
        <name>American Folklife Center</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5422">
        <name>Benton Flippen</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5418">
        <name>Carroll Best</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5417">
        <name>Charles Wolfe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5414">
        <name>Chrips Smith</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5420">
        <name>Grover Cleveland Salyer</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5416">
        <name>Marshall Wyatt</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5413">
        <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1801">
        <name>Ora Watson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5415">
        <name>Paul Brown</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5419">
        <name>Robert Franklin “Frank” Hicks</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2380">
        <name>Rounder Records</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5423">
        <name>Terry Zwigoff</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2495" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3417">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/9d3bda1f93063fdc627a2b0ca5a79918.pdf</src>
        <authentication>a60eddd7653433e8ff1b4f922917b473</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12033">
                    <text>HERALD

5253
Box
PO

Bethlehem

Moss
D
Mark

22

999

PA

Sing

18015-0253

Out!

A

THE OLD-TIME

A

MAGAZINE

HUME

IN

DEDICATED
6, NUMBER

THIS ISSUE

BOOTH

SPRING

TIME

1998

FESTIVAL GUIDE '98

REVIEWS

MUSIC

$6.00

MITES FROM THE JUDGES

MEMO HIES OF RON HUGHEY

EXPERIENCE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

3

OLD

TO

DANCE BEAT

OUR DOWN UNDER
&amp;

MORE

�Section with Illegible Text

Legends Of

Doc Watson

Old Time
Music

1963-1981

This collection

video

FEATURING

Jarrell,

Roscoe Holcomd,

Doc Watson, Clint
Howard, Fred Price,

Pete Steele
Titles

&amp;

include:

j
I

others
ROSCOE

f

HOLCOMB Across The Rocky
CLARENCE ASH
Mountain
LEY Free Little Bird, The Cuckoo
SAM MCGEE Wheels, Missis
DOC WATSON, CLINT HOWARD &amp; FRED
sippi Sawyer
PRICE Way Downtown Daniel Prayed, Lee Highway Blues
PETE STEELE Pay Day At Coal Creek, Coal Creek March,
Galilee SOMMERS, YOUNG &amp; HOLCOMB Red Apple Rag
TOMMY JARRELL John Henry, Drunken Hiccups ROSCOE
HOLCOMB Little Birdie, Graveyard Blues, Little Grey Mule
SOMMERS, YOUNG &amp; HOLCOMB Bile Them Cabbage Down
JEAN RITCHIE The
CORBETT GRIGSBY Pretty Polly
Cuckoo TOMMY JARRELL John Brown's Dream THE
WALKER FAMILY Bowling Green, Hangman, Rollie True Love,
I'll Be Somewhere Listening
ROSCOE HOLCOMB ohn Hardy
J

j
j

JEAN
Marys

&amp;

EDNA

of

performances

POL

13026

1982-1993

The Door, Dear Old
Sunny South By The Sea, Amaz
ing Grace, Foggy Mountain Top,
What Is A Home Without Love,

Nine Pound Hammer, Riding On
That Midnight Train, Fire Ball
Mail, Shake Rattle &amp; Roll, Make

These two videos capture 35
of rare film and television

years

Me Pallet,

the all-

Mike Seeger
Fret

Fiddle

n'

Old-time music is the
foundation on which hillbilly,
bluegrass and country western
music has been built. Mike
Seeger is a recognized master
of this style and in this video he
introduces us to the instruments
and themes of old-time music.
I
Titles include: Cripple
Creek, Old Mother Hippletoe,
i Oh Susanna, Waterbound, Josh
I Thomas' Roustabout, Deerwalk,
Freight Train, You Are My
Flower, Tennessee Dog, Head
Over

Heels

In

Love,

Molly Hare, Cotton Mill Blues, Wind and Rain,
and Lost Gander. Vestapol 13008 $24.95

Quill Dittv.

Fishing Blues

some

musicians
aside and filmed historic footage
of

the old time

of

making music

them

in

an in-

I

j
j
I

formal

atmostphere.
include:
Titles
CLARK
KESSINGER
Sally Anne
Johnson, Poca River Blues,
Wednesday Night Waltz, Billy In
The

Leather

Lowgrounds,

KILBY SNOW Shady Grove, Please
Advantage Of Me, Wildwood Flower, Close By
JIMMY DRIFTWOOD
Old Joe Clark, Galloping Horse

Chicken Heel

Take

In

The Straw

COON CREEK GIRLS

Rag, Peach
Pickin' Time Down In Georgia
TONY RICE ALL STAR JAM
Nine Pound Hammer, Cold On
The Shoulder,
Whitewater
NORMAN BLAKE &amp; THE RIS
ING FAWN STRING ENSEMBLE Jimmy Brown The News
DAN CRARY Country Boy Rock N'
boy, Salty, Molly Bloom
Roll, Medley: The Fishing Creek Blues/ The Blackbird/Turkey
In The Straw/ Bonaparte's Retreat/Arkansas
Traveller
DOC
WATSON &amp; JACK LAWRENCE Bye Bye Blues, Tennessee
Stud TONY RICE &amp; RICKY SKAGGS Where The Soul Of Man
Never Dies, More Pretty Girls Then One
NORMAN BLAKE
&amp; THE RISING FAWN STRING ENSEMBLE Nashville Blues,
Medley: The Cuckoo's Nest/Over The Waterfall/Opera Reel/
Cherokee Shuffle TONY RICE ALL STAR Jam Freeborn Man
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON Medley.Sheeps In The Meadow/
Stoney Fork, Medley: Bill Cheatham/Salt Creek DAN CRARY
Lady's Fancy, Black Mountain Rag.
Vestapol 13005
$24.95

Black Mountain

a

Norman &amp;
Nancy Blake
Rare Performances

1980-1995

Titles include: OHIO, 1980
Medley: Randall Collins &amp; Done

Gone, Medley: Green Leaf
Fancy Da Slockit Light, Briar
Picker Brown &amp; Stoney Fork
1984 Gray Coat Sol

ALABAMA,

diers
Polka #1
Waltz

Medley:
&amp;

Knockbauer

#2 &amp; The El Paso

Medley: Wilhin A Mile,

The Durham

Rangers,

Far From

Home, Primrose Last SOUTH
988 Jordan Am A
CAROLINA,
Hard Road To Travel
Pretties Little Girl In The County The
Little Stream Of Whiskey
Battle
IOWA, 1995 Hangin'Dog
ship Of Maine Medley: The Kitchen Girl &amp; Cattle In The Cane
Democratic Donkey Is In His Stall Again The Georgia Rail
road Vestapol 13059 $24.95
1

I

third one FREE (plus postage/handling)

valid until April 15th, 1998
USA/CANADA Postage/Handling: $5.00 for first video and $1 .00 for each additional video.
Make checks payable to Stefan Grossman's Guitar Workshop.
Visa/Mastercard Orders Accepted.
Write for our FREE
This

P. O.

is

catalogue.

STEFAN GROSSMAN'S GUITAR WORKSHOP, INC.
BOX 802, Sparta, NJ 07871
TEL: 973/729 5544 FAX: 973/726 0568

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

East

Johnson Boys
ISON J. FONTENOT La Valse De
Dimanche Apres Midi AL &amp; VIRGINIA MANES Romeo's Last
GROUP Red River Valley
Chance, Red Fox Waltz
FIDDLER'S CONTEST Katie Hill, McMongan's Reel, Cack
Anne
Johnson
Vestapol 13051 $24.95
ling Hen, Sally
Virginia,

DOC
Titles
include:
WATSON &amp; JACK LAWRENCE

offer

the 1966 Newport Festifolklorist Alan Lomax took

GROUP Turkey

&amp;

Special: Buy two Vestapol videos and take

I

At

val,

Don't

featuring Doc

Norman Blake
Dan Crary

I

Old Time Music
from the Newport
Folk Festival, 1966

Britches,

Watson, Tony Rice,

Am A Pilgrim,

'

Jailhouse Now,

Flatpicking
Guitar

(1977) Sixteen Tons, Smoke,
Smoke That Cigarette, (1981) Barbecue Rag I'll See You In
Vestapol 13012 $24.95
My Dreams
I

The

Legends Of

(1970)Cannonball

night Special,

In

Going To Chicago &amp; Life Gets
Tee-jus. Vestapol 13024 $24.95

time great American musicians.
Titles include: (1946) No Va

1

Billy In The
Lowground

Titles include: New River
Train, Shady Grove, Going To
Chicago, Blue Yodel No. 12,
Sleep Baby Sleep, You Must
In At

I

Bonaparte's Retreat, Cumberland Gap, The Boll Weavil, Old
Jimmie Sutton, Forked Deer, Sail Away Ladies. Cripple Creek,
ROSCOE
Breaking Up Christmas &amp; John Brown's Dream
HOLCOMB, 1972 Black-Eyed Susie, Pretty Polly 8 Old
Vestapol
13071
$24.95
Smokey

Rare Performances

Come

cancy, (1951) Nine Pound Ham
mer, Mus'rat, I'm A Natural Born
Gamblin' Man, Too Much Sugar
For A Dime, Spoonin' Moon,
Lost John, Dark As A Dungeon,
Petticoat Fever, Sweet Tempta
960 I'll See
tion, John Henry,
You In My Dreams, (1968) Mid

1970 Troubles, Cindy, Shady
Grove, Raggedy Ann, Two-Tim
ing Blues 3 You Are My Flower
DOCK BOGGS, 1966 Country
Blues., Pretty Polly &amp;
Hope
TOMMY JARRELL,
1976
Live
I

Doc Watson

1946-1981

Rag, (1971)

sive and individualistic makers of
old time country music.
Titles include: KILB Y SNOW,

I

Rare Performances

of

presents poignant
exciting musical perfor
mances by four highly expres

Wish
Was A Mole In
Creek,
The Ground, Sweet Georgia Brown, Peach Pickin'Time Down
In Georgia, Will The Circle Be Unbroken, Raincrow Bill, Ten
nessee Stud, Medley: Big Sandy/Bill Cheatham, A Roving On
A Winters Night and Black Mountain Rag.
Vestapol 13023 $24.95

Merle Travis

one

This video

Dooley, Southbound, Way
Downtown, Lonesome Road,
Medley: Nancy Roland/Salt

$24.95

and

and

Tom

I

Jarrell

Roscoe Holcomb

formance style.
Titles include: Deep River
Blues, Nine Pound Hammer,
Daniel Prayed, St. James Hos
pital, Shady Grove, Black Moun
tain Rag, Stack O' Lee Blues,

RITCHIE My Pretty Little Miss, The Four
YOUNG &amp; HOLCOMB Grey Eagle

Vesta

by

Tommy

seen
illustrates

rarely

SOMMERS,

performances

featuring Kilby
Snow, Dock Boggs,

the power and range of Doc's tal
ents and the evolution of his per

Clarence Ashley,
Tommy

Shady Grove

Rare Performances

http://www.guitarvideos.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FEATURES

NOTES FROM THE JUDGES BOOTH

By

1

1

5

Molly Tenenbaum

OLD-TIME MUSIC: OUR DOWN UNDER EXPERIENCE

By

I

24

Greg Shupe

RON HUGHEY-SOME

MEMORIES/

26

By Hank Bradley

FESTIVAL GUIDE 1998!/

28

COLUMNS

OLD-TIME MUSIC ON THE RADIO

I

6

By John Lupton

HERE

&amp;

THERE

I

7

By John Currie
THE DANCE BEAT

12

Mountain Legacy: A Celebration

of

Southern Appalachian Dance

&amp;

Music.

By Phil Jamison

WORKSHOP

Two tunes from Ron Hughey. Transcriptions by Hank Bradley
"Stony Point." Transcription by Carl Baron (page 38)

DEPARTMENTS

LETTERS

2

CLASSIFIED

39

REVIEWS

41

(page 37)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Letters

Compare Phillips' richly notated work

Review Response

lam glad that you have published

a

review

Czech CD, the Honza Bican's Pisnicky
Zmrzleho Drevorubce [vol. 5 no. 8]. One of
on

a

your readers from Chicago contacted me
and asked for a promotional copy.
put
him in touch with the author.
I

Irena Pribylova
Czech Republic

review oiGuitar Playing Hawaiian Style,
1 was well received here
George
Winston (mentioned in the review) got a
[The

vol

6 no

copy before

I

did (probably based on the

fact that surface mail to

extra weeks) and sent

players

in

Hawaii takes

a

few

the key slack key

it to

Hawaii.
Dr. Richard W. Brislin

Honolulu, Hawaii

Shame

on

you

for

printing

Tenenbaum's "review" of

Molly

The Phillips Col-

lectionof Traditional American Fiddle Tunes

Volume Two. Your reviewer apparently (1)
doesn't read music, (2) can't find an old-

time fiddler who does read music, (3) hasn't
written mu
got a clue what musicians use
sic for, and (4) is predisposed to find fault

with Stacy Phillips' monumental effort.
Couldn't you find a reviewer who is both
musically literate and enjoys old-time fid
dling? These are the people (there are thou
sands of us) for whom this collection has
value. No, it doesn't teach you how to
fiddle, and no, it doesn't teach you about
the fiddlers themselves, but if you've ever
tried to figure out the bowing to Doc Rob
erts' "AllIGot'sDoneGone," for example,

and then happen across Phillips tran
scription, you can't help but appreciate
the enormous effort that produced it.

Old-Time Herald welcomes letters. They

The

be typed or neatly written and signed
return address given If you send them
email, be sure and include your return

should
with
by

a

address.

We

DO NOT print anonymous let

ters. Letters may
them according

be
to

edited, and we will print
space available. The opin

ions expressed do not necessarily reflect those
of the

Old-Time Herald.

the bare-bones transcriptions you
printed in the very same issue of the OTH:
basic to the extreme, with no bowing marks
The Narmour and Smith "Charleston No.
2" you printed, simply can't stand up next
to Phillips' notation of "Carroll County
Blues" by the same artists. What a pity you

with

didn't get Phillips to transcribe this rare
gem! Then we would have a reliable guide,
not only to the bare notes, but to bowing,
accents, articulation, fingerings, chords, and
other details that Phillips supplies to help
us make music out of mere "henscratches
and flyspecks."

Furthermore, basing her review upon
sight-reading by a bluegrass fiddler makes
as much sense as reviewing French poetry
by having it read aloud by a non-native
speaker. If her "excellent sight-reader"
stumbled over the time signature changes
in Jim Bowles' "Christmas Eve," could that
be because she'd never heard the original?
Rather than dissing this beautiful collec
I
suggest you use it as a standard by
which to judge the quality of transcriptions
you choose to print in your magazine in the
future. If you can't (or won't?) find a musi
cally literate fiddler to help you make com
petent editorial judgments, at least you
could avoid embarrassing yourselves and
omit such misbegotten "reviews" from fu
ture issues.

tion,

John

J.

O'Loughlin

Oxon Hill, MD

With eyes open

I

enter the dangerous wa

reviewing the review of my book The
Phillips Collection of Traditional American

ters of

Volume Two

Fiddle Tunes

OTH fall 1997).

have my own ideas on the
course,
reservations the reviewer expresses, and I
would like to address a couple of points.
The purpose of the book is questioned in
the review. In the Introduction I statethat,

Of

I

"My hope is that each reader will interpret
the tunes according to his/her individual

muse." So

it is

not my intent to prescribe

a

particular style of playing to any tune. (I
realize that some people might find that
attitude near blasphemous.) As for whom

�thebook was written

hopefully it is meant
people like me who have learned to
read music and love the repertoire of many
styles of fiddling.
Iam misquoted for stating that "the book
(is meant) to serve as a snapshot of what
fiddlers.
are playing
." The phrase
"and listening to" was omitted in the re
view. I believe that moots the criticism that
follows the misquote.
for

Finally, for OTH to assign a book of
fiddle tunes to a reviewer for whom "a
book of written old-time tunes is an impos
sibility" seems

a

bit unfair.

Stacy Phillips
New Haven

CT

enjoyed [Molly Tenenbaum's] reviews in
6 no. 2] issue, and felt
they
brought some nice additional perspective.
I

the current [vol.

Bill Nowlin

Cambridge, MA
Kerry Blech comes down pretty hard on
the reissue of the original Kanawha-label
Hollow Rock StringBand album [vol. 6 no. 2],
which was first published in 1967 or so. As

arguably the single most important album
of old-time instrumental music to come out
of the 1960s, it is no doubt tempting to
search for a set of Emperor's Clothes when

reviewing the project
true: things

30

years later. It's

sometimes seem changed when
(continued

on

next page)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�viewed from theperspectiveof the future
look at reruns of the Mod Squad sometime.
And agree that, like most LPs, the Hollow

pitch voice or note, the tune which dies in
mid-course because the tune has vanished

Rock album makes

not acquired at all by many. As a trained
violinist, Alan was able to decipher Henry

I

short CD. There was
once another, second, master of these four
musicians
Alan Jabbour, Bobbie Thomp
son, Tommy Thompson, and Bertram Levy.
Where it is now
have no idea, and it is
a

I

certainly possible that it no longer exists,
but had it been found and included, the
new CD version of the original album
would certainly have been enhanced.
Maybe the search should continue?
Even as

a

short CD, however, the Hollow

Rock oeuvre remains

outstanding

as

a

col

anyone who doesn't al
ready have a copy, and who appreciates
old-time fiddle playing and repertoire,
should own one. Many of these tunes are so
deep now in the on-going oral tradition
lection of tunes

might be time to go back and check
on how the dang things "originally" went.
I've heard some pretty strange versions of
"Over the Waterfall" down through the
that

it

example. "Money Musk," on the
other hand, remains one of the best of the
years, for

great showpiece

A

tunes, along with

"George Booker" and "Last of Callahan,"
and it's great in both standard and crosstuning a terrific learning experience for

any fiddler dabbling in these healing wa
ters. As one who has played every tune on
this album, I can say with certainty that

they are all first rate, and well-worth learn
ing. Further, Alan Jabbour's style of fid
dling dramatic, energetic, clean, with just

enough embellishment to enhance the cru
is a fine vehicle through which
cial notes
to learn these tunes. This, I am sure, is in
part why Alan crafted his fiddling style in
this way. More than many players, Alan

Jabbour has, throughout his career, been
concerned with the propagation and dis
semination of the old tunes. He has seen his
task to be

a

teaching one (and has surely

been most successful).
the end, Kerry's oddest criticism seems
to be the complaint that Alan made this
In

as
record at all rather than producing
Alan and others later did with the
a field
Hammons family
recording of

Henry Reed. Well, I don't doubt that, to
some, a CD of the Jabbour Henry Reed
tapes would be of great interest. Maybe
that, too, will someday appear. I've heard
the tapes, however, and I can at least testify
that, by the time Alan met Henry Reed,

Reed was far past his prime as a musician.
field recordings which
Tapes of this kind

capture the palsied arm, the quavering off-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

from the mind, are an acquired taste, and

Reed, to bring his tunes back to life. In the
case of "Money Musk" (and possibly other
Reed tunes), Alan put together various
parts played in different sessions into a
coherent, exciting whole. Yet Alan's inter
was always in the tunes, the Henry
Reed tunes. He always said exactly what
he was doing in this project
recreating
the tunes of Henry Reed Like the rest of us,
Kerry included, who never got to hear

none of those little things which in
one sense "make" Irish fiddling. Howthen,
can this be a collection of Irish tunes? Miles
Krassen's effort to Colemanize O'Neill not

book

withstanding, the question

is

there are the trees.
N. Hicks

Section with Illegible Text

Siler City, NC

est

Henry Reed in his prime, Alan was unable
to recreate the style of Henry Reed with
real precision. He never made such a mis-

euided effort.
A

lot has

happened

world of old-time music. Many of the great
est old-time players of the century have
passed on. Many of us have had the good

fortune

to hear

some of them in recordings

from the field work of the '30s and '40s, and

others have been close enough in time for
us to have actually seen and heard them

playliveand
person. Somerecent "young
have
gone to extraordinary
fogie" players
of style exem
to
subtleties
recreate
lengths
of
the
some
greatest of these
plified by
collected players. As only one example,
Bruce Molsky has worked out how to cap
in

ture something in the bowing of players
like Luther Strong which, before he did it,
to all

was,
complete mystery
expect,
who listened to those Lomax-collected field
recordings (some of which were brought to
light in the Library of Congress album of
American fiddling edited in the 1970s by
I

Kerry Blech, in his winter 1997/98 review
of the Alan Lomax Collection Sampler

(Rounder 1 700) raises a couple of questions
that make me wish to comment. He says
that he hopes "all is on the up-and-up with
its

saleability" because he received

marked as
since 1967 in the

a

as I'm certain Bruce
Alan Jabbour). But
Luther Strong's tunes are
would agree

entirely worth learning and appreciating
apart from coming to a complete compre
hension of the most subtle nuances of his
style. Kerry, in his review, sort of misses
this distinction, as well as the brute fact that

there are no extant recordings of Henry

Reed comparable

to

those

Luther

of

that even though Alan saw Henry
Strong
what he saw, the shaky
to
recreate
play,
old man, was to miss the
of
an
old,
playing

point of what he was hearing.
Consider the example of the

O'Neill
Collection. Here we find this vast number
of tunes. Chief O'Neill "collected" them,
from himself and from other Irish players
who resided and passed through Chicago
ou'll find

around the turn of the century.

Y

almost no embellishment

the

in

whole

silly, isn't it?

Like Kerry's review of the Hollow Rock
CD, I think the most important point has
been missed. There is the forest, and then

a

a

It's

promotional copy.

copy

stan

dard procedure to mark promotional cop
ies, and marking them infers nothing about
the legality or availability of the recordings
in question. This sampler is widely avail

able, and we have made

it

available

at a

very inexpensive price (despite the 72-page
booklet) so that people will find it easy to

sample this fine Collection.

It is

troubling

that our attempt to make a sampler avail
able inexpensively seems to have called

into question in some fashion its bona fides.
Kerry also questions whether or not we
will be making available more of the oldtime music which Alan Lomax recorded,
but instead of contacting either Rounder or
the Lomax office to ask, he comes to the
in print that it "seems once again

conclusion

that our little niche in the music world

is

actual fact,

being overlooked, ignored."
the editors plan many reissues of AngloAmerican material, including all of the
various items he mentioned. In addition,
there will almost certainly be further vol
umes which will include ballad singers
In

and others from
as Pearl W.

of South

outside Appalachia, such

Nye of Ohio, Blaine Stubblefield
Dakota

the ballad

and

singers

New England.
The Lomax folks are well aware of the
rich old-time music recorded by Alan and
others associated with him, and would by
no means deliberately ignore the reissue of
which Alan recorded

in

this portion of the large body of recordings.

There are many excellent performances
here, and they will be released.
It

is

probably worth noting, addition

ally, that the Collection will present mate
rial from Alan's entire career. Though Kerry
says that he believes that "everything in
this mammoth collection

will be from the

late '50s forward, recorded in stereo" he

is

�again, unfortunately, incorrect. Once more,
he could have found out the answer simply
by inquiring. Most of the music will in fact
be from prior to the late 1950s, and it will be

presented

in

stereo or mono, as appropri

ate. Most of the tracks on the

sampler are

in

mono. A great deal of work has been done
to get the best possible sound, and only
recently the 20-bit mastering equipment
was taken to Washington for a lengthy
span of work with the original recordings
the Library of Congress.

at

Undertaking to release over 100 albums
body of works is

of music from this grand

daunting task, and we do hope for sym
pathetic support from lovers of folk music

a

everywhere.

Bill Nowlin

Cambridge, MA
I

thought that Molly Tenenbaum's review
Hubie King and Diane Jones's recent CD

of

"There Are No Rules," was unnecessarily
unfriendly, so I would like to offer my

response.
Molly seemed
organization and

looking for more
theme, but I thought

to be
a

Are No Rules clearly
such
things are needed. I
explains that no
of your favorite
some
think it is fine to put
reason than the
no
more
tunes on record for
is old-time
This
fact that you like them.
for for
noted
music, isn't it? Not exactly

that the title

There

mality and organization.
know Ms Tenenbaum, and I'm
I don't
not familiar with her musical background,
but I suspect that she is not much aware of
West Virginia banjo music, or may not be
en
very interested in it. She is certainly

I
thought her putdown of Diane's singing was unnecessar
of us old time
ily harsh. There aren't many
think that we
musicians after all, and
should try to be more supportive of one

titled to her opinion, but

I

another.
to being prejudiced, Hubie and
I admit
Diane are friends, they are two of my favor
have always par
ite banjo players, and
I

I

appreciate the nice recent review of Close

To Home:

Old-T imeMusicFrom Mike Seeger's

Collection, 1952-1967,

Smithsonian

Folk

ways 40097. I'd like to clarify a few points.
1) The review reads: "This CD repre

ticularly enjoyed Diane's singing. It seems
to me that her voice suits the music well.

sents samples from a number of artists that
had their own LPs recorded and produced

one of my
a year
about
release
its
since
CDs
favorite
CD
in
remain
will
it
my
player.
ago, and

or
by Seeger and published by Folkways
"
Rounder
Actually, this is the first time

There Are No Rules

has been

Clarke Prouty

I've released recordings by 16 of the 30-odd
artists on the CD. For many of those 16, this

Lanharn, MD

is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

their only released recording.

2)

Only one of the pieces on the CD was

previously released.
3)

Snuffy Jenkins really does play "Go

track
ing To Lay Down My Old Guitar" on
is
on
of
version
24. His
"John Henry"

Smithsonian

Folkways 40037.

It

never

occurred to me, but the two pieces do have
some similarities.
What think didn't mention in the notes
was that this CD was an integral part of a
project about 10 years ago to copy all of my
I

I

(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

field

recordings 1952-1967 for preserva

tion purposes. Listening to those 300 hours
of field recordings gave me a good oppor
tunity to select music for release. This is the
first of those collections to be published
and is dedicated to old-time music,
rily music recorded

in

prima

homes.
Mike Seeger
Lexington, VA

[The reviewers stnnci behind their reviews and
the OTH stands behind the reviewers.]

�Here &amp; There
Currie

by John

Events
The recent appearance

of Cape Breton

Natalie MacMaster in Morehead
a success that there are
tentative plans for more such concerts in
the next year. The show was co-sponsored
fiddler

Cannon, founder /director of the Western
Folklife Center in Elko, NV. Hal has also
produced radio and TV documentaries on

downtown Philadelphia hosts

old

time

music every Wednesday night from 9 to 12.
The restaurant/ pub is located at 2013 Wal
nut St. in Center City. Admission is free.

City, NC, was such

cowboy songs and poetry, ranchers, and
Mormons and has worked with the Bunkhouse Orchestra and Deseret String Band.

by the Luxton Family, Carteret Co. Arts
Council, and The Down East Folk Arts

Panel topics will cover Radio and Ethnic
Communities; Playlists; Radio Pioneers,
and Bluegrass, Old-Time Music and the
IBMA. We will have a tour of historic

&amp; Agents
Sheila Adams spent a week in New York
City in December, appearing with the New
York Revels Company who incorporated
some of her stories into their annual Christ

WPAQ, celebrating 50 years of program
ming bluegrass and old-time music Ninety

She will be ap
mas Revels production.
at
the
Ann
Arbor
(MI) Story Tell
pearing

Society.
Bill Domler is booking a monthly "tradi
tional folk" night at Susan's Cafe in
Granby, CT, and is looking for, as he says,
"
.Highwoods-style bands old-time,
not

bluegrass."

He also

hosts

weekly

a

radio program on WWUH in W. Hartford
and will promote appearances. For info,
contact Bill at 836 Iron Horse Blvd.,
Simsbury, CT 06070 or willen@erols.com
Also in the Northeast, there is an Irish

session

at

Mitchell's

Lambertville,

Bar, on

Church

NJ, the first Wed.

St. in

of each

starting about 8 pm. Contributor
Harold Dunn says, "Look in if you play,
month

and look in if you don't." Fair enough!
The Birmingham Country Dance Society

celebrated the holidays from end

to end in

grand style this year, beginning with the
Turkey Trot in November, featuring Red
Mt. White Trash, and

moving

to the

Christ

mas Dance with the Sofa Cats and the New

Year's Eve Celebration with the Squirrely
Germs. I hope they have as much fun danc
ing as they do naming their bands!

dollars covers full registration, all sessions,
and a BBQand square dance. Info: 910-7867998 (Tanya Rees

website:
OTR

at

Surry Arts Council)

http://lupton.sas.upenn.edu/

r.htm The conference

is sponsored
(Old-Time Music on the Radio)
and the Surry Arts Council of Mt. Airy, NC.
ot

by OTR

There

is a

semi-monthly (first and third

of each month)

American country
New York City at

Sunday
old-time jam session in
Thady Cons (Irish Bar), 915 Second Ave.
between E. 48th and E. 49th. The time is
always 1:30 pm-4:30 pm. All old-time mu
sicians and dancers of any level welcome.
Listeners are also encouraged to come. Info:
Jack Hirschorn Marble@Warwick.Net.
"Loud and Clear: Resonator Guitars

The Dopyera Brothers' Legacy To Ameri
can Music," an exhibit organized by the
Erie Art Museum in Erie, PA, is on display
from Dec. 31 through Apr. 15. Info: John

Vanco, Erie Art Museum (814)459-5477.
A Durham presentation of Kudzu, the
new family musical created by J ack Herrick,
Doug Marlette, and Bland Simpson,
adapted from the Doug Marlette comic

Brevard, NC, which is in Transylvania
County, but what the heck.) So far, no list of

February 10-12, 1988, and run through Feb

a

Hallo we'enf est in T ransylvania! (Well, it's

in

winners

or

survivors

The 3rd Biennial

Old-Time Music and

Radio Conference will take place June 2-4,
1998, at the Andy Griffith Playhouse in Mt.
Airy,

NC. Featured

artists

include the

Freight Hoppers, George Shuffler, and the
Slate Mt. Ramblers. Keynote speaker is Hal

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ing Festival (2/27-3/1),

Studies Conference

at

the Appalachian
Appalachian State

U. in Boone, NC

(3/21), a banjo workshop
Mt. Airy (NC) Story
(4/3-5),
Chicago
and will be touring
Festival
(5/8-9),
Telling
in

England and Scotland with Jerry Epstein

(6/1-26).
David Holt, who is probably in the Fiji
Islands right about now, will be back home
in March, appearing with the NC Sym
Raleigh (3/7) and in Tryon for
Super Saturday (3/28). April is taken up
with Merlefest and taping Riverivalk and in
May he will be in Los Angeles (UCLA-5/2)
phony

in

and Austria.

Woodshed All-Stars
(2/13-15) at the 11th

Mac Benford &amp; the
&amp;

new dance venue in Portland
(OR), Duffy's Pub, where there will be a
dance every 4th Sunday at 7:00 pm, featur
ing Spud Mountain and caller Bill Martin.
For info, call Duffy's at (503)285-0615 or
Nancy Martin at (360)695-4361.
Seems that there's a fiddle contest for
including
every occasion these days
There is

Artists

will be appearing
Annual Dance Flurry in Saratoga, NY, and
(3/15) at the Celtic Appalachian Festival in

Philadelphia, PA. Info: (315)422-0718.
Art's Artists, Artistic Representationannounces the signing of a true legend of
bluegrass music, Charlie Cline &amp; The
Lonesome Pine Fiddlers. After a long ca
reer with such artists as Bill Monroe, Jimmy
Martin, and the Warrior River Boys, Charlie

strip Kudzu, will be presented by Theater

has revived the Lonesome Pine Fiddlers,

Previews

that

Duke University, in conjunc
tion with Ford's Theater in Washington,
D.C. Kudzu will open with previews on
ruary 22

Theater

at

at

in

Reynolds Industries
the Bryan Center on Duke
the

R.J.

University's West Campus. Jack Herrick
and Bland Simpson of Red Clay Ramblers
fame are co-authors of the show, as well as
musicians and featured actors in the pro
duction. Info: (919)684-4444.
The Bards Restaurant and Bar in

dates

back

to

1937.

Info:

(919)

a

group

542-399 7 or

artmenius@mindspring.com.

Bob Bovee and Gail Heil will be on tour

Kansas, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Wis
consin during Feb. and early March. Per
formances include the Iron Horse Music
Hall in El Dorado, KS; the Oklahoma City
in

Square Dance; Cushing, OK community
concert; Black Hawk Folk Society in Mt.
Morris, WI; and a new venue for oldtime music, the Milwaukee Ale Haus in
(continued

on next page)

�and the Southern Appalachians."

Performers at "A Celtic Appalachian
Christmas Festival" held in Abingdon, Vir
ginia, on December 27 included Cherish
the Ladies, Wayne Henderson &amp; Friends,
Donny Golden and partner, J.P. Cormier
and Hilda

Kay Justice, the
Will
Konnarock Critters,
Keys, and Clint
Issacs.
Howard and Dan

Chaisson,

The Grace Family (Win, Paul, Leela, and
Ellie) have a busy schedule in the spring:

Memphis, TN, Columbia, MO, Keokuk,
A, Warrenton, MO, Ludington, MI, Battle
ground, IN. In late Oct. and early Nov. they
I

will be touring through Kansas, Oklahoma,
Texas, and Arkansas. They are booking
dates for this tour. They note that all of their

indoor performances are

in

non-smoking

venues and all performances are open to the
public unless otherwise noted. Info: (573)4432819;

pgrace@mail.coin.missouri.edu. They
updated calendar monthly in:

an

post

rec.music.folk and http:

www.dirtynelson.com

linen/.

Dancer Malke Rosenf eld has announced
her teaching schedule in Carrboro, NC, for
winter and spring classes in Cape Breton

step dance, old-time flatfooting &amp; clog
ging, and children's rhythm &amp; dance. Info:

(919)942-3725.
Ken Waldman, billed as "Alaska's Fid
dling Poet," will perform "a Valentine's

time of Love Poems, Storytelling, and Fiddle
Tunes" onFeb. 14at Cyrano'sOff-Center Play
house in Anchorage, AKInfo: (907)274-2599.
In

Print,

In

School

The Southern

&amp;

on the Net

Arts Federation

has

an

nounced that because of time and funding
limitations, they will cease publication of
their newsletter Folk Arts Notes for the
foreseeable future. They are looking at the
idea of a Web site and will be maintaining
their mailing list for important announce
ments. Editor Peggy Bulger can be reached
by phone at (404)874-7244 or email at
WI. April will find them in MI,

NC, and TN including the John C. Campbell
Folk School Apr. 17-18, Merlefest Apr. 2326, and the Jubilee

May

Center

in

Knoxville on

1.

Tom Sauber,

Brad

Leftwich,

&amp;

Alice

Gerrard will be touring on the west coast in
June in support of their new CD to be
released in the early spring. Among other
at the Live

venues they will be performing
Oak Music Festival near Santa Barbara.
Kevin Burke's Open House consisting
of Kevin

Burke on fiddle,

Sandy Silva,

stepdancing, clogging, Mark Graham

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

on

harmonica and clarinet, and Paul Kotapish
on mandolin and guitar has been "chasing
whales" down the Pacific Coast this De
cember with performances in Bellingham,
Seattle, Portland, Santa Cruz, Berkeley, and
Modesto, among others.
Ira Bernstein was in Belfast for 5 weeks

working

on

a

big

production called

Rhythms of the Celts. He reports that "it's
a Riverdance
type of show, but is more

pan-Celtic, tracing the Celtic culture from
mid-Europe, to Scotland, Wales and Ire
land, and then to the new world (which is
where come in) to Cape Breton, Quebec,
I

pbulger@southarts.org
The Raleigh (NC) News

&amp;

Observer fea

tured an article by Emily Yellin about the
Mt. Zion Fund, which locates and places
markers on the graves of early blues re
cording artists such as Charley Patton,
Robert Johnson, and Memphis Minnie.
The

November issue of Acoustic Musi

cian contains

a

story about one of the most

venerable folk music clubs in existence,
Club Passim in Boston, MA. Originally
called Club 47, it has featured the finest in
folk and traditional music for 40 years, and
first heard live performances
it's where
legible Text

Milwaukee,

I

�by Doc Watson, The New Lost City Ram
blers, The Charles River Valley Boys, and

Monroe,

Bill

to

name but

a

few.

sadder note, folknik, the newsletter
of the San Francisco Folk Music Club, re
ports that the Ash Grove, another of the
highly influential clubs from the past, has
finally closed. It, too, was an important
On

a

force in spreading the gospel of traditional
music. [See OTH vol. 5 no. 8.]

David Lynch asks us to inform everyone
that the Old Time Music Home Page has

a

www.oldtimemusic.com
addition, David also has a new email

new address, http:
In

address: dlynch@mindspring.com.
The lead article in Acoustic Guitar (Dec.)
is entitled "Next Generation." It is an over
view of CDs by 30 of the hottest young
artists in acoustic music, including such
familiar names as The Freight Hoppers,
Gillian Welch, Bruce Molsky, the Hix, Jones
&amp; Leva, Carla Gover, and Dirk Powell,
among many others. There is also a feature
article ("Strike Up The Band") by Cathy
Fink &amp; Marcy Marxer on how to share your
loveof music with your kids. .or anybody's
kids, for that matter.
The Athens (GA) Folk Music &amp; Dance

Society has included
and list of web

a

calendar of events

addresses and radio shows

interest as the centerfold of their quar
terly newsletter. It's a good way to remind
members of current events and it fits nicely
of

on the

refrigerator.

The fall issue of High Notes

Mountain

Music from West Virginia contains a cata
logue of (I would guess) nearly all of the
available traditional recordings by WV art
ists with prices and addresses. Interesting
little newsletter; write them at High Notes,

Elysian Ave., Morgantown, WV 26505.
The Bluegrass &amp; Traditional Music Soci
ety of Australia (mentioned in last issue's
column) has a newsletter titled Cumberland
456

County Bulletin, so if you're in that neigh
borhood, you should contact them at PO
Box 76, Berowra Heights NSW 2082 Aus
tralia.
The Austin Friends of Traditional Music

permanent home page on the
Their new address is: http://

now has
Web.

Mike Seeger has a new Web site which
includes concert dates, photos, sound clips,
a discography with links to Rounder and

Smithsonian/Folkways,

and biographical

pages about
friends and family. The site also includes
information

with

links

to

his article, "What is Old-time Music?" along
a

www.mikeseeger.pair.com/.
Many thanks to Smithsonian/Folkways

a

www.main.org/aftm/ aftmhome.htm

with

available compact discs
(originally printed in the May 1997 issue of
Bluegrass Unlimited). The address is http:/

of 20 currently

brief description and personal selection

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Records for their donation of the CD Close
To Home to our annual fundraiser in No
vember. Readers might want to check out
their Web site

at

http:

www.si.edu/ folk

ways. And for those of you who are new
subscribers, there was an article on the history
of

Smithsonian/ Folkways

in

OTH vol.

6

no.

1

Recordings, Instruments, &amp; Labels
A number of independent record labels

have formed the Independent Acoustic
Group as a means to gain marketing/ad
vertising advantage and to help create an
impact for the genre of folk music.
North Carolina ballad singer/ storyteller
Bobby McMillon and filmmaker Tom Dav

enport have collaborated on a video en
titled Frankie Silver: A Documentary,
which explores the ballad and legend of
the first woman to be hanged in North
Carolina. Bobby and his sister Marina
Trivette supply the musical portions of the
video and it includes "The Making of a
Ballad Singer,"

a

discussion of Bobby's
(continued

on next

page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

development

as

a

ballad singer.

Info:

(540)592-3701.
The Konnarock Critters have released a
new CD/cassette on Marimac entitled
Cornbread and Sweetpeas which includes
two original tunes from fiddler Brian Grim
and several vocal duets from Brian and
Debbie, not to mention a bunch of great

fiddle tunes. Info: The Critters at 409
Boomer Dr., Independence, VA 24348.
Music from the Lost Provinces is a new
CD released in Jan. It reissues 22 songs and

tunes first recorded from 1927-1931 by mu
sicians from Ashe County, NC and vicin
ity. The

anthology brings together for the

first time the complete recordings of Frank
Blevins &amp; His Tar Heel Rattlers, the Caro
lina Night Hawks, Ephraim Woodie &amp; the
Henpecked Husbands, and the North Caro
lina Ridge Runners. Also featured are se
lections by banjoist Jack Reedy and the

influential duo of G. B. Grayson &amp; Henry
Whitter. Produced by researcher Marshall
Wyatt ("Music from the Lost Provinces"
OTH vol.

5

nos.

3

and

4)

the

anthology also

28-page booklet. Music from the
Lost Provinces is the first release of Old Hat
Enterprises, a new label "devoted to qual
ity reissues coupled with thorough histori
includes

a

cal research."

Farmer's Daughters is a new release on
Heritage Records (HRC CD 1282) by the
all-female band, Farmer's Daughters, from
the Blue Ridge Mountains of VA. (See
view this issue).

re

Tom Sauber, Brad Leftwich, and Alice
Gerrard have finished recording a new CD
project to be released in the spring. It fea
tures mainly old-time songs (duets, solos,
trios) with fiddle, banjo, guitar, mandolin,
two guitars, and two fiddles.
The New Lost City Ramblers' CD There
Ain't No Way Out was nominated for a
Grammy in the "Best Traditional Folk Al
bum category." Also nominated were
Beausoleil, the Hackberry Ramblers, Jo el
Sonnier, and Jody Stecher &amp; Kate Brislin.
Organizations
Wayne Martin, director of the Folklife
Section of the NC Arts Council, reports
that work on the Traditional Music Trail
project is progressing, with the hiring of
Sally Council, formerly with the Southern
Folklife Collection. She will be working
with county agencies in the pertinent areas
Western NC developing criteria for sites

of

and creating talent inventories.
The Blue Ridge Music Center, located
on Fisher's Peak near Mt. Airy, NC on the
$5.2 million in
site
funds
for
federal
work, including roads,
site preparation, utilities, etc. Unfortu
nately, it does not cover the cost of a build
ing to house the Center.
The Southern Arts Federation has re
ceived a $200,000 grant from NEA for a
Leadership Initiative program titled Ameri
can Traditions. The program will enable
traditional artists of excellence to enter the
world of mainstream arts presentation and

VA/NC border, received

help arts presenters more effectively show
case these artists in their communities.

Among those participating are Bobby
McMillon, Homer Ledford, and Roy
Harper.
A new old-time music and dance group
(Low Country Old Time Music &amp; Dance

Locomads)

Society

is

located

in

the

area of SC. They
have monthly contra dances on the third
Sat. and monthly old-time jams on the second

Myrtle Beach/Conway

weekend of the month. Info: (803)2494027.
On The Air

Matthew Matlack (aka "The Rowdy
Redneck") hosts a show called American
Music Head on WKCR 89.9FM at Colum
bia University in New York City every
Sunday at high noon. For info, call Mat
thew

at

(212)853-6727.

�Paul Brown's hour-long documentary
Breakin' Up Christmas was an important
part of the NPR-affiliate holiday program
ming again this year. I hope it's around for

long time!
WUOT-91 .9FM in Knoxville, TN, broad
casts Live At Laurel and Music of the
a

Southern Mountains every Friday night

at

The winner of the Henderson guitar

at

the 3rd Annual Wayne C. Henderson Fes
tival was Brandon Davis of Galax, VA. He
told his father that he intended

to

sleep

with the guitar that night.

Jimmie Rodgers was inducted into the
Rock 'n' Roll Hall of Fame on Sept. 21.
John Lilly, formerly with the Augusta

Heritage Center, has taken

8:00 pm.

a new
position
Editor of Goldenseal Magazine, the West
Virginia folklife quarterly. His new ad
dress is John Lilly, PO Box 5402, Charles
ton, WV 25361, phone (304) 558-0220 ext.

as

Congratulations

The NC organization PineCone (Pied
mont Council of Traditional Music) has
been awarded a $10,000 grant from the NC

new

his

135;

net

address

is

Arts Council for general program support.
Their activities include the Stewart Theatre

lillyjo

concert series, the Pure Sound series, com

awarded 1997 National Heritage Fellow
ships by the National Endowment For The
Arts. In addition to being pioneers in blue-

munity outreach programs, and a weekly
radio show on WQDR-94.7FM in Raleigh.
They also sponsor several weekly and
monthly music and dance events in the
Triangle area.
Prof. William R. Ferris, founder and
director of the Center for the Stud y of Souththe U. of Miss., co-editor of
the Encyclopedia of Southern Culture and
ern Culture

at

scholar of the American South was re
cently confirmed as chairman of the Na
tional Endowment for the Humanities.

a

Jim

w vie wvne

&amp;

Jesse

t

ed

McReynolds have been

grass music, they are heirs to a long tradi
tion of old-time music in their home area of

southwestern Virginia.
Legendary country

performer

and

and former Louisiana

songwriter
gover
nor J immie Da vis celebrated his 98th birth
day at a celebration in Baton Rouge on
Sept. 11.
The Augusta Heritage Center of Davis

Music Foundation for many years, has been

&amp; Elkins College received $43,000 in grants
from the WV Humanities Council, the Na
tional Endowment for the Arts for its film

proposed by President Clinton as the new
chairman of the National Endowment for

making and folklife projects being directed
by Folk Arts Coordinator Gerry Milnes.

ner for

Arts, to replace retiring chair Jane
Alexander. Do we begin to see a pattern

Final Notes

One of the original Briarhoppers, Garnett
"Fiddlin' Hank" Warren died on Dec. 1 7at
the age of 88. Hank was a native of Mount

William Ivey, director

of the

Country

the

here
Jan

Davidson, director of the John

C.

Campbell Folk School in Brasstown, NC
and Wayne Martin, director of the Folklife
Section of the NC Arts Council, recently
toured Sweden,

Germany, Belgium, and

England as part of a NC delegation to
encourage European tourism to the Tarheel
State.
of the San Fran

Faith Petric, doyenne
cisco folk and traditional music scene, was
featured in the Oct. issue of Acoustic Guitar.
A member of the San Francisco Folk Music

Anna Wine, wife of WV fiddler Melvin
Wine, died of complications following sur

gery in September. Expressions of sympa
thy would be appreciated and may be sent
to: Melvin Wine, c/o General Delivery,
Copen, WV 26615.
Stephane Grappelli, 89, legendary jazz
fiddler and co-founder of the Quintet of the
Hot Club of France with guitarist Django
Reinhart, died of heart disease in early

December

in Paris.

Also an accomplished

Club

pianist, he played professionally from 1923
until this past summer, when poor health
forced him to retire. His influence on string

every summer with a vaudeville show that
includes the Flying Karamazov Brothers.

music was profound, inspiring several gen
erations of bluegrass, swing, jazz, and clas
sical players.
Bill Harrison, of Madison, AL, one of the
country's leading authorities on fiddling,

since the 1950s, Faith has recently
"retired" from some of her official club
activities, but still performs regularly,
writes a column for Sing Out! and tours

been

died ofaheartattackonNov.l6.Heformed
the Tenn. Valley Old-Time Fiddlers' Assn.

named to the Georgia Fiddlers Hall of Fame.
Jones, 86, who has been playing since 1924,
still appears with his band, the Dixie

1960s and served as publisher of The
Devil's Box for over 25 years. According to
Charles K. Wolfe, "He certainly and single-

Not bad for 82 years old!

Marion Jones, of Ellaville,

G A, has

Serenaders.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in the

handedly rejuvenated traditional fiddling

mid-South, and was the silent part
dozens of good projects. He was a
kind, decent man, with a robust sense of
humor and the love of a good cigar."
in the

Airy, NC. After the band left radio in the
early 1950s, he stayed on staff at WBT/
WBTV as a photographer. The Briarhoppers
reformed with five original members in the
early 1970s. Banjo player Shannon Grayson
died several years ago, and was replaced
by David Deese, former banjoist with
Monroe's Blue Grass Boys.

Rick Abrams, clawhammer banjo player
Piney Creek Weasels, an old-time
band from the Sacramento, CA, area, died
on Dec. 13 after a long bout with skin
for the

cancer. Rick was often at the Galax Fiddlers
Convention and won several first-place rib
bons in old-time banjo there.

My apologies for the misattribution in last
issue's Final Notes piece on Roy Huskey,
Jr. Roy's father, Junior Huskey, was the
bass player on the 1973 Circle project; Roy Jr.
was on the more recent (1989) Volume 2. /.C.

(continued

on page 23)

�Dance Beat

Mountain Legacy:
A Celebration of Southern Appalachian Dance
by Phil

&amp;

Music

Jamison

Appalachian clogging,

as an art

form as stage-worthy as any other

theatrical dance. But in addition to being
entertainment, Mountain Legacy attempts to tell some of the
history behind the development of modern clogging.
Flatfooting, buckdancing, and clogging are traditional forms of
percussive stepdance that have served the social and recreational
needs of communities in the southern Appalachians for many
kind of professional

generations. Clogging choreographed for the stage is a 20thcentury innovation which has evolved over the years. In the late
1920s the first "square-dance teams," as they were called, put
traditional buckdancing in front of an audience. In what is now
called "traditional freestyle clogging," the dancers did their own
individual steps while dancing a big set Appalachian square dance
(see OTH vol.1 no.2). Later on, in the 1950s, James Kesterson and
other dancers began to synchronize their footwork, and the line
formations of modern precision clogging were first seen in western
North Carolina (see OTH vol.2 no.l). In 1971, the Green Grass
Cloggers formed, and they developed their own style of choreog
OTH vol.1
raphy based on four-couple square dance figures (see
of
Fiddle
that
the
with
of
Their
no.5).
Puppets,
years
touring, along

Bernstein, and others, helped to propagate that style of clogging
throughout this country, as well as overseas.
Traditional clogging, flatfoot, and buckdance steps have their
roots in the stepdancing of the British Isles, African dancing, and
to some extent, Native American dancing. Through the years the
influences of other dance styles, including French Canadian
Ira

Pal

Parker

III

stepdancing and

Burton Edwards doing

fall

I

a

Lastambitious

and

a

part of what is probably the most

comprehensive clogging production ever

to

be seen. Mountain Legacy, featuring over 80 dancers and 20
musicians, was staged at the Diana Wortham Theatre in Asheville,

North Carolina for three performances on November 7-9, 1997.
The 500-seat theater was sold out for all three shows.
to

Billed as "America's response to Riverdance," comparisons
the Irish stepdance show are inevitable. Mountain Legacy,

like Riverdance, presents traditional stepdancing, in this case,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

today's modern
across the country far from the Appalachian region, the steps have
become standardized and regional styles have been lost. Unfortu
in
nately, the emphasis is now too often put on competition,
contests which are "sanctioned" by national clogging organiza
tions.

"jump through."

was invited to be

of
tap dance, have also fed into the development
As
it has gained popularity and spread
clogging.

Mountain Legacy is the inspiration of dancer Burton Edwards of
of
Maggie Valley, North Carolina, who grew up in a family
traditional dancers. His grandmother and other relatives danced
with Sam Queen's Soco Gap Square Dance Team, one of the first
that
performing square-dance groups in western North Carolina,
formed in the 1920s. In 1982, his father, Kyle Edwards, also a
buckdancer, built the Stompin' Ground in Maggie Valley, which
soon became

a

nationally-known center

of

clogging.

As

teenagers

the early 1980s, Burton and his sister Becky, along with their
world of competi
group, the Magnum Cloggers, entered the
in

tion clogging, winning numerous trophies and national titles.

�Burton won the world clogging championship three times.
For many years Burton Edwards has wanted to
present southern
to
the
the
Appalachian stepdance
public beyond
clogging world,
not just for recreation or competition, but as a viable form of
entertainment. Since it opened in 1982, the Stompin' Ground has
provided a venue for the many talented dancers who live in
western North Carolina. Elsewhere, other than at clogging compe
titions and at a few festivals, there are few places for this form of
dance to be seen and appreciated. Burton viewed the music and
dance at the Stompin' Ground as a show that could and should be
stage and be seen by more than the tourists who come to
Maggie Valley. Then along came Riverdance, doing just that
put on

a

taking traditional music and stepdance and putting it in the
theater. Burton formed a production committee consisting of

dancers Ira Bernstein, Barbara Kohler (artistic director of the Bailey
Mountain Cloggers), and Ray Hattaway (director of the Panther
Creek Dancers), and together they created the show, Mountain

old-time band consisting of Brad Leftwich, Alice Gerrard, John
Herrmann, Trevor and Travis Stuart, Meredith Mcintosh, and Don
Pedi, with John Cowan, formerly of New Grass Revival, making a
cameo appearance to sing "Dark as a Dungeon" as a musical
interlude between dance numbers.
a

Act Two, entitled "Then and There
Here and Now," provides
glimpse of some of the tributaries that have fed the development

modern clogging. These include English Hornpipe and Tap
Dance performed by Ira Bernstein, French Canadian Step Danceby
Eileen Carson's Footworks Percussive Dance Ensemble, the Green
Grass Cloggers performing one of their signature routines dating
of

from the mid 1970s, and finally, an early routine by the Fiddle

Puppets of Annapolis, Maryland.
The second half of the show, "Mountain Legacy: The Concert,"
features mostly modern precision clogging routines danced to a

Legacy.
Western North Carolina, 70 years after the start of team clogging,
is still blessed with an abundance of local dancers and
clogging
teams. With his reputation as a dancer and his unbounded enthu
siasm, Burton was able to bring together more than 80 dancers and

musicians, mostly from the local area, to donate their time and
talents for the production. Rehearsals began in August with the
dancers, many of them high school and college students, coming

Clogging is not presented here
preservation or revival, but as

Parker
Pal

together every weekend throughout the fall to work out the
choreography and practice. I became involved as a member of the
Green Grass Cloggers. Finally, Burton enlisted the help of Robert
and Virginia Barnett, former Associate Directors of the Atlanta
Ballet to direct the show, and with professional sound and lighting,
the production was ready to be seen by a theater audience.
As the program states, "Mountain Legacy is what the music and
dance of the Southern Appalachians has always been: a proud
personal expression of the hearts and souls of the participants."

III

20

Green Grass Cloggers doing

a

routine. The old-time hand

is in

the

background.

archaic folk dance worthy of
current dance form that is very

as an
a

much alive and still evolving. The show is a coming together of the
various diverging branches of clogging which coexist, but seldom
intersect.

Mountain Legacy consists of three acts which trace the history of
team clogging from its roots in flatfooting right up to the modern
precision routines. The show opens with its title tune, "Mountain

Nichols, myself and others, and a few
traditional southern Appalachian dance routines: the Southern
Mountain Fire Cloggers of Asheville dance a traditional eightcouple southern Appalachian Freestyle routine and the Bailey
Mountain Cloggers of Mars Hill College perform a Mountain
Smooth Dance routine. The scene ends with a dance tune during
which individual dancers mimic each others' steps and begin to
dance in unison as happened with the emergence of precision
clogging. The music for the barn dance scene was played by an
by Rodney Sutton,

Bill

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Parker
Pal

show. She reminisces with the audience about the dances that took
place in her youth and also recounts some of the historical back
ground of the dance.
The opening act is a barn dance scene set sometime in the first
half of the 20th century with an old-time string band providing the
music. This scene features buckdancing by Chris Ginn, flatfooting

III

Legacy," a beautiful and mournful mountain air composed by
Dirk Powell, and played on fiddles by Brad Leftwich and Trevor
Stuart. Cherie Sheppard as "Grandma," is the narrator for the

Buck dance free for all.
hot bluegrass and country music ensemble headed up by Wayne
Crowe of Maggie Valley and Gary Wiley of Waynesville, NC.
Included in "The Concert" are performances by Burton Edwards,

the

Bailey

Kirkpatrick,

Mountain Cloggers,
the Goodpaster

Delohn Collins and Jenny

Sisters of Kentucky, the Magnum

Cloggers and others.
The most unique of these modern dance pieces, the "Drum
Challenge," is a light-hearted male-female dance competition,
(continued

on next

page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Correction:
The review of the Mando Mafia CD [vol.
no.

2]

contains

an

error.

I

6

maintain the

home page for the Mando Mafia, and the

incorrect URL. Unfortu
used what was on
reviewer
nately, your

review

the CD,

has

an

which

is

incorrect

as

well. The

correct URL for the Mando Mafia: http://

www.access.digex.net/jmangin/
nimafia.htm.

Julie Mangin

�Booth

From The Judges'

Notes

compiled by Molly Tenenbaum

[The contest at the Appalachian String Band

Music

Festival

sidered

by most

is

Clifftop

generally con

old-time musicians

to be one of

representative, and most fairly

the best, most

judged of any of the

summer fiddlers conven

will

its voice

be

I

e-mail

please

write me

or

me

at

7002 23rd

at

T.

heard by this festival

comments and suggestions could apply

any contest.

comments,

Ave NE, Seattle, WA 98115.-- M.

Riley Baugus, North Carolina (fiddle and
banjo, 1997):
Thanks for the opportunity to speak
about my experience as a judge at Clifftop.
First let me say that
really did have fun

contest) we have chosen the Clifftop contest to
be the focus of the article below, although most
of the

academic senses about the tunes together.
I also
thought that most of the contes
tants played at nearly the same level. What

mt@langston.com,

tions and festivals. For this reason (and because
I think that the old-time music community feels
that

many judges who might wish to add their
remarks, and for this I apologize. If you
have been a judge and would like to add

to

ed.]

I

being

served

than

Clifftop (The Appa
lachian String Band Music Festival, at
1997,

In

Camp

1

at

Washington-Carver

in

West

perspective, and now

I

(they are all musicians) and regional back
grounds, that they all have different expe
riences of and beliefs about contests, and

that therefore there is no "judge's
perspective."I decided to do a little bit of informal
research, and collect the comments of as
many Clifftop judges as I could in order to

could come up
see if by studying them
with whatever the truth may be about con
I

think the results show that a contest
is just as amazing and silly, as varied and
complex, as old-time music itself. But you
may draw your own conclusions. We also

tests.

I

invited Bobby Taylor, the organizer of the
festival, who has served as a judge at other
fiddlers conventions, to add his comments.
that I failed to get in touch with
I know

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

it

I

I

would have my chance to find out. How
ever, after the contest was over, I realized
that all judges come from different musical

all

different experience
would be. I don't
had imagined
judge.

was

really think that there was a best or worst
part of judging for me. I liked some things
about it and others didn't. I really enjoyed
hearing all the performances. The ones that

Virginia) as a contest judge. I had
often wondered what contests were like
from the judge's

a

It

liked most were the less flashy, simple,
solid tunes, played very well. All in all, it
I

a
good experience. It helped me to
figure out, as a contestant, what exactly I
am being judged on, and I think it also gave
me some ideas of how to make it a better

was

experience for the judges that
when play in a contest.

I

encounter

mean is that everyone was good. That's
what makes it a real challenge to come up
with 5 out of 95, and then to have only one
that is the best on that day.
I think that the
Appalachian Stringband
Festival is by far the most fair contest that
one could ever enter. I and the other judges
that I worked with, seemed to put one
fairness. We
thing above everything else
to be
the
best
to
make
decisions,
struggled

ultimately

fair, no matter who was

playing

they played well, we gave them
marks.
high
the tune.

If

This brings me to another difficult part

of being a judge. Since we are musicians,
we know most of the musicians who are

playing

in the

contest and you can't judge

on the fact that

someone

is

a

nice person

and you like them. It has to be about the
music and how well it is played. It also

seemed a little strange to have to judge the
contestants in the Senior and Youth divi
sions with everyone else. The seniors are of
course the "real" old-time musicians, and
think that they deserve to be judged as an
elite group rather than being clumped with
everyone else. Sometimes it was hard to

I

I

From now on when I enter a contest, I
will either announce the name of the tune
I
am going to play, or ask the an
nouncer to do it. It was difficult for me to
pay attention to some of the tunes as closely
as I would have liked, because was trying
so desperately to decide what tune was
being played. Everyone knows how it is
when you hear a tune you know the tune,

that

I

but you just can't come up with the name.
That's what was happening to me some

times. When you hear that many tunes, one
after another, it gets difficult to keep your

young player over a
I was
thinking some
times, "Well, this guy has been playing for
50 years, but he's just not playing in tune."
judge in favor of

a

senior and vice versa.

So if the next person that got up had only
been playing for 5 years, and played with
perfect intonation, they probably got a
higher score. I just think that there should
hp

t-hrpp

"qpnaratp"

ratpporips that are

(continued

on next page)

�A contest introduces artificial and
sometimes unfair ways of thinking about

judged independently of each other. It is
nice for the seniors have the opportunity to
win their division as well as the entire

contest, but

it

doesn't seem honorable

judge these men and women, who
played for so long, with those of us
have learned from them. Judging the
divisions together made it extremely

cult to choose

a

winner

in each

music because of its judging criteria. But
without these rules there can't be a contest

to

have

in the

first place. So

diffi

of those

inherent non-objectivity of the judges.
why worry about it too much?

reflection on anyone at all. It is a number
that is given for a particular performance
of one tune, in a contest, by three people
who may not necessarily be certain of how

things

a

of

im

announce the tunes before

take a
they are played, and have the judges
for
easier
it is
couple more breaks so that
them to keep a clear head.
To conclude, I'll just say it was one of the

hardest jobs that I've ever undertaken,
loved it hated it, and I would probably do

I

I

were asked.

Paul Brown, North Carolina (full contest,
1993):

with me.
Judging at Clifftop was just fine
times it was fun. The worst part was
to play
sitting in a chair for hours, unable
music: would have preferred a much bet
ter reason for a sore rump! Second worst
was splitting hairs between great perfor
mances to come up with winners. The best
At

I

to hear lots of good
parts were getting
music and watching people enjoy the festival.

phrasing, deep understandingof traditional
flub.
style but contained a small technical

also frustrating to recognize that by the
nature of their rules contests seem to give

It is

players with a smooth, refined, technically
than musi
perfect approach more weight
other
cians who present
types of perfor
It's
something to
mance, however good.
a
reminder for
and
reckon with and accept,
of a
elements
me that the most important
are

away

from

stage,

where people are making inspired music
and eniovine each other's company.
still believe our
Having said all this,
I

team did an honorable job of judging the

contest, helped along

in great

Clifftop asked me

to be

a

days when the judges had to

there
judge everything, which means we sat
for the duration. It was hard work, but fun
too. The fun part was getting a chance to
to absolutely
every band /banjo
came
across the stage. I
that
/fiddler
player

listen

love to

I

it

really

a

could bring a woman's per
judging, and that it's impor
spective
tant and fair to have this ingredient if you

music con

convention

judge

at

felt that

I

to the

making
people
inspired music
and enjoying each
other's company ."

music

to say,

Alice Gerrard, North Carolina (full contest,

I

are

would only change a couple of things
about the contest at Clifftop. That would be
to split the different age divisions into sepa

grandmother used

perspective on the variety of
music, musicianship, and musical points
of view that exist.

from stage, where

I

"Don't take it
serious, it's too mysterious." Now let's go
play a tune.
my

gave me

vention are away

tive or negative.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

grounds. As

mostly because
rarely do that
in
the
"parking lot" and
hang

portant elements

I

I

soul, tone,

heart,

.the most

score that performance. As said earlier,
everyone who enters the contests plays so
well, it is hard to say that one is really a
To be scored
great deal better than theother.
20 points lower than the person who won is
not a large difference. The whole judging
little
thing requires that you notice every
to make a wise
in
order
can
that
you
thing
and fair decision. Every little thing, posi

again if

value

are out on the

friendships

in the

I

Clifftop.

judge me than non-musicians. But every
time I play God at a fiddlers' convention, I
tend to react to the whole idea of contests
and the
with more of a laugh. The music

Clifftop have tried hard to
create reasonable rules, and that certainly
made judging more pleasant. Still, the big
frustration was having to drop points when
hearing a performance that was filled with
at

at

judge again? Sure. I'm as fair as
the next person, and with the situation
turned around I'd rather have musicians
I

1991):
The folks

all the

1

Would

So

The folks

One of the very, very positive things that
was glad to see for the judges' sake, was
that they have stopped posting the scores.
think that some people tend to take a
number score too personally. It really isn't

it

be

contradiction

Each individual contest has a life of its own
based on its rules, the musicians, and the

I

rate contests,

tried to accept this

reality,
tween my own feelings about a perfor
mance and the rules, and do my best within
the structure. I feel that if we musicians
could do the same thing when we go up on
stage to compete, there would be happier
people all around and fewer hurt feelings.

three

categories. You see, for me the difficulty
comes in hearing a youth, then hearing a
senior, then hearing someone in the regu
lar contest, then hearing another youth,
and now having to decide if I think youth
number 1 played as well as youth number
3, or did senior number 5 play as well as
senior number 2, and did any of them play
as well as regular contestant 8.

to

I

this occasional

who

well-intended rules

part by the

assuming there will
women competitors. So,
are

be both men and
it

has bothered me

that until recently there have been mainly
male judges at Clifftop. I'm glad that Bobby

Taylor has sought out more women judges
and hope that he will continue to do so.
And I hope more and more women will

continue

to

enter the individual competi

tions.
Maybe Clifftop could lighten up a bit so
there wouldn't be so much pressure. I al
ways loved the "attatude" of the 1968 35th

annual Berkeley Old-time Fiddlers' Con
vention which gave 6 pounds of rutabagas
to the 2nd place winner and 3 pounds to the
1st place winner. And how about a backup
would be
guitar category (the guitar player
judged playing with a fiddler or banjo
player).

Although

I

feel that there is an essential

judging one good musician
fallacy
another
(kind of like apples and
against
the
phenomenon exists. I applaud
oranges),
the organizers' continuing efforts to im
the in
prove the "fairness" factor, and in
terests of both the music and the contest, I
if
hope that people will consider judging
called upon The more varied the represen
tation and points of view, the healthier the
in

climate.

�Gail Gillespie, North Carolina (traditional
non-traditional bands 1996):
Clifftop has been my top choice old-time
festival every year since I went to the first

one.

From

a

participant's

has nearly every feature

I

perspective,

it

hold desirable in

music festival: gorgeous wooded setting
high enough altitude that even August
afternoon temperatures are bearable, luxu
a

at a

rious hot showers, giant log building with
dance hall and wrap-around porches to
hang out on in case of rain and, wonder of

wonders, fair judging.
I've been going to fiddlers conventions
since the late '60s and have never known of
a contest situation in which the
organizers
have made such a sincere effort to create at
least the appearance of objective judging.
Judges, old-time musicians themselves, are
rotated each year and represent different

regional styles. Last year's lineup for the
contest included a northerner who
loves Virginia-North Carolina band music,
a West Virginian, and a fiddler who favors
the ornate Midwestern sound. When I was
asked to judge the band contest in 1996, 1
knew it would be a lot of work, but was
terribly honored to be asked as a known
band

"hard core" proponent of the Round Peak
North Carolina- V irginia sound So my com
ments below should be considered with all
of this in mind. I love Clifftop, but I think it
could be made a lot more fun for everyone
if a few minor chanees hannened.
at

The contest itself, once
the judges' table, was

in my

mind.

I

I

sat

myself down

whirlwind blur
remember being astounded
a

the level of skill represented by the 100 or
so bands in the traditional category and at
at

how absurd

it felt to

have

to

select only

5

few seconds
only
between each band, there was not a second
to mull over scores, let alone make any
for the finals.

With

a

with the other judges. The
most horrific problem I and my fellow
judges faced that year was that the scores

comparisons

got posted publicly. Although this prob
lem has been corrected and scores weren't

posted this year, there remains a sense of
desperate competition that I believe has no
place in old-time music. give the follow
ing suggestions as possible remedies:
1. "Spread the wealth." It would take a
I

pressure off of everyone, if, as Galax
the old-time band
contest grew to enormous size, there were
lot of

did in the '70s when

simply more places. Along with this, the

sizeor nature of the individual band prizes

would be reduced, thereby removing some
(continued

on next

page)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�edge of grimness. When I was re
searching old contests in North Carolina
and Tennessee held before 1920, thought
the system of awarding food and goods
was a lighthearted solution. One Tennes
see contest had separate categories for
popular tunes: i.e. the best "Sugar in the
Gourd" earned a 20-pound sack of sugar;
the finest rendition of "Leather Britches"
garnered a pair of deerskin pants, etc.
of the

1

2.

Figure out

a

way

to

convey

the rules

to

the non-traditional band entrants so that so

many bands do not end up having to be
disqualified. It was painful the year was a
judge, to be forced to disqualify the major
I

ity of bands, many of whom were highly
clever and skilled musicians because they
(a) used electric instruments or accessories,
or (b) because their selection had abso

lutely no rootedness in the Appalachian
string-band tradition either instrumentally,
stylistically, or in tune selection. In other
words, we had to award a prize to at least
one band thatplayed poorly and disqualify
more than one great band because the first
band played a tune that satisfied the rules
and the second simply played, for example,

swing number using swing instruments.
I'm not sure this problem has been totally
heard bands
resolved, since last year
a

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

warming up for the non-traditional contest
were simply playing other types of

that

music.

this

the case, the rules need
to be changed.
Misunderstandingof the rules
of the contest caused a lot of agony and
If

Bruce Greene, North Carolina (fiddle and
banjo 1996):

is to be

to

response

My strongest

judging

at

Clifftop (which pretty much the extent of
my judging career) was that there were too
is

expect it still does.
and
Clifftop is, by
large, the best festival
to go to if you can only attend one. It
attracts people from all over the country,

many contestants to judge anything mean
ingfully. If I remember correctly, there were
at least 70, maybe closer to 90, contestants
in both the fiddle and banjo contests, and

and yet, you can still hear and perhaps
even share a tune or two with legendary

honestly, after about 25 or 30, it's impos
sible to keep straight how they compare to
each other, particularly the first few that
played. I think it is probably a liability to
come on very early in the contest when

angry e-mail

West

in 1996 and so

Virginia

players

I

like Melvin

Wine

and Wilson Douglas. Walking around the
campground at night on Saturday last year

was an unforgettable experience. Under a
crystal sky lit up by the Milky Way, I was
treated to an incredible smorgasbord of

some of the best old-time musicians play
and playing fluently in styles
ing today
that represent the full range of nearly ev
erything possible in the world of old-time
music: tuneful pieces in C from Alabama
and Georgia, raggy pieces from

a

Philadel

phia band, real Cajun tunes played by folks
from Louisiana, as well as faithful replica

tions of classic piedmont North Carolina
bands that recorded in the '20s and '30s.
Somehow all of this joy should n't be sullied
by

a

contest structure that makes room for

people

to

feel such anger and resentment.

there is no one to compare to. If the judges
start out conservatively, they might not be
able to backtrack and put the early contes
tants in context with later ones. I know it

wouldn't

be fair to everyone wanting to
compete, but I think to get realistic judging,
a contest should be limited to the first 25 or
30 to

register.
Another aspect of having so many con
testants is that the few who make the finals
are almost an arbitrary decision. The judges
go by the total number of points each con
testant receives, and with so many compet
ing when I judged, there were at least 20 or
more who were within a point or two of
making the finals. So what does it really
mean that only five of them made the fi
nals? I tried to explain that to people who
were upset that they did not make the
finals
that their playing was essentially

every bit

as

as the

good

winners

but

it

was small consolation for most. In that
respect I think it is good to post scores.
know that can also make people unhappy,
to see their score and think they were jud ged

I

poorly, but I think there is no way to con
vince everyone that it was fair.
Contests do a strange thing to our sense
of values. Everyone wants to know who

won, and everybody has an opinion, and
often a strong one, about who should or
shouldn't have won. Is that what we are

won
playing this music for? Sometimes
if it might be just as enjoyable just to
give everyone a chance to play a couple of
I

der

tunes on stage

they want.

if

whether there was

a

bet just as

I

many people would come

to

Clifftop
contest or not.

Despite all that, rather enjoyed judging.
Hearing the wide variety of different styles
I

and tunes

was great, and in truth, most

people just did
again.
job

I

I

for fun.

tried to do the most

could, but

enough
versies.

it

it

conscientious

don't take

it

seriously

really bothered by the contro
tried to remember that the spirit

to be
I

I

would do

I

�of the music is, or

should be, that of some

thing we enjoy together for its own sake.
Contests really strain that spirit just by
their nature, so it seems that we all need to
try to do them mainly just for fun and try

not to get our egos so involved. It is a
difficult phenomenon that the contestants
who know they will really be in the run
ning are usually the ones who take their

scores the most seriously. They are usually
the ones who already get plenty of atten
tion for their playing, so why be in a contest
and get mad

if

you don't place?

Dot Kent, Illinois (dance contest 1997)
The dance contest in 1 997 lasted about an

hour and a half or two hours with a total of
about 40 or 50 dancers, the majority of
whom were competing in the 16-49 age

category. This was
time flatfooting.

a

terrific display of old-

The rules were a little baffling, including
prohibition of "precision knee bending"
and stating that "judges will not look for

clogging"; however, the contestants un
derstood the stylistic standards, and only a
couple flagrantly violated them for comic
effect There have always been a lot of great
most of them
dancers attending Clifftop
are also musicians, and they have often
chosen to compete with their instruments
but not with their feet.

I

mentioned

the

dance contest to many of these friends,
several of whom came without the right
shoes but ended up dancing in the contest

anyway.
to

The best part of judging was being able
concentrate so intensely on all of this

wonderful dancing. Of course I could have
wouldn't
done this in the audience, but
have because of all of the distractions: so
I

cializing, getting cold, getting hungry, look
ing around, whatever. The contest moved
very fast, and I found myself coming up
with

a

preliminary score before each dancer

was finished, often needing to look down

compare with previous dancers' scores.
was surprised at how holistic this process
was, since as a contestant I have tended to
fret over the details of my footwork. The
dancers who stood out showed an immedi
to
I

ate and fluid

embodiment of the music,

a

confident direct connection that was com
fortable to watch and hear. With so many

dancers

in the 16-49

category having su

perb rhythm, control, complexity, and re
sponsiveness to the music, these top three

places could have gone to any of a number
people. If I were to sit down, think about

of

all of the

dancers there, and come up with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

names of those who could best represent
old-time flatfoot dancing in all its variety,
would choose differently.

queries. would try to explain that was
very satisfied with the outcome, although
of course these were not my personal top
three selections (being a composite of the
scoring of all three judges), and would try
I

I

That's not how it works, of course. The
three of us were individually judging on a

I

I

personal standard that came down to how
each performance made us feel in that im
mediate moment, compared with the im
pact of the dancing of the others. This was

convey what was so terrific
dancing of these "winners" and
most of the dancing had been,
wised up after a
blah, blah.

hard thing to try to explain to the many
folks who asked me about the judging af

began asking my questioners if they had
seen the dancers who won the contest and

terwards. I started to feel resentful as
realized how much mental and emotional

then

a

effort

I

was putting into answering these

I

to

I

about the

how great
and blah,

while and

expressed my condolences for what
thev had missed: you should have been
(continual

on next pnge)

�was so great, hard to explain in
words, oh well.
ended up feeling kind of bad that so

there,

it

I

many wonderful dancers, especially those
I
may have coaxed to enter, had nothing to
show for how well they danced for us all.

I

hoped that they had enjoyed dancing for
the large and

enthusiastic audience

or had

gotten something good out of the experi
ence. I was also sorry that, as it turned out,
all the 16-49 ribbon

am very happy

women playing

holders were women.
see more and

to
in

I

I

want to see men keep dancing too; and we
certainly had great male contestants in the
group.

I
consoled myself with the gratifying
realization that all this means that the dance

contest has become like the music contests
with far more talent than can possibly be

awards process, and that
if you worry too much about who didn't
win you're missing the whole point.

recognized

in the

Brad Leftwich, North

Carolina

(full

con

test, 1992):

enjoyed judging at Clifftop more than I
expected. There were, of course, hardships:
it was cold that year, the contest went late
remember shivering
into the night, and
I

1

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

judgment of contestants in all categories,
leaving us precious little time to play music

visit with friends. But I en
precisely because it took me out

ourselves

or

joyed it
side my circle of friends and cohorts and
forced me to listen to the entire spectrum of
music represented at Clifftop. I heard indi

viduals

more

old-time bands, but

under a blanket and accepting tongue-incheek "bribes" of hot chocolate and whis
key. Moreover, this was before they split
the judging duties, and the three of us sat in

and bands

heard otherwise,
prised

at the

I

and

would have

never
I

was

at

diversity of what

by how much of

it

I

no

is

about the worst reason I
can think of, and a winner who believes
that's what First Place means is deluding

you're the best

is

him- or herself. Just play your best, enjoy
yourself (if you can), be gracious, and let
the chips fall where they may.

heard and

Gerry Milnes, West Virginia (full contest,

was really

1994):

neither math nor

correct answers.

science; there
Music's very essence is subjective. Being
human, judges in spite of all attempts to
find objective criteria (and bald-faced poli
will respond most
tics and fraud aside)
favorably to what moves them the most, and
this will vary from individual to individual.
A parting tip to aspiring contestants:
there are many good reasons to enter a
are

challenging yourself to do your best, enter
taining the audience, even winning some
much-needed cash. But trying to prove

once sur

delighted
good.
I can
honestly say that the three judges
that year listened intently to every entry
and sweat blood trying to rate them fairly.
But anyone who enters a contest needs to
understand that music

contest, such as conquering your stage
fright, as motivation for working on your
technique, or learning a cool new tune,

have three main thoughts about my
Clifftop judging experience. Two concern
the rules, and thus should be directed to
the contest sponsors (the West Virginia
Division of Culture and History) I suggest
I

sheet of "Considerations for Judges" di
rected to them in the form of recommenda
a

tions to be heeded. In general, the Clifftop
judging is the fairest I've seen in providing

whereby traditional fiddling is
encouraged through official policy.
Along with standard judging catego
a

forum
1

ries (tone, difficulty, etc.) there should be

a

category that represents "feeling," "emo
tion," or some such classification that

�portrays a "gut level" feeling portrayed in
the contestants performance.
2.

Since judging is such

a

subjective pro

cess, judges should be required to confer
throughout the contest. When judging and

rating 50 fiddlers, for instance, if two of
three judges are conservative in their dif

ferentiation of contestant's performances,
is more extravagant, that one judge
essentially picks the winners. This could be
held in check if judges conferred and essen

but one

tially were in agreement (or at least "in the
regarding contestant's scores.
Basic standards immediately result against

ballpark")

which subsequent contestants can be mea
sured. Without these consistent reality
checks and an understanding among
judges, winners can be anybody's guess.
3. If any contest is going to last, the
contestants themselves should not take

themselves too seriously. Sadly, even

at

Clifftop, people have dressed down the
people in charge for in some way being
responsible for them not winning. I know
that the people in charge go to great lengths
to

keep things fair.

Bruce Molsky, Virginia (full contest, 1992):

My Long Weekend Sitting Down at Clifftop
to be a judge at Clifftop right
I was asked
around the time its popularity really began
to skyrocket. I think everyone was sur
prised by the number of contestants that
year, and neither of the other judges (Brad

Leftwich and Jon Blisard) nor I had any
idea how exhausting it would be to judge
all the contests. In subsequent years the
responsibilities were spread between two
sets of judges.
It was cold on Saturday night, too; no, it
was freezing. The band contest didn't end
until around 2:00 am, several hours later

than

scheduled. We had very few breaks

and missed most of the partying. During
one of the scheduled breaks Brad and I

bolted in frustration to his campsite, played
three or four hasty tunes, wolfed a couple
of

sandwiches, guzzled

beverages and ran back

a

I

enjoyed the intensity of it.
Clifftop is vastly different from other
contests I've been to because it is clearly not
a regional contest. It's unique virtue is how
it celebrates the whole big wonderful mod
ern traditional music community. It's hard
not to feel that camaraderie in the contest,
and throughout the whole festival. think
that much of the excitement about Clifftop

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is intended to
traditional American

string music styles.
The challenge with respect to judging
such a broad contest is keeping personal

stylistic preferences out of the process. I'm
not sure if I succeeded in maintaining that
level of objectivity when I was a judge, but
I sure as hell tried and was
painfully aware
of it the entire time. I decided to listen more
for technical and artistic competence and
creativity, and to focus less on regional and
other defining characteristics. This was the
most difficult when Melvin Wine and Mike
Bryant tied for first place in the fiddle con
test.
think we all wanted to crawl under

happened!
benefits of including so many
styles (and perhaps age groups) outweigh
the complications of trying to judge them
all in the same contest, because it has really
helped to tear down some walls that sorely
need tearing down. For myself, probably
wouldn't have come to appreciate
midwestern fiddling if hadn't met Jeff
But the

was honored to have been asked and really

I

of all

the table when that

stage to get

complaining.

inclusive

I

couple of malt

to the

back to work. But I'm not

has been because the contest
be

I

I

Seitz and Chirps Smith and some of the
other folks who have come east to partici
pate. Judging and participating was
and

a

great

my mind

opened
learning experience,
(and repertoire) to some great music
it

I

hadn't

noticed before. Plus I've had so much more
for other

compassion

judges since being

one myself.

Molly Tenenbaum, Washington (fiddleand
banjo, 1997):
had never actually listened to a whole
I

contest before, and

I

think

I

learned

a

lot

from hearing so many players. Of 95 fid
dlers in a row, some really do stand out as

better than others.

I

was glad to know that

the whole contest premise, then, wasn't as

specious

as

I'd

thought. However,

since

lots of players in lots of styles are really
good, picking the top five and ordering

them seemed

a little silly.
However, it's
what we do here in the old-time world, so

did it seriously, hoping everyone would
know that not winning is not the same as
not being good. Not winning doesn't even
I

mean that you aren't good enough to win.
was pleased to see that the people who
I

did win felt happy and proud, and perhaps
got some boosts to self-confidence, and

I

hope that the people who did not win did

not feel hurt, and did not lose self-confi
dence. It seemed clear that much about the

winning performances

depended

on

chance, on how nervous the performers
(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

got, on how sure a sound they managed to
start out with, on how comfortable they

were with their own playing, and on how
far they have come in defining their own
styles.
ing

an

I

had

to

remember that

individual

I

was judg

performance, not

a

person's playing
general: heard many
whose
music
I love, but
they made
players
a few mistakes, or didn't
play as well as
in

I

they really play in the campground
give it as many points perhaps, but
just as much.

I

didn't

I

love

it

believe that all of us, experts and begin
ners, players and listeners, are a current
part of what will be our music's history,
but it felt frightening to actually commit
my part of that history to the record.
I

Still,

I

was happy to take

a

turn

think

I

the contest, Clifftop anyway, works best
when everyone takes a turn, and since we
are all part of old-time music, we should all
take turns.

I

would do

it

again, with

a

little

rest and recovery.

It was difficult to listen to the
beginners
who didn't have the mechanics of playing
down yet. I had to remind myself that there
are many reasons to enter a contest, and

Bobby Taylor, West Virginia (fiddler and
contest coordinator of the Appalachian

winning often isn't the main one. But
didn't like having to score such players

the festival better for the

I

all, beginners aren't bad players,
they're just players who will probably be
wonderful sooner than we think. It felt
after

to give such people low scores. It
was also difficult to hear people play tunes
that were too hard for them, or tunes that
didn't suit their style. I got so I was dying to

wrong

people play tunes they loved and
could play comfortably at their own high
est level. If I ever enter a contest again,
hear

that's what I'm going to do I'm not going
worry about what might please some
one, but I'll do what pleases me and hope
that some of that feeling gets across.
to

was painful to listen carefully and
critically to so many fiddlers and banjoists
in a row. Also, it was extremely painful to
sort the top five into order. However, I
know that as an audience member, I have
It

loved hearing the finals it's a wonderful
evening of listening, and every tune has an
edge of excitement. So I felt responsible to
who were
the audience, and the players
music
and
soul out
all
their
really putting
to do the best job I could.
The biggest treat of judging was

there

String Band festival/competition):
We are always looking for ways to make

implemented many of the suggestions.
I have
already redesigned the judges'

sheet to cover more aspects of old-time
music. It will give the judges extra avenues
to evaluate the soul and spirit of the perfor

mance. While it is true some technical evalu
ations have to be made in order to call it a

contest, the feeling and expression is a
large part of old-time music. In either case,
my goal is to make

hearing
I

hadn't heard or heard of before. I gained a
stronger sense of the range and strength of
all old-time music. It was a pleasure to

1

998 better than ever for

the judges as well as the contestants.
The early years of the festival were rough
on the

the

judges. They had to sit through

all

competitions. We now have two sets
for the

of

four musical

categories.
judges
made
the
festival
more
this
has
Hopefully,
for
the
We
want
every
enjoyable
judges.
one to feel at home, share the music, and
benefit from their visit. After all, we are
trying

to

preserve all the old-time music styles
younger musicians.

and pass them on to

was difficult to obtain the judges for
997 festival. This is a very hard job, but
is very important to have musicians who
It

the
it

so many fine players, especially the ones

wonderful people

who attend. We have gotten a lot of good
advice down through the years and have

are

1

respected

in the

old-time community.

years past the judges have strived above
and beyond the call of duty to be fair.
In

Because

of their

and

accomplishments

standing among old-time musicians,

it

has

have the chance to recognize great music,
though I'm sorry we couldn't recognize it
all. I also remembered (vaguely, and prob
ably inaccurately) the stories I'd heard about

meant a great deal to the winners of the
competitions. It is always great to win, but
it is not everything. The judges would be
the first to say that they would like to have

how
when they showed up everyone else knew
it was all over, or how no one had heard of

20 in the top 5

great fiddlers of the past in contests

them until they appeared at a contest, and
felt powerfully that contests are
then.
a continuing strand of old-time music his
I

tory, and felt a little confused to know it
was only me sitting there in judges' booth.

places.
have judged many contests down
through the years. I always felt it was my
duty to accept when possible. This is one of
the ways to contribute to the performance
of old-time music. I think it is important to
remember that there is always a good rea
son one is asked to judge.
I

�When judging I try to follow the guide
lines set by the particular contest, being as
fair as

possible.

In

judging the larger con

try to keep room at the top for the
finalists. To get into this section at the top, a

tests,

I

look forward to sharing

Like

nity

everyone who has judged,

it is

diffi

cult to evaluate special friends who have
entered the contest, but these circumstances

have to be put behind you. I will say these
situations seem to be a bigger problem at
small hometown contests. I would much
rather judge a larger contest for this reason.

have always put myself through the or
deal of judging because I felt contest events
were a necessary venue for the survival of
I

nlH-Hmp mnsir.
in

nothing

any festival,

there seems to be

set in stone. With

highly educated

fans and folklorists in attendance there will

always be ways to improve this event. We
are well aware that there will be changes as
the festival grows. We welcome sugges
tions from everyone and will constantly strive
refine the gathering

in

years

to

come.

Many thanks to all those wonderful
people in the old-time music community
who have enabled us to keep the festival
alive and well.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

child of the revival and
banjo, lives in Seattle, where

Molly Tenenbaum,
pretender

to

great old-time

I

contestant has to meet all the requirements
and excel in all areas on the judging format.

As

a

tune and visiting with everyone at the 1998
Appalachian String Band Music Festival.

she teaches

to the

writing

College,

and

a

at

North Seattle Commu

plays

music

with

Peter

Langston and with the Queen City Bulldogs.

�Music:

Old-Time

Our Down Under Experience
Shupe

by Greg

and boomerangs. Dulcimers

didgeridoos. Two years ago
not have convinced us
could
you
that the words "old-time music"
and

Banjos

and "Australia"

could logically appear
It is our good fortune

the same sentence.

in

recording session
This

Under: the 8th Annual Harrietville (Aus)
Bluegrass and Old Timey Music Conven

Wellington (NZ) Folk Festival.
Both festivals were incredibly rewarding
in terms of the caliber and appreciation of
tion and the

music, the friendliness of the people, and
the beauty of the surroundings.

Mon

day, October 14 to give us three days to
convert our body clocks to Australia time
before driving up to the festival. We were
hosted by Nick and Janet Dear and their
two sons at their bed and breakfast in

is a

"in 1936" or

whenever.

knowledgeable crowd.

Also playing

Wakefield,

a

U.S.

kid

particularly liked "Who Broke the Lock

Henhouse Door." Each

bluegrass mandolin

ducted

at

player known for his work with Red Allen
early 1960s. It was a treat for both
Frank and the other musicians to share our
love of this music for four days. Two other
string bands also performed. The Mighty
Fine String Band plays terrific music in the
style of the southern mountains (Rod and
Judy Jones have been coming to festivals in
the States for almost 20 years). Head Belly
Buzzard, on the other hand, played twin
different feel, a driving
that
was a revelation to
trance-like rhythm
to.
listen
a

s

to

on the

in the

fiddle tunes with

"sunny" western songs and old
Baptist hymns. All were well received dur
ing our five on-stage performances. The

songs

was Frank

the festival

at

Our band played a variety of styles of
music, from fiddle tunes and Appalachian

of us

con

least one workshop on our re

spective instruments (fiddle,

autoharp,

banjo, and guitar).

Old-time, bluegrass,
went on every night. I
singers there can wail
without an Australian

and singing jams
can report that the
with the best and

accent. Selections

ranged from old country standards and the

songs of legendary Australian country
singer Slim Dusty to songs of mining (gold

It was a bit disconcert
much American music in that

and coal) and love.

ing

to hear so

setting without the accompanying local
folk songs. However, when we asked, we

kilometers from the
one of the finest fiddle and

Blackwood, some
airport. Nick is

remark on the performers in the original

to

have been able to see for ourselves.
In October the West Virginia String Band
was invited to play at two festivals Down

The band arrived in Melbourne on

very familiar with string-band tunes and
country music songs, so much that
after playing a song one of the locals might
old

80

mandolin players in the country and it was
joy to spend several days playing music

a

there. After

a

six hour drive on

we arrived in Harrietville,

a

Thursday

small ski resort

Alps. Since October is
the only snow was on
there,
early spring
the surrounding mountain tops. We were
treated instead to a wondrous array of
flowers and nesting birds.
There are not a lot of old-time and bluein

the Australian

and many of
grass musicians in Australia
them (about 250) came to the four-day gath
ering. In addition to Nick and Janet Dear,

oriented

to

bluegrass,

a

lot of

people were

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Greg

ally non-stop until Monday morning.
While most of the musicians were more

Shupe

the other organizers, Rod and Judy Jones,
arrived from Sydney on Thursday night.
The music started then and continued liter

�were treated to some beautiful songs from
Australian experience. We found that
there is a revival of interest in local songs.
the

was given some
interesting field recordings made by one of
the musicians at the festival.
Our fiddler, Joe Dobbs,

The

following weekend found

us at

a

small Scout Camp in Wainuiomata, about

minutes drive from downtown
Wellington, New Zealand As in Harrietville,
the setting was beautiful, the people gre
20

garious, and the musicianship top notch.
a "folk" festival the
range of
music was diverse with more expressed
interest in traditional music, especially from
the British Isles as well as from New
Zealand. I expressed an interest in local
folk tunes and was deluged with informa
Since this was

tion, tapes, and songs (with more arriving
here in the States every few weeks). Songs
both old and new focused on themes

rang

ing from the whaling and sealing trades,
gold mining, and sheep farming to the
railroads, gum industry, and more.
There were terrific performances by Mike

banjo for over 20 years. He now lives

Pocatello, Idaho,

as

in

does Sallie Sublette,

Harding, Gumboot Tango (a totally New
Zealand experience almost impossible to
describe), Roger Lusby, the Jimmy Cook

well-known performer

at

the East and the West.

I

Band, Roger Giles, and many others. Once
again we were not the only Yanks there.

coal fields of southern West Virginia, learn
ing country, old-time, and coal mining

Winnie Winston (who has performed with
Bill Monroe, David Grisman, and Jody
Stecher) now lives in New Zealand and
added his music to the festival mix. He

conducted

a

workshop

on

frailing banjo.

Other workshops included Appalachian
dulcimer, harp, Irish step dancing, Morris
dancing, and singing. The participants were

who grew up in West Virginia.

She is

festivals both

a

in

was raised in the

songs along the way.
We plan to get back to Australia and
New Zealand at the very first opportunity.
We highly recommend the experience to
any of the adventurous out there.
For more information
about the
Harrietville Festival contact: Nickand Tanet

Dear, PO Box 61, Trentham, Victoria 3458,
Australia, or Rod and Judy Jones, PO Box
76, Berowra Heights, Sydney, NSW, 2082
Australia, email jrjones@tig.com.au. To
learn more about the New Zealand scene
contact: New Zealand Folk Foundation,
Inc. PO Box 9504,

Wellington NZ.

Greg Shupe is a musician who grew up in West
Virginia. He plays with the West Virginia
String Band and with Doris Justis and Dennis

Diamond. He makes his home

in the

Baltimore-

Washington area where he works in the Dept. of

Social Sendees.

extremely receptive to our band's tradi

tional and not-so-traditional music, join

ing in heartily in the concerts, jams, and the

Saturday night singaround.
With only a few days to spend in this
beautiful country we left Wellington much
too soon to allow time to tour the South
Island. However, we did get to visit and
play music with several of the people we
met

at

the festival.

Our band, the West Virginia String Band,

features

Dobbs

Joe

(fiddle),

Rick

McCracken(banjo), Sallie Sublette (autoharp
and guitar), and me (guitar). All of us have

roots in the mountains and in the musical
heritage of the Appalachians. Joe has been

performing
festivals for

at

old-time, bluegrass, and folk

years. Since 1 983 he has also
from the Mountains," a
on
West Virginia Public Ra
show
weekly
dio. Rick McCracken hails from Pennsyl
vania and has been playing clawhammer

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Shupe

"Music

Greg

hosted

25

One of the fiddle workshops with ]oe Dobbs.

�Ron Hughey—
by

Some Memories

Hank Bradley

with Ron

acquaintance

My

Hughey
enough,
returned

random

was

I

guess.
to

I

had just

California

in

August 1965, fresh out of two Army years
at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, and fresh
into two more years at Fresno State. From
North Carolina I was addicted beyond all

reason to the joys of old-time and bluegrass
music all jumbled into a continuous cloud,
and at first Fresno seemed a dead end.
Music in the engineering department? But
slowly out of the academic murk crept one
banjo player, a couple of guitarists, and the

news of a concert by the Sweets Mill Moun
tain Boys. Good name, but did they work in
a Sierra candy factory or play music?

They could play. They turned out to be

such time as he needed to go up the neck for
the high notes. Then the first came out of
the pegbox and worked like anyone else's.
complete our visual joys, the fiddle
never quite made it up under his chin, but

To

cruised casually up or down his shirt front,
turning from side to side under the bow to
spare the bow arm needless work when
crossing strings. We judged him happy
when the cigar tilted up to the latitude of
his nose.

Their repertoire was fiddle tunes. Con
tra dances not having been invented yet in
Fresno, we came to listen and marvel sit
ting down, and the music was electrifying.

The repertoire covered a wide cross sec
tion of geography, and another horizon
equally wide of time. They gave us old

breakdowns common

all over the South

romantic purists who didn't
(heaven
know the whole universe of American
fiddle music, but knew what we liked), and
for us

Midwestern hornpipe tunes, and wonder
ful crooked archaic tunes that had remain
ders when divided by 32. And waltzes, and
blues, and since Ron had left his inquisitive
ears open through the '30s and '40s, an
assortment of rags and swing tunes. Not
everyone reacted so well to these. Even
Pete was heard

announcing that since Ron
Geor

and Frank were about to play "Sweet

gia Brown," he would now disappear be
hind the curtain and brood. But Ron and

sufficient adventure and
energy that the rest of us just rode the
wave, dropped the complaint against

Frank provided

Frank Hicks on Gibson Super 400 guitar, a
railroad engineer and alumnus of the Spade

Coulee Orchestra,

making

astonishing

chords and bass runs. On three-finger banjo,
Dr. Peter Everwine of the English Depart
ment, whose explanation for taking up such
music was that once in Cincinnati he saw a

bluegrass band whose banjoist had lightening-bolt loafers, and if a banjo gave li
cense to wear such items, it was for him.
The fiddler was Ron Hughey, a big tall guy
with a grin and a cigar and end-to-end
strokes of the bow, who didn't need to
a

microphone

to be

heard
Byxbe

cling too close to
all over the hall.

obviously learned to play dances
before microphones were invented, and

Weill

He had

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

battered regularly in his metal and weld
ing work. But having plenty of spare length
in the others, he generally parked the first
in the pegbox and played with three, until

Rita

leaned into the music like he meant it. On
his left hand, the first finger was a bit stiff,

L-R Front: Ron

Back row: Jack

Hughey-fiddle, Hank Bradley-fiddle, Kenny Hall-mandolin, Frank Hicks-guitar,
Link-lmnjo, Larry Hanks-jews harp. Szveet's Mill August 1966.

�insufficient archaism, and later snuckoff to
try and figure out how to do it ourselves.
After the concert, Frank introduced me
I asked
if he ever played "Rye
Straw." He did, but apologized that he
didn't play it like anyone else, and in fact
had never heard two fiddlers play it alike.

to Ron, and

and I likewise, and sure
were
different, but plenty close
enough they
He played

enough

it,

to start

He had

a

friendship.

welding shop in Fowler, and a
loose enough schedule that visitors could
a

barge in and have a few tunes. This was
considerably more fun than puzzling over
the proper hookup of

unconfined

a

compression

wattmeter,

or the

of dirt. Born in

1914, he had come to Fresno from South

Greenfield, Missouri, where he was raised
in a musical family, his father a dance
caller, starting the fiddle when he was seven.
By his repertoire, he must have served a

apprenticeship playing Ozark country
dances before moving west. Finding Californians to be of all regions and tastes
full

Weill
Rita

wife Clara through the Sierra foothills, stop
at roadside restaurants here and there
to play up a few beers where everybody

Byxbe

mushed together, he added whatever was
necessary to keep the dancers moving and
entertained. A warm and genial fellow usu
ally (he did have a temper), he was widely
popular, as I saw on trips with him and his

knew them.
When I had enough of his repertoire, he
invited me to help play the old-timers'
dance in Fresno. They had to waive the rule
that no one under age 35 was allowed in.
Supported by a formidable piano player
(shame on me for forgetting her name), we

played the full spectrum: waltzes, squares,

two-steps,

polkas,

schottisches,

the

varsouvienne, the rye waltz, any number
of

swings and of course "Silver Bells" on

twin fiddles.

It was a very lively crowd,
date
complained afterward of
though my
the effort it took not to move her hips too
much for "that generation."

courtesy

ping

This drawing of -Ron Hughey by Earl Hollander first appeared in
Patty Hall's book about Sweet's
Mill, At the Mill (see OTH vol. no). The dedication under the drawing read "This book is dedicated

memory of Ron Hughey—
fine friend and memorable fiddler who helped forge that Sweet's Mill
which
we
all
share
spirit
today.
to the

in

his Western Stars, Bill Thompson and the

Ozark Mountain Boys, Sons of the Golden
West, and The Rangers. He was also cut
ting quite a swath through the fiddle con

tests, being easily one of the more powerful
hoedown fiddlers in the West, and having
some special tunes in the arsenal too. "Yel
low Gals" of course was the killer, part of
his family
him.

repertoire.

The crowds loved

He had a long history of western gigs,
evidenced by a fine long resume of band
names: the Arkansas Ramblers, the Texas

a lively interest in learn
new
(well, additional) tunes, and in our
ing
visits there was much swapping. It turned

Cowboys, the Air Riders, Bud Davis and

out that we were both busily stealing every

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

He maintained

tune off the first County Records reissues
(501 and 503! Long live Dave Freeman!),
and after playing through "Sally in the
Gardens" Ron remarked how furious Dad
Crockett had been at the assumption that
some record company was making a for

tune by re-releasing his old 78s. Dad
Crockett? Crockett's Mountaineers? Yes,
he, too had moved to Fresno (was it his
sons who recorded the nifty "Fresno Blues"
as a guitar duet?), and Ron had known him
well. From Dad Crockett, Ron learned
"Dubuque," and he madegood improvements
(continued on page 56)

�Festival

Guide 1998!

soon going to be that time of year again! Here are some vacation and weekend ideas for 1998. Bear in mind that some competitions require preBe sure and check to clarify that and other details before you plan a vacation around an event. Certain events may include some old-time
registration.
It's
music, but it may be a small component. If you are not familiar with the event, again, it would be a good idea to check before planning a vacation or a
trip. The OTH is not responsible for changes in scheduling or for cancellations.
Codes: wab (wheelchair accessible buildings); hp (handicap parking); arn (advance registration necessary); afr (no charge to competitors, admission
fee, or a portion, refunded to competitors). If information is not listed it was not available.
We send out a festival form each year to be filled out and returned to us. Be sure and keep us updated on any changes of address or contact persons.
If we missed
you this year, or if someone out there knows of an event and would like to have it published in the Guide next year, be sure and send us your
their name and address as soon as possible. We will send out a form in time for next year's Guide.
Have fun!

ALABAMA

Ozark Folk Center contact Elliott Hancock, PO
Box 500, Mountain View 72560 (870)269-3851,

Mar. 21 (Dothan)

Spring Farm Day Old-Time Fiddlers Conven
tion-Landmark Park; competition (afr), work

shops, concerts, jamming, farm demonstrations.
Rhonda Johnston, Landmark Park, PO Box 6362,
Dothan 36302 (334)79^3452.
Aug. 21-23 (Mentone)

Birmingham Country Dance Society Old-Time
Music &amp; Dance Weekend; camping; concerts,
dance, jamming. Diann Weatherly, 1452 Milner
Crescent, Birmingham 35205 (205)939-0120;

dweather@uab.edu
ARIZONA
Mar. 19-22 (Scottsdale)
US West National Festival

of the West;

camp
ing; workshops, concert, jamming, competition,
children's

events.

PO

Box

12966, Scottsdale

85267 (602)996-4387.

ARKANSAS
Jan. 10-Dec. 6 (Mountain View)
Ozark Folk Center; wab; hp. Note:

There are

events throughout the year at the Ozark Folk
Center in Mountain View. These include:
Apr. 3-4-Fiddle Fest; concerts, jamming.
Apr. 17-19-36th Annual Arkansas Folk Festival.
Apr. 23-26-21st Anniversary Dulcimer Jambo
ree;

competition, workshops.

May 8-9- Ballad Singing Weekend
May 22-23-Tribute

to

Merle Travis; concerts jam

fax 269-2909;

www.ozarkfolkcenter.com.

CALIFORNIA
Apr. 25-26 (San Diego)
San

&amp;

Hawley; free; wab; con

certs, workshops, dance, jamming, children's
events. Lou Curtiss, 3611 Adams Ave., San Di
ego 92116 (619)282-7833, or Scott (619)282-7329.
May

3

(La Grange)

Grange Fiddle and Banjo Contest-overnight
camping; wab; hp; competition (afr), children's
events, open stage. Christine Stevenson, PO Box
130, La Grange 95329-0130 (209)853-2128.
La

Oct. 9-10-25th annual fiddle and Dance Jambo

ree; dance, concerts.
Nov. 13-1 4-3rd Annual Cowboy Gathering; con

certs
NOTE: For

a

complete calendar

of

events

at tire

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Silverton Jubilee Folk Music Festival-camp
ing; wab; hp; concerts, workshops, dance, jam
ming, crafts. Jane Legge, PO Box 185, Silverton
81433 (970)387-5737.

FLORIDA

jamming.

June 19-21 (Santa Barbara)
Live Oak Music Festival-Live Oak Camp; wab;
hp; camping; concerts, dance, children's events,
jamming. KCBX Public Radio, 41 00 Vachell Lane,

Youth Ranch; wab; hp; camping;

San Luis Obispo 93401

781-3025;

hp;

con

(805)473-2440 (fax 805-

http://www.kcbx.org/liveoak.

July 31-Aug. 8 (Mendocino)
Lark In the Morning Music

ing;

competition, concerts, children's events,

Jim Strickland, 1848 Thistle Ct., Wesley
Chapel 33543 (813)991-4774.
Apr. 10-11 (Dade City)
9th Annual Will McLean FolkFestival-Sertoma

storytellers,
singers, poets, songwriting contest. Margaret
Longhill (352)465-7208; mlonghill@aol.com.
May 2-3 (St. Augustine)

Celebration-

Mendocino Woodlands; camping; workshops;
hp; concerts, dance, children's events, jamming.

Aug. 9-14 (Petaluma)
Klezkamp West: The Yiddish

Championships.

COLORADO
June 26-28 (Silverton)

ming, open stage, crafts. S.F. Folk Music Club,
885 Clayton St., San Francisco 94117.

San Francisco Free Folk Festival-wab;

shops.

Aug. 10-13-Hammered Dulcimer Workshops.
Sept. 25-26-Arkansas State Old-Time Fiddle

4010.

cert, workshops, dance, children's events, jam

(San Francisco)

Mickie Zekley, PO Box 1176, Mendocino 95460
(707)964-5569 larkinam@larkinam.com;
http://

workshops, con

(afr). Barbara Martin, Manager,
Area
Chamber
of Commerce, 201 S. Broad
Blythe
way, Blythe 92225 (800)443-5513 fax (760)922-

Apr. 3-4 (Dade City)
17th Annual Florida Old Time Music Championship-Sertoma Youth Ranch; wab; hp; camp

June (mid)

sessions, seminars, competition.
June 1-4-Intermediate Autoliarp Workshops.
June 8-11-Advanced Level Autoharp Work
Aug. 6-8-Autoharp Jamboree;
certs.

River Country Music
Festival; Colorado River Country Fairgrounds;
camping; hp; wab workshops, concertsd, dance,

competition

Diego Adams Ave. Roots Festival- Adams

Ave. between 35th

Jan. 16-18 (Blythe)
11th Annual Colorado

www.larkinam.com.

3rd

Annual Gamble Rogers Folk Festival-St.

Augustine Amphitheater; wab; hp; camping (at
Anastasia State Park); concerts, workshops,
dance, jamming demonstrations, guitar compe
tition.
Jim
Springfield (904)794-0222;
StoryBuff@aol.com.
Oct. 9-11 (St. Petersburg)

Folkarts Pro

Sunshine

State

gram-Walker Creek Ranch; hp; wab; workshops,

Hill Park,

wab; hp; camping; arn by Sept. 30;

concerts,

children's

dance, jamming,
430 W.

14th

St

events.

#514, NYC

Henry Sapoznik,
10014 (212)691-1272; livetrads@aol.com.

Old-Time

workshops, concerts, jamming, open stage,
children's events; Charley Groth, PO Box 668,
Crystal Beach 34681 (813)784-1771.
Oct. 16-18

Oct. 11 (Goleta)
27th Annual

Fiddlers Convention-

Stow House; camping; wab; concerts, competi
tion, Hilda Wenner, 967 Garcia Rd., Santa Bar
bara CA 93103 (805)966-1191.

Acoustic Music Camp-Boyd

(Gainesville)

Florida State Fiddlers Convention-Camp Crys
tal; camping; hp; workshops, concerts, dances,
jamming, band competition. Entry fee for band
is one pie. Dave Borland (850)627-7030 or Dea

�Browning (352)495-2243; dea@afn.org;

PO Box

713, Micanopy, FL 32677.

Nov.

7-8

(Barberville)

Barberville Jamboree-camping;

workshops,

concerts, dance, jamming. Jon Milner,
668, Crystal Beach 34681 (813)784-1771.
GEORGIA

PO Box

Apr. 18-19 (Dahlonega)
Bear on the Square

Mountain Festival-Town

Square; hp; wab; workshops, concerts, dance,
jamming, children's events. Glenda or Nick
Pender, PO Box 338, Dahlonega

30533 (706)864-

7817.

July 10-12 (Helen)
Unicoi Folk Life Festival-Unicoi

State

3984).
Sept. 12 (Blairsville)
Moun tain Music Festival-VogelState Park; wab;

camping (reservations

required), concerts,

dance, jamming. David Foot, Mgr. Vogel State
Park, 7485 Vogel St. Pk. Rd., Blairsville 30512

(706)745-2628; vogel@yhc.edu.
IDAHO

U of C

jam

sessions,

National Oldtime Fiddlers Contest-WeiserHigh
E.

Idaho, Weiser

ILLINOIS
Feb. 6-8 (Chicago)
37th Annual University of Chicago Folk Festival-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

State Park; wab; hp; camping; concerts, work
shops, crafts. J. P. Fraley'sMtn. Music Gatherin',
Carter Caves State Park, 344 Caveland Dr., Olive
Hill

41164(606)286-4411.

May 28-31

ing Contest- wab; hp; workshops, concerts, dance

Seedtime

jamming, competition (arn
stage. Judy Leschewski, Box
(217)428-2403.

Mountain

by May 15), open
471 4, Decatur 62525

Aug. 8-9 (Stockton)

Willow Folk Music Festival-camping; concerts,
jamming; all who perform on church stage
admited free. Judith &amp; Stewart Schlafer, 6250 S.
Willow Rd., Stockton 61085 (815)947-3648.

INDIANA
June 26-28

(Battle Ground)

26th Annual Indiana Fiddlers Gathering-wab;

(Whitesburg)

the Cumberland, Festival of
Arts-Appalshop; camping at Carr

On

Fork Lake; wab; concert, dance, jamming, open
stage. Jim Branson, 306 Madison St., Whitesburg

41858 (606)633-0108.
June 7-13 (Hindman)
21st Annual Appalachian Family Folk WeekHindman Settlement School; hp; wab; work

shops, concerts, dance, open stage, children's
events. Mike Muffins, Box 844, Hindman 41822
(606)785-5475.
July 17-18 (Leitclifield)
Ky. State Championship

hp;

Official

Walnut Valley Festival &amp; National
Flatpicking Championships-Cowley County

Resort Park; hp; wab; camping; competition,
children's events, open stage. Brent L. Miller, PO
box 4042, Leitclifield 42755 (502)259-3578.
Sept. 8-13 (Olive Hill)
J. P. Fraley's Mountain Music Gatherin'-Carter
Caves State Park; wab; hp; camping; concerts,

camping; concerts, workshops, dance, jam
ming, open stage, children's events. Kirk
Hallman, PO Box 49 Battle Ground 47920
(765)742-1419.
KANSAS
Sept. 17-20 (Winfield)
27th

compeh hon (am
concerts, dance,
jamming, children's events, open stage. Walnut
Valley Assoc., PO Box 245, Winfield 67156
(316)221-3250.
KENTUCKY
1

8

workshops,

Folklore Society, Box 67 Faculty
Exchange, Chicago 60637 (773)702-7300/9793.
May 22-25 (Decatur)
World Championship Old-Time Piano Play

Fairgrounds; wab;

June 22-27 (Weiser)
School gym. Layna Hafer,
83672 (208)549-0450.

Flail; concerts,

dances.

Park;

camping; hp; wab; concerts, dance, instrument
displays. Ellen McConnell, Unicoi State Park, Po
Box 997, Helen 30545 (706)878-3983 (fax 706-878-

hp;

Mandel

hp; camping;
hr. before contest); workshops,

Old-Time
Fiddlers Contest, Inc.-Rough River Dam State

workshops, open stage, jamming.

J.

P.

Fraley's

Mtn. Music Gatherin', Carter Caves State Park,
344 Caveland Dr., Olive Hill 41164 (606)286-

4411.

Sept. 18-20 (Ashland)
Poage Landing Days Festival/Ed

Haley Fiddle

(continued

on next page)

March 13-14 (Olive Hill)

Mountain

Memories

Weekend-Carter

Caves

�C,
ome

week
John

JOHN

spend

with

C.

a

us

at

Campbell

the
Folk

C

p\MPBFIl

School

...on a 372-acre farm in the mountains of North
Carolina. Discover our friendly community, our school's
fascinating 73-year history, our rich local music, dance
and craft traditions. Classes offered year-round.

^Hj

^B

^Hj

DANCE CALLING DANCE MUSICIANSHIP
BASKETRY AUTOHARP BLACKSMITHING
WEAVING BANJO WRITING PHOTOGRAPHY
CALLIGRAPHY
MT. DULCIMER
NATURE STUDIES
PRINTMAKING
CLAY
KALEIDOSCOPES
AUTOHARP
WOODCARVING BOOKBINDING
GUITAR
WOODWORKING
SPINNING
QUILTING
HAMMERED DULCIMER
STORYTELLING
FELTING BROOM MAKING
ENAMELING
and much, much more
Call for a complete catalog

1-800-F0LK-SCH
1

-800-365-5724)

Grove

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

BE

B

I
I

flj
Bj

B

H

S
S

Bl

B

fijj

|B

S

H
flj

I

B

�Festival-camping;

competition,

children's

events. Ashland Area CVB, PO Box 987, Ashland
41105 (606)329-1007/(800)377-6249.
Oct. 23-25 (Berea)
Celebration of Traditional Music-Berea

Col

lege Campus; wab; hp; workshops, concerts,
dance, jamming, open stage. Gordon McKinney,
Appalachian Center, CPO 2336, Berea College,
Berea 40404-2336 (606)986-9341 ext. 5140.

LOUISIANA
Sept. 4-5 (Plaisance)
Original Southwest Louisiana Zydeco Music
Festival-camping; hp; wab; workshops, concerts,
dance, jamming, children's events, open stage,
folklife presentations. Southern Development

Opelousas 70570 (318)942-

Fdn., 361 Sandoz,

2392.
Feb. 22 (Lafayette)

Cajun French-Music Assoc. Children's Music
Festival-Vermilionville Historic Bayou Attrac
tion;

wab;

hp;

workshops,

concerts,

dance,

children's events. Lisa Landry, Vermilionville,
1600 Surrey St., Lafayette
70508 (800)99BAYOU/ (318)233-4077.

MAINE

July 17-19 (Marquette)
Hiawatha Traditional MusicFestival-camping;
hp; wab; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,
children's events. Hiawatha Music Co-op, Po
Box 414, Marquette 49855 (906)226-8575.
Sept. 11-13 (Remus)
Wheatland Traditional Music Festival-camp
ing; hp; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,
children's events, open stage. Advance tickets
only. Lola Tyler, PO Box 22, Remus 49340
(517)967-8879.

MINNESOTA
July 31-Aug.

3037.

MISSISSIPPI
April 25 (Kosciusko)
Natchez Trace Festival- wab; hp; concerts, com
petition, children's events, open stage. Willa
Sanders, PO Box 696, Kosciusko 39090 (601)2892981.

MISSOURI

Convention-

competition, concerts. Shirley A. Littlefield, PO
Box 215, Clinton 04927-0215 (207)453-2017.

MASSACHUSETTS
Apr. 24-26 (Natick)
54th New England

Folk Festival-Natick High
workshops, dance,

School; wab; hp; concerts,

children's events, jamming, story telling, crafts.
NEFFA, 1950 Mass Ave, Cambridge 02140-2102
(617)354-1340

fax:

(617)354-3142;

pearl@sw.stratus.com;

http://www.neffa.org/neffa/.
July 25-Aug. 1 (Plymouth)
Folk Music Week-Pinewoods

Camp;

work

shops, dance, concerts, jamming. Steve Howe,
CDSS, Po Box 338, Haydenville 01039 (413)2687426; camp@cdss.org.

Sept.

5

(Zimmerman)

events, jamming, open stage. Jed Malischke, PO
Box 607, Spooner 54801(715)635-2479/ (800)635-

July 26 (East Benton, Waterville)
26th Annual East Benton Fiddle

2

Minnesota Bluegrass &amp; Old-Time Music
Festival-Camp in the Woods Resort; hp; camp
ing; workshops, concerts, dance, children's

(Blandford)

Blandford Fair Old Time Fiddlers Con test- wab;
hp; competition. Chris Keenan, PO Box 3,
Blandford 01008 (413)848-2177.
Jan. 15-17, 1999 (Durham)
12th Ralph Page Legacy Weekend-Univ. ofNH;
hp; wab; workshops, dance, jamming, open stage,
discussion groups. NEFFA, 1950 Mass. Ave.,

From June through October there are Fiddle
Contests in Missouri. For information on these
events contact the Missouri State Old Time Fid
dlers Assoc. for their fiddle contest calendar.
MSOTFA, PO Box 7423, Columbia 65205.
June 26-27 (Lawrenceburg)

Fiddlers

Snyder's

&amp;

Jam

Fiddle

Contest-

Snyder's Park; competition, jamming, clogging.
Virginia Snyder, 1347 E. Broadmoor, Spring

field 65804 (417)882-6621
(417)862-9034.

Retha

or

Etliridge

Dec. 18-19 (Lawrenceburg)
Old Time

Fiddlers Jam

&amp;

Contest-Snyder's

Music Park; hp; wab; workshops, dance, jam
ming, competition (am by July 19), children's

events, open stage. Virginia Snyder, 1347
Broadmoor, Springfield 65804 (417)882-6621.

E.

MONTANA

June 6-11 (Elliston)
3rd

Annual Montana

Fiddler's Assoc. Fiddle

Camp-camping; workshops, concerts, dance,
jamming. Jeanne Buckley, 319 Old Divide Rd.,
Roundup 59072 (406)323-11 98.

NEVADA

Cambridge 02140-2102 (617)354-1340/426-1018/

Jan. 23-31 1999 (Elko)

(603)225-6546 (fax 617-354-3142) smlskoe@aol.com

The 14th Cowboy Poetry Gathering- workshops,

or

concerts, exhibits, dance. Addison

py@hopper.unli.edu/or

pearl@sw.stratus.com;

http:// www.neffa.org/neffa.
MICHIGAN
May 22-24 (Remus)

(702)738-7508, Hal Cannon (702)738-7508
NEW HAMPSHIRE

Traditional Arts Weekend-camp
ing; hp; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,

June 29 (Weare)
Weare Fiddle &amp; Banjo Contest-Gazebo

children's events. Instructional weekend. Lola
Tyler, PO Box 22, Remus 49340 (517)967-8879.

ter

June 19-21 (Jackson)

Michigan Dulcimer Festival-West

ern Cultural

Arts Center; hp; wab; workshops,
concerts, dance, jamming. Warren Guiles, 9575
Peach Ridge, Sparta 49345 (616)887-9436.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

http:

/www. westfolk.org.

Wheatland

Southern

Wilhite

in

cen

town; hp; competition, workshops,
children's events, jamming, concerts. Robert
or

Kordas,

Barnard

516

Hill

Rd.,

Weare

03281

(603)529-1967.
Jan. 15-17 1998 (Durham)
12th Ralph

Page Legacy Weekend-U. of NH;
(continued on next page)

�wab; hp; New England square &amp; contra dancing
music, jamming, open stage. NEFFA, 1950
Mass Ave., Cambridge 02140-2102 (617)354-1340

399, Guilderland

NEW YORK

&amp;

June 20-21 (Poughkeepsie)
The Great Hudson River Revival-Marist Col

(fax 617-354-3142);

lege; wab; hp; concerts, children's events, dance,
jamming, crafts, environmental exhibits. Ron

pearl@sw.stratus.com;

http://

wrvw.neffa.org/ -neffa
NEW JERSEY
Apr. 25 (New Brunswick)
New Jersey Folk Festival-Eagleton Institute,
Douglass College, Rutgers Univ.; workshops,
concert, dance, competition (arn by 01/98 for
1999), 3/21/97 for crafts); children's events.

Helene Grynberg (732)932-9174.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Aja, 112

Market St., Poughkeepsie

(914)454-

7673.

Falcon

Ridge

Folk Festival-Longhill

Farm;

camping; hp; wab; workshops, concerts, dance,
jamming, children's events. Anne Saunders, 74
Modley Rd., Sharon 06069 (860)364-0366;

anne@falconridgefolk.com.
July 24-26 (Binghamton)

June 26-28 (Altamont)
Old

12084.

July 24-26 (Hillsdale)

Songs Festival

of

Traditional

Music

&amp;

Dance-Altamont Fairgrounds; wab; hp; camp
ing; concerts, dance, workshops, jamming, open
stage, children's events. Old Songs Inc., PO Box

Cranberry Dulcimer Gathering-Unitarian Universalist Church; camping; workshops, concert,
open stage. Ed Ware, 1259 Fowler
Place, Binghamton 13903-6036 (607)669-4653;

jamming,

�ed- ware@compuser ve .com

Aug. 10-16 (Olive Bridge)
Ashokan Fiddle &amp; Dance Workshop/Southern

Week-Ashokan Field Campus; camping; work
shops, concerts, dance, jamming. Fiddle &amp; Dance,
987 Rt 28 A West Hurley 12491 (914)338-2996.

NORTH CAROLINA
Feb. 28 (Biscoe)
Star

Fiddler's

Convention-East Montgomery

High School; wab; hp; competition (afr), dance.
Jean Sullivan, PO Box 101, Star 27356.
Apr. 23-26 (Wilkesboro)
11th Annual MerleFest-Wilkes Community

lege;

concerts,

wab; hp;

children's even

workshops,

Col

dance,

jamming, midnight jam. Ticket
(800)343-7857 (RV camping (910)838-

Center

ts,

6291).

May

2

(Durham)

Eno River

Old-Time

val-West Point

on

bring own seating

Newberry,
27611

&amp;

Bluegrass Music Festi

the Eno Amphitheatre;
&lt;fc

picnic;

concerts.

PO Box 28534,

PineCone,

hp;

Susan
Raleigh

(919)990-1900/664-8333.

May 22-24 (Union Grove)
Ole Time Fiddlers &amp; Bluegrass

Festival-

camping; com
(arn
by May 10), workshops, concerts,
petition
dance, children's events, jamming. Harper A.
Van Hoy, PO Box 11, Union Grove 28689
Fiddler's Grove Campground;

(704)539-4417.
June 5-6 (Mt. Airy)
Airy Bluegrass &amp; Oldtime Fiddlers
Convention-Veterans Memorial Park; competi

Mount

tion (arn by May 26), dance, jamming, open
stage, children's events. Jack E. Jones, 319 W.
Oakdale St., Mt. Airy 27030 (910)786-6830.

June 7-13 (Mars Hill)
6th Annual Blue Ridge Old Time Week-Mars
Hill College; Scott E. Miller, Center for Continu

ing Ed., Mars

Hill College,

Mars

Hill 28754

(800)582-3047; (800)582-3047; cep@mhc.edu.
June28-July3 (Boone)

Appalachian Mountain Dulcimer WorkshopAppalachian State University; wab; hp; work
shops, concerts, jamming, open stage. Lou Ellen
Jones, Conferences &amp; Institutes, University Hall,
Boone 28608 (704)262-3045.
July 2-4 (Asheville)
71st Annual

Mountain Dance

&amp;

Folk Festival-

hp; wab; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,
competition, open stage. Stewart Canter, PO

Swannanoa Gathering-Warren Wilson College,

Alleghany Fairgrounds; camping; hab; hp; com
petition (afr), dance, jamming. Allegheny Co.
Fiddlers Convention, PO Box 602, Sparta 28675
(336)372-2033; fiddler@ls.net.

July 5-11 -Celtic Week July 6-12 -Performance
Lab; July 12-18 -Dance Week; July 12-18 -Dul

Old Time Fiddler's &amp; Bluegrass

Box 207, Barnardsville

28709 (704)626-2457.

July-Aug. (Swannanoa)

Music &amp;
cimer Week; July 19-25-Old-Time
Dance Week; July 26-Aug. 1-Guitar Week; wab;
camping; workshops, concerts, dance, children's
events, jamming, open stage. Jim Magill, Dir.
The Swannanoa Gathering, Warren Wilson Col
lege, PO Box 9000, Asheville 28815-9000 (704)2983325 x426;

gathering@warren-wilson.edu.

July 17-18 (Sparta)

Alleghany

County

Fiddler's

Convcntion-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Aug.

1

Convention-

(afr);

jamming.

Moore, PO Box 1045, Jefferson 28640

Maryanne
(910)246-2737.
Oct. 3-4 (Brasstown)
John

C.

C.

Campbell

Campbell

May 15-17 (Coshocton)

Dulcimer Days-Lake Park Pavillion; camping;
hp; wab; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,
competition, open stage. Cheryl Oswald, Roscoe

(Jefferson)

Ashe Comity Park; competition

John

OHIO

1

May 16-17 (Logan)

Mayapplc Stomp-Isaac

Folk School Fall FestivalFolk

Village Fdn., 381 Hill St., Coshocton 43812
(740)622-93 0/ (800)-877-l 830.

School; concerts,

children's events, jamming. Bob Dalsemer, John
C. Campbell Folk School, One Folk School Rd.,
Brasstown 28902 (800)365-5724.

Walton

Lodge; camp

ing; workshops, dance, open stage. Sue Snyder,
566 Walhalla Rd., Columbus 43202 (614)2635666.

June 27-28 (Waynesville)

CaesaPsCreekPioneer Village OleTyme Music

(continued

&amp;

on next page)

�Food Festival-Caesar's Creek pioneer Village;

camping; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,
children's events, open stage. John Noftsger, PO
45370-0224 (937)862Box 224, Spring Valley
5551.

July 11-12 (Bath)
26th

Annual Music

Village (arn by July

In the
1

Valley-Hale Farm

&amp;

camping; concerts, dance,

children's events, jamming. Barbara Byler, Hale
Farm &amp; Village, PO Box 296, Bath 44210 (330)666-

Aug. 14-16 (Richland)
North American Jew's Harp Festival-Eagle
Valley Grange Park; camping for performers
only workshops, concerts, jamming, open stage,
children's events. Kathi Vinson, HCR 87 Box
923, Baker City 97814 (541)894-2345.
Oct. 17-18 (Portland)
7th Annual Pacific NW Sacred Harp

tion-Sellwood Community

Ctr.;

Conven-

singing school,

3711.

all-day singing; potluck dinner. Karen Willard,
15215 TubbsRd., Buckley 98321 (360)897-9545;

July 25-26 (Mentor)
Little Mountain Folk Festival-Lake

hallock@aa.net or KarWillard@aol.com.
PENNSYLVANIA

County
History Center; hp; concerts, children's events,
jamming. Joan Kapsch, Lake County Historical
Society, 8610 King Memorial Rd., Mentor 44060
(440)255-8979.
Sept. 19-20 (Coshocton)
Old Time Music Festival-Roscoe Village; wab;
hp; nearby camping; competition, workshops,
concerts, jamming, dance. Cheryl Oswald,
Roscoe Village Fdn., 381 Hill St., Coshocton
438 2 (740)622-931 0/ (800)-877-l 830.
1

OKLAHOMA

July

(Doylestown)

4

Fonthill Museum's Old Fashioned 4tli of July
&amp; Fiddle Contest-children's events, family ac
tivities, competition. David April, Fonthill Mu
seum,

84 S. Pine St.,

Doylestown 18901 (215)348-

9461.

Aug.

1

(Lancaster)

LancasterCounty Old FiddlersPicnic-Lan caster
County Central Park; hp; competition (afr), con
cert, dance, jamming. John Gerencser,
LancasterCo. Parks, 1050 RockfordRd., Lancaster

Feb. 26-28 (Wagoner)
Oklahoma State FiddlersConvention-Western

17602.

Hills Lodge; concerts, dance, jamming. Ginger
King, 7424 NW 29, Bethany 73008 (405)789-3850

Chester County Old Fiddlers Picnic-Hibernia
Co. Park; camping; hp; wab; concerts, dance,
jamming, open stage, crafts, hayrides. Cathy
Snowberger, Chester Co. Parks &amp; Recreation

OREGON
Mar. 20-22 (Molalla)

Singtime Frolics-camping; hp; wab; workshops,
concerts, dance, jamming. Arn. (503)281-7475.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Aug.

jamming. Phila. Folksong Society, 7113 Emlen
St., Phila. 19119 (215)242-0150.
Sept. 4-7 (Hamlin)
Fourth Annual Fiddling Bear Festival-Lake
Genero Park; camping; hp; wab; dance, children's
events, jamming, campfire storytelling. AFOTM,
228 Cherry

(Coatesville)

601

St., Katonah

10536

(914)232-4657;

bowen@morea.terranet.com.
Sept. 12-13 (Cooksburg)
The

Great

Dulcimer Round-up-Cook

Forest

Ctr. for the Arts, Cook Forest State Park;

Sawmill

camping nearby; lip; wab; workshops, concerts,
jamming, open stage. Felice Dugan, Sawmill
Ctr. for the Arts, PO Box 180, Cooksburg 16217
(814)927-6655.
Sept. 13 (Lyons)
Fiddle Festival-Lyons Community Park;
wab; hp; concerts, dance, competition, jamming,
Fall

open stage, crafts. Arlan Schwoyer, 300 Lyons
Rd., Lyons 19536 (215)682-6103.

SOUTH CAROLINA
May

8

Dept., GSC,
19382.

Aug. 28-30 (Schwenksville)
Philadelphia Folk Festival-camping; wab; hp;
concerts, workshops, dance, chldren's events,

9

Carolina

(Lancaster)

Legends Festival-Andrew Jackson

State Park; camping; hp; wab; workshops, con
certs, children's events. Lancaster Co. Council of
the Arts, PO Box 613, Lancaster 29721 (803)2857451.
Oct. 24 (Columbia)

Westtown Rd., West Chester

Fall Folklife Festival-McKissick Museum, Univ.
of SC; wab; hp; concert, children's events, folk
craft. Holly Mitchell, McKissick Museum, USC, Co1

umbia 29208 (803)777-7251

mitchellh@garnet.da.sc.ed

u.

SOUTH DAKOTA
July 31-Aug.
19th

1

(Canton)

Annual SiouxRiverFolkFestival-Newton

Hills State Park; wab; hp; camping; workshops,

dance, jamming, children's events;
Gaynor Johnson, 103 1 /2 S. Main, Canton 57013
(605)987-2582.
TENNESSEE
July 3-4 (Smithville)
Smitliville Fiddlers Jamboree &amp; Crafts Fcsticoncerts,

val-On the Square, downtown; wab; hp; compe
tition (afr), open stage, dance, jamming,
children's events. Smitliville Jamboree, PO Box
83, Smithville 37166 (615)597-8500/597-4163

http://www.dekalbtn.com

http://

or

www.festivals.com.

July 10-12 (Murfreesboro)
21st Annual Uncle Dave Macon Days Festivalchildren's
hp; wab; concerts, dance, competition,
Macon
Dave
Uncle
events, open stage.
Days
Fest.

Committee,

PO Box 5016, Murfreesboro

37133 (615)893-2361.
Oct. 8-11 (Norris)

Tennessee Fall Homecoming-Museum

of ApRice
Irwin,
John

palachia; concerts, jamming.
PO Box 1189, Norris 37828 (423)494-7680.
TEXAS
Apr. 24-27 (Hallettsville)

Texas State Championship Fiddlers Frolics-K of
Hall

&amp;

grounds; camping; wab;

hp;

C

competition,

�events, jamming, open stage. Ronnie Coffey,
MRFC, PO Box 702, Buena Vista 2441
8845.

6

(800)555-

June 26-27 (Elk Creek)

Grayson County Old-Time

Bluegrass Fid
school grounds;
camping; hp; competition (afr); jamming, dance.
Jerry Testerman (540)655-4740.
July 31-Aug. 1 (Hiltons)
Carter Family Memorial Festival- The Carter
Fold; wab; hp; concerts, dance. Janette Carter,
PO Box 111, Hiltons 24258 (540)386-9480. Note:
&amp;

dlers Convention-Elementary

The Carter Fold presents programs throughout
the year. Contact as above for schedule.

Aug. 4-9 (Galax)
Old Fiddlers Convention-Felts Park; camping;
wab; hp;

competition (arn by July

15, afr),

work

shops, dance, jamming, open stage. Tom Jones,
PO Box 655, Galax 24333 (540)236-3740.
Sept. 18-19 (Buena Vista)
Rockbridge Mountain Music &amp; Dance Festi
val-Glen Maury Park; camping; workshops, con
certs, dance, jamming, open stage. (540)463-5214
williams@rockbridge.net.
Oct. 24 (Ferrum)

concerts, dance, children's

events, jamming,

open stage, barbecue cookoff, cajun fun night.
Kenneth Henneke (512)798-5934.
June 19-20 (Stonewall)

Stonewall Peach Jamboree
dance, children's
Box

1,

&amp;

Melon

Festival-Festival

Aug.10-15 (Alvarado)
&amp;

(Amherst)
Fiddle

Briar

Old Settlers Reunion-hp; wab; con

May 6-9 (Rocky Mount)
Music Campground; camping; hp; wab; con
certs, workshops, children's events, jamming,
open stage, barn dance. Sterling T. or Dreama
Belcher, 1184 Tripple Creek Rd., Rocky Mount

24151-6149 (540)483-9839/489-1311.
June 12-13 (Rocky Mount)
13 th Annual Part-Time International Blue Grass
&amp; Old-Time Competitions-Tripple Creek Mu
sic Campground;

(817)790-6667.

tion

(am

by

camping;

May 31, afr),

hp; wab;

concerts,

competi
dance,

children's events, jamming, open stage. Sterling

Sept. 18-19 (Crockett)

Championship

Dance Festival-Sweet

wab; workshops, concerts,
dance, jamming, children's events. Joe Malloy
(804)381-6307.

certs, competition, children's events, open stage.
Otis A. Lane, PO Box 217, Alvarado
76009

61st Annual World

&amp;

18th Annual Festival in the Pines-Tripple Creek

Grounds Hwy 6; hp; wab; concerts, competition
(arn by Aug 1), children's events. Betty Terrill,
PO Box 44, DeLeon 76444 (254)893-6600.
Pioneers

4

Fiddlers

&amp;

Pioneer Festival- competition. Houston County
Chamber of Commerce, PO Box 307, Crockett
75835 (409)544-2359 (fax 409-544-4355).
Sept. 11-13 (Kerrville)
Texas Heritage Fall Festival-wab; hp; camping;

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

or Dreama

Belcher, 1184 Tripple Creek Rd.,
Rocky Moun 241 5 -61 49 (540)483-9839 489-131 1
June 18-20 (Buena Vista)

T.

1

WASHINGTON
Feb. 21-22 (Seattle)

Annual Pacific NW Sacred Harp Conven
tion-Sunset Hill Community Club; singing

Briar College; hp;

concerts,

928, Stamford 79553 (915)773-3614.
Aug. 3-8 (De Leon)
&amp;

Apr.

Sweet

College, Ferrum 24088 (540)365-4416.

7th

VIRGINIA

events. Mary Lou Klein, PO

dance, competition (am by June 25), open stage,
cowboy poetry. Texas Cowboy Reunion, Box

Peach

Kathleen

Hudson, PO Box 1945, Kerrville 78029 (830) 367-

Rodeo-hp; wab;

Stonewall 78671 (830)644-2735.

Leon

Rodgers Tribute.

3750.

July 1-4 (Stamford)
Texas Cowboy Reunion-camping;

De

children's events, jam

concerts,

workshops,

ming, Jimmie

Blue Ridge Folklife Festival-Ferrum College;
hp; concerts, children's events, jamming, dance.
Roddy Moore, Blue Ridge Institute, Ferrum

1

5th Annual Maury River Fiddlers ConventionGlen Maury Park; wab; hp; camping; competi
tion, dance, workshops, square dance, children's

school,

all-day

singing, potluck dinner. Karen

Willard, 15215 Tubbs Rd., Buckley 98321 (360)8979545; hallock@aa.net or KarWillard@aol.com.

May 22-25 (Seattle)
North west Folklife Festival -Sea ttleCenter;wab;
hp; concerts,

workshops, children's events, jam

ming, open stage. Northwest Folklife,
Harrison St. Seattle 98109 (206)684-7300.

305

June 22-28 (Port Townsend)

Country Blues Workshop-Fort Worden State
Park. Centrum, PO Box 1158, Port Townsend
98368-0958 (360)385-31 02 (fax 385-2470) h ttp:

www.centrum.org.
June 28-July 5 (Port Townsend)
Festival of American Fiddle Tunes WorkshopFort Worden State Park. Centrum, PO Box 158,
1

Port

Townsend

98368-0958 (360)385-3102 (fax

385-2470); http:/ /www.centrum.org.
WEST VIRGINIA

Augusta Heritage Arts Workshops-Davis

&amp;

Elkins College; hp; wab; workshops, concerts,

dance,

jamming,

children's

events. Gordon

(continued

on next page)

�Blaekley, Augusta Heritage Center, Davis &amp;
Elkins College, Elkins 26241 (304)637-1350;
gblackly@dne.wvnet.edu. Tliese include: Apr.

19-25-Spring Dulcimer Week; Ju ly 5-10-Cajun/
Creole, Guitar Week; July 12-17-Blucs&amp; Swing
Week;July 19-24-Irish Week; July 26-31 -Dance

&amp;Blucgrass Week; Aug. 2-9-Vocal &amp;OId-Time
Week; Oct. 25-Nov.l-October Old -Time Week;
Oct. 24-26-Augusta Fiddlers Reunion.)
May 9-10 (Fairmont)
Traditional Music Weekend-PrickettsFortState
Park; wab; hp; camping; concerts, jam ming, open

stage, children's events. David Elkinton, Rt
Box 407, Fairmont 26554 1-800-CALL-WVA.

3,

May 22-24 (Charleston)
Vandalia Gathering-Cultural Center and Capi
tol Complex
grounds; competition, concerts,
dance, children's events, jamming. WV Divi
sion of Culture &amp; History, The Cultural Center,
1900

Kanawha

Blvd.

E.,

Charleston

25305

(304)558-0220.
June 18-19 (Glenville)
West Virginia State Folk

Festival-camping;
workshops, concerts, dance, jamming, competi
tion. Ginny Hawker (304)462-8427.

June 21-27 (Snowshoe)
Allegheny Echoes The Snowshoe WorkshopsSnowshoe Mtn. Resort; hp; wab; workshops,
concerts, dance, jamming, children's events, open
stage. Limit 10 students per class. Mike Bing, Rt
2

Box 128-M, Marlinton 24954 (800)336-7009.

July29-Aug.

2

(Clifftop)

Appalachian String Band Music Festival-Camp
Washington Carver; wab; hp; camping; compe
tition, workshops, dance, children's events, con
certs, jamming. Director, Camp Washington
Carver, HC 35 Box 5, Clifftop 25831 (304)4383005.
Aug. 7-9 (Elkins)
The Augusta Festival-Davis

&amp; Elkins College
Campus &amp; Elkins City Park; workshops, con
certs, dance, jamming, children's events. Gor

don Blaekley, Augusta Heritage Ctr.,
College, Elkins WV 26241 (304)637-1350.

D

&amp;

E

WISCONSIN
Mar. 6-8 (Milwaukee)

Stringalong Weekend-Edwards Conference
Center; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,
open stage. Ann Schmid, UW-Milwaukee Folk
Center,

Fine

Arts-UWM,

FOLK/ (414)229-4622;

Milwaukee

53201

(800)636-

annschmid@aol.com.

May 8-10 (Gays Mills)
Gays Mills Folk Festival of Music &amp; Dancecamping; hp; wab; workshops, concerts, dance,

jamming, children's events, open stage, gospel
sing. Tim Jenkins,

Rt 2 Box 83,

Gays Mills 54631

(608)872-2419.
June 27-July

2

(Lake Geneva)

Summer Stringalong-Conference Point; work
shops, concerts, dance, jamming, open stage.
Ann Schmid, Music Workshops Ltd., 2851 N.
Farwell,

Milwaukee 53211

(800)636-FOLK;

annschmid@aol.com.
Nov. 6-8 (Milwaukee)
Stringalong

Weekend-Edwards Conference

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Center; workshops, concerts, dance, jamming,
open stage. Ann Schmid, UW-Milwaukee Folk
Center, Fine Arts-UWM, Milwaukee 53201 (800)636FOLK/(414)229-4622; annsclrmid@aol.com.

94817662/001161394995052.

CANADA

AUSTRALIA
Oct. 16-18 (Harrietville)

Harrietville Bluegrass &amp; Old Timey Music
Convention-camping; hp; wab; workshops, con
certs, jamming, open stage. Nick

Eureka; wab;hp; workshops, concert, jamming
open stage, dance. Ken McMaster, 361 Clarke
St., Northcote, Victoria, 3070. Ph: 0011613

&amp; Janet

Dear,

PO Box 61, Blackwood Vic 3458; 61-2-9456-1090.
Feb 19-20 1999 (Yarra Junction, Victoria)
Yarra Junction Fiddlers Convention-Camp

July 3-5 (Sudbury, Ont.)
Northern Lights Festival Boreal- Bell Park; wab;
workshops, concerts, dance, children's even

ts.

Audrey

Dumanski (705)674-5512; nlfbnet@vignet.on.ca.

July 24-26 (Vancouver Island)

(continued

on page 56)

�Workshop
"Yellow

Gnls"

transcribed

by

Hank

long-ago

Ron

Bradley

"Recalled

from

Hughey playing."
*1.

These illegible symbols repre

sent sliding the little finger from D
to E on the A string, while simulta

neously bowing the open

and until the last

E

string

1/16 note

of the

measure that pinky stays put on its
E. Easier to
play than describe.
Warning! Contra-dancing to this
tune may disrupt your health and
H.B.
spirits.

"Dubuque" transcribed

by

Hank Bra

dley
"A Dad

Crockett tune recalled from

long-ago Ron Hughey playing."
This obnoxious (but sweetsounding) chore is accomplished
by bridging the 3rd finger across
the A and E strings at once
the 4th
*2.

finger being free to flap up and

down

as

required on the high

B.

H.B.

Stony Point
transcribed

by Carl Baron

(following

page)
In my banjo tabs I usually indi
cate playing of the 5th string even

during slides, pull-offs, hammerI
find the drive in the banjo

ons.

comes from the sounding of the 5th
string as much as possible. While it
may not be possible for every player
sound the 5th string as often as

to

indicated, one should try.
The marks when the 5th string
is

used as
I

a

melody note.

consider the

1

st

and 3rd parts as

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

generic, but I've probably been influenced
by the versions found in West Virginia

older recording recently which included
this 2nd part, but can't recall for sure. The

more tha

4th part

is

n

in

a

ny ot her

from Frank George.

region The2ndpart
think heard some
I

I

I

sicians.

I

learned from contemporary mu
C.B.

�Stony Point (Wild Horse, Old Dad, and others)
Fiddle: GDAE; Banjo: gDGDE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

transcribed

by Carl Baron

�Classified

Musical Instruments
WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION-New-Used-

OLD TIME MANDOLIN

Vintage guitars, banjos, mandolins, archtops,
wood &amp; metal body Dobros, Nationals. Mando
lin Brothers, 629 Forest Ave., Staten Island, NY

Little River Stomp by the Buckhannon Bros. 25

718-981-3226. Call for
no-cliarge evaluation of your vintage fretted
instruments.
10310.

Free Catalog.

NOW

SUBSCRIBE

to

our

vintage instrument list with

monthly
28 jam

used and

packed pages

quality instruments for players and collectors
down-to-earth prices. $15.00/year ($30.00

of
at

overseas). Current issue free on request. ELDERLYINSTRUMENTS 1100N. Washington, POB
14210-FB34, Lansing, MI 48901; 517-372-7890;
http:

www.elderly.com.

INSTRUMENTALS

times, 73 minutes long. CDs $15.00, cassettes
$10.00 plus $1 .00 shipping. Make check payable
to

Dennis Buckhannon. Write: The Buckhannon

Bros., PO Box 6165, St. Charles, MO 63302-6165.

PLANNING

CASSETTE PROJECT?

A CD OR

I

Compact Disc &amp; Cassette Print
Design, over 00 projects successfully com pleted
in

specialize

1

date. From concept to final films. Digital im
aging, illustration and typesetting. Duplication
and manufacturing also available. Call Jim Burns
to

at

802-388-761

or write PO Box 685,

9

Middlebury,

VT 05753.

BOOKS, VIDEOS, CAS
much more. Free discount cata

INSTRUCTIONAL
MARTIN

Find out why we're the
world's largest Martin guitar dealer. Free dis
count catalog. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100
N.

GUITARS

POB 14210-FB34,

Washington,

Lansing,

MI

and

SETTES,

logs. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS,
ington, POB 14210-FB34, Lansing,
372-7890.

1

100 N.

MI

Wash

48901;517-

48901; 517-372-7890.

RURAL ROUTE

button-boxes,

ACCORDIONS,

concertinas,
Alabama's

dulcimers,

fiddles,

folk and acoustic

banjos,

guitars.

music resource.

Homewood Musical 3027 Central Ave. Birming
ham, AL; http:/ /limi.homewood.net; 205-8794868. Call us last.
CUSTOM BUILT BANJOS, Appalachian Dulci
mers, Violins, New-used. Restorations, Repairs.
W.A. West 704-656-2042;
6895 Hwy. 212
Marshall, NC 28753.

Bovee

2,

the

la

test recording from Bob

Heil; CDs $16; cassette $11 post
paid. Many other recordings available. To order
or for catalog: Bovee &amp; Heil, Rt 2, Box 25,
Spring
&amp; Gail

Grove, MN 55974; 507-498-5452.

COMPACT DISCS, CASSETTES, VIDEOS! New
free discount catalog with over 10,000 titles.
Bluegrass, folk, blues, jazz, old time country,
and much more, listed by category of music and
by artist. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.
POB

Washington,

14210-FB34, Lansing,

MI

48901; 517-372-7890.

Recordings, Books, Instruction
FLATFOOTING

WORKSHOP

INSTRUC

Bernstein. 1-3/4 hours,
27 steps, beginning to advanced. Easy to follow.
Each step clearly broken down and taught. Also
TIONAL VIDEO by

Ira

performed pieces. Step Manual and 2
differen concert performance videos also avail
able. Inquire: 179 Flint St., Asheville, NC 28801.

includes

3

t

704-255-9393; IraTenToe@aol.com.

TUNES FROM HOME--

A delightful collection
irresistible dance tunes in Old-Time, Cel tic,
and New England styles. Challenging times,

of

1

00

Zesty music! Book: $12.95, Tapes: $8.98, add
$2.00 shipping; CA residents add 6% tax. Order

Daniel Engle/Tunes From Home, 6984
McKinley #148, Sebastopol, CA 95472.
from

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Misc.
IMPROVE

products

for

YOUR PLAYING!

Free catalog

of

fiddlers and mandolinists. Petimar

Press, PO Box 30961

D,

Seattle, WA 98133.

JOIN FELLOW MUSIC LOVERS! American tra

ditional musicians perform with Vienna Sym
phony. November 3-8, 1998. Workshops, show
cases, sidetrips. R/T air, hotel, breakfasts, tick
ets, $1400. Limited seats. Info: 712-762-4363.

Equipment

The

ODD SIZED FIBERSKYN BANJO HEADS. Many
sizes from 10" to 12", $18 to $20. Gut banjo
$15. Everest banjo cases for

rims $85

strings,
plus shipping. Smakula Fretted Instruments,
Box 882, Elkins, WV 26241; 304-636-6710.
1

2"

P0

Old-Time Herald will accept classified

ads at the cost of 35 cents per word, minimum

$5.00. Any grouping

of

letters

or

counted as one word. All ads must
by

the first

publication

of the

month,

6

numbers
be

is

received

weeks prior

to

�Sales

County

TAPES

VIDEOS
ALL
BOOKS
www county sales com

CDs

I

ri WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF RI.UEGRASS
Section with Illegible Text

hJ

LP

PJ
LH

Association

1

1
1

MAR-9069
DOC-8013

■■P

&amp;

BEST SELLERS

Believe I'll Go Back Home" Enjoyable old-time string band music
1927-28 reissue of Alfred Karnes, Ernest Phipps, etc. from old 78s
RURAL STRING BANDS OF TENNESSE 18 wonderful cuts from the 1920s
STEPHEN WADE "Dancing in the Parlor" Wonderful old-time banjo with various guests
BRUCE MOLSKY &amp; BIG HOEDOWN Fine old-time string band w/ Rafe Stefaninni
SOUTHERN JOURNEY Vol 7 "Ozark Frontier" Almeda Riddle, Neil Morris, Bookmiller Shannon
WILL KEYS "A Banjo Original" Fantastic old-time music from this amazing banjo player
CARTER FAMILY "On Border Radio Vol 1" 27 tracks from XET Radio in the late 1930s
CAMP CREEK BOYS reissue of 1960s classic with Kyle Creed, Fred Cockerham, etc
JODY STECHER &amp; KATE BRISLIN "Heart Songs" Songs of Utah Phillips
ED HALEY "Forked Deer" 2-CD set with 36 tunes from this early amazing Kentucky fiddler
"I

KENTUCKY GOSPEL

CO-3511
CO-2721
ROU-0421
CO-2720
ARH-411

CO-2719
ROU-0424
ROU-1131/32

DELMORE BROTHERS "Brown's Ferry Blues" 18 tracks 1930s Bluebirds Excellent
LAUREL BLISS "Old Pal" Carter Family songs with guitar and dobro
TRADITIONAL FIDDLE MUSIC OF KENTUCKY:Along The Kentucky River Vol

TM-0707
ROU-0377
CO-3506

CLIFF PERRY

SHAN-6020
CO-2713
SF-40097
SF-40098
MAR-9064
CCS-112
CO-3510
YAZ-2013
YAZ-2014
RR-101

1

CO-3509
ROU-0384

CO-2702

ROU-11569
CO-2715

CO-2710

DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great 1940s King sides 18 tracks
RED MOUNTAIN WHITE TRASH "Fire In The Dumpster" 14 tracks old-time string
THE FREIGHT HOPPERS "Where'd You Come From..." Spirited old-time music from

CCS-110

WHOOP-101
ROU-0403

ARNIE NAIMAN

VEST-13071
YAZ-512
YAZ-516
FMV-01

SHADY GROVE (Tommy Jarrell, Roscoe Holcomb, Dock Boggs, Kilby Snow)
TIMES AIN'T LIKE THEY USED TO BE Super 70 minute video w/Jimmie Rodgers, etc
TRADITIONAL MUSIC CLASSICS (Buell Kazee. Kilby Snow, Doc Watson)
CARRYING THE TRADITIONS: APPALACHIAN FIDDLING TODAY 120 minute video
THAT HIGH LONESOME SOUND Video with Roscoe Holcomb, Sara/Maybelle Carter, etc
THE HARRY SMITH COLLECTION Fabulous 6-CD box set reissue of the 1952 classic LPs!
CHARLIE POOLE "Old-Time Songs Vol 2" Excellent collection of 1920s/'30s selections
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS with DOC WATSON "Strictly Instrumental" Great 1966 set- now on CD
JAMES BRYAN &amp; CARL JONES "Two Pictures" Fine old-time fiddle with guitar, banjo, etc

&amp;

CHRIS COOLE

"5

Strings Attached With No Backing"

CCS-117

MAR-2001

POSTAGE
HANDLING: USA ORDERS: Please add $3.00
first
ICCS-116
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Minimum shipping charge

40

Fine old-time

BASCOM LAMAR LUNSFORD "Ballads, Banjo Tunes, &amp; Sacred Songs of Western N. Carolina"
BILLY IN THE LOWGROUNDS "Old Time Music From the 1966 Newport Folk Festival"

SHAN-1404
SF-40090
CO-3508

LP
PL
LP
PL

band
NC band

MERRI-1

SF-40082
VEST-13051

r-^

2

ECHOES OF THE OZARKS Vol 1 with Pope's Arkansas Mtneers, Morrison Bros. etc. 1920s
ECHOES OF THE OZARKS Vol 2 with Fiddlin' Bob Larkan, Dr. Smith's Hoss Hair Pullers, etc.
NORMAN &amp; NANCY BLAKE "The Hobo's Last Ride" New collection of old-time tunes/songs
CLARK KESSINGER "The Legend Of..." Now on CD- classic Kanawha release from 1960s
CLOSE TO HOME Great old-time music from Mike Seeger collection
NEW LOST CITY RAMBLERS "There Ain't No Way Out" NEW recordings
LAUCHLIN SHAW &amp; A.C. OVERTON "Sally With The Run-Down Shoes" Fine banjo-fiddle duo
CARTER FAMILY "Clinch Mountain Treasures" Great 20 song set of 940s cuts
ERNEST V. STONEMAN "Edison Recordings 1928" Fine 22 track reissue many old songs
MUSIC OF KENTUCKY- Vol 1 with Alfred Karnes, B. F. Shelton, Ernest Phipps, etc
MUSIC OF KENTUCKY Vol 2 with Ernry Arthur, Bill Shepherd, Carver Boys, etc
THE CEDAR POINT STRING BAND Franklin George, David O' Dell. Nice
SKILLET LICKERS "Old-Time Songs &amp; Tunes" Great 1920s old-time from North Georgia
DIRK POWELL "If I Go Ten Thousand Miles" New old-time collection produced by Tim O'Brien
TOMMY JARRELL FRED COCKERHAM "Best Banjo &amp; Fiddle Duets" 21 songs -nice
HIGHWOODS STRING BAND "Feed Your Babies Onions" 23 track reissue of 1970s cuts
THE HOLLOW ROCK STRING BAND "Traditional Dance Tunes"
MOUNTAIN DULCIMER GALAX STYLE with Bonnie Russell and the Russell Family

CO-3S07

and

THE OLD-TIME HERALD

for

SPRING

1998

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

to 3
is

$4.00.

Lfl

$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00

$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
video
video
video
video
video
video
$60.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00

H
CS

LP

N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A

N/A
N/A
N/A

N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A

J

PJ

$8.00
$8.00
N/A
N/A
N/A

L^P

N/A

N/A
N/A
N/A

N/A

$8.00

Bg^

N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A

PJ

LP
PL

$8.00
$8.00
$8.00

P
PH

N/A

$8.00
$8.00
N/A

$8.00
N/A

N/A

$20.00
$20.00
$20.00
$20.00
$29.00
$20.00
N/A
N/A

$8.00
N/A

items, add $4.00 for 4 or more items
CD's and cassettes are
$1.50 each and LPs are $2.00 each. MINIMUM FOREIGN order is 2 items.
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U. S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES
DEPT. H BOX 191
FLOYD, VA 24091
540-745-2001
Minimum credit card order is $15.00
(Fax) 540-745-2008
&amp;

STOCK

i^gi
CD

THE RHYTHM RATS

ROU-1707

■n
PJ

NEW RELEASES

MEMBER

III

International
Bluegrass Music

OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDINGS

IN

PJ

LgP

PL
LP

IB

H

LgP

PL
LP

B^L
I

PlQ

PL
LH

�Reviews

A

grabber. I'll take one from a Young Billy just as
quickly as will from an Old Goat."

Banjo Original

Will

Keys

I

Most of the accompaniment

County CO-CD-2720
Will Keys-banjo; Barabara

Kuhns-fiddle; Doug Smith-

Guest

appearances from Tony Testerman
(bass), Jeff Little (piano), Wayne Henderson (guitar),

guitar.

Laurie Lewis (fiddle), Dudley Connell (guitar), Jimmy

Trivette (bass).
The Wearing of the Green Chinquapin Hunt
ing/Midnight on the Water/ Standing on the

Promises/Cat in the Pear Tree Once More/The
Dead March/ Silver Bell /The Eighth of Janu
ary/My Pretty Quadroon /Snake Chapman's
Tune/Down Yonder/Cieli to Lindo/Texas Gals/
Waiting for the Robert
Softly /Puncheon

Mountain

Black

Palms of

E.

Lee/ Blow

Floor/There

Ye

Winds

Fountain/
Rag/ Are You from Dixie?/
is

Victory/Goodbye Girls,

a

I'm Going to

Boston.
A

breath of fresh air, this one. As Joe Wilson
in the extensive liner notes, Will Keys'

explains

banjo style is unique: "There is no right hand
pattern only a requirement that the melody line
be as rich and full as
is

a

[TJhis
humanly possible
from a sounding of the
sensibility about melody. It is driven

style developed

melody,

a

by taste, not

"

picking technique.' Keys, who
was born in 923 in northeastern Tennessee, was
one of 17 children, and his musical sensibility
combines a taste for driving dance rhythms (his
a

1

a string band) with the el
touch
of
egant
parlor music (as played on the
piano and sung by his sisters). This CD shows us

elder brothers had

the full range, from the smoking band sound of
"Cat in the Pear Tree" (otherwise known as

"Mississippi

Sawyer")

to

delicate solo pieces

like "The Dead March"

and "My Pretty Qua
droon." The CD will surely delight anyone with

interest in old-time banjo.
Besides Joe Wilson's notes, Keys contributes a
few words on the provenance of the times. Some
were learned from the singing of his mother and
the playing of his sisters. Some were picked up
an

from local fiddlers such

as

Charlie Bowman, Bob

Clark of Blackley Creek, and Urg Light of

Chim

ney Top Mountain in Greene Comity, Tennes
his source for the
see. Keys describes Light
idiosyncratically named version of "Mississippi
ever
as "the best old-time fiddler
Sawyer"
I

heard,"

but, sadly, adds

that he knows

of no

playing. Others popular
recordings
pieces like "Silver Bell" and "Down Yonder"
were learned from records or the radio. Still
others were learned from young old-time play
of Light's

ers: Keys tells us that he got "Snake Chapman's
Time" from tire playing of Dirk Powell, which leads
him to observe that he's "an equal opportunity time

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

Will Keys'

banjo is provided by fiddler Barbara Kulins of
Dayton, Ohio, and guitarist Doug Smith. Their

playing blends well with his. In addition, Tony
Testerman steps in on bass for several of the

tunes. Variety is provided by Wayne
Henderson's guitar picking and Jeff Little's rol
licking piano

on "Down Yonder" and "Are You

From Dixie?" Laurie Lewis, Dudley Connell and
in a live recording from the
Jimmy Trivette

Masters of the Banjo tour
in the

spectacular burning

Tree." This is

a

in 1994

aid Mr. Keys

up of "Cat in the Pear

keeper.
ALLIN COTTRELL

�Our latest releases:
Gid Tanner

&amp; His

Skillet Lickers:

A Corn Licker Still in Georgia
All 14 sides of this popular skit, originally
issued on 78 rpm records 1927-30, by the
most famous old time band in history!

(CD's $15, cassettes

$10 ppd.)

Pancerzewski:
Legendary Northwest Fiddler

Joe

selected from LP's recorded 1972
1980 by the Northwest's greatest old time
Canadian-style fiddler. (CD only, $15 ppd.)
36 tunes

Send for free catalog, or visit our website at
www.bwnet.com
voyager

Voyager Recordings

Seattle WA 98122

424 35th Ave.

ballet Rodeo. This is indeed more aggressive than
Bela Bartok, who composed original times using

inspired by Hungarian folk tunes. But
Leadbelly took his "Rock Island Line" from Kelly
Pace's earlier recording reissued on this CD. The
Britisher Lonnie Donagan, in turn, had a hit with
his cover of the Leadbelly recording, and subse
scales

quently interested

a

lot of people in traditional

music. E.C. Ball's "Pretty Polly" on this CD is
identical with the old commercial recording by

Shelton, except that the banjo melodic line
played on a guitar. None of the people re
corded by the Library of Congress collectors
seem to have been concerned about ownership.
The music is in the tradition, received from an
B.

F.

is

unknown number
ously passed

of

generations,

and gener

on to the next ones. We may

tem

porarily profit from them, but we don't own
them. Copyright law is intended to protect indi
vidual artistic creation, but it makes no more

sense

for

"The

Blood Strained

Banders"

or

"Goodbye Old Paint," than Homer's copyrights
to The Odyssety.
LYLE LOFGREN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Hobo

Out on

Bill/Away

Mountain/Roll

the

Along Kentucky Moon /Waiting
and My Old Guitar/T
Tritzem Yodel (undubbed).

You

for

a

Train (2)/

for Texas

(alt)/

Man/The Tliing/I Don't Love
Nobody Hip Ca t's W edding /These Hills /Billy
Yank and Johnny Reb/Goodbye
Reb/Willis
Mayberry /Sweet Fern/Night Train to Memphis/Rosalee/(Somewhere) Somebody's Wait
ing (for You)/Kickin' Mule/Liza's Up a 'Simmon
Tree/Chicken Don't Roost Too High /Going
from the Cotton Fields/Tragic Romance/Methodist Pie/Fatal Wedding/What Does the Deep
Say?/I'm Tying the Leaves (So They Won't
Down) /Oh Captain Captain/Devilish
Mary /The Ladies Man (alt) /Hip Cat's Wedding
Sea

Come

(alt)/Night Train

to

hesitation
time

The Ladies

2:

trailing, song writing, singing comedian and all
around country music legend. I'll admit without

Memphis (alt).

I

to being a Grandpa fan from the first
saw Grandpa on TV 20 years back. He has

steadfastly remahied true to traditional country
music over the years and has left a large re
corded legacy which reflects that well, some
times. Casein pom t, thisnew5-CD set from Bear
Family. Everybody's Grandpa includes Grandpa
Jones's entire recorded output from late 1960 to
mid-1973, the years he was signed to Monument
Records.

Personally, feel that many of Grandpa's best
recordings (my favorites anyway) were done for
King Records (1943-51), but that material has
not yet been made available for a reissue project
1

such as this one. Given

that, Bear Family

has

gone to great lengths in remastering this mate
rial and presenting every th ing tha was recorded
t

Dixie?/Root Hog or Die/Fall
ing Leaves/Here Comes the Champion/Banjo
Am the Instrument/Springtime Comes But Once
a Year /Eight More Miles to Louisville (master)/

during the Monument time period, including
alternate takes and undubbed versions of songs.

The Little Old Lady /Sprin gtime Comes But Once
a Year
(alt) /Eight More Miles to Louisville

here and there, perhaps some material best left
unheard. Listen to "Christmas Guest" or "Christ

Are You from

3:

(alt) Eight More Miles to Louisville (alt) /On the
Jericho Road/I'll Meet You in the Morning/
Gone Home/Keep on the Firing Line/Just Over

the

Gloryland/Old
Empty Mansion/When

in

Way /The Glory

On/No Tears

Camp Meetin'
I

Time/

Get to the End of the

Land Way /Turn Your Radio
in Heaven/Lonesome Train

(Ramona Jones) /Sandy Land (Ramona Jones)/
Send Me a Red Rose (Ramona Jones) /Christmas
Roses/Christmas Guest.
Heart Full of Love/Goin'

4:

Down the River/

Moon of Arizona /Steady Drips of Water/Ev
Had Going for Me Is Gone/Don't
erything
I

Look Back
hi

/Trouble

hi Min d

(version

1

/Trouble

t's All this WorldNeeds/
Home/Mountain Laurel/

Mind (version 2)/Tlia

Bill's Gonna Soon Be

Smoke, Smoke, Smoke (But Not Around Me)/
I've Learned to Leave that to the Lord/Old
Troupe

Dog/Sweet

Lips (Battle of King's

Moun

/Plans /I'll Just Keep Living Along/ King of
Cannon Comity Hills/ Momi tain Dew/Old

tain)
the

McClain/Old

Rattler/Old Blue/Grassliopper
Bill/Goin' Down the River (alt).
5:

The Valley of the Never Do Good /Four Stone

Am
Walls/A Dollar Short/Coal Camp/Here
Plans/Green Hills of Home/Are You
Sleeping Daddy Darlhi' /Nasli ville on My Mind/
I

Makhi'

The Mountain

Man

/Deep Dark Corner

Mhid/Baby-O/My Old Lady/Brown
Fair

Mea

of My

Girl and

Ellender /Four Winds A-Blo win' /In tro/Fix
Pallet/Joke/Dooley Joke/The Air, theSun-

sliine, and the Rain /Joke/Castles in the Air/
Joke/Old Rattler's Pup/Joke/My Bonnie Lies
Over the Ocean /Rocky Top /Joke /I Don't Love

Nobody /John Henry /The Last Ol' Shovel/Joke/
Southern Bound/15 Cents is All Got.
I

Lords "Grandpa" Jones is currently working on
his seventh decade as

a

guitar strumming, banjo

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

As one might expect with such an all inclusive

approach, there

are

going

to be a

few problems

mas Roses" and you'll get the picture. Other
than these two cuts, the material in this set is
pretty consistent in content and sound with
much of the mainstream country music being

produced at the time. Throughout, the music is
textured with layers of sound provided by
Nashville's finest session players. Lots of rhythm
guitars, some piano here and there, occasional
electric guitar and drums, vocal choruses, and of
course, clawhammer banjo. At worst, it's "oldtime music and rube comedy meets the Nash
ville Sound." At it's best though, there's some
damn fine country music to be heard here, and
as like straightforward cormtry music, I found
much of the music on these five discs to be quite
I

enjoyable. There is sometimes some serious
wading through the other stuff to be done to find
think it's highly
it, however, and for this reason
I

unlikely that this set will appeal

to

many readers
a few

of the Old-Titne Herald. That said, there are

gems

to be

found throughout which should

to

most everyone.
appeal
Early on, there's a solid version of "Going
'Cross the Sea" which features some truly great
to

clawhammer

banjo playing from none other
Merle Travis that makes you forget all
about the drums. On Disc 5, from his final ses
than

sion for Monument, Grandpa offers up an un
usual but lovely version of "Brown Girl and Fair
Ellender"

to the

time

1

associate with Burnett

and Rutherford's "Willie Moore," accompanied
only by his own banjo and harmonica. Now

that's old-time music. Scattered in between are
Grandpa's renditions of older, traditional mate
rial, songs like "Willis Mayberry," a variant of
the murder ballad "Hills of Roane County,"
"Groundhog," and others. Many of these songs
first appeared on an album Grandpa recorded in
1963 in response to tire Folk Music Revival,
which was then in full swing. (The album was

called Grandpa Jones Sings
to be found are tributes

Real Folk Songs.)

Also

Jimmie Rodgers,
songs from the Carter Family, a fair number of
songs from the pen of Grandpa himself, and a
couple from his wife, Ramona.
Disc 3 contains my favorites
a tribute to the
Brown's Ferry Four, a group that Grandpa re
corded with in the 1940s that included the
Delmore Brothers, Merle Travis, and at times,
to

Red Foley or Qyde Moody. For this material
Grandpa got together with Ramona, Red Rector,
and Merle Travis and recorded with just four
voices and guitar with occasional mandolin by
Red. The results sound much like another pio

neering gospel quartet,

Tire Chuck

which suits my tastes just fine.
rial like this that

It

Wagon Gang,
was the mate

made wading through the rest
if they'd just reissue that

worthwhile. Now,
King material.

JIM

NELSON

�folksong sainthood by focusing the spotlight on
the compiler and thereby relegating the music
he compiled to secondary status. Just in case the
fat set of notes fails to make the point, you can
take the last of the six CDs, put it in to a computer
and see clips from Harry's films, photos of Harry
with Allen Ginsberg, Harry inarticulately re
ceiving a Grammy, and Harry with some col
lected American Indian artifacts. Quite your
renaissance man and fa-a-r out dude, was Harry

in the 1920s,

Smith.

served

Well, okay. Certainly the music can stand on
its own legs and withstand

being upstaged by
Smith's celebrants. If itseems strange in this
context to elevate addiction, deterioration, and
Mr.

funny movies over the artistry

of Tom

Ashley,

John Hurt, the Carters, and Blind Lemon,

the

approach succeeds in turning a
project which simply converts an old LP set to
compact disc to a must-liave souvenir for folk
revival baby-boomers, sentimentally reuniting
them with their vicarious rural roots and giving
them the music that ostensibly inspired their
musical and political heroes.
If this sounds like a
negative review, don't
Smithsonian

I

mean for

it to. Me,

I

would never have dreamed

good marketing ploy, nor would have
managed to turn a recycled set of ancient hill
billy, blues, and gospel music into a best-seller,
projected, they tell me, to sell hi excess of 30,000
of such

a

I

units by Christmas.
And I have to give Harry Smith a lot of credit,
too. In 1952, when jazz was the only 1920s music
available on reissues, it took vision and courage

to assemble a collection of early folk and ver
nacular music by unknown performers, to hear
the music's integrity, and to annotate and as

semble his selections into
project. Smith was able
and regional
to

address

a

to

a

thoughtful reissue

ignore racial, stylistic,

divisions by allowing his materials
variety of topics under broad cat

egories of narra tive ballads, dance, and religious
music and lyric songs, thus creating dialogues
on agriculture between Charlie Patton and the

record

companies who fortunately saw their
as capturers of folk and regional

role simply

music

in

situ. Later, the role of record makers

inevitably evolved to become creators of massmarketed lowest common denominator prod
ucts destined for the least discriminating and
widest possible audiences. How fortunate, then
and now, that so much quality music was re
corded beforehand under favorable conditions
and that

it

was inadvertently

pre

follow.

for our time and times to

For this reissue, Smithsonian project coordi
nator Jeff Place had to resort in many cases to
1 951-2
tape transfers made by Peter Bartok (yes,
Bela's son) for the original LP set. In other cases,
collector copies of clean originals were available
for transfer on the

modern equipment. Inevita

bly sound quality varies from one track to the

next, though it is never unacceptable.
For those who d like to hear more of the same,
and who enjoy the anthology format, Richard

Nevins has been creating
music collections

a

series of old-time

recent years for Shanachie's
Yazoo label, containing material from the 1920s
and 1930s which compares favorably in quality
in

temperament and spirit

to

music

in the

Harry

Smith set. Nevins'

taste is usually impeccable
and the quality of his sound restoration from 78s
to CDs is, too. Double-CD sets get released every

month

or two, and unless you've heard most of
those rare old 78s he has access to, you'll encoun

exciting and surprising music with each new
Like They Used to Be: Early Ameri
can Rural Music, released last summer, contains
encores from Pop Stoneman, Henry Thomas,
Banmon Grayson, Cannon's JugStompers, Uncle
Dave Macon and others in the Smithsonian set,
ter

one. Times Ain't

along with stellar performances by Bobby
Leecan's Need More Band, Charlie Jordan, A. A.
Gray, the Southern Moonlight Entertainers and
others which may be new to most of us. At
October's end another double set appeared, The
Rose Grew 'Round the Briar: Early American Rural
Love Songs, drawing yet more water from the

Carolina Tar Heels, on ancientballadry between

same well with

Tom Ashley, Coley Jones, and Buell Kazee, and
on courtship between the Stonemans, Rabbit

and obscure performers.
Notes on the Yazoo sets are minimal, with
brief artist bios (at least when something of an

Brown, and Dock Boggs, allowing the listener to
discover where their points of view varied and
converged. Smith enhanced his collection by

creating

a

delightfully idiosyncratic set

of record

judicious mixture

a

of

celebrated

artist is known) and nice vintage photos. There's
even

little comment on the songs themselves,

though remarkable examples

of

narrative bal

notes which managed to appear simultaneously
primitive and scholarly, and which aided the

lads, memorable blues and lyric songs, folk pieces
and dance tunes abound. If this constitutes a

introduction of young urban listeners to remote
musical traditions.
Not, of course, that any of this would have

demerit, it's made up for by generous timings
(23 78 RPM sides per CD) and by the relatively
low cost, at least by comparison with the

mattered
such

a

if

the music

wallop. And

it

itself hadn't delivered
did, recycling blues and
from

extinct

regional
hillbilly masterpieces
record catalogues, and introducing Mississippi
John, Uncle Dave, Uncle Bruit, jugstompers, and
string bands to Folkways buyers weaned on
Woody, Huddie,
Susan

Reed.

Pete, John

Intuitively

Smith stumbled on

a

or

Jacob Niles, and

otherwise, Harry

mother lode, created

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

by

Smithsonian collection.
I've already picked a number of my own
favorites, but I'll resist the temptation to list

them. It'd be

wouldn't want

a

long list, for one thing, and I
keep you from compiling lists

to

allow myself to cheer Yazoo
unearthing extraordinary versions of "Silver
Dagger" ("Wake Up, You Drowsy Sleeper") and
of your own. I'll just

for

"Poor Boy" ("Dollar Bill Blues"), and for getting

nice transfers of "I Truly Understand You Love
Ano titer Man" and "Look On And Cry" on to CD
for the first time.

that

Thaf

powerful lead

to

s Clyde Moody singing
Wade Mainer's tenor on

that last one, by the way.
DICK SPOTTSWOOD

�produced, hands-on products with real photos
hand affixed to thej-cards. But then the music is
hands-on, home-made. On
just that as well
Public Domain, Carl's two beautiful kids sit grin
a
piano bench in the background; T wen ty
features a photo that just might have been
taken at some late fall barbeque in these parts,
judging from the way the boys are grinning at
a 300
something mysterious in the foreground
gal. cooker mebbe??

ning on
Years

My point is, these two cassettes document the
old- time music as it is, as it lives, in its

real stuff

urban environment, still entirely accoustic after
all these years. I enjoyed them both.
To Order:

WM.N. HICKS
Michael Fishback 1313 Clarendon St

Durham 27705/919-286-9275.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�lias to be found anywhere,

it

might

be that the

band is vocally reticent on the breakdowns.
The real strength of this recording, and the
key to its listenability,

is the balance

afforded

by

well-placed songs. Debbie's wonderful rendi
tion of Ola Belle Reed's "I've Endured," and
Debbie and Brian's harmonized versions of
"Dixie Darlin'," "Say, Darlin, Say," and "Down
in the Willow Garden"
are testament to the
and
Jim
AI, besides bringing
pair's versatility.
tasteful accompaniment and fills, contribute ex
citing variation with guitar-bass duets; first, the

flat-picked version

of theSkillet Lickers, "I Don't
Love Nobody" and later the syncopated, fingerpicked rendition of the Carters, "Victory Rag."
Brian's own "Michelle's Waltz" is a graceful and

inspiring conclusion to this panoramic outing
a
perfect segue back to the first track.
In many ways, this may be among the most
mature offerings by a "youngish" group of oldand

time musicians. It is crafted like a good live
performance, and remains mindful of the spaces
and moods that happen within and between the
tracks. It contains all the high-powered old-time

fiddle-banjo music anyone could want without
the numbing repetition. The effect is to leave the
listener not just a wed, but moved, refreshed and
invigorated. By every measure that matters, this
one's another "guess-I've-gotta-get-it" record
ing for fans of old-time string-band music.
CHARLIE GRAVEL

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�One of the problems

is the

mix, taken

as is

show. The banjo and guitar
are decently balanced, but the vocals are far too
loud in proportion to the instruments. Some
"off the board" at the

times necessary volume and EQ adjustments
that make sense in the particular acoustic envi

ronment

of

a

room make for unbalanced

tape

recordings. Perhaps thatis whathappened here.
When have to choose between straining to hear
the instruments or being blasted by the vocals
well, I'll just choose to listen to some other tape.
Rhythm is another problem. The liner notes
indicate tha tStover and Martin are playing much
I

of their

repertoire "together for virtually the first

time." Most of the music on this tape is "virtu
ally" grooveless. There is no rhythmic unity at
all

until the sixth piece and then even the two

players don't always agree on the beat for the
remainder of the program. There is a nearly
continuous rhythmic strain between Martin's
easy lope and Stover's forward propulsion that
makes for some very uncomfortable listening.
The notes

also promise "incredible creativity
going on 'behind the scenes' as (Stover) lays
down one imaginative backup phrase after an
other during Mac's vocals." While thereissome
of this
occasionally (and it is very, very good)
usually Stover is playing the usual stuff.
If you've got a spare ten-er and want to hear
one

great performance

(Old Reuben

with

HI,

superb vocals by Stover and guitar and
(clawhammer) banjo that definitely agree rhyth
mically,) five other pretty good renditions, some
local ambiance, and hillbilly humor, and

a

scattered moments

is tire

of banjo

tape for you. Otherwise,
on his Dixie

brilliance, this

few

check out Mac Martin

Travelers recordings and Don Sto

ver with The Lilly Brothers. Listen to Cold, Grei/
Tomb of Stone and see if you still think bluegrass
banjo playing is tiresome and mechanical. See if
vou're still breathing.
JODY STECHER

order: White Oak Records, 3516 Highland
Ave Finleyville PA 15332.
To

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�From these people, the children learned tilings in
way they would be hard pressed to duplicate

is

was like

to hear

what the older people had

to

elsewhere.

say, what they thought of it, how they reacted to
it, what it meant to them. There are also three

of

musical selections,

a

In 87-year-old Atlia Thacker's story
having to work in the mines to help support
the family after his mother died, there is a simple,
casual reference to black lung. It puts that dis
ease into con tex in a way no textbook or govern
t

ment report could

possibly equal. Hearing

Arthur Slater tell what

it

was like

to

listen, on the

community, to a Joe Lewis
match
boxing
puts technological change into an
entirely new prospective. And there is nothing
first radio

in

the

Gladys Milton's description of
delivering babies, which ends: 'The sweetest
music this side of heaven is a newborn baby
Sometimes wish you could see it."
crying.
Dana Williams and Lillian Deihl must have
opened some eyes when they described doing
clinical

about

I

winter before soap powder and wash
laundry
machines.
They took an ax and cutice, which
ing
in

they melted
of soap

to

in a pot for the water. "We had a bar
We didn't have no
wash with.

washing powders. And you had

to cut that

soap

up and put it in the wash pot to make your suds
all those
like they use now for when they have

expensive powders."
It

is the

voices

of these

people that are the

heart and soul of this album, and it is hard not to
regret that there is not more of this material. Tha t

would have defeated the purpose of the album,
however, which is to balance the testimony of
the old people against the songs of the children.
The project is largely the work of Larry Long.

Described in tire album notes as "a musician,
community organizer, father, and educator" as
well as "a true American troubadour" (Studs
Terkel), Larry Longhas been working with

PAC

develop what is referred to as "an intergenerational curriculum, mixing oral history and
ERS to

song writing." The idea of having older people
speak to children in schools and then having the
children write songs based on what they heard
sounds admirable. am not quite sure how well
I

actually worked, however. The songs are
copyrighted by Larry Long but are credited
it

all
to

Larry Long and the children of the various grade
school classes before whom the old people spoke.
to know how much the songs
It is not possible
are the

product

of the

children and how much

they are the result of adult coaching. Musically,
the songs are of a sort perhaps best enjoyed in the

context

of the Here

1

Stand project and, indeed,

may be most appreciated by the principals them
selves. All of them are restatements of materia]
the children heard from the elders, but none of

them

is as

as the

eloquent

original testimony.

moreserious problem, however,

is that

A

thesongs

give little, if any, insight into how the children
actually reacted to what they heard. Coached
group song composition may not be best way to
provide such insight. It seems a little that some
one may have shoehorned
musical context into which

into

doesn't really

a

fit

would cheerfully trade all of
recordings of children telling what

very comfortably.
the songs for

this project
it

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

fiddle instrumental

and

two choral sacred performances, whose place in
this album is unclear. Neither their context on
the album

or the

accompanying notes tell

us

into the overall project.
Even so, this album still deserves respect as a
document of a remarkable project. It ends, ap
propriately enough, with advice by Walter
how they

fit

Frederick Bro wder who was born

in

1

926: "Wha

t

say to you is to do as well as you can on your
schooling. You may need it someday, notnecesI

sarily
about

to

make

a

living, but

to

make

a

life. That

s

it."

Indeed

it is.

A.V.

SHIRK

�and singing. The same elements are there
five albums: hammer dulcimer, a

as in his first

Carter Family song, banjo, singing, autoharp,
guitar, and mountain dulcimer. He has added
some new sounds and has some guest artists,
but this is

essentially

a

well done old-time al

bum. As you look over the list of the tames, there
are few surprises except for the couple of origi
nal tunes. These originals nestle in well with the

others. One change is

a

darker, more mature side

McCutcheon, which,

of

in my

come addition. Overall, this is
and one you will want to own.

opinion,
a

is

a

wel

fine recording,

The CD booklet has song words, sources, the
personnel on each cut, and tunings for the banjo

fiddle

or

to read

if they are out of the ordinary It is
easy
and follow, and as a D] I appreciate

I

also sense

hurried

trip to one's home
funeral. While there,
one meets again one's relatives and old friends,
at various get-togethers. Although the old con
tacts are made and the favorite tunes are played
I

town for

at

a

of

party

a

or

a

wedding

or

rawpowerof the songjust fine, withoutsomuch
didgeridoo.
An abrupt change of mood occurs with the
next song, the Carter family's "Over the Garden
Wall," complete with autoharp, with a more
gentle approach in the singing, and with Iris

Dement

on

monds,"

the title cut, is in

the harmony

part.

"Jack

of

a

two, the expatriate has no intention
to stay. His life is else

moving back home

where. This CD has many musical memories,
especially of old-time music, but has little newly

Dia

Tommy Jarrell's style
but with Steve Riley's Cajun accordion and with
Robin &amp; Linda Williams on vocals. You can't
have a McCutcheon album without hammer
dulcimer. "Wheels/Tim the Turncoat" are done
with piano, a New England contra-style arrange
ment. These are tunes that John and his
time hammer dulcimer mentor, Paul

having the cuts numbered and timed, both in the
booklet and on the back of the jewel case.
couldn't ask for anything more, in the way of
documentation. The recording quality and bal
ance is excellent.
It seems
to me that the songs represent a
musical journey, from discontent to content
ment.

"Reuben," you can hear that Stamper dulcimer.
think the dulcimer could have conveyed the

1

long
Van

Arsdale, discovered independently, he says.
Hammer dulcimer players will be anxious to
learn and play these tunes, too. John touches
base with his union/activist side with Woody
Guthrie's "Ludlow Massacre." The tasteful ar

rangement uses cello. John's voice now becomes
older and more serious.
Instead of a dreamy, nostalgic version of
"Sweet Sunny

South," John takes on

a

more

savage persona with gutsy voice and insistent

steel-stringed guitar. "Why was
roam?"

now

I

tempted

to

painful chant, yet the upbeat,
worldly, "pop" arrangement, to me, says that it
is

a

won't be easy for the sojourner to adjust to the
quiet life of the country he thinks he misses.
"The Yellow Rose of Texas" is a straightfor

uncovered traditional material

in that genre.
"Who'll Rock the Cradle," a McCutcheon origi
nal, and the first cut
sparsely arranged with

ward old-time version; "The Heaven's Wake,"
John's other songwriting effort is sung from a
17-year-old housemaid's point of view, about

what sounds like

fretless banjo timed dADAB,
expresses the conflict

McCutcheon

loosing

her lover

at

sea.

and Johnson's mandolin

changes

his voice

to

tell

between John's need to be out in the public eye
and his desire to be home with his wife and

Bangor," is a hammer dulcimer original which
runs into "Morrison's Jig," the war-horse from

family. This song sets the tone for the CD, the
almost frantic late-night drive, trying to get
"home."

reel. Jesse

McCutcheon goes on to examine another facet
to get home" thread on the next
oneof
ait, "Reuben,"
McCutcheon'sexperiments
don't
with African drums and ciidgeridoos.

piece, but the didgeridoo is not so overpowering
and even adds to the ominous tone of the subject

a

of the "trying

I

mind the drums, because I can easily associate
old-time music with the rhythms of Africa, and

slaves who brought such a strong influ
American music, but the didgeridoo, in
my opinion, is a distraction. On "Reuben"
probably wouldn't have minded the didgeridoo
so much, but the use of that instrument covered
to

1

up the sound of that wonderful old mountain
dulcimer that I.D. Stamper built. I.D. Stamper,

Kentucky, built mountain dulci
mers that had a booming, distinctive sound.
"Reuben" is McCutcheon's tribute to Stamper,
to the memories of the times when McCutcheon
used to roam the backroads of American music,
from eastern

collecting traditional songs and styles. The harddriving arrangement, in fact, is reminiscent of
how I.D. might have played
real

closely

to

the

it. So,

instrumental

if

story.

again
"Road to

McCutcheon's second album, turned here in to a
Smith adds to the excitement with
some fiery fiddling.
"Oh Death" is another

didgeridoo-and-drums

matter of this Dock Boggs piece. "Hangman's
Reel," another fiddle and banjo piece, shows off
John's proficiency on both instruments. "Time
Has Made a Change in Me" has a gospel-style

wi til the

ence

the

you listen

breaks on

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

piano accompaniment, and "Cumberland Gap"
finishes up the CD as it star ted, with sparse banjo
and mandolin arrangement. Maybe this starts a
trend, and we'll hear more old-time music from
McCutcheon in the future.
PAT WALKE

�is very good
it's just not as expressively
developed as, say, Cliff Perry and Laurel Bliss,
or Jody

Steelier and Kate Brislin.

I've been thinking about the push and pull
between old and new in old-time music. The

musicians

admire most are those who

I

try as

hard as they can to get exactly right the sounds
of their favorite old sources. It's
marvelous

when we can figure out those subtle techniques,
and when we can soiuid just like our teachers
and inspirations. But I'm not sure there's a point

putting on a commercial CD m usic tlia sounds
exactly like music that already exists on com
mercial CD, as, what with all these great re
issues, so much now does. The new music love
in

t

I

hear on recordings (I think) is that which
tries like hell to not sound new, which does its

best

to

darndest

to

emulate its sources, but that, despite
a little different. That's
why like

itself, sounds

I

the Rhythm Rats. Their "Prodigal Son," though

clearly based on Dock Boggs's version, sounds
slightly different simply because it has been
adapted to a string-band setting. In Jackson's
fiddling we clearly hear the feel and detail of the
source, whether Marcus Martin, Ed Haley, or
John Salyer, yet the music sounds like no one but
Jackson, though the distinctions are difficult to
pinpoint.
Another example

how

respect the past is
Lynn." Jackson, who plays it
beautifully, learned it from Birch Monroe, who
learned it from his famous Uncle Pen and played
of

to

the time "Jenny

it

on Uncle Pen's

fiddle.

past commemorated

I'd much ra ther hear the

in this rich

andsweetfiddle

nostalgic song with a hokey
shuffled fiddle break in the middle. (I love Bill
Monroe in general, but his song "Uncle Pen" to
me represents all that can go wrong with good
musical intentions.)
The best production for old-time music is
time than

in

a

music sounds like you're
nothing's been done to it: no
phasers, shifters, reverberators. But in order to
get music to sound like nothing's been done to it,
sometimes lots has to be done to it. Therefore
invisible; that

sittingnext

is, the

to it, as if

I

praise Bob Carlin for the "insight" the notes
credit him with he knows how to produce
MOLLY TEN ENBAUM

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�New York City
like
And,
many of his
fine fiddler and singer, and like

many of his fellows, became

policeman

in

fellows he was

a

the '20s
a

not so many, he had the good fortune and oppor
tunity to make many 78 RPM records during the
heyday of old-time commercial recording, the
'20s, and into the '30s. This disc is but

a

represen

tative sample of his music. He can also be heard
on one cut of the mouth-music disc reviewed in
vol.

6

no. 2, and he

performs mouth-music here

often surging a fiddle time and then
fiddling it in a kind of one-man-band fashion.
This is a delightful recording, and it grew on
as

well

me as

listened

1

to it. At first

I

thought

it

might

"popular Irish" side of things over
there where Irish eyes are smiling and (as my

fall into the

says) "omygod it's, it's, it's
Brigadoon!" Not so. Quinn is a fine, clean fid
not so spectacular as his contemporary,
dler
daughter

Michael Coleman, but well worth learning from
His songs range from the political ('The Shan
Van Vough," which is a
title but speaks to Irish

wonderfully mysterious
independence and must

a
meaning known to some OTH reader) to
historical ("Far Away in Australia") to the
Came
possibly double en tendemic "One Nigh
Home to My Kitty"), to the sentimental ("An

have
the

1 1

Farewell"). There are also a couple of fine
with an unnamed woman singer, and
these put me in mind of my favorite Irish duet,
Shane MacGowan of the Pogues and Kris tie
McColl singing "Christmas Eve in the Drunk
Irish

duets

fact, hearing Frank Quinn sing these
immigration, of sailing off to Australia
and such, put the Pogues into a deeper context
for me
McGowan cannot be unaware of these
Tank."

songs

In

of

optimistic precedents. Whatever, if you enjoy
Irish music and are interested in it's early re
corded manifestations, Frank Quinn should be
part of your collection.
WM.N. HICKS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�clawhammer banjo, this release will not

be of

prime interest to you; give it a listen if you want
to hear urbane, personal, and highly developed
musicality applied to the tradition, along with

some nicely conceived and played new
contemporary pieces.
and

ART ROSENBAUM

Merri weather Records, 109 Crawford
Rose Dr. Aurora, Ont. L4G 4S1 Canada; email
ragged@interlog.com; fax 905-841 -01 9; ph 905-

To order:

1

841-1879; $15 US/ $18 Can inc. postage.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�"Draggers' Reel" by saying, "I was draggin' for
flounder and cod, and the motor was makin' so
much noise, and
got annoyed with that, with
said to meself,
the noise, y'know, and
said,
'I'm goin, to make a time outa that,
get so tired
come home one night and made a
of that/ so
tune, and called it 'The Dragger's Reel.'" And
it's a good one. It's like Rev. Gary Davis once
I

I

I

I

I

I

I

heard a little voice inside my watch
more faith in Jesus.'"
'Little
sayin'
Yet P.E.I, is not so isolated that there aren't
sang:

wisps

"I

of

tunes almost everyone knows,

but

played the P.E.I, way This is maybe the best way
to understand style. Perhaps the most striking of
these

is "St.

Anne's Reel" on the Western vol

ume. As Perlman says, "The common North
first reached
American time, 'St. Anne's Reel'
the Island in the 1930s via broadcasts from
Quebec. Since step-dancers were unable to get
lift from tire time in its original form,
as
alterations had to be made in its melody
"
can be heard in the version by Dennis Pitre

good

(If this were written in hyper-text or Java or
something, you could now hear a snatch of the
Oh well, buy the
tune by clicking on it's title
collection!) A nice thing to do on a cold winter's
night would be to read Shipping News by the fire
with these CDs playing in the background. Now

put the book down for

a

minute and think about

what the phrase "good lift" might mean.
At another level, when I said the musicians
mean they aren't
I didn't
very good players. Most play for local dances,
and would surely be a joy to dance to. (They give
aren't professionals,

"good lift.") Though the accompanying pianos

and guitars (and pump organs!!) are sometimes
too far back in the mix for my taste, the backup

also great, and well worth studying and think
are
ing about. Indeed, if you are a player, and
tunes
is
of
dance
like
repertoire
feeling
your
is

getting, well, stale, just sit down and learn some

these tunes. I'll bet no one on your block is
playing "Island Boy" or "The Miramichi Fire,"
east or west P.E.I, versions, as yet. And do work
of

on the "Cock of the

North/Uncle

Jim" medley.

With these times under your belt,

or in

your

noggin, or wherever times get stored, you'll
surely get more calls to play for dances.
seem to be awash in superlatives. Do you get
the picture? (The CD booklets feature great pho
tos of all the fiddlers. Surprise!) Get these two
CDs. Listen to them a whole lot. That's an order.
I

WM.N.

HICKS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�flatpick. He recorded way back

Tc.trts-Working All Day Long/Grizzly Bear/
Down the Line/I Believe I'll Call My Baby /Big

and

omed Man's Blues? Hey Hey/
It Done? /John Henry/Blues in
E /The McPeake Family-]ug of Punch/Will You
Bill Broonzy-VJ

How You Want

Go?/Instrumental/Oro

Lassie

Go

Pete Steeh'-Pay

at

Day

Coal Creek/Coal Creek

prisoners

March/Galilee/Oklahoma Fiddle Contest/
Schuyler Michael- Two

in

believe,

a

Texas penitentiary. Each man has

white hat and outfit. Following the
vocal cues of the song leader they fell several
an ax, and

Tunes/Waltz/Soldier's

a

then chop them into smaller logs,
while singing the kind of songs that used to
accompany this kind of work before the prison
used chain saws. The haunting music is unfor

trees, and

Joy.
For

1

1

Beacht/

Se

in 1932,

has all the stock-in-trade

flat-picked G
licks that are now associated with bluegrass
wonder if this was how Bill Monroe's
music.
blues mentor, Arnold Shultz played guitar.
There is a 1964 "historic re-enactment" by
it

some time now, Stefan Grossman, through

his Vestapol series, has been making available
high quality musical "footage" that was hitherto

dispersed, inaccessible

lost. He's

or

virtually
performances from documen
tary and commercial and "art" films, from old
television shows and various video formats.
these

gathered

Here's an outstanding compilation taken from
by Pete, Toshi, and Dan
Seeger during their travels and stored in their

gettable, especially

a

song called "Working

All

Day Long."
Tha t's no t all There's Sonny T erry doing some

uncharacteristic

out-blowing, having

a

buck-

dancing con test with his nephew J. C. Burris,and
playing "The Chicken Reel." There's the famous

home movies taken

Quebecois fiddler Jean Carignan playing French,
Scottish, and Irish times with alternating long

barn for over 30 years.

sweeps and single bowing and doing an impres
sion of southern fiddling that is something like

Did you ever wonder exactly how Pete Steele
played TheCoal Creek March and Pay Day At Coal
Creek
Here he is, playing at home, wearing a

checked shirt that matches his fingerboard in
lays, and his banjo technique is as clear

as

day.

"Sally Goodin" in D. Then there's the bizarre but
inexplicably affecting music of the McPeake Fam
ily of Belfast (what other band needs or wants
their entire instrumentation to consist of two

glorious. He does another piece too, and in
each piece he picks the banjo in a slightly differ

harps

ent way.

McPeake!!)

It's

There's

a

series

fiddle contest

in

segments taken at a
Oklahoma in 1957 that is abso
of short

lutely fascinating. This
the

is

from an era just before

western con test fiddling style "madeperma-

music. In the accompanying well-assembled
booklet written by Mary Katherine Aldin, in
which Pete Seeger is quoted extensively con
cerning his memories of the filming sessions,
Seeger admits to being "not a good folklorist."
don't know the names

players and

of the

the tune names are not given. The latter are not
hard to recognize. We hear good and unusual
of
"Say Old Man, Can You Play a
Fiddle?", "Soldier's Joy," a good time you can
hear the fiddler tell his accompanist is "Grey
Eagle," but sounds like parts of times I know by

versions

other names, "Mississippi Sawyer," and "The
Mardi Gras Jig," of all things! watched thatone
I

with my eyes like saucers.
was a Cajun on vacation.

I

wonder

if the

an

at

a

summer camp

in

fiddler

last session

Then there's Big Bill Broonzy's

filmed

Michigan. He had

operation the very next day and never sang

again .I've always enjoyed listening to Broonzy's
recordings and the appreciation is deepened by
the visual

dimension. His relaxed attitude, sig

nature fingerstyle, and surprising two-finger E
chord are all there to see. About the latter, it's
right there up there with Ina Patterson's thumb-

on-the-bass G chord that some OTH readers
from the western states might recall. And he
does one of my favorite old Big Bill songs, "How
Do You Want

It

Done?",

played

in

G

with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

three sets of Uilleann

bagpipes
named Francie
They do their most famous songs
are each and all

and it's great. The only

video
I

is the

do wish

disappointment

in this

final segment of some so-so fiddling.
there were more Oklahoma fiddle

footage and wonder what other films the Seegers
have in their barn. This video should be in every
I

press out of Leather B r itches," (as Kenny Hall ably
put it). This is real old-time fiddling and good

So we

and

whose players

a

in America and shown on prime-time
television. Some of von mieht want one. too.

library

JODY

STECHER

�This video features four truly

wonderful and

important artists performing several tunes each.
Each musician sits in a chair and plays; nothing
there is no narration, no voice-over,
is added

accom

and only the most minimal of titles. The

panying booklet, written
up for this

by Jody Steelier,

makes

plainness with extensive biographi

anecdotes, some great
one
of
photos (including
Tommy Jarrell taken
about 1917
and detailed notes on the tunes. It is
cal

information,

hi teres ting

booklet suitable for
beginner's hi traduction to old-time music, and
video for the hard-core only.

an odd

combination:

a

a

Blues," "Pretty Polly," and

I

Hope Live," and
he tells the story of how he auditioned and then
traveled to New York to make his first record
"I

I

ings. He mentions having "domestic troubles"
that caused him to give up music and go back to
mining. He keeps an underlying and perhaps
ironic smile going throughout the music (even
introducing "I Hope Live" as "a love song"),
I

and seems an utterly charming man. It's great to
get a personal sense of him, and great also to see
his banjo playing and hear his singing up close.
The booklet describes his playing in detail, and

gives the banjo tunings, while in the video there
are several good shots of his right hand. On "I
Hope Live" he does several of his chilling vocal
I

shivers, and we see that no outrageous contor
tions take over his face or throat.

doesn't look
of his music

at all
as

fact,

In

like his music sounds:

I

tough; but here he is,

a

friendly man

in a

know

if

we're inside them or out? This video

offers non-verbal answers. Just listen to Roscoe
Holcomb. It's obvious that he's completely in a
tradition, and completely original.

Nevertheless,

tire

Holcomb experience

is

hard

get here. Of the performers on the video, as
Steelier puts it, "lie makes the least apparent

he

concession
was

shirt

listener, but by all accounts he
this footage

In

seems rather small, and the music doesn't
sound as big as suspect it really was. Neverthe
I

less, this is superb banjo playing on "Black Eyed
Susie." And we see up close that Holcomb's
guitar style on "Pretty Polly," with the thumb
and the first finger, is just about the same as his
banjo style on "Old Smokey." His singing here
doesn't nail you to the wall like the singing on

some

of his other

recordings, but that isn't

the

fault of his singing. Something about the film
simply makes him seem very distant. Perhaps
the camera is too far back. Or perhaps there's not
enough sense of the audience here. Holcomb
plays on a stage, but there is no evidence of an
audience. Anyway, dapper, thin, playing a banjo
time at breakneck speed while barely moving
his fingers or his face
it's good to see film of
him even if it doesn't capture his whole sound.

ne roocage

i

amazing music coming out

to the

spellbinding performer."

a

he

think

deep and dark and strange and

and tie, with all this

What are the parameters we should stay within?
Why should we stay within them? How do we

to

don't know other
wise. He sings three songs, his classic "Country
of him, and

lated." It's pretty tricky to think about: How do
we possess for our own the music we assimilate?

a

The Dock Boggs footage is the prize of this
video. According to the box, this is the "only

known footage"

process of absorbing and then putting forth "in
personal terms" and "within certain parameters,"
the music thathas been "received" and "assimi

or

i

ommy jarreu

is

more lrri car

ing than anything else Whoever held the camera
was having too much fun dissolving from one

shot

to

another to pay very much attention
the viewer is getting a good look

to

of him.

whether

The footage of Kilby Snow and the footage of
Roscoe Holcomb are equally good. We can watch

Jarrell's bow. For a lot of the time we see his face
and about two inches from the middle of the

the way Snow holds the autoharp flat, and the
way he gets melody and pick-up notes by stop
ping his finger and drawing it up two or three

bow. Or we get his torso, plus fiddle, plus bowminus right hand. However, the music is
tip

strings. His fluid and relaxed wrist will probably
be an inspiration to any musician, not only

autoharpists. What he can do with the autoharp
the rhythms in "Cindy," and the
amazing
corners
in "Chicken Reel"
well, wow.
sharp

is

1

love his version of "Shady Grove"

it's the two-

part one where each part ends on the 5-chord.
Steelier points out that "His version turns out to

pentatonic "Shady Grove" known
with tire tonic
Appalachia and beyond
note taken to be one step low. The shift of the
tonic anchor transforms the song without actu
be the same

at

good: Blanton Owen accompanies on banjo, and
Mike Seeger on guitar (thumb on thebassstrings,
fingers on the treble, no picks), and the band
sound is truly hot. After "Breaking Up Christ
mas," Tommy smiles in pleasure and satisfac
tion. Also in this part of the video, the perform
we
ers do seem to be playing to an audience
see

a

few shadows of people

si

tting

in

chairs, and

get the impression that there are more people
out there. The audience presence gives the mu

all over

sic warmth and friendliness that is not present hi
the Snow or Holcomb segments. (Oddly enough,

ally changing the tune."
This tune seems to me an example of one of
the possible themes of this video, if it has a

no sign of an audience. There is
one cut of Jarrell playing the banjo
"Cripple
Creek"
sweet and rolling, delicate and deliber
ate, smooth and forceful all at once. But surely
there must be better film of Tommy somewhere.

theme: each of these performers is a model of
how an individual musician can speak creatively
and personally through older musical forms.
Stecher's notes emphasize this issue, saying that
"Old-time music becomes authentic not in the
mimicry of a static received tradition," but in a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

this warmth is present in the Boggs segment,

though there's

The music is good, but the picture just makes
you want to tear out your hair.

Completely missing from the booklet and the
video are details about how, why, and where

these films were made. We are told that Kilby
hi Seattle in 1970, Boggs in
Newport, Rhode Island hi 1966, Jarrell at Black

Snow was filmed

Hawk College hi Moline, Illinois in 1976, and
Holcomb in Seattle hi 1972. The titles at the end
thank Alan Lomax, Mike Seeger, Black Hawk
and the University of Washington
Ethnomusicology Archives for the footage, but,
except for the Tommy Jarrell/Black Hawk Col

College,

lege part, it is not clear what source is respon
sible for what film, though we might guess from
the location of the Boggs footage that it was
taken during a Newport Folk Festival. would
I

like to know much

more about

these perfor

mances. Were these concerts? Workshops? Folk
Festivals? I'd like to have more of a sense of what
brought each

of these

talents

to the

place and

time these films were made.

Molly Tenenbaum

�Reunion cassette, the County LPs Country Fid
dling from the Big State and Texas Hoedown, and
jam session tapes.
As far as I know, there are no films or videos

playing, so it's impossible to say if the
and
fingerings are perfectly accurate
bowings
besides, Benny was pretty free in varying the
way he played his tunes, especially in jam ses
of Benny

listened to some of the originals, and
heard with what's on the pa
what
compared
accurate to me.
it
looks
and
very
per,
We all know that simply playing the same
notes that another fiddler plays will not make
sions. But

I

I

like that fiddler.

you sound

fingerings and bowings
enough. I've listened
and

to

the

Even doing

the

same way isn't

plenty of Benny's play

consider

myself a pretty good
But
when
treader.
propped the music up in
sigh
ing,

I

I

front of me and read through some of the tunes,

didn't somid like Benny. However,
understand better how he put all
those notes together, and what went into pro
ducing that inimitable Benny Thomasson sound.
This book is an invaluable resource for any
(surprise!)
I

was able

I

to

student of Benny Thomasson 's style. We are
fortunate that we can reap the benefit of Pete's
dedication to the painstaking task of transcrib
ing these wonderful and

challengingfiddle tunes.
VIVIAN WILLIAMS

Petimar Press, PO Box 33482, Seattle
WA 98133 Benny Thomasson homepage: http:/

To order:

www.halcyon.com/pethnar/bennyhom. htm.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�t;

MARIMAC

Now THIS is old time music!

THE LATEST RELEASES
THE VOLO BOGTROTTERS

Stringband with Vocal Accompaniment. An old time stringband with five
1920's and five feet in the 1990's. plays an infectious brand of classic old time music. Well known for their full and
fiddle sound, here they reveal their superb musical flexibility with occasional instrumental mixes that include a slide
and various banjo and mando-family instruments. All five members share spirited vocal harmonies. "It's wonderful,
F. Gosar KLCC-FM; "I can see why they are called the Grateful Dead of old time music because
of the old 78 's.
vecome a Boghead myself' G. Johnson, KA UR_FM
9067D $14.95
9067C
$9.95.

feet in the
driving twin
guitar, a tipple
has the sounds
I 've

just

THE KONNAROCK CRITTERS Cornbread and Sweetpeas
A favorite collection of 17 old time tunes and songs,
The
authoritive and melodic fiddling of Brian Grim joins perfectly with Debbie's (his sister) rhythmic banjo playing Debbie placed first
in the old time banjo contest at Galax this year. The mastery of Jim Lloyd on guitar and A1 Firth on bass fiddle provide depth and a
solid foundation for a rousing full string band sound. Brian's and Debbie's harmonies resurrect some of the beautiful family vocals
that were a tradition in the rural communities of the old South. Joe Wilson of the National Council of Traditional Arts comments,
"
"
There 's a push and shove, a fire in this music that echoes the western side of Grayson County, Virginia.
"(They) play with energy,
"
enthusiam and an infectious fire.
Dave Higgs, WPLN-FM
9068D $14.95
9068C
$9.95.
THE R YTHYM RA TS

Believe I'll

1

Home

Go Back

Their first CD is

collection of

a

"

archaic fiddle tunes, turn-of the-

century heart songs, mountain blues and ballads all are skillfully rendered with an evident love and respect for old time
music"... Bob Carlin. There is full string band sound of fiddle, banjo and guitar on many of the tunes as well as a less-is-better
approach to some, such as a fiddle solo a fiddle banjo duet, and several solos accompanied by a single instrument, ft is an
"Love it"... Lee Bolton, WOBO Radio

accomplished and inspiring performance.

9069D

Sally With The Run Down Shoe. "Simply

one of the most significant recordings of older old-time musicians

released

in

recent years"...Ga\\ Gillespie,

North Carolina Sand Hills. Dance

OTH review.

$14.05

BOB BOVEE AND GAIL HEIL

Rural

9D64C

Route

$9.95.

variety

Their first

CD-

collection

a

of

by an extaordinarily skilled duo who have been performing together it
forever. Kerry Blech, (OTH review) comments "They have an impeccable
sense of old time aesthetics... a great knack for carrying off some of the perky old-time

like

novelty pieces"..Ga\\
and rich harmonies

fiddle,

banjo; Bob

9066D

$14.95

guitar, harmonica,

9066C

THE DOUBLE DECKER STRING BAND
this "star"

I

banjo.

a

winner

9063D... $14.95.

$9.95..

Deep Hollows end High Ridges.

A

1

history

of

..$14.95.

23 cuts from previous

0364D..$

Marimac

DROP ZONE
Cassettes $7.00.
i

401 10.

CD

1

a

4.95. 9059C...$9.95.

Mountain Music-Mountain Struggle.

THE MARIMAC ANTHOLOGY
a

capella, old time and

Midwestern fiddle tunes with

classic. 9059D...$

favorites and original labor songs. 21 Tunes:
notes including

a

9063C...$9.95.

Midwest Harvest.

instrumental backup.

First CD for

401

Old country

1C...$9.95.

releases with extensive

4.95.

0364C..$9.95

-$12.00.

recordings will continue to be carried as long
materials to produce them. They are listed in

The
as

"drop

zone"

we have the

our

catalog.

They work at the important crossroads of southern

traditions: vocal and instrumental, and white and black, sacred and worldly. (They)
a roots-of-the-music
authenticity to their singing, without affected imitation: we

have

hear their own honest encounter with southern singing styles. ".Art Rosenbaum, OTH

review....9065D

of

Strong vocal leads

Chasing Rainbows.

GINNY HAWKER

"CHIRPS" SMITH

$0.95

revival old time string band. "The Double Deckers indeed have

with this superb release.

LYNN

ELAINE PURKEY
2.

&amp;

bluegrass harmonies.

Fiddle and banjo duo from the

superb material

seems

TRACY SCHWARZ

Traditional southern mountain singing styles including

to have been

tunas, sacred tunes, songs and old ballads, some now

quite obscure. 22 Tunes:..... 9064D

9069C

OTHER BEST SELLERS

"STILL NEW" RELEASES
A.C. OVERTON &amp; LAUCHLIN SHAW

$14.95

$14.95

9065C

We accept
To

$9.95.

Please mention that you saw our ad

Visa/Mastercard

Minimum credit card order

$15.00

order please call, fax or write

Marimac Recordings, Inc.
in

this issue.

P.O. Box 447, Crown Point, IN 46307

Phone 800-628-4507

Fax 219-662-6880

Shipping and handling:
f ret'

catalog:

lots of great old time music, early bluegrass,

early country blues, ethnic and contemporary

Phone 800-628-4507

Fax

219-662-6880

'1l
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

folk.

marimac@pla-net.net

USA: $2 for 1-2 items, $3 for 3 A items, $5 for 5+ items.
Non USA: $4 (minimum of 2 items)
$1 for each additional item.

Indiana residents must add 5% sales tax.
Prices subject to change without notice.

�Konnarock
Critters
The Reno

Section with Illegible Text

Brothers

HSIf,

Nickel Creek

lonesome
Timber
&amp;

15 More

Jul 31

Workshops
Demonstrations
Jam

For

Tickets And Info

&amp;

Displays

Camping

[Visa/MC Accepted]!

Or

Write:

Dluegrass,

PO Dox

607, Spooner Wl 54801

Day Ticket [includes camping) $35 Adv, $40 Gate. $32 Member
Day Ticket (no camping] $12 Adv, $15 Gate ($12 Sun), $11 Member

3
1

"

Old-Tlme Sq Dances

Crafts

MN

Call 1-000-035-3037

Sessions

Caiun Dance
Teen Actlvltes

The Woods Desort

IHrNW of Minneapolis

YetToBeHamed
Childrenss Activities

In

Zimmerman,

Bands

plus

Aug 1-2, 199S

&amp;

Camp

FESTIVAL

"

Top notch.

-Tim Graves, Tim Graves

&amp; Cherokee

"Great spirit and sense of fun.
-Bruce Molsky, Bruce Molsky

&amp; Big

Hoedown

"One of the very best we've been at
-David Davis,

"

A total

joy!"

The Warrior River Boys

"We were impressed by the high caliber of music.
-Laurie Lewis, Laurie Lewis

"

&amp; Grant Street

congratulated for making the event and the
music so kid friendly. " -Eddie &amp; Martha Adcock

"You are to be

Good Food

Oniformed Security
15 &amp; Dnder Free!!!
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

QQQschmitt
QCCjrnusic

now

Bluegrass

OCw centers.
Sponsored

By The

Section with Illegible Text

Minnesota Bluegrass

&amp;

Old-Time Music Association

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12034">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 6, Number 3 (Spring 1998)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12035">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 6, Number 3 (February-April 1998).&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Featured articles:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Notes from the Judges’ Booth,” by Molly Tennenbaum&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old-Time Music: Our Down Under Experience,” by Greg Shupe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Ron Hughey–Some Memories,” by Hank Bradley&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Festival Guide 1998!”&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Anna Wine; Stephane Grappelli; Bill Harrison; Garnett “Fiddlin’ Hank” Warren; and Rick Abrams.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12036">
                <text>1998</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2496" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3418">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/a3a3732db35a274e3dc1a3868f3a82af.pdf</src>
        <authentication>dd15c39ed17cc66e8836894206d24443</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12037">
                    <text>$3.50

The OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Winter 1987-88

�IS

CHRISTMAS
ALMOST HERE...
1

subscription to The Old-Time Herald magazine. This
quarterly publication offers interesting stories and articles that cover every aspect of old-time
music-dances, album reviews, historical features-including in-depth looks at the best bands
and musicians of today and yesterday.
Subscriptions are only $12 (U.S.) and information forms are on page 35. Order the
Old-Time Herald for your friends today and give them a little bit of Christmas all year long.
(Foreign subscriptions $16.00 U.S)
and what could be

a

better gift than

a

THE OLD-TIME HERALD

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

P.O. Box

1362, Galax, Virginia 24333

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
FEATURES
SAMANTHA BUMGARNER:
by

Charles Wolfe

REPORT ON GALAX

The Original Banjo Pickin' Girl

6

1987: 52nd Annual Fiddle Convention

10

by Jeanie McLerie

ELIZABETH COTTEN (1895-1987)
by

11

Alice Gerrard

THE PASSING OF FRED PRICE (1895-1987)
by

17

Alice Kay Adams

HANK BRADLEY:
as

A Fiddler From The Villages
told to Molly Tenenbaum &amp; Kerry Blech

28

Issues In Old-Time Music
CONTEST FIDDLING
by Howard Marshall, guest contributor

14

The Dance Beat
IN THE OLD-TIME DAYS: THE BEGINNING OF
TEAM CLOGGING
by Phil Jamison

Workshop
Ask

1

18

20, 21

Uncle Harold

Here &amp; There

27

SOUTHWEST CORNER NEWS

24

by Jeanie McLerie

OLD-TIME MUSIC
CAROLINA
by Hilary

IN

WESTERN NORTH
24

Dirlam

PRAIRIE PICKING IN CENTRAL ILLINOIS

22

by Bill Rintz

A

HOOSIER OUTPOST FOR OLD-TIME MUSIC

25

by Terri Klassen

Old-Time Music On The Radio
by

26

Emily Fine

RECORD

&amp;.

CASSETTE TAPE REVIEWS

CLASSIFIED

37

19

FROM THE EDITOR

2

LETTERS

2

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

between groups interested

in this music;
this would in turn, help increase interest
in the music. I believe it to be a worth

LETTERS

while

project

that

benefit

will

us

all.

What do you think?
Klonowski
Brookfield, IL

Paul
I am
in receipt of my first copy of the
Old-Time Herald, which I received from
Dave Freeman of County Records. I
have enjoyed the magazine very much. I
would like to see articles on old-time
singers from 1925 to 1935 such as Brad
ley Kincaid; Arkie, the Arkansas Woodchopper; Blue Grass Roy; Pie Plant Pete;

Mainer's
Stoneman

Mountaineers;

&amp;.

Ernest

Dhir.

Barbara Kuhns

Medway, OH

Family.

It's great! You've really outdone your
I had no idea the first issue would
be so well done. It's very attractive and
informative. Thanks so much for getting
it together. I heard Bruce Greene for the

selves.

in

at

V.

Edward Rozelle
Richford, NY

first time

of Lee Stripling taken
Port Townsend, Washington, the
person with the tape recorder is Warren
Waldron,
musician, of Somerville,
the picture

In

out

I

just read about your new magazine in
Times and I would like to

the Roanoke

I
don't sing and I
a subscriber.
don't play and I'm sure no one in my
family has even heard of old-time music,
but I love it just the same. Perhaps I'll be
only subscriber who isn't a musician,
but that's ok.

become

Pinecone concert. He's

a

Karen Garland

incredible.

Roanoke, VA
George Holt
North Carolina Arts Council
Raleigh, NC

have been enjoying the Old-Time
Herald. I was interested in the story of
Bruce Greene. I would like to send him
one of my tapes and see what he thinks
of an old West Virginia fiddler. I was
I

in 1906 near Huttonsville, in Ran
dolph County. grew up with West Vir
fiddler,
Woody
ginia's champion
Simmons. We played music together as
left
kids growing up, until 1930 when
West Virginia and came to Pennsylva

born

I

I

nia.

Woody

is

still my best friend in

Mill Creek.

Arnold Van Pelt
Fayetteville, PA
I
just received my copy of the first
issue and am most pleased with it. Great

job!

Here's an idea that I'm sure will turn
into a project of staggering proportions.
Now that the music we love has a central
focal point (this magazine), would it be

possible to compile a resource guide for
old-time music
organizations that
the
music, such as concerts
present
and/or workshops, music stores that
sell instruments and promote old-time
music, old-time festival listings, and

whatever else might need to be in such a
resource guide? Such a guide would

tremendously enhance communications

on your premier issue. I
and can hardly wait for number

Congrats

loved

it

two. I especially enjoyed Linda Higginbotham's article, which provided an
interesting and useful way of categoriz
ing the various styles and approaches of
the old-time music scene "circa 1987."

I

got a sense of poor Linda gingerly tiptoe
ing through a minefield as she tried to

accomplish the nearly impossible task of

praising the value and authenticity of
each group in turn without upsetting
advocates of the other groups. While I
think that she made her point very
clearly that all the groups are necessary
to contribute to the strength of the
whole, like strands of a rope. I will be
surprised if there aren't some fast and
furious words flying around. I hope that
stirring the pot like that is one of the
things your magazine is all about.
I'll begin the fun by tossing in my two
cents regarding her choice of the term
"classical traditional" as the label for the
first category she describes. I'm fairly
certain I know exactly the players she is
referring to and agree completely that
the music they play represents an evolu
tion of the style to such a point of purity
that any

embellishment

or

decoration

would only detract from its power. It is
truly "classic" in that sense. However,

use of that label and the accompanying
descriptive comments create the very
misleading impression that the music
played by this group is the true trunk of

�old-time music which has endured over
countless ages, unswayed by the chang

of popular tastes, and from
which the other more recent develop
ing winds

ments

are

merely

off-shoots

and

branches.

In the discussion which is sure to fol
low her article I think it's important to
keep in mind that the entire body of
what we call old-time music is only a
sprout.
is
a
channel
this music
Celtic
and
ancient
which
truly
through
Moorish traditions now flow, the partic
ular style itself is only slightly more than
a hundred years
old; four, maybe five,
generations at most. It has been fairly
well established that at the time of the
Civil War, the banjo was just beginning
to show up in the southern highlands
and the guitar was still almost entirely

Though

unknown
later,

in

in

the

the area. A mere 60 years
mid 1920s, the combina

tion of fiddle, banjo, and guitar playing
mountain tunes and songs was already
referred to as old-time music.
This 60-year period can be under
stood as simply the music-making span
of a single individual, from teens to 70s.
This same 60-year unit is all that sepa
rates us here in the present from the so"Golden Age of Old-Time
called
Music." We can conveniently date what
has been called the "revival" from 1958,
the year which saw the formation of the
New Lost City Ramblers and the appear
ances of the Kingston Trio's "Tom Dooley" on the Hit Parade. 1958 was only 30
years ago, but that is fully half of our
60-year unit. Maybe from this perspec
tive it's easier to see that we are talking
about such a short space of cultural time
that it's pretty difficult to say for sure
what is trunk and what is branch.
For those of us "younger" musicians
who got into the music pre-County 713,

the musical tradition exerted its primary
and strongest influence on us by way of
the old 78s made in the 1920s. Old-time

music, as revealed by these records from
about the mid-point in its development
from its birth to the present, included a
wide variety of styles and approaches.
This period of rich diversity and ferment
was marked by a combination of great
respect for the music's heritage along
with attempts to incorporate influences

from

other

popular
cians

and

were

musical

forms with both
Older musi
equally with the

traditional.
valued

of the

younger hot-shots, and many
most successful bands of the period fea
McMitured just such a combination

chen/Tanner

for example. It was a time
of commercial aspirations for the music
and full-blown dreams of stardom.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The older players of the so-called
"classical traditional" group are all that
remain of that generation which was in
its prime in the '20s and '30s. This group
certainly has the strongest ties with the
tradition, since obviously they have
been immersed in it for a longer period
of time. However, to imply, as the label
and description certainly do, that the
attitudes which now characterize this
group's approach to old-time music are
somehow more appropriate to the musi
cal tradition and the culture from which
it comes, is a great mistake. I submit that
the

conservatism, the non-commercial

ism, and the near-personal detachment
of this group is more the function of
their present age than anything else.

Perhaps it would be more useful to see
various approaches in old-time
music today as: 1) Old folks playing as
old folks naturally will 2) Young folks
playing like the old folks do today 3)
Young folks playing like the old folks
did when they were young, and 4)
Young folks playing like the old folks
may have if they were young today.
strongly suspect that these same general
groupings have been around from the
the

I

very

beginning

and

continue

will

to

move through the categories as appro
priate to their point of view and stage of
life.

surely feel this happening to me and
music. Where once I spent hours
practicing technically demanding claw
hammer banjo licks, now I'm more
likely to be found playing "Sally Ann"
I

my

for

the

thousandth

time with

an

easy

rolling beat. Probably a better example is
Fred Cockerham, who in his heyday as a
touring entertainer was considered to be
an innovative, hot-licks fiddler with a
style reminiscent of Arthur Smith.
Towards the end of his life, lo and
behold, here's Fred, enshrined as one of
the
leading figures of the classical

school.
With

all this

in

mind,

it

seems point

less to argue about which group is the
"keeper of the true flame." The impor
tant and wonderful thing about old-time
music is that it has always had equal need
for the energy and creativity of youth as
well as for the wisdom and experience of
old age, and it has equally rich rewards
for the musician at either stage of life.
We should remember to show at least as

much support and tolerance to our fel

low musicians as was shown to us
old-timers when we first came

by the
to the

music. I've got a hunch that no matter
which of the groups we may be part of
now, if we stick with old-time music
long enough, we will all reach that magi
cal point where the music seems to

express itself through us rather than the
other way around.
Mac Benford

Trumansburg, NY

Interesting article

in

issue #1 defining

the current categories of

old-time music!

especially enjoyed hearing a word or
two on "rock and roll" old-time as
played in upstate New York, as it was my
first introduction to the music.
So how about a longer article on same,
which alas, has largely migrated to

I

greater Philadelphia and the Massachu

setts/ Vermont border country? Of par
the
are
ticular note, of course,
Horseflies, the Heartbeats, and the var
ious incarnations of Bubba George. And
don't forget the "Cuban" influence of
John Specker, without whom this style
probably wouldn't have developed.
Good luck to the Old-Time Herald.
We've needed something like this for a
long time!
Faith Dominy
Ithaca, NY

�This fall marks the second season of
our dance series, "Charlotte American
Folk Dance." Our dances are monthly
on fourth Saturdays and their main
focus is old-time southern Appalachian
music and dance, although we'll do contras occasionally. One of our dilemmas
is getting callers. There are none in Char
lotte who know mostly calls that suit
old-time music. We'd like the word to
go out about our dance and our need for
callers. Thanks for passing the word
along.
Karen Singleton

Charlotte, NC

It's about time

WE had our own pub

lication! Best of luck

in

your new endea

vor.

We wish you great success in your
endeavor. We are part of the
DeBusk- Weaver Family and got to
know Albert Hash and through him,
Thornton and Emily Spencer.
current

Donnie and Linda Weaver
Oxford, PA
I
have been looking for someone to
teach me two tunes I heard at the Ham
mered Dulcimer and Irish Harp conven
tion at Cosby, Tennessee in 1985. The

and
Favorite"
tunes
were "Viola's
know
Do
you
"Throwing Jam (Jelly)"
those? They were played late Saturday
night in a big group jam session and I had
run completely out of tape. These tunes
have been haunting me. Where are my

1

Dwight Mays
Lewisville, NC

for

tunes with the new magazine. After 16
years with Old Time Music I know,
maybe better than most, the tribulations
as well as the joys of producing a maga
zine. I hope you experience many of the
latter and as few as possible of the
former.

Tony Russell, Old Time Music
London, England

musicians

and

roots, what

a

all,

back

got

player, the latejehile Kirkhuff (seereview
this issue

ed.)
Ed and

Geraldine Berbaum
Montrose, PA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

their

would be.
Some great old-time music is being
recorded, but the so-called country sta
tions won't play it. Thank God for the
smaller radio stations and the real coun
try DJ's

Continued good wishes

the staff

at

you and

to

all

the Old-Time Herald.

New Kensington, PA

Tammy Ann Murray

Gainesville, FL

Congratulations!

Your publication is
to the world of

welcomed addition

a

old-time music.
I
am particularly delighted that you
have chosen to also include old-time
dance in each issue. Phil Jamison is not
only an excellent dancer but is very
knowledgeable about traditional styles
of dance.
Keep up the good work.
Christian, The Old-Time Music
Dance Foundation, Inc.

&amp;

Readers of Hilary Dirlam's article
about Bruce Green in your Fall 1987
issue might be interested to know that
the

Archive

Folklife

at

only in the Archive. Anyone interested
in

The

using

the collection

Folklife

Building,

Archive,

Western

should contact
The Kentucky

University, Bowling Green
All indications from reading this first

issue

points

to

a

winner

and

well

Kentucky
KY

42101.

Burt Feintuch

Professor &amp;. Coordinator
Bowling Green, KY

it

should be, as the old-time music has
been neglected far too long. We know
that the "powers

Western

has
field
Kentucky
recordings of quite a few of the older
musicians from whom Bruce learned
many of his tunes. There's some rare and
beautiful music in the collection. The
recordings are available for listening

University

that be" in the music

business would like to see that type of
music go to a final graveyard; however

The

Old-Time

They should

be

Herald

welcomes

letters.

written, and
edited and we will print

typed or neatly

signed. They may be
them according to space available.

We are full-time performers of oldtime music and also we collect fiddle
tunes from the folks who still play the
old style. We have about 1500 tunes on
tape from 28 fiddlers in Pennsylvania
and New York State and have made
many friends. We still visit and write
letters to "Pappy" Jake Miller who
comes from a long line of players and is a
good old-time style player of the fiddle.
We collected about 500 tunes from one

to

difference the music field

Howard Vokes

Jacky

Let me wish you all the best of

mind, soul, God, country, and
Bible will always be with us and if the
record distributors,
music business,
record
people, A &lt;Sc R men,
one-stops,

heart,

ghostbusters?

Doug Mowrey
Aliquippa, PA
Bought your first copy at the Galax
Fiddlers Convention and think it's great!
would really hope your publication
could open doors for regional storytel
ling, which should go hand-in-hand with
family reunions, church homecomings,
and all sorts of musical gatherings.

that will never be, because the majority
of the people who love traditional oldtime music are tired of being "brain
washed," and still love the good old
simple things in life. Songs of the soil,

�Attention
STANLEY BROTHERS fans!
Now available to serious collectors and fans
of this legendary bluegrass &amp; old-time group is a
taken from live shows
unique series of recordings
of the 1950's &amp; 60's. All shows feature the fine MC
work of Carter Stanley and lots of great music
including some selections not previously recorded
commercially by the band. Write for a free catalog.
#1

#2
#3
#4
#5
#6
#7
#8
#9

New River Ranch
May 21, 1961
Rising Sun, MD
New River Ranch
May 15, 1960
Rising Sun, MD
MD
New River Ranch
July 3, 1955
Rising Sun,
Bean Blossom, IN Oct. 16, 1966
Brown County Jamboree
Shenandoah Valley Bowl
Edinburg, VA June 3, 1956
Oak Leaf Park
May 28, 1961
Luray, VA
Morrisville, VA July 8, 1956
Shipp's Park
Ash Grove
Hollywood, CA Aug. 30, 1962
Silver Creek Ranch
Paris, VA Aug. 5, 1956

COPPER CREEK RECORDS
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

P.O. Box 3161

Roanoke,

albums are
add
$7.00 each
order
to
$1.00
your

All

for

postage and

handling.

albums are also
available on

All

cassette.
VA

24015

�SAMANTHA BUMGARNER:
One of the sillier myths being bandied"
about these days by the Nashville

involves the role of
establishment
women in the history of country music.

It is said, down along Music Row and in
the august pages of Country Music maga
that before the advent of Kitty
zine,
Wells in the late 1940s, women had lit
tle to do with country music's develop
ment, they were cast as pretty faces only,
along to dress up the act. This of course,
is nonsense, and an account of the signif
icant women artists who contributed to
the development of the music would
take up the rest of this issue,

The Original
Banjo Pickin' Girl
by

Charles Wolfe

issue.

In fact,

an

all-woman string band had

with the very dawn of
country music, and formed
one of the very first string bands ever to
record old-time music. The focus of this
band was a remarkable woman named
Samantha Bumgarner, one of the true
a

lot

to

do

recorded

unsung pioneers of American tradi
tional music. Accounts of her career
have been vague and shadowy; the offi
cial

histories barely

mention her, and

none of her fine records are still in print.
This account itself has far too many gaps
and is based on too many secondary

sources, but

it

may

function

as a

start for

research
Aunt Samantha's life more fully, and it
may act as a modest tribute to the "Fid-

her

mid-40s

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Lunsford

Lamar
Bascom

in

Archives,

woman

Photo

raw-boned

dressed in a dark, stylish outfit; she car
ried a fiddle case and introduced herself
as Samatha Bumgarner. Her companion
was younger, wore a dark jacket over her
dress, carried a banjo case, and intro
duced herself as Eva Davis. As they
arrived at the studio, the Fisk Jubilee
Singers, a polite, well-trained singing
group from Nashville, were finishing a
You'll Join the
number called "Hope
was cleared and
studio
the
Soon
Band."
the two women took their places in front
of the big horn still used for the acoustic
record-making process. After a few
tests, the pair got tuned up and charged

Hill

dlin' Ballad-Woman."
The story starts, oddly enough, in
New York, on a Tuesday afternoon in
late April 1924. Two women from the
hamlet of Silva, North Carolina took the
elevator to the top floor of the Gotham
National Bank Building to report to the
laboratories of the Columbia Phono
graph Company. One of them was a tall,

Collection.

to

Mars

someone else who wishes

�a

grape around

It

a

vine.

Cindy.

Be my wife

was one of the first recordings

of

authentic traditional string band music;
it was basic, spare, uncomplex, and hon
est. The month before, Columbia had
recorded Gid Tanner and Riley Puckett
string band format, and also the
month before, Okeh had recorded Fiddlin' John Carson with his Virginia Reelers. In April, though, none of these sides
had been released, and record company
in

a

executives were still not sure what to do
with them. Old-time singers the execu
tives could understand; but the light,
floating sound of a Southern string band
was something else; a challenge to the
primitive recording technology, and a
question mark as to sales potential.
Still, the producers had some interest
in mountain music, and the two women
from Sylva had come a long way. They
let them cut 10 songs;- two more fiddlebanjo duets ("Big-Eyed Rabbit," and "I
Am My Mama's Darling Child"
the
latter a variant of "Soldier's Joy" and
quite different from the "Darling Child"
recorded two years later by the Blue
Ridge Highballers), two solos by Eva

singing and accompanying herself on the
banjo, and five solos by Samantha. After
Eva had recorded two vocal numbers
("John Hardy" and "Wild Bill Jones,"
both well-known traditional standards),
Samantha put down her fiddle, picked
up the banjo, and began picking. She did
"Shout Lou," "Fly Around My Pretty
Little Miss," and a version of "Roving
Gambler" she called "Gambling Man."
Finally, she picked and sang two tunes,
"Georgia Blues" and "Worried Blues,"
both of which sound like analogues to
the well-known "Going Down the Road
Feeling Bad."
It wasn't
until

months

that
of the

later,

specialty is singing and playing real tradi
tional American music, songs that are
"
part of our national musical lore. It was
a sign of the times that Columbia, which
had not yet perceived the market for
old-time music as such, tried to "formal
ize" the description of Eva and Samantha's music by referring to the fiddle as a
"violin," and by emphasizing the "folkness" of the music.
"Big-Eyed Rabbit" was not in reality
first
the
very
string band record
released, but only by a matter of
months. Tanner and Puckett's "Buckin'
Mule" and "Hen Cackle" (Col. 110-D),
issued in June 1924, is the first string
band record that can be documented,
though it is highly likely that records by
Carson's Virginia Reelers were released
at about the same time. But the records
by Davis and Bumgarner were certainly
among the first records to document
Southern music, and they were the first

produced

by

women performers.

preserved.

Samantha was born about 1880 in
Jackson County, North Carolina, a hilly
area
was

southeast of Asheville. Her father
area
Has Biddix, a well-known

fiddler who died in 1930 at the age of 78.
Samantha recalled that he was "a fiddleplayin' man from away back" who could
make his sourwood fiddle "croon like a
lovin' woman." Her father would not let
Samantha touch his fiddle, "but when he
wasn't at home I would sneak it out and
play." The young Samantha also deter
mined to play the banjo; her first banjo
was "a gourd with a cat's hide stretched
over it and strings made of cotton thread
and waxed with beeswax." By the time
she was 15, in 1895, Samantha could
play the banjo pretty well, and her father
finally bought her one; "I used to go with
him and play around over the country."
Thus, like so many later women who

their mark in old-time music,
Samantha got started by playing with a
father who was an old-time fiddler.
Before long Samantha married Carse
made

August 1924, tour
Columbia released

Lamar

Like

early sides by North Carolina singer
Ernest Thompson. A later press release
singled out the records by Eva and
Samantha: "The Columbia Phonograph
Company reports that the newly
released records by the musical discov
eries from North Carolina, now record
exclusively for Columbia New
ing
Process records are providing excellent
sellers.
They sing and accompany
themselves on banjo and violin. Their

Though Eva Davis and Samantha
Bumgarner were close friends when they
recorded those famous sides, Eva Davis
seems to have simply dropped out of
sight after this. Samantha, though, con
tinued to attract attention around the
Asheville area, and in fact became a reg
ular feature at the famous Mountain
Dance and Folk Festival staged by the
late Bascom Lamar Lunsford at Ashe
ville every year. Before she died in 1960,
several people interviewed her, and
some fragments of her colorful life were

Collection

Asked her if she loved me,
She said she loved me fine,
I
threw both arms around her,

pany released the rest of the records, and
the response was gratifying: the records
sold, along with the first sides by Gid
Tanner and Riley Puckett, and with the

Lunsford

into an old dance tune called "Cindy in
Meadows." Samantha played an
archaic, simple, fiddle lead for Eva's
rhythmic banjo chording. One of the
two started singing:
the

said

Archives,
Photo

copywriters

that

through November, the Columbia com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Hill

Columbia

Samantha and Eva were "quaint musi
cians" who were "famed for their skill
with the fiddle and banjo." Over the
from August
next three months,

Mars

the

Bascom

the
first
Bumgarner-Davis
records: "Big-Eyed Rabbit" and "Wild
Bill Jones." But the records had been
advertised to dealers as early as June 15
in an ad in Talking Machine World where

1926-Samantha

and Bascom Lamar Lunsford

at

her house in Sylva.

�Bumgarner; far from being nervous
about her music-making, or jealous of it,
Carse bought Samantha the first fiddles
she ever owned. But soon after that the
young couple saw their house burn, and
Samantha had to watch both her instru
ments go up in smoke. "I got another
banjo," she recalled, "but it was a cheap
one. I called it a 10-cent banjo. We was
in
Canton and they was having a
fiddlers' convention. Somebody entered
me in the banjo contest. First banjo con
test

I

knew

was ever in, and I was nervous. I
couldn't hit a string. Besides I had

I

that old 10-cent banjo. And here
looked up and saw all these fine banjos
wanted to
coming in from Asheville.
leave but they wouldn't let me. tell you,
was
didn't know
I
was so nervous
hitting the strings. But I won the contest.
And I've been winning them ever since."
Perhaps it was winning such a contest
the attention of the
that attracted
Columbia Phonograph Company to
Samantha and her music. Certainly she
had a secure reputation when she went

I

I

I

I

1

Lunsford

Collection

to New York in 1924 to record. But for
some reason, she never returned to
record any more, even though her
records were so popular that Ward's
re-released a couple of them on their

Archives,

Bascom

Lamar

Harmony label.
By 1928, though, she was finding
other outlets for her music. In that year
Bascom Lamar Lunsford started his
famous Mountain Dance and Folk Festi
val in Asheville, and Samantha was a

and

commercially,

Hill

Nick

Mars

recorded

Photo

charter member of the Festival roster.
Other participants in that famous first
included Ozey Helton and
festival
Dedrick Harris who like Samantha had

Marlor,
splendid ballad singer from
Madison County who later recorded for
the Library of Congress. Samantha thus
started an annual custom that was to
extend from 1928 to 1959; one of the
a

Asheville

festivals.

In

the

1940s

Samantha often appeared with "FiddlinBill" Hensley, and often won the clogdancing contest in addition to playing
Lunsford later
Bascom
the
banjo.
recalled the Samantha and Nick Marlor
would usually appear at the festival
"along about sundown" every year, and

that thousands of people yearly came to

expect their particular brand of music at
that particular time.
By the early 1930s Samantha' s fame
was

spreading

beyond

the

immediate

Asheville area, and she began to travel

widely: to New York, Washington, New

Orleans, Saint Louis, Chicago, Kansas
City, even to Mexico. In the early 1930s
she had her own show on the famous
"border radio" stations at Del Rio,
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Texas; hers was one of the first programs
sponsored by Dr. John Brinkley, the
notorious goat-gland salesman, who
later sponsored groups like the Carter
Family, the Delmore Brothers, and oth
ers. Samantha always liked to talk of the
time she played for the King and Queen:
this was probably in June 1939, when
Bascom Lamar Lunsford took a troupe
of dancers and singers from his Ashe
ville festival to perform at the White
House for Franklin D. Roosevelt, Mrs.

Roosevelt, and their special guests, King
George VI and Queen Elizabeth.
Throughout the 1940s she continued
to appear at the Asheville festival and to
pick the banjo at local contests. She
recalled

that she had won nearly

100

prizes at such festivals; "I don't play any
'Arkansas
thing but old-timey stuff
Traveler', 'Turkey in the Straw', and the
'Booger Man' were old when I began
playing." By now, though, she was
admitting that banjo playing was more
her forte than fiddling, though she could
also play mandolin and guitar. In fact,
Bascom Lamar Lunsford later admitted
that Samantha was the best all-around

musician he knew.
In

the

1950s

Samantha,

now

approaching 80, found herself caught up
in the folk revival that was sweeping the
country. In August 1955 she was written
up

in

a

Life magazine article about the

boom" that was sweeping the
country. That same month a group of
"banjo

�folklorists headed by Kenneth Gold
stein recorded her again, this time for an
LP entitled "Banjo Songs of the South
ern Mountains." Earlier Samantha had
recorded for the Library of Congress,
and for a record company from Liver
pool

England.

She

was

also

taped

numerous times during the 1950s while
on stage performing.
During these last years Samantha
lived alone in a little white bungalow in a
place called Love Field, in a valley south
of Sylva. She often appeared at festivals,
often dressed in rather quaint, old-

fashioned frilly dresses, and played her
old banjo with flowers painted on the

head. She wrote a number of songs her
self during her career; her favorite was
one called "The Last Gold Dollar." "1
wrote that, you know, got the idea when
the government took up the gold. "This
would date the song from about 1934.
The text of the song suggests, though,
that it was not the same song that was so
often recorded by old-time musicians
like Charlie Poole and John Carson in
the 1920s, sometimes under the title
"Don't Let Your Deal Go Down."
Samantha would sing:
Love me, babe, love me,
Love me like you used to,

When I'm gone,
The last gold dollar's gone.
I

it.

Samantha died on Christmas
Eve, 1960. She had suffered from arthri
tis in her last few years, and from a
broken hip, and she had been unable to
play for some months. Her regional
fame was such that the Asheville CitizenTimes printed a full-length editorial in
tribute to "Aunt Samantha." It read, in
part: "Mrs. Bumgarner's death in her 80s
just before Christmas marked the pass
ing of one of this mountain region's
most colorful and picturesque individu
als.
She came by her fiddle and banjo-

Her
Has
father,
naturally.
playing
Biddix, was also a fiddler. The two gen
erations
represented the traditional
Anglo-Saxon folk music whose strong
hold was southern Appalachia. With the
the
of mountain isolation,
melting

stronghold of folk arts was threatened

in

20s and 30s by patterns of unifor
mity. Fortunately, numerous collectors
of folk songs and ballads came in too,
then and before, and the many fine trea
sures of folk materials have been pre
served in books and on records."
the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

recordings of traditional Southern banjo
styles. Her career extended further back
than the history of country music itself,
and touched countless people. She was

from the "quaint musician" de
scribed by the old Columbia press
release; she was a tough, honest, proud,
mountain woman who knew exactly
who she was and what she was doing,
and her memory and her music will
endure.
far

Samantha Bumgarner:
Prewar Discography

Columbia Phonograph Company
Recorded
New York

April 22

and

23,

1924,

81706
81707
81710

in the Meadows 1, 4, 5
Am My Mama's Darling Child

Big Eyed Rabbit

11

Wild Bill Jones

12

John Hardy

13

(unknown title)
(unknown title)

14

Columbia 167-D

Cindy
I

4,

1,

1,

Shout Lou

16
18

Around My Pretty Little Miss
2
The Gamblin' Man
The Worried Blues
2, 3

19

Georgia Blues

2

Fly

2,

3

Columbia 191-D, Ha5113
Col 129-D
Col 129-D
Col 167-D

5

15

17

4

5

4,

in

Samantha Bumgarner, fiddle (1), banjo
(2), and vocal (3).
Eva Davis, banjo (4), vocal (5).

master

*Harmony

have been unable to document any
recordings Samantha made of this song,
though the mysterious session for the
Liverpool company may contain a ver

sion of
Aunt

In order to fully appreciate the signif
icance of Samantha's 1924 recordings,
one must realize that they represent
music by a woman who was playing a
style developed about 1900 or there
abouts, and that they represent the first

2

unissued
unissued
Col. 146-D
Col. 146-D
Col. 191-D, Ha 5113
Col. 166-D, Ha 5111
Col. 166-D, Ha 5111*

reissues labelled either "Louelle Gardner" or "Gardner and David"
"Big Eyed Rabbit" can be heard on reissue, Rounder 1029

�Report on Galax-1987
52nd Annual Fiddlers

including Japan, Switzerland, and
Poland, and we were not the only ones
from New Mexico. One can hear a lot of
good music during the four days of the
festival. I especially enjoyed listening to
local musicians like Enoch Rutherford,
Ivery Kimble, and Giles Lephew jam
ming with the editors of the Old-Time
Herald in their concession booth. There
was a large variety of bluegrass and I
heard some wonderful singing in some
of the bluegrass jams. There was plenty
of the punk/ new-wave variety of oldtime music as played in Philly and
Ithaca, and even Cajun music (I counted

Convention
by

Jeanie McLerie

five diatonic button accordian players),
D.
L.
Menard was there on

and

Saturday.
Besides

Higginbotham
Linda

1987

I
suppose my opinion of fiddle con
tests will always be colored by the first
one ever attended in Berkeley, Califor
nia, where first prize was three pounds of
rutabagas and second prize was five
pounds. Not to say it was a joke, it was
really quite serious, but it does put
things into perspective for me. The sig
nificance is in the gathering of the musi
cians, not in the judging or kind of prize.
The Galax Fiddlers Convention is
much more than a contest, and in fact
there are categories for singing, autoI

mandolin, and banjo, as well as
both bluegrass and old-time categories
for fiddle. Fifteen dollars paid at the gate
on Wednesday gives each contestant the
right to enter the contest (provided you
harp,

have

pre-registered),

and get back

10

dollars after competing. Y ou used to get
back the entire 15 dollars, and many of
the local contestants are upset about this
new ruling since the four-day gala event
would be nothing without the contest
ants. However, I think it is still a good
deal because the entry fee gives you a
spot to park and set up a tent either in
the large, lit lot, or back in the horse-stall
area where the younger old-time musi

cians prefer to camp. This year, perhaps
due to an extensive article in the New
Yorker magazine, many people arrived
on Sunday to get a good camping spot.
Hence, by Friday there seemed to be a
rather large burnout factor.
People were there from all over,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

kept wishing for a good burrito
vegetarian pita-bread sandwich.

or

a

What is important however, is that
this kind of event really stimulates live

music,

as

played

by

old-timers,

ama

teurs, professionals, and whoever. It's
great that the town hosts such an event
and I hope it will continue forever. This
music is one of the heartbeats of Amer
ica and as

listening to the local musi

cians play, and watching the action on
the stage, my favorite thing to do was
wander around the stalls visiting every
one's camp
"Bobville," home of the

John Hatton, Galax

friendly Red Hots, the "Galax Hilton,"
"Little Minneapolis," and so forth. It's
always fun meeting new people, seeing
old friends, hearing great music and new
styles of playing. The weather was good
this year
only a few light rainstorms,
and not excessively hot. The variety of
food at the concessions was slim and I

by

and

a

long as it is played and enjoyed
wide variety of people, it will thrive

continue.

Thank you Galax Moose Lodge for
organizing this wonderful convention!

�music.

We had many occasions to talk. Eliza
beth Cotten (or 'Libba' as she was often

known) wanted people to know about

how she was raised,
her, about her life
how she learned her music, her people
and what they meant to her, her expe
riences as a black woman, what was

important to her and what wasn't.
She had a prodigious memory and was

able to recall in amazing detail the story
of her life. And nobody could tell her
story better than Elizabeth herself. The
following are edited exerpts from trans
criptions made while putting together
the notes for her LP, "Elizabeth Cotten:
Vol. 3 When I'm Gone"
"Mama called me 'Babe'; my daddy
called me 'Shoat'. His name was George
Nevills. I don't remember him too
much. He was a tall man, he wore his hat
kind of one side a little bit. He was
brown
lighter than me, but a beautiful
brown, big but rawboney, thin hands
I'd sit on one leg and Lillie,
and feet.
my sister, on the other, and we'd comb
and braid his hair. He had lovely hair. It

kind of long on the top and we'd
make little long braids all over his head.
"My father's people was Indians. My
mama used to tell me how my daddy's
mother was a slave and how she used to
get whippings. How did they feel, whip

Jim

Mys

was

ELIZABETH COTTEN
(1895-1987)
by

Alice Gerrard.

living according to the Bible the
can do, 'cause you
can, that's all
never know when that time's coming.
And want to call all of you all-"Come
here children, I'm going now." I would like
I'm just

best

I

I

I

somebody
to die now.
but

or not,

I

and loving matriarch, died in Syracuse,
New York. I thought back on her words
and on all good times we had together in

sure would like

her

to

it.

I'd like

to be

can call my friends and tell 'em I'm
and just
going to die. And I'm going now.
close my eyes and go. Right straight up. I'm
going to fly like a little bird. Whenever it is,
where

composer of "Freight Train" and many
other songs and tunes, working woman,

tell 'em I'm going
around,
don't know whether I'll get that

to be

I

1987 at the age of 91,
Elizabeth Cotten, guitarist, banjo player,
On June 29,

I

I'll be satisfied.

Going just as straight up as

can fly.

Elizabeth Cotten, January 1979
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

D.C.

home

before

in

southeast Washington,
moved to Syracuse.

she

Innumerable cups of coffee, huge deli
cious feasts of chicken and dumplings,
mashed
potatoes, yeast rolls, fried
chicken, vegetables, desserts, the hustle
and bustle, with her immediate and
extended family coming and going,
laughing, talking, always a boundless
sharing of love and wisdom as well as

somebody hasn't done nothin'?
How could you do it? How could you
whip a dog if he ain't done nothin'?
"My mother's people were not slaves.
They were farmers. That's about the
ping

at that time for colored peo
ple to do. They didn't live close nowhere
that they could work for nobody. They
just kind of had to sow their grains and

only thing

reap them. They had cows, horses,
plenty of butter, chickens, eggs, every
thing that farming people had. She was
raised up on plenty to eat but she
worked very, very hard for that.
"Mama was a midwife. She delivered a

little child in Chapel Hill and all
through the country. Mostly white peo
ple called her Aunt Lou. Mama was very
many

a

pleasant. Very nice, obedient. Mama
was always kind of humble, just a little
a kind of pulled
bit; you could see it
back act, you know what I mean? She
wouldn't go too far too quick. I used to
didn't want to see her do too much of
that. But she seemed to get along alright.
You see, she had to do that maybe a little
more than I did. I don't know why,
'cause she was not a slave. But after she
had to get out and work for

herself and

work for white people, maybe she
picked it up then. 'You do what you're
supposed to do, everything's alright.'
That's what mama used to tell us.

�"My mother told me
maybe it was
just told to her: somewhere down in the

South, down

in

man burnin' on
That man
Way down
That man

is

in
is

Georgia,

there was

a

log.

a

burning,
the land of Georgia,
burning,

He's burning on

trying to serve God if you run around
and sing those kind of songs, but I
declare I think about 'em a lot and I
don't see where there's so much sin in it.
I say those
words, they come to you just
like a song you make of the gospel. They
come from inside of your heart, and do
you know why? Because you've been
mistreated. It could be your mother,
your father, your sister, your sweet
or your
dear
heart,
your husband,
You know, if you get hurt,
friend.
you know how you feel heavy? And
those words just busts out of you
you
got to make a song or talk about it, or do
something. Sometimes you can't talk
about it, but you can sing it. Yes indeed.
All the songs come from your heart,
good ones and bad ones."
Elizabeth married Frank Cotten when
when she was fifteen.

decided

I
wanted a guitar. I wasn't 12
years old and I went to work for this lady
she paid me 75&lt;f a month. I saved my
money and bought me a guitar for
$3.75. And the name of that guitar was

And I liked my guitar so very,
very much, and that's when I began to
learn how to play a guitar. The first thing
I'd do, I laid the guitar flat in my lap and I
worked my left hand till I could play the
strings backwards and forwards. Then I
started to chord it and get the sound of a
Stella.

a log.

Where Mama got that song I don't
know. It sounds like way down in slav
ery times doesn't it? Mama used to sing
that song to us and she'd tell us about
when the Yankees freed the Negroes.
She said she was ten years old. Not too
far from where they lived they had a
plank thing that goes across the water.
And she said it was the old plank road.
She said when the Yankees freed the
Negroes you could hear the paddle of
the horses feet coming across this bridge
you could hear it for so long, there'd
be so many of them you'd listen to 'em a

long time.
"Mama had a big rocking chair she
rocked in all the time; one for the front
porch and one for the house. And after
she died we carried her bed out, and her
trunk, and that rocking chair and a
straight chair. I put the chair right at the
edge of the door and put the rocking
chair kind of in front of the fireplace.
used to pray God to let me wake up and
let me see her sitting in one of those
chairs at night, 1 used to be coming from
work and when I'd get home and she
wasn't there, there was the empty rock
ing chair. And I'd go in the other room
and shut the door and cry as long as I
wanted to. I cried satisfaction, then I got
up, and I did that, honey, about two
months. And all at once one day some

and kept on till I could work my
song.
fingers pretty good. And that's how I
started playing with two fingers. And
after I played with two fingers for a while
I
starting using three. It was just in me to
learn. It's a gift I guess I got, it must be.
Something God gave me to live on since
I
got old. Music is a funny thing. It's
something you love. I don't know, it's

"I
was my own boss. That's what
made me feel so proud when I got mar
ried. Nobody to say, 'Go in the kitchen
and wash the dishes, make up your bed,
straighten up that floor, pick up!' Did it
if I wanted to and if I didn't, I didn't do

I

thing says to me, 'You've got to live
she's dead. She wants you to live. She
don't want you to grieve and go tingle
away to nothing, so snap out of it.' And I
did
just all at once I began to eat and
feel better.
"All my mother's brothers played
fiddle and a
music, every one of them
banjo. There was one fiddle in my family
growing up, and I don't remember
myself ever trying to pick up a fiddle to
play it. The thing wanted was an organ
or piano. My mother wasn't able to get
it. I was so full of music, if somebody
had of just took a little time to find out
how full of music I was, give me a few
lessons or kind of help me or show me,
I'd have been good.
"I learned the banjo upside down and
I

I couldn't
Elizabeth
(reverse the strings
was left-handed ed.) because it belonged
to my brother, and when he left home I
didn't have nothin' to play, so I just

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I was a pretty good little housekeeper
when I was first married. I was so proud
I married
at the
of that place, honey.
age of 15, birthed my baby when I was
16. And I didn't never have no more.
married I don't know how
"After
Frank got used to me 'cause I was kind of
babyish. 'Mama's baby, papa's pet, six

it.

Photographer

unknown

I

Elizabeth Cotten

as

a

young girl.

just something comes in you, comes
from inside of you, comes out. Just

mumble it out. Just come boobies out.
And you can shut your eyes and go with
it and repeat it. That's how I got all of
that music when I was growing up.
Go to
"I was raised up in a church.
church every Sunday. You didn't miss.
You go to Sunday school and stay the
eleven o'clock service, and sometimes
Mama would let us go back at three
o'clock service. I'm a Baptist. All them
was
songs that you play on the piano,
raised up going to Sunday school singing
them. Every body'd get a book and sit up
there and sing the songs. If there was
was
notes
there
somebody
always
there'd always know the notes. And he'd
sing it for you and then you follow him
we didn't know the notes.
"They said I couldn't make a good
member of the church and play those
worldly songs, 'Goin' Down the Road
that's what I played a
Feeling Bad'
I

whole lot. They just feel like you're not

years old and
if he'd look

a

at

baby yet. ...' Looked like
me hard I'd cry."

Elizabeth and Frank Cotten with their
daughter, Lillie, moved back and forth
between Chapel
Hill,
Washington,
D.C., and New York City. Eventually,
they settled in New York City where
Frank had a job as chauffeur and later
operated his own business as an auto
mechanic. Lillie went to school in
Yonkers and Elizabeth did day work and
worked in a furniture store. They lived
in New York until Lillie got married,
and
Frank
which
Elizabeth
after
divorced. Finally, as children and grand

children gradually moved to Washing

ton, D.C. Elizabeth settled there, living
with Lillie. She worked mainly at day
work for white families, and helped to

grandchildren and great
grandchildren. She worked hard to help
support her family; she arrived in the
raise

her

white neighborhoods early in the morn
ing, scrubbed floors, ironed, washed,
cooked
long hours and no security.
Often, she worked for people who were

unkind, but there were
she worked for with
whom she remained friends and with
whom she kept in touch down through
thoughtless

several

or

families

�the years. In 1947 or '48 she went to
work for Charles and Ruth Crawford
trained musicians
Seeger, classically
who were also interested in folk music.
Two of their children, Mike and Peggy,
were learning to play the guitar, and Eli
zabeth recalled:
"I forgot I could play guitar, there was
nobody around played no guitar. Didn't
even hear a guitar name called. Then
when I went to work for them I just kept
hearing all that pretty guitar music and I
said, 'I used to play the guitar,' and I
decided to play it, and I got Peggy's gui
tar and started playing. And the more I
could play it the better I could play it.
Mrs. Seeger would go in there and start
her music, I'd go in the other room and
start mine. And I'd feel so good after I'd
do that."

After the Seegers found that Elizabeth

could play, Mike and Peggy encouraged
her and learned from her. With Mike's

help she recorded her first album for
Folkways in 1957 and in 1959 Elizabeth
and Mike shared a joint concert at
the start of her
Swarthmore College
sporadic work as a musician. During the
mid-60s music work for her picked up,
and she was able to curtail her day work.
But it was in the late 1970s that her
career really got underway with the help

you're free-hearted, and you're musical
you're a hard worker,' she says. 'Your
last days are going to be your best days,
absolutely your best. In your last days
you're just going to close your eyes and
go off. You're not going to suffer, you're
not going to linger around, you're just
.' That's been a
going to go to sleep.
made up the
time
Elizabeth
ago."
long
words to her song, "When I'm Gone,"
about which she said:
'The words in this song are all about
made 'em up about myself. You're
me.
gonna miss the songs I play, you're
gonna miss me when I'm gone. You're
gonna to miss my playing, you're gonna
miss my singing, you're gonna miss my
walking, you're gonna miss my everyday
talk; you're gonna say, 'Well, I wish Eli
zabeth was here,' and you're gonna look
I

and

I

won't

be

there.

It's me,

it's me.

That's the reason I call it my song. It's
everything about me. Not nobody else.
So you can sing that song, if you want to,
when the ashes to ashes, the dust to dust.
We're all going to rise the Judgement
Day. That'd be wonderful, wouldn't it?
I'd come and gather you up and take you
right back with me. Oh, wouldn't that be
sweet?"

a booking
agent who
work
for
her, organize tours,
helped get
and who took a personal interest in her
she
welfare and success. Gradually
began to gain widespread recognition.
She was able to buy a house in Syracuse,
New York where her grandson Larry
lives and where she and her daughter,
Lillie, moved. Her grandaughter, Johnine, eventually moved there as well. In
recent years Johnine, who is a fine sing
er, often toured with Elizabeth. Syracuse
honored Elizabeth with a park, "Libba's
Grove", named in her honor; a confer

of John Ullman,

ence

room

at

the Educational

Oppor

tunity Center was named after her, and a
new Martin guitar was given her by the
Chamber of Commerce. She won a
Grammy Award for her Arhoolie LP,
and received a National Heritage Fellow
ship Award from the National Endow
ment for the Arts. She received a great
deal of media attention, she toured
widely, performing at countless folk fes
tivals, colleges and community events.

I

I

believed

had my fortune told once, and
her:

'You're

a

good woman,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Stephen

due.
"And

Condon

She recorded four LPs and, according to

Mike Seeger, there will probably be part
of another. Much recognition came her
way
recognition she never actively
sought, but which she accepted grace
fully, obviously enjoying what was her

�Issues
by

In

Old-time Music

Linda Higginbotham

ing,

and

tunings

are

not used and not

by the contest fiddlers. They
short, little in common but a
few tunes, and in some areas, a shared

mastered
have,

in

stage.

Contest fiddling has not penetrated
Appalachian contests to a large
extent but it virtually defines fiddling at
contests in most of the rest of the coun
try. In certain areas, such as Missouri
and Arkansas, where a fair amount of
traditional old-time fiddling exists, you
may witness the two attempting to share
What
without distinction.
a
stage

Courtesy
Marshall
Howard

As everyone knows, one of the most
important venues for old-time fiddling
is the contest. While there are numerous
fiddlers who never enter contests, the
contest remains for many a rallying
point and place to get together with
other musicians. It has also become over
the years the showplace for another type
an
of fiddling, "contest fiddling"
of
blend
jazz,
swing,
attention-grabbing
country, bluegrass, old-time and what
ever, topped off with a whopping dollop
of good old-fashioned showmanship.
It is the nature of traditional music to
spawn many bedfellows. I say bedfel
lows and not simply offspring because,
due to the limited number of outlets for
traditional and quasi-traditional music,
whatever music is spawned usually con
tinues to share the arena with traditional
music, often to the detriment of the tra
ditional music. Such has been the case
with traditional old-time fiddling and
contest fiddling.
Contest fiddling may be equated with
Texas long-bow (a good attempt at a
definition of Texas style is found in the
following article). It does share an his
torical connection with old-time fid
dling, but today there is almost no
stylistic connection between them. Clas
sical techniques, stressing tone produc
tion and left-hand virtuosity, are useful
to a person wishing to learn contest style
fiddling. Old-time bowing licks, phras

Missouri

Cultural

Heritage

Center

CONTEST
FIDDLING

North Missouri traditional fiddlers Delbert Spray (Kahoka), Michelle Ogle (Spray's
apprentice, Kirksville), and backup guitarists Jim Lindsey (Newark) pose after the fiddle
contest at the McCullogh Park Bluegrass Festival in Chillecothe, July 1985.

flashy, more accessible. Contest fiddling

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

say

more?
Yet often the old-time fiddlers in
these areas of the country have no other
place to be heard other than contests,
which do at least offer a chance to see
friends and be part of something; and
often the promoters, despite how it
appears, have some interest in aiding the
perpetuation of traditional fiddling. The
audience, too, contains a certain number
who actually prefer old-time style. What
is
the solution? Different divisions?
Segregated contests? Different judging
criteria? What do you think? While you
are pondering these thoughts, read the
following article by Howard W. Mar
shall, who as head of the Missouri Cul
tural Heritage Center, is very intimately
issue.
I
became
in
this
involved
work
and
his
with
him
acquainted
his
article
version
of
earlier
an
through
which was brought to my attention by
Erin Kotajarvi, a 16-year-old fiddler
from Thayer, Missouri.

THAT TEXAS CONTEST
SOUND, TAKE TWO*

the

happens? It is not too hard to imagine.
How can you compare contest fiddling
and traditional old-time fiddling? Tradi
tional music is by its very nature the
sublest of musics. Contest fiddling is

contests. Need

was created to win

Guest Contributor,

Howard Marshall

My attendance

Missouri

at

an

important con

which Texas-style
"contest fiddlers" from distant places
completely clobbered other stylists got
me to wondering about what's going on
with traditional fiddling. Not only did it
seem that there were no old-time
fiddlers in the top three finalists, there
test

in

in

were no bluegrass violin players either.
If it weren't for noted Boone Countian
Pete McMahan (5th place), who has the
sand and skill to go head to head with the
whiz kids,
Missouri styles
likeable
would have been skunked by Texas and
Oklahoma worse than when Texas and
Oklahoma football teams play the MU

Tigers.

The Fiddle Contest

recent years, the fiddle contest con
test has emerged as an important force
for the maintenance of fiddle styles and
tunes. Without the traditional events
like dances and house parties, the role of
In

contest has become vital. In many
cases, a contest provides the only oppor
the

tunity for fiddlers and friends to see each
other, visit, and enjoy sharing a tune or
two on the violin.

Since contests are essentially competi
tions, however, there are inevitable
hazards. There can be a fixation on cer
tain tunes proven to be winners, which
gradually become show pieces suited to
specific styles of playing. There can be a
tendency to mimic styles and attitudes
popular on the stages of "national" con
tests (e.g., Weiser, Idaho for the Texasstyle crowd, and Galax, Virginia for the
old-time crowd) so that the trend
toward definition of "national styles"
gathers speed, to the detriment of
regional and ethnic styles. There can be
almost continual domination by gifted
players and thus discouragement of
other players. Tremendous loss of cer
tain kinds of tunes once familiar in the
community can occur. Focus can easily
shift to the popular individual perfor-

�mance and away from friendly jamming,
fun, and sharing of experience.
Despite the efforts of associations like
the Missouri State Old-Time Fiddlers
Association, some of us feel that con
tests are still often run inappropriately
and judged on criteria that are inappro
priate. For example, "Showmanship"
and "Crowd Appeal" are sometimes
listed on judging criteria. Since contest
rules are often vague and even contra
dictory, Charlie Walden's "A Brief
Guide to Fiddling Contests: A Continu
ing

Missouri

Tradition"

(Missouri

Cultural Heritage Center /University of

Missouri and Missouri State Old-Time
Fiddlers Association, 1983) ought to be
required

reading

for

any

group

who

putting on an old-time
fiddling contest.
Fiddle contests are an agent for edu
cating audiences as to what is "good" and
"bad." There is an increasing emphasis
on the basically Texas and Oklahoma

considers

swing style of playing that seems to be

developing as a national contest style.
The popularity of the Texas contest
style is "teaching" audiences, contest
organizers, young people, judges, and
fiddlers
themselves that authentic
Missouri and Midwestern tunes and

Taylor McBaine (Columbia), Pete
and Jack
McMahan
(Harrisburg),
remember
Hockemeyer
(Mokane),
when a hornpipe was not allowed in a
contest as a hoedown but instead had to
be played as one's tune of choice. It is my

opinion,

unfortunate

that

classic

Missouri and Midwestern hornpipes
(many learned from listening to
Canadian radio stations in the early days
have been shoved
of broadcasting)
through the hoedown grinder and are
now played in the pace and mood of a
hoedown. I recall at an important and

commercially-successful

regional

con

test in 1986 when a senior Missouri oldfiddler asked the registration
time
person if one could play a hornpipe for
the "hoedown;" the registration person
and the contest managers had no idea
what the gentleman was even asking
about. The matter of the devolution of
the hornpipe deserves analysis from the

experts. One need only hear McBaine or
Jefferson City's Jimmy Gilmore play
"Durang's Hornpipe" (a Missouri stand
ard) the old-time way to see the differ
ence in bowing, pace, and melodic

structure.

styles are less desirable.

Hey Joe, What Should
Contest?

I

Play in the

difficult to articulate what we
mean by old-time fiddling as displayed
in the context of a contest. R. P. Christeson (who produced from his years of
field recording the University of Mis
souri Press volumes and LP record
It

The "hoedown" category has come to
include hornpipes played hoedownstyle. The senior contest players, like

is

What "style" manner of bowing, pace,
fingering, rhythm) shall a young person
take up in order to appeal to judges?
Events like dances and house parties,
where tunes and styles traditional in the
area generally
prevail, have been

replaced by the festival and contest as
the proving ground for aspiring fiddlers.
The unfortunate results include the fact
that few young players are aware of the
customary demand for "danceability" in
a tune rendition,
since, regrettably, no
one seems to dance very much any more.
Most young players learn tunes from
listening to recordings (tapes and LPs)
of fiddlers they like, rather than in the

disappearing context of the community

dance or pool hall jam session. All of us
learn from recordings, whether from
The Grand Old Opry or an LP record or
swapping favorite cassette tapes with
fellow fiddlers. That is fine. But many of
the best traditional fiddlers have never
by

recorded

been

companies

nor

workers.

by

commercial

preservationist

field

Their music is therefore not
accessible unless a person seeks out the
master at home or works with him at a
festival or contest.
The media, with its focus on progres
slick, stylish "Texas" playing,
sive,
commercial Nashville session fiddling,
and hot bluegrass (and "newgrass" also,
and Vassar Clement's marvelous "hill
billy jazz") music makes things more
difficult, of course. While some would
say that the media only report what
happens in an event, in fact the media
exert

a

considerable

influence on our

attitudes and tastes. (The media's treat
ment of "country" fiddling, and the sub
ject of bluegrass, deserve commentaries
of their own.)

called The Old Time Fiddlers Repertory)

Heritage

Center

pondered the subject in a short-lived but
important local newsletter, the Midwest
Fiddler (Feb. 15, 1976). In his essay,
Christeson considered whether contests
ought to just call themselves "entertain
ments" because so little of the violin
playing seemed to be old-time. Christe
son noted, interestingly, that when con
test rules try to emphasize old-time

have

a

"tune

Missouri
Courtesy

of

McMillen

we

Missouri contests
(along with a hoedown and waltz); but
or
few people have the confidence
or
a
to
a
schottische
knowledge
play
quadrille instead of another hoedown,
and most contest judges would be at a
category

in

loss to know how to evaluate such tunes
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ford

elsewhere,

Margot

As

choice

Cultural

fiddling, they may exclude kinds of
tunes that are just as traditional as
hoedowns and waltzes (such as schottisches, polkas, cake walks, jigs, quad
and rags) and thus
marches,
rilles,
actually encourage the dropping of these
less-common tune types.

Left-handed central Missouri hornpipe and contest tiddler Jake Hockemeyer gives a lesson
apprentice, Spencer Galloway (Sturgeon), with Howard Marshall providing guitar
second at the Hockemeyer's home in Mokane, January 1987.
to his

�Note on the Economic Sector
Contests offer prizes. People can
remember prizes of desirable goods and
services as well as cash and trophies.
Taylor McBaine's first contest prize,
won in the little Missouri River town of
Lupus in 1924, was a pair of overalls.
Indiana fiddler Betty Lindemayer's late
father, a contest fiddler during the
Depression, received in one of those
A

years a buggy whip, a pair of shoes, and a
load of coal as prizes.
Many senior fiddlers learned to play

tunes neighbors wanted for
entertainments in the days before TV.
Dances were very often an important
source of income for musicians, espe
cially during the Depression. Similarly,
jazz violinists like Kansas City master
Claude Williams supported themselves
playing in nightclubs. Traditional music
particular

reflects

not only cultural heritage but
changing tastes and demands of the pay
ing

audience.

It is

completely understan

dable that many skilled old-time fiddlers
play the contest circuit in order to win

cash prizes that augment their incomes.
If contest promoters and the skilled
judges acting as their agents reward play
if not noners of nationally-popular

Old-Time Fiddlers Associa
tion, and producers of major contests
could play key roles, as could public
agencies that give funds to contest man
agers., such as the National Endowment

the tune." (We do agree with the scho
lars that there is no "correct" rendition
or
style for an old, commercially-

distributed,

and

National

intercontinentally-

but
familiar tune like "Sally Goodin"
the tune should be recognizable.)
A distinctive feature of the Texas
"sound" is the style of the back-up
music. A jazzy, bar-chord, fast-moving
Texas dance band back-up style moves
but
the fiddle tune along beautifully
provides a very different feeling than
does a Missouri back-up style. Texasr
style guitarists use lots of swiftly chang
ing bar chords to follow the tune along in a
lovely and intricate way, rather than the
runs and open chords most characteris
tic of old-time and bluegrass backup gui
tar at a Missouri square dance. Some say

made
Twian

fall, there

is

produces

A

a

tendency to "pro

gress" into innovative, swinging exten
sions of the basic tune line in the third or
fourth repetition of the tune. This is
what old-time Missouri-style
players
like McBaine call "dressing up the tune."

them, the chief alteration
According
when a tune is dressed up is that "too
many notes" are added to the essential
traditional tune line. The Texas-style
players have dressed up Missouri tunes
Love
"Don't
like
Goodin,"
"Sally
to

the Lowground"
to the point where some of the senior
masters say they "can hardly recognize

Nobody," and "Billy

in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

attention to and per

Closing Word and

Contests

play

a

a

Question

vital role in setting

tant than the traditional tune itself.
Creativity and extensive jazzing (quite
often in perfect imitation of a recording

Benny Thommasson, Dick Barrett, et
more
become
important than
al.)
respect for and ornamentation of the
basic traditional tune. The tradition and
community heritage underpinning the
whiz kids' glory is ignored and some
times laughed at and trampled on.
We need to find ways to encourage
the

tunes

retention
and

of

styles.

authentic
Groups

Missouri
like

the

Center
Heritage

Courtesy
Jones

Cultural

I think
the main bone of contention
with Texas fiddling in "old-time" Mis
souri contests is that young people are
beginning to think that the ultra-creative
personal elaboration of the basic tune
now considered to be an improve
is more impor
ment on an old tune

by

late and tasteful playing of

Missouri

Former state champion and master central
Missouri old-time fiddler Taylor McBaine of
Columbia displays an impressive collection of
trophies won through many years of
competition. November 1985.

cians and they influence the attitudes of
older fiddlers, too. It hurts my feelings
when an old-timer puts his fiddle away
and doesn't enter a contest when the

Texas

Katherine

even how to describe
Texas fiddling, other than to compare
several features that stand in contrast to
traditional or old-time violin playing.
Texas fiddling has an emphasis on long
sure

waltzes.
Texas style has

special category for Mis
fiddling, and we hope

values and standards for younger musi

That Texas Contest Style

bowing strokes and single-string melo
dies; very precise intonation (a necessity
to succeed in playing jazz licks); more
vibrato; more decoration of the basic
tune; a slower pace than most Missouri
square-dance sets would be comfortable
dancing to; a repertoire stressing reels,
hornpipes, hoedowns, and rags (played
much the same tempo) and
at very

is a

old-time

that this will call

expectations.
not

Championships, one of

haps reward some of the state's fine tra
ditional players.
But
I like Texas contest-style fiddling.
I do
not want to see it totally take over
among our younger fiddlers in Missouri
contests. If the skilled youngsters from
distant places who perfectly render
Texas contest tunes continually over
whelm local fiddlers, I believe this will
do a disservice to future generations. I
believe a priceless part of our cultural
heritage will be lost.

surely cannot blame the young person
for adapting to these perceived values

I'm

Fiddle

the

souri

traditional fiddle styles and tunes, one

and

at

an

big-purse contests that attracts
distant Texas-style contest players. This
the

"progressive" backup style, and it
some very fine music. The
tenor guitar, chorded tenor or plecturm
banjo, electric guitar, and piano also
contribute to the Texas sound. I must
say that the elaborate and smooth barchord progressions Jerry Thomasson
used to play on the tenor guitar behind
his dad's fiddling are excellent indeed.
this

arts councils. In
important step has been
the November Land of Mark

for the Arts and state

Missouri,

twisters (who really are gifted
musicians) make the old-timer's articu

old-fashioned

Missouri tunes seem shabby. It would be
a sad state of affairs if the old-timers gave
up their traditions and started copying
the same Texas-style recordings that
represent a kind of "national" fiddle
style that the skillful young people have
already copied perfectly.
It is also painful to observe older

fiddlers who, seeing how jazzy and
attractive the contest-winning Texas
tunes can be, sit down and start "dress
ing up" and altering (in what I think are
appropriate ways) the style they learned
in their families and communities.
Could "authenticity" and "danceability" be given more weight on the judges'
score sheets? "Creativity" is important,
but I value most the kind of creativity
that takes place naturally as a dynamic
part of an ever-changing tradition; I do
not put as much value on creativity
when foisted upon me from cold com
mercial forces.
Most of the traditional fiddlers I
know regard danceable quality as just
about the number-one criterion for
good fiddling. The legendary "kitchen
fiddler" Art Galbraith of Springfield

Missouri impressed that on me 20 years
ago, and I firmly believe it.

�There is a tremendous amount of
pressure on the judges in any contest.
Contest managers might consider pro
viding judges with pints of whiskey, flak
jackets, and U.S. Marine escorts along
with pencils, scoresheets, and honora
ria. I struggled to serve as a judge on a
once for the
couple of occasions
Smithsonian Institution's Festival of
the middle
'70s, and once for the National Park
Service's western regional contest in San
Francisco in 1982 (where the other
judges were Benny Thomasson and Joe

American Folklife contest

in

Pancerewski). But remembering that£an

expert is a son-of-buck from out of
town," I'm not sure I would care to judge
a fiddle contest in my own backyard.
The old-time fiddle contest does play
a vital
role in the future of authentic
regional American fiddle styles and rep
ertories. Prizes are awarded according to

promoters' perceptions of consumer
demand, played out through the peri

lous labor of good judges who know there
will always be a beef. We need to find
ways to encourage the dynamic life of
and South
traditional Missouri tunes
Dakota tunes, and Vermont tunes, and

Texas tunes

accomodate

while still being able to

ourselves

to

the

popular

trends of today. What do you think?

Howard Marshall
Missouri Cultural Heritage Center
Conley House
University of Missouri
Columbia 6521 1

*This commentary is dedicated to the
memory of the late Bill Creson of Howard
County, who took pleasure in playing tunes
like "Moss Billy" and "Irish Washerwoman"
the old-time way at contests long after
audiences and judges came to prefer hotter
and slicker tunes; "That Texas Contest
Sound" is slightly different form first
appeared in the Missouri State Old-Time
Fiddlers Association Journal (spring 1987);
some of the material on economics was pre
viously used in text written by M argot
McMillen and me for an exhibition of his
toric violins in Jefferson City, an exhibition
that celebrated Governor John Aschroft's
July 1987 signing of "the fiddle bill" declar
ing the violin/fiddle to be Missouri's
cial musical instrument."

HOWARD MARSHALL,
of the

Missouri Cultural

is

"offi

director

Heritage Center

and professor of art history and geography at
Columbia.
the University
of Missouri
Marshall has made field recordings of Mis
souri fiddlers for 20 years, and took his PhD
at Indiana under Henry Glassie. He worked

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Music Hall of Fame, Conner
Prairie Pioneer Settlement, the Smithsonian
Institution, the Library of Congress, and

at the Country

Kansas State University before returning to
his home turf to develop theMissouri Cultu
ral Heritage Center and teach students to
come

to

grips with ordinary

history. There

has been a fiddler in each generation of his

since coming to Missouri from
Virginia, Kentucky, and North Carolina
in the 1930s, and Marshall says he is
attempting to carry on local traditions in
his own playing as well as through
research and teaching.

family

�The Dance Beat
by

Phil Jamison

In The Old-Time Days:

The Beginnings of Team Clogging
The fiddler kicked off the tune and
the rest of the band joined in. The Stony
Creek Boys were set up at the back of the

Collection

huge, empty stage. From offstage came a
rhythmic clatter as the 16 dancers burst
onto the dance floor in full step. The
sound of their tap shoes on the floor set
up a powerful cadence that fell in time
with the rhythm of the music. In

be.

Clogging (or buckdancing, as the oldtimers call it) as a solo dance form dates
back

to the earliest

Scottish

settlers

English, Irish, and

to

the

southern

Appalachian Mountains. They brought

their fiddle music and dances with them
to the area. Born from these roots, the
steps have changed over the years. Many
people believe that black and Cherokee
Indian dancing have influenced the
steps, giving them a heavier heel beat as
opposed to being all up on the toes as in
Irish dancing.

Square dancing was a popular activity
these mountains. Local dances could
be found almost any night of the week,
often following a corn-shuckine or barnin

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Lamar
Bascom
Archives,
Photo
Hill

Mars

dance figures. They danced all out for
close to 10 minutes while the band
played "Are You From Dixie?" As they
exited offstage, a few of the dancers were
close to fainting from exhaustion, but
this was not seen by the applauding
audience of 2,000 in the Civic Center
auditorium that night. This was just one
of 10 dance groups competing at the
60th annual Mountain Dance and Folk
held the first weekend of
Festival,
August in Asheville, North Carolina.
In western North Carolina there are
not just a few local clogging groups, but
dozens. They consist of dancers of all
ages, from senior citizens right down to
the kids in the "peewee" groups. Many
teams as a
have
schools
clogging
extracurricular
activity. It is
prestigious
a local
phenomenon that is unique to
this part of the country. As a clogger, I
became interested in how this came to

Lunsford

outfits, the doggers
brighty-colored
seemed to float across the floor, their
feet flying in freestyle clogging steps
while they executed big mountain circle

raising. Throughout the big circle dance
figures, the dancers used a smooth
"running step" as Cecil Sharp had seen
in Kentucky. Occasionally
during the
figures, dancers would break into some

individual

buckdancing,

as

moved by

music. This dancing was done
strictly for fun until the 1920s when it
the

exhibition.
1928 the Asheville Chamber of
Commerce wanted to attract more
tourists to Asheville. They decided to

was first put on stage for
In

to sell the area's rich local folk
culture and they enlisted Bascom Lamar
Lunsford to put together a show of
traditional mountain music and dance.
who had grown up in
Lunsford,
try

Madison and Buncombe Counties, was
deeply immersed in these traditions. Fie
was not only a musician and dancer, but
also a self-made folklorist who traveled
to neighboring counties in search of
traditional music.
Lunsford was concerned that the
mountain music and dance were dying
out, and he thought that a festival was
the way to promote them. He sent word
musicians in the
and
dancers
to

surrounding

communities

that

a

for "dancing clubs" and
"string bands" would be held. Five dance
groups formed to compete for the $100
prize being offered. They came from

competition

such places as Soco Gap, Sandy Mush,
Hominy Valley, and South Turkey
Creek.
The big event was held on the evening
of June 6 at Pack Square in downtown
Asheville. An area was roped off and a
wooden platform erected. More than
5,000 spectators crowded around the
dance floor that first night for what the
Asheville Citizen called a "throwback
from the modern jazz-mad world." The
program of "old-fashioned songs and
dances of the mountains" was a huge

success.
Lunsford had proved that even in
modern times, when the media was
beginning to dictate people's tastes,
there was still widespread interest in the

music and dance of the
This was the first folk
in
the United
festival
States, and
Lunsford and the Chamber of
Commerce decided to make it an annual
event. It expanded to fill two and
eventually three nights and came to
old

reliable

mountains.

�include

contests

for

ballad

singers,

harmonica players,
and individual buckdancers as well as

fiddlers,

pickers,

dance teams and string bands.

Although

Lunsford had set out to

preserve the old mountain traditions,
whether he liked it or not, the festival
sparked innovation and change. The

competition
dancers

to

excitement

lured

come
that

the

out
has

musicians and

and

created

an

keep the
dance from dying out, but it also led to

helped

change and standardization. When one
dance group wins, others are quick to
imitate their steps and style the following
year, giving the dance
groups a
homogeneous look and dance style.
The person who is reputed to have
influence in the
had
the
greatest
of
team
dancing was Sam
development
Queen of Haywood County. Queen had
promoted exhibition square dancing for
tourists at Maggie Valley for years. His
own dancing had been influenced by a
black caller and buckdancer named Bob
Love, and perhaps also by the dancing of
local Cherokee Indians just over Soco
Gap. Queen formed the Soco Gap
Square Dancers and took them to
compete at Lunsford's festival. His
group incorporated freestyle buckdance
steps throughout their dance figures.
One of the Soco Gap Dancers, Arnold
Cooper, was part Cherokee. Other
square dance teams in the area were also
a mix of Indians and whites, and in 1939

a
group called the Cherokee Indian
Juniors under the direction of Abraham

won

Walkingstick

the

the

Junior

festival.

Championship
thought that this Cherokee Indian
influence gave the Soco Gap team and
at

It

is

a heavier
beat with more
heel than the older style buckdancers.
This driving beat, together with the
use of freestyle buckdancing during the

other groups

influenced other dance teams
into a standardized
developed
western North Carolina style. Other
groups continued to perform the older
smooth-style square dancing without the
These two distinct
fancy footwork.
figures,
and

dance styles were judged together at the
Asheville festival until 1959 at which
time they were split into two categories.
Another style of clogging became
popular in the late 1950s. Precision
clogging, as it is called, is credited to
James Kesterson and his Blue Ridge
of Henderson
Dancers
Mountain
County. In this style all dancers do the
same step at the same time. It was felt by
the festival committee that this style
strayed too far from the individual
expression of traditional dancing, so
since 1970 precision teams have been
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

omitted from the festival.
The standardization of dance styles

only one result of putting dance
teams on stage in competition. Another
was
was

standardization of costumes
uniform look of groups

the

resulting

in the

today. Lunsford was opposed to
costumes. He thought that they killed
individuality and that the mountain
people should dress and appear as they
really are. In 939 he took the Soco Gap
Dancers to perform at the White House.
of someone in
At the suggestion
Washington they wore costumes for the
first time. In the 1940s and 1950s,
bright colored costumes, crinolines (due
to Western square dance influence), and
1

white, red, or even lime green tap shoes
became common on the dance stage.
The use of taps on the shoes started in
the mid- 1930s. The dancers liked the
rhythmic cadence created by their feet
on the floor, and the taps added to the
sound. Controversial at first, it wasn't
until after the Second World War that

were commonly
accepted.
Lunsford was opposed to taps as they
were not traditional at the mountain
square dances. An attempted ban on
them in the 1960s failed after one year
to be standard
and
they continue
footwear for doggers.

they

T earn

clogging both

in

dance style and

costume has changed greatly in the 60
years since Lunsford's first Mountain
Dance and Folk Festival. While he
wanted to stay close to the tradition in
order to preserve it, Lunsford tolerated
the gradual changes that take place when
a tradition thrives and remains alive and

growing as it has here in Western North
While elsewhere in the
Carolina.
country precision clogging has taken
over, many of the younger dancers in
clogging groups in this area appreciate
live fiddle music and enthusiastically
favor the cut-loose spirit of traditional
mountain freestyle clogging.

would like
following sources
I

this article:
by

Loyal

Consortium

to

of

acknowledge
information

the
for

Minstrel of the Appalachians

Jones

(Appalachian

Press, Boone, NC,

1984);

Chase That Rabbit by Stephen Marsh and

David Holt, Southern Exposure (Chapel

Hill, NC, 1977); From Our House to the
White House a film by Lawson Warren
and Ron Ruehl (NC Dept. of Natural
Resources, 1982); and interviews with:
Jackie Ward (Asheville Chamber of
Commerce), Don Wise, Gertie Mae

Morgan,
Crooke,
Jordan.

Raymond

Peek,

Glenn Bannerman,

Johnny
and

Ottie

�Workshop
CLEVELAND'S MARCH

This version of "Cleveland's March" comes from the late Roscoe Parish of Galax, Virginia. He can be heard playing the tune on

The Old-Time

Way,

Heritage 070. Banjo tablature

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

by

Andy Cahan.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

BRAVEST COWBOY
Key of D

741;

Oscar Jenkins,

Night--

Stay

Fred

All

This version
comes from the singing of Tommy; the
third verse comes from Tommy's sister,
A.G.
Julia Lyons of Toast, NC--

Tommy

ham,

Jarrell.

D
am the bravest cowboy

I

G
That ever trod the West;
D
G
I've been all over the Rockies,
A
D
Got bullets in my breast.

eighteen hundred and sixty-three

In
I

joined the immigrant band

We marched from San Antonio
Down

I

by

the Rio

Grande.

saw the Indians coming;

went out on the prairie,

I

Cocker

I

learned

to

sow the line;

I

learned

to

pocket money

But

I

did not dress much fine.

I

rambled on back

I

learned

rob and steal;

to

It's when

robbed that cowboy

I

How happy

I

wore

Texas,

to

I

did feel.

wide-brimmed white hat,

a

My saddle too was fine;

And when
You bet

I

I

courted

a pretty

called her mine.

I

courted her for beauty,

We heard them give their yell;

For love

My feeling at that moment

Till they carried me down

Rio

tongue could ever tell.

girl,

it

was

in

vain,
to

Dallas,

To wear a ball and chain.

Gerrard

LP

County

Alice

Source:

�HERE
&amp;

THERE
Prairie Picking in
Central Illinois
Bill Rintz

by

Springfield, Illinois is much better
known for the years Abraham Lincoln
spent here as a lawyer and a politician
than it is for folk and old-time music,
but there is an active music and dance
scene here. Other places in central
in

Illinois--

Champaign-

particular

also harbor old-time

string
bands and regular country dances.
Probably the most active string band
in central Illinois is Springfield's Allen
Street String Band, started in 1982 by
fiddler Bill Rintz and banjo player
Urbana--

David

Landreth.

Allen

Street

currently also includes Ed Hawkes on
guitar and

Andrea Todd-Landreth

on

bones, and the band
banjo-ukelele
plays concerts and dances throughout
Illinois as well as in Missouri and
A
Indiana.
organization
non-profit
and

called Prairie Grapevine started up in
Springfield in conjunction with the
band, and it still holds country bands
twice a month. These dances feature

Midwestern

and

Southern "hoedown"

square dances along with contra, circle,
Martha Tyner
and couple dances.

from Bloomington, Illinois, who
Allen
bass with
plays
occasionally
Street, is the person-in-charge and the
principal caller, sometimes assisted by

Darleen Ecklund, Andrea Landreth,
and others.

Prairie Grapevine also sponsors

a

folk

concert series which often
old-time music. A local
coffeehouse, the Southtown

music

includes

Coffeehouse,

couple of
years ago by a group of volunteers, and it
has served as a venue for old-music
concerts by Mid-western groups and
area old-timers, occasionally sponsored
Mandolin and
by Prairie Grapevine.
was

started

player Ivan
Waverly, Illinois and

a

from
fiddler Arlin
Dietz from Decatur, Illinois are two of
the older musicians who performed at
guitar

Dodge

Southtown Coffeehouse last year.
Unfortunately, the coffeehouse has just
the

lost its original location and is presently
looking for a new home in Springfield.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Boneyard Creek Cloggers

Twelve miles west of Springfield is the
Clayville Rural Life Center built
an
1850s stagecoach stop.
around
festival during
a music
holds
Clayville

(this year the 7th annual
early August) that always
includes old-time music, as do the spring
and fall crafts festivals. Nearby is the
New Salem State Historic Site, where
Mr.
Lincoln first settled in central
Illinois. New Salem sponsors an
informal gathering of bluegrass and oldtime musicians every September that
sessions
numerous
in
results
jam
summer
festival was
the

in

distributed throughout a reconstructed
1830s village. To the east of Springfield,
near Decatur, there are regular old-time
twice a
and bluegrass
jam sessions
Center.
Rock
at
the
month
Springs
(Around here bluegrass and old-time
music are not always as separate as in
other parts of the country.)
In the old days in Illinois, folks would
often jig-dance to fiddle music, but
organized clogging groups are a relatively
new

development

in

this

area.

In

group called the Prairie
Springfield
Cloggers gathers every so often at Mary
Anne Singleton's house, but they are
not so much a performing group as are
the Boneyard Creek Cloggers. This
a

clogging team in Champaign-Urbana has
even sprouted their own string band, the
Saline Ditch String Band, which is
about to make its debut.
The

Urbana Country Dancers

the most active

country dance group

are
in

central Illinois, with big dances every
other Friday. George Lowrey who

started the group, and Orace Johnson
call most of the dances, although they
occasionally have out-of-town callers.
They dance the usual mix of Southern,
Western, and New England squares,
contras, and other dances. The

Peppermill String Band
Snakeroot String Band are

and
the

the

two
most
these

Champaign-Urbana bands that
often provide the music for
dances. There is also an old-time string
band

based in Bloomington-Normal,
called 'Tater Patch String
which
Band,
plays every so often for
both the Springfield and Urbana dances.
Peppermill and 'Tater Patch both
include hammer dulcimer in the band,
and, in fact, there is a history of hammer
dulcimers in central and western Illinois
itinerant
due
to
music
old-time
instrument salesmen in the late 19th and

Illinois,

Peppermill
early 20th centuries.
includes Kathleen Everingham on
Bruce Williams on hammer
George Lowrey on guitar,
Michael Shapiro and sometimes
fiddle,

dulcimer,

Nelson

Mandrell
and

mandolin,

on

'Tater Patch consists of

and
on bass.

guitar

Francis Bray

Claudia Kauf

man on fiddle, Gary Kaufman on
banjo, Dale C. Evans on hammer dulci
mer. and Martha Tyner on guitar. The
core

group

of

Snakeroot

is

Wayne

Logue on fiddle, Brian Holloway
guitar, and Peter Fagan on banjo.

on

addition to the country dance
groups in Springfield and Urbana,
during the farming off-season (late fall
In

to

early

spring)

there

are

several old-

�square dances in small towns in
central Illinois such as Jacksonville and
Palmyra. These older dancers have
their own way of square dancing
they
dance to the beat, not to the phrasing of
the music as in contra dancing. The
bands are made up of impromptu

time

groups

of

area

country musicians,
including electric guitar or

sometimes
accordion, and they are as likely to play
modern country-western song for
round dance

time

as

a
a

they are to play an old-

hoedown

other

at

times.

Springfield dance caller and auctioneer
Davis and his band, The
Jim

Unpredictables often

turn up at this

sort of country dance. Also, Eugene
Brown is an elderly caller who calls
rarely these days but who has called
these small town dances for many years.
Old-time string band music does get
some airplay on a couple of central
Illinois radio stations. Folk Festival on
WSSR-FM, the National Public Radio
affiliate at Sangamon State University in

hosted

Springfield,

is

station

Champaign,

by

Bill

Rintz,

who often includes old-time music on
the program.
The community radio
in

WEFT-FM,

old-time music on several
features
programs, in particular The Willow

Branch
Taylor.

Rambler,

hosted

by

Bill

Finally, no article on old-time music
central Illinois would be complete
without acknowledging the debt owed
in

Indian Creek Delta Boys

of
of this

the

to

Charleston, Illinois. Members
now-disbanded group, especially Gary

Steve

and

Harrison,

collected

hundreds of old-time fiddle tunes in
southern Illinois in the 1970s and did
much to share inspiration and fiddle
tunes with others interested in old-time
music, including the Allen Street String

and quit playing. For example,

Gilmore

more information on old-time
in Central Illinois,
contact Bill

For

music
at

(217) 522-6041.

Monroe

in
eastern New
Elida,
we met him
was
in
his
when
70s
Mexico,
five years ago, and he had quit playing 30
years before that because he had been
told that he played "too scratchy" by
others in the area. To our ears he had a
fine old-time style (a bit unpracticed, of
course) with a repertoire that included

of

"Soldier's Joy," "Fire on the Mountain,"
and

Band.

Rintz

evolved (which is not a dance style), it
seems these musicians got discouraged

"Snowbird on the Ashbank." His
and

parents

grandparents

from

were

Oklahoma and Texas. With a bit of
encouragement from us and his wife, he
playing again in the local senior
centers, much to the delight of his peers.
A typical story, I surmise.
New Mexico,
Today in northern
acoustic music is alive and well,
especially old-time and bluegrass. We
Southwest
have two organizations:
began

SOUTHWEST
CORNER NEWS:
Albuquerque,
New Mexico
by

Jeanie McLerie &amp; Ken Keppeler

There has probably been old-time
music in the Southwest for many years,
because as people moved westward, they
brought along their fiddles and love of
cohesive
But
it
takes
a
dancing.
community to keep a form of music
alive, and as the contest style of fiddling

Gavilan

452

Pickers,

PI.

NW,

Albuquerque, NM 87107, and the New
Mexico Folk Music Society, PO Box
40421, Albuquerque, NM 87196,
which organize concerts, potluck jams,
and dances. Both have newsletters. El
Paso has the Border Festival the first

weekend

Tucson

in

Tucson has the

October.

Friends

Traditional

of

has Swallow Hill
on these).
(sorrv,
Southwest Pickers puts on great
monthly concerts during the summer on
Sunday afternoons in Madrid at the ball

Music,

and Denver
no addresses

park, several mid winter concerts in
Santa Fe, and the ever-popular Santa Fe
Fiddle and Banjo Contest on Labor

Day Sunday at the rodeo grounds. For
the price of a concert ticket, anyone can
camp out there and pick all night, to be
in great shape for the contest the next
day. Anything goes at this contest

(except the contest style, because there
from young
no money prizes),
Suzuki
students playing "Boil in'
are

Cabbage Down" en masse to the most
■clectic or pure styles of old-time and
luegrass that the locals can come up
with. There is also a category for
Hispanic fiddlers, and over the years the
audience has been treated with the music
of

Alfredo Vigil

and

Cleofes Ortiz

classic old-time fiddlers in the style of
Spanish colonial dance music.
The New Mexico Folk Music Society
has been putting on concerts over the
past few years including people like the

McKennas,

McGinley,

Danny

Dewey Balfa &amp; Tracy Schwarz, Sara

Grey,

The Boys of the Lough,

Touchstone,
Allen Street String Band

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to name

a

and

few. They also

�audience of several thousand. Behind
the stage, near City Hall, musicians
gather for jam sessions that can last far
into the night. Everyone is welcome to

Old Time Music

Western

In

North

Carolina

by

come and sit in. On a typical Saturday
night you might see Doc Snodderly's

Hilary Dirlam

Painless String Band

and the

Carroll

Best Band on the green.

There's lots of acoustic music going
on in the Asheville area. It takes a little
sifting to find the old-time music; you
have to know where to look. Often a
pickin' session will yield several bluegrass tunes to every old-time tune that's
and the musicians
played. The tunes
there, though.
There are several well-established jam

are

in Tijeras on the first
Saturday of the month, square and
contra dances in Albuquerque at the
Heights Community Center, potluck
and concerts of local
jam sessions,
musicians. The Friday calendar section
of the Albuquerque Journal lists dances
and concerts for the upcoming week, so
if you're coming through the area, try to
pick up this paper. Our local radio
station KUNM is in a state of flux and
NPR
takeover. We hope that the

sponsor campouts

voice as
a result. The American Folklore Society
is
having its annual meeting in
Albuquerque this October and we are
looking forward to a lot of musicial
community

is

not left without

a

activity in our area during that time.
In closing, I'd like to mention some of
the names and salute the efforts of those
who continue to play good old-time
music and keep it alive: the Adobe

Brothers,
Barnyard

the

Big

River

Ray

Mountain,

Ray,

Greene's in Black
Walter Davis, and

other musicians play the tunes they've
been enjoying for the last 50
years.
Tuesday nights at Tina Hicks and
Stephen Tyler's in Flat Creek there is a

specifically old-time jam. Thursday
evenings out at Mrs. Hyatt's, near the

Farmers Market, there's
include anywhere from

musicians,

a

jam that can

three to 15
plus spouses, kids, and
Traditional fiddlers might

onlookers.
include Grover

Sutton

Ben

and

Entrekin.
out

in

Friday nights on Bear Creek
Leicester you'll find Parham's

a session
now in its 16th year.
host is Chub Parham, guitar
player, banjo player, and (if the spirit
moves him) flatfoot dancer. The rest of
Bear Creek
the
Chub's
band,

Picnic,

The

weekly

Ramblers,

will probably be there
Gordon Freeman,
fiddlers
with
along
who plays with the
Hunter,
Tommy

Carroll Best Band,
now

in his

and

don't hesitate

Tommy Bell,

Boys,

to

old-time music lover,
look some of us up

when you're in the area.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

callers
and

Swinging
Jr.

Cole,

Tommy Bell (standing),

and Troy Lewis

Phil

Bridges,

Greene

Furman

an

supports

in

one
the

dance,

Swannanoa.

include

Meg

Jamison,

and

there's always live music provided by a
variety of old-time musicians and bands.
Too Hot to Cook is a regular at the Old
Farmer's Ball. Up in Celo, a little past
Burnsville, is a Saturday night once-amonth dance at the Arthur Morgan
School. Dudley Culp is usually the
is
and
music
caller,
provided by

90s and still fiddling.

and your trulv,

area

and contra

square

Frequent
McCleod

the
Lonesome
Ramblers, the Amazing

Fields, John Barnitz,
Bayou Seco.

Asheville

Old Farmer's Ball out

Frolics,

Moonlight

you are

Tommy Hunter

The

Fast Pesos, Distilled Spirits,
Sandyland (in Tucson), the Tune
Junkies, David Margollin, Louis
If

Amberg

Cleofes Ortiz, July 1987.

at

nights

Rob

Kerry

Blech

sessions that take place weekly. Monday

with

Bruce

on fiddle, and occasional guest
musicians. A newcomer to the area

dance scene

Dance

is

the

Old-Time Country

the Beech Community Center
in Weaverville. Tina Hicks calls squares,
at

mostly, and Martin Fox, Steven
Millard, Tyler and Don Pedi play old-

time tunes. This dance is the third Friday
of every month.
If you enjoy free-style clogging, Bill

Saturday nights on the green

in

City-

Asheville, is Western
North Carolina's famous (to us,
anyway) Shindig on the Green. This
event takes place between the Fourth of
July and Labor Day. Local bluegrassand
old-time bands play on stage, and local
County Plaza

clog teams

in

dance.

There's

usually

an

Stanley's Barbeque and Bluegrass

is

the place to go any night of the week.
You can dance to the music of the Mark

Pruett Band
every once in a while
Asheville-based Green Grass

the

up and dance there.
Night spots featuring any old-time
music in western North Carolina are,

Cloggers show

�alas,
practically non-existent.
McDibb's, in Black Mountain, used to

Wayne Erbsen

have old-time music fairly frequently,
but now seems to have everything but

old-time. Down the street

at the

major there can concentrate in the area
oldof the region's traditional music
time fiddle, clawhammer banjo, lap

Town

is
a
frequent
John Lilly
performer, playing guitar, fiddle, and
mandolin, and singing old-time songs as
well as Jimmy Rodgers favorites and
and rhythm and
early rock-and-roll

Pump,

blues.

You

Human

dulcimer, guitar, and country singing are
taught. Wayne also teaches beginning
fiddle and clawhammer banjo at the

Down Home Pickin' Parlor

Our

local

in

and are good to work with.
haven't
There's a lot
I

radio
couple of

public

a

performances and new recordings of
"Second Wind,"
musicians.
local
hosted by Tom Draughn and Don
Pedi, and "Country Roots." hosted by
Wayne Erbsen, are both well-worth
Listeners

can

call

Asheville

Citizen-Times

If

Hoosier Outpost for
Old-Time Music
it's

Klassen
in

there's a
contras are called there, always to live
music, and often to Southern old-time
music, although occasionally to Cape
Breton or New England styles.
The

dance,

Gordon Freeman

Bloomington,
square dance. Actually, more
Wednesday

15-year-old
sponsored

Wednesday night
the amorphous

by

Morrison,

BOTMDG
annual

involved

is

festivals:

more

for

with

two

Swing into Spring,

put together by Tom Morrison at a state
park west of Bloomington each April

1980, and Sugar Hill, now
approaching its 10th year, held in
August at a Girl Scout camp east of
town. A festival that traditionally hires
some Bloomington old-time musicians
since

Battleground

the

is

Fiddler's

held in June-July at the
Battle
Field, near Lafayette,
Tippecanoe

Gathering,
In

addition to playing for the dance,

musicians

old-time

perform
house at

the

at

occasionally
coffee

Daily Grind

Dunnkirk

Square,

at

the

Unitarian-Universalist
at

Jake's

coffeehouse,
(big names only), in the

bar

University Archives
Traditional Music concert series,
Indiana
in

city

parks

of
and

department-sponsored

summer). Recent
(in
include
Metamora, Pete
performers
concerts

Sutherland

and

Lotus Dickey

and assorted friends, and

Karen

Billings,

Leftwich and Higginbotham.
I

don't

sessions.

know of any regular jam
Most often, old-time music

spontaneously

combusts

at

house

parties, often in accompaniment with
dancing. Fiddlers, banjo-pickers, and
guitar players who make the area their
more-or-less permanent home include

Leftwich and Linda Higginbotham,
Sutherland, Mark Ritchie, Teri
Klassen, Bob Herring, Frank Bell,
Brad

Pete

Grover Sutton

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

me

or

information.

Indiana.

are

By Teri

Harmony School gym. Call Ted Hall,

Tom

mentioned.

in

A

the

is

Park shelter, and starting this fall in the

Jamison

requests,

to.

too.

(BOTMDG)

Group

cornerstone of the town's old-time
music community. It is free and takes
place summers at the Upper Cascades

Phil

listening

Bloomington Old-Time Music and

Dance

in

local Sacred Harp singing
in
both the white and black
groups,
traditions. There are local festivals and
contests that would take another entire
article to cover. Suffice it to say that if
you come to western North Carolina,
especially in the spring, summer, and
early fall, you'll probably hit an event
that includes some old-time music.

There

station,
weekly
WCQS,
programs that offer a fair amount of oldtime
music and often include live
has

Center

Asheville.
this old-time crossTo complete
section, it seems like a good idea to
mention a couple of recording studios
that
specialize in acoustic music.
Skylark in West Asheville and
Butterside in Asheville are good places
for old-time musicians to record. The
engineers (Pat Sky at Skylark and
Heller at Butterside) are
Steven
sensitive to how the music should sound

Johnson City, Tennessee. The Down
Home has a variety of entertainment,
but the
people there have a real
commitment to the area's traditional
needs
area
music. The Asheville
this.
like
something
You'll have better luck listening to the
radio.

Community

Jewish

catch John at the
Factor in Asheville
can

sometimes, too.
The nearest place offering old-time
music on a consistent basis is probably
the

also co-coordinator

is

Appalachian Music Program at
Warren Wilson College. A liberal arts

of the

The Easy Street String Band playing for

a

dance

at

Sugar Hill

�Randy

Marmouze,

Mark

and

Fedderson, of the now-retired Easy
Street Stringband. Lotus Dickey, a
fiddler, composer and guitar-player in
70s, lives about an hour's drive
south.
Indiana
especially its
University,

his

Folklore Institute, School of Music, and
Archives of Traditional Music
(Anthony Seeger, director), attract
powerful albeit transient influences to
the local old-time scene. Currently one
such is Cape Breton-style fiddler Kate
Dunlay. Past IU scholars have included

Miles Krassen, Dan Gellert, Richard

Blaustein, Dillon
Stanton, Blanton

Bustin, Gary
Owen, Tom
Carter, Judy Hyman, Jeff Claus,
Theresa Broadwell, and Billy
Thatcher.
Additional
quartered

include

in

the

bands that have head
the area in the past decade

Raincrow

Countryside

Band (with Dillon Bustin), the Dry
and Dusty Stringband (Brian
"Hawk" Hubbard, David Molk,
Robbie Wyatt, and Tom Sparks), the

Skjrtlifters

David

(Hubbard,

Wierhake),

Wyatt

the

and

Knott

Brothers (John Bealle and Paul
Tyler), and Strawberry McCloud and
friends.

McCloud,

a

transplanted

Kentucky

who died in Bloomington in
1980, learned tunes from Doc Roberts
and played with the Georgia Wildcats.
fiddler

He

taught

Bloomington

young

musicians tunes such

"Bloomington
fiddler Gary
Harrison has shared versions of tunes

Breakdown."

as

Illinois

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

such as "Late for the
as some of his originals,
such as "Boys, the Buzzards Are Flying."
The Highwoods Stringband played
here a few times in the mid '70s, and
he

collected,

Dance,"

as

well

inspired local musicians

in the

early days

of the dance.
A Sacred Harp singing group meets

irregularly

on

Indianapolis and
old-time dances.

Sunday
Lafayette

(Thanks to John Bealle
information included here.)

mornings.
also

for

have

some

�11:00

a.m.-12:00

noon

Monday-

gospel music, both tradi
tional and bluegrass. Monday through
Thursday afternoons contain a mix sim
ilar to the mornings, with late afternoon
concentrating a bit more on old-time
and bluegrass. Kelly Epperson hosts a
bluegrass and old-time music show Fri
p.m.
day afternoons from 2:30-5:00

Friday

has

WAMU-FM, 88.5 FM

Washington, DC
Owned

broadcasts

WPAQ,

the

Mt.

Airy

"Early

Country Classics,"

all

old-time

music from his vast collection of 78 rpm
records, with commentary, taped at his

home in Maryland, and aired 10:3
11:00 Saturday morning. From 11:00

a.m. until 1:00 or 1:30 Saturday after
noon, the "Merry-Go-Round" show
cases live bands, both old-time and

bluegrass. The show is booked five to six
months in advance. Elbert Marshall pro
duces "Blue Ridge Echoes," a taped
show presenting lots of local bluegrass
and old-time music, and occasionally
presenting excerpts from his personal
recordings of the Galax Old Fiddlers

Convention

in the years before the
Moose Lodge made official recordings.

From 2:00-6:30 p.m. Saturday, the
"Blue Ridge Spotlight Extended Edi
tion" concentrates on vintage disc and
tape recordings from the 1920s to the
'50s, and on current records in the old
time style. Ralph Epperson, the owner
and founder of the station, and Kelly, his
son, host this show in an informative
and

entertaining manner.
has itself been spotlighted

WPAQ

in

article by Jack Bernhardt in Bluegrass
Unlimited (August 1987). WPAQ-AM,
P.O. Box 907, Mount Airy, NC 27030,
an

(919) 786-6111.

Galax, VA
Another Epperson family-owned sta
tion, WBRF is not as heavily pro
grammed to old-time music as WPAQ,
but still contains some solid bluegrass
and old-time music on Mondays from
7:05-11:00
p.m. in a program hosted by
Flarold Mitchell. Harold is on the air
every evening except Friday and Satur
day. One Saturday a month, except in
the
the
summer,
"Carroll-Grayson
Hoedown" is broadcast live from the
Ruritan Building in Fairview, NC, six
miles south of Galax. And, of course,
WBRF airs the Old Fiddlers Conven
tion every August. WBRF-FM, P.O.
Box 838, Galax,

VA 24333.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

far

University,

into

wonderfully eccentric exception--

the

Dick Spottswood Show, 3:00-6:00 p.m.
Sundays. Ranging from blues to calypso

to old-time
demonstrates Dick's
coherent, broad-based and deep knowl
edge and understanding of American
regional and ethnic musical cultures.
The host uses his collection of 78 rpm

country-and-western

music, the program

records

in

many genres,

as

well

LP's. Among his numerous

as

recent

ethnomusi

cological projects, Dick has produced
the
15-album series, Folk Music in
America, for the Library of Congress in
1976. WAMU-FM, The American Uni
versity, Washington, DC 20016 (202)

885-1030.

Stay tuned to the Old-Time Herald for
more information on old-time music on
the radio!

Record

companies,

musicians,

and

festival promoters: send albums, tapes
and event information to the radio sta
tions and producers mentioned in these
listings.
Listeners, radio programmers, record
companies, and performers: help us
compile this listing of radio stations that
feature old-time music. Send all infor
mation to Emily Fine in care of the Old
Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA

24333.

Be as complete
as possible;
include the station's call letters, fre
quency, and location; affiliation (uni

versity, NPR, etc.) the shows that
feature old-time music, and times and
hosts. The station's general format or
program schedule, and an address and
phone number for the station would be
helpful

WBRF-FM, 98.1 FM

American

Virginia and
Maryland, and has primarily a public
affairs, talk, and bluegrass format, with a

to

Fiddlers' Convention in June.
Saturday, is a bonanza for old-time
music lovers: Joe Bussard produces

by

WAMU reaches

in

completing the picture,

�The problem

playing.

is

I

there

Is

don't like his fiddle
future

any

this

for

relationship?
isn't sure what you
do you not like fiddle playing in
general? Do you not think his fiddle
playing is any good? Either way, Uncle
Harold thinks that mutual attraction

Uncle Harold

A:

mean

between the sexes is only a short-term
serious differences of
for
panacea
musical taste, opinion, and abilities. Be
forewarned.
Who did first record the fiddle tune
"Candy Girl"?

Q?

Uncle Harold

A:

research

this

on

done

has

question

extensive
has

and

discovered that "Candy Girl" was orig
inally recorded by Uncle Bunt Stephens

You can hear this tune on

the '20s.

in

the
"Nashville
1. Actually,
Uncle Harold's extensive research
consisted of reading Charles Wolfe's
excellent liner notes.

County Record 541,

Early String Bands," Vol.

would like to join an old-time
stringband but wouldn't want to be in
Q=

I

I

any

band

that

would

member. What should

have

I

me

for

a

do?

When Uncle Harold read this, he
that some sort of logic
problem was being inflicted upon him.
After mulling it over, however, he has
A:

first suspected

come to the conclusion that you must
a
have
problem with your selfconfidence in the area of music. Uncle
Harold urges you, therefore, to ignore
your feelings and play as much as

possible
possible.

with

as

many

people

as

would like to cake this
welcome you to his column.

Uncle Harold
to

opportunity
Your questions and differences
with him are eagerly awaited.

of opinion

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�tradition and currency are not at odds, music
is from the villages where we live.
Molly Tenenbaum

on

...and nou\

in

Cannery

Row.

had

long hair, being
but these guys had

his own words:

was born April 6, 1940 in Oakland,
California, on scenic Telegraph Avenue.
When was five we moved down to our
family ranch, "Coastways." was raised
there, pretty much out of society, and
went to school in Santa Cruz.
My mother's generation all had music
lessons as kids, but they never took it
very far. The same with my generation.
We all had piano lessons for two weeks
I

I

I

I

when we were five but we were just too
wild, and eventually my parents quit
hiring piano teachers.
The music we had around was just my
Gilbert &amp;
parents' record collection
Dvorak
Bach,
Beethoven,
Sullivan,
and what came over the radio. An aunt
and
Marais
some Joseph
us
gave
sister
and
records
Miranda
got
my
carried away by the Weavers. In 1956,
that same aunt gave us a record of steel
band music that I just about wore out. I
still love that record. I learned a lot
about rhythm from it.
violin and viola in the junior
I played
can't remember
high school orchestra.
first heard old-time music, but
when
when I did, I liked it. There wasn't any
old-time music in the family. There were
some real hot musicians among the
great-aunts and great-uncles, though I
never heard them play. Great-aunt Sue
I

I

had quit playing in the mid-1920's and
her fiddle went under her bed until she
gave it to me in 1952, then it went under

a

my draft

I

Waller showed up in Monterey and we
started playing a lot of fast and furious
music, with me trying to sound like a
bluegrass fiddler. Butch wanted me to
come up and play his next gig at the
Tangent in Palo Alto in a band called
did.
"The Pine Valley Boys," which
The Pine Valley Boys went on to
Carnegie Hall and all around the country

surfboard rider,
than

hair

longer
mine, and big mustaches. They had a
five-string banjo, a fiddle, and a guitar.
Their names were Dick Graham and
Peter Stampfel, and they sounded pretty
much like their first Holy Modal
Rounders album. They were even crazier

1

were, and we really prided
on being crazy. It was like
in
love.
spent the whole next
falling
week with those guys when I wasn't
working. Peter showed me what he did
with the fifth string on the banjo and he
inspired me to take my fiddle out from
under the bed. I learned two banjo
tunings from Stampfel and went around

than

we

ourselves

for

all

a

tour.

hootenanny/folk

I

went to

Fort Ord.

I

the

go back to school, I received
notice. On that same day Butch

decided to

came these two

In

long-haired, wild-looking guys. Now

that

IN THE ARMY NOW
THEN ON TO GALAX &amp; OTHER

YOU'RE

MUSICAL REVELATIONS

The Army sent me to North Carolina

October 1963, and
the
to
hitch-hiked
in

day and all night

banjo
playing
through '61 and '62, but still played the
plectrum banjo in the beer and pizza
places.
My brother David and I played a lot
together from '61 to '63. We'd go to
hootenannies, which had even gotten to
Monterey. Everyone had their various
ideas about music. The political singers
sang their songs, the banjo players
would want to show off on the banjo,
would play
brother and
and
my
Chuck Berry, or
Mexican music or
anything you could think of.
The 1963 Monterey Folk Festival was
Doc Watson, Bill Monroe
really good
to
a big revelation
Clarence Ashley
seen
had
ever
time
first
the
it
was
me as
real southerners play music.
About the summer of 1963, just as
I

I

I

Convention

in

August 1964

Galax

the first one

I

1

Fiddlers
ever went

revelation. couldn't
believe that ordinary people would walk
around carrying so many instruments
to.

It

was another

I

and playing so much neat music, and no
amplification. That was what pushed me

off down the road of Virginia-style oldtime music.
think Buddy Pendleton won that
Galax convention. The fiddlers were all
playing solo in those days, a real joy.
heard Wade and Fields Ward play "Out
had heard the
on the Lone Prairie."
Wade Ward record and was thrilled to
hear them play the tune in person. The
Poplin Family was there. They seemed
to spend their whole time on the fiddlers
convention circuit and were huge
favorites. All they had to do was show
I

I

I

1961

my bed until

roommate gave me a
a
invented
tuning and
guitar,
learned some chords. When my aunt
In

college,
and

a

I

Mary who actually knew how to tune a
corrected me,
dropped
guitar,
had a
everything and started over.
I

I

mental breakthrough concerning chord
inversions while driving in a car one day
like how to play "Five Foot Two" up
the neck.

Some of my college friends played
clarients and trumpets and trombones,
and had a Dixieland band. I loved sitting
in the middle and listening to them play.
It was heaven on earth.
bought a fivestring Flarmony banjo for $65 but
couldn't figure out what you did with
took if off and
that short string, so
tuned the remaining strings like the top
four strings of a guitar and began playing
my chord inversions. I even had the

Bradley

I

Courtesy

nerve to ask to sit in with the Dixieland
band.
played with them a lot in

Hank

I

I

Monterey in 1959.
We were playing one night

in

Kalisa's

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Hank and David Bradley,

Lake Tahoe,

1976

�on

up

stage

with

costumes

shirts

and

their

little

Providence, Rhode Island that consisted

railroad

of Les Daniels and Martin Mull. The
three of us were quite a band for a week
or so. Those guys rewrote their own oldtime music, great stuff. We were the
Double Standard String Band. I was in
crazy heaven with them. We turned
an
Elektra Records contract
down
because we thought we really should
record for Vanguard, but that fizzled
out. Martin, of course, took it and ran

engineer's hats, striped
everyone would go

think I saw Luther Davis play,
didn't really meet him. Norman
Edmonds was still playing. I saw little
Edmonds start playing the
Jimmy
following year at Union Grove. He was
"Yaaay

!"

though

I

I

years old or something like that.
"The oldest fiddler and the youngest
fiddler right here in the Edmonds
six

with it.
In the summer of 1965, Jim Watson
went to the fiddlers convention in
and
Pulaski, Virginia. An older gentleman
was there playing the living hell out of a
fiddle. It turned out to be Clark
Kessinger. He had an interesting way of

family."

before

but

Galax

the

Convention started

Fiddlers

up, I went
went to see James Hypes,
trader who drove to all the
conventions with a trunk full of
the finest musical instruments
Bradley

Galax.

I

back to

ahorse
fiddlers
some of
I

ever

go up to Bluefield,
West Virginia to see Oscar and Eugene
did for a day. It was
Wright, which

saw. He suggested

I

Hank

I

Clarence Ashley

at

Union Grove, NC 1965

hung around Durham a bunch,
playing jug band music with Carter
Bannerman. I learned as many of the old
tunes as I could learn. By the time I got
out of the Army in August 1965, could
play abput 20 tunes. My repertoire was
small until County Records flooded me.
I

1

came back down to Galax,
great fun.
met Roscoe Russell, and it turned out
that Roscoe and Otis Burris hung out
together. I went cruising with them
around all the back woods of Galax and
hung out at Kyle Creed's store. I met a
whole lot of local musicians. They
thought it odd that I would play "The
Arkansas Traveler" in thekey of A, butl
didn't know any better, and they were
I

very tolerant.

bought my first County Records at
Galax or Union Grove, $4.98 postpaid.
Smith
the
discovered
Harry
in
Records
on
Folkways
Anthology
1965, Michael SherKer was a good
I

FRESNO,

RON

HUGHEY AND

SWEET'S MILL

I

banjo player from New York who had
taught art in Durham. I visited him in
New Y ork and he took me down to meet
Moe Asch of Folkways Records. Moe
was very kind to me and gave me a whole
bunch of Folkways records at $2.00

each as if to say, "Here young man, go
out into the world and do all this good
stuff." I memorized the anthology over
the next couple of months. I got County

501 and 503, a Jean Carignan record,
and "Mountain Music Bluegrass Style,"
and others.
On

that same trip
with
up

hooked

to
a

New York,

band

I

from

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

leaving Galax, I came out to
started to get doses of Ron
Hughey's (a transplanted Missourian

After
Fresno.

I

archaic Missouri fiddling, as
opposed to the even more archaic
southern style mixed with bluegrass that
ed.)

was going on in Galax at that time.

Hughey, Pete Everwine, and
Hicks were the Sweet's Mill
Mountain Boys; Kenny Hall played with
them occasionally. Frank and Ron had
regularly played dances in Fresco since
the '30s. Frank knew everything on
guitar from the oldest tunes right up to
western swing. I think he had played in
Spade Cooley's band and recorded with
Ron

Frank

Paul

Anastasio

and

Joe

Holley.

Pete

Hank
Courtesy

playing essentially simple fiddle tunes;
he'd play within a small compass, say
inside of a fourth or a fifth, and have all
these interesting melodic lines running
and
that never repeated themselves
always kept surprising me. I think I used
that as a model for some of my playing.
The week after I got out of the Army

Bradley

I

1964

Otis Burris,

Everwine was

played

a

professor

embryonic

at

Fresno and

three-finger

bluegrass-style banjo that made nice
accompaniment for fiddle.
I'd go down to Ron Hughey's welding
shop in Fowler, about 10 miles outside

of Fresno. Ron was
guy

and

a

big, jovial, friendly

loved to play the fiddle.

I'd

enhance that by bringing along a guitar
for the oom-pah. On terribly hot days in
Fresno we'd get in the car and drive up
into the foothills of the Sierras where life

cooler at a couple of thousand feet
We'd go from small town, to small
town, to little bars and roadhouses. Ron
knew everybody. We'd go to two or
three places in an afternoon, stop, have a
was
up.

beer, play fiddle, and not have to pay for
the beer. Then we'd go back down to

Fresno and swelter all night.
The first finger on Ron's left hand
was quite stiff. He had been a metal
worker most of his life and had banged it
many times with a hammer. His hands
were big enough that he could park that
finger in the pegbox and note with his
other three fingers unless he had to play
way up the neck for swing tunes. Then
he'd use his first finger as kind of a barre.
He had a strong right arm and played
very loud. His fiddle was relaxed against
his chest and would actually slide up and
down depending on what he was doing.
He'd turn the fiddle under the bow
although he'd also move the bow to
cross some strings. He'd usually have a
cigar stuck in his mouth. You could tell
how pleased he was by the angle of the
cigar. When it reached up and burned
his nose he was doing very well. The last
time I saw Ron play must have been at

Sweet's Mill
couldn't
I

in

1973.

say

when

Sweet's

Mill

�scorn is pointed
Berkeley, where

started. I first fell into it in the dead of
winter, 1966. For a long time Sweet's
Mill was basically
Virgil Byxbe's
summer home in the Sierras near
Fresno. The Byxbes were aiders and
abettors of the Fresno Folk Music
Society, with meetings at the Byxbe

house

and
at

moved in 1967.
That was the beginning of the real
marathon old-time music scene on the
West Coast.

Jeff

Courtesy

met all the Berkeley music freaks in
the summer of 1967, and I brought them
all down to Sweet's Mill for New Year's
1967. After this, Sweet's Mill started
getting really big. The last time I went
I

1973,

and

I

guess

it

continued

another three or four years.
In
1967, after 1 graduated from
engineering school at Fresno, I went to
Folk Festival and was
the Berkeley
first met
introduced to Doc Watson.
him at Sweet's Mill when he came down
with Fred Price and Clint Howard to
play for the Fresno Society in '66 or '67.
At the Berkeley festival Doc asked me to
and
with him,
play on the show
and
Rick
Shubb
spent a
subsequently
month with Doc playing on the tag end
of all his shows. It was great fun.
I

I

BERKELEY
the
with
working
Cleanliness and Godliness Skiffle Band a
lot, but by the spring of 1968 I was
back to
so I went
totally broke,
but I
Band
Skiffle
the
left
engineering.
a lot of
street
of
a
lot
music,
played
"Diesel Duck" music with Eric and Sue
Thompson and Rick Shubb, some
"Jose's Appliances" music with my
and
brother and Carter Bannerman,
some "Finger of Scorn" music with
Larry Hanks and Kenny Hall. Kenny
would stand up and say, 'The finger of
I

had

fiddlers.

Sue

Sue
Mac
where
Benford,
Draheim, and Will Spires lived was full
We
it was headquarters.
of musicians
the
music
all
old-time
played everlasting
time on the streets, or we'd go to
Virginia Waterson's to play all night.
The 35th Annual Berkeley Fiddlers
Convention came about when a bunch
of us decided, "Hey, let's put on a
fiddlers convention like the ones we
used to go to in Virginia."
several quasi-regular
were
There
bands: Dr. Humbeads' New Tranquility
The Benford-Bamford
Band,
String
Band of Jim Bamford, Mac Benford,
and Linda Laing. Jim played guitar and
he knew
was a Charlie Poole fanatic

Street

Ron Hughey, Fresno, CA ca. 1973 from his
album on American Heritage Records.

was

for

looking

Draheim was the other fiddler and we
kept very busy. The house on Colby

weekend

the occasional
Sweet's Mill.

had

1

Berkeley was full of banjo and guitar

players

Cherniss

gathering

you!" This was all in

at

been

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

them

all.

1969-70

(In

Mike

Seeger
Farms" on

produced the LP "Berkeley
Folksways Records which featured many of
ed.)
the Bay Area old-time musicians.

YUGOSLAVIA,

SEATTLE,

KANSAS, AND SEATTLE AGAIN
1970 Hank was asked to play music
Balkan dance group, Koleda. He
moved to Seattle where the group, directed
Tuell (Bradley), was located.
by Sandy
In

for

the

Hank

some

got

experience

playing

a little Bulgarian
Vranjesevic, a Seattle Serb
who played accordian, taught him several
tunes that he still plays. Koleda left for

music and

Tamburitzan
music.

George

June of 1970 and stayed for
returning from
After
Yugoslavia Sandy and Hank married, and
Hank's company moved them to Kansas

Yugoslavia

in

months.

three

where he worked

Sandy and

I

as a surveyor.

joined the Kansas Old-

Time Fiddlers Association and played
here and there. We played several small
gatherings

conventions

around
in

Kansas

and

fiddle

Missouri where things

more active. By that time,
learning to play guitar. We
played a lot of Grange dances just a mile
from our house. We'd play all night into
one microphone in a big, loud hall,
were

a

lot

Sandy was

playing waltzes, schottisches, and always
ending with "Home Sweet Home."
We returned to Seattle in the summer
of '72, with a detour through Galax. We
Galax Fiddlers
the
at
out
hung
Convention, playing with Mac Benford,
Walt Koken, and a bunch of others who
happened to be there. James Lindsey (of
the Mountain Ramblers bluegrass band

ed.) walked up out of the
from Galax
crowd and said, "Hey, we don't have a
fiddle player for our band; you want to
help us out?" So I was a Mountain
Rambler for the 1972 convention. We
played the "Florida Blues" and I got to

have all kinds of fun.
We spent several days around Galax,
then went to the fiddlers convention in
Fries. I played my fiddle there during the
dance contest. The band was Jimmy
Edmonds, me, and someone else. Every
dancer came up and told the band, "Play
'Old Joe Clark' as fast as you can." We'd
do it. 1 put so much force on the fiddle
that the glue joints came undone in the
humidity. I had to let the strings down
and forget

it.

After Sandy and I returned to Seattle
the Gypsy
Gyppo String Band got
rolling. The Gyppos were Jack Link on
fiddle, Nancy Schenk on bass, Jerry
Mitchell playing mandolin, Warren
Argo playing the banjo, Sandy Bradley
playing guitar, and me on the other
fiddle, although after I went back to
didn't have the time and only
work
with
them occasionally.
played
In 1978 my company asked me to
work full time and be the "boss." It be
I

hard

came

to

myself away

pry

from

work and find time to play music. I've
been struggling along since then, playing
as much as possible, but I've not done as
much playing as I'd like, and what I've
music
played has been almost all Balkan
wasn't playing oldsince about 1979.
time music except when Jody Stecher
came to town.
I
had seen Jody at Union Grove and
not
we played a little in 1968 and '69
We
and
actually
much,
very informally.
started doing gigs together about 1975.
We were a little bit crazy, like taking
Malvina Reynolds' song "Little Boxes,"
and playing it as a Cajun waltz. We'd
play "The Arkansas Traveler" on two
fiddles, trying to outcrazy each other. In
1975 we started going to the San Diego
Folk Festival regularly and doing little
gigs up and down the East, drove to
Toronto to play at the Marisposa Folk
Festival, and then came back through
Canada.
When Jody comes to town we always
I

concert, riding on the energy we had
We've progressed little since
then. The polish we had isn't there now.
I'd love to do a three-month tour with

do

a

in

1977.

Jody, then make
have the time.

a

record, but we don't

COMPOSING AND RECORDING
to invent
is
trying
tunes that
new
write
to
something new,
the
as
same
the
hearing
me
pleasure
give
Part

of

me

�and
both have this dream: say we had
six of the best musicians we could
imagine, what would we write for them?
I

the future, I'd like to play more
tunes, make up more tunes, try more
crazy things. I'd like to write more
animal terrorism tunes like "Chasing the
Squids" and "Chasing the Crickets.
"Chasing the Girls," I'd like to write that
one. I have all kinds of grandiose plans.
I'd like to record some more of my own
compositions. Some I may do as I did
In

ed.): all
my Bay record (see discography
with
I'll
do
more
by myself. Hopefully

other people,
far.

I

as

I

prefer that sound by

recorded the Bay record with me

the parts because I was short
knew exactly what I wanted to
do, and I didn't have a band available. It
could
became apparent to me that
record most efficiently if I'd haul a
carload of instruments to Alameda from
Mike
Seattle and play all the parts
and
Cogan had an 8-track studio
that's what I ended up doing. I have been

playing
of time,

all
I

Courtesy

Hank

Bradley

I

Hank

&amp;

Sandy Bradley

old musicians play something that takes

Before

me by surprise.

between

I

started playing

ages of six and
music,
twelve, I used to make up huge long
things that would ring in my head for
days; really extended pieces that would
go on for 15 minutes at a time, with
sections that would not repeat
themselves. I never attempted to write
them down or explain them to anybody.
That long, extended music doesn't come
to me anymore. I can pick an idiom and
synthesize if want to. I can sit down and
force myself to write a tune. "Tilden"
invented "Beasties
was done that way.

the

I

1

in

the Sugar"

at the

Renaissance Faire

16th century costumes.
A lot of the tunes I've written recently
have come to me in terms of one phrase
and I'll write it
or two
a measure

among people

in

don't forget it.
enough mental
energy or time to sit down and make a
tune of it, and invent a second half.
"Chasing the Crickets" was done that
way; at a restaurant the first line came
into my head and I wrote it down on a
napkin and stuck it in my pocket. Days
took it out and finished
or weeks later

down

or

Sometimes

tape

it

I'll

so

I

find

I

it.

My rules of composition:

It

can't be

can't sound like someone
obvious,
else wrote it, and I've got to like it when I
always want a tune to be
get done.
tricky, but not so tricky that eventually
lose interest in it. I'd like to put some
it

I

1

real energy into making up music and see

what

I

could put together. Jody Stecher

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1978

�1

got

my

always

recording since
four-track

recorder in 1975 and it's what I used as a
sketch pad to do my record. It's always
been interesting to me, very satisfying to
create something out of nothing; sit
there, play all the parts and have

a

wish they would continue it
I
somehow. That's what really made
southern fiddling sound like it does;

scene.

little

playing alone forces you to furnish mel
ody, harmony and rhythm all in one
package. You can't abandon any of it. At
western contests, they totally abandon
harmony, other than playing through
the chords like a jazz player does, and
rhythm. They've got these big, strong
backup bands to pound out chords so all
the fiddler has to do is think of an elabo

I

satisfying.

THOUGHTS ON CON
AND WESTERN FID
DLING
Music contests are a joke in them

SOME
TESTS

surprise, be venturesome, dashing,
was totally frozen in
experimental
We ended up with
rules.
the
concrete by
a whole generation of fiddlers who play
defensively. You play a tune as few times
through as you possibly can, then sto
before you make a mistake. You worK
out all these variations and you recite
them. It's like skating mandatory fig
ures. It has nothing to do with the joy of
movement at all. Western fiddle con
tests are purported to be very rational
scientific
and judged on meticulous
criteria. Weiser has gotten so perverted
by

judges don't even watch the
stage. They listen over a speaker in
another room to a mechanical reproduc
tion of the music. If they watch the musi
cians they might be unduly influenced
by the posture of the musician or some
thing like that. They have all these
that

the

wonderful rules like you can't pluck
strings because that's trick fiddling and
is sinful and should be disallowed. Cer

banned because the
the crowd would go
assumption
wild over them and they wouldn't listen
to the real music.
Most of the fiddle contests I've played
in have been in the West. The Washing

tain

tunes

are

was

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

accompaniment.

fiddle player always played alone. That
was a signpost of that whole musical

band playing something back. I always
look for something really neat when
listen to music.
Sometimes you don't find it, and if
you can think it up yourself, it's very

melody line.
Eck Robertson was raised in Texas
but played with lots of energy and sur
prises. I definitely prefer Eck Robertson
over the newer Texans. I could listen to

Hank

Bradley

rate

Courtesy

selves. Those who presume to judge the
music basically always do it on a gut level
feeling. In Virginia, I could accept that
the local people are going
somehow
to play the local music just right and win
the contest. Then I got here in the West
where everything is under the influence
of the Weiser, Idaho Convention. These
old fiddlers associations sincerely felt
you could develop rational criteria and
actually compare musicians and say one
is better than another. I felt like there
was a rulebook five inches thick and you
had to know the whole thing so you
didn't break one of those rules. The
which is
whole idea of playing music
them
take
to
people,
delight
supposed

presupposes

You never see one of those fiddlers play
ing alone. At Galax, until recently, the

current

ton state contest was in Buckley for sev
eral years. I went in '73 and they had
never seen me before, so they put me in
too old to be a
the Limited Division
to be a Lady,
female
not
enough
Junior,
too young to be a Senior, too unknown

to be in the Open Division. Limited was
for all those who almost made it. So I
won that. In 1974 I actually got to enter

Open Division. I played a bunch of
good old southern tunes: "Dusty Miller

the

more or less on the Arthur Smith line;
an Irish waltz we called 'The Young
Maid Milking Her Cow;" and "Bull At
the Wagon."

I

found out later that the

judges had gone off in the hallway and
asked. "What is this 'Bull At the
Wagon?' Is that old-time fiddling? Did
he make that up?" In one of the other
rounds, I actually played a tune I had
the
"Fall By
Wayside.
composed,
Nobody asked any questions about that.
won that one. (I shouldn't say won it
I

I

mug.) I've
in
I won
contests
few
other
in
a
played
Los Angeles at the Topanga Canyon
contests in '69 where Earl Collins also
was entered. You just can't go around
saying, "I beat Earl Collins in the fiddle
contest." That's really ridiculous. The
trophy was the best one that I've
received. It's on a great pedestal like
most fiddle trophies, except that it has a
nice jackass on top. To this day I love
that thing. I thought that was even better
than the Berkeley fiddle contest the year
we gave five pounds of rutabagas to the
winner and six pounds to second place.
The western style of music grew up in
more modern setting than the
a much
Virginia music did. Western fiddling
they

gave

me

the

biggest

Thomasson for hours. He
could always take me by surprise; there
was always some invention going on in
his playing.
Thirty to 40 years ago in the West,
there was a much bigger variety of tunes,
especially in the contests. I almost never
the late Benny

anyone play a jig or schottische in a
western fiddle contest anymore. They

hear

used to have elaborate set dances, like
the "Rye Waltz," but they also weresubject to all the influences of city music.

They had gotten away from the southern
mountains and no longer played like
their particular village.
IN CONCLUSION: SOME
THOUGHTS ON FIDDLING,
PHILOSOPHY, AND VILLAGES
Jody Stecher noticed something, as I
did, about learning music from the old
people in the South. Invariably where
we've been, at fiddle contests or just
meeting old people who played music,
there's a huge hospitality. They were

always willing to accept people like our
selves who were interested in learning to
play the fiddle or banjo. They were very
uncritical about the way we played, or
actually approved, saying, "Wow, that

Blech

1961.

Kerry

multiple-track

doing

�sounds just like my grandfather. "On the
other hand, the music establishment, the
musicologists, or the scholars, looking
at the young people like ourselves who
were not raised in the tradition often
"I don't care how well you play,
that's not the real thing, you're a pallid
copy of the real thing, you're insignifi
cant, go away, don't bother me." I

say,

know the Highwoods Stringband ran
into that. It's a common experience in
our generation.
don't intentionally mix ethnic things
in with my American music, and I don't
really get confused. Every kind of music
wasn't born
play is something that
with. There's something really spiffy
about going to some place where people
I

I

I

are playing a tune, or singing a song
that's like nothing you ever heard
before. To discover new ways to put

together rhythms and harmonies and
I'm not trying to synthesize
melodies
but there's a
all these glorious things
me.
there
for
attraction
out
huge
I'm always up for

a

certain craziness

in

my music and in music in general. That's
not that
why I love the Horseflies
they're totally crazy. Although they defi
nitely don't sound traditional they have
a lot of respect for traditional music and
musicians. They have a cohesive sound
and they are not afraid to do what they
want with their music. They've created a
whole new village. Bravo! More villages,
we need more villages.
The village idea is this:

it consists of a
distinct
enough to
society
dodge the onslaught of sweeping mass
culture. When trying something new or

Arbor scene,

existing villages.
was much wilder in my
am now. I would take a
through more or less the
the tune, then act like a
player and stay close to the harmonic

For

years I
playing than I
tune and play
framework of

improved.

think there was a lot of romanticism
in all my early musical travels. In fact, it
is still there when I go some place I
haven't seen before: these marvelous old
musicians are doing things that nobody
else remembers how to do anymore.
I

They're making up all this wonderful
stuff, they're really high on what they've
done, it's an intense creative process,
they're in an exalted state that us mere
mortal Californians couldn't hope to
emulate. Then you get acquainted and
find out the truth about what's going on,
What they're trying to do and why
which isn't the same as you projected,
but

is

altogether
prising.

just as interesting and frequently

Hank

Hank Bradley &amp; Jody Stecher

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1986

in

these

a

cians.
There's so much really terrific music
in the world. Y ou could never cover it all
in a lifetime. There is still a big attraction
for me in going around and finding those
new little things that I haven't heard
before.
If you're going to play a certain kind
of music, it's very wise to figure out how
the village works. You can't just record
some of the tunes, go off a thousand
miles and copy the tapes you've made of
those tunes. You have to know why the
tunes are played that way, what their
history is, and go back behind them to
see where the musicians learned them.
Out there in the world are all those thou
sands of old musicians playing amazing
stuff that's been going on for centuries,

changes. Somewhere along the line I lis
tened to some of that on tape and I
realized it didn't have anything to do
with the tune. I still occasionally fall off
the deep end, but now I see the reverse
and sometimes
play some particular
tunes the same way through many times
in a row without trying to go off the deep
end. Maybe that means it's a perfect tune
and can't be

But

lot or
the same kind of stuff, with the result
being that somehow the beautiful, angu
lar rough edges are knocked off the orig
so I try to keep my
inal music
attention out there with the old musi

fit the

jazz

and others.

contexts everybody tends to play

Bradley

and

There's been a music movement in
this country that includes the Berkeley
scene, the Cambridge scene, the Ann

Courtesy

small

more interesting.

for a village, you can be as
original as you want, but if folks are to
listen more than once, or adopt the com
position into their lives, the music must
fit their learned, shared approach to liv
their language and speech, their
ing
previous music. No rigid rules here, but
some aspects of the composition must

composing

interesting,

altogether

sur

�I

wish to purchase

a

1-year subscription

to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

I

is

my check/money

wish to purchase

a

$16.00 (foreign)

order for $12.00

1-year subscription

to The

Old-Time Herald.

Name

Address

Enclosed

I

is

my check/money

wish to purchase

a

order fro $12.00

1-year subscription

$16.00 (foreign)

to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

is

my check/money

order for $12.00

$16.00 (foreign)

Send to: The Old-Time Herald P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Sales

County
Ql
CM

LJR

HER-071

THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TM recordings by RCA Victor
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
Vol 1" Reissue fo 1920s material
HARVEY SIMPSON "Rat Foot In The Ashes" Old-time fiddle LP by West Virginia fiddler
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroe's best early 1950s Decca material
CHICKEN CHOKERS "Shoot Your Radio" Newly recorded old-time music by this Boston-area band
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
UNCLE DAVE MACON "Over The Mountain
Vol 2" Reissue of 1935-38 recordings
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish
w/booklet
EMRY ARTHUR "I Am A Man Of Constant Sorrow" Reissue of 1920's &amp; 30's recordings
RICK ABRAMS "Wild Goose" Newly recorded old-time banjo tunes and songs

FCOT-005

NASHVILLE BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent old-time LP,

'CMF-011
OH-191

AHR-004
*REB-853
"ROU-0241

"SH-3759

OH-0183
HER-070
OH- 190

FF-415

TH-1001
*HAT-3022
*CO-791
*CCS-110

"CO-788
"REB-850

*FF-352

*JA-014
"CO-790

*HH- 19842
*TR-1

CO-545
AJA-5042
CO-509
CO-789
MS-45003
CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406
HER-63

CO-777

GFS-901
AH-002
SOUNDA-001
P-

13263

"CCS-108
"REB-852

EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
THE HORSEFLIES "Human Hy" Old-time music by this New York string band
CONFLUENCE Hammer dulcimer music by Lee Spears and Christopher Deane
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 1940 s King material
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T.Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTWICH &amp; HIGGINBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
HEEHAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing
TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music
UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine 1920's/30's sides
Import
JIMMIE RODGERS "Train Whistle Blues" Super reissue of train songs by Rodgers
Vol 2 Classic recordings with the North Carolina Ramblers
CHARLIE POOLE
DEE &amp; DELTA HICKS "Ballads And Banjo Music From The Tennessee Cumberland Plateau"
WINK THE OTHER EYE Old-time fiddle band music from Kentucky, 1920 s/30's recordings
Vol 2 Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
SKILLET L1CKERS
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carroll County, Virginia
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920's/30's
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 1938-4
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL with Mike Seeger, Brad Leftwich, Benny Jarrell, etc
VIRGIL ANDERSON "On The Tennessee Line" Old-time banjo from the upper Cumberland
SEEMS LIKE ROMANCE TO ME Traditional fiddle tunes from Ohio
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American fiddle music from Mississippi
EDDEN HAMMONS COLLECTION Historic set of traditional fiddle music
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Songs Of The Carter Family" Fine 1960 LP with Maybelle Carter

$12.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
0.00
7.00
7.00

"Early Dot Recordings" His classic sides from the 1950s
LOUVIN BROTHERS "The Best Of" Features their top songs from the middle 1950

I'ROU-0242

by an

asterisk

"

$700

7.00
7.00
7-00

.$1

1

s

")

On all ORDERS in U.S. A please add $1.50 postage&amp; handling
CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $4.00 postage for first 1-3 LPs, $1.00 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

l|^l

7.00

MAC WISEMAN

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted

RI^J

1

A. ROB1C &amp; THE

*ROU-0239

KJ

NO

NEW RELEASES

"ROC1-0233

1^^

H
N

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS

EW
9LJ

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
W
READY FOR SHIPMENT

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
0.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

I^J

y*

1^1

.$7.00

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

$10.00
5

7.00
7.00
7.00

UB

^Ll

QH

�Record

Reviews

record. (Hilary Dirlam)
To order: Train on the Island Records,
POB 9701, Minneapolis, MN 55440

FOR OLD
TIME'S

SAKE
Bob Bovee
and
Gail Heil

to
Cairo/Jack of All
Bush and Tree/Cotton
Mill Girl/Old Ladies Pickin' Chickens/
Goin' To German/Whiskers/Rein

Down

Goin'

Trades/Every

carnation/Hideaway/Dollar Down and
Dollar a Week/Drunken Hiccups/
a
Where Did You Get That Hat/The
White Slave/George Washington/
Ridin' the Chuckline/A Change in the
Business/Two Faithful Lovers/Squirrel
Heads and Gravy

Bob

harmonica,

Bovee-guitar,

vocals/Gail

Heil-fiddle, banjo, guitar, vocals
There

is a

widespread ignorant belief on

the part of Eastern Seaboard

dwellers that

old-time music exists only on the eastern
side of the Appalachians. Among the

recently ignorant, I'm trying to fill up the
void with good old-time music from West
of Here. Heil and Bovee's record and

accompanying booklet both delight and
educate. Heil and Bovee are good musi

a
sense of humor. And
several generally wellare
there
although
known songs and tunes on their record,
there are a number of Midwestern songs
and tunes as well. I particularly liked "Old
Ladies Pickin' Chickens" and "Whiskers,"
both fiddle tunes. "George Washington,"
first recorded by Pope's Arkansas Moun
taineers in 1928, is a spirited song. Other

cians,

with

cuts include a cowboy poem, "Reincarna
tion,:" and some IWW, novelty, and par
have an
and Bovee
Heil
lor songs.
energetic, authentic instrumental and vocal
style. I have a slight quarrel with the mix-have preferred less harmonica and
I would

more fiddle. Gail Heil's fiddling deserves
to be heard a little better.
The booklet accompanying the record is
an

entertainment

in

itself.

It

includes

words to all the songs, background infor
mation, and various and sundry illustra
tions that must be seen to be believed.
All in all, Heil, Bovee, and others in
volved in this recording/publication
have done a great job. I recommend this
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Tunes, which he did in 1985, just in
time to arrive in Seattle for my wedding.
got to spend part of my honeymoon
following Clyde around again.
Clyde was born in 1921, so he has a
lot of music still in him. This record
should help further his reputation as the
transmitter of old tunes that have been
dle
I

CLYDEO
SCOPE
Clyde

Davenport

Country 788

forgotten outside his county or outside
his family. This record is just the tip of
the iceberg. He is reputed to have the
repertoire of solo fiddle tunes
mountain
living Southern
fiddlers. We get a mighty fine sampler
here beautifully backed up by Bobby
Fulcher and Sharon Poss. When this
sells well enough, perhaps Clyde will
again be recorded for our enjoyment and
certainly hope I don't
enlightenment.
largest

Callahan/Roses in the Morning/Five
Miles/Polecat's Den/One-Eyed Rosie/
Kitty Puss/Coal Creek March/Boatin'

Up the Sandy/Flatwoods/Flower From
the Fields of Alabama/Ladies on the
Steamboat/Old Mister Rabbit/The Old
Cow Died in the Forks of the Branch/
Jenny

Cotton Patch/Meriweath-

the

in

er/Rye Straw

It

I

have to wait another eight years. (Kerry

Blech)
To order:

People paging through my wedding
album have asked, "Who's the fella
wearing the overalls?" Well, it's a long
story. Andy Cahan and I took a brief trip
through North Carolina in spring 1979.
While in Durham, Barry Poss played us
a tape he had just made of Clyde Daven
port, a superb fiddler from Monticello,

Kentucky.

among

just stopped us dead in our

There were some familiar pieces
from the great Burnett and Rutherford,
who were from Clyde's hometown, and
haunting solo fiddle tunes, reminiscent
of Stepp and Strong from a long-ago
Archive of Folk Song field trip to East
and other interesting
ern Kentucky,
string band pieces. I asked Barry if that
tracks.

was his banjo playing on the tape. "I'm
flattered," he said, "but that's Bobby

Fulcher." I recognized Sharon Poss's fine
guitar backup.
I first heard
Clyde as a banjo player on

albums he
two now-out-of-print
recorded with fiddler W. L. Gregory
and saw the two of them perform at the
knew
1975 National Folk Festival.
Clyde could really play the banjo, as he
I

I

does here on four pieces: "Polecat's Den,
"Coal Creek March," "Old Mister Rab
bit," and "The Old Cow Died." I kind of
suspected he might play a little fiddle,
but what I heard at Barry's overwhelmed
me. Over the next few years, I kept hear
ing about Clyde's fiddling and received a
few tapes of him from Andy Cahan who
had gone to visit him. We hired Clyde
and Bobby to perform at the Kent State
Folk Festival in 1981 and I sat at his feet
almost the entire weekend.
guess you
could say I like his playing.
After
moved to the Northwest, I
I

I

suggested to Frank Ferrel that he hire
Clyde for the Festival of American Fid

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

County Records, P.O. Box

191, Floyd, VA 24091

�We have Elbert Marshall to thank for
providing us with this glimpse. He had
the foresight to make the tapes in 1963,

THE BELL
SPUR
STRING

in the days before every man, woman,
and child owned a tape recorder.

BAND

Heritage 047

Wednesday

Richmond/

Waltz

Night

Sleep in Your
Mountain
Barn
Ridge
Tonight/Blue
Boys/Kicking Mule/Mississippi Sawyer/
and
Home
Sweet Home/Sweet
By

Flop Eared Mule/May

Mountain/

Gal/Sourwood

By/Susanna

Wild Hog

I

in

the

Woods/Going Down

the

Road Feeling Bad

The band is from Patrick County,
Virginia, and consists of Ernest Stanley
(born in 1893) on fiddle, backed up by
his cousins Edgar Jessup (born in 1907)
on autoharp and Johnnie Jessup on gui
tar, and his son-in-law Martin Marshall
on the banjo.
The guitar stays in the background,
but it's everything it ought to be: solid,
in time, with good chord sense. I'm not
normally a big fan of the autoharp, but
in this case it really works-acting as a
chording instrument in the manner of a
mandolin or uke, filling out the guitar

strum on the offbeat, and in general con
tributing a great deal to the distinctive
Jessup-guitar/Martin sound of the band with its ringing, highautoharp/Juhnny
pitched sound.
Marshall-banjo
The fiddle and banjo are truly out
This is a great record. It's one of those
that
come
into
standing. Ernest Stanley's fiddling has
unexpected pleasures
like
a
a
clear
blue
hat
elegant, carefully crafted ways of getting
life
out
of
sky,
your
from one place to another, ranging in
someone gives you that fits just right. I
expression from plaintive ("Home
wasn't quite sure what to expect when it
Sweet Home") to driving ("Sourwood
in
the mail, unsolicited,
turned up
Mountain"). Martin Marshall plays the
Mr.
Elbert
note
a
accompanied by
frofn
banjo in a unique, exciting, old-time 3Marshall saying that he thought we
sometimes chording and
finger style-might enjoy this album he recorded. He
Earnest

was

Stanley-fiddle/Edgar Jessup

the

right;

neck is
measures
up when
and

precision

a

I

back of my
instrument that

on the

hair

"X-factor," and
set the needle

heard

the

it

stood right

in the

"Wednesday

grooves
Night

Waltz" come out of the speakers. (Atthe
"X-factor" is that
risk of circularity,
distinctive characteristic of classic oldtime music that makes your hair stand
on end. As a Supreme Court justice once
said about pornography, "I can't define
it, but I know it when I see it.")
The recordings were made for per
sonal, documentary reasons, and were
never intended to be made into an

There is a subtle difference
between music recorded in studios with
commercial audiences in mind and the
music people play for their own enjoy
ment. The latter is, for obvious reasons,
harder to find on records, but it often
album.

a
spontaneous excitement and
straightforward honesty that more than
compensates for any rough edges in the
performances or the recording quality.

has

It's also more likely to present real

tional

music

rather

than

a

tradi

packaged

image.

These
Band are

of the Bell Spur String
rare treat because they offer a

cuts
a

of a band of excellent non
commercial musicians playing their own

glimpse

music the way they like to play it, the
way they have played it for years and
years, and doing a tremendous job of it.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

sometimes

following the tune (espe
songs), but always right on
target rhythmically and with impeccable
taste. If the other instruments are ever
cially on the

in drive, it is more than made up
for in the banjo playing.
A variety of music is represented: a
waltz, several songs and dance tunes,

lacking

other non-dance instrumentals, country
blues, and even a gospel number. There
is quite a bit of singing on the record,
and the one

disappointment

vocals are hard to hear.

I

is

that the

can just

distin

wonderful old-time singing style
and some impromptu harmony, and I'd
guish

a

love to be able to hear

personal

favorites

are

it

better.

My

"Sourwood

Mountain" and "Kicking Mule" because
of the great fiddling and driving banjo,
and also "Home Sweet Home" and
"Wednesday Night Waltz," because no
one can wring the emotion out of a senti
and still avoid sound
mental melody-of old guys that
like
a
bunch
ing sappy-have lived a long time, seen and done a
lot of things, and played those old tunes
all their lives.
of classic Blue
a fan
Anyone who's
Ridge Mountain old-time music should
own this record. especially recommend
it to musicians who feel like they're in a
rut. It'll get you thinking about music in
new but very traditional ways. It's worth
learned some
listening to carefully.
great new licks from it. (Brad Leftwich)
I

I

To order:

Heritage Records, Rt.
278, Galax, VA 24333

3,

Box

�songs and tunes
rewards here.

learn

to

will

find

With 40 selections, it is hard to decide
which ones to single out for mention,
but these are some that feel stand out:
"Boys, Them Buzzards are Flying" is an
evocative original tune by Gary Harri
son with a strong traditional character,
played with power by the Fly By Night
String Band. The Canebrake Rattlers'
version of a 78 by theTenneva Ramblers
has richly suggestive vocal characteriza
tions that call to mind no particular early
recorded singer yet ring true. Dan Gellert's performance of a beautiful ballad,
"Old Bangum," with his fretless banjo
1

accompaniment, is satisfying in all ways.
The Red Mule String Band (from Ohio)
and the Indian Creek Delta Boys (from

Illinois) present good tunes collected
firsthand from fiddlers in their respec
tive states and play them with uncom
mon skill and understanding. Plank
transforms Tommy Jarrell's
Road
minor-keyed "Sail Away Ladies" with
fiddle and cello into what might be
spooky movie music. The Tomkins
County Horseflies "Who Throwed Lye
on My Dog?"

is

infectiously rhythmical,

banjo that percolates up and
down the scale and an interestingly
tuned, pulsating fiddle.
Most of the selections are based in
southern old-time music, though also
included are country blues, bluegrass,
French Canadian fiddling, and Cajun
music. The album begins appropriately
with a 1960 recording by the New Lost
with

a

Ramblers, the forefathers of the
young city string bands. Directly follow
ing are selections by the Highwoods, the
Hotmud Family, and the Hollow Rock
String Band, influential "second wave"
bands. From its thematic beginning, the
album proceeds through musically wellsequenced selections, ending with the
more experimental approaches to the
City

music.
The

double-album

set

is

attractively

packaged, with a painting by Ray Alden
on the front cover (a great adaptation of

Picasso's "Three Musicians" portraying
a string band) and comes with nice addi
tions: brief comments on each selection
on the back cover; a map of the United
States on the inner fold showing the
location of each band; and a 16-page

Young Fogies Gazette (fun reading!), with

cartoons
sketches

by

Alden and autobiographical
person on the record.

by each

Perhaps

because

the

original

tapes

were recorded on differing equipment,

sound quality, while generally good,
and some of the cuts are a bit
muddy-sounding. But this shouldn't
detract from one's overall enjoyment of
the record. (Joe La Rose)
the

varies,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

To order: Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box
278, Galax, VA 24333

�son," and he performs it here the way he
remembers his dad playing it years ago.
Another old family piece in the "high
key" tuning is "Camp Run." The title is
supplied by Ernie, the original name for
the tune having been lost and forgotten
long ago.
Among older West Virginia musi
cians, the best-remembered and most
respected fiddler is "Uncle Jack" McElwain, from Webster County. Ernie's
versions of West Virginia standards like
"Old Sledge" and "Betty Baker" come
from McElwain. Ernie states unequivo
cally that McElwain was the best fiddle
player he ever heard.
Tunes like "Wild Horse, "Jack of Dia
monds," "Twin Sisters" and "Gunboat"
(sometimes called "Goin' Down to
Georgie-O") were learned from fiddler
Wallace Pritchard, a family friend and
musical mentor of Ernie's during his
boyhood in Braxton County. The
album's title tune, "Elk River Blues," is a
fine original piece composed by Ernie
while "thinking about the old homeplace on the Elk River."
On a number of the tunes presented
here Ernie receives tasteful and unobtru
sive musical
assistance from Gerry
Milnes and Michael Kline on banjo and
guitar respectively. Milnes and Kline
began playing tunes with Ernie and

recording their conversations with him
1981. The result is this outstanding
document of a man's musical and family
heritage. Included with the record is a
booklet
containing Ernie's
12-page
reminiscences of his boyhood days a
in

long the Elk River, other more ancient
stories handed down by "Squirrelly Bill"
Carpenter, and a number of treasured
family photographs.

Elk River Blues is a well-produced and
entertaining album. For those who may
not be familiar with the old-time music
of West Virginia, this would make a fine
introduction. At the same time, it is a
valuable piece of research which should
be welcomed into the collections of the
serious student of folk music and folk
lore. (Frank Dalton)

To

order: Augusta Heritage Center,
&amp; Elkins College, Elkins, WV

Davis

26241

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�old-time musicians. Some of these songs
will be great party tunes. These Marimac

reissues are among my favorite tapes,
getting played over and over again in the
car and at home. I really can't give them a
better endorsement than that. I hope
you feel the same way about them.
(Kerry Blech)

To order: Marimac Recordings,
Box 5, Little Ferry, NJ 07643

P.O.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Section with Illegible Text

are

Around
Just
Advertise
In

The Corner!
Your Event
The

OLD-TIME
Reasonable

HERALD
Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333
for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�0

V

Your Best Source for:
Guitar
Fiddle
Harmonica
Blues Old-time Banjo
Dulcimer
American Folk &amp; Celtic Music

over 150 recordings in print, many with
tablature books available if you want to learn the
pieces. We also have Teaching tapes for beginning
dulcimer, and advanced
banjo, beginning
guitar,
We

have

and

banjo,

dulcimer.

Kicking Mule records have been featured in the
Nature Company and Wireless Catalogs, and three of
our dulcimer albums were Book of the Month Club
"Alternate Recording Selections."
Current new releases include Indie winning The Hills
of Mexico hv America's favorite cowboy duo
Horse
Sense; and If This Ain't Genius by the Cranberry
Lake Jug Band
Ask

for

a

free

copy
of the

of

best

page illustrated
in Folk Music

our

48

Kicking Mule Records, Inc
POB 158-OT
Alderpoint, Ca 95411
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

catalog

�FIELDS

WARD

1911 to 1987

SAMUEL CARLTON FEENY
1913 to 1987

IN

MEMORIAM
There will be articles on these influential old-time musicians

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in the

next issue of

the

Old-Time Herald

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

BULK RATE
U.S. POSTAGE
PAID
Woodlawn, VA
24381
Permit #4

&gt;' 1

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12038">
                <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 2 (Winter 1987-1988)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12039">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12040">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 2 (Winter 1987-1988).&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Featured articles:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Samantha Bumgarner: The Original Banjo Pickin’ Girl,” by Charles Wolfe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Report on Galax - 1987: 52nd Annual Fiddle Convention,” by Jeanie McLerie&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Elizabeth Cotten (1895-1987),” by Alice Gerrard&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Passing of Fred Price (1895-1987),” by Alice Kay Adams&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Hank Bradley: A Fiddler From The Villages,” as told to Molly Tenenbaum &amp;amp; Kerry Blech&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12041">
                <text>1987</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="12042">
                <text>1988</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1296">
        <name>1987</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2100">
        <name>1988</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5428">
        <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5430">
        <name>Alice Kay Adams</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5417">
        <name>Charles Wolfe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5427">
        <name>Elizabeth Cotten</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5429">
        <name>Fred Price</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5425">
        <name>Galax, Virginia</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5431">
        <name>Hank Bradley</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5426">
        <name>Jeanie McLerie</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5433">
        <name>Kerry Blech</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5432">
        <name>Molly Tenenbaum</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5413">
        <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5424">
        <name>Samantha Bumgarner</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2497" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3419">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/db21502ed82bd9dda429941d3edf38c9.pdf</src>
        <authentication>4b2e29894bb02e5905b5b21d43c06a25</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12043">
                    <text>THE OLD-TIME
HERALD
VOLUME

14, NUMBER

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

3

$7.00

MAC TRAYNHAM
ASHLEY CARDER
RECONSIDERING BRISTOL

�CENTRUM

9

Artistic Director, Suzy Thompson

FESTIVAL OF

AMERICAN

FIDDLE

TUNES
July

3

July 10

I

I

J
I

Located on the shores of

Puget Sound at Fort Worden
State Park in scenic
Port Townsend, WA

I
I

9
Hi

CELEBRATING
OUR 40th YEAR
week on beautiful Puget Sound learning, dancing and
playing music with masters of a wide variety of fiddling styles.
Our faculty includes Alice Gerrard, Bertram Levy, Jimmy Triplett,
Rafe Stefanini, Joe Newberry, Pete Sutherland, Rayna Gellert,

Spend

a

more.
Judy Raber, Jim McKinney, Frank Maloy and many

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ASSURE
YOUR SPOTREGISTER TODAY!
www.centrum.org
360-385-3102 ext. 127

I
H

�Section with Illegible Text

New

Releases from the Field Recorders' Collective

CD

Section with Illegible Text

Dean Sturgill (FRC710)
who was

dances

Born

1934

in

Maggie Parker

Ashe County,

in

a

the area for many years. This is a sampling of
recorded work with the Grayson Highlands Band and
some of his finest poems, read by him.
in

Johnson was

a

cappella or backed by banjo
or guitar) and fiddle tunes, including solo pieces plus
performances with the Double Decker String Band. There
recordings

of

songs

(a

songs and tunes

are traditional

as

well as

strong rhythm,

Old Time Fiddle

Music of Alleghany County, NC

exciting anthology featuring S fiddlers,
Kilby Reeves, Cleave Andrews,
and Howard Joines from musically rich Alleghany County,

Ralph Whited (FRC71

Ralph Whited may be best

7)

1

Century Alabama fiddlers. This well-recorded set of tunes
his

spotlights

generation old-time

driving, blues-inflected, breakdown-style

fiddling.

Carlton Rawlings (FRC718)

Those who have heard

Rawlings home recordings put him in the
same league with the great Kentucky fiddlers Doc Roberts,
Ed Haley, and Buddy Thomas. This CD is assembled from

the Carlton

recognition in her music-rich home state of
Missouri! This new CD (from recordings made in 1991)
showcases Vesta's extensive repertoire of breakdowns,
waltzes, two-steps, and schottisches, including a number
of tunes that no one else plavs.

time fiddle music covering the full spectrum

NC. It's old

895-

known for his tune "Possum Up a Gum Stump," the title
track from the classic CD compilation of 9th and 20th

so much

Mack Brooks,

Lawn Brooks,

A 4th

5)

(1

in Kentucky. Even in his 80s, Darley's deep
feeling for the music and delicately nuanced notes, as well
as his unusual sense of timing, gave his music a unique
sound.

musician, Vesta Johnson is the quintessential North
Missouri dance fiddler, with impeccable timing and an
uncanny feel for phrasing. No wonder she has received

An

(FRC712)

(FRC71

Fulks'

we can trace

and clear phrasing.

Vesta Johnson

originals, highlighting the immense breadth and
depth of his music.
Craig's

Much of Darley

(FRC716)

1990) repertoire came from fiddlers of his grandfather's
generation and represents some of the oldest fiddle music

recordings, made near the end of Fuller's long life, still
show his distinctive arrangements, intricate bowing,

number of

a

Darley Fulks

member of the

Tom Fuller (FRC71 4) Though Oklahoma fiddler Tom
Fuller's name may be unfamiliar, his tunes have been
spread far and wide, notably by Brad Leftwich. These

true master

American music. This CD features rare

of traditional

a

player as well, and this CD displays many of the special
features of her singing and her playing.

his

Craig Johnson (FRC711)

Parker was

(FRC71 3)

well known Hammons family of West Virginia. Maggie
had an enormous repertoire of traditional songs, some of
them rarely heard from other singers. She was a fine banjo

wonderful old-time fiddle player and poet
favorite at the fiddlers conventions and square
a

is

NC, Sturgill

the only known recordings of a great fiddler who never
received recognition beyond his own community.

Section with Illegible Text

OTHER CATALOG

LISTINGS
Dixie Hummingbirds FRC208
FRC301
Norman Edmonds Vol.

Walter Babson FRC313
P.T.

Bell

Berkeley

in

Norman

the 1960s FRC609

Jont Blevins
Gaither
Ernie
The
Fred

1

FRC410

Heywood Blevins FRC508
Dock Boggs FRC305
Dock Boggs 1966 FRC312
Dewey Balfa FRC207
Balfa Brothers &amp; Nathan Abshire
FRC118

Carpenter FRC204
Chicken

Chokers

FRC603

Cockerham FRC101

Bill Cornett FRC304
Banjo
FRC103
Clyde Davenport Vol.
1

You can

Edmonds

Galax Gems

Vol. 2 FRC302

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

Vernon

1

1

FRC21

1

FRC503

Kelly

John Hannah

Addie

FRC405

Albert

Hash, Volume

The

Leffew

&amp; Claude

Wolfenbarger

Dennis McGee

FRC707
1

FRC119

Uncle Charlie Higgins, Wade Ward &amp; Dale
Poe FRC501
Horse Flies FRC602

The

Hurricane

Ridgerunners FRC604

order via our website and pay using

PayPal

FRC308

Martin FRC502

Sidna &amp; Fulton Meyers
Howard Miller FRC706

Hellbenders FRC700

Rector Hicks FRC709

The

Marcus

&amp; Sady Courville

FRC504

Nee Ningy Band FRC610
The Plank Road String Band FRC606
Cecil Plum FRC404

The

Obray Ramsey

&amp; Byard Ray FRC113

Round

Peak Vol.

1

Round

Texas Fiddle Bands FRC409
Buddy Thomas

Peak Vol.

2

FRC1

1

Wade Ward FRC507

0

WV Musicians

Jimmy Wheeler FRC401

Blackard Family FRC112
Chirps Smith FRC608

Shelor

CD,

Aunt Jenny Wilson

H

send

Virgil

Anderson

FRC408

FRC1

005

Clyde Davenport FRC1 004

3

Roan Mt Hilltoppers

FRC1 002

Clyde &amp; Ralph Troxell FRC1 003

Stamper FRC306
a

$20 each DVD

Field Recorders' Collective, 6206 Washington Street, Ravenna, OH 44266

i

Ray &amp;

Mike Rogers FRC5Q5
Kilby Snow FRC205
Corbett

of Clay &amp; Calhoun

Counties FRC202

Lonnie Seymour FRC403
Arnold Sharp FRC406

Manco Sneed, Byard

FRC303

Union Grove 1969 FRC114

FRC1 09

Sexton FRC105

or credit cards. To order via US mail,

made payable to the Field Recorders' Collective to the address below. $1 5 each
too!
PLUS $5 for 1st Class Mail. Special quantity sale prices on our web site

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dan Tate FRC506

FRC201

Ross County Farmers FRC307
Band in Transition (Round Peak) FRC102

Lee

FRC509
2

Riddle FRC120

Dink

Fiddling Van Kidwell FRC412
Kimble &amp; Wagoner Families FRC106

Stoneking FRC708

John Summers FRC310

Roan Mountain Hilltoppers
Roberts FRC209

Tommy Jarrell Vol. 2 FRC212
Ward Jarvis FRC402

Albert Hash FRC411
FRC1

1

Lee

Reed FRC203

Renegades FRC605

The

Santford

FRC309

Ola Belle

FRC107

The Indian Creek Delta Boys FRC607

George FRC407
Jeff Goehring FRC601
Frank

Harold Hausenfluck Vol

FRC1 17

Carlton

Esker Hutchins

Clyde Davenport Vol. 2 FRC104
Reverend Gary Davis FRC116

Ray's Dream FRC115
John Ashby &amp; the Free State Ramblers
FRC108
Ray Alden

check

The Field

Recorders'
Collective

�THE

OLD-TIME
HERALD

J

MAGAZINE

DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
PO Box 61679

Durham, NC 27715
Phone and fax: (919) 286-2041
E-mail: info@oldtimeherald.org

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Sarah Bryan

BUSINESS DIRECTOR
Peter Honig

SENIOR ADVISORY EDITOR
Gail Gillespie

CONTRIBUTING

EDITORS

Hicks, Phil Jamison, Bob Smakula,
Clare Milliner, Walt Koken

Bill

ART DIRECTOR
Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group

FOUNDING EDITOR
Alice Gerrard
ADVISORY BOARD
Mac Benford,

Hilary Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher,

Ramona Jones, Garrison Keillor,
Pete Kuykendall, Brad Leftwich,
Lee Smith, Pete Sutherland

OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Art Aylsworth, Sally Council,
Gail Gillespie, Jim Watson

2016
No part of this magazine may be reproduced
in any form without written permission from
the publisher. Not responsible for loss or non
return of unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
2015 the Old-Time Herald. The Old-Time Herald

March,

(ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is published
quarterly by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
PO Box 61679, Durham, NC 27715. Subscrip
tion rates payable in advance. One year:
subscriptions-- Canada $35US;

$26 (foreign

overseas $39US). Periodical postage rate paid
at Durham, NC 27715 and additional mailing
offices. Postmaster: Send change of address to

the Old-Time Herald, PO Box 61679, Durham,
NC 27715. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is
a

not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation under
(c) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

section 501

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love

old-time music. Old-time music grassroots or
home grown music and dance
shares origins, influ
ences and musical characteristics with roots musics
throughout America. Our magazine, the Old-Time
Herald, casts a wide net, highlighting the Southeast
ern tradition while opening its pages to kindred
and comparable traditions and new directions. It
provides enlightening articles and in-depth reviews,
opportunities for musical learning and sharing, and
a forum for
addressing the issues and questions that
bear upon the field.
of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

20th ANNUAL

BEARSSSQUflRE
mOUNTAIN
April 16

&amp;

17

FESTIVAL
GA

Dahlonega,

(Friday night Auction/Dinner April 15)

An

Authentic Appalachian Festival featuring

Bluegrass &amp; Old-time Music
Artists Marketplace
Storytelling

9

MAINSTAGE LINEUP"';

'

I

1

Becky Buller
IBM A

Emerging Artist of the Year and

Recorded Event of the Year

Chris Jones

&amp;

the Night Drivers

Songwriter of the Year award, SiriusXM Host,
Band has 8 IBM A awards among them

Ugly Cousin

BlueBilly Grit

Georgia Crackers
Jason Kenney, Seth Livengood &amp; CaroMia
John Lilly Threadbare Skivvies
Pick

&amp;

Bow All-Stars

Gospel Jam led by Glenda Pender
(Please check our website for schedule updates.)
on the square day and night,
two days of free MainStage concerts,
two days of free workshops,
juried traditional mountain art &amp; crafts,

Jamming

live &amp;

silent auctions, storytelling,
food and more!

Bear

On

The

Square
Section with Illegible Text

�Our

The

25

thAmuverSiirij!

ome learn and share this summe

Swannanoa

in

the heart of North Carolina's

beautiful Blue Ridge Mountains.
Gathering

Old-Time Week, July 17-23
with Brad Leftwich, Raul Brown, Don Pedi, T
Sheila Kay Adams, Tom Sauber, Erynn Marshall,
Alice Gerrard, Eddie Bond, Josh Ellis, Ellie Grace,
John Herrmann, Bruce Molsky, Carol Elizabeth Jones,
Terri McMurray, Carl Jones, Phil Jamison,
Rodney Sutton,
Ben Nelson, Earl White, Fbul Kovac, John Hollandsworth,
John Lilly, Gordy Hinners, Ron Pen, &amp; Meredith Mcintosh.
The Swannanoa Gathering

ALSO:

Traditional Song Week, July 3-9
Celtic Week, July 10-16
Guitar Week, July July 24-30

Contemporary

Folk Week, July

Fiddle Week, July

Mando

&amp;

Warren Wilson College
PO Box 9000

Asheville NC28815
www.swangathering.com

828.298.3434

24-30

31

-August 6
Banjo Week, July 31 -August

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

J
/j

6

�In

Print, Online, On the Air

Across the Blue Ridge, the Appalachian
music and cultural history radio show by
Paul Brown, has returned to Winston-Sa
lem, North Carolina's WFDD. The show
at 8 pm EST and Sundays
pm EST, and can be heard, both
streaming and archived, at wfdd.org.

airs Saturdays
at

6

A

new website, lomaxky.omeka.net,

presents field recordings of Kentucky
traditional music, stories, and other lore
recorded between 1933 and 1942 for the
Library of Congress, primarily by John
and Alan Lomax. The site, which can be

searched by artist, location,

genre,

and

title, is a project of the Association for Cul
tural Equity, Berea College, the Library of

Congress, and the University of Kentucky.

The family of Virginia banjo player Hobart
Crabtree (1936 2010) has released a new
ly digitized collection of his recordings

(cdbaby.com/ cd/hobartcrabtree), and
continues to collect memories and memo
rabilia related

to

and banjo-building.

Crabtree's
Visit

life,

music,

facebook.com/

to follow the project
HobartCrabtree
contribute information.

or

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�THE 1927 BRISTOL SESSIONS AND RALPH PEER:

A MYTH AND A LEGEND LOSING LUSTER IN THE COLD LIGHT OF RECENT SCHOLARSHIP

By Ted Olson

so-called 1927 Bristol sessions— the recording sessions conducted in Bristol, Ten
nessee/Virginia, during July- August 1927 by A&amp;R (Artists &amp; Repertoire) producer
Ralph Peer and his employer, the Victor Talking Machine Company— garnered
relatively little attention until the 1970s. At that point, a few scholars (notably, music his
torians Charles K. Wolfe, Bill C. Malone, Tony Russell, and Nolan Porterfield) and some
serious music fans began to view this long-ago event in a small Appalachian city as one
of the most important recording sessions of all time. As evidence of the distinctiveness
of those sessions, these scholars pointed to Peer's "discovery" in Bristol, while record
ing amateur and semi-professional musicians from Appalachia during the summer of
1927, of future country music superstars the Carter Family and Jimmie Rodgers. Also,
observed these scholars, at the 1927 Bristol sessions (Peer would hold additional sessions
in Bristol the next year, so one needs to specify the year) Peer introduced an influential
music business model that involved song publishing and artist management contracts.
According to the emerging narrative, the modern country music industry was thus a
direct outgrowth of the 1927 Bristol sessions. Sealing the fate of the sessions were two
now oft-quoted phrases that emerged during the 1980s. In the mid-1980s Bristol's politi
cal leaders began referring to their city as the "birthplace" of country music. And in 1988
Porterfield referred to the 1927 Bristol sessions as a "big bang of Country Music evolu
"the Birthplace
tion." Eventually people began repeating the two phrases as sobriquets
and those separate yet related
of Country Music" and "the Big Bang of Country Music"
notions, repeated incessantly, soon took on the gravitas of myth and legend.

The

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�I

pondered the Bristol sessions
having co-authored two books

too have

story,
(one with Charles Wolfe, the other with
Tony Russell) exploring the subject and

having produced the 2011 Bear Family
Records box set in which the complete

contents of the 1927 and 1928 Bristol ses
sions including alternate takes were
first made available publicly. And I have
noticed how often the 1927 Bristol ses
sions and Ralph Peer are mentioned in
general conversations about American
music, even though such conversations
rarely divulge more than skeletal facts
about that event or about the man who
made the event possible. Indeed, people
have tended to speak of both with a kind
of rapturous language usually reserved
for cultural myths and legends.
Because of ongoing scholarship, though,
the mystique of the 1927 Bristol sessions
and the centrality of Peer in the music in
dustry he

helped

to create

are

being sub

jected to widespread scrutiny, and this may
necessarily alter the narrative. As more
people enter the fray of discussions over

significance of this early but indis
putably not the earliest event in country
music history, some will accept the estab
lished narrative, while others will invari
the

ably challenge it. This will no doubt result
from tire broader dissemination of facts
and the deeper font of

knowledge made

possible by two recent developments.
The

first is the

opening

of

downtown

Bristol's multi-million-dollar Birthplace of
Country Music Museum, which celebrates
(some might say capitalizes on) the 1927
To place that historical
Bristol sessions.
event into an approachable cultural frame
work, the museum attempts to render ac
cessible a narrative previously advanced
to a specialist audience by a small cadre
of music historians;

seum's

yet, through this mu
and sentimentalized

simplified
presentation of the event, the narrative
about the distinctiveness of the Bristol
sessions pitched for a mainstream audi

ence
arguably weakens, with the 1927
Bristol sessions recordings collectively fall
ing short of the expectations placed upon
them by the weight of hype and public
opinion. Like other location recording ses
sions in the American South from the 1920s
and early 1930s, Peer's work in Bristol in
1927 yielded some very strong recordings
(those by The Carter Family and those by

Blind Alfred Reed being arguably the most
perfectly realized, with Jimmie Rodgers'
recordings being flawed but, of course,
intimating the immense talent about to be
unleashed), but the 1927 Bristol sessions

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

also spawned some unexceptional record
The Museum's generalizing, multi

ings.

media approach to telling the story of the
1927 Bristol sessions tends to smooth over
nuances and ignore subtler, more contextualized interpretations of the event. The in
formed museum-goer might well wonder
what the fuss is all about. One can't help
but wonder if the 1927 Bristol sessions, pre
viously infused with mystique only a few
years ago, will soon be viewed not as cata

clysmic, but as a business-as-usual location
recording session of the 1920s and 1930s.

final analysis, that is what that event
one of many, and not the first, not

In the

was

the last, and

perhaps not even the best.

The second 2014 occurrence to force

reassessment

a

sessions
book that reveals

of the 1927 Bristol

was the publication of a
the man behind the myth. While receiving
less fanfare than the Birthplace of Country

Music Museum, this book

Ralph Peer and

Making of Popular Roots Music (Chicago
Review Press), written by music journalist
has made the deeper con
Barry Mazor
the

tribution toward expanding our collective
understanding of the 1927 Bristol sessions
The first
and their ultimate influence.
of
a seminal figure in
biographical study
commercial recording history, Mazor's
book positions Ralph Peer as the founding
father of the commercial music industry
and the linchpin of American roots music.
Some of the book's justification for plac
ing Peer on such

a

pedestal hinges on the

old narrative of the perceived superiority
of the 1927 Bristol sessions as a singular

historical event. Mazor writes: "If anyone,
even then, saw broader potential or musi
cal power in the down-home roots music
being skipped over so cavalierly, they cer
tainly weren't doing anything about it.
And then Ralph Peer came along. He saw
as much potential in passed-over, under-

the first vocal

performance by

a

blues act,

1920 record featuring "Crazy Blues" by
Mamie Smith, Walker three years later
a

signed Bessie Smith, who would prove to
influential and popular per
former among the many early blues acts.
Peer may have "discovered" the Carter

be the most

Family and Jimmie Rodgers

in

Bristol

but Walker had by that time al
signed and recorded such iconic

in 1927,

ready

1920s-era "hillbilly music" acts as Riley
Puckett, Gid Tanner, Charlie Poole, and
Vernon Dalhart. Decades later, these acts
would not matter as much to the Nash
ville country music industry because
they did not compose the kinds of songs

readily reinterpreted by subsequent re
cording acts, yet Walker's mid-1920s
"hillbilly music" signees were undeni
ably influential (Poole, in particular, has
had a lasting impact). Peer's location re
cordings in Bristol in 1927 may have be
come the catalyst for a legend, yet Walker

oversaw recording sessions

in

1928 and

1929 in nearby Johnson City, Tennessee,
that rivaled Peer's Bristol work in terms
of

yielding powerful, even iconic record

ings;

less focused

on finding

potential

publishable songs than Peer's
Bristol sessions, Walker's Johnson City
sessions were more wide-ranging, gen
erating records that represented a broad
er overview of regional music sounds
and styles associated with Appalachian
whites of that era (the story of Walker's
Johnson City sessions is documented
"hits"

or

co-produced with
Bear
Russell
for
Family Records).
Tony
The 1929-1930 Knoxville sessions for
Brunswick/ Vocalion, conducted by A&amp;R
in

a

2013 boxed set

I

producer Richard Voynow, yielded re
cordings by a more diverse array of Appalachia-based musicians jazz, blues,
and black gospel acts, as well as "hillbil

than heard in
every variety
combined
Bristol and Johnson City
(this

explored, professionally neglected music,
and did as much to make something of it,

ly" acts of

as any

one person has" (page 3).
As such, Mazor's book arguably over
reaches, as Peer was not the only recordist
during this era to seek out and make com
mercial recordings of talented amateur

exceptional diversity

musicians repre
folk
and
various
popular music
senting
other
recording industry
genres. Indeed,
other A&amp;R producers for other
pioneers
proved similarly dedicated
companies
to seeking out and finding audiences for

tion recording sessions).
Mazor's book describes how, by the late
1920s, Peer spread the net of what might

producer, Columbia

another ethnic music, Cajun music.
While Peer's signings in Bristol made him
wealthy through the lucrative contracts he
arranged with the Carters and Rodgers,

and

semi-professional

"down-home roots music."

one such

And at least
Records'
figure more or

was a
B. Walker,
less equal to Peer in terms of accomplish
ments and impact. While Peer recorded
Frank

of

Appalachian re

gional music is now documented on the
2016 Bear Family Records boxed set that
Russell and I produced in order to com
plete the trilogy of East Tennessee loca

commercially recorded through cham
Walker
pioning Latin American music.
was simultaneously making a similar ef
fort to record and commercially distrib

be

ute

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

his work within country music after World
War II was primarily focused on song pub

lishing; Walker's postwar activities includ

ed both record

new
final

artist

company management and

development

signing,

to

his

and

last label

Walker's
affiliation

was perhaps the greatest in coun
music
history: Hank Williams, Sr.
try
Mazor's book briefly mentions Peer s
main competitors in the quest to find and
record America's "roots music" heritage
Columbia's Walker, Paramount Records'

ext(MGM),

Art Satherly, and, on the documentary front,
John and Alan Lomax. Yet the book would
have been stronger had Mazor examined

more contextualized perspec
tive. The depth and breadth of Peer's com
petition was considerable, and the emerg
Peer from

a

ing recording

industry

benefitted greatly

by the presence of multiple efforts to travel
the countryside to record, document, and

ultimately transform American roots mu
sic. The recording of America's roots music

legacy was certainly

a

collective effort.

illuminating to know about
Peer's activities and to understand his mo
tives, and for these reasons alone Mazor's
To be sure, Peer re
book is invaluable.
Still,

it

is

corded many influential acts and was enor
mously successful in implementing new

music business approaches. One take-away
from Mazor's book, though, is that Peer,
while profoundly shaping the trajectory
of the American roots music business, was
at a fundamental level more interested in
business than in the people who made the
music. This approach manifested itself in
odd and unpleasant ways, such as his and
his company's marginal treatment of Blind
Alfred Reed. After "discovering" the West
Virginia-based
at the

singer-songwriter /fiddler

1927 Bristol sessions, Peer and Victor

contracted Reed for follow-up recordings;

1927 session in
a subsequent
Camden, New Jersey, and a 1929 session in
New York City yielded excellent (if poor-

but though

selling) records, Peer quickly lost interest
in this talented, even visionary artist, who
was thereafter relegated to singing for the
pocket-change of passersby on the streets

some of Reed's songs proved
popular among a post-urban folk music
revival generation, inspiring versions by a
range of popular recording acts including
Ry Cooder, Bruce Springsteen, UB40, and
Reed receives
Old Crow Medicine Show.
mention
in
Mazor's
book
one
(on page
just
93), and on that page Reed's songs are mar
ginalized as having been "topical." (Reed,
in fact, wrote all mariner of songs, a few
of which were indeed topical, but most of
which whether sacred or secular were
thematically timeless and lyrically adven
turous, as can be heard in a new release
Thereafter,

I

produced for Dust-to-Digital

exploring

Blind Alfred Reed's life and music.)

It is a

shame that Peer's self-serving evaluation of
Appalachia's 1920s-era music talent his

promotion of certain acts because they and
their songs were marketable and his neglect
of other acts because they and their songs

were not

should continue to hold such

a

stranglehold on the contemporary assess
ment of Appalachia's music heritage.
Knowledge is power, wrote hnglish
Sir Francis Bacon in 1597.
With new knowledge generated by re
cent research and by the reissuing of

philosopher

previously hard-to-find recordings on
record companies
historically-minded
committed to setting the documentary

straight, the current generation
music historians can and must rein
terpret the story of early country music.
Music historians brought the story of
record
of

the 1927 Bristol

sessions

to the public's
researched
and
attention,
wrote the first study of the man who
made those particular sessions happen.
Now it is imperative that we continue

and

Mazor

examine Appalachia's, and by exten

to

sion America's, music legacy, even if that
means that the narrative changes in the
telling and in the showing. And if the
1927 Bristol sessions and Peer's role in
America's music history ultimately seem
a little less central in the narrative than
they seemed only
is

inevitable

a

year or two ago, that

generally speaking, myths

and legends lose luster under the cold

West Virginia (until the town's
mid-1 930s ordinance, meant to eliminate
the presence of blind street-singers, ended

light of fact-based analysis.
Now that the 1927 Bristol story has been
claimed by non-scholars for supposed

that option for Reed). In 1958, not long after
Reed's death, Peer's company pressed the

ing

of Hinton,

public benefit (with the city of Bristol turn
the

location recording sessions

that

still-grieving Reed family to secure future
rights to Reed's then-seemingly-inconse-

happened there in 1927 into a central facet
of local tourism), the public needs to partic

quential song catalog for the fee of one
dollar, which, according to Reed's relatives
(in both written and orally communicated
statements) was never paid despite the
family's compliance with Peer's request.

ipate in

a factually accurate, contextualized
discussion about those sessions and their
role in Appalachia's and America's cultur
al history. And that discussion should be
guided, now as then, by scholars,

�Acoustic

Steve Kaufman's

Kamps

June 12-18: Flatpicking, Rhythm Guitar, Old Time Banjo, Mt. Dulcimer, Fingerstyle,
Old Time Singing, Old Time Mandolin, Hammered Dulcimer, Old Time Fiddle

|g

June 19-25: Flatpicking, Bluegrass Banjo, Mandolin, Songwriting, Bass,
Rhythm Guitar, Bluegrass Fiddle, Ukulele, Bluegrass Singing, Dobro

N
A

June 12-18: Flatpicking: Russ Barenberg, Steve Kaufman, Andy Hatfield,
Chris Newman; Rhythm Guitar: Steve Kilby; Fingerpicking: Clive Carroll, Mike Dowling, Todd Hallowell;
Mountain Dulcimer: Sarah Morgan; Old Time Banjo: Steve Baughman; Hammered Dulcimer: Linda Thomas;
Old Time Fiddle: Mike Bryant, Jim Wood and April Verch; Old Time Singing: Cary Fridley;
Mandolin: Carl Jones; Jam Instructors: Erynn Marshall and Keith Yoder; Beginner 101: Annie Savage
Old Time and Traditional Week

Bluegrass Week June 19-25: Flatpicking: Robert Bowlin, Mike Dowling, Grant Gordy, David Keenan,
Molly Tuttle, Doug Yeomans; Rhythm Guitar: Tyler Grant; Mandolin: Carlo Aonzo, Tim Connell, Matt Flinner,
Bruce Graybill, Andy Hatfield, Steve Smith; Bluegrass Banjo: Greg Cahill, Gary Davis, Bill Evans, Jeff Scroggins;
Songwriting: Wil Maring; Bass: Clint Mullican, Todd Phillips, Steve Roy; Bluegrass Singing: Kathy Chiavola and
Dan Boner; Ukulele: Marcy Marxer; Dobro
Greg Booth, Ivan Rosenberg, Jimmie Heffernan;
Bluegrass Fiddle: Bobby Hicks, Josh Goforth and Adam Masters; Beginner 101: Annie Savage
Call 865-982-3808 or Flatpik.com to Register

Musical Event Like None Other
Held each June in Maryville, TN

A
::jgm

Specially designed for Ultra-Beginners through Professional

Located

On The

Call or Write for your Kamp

Your

Maryville, TN Just 1 7 mi. So. of Knoxville,
Brochure or go to www.flatpik.com

Campus of Maryville College

$900.00 Paid Registration Entitles

in

You To:

Daily Rotating 2-Hour Classes with ALL of the Main Teachers
All Meals and Lodging (Companion Packages available)
Structured Slow and Medium Group Jam Periods
Master Classes and Afternoon Specialized Sessions
Ensemble Work, Open Mic. Time, Afternoon and Nightly Jams
Admission to All The Nightly Concerts

Scholarships Available
We'd like

to

Gold Award
Every Year
since 2002

at

www.flatpik.com

TN.

Gold Award Winning

More Classes
More Education
More Fun More F riends

Scholarships Available
Join us in June

j

jj
jl

thank Weber Mandolins, Ome Banjos, Codings Guitars, Indian Hill Guitars, Deering Banjos,
for donating instruments for our big Door Prize Give Away! More to be added!

Limited Spaces -Registrations and Kamp Info: www.flatpik.com
Register Online Today It Only Takes a Moment
Steve Kaufman's Acoustic Kamp
PO Box 1020, Alcoa, TN 37701
7865-982-3808 (Operators and Tape Machines are Standing By 24 hours)
www.flatpik.com
steve@flatpik.com
Interested
4

Find Out Why!

in

being

a

corporate sponsor?

Write steve(a), flatnik.com
Don

't

Sleep Through This Opportunity!

Acoustic Guitar Magazine, American Made Banjo Co, Bluegrass Unlimited Magazine,
The 2016 Kamp Series is Sponsored in part by
Blue Chip Picks, Capek Instruments, Collings Guitars, Deering Banjos, D'Addario Strings, DR Strings, Dunlop Picks, Fishman Transducers,
and Dalton Guitars, Lakota Leathers,
Flatpicking Guitar Magazine, GHS Strings, Heritage Instrument Insurance, Homespun Tapes, Huss
Handmade
Shubb
Head
Guitars, Weber Mandolins and
Ome
Martin Guitars, Mass Street Music,
Nation,
Capos, Thompson
Banjos, Peg

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Wood-N-Strings

Dulcimer Shop

J

�MAC TRAYNHAM, BANJO BUILDER AND MUSICIAN:
"IT"S ALWAYS BEEN ABOUT THE PARTY"

By Malcolm Smith

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�wind was constant and strong on top of Buf
falo Mountain, which looms high above the
farms and villages of Floyd County, Virginia.
According to Mac Traynham, it's that way most of the
time. He had guided a group of banjo players attend
ing a three-day class at his Willis, Virginia, home and
shop to the top of this peak to learn. "See that red tail

The

over there hunting for food?" Mac asks. "Look at the
rhythm in his moves. That might be where that tune
'Hawks and Eagles' comes from." The five students
who came locally from Virginia, but also from Idaho,
New Hampshire, and even Britain, gawked in awe at
the vistas below them.
Mac directed the students' gazes to the valleys below.
"See, over there, way over, that's the mountains of the

Grayson Highlands area which

is just

beyond where

Wade Ward lived. And over there is where the Round
Peak sound started. Right down over yonder you can
see the area and terrain that Uncle Norm Edmonds
came from. And then there's the Galax area, over there

where the famous fiddlers' convention is held..."
Mac doesn't just want his banjo students to learn the
tunes; he wants them to understand the context of the
music and the nature of the lives of the people who
passed it down. "To really feel this music, to really
"
he says, "I believe it helps to understand
know it,
the history of the local people and the areas where the
older styles of old-time mountain music come from."
Whether it's leading a jam at the Floyd Country
Store,

or

teaching

youngsters involved

a

banjo

beginners' program to
Appalachian Musi

in the Junior

cians program, or instructing a Blue Ridge Old-Time
Music Week class at Mars Hill University, his vast
knowledge and reverence of old-time music and mu

immerse his students in the traditions
accompany the music.
Mac is also revered as a performer for his banjo
whether solo or with various
and fiddle playing
other musicians, like fiddlers Shay Garriock, or in
the Sunny Mountain Serenaders with Mark Camp
bell and John Schwab; or with his well-known family

sicians helps

to

that

band featuring his wife, Jenny Traynham, on guitar
and vocals, and his daughter, Hanna Traynham, on
banjo; or playing for local dances or contests with the

Mountain Boomers.
However, Mac is probably best known

for his skills

as a banjo builder. He has built over 100 banjos since
1976, applying ideas he learned directly from master
builders like Kyle Creed, Albert Hash, and Wayne

Henderson. His hand-crafted banjos are gaining at
tention worldwide with the distribution of the fourthat
part North American Banjo Builders video series

mac Traynham with

a

repaired banjo.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

features Mac's work along with many other fine
builders throughout the US.
Mac's interest in the banjo and in old-time music
didn't come easy. He was raised in Oxford, North
Carolina, and Crewe, Virginia, and his mother, a
homemaker, and Iris father, a Presbyterian minister,
didn't particularly like the folk music of the Appa
lachian Mountains, even though both of Iris parents

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

were raised

in

fa

rural Virginia. Mac's

would sometimes play harmonica
in a rhythmic old-time style using a tech
nique known as tongue blocking to get a
ther

full sound.

He had learned the style as

a

black playmate
near Cluster Springs, Virginia. Mac later
heard Ernest Stoneman playing a har
monica with the same kind of sound on a
child in the 1920s from

78

a

rpm recording reissue.
"They associated banjo music with
So
partying and non-Christian stuff.
it wasn't really until I graduated high
school and moved out of my home in
Crewe, Virginia, that I started really

getting

into

banjo.

Of course,

at

the

time,
questioned everything that my
parents said was right or wrong, and I
guess learning the banjo was a kind of
I

rebellion for me, at first.
PK [preacher's
liked the party!"

a

kid],

I

Somehow

as

just naturally

Mac took some high school graduation
money and went to the grandfather of
a high
school sweetheart, who owned
a local music store, and bought his first
banjo. He and that banjo headed off to

college in the early '70s.

At first, all he heard on the college scene

way of banjo music was bluegrass,
and he tried to emulate what Earl Scruggs
in the

was doing with finger picks on a banjo.
"There wasn't any old-time music at my
college, just folk, and rock, and a bit of
bluegrass. I went to my first bluegrass
festival while I was there and heard some
of the bluegrass greats, including some

Japanese players, but I also heard some
thing else. There was a band there called
Country Ham, with Carl and Judi Pagter.
They were playing something different,
different songs, different harmonies, and
I took
special notice of it."
Back at college, Mac started to play the
banjo with small trios who were per
forming folk music or folk-rock, and he
started to have regular picking parties
in his dorm room. "I started associating
the banjo with music fun, with having a
party, and enjoying my friends. I guess in
some ways that hasn't changed."
After two years of college, Mac decid
ed the college life, although fun, wasn't
really for him.

He

headed back

to

his

parents' house and began to earn a liv
ing by roofing houses. Then he met a
young fiddler, Bob Freeman, with whom
he enjoyed playing, and started back
ing him up on guitar. "He was playing
strange tunes to me; Shetland Island
tunes, American tunes, Irish tunes and
such," Mac says. "We started playing

�regularly, and I moved up to Richmond
to play with him when he went there for
work. Bob helped me become aware of
cultural differences in fiddle and older
music traditions," he recalls. "We teamed
up with vocalist Kathy Frye and formed
a vocal trio doing old songs and rare fid
dle tunes. After a year, we all moved to
Blacksburg to resume our formal educa
tion and get up in the mountains where it
seemed the traditional string band music
was still thriving."
About that time, the Virginia clogging
scene picked up, and there was a lot
"There was
happening in Blacksburg.
of young people dancing, and
a scene
we joined in it, playing for the dancers.
I started
noticing how the energy in the
old-time string band music was integral
to the clogging and flatfooting energy."
This became Mac's introduction to play
ing in a string band for dancers, and he

loved the party.
In

1975 he went with some friends to

Galax Old Time Fiddler's Conven
tion for the first time. That trip was a
defining moment. It was there that he
first became fully aware of clawhammer
banjo playing. "I had heard about it, but

the

had never really paid attention to it,"
says Mac. "I noticed the old people and

I

young people who were playing
were having a lot of fun."
the

it

"Then this guy came strolling up to me.
He was
a Brit named Pete Parish.

He was

going through the camps at Galax carry
ing albums under his arms for sale. The
albums had 'Pete Parish plays banjos tunes
the Wade Ward way' printed on them.
didn't know who Wade Ward was, but

I
I

told this guy if he'd give me a banjo les
son, I'd buy one of his albums. Well, that
started my journey." Mac took the album

home, studied the liner notes, and devel
oped an interest in Wade Ward. "I've been
trying to understand his music ever since."

Mac bought a hand-built guitar
In 1976,
from renowned guitar builder Wayne Hender
son (No. 31). "It opened up for me the fact
that people

could make these things one

at a

time, and they would be great for a lifetime.
liked that idea," said Mac. So he took his new

1

guitar and started to play it, learning to fiatpick fiddle tunes with friends, learning from

records of Doc Watson and Norman

Blake.

He also found the joy of traveling to local

fid

hammer,

met

an

old-time

viewed him about the style.

player

and

claw
inter

"My friend said

that the player told him to keep

a

tight 'claw'

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Jim

old songs in jam sessions in the camps.
Then a friend of his, who couldn't play

Kacsmarik

dlers' conventions and playing along with the

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with your right hand, and to then keep your
wrist stiff while you keep time with your fore
arm," says Mac. "Upon trying to keep time with
the 'claw',

had an epiphany as

I

feel something

to

information
ence

a

big

a

differ

understanding of timing."

in my

back

Earlier,

Richmond,

in

luthier

budding

a

rhythmic.

that day made

got

I

I
really began
The second-hand

had

he

him

build

to

a

asked
that

banjo

old Gibson, to play a threefinger style on. He had this banjo when he

looked like
came

to

an

mountains

the

1975.

in

After his

epiphany in 1977, Mac took the back off that
banjo, and started to try out the stiff-armed
approach to the clawhammer style. "Before
was starting to get it, to get a better
long
also raised the action
feel for the rhythm.
I

1

on that banjo

so

I

could get my claw going

better, and that was it.
Mac started to listen

was doing it."

I

and study the sound

to

of the old-time players that he could find on re
cordings and also ones still living in the South
west Virginia area. Soon, he decided that he
needed the right kind of banjo. "I saw several
of the old-timers playing open-back,

sumed you couldn't play clawhammer
didn't know enough
onator banjo.
I

and

as

I

res
under

on a
to

stand that many old-timers did use resonators,
but I wanted a banjo built for the clawhammer
style."

So Mac headed down to central North

Carolina

to

that would

himself an open-back banjo
suitable for his new approach

find
be

playing banjo. An acquaintance, who also
owned a Wayne Henderson guitar, took Mac
over to Nowell Creadick's house and music

to

store. "For 75 bucks, he gave me a neck and a
pot," recalls Mac. "It was cool, because the rim
was birdseye maple, and
but it was tricky, because

it

had lots of brackets,

it

didn't have any frets

That made me nervous at first, but

on it.

I

re

ally got into it, and finally I felt like I had some
thing like I had seen at Galax and in old photos

of banjo players from the mountains."
Thus began

a

lifelong infatuation with old-time

banjo. "Everything opened up for me then, and
I've been trying to understand it ever since."
Soon Mac was listening

to and

visiting Tommy

Jarrell near Mt. Airy, meeting Kyle Creed and his
banjos, and becoming aware of the great players
in and

around Southwest Virginia.

handmade instru
to appreciate
a
ments even more.
Wayne Henderson
got
and
this
time
about
began to realize
guitar
"I

started

I

instruments were just as good
better than the classic factory instruments."

that handmade
or

He got inspired by the birdseye maple on his
first open-back, an inspiration that became
somewhat of a trademark for Mac's later and
current banjo creations.
"Somebody had this
door,"

he says.

flooring, and

I

"It

was

thought,

old

birdseye maple
made out of maple
well, maybe

I

can

�a banjo." Interestingly, it wasn't in Vir
ginia, but in the Appalachian hills of Vermont

make

Mac actually
honed his skills as

built

that

"I

an

his

first

and

banjo

old-time musician.

graduated from college, finally, in 1978,
first
a job in Vermont.

and headed up to take

I

woods, camping. I was work
National
Forest and getting eaten
for
the
ing
saw
up by the bugs and freezing at night. So
this farmhouse along the road that had a little
lived out

in the

I

trailer out behind

it.

1

stopped and asked the

old-timers who lived in the farmhouse about
was a
Somehow they sensed
the trailer.
I

banjo

player and

invited me

in.

After play

could stay if
ing some lively tunes they said
would play music for them some evenings so

I

1

they could dance in their living room some more.
It was a great deal for me as an avid musician
who liked the party.

It

was also

an

eye-opener

'country' people that loved banjo music and
flatfoot dancing existed in rural Vermont."
that

Mac sought out local musicians of his own
generation and found quite a crew. He looked
up

fiddler Pete Sutherland whom he had met

Virginia. He also played regular
parties and dances with George Ainley,
Ahmet Baycu, and Will Wright. "They had a
regular Skillet Lickers sound, and learned a
at a

party

in

ly at

I

They were mostly into 'Southern' music,
found
calling themselves the Corndodgers.
lot.

I

associated Southern music with par
tying and dancing, like did. I enjoyed being

that they

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the banjo player supporting the twin fiddling
of George and Ahmet. They turned me on to
some great music from their authentic sourc
made my way
es of material to learn from.
I

onto an LP, playing banjo with them on their
first album in 1978."

Mac

soon learned

that

Ahmet

also

made

his help to finish his
banjos,
He played around the area with
first banjo.
them for the rest of 1978, sharing their old
and so enlisted

records and sharpening his understanding of
what these Vermonters called "Southern mu
sic." "What

learned about myself up there is
could get people up dancing to
played, to move the party along,
I

simply that if
the music
I

1

I

was happy," says Mac,

"I

also learned that

listening to great music and memorizing it
helps one be a better musician."
After half a year of working in Vermont for
ests and playing with Northern musicians, Mac
yearned for his roots in Virginia. "I came back

Virginia home where the clogging
had taken off. I brought
back new knowledge of Southern tunes that
had learned about up North, and soon found

to my old

scene

in

Blacksburg

I

home in a twin-fiddle party band called the
Rebel Yellers, headed up by Paul Herling and
Rick Palmer." Mac came back to fiddlers' con
a

ventions with

a

renewed

music of the South
est, his

and

interest
a

in

old-time

serious love inter

soon-to-be- wife, Jenny.

�Before he left Vermont, he got a request to
from a player who liked the
a banjo

make

sound and style of Mac's hand built banjo.
He got the idea that if he sold one, he could
just make another one and perhaps sell more.
Mac sold the first banjo that he had finished
with Ahmet to his old fiddle buddy, Bob
Freeman. So he began to make more banjos.
abandoned

an

in

Virginia, he set up shop
house in Blacksburg and

he got back to

When

at odd jobs to
support his banjo-making habit. In the fall
of 1979 and 1980, Mac, accompanied this
time by Jenny, returned to work in the White

for the next two years worked

of New

Mountains

Gould

at

ples

Meanwhile

Hill

Hampshire, picking ap
Farm near Contoocook.

listened

they

to,

collected

and

learned old songs and began developing their
duet style of music.
He and Jenny eventually decided to move to

mountains

the
in

County, Virginia,

Grayson

in

Mac worked

the fall of 1980.

as

a

laborer while Jenny worked

struction

con

for

a

community services group and began think
They
ing seriously about nursing school.
summer of 1981 near Jenny's
Northern Virginia, and returned to
Grayson to find work and for Jenny to go to
nursing school. While they searched for a
married

home

way

that

in

to

make their new life affordable, Wayne

Henderson invited Mac
Folk

Festival

at

to go to the

National

Wolftrap near Washington,

DC, with the Henderson family, as a banjo
player and maker. "It was me and the Hen

dersons with Ed Michael of the Shenandoah
Valley as the fiddler. It was a special honor to
get to be thought of as a bona fide musician
and builder for the first time."
When that summer ended, Mac found
a

cabinet shop

years

in

Galax.

job in
following two
a

great deal about wood
experimented with the equipment

Mac learned

working. He

In the

a

a variety of woods. When not
immersed himself in the local mu

and worked with
he

working,
sic scene, playing fiddle as part of the Gray
son Ridgerunners, and learning the nuances of
Southwest Virginia's music.
"Jenny and lived up on Big Ridge near Elk
Creek, with neighbors of our generation like
Jerry Correll and Dale Morris of the Wolfe
Brothers. We got to meet old-timers like Al
1

bert

Hash,

and Hick

Enoch

Rutherford, Kyle Creed,
travelled to stay a

Edmonds, and

I

couple of days with Tommy Jarrell in Toast,
North Carolina, during this time," he says.
During their time in the Elk Creek area,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Jim

ers, they amassed a big collection of record
ings from which to learn exciting versions of

Kacsmarik

Mac and Jenny continued to play and sing
duets together, as well as playing for local
dances and radio stations like WBOB and
With help from fellow music lov
WPAQ.

Mac roughing out

a

new banjo neck.

�Kacsmarik

Jim

Jenny and Mac Traynham

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

old songs that they felt had been overlooked
and deserved a new life in their sound. That

mission still lingers today.
After four years

in Grayson County, Mac
Jenny moved back to the Blacksburg
area, where Mac returned to Virginia Tech
It was there
seeking a degree in Education.

and

that Mac and Jenny issued their first record
on the Heritage label, When the Roses Bloom
in Dixieland,
featuring Mac and Jenny on
vocals, Mac playing harmonica and archtop

guitar, and Jenny on Mac's dreadnaught gui
tar #31, built by Wayne Henderson in 1976.

Living in Blacksburg, Mac rediscovered
Mabry Mill on the Blue Ridge Parkway,
where old-time players and dancers regu
larly performed for visitors, sponsored by the
National Park Service.
Here Mac began to
meet many local musicians and rekindle his

friendships with people

hadn't seen

he

or

long time. He joined the local
people who gathered there to play and dance
during the tourist season.
heard from

in a

After receiving

his degree from Virginia
spring of 1985, the fall found
Mac and Jenny, along with almost-two-year-

Tech

in

the

old son Ben, moving to Franklin County
where Mac taught Technology Education at
the county middle school.
Jenny continued
to

work

as

a

nurse.

registered

Mac jammed

regularly with local old-time bands and
sicians like the Dry Hill Draggers and

mu
the

Sugar Hill Ramblers, which featured banjoist
and

His

songster Larry Sigmon.
reputation as a musician

builder

quickly

spread

and

banjo

throughout the re

gion. After the school year ended the Traynhams moved back to the New River Valley.
They became regulars at local venues, and

Mac's cabinetry
work,
Jenny's work in
and
their
eldercare,
frequent music gigs, and
were

between

kept busy

his banjo building,

raising a family.
In 1990, Mac and Jenny bought 42 acres
with an old fannhouse

in Floyd County, near
Willis, Virginia, located perfectly to put Mac
in the heart of old-time music, with close

proximity

to

Floyd, Galax, Blacksburg. and

other places that old-time music was flourish
ing. Mac began to pride himself on living
and

working

in

a

bartering economy, where

he could trade music

lessons for farm prod

ucts and farm labor, and trade cabinetry work
for help with the Traynhams' small herd of

beef cattle, with which they supplement their
income and make use of their open land.
On the farm,

he built a large

woodworking
headquar
ters for both his highly sought-after cabinet
shop that continues
work

and

doubles

his

to

banjo

serve

as his

building.

It

also now

classroom, where he and Jenny
frequently teach classes on old-time banjo,
as

a

�Jim

Kacsmarik
The church Mac and the

community helped

to become

fiddle, and guitar, emphasizing the region's
diverse styles of old-time music.
Mac's banjo building skill has became known

the Wild Goose

Uprising,

in

Indian Valley, Virginia.

Although Mac had turned away from

the church that he was raised in for many

As men
tion of other players and collectors.
tioned earlier, he was interviewed for Volume

years, parenthood and a unique preacher
have brought him back to spirituality. In
order to involve their children in religion,
Mac and Jenny had attended a small
church with a Presbyterian congregation

of the North American Banjo Builders video
which has been widely distributed, his

near their farm back in the '90s. Over the
years, the country church lost member

around the country largely due to his reputation
as a performer, but also because of the recogni

4

series,

shop has become a landmark on Virginia's
Crooked Road music trail, and his banjos have
found homes across the nation and the world.
As of 2016, Mac has completed over 100
"1 just like to make them at my own

banjos.

pace, and find loving homes for them." His
first banjo with a 12" pot was a keeper and
was eventually given to his daughter Hanna.
"It was

started

before she was born and

fi

nally completed when she was about two.
vowed to give it to one of my kids if they
would ever learn
made me

a

to

I

play," he says. "She has

part of the 'lucky daddy' club."

It

wasn't until college that Hanna really wanted
banjo, but she had been listen
her father's and mother's music all of

to take up the

ing to

her life.

In college, she began to play regu
larly with her parents and to apply the knowl

edge gained by listening and growing up in a
house constantly filled with old-time music.
Currently, Hanna is a regular fixture in the
Pacific Northwest old-time music scene and
plays frequently with her old-time trio the
Barn Owls.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ship and was in danger of becoming an
other empty building, until the regional
leaders decided to take a new approach.
In 2013, Abingdon
Presbytery hired a

former professional musician and claw
hammer player, who is also an ordained
minister,

to

hatch

church

building

proach

to

a

plan to revamp the

with

a

bold new ap

attract people who were look

something different in church.
The new minister began to renovate the
neglected building in hopes of a new era
of existence for this place in rural Indian

ing for

He
a corner of Floyd County.
enlisted the help of Mac and Jenny and
other local musicians to make some
dramatic changes to the church's atmo

Valley, in

and experience,
Appalachian-style music

sphere

dancing

in the

by
for

providing
singing and

former sanctuary space.

"The first thing he did," Mac says, "was
to tear out all the pews, take up the car
pet, and expose the beautiful old wood

floors.

Then

he

went out and

found

and got donated lots and lots of rocking
chairs. I could tell right away this was
going to be our kind of church."
The new minister, Edwin Lacey, had a
vision for the church that was rooted in
local tradition and that he hoped would
be more inviting to Floyd County and

regional residents. He called the church
the Wild Goose Uprising, and enlisted
people interested in his vision to help
him rebuild and redecorate the building
and the program. Mac was enlisted as
an informal music director and lent his
woodworking skills to the project.
The vision Lacey had was simple. He
states it this way: "Rocking chairs, bluegrass and old-time music, Mason jars,
The idea

potluck dinners, and Jesus."

has taken off, and Mac's music is a regu
lar part of the services, which are held on

Tuesday nights so as not to interfere with
On most
traditional Sunday services.

Tuesdays you can find Mac singing or
playing a hymn or two and playing for
the square dances that often accompany
the brief service.
Recently Mac, Lacey,
and the growing congregation have been
featured on National Public Radio and in
many regional and national publications.
Part of Mac's mission

in life

is

to

teach

traditional approaches to music. For sev
eral years, he has been teaching children

�At the Traynhams'

home in Floyd County,

Virginia.

adolescents who are part of the Junior
Appalachian Musicians program based in
Floyd. During these after-school classes
Mac teaches banjo and fiddle to young
people who come to learn the importance
of the instrument in their local heritage,
and get to explore with Mac some of the
and

great players and styles of the region.
In addition, Mac and Jenny have been

three-day or week
end classes in Mac's shop that emphasize
old-time banjo, guitar, fiddle, and sing
ing styles. These well-attended classes
have attracted musicians from across the

conducting unique

US and from as far away as the British

Isles. Mac's love of teaching shows, as he

patiently waits for everyone in a group
to get the notes by ear and the beat with

their foot. He is always quick to welcome
students both young and old, and, after
seeing and hearing Mac's latest banjo in

shop, these students often become
owners of Traynham banjos as well.

his

with
Mac's many records and CDs
Jenny, as well as with fiddler Shay Garriock, and bands including the Sunny

have been wide
their
revered
for
both
authenticity and
ly
their creativity. His most recent releases
include Merry Mountain Hoedoum, with
Hanna on banjo and Jenny on guitar; and
Into
the Sunny Mountain Serenaders'
Thin Hair, with guitarist John Schwab

Mountain Serenaders

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and fiddler Mark Campbell.

Mac's philosophy of music is simple but
elegant: "For me, old-time music has al

ways been about the party and the dance.
It has a social purpose. People used it as
a way to enjoy life, to have a good time.
Now, to do that and to dance really well,
you have to have a good strong beat, and
some good old tunes." Mac encourages
his students to go to the source, to listen
to the oldest recordings of a tune they
can, and build it up from there.

Hanging on

prominent
living room

wall

a

is

in

the

crudely
Traynhams'
made old banjo that carries many knife
scratches and modifications from its more
than

a

hundred-year journey on the planet.
it off the wall and care

Mac often takes

fully bangs out an old Virginia tune.
"To me, this is what it's all about," he
says. "You see, Jenny was taking care of an
elderly farmer's wife near here at [their]
home, and would often admire that old
banjo hanging on the wall. One day, she
played it for them, and it made their day. A
couple of years later the man called saying

gift. He had a neighbor, who was black,
back in the Civil War days, and when his
father was young, he used to look across
the field in the evening and see this older
gentleman playing the banjo on the front
porch of his house. He would watch and
listen as this man performed for his wife
and kids, who would dance up a storm.

After the chores were done, they would
have quite a party! Well, when the old
banjo player died, his wife knew that
[the man's] father loved his playing, so
she gave it to him. He played it some,
and then passed it down to [the man],
telling [him], 'Now I want you to play
it.'" The old banjo is still known to be
played and danced to at parties in the

Traynhams' home.

As Mac says, it is all about the party.
With the creation of his 100th banjo, his
growing fame as a musician and teacher

of old-time music, his many friends with
whom he regularly plays and sings as

he had

leads jams and performs at the Floyd
Country Store, and with years and years
of memories of great music and great
players, he has a lot to celebrate.

learned to play. When we went to visit Jiim

You can reach Mac, see his banjos, and
sample the Traynham family's music at

after that call, he told us this story.

mactraynham.com and

decided to give it to Jenny, as she
had impressed fiim so, and he never had

"That banjo had been passed down by
his father, who had died many years
ago. His father had gotten the banjo as a

he

Malcolm Smith

is a

at

macandjenny.com.

banjo player disguised as

a

professor, living on New Hampshire's seacoast.

�SHOW ME SOME MORE TUNES:

AN INTERVIEW WITH ASHLEY CARDER
By Sarah Bryan

often wondered why comparatively little attention has been paid to the old-time music of my native
of South Carolina. Other than a few notable exceptions (such as the Dixon Brothers, Rev. Gary Davis,
and Jimmie Tarlton), the state's traditional musicians were largely passed over during the early days of the
country and blues recording industry. In the early days of bluegrass the state's musical profile was raised
all of whom had roots
by musicians like Don Reno, DeWitt "Snuffy" Jenkins, and Homer "Pappy" Sherrill,
North
Carolina (justly)
But
the
old-time
music
as
on both sides of the Carolina state line.
revival,
during
earned a reputation as a phenomenally fertile region for old-time music, and scores of young musicians and
documentarians learned from and field-recorded musicians from around Round Peak, the Piedmont, and the
Blue Ridge and Smokies, South Carolina was again more or less overlooked.
When I met fiddler Ashley Carder about a decade ago, I was excited to learn of the many years he has spent
documenting the old-time music of South Carolina. The breadth of his work would do any state proud, but
in South Carolina, where so much of our musical heritage has gone unrecorded, what Ashley has done is all
the more important. In 2012, he was honored both as a musician and a documentarian with the Jean Laney
Harris Folk Heritage Award, South Carolina's highest recognition for traditional artists.
Ashley and his wife Carolyn live in the country outside Leesville, South Carolina. A software developer
by day, Ashley spends his free time playing in the bluegrass band Palmetto Blue, and working with his
considerable archive of recordings and other materials related to South Carolina's old-time music. In the spring
of 2015 1 visited Ashley to interview him for the OTH's Stories of Old-Time Music's Revival Generation oral
history project. The following article is excerpted and adapted from our conversation that day.

I've
state

Sarah Bryan

Stories of Old-Time Music's Revival Generation
Konrad Alt, and the old-time music community.

is

made possible

by the

support

of the

National Endowment for the Arts,

courtesy
of

Ashley Carder

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ashley Carder (far left, with fiddle)
old-time fiddlers Ella Thomas

with

and Kristen Harris at Bill's Pickin'
Parlor, January 2015.

�Family music
My mother was an Elvis fan, and she
almost named me Elvis. I'm glad she
didn't. She named me after the guy in
Gone With the Wind.

My mother grew up right around here,

Batesburg, South Carolina, area,
about two miles from here. She's from
here, and her family's been around this
area since the 1700s. My dad's fam
the

from West Virginia, the Hampshire
County area near the Potomac River,
in the mountains. A lot of them played
ily is

mountain music

fiddles, banjos,

and back in the Civil War the
guitars
ones that were too old to fight played
fifes and drums. So [there's] a lot of mu
sic on the Carder side. Maybe not quite
as much on my mother's side.
My mother, from as far back as I can

play the guitar and
later
on
radio. At anyplace
and
sang
sing,
could
she'd
play, in country
play,
they
bands. Your typical kind of honky-tonk
country. And when I was a little small tot

remember, [would]

can remember getting rocked to sleep to
songs like "Waterloo" and "Hang Down
I

Your Head, Tom Dooley." Those were my
things that stuck in my head rather than

mother would be
a small child. So I was kind of
to
singing
brought up on country music.
My father was in the service, and he was
stationed at Fort Jackson in Columbia
[South Carolina] and Fort Gordon down
the typical things that

a

outside

of Augusta [Georgia]. He met my
mother when he was in the service, and
they got married and moved back to [his
home in] Maryland. I lived up there until
I was nine,
and we moved back here to
Leesville in 1967. So I've been here ever
since. Prior to that I lived in Cumberland,
Maryland, which is where my dad was
born. It was right across the river from
West Virginia. His parents were both

from West Virginia.
Sarah: There's

a

lot

ofbluegrass

in that part

of Maryland, isn't there?

think there's some. There used to be a
guy that lived next door to us when I was
1

a

kid, his name was Grover Broadwater.

He

played fiddle, his brothers fiddled,

and they had a family band. They used to
get together at our house, and sometimes
was real
we'd go to their house when
small. They'd play fiddle tunes and sing.
I

j\

j.l

guess
music.

was just old-fashioned country
don't remember anybody calling

it

I

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

it

bluegrass back then. Yeah, there was

a

lot

of

everywhere
be

a

student, because

music

up there. But I guess
I've lived, there seemed to

lot of music around me.

Mama was always play
I said,
ing music around the house. She played the
guitar. Daddy would also play the guitar,
Well, like

a fiddle too. He didn't really
fiddle
tunes
per se, but he could fol
play
low along [with] songs. I could remember
when I was in about fifth grade, Mama had
an old Sears Silvertone guitar, [which] was
her first guitar. She got it around 1954. And
it was around the house. She also had a Gib
son J-45 that I was not allowed to touch. So
I started
messing around with the old Sil
vertone guitar, and she had a couple books
that had chords, and I'd look at those things
with the little strings and chord charts, and
figured out how to play the guitar. Mama
helped me a little bit. And I started just play
ing along with some country songs, and
sometimes I'd play with Mama or I'd play
with Daddy. I played the guitar from the
time I was I guess 10 years old or so up un
til I was in college. And I didn't do a whole

and he had

I
just taught myself enough to play and
could strum along with some songs. Mama

lot.

had Country Song Roundup magazine all the
time. Stacks about that tall [indicates height

with hands], which I still have. But I used to
pull those up and sing along.
When I was a little kid, I guess I was
different than a lot of kids. I would play
the old 78 rpm records that belonged to
my grandparents. I stayed with them
and

some,

my grandma

bought me

a

player with S&amp;H green
used 10 books of stamps
and bought me a record player. And
they had a bunch of old records. Some
of them went way back to the '20s, and
maybe this is why the old-time music
is in me
people like Kelly Harrell and
Vernon Dalhart and the old, old stuff that
was my grandparents' music back in the
'20s. And then there was more recent
stuff, some Flatt and Scruggs, and Bill
Monroe, and Roy Acuff, and Carl Smith,
Lefty Frizzell. I'd sit and listen to those
records and I could sing all those songs
when I was a little kid.
didn't have
I was
[the] first child and
didn't
live in a
with.
kids
to
any
play
I'd
entertain
so
myself
go
neighborhood,
listening to old records.

little

record

stamps.

She

I

I

Learning the Banjo
I

went

to

Wofford College in Spartanburg,
was not a really good

South Carolina.

I

was not disciplined.
family had ever been to
Nobody
college. My family were mill workers
[and] my dad was a painter. He did
commercial painting, and I used to work
with him every summer. But nobody had
ever been to college, so I didn't know,
couldn't really get into it,
guess. For
I

in my

I

the first three years

I

was there

I

kind

played on a computer
goofed
which actually did me good, because
of

off.

I

never seen a computer, but [now]
that's what
do for a living, and I've
done that ever since I got out of [college],
learned how to program. And then I quit
I'd

I

[college].

I

wasn't doing well in school,
couldn't but because

and not because

I

was just not applying myself. [There
are] probably lots of people like me.
quit and went to work with my father
I

I

painting contract jobs. He was
foreman on a job up in Easley, South
Carolina, where they were [painting] the
school up there. I stayed in Spartanburg
at a friend's house, and I'd drive every
day over to Easley and work with Daddy.
While he was up there he hired two guys,
one of them [was from] Pickens and
one of them was from Six Mile, South
Carolina a guy named Tony Jones,
played the guitar, and a guy named Terry
on these

Chapman, played banjo.
would
These
guys
instruments every day,

bring
and

at

their
lunch

break they would play them. Terry was a
bluegrass-style banjo player. remember
the first time I saw those guys play, it
was the first time I'd been around people
I

that were really good

at playing banjo.
always had liked banjo music.
I had
to learn how to play the banjo, so
I
went to a pawn shop in Spartanburg
and bought a little Harmony banjo, for
75 bucks, I think. This fellow Terry Chap
man showed me the basic rolls and stuff,

I

photocopied the little thing he had
a Janet Davis workshop
something that had tunes with tabla-

and he

that was out of
or

I went
out and bought the Earl
Scruggs banjo book, and I taught myself
how to play bluegrass banjo.
So what happened is I ended up just
picking with these guys. And there was
another guy [I played with] that worked
with Daddy, from Columbia. Daddy

ture. And

played the guitar too, so he would ac
company me on the guitar while I was
learning these banjo rolls. And then
these other fellows, we'd get together
after work and play music. I kind of got
to where I was pretty fair at the basics of
playing bluegrass banjo.

�heard about festivals. There
festival over around Little Moun
tain, South Carolina, back in the late '70s,
early '80s. I went over there to check
out the festival and I met some people
jamming, and so I said, "I learned to
play banjo. Can I play with you?" And
of course they let me come in and play
with them. A couple of the guys lived
over this way, and I found out that one
of the men who was sitting there playing
guitar used to play with my mother in a
And then

was

I

a

band back in the late '60s. Once he intro

duced himself
he

I remembered
him, and
remembered me from maybe when

I

was 10 or 12 years old. So he said they
were trying to start a little band, he and
his son-in-law and a couple other people,
and they'd like me to come play some
with them. And they got together regu

larly down at people's houses over in
Ridge Spring, about 10 miles from here.

started playing with these guys.
guitar player was named Carlin
Padgett, and he actually [played] with
Fisher Hendley and the Aristocratic Pigs
for a very short while, in I think 1942. He
bought him one of those small Martin
guitars when he was in his early 20s, and
he decided he was going to be a musician,
and he went and auditioned with Fisher
Hendley. And he said, "You're hired." He
played with Fisher Hendley about two
or three months until his wife said, "No,
you need to go get a real job." She didn't
So

I

The

like him doing that.

Anyway,

I

could go sit down with Mr.

and he would accompany me,
and I mean, he was excellent. Old-style
guitar player. He had also played electric
Carlin,

guitar in country bands. He helped me
with timing, he helped me with my
guitar playing. And he was one of these
guys who could play these tunes and he
could play rhythm and put runs in there
at the same time
like he was playing
but
he
was
also playing lead at
rhythm
the same time. I picked a lot of that up
from him.

South Carolina fiddling
gotten the fiddle that
grandfather, who was a
fiddle player. His name was Albert Carder.
My

courtesy

had

to his

He died in 1941, but he grew up in West
Virginia, and like I said earlier, all of his

of

Ashley Carder

Fiddler Daniel "Bo" Norris,

daddy

belonged

c.

1930s

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

family were very musical, except for my
he was the only one who
grandfather
wasn't. All of his brothers used to play
music, and they actually had a barn dance

�down

the Carders'

at

farm,

Uncle

Tom

Carder's place. When my grandfather
was courting my grandmother, she was
not

allowed

to go out to the

Carders' place

because they had those evil dances and
stuff. They might be fiddling and maybe
drinking or something like that. So if he
wanted to court my grandma, he had to
go to her house.
I
got Daddy's grandfather's fiddle, and
thought, "Well, I'm going to learn how to
do some fiddling." This was about 1981.
Carlin Padgett, the guy who played gui
tar, he said, "There's an old man who
lives right down the road here who plays
a bunch of old fiddle tunes. He's never
really played the modern country stuff,
he's just an old-time fiddle player." His
Mr.
picture's over there on my wall
Bo Norris. He's seen holding his fiddle

down on his chest. [Carlin Padgett] got

come over to his house while I
he was maybe 70
was there, and Mr. Bo
years old he held his fiddle down low
and he played old-time tunes. "Get Along
Home, Cindy, Cindy." I was really fasci
nated by these tunes. So I learned how to
Mr. Bo to

play "Cindy." He played it in the key of
A. That's the way he learned it. A lot of

festivals, old-time folks, play it
played it in A. He played all
your typical stuff: "Soldier's Joy," "Lib

people

at

in D, but Bo

erty," "Red Wing," all that kind of stuff,
but he also played some old tunes that
I
I

had never heard before. At that time
hadn't heard a lot of these other ones

too, that are common as anything now.
He played one called "Skid Row" that
I'd

never heard

anybody besides him

played another called "Down in
On
a Hog" that I've never heard
Georgia
anybody play. He's the first person I re
ally heard who played vast numbers of
old-time fiddle tunes. He was a simple

play. He

guy but

a

good old-time fiddler.

1

up my first fiddle tunes from him.

picked

Then I heard about Pappy Sherrill, who
lived over around Chapin [in Lexington
County, South Carolina], who was a bigtime radio fiddler back in the '30s and
'40s. He was still over there in Chapin
sawing away on the fiddle every chance
he got. ran into him at a festival one time
and introduced myself. I started going
to his house some, and I'd take a tape

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ashley
of
courtesy

player. Normally he'd charge people to
give lessons, but basically he just invited
me to come plav tunes with him.
He was big into trick tunes and stuff,
vaudeville stuff. I guess he came out of
that era, and the people he learned from
when he was growing up played stuff

Larder

I

Bo

Norris,

1970s

�courtesy
of

Ashley Carder

Homer "Pappy" Sherrill and Ashley Carder

at

Bill's Music Shop

to Mockingbird."
He used
fiddle
the
bow
between
[with]
play
his knees, and he could play behind his

like

"Listen

to

back and do all that stuff. I guess they
were entertainers back then. The guy that
played with him a lot, Snuffy Jenkins
they played together from 1939 up until
Snuffy died I heard Snuffy say one time
he was an entertainer first and a banjo
picker second. And I think that was true

with

those guys.

on

the

They played
radio and then they traveled around and
did shows in the evening wherever. They
did two shows a day on the radio, and
then traveled around in the evening to

go to schools and theaters and wherever
people would have them, and they'd
charge admission and make their money
that wav.

bunch of tunes from Pappy.
home and sit there
and work at tunes. I wasn't so much into
the bowing,
guess, as I was into just
the
tune
down. So I'd go back to
getting
and
he'd
tell me if was right or
Pappy
And
or
close.
he wasn't too mean
wrong
about it. He'd tell me had it or I didn't,
and he'd sit there and show me what
was doing wrong sometimes. And he
loved it. We'd sit there and play on his
I

learned

a

I'd tape it and then go
I

I

I

I

porch sometimes until midnight or later.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in West

Columbia, South Carolina, 1999.

His son Jerry would play the guitar and
Ms. Sherrill would bring us cookies, and
sometimes she'd have cake.
So I learned from Bo Norris first and
then Pappy Sherrill.
By that time I was going to festivals
regularly. I liked to go to Galax, and up
there was just a multitude of all kinds

musicians. All kinds of
musicians, bluegrass people.
of

old-time

I'd go to
the Fiddler's Grove festival too. One year
a
couple friends and I decided we were

going
go check out this guy named
Tommy Jarrell. So we went to Tommy's
house and knocked on his door
there
were four of us there we knocked on
to

his door, and he came

we said,

to the door and
we hear you're a
and we'd like to know

"Mr. Jarrell,

fiddle player
if you'd fiddle some with us." And so [he
said], "You fellows come on in and have
seat!"

a

played guitar, and Tommy pulled out
his fiddle, and he just told story after
story. It was like we were family. We
probably were there three or four hours
at Tommy's house. I had my tape player
running, and he didn't tell me to turn it
off. I've talked to a lot of people [who
say] apparently [if he] knew you were
a
folklorist, he wouldn't particularly
I

like you to come there, but we were just
regular people and wanted to play some
tunes. And he sat there and told stories
and played
tunes. He'd re-tune his
fiddle; he had it in standard tuning, and
he'd play "Breaking Up Christmas" in
A cross-tuning, and he'd switch it again
and play "Jack of

Diamonds"

in that kind

tuning. That was about 1983 or '84. It
was a year or so before he died. He was
of

just the

friendliest guy.

Around

that same time I had gone
back to college. After my nine-month
stint working with Daddy, I had decided
college wasn't so bad after all. I didn't
want to have to get up and be dirty and
sweaty every day like he did. So I went
back to school, got a job programming.
still got back to Spartanburg on a regular

I

basis on the weekends [to] visit my
friends up there, and I found out about
an old-time jam at a guy's TV repair
shop. His name was Marvin Newman.
He was an older guy, maybe in his 60s,
which was older to me at that time. I was
in my 20s. He had

a
jam at his place and
there were usually five or six or eight or
10 people crowded in this little room.

Way
Mr.

I

remember

it

Newman played

I

a

may be wrong
Hawaiian guitar,

but he had to read music. He couldn't

�courtesy
of

Ashley Carder

Vernon Riddle (I) and Ashley Carder at the Snuffy Jenkins Festival in Cliffside, North Carolina, 1985

play it if he didn't have his music stand
there. But then these other old guys
would come. There was another guy

whose name was

Bill Cudd, who was
about 80, who played mandolin, and he
could pick out all these old-time tunes.
There was another man named Freeman
Quinn who was a fiddle player and
guitar player. He played a lot of tunes
I
learned some tunes from him, "Silver

Bells" and a few others.
And then there was a guy that showed up
there one time named Vernon Riddle, and
the minute
heard him fiddle, I could tell
there was something different about his
fiddling than anybody else's. He was way
more elaborate. And so I got his contact
info, and every time I came up I'd want to
hook up with him. He also played [at] a
Red Barn Flea Market out on Highway 29
from Spartanburg going to Cowpens, and
they had a few people would get together
I

there on

a

Saturday

or

Sunday afternoon

and jam. Vernon had
me come out there, and once he noticed
at

the flea market

was taking an interest in his fiddling
he started feeding me all these cassette
tapes. He had all these recordings he had
I

made of people, [including

everybody's heard

of by the

Robertson. And Benny

fellow that
name of Eck

a]

Thomasson and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Norman Solomon, all these people I'd
never heard of.
I found
out [Vernon Riddle had been]
in the Air Force in Texas. He was from
Spartanburg, but he got stationed in
Amarillo. And he already fiddled, like
regular, standard style, just old-time
fiddle tune kind of fiddling, and some
country music. Around Spartanburg he
played on the radio and sang country
before he went into service. When he
went into service he was in Amarillo,
and he met up with Eck Robertson, who
was maybe 70 years old
he

sat

go to

at

the time. And

down with Eck, and he could
his house, and he would do like

what

I did
he'd have his reel-to-reel
player, and he'd tape Eck playing tunes.
He would accompany him sometimes,

and

sometimes Eck would just play by

himself. And Vernon learned all these
tunes from Eck. He played a lot of Eck's
tunes that I've never heard anybody play,
[some] that Eck never recorded. Stuff like

"Rhubarb" and a couple others, a tune
called "Chadwick." So picked up a lot of
those tunes from Vernon. And I remained
in touch with him all throughout the rest
I

of his life, until he

passed away.
People up in Spartanburg didn't under
stand his fiddling
they were mostly

�courtesy
of

Ashley Carder

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Vernon Riddle (I) and Ashley Carder at Vernon's

South Carolina country music people, and
here comes this guy who's from Spartan
burg but he came back from Texas, and
now he's playing all [this Texas music]. No
body could follow him, because he played
all these ornamented times, or times no
body had ever heard of. He played hun
dreds of tunes, and he'd give them to me
on cassette, and I'd go home and listen to
them, and next time I saw him I could back
him on guitar. He said, "You're the only
person in South Carolina who could play
the guitar with me."
There was another fiddler who used to go
Market, fellow
name of Boyd Isler. He was just a
down-to-earth kind of guy. He was
60 years old at the time and he
to the Red Barn Flea

by the

happy,

house, 2003

hanging on the wall

I'd take it

down

and play it, and I'd occasionally still go
to the festivals, but not as much as I did

when I was single. And there came a guy
to town named Bill Wells back in the
late '80s, and he

started

opened up

a

store and

picking parlor. I started going
over there, and I met a bunch of different
people, a lot of people from all around
the Midlands of South Carolina.
Around 1990 or '91 Bill asked me if I
would fiddle in his band. Bill was from
a

Virginia from [near where] Ralph Stanley
was from, and he grew up right down
the road from the Carter Family. Actually,
the Carter Family were his cousins. So he
lot of

mountain music, bluegrass,

maybe
played
some real high-energy, foot-stomping kind
of fiddling. He lived in a wooden house
outside of [Spartanburg] going toward

played

Cowpens. He had

supposed to be. You came over there, you
were going to be acoustic. I played fiddle
with Bill off and on for 20 years.
He was a good man. I like to say he was
like a bluegrass daddy to me.
[After my] son graduated high school, I
had more free time to play music, and I
started playing again, more often. [I've]
pretty much been playing ever since.

a
rickety old front porch.
used to go over to Boyd's house when
I wasn't
going over to Vernon's house. I'd
sit
out
on Boyd's porch with him. And
go
he was a spinner of tall tales. Boyd was just
the most fun guy. Man, you could sit out
there and fiddle with him forever. Buddy
of mine, he used to go up there with me
I

sometimes, he said, "If I went to the doctor,
and doctor told me I only had a week to

I believe
I'd go up here and spend it
on Boyd Isler's porch and play music with
him." But he was a good old-style fiddle

a

and he had the bluegrass jam over there and
he did not allow any electrical instruments
in his jams.

He was

a

real stickler for his

definition of what he thought music was

live,

player. He could play all the breakdowns,
and he had a lot of action in his bow stroke.
Then I got married, and I kind of quit
playing as much. I still had my fiddle

Preserving South Carolina's Music History
Pappy Sherrill's family gave me a whole
bunch of his stuff. You see his hats hanging
on the wall,

people

used

and fan mail and stuff that
to

send

him

when

they

�played on radio stations back in the '30s
and '40s. They let me play his fiddle for

two or three years. It's in a museum right
in North Carolina. They gave me a
large quantity of Pappy's field recordings.

now

Mrs. Riddle gave me

a

whole bunch

of

Vernon's stuff. I've got his reel-to-reel
tapes in there [from when] he went to
see Eck Robertson
his original tapes.
I've already digitized them. I was work
ing on an Eck Robertson project, which I
haven't finished yet.
Pappy's
a

project

son

done

Wayne wanted
on Pappy, so

to
I

see

went

[and arranged his recordings]
from the year 1986 up
to the year 2000. Ms. Sherrill just passed

through

chronologically

away last year. She was actually at the
same nursing home as my dad, and on
the same hall. I would go visit my dad
and then I'd walk down and see Ms. Dot,
and I'd get her to tell me stories and stuff
while I was in there. When I had the CDs
made, I went to see her on Christmas Day
that year, maybe three or four years ago,
and gave her the CD. She was talking

about all these people he played with.
a real talkative mood. She was
I think about 92 or 93 at the time, and her
mind was really sharp. She was naming
off all these people he had played with
over the years and how, when they used
to play on WBT in Charlotte, sometimes
these guys would go back and visit their
families up in the mountains. [To get to
one musician's house you] had to park
and walk across the creek and go up the
hill, and his family lived up there in a
little house up on the hill.
She was in

[Dot Sherrill] said, "There's one guy
[Pappy] used to play with back in the
'40s who's still alive. He lives in Florida,
and his name's Marion Kyzer." She said,
"You need to call him up. He'd be glad
to talk to you. I bet he could tell you
some stories." And so I called up Mr.
Kyzer. Talked to him for a good while.
He was in his 80s, [had] joined the Hired
Hands in late 1948. Somebody had just
quit the band, and they were looking for

tenor singer. He played steel guitar
not pedal steel but just the straight steel
guitar. Snuffy didn't particularly care
for steel guitar, but Pappy and Tommy
Faile who later [was a] guitar player
for Arthur Smith
they auditioned this
Mr.
Marion
guy,
Kyzer, and they said,
"You're hired." And he was an 18- or
19-year-old kid, just out of high school.
Bass player Ira Dimmery told him he was
the best steel guitar player in the state of
South Carolina. He played with them for
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

two years until he got drafted in the Air
Force, and when he came out, everybody
was going to the pedal steel. He didn't
have the pedal steel, nor did he feel like

adapting, so he just quit playing.
During the time he played with the
Hired Hands, in '48, '49, and '50, they
had played two shows daily on the radio
station, and then they'd go off in the
evenings, and go around and play gigs
out around the area. Sometimes they'd
drive several hours to get there. If they
ever wanted to take a vacation, what
the radio station would do was instead

playing live, they would go in
there during the off-hours in the studio
where they would normally broadcast
from, and they would record the entire
show on a big transcription disc. They
would broadcast that disc as if it were a
live program, and then they'd throw the
disc away
they were a one-time deal.
Mr. Kyzer asked the radio station, "Can
I
take one of them home with me, so I
can have some of our music?" And they
said, "Sure, we're going to discard them
otherwise." They had no use for them
once they aired. So he took two or three
discs of their programs.
He went in the Air Force, then he moved
to Florida after he got out of the Air Force,
and he had his old records there from the
of them

station still. He noticed they were turn
ing white and deteriorating, so he rigged
and he had to move
up a record player
the arm because the records were bigger
than a 33
they were big, 16-inch. And
he recorded those things off to reel-toreel tapes. He only recorded his favorite
stuff
he didn't record the whole show.
He didn't particularly care for the old
fiddle tunes and stuff, so I think he left
a lot of those out. He threw
away the re
cords because they were getting mold or
some kind of white oxidizing on them.
So he recorded his favorite stuff, which
had

lot of him

playing steel guitar. It
does feature a lot of Snuffy playing banjo
real clear where you can hear it. It's
a

the earliest [group of recordings] I know
exists that has Snuffy very clearly
playing his three-finger roll on some of
of that

the

songs that Earl [Scruggs]

recorded

later.

project with that. I called Mr.
"I want you to narrate
Kyzer
it. I want you to talk at the beginning
about how you met these guys and how
you got to be a member of the band, and
then we'll play a few songs and I want
you to talk about the instrumentalists."
So he narrated throughout, and he talked
a

and said,

about Snuffy doing comedy, and
put
that together as a project.
When I was working with Mr. Kyzer,
one of the things that he told me is that
he had some little stories, and he didn't
know if anybody was interested in them.
Back 10 or 15 years ago, he decided
I

sit down and just kind of write his
memories. Stories of him playing music.
to

He said nobody cared about it but him,
but he wanted to write it all down, so he

wrote

it

down.

He started back playing now. He sent
me an email about two or three days ago,
and he wanted to tell me that he did a

whole program at his church on the steel
guitar. He plays his steel guitar all the
time now, and he said it was all my fault.
He thought nobody else had any interest

would always kind of wrap up
written stories] and at the end of

in it. He

[his

story, he would say something like,
"Well, I don't know why I'm writing this
stuff down because nobody will care to
read it." And I read that and I wanted to
a

cry. I thought, this man's stories need to
be preserved, and as much of the music
as

I

He

could find.
said,

"People

want

to

hear

this

said, "Yeah, there's a whole
of
community
people out here, and a lot
of them are really into this kind of music."
stuff?" And

I

Why do you think South Carolina music lias re
ceived so much less attention than [music from]
North Carolina, and even Georgia and Tennessee?
It bothers me, because
like
Bo
Norris
over there, you
people
see him holding his fiddle and you hear
him fiddle, you'll say, "Man, that's an
I

don't know.

old-time fiddler!" And according to
him, he picked up a lot of his tunes
from old guys who lived in his neck
of the woods out there in the country.
said, "Where did you learn that, Mr.
Bo?" "Well, I learned that from Old Man
I

Kyzer got excited about the fact that
somebody's interested in this old music.
Mr.

send you

So he said, "I'm

to

stuff." And

to it, and

I

going
listened

condition. Musically,
like live radio shows. And so

it

incredible

the best stuff off of there

everything

worked on

that

was

on

Edwards."

was in
it was

pulled
actually most
there

I

and

I

Or,

"I

learned that from Old

Gregory." He learned some off
the records too, once records came out,
but he was right there on that border
line where, when he was first learning,
there was no such thing as a record. He
learned from the old guys. And I think
Man

all this

�courtesy
of

Ashley Carder

Palmetto Blue

at the

South Carolina had plenty of old-time
musicians around, it's just nobody
cared to document them. I could re
member back in the '80s, another guy
and myself trying to go over to the uni
versity, and saying, "Y'all need to go
study Mr. Norris and people like him,
and document these guys. They're real
ly old, and they have their own style of
fiddling, and nobody's paid them any
attention." And they were like, "Well,
we're busy with the basket weavers
down on the coast right now. We'll get
around to it." Well, these guys died and
nobody ever documented them.
Except for you.

wasn't in the business of
documenting. It was just interesting to
but

Yeah,

me.

I'd not

I'd say,

some

I

necessarily interview them,

"Play me some tunes. Show me
more tunes. Let me hear some

I was
wanting to learn, and in the
process they would tell me stories. And
I'd say, "Where'd you learn that tune?"
and they would tell me. At the time was

more."

I

not really in the mindset of documenting
people, but it turns out now I have some
of the only recordings of these people.

Musical Distinctions
was learning fiddling, all the
guys who played, they were just
fiddlers. If they happened to be around
I

old

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

people picking banjos with finger picks,

they'd play right along with them. If
there was somebody who had electric
guitars and sang honky-tonk music,
they'd play that too. Or if they found
somebody sitting on the back porch
sawing on the fiddle, holding it down
on their chest, they could go and play
"Get Along Home Cindy" right there
with them. And that's kind of the way
I have
always have felt about fiddling. I
like it all. I don't know that I would call
myself a bluegrass fiddler. And some
people look at me and say, "Well, you
don't have all the right stuff for old-time
either. You're too fancy," or, "You're too
prissy on waltzes," or whatever. "You're
not an old-time fiddler. What are you?"
It's like, I'm just

a

fiddler.

Do you think that's especially characteristic
of South Carolina music, or is that a genera
tional thing, from the older generation that

you learned from

just country music to him. He said that

long as they were having bluegrass
festivals and they wanted to hire him
to come play, he would be a bluegrass
band. But he said they were just old-time
as

country musicians.
I
think it [also] has something to do
with the area. Of course, I can remem
ber when I started going to Galax in
the early '80s, there were these old
men who grew up right up in that area,

and they played old-time fiddle, but if

somebody [started] Scruggs-style banjo
picking and started singing the bluegrass, they'd get in there and play some
My observation is that may
sometime around then,
there started being this divide, and the
old-time folks became very academic
about the definition of old-time, and
of that too.

be in the '80s or

the

bluegrass people kept on going
down their path. think your two styles
have kind of diverged, and now people
don't even remember that a generation
I

two ago these guys were just play
ing music. They didn't categorize them
selves. And I would like to see people
or

There's this kind of grey area in between
[old-time and bluegrass], and that was
[what] the radio guys [played]. Pappy
Sherrill once told me, he said all these
[were] making all this big deal
out of bluegrass music. He said he didn't
mind riding the bandwagon, but he said

get along better, myself.

people

didn't know what all this commotion
was about bluegrass music. He said
they'd been playing that stuff before they
ever heard of bluegrass. He said it was all
he

When

Festival in August 2015. -r: Steve Willis, Ashley Carder, Anna Davis
(Like Ashley Carder, Boutwell and Klein are recipients of South Carolina's Jean

University of South Carolina's FolkFabulous

Cumbee, Shellie Davis, Chris Boutwell, and Dr. Larry Klein.
Laney Harris Folk Heritage Award)

You
his

can

read

more

about
and

Ashley
his

Carder,

music

at
documentary
and
at
his
band's
website,
scfiddling.com
palmettoblue.com. Videos of old-time and
bluegrass music from South Carolina are

work,

available on his YouTube channel, WACarder.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

BLUEBOOK
BAND

&amp;

FESTIVAL GUIDE

The HANDBOOK for Bluegrass, Old Time &amp; Traditional Music Events
all across America!

j|^H

BANDS

|H
H

_

FESTIVALS
&amp;

FIDDLE CONTESTS

ASSOCIATIONS

BUSINESSES

RV PARKS

NOW AVAILABLE!
ORDER TODAY!
Mail $20

+$6 Postage/Handling

T.S.BA

Rural Route One, Box 71,

Section with Illegible Text

to:

Pat Davidson

Kahoka, MO 63445

�Reviews

Hounds

er:

and

Folksongs
Field Recordings from the Upper

Midwest, 1937-1946

James

P.

the Woods

Ray Calkins

Iva
boy Tune (Kvasarvalsen)
Rindlisbacher: The River in the
Sven "Shantyman" Svenson (Otto
Otto
bacher): Dinner Horn Solo

Another America:

of

in

unknown percussion player:

Leary

bacher

and

Ray

Shanty
Kundert

Pines

Rindlis
Rindlis

Soldier's

Calkins:

Joy
Frank Uchytil with Otto Rindlisbacher and
Iva Kundert Rindlisbacher: The River in

the Pines

Otto Rindlisbacher and John
Giezendanner: Woods Holler
Hoot Owl

/

Fisher's Hornpipe
Pig
town Fling / Lancer's in Five Parts / Robert
Walker -- Lost Jimmie Whalen / Warde Ford:
Little Brown Bulls / Crandon / Warde Ford
Leizime Brusoe:

and Art Ford: I'd Rather Be

/

Poor White Man

a

N***** Than

Charles Spencer:

/

Adley-ca-budley-fatley-ca-ham-shaw
Locks and Bolts

a

Mighty

/

Clyde Spencer and Harrry
Fannin: The Sinking of the Titanic / John H.

Matheson: A Mhairi bhan og (O Fair Mary)

/ Stocainnean daoimean (Diamond-Pat

terned Socks) / Gabhaidh sinn a' rathad
mor (We Will Take the High Road) / The
Balkan

Troubadours

Mitrovich,

(Dan Radakovich,

Lubo Mitrovich,

Bob Rajacich,

Nick
and

/ Angelina vodu
Pouring Water) / Cecilia
Kuitunen: Charm for Hiccups / Anna Lei
George Rajacich): Alaj Gigi

lije

(Angelina

is

no: Charm for Toothache /
Olga Simi and
Sue Simi: Pium, paum / Matti Simi and Sue
Simi: Vilho ja Pertta (Vilho and Bertta) /

Matti Perala: Heramaen pukki (Old Man's
Goat) / Josefiina Perala: Kataja (The Juni
per)

/

Otto Sarkipato:

soutelemaan

Lahtetaan pojat nyt

(Boys, Let's Go Rowing) /
Keskella lahtea (In the Middle of the Bay)
/ Maria Heino: Laurilan Aleksin harmoo

nipeli (Laurila Aleksi's Accordion) / Ei ku
kaan puhu puolestani (No One Speaks on
My Behalf) / Eika ne haavan lehdet lakkaa
(Never Cease the Aspen Leaves) / Istuta,
tytto (Plant, O Girl)
CD

2

(The River in the Pines: The Wisconsin Lumber
jacks Recordings)

Earl Schivartztrauber and Ray Calkins: Fred

Sargent's Shanty Song

Otto Rindlisbach-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Tony

Romel

zelaznej fabric (In
Tony Strzelecki and pos

and Sylvester Romel: W

the Steel Mill)

sibly Tony Wasylk: Turkey in the Straw
Felix Kania: Czerwono posiadlo, a zielono

zniszlo (Red When
It Bloomed)

Jolly Lumberjack)

(Vagabond

Lumberjack Story

Swed

Sven

Story
"Shantyman"
Svenson (Otto Rindlisbacher), Iva Kundert
and
Frank
Rindlisbacher, Ray Calkins,
Kvasarvalsen
Waltz)
Uchytil:
(Swagger
Otto Rindlisbacher: Rippling Brook
Iva

CD1

Tony Wasylk: Irish Washerwoman
Strzelecki: Polish Polka
Adolph

Was Planted, Green
Edwina Lewandowski
and Stephanie Lewandowski: Goldmine in

Horn Solo
ish Dialect

(Pigtown Fling: The Sidney Robertson Recordings)

Lewandowski and Stephanie Le
wandowski: Chodzcie ggski moje (Come
Felix Kania: Wed
My Little Geese)
ding March
Tony Strzelecki and possibly
Edwina

Holler
Otto Rindlisbacher, Iva Kundert
Rindlisbacher, Ray Calkins, Frank Uchytil,
Earl Schwartztrauber, and John Giezendan
ner: Die lustigen Holzhackerbuab'n (The

Fred Sargent's Shan
Sven "Shanty
ty Song (Schuhplattler)
man" Svenson (Otto Rindlisbacher): Cow

Section with Illegible Text

diesem Baum? (What's on This Tree?)

an

Kundert

Rindlisbacher, Otto Rindlisbacher,

and unknown pianist

Saeterjenten's son

(Herdsgirl's Sunday)

tag

/Ray

Calkins:

Peter H.
Styrmans vals (Pilot's Waltz)
Plante: Rolling the Logs
French Dialect
Otto
Story /Frank Uchytil: Marie Patin
Rindlisbacher and Ray Calkins
Turkey
in the Hay
Otto
Woodchopper's Jig
Rindlisbacher: Gamle reinlander
(Old
Otto Rindlisbacher and John
Reinlander)
Giezendanner: Yodeling
Otto Rindlis
bacher

CD

Sorland springar'n

3:

Harps and Accordions (The Alan Lomax Recordings)

Joe

the Sky

Yalmer Forster:

Waltz)

Kulkurin valssi

Amanda Hdrkbnen:

Kaurapellon pientareella kasvoi kaunis
kukka (On the Side of an Oat Field Grew

Beautiful Flower

a

Aapo Juhani:

Juli

Henry Mahoski: Kauhavan Polka
Selma Elona Halinen: Pikkulintu era
maassa lauleleepi suruissana (A Little
ana

Bird in the Desert Sings Sadly)

Frank

Meripojan laulu (Sailor's Song)
Amanda Hdrkbnen: Oli mulla ennen puna
set posket (I Used to Have Red Cheeks)
Kalle Kallio: Kuule sina Hiltu kun laule
len (Listen Hiltu When I Am Singing)
Wain'o Hirveld: Kyllapa kai (I Guess So)
Kusti Simila: Yli kymmenen vuotta Kor
piinissa oli jo asuttu (Ten Years We've
Lived in Corbin)
Lillian Aho: Oi Herra,
ma
matkamies
maan
(Oh Lord, if I, a
jos
Wanderer of the Earth)
Pekka Aho and
Lillian Aho: Mun Kanteleeni kauniimmin
(My Kantele Will Sound More Beautiful)
Emil Maki: Suun kloorin kloorin halle
Maki:

luuja! (Oh Glory, Glory Hallelujah!)

CD

4

Cloud
Cloud: Red River Jig
Squaw Dance
Cloud and Clarence Cloud: White River

When the Dance Is Over: The Helene StratmanThomas Recordings, Part One

Edward King: Le Jour de 1'an
Ida Goyette, No. 1

Stella Stacy and Henry Thunder: Flute Song
Winslow White Eagle: War Dance
Wal

Alan Lomax:
Joe

Introduction

It

When

Two-Step

to Joe

(New Year's Day)

John Cadeau with Ed Cadeau, Adelore Vizina,
and probably Joe Miron, Mose Bellaire, and

Edward King: Non que j'aime done que la

boisson (No,

but the Drink)

So

I

Don't Love Anything

Fred Carriere: La fille du

roi (The

Le

King's Daughter)
marriage
Exilia
anglaise (The English Marirage)
Bellaire: I Went to Marquette
Fred Car
riere: Pretty Polly Those Western Shores
Bill McBride: No Sir

Bert Graham: Joe

Williams

lace Smith and Albert Webster:

Er
Emery Olsen: Good for the Tongue
nest Joseph Belisle: Je ne veux pas d'un av
ocat (I Do Not Want a Lawyer)
Charles

Cardinal
How They Sang the Marseil
laise in Chippytown Falls
Mary Agnes
Starr: Michaud
Marie Donalda Lagran
deur: Bonsoir, mes amis (Good Night,
My Friends)
Alfred Vandertie: I Went to
Market C'est l'cafe (It's the Coffee) [the

Unidentified man: Torch Lake
Lester Wells: Traverse City
Nils Larsen:
Yulia and Olaf
Lester Wells: Long Bar
ney
Adolphus Delmas: Hayfoot, straw
foot
Ed Thrasher: Shoot the Cat
Charles

Tune

Russian Jig
Buffalo Gals
Mother Song
Herman Meyers: Was war

o'r

Ketvirtis:

Tsyatkatho

Margaret "Laughing Eyes" Edaakie (Ea
Leizime
gle) and Phyllis Lewis: 49 Song
Brusoe, Robert McClain, Walter Wyss, and

Kermiss Song]

Emile Boulanger:

John Persons: Cornish Story
liam Reese and Selina Phillips: Cawn

(Paradise)/

Dr.

Daniel

W.

Dance
Wil

esgyn

Wickham

�My Welsh Relation
Hugh P. Jones: Y
du
Black
(The
John Wil
mochyn
Pig)
liams and chorus: Siani bach (Dearest Sian)
Lillie Greene Richmond: Hide Thou Me
Little Old Log Cabin in the Lane
One
More River
Preston Willis: Chase the
Buffalo
Hamilton Lobdell: Barker's Call
Pearl Jacobs Borusky: My Old Hen's a
Good Old Hen
Last Saturday Night
I

Entered

a

House

Did
Dishes
/Three

Charles

You Ever See the Devil?
and

Dietz:

Questions
Emery DeNoyer:
Irish
Shantyman's Life

Six

Snow Deer

Jubilee
John Muench with Ralph Weide:
Irish Washerwoman
Noble Brown: Oh,

Nine Years Ago

It's

Land

I

Was Diggin' in the

Robert Walker:

County Clare
du Lac Jail

McNamar'

Charles Robinson:

from
Fond

Moody Al

Lewis Winfield:

Bill Neupert: Red Light Sa
phabet Song
loon John Christian: Red Light Saloon
Bessie Gordon: Gambler's Blues

CD 5
My Father Was a Dutchman: The Helen Strat
man-Thomas Recordings, Part Two
Noble Brown: My Father Was a Dutchman
Richard Taschek with Laura Zenz and Lou
is

Taschek: Die

Deutschmeister (The Ger

man

Master) [Regiment] /Hans Huber.
Wiener Fiakerlied (Viennese Coachman's
Ella Mittelstadt Fischer: Wir sitzen
Song)
so frohlich beisamen (We Sit So Merrily
Charles

Together)

Robinson:

Sockery's

Martha Steinbach: An einem Fluss

Cat

Rapidly Flow
Albert Mueller: Landjager

daraus an Schuss (By
ing River)

a

John Giezendanner with
Giezendanner: Echo Yodel
Otto
Rindlisbacher:
Landler
Luxemburger

(Gamekeeper)

Albert

Onse gescht fu Chi
Guests
from
Rika
cago (Our
Chicago)
Tuinstra
(Knife
Enhoff:
Schaarensliep!
Marvin Fennema:
Bokkie
Grinder!)
Jacob

Becker:

C.

Anna

(Billy Goat)

C.

Scholten:

Gysbers

Moeder, moeder de beer ist los (Mother,
Mother, the Bear Is Loose)
Mary Tillema Smedema: Epitaph
Dick Kok: Wiene
Wederslweh bloed volksrang (Blood of

Netherland

Flows)

Vlaggelied

(Flag

There Would Be No World)
Vinca ca
Charles
(Wine, Wine)
Pelnar, John Pel
nar, Bill Slatky, and Louis Kasal:
The Yuba
alej (Prune Song)

Band

(Otto Stanek,

Wencil

Svestkova
Bohemian

Stanek, George

McGilvery, William Tydrich, Anton Stanek,
Nick Rott, Martin Rott, and Alfred Stanek):
Em
Popelka polka (Cinderella Polka)
ily Bauer McClure and Mayme Bauer Doser:
Pod nasima okny (Underneath Our Win
dows)
Emily Bauer McClure and Mayme
Bauer

Doser:

uzkou (As
Albert

I

Kdyz jsem sel cestickou
Walked That Narrow Path)

Wachuta:

Vojak

od

Prairie

du

Chien (Soldier from Prairie du Chien)
John Ciezczak: Zbojniki (Bandits' Dance)
Ber
John Ciezczak: In the Style of Sabala
nice Bartosz: Matus moja, matus (Mom

Miaies czapke (Hat
my, My Mommy)
with Peacock Feathers)
Adam Bartosz:
Zajumiaty bory (The Forests Roared)
Stasia Pokora: A witajze (Oh Hello)
The
Lithuanian Group from the Church of the Im

e

tanto bella
Irene

ful)
(It

Is

Ruffolo: Sona

Midnight)

Tiki-ta!
to

(America

Charles

Tamburitza

Most

Is

la

Beauti

Instruments

The

Elias

Tamburitzans (Charles Elias Jr., Ann Elias,
Martha Elias, and Mary Filipovich): Da nije
ljubavi nebi svjeta bilo (If Not for Lovers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the

focus

English, when,

as

onto
a

listen

songs sung in
to what's here

will show, this was far from the only lan
guage found in such Great Lakes states

Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan.
region was heavily infused with
pockets of Scots Gaelic, Serbian, Finn
ish, French Canadian, German, Polish,
Belgian Walloon, Cornish, Swiss, Dutch,
Italian,
Czech, Lithuanian,
Swedish,
Danish, Norwegian, and Icelandic, as
well as multiple indigenous languages
sung and spoken by the Oneida and Ho
Chunk. None of this is to say that this
set is the place to come to hear dense
amounts of these languages, as so much
here is in English, with songs borrowed
from other oral sources and modified to
fit various cultural subgroups; yet many
as

This

other languages are represented
here,
they should be.
Of course, the story of how this collec
tion ultimately came to be involves child
of the

as

hood curiosity, and the exhausting and
exhaustive work of three folklorists in
particular. Scandinavian scholar James P.
Leary, who is also a Professor at the Uni

Stella Skeris, Agnes Zupancich): Subatos
vakareli (Saturday Night I Saddled My
Black Horse)
Jalmar Nukala and Mamie
Wirtanen Nukala: Tula tullallaa, posket
Abel Jot
pullalla (Cheeks Full of Pulla)
blad: Flickan pa Bellmansro (The Girl at

versity of Wisconsin-Madison, recalls his
father taking him and one of his broth
ers to a place called the Buckhorn, in
Rice Lake, Wisconsin, when he was five

Charles O. Lindberg: Luf
Bellmansro)
farevisa: Hobo Song Ruth Johnson Olson

Carlson: Julen ar inne
Kamma Grumstrup:
Here)
Fra fjerne lande kom hun dronning Dag
mar (From Far Lands Came Queen Dag
Otto Rindlisbacher: Fannitullen
mar)
Alice Everson:
(Devil on the Wine Keg)
Kom kjyra (Come Cows)
Britha Lothe
and Hannah Haug: Her er det land (This Is
the Land)
Hans Waag: Gamle mor (Old
The Psalmodikon Quartet (Elsie
Mother)
and Alice

(Christmas

Johnson
Is

Thompson, Emily Thompson Flugstad, Nora
Thompson

Brickson,

and

Bertha

Larson):

Yderst mod norden (Far in the North)
Sigurline Bjarnarson and Christine Gud
mundsen: CDlafur reid meS bjorgum fram
(Olafur Rode Beneath the Cliffs)

DVD
Alan Lomax Goes North:
"The Most Fertile Source"

mezzanotte

Joseph Accardi: Tiki-ti,
Elias Jr.: Introduction

shift

maculate Conception (John Abromaitis, John
Aldakauskas, Lucia Aldakauskas, Mary Al
dakauskas, Ruth Baranoucky, Ann Belekev
ich, Edward Girdaukas, Alexander F. Skeris,

Song)

Henry Kempers
Daisy, Daisy
Thomas St. Angelo, Mr. and Mrs. Ambrose
DeGidio, and Michael Ranallo: L' America

to

massive five-pound book and
multi-disc box sets out to right a wrong
or two. The various LP collections of field
recordings from the sessions that pro
This

duced this set, as well as others that have
been released over the decades, tended

years old. After a hike in the woods, and
while his father and a friend were sit
ting at the Buckhorn bar over Breunig's
Lager (a beer that now has its own Face
book page), young James would roam
the shop /bar and gawk at curios, which
included a wall full of homemade instru
ments made by lumberjacks in the re
gion. On display were zithers, autoharps,

odd-shaped single-string bowed instru

ments, cigar box fiddles, Viking cellos,
violins, and items akin to the guitar. Re
turning there

as

a

young man

in the

mid-

'60s,
only found the instruments
still there, but started hearing stories
from older locals about the time some
he not

body from Washington, DC, came to re
cord many people in the area, including
the man who owned the collection. And
it was this that sealed his fate. Years later
still, he kept coming across references
to recordings collected by three people
specifically Helene Stratman-Thomas,
Sidney Robertson, and Alan Lomax
and it's their recordings
the entirety

of this

make
To

up

their

three of these collec
recognized that, since the area had

perpetual credit,
tors

that

collection.

all

such a mixed variety of music on offer,
their focuses needed to be broad. Also, as

these recordings

were made during the

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Depression,

well

as

as

when World War

raged and mass consumer culture was
a bomb about to be
dropped on the US,
their timing was crucial.
Their stories, and how the work each
did connects with the others', is told at
II

length

in

Leary's 430-page book, which

includes excellent black-and-white pho

tography of the folklorists and the musi
cians they championed, and is the focus
of this release. Every track here, all 188
of them, is explored
cluding translations

in

ocean-depth, in

of lyrics,

stories of

and from the performers, details of the
various ethnic groups and how and why

they ended up in the area, and a massive
amount of light placed on Wisconsin in
particular, thanks to Stratman-Thomas'
work. So exhaustive is the research that
other

bits

of

information tied

to

this

particular time and place spring up. We
learn of various ethnic groups' migratory

patterns and resulting experiences, like
the fact that, say, a Polish immigrant in
Michigan might learn clarinet from area
Lithuanians, that the Klan had attacked
Slavs in the area in the 1920s, or that
Welsh folks had settled parts of southern

Wisconsin

in

nomusicology

the mid-19"1
is

a

century.

Eth-

to

learn

fantastic way

history and make connections, and that
has perhaps never been on display more
intensely than it is here.
But it's the music, which

slowly, like

a

complexities
that's

Leary's

reveals itself

fine wine, with hints and
that take time to sink in,

crucial

for

true

text.

There

are

birch

empathy with
waltzes led by

bark players, Hardanger fiddle
tunes, hardcore Swedish solo cow horn,
deep, mournful Viking cello solos, ver
sions of "Soldier's Joy" played on cigar
box fiddle, Ojibwe solo fiddle tunes,

Finnish-sung kantele tracks that'll guar
broken hearts, button and piano
accordion tracks, frantic yodeling, Serbi
antee

an tambouritzan

ensembles, Paul Bunyan
Ho
Chunk
hand drummers, and
harpists,
lots and lots of a cappella song as well
as spoken word. There are examples of

ditties, hilarious, X-rated
of Lumberjack songs,
shanty tunes that share the melody with
"Little Brown Jug," and, as Leary states,
many "sonic fragments of lost worlds."
Scattered
throughout this collection
are cultural mash-ups, or as Leary de
"Irish Brogue"

bawdy tunes, piles

tails better than

I

ever could: "'The Irish

Washerwoman' played on accordion by

Germans
a ballad
sung verbatim from
Danish folk-school songbook," or "a
Ho Chunk warrior song repurposed for
summer tourists." The wealth of goods
a

here is staggering,

and

I

suspect that,

many listening to even a single disc's
worth of this collection, the United States
for

just got bigger.
To make this release even more

defini

tive, Leary thought to include color foot
age from Lomax's various aborted and
shelved film projects done in the late
1930s. Leary has edited selections from
footage shot in Michigan, and features

Upper Peninsula lumberjacks, Detroitarea Serbian tambouritzans, Finnish Cop
per

Country

dwellers,

Viking

cellists,

and Paul Bunyan harpists, with Lomax's
audio deftly edited in something like
sync, to at least suggest the performances
he filmed. There's also footage of Finnish

accordion player Aapo Juhani perform
ing some fascinating magico-religious

involving leafy twigs. It's a
document of animism merging
with a more established religious form,
practices

great

and as such, it connects pockets of Amer
ican life to hybrid religious practices all
over the world.
With every collection Dust-to-Digital

releases, which has increasingly focused
on books with accompanying sound, it's
tempting to repeat the claim that they've

�outdone themselves every few months.
astounding in its exhu
mation of sounds many of us were only
But this set, so

distantly aware

nothing else
country of immi
with all the prejudices, taboos,
of,

on this earth. This is

grants,

is

like

a

awkward

ritual, marginalization, and
other social complexities that come with
it. Yet it's also guaranteed that, at least at
one point, hundreds of folk hybrids ex
isted here, some found only stateside due
of an ethnic group's
remain
isolated
for too long.
ability
This collection, wonderfully written and
aurally enhanced, screams that about as
brashly as anything ever released.
to the

impossibility
to

BRUCE
To

order:

MILLER

uwpress.wisc.edu/books/5231.htm

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

eluded) and "Shake That Thing" (includ

ed), before fading from the business in the

Depression days of the mid-1930s.
All but a couple of Jackson's tracks here
were recorded with vocal and solo sixstring banjo or guitar. Those that weren't
either added a second banjo or a guest
lead vocalist, such as Lucille Bogan on
"Jim Tampa Blues."

Wisely,
ers Cary

the

reinterpretations by sing
Moskovitz, Dom Flemons, Jen

Maurer, Adam Tanner, and Jerron Paxton

mostly expand the musical settings a bit.
Some are not far from the originals, such
as Tanner's banjo take on "Shake That
Thing," backed with guitar and bass, or
his cover of "Bright Eyes," backed with
guitar. Others get full band treatments.
With 15 tracks, all of them engaging and
pleasing, it would take too much space
to

examine them all, but several do stand

out for remarks.

First up

would

be the

opener, "Alabama Bound." Moskovitz
enters on solo tenor banjo, hinting at the
original, but at the start of the second
verse a full traditional New Orleans jazz
band sound roars in and starts stomping,

and weaving clarinet, trumpet, and piano
This makes
sense
perfect
actually; Jackson was from
fills over accordian and bass.

�New Orleans and at one point recorded
with Freddie Keppard's Jazz Cardinals,
so in a way it's an honorific interpreta
tion. Similar in setting is "Mama Don't

You Think

I

Know,"

instrumentation,

Jen

and

in feel

Maurer's

if

not

"Papa's

Lawdy, Lawdy Blues" and her cover of
Jackson's less bawdy version of "Shave
'Em Dry." Also of note are Maurer's soft,

coquettish "I Got What It Takes," Moskovitz's reading of "Airy Man Blues"

with one of the grittiest bass clarinet so
los I've heard, and Jerron Paxton's piano
version of "Skoodle Um Skoo," on which
he imitates Jackson's oddly-strummed
banjo break with an even more oddlyphrased piano solo.
Purists may prefer the Jackson
nals.

That's fine.

origi

But since we already
have those indeed right within this
it's nice to get a different
very "twofer"

interpretation of them as well, especially
since Moskovitz and the others captured
Jackson's playfulness and spirit so well.

BILL WAGNER
To

order: document-records.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Jim Watson to join him to create "a

band

like sound" and record this CD.

Jabbour met Henry Reed in 1966, while
still

a

graduate student

at

Duke. At this

time, most of us who were playing "old
timey music" (as we called it) had first
heard it from the New Lost City Ram

blers, who were mining commercial 78s
for songs and a few tunes. It is hard to

imagine how exciting it must have been
to meet somebody who had been fid

dling throughout his life, and had a huge
repertoire different from those found
on commercial recordings. Jabbour calls
Reed his "main fiddle mentor," and a
majority of the tunes on this recording
are from Reed.

When playing these tunes, Jabbour
fiddles the melody with few if any
variations. Perlman has developed a
distinctive clawhammer style allowing
the banjo to follow the twists, turns and
ornamentations of the fiddle. His style,
to these ears, seldom uses the 5th string.

He will do this, play a harmony or coun
terpoint to the melody, or even simply

play rhythm. Watson plays a very sim
ple guitar style mostly in boom-chuck
style with few if any bass runs. At all
times, you can hear each instrument fol
lowing its own line.
Some of the tunes really are classics:
"Rye Straw," "Fire on the Mountain,"
"Old Joe Clark," "Love Somebody" ("Too

Young to Marry"), "Texas" (as we now
know, also called "Newcastle"), "Turkey
in the Straw," (all standard, but played
as Henry Reed played them), and even
"Mississippi Sawyer." Others from Reed
(and often played earlier by Jabbour
and the rest of the Hollow Rock String
Band) include "Ragged Bill," "Shoo Fly,"
"Grover Jones' Waltz," "Henry Reed's
Schottische," and "Red Fox." Since this

relatively uncom

last group of tunes is

mon, one wonders why these are called
"classics." To be sure, they are certainly
at least a century old, but they are rare.
Of the 40 Henry Reed tunes transcribed
in the Milliner-Koken Collection, there are
only four on this CD.

primarily an instru
two tracks with
singing, both by Jim Watson. These real
ly are classics: "Casey Jones" and "When
You and I Were Young, Maggie," and
Watson does justice to these songs!
Jabbour's extensive liner notes are won
derful. They discuss the history of the tune
and its name, the detailed structure of

Although this

mental

CD,

is

there

the tune (often

are

comparing the way Reed

played each tune

to

other fiddlers),

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

chord selection, and the source, in addition
giving the key, banjo tuning, and fiddle
tuning where not conventional. Sixteen
to

the

pages of liner notes, in all, which

I
applaud.
summarize: an enjoyable CD with
a number
of "classic" tunes done well,
plus a lot more obscure tunes than one

To

would expect from the title.

PETE PETERSON
To order:

kenperlman.com/classics-html

�that propels Nickerson to his most
ing performance overall on the

attack
record

ing. Only slightly less so is his fiddle and
banjo duet with Hughes on the standard
"Mississippi Sawyer." The format, along
with the slightly slower tempo, make it
Elsewhere, the
just a bit more relaxed.
fiddle tune "Old Buzzard" has some "get

moments in which Nickerson punctu
a
phrase, while the vocal
number, "Georgia Man," a semi-comic
tale of domestic discord (if there can be
such a thing), features Jeter's emphatic,
somewhat bluesy lead vocals. On each of
it"

ates the end of

those, there is

a
lighter support given by
backing. "Georgia Man," for example,
employs jangly banjo and scrubbing man
dolin accompaniment.

the

that use of

lighter approach that
is both the dominant sound and what the
band does best here. Theirs is a sound
of solid fiddle played with lots of long,
humming notes and a pared-down
melody line, of banjo blended almost
evenly into Harman's bass-run-less,
It is

a

open-chord guitar strumming, and of an
underpinning of buoyant bass. The ef
fect is effervescent, what you might call
the "Uncle Earl" bounce.

That's not to

say they sound like Uncle Earl, just that

they produce a similar relaxed flow. Lis
ten to "Booth Shot Lincoln," or to "Duck

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

River," or to "Fire On the Mountain."
The beat of each, along with the "Crys
tal Stream Waltz," is catchy and pleasant

without being overly forceful.

Much the same thing occurs on the vo
numbers. "Travelin' Man," sung by
Harman, has a sing-along, folk quality to
it, the chorus of which gets in your head.
cal

"Willie Moore" has the folk quality with
out the sing-along feel, and while it's not

earworm tune, it is well done. Hughes
sings that one with a gentle touch, much
as he does "I'm Just Here to Get
My
Baby Out of Jail." Truthfully, neither will
make you forget the standard versions,
an

but they both are interesting readings,
"I'm Just Here..." in particular, featuring

Middle Eastern-tinted runs,
drive,

and

a

nifty,

a propulsive
pedal-point, country

passage in the chorus. Whether they ar
ranged it themselves or learned it from
a
recording is anyone's guess, for they
don't include any source recordings. If
they did arrange it, or any of the others
including the album's absolute standout,
"Willow Tree," sung expressively by
Jeter and enveloped in a whirl of tubby
and percolating banjo and a sheen of autoharp

created

a

more power to them.
very listenable sound.

They've

BILL WAGNER
To

order: emptybottlestringband.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Old Texas Fiddle, Vol.
Weird Tunes of Old Texas
Spencer and Rains

Lady In the Center

same revive, preserve, and revel in old
Texas fiddling.
Once again, of the 22 tracks, tunes learned
from Duck Wootan get the most represen
tation. On the first volume there were six.
Here there are four, including the relatively
obscure "Rabbit Hash," an appealing tune
possibly of African American derivation,
and the 34-time "Wolves In the Wood,"
which has a Cajun-like tint.
"Porter's
Reel," from Stafford Harris, the only other
source musician represented on both vol

II:

umes, also has a strong Cajun bounce, so
much so that the fiddles sound like an ac
cordion. Couple that with an ear-catclring
B section melody and a hint of
ragtime,
and it ranks amone tire best tracks here.
Lake Porter's semi-hypnotic
"Black
Jack Groves" stands out for the wailing
note that announces the A section and
that presages the short vocal chant and

Three Hands Round

Rab
Blue-Eyed Susie Sally Johnson
Hash
Porter's Reel
Fire On the
Mountain
Old Joe Clark
Chicken
Reel
Duck Creek
The Scolding Wife
Wolves in the Wood
Unfortunate
Summer
Puppy
Long
Day
Copper
bit

Skeedaddle
Springs Blues
Stumptown Stomp
Waterloo
Kitty Crankie

whoop that comes mid-tune.

Black Jack Grove
Johnny Walk Along With Your Paper
Collar On
Old Paint
The

Lost Girl

with the album's

Seven tracks into this recording comes the
"Old Joe Clark."
Now, before
your eyes glaze at that information, con
sider that unless you're widely conversant
with all manners and styles of fiddling,
there's an almost certain chance you've nev
er heard it played like this
--old Texas style.
warhorse,

Eyed

a

colorful.
fluences.

It

full six minutes.

a

distinct. It's

incorporates myriad ethnic in

In short, it represents what made
old Texas fiddling unique, and by that I
mean the kind of Texas fiddling that blend

ed the Celtic

/Appalachian style with

the

influences of Germans, Czechs, Mexicans,
and Cajuns, to name but a few, and which

solid body of work dedicated
to that pursuit.
Already behind them is
Rains' excellent Old Texas Fiddle album.
Volume Two is equally captivating. The
backing musicians Brendan Doyle on
banjo, Nancy Hartness on guitar, Char
lie Hartness on ukulele, and Virginia
Musser on bass for nine tracks
are dif
ferent this time around, as are most of
the source musicians, but the aim is the

truly

raggy-sounding

You

BILL WAGNER
To order:

spencerandrains.com

Note to Artists and Record Companies
Please send all material for review to the

th Illegible Text

a

th Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text
th Illegible Text

the

dling of both Rains and Spencer.
can't go wrong with either volume.

existed before Western swing and contest
styles more or less steamrolled it.
Fiddler Howard Rains has spent much
of his career exploring those early Texas
tunes and stylistic approaches. Fiddler
Tricia Spencer, from Kansas, came to it
a little later, but
together they've begun

creating

Susie,"

waltz "Skeedaddle."
The CD closes
with a final highlight, "Old Paint," the
album's one true vocal (backed only by
fiddling), and a wonderful choice at that.
There are differences between the two
volumes. The first was a bit more var
ied in tune selection, and the sound was
thinner; the banjo and guitar seemed to
stand out more clearly. On this volume,
the sound is more unified, more focused
on the fiddles, and more dense. But that
unity makes for a pleasing overall sound
and well compliments the smooth fid

mesmeric lope

It's

Unusual might

Scolding Wife" from J. D. Willingham, and the heavily German-influence

this version, handed down from Jack
Gage (born 1876), the pace is very modest,
about 90 beats per minute, and the FCFCtuned fiddles drone gloriously, flirting with

melody and creating

fits well

"The

In

that goes

It

Weird Tunes

be a better
not
in
the
Perhaps
Mississippi
class of unusual tunes, but odd enough
in its own right.
Also of note are the
variant
of
three-part
"Black-Eyed Susie"
attributed to Elmo Newcomer as "Blueof Old Texas.

word.

the

subtitle

OTH (PO Box 61679, Durham, NC 27715).
Please do not send to individual review
ers. What gets reviewed is determined
at the discretion of the OTH according to
space available, balance of old and new,
and compatibility with our mission. We
cannot review everything that comes in
nor guarantee that because we received it
we will review it. We do not return mate
rials to the sender. Thanks!

�Babes

Snow

in
Hill

the Woods
Strings

Palmer Loux: fiddle; Sue Shumaker: fiddle; Gor
don Arnold: banjo; Greg Loux: guitar

The Indians are Over the Hill

Babe
Ewe
Down
from
Den
Horney
Coming
ver
Rose in the Mountain
Hell Up
Coal Holler
Off She Goes
Jenny on
the Railroad
Meriweather Salty River
Reel
McMichen's Reel
Ohio Waltz
Sand Mountain Drag
Red Apple Rag
Wink the Other Eye
Wish
Moonlight
I Had
Time
Sweet Bama
My
Again
This

wonderful

all-instrumental

CD

is

built around the twin fiddling of Palmer
Loux and Sue Shumaker. Several bands
back in the old days had two or more
fiddles, including the Skillet Lickers, the
Carter Brothers and Son, and more re
cently Highwoods. But this CD has more
than is implied by "two fiddles playing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�band." Twin fiddling hap
the two fiddlers involved
pens
have made a conscious; derision in play
in

the same

when

tunes

the
of

course,

in

harmony This
without written

is

all

done,

music;

first couple of times through, then start
playing in harmonies. Since Palmer and
Sue are both excellent musicians, I sus

pect that sometimes Palmer is playing
lead and Sue is creating harmonies, and
sometimes the other way around. While
this is going on, Greg Loux is playing ex
cellent backup guitar, while Gordon Ar
nold is playing either a melodic clawham
mer banjo or backup with a bowed cello.

(Wow.) All four musicians blend very well
together; a lot of time and fun have clearly
been spent getting to that happy condi
tion. For many years, Fiddler's Grove had
a twin fiddling category, and Palmer and
Sue were competing as a duo (and win
ning ribbons) over 20 years ago!
Flistorically, one of the earliest exam
ples of twin fiddling know is the Carter
Brothers and Son's "Jenny on the Rail
road," recorded in 1928 (check it out on
I

Document 8009, Mississippi String Bands,

Hill.

1),

also

The late

J.

here by Snow
Fraley made magical

played
P.

music with Betty Vornbrock

playing

second fiddle too, and the band cred
its J. P for their version of Arthur Smith's
a

"Red Apple Rag."
This treatment can be applied to almost
any kind of tune: fast, slow, waltz, rag, as
long as the tune has definite chords. (As
an

example

of

what probably wouldn't

work: "Candy Girl.") There are no bad
tunes on this CD, and it's hard to pick out
favorite examples of each. The very first
track, "The Indians are Over the Hill" is
a
great tune. (Because of that third part,
which is played at random times, it is not

good dance tune, sadly.) So, for that
matter, are "Salty River Reel" and "McMi
chen's Reel," and the list goes on. In con
trast, Ernie Carpenter's "Homey Ewe" is
a wonderful, stately, slow tune in which
the harmonies really stand out and have
time to build and ring. Ragtime? The
East Texas Serenaders recorded "Babe"
with only one fiddle, but hearing it here
with two, it sounds like the two fiddles
belonged there all along! (In addition to
a

the source recording on Document 8031,
listen also to Suzy Thompson on her No
Mockingbird CD.) And there's Tony Ellis'

"Ohio Waltz."
This CD belongs in your collection.
Good liner notes (citing sources!), and an

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

tunes well played by

four friends who have played together
long enough to have found a groove of

good-sounding music.

PETE PETERSON

the

harmonies are often created on the spot.
Generally the fiddles play in unison the

Volume

excellent choice

To order:

cdbaby.com/cd/snowhillstrings

�friend who already played soon won
I found
that three simple
and
the
use
of
a capo would al
tunings
a

me over. And

low me access

to

most of what

I

wanted

to play.

Still, I ve continued to be interested in
how varied tunings can enrich the possibil
ities, especially for solo playing or accom
panying songs. And while I spend almost
all of my playing time using clawhammer

don't want to neglect other
picking styles with old-time pedigree.
style,
Art

I

also

Rosenbaum's

Old-Time Banjo Book
Art's decades
playing
of careful observing and playing and
teaching have equipped him, like few
others, to offer this extensive DVD and
book filled with tunes and tablature and
is

a

part in that.

visual demonstrations.
Art himself started simply, as he relates
in his introduction, with Pete Seeger's
How to Play the Five-String Banjo, some
60 years ago. In that book, Seeger men
tions banjo player Rufus Crisp from
eastern Kentucky who, he wrote, knew
some 18 tunings. Art Rosenbaum was
intrigued and found some of Crisp's
recordings. Soon he was spending time
in the physical presence of some of the

old-time players, watching and
listening. Art absorbed not only their
great

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tunes, but also the varied picking styles
and tunings. This book mentions a host
he's learned from first-hand: Ed Teague,
Pete Steele, Omie Rose, Smokey Moun
tain Cass Moore, George Gibson, and
Ola Belle Reed. Others mentored Art
through their recordings: Banjo Bill Cornett of Kentucky, Hobart Smith of Vir
ginia, Samantha Bumgarner of North
Carolina, and Uncle Dave Macon of Ten
nessee. And still other great and more
current players "traded tunes, songs,
the likes
licks, and of course, tunings!"
of Tom Paley, Ken Perlman, Bob Carlin,
Paul Brown, and Dan Gellert.
That gallery of greats

suggests some

thing about the scope here: the regions
and settings
represented range from
mountain hollers to Midwest towns to
Southern festivals. It's hard to imagine a
more complete education. It's therefore
also hard to describe adequately the way
this resource brims with learnings from
Art's lifelong apprenticing.
But knowledge does not always trans
late to ability to teach. Happily, Art ex
cels here as well. As many players attest,

he's been sharing such sharing expertise
for decades: His 1968 Old-Tune Mountain

example, while out of print,
generates discussion on banjohangout.com. His tablature/ audio FiveBanjo,

for

still

String
Banjo

Banjo and The Art of Mountain
have also allowed many to learn

from his old-time immersion.

Now this latest resource gives,
through well-produced video, accu
rate tablature, and fascinating text
hours of pointers and presentation and
lore. The 47 tunings range widely and
sometimes beyond the ordinary. Some
have colorful names, such as "Hiram
Hubbard tuning" or "Train on the Is
land tuning" or the G minor "Katy
are
Cruel tuning." "Some tunings
sprightly and cheerful," Art explains;
others, such as Dock Boggs' "country
blues" tuning, have a more mournful
feel. "Other tunings suggest moods I
can't easily put into words," he says
on the

video introduction.

Art's careful cataloging here
Wade Ward's oft-quoted dic
tum that each tuning can convey a "dif
ferent atmosphere." That evocative im
age suggests that something powerful
happens through attention to more than
individual notes, but also the feel created

Indeed,
confirms

�a certain combination of
open strings,
fretted notes, and favored "licks."

by

Art

somehow conveys

the breadth

of

world of old-time styles. I think of it
a kind of visual
and audio encyclo
pedia, but ever so much more interest
ing than a string of topical entries. And
a

as

compelling simply because of
Art's masterful playing so carefully and
clearly captured in the video segments
it's not so

and printed tab. I think it has to do also
with stories about players he's learned
from, licks or slides he's emulated, side
comments about some subtlety of in
terpretation that can come only when
someone has spent time with the mas
ters. What he has created is as much a
reference work for decades to come as
an

instructional piece.

This comprehensiveness suggests

some

thing about the intended audience. What
Art has created will likely be the most
help to players with basic knowledge of

playing styles and common tunings. He
suggests, however, that even a novice
player, by starting with the book /DVD

sections on double-C or open-G tunings,
could begin with the well-known tunes
there and work forward and backward.
And a near-beginner could certainly en
joy seeing the wide, even wild range of

playing styles possible.
Fortunately the tunings are grouped in
musical families, usually related in some
way to a common key. Art also employs
a useful system based on fret numbers to
explain, conveying clear steps to get to
the various tunings. He also delves deep
ly in how to use tunings, and provides at
least one sample tune or song for each.
This makes moving from page to page
and tuning to tuning easier.
I
also appreciated Art's interest in
other picking techniques. Clawhammer
has practically eclipsed other old-time
banjo picking patterns in many jam set
tings. But Art shows (and tabs out) twofinger and three-finger style approaches,
thumb-lead and index-lead, Pete Seeger
up-picking and the more common down
stroke styles. This book is therefore about
more than an assortment of tunings.
Video close-ups allow the viewer to see

clearly what is going on with the right
and left-hand techniques.
Oh, and a bonus: Art offers some great vo
cals on the video. His early mentor, George
Gibson of Kentucky, knew an old-timer
who quipped, "If you can't sing it don't
pick it." Many of the tunings in Art's proj
ect work especially well accompanying

old-time singing. As

if the

book and DVDs

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

didn't

already

brim and

expanding possibilities
Art has included verses

overflow

with

for banjo
in the

players,
book for the

songs and ballads he's collected.

tempting to say more about this
remarkably wide-ranging resource, but
It's

the four hours of total playing time on
the two DVDs leave me with a sense of

riches yet to explore. What Art Rosen
baum has put together is a subtle invi
tation, suggesting that perhaps it's time
for me to get back to watching, listening,
and absorbing.
TIMOTHY JONES
To

order:melbay.com

�New England boasts

YANKEE FIDDLERS
By Paul

F.

Wells

a

Although
dling tradition

fid

that has roots in the
Colonial era, it is probably safe to assume
that most readers of the Old-Time Herald
are more familiar with music that comes
out of the American South than from
the Northeast. There is good reason for

the huge disparity between
ways the musical traditions of the
two regions have been recorded and
otherwise exploited. Whereas the com
mercial recording of Southern old-time
music that began in the 1920s brought
of great fiddlers to wide at
a plethora
tention
Robertson, Tanner, McMichen,
Kessinger, Roberts, to name just a fewMellie Dun
only three Yankee fiddlers
ham (Maine), Uncle Joe Shippee (Con
necticut), and Uncle John Wilder (Ver
mont) made records in the 1920s. Their
total output was just 14 sides, containing
fewer than two dozen different tunes. All
three of these men who recorded did so
because of some connection with Henry
Ford and the national mania for fiddling
and fiddling contests that Ford generated

this, given
the

in 1925

'26.

Once that craze inevitably

faded from the public's interest so, too,
did the New England fiddlers who had
benefited from it. There was no followup on the part of record

companies

to

market for Northeast tradi
develop
tional music, and no new popular music
genres, parallel to country or bluegrass,
grew out of the region's traditions. Nev
ertheless, there is a rich history of Yankee
fiddling and in this visit to the Attic we
take a look at images of several of New
England bow pullers.
We begin with the oldest member of the
group, a man who was an active, noted
fiddler during the era in which Mellie
a

themselves
Jolrn Wilder
two of the earliest-born fiddlers from any
region to make phonograph records
were young men. Abram (sometimes
Abraham) Pushee lived from 1791 to 1868.
Dunham and

Early in his life he resided in Canaan, New
Hampshire, but by the time of the 1860

courtesy

census he was living in the larger town of
Lebanon, about 15 miles to the west. The
photo comes from the studio of Billings
&amp; Hough in Lebanon. It is in the small

of Paul

Wells

Abram

Tushee

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(2.5" x 4") carte de visite (CDV) format that
was popular from 1859, when it was in
troduced to America, until the late 1870s.

Pushee would appear
ties in the

to be in Jiis

portrait, so the

seven

image probably

dates from the early to mid-1860s.
He was

a

saddler

or

harness maker by

trade, and was active in the community
life of Canaan. He attended and was

�affairs of the local Con
was elected town
gregational
moderator in 1823, and in that same year

involved

in the

church,

helped establish

Masonic lodge

a

in

Ca

naan. He also apparently lived in Lowell,
Massachusetts, for a time; an Abraham

Pushee, identified

as

a

musician,

listed

is

in the 1849 Lowell city directory.
He was well-known in the region as

a

fiddler, band leader, and dancing master.
As was fairly typical of New England

dance musicians of the era, Pushee was
musically literate. He was sufficiently
versatile as a musician to be able to
lead the small orchestra that accompa
nied a musical stage production in the
state capital of Concord in 1828; he is
described as "the noted violinist... of
Lebanon" in a history of Concord. Push
ee also composed tunes; several pieces
attributed to him appear in collections
published in Boston and Lowell. These
include two tunes found in Ryan's Mam
moth Collection,

published by Elias Howe

in 1883 (aka One Thousand Fiddle Tunes or
"Cole's"). One of these, "Pushee's Horn

pipe," is the melody that was recorded in
1926 by the Plymouth Vermont Old-Time
Dance Orchestra, led by John Wilder, un
der the title "Lady

Washington's Reel."

attribution to Pushee in Ry
an's, for "Young America Hornpipe," is
clearly erroneous; the tune is a variant of
"Farewell to Whisky," composed by the
renowned Scottish fiddler and composer
Niel Gow and first published in 1801.
Pushee was known to, and may have
The

other

been the teacher of, Charles M. Cobb of
Woodstock, Vermont, a town about 20
miles from Lebanon. Cobb compiled an

impressive manuscript containing

a

wide

range of music that included, but was
no means limited to, fiddle tunes and
lated dance music. Numerous tunes
Cobb's book (which is in the collections

by

re

in
of

the Vermont Historical Society) carry the
notation that they were from, or by, "A.

Pushee." Clearly, Pushee was a musician
who left his mark on the fiddle and dance
traditions of northern New England in the
middle of the nineteenth century.
Our next fiddler also happens to have
hailed from Woodstock, Vermont, or
least he sat for a photographer (E. R.
Gates) who was based there. I have no
other information about him
but that
won't stop me from engaging in some
at

speculation about his identity!
I

is

would like very much
a

of Uncle

photo

Plymouth

Vermont

chestra, as

a

to

think that this

John Wilder,

of the

Old-Time Dance Or

young man. There are numer-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

E.

R.

Gates

Woodstock,

NY

�courtesy
of Paul
Wells

ous extant photos of Wilder (who was an
uncle of President Calvin Coolidge) that

were taken during

his brief time

in

the

spotlight in 1926, though I do not own any
myself. offer here a copy of a studio por
I

trait of Wilder that was found online, plus
a composite image of the heads of Wilder

and the

anonymous Woodstock fiddler

in

my photo, for comparison purposes.
There are a number of points than can be
made both for and against the possibility
that they are the same individual. The size,
angle, and shape of the ears of the men are
strikingly similar. Both men have strongly
arched eyebrows and deep-set eyes. Also,
the

hairline and the way the hair on the

right side of the head flows back are very
similar in both cases. Arguing against
identity, one could point out that Wilder

lived in Plymouth, not Woodstock, where
the photo was taken. However, the two
towns are separated by less than 15 miles.
Woodstock has always been the larger of
the two communities-- with a population
of

c.

3,000

pared with

in

the years

c.

1,200 for

1850-1870

com

Plymouth so is
have supported a photog

more likely to
raphy studio, which could have drawn its

clientele from surrounding towns.
Wilder is known to have been a farmer all
his life, so one might question whether or
not a Vermont farmer would have owned a
fancy suit such as the one tire man pictured
here is wearing. However, in all the news

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

photos of him from his period of fame
in 1926 he is dressed quite well, and the
matter of rural musicians putting on their
Sunday best for a visit to a photographer's
studio is a topic that we've touched on
numerous times in our visits to the Attic.
Perhaps the most serious objection to the

idea of this being a photo of Wilder is a
matter of chronology. This image, like the
one of Abram Pushee, is a carte de visite,
and that format is said to have passed out
of popularity by the late 1870s. Wilder was
born in 1847 (some sources give 1846 but
census records indicate that the later date
is

correct).

It is

difficult

to form

a

good es

timate of the age of the man in the photo,
but he is probably at least 30. The rounded
corners of both the print and the mounting
card suggest that it comes from late in the
CDV era, so

a

date in the late 1870s is

at

least within the realm of possibility.
So... a great many ifs, and maybes, and

stretches, and perhapses, mixed with a
healthy dose of wishful thinking. There is
no way to be certain, one way or the other,
and perhaps the best we can do is to say
that there are enough similarities between
the men in the two photos that we cannot

not Wilder in both cases. I
be sure that
leave it to readers to draw their own con
clusions. In any case, it is a nice photo of a
late -19th-century Vermont fiddler.
We move a bit further south now, into
southern Connecticut. The two musta
it is

chioed

gentlemen wearing

sporty caps

and button-up sweaters, standing up and
playing their fiddles down on their arms,

hailed from Wawecus Hill, just west of
Norwich. Norwich is on the Thames Riv
er, about 15 miles north of New London.
They are literally twin fiddlers; a hand
written note on the back of the photo
identifies them as the twin sons of a Colo
nel James D. Rogers (1811-1885). The fid
dler on the right is also James Rogers, but
the name of the one on the left is obscured.
A bit of Internet digging reveals that Col.

twin sons were James Benjamin
George Woodworth, and that they

Rogers'
and

were born March 18, 1851. James (the son)

�died in 1929 and

Cemetery

in

is

buried

Norwich;

I

in

Maplewood

have found no

further trace of brother George.
Nor have I been able to learn anything
about the fiddling activities of the Rog
ers brothers. They are not known to have

participated

in the big

fiddle contest that

was held in Providence, Rhode Island, in
January 1926 that was won by Joe Shippee from the nearby town of Plainfield.

(Shippee's victory in this contest led to his
one trip to the recording studio.) Presum
ably James and George provided music
for dances and other events in the Nor
wich area and, also presumably, played
together as a duo. Would that we knew

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

what their fiddling sounded like! Did
they double the melody or did one pro
vide some sort of seconding to the other?
Might they have played in octaves as is
done in some areas of Ireland? We briefly
explored the possibilities of twin fiddling
few years back, in our very first visit to
the Attic (OTH vol. 12, no. 11).
Our final fiddler is another man who,
a

if not exactly a household name, even
within the realm of traditional fiddling in
New England, is, like Abram Pushee, a
known quantity. Cassius "Cash" Radford
from New Hampshire was yet another
Yankee who was able to ride the 1926 fid
dling craze to a brief round of fame. In

February of that year Radford traveled to
Washington, DC, and played fiddle for
President Calvin Coolidge; "Cash Rad
ford Fiddles for President Coolidge" pro
claimed the headline on the front page
of the February 13th issue of the Nashua
Telegraph. Radford had arrived in the na
tion's capital that morning, and in the
company of former New Hampshire
governor John H. Barlett, played for the
president at a noon gathering.
Radford was able to parlay this notoriety
a
six-night run as a featured performer
at the Tremont Theater in Nashua in late

into

February and early March. The Tremont,
at the time was located at 172-174

which

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Main Street in Nashua, had been the site
of a small fiddlers' contest a month earlier,
on January 28. Radford was not among the
competitors in that event, but his appear
ances

theater

the

at

apparently

inspired

the man who placed second in the contest,
Llewellyn Powers of Nashua (who was pic

tured in the Attic in OTH vol. 13, #12), to

challenge Radford

to

a

fiddling showdown.

have been thus far been unable to find any
evidence that such a contest actually took
place. (Remarkably for the time, the contest
at the Tremont was won by a woman, Kittie
I

Nickles.)

M.

Later in life Radford was one of the

mu

Eloise Hubbard Linscott worked

sicians

with when conducting fieldwork that cul
minated in her book, Folk Songs of Old New

England (1939). At the time of his associa
tion with Linscott, Radford was 93 years
old and living in Pembroke, New Hamp
shire, near the state capital of Concord.
Linscott tells us that by then his fingers

had become so crippled that he could no
longer hold a bow. He obligingly whistled

tunes for her instead of playing them,
A couple of notes:
In

1.

talking

about

"Yankee"

fiddlers,

I

mean people of Anglo heritage who lived in
predominantly rural areas of New England.

Some of the many fine Quebecois fiddlers who
in the pre-WWII era lived in New

recorded

at various times, and Boston was
some good Irish traditional musi
cians who recorded. But interaction between

England
home

to

the different musical toorlds during this era
seems to have been limited, at best. Also,
whereas the companies who issued recordings

Dunham,

by

Wilder,

and Shippee did so in

their mainstream popular series, recordings
by Quebecois and Irish musicians were is

segregated "ethnic" series that were
targeted to specific cultural markets.

sued

in

photo of Llewellyn Powers that ran
earlier installment of this series, he is

2. In the

in an

pictured with an impressive silver loving cup.
I noted at the time that I was unable to make
out any date on the cup, and speculated that
the photo might have been taken in the 1930s.
A

somewhat different photo of Powers with
is surely the same cup ran in the Nashua

what

paper on February

26, 1926.

The story

that

accompanies the photo carries the information

that Powers had won the cup at a recent com
petition held at the Strand Ballroom in Boston.

The
the

author is pleased to acknowledge
assistance of fellow fiddle researchers

Paul Gifford and Steve Green in helping
to track

down photos

about, John Wilder.

of, and

information

�Cash

the

Radferel

Champion

From

Fiddles

courtesy
of Paul

Wells

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

NH

�Join us for the 7th Annual

Time-

Old

--Surry
Fiddlers
APRIL

Convention
1 &amp; 2, 2016

SURRY COMMUNITY COLLEGE

Friday, April 1st

Saturday, April

7:00 p.m.

S5.00 Admission

$5,600

FREE

Adult

Mountain Park
Old Time Band

&amp;

Youth Competitions All Day

Contest Registration begins

Ballard's Branch

Bogtrotters

IN PRIZES

AND RIBBONS

Music by:

New

2

Fiddlers
Convention

Square Dance
Children under 12

DOBSON, NC

at 10 a.m.

$5.00 Admission
Contestants
12

&amp;

&amp;

Children

Under Free

Free Workshops, Luthier Displays, Jamming, Cake Walks,
Quilt Raffle, 50/50 Cash Drawing &amp; Dining at the Knights' Grill

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

WWW.

Surryoldtime com

0

�Fielding,

Bob Flesher,

Kevin Fore, Greg Galbreath,

Lo

Gordon &amp; Tim Gardner,

Kevin Enoch,

Wvatt Fawlev, Will Fieldina.

Bob Flesher.

Kevin Fnrp.

Gren Galhrpat-h

I n Gnrdnn

CONVERSATIONS WITH NORTH AMERICAN

I

BANJ0 BUILDERS

I

nohOn-lln.

GlmnOir

rr=

r-Knv..,.

Patrick

Doc

Huff,

Laurent

Dubois,

Kevin

Enoch,

Wyatt

Fawley

Will

4-volume, 12-DVD set of interviews
with 38 open-back banjo builders and historians.
documentary

will be

talked about for

a

long time to come."

Enter code OldTimeHeraldBanjo through
June 30, 2016 to save 20% off the complete
12-DVD set at folkways.si.edu

Banjo News

SreaAdamc

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings

Section with Illegible Text
Reiter, Bill

Rickard, Jason

Romero,
Pete

Ross,

Eric

Schlange,
Peter

Szego,

Bob

Thornburg,
Mac

Traynham,
Doug

Linger,

Colin

Vance,Bob

Winans,

George

Wunde

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ramsey,
Bart

flR,.,

"This

Mike

ooilman,

IMoel

Booth,

John

Bowiin,

A

a

�&lt;foui ua in 2016!

AUGUSTA
HERITAGE CENTER
of Davis &lt;%Elkins College
Section with Illegible Text

2016 SUMMER SESSIONS
tfullllO- J\lLCLUAt 14
APPALACHIAN

ARTS, CRAFT &amp; FOLKLORE

CLASSESJuly 10

ALL

IRISH WEEK

WEEKS!
12

-August

FOLKLIFE WEEK

July

24-29

CAJUN &amp; CREOLE WEEK

BLUEGRASS WEEK

CLASSIC COUNTRY WEEK

July 31

August

5

July 10-15
OLD-TIME WEEK, VOCAL WEEK
BLUES

k SWING WEEK

AND AMERICAN

July 17-22

VERNACULAR DANCE WEEK

August

7-12

AUGUSTA FESTIVAL

(c4ugut 12-14]
Featuring

a

SQUARE DANCE on Friday evening;

juried CRAFT SHOW, DEMONSTRATIONS and
PERFORMANCES
and

all day

Saturday

Elkins City Park

in

FESTIVAL CONCERT WITH MOUNTAIN STAGE in

evening; and

a

GOSPEL SING on Sunday

morning.

&lt;$am Uhe JDate!
OCTOBER OLD-TIME

WEEK

FIDDLERS' REUNION WEEKEND

iMM
randoiph
county
virgissa'
WEST

mm
VIRGINIA

Culture and History

WEST VIRGINIA COMMISSION
ON THE ARTS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FOR MORE INFORMATION

OCTOBER 16-21
OCTOBER 21-23

OR TO REGISTER,

WWW AUGUSTAHERITAGECENTER
OR CALL

304-637-1209

VISIT
National

Endowment

ORG
ARTWORKS.

for the Arts

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12044">
                <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 14, Number 3 (March 2016)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12045">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12046">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 14, Number 3 (March 2016).&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Featured articles:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The 1927 Bristol Sessions and Ralph Peer: A Myth and a Legend Losing Luster in the Cold Light of Recent Scholarship,” by Ted Olson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Mac Traynham, Banjo Builder and Musician: ‘It’s always been about the party.’,” by Malcolm Smith&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Show Me Some More Tunes: An Interview with Ashley Carder,” by Sarah Bryan&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Yankee FIddlers,” by Paul F. Wells&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12047">
                <text>2016</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="1632">
        <name>2010s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5434">
        <name>2016</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5438">
        <name>Ashley Carder</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2427">
        <name>Bristol, Tennessee</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5436">
        <name>Mac Traynham</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5437">
        <name>Malcolm Smith</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5413">
        <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5440">
        <name>Paul F. Wells</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1474">
        <name>Ralph Peer</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5439">
        <name>Sarah Bryan</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2452">
        <name>Sullivan County, Tennessee</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5435">
        <name>Ted Olson</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2505" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3430">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/a0c93eef0ad08f49e867f7ee02bc4852.pdf</src>
        <authentication>8152d771a659a9252932bff4b2e1f89b</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12101">
                    <text>CELEBRATING

OUR 21st YEAR
OLD-TIME

THE
HERALD

A MAGAZINE DEDICATED
VOLUME 11, NUMBER

7

MUSIC

OLD-TIME

TO

NOVEMBER, 2008

OCTOBER

$7.50

MANDOLIN BANJOS
f

Are you foe weary
pick up
your instrument &amp; play a tune?
Old "get up and go"
got up and went?
Take the advice of

CREATURE

PROM
THE

BLACK
GOON

John Brinkley
'"Remember, a man is only

Dr.

as old as his glands

5

!"

String
Banjo

The Astounding
Jnlay Work
Will Give You
The Heebie

Dr. Brinkley
performing another
rejuvenating
medical operation.

Jeebiesl

What in the world does Dr. Brinkley have to do
with Old-Time Music? Read this issue to find out!

Featured

in this

SORRY!
Cut of

issue:

Stock

XERA's Dr. John Brinkley
Sen. George Cecil McLeod of Mississippi
The trouble with reviews...

Guarantee

Safe

We © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.
Copyright

Delivery

of

AU

Our

Shipments

�Acoustic
music
careers
grown here
Dear Friend,
independent musician myself,

As an

I

know how hard

it

to get your music

is

right people. That's what led me to develop the OasisSampler

heard by the

radio promotion CD program.

this program, previously unrecognized Oasis clients have signed recording
landed
lucrative sponsorship deals, had their music featured in the soundtracks of
contracts,
Thanks

to

hit HBO series,

and much more.

couldn't be easier: When you order your CDs, just tell us which track of your
music you want promoted to radio on the OasisSampler and we take it from there. There is
absolutely no additional charge for the program. Plus, we send our proprietary radio station
The

program

contact

to you, so you

list directly

receive your song
I

can follow

and stir up even more of

hope we have the opportunity

we can add your

to work

on

music to the prestigious

up
a

personally with the

DJs

and stations

your

next disc manufacturing

music-industry

project,

Sincerely,

Micah

P.S.

May

I

send you

of an OasisAcoustic

what

all the

as well.

I'll

fuss

is

a

President

free sample?

I'd

love to get

a

free copy

radio broadcast sampler so you can see

about

also include

a

and how we can promote your music to radio

copy of our latest, ground-breaking

catalog with your sample.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

so that

tradition that the OasisSampler

series has become.

Micah Solomon

who

buzz.

disc replication

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FEATURES
Goat Glands and String Bands:
By David Holt

Dr.

John Brinkley /16

Old, New, and Real:

The Case of

Mississippi's Senator George Cecil McLeod/26

By Chris Goertzen

COLUMNS
HERE &amp; THERE/8

ISSUES

IN

OLD-TIME MUSIC/14

Old-Time Herald Reviews
By Alice Gerrard

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS/2
LETTER FROM THE EDITOR/7

CLASSIFIEDS/32
REVIEWS/34

COMING SOON:

Old-time music

in

digital archives

Vesta Johnson

�Letters
Regarding reviews
Certain CD reviews that appeared in the last
issue of the Old-Time Herald have become

would

of sharp controversy and hard
feelings over the last several weeks. Given the
intensity of the discussion, this would seem

critical.

the

an

subject

clarify our editorial
reviews.
subject of
but afeiv very rare cases, the materials

appropriate

policy
In all

time

to

on the

discussed

in the

for the express

pages of the OTH are sent
purpose of being reviewed.

to us

Art

be aware that if they seek review in
these pages, we can 't guarantee that the review
ers' opinions will be unequivocally positive. We

ists should

consider both our reviewers and our readers

to

highly knowledgeable about old-time music,
and although another listener may have a dif
be

ferent, and

no less valid,

recording,

we believe

response

to

any given

that our revieivers will

express their opinions in a manner that is infor
mative both about the recording and about the
wider context of old-time music.
We feel that Jody Stecher's review of The
Way It Was, discussed below, more than
met these standards. Jody, who has written

reviews for the Old-Time Herald for many
years, was highly complimentary about the

artists' musicianship, but detailed his dis
agreement with the historical premise of the
recording. The historical aspect of this contro
good example of the sort of debate
versy
that we welcome in this magazine. We rely on
is a

our readers

with what

to
is

speak up when they disagree
in our pages.

printed

Although controversies such as the present
one are painful in a community as tightly
knit as ours, we believe that no good purpose

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

be

served

in

ers (or readers) were
It is our

the long

review

run if

discouraged from being

belief that the value of honest

discussion far outweighs
forced congeniality.

the benefits

en

of

to offer my personal thoughts re
one
subtext
of the debate below. Some
garding
the
letters
we
have
received have called into
of

would like

I

question Jody Stecher's authority

the

on

sub

ject of old-time music, citing in alarmingly
hostile terms his Northeastern background
and residence

in

California.

I'm

a

native of

the South, and (although I did not learn from
them my family has included many tradition
al

musicians over the generations.

I

do not

be

lieve that by virtue of possessing this heritage,
I can claim
greater authority about old-time

music than
ground.

a

fellow musician of different back
generations the distinction

In earlier

might have been relevant, but-- while regional
heritage is still very important, and a justifi
able source of pride-- for more than a gen
eration now,

a
large portion of the devotion,
creativity, and labor that has kept our music
so vital has come from people who are neither

from Appalachia

nor

even from

the

South.

It's hard to imagine where we would be today
without the documentary efforts (as well as the

artistry) of the New Lost City Ramblers, Alice
Ray Alden, David Freeman, Andy
Cahan, Bob Carlin, and far too many others to
list-- artists who are not natives of the South
Gerrard,

Appalachians. I'd like to propose to fellow
old-time musicians that the time has come for
ern

us to

dispense with regional antagonism.

Sarah Bryan

�takenly speculated about tune origins and
sources. Again, some specific examples
would be helpful. One might question
the rationale of grammatical corrections

coming together of the banjo and
fiddle in ensemble is not well-docu
mented, but [Cece] Conway [author of
African Banjo Echoes in Appalachia]
does riot find evidence for it happening
prior to the minstrels. In the mountains,
The

the

dated roughly from the Civil War

it

riod until roughly World War

review. Are we to be graded on this as
as our music? This seems like a waste
of readers' time.

in

pe

Finally, I'd like to ask anyone who has

I.

read the review of our CD and this rebuttal

(www.traditionalmusic.co.uk)

to

listen to the CD and the original sources,

and make your own judgment as to what
"authentically old" sounds like. When this

Playing styles found most commonly
in the south-central region [of Kentucky]
include fiddle-banjo combinations asso

music we all hold so dearly is reduced to
mere academics, we have a real problem.
Please see our many positive reviews from
well known experts in the half-page ad we

ciated with African-Americans prior to
the Civil War.
(Special Collections, Hutchins Library, Berea

College, www.berea.edu

a

well

hutchinslibrary

have in this issue.

specialcollections)
The
core

Martin Fox
Fairview, NC

fiddle and banjo ensemble, the
of the mountain string band and

the symbol of the Blue Ridge region for
many Americans, is a prime example of

just saw the review by Jody Stecher of
The Way It Was, by Martin Fox and my

I

new flavor that emerged from the cul
tural stew simmering in the region prior
to the Civil War

a

I was born and raised in the Appa
lachians. Now, that certainly does not
make me an expert and I have never tried

self.

(Joseph Wilson and Wayne Martin, "A

a lofty goal, but I am pretty sure
have better first-hand knowledge of the
music from that region than a Brooklynborn California resident who made refer
ence to "our Appalachian mountains," as
if he were a part of it, in his review. The
review was all about slamming the liner

for such

Brief History of Blue Ridge Music," in
Fred Fussell and Cedric N. Chatterley's
Blue Ridge Music Trails: F inding a Place in the
Circle, UNC Press, 2003)
Mr.

I

Stecher also took issue with our style
He says we have not captured the

of play.

way music sounded
century; instead, our music
reflects the way fiddle and banjo music
sounds today. However, he cites no sourc
true essence
in

of the

the 19th

Is there
that
research
supports any
any published
of his assertions? He doesn't give any. I
don't know how music from that time pe
riod sounded, and I don't think that Mr.
Stecher does either. We don't have any re
cordings from that period, so the best any

es for any of the "facts" he cites.

of us can do is to

attempt

to

play the

mu

sic in the style we think may be accurate.
Regarding the grammatical form of our

notes, and Martin directly. Martin is not
only my best friend but a true player and
active supporter of the area, the people,
He is appreciative to
and their music.
be mingled with our heritage, and has
never attempted in any way to become
the typical outsider that wants to show
us how it was and how it should be.
Jody spent nine-tenths of the full-page
review giving the reader a lesson in cor
rect punctuation and how things were
done 200 years ago, which many people,
myself included, could debate and reject

He took the entire project
into his own interpretation
pertained to what we were trying to

as [not]

liner notes, Stecher says: "The liner notes

and

are

as it

detailed and problematic with frequent
oxymorons, impossible anachronisms,
mistaken speculations about tune origins,
tenuous links to fiddling sources, mis

factual.

wound

it

We have several active mu
sician friends in Southwest Virginia and
East Kentucky who agree that his feeble

accomplish.

phes, although they may be misplaced,
Stecher
they didn't wander anywhere.
does not give examples of any of his other
criticisms, and having reread the notes,
I
didn't see
I
simply can't find them.

attempt of being a self-appointed "Oz" as
to what the later 19th century presented
as old-time music and how it would have
sounded is simply not accurate.
Lastly, everyone is a critic in some fash
ion, and what is good is always to the eye
and ear of the beholder. This was not a
music review. If it had been I would not

the

be

spellings and wandering apostrophes."
found one misspelled word, but that was
error. Regarding apostro
a typographical

oxymorons and impossible anachro

nisms.

I

also do not believe

I

have mis

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

sending this

to

you.
Jeff

Winegar

�More on The Way it Was Review
Martin Fox and Jeff Winegar received
some undeserved criticism in Jody Stecher's review of their CD. The main point
of

contention

is that the CD, by its title,

treats banjo /fiddle duets as the norm in
the 19th century, while the evidence to
support this resides in the "almost none"
category. Stecher does restrict his argu
ment to Appalachia, but folks were set
tling that area in the 1790s and they came
from

the
is

East

where

the

documented.

fiddle /banjo
have been re

pairing
searching this question for my set of CDs
subtitled Fiddling on the Frontier. Here is
some of what I've found.
There is Nicholas Creswell's account in
1774 of "Fiddle and Banjo played by two
I

negroes." In late colonial /early repub
lican times both Ben Carter, grandson of
Robert "King" Carter in Virginia, and
Randolph Jefferson, Thomas' brother,

fiddlers/ violinists

both

are

de

scribed by their slaves as seeking solace
among the slave musicians until late in
the night. These slaves presumably had
both fiddles and banjos. An 1843 cover
lithograph for the sheet music to Jim
Crow Polka shows a caricature of four
black minstrels, two of whom are play
ing fiddle and banjo. An 1853 watercolor titled Lynchburg Negro Dance shows
three black musicians, two on banjo
and fiddle. An 1863 painting by John
Ehninger called Old Kentucky Home por
trays a black man and his son on fiddle

albumen print from the
1860s entitled Black Musicians in Minstrel
Line features four black musicians, two
with banjo and fiddle. These are just a
few; there are others. Dena Epstein in
Sinful Tunes and Spirituals cites further
references; George Gibson cites a num
and banjo. An

examples of the gourd banjo in
Appalachia, one destination for escaped
slaves who are documented by Robert

ber of

Winans as playing both fiddle and ban
Admittedly, most of what I've cited
here is from the African American expe
rience, but other authors, for example,
Gerry Milnes in Play of a Fiddle, attest to

jo.

the cross-cultural environment
musicians in West Virginia.

among

a whole, I think there is enough
both
circumstantial and direct,
evidence,

Taken as

for

me

to

conclude that the pairing

of

the fiddle and banjo was not uncommon
throughout the 19th century. How much

is needed? That will be differ
ent for each person and those steeped in
academia may require more "proof" than

evidence

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I,

but the number

criticism

is

of

words devoted

disproportionate

to

differ
would be

to the

ence in proof requirements. It
more prudent to say that we know it was
done; we don't know how it sounded.
Christian Wig

�He recorded

at the end of the cylinder
which had begun in the last quarter
of the 19th century, and he recorded on a
disc. Edison was still issuing some cylin
ders in 1925 but by then they were were
transferring the music from disc mas
ters. By the 1920s Edison was recording
directly to discs and issuing the music as
both 78 rpm discs and, in smaller quanti
ties, as Blue Amberol Cylinders.

era

My apparent quibbles about grammar
were meant to be a door to the bigger ques
tions about music and music history. For
instance my remark about apostrophes
had more significance than the scolding
school teacher stance for which it was mis
taken due to my clumsy presentation. The

missing apostrophe in "Highlanders Fare
well" is connected to some fascinating
music history. As many of us remember,
Emmett Lundy introduced one of the two
renditions he recorded (for the Library of
in 1941)
with a story connect
tune
to
this
a
Scots
ing
Highlander bid
As such
farewell
to
his
sweetheart.
ding

Congress

would be "Highlander's Farewell.
a fragment of a
mag
nificent 10-part Scottish strathspey entitled
"The Highlanders' Farewell to Ireland."
The apostrophe in this case refers to the
entire regiment. The tune was published in
1781 in Alexander McGlashan's Collection,
and several times in the 19th century. It's
played often in its full glory in Cape Bret
on, Nova Scotia. Parts of the original tune,
slightly transformed, make up the fourpart Irish reel "Farewell to Ireland," which
the title

"In fact this tune is

legendary County Meath fiddler Frank
Higgins recorded for Regal Zonophone
just a few years before Lundy recorded his
version on the other side of the Atlantic.
The statement that "Highlanders Farewell
"
was "probably at least fairly common in
tire
O'

the early days of the Galax, Virginia area"
example of what I meant by "specula

is an

tion." Another example is the question of
whether The Wounded Hoosier is related
to the Irish air "The Wounded Hussar." The
titles certainly sound similar but the melo
dies of these two tunes are unrelated. The
Wounded Hussar is a popular melody that
has been recorded many times under that
name or as "Captain O' Kane," named for
the 17thcentury Antrim warrior known as
Slasher O'Kane. The melody of "The Wan
dering Hoosier" is derived from the well

known Irish air, "The Blackbird," a tune
long associated with both fiddle and harp
in both set dance and slow air versions. It's
also a much loved song, a political allego
ry of many verses in which the blackbird
represents none other than Prince Charles

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Edward Stewart himself. This tune is a sib
ling of the melody that Edden Hammons
played as "Queen of The Earth and Child
of The Skies." Sam Bayard has
its use as

Again

documented

burial march in Pennsylvania.
apologize to all I offended and

a
I

also to Mary Z. Cox, in whose CD review
I also failed to find the
appropriate words
and tone.

Jody Stecher

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

can be justly described as a master musi
cian for his instrumental playing (on all the

instruments) and particularly

string band

for his singing.

has made

a

In all of

those 43 years, Jody

very modest living solely by

playing and teaching music, with

an

even

less lucrative extra through his writing for

number of musical journals.
I
oppose the conceit of folklorists

a

and

other authorities who shrug off the expres
sions of those not born to their music. In

stead I take the view that any musical form
is a cultural language that can be learned,

brilliantly so, by the non-na
and this Jody has done in spades. No
better testimonial to this ability has ever

sometimes
tive

been furnished than one

I

heard from an

pedigreed) musician
at a 1977 festival after a Jody performance
of old-time music: "That little bald-headed
sonofabitch can sure sing."
old Missouri

(read:

Hank Bradley
Seattle, Washington

�Letter from the Editor
member of the generation of old-time musicians who were introduced to the Old-Time
Herald as children or teenagers (the latter, in my case), I owe much of my understanding of
this music and its history to the body of work that the magazine has established in its first twenty
years. The contributions that Alice Gerrard, the magazine's founder, and Gail Gillespie, Editor in
Chief since 2003, make and have made, both as scholars and as musicians, enrich the contempo
rary world of old-time music immeasurably.

As

a

After five years, dozens of issues of the magazine, countless all-nighters spent editing, and far
too many festival hours spent running the sales booth rather than playing music, Gail has decid
ed to retire from the Old-Time Herald. The role of an editor is largely played behind the scenes, so
oftentimes readers may not know a whole lot about the person who orchestrates the magazine.
On the occasion of Gail's retirement from the Old-Time Herald, allow me to introduce her to those
of you who may not know her personally.
Gail Gillespie is, of course, an old-time musician

who plays just about
every instrument you can think of. She is head-spinningly knowledgeable about old-time music.
If you need to know the Buckle Busters' children's dogs' shoe sizes, I suggest that you consult
Gail. During all these years that she's been editing the magazine, she and her husband Dwight
Rogers have also been tireless supporters of local music here in Central North Carolina, organiz
ing jam sessions, spreading the word about area events, and coaxing shy musicians past their
reticence. Dwight and Gail have two great daughters, Amy and Nora, and a granddaughter, Coralee Rogers- Vickers, who is perhaps the cutest child ever to be bragged on by a doting Mamaw
and Papaw.
and

a

great one

at that,

The Old-Time Herald staff would like to express our gratitude to Gail for her
as

outstanding work

editor of this magazine.

Another person who deserves a great deal of credit for the OTH's longevity and success is
Executive Director Katherine Meehan, whose expert management has kept us afloat in a time
when many larger magazines are giving up the ghost a real feat. Katherine too is leaving the
Herald after years of dedicated work. Her legacy is an organizational infrastructure so sturdy and
efficient that it's hard to believe old-time musicians have been within a mile of it. Thank you,
Katherine, for your great stewardship.

Upon Gail's retirement, I've slid over into the editorial chair. I am honored that Gail and Alice
have tapped me to continue their work (and am glad that they'll still be close at hand!), and I'm
delighted and lucky to have as my colleagues Artistic Director Steve Terrill, and Ruth Eckles, our
brand-new Business Manager. I hope that readers of the Old-Time Herald will also continue to
help guide it, by sharing your thoughts about the music in general and the magazine in particu
lar whenever you take a notion. The best ways to reach me are by email (editor@oldtimeherald.org)
and on Facebook; communications by more antiquated means, like the telephone (919-419-1800)
and MySpace, will also find their way to me. Please keep us up to date on old-time doings in
your area, and don't hesitate to share ideas about what you'd like to see featured in this maga
zine. It's like the Cofer Brothers say: When you get a good thing, shove it along.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Sarah Bryan

�The California Banjo

Gathering
October 17-19, 2008
Doubletree Hotel
Sacramento, CA
Featuring:
Mike

Clarke

Seeger

Buehling
Sammy Shelor
Peggy Seeger
Tim Weed

Buddy Wachter
Mick
Bill

Moloney

Keith

Gordy Ohliger

Iffim

sessions

Luthiers

Collectors

Concert
Open to the Public
Oct. 19, 2 to 5 p.m.

^|Pre-register

or

Information

vuww.thebanjoman.com
(209)352-5190

/j

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�tions will be made use of, (3) anticipated
research outcomes (e.g., print publica
tions, audio /video documentaries, tune
transcriptions, lesson plans, public per
formances, Web-based resources), (4) the

length of time needed for the project (one
month minimum, three months maxi
mum), and (5) preferred dates of resi
dence. Also required are three letters of

recommendation from colleagues famil

with applicant's work. For graduate
degree candidates, the recommendations
must include those of the professor di
recting the applicant's research and the
iar

department chair. Applicants

are

respon

sible for contacting all persons providing

recommendations. For information about
Berea's Sound Archives and other tradi
tional music collections, see www.berea.
edu

hutchinslibrary specialcollections
specialsound.asp. Proposals or inquires
should be sent to: Harry Rice, Special
Collections &amp; Archives, Berea College,
Berea, KY 40404, harry_rice@berea.edu.
The Charlotte (NC) Folk Society has
been holding its jams and concerts at the

Central Piedmont Community College
campus for twenty-six years, but this
fall will be moving to a new and bigger
venue at the Great Aunt Stella Center,
a former church downtown with a 400seat sanctuary, ample parking, and great
The Folk Society's events,

acoustics.

which are family-friendly, open to the
public, and free (donations are always
appreciated), are made possible in part
through a Cultural Project Grant from
the Arts and Science Council, and the
Grassroots Program of the North Caroli
na Arts Council. Visit www.folksociety.
org for this fall's concert schedule.

Artists and Recordings
Bob

Bovee and Gail Heil will be
at the Rochester
(MN)

performing
Public

Library on October

11;

National

Music Museum in Vermillion, SD, on
Oct. 17; Crosscurrents in Kansas City,
MO, Oct. 18; Great Plains Bluegrass and
Old Time Music Association concert
and fiddle workshop in Omaha, NE, on
October 25; "Kids in the Rotunda" at

Overture Center in Madison, WI, on
November 15; Neenah (WI) Public Library

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

on

November

23;

Ginkgo Coffeehouse in

MN, on Dec. 4; Rhein River Arts
Center in New Ulm, MN, Dec. 6.
St. Paul,

Serenaders

(Madison,

WI).

Neo-Tradi-

tional Band: Special Ed and the Short Bus

(Richmond, VA); La Vivelle (Kensington,
Windy City Clock Jobbers (Chi
cago, IL); Poor Taters (Athens, WV); Vin
MD);

Congratulations

egar Creek Constituency (Lancaster, PA).

Contest winners at this year's Appala
chian String Band Music Festival (Cliff
top, WV), include the following. Fiddle:
Erynn Marshall (Gibsons, British Co
lumbia); Rayna Gellert (Lexington, KY);
Chance McCoy (Greenville, WV); Emily
Schaad (Boone, NC); Christina Wheeler,
(New York, NY). Youth Fiddle: Isaac Ak
ers (Chapel Hill, NC); Tessa Dillon (St.
Albans, WV); William Brauneis (Wash
ington, DC). Senior Fiddle: Walt Koken
(Avondale, PA); Jimmy McCown (Hardy,
KY); H. O. Jenkins (Dobson, NC). Banjo:
Tim Bing (Huntington, WV); Bob Smaku
la (Elkins, WV); Jim Holland (Athens, AL);
Chad Ashworth (Nitro, WV); Cathy Fink

(Kensington, MD). Youth Banjo: Corbin
Hayslett (Amherst, VA); Daniel Rothwell
(Smyrna, TN); Silas Akers (Chapel Hill,

NC). Senior Banjo: Jimmy McCown (Har
dy, KY); Reed Martin (Cabin John, MD);
Marvin Gaster (Sanford, NC). Traditional
Band:

New

Mules

(Bloomington,

IN);

Red State Ramblers (Lexington, KY); Or

pheus Supertones (Avondale, PA); Uncle
Henry's Favorites (Crozet, VA); Magnolia

Best Original Song: Special Ed and the
Short Bus (Richmond, VA). Best Original
Tune: Windy City Clock Jobbers (Chica

go, IL). Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 15 and
under: Rebecca Molaro (Asheville, NC);
Alice Jamison (Asheville, NC); Zoe Norris (Asheville, NC). Old-Time Fiat-Foot

Dance, 16-40: Becky Hill (Nashville,

Josephine Stewart (Charlottesville,

MI);
VA);

Anna Carter (Minneapolis, MN). OldTime Fiat-Foot Dance, 41-59: Ira Bern
stein (Asheville, NC); Andy Edmonstone
(Rosewell, GA); Jay Bland (Kennesaw,
GA). Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 60 and
older: Thomas Maupin (Murfreesboro,
TN); Daniel Butner (Winston-Salem, NC);
Mary Butner (Winston-Salem, NC).
After last year's Clifftop, we neglected
to

announce contest winners

Our

apologies

and

belated

in the OTH.

congratula

tions to the winners of the 2007 contests,
who were as follows. Fiddle: Mike Bry
ant (Harriman, TN);

Stephanie Coleman

(Durham, NC); Mark Simos (Watertown,
Chance
MA);
McCoy
(Martinsburg,
WV); Darin Gentry (Brevard, NC). Youth
Fiddle: Meade Rickter (Sugar Grove,
NC); Jordan Rast (Lancaster, PA); Riannon Fowler (Scott Depot, WV). Senior
Fiddle: Jim Cauthen (Birmingham, AL);
Benton Flippen (Mount Airy, NC); Walt
Koken (Avondale, PA). Banjo: Adam
Hurt, (Winston-Salem, NC); Brien Fain
(Stuart, VA); Hilarie Burhans (Athens,
OH); Frank Evans (Toronto, Canada);
Bob Smakula (Elkins, WV). Youth Banjo:
Frank Evans (Toronto, Canada); Corbin

Hayslett (Amherst,

VA); Cole

Holland

(Athens, AL). Senior Banjo: Walt Koken
(Avondale, PA); Jim McKown (Hardy,
KY); Mac Benford (Trumansburg, NY).
Traditional Band: New Dixie Entertain
ers (Harriman, TN); Orpheus Super
tones (Avondale, PA); Haywire Gang
(Natural Bridge, VA); Clef Twangers
(Watertown, MA); Cork Burners (Clay,

Neo-Traditional Band: Old-Time
Liberation Front (Lancaster, PA); Hound
Dog Hill (Churchville, VA); Pan-Demonium (Greensboro, NC); Common Taters
AL).

(Fayetteville, WV); Bull City Six Shoot

NC). Best Original Song:
VA).
Dog Hill (Churchville,
Best Original Tune: Bull City Six Shoot
ers (Durham, NC). Old-Time Fiat-Foot
Dance, 13 and under: Molly McGuigan
ers (Durham,

Hound

�Haley McGuigan (Hel
lam, PA); Rebecca Molaro (Asheville,
NC). Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 14-59:
(Hellam,

Ira

PA);

Bernstein (Asheville, NC); Josephine
(Charlottesville, VA); Ryan

Stewart

Clover-Owens (Ithaca, NY). Old-Time
Fiat-Foot Dance, 60 and over: Thomas
Maupin (Murfreesboro, TN); Margaret
Hale (Ferrum, VA); Mary Butner (Win
ston-Salem, NC).
At this summer's Old Fiddler's Con
vention in Galax, VA, the following art
ists took home awards in the old-time
categories. Best Ail-Around Performer:
Old-Time
WV).
Jake Krack (Orma,
Fiddle: Jake Krack (Orma, WV); Nancy
James Burris
Sluys (Westfield, NC);
(Galax, VA); Helen White (Mouth Of
Wilson, VA); Crystal Blevins (White
Top, VA); Richard Bowman (Ararat,
VA); Paul Muller (Ashland, VA); Kilby

Spencer (Crumpler, NC); Bill Birchfield

TN); Nick McMil
(Roan Mountain,
lian (Mount Airy, NC). Youth Old-Time
Fiddle: Adam Larkey (Erwin, TN); Car
son Peters (Piney Flat, TN); Kali Taylor
VA); Sarah Seymour
NC); Erin Hall (Radford, VA).
Clawhammer Banjo: Trish Fore (Low

(Barren
(Lenoir,

Springs,

NC); Alan Rutherford (Indepen
dence, VA); Sarah Garbade (Mouth of
Wilson, VA); Marianne Kovatch (Morgantown, WV); Mac Traynham (Wil
lis, VA); Adam Hurt (Winston-Salem,
VA); Marvin Gaster (Sanford, NC); Tina
Gap,

Steffey (Jefferson,
(Mount Airy,
VA).

Youth

NC);

NC); Kelly Breiding
Brien Fain (Stuart,

Clawhammer Banjo:

Jared

Boyd (Laurel Fork, VA); Ben Hill (Galax,
VA); Chris Johnson (Sparta, NC); Chris
topher Cason (Elkin, NC); Andre Lamb
(Sparta, NC). Dulcimer: Tim Thornton
(Shawsville, VA); Gin Burris (Hillsville,
Don Newhauser (Charlestown,
VA);
IN); Kimberly Dean (Roanoke, VA); Dot
Christenson (Lexington, KY); Katie Cannaday

(Calloway,

(Independence,

Nancy Tuggle
David Parks (Dub

VA);

VA);

lin, VA); Sheri

Sigmon (Rocky Mount,
Massie (Wytheville, VA). Au
Ronnie Burroughs (Keysville,

VA); Stan

toharp:

Fredrick Douglas (Pickens, SC);
David Kirby (Peachbottom, PA); Glenna
Anderson (Christiansburg, VA); Rhoda
Kemp (Roanoke, VA); Tony Mabe (Wal
nut Cove, NC); Jimmy Handy (Wool
wine, VA); Ros Wynn Roberts (Hillsville,
VA); Jeannie Crane (Lewisburg, WV);
Edward Anderson (Christiansburg, VA).
VA);

Guitar: Steve Lewis (Todd, NC); Wayne

Henderson

(Mouth of Wilson, VA);
Scott Fore (Radford, VA); Brandon Da

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

VA); Mark Unruh (Hockes
Will
sin, DE);
Jones (Cana, VA); Henry
Boitnott (Roanoke, VA); Austin Mikeal
(Lansing, NC); Mike Brown (Woodlawn,
VA); Buddy Dunlap (Wardensville, WV).
Folk Song: Leslie Dunbar (Eagle Rock,
VA); Heather Mabe (Walnut Cove, NC);
Karen Yates (Morehead, KY); Trevor
McKenzie (Rural Retreat, VA); Albert

vis (Galax,

(Marion, VA); Tyler Wil
liams (Johnson City, TN); Kim Dunham
(Saltville, VA); Tiffany McNeely (Cor
nelius, NC); Ashley Jones (Cana, VA);
Kim Allison (Johnson City, TN). Dance:

Blackburn

Kenny Monahan (Rural Retreat, VA); Ju
lie Shephard (Greenville, VA); Mitchell
Robinson (Galax, VA); Michael Sexton
(Hillsville, VA); John Perry (Indepen

dence, VA); Marsha Todd (Mount Airy,
NC); Amanda Fithan (Pulaski, VA); G. W
Gibson (Abingdon, VA); Cherie Quinn
(Ferrum, VA); Angela Hale (Elk Creek,
VA). Old-Time Bands: Cabin Creek Boys
(White Top, VA); Whoopin' Holler String
Band (Orma, WV); Blue Ridge Moun
tain Ramblers (Low Gap, NC); Southern

Pride (Galax, VA); Ubiquitones (Greens

boro, NC); Grayson Highlands Band
(Jefferson, NC); Pilot Mountain Bobcats
(Westfield, NC); Backstep (Mount Airy,
NC); Slate Mountain Ramblers (Ararat,

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Mac

Sara

Creepers (Morgantown,
Virginia Carolina Band (Indepen
dence, VA); Smokey Valley Boys (Mount
Airy, NC); Zephyr Lightning Bolts (State
Road, NC); Roan Mountain Hilltoppers

Garbade (Mouth of Wilson, VA); Cody
Jackson (Austinville, VA). Autoharp: Jo
Ann Redd (Galax, VA); Glenna Ander

Ramblers (Galax, VA); Sweetbriar Jam
(Lenoir, NC); Wide Open (Laurel Fork,
VA); Old-Time Tradition (Laurel Fork,

VA);

VA);

Virginia

WV);

(Roan Mountain, TN); Dry Hill Drag
gers (Ferrum, VA). Youth Band: Kickin'
Grass (Hillsville, VA); Chestnut Creek

VA). For full contest results, visit www.

oldfiddlersconvention.com.
At the 42nd Annual Old Time Fid
dlers'

and

Bluegrass

Convention

in

Fries, VA, Billy W. Bourne of Fries won
the Henry Whitter Award, and was

named Best All-Around Performer.
Winners in the old-time music competi

Traynham

(Willis,

VA);

H.

son (Christiansburg, VA); Edward An
derson (Christiansburg, VA); Bill Birch
field (Roan Mountain, TN); Stan Spen
cer (Stuart). Folk Song: Jessie Lovell
(Fries,

VA);

Lloyd

Elizabeth Vaughan (Fries,
Richardson (Warrensville,

NC); Audrey Sams (Dublin, VA); Erica
Weiss (Cambridge, MA). Dance (16 and
over): Kenny Monahan (Ivanhoe, VA);

Justin Jackson (Austinville, VA); Shane
Bond (Fries, VA); John Perry (Indepen
dence, VA); Susan Aske (Colfax, NC).
Old-Time Bands: Pilot Mountain Bob

Widner

cats (Westfield, NC); Grayson County
Ramblers (Mouth of Wilson, VA); Cabin
Creek Boys (Independence, VA); Buf
falo Mountain Boomers (Willis, VA);
Old Number 6 (Independence). Youth
Clawhammer Banjo: Jarrett Boyd (Lau
rel Fork, VA); Miguel Villarreal (Glade
Valley, NC). Youth Guitar: Joseph Bur
cham (Ashburn, VA); Monica Santos

Nancy Sluys (Westfield, NC); Justin
Jackson (Austinville, VA). Old-Time
Allen Rutherford
Banjo:
(Indepen

(Sparta, NC); Chip Moyer (Sparta, NC);
Jesse Allen (Laurel Fork, VA). Youth
Old-Time Fiddle: Veronica Randolph
(Front Royal, VA); Timothy Hale (Gal
ax, VA); Kitty Amaral (Elk Creek, VA);

tions include the following. Guitar: Ger
ald Anderson (Troutdale, VA); Stanley

(Hillsville, VA); Gary Lowery
(Marion, VA); Carl P. Brickley (Saltville,
VA); Eddie Day (Rural Hall, NC). Old
Time Fiddle: Brian Grimm (Indepen
dence, VA); Adrian Powell (Lexington,
Bowman (Ararat, VA);
KY); Richard

dence, VA); Trish Fore (Lowgap, NC);

Sara Bobbitt (Woodlawn, VA); Abbey
(Elk Creek, VA). Youth Dance
(16 and under): Lindsey Jackson (Aust

Hensley

inville, VA); Stephanie Gibson (Galax,
VA); Rose Randolph (Front Royal, VA);
Dawson McKay (Crockett, VA); Steven
Dunford (Fries, VA).
This
Historic Happy Val
year's
Old-time
Fiddlers' Convention
ley
took place over Labor Day weekend
in Caldwell County, NC. Contest win
ners were as follows. Old-Time Banjo:
Chris Miller; Mary Dickerson; Michael
Fox. Old-Time Fiddle: A. G. Edmonds;
Steve Kruger; Amanda Wright. Dance:
Amanda Wright; Mary Dickerson;
Dane Summers. Autoharp: Doug Pratt;
Gail Deal; Mary Umbarger. Mandolin:
Daniel Bishop; David Wiseman; Chris
Laws. Guitar: Steve Lewis; Elia Lau
ren; Clarence Green. Bluegrass Fiddle:
Jeff Michael; Danielle Bishop; Lucas
Pasley. Bluegrass Banjo: Steve Lewis;
Eric Ellis; Perry Woodie. Twin Fiddles:
Nathan Taylor and Emily Shaad; Mike
Fox and Richard

Shook; Jeanne Green

Marshall Goers. Old-Time Band:
Tap Water; New River Rock Skippers;
Smokey Valley Boys. Bluegrass Band:
The Williams Family; Carolina Drive;
and

High Country Drive.

�Final Notes

Northwest musician George Chudacoff
passed away early Monday morning on
August 25, 2008, at his home in Vancou
ver, Washington. George was well known
and highly

especially
bluegrass and flat-picking circles
Portland

respected,

Vancouver

area.

He

in

the

of the

taught

guitar, banjo, and mandolin throughout

Northwest

the

and

the annual Puget

at

Sound Guitar Workshop.
George was 59 years old and had battled
cancer for two and

a

half years. He out

lived his prognosis by about a year and a
half from the time he was diagnosed.
George recorded a CD entitled Unfin
ished Business, which features talented
as Carol Harley and Lau
Misty River, Wayne Hen
derson, Helen White, and others. The CD
represents George's thirty-year career of
playing, recording, and teaching music
in the Pacific Northwest.
The magazine Victory Music Review re
cently reviewed the highly praised CD, and

musicians such
ra

Quigley

of

available for purchase via CD Baby.
Even though the Northwest music com
munity has lost a wonderful musician,
it is

his music will

continue

to live!
Jim Portillo

a

medic with the 29th Infantry Division.

He served in the
and

invasion

of

Normandy

continued fighting until the end

of

the European Campaign, then returned
home to Lick Creek where he resumed
working the family farm. For much of his
life Hick lived as

a

bachelor and farmed

land owned by his family.
During his
time as a farmer he produced wheat, bar
ley, corn, and tobacco, ran a dairy opera
tion, and operated a sawmill at his home
to meet local building demands. He con
tinued to farm and run the sawmill until
his retirement sometime in the 1970s. In
1977 he married Sue Taylor Atkins, who

Community Hospital

in

Marion, Virginia.

brothers. He is survived by his wife, Sue
Atkins Edmonds of Atkins, Virginia; two
step-sons, John Atkins and Randy At
kins, both of Atkins, Virginia; three step

daughters, Jeffie Campbell and husband
of Marion, Virginia, Cindy Sneed
and husband John of Spring, Texas, and
Anne Reedy and husband Jack of Hous
ton, Texas; one sister-in-law, Juanita Ed
monds, of Christiansburg, Virginia; three

Bill

step-grandchildren

and three

step-great

Hick was laid to rest at
grandchildren.
Chatham Hill Cemetery in Chatham Hill,
The cemetery is secluded and
Virginia.
lies on a small knoll overlooking Rich Val
ley, offering peaceful, pastoral views
the surrounding countryside.

of

Born in 1913, Hick lived nearly his en
community of Lick Creek in
Smyth County. During World War II he
was drafted into the Army and became
tire life in the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

miss him greatly!

Shay Garriock

Fiddler and fiddle maker Clifford Hardesty, 87, of Canal Lewisville in Coshoc

ton County, Ohio, died on July 8th. Born
in 1921, he was one of the nine children

fiddling. He began playing in his late teen
years and was almost entirely influenced
by notable fiddler Beverly Thomson and
his two older brothers, all of whom lived
on a farm less than one mile from Hick.
He was also influenced by early country
recordings, his favorites being those of
Fiddling John Carson. Hick was later in
fluenced by some bluegrass and modern

of John (a coalminer and farmer) and
Florence Hardesty of Coshocton County.
He began to play music at the age of ten,
when he borrowed his older brother's
fiddle and taught himself to play "Red

a

country artists, but throughout his
dling career he maintained a pure
time noting and bowing style. His
was truly old-sounding, rhythmic,

fid

old-

style
and

had many unique varia
lively,
tions of standard tunes that were won
derful, crafted through time by his sub

He was preceded in death by his parents,
Charles and Alice Edmonds, and four

learned from this very kind man. The
chance will not come again, and will we

guitarist, singer, and storyteller.
Hick was best known for his old-time

is

and

Virginia fiddler Boyd Wilbert "Hick" Ed
monds died on June 24th at Smyth County

on, living only in our memories, imagi
nation, and music. We are delighted
that Hick's fiddling will be carried forth,
and are grateful to have befriended and

he

sistence upbringing and long agrarian
life with few influences from outside his
community. Hick was a tenacious fiddler
too, being able to saw out tunes up until
a vear before his death.
Hick has received several awards for his
fiddle playing the most notable of these
being in 1998 when he won the second
place in the Senior and fourth in the Over
all Old-Time Fiddle categories at the Ap
palachian Stringband Festival in Clifftop,
West Virginia. Hick's fiddle playing was
almost always accompanied by his wife
Sue on guitar, and their duet playing has
become much admired around Smyth
County.

More recently they gained the

appreciation
far and

of

old-time music listeners

wide with the release of their CD

Whoopee Liza Jane in 2003.
Hick was one of the last
in

followed

Valley,"

by

Round the Mountain" and "Can

"Coming
I

Sleep in

Your Barn Tonight, Mister?" As a young
man he farmed and worked hauling coal
and lime with his '39 pickup truck. He

later went into the fuel business, operat
ing a service station in West Lafayette. In

1973 he began teaching himself to build
fiddles, of which he built scores over the
course of the next thirty-five years. Hard
esty appears on multiple recordings (in
cluding Clifford Hardesty: Ohio's Master
Fiddler), and played and demonstrated at
many festivals throughout the nation. He
was a teacher and mentor to many musi

cians in Ohio and beyond.

Folk and jazz musician Artie Traum died
on July 20th. Traum was brought up in the

young man was exposed
Greenwich
Village folk and
thriving

Bronx, and as
to the

a

blues club scene in the 1960s. With his
brother Happy, Traum performed at the
1969 Newport Folk Festival, and toured

widely

surviving "old-

Virginia and the Southern
Appalachian region. Fortunately, quite
a few
of the younger musicians have
been lucky enough to experience Hick's
fiddling and life, perhaps most notably
within just the last few years when all
but a few of the old-timers have passed
timers"

River

in the

early 1970s. In the '70s and

'80s, Artie Traum was part of the Upstate
New York folk musicians gathering known
as

the

Woodstock

Mountains

Review.

Throughout his life, Traum was a prolific
performer, recording artist, and producer,

who also wrote instructional books, pro
duced documentaries, and took part in a
great many other creative endeavors

�Banjo
News Letter
THE

5

STRING BANJO MAGAZINE

Call or Write
for a FREE

Sample Copy
Profiles, Tablature, Reviews

MP3s at

www.banjonews.com

PO Box

Banjo Newsletter
3418, Annapolis, MD 21403
(800) 759-7425

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�music; some only want to review reissues
of classics; some know a lot more about
blues or Cajun than others; and so on.

The review process goes thusly. CDs are
sent in to the OTH. Decisions are made as
to what to review and what not to review
based on a number of criteria. Does it gen
erally fit into the genre of traditional music?
(Believe it or not, the OTH gets a lot of stuff
that doesn't by any stretch of the imagi
nation have any connection to traditional
music). Is it an important reissue? Does
it

seem,

good CD
or any CD by

to be

listening,

unknown musician

by an
a

at first

known musician who

a

is out there

work

ing?
space available in the magazine?
So, from the very beginning of the process
decisions are being made about what to
review and what not to review. These de
cisions can be to some extent subjective.
Then the reviewer is chosen depending
Is

on his or her availability,
i.e., "Here's

of the genre

and
a

knowledge
banjo /fiddle

recording. Let's give it to Sam Reviewer
since he plays both and is knowledgeable

about the genre." Beyond that, it comes
back in, is edited, and goes to press.
Here is an excerpt from the guidelines
the OTH sends out to reviewers.

very conscious of how angry he was, and
at the same time scrambling (unsuccess
fully) to remember what the review said
as he brought up point after point. After
I
got home a few days later, I looked up
the review, and was surprised to see that
in general it was a very positive review.
There were a few things the reviewer took

issue with, but they appeared

However

minor.

this

is

cally positive the review may be, are in
clined to remember mainly the things the
reviewer doesn't like or takes issue with.
I have
talked over the years with many
about
the issue of reviews and how
people
they

should

fer widely.

It

be

handled.

should print anonymous

need to have

dif

Opinions

has been suggested

that we

reviews. As one

magazine that prints anonymous reviews

puts it: "[Reviews are] contributed individ
ually by a selection of our various reviewers
[named at the beginning of the reviews sec
tion] cowering under the cloak of collective
Here are

anonymity."

couple of samples

a

from that magazine's reviews section:
utterly forgettable
even the participation

We believe that reviewers

to me to be

the thing
artists, no matter how criti

I've found

and

can't

a

to develop their voices. Revieioers
have opinions and the old-time music com
munity needs to accept that. If you record

salvage

this

pile

of [name]

of crap

chance

The title song
have heard

something and put it out there, it will be
reviezved. Artists won't always like what a
revieiver says, or they may

review--

in a

obligation,
views, is to
as

be

Our

as a

magazine with critical re

be as

straightfonvard and honest
't

subscribe

to the

notion

that if you can't say something good, you
shouldn't say anything at all. We subscribe
to the

notion that honest criticism will help

set

musical standard and maintain

a

the

integrity and credibility of the OTH. Otherwise it just becomes a fanzine.

Over the years, artists have taken issue
with reviewers in different ways. Some
times they write in and say so, other times
they resort to name-calling on the Inter
net. I once had someone corner me and
bring up a review that had been printed
at least a couple of years before. He had

been carrying around a lot of anger for all
that time at what he felt was an unfair re
view, and he was shaking his finger in my
face, saying things like, "You're the editor,
you should be more responsible for what
people say," and a lot more about the per
ceived unfairness of the review itself. I was

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

anything

[the] first track on

a

I

CD

improve.

always had a policy of not
anonymous reviews, though

The OTH has

disappointed

or they may be ecstatic.

possible. We don

that fails

bad as

is as

printing
that might be one way

to go.

suggested that we shouldn't
that reviews are the an
do reviews at all
tithesis of what the old-time music com
It

has been

munity

is all

about

and that we should

just list releases, or a brief description of
the kind of music they contain. However,

think people really like the rbview section
Surveys have indicated that
the reviews are one of the more popular
features of the magazine, keeping people in
and there's a
touch with what's out there
lot out there. What with the availability of
I

of the OTH.

digital home recording, recording a CD is
within most people's reach.
It has been suggested that when we get
a
negative review, we also print
review of the same recording.

a

positive
It's

also

been suggested that people stop whining
and grow up. It's a never-ending subject,
and I personally don't think it can be re
solved to everyone's satisfaction. But it is
definitely worth talking about and keep
ing the door open to discussion

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

GOAT GLANDS
AND STRING BANDS:
DR. JOHN BRINKLEY
by David Holt

do the Carter family, the Nazis,
the FCC, the AMA, 12 million De

Whatpression dollars, goat glands, coun

try music radio, rock and roll, and 16,000 pairs
of gentlemen's testicles have in common? The

answer

is Dr. John R.

Brinkley.
One day in the fall of 1918, in Milford, Kan
sas, a forty-six-year-old farmer named Bill
Stitts worth came to see Dr. John Brinkley with
a problem.
Stittsworth said he had lost his
vigor and didn't have any "lead in his pencil,
no powder in his pistol." The farmer looked
out the window, and watching the frisky bil
ly goats, said, "Too bad I don't have a billy
goat's glands." He said, "Doctor, I want you
to transplant them into me."
A few days later Stittsworth returned to the
clinic ready for the operation. Dr. Brinkley
entered the operating room with his mask,
rubber gloves, white gown, and a small tray
with two goat testicles in the center. After the
man was anesthetized, the Doctor cut a small
plug from the fresh goat gonads and inserted
it in a hole made in the man's testicles.
When the farmer healed up he reported that
"his pencil was full of lead... frisky again."
Nine months later, Stittsworth and his wife
were thrilled to have a son, whom they ap

propriately named Billy.

�The Doctor is in
No one was more

delighted than

Dr.

realize he had a po
Brinkley. Quick
tential financial bonanza, Brinkley hired
to

publicist and built

a

an

ad

campaign

around "Billy," his wondrous new opera
tion, and the great doctor himself.
But Dr. Brinkley wasn't a real doctor.
He had been brought up poor in the
mountains of Jackson County, North Car

olina, near Cullowhee. Born July 8, 1885,
went to live with his Aunt Sally when
his parents died. He left home, married a
local girl named Sally Wike, and became
he

a

snake-oil huckster in

a

traveling medi

cine show.
It

was in the medicine show that Brin

kley realized the value music had in get
ting and holding an audience. As musi
cians playing traditional mountain music

drew in the crowd, Brinkley would play
the part of a doctor and make the pitch
for his alcohol-based remedy. It was
here Brinkley learned his smooth patter,
which folks said could charm a wagon
out of ditch.
After the medicine

show folded, he
South Carolina,
where he opened Electro Medical Doc
tors. For $25 he and his partner James
Crawford injected patients' rear ends
with colored water. It was guaranteed to

moved

cure

Greenville,

to

everything from gout

to

cancer, plus

improve patients' sex lives. After several
months of taking in wads of cash and
racking up unpaid debt around Green
ville, they skipped town.
The pair traveled to Memphis, where
Brinkley met and married Minerva Jones,

a real physician. Brinkley
spoil the wedding festivi
ties by telling her he was still married to

the daughter of

didn't want

to

Sally Wike.

It wasn't
long before the Greenville,
South Carolina, sheriff captured him and
Crawford and threw the two of them

Greenville County jail. With bor
rowed money they were able to pay off
their debts and jump back into helping
mankind with their medical miracles.
in the

John Brinkley had always wanted to be
real doctor, but he didn't want to bother
with all that pesky education, so in 1915
he attended a diploma mill called the
a

Kansas City Eclectic School of Medicine.

medical doctor in

Kansas, Arkansas, Texas, and Connecti
cut. In fact, he began referring to himself

simply

as

"Doctor."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Historical

a

Society

diploma that allowed

State

a

him to call himself

Kansas

For $150 he got

�Medicine

the

in

early

1900s was just

recover from its deregula
tion under Andrew Jackson's presidency
(1829-1837). Basically, any citizen could
to

beginning

practice medicine without fear of repri
sal. Although allopathic or "Western sci
entific medicine" was beginning to take
hold, there were many other schools of
thought. Eclectic medicine, homeopathy,
naturopathy made use of botanical
remedies. There was very little regula
tion by the government. America was
and

"No

dice,"

said

Mr.

Fritz.

weeping
dollars

Mrs.

to

Brinkley

"Two hundred

a

more

operation." She was able to
garnish wages until the bill was paid, but
or no

Mr. Fritz

unfortunately

said after the

op

eration he was "much worse than before
Brinkley worked on him."
If you wanted the very best, you could
pay $5,000 and get human glands sup
plied by prisoners on death row.

natural

breeding ground for quacks,
especially since many of the "scientif
ic" doctors were no more able to cure a
disease than the naturopaths. (Andrew
a

Jackson likely died from an overdose of

calomel [mercurous chloride] and sugar

of lead [lead acetate], prescriptions given
to him by his allopathic doctor.)

Moving

Milford

to

After his medical degree was pur
chased in Kansas City, Brinkley's wife
Minnie read in the newspaper that a
doctor was needed in Milford, Kansas,
a small town near the center of the state.
They moved there just as the 1918 flu
pandemic was breaking out. In one of
his few non-self-serving acts, he drove
all over the county doing his best to help
the
It

ford

victims.

was after
that

he

year of practice in Mil
performed the first goat

a

gland operation.
Times were hard, but many men weren't.
The Doctor's high-priced goat gland place
bos worked just often enough to get people
talking. The word began to spread. Prob

lem customers were bullied or paid off.

Articles appeared in newspapers and
started coming from all over the
country to Milford, Kansas, to drop their
men

pants and pay big bucks to get as frisky
as a goat again. Soon he was making half
a

Fritz hoped he'd give him the operation,
maybe not even charge him at all.

million dollars

a

year. He became the

Midas of Milford, with

a

16-room hospital

that could not keep up with the demand.
$750 was a lot of money in 1918 (about

Turn Your Radio On

Brinkley's

publicity

with

campaign

Billy caught the attention of Harry Chan
dler, publisher of the Los Angeles Times.
He brought Brinkley out to California for

operation for some of his staff (and
possibly himself), as well as a few of his
wealthy friends. While he was in Los
Angeles, Chandler showed Brinkley his
the

new radio station, KHJ, one of the first
in the nation. Doctor realized radio and
his big con were made for each other. He
could put his message into almost every
home in the Midwest.
Radio was new. There was no standard
format or even advertising, but more
importantly to Brinkley, there was al
most no regulation.
When Brinkley returned to Milford he
built a studio and a hundred-foot radio
tower on the grounds of the hospital, and
started KFKB, "Kansas First, Kansas Best,
the sunshine station in the heart of the
nation." Much of the programming was
Doctor's talk about medical troubles.
"Don't let your doctor two-dollar you
to death
come to Dr. Brinkley
take
of our

advantage
I

compound operation

can cure you the same as

Hopkins

I

did Ezra

Possum Point, Missouri."

of

"Bedroom problems? Tired by nine PM?
Old get up and go just got up and went?
Remember a man is only as old as his
glands. And
He

Dr.

Brinkley

is

here to help."

would croon into the microphone,

"Observe

the

rooster

and

the

capon.

stead of putting in a plug of goat gland
into the man's testicles he simply put in
a sliver of
goat testicle in the man's scro
tum and sewed it back up. It was faster,
created less infection, and seemed to

overlook tire $200 shortfall. Brinkley
seemed like such a nice Christian man that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Brinkley refined the operation. Now in

Society

mortgaged his farm for $550, and hoped
that Brinkley, seeing that he had put up ev
erything he had to raise the money, would

tects them, but the capon eats the food
the hens scratch up. He will even sit on
their eggs. Do you want to be a capon or
a rooster?"

Historical

The rooster will fight and work for his
flock. He stands guard over them, pro

Kansas State

$7,000 in today's currency), but it was
a small
price to pay to make a man a
man again. If you couldn't afford the
full operation you could get injections
or elixirs to drink, most of which were
colored salt water.
A Nebraska farmer named Joseph Fritz

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Minnie and

Dr. John Brinkley preparing

a

goat gland operation

at their

hospital

in

Milford, Kansas.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have the same rejuvenating placebo ef
fect on many of his patients.
Typically,
the body of the patient would absorb the
goat glands as foreign matter, but infec
tion and sometimes death were trouble
some side effects.
Behind the hospital was a herd of
Toggenberg goats that the patient could
select from, or if the patient had a partic
ularly frisky goat at home he could bring
it along. Many people did travel
halfway
across the country with their own espe
cially horny goats.
Doctor had a low-key, friendly voice and
could free-associate for hours over the radio:
"My friends, note the difference between the
stallion and the gelding. The stallion stands
erect, neck arched, mane flowing, chomp

ing the bit, stamping the ground,
the female, while the

seeking
gelding stands around

half-asleep, cowardly, listless. Men, don't let
this

happen

to

you."

There were very few radio stations in
the entire country at that time. The radio
was something new and miraculous in
itself, a voice out of the sky. Rural folks
around the country sat around the radio
all

evening listening

to

the Doctor and

Midwestern
musicians like Fiddlin' Bob Larkin and
hillbilly

music

on

KFKB.

Cowboy Slim Rinehart kept the rural lis
teners tuned in.

was voted the most popu
station in America. Dr. Brinkley

In 1929 KFKB

lar radio

was making money hand over fist, and
he spent it just as quickly. The town of
Milford loved him. He bought a limou
sine, jewelry, a yacht, even an airplane.
He bought new uniforms for his Milford
Goats baseball team, paved the streets
of Milford, built a park, and built a new
post office to handle the 3,000 letters he
received daily.

Medical Question Box

colored water. He told the radio audience
what drugs to buy from pharmacists
who were in on the scam. The pharma
cists kicked back one dollar to Brinkley
on each jar sold (at about six times nor
mal retail) and kept the rest of the money.
The pharmacists loved it.

Don't Mess with Doctor
Doctor had his enemies. One of the
most determined was Morris Fishbein,
editor of the Journal of the American Medi
cal Association. The AMA was a growing

but not very powerful organization and
had no real authority except a bully pul
pit. Fishbein was determined to bring
Brinkley down even if it took years.

Fishbein wanted Brinkley's medical li
cense revoked for "organized charlatan
ism." In 1930 the Kansas City Star pub
lished the names of five people who had
died at Brinkley's hospital since the fall
of 1928. His signature was on their death
certificates. Later that year it was dis
covered that actually 42 people had died
there. Some hadn't even been sick when
they arrived. His license was revoked.
At the same time, the Federal Radio

Com

mission withdrew his license for KFKB.
A lesser man might have folded. But
when Doctor's balls were to the wall,
what did he do? He ran for Governor of
the state of Kansas in 1930. His slogan
was, "Let's pasture goats on the statehouse lawn."
There were only five weeks until the
election and he would have to run as a
write-in candidate. But Brinkley had a
few tricks up his sleeve. In his private

plane he visited every county in the state.
It was the first time an
airplane had been
used in a political campaign.
A big crowd would be waiting. Some
one would look up and shout, "There he

plane would circle overhead.
be met by a marching
band. Women in nurses' outfits presented
lollipops and balloons to the children.
At a rally he would have preachers and
musicians entertain the crowd and cheer
leaders would lead a chant to teach the
spelling of Brinkley's name. He drew
huge crowds for the spectacle.
His opponents were boring bureaucratic
men who began to worry they would lose
the election. With three days to go they
is," and his

started an extremely popular
radio segment called "Medical
Box." Listeners would write
questions about their medical
Doctor would prescribe the

In 1928 he

half-hour

Question
in

asking
problems.

right combination of his special elixirs.
"Dear Doctor," said one young lady,
"When female cramps get a grip on me, I
can't do nothing. Can you help?"
"You'll need to take Tonics #27 and #52
for four weeks. It will cure you right up.

But oh, my friends, you must help me.
Remember your letters asking advice
must be accompanied by two dollars."
Doctor had 1,500 drug stores carrying
his tonics, which were made mostly of

The plane

would

passed legislation that said any other
spelling besides "J. R. Brinkley" would in
validate the ballot. As it turned out, Doc
tor won the popular vote in Kansas and
three counties in Oklahoma, but 50,000

�Society
Historical
State

Kansas

In his

1930 bid

for

Governor of Kansas, Brinkley used his private plane

votes were disqualified for incorrect spell
ing. Dr. Brinkley lost his bid for governor.
The time had come to leave Kansas.

to

fly to even/ county in the state. It was the first use of an airplane in

came the most powerful station the world

million-watt XERA.
The station was so powerful that it would

has ever known

electrocute birds
Not in Kansas Anymore

pliances

To make sure no competition sprang up,
Doctor completely demolished his hos
pital in Milford, leaving a pile of rubble.
He moved his entire operation to Del
Rio, Texas. Del Rio was right on the bor
der with Mexico, and at the time Mexico
was angry with the US government for
not letting it have any frequencies on the
radio dial. They invited Brinkley to build
as

powerful

a

station

as he

would like on

the Mexican side of the border, and blast

back into America. And so in 1932, Dr.
Brinkley built 50,000-watt radio station
it

XER in Villa

Acuna, Mexico.

In 1935 it

be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

spark,

in

turn

mid-flight, make ap
on car

headlights,

make the hair on your arms stand up. If
you had a telephone in Del Rio all you

could hear on it was XERA. Bedsprings
made a perfect antenna so the sounds of
XERA played through your dreams. You
would be lying in your bed and up from
your springs you'd hear, "How many of
you suffer from indigestion, bloating,
belching, and embarrassing gas?"
Old cowboys remembered when they
were mending fences around Del Rio they
could poke

a

tin can onto one of the barbs

of the fence and pick up XERA.

you were
riding along on your horse you could hold
a foot-long
piece of barbed wire in your
If

a

political contest.

teeth and pick up XERA in your head.

The station reached
everywhere in
America, into Canada, across the North
Pole, and into Russia. The KGB used the
station to teach English to its spies. In fact,
when the ionosphere and cloud cover

were just right you could hear XERA any

where in the world, including Australia
and Indonesia.
Country Music was the Lure
Brinkley
mentalists,

programmed
storytellers,

gelists, politicians, and
music. He could afford
in the

business

Brothers,

the

to Del
Pickard

clairvoyants,

preachers, evan
hours of country
to bring the best
Rio: the Delmore
Family, Lonnie

Glosson, the Callahan Brothers, Gene
Autry, Jimmie Rogers, Red Foley, Patsy

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Montana,

J.

E.

Mainer's

Mountaineers,

and from his home town of Sylva, North

Carolina, banjoist Samantha Bumgarner
and fiddler Harry Cagle. He was even
able to lure away from Poor Valley, Vir
ginia, the first family of country music,
the Carter Family.

years passed.

The Circle is Broken
It was the steady income and the warm
winters that got the Carter family all the
way down to Del Rio. The Carter Fam
ily was famous in the Southeast but not
nationally. They had never been able to

make
the

a

good living from recording. Once

Depression

hit, record sales

complete

stalled. But in Del Rio they would each
get $75 a week and not have to deal with
travel, audiences, fans, or agents. Because
ly

of the

unbelievable reach

of XERA,

they

would amass thousands of new fans and
Sara Carter would find her long-lost love.
The Carter Family had become one of
the biggest names in early country music
in the South with songs like "Wildwood
Flower," "Keep on the Sunny Side," and
"Will the Circle Be Unbroken." Sara's
compelling voice was at the heart of their

sound. Maybelle was the guitar genius
and harmony singer. A. P. wrote or found
their songs and sang bass in the trio.
A. P. and Sara were married, but it was
a
strange relationship. A. P. was quiet,
and

prone to take off walking
down the railroad tracks and not come
back for days or even a month at a time,
looking for new songs.
While husband A. P. was wandering off
in the Virginia hills, Sara fell in love with
A. P.'s first cousin, Coy Bayes. Coy was
quirky,

family got to Cali
fornia, Sara didn't even know where Coy
was. And because he hadn't received any
letters, Coy had decided that Sara had
lost interest in him.
Sara and A. P. divorced, but continued
recording and working together. Seven
By the time the Bayes

In 1938 Dr. Brinkley invited A. P., Sara,
and Maybelle Carter to play on XERA.
The problem was that Sara and A. P.'s re

lationship was

to

to

hear back from him, she stopped writing.

don't care."

A. P. I'll do as I durn well
don't need his permission."
Patsy: "A. P., Sara says she will be hap
py to sing an old favorite tonight."
I

N ormaily Sara would just smg her songs
without ever saying a word to the radio

audience. But on this still desert night in
1939, feeling particularly lonesome, she
stepped up to the mic in the XERA studio
and said she was dedicating this song to
Coy Bayes, somewhere out West.

It

had

been eight years since she had seen

or

heard from him.

T'would been better for us both had we never
In this wide and wicked world ever met.

For tlie pleasures we've both seen together
I am sure love we'll never
forget.
Oh, I'm thinking tonight of my blue eyes

Who

is

sailing far over

the seas.

Oh, I'm thinking tonight of him only

And

in

New Mexico, then finally settled in Indi
an Valley, California, an old mining area
250 miles north of San Francisco, exactly
in the middle of nowhere.
Sara wrote him many heartfelt letters
but got no answer. Coy's parents had
been hiding her letters. When she didn't

I

"Tell

Sara,

please.

I

wonder if he ever thinks of me.

Oh, you told me once dear that you loved me

little Poor Valley, Virginia, in 1931, the
kind of scandal for which somebody was

moved out West. They first moved

tonight.

Patsy would turn to Sara and say, "A.
P. would like
you to sing whatever selec
tion you'd like this evening, honey."

for days at a time when A. P. was gone.
Of course, when A. P. found out, he
was hurt and furious. This was a painful,

likely to be killed.
Coy's father couldn't allow it to destroy
his family. He packed up the entire Bayes
clan, including 32-year-old
Coy, and

wouldn't

between them while they were all three
standing in the same room.
A. P. would say something like, "Patsy,
tell Sara she can sing whatever she wants

tall, fun-loving, and 14 years younger
than A. P. Sara and Coy would sneak off

embarrassing, and dangerous scandal

so bad that they

talk to each other. Country singer Patsy
Montana had to deliver the messages

And you said tliat
But

a

zue never

would part.

link in tlie drain has been broken

Leaving me with

a

sad and aching heart.

XERA was so powerful

it

reached all

the way into that little California town
in the Sierra Nevadas, 1,700 miles away.
As luck would have it, Coy happened to
be

listening that night

in 1939 to the Good

Neighbor Get-Together show and heard
Sara say she was dedicating "Think
ing Tonight of My Blue Eyes" to him.
He turned to his mother and said, "I'm
going to go get Sara." His mother said,
"Well, Coy, I guess you better go."

�He traveled all the way to Del Rio, Tex
married her the next week. Sara

as, and

had found her lost love.

Musicians Were Listening
All Over the Country
was

It

the

musicians
tuning

in

mid-1930s

and

budding

remote communities

in to XERA and

were

soaking up the

music. Grandpa Jones in Ohio used to
put a crystal set in a big washtub to am
plify the sound. Everyone in the family
would hang his head over the metal tub
to listen to J. E. Mainer's Mountaineers
and Slim Rinehart.
Young Chet Atkins listened in Tennessee
and learned all the Carter Family songs.

Seven-year-old Johnny Cash fell
with

in love

Carter's

ten-year-old June
(Years later they got married in

voice.

fever.)
Doc Watson in Deep Gap, North Carolina,
sat in front of his radio hearing Smith's
Garage Band play "Beaumont Rag" on
a

the fiddle every night while he worked it
at home on the guitar. Doc heard the

out

Delmore Brothers play "Big River Blues,"
which he reworked into his signature fin
ger-picking song "Deep River Blues."
For the first time, the entire nation could
hear folk and country music. Its popular

ity began to spread to every corner of the
land. Bill Malone says in Country Music
USA, "In the dissemination of country

music

throughout the United States,
nothing was of more importance than the
powerful Mexican border stations. No
one can ever know the number of tradi
tional ballads that may have found their
way into some remote Midwestern area
solely through the means of Mexican

radio transmission, an oral process that

perpetuated the lives of these songs and
made it possible for them to be collected

by folklorists at
A

a

later date."

Six-Inch Life-Size Statue of Jesus

Early country music was the bait, but
product sales were the catch. All kinds
of things were sold over XERA beside
goat gland operations: electric bow ties,

hair dye, genuine simulated diamonds,
tomato plants, live baby chicks, "Certi
fied Radioactive Water," a six-inch "lifesize" statue of Jesus along with an auto

graphed photo and a wind-up John the
Baptist doll. It was the birth of modern

commercial radio.

Dr. Brinkley was making more than a
million dollars a year, while the average
doctor made $3,000.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ashe
Ray
courtesy

Johnnie Boy, Minnie, and Doctor.
In the heyday in Del Rio, he had 50 sec
retaries to handle his mail, and an army

of assistant quacks. He and his business
partner Mrs. Brinkley built a mansion and
had Galapagos turtles, peacocks, and pen
guins wandering the grounds. There was
a pipe
organ with an organist hired away
from Grauman's Chinese Theater in Hol

lywood. The driveway

to their

was the widest paved road

in

mansion

Del Rio.

He had 12 Cadillacs that were color-coor
dinated with his home, all red one year, all
green the next. They even bought a Cadil
lac for their son, Johnnie Boy, who was still

adolescent. Johnnie Boy had anything he
wanted, even his own bodyguards. People
in Del Rio and around North Carolina re
membered Johnnie as "incredibly spoiled."
There were three gigantic yachts anchored
in Galveston (one was 172 feet long with
a crew of 36), several
airplanes, a 13-carat
diamond on His right hand and a 10-carat
an

on his left, each as big as a quarter.
Jeanette Carter once said that Doctor

in

"He came

with

down the stairs

in

a

white suit

monkey on his shoulder, its tail
wrapped around his neck. We didn't see
a

stuff like that in Poor Valley, Virginia."
The Brinkleys would spend part of the
summer sailing around the world on their
yacht or flying back to Western North Caro
lina to visit friends near the old homeplace.

They bought a second home near East La
Porte, North Carolina, so they could stay
for extended visits. Ray Ashe from Jackson

County remembers visiting the Brinkley at
their summer home. "Everybody around
there thought he was really something.
Once he drove up in a red Cadillac with
'Brinkley' embossed all around it. He was
always nice to us. You would have liked
him. He came to visit my grandmother,
whom he wrote to regularly. He said he
loved her like she was Iris own granny."
This was the high-water mark for the

Brinkleys. But in the late 1930s, Doc
tor made two drastic mistakes. He al
lowed Nazi sympathizers to broadcast
on XERA, which raised the hackles of

vited the Carter family to his mansion. On a
wall near the entrance was a large photo of
Doctor with a record-breaking 750-pound

he

fish, titled "Tuna Fish and Self."

him

the

American government; and worse,
decided to sue Dr. Fishbein for calling
a

quack in

a

magazine article.

�Holt

David

The Brinkleys' summer home near East La Porte, NC.

The End is Coming
In 1938 Dr. Morris Fishbein wrote an
article essentially calling Dr. Brinkley a

charlatan. Foolishly, Doctor started be
lieving his own publicity, and decided
to sue Fishbein for libel and $250,000 in
damages. The trial was to take place in
Del Rio. How could he lose on home turf?
But two things really seemed to trouble
the jury:

Brinkley's

admission

that

he

had been injecting people with colored
water instead of medicine, and the claim
in the advertisements that the goat gland

operation was

a

true graft which, under

oath, Doctor admitted it was not.
The jury found that there was no libel,
which translated that Brinkley could be
called a charlatan as Fishbein had charged.
In the past, Doctor had been able to
stop most damage suits by using threats,
Pinkerton detectives, stalling, or just
paying out of court. But by now he had
more than a million and a half dollars in

judgments against him.
Everything began to unravel as he was
besieged from every side. In 1941 Doctor
had several heart attacks.
Ironically, it was the last mailing of print
ed ads for the goat gland operation that
moved the Postal Service finally to charge
him with mail fraud, after 20 years. Doc
tor was scheduled to appear in the postal
fraud trial in the spring of 1942, but died

shortly before, at the age of 56.
Dr. John Brinkley left quite a legacy as
the most successful charlatan in Ameri

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

can history. He helped in the develop
ment of radio by giving regulators some
thing to regulate. He created the modern
radio format of commercials, talk, and
popular music. He revolutionized po

litical

campaigning by introducing air

planes, sound trucks, and radio.
Perhaps most importantly, his border
radio stations spread early country and
mountain music throughout the United
States, setting the stage for coma try music's
great popularity in the late '40s and early
'50s, and the folk music boom of the '60s.
Brinkley left a million-watt radio sta

a number of fine books that in
clude information on Dr. Brinkley:

There are

The

Roguish

can

North Carolina, area.

Most Dangerous
Pursued Him,

Who

by Pope Brock,

World of Dr.

Brinkley

Gerald Carson, Rienhart, 1960

across the country and opened the door
to grittier rock and roll. As Wolfman said,

David Holt is a Grammy Award-winning tra
ditional musician who lives in the Asheville,

Man

Crown Publishers, 2008

2002

dues to rhythm and blues."
Wolfman Jack talked a young David
Holt into buying an autographed pic
ture of Jesus and 100 live baby chicks
for $3.99, and introduced this young
boy to the sound of Elmore James and
Muddy Waters, who sang "I Just Want
to Make Love to You." But that is a
whole other story

the

and the Age of Flimflam,

tion dormant on the border of Mexico. It
was taken over in the early 1960s by Bob
Smith (AKA Wolfman Jack) who did the
same thing for black music that Brinkley
did for mountain music. Wolfman spread
the sound of black rhythm and blues all

"We pay our

America's

Charlatan:
Huckster,

Border

Radio by Gene Fowler and Bill

Crawford,

Will

by

You

University

of Texas

Press,

Miss Me When I'm Gone: The

Carter Family &amp; Their Legacy

Music

by Mark

in

Ameri

Zwonitzer with

Charles Hirshberg, Simon and Schus
ter,

2002

Country Music, USA by Bill Malone,
University of Texas Press, 1968
For this article I have interviewed Ray
and Ruth Ashe, Jeanette Carter, Doc Wat

son, Wade Mainer, and Lonnie Glosson.

�New, Used 6 Vintage Instruments

5-String 6 4-String Banjos
Vintage Gibson 6 Martin Guitars
Mandolins, Ukuleles. Harp-Guitars,
Resonator 6 Hawaiian Guitars

A A A A A A A AAA A AA A A A A A A A A A A A A

INTERMOUNTAIN

GUITAR

712 East

&amp;

100

BANJO

South

Salt Lake City. UT 84102
tel. 801.322.4682

fax 801.355.4023

guitarandbanjo@earthlink.net
www.guitarandbanjo.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

NOW THERE'S AN EASIER WAY TO TRACK DOWN

r

It's not always easy finding

those Old-Time Music releases independently

produced by devoted musicians. That's why The Old-Time Music Home PplM
opened an online CD store where you can get more of those hard-t6-find;J^P
and the musicians can sell their music without paying a hefty
recordings
commission. Isn't that the way the Old-Time Music community should work?

THE INDEPENDENT
OLD-TIME MUSIC STORE
AT WWW.OLDTIMEMUSIC.COM

I

�Vintage

Instruments
Since 1974

Specialists in Acoustic
Fretted Instruments
New &amp; Old
Experts in sales &amp;
appraisals of vintage
Martin and Gibson
Guitars &amp; Mandolins
New instruments by
C.F. Martin ฀National
Gold-Tone and others
See our web site for our
full inventory of fine

vintage guitars,
mandolins, banjos, ukes,
&amp; fiddles
We also carry a broad
range of accessories

straps, strings, tuners,
Calton cases, etc.
Fred Oster &amp; Catherine Jacobs
507 South Broad Street

Philadelphia, PA 19147

215-545-1100

www.vintage-instruments.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Reese
Bryan

State

Mississippi
Copyright
© 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.
House in Jackson.

�OLD, NEW, AND REAL:

THE CASE OF MISSISSIPPI'S SENATOR GEORGE CECIL MCLEOD
By Chris Goertzen
The following article is excerpted and condensed from Southern Fiddlers and Fiddle Contests,
forthcoming from the University Press of Mississippi.

opportunities; one local logger and fid

the

with him. Camp Shelby, southeast

twentieth century,

the

changes were gradual. The oldest fiddlers
active both in the middle of the twentieth
century and today have lived through
these transformations, sometimes help
ing change come about, at other times
resenting and resisting it. I will illustrate
how fiddlers' lives and activities have
changed in the last half-century through
a case
study of a fiddler who started fid
dling in an environment firmly set in the
past. He is George Cecil McLeod, a farm
er and former Mississippi state senator.
Three McLeod brothers migrated from
the Isle of Skye to North Carolina about
1800; then two of them relocated to Mis

dler brought tunes from Canada home
of

Hattiesburg, housed military profes
sionals and draftees from throughout
the nation; a violin repairman of Ger
man extraction trained there during

World War II; and the nearby Gulf
Coast has always been cosmopolitan.
McLeod's father didn't fiddle, but fid
dlers were far from hard to find. McLeod
recalls

that

"a

of

high percentage

the

folks, either their daddy, or their granddaddy, or their uncle, or their neighbor,
played the fiddle. In their younger days,

they would have gone visiting [to a fid
dler's home], or they knew that their
daddy had, or their parents had
very
few people hadn't been exposed to fid
dling." This echoes another broad factor
in the history of music in the rural South:
fiddling remained more central in musi

sissippi. George Cecil represents the fifth
generation of McLeods in the state. His
family background thus echoes several
broad trends in Southern demography
and in the history of American fiddling.
Many Scots immigrated to rural areas of
the Southern colonies and later Southern

cal life here longer than elsewhere in the
United States, for a mix of demographic
and financial reasons.

United States, and so their musical taste
strongly influenced the formation of
composite Southern musical taste. Their

the company of the two most skilled fid
dlers in the area, his uncle and especially

distinctive

and

rhythmically

complex

fiddling was especially apt for mixing
with blacks' performance practices over
the history of blackface minstrelsy in the
South. Second, many Southerners inter
ested in traditional music issued from a
broad trend in settlement in the South:

families of Southerners gradually spread
west across the South (very quickly in
the McLeods' case) and often have been
in the South for generations. They iden
tify themselves as Southerners more than
as members of any ethnic group.
McLeod was born in 1927, just outside
of Leakesville, in the pineywoods of
Southeast Mississippi. But any roman
tic equating of "rural" with "isolated"
would be hasty and simplistic, even
for the time when McLeod was a child.
Workers in lumber camps moved regu
larly from logged-out areas to newer

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

up on Saturday night to dance.
They'd clear the furniture out of one room
and the hall, and Uncle M. L. would play,
with some of the children accompanying
him, some on guitar, and some of the girls
would sometimes play piano [or] accor
dion. They danced in the bedroom and in

gather

the hall connecting."

Fiddlers back then typically started play
ing later in life than the best fiddlers of
today. By the time McLeod finally owned
a fiddle, his head was full of fiddle tunes.
He was in the tenth grade. His school
band director, a violinist, gave McLeod
lessons for about six months until the
director was drafted. When McLeod fin-

Young George Cecil regularly sought out

distant neighbor named Jode Denmark,
who was born in 1891 into a family in
which many of the men fiddled. I found
a

a common
pattern among older
fiddlers: they had more than One mentor A
close to home and knew fiddlers both J
within and outside of their family.
McLeod's main teacher, Den
mark, "had a little farm

this to be

3

maybe worked some turpentine
and logged wood some. He re
paired instruments a good bit."
Even before he made many treks
to hear Denmark play, McLeod
was regularly exposed to fiddling:
"Uncle M. L. Griffin, who married
my daddy's sister, they had eight
was.
children, all of them older than
They were all talented musically, and my
uncle played the fiddle. And that's where
the young folks up in Leakesville would
'

I

Goertzen

cally during

as both music and
practice changed dramati

fiddling

Chris

Although
as social

�ished high school, he attended Mississip
pi State University for a year, then went
into the Navy for sixteen months. He re
turned in the fall of 1946 and soon had a
semester of violin lessons from the head
of the music department at Mississippi
State College for Women, about twenty
miles east of Mississippi State University,
where he was enrolled. He summarizes
that he has "had a few violin lessons, but
not enough to hurt [my] fiddling."

McLeod played "Sugar Foot Rag" on his

first date with the woman he

would mar

"When I met her, had just learned it,
it was fresh on my mind. I heard that
tune one night [on the radio], when I was
out in the pickup. And it appealed to me.
And I got to humming it. The next morn
ing got up, and while Mama was cook
ing breakfast learned it. And it's always
been one that I liked to play." This sort
I

ry.

and

playing some. And then we had the first
bluegrass festival near Chatom [Alabama]
here in '71. So from that point on, I began
to hear fiddlers more."
Thus, the interval between decline and
revival of fiddling in this part of the Deep
South was remarkably brief, and not so
very long ago. Indeed, when Mr. McLeod
took up the fiddle again, some of the
same forums for performance were there
as earlier (though some of these have

gradually declined since). The use of
fiddling at political rallies was one such
forum: McLeod's opponents didn't spon

sor fiddle music, but he offered it himself,
with telling moments of hesitation:
Even when

the early
through
especially
'70s, I hadn't even thought about the ef

I

I

learning process, that is, inexact rep
lication in which a remembered outline
is fleshed out anew by individuals who
therefore had to command and exercise
considerable creative ability, was more
common then than now. In contrast, to
day's ubiquitous audio recorder allows
fiddlers to emulate one another with as
much precision as the learner's technical
of

running, you go through the newspaper
offices, radio stations, TV stations, and
the local printer to print up stuff to ad
vertise, to get people to remember you to
I'd played in all these
vote for you.
rural counties. I'd gone and played at
the

cakewalks,

knew

in Jackson County [on the coast]. Folks
will ridicule you if you do." [But] folks in
Jackson County was countiy folks [even
if they had moved to the city]. So I carried
7
my fiddle
got up, introduced myself,
and told them I wanted to play a little bit

time that fid
coincidentally
was
aside
in popular
dling
being pushed
consciousness. The biographical factor
was simple: the McLeods had entered

and just slid on into the tune. I didn't
play but just [a few moments] and there
was

the dairy business, a grueling occupation
leaving little time for recreation. The audi

lot].

got

in the

dairy

And I didn't play hard
business in '61
fiddle
from
the time I started dairy
ly any

ing until I got into the campaign [for state
wasn't in
senator] in '67. Consequently,
real good playing form then, but then af
I

I found out it worked
in politics, I got
chance to go to more functions and have
more reason to play some, I went back to

a

a

and

dozen couples
the

crowd

was

up

down there

in

out cards, and

Jackson
I

square

clapping

and keeping time for them before
And the next week
the tune.

I
I

very seldom came across

low that played the fiddle.
It

striking both that McLeod's

is

quit
was

County passing

somebody that hadn't heard of some

fel
con

stituents in rural Greene County thought
that the presumably more cosmopolitan
residents of a county on the coast would
look down on fiddle music, and that those
constituents were at least temporarily

wrong. These residents of Greene Coun
ty apparently were self-conscious about
their own enjoyment of a slice of culture

ter

that was

a

though

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

half

dancing,

ence for fiddling was shrinking anyway,

I

played the fiddle. [Before giving

I

speech, I'd] go and play the fiddle.
And the folks around here were saying;
"Now, don't go and play that thing down

the same

[a

meetings,
Everybody

a

was still part of local daily life during
McLeod's young adulthood in the early
1950s. He performed at square dances
and other functions all over the area. He
had less time to fiddle in the early 1960s,

played right smart

PTA

plays,

and dances, and at home.

McLeod's hearing a fiddle tune on the
radio in 1950 fit Southern trends more
than national
ones. Indeed, fiddling

owing to the inroads of rock music among
the young and a concerted effort by the
media to make public entertainment more
streamlined and thus profitable through
economies of scale. But McLeod returned
to fiddling. He described his performing
hiatus as follows: "Through the '50s, I

in

fect that the fiddle would have when I was
campaigning, because it was just some
But when you're
thing I liked to do.

ability permits.

at

'67 and

ran for office in

I

the '70s,

rural

explicitly old-fashioned by then,

it

had been right at the center of

entertainment when many of them

were children. That McLeod's disagree
ment with their prediction of urban dis
dain for fiddling was on target was ow
ing to his keener sense of demography;
however, the difference in taste that they
wrongly thought was in place around

certainly has materialized since.
can't imagine fiddling being thought
anything better than quaint at a politi
cal rally in Jackson County now. McLeod
still plays at rallies in Greene County oc
casionally, although he feels that the po
litical rally as an institution has declined
considerably. After all, we no longer need
to assemble to learn what candidates
think. But small traditional political ral
lies still occur in Greene County, and or
ganizers welcome McLeod's fiddling out
of respect for him.
I attended
one held June 13, 2003, on a
farm in the county. My impression on ar
riving was of pickup truck after pickup
1970

I

truck, and of powerful odors of barbe
cue. Local candidates spoke briefly, as
did the Republican gubernatorial candi
date in a whirlwind stop. He shook all

hands, praised George Cecil's fiddling,
gave a quick speech in which recollec
tions of hunting segued into references
to Greene County and then to promises
concerning tort reform and other themes
certain to resonate, and was gone. Had
he heard the

fiddling? Had anyone? The
was Republican stalwart and
former state senator McLeod who was
playing seemed the only reason fiddling
was even symbolically valuable.
McLeod's fiddling is more appreciated
these days at another annual political af
fair, the reunion of former state senators
in Jackson. In one room, most of the so
fact that

it

cializing and politicking goes on, and we
eventually eat a traditional catfish din
ner. In a neighboring smaller room, the
caterers lay out enormous chilled prawns
all

and oysters on the half shell (our tax dol
lars at work), and the musicians set up

shop. A few of the attending present and
former senators and members of their

families pay some degree of attention to
the music now and again, and most can
not avoid hearing it at some point, since
patronizing the restroom entails passing
within a few feet of us. But the end result
is not a concert for these politicians but
rather a contribution to a down-home at
mosphere. What's in it for the musicians?
paid nothing (apart from access
pricey snacks), and it's not all that
easy to hear one another through the roil
of hearty conversation. For us, the value
of the occasion is in the energy of the situWe're

to the

�ation and our own take on the symbolism

occasion: our music is a welcome
social lubricant among a crowd of people
who are really accomplishing something.
The something that they are doing while
at the party seems like
everyday schmooz
ing, but this chatter includes power bro
kers influencing one another on matters
of the

of

great consequence

to

our

time

in

the

In

the

state

of this

McLeod's running for office and serv
ing in the Senate during the 1970s led to
a modest but real amount of national ex
posure for fiim through a pair of perfor
mances on the Grand Ole Opry and also
to his

being part of Mississippi's delega
tion to the Festival of American Folklife.
He played at the Opry at the invitation of
Bill Monroe. His friendsJrip with Monroe
resulted from the fortuitous conjunction
of the arrival of bluegrass festivals in Mis
sissippi with the process of running for of
fice. When McLeod was arranging for ra
dio spots during his campaign, he had the

choose what music would
run behind his short broadcast speech
and found that his favorite tune available
at one station was by Monroe. "And that

opportunity

to

[of 1971] we had the first bluegrass
festival I'd ever gone to." After McLeod
got better acquainted with Monroe at the
series of festivals over a half-dozen years,
Monroe invited him to perform as his
guest at the Grand Ole Opry in 1979.
fall

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

up to Washington.
the featured state at

was

It

one they had, and each year

they'd feature a state.
They took up
about 150 Mississippians of various
arts and crafts

[including

a] chair maker

Greene County
7
got
go as a fiddler, mainly because I was
the Senate at the time, and they was

from up here
to

in

to

trying

funding-works.

in

cater

to

the

legislature

know how

you

to

get

that kind

of

don't know if it helped them for
in there I didn't control the
leg

I

me to be

islature

or anything like that. But they
had good intentions. And I enjoyed go
ing, so I'm not complaining about that.

capital,

audience hearing fiddling
because it was increasingly considered
part of American history.
tions

was

Festival of American Folklife.

the eighth

Jackson, his playing territory expanded
to fit that city: "I played in a number
of occasions up there. I carried the fid
dle with me, and every now and then,

there'd be something that came up. I've
played for the historical society, some
old ladies having some sort of a meet
ing. Or play for school young' uns, there
were just a number of things. I played
with the Jackson Symphony, at their
Brown Bag Concert." Such occasions for
performance point out that fiddling was
becoming a music for which much of its
audience was polarized by age, the old
and the very young, but with both sec

went

we

'74,

Mississippi

state. The

essence of the meeting is a heady combi
nation of nostalgia with very real power.
This particular music satisfies because the
crowd, although not uniformly elderly,
does center on men in their seventies who
remember when fiddle music was the dai
ly fare for political occasions.
We'll return now to McLeod's time as
a member of the Senate, the
early 1970s.
Since doing this job caused him to spend

considerable

An earlier trip that resulted from McLeod's
visibility as a fiddler and state senator was
:o the Festival of American Folklife:

But they carried

..as

a

a
fellow up therefrom
Meridian, Mississippi]

[near

Chunky

square dance caller. And

I

didn't

even know that they was carrying a fel
low up there as a square dance caller...

Coming back [from a concession stand, I
saw that] fellow on stage, and he was try
ing to get people lined up to square dance.
They had just skadoodles of people. I don't
know if anybody had

count.

a

It

was differ

ent things going on all over the mall, and a
crowd of folks had been there and listened to
our music. And [the caller] was trying [to

arrange

a

dance for

bunch of college kids
stage: He could see as

group including]

a

I
I

a

came around the

came around that

I

knew something about it. He immediately
called on me to lead [the dancers]
So we got out there. He was

figures. Of course
ing

to

calling

the kids [had] seen

the

danc

fiddle music, [but] they didn't know

anything but skipping. They'd skip from
here plumb over to that couch over yonder
per skip, and just absolutely mess a dance
up because of the long skip.

Everybody can

skip that far, you know. It's

of

a

a

dance step. But they saw

't

skip instead
it

done

in a

movie; I remember seeing the same movie.
And it was some Tin-Pan-Alley [director's]
idea of a way to put emphasis on
just hozv hillbilly it was

it, to

show

And Ralph Rinzler's wife [Kate] was in
he was put
charge of the stage up there
ting on a clinic square dancing, up at the
end of the mall. And she
had seen me
calling square dance when we was play
ing for ourselves, and she asked me would
go up there and call a square dance. There
wasn't anybody up there at that stage. So
I

Mickey [Davis,

a

violist who also fiddles]

got a guitar picker, and we walked up there
[and led a very successful dance].

Thus, at this national event, McLeod
found that the little that well-intended
younger urban visitors knew about
square dancing had not come from per
sonal experience. Instead, what they
knew about the main kind of dance asso
ciated with older-style fiddling had been
filtered through the media, and thus styl
ized to exaggerate rustic associations.
Of course, many Americans in the babyboom generation likely including much
of the festival audience
learned some

dancing in physical education
classes. I remember this well: a gym with
its characteristic palette of odors, mixed
attitudes on the parts of the participants,
and a scratchy variable-speed turntable
from which emanated bad renditions of
music seldom connected with the older
history of the dance, with fiddline.
McLeod still likes to teach square danc
ing and insists that it be done with as
much historical accuracy as possible.
True, this process entails his relinquish
ing his treasured role of fiddler to some
square

one else, and

it is not always easy to find
fiddler for this purpose. He does
not explain steps over the microphone
but teaches as he learned, from within
the square. He is the man in the head
couple and talks and maneuvers others
during the dance.

an apt

I witnessed
him teaching square danc
ing recently at the Two Rivers Bluegrass Festival (held in his hometown of
Leakesville), as one of the activities away
from the stage on an evening early in the

festivities. Among the participants were
a handful
of experienced dancers, avid
who
had learned fancy square
hobbyists
as
dancing
part of a club. This presented
its own problem: these dancers wished

"help" McLeod by taking over, by
teaching the modern fancy western-style
square dance.
What of other settings that called for
fiddlers or at least offered the sounds of
fiddling to the public in Greene County,
Mississippi, earlier in the century? Fid
dling on local radio ceased when rock
music arrived, then returned in a small
way with bluegrass, though that faded
too after a while. How about fiddle con
tests? McLeod played at them regularly
to

for fifty years, but their flavor continually
evolved, so his tune choices for contests

have changed
contest, held

in
in

1949, he played

response. In his first
Fruitdale, Alabama, in

"Pop Goes the Weasel"

holding his fiddle not just under his chin,
but also upside down, behind his back,
and

so forth.

That contest still retained

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

much of the feel of 1920s, but times were
changing. Later, McLeod did well in a
contest through a politically astute tune
choice: "In the playoff, I played a waltz,
and I played 'Carroll County Blues.' And
I was
in territory close to where 'Carroll
County Blues' supposedly emerged."
When McLeod, following his teacher's
advice, began using "Ragtime Annie" in
contests, he discovered that other tradi
tional Mississippi fiddlers found his ver
sion suspect, in part because a flourish
with which he opened the high strain
was deemed unusual but even more so
because of the inclusion of Jode Den
mark's third strain (one that McLeod
hadn't often heard elsewhere, because it
is found almost exclusively in Texas ver
sions). Yes, that strain does appear in the
1922 commercial recording by Texan Eck
Robertson, and that may well be why it
was in the version McLeod learned, that
record
of Jode Denmark. Robertson's
ings were sold all over the United States

during the 1920s and 1930s but that sub
sequently became much harder to find.
This efflorescence was during Denmark's
youth. Denmark's repertoire was eclec
tic, just as Eck Robertson's had been, and
iust as McLeod's would be.
Today, with a lower geographical density
of fiddlers and with fiddlers meeting and
hearing each other at contests or festivals
more often than in each other's homes,
more of a purist attitude has emerged,
one not very tolerant of heterogeneity of

repertoire or style, despite admiring the
eclectic repertoires of fiddlers of the past.
Contests, in order to be coherent, need to
be divided into categories, and these are
often defined by style. Thus, many con
tests in the Southeast place fiddlers in ei
ther the old-time category or that of bluegrass. Elsewhere in the country, a contest
may have old-time style separated out
from the array of newer solo fiddle styles
that are centered on Texas contest style.
Such segregations by style have benefi
cial effects. By protecting styles possess
ing less "ear candv" than the contestoriented styles, these separate categories
of

competition preserve variety

of style.

since these styles are of different
vintages and appeal to performers of dif
ferent ages in some parts of the country,
the separation allows for the exposure of
a broader sweep of the history of Ameri
can fiddling during contests. McLeod
could have easily won more at contests
by having become more of a modern oldAnd

if he had sought out
old-time style self-consciously and

time purist, that is,
an

�Goertzen
Chris
of
courtesy

Sen. McLeod playing at home accompanied

by the author, Chris Goertzen.

meticulously avoided any influences of
bluegrass or of Texas fiddling. But that
would have been true neither to the let
fiddle tradition
inherited in Leakesville, Mississippi.
And his own cumulative approach to
shaping a repertoire and style strikes me
neither labored
as an unusually careful
nor precious but genuinely nuanced
mix of respect for what he learned from
his principal teacher, Jode Denmark, with
how fiddling evolved in his own life af
ter his apprenticeship years. He reflects
on his music more than many fiddlers do
but does not obsess about any aspect of
symbol or sound. It's fun, it's history, it's
ter nor to the spirit of the

he

part of him, and it's

a

way

share this

to

whole package with family, friends, and
also with strangers, who thus are more

likely to become friends.
Would McLeod pass on tunes in the
same sort of intimate environments inwhich he learned them? The simple an
swer is no, but the reasons are complex.
The chance of keeping fiddling vital
in

the family

would

and

in

the

neighborhood

some continuity in
depend
several spheres, in how daily life in rural
areas does or does not encourage extend
ed families to stay reasonably intact and
to interact regularly, to what degree fid
dling can be heard on a regular basis out
side of the home, and whether a musical
child would see fiddling as a fun choice
for

a

on

hobby.

Of George Cecil's children,

lives

at

home and

a

a

daughter

son lives very near

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

McLeod's former home. Another
child lives in Mobile, Alabama, about
an hour away, several are in Atlanta,
one teaches at Delta State (about two
hours away), and a daughter has retired
with her air force husband in Hawaii.
Since Leakesville has neither the natu
ral resources nor felicitous location that
would encourage further growth, hav
ing more children in this large family
depart than stay isn't surprising and
in fact simply reflects national demo
graphic trends. But, unsurprising or not,

by in

this doesn't help in fostering any sorts
of oral tradition within such families. In

McLeod's kids took up the
fiddle. There were so many other kinds
of music around to enjoy as they grew
up (a much wider selection than in their

fact, none of

parents' childhoods), and fiddling sym
bolized patterns of life from which they
grew away. Will an apprentice surface
outside of the family but within the com
munity, someone who will visit George
Cecil the way he visited Jode Denmark?
This hasn't happened yet.
In a sample fortnight, from September
28 through October 12 of 2002, George
Cecil McLeod fiddled in quite a vari
ety of venues. His main guitar accom
panist for nearly thirty years has been

a retired postal worker who
lives in Wiggins, about an hour's drive
from Leakesville (they met at a bluegrass festival in the mid-1970s); how
ever, McLeod often invites others to join
in. At the annual McLeod family reunion

Lee Fulcher,

�Leakesville, he, Lee, and played in a
a church
fellowship hall while
well over one hundred family members
in

I

corner of

visited with each other and filled their
plates with home cooking. Some folks
listened and some didn't, but even those
who hadn't seemed to have been paying
attention later expressed sincere grati
tude; it was clear that symbol as well as
sound had mattered.
The Pine Belt's dulcimer club invited
him to fiddle a few numbers at their

meeting in Hattiesburg and
also to join in with their group numbers
when possible. ("We play in the key of
D," we were told at this low-pressure
jam.) On the way to that event, he and
weekly

Fulcher stopped off

county hos

at the

pital and played for the ward on which
Mrs. McLeod was recuperating from
hip surgery. He and Fulcher performed
one evening at a local restaurant, and

they also competed at the state fiddle
contest held during the state fair. Last,
we three would have played during
the opening evening of a local bluegrass festival, but back-to-back tropical
storms caused the festival to be can

celed. This was an especially busy time
for McLeod as fiddler, but the venues
were representative.
McLeod continues to do his best to
continue to represent his local fiddle
tradition and considers it both an honor
and a pleasure to do so. To what degree
is his case representative? It does seem
that most of the venues in which he
now plays welcome him partly because
he is a fiddler but more because they
enjoy his charisma and wish to honor
His personal his
tory illustrates broad shifts of fiddling
in American culture, first moving from
him as an individual.

normal

entertainment
viewed

area to being

in
as

a
a

very rural

fun illustra

tion of history, then to being the stable

linchpin of a fiddle-based subculture,
the fiddle contest environment.

Chris Goertzen teaches music history and
world music at the University of Southern
Mississippi. He is the author of Fiddling
for Norway: Revival and Identity, and
coeditor of the volume of the Garland En
cyclopedia of World Music about Eu
ropean music. His new book, Southern
Fiddlers and Fiddle Contests, will be
published this November by the University
Press of Mississippi.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Section with Illegible Text

Old Time Music for the Holiday

Season

20041

12005

1

2006

I

2007

12008

Great old time gifts from the Field Recorders' Collective: CDs, DVDs or photographs. Below is just a sampling of our
CDs and DVDs, please come to visit www.fieldrecorder.com to hear sound samples and see all of our offerings. We
are now in our fifth year of producing quality and rare old time music!

order via US mail, send a check made payable to the Field Recorder's Collective to the address
below. $15 each CD, $20 each DVD PLUS $5 for US domestic priority mail. Please check our Web
site for additional discs and discounted sets. We accept Paypal and credit cards on our Web site.

To

Field Recorders' Collective,

124 Quaker Bridge Road, Croton, NY 10520

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Field

Recorders'

collective

�Reviews

ongoing documentation of Texas religious
and vernacular music he initiated. (Ray
Alden has put up a beautifully done web
site about Owens on fieldrecorder.com,
and there are additional related articles
there by Dan Foster.) Alas, however, the
original recording media and field notes

Texas Fiddle Bands:

The Bill Owens 1939 Recordings

did not survive, so we are mostly are left

with some speculation about the artists
on this disc, but we do have their music.

Marynell Young made an admirable at
tempt to determine name spellings and
tune titles, so huzzahs to her.
There is considerable historical signifi

Field Recorders' Collective FRC 409
J.

D.

A. (jack) Meyers, fiddle;

Vee

Tuller, guitar;

J.

Dillingham, banjo, vocal; Sam Welch (fiddle)

and Family; Ed Gillespie, fiddle; Colonel Ogden
and his son Jimmy; Jace Middlin (fiddle) and his
Alabama Boll Weevils

Hell Among the Yearlings
Arkansas
Durang's Hornpipe Rickett's
Soldier's
Hornpipe Eighth of January
Leather Britches
Irish
Joy /Little Fish
Washer Woman
Rustic Dance
Cattle
Traveler

Cane Break
Run Nigger Run
Billy in the Low Ground /Give the Fid
dler a Dram Heel and Toe Polka with the
Night Cap On Polka Schottische
Sally
Gooden
Patsy Mind the Baby /Cripple
Creek
The Bastard King of England
Cornhuskin' Gal
Listen to the Mocking
Bird
Rochester Schottische
Sally John
son San Antonio Rose
in the

remarkable collection is something
that veritably came out of nowhere. There
is a long saga involved with bringing
other of Bill Owens' field recordings that
This

urge you to read, at www.fieldrecorder.
com. In that narrative, Dan Foster (my
introduction to these old recordings of
I

fiddlers) describes his odyssey in
tracking down the Peter T. Bell recordings
initially, and then finding better-quality
copies. Marynell Young, Steve Green,
several others, and I were all involved at
various stages of these voyages of discov
ery. Marynell went on an alternate trail,
Texas

failing to find the original Bell disks, but
found this lovely treasure, something we
knew nothing about prior to her discov
ery. I hope at some point Marynell will
write down her part of the discovery
put on the FRC website. In short, she
found digital copies of the original discs

to

in the Cushing Collection at Texas A&amp;M
University, and made copies. These items,
contained on this CD, were recorded by
Bill Owens on an instantaneous disc re
corder that he modified in 1939, part of an

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

cance in this set, and the Bell set, as Dan
Foster discusses on the FRC site. Owens
captured some of the few audio record
ings of the older Texas fiddle music, precontest style and pre-swing. We do hear
on this CD that these two styles (now

dominant

in Texas)

made some inroads

among the group that Owens recorded,
but more about that later.
Bill

Owens

or

some of the musicians talk

and announce on some of the discs. The
set starts out with a recording session on
February 18, 1939, in or near Austin. The
as Marynell identified them,
"Uncle Jack" Meyers on fiddle,

musicians,
are

J.

A.

Vee Tuller on guitar, and

J.

D.

Dillingham

on banjo. We'll hear more about them lat
er, too. They have a very nice set of tunes

a solid
square dance band. Their
"Hell Among the Yearlings" is not the
common D tune usually associated with
that title, nor is it the tune that Ft. Worth

and are

denizen Moses Bonner recorded

for

Vic

Canebrake."
More than likely, they'd have been famil
iar with Bonner, who had been quite in
volved in fiddlers' associations in Texas.
It bears more resemblance to the "Paddy
tor in 1925, "Yearling's in the

on the Turnpike"
"The Route" group of
tunes that some call a "double tonic" be

dance music. Following these tracks is
one solo performance by Dillingham on
banjo and vocal, singing "Diamond Joe."
This is a reprise, of sorts. "Reprise?" you
ask? Yes sirs and ma'ams. This Dilling
ham fella recorded this tune for John A.
Lomax in Austin in December 1935, and
it is now housed in the American Folklife
Center in the Library of Congress (AFS
537-A). This is the source Bruce Molsky
used for his reworking of this tune. And
no, it is not the "Diamond Joe"that the
Cofer Brothers waxed in the 1920s, nor
the one that floated around the singersongwriter scene in the 1960s.
Ed Gillespie, fiddle and vocal, is next
up on this CD. We don't know, however,
who else was on this recording session.

His "Little Fish" evokes "Bright Sher
man Valley," with echoes of "Free Little
Bird." "Leather Britches" sounds to me
like there are two fiddles on it, and is
done rather slowly with a nice sortie
into the upper register. The "Irish Wash
er

Bonner's "Yearling's in the Canebrake,"

and is almost a missing link in the eti
ology of this tune that eventually be
came popular as "Cattle in the Cane" in
more modern times. "Run, Nigger, Run"

probably owes a lot to the John Carson
(1924) and Skillet Lickers (1927) rendi
tions. No doubt, however, that tune was
very widespread. Gillespie ends his set
with a nice, slow version of "Billy in the
Low Ground," again sounding like two
fiddles at work. Jace Middlin's group

cause the tonal center shifts from the Ichord to the VH-chord, something many
associate with classic Scots folk fiddling,
but Meyers' tune has a more minor qual

has

ity, or more

the

"modalish," if you will. They
take "Arkansas Traveler" at a moderate
pace and I do hear some nuances of the
Texas contest style, but it still would make
a great square dance piece. Meyers' "Du

rang's" is bouncy and jaunty, notey, and
with short bow strokes. His "Rickett's"
is a classic book version, almost like he
obtained it from Cole's 1000 Fiddle Tunes
(or its ancestor, Ryan's Mammoth Collec
tion). "Soldier's Joy" is kind of a "book"
version, with variations, and there is

nothing particularly noteworthy
"Eighth of January" except that

in

their

it is

solid

Woman," in 6/8 time, again sounds

like there are two fiddles. I don't know
if Gillespie called the next piece "Rustic
Dance" or if someone else put that title
on it. It is not the same melody usually
associated with that title (though the
story of that title could be an entire arti
cle in itself), but like that tune, it is in the
key of C and is an old-time schottische
or clog. Gillespie's rendition of "Cattle
in the Cane Break" is very evocative of

a

pleasant peppy sound on "Give

Fiddler a Dram" that sounds like
some cross-pollination of similar tunes
in the family, using what sounds like
fiddle, guitar, bass, and perhaps tenor
banjo, banjo, or mandolin. The next two
items are listed as "unknown" but the
fiddling sounds very familiar. "Wag
oner"

sounds

like it is surely in Ed
able
hands, with some ting
Gillespie's
es of Am Stuart and J. W. Day thrown
in. It sounds like two fiddles, again, on
"Pick the Devil's Eye Out" with one part
sounding like "Eighth of January," and
the obligatory pizzicato.

�Marynell told me the next performers'
names sounded like "Colonel Ogden and
son Jimmy/' and though it does not sound
like that to me, I can't tell you what it does
sound like. So they may remain a mys
tery. Whoever they may be, they hearken
back to the older styles of ranch and so

course, and I have my favorites among
modern Texas fiddlers, but I prefer the
older styles found on this CD (and also
surviving in West Texas among members
of the Lewis family; someone should re
cord and issue material from them, and
do some interviews). I am submitting

cial dancing, lots of couple and big-circle
formats and non-breakdowns, which is a

to the

subject that Dan Foster addresses in his

essays on the FRC website. The interest
ingly titled "Heel and Toe Polka with

"Jenny Lind
Polka." Check out Narmour and Smith's
"Heel and Toe Polka" (1929) for another
example of this piece. Ogden next plays
"Polka Schottische," which we hear to be
a version
of "Flop Eared Mule," which
the

Nightcap On"

appeared in print

is in fact

as "The

Detroit Schot

Howe's mid-nineteenth
century publication(s) Musician's Omni
bus, and has been found in many Euro

tische"

in Elias

pean folk musicians' repertoire as some
thing of their own. Next is a bit of a sur
prise, "Old Sally Gooden," in A and with
a wild guitar rhythm. Their final track, a
very nice one, is called "Patsy Mind the
Baby" and is an old-fashioned clog.
Sam Welch and Family (Leroy Bowman
on guitar

perhaps), recorded

in

Austin

in

March 1939, finish this set with a more
modern sound. "Cripple Creek" is longbowed, with some pizzicato. "Bastard
King" is quite the bawdy piece, sung by
solo voice and guitar. "Corn-

Mr. Welch,

Gal" is a fiddle /guitar piece
style of "Old Richmond," "Katy
There's a Bug on Me," which probably
knew life at one time as a schottische be

huskin'
in the

fore

becoming

a

breakdown.

It's

pretty

notey, and has the feeling to me of the
1930s "Hillbilly radio show fiddling"
sound. They follow that up with fiddle
and guitar on "Listen to the Mocking
Bird," with the requisite third-position

Next up is something
"Rochester
Schottische," and

meanderings.
called

schottische, it is not the mel
associated with this title.
The now-ubiquitous contest tune "Sally
while

it is a

ody usually

Johnson" makes its appearance here,
with modern chord backup and perhaps
tenor banjo. They end the set with the
Texas swing favorite and standard "San

Antonio Rose," very swingy.
So there

you have

it,

a

wide variety of

styles and sounds, showing how nonhomogenous Texas fiddling had been
at one time, before everyone seemed to
try to sound like whoever had won the

previous year

test. There are

at the

Crockett fiddle con

wonderful exceptions,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

Old-Tune Herald a listing of Texas
fiddlers recorded prior to World War II
who were recorded for the Library of
You can

Congress.

read this list at www.

-ed.)

oldtimeherald.org.

Examples

of their

fiddling can be found at the Library of
Congress website, in the John A. and
Ruby T. Lomax site, http:/ /memory.loc.
gov ammem lohtml lohome.html.
In

listening

Dillingham,
reminded

to

J.

A.

Meyers, with J. D.
I was
strongly

on this CD,

Miers (sic) and J. D.
Dillingham's recordings for John Lomax,
in

the

of A.

J.

Austin area

in

1935 and

1936. In

deeper into some unpublished
research by Guthrie Meade, I found that
Gus listed this gent as Andrew J. Mears. I
then searched for Andrew J. Mears in the
Social Security Death Index, and found
Andrew J. Mears, born November 19,
1892, died August 1975 in Mansfield, Tar
rant County. Unless someone in that area
does a more thorough search and perhaps
can interview relatives, or does a newsdigging

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

paper search for fiddlers, we may never
if this is, in fact, the same person.
I did a similar search for J. D.
Dillingham
and found Jefferson D. Dillingham, born
November 25, 1898, died in Austin on

know

May

5,

1998.

I

found census information

Dillingham, born
who
moved
to Tarrant
Kansas,

on an older Jefferson D.
in 1867 in

County and appeared there in the 1930
census records. There also was a vague as
sociation with this elder Dillingham with
the legendary Texas outlaw Sam Bass, but
the entry I found was incomplete, so I
don't know the nature of the association.
One regret I have is that Bill Owens did
not record

J. D. Dillingham on his fiddle,
something that John Lomax had done, but

those discs are in pretty bad shape. Or

at

least the tape dubs are.
KERRY BLECH
To

Order: www.fieldrecorder.com

�several cuts of Tommy playing banjo
with Earnest East (only faintly heard) on
fiddle, with Mac Snow on guitar. There
is one track of Laurence Lowe (Charlie
Lowe's son) on fiddle with Fred Cocker
ham on banjo, and one cut from an old
home recording of Tommy and Charlie

Lowe.
If

of

you're already familiar with the music
these musicians and have their record

a must-have CD for an
invaluable glimpse into what it was like
to sit around playing music with these

ings, this is still

informal settings, or, as we like
you like old-time mu
sic and aren't familiar with these players,
or don't have their recordings, you gotta
have it. These musicians are the real thing
and these were real moments in time
guys

in

to call it, real life. If

ALICE GERRARD
To order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�But that misses

the point. These aren't
these are friends making

performances,
music together where, through good for
tune, there was a tape recorder running.
I'm glad we have these. Thanks to Andy
Cahan for recording them. As Ray Alden
says, "You have but to put this CD in
your player to unlock these treasures."
PETE PETERSON
To order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The most interesting of the instrumen
are the banjo duets. "Waiting for

tal

Nancy" and "Bear's Leaving Town" (both
written by Curt in 1978) are exciting lis
tening. Two banjos back up Curt's rendi
tion of "Sweet Sunny South," a perfect

setting for Charlie Poole's wistful song.
The last track, a "Reuben's Train" esque
version of "Nine Hundred Miles," fea

tures both Curt and Bob singing, both
playing Curt's gourd banjos. This would
be a really stunning finish to the album
if it wasn't a whopping seven and a half

minutes long. The singing doesn't start
until five minutes or so into the track.
There's a saying I've seen on hats and
shirts: "Old-time music
better than

Tit

believe this track to be a per
example of that phenomenon. It must
have been fun to play; Curt mentions in
sounds."

I

fect

the liner notes that they played the tune
for 20 minutes, probably inducing the

tune

trance

that's such

a

great feature

of playing old-time tunes. Sometimes it
doesn't translate to listening, though.
The more familiar
tunes
"Seneca
Square Dance" and "Mississippi Saw
are played as banjo/hammered
dulcimer duets. These are less success
ful. The instruments are playing in the

yers"

same pitch range, for the most part, and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

dulcimer's sustain gives a muddy
to the mix, covering the banjo's

the

feeling

quicker attack and decay.
Some songs on this CD will be familiar
to listeners. Others are less well known,
of greater antiquity, with interesting ar
rangements. I found a couple of things
distracting, though. Most of the vocals

way in front of the instruments, giv
ing an auditory picture of voices a few
inches from your ears while the instru
ments are several feet away. The vocal
harmonies, though precisely worked out
in terms of pitch, don't always match the
phrasing of the lead vocals.
are

Special mention needs to be made of
Rangers." I remember listening
to the New Lost City Ramblers' version;
the liner notes also cite Ian and Sylvia as
a source. I have seldom had such vivid
pictures in my mind from hearing a song
"Texas

as

I

had from listening to Bob and Curt's

arrangement, Curt freely echoing Bob's
meditative vocal phrases on the ham
mered dulcimer. This form of emotional
punctuation is common in Indian classi
cal and ghazal singing, which translates

song with an eerie effectiveness.
Among the less-well-known songs are
"A Long Time Ago," a humorous capstan
shanty with concertina accompaniment,
to this

"Ticklish

an

Reuben,"

early-twentieth-

century novelty "laughing" song, and "I
Only Want a Buddy (Not a Sweetheart),"
widely popular in the 1930s, recorded by
Bradley Kincaid and Bing Crosby, among
others.
The liner notes

a
delight. Schol
instru
information,
arly background
ment details, and general musings are
imparted with a light touch and a solid
sense of humor.

are

HILARY DIRLAM
To order:

Note

to

(650) 804-2049; or

www.cdbaby.com

Artists and Record Companies

Please send all material for review to
the OTH (PO Box 51812,

Durham, NC

27717). Do not send to individual

review

ers. What gets reviewed is determined at
the discretion of the OTH according to

space available, balance of old and new,
and compatibility with our mission. We
cannot review everything that comes in
nor guarantee that because we received
it we will review it. We do not return ma
terials to the sender. Thanks!

�rounded by a large wilderness area, home
to native plants and wildlife Northern
California, it lends its name to this string
band, based in Walnut Creek.
Carl Pagter, Harry Liebstrand, and Matt
Dudman have been active musicians and
organizers in the traditional music scene
for many years. (More details are avail

Grand Picnic
Mt. Diablo String Band

able on their CDBaby page.) Harry Lieb
strand started playing fiddle at age four,
learning from his father. Moreover, this is
band. Harry and Cin
a two-generation
and
son play fiddle and
dy's daughter

Harry Liedstrand, fiddle and vocals; Cindy LiedTerrell Liedstrand,
strand, guitar and vocals;
mandolin; Carl Pagter, banjo and vocals; Corbin
Pagter, mandolin and vocals; Matt Dudman,
bass; Parrin Liedstrand, fiddle

mandolin, and Corbin, Carl's son, plays
mandolin and sings.

Woodchuck/Old and Gray/
Ladies Quadrille/Pine Valley Waltz/Fire

ergy, precise rhythm that

Indian Ate

on the

a

Mountain /The Happy Tune /Will

the Roses Bloom (Where She Lies

Sleep

Billy Wilson /Crockett's Hon
eymoon/Goodbye, Girls, I'm Going to
Boston/Shamus O'Brien /Forked Deer/
Wild Goose Chase/
Taggart's Reel #3
Hobb Dye/Tater Patch /Grand Picnic/
ing) /Old

Jeff

Sturgeon

Mt.

Diablo

landscape

is
in

familiar feature of the
California's Bay Area. Sur
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Given the size of the group, and the fact
doesn't seem to play out
much, they have a surprisingly high-en
that the band

would enliven

dance or festival stage anywhere in the
US. The band's repertoire is drawn from
a

Appalachia, California (via
Mill Band, of which Harry

the

Sweets

is

former

a

member), with a couple of tunes from the
Midwest and New England thrown in for
good measure. All tunes and songs are
performed with authenticity and taste.
"Old and Grey," learned from Kenny
Hall, who got it from a Charlie Poole 78, is
sung by Harry with a hard-edged plain
tiveness reminiscent of the singing of Peter

Stampfels. Other California tunes include
"Ladies Quadrille," "Pine Valley Waltz,"
and "The Happy Tune," a suitably cheery
rag in C. "Will the Roses Bloom Where She
Lies Sleeping"

Scruggs)

is

(popularized by Flatt and

sung

as

a

father-son duet by

Carl (lead) and Corbin (tenor). "Crockett's

is a lovely tune originally
recorded in the 1920s by Crockett's Ken
tucky Mountaineers, who lived in Fowler,
California, from 1919 on, making this a
great choice for the CD.
With
The album is well recorded.
so many instruments and quite a few
switches of lead and backup vocals, it
might have suffered from a lack of clarity.
Everything is, however, bright and clear.
Cindy Liedstrand's guitar work deserves
special mention; she and Matt Dudman
(bass) provide a rock-solid rhythmic un

Honeymoon"

derpinning for the rest
The liner notes

are

of the band.

well done, citing

original sources whenever possible. Last
a stunning photo of
the Mt. Diablo range on the cover. This
is a well-crafted album, and if you want
to listen to some old-time music played
in the traditional family band style, I

but not least, there is

recommend this CD.

HILARY DIRLAM
To order:

www.cdbaby.com/cd/mtdiablosb

�The Horse Flies

Field Recorders' Collective 602

violin vocals; Jeff Claus: acoustic
guitar, banjo-uke, vocals; Richie Stearns: banjo,
vocals; John Hayward: bass; Taki Masuko: per
cussion; Peter Dodge: accordion, synth
Judy Hyman:

Ride

Old

Buck/Jimmy

Johnson/New

Monongahela/ Improvisations /Who
Throwed

Lye/Cotton

Eyed

Joe/Lost

Train Blues /Oh Death /I Live Where It's
Gray/ Thank You Frank /Jenny on the

Railroad /Human Fly /Candy Girl/Iko/
Breaking Up Christmas

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�in

1995),

fiddle band pow
fifth gear. The difference

which it's

a

ering along in
of the
is mainly about the "experience"
to learn
If
CD,
wanting
you're
guess.
one of Chirps' tunes, this CD is perfectly
set up for that delightful chore. Chirps
introduces each one, plucks his strings
for tuning, and sets to work, mostly on
1

fiddle but sometimes on another instru

There's no particular "build" to
listening to the whole disc as a piece
ment.

"con
outmoded
any
cept
that
demand
unless
your
you
just
ways,

but then the Internet has made the

somewhat

CD"

listener do
whole hour

it
a

your way by making the
single cut. Chirps' tunes, at

Some you'll
are totally
others
version
know some
of;
fresh unless you already know Chirps'
playing. For some reason was particu
any rate, are plumb choice.

I

larly happy to see "Citaco" among the
tunes. It's one I'd heard a long time back
at one of those campfires I was mention
ing, and I didn't remember it at all. Now
I've got it here and I've only got me to
blame for not learning it. Mama tried.
It's

CD.

ereat to hear this Renegades
There's not enough emphasis in oldreallv

time music

singing, partly or mainly
due to the kind of random fact that con
tests tend to highlight the instrumental
when it comes to the old-time category,
but also because a lot of good or even great
old-time pickers just don't seem to want
to sing. I don't understand this reticence.
on

Both Tommy Jarrell and Bob Dylan have
made it crystal clear that it's really okay to

sing, that you don't have to be Tammy or
Ella to do it, or even do it well. Maybe if

Tammy or Ella were actually in the room,
you might STFU. Otherwise, believe in
your voice; leam the words right, listen to
how it's done, then do it sing! Anyways,
the Renegades never had this problem of
reticence, and they didn't need a contest
This CD comes from its origi
situation.
nal 1993 DAT recording,

issued then

as

a

cassette, plus (some or all of, it's not clear)
their 1995

I

Need

to

Find CD.

As all four

members are songwriters, there's

a

lot of

original material on the disc, most of it still
in the style of that part of old-time music
that gets called "early country" or "classic
country" sometimes, particularly when it
has electric instruments or drums. James
Leva, who writes the notes on the cover,
I'd
calls the band "nascent Americana."
the
lack
of
about
twang
only quibble
here
just don't understand why there's
I

no steel, tele, or light drums, at least from
time to time, aside from it being just an ar

bitrary decision.

But I'm

speaking purely

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

musically obviously these folks come out
of the old-time world, where electric isn't
appreciated much, and where the tastes
hearken back to the pre-electric sounds of,
again, the Monroes, the Stanleys, the Cart
ers, the string bands.

I'm

in total

agree

ment with James that old-time as a living
genre encompasses must encompass
has to be happening now;
harder, more manual way
the past. And bands like
of "recording"
the Renegades are evidence that, indeed,

originality.
it's not

It

simply

a

really alive. Toucliing
CD offers great perfor
this
the other base,

old-time music

is

tire great old-time tunes:
from Burl Hammons, "High

mances of some of
"Big Scioti"

from Emmett Lundy,
Farewell"
Old Hen." If you
"Cluck
Winds,"
"Chilly
didn't hear tire Renegades live, or only sorta remember how good they were: voila.

landers

The Horse Flies live in another hemi
Some
sphere of the old-time planet.
another
from
even say they're entirely
planet. Not true, not at all. They began
as a band in 1981, up in the environs of
Ithaca, New York a veritable jungle of
the old-time, full of Highwoods and Hen
ries (and these days, Buffalo even). This
CD gives us five early cuts of their music,

recorded at home in 1984, two of them
pretty much damn good traditional fiddle
tune cuts
raucous, driving, with clean,
rhythmic fiddling and, from the first cut, a
very interesting, distinctive take on banjoplaying from Mr. Stearns. Then, with the
third cut, the CD shows us the evolution
of the Horse Flies into a string band that
admits, embraces, accepts the fact that its
members live in the '80s and '90s, can play
their instruments creatively as well as
with a grounding in sources, and have ac
tually listened (as all of us in fact have, to
some or other extent) to all sorts of music.
After the first five cuts the CD moves its
lens to 1988, where the band is captured
in festival concert and great form. By then
they've added a synth, and are doing not
only roaring old-time tunes (some twisted
cubist's face, to be sure
evidencing
appreciation both of musical theory
and, perhaps, of such deep questions as:
"Why, anyway, does a major scale domi
nate the fundamental character of a West
This evolution into a kind
ern melody?"
of modernity started early, with "Who
Throwed Lye," one of the at-home tracks
from '84. It blossoms and builds with cuts

like

a

an

like "Thank You Frank,"
val concert.

from the

festi

Meanwhile, they developed

vocal side (apart from the fiddle-tune
is just
"I Live Where It's Gray"
vocals)
a really neat piece; it's "old-time" because
a

Horse Flies are an old-time band. If
they weren't, the song would be just as in
teresting, and it might get more air in the
burgeoning world of, say, satellite radio.
across
By '88 the Flies are also reaching
the

genres

to

the zydeco

rhytlrms of "Iko."

Indeed, one of the very enjoyable tilings
about the Flies is their use and awareness
of genre rhythms. Not only zydeco, but
also reggae is represented.

And they re

turn, after sipping the various umbrellaadorned glasses on the musical table of
1988, to some smoky shine with a good
bead, ending with Tommy Jarrell's "Break
ing up Christmas," done their way.

This CD is a great listen, end to end. Ray
tells us in the notes and to my pleasure
that they've put out a new CD in '08 called
Until the Ocean. It has to be good. And it's

typical of Ray's generosity that he would
mention it it's not, after all, on the Field
Recorder label. That's Ray for you. Go
check out his whole site online. I'm sure
there's been new stuff added since I start

writing this piece this morning. After
all, it's already lunchtime. Like Mr. Jarrell
liked to sing: "Soon be time, soon be time,
soon be time, to sit and eat again."

ed

BILL HICKS
To Order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

�York City. The Chicken Chokers sound as
if they were in their twenties at the time

exuberance

show

typical of that
they play hell-for-leather
age group
breakdown tunes with technical aplomb.
they

as

I
particularly liked the fiddle-harmonica
combination in "Cacklin Hen and Rooster

Too," "Tempy," and "Texas Gals." Even bet
ter is a harmonica-banjo duet at the start
of "John

Dream." If I'd been at
I think
I'd have pre
bright harmonica future for Mark
Brown's

the tavern that night,

dicted a
Graham. "Cumberland Blues" (an instru
mental that is not the Grateful Dead song)
is a nice change from the breakdowns. It's

done
feel.

but
In

I

right speed and with excellent
have no idea where it came from,

at the
I

like

it a lot.

addition

to

exuberance, the Chokers

display some other youthful characteris
tics: sophomoricism in some of the words
to "Ruben" ("Ruben had a wreck/ Broke
his friggin' neck
"), and a tendency to
to
the
instruments rather
the
songs
pitch
a few in
stances of severely strained vocals. Tradi
tional singers usually retune their instru
ments rather than cause pain to either
their vocal chords or their listeners' ears.

than to the voices, resulting in

Some of the songs may be more familiar
under other titles: "Jordan" is Uncle Dave
Macon's "Jordan is a Hard Road to Travel,"
albeit with the peculiar imagery of both
putting on (rather than pulling off) one's
overcoat and rolling up one's sleeves.
is

"Tempy"

Bascom

mostly

Lunsford's

Wish I Was a Mole in the Ground."
"Months and Months" is Uncle Dave's "I
Don't Reckon It'll Happen Again."
I'll join the chorus of reviewers in lauding
the Field Recorders' Collective releases of
previously-unavailable non-studio old"I

hope they'll contin
must point out that
could be
information
the accompanying
the
The
back
of
jacket
greatly improved.
lists 5 musicians, while the cover photo
shows 6, none of whom are identified. Jim
Reidy is listed as playing only banjo uke,
time recordings, and
ue. At the same time,

but

a

5-string banjo

I

is

I

clearly being played

on several of the cuts. The one paragraph
of notes includes the statement, "Kevin

Wimmer abandoned violin for fiddle
",
yet Kevin is mentioned nowhere else, on
either the Chokers' or the FRC website.
I

can

understand that the expected sales

a booklet. But there
notes
available for re
sensible
should
cords by even urban bands. The CD jacket

do not justify printing
be

directs you to www.fieldrecorder.com, but
the notes given there for this recording are
limited to obscure reminiscences by band

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

members, including one (Stefan Senders)
who is not listed on the jacket, and exclud
ing one (Chad Crumm) who is. I'd want
some independent commentary similar
to that which accompanies a recording by
traditional artists, including something
about the sources of the music.
LYLE LOFGREN
To order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

�Home/Valse

A

Cathleen/L'Homme

Ca

jun Travaille 'Si Dur/Rieve de Soulard/
Johnnie Billy Goat/Valse a Pop/La Talle
des

Ronce/La Valse Minuit/Hee HawSpecial/ Creole Belles

Scott Playboy

Belles are a working band
women, plying their music and

Creole

The

have for their sources. Each tune is, I'd
estimate, eminently learnable, at least
for the intermediate fiddler or accordion
player, and particularly with the assis
tance of, say, the Amazing Slow Downer.
Possibly this is even true of the vocals,
at least if the student has some modi

their joy mostly around the Bay Area of
Northern California since 1995. For this,
their first recording, they have added

cum of French to ground him. (For me,
sadly, my abilities in French are limited
to "Une biere, Monsier," and, later, "Une
Thus, in my personal Ca
cafe por favor."

an

jun

of four

extremely

"special

guest, "Andrew

Southwest Louisiana native

Carriere,
whose father was the traditional Creole
musician Bebe Carriere. He fortuitously
a

California, and brings enormous
authenticity and energy to this record
ing. Not that such would be lacking oth
erwise; these four "belles" have listened
to their impeccable sources
well, and
have the chops to carry the concert, the
dance, or this recording project. None
theless, having Carriere on board adds a
lives

in

great deal, as is evidenced by the fact that
participates in one way or another on

he

10 of the 18

cuts, including great vocals

on all ten cuts and masterful

accordion

My guess is Carriere fre
in their live work as
well. It's just one of those things perhaps:
a guy in a band called the "Creole Belles"
just doesn't quite make sense.
Carriere is of course his own"source," a
transplanted son of Louisiana. The Belles
have learned well, and at close range.
Their sources include Canray Fontenot,

zydeco fiddling experience I have
my conversation to trading

restricted

rhythmic chops with the drummer.

It is

the better part of valor to refrain from at
tempting the Cajun "Aieeeeeee" without

some knowledge of la Fmngaise.)
If this group is doing a lot of gigs these
days I would expect them to be well into
their second pressing, and with good rea
son. You'd want to take a bit of the band
home after one of their concerts and/
This CD would definitely
or dances.
do the trick. At the same time, I would
say that their reverence to a small degree

dampens the pure insanity that inhab
Cajun/ zydeco bands. And

its the best

on six of them.

again, Carriere does much here to push

quently participates

the fun meter back into the red zone, as
do Delilah's impassioned vocal stylings,

the Ardoin family, Nathan Abshire, Will
[sic] Bolfa, Boozoo Chavis, and the in
comparable Dennis McGee. The singing

Lewis and Karpan has a country puri
would surely be as at home at the
Lacassine or Rayne, Frog Capital
of the Universe, as at a weekend night
of

ty that
gym in
at

Freight and Salvage.

The Cajun-style

first-rate throughout, includ
fiddling
brief
ing
forays into the arcane art of sec
onding since Heil also has duties on the
bass, and since the group clearly wanted
is

to do an

essentially "live" recording, the

"seconding" facet of Cajun music is nec
essarily limited to some extent. It isn't
fair to complain about physics, and if
there's a "Yankee stroke" hiding in Lew
is' right arm, as is hinted modestly in the
notes, I sure couldn't hear it.
One of the very nice things about this

CD is its clarity. No doubt a lot of this has
to do with the quality of the recording

good mics, good space, good engineer,
I'd guess
and of course good playing.
that

a

bit of the clarity

also reflects

the

genuine affection and respect the Belles

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

which

partner
a

happy

reminded my musical

and

life

Libby of the great Cleoma. It's
compromise for all concerned.

Let the bon tons roulette.
BILL HICKS

To Order:

www.creolebelles.com

�Courville and Ernest Fruge, you will love
cuts. "Chez Denouse," recorded
by Dennis McGee as "Two Step de Gran
Marais," is especially beautiful. "Brasse
le gombo vite" (a Doucet original) seems
to conjure up the Klezmer roots of Cajun
music. (Okay, so there aren't really any!)
The rest of the selections are solos, and
many of these are also quite wonderful.
these

On the truly funky "Two Step de Basile,"
Michael pulls out his whole bag of tricks

tribute to the early Cajun music heroes

in

Leo Soileau and Mayeuse Lafleur.
medley "Reels de Mamou" sounds

The

kind
of Bruce Molsky-ish, not surprising since
one of the tunes is a version of "Wagonner" from the playing of Wallace "Cheese"
Reed, who was a big fan of western swing

suspect, influenced by the music
Robertson and other early Texas
fiddlers. It's common practice for Cajun
musicians to rework a tune in a different
rhythm; it gives a new perspective to old
and,

I

of Eck

familiar tunes. Wade Fruge's signature
waltz, "Caillette," becomes "Wade's Twostep;" Austin Pitre's "Chere Joues Roses"
is played as a reel.
The only accordion
is
the
solo
"Amedee's
Accordion"
piece
de
on
which
Michael's
("Two Step
Elton"),
evokes
the
strong bassing perfectly
primi
tive and powerful sound of the old Amedee (Amede) Ardoin recordings. This is
the most rocking piece on the whole CD.
The production is spare. This CD was re
corded quickly without overdubbing, which
it a nice fresh
quality, definitely not
over-produced. The thick booklet includes
Andy Wallace's detailed bio, plus Michael's
notes to the songs, which are written in a
playful and conversational style.
Like all of Michael Doucet's music, this

gives

times self-indulgent but also thor
oughly enjoyable. Michael possesses both
CD is

at

impressive command of technique on
a
free-wheeling attitude;

an

the fiddle and

what keeps his music from being super
ficial is his unwavering passion for and
dedication to the old-time Cajun music
of earlier

generations.

the musicians who
of

He always credits

influenced him (many

whom he learned from first-hand) and,

like

Dewey Balfa before him, by doing

this he provides

map for

the seeker

with a road
the most obscure and

exploring
beautiful of Cajun music sounds. Funky
Buddhist persona notwithstanding, Mi
chael Doucet's connection with the deep
est roots of Cajun music is undeniable, as
is his

stature as the most important Cajun

fiddler of his generation.

SUZY ROTHFIELD THOMPSON
To order:

(888)365-5929, www.folkways.si.edu

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

convey a sense of continuity between
contemporary urban style and its roots.
Familiar names-- Lead Belly, Elizabeth
Cotten, Little Brother, Sonny Terry, Gary
Davis-- appear alongside less familiar
ones whose contributions are every bit
The Thrasher Wonders were
as worthy.

two-brother-one-sister trio who capably
emulated the Golden Gate Quartet on a
1945 performance of "Moses Smote the
a

The brothers later joined R&amp;B gi
Clyde McPhatter in the 1950s as mem

Water."
ant

bers of the Drifters.

Baptist pastor Brother
Willie Gresham sings and responds to his
Athens, Georgia, congregation in a spell

binding performance reminiscent of the
popular Rev. J. M. Gates records made in
nearby Atlanta more than 75 years ago.
Alvin Dockett and Blessed is a Washing
ton, DC, large mixed choir inspired by
the James Cleveland style that evolved in
and

the 1970s,

whose polished contem

porary style retains an abundance of pas

sionate singing and compelling rhythms.
There's a neat relic from the mid-1940s
that couples the voice of Rosetta Tharpe
influenced Ernestine Washington with a
New Orleans revival band led by cornetist
Bunk Johnson, whose music was featured
nightly at New York's fashionable Stuyve
Civil rights legend Fannie
a powerful singing voice;
leads other Greenwood, Mis

sant Casino.

Lou Hamer had
here

she

mixing old-time scripture
citations with contemporary (1963) Free
dom Movement sentiments. I'll resist the
temptation to cite other tracks, even when

sissippians,

they're as good as or better than those I've

singled out.
Much as I like it, I recommend the CD
primarily to those whose tastes encom

pass untrained voices in (usually) unso
phisticated settings. Even if you don't
think the description fit, give Classic Af
It
rican American Gospel a listen anyway.
features some good out-of-the-way mu
sic and you may well enjoy more of it
than you think.

Recording information in both CD book
lets is not consistent. Sometimes we're
told when and where a record was made,
but elsewhere we're only shown a record
number and date of a previous Folkways
release. Instead of artist photos there are
vintage generic snapshots of dancers,
pianos, night club and storefront scenes
in Classic Piano Blues, and assorted wor

singers, and preachers in the
Photos of actual performers
gospel
would have been nice to include too.
shipers,

set.

DICK SPOTTSWOOD
To order:

1-888-365-5929,

www.folkways.si.edu

�popular music in the world." He in
cludes at least two towering classics,
which is a gutty move in itself. "Dust

My Broom" is surely one of the top five
blues pieces ever, and this version from
Robert Johnson himself remains a killer
no matter how many times you hear
it.
Then there's "Another Man Done
Gone," a song recorded by John Lomax
in 1938 from the

singing

of Vera

Hall-

Scott tells us that this original Vera Hall

recording (and she learned it from her
mother, which takes it waaaaay back)
was played by the Library of Congress

commemorate the eightieth anniver
sary of the Emancipation Proclamation.
It still resonates of course. Other "cov
ers" (to use a word that doesn't fit so
well in this context) include Son House's
to

"Grinnin' in Your Face," and the J. S.
Lenoir/ Willie Dixon "Down in Missis
sippi." Giving a nod to more modern
song-crafting, Scott also includes Tom
Waits' "Little Trip to Heaven," which,
with its swingy changes and very tasty

organ playing by T-Bone, reminds us of
where the old blues ended up.
Of the original cuts, I think my favorite
is probably "I Should Get Over This." He
mixes a lyric which expresses acceptance
of loss with a neat dancey Gurian gui
tar sound, surely one of the underlying
reasons that his chosen musical sources
are those of much of the world: you can,
amazingly, dance to Bob Marley's "War
How is
(We Don't Need No Trouble)."
that even possible?
Here's the edge of
the knife:

From this window,

I

see it's just

a

All the kids out playing stick ball
And no one keeping score
Who could ask for more
the man said, I'm

As

game
in the rain

bleeding, and

I

never felt the cut.
On another of his original compositions,
Scott plays a gourd banjo in a tuning he
learned from Sherman Hammons: "a
tuning designed to make playing in the
West African minor pentatonic scale
the blues scale
easy." Thusly we brush
aside these genre-fied conceits the way
the Mexican bandits brush aside Bogey's
complaints: "Badges? We don't need no
stinking badges."
A final note on the context of these
songs

done

Frequently

Putting out

a record
time, like it or not.
in the land of "old-time" we

is in order.

is an act

in real

find artists who suggest they are actually
making music in the 1920s or '30s, or at
least sorta act that way. Sadly, this is of

course impossible.

The Triceratops is

ex

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tinct now; all we have is the white tail.
Scott dedicates two of his own songs to,

respectively, the survivors and victims of
Katrina, and the survivors and victims
of 9/11. His cover art also refers to Ka
trina, featuring a remarkable photo by
John Rosenthal of a ruined New Orleans
church. As with everything else on the
CD, bringing these tragedies into focus is
done with taste and love. If your focus is
a tad wider than the
genre to which this
is
dedicated, you should enjoy
magazine
every cut on Thunder's Mouth.
BILL HICKS
To Order:

www.cattailmusic.com

�songs that Lydia sang, as well as the in
struments they played. Life was hard for
the family. Their relative poverty, Lydia's
father's struggles with alcohol and the
family's struggles with prejudice against
Mexicans and Tejanos, all took their toll.
Lydia never went to school. The fam
ily moved back and forth from Texas to
Mexico, struggling to earn a living as mi
grant laborers, and eventually decided
to try making a living playing music. In
1929 they went to San Antonio to audi
tion for Okeh Records
they were paid
$140 to record 20 songs.
One thing led to another and

eventu

ally,
Lydia's popularity grew, she and
the family were able to earn a small liv
ing with their music playing on the radio,
and in restaurants, tent shows, and other
venues. By the 1930s she was famous and
as

beloved

by her
"La

nickname

people, who gave her the
Alondra de la Frontera"

Meadowlark

("The

of the Border").

She

traveled and toured widely up until she
suffered a stroke in 1988. She was invited
to sing at Jimmy Carter's inauguration in
1977, and was the recipient

of both

the

National

Heritage Fellowship in 1982
and the National Medal of Arts in 1999.
This CD presents the music of a singer
singer of great passion and deep feeling

a

and love for her culture and her musical
heritage. Most of the songs on the CD

Lydia accompanied only by her
12-string guitar, although there are sev
eral with her sister and brother, and with
are

of

various conjuntos or bands featuring ac
cordion greats like Narciso Martinez.
The

CD

contains

a

36-page booklet

with information on the songs, a biogra
phy, some nice photographs, and song
words with translations. Altogether a
nice package.
I was fortunate
to have met Lydia Mendoza when we were both part of tradi
tional music tour on the West Coast. She
was

a

consummate

remember

professional and
her

about how

I

she

asking
managed to convey such emotion night
after night with certain songs that she
sang over and over. I'll always remember
what she said about how she placed her
self mentally in the song, becoming one
with the story and the emotion. Lydia
Mendoza was a singer's singer, and a

singer beloved by her audiences, espe
cially her Mexican American audiences.
This CD is a fine reflection of her art. I
highly recommend
especially to singers.

it

to

everyone, and
ALICE GERRARD

To

Order: www.arhoolie.com, (888) 274-6654

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Sing It Pretty: A Memoir
Bess Lomax Hawes

Lampell,
Hawes).

and

her

husband-to-be
the War

During

Butch

worked

she

government's Office of War In
formation, incorporating folk song into
propaganda broadcasts, activities which
for the

earned for her the 1946 attention of the
FBI's earliest efforts to smoke out "unAmerican" plots such as labor unions

whether everybody else knows them

or

not, and the appropriate

of

introduction

those items of intellectual power into the
public discourse has been the unswerv

ing thrust of my work, whatever form it
took, all my life." We will look long in
the halls of Washington before we find

another like her.

and

working-class song lore. In the 1950s
she relocated to California and began her

University of Illinois Press

The name Lomax will of course catch the

attention of OTH readers, quite deserv
edly in this case. Bess Lomax was born
in 1921, the daughter of John A. Lomax
and younger sister of Alan Lomax. Her
"memoir" (it is not intended to be an au
tobiography) recounts her 60-year pro

fessional career

as

performer, folklorist,

author, and administrator
vocate for the folk arts at the highest
teacher,

ernmental

levels.

/ad

gov

home-schooled

The

Bess began in the 1930's as a teenage as
sistant to her father and brother during

publication

of the classic book Our

Sing

ing Country, the first folk song collection
to be based on field recordings
rather

than written texts.

Having accompanied

her father into Texas prisons to transcribe

inmate performances, she followed him
to Washington,
DC, to work in the Li
brary of Congress archives:
And when

I

lis
spent hours ev

wasn't reading

I

was

life's work combining her passion for
folk song with her calling to educate, be
ginning as a community guitar teacher
and eventually attaining the tenure wars
of academe at UC after returning to col
lege to complete her MA. (Her surpris
ing thesis was on a song every American
knows and can sing but knows nothing
about: "Happy Birthday to You.")
By the 1960s and the "Folk Revival," her
love for what she calls "the difficulties
and splendors of trying to explain things
across cultural lines," her many articles
about and research into children's songs,

growing network of university
colleagues brought her to the attention
and her

Berkeley Folk Festival's planners.
festival work followed, and by
1976 Ralph Rinzler had lured her back
to Washington as an assistant director
of the bicentennial Festival of American
Folklife. She then moved to the National
Endowment for the Arts, serving under
of the

Other

presidents Ford, Carter, Reagan, and the
first Bush,

retiring

in

1992 and

receiving the National

Medal

in 1993
of

Arts

from President
den ceremony.

tening, for Alan and I
ery day playing back every single song
loudly, cataloging each one, transcrib
ing the words, and locating any avail
able field notes. Eventually the patience
of our scholarly research neighbors
was exhausted, and we were exiled to a

Clinton in a Rose Gar
Her account of life as a
bureaucrat
is clear-eyed: the
Washington
woman endured the blind alleys, cross
currents, and conflicts inevitable in any
huge bureaucracy, and took in stride the
eternal focus on funding. (Imagine try

small attic

ing to explain the concept of "folk arts"

at the

very top of the Library

of Congress with only the pigeons for
company. As we listened to hour after

hour of field recordings day after day,
the dust and the heat blew in as they
had perhaps on the singers
and the painted friezes and

themselves,

the gilded
decorative panels filtered the roaring ax-

chopping songs and the crashing shape
note hymns down through the ornate
and orderly library stacks below us.

In

evenings, string quartets woidd play
Schubert and Chopin in the groundthe

floor concert

hall,

but in

the attic

the

unsilenced and unquenchable voices of
southern working people sang on.
By the 1940s Bess was a performing

member of the Almanac Singers (Woody
Guthrie, Pete Seeger, Lee Hayes, Millard

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a
congressman while simultaneously
convincing him to fund your project with
the tax dollars of his constituents. Nasty

to

job, and we were fortunate
Bess Hawes to do it.)

Astonishingly modest
her accomplishments,

of

to

for

have had

a

Bess

person

Hawes

claims that "I am never, inside myself,
quite sure what I am being honored for. I
have singly produced no books, no films,
no songs; all my creative work has been
collaborative," a sentiment she supports
with warm portraits of colleagues such
as Rinzler and Bessie Jones.
Her book
concludes, "I have always had the un
shakable belief that every single human
being has some knowledge of impor
tant

elements

of

beauty and substance,

JON PANKAKE
To Order:

www.press.uillinois.edu,

(217) 333-0950

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

nations of the NBD, respectively. Tyler's
chapter, "The Rise of Rural Rhythm," is
the longest in the book and one of the
also the one that is likely to be
of most interest to old-time music fans.
Tyler discusses the origins of the NBD,
and puts it in context with the few pre
decessors it had in the realm of live oldtime music on radio. The first broadcast

best.

It is

of the
19,

National Barn Dance was on April

1924,

in

the second

week of opera

tions for station WLS. Beginning in 1933
listeners across the country could tune
in the Barn Dance on the NBC radio net

work. Like any good cultural phenom
enon, the NBD has its own origin myth;
i.e. that it began by accident when, faced
with a lack of programming for Saturday
night, station janitor Tommy Dandurand
magically produced a fiddle and went
on the air with a few tunes. Tyler pres
ents evidence, in the form of an advance
newspaper notice about the forthcoming
broadcast of the "first weekly national
barn dance over the radio," that the
show's inception was deliberate.
Tyler notes the variety of musical styles
represented on the NBD, and comments
that the mix of hillbilly and pop "never
to be

for either WLS

problem
appeared
or for much of its audience,"
at the

a

time the NBD began

"a

and that
rubric for

defining the difference between country
music and pop did not exist." Tyler, and
many of the other contributors, make a
distinction between "rural music" and
what we now call "country music" as a
genre: "In short, some rural musicians,
from all parts of the United States, have
been known to play music that is, accord
ing to current definitions, unquestion
ably not country music."
Tyler

provides

a

good discussion

of the

different types of musical acts that ap
peared on the NBD, and groups them as
"Fiddlers," "Folksong Artists," "Modern
Folksong Artists," "Western Song Art
He be
ists," and "Novelty Musicians."
moans the fact that although early NBD
artists recorded extensively, their work
has been poorly represented on reis
sues, and no recordings of broadcasts
He sums up
are known prior to 1939.
the situation somewhat wistfully: "The
National Barn Dance is not well remem
bered primarily because of the incom
pleteness of the sonic record"
Wayne W. Daniel picks up the histori
cal narrative in this essay, "Music of the
Postwar Era." Whereas the early years
of the NBD largely coincided with the
era

of

the

Great

Depression,

the

pro

when all
a period
American culture underwent rapid
As Daniel notes, the show
changes.
gram came of age in
of

"had

to

adapt

the fears,

to

a

demands,

society beset by

and sacrifices

of

a

world war, followed by a postwar boom
that brought a higher standard of living,
new consumer mass media technology,
altered life styles, changes in musical
tastes, and innovative entertainment
concepts." These were changing times
for country music
indeed, -for all genres
of American music. The number of radio
stations increased, and many continued
to program live music, but it was also the
era in which other media emerged that
would eventually bring about the virtual
death of live radio. Recordings grew in
importance, the world of network radio
was in decline, and television was in its
NBC dropped the show
ascendancy.
from its radio network in 1946.

A

tele

vised version of the NBD, the ABC Barn
Dance, was carried on the ABC television
network for thirty-nine weeks in 1949,
but it was not successful.
The program aired on WLS for the last
time on April 30, 1960, shortly after the

station was sold

to

American Broadcast

It was
ing-Paramount Theatres, Inc.
reincarnated on another Chicago radio
station as the WGN Barn Dance, where
He cites no one
it survived until 1969.
cause for the show's ultimate demise,
but notes that changing musical tastes

the rise of

rock-and-roll

in

particular

as one factor.

Chicago historian Lisa Krissoff Boehm's chapter, "Chicago as Forgotten
Country Music Mecca," places the Na
tional Barn Dance within the context of
She
the city from which it emanated.
sounds the familiar theme of neglect of
the NBD on the part of historians both
of country music and of the city of Chi
cago. She argues that the music of the

NBD represented

"a

Midwestern sound,

true to the city and the region" (p. 103),
but that the connection between the city
and the surrounding rural areas of the

region was rapidly disappearing.
The show's rustic image was also at
odds with other aspects of Chicago's
The city's large foreign-born
culture.
population, its rapidly growing African-

American community, and the popular
view of Chicago as the home of corrupt
politicians and gangsters, made

it an

un

likely setting for a barn dance, even a vir
tual one. Boehm makes the astute obser
vation that while blues had a strong base
in the city's culture, the rural, white mu-

�sical forms did not. A vibrant new style
blues grew and developed in Chicago,

of

while the white rural styles of the NBD
increasingly came to represent the music
of an older and aging generation.
Nos
talgia has its limits when it comes to sus
taining musical styles.
In this context it is perhaps also worth
noting the apparently total absence of
any Irish element from the NBD's mu
sical mix. This is the same Chicago in
which Capt. Francis O'Neill did his
landmark work collecting and promot
ing the music of the city's Irish immi
grants less than a quarter century before
the National Barn Dance went on the air.
That the city's Irish musical community
was not tapped for the NBD may well
be due in large part to the insular na
ture of this community. In the present

much is made of supposed connec
tions between Irish and country music,
yet it seems that no such connection was
made during the era in which the Na
tional Barn Dance flourished.
The remaining essays in the book in
era

clude:

"Early

Audiences"

Broadcasting and Radio

Susan Smulyan; "Race
and Rural Identity," by Michael Bertrand;
"Patriarchy and the Great Depression"
by

by Kristine McCusker;

"Cowboys

in

Chi

cago" by Don Cusic; and "The National
Folk Festival" by Michael Ann Williams.
Bertrand's and Williams' contributions
are the best.
Bertrand touches on key
issues such as the racial makeup of the

radio audience for the NBD, the role of

blackface minstrelsy in its programming,
and the positioning of country /rural
music in opposition to urban jazz. Wil
liams does an excellent job of contrasting
what she terms "two forms of theatrical
presentation of traditional culture," the
National Barn Dance and the National
Folk Festival. One was a purely commer
cial form of

entertainment, disseminated

via mass media, and the other was (and
still is) a more self-conscious cultural

program. She treats this theme at greater
length in her book, Staging Tradition: John
Lair

and Sarah

Gertrude

Knott, also

pub

lished by the University of Illinois Press.
The Hayloft Gang is an important book
about a chapter in the history of (mostly)
country music that has heretofore not re
ceived the attention that it deserves. While
not all chapters will be of prime interest to
all OTH readers, there is much here that

warrants attention from serious fans of the
history of old-time and country music.
PAUL
To Order:

www.press.uillinois.edu,

F.

WELLS

(217) 333-0950

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

or

three times in different chapters. Some

judicious editing could have made for
stronger, more condensed whole.

a

The photos are amazing: of Iry, his im
mediate and extended family including
ancestors and descendants, his many
musical colleagues, and the dog that is
heard on "Duralde Waltz." And some
truly strange ones: the back brace worn
in the late 1940s (Iry's back was broken in
a car accident when the friend who was
driving fell asleep at the wheel), Iry's
First

Communion card, and (my favor
worn ladderback

ite!) two

chairs upon

backsides
of Iry Lejeune, Amede Ardoin, Amede
Breaux, Angelais Lejeune, and others.
wondered if these were magic chairs;
which supposedly

rested

the

I

maybe
to

play

if

I

sat on one of them, I'd be able

as

beautifully

these

as

seminal

masters of the Cajun accordion?
The author, Ron Yule, is

a

bluegrass fid

dler who came to Cajun music relatively
self-published several other
books about bluegrass fiddling. He is not
an academic, and does not maintain the
conventional scholar's distance from his
subject. His writing style is in-depth and
extremely respectful, and often becomes
late. He has

quite emotional, mirroring the emotion
that was at the root of Iry Lejeune's mu

Among the many short chapters in
write-up on Iry's
accordion style is especially well written.

sic.

this book, Chris Miller's

The lyrics chapter is terrific; all 25 of Iry's
recorded songs are included, both in the
original French and with English transla
tions, and each page includes a photo of
the label of the record, well worth exam
ining closely. For example, I never knew
that "Love Bridge Waltz" was recorded
for the Opera

the hillbillies!"

record company: "hits of
The French lyrics have

been well transcribed with contractions
like 'tite and 'garde

literation

is

included.

provided.

No trans

For that, one

must

go to Ann Savoy's Cajun Music: A History

of a People and Raymond Francois' Oh Ye
Yaille. Comparing the transcriptions from

these

books

reveals

some

completely understandable

anomalies,
considering

1940s and '50s, when these
were
recorded, Cajun French was
songs
not really a written language at all. Ron
Yule's book was made at the instigation
of and with the encouragement of Ervin
Lejeune, one of Iry's sons and a great ac
cordion player in his own right (as was
his brother Eddie who died in early 2001,
way too young, only in his forties). Even
so, I found the "Who Is Iry Lejeune, Jr.?"
section to contain a little too much infor
mation. Wailin' the Blues Cajun Style isn't
meant to be a general introduction to Ca
jun music, but readers who don't expect
a narrative and who enjoy minutiae will
have a wonderful time with it, and for
those who are interested in learning Iry
Lejeune's song it should prove very help
ful. A must-have for those interested in
the postwar Cajun music scene, in Cajun
accordion music, and especially the mu
that in the

sic and life of Iry Lejeune.
SUZY ROTHFIELD THOMPSON
To

order: www.ronyule.com

�whether the square dances are keepers,
in which you don't change partners, or
mixers, in which you do. There are also
several big circle dances (my concept of a
"mixer") and Sicilian circles. Other than
line dances, that about covers the types
of group dances that I know of.
The book is enjoyable on many levels.
There's a lot of humor, including the titles
given to certain dances: "Metaphors Be with
You," "Dorna Loon," and "What the Hey!"
The illustrations, garnered mostly from
traditional books, are spare and appropriate,

including

a

depiction of

a

Hog-Eyed Man.

Most dances have footnotes telling how
they came to be written; they are amusing
and give the reader a feel for the person that
Brian is
an outgoing, good-humored, and

enthusiastic Alaska denizen who surrounds
himself with music and dance.
The dance community is fortunate that
Brian has chosen to share his dances and
stir them into the traditional pot.
I rec
ommend this book for contra and square
dance callers, dance enthusiasts, and for
just plain old fun.
TONI WILLIAMS
To order:

bdemar@alaska.net

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a
Johnson. One
of
booth
Johnson,
snapshot
grainy photo
cigarette dangling from lips adorns the
cover of Crossroads, the rights to the im
age controlled in the name of Johnson's
heirs by LaVere, who also contributes the
book's foreword. Both the lowlights and
highlights of the McCormick /LaVere
rivalry seem fairly covered with credit
given where credit is due.
Crossroads is a handy guide to the Rob
ert Johnson saga. Graves touches on the
the possible film
salient talking points
bluesman
which
really sold his
snippet,
soul at the crossroads, the Hollywood
film, the US postage stamp, the correct
recording playback speed, the lost songs,

photographs

of Robert

moments struck
as
an account of
such
out
of
me as
sync,
1950s multi-track recording techniques
and brief mentions of Ozzie Osborne and
and the lost son! A few

Charlie Daniels. All-in-all, though, Cross
roads is a brisk, insightful read, a reliable
overview, especially for the blues neo
phyte or interested fan seeking to learn
more about the quintessentially Ameri
can/African American roots music phe

nomenon known

as

Robert Johnson.
JERRY

To order:

www.ipgbook.com

ZOLTEN

�strong role in the Sacred Harp tradition,
as well, and Elene Stovall of Birmingham,
Joyce Smith Walton of Pisgah, Alabama,
and Charlene Wallace and Carlene Grif
fin of Mt. Zion, Georgia, speak of their
involvement in the tradition, often travel
ing hundreds of miles in the course of a

weekend

for

singing.

The film

footage of the singing is very
powerful. Different members of the sing
ing groups take turns leading the groups
from "in the square," as the leadership
station is designated. No one appears to
be excluded from this song-leading role-adults, teenagers, and children of both

sexes are shown leading the singing.
Leaders mark time and direct the sing
ing in accordance with their own way of

keeping time and their confidence work
ing in that role. Many of the singers also
keep time while singing. Each song is
preceded by "pitchers" giving the sing
ers in each vocal part their starting notes.
It is pointed out that the "pitchers" do

not have perfect

pitch, but good rela

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tive pitch, so that while a song may not
end up being sung in the key in which
it was written, the accommodation that
the pitchers have made in

selecting the

starting notes for each part may have
the effect of making the song easier to
sing than it would have been in its origi
nal key. Richard Delong of Whitesburg,
Georgia, one of the pitchers,

is

a

distinc

tive presence, keeping time with
and is unabashedly moved by the

a

fan,

sing

ing on several occasions. The singing is
quite loud and is meant to be done full-

without dynamics or special
consideration given to blending. One of
the singers points out that the singing is
"experiential" rather than performanceoriented, and in this respect I think it is
like a lot of old-time music. Many of the
singers speak to the incredible sensa
tion of being in the middle of the sound,
and I don't think it's an exaggeration to
describe the feeling that they get from
that as addictive. It is thrilling to see a
roomful of people just singing their guts

throated,

I think
the power of what they
doing, apart from the sheer volume,
comes from their belief. It's an exagger
ation to say there is no vocal blending,
too. It's just that the blend, because of

out, and
are

common practices in the
counterpoint, like avoidance
writing
of parallel fifths and octaves, has a more
open quality than is commonly found in
choral singing, and thus ends up with
and more ringing sound, al
a brighter
for

disregard

of

most Asian-sounding

at

times,

or

like

a

bee hive.

won't get into the history of Sacred
singing here. You can find the
movie and watch it to get more infor
mation and background on the subject.
came away from the film though, cer
I

Harp

I

tain that the Sacred Harp singing is a
vital and valuable part of the singers'
lives, and that if you or I ever want to
participate in the singing, we will be

warmly welcomed.

JOHN M. MILLER
To Order:

www.thirdday.com/awake

�S

MUSIC DISPATCH

*1

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

fimesra8s *siaes

BAN

O

Best of Bluegrass
Book/CD

00690636 $24.95

B

bTo^-TfTb

00695358

Parlor Guitar

Book/CD

I

Book or Book/CD

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

00699796

$7.95

"■

$14.95

$14.95

Ragtime Guitar
Book/CD

00699611

rols'fiaBHme
MANDOLIN

GUITAR,

00699529

Easy Songs for

$6.95
$14.95

L E

5-String Banjo
Book/CD

Mandolin

00695865
00695866

L&gt;

Bluegrass Guitar
Classics

5

i

Comtry

Bluegrass and Folk

Hal

Guitar Book/CD

Leonard Mandolin
Method Book/CD

00695355

00695102

Earl

$19.95

MOKE?

$12.95

Scruggs and the

5-String Banjo
Book or Book/CD

00695764
00695765

MUSIC

$19.95
$34.95

$14.95

The Ultimate Banjo

Songbook
Book/2 CDs

00699565

$24.95

DISPATCH

j
j

'

�AMERICA

KEEPING

OLD &amp; WEIRD

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
FOLKWAYS.SI.EDU

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Save 20% through

888-F0LKWAYS
2/28/09

on

CD

or

800 410-9815

Orders with Code HERALDFW08

�5-STRING
PRODUCTIONS
Section with Illegible Text

Cataloochee

Bowling Green

Carol Elizabeth Jones

Alice Gerrard

&amp;

Mike Seeger

Evening at WPAQ, 1984

An

Benton Flippen

&amp;

the

Smokey Valley Boys

and leaving life

dozen songs about living, loving,
in the Appalachian
mountains.

Extraordinary performances by
two iconic musicians. Includes
three tracks with the legendary

5SP08001

Tommy Jarrell.

Recapture a memorable night of
music with one of the South's most
powerful old time string bands.

5SP08003

5SP08004

A

More Great Releases:
From Mali to America SSPO6004

Cheick Hamala Diabate and Bob Carlin
Birdie sspo/oo/

Wayne &amp; Margaret Martin
and Craig Johnson
The Road To Agate Hill SSP06003

Alice Gerrard, Gail Gillespie,
&amp;

Sharon Sandomirsky

It's About Time SSP07003
John Hoffmann &amp; Mac Benford

Ernest

V.

Big Ears ssposm

Stoneman:

The Unsung Father of
Country Music
Ernest V. Stoneman
Ernest V. Stoneman, pioneering
composer and performer, defined
the formula of "three chords and
the truth" and became the first
rural singer/songwriter of the

Mark Simos &amp; Friends

Falls of Richmond

Paul Brown

intimate solo recording that
reveals Matt to be a compelling
multi-instrumentalist and singer

The Rest

5SP08002

&amp;

An

Yet to Come 5SP04004

Lone Prairie ssposoo
Matt Brown with Paul Brown

Beverly Smith
1

SSP07002

Matt Brown
On the Edge ssposoo4

The Cliffhangers

5SPH00I

Clifftop Notes Vol. 1 ssposoos
Mark Simos &amp; Friends

www.5-string.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

Double Decker String band

Old-Time Fiddle Lesson Vol.

20th century to record.

334 West Union Street, West Chester,

Red Clay Country 5SP06002

Matt Brown

Known for their Reputation

PA

19382

info@5-string.com

The Hoover Uprights

SSP05002

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12102">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 11, Number 7 (October-November 2008)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12103">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12104">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 11, Number 7 (October-November 2008)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Goat Glands and String Bands: Dr. John Brinkley,” by David Holt&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old, New, and Real: The Case of Mississippi’s Senator George Cecil McLeod,” by Chris Goertzen&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – Old-Time Herald Reviews,” by Alice Gerrard&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for George Chudacoff; Boyd Wilbert “Hick” Edmonds; Clifford Hardesty; and Artie Traum.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12105">
                <text>2008</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="1004">
        <name>2000s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1005">
        <name>2008</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5459">
        <name>Artie Traum</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5457">
        <name>Boyd Wilbert “Hick” Edmonds</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5455">
        <name>Chris Goertzen</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5458">
        <name>Clifford Hardesty</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5453">
        <name>David Holt</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5452">
        <name>Dr. John Brinkley</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5454">
        <name>George Cecil McLeod</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5456">
        <name>George Chudacoff</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5413">
        <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2506" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3596">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/072a7e8c5394adfb473e1a5fe2985a94.pdf</src>
        <authentication>a11cba8e81242b279cf6404c2ff0815a</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12803">
                    <text>THE OLD-TIME

HERALD

Volume 13, Number 11

$5.00

EVERYONE SOUNDED DIFFERENT:
AN INTERVIEW WITH CHRIS COOLE
TOM FULLER:
THE LIFE AND TIMES OF A FIDDLER
FROM INDIAN TERRITORY
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�LEAD BELLY: THE SMITHSONIAN FOLKWAYS COLLECTION

Section with Illegible Text

"This is

a

powerful time

to

hear Lead Belly's voice again"

NPR

The first career- spanning, in-depth box set
dedicated to the American music icon
5

CDs/108 Tracks (16 unreleased)

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
1

-888-FOLKWAYS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Enter code LEADBELLYOTH
through 3/31/15 for

a

20%

at

folkways.si.edu
discount on this box set

�Section with Illegible Text

New

Releases from the Field Recorders' Collective

CD

CDs for

fsPEClA^H^^

only$56|

Howard Miller (1912-1990) of Ashe County, North
Sixty Years of North Carolina Fiddling (FRC706)
Miller. These sessions establish Howard Miller as
Monroe
and
his
to
fiddle
was
father,
Charles,
Carolina,
grandfather,
by
taught
undiminished
and
as
a dynamic fiddler in his own right whose talent remained
G.B.
of
the
repertoire
Grayson
prime interpreter
through the years.
Albert Hash, Volume 2 (FRC707) Albert Hash (1 91 7-1 983) was a beloved fiddler and instrument maker from Grayson
as one of his early bands, The Virginia
County, Virginia. This disc features Albert's takes on different old fiddle tunes as well
Carolina Boys from their weekly radio show in the 960s. (See also FRC41 Albert Hash.)

Howard Miller

a

1

1

Missouri Fiddling and Banjo Playing (FRC708) Lee Stoneking (1907-1989) was among the best
Lee Stoneking
fiddlers in west central Missouri. Lee began learning from his own father around the age of seven. These recordings, made on
well as
a visit by Brad Leftwich, Linda Higginbotham, and Kenny Jackson in 1985, include tunes not represented elsewhere, as
samples of his fine up-picking banjo style.
Rector Hicks Sugar in the Morning (FRC709) Rector Hicks, fiddler, was born in West Virginia and lived
These recordings include his unique versions of familiar tunes, rarely-heard hymns, waltzes, and marches, some

Akron Ohio.

in

Ed

Haley pieces,

tunes.

and two fine self-composed

Johnson
Coming Soon: CDs featuring Dean Sturgill, Alleghany County Fiddlers, Maggie Hammons Parker, Craig

&amp;

others.

FULL CATALOG LISTING

the 1960s FRC609

Manco Sneed, Byard Ray &amp; Mike Rogers

Jeff Goehring

FRC601

John Hannah

FRC405

Harold

mnm
1

mr,,,

poe

FRC1 01

1

FRC103

1

You can

FRC208

FRC700

Snow FRC205

Corbett Stamper FRC306
Lee Stoneking FRC708

FRC61 0

Road String Band FRC606
Cecil Plum FRC404

John Summers

Ramsey &amp; Byard Ray FRC1 13
Q|a Be|]e Reed FRC2Q3

Texas

Da|g

jp,e

Roan

Renegades FRC605

Wade Ward FRC507

Mountain

Hilltoppers
Dink Roberts FRC209

FRC201

WV

FRC307

Ross County Farmers

Creek Delta Boys FRC607

Fiddle Bands FRC409

Buddy Thomas FRC303
Union Grove 1969 FRC114

Vernon Riddle FRC1 20
FRC604

Musicians of Clay
Counties FRC202

Jimmy

&amp;

Calhoun

Wheeler FRC401

Transition (Round Peak) FRC102
Round Peak Vol. 1 FRC109

Aunt Jenny Wilson FRC408
Virgil Anderson FRC1005

Ward Jarvis FRC402

Round Peak Vol.2 FRC1 10

Santford Kelly FRC503
Fiddling Van Kidwell FRC41

Lee Sexton

Clyde Davenport FRC1 004
Roan Mt Hilltoppers FRC1002
Clyde &amp; Ralph Troxell FRC1003

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

1

FRC21

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

2

FRC212

order via our website and pav using

PayPal

Band

1

FRC1 05

Lonnie Seymour

2

or

in

credit cards.

to the address

To

FRC403

order via

below. $15 each

CD,

US

mail, send

a

check

$20 each DVD

The Field

$5 for 1st Class Mail.

Field Recorders' Collective, 6206 Washington Street, Ravenna, OH 44266

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FRC310

Dan Tate FRC506

Obray
&amp;

F|ies FRC6q2

made payable to the Field Recorders' Collective
PLUS

FRC505
Kilby

The Plank

FRC119

p

The Indian

Clyde Davenport Vol. 2 FRC1 04
Reverend Gary Davis FRC1 6
Dixie Hummingbirds

1

The Hurricane Ridgerunners
Esker Hutchins FRC1 07

Cornett FRC304

Clyde Davenport Vol.

The Nee Ningy Band

FRC707

char|je Hjggjns_ Wade
The Horse

FRC204

2

Vol

Rector Hicks FRC709'
1

7

The Chicken Chokers FRC603

Cockerham

1

Chirps Smith FRC608

Sidna &amp; Fulton Meyers FRC504
Howard Miller FRC706

1

Hausenfluck

The Hellbenders

Gaither Carlton FRC118
Ernie Carpenter

George FRC407

Albert Hash, Volume

riSL FKC2
Balta

Bill

Dennis McGee &amp; Sady Courville FRC308
Marcus Martin FRC502

arr FRnl

Brothers &amp; Nathan Abshire FRC1

Banjo

ihelor Blackard Family FRC112

Albert Hash FRC41

FRnns

Jont Blevins FRC1

Fred

Arnold Sharp

Addie Leffew &amp; Claude Wolfenbarger
FRC509

DVDS

in

nnrE RnnrK
l nn

Balfa

Kimble &amp; Wagoner Families FRC1 06

FRC302

Frank

3

Heywood Blevins FRC508

Dewey

FRC301

2

I

FRC31

PI Be|| FRC410
Berkeley

1

Norman Edmonds Vol.
Galax Gems FRC309

FRC108
Walter Babson

FRC406

Norman Edmonds Vol.

ffl*

Ray's Dream FRC115

Alden

Ray

John Ashby &amp; the Free State Ramblers

THE OLD-TIME

HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG

Recorders'
Collective
VOLUME

13,

NUMBER

11

1

�THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD
A

MAGAZINE

DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME

MUSIC

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.

POBox 61679
Durham, NC 27715

Phone and fax: (919) 286-2041
E-mail: info@oldtimeherald.org

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Sarah Bryan

BUSINESS DIRECTOR
Peter Honig
SENIOR ADVISORY EDITOR
Gail Gillespie

CONTRIBUTING

EDITORS

Bill Hicks, Phil Jamison, Bob Smakula,
Clare Milliner, Walt Koken

ART DIRECTOR
Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group

FOUNDING EDITOR
Alice Gerrard
ADVISORY BOARD
Mac Benford,

Hilary Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher,
Ramona Jones, Garrison Keillor,
Pete Kuykendall, Brad Leftwich,
Lee Smith, Pete Sutherland

OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Art Aylsworth,

Gail Gillespie,

Sally Council,
Jim Watson

January 2015
No part of this magazine may be reproduced
in any form without written permission from
the publisher. Not responsible for loss or non
return of unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
2014 the Old-Time Herald. The Old-Time Herald

(ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is published
quarterly by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
PO Box 61679, Durham, NC 27715. Subscrip
tion rates payable in advance. One year:
$20 (foreign subscriptions-- Canada $27US;
overseas $30US). Periodical postage rate paid
at Durham, NC 27715 and additional mailing
offices. Postmaster: Send change of address to
the Old-Time Herald, PO Box 61679, Durham,
NC 27715. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is
a not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation under
section 501 (c) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love
of old-time music. Old-time music
grassroots or
home grown music and dance
shares origins, influ
ences and musical characteristics with roots musics
tliroughout America. Our magazine, the Old-Time
Herald, casts a wide net, highlighting the Southeast

ern tradition while opening its pages to kindred
and comparable traditions and new directions. It

provides enlightening articles and in-depth reviews,
opportunities for musical learning and sharing, and
a forum for addressing the issues and questions that
bear upon the field.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Letters
have enjoyed reading Walt Koken's
account of the trials and tribulations of

We

A

String

Band

In

The

Early 1970s. In his

most recent account, "Mariposa"

OTH

mentioned the fiddle
the Smithsonian Folklife Fes

Vol. 13, No. 10), he

contest

at

tival in Washington, DC. We were there
and made the CBS Evening News, coast
to coast, jamming with J. P. Fraley and
Buddy Thomas. The fiddle contest was
judged by the four Kentucky fiddlers at
the Festival, including Thomas and Fra
ley. At the start of the contest, the judges
announced that a factor they would con
sider in the judging would be whether
the fiddler was

playing in the style of the
region from which he or she came, or in
a style "borrowed" from another
region.
Besides the fact that she is a very good
fiddler, perhaps one reason why my wife,
Vivian, won this contest was that she was
playing in the Pacific Northwest dance
fiddle style in which she was raised.
Phil Williams
Seattle, Washington

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�19 th

Annual

BEARS! SQUARE

mOUNTMN FESTIVAL
April 18-19, 2015

Dalilonega,

Ga.

MainStage Lineup:
Hog-eyed Man, The Threadbare Skivvies,
The Skillet Lickers, BlueBilly Grit,
The Buzzard Mountain Boys, Jason Kenney,
John Lilly, Sons of Bluegrass,
Curtis Jones and the Primal Roots,
Gospel Jam led by Glenda Pender

Jamming on Dahlonega's historic square,
free MainStage concerts, music workshops,
a juried traditional mountain crafts market,
live country auction,
gospel jam, children's
activities, great food
and more!

BearOnTheSquare
Section with Il

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Bole, Andover; Cordelia Rosmiarek, Bev
erly; Sadie Cacho, Amesbury.
The following were contest winners at
the 2014 Berkeley Old-Time Music Con

vention, which took place September

16

Berkeley, California. Old-Time Band:
Foot
Pig's
String Band (George Bradshaw,
Ed Cirimele, Ken Torke, Mark Wardeburg, Barbara Rosner, Linda Sullivan);
Sydney Special (Sydney Roberts, Stefan
Curl, Susan Sullivan); Bakesale Buddies
(Rowan McCallister, Allegra Thompson,
Emily Man, Robin Fischer). Best Family
Band: Yellins Ruyle and Granny and the
21 in

Girls. Best Bribe and Most Fiddles: Pos
sum Riot. Best Hats: Granny and the
Girls. Best Anagram: Evil Diane. Best Ka

raoke: Serenity Devine.
The 2014 South Carolina Fiddling Cham
pionship was held on September 21 in Pick

ens, South Carolina, with the following win
ners. Senior Fiddle: Robert Burns (South

Carolina State Fiddling Champion), Pey

ton O'Kelley, Nick Hallman. Junior Fiddle:
Mary Johnson, Jonathan Eernisse, Ella

Thomas. Junior Open: Danielle Yother,
Alex Alexander, Bailey George. Old-Time
Banjo: Bob Buckingham, Bailey George,
Josh Johnson. Guitar: Danielle Yother,
Nick Hallman, Alex Kelly. Old-Time String
Band:

Pumpkintown Honey Drippers,
Piedmont Mule Chasers, Out of the Blue.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�TALES FROM THE 'WOODS, PART 10
JENNY ON THE TURNPIKE
By Walt Koken

concerts in various community
park locations. The county or
town had a stage built on a semisized flatbed trailer, with back,

sidewalls, and roof constructed
entirely of metal. We performed
several

different

times

in

dif

ferent venues in this "tin can."
Folks would come out, bring
ing their folding chairs and ex
pecting to hear a polka band or

equivalent entertainment,

and

brighten their eve
best we could. Although

we would

ning

as

there would inevitably be one
or two young folks in the crowd
who got up and danced, for the

friend Jeff Warner had a school
the Guitar
Workshop in

Ourcalled

Roslyn, New York, on Long Island. Jeff's
father Frank Warner was a collector of
Appalachian folklore. He had recorded
Frank Proffitt, whose rendition of "Tom
Dooley" had somehow leaked, perhaps
slightly altered, into the repertoire of the
Kingston Trio. fheir hit recording of this
tune back in the 1950s had led me, and
others, I'm sure, down the twisty path
into the depths of old-time music. Jeff is
a wonderful folk musician, and a scholar
of sea chanteys and old English songs, as

well as Appalachian music. Periodically
he

would get us

to play for his

students,

and we met many

including
at

interesting folks there,
musical
Jeff's
accomplice

that time, Jeff Davis,

guitarist Peter

Pickow and his brother Jon, who lived

with their famous dulcimermother
Jean Ritchie, fiddler and
playing
Chris
Romaine, Irish musi
banjo player
cian Mick Moloney, and others who hap
pened to be passing through.
Jeff felt it was important for us to play
there, but in order to make it worthwhile
in the area

he would set up gigs
Hempstead, in Nassau
County, with whom he had some con
nections. Nassau County encompasses
for us financially,
with the Town of

a

very large area on Long Island, and in

the summer,

it

would sponsor outdoor

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

most part the audiences were
very sedate, and the tin-can effect
of the metal stage tended to cause the
sound system intermittent feed-back.
Not our favorite of gigs, but as they say,
ya gotta do what ya gotta do.
So it was that Jeff had roped us into
one of these gigs on a Thursday night
before the Galax Old Fiddler's Conven
tion, which was our destination for the
weekend. It was about 1973 or '74. We
needed to register for the contest the next
day, Friday, by suppertime, so we played
at our prescribed time at the park, then

packed up and took off at about eleven
o'clock on a warm summer evening.
Galax, in Southwest Virginia, was a long
haul from Long Island.

Our early '50s Ford panel trucks had
fallen by the wayside. They had six-volt
electrical systems, which tended to make
starting difficult. I had retired mine to fire
wood duty, where it provided trusty ser
vice for several more years. Meanwhile,
Highwoods had jointly purchased a used
window van, and tricked it out much the
same as the old panel trucks. It had two
seats in front for driver and navigator,
behind them a bench seat that could hold
three people, and behind that a plywood
bed set at seat-top height, with room for

instruments, luggage, and camp
ing gear underneath. We put a foam mat
tress on the bed, and Jenny had sewn a
cover for it, and some small curtains for
the side windows over the bed, affording
all the

a

bit of privacy. We put

a

lot of miles on

that baby. With a standard transmission
and no air conditioning, it was a chilly

ride in the winter, and stifling in the sum
mer. In those days we were on the road
about half of every year, so we spent a
lot of time together in it. Half of the year
in the van meant we had some time for
growing vegetables and other pastimes
and

supplemental occupations at home,
well as for getting together evenings
to work out new musical material, which
was an ongoing process.
as

On that

late-night departure from Long

Island, Bob took the first leg at the wheel,
while I navigated us west to the Verrazano
the

Narrows Bridge, and then south onto
New Jersey Turnpike. Mac and Doug

were soon asleep on the bed while Jenny
snoozed on the rear seat. Night driving
meant less traffic, but also held the dan

ger of falling asleep at the wheel, and we
hoped to cover some ground before the
next driver-navigator shift took over.
We had been traveling southbound an
hour or two when it came time for a pit

stop. We pulled into

a

service area on the

turnpike, and in the manner of

a

true pit

stop, with but a few minutes elapsing, Bob
quickly pumped the gas and checked the
tire pressure, while I debugged the wind
shield and checked the oil. We paid the bill
and silently took off, this time with me at
the wheel, Bob and I softly telling stories
while the others slept. Soon I asked Bob to
check and see if there was any coffee left
in the thermos. He turned around to look
for it under the rear seat, saying, "Jenny,
Jenny. .where's Jenny!!??" I thought he
was making a joke, but his shouting woke
up the others.
Well, she was not in the van. That much

we knew. And now that Mac and Doug
were awake, they knew it too. It was not
an easy situation, since we could not just
turn around on the turnpike. Bob looked
at the map, and the next exit on the pike

was another service area, about 20 miles
ahead, so that would be our first step in
retrieving Jenny.
Soon there we were,

at the next ser
vice plaza, somewhere on the New Jer
sey Turnpike, in the middle of the night,
separated from our beloved bass player
whom we had inadvertently deserted a
half-hour back up the road. We hoped
that she would stay put long enough for
us to get back to her, and headed into
the restaurant to try to find a way to call

�back to the service area where she was.
We sheepishly told the hostess our situ
ation and that we needed to contact the
previous plaza, and she obligingly wrote

down

a phone
number, and made us
some change for the phone booth. This
was literally decades before cellphones
came into being, so it was the phone
booth or nothing. Sort of a shot in the
dark. I dialed the number, deposited a

handful of quarters, and waited.

It was Jenny on the other end
phone! She was not happy. Not
happy at all. She had choice words for me.
She had sleepily and silently gotten out
of the van to visit the ladies' room, and
when she came back out, we were gassed
up and gone. Not knowing whether we
had just ditched her, or something else

"Hello?"

of the

had happened,

she had gone back into

down in a phone
booth to wait and possibly ask someone
for a ride. To add insult to injury, she
soon found herself being questioned by
the service area and sat

a pair of New Jersey Highway Patrol of
ficers. She told them that she was a mem
ber of an old-time music group, and that
she had been left behind by the four guys
in her band. They found that either im

or just nonsensical.
mere
coincidence, the number I di
By
aled happened to be the phone in the very
booth where she was sitting, and when
she told the troopers we were at the next

plausible

service

area, they gallantly offered to
a lift there, as that was the direc
tion they were going. That saved us from

give her

driving south

to the next exit, paying the
back
on the northbound lane,
toll, getting
to
the
first
exit
past where she was,
going
and repeating steps one and two in or

der to get to the Jennifer Cleland Service

Plaza. That would have taken us much
further into the long night than we really
wanted to go. Besides, there was a possi
bility that she would have already gotten
a lift from some fellow traveler to who

knows where.
Unfortunately for Jenny, her "free ride"
to listen to an ear

meant that she had

ful from the troopers, who laughed and
wondered what kind of dummies would

leave her stranded like that. By the time
they deposited her at the service area
where we were, she'd had about enough
of them and us. Our rationalizing and
sincere apologies didn't seem to cheer
her up much. So onward we rolled into
the night, southbound,
plank road.

down the old

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�EVERYONE SOUNDED DIFFERENT:
AN INTERVIEW WITH CHRIS COOLE
By Thomas Grant Richardson

Thomas Grant Richardson

more than 15 years, a strong and vibrant old-time music community has been growing steadily just north
of the 49th parallel, in Toronto, Ontario. Sparked by Cary Fagan's article in the OTH (Vol. 11, No. 12), which
gave a thoughtful overview of old-time music in Toronto, I began in-depth research there for my doctoral
work in folklore and ethnomusicology. In Toronto, we have a rich case study of a contemporary scene located
within a densely populated area (the city has a population of over 2.5 million), which has found value and sus
tenance in this traditional American art form. During my research I have met a number of players, participated
in jams, seen many bar shows, gone to square dances, camped in "Camp Canada" at Clifftop, and interviewed
musicians in their homes.
Throughout the course of my research nearly everyone has talked about Chris Coole, as one of the best banjo
players and teachers in Toronto (and beyond), and as one of the founding pillars of the current scene there. An
accomplished clawhammer banjo player as well as flat-pick guitarist, Chris is equally comfortable in old-time and
bluegrass, and maintains steady gigs with the bluegrass band the Foggy Hogtown Boys. This gives him a unique
perspective on the confluence of these genres. As one of the stalwarts of the Toronto scene, he also has insight on

For

the community, its history, practices, and aspirations.
On a cold Saturday afternoon in 2013, I sat down with Chris in his kitchen in the west end of Toronto, and we
talked about instruments, old-time and bluegrass, John Hartford, Bill Monroe, and teaching, all while he made us
a

dinner of homemade pizza. This

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is an

excerpt from that conversation.

-Thomas Grant Richardson

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Since doing this very "off-the-cuff" interview in 2013, a few things
have changed. The Good Right Arm Stringband is now defunct. This
past year I've made albums with the Lonesome Ace Stringband, as
well as Ivan Rosenberg, and the Foggy Hogtown Boys. Other than
that, I'm still playing away up here, very honored to be a part of the
old-time music tribe and grateful for all the wonderful music and
musicians from the past and present that continue to inspire.
-Chris Coole

�Could you give me a snapshot of your
musical activity right now?
dealing with right
probably doing too
the Foggy Hogmuch.
with
play
town Boys. That's traditionally been
One thing

now

I'm

is that

I'm

I

one of my main gigs.
play solo,
used to
once a week. That's what
I

1

do

a

lot when

I

was younger, and I
about 15 years,

it for

stopped doing

get back into that.
starting
with
Ivan
play
Rosenberg as a duo.
with
the
Good Right Arm
play
I
Stringband.
play with John Show
so I'm

to

I

I

and Max Heineman
Lonesome Ace Stringband.
man

in

the

play
with Arnie Naiman on occasion still,
play with
doing our duet stuff.
I

I

a

singer

We
rial.

named

Simone

Schmitt.

her original
She's more from the alt.

do

a

lot

of

try/ rock world. She's

songwriter

and

mate
coun

really good
singer. She used to
a

a band called $100, and now
she's in another band called Highest
Order and she does her own thing.

play in

And then one of the main things I've
been doing the past few years is as
a sideman for David Francey, who's
quite a successful singer-songwriter
here in Canada. He's won a bunch of
unos and stuff like that. I tour with
him, do gigs with him, record on his
albums. And teach a lot.

J

I

One thing you didn't mention is Crazy
Strings, and I don't entirely know the

difference between

Foggy

Hogtown

Boys and Crazy Strings.
I've been playing at that gig...
we think it's our fifteenth year. No
one remembers when it started, to
be honest with you. Over the years
there's been different people in the
band. It was always a bit of a jam.
So it's me, Joey Wright, Dan White-

Andrew Collins, Chris Quinn.
About five years ago we sort of took
it over as Crazy Strings.
My friend
with
the
name
came
some
Joey
up
one asked what the name of the
band was and there was no band,
ly,

and he just said Crazy Strings off the
top of his head. And we just called
the band that played on Wednesday

plus Marc Roy.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

just

I've ever met.

don't mean the best bluegrass
guitar player in Toronto...
mean the best bluegrass gui
tar player I've ever seen in my life.
And he showed up when he was 15
or something, just started showing
up and sitting in with us. But Marc
So you
I

doesn't live in Toronto right now. So
he's only in town every other week
or so. And we just chose to continue
with the name Crazy Strings be
cause it seems like the right thing to
do. That gig has always been Crazy
Strings. But Crazy Strings does not
exist outside the Silver Dollar.

And the Foggies are about 90% bluegrass?
I would
say not so much anymore.
I
would say the Foggies are 70%
bluegrass now. And that line has
definitely got a lot more blurred in

the past few years. Mostly because
of all the people in the band. We all

bluegrass, but I've always been
more into old-time music. But I love
bluegrass. I've always been much
better at playing old-time music
than I am at playing bluegrass.
like

bluegrass bands you play guitar.
Do you play any bluegrass banjo?
No.
mean, I can play that, a little
In the

I

bit.

what

It's

I

started playing years

and years ago, and
actually teach
it a little bit, but I've never played
I

bluegrass banjo

in

a

band.

That's [Chris] Quinn's role?

He's

the

bluegrass banjo

player.

But quite often we switch over and
play clawhammer banjo and he
I

plays guitar.

happens

at

Every set we play, that

some point now. Over

the past few years, Max and John got
more into old-time music, so now
half the band is more into old-time

music than bluegrass. Or listens to it
more anyways. So that's reflected in
our show. And frankly, I think that's
one of the things that sets us apart.

I

mean there's a lot of good bluegrass
bands out there, but there aren't a lot
of bands who can legitimately switch

Kim Sedore

night Crazy Strings. And then John
Showman joined, then Max [Heinemann] joined. And really it's al
ways been like a club. It's like whoever's in town. But these days the
band is the Foggy Hogtown Boys

started showing up at
Crazy Strings when he was about 15
years old, and he's literally the best
bluegrass guitar player I've ever
seen in my life, and I've seen all the
in the
good ones. He's the most
virtuosic
truest use of the word
Marc

The Lonesome Ace
I-

r,

Stringband:

Chris Coole, Max Heineman,

John Showman

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

over. A lot of them will touch on it,
but it's not really old-time music.
When we actually go into old-time

world, we're actually pretty close to
actually playing old-time music. It

sounds like
Rather than

a

old-time band.

an

bluegrass band trying...?

Rather than a bluegrass band taking
breaks over "Angeline the Baker," and
then saying they're playing old-time
music. I think we do the bluegrass
thing very well and I think in the
past few years, when we go to bluegrass festivals or when we're down at
IBMA, the thing people notice about
us is that we're actually pretty good at
switching over to old-time music.

How

do you

blending?

Is

feel about that kind of
that different in Toronto

from what you experience in the States?
There seems to be this idea in the States
that there's a hard line between bluegrass and old-time. That they're two to
tally different things and we don't mix
them. I'm not sure if it's that separate.
I
think in the hardcore bluegrass
scene it's still more separate. I think
most people who play old-time mu

sic up here probably

stumbled onto

stumbling was
Most
bluegrass.
people up here who
I think, at some
play bluegrass,
point
in their lives didn't know what the
difference was between old-time
music and bluegrass. And then they
it,

so

part

got into

it

of

their

and the whole thing got

a

bit more focused, and they realized
it's two different things. Then they
decided which of those two things

they like more. But having gone
through that period of not knowing
there was a difference, that makes
them more accepting of it.
got into old-time music and bluegrass at the same time. I liked them
both. This was in '89 or '90...
I

And how old were you?
Well,

I

got my first banjo when

I

was 17. And that would have been
in 1990. And I'm a very obsessive
person, when
I

I

really get into

get into something
it. Those were my

young years. Those were the years

that if you were obsessive... you're
a kid, so you have the time to pour
yourself into it. I just can't express

how important

that

all

seemed

to

me at the time. Very soon after was
into it, I went down to the Augusta
I

�Coole
Chris
courtesy

Chris Coole busking at age 17.

Heritage Center

[at

Elkins,

Davis and Elkins
West

College

in

for

the

fall

for

about three years after,

[Old-Time

Virginia]
and

Week],
I

would

volunteer there. That's where

I've heard part of this story from Scott.
Yeah, me and him, we were serious
kindred spirits. It was such a wicked
time for old-time music, because all

guys like... John Herrmann, and
[Bruce] Molsky, and Brad Leftwich...
they were probably the age that am

the

I

now, or maybe slightly older. They'd
been playing for a long time, but they
were so into it. There was a lot of
It was a cool time
fire in the music.
because it was... weird! I mean, oldtime music may seem weird now,
but it was even weirder 20 years ago.
Because you really felt like you were
part of a secret society. And that's
loved
what loved about it. mean
the music, it was moving me, but I re
mean it
ally dug the mystery of it.
was so fucking weird!
I

a

place

like Augusta?

it was, yeah! I still think it
still think it was more insular.

To me

was.

I

met

I

Scott Prouty.

1

You think that was true, even at

1

1

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Old-time still confounds people. Many
people in Toronto have said it's secret,
Do you
it's tucked away, it's hidden.
feel that's accurate?

perception

By my

of it,

it

doesn't

feel that way anymore, but I think
It's still a weird thing.
it totally is.
I mean,
if
go knock on every house
I

on

my

know
about

block,

what

if

I

nobody's
the

fuck

going to
talking
them about

I'm

start talking to

old-time music.

But back to the

distinction between

think those
a lot to do with the oldhad
camps
time musicians and the bluegrass
musicians sort of coming together.
Because you'd get all these great
players who were on staff at the

bluegrass

and old-time.

I

same time, and you'd have cross
over jams with really good players. I
mean, the teaching staff. remember
I

�You

may occasionally get in a jam
and have a drink and say
hello. But most of the time you're

John Hartford is

lots of small camps in Canada.
And [went] over to England in April
[2013] to teach at Sore Fingers. I've
taught at this camp in British Co
lumbia a lot over the years. Now it's
called Nimble Fingers. And this is
It's been going a long
a cool thing.
think it's the best camp
time and
I've ever been to. It's in such a great
location. And everybody's living on
site. It's in the mountains. And it's
well run. The people who took it over

session

old-time

are both

made no contact with anyone else
who's played there.
But these camps, where you a get
these musicians and they'd be liv
ing together in the same place for
five or six days... they'd actually
have a chance to make a connec
tion! Then you begin seeing albums
like Dirk Powell and Tony Furtado's
come out. And Tim O'Brien started
showing up. think Tim O'Brien was
aware of old-time music and was
playing it, but I feel like they were
started
two distinct things when
then
over
the
and
down
there,
going
next ten years I really started seeing

How long did you go down to Augusta?
to fall Au
I went once as a student,
summers.
One
then
three
and
gusta,
summer was there all summer, and
was
then two or three summers
there for two weeks, volunteering.

he was the
seeing Dudley Connell
lead singer for the Johnson Moun
remember seeing him
tain Boys
in a jam with Melvin Wine. And he
I

was loving it. And it's one thing, you
go play at a festival and all these
great musicians are there, and you
think "This is cool. Great, they're
pals

this festival." But

at

musicians

don't have time when they're work
ing. Nothing ever really happens.

just doing your thing and you leave
at the end of the festival. And you've

I

1

a

lot more

interplay between the two

music. I've thought about it
styles
a lot.
really feel that those camps
had a lot to do with that. You take
of
I

bluegrass people, and you take
the old-time people... well, all of a
sudden, Tim O'Brien, who's respect
ed in bluegrass, is playing with John
the

Herrmann, who's very respected

it,

If

guess it's alright. If they're doing
why shouldn't we do it?"

the famous people are doing it...?

Yeah, if the famous people are
crossing over, maybe it's cool. And
remember when [John] Hartford
first started coming down. I remem
ber when he first came down to oldtime things, people were very... He
and Bill Monroe are my two favor
ite musicians, so I was thrilled to
I

be

near him, but

lot of

anywhere
people in old-time music were like,
a

"What's he doing here?" It was al
most like there was a distrust of him.
And that changed over the next few
years. He proved himself. He put out
all those great Ed Haley albums, and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

don't know how you'd
bluegrass
define Hartford but everyone was
thinking, "Oh, it's cool." His fiddle
albums are really good. They're
not traditional old-time but they're
great. And he's obviously into it. All
that stuff, to me, started opening it
I

up.
a weird
example. His
weird old-time, but his bluegrass is also pretty weird bluegrass.
He didn't fit in either.

is

I

I

Doing this and that. One of the cool
was there
things I got to do while
like
Melvin
was... they'd get guys
Wine and Leland Hall and they'd
need someone [to assist them]. If
1

you got someone that old you can't
just say, "Okay, you go to this class."
You need someone with them all the
time. From the moment they go to

to the moment they go to
bed. Out of respect, you got to make
sure everything's cool. So that was
one thing I was able to do, which
was great. Unfortunately I was such
looked so
a hippy back then, and

breakfast

1

never made a great connec
crazy,
tion with them. But I still got to hang
out with them all the time.
I

in

old-time music, and they're playing
together. And everyone's like. "Oh,
I

did so much work for that. And so
there was this guy who was sort of

Have you ever taught at Augusta?
Yeah, I taught there once a few
years ago at their fall Old-Time
Week. taught banjo there.
1

Do you have an established number of
camps you teach at?
I've been making my living at music
for 20 years now, and I still will rarely
turn

anything

down

money. Just in the past
I

that

couple of years

will occasionally turn down

bar gig, just
to

a

shitty

know it's going
But I would teach at

because

bum me out.

involves

I

any camps. They're great gigs. They're
fun. I enjoy teaching a lot. I get to meet

well.

So

anytime anyone asks me to teach
camp, I'm there in a second.

at a

my heroes.

And

they pay

I've taught at Midwest Banjo Camp.
I've taught at Augusta. I've taught

at

I

When

I

musicians, Julie and Craig.
first started going there, hav

ing old-time music was a really new
thing. I've been teaching there eight
or nine years, and it's really opened
up to where most of the jams you see
are actually old-time jams. At least
it's so much more ac
cessible than playing bluegrass.

50/50. Because

Do you mean being

a

novice

or

interme

diate player gets you farther as an oldtime player than as a bluegrass player?
You can get into playing music
quicker. And you can get into some
important things about mu
quicker playing old-time music
than you can playing bluegrass. You
develop a sense of melody quicker,
which is super important. All the
of the
sic

great [early] bluegrass guys grew up
listening to old-time music. There
was no

bluegrass.

The formative ones...
Yeah, the guys! The guys that in
vented the genre! Yeah, Monroe
Monroe did not grow up listening to
bluegrass, obviously. Ralph Stanley
did not grow up listening to bluegrass. The McReynolds brothers did

not grow up listening to bluegrass.
Jimmy Martin... well, Jimmy Martin
sort of grew up listening to Bill Mon

first-generation bluegrass guys grew up listening to oldroe. But those

time and country and gospel music.
And to me, it's a good case for, if
you want to learn to play bluegrass,
learn to play old-time first so you get

sense of fiddle rhythms, you get
sense of playing the melody.
a

Do you find

a

big distinction, in playing
between the US and Cana
how attitudes are preconceived?
a

and teaching,
da? In

Yeah, in the States they're more used
to it. Just by virtue of the amount of

people there. All the scenes are a lit
tle bigger and more established. I'll

�teach at

workshop

a

it's getting better, but

pens

I'll go teach

a

it

still

hap

banjo workshop

recording de

and no one will have a
vice. And you go to the States and
they've basically got film crews set
up! Everybody's ready for it! And in
Canada, again, it's gotten a lot better
in the past 10 years, but I remember,

Canada, after a
camps
teaching
while you realize, "I don't just have
also have to teach
to teach the tune,
what this music is."
in

at

1

history and culture?

In terms of

don't feel that comfort
able delving into that. More just what
it's like to play it. Like what you're
trying to do here and what you're
trying to achieve, with the jam ses
sions and with the community. And
where it's coming from and how
it's different from bluegrass. Why
it's different from bluegrass. Why
it might be better that it's different
Yeah, but

I

from bluegrass. It's good that it's dif
ferent from bluegrass. But you have
to

convince people who

are

coming

wasn't like...
So there's
cousin.
bluegrass's simple
a bit more of that. When I go down
to the States, unless I'm teaching a
from bluegrass that

it

super beginner class, the people are
hip to it already.
What about with private students here
in Toronto?

Again, it's gotten a lot better over
Now I'd say 50% of the
teach
sort of know what it is
people
the years.
I

they're trying to do. What they're af
you know, for a long time, one
of the hardest things was that most of
my students had a very vague idea
of what their goal was. They sort of
thought they liked the banjo or some
ter. But

Again, a lot of it was trying to
introduce them to the music enough
that they could form an opinion of
what they wanted to do with it. Be
cause they hadn't listened to enough
of it, and hadn't seen it played to the
point where they were able to get a
vision. To get to the point where they
thing.

can say, "Oh there's all this stuff out
like." Even
here, but this is what
within the genre. The more you ex
I

plore
for me

it

and this is still
the more

I

educated my decision is for how
want my music to sound.

Canada and

in

happening

explore, the more

get sharper vision of style and aes
thetic in my music and what I want.
learn about it, the more
The more
I

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

nothing old about it. They way you
see people play at festivals, jamming at

I

Clifftop or whatnot, that to me is more
modern than bluegrass. The standard
ized way of playing, with the claw

terms of the aesthetics of your de
cisions, can you trace a path of what
you've been after since you've been a
In

hammer banjo and the guitar playing
essentially a bluegrass rhy thm, and the
fiddle players playing in an extremely

professional musician, through people
you've wanted to sound like, to sound

I mean, it's sort of traced
Round Peak guys, like
Tommy Jarrell. Those guys were huge
influences on how people play oldtime music. But to me it doesn't sound
old. When I listen to old records, that's
hear at Cliffnot anything like what
I don't think that's
Which
is
good.
top.
bad. I just think that it's unfortunate
that the music is labeled. To me, when
the way it's
I listen to old-time music
and there're
played most of the time
different examples, like Mike Seeger,
people who have been really great at

ing like Chris Coole? You said your two
favorite musicians were Bill Monroe
and John Hartford; so did you start out
to

trying

rhy thmic way,

back

play like them?

No, I've never really tried to learn
to play like anybody. I know ev
erybody says that, but I never re
ally learned note for note off people.
do remember, I
But the one thing
would try to learn things off records
when I was first starting. This was
so it

was me going to
found,

record stores and whatever

I

Deseret String Band al
bum, I'd learn go home with the
"Girls in the Morning." If it was a
Little Roy Lewis album, I'd learn
"Preacher and the Bear." So it was
just a mish-mash of whatever I could
find. It's always been important for
the music to have context within my
life, otherwise I would have felt like
I was
working at Pioneer Village or
if

it

was

a

playing that old style and doing it in
their own way
looking back on it, to
essence
of
old-time music was
tire
me,
that everyone sounded different. That
was it! And I understood that early on.
There's no right way to do this. Just like
Bill Monroe and John Hartford, who
are really in the spirit of individuality,
I've always needed to be myself. To
sound like myself. And that's impor

something. That's something I've re
ally been aware of.
I
actually think it's

old-time music
I

is

think it's

tant to anyone who plays music.

unfortunate that
called "old-time

stupid name. I
think it's really limiting. I hate that
it's got this baggage of being old,
don't want to get
which it isn't.
into this thing of acting like I'm old,
dressing like I'm old. I mean, I grew

music."

a

terms of the Clifftop jam style, are
you reacting to the style or also the in
strumentation and repertoire?
In

Yeah, the instrumentation, and the
common repertoire. And the tunes
often are played in a similar way.

I

up in an
in

a

neigh

upper-middle-class

big city, and I've lived
big city my whole life. And I've

borhood in

a

always been aware that

if

want

I

to

do this properly, the only way is to
make the music have context within,

Talking with African American old-time

players, one of the common frustrations
was that instrumental dance tunes came
to stand for old-time as a whole. Songs
got left out, rags got left out, blues got
left out.
When did that become old-time mu
I love it. I love
doing it. I love
I don't
it.
disparage the fact
playing

was born into
and the life that I've chosen to live.
and reflect, the life

I

sic? And

that that has become old-time music,

Do you get push-back on that because of
where you grew up or live? Either the
urban aspect or the Canadian aspect?
years old?
don't think do. think used to
think
used to think
did.
think
people thought that, but now I don't
think people are
think they do.

you're not

Or the fact that

I

I

I

but it's proof that it's totally changed.

I don't know if it holds
think it's a barrier for
people exploring a little bit with it.

And it's not old.

80

it

I

I

tire

I

I

pre-Internet,

to

back, but

I

I

1

I

pretty accepting of what

I

do.

But tire tiring that gets me about it
being called "old-time music" is that
the way it's played,

right now, there's

have your teaching DVD. Is there any
thing outside of that that is fundamen
tal to your teaching method?
If you
It's definitely for beginners.
come for a beginner's lesson you'll hear
I

me say

a

lot of those identical things.

I

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Wilson
Rodney

Chris Coole

mean, I didn't script that or anything,
just went in there and did my thing.
But

similar

that's

to

what [your]

that

stu

dents start out on?

Absolutely.
teach.
teacher.
I

It's

exactly the
learning

But I'm still

way
as

a

did that when
glad
I
did, but there's still technique
things, subtle technique things and
ways to explain things, and things I

wished

I'm

I'd

I

thought of when

I

changed the bridge, but other than
I haven't done
anything to it.

I

made

that video. Just subtle little things.

me about the head. It's totally
worn through.
It's a fiberskyn head with the fiber
skyn just worn away. A fiberskyn
head has a clear plastic head and the
other head on top of it. It actually
has two layers. So it's a normal fiber
skyn head, and I just went through
the fiberskyn layer on it.

Tell

Just from using it?
Tell me

little about your Vega banjo.
It's a late-'70s Vega that was prob
ably made in Korea. Well, overseas
a

got it back around '92 or so.
was more set up for bluegrass.
I had
it set up with a higher action
and a fiberskyn head put on it, and

anyway.
And

it

I

to

a

fire or

It

didn't get too close

anything?

No, just from using it. I mean, I was
busker. And I played mostly in the
subways. And the subways are dirty
as hell. Like, I'd come out and blow
my nose and it would be black! So
a

my banjo just ended up getting really

�Sedore
Kim

Chris Coole (center)

dirty as

a

recording session with Scott Prouty and John Gallagher.

result of that.

And

was

it

lot. In those days I was play
lot. Hours and hours a day.

used
ing

a

at

a

a

And what about the main guitar you
use? Last time I saw you play you had an
odd-shaped guitar. What kind is that?
don't know what kind of guitar it is.
It's something from Chicago. Around
I

the turn of the century. It's not

a

Regal,

because Bob Carlin said it's not
gal and he wrote

a

a

Re

book on the things.

As far as he's concerned it's from

cago. It's similar to
but I don't think it's

Chi

some Washburns,

Washburn. You
know how there was all those guitar
a

companies in Chicago... it's one of
those Chicago guitars.

ones. And

And it's cool that they all sound differ
ent. I have a really cool dreadnaught
that I've had for years that
for

such an interesting shape.
It's

a

really good guitar. But

interested

in

instruments.

1

am not

Someone

will glaze
starts talking about banjos,
over so fast. I'm not interested in them
I

at

all.

I'm interested

in

having good

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

everything. Then

I

I

just played

got into finger-

style guitar five or six years ago. And
liked
I had
a guitar made for me, and
could fingerit. It was an OM size.
I

is so

ing

a

big you'd swear you were play
dreadnaught if you closed your

eyes. Your arm is in the same place as
if you were playing a dreadnaught. So
it's perfect because it gives me that nice
old, dry sound, that you like for oldtime music. But it feels like you're play
ing a dreadnaught. And it's really got a
big sound for strumming.

I

never felt comfortable
was a great guitar,
flat-picking
used it. And I was teaching at
and
this camp out in BC, and Chris Quinn
came up to me and said, "You got to
pick on

it,

but

on

I

it. It

I

play this old guitar that's here. You got

check
terested.
to

I

It's

have them. And as far as

I

I'm concerned, you have to have a few
extra ones, for tunings in live shows.

it

out." And

I

said

I

wasn't in

had two guitars already. And
eventually played that guitar, and it
I

was the guitar I'd be waiting for my
knew within minutes. It
whole life.
I

sounds amazing
sounds amazing

for finger picking. It
for flat-picking. It's

ladder-braced, so it's got that funky
old sound. But the way the back bout

And what other banjos do you use?
Honestly, I only ever play that banjo.

My Vega. I'm sort of a one-instrument
person. mean, in the case of the gui
I

tars... one's

a

instrument,

bluegrass

one's for everything else. But as far as
the banjos go, I really always use, that
one banjo, and I always have.
Thomas Grant Richardson

currently fin
folklore and ethnomuishing
sicology at Indiana University. He is the
Curator of Education and Outreach at the
Birthplace of Country Music Museum in
Bristol Tennessee/Virginia.
his

PhD

in

is

�stood in Jan Fitzgerald's home recent
ly in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma, hold
ing her father's familiar old fiddle in
my hands and trying to wrap my mind
around the fact that it had been almost 40
years since I had last seen it or heard him
play. Tom Fuller's fiddle was just as I re
membered: the top was painted brown,
which he had done when he discovered
he had no varnish in the house after a
repair (I can still hear his voice: "Brad,
I'm the kind of fellow who likes to get
a
job done one way or another."), and
there was the old rosin-encrusted bow
with enough of the finish worn away to
reveal that it was made of aluminum.
Miraculously, the glue joints were still
solid; the strings, bridge, and sound
post were all there; and enough hair re
mained in the bow to hold rosin from
the ancient cake that I found in the
compartment of the case. I carefully
tuned it up and then launched into
one of his tunes: "Jan's Tune," he had
called it, because it was his daughter's
favorite. It was an emotional moment.

I

Jan's daughter Cindy caught it on her
cell phone camera and immediately
emailed the video clip to me. I couldn't
help but be struck by the odd incongru
ity of that ultra-modern technology and
the beat-up old fiddle. How vastly dif
ferent must have been the world Tom

Brad

Leftwich

Fuller was born into

Tom

Fuller's fiddle.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

124 years earlier!

�TOM FULLER:

THE LIFE AND TIMES OF A FIDDLER FROM INDIAN TERRITORY
By Brad Leftwich
A hard start in

life

Both sides of Tom's family were from
His maternal
Missouri.
grandfather,
Aaron A. Baxter, was a Baptist circuit
preacher who had moved with his fam
ily from Missouri to Texas around 1882.

Tom's father, Thomas Daniel Fuller, mar
ried Aaron's daughter Emma around the
same time. The new couple came to Texas

also, most likely accompanying her fam
older siblings were all born in
Star
State.
the Lone
Even as the Fullers started their own
family, calamity befell the Baxters. Aar

ily. Tom's

on's descendents say he was murdered.
The story that has been passed down in
the family is that his horse returned one
day without him, and he was found shot
in the back,

robbed of the church collec

tion money.

I

The Fullers moved to Indian Territory
about 1889. Tom was born November 20,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1890, and his parents named him Thom
as Lonzo Fuller. He was the next-to-

youngest of six children, and the first to
be born in their new home in the Chicka
saw Nation. They lived near what is now
the town of Countyline, on the boundary

between Stephens and Carter Counties

southern Oklahoma.
At that time there were actually two
territories: Indian Territory, or I.T., was
in

roughly the southeastern part of the
present state, and Oklahoma Territory,
or O.T., was the northwestern part. Big
changes were afoot in Oklahoma Ter
ritory. Lands that had previously been
held as reservations for various Native
American nations were being opened to
white settlement through a series of land
runs. These were dramatic and colorful
events in which throngs of people would
mass along the border and, at the shot of

pistol on a given date and time, race
horseback, in wagons, or on foot
to claim land. Cities sprang up literally
a

in on

|^BH

overnight.

When the Cheyenne and Arapaho reservation was opened in 1892, Elizabeth
Baxter, Tom's grandmother, recovering
from her husband's murder, packed up
her children to start over again in Oklahoma Territory. On April 19, she and her
family lined up with 25,000 other hopeful settlers. The starting gun was fired at

noon, and they were among the fortunate
ones who were able to stake a claim. They
established a farm in Washita County

near present-day Mountain View, not too
far from her daughter and son-in-law.
Before

long,

misfortune struck

again

this time in the Fuller family. Tom's mother Emma died in 1896, when he was six
years old. His father, unable to care for the

n-^nMr

a

Jt

r

Hopeful settlers begin gathering for the opening of
the Cheyenne- Arapahoe reservation on April 19,
1892. Tom's grandmother Elizabeth Baxter and her

family made the land run and successfully staked
a claim.
(Clinton Daily News Photo Archive,
Clinton, Oklahoma)
Above:
in

Tom's

1906 when

mother,
he was

of the Fuller family)

Emma Baxter Fuller, died
just six years old. (courtesy

�courtesy Fuller family

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Tom 's

Aunt Nora and her husband, John D. Williams, took

Williams became

a

father figure

to

children by himself, placed them with
other families. Just two years later, in Earlsboro, Oklahoma Territory, the father was
involved in an altercation over two of the
girls. It's unclear what exactly caused the
trouble, but gunfire erupted and he was
fatally wounded. Young Tom became an
orphan at the age of eight.
Tom and
a

all of his

siblings except

married older sister went

to

Tom in as a

young teenager.

Tom, who always said "that's the man who raised me.

for

live with
farm she

their grandmother on the
homesteaded in Washita County. Tom

lived there for two or three years (he ap
pears as a member of the household in
the 1900 census). She gave him a loving
home, and ever afterwards he was espe
cially fond of her.
Elizabeth raised at least eight children
of her own. After the death of her hus

band and taking in her orphaned grand
children, she became the head of quite a
large household. To ease the strain, Tom
went to live with his sister who, in a

now-familiar pattern for the family, was
already a widow herself with two small

children. There was plenty for him to do,
and he made himself useful.
Shortly thereafter, Tom met the girl
who would become his wife. At the

"

time, he was

12 years old and Abbie
was just 7. Tom and his
older sister were traveling by wagon
from western Oklahoma to visit family

Gail Stearns

Missouri. They had reached Boggy
Creek when one of their horses died.
Tom's sister borrowed a horse from
the Stearns family, and left Tom there
perhaps to guarantee the return of the
horse. He turned out to be such a good
worker around the farm that Abbie's
parents wanted to keep him, give him
a
good home, and send him to school.
Before long, however, his sister sent for
him. Tom and Abbie stayed in touch,
sending letters back and forth.
As a young teenager, Tom went to live
in

with his aunt and uncle, Nora Baxter and
John D. Williams. They lived not far to
the east of his grandmother's place, on
a

farm near Fort Cobb in Caddo County.

His uncle was the archetypal cowboy: tall,
lean, and tough, with a big mustache and a
strong work ethic. Williams became a role

model for the fatherless boy and had a big
influence in the molding of his character.
He was very good to Tom, who always de
scribed him as "the man who raised me."
He taught Tom about horses and livestock,

�courtesy Fuller family

1922 the Fullers were able

In

to leave a

hardscrabble life on the farm when Tom landed

a

job as

a

roustabout for the Roxana Oil Company.

I

r,

Loyce, Tom,

Abbie, and Tommy.

cowboy work, and farming, and paid him
for his work around the place.

was about this time that Tom began

It

playing the fiddle. He taught himself to
play by ear, and was active playing for
dances in the area from his early teens
through his early twenties.

He was eager to get out on his own, so

when he was about

15 he

took over

a

field

his uncle, "bached" in a shack by
himself, and raised a crop. It was a hard
from

life with few comforts. At night he rolled

out
in

a
a

pallet; in fact, he said he never slept
bed before he was 21 years old. It's

to imagine that playing the fiddle
would have been welcome entertainment.
Because he had to work, Tom didn't get
as far in school as he would have liked.
His wife Abbie told me he went to a
country school near Fort Cobb and prob
ably made it to seventh or eighth grade.
Most of Tom's classmates and friends at
school were Native Americans, and he
could speak some of their language.
By 1910 Tom was boarding with his old
er brother Willis, the two of them farming

not hard

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

together on their uncle's land near Fort

Cobb. Tom had continued his correspon
dence with Abbie, once even managing
to talk with her by telephone. He went to
visit in person when he was 17. After that
the tempo

of the courtship

accelerated,

marriage in 1915. He was
25 years old and she was 19.
They settled initially in Cox's Store,
about 10 miles east of Lawton. Tom had
a
variety of jobs, doing cowboy work,
farming, and hauling with a wagon and
team. They moved several times: first
to Lawton, where their oldest daughter,
Loyce, was born in 1916; then west of
Lawton where they rented a farm with
a two-room house for about a year; then
back to Cox's Store where Tom sharecropped with his father-in-law. Their sec
ond child, Tommy, was born in 1920.
This was a hard time for the Fullers. Tom

leading

to their

a
living, and Loyce said
starved
to death on the farm.
they nearly
life
and
long hours of work left
Family
little time for music, and Tom played for
fewer dances during this period.

struggled

to earn

Boom times
The Fullers' luck began to change with
the oil boom in Oklahoma and Texas. In
1921, oilfields were developed in the vi
cinity of nearby Duncan, Oklahoma, and
in 1922 the family was able to leave the
farm when Tom landed a job as a roust
about. He hired on initially with the Rox
ana Oil Company,

a

predecessor

to

Shell

Oil, and then he worked for Shell for the
rest of his career. The family moved fre

quently

at first

as Tom

was transferred

back and forth between Oil City and Gas
City, two boomtowns near Duncan.
In 1929 Shell sent Tom to Kilgore, in
East

Texas,

to

work in newly opened
a roustabout was

oilfields there. Being

transient job, so the family remained
Duncan. Tom lived out of his car, but
this was during the Great Depression
and he felt lucky to have a job at all. In
a

in

to give more people jobs, Shell
worked employees in alternating twoweek shifts. Tom would drive back to

order

Duncan during his time off. Their third
child, Jan, was born there in 1930.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

In 1932, Tom moved up to a more desirable job as a pumper, responsi
ble for operating and maintaining the oil well pumps on the company's

lease. A year later, another pumper position opened up in McCamey, in
the arid expanse of West Texas, and Tom was chosen to fill it. Because
being a pumper was a stationary job, the Fullers were able to be together
again

as

a family.
took
They
up residence in a shotgun house among the pump jacks on
the Sapp oil lease about 10 miles out of McCamey, in a valley between the
low, flat-topped peaks of King Mountain and Castle Mountain. Soon they
moved into the Shell Camp, comprising several houses for employees and
a community hall where Tom played for dances. They relocated to anoth
er oil lease that was closer to town when Jan was in junior high, but they
never left the McCamey area again until Tom retired. Their fourth child,

Dan, was born there in 1937. They felt very prosperous, especially when
Shell replaced their old shotgun house with a brand-new house with in
door plumbing and an actual bathroom.

the 1920s the family moved several times as Tom was
transferred hack and forth between Oil City and Gas City, two
boomtowns near Duncan, Oklahoma.

During

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

family
Fuller
courtesy

Tom

initially taught himself

to

play by

ear, but he was

proud when

he

learned

to

play "by note"

in the

early 1920s.

Tom retired in 1953 after 30 years with
Shell Oil. He loved horses and stock, and
loved growing things, so after spending
so

many years in the arid countryside of

West Texas, he and Abbie moved to the
lush Ouachita Mountains of Polk Coun
ty

in

western Arkansas. They bought

a

house and 52-acre farm in the commu
nity of Ink, near Mena. Tom farmed and
even did some cowboy work right up to

the age of 75. Then the couple moved into
Mena, where they lived out their remain
ing years. Tom died on March 13, 1979, at
the age of 88.

Tom's life as
In his

a

musician

early teens, about 1905 or

a

little

before, Tom sold bluing, a product used
to whiten laundry, to earn extra money
to buy his first fiddle. He taught himself
to play by ear initially, watching and lis
tening to other fiddlers in the area. He
played quite a few dances as a teenager
and into his early twenties. After mar
riage in 1915, he still played occasionally
for dances, but not as often.
Eager to improve his skills, he took some
lessons from a music teacher in Hulen,

in the early 1920s, before he
and his family moved to Oil City. Hulen
is a small town southeast of Lawton, and

Oklahoma,

would have been about

a

20-mile round

trip from his home near Cox's Store. He

was proud of learning to play "by note,"
and afterwards he enjoyed playing mu
sic from the church hymnal. He used to
joke that he played fiddle for dances and
violin for church.
In the early years of Tom and Abbie's
marriage, while they were still living in
Oklahoma, there weren't many other
musicians with whom Tom could play
on a regular basis. He didn't have much
spare time for music during that period
of his life in any case. But on the
sions when he did play for a dance,

occa

a

gui

tar or banjo player often seconded him.
With the move to McCamey, Texas, in 1933,

Tom's music once again began to flourish.
There were more opportunities to make mu
sic, and more musicians with whom to play.
And he didn't have far to look for backup:

when daughter Jan grew old enough, she
began playing music with him. She was his
main accompanist until 1947, when she left
home

to go to

college

in

Denton.
a small violin as

Tom started Jan out on

�family
Fuller
courtesy

Tom

depended on

Jus

daughter

Jan for backup at dances

young girl. In the two-violin configura
tion they played mostly hymns together,
both at home and sometimes for Sunday
evening services at the First Methodist
a

Church. She says she nearly mastered
one hoedown, which Tom dubbed "Jan's
Tune" in her honor. Jan remembers her
father telling her, "When I'm gone, I want
you to have my violin." And she still has
it to this day, along with the small violin
he bought to get her started.
When Jan reached her early teens, Tom
taught her to play guitar, and she began
backing him up at dances. Playing for
long dances on a steel-strung regular gui
tar was hard on her fingertips, however,
so when she was in junior high school
Tom bought her a lap steel guitar, which
was played with a slide. Before long they
bought a piano for $100 (which her son

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

until she left for college

in

1947. They also enjoyed twin fiddling on hymns.

Steve still owns), and Jan learned to ac
company fiddle tunes on it.
Dances were a popular form of en

tertainment

in

the

1930s

and

ery month or so Tom played
sponsored by Shell Oil for its

'40s.
for

Ev

parties

employees,
when she was old enough

joined by Jan
to provide backup. The parties featured
dancing as well as free beer, sodas, barbeque, and watermelon. Jan and her sis
ter Loyce said people danced two-steps,
waltzes, and polkas as well as square
dances at these events.
Tom's son Dan came along later, seven
years younger than Jan. He picked up the
steel guitar she left behind when she went
to college, and he then began playing with
his father.

Dan remembers that the venues

where they performed included VFW danc
es and the Holiness Church, where one of

Tom's musician friends was

a

member. (The

Fullers were lifelong Methodists.)

dance fiddler had to be versatile. Tom
played plenty of traditional hoedowns
and waltzes, as well as some schottisches and polkas, but he also kept up with
trends in popular country music and
eagerly learned anything new that ap
pealed to him. Bob Wills was very big at
that time, and Tom bought sheet music
for some of his hit songs. His son Dan still
has a box of Tom's music that includes
A

titles like Johnnie Lee Wills' "Rag Mop,"
Spade Cooley's "Oklahoma Waltz," Jack
even Cole
Guthrie's "Oklahoma Hills"

Porter's "Don't Fence Me In" and Irving
Berlin's "Alexander's Ragtime Band."
But he gave even the tunes he learned
from sheet music a distinctive sound that
was all his own.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Tom played other instruments

as

well.

He learned to play French harp, mounting
it in a holder around his neck and accom

panying himself on guitar. There's also
photo of him playing lap steel guitar.
Tom and Abbie's older son Tommy

a

mar

ried into the Tidwell family, a musical clan
in nearby Midland, Texas, with whom Tom

played music whenever he could. Tom
my's wife Oneida Tidwell played guitar
and sang, her sister Etta Pearl and brother
Bill also sang, and "Daddy" Tidwell played

fiddle.

In the early 1950s, Tom, with his son
Dan on lap steel, went with the Tidwells
to a studio in Midland and made a record.

"San Antonio

Rose"

is on one

side, and

"Kelly Waltz" is on the other.
i ms was
strictly

saying that he was inspired
fiddle after

since
tne
rammes
knew each other and
played music togeth
er regularly, there's

fied with his job
at Shell Oil and

good
could

a

didn't

it

a

Tom

aspire to
career in mu

However, he
associated with
musicians in Mcsic.

After

a

with

Castle

whom he played
was
regularly

retirement,
played for
few dances at the

Tommy

Oil

who

center

in

Ink,

Arkansas.

He

loved

to get

to

gether with other
musicians when he

of

a

community

had

courtesy

fellow Shell

any

Tom still

family. One of the

Wayland Seals,

been

In

gree by his fiddling.

teresting musical
connection with
the famous Seals

musicians

Fuller.

Jimmy played
music with Tom and
no doubt was influ
enced to some de

in

an

possibility

have

case,

Camey who did.
had

take up

gether in McCamey, and remembers Fiim
quite well. "He was about the best fiddler
I
ever heard," Dan told me. "We played
together, Dad and Jimmy on fiddles, Wayland on guitar, and me on lap steel."
It's can't be known for certain who the
fiddler was who inspired Jimmy Seals
to take his first step towards a career in
music, but it's an intriguing thought that

for fun, though.
Tom was satis

He

to

group of his father's friends
dropped by one day after dinner to make
music. Jimmy delighted in hearing the
fiddler play, and asked for a fiddle of Iris
own.
Dan Fuller, Tom's son, was just a few years
older than Jimmy Seals. They grew up to
a

the

opportu

regardless of
In the late 940s and early '50s, Tom and his son Dan
what
day
they played.
Fuller played music regularly with Wayland Seals
as a pipefitter in
"Daddy played for
and his son Jimmy. Pictured here in an early promo
the oilfields and
his own pleasure,"
photo,
Jimmy Seals became a Texas champion fiddler
at night as a mu
said
his
daughter
and later a rock star with Seals and Crofts.
sician.
"and
[an,
Wayland
anyone
was a talented guitar picker who had
who was interested in playing with
modest success in a rockabilly band that
him, it just thrilled him to death."
employee
worked by

1

made commercial

recordings

as

the Oil

Patch Boys in the 1950s. You can listen
to one of their recordings,
"When I'm
Gone," on YouTube.

My visits

Raised in a musical environment, Wayland's sons were even more successful.
Dan Seals became a major country mu
sic star. His older brother Jimmy also
achieved stardom in the soft rock duo
Seals and Crofts, which had a numberone hit in 1972 with "Summer Breeze."
It's a little-known fact that before hitting
the big time in commercial music, Jimmy
Seals was an old-time fiddle prodigy who
won the Texas State Fiddle Contest in 1950

he was 81. His

at the age of

nity,

nine. He has been quoted as

I

met Tom in 1971

ald, was

a

1

was

18

years old and

grandson, Mike Fitzger
high-school friend of mine in

Stillwater, Oklahoma. Mike's birthday is
January 8, and he told me that every year
on his birthday the telephone would ring,
and

it

would

be "Pop" (as the

grandkids

called him) on the other end playing the
fiddle tune "The Eighth of January."
Mike knew I was learning to play
banjo and was interested in fiddle mu
sic, so he invited me over to meet his
grandparents when they were visiting

�RECOLLECTIONS
OF A VISIT WITH
TOM FULLER
I

asked David Winston what he remembered

about the visit

to Tom

Fuller's home

he and

made along with our friend Al Tharp in
1975. Here's what he told me. -BL

I

remember that we bedded down in
the kitchen after our afternoon and
evening of making music with Mr.
Fuller. He looked in on us before going
to bed himself. After locking the door

I

leading
Al Tharp, Brad Leftwich, David Winston, and Tom Fuller in 1975.

l-r,

during the Christmas holiday. Tom
hadn't brought his own fiddle, so
brought mine, which I was just starting

I

learn to play.

to

I

mas present. I tried to play along on ban
jo, but I didn't know his tunes and wasn't
accomplished enough to pick them up
on the fly. In retrospect, I wish I hadn't
ruined the recordings with my poor at

second him.
didn't have enough experi
Initially,
ence to appreciate properly Tom's fid
dling. His fingers were bent with arthri
tempts

to

I

middle finger of his
tis, especially
left hand, which sometimes caused him
the

those notes flat. He claimed a
55-percent hearing loss, which made it
difficult for him to correct pitch errors,
and he was playing on my fiddle, which
was set up differently than his own. I was
fortunate to be hearing authentic tradi
tional fiddle music from early twentiethcentury Oklahoma and Texas, but to my
novice ears it just sounded rough.
put the tape away and didn't listen to it
again for another year. In the meantime,
more involved in old-time
I had become
music and had the opportunity to hear a
variety of other traditional fiddlers. The
to

play

1

next time

got the tape out, Tom's fid

I

dling seemed much more interesting and

listenable.
playing,

There was

and

a

a

joyful

lilt to his

distinctive sense

of

style

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

something

bowing
decided

that was

especially appeal

to pay him
ing. I
in the summer of 1973.

a

visit

at

home

to Mena, Arkansas, that Au
and
spent a couple of days enjoy
gust
and
Abbie's warm hospitality
Tom
ing
and making music. Tom was a gentle,
good-natured man who smiled easily.
I

tunes for me, which I
played
recorded on the brand-new reel-to-reel
tape recorder had received as a Christ
six

He

in his

drove

seemed always to have a twinkle in
a playful comment to make.
found him thoroughly charming. He
was delighted to have a visitor, and
He

his eye and
I

rarely left my side except to take naps or
to go to

sleep

at

night.

Tom loved to play with other people and

mind my inexperience or
his tunes. He always
with
unfamiliarity
wanted me to play along, and didn't es
pecially care to play solo for my tape re
didn't seem

to

to

corder. "Get your banjo and play this one

with me," he'd say.
visit, and continued

I

learned

a

lot on that

learn throughout
the next year from the tapes made.
I
visited him again in July 1974 and
visited one last
made more recordings.
time in December 1975, bringing with
me two musician friends, David Winston
and Al Tharp. We didn't have a tape re
corder with us on that trip, unfortunately,
although we had a wonderful time visit
to

I

I

ing and playing music.
That was the last time I made music
with Tom. heard from his family several
years later that he had been out walking
one day, and just lay down in the grass
1

and passed away.

the
to

garage, he exclaimed
of "You boys

the effect

I had to make
sure nobody
stole you." Passing the kitchen table,
he accidentally hit it with his hip and
said, "I don't see why they have to put

are so cute,

darned corners on these things." We
laughed. He was a wonderful fellow.

He had a self-deprecating sense of hu
mor, as reflected in the fiddle refinishing story [in the main article], and his

answer when one of us asked if he still
drove a car. He explained how he had
been driving, even though his eyesight
was failing. The evening sun was low
in the sky, and he couldn't see much at
all and decided to just follow the curb,
until: "Wham! I went right into a car
parked on the side of the road. That
was the end of driving for me." His
delivery was like his fiddling: light,
bouncy, and filled with humor.
Being introduced to his music opened
me up to something far different from
the Round Peak approach with which I
was obsessed. But what was interesting
is that his music as it was refashioned
by the time

I

heard

it

[due to arthritis]

was almost completely defined by his
bowing, not unlike Tommy Jarrell's
playing. But Tommy stomped on the

downbeat, and Tom bounced on it.
-David Winston

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Demijohn
Tom Fuller

Transc. by Brad Leftwich

�Some notes on the music
Tom thought of his tunes

as

being basi

cally of two kinds: on one hand were the

traditional hoedowns and waltzes,
along with a few polkas and schottisches;
and on the other, the commercial songs
and tunes that he referred to as popular
old

(or

as

he

pronounced

it,

"poplar,"

like

the tree) music. He knew I was particu
larly interested in the hoedowns, so we'd

play tunes like "Arkansas Traveler,"
"Wagner," and "Durang's Hornpipe."
He enjoyed them, too, but he also really
liked his popular tunes, so then we'd

play some of his favorites, such as "Jambalaya," "You've Got to See Your Mama
Every Night," and "Rubber Dolly." He
understood that those tunes and songs
were hits way before my time, and that
I
didn't quite understand their appeal;
out to me in
his usual good-natured way, "there was
a time when them pieces was very, very
pop'lar."
His playing was stronger on the first
tape I made than it was later on, but my
attempts to back him up are frankly em
barrassing to me. In later visits my play
ing got somewhat better, but Tom was
"You

know,"

he

pointed

clearly slowing down.

In the

recordings,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

one hears the toll taken by his advancing
age, hearing loss, and arthritis. He knew
he was out of practice; he'd have to stop
every now and then to take a nap and
give his sore fingers a break, sometimes
soaking them in rubbing alcohol. Once,

discovered that had recordings of him
playing his distinctive "Great Big Taters

That'll be all for a zuhile! Say, you
know, you don't knoio how much prac

time. Moreover, he told me he had origi
nally learned it in the key of G. Similarly,
I discovered
I had
one recording of him
playing "Flop-Eared Mule" (a tune that
switches keys between the two parts) in
the keys of D and A, and another one in C
and G. He moved "Buffalo Gals," which
fiddlers usually play in A or G, into the
novel key of F just because he liked the
sound of it. And have to agree.
wish I had thought to ask him about the
sources of his tunes and the fiddlers he
learned from, but was young and more
interested in learning tunes than history.
He called one of his tunes "Demijohn,"
which is the name of a creek west of Ardmore, not far from where he grew up, and
it is doubtless among the earliest tunes he
learned. "Jan's Tune" is also known by the
name "Oklahoma Run," a reference to the
land runs mentioned above that opened
Native American lands to white settle-

winding up a music session, he touched
my sleeve and said with a chuckle:

tice you've given me, your coming here,
digging up these old tunes]. Noio some
of 'em 's sort of hard for me to play again,
you see. I used to just play them, really
didn't have to think of them, they'd just

play their selves, seemed like. And now
playing things with you, practicing
and everything, but still
got

to

watch myself!

1

find out

I've

But the careful listener will also hear the
musical craftsmanship beneath the sur
face roughness: Tom's intricate bowing
with its bouncy lilt, his strong sense of
phrasing, his distinctive arrangements of
tunes, and his steady timing. He always
stomped his foot when he played, and
when he began a tune at a given tempo,
that's where it stayed!
He sometimes transposed tunes into
different keys. Years after his death I

I

Sandy Land," with its unique extra
phrase in the high part, in both the keys
of A and D. Although he didn't say so,
in

I'm pretty sure he

played the one

in D to

accommodate me, because that's where
my banjo happened to be tuned at the

1

I

I

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

family
Fuller
courtesy

Tom and Abbie in 1960

ment

one of which, the Cheyenne-Arap-

aho run of 1892, was an important event
in his family's history.

xt

Although Tom played all his tunes in
standard GDAE tuning during the time I
knew him, he told me that in earlier years
he had used a number of discord tunings,
including DDAD, AEAE, and AEAC#.
He stopped using them as musical tastes
changed in favor of standard tuning with
the growth of the commercial music in
dustry, and he said his hearing loss later
in life made it impractical for him to do
much retaining in any case. Arthritis even
tually caused him to simplify the left-hand
noting on some of his tunes, but his bow

ing remained impressively complex.
He used many of the same bow
rhythms that are found throughout the

although there was something
unique about his bowing that baffled me
South,

for years. At the time, of course, I was a
beginning fiddler and everything baffled
But

me.

eventually
began unraveling
techniques of my mentors and heroes
such as Tommy Jarrell and Melvin Wine,
and yet Tom Fuller's sound continued
I

the

perplex me. What was the source of
bounce in his rhythm? Why
couldn't
duplicate it? Only recently
have I begun to understand the unusual
cross-bowing syncopation that was a
to

that jaunty
I

staple of his rhythm.

Tom was eager to help me learn to fiddle
to show me his tunes, but he wasn't

and

particularly concerned that I play just like
him. After one taping session he said,

Coda
Abbie told me that although her husband
was an orphan, he got lots of love while he
was growing up. You could see it in his per
sonality. And the love he had received, he
passed along generously to others. Tom was
a

kind, nurturing man who loved growing

things, loved raising animals, loved mak
ing music with other people, and above all,
demonstrated his love for his family.
Jan likes to tell a characteristic story
about her father. Shell Oil employees
who had worked for the company for

years received an award. They could
choose among different items of jewelry
such as a tie pin or watch. When Tom
hit this milestone, he chose a gold watch
a woman's watch.
with two diamonds
He gave it to Abbie, and she proudly
wore it the rest of her life.
I'll always treasure the time I spent with
25

Tom. In

addition

to his

being

a

delight

ful person, it was a rare opportunity for
me to be exposed to a traditional art that

has all but ceased to exist. There's plenty
of great fiddling in Oklahoma and Texas
today, but in the ensuing generations it
has become a very different thing than

was when he was young. The record
ings I made are due to be released soon
through the Field Recorders' Collective.
I
hope that even with all the recordings'
imperfections, they will help people bet
it

ter

understand and appreciate

the

his

tory
fiddling from that area, and the
of
Tom Fuller in particular.
artistry
of

hope that comes out plain to where if
any of them you like, that you can copy
off of them. And add to them if you can.

fiddler, banjo player, and
singer originally from Oklahoma and now living
in Indiana. In addition to teaching, he performs

and there's
If you find better bowing
how
it is, if you study
know
you
always,
there's always notes that will
music

with his wife Linda Higginbotham, the Hogwire
Stringband, and Tom, Brad &amp; Alice. Recently

in there if you know how to put
them in; and if [they] come to you, let

Oklahoma prior
sti/le. The recordings

I

come

'em in.

Don't try

to

copy

because I'm not perfect.

me too close,

Brad

he's

Leftwich

been

is

a

documenting

old-time fiddling in
contest

to the spread of Texas

Missouri fiddler

Lee

that he and Linda made of
Stoneking have just been re

leased through the Field Recorders Collective.

�CHAMPION RECORDS:
OLD-TIME PLAYING AND SINGING
(AN ONLINE RESOURCE)
By Kinney Rorrer and T. Malcolm
The

Old-Time Herald

is

pleased

to

present

a

Rockwell

new resource on our website. "Champion Records: Old-Time Play

ing and Singing" is an extensive historical record, compiled by Kinney Rorrer and T. Malcolm Rockwell, showing
the shipping figures for old-time music recordings issued on the Champion label between 1925 and 1934. The data

offer important insights into the popularity of some of the prominent as well as lesser-known performers of the era,
and the impact that the Great Depression had on the early country music industry. Please visit oldtimeherald.org
to

view this important new guide.

Fans of old-time music have, in many instances, listened to reissues of pioneer old-time players and
singers such as Ernest Stoneman, Grayson and Whitter, Roy Harvey, Doc Roberts, the Red Fox Chasers,
Ben Jarrell, Jimmy Johnson's String Band, and many others whose classic sides were recorded by the Stan-

Piano Company in Richmond, Indiana. While many of the earliest releases by these artists were issued
on the 75-cent Gennett label, many others were issued on Starr's budget label, Champion, and sold for
35 cents each. After the demise of the Gennett label in 1930, the Starr Piano Company continued releas
ing old-time music on the Champion label as well as on another budget label, Superior. (Starr Piano also
custom-pressed old-time releases for Sears and Roebuck on their Supertone, Challenge, and Silvertone
labels, sold through their catalogues.) However, in many cases, the later old-time releases were limited
to Champion only. The Champion releases also included Hawaiian music, novelty tunes, jazz, popular
music, gospel, and blues (so-called "race records").
The Champion releases began in September of 1925 and continued until December of 1934. The series
began with number 15001 and ended with release number 16832. The first old-time release on Champion
"The Lightning Express," Champion 15017, recorded
was by Vernon Dalhart ("The Runaway Train"
the
first 25 old-time releases. As Dalhart's popularity
for
15
of
would
account
whose
1925),
recordings
and
faded, more authentic rural Southern singers
players would come to dominate the old-time music
series. By the 15200s, Champion tended to release old-time music in blocks of three or four records at a
time. Eventually the old-time releases would come in blocks of six or more. By 1930 it was not unusual
to have as many as a dozen old-time releases at a time. Old-time singing, string bands, and gospel music
came to rule the series by the early 1930s. While Champion drew artists from many regions in the South,
artists from West Virginia and Kentucky became major players in the new releases. This may have been
due to their proximity to Richmond, Indiana.
The highest-selling record among the Champion old-time releases was by Carson Robison. 37,280
"'Leven Cent Cotton, Forty Cent Meat")
copies of his Champion 15746 ("Why Did I Get Married"
were shipped. Champion 15750 (Melvin Robinette and Byrd Moore's "Birmingham Jail" and Leonard
Rutherford and John D. Foster's "Six Months Ain't Long") came in second with 29,871 copies shipped
from the factories in Richmond. Grayson and Whitter, Asa Martin, and John McGhee also had respect
able selling records, with their best-sellers topping 16,000, 21,000, and 17,000 discs sold, respectively.
record sales became
By the 1930s, following the collapse of the national economy in the fall of 1929,
such
as Gene Autry and
of
the
With
the
of
some
anemic.
Jimmie Rodgers-inspired singers
exception
Cliff Carlisle, few old-time releases were topping 500 copies by 1933. Many in fact fell into the double
digits only. Unfortunately, it was during this sales drought that amazing and exciting groups such as
the Shepherd Brothers, the Walter Family, Jimmie Johnson's String Band, and others appeared before
the microphone at Gennett studios. Many of these masterful performances survive in only a handful of
copies, if they survive at all. During its lifetime, Champion Records recorded and thus preserved some
of the finest rural acoustic music of the time. The recordings are, as discographer George Blacker has
called them, a true "parade of champions."
Visit

oldtimeherald.org/ champion

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

view "Champion Records: Old-Time Playing and Singing."

�903 East Main Street
Abingdon, VA 24210
(276) 525-1880
Shop Us Online1.
.com
Section with IllegiCaposmusicstore
ble Text
Stone Hours: Monday-Friday 10-6 PM
Saturday 10-9PM

Section with Illegible Text

Join us for our Jam every Saturday at 6:30

We are proud to
CARRY

A

SELECTION

BROAD
OF

SMALL

SHOP

INSTRUMENTS

FROM

THE

NATIONAL

FINEST

BUILDERS

AND LOCAL LUTHIERS
IN

OUR OWN

BACKYARD.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

la

q|
We have posted on our web site 293 tunes
played

by

of

years

100
field

broad

diversity

found

in

the

traditional

fiddlers,

from

recordings,

representing

of fiddlers

and

fiddle

50
the

music

Pacific Northwest. These mp3

files are freely downloadable. To reach them,
go to the web site and click on the microphone

image
fiddlers
the

in

the

upper

residing

recordings

in

right corner. Besides
the Pacific Northwest,

include

some

fiddlers

from

elsewhere who were recorded here and have
been influential on Northwest fiddlers. This
an ongoing project and more will be added.

Voyager Recordings
Section with Illegible Text

is

�takes don't prevent the enjoyment of their
music for me. There is some astounding
guitar backup on many tunes, with excit
ing bass runs, and the fiddles, on the two
tunes on which they are employed, are

excellent, with "Coughdrop Blues" creat
ing the typical North Georgia sound.
Informative notes are provided by
Tony Russell. There does appear to be
some vagueness concerning the band's
personnel, and these liner notes and
Tony's invaluable book Country Music
Records: A Discography 1921-1942 are not
in complete agreement on some person
nel/instrumentation points. Of course,
for the

enjoyment of this wonderful mu

sic, that really doesn't matter. Be thank
ful to have this delightful music finally
available on CD.
BOB BOVEE
To order:

arhoolie.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�and learned by Lundy from the

fiddling

Green Leonard (1810-1892). Here is
a tune that has been
played in Grayson
for
200
County
nearly
years.
Since the band does not give liner notes
of

(sigh) the reviewer can only guess at
sources. "Hell Broke Loose In Georgia"
sounds pretty much like the Skillet Lickers' version. "Hesitation Blues" is prob
ably from Burnett and Rutherford's
"Curly Headed Woman" and not from
Clearly, Eddie Bond did
not learn "Texas Gals" from A1 Hopkins,

Charlie Poole.

who played the A part as a pentatonic
tune, but where DID he get it? "Johnson
City Rag" sounded very much like "Oth
er Side of Jordan" done as a fiddle tune.
hard to believe that the Bogtrotters
learned "Pig Ankle Rag" directly from
Uncle Dick Hutchison, and one is led
It is

suspect the Highwoods String Band.
(On the other hand, the 1994 New Bal
to

lard's Branch Bogtrotters had Tom Mylet
playing bass, who is in the Wolfe Broth
ers with Jerry Correll, who is a big fan of
Uncle Dick.)
All nitpicking aside, this is
joyable CD. Perhaps it is time

example

of the

Old Time Music,

a

very en
use the

to

Brandywine Friends of
whose 1974 festival was

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

called "The Galax Sound." The New Bal
lard's Branch Bogtrotters give us a good
example of the Galax Sound.
PETE PETERSON
to

order: cdbaby.com/cd/thenewballardsbranchbogt

�see.

If

these guys

Josh Smith on guitar,

clawhammer banjo, and jug, William See
on fiddle, guitar, and banjo, and Squir

rel McLain on banjo and vocals
ever
once considered a slow or a parlor-type

tune, they must have shouted it down
darn quickly. There's not a one on the
recording. Just 12 songs that bounce and
12

pound away,

songs with

dominant sound
medium-fast tempos.

end

and

thick, low-

a

medium

to

From the fiddle band side come the
standard "Sourwood Mountain" with
trio vocals, "They're After Me" from Un
cle Dave's repertoire, "Darlin' Honey"
from Arthur Smith, "Let's Hunt the Wild
Horses" once recorded by Edden Hammons, and "Josie Girl." You could also
include "Glade City Rag," which is really
just "Beaumont Rag," and their cover
of "Leaving Home" which was Charlie
Poole's variant on "Frankie and Johnny."
"Sourwood Mountain" comes off best

among

the

instrumentals.

has the most pop.

It

tire

Being

certainly
opener, it

also benefits from being the introduction
to the

band's sound.

For

it

they've cho

sen to push the low end out front, and
that creates a monolithic sound. Of the

vocals, "They're After Me" and "Leav
ing Home" come off well. "They're After
Me" is not quite Uncle Dave (who is or
was?), but McLain gives a good account
of himself. On "Leaving Home," I think
he betters the original. Lots of good snap
to the vocals.
From the jug band side they've select

Memphis Jug Band's "I Can Beat
You Plenty" and "He's In the Jailhouse
Now," the latter of which uses the 1915
ed the

words and format rather than the more
familiar later versions. "Tickle Britches"
first appeared
ards, though

in 1929

by the Jazz

Wiz

was also recorded by B.
B. King. Also here is "The One Called
Shave 'Em Dry," the recording's lone
band original. "Shave 'Em Dry" is a racy
adult party song from the 1920s. The
Rounders' song has none of that racy lan
guage in it, but rather pays tribute to the
song through various comic vignettes in
which the singer recalls wanting to play
the record. Its "How Long"-like melody
gives it a ring of familiarity and makes it
a highlight.
Actually, any of the four jug
band tunes, along with "They're After
Me" and "Leaving Home," both of which
have a jug band, raggy feel, can be con
sidered highlights. That side is certainly
the band's strength.
None of the versions here seem to seek
to replicate a recorded version. Obvious
it

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ly, the band learned these songs some
where, perhaps from the original sources,
but they largely bring to each tune their
own approach and sound. That and the
solid instrumental work and the above-

average lead and harmony singing (and
the inclusion of 3-D glasses), make for an
enjoyable and entertaining recording.
BILL WAGNER
To order:

gladecityrounders.com

�Nick Hornbuckle
Twelve by Two (Plus or Minus One)

Nick Hornbuckle: banjo, piano, percussion; John
Reischman: mandolin, mandola; Miriam Sonstenes: fiddle; Emma Beaton: cello; Shanti Bremer:
banjo; Marisha Devion: bass

Cumberland

March

Gap

Virginia

Reel

Bell's

Yell In the
Ninety Degrees
Shoats
Sail Away Ladies
Too Young to
Geese Honking
Julianne John
Marry
son
Lost Girl
Sal's Got Mud Between

Her Toes
Just

Cold Frosty Morning

when you think you know every pos

sible way of getting melodies out of a banjo,
somebody works out a new one. Here the

innovator is Nick Hornbuckle, who has de
vised ways of playing fiddle tunes cleanly

and elegantly on the banjo using only two
thumb and index finger. Using fre
fingers

quent pull-offs and hammers, he compen
sates for the flexibility gained when using

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�a three-finger style. In addition, he plays in
some nonstandard tunings. To paraphrase
Carl Sagan, extraordinary playing requires
extraordinary methods. Part of the crisp,
ringing sound that he gets is from using
a resonator banjo and a fingerpick. (Wade
Ward played a Mastertone. So did Charlie
Poole when he could borrow Reid Rakes'

banjo. But

I
digress.)
Quick diversion into banjo history. There
are two main ways of playing the banjo,
down-picking (the many kinds of clawham
mer) and up-picking (fingerstyle). Hornbuckle explores the paths worked out by the
late Will Keys and played by Keys' admirer
Chip Arnold. I do not know whether Hornbuckle knew, much less was influenced by,
either of these two men. (Living as he does

Northwest, one is led to sus
pect long solitary rainy and snowy evenings
with nothing to do but play the banjo.)
One can consider this all-instrumental al
a
bum simply as very good entertainment

of the tunes here,

"Ninety

Degrees,"

"Too Young to Marry,"

and

the arrangements sound similar, showing
that the same combination of notes can be

achieved through down-picking and uppicking. The arrangement of "Lost Girl"
reminded me very much of Adam Hurt's
playing of the same tune. The pattern, if
I am
correct, is that Hornbuckle has used
secondary sources (Carlin, Hurt, others) as

his starting point, and not source

or try to dig deep
As entertainment, the lack of liner notes
(including sources and tunings) means

er.

but banjo players who want to
learn from this album and perhaps bring
some of Hornbuckle's innovations into

nothing,

their own playing will be frustrated. Hap
pily, Hornbuckle has written an instruction

book (available directly from the author

nickhornbuckle@gmail.com)

in

at

which he

reveals his tunings and picking patterns. He

has also posted YouTube videos (search un
der his name) in several of which he plucks
each string before starting to play, allowing

the tuning to be ascertained. I would never
have realized that his "Sail Away Ladies" is
played in F with the banjo tuned in doubleC with the 5th string at F, without this help.
Tunings are non-standard, but fiddle tunes
in D,

I

believe, are in double-D (aDADE);

"Cold Frosty Morning" and "Bell March"
sound like modal tuning.
A

second frustration

is this: he

lists the

other musicians on the CD, but does not
give the tracks on which they play. Is that
wonderful low part on "Sail Away Ladies"
played on bowed bass (Marisha Devion)
or cello (Emma Beaton)? Whoever played

deserves recognition! And yet another
complaint: the inside of the CD contains
blurbs from other musicians praising
Hornbuckle. If this was done to help with
a
most CDs come in a
buying decision
it

plastic wrapper, so the prospective buyer
does not see these until after the CD is
I wish
that he had used this
purchased
space to give sources and tunings!
Without sources, the reviewer is forced
to speculate. Is it a coincidence that three

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

record

ings, who probably played these melodies
on the fiddle anyway.

None of the above should be allowed

to

de

tract from the fact that this is, as said above,

innovative and extraordinary playine.

in the Pacific

good musical program

Honk

"Geese

ing" are also on Bob Carlin's old Banging
and Sawing recording? For the first two,

PETE PETERSON
To

order: nickhornbuckle.com

�Fiddlers 20: Tunes from Twenty Master
Fiddlers Featured in Fiddler Magazine's
First Twenty Years

nizable tune

is questionable. Jabbour gives
nice reading, nonetheless. Though not
a well-known tune, Dan Gellert's recording
of "Old Folks, You'd Better Get to Bed" is
it a

of note, if for no other reason than that he
recorded it on an old cylinder machine, giv
ing a performer known for his rough-hewn

and gritty performances an extra layer of
sand.
Irish fiddlers, according to Kevin

Reel of the Metis

Le

Mounton chanteur

Rob Fraser's Welcome to San Francisco
L' Amour ou
Rocky Mountain Goat
folie
Burley Coulter's Song for Kate
Branch
Audubon's Lucy
The Doon
Reel The Reel of Mullinavet
Maud Mill

la

Wolves A-Howlin'
Lisselsjovalsen
Huntly Lodge The Marquis of HuntMiss Hannah of Elgin
ly's Strathspey
Lasses
The Golden Castle
Craigellachie
Old Folks
Mickey Callaghan's Fancy
er

The Girl I Left
You'd Better Get to Bed
Mi burro verde
Behind Me
Tango do-

Clivus Mulchum

blado

of Reaths

Lord

geon On the Gate
Fiddler's Road
All fiddlers,

know
For 20

Mrs. Ferguson

Doune's Strathspey

Pi

Mrs. Johnson Pitworth

Amazing Grace

and for that matter, violinists,

should know of Fiddler Magazine.
years, they've been one of the expert

or

sources for those interested in tire lives and
thoughts and music of fiddlers from virtual
ly any branch of fiddling worldwide. Read
ers can find in its pages
files of performers, and

interviews and pro
equally important,

transcriptions of tunes from those perform
ers. Those transcriptions are the focus of this
combination songbook and CD set, offering
some 29 tunes (several are medleys) from 20
iconic fiddlers who've been featured in the

magazine through the years.

How
warhorses will, of course,

Of those tunes, 17 are traditional.

many of them are

depend upon your familiarity with any one

I don't
get the feeling that this is a col
lection of overdone tunes. Mark O'Connor
performing a somewhat rhythmically loose
version of "Amazing Grace" comes the clos
est to being an international chestnut. Ev

style.

eryone should know that one.
lert's version of "The Girl

I

Rayna Gel-

Left Behind Me"

might also qualify to those familiar with the
old-time repertoire, though her interpreta
tion seems only to hint at the well-known
melody, making it not only practically a new
tune but an engaging one as well. Old-time
players may also know "Rocky Mountain
Goat," here played by Alan Jabbour, but

whether

it is a true

warhorse

or just

a

recog

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Burke, should know the tunes he plays
here, "The Reel of Mullinavet" and "Maud
Miller," quite well. Irish fiddlers may recog

nize "Mickey Callaghan's Fancy," as played
here by P. J. and Marty Hayes. Not know
ing the Cape Breton (represented by Buddy
McMaster) and Scottish (represented by
Pete Clark) canons too well, I can't say how
familiar the tunes offered here are.
Of the originals, the standouts definitely
include the 3/4 gypsy jazz piece "Le Mouton chanteur" from Evan Price, longtime
member of the Hot Club of San Francisco.

Presented
ing

in five sections, it is an intrigu
medium-tempo tune characterized by

subtle phrasing and a lilting melody over
a constantly shifting progression.
Swedish
fiddler Mats Eden's "Lisselsjovalsen" is also
good, full of interesting twists and turns.
Also of note are Calvin Vollrath's tribute to
the Metis people, "Reel of the Metis," and

Judy Hyman's "Audubon's Lucy."

�On

the nuts and

bolts side of this set,

nothing here is overly difficult. The Evan
Price tune does takes a bit of effort, some
of the others as well, but ear players with
intermediate skills, or good sight readers,
should have little problem. The CD, which
can stand on its own,

is obviously quite
Most of the tunes have chord
helpful.
markings, and a couple include bow direc
tion markings. The charts are easily read
and if you press hard enough the book
stays open on a stand. All around a nice
set of tunes celebrating a fine magazine.
BILL WAGNER
To order:

fiddle.com /Fiddlers-20-book-CD.page

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�I

e

about th

24th Annual
t.Qnat

itvat*°^?inldt\memusic^S

Blue

Ridge

Old-Time

Music

Week
June 7-13, 2015
Joih

Wlzrrs

tJ^

Hill,

MT.C.

Mountains for old-time music classes appropriate for all ages and skill levels.
Nationally-known instructors include: Michael Ismerio Helen White, Sandol
Astrausky, Brad Leftwich, Robby Robertson, Hilary Dirlam, Tom Sauber, Pete
Peterson, Erynn Marshall, Carl Jones r Walk Koken, Clare Millner, Bill Dudley,
Beverly Smith, Steve Kilby, Rhonda Gouge, Alice Gerrard, and Margaret Wright!

H

'

Mars Hill

University Conferences and Events

PO Box

^^^^3phone: 828^9^^^^^j^^co^ere^cesp^mh^;^ir
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

H

6785, Mars Hill,

NC

28754

H
H
M

j^H

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

esting.
erate:

I

recommend

it is a

it

highly. And to reit

companion to the Sittin' in
that too.
I recommend

the

Catbird Seat CD.

HILARY DIRLAM
To order:

mudthumper.com

�Review Essay
Stinnett, Legendary Missouri Fiddler:
Home Videos from the Dwight Lamb Collection

courtesy

of

Sarah

McMahan

Cyril

Missouri Valley Music,
Pleasant, Canton, SD, 57013
To order: Bill Peterson,

Stinnett was a Missouri
fiddler whose music has come

Cyril
to

exemplify
mid-twentieth

the

finest

in

century North
American fiddling. Of Scotch-Irish heri
tage, Stinnett was a native of the fertile,
rolling northwest Missouri prairie farm
land that folds back above the east bank
of the Missouri River as the Big Muddy
curves northward at Kansas City Born in
1912 in

Savannah (Andrew County), just

north of St. Joseph, Stinnett was a bach
elor farmer all his life. He died in 1986 at
his farmhouse near Fillmore.
Stinnett's father had been born in South
Missouri, in the farming village of Fordland (Webster County), east of Springfield
and north of Ava, where the landscape be
gins to change into the more rugged and
stereotypical Ozark mountains. Cyril's
mother was born in southern Iowa, and
his parents moved from the Springfield
area to the St. Joseph farm before Cyril
was born. All of Cyril's eight or nine
brothers and sisters played music.
Cyril Stinnett, Legendary Missouri Fiddler
was released in 2013 by Missouri Valley
Music, and this DVD gives the world an
informal if not off-hand glimpse of one of
the most enigmatic and finest fiddlers in
all time (and I do not say that hastily). The
project was developed by musicians and
Cyril Stinnett fans, his peer and old friend
Dwight Lamb (Onawa, Iowa), and Lamb's
protege Bill Peterson. Amber Gaddy of Co
lumbia, Missouri, wrote the album notes
her colleague, David Cavins, pro
duced the video digital transfer as well as
the pleasing album design. The DVD con
and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

5

1

1

Contest organizer Jake HughespresentsCyrilStinnettwith the first place
trophy in a major competition, part of the 1967 Salisbury centennial
celebration. Fiddler Gene Wells of Fayette is in the background.

S.

tains some 117 tunes (several are repeated)

several hours of fiddling recorded by
Dwight Lamb in May and December 1979.
Stinnett was of the generations of players
who experienced and by turns embraced,
in

accommodated

eth century,

the style has receded

from

prominence due to the coming influence
of major National Contest style fiddlers,
judges, and audiences at the big meccas
of violinistic performance such as Ath

virtually
changes that traditional
fiddle and dance music went through in the

ens (Alabama), Clarksville (Tennessee),
Nashville (The Grand Masters), Moun
tain View (Arkansas),
Branson, and
Sedalia (Missouri), Grove (Oklahoma),

and stately fiddle

Hallettsville (Texas), Denver (Colorado),

rejected,

or

Jus

playing

to

all the sea

twentieth century. The spare, melody-driv

en, "hornpipey," ornate,
style in which Stinnett

excelled was once

widely heard and widely effective in Mid
west fiddlers' contests. The style, dubbed
Missouri

Valley Style by Charlie Walden,
owes its identity to the influence and record
ings of players such as Stinnett, his friends

(especially Dwight Lamb), and their men

and, of course, Weiser (Idaho). What
once was a style admired and studied

by young players has be
come almost a relic of the past
which,
of course, makes this fiddle style ripe for
rediscovery and celebration by younger

assiduously

tors such as Casey Jones (North Missouri)

generations whose imaginations are not
enmeshed in the Texas-derived National

and Bob Walters (eastern Nebraska).

Contest

While numerous other players in this re
gion and far beyond learned tunes from

guitar accompaniment.
In
the next generation,

style

fiddling

the

day's champions
lie Walden (Evanston,

Holt (Ava), Taylor McBaine (Columbia),
Geoff Seitz (St. Louis), and Amos Chase
(Grantville, Kansas), few such admir

Hallsville),

Walters-Jones-Stinnett-Lamb circle,
including influential players such as Bob

ers

adopted the Walters-Jones-Stinnett-

Lamb fiddle performance style. Lonnie
Robertson presents an interesting case of
an influential Ozark fiddler who adopted

much of the Northwest Missouri horn
pipe style in the years he was playing on

radio programs in the 1930s and 1940s in
North Missouri, Iowa, and South Dakota,
with Bob Walters and Casey Jones.
In former times, the Missouri Valley (or
North Missouri) style was more famil
iar and more admired. Once prominent
at contests in the early to mid-twenti

and

sock-chord
among

of the style are

Bill

to

Char

Illinois; born

in

Shull

(Warrensburg),
Lansford (Reeds Springs), Liz Amos
(Sandy Ridge, Pennsylvania), Brad Solon
(Rapid City, South Dakota), and broth
ers John and Jason Shaw (Lincoln, Ne
braska). Missourians who moved away
Jim

continue

to promote,
play, and teach
Stinnett's music, such as Mike Hartgrove
(primarily known as a bluegrass fiddler;

learningmusician.com/ fiddlegrove)

in

North Carolina, and, origi
from
Mike Drayton (the Iowa
Iowa,
nally
the
Arkansas Sheiks; cur
Corndodgers;
Albemarle,

rently, the Roadoilers; roadoilers.com), in
Santa Rosa, California. Thankfully, in the
current generation of younger fiddlers,

�core of strong players deep into
the music of Cyril Stinnett, Bob Walters,

there

is

and Dwight Lamb, such as Bill Peterson,

Amos, Richard Shewmaker (Colum
bia), Joe Fedrizzi (Dearborn), David Scriv
ener (Forsyth), Pete Howard (Fayetteville,
Liz

and other tunes, such as his

simple-sounding
cluded

bowed

"Cripple
notes,

deceptively
Creek,"

in

unusual
the
1950s
and
1960s
when
technique by
R. P. Christeson
noticed it in Stinnett's
32nd

an

and Bob Walters' fiddling.

Arkansas), Robert Freeman (West Lafay
and Nate Kemperman
ette, Indiana),
(Ames, Iowa).
When I first met the Springfield, Mis
souri, fiddler Art Galbraith at a festival
in Mountain View, Arkansas, in 1968, he
remarked that was from "up north" (the
Columbia area) where "those hornpipe
fiddlers like Jake Hockemeyer and Cyril
Stinnett are from." Galbraith was a sharp

A goodly portion of Stinnett's repertory
was drawn from local fiddlers and family
members who played at old-time dances
and sessions. Cyril seems to have leaned
a number of tunes from his father's hum
ming of the melodies. Another portion
was drawn from many other regions
(notably Canada; Ned Landry and Don
Messer tunes crop up regularly), as well
as from commercial
recordings; blue-

critic

grass records; Bob Wills; radio programs;

I

and

studious analyst of fiddling,
recognized the differences between
and

the several major fiddle styles in Missouri
that connected to the state's settlement

history and its major cultural-geographic
regions. Galbraith himself played a num
ber of tunes he learned in jam sessions
with Cyril Stinnett, although Galbraith's
personal fiddle style was unchanged.
For Cyril Stinnett and company, the in
is their

tricate,

of

driving hornpipe
cup
hokum and the shuffle
bow except when a tune demands it
(e.g., the Missouri icon, "Marmaduke's
they rarely embrace the
Hornpipe")
tea.

They shun

double-stop, they revel

in the

keys of

F

B-flat, they seldom play in chorded
tunings, and they master the bow. Their

and

bowing

smooth that listeners some

is so

times say they play "long bow" style, but
in fact

their bow changes are so smooth

and subtle that they are difficult to hear.

They don't mind figuring out a tune from
Cole's or, more currently, any of the many
even while
tune books now available
don't
read
music.
typically claiming they
Fiddlers in this northern style make ev
ery note count, bow with precision, and

amazing interest to a melody
be pedestrian in the lesser
witness Stinnett's treatment of

can bring
that could

hands

such underappreciated classics as "Crip
"Boil

ple Creek,"

the

and "Old Joe Clark."

I

Cabbage Down,"
have been told on

numerous occasions over the past

40 or 50

years that Stinnett's tunes were "simple."
1

have learned

to reply,

"Then let me hear

you play that like Cyril." Stinnett strove
for perfection, and in his time he was of
ten called

"fiddling machine" (Taylor
McBaine) and "fiddling computer." As
well as enjoying playing archaic and rare
tunes, Stinnett employed an equally ar
a

chaic bowing technique.

"Thunderbolt
"Wake

Up

His

versions of

Hornpipe," "Grey Eagle,"
Susan," "Ragtime Annie,"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the

influential

45

rpm

records by Jim

(Texas Shorty) Chancellor that sold in the
1960s in Missouri and helped nourish the

evolving "Texas" or "progressive" con
test style fiddling that led to today's "Na

tional Contest style"; and from hearing
other fiddlers play tunes directly from
print collections such as the influential
the Cole's (M.M. Cole, One Thousand Fid
dle Tunes,

Chicago, 1940),

a

republication

of the 1883 Ryan's Mammoth Collection.
Amber Gaddy writes in the album

notes that Stinnett admired and played
tunes from the commercial fiddlers
Howdy Forrester and Robert (Georgia
Slim) Rutland. Along with Tommy Jack
son, Arthur Smith, and Texas Shorty, that
just about makes a full list the most in
fluential commercial fiddlers in terms
of Missouri fiddling from the 1930s into
the 1960s (when Kenny Baker would
soon show up on such a list). Gaddy re
minds us of the many B-flat hornpipes
at which Cyril Stinnett excelled. Many
of these remain rare today as they were
in Stinnett's heyday and found chiefly
among seasoned Missouri contest fid

dlers of high skill ("Old Countryman's
Reel," "Thunderbolt Hornpipe," "Red
Lion Hornpipe,"
"Done Gone, "High
Level Hornpipe"), while others continue
to percolate through the repertoires of a
number of central and North Missouri
as "Blue Water Horn
Water
"Blue
Hornpipe" is often
pipe."
heard in its book tune version and title
as "President Garfield's Hornpipe," but

style fiddlers, such

Stinnett's version operates in oral tradi
tion and, according to Charlie Walden, is
a different (albeit subtly so) tune.
Stinnett was in command of the many
old standards he would need at a dance or
jam session, and he knew numerous ob
scure regional tunes (e.g., "Centerville,"
"169"). At the same time he seemed to

specialize

in

demanding hornpipes and

reels that would help him make the finals
in contests playing against other master
contest fiddlers in Missouri, such as Pete
McMahan, Jake Hockemeyer, Gene Wells,
Cleo Persinger, Leroy Canaday, Nolan
Boone, and Taylor McBaine (all from cen
tral Missouri) and fiddlers from the Iowa
Nebraska quadrant such as Frame

Davis and Ed Mahoney. Stinnett was as
much an enigma and puzzle as a person
to those fiddlers, who often butted heads
with him at contests and greatly admired
his playing, as he was to me.
One of the aspects of Stinnett's playing
that still impresses me is his fearlessness.
Asked to play a tune he only knew slight
ly, he was immediately able to grasp it and
make music, in any key. In addition, he
vaulted without hesitation into the upperregister positions, particularly noticeable

challenging tunes in the key
and
"Jack Danielson's Reel"

in

of A (e.g.,

"Canary

Waltz," often played by Stinnett in con
tests); his left-handed playing of the violin

"upside down" made this more difficult,
occasionally one senses the stress of
trying instantly to get the intonation just
right on some of those high notes.
So precise and perfected was Stinnett's
playing that he played a number of tunes
that, to many of us, might sound like ver
sions of the same tune. One evocative
example is his "Coming Down from Den
ver," an important Missouri tune; his ver
sion is the typical one in Missouri. After
fiddling "Coming Down from Denver"
in the Fillmore Park session video, a few
tunes later he goes on to "Lardner's Reel."
"Lardner's Reel" is often considered a
possible ancestor of "Coming Down from
Denver," and as Stinnett played them, the
and

first part (high part) is virtually the same
in both titles. But the second (low) parts
differ. His "Lardner's Reel" second part is
more like Byron Berline's second part to
Berline's "Coming Down from Denver."
It is anyone's guess as how these second
parts evolved. Berime and Stinnett had
known each other since the 1960s when

they competed

at

National Contest

contests, including the
at

Weiser, Idaho.

ingredient in fiddle style is ac
companiment. Many times, Stinnett had
the luxury of skilled and willing gui
A vital

tarists familiar with his music and his
ways. When good seconding was miss
ing, Stinnett had the uncanny ability to
ignore poor or incorrect accompaniment
and keep right on fiddling. In this region
and in his era, it was the straight-chord,
clean, old-time guitar backup that was

�preferred by most contest fiddlers (even
while the same guitarists could often
play swing chord style for other occa
sions) across the US. The capo was wellused by these guitarists, in part to keep

open-chord sounds when the fiddler
moved into B-flat or F. On the present
DVD project, Stinnett is ably seconded
by guitarist Dave Copeland of Ottumwa,
the

Iowa, at the Fillmore Park session, and at
the Lamb house session by Elvin Camp

(Iowa), Stinnett's Missouri nephew

bell

Tolbert (Pete) Stinnett, and Copeland
the three guitarists taking turns as Cyril
eases seamlessly through one tune after
the other. (Pete Stinnett was a capable fid
dler, but as

a

youngster revealed himself

guitar player and was henceforth
dragooned into being the guitar "second"
to be

a

fiddle sessions with his elders.)
interested in learning to play
the bedrock straight-chord guitar style
would do well to play along with the mu
sic on the DVD, just as interested fiddlers
will play along with Stinnett's fiddling.
All but Dave Copeland have passed
away, and today Copeland remains a
source for information about Stinnett
and other musicians of former times. It
should also be mentioned that, while not
a participant in the sessions on this DVD,
at

All those

old-time parlor banjo playing of Lena
Hughes of Ludlow (Casey Jones' young
the

er sister) was one of Stinnett's favorite
backups; Lena's archaic, ker-plunky uppicking parlor banjo accompaniment can
be heard on other Stinnett recordings,
and she accompanied him at the Weiser
contests in the 1960s.
We have a bank of Stinnett's music on
1980s cassettes, thanks to Bill Shull and
Charlie Walden of the Missouri State OldTime Fiddler's Association, as well as on
the University of Missouri sampler project

"Now That's

a

Good Tune:" Masters of Tradi

(1989, Voyager Re
cords CD reissue 2008), and a 2005 Round
er CD called Three Fiddlers from the Show-Me
tional Missouri Fiddling

State (Stinnett, Lyman Enloe, Casey Jones).

Among Walden's contributions
in

Old-Time

Herald,

is

a

"Cyril Winfield

profile

Stin

Hornpipe and Hoedown"
(winter 1994-95, pp. 10-11), and a number

nett: Master of

included in Walden's
fiddle CDs, tune books and website (charliewalden.com). Walden remains the prin
cipal pipeline to the world of Cyril Stinnett.
Bill Shull notated his "Little Dog Trottin'
Down the River" and "Cyril's Tune" in
of Stinnett's tunes are

Cross-Tuning

Your Fiddle

(Mel Bay, 1994).

present some of Stinnett's saga, and a tran
scription of his "Paddy on the Turnpike,"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

�Lamb
Dwight
courtesy

Left-handed fiddlers Dwight Lamb and Cyril Stinnett, flanking Lena Hughes with her Gibson RB100 five-string banjo, on Jake
and Lena's front porch in Ludlow, circa 1970.

Quick and Devilish"

in "Play Me Something

Missouri Press, 2012). New
(University
er on the scene is the young musician and
scholar Amber Gaddy, whose insightful al
of

bum notes grace the Cyril Stinnett, Legend
ary Missouri Fiddler project.

many years, it was hoped that Cyril
Stinnett's three 1970s self-produced LP
records would be reissued on CD, but a
variety of problems have prevented this.
Recently, Walden has made recordings
and transcriptions of Stinnett available
For

on his

website and

in

publications. Da

vid Cavins has posted music and video

of Stinnett on his website devoted to
Missouri traditional fiddle and dance
(mofiddledance.org). A number of Stin
nett tunes are made available by Larry

Warren

on

his

Slippery

(slippery-hill.com).

Bits

Hill

website

of the

Dwight

Lamb videos have been posted to YouTube and other websites.
In addition to this DVD, some of his Stin
nett's best playing is among the recordings
made by Phil Williams of Voyager Records
at the National Oldtime Fiddler's Contest in
Weiser, Idaho, in the mid-1960s, when Stin
nett was a contestant and National Cham

pion (1966). He was in peak form and, ever
the reticent magician in striped overalls,

absolutely mesmerized
carnival

at

Weiser

people at the big
sessions as well

in jam

contest arena. These recordings,
and many more of great historical interest,
are in the Williams Tape Archive, donated
recently by Phil and Vivian Williams to the
State Historical Society of Missouri in Co
lumbia (shs.umsystem.edu). They have
as in the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

uploaded several of Stinnett's tunes from
Weiser in the 1960s on the Voyager web
site (voyagerrecords.com).
To win the national title at Weiser in
1966, Stinnett's five "rounds" of competi
tion tunes included, "Sleepy Joe," "Five
Miles Out of Town," "Canary Waltz"
(Missouri tunes), "Woodchopper's Reel,"
"Pacific Slope," "Bennett's Reel" (Cana
dian tunes), and the worldwide favorite,
"Sally Goodin." All of these titles appear
in Cyril Stinnett, Legendary Missouri Fid
dler. Examination of Phil Williams' re
cordings of the Weiser contest during
the

mid-1960s indicates that the old-time

straight-chord guitar accompaniment
was still in vogue (as were pianos, and
banjos both four- and five-stringed), and
this was Cyril Stinnett's preference.

Thanks to Dwight Lamb's videos, we
can now see for ourselves how Stinnett
handled the bow (surprisingly using a
small portion of its length) and violin
(playing left-handed on others' violins)
and plays tunes, his demeanor almost a
trance, and with almost no spoken com
ment or interaction with others, and with
little indication

ment

of

happiness

or

enjoy

almost four hours of fiddling.
Here, Stinnett is in his mid-sixties and
playing in peak form, with flawless bow
ing, ornaments, accent, etc.
The impact of Cyril Stinnett's music has
been tremendous, no matter what region
or style a fiddler may prefer. Just as there
are

in

devoted fans

of

Tommy

Jarrell or

Ma

jor Franklin or Lowe Stokes across the
globe, so too are there fans of Cyril Stin

nett. Those who admire Stinnett's music
and attempt to play his tunes are easily
found out. One example: A decade ago,
at the Weiser, Idaho, fiddling festival, late
one night I was exhausted and wander

ing (or wondering, as it were) through Tin
Town and Stickerville working my way
back to the parking lot, I paused to lean
against a picnic table and started playing,
for no

good reason, "Thunderbolt Horn

pipe" and then "Angus Campbell." A

fid

dler came up behind me and said words to
the effect of, "Hey, did you get that from
Cyril Stinnett? That sounds like him."
Stinnett as a person was what some
would call "an enigma" or "a remote ge
nius." I remember Stinnett and have seen
him play in contests, first circa 1967 at
Paris, Missouri, where he competed with
the likes of Jake Hockemeyer, Gene Wells,
Pete McMahan, and Taylor McBaine. But

cannot say that I knew him. He was a
man of few words, and numerous stories
circulate about his odd reticence as well
as his almost unbelievable ability to play
I

seamlessly for hours, answering anyone's
tune request with a faultless rendition in
stead of a conversation. I included colorful
anecdotes from Gary Lee Moore and Ken
Brank about Stinnett at the National Oldtime Fiddler's Contest in the 1960s in "Play
Me Something Quick and Devilish." We all
spoke of him as "Cyril" (he pronounced it

"Serl"), but few really knew him.
The videos reproduced on the

DVD
cleaned
and
transferred
(nicely
up
by Da
vid Cavins) were filmed by Dwight Lamb
at three events, a May 27, 1979, fiddlers'

�contest at Fillmore, Missouri (the town
near Stinnett's farm), a session at the Stin
nett farm after the contest (and continuing
the following day, May 29), and a session
in December 29, 1979, at the Lamb home
in Onawa, Iowa (a few hours' drive north
of Fillmore). Never owning a good violin,
Stinnett typically borrowed a violin from
his visitors, and he plays Lamb's violins on
these sessions. This DVD from Missouri
Valley Music lets us not only hear Cyril
Stinnett, one of the true geniuses of North
American fiddling, but see the man him
self as he nonchalantly takes us through a
treasure trove of flawlessly-played tunes
both rare and commonplace. For those still

living with

a

VCR machine and

videotape,

Cyril Stinnett: Legendary Missouri Fiddler is
a great excuse to upgrade your
gear and

acquire a DVD player. There are album
notes and biographical information, but
there is nothing printed on the DVD pack
age to tell us who produced the project.
The DVD slip case is well designed, with
a graphic created to
represent the kind of

striped overalls that Cyril Stinnett usually
wore at contests and public events.

nice uncredited introduction
by Dwight Lamb filmed by Peterson in
May 2012. Also uncredited, Amber Gaddy
and David Cavins had major roles in the
project. I contacted Amber and learned
that she had written the album notes
and that David had created the jacket de
There is

a

sign as well as done the work to spiff up
and convert the videos to DVD format.
Lamb's video camera provided good
sound, and Cavins skillfully improved
and restored as much of the sound (and
video) as possible. Thankfully, Stinnett's
guitar accompanists are named, but little
information can be found to tell us about
the contexts and occasions when Lamb
made the original videos.
Many of us have long enjoyed listening
to

Cyril

Stinnett's three self-produced

records from the 1970s as well as
the other examples available through
various sources. But I agree with Da
vid Cavins when he says that the LP
records, as good as they are, did not do
LP

Cyril justice, owing to the pressures of
the

costly recording sessions.

He

sim

ply was not at his best in many of the
tunes on those LPs. But here, in infor
mal sessions among friends, Stinnett is
thoroughly relaxed, and he plays at his
absolute best. We thank Dwight Lamb,
together with his proteges Bill Peterson,
Amber Gaddy, and David Cavins, for

makin? these videos available.

HOWARD (RUSTY) MARSHALL

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The History

of

"THE BLACK MOUNTAIN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

BLUES"
LESLIE

KEITH

H

�Attic

THE STORY OF "BLACK MOUNTAIN BLUES"
By Paul F. Wells

this issue's foray into the Attic we turn away from looking at old photographs of musicians and
delve into the world of antique music ephemera miscellaneous, uncategorizable printed items

Inthat

were not intended to have a long life span. ("Minor transient documents of everyday life" is
how the Ephemera Society of America defines the materials their members collect and study.)
the item at hand is a curious little leaflet about the history of the fiddle tune Black Mountain Blues,
or, as it is better known, "Black Mountain Rag." The piece is printed on a single 9" x 12.5" sheet of pa
per, which is folded once, making a four-panel pamphlet. The front panel serves as the title page. On
the inside, fiddler and banjo player Leslie Keith gives a brief autobiographical sketch and an account of
the famous tune that he crafted. On the facing panel are several photos of Keith posed with his instru
ments, standing in front of a trailer towed by what appears to be a mid-to-late-'40s automobile. The
." (Moore was a
writing on the side of the trailer reads "Lee Moore's Sandy Valley
country music
and
who
is
most
well-known
for
his
association
with
WWVA
in
DJ
performer
long
Wheeling, West
Virginia, but who worked at numerous other stations in the region as well.) The back panel of the bro
chure is blank. There is no indication of when, where, or by whom the item was printed. Presumably
Keith sold this little gem at his personal appearances, or through the mail to his radio listeners.
Leslie Keith is not nearly as well known in today's fiddling world as he ought to be. He was born in
Pulaski County in Southwest Virginia either in 1909, as he states in this brochure, or in 1906, the date
given by historian Ivan Tribe in the book Mountaineer Jamboree: Country Music in West Virginia. Re
gardless of which date is correct, Keith established himself as one of the top fiddlers in the region and
embarked on a professional career while still in his teens. He and his mother moved to Birmingham,
Alabama, in 1923 and, as he states in this leaflet, he began playing over Radio WBRC in that city. It
was while he lived in Alabama that he heard a tune called "The Lost Child," which became the basis
for "Black Mountain Blues." In the brochure Keith says only that he learned it "from a real old fiddler
down in Alabama," but in a later interview with California John Delgatto (who produced Keith's only
LP, Black Mountain Blues, c. 1974) he identified the source as a man named Jim Montgomery. Most OTH
readers will be familiar with the 1928 recording of "The Lost Child" by the Stripling Brothers, who
were also from Alabama. The resemblance between this piece and typical versions of "Black Mountain
Blues /Rag" is quite obvious.
Keith was of the generation of Southern fiddlers who formed a bridge between older, local styles
and the emerging world of professional country and bluegrass fiddling. He had an extensive career
on radio and, as was typical of the times, worked with a variety of other performers. His most famous
association was with the Stanley Brothers; he played on their legendary first recordings on the RichR-Tone label. He later worked with Bill and Earl Bolick, the Blue Sky Boys, and recorded on their final
session for RCA Victor in 1950. Keith left the music business in the early 1950s, moved to California in
1959, and ultimately retired to Tucson, Arizona. While in Tucson he was befriended by folklorist and
old-time musician "Big Jim" Griffith who helped Keith remain visible and musically active until his
death in 1977.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�'

History of

"The Black
Mountain Blues"
in 1909 in the mountains
Virginia. When I was a very
small boy my greatest ambition was to
become a fiddler.
Every time I was
where there was a fiddle, I would try
In fact, I would walk miles
to play it.
be
around
to
one, thinking that I
just
When
to play it.
a
chance
might get
I was 20 years old my mother
bought
We had
for me the fiddle I now have.
a Victrola,
so I managed to get a few
records that were old time fiddle tunes.
I

was born

of Old

Well after I played those records
and learned them, it wasn't so hard for
me to fiddle most anything I wanted to
play. When a stage show would come
through our little town, most of them
would let me do a number on their
show as guest artist. The people seem
ed to like it very well.
Then I decided to get down to busi
ness and learn everything I possibly
could about old time fiddling, so I
could get on the radio. Then a little
later I tried out at W BRC Birming
ham, Alabama, passing the audition
okay. I played there a while.
Then my mother and I moved to
Where we lived in Ten
Tennessee.
nessee we could see the "Black Moun
tains," and so one Sunday afternoon,
while I was sitting out on the front
porch, I decided to make a tune and
call if the "Black Mountain Blues."
had learned a tune from a real old
fiddler down in Alabama which he call
ed "The Lost Child."
1

I took a little bit of this tune, and
little of two or three of the Carter
Family's tunes, and put them all to
gether and made the "Black Mountain
Blues."

So

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The first time I played the "Black
Mountain Blues" on the radio,
began
to get lots of requests
saying they
Then in a
liked the tune very much.
few weeks I had gotten so much mail
for "The Black Mountain Blues that
I
had to play it almost every day to
I've received
answer the requests.
more mail for "The Black Mountain
Blues" than any other five tunes I
1

play.

During my radio career I have won
several big fiddler's contests, and the
tune that won all the contests for me
was "The Black Mountain Blues," and
you radio friends are responsible for
making the "Black Mountain Blues"
the most popular old time tune I play.
in

I

vice

had to quit radio to go into the ser
in 1942.
I
was in the army three

I
seventeen
was
overseas
years.
months and saw service in the North
Fourteen months
African Campaign.
of that time I was entertaining the sol
diers by playing "The Black Mountain
Blues" which seemed to be the favor
ite with the thousands of soldiers I
played it for aver there.. I am very
thankful to be back in the States play
ing to my radio friends once again.

time you friends would like
"The Black Mountain Blues"
or anyother tune, just drop me a card
or letter to any radio station I might
be on and I'll be glad to play it for you.
I
also play a five string banjo and
So here is
guitar, and try to sing.
and
one will
that
each
even'
hoping
enjoy the pictures and the history of
"The Black Mountain Blues."
to

So any

hear

Thanks

a

lot.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Your Indian Friend,

Leslie Keith

�DOWN HOME RADIO SHOW
vernacular Music of the Americas

www.DownHomeRadioShow.com
Old-time, Blues, Pre-Blues, Gospel &amp; Spirituals,
Latin American Folk Music, Field Recordings,
Interviews, and more

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Hosted by Eli Smith

�HoustonFest
Celebration of Song

"A

&amp;

Service

"

Felts Park Galax, VA

Bluegrass
1st
3

Stages

As

year.

a

part of HoustonFest,

Houston
Caldwell Music
Scholarships are
each year

unique area dedicated
to youth music &amp; activities featuring
outstanding young musicians. An Instrument
Petting Zoo is ongoing
where novice can try
different traditional
is a

awarded to deservine
youth &amp; grants are awarded to non-profit traditional
music programs of the region. During the first 3
years of the program 25 scholarships and 7 grants

acoustic instruments
with the assistance of
friendly musicians.
Photo by: Pat Jarrett/V Folklife

Regional Artisans demon

Program

strate their crafts ranging from

Jam Sessions:

painting, stained glass, jewelry,

Bring
your instruments and join in

etc. A special area is dedicated to the Luthiers
of the region along with a silent auction.

impromptu jam sessions.

jr

K

I

$20.00 per day
Children 12 &amp; under FREE

about the

region are lead by the
Virginia State Folklorist,
Jon Lohman with
leaders
in
both Bluegrass &amp; Oldtime
participating
music.

artists participate.

At the Gate:

May

musical tradition of the

regional and inter
national known

TICKET PRICES:
Advanced 2 day ticket $25.00
Advanced 1 day ticket $15.00

in

Workshops

time, and Youth
Music. Both

Camp Houston

weekend

are

Bluegrass, Old-

Over 30 bands perform each

Oldtime Music

with

ongoing music
dedicated to

1

&amp;

B

Campins:
Campers

are

Both Tents &amp;

invited

to

camp

on the premises (Make your

Reservations)

HoustonF estGalax. Com
For Tickets &amp; Information:

Phone:

276-236-9908

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

HoustonFestGalax@embarqmail.com

�KITCHEN CULTURE ARTISTS

Toby Rodriguez, chef
Bryan Kyzer, chef
The Revelers, music
Corey Porche, dance

One summer that can
change your lif e.

VOICE WORKS ARTISTS

Cathy Jordan
Cedric Watson

Jennifer Scott
Elizabeth LaPrelle
Pharis Romero
Miguel Govea and Susan Pena
Pamela Bertoli
Casey MacGill
Moira Smiley
Eli West
Laurel Bliss
Caleb Klauder and Reeb Willms

Kitchen Culture

May 6-10

once-a-year gathering featuring the artists, music, food, and dance of a specif
region of the world. In 2015 we celebrate the unique culture and heritage of
the Cajun community from Southwest Louisiana.
A

ic

Voice Works

June 23-28

duets, classic jazz, swing, how to find
Mexican music, Appalachian ballads, Irish folk songs,
mountain gospel, honky-tonk songs, bluegrass, and much more.
Learn to sing harmony, vintage country

a

FIDDLE TUNES ARTISTS
Lee Sexton

and Johnny Sexton
Vesta Johnson with Steve Hall
Billy Baker with Jack Hinshelwood
Pedro Dimas and family
Rodney Miller with Sandy Bradley
Kristian Bugge, Sonnich Lydom
and Morten Alfred Hoirup
Lisa Ornstein, Andre Marchand,
and Normand Miron
8rian Conway, Rose Conway Flanagan,
and Mark Simos

third part, traditional

Fiddle Tunes

June 28-July

5

Suzy Thompson, Artistic Director

I

The Festival of American Fiddle Tunes provides an opportunity to be in
community with the bearers of fiddle traditions. You'll improve your skills,
discover culture through music, learn music in a cultural context, and build

lifelong relationships

in

the fiddle music community.

Kinnon and Betty Lou Beaton
Christine Balfa and friends
Frank Maloy and Mick Kinney
Ruthie Dornfeld

Jody Stecher
Milton Vanicor and more...

Fort Worden State Park
Port T ownsend, W ashington

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Register Today

Centrum.org

SAGIt O ARTS

"Try

ARTS

by
VP

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12107">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 13, Number 11 (January 2015)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12108">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12109">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 13, Number 11 (January 2015)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Featured articles:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Tales from the ‘Woods, Part 10: Jenny on the Turnpike,” by Walt Koken&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Everyone Sounded Different: An Interview with Chris Coole,” by Thomas Grant Richardson&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Tom Fuller: The Life and Times of a Fiddler from Indian Territory,” by Brad Leftwich&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Champion Records: Old-Time Playing and Singing (An online resource),” by Kinney Rorrer and T. Malcolm Rockwell&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12110">
                <text>2015</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="1632">
        <name>2010s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2762">
        <name>2015</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5464">
        <name>Brad Leftwich</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5465">
        <name>Champion Records</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5461">
        <name>Chris Coole</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5466">
        <name>Kinney Rorrer</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5413">
        <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5467">
        <name>T. Malcolm Rockwell</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5462">
        <name>Thomas Grant Richardson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5463">
        <name>Tom Fuller</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5460">
        <name>Walt Koken</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2507" public="1" featured="1">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3432">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/f8a1dbd5e3756bc39103c704c520e80a.pdf</src>
        <authentication>80ca1eaff48f1eaf465ef9a91c95f49d</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12111">
                    <text>$3.50

The OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Fall 1987

THE SLATE MOUNTAIN RAMBLERS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�NttTie mahs

I

ORIGINAL

MOUNTAIN MUSIC

703-728-3603--

--PHONE
BLUEGRA5S,

^1/N

FOLK, GOSPEL

AVAILABLE FOR:

&amp;

TRUCK SONGS

FESTIVALS.

GATHERINGS, HOMECOMINGS, REUNIONS

ETC.

GOOD CLEAN MUSICAL ENTERTAINMENT GUARANTEED
WE BUY

SELL

&amp;

BEST WISHES TO

TRADE QUAL ITY MUSICAL
AND SUPPLIES

INSTRUMENTS

ROUTE 100 NORTH

HiLLSVILLE, VA

THE OLD-TIME HERALD

24343

FROM

MUSICIANS!

THE OLD-TIME MUSICIANS
&amp; DANCERS

Send us your business card

OF SEATTLE

$30.00 we will print it as an ad in The
Old-Time Herald. Send cards with check or
money order to: The Old-Time Herald,
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333
For

JUNE APPAL RECORDINGS

Festivals!
Record Companies!
Instrument Makers!
Music Stores!
Others!
Get the word out!

Advertise in
THE OLD-TIME HERALD!

presents JA0051

WHOA MULE

by

LEE SEXTON

long-awaited premiere album by eastern Ken
tucky's finest master of the drop thumb banjo
the

Selections include

old-time solo versions of Cumberland Gap,
Shady Grove, Buck Creek, and Fox Chase, banjo with guitar and
bass on McCloud's Reel, Spinning Wheel, Eight more Miles to
Louisville, Lee Boy Blues, Nubbin Creek and more. Vocals on
John Henry and Whoa Mule, Whoa. Also, exciting double fiddle
work with long-time partner Marion Sumner on Caney Creek and
Grey Eagle.
Also

available from June Appal, recordings by Uncle Charlie
Osborne, I.D. Stamper, Dutch Cove String Band, Andrew Boarman, J. P. Fraley, Ralph Blizard, Ola Belie Reed, Lily May Ledford, Roan Mountain Hiiltoppers, David Holt, Jean Ritchie, and
the Metropolitan Blues All-k Stars, just to name a few!

Write

to The Old-Time Herald
P.O. Box 1362 for rate sheet.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

June Appal Recordings
Box 743

Whitesburg,

KY

41858

(606)633-0108

WRITE OR CALL FOR FREE CATALOG

�The OLD-TIME HERALD
Vol. 1 No. 1
Fall 1987

Published

by

The Old-Time Music Group
P.O. Box 1362
Galax, VA 24333

703-236-7808
Editor
Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Brad Leftwich

Linda Higginbotham
Hilary Dirlam

Bobby Patterson
Phil Jamison

No part of this magazine may be repro

duced

in any

mission

form without written per

from

the

publisher.

responsible for loss or non-return
unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
1987 The Old-Time Herald

The

Old-Time

Herald

is

Not
of

published

quarterly the first of August, November,
February, and May.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

LETTERS
The Old-Time Herald welcomes letters.
They should be typed or neatly written, and
signed. They may be edited and we will print
them according

I'm very anxious to see the Old-Time
Herald. I hope you will feature a lot of
our Asheville area musicians.

space available.

to

James Kennison
Swannanoa, NC

As people began to hear about The OldTime Herald, we began to get letters. Here
are a few:

While
Hartford's

I

was

Nashville

in

over
the final

this

past

at

John

weekend

touches to my latest
putting
album, he gave me a copy of your letter
to him
about the Old-Time Herald
magazine. So I'm writing to tell you I'm
for anyone or anything that will help
spread the word and get the attention of
people about old-time music. We sure
need all the help we can get, and I'd like
to be

a

subscriber to your magazine and
I can. Good luck

help out in any way that

with your magazine.

"The Banjo Man From Turkey Creek"
Elmer Bird, Hurricane, W.VA

Enclosed find $10.00 for a one year
subscription to the Old-Time Herald,
What other
old-time
music
good
publications, associations, or books can
you recommend to me?
Do
know the names and
you
addresses of persons who have any back

issues to sell of my old Cowboy Music
World
magazine that
formerly
published in the 1940s? I was known
then as Texas Frank.
I

I'm

also

trying

to

get

the

new

addresses of some of my old subscribers,
especially country &amp;t western radio
artists heard in the 1940s.
Keep up the good work!
Frank Karpinski

Flushing, NY

I'm

looking forward

to the

Old-Time

Herald!

Suggestion:

It

would

be great to have

a

"banjo camp." For example, 3, 5, or 7
days of nothing but classes/ workshops
for

banjo

players

with

opportunity
this as

a

I

go

a

great

concentrated
about promoting

to learn in

form. How would

experienced

What

teachers/players.

If any of our readers can help answer Mr.

Karpinski's questions, please write c/o the
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,
VA 24333.

a

Welcome

to the world of publishing.
forward
to your first issue. Best
Looking
of luck.

possible forum?

Don Summers
San Rafael, CA

Thanks for trying to establish a forum
that has great potential. Hats off to your
initiative in getting this underway!

The News

&amp;.

Lynchburg, VA

Best of luck with this endeavor. I look
forward to the first issue. Vive OldTime Herald!
Karen Philbeck

Rob Golan
Kittrell, NC

Great idea! I look forward to your
with
breath and
magazine
panting

frothing mouth.

Billy Cline
Daily Advance

Asheville, NC

It's a great idea, the time is right, and
we wish you great success. Hope your
magazine can be about people and music

while avoiding the superstar syndrome.

Pete &amp; Ellen Vigour

Armin Barnett
Seattle, WA

Crozet, VA

New magazine! Fine idea! Sign me up
a charter
subscription and let me
know if I can be of any sort of help.

Good luck in your efforts. Here's
hoping your venture has the success we

for

Hank Bradley

Seattle, WA

all

need if this music

is

going to fly.
Barb Shade
Batabia, OH

�THE SLATE MOUNTAIN RAMBLERS
by

Bill Mansfield

Barbara Poole,

Dan Williams

Richard Bowman

Alice Gerrard,

in
and Carroll Counties,
and Surry County, across the

Grayson

Virginia,
line in North Carolina, make up a small
portion of the Blue Ridge Mountains,
but this small portion has been a bastion
of traditional music for as long as
anyone can remember. The Slate
Mountain Ramblers hail from this

region and are proof that the traditional
old-time music for which the area is
famous is alive, well, and growing, for
they are a relatively young band and are
devoted to their music.
Consisting of Richard Bowman, Dan
Williams, Barbara Poole, and (most

Mansfield,

the

Slate

community function, the
members still get together to enjoy each
other's company and play music for
some

their own delight.
The band was ultimately the result of

Ray Chatfield's decision to move from
Colorado to Mount Airy, N.C. An
aspiring old-time banjo player, Ray

rightly figured that the best way to learn
old-time music was to live in an area
where it was part of the cultural
Mount
landscape. In the Galax, Va.
Airy region he was able to learn from the

old-timers in person and absorb some of
the atmosphere surrounding the music.
Ray did learn from and play with
these old masters, but longed to organize
a band
of his own and compete in the
fiddlers' conventions. Knowing of his
desire, Tommy Jarrell recommended
that Ray get in touch with Richard
Bowman, a fiddler from Ararat, Va. Ray
Dan
knew
Galax
guitarist
already
Williams as a result of the many music
sessions at Tommy's house, so with Dan
from
Slate
Buck
Stockton
and
Mountain providing the rhythm on the
guitar and bass respectively, Richard
playing the fiddle, and Ray the banjo,
the

Slate

playing
contests.
When

Mountain Ramblers began
fiddlers'
at
winning

and

Buck Stockton left to play
bluegrass gospel, Dan recruited Barbara
Poole ofLowgap, N.C. to play bass. Dan
and

about

Barbara
10

had

performed

years earlier

in

the

together
original

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gerrard

Bill

Ramblers are making music
that has been part of this region since it
was first settled. Formed five years ago,
the band has performed for square
dances, family reunions, local radio
shows, parties, concerts, and the many
fiddlers' conventions held in this part of
the country. Even when not playing for

Alice

recently)
Mountain

The Slate Mountain

Ramblers warming up

in

the Fries,

Va.,

YMCA (Old

Fries Theater) gym

Shady Mountain Ramblers. Richard,
too, was a "retired" musician, and the
three
of them really enjoyed this
renewed musical activity. The Slate
Mountain Ramblers became successful
contests and were soon in
at fiddlers'
house
demand
for
dances,
square
and
concerts.
parties,
After playing for four years, Ray Chatfield left the group to play with another
the
and
old-time
band,
remaining

members looked for a replacement.
After trying several different musicians,
they finally settled on Bill Mansfield,
who was living in Siloam, in southern
Surry County.
The Ramblers'
line-up
guitar, bass, and banjo is

combination

of
a

fiddle,

common

for string bands from this

ensemble plays in the
region.
driving, cohesive style that has come to
typify the so-called "Galax sound."
The

Though the Slate Mountain Ramblers
have their own unique "voice," the
sound of the band's old-time songs and
lively dance tunes can be compared to
the sound of their musical forebears: the
Shady Mountain Ramblers, the Pine
River Boys, and the Pine Ridge Boys and
Patsy (all of these bands have records
available on the Heritage label). As of
Mountain
the
Slate
this writing,
Ramblers can be heard on the 1985
record of the Galax Fiddlers' Convention.
The Slate Mountain Ramblers are a

music
of the active, ongoing
tradition of the Grayson-Carroll-Surry
County area; but the people that make
up this ensemble have not developed in
an isolated region, deprived of contact

part

mainstream

society. Barbara
to
admits
rock-and-roll;
liking
readily
both Dan and Richard enjoy country
and bluegrass music. Bill has eclectic
musical tastes, listening to everything
from classical music to rhythm-andblues. But when it comes to playing
music, the band members have chosen
music of their
to play the old-time
reainn.
They come from backgrounds where
making music was a family tradition,
of the band has
and each member
this musical
to
continue
chosen
actively
heritage. The use of traditional music in
the media has broadened their exposure
with

to it, but also reinforced their
to play the old-time music. The

decision

forces of

the folk revival have also influenced the
Slate Mountain Ramblers in varying
degrees, making them more aware of
their traditions and strengthening their
desire to learn.
In the following
section, the band

discuss

their
"musical
how
they came
biographies," describing
to play old-time music.

members

Richard Bowman
Richard
Va.

Bowman

There was music

was born in Ararat,
in

his

family, but

by

�the time Richard was born

to children),

the

(the youngest of
tradition was not an active

Though it was his cousin who got him
started playing old-time music, he had to
look outside the family to develop his
musical interests. Fortunately, Richard grew
up in an area where it was relatively easy to
one.

find traditional

musicians.
school, Richard worked with his
father on the family farm. Since he finished
While

in

Richcird has worked for
company near his home. With
school,

a

lumber

his wife
Barbara
and
their
daughter Marsha,
Richard lives on the Bowman family land in
Ararat.

weekend.

Tommy taught me a lot on the fiddle.
When
started playing
was used to

in straight, standard tuning. He
me
how to tune over in D and A. I
taught
had to learn to play over again! He would
sit down and show me the tunes. He'd
drag the bow slow, till I caught what he
was doing. Tommy wouldn't teach me

playing

one part of the tune

at

a

time. He'd play

second part. On and on, until could
follow him. Then he would play the tune
the

I

right and I'd keep up if I could. He had
lot of patience, and I mean a lot of it.

We

played

at

Blackberry

lot, and at Fancy Gap some, and
at
the
Hills ville VFW. We played a
up
lot on Sundays at family reunions.
Anybody that knew any of the band, if
they were having a reunion,, we'd always
go play. We went to the World's Fair
in Knoxville in 1984. We were there for
eieht davs.
I
learned a lot from the Pine River
Boys, I really did. But when Marsha

Ridge

I

I

a

came along,

a

a

I

quit playing for

a

year and

half.

Well, Ray Chatfield came here from
Colorado, and Tommy sent him up
here, and we got to playing. There was

Daddy played the banjo, and Mama
was the last
played the autoharp. But
kid in the family and he had quit playing
before I got old enough to listen. They
used to play a lot. Mama will play some
now if I get after her. But Daddy got to
where if he couldn't play perfect, he

and got him to play the guitar, and Buck
to play the bass. Buck lives
down at Slate Mountain and that's
where the name comes from. He got to
playing bluegrass gospel, so we got

I

wouldn't play

at all.

According

to

Stockton

Barbara Poole to play bass with us. We
still kept the name.

every

one around that used to hear him, he
used to play a lot.

to play at fiddlers' conventions,
I love
but it's always the trip home that gets
bothersome. I don't like to be put up on
the stage to play to people. I'd rather

I
worked in a saw mill during the
daytime and would coon-hunt at night.
Well, Jack Burns, my second cousin,
really got me involved with it. We coonhunted a whole lot and what time we
he picked the
weren't coon-hunting,
guitar. Jack played more old-time music

Alice

Gerrard

than he did anything and, well, I got to
where I liked the sound of old-time
music better. He had an autoharp that
none of them played, and would mess
with it some. I played hymns and slow
tunes till I got to where I could play
I

something.

I was
about 20 when I started fooling
with the fiddle. The first fiddle I ever had
my hands on was the one 1 learned to

from Cousin Jack. I learned
the fiddle the hard way, one note at a
time. I didn't know how to tune or any
thing, and J ack lost lots of sleep try ing to
get me to learn to play a few tunes. Then
I
got to listening to albums and learned
to play a little. When I got to where
could play a few tunes on the fiddle, then
when I wasn't playing with Jack would
beg Mama to play, and she would get the
autoharp out and play some. learned a
few tunes from her.
What really got me started was
Tommy Jarrell's birthday party. He
went over to the radio station WPAQ)
play.

I

got

it

I

I

I

and

played

there

that

number-one

day.

He

was

a

fiddler and a number-one
fellow on top of that. The way he played,
no one can play like that any more. I
used to go down to Tommy's and
he would sit and play and fool with me a
lot. Sometimes we would just sit and
talk,

not play

a

tune.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

fiddlers' convention coming up, and he
asked me if I wanted to go. Ray saw Dan

Richard Bowman

I

I

I

fine banjo player.)

We went on several trips. We played
the

summer.

square

In

dance

conventions during

winter we were playing

somewhere

a

different sound. It's

person that's playing.

I

think it's

they play and the way they
learned to play that makes a difference. I

we played at was in Stuart, Va. We went
down there and won third place. Then
got to playing with Dea and Melvin
Felts, in the Blue Sky Ramblers. Dea and
Melvin played the fiddle and banjo. We
played around at contests for a couple of
years. Then I got to playing with the Pine
River Boys.
I
played with the Pine River Boys
about four years, and I learned a lot from
them. Abe Horton was the banjo player
all the time
was playing with them, but
we'd switch around a little bit. Every
once in a while I'd get tired of playing the
fiddle or get aggravated trying to tune,
and I'd hand the fiddle to Abe. I would
let him fiddle and I would hold his banjo
and
make
out like
was playing.
Actually, Richard is a
(Editor's note

of the fiddlers'

Everybody's got
in the

the

1987

I played
with Cousin Jack for four or
five years. The first fiddlers' convention

all

play where the people can get around
you. I'd love to be sitting out some
where with the people around, maybe
two or three dancing. I enjoy that more
and it looks like the people enjoy it
more.

a

every

way

don't think it has anything to do with
where you are from.
For one thing,

you've got to hear the

music. If the fiddle is over everything
else, that's all you're going to hear. If
you're listening to a band and you can't
hear the banjo, then he'd just as well not
be there. You have to work together to
get the sound, because if you can't hear
it ain't there.
You got to be serious with your music
when you're playing, but you can't be
too serious. If you've got a good person
ality, plenty to eat, and are out to have a
if you can play at all, your
big time
music will be good.

it,

Dan Williams
Dan

Williams

was

born

in

1934

Alleghany County, N.C. At an early age

in

he

and his family moved to a farm near Piper's
Gap, Va. Dan and his wife, F aye, have
moved around the Grayson-Carroll County
area, finally settling in Piper's Gap close to
where he grew up. They have one married
daughter, Dede. Currently Dan works as a
bank courier.

�interested

Dan's aunts and uncle on his mother's
side were musical, playing the dulcimer or
guitar, but the most significant musical
influence of his early years came from out
side of his family. Dan has experience with
country and bluegrass music and enjoys

playing both kinds,

in it. If

could do

she could do it, then

Shady Mountain Ramblers first
record, Heritage 002.) That was just
about an every-weekend thing. We had
four square dances going: one week in
Sparta, one at Lowgap, one at the
Fairview Ruritan Club and one at
the

I

it.

18 when she showed me
chords on it. She would tell me
when to change from one chord to
another to make it sound right. She
would holler, "Change! Change!" as the
ballad or whatever I was singing would
change.
1
tried to follow a lot of tunes by
Charlie Monroe and a whole lot by the
Carter Family. We listened to a lot of
radio back then. There wasn't any TV.
They had some music from Waterloo,
Iowa; Del Rio, Texas; that barn dance

was about

I

three

but prefers to play old-

time music.

couldn't even play the radio,
but my mom,
can remember her
playing the dulcimer. She could play
"The Wildwood Flower," "The Johnson
My dad

1

Boys," and she had one that she called
"Little Mohee." They were all simple
tunes. At night, if she wasn't too tired,
she'd pick a little. When you live on a
farm and are raising a bunch of kids, you
don't have too much time for music.
This retired school teacher, a man
named Omar C. Cox, used to teach in
the White Top area of Grayson County,
O.C., we called him, had a large farm,
and he decided that he wanted to be
close to his farm, but he didn't want to
live by himself (he didn't have any
family). And he asked Daddy if he could
board with us.

that

they

have

in

Wheeling,

Hillsville.
At the square dance they really liked
music and that's what we

old-time

played. The majority of your bluegrass
pickers will tell you that people can't
round and square dance to bluegrass.

They've got to have the old-time beat for
people to dance to.
Now, you can't play a square dance

West

and

Virginia; and the Grand Ole Opry.
So I started with Talmadge Smith
playing the fiddle and he said, "I'll teach
you a little bit of different tunes on the
guitar." Talmadge taught me quite a bit.
We got to playing with Charles Hawks.
Charles played the bluegrass banjo, and
we were making music! You'd call it
bluegrass. I played a little bit with James
Lindsey's band, the Mountain Ramblers,
was never a
at square
dances, but
member, just kind of a fill-in.
After I got married,
the
music

a

fiddlers' convention too. Y ou have
to go to the other. We

to give up one

have

played

early

convention, then gone
and

then come

convention
But

that's

back

at

a

to play
to the

fiddlers'

dance,
fiddlers'

a

to see if we'd won anything.

pretty

after seven years
quit.

I

nerve-wracking.

just got tired of

it

So
and

Dan was not completely idle after his
second musical retirement. He played music
"
with different musicians just for fun."

I

Me and Tommy (Jarrell
ed.) and
ed.) played some at
(Creed
different places. I thought the world of
both of them; Luther Davis and Fred
Cockerham, too. I loved to play with
them because they were true old-time
Kyle

musicians.

This younger generation, they were
born and raised with the rock group and

that's what they are interested in. A lot
of what they call old-time music is cut
up and jumbled up. The tune is not
turned like it's supposed to be. They
don't play it on out in the melody; it's
cut short. They have found a different
technique. It's kind of hard to explain.
But some younger musicians have really
picked up the old-time tunes and have

Alice

Gerrard

really played them. My nephews, James
and Joey, are in their 20s and they are

Dan Williams

the fiddle, the banjo, and
guitar. That's where my sister
learned to play the guitar. He would take
his banjo and tell my sister when she
was supposed to change chords. And she
picked it up, just like that.
I
got to listening to him and her, just
the banjo and the guitar, and I was
the
house
forever
around
going
humming what had heard them playing
He played

some

I

the

night

before.

That's

where

I

got

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1987

stopped. went 10 years and didn't play
nothing with nobody. Then Whit
Sizemore came and asked me if I'd play
I

the

guitar

with

him

as

a

fill-in.

So

hanging
good.

on

to

old-time

music

pretty

I'm very finicky about my music.
You take a good, strong fiddle, with a
good banjo right behind him mocking
that fiddle, and then good drive on the
guitar, making some good runs too; the
guitar carries the time and the basscarries the rhythm. That's good old-time

music.

I

played one square dance with Whit at
the Fairview Ruritan Club, and after
played that one dance the other guitar
player quit. So I played with Whit and
the
Mountain
his
band,
Shady
Ramblers, for seven years. (Editor's
Dan played guitar and sang on
note

I

Barabara Poole
Barbara Poole is part of the musical
Edmonds Family of Galax, Va. Her grand
father, Norman Edmonds, recorded two
classics of old-time music back in 192 7
("Black-Eyed Susie" and "Train on the
Island," both reissued on County 535). Both

�Uncle Wade was known for the Buck
Mountain Band. That's what we were

of her parents played, and her younger
brother Jimmy was a child prodigy, playing
the fiddle by age five. W ith such a musical
household, Barbara could not help but play
music. Her parents urged her to take up a

then. I played with them about
seven or eight years, I reckon, mostly on
back

Saturdays

Mark

Sanderford

and folk festivals with her grandfather and
as part of Wade Ward's Buck Mountain
Band.
Barbara and her husband Ronald live in
L owgap,
N.C. with their three children:
Ronnie, Sharon, and Jimmy Dean.

Norman Edmonds
I

learned how to square dance before

ever learned how to play.

was fun. My

It

remember
family would help me.
the
"Chase
the
Eight,"
learning
"Figure
Squirrel," and the "Paul Jones." "The
Golden Gate" was my favorite. The kids
would have their circle and they would
dance and the grownups would have
I

theirs.

Daddy always wanted us kids to learn
instruments and they always had
them around. I tried to play the guitar,
the mandolin, and others.
I was
playing before got out of high
school, probably about 15 or 16 years
old. "Uncle" Wade Ward was the one
that coaxed me into it. Jimmy was
already playing with him and Uncle
Wade wanted me to play the bass.
Daddy already had a bass, and Uncle
Wade kept coaxing me to play, so Mama
started working with me. Daddy helped
me, too. He showed me the chords, and
if I got out of rhythm, he'd look at me
hard. Mama started me out, helping me
with some of the slow ones
maybe
"Little Brown Jug"
something slow,
till I could get my rhythm. I'd watch
Mama; she'd play real slow, and when
she'd change, then I'd change. We
played "John Hardy" till I wore it out. I'd
watch Mama change, till
got to
changing on my own.
Growing up playing with Uncle W ade
was really special. It was just like a picnic
all the time. He was all the time making
me laugh. When he talked about food, it
would make your mouth water. He was
all the time talking about going some
where and eating cornbread.
He had two black derbies. He'd wear
one and make me wear the other one and
the

Alice

Gerrard

I

with

youngest

Dean

son,

Jimmy

1987

There were fiddlers on the Edmonds
side as far back as anyone can remember.
Jimmy just always had it. Daddy, he
plays, but not like Jimmy or Grandpa.
From what I understand, my greatgrandpa played the fiddle, so it's come
down.
I
remember when I was little, Mama
would go play with Grandpa at fiddlers'
conventions and was too little to go.
I

I

remember

Grandpa
playing "Black"Golden
Susie,"
Eyed
Slippers," "Sweet
Little

Julie,"

"Ship

in

the

Clouds,"

"Hawks and Eagles," and "Fortune." I
grew up on "Fortune." Those are the
tunes
think of when I think of
Grandpa.
Anytime someone would ask him to
play, he'd play. For square dances, as
long as anyone would dance, Grandpa
would play. It used to tickle me, as long
I

anybody was picking up their feet, he
wouldn't quit. He played for the
as

fiddlers' convention
wasn't able to.

at

Galax

till

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

he

I

looked pathetic

in it. I'd try to forget it
home, but he'd never let
him
had
and
a
special
He
never
my
relationship.
forgot
birthday. He was one of a kind.
I

and leave
me.
Me

it at

I

Parsons'

for

We'd

Auction

out

anywhere.
Played every Saturday when there was a
sale. We played at fiddlers' conventions,
and if somebody wanted us to play for a
square dance or at people's homes, we
would. Sometimes someone would call
up and just want the Edmonds famiy and
we'd go play, like the Christmas party at
the Moose Lodge in Galax. It was just
and Mama and
me, Jimmy,
Patsy,
We
would
Daddy.
play around the
house, too. But now you can't hardly get
us together any more, and I miss it.
I
saw Whit Sizemore one day (after
Wade Ward's death), and he had started
playing for square dances at Fairview. I
wasn't playing very much and he said
they needed someone to play the bass
with them. I went over there one night
and just started playing the bass with
them. I played with them for about a
year, but after got married and Ronald
started driving a truck, I just didn't have
time for it anymore. Audine Lineberry
took my place.
After I quit Whit I didn't play much
anymore for about 10 years. But I went
to a fiddlers' convention one night and
Dan, Richard, and Ray were standing in
line and I started talking with Dan. Their
bass player didn't show up and they

Company.

musical instrument, and the activities of her
family introduced her to such well-known
old-time musicians as Wade Ward, Glenn
and
Charlie Higgins.
Barbara
Smith,
at
conventions
performed
many fiddlers'

go

I

asked

me if

wouldn't

I

be

interested

in

playing the bass with them. Well, I
could play
didn't even know if
I

anymore

or not.

I

had to

borrow

a

bass,

The next week at the
Vaughan School Fiddlers' Convention
we won first, and I knew playing bass is
where I wanted to be.
like music you
In old-time music,
can dance to. I like a sound where it's
and

we

won!

I

your feet still. A good
bass
that can blend in good
backup,
with a guitar, then you've got a good
foundation that's hard to beat. And then
when the fiddle and banjo blend right in
hard

to

keep

a

unique sound. I love to
music when it's played
sort of peppy and it's got good musicians
listen to Tommy
behind it. When
and
Creed
it's hard to
Kyle
Jarrell
there,

hear

that's

a

old-time

I

beat the sound that Tommy and Kyle
had.
If our generation doesn't keep oldtime music, it will eventually fade out,
and that'd be a shame. It's too special to
just die. I've heard some get out and sort
of mutilate it, and that breaks my heart.
It hurts me to see how they have messed
up the old-time music; it takes away
from it, to me. They think they are

�They sang songs like "The Preacher and
the Bear," "Black-Eyed Daisy," "Little
Brown Jug," "Red Wing," "Old Dan
Tucker," and things like that. They
probably developed my musical tastes.
all kinds of music growing up
I heard
in Raleigh. When I was about four or
five my parents took me to a Jerry Lee
Lewis concert. fell asleep. reckon that
I

I

indication of my interests.

was an

didn't really take an active interest in
music until I was 1 1 or 12. Ma took us to
see a western and in the sound track of
the movie, somebody was playing a jews'
asked, "What's that?" and she
harp.
explained what it was. Then she told us
that she used to play one when she was a
little girl.
Well, the next day my younger
brother went out and got one and Ma
showed us how to play it. He never
did.
learned to play it, but
About the same time, I discovered the
"Flatt
and
Scruggs TV Show" on
Saturday afternoons. I spent a lot of time
trying to play along on the jews' harp
I

I

I

with Lester and Earl.
I

didn't know anything about music,

but really liked the idea of being able to
make my own.
mean, listened to the
radio and enjoyed rock-and-roll, but I
never felt like that was real music. It
seemed to me that they were putting on,
acting, not really being themselves. And
the music on the radio changed all the
time. There was a new Top Ten every
week. The music that my mother and
I

Mark

Sanderford

I

L-R: Wade Ward,
The Buck Mountain Band
Frances Edmonds, fiddle-Jimmy Edmonds.

playing old-time music and in their way,
I
guess they are. But a lot of it is too fast
to dance to, or with singing, too slow.
It's not old-time, the way I grew up with
love fiddlers' conventions. love the
and
night atmosphere,
people are
gathering around you and you know
you're sounding good. For me, it's just
like being on a high, when you know you
are sounding good and everybody is
when they get out there
tickled

helped develop his preference for old-time

I

time.
and
having a good
dancing
I
the
older
love
to
see
Especially
people.
an old person have a good time. You
know they are the ones that handed it

down to us.

'

music. Mansfield has been more affected by
revival than the other
the folk music
members of the band. It was to the revival
that he turned to find out more about
traditional music when he had exhausted his
sources at home.

Bill Mansfield

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

grandfather sang was more constant.
When I heard Flatt and Scruggs play
"
"Old Dan Tucker or "Going Down the
Road Feeling Bad," some of the music I
heard at home, it just struck something
in me. It made more sense.
My oldest brother came down home
from college with a harmonica. Well,
thought of all those stories about

I

in
the
kitchen,
sitting
singing, patting his foot, and playing the

Grandaddy

harmonica, and

I'm the
the band.

closest thing to

a

foreigner

in

They

Barbara's, Dan's, or Richard's.
the
father
mother's
played

My

but

decided to learn to play

high school some people found out
could play the jews' harp and the
mouth harp and asked me if would be
interested in joining their band. I
thought it would be like the Foggy
Mountain Boys and so I said, "Sure!"
But it turned out to be an old-time
band. Jim Collier, the organizer of the
In

were all born right
around Galax and have lived here all of
their lives. Their musical roots are a lot
deeper than mine, too. Old-time music
was in my family but not as intense as it

harmonica,

I

it.

that

is in

Bill Mansfield, the newest and youngest
member of the Slate Mountain Ramblers
was born and raised in Raleigh, N.C. At an
early age, Bill started learning songs and
tunes from his mother and grandfather, who

Poole,

were from rural Chatham County, N.C.
homemade
music
introduction
to
This

it.
I

Barbara Edmonds

I

I

don't

recollections of him playing.

have
I

many

know he

played "Golden Slippers," "Swing Low,
Sweet Chariot," and "I'm Going Down
the Road Feeling Bad." But mostly I
remember him and my mother singing.

I

I

band, played knock-down-style banjo,
and that was the first time I'd ever seen a
banjo up close. The sound really excited
me and I spent a lot of time at Collier's

house listening to him play. Jim also
introduced me to recordings by Doc
Watson,
George Pegram, Roscoe
Holcomb, and people like that.

�decided to learn the banjo. So got a
banjo and an Earl Scruggs

of banjo playing, and returned
of times to visit with Surry

instruction book, and tried to learn to

musicians

had to take my banjo
play.
over to Jim's house to get him to tune it
for me. I'd try to play it till I knocked it

East, and Benton Flippen.
In 1979 I was lucky enough

to get

Cockerham.

quit my

I

I

cheap

was awful.

I

I

Earnest

Tommy,

Fred,

couple
County

a

grant from the National Endowment for
the Arts to study banjo with Fred

out of tune, then take it back. I couldn't
play Scruggs style and I couldn't even
make noise trying to frail, but I kept
wrestling with it.

was so excited

I

I

job and spent about six months traveling
up to Fred's trying to "catch his tunes,"

Jim went off to college

as he

at Appalachian
Boone. While he was up there
he got up with Arnold Watson, an oldtime two-finger banjo player who is also
older
brother.
Watson's
Doc
Jim
introduced me to Arnold and his banjo
really like Arnold's playing
playing.
could make music
and discovered that
style, and
playing finger-and-thumb

State,

a

would say. Jim Collier and Barry

Poss did much to get me started on the
banjo, but it was Fred who really taught
me to play.
wnen tne grant ran out, i needed to
get a job, but instead of going to work,
went to back to school.
got a student
workship that enabled me to start

in

I

I

I

I

working towards my master's degree in
folklore at U.N.C. Studying folklore
broadened my appreciation of
traditional cultures. It has helped me to
better to understand the culture that I'm

lot of time doing it.
spent
About two years later, in 1973, got a
summer job working on a ferry boat. It
turned out to be in the middle of
nowhere, so I spent all my spare time in
the bunk house playing the banjo and
a

1

part of and

culture
After

got to where

I
could frail.
around
for a couple of years
played
and in 1975 went to the Union Grove
ran into
Fiddlers' Convention. There
im Collier, and once again he helped me
J
out. He was playing fiddle with Barry

in

proud of the rural
North Carolina.
to

Luther Davis of Galax, Va.

be

by

from

a

Willard Gayheart
photo by Alice Gerrard

finished graduate school, got
working with North Carolina's
worked at a
Visiting Artist program.
of
community colleges before I
couple

I

I

I

job

a

I

I

got

the

chance

work

to

at

Surry

Community College in Dobson. While I
ran into the Slate
was working up here
I

Mountain

Ramblers

at

fiddlers'

Andy Griffith
Theater, and other places. I liked their
music and was very flattered and pleased
when they asked me to make music with
them. But to tell the truth, they are such

conventions,

at

the

Roger

Manley

fun people that I'd enjoy hanging out
with them even if they didn't play a note.

Bill Mansfield

1984

and Sharon Poss, who were part of the

Mountain

String Band, out of
Durham.
really liked the way the banjo
and the fiddle worked together in their
band. So
hung out with them. When
Fuzzy

I

I

they left the convention to go visit with
Tommy Jarrell and Fred Cockerham, I
managed to tag along.
At Fred Cockerham's house
got to
hear Tommy and Fred up close. I was
devastated by their music. The banjo
and fiddle had a sound of being so
intertwined that you couldn't tell where
one stopped and the other started. The
I

The Slate Mountain Ramblers are an
interesting band, not only for the music
that they play, but for the reasons that
they play old-time music. Though they
have all been exposed to other musical

manifestations

of

20th-century

they have chosen to maintain
traditional musical expression of

America,
the

Autoharp player, Kilby Snow
of Galax Va.

by

Willard Gayheart

their particular part of America.

Traditional
the years,

music has changed over
continue to change.

and will

The Slate Mountain Ramblers,
collectively and individually ensure that
the traditional music of the southern
Blue Ridge will live

on.|

Fred played the tune, kept the
rhythm going, and varied the tune was
way

what
I

I

had been

got

Barry,

looking for.
who

is

a

real

Cockerham-style banjo player,
me

to

good
show

everything he knew about that kind

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Jammin' with Uncle Tommy"
by

Willard Gayheart

�LOGO
CONTEST!!!
We are looking for a logo that
symbolizes what the Old-Time Herald is
all

about. Send your ideas/ original art

work/graphics/to: Logo Contest, c/o

the Old-Time Herald P.O. Box 1362,
Galax, Va. 24333. We will choose a
winning entry and the winner will
receive a lifetime subscription to the the
Old-Time Herald.
Entries should be received by us no
later than December 1, 1987. Entries are
not returnable.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Issues In Old-Time Music
Linda Higginbotham

by

OLD-TIME MUSIC CIRCA 1987
acquainted with the
of old-time music played
today is aware that there is a variety of
forms coming under its heading. Adding
to this confusion is the fact that although
old-time music in some form is widely
it
is
still overshadowed,
played,
especially on the commercial level, by
bluegrass, folk, and other related genres.
Because of this, it is frequently included
under those headings although it is quite
distinct. There is much that could and
should be written about how old-time
music is different from other acoustic

American genres, including popular old-

Anyone

time music. Its special quality also has a
peculiar life to it. It isn't just very old; it
is very old and still vital, still capable of
touching our souls. This deep vitality
gives it the power of a primordial womb
from which new types of music may

abundance

Gerrard

genres; however, for the purposes of this
article, I am going to assume that the
average reader has some concept of these
The issue

Alice

differences.

I

wish to address concerns
old-time music itself.

the trends within

as American
culture has grown
infinitely more complex over the past 50
years, so has the domain of old-time
music. What is called old-time music
today includes the old traditional music
and forms that are closely tied to it, yet
different. The following article is an
attempt to describe, in very broad terms,
what is happening in old-time music

Just

today.

My motives for undertaking such a
task are several. First of all, the various
trends within old-time music are not

getting

the

Second,

by
as

music

recognition they deserve.
not looking at old-time

music

within

distinctions can and should

which

spring, depending on the
needs of the times. Classic old-time
music itself cannot be replaced. If it dies
out, some aspects of its form may
continue in other music but its essence
will be lost.
Classic old-time music is subtle, not
flashy. It exhibits a controlled energy
that is not forced, no matter how fast or
intense the playing becomes. The music
has a continuous flow to it and follows

continually

Bert Dickens,

Ennice, NC

closely

1986

forms of old-time music can also be seen
as traditions of their own.
What makes classic old-time music
recognizable is hard to define. It has a
timeless quality, a depth, which sets it
apart. It is a depth that results from the
gentle shaping of the music over many

generations,

by

countless musicians.

Its

form does change but it does so slowly
so slowly that at any particular time it
remains relatively unaffected by current
trends. This makes it in some ways more
akin to the pure traditional music of a
than
to
most
land
other
foreign

some

internal

rhythmic

structure, even among the more melodic
players. Classic musicians tend to play in
small groups, taking turns if many
musicians are present. They prefer to
play with others adept in the same style
and derive immense delight from the
discovery of a new classic player. Classic
musicians often have smaller repertoires
than other old-time musicians and seem
to derive more satisfaction from playing
the same tunes again and again, refining
them over the years.
In order to become a classic old-time
player it is usually necessary to learn
from another classic old-time player or
players. This relationship frequently

be made, we

run the risk of losing the purity of the

older

motive
music,

traditional forms. The third
is to help people new to old-time
or

involved, get

who
an

are

only

introduction

marginally
to what is

going on.

The domain of old-time music can be
roughly divided into two catergories,

I
call classic and popular. In
addition to these two groups, mention
a third eclectic category.
The music in
this category has stylistically stepped
outside the bounds of old-time music
but often draws upon it as a source of
inspiration and material and so is
mentioned here.

which

I

Alice

I
mean what is often
By classic,
referred to as traditional old-time music.
have chosen to describe this category as
classic or classic traditional, rather than
simply traditional, because the popular

Gerrard

Classic Old-Time Music

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

John Rector, Chester McMillian,
Dale Morris Galax, VA
1983
L-R:

Whit

Sizemore,

Frank

Bode,

�discussed here (there are undoubtedly
other forms too) have all been around
for over 15 years and are still going
strong. I call them festival, front porch,
and collector old-time music. I did not
divide classic old-time music into sub

of time.
Certainly professional
the motive
are
not
considerations
behind learning to play any kind of oldtime music.

Because popular forms of old-time
reflect prevailing taste they are

music

groups because the similarities between

classic

Higginbotham

Mt. Airy, NC Fiddlers'

Convention 1987

well

provide

an

enduring

inspiration, purity, depth,
seemingly against all odds,

as

Higginbotham
Linda

Rorrer,
1987

guitar-Doug

old-time
kind

of

source

of

American

Winston, fiddleWinston

L-R:

banjo-David

James

Leva, guitar-Mary

1987

Popular Old-Time Music

popular
rarely

as

traditions do perform, but
professionals over a long period

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Linda

Higginbotham

any form

L-R:

fiddle-Andy Cahan, banjo-Brett
1987
Riggs, guitar-Paul Sutphin

seem

types

relatively enduring. The three
of popular
old-time music

is

the
Often
all
band or jam session will
pause and lay emphases at the same time,
in a manner that is rarely heard in classic
old-time music. The clawhammer banjo
players usually double-time their fifth
string and the fiddlers use a lot of fast,
short bow strokes, both of which
contribute to the energetic sound of the
music. Often the fiddlers will heavily
emphasize the beginning of a phrase, and
the banjo players employ a distinctive
"chunk" to their strum. Bands in festival
old-time music almost always use a bass.
Although they have learned to play
differently, the first players of this style
drew much of their inspiration from

(then)

anticipations.
in

a

classic

living

dance

musicians

Tommy Jarrell and Fred
Cockerham. The first bands in this style
such

as

(Highwoods,

Plank

Road,

etc.)

drew

twin-fiddle, fast-paced,
good-time sound of the Skillet Lickers.
Now, the tradition has taken on a life of
heavily

bound to die out or change over time
much more quickly than classic old-time
music. Y et if we compare them to trends
in
commercial American music, they

It

Festival music is usually played fast.
This speed, along with a certain density
of texture, contributes to its energy.
Classic old-time music can also be
played fast but it has a different feeling.
There is a characteristic jazzy phrasing to
festival old-time music that manifests
itself in more dramatic pauses, stresses,

instruments

culture.

Popular old-time music encompasses
of old-time music that is not
classic traditional and yet is not so
different from it that it has become
another type of music altogether. It may
display influences from other genres
such as rock-and-roll, folk, jazz, and
classical music, but it still remains
recognizable as a form of old-time
music. Like classic old-time music,
old-time
music
is
not
popular
commercial but amateur music, played
simply for the love of it. Of course bands
and individuals in both the classic and

am calling

immediate appeal.

and

access

and vitality,
in

Rorrer

banjo-

particular

to
perceptiveness,
musicians and a
classic traditional
willingness to learn from them. Because
of this, it may not be for everyone. The
musicians who do go this way find it
immensely rewarding; and they also
as

Kinney

Sutphin,

Higginbotham

their

fiddle-Kirk

L-R:

Linda

within

I

festivals play in its
widely heard at at
least three major old-time festivals
Brandywine, Mount Airy, and Galax. Of
course other forms of old-time music
can be heard at these festivals too, but
this music is particularly evident due to
the many people playing it and its

perpetuation.

a

strengths and weaknesses.
Learning to play classic
music
a
certain
requires

Festival Old-Time Music.

central importance

Although

working

festival and front porch styles.

type of music "festival" old-time
music due to its particular energy and
good-time feelings, and because of the

this contact.

classic old-time players
particular way of playing,
this is not to say they don't develop their
own sound. Each musician is quite
individual and classic players sound at
least as different from each other and
their mentors as musicians of any other
style. But they make their contributions
to the tradition almost unconsciously, as
natural outgrowth
of the music
a

their

this

players, even after they are adept, will
often make a great effort to spend time
with
other classic players, deriving
needed support and inspiration from

must learn

outweigh

players

differences for the purposes of this
article. However, will later refer to two
old-time music:
of classic
types
a
more melodically
hornpipey"
a more
oriented style, and "dance"
in
which
oriented
style,
rhythmically
some ways parallel the split between
I

Linda

occurs on a somewhat regular basis,
almost like an apprenticeship. The art of
classic old-time playing is, in large part,
contained in right-hand technique. This
makes it difficult for the novice to figure
things out properly from a recording.
Beyond this problem, there is another
difficulty. Unlike older players and oldtime players of the past, all younger
(under 50 years old) musicians today
have been heavily influenced by other
genres prior to, or along with, their first
exposure to old-time music. The result
is that while it is not impossible for a
person under 50 to be a classic player, it
requires a more conscious effort. The
players of today who attempt to learn
"on their own" will probably play a form
of popular
old-time music. Classic

on

the

own, with the players mainly learning
from, playing with, and listening to each
other (and recordings). The style is
transmitted through the close contact
that these players have with each other,
its

�for festival music

over great distances

although it spreads
represents a close

network of players.
People who are attracted to festival
old-time music find it more accessible
than classic old-time music. It fits in
better with their total musical
background. While this style of playing

lead

to

ways

a

beat which easily
draws people. It is continuing to develop
and attract new musicians and possibly
may even become as enduring a musical
form as bluegrass. Certainly this is a
movement to watch. Because of its close
association with festivals and partying
there has been a tendency not to take it

seriously

or

in many players the sense that
they have made something of their own,
there is a recognizable consistency to it.
In this sense, although festival music is
not a classic tradition, it has become a
popular tradition with a tremendous

power of its own.
Festival old-time
radiates fun. It has
ment and infectious

as a

music
an

positively
obvious excite

musical genre. But

1

believe

attitude is beginning to change.
Festival musicians' connection to oldtime music is of a different nature than
but their
the
classic traditionalists'
music is no less worthy of respect; and
the importance their music holds in
their lives is often equally great.
that

Front Porch Old-time Music. This
a

large,

diffuse

musical

event

outside

community

plays

and

repertoire

for

much front porch music comes from a
group of musicians who were them
selves inspired by classic hornpipey
fiddlers such as Charlie Fliggins and
Henry Reed, and various West Virginia
musicians. These precursors of front
porch players appreciated the simple
beauty of the old melodies and the
craftsmanship which went into making
the tunes more than they did a driving
rhythm. They followed their classic
sources of inspiration more closely then
do current front porch players.
In the late '60s and early '70s this prefront porch group was very influential.
Their records (for example, the Hollow
and the Fuzzy
Rock
Stringband

Mountain Stringband) and instructional

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Krider,

Erb, fiddle-Sumio
1987
Seo, guitar-Shirley Kohl

front porch music fulfills
aspects that classic
traditional music played in the past
(while classic musicians in many areas
play in relative isolation from their
communities) and is often associated
with a regular local dance.
Front porch musicians have several

perpetuation,

of the social

many

things in common. For one thing, their
repertoire (either directly or indirectly)
is

influenced

less

by

the

and

music or classic dance
and modal tunes are
The influences brought
folk (and sometimes
than

aforementioned

books. Their music has a
rhythmic feel to it than festival

records

jazz

and

music, and Irish
often preferred.
to bear on

it are

classical) rather
rock-and-roll (as with

festival music). There is more use of
folk
such
as
other
instruments,
hammered and lap dulcimers. It is often

course, some very
players in this group who
of

qualities associated

This is an

to imitate it.

One thing collectors share is a very
large repertoire. While classic musicians

lovingly rework

a slowly evolving body
festival players are most
likely to learn whatever tune is currently
hot, collectors are constantly on the
look-out for "new" old tunes. They are
most likely to get their music from
either 78s or new or old
recordings
but they also learn
field recordings
tunes from other old-time musicians.
Collectors are often players of
exceptional talent with the ability to

of tunes

Higginbotham

guitar-Mercedes

dulcimer-Anna

are

changes

extremely important group and one
quite different from the previous two.
Unlike front porch and festival music,
collector old-time music does not bring
other musical influences to bear on
classic old-time music but rather strives

Linda

L-R: guitar-Gail Bloomer, banjo-Steve

chord

Collector Old-Time Music.

is

Griffith,

are,

or

carry on many of the

its

in

lilt, and pretty or unusual

with
classic traditional hornpipey
music. However, the real strength of this
movement currently lies not in its most
talented members, but in its average
players. It is available to just about
anyone who has always wanted to take
up an instrument and it allows virtually
everyone to participate in an activity
which
brings
people together and
provides a dimension of creativity in
their lives.

if
community
organized dancing is
involved. Because of the strong role the

local

a

lines

accomplished

movement,

music because these players display a
more relaxed attitude in their pursuit of
old-time music than the classic and
festival players and because its roots
stem more from a "listening" than a
"dance" form of classic old-time music.
(Through a twist of fate, however, this
music now has a strong association with
dances in many areas.)

inspiration

valued.
There

their

representatives of which can be found in
every corner of the United States. I have
called this music "front porch" old-time

The

melody

simple, wholesome,
In addition to being

natural lifestyle.
attracted to the music and in keeping
with the kind of lifestyle they wished to
create, many people were starting up
square and contra dances in places
where country dancing had all but died
out; these dances used, of course, live
music.
Many present-day front porch players
have slight contact with other forms of
old-time music or even front porch
players outside their area. They learn
tunes from local front porch players as
well as from written music, tablature,
and recordings. Many of the people who
take up this music do so more for social
contact than musical expression. Their
music is very community oriented and
they are more likely to attend a festival

fulfills

played with

(for example, those by Miles
were
Krassen and Art Rosenbaum)
some of the first to reach a large
audience. They struck a chord in many
people who were at that time looking for

books

and

many different musicians.
classic or festival musicians
take new tunes and
will generally
incorporate them into their own style of
playing, a collector will attempt to play a
tune in a manner similar to the original
source.
There are two sides to collector oldtime music. One stresses the collecting
of old 78s. Much of the old-time music
these musicians copy was recorded for

emulate
Whereas

commercial purposes in the past.
collector old-time music

way,

incorporate

trends

popular

In

this

may

into

but they are trends
which were popular some 50 years ago.
Frequently this vintage music, along
with old-fashioned dress, is used for
performing purposes. Because of its

traditional music,

novelty, the vintage approach has often
come to typify modern presentation of
old-time music to the general public.
On the other side

whose

interests

noncommercial

are

lie

tune wizards

more

with

such
as
recordings
of Congress recordings and
Library
archival
sources as well as
other
field
recordings. They
contemporary

�also learn from other living musicians,

traditional

classic

including
When they

from

learn

do

players.
classic

musicians

to
remain
they
prefer
somewhat removed, learning versions of

tunes but not internalizing a particular
traditional style to the extent that they
embody it the way a classic player does.
of these musicians have the
Many
versatility to play with old-time
musicians of any type. This, along with
their
enormous
and
ever-growing
repertoires, makes them perennially
popular with all old-time players.
Without the contribution of the oldtime collectors, the stock of available
tunes would be drastically reduced.
Their versatility, musical talent, and
numerous
inspired
repertoire have
people in old-time music, and their
dedication has been a sustaining force in
the music for many years.

Eclectic Old-Time Music
Basically, two types of musicians
compose this category. On the one hand
are musicians who have more or less
consciously taken some aspect of oldtime music and blended it with another
form of music to create a new genre or
their own original music. On the other
are musicians who play many types of
music including some form of old-time
music.

almost impossible to perform
without adopting a certain element of
would say that most
eclecticism, and
old-time performers do. In general, the
more commercial the old-time act, the
more eclectic the band (or performer)
needs to be, with the most successful
being either totally eclectic or crossing
It

is

I

over

into

some

other

roll" old-time music for want of

a better
some very talented
musicians in this group, many of whom
are
Stylistically, their
quite young.
music has much in common with rockand-roll, but it is played on traditional

word.

There

are

instruments

(along

with

some

interesting additions) and uses many
old-time tunes. These rock-and-rollers
also play festival old-time music and
exert a considerable influence on it. In
some ways the rock-and-roll old-time
music that they play can be seen as a
further extension of their festival music.
Eclectic old-time music has made, and
has the potential to make, tremendous

contributions

the old-time
to
movement. The high visibility of the
many performers involved makes them
ideal spokespeople for old-time music
even if they play little old-time music
themselves. On a musical level they
often serve as sources of inspiration for
popular old-time musicians and, of
course, they make other kinds of music
besides old-time for us to appreciate.

In

Conclusion

Obviously, many people do not
neatly fit into one category or another;
some partake of several and others
change their styles over time. The
musicians from the different categories

play together, even sometimes in the
same bands. But I believe all the trends

mentioned do exist and can be meaning
fully identified. This article is not the
word but rather one of the first
words in an attempt to develop a
last

consistent

and

which represents

respectful
all

language

forms of old-time

music. I have begun work on an article
on festival old-time music and hope to
do articles on the other trends as well.
The
article(s) will be based on
information and quotes I receive from

musicians themselves.
There are people who say there is no
real old-time
music but (what I've
called) classic old-time. There are others
who claim that popular old-time music
is classic old-time music and there is no
difference. Some even claim this about
eclectic old-time music. All of these
views represent a genuine love of the
music. One seeks the continued survival
of classic old-time music; the others,
respect for new forms.
Old-time music, if it is to survive and
flourish, needs all of its forms. It is like a
rope which is composed of several
strands. Each strand contributes to the
strength of the braid. We need classic
old-time music because it is the soul and
the source; we need festival music for
the energy and life it has brought; we
need front porch old-time music for the
broad base of support it has created; we
need collector old-time music for its
and
we need
invaluable repertoire;
eclectic old-time music to gain respect
and recognition in the larger sphere.
Most important, we need all this music
because it has brought some element of

indefinable joy into our often-routine
existence, and that is what old-time
music

is all

Comments

about.
on

the column and suggestions

"Issues" may be sent to Linda
Higginbotham, c/o The Old-Time Herald,

for

future

P.O. Box 1362, Galax,

VA

24333.

more

commercially viable type of music, be it
bluegrass, folk, country, or rock-androll.
A few eclectic performers have had
considerable experience with some form
of old-time music, others only marginal
contact. In either case, their position as
performers makes them important.
When they affirm their connection to
old-time music in loving and respectful

shot

in

the arm to the

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gerrard

a

whole movement.
Unfortunately, it
sometimes happens that old-time music
is presented
as
something backward,
something to go beyond, by people
seeking to appear more accomplished.
Not all people in this category are fulltime professional performers. One of
the
most interesting and exciting
movements in eclectic old-time music is
based in upstate New York and consists
mostly of nonprofessional or semiprofessional musicians.
call it "rock-and-

Alice

terms, they give

Banjo-Enoch Rutherford,

fiddle-Tim Donley

1987

�The Dance Beat
by

Phil Jamison

THE KENTUCKY RUNNING SET
This account,

one evening after dark,
on the porch of one of the largest houses
of the Pine Mountain School, with only
one dim lantern to light up the scene. But
the moon streamed fitfully in, lighting up
the mountain peaks in the background
and, casting its mysterious light over the
It

was danced,

heels, drag their feet lazily on the floor, or
do a hoe-down step or two, i.e., a heeland-toe shuffle, or clog-dance step.
When music was used at dances, it
consisted of unaccompanied fiddle or
fiddle with banjo. Throughout the dance,
onlookers as well as the dancers would
reinforce the rhythm of the music by

alternately stamping and
is
done in various
ways, but the usual method is to stamp
with the right foot on the strong accent
"patting,"

i.e.,

clapping.

"Patting"

and

clap the hands on the weak one, the

head
his
back,
executant
throwing
inclining his body to the left and
emphasizing the movements of the feet
and hands so that the rhythm may be seen
as

well

as

hear.

The fiddler and the banjo-player each
have an assistant, a "beater," who, sitting
at
right angles to the instrumentalist,
"beats" the strings between the bridge and
the player's left hand with two pencil-like
These sticks,
sticks.
wooden
being
flexible, strike all the strings

simultaneously

and

this

produces

a

drone effect which, if the
"beater" is deft in his movements and
skillfully varies his rhythms, adds depth
to the tunes and gives material aid to the
dancers.
The players in Kentucky generally
managed, notwithstanding the melodic

rhythmical

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of
Book

V

In 1987, there are still some local and
indigenous dances to be found around
the country. In future issues of the Old

Time Herald, I will feature some of these
as well as cover other topics relating to
traditional dance and clogging (or "hoedowning," as Sharp says it was called). I
welcome ideas, comments, and
contributions to this column from any

interested

Hanlon Mountain Team;
Appalachian Photographic
Mars Hill College

Southern
Archives

poverty of the tunes, to play them with
such force and adandonment that they
made excellent accompaniment to the
The dancers set the tempo,
dance.
varying it from moment to moment at
their pleasure, and these variations it is
the duty of the player to follow as though
he were accompanying a song.

influence.

The dancers often improvised stepvariations of their own, e.g. kick up their

Part

Dance

years ago.

exaggerate
proceedings, seemed
wildness and the break-neck speed of the

dancers as they whirled through the mazes
of the dance. There was no music, only
and
the stampings
clappings of the
onlookers, but when one of the emotional
and this
crises of the dance was reached
the
times
several
during
happened
the air seemed literally to
performance
pulsate with the rhythm of the "patters"
and the tramp of the dancers' feet, while,
over and above it all, penetrating through
the din, floated the even, falsetto tones of
and
the
unexcitedly
Caller,
calmly
reciting his directions.
(The dancers held their bodies) erect,
motionless, with every limb loose and
This reposeful carriage,
relaxed.
together with the swift, gliding move
ment, gave to the dancers an impersonal,
detached appearance, as though they were
moving in a dream or under hypnotic

in

Country
Sharp's
(London: Novelle and Co. Ltd., 1918),
provides an interesting eyewitness view
of the dances of Eastern Kentucky of 70

the

to

printed

The

This is what Cecil J. Sharp reported
seeing when he traveled to the southern

Appalachian Mountains in 1917, in
search of traditional songs and ballads.
Sharp's theory was that the Kentucky
running set he observed was related to

folk dances of his native England,
which had been lost from the traditional
culture there. According to Sharp, these
dances were brought to America
sometime in the 18th century by
immigrants from northern England and
Scotland. They remained close to their
pure form due to the isolation of the
settlers in the mountains.
As Sharp described it, the dances were
done with four (or more) couples in a
square (or circular set). Each figure is
initiated by the first couple as they dance
their way from one couple to the next
around the set. When the first couple
reaches the fourth, the second couple
proceeds to the third, initiating a chain
all
of dance figures until
reaction
the
A
few
of
it.
have
done
couples
the

figures that Sharp mentions by name
are: "Shoot The Owl," "Bird In The
Cage," "Wild Goose Chase," "Going
Down Town," "Chase The Squirrel,"
and the "California Show Basket."

observers,

dancers,

or

musicians,

readers. Write to me c/o

the Old-Time Herald,
Galax, VA 24333.

P.O. Box

1362,

�BLACK STRING BANDS:
A FEW NOTES ON A LOST CAUSE
by

Charles Wolfe

People loved Arnold so well all through
Kentucky there; if he was playinga guitar,
they'd

go

up

gang

around

him

till

he

would get tired and then maybe he'd go

admired him so much
train.
never forgot a lot of things he would
say. There's things in my music, you
know, that comes from Arnold Schultz
use in a lot of my music. In
runs that
fiddle piece or a breakdown,
a
following
he used a pick and could just run from
one chord to another the prettiest you've
ever heard.

catch
that

a

1

I

1

to say, Arnold Schultz's band
never made it into a recording studio
at least playing the kind of oldeither

Needless

Monroe remembers.

time breakdowns

this one from blueQuotes
grass and old-time musicians are by no
means atypical. For 10 years I have been

such

Fiddle-Leonard Bowles, banjo-Irvin Cook, Martinsville,
Courtesy Blue Ridge Institute, Ferrum College

different version of this article
originally appeared in the March 1978
(A

Devil's Box)

Dorris Macon, the guitar-playing son
Uncle Dave
banjoist
legendary
the
to
tell
used
story of the first
Macon,
time he went to make records with his
famous father. It was in April 1930, at
of

the

old

St.

James

Hotel in Knoxville,
Vocalin Records

for

where producers
had gathered to make records of East
Tennessee acts. Musicians from as far
north as Kentucky and as far south as
Alabama had come up to the session,
which was being conducted by a man
named C.F. Lyons, who had come from

company's main office in Chicago.
assistant was well-known tiddler
Lowe Stokes, the Georgian who had
become a mainstay of the era's most

interviewing at length older country
musicians and folk musicians from the
1920s and 1930s about that misty

VA

borderland

and the "record man" Lyons
came out of his office to listen. The band
played on for four or five minutes before
Lyons waved his arms and stopped
them. "Sorry," he said. "Can't use you,"
and at this the musicians quietly walked
back down the stairs. Uncle Dave had
been enjoying it, though, and said, "Cap,
why not give the boys a chance?" "No,"
said Lyons. "That music doesn't sound
like anything I've ever heard," and
walked away. Years later Dorris, when
asked what kind of music it was, would
recall: "It was good dance music. And
that old man was the loudest fiddle
player I ever heard."

before,

What Uncle

Dave

Dorris

and

had

the
His

witnessed

popular string band, The Skillet Lickers.
"People sat on benches in the hallway
waiting for a chance to audition,"
recalled Dorris. "Pap didn't have to, of
course, but he liked to sit and watch the
others. So we sat there all one morning
watching them come and go." Just
before noon, after all the other acts had
gone, a group of four or five black men

black string band. One of Dorris
Macon's better known colleagues, bluegrass patriarch Bill Monroe, has a story
almost as good:

appeared. 'The leader was an old man
who played the fiddle, and he had a
skinny white beard." The band began
playing a tune Dorris had never heard

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was

typical
probably
encounter between the new mass media
and one of the most potent but leastknown examples of traditional music:
a

the

ever seen this
think
The first time
this square dance
man Arnold Schultz
I

was

at

I

Rosine, Kentucky, and Arnold and

two more colored fellows come up there
and played for the dance. They had a
guitar, banjo, and fiddle. Arnold played
the guitar, but he could also play the
fiddle

as

numbers like "Sally Gooden."

wherein

traditional

American folk music was somehow
transformed into commercial country
music; many, many of them mention
bands such as Arnold Schultz's string
band, and point to them as influences, as
models, as colleagues. They point to a
genre of American music that most
scholars have ignored, and that most
members of the general public do not
even know existed: a genre that DeFord
Bailey, the famous harmonica player of
the early Grand Ole Opry, defined for
me as "black hillbilly music." "Sure," he
said, "black hillbilly music. Everybody

around me grew up playin' that. Fiddles
and banjos and guitars; they weren't
playin' no blues then. It was black
hillbilly music."
For
years the emphasis of those
studying black American folk music has
the
been directed to religious music
first really respectable music to study; to

the first commercially successful
brand of music; or to blues. Y et do these
three forms really account for all of the
rich variety of black music found in folk
tradition, or just the most visible ones?
What about the rural fife-and-drum
jazz

tradition, which has lingered unnoticed
Tennessee until this present
in
generation? What about the tradition of
black non-blues secular song? And what
about the tradition of rural string band
music? To explore these aspects of black
music requires

a

great deal more musical

�archaeology, but might in the end yield
results as fruitful as those coming from
jazz, blues, and religious music studies.
Black string band music as a genre has
often been wrongly associated with
blues; while many string bands played
some blues, many others did not, and
played in repertoires and styles that
seem related to, and yet distinct from,
the styles and repertoires of white string
bands. It is -certain that the string band
tradition existed before the blues
as
a
some
older
genre;
emerged
musicians

I

have

interviewed

have

suggested that when the blues became so
intensely popular shortly after the turn
of the century, and when it emerged as
virtually the only form of rural black
music to gain access to mass media, it
virtually swamped the older forms, and
these forms were driven even further

into the backwaters of the rural South.
to
There
continued
flourish,
they

unheralded and undocumented by the
and by the commercial record
companies.
even
there
are
Oddly
enough,
band
of
a
strong string
suggestions
tradition in New Orleans, the alleged

scholars

home of jazz.
early

as

the

1

I

have found a reference, as
a black fiddler who

840s, to

been trained "in New Orleans,
where they know how to teach the fine
music." One of the first New Orleans
featured six black
in
1806,
balls,
whom
most
of
musicians,
played
fiddles; a directory of some 217 jazz
musicians who worked in the Story ville
district from 1898-1917 reveals more
fiddlers in these early bands than
had

trumpeters, banjoists, or saxophonists.
Early photos of New Orleans jazz bands

often show, in addition to a guitar or
banjo, one or more fiddles; and many
leaders of brass bands, such as Lorenzo
Tio, Sr., also led smaller string bands for
quieter parties. It is not surprising that
writer George
Washington Cable,
describing black New Orleans music as
early as 1886, claimed that the fiddle,
not the banjo, was the truly favored
instrument of the Negro.
For the record, there are numerous

instances

of

acknowledging
Muddy

origins.

blues

musicians

string-band ties and
Waters early in 1942

sang on several records by Son Sims, a
Mississippi fiddler, possibly the same
fiddler that performed with Charlie
Sam
10
Paton some
years before.
Chatman, of the Mississippi Sheiks, had
a father who fiddled tunes like "Turkey
in the Straw," as did Honey boy Edwards
and Brownie McGhee. Skipjames, Fred

McDowell,
remember

and Gatemouth Brown all
attending country dances

where the music was not blues, but
string band music. James (Butch) Cage,
who accompanied blues singers on his
fiddle, even held the fiddle to his chest as
he played, like older white fiddlers, and
remembered a number of older black
Mississippi fiddlers. Even W.C. Handy
devotes a passage in his autobiography
to remembering his Grandpa Brewer,
who had played fiddle for dances since
slavery days, making extra money and
delighting crowds in Alabama with
fiddle music accompanied by "beating
the straws": having a young boy take
knitting sticks and beat on his fiddle

as he played.
Handy's Uncle
White was even more of a showman,
and would sing and play such numbers
as "Sally Got a Meatskin Laid Away"
while stomping his feet to provide a

strings

rhythm.
The scanty references in print to rural
black music before the Civil War also
string band
suggest a flourishing
tradition. Dena Epstein's book Sinful

Tunes and Spirituals contains numerous
references. As early as 1774, a

such

diary describes a Southern plantation
party where "a great number of young
people met together with a fiddle and
banjo played by two Negroes." In the
prewar South, black string bands are
found consisting of banjos and flutes;
and
fiddles,
banjos,
triangles; twin
fiddles with a fife; and others. In the
1840s in North Carolina, a black band is

described
Cover of piano sheet music, copyright 1890
Courtesy Andy Cahan

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Kunkel Bros., St. Louis, MO

as

consisting of two fiddles,

a

triangle, and castanets.
Another important source for early
black traditional music is the life
histories collected from former slaves in
flute,

a

banjo,

a

the 1930s by the Depression-era

WPA

�project. Historian Bob Winans has
listed references to music in these, and
has found something like 205 references
to fiddle playing, 106 mentions of banjo
playing, but only 15 references to guitar
playing. This suggests again that the

instrument

often

so

associated

black music and blues

with

the guitar

the scene. Most
recalled black life
before or during the Civil War
remembered string bands as simple
the same
duos
fiddle-and-banjo
instrumentation that defined early white
string band music. Without much
doubt, the fiddle was the favorite
instrument of both white and black rural
was

latecomer

a

slaves

former

musicians

in

to

who

the 1800s.

Much of this tradition was still highly
visible in the 1920s when commercial

recording

companies

String Band, featuring mandolin, guitar,
and cello, and recorded several
fascinating sides for Columbia, while
Nap Hayes and Matthew Prater (The
Blue Boys) recorded folk variants of
Scott Joplin's rags using mandolin and
guitar. Black "hoedown" music was
recorded by James Cole (probably from
Indiana), and by the spectacular square
dance band headed by fiddler John
Lusk. This latter band, recorded by the
Library of Congress in 1946, played for
years in rural Tennessee just a few miles
from the birthplace of bluegrass star
Lester Flatt, and featured the "prebluegrass" banjo styles of the late

Murphy Gribble.
Some regions seemed to

be

hotbeds

black string bands, or at least for
those that got recorded. East Tennessee
for

to

began

Southern music. Unfortu
nately, the record companies segregated

document

into separate series, one
whites and the other for
designed
blacks. White rural music included
fiddle bands, banjo tunes, sentimental
songs, and a few religious pieces; black
music series were dominated by country
blues, gospel, preachers like Rev. Gates,
music

this

for

and

a

few vaundeville

a

Still, this miniscule sample contains
some tantalizing bits. A handful of
records from the late 1920s shows white
and black musicians playing together,
several years before jazz's first
"integrated" session. Jim Booker played
with
white
banjoist
"Grey
Eagle"

Marion

Leonard Bowles, Martinsville, VA
Courtesy Blue Ridge institute, Ferrum
College

Tennessee Chocolate Drops," and in its
hillbilly series, "The Tennessee Trio."
Most people today, though, recognize

band as the genesis of Martin,
Bogan, and Armstrong, and it was based
around the fiddle of Howard Armstrong
and the guitar of Carl Martin. More
doing over
prolific in their recordings
18
sides for the Old American
was the
Recording Company in 1931
mandolin player/
band headed
by
fiddler Joe McClain and guitarist Joe
Evans, called "The Two Poor Boys."
They did thing like "Old Hen Cackle"
this

"Sourwood Mountain" as well
novelty pieces like "Take

as
a

City, a 1928 Columbia
session
yielded a great "Lindy,
recording
Lindy" by the Proximity String Quartet,

composed of two white

and two black

musicians, and a 1927 session in Bristol
saw
a
collaboration
between white
Paul
and black
Johnson
guitarist
harmonica player El Watson for Victor
Records.

growing

up near

Tennessee,
defined another

Carthage,

just east of Nashville,
center for black string
McGee, one of Uncle
and a mainstay of the

band music. Kirk

Dave's sidekicks
early Grand Ole
dozen black fiddlers

Victor. Andrew Baxter, an AfroCherokee fiddler born in Northwest
Georgia in 1870, played regularly with
for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

unusual.
bands from that area was a black band
known to most white musicians as "the
Armstrong Boys." They actually did get
to
record at Macon's session for
Vocalion, with fiddle, banjo, and guitar,
doing two distinctive local pieces, "Vine
Street Drag" and "Knox County
Stomp." The record company issued the
78 in its race series calling the band "The

The kind of music Grand Ole Opry
star DeFord
learned while
Bailey

for Taylor's
in
1927, and a black
Kentucky Boys
harmonica stylist recorded with the
white Johnson Brothers that same year

white Georgia fiddlers, and played lead
the Georgia
Yellow
Hammers'
popular 1928 recording of "G Rag."
Other recordings reflect a complex
school of rural black ragtime; Dallas
musician Coley Jones formed the Dallas

Macon

Johnson

Underwood

on

Dorris

band

Knoxville was not that
One of the best-remembered
at

That
Both were
Baby."
apparently from Knoxville, and both
sold their records on dozens of dimestore labels to old-time fans who
probably never knew the team was
black. A popular fixture at the old
fairgrounds in Knoxville was a third
black string band, this one headed by
singer and piano player Leola Manning.
Yet a fourth group was centered in
nearby Loudin, and headed by singer
Will Bennett, who managed to record a
driving version of "Railroad Bill" at the
St. James Hotel session. Further east, in

was
full

string band.

The

blues and
Look
at

numbers. Black

minded, but
equipment
woefully inadequate for recording

one.

remembered

and

bands playing something other than
blues didn't fit into either sterotype, and
so few of them were recorded. Thus
today we are left with only a pathetic
handful of recordings representing this
tradition in its flowering: there are
perhaps as many as 50 commercial
prewar recordings that really reflect it, as
opposed to some 20,000 prewar records
of blues and gospel music. In the 1930s,
when the Library of Congress got into
the field, recorders were more opentheir

was

DeFord Bailey
Early 1930s
Courtesy Country Music Foundation,
Nashville, TN

Opry, knew over a
and banjo players in the hills near his
home at Franklin,
south
of
just

Nashville. John Work, a leader at
Nashville's Fisk University and himself
a noted
black scholar, was perhaps the
first scholar in the country to recognize
the

strength

of the black

string band

�tradition
both in this area and in
Alabama. His letters show that he knew
this music was not blues and not gospel,
but a genuine third type based on fiddle
and banjo songs, and that it was dying

it could be documented.
Work
himself recorded two fine
Nashville bands: One was James Kelly's
Nashville Washboard Band, which used

out faster than

Courthouse Square in
featuring pieces like "Old
"
"Soldier's
Joe," "Round Dice Reel,
Joy," and others. Another was the
fiddle-banjo duo of Nathan Frazier and
Frank Patterson
dynamic performers
who offered distinctive versions of
unusual songs like "Texas Traveler" and
to

on

play

Nashville,

as

Lornell

"Indian and the Woodchuck." As late

recorded James
Campbell's Nashville Street band,
featuring the fiddling of Beauford Clay,
one of Kirk McGee's friends from
Williamson
County. With the
exception of the latter, none of this

Kip

1962 Chris Strachwitz

John Lawson Tyree, Franklin County, VA

material is readily available to the
public, though plans are underway to
reissue some of it on a forthcoming
series by Rounder Records.
A complete
survey of the small
recorded heritage of black string bands
would also have to include numerous
other influential men or groups: the
Mississippi Sheiks, the one black string

band that really found commercial
success on early records and who
introduced "Sittin' on Top of the

World";

Weaver,

Sylvester

the

Louisville guitarist whose "Guitar Rag"
was the source for the Western swing
classic

"Steel

Guitar

Rag";

Peg

Leg

Howell and his Gang, the fine Atlantic
band

that featured

unpredictable

fiddling

the wild and

of

Eddie

Endres

area

own, but backedJimmieRodgersonone
session; and Oscar Woods, the
Shreveport guitarist who backed Jimmie
"You are My Sunshine" Davis on some
of his rowdier sides. Each deserves a
story to itself. And, to be sure, deserving
of a story are the few rare glimpse of this

tradition still alive, as researchers like
Kip Lornell and CeCe Conway have
discovered.

The study of black string band music
still
in
its
but
even
infancy,
preliminary investigations have posed
some potent questions: Is (was) there a
is

string band repertoire distinct
the white
one? Is there an
identifiable black fiddle style? Have
there been characteristic and distinctive
black instrumental combinations? Have
black

from

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Clifford

Anthony and recorded a dozen sides for
Columbia; Clifford Hayes and his
Louisville Jug Band, who not only made
hits for Columbia and Victor on their

Josh Thomas, Hollins, VA ca. 1975
Courtesy Blue Ridge Institute, Ferrum College

geographical

features

combinations

(do

affected

these

fiddle-banjo

combinations seem more common in
guitar combinations in
the
How really
deep
South)?
the mountains,

representative of the music were these
recording sessions? How were the bands

recorded related to other quasiblues forms such as the jug or wash
board band, the vaudeville or medicine
show tradition, or even the tradition of
that

the black non-blues songsters like Henry
Thomas, Luke Jordan, and Jim Jackson?

How were they related to various black
formal composers like Gussie Davis,
Scott Joplin, or even W.C. Handy? Until

scattered bits of evidence about this
are collected,
collated, put in
proper context, and studied, we can only
and wonder
guess at the answers
the

music

about what we have lost.

�When

I

began thinking about writing

knew two things about
music: First, he had
spent some years in Kentucky learning
music from traditional musicians there.
Second, whenever we played music
together Bruce always knew lots of tunes
tunes with
I had
never heard before-wonderful names and rhythms that
this

article,

Bruce

I

Greene's

tripped me up. In fact, Bruce knows
more about old-time Kentucky fiddling
than just about anyone else.
How did it happen? What does it
mean in the musical scheme of things?
How does Bruce Greene feel about being
one of the only people left to embody an
entire musical tradition?
Bruce was born in New York City on
January 10, 1951. His family moved to
Wyckoff, New Jersey when Bruce was a
year and a half old. He lived in New
Jersey until he went away to college.

came out of a
father
"My
homesteading family from Washington
state,"

says Bruce. "There

was

a

romance attached to the farm life

lot of
that

steered me toward folk music in some
on his
grandfather
ways." Bruce's
father's side was a singing master, and
mother listened to records of
his
classical music and Broadway shows. He
remembers that his uncle Bruce had
what he describes as a "one-man band,
with a tenor banjo with Christmas tree
lights in it," and some other

instruments.

"1 took piano lessons when I was a kid,
hated it. My parents insisted that I take
some kind of music lessons so I switched
over to guitar. They told me if I didn't
I

lessons I couldn't play
was a real ultimatum. I used
to carry the guitar upstairs and sort of
bang it against the bannisters to see if it
would break. I made a point of
take

guitar

Alice

Gerrard

baseball.

1987

Bruce Greene,
Kentucky Fiddler
by

Hilary Dirlam

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

It

everything I learned about
reading music."
Bruce remembers going to square
dances at the local Grange Hall with his
a "funky
parents. There was live band
New
band;
any
type
England
instrument they could get ahold of
and accordian, a tenor banjo, a piano.
just like all the early '50s records. It was
a
great scene!" After Bruce started
learning fiddle music he ran into some of
the tunes he had heard that band play.
"When I was about 12 a cousin of
mine came to visit. She was some kind of
a beatnik
played guitar and sang Joan
Baez songs. That got me and my sisters
inspired; we wanted to be just like her."
Bruce admits to having listened to Peter,
forgetting

Paul,

and

Mary;

Ian

and

Sylvia;

Eric

Anderson; and Jesse Colin Young. "I'd
hear little bits of bluegrass

Flatt and

�Scruggs

I

liked that

awful lot but

an

had no idea where to find it."

When his

family moved from Wyckoff to Tenafly
heard more folk music. "I was
of
by
Library
Congress
intrigued
he

of traditional Southern
music." Bruce heard the New Lost City
Ramblers and found them inspiring. He
got a banjo and started out trying to play
bluegrass, but switched to old-time as
soon as he heard it.
Bruce got a fiddle when he was 18, but
"I didn't have any idea what to do." He
had never seen anyone play. "I just tried
to get as many notes into every bow
stroke as I could." Bruce remembers
meeting someone from Tennessee
around that time who told him it took
10 years to learn how to play the fiddle.

recordings

it was 10 years
"I guess he was right
before I felt like I was playing fiddle
not just tunes."
Bruce realized that he wanted to learn
more about fiddle music. After a year at

"real old-time fiddler.
suspicious of me; he
couldn't understand my New Jersey
accent, and whenever I said anything
he'd turn to his wife and ask, 'What'd he
say? What'd he say?'"

Sammy
Sammy

Dyer,

a

was

Sammy Dyer had learned fiddle tunes
from his father and had also learned
tunes from the radio. He knew unusual
versions of old-time tunes and had a
strong bowing style. "Sammy was the
kind of guy folklorists love; he knew a
little bit of a lot of folk traditions: string
He claimed he
games, kid's games.
couldn't read or write and he had an

incredible memory."

Bruce Greene learned "Jim Shank"
from Sammy Dyer. Another tune, "Sow
in the Tater Patch," escaped Sammy's

memory. "We spent

a long time trying
this tune he could almost
He knew we could find
remember.
someone out there who could remember

to

turn

up

College in Washington State,
decided to become a student at
Western Kentucky University, one of a
handful of places offering an under
graduate degree in folklore. By this time,
he

prejudices yet."

Bruce's first school project was to
research Henry Bandy, a turn-of-thecentury Kentucky fiddler. Henry Bandy
had been quite well known
"a
showman"
and he was the excuse
Henry Bandy

ca.

1903

of

I

I

music."
The first musician Bruce met was
Casey Russell, a banjo player who lived
just across the border in Lafayette,
Tennessee. "He had been crippled with
polio, and ended up running a photog
raphy studio with a little back room
where he sold musical instuments.
Walking into the studio was like going
back into the 1880s. He had one of those
cameras where you throw a big black
hood over your head, and faded old
backdrops for people to stand in front of
Grecian
columns
it
was

incredible."
Casey Russell

in

turn sent Bruce to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

called 'Sleeping in a Corncob Bed' which
turned out to be a version of
'Sugar in
the Gourd". He also played 'Scott's
Return.'"
Another old-time fiddler in the area
was Pat Kingerey, who had learned from
his uncle. "Pat Kingerey was real sick,
too. Every time I went to see him, he'd

drag himself out of bed to play me

a

few

her

Toes,'

(probably

and
a

'Shamrock

schottische

originally)."

I

knock on doors, and find older
musicians. This was what really wanted
to do. Coming from an academic back
ground, I thought if you wanted to learn
something you had to go to school.
What really wanted to learn was fiddle

was important to him for
to learn them. He played a tune

It

Shoddy'

had

Bruce needed to start meeting members
the
of traditional
community
musicians.
Kentucky
"Working on this
research project made it easier to go out,

me.

Between

learned there was
more to fiddling than "just running the
bow back and forth. I was totally
infatuated with the fiddle. tried to play
everything I heard; I hadn't formed any
Bruce,

for

someone

more tunes. He had a real understanding
of what I was trying to do. It was
important to him, too. He knew lots of
tunes that nobody else knew: 'Whittlin'
Wood,' Tittle Daisy,' 'Sal's Got Mud

Clark
Bruce

says

"George Booker." "Dr. Humphrey,"
"Scott's Return," and "Folding Down
the Sheets" (the Kentucky name being
"Hanging Out the Sheets").
Milo Biggins was the last fiddler who
knew these tunes. His health was very
bad. "He could only play for a few
minutes at a time; his fingers would lock
up so he could just play little snatches of
tunes for me. He was like a lot of the old
he'd go home and think about
people
the tunes; try to come up with new ones

found someone
who did."
In short order, Bruce found a number
of older fiddlers
Chester
nearby;
Huffman and Sammy Walker from
Barren County, John Rountree and Elzie
Estes from Warren County, Jim Bowles
from Monroe County, Gusty Wallace
from
Metcalfe County,
and
Milo
Biggins, also from Barren County.
"He knew a lot of neat old tunes,
many of which had been brought into
the area around 1900 by a guy named
John Gregory, originally from Virginia.
He brought this great storehouse
of
Virginia tunes. Suddenly the whole face
of southern
music
had
Kentucky
it,

and

we

finally

Harry Flippen

changed."

Bruce never heard him fiddle of
course, but, from hearing others who
had learned from him, thinks that the
tunes and the style of playing are similar
to those of fiddlers like Emmett Lundy
of Galax,
He
mentions
Virginia.

Most
of
the
western
Kentucky
fiddlers Bruce met were retired farmers,
although Milo Biggins had a shoe repair
shop "full of ancient machines." Bruce
gradually came to identify with these old
fiddlers. "Because of the music I wasn't
an outsider; I was one of them."
At this point, Bruce was learning
tunes, not consciously learning style. "I
tried to make it sound like them. I don't
know how much my bowing style came
from them. Most of the fiddlers used a
vigorous bowing style, lots of energy put
into each note. Open tunings had been a
tradition, but were mostly no longer
used."
Bruce's first five years in Kentucky
were spent in the central and southern
part of the state, although he began to
run into fiddlers from eastern Kentucky
and was learning more about that style.
"I was
interested in how the fiddlers
controlled the ways they got notes
the
way they changed direction, being able
to stop the bow dead in either direction,

stopping and starting in the same
direction. I started noticing that some
classical techniques were similar, but
these

fiddlers had never had classical
training. For me, it was a whole different
idea of bow control. The fiddlers were
more connected to the old style in
eastern Kentucky, less influenced by
outside music, more connected to the
past generations."

�from
Western
Bruce
graduated
Kentucky University in 1974, bought a
farm with some friends, and kept on
learning tunes. Around this time he met

I

copied.

"I

I

found out that
Salyer, from

I

1

a

light bulb had gone off in my head

'That's it!'
what I always imagined
fiddle playing should be like. I was
seeing what I had been hearing in my
head for years. It was like a genetic

Milo Biggins

ca.

1972-73

memory."

John Salyer's sons were happy to let
Bruce listen to the tapes, and to show
him some of the tunes themselves.

some of John Salyer's
favorites had been well-known tunes

Although

and

"Wagoner"

Ground"

"Billy

he also

had never heard

the

in

Low

he says.

a couple of bands with
brother Doug in college, and now
plays with the Swinging Bridges band in
Celo. Though he hasn't made a career of
performing, many of the tunes he
in
from
the
old
fiddlers
learned
Kentucky have made their way through
him out into the wider world of younger

Bruce played in

played tunes Bruce

anyone else play: "Gilda
"Indian Ate the
"Duck
River,"
Roy,"
Woodchuck," and "Featherbed," as well
as tunes named for the fiddlers who had
"Bill
Brown," "Jeff
played them:

his

Sturgeon," and "Brad Walters."

"John Salyer played in the 'hoedown'

old-time musicians. Bruce hopes to have
audience in the future for his
a wider

simple and straightforward
bowing. He also played what consider
the old Virginia style, more complicated
and stately. His bowing is still the best
style

I

playing, too.
"There's a lot more to old-time music
than people give it credit for," Bruce
says. "Most of what we've learned is
only the remnants of a huge tradition. By
the time anyone realized it was dying
out, there wasn't a whole lot left of it.
At one time old-time music was taken
very seriously. It was like classical folk
music. They had techniques and ways of
approaching music. They didn't just
pass down the tunes, they learned ways
of playing them." Bruce sees himself as

I've ever seen or heard."

is still learning from the Salyer
eleven years, still visiting
after
family
"The
occasionally, and learning tunes.

Bruce

I went
up to visit Grover Salyer
started talking in depth about all the
different lines of fiddle musicians there
had been in Magoffin County. In one
hollow there was one style, in the next
hollow another gang with their own
style. These lines of musicians could

last time

Gustace Wallace ("Gusty") 1972

he

probably
Music
fiddler

be

traced

back

down

was
passed
to the next,

consciously tried

to

and

to play

I

it

Virginia...

from one
think they
the way the

generation before had. They would talk
about how so-and-so did play it right
and so-and-so didn't play it right."
During
Bruce

his

began

last years in
to slow down

Kentucky,
his

tune

collecting.

then I knew Guthrie Meade and
John Harrod, who were also doing a lot
of collecting, and I still had lists of
people to visit. But had begun to feel
"By

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

'Oh, didn't you know? So-and-

Bruce moved from Kentucky to Celo,
North Carolina in the late '70s. For
some time family life has occupied most
of his time; but also during these years
his reputation as a regional stylist has
been growing. Bruce has taught at the
Augusta Heritage Workshop in Elkins,
West Virginia, and the Swannanoa OldTime School in Swannanoa, North
Carolina. In the last couple of years
Bruce has played at the Toe River and
Black
Mountain Festivals,
both in
western North Carolina. This summer
Bruce got first place in the Senior Fiddle
Division at the Fiddlers' Grove Contest.
He
has
mixed feelings about this.
"Contests make me nervous; it isn't fun
"
to play music when you feel like that,

Magoffin County. got to go to his son
Grover's house and listen to the tapes....
When finally heard his fiddling, it was
like

I

irrelevant."

couldn't get that

off my mind. Eventually
fiddler was John
the

I

so just passed away.' The idea of staying
in Kentucky began to seem too painful.
And I didn't know what to do with the
stuff I'd learned. There was no one to
to
seem
with.
It
share
it
began

told Bruce about a fiddler he had spent
time with long ago. He was the best
fiddler Charlie Strong had ever heard.
to
be
fiddler
hadn't
wanted
The
recorded; his sons had convinced him
finally, but had to promise never to let
the tapes be

would knock

I'd hear

old man named Charlie Strong who

an

had been gone, many
had known had died.
on somebody's door and

"During the time
of the old fiddlers

isolated.

I had
learned zillions of tunes,
but didn't feel like it was doing me any

I
started slowing down and
spending more time with fewer people."
In 1976 Bruce took a short-term job
and realized for the
at the Smithsonian
first time that there was an old-time

good.

having become part of that tradition
as much as is possible, now that a lot of
the traditional culture surrounding the
music has been so radically transformed,

music "scene." "It freaked me out! I
wasn't used to anyone else being into
this kind of music. I felt like a curiosity; I
realized

would

I

had

experienced something

I

never be able to share." Bruce

describes

himself

"judgemental"
purist. I made

at
it

as

being

the point.
was a real
hard for myself. I had a
I

chip on my shoulder." What changed
his attitude was going back to Kentucky.

transformed.

"A person who learned it the way I did
pretty rare. just happened to be lucky
enough to get in on the last of it. I threw
myself into this dying culture; couldn't
separate it from the music. Tradition
isn't being handed down the way it once
was because a lot of the traditional
culture is gone. The rules aren't the same
is

I

I

anymore.

�"Anyone who wants to learn these
tunes now, as they once were played,
will have to learn them from younger
people like me. At some point the
people who have invested all the time
and energy into learning a tradition will
be the only ones who are a direct line to
the old tradition.
'The main point is: Is the music going
to die out or is it going to live? And if it is
going to live, what are we going to do to
encourage it? The only people I really

want to be accepted by are the people
got the music from, and I feel like I've
gotten that. I'm one of them as far as I'm

I

concerned."
Bruce

sees

the

music

as

a

real

connection to the past. "The age we live
in, most people don't care much about
the past.

The thing that got me deeply

involved in this music was a connection
to something really ancient. If you throw
yourself into it, you can connect to the
whole flow of history.

I

think the music

essence of where
a

lot of the appeal

passing on their history and the way they
felt about life. Grover Salyer always says
his father was very aware that the music

that he was
was his, but not only his
also the man passing it on from one
generation to another, and he felt keenly

a caretaker of
ancient and carefully cultivated
music. I think people in this age need
that kind of connection and assurance
that the things we love will continue.
"I'm after the qualities in the music
that make it timeless. There is an essence
of it that's still there, no matter how
much culture changes on the surface.
That's what I'm after."

the

responsibility of being

this

Bruce has just completed recording a
cassette tape of his music: Vintage Tunes
From Kentucky. It will be reviewed in the
Nov. issue of The Old-Time Herald.

Alice

Gerrard

has something of the
we came from. That's

that it has for people. The old traditional
people understood this. Even in the old
days they called the music 'old-time
music' because it bonded them to the
past. It was a way of preserving and

L-R: Don Pedi, guitar-Pat

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Sky, fiddle-Bruce

Greene

1987

�ance

on

biggest

those rare sunny

event

The

days.

Seattle is the
Folklife Festival, held

Northwest

in

a
over the Memorial Day weekend
blowout. It's free and
four-day
Center
Seattle
sometimes
grueling.

(home of the 1962 World's Fair) is the
site, and as many as 16 stages are going at
once from 11:00 A.M. until midnight.
One stage is devoted to string bands, one
to old time fiddlers, there are three or
four dance areas, workshops,
panel

countless jams.
the second biggest event

discussions,
I'd say

Schrader.Tony Goldenberg, Stu
Williams, Phil and Vivian Williams,
Gallaher, Kevin Wimmer,
Jerry
Paul Elliott, Gary Lee Moore, Sheila
Blech, Liza Constable, Rich Levine,
Jerry Mitchell, Mike Schway, yours

NMT presents national acts like Cathy
Fink, the Horseflies, Hot Rize,
Ralph Stanley, Dewey Balfa, Bob
Brozman, and Pop Wagner to name a
few who have appeared in the past year.

The University
Bistro, 4135
University Way, has been having some
old-time music about once a month.

truly, or any number of others. We've
even tracked down some old-timers who
have migrated here, like Lee Stripling
from Alabama, the fiddling son of the
legendary Charlie Stripling. Lee likes
to saw one off with friends and visitors.

it's been Hank Bradley and
friends. Mike Seeger appeared there a
while ago. The Seattle Folklore

Lately

Society

has

a

monthly coffeehouse with

The Washington Old-Time Fiddlers
Association, mostly contest-style

and

is

the

Festival of American Fiddle Tunes

at

Wash, held the week of
July 4. Master fiddlers are brought in
from around the country to teach and
demonstrate their various styles. Tutors
are
available and there are several
concerts. The big fiddle contest happens
in Weiser, Idaho about the middle of
June and I'm told there's some mindboggling music in the campgrounds.
Port Townsend,

Kerry

Blech

I

in
the
Bluegrass festivals abound
and
it's
a
Northwest,
always pretty good
bet to find some old-time music at those

events.

as
a

it

particularly
town of

is a

you were still on the Piedmont.

Seattle, there's a couple of
ways to find out what's going on. One is
to pick up a free copy of Victory Music
in

and

try

to

decipher

their

calendar. Another is to pick up a copy of
the Seattle Folklore Society flyer, which
also has a monthly calendar. There are
some sure-bet locales for old-time
action, though. Murphy's Pub, 2110
N. 45th, while usually offering Celtic
music, occasionally has some old-time,
but every Saturday at noon it is the
venue for "Sandy Bradley's Pot Luck,"
over
a
live radio show syndicated
National Public Radio. Sandy's cohorts
in crime are the Canote Twins, who lay
down some raucous fiddle music when
so moved. They usually have two guest
acts per show and often feature "name"

old-time musicians. Another sure bet is
5213
the
New Melody Tavern,
Ballard Ave. Every Monday night there

FREE square and contra dance, and
if you are so inclined, you can sit in with
the band or sign up to guest-call a figure
or two. Tuesdays at the NMT usually
have an old-time music jam session,
though first Tuesdays are given over to
step dancing. Thursdays at the NMT
find a bluegrass jam. The other nights
feature fine local and regional acoustic
music, and a couple of times a month the
is

Port

periodic

who upped and relocated to
Washington some time ago. You'd think

Review

plays "Wolves A-Howling"
Festival of American Fiddle

of Darrington,
town
of Seattle, holds a monthly

Tarheels

When

Lee Stripling, son of Charlie Stripling,

The

northeast
well
as
old-time
jam
It
is
sessions.
bluegrass
interesting place because

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddlers,
puts on many shows and
usually shows up in force at the
numerous fiddling competitions.
with
the
familiar
not
that
I'm
know there are
Portland scene but
some monthly dances there, and every
Sunday night at the East Avenue
Tavern an old time jam and clogging
session materializes. All in all, there's a

a

at

the

Tunes,

in

an

appearance

one rainy

Friday night.

Seattle is big on dances, mostly
contras. The Ballard Eagles is the
home of the regular Thursday night
There are enough monthly
dance.
dances that your month gets pretty busy.
of social
Lots
events,
weddings,
brunches, and benefits occur, so there is
to
no
of opportunity
lack
play
informally or listen. There aren't many
bands with permanent personnel up
here any more due to parental and job
obligations. Some bands have broken up
because personnel have moved away.
Some of the longer-lived bands one
might encounter at dances are Flash in

the Pan, The Mudflat Ramblers, and
Sandy Bradley and the Small

Wonder String Band. There

are

quite

few musicians, regulars on the scene,

who pop up in numerous bands and in
odd combinations. It's likely that in any
given month you'll get a chance to dance
to

Armin Barnett, Bill Meyer, David

C

a

h n

N

a

n

cy

K

a t z

M

oily

Tenenbaum, Laurie Andres, Jack
Link, Roy Marshall, Chrissie
McPhadden, Hank Bradley, Tony
Mates,

Old-Time Notes
from Music Citv

great variety of music. This past year
ethnic music, but Tom

Paley put

A1

Hart,

Barry

old-time community
Come up and see us

sometime.

Townsend, Washington

has seen mostly

a

large and friendly
in the Northwest.

Schultz,

Candy Goldman, Steve Nelson, Jim
Newberry, Mark Graham, Warren
Argo, a Canote or two, Sue Perkins,
Frank Blade, Sue Truman, Bertram
Levy, Howie and Lori Meltzer, Erin

Patty Hall

by

Is there an old-time music scene in
Nashville? To ask the question is usually
." or a
to get a hedging "well, not really.
bemused ".
maybe there is, but you

really have to look for it."
The fact is, there is old-time music in
Music City. You might have to dig
deeply into the Sunday "Showcase" to
find the clubs that offer it; you may have
to drop in and read the bulletin board at
places like Gruhn Guitars down on
Lower Broad; you might have to call up
folks like John Hartford, Frazier

Moss,

Jacky

Christian

or

Anne

Romaine,
usually know where
there is some old-time picking going on.
Though it's not a full-blown "scene," as
may be the case on either coast or in
who

university

old-time music
home in the Mid-South.
hottest old-time bands
these days is the
town
towns,

definitely has a
One of the
around

Stillhouse Reelers. The Reelers, who
have performed in this area for years,
have weathered several hiatuses and
have recently regrouped. With new
energy, they are taking the area by

Andrew Smith, Mike
storm.
DeFosche, Brooke Allen, and Paul
Ritscher offer up stunningly tight
renditions

Carter
of Charlie Poole,
and various other Depression-

Family,
era tunes.

Dressed

in

1930s

Sunday

Best, the talented Reelers are a visual
treat as well. Most recently they played

�the
to

Tennessee Crafts Fair, and according

guitarist/business

Smith,

manager

interested in engagements anywhere
in the country."
May 6 marked an important night for
old-time musicians and their fans in
Nashville. It was the third annual
"are

Tribute

Rodgers

Jimmie

concert,

American Lung
Association and hosted by Nashville's
Bluebird Cafe. The show's roster was
filled with country luminaries and other
sponsored

the

by

not so well know, but equally talented
rising stars and traditional musicians.
Among the old-time performers was

McDonald Craig,

the riveting,

one-of-

renders

who

a-kind singer
Jimmie
Rodgers' songs just like the Blue Yodeler
himself sang them. To see and hear Craig
perform is a haunting experience, so

uncannily

similar

Rodgers'. Craig

is

a

mention for their efforts in occasionally
booking old-time acts. Among them: the
Bluebird Cafe, the Station Inn, the

Sutler,

the

Corner,

and

An

lovers

event
look

Boardwalk,

Douglas

12th and Porter.
that

all

forward

traditional-music
to

each

year

Tennessee Grassroots Days. Held
in
last weekend
September

is

the
in

Centennial Park, this free
unique Tennessee festival.
Offering both music and folklife
demonstrations, Grassroots Days has
enjoyed a 12-year history of growth,
support, and record attendance, despite
dwindling financial support. Regardless
of finances, Tennessee Grassroots Days
has not missed a year.
Nashville's
event

is

a

In

selecting

performers

and

festival staff have relied
flexible definition of what
a
on
constitutes "grassroots culture." As a
result there are delightful surprises every
year at Grassroots Days that confirm
that folklife isn't just old, quaint, and

demonstrators,

rural,

urban,

hard

but

also

ongoing, evolving,
contemporary, and refreshingly
to

is

categorize.
about

information

For

more

Tennessee

Grassroots Days (or to make a much
appreciated financial contribution to the
festival), write to Anne Romaine,
Director, Southern Folk Cultural
Revival

Project,

339

Valeria

Street,

Nashville, TN 37211 (615-331-0602).

Alas, we are out of space for this issue.

his style to
is
warm entertainer, an

engaging storyteller, and continues to be
the star attraction at many old-time

music

gatherings

Southeast.

throughout

the

Also on the bill that night was oldballadeer
Roy Harper, from
Manchester, Tn. Harper usually drives
to gigs in his shiny red 1948 Chevy
Fleetline, dressed nattily in black suit,
white shirt, and bow tie. With lots of
personal commentary on the virtues of
the "good old tunes," he presents his
old-time ballads with accompaniment
and
one of his many
on
guitar
A
former railroadman
harmonicas.
himself, Roy feels a special closeness to
Jimmie Rodgers' material, and at the last
two Rodgers benefits his performances
time

inspired standing ovations.
Along with McDonald Craig, Frazier
Moss, and other traditional musicians,

Roy Harper was featured this past year
in
the Country Music Foundation's

"Tennessee Traditions" Artists-in-theSchool's
Coming up for
program.
Harper will be performances at another
Rodgers tribute concert in
Jimmie
Prairieville, Texas; the Smithville Fiddle

Convention (July 3-4);

and at special
programs for senior citizens, held every
two weeks throughout the summer at

is

a

club that specializes

in

old-

local and
can find

musicians
regular work and where Nashvillians can
always find old-time music. There are,
however, some local clubs worthy of
touring

old-time

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Clark

lacks

time/folk music, where both

Thomas

Middle Tennessee State University.
In a town that devotes its attention
primarily to commercial music (country
and rock) it is difficult to find places to
play (if you're an old-time musician) or
places to listen (if you are an
appreciater). What Nashville (still!)

Reelers L-R (standing) Paul Ritscher, Andrew Smith, Mike
(sitting) Brooke Allen

The Stillhouse

DeFosche

�McMillian

To those of you who may be muttering,
"How can she write a column on oldtime music and not mention.
.etc.,
etc." I offer the assurance that this is but
the first installment of what we hope will

occasional exchanges on MiddleTennessee old-time music. For that to
happen, however, we need your input. If
be

you have any news to share, or if you are
festival director,
an area club owner,
old-time
or
musician, please
folklorist,
add me to your mailing list. Send your
and
announcements (pictures
news
we'll try to use them) to Patty Hall,
too
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,
VA 24333. Till next time, keep on with
the good old music.

Gerrard

Alice Gerrard

Nell Smith, singer, Galax, VA

with

exception

its

is

no

well-deserved

reputation for being one of the centers
of classic old-time music. Fiddlers'
conventions abound, and old-time
for
musicians are in demand
pig
pickins', birthday parties, and other
social occasions. Since 1984, an organi
the

called

Association

Blue Ridge Music

has held

monthly meetings
Recreation Center on the
first Thursday of each month, and has
managed with very few exceptions to
sponsor monthly performances of local
old-time and bluegrass music on the first
Saturday of each month. Conceived of
in

the Galax

and

organized

by

a

group

of

local

musicians, the BRMA (an entirely
volunteer organization) presents older

musicians; those
visible and
as
well
as those
at
home,
play mostly
who are better known; and individual
musicians as well as bands. Some of the
musicians who have performed at the
as

well

as

younger

musicians who may

BRMA shows

be less

are the late

Rafe Brady,

fiddler from Laurel Fork,
a
Galax bluegrass
Va.; Borderline,
group; clawhammer banjo player Bertie
Dickens of Ennice, N.C., youngest (at
85 of the famous Caudill family of oldtime musicians; James Lindsey and the
Mountain Ramblers, still going
strong, whose former members include
such great bluegrass musicians as Otis
the legendary

Burris,
Hawks,
black

Galyean, Charles
others; the Foddrells, a

Cullen

and

country

Stuart,

Va.;

Lovell,

and

together

or

blues

duo

from

near

Evelyn Farmer, Jessie
Dorothy Hess, who play
individually

all

fine

singers and guitar players; Nell Smith,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Fancy

Gap

Lantern

is

held

at

Ruben's Red

on Saturday nights from

8:00-

This dance features old-time
music and is also worth checking out.

12:00

P.M.

About 25 miles away

unaccompanied

an

songwriter

from

the

and

singer
Galax

area;

the

local bluegrass group
features Buddy
which occasionally
Pendleton on fiddle; Clint Howard

Highlanders,

a

and the Blue Ridge Mountain Boys
These
from Mountain City, Tenn.
are just a sampling of some of the fine
musicians
and
old-time
bluegrass
presented by the BRMA. The
Association puts out a quarterly
newsletter and if anyone wishes
information on the shows, meetings,
newsletter, or any other aspect of the
organization, they can write to: BRMA,
P.O. Box 1241, Galax, VA 24333.
There are several very active local
dances with callers and live music. They
feature regional dances such as "Lady
'Round the Lady, Gent Don't Go...,"
"Georgia Alabama," and "Chase the
Squirrel." These are interspersed with
flatfoot dancing, "Paul Jones," waltzes
(which are not exactly danced in classic
waltz step), and other opportunities for
individuals or couples to show off their

expertise.

A

highlight

at

the

dance (for this writer) is
when Tom Norman plays "Backstep
Cindy" on claw-hammer banjo while
Jay Burris flatfoots. The dances tend to
be informal, and beginners needn't be
nervous about not knowing the figures.
You will be pushed and pulled along
with great good humor until you catch

Independence

on.

Two

dances

Mountain

feature

the

Shady

Ramblers, an old-time
band consisting of Whit Sizemore on
fiddle
(occasionally fiddler Greg
Hooven fills in if Whit has to work),
Tom Norman on banjo, and Chester

there

in Sparta, N.C.,
another weekly old-time music
taking place on Monday nights

is

event
from 6:00-9:00

P.M.

at

the

County Senior Center
old-time

Alleghany
classes

and guitar

in

for

fiddle, banjo,
folks ages 16 to 99. Cleo Reeves
Thornton Spencer
teaches
guitar,
teaches fiddle, and Emily Spencer
teaches clawhammer banjo. Most oldtime music lovers are probably familiar
with the work of Thornton and Emily

Gerrard

the Blue Ridge, and the Galax area

zation

1986

old-time music throughout

is

excellent

Alice

There

Alice

the Blue Ridge
by

An

guitar.

1

Around

In &amp;

on

dance band with the additional bonus of
including Tom Norman, one of the
finest traditional singers anywhere, the
Shady Mountain Ramblers have been
playing for the Independence and Fancy
Gap dances for years. Friday nights from
12:00 P.M. the dance is at the
8:00
Fancy Gap School off of Rt. 52 in
Fancy Gap, Va. The Fancy Gap dance
will resume in September after the
cafeteria is renovated. On Saturday
nights from 8:00- 2:00 P.M. the dance is
VFW building
at the Independence
off of Rt. 58 in Independence, Va. Ifyou
like dancing and old-time music, you
couldn't find a better combination than
these dances with music by the Shady
Mountain Ramblers. Another dance in

L-R:

Homer

Cleo Reeves

Reeves,

Brad

Bedsaul,

1987

through their work with the late Albert
Hash in the Whitetop Mountain Band.

People may not be so familiar with Cleo
Reeves (although they may have heard
of his younger brother, Del Reeves of

on
the
Grand Ole Opry,
"Girl
Billboard," fame). Cleo and another

brother, Homer, play guitar duets and
sing songs reminiscent of early Jimmy
Rodgers and Delmore Brothers.
For Thornton and Emily, the idea of
old-time music in a class
teaching
situation started with occasional private
lessons, and the subsequent realization,
as Thornton
said, that "when there's

�only one person that can't play, they're
pretty self-conscious, but if there're a
bunch, they're not." Thornton and
Audrey Hash
along with
Emily,

Albert

Miller,

Rutherford,

Enoch

Hash,

Flurry Dowe, started
holding classes in the Mount Rogers,
Va. firehouse near their home. (They
and

subsequently

received

National

Endowment for the Arts funding for this
project.) About a month later they
received an inquiry from the Wilkes
Community College Continuing
Education program, resulting in their

teaching old-time music classes in West
Jefferson, N.C. Through the interest and
encouragement of Gene Carpenter, an
older banjo student, guitar player, and
Gerrard

singer, Thornton and Emily approached

College, which
Community
sponsor the classes in Sparta as
well as West Jefferson.
The old-time music classes are held in
three rooms on the second floor of the
Alleghany Senior Center in Sparta. In
one room Cleo Reeves teaches guitar.
Porter Fender, a distinguished elderly
gentleman, often plays old-time fiddle
tunes for the class so that guitar students
Wilkes

Alice

agreed to

Thornton Spencer (2nd from left, seated)

and

fiddlers, Sparta, NC

1987

can learn to play backup. Porter learned
to play the fiddle years ago, moved to
Akron to work in the rubber plants,
took up his fiddle again upon retire
ment, and returned to the Blue Ridge.

to each class. Cleo is
helped out by his older brother,
Homer. In another room, Emily takes
one banjo student at a time into a corner
and works with him or her while the
others help each other and practice
tunes in another end of the room. In a
third room Thornton can be found
playing a tune with the fiddle students,
or perhaps
talking with them about
making fiddles or filling bows. When he
thinks a student is ready, he gets them to
a
tune by themselves,
always
play
He comes faithfully

Alice

Gerrard

also

Emily Spencer (seated

encouraging, always supportive.
Sometime before nine o clock, Enoch
Rutherford gets out his banjo, Carol

far

right) and banjo players, Sparta, NC

1987

Holcomb

her guitar, and various others
their fiddles, and the jam session begins.
Sometimes a few play and others listen
or flatfoot to the music, other times

everyone

Richard

joins

in.

Nichols,

so

often

bluegrass

guitar

Every
a

player, and his dad, Oscar Nichols, an
old-time banjo player, will drop by and
play along with those who want to play.

traditional

Older

musicians

are

to attend the sessions as
possible, to play with the
students, show them things, and
provide a first-hand connection to older
traditions.
The old-time music classes provide an

encouraged
often

as

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

encouraging and supportive atmosphere
which to learn. As anyone knows who
has tried to learn to play old-time music,
this is a crucial element in developing a
person's self-confidence as a musician.
Thornton and Emily guess that several
hundred students have passed through
the classes in one way or another. Some
have become extremely proficient; all
have incorporated old-time music into
in

their lives to some degree. To all, it has
provided great joy and enrichment.

Anyone who is interested in more
information about the classes in both
West Jefferson and Sparta can call
Wilkes Community College at 919667-7136. For information about the
Sparta classes, call Carol Irwin at 919-

372-4640

or

372-8840.

�GET YOUR SUBSCRIPTIONS NOW!
For Yourself &amp; Your Friends!
Become a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald. Special rates apply until Sept.
subscription will be $12.00.

wish to buy

subscription to the Old-Time Herald for

a

(Foreign subscriptions

is

a

1

enclosed

$12.00

$10.00

friend

a

1987. After Sept.

$10.00

wish to become a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald for one year
Sept. 1 please enclose $12.00)
1

I

1,

one-year
(After

is

enclosed.

add $4.00)

Name
Mailing Address
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333)
(Send check or money order payable to the Old-Time Herald,

GET YOUR SUBSCRIPTIONS NOW!
Your Friends!
For Yourself
Become a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald. Special rates apply until Sept.
subscription will be $12.00.
Sept.

1

wish to buy

1

subscription to the Old-Time Herald for

a

(Foreign subscriptions

add

is

one-year

a

1

enclosed

$12.00

$10.00

friend

a

1987. After Sept.

$10.00

a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald for one year
please enclose $12.00)

wish to become

I

1,

(After
enclosed.

is

$4.00)

Name
Mailing Address
VA 24333)
(Send check or money order payable to the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,

GET YOUR SUBSCRIPTIONS NOW!
For Yourself &amp; Your Friends!

Become a Charter Subscriber
subscription will be $12.00.
I

wish to become

Sept.
I

1

a

to the Old-Time

Herald.

Special

rates apply

until Sept.

1,

1987. After Sept.

$10.00

Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald for one year

is

1

enclosed

a

one-year
(After

please enclose $12.00)

wish to buy

a

subscription to the Old-Time Herald for

a

$10.00

friend

(Foreign subscriptions

add

$12.00

$4.00)

Name
Mailing Address

(Send check

or

money order payable to the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

enclosed.

�County

S

■J

Ln
HJ

"HAT-3022
*CO-791
*CCS-110
"CMF-009
"CO-788
"REB-850
*FF-352
MA-014
"CO-790
"TR-5055

*HH-19842
*SOW-7811

CO-545
AJA-5042
CO-509
OH-167

CO-789
MS-45003
CO-526
HER-22

ROU-0057
CO-548
FF-251

CO-406
CO-737
HER-39
CO-712
CCS-

1

02

HER-63

CO-777
ROU-0058
GFS-901
AH-002
AHR-001
YODEL-01

AHR-003

SOUNDA-001

C2T-40149
ROU-0201
*GJ-19861
P-l 3263

"CCS-108
"REB-852
"KING-864

HJ

Kj

CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 1940s King material
LOUV1N BROTHERS "Radio Favorites 1951 -57" Super LP of early radio broadcasts
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumental" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T. Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTWICH &amp; H1GG1NBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
NO STRINGS ATTACHED "Dulcimer Dimensions" Dulcimer LP by this popular Roanoke band
HEE HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing
JERRY READ SMITH "The Strayaway Child" Much acclaimed hammer dulcimer album

$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.75
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00

TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music
UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine 1920's/30's sides
JIMMIE RODGERS "Train Whistle Blues" Super reissue of train songs by Rodgers- Import
Vol 2 Classic recordings with the North Carolina Ramblers
CHARLIE POOLE
VERNON DALHART "The Wreck OfThe Old 97" with Carson Robison &amp; Adelyne Hood
DEE &amp; DELTA HICKS "Ballads And Banjo Music From The Tennessee Cumberland Plateau"
WINK THE OTHER EYE Old-time fiddle band music from Kentucky, 1920s/30's recordings
Vol 2 Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
SKILLET UCKERS
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carroll County, Virginia
Vol 1 Old-time instrumental music recorded in North Carolina and Virginia
OLD ORIGINALS
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920 s/30's
HOTMUD FAMILY "Meat And Potatoes And Stuff Like That" w/TJLundy on fiddle
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 1938-41
RAY &amp; INA PATTERSON "Songs Of Childhood &amp; Home" Lovely mandolin/guitar duet singing
OLD FIVE-STRING Clawhammer banjo solos by Bobby Fulcher, Paul Brown, Andy Cahan, etc
COON CREEK GIRLS Wonderful late 1960s recordings by this popular female string band
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Blue Ridge Cabin Home" Super reissue of the middle 1950 s recordings
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL with Mike Seeger, Brad Leftwich, Benny Jarrell, etc
VIRGIL ANDERSON "On The Tennessee Line" Old-time banjo from the upper Cumberland
Vol 2 More old-time instrumental music from North Carolina &amp; Virginia
OLD ORIGINALS
SEEMS LIKE ROMANCE TO ME Traditional fiddle tunes from Ohio
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American fiddle music from Mississippi
FIDDUNG JOHN JOHNSON Old-time fiddle music from Clay County, West Virginia
CRITTON HOLLOW STRING BAND Traditional music from Paw Paw, West Virginia
ELK RIVER BLUES Traditional fiddle tunes from Braxton County, West Virginia
EDDEN HAMMONS COLLECTION Historic set of traditional fiddle music
BOB WILLS "The Golden Era" Recent 2-LP set of his fine Columbia recordings
TONY RICE "Me &amp; My Guitar" With Sam Bush, Jerry Douglas, Bobby Hicks, Vassar Clements
GRANDPA JONES "Gospel Live From Hee Haw" More fine gospel music w/Grandpa&amp; company
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Songs Of The Carter Family" Fine 1960 LP with Maybelle Carter
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings" His classic sides from the 1950's
LOUVIN BROTHERS "The Best Of' Features their top songs from the middle 1950s
STANLEY BROTHERS "Country Folk Music Spotlight" Fine bluegrass LP from 1963

$7.00
$7.00

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted by an asterisk

I*TR-1
[■H

H

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS

Qa
PQ

Sales

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
W
READY FOR SHIPMENT

$10.00

$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
0.00

KJ

^JK

M
1^1
rTB

1

$10.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00

[g|

"

")

On all ORDERS in U.S. A please add $1.50 postage &amp; handling
CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $4.00 postage for first 1-3 LPs, $1.00 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

LJH

LJH

�Record
Artists and record companies-please
send records and tapes for review to The
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1363, Galax,
VA 24333.

Reviews

songs, one sacred
number, and a fine fiddle-banjo duet to
round things out.
The album is not without its faults,
but I wish to take issue with another

couple of old-time

who dismissed these
performances as "average old-time

reviewer

Black-Eyed

Susan
Robert Sykes
&amp; The Surry

County Boys
Susan

Black-Eyed

Heritage 057 (Heritage Records, Rt. 3,
Box 278, Galax, VA 24333)

I

Don't

Love

Nobody/Paddy

the

on

Turnpike/Old Crossroads/Old Joe
Clark/Sweet Bunch of Daisies/
Honeysuckle/Cumberland Gap/
Willow Garden/Cacklin' Hen/Susan
a
Friend/Peacock
Anna
Gal/What

Rag/Robert's

Serenade/Black-Eyed

Susan

Robert
mandolin
and

Sykes-fiddle/Verlen
and

vocals/Frank

CliftonBode-guitar

vocals/Paul Brown-banjo

A few years

ago

after attending the

Airy Fiddlers' Convention in
North Carolina, my wife and went on a
tour of local radio station WPAQ.
There we heard some wonderful tapes of

Mount

I

bluegrass and old-time musicians
recorded live on WPAQJs "Merry-Goarea

Round" show, and it was then that first
got to hear and appreciate the fiddling of
Robert Sykes. I had seen Robert sitting
in at sessions with his friend, the late
Tommy Jarrell, at the Galax Fiddlers'
Convention, but on those occasions the
center of attention was almost always
I

the

dynamic Tommy.

Robert began playing as a teenager in
the late '20s, and continued making
music with family members, friends,
and neighbors on up into the early '50s,
when he laid his fiddle down for 25
with
In
the late
the
'70s,
years.
of Tommy Jarrell and
he
took
it up again. And now,
others,
happily for us, Heritage Records has

encouragement

an
album containing
released
14
examples of Robert's playing. With the

help of singer and guitarist Frank Bode,

Paul
and
Brown,
Verlen Clifton, Sykes
presents a good sampling of some of his
favorite fiddle tunes, together with a

banjo-picker

mandolinist

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddling." This is solid Mount Airy-style
music of the kind that has
band
maintained my interest in old-time
music over the years, and kept me
the
500-plus miles from
traveling
to
events like the Mount
Pennsylvania
Airy and Galax fiddlers' conventions
every summer.
Most of the tunes here are standards,
strongly associated with this part of the
country. The band works well together
on such warhorses as "I Don't Love
Nobody," "Cacklin' Hen," "Old Joe
Clark" and "Susan Anna Gal." Sykes'
fiddling is at its best on faster break
down tunes like these, where his years of
playing at dances, parties, and schoolbreakings in Surry County leave him in
good standing as a fine dance fiddler.

Especially noteworthy are the unique
treatments given to "Black-Eyed Susan"
(which becomes a whole different tune
in

the

key

of

A),

and

"Robert's

version of "Clinch
Serenade"
(a
does
Mountain
Sykes
Back-Step").
another exceptional job on "Paddy on
the Turnpike" (a version similar to that
who learned
played by Tommy Jarrell-it
from whom?). On "Cumberland
Gap," Paul Brown's clawhammer work
sets off Robert's playing nicely in the
traditional mountain pairing of fiddle
and banjo, while more recent influences
can be heard in Sykes' rendition of
Arthur Smith's "Peacock Rag."
most part, WPAQ's Lew
Heritage Records' Bobby
Patterson have done a good job of
mixing and mastering the cuts on the
album. In a couple of instances tunes
begin with annoying fade-ins (somewhat
abrupt on "Cacklin' Hen), and "Willow
For

Bode

the

and

Garden"
problems
seem to
but these

forgiven.

has

some

recording-level

start. Levels in general
fluctuate a bit here and there,
minor technical flaws are easily
All but two of the album's cuts
from live radio performances.
at the

are taken
The exceptions are "What a Friend" and
"Cumberland Gap."
I
that you buy this
recommend

record, put it on a cassette tape, and play
while you're driving to the fiddlers'
conventions this summer. It'll put you
in the proper mood. (Frank Dalton)
it

�dance to fiddlers Sam Avery and Sam
Green as they tear through "Silk and
Satin" and "Mulberry Gap." Barnicle
was an important figure in the history of
field collecting and Smyth's discovery
allows us to appreciate even more of her
work. (Kerry Blech)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�South in those earliest days of recorded
country music. By presenting a wide
range of examples from a geographical
area covering eight different states, and a
time period spanning 10 years (19281937), the album makes its point well.
These musicians were playing music
that was modern for its time and place,
expanding and updating a rich musical
heritage handed down to them from an

earlier time. The record jacket, one of
County's slickest, shows four musicians
grouped around a spanking-new Ford
automobile, with not a mule or bell-cow
in sight. The influence of jazz, blues, and
swing music on these bands is obvious
after even the most casual listening. Tin
Pan Alley and ragtime have also left their

mark, and the fact that not all Southern
to
the
limited
bands were

string

fiddle-tune

becomes

traditional
quite clear as we listen
nerformances on this record.
fare

to

the

two

Ramblers released
sides in 1937, and they
close the album. Their
and
open
"Franklin County" Blues and "Ridin' in
an Old Model T" are highlighted by the
jaunty fiddling of blind musician Ed
Rickard (an Alabama state champion in
1936), and some choice bass playing
Fiddler Ben
from Wally
Wimbly.
The

Dixie

commercial

his group, the Grinnell
Wolfe's notes for
Charles
Giggers (see
the derivation of the band's name),
perform two tunes influenced by classic
piano ragtime. "Duck Shoes Rag" and

Tinnon

and

"Plow Boy Hop" were recorded by this
in 1930. (The latter tune
is still current in their home state under
"Tennessee
the title "Kansas Rag").
River Bottom Blues," done by Mike

Missouri group

Shaw's Alabama Entertainers, features
fiddle and kazoo. One's appreciation of
this performance may well depend on
one's opinion of the kazoo as a musical

instrument.

At

any

Wolfe

rate,

speculates that this obscure band may
have been composed of black musicians.
The Freeny Harmonizers, in a threeman version of a larger band that some
and
horns
included
times
drums,
recorded "Podunk Toddle" in 1935.
The

from

tune, actually

around

a

medley

Leake

of pieces

County,

Mississippi, features fiddling by Ira Ellis,
the band's part-time trumpet player! In
the case of the Scottdale String Band, a
group hailing from the Atlanta suburb
the lead
of Scottdale,
Georgia,
instrument was usually the banjomandolin. On "Waiting For the Robert

Lee," the sound of that instrument
predominates, despite the addition of a
E.

fiddle.
The

earliest

recording

in

this

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in
1928
was
done
collection
by
McLaughlin's Melody Makers, whose

"Dill Pickles Rag" may be the most "old-

fashioned" sounding piece on the
the
album.
swingiest is
Perhaps
"Skyland Rag," done by the Rector Trio
at their only recording session, in 1930.
Fiddler Pender Rector was one of the
most innovative players in the Asheville,
N.C., area, and if the rest of the material

recorded
included here,

he

is
it

as good as the piece
deserves to be heard on

future reissues.
fine mandolin
Two

Mountain

Toddle"

Rag," are

rags,

"Stone

"Mandolin
Walker's Corbin
and

played by
Ramblers and H.M. Barnes' Blue Ridge
Ramblers respectively. The well-known
"Stone Rag" is here too, in a spirited

version
by
recorded in

Maddux

the

1935.

Virginia musician
some hot fiddling

Family,
West
Jess Johnston does
Legendary

on "Killin' Blues,"
the
equally legendary
accompanied by
Byrd Moore on guitar. (Johnston was
also an accomplished guitarist. Listen to
Old Time Mountain Guitar
County

is from Will
from
Vardaman
Ray, brothers
Mississippi who usually performed as
part of a five-piece band (there were
Their
1930
other brothers.)
three
Will's
feature
a
duo
as
recordings
graceful, eccentric fiddling and
Vardaman's guitar back-up. (The tune
given here has been released before on
Traditional Fiddle Music of Mississippi,

523). "Jake Leg Wobble"
and

Vol.

2

County 528.)
sounds like there's

a lot to absorb
is. Fourteen
there
here,
some of them
solid performances,
superb, are offered up from 12 different
bands. The notes are filled with detailed
information about the musicians and the
music they played. Although most of the
performers on this album were fairly
obscure, and many released only a
handful of commercial recordings, the
music presented here is exciting and
vital. It is music that was not as well
documented as it should have been, but
which has to be heard before we can
draw an accurate picture of the history
of old-time string music in the South.
Ridin' in an Old Model T is another

If it

that's because

example

of

County

Records'

praiseworthy efforts at turning out fine
anthologies of early commercial country
music. (Frank Dalton)

�notes are very brief and do not give
credits concerning the singers or tune
sources. All selections are cleanly played
and recorded, and the result is a tight,
bouncy sound. "Polecat Blues" and
"Looking for Money" stand out as

highlights.
Although all the musicians are very
proficient, the harmonica work of Mark

Graham

is

contributions

exceptional.

His

add significantly to the
overall sound of the band.
On the whole, the stronger half of this

album is by the Tompkins County
Horseflies. The four-member band has a

unique

sound:

their

creative

combination of other musical influences
with Southern string band music can be
readily heard. The outcome is a tight,
"together" sound with a distinctive
rhythm.

The Flies present eight selections, two
of which are songs. Their liner notes are
more complete, with references to the

singers and to tune sources. Jeff Claus
sings lead to Richie Stearns, harmony on
"Zion," a Jamaican reggae number they
learned from The Ethiopians. Richie
also adds his own "Slow Falling Star"
with Judy Hyman on harmony. Other
standouts are "Benton's Dream" and
"Bloomington Breakdown." The dance
floor beckons on these two tunes, for
the music quickly gets into your feet.
This album by the Chokers and Flies
has some strong merits; however, if you
are an old-time purist, straight and true,
you may not care for it. Traditionalists
do not want the heritage to be lost in a

progressive

movement.

Their

dedication and respect for the legacy of
old-time music are qualities of the
highest order. On the other hand, this
progressive sound has a way of appealing
to a newer and younger audience. This
music often bridges a gap between oldtime and other styles of music. Let us
hope this newer audience will grow to
appreciate both the new sound and the
foundation from which it came. (Dale

Morris)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�and

Tommy

Jarrell

head

up

a

Creek
distinguished
Boys grew up during the 1920s when
old-time string music was part of
everyday life. This recording saves for us
the music of a great band that was
carrying on a tradition of an earlier time.
Recorded by Charles Faurot in the
mid-1960s, the album captures some of
the finest old-time music ever recorded.
Faurot used only two microphones in
his recording, one for the fiddle and one
for the banjo, with the accompanying
guitars and mandolin gathered in close.
This process was a success; the sound
quality is good, and it shows that an
expensive studio isn't necessarily
list.

The

Camp

essential.

Freeman of County Records
provides some very interesting liner
notes, not only about the band, but also
about old-time music in general. He
comments briefly yet accurately on the
history of the area and its music. For
anyone new to old-time music, this
album makes an ideal starting point
not only musically, but also historically.
The full and lively sound of the Camp
Creek Boys won them many prizes at
area fiddlers conventions. In fact, they
often had to compete in the same band
category with bluegrass bands. It is
interesting to note that it was only in
1971 that the Galax convention created
for old-time bands.
a separate category
This intense competition helped the
Camp Creek Boys maintain the clear,
on this
driving style demonstrated
album.
There are 12 tunes on this LP. All are
traditional, yet tunes like "Fortune,"
"Let Me Fall," "Fall on My Knees," and
Dave

"Cider Mill" are rarely heard outside the
Mount Airy-Galax region. Two of the
selections, "Old Joe Clark" and

"Soldier's Joy," feature the duet picking
of Fred Cockerham and Kyle Creed. To

this day many enthusiasts list Fred and
Kyle as the best when discussing oldtime fiddling and clawhammer banjo
respectively. Kyle, Fred, and Ernest East

capably switch about throughout the
album. Kyle fiddles on two numbers,
Fred plays fretless banjo on two, and
Ernest fiddles on two (one with Fred),
and he plays guitar on yet another tune.

accompaniment of Paul Sutphin
Collins on guitars, and
Verlen Clifton on mandolin add
significantly to the overall sound of the

The
and

Camp

Ronald

Creek

Boys. Part-time

member

Roscoe Russell of Galax also plays guitar
on one selection. Other highlights are
the strong singing of Paul Sutphin on
"Let Me Fall" and "Lonesome Road
Blues," and Fred's distinctive vocals on

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Fall on My Knees," "June

Apple," and

"Cotton-Eyed Joe."

of the Camp Creek Boys
presented here have passed on. Fred,
Kyle, and Ronald Collins are gone, but
the memories and their music remain.
They left a legacy of the highest quality,
and old-time music is certainly richer for

Three

their contributions. (Dale Morris)

�information

about

the

tunes,

the

repertoires of the musicians, and stories
of their lives in their own words. It is
illustrated with photographs from the
present day and the distant past, and is
altogether as interesting as the record.
There are problems with this record
that listeners will undoubtedly note.
The sound quality is highly variable
since all the recordings were made at the
under
musicians
homes of 'the

circumstances not conducive to studio
perfection. Likewise, the musicians were
no

longer

"in

their prime" when these

recordings were made, and the effects of
age on technical facility are sometimes
noticeable. None of this bothers me.
What comes through so clearly here is a
great and emotional music, cultivated
and nourished by three fine musicians,
throughout the best part of a hundred
years. (Craig Johnson)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�OLD-TIME MUSIC ON THE RADIO
Emily

by

J.

Fine

Early country music by transitional
figures like Jimmie Rodgers, the Carter

Fiddlin' Arthur

and

Family,
played

once

in

a

long

Smith is
while on

2-hour blue
"Sunnyside,"
grass and country music show aired on
WXPN's

Saturdays.

WHYY-FM,

91 FM,

Philadelphia, PA.
Old-time music

topics featured
Boy
"Country

in

one of the many
depth on Bob Carlin's

Rock-and-Roll,"

P.M. on

2:00-4:00

is

Sat.

this National Public

Radio station.
Carlin, a noted
record
producer, and
performer,

of Old-Time
Friends
Music, Goldstein is a primary influence
of the
on the thematic orientation

Brandywine

Brandwine

Mountain

Music

Convention each year.

Tell us where you can hear old-time
on the radio! A listing may be
compiled for inclusion in a future issue.
Write to the Old-Time Herald and
include the following information: the

music

station's call letters, frequency, location,
affiliation (university, NPR, etc.), the
shows which feature old-time music,
times, and hosts. An address and phone
number for the station would be helpful
in confirming this information.

of the radio series "Our
Musical Heritage", looks at facets of
"roots music," with special attention to
music of the southeastern United States
and to new releases on LP and CD.

producer

WXPN-FM, 88.9 FM,
Philadelphia, PA.
hours

Thirty-two

music

can

be

supported,
community

a

week

of

folk

found on this listener-

non-commercial,

station

affiliated

University of Pennsylvania.

with the
Listen for

old-time music as part of the multi-genre
traditional folk and acoustic music
show, "Homegrown," M-F 9:00 A.M.12:00 noon, and especially featured on
Emily Fine's Tuesday 'Homegrown."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

WXDR-FM, 91.3 FM,
Newark, DE
Five

hours of mixed old-time,
and country
bluegrass,

traditional
music,

along with a bit of Cajun and
swing, are broadcast every
on
WXDR. Alice Sebrell's
Porch Blue Ridge," Sat. 9:00-

Western
weekend
"Back

"Fiddle Workshop"
by

11:00 A.M., and Carl Goldstein's "Fire
on the Mountain," Sat.
P.M.,

11:00

Willard Gayheart

A.M.-2:00

contain about one quarter old-time

music.

As chairman

of the board the

This is our first issue and we would
like to hear from you: What do you
think of the magazine? What kinds of
articles, columns, etc. would you like
to see in future issues? Write to us at
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA., and let
us hear your voice.
Do any of you have questions and
know where to go for the
answers? Who originally recorded
'Candy Girl'? "What kind of strings
do you put on a banjo ukelele?" "How
can I play clawhammer banjo if my
fingernail keeps breaking?" It takes a
special person to be able to answer all
these and many, many more obscure
questions, as well as many more
common. We have found the perfect
person in "Uncle Harold" who, with
the help of other knowledgeable
folks, will try and answer your
questions. Please direct questions to
"Ask Uncle Harold", c/o The OldTime Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,
VA 24333.

don't

�V

Your Best Source for:
Harmonica
Fiddle
Guitar
Dulcimer
Blues Old-time Banjo
American Folk &amp; Celtic Music

recordings in print, many with
tablature books available if you want to learn the
pieces. We also have Teaching tapes for beginning
advanced
and
dulcimer,
guitar,
banjo, beginning
banjo, and dulcimer.
We

have

over

150

Kicking Mule records have been featured in the
Nature Company and Wireless Catalogs, and three of
our dulcimer albums were Book of the Month Club
"Alternate Recording Selections."
Current new releases include Indie winning The Hills
Horse
of Mexico hv America's favorite cowboy duo
Sense; and If This Ain't Genius by the Cranberry
Lake Jug Band
Ask

for

a

free

copy
of

the

of

best

our
in

page illustrated
Folk Music
48

Kicking Mule Records, Inc
POB 158-OT
Alderpoint, Ca 95411
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

catalog

�BRI

RECORDS

VIRGINIA TRADITIONS SERIES
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI

001 Non-Blues Secular Black Music
002 Ballads From British Traditions
003 Western Piedmont Blues
004 Native Virginia Ballads and Songs
005 Blue Ridge Piano Styles
006 Tidewater Blues
007 Virginia Work Songs

Prepaid orders only. Add

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1.00 per album for shipping and handling.

money order
Blue Ridge Institute
Ferrum College
Ferrum, VA 24088

Check

$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$9.98

or

to:

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

XO
'L3
V.1
#1

HULK RATE
U.S. POSTAGE

PAID

Woodlawn,
24381
Permit

VA
#4

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12112">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 1, Number 1 (Fall 1987)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12113">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12114">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 1 (Fall 1987)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Featured articles:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Slate Mountain Ramblers,” by Bill Mansfield, Barbara Poole, Alice Gerrard, Dan Williams, and Richard Bowman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Black String Bands: A Few Notes on a Lost Cause,” by Charles Wolfe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Bruce Greene, Kentucky Fiddler,” by Hilary Dirlam&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12115">
                <text>1987</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1296">
        <name>1987</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5428">
        <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5469">
        <name>Barbara Poole</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5468">
        <name>Bill Mansfield</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5475">
        <name>Bruce Green</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5417">
        <name>Charles Wolfe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5470">
        <name>Dan Williams</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5476">
        <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5413">
        <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5471">
        <name>Richard Bowman</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5472">
        <name>Slate Mountain Ramblers</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2508" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3433">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/083847cdd5ddea476c3104cc89331c28.pdf</src>
        <authentication>06009804f360e0a723d4807fac03e50a</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12116">
                    <text>$3.50

The OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Summer

May

the
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Heartbeats

July 1988

�Brandywine
mountain music

'88

convention

&lt;8^

/n\

v

JULY

15-17
FAIR HILL, MD.
PLEASANT VIEW
STABLE S
ON

h

/7\

A/

KIRK ROAD

v^iii^vN
ir

Tickets
Saturday
Sunday

Weekend

6.00

PM

Noon-Midnight
10:00 AM-5:00

1

PM

3.00

12.00

29.00

ticket

Children under 12 free
Senior citizens half price
Camping and parking included
No advance ticket sales
Motels available in nearby Newark, DE
24 hour security
No drugs or pets
No alcohol in stage area
For more information, call (302) 475-3454
or write Box 3504, Greenville, DE 19807

Ark.

Southard Audio

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(Sat,

Sun)
Sun)

(Sat, Sun)

Major Contay

&lt;Sl

Canebrake

Rattlers (Sat)
Matokie Slaughter (Sun)
The Wildcats (Sat)
Mike Seeger &amp; Paul Brown
Southern Mtn. Melody
Makers (Sun)
Mac Benford

Music, a non-profit organization dedicated
preserving and presenting traditional
American folk music.

(Sat)

(Sat)

(Sat)

(Sun)

Nashville Bluegrass Band
The Dixie Hummingbirds

Three days of concerts, workshops &lt;Sc
dance. Friday dance featuring the Rural
Rhythm Stringband with caller Pete
LaBerge and also Tracy Schwarz &lt;Sc the
Green Mtn. Cajunos; Dance workshop
and dance on Sat. afternoon 4:30-6:00
PM; Acres of the finest old time
musicians in the world; Camping; Food;
Crafts; Music concessions. Presented by
the Brandywine Friends ot Old Time
to

Fiddle Puppets &amp; Steve
Bud &amp; David Reed

by

(Sat,

Melvin Wine &amp; Sarah Singleton
Braxton County Fiddlers (Sat)
Springgap Hellbenders (Sat)
Volo Bogtrotters (Sat, Sun)
The Skirtlifters from N.E.

Hickman

Sound

'

PRESENTING

Bogan &amp;l Armstrong
The Troxell Brothers
Friday Dance 7:30-11:30

A

(Sun)
(Sun)

�The OLD-TIME HERALD

Vol.

1

No.

4

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
P.O. Box 1362
Galax, VA 24333

703-236-7808
Editor
Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Brad Leftwich

Linda Higginbotham
Hilary Dirlam

Dance Editor
Phil Jamison

Advertising

Dale Morris
Michael Ayers

Administrative Consultant
Bobby Patterson

The Old-Time Herald is published quarterly
the first of August, November, February, and
May by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
P.O.
Box
1362, Galax, VA 24333.
Subscription rates payable in advance. One

$12.00 (foreign subscriptions $16.00
U.S.). Classified ads cost 35 cents per word,
minimum $5.00. Any grouping of letters or
numbers is counted as one word. All
classified ads must be received by the first of
the month, one month prior to publication.
Postage paid at Woodlawn, Virginia, second
class application pending. POSTMASTER:
Send address changes to the Old-Time
Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333.
year

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�perhaps

act,

of

one

the

crossovers." They would

have

"country
been

a

perfect opener for the Grateful Dead.
Old-time music has the potential to
charm millions. Perhaps a band of today
could seek to tour with an established
artist or group. They could reach huge
numbers with exciting and enormous

be great to see a column where
callers could exchange dances or tips on
how to improve their calling skills, etc.
am always looking for a new dance to
add to my small collection.

would

I

Gretchen Kerndt
Fairbanks, AK

possibilities.
Tony Goldenberg
Seattle, WA

acquainted with oldmusic about 5 years ago when I
moved to Beech Mountain, N.C. from
California.
My first evening in North Carolina, a
friend took me to a gathering of people
sitting around a fire playing the fiddle,
banjo, guitar, and bass. This was my first
introduction to old-time music. Since I
now live in the city have lost touch with
the music and the people. Your magazine
has
reacquainted me with the
opportunity to experience the music and
the people once again.
I

first became

time

Comments &amp; Corrections:

I

love Samantha Bumgarner's banjo
wish she was still around. I
playing.
would like to see someone do an article
on the Crook Brothers before they go.
They're the oldest band on the Grand
Ole Opry.
like to say that I was not born
I would
in Culpeper. My family lived there at the
time of my birth. I was born in Char
lottesville because it was the nearest
I

I

hospital of any consequence at that time.
started playing
Another
thing-clawhammer banjo just after the Galax
I

Convention of '69, not '60. I
did clawhammer wrong for four years,
and it was November of '73 when Lou

Fiddlers

McRae straightened me out. And it was
eight months later where I placed third at
Galax, August of '74. I'd never heard of
clawhammer banjo in 1960, not even on
those John Carson records. I think that
Traveler" had something
"Arkansas
pretty close to clawhammer. I can't
really tell what he was playing on that for
sure. It may have been just another form
of fingerpicking, but who knows.
The Buzzard Brothers tape cannot be
obtained from Liberty Audio. Anyone
who wants to obtain one can obtain one
from me (8002 Neuson Ct., Richmond,
VA 23229).
Harold Hausenfluck

Richmond, VA

Anne Gahagan
Hopewell, VA

I really love old-time music, especially
Gid Tanner &amp;. the Skillet Lickers and

Uncle Dave Macon. Their instrument
ation is something else! I am a devotee of
it's my absolute favorite,
Cajun music
of the fiddle and the
the
sound
especially
French accordian. I hope to acquire a
triangle soon, and will try to learn to
accompany my Cajun records.
listen to the "Down Home Show"
"Hillbilly at Harvard" on WHRB,
Harvard radio in Cambridge, Mass., and
really feel that the "Down Home Show is
very, very well done. forgot to mention
I

and

I

also love the instrumentation
singing of the Carter Family.
that

I

Elizabeth Duncan

Boston, MA

I

the

enjoyed Mac Benford's column
last

OTH.

It

was

always

easy

to

envision the Highwoods
Stringband
opening for a nationally known big-time
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"music-hobbyists,"

or

quasi-political

journals. Your tasteful, informal, and yet
well-informed first efforts are what I had
hoped to find again after the demise of
my most recent favorite, the Black Sheep
Review.
Even if everything else fails to meet
my expectations, Linda Higginbotham's
"Issues in Old-Time Music" column will
the
on
my name
probably
keep

list. The first two
columns caused me to reflect on some
attitudes that re-surfaced frequently
enough among traditional musicians
have had contact to cloud
with whom
my own enjoyment of the music on
occasion.

subscription

I

The first is what some might term a
'purist' attitude, but I see it as an elitist
one. Having traveled to the "true source"
or studied with the "true masters," folks
in this frame of mind maintain there is
only one "right way" to interpret a given
tune or genre of tunes. It has always
seemed to me that if this view became

widespread we would eventually arrive
at one homogeneous state throughout all
of what we choose to call old-time
music. All unique styles-- individual
and regional-- would necessarily give
way to the "true sound."
If

anything,

the

threat

of

losing

individual and regional sounds due to

the pressure of pervasive mass culture is
all the more reason to encourage those
who tinker with the tunes. Certainly it is

artist's obligation to pay due respect
to his or her heritage but it is equally an
an

My sincere congratulations on your
magazine. It is about time there is a
national voice for old-time music. Even
here in the far-flung frozen north of
Alaska, there is a small but growing

enthusiasts.
of old-time
Your magazine helps to keep us up here
in Alaska informed of the happenings
in the rest of the country.
I
have one suggestion. As a caller it

population
in

and

Having subscribed at one time or
another to just about every folk and
acoustic music publication that's come
down the road, I have some basis for
judgement in saying the Old-Time Herald
appears to be one of the best-- even
after only two issues. It seems these
tend
to
be
kinds of publications
"fanzines"
stuff for yuppie
or slick

obligation to add to it. I doubt any oldtime musicians really went to see the
etched
music
certainly behave

in

as if

but some
they do when they

stone,

welcome the struggling newcomer,
when they close their minds to exper
imentation, and certainly when they fall
prey to their own narrow-mindedness.
Categorizing music also troubles me.
fail to

�bet the most useful categories for
most musicians are the ones I use: Music
Don't Like. Music I
like, and Music
Like is what I play, buy and/or listen to.
Music I Don't Like generally gets a lot
less attention. What we try to call it
doesn't seem to matter much anyway.
Not long ago Frees tried to stick a "New
Acoustic Music" label on what most
folks now just like to call "Windham
Hill Music" or "Yuppie Elevator Music."
What is truly classic music will be
timeless and must define and establish a
place for itself. The musicians and music
appreciator's job is to build upon that
which is of value and let go of that which
is
not. Clearly this is an individual
aesthetic judgment having nothing to do
with what the music is called.
can say I've
As for music contests,
to give
two
reasons:
in
them
for
played
myself incentive to learn some new
material and to have an audience
somewhat more attentive than that at the
local open-mike night or on the street
corner. But contests for music that began

I'd

I

I

I

life as home-grown entertainment rub
the wrong way. Let's have more Berkeley
I'll happily
Fiddlers Conventions
supply the rutabagas if everyone

by my place afterward
some friendly music and call
some dances.
And, finally, a request for some
articles in the Herald on the instruments
themselves and the people who made
and make them. I'd be most interested in
banjo and dulcimer makers since fretless
banjos and
(and other "primitive")
plucked dulcimers have their origins in

promises to come
to

the

play

southeastern

unique roles

in the

mountains

and

play

music that originated

there.
Jim Marsh

Stockton, CA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FIDDLE
at
RD

1,

&amp;

DANCE

Ashokan

Box 489, West Hurley, NY 12491

914-338-2996

ROOT CAMP 1988!
CLOGGING
CONTRAS
SQUARES
SET DANCE
STEP DANCE
CALLING
SWING JITTERBUG TWO-STEP
FIDDLE BANJO GUITAR MANDOLIN
ACCORDIAN PIPES PIANO SINGING
BAND LABS
STORYTELLING

NORTHERN WEEK
Aug 7-13
Peter Barnes, Mary Cay Brass,

Pete Jung,

David Kaynor, Vandy Kaynor, Benoit
Legault, Normand Legault, Molly Mason,
Lisa Omstein,

Fred Park, Jay Ungar...

CELTIC WEEK

Aug 14-20
Alistair Anderson, Alistair Brown, Jim
Cowdery, Seam as Eagan, Alisdair Fraser,
Eileen Ivers, Billy McComiskey, Hamish
Moore, Mark Simos, Marianne Taylor...

SOUTHERN WEEK

Aug 21-27
Bernstein, Bob Car Lin, Dave Grant,
Ginny Hawker, Horseflies, John Krumm,
Bruce Molsky, Bob Naess, Millie Ortego,
Fred Park, Ruth Pershing, Tracy Schwarz...
Ira

WESTERN

&amp;

SWING

Aug 29-Sept 4
Junior Daugheny, Dixie Doughboys, Matt
Glaser, John Krumm, Molly Mason, George
Marshall, Kathleen Myers, Ann Percival,
Eldon Shamblin. Jav Unear. Pod Wagner...

�ODE TO WILLIE FOREST
by

Dwight Mays

The old banjo picker

Paused for

moment

a

To wipe away a bead of sweat
That had formed across his brow

During "Wild wood Flower,"

Even though a cool breeze
Blew through tall oak trees

Out beyond the swing
On the porch of the homeplace.
You could trace the eighty-three
Seasons of this man's life
In

the lines on his face;

Deep-creviced lines,
Like deep-plowed ground,
Are indications of good seed,
Good soil, and good harvest.
For Willie Forest, they are
Twenty acres and

a

strappin' good banjo.

Lines that knew by heart
"Cotton-Eyed Joe" and "Precious
Mem'ries;"
Lines where cotton was hoed

And picked by hand;
Where field pines were pushed back
To let the sun grow row crops
twelve
To fatten fourteen children
into
adults,

Never to produce an abundance,
But to have enough to endure.
clock divided time

A Regulator

Into even strokes,
As the banjo-notes

Plucked one at a time,
Pulled each chord of music

Through

a

soul-frame of eternal beauty,
a symbol for all time,

And became

Captured also

in leather trunks,
Iron beds, and Prince Albert in the can.

Simple lines, like simple living
Lead to simple faith.
A large-print Bible,
Read two chapters at a time
Each day of the season
Of a man's life
Will sustain all the lines,
And bring him to that "land

Beyond the river that they call the sweet
forever."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�"MUSICAL SCULPTURE":

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Hilary Dirlam and Linda Higginbocham

Kuber

by

Fran

the

Heartbeats

L-

R Tara,

Rose, June, Beverly

�I

lived in Vermont for two-and-a-half
then went to Michigan
and

Beverly Smith, guitai

years,

studied languages in
finished school.
school: Spanish and French, though
was an English major for the first two
years, and I studied a little bit of music. I
think studying foreign languages has
helped my ear. I much prefer learning by
ear now-- old-time music has helped me
develop my ear amazingly. With classical
music you're really chained to the sheet
music unless you memorize it. I'd like to
go back to the piano now and approach it
from the old-time method-- playing by
1

I

The

Heartbeats

appeared

concert

at

last

on

the

the

Saturday night
Rockbridge
(Va.) Festival last September. Everyone was
waiting for them, and they were worth
waiting for.
Their music is spare, focused, and intense
--whether it is a minimalist, cross-tuned
version of the fiddle tune "Laughing Boy," or
Rose's sparse, smooth arrangement of "Red

Rocking Chair," or any other traditional
tune or original song they do. They start and
stop

on

a

dime.

Not

a

note

a

or

word

is

wasted. They are without a doubt one of the
best progressive old-time bands in the country
now.

Originally
viewed, one

by

a

little reluctant

to

be

inter

one the Heartbeats submitted

themselves to questions at the Rockbridge
Festival. Later, in a telephone interview they
clarified their thoughts.

OTH: Tell

me something about your
musical background.
RS: I took classical piano for 12 years;
somewhere in there I studied clarinet for

years

and

taught

myself guitar.

There were about five banjo players in
in
Ann Arbor,
dorm
my
college
Michigan. I didn't know the difference
between bluegrass and old-time music
I
just found someone to teach me banjo,
and it turned out to be old-time music.
In 1976 to '77 I started going to a coffee
house and heard the Highwoods Stringband and the Corklickers. I lived real
close to Remus, Michigan, and started
going to the Wheatlands Festival there.
In 1980 I went out to Colorado to do
solar energy work and joined the How
Ya Been String Band. We traveled all
over the state playing dances; there were
only a few of us who played old-time
music in Colorado. I came east in 1982
and I've been here ever since. That fall
when I came back, I picked apples at
Double Four Orchard in Vermont. We
had an all-woman crew plusjumahl, who
could
had convinced to come up so
have someone to play tunes with. A
fiddler, Bob Naess, lived 20 minutes
down the road; he brought candy to us in
our trees, and every night we played
music. That fall I started playing guitar
with Bob and Jumahl in the OK Bayou
Cajun Dance Band.
I

OTH:

What was it like when the
Heartbeats first got together?
RS: All of a sudden here we were,
plopped in a room together playing this
great music. It was a magic sound. In fact,
it worked so well that there was all this
outside pressure on us to play. We
started winning contests.... it seemed so
premature. We didn't have a natural

development

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

as

We

band.

a

came

together and were good right away, and

everybody had high expectations right
off the bat.
did

have

talked

Rose Sinclair, banjo and accordian

three

ear.

it all

was kind of scary, and we
some rocky times, but we
It

out.

OTH: What's

it

I

that trust just to be able to try
things. I've never sung before, and I'm
singing with the Heartbeats. It's great!
It's really a great group to work with.
We laugh a lot. Playing with the
need

Heartbeats, music has gone a step up
artistically for me. We're not doing
music off records, we're building music
together. It's really exciting to have

something that's yours.

OTH: Where
RS:
on

a

do you see

it

going?

We're beginning to use amplifiers
couple of songs-- we're not using

effects--

we just want

a

stronger sound.

We do have a commitment to traditional
instrumentation, but we're experiment

ing. I'd like to see us travel more. I'd like
us to put out a good tape or album at

some point, though
premature now.

it

OTH: Can you sum

might be

a

little

up what you get out
of being in the Heartbeats?
RS: Through the Heartbeats, I can have
it all.
can express my love for old-time
music, as well as who I am in the '80s,
I

through original music.

me a little about your life
before the Heartbeats.
BS: grew up in Menlo Park, California.
My dad had played classical music, and
I

he taught me to play the flute when
in the fifth grade.
We used to

I

was

sing
family

harmonies when we'd go on
outings. I don't even remember the
songs-- they were probably pretty
corny. I was born in 1950, and when
they

had

the

folk

revival

of the early

'60s, my sister got a guitar and started
taking lessons from Jerry Garcia, who
was playing bluegrass music back then.
She took lessons along with a friend, and

encouraged them

Jerry

to

do

old-time

He told them
bluegrass harmonies.
about this group called Kathy (Larisch)
and Carol (McComb). They did Carter
Family songs along with some more
modern stuff.

My father wouldn't let me get

because he thought I'd be

in

a

guitar

competition

with my sister. So I'd find her tablature
and learn it. I liked the Kathy and Carol
album so much-- looked on the back
and discovered the Carter Family that
was playing Carter Family songs
way.
when I was in the eighth grade. I saved up
I

I

my money and got an autoharp and
then, finally, a guitar. I played with my
thumb and finger like Maybelle Carter
did. Back then
didn't know anyone else
who played old-time music. didn't even
know what it was.
When I got out of high school,
moved to the mountains of Oregon.
met a guy, Tom, who played jews harp,
and he was part of an old-time music
scene in Fresno that eventually spread to
Seattle. He showed me how to flat-pick
the guitar, and I met other people who
played old-time music. But the first oldtime band I saw live was when I went
back
to
California. It was Dr.
all

like now?

think we're doing well now. We're
developing a sound. We had the fiddle
tunes down, but we wanted to do songs.
I've never been in a band before where
we composed together. It's like building
a musical sculpture. We've developed a
great amount of trust in the band. You
RS:

OTH: Tell

I

I

I

I

Humbead's New Tranquility String
Band and Medicine Show. I felt like this
was what I'd been looking for-- this was
it!

ended up moving near Vancouver,
the man I was living with, Ken
Hatch, played the fiddle and taught me
how to play the banjo. We busked in
Vancouver. I remember saving up to get
a
cassette tape recorder; it was 14
dollars.
I lived
in Canada for a couple of years,
where I began squeaking away on the
fiddle. Next, I moved to Texas for a year,
then back to California to start music
school playing flute. I forgot about old
time music. For one thing, I wasn't
hearing any. I started playing in a band
that did light country rock, swing, and
I

and

�some bluegrass.

in it for eight
I stayed
never finished music school
because the band toured. I played flute,
guitar,
banjo, fiddle, maracas, sand
blocks, and sang. In the band, learned a
lot about arranging music, and working
with a band, but I never put enough time
in on any one instrument or type of
music. At the same time, as a student, I
was
always practicing,
practicing,
practicing the flute. Aside from

years.

I

I

technically,

I

couldn't play the flute

at all

it
only knew how to practice
was this never-ending thing. Music is out
there somewhere, and some day you'll

because

I

get to play it.
I
traveled to India one year. Getting
away from the practice room made me
ask myself what I had been doing. When
I
came back, I did some time in the
Balkan music scene. I ended up going to
Port Townsend (an old-time music
ed.) and I heard Tony
teaching camp
Goldenberg play the fiddle. I said,

sounds so bad
but it's so good." All the stuff I'd been
studying in school didn't make sense
"What's that?

love

I

it, it

with that, but it was what I liked. I stayed
up all night and just played tunes, tunes I
didn't even know, playing the fiddle. I
came away from that festival feeling like I
not
wanted to play music with people

just practice for a concert. Next year I
went back and Tony Goldenberg told me
should go to the East Coast. I ended up
I

'82. Eventually

going there

in

back

and

east

bought a
Germantown, Pennsylvania.

I

moved

house

in

had no idea what I was going to do for
a living. I had all but stopped playing the
fiddle; there were so many people who
I

played

incredibly

well,

it

encouraged and frustrated me.

I

couldn't.

didn't

I

do

anything

on the

guitar except boom-chuck boom-chuck,
and Tara wanted Rose to play some
accordian, but she had only played

Cajun stuff.

was really challenging,

It

but

worked, and that spurred us
on. To me, and probably to everybody,
eventually

it

that's been the exciting thing lately: the
songs. We take ourselves for granted
with the tunes.

OTH: What

are you concentrating on
now?
BS: At this point I'm mostly interested
in getting the songs better and learning
new ones. I really am learning new stuff
on the guitar. I only want to play the
music I like and that I think I can play
well. I've had to let go of a lot of musicial
interests to do it, but finally I am getting
the guitar to sound exactly like I want.

Tara Nevins, fiddle

OTH: And what
ground been like?

has your musical

TN:
grew up
Orangeburg, about

in

I

a

a

town

back
called

half-hour north of

New York City. I started playing violin
when I was in the fifth grade. In the
decided that playing the
eighth grade,
violin was extremely uncool. My father
disagreed. I continued the violin. My
parents are both musical, and are great
dancers. My mother loves the old bigband sound. I listened to the Beatles,
Monkees, and the Mamas and the Papas.
Everything on the AM station. I taught
myself guitar and sang out of their songI

books.
When

I

was

18

I

went to Potsdam,

N.Y., to study at the Crane School of
Music. I first heard old-time music there,
at the Wild Oat Bar, by a band called the
St. Regis River Valley String Band. I
thought it was really cool because the
people were cool, too not just the
music. I was seeing these people living
out on a farm, with pigs and cows, and
they were my age, but they weren't really
farmers. They played a Highwoods
record for me,
and
that was the
of the end of life

beginning

known

as

I

had

it.

didn't start playing
22 because I was
on
concentrating
my classical studies,
having a disadvantage in never having
taken private lessons. So when I got to
college I had a lot of catching up to do,
practicing scales and so on. I didn't feel
like I could play the fiddle at the same
time, so I played the mandolin instead.
received a music ed degree with a
concentration in violin, but I wasn't a
fanatic classical player. I can't say that
classical music never moved me, it's just
that while the technique was staring you
in the face, it was blocking the view. I
dropped violin like a hot potato and
began playing the fiddle.
My last semester in college I started
playing with St. Regis, and we traveled
for two years as a full-time band. We
recorded an album, Backroad Breakdown,
on Adirondack Records. Then in 1980 I
met the Bubba George String Band. They
played the hottest, funkiest, sexiest oldtime music I'd ever heard. I just packed
my bags and moved to Ithaca, their home
town.
I

the

was

1

9

fiddle

then, but
till

I

I

was

I

both

had left

my band, and I had left classical music. It
like stopping one life and starting

was

another.

OTH:

the
And then you joined
how
all
did
Heartbeats;
you
get together?
BS: I had played with Rose a lot. Rose
and J une and T ara liked playing together.
Rose and June and I knew that we liked
to play together. They were thinking,
"This is really working, let's get Beverly
and try a dance like that." The first time

together, it was like, "Hey,
really like your fiddle playing, hey,
."
really like your banjo playing.
OTH: What happened then?
we played

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gillespie

concerts

but they wanted more than tunes. We
felt as though we didn't want to sing only
old-time songs. We don't like the way
they sound when we sing them. June and
Tara both write. Tara writes a lot, so she
just picked out some songs she thought
we might be able to do. At first we

Gail

BS: People wanted us to do

I

At the Rockbridge

Festival 1987

�Benton

Flippen,

Ralph

Bruce

Blizard,

Molsky, and Kenny Baker.
OTH: Is an album in the making?
TN: People want the Heartbeats to make

a record of dance tunes,
but I think, no.
An album is like a painting, and that is
not the exact picture we have in mind.

June Drucker, bass
OTH:

as

Gillespie

with everyone else, we're

Gail

Just

interested in your musical life before the
Heartbeats.
JD: I started playing violin in the third
grade. I had a horrible music teacher, and
by all rights it should have ended my
music career then. I don't think music is
anything
really wanted to do as a kid. I
started playing guitar in junior high
school, and
played by myself for 10
years; I don't think I ever thought about
with
else.
It
was
playing
anyone

something

I

I

Rockbridge

OTH: How about

the Heartbeats,

how

does that work?
TN: The Heartbeats, from the very first
time we played, had a certain chemistry.
I can't
explain it. I have no idea what it's
all about. I've known June for years, but
the first time we played together, I didn't

know Beverly and hardly knew Rose.
We have a lot of good times and laughs
when we get together. Beverly and Rose

live in Philly, and June lives an hour away
in Homeville. Since this past
February,
I've been living half out of Homeville
and half out of Rose's. But I'm about to
make a move to New York City. It's
about a two-hour ride from New York to

Philly, and my life style is flexible
enough so I can go there. We all have the
freedom to come and go. None of us are
married. Beverly and Rose's homes are
the closest things that any of us has to
children.
OTH: How do you see your songs fitting

with the band?
TN: We made a transition from being a
tune band six or seven months after we
in

1987

come off, the songs we do need a power
that acoustic instruments alone can't
supply. We've tried amps on some of the
songs, but it's going to take a while.
OTH: Tell me something more about
the Heartbeats' music.

TN: For years my goal has been to be in a
semi-acoustic band like this: when you
hear

it,

it's

listenable

to

original material, and it's
more than an old-time

a

fiddler?

OTH: What fiddlers have influenced
TN:

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

or 18.

I

TN: I'm always learning. There's

a

ton

up about the fiddle all the
Sometimes you learn the most

I'm picking

time.

profoundly subtle things. Half the time
don't realize I'm learning something

until I've learned
learn bv osmosis.

it

already.

I

think

I

I

you?

my

I'd say the two major influences on
fiddling are Jeb Puryear (of Bubba

George

Correctone

ed.) and John Specker
String

Band

ed.).

(of the
Also

myself for fun, and

it

liked

pretty well, but

it

I

liked

went on a trip
across country with some friends in the
early '70s and went to some festivals.
met a guy in New York City who played
old-time banjo, and zoom
on my way!
There was a really happening scene in
I

I

Philly at the time, and I came in as the
new nerd. I was living in Maine, and I'd

really

as

me,
the

along with the Talking Heads and
Neville Brothers. Lyrically and
melodically, some of my songs fit the
pop genre but the instrumentation and
the players make it different. To really

7

OTH: What about you

started. We decided to work on songs,
and since December that's what we've
been doing. I knew Rose played Cajun
accordian, and I wanted to try it on my
songs. I write some commercialsounding songs, and do listen to some
contemporary music. Bob Marley and
Jimmy Cliff have been a big influence on
I

1

something

cliff.

did by

old-time music better.

audience, but you can see and hear the
roots. Stretch the traditional shape, but
keep it grounded. You have to play how
you feel. It may not be enough for us to
play old-time tunes alone, but I love that
I love
playing tunes. I want to do both.
I have
an electric violin and play some
electric music, but
would never be
satisfied if that's all I did. That's one
reason I love zydeco. It's rhythm and
blues, but it's got this accordian in it, and
that is one thing that makes it sound
funky and root-tied; and when music
sounds like that, it just sends me off a
I

I

wasn't till I started playing old-time
music that the idea of playing with other
people occurred to me. None of my
family plays music, although they have
been supportive of me being a musician.
I
heard bluegrass music and started
playing banjo around 1970, when I was

come

down and play all these New
England tunes that everyone in Philly

hated. You kind of had to beat your way
into the scene there.
In the Philly music scene there was
really no one around who played bass, so
I just ended
up doing it, and you can get a
lot of work as a bass player. I work on it.

Sometimes
music

is

it's

a

but when the
it's great. It's
the bass comes in and
drag,

really happening,

really important;
its solid thing.

does

fiddle

I

don't think of it as
I've
played

unimportant.

little bit on and off, but I never
got serious about it. It was just
something to do for fun, and I ended up

writing

a

a

couple of tunes.

The first band I played with was the
Jubilo String Band. I played with them
for a long time around the PhillyBaltimore area. Then everybody started
getting different interests. I played in the
Barn Burners for a few years, and then

got in a swing band; that was fun. But
got tired of playing swing in bars and
clubs. I felt like
couldn't go into
I

another scummy bar playing for drunks,
(Continued, on Pane 2d)

I

�17th ANNUAL

Blue Grass

Old Time

&amp;

FIDDLERS
CONVENTION
ALWAYS HELD THE FIRST WEEK END
WILL

FRItSAT.,

Startina Fri.

at

BE

IN

JUNE

HELD

JUNE

3-4,1988

Sat. at 9:30 A.M.

7:00 P.M.

VETERANS MEMORIAL PARK
West Lebanon St.
ADMISSION: Fri. $4, Sat

.$5,

Sponsored

Two Days $8,

by The

Contestant's ticket $10, Children under

AMERICAN
REGISTER

MRS.

JACK

E.

NOTE: Contestants will use only songs and instruments

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

MT. AIRY,
LEGION

8

N. C.
FREE witn Paid Aihiii

and V.F.W.

WITH:

319 W. OAKDALE STREET, MOUNT AIRY, NC 27030
from the public domain and authentic folk or mountain music field. No copyrighted music will be permitted.

JONES,

�ROBERT "BUD" GARRETT

learned from his older brother and
relatives and neighbors of the
Hill Community.
historic
Free
Playing the acoustic and electric
guitar, Bud started singing profes
sionally in 1943 in local dance halls in
other

the
Cumberland area of
upper
Tennessee. He has had a number of

records out on a variety of labels,
the Exello
with
label,
including
recordings of blues songs such as
"Quit My Drinkin" and "Do
Remember." He also adapted wellloved tunes such as "Old Joe Clark"
to his own blues and ragtime style.
Garrett was a leader in the Free Hill
Community. He owned a business
there, selling new and used
merchandise as well as repairing cars,
trucks, and small equipment. He
drove a school bus for many years and
assisted with the Senior Citizens
Center. The Free Hill Community
was founded before the end of the
Civil War by freed black slaves to
whom the land had been deeded. It is
in the upper
a mountain community
Cumberland Plateau, and its residents
are primarily the descendants of the

original founders.
Born

1916,

28,

January

Bud

Peggy

Wilkerson,

courtesy

Southern

Folk

Cultural

Revival

Project

Garrett was the son of John Tom
Garrett, a tobacco farmer, and his

1977

wife Adeline Hamilton Garrett. From
Bud learned to make
his father
marbles. "He would take a piece of
flint to the field with him every day.
He would file a little of it away every
day until he got it round. Then he
would put it in a rounded out form
made of sandstone and put it in a
creek where the water would keep
marble. The whole
the
turning
process might take a year and a half,
but he would come up with a smooth,
round marble. On the other hand a
flood might come and he would have
to start over."
Bud Garrett, however, came up
with the idea for a marble machine
that would grind out the marbles in
just a few minutes. This is the same
machine that he exhibited at the

Grassroots Days. He
marble yard in Celina similar
at the Standing Stone State
Park between Livingston and Celina,
Tennessee
started
to one

Bluesman Robert "Bud" Garrett,
71, died of a massive heart attack
Free Hill, Tennessee, near Celina,
November 24, 1987, while playing
marbles in the Bud Garrett Marble
Yard. He was one of the great

in

old-time country blues
singers, having performed all over the
South in clubs, bars, colleges, and
community centers. He performed
Tennessee

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with the Southern Grassroots Music
Tour and the Tennessee Grassroots

Nashville. He also performed
Days
at the
1982 World's Fair and the
Smithsonian Folklife Festival as well
as the Tennessee State Parks Folklife
Festivals, the Fisk Folklife Festival,
in

and others.

Garrett's
country

blues

unique
singing

mountainstyle

was

a

Tennessee,

to

play

a

game

called

Rollev Hole.
Rolley Hole was played in the days
before the Civil War in Celina. The
yard is 40 x 20 feet and there are three
tiny holes just big enough to hold a
marble placed at equal distances on
the yard. The game is played with
(Continued

on

Page 22)

�The old originals are dying off. Each

year there are fewer musicians of what
we regard as the "golden age" of old-time

music, the artists of the 1920s and '30s.
The golden age itself, of course, is partly
myth; it was not so much a historical era
as a single moment in the continuous
development of country music, frozen in
time for us by the phonograph record.
Still, it was a great time, a time of
tremendous ferment and change, a time
of great musical diversity, and a time of
some of the great classic performances
by the greatest artists. The generation
that brought traditional music and the
20th century together is disappearing
fast, and one of its major figures, Fields
Ward, is one of our recent losses.
Fields Mac Ward was born on January
23, 1911, on Buck Mountain, just west
of Independence, in Grayson County,
Virginia. One of five children of Davy
Crockett and Perlina ("Linie") Ward, he
was raised in an intensely musical house
hold. The small farms of the Blue Ridge
Mountains were almost completely self-

sufficient
century:

the early years of this
crops were raised for home
in

consumption,

tools

were

often

Ward

Mullin

hammered out at a small home forge,
clothing was sewn from homespun
material. Even the amusements were
homemade. Especially on long winter
evenings, the family would entertain
themselves with Crockett's fiddle tunes

courtesy

Frances

and Linie's ballads, and as the children
grew they took up the music themselves,
Sampson becoming an excellent banjo

player, Curren learning autoharp, and
Verna Mae and Kate following their

mother

as

singers.

Fields'

earliest

musical memories were of his mother's
singing; in later years he remembered
crying over the old grey goose a-dying,
and he remained partial to what he wryly
called "tear-jerkers" the rest of his life.
But the mountain

homeland of this

traditional culture was not as isolated as
some of the most romantic folklorists
imagined. Education, at least to the
elementary level, was widely available,
and

factory-made

goods,

including

musical instruments, were common.
Traditional musicians, with their typical
curiosity and inventiveness, were experi
menting with new instruments, styles,
and sounds. By the time Fields was born,

the banjo had been around for half a
century, the guitar was becoming fairly

common,

and
the
had
autoharp
appeared here and there. All the "oldtime" instruments but the fiddle were
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

WARD

FIELDS
1911by

1987
John Coffey

"You can stomp them flowers all around my grave,
They'll rise and bloom again."

Fields Ward, "Riley and Spencer"

�fairly new then; older musicians
could easily remember the first appear
still

ance of the banjo in the mountains.
With the new century, the steady
trickle of outside influences was to
become a flood. In Galax, at the eastern
end of Grayson County, the railroad had
arrived in 1904; and not long after
World War I there were several
furniture factories, a small but sub
stantial business section, and even a
modest airport. It was to this mountain
boom town that the Wards moved in

1921.
Settling in the community of Ballard's
Branch to the west of town, Crockett
soon found work as a carpenter and the
family easily integrated itself into the
new community. Clarence Wroten, a
distant cousin, remembers Fields as a 10year-old schoolboy at Oldtown, already
something of a natural performer with a
taste for deadpan humor that was to last
his whole life. The Wrotens also had the
first phonograph in the area, and Fields
became a frequent guest and avid listener
just as country music was first appearing

on records.
It was during these years that Fields
met the musician who was to influence
him more than any other. Alec "Eck"
Dunford was a somewhat mysterious
figure in the community. His family was

unknown

around

Galax (though
Dunfords are numerous in neighboring
Wythe County), and he never spoke of
his origins. He disclaimed any formal
education, but was well-read and fond of
quoting Shakespeare and Burns. Unlike
the other musicians of the community,
he

ditches. They spent a week in Richmond
in zero degree weather, recording under
trying circumstances. Gennett was a
subsidiary of the Starr Piano Company,
and the recording studios were in the
main building together with the piano
factory and an associated company that
vacuum brakes. Years
manufactured
later Stoneman remembered having to
tune, practice, and record everything in
the odd intervals when the machinery
and the piano tuners fell silent. As the
Fields
Grayson County Railsplitters,
Eck
guitar), Samp (banjo),
(vocal,

loose aggregation of local players he used
over the next several years. In 1927, the
Wards joined the procession of Grayson
County musicians into the recording
studios. Fields, then 16 years old, was
the
lead singer
and guitarist,
with
Crockett playing fiddle, and Fields'

brothers
Sampson ("Samp") and
Curren on banjo and autoharp respect
ively. The performances really did not do
them justice; everyone was nervous and
played too fast, and the music lacked the
smooth flow and interplay that was
typical of their best. Nonetheless, the
Okeh Company released two of the
songs almost immediately and another
two about a vear later.
The family had begun to appear at
community events around Galax, and
Fields, as the lead singer, was very much
in the spotlight. Always
uneasy as a
with Crockett
performer,
especially
around, he developed the habit of
steadying his nerves with a shot of
whiskey before showtime, and it was by
only the narrowest of margins that he
escaped the fate of so many country
musicians, who destroyed their careers
with the traditional
and themselves
stage-fright cure.
In the spring of 1929, Fields and Samp
joined the Stoneman entourage on one
of

their

periodic trips

to

(fiddle),

proprietary
feeling about the
was especially
strong toward
certain songs he regarded as his own
His

music

compositions. Fields said

developed,

Richmond,

he

began

working

combinations of traditional and original

verses into compositions with an overall
story and sense. He claimed authorship
of "Deadheads and Suckers," which was
mainlv a reworkinp of a traditional sonp.
This must have been one of his earliest,

since he had recorded it at the Okeh
session when he was 16. Later songs of
his, like "Riley and Spencer," which he

developed from one or two verses he had
heard, show a more extensively
developed and original style, although
elements of traditional material were
always evident in both words and music.
Like many similar towns in the 1920s,
Galax had developed an active semi-

professional music scene. There was

a

core group of musicians in a shifting
series of bands playing at dances, auction
school breakings and movie
sales,
houses. None of the jobs paid much, and
most of the musicians,
except for

courtesy

Frances

Ward

Mullin

Stoneman, had to keep regular jobs at
the furniture
factories or elsewhere

began in 1924,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

he always had

trouble remembering tunes unless he
could sing them, and he had begun
making up words to dance tunes simply
to aid his memory. As his writing skills

become proficient on guitar

as had Henry Whitter,
within a few years Stoneman had
recruited Eck Dunford as part of the

(harmonica,

40 vears.

Indiana to record for the Gennett
Record Company. Stoneman, somewhat
erratic behind the wheel according to
Fields, did most of the driving, with a
few unscheduled
stops in roadside

including a familiarity with open
tunings and old pieces like "Spanish
Fandango." He was a frequent, and
memorably eccentric, guest at the Ward
home; and he and Crockett became
locally famous for their twin fiddling.
Fields, who had always found it difficult
to learn music from his father, soon
became a pupil of "Uncle Eck," learning
both a solid backup style guitar and a
number of the fingerpicked solo pieces.
1924, when Fields was 13,
By
Columbia had issued its first recordings
of Riley Puckett, whose singing and
revoluntionary guitar playing were to be
the other great influence on Fields' own
style. He spent hours learning Puckett's
songs and unique guitar bass runs, subtly
making them his own as he absorbed
them. Neighbors of his were beginning
to record
as
well: Ernest Stoneman
and

Stoneman

recorded 15 sides, which
Fields later described as "the best music
we ever recorded." For some reason the
company decided not to release any of
the sides, and a dispute ensued at the end
of which Fields took home test pressings
of the entire session, and refused to deal
with another record company for almost

could read music, and he was one of

the first to

and

autoharp)

Crockett and Linie

in

the

1950s

around town to make a steady
at the movie house was free
and many of the survivors of
remain somewhat burned out

living. Pay

admission,

those days
on movies
after their years of providing music for
the same silent films over and over again.
Fields was playing with his own family
then, and on and off with the Buck
Mountain Band, led by his uncle Wade

�In March 1931, at the age of 20, Fields
Their
Todd.
Elsie
Naomi
married
four
the
to
over
years
family grew
children, and eventually nine grand

reminiscences of the musicians who
were there suggest a sort of old-timey
Woodstock
huge and unexpected
crowds of musicians,
listeners, and
outdoor camping under
hangers-on;

children

primitive

and

and even,

to top

Ward.

and eight

the Wards' family doctor, began playing

Crockett, Samp,

autoharp with Fields,
and

and

Eck,

who

Davis

was apparently
the Bogtrotters

it

them

named

in

often-swampy road to
recognition
Ballard's Branch. Around this time
of the

Walter Alderman joined the group on
bass. When the Galax Moose Lodge

world-famous

their

began

series

of

fiddlers conventions in April of 1935,
the Bogtrotters swept the field, winning
first

in

place

(Fields),
storytelling
was another convention
band,

guitar

and

(Alderman),

singing
(Eck). There
that

fall;

Fields

competition
Sam"),

and

again
a

won
(with

the

guitar
"One-Eyed

square-dance team under

it

courtly
anyway,
insisted
morning

was the best he had ever tasted.
time
the weary pickers straggled
the
By
home, Samp had decided the life of a
musician was not for him, and never
played in public again. W ade became the

group's sometime banjo player then, as
did W. E. ("Doc") Dalton and Marvin
Evans.

1937, Fields' music began to reach
northern, urban audience of folkmusic enthusiasts. Alan Lomax, then
In

the

collecting for the Library of Congress,
arrived

the
fiddlers
Galax
for
that October, and stayed
more days recording the local
in

convention
several
musicians.

Greatly flattered

at

taining.
They

ill

they had to

a

feeling.
By

1942,

decided

this kind

panied ballads in the library's collection.
Between 1937 and 1942 the Bogtrotters,
and various other combinations of the

Bogtrotters,

local favorites,

in fact,

morning show for the eastern part
of the country and an afternoon show
for the West Coast. The band played,
Fields sang, Eck told stories, and Wade
played his inimitable "Fox Chase" on
banjo. Among the listeners who were
impressed was John Lair, who had left
WLS in Chicago two years earlier to
start the Renfro Valley Barn Dance, by
then second only to the Grand Ole Opry
as a clear-channel country music broad
cast. Lair offered Fields a contract, but
made it clear he was interested only in a
solo singer-guitarist, expecting Fields to
"get rid of the old fellows" he was playing
with. This Fields indignantly refused to
and
once again the world of
do;
commercial country music went on
without him, once again with a residue of
do

fashion, drew up his water
and returned to camp. Fields
years later that the coffee that

also attended the notorious
Whitetop Folk Festival that year. The

the

but

the

heard nationwide

to fetch the
water for the morning coffee. Finding a
group of women washing their feet in the
stream, Eck excused himself in his usual

encampment appointed Eck

were voted Most Enter

Jenkins'

second.

Frank
band contest,
rapidly becoming

in

over

Eleanor Roosevelt.
the story of the morning the Bogtrotters'

of recognition the Bogtrotters recorded
their best and most original material,
while Linie contributed what are still
considered some of the finest unaccom

direction

came
group won

his

Davis traveled to Roanoke to broadcast
WDBJ for the CBS American
School of the Air. This program,
arranged and emceed by Lomax, was

conditions;

off, a visit from
Fields loved to tell
all

Crockett

and

Eck

had

they were too old to lead the

lives of professional

musicians, and the
Fields did not

Bogtrotters disbanded.

place at the fiddlers convention that
year, though his daughter Frances, and
Crockett took second and third in the

singing competition.

Fields was playing

here and there with Ray Fortner,

Cockerham,

Herbert

Fred

Higgins, and
contemporaries.

several other of his
There was a fairly regular square dance at
the American Legion Hall, with over a
hundred dancers typically packed into
the smallish room. Fields and Naomi
recalled years later the time someone
gave him a bottle of peach nectar at the
He had already
fiddlers convention.
fortified himself for the guitar
competition, and the last thing he

remembered

was

his

first

sip

of the

time he got on stage, he
was weaving back and forth around the
footlights, while Naomi sat in the front
row, anxiously lunging for him each time
he was about to fall into the audience.
Neither of them was sure if he won that
nectar.

innocent. One day

Frances

year.

courtesy

The Bogtrotters

in

1940:

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dr. Davis,

Eck, Crockett,

Fields,

Wade

By the

Mullin

a

family; by this time the string bands were
not home-based as they had been a
was
Fields
and
before,
generation
spending more and more of his time with
harda
hard-drinking,
hard-playing,
living set of musicians. By 1934, the
family band had extended somewhat.
Dr. W. P. Davis, a local chiropracter and

inadequate

at

Ward

The life of

great-grandchildren.

musician was not easy on his

for Lomax both in
the Library of Congress in
Washington, D.C. The high point of this
relationship came on January 9, 1940,
when Fields, Crockett, Wade, Eck, and

recorded

Wards,

Galax and

Those

were

wild times, if curiously
he and several friends

went across the state line to visit their
favorite bootlegger. After sampling his
all
decided
to
wares
awhile,
they
serenade someone's girlfriend nearby.
The young lady's father, not charmed by
the sight of two drunken musicians on

�doorstep, chased them
ever the comedian, cast
clothesline in the yard as
the
pasture nearby,

his

After

inspiration.

instructions, the boys

all
an

off. Fields,
eye on the

he left, then at

and

had

all

an

his

following

took cover to

watch the old man chasing across the
field after four sheep attired in his best
long red underwear.
During the years of World War II, the
area around
Baltimore,
Maryland,
attracted a huge number of families from
southwestern Virginia. The steel mills
and shipyards there were the main focus
of the migration; sections of south and
Baltimore
east
became, in effect,
immigrant communities where the

minority were Scots-Irish
mountaineers whose families had been
in America for two centuries and more.

ethnic

But they were just as new to the city as
any of the more recent immigrants, and

like them they often sent one or two
pioneers ahead to scout the territory,
obtain jobs, save some money, and bring
the rest of the family along later, some
times a few at a time. Some relatives,

friends, and neighbors stuck closely
together, while others scattered, not to
meet again for years. Many of these
settlers, uncomfortable with city life,
invested their savings in land to the
north and east of Baltimore, where they
could enjoy the combined advantages of
country living and a booming postwar
economy. Fields never lived in the city
itself, but in 1947 he moved to Harford
to manage a dairy
Over the next several years, he
worked at several jobs, eventually be
coming a painter, the trade he was to

County, Maryland,
farm.

follow the rest of his life.
Sometime around 1953 he discovered
that his boyhood friend and fellow
musician Clarence Wroten had also
moved north, settling in Kingsville, in

Baltimore

neighboring

County.

daughter Betsy remembers
sitting at Fields' feet by the hour as a
young girl, begging him to sing "Riley
and Spencer" over and over. But aside
from playing and singing at home, he was
doing very little musically. What he was
doing was seriously coming to grips with
his drinking problem. After two trips to
a rehabilitation center and the beginning

Clarence's

of

a

deep and lifelong involvement with

Alcoholics

Anonymous,

he

finally

habit. His
years of work for A. A. are not well
known among his musical audience; but

succeeded

the

in

countless

defeating

recovering alcoholics

helped knew him only

counselor,

the

and

had

he

their friend and
little idea of his
as

He had a
accomplishments.
musicians
and
for
concern
young
special

musical

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�tried to encourage them to learn from

the mistakes he had made. Only because
he was so forthright
about his own
alcoholism has it been mentioned here.

The stories about his drinking are those
he told himself
not without wry
humor, but making a serious point as
well.
In the early '60s, Fields
discovered
that Alan Lomax had published several
of his songs, together with a number
obtained from his parents, with adapt

ations and arrangements copyrighted by
Lomax and by Ruth Crawford Seeger
all of this without his knowledge. This
cultural strip mining seems to have been
done more or less in innocence; the
collectors
the
music as
regarded
that is to say, as public
"traditional"
domain. Fields, to say the least, did not
see matters that way; his songs and those
of his
family were their personal
creations and their personal property.
As far

as he

was

concerned,

he had been

with Wade, and five years later made his

community, and even there his style was
so unique as to be almost impossible to

Rounder. He remained
highly
suspicious and distrustful of
record companies, often accusing them
last record

for

imitate. The best recordings, made in his
the 1929 Gennett sides and the
prime
of Congress
Library
pieces by the
were not available to the
Bogtrotters
general public until he arranged for their
release in the 1960s. His greatness was
rather a matter of his music itself. He had
a deep emotional involvement
in what he

of tampering with his music and cheating
him on royalties.
At that time he was a much more

seasoned
than

and

comfortable

performer
younger years, but had begun
played fiddle for him frequently
the '70s, and by then he had

in his

to tire.

1

everything had
Whether it was an
autobiographical blues-ballad like
sang; as he said, he "put

during
decided to make his concerts as easy as
possible on himself
especially if he
was not sure of his audience. "We'll just
give them a little 'Sally Ann,'" he would
say to me before the show, meaning that
we would stick to the old standards and
not get involved with his more personal
material. By the time he had finished his
opening number (usually "JesseJames"),

into

"Riley

and

he

I

song."

and

Spencer"

or

partly

a

nonsensical dance piece like "Fortune,"
he sang it with an

intensity of feeling that
brought tears to listeners' eyes. His
voice, though in the bass range, had a
haunting, plaintive quality usually only
heard from tenor singers. He could bend
notes almost to the breaking point, but
never lost control or lapsed into put-on
dramatics. His guitar style matched his
singing perfectly, following his vocal line
through oddly compressed and
expanded meters and bent notes with a
syncopated thumb and index-finger
picking pattern. His influence on those
who heard him was manifested in their
realization of what heights of artistry
old-time music could achieve. His old
friend Clarence Wroten put it best: "I've
heard a many of a good musicianer, but
Fields Ward was one of a kind."

the audience was in the palm of his hand,
and by the end of the show he had once
again given them all he had. His health by
this time was in serious decline. His

enraged at the
thought that others were (as he
supposed) getting rich off the music that
had earned him so little. His relations
with the entrepreneurs of the music
business had never been exactly cordial,
and
from this time on fluctuated
robbed,

a

was

between
and open
quiet distrust
Matters were not greatly
hostility.
improved when, after one of his visits to

Virginia, part of a show he and Wade did
the Parsons
Auction Company
for
turned up on a Folkways record, again

without payment
the same time,

radio

that

a

or

permission. About

hit song appeared on the

sounded

suspiciously

like

Frances

Ward

Mullin

"Deadheads and Suckers," followed by
several others that sounded equally
familiar. Betsy Wroten sat him down
and explained some of the basics of

courtesy

copyright law to him, and he began to
copyright some of the material he had
been giving away since 1927. Also at her
he
ordered the Ward
material in the Library of Congress

suggestion,

Fields and Wade around

1968

all but immediate family.
Crockett died around that time at the

closed to

leaving Fields his "ballet box"
full of his and Linie's handwritten copies
of the songs they had known all their
lives. This became one of Fields' most
treasured posessions and the source of
many of the songs he sang in his later
this
time he had been
years.
By
"discovered" by a younger generation of
old-time music enthusiasts and began
performing at colleges and folk festivals.
The masterpieces of his 1929 Gennett
recording session were finally issued on
age of 94,

the

Historical

pressings
years.

In

using the test
kept for almost 40
1968 he recorded for Biograph
he

label,

had

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Author's note:
am deeply indebted to
Mrs.
Fields' daughter,
Frances
Ward
Mullin, for extensive information and
numerous photographs from the family
collection. Clarence Wroten shared many of
his recollections of Fields and of the Galax
music scene of years past, and made me
aware of published histories of the town and
of the fiddlers convention that provided
valuable background information.
would
I

strength

was

sapped

by

years

of

hypertension, diabetes, and a bleeding
His emphysema was beginning to

ulcer.

interfere with his singing, and his playing
was

noticeably slowed

by his

worsening

arthritis. His performances became less
frequent, and by the very early '80s he
had stopped playing altogether. He spent
his last few years at his home in Bel Air,
Maryland, dying there on October 26,
1987.
Fields W ard was not a historical figure
in
old-time music as the term is
ordinarily understood. He had very little
influence on musicians outside his own

I

especially like to thank my wife, Betsy
Wroten Coffey, for sharing her favorite
Fields stories, reading and correcting this
and not least for having
manuscript,
afforded me the privilege of knowing Fields
Ward.

�FIELDS WARD
You could sing the sun to sleep
Or make the moon cry

When

I

By

a child
your feet.

sat as

You sang for me

In a voice shaped by the wrinkles
Your soul had earned teaching my ears
To be eyes
That I might see how life felt.

Your music, like a great train, carried me
Through rich, ripened notes
Growing like endless acres of wheat,
Gold-green, warmed by the sun.
You took me to meet "Jesse James,"
Held my hand as we watched him

Die, and allowed me to share
The grief of his wife and children
Before heading south, where
I saw
a whole family
each
other farewell
Bidding

During "Cruel Slavery Days."

Along the journey we found ourselves
At a square-dance or two,

Shared

a box supper with a fellow
"Trav'ler from Arkansas,"
And the three of us laughed
At the carrings-on
Of "Old Joe Clark"

And "Sally Goodin"
As hand in hand they started
"Down the Road"
Toward "Old Richmond"
To seek their "Fortune."

Thank you for sharing that with me.
--Betsy

Rutherford Coffey

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Issues in Old-Time Music

OLD-TIME AND BLUEGRASS:
BRIDGING THE GAP
by

Bluegrass and old-time music are two
quite different expressions of southern
American string band music. Rhythm,
and,
playing styles, instrumentation,
perhaps most significantly, intent differ
between bluegrass and old-time pickers.
While old-time music is a folk (that is to
say, created for other than commercial
reasons) form that was commercially
exploited during the 1920s, bluegrass
music developed for clearly commercial
reasons during the 1940s. Bluegrass then
proceeded to take on both folk and
commercial aspects, retaining both to
this day.

Old-time and bluegrass musics,
nonetheless, have much to share and
much in common beyond being two
branches of the same tree or including

same tunes in their
of these common
repertoires.
are
features
products of natural
evolution, others have been forced upon
us as a result of our standing as specialty
musics in a mass market economy. That
means bluegrass and old-time music face
some of the same issues, also, as do
blues, Cajun, commercial folk, nortena,
and gospel music.
Thirty years ago country music faced
many of these problems. The response
many

of

of

their

distinctions

the

Some

industry

was

to

blur

the

between country and pop

music, to abandon listeners under age
30, and to become the pop music of the
middle-aged. Going for millions of new
listeners, the country music industry
achieved its commercial goals at the
expense of the music's soul and vitality.
Since that time country music has not
produced the great creators and
innovators on the order of Jimmie
Rodgers, the Carter Family, Bob Wills,
Ernest Tubb, Bill Monroe, Hank
Williams, or Elvis Presley. As appealing
as
the image of string band music
broadcast
the recorded
dominating
media may appear, I doubt many of us
would want to pay the price of losing the
very qualities that drew us to the old

Southern sound.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The

Art Menius

International

Association (IBMA),

Bluegrass Music
the organization

for which I work, bases its activities on
several basic principles that deal with
this large issue: 1 we accept that bluegrass music is a specialty field, not a mass
market pop music; 2) we appreciate that
as a trade organization for the entire
field, it is not our business to define the
music nor to show favoritism to either
the most traditional or contemporary
sounds. We must have many rooms in
our mansion;
3) that we must not

involve ourselves

in

encouraging

or

dis

couraging change and growth. The music
must be allowed to continue to evolve
naturally; 4) that many people who
might like bluegrass music do not get the
for
hear
it
and
to
chance
judge

themselves. We will consider our task
when
everyone has that
complete
opportunity. At the scales in which
bluegrass and old-time music operate,
just a thousand new listeners will have a
very big impact; and 5) that while there
are

many different styles within

blue-

grass and many different sorts of people
who love and play our music, there are
many planes on which we must work

together.
Those of

us in the bluegrass and oldtime communities must appreciate that
those outside more often than not lump
us together. To someone who listens to
the
Bon Jovi,
or
Manilow
Barry
distinctions between the fiddling of
Tommy Jarrell and Marion Sumner are

not at all apparent. For people in the
mass culture it is very easy to view Randy
Travis, the Red Clay Ramblers, the
Nashville Bluegrass Band, Pete Seeger,

John Jackson, the Tannahill Weavers,
the Old Hollow String Band, Webb
Pierce, and the Stanley Brothers as all
"that kind of music." That uninformed
viewpoint from the outside should be
enough to convince all of us of our
common interest.
It is most important to bluegrass and
old-time music because the outside
audience to which both musics most

naturally appeal is folk music fans. These
are a large body of people, cultivated
during the boom years of the late 1950s
and early 1960s, who appreciate "real
music," but are not keyed into any one
real music. Anyone who has lived in a

community for an extended
noticed the same faces at
concerts by Bill Monroe, Taj Mahal,
Beausoleil, and Mike Seeger, and
college
period

has

perhaps realized that these fans are never
seen at fiddlers conventions or bluegrass festivals. They create the very real
trends that exist within specialty music.
A few years ago bluegrass was the hot
speciality music, then Celtic dominated,
now blues and Cajun hold that position.
Many of the areas of common interest
between bluegrass and old-time music
are simply practical. Those who perform
or semieither genre professionally
professionally often find themselves on
the same stages at such events as the

Philadelphia

or

Winnepeg

Folk

Festivals, or playing the same New
England coffeehouses. Contests such as
the one at Galax, Virginia, include both
bluegrass and old-time competitions,
and a few bluegrass festivals occasionally
engage an old-time band or old-time
related performer.
We clearly share the same media.
Until the Old-Time Herald was created,
Bluegrass Unlimited served as the primary
national outlet for articles and
advertisements about old-time music.
Mail order houses such as County Sales
and Elderly Instruments serve buyers of
both old-time and bluegrass recordings.
Many independent recording labels, for
example Rounder, Heritage, and June
Appal, release old-time and bluegrass
products. Hundreds of radio programs,

especially on non-commercial stations,
include bluegrass and old-time music
mixed with a
together, sometimes
variety of other specialty sounds. We
share a common interest in the strength
of these outlets.
As becomes obvious above, old-time
music also confront
and
bluegrass

�similiar issues within their communities.
Both are traditonally based music that
continue to remain alive and growing
musically. We each have listeners and
players that span several generations.

Old-time and bluegrass are participatory
musics depending on parking lot and

porch picking for much of their
appeal and sincerity. This means that
rather than a simple performer/ receiver
we
must deal with a
dichotomy,
that
reaches
from listener to
spectrum
amateur musician to contestant to semiback

professional to professional performer.
Bluegrass and old-time musics alike
suffer from those who would have us
believe in traditional vs. progressive
styles as a divisive dichotomy. It is a false
one. We can have both traditional and
progressive artists in our music. In fact,
we must have both,

and

gradations

and all the shades

between.

Neither

bluegrass nor old-time music as a whole
can be healthy unless both new and old
styles are strong.
As soon as a folk music moves to the
concert stage and record grooves,
commercial factors come into play.

Recordings have to sell in sufficient
quantities to fund the project. Enough
people must show up for

a

festival that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

promoter can continue to afford to
produce the event. Those who become
full time professionals in order to devote
the

their time to music must have enough
work to keep bread on the table. This
brings these people into conflict with
those who view the music as a people's
back porch style. These issues confront
all the specialty musics.
Ultimately, both old-time and
bluegrass depend on new listeners,
players, and performers to remain alive.
Our roots are strong, but we must sprout
new branches or the trunk will die. If all
all

the rest that we have in

common

is

not

is why bluegrass and oldtime must work together.
The common interest can be served in
a variety of ways. W e can work together
to encourage radio to play string band

enough, this

music in all its incarnations. We can
encourage events, promoters, and clubs
to use bluegrass and old-time talent. We
can make sure that the outside media
know what is happening in both fields,
so that those not yet in the bluegrass or
old-time communities will know where
to find us. The time is now for old-time
and bluegrass to work together so that
both musics can be heard by those who
have not been given the chance before.

We can start by appreciating the
shared interest and by respecting each
other.
The
bluegrass and old-time
communities are filled with people from

different

many

backgrounds

and

cultures who love genuine, heartfelt
music played with feeling. Too often our
musical passion has driven us apart. Let
us now love each other because we love
our music. We are family, and we can
open doors together that we cannot open
separately.
ART MENI US

is

International

the

executive director of

Bluegrass Music
St.,
(326 St. Elizabeth
KY 42301; 502-684-9025), a

Association
Owensboro,

trade association that publishes
International Bluegrass. He holds an MA
the University of North
Chapel Hill. He served as an
interpretations
specialist for the North
Carolina Department of Cultural Resources
in

from

history

Carolina

at

three and a half years. He worked as
publicist and writer for the Linear Group,
which produced "Fire on the Mountain" for
for

cable

TV and

the "Liberty Flyer" radio
He has written widely about bluegrass and old-time music. He assumed his
current duties in November 19 85. (Those
interested in becoming members of 1BMA

series.

may write

to

the above

address

ed.)

�The Dance Beat

Flatfooters
at

Mabry Mill
by

Tina Hicks

The neighboring counties of Patrick,
and Floyd in the Blue Ridge
Mountains of Virginia abound with old
time music and dance. The community
hosts a number of regular square dances

in lawn chairs arranged in a
around the musicians and
dancers. The musicians assemble around
In front of the table,
a wood block table.
the resident park ranger lays out two
dance boards forming a rough stage,
approximately eight feet by eight feet.
Fiddlers, banjo pickers, guitar players,
flatfooters, family, friends, and tourists
congregate weekly.

They gather

semicircle

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Stephen

and music gatherings. One such event,
one of the most dynamic and colorful of
all, takes place at Mabry Mill.
However, Mabry Mill happens not to
be a dance hall. Located near Meadows
of Dan, Virginia on the Blue Ridge
Parkway, Mabry Mill served as the main
grist mill for the community during the
1800s. Still in operation today under the
auspices of the National Park Service,
Mabry Mill remains an example of an
old-time mountain industry.
Every Sunday afternoon from spring
to fall Mabry Mill features old-time
music and dance. A large crowd of
spectators turns out to witness the event.

Tyler

Carroll,

1987

L-Ed Spence; R-William Hall

This event has been running for nearly
It was organized originally to
reflective of local
entertainment
provide
culture for Mabry Mill visitors. So that
reflect
their
will
the
music
truly
a
as
regular
Cap Ayers,
background,
picker, points out, the music played
must be old-time music. This does not
necessarily represent a distaste for
bluegrass music; indeed, some are Bill
12 years.

Monroe

fans

and

schoolhouse shows.

recall

his

early

On any given Sunday the ensemble of
may be a large crowd of

musicians

fiddler and banjo
they are there to
provide dance music. Ivan Weddle from
Floyd, regularly fiddles at Mabry Mill.
Most tunes heard at the mill come from
his repertoire and include ones like
players
picker.

or

simply

In

any

a

case,

"Sally

Ann,"

and

"

"Sugar Hill,"
"Long
Tongued

"Sarojane," "JohnHenry,

Woman." Ed Keith from Willis, Va.
frequently accompanies Ivan on banjo.
His son Coy Keith occasionally attends
and plays both banjo and guitar. Some
Sundays Ivery Kimble from Laurel Fork,
Va. shows up with her guitar. Now and

�Abe Horton from Fancy Gap
comes by to pick. Abe plays fiddle and
banjo, and is a fine singer. Fiddler Rafe
Brady attended from time to time before
he passed away. With the never ending
variety and combinations of musicians
and dancers, every visit to Mabry Mill is
a unique experience.
The dancers have characteristic styles
and steps that set them apart from each
other. The close link between dancer and
then,

determines

music

a

"common

denominator" among the many different
styles. In fact, some think of flatfooting
not only as dancing and responding to
the music, but as music in itself, or

as

a

way to make music. Each dancer listens
to the music and "steps out the tune" in
his or her own characteristic style.
For instance, Martha and C. T. Janee

from Floyd create rhythms with the
weight centering on the flat of the feet.
Some dance a solo "Charleston style" of

flatfooting (an example of the blending
and popular culture). Others
bring more modern and contemporary
clogging steps. Though highly personal
of folk

in

in

style,

characterized
footwork

general

and

by

the

dancers

are

low-to-the-floor

or

for

as

long

he

as

make the difficult look simple. His most
distinctive step is simple, yet so elusive,
so powerful and so perfect. It fascinates

once did. Hoy's

characteristic step involves side to side
movement and close to the floor
footwork. The step ends with a small

dancers, and many, including
myself, have tried to pick it up. have yet
to see anyone accurately
capture his
timing. Luther knows his step eludes me
and that I would love to learn it. When
try to copy him he always tells me with a
grin, "You're missing a lick, Tina, but
you're coming along."
Needless to say, Luther's step nearly
defies description. With an upright
posture, arms hanging freely at his sides,
knees slightly bent, he moves across the
floor. His feet remain very close to the
ground. Though most of his weight
centers on the balls of his feet, he does
not necessarily dance up on his toes. He
drops his heel to sneak in triplet sounds.
By rocking from ball to heel and heel to
many

forward kick.

I

inimitable Luther
Boyd stands out among flat-footers.
When asked about his dancing, Luther
describes it as "just plumb country
flatfootin'". Having learned by imitation
and observation of his grandfather, the
72-year-old Luther recalls, "Back in my
courtin' days we used to go to the frolic.

Undoubtedly,

what

Or

1

shucking
we'd

or

have

a

the

I

mean is, after the corn
the log rolling, why then
dance to celebrate. Soon

married though, I quit
recent years with the Mabry
I've started back again."
of Meadows of Dan, Luther
farmer. He says that dancing
has cured his arthritis. He does it for fun,
exercise, and to dance away his troubles.
Proud to mention that he is the four-year
flatfoot champ at the Patrick County
Fair, he has won numerous prizes and
ribbons at other local events over the
after

I

got

dancing. In
Mill event,
A native
is a retired

ball with
he creates

careful attention to the

music.

of walk

in

habit

with

of

playful,

looking

at

his

feet.

mischievious

A

very

dancer,

William has a really good time. He often
becomes tickled, especially after doing a
fancy step, and will chuckle to himself.
Known not only for his beautiful
but
known also for his
dancing,
beautiful smile, Hoy Hayden from near
by Mt. Airy, N.C., occasionally appears

Suffering from knee
problems, Hoy does not dance as much
at

Mabry

locks into his
repeatedly
step and has many
spontaneous variations of it. Every now
and then his eyes twinkle, and he starts
When this happens,
to look frisky.
Luther tries out his showier steps, which
still remain graceful and stylish. One of
these steps involves a change in posture.
Luther bends at the waist, perhaps so he
Luther

Tyler

a

almost

Mill.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

step,

characteristic

time to the

little "jog" added to the
walking effect. Williams's feet come off
the floor about three to four inches. He
contains his movement to a small space,
rarely more than three feet by three feet.
He stands up straight, but also has a shy
music

in his

gliding, flatfooted look.

kick."

Stephen

sounds,

sort

a

little "run or jog"
a

His step begins with low-to-the-floor
stepping. It ends with a small forward
swing of the leg or a very contained
forward kick. As he does this step, he
moves
slightly from side to side.
Luther's sideways traveling resembles
that of Hoy Hayden, though Luther
covers a much smaller space. (I do not
yet understand his timing completely.)
He keeps his basic rhythm going with
this step for most of the tune. After
awhile, it becomes a hypnotic, subtle
drumming, characterized by his slightly
syncopated, carefully timed "dig and

years.

are the older
local
My favorites
farmers who come out to have fun and
dance. Their dancing tends not to be
flashy Each one displays
highly
individualized footwork. These dancers
include, among others, William Hall,
Hoy Hayden, and Luther Boyd.
A shy, quiet, and lighthearted fellow,
William Hall is a retired cabbage farmer.
Clad in overalls, a work shirt, black laceup work shoes, and white socks (which
help to highlight his feet), he faithfully
attends the Sunday event. William's
dancing is carefree and in some ways,
reckless, yet controlled. He does a basic
step that some refer to as the "Tennessee
walking step." The walking step is as it

a

L-Tina Hicks; R-Luther Boyd

When
positions

1987

Luther
front of the
fiddler so that he can hear the music. If
the crowd of other dancers becomes too
loud, Luther gets off the floor.
Luther really dances to the music. If he
wants, he can be flashy, but for most of a
tune his stepping consists of subtle,

poised,

footwork.

ready

to

himself right

graceful,

dance,
in

carefully-phrased

Luther's effortless style allows him to

can better

hear his feet.
Although similar to one of

William

Hall's fancy steps, Luther's style causes
his step to look different. Both men give
it a playful look, but William makes it
appear reckless while, Luther makes it
After eight beats of
look refined.
crouching atop this step, Luther returns
to his basic step and upright stance.
All three of these flatfooters, W illiam,
Hoy, and Luther, are a joy to watch.
Musicians love to play for them and
love to dance with them. All three

I

characteristically dance with low-to-thefloor footwork. They all use the endless
or
toe-heel.
variations
of ball-heel
However, not one looks like the other
when he dances. Herein lies the great
beauty in old-time dancing.

�In a section of the country rich in
traditional music and dance, the Mabry
Mill gathering encourages the interesting
variety of local musicians and dancers to
get out and come together. It reflects the
nature of old-time music and dance by
showing us the great beauty found in

individualized self-expression.

This article was condensed from my
longer work, "Music and Dance in the
Blue Ridge Mountains
of Virginia"
which is included in Jacky Christian's

forthcoming book Southern Folk Dance.
All the information comes from my own

personal experiences attending Sundays
at the Mill during the seasons of 1984,

1985, 1986, and 1987. Through danc

these folks for fun, I had the
opportunity to make friends and spend
time learning about them. The exper
ience also provided me with a feel for
what their music and dance means to
them.
ing with

Tina Hicks is a dancer, caller, and folk
culture researcher. She currently dances with
the Green Grass Cloggers of Ashville, N.C.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�ASK
?

Uncle Harold

H.A., Harmony, N.C. writes: "My
band was recently hired to play at a
dance weekend 600 miles away. During
the big Saturday night dance a local
musician wanted to come and sit in with
the band 'for a tune.' I expressed some
hesitancy as the band had worked out
some unusual

tunes especially

for this

occasion, but we finally said O.K. The

local musician, once behind the mike,
never budged for the rest of the evening.
My cohorts and I were unsure of the
local etiquette, but we felt a little put
upon. What is the accepted procedure?

your uncle has found himself in
this very same situation, and he didn't
know what to do either. Dance
musicians, what do you do? Let your
A: H. A.

uncle know!

Uncle

Harold

has

noticed that the

other well-known uncle (Dave, that is)
seems to hold a peculiar fascination for
number of people.
an unprecedented
Though not himself an addict, he will be
helpful and send on the following
request: Don Summers is looking for
"Uncle Dave Macon obsessives" and
and
wants
tablature
song sources.
Others thusly inclined can write Don at
338 Bay view St., San Rafael, CA 94901.

Clemantine

Dear Uncle Harold
What

unusual band pictured on p. 24
of the Spring issue. Where does the band
find left-handed fiddles, guitars, and the
rare lefty
5-string banjo? Did Brad
Leftwich have anything to do with it?
an

Joe
Urbana, IL

To answer I.J.'s

inquiry about the
left-handed instruments

unusual

Leftwich is not the per
this
musical arcana. Actually,
of
petrator
this is a rare photograph of a string band
Mr.

Brad

J.,

from a parallel old-time universe where
objects are mirror images of objects in
our own universe and where a typical
dnab gnirts plays tunes such as "Einna
Enitgar" and "Partelttar". The tunes are

known

as

they are
as the

Brandywine

has

a

about not feeling like a part of the
festival scene, while her "significant
other" had a good time.)

Mrs.
Brace yourself, Clemantine.
A.B. of Norton, Virginia, has some stern
words for you. She feels you are

"narrow-minded

Section with Illegible Text

Isen

of

couple of suggestions from
concerned folks about the alleviation of
her desperate plight. (Astute readers will
remember that she wrote her uncle
received

"leers" and "nwodkaerbs," and
played at great gatherings such

famed Xalag Fiddlers Convention.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and unreceptive"
about "mountain culture" although she

that "only true native-born
Appalachians have a geniune love and
appreciation for their own heritage with
the exception of a few 'adopted' sons and
daughters. If one is not brought up with
some of the peculiar habits and ways of
also states

mountain people, it is sometimes
difficult to understand and grasp their
intentions or meaning." She wonders if
you have ever made molasses, milked a
cow, butchered a hog, or pieced a quilt.
the

On

a

more practical and less critical note

mentions the Augusta Heritage
workshops in Elkins as a good place to
she

start learning.

more sympathetic
Clemantine's plight is taken
A

signing

herself

view of
by someone

"Whole

Person

Though Tone Deaf," Wilkesboro,
N.C. She says,

"I've found that there are
many non-players at these things who
have mates that do play. Few that I know
on either side of the fence feel there's any
fence at all if both sides can treat the
situation with understanding and flex

ibility. ...A
or

happy

'mixed'

happier

couple
than

a

can

be

as

one-interest

couple so don't give up!" She also says,
"We know of a couple, both of them

superb musicians who were an item for
years... and played together for as long as
Yet their
they'd been together.
relationship recently ended. They
couldn't survive on mutual interest
alone." In addition she chastizes Uncle
Harold for not giving Clemantine more
encouragement. "With a response like
you gave Clemantine you're liable to
like
newcomers
feel
make
they're
unwelcome." Gosh, your uncle only
thought he was being realistic!

Uncle Harold

has received

a

request

information on Charlie and Bonnie
Barley
specifically, A.G. of San
for

Francisco wants

to track down a 78 disc
issued on the Bullet label (number 694)
in November,
1949. On one side was
L's
Contract
Time," on the other,
"John
"Miner's Welfare Fund." A.G. says he's
been searching for these articles and
titles for four decades. If any one has any
information let your uncle know and heinformation let your uncle know and
he'll put you in touch with A.G. And in
the same vein, S.T. in Oakland is looking
for information on a group called The
Corn Cob Crushers.

E.P., Williamsburg, Ohio writes:
"Please help me find out about a song I
heard my grandma play on the banjo
when I was a little girl. The only words I
can remember are, "Little whitewashed
cabin with grapevine o'er the door."

Uncle Harold called his good buddy
Wayne Erbsen (who incidentally hosts a
bluegrass show Sunday
on
6:00
WCQS in Asheville,
nights
N.C.). He told Uncle Harold that a song
great traditional
at

called "Little Whitewashed Chimney
with the Grapevine O'er the Door" can
be

found on County Records #740 Bill
and the Dixie Mountain Boys,

Clifton

recorded

in

Nashville

in

1957.

E.P.

might also try writing to Bill at Box 123,

Mendota, Va. 24270.

to
popular opinion,
Contrary
Harold doesn't know every

Uncle

is to know about old-time
music. But he knows where to find out,

thing there
by

golly!

A

conversation

with

Kerry

�Blech

yielded the following nuggets of
information. In answer to C.W. (Salt
Lake City), the tune "Farewell Trion"

was written by James Bryant.

V.A.,

Salem,

Missouri, wants

to

know the origins of the tune "The Lost
Child." Kerry again informs us that

Charles and Ira, the Stripling Brothers,
originally recorded "The Lost Child" on
Nov. 15. The Lost Child &amp; Other Original
Fiddle Tunes Recorded 1928-36. Charles
learned the tune from a neighbor, Pleas
but
added
the
Carroll,
pizzicato.
Charlie's son. Lee, has the fiddle on
which his dad recorded "The Lost
Child" and keeps it in the AEAC#
tuning.

R.G., Wimauma, Florida, writes,
"Could you Give me some suggestions
for playing rhythm on the banjo behind a
singer while maintaining a good tradtional sound?" Uncle Harold's playing is
on an uncertain level. So he asked one of
his nephews, an accomplished and wellknown clawhammer banjo player who
for
reasons unfathomable
to Uncle
Harold, wishes to remain anonymous.
Here's his answer.
"I'm

tempted

to

say

just

eliminate

notes
but I say that to everything. It
seems to me that each song requires a
different answer. The first thing is to
learn the melody, the words, and the
feeling the song conveys. Some songs call
for a strong melody to support them.
Others seem to call for a more chordal
backup. You might try some two or

three-finger rolls behind the melody, or
a clawhammer roll with a rhythm
like:

...or a counterpoint melody or rhythm
might suit the song best. I suppose this
doesn't do much to give a specific
answer. But if you have the melody and
the chords to a song sunk deep in your
head, play around with the song until the
right mix seems to assert itself. Use all
the

techniques you can to try to
communicate the feel of the song...
chords, single notes, drop thumb, fifthstring thumb, strumming, etc. There's

really no one answer."
Are there other banjo players out
there with ideas on this? Uncle Harold

wants to hear from you!
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�ROANOKE COUNTRY
RADIO
FROM
1954

1924by

There were few radios in Roanoke,
Virginia, on June 20, 1924, but on that
the
first local
broadcast
that
day
Roanoke Valley radio owners heard was
WDBJ's station employee, Ray Jordan,
performing three fiddle tunes. From this
modest start, country music was per
formed live over Roanoke stations for
the next 30 years. Between 1924 and
1954 local stations featured live hill
music programs
each
billy
early
morning, around noon, and again in the
evening. The early days of radio were
often impromptu and informal. In the

1920s there were no constricting "alltalk" or "easy listening" formats. Nor
were there any disc jockeys who played
records. Nearly all of the programming
was performed live and moderated by
announcers who also read commercials
and made announcements about events
of
local
interest.
The essence
of
pioneering radio was its local orientation
and its encouragement of improvisation,
and

WDBJ,

which

was

Richardson- Whelan

started by the

Electrical

stands as an important
Virginia broadcasting.

Corporation,
pioneer
The

in

earliest country
music on
Roanoke radio was performed by area
string bands and singers. Groups such as
the Roanoke Jug Band,
the N&amp;cW
the
Blue
Fox
Chasers,
Stringband,
Ridge
and the Salem Highballers began playing
on WDBJ as early as 1926. The most
important of the early groups was the

Roanoke

Entertainers,

a

five-piece

string band that had regular weekly or

bi

broadcasts between

1930 and
1936. Most of these 15-or 30-minute

weekly

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

broadcasts

Kip Lornell

hosted by Hayden
the "Red-Headed
Announcer," who went on to enjoy a 50were

Huddleston,

year

radio

television

and

career.

The

height of the Roanoke Entertainer's
regional fame came in 1931. During the
first week of February they boarded a
train for New York City in order to
broadcast over the CBS network and

audition
weeks
before

for
later

Columbia
the

Congress

Records.

Six

Entertainers
played
at
the
request of

Congressman Woodrum. By the end of
the year these musicians had also sung to
large

regional

audiences

on

WRVA's

"Corn Cob Pipe" program in Richmond,

Washington, D.C.'s WMAL.
the Depression placed a
stranglehold on the American economy,
WDBJ's first area competitor, WRBX,
signed on the air, broadcasting from the
Hotel Roanoke for two years before its

and on

Just

when

small Cyrstal Spring studio

was finally
1933. Until it went off the
air in 1935,
WRBX broadcast many
shows
Roanoke Valley country
by
artists
such as the Floyd County
the Junior Cavaliers,
the
Ramblers,
Neuman Stringband,
and
Hawaiian
guitarists Herbert Rickman. For at least
one year the station also featured a three-

completed

hour

in

Saturday

Night

barndance

program.
WDBJ

continued to dominate the
Valley's early radio through the rest of
the 1930s. Along with other programs,

country music fans could hear local
hillbilly bands at least three times daily.
During the 1930s, "western clothes,
movies, books, and music also gained

favor

among many Americans, and
nationally, the Sons of the Pioneers, the
Girls of the Golden West, Bob W ills and
the Texas Playboys, and Gene Autry
were particularly popular. In Roanoke,
in
addition to the more traditional
stringbands, a local western act, the
Texas Troubadours, (Ed Newman
Lawrence
Sink
and
fiddle,
guitar,
and
banjo, Glen Howell
bass,
guitar
Paul Byrd
tenor banjo) was perhaps
the Valley's favorite country group until
they disbanded in 1941. The Texas
Troubadours made hundreds of
at
community
personal
appearances
centers, civic clubs, and schoolhouses
within one hundred miles of Roanoke.
In the fall of 1939 WDBJ lured Roy
Hall &amp; the Blue Ridge Entertainers away
from WAIR Winston-Salem, North

Carolina.

This Dr. Pepper-sponsored
group proved to be one of the Roanoke
Valley's most popular hillbilly bands.
Their
15-minute shows
twice-daily,
were followed by many local music
lovers eager to hear the Blue Ridge
Entertainers' blend of a capella sacred
songs, fiddle tunes, and popular country
songs. Roy Hall and his brother, Jay
with fiddler Tommy
Hugh,
along
bass
and
player
Magness,
guitarist
Wayne Watson, dobro player Bill
Brown, the multi-talented Hall Twins
(Saford and Clayton), and the familiar
voice of Irv Sharp became well-known to
Roanoke Valley residents. The Blue
Ridge Entertainers performed through
out southcentral

Virginia and parts of
West Virginia and North Carolina.
Because of their popular Victor record-

�"

ings such as Don't Let Your Sweet Love
Die," the group was gaining national
prominence when Roy Hall was killed in
a

1943 car crash.
WDBJ finally gained

a
formidable
November of 1940
when WSLS signed on the air. Owned
the
Shenandoah Life Insurance
by
Company, and affiliated with the Mutual
Newtork WSLS ran a professional, wellfinanced operation. In 1942 the station
started an innovative regional link, the
Tri-Cities Network, with Danville's

local competitor

in

Watson,

Woody

Mashburn,

and

in

their

Wanderers' daily
WSLS broadcasts continued to exploit
Clayton Hall

the

western
music.

and

themes

images

Roanoke's final major radio station,
WROV, signed on the air in December,
1946, to the sounds of Jay Hugh Hall and
the Happy-Go-Lucky
Boys. WROV's
arrival underscored the fact that the air
waves of the Blue Ridge were becoming

crowded.
stations

1950 there were radio
Bedford, Covington, and
Wytheville. This was a boon to country
musicians who were able to move from
one station to another in search of a fresh
audience for their music. Through radio,
hillbilly musicians were able to book live
personal appearances that provided the
primary income for those seeking to
make music a full-time livelihood.
In

By

in

1940s and early 1950s the
Nashville was slowly
more pronounced and the

the late

influence
becoming

of

area's country radio groups increasingly
"covered" the latest hits. Honkytonk
music and bluegrass were also heard
more often on Roanoke's radio stations.
The downfall of local country radio
and
live radio
in
was the
general
explosive impact of television. The
Valley's first television station, WSLS,

1953. By the middle

signed on the air

in

music

longer

of the 1950s television had swept across
the Roanoke Valley and live country
was

no

found

on

the

schedules of local radio stations.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Courtesy

Blue

Ridge

Heritage

Archive

WDVA and WLVA in Lynchburg.
These ties provided WSLS with strong
diverse programming that highlighed
national as well as regional talent. In the
country field Bill Monroe was beginning
to establish bluegrass as a musical genre,
while local groups such as the Virginia
Hillbillies and the Big Lick Entertainers
were heard over WSLS. One of the
station's most popular groups from
1943 until 1948 was the Wanderers of
the Wasteland. Formed by three former
members of Roy Hall's band
Wayne
L-R Glen Howell,

Roy Lemmon, Mel Linkous, Virgil Simmons,

Gordon Reid 1949

�RENEWALS
DUE
!

have
of you
many
Although
already renewed your subscriptions
to the Old-Time Herald, we urge those
of you who haven't, to do so. For
your convenience we have figured out
how to put the expiration date on the

computer

mailing

label.

This

the date of the 4th

expiration date

is

subscription

expires

ISSUE in your subscription. We
must receive your check or money
order in the mail before the next issue
so that we can continue your sub
scription. For those of you whose

with

this

May-July) issue, please
remimt renewals before the Fall
(Aug. -Oct.) issue. Thank you for all

(Summer,

your support.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�group is the Men's and Women's
Fiddlers Association of Iowa, often

HERE

name, Old

still called by it's original

Fiddler's Association. They meet

&amp;

nights) and the Scotch Ridge Cloggers
in Indianola (Friday nights). Monthly
dances of primarily squares and contras
are sponsored by Onion Creek in Ames,

on

Tuesday of each month at the
Knight's of Pythias Hall in Des
Moines, and 30 or more fiddlers may
play in sequence during the evening,
the first

THERE

Weldon Gourd, Phil McCrea,
Dave Bellegante. It is also the best
as

by

to

Susan Brown

Old-time music and dancing

in

in

central

have a very low profile on the
"modern" scene. Events are almost
entirely local and non-commercial, and
many people who play may not get out at
all. However, while there is virtually no
old-time music (or bluegrass, for that
matter) on radio or in concert, there are
plenty of musicians and fans who will
show up anywhere an old-time/ country
jam session or "hoedown" dance is held.
Interest in the music has not been taken
up by younger people to the extent it has
in many parts of the country, yet there is
or
more friendly,
not
a
energetic,
Iowa

dedicated group of musicians than the

older Iowans who still eniov it.
For example, within 50 miles of Des
Moines there are over 14 regularly
or
scheduled
monthly jam
weekly
sessions where piano, banjo, guitar, bass,
and bones ("seconders") are brought out
to back up the many fiddlers. The largest

learn

about

fiddle

dances,

the

many

dances

local with

and

dancers,

way

visiting

hoedown
and

Although clogging has become very
popular in Iowa, most teams are of the
"modern" variety. One group of squarethe
dance performers,
Tri-County
Travelers of Altoona, has been
into

its

Creek

sponsored

Cloggers

by
in

the

Ames

a

small

the

base of enthusiastic

although

musicians

old-time recordings.

by

participation of
and callers is

In

Iowa

City

the

Dennis Roseman (Department

of
of Iowa, Iowa

Mathematics, University

City, IA 52252) is another organization
that sponsors concerts, get-togethers and

many

dances.
Fiddlers' Picnic, held

occasional

years, inspired by the "jigging" first seen
in the 1950s on "Barn Dance." More
traditionally-inclined musicians and
dancers can also be found at open

practices

of

through

Friends of Old-Time Music, headed

clogging
for

programs

any

made

River City Friends, R.R. 1 Box 95,
Preston, IA 52069). Pat tracks many
individual musicians, jams, house
concerts, and summer festivals for the
benefit of old-time fans. She and Mike
Mumm are frequent performers locally,
and she also has a Sunday afternoon
radio show on KROS 1340 AM playing

Ellsworth Clarks.

routines

for
be

In
eastern Iowa, an excellent
newsletter is published monthly for the
River City Friends of Folk Music by
Pat Walke (subscription $5/yr. to

months.

traditional

can

increasing.

contests,

There are still dances also, such as the
Happy Swingers meeting in the same
KP Hall on the second and fourth
Saturdays, where they waltz, schottische,
polka, and call traditional old squares to
fine old melodies by family bands like

incorporating

above

Susan Brown, 95th Court, Johnston,
I A
50131. Most of the production is

jams that are held in
small communities all over the state in

the

Contact

Company.

country/old-time
the summer

Des

teaching group, the Front Porch Dance

while others watch and listen, dance, or
join a jam session in the basement. This
gathering is a great place to meet some of
Iowa's best fiddlers, young and old, such

Iowa

weekend of the month
Moines by a new performing/

and on the third

annual
weekend
in October, brings out lots of acoustic
musicians for a last fling at parking-lot
picking before the cold weather.
Harvest Home from Iowa City includes
A1 Murphy on fiddle and Bob Black
two musicians who are
on banjo,
probably well-known to many people
outside Iowa.

Onion

(Sunday

Their

the first

Finally, two large festivals that include

old-time music and dancing ought to be
mentioned. The first is Bob Everhart's
festival in Avoca, near Council Bluffs,
on Labor Day Weekend. It draws very
crowds, and many local and
large
nationally known country and old-time
in
a
mixed
participate
of contests, workshops, and

performers
program

exhibitions. In Des Moines the Living
History Farm, a living museum of
traditional farm life and practice, has
begun to sponsor a Traditional Music
Weekend (this year from July 16-17).

real effort to
to a wider
and
bring out the many
who are still known to only a

Susan

Brown

The organizers are making
promote old-time music

Fiddler's Association Jan. 1988
Don DeCamp-bones,

Millie Laurinas-piano,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Weldon Gourd-fiddle,

Phil McCrea-fiddle

audience,
musicians

small circle of friends.

a

�Old-Time Music Notes
from Birmingham
by

"Fiddles

Cauthen

Joyce

used

to

be

Everis

famous,"

said

Campbell of Troy, Alabama.
"You'd go possum hunting and the dogs
would tree, and if you shook the tree, a

fiddle or a five-string banjo would drop
your head." There aren't as many
fiddles and banjos in Alabama as there
were 70 years ago when Campbell was a
boy, but you can still find them if you
shake enough trees.
Birmingham has a sizeable contingent
of old-time musicians who began playing
in the early '70s. They drew inspiration
from Horse Pens 40, a nearby festival
that featured the Highwoods, the Red
on

Clay Ramblers, the Hot Mud Family,
Ace Weems and the Fat Meat Boys,
etc.
Horsepens 40 became an
arts/crafts/food fair, however, and
most of Birmingham's old-time crowd

Old-Time

Valley

Convention

in

Fiddlers

Athens,

month. Since their schedule
unpredictable, they keep their 200 or

Alabama,

which takes place on the first Friday and
Saturday in October. While the fiddle
competition seems to lure only contest
ants in the modern
"supersmooth"
mode, the old-time banjo and old-time
string band categories provide niches for
musicians who play in older styles.
Each spring (the first Friday and
Saturday in May) the Brierfield

Ironworks Park

near

Montevallo has

members informed of dances, festivals,
and concerts in a congenial monthly
newsletter.
BCDS also sponsors the
popular, semi-annual Old-Time Music
and Dance Weekend
at
Camp
an
event that attracts
Tekawitha,
musicians and dancers from across the
South. Over the years, Birmingham
country dancers have had the pleasure of
dancing to folks like Bruce and Audrey

a

festival that features old-time, bluegrass,
and
folk,
Cajun music. Brierfield
recently produced a record entitled

and Paul Brown, the Rising
Fawn Ensemble, Lotus Dickey, Pete
Sutherland, Ralph Blizard and the
New Southern Ramblers, the Stillhouse Reelers, Sandy Bradley and
the Small Wonder String Band, the
New Dixie Entertainers, the Red

Molsky

Possum Up a Gum Stump: Home, Field,
and Commercial Recordings of Alabama
Fiddlers, which you will be reading about
in a future issue of the Old-Time Herald.

includes
some of
by
recordings
Alabama's legendary fiddlers, such as
Charlie Stripling and Y.Z. Hamilton, as
well as living fiddlers who play in older
styles.

Hots,

many other fine groups,
the Cajun
dance bands
Beausoleil and File'. There's also a
country dance society in Huntsville, but
as
Huntsville has an active old-time
scene of its own, they will tell you about
it in a future issue.

It

old-time

Among area musicians are Ricky and
Mary Anne Stone and Frankie
Edwards, who with Jackie Burgess and
Mike Norred of Anniston, form the
Toadstompers. Performances by the
Toadstompers include Mt. Airy oldwell

musician,

as

blues numbers led

Another

Lee Nicholson,

Birmingham
plays

with

Park

as

Norred.

Flintstones.

Cauthen,

Bill

Nicholson describes
as

"primitive

Joyce,

and,

jungle

Brierfield

rhythms."

music
Jim,

Carey

Nancy Martin,
Ed Baggott comprise

and

arurtcsy

the

Ironworks

Bill McClain and Edwin and Karen
Wilson of Huntsville in a band called
Flintstone

Jackson,
soon.
Once

and

they

will

be

recording

Kim

Appel,

Phil Foster, and
Red Mountain White Trash, which

specializes in country dance music and
tunes learned from older fiddlers in the
area. Ed Baggott, formerly of Jackson
Mississippi and Houston, Texas, is the
most recent of several old-time
musicians from other parts who have
enriched the Birmingham music scene
over the years. Others include Lloyd
Baldwin from Florida, Bill and Susan
Boyer Haley from Missouri, and Ivan
Mann from North Carolina. All of the
musicians above, plus Dave Borland,
Laura Vines, and others team up for
jam sessions and form bands for various
performances. James Bryan, formerly
with the Rising Fawn Ensemble, now
performs with Carl Jones and Tom

Noah Lacy of Ider, Ala., on Sand Mountain is one of
1 1
fiddlers featured on the recently produced
Possum
Home, Field,
Up a Gum Stump:
Commercial Recordings of Alabama Fiddlers.

A

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

new

organization,

Folklife

A

sponsored
convention

an
in

Alabama

the

ssociation,

and

old-fashioned
Montevallo and

recently

fiddlers

is making
Alabama
folklife
plans
festival to take place in the summer of
1989, featuring old-time fiddling, blues,
gospel singing, and other regional music

for

as

the

first

well as arts and crafts.

Much of the old-time music activity

Birmingham

Birmingham
Society,

centers

around

Dance

Country

which was founded

in

the

in

1981 by

group of old-time musicians in search
an audience.
They hold Saturday
night dances once, sometimes twice, a
a

year most of the musicians in
the area converge upon the Tennessee
a

addition, there's "a whole 'nother"
music scene in Alabama.
Hundreds of men and women who had
played in string bands in the '20s and
'30s, when fiddles were "famous,"
resumed their music in the folk revival of
the late '60s and early '70s. Some, like
Ralph Whited of Oneonta, who plays
in a string band with his brother, J.D.
and cousin Carter Whited, have a real
old-time sound.
Others
show
the
influences of popular recording artists
they have listened to over the years, like
Arthur Smith, Bob Wills, Tommy
Jackson, and Kenny Baker. For instance,
In

fixes.

by

and

including

now travels to the Galax and Mt. Airy
fiddlers conventions for their annual

time music

is

so

of

Howard

Colburn

influences

has

combined the

father's old-time
fiddling with all the above and now plays
in the style Charles Wolfe has called
"southeastern swing." Colburn and
many others hold forth every Saturday
in McCalla at the Tannehill Opry, a
music hall they built after passing the hat
at musical
gatherings for the last 17
of

his

years.

Most counties in Alabama have some
of musical gathering place where
you can hear musicians render old-time
tunes, bluegrass and gospel standards,
Texas swing, etc. Often there's a dance
floor where folks do buckdancing,
"round" dances (i.e. couple dances), and
one or two sets of Appalachian circle
dances per night. If you are visiting in
Alabama, ask around and you may find
sort

one near you. Go there and you are likely
to find a bunch of older folks who will
like your music and warmly encourage

you to join them.
For more

information about old-time

�in
the
events
and
dance
music
contact
Joyce
Birmingham vicinity,
2169 Shadybrook Lane,
Cauthen,
Birmingham, AL 35226 (205-822-

0505)

call

or

Ricky

Stone

at

Fretted

Culture

&amp;.

History

Instruments (205-879-6489).

West

Dept.

of

Virginia's

Virginia

Old-Time Music

is a

fiddle tunes;

place

as

in

is

as

crooked

many other ways

it

complex and contradictory

Mike

as its

courtesy

Margo Blevin

West Virginia's terrain

Keller,

by

West

Scene

as those tunes. It's a state teeming with
old-time music, but if you don't know

where to look for

it,

Glen Smith fiddles on stage
and Mark Payne.

it's not always easy

find. Despite economic pressures,
West Virginia is still home to some of
musicians in the
the best old-time
to

country, many still playing in their '70s
to
'90s. Four major annual events
dominate the old-time music calendar,
and dozens of other small festivals
include traditional old-time and bluegrass music to some extent.
The "season" starts each May with the

Vandalia
Memorial Day
free
a
state-sponsored
Gathering,
weekend

which sprawls across the treelawns of the state capitol in
Charleston. This family-oriented festival
features tastefully conducted contests
(with separate categories for bluegrass
old-time fiddle, banjo, and
and
dulcimer), a free-style clogging stage
with non-stop music by the bluegrass
group, Goldrush, a liar's contest, black
gospel, jam sessions, great ethnic food,
festival
shaped

concerts

all-day and evening
dominated by West Virginia's older
traditional musicians. Such mainstays as
and

O'Brien, Phoebe Parsons,
Andy Boarman, Glen Smith, Woody
Simmons, Lefty Schaeffer, Frank
Sylvia

George, Melvin Wine, Ernie
Carpenter, Blackie Cool, John
Loving, Joe Dobbs, Wilson Douglas,
Flarvey Sampson, French Mitchell
and dozens more may be heard. As

at

just

about every West Virginia music event,
the best picking usually centers around
the whereabouts of the Bing Brothers,
the

best

old-time

band

and

probably
best-kept secret in the state. The band
includes brothers Tim, Dave and Mike
Bing, Greg Gibson and Danny
Arthur. Among the younger generation
musicians, all of the best can be heard at
Vandalia,
including Bobby Taylor,
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

the 1987

Vandalia Gathering, accompanied

Ron Mullenex, Gerry Milnes, Tom
King, Jim Costa, John &amp; Dave

Morris, Buddy Griffin, Robert
Schaeffer, Robin Kessinger, Kate
Brett, Larry Rader, John Preston,
and Alan Freeman, to name just a few.

but going
Smaller than Vandalia,
strong and almost unchanged since it was
founded in 1950 by Dr. Patrick Gainer,
is

the

Glenville Folk Festival,

this year

running from June 16 to 18. This is still
traditional singing,
festival
for
the
dancing and picking. It's barely
organized, and mostly attended by those
who play music or dance, with listeners
Some of the most
in the minority.
traditional dance styles in the state can
be seen at Glenville. There are contests

(don't miss the Over-50 contest), and
concerts, but for most people, the
festival takes place around the town's
only motel and its parking lot. The
Saturday morning gospel sing features
such outstanding local singers as Ginny

Hawker

Jesse Marks.
the major music
At midsummer,
events are the Augusta Heritage Arts
and

Elkins, from July 10 to
Workshops
August 12, packing in 5 weeks of classes
and concerts, ending with the 3-day
Augusta Festival. Much of the old-time
music at Augusta takes place during
in

"Old-Time Week," July 17 to 22,
coordinated by Gerry Milnes. Musicians
studying at Augusta during "Old-Time
Week" this year will have their choice of
working with Milnes, Frank George,

Clyde

Davenport,

Mike

Bing,

Ron

Mullenex, Jim Costa, Bruce Greene, or
Craig Johnson. Guest instructors will

by

son Delano Smith (R)

include
Ginny Hawker, Alice
Gerrard, Matokie Slaughter, Ernie
Carpenter, Melvin Wine, Clyde Case,
and balled singer

Phyllis Marks.

The eclectic schedule of Augusta
classes includes plenty of old-time music
instruction during the other four weeks
of the summer session as well. Among
others, on staff for two weeks will be
Critton Hollow, probably the bestknown old-time band in West Virginia.
A full-time touring concert and dance
band, the group is made up of versatile

musicians Sam Herrmann,
Herrmann and Joe Fallon.

Joe

major old-time music
state is the Stonewall
Jackson Jubilee, held at the Jackson's
Mill 4-H Camp, near Weston, every
Labor Day weekend. This large popular

fourth

The

the

event

in

event

costs

Concerts
evening

almost nothing to attend.
and
the
day
throughout

feature

such

Griffin Family Band,

groups

as

the

Samples
Band, Clan Erdverkle, the
Brothers,
Big Possum String
the

Family
Bing

Band, gospel groups,

and many of the

same "old master" musicians mentioned
earlier.

would be impossible to list here all
music and dance events happening
throughout the year. To mention only a
few more, the highly active Charleston
group, FOOTMAD (Friends of OldTime Music &amp; Dance) holds a nice small
festival at a 4-H camp in late September.
FOOTMAD also sponsors a wellIt

the

attended concert series throughout the
year, monthly square dances, and their
newsletter gives timely information on

�concerts

dances

and

the

throughout

state. Old-time performers also appear
in Charleston thanks to the live public
radio variety show, Mountain Stage,
hosted by Larry Groce and the laidback interview/albums format of Joe

Dobbs'

Music

weekly

From

the

Mountains.

Other organizations in the north and
central parts of the state are the Elkins
Country Dance Society, which holds
either a dance or concert every month,
the

and

FOOTMUSIC

Morgantown

group, which schedules monthly square
and contra dances at W.V. University.
The
moving spirit behind the
Morgantown dances is the frenetic
and irrepressible
silliness of
energy

Stewed Mulligan,

a

Doddridge Coun

string band fast becoming known out
side the region. Morgantown also boasts
ty
a

monthly traditional dance

at

Murilla

Park, presided over by old-time caller
Worley Gardner. Worley also runs a

Winter

Festival every February. A
weekly Tuesday night jam session is held
in Morgantown, and old-time music can
be heard on occasion in the local clubs.
For those who want to know more
about the traditional music of West
Virginia,

I

highly

recommend

reading

Goldenseal Magazine, West Virginia's
state folklife quarterly.

It offers in-depth
interviews with old-time musicians, as
well as listings of West Virginia festivals

which

feature some

traditional

music

and/or folklife events.

name

Backwoods

is

Backwards Banjo

of

his

Banjo,

ink

correct

Benford
banjo

I.

The

album

to Mac

not

lack

Apologies

stated in the
last issue of the dlO-emiT dlareH.
Also corrected is the printing of the
photo (R) which was printed back
as

a

courtesy
--Thompson,

wards

as

test of the observational

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Erie

slliks of Old-Time Herald readers.
L-R Mac Benford, Walt Koken,

Jack Link, Bob Potts

�Workshop

HALF-SHAVED

from Fields Ward

In its relative simplicity, this beautiful clawhammer version of "Half-Shaved"
takes nice advantage of the banjo's resonant
D and F#. The third string, tuned in E, reminds you with its
qualities and the special tuning with 3 drone strings covering 2 notes
constant dissonance that you are playing a banjo rather than something more orderly.
As remarkable a solo tune as this is, it also sounds great with accompaniment, and the guitar chords I've noted are the ones that
Fields frequently used.

--Paul

Discography: Heritage 039 Old Five String
Dent Wimmer

Traditions

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Fields Ward and Paul Brown; Home-Made Music LP001 Appalachia

Brown

The Old

�Marimar Recordings
4000
4002
4003

CANDY FROM STRANGERS
The Dixie Darlin's
SONGS OF THE JERSEY PINES AND SHORE Merce
WHERE THE CRICKETS FIDDLE
Jim Albertson
The Barbara Beeman Band;
MOVING DAY

8000

THROW

8001

LET

4001

old-time

YOUR TIME AWAY
The Otis Brothers
ROLL!
John Cephas &amp; Phil Wiggins
IN THE LAND OF CORN AND WINE
The Otis Brothers
RIGHTEOUS BLUES
Bill Ellis
with an amazingly

8002
8003

new-time pop, blues, folk and more
regional songs of the Pine Barrens
songs and stories for kids, grown-ups, and other wild life
vintage pop, folk/rock, blues, and contemporary songs
black-based blues, sanctified, and pre-blues recreations
high energy acoustic blues-- strong vocals, hot harmonica, solid guitar
the Brothers have grown with each new outing-- a special tape
agile guitar technique &amp; performances to the heart of blues &amp; sanctified

Ridgway

IT

&amp;

Pinehawkers

FORKED DEER
Dan Gellert &amp; Shoofly
mountain music with guts and swing-- features Dan's great fiddling
SONGS THAT SCARE ME Pat Conte
recreations of blues and old-time classics-- includes mystery instrumentals
LOVE THEM DUCKS
Half Shaved
well performed old-time tunes and songs in the string-band tradition
TUESDAY NITE LIVE
old-time music in Philadelphia-- the good time, party atmosphere of the early 1980s
GOIN1 DOWN THE COUNTRY
Steve Garcia with Matt Levine
1930s style country music-- upbeat banjo, harmonica
GOING NOWHERE FAST
Uncle Willie &amp; Brandy Snifters
comes with booklet-- the old-time spirit lives!
WHEN THE YANKEES CAME DOWN
live concert recordings, 1980-1984
Major Contay &amp; Canebrake Rattlers
BEHIND THE TIMES
Bob Bovee and Gail Heil
great duet singing by Bob and Gail on wonderful old songs
STILL LAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS
a high
level of singing and playing
Lazy Aces String Band
OLD TIME FRIENDS
with booklet-- Ray and 34 of his "old time friends" present a survey of old-time music today
Ray Alden
IN THE HILLS OF HOME
Smith
&amp;
Bob
Cowan
with booklet-- a warm documentation of a community's music
Raymond
TRADITIONAL FIDDLE MUSIC OF MISSOURI
with Dennis &amp; Emily Buckhannon-- includes Cyril Stinnett tunes
Charlie Walden
The Fish Family Dance Band
FLUKE HITS
level
contra-dance
music-- medleys you can dance to, great tune selection!
high
FARMER'S FROLIC
Ross County Farmers
features Lonnie Seymour's wonderful and rare fiddle tunes from Ohio
A SOUTHERN CATALOG
instrumental adaptations of old-time tunes-- mixes electric and acoustic instruments
Joe LaRose

9000
9001

9002
9003

9004
9005
9006
9007
9008
9009

9010
9011

9012
9013
9014

9100

classic

JOYFUL NOISE, VOL.
JOYFUL NOISE, VOL. 2
THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL.
THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL. 2
THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE
booklet
A

9101
9104

1

1

9105

9104-05
9106
9108
9109
9110

MAKE

ME

COWBOY

A

AGAIN

FOR

A

DAY

CHEVROLET SIX
Oscar Ford
JOHNNY'S GONE TO WAR
IT'LL NEVER HAPPEN AGAIN
Old-Time String
GOIN' UP TOWN
Old-Time String Bands, Vol. 2

9111

9200

UP

9600

FEAST HERE TONIGHT!
THE
THE
THE

CT
GC
VB

AGIN

THE

Rabbit

COWBOY TOUR
1935 GRAND CANYON
VOLO BOGTROTTERS

Ask for MARIMAC

includes

Everett

MOUNTAIN

descriptions

cassettes
and

at

your

in

Pitt
a

gospel and sacred music recordings from the Golden Age
Age sides-- quartets, shape note, duet, string band, and solos
moonshine and temperance songs from the Golden Age
more moonshine and temperance songs-- many songs, many artists
16 pages of annotations by W.K. McNeil-- packed
with facts and information
classic songs of the West from Golden Age recordings
all of Ford's known Golden Age sides-- with McMichen,
Stokes, Puckett, Grace
war songs from Golden Age recordings-- string bands, duets, solos
Bands, Vol.
many bands, many tunes, classic sides
the string bands keep coming with no end in sight!
1

home

cut and

Log

Skip

live
COWBOY

full listings

local
of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

old-time

more Golden

A

BAND

dealer,

or

recordings

write

all selections

wire recordings

Gorman

and

&amp;

from

the

on

the

each

1940s-- very fine versions of ballads and song
Bluegrass traditions with tasteful innovation

by the Nat'l. Council for the Traditional Arts
anniversary concert-- issued by Sharlot Hall Museum
the Chicago area-- incudes some super Illinois tunes

tour-- issued

a young
band
for our catalog which

artists

from

Rich Starkey--older
50th
from

cassette.

RHY

'

I

ITTI

F

FFPRY
rfcl\l\Tj

Ml
NJ

n7Cd.^
U/04d;

II
Q A
U.D.

�Sales

County
H

9

NEW RELEASES
CO-786

GETTIN' CP THE STAIRS

AT- 103

POSSUM

"CCS- 111

QS-5031

FCOT-001

*CMF-011
OH-191

*REB-853

ROU-0241

"ROU-0233
OH-0183
HER-070

*ROU-0242
FCOT-005
*FF-415

*ROU-0239
*TH- 1001

"HAT-3022
"CO-791
"CCS-110

"CO-788
*REB-850
"FF-352
*JA-014
"CO-790
*HH-

19842

CO-545
AJA-5042
CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406
HER-63

CO-777
GFS-901

AH-002

SOUNDA-001

*REB-852

UP A GUM STOMP Commercial &amp; field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
FLATT &amp; SCRGGGS "You Can Feel It In Your Soul" Classic gospel from the 1 950's
DOC WATSON "Out In The Country" Fine live recordings from the 1 960's

OLD HOLLOW STRINGBAND Old-time music from North Carolina
FIVE MILES OGT OF TOWN
TRADITIONAL MUSIC FROM THE CUMBERLAND PLATEAU
Vol.
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
Vol 1" Reissue fo 1920s material
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroe's best early 1950s Decca material
CHICKEN CHOKERS "Shoot Your Radio" Newly recorded old-time music by this Boston-area band

2

DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
UNCLE DAVE MACON "Over The Mountain -Vol 2" Reissue of 1935-38 recordings
THE OLD TIME WAYThe music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish
w/booklet
NASHVILLE BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent old-time LP,
w/Kirk Sutphin
A. ROBIC&amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
THE HORSEFLIES "Human Fly" Old-time music by this New York string band
CONFLUENCE Hammer dulcimer music by Lee Spears and Christopher Deane
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930 s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 1940 s King material
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T. Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTWICH &amp; HIGGINBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
HEE HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing

7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
.$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50
$1 0.00
7.50

TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music

*TR-1

P- 13263
'CCS-108

fC

TRADITIONAL MUSIC FROM THE CUMBERLAND PLATEAU

Recent field recordings

CO-787

UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine 1920's/30's sides
"T rain Whistle Blues" Super reissue of train songs by Rodgers
Import
Vol 2 "Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
SKILLET LICKERS
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carroll County, Virginia
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920's/30's
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 1938-41
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL with Mike Seeger, Brad Leftwich, Benny Jarrell, etc
VIRGIL ANDERSON "On The Tennessee Line" Old-time banjo from the upper Cumberland
SEEMS LIKE ROMANCE TO ME Traditional fiddle tunes from Ohio
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American fiddle music from Mississippi
EDDEN HAMMONS COLLECTION Historic set of traditional fiddle music
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Songs Of The Carter Family" Fine 1960 LP with Maybelle Carter
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings" His classic sides from the 1950 s
LOUVIN BROTHERS "The Best OF' Features their top songs from the middle 1950s
JIMMIE RODGERS

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted

I*SH-3759
bfl

H
K

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS

EM

LJV
PLJ

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
READY FOR SHIPMENT
W

by an

asterisk

"

")

On all ORDERS in U.S.A. please add $2.00 postage &amp; handling
.00 each additional LP
FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $5.00 postage for first -3 LPs,
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPT. H„ BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703)745-2001

CANADIAN

&amp;

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

1

1

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
2.00
7.50
7.50
7.'5 0

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
$10.00
7.50
7.50
7.50

HJ

KJ

U

�RECORD REVIEWS
DEE AND

DELTA
HICKS:

BALLADS

Cumberland Plateau

or the Hicks family
itself. There are several rare songs here,

AND
BANJO
MUSIC
FROM THE
TENNESSEE

unusual and infrequently collected songs
interest, but academic
scholarly

of

considerations are not what make this
such a good record. From start to finish
this record is full of great music well

CUMBERLAND
PLATEAU

performed.

County 789
The

Lulu/Ketter

Shout
Constant
Lather

"The Fox Chase," the opening cut of

Chase/Poor

Fox

and

Calvary's

Man's

Song/

Gun/Man

of

Sorrow/Lone Cow Trail/
Shave/He Who Died on

Mountain/In

the

Pines/

Young Johnny Sailed from London/The
Sea

Fowl/Susie Girl/Lily of the West/
Buck/The Lost Gander/The

Hairy

Vulture
In

my collection of records there

are

a

few albums that I listen to regularly.
They seem to provide some obscure
musical nutrient I require, and so I
constantly return to them. Most of these
records are collections of field record
ings, home music not really intended for
commercial use. John Cohen's High
Atmosphere collection is one of them, as

collections of Hammons
family music, and the magnificient Ed
Haley homecut discs issued by Rounder
some years back. Another record, the
are the two fine

most

recent, is Dee and Delta Hicks:
Ballads
and
Music From
the
Banjo
Tennessee Cumberland Plateau.
The late Dee Hicks and his wife Delta
lived in Fentress County, Tennessee,
the heart of the

in

Cumberland Plateau. It's

many ways: the
with
sandstone
cliffs, the valleys dotted with abandoned
fields, and coal towns withering in these
waning days of the mining industry; a
beautiful country for all this, but a little
a

lonely

mountains

country

in

crowned

melancholy to the traveler passing
through for the first time. The modern

age has not completely swallowed the
Cumberland Plateau; evidence of earlier
days survives in architecture, in signs

along the roads, in the music of Dee and
Delta Hicks themselves.
Ballads and Banjo Music presents a
good overview of Dee and Delta's large
and
very interesting repertoire, the
sources of which range from very old
ballads to music specific to the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the album,

is

singing style.

a

good showcase for Dee's

The

rise

and

fall

of the

melody line and Dee's easy ornamenting

of passages evoke the sounds of the hunt,
the call of the horn, the baying of the
hounds. Dee's understated delivery of
songs is a pleasure to hear. "Ketter Gun,"
a
song composed by his father, and
"Lather and Shave" are both humorous
pieces. Dee makes no big plays for laughs
here, but lets the humor in the songs
speak for itself. No more is necessary.
Likewise, "The Vulture," a macabre and
from
the
unsettling piece derived
Hutchinson family singing troupe of the
mid- 19th century, is sung with a quiet

confidence

that

underscores

the

disturbing subject of the song.
Delta

fine but very different kind of
has all the reserve of a
firecracker, singing her very effective

singer.

is

a

She

"Man of Constant Sorrow" with brass
authority. Her "Lily of the West" is

and

volatile. Bobby Fulcher's detailed and
interesting notes to the album indicate
Delta's preference for songs with lots of
action. She surely can sing them.
The icing on this cake is Dee's banjo
playing. When I play this record for
friends they invariably ask "What is he
doing?" and "How does he do it?" I don't
know either, but Dee's banjo style, so

removed

from the mainstream
clawhammer
playing of today, is
wonderful. "Shout Lulu" is a strange and
pleasingly rough-hewn song at one time
common throughout east Tennessee;

and another banjo piece, "Susie Girl," is
narrative comic song of the "Ginger
Blue" variety. My favorites on the banjo
are the fine "In the Pines" and Dee's
a

lonesome and ethereal "Lost Gander,"
one of the finest banjo solos to be heard
on any planet.
This record had so much going for it:
substantial music, good sound quality

(for

a

record

of

this

kind),

and

informative notes that give the reader

insights into the lives of the
musicians. Bobby Fulcher, who has done
the research for this and other records
from the Cumberlain Plateau,
and
County Records deserve a lot of praise
and credit.
If you've been raised exclusively on
real

the hot string bands of past and present,
this sort of music may seem very

unfamiliar at first listening. Neverthe
less, whether you come to it looking for
new material to learn, or merely to listen
and enjoy, this album has a tremendous
amount to offer, as did Dee and Delta

themselves. (Craig Johnson)
To order: County Records,
191, Floyd, VA 24091

P.O.

Box

�throughout many parts of the world.
Their reputation for a quality show of
traditional and contemporary clogging is

renowned.
Although the individual
members have varied throughout the
group's 17-plus years, their dedication
to old-time music and dance has not.
Through the Ears is a fine combination
of music and dance. The LP contains 15
selections recorded live in the Clogger's
home state in North Carolina. The
difficult job of recording both music and

dancing live was handled well, and the
sound quality is very good. Some 9 cuts
are strictly music, 5 contain both music
and clogging, and one just rhythmic feet.
The Smokey Valley Boys deliver 3
tunes played in their usual strong
fashion. Paul Sutphin adds his grand
voice to 2 of their numbers. "I Have No
Mother" features the fine singing of
Suzanne Edmundson and Carol
Elizabeth Jones. I wish the record
contained another by these two. The
Luke Smathers String Band renders a
nice cut in their mountain swing style as
does John Lilly in his own "A Little
Yodel Goes A Long Way." I especially
liked "Candy Girl," which spotlights
Bruce Molsky on fiddle with Andy
Deaver providing the rhythmic feet. This

selection goes right to the heart of the
album
good old-time fiddle music and
dancing just naturally go together.
"Cheatham County Rag" is a bit of a
disappointment for it doesn't show

Ralph Blizard at his
fiddler in the style
Smith, and this cut
intonation trouble.

"Moonshine

on

Hills" is
standard.
If

you're

more
a

best. Blizard is a fine
of the late Arthur

has some tuning or

His backup fiddling
in the North Carolina
up to his usual high

fan of clogging, or if you're

just looking for an album that has

a

nice

variety of good old-time music, then you
will want Through the Ears. Remember,
"the ear bone is connected to the foot
bone.
(Dale Morris)
To

order:

Rounder

Records,

186

Willow Ave., Somerville, MA 02144.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�many audiences-- not only on those
two northern coasts, but in the land in
between and the Upper South as well.
Mark is a bit of an '80s renaissance
man, as he is a virtuoso on the French
harp, a fine singer of traditional songs, a
composer of poignant social satire, a
and
a
blower,
glass
composer of

humorous ditties. His originals often
parodies

of traditional

material.

are

In his

he has played Irish concertina,
harmonica, and old-time fiddle.
This album dwells on his old-time

past,

harmonica

instrumentals

and

his

original songs. It is hard to sit still during
the duets of Mark's harmonica
and
Stefan Sender's banjo on "Mississippi
Sawyer" and "New River Train." Fiddler
Chad Crumm joins them for a rousing
"Lost Indian." As if that wasn't enough,
Mark shows some of the chops he's

copped
Parham,

from
and

DeFord

countless

"Piedmont
Blues"
and
Whiskey /Fiddler a Dram."

Bailey,

Red

others on
"Kentucky

But his harmonica is only half the
show. Mr. Graham tackles some weighty
and unusual subjects with his songs:

transsexualism

"Rufus and Beverly,"
"Veal Life Blues,"
cruelty
evolution parts one and two in "Big
Band" and "Their Brains," and much
animal

in

in

more. The arrangements on his originals
vary, from the traditional forms one
might have encountered from Fiddlin'
John Carson, Blind Alfred Reed, or

Golden

Harris,
through a more
sound
on
the two selections
progressive
on which the Horseflies back him, to the
futuristic jazz flavor when Matt Glaser
the lineup.
Mark's music has many facets. He

is

in

sure

is

to many,
but it is
appeal
inevitable that some listeners may not
like the whole album. Strict tradition
alists may shy from some of the more
avant-garde arrangements or from the
unusual subjects of certain songs. I
would guess, though, that most every
one would be moved to at least a chuckle
or chortle by some of his clever word
to

plays: "I can see your aura and it's
ugly. ..all of the goodness in you is gone,
you are darkness with no dawn/ either
that or you are eating too much meat," or
"with a negative IQ, you'll be lonely, sad,
and blue/oh, life is hard but life is

hardest when you're dumb." Those who
have seen Mark perform in the past
couple of years know that he is still
writing fine songs, singing those good
old ones, and playing hot old-time
harmonica. Maybe by the time we've
worn these grooves out he'll grace us
with another album (Kerry Blech)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

To order: Front Hall

Rd., P.O. Box 307,

12186

Records, Wormer
Voorheesville, NY

�CASSETTE
TAPES
STAND BAYOU
Lacassine Special/La Valse De

Rosa/

Bal/Rainbow Waltz/Enterre

Ete Au

J'ai

La

Pon Pon

Moi Pas/Cajun Crawl/Bayou

Waltz/Two Step
Special/Napoleon's
De Midland/Reno Waltz/Baby Please
Don't Go/La Porte D'en Arriere
harmonica, and
Enoch-guitar &amp; vocals; Bob
Smakula-fiddle; Ellen Smedley-triangle.
Brad

Smedley-accordian,

vocals;

Kevin

interesting phenomenon has been
happening in many of our urban centers
over the past decade. A lot of the people
interested in various forms of traditional
music who once traveled to Tommy
Jarrell or to Fred Cockerham to learn
music are now going to
old-time
Louisiana to visit Dewey Balfa, Dennis
McGee, Wade Fruge, Boisec Ardoin,
An

and others to learn Cajun
music.
have
individuals
of these
Many
formed bands-- "Bayou" seems to be
the most popular word to stick in the
band's name. Witness How's Bayou
from Seattle, OK Bayou from Vermont
and Virginia, Bayou Seco from New
Mexico, and now Cleveland's Stand
These bands have much in
Bayou.
common. They are all good, they all have
the burning desire to play this music,
they have gone to Louisiana, they have
impassioned vocals.

Marc Savoy,

Stand

formed

Bayou

around

accordianist Smedley, who has diligently
practiced over the years, listening to Iry
Lejeune,

Lawrence

He has also
vocal style, and it
rest.

Walker,

developed
is

and all the
a

plaintive

the singing that really

moves Cajun fans. The rhythm moves
feet

the

and

the

agony

of the

singer

moves the heart.
danced to this band more than two
years ago, and they were quite dance
able then. They now cook. They have
also done a nice job of blending the
standards with more
most-requested
I

pieces on this tape. "Cajun
from
the Hackberry Ramblers,
Crawl,"
is one of my all-time favorites. It remains
somewhat of a rarity since it is a
harmonica showpiece, but Smedley does
it
well.
especially like the band's
treatment of "La Porte D'en Arriere."

obscure

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

D.
L.
Menard's
have
taken
They
warhorse and breathed new melodic life
into it without going too far out. This is a

band,
very traditional-sounding
reminiscent of the early Balfa Brothers
records, with a solid rhythm section and

fiddle
and
the
leads
alternate
by
accordian. There seems to be a fais do-do
a-brewing on the Cuyahoga delta, and
Stand Bayou will be there. (Kerry Blech)

Goose Acres, 2715 Cornell
Cleveland, OH 44106
To order:

old

time friends

�Bogtrotters

fiddlers,

played

one great

tune after another, almost all of which
were of Midwestern origin and entirely
unknown to me. 1 enjoyed that night,
and I've enjoyed the Bogtrotters'

tape

as

well.
The

Volo Bogtrotters are Chirps
Smith, fiddle; Fred Campeau, fiddle and
banjo;

Steve

Rosen,

and

banjo

mandolin; Jim Nelson, guitar; and Tony
Scarimbolo on bass. All of them sing,
and vocal numbers figure prominently
on this tape.

Bogtrotters wear a number of
hats comfortably.
Although
they play fast and quite rhymically, their
The

musical
fiddle

intricate and don't
to skeletal melodies
plugged into repeated rhythmic patterns.
This contrasts well with the highly
percussive banjo playing, steady bass
lines

are

confine themselves

and

underpinning,

rolling

guitar

passages that characterize the band's
music. Their musical sources are diverse,
ranging from 78 rpm records to the
tunes of older Midwestern players as
well as newly composed pieces.
The tape opens with "Money Creek,"
Fred
composition, a
Campeau's
performance that bursts upon the
listener like a fanfare of trumpets and
This is the
roars
along thereafter.
Bogtrotter's pace. It works to great
advantage on the instrumental cuts in
particular. A lot of interesting things
happen: varied and inventive banjo
parts, some slinky guitar playing, and
striking chordal sounds in the fiddle
parts.

All

well

are

showcased

by

engineers Flawn Williams's lucid mix.
Of the tunes, "Rollin' River," "Cora
Dye," "Litchfield," and Lotus Dickey's
were
"White
River Bottom"
my
favorites.
This powerful dance-band sound
doesn't work quite as well with some of
the songs. "Cotton Eye Joe," "Johnson
Gals," and "Shady Grove," all pieces
with somewhat incidental lyrics, fare
well with this treatment, but "Salty
Dog," "How Long," and "Bully of the

Town," though

well sung and solidly

bounce, rasp, and
source
of
performance on
slipperiness
78s by the likes of Sam and Kirk McGee,
played,

lack

the

and the Skillet
the Cofer Brothers,
Lickers. Notable exceptions are "Don't
You Hear Jerusalem Moan" and "Texas
Rangers," both led by Chirps Smith,
whose
more deliberate
pacing and
rough-hewn delivery stand out as my
favorite vocal performances of the tape.
The Bogtrotters are as inventive vocally
"Sail Away Ladies"
as instrumentally.
features unusual and interweaving vocal
lines, and the harmonies throughout the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tape are strong and assured.
I've played this tape repeatedly,

a

practice I reserve for few recordings.
Some cuts I like better than others, some
things I might change were it my business
to change them, but above and beyond
this, the Volo Bogtrotters have

a very
fine tape, a tape that
their
considerable
enthusiasm,
displays
strength, and talents. (Craig Johnson)

produced

To order: 3740 N. Janssen, Chicago, IL

60613.

�CAJUN MUSIC
Reflection of

A

by

a

Ann Allen Savoy

People, Vol.

1

(Bluebird Press)
This is a gem of a book, and in the four
short years since its publication, it has
already become a classic. It is a compre

hensive and complete story-- musically,
historically, and visually--of the people
of southwest Louisiana, as told through
interviews with some of the most
influential musicians, the songs, the
essays by the author, the discography,
and the photos.
Ann
Allen Savoy grew up in
Richmond, Virginia, and adopted the
Cajun way of life when she married Marc

Savoy in 1977. Marc's music store and
accordian
factory, the Savoy Music
Center, in Eunice, was already esta
blished as a gathering place for local
musicians and music lovers The need
for a book of this sort soon became
apparent to Ann, and she began docu
menting the Cajun way of life with her
camera, tape recording interviews, and
transcribing songs with the help of a few
friends (until she learned how to do it
herself). All of these elements come to
beautifully because of Ann's
gether
heartfelt compassion for the people and
the music.
I love this
book and have read parts of
it over and over. Some of the interview
segments are priceless, and even as I
write this review I get sidetracked into
the book. For instance, Ann asks Dennis
McGee, great nonogenarian fiddler and
recording artist since 1929, "Do you like
music more than other things in life?"
Yes, I like music more than anything. I
love my wife a lot but I also love my
music a lot." The reproduced newspaper
articles, the first-hand remembrances by
friends and relatives of the musicians,
the fantastic photos by Ann as well as the
old ones from the Library of Congress
and the musicians' photo albums, all add
up to make this book a treasure. A good
amount of the book is in Cajun French
(the songs of course, and part of the

The

interviews).

French

is

well

translated, and in the case of the songs,
also put into Ann's own version of easy-

to-read-and-pronounce phonetics.

Ann, mother of four, wife, musician,

performer,

writer,

researcher,

co

for the Library Theater in
Eunice, and friend to many, is working
on Volume 2 and 3 of Cajun Music. If
you love Cajun music and culture, or if
you are simply fascinated by the course

ordinator

of history and
French language
want to take

Louisiana,

the

evolution of the

Louisiana,
vicarious
this book belongs
in

or if

a

trip
in

you
to

your

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

library. It can be ordered by writing to
the author at P.O. Box 941, Eunice, LA

70535.
$40.00

$29.00
for

postage in the
(Jeanie McLerie)
of

for

clothbound

or

hardbound includes the price
U.S.

and

Canada.

Artists and record companies
please send records and tapes for
review to The Old-Time Herald,
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333.

�DON'T
FORGET
TO RENEW
YOUR SUBSCRIPTION
for another
WONDERFUL YEAR
of the

OLD-TIME HERALD
&amp;

Tell Your Friends About Us

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Thanks

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Xo

L3
V.1

#4

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12117">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 1, Number 4 (Summer 1988)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12118">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12119">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 4 (May-July 1988)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘Musical Sculpture’: The Heartbeats,” by Hilary Dirlam &amp;amp; Linda Higgenbotham&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Robert ‘Bud’ Garrett,” by Anne Romaine&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Fields Ward,” by John Coffey&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Roanoke Country Radio from 1924-1954,” by Kip Lornell&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues In Old-Time Music – Old-Time and Bluegrass: Bridging the Gap,” by Art Menius&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Flatfooters at Mabry Mill,” by Tina Hicks&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Iowa,” by Susan Brown&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Old-Time Music Notes From Birmingham,” by Joyce Cauthen&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – West Virginia’s Old-Time Music Scene,” by Margo Blevin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Knowing Fields Ward In His Later Years,” by Paul Brown&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Fields Ward (Poem),” by Betsy Rutherford Coffey&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2100">
        <name>1988</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5480">
        <name>Anne Romaine</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5485">
        <name>Art Menius</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5489">
        <name>Beth Rutherford Coffey</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5481">
        <name>Fields Ward</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5476">
        <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5482">
        <name>John Coffey</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="3510">
        <name>Joyce Cauthen</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5483">
        <name>Kip Lornell</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5478">
        <name>Linda Higgenbotham</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5488">
        <name>Margo Blevin</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5413">
        <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5415">
        <name>Paul Brown</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5479">
        <name>Robert “Bud” Garrett</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5487">
        <name>Susan Brown</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5477">
        <name>The Heartbeats</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5486">
        <name>Tina Hicks</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2512" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3437">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/8f4426abaeb0134abaa6c404b759000b.pdf</src>
        <authentication>62984b7a03b46402eb11c75464847bbc</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12138">
                    <text>THE OLD-TIME

HERALD

VOLUME

13, NUMBER 12

$5.00

THEM
MAKE

MAKE

HAPPY- SCOTT BOATRIGHT

SAD

AND

THEN
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FESTIVAL AND CAMP GUIDE

2015

�KITCHEN CULTURE ARTISTS

Toby Rodriguez, chef
Bryan Kyzer, chef
The Revelers, music
Corey Porche, dance

One summer that can
change your life...

VOICE WORKS ARTISTS

Cathy Jordan
Cedric Watson

Jennifer Scott
Elizabeth LaPrelle
Pharis Romero
Miguel Govea and Susan Pena
Pamela Bertoli
Casey MacGill
Moira Smiley
Eli West
Laurel Bliss
Caleb Klauder and Reeb Willms

Kitchen Culture
May 6-10

once-a-year gathering featuring the artists, music, food, and dance of a specif
region of the world. In 2015 we celebrate the unique culture and heritage of
the Cajun community from Southwest Louisiana.
A

ic

j

Voice Works

June 23-28

Learn to sing harmony, vintage country duets, classic jazz, swing, how to find
third part, traditional Mexican music, Appalachian ballads, Irish folk songs,
mountain gospel, honky-tonk songs, bluegrass, and much more.

a

FIDDLE TUNES ARTISTS
Lee Sexton and Johnny Sexton
Vesta Johnson with Steve Hall
Billy Baker with Jack Hinshelwood

Pedro Dimas and family
Rodney Miller with Sandy Bradley
Kristian Bugge, Sonnich Lydom
and Morten Alfred Hoirup
Lisa Ornstein, Andre Marchand,
and Normand Miron

Fiddle Tunes

June 28-July

5

Suzy Thompson, Artistic Director

The Festival of American Fiddle Tunes provides an opportunity to be in
community with the bearers of fiddle traditions. You'll improve your skills,
discover culture through music, learn music in a cultural context, and build

lifelong relationships

in

the fiddle music community.

Brian Conway, Rose Conway Flanagan,

and Mark Simos
Kinnon and Betty Lou Beaton
Christine Balfa and friends
Frank Maloy and Mick Kinney

Ruthie Dornfeld
Jody Stecher

Milton Vanicor and more...

Port Worden State Park
Port Townsend, Washington

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Register Today

Centrum org

SAGE O ARTS
ARTS

VV

�I

www. Field
New

H

.com

recorder

Releases from the Field Recorders' Collective

CD

Section with Illegible Text

Howard Miller

Howard Miller (1912-1 990) of Ashe County, North
Sixty Years of North Carolina Fiddling (FRC706)
Carolina, was taught to fiddle by his father, Charles, and grandfather, Monroe Miller. These sessions establish Howard Miller as
prime interpreter of the G.B. Grayson repertoire and as a dynamic fiddler in his own right whose talent remained undiminished
through the years.

a

Albert Hash, Volume

2 (FRC707)
Albert Hash (1 91 7-1 983) was a beloved fiddler and instrument maker from Grayson
County, Virginia. This disc features Albert's takes on different old fiddle tunes as well as one of his early bands, The Virginia
Carolina Boys from their weekly radio show in the 960s. (See also FRC41 Albert Hash.)
1

1

Lee Stoneking
Missouri Fiddling and Banjo Playing (FRC708) Lee Stoneking (1907-1989) was among the best
fiddlers in west central Missouri. Lee began learning from his own father around the age of seven. These recordings, made on
a visit by Brad Leftwich, Linda
Higginbotham, and Kenny Jackson in 1985, include tunes not represented elsewhere, as well as

samples of his fine up-picking banjo style.
Rector Hicks Sugar in the Morning (FRC709) Rector Hicks, fiddler, was born in West Virginia and lived
These recordings include his unique versions of familiar tunes, rarely-heard hymns, waltzes, and marches, some
and two fine self-composed

H

Akron Ohio.

in
Ed

Haley pieces,

tunes.

Coming Soon: CDs featuring Dean Sturgill, Alleghany County Fiddlers, Maggie Hammons Parker, Craig Johnson

others/]

&amp;

FULL CATALOG LISTING
Alden

Ray

Ray's Dream FRC1

1

5

John Ashby &amp; the Free State Ramblers

Walter Babson FRC31

in

the 1960s FRC609

Addie Leffew &amp; Claude Wolfenbarger
FRC509

1

966 FRC31

Harolc'

Balfa Brothers &amp; Nathan Abshire
i t p|Qi,inc
jont
Bievins

FRC1

ppri
pku i 7
1

earner cariton eku
Ernie Carpenter

Cockerham

Banjo

Bill

1

[ff
Unc'e

i

FRC101

1

FRC1 03

Clyde Davenport Vol. 2 FRC1 04
Reverend Gary Davis FRC1 16
Dixie Hummingbirds

1

2

FRC707

Vol

1

FRC1

1

9

FRC700

FRC709
Charlie Higgins, w
Wade Ward &amp; Dale

rrHhick,s

The Indian

FRC208

You can order via our

FRC604

RaeV

Delta Boys FRC607

Hilltoppers

Buddy Thomas FRC303
Unjon Grwe %9 FRC1

Musicians of Clay &amp; Calhoun
Counties FRC202

FRC201

WV

Transition (Round Peak) FRC1 02

FRC211

Band

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

2

FRC212

Round Peak Vol.

Ward Jarvis FRC402

in

FRC1 09

M

Round Peak Vol.2 FRC1 10

gl

Lee

S

Sexton FRC1 05

Lonnie Seymour

2

1

$1 5

each

III

FRC403

or credit cards. To order via US mail,
CD,

send

a

$20 each DVD

Mail.

Jimmy Wheeler FRC401
Aunt Jenny Wilson FRC408
Virgil

Anderson

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FRC1

005

Clyde Davenport FRC1 004
Roan Mt Hilltoppers FRC1 002
Clyde &amp; Ralph Troxell FRC1 003

check

M

Jf

Field Recorders' Collective, 6206 Washington Street, Ravenna, OH 44266

THE OLD-TIME

4

Wade Ward FRC507

Ross County Farmers FRC307

1

website and pay using PayPal

^£5!^

RC1

Mountain

Roan

FRC31 0

Dan Tate FRC506

FRC203

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

Santford Kelly FRC503
Fiddling Van Kidwell FRC41

John Summers

Dink Roberts FRC209

made payable to the Field Recorders' Collective to the address below.
PLUS $5 for 1st Class

The Nee Ningy Band FRC610
The Plank Road String Band FRC606
Cecil Plum FRC404
'
Ola Belle Reed

FRC205

Corbett Stamper FRC306
Lee Stoneking FRC708

Renegades FRC605
Vemon Ridd|e FRa 2Q

FRC1 07

Creek

FRC505

Meyers FRC504
Howard Miller FRC706

p|urrjcane Rjdgerunners

Cornett FRC304

Clyde Davenport Vol.

Kilby Snow

Hausenfluck

Esker Hutchins

2

Sidna &amp; Fulton

Horse F|ies FRC602

FRC204

1

FRC608

Chirps Smith

FRC405

Poe FRC501

The Chicken Chokers FRC603
Fred

1

Arnold Sharp FRC406
Shelor Blackard Family FRC1

FRC1 06

Manco Sneed, Byard Ray &amp; Mike Rogers

Hellbenders

Dewev Balfa FRC207

Wagoner Families

Dennis McGee &amp; Sady Courville FRC308
Marcus Martin FRC502

Albert Hash, Volume

2

&amp;

FRC601

George FRC407

Altiert Hash FRC41

Dock Boqqs FRC305
Boons

Kimble

FRC302

Jeff Goehring
John Hannah

Heywood Blevins FRC508
Dock

FRC301

2

Frank

3

Bell FRC410

Berkeley

1

Norman Edmonds Vol.
Galax Gems FRC309

FRC108

P.T.

Norman Edmonds Vol.

HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG

The Field

Recorders'
c collective
VOLUME

13,

NUMBER

12

1

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Scott Boatright circa 1922, courtesy of the Boatright family.
Cover design by Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group, Greensboro, NC

Printed at Sutherland Printing, Montezuma,

IA,

www.sutherlandprinting.com

�Letters
Profanity
just opened and glanced through my
copy
Herald Volume 13,
13.
copy of the Old-Time Herald
Number 11. 1 was appalled and disgusted
with the filthy words used in the article
didn't
"Everyone Sounded Different."

I

I

read through the entire article and I don't
plan to do so. As a matter of fact I was so

disgusted that
now.

If

I

laid the issue aside

this is the type of language

you plan to publish,
my subscription

to

I

wish

discontinue

your publication.

have been involved
music for over 60 years.
I

to

for

that

with old-time
have worked
keep this music alive and
I

hard trying to
to help instill it into our younger genera
tions. I am very pleased with the number
of youngsters in our area that have be
come involved. I am now seeing the most
interest and talent that I have ever seen.
I don't
think that we need to use filthy
language in putting our music across.
don't know what else I can say to you

I

except that

I

hope you will do whatever

you can to correct this situation and to
change your direction in the future.
Herb Key

Wilkesboro, North Carolina

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here &amp; There
The Lanesboro Barn Dance

at the

Sons of

Norway Hall in Lanesboro, Minnesota,
continues in its 21st season with Bob Doug
las and Roy Pilgrim and Aviva
er on April 11; July 11 with A.

Steigmey

Srubas
and Rina Rossi; August 13 with Dot Kent
and Chirps Smith; and September 12 with
Cathv Mosher and Lee Guthrie.
The 17th Annual

J.

Bluff Country Gath

ering will be May 14-17

in Lanesboro,
Minnesota. There will be workshops on
fiddle, banjo, guitar, mandolin, singing,
clogging, and square dance calling for

The Friday concert
barn dance are open to
the public. For further information visit

registered

students.

and Saturday

boveeheil.com

or call (507)

498-5452.

Spring Rally of the American
Banjo Fraternity will take place at the
Allenberry Resort in Boiling Springs,
The

23, 2015. The
Pennsylvania, May 21
event is devoted to post-minstrel nylonstrung five-string banjo music, as played
in the late 19th and early 20th

centuries.

The Fall Rally, also
is

for

at Allenberry Resort,
October 15-17. Visit ban-

planned
jofraternity.org for updates.
Music-related events will take place
throughout the Crooked Road region of

Southwest Virginia June 12 20 during
Mountains of Music Homecoming.

the

Organizers write that the nine-day, multisite festival will include "concerts at the
legendary Carter Family Fold at the foot
of Clinch Mountain, exhibits at the Ralph
Stanley and Birthplace of Country Music
Museums, classes in flatfoot dance, semi
nars on traditional music, and long-run
ning community jam sessions at places
like the Floyd Country Store, where visi
tors are encouraged to bring their own
instruments and join in. Each evening,
festival-goers can choose from two to four
Crooked Road concerts in different com
munities in the region." Details about per
formers and venues will be published this

at mbisofmusic.com.
singing workshop, "The Cool of the
Day: Group Singing in Sacred Places,"
will be held July 5
10 in Elkins, West
Hosts
Michael
and Carrie Kline
Virginia.
ancient
ballads
and tradi
write, "Sing

spring
A

tional

outdoor

Appalachian

songs

In

between May 3 and May 31 costs $195.
Visit folktalk.org/ events.html for details,

Association (MSOTFA)

or call (304)

recordings,

mining songs. Early registration
(by May 3) costs $185, and registration

Events

in

dramatic

settings in the Monongahela
National Forest." Activities will include
learning to sing harmony lines, hearing
stories of singers' lives, and singing tradi
tional and classic country songs, as well

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

print, online

as coal

636-5444.
The Gail Heil Memorial Fiddle Contest
will be held Saturday July 18 at the Com
munity Center in Lanesboro, Minnesota.
Details will be announced at boveeheil.
com. ("Strictly old-time fiddling.")
The Grand Targhee Ski Resort in
Alta, Wyoming, will be the setting for
the Targhee Music Camp, August 3
6. The camp will offer instruction in

mandolin, guitar, fiddle, bass, singing,
banjo, and songwriting. Visit targheemusiccamp.com for details. Following
the 29th Annual Grand Tar
ghee Bluegrass Festival will take place
the camp,

August 7-9.

4

7

in the

a

Ameri

can Roots Music Program

at Rocky Ridge
Music Center in Estes Park, Colorado.

Organizers write, "Join us for this fourday immersion in traditional Southern
music. The program combines private
and group tutorials in various five-string
banjo, guitar, fiddle, piano, and mando
lin styles with performances, panels, and
historical presentations. We welcome mu
sicians age 18 and over, from advancedbeginners to the most advanced levels."
(Participants the age of 18 are welcome
with an adult chaperon.) Registration
costs $785 (Denver Folklore Center pa
trons receive a $50 discount with the dis
count code DFC15). Visit rockyridge.org
for details and registration.
Bob Bovee will be appearing on April
10 at the Fayette Opera House, Fayette,
Iowa; Lacrosse Public Library on April
20;

Hartsburg Grand Theater on April

Maplewood (Minnesota) Library May
and Harkin

26;
5;

Store State Historical Site in

New Ulm, Minnesota on May 25. On June
10 Bob Bovee and Pop Wagner will play
Music in the Park in Spring Grove, Min
nesota, and on June 13 the duo will play
at Creek House in St. Paul, Minnesota.
In

Ashland, Oregon,

an

open old-time

jam takes place every Saturday night
from 5-7 PM, at Oberon's Tavern, or on
the

Missouri

Old-Time Fiddle

State

books,

is

now offering
items re

other

and

lated to Missouri's fiddling heritage

at

MSOTFA_Store
For a limited time,

missourifiddling.com
msotfa_store.html.

cassettes will cost only

$3

each.

Final Notes
Old-time musician and longtime Old-Time
Herald contributor Lyle Lofgren died in
August

2014.

Mary

DuShane

shares

her

memories of Lyle.
Lyle Lofgren's many friends and cohorts
old-time music will tell you of his in

in

Banjo player Stephen Wade will teach

workshop September

The

downtown plaza.

Congratulations
Kirkwood, Missouri, fiddler Vesta John
son received the Nashville Old Time Sh'ing
Band Association's Old Time Music Award.
The award was presented on March 5 at this
year's Breaking Up Winter gathering.

telligence
research

and curiosity, wide-ranging
interests, and prolific output

writer. Yet Lyle, the son of Swedishdairy farmers near Harris,
Minnesota, liked to say things like (about
learning to play the guitar), "A youth
as

a

American

spent hand-milking Holsteins gives me
the strength to squeeze the chords." He
said his love of music began before he
was born, because his mother hummed

all the time. He hummed throughout his
whole life, including his last day.
While studying physics and engineer
at the University of Minnesota, Lyle
teamed up with fellow student Bud Claeson to seek out old records with wonderful

ing

a gathering of the Folk Song
Society of Minnesota, he sang a Bascom La
mar Lunsford song, attracting the attention
of his future wife, Liz. They sought out the
only other person who regularly borrowed
Library of Congress musical material from
the public library, Willard Johnson. Soon,
along with Jon Pankake, then editor of the
Little Sandy Review, and Iris wife Marcia,
who lived in the neighborhood as well,
they were all learning old songs together.
They dubbed their group Uncle Willy and

old songs. At

tire Brandy Snifters, immortalized in the
mid-'60s Electra recording The String Band
Project, as well as on several recordings
they later produced on their own label,

Lak-O-Tone records.
The Brandy Snifters' long friendship
with Mike Seeger and the New Lost City
Ramblers began at one of the famous
parties following a Folk Song Society
concert. Liz says both groups would "lis
ten and listen and play the 78 records
and tapes over and over" to pick out the
words and would learn the songs, "not
simply imitating the recordings but in-

�terpreting the spirit of the music." They

advised the Guthrie Theater

in

Minne

apolis on producing concerts featuring
Southern source musicians such as Doc
Watson, Jean Ritchie, Libba Cotten, Rev
erend Gary Davis, Jesse Fuller, Mance
Lipscomb, Mississippi John Hurt, Roscoe
Holcomb, and Dock Boggs. Liz has great
stories and photographs from the postconcert parties, which you can see at
lizlyle.lofgrens.org. (The website, highly
recommended, also includes many enter
taining articles by Lyle.)

worked his whole career

Lyle

as an

en

gineer for Rosemount Engineering, de
veloping such techniques as measuring
the temperatures below the surface of the
moon, and writing articles on physics for
technical publications, yet always play
ing, singing, and writing about music.
He and Liz raised four boys: first Mark
and Ken from Liz's first marriage (Mark

says Lyle was

with kids,

a

a

great father, "wonderful

playful guy"), then their son

and then their adopted son Jona
than. Their adoption of Jonathan was the
Lee,

interracial adoption in Minnesota.
Lyle's many interests included reading
first
and

writing poetry, translating Swedish

the Ojibwe
re
Pankake
language, and,
seek
the
Snifters
to
vealed, taking
Brandy
bluebirds in the Minnesota River Valley,

poetry

to

English, learning
as

Marcia

plus cross-country skiing together and
attending Minnesota Orchestra concerts.
He loved many kinds of music, including
the Grateful Dead (we had a group sing
of the Garcia-Hunter song "Ripple" at his
memorial). For years he wrote a column
for the

monthly publication

of the

Min

nesota Bluegrass and Old Time Music
Association (MBOTMA) on "Remember
ing the Old Songs," advised and record
ed segments on old-time music for Phil

Nusbaum's long-running radio show in
Minneapolis called Bluegrass Saturday

Morning, and of course wrote articles and
reviews for the Old-Time Herald.
His last illness came on fast, and Liz
says he couldn't have had a better death,
with family and friends all around him,

singing and telling stories.

Mary DuShane

Fiddler Harold Luce, 96, of Chelsea, Vermont,
died on August 13, 2014. Adam Boyce shares
the

following remembrance.

Harold Luce was born in Chelsea, Ver
mont on October 11, 1918. His parents
were of modest means. The young Luce

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

grew up around the working landscape
of a farm in the valley of the First Branch
His education was
of the White River.
limited to what he received at the lo
cal one-room school, as well as what he
picked up for himself on his own.
The first time Harold was captivated
by the sounds of the fiddle was when he
was about five years old, listening to the
lively strains coming from a neighbor's
henhouse where a "junket" was taking
place. The young Luce was instructed
that he could not attend, yet he wanted
His older brother was tak
to so badly.
ing lessons to play the fiddle, but was

hardly as interested in the instrument
Almost as if he knew
as Harold was.
his own destiny, young Harold would
clamber onto the piano bench, reaching
for his brother's fiddle on top of the pi
ano, only to be tattled on by his sisters
at least for
and have to give up the idea

that moment. Later, a hired man at the
Luce farm who played the fiddle some
what would be allowed to take down the
fiddle, and he would, in turn, let young
Harold hold it and try to play it. The
hired man only knew how to play notes
on one string, moving his hand up and
down the fingerboard. Another hired
man later showed Harold that he didn't
need to slide his hand, but rather use all
four strings, keeping his hand in one po

sition.

Apparently Harold learned very

quickly, and his parents decided that he
should receive more formal training. His
first

lessons on the violin were about the

time he was 11; later, when he was 17, he
received some more lessons through a
WPA program from a violinist.
Largely, Luce taught himself to play,

A
picking up tunes he liked by ear.
him
a small Victrola with
neighbor gave
several records, and the young fiddler
would try to play along. Harold also
went to dances that were in the neigh
borhood, most of which were "kitchen
junkets", in which the tables and chairs
were moved out of the way, and a house
was transformed into a ballroom for an
evening. A well-known fiddler and con
tra dance prompter named Ed Larkin
played at these dances, and Luce would
listen intently to the old gent, trying on
his own to play the tunes he had heard.
Some of these dances were held at the
Sons of Union Veterans Hall at the south
end of Chelsea village.
Young Harold
was extremely bashful and didn't play
out in public. He would sneak into the

early, finding a convenient hiding
place behind the piano, where he could

hall

follow along with Larkin without being
discovered.
During the intermission,
Luce could sneak out to grab a doughnut
or some other goodies at the refreshment
table, then hightail it back to his hiding
place.
Eventually Harold would come
out and play with him. Harold got over

shyness, somewhat, and continued

his

to

play with Ed Larkin for dances.
When Harold Luce was 16, several im
Ed Larkin
portant things took place.
formed a group of contra dancers to carry
on the old-time dance tradition of the area,
Harold being one of the original members
chosen by Larkin, filling in as dancer or
fiddler as the occasion demanded. This
same year, 1934, Luce went to a kitchen

junket that Ed Larkin was supposed to be
at, but couldn't make. Harold filled in on
and during the course of the
when
the fellow who tried to do
evening,
the calling simply could not be heard or
the fiddle,

understood, Luce started calling out

the

while fiddling away, probably
he had observed Ed Larkin do himself.

changes
as

Quite an accomplishment for the young

Harold, which would be something he
would continue to do and gain much rec
ognition for in later years. At this same
junket, he met a young lady who would
later become his wife, Edith Keyes. The
two didn't speak to each other until four
years later, when Harold sent word with
someone to ask her to go with him to the
New Year's Ball at the Chelsea Town Hall.
The young couple won the prize for the
best dancing pair, and about a month lat
er, the two were married.
Harold and Edith began married life on
farm, eventually raising six children. In
between chores, Harold still found time to
Sometimes Luce would
play the fiddle.
home for a kitchen jun
at
someone's
play
ket, getting as much as three dollars for
the night's fiddling, more than he might
get working an entire day on the farm.
As time went on, Harold found fiimself
working two jobs at once to pay the medi
a

expenses of his son, Clayton, who had
contracted encephalitis. During this time,
cal

Luce got only about four hours of sleep
a
day, between the chores needing to be
done on the farm and the work at the
Cone-Blanchard machine shop in Windsor.

Clayton eventually recovered, and the rou

tine got somewhat easier for Harold.
In the 1930s, Luce got the idea to invent
that he could operate with his
a device
feet that

would play the piano, freeing up

play the fiddle, while he also
It was somewhat out
played a
of necessity, as piano accompaniment was

Iris

hands

to

harmonica.

�sometimes unavailable.

This same outfit
Harold used one winter at the Brookfield
Town Hall for dances, becoming a literal

calling dances and playing, though this
time for a much larger audience.
Tragedy struck tire fiddler in 1988. While

one-man-band,

operating a mowing machine, clearing the
roadside, Harold happened to sever two of
Iris fingers on Iris right hand, the result of
getting Iris hand mixed up with the powertake-off belt on tire back of the tractor. Un
daunted, Luce recovered through therapy,
and once again resumed playing the fiddle.
If it had been Iris left hand, his playing might
have ceased, though Harold himself said
that if it had been his left hand, he simply
would have taught himself to play with the
a truly remarkable testimony
other hand

where he fiddled, played

all at the
piano, and called the changes
same time. He also invented a similar de
vice that allowed him to play either gui
tar or banjo with his feet, along with the

fiddle and harmonica. Luce enjoyed cre
ating different "stunts" that he could do
while playing the fiddle, including doing
keel somersaults and rolling himself into
a blanket while he played "Pop! Goes the
Weasel." He has also been known to light
a
cigarette while playing the fiddle, even
though he never smoked a day in his life.
In 1940, Harold Luce played for the Ed
Larkin Contra Dancers when they went
to the New York World's Fair folk danc
ing competition. Ed Larkin was originally
to play and prompt, but got his thumb
jammed in a car trunk door. Larkin did

prompting while Harold fiddled, and
the group received the Award of Merit.
the

After Larkin passed away in 1954, Luce
was one of the mainstay fiddlers of the
Ed Larkin Contra Dance Group, but also
found time to dance with Edith. In 1964,
Harold played for the Ed Larkin Dancers
this
at another New York World's Fair
In addition to
time non-competitively.
playing for the Ed Larkin Dancers, Harold

played on his own for square dances and
other types of events. His reputation was
growing, and Luce was gaining legendary
status in his own area as an old-time dance
fiddler who played so smoothly and ef
fortlessly. Harold became involved with
the

newly-created Northeast Fiddlers' As
in the mid 1960s, helping to pre

sociation

serve and promote old-time fiddling. He
also joined the Southern Vermont Fiddlers
and the Champlain Valley Fiddlers,

enjoy

incredible, indomitable spirit.
Harold Luce performed in many events

to air

around New England, from dances to fu
nerals; from folk festivals to weddings;
from nursing homes, senior centers,
hospitals to prisons, barn raisings,

and
and

talent shows, as well as birthday and an
niversary parties. While he preserved the

traditional music of the region through
his playing, he also created a tradition and
style all his own. From tunes he heard Ed
Larkin play, such as "Soldiers'

Joy"

and

tunes he grew
as
such
"Always," "Penn
up listening to,
and
"Back
in the Saddle
sylvania Polka,"
a cultural trea
Harold
Luce
was
Again,"
sure and storehouse of music. He was the
example of how simple but sweet music
was once the only entertainment in rural
"Irish Wash-Woman,"

to

Vermont, and was as close as the neigh
bor's kitchen. Harold Luce was a dance

fiddler who played slowly enough so
people could keep up, yet lively enough
to set their toes to tapping.
Luce was also noted for his volunteering
Grange and as a driver for the stage
coach
driving many people to various
doctor appointments and such. His kind,

in the

monthly meetings
which fiddlers young and old keep the
tradition alive. Luce went to fiddle con

soft-spoken manner and his humorous, al

tests, usually placing very high with his
truly "old" style. Even though he didn't
consider himself a competitive fiddler, he
won many trophies at contests all over

Harold has long been recognized as a
cultural treasure by the state of Vermont,
and in 2004 he was the recipient of the
Governor's Heritage Award, through the
Vermont Folklife Center.
Could a five-year-old boy have ever re
alized the astounding level that he would
attain, or the incredible influence he
would have on countless others, some of
whom would come to him for lessons and
guidance in their own playing? Could
that boy have realized the admiration

ing the

or jam

sessions

at

New England.
In

staff

the early 1980s, Harold Luce was on
at the Pinewoods camp in Plymouth,

Massachusetts,

during American

Dance

and Music Week.

He was there just for
the week, returning the following year to
continue his residency, teaching the danc

learned so long ago, in addition
playing music with other artists from
all over the United States. Luce also went
to the Smithsonian Festival of American
Folklife in Washington, DC, once again
es he had
to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

most "rascally" side made him a favorite of
most anyone who met or knew him.

would gain for his simple
yet comprehensive repertoire? Could he
have realized that he would make such
an important contribution to the very
and respect he

thing he enjoyed so much? Could that
young fellow begin to imagine that he
would be noted and respected
just for
playing music for people to dance to?
Harold Luce continued his life-long in
terest in fiddling until he passed away on
August 13, 2014. He was an important
link to a vanishing past, and we are the
ones who are richer for having known
him and his playing.

Adam Boyce

Julia Mae Brown Mainer, old-time guitarist and
singer, died on January 21, 2015. The North

Carolina native and long-time resident of Michi
gan was a performing musician for over seventy

years. Beginning her career as Hillbilly Lillie,
she was best known in later years as the musi

husband, banjo player and Na
tional Heritage Award recipient Wade Mainer.
Wade said of Julia, in an inteivieiv quoted in
Dick Spottswood's 2010 book Banjo On the

cal partner of her

Mountain:

Wade

Mainer's

First

Hundred

Years, "[Julia's is]
beautiful voice, don't ever
hear nobody else sing with a voice like she sings
"
with. Julia Mainer was 96 years old. Jim Grif
a

fith contributed the following remembrance.
I heard Julia Mainer's voice
was on the Wade Mainer King LP Soidful
Gospel Songs, where she sang "My Soldier
Boy" and "Streamlined Religion." Typi
cally for this modest, self-effacing wom
an, her solos were uncredited on the LP.
Her voice, however, was unforgettable,
and I finally learned who she was.
Born Julia Mae Brown, Ms. Mainer per
formed over WSJS in Winston-Salem,
North Carolina, as "Hillbilly Lillie" be
tween 1935 and 1937, the year she mar

The first time

ried the well-known
player Wade Mainer.
from music while she
five children together,

singer and banjo
She then retired
and Wade raised

moving

to

Michi

gan in the meantime. When Wade retired
from his job at the Ford Factory they be
gan recording and playing at festivals to
gether, with Julia providing solid guitar
backup to her husband's banjo.
Julia also sang duets with Wade, and
every show featured at least one solo
by Julia. A deeply religious woman, she

specialized in gospel songs, bringing
them a powerful voice reminiscent

to

of

such great singers as Molly O'Day. One of
her specialties was to adapt the recitation
style made famous by the Golden Gate
Quartet, and nobody who has heard her
rendition of "Jonah" will easily forget the
experience. For those who are fortunate
enough to have known Julia Mainer, it

�may be her shy smile, gracious manners,
genuine neighborliness, and generosity
that will be even harder to forget.
Jim Griffith

Lester

McCumbers

passed

on

away

January 26, 2015 at the age of 93. He was
born in 1921, deep in the hills of Calhoun

County, West Virginia. His wife Linda
was two weeks older, and they grew up
together, walking a few miles to Beech
Grove School every day. Lester and Lin
da got married in 1937, when they were
both 16 years old, and spent their lives
together raising nine children and mak
ing a living. When Linda passed away in
2010, they had been married 73 years.
Lester learned to play the guitar when
just a young boy, and later played with
local fiddlers French Carpenter, Ward
Jarvis, and others. He was about 15 years
old when he started learning a few fiddle

tunes from his father, Henry Franklin

Mc

Cumbers.

Playing the fiddle became a
of
Lester's life, and he played
large part
nearly every day. "I just don't feel right if I
don't play a tune or two every day. Music
gives me a lot of satisfaction in my heart.
I've always tried to play the fiddle or sing
a
song to suit myself and the way I feel it,"
Lester said in an interview that appeared
in the Spring 2004 issue of Goldenseal.
In the mid-1960s,
Lester and Linda
played in a bluegrass band with their
sons Roger, Bill, and Tim, along with
their son-in-law Paul Cottrell. They called
themselves Lester McCumbers and the
Sandy Valley Boys, and hosted a radio

show on WSPZ radio in Spencer, West
Virginia. The 30-minute shows were live
on the air every Saturday afternoon

and

featured many local musicians.
After their son Roger passed away in
1998, the Sandy Valley Boys disbanded,
and Lester and Linda began playing with
Braxton County old-time banjo player
Carroll Hardway, with whom they played

until his death in 2002. After that, Lester
and Linda continued to play and sing at
festivals around West Virginia with oldtime banjo player Kim Johnson, and were
often joined by their sons Bill and Tim.
Even though Lester and Linda's mu
sic was known across the country and

around the world, they mostly played
local festivals within a few miles of their
home. It was a big deal for Lester to trav

Virginia and play at the Richmond
Folk Festival in 2009, and also for him to
make a trip to Tennessee for the Breaking
Up Winter gathering in 2012.
el to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Their favorite festival of all was the
West Virginia Folk Festival at Glenville,
where Lester made many friends and
won many blue ribbons at fiddle contests
over the years.
In 2004, Lester became the first West Vir
ginian to win the first place blue ribbon in
the fiddle contest at the Appalachian String
Band Festival at Clifftop, West Virginia.
In 2005, Lester was the recipient of the

it in you. He often stated,
"Some folks are dancers, some are 'musicaners,' and some just ain't got it." He
belied those feelings, though he was al

Lester meant a great deal to me. I had
played music with Wilson Douglas for

As they say, the rest is history. There are
those of us who believe that Robert's

Vandalia Award presented by the West
Virginia Division of Culture and His
tory. Each year, the Vandalia Award, the
state's highest folklife honor, is present
ed to recognize lifetime contributions to
West Virginia's folk culture.

didn't have

ways encouraging everyone to get on the
dance floor and "give it a try."
Kobert had been dancing all his life,
and by 1978, he had won almost every

flatfoot dance contest at fiddlers conven
tions in Western North Carolina and East
Tennessee. That was the year that Robert
was "discovered"
when the old-time
band
the
Cork
Lickers invited the
string
Green Grass Cloggers to Slagle's Pasture
in Elizabethton, Tennessee, to come check
out the best dancer they had ever seen.

many years, and after he passed on in 1999,
I was
at loose ends and was
looking for
to
with
when
I visited Les
somebody
play

Dotson's

ter at his

three-finger banjo style has had on banjo
picking, and that Doc Watson's flatpicking has had on guitar playing. It was
only in his last decade that Robert finally
began to have a small inkling of the role
he played in reviving and maintaining
an interest in flatfoot dancing.
A Celebration of Life was held for Robert
on January 17th in Boone. Old-time music
was played by his friends Cecil Gurganus,
Trevor McKenzie, and Gordy Hinners,
with singing by Debra Jean, Randy, and
Kelly Sheets. Robert's beautiful wooden

home

in

Nicut one day in 2001.

Lester liked the sound we made and decid
ed that it would work out fine if we played
together. I definitely appreciate the fact
that I have struck the mother lode of West
Virginia fiddling by being lucky enough to
have known and played with both Wilson
Douglas and Lester McCumbers.
Lester McCumbers was a great friend and
a wonderful
guy to know. Lester was talent
ed at fixing just about anything that needed
fixing. Fishing was always one of his most
favorite things to do, and he was known for
catching many muskies. He told many fas
cinating stories, and generously shared his
music with all. I miss him very much.
Kim Johnson

Robert Lee Dotson of Sugar Grove, North
Carolina, stepped off the dance floor of life
on Tuesday, January 13, at the age of 91.
Robert was a farmer all his life, and
he

continued

a

tradition

of

old-time

passed down
through generations. He was the source
for the "Walking Step," an intricate flatfoot dance step that members of the
Green Grass Cloggers and Fiddle Pup
pets adapted and shared worldwide. He
and his late wife Myrtle garnered many
dance ribbons and trophies in their trav
els together, including the 1994 North
Carolina Heritage Award.
Robert was born on May 13, 1923, near
the banks of Cove Creek, west of Boone
in Watauga County. He was the oldest
of eight children born to Don and Bina
Hicks Dotson. Both sides of his family
were dancers, and Robert firmly believed
that you were either born with it, or you
folk and flatfoot dancing

"Walking

Step"

has

had

an

equivalent impact on Appalachian per
cussive dance to that which Earl Scruggs'

casket, handmade by Cecil, was rolled out
of the service to the tune of "Golden Slip
pers." In the back of his trusty old '98 Ford
F-150, his casket was carried to his family
cemetery at St. John's church in Valle Cru
ris, where the Cork Lickers were waiting,
playing some of Robert's favorite dance
tunes. Mark Adams led the Cork Lickers

in singing "Meeting in the Air," and Rob
ert was laid to rest next to Myrtle. Their
tombstone, which Robert had made for

them, has an epitaph that reads, "We've
Gone to Dance."
For those of us lucky enough to have
known Robert personally, you knew that

never met a stranger. He lived life to
fullest and shared his love of dancing
with everyone he met. The world has lost
he
its
a

kind, loving,

an article

upcoming issue

Virginia

dancing man! Watch for

chronicling Robert's life

in an

of OTH.

Rodney Sutton

old-time musician Bill Richardson

died in September of 2014. A remembrance
of Bill will appear in an upcoming issue of
the

OTH.

�DARE TO BE SQUARE:
PASSING IT ON
By Phil Jamison

Lee

Bidgood

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dance Beat
1988, the second year of the Old-Time
I wrote an article for the Dance

InHerald,

Beat column titled, "Community Dances
in the Eighties: Dare To Be Square!" (Vol.

1, No. 6, November 1988). That summer
had traveled across the country, from my

1

home in western North Carolina

to the

Pacific Northwest, and everywhere 1 went
I heard
stories of contra dances replac
ing squares at local dance venues. Prior
the 1980s, contras were primarily found

New England and were relatively rare
elsewhere, with the exception of venues
associated with the Country Dance and
Song Society. In the South, that included
Berea College in Kentucky and the John
C. Campbell Folk School in Brasstown,

North Carolina. I was no stranger to con
tra dances. I had gone to contra dances in
Vermont and New Hampshire as a teen
ager in the early 1970s, and by the early
had begun (by request) to in
1980s,
clude a few in my own calling repertoire,
which up until that time had consisted
entirely of squares. In that first Dare To
discussed the pros and
Be Square article
cons of squares and contras. I admitted,
I

I

however, that

preferred squares. They
were my first love, and I was dismayed
to see them being displaced by contras
I

In my eyes, con
kudzu of the
like
the
was
dancing
an exotic, inva
traditional dance world
sive species that was spreading across the
land, beautiful in its own way, but pro
lific to the point that it was extinguishing
indigenous forms of traditional dance.
The change that was taking place at that

throughout the country.
tra

time, however, involved more than sim

ply substituting contras for squares. The
contra dances that were becoming popu
lar were not the traditional contra dances
of New England, but a modern style with

choreography that was designed

to

keep

dancers in constant motion.
Just as the modern Western square dance
movement of the 1950s did away with
traditional visiting-couple figures, these
modern contra dances avoided tradi
tional ("unequal") figures that involved
all

of

the

only one couple
ing the

at

a

time, thus eliminat

distinction between "active" and

couples. This choreographic
with the growing pop
coincided
change
"inactive"

ularity of contra dancing; in larger halls,
the contra dance lines had become too
Dare

To

Be Square,

Helvetia, West Virginia, 2014

�long for traditional contras with every
one having a turn as the active couple.
In addition to this change in choreogra
phy, new figures, such as the Hey and

in the

the Gypsy, both adopted from English
country dancing, were introduced into
the dances at that time.
The popularity of this modern form of
contra dancing led to the formation of
many new "dance communities" (com
munities of dancers) around the country.
These, however, were not "community
dances" (dances of a community), which
are typically attended by non-dancers as
well as dancers. Instead, they were events
specifically for "contra dancers." I watched
as my local dance, the Old Farmer's Ball
(in Swannanoa, North Carolina), which
helped found in 1982, evolved into a con
tra dance. This new dance community, for

1

the most part, was

separate from the oldtime music community. Consequently,
many of the local old-time musicians quit
attending the dance, and those who were
hired to play became more like employees
who provided a service.
As a caller,
found myself being told by
dance organizers how many squares I was
allowed to call during an evening, and at
some venues, I was told that I would not
be hired if
intended to call any squares.
More than once I recall being booed by
dancers from the floor when asking them
to take partners for a square. As a veteran
caller, who had been involved in tradi
I

I

tional dancing longer than many of these
new dance organizers and contra dancers,
I took offence. I felt alienated,
and I shared
my observations and opinion of what
saw happening in the OTH's Dance Beat.
disliked contra dances;
It wasn't that
disliked the new attitude that had devel
oped, and was concerned that the enor
mous popularity of these dances would
eliminate old-time squares completely.
Writing in the Old-Time Herald, I knew
I

I

I

I

was mostly preaching to the choir.

offended some
Apparently however,
avid contra dancers, and I was accused of
I

being divisive and subsequently blacklist
ed as a caller at a number of venues and
dance events.
Since that first Dare To Be Square article
appeared, modern contra dancing has
continued to prosper and spread across
the country at the expense not only of
Southern squares but also of the tradition

contras ("chestnuts") and quadrilles of
New England. I watched as this change
was occurring, and in 2003, fifteen years
al

after my first Dare To Be Square article,
I wrote
a follow-up article for the Dance

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ends, dance camps, vacations, and even
cruises) catering to avid contra dancers
("dance gypsies") took place throughout
the year. In an attempt to understand and
evaluate this phenomenon, I posted an
online survey to ascertain the attitudes
and views of contra dancers. (I already
knew the opinions of my friends in the
old-time music world.) reported the re
sults of this survey in my article, and I
also noted the historical shifts in popu
lar American social set dance styles that
have occurred throughout our nation's
history: from English country dances
in colonial times, to the introduction of
I

French

in the

quadrilles

of

early years

the Republic, to the subsequent develop
ment of the American square dance by
the

middle

of the

nineteenth century, the

those dances throughout
the country during the first half of the
twentieth century, and finally to the pop
ularity of modern contra dances of today.
Both of these Dare To Be Square articles
can be found online at the Old-Time Her

proliferation

of

website (oldtimeherald.org).
continued to be
advocate for squares, I believed that
Over the years, as

I

an
if

I

could just call the perfect square dance,
contra dancers would come around and
love them as much as I do. At some point,
however, I realized that this was unlike
ly to happen. Many of the new dancers
more interested in novelty
and the personal high ("dance trance")
they got from dancing; they had little
or no interest in traditional music and
dance. In fact, as I recently learned from
the term "tra
a contra dance organizer,
ditional" was actually a turn-off. It took
to be

me a while to be convinced, but at some
realized that the contra dance
point,
scene and old-time music community,
while sharing some devotees, were large
ly two different worlds. (This, of course,
is not true everywhere. Old-time music
has remained prevalent in some contra
dance communities, but that seems to
I

be the

exception rather than the norm.)

These two dance forms could, and per
haps should, exist separately and inde
pendent of each other. That is how it is in
Blacksburg, Virginia, and Minneapolis,
Minnesota, where long-standing square
dances and contra dances have coexisted

separately

for

many years.

In

recent years, however, there has been

renewed

interest

in

traditional old-time

square dancing. One person who was
partly responsible is Bill Martin (19472012), an old-time musician and dance
caller from Portland, Oregon, who started
calling dances with the Foghorn Stringband in the late 1990s. Bill's attitude was,
"It's a party first, and a dance second,"

his enthusiasm sparked a surge of
interest in square dancing in Portland's
young old-time music community. Be
fore long, Bill was serving as a mentor to
a new
generation of square dance callers.
His influence on Portland's old-time mu
and

sic and dance scene is
in the 2003,

Oregon

tary,

Dance

beautifully profiled
public television documen

Art

Beat:

Bill Martin

Square

www.opb.org television
artbeat segment bill-martin-

(http:

programs
square-dancing)
With a similar intent, in May 2004, fol
lowing the publication of my second
Dare To Be Square article, dance caller
Nancy Mamlin and I hosted the first
Dare To Be Square weekend in North
Carolina. It was held on the campus of
Warren Wilson College (where I teach) in

Swannanoa, and that first year, 23 call
ers, wannabe callers, and dancers joined
us for a weekend of squares and call

ing workshops. Among the participants

ald

seemed

1

that

titled, "Old-Time Square Dancing
21st Century: Dare to be Square!"
Herald, Vol. 9, No. 3). By that
(i Old-Time
time, new contra dance communities
had become established throughout the
country, and contra dance events (week
Beat

were Caroline Oakley and Maggie Lind,
two of Bill Martin's young proteges from
Portland. Two North Carolina bands,
the Hushpuppies and the New Southern
Ramblers, were on hand to provide the
music. We repeated the event in 2005,
and

by the

third year,

over 50 partici

pants were showing up. The following
two years (2007 and 2008), Caroline and
Maggie organized a Dare To Be Square
West weekend in Portland, Oregon, and
and 2010, a Dare To Be SquareWest weekend was held in Seattle, Wash
ington. Since that time, 11 more inde
pendently organized Dare To Be Square
weekends have taken place: at Riner, Vir
ginia (2011, 2012), Elkins, West Virginia
in 2009

(2013),

Los

Knoxville,

Angeles,

Tennessee

California
(2014),

(2013),

Helvetia,

West Virginia (2014), Oakland, California
(2014), and in Brasstown, North Caro
lina, at the John C. Campbell Folk School
(2011, 2012, 2013, 2014). Three more Dare

weekends are currently
Helvetia, West Vir
planned
29-30)
(mountaindancetrail.
(May
ginia
org), Brasstown, North Carolina (Octo
ber 31-November 1) (folkschool.org),
and Vancouver, B.C. (November 13-15)
(daretobesquarewest.org).
To

Be

Square

for 2015: in

�These

Dare

workshops

To

Be

Square

have become

an

weekend
important

resource for the next generation of young
callers, and they have contributed to a re
vival interest in traditional square danc
ing. In recent years, new dances have be
come established in communities across
the country

from Montague, Massachu

Oakland, California. When I re
called
the Washington, DC Square
cently
Dance (sponsored by the Folklore Soci
setts, to

ety of Greater Washington),
600 mostly young dancers

more than

showed up.
There is also renewed interest in squares
at some dance weeks and weekends. One
such event, the Georgy-Alabam Square
Dance Weekend, which is co-hosted by
the Birmingham and Atlanta old-time
music communities, has taken place each
January at the Cheaha State Park in Del
ta, Alabama (near the Georgia-Alabama
state line), since 2010. In addition to these
new dances, traditional old-time square
dancing can still be found in communi
ties scattered across America. In West
Virginia, a number of community dances
are now linked together by the Mountain
Dance Trail (mountaindancetrail.org).

"community dances" (not "dance
communities"). They were the dances
that were enjoyed when a community
as

gathered together, and perhaps that is
their natural setting. As Bill Martin said,
"It's a party first, and a dance second."
In earlier times, they took place at com

munity celebrations such as weddings,
but dance frolics also followed work par
ties
corn-shuckings, log-rollings, and

house-raisings. Today, square dances still
take place at weddings, parties, summer

camps, and festivals, and with the new
crop of young callers who are currently
stepping up to the mic, it now appears
that these dances will survive to be en

joyed by future generations.
Phil Jamison (philjamison.com) is an old-time
musician and flatfoot dancer who has called
dances, performed, and taught at music festi
vals and dance events throughout the United
States and overseas since the early 1970s. He
teaches mathematics and Appalachian mu
sic at Warren Wilson

College, where

he also

Old-time square dancing also continues

coordinates the Old-Time Music and Dance
Week at the Swannanoa Gathering. Phil's
forthcoming book, Hoedowns, Reels, and
Frolics: Roots and Branches of Southern

to

Appalachian Dance, will

be a popular feature at traditional
music festivals such as the West Virginia
State Folk Festival at Glenville and the
Appalachian String Band Festival at

Clifftop, West Virginia.
While most of the square dance callers
of my parents' generation, some of whom
were my mentors, are now gone, the old
square dance books of 1940s and '50s are
still available in libraries, and new on
line resources for callers now also exist.
These include Bill Martin's, "A Look At
Southern Squares"
(bubbaguitar.com/
squaredance/ index.html), an online col
lection of Southern square dance figures
taken from the old dance books, and the
Square Dance History Project, an online
archive that documents the history of
square dancing in America through vid
eos, photographs, audio files, and text

(squaredancehistory.org).
Although I was discouraged three de
cades ago when I wrote the first Dare
now believe that
to be Square article,
old-time square dancing,
traditional
having been rediscovered by the next
generation of young old-time musicians,
will likely survive on some level. These
I

dances may never achieve the popular
ity of modern contra dancing or modern
Western square dancing (which is now in
decline), and maybe that's for the best.
These American folk dances originated

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the

I

be

University of Illinois Press

published by
2015.

in July

�TALES FROM THE
'WOODS, PART 11:
KENT STATE
By Walt Koken
were slated to perform at the
annual Kent State Folk Fes
tival in February 1977. Most people have

Wetenth

heard of Kent State by way of the fatal
shootings by the National Guard that
occurred there in 1970 during anti-war
protests. The '77 fest was organized by
Kerry Blech and company, and it was
held indoors on the campus. There were

concerts on Friday and Saturday nights,
and workshops during the day.
In those days we tried to get as many
festival gigs as possible, since the audi
ences were bigger and consequently the
gigs usually paid better. If we got five

hundred

dollars for

a

weekend, after

two to four days' travel expenses and
meals, the remainder didn't go very
far split amongst the five of us. Conse
quently we were living hand to mouth,
and doing other types of work during
slow times. One or two of us occasion
ally got some backing from parents
who wanted to help us. Most of the big
festivals were outdoors in the summer,
so the Kent State one was a boon for us
in the winter.
That year's festival lineup included
John Jackson, an African American mu
sician from Fairfax City, Virginia, who

played
and

very

wonderful

sang blues

finger-style

and

soft-spoken,

a

ballads.
real

His day job was digging

guitar
was

He

gentleman.
and

graves,

his hands were very powerful, yet deft
on the guitar. We had previously done

workshops

with him on

a

tour set up

by Mike Seeger. At one of these,

some

one asked him if he had learned any of
his music from 78 rpm records, and if
so, by whom. He admitted that yes, he
had learned lots from recordings, but he

didn't know who was playing on them
because he couldn't read.
West Virginia storyteller /singer

rod Workman was there with his

Nim-

daugh

Phyllis Boyens. Workman was an
ex-coalminer, and his music lampooned
the coal industry as well as other current
ter

happenings.

Robert

Junior

Lockwood

was on the bill, as was Lonnie Austin,
who was a one-time fiddler for Charlie
Poole. "Poor Howard" Stith was there

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

too. He is

a

singer and guitarist from the

Minneapolis area.

Also there was one of our "sister" bands,
Hotmud Family. Dave Edmundson,
Suzanne Thomas, and banjo player Rick
Good were the core of the group. Dave
played the fiddle and Suzanne the guitar.
Their bass player for some years was Tom
Harley Campbell, who was followed by
Jerry Weinert. These folks lived in Spring
Valley, Ohio, and hailed from the Dayton
area, where they had played in various
the

combinations

for years. We did many
festival and club gigs with them, includ
ing our stint at the Festival d'Epalinges

Lausanne, Switzerland, and Mahoga
a bit of bluegrass /folk flavor to their music. They
in

ny Hall in Bern. They had

were our Midwestern counterparts, and
we enjoyed each other's company in
many settings. Both of our bands played
Grass Cloggers when the
opportunity arose.
A good friend of the Hotmuds was
Greg Dearth, who also joined their band
later on. A wonderful musician who
had spent time with Ohio fiddler John
Hutchison, Greg was the conduit for
spreading some of Hutchison's tunes,
like "Cowboy's Dream" and "Three
Thin Dimes." The Hotmuds also some
times performed and recorded with
Van Kidwell, an older fiddler originally
from Kentucky who had moved north
for the Green

Ohio years previously. They always
referred to people who migrated from
to

�Kentucky as "briar hoppers." Kidwell
brought us tunes like "Midnight Ride,"
and is probably the source for the ver
sion

of

that

Scioty"

"Big

is

widely

played today. The Scioto River empties
into the Ohio at Portsmouth.
The setting for the concerts was a large
auditorium in an old building on cam
pus. The Saturday night audience was
enthusiastic and the show was very
lively. Nimrod Workman, quite elderly
at the

time, sang his

"

Waterbug Blues,"

a

hilarious takeoff on the Watergate scan
dal, and he entertained the crowd with
antics like wrapping his arms around
the outside of his ankles and putting
his hands inside and in front of his feet
on the floor, and "walking" the stage in
such an inimitable position.
John Jackson wowed the audience with
his wonderful guitar style. He began to
tell a joke about a rattlesnake, but got to
laughing so hard about the joke that he
couldn't tell it. What a lineup. They don't
have festivals like that any more. Such
musical characters and storytellers seem

thing of the past.
We were scheduled last on the eve
ning concert, after Poor Howard, so
while he was singing on stage we
to be

a

went backstage

to get

ready. The green

room was to the left offstage and up
two flights of stairs. We had taken
our instruments up there earlier. We

reviewed our set list and got "tuned
up." Someone came up and told us
Poor Howard would play just two

more tunes, so we grabbed our stuff
and headed down the stairs.
Dave Edmundson was coming up
the stairs as we were coming down,
and when he saw Jenny and the bass
coming at him, he made a dramatic
gesture of backing against the wall on
the landing, arms out, as if avoiding a

freight train in
for

everyone

a

tunnel. Unfortunately
building, when he

in the

pressed himself against the wall, he
backed into the fire alarm, and off it
went. And did it go! A very, very loud
WAAANK, WAAANK, WAAANK, in
cessantly and obnoxiously enough to
wake the dead!
Oddly, nobody left the building. It seems
though they weren't fooled. They
had come for the music, and there they
stayed. Poor Howard was really Poor
as

Howard now. He continued on stage but

was very difficult to hear him. He was
looking around to the wings for direc
tions. Kerry made a sign for him to keep
it

going, so he did, bravely.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

We figured that the fire department
would arrive shortly and turn off the
alarm. The reality was that it was Satur

day night on campus, there apparently
was nobody around who could handle
the situation, and the alarm may have

been connected

to

a

campus

security

center but not to the fire department in
town. Consequently Poor Howard had
to continue for another half hour before
they found someone who could turn off
the alarm. Luckily for us, the audience
was still there, intact.
After all that, we played a good set. We

always managed to liven up a crowd,
and it was not unusual for folks in the
audience to start dancing in the aisles
when we played. Since the crowd was

becoming more and more restless as it
got later, we finished the evening by do
ing a medley of dance tunes, and had
them all dancing out of the auditorium
in a long snaking line. That piece ended
up on a compilation recording of Kent
State Folk Festivals, and later on the

Highwoods'

Live

CD. That night lived

on in infamy of sorts, with the fabled
fire alarm story and all. Years later we

heard that Dave Edmundson was telling

everyone that Jenny set
stuff of legends.

it

off. Such is the

�2015 FESTIVAL AND CAMP GUIDE
following pages you'll find information about old-time music and dance festivals, contests, workshops, and
camps, as well as some events in related traditions. Before planning a trip, be sure to visit the event's website or contact
and to find out about admission cost, registration
its organizers to verify that the information here remains correct
the

In

rules, handicapped accessibility, appropriateness for children and pets, and lodging or camping information. Workshops
and camps usually charge tuition, and have limited enrollment, so plan well in advance. Enjoy festival season!

ALABAMA
23

26

(Loachapoka)
Gathering Old Time Music
Festival. Concerts, workshops, jamming,
dance. Info: leecountyhistoricalsociety.org,

April

Lee County

(334) 283-3045.

August

21

23

2-3

Info:

dance,

April 11 (Cloverdale)
Cloverdale Old Time

Fiddle

Festival,

Cloverdale Citrus Fairgrounds. Com
petitions, jamming, concerts. Info:
cloverdalefiddlers.com, (707) 829-8012.

May 14

16 (Los

Angeles)

Angeles Old-Time Social, multiple
venues. Concerts, workshops, dance, jam
ming. Info: oldtimeisagoodtime.com.
Los

May 17 (Agoura Hills)

(Athens)

Tennessee Valley Old-Time Fiddlers
Convention, Athens State University.
Concerts,

16 (Mountain View)
Thumb Picking Weekend and National
Contest, Ozark Folk
Thumbpicking
Center. Concerts, competition, jamming.
Info: ozarkfolkcenter.org, (870) 269-3851.

May 14

(Mentone)

Old Time Music and Dance Weekend,
Camp Riverview. Dance, concerts, jam
ming. Info: bamalong.com.

October

April 23 25 (Mountain View)
Dulcimer Jamboree and Southern Re
gional Dulcimer Competition, Ozark Folk
Center. Competition, concerts, jamming.
Info: ozarkfolkcenter.com, (870) 269-3851.

competition, jamming.

athens.edu/fiddlers, (256) 233-8215.

October 15 18 (Nauvoo)
Old-Time Week at the Alabama Folk
School, Alabama Folk School at Camp
McDowell. Workshops, concerts, dance,
jamming. Info: alfolkschool.com, (205)

July 23

25

(Mountain View)

Mountain Dulcimer Week, Ozark Folk

Center. Workshops,
Info:

concerts,

jamming.

ozarkfolkcenter.com/events,

(870)

269-3851.
June

4-6

Topanga Banjo-Fiddle Contest and Folk
Festival, Paramount Movie Ranch. Con
certs, competition, dance, jamming. Info:

topangabanjofiddle.org, (818) 382-4819.

June 14

(Mountain View)

Autoharp Workshop, Ozark Folk
Center. Workshops, jamming. Info:
ozarkfolkcenter.org,

(870) 269-3851.

17

(Grass Valley)

California Bluegrass

Association

Mu

sic Camp, Nevada County Fairgrounds.

concerts,

Workshops,
Info:

dance,

jamming.

cbamusiccamp.org, (360) 647-0741.

387-18106.

June 25 (Mountain View)
String Band Camp, Ozark Folk Cen
ter.

ALASKA

April 6-12 (Juneau)
Alaska Folk Festival.

Workshops,

concerts, jamming. Info:
(870) 269-3851.

ozarkfolkcenter.com,
Concerts,

dance,

workshops. Info: akfolkfest.org, (907) 4633316.

September 3-5 (Mountain View)

to Grandpa Jones, Ozark Folk
Center. Concerts. Info: ozarkfolkcenter.org,
(870) 269-3851.

June 18

21

June 20

28

(Grass Valley)

Old-Time Music Gathering at the Cali
fornia Bluegrass Association's Fathers
Day Bluegrass Festival, Nevada County
Fairgrounds. Concerts, jamming, work
shops, dance. Info: cbaontheweb.org.

Tribute

(Nevada City)

Alisdair Fraser's

Sierra Fiddle

Camp,

Shady Creek Camp. Workshops, jamming.

September

ARIZONA

(Salome)
Spring Fiddlefest, Salome Lions Club.
Jamming. Info: (928) 859-4621.

April 17

19

18
20 (Flagstaff)
Pickin' in the Pines Bluegrass and Acous
tic Music Festival, Pine Mountain Am
phitheater. Concerts, competition, dance,
jamming. Info: pickininthepines.org, (928)
525-1695.

September

ARKANSAS

April 17 19 (Mountain View)
Arkansas Folk Festival. Concerts, jam
ming. Info: arkansasfolkfestival.com, (870)
269-8068.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(Mountain View)
Days, Ozark Folk Center.

11 -12

Folk Dance

Workshops,

concerts, jamming.

ozarkfolkcenter.com,

Info:

(870) 269-3851.

20
22 (Mountain View)
Fiddle Weekend, Ozark Folk Center. Com
petition, jamming. Info: ozarkfolkcenter.org,
(870)269-3851.

September

sierrafiddlecamp.org, (530) 478-9004.

Info:

June 22

26 (Berkeley)
Fiddlekids, Berkwood Hedge School. Work
shops, dance. Info: freightandsalvage.org/
fiddlekids, (510) 644-2020.

July

5

11, 12

18

(Placer County)

California Coast Music Camp. Work

shops, jamming. Info: musiccamp.org,
(415) 609-4280.

CALIFORNIA

April 9-12 (West Marin County)

Walker Creek Music Camp, Walker Creek
Ranch. Workshops, jamming, dance. Info:
walkercreekmusiccamp.org, (415) 663-1342.

August 11 (Sonoma County)
Golden Old-Time Campout. Jamming,
workshops, dance. Info: cbaontheweb.org.

September

16

20

(Berkeley)

Berkeley Old Time Music Convention.
Workshops, concerts, dance, competition,
jamming. Info: berkeleyoldtimemusic.org.

�FLORIDA

October 11 (Santa Barbara)
Old-Time Fiddlers Convention, Rancho

la

Patera and Stow House. Workshops, con
certs, dance, competition, jamming. Info:

fiddlersconvention.org, (805) 681-7216.
COLORADO

July 9-12 (Berthoud)
Rocky Mountain Old Time Music Festi
val, Parrish Ranch. Concerts, dance, jam
ming. Info: thecroma.org, (970) 217-0498.
July 26

August

2

(Winter Park)

Rocky Mountain Fiddle Camp, Snow
Mountain Ranch. Workshops, concerts,
dance, jamming. Info: rmfiddle.com,
(303) 596-9870.

September 4-7 (Estes Park)

American Roots Music Program, Rocky
Ridge Music Center. Workshops, con
certs, jamming. Info: rockyridge.org,
(970)586-4031.

CONNECTICUT

June

14

11

(Mystic)

(860)572-0711.

DELAWARE

October 23 25
(Rehoboth Beach and Dewey Beach)

Sea Witch Fiddlers Festival, Rehoboth Beach
and Dewey Beach. Concerts, competitions,

jamming, dog parade. Info: beach-hin.com

sea-witch-halloween-fiddlers-festival,
(800)441-1329.

DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
31

(Glen Echo, Maryland)

Washington Folk Festival, Glen Echo
Park. Concerts, dance, workshops. Info:
fsgw.org, (202) 566-1977.

June 24

28, July

neer

Settlement.
Info:

shops.

Pio
work
folkfiddle.com/barber.htm,
Concerts,

Barberville
dance,

(386) 749-2959.

April 10 11 (Dade City)
Florida Old Time Music Champion
ship, Sertoma Youth Ranch. Workshops,
Info:
concerts, competition, jamming.
fotmc.org, (813) 758-6591.
March 27

29 (High Springs)
Suwannee Banjo Camp, O'Leno State Park.

Workshops, concerts, jamming. Registration
required. Info: suwanneebanjocamp.com.
May 22

24 (White Springs)
Florida Folk Festival and Official State
Fiddle Contest, Stephen Foster State
Folk Culture Center. Concerts, contests,
dance, jamming. Info: floridafiddler.org,

(850) 519-2101.

June 12

14

ming.

Info:

(High Springs)
Sparrow Music Camp, O'Leno State
Park. Workshops, concerts, dance, jam

https://sites.google.com/

site/ flmusiccamp/, (850) 519-2101.

Sea Music Festival, Mystic Seaport. Con
certs, workshops. Info: mysticseaport.org,

May 30

April 25 26 (Barberville)
Barberville Spring Frolic,

1-5 (Washington)

Smithsonian Folklife Festival, National
Mall. Concerts, dance, workshops. Info:
festival.si.edu, (202) 633-6440.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

October 2-4 (Otter Springs)
Florida State Fiddlers Convention, O'Leno
State Park. Competitions, concerts, jamming,

dances, workshops. Info: floridafiddler.org.

GEORGIA

April

19

18

(Dahlonega)

Info: bearontliesquare.org,

jamming.
348-1370.

(706)

May 28 30 (Bean Blossom)
John Hartford Memorial Festival, Bill Mon
roe Memorial Park and Campground. Con
certs. Info:

jolinliartfordmemfest.com,

315-3670.

April 24 25 (Calhoun)
Georgia String Band Festival and Gor
don County Fiddlers Convention. Con
certs, competitions, workshops, jamming.
Info: harrisartscenter.com, (706) 508-5598.
May 22 23 (Ringgold)
1890's Day Jamboree, downtown Ring
gold. Competition. Info: 1890sday.com.

(Hiawassee)
Georgia Mountain Fair, Georgia Moun
25

tain Fairgrounds. Concerts, competition.
Info:

Folk Music and Storytelling
Festival, Island Park. Concerts, workshops,
dance, jamming. Info: foxvalleyfolk.com.
Fox Valley

INDIANA

Bear on the Square Mountain Festival,
Public Square. Workshops, dance, concerts,

July 17

September 6-7 (Geneva)

georgiamountainfairgrounds.com,

(706) 896-4191.

October 9-17 (Hiawassee)
Georgia Mountain Fall Festival, Georgia
Mountain Fairgrounds. Concerts, competi
tion. Info: georgiamountainfairgrocmds.com,
(706) 896-4191.

October 10 (Athens)
North Georgia Folk Festival, Sandy
Creek Park. Concerts, jamming, dance.
Info: athensfolk.org, (706) 338-3111.
October 10 12 (Savannah)
Savannah Folk Music Festival, multiple
venues. Concerts, contests, dance. Info:

savannahfolk.org, (912) 355-3357.

(314)

June 26 28 (Battle Ground)
Indiana Fiddlers' Gathering, Tippecanoe
Battlefield.
Concerts, workshops, jam
ming. Info: indianafiddlersgathering.org,
(765) 742-1419.

IOWA

August

September

31

6

(LeMars)

National Old Time Rural, Folk, and Bluegrass Festival &amp; Pioneer Exposition of
Arts, Crafts and Rural Lifestyle, Plym
outh County Fairgrounds. Workshops,
concerts, dances, competition, jamming.

ntcma.net/national-old-time-music-

Info:

festival.php, (712) 880-1052.
KANSAS

August

23

Kansas

(Lawrence)
State

Fiddling and Picking
Championships, multiple venues. Com
petition, concerts, jamming. Info: kansas-

fiddlingandpicking.org, (785) 691-7314.

September 16 20 (Winfield)
Walnut Valley Festival, Winfield Fair
grounds. Concerts, workshops, jamming,
dance. Info: wvfest.com, (620) 221-3250.

IDAHO

June 22

27

(Weiser)

National Oldtime Fiddlers

Contest and
Festival. Workshops, concerts, dance, com
petition, jamming. Info: fiddlecontest.com,
(208) 414-0255.

6-7

April

10

11

(Berea)

Mountain Folk Festival, Berea College.
Youth-oriented dance, workshops. Reg
istration required. Info: Berea.edu/mff,
(859) 985-3142.

ILLINOIS

June

KENTUCKY

(Morris)

Gebhard Woods Dulcimer and Tra
ditional Music Festival, Goold Park.
Concerts, workshops, jamming. Info:
gebharddulcimer.org, (815) 942-0796.
28 (Lewiston)
Lloyd Loar's Hometown Bluegrass Fes
tival. Concerts, jamming. Info: on Face-

June 26

book, (641) 334-8284.

June 7-12 (Hindman)

Appalachian

Family Folk Week,

Hind man Settlement School. Concerts,

workshops, jamming, dance.
hindmansettlement.org,
June

Info:

(606) 785.5475.

5-6 (Whitesburg)

Seedtime

on

certs, jamming

Cumberland. Con
workshops, dance. Info:

the

appalshop.org/ seedtime, (606) 633-0108.

�26 (Bardstown)
Kentucky Music Week, Foster Heights
Elementary School. Workshops, con
certs, jamming. Registration required,

June 21

instrument

rentals available.
kentuckymusicweek.com.

Info:

September 9-12 (Olive Hill)

Fraley Festival of Traditional Music, Cart
er Caves State Resort Park. Concerts, work

shops, jamming. Info: fraleyfestival.com,
(606) 286-4411.

LOUISIANA

April

16

11

(Lafayette)

Dewey Balfa Cajun and Creole Heri
Vermilionville

tage Week,

Living

tory Museum and Folklife Park.
certs, workshops, dance, jamming.
lafolkroots.org, (337) 234-8360.

April

22

26

His

Con
Info:

(Lafayette)

Festival International de Louisiane.
Concerts, dance, workshops. Info:
(337) 232-8086.

festivalinternabonal.com,

July 17

18

(Natchitoches)

Natchitoches-NSU

er

Folk Festival, PrathColiseum on NSU campus. Concerts,

dance, competition,

Info:

jamming.

louisianafolklife.nsula.edu,

(318) 357-4332.

October 9-11 (Lafayette)
Festivals Acadiens et Creoles. Concerts,

festivalsacadiens.com.

dance. Info:

October 23 24 (Lafayette)
Blackpot Festival and Cookoff, Acadian
Village. Concerts, jamming, dance. Info:

blackpotfestival.com.

MAINE

14

-19, June 19- 20,
14, June
21 (Montville)
14, August 16

June 12

August

9

Maine Fiddle Camp,
Workshops, jamming.

Camp

NEOFA.

re

Registration

quired. Info: mainefiddlecamp.org, (207)
443-5411.
June 29

July

3

(Bar Harbor)

Acadia Trad School, College of the At
lantic. Workshops, concerts, dance, jam
ming. Info: acadiatradschool.com.

July 23

26

(Cornish)

Ossipee Valley Bluegrass Festival, Ossipee

Valley

Fairgrounds.

Concerts,

workshops, dance, competition.
ossipeevaIley.com, (207) 625-8656.
August

28

30

Info:

(Bangor)

American Folk Festival. Concerts, dance.
Info: americanfolkfestival.com, (207) 9922630.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

MARYLAND

April 10

12

(Edgewater)
Dance Weekend, Camp
Dances, concerts, jamming. Info:

Chesapeake

Letts.

chesapeakedanceweekend.org.
May 30

31

(Glen Echo)

Washington Folk Festival, Glen Echo
Park. Concerts, dance, workshops. Info:
fsgw.org, (202) 566-1977.

June 13 (Westminster)

Deer

20 (Takoma Park)
Takoma Park Folk Festival, Takoma Park
Middle School. Concerts, dance. Info:
tpff.org, 301-589-0202.

September

Fiddlers

Creek

MASSACHUSETTS

April

(Charleton)

15

13

Camp North, Prindle Pond Con
ference Center. Workshops, concerts, jam
ming. Info: mugwumps.com/ fcn-fall.html,
Fiddle

Convention,

Carroll County Farm Museum. Com

petition, jamming, concerts, dance.
Info: commongroundonthehill.org/
deercreekfestival.html.

(774) 207-0284.

April

17

(Charleton)

19

Mandolin Camp North, Prindle Pond Con

ference

June 19

21

(Keedysville)

Antietam Early Banjo Gathering, Pry
House Field Hospital Museum. Presenta
tions, concerts, jamming. Info: pryeducation

@civilwarmed.org.
June 28

July

3,

July

7-12

April 24 26 (Mansfield)
New England Folk Festival. Concerts,
dance. Info: ww.neffa.org, (617) 299-1590.

(Westminster)

Weeks I and II, McDaniel
College. Workshops, concerts, jamming.
Registration required. (410) 857-2771.

Tradition

Center. Workshops, concerts, jam
ming. Info: mugwumps.com/mavfall.html,
(774)207-0284.

12 (Westminster)
11
Common Ground on the Hill, McDaniel

July

College and Carroll County Farm Mu
seum. Workshops, concerts, dance, jam
ming. Info: commongroundonthehill.org,
(410) 857-2771.

May 15

(Charleton)

17

Banjo Camp North, Prindle Pond Confer

ence Center. Workshops,

concerts,

jam

ming. Info: mugwumps.com/bavfall.html,
(774) 207-0284.

July 24

Lowell

26

(Lowell)

Folk Festival.

workshops.

Info:

(978) 970-5000.

Concerts, dance,

lowellfolkfestival.org,

August 8-15 (Plymouth)

American Dance and Music Week (Pinewoods), Pinewoods Camp. Concerts,

workshops,

dance, jamming.

(413) 268-7426.

Info:

cdss.org,

MIUHIUAN
24 (Remus)
Traditional Arts Weekend. Workshops,
concerts, jamming, dance. Registration

May 22

required.

Info:

(989) 967-8879.

June

wheatlandmusic.org,

5-7 (Olivet)

Midwest Banjo Camp, Olivet College.
Workshops, concerts, jamming. Info:
midwestbanjocamp.com.

June 14

19

(Mecosta)

Earful of Fiddle Music and Dance
Camp, School Section Lake Family

Camp. Workshops, jamming, dance. Info:

earfuloffiddle.com, (989) 561-2308.
July 17

19 (Marquette)
Hiawatha Traditional Music Festival, Mar
quette Tourist Park. Workshops, concerts,
dance, jamming. Info: hiawathamusic.org,

(906) 226-8575.

�September

13

11

(Remus)

Wheatland Music Festival. Concerts, jam
ming, dance. Info: wheatlandmusic.org,
(989) 967-8879.

MINNESOTA

17 (Lanesboro)
Bluff Country Gathering, Sons of Nor
Work
way Hall Community Center.
shops, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:

May 14

boveeheil.com, (507) 498-5452.
May 29

31

Minnesota

(Richmond)

Homegrown

Kickoff,

Mariana Campground.

Rancho

El

Work

shops, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:
minnesotaoldtime.org, (800) 635-3037.

August

1

(Virginia)

Minnesota State Old-Time Fiddle Champi
onship. Competition. Info: (218) 290-9877.

August 6-9 (Richmond)

&amp; Old-Time Music
Festival, El Rancho Mariana Campground.
Workshops, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:

Minnesota Bluegrass

minnesotaoldtime.org, (800) 635-3037.

August 29
Minnesota

30 (St. Paul)

State Fair and Minnesota
State Fiddle Contest. Competition. Info:

fiddlpmn.com.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

MISSISSIPPI

May 16 (Washington)
Great Big Yam Potatoes Old Time Mu
sic Gathering, Historic Jefferson Col
lege. Competition, jamming, dance. Info:

bigyampotatoes.com.

MISSOURI
20 (West

June 19

Plains)

Old-Time Music Ozark Heritage Festi
val. Workshops, concerts, dance, compe
tition, jamming. Info: oldtimemusic.org,
(888) 256-8835.

MONTANA
11

April

(West Kalispell)

Fiddle

Glacier

Smith

Festival,

Valley Grange. Competition. Info:
glacierfiddlefestival.blogspot.com.
June

12, June 14

7

Fiddle

Montana
concerts,

jamming.

19 (Monarch)
Camp. Workshops,

Registration

re

quired. Info: montanafiddlers.org, (406)
736-5391.
July 25

26

(Great Falls /White Sulphur Springs)
Montana State Fiddle Contest, St. Thomas
Church church camp. Competition. En
trants must have been members of Mon
State

tana
for

at

Info:

Old-Time Fiddlers Association

least 60 days prior

to

competition.

montanafiddlers.org.

NEBRASKA

May 23 (Beatrice)

Monumental

Fiddling Championship,

Homestead National Monument of Amer
ica. Competitions, concert, jamming, work
shops. Info: nps.gov/home, (402) 223-3514.
June 15

19

(Avoca)

Schoolhouse Fiddle Camp for Beginners,
Old Avoca Schoolhouse. Workshops, jam
ming. Info: greenblattandseay.com,

(402) 275-

3221.

July 13

17 (Avoca)

Schoolhouse Fiddle Camp for Inter
mediate/Advanced Fiddlers, Old Avoca
Schoolhouse. Workshops, jamming. Info:
greenblattandseay.com, (402) 275-3221.

�NEW HAMPSHIRE

September

26

27

(Portsmouth)

Portsmouth Maritime Folk Festival. Concerts,

singings. Info: newenglancbolknetwork.org/
pmff.

NEW JERSEY

September 4-6 (Woodstown)

Delaware Valley Bluegrass Festival, Salem
Fairgrounds.

County

Concerts, jamming,

dance. Info: delawarevalleybluegrass.org,
(302) 321-6466.

NEW MEXICO

May 22

25

(Socorro)

FolkMADness Music and Dance Camp,

New Mexico Tech. Concerts, dance, work
shops, jamming. Info: folkmads.org.
June

6

(Albuquerque)

Albuquerque Folk Festival, Albuquerque

Balloon Museum. Concerts,
dance, jamming. Info: abqfoIkfest.org,
International

(505) 247-9177.
28

August

30

(Santa Fe)

Bluegrass and OldTime Music
Festival, Santa Fe County Fairgrounds.
Concerts, jamming, dance. Info:
Santa

Fe

southwestpickers.org.

October 16 17 (Albuquerque)
New Mexico Dulcimer Festival. Concerts,
workshops, jamming. Info: nmdulcfest.com,
(505) 292-6030).

October 3-4 (Truth or Consequences)
New Mexico State Fiddle Contest. Com
petition. Info: nmotfa.com, (575) 297-4125.

NEW YORK

April 17

19 (Brooklyn)
Brooklyn Folk Festival, St. Ann's Church.
Concerts, dances, jamming, workshops.
Info: brooklynfolkfest.com.

May 23 (Olivebridge)
Ashokan Uke Fest, the Ashokan

Cen

Workshops, concerts, jamming. Info:
ashokan.org, (845) 246-2121.
ter.

May 22 24 (Altamont)
Black Creek Fiddlers Reunion, Alta
mont Fairgrounds.
Workshops, jam
Info:
(518) 765-2815.

ming.

blackcreek.oldsongs.org,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

June 26 28 (Altamont)
Old Songs Festival,

Workshops,

grounds.
jamming.

Info:

July

4

concerts,

Fair
dance,

oldsongs.org/festival,

(518) 765-2815.

June 28

Altamont

Workshops, concerts, dance, jamming.
Info: ashokan.org, (845) 246-2121.
16

(Olivebridge)
Guitar Camp, the Ashokan
Center. Workshops, concerts, dance, jam
ming. Info: ashokan.org, (845) 246-2121.

Ashokan

July 16 19 (Trumansburg)
Finger Lakes Grassroots Festival of Mu
sic and Dance, Trumansburg Fairgrounds.
concerts, dance, jamming.
Workshops,
Info: grassrootsfest.org, (607) 387-5098.
July 19 25 (Olivebridge)
Ashokan Fiddle and Dance Northern Week,
the Ashokan Center. Workshops, dance, con

certs, jamming.

Info:

ashokan.org,

(845) 246-2121.

Ashokan Fiddle and Dance Southern Week,

Ashokan Center. Workshops, con

certs,

26

(Brooklyn)
Slope Bluegrass and Oldtime
Jamboree, Prospect Park. Concerts, jam
ming, workshops. Info: jamesreams.com,
(718) 374-1086.

dance, jamming.
(845)246-2121.

Info:

NORTH CAROLINA

April 16 19 (Silk Hope)
Shakori Hills Grassroots Festival of
Music and Dance, Shakori Hills. Con
certs, jamming, workshops, dance. Info:
shakorihillsgrassroots.org, (919) 542-1746.
April

18

(Yadkinville)

Yadkin Valley Bluegrass and Old-Time
Yadkinville
Convention,
Elementary.

Competitions.
April

23

26

Info:

yadkingrass.com.

(Wilkesboro)

MerleFest, Wilkes Community College.
Info:
Concerts, workshops, dance.
merlefest.org, (800) 343-7857.

May 7-10 (Black Mountain)
Lake Eden Arts Festival (LEAF), Black

Mountain College. Concerts, workshops,
jamming, dance. Info: theleaf.org, (828)
68-MUSIC.

August 9-15 (Olivebridge)
the

25

Park

(Olivebridge)

Ashokan Fiddle and Dance Western
and Swing Week, the Ashokan Center.

July 12

September

ashokan.org,

24 (Union Grove)
Fiddler's Grove, Fiddler's Grove Camp
Ground. Contests, jamming. Info:

May 22

fiddlersgrove.com, (704) 682-1350.
June

5-6 (Mount

Airy)

Blue Grass and Old Time Fiddlers Conven
tion, Veterans Memorial Park. Competitions,

jamming. Info: mtaiiyfiddlersconvention.com,
(336)345-7388.

June 7 13 (Mars Hill)
Blue Ridge Old-Time Music Week,
Mars Hill College. Workshops, jamming.
Registration required. Info: mhc.edu/
oldtimemusic, (828) 689-1167.
June 12 13 (Eden)
Charlie Poole Festival, Governor Morehead
Park. Concerts, competitions, jamming. Info:

charlie-poole.com, (336) 623-1043.

June 27 (Lenoir)
Heritage Day and Wood Kiln Opening, Tra
ditions Pottery. Concerts, demonstrations.
Info: traditionpottery.com, (828) 295-5099.
July

5-11 (Swannanoa)

Traditional Song Week at the Swan
nanoa Gathering, Warren Wilson Col
lege. Workshops, concerts, jamming.

swangathering.com,
July

11

Shape

Info:

(828) 298-3434.

(Brasstown)
Note Singing,

John

C.

Camp

bell Folk School. Info: folkschool.org,

800-FOLK-SCH.

�(Swannanoa)

July 19

25

July 26

August

Old-Time Week at the Swannanoa
Gathering, Warren Wilson College.
Workshops, concerts, jamming. Info:
swangathering.com, (828) 298-3434.
1

(Swannanoa)

Guitar Week at the Swannanoa Gathering,
Warren Wilson College.
Workshops, con
Info:

certs, jamming.
(828) 298-3434.

July 17

18

grounds.

October 8-11 (Silk Hope)
Shakori Hills Grassroots Festival of
Music and Dance, Shakori Hills. Con
certs, jamming, workshops, dance. Info:
shakorihillsgrassroots.org, (919) 542-1746.
October

(Sparta)

Fiddler's Con
Higgins Agricultural Fair

Alleghany
vention,

swangatliering.com,

October 3-4 (Brasstown)
John C. Campbell Folk School Fall Fes
tival, John C. Campbell Folk School. Con
certs, workshops, jamming, dance. Info:
folkschool.org, 800-FOLK-SCH.

County

Info:

Competition, jamming.

(336) 363-4383

alleghanyfiddlersconvention.com,

August TBA (Lenoir area)

Happy Valley Fiddlers Convention, Jones
Farm. Concerts, competition, dancing,
jamming. Info: happyvalleyfiddlers.com,

15

18 (Black

Mountain)

Lake Eden Arts Festival (LEAF), Black

Mountain College. Concerts, work

shops, jamming, dance. Info: theleaf.org,
(828) 68-MUSIC.

October 16 18 (Stecoah)
Apple Harvest Festival, Stecoah Valley
Center. Concerts, dance, jamming. Info:

stecoahvalleycenter.com, (828) 479-3364.

(828) 758-9448.

August 6-8 (Asheville)

Mountain Dance and Folk Festival, Diana
Wortham Theater.

Concerts, dance. Info:

folkheritage.org, (828) 258-6101

August 2-8 (Swannanoa)
Mandolin and Banjo Week

345.

Warren

lege.

swangathering.com,

August

2-8

Fiddle Week

the

Swan

Wilson

(828) 298-3434.

(Swannanoa)
at

the

OHIO

May
at

Col
Gathering,
Workshops, concerts, jamming.

nanoa
Info:

x

Swannanoa Gather

ing, Warren Wilson College. Workshops,

concerts, jamming. Info: swangathering.
com, (828) 298-3434.

August 7-8 (Lansing)
Ola Belle Reed Homecoming

Festival,

Lansing Creeper Trail Park. Concerts, jam
ming. Info: olabellefest.com, (336) 384-4000.

Aug. 6-9 (Little Switzerland)
Camp DoReMi, Wildacres Retreat. Work
shops, jamming, shape-note singing. Info:
campdoremi.org, (706) 769-8782.

September 4-5 (Lake Junaluska)
Smoky Mountain Folk Festival, Lake
Junaluska Conference and Retreat Cen
ter. Concerts, dance, jamming. Info:
lakejunaluska.com/ sm-folk-festival/
September

17
19 (Silk Hope)
Hoppin' John Old-Time and Bluegrass
Fiddlers' Convention, Shakori Hills. Com
petitions, jamming, workshops, dance.
Info: hoppinjohn.org, (919) 542-1746.

September 26 (Cullowhee)
Mountain Heritage Day, Western Caro
lina University.
Concerts, dance, jam
ming, shaped-note singing. Info: mountainheritageday.com, (828) 227-7129.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1-3 (Columbus/ Galloway)
Ohio Folk Festival,

Central

Bat

Creek Metro Park,
concerts,
Workshops,
jamming. Info:

telle-Darby

columbusfolkmusicsociety.org,

419-8614

(614)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

PENNSYLVANIA

May 8-10 (Cincinnati)

Appalachian
land.

Festival,

Coney

Is

Info:
(513) 251-3378.

Concerts, dance, jamming.

appalachianfestival.org,
May 22

24

(Lisbon)

Dulci-More Festival, Boy Scout Camp

McKinley. Workshops, concerts, jamming.
Info: duIcimore.org, (330) 332-4420.
July 11 (Archbold)
Sauder Village Fiddle Contest, Sauder Vil
lage. Competition. Info: saudervillage.com,
(800) 590-9755.

August

21

May 21

23

(Boiling Springs)

American Banjo Fraternity Spring
Rally, Allenberry Resort. Concerts,
jamming, presentations on the theme
of ragtime or classical banjo.
Info:
banjofraternity.org, (814) 938-6600.

May 22 24 (Huntingdon)
Folk College. Concerts, workshops, jamming.
Info: folkcollege.com, (814) 643-6220.
June 19

21 (West

June 24

28

Chester)

Brandywine Revival Festival. Jamming,
concerts, competition. Info: "Brandywine
Revival 2015" on Facebook.

(Nelsonville)

Parade of the Hills and Ohio State Fid

dling Contest, Stuarts Opera House.
Competition.

Info:

paradeofthehills.org.

workshops, jamming. Info: mlag.org.

certs,

August

OREGON

September 5-7 (Mount Hood)
Zigzag Mountain Old Time

Music

Campout, Zigzag Mountain Farm. Jam

ming. Info: zigzagoldtime.com.

(Newport)

Mountain Laurel Autoharp Gathering,
Little Buffalo Family Campground. Con
(West Chester)

8

Chester County Old Fiddlers' Picnic,
Hibernia County Park. Concerts, dance,
jamming. Info: chesco.org/ccparks.

September 4-7 (Hamlin)
Fiddling Bear/Lake Genero Musicians'

Gathering, Lake Genero. Jamming. Info:

sacrasoft.com/ genero.

September 11 13 (Huntingdon)
Greenwood Furnace Folk Gathering,
Greenwood Furnace State Park. Work
shops, concerts, jamming,

dance.

Info:

folkgathering.com, (814) 643-6220.

September

20

(Lyons)

Lyons Fiddle Festival, Lyons Community Park
Concerts, competition, dance, jamming. Info:
lyonsfiddlefest.com, (484) 772-5223.

SOUTH CAROLINA

(Pickens)
Fiddler's Convention and
Carolina State Fiddle Cham

September
Ole

19

Time

South

pionship,

Hagood

Mill.

Competition,

concerts, jamming. Info: facebook.com/
hagoodmill, (864) 898-5964.

TENNESSEE

April 18 (Holladay)
Old-Time Bluegrass and Fiddler's Jam

boree, Holladay School. Competition.
holladaybluegrass.com.

Info:

June 14 20 (Maryville)
Steve Kaufman's Acoustic Kamps, oldtime week. Workshops, concerts, jamming.
Info: flatpik.com, (865) 982-3808.

�VERMONT

June 21 27 (Maryville)
Steve Kaufman's Acoustic Kamps, blue
grass week. Workshops, concerts, jam
ming,. Info: flatpik.com, (865) 982-3808.

3-4

(Smithville)
and
Fiddlers'
Jamboree
Crafts Fest. Competition, jamming. Info:

July

Smithville

[une 21

27

(Starksboro)

Northeast Heritage Music Camp, Com
mon Ground Center. Workshops, jam
ming, concerts, dance. Registration re
quired. Info: northeastheritagemusiccamp.
com, (802) 229-1403.

smithvillejamboree.com, (615) 8500.

12 (Murfreesboro)
Uncle Dave Macon Days, Cannonsburgh
Village. Competition, concerts, dance, jam
ming. Info: uncledavemacondays.com,

July 10

(800) 716-7560.

VIRGINIA

May

1-2

(Galax)

HoustonFest: A Celebration

September

18

20

Bristol

(Bristol)
and Roots

Reunion,
Rhythm
Concerts, jamming, youth
Info:
bristolrhythm.com,
competition.

downtown.

(423) 573-1927.

October 9-11 (Clinton)

Tennessee Fall Flomecoming, Museum
of Appalachia.
Concerts, dance, jam
museumofappalachia.org,
ming. Info:
(865) 494-7680.

of Song and
Service, Felts Park. Concerts, competition.
Info: houstonfestgalax.com, (276) 236-9908.

May

(Abingdon)

9

CrookedRoadYouthMusicFestival, Heart-

wood. Concerts. Info: tliecrookedroad.org,
(276) 492-2409.

May 9 (Fries)
Henry Whitter Festival, Fries Town Park.
Concerts, jamming. Info: (276) 744-2231.
May 21

TEXAS
11

April

(Austin)

Janie's Jumpstart. Workshops, concerts,

jamming. Info: janiesjumpstart.com.

(Hallettsville)
Texas State Championship and Fiddlers
23

April

26

Frolics, Knights of Columbus Hall. Com
petition, concerts, dance. Info: kchall.com,
(361) 798-2311.

May 21

June 7 (Kerrville)
Kerrville Folk Festival. Concerts, contests,
kerrville-music.com,
food, dance. Info:
(830) 257-3600.
14 (San Antonio)
Folklife Festival, Texan Cultures
UTSA HemisFair Park Campus. Concerts,
dance. Info: texasfolklifefestival.org, (210)

June 13
Texas

458-2224.

Info:

16
19 (Austin /Driftwood)
Austin String Band Festival, Camp Ben
McCulloch. Concerts, workshops, dance,

jamming. Info: aftm.us.

(Ferrum)

crookedroaddulcimerfestival.org,

(540) 365-4412.

May 30 (Appomattox)

Sweeney and the Banjo Festival,
Appomattox Courthouse National His
torical Park. Concerts, exhibits, presenta
Joel

tions. Info: 434) 352-8987.

June 9-12 (Buena Vista)

Maury River Fiddlers' Convention,
Glen Maury Park. Contests, concerts,
jamming. Info: mauryriverfiddlers.com,
(800) 555-8845.

June 12

13

(Newport)

Henry Reed Memorial Fiddlers Con
vention, Glen Lyn Park.
Workshops,
concerts, dance, competition, jamming.
Info:

October

24

Crooked Road Dulcimer Festival, Ferrum
College. Concerts, workshops, jamming.

gilesmountainstringband.com.

June 12

20

Mountains

(Various locations)

of Music
Homecoming,
various locations throughout Southwest
Virginia. Concerts, jamming, workshops.
Info:

mtnsofmusic.com.

June 15

19

(Independence)

Peach Bottom Farm Fiddle and Strings
Camp. Workshops, jamming, camping. Info:
peachbottomfarm.com, (276) 773-2181.

UTAH

May

10 (West

Valley)

Salt Lake City Fiddlin' and Pickin' Contest.

Competition. Info: utaholdtimefiddlers.net.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

June 20 (Mouth of Wilson)
Wayne Henderson Festival, Grayson High
lands State Park. Concerts, competition, jam
ming, dance. Info: waynehenderson.org.

�19 (Monterey)
Highland County Old Time Fiddlers Con
vention, Highland County Fairgrounds.
Competitions, concerts, jamming. Info:
lrighfiddle.com, (540) 292-2083.

July 16

June 26

27 (Elk

Creek)
Grayson County Fiddler's

Convention,

School Ballpark.

Elk Creek

Compe

tition, jamming, dance. Info: ecvfd.net,

July 25 31, August 1-7, August 8-14
(Port Orchard)
Puget Sound Guitar Workshop. Workshops,
concerts, dance, jamming. Registration re
quired. Info: psgw.com, (360) 647-0741.

August 9-16 (Centralia)

Centralia Old-Time Music Campout. Jam
ming, dance. Info: centraliacampout.com,
(360) 807-8461.

(276) 655-4866.

July 20

24 (Big

10

September
American

Stone Gap)

Mountain Music School, Mountain Em
pire Community
College. Workshops
(registration required), concerts (open to

State

13

Banjo

Park.

Camp,

(206) 781-5026.

Fort

Flagler

concerts, jam

Workshops,

Info:

ming.

(Nordland)

americanbanjocamp.com,

(Elkins)

July 26

31

July 29

August

Bluegrass Week, Davis &amp; Elkins College.
Classes, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:
augustaheritagecenter.org, (304) 637-1209.
2

(Clifftop)

Appalachian String Band Music Festi
val (Clifftop), Camp Washington-Carver.
Competition, concerts, workshops, dance,

jamming. Info: wvculture.org/ stringband,
(304) 438-3005.

August 2-9 (Elkins)

Old-Time Week, Davis &amp; Elkins College.
Classes, concerts, dances, jamming. Info:
augustaheritagecenter.org, (304) 637-1209.

Info:

public).
mountainmusicschool.org,
(276) 523-7489.

August 3-8 (Galax)
Old Fiddler's Convention, Felts
Competition, jamming, concerts.
oldfiddlersconvention.com,

August

14

Park.

Info:
(276) 236-8541.

12

13

Music

and

Dance Festival, Glen Maury Park. Work
shops, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:

rockbridgefestival.org, (540) 291-2414.

27 (Mouth of Wilson)
September
Grayson Highlands Fall Festival, Grayson
Highlands State Park. Concerts, jamming,
26

dance. Info: ghfallfestival.50megs.com,
(276) 233-8237.

October 24 (Ferrum)
Blue Ridge Folklife Festival, Ferrum
College. Concerts, jamming, dance. Info:

blueridgeinstitute.org/festivals.htm,
(540) 365-4412.

WASHINGTON

April 25 26 (Spokane)
Northwest Regional Fiddle Contest, Trent
Elementary School. Competition. Info:
northwestregionals.com, (509) 228-9030.
May 22

25

(Seattle)

Northwest Folklife Festival, Seattle Cen
ter.

Info:

Workshops, concerts, dance, jamming.

nwfolklife.org, (206) 684-7300.

July 28 (Port Townsend)
Voice Works, Fort Worden State Park.

June 23

Workshops, jamming. Info: centrum.org,
(360) 385-3102.

June 28

July

5

(304) 637-1209.

(Port Townsend)

Festival of American Fiddle Tunes, Fort
Worden State Park. Workshops, dance.
Info: centrum.org, (360) 385-3102.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ming, concerts, dance. Info: wvculture.org/
Vandalia.

August 2-9 (Elkins)
Augusta Vocal Week, Davis &amp; Elkins
College. Classes, concerts, dance, jam
ming. Info: augustaheritagecenter.org,
(304) 637-1209.

May 31 (Helvetia)

May 29

Dare

(Buena Vista)

Mountain

Rockbridge

WEST VIRGINIA

May 22 24 (Charleston)
Vandalia Gathering, Capitol Complex. Jam

15 (Fries)

Fries Fiddlers' Convention, Fries Town
Park.
Competition, jamming. Info:
graysoncountyva.com, (276) 773-2000.

September

August 2-9 (Elkins)
Augusta Dance Week, Davis &amp; Elkins
College. Classes, concerts, dance, jam
ming. Info: augustaheritagecenter.org,

Be

to

Square West Virginia.
dances. Info:

workshops,

Calling

mountaindancetrail.org, (304) 637-1349.

August 7-9 (Elkins)
Augusta Festival,
campus of Davis

certs,

June 16 (Fairmont)

Dulcimer Festival, East Fair

Pattyfest

mont High School. Workshops, jamming,
dance. Info: pattyfest.org.
June 18 21 (Glenville)
West Virginia State Folk Festival. Con
certs, competition, jamming, dance. Info:

26

(Marlinton)

Allegheny Echoes Summer Workshops.

concerts, dance.
Info: aIleghenyechoes.com, (304) 799-7121.
Workshops,

jamming,

July 5-10 (Elkins)
Early Country Music Week, Davis &amp; El
kins College. Classes, concerts, dance,
jamming. Info: augustalieritagecenter.org,
(304) 637-1209.

July 5-10 (Elkins)
Cajun/Creole Week, Davis &amp; Elkins College.
Classes, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:
augustaheritagecenter.org, (304) 637-1209.
July 12

17

(Elkins)

Blues/Swing Week, Davis

&amp;

Elkins College.

Classes, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:
augustalieritagecenter.org, (304) 637-1209.
July

19

24

Elkins City Park and
Elkins College. Con

dance, competition,

jamming.

augustaheritagecenter.org,

(304) 637-1209.

August 9-16 (High View)

Traditional Dance for Educators, Timber
Ridge Camp. Workshops, dance. Info:
(413) 203-5467,

cdss.org/programs.

October

wvfolkfestival.org.
June 21

Info:

&amp;

(Elkins)

Irish/Celtic Week, Davis &amp; Elkins College.
Classes, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:
augustaheritagecenter.org, (304) 637-1209.

18
25 (Elkins)
October Old-Time Week, Augusta Heritage
Centei; Davis &amp; Elkins College.
Classes,

Info:
(304) 637-1209.

augustaheritagecenter.org,

jamming.

October

23

25

(Elkins)

Old-Time Fiddlers' Reunion, Augusta
Heritage Center, Davis &amp; Elkins Col
lege. Concerts, dances, jamming. Info:
augustaheritagecenter.org, (304) 637-1209.

WISCONSIN

July 16

19

(Dodgeville)

Hardanger Music and Dance Workshop,
Folklore Village. Workshops, concerts,
jamming. Info: hfaa.org, (612) 568-7448.

August

14

15

(Madison)

Sugar Maple Traditional Music Festival,
Lake Farm Park. Workshops, concerts,
dance, jamming.
(608) 227-8685.

Info:

sugannaplefest.org,

�WYOMING

AUSTRALIA

July 10 12 (Buffalo)
Big Horn Mountain Festival, Johnson
County Fairgrounds. Jamming, compe
titions, workshops. Info: bighornmoun
tainfestival.com, (307) 672-3325.

September

August

3-6

(Alta)
Targhee Music Camp, Grand Targhee
Ski Resort. Workshops, concerts, jam
ming. Info: targheemusiccamp.org.

August 8-9 (Douglas)

Wyoming State Fiddle Contest, State Fair
Park. Competition. Info: wystatefair.com.

18

20

(Guildford, Central Victoria)
Guildford Banjo Jamboree. Concerts, jam
ming. Info: banjojamboree.org/intro.htm.
October 23 25
(Dorrigo, New South Wales)
Dorrigo Folk and Bluegrass Festival.
Concerts, workshops, dance, jamming.
Info:

dorrigofolkbluegrass.com.au.

ENGLAND

May 22

25

(Sacrewell)

Sacrewell Camp Spring. Jamming, dance.

Info: foaotmad.org.uk.

CANADA

July 3-5 (Souris, Prince Edward Island)
Prince Edward Island Bluegrass and Old
Time Music Festival, Rollo Bay Festival,
Grounds. Concerts, workshops, jamming.
Info: bluegrasspei.com, (902) 566-2641.
July

5-10 (Palgrave,

Ontario)

Fiddle and Step-Dance
Camp. Workshops, jamming. Registra
tion required. Info: fiddle. on. ca/ fiddle,

Orangeville

(519) 941-5683.

September 4-6 (Hastings, East Sussex)
Sweet

Hotel.

Sunny

Info:

South,

Fairlight

Lodge

sweetsunnysouth.co.uk.

August 7 (Sidmouth, Devon)
Sidmouth Folk Week. Concerts, work

July 31

shops, competitions, ceilidhs.
sidmouthfolkweek.co.uk.

Info:

August 7-16 (Sacrewell)
SacrewellCampSummer.Jamming, dance.
Info: foaotmad.org.uk.

July 20 24
(Salt Spring Island, British Columbia)
Salt Spring Island Fiddle Workshop.

Workshops. Registration required.

fiddleworks.ca, (250) 538-1919.

August 2 (Cambridge, Ontario)
Mill Race Festival of Traditional
Music, downtown Cambridge. Work

July 31

shops, concerts, dance, jamming. Info:
millracefolksociety.com, (519) 621-7135.

August 5-9 (Shelburne, Ontario)

Canadian Open Old Time Fiddle Cham
pionship. Competition, dance, jamming.
Info: shelburnefiddlecontest.com,
(519)
925-8620.

August 13 16 (Saskatoon, Saskatchewan)
John Arcand Fiddle Fest. Competi
tion, concerts, workshops, dance. Info:
johnarcandfiddlefest.com, (306) 382-0111.

August 16 21, August 23 28 (Sorrento)
NimbleFingers Workshops. Workshops,
jamming. Info: nimblefingers.ca.

August 22 (Sorrento)
NimbleFingers Bluegrass and Old-Time

Music Festival. Concerts, jamming. Info:
nimblefingers.ca.

September

11

GERMANY

Info:

13

(Parksville, British Columbia)
Vancouver Island Music Workshop, Seven
Springs Resort. Workshops, jamming. Info:

vancouverislandmusicworkshop.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

May 8-10 (Freising)
Old-Time Musicians Meeting, location TBA.
Concerts, jamming. Info: oldtimemusic.de.

IRELAND

July

4-12

(Miltown Malbray, County Clare)
Willie Clancy Summer School of Irish Tra
ditional Music. Workshops, concerts, jam
ming. Info: scoilsamhraidwillieclancy.com.
SCOTLAND

May 22

24

(Strichen, Aberdeenshire)

Strichen Festival. Concerts, dance,

workshops.

Info:

01779821301,

buchanheritagesociety.co.uk.
August

19

23

(Campbeltown, Kintyre)

Mull of Kintyre Music Festival. Con
certs, workshops, ceilidh, jamming. Info:
mokfest.com.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Scott Boatright circa 1922

�SCOTT BOATRIGHT:

MAKE THEM SAD AND THEN MAKE THEM HAPPY
By Roy Andrade

you don't recognize the name
Scott Boatright, but you've probably heard
of many of the people he played in groups
with in the 1920s and '30s. He never made commer
cial records, but he was among the most respected
and active old-time country musicians of his time.
In his prime he performed, either on guitar or banjo,
with many country music greats, including Cowan
Powers, Clarence "Tom" Ashley, John Carson, Dud
ley Vance, Dock Boggs, Uncle Dave Macon, Melvin
Robinette, and many others. His was a rambling and
brief professional career that closely mirrored that of
many other early country musicians who quit music
to pursue more dependable jobs.
are

Chances

through the southern part of the county,
and the Holston River runs through the
northern section. Gate City is the larg
est town, with around 2,000 people to

gCGBD tuning for C and D tunes, and in
gDGBD for G and A tunes, but was fond of
other tunings. Much of his banjo repertoire
consisted of the classic traditional pieces of
tunes like "Ida Red," "Sourwood
the day

Mountain," and "Turkey in the Straw." But
he had many specialty pieces that he took
great pride in having developed. Some of
these numbers were "Coal Creek March,"
which he fingerpicked in the key of G with
the bass string tuned down to a low G, an
intriguing tune called "Davenport," which
sounds as if it is related to "Last Chance,"
a
tune he fingerpicked beautifully
called "Prentiss," which closely resembles
the "John Brown's Dream" and "Pretty
Little Girl" family of tunes.
He was also fond of singing with the
banjo, but more often he would back

and

himself up on guitar. Some

of his

favor

ites were "I Won't Have to Cross Jor
dan Alone," "In the Garden," "Where
Has My Little Dog Gone," and one that
he was particularly proud of, "Virginia

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Rose." He learned this song from

a

song-

writing neighbor named Griffiths, a re
clusive type who never performed his
own songs. Boatright learned the man's
songs and held them close, but shared
"Virginia Rose" with guitarist Hub Mahaffey, who secretly gave it to a man
named Woodrow Huff. Huff gave it to
the Carter Family, who had some success
with the song. Boatright remained a little
sore at Mahaffey over that matter.

Boatright played guitar with a flat pick
a
thumb-pick, and also with his bare
fingers. Some early photographs show
or

heavy pick wear on the top of his guitar
and against the saddle, suggesting that
he played as close to the bridge as he
could. He likely did this to get a punchi
er bass note and strum, which was com
mon for guitar players at the time. He
also had fingerpicking numbers that he

worked into performance pieces, includ
ing "Rabbit Blues," "Something Blues,"
and "Clarence Green Blues."

cember 17, 1905, on a 1,400-acre farm near
Fort Blackmore in Scott County, Virginia.

Scott County is in the far southwestern
corner of the state, just north of Kingsport, Tennessee. The Clinch River runs

in

farmland that give way to the Tennessee
Valley just a few miles to the south.
Scott Boatright was the first of five
children born to Robert Franklin (R. F.)
Boatright and Rebecca Elizabeth Gilliam.
R. F. Boatright was a civil engineer and
inventor most remembered for his 1902
patent for a device called a wire-stretch
er, used for tightening wire around fence

posts. He was also an accomplished fid
dler and banjoist. Scott told Mike Seeger
that he remembered his father coaching
him on fiddle tune melodies:
My daddy was

a

good fiddler, the best
died when 1 was

He

this

country.
When I was six years old I would
ivhistle the tunes he played, and if I
seven.

whistled
had

a

it

wrong

he'd correct me. He

lot of patience.

The year of 1912 was a difficult one for
Boatright clan. Scott's grandfather

the

died in January, and in the spring, the
family farmhouse burned to the ground.
That winter, R. F. Boatright died, leaving
his wife Rebecca with five young chil
dren including a newborn. The surviving
family moved to another, smaller house
on the farm, and Rebecca began inviting
less-fortunate people to live with them
and help out as they could. One of these
was Sylvania Duncan (pronounced SillVie-Na), a local woman who played ban
It was
jo and fiddle, and was crippled.
that
Scott
from Duncan
Boatright first
learned downstroke banjo at the age of
12. He said of Duncan, "She's where I got
she could do that.
the double noting
She played the fiddle too. She'd twist all
she played pretty good."
around

playing guitar and singing

songs
early teens and became
both
on
guitar and banjo. He
proficient
told folklorist Barry O'Connell that he
in

De

was

It is a

He began

Walter Scott Boatright was born on

it

thoroughly rural place, with
combination of steep slopes and rolling

1900.
a

people fewer than

60

scarcely

in

Boatright played banjo in both the claw
hammer style, and three-finger style. He
said about banjo playing, "We called our
music hillbilly music. It's older than coun
try music. The way I play banjo is not
country. There's a difference. They don't
put notes in it anymore, it's just strum,
strum, strum." He played primarily in the

current population is

day. The county's

his

learned music both from the radio and
from phonograph records:
I listened to the radio a lot,
mostly out
of Nashville, but also from Knoxville,

�courtesy
of
the

Boatright
family

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Scott Boatright with unknown fiddler player

in

Norton, Virginia circa 1932

�Tennessee,

Covington,

Wheeling,

West

We

Virginia

Boggs around 1926 and 1927. Dock had

and

Kentucky,

al

connections

remem

we'd

be

learning things off the phonograph.
mostly followed Riley Puckett, I liked
his playing. And the Skillet Tickers. I

Didn

't

never saw them live, just on records.
1923 he formed his first of many

at.

ways kept

a

phonograph, and

I

ber

tright told Mike Seeger:

We'd pass

a

show when

big

related

he

danced--

to

traveling by train, and eventually did
play theaters and schoolhouses to soldout crowds in eastern Kentucky. If they
had

a

day off between engagements they
a town
along their

route and try to gather

crowd for some

a

impromptu entertainment. Things didn't
always go as planned, as Boatright re
lated to Seeger:
One time we was on our way down
Kentucky

and stopped over in

rough joint and we thought we'd make

little money. So we'd say, "Now, if
you want to see a good dance," five to
six dollars, you know, we'd set the price.
A big crowd came in there and they
a

He played the banjo,
and I'd try to lay it on him and he'd try
to lay it on me, just for fun, you know.

you can't play

I.

had a special tune to go with it.
The two had many adventures together

a

great buddies.

"Well,

it

through

Me and Charley Powers, you know, of
me and him used to
the Powers family

and

so did

a

might show up in

simi

lineup, Fiddlin' Powers and Family
from nearby St. Paul, Virginia, led by pa
triarch fiddler Cowan Powers. Powers'
son Charley and Boatright became close
friends and musical compadres. Boa

something

anything like

coal mining, shoveling
coal. I had my own dance, the buck and
wing, that old-timey dance. Each dance
made

lar

learn

Dock danced and

put on

hard to promote themselves and to put
together an entertaining show. Over the
next five years they played occasional ra
dio programs, theaters, and social events
in and around Scott County. Boatright
said that it was during this time that
the band connected with and learned

He'd

or

few times around barbershops,
then they'd ask for another dance. Dock

bands, the Boatright String Band, with
his sisters Beulah and Mae playing uku
lele and guitar, respectively, and his halfbrother Jim on fiddle. The band worked

be

gone for two or three months.

play any theaters

the hat

In

a

Sometimes

Kentucky.

that. We played at barber shops. Mostly
dry areas, so there were no bars to play

I

from another family band with

in

was all drinking and hurrahing around

he'd

say,
that." I'd learn

and they passed the hat around three or
four times, and they was just throwing
money in and throwing money in. We

something, I'd tell him the same thing.

else passing

By 1926 the family band was falling apart.

was

revelation after a gig one night in
Kentucky and decided that his career aspi

up Dock's hat and passed it around and
then eased out the door and took the hat,

rations lay with the church. He figured that
if he could attract big crowds with music,
he could put his public influence to bet
ter use by spreading the word of God. He

money and all.
In the fall of 1928 Boatright assem
bled a revised version of the fam

Mae Boatright married and decided to fo
cus on starting a family over music. Jim
had

a

hung up his fiddle for good and became

a

Baptist preacher. Scott's other sister Beulah
moved around a lot, was married several
times, and was keen for adventure. Around
1927 she bought an airplane and
along
with brother Scott and her boyfriend and

would charge locals
views between Scott County and

pilot Vauglrn Shores
for aerial

Norton, Virginia.
1927 Boatright began play
with Dock Boggs, the banjo
songster from nearby Norton who was
beginning to make a name for himself.
The men traveled together as a duo off
and on for close to two years, performing
songs, tunes, and dance numbers. Boa
tright told Blanton Owen:

Early in
ing guitar

I

first played

coal

camps with

Dock

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

used

to

somebody

the

hat around while we were playing, and
some fellow walked over there and picked

ily band with his sister Beulah

and

powerful young fiddler from near
Coeburn, Virginia, named Melvin
Robinette. The band traveled to Bris
a

tol, Tennessee, on the weekend of
October 26th to participate in a fiddle
contest, and were registered as the
Boatwright [sic] String Band of Dun-

gannon, Virginia. Other participants
included the Hill Billies, "The Carter
String Band of Macey Springs, Ten
nessee" (presumably the Carter Fam
ily from Maces Spring,

Virginia, and

likely with fiddler John Dykes, who
was playing often with A. R Carter at
that time), and various other fiddleled groups featuring fiddlers G. B.
Grayson, Steve Ledford, and others.

The Boatright String Band placed sec-

�courtesy
of
the

Boatright family

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Scott Boatright circa 1925

ond or third, Robinette told Seeger,
and as soon as they returned back
home the next day, they were encour
aged back to Bristol by a musician
friend, who told them that record
producer Ralph Peer had asked that
all winning contestants return to Bris

It'd make Dock so mad for me or

Char

pick up the banjo around where
everybody was at. He'd say something
about it every time we did it. See, Dock
ley

to

wasn't

great banjo picker, you know.
sang with everything along ivith
his playing and had good timing with
a

He

tol on Sunday the 28th, to audition for
what would become the 1928 Bristol
Sessions.
The band promptly returned to Bristol,
but things did not go well
there was
some confusion and disagreement about
the material to be performed at the au
dition. Robinette preferred to play older
traditional tunes, while Boatright thought

that downstroke. He played all them-called them "graveyard songs." Ev

I

erything was sad and lonesome. Them
miners, it went big over there in mining
country. A lot of them drink over there
anyhow, they'd get lit up on one of them
old songs
they really liked him.
The band was centered around Boggs'

that renditions of songs they had recently
learned from records or radio might give
them a better shot at being recorded. Af

songs but they also played dance tunes
and wrote and performed skits. Boggs
and Boatright brought the band back to
the Kentucky towns where they had made

ter

a

a

heated exchange, Boatright walked

out and the band never auditioned.

Meanwhile, Dock Boggs was enjoying
increasing popularity in the region
and decided to form a bigger band, the
Dock Boggs Cumberland Mountain En
with Charley Powers and
tertainers,
on
Boatright
guitars, and Melvin Robin
his

ette on fiddle.

It is

interesting

to note that

Boggs recorded commercially in 1927
and 1929 with two different guitar play
ers, Hub Mahaffey and Emry Arthur,
but chose to perform regularly with his
friend Scott Boatright.
Both Boatright and Powers were excellent
banjo players, but were relegated to guitars

because Boggs wanted only one banjo,
Boatright explained to O'Connell,

as

name for themselves in previous years

and remembered making as much as $700
a week on tour with the bigger band. Boa

tright told Seeger, "Oh, you couldn't get
in the door every night. I'll tell you what's
the truth, my clothes was kind of dirty,
and I got so well off that I bought me a
new outfit and throwed them away."
Boatright maintained the Boatright String
Band throughout this period, but was also
in

demand

as an

accompanist through the

late 1920s and into the '30s. He went on

tours with Tom Ashley, John Carson, Clar
ence Greene, and others, and in 1929 was
one of the first performers on the newly
formed radio station in Bristol, WOPI
("Watch Our Popularity Increase"), back
ing up fiddle champion Dudley Vance.

�In

the

summer of 1929 he dabbled with

full-time

employment,

moving

to

Cleve

work in the Hupmobile fac
land, Ohio,
as
a brake installer. By the fall he was
tory
back in Scott Comity playing music. In 1930,
Boatright and Hub Mahaffey began playing
music together in yet another incarnation of
the Boatright String Band. Mahaffey was a
to

powerful guitar player and singer who in
1927 had made commercial recordings with

both Boggs and John Dykes, the masterful
dance fiddler from Kingsport. This band
billed itself as being "Hawaiian Players and
Singers" featuring "Hub Mahaffey and his

Famous Steel Guitar." Boatright booked the
shows, promoted and publicized them, and
wrote the program. Their promotional ma
terials described the band as playing "Old
and New Numbers with Great Skill" and
also "Buck Dancing and Charleston Danc
ing" and "Blackface Musical Comedy Act."
Boatright told O'Connell:
Hawaiian-style guitar player,
plus my sister on ukulele. We played all
over this country, played in Southwest
I

got

Virginia

a

at

coal company

theaters at

We played old love songs, old
hillbilly songs, stuff like that, and Hawai
the camps.

ian songs. Got
Hawaiian style,

all dressed
at

a

up for tryouts,
theater. It was raining

change out of those uniforms
and thought we wouldn't get the gig, but
we did! Got to not only play at each the
ater, but played them all three times. My
so we had to

experience with entertaining

is make them

sad and then make them happy.

He was particularly proud of the "Ha
waiian" group because it afforded him
the chance to play the popular music of
the day, including the new sounds of the
Hawaiian slide guitar, which was fast be
coming commonplace in string bands.
Unlike many other string bands of the

String Band was able
to survive through the early years of the
Great Depression with the help of concerts
time,

the Boatright

sponsored by Kentucky coal companies,
which as a whole suffered the effects of the
collapsed economy, but not to the degree
that most other industries in the area did.
But by the end of 1932, the band had
more personnel changes. Melvin Robin-

to quit pursuing music as a
full-time occupation, and began working
as a carpenter. He had become a respected
and intimidating fiddle champion, and
had made several commercial records
with guitarist Byrd Moore, but decided it
was too difficult to make a living in music.
In 1933, Charley Powers left home after a

ette decided

quarrel with his father, joined the Army
and was stationed in Hawaii, never to be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�courtesy
of
the

Boatright family

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�seen in or around Scott County again. Hub
Mahaffey continued to play music with
Boatright and others for several years be
fore moving to Detroit, Michigan.
In 1942, in the middle of World War II,
Boatright, at the age of 36, was drafted

into the US Army. He was assigned to
the Eighth Air Force in Peterborough,

England, where he worked for several
months building airfield landing strips.
He was then transferred to Cambridge
and trained as a Military Policeman. Dur

ing his stay in England, he would rou
tinely entertain the troops in local pubs
by singing with his guitar and dancing,

would occasionally play as part of
shows in Cambridge, both solo

and

theater

with a fellow soldier from Illinois
who played accordion. An English news
paper article from the time says, "A wellvaried program was presented and was
warmly acclaimed by another packed
house at the 'Rex Services' Night.' One
of our American friends, Pte. Boatright,
with his guitar, sang Hill Billy songs and
finished with a tap dance."
His tenure in the armed forces was
cut short by the onset of severe stom
and

ach

causing him to be honor
discharged from service early in

ulcers,

ably

1944. On his trip back to Scott County
after returning from England, he met
his future wife, Janie Thompson. She
was riding the bus home from work at
Eastman Chemical Plant in Kingsport.
On the last day of spring that year, June

were married. The newlyweds
to the family farm in Fort
Blackmore and Boatright began carpen
try work. For a short time he made his
living in construction and repairs before
20, they

moved back

finding permanent employment as a fire
tower lookout with the National For
couple's first child, Sue
in
was
born
1945, followed by Scott
Ella,

est Service. The
Jr.

in 1947, and Billy in 1953.

During his child-raising years, music
and mostly private, pur
a modest,
suit. Boatright's job with the Forest Ser
vice afforded him time to continue work
ing on music while watching for forest
fires from the towers on Osborne Ridge
was

and Buckner

Ridge in Scott County. Sue

remembers bringing provisions to the
towers and hearing guitar music coming
Ella

from above. Mostly he would play alone,
a few times a year he would sing songs
for the family. Sue Ella remembers "Old
Shep," the Red Foley classic, in particular
because it would make her cry. Her dad
called it the "saddest country song ever
written." Sue Ella says she didn't know
but

Scott Boatright with accordion player Clarence Sorensen

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

England during World War

II

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

played the banjo until sometime in her
"It just kind of appeared." she said.
He retired from the Forest Service in
1975 and moved to Kingsport. In 1977,

he

teens.

working at Mountain Em
Community College and became in
volved with Home Craft Days, a festival
celebrating mountain culture, which she
Sue Ella began
pire

now runs. It was through this festival that
a new generation of musicians became

aware of Scott Boatright and the signifi
cance of his music. Among these young

musicians were Rich

Kirby, John McCutcheon, Tom Bledsoe, and Jack Wright,

who all spent time with Boatright absorb
ing his music and stories. He was also
visited by Mike Seeger, Blanton Owen,
Barry O'Connell, and others. Speaking of
country music, he told O'Connell:
I

believe we had better entertainment

than
day.

most of the bands they've got to
Played

and had more

more things

Boatright loved the singing of Jimmie
Rodgers, and disliked that of Kenny Rogers.
He admired the music of Rich Kirby and his
community of younger old-time musicians,
and appreciated Doc Watson. He saw Bill
Monroe once but thought that the banjo
playing was offensive and too loud.
Scott Boatright died in October 1996, but
is still remembered fondly in Scott Coun
ty as someone who took great pleasure
in passing on his music and ideas to the

younger generations. Sue Ella Boatright
still lives in Scott County on a property
adjoining land owned Dale Jett, the grand
son of A. P. and Sara Carter. The music of
Southwest Virginia lives on at the Carter
Family Fold, Home Craft Days, and many
other gatherings in the region.
Thanks

to

Sue Ella Boatright, Dean of Work

force Development at Mountain Empire Com
munity College in Big Stone Gap, Virginia, and

variety,

daughter of Scott Boatright. A passionate sup

parts, you

porter of the arts

good singers singing different
know, tenor and all, plus a
comedian and dancing. We would play

old

tunes

originals.

and

songs,

It has

new

changed

a

stuff,

and

lot though.

I don't
like all this 'honey' and 'baby'
I'm
not bragging, but I think the
stuff.

shows we used

to

taining than what

play were more
is done today.

enter

in

Southwest Virginia, she has

been very gracious in sharing the story of her
father and his life in music. Thanks also to her

brother Scott Boatright,

for his help supply
and
other information
ing photographs, articles,
about the family, and to Kalia Yeagle and Tyler
Jr.,

Hughes, who spent many hours transcribing
interviews, researching, and doing fieldwork.

�vi

7,.
Oimms

nPtmut Actuslu cl
yhop
a

'

903 East Main Street
Abingdon, VA 24210
(276) 525-1880
Shop Us Online1.
www .caposmusicstore.com
Store Hours: Monday -Friday 10-6 PM

'

Saturday 10-9PM
Join us for our Jam every Saturday at 6:30

We are proud to
CARRY

A

SELECTION
SHOP

BROAD
OF

SMALL

INSTRUMENTS

FROM THE

NATIONAL

FINEST

BUILDERS

AND LOCAL LUTHIERS
IN

OUR OWN

BACKYARD.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Section with Illegible Text

CHARILE

POOLE
Music

I

June

Festival

2015

12-13,

Morehead
Park
I Governor
I
422 Church Street, Eden, NC
f

H1

www.charlie-poole.com

II lifetime

Achievement
presented

Tony

1

1
s

V

Award

to

Rice

Conceif, Contests/Jamming. Free Camping
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

I
I

j

�Reviews

Fields Ward and the
Glory Land (1929)
You Must Be
Railsplitters:
Grayson County
a Lover of the Lord (1929)
Sid Harkread-

Work Hard, Play Hard, Pray Hard:
Hard Time, Good Time &amp; End Time

Music

er and

1923-1936

Grady Moore: The Gambler's Dying

Words (1927)

Kentucky Holiness Singers:
I'm On My Way (1930)
Snozvball and

Sunshine: Leave It There (1931)
Alfred
We'll Never Grow Old
J. Karnes: Where
Ernest Phipps and His Holiness
(1927)
If
the Light Has Gone Out of
Singers:
Your Soul (1928)
Taylor-Griggs Louisiana

When the Moon Drips
Red Brush
Away Into the Blood (1928)
Singers: Beyond the Starry Plane (1928)
Elder G.P. Harris: My Christian Friends in
Bonds of Love (c. 1933)

Melody Makers:

Hard Time Music, 1923-1930: Earl McCoy,
Alfred Meng, and Clem Garner John Henry
the Steel Drivin' Man (1930)
David McCarn Poor Man, Rich Man (Cotton Mill
Allen Brothers: I've
Colic No. 2) (1930)
Got the Chain Store Blues (1930)
Fiddlin' John Carson The Farmer Is the Man
Who Feeds Them All (1923)
Oscar Ford:
Earl John
The Farmer's Dream (1930)
son: When the Roses Bloom Again for the

Harry "Mac" McClinGo He That Car (1928)
Red

Bootlegger (1930)
tock: Jerry,

Gay and Jack Wellman:

Flat Wheel Train

Pierre La Dieu:
Blues, Parts 1 &amp; 2 (1930)
Saw
on
the
Plover (1928)
Driving
Logs
Darby and Tarlton: All Bound

Down

in

Texas (1929)
Buell Kazee: Poor Boy Long
from
Home
(1928)
Ways
Georgia Crack
ers:

Diamond

Joe (1927)

Bill

Chitwood

Fair (1927)

Tan

Soldier's Joy

and

Mountaineers: Fourth of July
Mountain

Gid

Don't Bother Me (1930)

North Carolina Hawaiians:
(1928)

esting and entertaining reissues of early
country music 78s that I have had the
pleasure of listening to and /or review
ing in quite a while. It is also the first set
of LPs I have ever reviewed, making this
my first ever actual record review. (The
set was also released on CD.) As we have
come to expect from Tompkins Square
releases, especially their box sets and re
issues, this collection is well-organized
and attractively packaged. Included is
a 60-page, well laid-out booklet that in
cludes many unusual, rare photographs

illustrations. More on that lat
Most 78 reissues are organized around

and other
er.

historical events, re
specific theme
gional musical styles, etc. This particu
lar collection focuses on three themes
la
common to the human condition
bor, recreation, and spiritual life. Each of
these themes is, in turn, the focus of one
of the three discs that make up the set.
As indicated by the title, the recordings
reissued here were made over a thirteenyear period during which county music
(not labeled "country music" at the time)
a

Good Time Music, 1927-1935:
ner and band: Work

I'll just say this up front. Work Hard, Play
Hard, Pray Hard is one of the more inter

His

Georgia

at the

Country

Warren Caplinger's Cumberland
Entertainers: McDonald's Farm

Carolina Ramblers String Band:
Frolic
Cherokee Ramblers:
(1932)
Barnyard
Home Brew Rag (1935)
Herschel Brown
(1928)

Corn-Shucking Party in Geor
Charlie
Wilson and His Hayloft
(1928)
gia
The
Beer
Aiken County
Gang:
Party (1933)
Whit
String Band: Charleston Rag (1927)

and His Boys:

Gaydon: Tennessee Coon Hunt (1929)
Hack String Band: Too Tight Rag (1929)

Oscar
Brothers: Cheat 'Em (1928)
Hide Away (1927)
Tennee ssee Ram
blers: The Preacher Got Drunk and Laid

Allen
Ford:

Down His Bible (1928)
End Time Music, 1927-1936: Gid Tanner:
You've Got to Stop Drinking Shine (1930)
Happy Four: Climbing the Golden Stairs
McDonald Quartette: Oh Declare
(1927)
Dixon Brothers: Easter
His Glory (1927)
(1936)
Georgia Yellow Hammers: I'm
Day
S-A-V-E-D (1927)
Corley Family: Way to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

underwent considerable reinvention and
evolution, as did the various mass media
which contributed to its popularity.

There's so much great material in this col
lection that discussing every cut is just not
possible. However, there are a few songs

on each disc that really grabbed my atten
tion, many of which I had heard for the
first time while listening to these CDs.
The material on the first disc, Work Hard:
Hard Time Music, 1923-1930, focuses on
the often interconnected subjects of hard

work and hard times, and is made up of
work songs, protest songs, laments, and a
couple of songs with a more light-heart
ed outlook. It starts off in high gear with
Earl McCoy and Clem Garner's unusual

�version of "John Henry the Steel Drivin'
Man," itself driven by McCoy's steel gui

playing, with strange chord changes
great harmony singing throughout.
The rest of the CD is indeed a mixed
tar

and

as well as by subject mat
from David McCarn's commentary
on working in the cotton mills, "Poor
Man, Rich Man," to the Georgia Crackers'
rough-and-ready tough luck song "Dia
mond Joe." In between we are treated to
songs about farmers (including Fiddlin'
John Carson's paean "The Farmer Is the
Man Who Feeds Them All"), lumber
jacks, bootleggers, railroad workers, and
drifters. Red Gay and Jack Wellman's ob
scure and previously un-reissued "Flat
Wheel Train Blues, Parts 1 &amp; 2" consists

bag, musically
ter

of

rambling dialogue between the engi

neer and fireman in

scribes encounters

a

locomotive.

It

de

and

sights along the
way, with train whistle and other sound
effects made by Gay's fiddling and Wellman's

finger-picked, open-tuned guitar
providing the rhythm of the train itself as
it moves down the track with a flat wheel
on one of the cars. Another standout track
is the Allen Brothers' "I've Got the Chain
Store Blues." Not only is this a great hill
billy blues performance, but the subject
matter itself (buy local) continues to have
relevance in contemporary times, with
its exhortation to working folks to avoid

shopping
shopping

at the

chain store and take their

home store man.
The subject matter of the second disc
can be neatly summed up by its title: Good
Time Music, 1927-1935. Of course, "good
times" means different things to different
people, so we are treated to a great vari
ety of good clean (or not) fun activities
put to music. Starting with Gid Tanner's
boys' ode to sloth, "Work Don't Bother
Me," and finishing up with the Tennes
see Ramblers' devil-may-care take on life
in "The Preacher Got Drunk and Laid
Down His Bible," we take musical ex
cursions to the county fair, the farm, and
to the

liquor-soaked corn-shuckings. Along the
way we make home brew, go to a beer
party, go on a raccoon hunt, and just have
a merry old time. The hilarity is broken
up by the inclusion of a few instrumentals, which contribute considerably to the
good times. The North Carolina Hawaiians play a great but almost unrecogniz
able rendition of "Soldier's Joy" on steel
guitar with guitar back-up. "Barnyard

Frolic," a rollicking version of "Cacklin'
Hen" played here by the Carolina Ram
blers String Band, may not be a true in

strumental because Steve Ledford sings

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

few lines about the old hen, but it makes
for a good dance tune nonetheless. The
Cherokee Ramblers take "Home Brew
Rag," made popular a few years earlier
by fellow Georgian Lowe Stokes and tear
it up here in an up-tempo harmonica-led

breakdown. City meets country on the
Aiken County String Band's mandolin
work-out,

"Charleston

Rag,"

and

the

Hack String Band's "Too Tight Rag" with
its fiddle and "jazzhorn" (kazoo?) duet.
Finally the Allen Brothers play one of
the strangest

Cheatham"

low-down versions
they call

it

of "Bill

"Cheat 'Em"

ever committed to shellac.
By the end of the week, all that fun and
hilarity may cause some folks to have re
grets and seek some sort of redemption,
which brings us to the third disc
End
Time Music: 1927-1936. Included here
is a wonderful sampling of early sacred
country music from a time before rural
white sacred and secular music became
the

separate genres. Granted, many
songs presented on this disc were drawn
from hymn books representative of vari
of

ous
the

denominations; the selections by
Happy Four and McDonald Quar

tette come straight out of Baptist shape
note songbooks, and the performance

by Snowball

and

Sunshine

sounds like

congregational singing straight out

of

a

church service. On the other hand, sev
eral selections are by performers better
known for their non-religious material,
including the Georgia Yellow Hammers
and

the

Grayson County Railsplitters.
songs themselves cover a wide
range, from songs of praise like the Mc
Donald Quartette's "Oh Declare His Glo
ry" to admonitions to leave the sinful life
behind, as in Sid Harkeader and Grady
Moore's "The Gambler's Dying Words"
(done to the tune of "Roving Gambler").
Gid Tanner's boozy take on "You've Got
to Stop Drinking Shine" is not bound to
The

convince many people to change their
ways, while the Taylor-Griggs Louisiana
Melody Makers' "When the Moon Drips

Away Into the Blood" maybe one of the
scariest end-time songs ever recorded.
No matter one's take on the subject mat
ter here, the music on this disc is simply

transcendent and powerful.
As mentioned earlier, this set includes

a

thick booklet containing rare old photo
graphs, discographic information about

the records used for the set, and wellwritten, illuminating essays by Nathan
Salsburg, Amanda Petrusich, Sarah Bry
an, and John Jeremiah Sullivan, in which
they each reflect about the music found

�each disc and the
about how most of the
reissue were acquired.
contains more than a
on

fascinating story
discs used for this
That story, which
little serendipity

and extremely good fortune, could be the
stuff of legend among 78 collectors. The

short version involves Nathan Salsburg,

the compiler of this set, getting a phone
call that alerted him to boxes of records

being discarded by a crew cleaning out
the apartment of a recently deceased re
cord collector who had had little contact
with the outside world. As it turns out,
Salsburg's luck is also our good fortune,
for we get to share in his bounty
form of this amazing collection.
JIM

To order:

in the
NELSON

tompkinssquare.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�to 2001, to a concert he and guitarist Mike
Miller gave at the North Central Michigan

Charlie Walden and Mike Miller

Old-Time and Hot Fiddling

Regional Fiddler's Convention.

That raises an interesting question.

If

you're

performing at a fiddle convention, an event
where people will have heard these tunes
countless times perhaps countless times
at that festival
why would you program

Forked Deer
Flop-Eared Mule
Grey Ea
Leather Britches
Listen to tire Mock
gle
ingbird
Rag

New Soldier's Joy
Beaumont
East
Dreamy Georgiana Moon

Tennessee Blues
Black
Sally Johnson
and White Rag
Clarinet Polka Memphis
Blues
Arkansas Traveler
Waiting for the
Robert

E.

Lee

Turkey in the Straw

Where previous recordings from fiddler
Charlie Walden have mixed, to varying

degrees, known and obscure tunes, "Old
Time and Hot Fiddling" is

a

set of

stan

dards, sixteen in all, including the seven
"bonus trax" that Walden states were "re

corded in somebody's basement."

The

first nine tracks on the album,

those not
recorded in "somebody's basement," date

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

such standards for your show? One guess
is that Walden and Miller recorded other
tunes at that convention, several of them
more obscure limes, but have grouped these
here to meet a theme, perhaps one focused
on display fiddling or contest fiddling style.
So, too, the selections from the basement
tapes. Of course, that's just a guess.
Asking that question should in no way

denigrate the work found here. Walden is a
highly-skilled fiddler/ musician with a nice
touch, a fine sense of melodic invention,
and lots of energy. At times his sound is
reminiscent of Arthur Smith's bluesy tone.
His website mentions the three Illinois state
fiddle championships he has won, winch
alone should make a strong case for his

playing. His website also mentions that this
"
concert was recorded "warts and all,
but
aside from a couple times when the fiddle
was a bit close to the microphone, and a
couple of minor intonation slips, I hear
nothing that should cause any concern.

I do hear is a set of short
(none lon
than
2:58
and
seven
than
less
two min
ger
utes) versions of old-time fiddle tunes such
as "Hop Eared Mule" and "Arkansas Trav

What

eler," set beside raggy and bluesy numbers

such as "Black and White Rag," "Memphis
Blues,"

and "Clarinet

Polka,"

all

of them

performed in a "hot" style. All but one of
them are fiddled over a two-beat rhythm
from Miller playing his guitar in a closedchord, bass /strum pattern that sometimes
walks tire chords but features very few walk
ing bass lines.

"Dreamy Georgiana Waltz"
two-beat
represents
pattern. In contrast to marry fiddle record
ings, Walden varies greatly his choruses,
tire one break from this

moving beyond simple ornamentation and
subtle rhythmic punctuations.
If there is one thing that is a detriment
here it is that almost all of the tunes are
in the same tempo.
Keys vary (G being

dominant), but only "Memphis

Blues"
and "Listen to the Mockingbird" fall out
side 120 beats per minute. That makes it
a bit
repetitive if taken all at once.

Given

that

all

the

arrangements

and

most of the tempos are the same, and giv
en that Walden plays with such consisten
cy from track to track, choosing highlights
is

somewhat difficult. Perhaps because

it

breaks most with the presentation of the

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

others, "Memphis Blues," slightly

swing

ing as it is, stands out. Because of its vari
ants, I also favorted Walden's version of

Beaumont Rag; because

I

haven't heard

it

that often, "Waiting For the Robert E. Lee";
and because it's a favorite tune of mine,
"East Tennessee Blues."
BILL WAGNER
To order:

cdbaby.com/cd/waldenmiller

�the

schmaltz might be just

a

bit over the

top, but by this point the band has earned
the right to be a bit schmaltzy.

Also here are two originals by Lewis, "Bell

and Anchor Rag" and "Route 77," both of
which are fine examples of writing in a by

gone style. "Bell and Anchor" has all those
"Chicken Reel" qualities, full of back-andforth slides and seat-of-the-pants raggy
"Route 77" uses the twin
syncopation.
banjo format of the turn of the century, but
tempers it with a bit of swing feel.

Though there is a familiarity in some of
song choices, the eclecticism, hand
ful of oddities, and musicianship, along
with humor and good feeling, makes this
the

a very fine recording of
vintage-sounding
American music.

BILL WAGNER
To order:

cornpotato.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�collection
of Paul
Wells

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Attic

THE WELL-DRESSED FIDDLER

...OR VIOLINIST?
F.Wells

By Paul

many of our excursions into the Attic I've drawn attention

to

people in the photographs presented have gener
taken
ally
pains to look and dress their best. It may be difficult for
in
people
today's world, in which smart phone selfies proliferate
the fact that the

In

by the thousands, to comprehend the fact that in times past the oc
casion of getting one's picture taken (or "made" if you were in the South)

was not something to be taken lightly. It required some planning, perhaps
travel to a distant studio, and enough money to pay the photographer's
fee. It was a time to trot out one's finest duds, perhaps get a haircut or
new 'do, and generally to spiff up as much as possible. After all, this was
to be a record for posterity, even if the thought of someone a century or so
later acquiring the photo and writing about it was unimaginable.
One thing we never see in these shots
predominantly rural musicians from

of

times past

is

anyone dressing

as

a

rube,

into

city people's
deliberately playing
stereotyped images of how country folk

dress. That sort of thing came later, dur
ing the era in which rural music and mu
sicians became professionalized, and was

imposed by mediators wishing

to

amp

up the music's

hillbilly image for radio
barn dance programs and such.
In the present installment we look at
fiddlers who took things further than
looking their Sunday best, and dressed
in attire that would have been acceptable
in the highest social circumstances. But
given this, can we be sure we're looking
at fiddlers and not violinists? Of course
we can't always be certain, but a little
probing lets us come up with some rea

sonable assumptions. In two instances
we're dealing with men who were known

at least one of whom
daresay
confounds our expectations in terms of
his musical endeavors. We'll begin with

quantities,

I

the other of the two.
The

regal-looking seated gentle
substantial loving cup at his
Llewellyn Powers, a New Hamp

very

man, with

a

feet, is
shire fiddler who lived from 1860

1951.

ager he joined "an orchestra specializing
dances." This most likely was a typical

in

New England quadrille band, an ensem
ble that usually contained a mix of string,
brass, reed, and percussion instruments,
and whose members played from written

music. The repertoire of such groups was
similarly mixed. Traditional jigs, reels,
and hornpipes were certainly present,
but so were waltzes, polkas, quadrille
sets, and other types of dance music. It
was the jigs and reels that Powers was

known

for later in life and that brought
him to the attention of people like Lin
scott and folk festival promoters. He may
have been a skilled note-reader but he

probably never played European cham
ber music. The photo is undated but it is
most likely from the mid-to-late 1930s. I
am unable to read the inscription on the
trophy, but presumably the winning of
provided the impetus for having this
beautiful studio photograph taken.
The photo of the two steely-eyed gents
seated with their instruments held upright
on their thighs comes from the Kelmestrud
it

studio that had branches in Twin Valley
and Ulen, Minnesota. Both towns lie in the
far west edge of the state, close to the North
Dakota border.

the cup is evidence of his success
tests
in them
performed at folk festivals as

They are separated by a
12 miles, and Ulen is only
about 40 miles from Fargo, North Dakota.
Neither town has ever been very large; in
the 1910 census, around the time this photo

far

was likely taken, each had

fiddler of some repute in
New England. He played in many con
Powers was

a

as Washington, DC, and record
independent folklorist Eloise Hub

away

ed for

bard Linscott in the 1940s. His first instru
ment is said to have been the cello but he
later taught himself the violin through
the use of an instruction book. As a teen

distance of only

population in
serious
young musicians are impeccably decked
out in three-piece suits, with high stiff col
lars and cravats, and one has an elegantlooking watch fob and chain. They look
the neighborhood

a

of 500. Our two

�ready to perform for the governor. Except
for their shoes. Their footwear is not quite
up to the standards of the rest of their out
fits, especially the fellow's on the left. Their

roughness hints

at

working-class status for

the wearer. Factor in the lack of chinrests

on the men's instruments and the sparsely
populated area of the photo's provenance,

seems more likely that our subjects
performed in small-town dance halls than
in orchestral venues.
The latter scenario is not impossible,
however. Fargo is currently home to the
and

it

Fargo-Moorhead
Symphony, a profes
sional orchestra that traces its roots to an
informal ensemble first formed in 1912 for
local Norwegian Saengerfest (song festi
val). It is within the realm of possibility
that our determined-looking young men
were among the ranks of the 40 musicians
said to have played at that event. Whatev
er their musical bents, they clearly wanted
to look their best when sitting for their
a

portrait in Ole Klemstrud's studio.

Perhaps string musicians in the upper
Midwest just had a high standard of
collection

dress in the early 20th century. Our next
image, of two standing guitarists and a
seated violinist, comes from the studio

of Paul

Huebschen in Milwaukee. Based
business addresses this shot prob

of John

on his

Wells

ably also dates from the first, or perhaps
second, decade of the century. Again, the

musicians are superbly turned out. But
what sort of music might a group with
this instrumentation have played? And
in what venues? Their polished look
and urban location makes playing at
country dances seem unlikely, though of
course they could have come into the big
city from out of town just to have their
photo taken. It also seems an improbable
combination to have played any sort of
classical music. Perhaps they specialized
in some sort of contemporary popular
dance music, such as rags or two-steps.
Whatever type of music they played,
they surely looked good while doing so!
The seated fiddler wearing the lovely
black hat in our fourth photo is another
Midwesterner. The photo is the work
of the Cottage Studio in Oelwein, Iowa.
Oelwein

is

a

good bit larger than the

Minnesota we just looked
two towns
but
still
not
at,
very large; its population
in

collection
of Paul

Wells

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was about 6,000

in

of

the mid-20th century

expansion

in

1910 and

after

a

bit
it

has shrunk again to about 6,400. Cottage

Studio began operations in 1896 so again
our photo probably dates from the first
decade or so of the 20th century. There is a

�collection

of
Paul Wells

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�name penciled on the back of the photo;
the first name has been obscured from
the photo having been glued into an al
bum at one point, but the last name is
clearly visible: Kiel. There are still Kiels
in Oelwein, and there was a Bert Kiel
who lived there from 1883-1956. From
what little is readable of the subject's first
name it might well have been Bert. The

time frame of his life is right for this to
a picture of him. Again, this is not an
area likely ever to have supported much
in the way of high culture. The man's re
laxed attitude with his instrument and
the fact that he's holding it against his
upper arm indicates that he probably

be

was a dance fiddler. And
some, well-dressed one.

a

very hand

Our next three examples have no

iden

tifying information regarding photogra
pher or location. The mustachioed man

standing and leaning with his left arm
on a tree stump is identified on the back

of the photo as D. W. Foreman. There is

further note that it was taken May 18,
1884. While Mr. Foreman is perhaps not
a

quite as elegantly dressed as some of the
others we've looked at, his long coat,
stiff collar, and tie give evidence of his
seriousness of purpose. As to what that

musical

purpose might have been, ev

erything about him screams "fiddler":

his bow grip, his left hand grip, the posi
tion of the instrument against his neck,
even the loop of
the lack of chin rest

leather or twine in the scroll by which
he could hang the instrument on a wall

rather than tuck it carefully away in a
case. Would that we knew where it was
that he plied his trade.
There is a hand-written name on the
back of the shot of the standing, left-hand
ed player but I can only guess at it: A. J.
Cuggner is the best I can do. This fellow

perhaps the least-polished looking of
sports a long
coat, tie, and a spiffy boutonniere in the
middle of his chest. That he was actually
a left-handed player and that we're not
looking at a print made from a flopped
negative can be borne out by examining
the buttons on his coat; they open in the
customary direction for men's clothing.
is

all in this gallery, but he still

collection
of Paul

Wells

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Again, his playing position tells us that
this was not a symphony player.
The seventh photo, of the two standing
fiddlers poised with bows on strings, is
my personal favorite of this batch. The
hairstyle of the
fellow on the left, the funky studio back
drop, and the lack of any attempt to co
ordinate bow positions between the two

curious-to-modern-eyes

�players, all contribute to give the photo a
feeling of subdued energy, of a restrained

wildness. There

is an aura

of shabby

el

egance and an almost Gothic feel about
the image. It calls to mind the famous
photo of Cajun fiddlers Eraste and Arville
Courville that is of a similar vintage, and
that appears on the cover of the Yazoo CD
release of the early recordings of Dennis

Of all the people featured in this
installment of the Attic, these are the folks
whose music I would most like to hear. I
rather doubt that they were playing any
of the Sonatas for Two Violins by Baroque
composer Jean-Marie Leclair! Alas, we
have no information whatsoever about
place, date, or identity of the musicians.

McGee.

all the

Among

musicians pictured here
I would
peg

the one who, on face value,

most definitely being a classical vio
linist rather than a fiddler, it is the man
as

final

our

example the elegantlywell-groomed fellow with the
instrument tucked under his right arm,

in

dressed,

the bow

And

I

hanging from his index finger.
would be wrong. This our second

known quantity:

it is a photo of Wiley
Marshall (1868-1951),
from Moberly,
Missouri, which was also the location of
the DeVinney studio who produced this
shot. Wiley Marshall was the grandfa
ther of present-day Missouri fiddler and
fiddle historian Howard Wight "Rusty"
Marshall. The younger Marshall is the
author of Play Me Something Quick and

Devilish:

Old-Time Fiddlers in Missouri,
in 2012 by the University of
Missouri Press (and soon to be reviewed

published
in

these pages).

includes a copy of this very same
photo of Wiley Marshall on p. 272 of the
book, and tells us that the elder Marshall
was, in fact, both fiddler and violinist. He
started out as a young man fiddling for
dances in the area, but later in life took
violin lessons from a Prof. Johannes Goetze. Goetze was a German immigrant
who founded and ran a music academy
in the area. Goetze also led an orchestra
that played both European art music and
more popular fare, such as accompani
ment for silent movies. Marshall played
in Goetze's orchestra, and presumably
He

Many thanks to Steve Green for biographi
information about Llewellyn Poivers.

cal

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Paul
collection

of

"ready to play in Goetze's orchestra, ca.
1900." What he wore while fiddling for
dances we are not told,

Wells

kept his fiddling chops in shape at the
same time. Of the photo, Howard Mar
shall says that it shows Wiley Marshall

�collection
of Paul
Wells

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�LEAD BELLY: THE SMITHSONIAN FOLKWAYS COLLECTION

Section with Illegible Text

"This

is a

powerful time

to

hear Lead Belly's voice again"

NPR

The first career-spanning, in-depth box set
dedicated to the American music icon
5

CDs/108 Tracks (16 unreleased)

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings

Copyright
© 2021
ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.
Section with Illegible
Text

Enter code LEADBELLYOTH
through 3/31/15 for

a

20%

at folkways.si.edu
discount on this box set

�VINTAGE

NAUCK'S
RECORDS

Rare Records
JL

mirJk

frit

1Kb

L!BHj8 ^EBSTa'Wt

H'V^Ii 't-

I

fc

"Tr I

-m^

-ti L
:V

f

T-^7

4 jC 1

Ja

i
T C

■Iil

54

1

J]

gfl
01

Superbly Presented

Accurately Graded

_*

rJ TIW

TbJJ

pTBi

"■!

f

Til

Victor

win
HH
.H

J **' V

H

f
Mr?
E

LI

i k

',&lt;
NnV

,ssa

(Will

J)1
&lt;/

Shade)

Memohis Jue Band

C

Dance Orchestra with harmonica
Vocal

retrain

by

Shade-Ramey-Weldon

JIMMIE

&lt;nd

'

\l

E}3?1

gUmH
uHlllSll^^^L
Bk

\A
v$V

v\

"

1

p

J

t

i

I'll

PREACHIN' BLUES
(UP Jumped the Devil)
-JohnsonROBERT

JOHNSON

vi

Gu^

with

6 r

"o

si

A

fnl

/'/

S0l3

\X\

',

",

e
IS

Evangelist

coming
R

H.

ill

'

I

&amp;$$&gt;.
f

l
"A

'*
'i

v

:::7''.-

J

"*-

9tt

1

Af

PATml llhi|
t|

Harris

B
'- V'-*

'

N

the aeouan company

5

Lady

AH

P^H

SOON

of the

I

"ODGERS

ft

s""""

A

JESUS

Mr

^0?

\I

K

Pj
y))

KANSAS CITY BLUES

\A

ki^'TT^'

W2ii85-A|

'v

jfjr

J^BL\

I

I

I

are the world's largest dealers

g

Cjt

_

r
cr&gt;

V

Please Note

Piccolo and Piano

IRISH SET PJECE

R J'

vintage 78rpm &amp; cylinder recordings.
Contact us if you have quality records for sale,
or if you would like to receive our auction catalogs.
in

lk

i

jockey

McNAMARA

C/^o
^&gt;/?Aph Recoup

v

g

Audio Equipment
Custom Styli &amp; Turntables

Disc-O-File Record Sleeves
Books

&amp;

Discographies

77389-4539
Spring, Texas
930-6862
Fax:
(425)
(281)288-7826

22004 Sherrod Lane
Phone:

we do not deal in LPs, CDs, tapes or 45s!

Collector &amp;
Archival Supplies

Jf

nauck@78rpm.com

Copyright
© 2021
ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.
Section with Illegible
Text

I

,!^-'

/j\j/

'

1

'

3':

ft.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12134">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 13, Number 12 (March 2015)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12135">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12136">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 13, Number 12 (March 2015)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Tales from the ‘Woods, Part 11: Kent State,” by Walt Koken&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“2015 Festival and Camp Guide”&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Scott Boatright: Make Them Sad and Then Make Them Happy,” by Roy Andrade&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dance Beat: Dare To Be Square: Passing It On,” by Phil Jamison&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Harold Luce; Julia Mae Brown Mainer; Lester McCumbers; and Robert Lee Dotson;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12137">
                <text>2015</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="1632">
        <name>2010s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2762">
        <name>2015</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6467">
        <name>Harold Luce</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5497">
        <name>Highwoods String Band</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6468">
        <name>Julia Mae Brown Mainer</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5491">
        <name>Kent State University</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6145">
        <name>Lester McCumbers</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5474">
        <name>Phil Jamison</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6469">
        <name>Robert Lee Dotson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5493">
        <name>Roy Andrade</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5492">
        <name>Scott Boatright</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="970">
        <name>Square Dancing</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5460">
        <name>Walt Koken</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2513" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3438">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/7c574889dc2837df95a7d5161c674b69.pdf</src>
        <authentication>bf62e4204181d9e50de49d93fc64835e</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12142">
                    <text>THE OLD-TIME

HERALD
VOLUME

14, NUMBER

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

$7.00

A SEA OF THINGS TO LEARNS
AN INTERVIEW WITH BILL HICKS

�i

A BLUEGRASS EVENT LIKE

IE f Oil

OTHER IN

26th ANNUAL

BMA BUSINESS

BLUEGRASS MUSIC

INTERNATIONAL

CONFERENCE/EXPO

AWARDS SHOW

SEPT 29

THURS,

IBMA

OCT

RALEIGH

1

CONVENTION

Business Conference

is

CENTER

Awards Show

share and discover the

to

Section with Illegible Text
INTERNATIONAL BLUEGRASS MUSIC ASSOCIATION

empower. NEW this year:

WORLD OF

Afternoon Showcases
Nearly double the cutting-edge

PRESENTED

BLUEGRASS

World of

BY

Q C/l/fiS/

With

This unique

you the

the annual bluegrass

of

offerings for every bluegrass
and fan!

the world!

in

networks,

industry best practices,

in

discovering new bluegrass music, and seeing some

business conference registration.
Ramble-only passes also available.

with full

of

DE OPEN

PNc

BLUEGRASS FESTIVAL
OCT

2-3

DOWNTOWN

RALEIGH

5 RED

HAT

AMP

This year's line up for Wide Open

Bluegrass

is

even more incredible than

last year, with Alison Krauss &amp; Union

week-long event provides the unmatched

learning the latest

showcases

music

industry event and

opportunity for expanding your professional

hottest acts shaping bluegrass music
today! Privileged access to all

is

multifaceted

professional

VARIOUS DOWNTOWN VENUES

Ramble brings

a

festival with hundreds

over 150 showcase performances,

the Bluegrass

Bluegrass

homecoming,

RAMBLE
1

bluegrass acts

2015

SEPTEMBER 29-0CT0BER 3, 2015-RALEIGH, NC

OCT

and featuring performances by the best

BLUEGRASS

panels and workshops

RALEIGH, NC

SEPT 29

Bluegrass Music
the biggest night on the

is

bluegrass calendar, recognizing
outstanding achievement in the genre

latest tools, strategies, technology and
sounds. Designed to educate and

seminars,

MEMORIAL AUDITORIUM

RALEIGH

1

The International

the

premier industry event for bluegrass

professionals

OCT

your favorite perfomers.

Station featuring Jerry Douglas, Sam
Bush Band, Steep Canyon Rangers,
The Infamous

Stringdusters

and many

more! Plus, our FREE Streetfest includes
over 80 bands on

5

stages.

BLUEGRASS MUSIC MOVES VOU. COME TO THE EVENT THAT MOVES BLUEGRASS MUSIC!
REGISTERTOOAYATIBMA.ORG

h

HLsL:

aut

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

i

■&gt;

.JA. .ardttiwitfiiiu

&gt;

a

t

a
..-&lt;i

JB

ftrjiiiW

niMM

�I

www, Fieldrecorder
Section with Illegible Text

New

Releases from the Field Recorders' Collective

CD

Dean Sturgill (FRC710) Bom in 1934 in Ashe County, NC, Sturgill is a wonderful
old-time fiddle
and poet who was a favorite at the fiddlers conventions and
player
square dances in the area for many years. This is a sampling of his recorded work
with the Grayson Highlands Band and some of his finest poems, read by him.

Vesta Johnson

Johnson was a true master of traditional American
Craig Johnson (FRC71
music. This CD features rare recordings of songs (a cappella or backed by banjo or
guitar) and fiddle tunes, including solo pieces plus performances with the Double
Decker String Band. There are traditional songs and tunes as well as a number of
Craig's originals, highlighting the immense breadth and depth of his music.

showcases Vesta's extensive repertoire

Old Time Fiddle Music of

and delicately nuanced notes, as well as his unusual
music a unique sound.

schottisches,

Parker was

a

generation old-time musician, Vesta Johnson

CD (from recordings made in 1991)
breakdowns, waltzes, two-steps, and

number of tunes that no one else plays.

a

including

of

Darley Fulks (FRC716) Much of Darley Fulks' (1895-1990) repertoire came from
fiddlers of his grandfather's generation and represents some of the oldest fiddle
music we can trace in Kentucky. Even in his 80s, Darley's deep feeling for the music

Alleghany County, NC (FRC712) An exciting
anthology featuring 5 fiddlers, Lawn Brooks, Mack Brooks, Kilby Reeves, Cleave
Andrews, and Howard Joines from musically rich Alleghany County, NC. It's old
time fiddle music covering the full spectrum of the genre.
(FRC71 3)

A 4th

5)

home state of Missouri! This new

music-rich

1

Maggie Parker

(FRC71

the quintessential North Missouri dance fiddler, with impeccable timing and an
uncanny feel for phrasing. No wonder she has received so much recognition in her
is

sense of timing, gave his

Ralph Whited (FRC71

7)
Ralph Whited may be best known for his tune "Possum
Gum Stump," the title track from the classic CD compilation of 19th and 20th
Century Alabama fiddlers. This well-recorded set of tunes spotlights his driving,

Up

member of the well known Hammons

family of West Virginia. Maggie had an enormous repertoire of traditional songs,
some of them rarely heard from other singers. She was a fine banjo player as well,
and this CD displays many of the special features of her singing and her playing.

a

blues-inflected,

breakdown-style

fiddling.

Carlton Rawlings (FRC718)

Tom Fuller (FRC71 4) Though Oklahoma fiddler Tom Fuller's name may be
unfamiliar, his tunes have been spread far and wide, notably by Brad Leftwich.
These recordings, made near the end of Fuller's long life, still show his distinctive

home recordings put him

arrangements, intricate bowing, strong rhythm, and clear phrasing.

community.

Roberts,

Ed

recordings

in

Those who have heard the Carlton Rawlings
the same league with the great Kentucky fiddlers

Haley, and Buddy Thomas. This CD is
of a great fiddler who never received

Doc

assembled from the only known
recognition beyond his own

Section with Illegible Text

OTHER CATALOG
Ray Alden

LISTINGS
Clyde Davenport Vol. 2 FRC1 04
Reverend Gary Davis FRC1 6

Ray's Dream FRC1 5
John Ashby &amp; the Free State Ramblers
FRC1 08
1

Walter Babson FRC31
P.T.

Bell

Berkeley

3

in

the

1

960s FRC609

Heywood Blevins FRC508
Dock Boggs FRC305
Dock Boggs
966 FRC31 2
Dewey Balfa FRC207
Balfa Brothers &amp; Nathan Abshire

Galax Gems

Gaither
Ernie

1

FRC1

Chokers

Cockerham

1

1

1

8

FRC603

FRC1 01

Bill Cornett
FRC304
Banjo
FRC1 03
Clyde Davenport Vol.
1

You can order via our

Ola Belle

Tommy Jarrell Vol. 2 FRC21
Ward Jarvis FRC402

FRC302

2

FRC309

Santford

2

FRC503

Kelly

Fiddling Van Kidwell FRC412
Kimble &amp; Wagoner Families FRC106

John Hannah

Addie

FRC405

Albert

Hash FRC41

Albert

Hash, Volume

The

Leffew

&amp;

Claude Wolfenbarger

FRC509

1

2

FRC707
1

FRC1

1

9

Hellbenders FRC700

Uncle Charlie Higgins, Wade Ward &amp; Dale
Poe FRC501
The

Horse Flies FRC602

The

Hurricane

McGee

Marcus

Martin FRC502

&amp; Sady Courville

Sidna &amp; Fulton Meyers
Howard Miller FRC706

Rector Hicks FRC709

Ridgerunners FRC604

website and pay using PayPal

FRC308

FRC504

J

Buddy Thomas

Round Peak Vol.1

Wade Ward FRC507

Round

Peak Vol.

2

FRC1 10

WV Musicians

Sexton FRC105

Obray Ramsey &amp; Byard Ray FRC1

Corbett

3

Kilby

Jimmy Wheeler FRC401

CD,

Ray &amp;

Virgil

B

III

Stamper FRC306

send

Aunt Jenny Wilson

pal

Mike Rogers FRC505
Snow FRC205

or credit cards. To order via US mail,

of Clay &amp; Calhoun

Counties FRC202

Lonnie Seymour FRC403
Arnold Sharp FRC406

Manco Sneed, Byard

FRC303

Union Grove 1969 FRC114

FRC109

a

FRC408

Anderson FRC1005

Clyde Davenport FRC1 004
Roan Mt Hilltoppers

FRC1002

Clyde &amp; Ralph Troxell FRC1 003

check

$20 each DVD

I

Field Recorders' Collective, 6206 Washington Street, Ravenna, OH 44266

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Texas Fiddle Bands FRC409

Ross County Farmers FRG07
Band in Transition (Round Peak) FRC102

Nee Ningy Band FRC610
The Plank Road String Band FRC606
Cecil Plum FRC404
1

Stoneking FRC708

Dan Tate FRC506

FRC201

FRC209

Blackard Family FRC112
Chirps Smith FRC608

The

"

Lee

John Summers FRC310

Shelor

made payable to the Field Recorders' Collective to the address below. $15 each
PI IIS SS fnr Kt fla&lt;;&lt;;
Mail Snprial nnantitv sale nrirp&lt;; on' nnr wph sitp
ton!
...w,...
T
p-

Roberts

Lee

Dennis

Reed FRC203

Renegades FRC605
Vemon Riddle FRC120
Roan Mountain Hilltoppers

The

Dink

George FRC407
Jeff Goehring FRC601

Harold Hausenfluck Vol

7

Carpenter FRC204

The Chicken
Fred

FRC1

Carlton FRC1

Vol.

Frank

1

Jont Blevins

Edmonds

FRC107

1

1

Norman

FRC41 0

Hutchins

Esker

The Indian Creek Delta Boys FRC607
FRC211
Tommy Jarrell Vol.

1

Dixie Hummingbirds FRC208
Norman Edmonds Vol.
FRC301

i

The Field

Recorders'
Collective

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

VOLUME 14,

NUMBER

1

FEATURES
The Folk Box: A Forgotten, Yet Unforgettable,
Album from the Folk Era 8
By Ted

Olson

Tales from the 'Woods, Part 12:

J.

P.

and Roscoe

18

By Walt Koken
A

Sea of Things to Learn:

An

Interview with

Bill Hicks

20

By Sarah Bryan

The Banjo Collector's Gathering
By Krishna Gaddy

34

COLUMNS
HERE &amp;
ATTIC

THERE/ 4
49

DEPARTMENTS
CORRECTIONS

CLASSIFIEDS
REVIEWS

3

38

39

Rock and Roll Hall or Fame and Museum
Library and Archives

2809 Woodland Ave.
Cleveland, OH 44115

RECEIVED

AUG

1

1

2015

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

Old-Tim? Music

I

Week
October

15

18, 2015

at the

Alabama Folk School
at Camp

McPowcll

Offering advanced-beginner and
intermediate-advanced classes by:

Paul Brown, Fiddle I
Erynn Marshall, Fiddle

II

Shields, Mandolin I
Sam Bartlett, Mandolin II
Joyce Cauthen, Guitar I
Hilary Dirlam, Guitar II
Terri McMurray, Banjo I
Carl Jones, Banjo II
Mick Kinney, Repertoire
Pat

I

105 DeLong Rd.
Nauvoo, AL 35578

I

205.387.1806

I

www. Alfolkschool

I

com

�Section with Illegible Text

Weekend Music Camps

Small classes, great
teachers, and a

whole lot of

FUN!

specialize in classes at
all levels for Fiddle,
Clawhammer Banjo, Guitar,
Bass and Singing
_
We

Camp Director:
Jane Rothfield

J

e'

www.JaniesJumpstart.com
SAVE THE DATE!: April 1-3,

Oxford

2016

PA

plans for weekends in
Vermont, North Carolina,
Georgia, Texas &amp; Washington
20

7

6

Scan to go to website
and keep information
on your phone or tablet.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Clay Russell (Troutdale, Virginia),
Sonah Riddle (Burnsville), Travis Watts
(Toast), Evan Hoots (Olin), Luciya Sulli
van (Winston-Salem). Adult Guitar: Pre
sley Barker (Traphill), Andy Edmonds
(Mount Airy), Steve Kilby (Mouth of
Wilson, Virginia), Christian Cail (Mount

Banjo:

Airy), A1 Barnosky (Durham). Youth Gui
tar: Presley Barker, Brody York (Mount
Airy), Soyara

Sullivan (Winston-Salem),

Grayson Riddle (Burnsville). Adult Bass:
David George (Westfield), Lulu Furtado
(Front Royal, Virginia), Jason King (Pleas
ant Garden), Barbara Bowman (Mount
Airy), Hannah Robins (Roanoke, Vir
ginia). Youth Bass: Jackson George (West
field). Adult Dobro: Robert Ellis (Mocks
ville), Alan Jolley (Gastonia),
Danny

Hargis

(Huntersville),

Moller

Stephen

(Elgin, Illinois), Pammy Davis (Pleasant
Garden). Adult Mandolin: Vincent Bull
ins (Lawsonville), Ben Somerville (Rock
ville, Maryland), Greg Jones (Mount Airy),
Karl Smakula (Montrose, West Virginia),
Joseph Scott (Mount Airy). Youth Man
dolin: Elijah Moore (Kernersville), Caleb
Covney (Boone), Chaney Parsons (Roar
ing

River),

Ian

Madden

(Chapel

Adult

Hill).

(Mouth

Autoharp: Penny Kilby
Virginia), Vickie Boyd (Laurel
Fork, Virginia), Christine Olson (Garner),
Michael Poole (Pittsboro), Jimmy Handy
(Woolwine, Virginia). Adult Dulcimer:
Hunter Walker (Beckley, West Virginia),
Ehukai Teves (Bryson City), Kirk House
(Winston-Salem), Lois Hornbostel (Bryson
City), Dick Lamb (Keezletown, Virginia).
Adult Folk Song: John Goad (Rogersville,
Tennessee), Elizabeth Baker (Front Royal,
Virginia), Elizabeth LaPrelle (Rural Re
of Wilson,

Meadows, Virginia), The Country
Boys (Mount Airy). Youth Bluegrass Band:
Durham Yungins (Chapel Hill). Most
(Max

Promising Youth: Presley Barker.
Winners at this year's Henry Reed Me
morial Fiddlers' Convention, held June 12
13 in Newport, Virginia, were as follows.
Old-Time Fiddle: Steve Kruger, Tessa Dil
lon, George Aschmann, Betty Vornbrock,
Bill Blevins. Old-Time Banjo: Steve Kru
ger, Russ Boyd, Chip Arnold, Hunter
Walker, Mike Harrison. Old-Time Guitar:
Jon Benfield, Billy Cornette. Mandolin:
Rick Hall, Paul Boone, Addison Dobbs.
Banjo-Fiddle Duet: Betty Vornbrock and
Ron Mullennex; Tessa Dillon and Ga
briel Skogland; Lieselotte Heil and Steve
McCumsey; Paul Herling and Ginger
Wagner. Bluegrass Banjo: Lane Robert
son, Nessie Hunt, Mike Crawford, Jacob

Right, Kenny Hamblin. Bluegrass Guitar:
Brandon Hilton, Rick Hall, Jon Benfield,
Sam Albert. Folk Song: Jina Gillis-Rosen-

crans, Fred Benfield, Lieselotte Heil, Lon
Reid. Dulcimer: Hunter Walker, David
Park, Matt Peyton, Tim Thornton, Chuck
Richardson. Bass: J. W. Meade, Ron Tru
man. Dance: Danny Williby, Judy Atkin
son, B. K. Hodges. Old-Time Band: The
Critters, Ridge
Valley String Band, Reed Island
Rounders, Tone Tied. Bluegrass Band:
Blue Connection, Blue Rock'n Grass.
At the Charlie Poole Festival, held June
13 in Eden, North Carolina, winners were
as follows. (Winners' hometowns in North

Diggers, Craig County
and

Carolina, except as noted.) Grand Cham
pion, Old-Time Three-Finger Banjo: Seth
Swingle (Earlysville, Virginia). Clawham
mer

Banjo:

Robert

Stowe

(Stoneville),

treat, Virginia), Tommy Nichols (Mount
Airy), Ted Turner (Max Meadows, Virgin
ia). Youth Folk Song: Carson Peters (Piney

Seth Swingle, Micahlan Boney (Claxton,
Georgia), Jason Hughes (Greensboro),
Jamie Rowen (Wilmington). Bluegrass

Flats, Tennessee), Lillian Chase

Banjo: Jay

ville),

Aila

W.,

Anneli

(Weaver

Burnett, Eliza
Dance: Marsha

Beyer (Raleigh). Adult
Todd (Mount Airy), Becky Hill (Elkins,
West Virginia), Becky Wood (Martinsville,
Virginia), Emolyn Liden, Aaron Ratcliffe
(Greensboro). Youth Dance: Travis Watts
(Toast), Liam Purcell, Marissa Colter

(Clemmons), Kenyon Purcell (Boone),
Paxton Ashe (Galax, Virginia). Adult OldTime Band: Slate Mountain Ramblers
(Mount Airy), Crooked Road Ramblers
(Crumpler),

Strickly

Strings
Bolts

(State

(Boone),
Road),

Lightning
Buckstankle Boys (Mount Airy). Adult

Zephyr

Bluegrass Band: Uncle Touchy and Feel
ers (Lewisville), Crossroads (Mount Airy),
Fiddlin Carson Peters Band (Piney Flats),
Adam McPeak and Mountain Thunder

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Adams (Spray), Jacob Harbour
(Danbuiy), Christian Yates (Hampton,
Tennessee), Johnathan McHone (Walnut
Cove), Seth Swingle. Old-Time Fiddle:
Riley (Greensboro), Liam Purcell
(Deep Gap), Aaron Ratcliffe (Greensboro),
Katie
Christen Blanton (Greensboro),
Griffin (Eden). Bluegrass Fiddle: Katie
Griffin, Micahlan Boney, Liam Purcell,
Holly Riley, George Cox (Ruffin). Flat

Holly

Pick

Guitar: Jeremiah Jobe (Reidsville),
Liam Purcell, Johnathan McHone, Jacob
Harbour, Glenn Craver (Winston-Salem).
Finger-Style Guitar: Jeremiah Jobe, Glenn
Craver, Mark Dillon (Randleman), Elijah
Buist (Eden,). Charlie Poole Song: Robert
Stowe (Stoneville), Aaron Ratcliffe and
Nora Weatherby (Greensboro), Jacob Har
bour, Linda Henry and Jerry Dallal (Ar-

�lington, Massachusetts). Solo Vocal: Han
nah Lomas (Wilmington), Holly Riley,
Christen Blanton, Matt Nelson (Littleton),
Nora Weatherby (Greensboro). Duet Vo
cal: Hannah Lomas and Jamie Rowen,
Katie Griffin and Tyler Wiseman (Eden,
North Carolina and Hampton, Tennessee),
Linda Henry and Jerry Dallal, Holly Ri
ley and Emily Damrel (Greensboro), Ja
mie Priddy and Emily Priddy (Madison).
Folk Song: Mark Dillon, Holly Riley, and
Emily Damrel (Randleman), Micahlan
Boney, Hannah Lomas and Jamie Rowen,
Liam Purcell, Christen Balton. Youth Vo
cal: Micahlan Boney, Elijah Buist, Bailee
Ander
Ridlon (Reidsville), Meredith
son (Reidsville).

Glenn

Nelson,

Open Instrument:
Craver,

Matt

Johns
Johna(Huntington
than McHone, Micahlan Boney. Youth
Instrument: Micahlan Boney, Jeremiah
Jobe, Elijah Buist, Grace McCrickard
Beach,

Henry

California),

(Greensboro), Lily Moore (Summerfield).
Old-Time Band: The Stray Zincs (Greens

Crooked Cousins (Greensboro),
The Usual Suspects (Brevard), Advanced
Note Dodgers (Greensboro).
Bluegrass
Band: Lonesome Rails (Hampton, Ten
nessee), Port City Pickers (Wilmington),
Flat Mountain Outlaws (Danbury). Youth

boro), Yer

Weather
(Reidsville),
Moore the Merrier (Summerfield).
Band:

Hot

The

produced festivals, recordings, national
and international tours, wrote articles,
books, and created the Blue Ridge Music
Center and the Roots of American Music
exhibit housed there. He rebranded Hwy.

runs through Southwest Virginia
Crooked Road and made the cul
ture and music found along this route an
important part of the region's economy.
His keen political sense made him a great
advocate for the arts and all the artists he
loved so much. Joe loved a good politi
cal fight almost as much as he loved tra
ditional music, but to all who knew him
we all knew that the thing that drove him,
inspired him, fed him, was the music, al
ways the music.
as the

Joe gave his life to his passion and in turn
was repaid with every conceivable honor
and award the world of folklife has to of
a National Endowment
National Heritage Fellowship
in 2001, the nation's highest honor for tra
ditional artists. The Library of Congress
named him a Living Legend in 2009. But
the honor he most appreciated was the
love, respect and gratitude shown to him
by all the people whose lives he touched.

fer.

He received

for the Arts'

survived by his wife, Kathy James;
his daughters Melinda Wilson and Lau
and her husband Joel
rie Niswander
Niswander, and his grandchildren Wesley
and Emma Niswander; his step-daughter,
Joe is

Jacqueline Pfeffer; the mother of Melinda

Joe Wilson left us on Sunday, May 17,
2015. He left us a legacy so vibrant and
alive that even though his physical pres

and Laurie, Patricia Wilson; his brother,
James Walter Wilson; his sister, Julia Wil
son; his sister-in-law Helen Wilson; his
nieces and nephews Paul Wilson, Yvonne
Wilson, Bryan and Judy Wilson, Teresa

from the phrase "gone but not forgotten."
Joe was born on March 16, 1938, in Creston, North Carolina, the second son of Jo
sephine and James Wilson. When Joe was

about two years old the family moved to
Trade, Tennessee, where he grew up with
his older brother, Kenneth, and his two
younger siblings, James Walter and Julia.
He embraced his Blue Ridge Mountain
cultural heritage with love and passion,
and he shared that love with everyone he
met. Joe was always eager to learn new

things and this curiosity about the world

and other traditions gave him the ability
to embrace the cultures and traditions of
people from all over the world.
His long tenure as the Executive Director
of the

National Council for the Traditional

Arts (NCTA) provided Joe with the plat
form he needed to spread his traditional

culture gospel all across the globe.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

He

Ritchie's life and music appears on page
12 of this issue of the Old-Time Herald.

58 that

Final Notes

ence is gone, his spirit and his passions live
on in all of us who knew and loved him.
His time here on Earth removes the cliche

Appalachian musician and National Her
itage Fellow Jean Ritchie died on June 1
in Berea, Kentucky. A remembrance of

and

Danny

Hott,

Jessica Wilson, Neil
and Bryce Ed

James, Andrew James,

wards; his mother-in-law,

Maryse James;

and his brother-in-law, George James.
A celebration of Joe's life, work, and
legacy was held on June 25, 2015, at the

Blue Ridge Music Center, at Mile Post
213 on the Blue Ridge Parkway at Galax,

Virginia. A second celebration is being
planned later in the summer in Washing
ton, DC (date, time, and place to be an
nounced on the National Council for the
Traditional Arts' website, ncta-usa.org).
In lieu of flowers, it is the wish of the
family that contributions in memory of
Joe's life, work, and legacy be made to the
National Council for the Traditional Arts
(NCTA) to support programs that promote
and benefit the Blue Ridge Music Center
and the artists of the Blue Ridge region:
NCTA, 8757 Georgia Avenue, Suite 450,
Silver Spring MD 20910.
Kathy James

Jonathan Bekoff died at home in the night
between June 14 and 15, 2015, after a threeyear illness and the culmination of a life

long spiritual journey. Jon was born May
8, 1959, in New York. Raised in Montreal,
Canada, he also lived in Ohio, Virginia,
Oregon, and Vermont before settling in

Greenfield,

Massachusetts,

in

1996.

He

gifted math teacher in Vermont for
27 years; as his principal recalled, "Jon was
a gentle soul and loved to connect with
was

a

people, especially with the kids."

Jon had passions for studying, collect
ing, playing, mentoring, and sharing
roots music of the world, particularly
American old-time and music of Africa
(e.g. Malian, Congolese, Shona) and the

African

diaspora

cumbia). Jon was

(e.g.

mento,

Haitian,

multi-instrumentalist,
mandolin,
banjo, kora,
playing guitar,
fiddle
was his
but
old-time
etc.,
balafon,
a

forte. Jon started fiddling in 1978,

and

quickly mastered several regional styles,

though he seemed to prefer the excite
ment and danceability of early Geor

gia string bands and favored the "great
Southern waltzes" of the 1920s and 1930s.

developed a unique style of "comple
mentary" fiddling, drawing from the Cajun tradition, but applying his own char
acteristic countermelodies,
harmonies,
and
syncopated double-stops. When
asked why he developed this accompa
nist approach to fiddling, Jon simply said
it was "fun" and he never understood
Jon

why others didn't also do it.
Jon was extremely self-effacing

and

shunned performance opportunities and
large festivals in favor of jamming with

small groups of friends around Western
Massachusetts, Upstate New York, and
Vermont. He exerted a subtle yet per
vasive influence in his music commu
nity through His enthusiasm for source
recordings,
playing with "mentees,"
and seeing

the

excitement of discovery

others. Anyone who came in contact
with him came away with his or her cu
riosity awakened and courage bolstered.
As a gifted teacher, he had an intuitive
ability to assess the strengths of his play
ing partners; his sensitivity and giv
ing nature drew the best out of players,
while gently buoying their weaknesses.
in

The

blog

Oldtime

wordpress.com)

Party

was Jon's

(oldtimeparty.
passion from

�about 2011 to 2015. Jon described it as an ar
chive of collected material including articles
on music history, album and book reviews,
and links to other repositories of "mostly
southern American vernacular music." The

content reflects his scholarly interest in the
people who field-recorded roots music (e.g.,
his "holy triumvirate" of old-time:
Alan
Lomax, Harry Smith, and Moses Asch), and
the diversity of posts underscores his
cultural interests in roots music.

Jon's last words were laid out in

multi
a

let

family and friends, in which he
informed us that His last year of life was
ter

to

his "most peaceful, clarifying, and

mean

addition to communing with
ingful."
others fltrough music, Jon adored spend
In

ing

His

last

few years

alone,

exploring
alternative healing, spirituality, reading,
listening to audiobooks, podcasts, and his
vast music collection, and hunting materi
al for his blog. Jon left this world without
fear and with profound gratitude for Jus
56 wonderful years. As our folk acoustic
curator, he lined up blog posts until His
last two weeks of life. Let us honor him by
taking a moment to browse through the
blog's archives, which includes a more
detailed musical obituary with links to
learn more about Jon's music. Jon never
made commercial recordings, but hours
of his unique style can be observed at the
MoonsfiineV Old-time Field Recordings
YouTube channel. Anyone who wants to
contribute content can contact the blog at

oldtimepartyblog@gmail.com.
Moonsfiine
(Excerpted with permis
sion from oldtimeparty.wordpress.com.)
the
Lalumondier,
Lloyd
legendary
French-American old-time, bluegrass,
country, and swing fiddler from Festus,
Ste. Genevieve County, Missouri, died
June 30, 2015, from the cumulative com

health. Lloyd was 91, and
had been in failing health since the death
of his wife and musical partner, George-

plications

of ill

na, in 2013. After

Georgena's death,

he

had been moved to an assisted care cen
ter in Mission, Kansas, in order to be near
the loving care of his daughter and sonin-law, Daria and Mike Carpenter.
Lalumondier was born in Bloomsdale,
where his father, Albert, had been a stone
mason and built or supervised construc
tion of numerous buildings in the area,

including public works projects where
Albert supervised Civilian Conserva

tion Corps workers during the 1930s
and early 1940s. The Lalumondier family
had come to the old Ste. Genevieve Dis
trict in the 1700s from Quebec, and were

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

known

for their skills in the construction
trades. Records indicate that branches of
the family had come from southwestern
France to Canada as early as 1666. One

houses built in the ancient
Norman French framing tradition in Ste.
Genevieve, the Antoine LaLumendiere
of the family

house, is listed in the National Register
of Historic Places. A natural fiistorian,
Lloyd Lalumondier, who was one-quar
ter German, was keenly interested in lo
cal cultural heritage and enjoyed giving
guests tours of the old French commu
nities. Lloyd fiimself became an aircraft
instructor and pilot, and for many years
worked in the PPG ceramic glass indus
try in nearby Crystal City.

Lloyd started out in music by playing
guitar for other fiddlers, but soon took up
the violin. While he was in grade school
in the 1930s, his mother sent Lloyd and
his sister Irma to the Catholic sisters at
their parish school to be taught accordi
on, 25 cents a lesson, but the lad's mind
was locked into fiddle music.
As a young man he was brought into
the old French "Guillonnee" group in
Bloomsdale in which his father, Albert,
was the leader and one of the fiddlers,
and they took part in the New Year's Eve
mumming rituals for many years. (Albert

Lalumondier's "Guillonnee" is docu
mented in Henry Belden's world-famous
1914 collection of Missouri ballads and

folk songs.) Lloyd finally quit fiddling in
the annual Guillonnee in the 1990s when
the local group leader barred Georgena
from playing guitar in the group for the

mumming procession, even though she

was asked to replace the absent guitarist
and even though she wore a costume and
disguise (as all the group did), because
she was a woman.

Lloyd Lalumondier (most people today
pronounce the name "laJimun'deer") was
versatile and soaked up all the music he
could, not only from the old-time fiddlers

community such as Jess Drury and
Valle Winters, but from fiddling at dances
in his

traditions of other groups; in his region,
the original French musical heritage was
overlaid and sorted into not only the early
Kentucky- and Virginia-type Scotch-Irish
fiddlers but also the many German-speak
ing immigrant musicians who in some
ways came to dominate the communities
in this

south of

area along the
St.

Louis.

Mississippi River

Lloyd loved playing twin fiddle and
loved waltzes. He was a born teacher,
and was able to convey complicated fid
dling tecJmiques to others. I met Lloyd
Lalumondier in the early 1980s at a
spring dance and fiddlers' get-together
at the senior citizen's center in Potosi.
Like other seasoned fiddlers, he would
lead a set of tunes for the dancing (in the
lineup of fiddlers willing to do so), and
then repair to a back room or the base
ment to pile into a hot session of hard

shared Lloyd's enjoyment
waltzes and playing twin fiddle, and

core fiddling.
of

I

we became friends.
I visited
Lloyd and Georgena a number
of times and on one occasion Georgena
prepared her "bouillon" recipe and we
enjoyed a classic Missouri French meal

together before a good session of fiddling
and talking. As I was preparing the 2012
book Play Me Something Quick and Devil
ish, I turned to Lloyd Lalumondier as my
guide tlrrough the old French communi
ties and their music, and his own saga
anchors the chapter on French- American
fiddling in the book.
In his final years, only fiddle music

seemed to rouse him from the grasp of
Alzheimer's disease. He never quite re
covered from Georgena's death. In Mis
sion, Daria arranged for the fiddler and
fiddle teacher Pat Ireland to meet with
Lloyd and give Jiim some "fiddle les
sons," wJiich helped keep Lloyd's mind
active. I last saw Lloyd, whom I valued

greatly as a friend and fiddling col
league, in Kansas City's Swope Park in
the fall of 2014,

when Daria and Mike

and swapping tunes with other fiddlers,
and from radio, records, and other sourc
es. He also enjoyed playing one or two

brought him to a fiddle Jiistory program
I
presented with Kathy Gordon and Russ
Ravert. WJiile he could no longer play
with the marvelous grace and power of

"Cajun"

his

dance tunes, even though this
twentieth-century music form from Loui
siana was different from the old Missouri
French music he grew up with. In his
early days, he fiddled with several coun
try bands that played on live radio shows
and for old-time dances in the old French
district. He could recall with great detail
the customs of the French community's
dance traditions in comparison with the

younger years, he brightened as we
visited and played some of the old tunes
together with Pat.

In addition to his great fiddle music
and illuminating anecdotes, I remember
Lloyd's quick wit, subtle jokes (always
delivered with a twinkle in his eye), and
his big smile, always ready for a visit and
a tune. Rest in
peace.

Howard Marshall

�December 1999, a website popular among
music fans, mudcat.org, featured a thread that
encouraged speculation about "The Essential
Thread participants — in
Folk Recordings."
cluding prominent promoters of folk music —

In

Rinzler

Institution

Ralph

Collections,
Smithsonnian

Robert Yellin,

agreed upon the lasting importance of three
collections: Harry Smith's Anthology of Ameri
can Folk Music, Alan Lomax's field recordings,
and Ralph Peer's 1927 Bristol Sessions. Also
mentioned by some participants were a few
recent compilations, as well as certain albums
from major folk and blues musicians. Many
participants lamented the dearth of reissued
folk music on compact disc from the back-cat
alog of Elektra Records, a company renowned
for its contributions to the genre during the
urban folk music revival. And one Elektra re
lease, The Folk Box, received particular praise
from a number of people fortunate enough to
have heard it.

Folklife
Archives
and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

THE FOLK BOX:
A FORGOTTEN,

YET UNFORGETTABLE, ALBUM
FROM THE FOLK ERA
By Ted Olson

Clarence Ashley

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Released in 1964,

The Folk Box

was note

which it represented
worthy
way
the diversity of American folk music. Un
available for more than four decades, The
for the

in

Folk Box can once again be heard and en
joyed, thanks to a special 50lh Anniversary
Edition from Rhino /Elektra Records. Jac

Holzman, who produced the original al

bum and who co-produced

this reissue,

widely known as the founder of Elek
tra Records
arguably the most success
ful folk music label during the urban folk
music revival of the 1950s and early 1960s.
By about 1964 Holzman believed that the
concept of folk music had changed signifi
cantly from earlier in the twentieth centu
ry. Never one to shrink from a challenge,
is

Holzman,

producing

to
a

prove his point, began
collection of folk music

recordings from the 1920s through the
1960s. Thematically structured to explore
the broad historical themes associated with

American folk music, The Folk Box incor
porated a wide range of recordings, from
traditional ballads, lyric folk songs, and
instrumentals, to blues and sacred music,
to various ethnic music traditions, to pow
contemporary songs by such folkstyle song-crafters as Woody Guthrie, Bob
Dylan, Phil Ochs, and Tom Paxton.
Holzman launched Elektra in 1950
erful

when an undergraduate at St. John's Col
lege in Annapolis, Maryland. A fan of
both classical and folk music, Holzman
leased

inaugural Elektra LP, re
collection of lieder by composer

as the

in 1951,
a

John Gruen, featuring interpretations of

classic poetry sung to avant-garde piano
arrangements; despite receiving strong
reviews, that album sold fewer than 100
copies. It was, in Holzman's words, a

Observing that the
"training record."
classical repertoire provided "no chance
of exclusivity," Holzman felt that folk
music "fitted my one-to-one approach
and my almost non-existent budget. The
equipment and recording techniques
were straightforward, mistakes would
not be catastrophic, and I could create
Elektra's
a label with a stylistic niche."
breakthrough release came next a 1952
10-inch LP by Jean Ritchie, a traditional
singer, songwriter, and fretted dulcimer
player from Viper, Kentucky, who was
living in New York City. Costing ap
proximately $20 to record, that album
sold several thousands of copies. Elektra

had found its niche.
The label subsequently released a re
markable string of albums showcasing the
talents many of the leading musicians of
the urban folk music revival. At first com-

�peting

in the folk

music market with such

small

independent record companies as
Folkways, Tradition, and Riverside, Elektra
by the early 1960s had grown significantly,
and by then Holzman considered his main

in folk music to be Vanguard Re
cords, which had signed some major acts
(The Weavers, Joan Baez, and Doc Watson,
among others). Yet those who signed with
Elektra during the label's "folk years"
a
roster that included such fixtures of the
Greenwich Village folk scene as Cynthia
Gooding, Susan Reed, Oscar Brand, Bob
Gibson, Dick Rosmini, and Fred Neil, as
well as several nationally and internation

rival

ally renowned folk stars including Ritchie,
Josh WJiite, Theodore Bikel, Jean Redpath,
Collins, Paxton, and the blues trio Koerner,

considered themselves for
Ray &amp; Glover
tunate because Holzman was a visionary
with an aura of success in business matters.
"Jac was the reason that most of us who
were on Elektra have had long careers,"
reflected Collins in 2013. "He was pas
sionate, emotional, sensitive, and brilliant
about marketing the music we made. He
was the fundamental reason for the timelessness that the folk revival has adhieved."
Ritchie added, "Jac knew everything. He
was the genius in the room, and you knew
it at all times."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Released in September

1964,

in

mono,

Elektra EKL-9001 (in the United King
dom it was issued as EUK 251/2), The
as

Folk Box

83 previously released
veritable who's-who of

compiled

recordings by

a

folk musicians from the US and the Brit
containing four LPs

ish Isles. A boxed set
and

a

48-page booklet, the album was

a

collaborative effort of two companies,
Elektra Records and Folkways Records.
As Holzman related in his 2000 book
Follow the Music, "In the early years my

competition
Folkways.

had

been Moses

Asch

at

Moe considered me an
eventually
upstart, an encroacher, but
we became friends.
Moe and I would

meet every few months for lunch to dis

cuss the state of the business."

Although the two companies, both based
New York City, were deeply committed

in
to

folk music, Elektra and Folkways had

significantly different approaches to re
cording and marketing that music. Holz
man, for instance, was more conscious of
the technical opportunities for recording
folk music.

According to Ed McCurdy,
Elektra
act, Holzman was the
longtime
first producer to release folk recordings
a

that

possessed high-quality sound. For
Holzman praised Asch for gen

his part,

erating "one of the world's great folk and
ethnic music libraries."
Both companies drew from their strengths

creating The Folk Box. Holzman served
project producer, and the lion's share
of the recordings selected for The Folk Box
were drawn from Elektra's catalog. Asch il
lustrated the booklet that accompanied the
in

as

album, and Folkways contributed slightly
more than a third of the project's contents,

permitting the inclusion of recordings by
such seminal

acts as Guthrie, Lead Belly,

Big Bill Broonzy, Doc Watson, Pete Seeger,
and the New Lost City Ramblers. To pro

vide the fullest possible balance of coverage,
were li
a handful of additional recordings
censed from other record companies.
The original album notes for The Folk
Box were penned by Robert Shelton, who

compiled the selections included on the
album. Shelton is primarily known today
for one piece he wrote for the New York
Times
his September 29, 1961, review of
a Gerde's Folk City concert headlined by
the Greenbriar Boys, in which he gushed
about the opening act,

a

then-unknown

By
20-year-old musician (Bob Dylan).
1964, Shelton was arguably the most in
fluential critic of popular music in the US.
He presided over the urban folk music re
vival from several vantage points, cover
ing recordings and concerts for the New

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Jean Ritchie at the Newport Folk Festival
In

a

1997 scholarly article entitled "The
Share: Scottish Ballads in Ap-

Lion's

palachia," Thomas
major

ballad

G.

Burton surveyed

New

World
twentieth-century
collections and compiled a list

best documented, most widely
and hence most popular
dispersed
traditional ballads of British origin in
Appalachia. According to Burton, "the
lion's share" of the most common bal
lads in that region could be traced back
of

to

by

the

Scotland (brought to the New World
immigrants of Scottish or Scots-Irish

backgrounds). According to Burton, the
most popular ballad in Appalachia, his

torically, was "Barbara Allen," of Scot
tish or of northern English origination.
The narrative embedded in this particu
lar ballad
bearing the universal theme
of love that was unrequited in life and
ultimately consummated in death (con

veyed through the immortal image of a
has ap
rose growing around a brier)
pealed over the centuries to singers of
many ethnic backgrounds. Well-known
recorded versions of the ballad include

versions by Vernon Dalhart

"hillbilly"

(1927) and Bradley

Kincaid (1928), the

sweetly harmonized
rendition (1958), Joan Baez's melodra
matic reading to her own finger-style
guitar (1961), Art Garfunkel's pop in

Everly

Brothers'

terpretation (1973), and Dolly Parton's
live version with accompaniment by the
Irish revivalist band Altan (1994). But to
these ears, there is a definitive version
of the ballad, one integrally associated

with Appalachia: Jean Ritchie's minorkeyed a cappella version, recorded for
scholar /producer Kenneth Goldstein in
1960 and released on Folkways Records
as part of a two-LP showcase of her east
ern Kentucky family's legacy of British
ballad survivals (entitled British Tradi
tional Ballads in the Southern Mountains,
Volumes

1

and 2).

It is

entirely defensible

Ritchie's "Barbara Allen" is
the definitive Appalachian ballad per

to say that

formance of the recorded sound era.
(Certainly, the archivists with Smithso

nian Folkways Records thought so, as
this recording is the only British-derived

�JEAN RITCHIE:
NATURAL MUSIC
(December

8,

1922

June

1,

meadow by Ritchie's melodious voice,
which bubbled like water flowing. That
the

Ritchie's contributions to American culture
were various and powerful, and no doubt
will be lasting. She introduced the Appala
chian (also known as the "lap" or "fretted")
dulcimer to a new generation of Americans;
she demonstrated how traditional ballads

2015)

perfect communion between people and

wild animals lasted for several minutes,

long enough for one of her tragic Old
World ballads
perhaps it was "Barbara
Allen"
to unfurl in a New World setting.
After someone flinched and the deer scat
tered, I realized that Ritchie's singing was
truly natural, timeless music.

should be performed in modern venues
and contexts; and she composed remark
able, and remarkably honest, original songs
that celebrated traditional themes ("Now Is

and
Many years later, I finally heard
met Ritchie in person.
In 1998
I
attended the Great American Dulci
mer Festival at eastern Kentucky's Pine
Mountain State Resort Park, where she
was the main performing act; she sang
several songs accompanied by her dul
cimer and played a few tunes on the
instrument, and then she set her dulci
mer down and, saying something like
"This is what everybody wants to hear,"

the Cool of the Day") and that confronted

then

Diana

contemporary issues such as the economic
devastation in rural areas ("The L&amp;N Don't
Stop Here Anymore") and the environmen

destruction of strip mining ("Black Wa
Beyond her own music, she was a
skilled documentarian and a talented writ
er, whose memoir of growing up in eastern

Davies,

tal

ters").

Ralph

Rinzler Folklife Archives

Kentucky The Singing Family of the Cumberlands) remains a classic portrait of Appala
chian culture. Jean Ritchie was powerful,
and humility was part of her power.
My own introduction to Jean Ritchie's
music came in the 1960s when, as a child,
I first heard
some of her recordings on the

and

Collections,

Elektra/ Folkways

Smithsonian
Institution

Child ballad on the company's fine 2002
anthology Classic Mountain Songs from
Smithsonian Folkways.)
Ritchie's version of "Barbara Allen" is, for
fully realized, textually complete British
ballad, remarkably short, clocking in at just
over five minutes. A master musical stylist
a

who had

a

profound understanding of tra

ditional aesthetics, Ritchie knew that, even
with ballads, less is more. She sang "Bar
bara Allen" and many other ballads in the
old unaccompanied manner (while on oth
er ballads she accompanied herself on the
dulcimer), yet her ballad performance style,
despite being in a minor key signature, can
not exactly be called stark or faux-ancient,

because of her sweet-toned, mellifluous
vocals. She understood the aesthetics of the
urban folk music revival, having been a ma
participant in (and leader of) that post
war New York City-based scene, but main
stream aesthetics rarely governed her ap

jor

proach. (The one exception on record might

which ca
tered to contemporary tastes and received a
critics' award from Rollirig Stone magazine.)

be her 1977 album None But One,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

collaboration

launched into "Barbara Allen";
al

ditorium seemed

anthol

The Folk Box.

Two

song originally associated with an Eng

mummer's play. In the early 1960s
Bob Dylan was so mesmerized by Ritchie's
haunting recording that he borrowed her
lish

undergird his lyrics in his early
"Masters
of War." (As if to document
song
that point, The Folk Box included Judy Col

melody

to

lins' 1963 cover of the Dylan song.)
Sometime in the mid-1970s, when

a

teenager visiting the local library, I found
Ritchie's two- volume Folkways set of Ap
palachian ballads. I transferred those LPs
to cassette (as was the practice in those
years) so I could listen to her singing in
the field

(literally and

1979, while working as
counselor in the West

In

figuratively).
a summer camp
Virginia

hills,

sever
au

disappear, and time
stopped. Listening, I closed my eyes
where I was sitting and could almost rec
reate the scene of deer gathering in that
mountain meadow, also listening to the
strains of natural music.

One of the truly memo
ogy
rable recordings on that anthology was her
1954 interpretation of "Nottamun Town,"
a

for

minutes, the roof and walls of that

I

sometimes played that tape for campers
during Appalachian culture appreciation

events, and several of the kids said that
Ritchie's music was "cool." They weren't
the only ones who felt that Ritchie's sing
ing was alluring. Once, during a creative
writing activity, the campers and I were
sitting and writing, scattered across a
ballads
while centuries-old
meadow,
wafted from a cassette player; suddenly
low whispers could be heard among
the campers, and soon everyone's atten
tion was directed toward the small herd
of deer that had entered the meadow to
forage, seemingly oblivious to us and the
music or, I've long thought, attracted to

years

to

later

I

met

her

and

her

acclaimed photographer
George Pickow, at eastern Kentucky's
Pine Mountain Settlement School; at

husband,

the

the

"Symposium on Settlements

in the

Southern Mountains," held there in June
2000, I had been asked to convene an
academic session discussing the music
associated with the settlement school
movement, and Ritchie was the principal
speaker. That event was a homecoming
for her, as she and her

siblings had once

attended classes there; later, folklorists

Elizabeth Barnicle and Tillman
Cadle had made documentary record
ings of Ritchie singing songs and ballads
with her sisters at Pine Mountain in the
mid-1940s. At that symposium, Ritchie
reminisced about the important role that
that school had played in her life, and she
talked about the importance of family
and heritage. And every word she said
that day was communicated with the
same gentle yet firm honesty, sly intelli
gence, and charming wit that infused her
music. She was from Appalachia (she
frequently returned to eastern Kentucky
Mary

throughout her career, and she eventual

ly retired there), yet her music
whole world a far better place.

testament

to the

her music

sounded

made the
It was a

depth of her artistry that
so natural.
--Ted

Olson

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

co-editing Hootenanny, a mag
azine devoted to the folk music scene; and
York Times

contributing interpretive writing for the
annual Newport Folk Festival program
and for various books (such as The Mitch
ell Trio Song Book). Additionally, Shelton
wrote album notes for various recordings,
including under the pseudonym Stacey
Williams Dylan's eponymous 1962 de
but album for Columbia Records. And in
1986 Shelton published an important bi
ography of Dylan, No Direction Home.
The Folk Box, which retailed for $9.95,

sold approximately 17,000 copies and re
ceived positive press coverage. The Jan
uary 2, 1965, issue of Billboard declared
the album a "Special Merit Pick." In the

November 1965 issue
as

now

a

of Sing Out! (then
folk
music
periodical in
leading

the US) an unnamed reviewer asserted
"
that
[although the material has been

previously released, this is no random
sampling of the catalogues of the two
companies. The set is an intelligentlyprepared examination of American folk

music.
Over-all, there is little to quar
rel about in the selection of singers and
songs
dition

to any

a

valuable ad

folk music library."

reviewer

chided Shelton
album
notes meant to
advancing (in

That
for

The Folk Box is

same

justify the inclusion of songs by Elektra
"singer-songwriters" Ochs and Paxton)
"the shaky idea that a small group of

axe-grinding

songwriters

are

creating

But the reviewer
instant folk music."
did not see what Shelton clearly saw
that at the time of the release of The Folk
Box, the folk music scene was rapidly
changing. In 1964, the so-called British
musicians
Invasion younger British
who were avowed fans of American folk
music but whose own music was mostly
self-penned, youth-oriented, and electri
fied
arrested the attention of a whole
of Americans.
Inspired by
these fresh sounds from overseas, many

generation

younger American musicians, including
soon-to-be-famous members of such rock
groups as the Byrds, the Lovin' Spoon
ful, and the Grateful Dead, moved away
from an overt reliance on the traditional
repertoires and styles popular during the
urban folk music revival; those musi
cians began to play original songs with
electronic instruments and drums.
At the Newport Folk Festival in July
1964, the Weavers' Ronnie Gilbert had

announced

Dylan

the

to

audience by

saying, "And here he is... take him, you
know him, he's yours." Resentful toward
such implied obligation that he serve as
spokesperson for the folk music commu
nity, Dylan tuned out; and upon return
ing to that festival the next summer, he

plugged

in.

During

this

same period,

Ochs, Paxton, and such other Elektra art
ists as Tom Rush were likewise becom
ing less beholden to traditional sources
and instead were favoring more personal
approaches to music-making. Far from
misrepresenting folk music, Shelton was

prescient in forecasting the flaring up of
the singer-songwriter movement out of
the ashes of the urban folk music revival.

When

The Folk Box

was released in 1964,

Holzman was actively pursuing a broad
That same year,
er horizon for Elektra.
he implemented the innovative None

such Records label, which specialized in
releasing classical music albums at a spe

(Holzman said that the
release high-quality albums

cial price point

goal was to

same price as a trade paperback");
few years later, he launched the None
such Explorer Series, dedicated to show
casing music traditions from around the
"at the
a

world.

At this juncture

Holzman signed

and began promoting two era-defining
West Coast rock groups, Love and the
Doors, and he also began encouraging
some of Elektra's "folk" acts such as
to experiment, even
Collins and Rush

�meant going beyond the established
perimeters of folk music. Hence, The Folk
Box
the project that most emphatically
documented Elektra's central role in the
in many re
urban folk music revival
spects marked the end of the folk era.
Musicians whose recordings formed the
core of the album remember it today with
considerable affection. In 2013 Collins re

if it

called that "The Folk Box had

a

huge im

explored and celebrated the music
pact
of the people who were active in the folk
it

revival."
That same year, Jean Ritchie,
Elektra's first folk musician, asserted that
the album was instrumental in bringing
her music to a wider audience: "I appreci
ated The Folk Box then, and

Brand,

I

still do."

who has continuously

hosted

influential

weekly radio program
Folksong Festival on WNYC-AM since
December 1945, related in 2013 that "in
the

The New Lost City Ramblers

1964, The Folk Box was an extraordinary
of the traditional and the new.

collection
It

reflected the fluidity of the music and

the energy of the time that has persist
ed in the 50 years since." According to

Brand, Rhino/ Elektra's reissued edition
of The Folk Box "will serve to remind the
current singers, songwriters, and audi

ences of the passions that catapulted the
folk traditions and their progeny into the

consciousness
Certainly,

of this country."

The Folk Box

documented the

old-time
significant
music within the broader urban folk mu
role

sic revival.

of

rural-based

The specific recordings that

a
perceived sense of "au
thenticity" were by musicians with strong
personal connections to traditional music

gave the album

(for example, Ritchie, Clar
ence "Tom" Ashley, Blind Willie Johnson,
and the unnamed performers in several
field recordings). Other acts were includ

environments

ed on The Folk Box

1964

because

at the

time

they were considered as tradition-

influenced yet innovative groundbreakers
(Woody Guthrie, Lead Belly, and Big Bill
Broonzy, for instance), or as skilled inter
preters of older repertoires (such as the
New Lost City Ramblers, Pete Seeger, and
Josh White), or as talented upstarts who
clearly respected traditional music genres
and styles while

unapologetically modern

izing them (Doc Watson, Ramblin' Jack El
liott, tire Dillards, among others). Not sur
prisingly, all those recording artists are still
widely esteemed today, some as essential
musicians within the old-time music pan
theon. Hence, the creators of The Folk Box
were prescient in identifying musicians
who would have lasting credibility as mas
ters of revivalist old-time music.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Doc Watson

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Comparisons between

The Folk Box

and

another box set, Harry Smith's 1952 LP
set Anthology of American Folk Music, are
For his legendary
perhaps inevitable.

compilation

selected

Smith

84

memo

rable sides from 1920s and 1930s com

mercially released 78s, while The Folk Box
was a post-War anthology comprised
primarily of commercially released stu
dio recordings taken from various 1950s
and early 1960s LPs alongside several 78
RPM sides and some documentary re
cordings.
more

Certainly,

The Folk

comprehensive

Box offers

historical

cover

more overtly educa
tional presentation. The fact that Harry
Smith's album has become iconic while
age and features

The Folk

Box

a

remained

decades seems at least
a
modern predilection

out-of-print for
in part to reflect

the

for

exotic;

Smith's

anthology famously presents
a
self-consciously quirky overview of
American music inspired by tradition.
The Folk Box offers its own charms for
those who appreciate memorable record
ings of treasured ballads, songs, blues,
tunes, and other kinds of vernacular mu
sic performed by traditional and revival
ist performers.
Beyond that, the album

a compelling snapshot of one moment
but
from the urban folk music revival
the
last
a
moment
it
was
what
gasp of

is

poignant youth cultural movement be
publicly moved on from "folk
music," taking his generation with him..
Listeners today whether rediscover
a

fore Dylan

ing The Folk Box or hearing it for the first
time through the new edition will mar
vel at the power of its material and per

recent years, some have

formances.

In

belittled

lampooned

or

the

urban

folk

will for
ever document the lasting cultural sig
nificance of a music movement in which
music revival, but

The Folk Box

people honored the best
recasting

older music

in

of the past by

modern

and

meaningful ways.
The greatest compliment the contem

porary listener can pay the album and
the people who originally made this al
bum possible is to learn and perform
the timeless material therein (ideally, as
heard

on the original recordings, in a
manner balancing passion and craft). Al
though forgotten for years, The Folk Box
is an album for the ages. (2&gt;
This essay was adapted from the liner notes
new edition o/The Folk Box. The set

to the

is

carried by music retailers including

Moose (bullmoose.com).

Bull

�&lt;e£

Friday Night Jam

Old-time

Hotdogs

Camping

Cash Frizes

Flat Footing

Pickin'

Grinnin"

Fiddle

Byway

11th Annual

Scenic

Happy Valley Fiddlers Convention
September

4

2015

6.

Guitar

Contest

Jammin'

Circles

HWY

268

Labor Dav Weekend

Farm

Friday Evening
Music starts

Free Admission
FM

$25 for entire
weekend (Fri, Sat, Sun)

Camping:

at 7:00

Fun

Jones

Wayne Martin and the Happy Valley Pals
Marvin Gaster, old-time 2 finger banjo picker
Lightnin Wells, NC master of acoustic blues &amp;
vintage traditional music, special guest artists

primitive, no services

Fee does not include admission

Old fashioned cake walk and dance

Adults $10

Family

Saturday
(children

15 &amp;

at

under free)

Music competition from 10 AM until
PM
Flatfoot dance workshop
Instrument Makers Tent offering demonstra
tions, Junior Appalachian Musicians showcase

Gravesite-

1

Foster
Laura

Check out our website

at

www.happyvalleyfiddlers.org

1

stage

Children's activities,
historic information

Musicians

gate

for info on

competition

Location
Hwy 268 Between Lenoir

&amp;

N.

Wilkeshoro

hayrides, storytelling, and

Sunday Concert- Adults
"

$10 at gate

10:00 AM till 5:00 PM

Valley

(children 15

&amp;

under free)

Performers include:

Happy

Strictly Strings
The Neighbors

&amp;

Ft.

Defiance

Country

Ham

Biscuits

Band

Contest

Over

Mountain

Victory

Trail

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dogs must be leashed.
Rest

Bring lawn chairs.

Chapel
of

Wayne Henderson Guitar Extravaganza
The Kruger Brothers

Near

Picturesque

Kilby Spencer &amp; The Crooked Road Ramblers
Jeff Little Trio
Strictly Clean and Decent
The Harris Brothers

$4

�TALES FROM THE 'WOODS, PART 12:
J.P. AND ROSCOE
By Walt Koken
the mid-1970s we had run our van
into the ground. It was the replacement
for our old panel trucks, a heavy-duty
Ford window van that we had custom
By

ized to fit our needs.

It

was used when

we bought it, we put many hard miles
on it, and now it was dead. Our hopes

continuing our barnstorming were dy
ing with it, as we didn't make enough
of

to buy a replacement. Festival promoter
Quint Davis had flown us to New Or
leans to play at the Louisiana Heritage
Festival, and while we were there we ran
into our friend Alan Jabbour. When we

mentioned to him that our career as a
band was in jeopardy, he suggested that
we apply to the National Endowment for
the Arts for grant money. Since he was
top man at the folk arts division of the
NEA at the time, we took him seriously,
and after
a couple
months and some
doing, we found ourselves in Whites-

burg, amongst the rugged mountains of

eastern Kentucky, on a two-week NEAsponsored tour of the region, with the
supposed purpose of bringing old-time
music back to the people there.
Our base was Appalshop, which had
been organized a few years previously
as

part of the War on

Poverty program,

and their focus was on improving the
lives of folks in the area, by way of films,

festivals, and education. Appalshop, its
recording label June Appal, and radio
WMMT are active to this day.
We borrowed a generous friend's van
for the trip, with the promise of grant
money in our future. It didn't measure up
to our own rig, but it ran. Our guide for
the trip was Jack White, whom we would
meet at the Appalshop every morning,
and he would drive us to our destination
for the day and /or evening, and often
would play guitar with us. We stayed at
the house of another member of the orga
nization, since she was out of town then.
It was May, and the beauty of the area
was marred to some degree by an ongo
ing forest fire. Yes, fire on the mountain!
It was quite dry at that time there, and
the fire was creeping over the mountains
through the understory, the brush and
dead leaf litter. We played a coffeehouse
one night in Williamson, West Virginia,
and it was spooky driving home in the
dark, with an endless line of fire creeping

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Members of the Highwoods String Band with

J. P.

along the forest floor and caustic smoke
limiting visibility. Williamson was where

we met banjo-playing lawyer Larry Web
ster, who in recent years has engaged

some of us to play at the fabled Hillbilly
Days in Pikeville, Kentucky.

played somewhere in the area at least
once a day, often in schools for children of
all ages. We traveled to play at a school in
We

Rabun Gap, Georgia,

a

gig set up by Eliot

Wigginton, and afterwards visited the Fox
fire compound. We did a gig at a club near
Charlotte, North Carolina, called the Old
Stump Hole. One afternoon Jack set up a
at

Appalshop with

get-together
Fraley,
who happened to be traveling through.
He worked for the National Mines Ser
J. P.

vice, and his occupation took him around
the world, wherever mine equipment was
used. Consequently his fiddling included
music from exotic countries, besides tradi
tional favorites and tunes from his father.
He had many stories of coal mining, both
old and modern, and it was fascinating
spending time with him.
It had finally begun raining, and as we
sat there playing and storytelling, we
had to choose our spots carefully, as Appalshop's roof leaked everywhere. We

situated ourselves amongst an array of

Fraley (second from left).

pots, pans, and buckets collecting drips,
and our music and laughter was definitely
a relief from the
damp depression of the
P. told us about deep
J.
surroundings.
and
mining
strip mining, and how the

miners could only get about ten
percent of the coal seam, and the soil and
stone that came from above the seam
would wash down into the streams and
cause flooding. We had seen vistas while
going to gigs on the tour where a cor
ner of every mountain in sight had been
chewed away, running like a ribbon in
strip

an

odd

testament

to

mankind's domi

nation over nature. Nowadays they just
use mountaintop removal, a system that
destroys the beauty of the area. Part of
Appalshop's program was educating
folks about such matters.
J. P. was full of tunes, and we adapted as
fast as we could to his style. Every other
tune was in a different key. He explained
what a galleynipper was, and told sto
ries about his tunes. When after several
hours he decided he'd better drive home
before it started flooding, he said with a
twinkle in his eye, "I'm glad you had a
chance to talk to me."
The next day we played a concert at
Warren Wilson College. It continued to

�coutesy
Koken
of Walt

Members of the Highwoods String Band with Roscoe Holcomb/Halcomb (third from left).

rain. Our friend Bill Hicks, then fiddler
for the Red Clay Ramblers, showed up.
Our bands had spent many hours at fes
tivals together, and he followed us back
to Mimi's house after the show for a few
tunes. It was threatening to flood, and
raining harder. As the evening grew
late, Bill and I played chess in the kitch
en after everybody retired, and kept
watch on the creek behind the house by
way of the back porch light. Finally in
the not-so-wee hours, he decided that
he too had better leave before total in
undation. There we were, with no place
to go, wondering if we'd float away in

sleep. The morning brought high
water and a mess of everything plastic
our

in it.

floating
Jack continued

to

drive us

to our

gigs, and on the way to one, we
off to visit Roscoe Halcomb,

many

stopped
better-

Roscoe Holcomb. Jack knew
the way. We turned off the highway onto

known
a

as

dirt road

headed up

a

holler, and there

small settlement of a half-dozen or
so houses. When we had done a couple
concerts with Roscoe as part of the Smith
sonian's tours, he had told us the proper
spelling of his name. He was a real char

was

a

acter, not quite the stark mountain man
that John Cohen's movie had made him

out to be. He knew

a

slew of songs, and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

could humorously make his coal miner's
windpipe sound like a freight train wJiistle

when he wanted

to.

was a beautiful warm spring day. We
knocked at the door, and when eventual
ly Roscoe opened it we crowded in. The
house was very small, just one room with
a large coal stove heater. Although it was
warm out, he had his coal stove cranked,
and it was stifling in there. After we had
exchanged a few stories, a young neigh
It

bor boy came to the door and said, "Mr.

Halcomb, my mom is driving down
the church bazaar, and she wants me
ask you if you'd like

a

ride." After

a

to
to

few

moments' thought, he replied, "I don't
believe will. Something might happen."
I

had many chuckles about that
statement over the years.
Back in Whitesburg, Jack asked us to
back him up as he recorded his origi
We've

nal song "Springtime in the Mountains
Again." He had taught it to us as he

drove us along, and I recently heard a
copy of it. Not bad.
Our tour ended, and we returned the

borrowed van

to our generous friend.
With our "profits," the grant money from
the NEA, we were just able to purchase
another used van, which we customized
like the old one. It seemed like catch-22,
but we carried on valiantly anyway.

�Edwin
Massengill

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�A SEA OF THINGS TO LEARN:
AN INTERVIEW WITH BILL HICKS
By Sarah Bryan

I visited Bill and
Libby Hicks at their home in the
outside Siler City North Carolina, to interview Bill for
Stories of Old-Time Music's Revival Generation. Bill is a fiddler and
stonemason, a founding member of the Fuzzy Mountain String Band
and of the Red Clay Ramblers, and a long-time contributor to the OldTime Herald. Nowadays he performs and records with Libby, and with
the band Craver, Hicks, Watson, and Newberry. We talked about his
early years as a musician, the influential 1970s old-time music scene in
the Triangle (Chapel Hill-Durham-Raleigh) region of North Carolina,
and his friendships with elder musicians including Tommy Jarrell and
Burl Hammons. The following pages are excerpted and adapted from
that interview. (In the coming months the OTH will be putting ma
terials from Stories of Old-Time Music's Revival Generation online,
including video and the full transcript from Bill's interview.)
-Sarah Bryan

this spring

Early
woods

Stories of Old-Time Music's Revival Generation is made possible by the support of National
Endowment for the Arts, Konrad Alt, and the old-time music community.

Growing Up
Dad was from Durham County [North
Carolina] and grew up on a tobacco
farm east of Durham. Actually, slightly
before he was born, his county, his little
area, which was called I think Little Lick
Creek, was incorporated into Durham
County. It had been part of Wake County,
but it was too far to drive to Raleigh in a

wagon

to do

business,

so

Durham Coun

got a'little bigger.
My mom was from Wilmington. They
met in Raleigh. She was a school teacher
and he taught at North Carolina State in
the '30s. He was born in 1901, and she
was born in 1911. They got married in
1941, and I was born in '43
My dad left the farm running, he was
glad to get out of there. And I remember in
the '50s at one point asking him, "Maybe
I should
go [work] over there?" They still
had a working tobacco farm when I was
ty

growing up, using the old system. They

had tenant farmers, they used mules for
power. My dad raised tobacco, put him
self through State College with a field. His
dad said, "You take that field, you raise it,
cure it, and that'll be your tuition."
Young Bill Hicks with his parents.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was in Raleigh. We'd go [to the farm]
Sunday dinner. I met some of the peo
ple who were tenant farmers. There was
a
boy about my age who was one of the
children of a tenant farmer on that farm,
who was an incredible shot, because he
probably hunted all the time. He shot a
mockingbird on the wing with a BB gun.
I

for

Just amazing.
But anyway,

my dad just sort of said,
"No, you don't want to even think about
getting involved. That's all dying. That'll
all be gone." He could see ahead. But I

really understand
really nice situation.
grew
had
a really good job with tenure.
dad
My
He was actually a pretty significant figure
in State College stuff. What he taught was
philosophy, but it was a kind of practical
philosophy. His favorite course was Mar
mean,

that. So

a

I

kid

doesn't
up in

a

riage and Family Living, and his favorite
students were probably the guys who
came back from World War II, who were
grounded in things. They had a sense
of what's serious, they were older. But
was [born
missed all of that, of course.
I was
'43.
When
in]
growing up we'd go

I

I

�station and watch the trains,

to the train

and we'd go out to the Raleigh-Durham
airport and watch the planes land. That

was stuff we did in the '50s
My dad's father played fiddle. As a ru
ral family, they made their own music,
like most, at least many, rural people did.
My dad would tell me some about mu
sic in the old days, how when he was a
as they
kid, they would do things like
do in the mountains and rural places
they had things like corn shuckings,
and different events, dances, where mu
sic would be a part of that, and people

would

My granddaddy played
think his wife's brother, Uncle
Carson, played banjo. I think his wife,

fiddle.

play.

I

Hicks, possibly she played piano
or guitar some. But it was just an inthe-family thing. They were attracted to
music. One of my dad's sisters ended up
playing pretty decent classical piano and
taught elementary school in Raleigh, and
used a lot of music in her classes, and
had a grand piano at home. Ava actually
gave me lessons a little bit when I was

Ora

grammar-school age. My grandfather
was born in 1872, so by the time I knew
him he was quite old. He still played the

[fiddle] a little bit, but he would do kind
quirky old things. He would sit in the
kitchen, and play and sing verses of the
Bible. Just open the Bible and sing things,
I
guess sort of making up the melody.
He died in '53, so I was about 10. When
I
got to the fourth grade, which was not
too long after that, my school in Raleigh
had a really good string program. And
we were all kind of gathered together in
of

the assembly, and they said, "Anybody
wants to be in the orchestra next year,
My parents
just pick an instrument."
said, "Well, we have Granddaddy' s vio
lin. Why don't you pick a violin, because
we have one, we don't have to buy one."
And so I did. And that's how I started

playing the instrument.

stayed in that orchestra. They had a
great set-up. The grammar schools had
little orchestras, then in junior high there
was a junior high orchestra and in senior
high a bigger orchestra. And we were
good. We would go and have a competi
I

courtesy
of Bill and

Libby Hicks

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

year in Greensboro, and our
orchestra did well. So I ended up being
in the string section, and learning how to
tion once

a

read music. Also just learning a lot of the
techniques of playing the instrument.

1

wasn't really, really, really good
I

wasn't bad.

at it,

but

�The Fuzzy

Mountain String Band.

l - r,

standing: Vickie Owen, Sharon Sandomirsky, Bill Hicks, Eric Olson, Malcolm Owen seated,

Tom Carter,

Blanton Owen

Hollow Rock and Fuzzy Mountain
About that time I was starting to get
interested in more well, I was already
interested in the music that was on the
radio, but I started messing around with
the
of
ate

guitar

other

and

things,

got
dropped violin until
school at UNC [University

Carolina],

I

which

and
to

sort

gradu

of North
was '65, '66. Tommy
were both studying phi

Thompson and
losophy at UNC, and met each other. He
I

wasn't really very much. But there were
some things that I remembered how to
do which were really helpful, such as
simply making a decent bowed note, and
hitting accurate noting. I mean, I didn't
remember a lot of things, but I could play
okay, and I could be in tune. Tommy and
Bobbie and some other people were do

ing sort of old-time singing-type stuff
Carter Family, Charlie Poole was a big

had been there a year or two before I got
there. He was a very gregarious person,
and he and his wife Bobbie lived in a big,
old country house outside of Durham,
in a little community called the Hollow
Rock community. He threw these big mu
sic parties every Friday night. Before that
think
he also threw these other parties.
the first time I was ever out there was a

influence on what Tommy was doing,

party for all the graduate students and
the faculty that he threw one Saturday af

around Durham. Tommy and I were go
ing to graduate school, and Bobbie was a
book designer at Duke University Press.

I

ternoon. So I started going to those, and
got the fiddle out again, and was just sort
could remem
of playing by ear what
which
ber of how to play the fiddle
1

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and the Stanley Brothers, the 40s rural
music. So I could play breaks. I didn't
really know much about fiddle tunes at
that point, but I could play breaks, and I
was doing that. And now and then Tom

my and Bobbie and I, and I'm not sure,
there may have been some other people,
played one or two little coffee house jobs

Tommy had met Alan Jabbour,
in graduate school at Duke. Alan
started coming to these music parties. And
By

'67,

who was

Alan had already, on his own, been collect
ing tunes from Piedmont fiddlers, and had
found this amazing source, Henry Reed,
who was a real old man. Because of Alan's
which came from his
ability to do this
a classical musician in Flori
as
background
he was able to hear what Henry
da, before
Reed used to be, before he met him, and to
in a way bring those tunes back from being
kind of weakly played to what Alan could
do with them. So Tommy and Bobbie and
Alan and Bertram Levy made a little string
band, the Hollow Rock String Band, and
made a record in I think it was '67 when
that record came out. I was aware of that,
wasn't going to their private practices, but
they also came to those Friday-night par
ties which kept going on. I was sort of at
the edge of the circle. And in the middle of
it was Alan Jabbour, who wanted the band
he was playing in, which included Tommy
and Bobbie and Bert, to play specifically.
That's one of the things that's real im
portant about the Chapel Hill scene of
I

that era, and certainly affected me too as

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

got more and more involved in it. I was
already able, when I heard a fiddle tune,
[to] sort of figure out roughly what it is.
I

Particularly tunes in the standard fiddle
keys like D and A and G and C, I could
kind of figure out a rough, I don't know,
template for the melody. But I didn't
know that you had to learn it more care

really through Alan.
jump ahead slightly. After a while the
Hollow Rock sort of disbanded because
Alan moved away. He graduated and
went I think first to California and then to
the Library of Congress. Bobbie and Tom
my split up, and Bertram was getting a
fully, until
I'll

medical degree, and he eventually moved
up to the Northwest. So Bobbie then
aligned herself with other of these people
who were in that larger Friday-night jam
session who were good players. But she
became the person who made the Fuzzy
Mountain Band into a rigorous tune-learn
ing tiring, where we were learning just
like Alan was

we were learning, "This
is specifically somebody's tune, and we're
going to leam it carefully, the way they
did." And we practiced. I was invited to
join that band in the spring of 1970, actu
ally at Union Grove, and they had been
playing there in different configurations
for several years. Bobbie was probably in
both groups, but when the Hollow Rock
Band wasn't there, she became much more

focused on [tire Fuzzy Mountain String
Band]. Malcolm Owen, Blanton Owen, an
other banjo player named Eric Olson, and
Malcolm's wife Vickie, Bobbie, surd me. We
started practicing Wednesday at Bobbie's
house and Sunday at Malcolm's. And we
were just learning tunes
Sarah:

What

do

you think Bobbie Thomp

would have done musically if she had
lived? [Bobbie Thompson died in a car ac
cident in 1972.]
don't know. I think we might have
done more things with the Fuzzy Moun
tain Band, because her bottom end of the

son

I

guitar playing is real good in that band.
It's a little bit sparse. I think Sharon [Sandomirsky] does great in that band too
and she does a little bit more. Bobbie was
not so much interested in just music. She
was a graphic artist. She had had, right
before she got killed, a big show at Duke
of her intaglio prints, and she taught

printmaking
at
a

at

Duke

as

well

as

working

the Duke Press. She was on her way to
job working with the Princeton Univer

sity Press and maybe teaching there too.
when she
got killed in a wreck. So she would have

She was on her way to that job

kept on playing music, but
she was solely
I

a

I

don't think

musician.

was struck, rereading the notes on the back

of those Fuzzy Mountain records, how precise
you were in noting the source [of each tune],

and whether you learned directly or indirect
remained in the
ly. That's something that has

old-time community

as

a

value. I'm wonder

ing if that started with you all?
Well, I think it started with Alan

at

least,

because that's how he writes about the tunes
on the Hollow Rock record, which was kind
of the model for how we thought a record
of tunes should be presented. Bobbie surd
Malcolm, they were the kind of leaders of
that band but it was pretty democratic. But
I
certainly wasn't the leader when I joined
that band, and I was learning what they
I wanted
to be a helpful member
you know? But that [specificity] was a big
part of that. I mean, we'd have so and so's
Sally Ann and so arid so's "Sally Ann" and
somebody else's "Sally Ann."

wanted.

We just thought old-time music was
real wide sea of possible things to learn.

a

Fiddlers' Conventions
Somewhere in there, about '67, we also all
found out about Union Grove [Fiddler's
Convention], And that was a big eye-open
er, to go there and all of a sudden there
was all this music for a whole weekend.
Union Grove at that point was not what
it became. It wasn't crazy. It wasn't thou
sands and thousands of people. They had
with old-time and bluegrass,
a division
and they gave out prizes in each division.
We just drought of ourselves as being more
old-time, because we were doing stuff that
was older. But of course bluegrass then
wasn't what it became either. The Stanley
Brothers are pretty old-time bluegrass; and
that was a model. And the other thing drat
divided the bands up was the banjo style.
and
you played three-finger with picks
started
out
playing
Tommy Thompson
three-finger widr picks you were in blueIf

grass, but if you played clawhammer, then
you were playing in the old-dme category.
But people did singing [tooj. It wasn t

just fiddle tunes, like it became in maybe
as an example, like Clifftop,
the '80s
say.

It

was much more integrated songs

and music, and less hard-core division. A
convention I've been to not so long ago,

probably ten years ago, the one in Inde
pendence [Virginia], still is sort of done
in that way. There's a lot more singing on
the old-time side than is typical. That re
minded me of Union Grove

�Learning From Older Musicians
Malcolm and Blanton had gone out and
collected tunes.
went out some, Bob
bie and I, and different of us would go
to meet fiddlers. Somebody would say,
1

"Well,

you ought to go see" somebody,
it might be, and often the people

whoever

were real happy

that

somebody would

show up and be interested in their music.
I

felt like

lot of times they'd sort of been

a

dropped by their communities. Tilings
had changed. Bluegrass came, and rockthey were just this maybe
good player who didn't have many
people who were interested in what he
could do. And so people like us, we could
more or less speak their language. So I de
veloped a really good relationship with
and

and-roll,
real

Tommy Jarrell by going and visiting him,
and I also went and visited Burl Hammons
several times. And Malcolm had gone to
see both of those people. He had collected
a
good deal from Taylor Kimble. Blanton
was in the Navy when I first joined the

Fuzzy Mountain Band, but he got out of
the Navy, he got done with that, and then

he started

going to I guess maybe first an
undergraduate program at East Tennessee,
and then a graduate program in folklore.
And another guy that showed up in 1970
or '71 was Tom Carter, who had graduated
from Brown
lore [program

and was going to the folk
at UNC]. Tom Carter and

Blanton were both in the Fuzzy Mountain
Band, and were collectors. After they left
the area, Blanton and Tom did some bigtime collecting in Virginia

When

I

was going

to

Union Grove, the

absolutely dominated Union

person that

Grove was Clark Kessinger. He started
coming there for whatever reason in
about '67 or '8 and he was amazing. He
was just amazing. So he won until prob
ably they finally said, "Don't get in this
anymore, nobody else can win if you're

in it." He

was

a

showman too.

Oscar Wright, who is a source that we
learned some really pretty tunes from,
talked about the time he was to play in a
dance, probably where he lived in Princ
eton, West Virginia, and Henry Reed
came in. And didn't even have a fiddle.
So Oscar loaned him his fiddle to play
a tune, and then felt like he never could
even go back on stage. He was so good
that Oscar didn't want to take it away.
[Oscar] did really beautiful tunes, and
he sang in

a

real high voice, and he sang

sweet parlor love songs. There was a
think it was "Gentle
song he would do
where he would stop. He'd say,
Annie"
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"I can't sing the last verse, it makes me
too sad. I'll start crying." He wouldn't be
able to sing it. He was real nice. He was
probably [in his] early 80s at least when
we'd go visit him

Can you talk

a

same language,

bit more about speaking the
or understanding
the older

musicians you went
had grown up in

a

to see, even though you
more urban environment?

Right. Well, I think I had an advantage in
that I was Southern. I just didn't have too
much trouble relating to Southern rural
people. And I don't think they felt like I
was all that unrelated to where they were
coming from. I've always been good at

hearing the differences, and sort of speak
ing the language of who I'm with.
Well, Tommy [Jarrell], you've probably
seen the movies of him. He was just ex
actly like that. He was a storyteller. He
was a gregarious person, and I think
wherever he was he would be the kind
of guy you'd meet at the country store,
and be sitting around. And he did drink
pretty seriously, although he knew how
to not drink quite too much. The Hammonses, they were deeper into the moun
tain way of being and talking. They were
at almost the center of the Appalachians,
and their family had migrated deeper
and deeper into the most kind of old way
of being. This is Alan Jabbour's theory,
and I think it's true: they learned how to
live in the frontier. Before the American

Revolution, the Hammonses were among
the hundreds of thousands of people that
did that. As civilization encroached, they
kept going deeper into the wilderness.
But in the case of West Virginia they sort

circled around; they went to Kentucky
with Daniel Boone, that wave of settlers,
and then the Hammonses went back up
into West Virginia, which was a more dif
ficult place to live. And they were pretty
of

proud of the fact that mostly they did not
have jobs. They thought that jobs were

kind of an unfortunate thing. They had
different ways to make a living. I think
Burl had jobs sometimes. He would go to

somewhere like that, and work.
They just didn't want to be working a
job. I'll bet they all did some logging, and
Ohio

or

they did hunting.

and that
When I went to Burl's house
was just about a cold call, I just knew
where he lived, I think Dwight Diller
I
told me how to find his actual address
just parked in front of his house, walked
up this steep hill and knocked on his
door. And they were real nice. You know,
"Sure, come in." I said, "You want to play
some?" "Sure." I think Dwight was there,

and Sherman [Hammons]
I

went over

and Burl. One

where Maggie
[Hammons Parker] was and spent sev
eral hours talking to her, and recorded a
little cassette, which I'm not sure have
morning

to

I

any more, of her singing and telling sto
ries. They talked a more mountain dia
lect than Tommy did
I

didn't

perceive the real poverty

of

their lives, in the sense of just how oldtime and poor they were; which is what
happens if you don't ever have a job.
That's just how it is. It didn't use to be
that way so much. When
walked up
that hill to Burl's, in the back yard there
I

was

a

great big hog being

raised, and

they would slaughter that hog in the fall
and that would be mainly their meat.

There was a good-sized family living
in that house. He had two older sisters

who cooked, and they made a great big
groundhog stew for us that one night,
which I had some of, which was really
good. And Burl was saying, "That's
good stuff. Groundhogs don't eat bad
he kept
food, so that's"
saying
"that's real clean meat." And it was. It
was great. It was just kind of like any
sort of stew. It was potatoes and carrots
and different things, and the meat. It
was good. But their kitchen, there was a
bare light bulb on a wire hanging down.
I mean,
it was a simple place. But I was
all focused on the music. I wasn't really
thinking about that
Did the Hammonses and Tommy Jarrell seem
old to you?

Some of them did. Burl was 64.

27.

in

So

a

way,

yeah.

But

Burl

I

was
was

younger than Tommy Jarrell by a few
years. Maggie seemed older, and these

other sisters and Sherman, Burl's older
brother, they all seemed older. But they
were in good health and pretty spry, so
they didn't seem old like they needed
to be in a rest home or something. They
were just doing.

I'm just

wondering how much you might

have felt the generation difference.

certainly did. I mean, I was born
parents who were pretty old, and so I
was sort of used to being around those
people, that generation, but as parents
and not grandparents.
Tommy and Burl were my dad's gen
eration more or less, Burl a little young
er, Tommy almost exactly the same age
as my dad. And I think I did relate to
both of them in a sort of way as being
fatherly tutors.
Yeah.

of

I

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Cultural Convergences
When

I

involved

first went to college
in the civil rights

I

got very

movement

happening in Chapel Hill. And
was a minority, in terms of Southern
white people particularly young peo
well, anybody. I was a small minor
ple
But
I was out there
marching.
ity.
Vietnam was so god-awful that,
I think
that was

I

certainly for me, but I think for a lot of
people, we were looking for something
that seemed like a good thing to be doing
with your life. For me, getting involved
playing fiddle, and learning stuff like
that, was that. I never was put to the test

in

of "What

would you do

if

you were draft

deferment in college, and I
Then when they got
deferment.
kept my
rid of deferments, they did this lottery
system, and I just lucked out and had a
ed?"

I

had

a

high draft number. Everyone said
you're above 150 you probably won't
be drafted, and I was like 300. So at that
point my future was kind of liberated,
and I didn't have to deal with the actual
thought which I had of, "Well, I may go
I
to Canada."
just don't know what I
would have done. I was pretty radical
ized because of being in the civil rights
movement, to feel like if you were drafted
into something like Vietnam, that doesn't
real
if

mean you have to do it. Of course, [for]
that's
millions of people, that's just duty
what you do. And that's one of the differ

ences between me and people like Tommy

Jarrell. Though maybe not him in
lar,
a

particu

because he was radicalized by being

moonshiner family.

That's another kind of

a

in

thing. Mountain

people have always had this, they've been
willing to be apart, some of them, by things
like

[illegal moonshining]. Tommy Jarrell
made great moonshine. I had a chance to
have a little bit of his moonshine, and it was
awesome. I'm not sure [if] he made it, [or]
people in his family made it. He liked it, and
he had some around. It was aged in charred
kegs, and it was golden-colored, and he
would shake it up and show you why it
was really good, the bead and all that stuff.
I
think the mountain attitude of being
willing to not be just duty-bound was at
tractive. Maybe not the main thing, but it
was something there.

Red Clay Ramblers
The

[Red

Clay] Ramblers started

'72, sort of out of the

in

remnants of the

Fuzzy Mountain thing, and that same
Thompson had
and
and Jim
been having. Tommy
Watson formed that band in the fall of
big party that Tommy

I

'72, and then [Mike] Craver came in in
the spring of '73. I thought once we got

going and playing around and stuff, we
were like part of the soundtrack for the
alternative community.
Was

it at

the time of [the play]

Studs that you started ivorking

Diamond
[as

a

full-

time musician]?

That play was a big success, meaning
got amazingly good reviews. That
play was done in Chapel Hill in the fall
of '74. It was incredibly popular there.
We played several weekends more than

it

was still basically a lo
was real good. It was so
good that the people who wrote the play
got some people from New York who
were promoters, who were associated
with the Brooklyn Academy of Music,
we meant to.
cal thing, but

It

it

but did commercial theater, they came
down to look at the play and said, "We
could take this to New York," just almost
as it is. But they did some things to it.
They tightened it and got rid of a certain

amount of exposition.
They had Pat Birch, who was a top
choreographer who had done Grease

�The Red Clay Ramblers at the Cat's Cradle in Carrboro, North Carolina.

l-r:

Tommy Thompson, Bill Hicks, Mike Craver, Jim Watson.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The Red Clay Ramblers.

I

-

r,

Jack Herrick, Tommy Thompson,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Bill Hicks,, Mike Craver, Jim Watson.

�Conway

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�courtesy
of Bill and

Libby Hicks

that were successful,
already had dance
choreograph
in it, but she just made it into a spar
kling kind of a thing. We went up there
and did these real intensive rehearsals
and other things
it.

for about

a

It

month, in December.

So

it

New Year's Eve, and it got
opened
in places like the New
reviews
amazing
on

was sold out for about six
a week. They sent
trains from North Carolina. People by
the trainload went up there and would

York Times.

It

months, eight shows

show up

at

shows. Very famous people

see us. Alec Guinness was there,
Walter Cronkite was there. A number of

came

to

notable people.

event of it be
and
we
had
these reviews
successful,
ing
we could quote to anybody. So what do
you know, we were getting bookings! We
So at the end, we had the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

were getting bookings around the United
States and in Canada, and before long we
were able to tour in Europe. And so we
were able to pretty much be full-time
musicians. Doing the play pretty much
was working
cost everybody their job.
at Duke University Press, and they gave
me a long leave of absence, but finally
they said, "Well we've got to know what
I

do," and I said, "Well,
this horse and see
ride
I've just got
what happens." Tommy had been teach
ing, and he gave that up. Mike and Jim

you're going

to

to

had different things they were doing. But
we were able to put that together.
wouldn't say it was a good living.
When
finally left the band in January
'81, left because I realized that I wasn't
making but about 25 cents an hour. And
had [built my] house and I felt
by then
I

I

1

I

bad that
wasn't here. I wanted to be
more involved with just being here.
And then the Ramblers, as they went
I

to have successes in the
Tommy was interested in theater. He
wrote a play on his own, a one-man play
that's pretty good, about a banjo player.
And the association with [later Red Clay
Bland
Ramblers members]
Simpson,

on,

continued

ater.

who's the writer, and Jim Wann, they
did several other collaborations, and it
just was a way of continuing on. And of
course Craver too. Mike Craver after he
left the Ramblers had two or three really
big theatrical successes of musicals that
are more just exactly what he wanted to
do. But that all comes out of the fact that
Diamond
it

Studs

gave everybody

in

it

a

find the next thing, whatever
might be. You never know [with] the-

foothold

to

�ater stuff and movie stuff, all of that can
just be great, or just not work.
I've always wondered if the eclecticism of
the material that the Red Clay Ramblers sang
was [due to] each of you having a broad area
of tastes, or if it was sort of a sense that in the
'20s and '30s, the musicians in those days also
were listening to and playing all sorts of stuff?
I think
that and the taste. Really most of
I was
in the Ramblers it always
seemed very democratic. We would have
practice sessions and someone would

the time

say, "Well, let's do this," and the next guy

would

say, "Well, let's learn this one, let's
do this." And we'd sort of go around and

everybody would provide something.
Now and again someone would say, "No,
I

hate that,

I

don't want to do it." The four

really did have together a pretty
wide range of tastes. I mean, you can hear
that in those first two records, but even
before we started writing at all. And it
was real natural to write something. Cart
of us

Stanley wrote things, the Carter Family
least sort of wrote things.
So the eclecticism
to me, what we
were doing, seemed exactly like the
sort of sea of music that we were taken
out of. I think I broadened the range
by being interested in stuff like blues.
Like on that first record [Stolen Love
there's about three things in different
ways that are blues-oriented. There's
that "Honey Babe" song, which I think
may be the Mississippi Sheiks', and
I did
"I Got What It Takes," which is
Bessie Smith. I mean I picked that song
'cause I just liked the words, and Craver could play it real good
the piano is
real good in that.
Also having the piano. That was a re
ally good thing. Craver came into the
band as a bass player because nobody
er
at

knew he played piano. He could play
guitar, and was interested in Carter
Family, and was interested in harmony

he had a great high voice,
nice
He brought all these
voice.
really
real interesting things to the band that
broadened us. I would say of all the

singing, and

people he really brought in the most.
He would do stuff like "Keep the Home
even though that's an
song, it's really more like a
Tin Pan Alley old-timey song.
Fires Burning"

old-timey

Revivalism
I

wanted

to

ask you about the words

"re

vivalist" and "revival," how you feel about
those terms.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�don't have any particular bad feeling
about that. think [there's] sort of an accu
I

I

always felt like, if you learn how
to play the music well, that there's a way
in which you're reviving if it's gone. Like
Alan's metaphor of the fiddle tunes it's
like an hour glass and the tunes are down
racy to

it.

I

last little grain of sand, and then
somebody like Alan comes along and they
to the

get them going again. They revive those
think it's
tunes. That's fair enough. But
an activity.
think that if you do the activ
ity well, then pretty much you're doing it,
I

I

and it's not like, "You're a revivalist, and
this guy's real, but you're not quite real."

don't think you have to come from a cul
it was once part of. If you can
as an ex
fiddle
tunes well enough
play
then
be
a good dance fiddler
to
ample,
that's no more than what Henry Reed did,
or [what] people 100 years ago did. That's
the same idea. That's the task. And it's not
I

ture which

very different from what learned how to
do later on. My brick laying is about as
good as anyone else's brick laying, you
I

know?

It might not be as fast, but I get it.
The things are plumb and they're straight
and it's a task.

That's another thing, the general truth
of it is that [with] all the media and
stuff that were available and began to

available in the '20s, you just could
hear more. And so it was real hard to be
a culture that was just closed off the way
be

[had been]. Probably poverty kept it
closed off and people not being able to
afford good cars, not being able to afford
a record player, they stayed more like it
was in the old days when everybody
it

was just learning. Like Tommy Jarrell
talks about riding a horse somewhere
and learning some tunes, and then sing
ing them over and over to himself un
til he could get home to practice. Well,
now we have all that stuff. So it might
be sort of a moot question. I don't know
if there's too many places where people
are really, really isolated where you
can say they are not revivalists. I mean,
some of the old fiddlers we would go

visit would record you.

a

lot

of

quit. And she quit. He said, "I can't kick
them off the stage." We played there a

number of times. It was the Town Crier
in Beacon, New York.
She was just incredibly upset. After
our show we went and talked to her and
tried to explain that, "Look, we're not
supporting those views. These are old
songs, and we think that's just a funny
song, and its just a piece of humor in
we're not really saying that
the show
to you." Because we were kind of con
vincing, she didn't quit. But I think we

quit doing that song after that because,
the point wasn't to ever
again, it just
do that to anybody. She told us about
[how] she had come to that job after
leaving an abusive husband, and that
little coffee shop was a place that she felt
and here these guys come in there
safe
with a bunch of stuff like that, and that

was invading her emotional space. And
I think
she was right.
That's about the power of [old-time
music]. There's always that, and maybe
more than we realize. I'll tell you an
other story like that. The Ramblers did
an old gospel song,
"Daniel Prayed"
has call-and-response and it's a capella
the way we did it. One time in '74 we

were supposed

humorous songs

done by people like Blind Alfred Reed,
[which were] in one way or another kind
of rants about how women were get
ting, [how] they were not being what
they were supposed to be. [The Red Clay
Ramblers] had a job one time in a coffee
house in Upstate New York and we did

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

play

a

job in Cullo-

western North Carolina, and
whee
the guy who was the promoter was
concerned that people weren't going to
show up in any numbers. He suggested
we go down to Cherokee, which wasn't
in

too far away, and play some on the
street and sort of tout the show. So we
did. We found a place on the sidewalk
in front of some stores, and sang for a
while, and told people there was a show
that evening.
We did "Daniel Prayed." And there was
old man, maybe a Cherokee, I'm
not sure, this old wizened old man who
was nearby. I think he was sweeping the
this

sidewalk.

The Power of Old-Time Music
There were

"Woman's Been After Man Ever Since,"
which is one of those songs. It really is
funny. And a woman that worked in
that coffee house told the owner if he
wouldn't kick us off the stage, that she'd

and

He

started

something

threw

down his broom

testifying. We just
on in him. We were

turned

messing

around with another piece of the power,
you know, and we didn't expect that.
We didn't know what to think! We just
sort of shut up and let him go on for a
while, and he finally kind of ran down
and went back to sweeping. But that's
the deal: you're fooling around with stuff
that's powerful.

Q^ff

CATCHING UP
Stories

Revival Gen

of Old-Time Music's

eration focuses mainly on old-time music be
tween the 1960s and around 1980. We asked
Bill to provide some contemporary context
about his life and music in the decades since.

kind of musical culmination of my
years was our live record,
Chuckin' the Frizz. We got that done in

TheRambler

January of '79, the same month I got the
logs to the cabin moved out here [Bill's
home near Siler City, North Carolina]. I
went up to New Jersey to Dale Ashby's
studio and we did editing and such a few

months later. Ashby was a fantastic re
mote engineer and had worked with gos
pel choirs in churches, and with Laura
Nyro at her place on Long Island. Flying
Fish had been willing to pay for him, so
Frizz was probably the most expensive
record we'd made, production-wise.
But after getting Frizz

completed

I

start

ed feeling like tilings were unraveling in
the band, and things were also not going

well with my marriage. We were gone
too much, you could say that about both
areas of my life. I started thinking about
how little I was making per hour away
from home, and how the times when
I
could be here and work on the house
were the high points, and the circuit of
gigs we were doing seemed like the same
old milk route with nothing much new
bar gigs, some festivals, more
or better
bar gigs. We did Jolinny Cash's daugh
ter Rosanne's East Coast wedding recep
tion, racing down there from the Upper

Peninsula of Michigan,

thinking

it

was

big break of some kind, and it fell flat
because they had pretty much tin cans on
a

waxed strings for a sound system.
It also seemed like our practices were
not what they had been, a fun democratic
kind of thing where everyone wanted to
be there doing it. Jack Herrick also start
ed trying to run the practices by

out lead sheets and such

didn't really get

or

a

giving
method we

were used to. Slowly

in the time after Frizz came out, from say
mid-'79 till October 1980, the vibe in the

bus wasn't so great.

down up

in

Then the bus broke

southwestern Wisconsin on

a

gave notice. So they end
ed up picking Clay Buckner to replace
me, and he and I did a few gigs together
in that winter, '80-'81, and I was stand
road trip, and

I

ing on the curb at the end of January, '81,
sniffing the diesel fumes from the '48

�Trailways they'd done bought searching
for more leg room.
I sat around for a

couple of dark months
stove. Amiie [Malone,
Hicks' former wife] had left — she'd real
in the cabin, by the

ly left that previous fall. I finally got a job
with the guy who I'd hired to help build

the cabin, a counter-culture carpenter if
there ever was one named Robin Garrett.

Sometime during the spring

I

started sit

ting in with the Red Rose Flyers,

a

string

band run by Dave and Tom Holt and a
various assortment of folks. They played
a dance every
Tuesday night at a bar in
Carrboro that was once the railroad sta
tion — it was called The Station. And the
Flyers did gigs now and then too. And
at that dance I hooked up with my wife,
I
did
Libby, at some point that year.
various building jobs, basically carpen
try jobs, for Robin and then some other
contractors, and then I hooked up with
a very
good stone mason, Joe Kenlan,
because he'd heard I was building my
chimney on the cabin. I drove an old
'60s pickup that was barely running, a
real rattle

trap, then

little yellow '76
Datsun. When I moved into the cabin
there was a tarp for the front door, and
the first winter it snowed in on my face
through cracks in the outer gable plank
a

Hammons Family would have
ing.
been comfortable in my house.
The

Then Libby and
got married in '84,
I
quit smoking, and we got a well
pump and running water as Libby' s little
girl Anna was going to be out here, and
I built
an addition onto the place with a
room for Anna, and we got a real stove
I

and

instead of a three-burner gas stove top.
It became more and more liveable for a
family. I kept working on various ma
sonry jobs with Kenlan, then went out on
my own. I went back to school to get a
teaching certificate, but my student teach
ing section was so horrible I went back
to masonry yet again. And all the while
Libby and I kept playing music— dances,
and gigs with little bands that would
come together as they do: the Next Zenith
String Band with Tom Holt on banjo, the
RKX (get it, "Archaics?") with Margaret
Martin, which featured a lot of great duet
singing with Libby and Margaret; then a
band with another real good woman sing
er from around here, and John Worthing
ton on guitar, a bit more towards hon
kytonk. One of our big "hits" was Merle

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Haggard's "Silver Wings." I think that's
where Libby and I worked up some Dan
Hicks stuff that we eventually recorded
on our own CD, in 1999.
I kind
of partially re
Ocracoke Island [in the Outer
Banks of North Carolina]. She'd totally
burned out on all the driving from the
edge to the center of the Triangle, and
couldn't find a job that did her abilities

In '95

located

Libby and
to

justice. We'd gotten to the big ten-year
mark in the marriage. So we packed up
and went to Ocracoke, and Anna went to
school there for a year, '95-'96, 1 worked
there some, Libby worked there. I'd
come up here and do masonry jobs when
they came up, keep an eye on the cabin.
We had a guy staying here too, when I
was gone. We rented a little house down
there, Libby started doing art glass work,
got a kiln and was doing really wonder
ful fused glass pieces and selling them
on Ocracoke and at a gallery in Manteo
[on Roanoke Island] too. And we were
not only playing as a duet, but got into

amazing Cajun zydeco band cen
tered around Bryan and Barbara Blake,
in Gloucester, North Carolina.
Bryan
and Barbara were kind of like Tommy
and Bobbie, I guess. Very outgoing, gre
an

garious folks, loved parties, totally open
about who they played with, what kind
of stuff they would do. Bryan was and
is a great Cajun accordion player and
singer, also plays fiddle, also just a great
band leader. In his other life he is a boat
builder and he's a fireman too, in the
Marshallberg, North Carolina, fire de

50,000 fewer miles, its wipers don't work
sometimes). I should also mention that
I
got into a songwriting jag in the late
'90s and did a solo singer-songwriter CD
in 2001, and for a while I tried my hand
at solo songwriter gigs with mostly my
guitar for backup, but eventually it got to
feel too thankless a task. Paying for the

gas is only so much of an argument for
driving to the gig.
In 1999 Jessie Thompson Eustice, Tom
my's daughter, corralled Mike Craver and
me to play what turned out to be Tommy

Thompson's last public performance,
a

free Carrboro Music festival.

at

The next

Jim, Mike, I, and Joe Newberry,
played the Eno Festival in Durham as the

year

O'Blurs.

It

was the start of

a

reunion band

that still plays today. We did various little
road trips and local things as we could,

Northern Ire
at Missouri's
Big Muddy Festival, Wheatlands in cen
tral Michigan (where RCR had been a big
deal in the late '70s), and the Hiawatha
including

a

trip

in '05 to

land, and nice festival gigs

Festival, in Marquette, Michigan, capital
of the "UP," another reunion from a great
trip RCR had done in 1980. In '09 we de
cided to call ourselves the Craver, Hicks,
Watson, Newberry Band. Or as the boys
say, "the law firm." I've been a member
of CHWN longer than I was with the Red
Clay Ramblers! A couple of years ago we
did a nice CD over at the Rubber Room

Chapel Hill, You've Been a Friend To Me.
Singing with harmony, some tunes. Same
in

ever was.
When tire '08 recession hit, I was working a
great stone job, and that kept me going well
into '09. But the next job didn't happen, and
as it

partment.
So Libby

'99, is just at 250,000 miles, and is still the
best vehicle we own (though the S-10 has

and

I

known Tongues,

played

a

lot with

Un

Bryan and Barbara's
until
we
left
Ocracoke and came
band,
back up here in '03-'04. Meanwhile my
stonework had gotten good and it was a
good time to be a freelance stone mason,
so work was good.
Anna had gradu
ated, gone to college, gotten married,
gone back to college. Libby and I did
mostly dances here and there— we're a
damn good contra-dance band, fiddle
and piano. We've worked up nifty med
leys, which contra-dancers like because
the changes give the dance a kick. We've

contra-dances from Montpelier,

played
Vermont, to Greenville, South Carolina,
with a long side trip to Tucson, Arizona,
and Austin, Texas. Yee-haw! Our little
Toyota Tacoma, which we bought new in

finally

I

got

in the office.

a

"real job" at Bish Scrap Metal,
That's what I do now. First

"real job" was after

I hit 65!
Surely I'm an
tire
Hammons
clan?
member
of
honorary
Have to ask Dwight Diller, I guess, see what
he opines. The normal job hours put a big

cramp in my general creativity, but Libby
When it's
and I try to do a few dances.
not too hot, we battle the encroaching
a blog,
I write
jungle here at the cabin.

fiddlerbill.blogspot.com.

It

keeps my

typing chops up, and now and then I write
a good piece of sort of
personal-oriented
political commentary, if I do say so myself.
I turned 73 last
January. Damn!
--Bill Hicks

�THE BANJO COLLECTOR'S GATHERING
By Kristina Gaddy
Some will always call the event by its

room that contains an 1850s
minstrel banjo, a replica of the first banjos that ex
isted in the New World, and several early Fairbanks
Imagine
Whyte Laydie banjos— as well as a hundred other ban
jos, some new, some vintage, some common, some
rare. To all of that add cabinet card photographs of ban
and
jo players, posters of minstrel shows, stunning inlay
This isn't
engravings, and 19th -century banjo catalogs.
a banjo exhibit at the Musical Instrument Museum in
Phoenix or at the National Museum of American His
tory. It's what the Hyatt Hotel ballroom in Morristown,
New Jersey, looked like one weekend this past Septem
ber. These treasured items from private, world-class
banjo collections around the country are displayed oncer

walking into

a

a

year for the Nineteenth Century Banjo Gathering.

original name, the Banjo Collector's
Gathering, while others lovingly call it
the Banjo Geekathon, but whatever you
call it, the meeting is not solely for col
lectors, solely for academics, or solely for

musicians.

It's for all of them.

It is

an

op

portunity for collectors to show off their
latest finds, for builders to exhibit their
latest pieces, and for curious research
ers to present their latest theories. They
get together to explore the rich history of
the banjo, from its African origins to its
role in blackface

minstrelsy, its days

as

instrument played by the turn-of-thecentury New York upper classes, and its
an

role as an icon of country music and of
America. In its 17 years of existence, the

Gathering has spawned books, articles,
and museum exhibits that have changed
our understanding of the instrument.
This past year in New Jersey the Gath
ering returned to the state where the first
group of collectors met in 1998. That first

event, in Cape May, New Jersey, was sim
ply an opportunity to get together with
friends and talk banjos. Organizers and
founders Jim Bollman and Peter Szego
say that they had been getting together
with friends at festivals and camps for a
couple of years to talk casually about the
Jristory of the banjo, but those events were
playing the music, not learn
ing about the background of the banjo.
"There really wasn't any venue to concen
trate on the instrument itself," says Szego.
Bollman and Szego, who credit banjo
player and scholar Bob Carlin with sug
gesting a more formal get-together, invit
ed about 15 friends to a small bed-andbreakfast in Cape May. They invited some

designed

for

collectors, musicians, and
academics,
builders. Everyone they invited came,
and they had presentations, roundtable

discussions, and a show-and-tell of rare
banjos. At the heart of it all was the cul
tural history of the banjo. Bollman, Sze
go, and the early attendees saw the banjo
more than just a musical instrument;
they saw it as a way to examine history,
as

technology, community, and American
culture, something Bollman and Szego
Kristina Gaddy

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

had been doing for years.
Jim Bollman has been a collector all his
life. Music surrounded him in his child
hood too: there was always a guitar ly
ing around, and his mother taught him

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�to play "Ain't She Sweet" on the banjo
ukulele. When he was 12 years old, Boll-

man traded his Dinky Toy collection for
his first banjo, an instrument "with beau
tiful inlaid birds," he recalls.
By the early 1960s, he started getting in
terested in antiques and the folk music re
vival. He was listening to bluegrass music
and talking with dealers about old instru
ments. Then, in 1965, he got the old-time
bug when he attended Carlton Haney's
music festival in Virginia and for the first
time heard Mike Seeger play clawhammer
banjo. Bollman began learning to play.
He had a eureka moment when he real
ized that not many people were collect
ing banjos, and that he could find the in
struments in antique shops. His collect
ing habit kicked in and he became one
of the first people in the United States
actively to seek out the best banjos from
the 19th century. One the one hand, this

meant that he could start developing his
collection, but on the other, it meant that
few people had information about the
banjos. Along with Bollman's collecting
came an immense desire for information.
"The more

found out about the banjo,
I became,"
he says. He
had to collect source material in order to
find out about the banjos. He also started
the more

documenting
jos,

trading

enthusiast

I

interested

tire

serial numbers of

them with

classic-era

Jim Bollman (left) ivith Jayson Dobney,
the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

ban

banjo

Kaufman, and mapping out
the chronology of the instrument. Soon, he
was collecting not just instruments, but all
manner of ephemera. His collection grew
Eli

include not only photos and instru
ments, but cards, dolls, magazines, cata
logs, and anything else that could tell him
about the history of the instrument. Today,
to

many of the photos of early banjo players
you'll see in print are credited to Jim Bollman. His desire to learn more about the in
strument also led him to hanging out with
fellow enthusiasts and collectors like Mike
Holmes, Lester Davidson, Doug Unger,
Mike Seeger, and Peter Szego.
Szego got into traditional music the way so
many other people of his generation did: by
hearing the Kingston Trio on the radio. His
world, like Jim Bollman's, seemed to collide
serendipitously with the banjo. When he
was 15 his mother took him to a Pete Seeger
Two houses down from his home
New Jersey, someone played Scruggs-

concert.
in

style banjo. In the 1960s he'd take day trips
into New York City to play by the fountain
at Washington Square Park, and eventually

played Dobro in a bluegrass band.
Although he gave up bluegrass music in
college, he was drawn to rhythm and mu-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Peter Szego

Associate Curator of

the

Department of Musical Instruments

at

�Curator Jerry Fabris of the Thomas Edison National Historical Park working with
By the 1970s, he moved to New York
City and wanted to learn tap dance. Rath
er than learning what was new and com
sic.

mercial, Szego tracked down older black
tap

dancers in the city for lessons.

He

rented a studio space near Times Square
for about three dollars an hour, and took
private lessons from some of the masters.
When Szego moved out of the city in the

early 1980s, he couldn't bring his teachers,
so he found the "closest thing to tap danc
ing on strings I could find," which turned
out to be clawhammer banjo. This was
exactly the same time that Jim Bollman's
collection was on display at the Massa
chusetts Institute of Technology's exhibit
Ring the Banjar. Just seeing those banjos

inspired Szego to start collecting.
Szego and Bollman became
and talked

friends

about the philosophy of col
Amassing items is different

lecting.
from collecting, contends Szego. It's not
just acquiring objects that counts, but a
"serious collector's mentality." The items
have to have a significance, to be part of
a narrative.
Bollman had spent years de
that
narrative, and now there
veloping
was a whole community wanting to learn
about the history of the banjo. By creating
the Banjo Collector's Gathering, they in
vited research, collaboration, and curios
ity

among fellow banjo enthusiasts.

When

Peter

Szego

and

Jim

Bollman

planned the first Gathering, Szego thought
it would only take place once. Then attend
ees started talking about "next year."
So
in 1999, he and Bollman planned the next

meeting in Baltimore, Maryland. It was at
tended by about 30 people. That was the
first year that banjo maker Pete Ross at
tended the Gathering.
Ross doesn't con
sider himself a collector, but recognized the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

cylinder phonograph.

benefit of the event and being able to see
first-hand collections like those of Bollman,
"It nurtures
Szego, and Hank Schwartz.
those of us who build," he says. "I'd never
get a chance to see those instruments other
wise." Ross has been attending the Gather
ing ever since and says, "Every year, I'm left
with at least one little magical moment."
At that second Gathering in Baltimore,

Ulf Jagfors presented research on the Afri
can instruments related to the New World
Cecelia Conway had published
banjo.

her book African Banjo Echoes in Appalachia
four years earlier, and other scholars had
the African roots of American

explored
music, such

as

Dena Epstein in her book

Sinful Tunes and Spirituals: Black Folk Music
to the Civil War, but there was less research

into the actual instruments that may have
been the "ancestors" of the banjo. Jagfors'
research
and to

explored links to the akonting,
the jali musicians and storytellers

(also called griots) of West Africa.
Those early meetings set the stage for
continued research on the Jiistory of the
banjo. The Gathering has created an envi

ronment where anyone can present their
research and discoveries. Bob Carlin says,
"This small group of people has developed
the biggest trends in banjo research." Jim
Bollman asserts that the Gathering "can
modestly take credit for a lot of the banjo's
history today." So much research about the
banjo has roots in the Gathering: Carlin's
The Birth of the Banjo: Joel Walker Sweeney
and Early Minstrelsy Pete Ross, Greg Ad

ams,

and Bob Winans'

exhibit on instru

ment builder William Boucher, Jr., and the
earliest commercial production of banjos;
and Jim Bollman's discovery of master
Boston banjo maker Icilio Consalvi, just to
name a few examples. "We may each have

our own particular focus, but there's no
other place than here to present this infor
mation," says Peter Szego.
The Gathering isn't just about presenting
research and serious discussions about the
banjo; the social element and collegial na
ture of the first Gathering still remain. "I go
to these things to hang out with people I like,
who have common interests beyond the
banjo," says Tony Thomas. The organizers
have kept it small and homey. Jim Bollman
figures that those who are interested will
learn about it and show up. These days,
there are usually between 50 and 75

attend

Attendees

introduce themselves the
first .night, but most people already know
each other. Outside of scheduled activities,
you can find people swapping tunes, enjoy
ing good food and drink, and talking about
ees.

anything from bicycles to punk rock.
From the beginning, Jim Bollman and Pe
ter Szego also wanted to choose locations
that had something to offer.

included visits

to the

THs past year

exhibit of Martin gui

tars at the Metropolitan Museum of Art,
which Szego helped curate, and a private
tour of the Morris Museum's Guinness Col

lection of Mechanical Musical Instruments
and Automata. Jerry Fabris of the Edison
Museum also brought a wax cylinder re
corder to create a recording of Greg Ad
ams and Henry Sapoznik. Although these
activities weren't all directly banjo-related,
they represent the curiosity of the attendees.
Previous Gatherings have included visits to
the Long Island Museum, the Museum of
Fine Arts in Boston, Williamsburg, Virginia,

and the Museum of Appalachia.
This fall, the Gathering will

convene

Waterfront Marriot Hotel in Balti
more, Maryland, the weekend of October
at the

30

November

1.

�CAPO'S

903 East Main Street
Abingdon, VA 24210
(276) 525-1880
Shop Us Online'.

MUSICSTORE

sww.caposmusicstore.com
Store Hours: Monday-Friday 10-6 PM

Section with Illegible Text

Saturday 10-9PM

Join us for our Jam every Saturday at G:30

We are proud to
CARRY

A

SELECTION
SHOP

BROAD
OF

SMALL

INSTRUMENTS

FROM THE

NATIONAL

FINEST

BUILDERS

AND LOCAL LUTHIERS
IN OUR OWN
BACKYARD.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&lt;

�Reviews

started

abruptly ended. All that is true
recording, from the ambience at
the luncheon, to a truck going by during
"Oklahoma Redbird," to the inclusion
of 48 tunes, some as short as 34 seconds.
None of that detracts one bit from the
opportunity to hear this master fiddler

Lee Stoneking: Missouri

Fiddling

&amp;

or

of this

Banjo Playing

in action.

Tracks one through 16 come from a ses
sion on Stoneking's porch and find his
performances more informal and short
er
usually one or two passes through
the tune
than those at the luncheon.
The Field

Recorders' Collective FRC708

Bitter Creek

Twinkle Little Star

Sally

Johnson
Blackberry Waltz
Blackberry
Two-Step Cleve Barnhart's Schottische
Oklahoma Redbird
Rustic Dance Schot
tische
Schottische in Key of D Fisher's
Hornpipe in G Fisher's Hornpipe in D
Clucking Hen

Great Big Taters in Sandy
Land
Lonesome Blues
Long Gone
What a Friend We Have in Jesus
Ala
bama Gals
Leather Britches
Birdie in
the Snow Bank
Echoes of the Ozarks
Chicken Reel
Martha Campbell

Angus Campbell
Durang's Hornpipe

Eighth of January

Willott's Hornpipe
Goes
the
Weasel
Pop
Cackling Hen
Dream
Waltz
My
Rolling Stone Break
down
Bill Cheatum
Adrian's Reel
Fire on the Mountain
Sally Goodin
Big
Sandy River
Orange Blossom Special
Arkansas Traveler
Shortening Bread
Old Indiana
Sweet
Cripple Creek
Marie
Can I Sleep In Your Barn To
On a Cold Winter's Night
night Mister?
Banjo Tune in the Key of A
Floating
Down the Mississippi Little Orphan An
nie
How Old Are You My Pretty Little
Miss?
Ain't She Sweet
Alabama Gals
In

mid-summer

1985,

Brad

Leftwich,

Linda Higginbotham, and Kenny Jack
son were taken by friends to a senior citi

zens' luncheon in Lowry City, Missouri,
and there met fiddler and banjoist Lee
Stoneking, who was the featured enter
tainment that day. Stoneking invited all
three to join him on stage, which they
did, and Higginbotham made sure to re
cord the event on tape. The taped results
of that event, and those from some ad
ditional jamming on Stoneking's porch

later that day, are the subject of this Field
Recorders' Collective release.
The FRC CDs are, for the most part,
non-studio recordings.
They include
background noises and verbal patter,
and, quite often, the tracks are many
and short and are sometimes hesitantly

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

According
not known

to

Stoneking was
tempos, and the re

the notes,

for fast

sults here bear this out. Most of his tem
pos in this section hover between the 76
bpm of "Cleve Barnhart's Schottische"
and the 92 bpm of "Sally Johnson." The
is "Big Taters In Sandy Land"

exception
at 120
as on

bpm. Opting for slower tempos,
such tuneful standouts as "Black

berry Waltz," "Blackberry Two-Step,"
"Rustic Dance Schottishe," and "Twinkle
Little Star," allowed for a smoother, more
rounded tone and a refined flow, still
rythmic but not choppy. His variations
are

minimal,

are so short.

in

part because

the tunes

�When the recording shifts to the luncheon,
tracks 17 to 39, the tempos jump and there
are a few more tunes with slightly longer

running times, several, such as "Angus
Campbell," "Leather Britches," and "Bill
Cheatum," having four or more passes
through each, though the variations re
main subtle. The increased tempos and
his use of an amplified fiddle change
his tone and

attack somewhat

to

one

a

Still, Stonekraspier and sawing.
ing's playing and arranging skills shine
through, most notably on "Birdie In the
Snow Bank," "Echoes of the Ozarks,"
and Stoneking's original "Old Indiana."
bit

The final ten tracks find

Stoneking back

on his porch, this time with his banjo. It
sounds like he uses a two-finger, up-pick

ing style, one somewhat spare but very
tuneful. "On a Cold Winter's Night" is
perhaps the best of these tunes, though
they are all pleasant takes, and round out
an

overall enjoyable recording.

BILL WAGNER
To

order: fieldrecorder.org

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�mind." (When the band does the review
is grateful.) The usual

er's work for him, he

configuration of the Happy Valley Pals
Martin, fiddle;

Wayne

Margaret

is:

Martin,

guitar; Gail Gillespie, banjo; and Dwight
Rogers, bass. They are a two-couple band;
Gail and

Dwight

are

a

couple,

as are

Wayne

and Margaret. And they make wonderful
music together, and have for some time.
What's more, it's clear that they are hav

ing fun making music, and that is apparent
even through the Is and Os of the CD.
All four band members are both
good

singers and good instrumentalists. Good
bands start with good fiddling, and Wayne
can play tunes from Tennessee,
Georgia,
and North Carolina (and other locations)
with recognizably different and appropriate
styles. Dwight Rogers, who can play several
instruments well, here plays solid, tasteful
bass, as well as ukulele on five tracks. Mar
garet's backup guitar is excellent; on some
tracks she plays simple boom-chuck and on

others connects the chords with nice runs.
But what makes them distinctive is Gail Gil
lespie's banjo playing. After many years of
living in the Piedmont and listening to (and
making friends with) many older fingerstyle banjo players, Gail has developed a
traditional yet innovative three-finger banjo
style which blends perfectly into the Happy
Valley Pals. Margaret and Gail have clearly

spent a lot of time listening to Roy Harvey
and Charlie Poole (although the liner notes
credit

one point "the guitar runs of John

at

By the

Dilleshaw.")

way,

"Sally with

the

Run-Down Shoes" features Gail on guitar
and Margaret on finger-style banjo.
Some personal favorites. Instrumental:
"Sally ..." (which sounds like the tune I
know as "Jenny Lind Polka"— that which
we call

rose...);

a

original

timing!);

"Stone Rag" (with the
and "Leake County

I
convince anyone else that
this is where "Logan County Blues" came
from?). Singing: clianneling the Carter
Family with "Schoolhouse on the Hill";

Blues"

(Can

"Frankie Silvers" (if you want to learn the

backstory of tJiis murder, try Sharyn McCrumb's true-crime novelization of this
1833 murder); Wade Mainer's "Ramshack
le

Shack";

"and

Georgia

Wobble

Blues"

(this band is certainly living a ragtime life).
The Happy Valley Pals (and their lis

teners!)

have reason

to

be

grateful

to

County Records; County 3530 was where
first learned about the Roane County
Ramblers, the Happy Valley Pals' source
for "Alabama Trot" and "Green River
March." And County's Nashville: The Ear
I

ly String Bands (County 3521 and 3522)
has the source recordings for "Salt Lake

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

City Blues" and "Stone's Rag." As hap
in the best of modern old-time mu
sic, they have learned from the source,
and then made it their own. What more

pens

could you want

in

a

CD?
PETE PETERSON

To order:

jardownmusic.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Aunt, she beat me/ And she kicked me /In
It's not only a beautiful per
temple.
formance, but a fascinating arrangement—
which could describe any selection on this
excellent album.

the

SARAH BRYAN
To

order: lonesomeace.com/music-store

�just to the beauty of the music. Which
is as it should be, but seldom achieved.
This is an excellent CD.
PETE PETERSON
To order:

dittyville.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

other Midwest old-timers, as the liner notes

detail).
That Midwest regional center of gravity gets
in the presence of the other members

reflected

of New Bad Habits. St. Louis resident and
banjo player Dave Landreth has a rollicking
CD of his own, Chairs. He's played with sev
eral string

bands including

the Combine,

the

Elderbullies, and the Vigortones, and brings
that

background to New Bad Habits.
found on this CD made me want to

great

What

I

hear more of his great clawhammer playing.
Like Chirps Smith, Tim Foss, also on fiddle,

name for himself through his
playing. His solo CD,
The Cat Came Back, includes dance tunes

has

made

a

Midwest-influenced
and

original

compositions,

and

his

playing

has taken him not only to regional events but
also a tour of Europe with the Foghorn String
On Shades of Death Creek, he and
Chirps speak the same melodic language, and
they keep their twinned fiddling on rhythm
and in sync. Their twin fiddles appear on half

Band.

of the

18

tracks.

Guitar and bass are covered ably by Andy
Gribble. His back-up keeps things simultane

ously rock-steady and moving along. He's
known for his proficiency on several instru
ments and, like others in the band,
quents Midwest dances and festivals.
It

is the

he

fre

Midwest roots of the band's mem

bers that helped make this CD stand out for

�me.
as its

While the region is not as well known
Southern counterparts for old-time mu

sic, there

is a

venerable history of traditional
in Illinois and its bor

dance and fiddle tunes

dering states. A full eight of the tunes on this
CD trace to sources in Missouri, Wisconsin,
Iowa,

and,

Michigan,

not

surprising

given

that it's Chirps' native state, Illinois. One gets
the idea from this selection that Midwestern

old-time tunes

are

often played

faster than

their southern Appalachian counterparts!
But a second thing distinguishes this record
ing with repeated plays: I notice not only the
Midwest heritage that forms the backdrop,
but also the ways the tunes

themselves tend

toward the rarely- or never-before-recorded.
That, too, may account for the fact that it
was only later listens that made my liking for
Shades of Death Creek really grow. There are
reasons that some of the old-time stand-bys
are, well, stand-bys. Their tunefulness and lilt
mean musicians keep coming back to them.
That familiarity can be a great strength and
may leave many old-time enthusiasts content.
But for those interested in new tunes, new
turns of musical

older versions
the fifth

phrase, new

on

the

"Durang's Hornpipe,"
CD like Shades of Death

track), a
Creek will hold extra appeal.

Horned Buck"

takes

(like

in the

key of

So while "Fork
D

does not ap

pear
any of my banjo tablature books, it's
a good
one (sourced back in the liner notes
in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�to

fiddler Henry Elie, who died in
Something similar could be said of

Illinois

1986).
"Doc Corn's Tune"
Southern

Illinois

in

G:

farmer

name graces the tune title.
The Midwest connection
still if you count the three

it

and

traces back

to

a

fiddler, whose

is

actually stronger
tunes here written

members. Dave Landreth, for in
stance, composed "I Gotta Get a Job," and the
liner notes tell the humorous story behind the
by the band's

title. And Chirps came

originals,

of

including

up

with the other two

the title track. And there's

a

story there, too, though not Midwest-spe
cific: The macabre feel of the title (to say noth
bit

a

ing of the spooky woodcut on the cover) comes
from his travels just south of Clifftop, West Vir

ginia. Passing through the town of Danese, with
a creek with that morbid and mysterious name,
gave him the inspiration for a tune title.
As with other important recordings I've en
countered, it was careful listening (and linernote reading) that yielded repeated rewards.
So in this case I'll keep coming back.
TIMOTHY JONES
To order:

cdbaby.com/cd/ newbadhabits

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�many vocal duets.
tight harmony, but the voices
blend well and the off-hand manner is
engaging. "Crazy About Nancy Jane,"
a raggy, hokum blues, is the next high
the

fering

It's not

light,
by

a

first

of

a

and that's followed a track later
somewhat wistful version of "I'll

one of three standards in
cluded here— the others being a medium-up bouncy version of "You Are My
Sunshine," and a tremolo-driven cover
All of those are
of "Goodnight Irene."
well
as
is
done,
Jimmie
very
Rodgers'
"No Hard Times," sung by Mindte, and
John Hurt's "Let The Mermaids Flirt
With Me," which has "Waiting For a
Train" overtones. About the only track
Fly Away,"

that falls short is "He's In the Jailhouse
This is not the Rodgers version

Now."

but the 1915 version that led to versions
from the Louisville Jug Band and the

Memphis Sheiks. Franklin and Mindte's
version sounds cluttered and out of sorts.
That and some problems here and there
with the way the mandolin was record

ed— often the blend with the guitar is not
there, making it sound brittle and stac
cato— are the only weak spots on what is
a
nicely varied and very good recording.
BILL WAGNER
To order:

pxrec.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ond part of the film is the complete per
formance, beautifully filmed from the best
seats in the house.
The viewer is brought into the energy

celebration

the

of

fabulous

via

exciting
and

photography,

music,
personal

vignettes. Readers of the OTH will feel

and honor for performers
have
enjoyed over the past
they

the gratitude

whom

decades.
Those of us who miss
dance company Rhythm in Shoes
will be happy to see reprises of some
of their wonderful numbers, including
four
the

"Gotta Go," "Mississippi Lawyer,"
"You Take It." Leahy's

interesting
a

and

choreography

is

and varied and has at times

hugely appealing

whimsical light
solidly supported

and

ness. The dancers are
by one of the "best dance band(s) in all
the land," led by Good, the best dance
banjoist ever. The talented cast of ama
teurs and professionals executes every
note and each step with joy and preci
sion. Truly, Wheatland loves dance.

Leahy /Good
participant
dance workshops at many camps and
events, I appreciate the historical aspect
of this film. Many cast dancers were in
spired by and/ or were part of the Green
Grass Cloggers, who toured the coun
As

in

a

try in the

1970s.

the

Green Grass changed

many people's lives by setting hearts on
fire, and by planting seeds of traditional
dance and music everywhere they went.
It's sweet to see some of that generation
and sounding good,
namely Ira Bernstein, the Costabella
Cloggers, and Rodney Sutton.

again, still looking

/Good collaboration has al
ways honored community and moved
tradition forward by inviting new gener
The Leahy

ations

participate. The cast of perform
of these youngsters
all grown up (Ben Cooper, Nic Gareiss,

ers

to

includes some

Abby Ladin, and Emma Young) and also
some budding talents, integral parts of
the

whole ensemble.

Everyone is on stage for the last num
ber, dancing and playing to "Struck by
Lightning," which is, and always was,
the best finale! And there is more. There
are extras: a YouTube teaser and a dance

competition, and the Friday night BuckOff, where everyone wins, audience and
performers alike.
"Carry

it

On

.Live" is perfect for those of

whose lives were changed by the Green
Grass Cloggers in the 1970s, for those who
loved Rhythm in Shoes, and for those who
are looking for entertaining theater.
us

NIKKI LEE
To order:

wheatlandmusic.org/

store

�Attic

"ARKANSAS TRAVELER"
By Paul

F.Wells

knows "Arkansas Traveler," right? At least everyone
OTH surely does. After all, it's arguably the most widely
known American fiddle tune, perhaps rivaled only by "Turkey in the
Straw." It's a fiddle tune that even people who know nothing about
fiddle tunes are likely to be familiar with, even if they can't put a title
to it. Sure, it's become so hackneyed through extensive use and abuse
by producers and arrangers in various media that the adage about fa
miliarity breeding contempt often comes to mind in connection with
it, but it's still a good tune, one that's always fun to romp through in a
jam session or to lay down for a flatfoot buckdancer to step to.

Everyone
reading

Historically, the tune has long been
connected to a comic sketch featuring
verbal jousting between a traveler who
has lost his

way and a wise-cracking
fellow fiddling on the front steps of a
cabin in the backwoods of Arkansas,

who gives singularly unhelpful replies
to the traveler's requests for directions.
It's only when the traveler shows the
settler that he knows the portion of the
tune that the settler does not that they

achieve any sort of rapprochement.
Performances of tune and sketch were
a
staple of American stage entertainment
throughout the second half

of the

19th

century and on into the 20th. Numerous
recordings of it were made prior to the

advent of the hillbilly recording era of the
1920s, by comics Len Spencer and Steve
Porter (usually with a violinist such as
Charles D'Almaine or George Schweinfest

providing the music). And, of course,
one of the very first recordings of "au

thentic" American fiddling was the duet
rendering of "Arkansas Travler" by Eck

Robertson and Henry Gilliland for Vic

tor in June of 1922. Their fine rendition is
clear evidence that, in addition to its life

Joseph re-joined his parents, who were
then living in Richmond, Virginia. Af
ter his mother died and his father took
a second
wife, the re-configured family

moved

westward,

eventually

working

their way to the Ohio River Valley. Jo

torical

the Queen City. He led the orchestra in the
theater, played the organ and directed the

Sketch and tune first appear in the his
record in the mid-1840s. Because
"Arkansas Traveler" has been an artifact of
American culture for more than a century
and a half, it has attracted considerable at
tention from historians, folklorists, and jour
nalists who have tried to divine its origins.
In spite of their best efforts, no clear-cut an
swers have emerged; there are at least four
competing claims of authorship: Edward
P.
Washbourne and Colonel San(d)ford
Faulkner, both of Arkansas, Mose Case of
Buffalo, and Joseph Tosso of Cincinnati.
At this point it does not much matter

which,

if any,

of

these claims of author
I will
make no at

ship are valid, and

prove or disprove any of them.
offer here a couple of pieces of
ephemera that relate to the last of these
to

tempt

Rather,

I

putative creators, violinist Joseph (chris

either Jeremiah Clarke (c. 1674-1707) or Henry Purcell

(1659-1695)

Hen's March
New Preceptor for the German Flute, Albany, 1834

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

get him a good musical education, and
the boy was admitted to the famed Paris
Conservatory at the age of eight. In 1817,

seph taught music in Louisville, Ken
tucky, for a few years, got married there,
and in 1827 went back upriver to Cincin
nati, where he settled permanently.
He was very active in the cultural life of

Trumpet Tune.

A

his father took him to Paris in order to

hands of stage professionals, the
"Arkansas Traveler" tune had become
well ensconced in Southern fiddling tra
dition by the early 20th century.
in the

Arkansas Traveler

from

tened Jose) Tosso (1802-1887).
Tosso was born in Mexico City, August
3, 1802, to Italian parents. His father is
said to have been both a jewelry dealer
and violinist, and to have played in the
theater in Mexico City. Young Joseph
displayed an interest in music at a very
young age. When he was six years old

choir in the St. Xavier church, taught mu
sic at Dr. Locke's Female Seminary, was
a
partner in running a music store, oper
ated

a
dancing academy, and gave many
concerts. Although he was a classically
trained violinist— and, by all accounts,
a very good one— Tosso was
pragmatic
enough to cater to the tastes of his com
munity. He often played music that had
value more as entertainment than as fine

art. He

provided music for dancing

at

co

tillion parties and performed in popular
variety theater productions.
He is said to have begun performing
"Arkansas Traveler" around 1841 or 1842,
claiming both skit and tune as his own

creations. Regardless

of

the

veracity of

this claim, he did so much to popularize

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Arkansas Traveler" that it became inex
tricably linked with him; a writer in the
Cincinnati Gazette in 1851 termed it Tosso's "celebrated and unrivalled piece."
The concert program reproduced in this
installment of "The Attic" shows that he
continued to feature it on his programs un
til late in his performing career. Tosso was
in his 73rd year at the time of this concert
in February of 1873. The fact that "Prof.

Tosso's adventures in Texas, or 'The Ar
kansas Traveler'" was the closing number
on the program suggests that this was his
big show-stopper, the signature piece to
be brought out for the grand finale. An ac
count of a concert five years later in which

"Arkansas Traveler" was again the closing
number gives weight to this notion.
The meaning of the description of the
event as a "Complimentary Concert to
Prof. Tosso" is unclear.

The

designation

was something done in his
suggests
or
honor,
perhaps a benefit. The fact that
he performed in roughly half of the num
bers on the program does not negate this
assumption, as it was customary at the
time for honorees to perform in their own
benefit concerts. Loveland, where the con
cert took place, is a suburb of Cincinnati.
The admission ticket to the concert
that is also reproduced here is a much
fancier and more durable bit of ephem
era than the program. Whereas the pro
gram was printed on thin paper with
high pulp content, the ticket is on heavy
that

it

card stock, and, though it's difficult to
tell from the reproduction, is nicely em
bossed. (The elements that appear in
the scan to be

are

depressions

actually

raised above the surface of the paper.
This is an optical illusion that's a visual
artifact of the scanning process.)
Tosso continued to make limited con
cert

appearances

into

the

1880s.

He

1887.

passed away on January 6,
What of his claim to have written "Ar
have
Researchers
Traveler?"
kansas
traced some of the jokes in the comic

16th-century Germany and
18th-century England. These discoveries
show that although Tosso may have had
a hand in giving the sketch its familiar
shape, he did not create it out of whole
cloth
nor did any of the others whose
names are associated with its origin.
And the tune? While I'm unaware of
any evidence that the tune as a whole ex
dialogue

to

isted prior to the mid-1840s, the principal
musical motif of the high part the part
that the traveler in the story knows but
does
the resident of the cabin does not
turn up earlier. A short piece for trumpet

�organ from 17th-century England,
titled simply "Trumpet Tune in D" and

and

ascribed variously to composers Henry
Purcell (1659-1695) and Jeremiah Clarke
(c.
1674-1707), includes the descend

and since Tosso

Cincinnati
of
it.

worked

it is at

as an

organist in

least within the realm

possibility that he was familiar with
might well have had occasion

Or, he

to hear "The Hen's March" played by a
fife and drum corps on some ceremonial
occasion. Then again, his claim to have

composed "Arkansas Traveler" might be
legitimate. The sort of melodic pattern
that the tunes share is

and has

something

a

of the

bit "violinny,"
character of a

fingering exercise. It could easily have
been something that Tosso worked up
into

a

The
For

biographical information on Joseph
am heavily indebted to Ophia
Smith's article, "Joseph Tosso, the Ar

Tosso
D.

free-standing tune.
mysteries and questions never stop!

I

kansaw Traveler," that appeared

in the

Historical
Archaeological
vol.
56, June 1947, pp. 16-45.
Quarterly,
This article is now available online at:
Ohio

State

and

Norm Co
publications.ohiohistory.org.
hen's excellent booklet that accompanied
Minstrels and Tunesmiths:
Commercial Roots of Early Country
Music (1981), was invaluable as a source
JEMF LP-109,
The

information about the pre-hillbilly re
cordings of "Arkansas Traveler." Cohen
also provides references to earlier studies
of Arkansas Traveler.
Thanks also to Katherine Preston for lo
cal Cincinnati information.
of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Wells

a few early
19th-century
American collections for flute or fife, and
is said to remain popular in Scotland
and in the Shetland Isles. Transcriptions
of portions of these tunes, together with
the high part of "Arkansas Traveler" are
included here; compare the music in the
final four measures of the earlier tunes
with that of "Arkansas Traveler."
Whether there is any genetic link be
tween the older British tunes and the
familiar American tune is, of course, un
known and probably unknowable. But
there are some possibilities to consider.
The
Purcell /Clarke "Trumpet
Tune"
was sometimes set as a solo organ piece,

of Paul

tune turns up in

collection

ing melodic sequence that opens the
high strain of "Arkansas Traveler." Very
closely related to this is a Scots tune titled
"The Hen's March," that may have been
composed by Edinburgh music publish
er Robert Bremner (c. 1713-1789). This

�photo: Two Rivers

photo: Erynn Marshall

Celebrating the music and musicians
of the Blue Ridge Mountains

Ridge

&gt;T

1^

"

j

J

J

JVlUlSIC

Saturday Concerts Museum
Mid-Day Mountain Music Daily

Milepost 213 on The Blue Ridge Parkway,

WWW.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Blue

ridge

music

center

org

Galax, Virginia

�Smithsonian Folkways Presents Uniquely
American Ballads of Tragedy, Murder, and Scandal

I
1^

CLASSIC AMERICAN BALLADS
from SMITHSONIAN FOLKWAYS

f

'

SpSV

m

Smithsonian Folkways

Born of the British ballad, its American offspring was the blank canvas for all type of tale,
the more calamitous or scandalous, the better. Jesse James and Billy the Kid, train wrecks
and hurricanes, the Titanic and Tom Dooley, fatal lovers' quarrels and foiling the devil, all
and more were normal fare, served up in a song. Classic American Ballads is 25 tracks of
time-worn tragedy drawn from the deep fount of the Smithsonian Folkways archives.
74 minutes, 40-page booklet with extensive notes and photos.

Enter code OTHBALLADS at

folkways.si.edu through
to

save 20%

on CDs or

12/31/2015

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings

album downloads

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

�us

Join

this

at

fall

AUGUSTA
HERITAGE CENTER
Davis$Elkins College

of

OCTOBER OLD-TIME WEEK

October 18-25
Frank Lee

COORDINATOR:

BANJO

GUITAR

Wayne Erbsen

Reeb Willms

Frank Lee

MANDOLIN

Dan Gellert

Caleb Klauder

FIDDLE

WASHTUB BASS

Michael Ismirio

Adam Smith

David Bass

BROOMSEDGE BASKETRY

Jimmy Triplett

Enrica McMillon

DULCIMER
Lois

STAFF MUSICIANS

Hornbostel

Deborah Posey

Ehukai Teves

BenTownsend

The week wraps up with the

25thAUGUSTA

OLD-TIME FIDDLERS' REUNION

(October 23-25)
featuring

a

SQUARE DANCE on

Friday evening; PERFORMANCES
by

older generation master
fiddlers and younger

accomplished fiddlers from

all

over West Virginia all day Saturday;
and

a

GOSPEL SING on Sunday morning.

For more

Randolph

WEST
VIRGINIA

COUNTY
VIRGINIA

WEST

Culture

WEST

and History

VIRGINIA COMMISSION
ON

THE ARTS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

information

or to

visit www Augusta
or call 304-637-1209
Heritage

register,
Center

Org

National
Endowment

ART

WORKS.

for the Arts

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12139">
                <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 14, Number 1 (July 2015)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12140">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 14, Number 1 (July 2015)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Folk Box: A Forgotten, Yet Unforgettable, Album from the Folk Era,” by Ted Olson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Tales from the ‘Woods, Part 12: J. P. and Roscoe,” by Walt Koken&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“A Sea of Things to Learn: An Interview with Bill Hicks,” by Sarah Bryan&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Banjo Collector’s Gathering,” by Kristina Gaddy&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Joe Wilson; Jean Ritchie; Jonathan Beckoff; and Lloyd Lalumondier&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12141">
                <text>2015</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="1632">
        <name>2010s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2762">
        <name>2015</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5495">
        <name>Banjo Collector’s Gathering</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5494">
        <name>Bill Hicks</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5497">
        <name>Highwoods String Band</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5499">
        <name>J. P. Fraley</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6462">
        <name>Jean Ritchie</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5566">
        <name>Joe Wilson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6463">
        <name>Jonathan Beckoff</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5496">
        <name>Kristina Gaddy</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6464">
        <name>Lloyd Lalumondier</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5498">
        <name>Roscoe Holcomb</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5435">
        <name>Ted Olson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5500">
        <name>The Red Clay Ramblers</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5460">
        <name>Walt Koken</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2514" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3440">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/baf2d6855ab615ac130cd71793758a64.pdf</src>
        <authentication>f6cad62eda87c84d4cb8b326b83af47c</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12144">
                    <text>THE OLD-TIME

HERALD

Volume 14, Number

2

COLUMBIA
ITALIAN

RECORDS

THERE ARE STILL A LOT OF RECORDS
YOU HAVEN'T HEARD
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

$7.00

�NOVEMBER

P

Ti

AVAILABLE

AT

6

P

1U
IH
HI I

U

OLD-TIME MOSIC

OF

""

CO-PRODUCED
BY GRAMMY

WINNER

FIFTY YEARS OF COUNTY RECORDS
A FOUR-CD COLLECTION
A deluxe box set containing one hundred

thirteen old-time performances recorded for

County Records from the 1960s

to the 1990s.

Originally issued primarily on LP, most of these
tracks have never been released on CD. Thirty of
the tracks are previously unissued and heard for

their very first time in this edition.

Collected and recorded by
Charlie Faurot, Bobby Fulcher,
Rich Nevins, Barry Poss and others,
these performances are among the
very best old-time recordings made
by "true-vine" musicians. Legendary

performers include: John Ashby, E.C. Ball,
Fred Cockerham, Kyle Creed, Tommy Jarrell,
Clark Kessinger, Steve Ledford, Hiram Stamper,

Wade Ward, Melvin Wine and many others.

This set contains

a

28-page booklet with notes

by

Kinney Rorrer, annotations by the late Charlie

Faurot and Kinney Rorrer, several unpublished photos of musicians, and essays by contributors to
this collection.

COUNTY

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ORDER VOUR BOX SET TODAV
WWW.COUNTVSALES.COM

AT

�Section with Illegible Text

New

Releases from the Field Recorders' Collective

CD

Section with Illegible Text

Dean Sturgill (FRC710)

Born

1934

in

Maggie Parker

Ashe County,

in

old-time fiddle player and poet
NC, Sturgill
who was a favorite at the fiddlers conventions and square
is

dances

in

wonderful

a

the area for many years. This

is a

Craig Johnson (FRC71

1)

Johnson was

of

sampling

his recorded work with the Grayson Highlands
some of his finest poems, read by him.
a

Band and

true master

features rare

traditional American music.
recordings of songs (a cappella or backed by banjo
or guitar) and fiddle tunes, including solo pieces plus
performances with the Double Decker String Band. There
This CD

of

songs and tunes as well as

are traditional

a

(FRC712)

Music of Alleghany County, NC
exciting anthology featuring 5 fiddlers,

Mack

Lawn Brooks,

Brooks,

Kilby

Reeves, Cleave Andrews,

and Howard Joines from musically

rich

sound.

SPECIAL LIMITED TIME OFFER:
OTHER CATALOG

Walter

Babson

RT. Bell

the

in

&amp; Nathan

FRC1

1

Abshire

John Hannah

Cornett

FRC304

Banjo
Clyde Davenport Vol.

1

Addie

FRC405

1

Dennis
1

FRC1 03

You can order via our

Uncle Charlie Higgins, Wade Ward &amp; Dale
Poe FRC501
Horse Flies FRC602

The Hurricane

Ridgerunners FRC604

Kelly

Leffew

McGee

FRC21

Ralph Whited may be best

fiddling.

Carlton Rawlings (FRC718)

Those who have heard

Rawlings home recordings put him in the
same league with the great Kentucky fiddlers Doc Roberts,
Ed Haley, and Buddy Thomas. This CD is assembled from

the Carlton

the only known recordings of a great fiddler who never
received recognition beyond his own community.

FRC503

&amp; Claude

Wolfenbarger

Belle Reed FRC203

Lee

The

Renegades FRC605

John Summers FRC310

Riddle FRC120

FRC308

Martin FRC502

2

Union Grove 1969 FRC114
Wade Ward FRC507

WV Musicians

Sexton FRC105

Jimmy Wheeler FRC401

Blackard

Manco Sneed, Byard
Kilby

Ray

1

■■Virgil Anderson

&amp;

kj
pj

U

Stamper FRC306

or credit cards. To order via US mail,

send

to the address below. $15 each CD, $20 each

Aunt Jenny Wilson

2

Mike Rogers FRC505
Snow FRC205

Corbett

of Clay &amp; Calhoun

Counties FRC202

Lonnie Seymour FRC403
Arnold Sharp FRC406
Family FRC1
Chirps Smith FRC608

FRC113

Buddy Thomas FRC303

FRC1 10

Nee Ningy Band FRC610
The Plank Road String Band FRC606
Cecil Plum FRC404
&amp; Byard Ray

Texas Fiddle Bands FRC409

1

Round Peak Vol.

Shelor

The

Dan Tate FRC506

FRC201

Ross County Farmers FRC307
Band in Transition (Round Peak) FRC102
FRC109
Round Peak Vol.
Lee

&amp; Sady Courville

Stoneking FRC708

Ola

Roan Mountain Hilltoppers
Dink Roberts FRC209

2

$5 for 1st Class Mail. Special quantity sale prices on our web site

a

FRC408

FRC1005

Clyde Davenport FRC1 004
Roan Mt Hilltoppers

FRC1002

Clyde &amp; Ralph Troxell FRC1003

check

DVD

too!

Field Recorders' Collective, 6206 Washington Street, Ravenna, OH 44266

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

80s, Darley's deep

spotlights his driving, blues-inflected, breakdown-style

Sidna &amp; Fulton Meyers FRC504
Howard Miller FRC706

Obray Ramsey

website and pay using PayPal

made payable to the Field Recorders' Collective
PLUS

Marcus

9

Rector Hicks FRC709

The

1

FRC509

1

Albert Hash, Volume 2 FRC707
FRC1
Harold Hausenfluck Vol
The Hellbenders FRC700

8

Cockerham FRC101
Bill

1

(FRC71 7)

in his

1

Vernon

1

Fiddling Van Kidwell FRC412
Kimble &amp; Wagoner Families FRC106

1

1

Ernie Carpenter FRC204
The Chicken Chokers FRC603
Fred

Santford

FRC309

Albert Hash FRC41
FRC1

FRC107

Tommy Jarrell Vol. 2 FRC21
Ward Jarvis FRC402

George FRC407
Jeff Goehring FRC601

Even

Kentucky.

known for his tune "Possum Up a Gum Stump," the title
track from the classic CD compilation of 9th and 20th
tunes
Century Alabama fiddlers. This well-recorded set of

generation old-time

Indian Creek Delta Boys FRC607

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

Vol. 2 FRC302

Frank

7

Carlton FRC1

Edmonds

Galax Gems

960s FRC609

1

Jont Blevins

Esker Hutchins

1

Norman

Dewey Balfa FRC207

Gaither

A 4th

5)

in

more CDs for $14 each. 10 or more for $12.50 each.

The

Dixie Hummingbirds FRC208
FRC301
Norman Edmonds Vol.

Heywood Blevins FRC508
Dock Boggs FRC305
Dock Boggs 966 FRC31 2
Balfa Brothers

or

1

FRC31 3

1

5

Clyde Davenport Vol. 2 FRC1 04
Reverend Gary Davis FRC1 6

FRC41 0

Berkeley

(FRC71

we can trace

Ralph Whited

and clear phrasing.

LISTINGS

Ray's Dream FRC1 15
Ray Alden
John Ashby &amp; the Free State Ramblers
FRC108

(1895-

Tom Fuller (FRC71 4) Though Oklahoma fiddler Tom
Fuller's name may be unfamiliar, his tunes have been
These
spread far and wide, notably by Brad Leftwich.
recordings, made near the end of Fuller's long life, still
show his distinctive arrangements, intricate bowing,

of tunes that no one else plays.

of the genre.

Fulks'

Much of Darley

(FRC716)

feeling for the music and delicately nuanced notes, as well
as his unusual sense of timing, gave his music a unique

Missouri! This new CD (from recordings made in 1991)
showcases Vesta's extensive repertoire of breakdowns,
waltzes, two-steps, and schottisches, including a number

Alleghany County,

time fiddle music covering the full spectrum

NC. It's old

Darley Fulks

member of the

musician, Vesta Johnson is the quintessential North
Missouri dance fiddler, with impeccable timing and an
uncanny feel for phrasing. No wonder she has received
so much recognition in her music-rich home state of

Old Time Fiddle
An

a

player as well, and this CD displays many of the special
features of her singing and her playing.

Vesta Johnson

originals, highlighting the immense breadth and
depth of his music.
Craig's

Parker was

3)

1990) repertoire came from fiddlers of his grandfather's
generation and represents some of the oldest fiddle music

strong rhythm,

number of

(FRC71

well known Hammons family of West Virginia. Maggie
had an enormous repertoire of traditional songs, some of
them rarely heard from other singers. She was a fine banjo

The Field

Recorders'
Collective

�THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD
A

MAGAZINE

DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME

MUSIC

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
PO Box 61679

Durham, NC 27715
Phone and fax: (919) 286-2041
E-mail: info@oldtimeherald.org

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Sarah Bryan

BUSINESS DIRECTOR
Peter Honig

SENIOR ADVISORY EDITOR
Gail Gillespie

CONTRIBUTING
Bill

EDITORS

Hicks, Phil Jamison, Bob Smakula,
Clare Milliner, Walt Koken

ART DIRECTOR
Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group

FOUNDING EDITOR
Alice Gerrard
ADVISORY BOARD
Mac Benford,

Hilary Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher,

Ramona Jones, Garrison Keillor,
Pete Kuykendall, Brad Leftwich,
Lee Smith, Pete Sutherland

OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Art Aylsworth, Sally Council,
Gail Gillespie, Jim Watson

November, 2015
No part of this magazine may be reproduced
in any form without written permission from
the publisher.

Not responsible for loss

or

non

return of unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
2015 the Old-Time Herald. The Old-Time Herald
(ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is published
quarterly by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
PO Box 61679, Durham, NC 27715. Subscrip

tion rates payable in advance. One year:
subscriptions-- Canada $35US;
overseas $39US). Periodical postage rate paid
at Durham, NC 27715 and additional mailing
$26 (foreign

offices.

Postmaster: Send change

of

address

to

the Old-Time Herald, PO Box 61679, Durham,
NC 27715. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is

a not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation under
section 501 (c) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love

old-time music. Old-time music
grassroots or
home grown music and dance
shares origins, influ
ences and musical characteristics with roots musics
throughout America. Our magazine, the Old-Time
Herald, casts a wide net, highlighting the Southeast
ern tradition while opening its pages to kindred
and comparable traditions and new directions. It
provides enlightening articles and in-depth reviews,
opportunities for musical learning and sharing, and
a forum for addressing the issues and questions that
of

bear upon the field.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here &amp; There
Events

American Banjo Fraternity spring
28,
gathering will take place May 26
2016 at the Allenberry Resort in Boiling
Springs, Pennsylvania. The meeting in
cludes a free concert at 7:30 on May 28. Vis
it banjofraternity.org for more information.
Janie's Jumpstart Old Time Music
Weekend Camp will be held April 1-3,

The

Pennsylvania. Instructors
will include Janie Rothfield, Rachel Eddy,
Gailanne Amundsen, and Shona Carr. Visit
janiesjumpstart.com or contact janerothfield@gmail.com for registration details.
Bob Bovee will be performing at the
Omaha Folk Song Society in Omaha, Ne
braska, on November 14; Lewis and Clarke
Interpretive Center in Sioux Falls, Iowa, on
2016, in Oxford,

November 15; in Sandstone, Minnesota,
on December 11; and at the Roots Cellar in
Minneapolis, Minnesota, on December 12.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Correll.

Vornbrock,

Jerry

Fiddle:

McMurray,

Eric

Bluegrass

Dewey Long,

Madalyn Jarrett. Old-Time Banjo: Ron
Mullenex, Joseph Decosimo,
Emily
Poole, David Winston, Ben Poe Bluegrass Banjo: Adrian Sheets, Steve Chris-

Scales, Ron
Duet:
Puckett.
Erynn
Banjo
Marshall and Carl Jones; David Win
ston and Mary Jane Epps; Betty Vornbrock and Hunter Walker; Ron Mullennex and Jerry Correll; Samuel Bolt
and Steve Chrislev. Guitar: Rick Hall,
ley,

Tim

Jarrett,

Stewart

Fiddle and

Don Marrs, Joshua Raines, Jared Sweet,
Stewart Scales. Mandolin: Carl Jones,
Matt Stacy, Don Marrs, Honey Brassfield, Eric McMurray. Dobro: Adrian
Sheets, George Watkins, Mike Hankins. Harmonica: Tommy Taylor, Robie
Castel, Dairel Bobbitts, Wiley Williams.
Dulcimer: Hunter Walker, Lois Hornbostel, Ehukai Teves, David Park, Ezra

Drumheller. Bass: David Chrisley, Ben
Silcox, Joe Dejarnette, Jamie Stacy. Autoharp: Pam Hunt, Tim Taylor,
thy Williams. Folk Song: Jamie
Ehukai Teves, Austin Viars, Pam
Madalyn Jarrett. Old-Time Band:
the Beetles; Reed Island

Doro

Stacy,

Hunt,
Meat

Rounders; JefLast Minuet

fersonville Skirmish Band;
Band; McLothin Brothers

Band. BlueBand:
Turkey Creek; Bad Ridge;
grass
Adam McPeak and Mountain Thunder;
Becky Webb Band; Plan B. Dance, Male:

Robert Wilcox, LeRoy
Dalton Roberts.
Teves,
Long,
Dance, Female: Rita Booth, Virginia
Green. Dance, Youth: Thomas Romeo,
Sierra Buchanan, Katherine Romeo,
Julie Haines, Annie Smith. Youth: Ma
dalyn Jarrett, Ezra Drumheller, Isaiah
Robie

Castel,
Ehukai

Hagerman, Dakota Hagerman. Best All
Around Performer: Ervnn Marshall.
The Highland County Fiddler's Con
19 in Mon
vention took place July 16
terey,

Virginia, with the following win

ners. (Hometowns are in Virginia un
less otherwise noted.) Old-Time Fiddle:

Virginia). Open: Sam Herrmann; Glenn
Craver; Patrick McCauley (Front Royal);
Hannah Johnson (Keezletown); Rebecca

Clayton (Hillsboro, West Virginia). Folk
Song: Dick Harrington (Charlottesville);
Hannah Johnson; Joe Herrmann; Julia
Merkel (Keezletown); Glenn Craver.
Old-Time
Paw,

Band:

West

Critton

Hollow (Paw
McDowell

The

Virginia);

Muttonbusters (McDowell); Jubilo (Pal
myra); The On Demand Band (Keezle
town); Misfit Toys (Charlottesville).
Adult Dance: Eugene Ratcliff (Mon
terey); Ellen Ratcliff (Monterey); Aaron

Olwell

(Roseland);

Ruth

Chappell.

Youth Fiddle: Eli Phillips (Hot Springs);

Alexis
Emma
Harmon
(Monterey);
Alexis
Dance:
Youth
Small (Monterey).
Small (Monterey).
The Gail Heil Memorial Fiddle Contest
took place on July 18 in Lanesboro, Min
nesota, with the following winners. Open
Division: Alita Weisgerber (St. Peter,
Minnesota); Timm Foss (Soldiers Grove,
Wisconsin); Tom Weisgerber (St. Peter,
Minnesota). Junior Division: Charlie Burket (Rochester, Minnesota); Holly Reyner
(Independence, Iowa); Isabelle Ekstrom
(Lanesboro, Minnesota). Senior Division:
Mary DuShane (Minneapolis, Minneso
ta); Gaye Harrison (Charleston, Illinois);

Russ Guyer (Harmony, Minnesota).
The following were winners at

this

year's Alleghany Fiddlers Convention,
held the third weekend of July in Spar
ta, North Carolina. (Hometowns are in
North Carolina unless otherwise noted.)
Old-Time Fiddle: Lucas Pasley (Sparta);
Richard Bowman (Mount Airy); Jerry
Correll (Elk Creek, Virginia); Helen
White (Mouth of Wilson, Virginia); Brett
Martin (Elk Creek, Virginia). Bluegrass
Fiddle:

Shipley (Kingsport,
Crystal
Tennessee); Kitty Amaral (Elk Creek,
Virginia); Jacob Turnbill (Shelby); Av
ery Davis (Radford, Virginia); David
Woodie

(Huntersville).

Junior

Fiddle:

Herrmann (Paw Paw, West Virginia);
Aaron Olwell (Roseland); Gerry Milnes

Ruth Shumway (West Jefferson); Marissa Colter (Clemmons); Sarah Lemonds
(Charlotte); Cooper Parsons (Crumpler);
Eliza Meyer (Raleigh). Old-Time Banjo:
Marsha Todd (Mount Airy); Trish Fore

(Elkins, West Virginia). Old-Time Banjo:
Seth Swingle (Earlysville); Victor Furta-

Fork,

Isabella Gorman (Front Royal); Lyle
Werner (New Orleans, Louisiana); Joe

do (Front Royal);

Stephen Casto (Mar-

linton, West Virginia);

James Schooling
(Leesburg); Dan Easley (Keezletown).
Old-Time Guitar: Glenn Craver (Win
ston-Salem, North Carolina); Steve Ritz
(Romney, West Virginia); Mike Harrison
Dennis McKim (Vil(Harrisonburg);
lamont); Jim Morris (Springfield, West

(Galax,

Virginia);
Virginia);

Jared

Boyd

Madison

(Laurel

Shepherd

(West Jefferson); Stanley Widner (Fancy
Gap, Virginia). Bluegrass Banjo: Andy

(Winston-Salem); Steve Chrisley (Wytheville, Virginia); Clay Russell
Lowe

(Troutdale, Virgiriia); Eric Hardin (West
Jefferson); Grayson Tuttle (Wilkesboro).
Junior Banjo: Clay Busic (Piney Creek);
Brittany Osborne (Jefferson); Caleb Os-

�Mandolin: Matt
Stacy (Grundy Virginia); Connor Lam
bert (Troutman); Austin Tate (Marion,
Virginia); Zack Arnold (West Jefferson);
Rodney Hodges (Galax, Virginia). Ju
nior Mandolin: Peyton Sexton (Sparta).

borne

Creek).

(Piney

Guitar: Pressley Barker (Traphill); Steve
Lewis (Todd); Jacob Greer (Jefferson);

Nick Weitzenfeld (Roanoke, Virginia);
Steve Kilby (Mouth of Wilson, Virginia).

Mason

29

ton, West Virginia);

(Big Sur, California); Henry Barnes (Co
lumbus, Ohio). Senior Fiddle: Rafe Ste-

fanini (Elkins Park, Pennsylvania); John
Longwell (Gandeeville, West Virginia);

Joe Herrmann

Youth

Hazel Pasley (Sparta); Mason
Wagoner (Glade Vallev). Bass: David
Chrisley (Wytheville, Virginia); Jamie
Stacy (Oakwood, Virginia); Scott Gen
try (Roaring River); Loyd Richardson
(Warrensville); Ben Marshall (Mount

Ford,

Airy). Junior Bass: Kyser George (Westfield); Katie Jones (Linwood). Autoharp:
Vickie Boyd (Laurel Fork, Virginia);
JoAnn Redd (Galax, Virginia); Bobbi
Roberts (Galax, Virginia); Mary Um-

er

Guitar:

Gwyn

Virginia);

barger (Harmony); Penny Kilby (Mouth
of Wilson, Virginia). Dulcimer: Ehukai
Teves (Bryson City); Clarence Roberts
(Galax, Virginia); David Parks (Dublin,
Virginia); Lois Hornbostel (Bryson City);
Dobro:
Alan Darveaux (Morganton).
Keith Aiken (Henderson); Jordan Roberson (Stoneville); Glenn Craver (Win
ston-Salem); John Powell (Mocksville);
Josh Hazelwood (Dobson). Harmonica:
Eddie Ogle (Wytheville, Virginia); Glen
Zuhlke (Galax, Virginia); Paul Hiatt

(High Point); Milton Scott (Thurmond);
Wayne Childress (High Point). Old-Time
Band: Slate Mountain Ramblers (Mount
Airy); Blue Ridge Mountain Ramblers
(Sparta); Correll's Bait and Tackle (Elk
Creek, Virginia); New River Renegades
(Mouth of Wilson, Virginia); Hard Cider
(Elk Creek,
Bad Ridge

Virginia).

Bluegrass

Band:

(Oakwood, Virginia); Turkey

Creek (Kingsport, Tennessee); Sons of
the South (Troutman); Claybank (West
Jefferson); Adam McPeak and Moun

Thunder (Wytheville, Virginia).
Junior Band: Shadow Grass (Troutdale,
Virginia); Jones Sisters (Linwood). Vo
cal: Eric Marshall (Mount Airy); Tommy
Nichols (Mount Airy); Donna Correll
(Elk Creek, Virginia); Tom Rosencrans
(Fries, Virginia); Dennis Joines (Sparta).
Senior Dance: Samantha Wilhelmi, Cherie Compton, JoAnn Call, Vicky Boyd,
Stacy Boyd. Junior Dance: Madison
tain

Shepherd,

Tyler

Mary Claire
Colter, Liam Purcell.

Carrico,

Hooper, Marissa
Children's Dance Participants: Cooper
Parsons, Gio Lopez.
The Appalachian String Band Festi
val, held at Clifftop, West Virginia, July
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Andrew Fitzgibbon

(Montrose, West Virginia); Erynn Mar
shall (Galax, Virginia); Grace Forrest

(Ararat,

Junior

2, had the following contest
Fiddle: Jake Krack (Marlin-

August

winners.

Fiddle:

(Paw Paw, West Virginia).

Andrew Vogts (Chadds

Pennsylvania); Grayson Wickel
(Asheville, North Carolina); Stephanie
Flowers (Montreal, Quebec). Banjo: Vic
tor Furtado (Front Royal, Virginia);

Seth

Swingle

Brad

(Earlysville,

Virginia);

Kolodner (Baltimore, Maryland); Hunt
Walker (Beckley, West Virginia); Jesse
Pearson (Huntington, West Virginia).
Senior Banjo: Marvin Gaster (Sanford,
North Carolina); Arnie Naiman (Aurora,
Ontario); Bertram Levy (Port Townsend,
Washington). Youth Banjo: Victor Furta
Trevor Hammons
Virginia); Joey Webb
do;

tucky). Traditional

(Swoope, Virginia);

(Marlinton, West

Ken
Buffalo Gap

(Frankfort,

Band:

Old

Drake

(Galax,

Virginia); Donkey Nation (Columbus,
Ohio); Uncle Henry's Favorites (Crozet,
Virginia); Bill Kimmons (St. Albans,

West Virginia). Youth Traditional Band:
The Onlies (Seattle, Washington). NeoTraditional Band: Roochie Toochie and
the Ragtime Shepherd Kings (Nash
ville, Tennessee); The Rigs (Brooklyn,

New York); Himalayan Memo (Cincin
nati, Ohio); Cameron DeWhitt and the
Confirmation (Philadelphia, Pennsylva
nia); Root 2 Music (Montvale, Virginia).
Youth Neo-Traditional Band: The Psycho
Exploding Orangutans (Chadds Ford,
Pennsylvania). Old-Time Flatfoot Dance,
age 15 and under: Victor Furtado; Luke
Snuffer (Beckley, West Virginia). OldTime Flatfoot Dance, ages 16 through
40: Gvasi Heus (Hinton, West Virginia);

Kathryn Cohen (Brooklyn, New York);
Gooch
Pennsylva
Jenn
(Pittsburgh,
Flatfoot Dance, ages 41
Old-Time
nia).
through 59: Suzanne Ambrose (Kendal,
Cumbria, UK); Thomas H. Reedy (Parkton, Maryland); Gene Worlledge (Mt.
Lookout, West Virginia). Old-Time Flatfoot Dance, age 60 and older: Rosie Da
vis (Palmerstown, Dublin, Ireland); Wil

liam McGuigan (Hellam, Pennsylvania);

Jane Henderson (Bloomington, Indiana).
Grand
Champion Old-Time Flatfoot
Dance: Suzanne Ambrose.
At the 80lh Annual Old Fiddlers' Con

vention
gust

in

3-8,

Virginia, held Au
following were contest

Galax,
the

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(Hometowns in Virginia un
less otherwise noted.) Old-Time Fiddle:

winners.

Jake Krack (Marlinton, West Virginia);
Jacob Bowen (State Road, North Caro

Richard Bowman (Mount Airy,
Carolina); Billy Hurt (Boones
Mill); Henry Barnes (Columbus, Ohio);
lina);

North

Phillips (Chapmansboro, Tennes
Rex McGee (King, North Caro
lina); Betty Vornbrock (Hillsville); Ivy
Sheppard (Mount Airy, North Carolina);
Ivy

see);

Barbara Kuhns (Medway, Ohio). Youth
Old-Time Fiddle: Annabelle Watts (Philpot, Kentucky); Andrew Vogts (Chadds
Ford, Pennsylvania); Liam Purcell (Deep

Gap, North Carolina); Isabella Gorman
(Charlottesville); Bryan Lakey (Thom-

asville, North Carolina). Bluegrass Fid
dle: Glen Alexander (Charlotte, North
Carolina); Corinna Logston (Nashville,

Daniel Greeson (James
Tennessee);
town, North Carolina); John Hoffman
(Thomasville, North Carolina); Danny
Knicely (Lovettsville); Kitty Amaral
(Elk Creek); Crystal Shipley (Kingsport,
Tennessee); Casey Driscoll (Mount Airy,
North Carolina); Carson Peters (Piney
Flats,
Tennessee);
Fraleigh
Stephen
(Raleigh, North Carolina). Youth Bluegrass Fiddle: Ivy Phillips; Kitty Amaral;
Samuel Hill (Sanford, North Carolina);

Lemonds (West Jefferson, North
Bethany Kelley (Appling,
Georgia). Clawhammer Banjo: Victor
Furtado (Front Royal); Madison Shep
Sarah

Carolina);

(West Jefferson, North Carolina);
(Fries); Marsha Todd (Mount
Airy, North Carolina); Brandon Nester
(Fancy Gap); Trish Fore (Galax); Kelley
herd

Eric Hill

Breiding (Mount Airy, North Carolina);
Jim Lloyd (Rural Retreat); Marianne Kovatch (Fries); Nancy Sluys (Westfield,
North Carolina). Youth Clawhammer
Banjo: Victor Furtado; Madison Shep
herd; Uma Peters (Nashville, Tennessee);
Brittany Osborne (West Jefferson, North

Carolina); J. C. Keyser (Catlettsburg,
Kentucky). Bluegrass Banjo: Jeremy Ste
phens (White Creek, Tennessee); Andy
Lowe (Winston-Salem, North Carolina);
Brandy Miller (Fleetwood, North Caro
lina); Steve Lewis (Todd, North Caro
lina); David Carroll (Bedford); Lee Dun

Timothy Mills (Riner);
Brennen Ernst (Mount Airy, North Caro

bar (Eagle Rock);

lina); Jimmy Paschal (Yadkinville, North

Carolina); Steve Chrisley (Wytheville).
Youth Bluegrass Banjo: Clay Russell
(Troutdale); Trevor Holder (Ringgold,
Georgia); Adam Bishop (Riner); Travis
Watts (Mount Airy, North Carolina);
Clay Busic (Piney Creek, North Caro
lina). Mandolin: Ryan Blevins (Marion);
Kevin McKinnon (Mocksville, North
(WalkerCarolina); Rodney Hodges
town, North Carolina); Vince Bullins
(Lawsonville, North Carolina); Ralph
McGee (King, North Carolina); Arnie
Soloman (Greensboro, North Carolina);
Mark Jones (Kernersville, North Caro
lina); Eli Wildman (Floyd); Ricky Ellis
(Bedford); Giri Peters (Nashville, Ten
nessee). Youth Mandolin: Eli Wildman;

Addison Levy (Radford); Jack Ingraham

(Woodlawn);
North
(Durham,

Fernandez

Olivia

Carolina);

Kelley (Appling, Georgia).

Victoria

Guitar: Pre

sley Barker (Trap Hill, North Carolina);

Wayne Henderson (Mouth of Wilson);
Eric Hardin (West Jefferson, North Car
olina); Rick Hall (Princeton, West Vir
ginia); Nick Weitzenfeld (Floyd); Jack

Hinshelwood

(Abingdon);

Spencer

Greg Wilson
(Fries); Zack Arnold (West Jefferson,
North Carolina); Matt Osborne (Bristol).
Youth Guitar: John Hill (Sanford); Nick
Weitzenfeld (Roanoke); Pressley Barker
(Traphill, North Carolina); Carson Peters

Strickland

(Lambsburg);

(Piney Flats, Tennessee); Jeremiah Jobe
(Reidsville, North Carolina). Dobro: Tony
Joines (Millers Creek, North Carolina);
Eddie Marrs (Princeton, West Virginia);

�Doug Smith (Medway, Ohio); Jordon
Roberson (Stoneville, North Carolina);
Alex Donahue (Roanoke); Jake Joines
(Millers Creek, North Carolina); Mag
gie Anderson (Woodlawn); John Powell

(Mocksville, North Carolina); Quentin
(Dapto, Australia); Greg Worth
(Mouth of Wilson). Dulcimer: Hunter
Walker (Beckley, West Virginia); Sharon
Boyd (Colonial Heights); Dot ChrisFraser

tenson

(Lexington,

Kentucky);

Jimmy

Watts (Virgilina); Clarence Roberts (Ga
lax); Kendra Ward (Bidwell, Ohio); Don
Neuhauser (Charlestown, Indiana); Tim
Thorton (Shawsville); Lois Hornbostel

(Bryson City, North Carolina); David
(Dublin). Autoharp: Eddie Bond
(Fries); Ronnie Burroughs (Keysville);
Penny Kilby (Mouth of Wilson); An
thony Ramsey (Page, West Virginia);
Judy Pagter (Stanardsville); JoAnn Redd
(Galax); Libby Kahn (Independence);
Forest Hollingsworth (Christiansburg);
Frederick Douglas (Pickens, South Car
olina); Gerald Anderson (Trout dale).
Parks

Folk Song: Leslie Dunbar (Eagle Rock);
Jina Rosencrans (Fries); Amy Ellis (Bed
ford); Megan White (Greensboro, North
Carolina); Lindsey Nale (Galax); Bonnie
Bond (Fries); Tyler Williams (Johnson

Beverly Horton (Kingsport, Tennessee); Allan Brown (Parkdale, Ohio); Tommy Nichols (Mount
City, Tennessee);

Airy,

Carolina). Dance: Mark
(Eunice, North Carolina); Del-

North

Handy
bert Dunford (Wytheville); Julia Pow
ell (Swannanoa, North Carolina); Glen
Wimmer (Rocky Mount); Mitchell Rob
inson (Galax); Kathy Delp (Galax); Brian
Ferguson (Rocky Mount); Angela Hale
(Elk Creek); Justin Jackson (Austinville);

Susan Blankenship (Stuart). Old-Time
Bands: New Ballards Branch Bogtrotters (Galax); Whoopin' Hollar String
Band (Marlinton, West Virginia); Slate

Mountain Ramblers (Mount Airy, North
Carolina); Crooked Road Ramblers
(Columbus, Ohio);
Galax); Donkey Nation
Five Mile Mountain Road (Boones Mill);
New River Bound (Christiansburg);
Tune Town (Marion); Dry Hill Draggers
(Ferrum); Four State Ramblers (Asheville, North Carolina); Zephyr Lightning
Bolts (State Road, North Carolina); Texas
Pete and the Smokey Beats (Lexington,
Kentucky); South Carolina Broadcast
ers (Mount Airy, North Carolina); Pilot
Mountain Bobcats (Westfield, North
(Fries).
Carolina); Virginia Creepers
the
South
Sons
of
Bands:
Bluegrass
(Statesville, North Carolina); Mash (Sa
lem); The Coyote Ugly Band (Kingsport,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Tennessee); High Voltage (Pfafftown,
North Carolina); The Del-Tones (Kernersville, North Carolina); Fort Thumpter
(Winston-Salem, North Carolina); The
Country Boys (Mount Airy, North Caro
lina); The Loose Strings Band (Galax);
The G. J. Project (Mount Airy, North
(Timberlake,
Carolina);
Bridgetown
North Carolina); Cox and Company
(Pulaski); Clay Bank (Jefferson, North
Carolina); Second Wind (Fries); Cool
Breeze Bluegrass (Johnson City, Tennes
see); Peaks Mountain Bluegrass (Ga
lax). Youth Bands: Iron

Mountain Band

This year's Hoppin' John Oldtime and
Fiddlers' Convention was

Bluegrass

held September 17 - 19, at Silk Hope,
North Carolina, with the following win
ners. Old-Time Fiddle: Joseph Decosi
mo, Richard Bowman, Erynn Marshall.
Bluegrass Fiddle: Gil Benson, Clay She-

Campbell. Youth Fiddle: Olivia
Fernandez, Ben Bullard, Sophia Fernan
lor, Bob

dez. Old-Time Banjo: Jim Collier, Joseph

Decosimo, Alan Julich. Bluegrass Banjo:
Brandon Henson, David Thronbury,

Moore. Youth Banjo: Cage Bul
lard. Mandolin: Zeb Gambill, Spencer
Hugh

Zach Mondry. Guitar: Hiro
Arakawa, Zeb Gambill, Cary Moskovitz. Bass: Keith Sikes, Jason Kind, John
Gaster. Youth Other Instrument: Ben

Tennessee); Shadowgrass
(Galax); Gravel Road (Radford); Glitz
and Grass (Philpot, Kentucky); Psycho
Exploding Orangutans (Chadds Ford,
Pennsylvania). Best All- Around Per
former: Jake Krack.
The following contestants were winners
at this year's Old Time Fiddlers Con

Mobley,

Kruger, Kilby Spencer, Adrian Shep
herd-Powell. Twin Fiddle: Cecil Gurganus and Willow Dillon; Kilby Spencer
and Jacob Bowen; Kathleen and Anissa

Folk Song: Kenny Jackson, Ed Norman,
Lightnin' Wells. Adult Dance: Joan Lev

Burnett; Adrian Shepherd-Powell and
Todd Meade; Elizabeth Sauls and Faith
Dominy. Banjo: Jared Boyd, Kelly Breiding, Matthew Bright, Willow Dillon,
Joseph Decosimo. Guitar: Wayne Dye,
Tim Yates, Pam Engelbert, Gene Ander
son, Blaise Shulten. Mandolin: Caleb

ard,

Flats,

(Piney

in Laurel Bloomery, Tennes
see, held August 21 and 22, 2015. Fiddle:
Jacob Bowen, Richard Bowman, Steve

vention

Coatney, Wayne Dye, Rodney Hodges.
Bass

Fiddle:

Barbara

Bowman,

Stacy

Butch Barker, Daniel Teague,
Donna Correll. Dulcimer: Dick Lamb,
Clarence Roberts. Autoharp: Stephanie
Jeter, Richard Bowman, Bobbi Rob
Boyd,

erts, Art Lang,

Penny Kilby. Vocal Duet:

Molly and Sadie Yates; Kristal Harman and Stephanie Jeter; Ian and Kelly
Snider; Kathleen and Anissa Burnett;
Aaron Ratcliffe and Nora Weatherby.
Folk Song: Doug Sharkey,

Jared Boyd,
Alan Teichman, Shooter Brown, Rich
Kirby. Harmonica: Art Lang, Paul Hiatt,
Billy Davies. Band: The Slate Mountain
Ramblers;
Straight Outta Whitetop;

Strictly Strings; Tommy and the Ivan
Hoe Downers; The A to Z is Still Open
Tomorrow. Adult Dance: John Turner,
Brett
Phoebe
Martin,
Douthwaite,

Shawn Terrell, Julie Shepherd-Powell.
Youth Dance: Sadie Yates, Liam Purcell,
Molly Yates, Hawk, Nora ShepherdPowell. Youth Performance: Liam Pur
cell, Anissa Burnett, Fiddle and Frets,
Asa Nelson, Molly Yates.

Bullard,

kovitz.

Django

Burgess,

Old-Time

Milo

Mos-

Band:

Appalachian
Thunder; Haywood Billygoats; John
Hardy Party. Bluegrass Band: Bluegrass
Bungaloids; Treeline Grass. Non-Tradi
tional Band: Stray Local; New Harmonic
Convergence; The Fernandez Sisters.

itt,

Phoebe

Youth Dance:

Douthwaite, Julie Chiles.
Cage

Bullard,

Ben

Bull

Silven Vincent, Faris and Nightin
gale Pergoletti (tie). The Cook-Off: John
Hoppers Team; Motown Mushrooms;
Hoppin' Gabriel.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

If

it

sounds too good

be true,

it

could be

to
a

Modern Mountain
Dulcimer

�Hick Edmonds and his wife Sue. Bill also

of

became close friends with the family of
famed Giles County fiddler Henry Reed.
Over the years, Bill got involved with
the Hoorah Cloggers and the budding
Blacksburg Square Dance. For decades

Bill

was instrumental in instigating and

he

perpetuating various public old-time
jams in Blacksburg. When the jam would
lose its home at one bar, it was always
Bill who would court another, bring
ing with him a ragtag bunch of fiddlers

and banjo players. It was important to
him that the jam exist in a public space

where
and

Virginia

Tech

students

college

other young musicians could hap

pen upon the music by accident, as Bill

himself had happened upon

it.

While

it

was important to Bill that the music stay
rooted in the past, he was no preserva
tionist. He wanted it to be a little bit wild,
a little bit dangerous, a little bit shocking
if

If

possible.

he

could push things just

brink of being out of control and
hold them there, it was a job well done.
He had a gift for knowing when and how
to lure young people into the music, and
when to get out of the way and let them
to the

own it. It was commonplace for Bill to
send some promising college kid home
with a banjo, and commonplace for that
college kid to come back and become a
regular part of the jam. He cared more
for energy than for training. My own
first old-time gig was playing mandolin
with Bill Richardson and the Jugbusters
at the Floyd Country Store. I didn't even
own a mandolin. Bill borrowed one for
the night,
got three chords down, and
I

he put me on stage.

He had heard

me

could keep time
play guitar and knew
and stay in front of the beat, and that was
enough for the dancers.
I

While he played in various other oldtime and country bands over the years,
Bill is probably best remembered as the
driving force behind the Jugbusters, the

main outlet for his fiddling, songwriting, and rabble-rousing. What started
as a fairly standard four-piece old time

string band evolved over time into a mo
bile six- or seven-piece dance party, often
with drums and electric guitars. Bill was
a paradox of purism: on the one hand, he
had an almost fanatical devotion to what
as the old way of doing
and
an
open and vocal disdain
things,

he

perceived

what he saw as the watering-down of
traditional music. He didn't want to hear
old-time festival jam bands that only
played breakdowns. If a band couldn't
play a proper country dance with a mix
for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

breakdowns and country two-steps,
wasn't interested. On the other hand,

he was

perfectly happy to bring "Sally
Ann" with drums and electric guitar to a
honky-tonk if that was what it took to get
the party started. He was astonishingly
skilled

writing original music, as long
to him like old music. And
he wasn't bothered by what others saw
as it
as

at

sounded

the

contradiction. Either you played

the music right, understood and respect
ed the spirit of the thing, or you didn't.

if you didn't, he didn't mind telling
about
it. Bill ruffled a lot of feathers
you
in his lifetime, and he liked it that way.
Deflating pretense was a favorite hobby.
Bill's vision for the Jugbusters was to

And

nothing less than the best party band
working in the New River Valley. In my
years playing with the band, I'd have to
say that he succeeded. The Jugbusters
were equally at home playing for octo
genarians at traditional dance venues
like the Ruritan Club in Beulah, North
Carolina, and Clark's Sawmill in Raphine, Virginia, playing for tourists and lo
cal dancers at the Floyd Country Store in
be

Floyd, Virginia, and playing weekly latenight bar gigs for inebriated college kids
at the Cellar in Blacksburg. No matter
the crowd, the goal was always the same

to Bill: to get people to loosen up, to get
them to dance. And while he had a broad

repertoire of the breakdowns favored by
modern festival bands, Bill's ace-in-thehole was always the country two-step. It
was his mantra to the audience at every
show: "There's no easier way to make a
lady happy than to ask her to dance the
two-step!" (This inspired the title of the
third Jugbusters album, No Easier Way.)
His long-time girlfriend and the unoffi
cial band photographer Cynthia Connolly
gifted Bill with a neon "TWO-STEP" sign
that came with us to every gig and illumi
nated that easy way to happiness. It was
as much a part of the show as Bill's Stet
son hats, tailored sfiirts, and skinny ties. In
addition to the hundreds of gigs played,
the

Jugbusters

produced

four

albums:

Radio Show: Live From the Rex (2004), Keep
the Crows Out: Live From the Floyd Coun

(2005), No Easier Way (2008), and
HonkyTonk Hymnal (2013). The latter two
featured a number of Bill's original songs,
as well as those of other band members.
It's a cliche to say that someone died
too young, but Bill Richardson died too
young. When cancer took him last Sep
try Store

age 60, he was at the height of
powers. He had developed a truly

tember
his

distinct

at

fiddle

style

that stayed

firmly

rooted

in

traditional

old-time

music,

but had evolved through his time play

honky-tonk bands. He was an
opinionated clawhammer banjo player,
and an evangelist for the Galax style. He
was one of the finest old-time guitarists
ing

in

have ever played with, and one of the
most clever and prolific songwriters. In
the last week of his life, his hospital room
was a "who's who" of old-time musi
cians and dancers in the New River Val
ley, with music emanating from its door
from morning until well after official vis
iting hours had ended. He died the way
he had lived
throwing a big, fat party.
on an obscure hill
he
lies
buried
Today,
side in the Rich Valley of Virginia, at the
feet of his friend and musical mentor,
I

Hick Edmonds. The "TWO-STEP"

sign
comes with me to gigs. Because if
you're going to leave a light on for Bill
Richardson, it had better be neon, and it
had better make people dance.
still

Liam Kelly

old-time, Cajun, and Scan
traditional music communities

The Midwest

dinavian

mourn the passing of Minneapolis harmon
ica and guitar player Myron Price, who suc
cumbed to cancer in May. He was 66.
Many old-time musicians will recall
Myron from visits to Swannanoa, North
Carolina; the Fiddle Tunes festival in Port

Townsend, Washington; and his long atten
dance at Minnesota's Bluff Country Gather
ing. Although he studied Eastern European
history and languages in Chicago colleges
when he was younger, his first love was
"the music." Never much of a camper, he
would take a room near a festival, spending
time jamming and celebrating the music.

Myron was known for his encyclopedic
memory of old-time tunes and songs, hav
ing learned them as a part of his folk mu

performing in Chicago and Madi
son, Wisconsin, coffeehouses in the 1970s.
Fred Campeau remembers listening to
LPs of country blues, Cajun, and old-time
masters with Myron during those forma
That old-time and folk com
tive years.
bination was the wellspring for the 1981
children's LP In Came That Rooster (Travel
ers Records) he and eight other Midwest
After moving to
musicians released.
Minneapolis with his partner, Sarah, he
played in Cajun and Scandinavian bands
and did a stint in the house band for the
Wild Goose Chase Cloggers. He settled
into playing guitar and harmonica for the
Gritpickers, with whom he recorded his
second album, Harmony Grits.
sic days

�After leaving Target's employment, he
spent his time seeing movies, finishing
the requirements for his degree, reading
books, playing music and enjoying his
friends. Told of his cancer, he spent his
remaining months celebrating life with
friends, playing his harmonica and jam
ming in hospital rooms and hospices. It
was not unusual for visiting musicians to

tune in his hospice room to the ap
plause of staff and other patients.

end
A

a

celebration of Myron's life is planned
spring in the Twin Cities.

for the

Rob Daves

As some of you may know by now, British

old-time musician Keith Johnson passed
away at his home in Gainsborough, Eng

land, on May 2nd, after a long, brave fight
with cancer. What many American readers
of the Herald may not know is that Keith
was largely responsible for the very exis
tence of the British organization FOAOTM AD (Friends Of

American Old Time Mu

sic And Dance) and for the creation and
growth of the Gainsborough Old Time Fes

tival. He made

a

great contribution to the

old-time music in
growing popularity
the UK, and for British people who play or
listen to much old-time music, the chances
of

are that their reasons for

doing

so were

in

penetrated his soul,

so he

bought

banjo
and started
from one festival he told Brenda that their
next holiday would be in the USA, and
to

learn.

a

When he got home

they flew to Charlotte, North Carolina,

with the intention of going to Clifftop.
They didn't make it past Fancy Gap, Vir
ginia, in the Blue Ridge near Mount Airy,
North Carolina. Responding to an ad in
a local free paper they visited a large af
ternoon backyard session in Mount Airy
at the house of Jack and Hazel Fallis. Jack
was a program presenter on WPAQ, the
Mount Airy radio station famous for its
coverage of old-time music in the Round
Peak area, and he knew many of the local
musicians. The house was also a bed and
breakfast accommodation and Keith and
Brenda stayed there for the Old Fiddlers
Convention at Galax, where he taped a
session with Benton Flippen, Carlie Mar
ion, and Alice Gerrard at the Old-Time
Herald stand. They spent a lot of holiday
time with Jack and Hazel over the next
few years, getting to know the area and
the people, especially the musicians.
Keith had bought a banjo and
banjo workshop in Ripponden,

In the UK,

went

to

a

Yorkshire, in November 1993, where to his
astonishment he met two people who were
neighbors of each other, neither of whom
knew the other played the banjo! The idea

forming Foaotmad emerged from that
workshop. Keith set about organizing a
festival in Gainsborough in 1994, featuring
Tom and Ben Paley with Sara Grey. During
that weekend, Foaotmad was formed and
set up under the chairman
a committee

some way by Keith.
Born during the Second World War and
growing up in the '40s and '50s, he built his
community spirit in the shared hardships

of

they were married four years later.
They had three sons, Andrew, Paul, and
Robert, who now have their own families
but always remained close to Keith and

ship of Guy Tucker with Keith as Secretary
and Tom Paley as President. Advice and
the Foaotmad logo came from John Les,

fluenced

in

and difficulties of post-War rationing and
shortages. He met his wife Brenda in 1959
and

Brenda. Keith made his living as an electri

business installing
electrical
security systems.
professional
Keith was a doer and an achiever. If he
decided to do something, then it was go
and not by accident. He
ing to happen
was always very keen on his community
and he was very good at inspiring others
to share his interests, which have been
cal engineer,

and ran

a

many over the years. He had member
ships of several sporting organizations
like the Aegir cycling club and the Gains

borough Wildfowlers Club. His big pas
sion before old-time music was sailing.
As a young father he served as the skip
per of the 6th Gainsborough Sea Scouts

for 15 years, and his sons called him Skip.
His life changed in the early '90s when
he visited some of the few British blue-

grass festivals and the sound

of

banjos

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

who ran the successful Conwy Bluegrass

Festival in North Wales. Keith left the com
mittee in 2002 but continued to run the fes
tival until 2011, when he and Brenda were

awarded honorary life memberships of
Foaotmad, a very popular decision.
Keith booked many of the American
guests and put them up during their
visits. He treated them as if they were
family members and his kindness and
consideration were much appreciated.
Thanks to Keith, many great artists came

Gainsborough to perform and present
workshops over the years, and formed
friendships with and provided inspira
to

tion to many of our members. Keith built
small Appalachian cabin (complete
a
with porch) on his back lawn to provide
extra accommodation

and picking space
guests, and many great old-time sig
natures can be found on the inside walls.
for

Keith also organized annual weekend
and banjo workshops, mainly
involving the great West Virginia musi
cians Dwight Diller and Dave Bing, who

fiddle

taught us many tunes by ear at various
locations around Gainsborough includ
ing the legendary East Stockwith vil
lage hall. These workshops, in my opin
ion, raised the general standard of play
through the country. People left those
workshops with a much clearer idea of
how old-time music should sound and
feel, and with lots of first-hand inspira
tional stories about the great old musi
cians that were the sources for the tunes.
Really good banjos were not easy to
find in this country and, as a service to
members, Keith selected and sold Cedar
Mountain banjos handmade by his friend
Lo Gordon of Brevard, North Carolina.
He also bought and loved to play an
early Dave Bing fiddle and a Dave Stacey banjo. For many years Keith would
attend our summer camp at Sacrewell
farm near Peterborough, an informal fun

week of tunes around the campfire. He
once brought Dwight Diller with him, to
everyone's delight.
Around 2005 Keith and Brenda made a
second home in the Appalachians, buy
ing and beautifully modifying a cabin in
the woods near Cana, Virginia, under the
Blue Ridge. They spent much time there

making many friends and strengthening
the musical ties between Foaotmad and
the local musicians, Keith getting around
on his Harley Davidson. Foaotmad mem
bers visiting the States were always wel
come to use the cabin as a base, and the
Johnsons were terrific hosts, installing
won
I have
a caravan for extra guests.
derful memories of playing tunes with
friends on the cabin porch on warm eve
nings, drinking cold beer and listening to
the katydids while watching the fireflies
and hummingbirds as dusk settled on
the Blue Ridge.

Keith spent time in his final few years

constructing and flying radio-controlled

model aircraft from the garage at his
home (known to the family as Hangar
No 9!). He always had a very positive at
titude that never failed him, and still had
a twinkle in his eye at his last Gainsbor
ough Festival this year.
Keith's funeral at St Paul's Church,
Gainsborough, was very well attended,
and tunes were played during and after
the service by Foaotmad members, for
which Brenda and the family expressed
their appreciation and thanks.
Ray Banks

�BIRTHPLACE OF COUNTRY MUSIC MUSEUM
By Roy Andrade

Malcolm Wilson

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Virginia,

of-the-art,

Bristol,

now has

a

state-

Smithsonian-affiliated

museum to celebrate its role in the
country music recording industry. The
facility was built by the Birthplace of
Country Music (BCM), a group that pro
motes regional music through its many
endeavors. Of course, country music
was not born in Bristol. Nor was Bristol

the first place where country musicians
recorded. The Bristol Sessions may not

have even captured the broadest or best
sampling of country music at the time.
But what the Bristol Sessions, recorded
in 1927 and 1928, did do was to create the
country music recording industry, pri
marily through the successes of Jimmie
Rodgers and the Carter Family. That's
not all, though. Technology, geography,
and a complex combination of social
and labor issues came together at just
the right time in Bristol to make these re
cording sessions so significant. Museum
director Dr. Jessica Turner says, "What

we are trying to do in the museum is to
really embrace the variety. There's not
one single narrative that we can follow,
and I really like that."
The museum does not disappoint. One

might expect, perhaps, that an endeavor
of this size would reach for the common

denominator among its prospective visi
tors, maybe skimming over details or sim
plifying the story in an effort
with the most visitors. Instead,

to
it

connect
has the

kind of depth that the general public, mu
sicians, and scholars alike will appreciate.
This 24,000-square-foot facility situ
ated just north of Bristol's main com
mercial street was built to tell, in detail,
the story of the Bristol Sessions, but it
ultimately tells much more: the broader
story of commercial

and

casual Ameri

old-time music, and what it sees as
the continuing musical impact of oldcan

time music's commercial success. Turner
says, "I think we are concurrently tell
ing a number of different stories. We are
telling the story of Ralph Peer coming to
Bristol and making history. We are also
telling the story of recording and mi
crophone technology that helped make

much higher-quality records in the late
1920s. We are also talking about individ
ual musicians who were intrigued by the
those who wanted to
recording process
make a record, or who found themselves
Birthplace of Country Music Museum

in Bristol, and

thought, 'Wow, that would

�be fun to do.'

I

ries are really
The idea for

a

efforts

the

of

outgrowth

which for

think those individual sto

compelling."
a museum was

15

the

of

natural
BCM,

years has been actively try

ing to raise awareness of the importance
of the Bristol Sessions to the story of
country music. Its annual Bristol Rhythm
&amp; Roots Reunion festival in
September
has become a world-class event, and has
helped provide BCM with the awareness
to further its goals. Their offices have the
feel of a bustling creative office space in

Manhattan, complete with bright colors
and bright art, and music playing up and

down the halls. The organization has 13
employees and is a symbol of success in
Bristol, which is evolving into the cultur
al

hub of the region.

museum was built at a cost of $11.5
million. Funding came from many sourc
es, including the Virginia Tobacco Com
mission, Appalachian Regional Commis
sion, the states of Tennessee and Virginia,
and state and federal historic tax credits,
with operating support from the Tennes
see Arts Commission, Virginia Commis
The

sion for the Arts, and the cities of Bristol,
Tennessee, and Bristol, Virginia. Thanks
to generous donations and grants, mu
seum planners were able to hire elite
designers, specialists, and artists from

around the country.
Since Turner's work began at the muse
um in January 2013, people from around
the region have been coming forward to
share their stories and remembrances of
either the Bristol Sessions, or other as
pects of old-time music in their families

communities.

or

um

In

this way, the

muse

piecing together what is perhaps
as complete a story of the
beginnings of
commercial country music as exists to
is

day.

It

is a

and friends

courtesy Birthplace of country Music Museum

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

folklorist's
of

dream. Relatives

1920s

recording artists,
even musicians who hoped to record,
are coming forward with stories, instru
ments, documents, or rare recordings,
never having considered such things of
value before now. Turner says that Geor
gia Warren, the last surviving artist to
record on the Bristol Sessions, came to
tour the museum recently. "It was fantas

show her through. Her group was
congregation. They didn't even have a
church. They met in peoples' homes. Just
a
community of gospel singers who came
tic to
a

to

Bristol because

they heard about the

Sessions and thought, 'We sing, let's go
record one of our songs.'"
The

seat,

two-story facility features a 100acoustically engineered perfor-

�courtesy Birthplace
of

Country Music Museum

Church theater

at

Birthplace of Country Music Museum

mance and teaching theater, a gallery for
traveling exhibits, the museum archives,

classrooms

for

educational

program

ming,
gift shop, and a two-story pillar
like sculpture with photographs of Ses
sions performers, and embedded with
speakers. And that's just on the first floor.
The second floor
the heart of the mu
seum has a theater that shows the ori
entation film Bound for Bristol, and plenty
a

of

interesting displays and elements, like

word tally of the most frequently sung
words in the songs of the Bristol Sessions.
You guessed it, "Jesus" comes in first.
Additionally a small chapel anointed
by one of the Pentecostal musicians who
performed gospel music for the film
welcomes visitors to sit in church pews
and watch a film about faith and religion
and how it shapes the music.
WBCM, a working and licensed lowpower FM radio station, will broadcast
live programming and archival radio
shows from the region. Another small
theater shows a film about the musical
techniques used in the Bristol Sessions,
i.e., what people were doing with their
hands. There is a listening station with
the 68 original tracks that were released
a

from the Sessions and a mixing sta
tion where visitors can move sliders on
and

substitute instru

mixing board,
ments for one another to create different
mixes and blends of contemporary ver
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

sions of Bristol Sessions songs. There are
other exhibits that explore technology
and its relationship to tradition, the roles
of

community, labor, and faith

in

Appa-

lachia, and an exhibit that looks at com

munity gathering spaces, conventions,
and festivals as a way of bringing people
together around the music. And there is
much more. As you would expect, there
are panels throughout the museum with
written narrative, describing the exhib
its, and telling the story in context.
BCM is also developing plans to use the
museum space for educational outreach.
They are holding teacher in-services, and

have plans to offer master classes and
lectures and discussions that delve deep
er into academic issues. "I hope for more
conversation about these sessions and
regional music, and about what it means
to be Appalachian. All these things are
good to dig into and debate. On the one
hand we have these gorgeous exhibits
that appear to tell a pretty authoritative
story, but I think as authoritative as they
look, it's important to recognize that the

story is something to continue debating,
and I like to invite people to do that. I
think one of the things the museum can
do well is to make itself that kind of re

source and facility where learning
tinues to happen and intellectual
versations are alive. And I think we
to engage people in this idea that

con
con
have
there

were things that led up

to

these Bristol

Sessions that are really significant and
part of the whole story," says Turner.
The matter of the designation "birth
place" continues to be one of the conver

sations that keeps coming up. The US
Congress named Bristol the "Birthplace
of Country Music" in 1998, and Turner

says that needs clarifying. "Sometimes
the Birthplace of Country Music is an
unfortunate name, because it implies
that we are all about the Bristol Ses
sions, and the recording industry and
these songs, and this music in the 1920s.
What we are doing at BCM is digging
deeper into the reasons for the com
mercial success of the Bristol Sessions.
But we're also talking about the OKeh
and Columbia labels, and the Johnson
City Sessions, the Knoxville Sessions,
and of course the many other recording
sessions that happened prior to those. I
think once people understand that we
are acknowledging and celebrating that,
and not arguing it, folks out there who
are knowledgeable will relax a little bit."
Turner embraces the idea that the facility
is

contributing

to the

community.

"I

feel

very touched at the idea that in a lower-income area of the state, there is going to be
this really magnificent, academic, engag
ing museum that will be in people's back
yards. It doesn't have to get shipped off to
a distant archive, it can
stay right here."

�TALES FROM THE 'WOODS, PART 13: BURLINGTON
By Walt Koken

or

Mac had booked

into a
Vermont. This
us

Doug
club in Burlington,
was new territory for us. It was for Fri
day and Saturday nights, and there was
a
guarantee against the door. The guar
antee was minimal, but supposedly this
club restaurant was a popular night spot
and had a capacity for a large crowd. Be
sides, it was January, and we had very
little work at that time of year, so, hoping
for good fortune, off we went.
We estimated the drive time to be about
six hours, but the weather report was
somewhat threatening, so we decided to
leave Friday about mid-morning, arrive
in the

afternoon with plenty of time

to

get

the road noise out of our ears, and have
supper before the gig, which was slated

nine o'clock that evening.
was overcast that morning and the air

to start at
It

temperature was just above freezing

as

we rounded up the five of us in the van
and headed north about ten o'clock. It
took planning to pick everybody up on
the way to a gig. When we came home
from a trip, we would try to set things up
so that whoever lived furthest from the
next job would take the van home. This
trip we were headed north to Syracuse,
then west to Albany and then north to

Burlington, so Doug and Jenny, who lived
the furthest south on the Tioga/ Chemung
County line, came by way of my house
and Mac's in Schuyler County, and then
we picked up Bob over in Seneca County.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and we were
new venue. About
optimistic about
halfway to Syracuse, when we picked up
interstate 81 north, we hit some snow, start
ing to fall in large wet clumps. The remaing
30 miles to Syracuse set the tenor for the
trip. By the time we got close to Syracuse
and the Thruway, our chosen route east for
the day, the roads were well covered, quite
icy and slippery. In fact, when we took the
exit ramp for the Thruway, we slowly skid
There was no precipitation,
this

ded into the guard rail, crumpling the cor
ner of tire front bumper on the van.

The road surface on the Thruway itself
offered no more comfort. It soon became
evident that driving was really treacher
ous. The snow was building up, and cars
and trucks were spinning off the road all
over the place. Visibility was decreas
ing rapidly, and our top speed was only
about 25 miles per hour. We couldxr't
pass slower cars and seemed to be losing
power in the van. When we pulled into a
service area for gas, we noticed that the
exhaust was black smoke, and the carbu
retor had become white and fouled with

frost.

No wonder

the off-ramp.

we had

The accelerator

skidded on
cable had

locked up with ice! We sat in the service
area for a while with the engine running.
That finally warmed up and thawed the
carburetor, and we took off again into the
great wlriteness.
So onward we trudged, passing by the
luckless motorists who had skidded off tire

road and were waiting to be winched back
onto the snowy ice link we were traveling
on.

Unfortunately, keeping

it

on the road

meant driving slowly, so our six-hour cruise
was turning into an extended nightmare.
Driving became very stressful, and not just
for the driver. Although we were only trav
eling at 25 miles per hour or so, we were
going as fast as we could, on the ragged
edge, trying to make time while slithering
along. Another mile per hour faster and
we would end up in the ditch like so many
others. The passing lane, for the most part,
was unplowed, so slower traffic was more
of a problem. We stopped to change drivers
occasionally, but whoever was driving was
wJute-knuckling it, leaving the others to
hope for the best. The heater in the van was
somewhat inadequate, and since most of
tire warmth was concentrated on the wind
shield defroster, we were chilly. And being
bundled in our winter coats made it even
more discomforting. We were not making
good time, and we wondered whether we
would even make it to the gig, but this was
long before the days of cell phones, and our
best option was to just struggle onwards to
the gig and the lifestyle to wlrich we had

committed ourselves.
It was well after dark when we passed
Albany, the halfway point on our jour
ney. There we caught the Northway
towards Burlington, a mere 150 miles
further up the pike. It was still snowing
and we were nerve-racked, exhausted,

�partially snow-blind, and hungry, but we
were determined to make it to this gig, so
we just kept plowing along.

Our best shot was to stay on the Northway as long as possible. It was probably
the fastest traveling. At some point past
Lake George and before Lake Champlain
we jogged east into Vermont, and with
about 20 to go to Burlington, the snow
stopped, the roads were clear and dry, and
there was no snow on the ground! So we

sped on into town, and pulled up to the
club about ten o'clock, an hour late for our
gig, and very weary. Our six-hour jouney
had turned into 12 hours.
Well, to make matters even worse, the
a bit ticked off at us, to
put

owner was

it mildly. People had come for dinner,
but since there was no entertainment,
they had gotten a refund on their cover
charge and left. We had been the victim
of a large dose of lake snow, a phenom
enon characteristic of land downwind of
the Great Lakes, specifically in this case
Lake Ontario. Burlington happened to
have been a bit north of the lake effect
that day, and this particular club owner
did not really believe or care for our ex

cuse, thinking

it

was just

a

"snow job".

docked our fee for that night. We
pulled out our instruments and com
menced playing as best we could for the
So he

folks that were left, salvaging the rest of
the night to some degree.
It's pretty difficult to be so exhausted
and still play well, let alone put on a
show and be the life of the party, but
we hung in there, knocked off the first
night's gig, and got some sleep. The
next day was a relaxing one at a friend's

house, which was very close to the club,
and the weather was better, so we were
optimistic about our second appearance
that night. Since it was Saturday, we fig
ured there would be a livelier crowd,
and

a

better

performance.

We

showed

usual time, but the owner was
still angry. The Saturday night show was
up at the

supposed to start an hour earlier. Woops!
Somebody didn't read the fine print on
the contract. So he docked us again!
What the heck kind of group was this,
anyway, that showed up an hour late on

consecutive nights?

Our drive home the next day was much

less eventful.

It was smooth sailing, and
only took us the normal six hours, but it
had the feel of a sports team riding home
on the bus after a disappointing loss. It
had been a rough weekend for us, and
we had learned a hard lesson. We never

played

in

Burlington again.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�MARK WARD: MULTIFACETED LUTHIER

Christian Wig

Mark Ward

in his

workshop

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

By Christian Wig

�ave you ever wondered what kind of
person becomes a luthier? Most Herreaders know that a luthier is one
who makes and /or repairs stringed instru
ments, from lutes (the derivative word from
the French) to violins and guitars and banjos.
A luthier is someone who can sit at a work

ald

bench for uninterrupted hours on end, gen
tly, painstakingly shaving and sanding wood
to fit this or scraping old wood to glue that,
mostly by hand in the same way that luthiers
have worked for centuries. Here the concept of
a
"bigger hammer" does not belong.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�as a beginning fiddler
bought fiddles and banjos,

Back in the mid-1970s,
and luthier myself,

I

performed minor surgery, and sold them in my
shop. But at some point I realized that if I wanted
to make a real living this way, I would have to
get some serious training. The incident that ulti
mately convinced me involved a fiddle belong
ing to my North Fork Rounders buddy Les Pow
ers. This fiddle, and my unsuccessful restoration
of it, became one of the miraculous salvations I
will address later. So I put on hold my dream of

a world-renowned
luthier and began
searching for a professional fiddle fixer for my
own problems. I would find one for a while until
something would happen to dissatisfy me, and
then I would begin looking for another.

becoming

Then

met Mark Ward
not as a luthier at first,
fine fiddler and extraordinary banjo
player. We met at Clifftop (the Appalachian
String Band Music Festival) one year, and have
played together ever since; we even recorded a
CD together several years ago. It was then, as
I was
visiting him to practice for the CD, that I
began learning the extent of his many talents as a
luthier. He showed me his workshop, a smallish
room upstairs on the second floor of the house,
but

as

I

a

work bench cluttered with projects, shelves with
necks, backs, and sides of fiddles and necks and
rims of banjos, all on their way to completion.
All the other upstairs rooms housed variously
sized planks of curly maple, spruce, walnut,
and rosewood. The basement contained power

tools
table saw, planer, and drill press. Then
Mark showed me an elaborate banjo neck he had
made, a copy of an early Fairbanks Electric with

beautiful pearl inlay perfectly engraved
on one of several banjos he plays today.
As

a

now

young teenager, already playing bluegrass

banjo, Mark also listened to the Skillet Lickers and
Uncle Dave Macon. "They seemed more fun, and I
just thought that was a different kind of bluegrass."

Even then Mark knew he wanted to make banjos,
and in 1996 he joined an elite group of banjo mak
ers, including Kevin Enoch, Bob Anderson, and
Greg Gfell, to name a few, who have apprenticed
with nationally known banjo builder Doug Unger
of Peninsula,

Ohio, through

a

program sponsored

by the Ohio Arts Council. Here Mark learned the
techniques of master banjo builders of the late 19lh

early 20th centimes who fashioned master
pieces played by the great classical banjoists of the
time, such as Fred van Eps, who adapted ragtime
and minstrel pieces to the banjo. Mark had already
made three banjo necks, matched them to pots, and
found happy homes for them. But in his continu
and

Christian Wig

Mark Ward two-point fiddle

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ing effort to improve his techniques, he took a tip
from Iris good friend, Greg Gfell of Kent, who en
couraged him to seek out Doug Unger. For the ap

prenticeship Mark made a replica of a Tubaphone
neck with an elaborately engraved mother of pearl
and abalone flowerpot on the peghead, and mus

tache and diamond inlays up the neck. Matched up

�original pot, the banjo was a work of
wish I would not have sold that one,"
"It was a nice-sounding banjo."
Mark,
says
I knew
of what he spoke, as I had participat
ed in the same program with Doug Unger
a few years earlier, even
making a similar
to an

broken fiddle to Frank for

art.

to repair it.

"I

neck.

Doug Unger was an art professor at Kent
State University for over 30 years, and still
makes instruments today. From him Mark
learned

more than engraving and banjo
making. "He taught me about art and de
sign and how to look at the bits and pieces
that make up the whole," Mark says. "I
look at how the shape of the inlay interacts
with the outline of a peghead, and then

how the engraving within

tire

inlay inter

acts with tire outline of the inlay, or even
tire proportion of the diameter of the banjo
pot to the length of the neck. A big, fat pot
just looks odd on a short-scale neck."

Another time

at

Mark's

downstairs in

living/ music/ spinning/ knitting room

the

where Mark spins wool into yarn and Iris
wife Barb Zavon knits and quilts
I saw
two fiddles that Mark had made. Both
played easily and sounded great. One of
them was a two-pointer, referred to as such
because the bottom two points at the lower
ends of the F-holes are missing, allowing
for a smooth transition from the waist to
lower bout. I was transfixed. This was
a feature
of fiddles built by Williamson

Hamblen (1846-1920) in western Virginia
and

later

Indiana.

Garry

Harrison,

tire

well-known Indiana fiddler, researched the
Hamblen family and made several twopointers. He played one at Battleground
(Indiana Fiddlers' Gathering) one year.
Mark was fascinated with it and began

making his own version. As

fair as

I

know

Garry and Mark were the only two luthiers
making these unique fiddles. The absence

bottom points does not alter the
because
the corner blocks on the
sound,
inside corners (points) of a normal fiddle
render the sound chambers the same size.
In the hands of air experienced luthier, and
of two

all

other things being equal,

a
two-pointer
would
sound
the same.
four-pointer
After college at age 27, Mark began an in
formal apprenticeship in violin repair and
restoration from Frank Marincek, a violin
maker and repairman in Cleveland, who

and

a

was born around 1929. He was the protege
of Otto Luderer, born in 1895 and trained
in Mittenwald, Germany. Mark was no
stranger to the fiddle. At 18 he took up oldtime fiddle, detoured into Irish fiddling for
a long time, then came back to old-time fid
dle in the early 1990s. In 1986, with a strong
desire to learn how to fix violins, he took a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

lesson on how

Working out of his house and

with fiddles hanging everywhere, an iras
cible Mr. Marincek reluctantly took Mark
on as a student. "Frank was hard to please,"
says Mark. "I would often take him some
thing I had been working on and he would
say, 'What is this? I can do better with a
hatchet!' Then he would say something

vulgar in Hungarian and show me how it
should be done." During one visit Frank

gave Mark a violin to play, after which he
asked Mark what he thought of it. "Did
you like that?" he asked. When Mark an
swered in the affirmative, Frank replied in
a
gruff tone, "Well, you ought to. It's worth
$100,000." Actually, Frank was a very nice
man, and much of the gruffness was an af
fectation put on in kindness and in jest. All
in all it was excellent training under a hard

taskmaster dedicated to passing along the
complex traditions of violin repair. Frank
died in 2008, but left Mark with much wis
dom, many memories, and a wealth of skill
in making and fixing violins. He told Mark
how he wished the opportunities for learn
ing new techniques had been as available
to him when he was younger as they are
today, and that Mark should always take
advantage of such opportunities. And so
he does.

Mark's education, however, was not ex

clusive

music and instrument repair.
1984
he
had earned his MA in English
By
Literature and was teaching at Kent State
University. But with a solid introduction
to the world of violin repair, he sought ad
vice and method from other area luthiers,
and his hobby gradually became a home
business, while he raised a family, taught,
and played music. In 1995 Mark made his
first fiddle. "That first one looked okay
and

to

sounded something like

remarks. But

it

a

violin," he

gave him such

a

sense of

he knew he had to
continue. So in 2000 he took a series of
courses at the University of New Hamp
shire in violin restoration and bow mak
ing, which included, Mark says, "how to
make it appear the varnish was not dis

accomplishment that

turbed in order to affect an inconspicu
ous repair. It starts with good crack repair
and wood manipulation." The next year
saw Mark at Oberlin College for another
course in bow making and repair. He con
tinued to make banjos and repair fiddles,
in 2006 for a year worked repair
ing all kinds of stringed instruments at
Woodsy's Music in Medina, Ohio.
Then at Clifftop in 2007 Mark met his

and

soulmate, Barb Zavon,
dler and guitarist,

a

quilter,

wonderful fid
and

culinary

expert from Cincinnati. Soon thereafter,
tired of teaching and desirous of being
a full-time luthier, he
quit academia and
moved to Cincinnati, where he was able
to further his dream. There he could de
vote as much time as he wanted to luthiery. Then Mark made two choices that
significantly increased his knowledge,
ability, and confidence in fiddle mak
ing. In 2008 he attended a violin-mak
ing workshop at Boston's North Bennet
Street School, which covered both var
nishing and antiquing; and in 2012 he
spent three weeks in California at Mi
chael Darnton's violin-making school in
Claremont, which included in-depth day
and evening instruction.

Now

all

that

training and experience

was about to be put to the test in

a

se

ries of fiddle rescues that, even though

I

know how they were done, remain magi
cal to me. Our first story concerns our
good friend from Columbus, Andrea Ardito, who had become dissatisfied with
the sound of her fiddle. At Clifftop one
year she purchased a wonderful fiddle
with no maker's label, but with two le
gitimate repair labels, one from 1844 and
another from 1906. In the tradition of
violinists naming their fiddles, Andrea
called it her "chocolate fiddle," because
of its darker color. It played well and
loud and she loved it. But soon summer
turned to fall and the chocolate fiddle,
now in a house with a forced-air furnace,
began to show some cracks.

Upon careful examination of that violin,
Mark found that it had once been painted
and probably hung on a wall. Someone
had stripped off the paint and sanded the
top to remove the residue. In so doing,
the top, as well as the edges, had been

thinned

in

some places down

millimeter (the thickness

of

to

two

half

a

busi

ness cards). In some places the purfling
was paper-thin. This thinning of the top
had encouraged dozens of new cracks in
the area near the treble f-hole, as well as
opening old ones repaired in some dis
tant past. There was also a large sound
post crack. The inside of the top was a
nightmare, with prior repairs made with
thick, jagged pieces of what appeared to
be pine that had been used as cleats, in
some cases with cleats on top of cleats.
Glue was slopped all around the areas
covered by the cleats. These repairs were
probably not done by either of the lu
thiers listed on the labels.
At some point this project stopped be
ing a restoration and became a resurrec
tion. But the old,

unsightly and ungainly

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

system of cleats had

to

removed.

be

A

major soundpost patch was required,
due again to numerous tiny cracks and
the area being super-thin. Here one must
inlay new wood into the top to cover the
entire length of the crack. "Cleats for a
soundpost crack do not work too well,
as the cleat acts like a hinge in that high
pressure area," says Mark. But an inlaid
patch assures that the crack cannot be
re-opened. Then Mark employed a tech

nique called "half-edging" or doubling
the edges sanded too thin by the sander.

New wood is grafted onto the
the underside of the top. This
virtually invisible when the
re-assembled. Then new wood

edge on
repair

is

fiddle is
must be

grafted into all the thin spots, graduated
and feathered into the surrounding areas
in order to replicate the thickness of the
any particular spot. The
fiddle top is not meant
to be uniform, so care must be taken to
maintain the proper thickness in every
area. Furthermore, the grain of the new
wood must match that of the old and any
cracks in the area must be repaired first.

original top
thickness of

at
a

what is it about this fiddle that makes
it worth the effort and cost, when
surely
there must be others out there as good or
So

better that would require less of an invest
ment? According to Mark's research, the

1844 chocolate fiddle is a Mittenwald "trade
fiddle," sometimes called a "factory fiddle."
These violins were made in shops around
certain areas of Germany (e.g. Markneu-

kirchen,
other

Mittenwald,

local

Klingenthal),

or

by

makers, who would buy the

wood from dealers

in the

eral fiddles

fall, make

over the wintei;
back to dealers in the spring.
were highly skilled, others
These fiddles were sold to

supplied the trade

in

the

sev

and sell them

lier repairman is recorded in a book entitled
German and Austrian Violin Makers by Karel

Jalovec. The label, translated by Nikos Pap-

pas, who actually found the fiddle in the
is handwritten in old German

first place,

script, penned onto a barely visible faded
label. It reads "Repariert von J.W. Bindernagel
im Gotha

1

844" ["Repaired by

J.

W.

Binder

1844"]. Bindernagel was
nagel
born in Remstadt near Gotha around 1770,
in

Gotha,

and died in 1845 in Gotha. According to
the book he was primarily a guitar maker
and his wife was "an outstanding guitar

virtuoso." A quick comparison of the writ
ing in the book and that on the label shows
many similarities, but Mark cannot say with
absolute certainty the same hand wrote it.
"I

would think

cause

it is

legitimate, though, be

going to fake a repair label,
do
it
from
someone
who is primarily a
why
guitar maker?" What gives this fiddle more
if

you are

value than the common trade fiddle
well it is made.

is

how

The second fiddle restoration is the one

mentioned earlier, on the instrument be
longing to Les Powers of Newark, Ohio.
Les and his wife Christina
in the mid '70s,

and as

a

got married

wedding pres

gave him the fiddle. It has an
intriguing look with its dark, dull fin
ish, double purfling on the top and back,
and geometric design inlaid into the
back. The inside label reads "Gasparo
da Salo," after the Italian violin maker
(1542-1609). (Again, the label does not
often indicate the actual maker.) It has a
sound usually described as dark, with a
heavy bass and a lighter treble. Various
clues indicate that the Powers fiddle is
another trade fiddle, but from the later
ent

she

well-made instrument, but

Some makers

1800s.

not so much.

some point after Les got the fiddle the
action began to rise. Eventually the neck

brokers who

rest

of Europe

and America. Quite often the labels glued

inside these violins are unreliable, placed
therein only to sell the instrument. Many
of these violins are not exact copies of any
specific one made by Stradivarius or Maggini or indeed anyone. Most violin histori
ans believe that those instruments made in
the earlier 19th century, like the chocolate
fiddle, are transitional instruments origi
nally made with shorter necks pitched at
an angle nearer to the plane of the top. At

some point their necks were re-pitched to a
greater angle and lengthened, as in the case
of the chocolate fiddle, in a gradual evolu
tion that improved the sound and increased
the volume, thus answering the needs of the
larger orchestras of the day. The chocolate
fiddle is more interesting because the ear

It is

a

at

came to rest on the top, making

it

un

went to a repairman for
playable.
the first time since Les took ownership. I
do not know how many times he had to
have it fixed, but I do know it was never
fixed for long. At that time Les was pri
Off

it

marily a banjo player and did not play
fiddle very much. This was sometime
in the early 1990s, after I had re-entered
the world of the luthier, and I tried my
hand at repairing it. Part of the problem
was that sometime in the past, the heal
button had broken away from the back.
Someone had tried to repair it with small
wooden spikes that just would not hold
over time. As I recall, my repair attempt
ed to line the inside of the back with new
wood and simply glue all parts back to

gether again. Not good enough. My re-

�courtesy
Mark Ward

Underside of

the top of Les Powers 'fiddle,

pair lasted nearly

a

year before

it

after Mark's repair.

failed

and the neck sank back to rest on the top.

Again Les found himself at the mercy of
a violin repairman, who
just re-glued ev
erything much the same as others before
had done.
So what did Mark do that was so spe
cial? He performed a heal button graft.
He removed the top and the broken
heal button and glued new wood onto
the inside of the button area, feather
ing it to merge gently with the back.
He then made a new neck block that fit
tightly to the inside of the back. Prior
repairs having neglected

this step

prob

ably contributed to the lack of success.
After repairing various cracks, as well
as a sound post crack as in the chocolate
fiddle, Mark reassembled the fiddle and

began working on the button area. He
feathered the cut-out area where the but
ton would go, feathered a button-shaped
piece to mesh with the cut-out, and glued

but he sanded that piece to be thin
ner than the surrounding area. He then
salvaged wood slivers from the original
button and applied them as an overlay.
When scraped flat, this restored the color
and texture of the old wood. After a little
it in,

varnish touch-up, the repair is invisible
to the naked eye. I returned the Powers
fiddle to Les last December and he was
very impressed. This fiddle, with all the
repairs over the years, has turned out to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

cost far more than he could have imag
ined, and I would guess he will have
that fiddle forever. For some fiddlers, the
reason they hang on to their instruments,
whose total costs far outweighs their val

ues, is simply because they apply differ
evaluate them.
Then there was the resurrection of Mike
Eberle's fine fiddle, made in Cincinnati in

ent criteria to

the late 1800s, a very well-made American
fiddle, which was stepped on by a friend.
It broke the neck, shattered the
top and
back,

and

created

a
giant jigsaw puzzle
re-assemble. After being reglued together, the pieces of the back and
top were warped. Mark made plaster
casts with the correct arching on which
to lay the pieces. After a bit of warmth
and gentle pressure, they resumed their
shape, dried out, and could be reassem
bled. Other fiddles brought to him for

wood, and other fine banjos with block
rims, as well as others with rims he bends
himself; a tackhead banjo specifically for
my collection; and a special-order banjo
neck for singer /songwriter Ry Cooder, to

matched with an antique pot Cooder
already had. This last order was a referral
from Mark's friend Dan Gellert, the wellknown banjoist, fiddler, and singer of old
songs, and friend of Ry Cooder. Cooder
liked it so well that he has commissioned
a second
banjo from Mark, this time a
neck and pot. Dan has also ordered a ban

be

Mark. Mark has applied his res
toration skills to two of his own vintage,
pre-War guitars, a Martin and a Gibson.
(I am also aware of another banjo order
Mark has received. Remember that neck
I made
under the guidance of Doug Lin
ger? I never totally finished it. The writ
ing of this article has inspired me to have
Mark finish the neck, find an original

for Mark to

jo from

repair have had such problems as glued
sound posts, necks held on with screws,
fingerboards held on with epoxy, and my

Tubaphone pot, and assemble the two.)

favorite, tuning pegs super-glued in place
so the strings would not go out of tune.
Other notable projects Mark has accom
plished in the recent past include several
two-point fiddles, one of which is now
mine, nicely distressed to look 200 years
old; two normal-looking fiddles which
have new owners; a copy of a Stradivari
pochette for Nikos Pappas; banjos with

Dobson-shape

tone

rings

spun

out

of

Mark does not seem to be interested

in

having a shop on a Main Street open to the
public. His advertisement is by word of
mouth, and he always has work. Word of

high-quality workmanship and uncom
promising work ethic is slowly spreading
throughout the old-time music world. That

his

world has many trade fiddles that could
use some serious help, musicians who want
good-quality fiddles and banjos, and anoth
er

reliable luthier to work some magic.

�Karen Jabbour

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�AN INTERVIEW
WITH ALAN JABBOUR
by Brian Lockman

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Alan Jabbour

linist

Floridian

is a

by birth and

vio

a

early training. The folk revival drew
him into studying folklore and folk music as
by

graduate student at Duke University in the
1960s, when he documented and apprenticed
with old-time fiddlers in the Upper South. He
a

UCLA before becoming head of the

at

taught

Archive of Folk Song

Library of Con

at the

gress (1969-74), director of folk arts

at

the

National Endowment for the Arts (1974-76),
and director of the American Folklife Center
Library of Congress (1976-99). He has
served on several boards of cultural organiza
at the

tions, and since his retirement
his time writing,

he has

spent
and

lecturing, consulting,

playing the fiddle again.
The

following article

is

adapted from

an

interview with Jabbour conducted by Brian
Lockman in December, 2014, at Alan and
Karen Jabbour

's

home in Washington, DC.

started playing violin at age seven.
Our school in Jacksonville, Florida
had a little string orchestra, and got
invited to play. And when asked which

I

I

instrument

I

wanted

to

play

said,

I

"I

guess the violin." So I was playing vio
lin and was naturally led into classical
music.

I

love classical

to the

exclusion

music

in

the

music, but not
loved pop

of all else.

when

1

was grow
ing up, especially the sort of Southernbased grassroots rock and roll that was
popping up on small labels all over the
'50s

I

country. When I went to the University
of Miami around 1960 I had one friend,
Ron Kickasola,
a

who was already called

folk singer. He was singing in

a

little

coffee house in Miami. I would go to lis
ten, and sort of got smitten by folk music,
and thought, "Here's a whole category I
never thought about much." So bought
some Joan Baez records, and you might
say I was being introduced to what we
now call the folk-song revival.
When went to graduate school at Duke
I

I

in the fall of 1963,

majored in
with
a
English literature,
special focus on
medieval literature. In my first semester
I took
a seminar in the traditional ballad
with Professor Holger Nygard. In the

University

1

class he would drag out Library of Con
gress field recordings, and I was smitten
by the sound and texture of them.
By the time I got to graduate school I
had more or less abandoned the violin.
I still
had it, but it was under the bed

somewhere

in my
graduate student
apartment. But this music really excited
me and I got interested in the whole

topic of the collecting and editing of folk

�music.
got so interested that I wrote a
Master's thesis on the collecting and ed
iting of folk-song and folk music in the
English-speaking world from the 18th
I

to the

century

present.

Collecting
Somewhere along the way

I

got the itch

collect myself, and I thought, since
played violin, why don't I collect instru
mental folk music, specifically fiddle
playing? I already knew a lot about the
basic instrument and how it functions,
to

would give me

step up on oth
ers. And there hadn't been much work
and that

done

a

in that area.

So I set about collecting old-time fiddle
tunes in the mid-'60s.
started right in
Durham County. Duke is in Durham,
North Carolina, and Durham County
was rural and was a perfect place to start.
I

just got in my car and drove to a coun
try store and asked, "Are there old fid
I

dlers around here?"
And within ten
minutes was at the doorstep of a fiddler
named Edsel Terry. In the course of that
first visit he pulled out his fretless
banjo
and played a tune. He "knocked" it. That
was his term for what people now call
I

clawhammer

trailing. He was a really
good banjo player and a really good fid
dle player. His fingering positions were
pretty much as I had learned it growing
up, essentially the same as classical violin.
I think
he was intrigued by my interest

in his
I

think

or

music. Fiddling
it

would

is

a

public art, so

be harder

to ask

some

body about ballad singing, because that's
more private. It's not something you do
in public all the time. But fiddle
play
ing is a public art, so people expect that
outsiders might be interested. He and
the other elderly fiddlers I met asked me
about my background, and learned that I
played violin. So they treated me not as
if I were a documentarian, but as some
body coming to learn. And that in turn

encouraged me.
fiddle from under the
bed, and pretty soon I started bringing
not only my recording machine, but my
fiddle along with me. Thus emboldened
So out came my

by their

encouragement,

I

would some

times play along. It was my way of en
couraging them by showing them that I
really was trying to learn, and learning

helped me transcribe the tunes.
I started
noticing things that I might ini
tially have glossed over, like noticed that
when they would come to the end of the
phrase and it ended on an open E-string,
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

they would double it with the fourth fin
ger on the next string. They would create
what in classical music is called a "uni
son." So I was starting to pay closer at
tention to their styles than I had initially
when I was just thinking, "Old Joe Clark,
that's neat." So now I was thinking on a
more detailed level or a kind of meta-level where style is both the details within a
tune and, in a sense, is beyond the tune,

area I was doing as wide a sweep as I
could, and it was that widening coverage
that led me to Henry Reed, for example,
who I met through another fiddler, Oscar
Wright, and his son Eugene. By then I had
recorded dozens of fiddlers, but Oscar was
playing some tunes that I had never heard.
And I thought, "Wow, this is great. Can I
come visit you?" And Oscar said, "Sure."
All the fiddlers I ever visited were wel
coming. They were happy that somebody
cared. They seemed sometimes to think,
"Wow, I didn't think anybody cared about
these tunes anymore." They didn't articu
late that, but I could tell it from their sur

because

it applies to many tunes.
most common place for Edsel to
play the music was at dances, but it was

The

also the case, as it is today, that people had
little jams in their homes. They weren't for

prise and delight that somebody wanted
to hear it and wanted to record it, which
even then was a symbol of really caring.

dancing, though somebody might jump

up and do
with it, but

little flat-foot and dance along
it was art for art's sake,
doing it

a

just for the pure pleasure of making music.

Ensemble playing was really common
way up through the Blue Ridge.
You could feel that ensemble being part
of the music. But as you got deeper into
the Appalachians there was more solo

Influences

all the

in the old days.
One time Carl Fleischhauer and I were
recording Burl Hammons and we started
thinking about making a record of him,

playing

because he was

a

wonderful fiddle play

Then we thought maybe we ought to
get somebody to play with him, because
er.

in our

minds ensemble was what

a

re

cord would be, but actually Burl didn't
go with ensemble playing very comfort
ably. It was hard to play with him. He
would do little pauses, he would put in
extra beats, he would do all the things
that make a solo fiddling style really en
gaging, but which confound a group of

people trying to follow along when they
would play ensemble.
Ensemble playing would include fid

dle, guitar, and banjo, but further to the
west, like in Randolph County, North
Carolina, a get-together might have a
hammered dulcimer, a guitar, and a fid
dle. It would be good music, but unusual
texture because you don't usually hear

hammered dulcimer as part of
time string band ensemble. But

an oldin that

world you did.
I was
awestruck by how much I was
finding that was totally unknown to the
wider world. It was different stuff in dif
ferent areas, like the hammered dulcimer
in Randolph County just 60 miles west
of Durham and Chapel Hill and 30 miles
south of Greensboro, but it was like anoth
er world of music going on that
nobody
knew about. That's what excited me.
part of the

Initially in terms of my collecting ap
proach, instead of concentrating on one

Father-to-son
and generation-to-gen
eration is a wonderful sentiment and
maybe it applies in certain ways, but in
music, especially in fiddling, father-toson didn't work very well, as I found
out. It can sometimes be a little too close
for
comfort. Grandfather-to-grandson
would have been better. A lot of young
people who were interested in fiddling
would hang out with the fiddlers two
generations older than them, like their
because
grandparents,
grandparents
and

that

generation would always al

low you more

latitude. They were so
glad that somebody cared that they were
not going to fuss about exactly what you

how you changed it, whereas
forever correcting. Tommy
was
forever
Jarrell
correcting his son Ben,
played
fathers

or

are

B.F. "Ben," he would say, "That's
wrong.
You got that wrong." It's tough if you're
the son. So I would say that it was usu

ally passed to the son from a grandfather
uncle or old guy down the road,
but not father-to-son. That was too close.
Records and the radio affected fiddling
a lot, but
Henry Reed was born in 1884
and learned fiddling by the turn of the
century. He had learned from old guys
like Quince Dillion, and when records
and radio came along he was fascinated
to learn things from them, but his basic
or great

style was in place already. So

it

wasn't

shaping influence on his style, it was
more a shaping influence on his reper
tory. If a tune caught his fancy he would
a

learn

it, but he already had a repertory
maybe hundreds of tunes by the time
radio and records came along.
One fiddler I visited was Taylor Kimble.
He lived in Virginia in the Blue Ridge and

of

�was

in his seventies when
knew him.
visited him several times, and of course
I

I
I

brought my tape recorder and recorded
him. Well, the next time I went to visit
him I got my tape recorder out and there
was another tape recorder there. Taylor
was inspired by my tape recorder to get
one himself. So he would make me play
tunes for him, and it became what it re
ally ought to be, which is a kind of an
exchange, because the comfort level is
best when you have something to offer
as well as something to receive. If you're

always
receiving end it's okay
when you're young, but if you want to
on

the

equal, you give as well as receive.
So when I went back to visit Taylor for
the third or fourth time he was playing a
tune, "Stony Point," and I noticed that he
be an

played
ry Reed

from

a

it in

three parts, just the way Hen

played it, but Henry Reed was
hundred miles away. So
said,

"Taylor,

I

what do you call that?" and he

said, "Stony Point." And I said, "Amaz
ing. Everything fits. Where did you learn
that?" And he said, "I learned it from
you! You played it the last time you were
here and I recorded it." And that was a
nice example of reciprocity.

Variations
fiddler understands
that you have to have some latitude in
playing a tune, but where you apply the
latitude is what counts. Sometimes if you
It's

funny.

Every

differ from the way the old-timers did
that

would

be

it

within the zone of latitude,

but something else would be,
that wrong." Tommy Jarrell
me doing a tune that I learned
and he said, "Well now, there's

"You got

once saw

from him,
one thing,
let me show you." He wanted to fix one
detail because it seemed to him that lati
tude did not extend that far.
But every fiddler

understands that it's

difficult to imitate another
fiddler exactly. In classes I teach, I en
courage people to try to imitate me, not
because I want them to play exactly that
way for the rest of their lives, it's because

extremely

imitation

one route to get out of the
stylistic box they are in.
Fiddlers know this, and their versions
of

is

different tunes show different stylistic

traits because every tune they learn tends

a mixture of them as a
stylistic gen
erality and the person they learned it
from who has a different stylistic gener

to be

ality. But in learning the tune they pick
up some of the style and the character of
that other fiddler as well. So then they

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

learned that and habitually repeat it, so
it gets embedded with the tune. That's
why fiddlers will say, "I learned it from
so-and-so," because they are thinking of
the person they learned it from as they
play it. They are replicating little details

three, as many as we could digest in a
week. As this went on other people start
ed joining us and the circle grew. It was
like an eruption. Where did it come from
all of a sudden? It seems like there were

of the

Chapel Hill area playing music.
When we went to our first fiddlers con
vention we realized, "Oh my gosh, we
need a name," and we came up with the
name Hollow Rock String Band. There
was a little Hollow Rock store up by
New Hope Creek where the Thompsons
lived, and that store was the convening

style they can hear in their ear.

Chord selection
Talk occasionally crops up in the mod
ern old-time music scene when it comes to

chord selection that, "Well, in the old days
they didn't have a three chord," and blah
blah blah. But the old-time scene then was
certainly varied. Everybody was different.
Every place was different. There was tre

mendous variation, and maybe,

in

some

places, nobody cared, but other places
they cared a lot. Henry Reed's son said his
father would correct him on their guitar
chords like, "No James, you've got that
wrong." James tlrinks he's now doing His
father's chords because he says, "Daddy

would just stop. He would take his bow
and tap me on the hand and say, 'James
you got that wrong there.'" So apparently

Henry Reed was particular about what
chords you played.
On the other hand, at the Narrows Fid
dlers Convention, our band,
Rock String Band, played.
member most is Oscar Wright
Reed sitting side by side on

the

Hollow
re

What

I

and Henry
the back of

somebody's station wagon, listening to
playing our hearts out for our men

us

tors who taught us. I think that situa
tion was for quiet admiration, and not

for fussy correction about chords. But in
many ways we had to invent the chords,

because I had usually just recorded one
fiddler playing, so I had to extrapolate
what the chords might be.
The Hollow Rock String Band
One

day

ments and

guy came

student apart

over from the
next apartment building, and it was Ber
tram Levy. He said, "Wow, where did
you learn these tunes?" and I told him
a little about what I had been
doing. He
a

said, "You want to come join a jam I play
with?" He was already getting together
with Tommy and Bobbie Thompson.
Tommy was a banjo player and Bobbie
played guitar. So I went with him the
next week to a jam, and that was the be
ginning of the Hollow Rock String Band.
It

just became week after week, getting

together, learning another tune or two

of

musicians

the

in

Durham/

for people, and it seemed like a
name
for a string band.
good
We got recruited as a band for events

place

like "Save the Eno River" and other

oc

casions. By 1967 we had played enough
around Duke that we had become known
as

the local string band.

Somebody de

vised the idea of having a Duke Folk
Festival with us as the musical hosts. We
had Pete Seeger and Doc Watson and all
sorts of people who we would now call
stars, and the Hollow Rock String Band.
So little by little we became notorious, or

maybe famous.

We got paid occasionally, but it was a
labor of love. More likely, if it was an
outdoor fish-fry or burger fry we got a
burger, and that was fine with us. We got
to eat and drink and have a good time,
but we made no serious money.
We had square dances in Durham in the
1960s, just because we felt we ought to, and
it was fun. We had big square dance
parties
outdoors in 1967 to '68 where there would
be

a

hundred people there.

So

gradually

we were connecting up with and contrib
uting to what became a dance revival as
well as instrumental music revival.
We recorded in the late fall of 1967, but
the album came out in the spring of 1968.
regret that Henry Reed died too early to
I

was playing outdoors on

I

the porch at our graduate

dozens

or

hear our album, which in a way honored
him by choosing so many of his tunes, and
we said so on the album. But he did not
hear it. That always makes me feel sad.

Old-Timers' Repertory
jams went on
sorts of places. We have evidence,
for example, that there were some bands
that had piano in them along the Blue
Ridge. If you talk to current people who
think they know about old-time music

Among the old-timers,

in all

and

mention using a piano, they would
doesn't seem right." Blue

say, "Well, that

Ridge music was, in fact, complicated.
was different things in different places.

It

�you listen to the Henry Reed website
you would see that he's playing all sorts of

your aesthetic

If

tunes, and in

way, his repertory

a

is

not

a

old-time music and Appalachian
guide
music at the turn of the century. It's a guide
to all music, maybe to American music
gen
to

erally. He didn't play just what we think of
as old-time. He got into popular tunes that

he got off records or that he heard

through
some other secondary sources. He played
one ragtime tune that

call "Ragged Bill"
to the original sheet
I

that
tracked down
music which came out right after the turn
of the century. I don't know if Henry Reed
learned it from that sheet music or if he
learned it from a record or if he learned it
I

from somebody else who learned it from
record, or from somebody who learned
imperfectly from sheet music.

a

it

band, we departed from old-time
only occasionally. For example,
playing at fiddlers' conventions, often
you'd be jamming away and some drunk
would come up and say, "Play 'Dixie'!"
and so we would have to play "Dixie." I
didn't mind playing "Dixie," but I wasn't
As

a

music

accustomed
thought of

to
as

it,

and

it

old-time.

wasn't what
But

I

Kyle Creed at a jam one day, and some
drunk came up and said, "Play 'Dixie,'"
and Kyle played it and then he stopped a
moment and said, "The Northerners had

'Yankee Doodle,' and
the better tune."

I

So he

Doodle" next.

think they've got
played "Yankee

Jam Protocol

There
but

it

probably was a jam protocol,
was informal and, of course, the

fiddler is the least conscious of protocol
because the fiddler just naturally leads
and the others follow as best they can.

I

would sometimes stop

to

give somebody

chord because I thought it would make
lot better. I was imitating Henry Reed

a

it a

with his sons, hopefully with good will,
but also hoping that making a different
chord there might strike the musicians as
an interesting musical step forward.
think there was a kind of invisible pro
tocol. An astute observer could note these
things, but I was not an astute observer.
I was
just fiddling. But if somebody was
I

wrong chord, somebody else
would turn to him and show him the
playing

a

chord, but nobody told them, "Get out
of here."
think the ideal was always a
democratic ideal, but the ideal and the
I

reality sometimes may be different, be
cause aesthetics isn't quite as democratic
as other social engagements. Sometimes

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

overwhelms

guitar players would watch what
Bobbie Thompson was doing, because
she was doing it right.
There was a tendency for the members
of the band to be in the middle of the jam
and for others to ring around them. But
The

everybody played together
as if somebody was leading.

wasn't
was often

so it
I

the only fiddler, because the early group

tended

include mostly banjo and gui
did not take many years before
fiddlers started to appear, like Bill Hicks,
to

tar. But it

who started frequenting the scene as
a fiddle
player. And some of the banjo
players heard the siren song of the fiddle
and got

diverted.

In

Washington

I was in LA for one
year, because I was
offered a job in Washington as head of
the Archive of Folk Song at the Library

Congress. I had gone there to do re
search into the history of old-time tunes,
and when Rae Korson retired, Harold
of

Spivacke, who was the chief of the mu
sic

division

In 1968

I

finished my dissertation. My

year. There was an

veloping out there.
from our old-time
limited. They did
repertory. Bertram
the West Coast the

old-time scene de

was a lot different
scene. It was pretty
not have a very big
Levy moved out to
same time I went to
Los Angeles. He went to the Bay Area
and did his residency as a doctor at Stan
ford. I teased him that he was a sort of
It

Johnny Appleseed of old-time music,
bringing it to the West Coast. I think Ber
tram even more than I helped spread the
idea. I spread it a little bit, but I was too
busy. I was in my first year of teaching,
and it took a lot of work.
After Bertram and I moved away, the

band got together occasionally, but tire band
broke up in another way. The marriage of
Tommy and Bobbie Thompson broke up.
That was a kind of an explosion that broke
up tire originally constituted band forever.
Tommy started a band that he called tire
Red Clay Ramblers, and a group formed
around Bobbie that was called the Fuzzy

Mountain String Band. The Fuzzies, as they
called themselves, were really a reconstitution of the old circle without Tommy, Ber
was partly musical and
partly people choosing sides in tire mar
riage breakup. People felt that Bobby need
ed support, and were drawn to her music
anyway. So she became the anchor musi
cian for tire Fuzzies as she had been for us.
tram, and nre.

the

library,

telephoned

editor of the next album in the Library
of Congress series, which was to be on
American fiddle tunes. So I said, "Sure,
come on over." We met at the John Ed
wards Collection of hillbilly recordings
that was then at UCLA and is now at
UNC, and we talked, and we talked, and
we talked. An hour passed, and then an
hour and a half, and I was wondering,
"This is getting awfully long." Finally he
said, "You may not have heard, but Rae

retiring. Would you be interest
I realized
that I was actually
going through a job interview and didn't
know it. So I took the job. One of my
colleagues, an assistant professor, said,
"You're going to leave and academic post
with tenure track for a job at the Library
Congress? Sounds kind of far out. You
sure about this?" But I was sure. It was
exciting. It was a new vista for me, and
having studied collectors of folk-songs
for my master's thesis it seemed like a
natural job for me.
The archive included field recordings,
mostly of American folk-songs. It was
then called the Archive of Folk Song. It's
now called the Archive of Folk Culture.
It's now part of the American Folklife
Center, which is a whole separate divi
sion of the Library of Congress.
had
is

ed?" Then

first job was at UCLA, so my wife and
I headed
west and I taught at UCLA for
a

at

me and said he was going to be out in
Los Angeles and would love to meet the

Korson

The Band Breaks Up

I

was with

perception

your democratic social perceptions. In a
certain case you might really want the
banjo player to not play so loud, or you
want that guitar player to listen to what
the other guitar player is doing. That's
why the better people were in the center.

I

brought my recordings there and they
had copied them onto big ten-inch reels
of tape, so a preservation copy of my col
lection already existed there.
With that job I was still able to go out
and collect. My work with the Hammons family was done in 1970 to '72
while I was in that job. And I visited
Pennsylvania and did some field record
ing with Jehile Kirkhuff and the Irish
fiddler from Philadelphia, John Vesey.
Busy With

a

Career

It

My years as director of the American
Folklife Center were intense. The Folklife
Center was created by an act of Congress,
I had
to deal with a Congress that was

so

involved with the Center's authorization

�and appropriation. I was a manager and
a
big staff, and the staff got to do
the fieldwork. I only got to go out once or

we had

twice for a field project. I did record a sec
ond Hollow Rock album with Jim Watson
and Tommy Thompson in the early '70s,
and then I recorded a third LP with Tom

my and Sandy Bradley in the '80s.
I did not do an album in the '90s, so
may
be that was the period when the world

was too much for me, and my music lan
guished. I played occasionally when peo
ple would invite me to do things on the
Washington circuit. I recorded Senator
Robert Byrd for the Library of Congress,
but I didn't do a recording for myself un
til I retired. Then I started playing music
more actively again.
By then there was a rise in music camps,
and I got invited to teach at a couple of them,
but I didn't play full-time. It was more like
half-time, but that was still significant, be
cause before that it was just occasional.
I
did some touring with Bertram Levy
and

he

and

I

made an album called

A

Henry Reed Reunion. And I met Ken Perlman and the two of us started playing. We

made an album called Southern Summits.
I did a DVD instructional
video and

Then

transcription book. That was a lot of
fun as a creative exercise, because I tran
scribed my own fiddling. Now I'm work
ing on another album and I'll probably do
another transcription book to go with it.
a

Old-Time Music Today
think old-time music has changed over
the years, but let me start with how it's the
same. This is important. It's the same in
that it's still a kind of music that prizes inti
macy. And I think that's really, down deep,
the base of old-time music. It's about inti
mate sharing of music with others. The jam
is really the key thing. Concerts and CDs
are fine, but finally, the jam is what defines
old-time music. Because old-time music is
about intimate groups of people making
music together, and that seems to me to be
the same as it was as I encountered it from

old-timers

a

to

way

Why

I

balance all those things.

somebody else that

Like Old-Time

I
think most people who put in their
own variations put them in out of ne
cessity, not for creative reasons. I've al
ways felt that, unlike classical music,
which has a demanding single standard

of

competence

you either can do

it or

you can't old-time music seems to have
plateaus of competence, each of which
enables you to play with competence at
a certain
simpler or more complicated
level. And you can move up step by step
as far as

it's an

you can get.

I

like that. In

a

way

extension of that democratic im

pulse. But aesthetics is not always demo
cratic, so in reconciling the two I think
old-time music has come up with the
idea of multiple levels of competence,
and at each of those levels people can
play with personal satisfaction. That's
really important, because I've talked to
so many people who started in classical
music and they just gave up because they
felt inadequate. That's not a good reason
to give up if you love music.
If you have a kind of music that enables
you to play at a level adequately and with
satisfaction, maybe you can find other
people at a similar level and you can get

that satisfaction collectively. Then maybe
you can even join not too obtrusively

a
larger jam with some people who are
two plateaus above you. No harm done,
you're not hurting anybody. So you've
got the intimacy and democratic ideal
and the demands of aesthetics, and you
end up with levels of competency, all of
which are satisfactory.
But you also, to a degree, pick and choose

in the '60s.

your group. You don't pick it by exclusion,
but you pick and choose just by asking
people over and forming a sort of infor
mal core group, and if others join in, fine.
You don't want to tell

people

to go away.

That's not in the spirit of old-time music.
You might have to once in a while, when
all else fails and

think the key human factors govern
ing it are similar. Is there a pecking or
der? Is there an arrangement? What are
the secret unspoken rules? I think they
are not dissimilar to what they were
I

with the old-timers, because
think they
have to do with human interactions in
an informal intimate setting, where
you
don't want to insult people, you want to
I

friendly and supportive and accom
modating, but you also have certain aes
be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

change but through unconscious change.
the fiddle it is so hard to imitate

With

in

I

the

thetic standards and you're trying to find

somebody is really ruining
pleasure of everyone else. And some
times two or three people sit down who
the

are long lost friends and want

a

chance

to

play together again, and they don't want

joined by eight other people who im
mediately change the direction of the jam.
to be

Imitate or Change

it's going to change
anyway. Don't worry about change, wor
ry about imitation and conveying what

we hear. We might change certain things
where we really think it's better, but that's
one little detail. If you learn to play a tune
with one chord and later you try a differ
ent chord you might think, "Wow, that
really makes it come alive." That's differ
ent from constantly changing everything,
as if

everything's up for grabs. You ought
have some ideal of what drew you to
a tune to make
you want to play it in the
first place. That ideal prizes imitation but
knows from experience that imitation will
still vary and will still change over time.
to

I've

in my

own playing by

listening
myself from the '60s and '70s
and '80s. I've changed, and that's good. I
didn't try to change. I might have changed
a tune where in the '60s I
thought of one
set of chords for "Red Fox" and then I had
a brilliant idea that I stole from Ken Perlman, and I got another starting chord for
"Red Fox." That's conscious change, and
we all do that, too, but that's not changing
to

the style, it's just changing that particular
detail. But
can tell you exactly what I
changed and why, and what the story is
and where it came from. So I'm in favor
I

change, but I'm not in favor of seeking
change as a general principle. I'm in favor
of seeking reproduction of what one has
encountered as the ideal, but the reality is,
of

change happens anyway.
Old-time music is so diverse that
gives you plenty of latitude. It's not

it
a

single thing that must be a single way, or
it shouldn't be a single thing. Once in a
while people get the idea that it is a single
thing that must be done in a certain way.
I
think we have to be patient with such
people at first, but sooner or later we trust
they will figure out that the world is more
and complicated than that,
the
world they think they are
including
If
imitating.
you're imitating the world of
and Fred Cockerham and
Jarrell
Tommy

interesting

those guys in one little patch of the Blue
Ridge, well that's Blue Ridge music, but
it's quite different from Taylor Kimball's
Blue Ridge music, which was just 30 miles
up the Blue Ridge, but has quite different
tunes and different approaches.

Commercial Appeal
think the very things I prize most
about old-time music are that it influ
ences the commercial world all over the
I

believe that most evolution that's
worth its salt evolves not from conscious
I

discovered this

�Ken Perlman, Jim Watson, and Alan Jabbour at

Augusta Old Time Week

at

place, but retains its own identity. That's
really important, because the minute you

micro-changes

start doing

now

it for

thousands instead of a
eight, you are cre

of four or six or

group

different human experience, and
ating
inevitably it will drift. That doesn't mean
don't play occasionally for an audience
a

1

of

a

thousand people

at

that's not what sustains
not what sustains

a

festival, but

me,

and

the music. What

that's

sus

tains the music is the intimacy, the demo
cratic values, and the sense of diversity.
These are all qualities that don't lend

themselves

to

making pop music.

prize that sense of diversity that makes
you alert to somebody starting a tune and
I

different way that maybe you
doing
can pick up and corroborate, so in a sense
at the micro-level it looks like it's just doing
the same tune over and over, but it's intro
it

in

a

ducing little changes

and it's introducing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The

Davis and Elkins College
as the

in

Elkins, West Virginia, 2014

group adjusts to itself.
I see
happening

interesting thing
is

that

classical violin players are

taking old-time music seriously. Now
young people who play classical music
are experimenting with old-time music,

and maybe jazz, too. That's a big change
and that may influence old-time music in
the coming generation or two.
I'm

cians

getting classically trained musi
more and more in the classes

teaching. Some of the young ones
crackerjacks and they pick it right
up. It's like learning a new language.
When you're young you can speak it
like a native, but when you're my age,
I'm
are

72, it's harder.

it

to do for

ought

you. And

if

not, then

the tradition is getting too persnickety.

Playing Fast
In jams

I

think I've noticed

a

trend to

ward playing fast. I've got to introduce
this by saying
the Hol
my mea culpa
low Rock String Band played like bats
out of hell. I listen to that recording now
and think, "Oh my gosh, what were we
thinking?" Well we weren't thinking. We
were bats out of hell, and that's the way
they behave. So I think playing fast is a
trait of

When

young people.
I

first heard bluegrass

I

saw all

these

satisfaction that can give you pleasure,

young bluegrass banjo players
playing like bats out of hell because they
could. They had figured out how. And in
a way we did the same
thing. So I can't

and

say it's

But it's never too late to learn to play
the fiddle, because you'll find a level of
if

so, then the tradition is doing what

something new, but

I

will say that

�I

tried even then to put in what I called
and do the bowing pat

"all the notes,"

terns that

I had learned
from my mentors,
some of whom played fast and some of
whom played slower. But what I thought
was important was the style. I did try to
do that even when I was going fast.
What's happening now is that I'm slow

ing down in my capacity, but also in my
taste. I don't know whether the gradual
loss of capacity is forcing me to change
my taste or whether the change in taste is
pulling me back, but now I love a "Mis
sissippi Sawyer" that is not too fast, but
has a lot of 16,h-notes and a lot of trip
lets and a lot of other little details. But

when somebody

speeds

it

enough

up

can't play those notes anymore and, I
think, "Oh my gosh, we're playing 'Mis
I

sissippi Sawyer' and I'm being robbed
my chance to play

it

like

I

want

to

play

of
it.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have

skeleton of 'Mississippi
Sawyer'
keep up with these
I wonder if
So
guys."
people are learning
it in the skeletal form from the
very be
I'd

to

play

a

in order to

ginning. It's not that they are shortening
down because they can't get in all the
notes, they don't hear those notes as part
of it. They hear the skeleton tune. I don't
want to sound like I'm blaming banjo
it

players, whom

adore, but many of them
a sort of skeleton of the
tune as the tune. That might be perfect
for banjo, but to me the fiddle is perfect
I

stylistically play

when it's filling those gaps between the
banjo strums with extra notes that give it
texture and style.
worry about the loss

notes than they're doing, and the notes
that they're playing is not the tune as I
know it. It's a skeleton of the tune. So I'm
worried about that. Luckily there will al
ways be old people with us, now I'm one
of them, to rein in the
So

young.

where are we headed,

need

people? We

think about the consequences
of the trend towards "Faster, no matter
what." As for me, I'm happily slowing
down with age and happily making a
to

new CD of that slowing down, and hop
ing I can induce others to at least consider
that as

a

viable way to make satisfying

old-time music.

I

of that.

number of jams where most
of the people were intermediate-level
jammers, but they're playing at a pace
where they couldn't possibly do more
I

ve heard

a

Brian Lockman is president and CEO of the
non-profit Pennsylvania Cable Network. He

plays banjo and fiddle with the Buc Hill Aces
along with his wife Nancy Karvois Lockman
and friends Glenn Carson and Patty Carson.

�I

TRE VAGABONDI

collection
of Todd

Cambio

promotional shot ofTre Vagabondi, a popular early recording group. The guitar player,
Salvatore Lucanese, was brother to the popular crooner and guitar player Nick Lucas.

A

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�THERE ARE STILL A LOT
OF RECORDS YOU HAVEN'T HEARD
By Dan Margolies

allure of scarcity is mother's milk to old-time mu
sicians and collectors of 78 rpm records alike. Since
generations of master 78 collectors have already
found so much of the good stuff, what is to be done for the
obsessed still on the hunt for records and riveting music?

The

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

helps to broaden your horizons. Sometimes
scarcity in the quest has pushed devoted collec
tors in new directions and often yielded some
incredible new finds and valuable new collec
It

tions. One prominent example is Chris Strachwitz, founder of Arhoolie Records and a patron
saint of vernacular music recording. He found
that while blues and old-time collectors had al
ready secured vast swaths of classic 78s when he
was building his musical empire, virtually no
body was collecting the varied and superb body
of Mexican and Mexican-American 78 record
ings. Pretty soon he built the largest collection
of this music in the world, and saved an almost

impossibly rich but largely ignored component
of the
to the

nation's musical heritage. You can listen
vast fruits of his labors, for free in 50-sec-

ond increments, online at the Fronteras Collec
tion at UCLA (http:/ frontera.library.ucla.edu).
Even in the era of such instantly accessible

digital collections

Fronteras or the Digital
Appalachia, as well as other newly
opened digital archives of field recordings and
commercial streaming services, there still re
mains a vast amount of compelling music of
natural interest to old-time musicians waiting to
as

Library of

be

discovered, unheard, on 78s. Much of it has
decades or since its release in

not been heard in

the pre-War period. Indeed, much of this music
has never even been heard of in modern times
by more than a handful of the anointed or lucky

collectors.

Obscure and great music on vanishscarce
78s with that lost timbre of the era:
ingly

sounds like the perfect thing
musician to seek out.

for any

old-time

This was the situation luthier, musician, and col
lector Todd Cambio found himself in by happy ac
cident after serendipitously coming upon a milk
crate of 78s that were utterly new to him. A gui
tarist and longtime collector of blues and old-time

discovered (and developed an abiding pas
a whole new realm of
long-lost ItalianAmerican music which was released on 78s and
essentially forgotten after the first decades of the
twentieth century. Cambio happened upon a trea78s, he

sion for)

�collection
of Todd

Cambio

Italian string band circa 1900

sure trove of folk music recordings that has
been almost entirely ignored by 78 collec

tors and musicians, and which he is now in
the

process

of

to the

re-releasing

the first time in close to

a

public for

century.

The fruits of Cambio's collecting efforts
to date emerged in a box set released hy

records called Paese Mio Bello/ My
Beautiful Country: Historic Italian-American

JSP

1911-1939, which was co-pro
duced with Hank Sapoznik and remas
tered by Adrian Cosentini. The records in
the two-disc set come from Todd's collec
Recordings,

tion and from records owned by Joseph
Sciorra and shipped to New York for digi
tizing. Todd has been amassing records

several years with intensifying interest
music and its context. With some
committed digging he has been turning
for

in the

that have not been heard
since they were first released.
One payoff of record hunting is hear
ing incredible music for the first time.
As legendary collector and musician Pat
Conte told me, "You are invited in, just
up recordings

through

the

themselves.
sic,

really.

approach

fascination of the sounds

This is true with any

And
that

it's
I

mu

the

non-scholarly
always thought was

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

more inviting. That was my approach,
and it was in emulation of the things I

liked best in my own listening or expe
ditions into discovery. I wasn't steered
into some sort of misguided professorial
understanding by copious notes on a 78
sleeve. There were none!"
Todd was similarly and irresistibly drawn
to the records because of their sound, the

depth of the playing, and the feeling of
the music. "It's got everything," he says.
"Records that are as raw and powerful as
a great blues record.
There were a hand
ful of a cappella records of Neapolitan fruit

vendors, lullabies a beautiful one like
'Ninna nanna' by Carolina Voccia. Records
like that are as intense as a Texas Alexander

record or something, you know? There are
awesome string bands, a ton of great fiddle
music, and mandolin music. A lot of it is
dance music mazurka, schottisches, qua
a ton of polkas.
A ton of
drilles, polkas
clarinet
tenor
."
music.
music,
great
banjo

The

instrumentation

on these

records

quite varied and moves well beyond
stereotypes of Italian mandolin music.
is

While Italians were often associated with

mandolin, in the 1920s the tenor ban
was, according to Cambio, considered

the
jo

hipper among musicians and appears on
numerous recordings. This is music that
defies easy categorization.
Mandolins have a unique place in the
story and should not be viewed simply
as an Italian cultural import. The expan
sion of the mandolin in the United States
was almost less an Italian influence than
an unexpected reverberation of Northern

banjo obsession in the cities. The explo
sion of mandolin popularity followed the
banjo craze and, as Paul Sparks writes

history of the classical mandolin,
"when mandolin ensembles became pop

in his

ular in the 1890s, they

modeled their orga

nizations on banjo clubs [in the Northern
cities] rather than Italian circoli."

Mandolins started
in the

to be made in earnest
United States in the 1890s because

high tariffs and shoddy foreign instru
ments. Lyon and Healy began produc
ing instruments in Chicago with Italian
luthiers in 1894. C. F. Martin &amp; Co. start
ed two years later. Orville Gibson began
experimenting on mandolins around the
same time and started making a novel
style of flatbacked instruments in Kalam
azoo in 1903. These rapidly became de
sirable instruments for vernacular styles
of

�music, though classical mandolinists
famously derided them as "miniature
of

lumberyards painted up by prostitutes."
Spark says Gibson's rise in popularity
was due

focused "campaign
of denigration against traditional Nea
politan instruments" in writings that
read "almost like evangelical tracts, de
in part to

a

nouncing unbelievers and exhorting the
faithful to spread the word."
Maybe
roadside signs in the South should read
"GET RIGHT WITH GIBSON."
The types of music on these

American

Italian-

records varies

The
widely.
first disc of Paese Mio Bello is traditional

music that will sound not that unusual
to

old-time musicians' ears.

fiddle

There are

accordion tunes, guitar-ac
companied tunes, folk songs, and so on.
The second disc tends toward more pro
fessional forms of music. Todd sees this
and

collection

as

possibly representative of
"an average Italian immigrant's record
collection in the '20s or '30s."
Conte points out that "The reason that
traditional music in the Italian cata
logue is so sparse has never really been
explained... the paucity of real rural/
village /string band music from Italians
remains to be explained. Embarrassment
in view of the snobbery of great tenors,
or light classics... or was it a
conspiracy?
Some kind of academician will even
tually let us know. There are far more
comedic sketches, in the style of the
Skillet Lickers, than there are straight
string band performances in the Italian
catalogue. Ultimately they involve more
food than liquor, but the body of rural
sketches on 78s of the 1920s are the last
remnants of very ancient entertainments,
involving all those good things in life like
love, rent, taxes, hunting, mean cops
even drugs and murder can be funny.
There are equivalents in this set for many

genres parallel
just have to dig

to
a

old-time music. You

little."

Some of the difficulty in putting out this
kind of reissue set and ensuring good
sound comes from the fact that some of
these records are very difficult to find in
"There are maybe three
any condition.
or four

people who have collections" of

these kinds of records, Todd says. "There
just aren't many. That's part of the thing;
this stuff was just cast away. And if there

collectors, what can you do? It's not
like blues or hillbilly when you can go to
various collectors and get the best copy."
are no

Todd is one of the few among the al
ready few collectors of these records who
did not grow up aware of the richness of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

this particular music as a child. He had no
idea it was out there. "To me it's just that
this music is so

neglected.

At this point

now, these records are being thrown out.
They have always been thrown out. This
is the music of my
great-grandparents.
My grandparents wanted to be Ameri
can, and they ditched everything except
for the food. They didn't identify them
selves as Italian-Americans, they were
Americans. They stopped speaking Ital
ian, and they assimilated. Maybe my
grandparents would have held onto the
records. The likelihood that my parents
would hold on to them, less. Their chil
dren, infinitely less." And better yet for a
record hunter, Todd says, "Nobody col
lects these records except for six nuts that
are all broke!"
Todd found the records in the usual
places from flea markets to EBay, a pro
cess that was made a bit more challenging

by his

Midwestern location but leavened

He talked to "old Ital
by technology.
ian guys. But they don't want to get rid

instead Todd did some
less
common.
He "traded blues
thing
and hillbilly records with collectors who
have stashes. And there is nobody stupid
enough to do that to trade blues records
of records."

So

for Italian records!"

So

before long he had

huge number of records. And he want
ed other people to hear them, and to hear
what they had been missing.
I
can recall having a conversation with
Todd in Madison in 2010 when he was
a

considering his quandary of having piles
of superlative records that nobody has
heard, but that he knew must be heard.
have long been of the mind that it takes
visionary in the right place at the right
time to deliver music from another era or
another world that people need to hear.
Think of epochal efforts like Harry Smith's
Anthology of American Folk Music, Alan
Lomax recordings, or more recent DustI

a

to-Digital box sets, among any number of
other world-shattering releases that have
changed the course of musicians' lives.
Conte says, "At least now with Todd's
set, some sense of style is made more
accessible, and maybe will spark more
interest. Not many people would know
of [fiddlers] Nullo Romani or Pantano or
any number of others at Galax or Clifftop fiddle circles. But no one is crusad
cause, either. The whole persona
of [the] crusader
like during the '50s
with the New Lost City Ramblers has
been replaced with a network of buzzes
ing for

a

involving instantaneous knowledge of
hipness, or once-secret knowledge, with

a
simple keystroke. Todd's set may al
ready be injected into this network for all
we know."

Maybe this

is a

crusade; maybe

start of something.

ward
is

it is

the

looking for

to

big sampling of everything. Of the
maybe four have been released

a

just

is

uncovering many new records
future collections. "This project

to

and also

Todd

44 tracks,

My hope is that there will be sub
releases
and that I can tighten the
sequent
focus, so there would be one that is all fid
dle and one that is all clarinet."
Todd has managed to find a lot of great
new records in this unreleased pile. Be
ginning to collect the records made sense
because the music was a revelation. The
first record that Todd was really struck by
was a Sicilian quadrille ("Quadriglia Alia
before.

Sicilana") played by Vincenzo Adamo and

recorded

in

New York in 1919.

made

"It

was a dance, a square dance, and
a caller," Todd told me.
As he writes in
the liner notes to his reissue collection,
sense,

it

"As

musician who has played many a
I
instantly recognized what I was

a

dance,

great tune led by a great caller,
a
good time. I was infected." It
well
known in old-time music.
feeling

hearing:

a

compelling
is

a

The obscurity of the music is part of the
appeal, but the music is the centerpiece.
me it's just fascinating

"For

sense of discovery

in

there

these records

is

a

that

have never seen the light of day," he says.
"Or each time a picture turns up of one
of these musicians.
Making a find like
that for old-time music or for blues,
But for this

just so incredibly rare.
ery week

it is

ev

find something that is major.
I am the
Maybe
only one who cares, you
at
this
know,
point, but it is exciting." He
often thinks about "that sense of discov
I

ery that our generation missed out on" in
discovering and, in some cases, rescuing
the legacy of old recordings. Most of the

records had long since been discovered
before many people who are now barely
middle-aged came to collecting 78s give
or take the few ultra-rare, long-lost Blind
Blake 78s that have turned up recently.
The old records are not the more main
stream music that one might think of

when considering the Italian-American
musical heritage. There is a diverse and
very broad-ranging
and

it

history

to the

has its obscure corners,

old-time music

is

music,

much

as

rich re

particularly
gional corner of the vast American soundscape. Aficionados of Italian-American
music are a passionate group. There is
an ongoing and growing revival in Italian
traditional music, and like any committed
a

�Sicilian
is

zampogna

player.

The

zampogna

traditional shepherds' instrument and
associated with Christmas in Italy, as it was

was

a

shepherds who first saw the star announcing
the birth of Jesus. During the Novena di Natale

zampogna players would come to town and
play door to door for tips of money or food.
Many Christmas records feature zampogna
players playing the Novena.

group its members are surefooted in their
understanding of the singular power and
purity of the musical traditions they are
preserving. Some of the music on these
recordings is played on instruments that
are obscure and no longer popular, like

cane flutes and the zampogna

kind of

(a

bagpipe). But efforts exist to revive them.
Documentary filmmaker David Marker
made a film on the zampogna as a way to
bring attention to this instrument largely
"forgotten and unheard in the 21st centu
film proclaims.
There have been a surprisingly

ry," as the

small

number of releases of Italian-American
folk music from the early years, and these
collections themselves are pretty obscure.
Many are familiar with Lomax's record
ings, but these are of Italian rather than

Smithson

Italian-American musicians.
ian

Folkways has

Italian

Folk Music

a

couple of volumes of
Collected

New Jersey and Rhode Island

in

New

York,

from 1979,

which are also hard to find.
As for es
sential collections of old 78 recordings,
Pat Conte and Michael Schlesinger put

out Rimpianto: Italian Music in America,
1915-1929, on Global Village Music in

fortunately, available
those who purchase digi
tal music. There is the striking collection
curated by Dick Spottswood and put out
by Rounder in 1995 called Italian String
Virtuosi, which features works on banjo,
mandolin, and guitar from 1908-1932.
1986.

The

on iTunes

All

set is,

for

musicians would profit from listen

these recordings. But oth
erwise, the vast bulk of the 78 legacy of
this era of musicians remains unheard.
What is the significance of a new box
ing to each of

set in the era of digital downloads? Is
the virtue of a collection being diluted?
Pat Conte, curator of so many essential

collections of 78s, notes that, "a record
release nowadays exists simultaneously
on different planes, like different

dimen

sions. Most people may never even see
the wonderful artwork or the package
itself. Liner notes. ..whether necessary or
not, depending on what camp you are
from. ..are just about extinct. Even titles
and composers can take a backseat in a

streamlined race

for

source material. There

collection
of Todd

Cambio

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

downloadables

as

sense of deep
caving and excavating anymore. I guess
that is both good and bad."
Nevertheless, Conte sees Cambio's set as
meeting a different end than his own Rim
is no

pianto. "I think they compare favorably,
but Rimpianto centered on what I thought

was more of an immigrant experience (in
New York, for instance) rather than Todd's

�broader

Conte says.

spectrum/'

"What

Todd has finally done, rather than
looking
behind over his shoulder, is present a wid

view of sounds that mattered most to
Italian- Americans of the time
something

er

you would have heard pouring out of a
window while passing, or right on a cor
ner of Mulberry Street. You can hear brass
playing or a street cry and smell the salsice
roasting while a mother is singing a lul
laby on a stoop with her baby. Mandolins,

guitars, wonderful singers like Romito or
Nina De Charny. Precisely songs like theirs
would have added to the overall ambience
in living room gramophones or
loudspeak
ers at the festa. The overall effect of a
larger
CD set too helps give an overall feeling, a
satisfaction that you have indeed gone on
some sort of journey."

Thinking of the more readily available mu
sic of the virtuosic masters, Todd calls their
artistry "tire icing on the cake, and you can
only eat so much icing. I wanted the cake,
the meal before the cake, the antipasti."
Todd thinks collecting 78s of forgot
ten music is much like building guitars

forgotten ways. "I am not inherently
guitar maker," he says. "I turned into
one because nobody else was doing it the
way I thought it should be done. I am
not a record collector either. But again,
I felt
like this stuff was just not valued,
in
a

was going to disap
save
what I can, and
pear. My duty
to establish some kind of a collection."
not being collected,

it

is to

An accomplished guitarist, Todd has
been steeped in playing, collecting, and
studying old-time and blues for decades.
He is probably most familiar to readers
of the Old-Time Herald as one of the
major

revitalizers of old-time methods of guitar
construction, focusing especially on the
lost secrets of ladder-braced parlor and
vintage Stella 12-string guitars (covered

piece, "Ladder-Braced Gui
Mysteries of the
Old-Time Sound," back in 2005). Players
around the world have been treasuring
Todd's guitars ever since he launched
the Fraulini guitar company, based out
of Madison, Wisconsin, more than a de
cade ago. Mike Seeger cited Todd's in
in

an

OTH

tars and the Enduring

struments

as capturing the essence and
sound of old guitars from the early twen
tieth century, and he played one.
Pat
Conte says, "He built for me what has to

be the

world's loudest 12-string guitar...

am actually afraid to play

it for

fear of

I

a

sound concussion."
One crucial
lar
in

aspect of Todd's particu
interest in old ways to build guitars
the United States led him to seek out

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the master builders of an earlier era. Vir

these master builders were
Italian-Americans, like Todd himself.
These men were generally unknown and
worked in small shops, and they are all
tually

all

of

but

forgotten today. The guitars they
built, considered classics today by blues
and old-time players, were not sold un
der their own names and were
signed

in

out-of-the ways places known only to
These Italian-American made

luthiers.

guitars came from the small shops of
builders like Antonio Cerrito and Rafael
Ciani.
Another was Antonio Grausso,
one of the first Italians to build instru
ments, mandolins and guitars, in New
York in the late 1890s. He later ran

and published

a

store

Italian-American music.

The labels in his guitars read, "Antonio
Grausso, Naples and New York." Todd

says "I think he also imported mando
lins from Naples and then put his label
on them, though a friend of mine who is
mandolin collector doesn't buv it."
The makers have been largely neglected
by guitar historians. Todd says, "Nobody
has done a history of those small shops.

Those

guys did cool stuff that is going
into the abyss. Great designs, va
rieties of stuff, whole families of instru
ments." Todd has researched the makers
to slip

�and their
ies and

genealogies

in

historical societ

And he has been hon

interviews.

oring them in the guitars he builds.
Pat Conte

says,

"I

think blues schol

would be shocked to know that
a
small handful of Italian-American
craftsmen names like Cerrito, Gal
ars

liano, or Ciani
may have been house
hold names in the guitar makers' scene
of

downtown New

'20s

York in the '10s and

then contributed

but

anonymously

to the

just about

sound of the Delta

as we know it today. (The Stellas that
were continuously used, for example, at

Paramount's
sions

legendary

recording ses

involving Lemon,

Patton, Skip,
and Son House!) Those Stellas were the
affordable staples of American
traditional music, the labels of which
covered over the above makers' names
in hundreds of music stores across the
quality

South and North."
One fruit of this research into Italian-

American makers came in his quest to
build a guitar like Ernest Stoneman's
famous big-bodied Galiano Auditori
um. Stoneman's guitar was, according
to Todd, "just a brand name. Antonio
Cerrito probably made that one." The
Galiano name for guitars was used by

several guitar builders, including Ra
phael Ciani, Giuseppe Nettuno, and
Antonio Grausso, and even the Oscar
Schmidt Company. Stoneman's guitar
has disappeared (perhaps run over by

car), but Todd recreated it from close
analysis of photographs and his knowl
edge of the building techniques of Cer
rito and others.
Todd built a Stoneman Galiano guitar
a

to

help celebrate the release of

man boxed

set.

He

has also

Stonemade a

a

Ciani-style guitar. They "all heavily in
fluenced me," he says. "I'm interested in
the stuff, the music and the instruments,
because it is really great stuff, and there
is so much that is unknown about both
them. And I'm not content. I don't do
copies, but my stuff is definitely influ
enced by the Italian stuff I collect. But
like music, I want it to be my own thing.
But I want the impact of these instru
ments to be there. For the music, I am
of

interested

in it

partially for my heritage
things and learning

and hearing new

new things."
Luckily for Cambio, he faces no fruitless
search for long-gone

Traditional chitarra battente instrument built

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

by Todd

Cambio, Fraulini Guitars.

Italian folk instru

ments, since he can simply build them
and resurrect them from the past.
In
2012, in preparation for a traditional Ital
ian music festival, the All Things Italian

�festival

that takes

in

place,

unexpectedly,

Fairfield, Iowa, Todd built an obscure
four-string instrument called a chitarra
battente so it could be used at the festival
to perform traditional songs.
Reflecting on the connections Todd cre
between these master craftsmen's

ates

approaches
bringing it

to

guitars and the task of
and relevance today,

to life

Conte says "now as for Todd [who is]
also steeped in blues, by the way, [and
Todd
is] a superb musician as well
has gone through what I think is a slow

metamorphosis in relying less and less
on technology and more on Old World
sensibilities and craft. His creations look
if they were [made] around in 1891,
and sound every bit as beautiful as they
look, and they keep coming. Look at his
catalogue, you reach into the time tun
nel and pull out a new Old World guitar.
The same goes for the Mi Paese set.. .it's
not about technical skill in the spotlight,

as

or

dazzlements per se...it's about the real

roots as well as the mulch, the rich soil

around it. It's pretty much the way he
lives as well. A pioneer spirit mixed with
ethnic pride and oodles of talent."

Adding the heritage trip on top of a
musician and collector's frothy blend
of obsession can have some outsized
results.

Todd said the collecting was
driven
entirely
"musically, for me per
sonally. I grew up playing blues because
those were the people I was exposed
to... Eventually I started to play oldtime music because I wanted to be more
social. But none of that had anything to
do with me or my history. Blues, I was
around it, but I'm not an African Ameri
can. It's like Hank [Sapoznik]'s
Tommy
If you want to discover
Jarrell story.
your musical heritage, you have to have

something to go to. There is nothing for
Italian-Americans. There is nothing, no
collection, it doesn't exist. You have to
find the records themselves, and its not
easy task.'
Many readers are likely familiar
Hank Sapoznik's iconic story of the
in 1977 when Tommy Jarrell asked
if his people had their own music.
an

with
time
him
This

led Sapoznik to an ongoing
into klezmer music collecting,
history, and playing, which was a path
that eventually led to him intersecting in

question

journey

Madison with Cambio, who himself was
embarking on a similar journey of redis
covering a musical heritage, as rich and
inviting as old-time remains.
Conte sees connections between all
these musics in "a thread of traits that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

include
ty."

power,

He recalls

emotion, style, hones
"plenty of Italian music

revivalists going back to the '70s, right
alongside of all the thriving klezmorim,
just not as visible outside of the Italian

community. But remember, the klezmer
scene was rich with monster musicians
who knew no bounds; Andy Statman
could play fiddle tunes all night, but also
wail like Albert Ayler or Pericles Halkias
and then go back to Monroe. When I met
him in the '70s he was noodling 'Born
Under a Bad Sign' on the mandolin, com
plete with exact Albert King lead lines. I
can only speak of New York, where I
grew up, and [where] the predominant
old-time and blues revival people were
mostly Jewish, not Italian! Ray Alden, for
instance, was an exception. And before
that most of the whole folk scene was fu
eled with Jewish calypsonians and cow
boys and imaginary railroad tramps. But
yes, there are quite a few Italians playing
old-time music now."
The discovery of ethnic music-mak

ing in America that ran concurrent to
the development of old-time music
as a mature form is increasing, and a
number of new releases highlight this
overlap. Sapoznik put out Cantors Klez
morim &amp; Crooners 1905-1953: Classic Yid
dish 78s from the Mayrent Collection (JSP)

The box set Slovenia, USA: Slo
venian Music Made in America (JSP) has
a revelatory first disc of the Hoyer Trio,
recorded between 1926 1929 (their ear
liest single dated to 1924). This popu
lar group played guitar, accordion, and
in 2009.

a
variety of tunes
waltzes, redowas, and the like.

banjo on

polkas,

Popular music played by popular mu
sicians did not exist in the narrow cat
egories record companies created. Elijah
Wald has shown how Robert Johnson
had far wider musical sources than have
been understood before. As Conte says,
"In the case of the Mississippi Sheiks, for
instance, all the brothers had to learn Ital
ian tunes as well as blues or string band
tunes so they could eat! Mississippi had a
great influx of Italian laborers at the time
where the Sheiks played functions. They
learned polkas as well, pop tunes of the
day,

and anything else that would

get

them hired for whatever etlvnic group.
Hell, Jaybird Coleman was hired to en
tertain at Klan functions! That polka and
other stuff was of no interest of course to
their record company."
There undoubtedly remains

a divide
between the perceptions of "ethnic" folk
and "American" folk in the mindset of
many musicians and collectors, which
ironically simply echoes the old racial
and ethnic divides of the record com

panies.

included

Cajun music, sung in French, is
in the

ern music,

canon of classic South

but conjunto music

Spanish recorded

in the

sung in
same era just

over the border in Texas, is not. This
seems at least in part due to the idiosyn
crasies of Harry Smith's genre defini
tions, more so than any actual divide in

music-making. But the overlap and
overwash of the musics were there
and deserve some serious fresh consid
the

the

eration. Since both styles of music are
hybrid forms sung in another language,
and therefore might be equally obscure,
it is logical to think that the absence
music from the
of Mexican-American
mainstream canon has broader signifi
cance. Time to reverse this oversight.

Old-time

musicians
the

might consider
ethnic sources and

reevaluating
context of their music, and not viewing
the music within black /white regional
binaries, where they continue to per
sist. We are at a moment in observing
the history of recorded old-time music
in the South when most of the old sup
positions and erroneous beliefs of isola
tion have been thoroughly punctured.
Belief in the whiteness of the banjo, and

�overall whiteness of old-time, has
disappeared through the blossoming of
understanding of the instrument's Afri
can roots, which has followed the work
the

Conway and other banjo histo
rians, dance scholars like Phil Jamison,
as well as sharp social historians like
David Whisnant. The myth of isolated
Appalachian culture existing out of
time has been dismantled by scholars
and Appalachian activists, even if it
has astounding persistence in both the
of Cece

popular imagination

and in some

ro

mantic corners of more-old-timey-thanthou youthful revivalism. The myth of
the dominantly rural character of oldtime music has been very effectively
exploded by fine work like Patrick Huber's Linthead Stomp.
The globalized
character of late-19lh and early 20th-century West Virginia is increasingly well
known. Fewer than half of the people
working in the West Virginia coal mines
in 1912 were "native white Americans,"

history
Stephen
a

of the state by Otis K. Rice and

Brown tells us. Thirty-five
of
the
miners were born abroad,
percent
with Italians overwhelmingly the largest
group of such immigrants. Presumably
no small number of these thousands of
workers were musicians. What did they
W.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

play, where, and with what other mu
sicians? Who was listening? These are
questions that haven't been answered.
There are also any number of questions

about what Southern musicians heard
when they were on recording trips to
New York and other points urban and
North, drunk on good red liquor and

surrounded by the cacophony of the city
precisely the era when all of these re
cordings were being produced.
in

A lot of

research remains

to be

done.

James Ruchala of Winston-Salem, North

Carolina,

an

ethnomusicologist

spe

music of Round Peak,
has been uncovering some intriguing
new material.
He notes that "Surry
County, North Carolina, had a signifi
cant amount of Italian immigration for
a while.
They were skilled stonecutters
who worked at the granite quarry east
of Mount Airy. One of the earliest mu
sicians that I learned of in researching
music was a Ligurian immigrant named
Bastanna Fopeanna, who was a stone

cializing

in the

cutter

and organ grinder. His family
came to use the surname Turney. One
local history source says that this was

originally

a

nickname given

to

Fope

anna because of the motion of the organ
crank.
Fopeanna was born in Genoa,

Italy, in 1822 and died in 1915. I drive
past his grave almost every day. Intrigu-

ingly, Tommy Jarrell's mother's maiden
name was Turney, but there's no evi
dence that could find that Tommy was
related to Fopeanna." It does make you
think though. What might Tommy Jarrell have done with a chitarra battente
There is no shortage of ethnic music
on 78s waiting for collector interest, and
no doubt much of the extant record
ings are still waiting to be dusted off
in some junk store, attic, or
garage sale.
Dick Spotswood's canonical index of
ethnic records lists more than 200,000
I

recordings. There are something like
8,000 Italian recordings alone, so there
is

almost no limit

to the

new music

to

hear or new records to seek out. There
are any number of other rich possibili
ties. Looking back, we see and hear the
early old-time musicians and bluesmen, playing the music of mountains,
mills, and Delta on Italian-American

made instruments.

Looking forward,

we can strive to hear again the many

other sounds of the era.
Dan Margolies

is a

historian

and banjo and

bajo sexto player in Norfolk, Virginia. He
can be reached at dsmargolies@gmail.com.

�PRECIOUS MEMORIES:

BRINGING SARAH OGAN GUNNING TO LIFE ON STAGE
By Art Menius

It

that moment

starts on September 4, I960, the day Aunt Molly
Jackson, after dying at age 80, was buried in Sacra
mento, California. Sarah Ogan Gunning, her half-

of labor

Thus opens songwriter,
playwright,
and activist Si Kahn's new one-woman
play, Precious Memories, starring Sue
Massek. Massek has been a banjo player
for almost 40 years with Louisville's pio
neering feminist old-time band the Reel
World String Band. Massek's Sarah tells
the stories of both remarkable mountain

singers and her brother Jim Garland,
while bringing her songs and stories to
life on stage and on a new album of the
same name. Kahn set Precious Memories
just before Gunning's musical career was
restored during the third and best-known
20th-century folk revival. She had also

Sarah
to be

went through

in the first revival, that of
Woody Guthrie, Lead Belly, and the close
ties to left wing politics and the labor
movement. The second revival, between

participated

World War

II and the
McCarthy persecu
featured
folk as pop music with the
tion,
Weavers topping the charts. Sarah de
scribes both her indelible ties to Jackson
and the conflict born of mutual jealousy
and resentment. The elder woman inher

ited the unwanted job of raising her halfsister. She had little fondness for Sarah's
youth and better looks and voice. Gun

dominant per
sonality, gift for self-promotion, and her
Dylan-like penchant for reinventing and
rewriting her biography into mythology
ning

or,

resented

Jackson's

more accurately, pure myth.

Following an advance workshop per
formance in March 2013 at Northern Cal
ifornia's Main Stage West, Massek has
taken Precious Memories on the road. Her
Sarah Ogan Gunning has taken the stage
at festivals (Northern Appalachian Folk

Appalshop's Seedtime on the
Cumberland, the SongFarmers Gather
ing), colleges and universities (Universi
Festival,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

conferences (Southeast Regional Folk Al

liance), theaters, and churches. She even
performed an excerpt on the public radio
and television show Woodsongs.
What a propitious time 1960 was for
Gunning. Massek says, "It seems to me
that partially because of Molly passing
and partially because of the times, with
the third and biggest folk revival go
in all of

them, but that [one] really took off right
after Molly died
it feels like she really
blossomed once Molly wasn't there to try
and over-shine her."
Kahn explains how Precious Memo
ries came to be set on that day. It began
with his efforts as playwright to create
a dramatic arc to the
story. That process
moved the presentation from Massek
singing, playing, and telling stories to a
fully realized

musical play.

To

start,

he

interviewed Massek about Gunning. He
asked her to start playing and singing
Gunning's songs in the front room of her

Willisburg, Kentucky, home.
She urns sitting there and playing and
it

came

how

to me

to

start the show and

said, "Don't stop playing, I'll be right
"
back.
This is the great challenge in all
I

theater and it's

a
challenge when you're
someone's life. How do
you get into it? How do you get out of
it? How do you make it dramatic with

dealing

out
it,

with

dramatizing
and how

that

helps

do

it or

over-dramatizing

you get started

the

audience

what's happening?
I went into the kitchen.

I

in a

way

understand
took out

a

yel

low pad and I wrote down, "Well Molly,
I
guess that's the last of you." That be
came the beginning of the show, and in

years that she and

say

by

sorry to say that, but it is," and then she
says, "You and I never did get along very
well, did we?"
I

participated

in the 50

ing, "Well Molly, I guess that's the last of
"
you, and she pauses and she says, "I'm

ty of Kentucky, Frostburg State, Radford),

and Sarah

re-thinking this relationship,
re-experiencing all the emotions she
to be

Molly were both alive. She starts

causes.

ing on

place

it creates the appropriate mo
ment for Sue and Sarah, but really for

Both are far from their Kentucky mountain homes, and
they ended up in these far-away cities via New York City
and the pre- World War II urban folk revival, closely tied

left-wing support

takes

"It

drama and

sister, younger by 30 years, reflects on their tumultuous
relationship from the loneliness of her Detroit apartment.

to

realized,

I

the date of Molly's funeral." That's
when we set it, because that creates the
on

wrote down those lines.

still

the

playing
banjo,
Ogan Gunning, so

Sue was still
Sarah

singing

went back, I said,
"Finish the song, put down the banjo.

Read this

to me

as

I

and see how

it

feels.

"

She

put down the banjo and she read, "Well
I
guess that's the last of you," and
that was really how we got started.
These are the devices by which you
create dramatic tension within the one-

Molly,

I think the choice
of
one
because I feel such
good
and responsibility to his

person musical, and

Molly was

a

sensitivity

a

tory. There are other shows about people
like this, they romanticize it, invent
facts. I have kept as close to the facts as I
can in

Precious Memories.

Getting the always-busy Kahn on board
proved a bit of a challenge. The two did
a concert
together in Lexington. After
wards they caught up on each other's
lives over falafel. Massek mentioned that
she wanted to make a living through her
music starting with a one-woman play.
As Kahn tells the story, she said, "It's
got to be about somebody from the past

that people need to know about," and I
said, "Do you have a thought as to who
that might be?" She said, 'Sarah Ogan
Gunning,' and it was like I froze because
I
thought, 'That is so right' because I've
known Sarah Ogan Gunning's music
since I heard it on a Pete Seeger record
when I was 15 years old."
At three

the

in

morning here

I

wrote

this really carefully phrased and guard
ed email that said, "Sue, I just wanted

repeat in writing my offer to help
you write this show yourself, as I'd be
happy to do it, proud to do it. We've
to

been friends
at

a

some point

long time, but should you
in the future ever decide

that you want an outside writer

to

do

�this for you and with you, I would be
honored." She said to me later, "I ran
down the stairs screaming, 'He's going
to do it.

He's going

to do

it.'" That was

hozv it [happened]. But Sue should
get
full credit for the idea. It was her idea
to

create it.

whose story is told in Shelly
excellent biography
Pistol

Jackson,

Romalis'

Packin' Mama: Aunt Molly Jackson and
the Politics of Folksong,
changed the lives
of both women and their brother when
she learned that a commission of New

intellectuals had come to southeast
conditions in the
coalfields. In November 1931, Jackson
astonished the commission, which in
cluded John Dos Passos, Sherwood An
derson, and Theodore Dreiser, when she
York

ern Kentucky to study

sang one of her songs, "Ragged, Hungry
Blues," as her testimony.
Ingratiating herself with the commis
sioners, especially Dreiser, by early De
cember she had landed in New York City,
where she made her first recordings on
December 10, 1931. Her new connections
booked her for numerous events to raise
money for the southeastern Kentucky
coal miners and union organizers. "They
took a look at this astounding singer and
eloquent person," Kahn says, "someone
clearly identifiably from eastern Ken

tucky. They hired her to travel the coun
money for the strikes and to

try to raise

sing about it. She actually went to 38 dif
ferent states until she was in a really aw
ful bus wreck and got injured."
Jackson soon became a figure consid
ered to represent Appalachian authentic
ity in the

burgeoning New York City folk

scene. Her circles came to include Alan
Lomax, Woody Guthrie (who would
become Gunning's biggest fan), Pete
Seeger, Earl Robinson, and Will Geer.
By 1935, Gunning and Garland had
joined Jackson in New York City and be
gun making recordings for the Library of
Congress. Guthrie's glowing portrait of
Gunning in a 1940 issue of the Commu
nist newspaper The Daily Worker, which
Massek quotes in Precious Memories, in
creased the animosity between the two
half-sisters. After World War II started

Gunning moved to Washington State
and eventually landed in Detroit.
In developing
Precious Memories, the
pair had to confront Gunning's own

kind

of

prevarication.

While

not

self-

aggrandizing like Jackson, she remained
silent while others, particularly Guthrie,
invented stories about her. "We know
that Woody was

something

of

a

rounder

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�when

it came to women," Kahn explains.
"From the way he wrote about her, he
sure had a crush on her. She was a stun

rible things.
Once she did that research
and made that connection, then she un

ningly beautiful woman, and she would

derstood

have been about 30."
In one of the play's most gripping mo
ments, the peak of the dramatic arc, one
can easily forget Massek is an actor and
not Gunning herself. She reflects on how
brutally hard her life has been, while es
tablishing her own personhood and ad

rather than just the one at home.

sticking together and doing all those ter

a

for her music

drawer. She begins to read,

while and

it did

good knowing that not
was true. I never wrote

word

a

in

of

it

wrote

ev

of my songs
Kentucky.
ery last one of them after I got to New
York. I never told people in New York
that

wrote

I

I

them on the Lower East
never said

Side, but

I

let

believe when

them

1

didn't, and

I

compli
like stand

they

mented me for what was it
ing there singing your songs in that
hail of bullets. I never did that, not in
Bell County, not in Harlan County,
not any place

else....

I

never put

thing
washed every day

to

I

get the

to

try

any

clothes

on the line other than the

coal dust out of them.

Massek feels that the incisive political
economic analysis Gunning, who
wrote "I Hate the Capitalist System,"
made of the injustices in the coalfields
provides the most important single thing
she wants to convey to audiences. "I
a

real direct

connection be

tween the corporate control of our world
today and coal operator control of the
world that she grew up in."
1
think instinctively, she knew that
they were being victimized by injustice,
but came to really understand hoiv big
the powers

ing.
in

It

were

that

wasn't just

front of her that was doing

Market,

at

Highlander [Center
Tennessee]

that,

trying

it

huge thing
to

wasn't her fault.

in

Neiv

"People kept

telling me I couldn't say 'the capitalist
system.' Well, I did some research and I
found out it was all the company bosses
and owners all over the world that were

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

just have
As

It

lander Center," Massek says. "It was a
meeting that Guy and Candie Carawan

discuss the issues

in the

coalfields

at the time.
Sarah was there.
thrilled me because I'd seen her on

at the Smithsonian
American Folklife] ."

stage

to the

[Festival

Smithsonian Festival and

festival, a group of people who were
trying to have marijuana legalized were
protesting. They swarmed the stage and
dropped two pounds of marijuana over
the audience and caused a riot. Horses
the

were running through, and it was pretty
scary, but Utah Phillips went backstage,

out of her mouth, it stunned everybody
and they just stopped. She stopped the
riot.

The image of this

on a big
to

know that woman.
There's

tiny woman

huge stage, singing,

Capitalist System"-some

sort

is

having

conversations

could go out. Nozv, I
think of that big, wide smile

to

I

I

feel okay.

case with theatre, crafting
Memories became a collabora

the

the

I

of

responsible for the script, and Sue fineI was
with the mine workers

tuned it...
in eastern

Kentucky during the early

'70s, working on the Brookside Strike in

Harlan County... so I have some sense
of the accent, the ebb and flow of the

language's rhythm, the words that you
use and don't use, but nothing as finely

tuned as Sue."
Massek describes them working to
gether to create a book that rang true to
Gunning's voice. "My memory of Sar
ah has

faded, I'm sure, but it feels true
Sarah, to my memory of Sarah, and
that's the best you can ever do. We did
a lot of research ourselves to
try to find
out exactly what she said. I watched the
Appalshop film Dreadful Memories [by
Mimi Pickering and available to stream
on folkstreams.net] over and over again,
to

came upon that one panel where she was
singing, the labor panel. One evening of

Capitalist System."

manner

could draw upon

tor,

tray Gunning's story on stage happened
before they met. "I met her at the High

went

I

team grew to include a direc
lighting designer, set designer, and
costume designer. Kahn says, "I was
tor,

the Chicago Folk Festival the next year.
The event that led to her desire to por

I

have some

Precious
tive process. Even with Massek serving
as both music-maker and musical direc

advantage of hav
known
ing
Gunning when she earned
a new
career in the 1960s, appearing
at the 1964 Newport Folk Festival and

put together

to

room,

of hers, and

fight.
had the

to

a

quite

dressing

that everybody was

operator

ing life difficult. She said that she did
some research, and I can remember her

saying

a

book

to feel permission from
Even though she's gone,
few times of sitting in the

with her before

to be

When that popped

mak

it took

it

fight

it,

her to do this.

a

grabbed Sarah, put her out in front of a
microphone, and she sang, "I Hate the

were

they
that coal

grasp that

a

Massek

It

and

think there is

got
was

a

somehow wanted

nurturing Pete
his mentor for

and

book about Sarah

from watching her.... At first I felt a
little self-conscious about it and also

hard on your
self-esteem until you really figured out
it wasn't your fault. I think she
really

one

single

a

think

babies, it would have

world of

a

you

I

I

isms and stuff that

was really good for
her self-esteem-- I think when you suf
fer the kinds of poverty she did, losing

know you were jealous when you
saw what Woody Guthrie wrote about
know

or

a

feels easier than portraying
didn't know because I knew

It

her well enough

gave her validation
way that she had never

Seeger alone-- she was

I

I

Sarah.

it

know Pete Seeger,

to

talking

"You write

someone

really gotten
Having Woody
Guthrie write about her, and singing
with the Almanac Singers, and getting

Jackson:

me, and

a

about Sarah

writer, this play is perfect. It gives me
a vehicle
to let the world know about

back home.

"Sarah, Sarah, standing in a hail of bul
from the Deputy's guns singing
bravely into the face of the bullets fly
ing by and singing the truth." She then
to

in

I]

Archie Green

to do.

someday." Since I'm not much of

world economic problem

also think that

I

wanted

I

were

he said,

built her self-confidence:

lets

speaks

it as a

[and

Massek believes that Gunning's time in
New York City developed her anti-capi
talist analysis of coal mining issues and

mitting her shortcomings. Massek walks
across the stage, sits, and pulls Guthrie's
article from

something

"

"I

was like,

up

hate the
"I

need

"

of commonality I
felt with Sarah immediately, and after I
got to know her, then I just knew it was

trying to remind myself of her gestures
and the way she spoke."
The process of crafting Precious Mem
ories also required compromises, as
Kahn explains:
Sue had the intonations, and then at

a

certain point she would say, "I don't be
lieve Sarah would have done that," and
we had to settle some of those with our
verbal fists.

There was what

in the play as a poem where

is

described

Sarah says,

"I'm half sorry I wrote that poem about
you, Molly, but mad as I was, I couldn't

help myself.
in

no

"

She goes on to trash Molly
terms, and when I pre

uncertain

sented that

as part of the draft, Sue said,

�don't

"I

know.

would

never

was

She

sweet.

too

She

have

done something like
that." I said, "Sue, she not only wrote
this poem, she recorded it. It's a
song. It's

Tennessee Folklore Society

on an LP the

put out, and what we have in the play is
mild compared to some of the rest of it. "
The accusations she levels against her

half-sister are scurrilous and extreme, so
finally we agreed that we would do about
half of

it

and do

there she said

it.

it as a poem, but even
She wrote it. She did it.

When Kahn was in Lexington for a twoweek residency, the pair tried to take full

advantage of that time, especially for re
search. According to Kahn,
There's
in that

not

a

lot out there.

first week, went

Sue and

[to] the

I,

won

at the University of Ken
and
tucky,
they've got a lot of the stuff
about the coal fields and the strikes,

derful archives

and we're looking at these,
ing at the

fliers

for the

meetings during

this great strike that Sarah
and we're looking at the
that

talks about,

newspapers
wrecking Bell

"Communists

say,

we're look

County." There's so much there. It's old
yellow stuff, folio after folio after folio,
but no one has written extensively about
Sarah Ogan Gunning.
Kahn says that one chapter in Romalis'

book, Gunning's granddaughter's
memories, and Archie Green's liner notes
to Gunning's Folk Legacy album Girl
of
Constant Sorrow comprised all the bio
graphical information available to them.
"There is not the kind of detailed
mation that you want when you're
a historical drama where
you care
accuracy, where it's both a dramatic

and an educational tool."
Now,

true that

it is

I

infor

doing
about
piece

don't know what

Sarah did on the day of Molly's funeral,
but there ivas a day of Molly's funeral,
it is the
day the musical takes place,
and

I can
speculate from my experience
what she would feel, what she would
do. That's the process of creation. But

the hard work

Massek's.

It

of creation

would

be

really

is

Sue

the

imagining of
learning of it and the
embodying of it. We were bringing to
gether photos for the slideshow that goes
and

it

then

in the back

the

[of the stage set] and Sue sent

photo without any label on it... I
emailed back, "You look so beautiful in
that picture. It's one of the best photos of
"
you I've ever seen.
me

a

She

emailed

that's

Sarah."

back,

Really,

"That's
it's

not

me,

extraordi

nary, the resemblance, and I have such
admiration for Sue who had never acted

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

day in her life. After the performance
[Southeast Regional Folk Al

at SERFA

liance Conference

in Montreat, North
Carolina, in mid-May 2015], I heard
somebody saying to Sue, "How many
musicals have you starred in?" Sue

said, "This is the first one." She said,
"What other acting experience did you

have?" Sue said, "I've never acted
my life before this."
Kahn says that one
of the

came

"absolute joys

that Sue Massek and

partnership

have"

I

of

in

from

seeking

out

Gun

ning's descendants. They knew she had
two children who died young, one from
starvation during

a

strike and the other

tuberculosis. They had no idea about
the two that lived to adulthood.
of

Sue found out that Sarah had

a

grand

in

Hart, Michigan,
about an hour from Grand Rapids, and
she made contact with her. Her name

daughter

is

Rosie

living

Hickman,

Ogan

and

she's

a

photographer. Rosie was just so excited
and she said, "You know, I've written
a memoir about
my grandmother." We
were like, "What?" She said, "Oh, I've
got all this information." We acciden
tally stumbled on a major Sarah Ogan

Gunning archive. She says, "Oh yeah,

I

got letters, I got pictures, I got pictures
of our family. I've got a banjo."

Massek expresses a deep appreciation
folklorist Archie Green's research
and his interest in helping Gunning find
a new audience.
"I think he understood
how overshadowed Sarah had been by
Molly and how fictional so much of what
people were hearing about Molly was."
Green, who had interviewed Jackson not
long before her death, finally found Gun
ning in Detroit in October 1963. Green's
attention proved transformational for
Gunning, for whom the two decades pri
or to her 1983 death at 73 were her most
comfortable times.
for

He was able
the extreme

help get her up out of
poverty she was living in.
to

in New York, she was in terrible,
terrible poverty. Detroit was better, but
it still... was very, very poor. Now, her

Even

granddaughter has a wonderful memo
ries of the Detroit house and said that
all over the house was

candy and food.

Just stacks and stacks of food in every
closet. Her granddaughter said it was

just because she was so hungry for so
long as a young person, that food was
a
security for her, to have plenty of food
in the house.

As

ment,

the
a

play

continued

its

develop

conflict that now seems funny

�occurred due

to

as an actor. Kahn

Massek's inexperience
seemed to take espe

rizing 90 minutes of scripted songs
and going out in front, and try to re
member where am I supposed to be in

cial joy in relating this as we talked at
the 2015 SERFA conference.
Sue said,

this moment, so when Sue talked about

need you to make me one
don't
move. ...I don't move
promise.
just
on stage and even when I'm
playing in the
band. You need to promise me that I will
"I

co-creation,

not have

to

move on stage.

I

said,

"Sue,

I'm going to put you in a
rocking chair
and you're going to stay therefor 90 min
"
utes. She said, "Okay then, that's a deal. "
"
I said, "It's a deal.
That's how 1 wrote the

musical. There's

no stage directions
says she gets up and moves.

that

That hurdle crossed, Kahn recruited
Elizabeth Craven to direct Precious

Craven spent some twenty
Knoxville,
Tennessee, with the
years
of
Tennessee's
drama de
University
partment and an experimental theater
group that met in the basement of the
Memories.
in

Theater called The Playgroup.
Craven had since relocated to Main
Laurel

Stage West in Sebastopol, California,
less than 100 miles west of Jackson's fi
nal resting place in Sacramento. Kahn
considers Craven, who had already
directed three of his previous plays, a
"genius at theater." Kahn's Mother Jones
in Heaven has been
part of Main Stage
West's last two seasons. He and Massek
flew to California to work with Craven.
Kahn picks up the story there:
Sue is sitting there in her
rocking chair,
really happy, anxious, nervous, but
playing her banjo and just rocking back
and forth.

Beth said, "All right, let's
started.
Sue, on your feet." Sue said
get
very calmly, "Beth, you don't under
stand. Si promised me that I wouldn't
have

to

leave my rocking chair for the

minutes of the show, and so I'm just
going to keep rocking here." Beth said,
90

"You

know, Sue, you're new

cal theater and to theater,

to

musi

but in theater

once we begin rehearsals, the writer is
not in charge. The director is in
charge
and in fact, if Si has anything he wants
say, he has to say it to me. He's not
to talk to
you. These are the rules with
"
theater.
She said, "Sue, you'd better get
to

on your feet.

"

The other

night here at SERFA, she
striding back and forth across
the stage and putting her fists in the
air, talking about her father, saying,
"Join the union, fight for better work
ing conditions," and she'll cross the
was

stage and become very, very dynamic.
I think
it's just such a tribute to her
courage. I have no intention of memo

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of course

it

It's

is.

a

won

derful act of co-creation, and theater

I

is

just unbelievably collaborative.

Massek

earned

her

courage

through

sustained effort. At the first performance
after five months she needed someone
side

on

took

a

stage to feed her lines. "That
lot of practice, a lot of going over

over and over and over the lines.
The songs, because I had sung several of
them ahead of time and heard her sing
and

ing, were pretty easy and that will give
me a mental break. It took me a long time
to learn the lines, and hard work, five

hours a day."
Precious Memories is, of course, a mu
sical with Massek singing and accom

panying herself on banjo,
ment

that

Gunning

instru

an

played

at

home,

her granddaughter, but
not on stage. The play, supported by
an Indiegogo campaign that has so

according

far

to

raised more than $7,500, includes

songs plus brief parts of a couple
of traditional gospel songs. Kahn ex
plains the selections:
11

I didn't write
any of the songs. There's
seven songs by Sarah Ogan Gunning,
one song by... Aunt Molly Jackson.
There's two traditional ballads from her

family's historical collection. Her fam
contributed

ily

hundreds

of songs

to

the Library

of Congress. Archie Green
recorded them, Alan Lomax recorded
them. We'd do "Loving Nancy," which

seems

have been unique to that fam
and we did "I Am a Traveling
ily
Creature" which both Sue and I had
learned from the singing of the great
to

West

Virginia miner, Nimrod Work
man, who actually worked with Mother
Jones in the mines during the mine
wars, but we then discovered that Sar
ah

had recorded

a version,
and that's
version we used.
The music appears on the Strictly Coun
try compact disc entitled Precious Memories

the

Last Will,

which accompanied another one-

actor play written by Kahn.

Massek has 38 years' experience pro
viding folk music in public schools.
Thus it is no surprise that she has created
curricula for Precious Memories, so that
the play can be used as an educational
resource in high schools and colleges,
as well as community
groups. "I believe

it's deeply important to keep alive the
memories of those hard times and of
how people worked together to make
a difference,
and to make a change,"

she says. "One of my goals is to bring

awareness of this rich history of fight
ing back and standing up for ourselves
to the next generations of
young adults.

But

I

also

want

I

to

remind folks in my

generation, who might have forgotten,
about why this history is so important
to our democracy"
Both Kahn and Massek, who believes
that by the 1970s, unlike in 1960, Gun
ning knew her songs would outlive her,

offer lofty goals for Precious Memories.
Kahn says he hopes that people say
that Gunning "was someone just like
me, and look what she did! If she could
do that,

I

could do that... Sarah really
a lot of education
or have

didn't have

lot of privilege

and yet she became
extraordinary influential force. Sue
Massek is just one of the young artists,
a

an

primarily

young

women,

that

Sarah

created possibilities for."
Massek, who expresses her deep ap
preciation for Kahn's work with her, also
hopes her play will inspire people:
The ultimate goal,

the altruistic goal or
that's beyond me, is that it can
be
something that will be a tool for people
who are working for social justice and
the goal

they will help people with analysis, espe

cially working people. ..If they could un
derstand her very down-to-earth analysis
of.
it
is

..where the evil is coming from, I think
could begin a change in people. It just
another tool for that; it's certainly not

itself, but if we can get
out
there doing that kind
enough people
then
work,
of
things can change. You

going

to do it by

Sue Massek as Sarah Ogan
Gunning Sings the
Songs from Precious Memories, An Original
Play by Si Kahn. The album, released on

can't just preach to people. You've got to
give them concrete examples of how you

2015, contains 16 songs, since they
perform an additional five cuts coming
from Jackson and Garland. That makes it

the meantime, Massek will be "trav
eling the country performing the musi
cal, trying to give people a sense of what
life was like in the eastern Kentucky coal

May

1,

the largest compilation of songs associated
with their family. Kafin and Alice Gerrard
join Massek on several songs. The record
ing reached as High as #2 on the FolkDJ

chart, behind John McCutcheon's

Joe

Hill's

can go from here to there.
In

camps during the early 1930s and how,
despite those hard times, people found
ways to make life better for themselves
and others.

"q£

�H
HI

^gemmm
&gt;

^VINTAGE INSTRUMENTS
2JJ Butler

Brooklyn

Street

11217
f7im 237-6092
iVT

RETROFRET

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

�Reviews
Lead Belly:
The Smithsonian Folkways Collection

Hitler)
Big Fat Woman
(Bellevue Hospital Blues)

Been So Long

Disc Four:

Goose

Folk Songs
Boll Weevil

Ha This

a

WNYC,

outro)

Way

WNYC,

of

America

Yellow Gal
Leaving Blues

(Grey
HaIrene

Folk Songs of America

(Almost Day Blues in My Kitchen, Blues
In My Dining Room
Went Up On the
Mountain
Good Morning Blues
Baby,
Don't You Love Me No More T. B. Blues
I

Smithsonian Folkways SFW40201
Disc One:
The Bourgeois Blues
Fannin Street
The Mid
(Mister Tom Hughes Town)
Black Girl
John Henry
night Special
Pick
(Where Did You Sleep Last Night)
a Bale of Cotton
Take This Hammer
Cotton Fields
Old Riley
Here, Rat
Rock Island Line
The Gallis
tler, Here

Pole (The Maid Freed From the Gallows)
Ha-Ha This a Way
Boll
Sukey Jump
Weevil
Scottsboro Boys
Governor O.

Allen

Governor Pat Neff
There's a
Man Going Around Taking Names
On
a
You Can't
Monday (Almost Done)
Lose Me, Cholly
Keep Your Hands Off
K.

Her

We Shall Be Free

Disc Two:

Alabama Bound
Almost Day (Christ
mas Is a-Coming)
Fiddler's Dram
Green Corn
Sally Walker
Bring Me a
Little Water, Silvy
Julie Ann Jolmson
Linin' Track
Whoa, Back, Buck
Shorty

Ham and Eggs (Make It on the
George
Side of the Road)
Moanin'
Out on the
Western Plains
Noted Rider
Meeting
at the
Building (All Over Tlais World)

Good, Good, Good (Talking, Preaching
Through the Valley) Ain't
You Glad (The Blood Done Signed My
I'm So Glad, I Done Got Over
Name)
We Shall Walk

The

Hindenburg Disaster

Haul Away Joe
Lee

Jean Harlow

Old Man
Laura

Ella Speed

Sweet Jenny
Queen Mary

Disc Three:

Good Morning Blues
Sail On, Little
Girl (You Can't Mistreat Me)
Easy Rid

Irene
If It Wasn't For
outro)
Dicky
What's You Gonna Do When the World's
On Fire
Rock Me (Hide Me in Thy Bo
Packin' Trunk Blues
som)
Leaving
Blues
How Come You Do Me Like You
Do?
One Dime Blues
I'm Going to Buy
You a Brand New Ford
Jail-House Blues
(It Was Early One Morning)
Shout On
I'm
All
Out
and
Come
Down)
(Honey,
and Sit Down Beside Me

Red River

Yes, I Was Standing in the Bottom
When It's Springtime in the Rockies
Ain't Going Down to the Well No More

Go
2)
Every Time I Go Out
Old
Hannah
Black Betty
Down,
No
body Knows You When You're Down and

(Version

Out
Stewball
Ain't It a Shame to Go
Fishin' On a Sunday
Relax Your Mind
Princess Elizabeth
Silver City Bound
The Titanic
House of the Rising Sun

It's Tight Like That

Diggin' My Potatoes
Backwater
Springtime in the Rockies
Blues
Didn't Old John Cross the Water
De Kalb Blues (Ain't Gonna Drink No
More)
They Hung Him on the Cross

(Version 1)
They Hung Him
Cross (Version 2)
In the World

on the

Lead Belly: The Smithsonian

Folkways Col
2015 set celebrating the music of
Huddie Ledbetter (c. 1888-1949), is cast
in the basic mold as
and has been ad
a

vertised

as

a

companion

to

that same

label's acclaimed 2012 Woody Guthrie
set entitled Woody At 100. Both releases
were not only issued by the same com
pany, but they also claim the same pro
ducers (Jeff Place and Robert Santelli),

Poor Howard
Duncan and Brady
How Long, How Long
T. B. Blues
Jim Crow Blues
John Hardy
Pigmeat
Outskirts of Town
In the
4, 5, and 9

mastering engineer (Pete Reiniger), and
director (both sets were designed by
the Visual Dialogue company's Fritz Klaetke, who won a GRAMMY for his work

Evening (When the Sun Goes Down)
Red Cross Store Blues
Diggin' My Po
tatoes
Blind Lemon
When a Man's a
Alberta
Ex
Long Way From Home

on the Guthrie package).
This is a vet
eran team, with many historical record
ing releases and music-related museum
exhibits to their collective credit.

er

Na
cerpt from "The Lonesome Train"
tional Defense Blues
Hitler Song (Mr.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

hardcover book) samples of his idiosyn
cratic prose writing and visual art. Since
Lead Belly is principally remembered
for his music, the newer Smithsonian
Folkways set commendably features a

generous selection

of recordings
108 in
made by Lead Belly for three labels
(Folkways, Stinson, and Disc) as well as
for the Library of Congress; the set's five
CDs effectively illustrate the musician's
stylistic range and diverse repertoire.
The set features 16 previously unreleased
recordings, four of wlaich were of Lead
Belly compositions never before released
in any form. (By contrast,
Woody At 100
included 57 tracks in all, 21 of which
were previously unreleased recordings,
with six of those 21 constituting neverbefore-heard original songs by Guthrie.)
all

Among the recordings in the Lead Belly
performances of songs
associated with the musician
some of
set are inspired

Disc Five:

lection,

from his recording career over three CDs
as well as (in that set's
154-page 12" x 12"

art

Woody At 100 explored the entirety of
Guthrie's work, incorporating selections

which

he

composed

("The

Bourgeois

Blues," "Bring Me a Little Water, Sylvy,"
"Cotton Fields," "Alberta"), and some of
which he adapted from other composers
("Rock Island Line") or from traditional
sources ("The Midnight Special," "Irene
[Goodnight Irene]," "Black Girl [Where
Did You Sleep Last Night]," "The Gal
lis Pole," "Pick a Bale of Cotton," and
"Black Betty").
Whether written or ar
Lead
ranged by
Belly, these songs have
been embraced over the decades by in
numerable music-makers, from interna
tional pop music legends to heroes of
various roots music subgenres to local
singers and strummers. Yet other musi
cians' interpretations of such songs gen
erally lack the irrepressible combination
of

touglmess and tenderness present

in

Lead Belly's versions; indeed, one of his
principal gifts was infusing his music

with contrasting elements.
Also included on the

Folkways
ment

set are recordings

Lead

Smithsonian
that

docu
rendi

Belly's passionate
work songs (including

tions of various
"Linin' Track"),

songs (such as
blues composi
[When the Sun
gospel material
("There's a Man Going Around Taking
Names") and songs for children (most fa
mously, "Ha-Ha TJiis Way"). Represent
ed on the set as well are various topical
prison
Monday"), and
tions ("In the Evening
Goes Down]") as well as
"On

a

songs, whether prompted by civil rights
incidents ("Scottsboro Boys"), celebri
ties

Harlow"), notorious figures
Song [Mr. Hitler]"), or ephem-

("Jean

("Hitler

�eral events

national

of

or

international

interest

Lead Belly
("Queen Mary").
two
of
the
set's
other
composed
topical
"Governor Pat Neff" and "Gov
songs
ernor O. K. Allen"
to thank the gover
nors who, appreciating his music, par
doned him for his crimes and freed him
from prison. As evidenced by many of

his songs (whether topical or not) show
cased on the set, Lead Belly had the rare
ability to turn rough-and-tumble per

sonal experiences and observations into

songs of universal interest and relevance.
Lead

Smithsonian

The

Belly:

Collection bears

witness

to

Folkways

the

striking

range and marked contrasts in the

sician's

repertoire,

style, and songcraft.
the

mu

voice,
A

excitement on most

performance
significant part of
of the

recordings

Lead Belly's own 12-string guitar ac
companiment, played with dexterous yet
is

firm

technique

that

was paradoxically

both influential and inimitable. The set,
though, includes a few a cappella record
ings, proving that he could command at
tention and generate excitement without
his

rhythmically intense, hypnotic guitar.
Additionally, on CDs 4 and 5 the listener
can hear some of Lead Belly's spoken re

flections uttered during two radio show
broadcasts from 1941 and also during
his "last sessions" informally recorded
in 1948 by Frederic Ramsey.
Such com
ments by Lead Belly open windows into
his formative years as well as provide
clues as to his music tastes.
the

Happily,

mastering

throughout

Smithsonian Folkways Col
lection does justice to this historically
Lead Belly: The

significant yet ultimately timeless mu
sic. These recordings
some of which

were made under less than ideal, and
even difficult, conditions
have never

sounded

so

magnificent.

The set's 140-page book compiles es
says that set the recordings into various
contexts (by Santelli, Place, and Lead

Belly's niece Tiny Robinson), helpful
track-by-track notes (by Place), a discography, a bibliography, and various
illustrations (a gallery of album covers,
for instance) and photographs (such as

a rare
color photograph of the musi
cian, suffering from ALS, in 1949 dur
ing his final days). Taken together, the
5 CDs and the book survey Lead Belly's
life and his vast repertoire in a compel
ling, memorable, and moving manner,
and the set offers the fullest portrayal
of this great songster thus far presented
in a single release.
Since a truly com
plete package of Lead Belly's record

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ings (combining his entire output on
"folk" labels such as Folkways and also
his many field recordings for represen
tatives of the Library of Congress and
other documentarians, along with his
work for such commercial companies as
the American Record Company, Victor,

materialize

and Capitol)

to

in the

Lead Belly: The

is unlikely
foreseeable future,

Smithsonian Folkways Collection is likely
to remain the essential and central com
pilation of Huddie Ledbetter's music
for years to come.

TED OLSON
To

order:

folkways.si.edu/leadbelly

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Affordable, professional,
handcrafted banjos

Made using
100% Native

Appalachian
Hardwoods.
WWW. PISGAH BANJOS .COM

�McMaken
plays the fiddle all through.
plays predominantly rhythmic support on
the lap dulcimer on 10 tracks, switching to

combination of rhythm and melodic dou
bling on mandolin on the remaining five.
a

It's quite remarkable, the depth and full
ness of sound the two of them achieve
on

numerous

tracks

this

throughout

re

cording. When they do, the duet seem
ingly expands to a trio or even a quartet
sound. The tracks that create that rich
effect are almost entirely those combin
ing the fiddle and the dulcimer. "Apple
Blossoms," the opener, is representative
and a fine introduction to their sound.
On one hand you have lots of low-string
drones (F#) and a melody largely played

middle register. How much of that
is Cade's own interpretation is unclear.
He gets his version from Kentucky fiddler
in the

Isham Monday by way of Bruce Greene,
so that may be their take on it.

Regard

less, Cade gets a thick resonant sound and
solid drive from his fiddle. On the other
hand is McMaken's dulcimer, which re
minds me of the playing of Irish guitarist
From it we get a propulsive,
attack
but also a gap-filling drone
ringing
that makes it an album highlight.
In a similar vein are "Betty Baker," also

John Doyle.

with an F# drone,

"Pretty

Betty

Mar

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tin," which has an interesting section on
which the dulcimer plays a low part, and

"Flight of the Wild Geese," a lively tune
drawn from Byard Ray. Any one of them
would have to be judged a highlight. So,
too, "Boatsman," which is not only lyri
cally played in a "Bonaparte's Retreat"like manner, but benefits from being in
one of the few slower settings
The fiddle and mandolin tracks tend
to be more sparse. That is the nature of
the

mandolin.

strument,

Played

as is the

as

a

rhythm in

case at times here, the

mandolin doesn't ring

as much, leaving
hence a sparer sound. Mc
Maken, however, opts to play most of

more gaps

accompaniament as a dual lead. That
doubling does make the leads more excit
ing but at the further expense of a rhythm
background. To achieve the best effect,
his

the recording balance needs to be right,
with both instruments distinct.
Cade and McMaken only achieve
Unfortunately,
that balance on two tracks, "Far On the
Mountain" and "Hog-Eyed Man." While
the others present a nice contrast and are
not without interest, those two rise to a
level among the best tracks on what is a
fine recording overall.
BILL WAGNER
To

order: cdbaby.com/

cd/hogeyedman

�repeatedly how much what

sounded like

I

was doing

was from that country.)
Then there's what the drones,
especially
those coming from Hindustani classical vo
calists, have meant for the American mini
malists such as Lamonte Young or
Terry
Riley, who made their most radical musical
statements half a century ago. Among their

to

it

contemporaries was North Carolina native
Henry Hynt, who saw honky-tonk country
and Appalachian fiddle tunes as obvious

points for conscious avantgarde exploration. Though his recordings
didn't start seeing the light of
day until
about 15 years ago, they date back to the
early 1960s and show somebody who was

jumping-off

considering not only other places for folk
music to go, but a way to make minimalism
less academic. It was Hynt,
alongside the hi

lariously and righteously disrespectful Holy
Modal Rounders, who truly embodied the
term "acid folk." While Flynt was raw and
meditative, the Rounders at their furthestout were a barely
functioning carnival, at
times reverent, at others turning old-time
fiddle tunes into a disorienting
glop.
All of this brings us to the Black
Twig

Pickers.

First of all, two of the members,
Gangloff and Nathan Bowles, also
perform with Pelt, an experimental drone
and ambiance-based collective
prone to let

Mike

ting recording environments become part
mix. Meanwhile, the more recent

of the

addition Sally Ann Morgan, who's placed
in fiddle contests and
played stages at oldtime festivals throughout the Southeast,
naturally allows BTP to embody a few dif

ferent

scenes easily. Here's a group that,
through its exploration of meter-less drone
in one setting, and
straight-up fiddle break
downs in another, is ultimately able to see
where the two converge. Those results are
perfectly illustrated here, in the quartet's
first collaboration with
Brooklyn-based gui
tarist Steve Gunn. Gunn, whose own work
both as a solo artist and in connection with
drummer Steve Truscinski, guitarist Cian

a

unshackle old-time from the "old." After
suspended, drone-based fiddle introduc

tion from Morgan, the band kicks into the

melody, sounding as if they're playing in
the darkest of caverns. The
pulse is slow,

deliberate,

experi

mental composition as natural as
anything
Flynt or the Rounders pulled off.
But the album's penultimate and final
tunes are where the Gunn /BTP connection
finds its true footing. Gunn's
"Trailways
Ramble" has his vocals, which
always seem
like a natural extension of his
guitar play
ing, while jaw and mouth harps, fiddle, and
banjo percolate under a single chord. But
the centerpiece of this release, and the en
tirety of Side Two of the vinyl, is the full-on

Gunn /Twigs collaboration that
gives this
release its title. Not unlike the
recordings
of psych-folk one-offs the
Serpent Power's
single-chord jams recorded for San Fran
cisco's KPFA in 1970, Gunn and the
Twigs

develop a single-chord raga style. There's
several minutes of tension before the tune
unfolds, driven by Gunn's finger-picked
open-tuned groove, a harmonium-like
shruti box providing constant sustain, ban
jo, fiddle drone, gongs, and singing bowls.
Here then is the Pelt influence,
performed
by a band as comfortable as it comes with
Virginia-area old-time fiddle tunes, per
fectly in sync with Gunn's minimal, modal
direction. So, is this an old-time album? Ar
guably, it's as old-time as it gets, cruising
through and then ultimately past the tunes

themselves, discovering the original pulse

that relates music from every
region of the
world, conjuring Rajasthan, Central Asian
steppes, Tuareg lute players from Niger,
and Sherman Hammons impressionism in

ry near

To

Seasonal

neatly divided into
halves. The first three tunes find the BTP
leading the show with original composi
tion "Dive for the Pearl," which involves
the

Hire

is

repetition of old-time, the right-hand

drive of Bowles' banjo, and Isak Howell's

mouth harp blowing to the fore. Yet their
version of the standard "Don't Let Your
Deal Go Down" is a fine example of how

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Morgan's

cymbal provides an undercurrent of dan

equal measure.

traditional acoustic music
enough
for some time, which makes his connection
to Black Twig Pickers seem natural (he's al
ready recorded an album with Gangloff).

foreboding.

ger, while Morgan's vocals seem to bounce
off the walls behind the band. Here then is
an example of old-time music as

Nugent, and long-time avant folk lap steel
player Mike Cooper, has hovered in territo
to

and

"Cardinal 51" owes its existence to "Trou
ble in Mind," but there's
something odd
happening here. Bowles' struck bowed

BRUCE MILLER

order: thrilljockey.com

Note to Artists and Record Companies
Please send all material for review to the
OTH (PO Box 61679, Durham, NC 27715).
Please do not send to individual review
ers. What gets reviewed is determined
at the discretion of the OTH
according to
space available, balance of old and new,
and compatibility with our mission. We
cannot review everything that comes in

nor guarantee that because we received it
we will review it. We do not return mate
rials to the sender. Thanks!

�not only describes the dances, but she traces
the evolution of these Appalachian tradi

tions and provides well-researched histori
cal background for each community to help

put these dance traditions in context. Nu
merous quotes from local participants give
a human voice to these stories and help to

illustrate the

of these dances to

importance
communities in which they take place.
Spalding first focuses on the dance tra
ditions of northeastern Tennessee with a
profile of the Beechwood Family Music
Center, a family-oriented music venue
the

near Kingsport, in Fall Branch, Tennes
see. Here on Friday and Saturday nights
in the late 1980s, she encountered flatfooters, two-steppers, and square danc

ers filling the dance floor. Founded in
1982, the Beechwood Family Music Cen
ter and other music and dance venues
in the region (such as the Carter Family

Fold) reflect the renewed interest in oldtime music and dance that came with the
folk music revival of the 1960s and '70s.
Spalding profiles two dance communi
ties in Southwest Virginia. One of these

Martinsville, where the African
American community continued the tra
dition of house dances into the 1960s. This
community's rich tradition of music and
dance included a Black Fiddlers' Conven
is

in

tion that started in 1928 (seven years be
fore the first Fiddlers

Convention

at

Ga

lax, Virginia, in 1935) and lasted into the
1940s. Spalding's informants differentiate

the African American square dance tradi
tion from that of European Americans by

noting the emphasis on improvisational
percussive footwork (buckdancing) with
one's partner that took place during the
course of the black dances.
To the west, in the coalfields of South
west Virginia, Spalding encountered a dif

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ferent dance tradition in Russell County.
Here, in the community of Dante, at both
black and white dances, the dancing re
flects the influence of urban dance styles,

brought to the region with the coal mining
industry in the early twentieth century. In
the mid-twentieth century, when Dante's
African American community gathered to
dance at Mr. Perry's Sweet Shop, the danc
ing consisted of jazz-era swing dances,
such as the Charleston and the lindy-hop.
These dance events were also attended by
whites, who likewise incorporated some
of these modern styles into their own
dancing. This can be seen in the predomi
nantly white dances that began to be held
in Dante's volunteer firehall and com
munity center in the 1980s. The dancing
consisted entirely of flatfooting (or buckdancing), couple dances, and cakewalks,
but no square dances. Spalding observed
that the dancers often flatfooted as cou
ples, rather than as individuals, and she
suggests that this reflects the legacy of the
earlier African American couple dances.
In eastern Kentucky, dancing was pro
moted at the Pine Mountain Settlement
School as part of the progressive era edu
cation and recreation movement of the
early 20th century. This is where Cecil
Sharp and Maud Karpeles encountered
"set running" [Southern square dances]
in 1917
the dance that they described

and published the following year as the
"Running Set." The dance repertoire at
Pine Mountain reflected the Anglo-cen
tric bias of the school's founders, and it

included English country dances, mor

ris dances, and sword dances. Spald
ing notes that the later dance programs

Berea College in Kentucky and the
John C. Campbell Folkschool in western
North Carolina drew largely from this
at

Anglo-centric dance repertoire that was
introduced at Pine Mountain.
In addition to Pine Mountain, Spalding

profiles the dance traditions of two other
communities in eastern Kentucky. One of
these is Hoedown Island at the Natural
Bridge State Resort Park in Powell Coun
ty, where from 1962 until 2006, square
dances and freestyle clogging took place

the dance pavilion at this summer
tourist resort. The other is the Carcas
sonne square dance in Letcher County,
Kentucky (see "The Square Dance at
Carcassonne Kentucky," Old-Time Her
ald, Vol. 2, No. 7). This dance, started in
1967 as a revival of the house dances that
existed before the Second World War,
has been a regional tradition for close to
in

years, making it the longest running
community square dance in Kentucky.
Its future, however, is now uncertain due
to recent declining attendance.
While each of these six community pro
files can stand on its own, together they re
50

veal the diversity as well as the common
alities and continually evolving nature of
the dance traditions in rural Appalachia.
They illustrate the cultural exchange be

tween African Americans and European
Americans and the influences of the folk
dance

movement, industrialization, and

the folk music revival. Spalding's

study,

however, does more than simply describe
the dance traditions of these communities.
It reveals much about the broader history
and

culture

communities.

of these
I

rural

Appalachian

highly recommend Susan

Spalding's Appalachian Dance, not only to
those with an interest in traditional dance,
but also to anyone with an interest in the
traditional culture of Appalachia.
PHIL JAMISON
To order:

.press.uillinois.edu

�Smithsonian Folkways Presents Uniquely
American Ballads of Tragedy, Murder, and Scandal

1

CLASSIC AMERICAN BALLADS
from SMITHSONIAN FOLKWAYS

Smithsonian Folkways

Born of the British ballad, its American offspring was the blank canvas for all
type of tale,
the more calamitous or scandalous, the better. Jesse James and
the
Kid, train wrecks
Billy
and hurricanes, the Titanic and Tom Dooley, fatal lovers' quarrels and
foiling the devil, all
and more were normal fare, served up in a song. Classic American Ballads is 25 tracks of
time-worn tragedy drawn from the deep fount of the Smithsonian Folkways archives.
74 minutes, 40-page booklet with extensive notes and photos.

Enter code OTH BALLADS at

folkways.si.edu through 12/31/2015
to save 20% on CDs or album downloads
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
Section with Illegible Text

�4airb ua in 2016!

AUGUSTA
HERITAGE CENTEB
of Davis &lt;%Elkins College
Slkim,

&lt;ll/eAt

tyityMcu

2016 SUMMER SESSIONS
12

tfidyslO- oQugmt
ARTS, CRAFT &amp; FOLKLORE

IRISH WEEK

CLASSES- ALL WEEKS!

July 24-29

-August

July 10

12

BLUEGRASS WEEK

CAJUN &amp; CREOLE WEEK

July 31

August

5

EARLY COUNTRY MUSIC

OLD-TIME WEEK, VOCAL

WEEK

WEEK AND AMERICAN

1Q15

Jul

VERNACULAR DANCE WEEK
BLUES &amp; SWING WEEK

August

7-12

July 17-22

AUGUSTA FESTIVAL
(c/lagMt 10-12]
Featuring

a

SQUARE DANCE on Friday evening;

juried CRAFT SHOW, DEMONSTRATIONS and
PERFORMANCES
and

all day

Saturday

FESTIVAL CONCERT

SING on Sunday

in

in

Elkins City Park

evening; and

a

GOSPEL

morning.

Watch for details on the 201

6

OCTOBER OLD-TIME

WEEK and FIDDLERS' REUNION next October!

BHOOipiI
vrandQM;.|^S^.
/&gt;/^\|

t

V

iwwisi

Culture
Virginia

c

History
v.
omminsiomMl-

ON THE ARTS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FOR MORE INFORMATION

OR TO REGISTER,

VISIT
"WJ

WWW AUGUSTAHERITAGECENTER
OR CALL

304-637-1209

ORG

V

ARTWORKS.

National

Endowment

for the Arts

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12145">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 14, Number 2 (November 2015)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12146">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12147">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 14, Number 2 (November 2015)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Birthplace of Country Music Museum,” Roy Andrade&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Tales from the ‘Woods, Part 13: Burlington,” by Walt Koken&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Mark Ward: Multifaceted Luthier,” by Christian Wig&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“An Interview with Alan Jabbour,” by Brian Lockman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“There Are Still a Lot of Records You Haven’t Heard,” by Dan Margolies&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Bill Richardson; Myron Price; and Keith Johnson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12148">
                <text>2015</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="1632">
        <name>2010s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2762">
        <name>2015</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5504">
        <name>Alan Jabbour</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5909">
        <name>Bill Richardson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5501">
        <name>Birthplace of Country Music Museum</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5505">
        <name>Brian Lockman</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2427">
        <name>Bristol, Tennessee</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5507">
        <name>Burlington, Vermont</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5508">
        <name>Chittenden County, Vermont</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5503">
        <name>Christian Wig</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5506">
        <name>Dan Margolies</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5497">
        <name>Highwoods String Band</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6466">
        <name>Keith Johnson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="3973">
        <name>Luthier</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5502">
        <name>Mark Ward</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="6465">
        <name>Myron Price</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5493">
        <name>Roy Andrade</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2452">
        <name>Sullivan County, Tennessee</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5460">
        <name>Walt Koken</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2515" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3441">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/f379cfc62461dfd28d52cc12c645a4d7.pdf</src>
        <authentication>6726a83c9c18c72ebb55180fcaa28ddc</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12149">
                    <text>$3.50

The OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Feb.-Apr. 1988

Spring

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

DYKES MAGIC CITY TRIO

�FESTIVALS!

CONVENTIONS!
are
Just Around
Advertise

The Corner!

Your
In The

OLD-TIME
Reasonable

Event

HERALD
Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333
for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
FEATURES
DYKES MAGIC CITY TRIO

DON'T YOU REMEMBER THE TIME
FREENY 1913

SUMMER
by

1987

10

IN FAT CITY

22

Jenny Cleland Vittek

BENJAMIN FRANKLIN JARRELL 1933
by

SAMUEL CARLTON

Pat Conte

by

A

4

Charles Wolfe

by

1987

HAROLD HAUSENFLUCK, YOUNG OLDTIMER
by

BUY OR BYE!

WILLARD WATSON: OLD-TIME FLATFOOT

DANCER

18

Phil Jamison

Workshop

20

LITTLE ROCK AREA

Here &amp; There
by

David

R.

by

1

27

Robert Cogswell

SOME SAN DIEGO OLD-TIME NOTES
by

26

Peterson

THE CUMBERLAND MUSIC TOUR

Ask

12

Mac Ben ford

The Dance Beat
by

31

Emily Fine

Issues In Old-Time Music
by

30

Alice Gerrard &amp; Brad Leftwich

28

Lou Curtiss

Uncle Harold

36

Walter Raleigh Babson 1900

1987

Ola Belle Reed Fund

George Lowrey 1927

11

34

1987

11

Notice To Subscribers

17

Award

11

Tommy Jarrell

FROM THE EDITOR

2

LETTERS

2

CLASSIFIED

17

RECORD &amp; CASSETTE TAPE REVIEWS

39

�FROM
THE
EDITOR
Patty Hall, our correspondent in and
Nashville, reports that The
Bristol Sessions has been nominated by

around
the

Arts

National Academy of Recording
and Sciences
(NARAS) for a

Grammy Award in two categories: Best

Album Notes (by Charles Wolfe), and
Best Historical Album (co-produced by
Kyle

Young

Country

and

Music

Bob

Pinson

of

the

Also
Foundation).
Best Album Notes is

nominated for
Nolan Porterfield for ]immie Rodgers On
Record: America's Blue Yodeler.
People can tune in on March

2

to the

nationally telecast 30th anniversary
presentation of the Grammy Awards

from Radio City Music Hall to see the
results.
The best way to give traditional music
a
better chance at winning Grammy
Awards is for people who qualify to
become voting members of NARAS.
who is a voting member of
Patty,

NARAS

as

well

as

a

NARAS Craft

Committee member (members who are
particularly knowledgeable in certain
categories), tells us that the general
requirements for membership include
having performed on, written the music
for, or produced or annotated (written
liner notes for) several cuts or albums.
She says, however, that people may

obtain
ments

specific

membership

require

writing NARAS National
Headquarters, 303 N. Glen Oaks Blvd.,
Burbank, CA 91502, or by calling them
at 2 1 3-849- 1313. They may refer you to
your nearest local chapter.
Benefits of NARAS membership
include not only being able to nominate
and vote for your favorite traditional
artist, and attend the annual telecast
show of the Grammy Awards, but also
opportunities to purchase discounted
albums, cassettes, and CDs of all kinds.
by

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Just received Vol. 1, No. 2. What a
fine magazine. I look forward to every
issue. Thanks for putting it together for

old-time music lovers. I started
playing guitar in 1953 and bought my
first 5-string banjo in 1956. 1 played
bluegrass for 12 years and during that
time 1 had heard some old-time and
us

claw

hammer

banjo

playing

but

I

was

I
thought that
very narrow-minded-was "junk." If it wasn't Scruggs-style it
just wasn't banjo playing. I developed
an index finger problem in 1968 and
gave up banjo until 1984, at which time

Bill

Mansfield came to Salisbury for

a

solo concert. I was greatly inspired by
Bill's playing. I rushed out and bought an
open-back banjo, practiced a lot, then
up for a year, convinced I could
never break old habits and get moving on
Then I went up to Mt.
the "downstroke."
gave

and had a short
Airy
lesson from Terri McMurray, saw loads
of banjo pickers and left there eaten up
with inspiration. At this writing I'm still
for

convention

a

and

practicing

having

fun.

I

haven't

made my debut yet.
I
would like to say I have found a
whole new world of music I never knew
existed. I enjoy it more than any music I
have ever heard. I still listen to bluegrass
and sit in on picking sessions with my
guitar, but my real love is old-time

those dyedin-the-wool
bluegrass pickers, don't
thumb your nose at old-time music. I'm
not trying to convert anyone, but open
up your mind and let it come into your
heart. It's good-time music.
just received my first album of
Tommy Jarrell playing fiddle, and Kyle
Creed playing banjo-June Apple. I love
Kyle's style.
Folklore
Yadkin
I
belong to the
Society. I just can't wait until the
festivals start up in the spring. Thank
you and keep up the good work.
music. So

I

would say to

all

I

Dick Jones
Granite Quarry, NC

Festival Cancelled:

on the birth of this
new
magazine. I've been waiting a
great
time for a thing like this to
long
long,

Congratulations

cancel the
&amp;. Dance
Convention which was to have been
held Sept. 16-18, 1988 at Glen Maury
Park in Buena
Vista, Va. We feel that we
lack sufficient organizational strength to
properly administer our festival.
We had two wonderful festivals and
have received much support from our
regret

I

that

we

must

Rockbridge Mountain Music

happen!
Since my two visits to the "heart of

Galax" in 1984 and
1986, my
enthusiasm for your beautiful trad

music has been growing and
growing. Thanks to the help of some
great friends from the Galax area I've
been able to collect a lot of your good
music. This new magazine provides me
itional

musicians around the
country, and the National Endowment
for the Arts. We expect to maintain our
non-profit organization and to become
involved with ongoing local
more
and
musical
events,
possibly, to
festival. At
another
eventually present
the present time we plan a potluck
music and dance party for the afternoon
community,

with

the

double-decker

pavilion,

Maury Park in Buena Vista, Va. Watch
the Old-Time Herald for further details.
We would like to thank all of you for
your help and support.
Mike Seeger

Lexington, VA

Correction:
Two small points with regard to your
obituary on Fred Price. The photograph
of Fred which you published was taken
by Sylvia Pitcher in September, 1980,
and appeared in Old Time Music issue
No. 35, alongside my interview with
second point is where
The
Fred.
that Fred played with
states
article
your
his mother and father, "both talented

musicians." In the above-mentioned
interview I asked Fred if his father
played an instrument, to which he
replied, "No, he couldn't even sing, but

oh, he loved the fiddle the best of any
thing he heard in his whole life." In reply
to the same question regarding his
mother Fred stated, "She picked the
banjo, one of the best claw hammer
banjo players I've ever heard."

Carolina

Western

information

More

can

singings
Sacred

be

Henry Bradley
Seattle, WA
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

think you are doing

a

found

Newsletter,

Harp

Thanks

concern

again

for

the
traditional music.
in

in

in

great job.

I

dance--

a

in

festival is
September.

nation-wide
the

National
551,

P.O.

Box

your

care

and

preservation

of

Laura Boosinger
The Painless String Band

its

I

on

Temple, GA 30179.

I've been meaning to write for a month
in praise of the quality of your magazine

especially like the articles on

long and

University

This
N.C.
generally the 3rd Saturday

Cullowhee.

Frank Weston

feature articles. Wolfe on
Samantha Bumgarner is terrific, and if
you've a string of those lined up I bet you
do well. Also I am pleased to see fine
opinionated stuff that should generate
some first-rate letters.

a

Thanks for your mention of old-time
music in western North Carolina. We
are fortunate to live in such a rich and
musically diverse area. One correction,
however. Western N.C. is home to
Christian Harmony singing, not Sacred
Harp singing. Although "Sacred Harp"
has become the generic term for shaped
note singing, there is a distinct difference
between the two. The names refer to two
different songbooks whose style and
In
different.
are
markedly
practice
western North Carolina we sing from
Christian Harmony, which uses William
Walker's seven-shape system of shaped
notes. Annual singings are still held and
most often led by singing master Quay
Smathers. Singings in Etowah, N.C. are
held at the Etowah Elementary School
the first Sundays in May and September.
Our oldest continuing singing is held the
second Sunday in September at the
Morning Star Methodist Church in
Canton, N.C. Another singing of note,
Sacred Harp and
which includes
Christian
singing, is held
Harmony
at
Mountain
Day
Heritage
during

Glen

London, England

and

additional information.

lot of

Theo Lissenberg
Haarlem, The Netherlands

and evening of Saturday, Sept. 17, 1988,
at

a

wish you and the magazine
happy life.
I

Weaverville, NC

topic often left behind

or in the wayback pages of many of the magazines and
trade journals.

Trina Royar

Baltimore, MD

The

Old-Time

Herald welcomes

letters.

They should be typed or neatly written, and
signed. They may be edited and we will print
them according to space available.― Ed.

�DYKES

MAGIC CITY TRIO
by

spring of 1927, commercial
music
was not quite four years
country
old. Its big stars were the string bands led
by Charlie Poole, Gid Tanner, Fiddlin'
John Carson, Burnett and Rutherford,
and Al Hopkins' Hill Billies. Waiting in
the wings were the great vocalists that
would be recorded later that summer in
Ralph Peer's famous Bristol session-the Carter Family, Jimmie Rodgers, Pop
Stoneman. But for now the music of the
In

the

Charles

Wolfe

day was still

string-band fare, and three
locations were emerging as hotbeds of
the style-at least as far as recording
companies were concerned. One of these
was Atlanta, home base for Gid Tanner,
Clayton McMichen, the Skillet Lickers,
and the Georgia Yellow Hammers. A
second was the Galax area, home base
for Ernest Stoneman, Henry Whitter, A1
and the Jenkins-Jarrell
The third was the Tri-Cities
area
the
of upper east Tennessee,
bustling triangle of Kingsport-Johnson

Hopkins,
families.

an urban

City-Bristol
that

could

conglomerate

boast a larger
than any other city in the

1927

in

population
Appalachians.

By the spring of 1927, a number of
musicians from the latter area already
had recorded successfully: Uncle Am
fiddler from
Stuart, the champion
nearby Morristown who had recorded
for Vocalion; the Roe Brothers, from
Bristol, who had recorded for Columbia;

Fiddlin'

Cowan

Powers,

from

Virginia, an early hit for
Victor; the Johnson Brothers, Paul and
Charles, from Johnson City, who played
Hawaiian guitar and sang the blues; and
Charley Bowman, the Johnson City
fiddler who played lead on many of the
early Hill Billies records. But one of the
best
and most popular in terms of
record sales
was a three-piece string
band led by Kingsport fiddler John R.

autoharp

consisted of Dykes,
Mahaffey, and

"Hub"

player

named

his
an

Cleo

It

guitarist

Myrtle

Vermillion. It was one of the most
popular dance bands in east Tennessee,
and it went by the name of Dykes Magic
City Trio.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Courtesy

Dykes.

McNutt

Dungannon,

L-R: John Dykes,

Myrtle Vermillion, Hub Mahaffey

�That March of 1927 they journeyed to
New York to record 14 sides for the
Brunswick-Vocalion company, sides
that constitute some of the earliest and
best examples of east Tennessee
band
indeed Appalachian
string
music. Though people in the mountains
in the 1920s certainly knew of the band,
and though record collectors have for
years found hundreds of copies of their
bestselling 78s in attics and flea markets,
modern fans of old-time music knew
little about the band itself until recently.
For a time, some speculated that the
in
the
title was
City"
"Magic
Birmingham, often called that; but
finally in one of Mike Seeger's interviews
with Dock Boggs, who often performed
with Dykes, a reference was made to "old
man John Dykes," and researchers were
pointed in the right direction. The Magic
City of the name was Kingsport, then (in
1927) one ofthe new, "planned" cities of
Appalachia, a booming town in which
the

new

industrialism

of

the

1920s

merged with the older traditions of the
an
It
was
surrounding mountains.
appropriate base for the Magic City trio

recordings

another

merging

cumbersome

time.

expensive, and
be chosen to
could
only
record. The auditions had been held in
February 1927 at the big, new 100-room
Hotel Norton in Norton, Virginia, and
among the "eight hundred" contestants
was

a

and

few artists

working
farm

talent scounts

in

them sing, and heard A. P. play the
fiddle; they decided they might sign A. P.
as a fiddler, but A. P. would have none of
In the end, three acts
it and stalked out.
from the area were chosen: Dykes,

a
and
banjoist-singer Dock Boggs,
person identified only as "Preacher
Johnson." (I have been unable to trace
Johnson, though he was from Wise
County, Virginia, and apparently did cut

this music only after

a

a

named

young 30-

Myrtle

her little five-bar autoharp from a
local man named McClure, who taught
and composed pieces on the instrument.
The third member of the band was G.
"Hub" Mahaffey, a guitarist and
H.
singer. He was born and reared around

Cleo

McNutt

on

selected to make
representative of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

woman

artists like Mr. and Mrs J. W. Baker of
Falls Branch, Tennessee, all seemed to
use them well before Sara popularized
them on her Victor records.) Myrtle first
married a man named Enochs when she
was 15, and when he died prematurely
she married Schuyler Vermillion and
moved with him to a log cabin over by
Gate City. She was 19. She learned more

of

recording company had heard over
eieht hundred contestants."
audition had been another
That
response to the increasing popularity of
the Tri-States area in old-time music.
Though it is often overshadowed by
Ralph Peer's famous July 1927 audition
for Victor in Bristol, the Brunswick
audition referred to in the Big Stone Gap
article actually preceded it by some six
months. The problem was that instead of
recording on the spot, as Victor did in
Bristol, the rival Brunswick company
then later
and
auditioned,
merely
brought the acts up to New York. This

he

(Just

the news in the

the

1925,

parties up in the valley near Nicklesville.
how or why the autoharp got
started as a folk instrument in this corner
of Virginia is a curious problem that has
yet to be solved; people didn't make
them, as they did hide-head banjos, but
often ordered them from Sears or other
catalogue stores. The Carter Family clan,
which included other early recording

some masters; perhaps they were never
released.) Though in modern times the
sides recorded by Dock Boggs have
overshadowed the efforts of Dykes, in
1927 it was Dykes who was the big star,
obviously better known to the people of
Appalachia than either Boggs or
Preacher Johnson.

Courtesy

recorded.

about

who could play banjo and
who
but
played autoharp with the
guitar
new band. She was born in Scott County
in 1895; her mother was an Addington,
and this related her to Maybelle Carters'
family; another family tie related her to
Sara Carters' family. She grew up with
two of her uncles, both Addingtons, and
from her earliest days of memory played
the autoharp and participated in music

1920s. For example, the July 27, 1927,

He was

There,

new band he called the Magic

old
Vermillion,

year

listened to

issue of the Big Stone Gap Post, in the
rough mining country of southwestern
headlined "Old Fashioned
Virginia,
Dance Friday: Dykes, Famous Fiddler,
"
W ill Furnish Music. The story went on:
R. Dykes, of Kingsport, who is
"J.
nationally known as an old time fiddler,
together with his associates, will furnish
music for a genuine square dance at
Since
Pleasure Island Friday night
the new dancing pavillion has been
erected this summer, this is the first
dance of its kind to be held there. Mr.
Dykes has just returned home from New
York City, where several selections of
'mountain music' were
his
famous

a

City Trio.
One of the members was

tradition and technology.
For a band so obscure to modern fans,
Dykes' trio was often

in

formed

the 1920s he had stopped
the mines and had bought a
the Bloomingdale area near

in

Kingsport.

John Dykes had beaten out for the honor
of recording were A. P. and Sara Carter.

(Brunswick

By

John Dykes,

1927

Dykes was born about 1882, and
spent years working in the mines at
places like Dorchester and Josephine in
Wise County, Virginia. During this time
he also won fame as one of the best
square-dance fiddlers in the region. "He
fiddles to perfection all the old tunes
used for dances at the mountain homes
which are so vividly portrayed in the

novels of John Fox, Jr.," commented a
Wise County newspaper writer of the

Norton, Virginia, but had moved to
Kingsport to work as a carpenter in the
booming construction business there.
He was a slender, handsome man who
had the reputation of being a somewhat
carefree rambler. Though not actual

members of the band, two other men
often worked with the Magic City Trio:
Dock Boggs, the banjoist and singer
from Pardee, Virginia, and a square
dance caller named Kyle Jayne, who
lived around the Bloomingdale area.
(Though it is Dykes who does the square
he could
dance calls on the records
same
at
the
and
call
fiddle
apparently
he preferred to have a full-time
time
set caller when he played big dances.)
Boggs did banjo songs, played with the
band, and did a unique "talking dance,"
where he would get up at one side of the
room and dance across it, talking and
telling a story to illustrate the dance as he
went.
Many of the dances were held in Gate

�As crowds continued to grow, Schuyler

Kingsport, or surrounding
communities. Since none of the

City,

another smaller
house on the farm as a regular dance hall.
This had two big rooms in it, and using it
saved having to drag all the furniture out
of the room of the main house.
Then came February and the band's
audition at Norton. In March they were
invited to come to New York to record,

Vermillion

musicians could drive a car, Myrtle's
husband Schuyler Vermillion became
chauffeur for the band. They played
contests in Mountain City and dances in
Big Stone Gap; they played at the court
house in Gate City, and at rural schoolhouses in Manville. When Schuyler
bought a farm on the Holston River,
they began to .congregate there and to

hold house parties
combination rehersals

that

up

Brunswick

company sent
the company's
expenses for
local contact, Mr. McClure. It was the
start of a grand adventure for them all.
They were to go up with Dock Boggs and
Preacher Johnson, and were to catch the
train at Norton. Boggs' memories of the
and

the

them

were

dances.

and

fixed

Myrtle's daughter, Cleo McNutt, recalls
what went on at one of these:

to

trip, as well as letters Myrtle wrote back
to her husband and daughter, give us an
unusually detailed account of this classic
cultural confrontation, and about the
trials of making records in the 1920s.
Mrytle's first letter was written from
the

Hotel Norton on March

5,

1927:

Dearest Schuyler and all:
We are at the Hotel Norton tonight
got here all right, didn't have any
trouble. We went straight to Mr.
Clure's, and we got our expenses paid
from Mocassin Gap, and they took us
here to the hotel for tonight. Mrs.
Dykes is staying here tonight too. W e
have been practicing some. Mr. Boggs

Courtesy

Cleo

McNutt

is

Hub Mahaffey,

1927

here

him

Let's start

at our
and you had to
done first
get your
the cows taken care of
away and supper over

farm,

house.

It

get your

was

a

chores

children fed and
and the milk put

with. Then you
out a room. Usually there
wasn't much in a room to clear out
old rough floors and pretty rough
walls. But the room was fairly big.
There was a fireplace, and in winter
time or when it was damp down by the
river, you'd build a fire. They'd come
in there, and they'd start playing and
dancing, and when they stopped was
when they dropped. Sometimes it
would be a daylight, about milking
time next morning. And the floor
would get so slick they'd have to throw
stuff on it to keep people from
breaking their necks on it: wet meal or
something. But as soon as it dried,
they'd have to sweep it up and throw
more on. The house would be packed
cleared

full.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

too

he

is

going

with us

tomorrow.
We will leave here on the 6 o'clock
train for Ashland, Ky.; will get there
about 8 o'clock tomorrow night.
We practiced playing in my room
tonight but everybody came up. The
room and the hall was crowded. Dave
Beverley was here. Somebody had hit
in

the back of the head with

a

38

cut

special
of his

a

head

great place

through

in

his

the back
cap.

It

happened this evening on top of the
mountain between here and Jenkins,
much,
Ky. He wasn't complaining
though; he was up here enjoying the
music. Harley Green and Katherine
just begged me to go up to their house
tonight, but they thought we'd better
stay together and practice, as our hotel
bill was paid.

pouring rain here tonight.

It is

am

going

to

take

my

harp

to

I

the
for a

I got it from and swap it
harp. Mr. McClure wrote a
piece and is sending it by me to give
them. He said it wasn't far from the
Brunswick place. So I guess I've wrote
enough as it is close to 12 o'clock and

company
five-bar

we have to get up early.

Yours only,
Myrtle

All of March 6 was taken up by the
train ride to Ashland, and then all of
March 7 and half of March 8 were
occupied by the further trip into New
York City. On the way, the band
continued to practice on the train,

collecting small change in tips from
fascinated passengers. This was good,

because
Central

when

Station,

they

got

into

Grand

was

promptly
rest of their expense
Dykes

robbed of the
money. They found their way to the
Brunswick recording studios, at 799
Seventh Avenue, and reported to the
recording supervisor, James O'Keefe. (It
would be O'Keefe who would later
supervise field trips to Ashland and
Knoxville and become the premier A&amp;.R
man for Brunswick's old-time line.) He
took them over to the nearby Hotel
Cumberland on Broadway, and told

�them to rest up for the next day.
Myrtle's next letter dates from that
night, and describes their reaction to
New York:
Well, we finally did get to New Y ork
2 p.m. today. We sure saw some

about

fine sights on the way out. And New

some town too. We are staying
hotel while we are here; my
room is on the 6th floor. We are on
York

at

is

this

Broadway.
We will not get to broadcast any
you have to get your dates

in

a

it
as
is
filled
up
appointments. So we will begin
tomorrow. They said they would
us tomorrow and the next day.

ahead

as

week

with
work
work
So

I

guess we will leave here on the mid
night train Thursday night and get to
Washington D.C. by daylight and stay
over till evening there.
Well, I can't begin to write you of all
have seen. It would take all night. If

I

we get along all right

expect we will be
home by Saturday anyway.
We
sure have been treated good
I've almost began
to
everywhere.
believe I'm somebody. Ha ha. Tell
Nancy and Cleo and Hicky to be good
I

in

I get any chance
I'll try to bring
them something, if its only candy.

and if

We left Ashville, Ky. Monday eve

and road all night and till 2 p.m. the
next day. I slept in the pullman. The
rest had day coaches as all the pullman
cars were filled up. We boarded the
Eastern Special on the C.&amp;.O. The
F.F.V. supposed to be the fastest on
the same road that George
the line
Allen had his wreck on. I thought of it
when we went thru Hinton and crossed
the Ohio through the big bend tunnel.
Mr. O'Keefe was very much pleased
to see us, and has sure treated us good.
Told us to see the sights of New York
at their expense. But Mr. Dykes and
the boys were so tired and sleepy they
retired early and I didn't have no one
to go with me, so I went to my room
and looked out over the city till I got
sleepy and went to bed. I was afraid
couldn't sleep, as it is sure a noisy
1

place.

mental versions of well-worn
East
Tennessee favorites; the third was one of
the first versions of the Texas dance-hall
anthem, and the tune that was generally

recognized

as

Dykes'

particular

"Twilight is Stealing" was a
well-known favorite in southwestern
Virginia; it had been composed in the
1870s by two gospel pioneers of the
Shenandoah Valley, Aldine Kieffer and

specialty.

Unseld. (Dykes, however, sang it
from a James D. Vaughan songbook
as
the Brunswick clerk dutifully noted.)
The A&amp;.R men wanted square-dance
B.

C.

tunes most of the time, but allowed the
group to sing on the last effort; Dykes
and Mahaffey sang, along with Myrtle
her only known recordings, though she
had a fine, light voice and was known
locally

a

as

an

channel swim with the same suit she
wore when she swam the channel. It
certainly was wonderful. Oh, I wish
you and all the rest could have seen it.
The Brunswick people are floating the
bills.

next

The

March

day,

10,

Boggs

recorded four more sides, including his
famous version of "Pretty Polly," and the

Magic

City

band

did

seven

instrumentals.

These were "Tennessee
Girls," another familiar East Tennessee

tune;

"Huckleberry

generally

known

as

more
Tennessee

Blues,"
"East

excellent singer.

That night Myrtle described the day in
third letter home.
Thought I would write you again, as
they decided they couldn't get through

till Friday night. We made 2
records today
besides Mr.
"Dock" Boggs' work. He didn't quite

with
and
get

us

lh

finished.

Oh

you

just

ought

to

hear

the

autoharp on the records. They let us

good thing that they slept well,

some 16 masters
two takes of each of
eight songs. Boggs went first, doing
versions of "Country Blues," "Sammie,
Where Have You Been So Long,"
"Down South Blues," and "Sugar Baby";
on all but the first, Hub Mahaffey
backed him on guitar. Then Dykes' band
began recording, doing their versions of
"Frankie," "Poor Ellen Smith," "Cotton
Eyed Joe," and "Twilight is Stealing."
The first two were well-known instru

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Well, I went walking down
Broadway tonight and seen the sights.
Oh, my. I seen a life-time in one night.
Dykes went with me, and we went to
the Paramount Theater and saw some

of the greatest dancing and acting in the
world before they opened up the
movie. Gertrude "Trudy" Ederle was
there, the only woman in the world
that ever swam across the English
(channel). They had a big glass basin of
water and she done her famous

Gerrard

a

Alice

was

O'Keefe, true to his word, did work
them the next day. The musicians cut

Courtesy

It

for

hear one that wasn't quite perfect.
They sure did brag on it! They told us
we didn't have no idea what fine
records we made. Said they would out
sell any of this scientific stuff.

�Blues" on the strength of a rival 1926
recording by the Hill Billies, and still
widely known in the area today; "Free a
Little Bird," one of the most popular of
the Brunswick recordings; "Shortening
Bread," another local favorite still played
in the area, replete with Dykes surprising
grace notes and Mahaffey's solid guitar;
"Ida Red," and "Callahan's Reel," both
associated with another area fiddler,
Cowan Powers, who had recorded them
in 1925, and "Red Steer," which Powers
under the title
had
also recorded,
"Brown's Dream." In spite of Myrtle's
assertion in her letter, most of the time
you cannot hear her autoharp on the
either because
fiddle tunes sides
Brunswick engineers did not know how
to mike it, or because she held it in her
lap too far away from the microphone.
Friday, March 11, the band rounded
out their work with three final tunes: the

"Golden

well-known

Slippers";

no evidence to support this
fact, Dykes' friend Dock

though,
Boggs

record for Lonesome Ace, the strange
grass-roots Virginia record company.)
Dykes' superb fiddling deserves more
tribute and analysis than we have space
for here. It was a well-defined upper East
Tennessee style that seemed especially
in
virulent
County; it
Washington
a
highly
emphasized the E string,

it right in on the farm, cause
they were trying to pay if off. She said
later, 'I didn't get a bit of good out of that
he just put it in on this old farm. That
just meant more work for me'." The
records were released within weeks, and

and dad put

and
both locally
in
the
stores
were
selling
nationally; they
in Bristol by the time Ralph Peer arrived

popular

auditions in July 1927.
Brunswick later wrote Dykes to return
for more recordings, but one New York
experience was enough for him, and he
demurred. By 1930 Myrtle had another

for his

and

her

duties

with

it

made

it

increasingly hard to work with the band.
Soon the Magic City Trio had broken
up. John Dykes was not to record

anymore. (A well-known tale circulating
tells of a
among record collectors
collector who once saw a broken copy of
Ace record by "Fiddlin'
a Lonesome

John Dykes"

in

a

remote West Virginia

cabin; the Lonesome Ace files, however,
have been located, and there is in them

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The

Dykes

Magic

City

Trio

sides

Old Homestead OHCS igi,
appear
while the Dock Boggs sides can be found on
on

RBF Records,

RF 54.

C.W.

thank Cleo McNutt for her
kindness in sharing with me
and
hospitality
a
pleasant afternoon of reminiscences,
photos, and scrapbook-looking. Cleo, the

though not fast bowing
manner, a fondness for slurring up to
notes, and a penchant for tuning down a

I

tone.

wish

to

daughter of Myrtle Vermillion, is an auto
harp player herself, and her home in Weber

City, Virginia, is often the center of many a
music session. She loves to play and we had
several good tunes during my visit. Cleo has
issued
a
Log Cabin
tape,
privately

Entertainment:

Wildwood Flower,

for

limited quantity. It includes Cleo on
autoharp, Vance McMurry on bass, Red
Lambert on fiddle, and Robert Quillen on
Write Cleo McNutt, 112 Elm,
guitar.
Weber City, VA. 24251, if you wish to
sale

a

in

Cleo

McNutt

order or inquire about the tape.

Courtesy

doesn't seem to be present.
Brunswick asked Dykes if he wanted
royalties or flat fee payment, but he
didn't know what royalties were, so he
took a flat rate of $50 per side, to be
divided among the three band members.
Cleo McNutt recalls: "Mom got her part

baby,

LP.

rhythmic

version of the old chording piece,
"Shout Lula," that Dykes called "Hook
and Line" (it was also known to Boggs
under this title); and a last gospel
number, "Far Beyond the Blue Sky."
This was an early, if not the first
recording, of a song that later became a
gospel hand-clapper under the title, "Do
and
Me."
Dykes
Lord, Remember
on
this;
though
sing
Mahaffey
Brunswick files indicate a third voice, it

were

Blizard; Mr. Chester Wilson; Mr. Tabby
Collins; and Mr. Tony Russell.
Discographical note: all the Brunswick
recordings discussed above are available on

in

did

Schuyler &amp; Myrtle Vermillion

Myrtle Vermillion continued to play
autoharp, banjo, and sing, though only
for her own family, and by 1950 was in
ill
health; she died in 1970. Her
daughter, Cleo McNutt, continues her
autoharp tradition, and is active with a
Hub
bands.
of regional
number
Mahaffey played with a number of local
radio bands through the 1940s and even
up until the 1960s; he spent his last days
in a nursing home in Sullivan, where he
entertained friends by playing his old

records.

a
John Dykes himself,
band
two
than
older
generation
members, was pretty much out of music
by the 1930s, though he still went to an
occasional fiddling contest or square
dance. He died sometime in the 1940s,
thinking perhaps of his brief shot at
and of the well-crafted legacy he
glory
forged during those memorable three
days in New York in the March of 1927. H

Credits:

special

McNutt; Mr.

S.

G.

thanks to Mrs. Cleo
Thomas; Mr. Ralph

Ed.

�0

V

Your Best Source for:
Harmonica
Guitar
Fiddle
Dulcimer
Blues Old-time Banjo
American Folk &amp; Celtic Music

recordings in print, many with
tablature books available if you want to learn the
pieces. We also have Teaching tapes for beginning
dulcimer, and advanced guitar,
banjo, beginning
banjo, and dulcimer.
We

have

over

150

Kicking Mule records have been featured in the
Nature Company and Wireless Catalogs, and three of
our dulcimer albums were Book of the Month Club
"Alternate Recording Selections."
Current new releases include Indie winning The Hills
Horse
of Mexico hv America's favorite cowboy duo
Sense; and If This Ain't Genius by the Cranberry
Lake Jug Band
Ask

for

a

free

copy
of the

of

best

page illustrated
in Folk Music

our

48

Kicking Mule Records, Inc
POB 158-OT
Alderpoint, Ca 95411
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

catalog

�DON'T YOU REMEMBER THE TIME―
SAMUEL CARLTON FREENY
1913-1987
by

Pat Conte

Stilled now, and forever, is the banjo
of Samuel Carlton Freeny; it's the same
banjo that was reluctantly tucked away
under the bed just prior to the first of
five campaigns that brought him to the
Pacific and back, from 1941-1945, to
face the Japanese enemy during World
War II. Before he retired from a rural

Electric

Co-op

near

Carthage,

Freeny was a busy man
during the fruitful post-war years, when,
it seemed, "everybody wanted electricity
all at once." After '45 there wasn't much
time for music in the Freeny home
work was hard and plentiful for the
young lieutenant colonel's new family
that is, until artillery rumbled once
more, this time across the 38th Parallel
1950. Again, Freeny
on June 27th,
not a
answered his country's call
"war," they said, but rather, a "police
action." Nonetheless, he returned safely
to eventually manage the Central Power
and

become

a

pillar of the

Pat

Association

Conte

Mississippi,

in

his

Methodist

Church

as

Courtesy

Freeny community (so named in honor
of his great-uncle, who emigrated from
Georgia in 1835). A Mason and a
Shriner, Freeny was to become a fixture

The Leake County String Band, April 30, 1985
L-R: Sam Alford, Carlton Freeny, Howard Smith, Haywood Sanders, Smith Freeny, Shelby Sanders,
and Joe Cox.

a

distinguished lay leader emeritus, and
spearheaded many progressive church

civic affairs. He also made a few
phonograph records, way back when.
and

There's a Mr. Alvis Massengale who
lives about 25 miles from Carthage. A
nonegenarian fiddler, he lives alone
now. His son also plays. Massengale
keeps himself entertained now and then
by scratching out some of those fine,
bent tunes the region is known for
the
same kind he put down on 78s with his
own band,
the Newton County
Hillbillies, back around the time the
Freeny boys were in their heyday. In
later years Alvis often sat in with Sam
Freeny's band, the Leake County String
Band, and for three or four years even
replaced their lead fiddler after a heart
attack claimed him. There was much
shared by these two men
the melodies,
the contest memories. One can imagine
the strains of "Happy Hour Breakdown"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Going to the Wedding to Get Some
Cake" when old Alvis would lead. One
also
can
lament
the
swift-coming
twilight, during our lifetimes, of the
grandeur of the Mississippi fiddle bands
of more than a half-century ago, gone
now but for a brief and recent flicker of
or

time.
The

recording engineer's assistant,
probably an eriiployee of H. C. Spier of
the General Phonograph Company, was
having a bit of trouble placing the boys

in a "regular" room
(a
hotel room, that is), in
Miss.,
Jackson,
December 1930. Ready were
Fonzie
Cannon, the guitarist (who set up the
session), Leslie Freeny on fiddle (Sam's
cousin), and Hendrix Freeny, "who
could play just about any instrument,"
also on fiddle. They kept backing up

"just

right"

poor Sam until he was almost out of the
room. "Equipment was not what it is
today," he told me. That beautiful old
ribbon mike gave a rich, warm sound,
but Sam's Mastertone banjo cut through
like a razor across ice. An afternoon's
work left us some of the most timeless
and sparkling jewels in the history of our
nation's music. But Okeh, like many
other record companies, was doomed as

choke-hold of the Depression
tightened. Freeny's Barn Dance Band
would record no more. Pause now, and
listen to "Mississippi Square Dance" or
"Sullivan's
Hollow" (County 529).
Once, at a festival, I heard those County
reissues referred to as the Testaments
themselves, Old and New. Powerful
the

words shared by many for
striking music, after 50 years.

equally

�the decade that followed, Sam and
cousins organized a new group. The
Freeny Harmonizers played out of
Kosciusko, Miss, on a Sunday afternoon
In

his

radio spot, mixing good times with more

recording

(for

Vocalion,

briefly),

and
fairs, square dances,
county
contests, until the war years curtailed

little money and merriment those
events afforded.
Once retired in 1977, Sam took the
banjo from under the bed a little more
frequently. A year or two later he helped
form the Leake County String Band,
which hearkened back to the days of
Will Gilmer's band, the Leak County
Revelers (the single most popular 1920s
Mississippi band). The new band now
had Morgan K. and George Gilmer,
along with Sam Alford and Howard
Smith on guitars,
and cut some
albums in Walnut
privately-pressed
Grove, Mississippi. For eight years the
band continued on, changing faces, and
echoing the strains of music that flowed
the

through places like Sebastopol and
Lorena, the Bienville Forest, and the
seams of blues country. They played a
new circuit of functions throughout
Union, Canton, and Greenwood. There
at the Radio 960 studios they filmed a
half-hour TV show with the sevenmember band that was to be the final and
most formidable lineup of the Leake
County String Band: Alford and Shelby
Sanders, guitars; Freeny, banjo; Howard
Smith, this time on mandolin; Heywood
Sanders and Smith Freeny, fiddles; and
Joe Cox, bass. From about 1985 on the
band enjoyed a surprisingly energetic
schedule of two rest home appearances a
week, in addition to the occasional
family reunion and performances at
arenas in Lauderdale and Howland Park,
and of course the state parks and church
socials. Folks would come to the arenas
from miles around to see those Nashville
headliners who, of course, would be in
town to play the theaters at night. And
the oldtimers, who listened to the Leake

County String Band play old numbers

like "Make Me A Pallet on the Floor"
"Sweet Bunch of Daisies," or "John
Henry" would still be talking about the
time those Freeny boys backed up

Jimmie Rodgers when he passed through
on his way from Meridian to Carthage,
in '30. Fine boys. Fine times.

By March of last year, the Thursday
practice sessions had coasted near stock-

Sam "had trouble with his air," as
they say, and by the time they celebrated
the first anniversary of Carlton Freeny
Day in town, Sam's ill health had him
still;

practically immobilized. Samuel Carlton
Freeny died, at age 74, on Monday,
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

August 24, 1987.
There's a new podium at the Freeny
Methodist Church, attached to which is
a plaque
bearing his name. In all of our
hearts there, too, is stamped his music.
And while their mortal clay reposes
here, those boys from near Sullivan's
Hollow, their music rings across
Heaven, now reunited. We'll remember
the time, Carlton Freeny.
.1

�BUY OR BYE!

Issues In Old-Time Music

Old-Time Music in the Consumer Age

(with Personal Reminiscences)
by

Mac

one to think that this may just be the
music's finest hour. We have learned to
tap into the centuries-old magic of the
music and bring it alive today, each with
our own personal style.
The obvious strength and vigor of this
revival, however, seems to manifest itself
these days in what could be called the
"social" side of the music
you know, a
bunch of friends getting together in

informal situations to play high-qualitv

music just for the sheer joy of it. At the
same time, in the past five or six years I
have noticed a steady decline in the
number of old-time musicians appearing
in performance situations. Fewer oldtime bands are being featured at folk and
bluegrass festivals. Clubs that used to
present traditional music are folding up.

Looking back

I

realize

how lucky

I

my full-time pro
fessional musical career coincide so
nicely with a widespread peaking of
interest in the kind of music I choose to
have

been

to

have

play. I was surely in the right place at the
right time. However, I must confess to a
certain feeling of regret and disappointment
as well. At the time it felt as if those
glory days of the early 1970s were just
the start of even bigger and better things
not only for my career but for oldtime music in general. At long last it
seemed as if this wonderful style of
music from our past were about to
secure for itself a small but permanent
place in the American musical environ
ment, never again to totter on the brink
of extinction. Perhaps this was a hope

lessly idealistic expectation.

In any case,

times certainly have changed, and 1 fear
now that a golden opportunity may have
slipped through our fingers.
Of course, the tradition is far from
dead, and I'm not about to call in the
undertaker just yet. The recent article,
"Fiddling," in the New Yorker magazine
paid tribute to the vitality of the current
old-time music scene. It reported that
there were 174 old-time bands registered
at the Galax
Fiddlers Convention in
An old program that I got at Galax
1 986.
in 1969 shows a total of 76 bands, of
which only 16 or so were old-time. The
number, skill, and breadth of repertoire
of today's old-time musicians tempts

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

seem less
promoting concerts of oldtime music. Fewer records of old-time
music are being issued. Southern dance

College

interested

music

organizations

in

losing ground on the revitalized
country dance circuit in many places.
Most important, fewer old-time bands
are forming with the intention of touring
around the country and performing full
time. In short, it seems that the "commer
is

cial" as opposed to the "social" side of
the music may be in trouble.

have many friends who feel that this
is only natural and, actually, all to the
good. Old-time music, they say, was
traditionally meant to be played in the
home. They contend that trying to take
this music to a stage or concert hall
I

involves such hassles and compromises
that

it

the music

only harms

people who play

and the

know from exper
ience that putting the music in a per
formance situation can take some of the
fun out of it. I'm convinced, however,
that without the numerous hassles,
compromises, and frustrating profes
sional ventures, many of these same
folks would never have known the
luxury of playing the music in the
comfort of their living rooms.
Of course, the social function of oldtime music is basic to its very nature.
Unlike, say, symphonic music or heavymetal rock-and-roll, old-time music is
perfectly appropriate for small, informal
get-togethers. This gives it a definite
it.

I

Benford

advantage in appealing to musicians who
respect and cherish the music for itself,
rather than as a vehicle for gaining

attention.

Its

distinctive "down-home"

quality results from the fact that it can
be, and is, played "down home" keeping
the music human and accessible and

preserving

its

magical

simplicity.

However, without an equally vigorous
commercial side, the music would have
been unable to grow and extend itself
through time and would probably have
died out long before now.
Certainly it was live and recorded per
formances by the New Lost City

the
Ramblers
before them,
and,
Kingston Trio that originally introduced
me to old-time music and inspired me to
play it myself. Hopefully some of my
performances have had a similar effect
on others. In fact, I suspect that there are
very few of us currently playing old-time

music who were not initially won over
by some form of professional present
ation of it. For example, try to imagine
music
without the
old-time
today

commercial enterprises of the 1920s that
resulted in all those priceless per
formances captured on 78 rpm records.
Or try to imagine old-time music with

out the "folk scene" of the '60s, for that

matter.
The commercial side has always been
important and legitimate part of the
tradition the traveling Celtic minstrels
who traded news and music for lodging
in the castle, the slave who found that
playing for the master's dances was
easier than field work, the medicine
show entertainers, the blind fiddler
passing the hat on street corners, and the
hillbilly banjo picker who made it to the
Grand Ole Opry. The musicians who
have committed themselves to gaining
some form of reward for their talents
have carried much of the responsibility
for keeping the music alive and growing
from one generation to the next. Their
very livelihood has depended on their
ability to apply their own personal skills
and imagination
to the music they
inherited from the past, so as to present
it in a way that will touch and appeal to
whatever audience they face.
an

Even older folks who grew up with

�old-time music on a social level in their
families and communities have related
that it was the rare talent and
commitment of a professional musician
(and the attention and acclaim that

comes their way) that inspired them to

become musicians. This situation

even
more true today when the old ways of
passing the music along simply do not
is

work any more. With all the choices
available through the media, the type of
music played by one's parents in one's
home is probably the last thing that
would interest today's young musician.
Put the same music on TV or on a stage
in front of a wildly enthusiastic crowd
and it is a whole different story.
to
comes
down
simple
mathematics. Think how many of the
It

all

old masters are passing away. Think how
many musicians of our generation are
being drawn off to other interests. Think
how many folks, who at one time loved

dance to old-time music,
now have commitments that keep them
from getting out much any more. Right
now these numbers are not being
replaced and the scene is not so large or
healthy that it can afford to lose even a
single person. Only a constant influx of
new converts can counteract the natural
and inevitable trend towards zero.
Attracting the necessary new numbers
is only possible when the music and the
potential audience maintain constant
access to each other. Old-time music
to listen

and

never encountered

can never be

appre

Re-establishing old-time music
on the level of community function, as
seems to be occurring these days, is just
ciated.

not enough.

It

was

not enough

in

the

1940s and '50s, even in the music's
home territory, when the music came
within a generation of disappearing. It is
certainly

not

radio,

enough

in

the

media-

1980s. We are talking about
TV, concerts, club dates, tapes

oriented

and records

in

short, show biz. The

amount of old-time music that gets out
to contact those "virgin ears" depends
on
a
almost
flourishing
entirely
commercial basis for the music.
Not only the amount, but the kind and
quality of the music passed along is
determined by the "performance" side of
old-time music. Professional musicians
have the impetus and also the
to
fully
develop their
opportunity
technique and creativity, since for them
music is more than just a side-interest.

They

are

forced

to

work

towards

successful resolutions of the conflict
between the debt to the past and the
demands of the future. At the very least,
the constant playing necessitated by a
busy schedule of performances and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

rehearsals will result in an improvement
touch and timing. It stands to reason
that the music itself will reach its highest
level when it is in the hands of those with
the
most inducement to constantly
expand their skills of expression and
execution. A thriving commercial basis
for this music would in turn enable the
in

musicians so motivated to commit their
full-time to the challenge of
making old-time music live in the
talents

present. As it stands today, too many of
those rare individuals who are drawn to a
musical career are being lost to our
music for purely economic reasons.
Also consider for a moment the
distresssing fact that old-time music is
nowadays being described as "a musical
form where lyrics are secondary." (See
"Fiddling" in the July 20, 1987 New
I
bet such great singers as
Yorker).
Tom
Charlie
Poole,
Ashley, Dave
Macon,

Riley Puckett, Almeda Riddle,

and Texas Gladden to name a few, are
spinning in their graves. I'm actually
coming to think that until a musician has
made a serious attempt to master the
vocal side of old-time music, he or she

the surface of what
this tradition is all about. Yet there is
real danger that this recent widespread
misconception may, in fact, be coming
to the current
true, due primarily
imbalance between the "social" and
"commercial" aspects of old-time music.
Most performers learn very quickly that
is is difficult to hold the attention of an
audience for a whole evening of instru
mental music unless, of course, you are
has barely scratched

music for a dance. It is
through the vocal numbers that per
former and audience can share the wide
range of emotions, tears to laughter,
appropriate to this musical style. It is
through the romance and poetry of the
lyrics that an audience can be brought to

providing

�appreciate the many past ages from
which this music speaks. Vocal arrange
ments and harmony parts are hard to
work out at informal festival jam

sessions, however, and so to many
people, old-time music becomes nothing

but tune after tune after tune.
At the same time that we have become
ever more dependent on access to the
audience for the health and longevity of
old-time music, the competition for that

access has become increasingly fierce.
Music and entertainment have become
big business, capable of generating huge
sums of money. As in any big business,
total monopoly

is

the obvious winning

strategy and the aim of the game is to
create a single, unified audience where
each individual likes exactly the same
thing at the same time, and then forgets it
at the same moment in favor of whatever

determined to
the next "hit" product
be.
Many powerful people in this
business view all variant musical forms
simply as impediments to the realization
is

of their goal. If they fully grasped how
committed old-time music is to the pre
musical
servation of long-enduring
values, as opposed to the fast bucks of
fad popularity, they might even deal with
us as a real threat.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

spite of this, many musical forms
to grow and thrive outside the
of mass
mainstream
popularity.
Classical music is, of course, the most
successful example. But other "un
popular" styles such as traditional jazz,
blues, marching music, polkas, and bluegrass, have also been able to claim and
hold a secure portion of the means of
audience access, even in the face of this
competition. Up until a few years ago,
old-time music seemed to be one of
those small but thriving musical pockets.
Recently, however, its share of the total
musical audience has begun to decrease.
I refuse
to accept the explanation that
old-time music has less power, magic, or
contemporary value than those other
"non-popular" yet successful musical
In

continue

styles.
and

guess

the

inescapable conclusion
whole point of this article,

The
is

I

that the fault must lie with us.
has been my good fortune to

Now it
have encountered

some incredibly
supportive people in my career, for
whom I'll always be grateful. On the
whole, however, it just may be that
people involved in old-time music may
make the worst fans in the world. Not
that we lack for love and devotion to the
music, but we seem not to have grasped

obvious fact that in the competitive
popularity contest that is today's music
the

scene, the only votes that count are cast
with dollar bills. Wishing it were other
wise, unfortunately, just does not get the
job done.

It is a fairly common occurrence for
old-time fans to prepare for a festival by
gathering together expensive cameras,
valuable antique instruments, high-tech

camping gear, various gourmet delights,
and then try to figure out how to sneak in
or wrangle a free pass. Everything has
been supported except the performers
and the event that were the supposed
focus of the journey. I have witnessed
people ordering nothing but ice water at
a
a club where they have gone to hear
band they had begged the manager to
hire. It is any wonder old-time music is
not featured there very often? Members
of the audience have often come up to
a
me following
performance to
announce that they had enjoyed one of
my records so much that they taped it for
all their friends. It is obvious that they

intended this to be appreciated as a
compliment and are totally unaware that
they have admitted stealing from me and
the record company that took a risk on
my music. The large number of old-time

�bands entered

at

the Galax and Mt. Airy

conventions, which

usually seen as a
sign of the music's growing strength, can
also be taken as an indication of the
number of people who will do anything
to avoid paying their money to those
who put on the event (at these events,
is

contestants admission fees are refundable
ed.). Multiply these kinds of occurrences

throughout

the

old-time

music

scene

not hard to imagine that in a few
won't be much old-time
there
years
music to spend money on.
and

it is

Ironically, it may be old-time music's
success at attracting participants that is
the very cause of its difficulty in estab
lishing widespread fan support. To the
many people who play this music with
some skill, the role of a "fan" must seem
somewhat beneath them. The barriers
between performers and audience have
been so successfully broken down that
to some it must hardly seem worth
for a performance of
that
happens for free in their
something
homes. A friend of ours once accused
the Highwoods band of being fools for

paying

money

making old-time music look so easy and

so fun that we turned our

fans

potential

into potential competitors. Unfortu
nately, there is a certain sad grain of truth
in his joke. More than anything else, oldtime music today lacks the commercial
support that only comes with a large

body of dedicated fans.
Check out the newsletter of the
a
Baltimore Blues Society, for example
regular monthly publication by and for
the blues fans in just one town. In it you
will find information on the 20 or so area
clubs that feature blues, the six radio
stations that have blues programs, the
latest record releases (at least a dozen
each month) and the numerous blues-

oriented festivals across the country.
Information is present on a wide variety
of blues performers
young, old,
black, white, traditional, progressive,
male, female, and acoustic as well as
electric.

The feeling

is

clear that while

individual members naturally have their
favorite performers and preferred
approach to the blues, they can
to

support the genre

as a

all

unite

whole. This

is

one small example from today's
blues scene. Old-time music has nothing

just

comparable, and yet just 25 years ago
music
blues and old-time
country
occupied roughly equal shares of the
overall music scene.
Neil Rosenberg,

in

his

B

luegrass,

A

(University of Illinois Press),
gives an excellent account of the crucial
role played by active fan support in the
success of bluegrass music today. Fans of
History

this

musical

style

have

always

been

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

wonderfully

supportive,

regularly

buying all the records by their favorite
groups, and traveling great distances to
see their favorite performers. Rosenberg
describes how, by means of articles and
record reviews in the bluegrass

magazines and fan newsletters, the fan's
buying power was coordinated and
focused in such a way as to ensure the
current popularity of bluegrass music
while maintaining its firm ties to its
roots.
While I'm on the subject, let me say
that the wide gap that seems to exist
today between bluegrass and old-time
music is one of the most senseless and
unfortunate aspects of the current state
of affairs. The two musical forms are
obviously so closely related that their

similarities
differences.

To

far outweigh
their
claim the recognition

that he so rightly deserved, Bill Monroe
at one time had to stress the difference
between old-time music and the new
musical form he had created. Make no
mistake, however, his obvious goal was
simply to find new and exciting ways of

presenting those elements of old-time
music that had made such a profound
impression on him as a youth. This man
should be our role model. know from
experience that well-performed old-time
I

music

can

be

a

highly

appreciated

addition to a bluegrass festival. This
should be especially true today now that,
with

success

assured, bluegrass has
its more
archaic roots. If there were some way to
join forces, I think it would be a natural
match and of great benefit to both forms
of Appalachian string music.
its

become more positive towards

We

have

a

lot

learn

to

from

the

bluegrass scene. As the fans of bluegrass
and blues have shown, to support the
"sale" of the music does not necessarily
lead to "selling out" the music. In fact, it
a situation
to develop
is in allowing
wherein our valuable music can only be
given away for free that we do the music
a

disservice.

This

is

the

age

of

consumerism, and any plans for the
preservation of the music we love must
take this reality into consideration. Of

course even if those of us who already
love old-time music were to devote
ourselves to supporting the music with
as much energy as we put into learning to
play it, it would still not be enough. We
be
must constantly
attracting new
converts. To survive, the music must
reach out to new generations and new

segments of society.
The

responsibility

for

this

rests

primarily on those of us who are per
formers. We must begin directing more
of our performances to the unconverted,
rather than always to our close friends
and fellow musicians. Instead of trying
the in-crowd with some
to impress

obscure, newly-discovered material, we
should consider using numbers like
"Cripple Creek," "Oh Susannah," "John
Henry," "Shortnin' Bread," or one of
those tried and true classics that might
strike a chord of recognition in a
newcomer to the music. Instead of
muttered, off-the-wall humor or injokes, we must realize that the time
between numbers is an important part of
the performance, to be used to entertain
or give the audience an added handle on
the music. It is almost as if some of us
have taken for granted that old-time
music will not appeal to anyone who
does not already understand its subtle
ties, therefore any effort in this direction
is avoided. Remember that almost every
one of us represents a contradiction of
that assumption.
In the early 1970s, the Highwoods
Stringband had great success with its
very casual approach to stage dress and
presentation. We were lucky that what
happened to be our natural style proved
also to be a highly effective performance

technique, setting us immediately apart
tie-and-vest
the
from
academic,
approach of many of the '60s string
bands on the one hand, and the
humorless, polyester-uniformed style of

�most bluegrass bands

at the time. It only
our
and
jeans
unpretentious stage manner were in
perfect conformity with the style being
set by the leading pop and rock groups of

worked

that

because

Today's audiences, however,
are
accustomed
to
costumes, sets,
effects, and a highly crafted performance
era.

package. Unfortunately, many bands
taken the Highwoods' informal
style even farther in the wrong direction,
appearing on stage half-crocked and
half-dressed. This has become so
frequent that old-time music and totally
have

unprofessional

conduct

nearly synonymous
many promoters.

in

have become
the minds of

remain convinced that it is possible
a format
for presenting oldtime music with enough flash and showbusiness savvy to appeal to today's
general audience without losing the heart
and soul of the music. There is a certain
I

to devise

angularity or roughness that is somewhat
basic to the nature of the music; but this
is not the same thing as sloppiness,
which should be avoided at all costs.
Old-time music at its best has a certain
tightness, a focused energy, and a
dramatic use of dynamics that needs
simply to be applied to the performance

whole. Medleys, instrumental
comedy skits, and dramatic
are
all
of the
recitations
part
performance tradition of our music
dating back into the 1920s, but the oldas

a

breaks,

time bands of today seem afraid of trying
even these simple devices. I'm not sure

whether

the

fear

primary

compromising the purity of

is
of
the music or

looking foolish on stage if these
attempts should fall short. To be sure,
the challenge is not an easy one, but oldtime music desperately needs skilled
musicians who will wrestle with the
problem along with fans who will
support rather than scorn their attempts.
It will be especially difficult making
of

any kind of headway these days. The
style of the '80s, with its emphasis on the

the synthetic,
and the
contemporary is just not as hospitable to
old-time music as was the interest in
rural life-styles, magic, historical roots,
5
and things homemade that prevailed

slick,

1

ago. These styles move in
ever-shortening cycles, however, so this
time to begin our new
is a perfect
approach. We must be ready when the
next cultural opportunity presents itself.
music fails to
Even if old-time
to 20 years

generate enough commercial support to
keep itself alive, there is one other
possible scenario for survival on a
performance level. If what we are doing
were

determined

to

be

an

invaluable

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

contribution to this nation's cultural
environment, we might possibly receive
the kind of philanthropic patronage and
official support that classical music now

enjoys.

Unfortunately,

such

a

determination will have to be made and
confirmed by the academic folklore
establishment. There was a time when
folklorists and musicians were two facets
of a single community, united in its
enthusiasm for the music. Since then,
however, the relationship has deterior

Mac Benford
and singer, and

is

a

an old-time banjo player

founding member of both

now-disbanded Highwoods Stringband,
influential and popular old-time band

the
an

during the 1970s, and the Backwoods Band,
also disbanded. Mac, originally from Hew
Jersey, makes his home in Trumansburg,
N. Y. He has recorded a critically-acclaimed

album
Rounder
Records,
for
Backwards Banjo, and currently performs

solo

solo and with Mac

Benford's Old-Time

Band.

ated to the point where both sides now
view each other with near contempt.
Much could be done to repair this rift, to
the great benefit of players and students
of old-time music alike. This could be
the subject for a whole other article.
Suffice it to say, until the present

generation of old-time musicians is seen
to be the legitimate inheritors of the
tradition (which we obviously are), we
must learn to operate in the competitive
marketplace without any help.
In our frustration with the lack of
commercial success, we have developed
a

"siege

mentality"

that

has

isolated

us

from the contemporary musical world.
Rather than protecting us, this isolation
now poses a threat to the continued
existence of the music we love. We must
to the
get busy and build some bridges
world of academic folklore, to other
related musical forms that have been
more successful, and most importantly
to that huge body of music-lovers who
have yet to be moved by some of the
most powerful music in the world. We
must stop taking the music for granted
and treating it as something totally for
our own amusement. We must dispense
with the romantic notion of faithfully
going down with the sinking ship, and
start repairing the boat. It goes without
saying that a link must be strong at both
ends to preserve the strength of a chain.

We can all feel a deserved pride in the
dedication and righteousness with which
and cherished the
we have received
priceless gift of this music from the past.
It is

now time for us to focus the same

attention and energy on passing this gift
along to future generations.
Well, thanks for bearing with me
while
got some of these troubling
thoughts off my chest. I hope I haven't
offended anyone, but if I've managed to
stir up a few arguments I'll be delighted.
I

There

is

so much that we can do, but

it all

begins in accepting the problem. I just
want to be able to rest easy in the
knowledge that the joy this special kind
of music has brought to me will be avail
able to my grandchildren. Folks, as you
may have guessed from all this yakketyyak, I'm just a little nervous about it.

If

anyone

is

interested in contributing

to

this column, please send your ideas or typed,

double-spaced
"

manuscript for consideration

Old-Time Music," c/o Linda
Higginbotham, Old-Time Herald, P.O.
Box 1362, Galax, V A, 24333.

to:

Issues

in

�CLASSIFIED

FLATIRON,

first of the month,

2

months prior to

publication.

SALE:

Carter

Original

DEERING,

$12.00.
1101"

Brown

2001 "Missing
Doesn't Live Here"

Bluejay

You/Johnny

REITER,

stock now
catalogs.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.
Washington, POB
14210-AJ34,
Lansing, MI 48901 (517) 372-7890.
best

the

prices.

in

Free

BANJOS, BANJO ALBUMS, and more.
World's largest bluegrass and folk music
store. Free mail order catalogs.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS, 1100 N.
Washington, POB 14210-AJ34,
Lansing, MI 48901 (517) 372-7890.

Carter
(1966) Bluejay
Rat Tale"/"Jimmie
Back" Mint. $12.00. A. P.

WASHBURN GUITAR c. 1895. Smallbodied, rosewood, excel, cond., perfect
intonation! $600. Must sell. K.
Singleton, 721 McAlway Rd., Charlotte,
NC 28211,

704-364-5433.

EARTHLY

DELIGHT

Joe

Is

gems

WANTED:

Old WLS National Barn
material (song folios, pictures,
family albums, autographs, etc.) Other
material (song folios,
old C&amp;.W
pictures, etc.) Will consider trading
Carter material. See above ad. S.A.S.E.
Harvey H. Fink.
Dance

THE DAILY CLOG

featuring

monthly news
hard-hitting clog
is a

events
dance.
$6.00 per year. Free sample upon
request. Contact Julie Mangin, 95 East
Wayne Avenue #312, Silver Spring, MD

journalism

to

and

a

old-time

calendar
music

of

&amp;.

20901.

THE CLOG PALACE features old-time

music for free-style
clogging every
Thursday at Capt. White's Oyster Bar
and Clog Palace, Silver Spring, MD.
Contact Julie Mangin c/o The Daily
Clog, 95 East Wayne Avenue #312,
Silver Spring, MD 20901.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

a

book

of

fiddle

original
as

tunes. Featuring such
"Reel du Cou Rouge" and

"Chernobyl Hornpipe," handsomely
illustrated and cheap (only $4.50). You

can't go wrong! Order today from Hilary
Branch Rd.,
128
Dirlam,
Spooks

Asheville, NC 28804.

FINE

relating

TAYLOR,

"Wharf

Carter Family Scrapbook (1952). Mint.
Rare. $30.00. Jimmie Rodgers
13$
postage stamps. Rare. Mint. (Write).
Camden LP ACLI 0047 "Old Cottage
Home" $30.00. Carter Family MCA
1070 (Japan import) "More Favorites"
Mint. Rare. $60.00. Postage $2.50. Lots
more Carter stuff. State wants. S.A.S.E.
1-414-699-4556. Harvey H. Fink, P.O.
Box 156, Johnson Creek, WI 53038.

letter

GUILD,

Family

collector LPs. Mint. Limited. Camden
ACLI 0501 "Happiest Days of All."
Camden Cal. 2473 "Lonesome Pine
Special" $24.50 each. 45sJanetteCarter

(1966)

STIVER,

KENTUCKY, much more,
at

The Old-Time Herald will accept
classified ads at the cost of .35 cents per
word, minimum $5.00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the

MARTIN,

STELLING,

GIBSON,

BLUEGRASS

INSTRUMENTS,

new,

&amp;

OLD-TIME
used,

vintage.

Free, friendly advice. All correspond
ence answered promptly and in depth.

919-383-5750. 39$ S.A.S.E. brings
current listing. Subscriptions with extra
services $5.00. Harry &amp; Jeanie West,
P.O.
Box
North
17067,
Durham,
Carolina 27705.
Or,

�The Dance Beat
by

Phil Jamison

Willard
Watson:
Old-Time
Flatfoot

Jamison

Dancer

Phil

Years ago, old-time music and dance
were an integral part of a community's
culture and social activities. People made
their own music and they danced for

Deep Gap, NC, 1987

their own entertainment.
Today,
musicians wishing to learn the old styles
78
the
have
luxury of numerous
some

of the

of the
1920s and
there were no
Unfortunately,

video

recordings

that

music

captured

'30s.

cameras back then to record the dancing.
A

visit

Watson

flatfoot dancer Willard
provides a glimpse of those

with

times.
Willard Watson and his wife, Ora,
whom he refers to as "the old hen," live
down a back road just below the Bkne
Ridge Parkway near Deep Gap, North
There are always a few
Carolina.
chickens running free around the yard
and in the road in front of their house.
Across from the house is Willard's
woodworking shop with a sign that
reads, "Willard Watson's Woodworks
Within." These days Willard spends
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

much of his time

in the shop creating an
unique wooden toys:
"dancing dolls" (limber jacks), "pecking
hens," "bouncing pigs," and others.
Despite the remoteness of their home,
Willard and Ora receive almost daily
visitors, who seek out his toys as well as
the quilts that she makes.
Willard Watson was born on June 1,
1905, "back up on the mountain" about
a mile from where he now lives. In his 82
years he has "done everything a man
could do to raise a gang of children." At
the age of 14, he and a cousin left home
to become loggers. They walked 10 miles

assortment

to

of

train and
a logging
to the logging camps up on Rich

Boone, hopped

rode

it

Mountain. He worked there for three
months before his family finally found

out where he was. At other times in his
life, work has taken him farther from

home. He logged in Kentucky and
Virginia, worked in the coal mines of
West Virginia, and in the 1940s he
worked for a few years at a battery
factory in Cleveland. He has traveled all
over

the

country,

but

returned to his home

in

he

has

always

Deep Gap.
While many people think of Willard
as a toy maker, he is known by others for
his flatfoot
dancing. When he was
growing up, Deep Gap was an area rich
music and dance. Many
in old-time
members of his family were musicians

�and dancers, the most famous being his

first

Watson.
Square
"old-time shindigs" as
or
calls them, were common at

cousin,

dances,

Doc

Willard
and
other social events.
weddings
Dancing did not take place in dance
halls, but in people's homes. They would
roll back the rug and move all the
furniture to make room, and the house
would fill with people. The musicians at
these events included Doc Watson,
fiddler Ben Miller, and banjo players
Clifford Collins and Johnny Watson
(Doc's brother) to name a few. Willard

played banjo as well. The dancing was
often led by Willard's uncle or his
cousin Marvin Watson. They danced in
circle sets of usually eight couples, to
calls such as "the grapevine swing" and
"four hands up, four hands down, grab
your partner all the way around." Today
Willard knows of none of this type of
square dancing still being done in the
Deep Gap area.
Willard describes himself as a flatfoot
dancer. He learned from his mother,
who he says was a good dancer, but
perhaps his biggest influence was his
"the
best
uncle, Granville
Triplett,
flatfoot dancer" he ever saw. Granville
had spent some time in the penitentiary,
and while there he worked with a black
man firing the huge boiler of a rock
crusher. Apparently he learned some
steps from the other man and danced
them to the timing of the engine. Willard
learned these steps when Granville
returned home. They are interesting
steps with fitting descriptive names:
"floor
shine," "shoe shine," "the
barnyard slide," "wring the chicken's
neck," and "snake crawlin' in the grass."
According to Willard, these are flatfoot
steps, not buckdancing (or clogging,
which is "something very different"). He
describes buckdancing as a "jumping up
and down" motion, as opposed to the
"very

smooth"

and

close-to-the-floor

look of flatfoot dancing.
Willard is very outspoken in his
preference for old-time music over blue-

grass (which he doesn't care for at all).
He says, "there ain't nothing to beat the

old-time stringband music to dance to."

favorite dance tunes are "Jimmy
Sutton" and "Shout Little Lulu." Until a
few years ago, Willard could be seen
dancing at the fiddlers conventions in
His

Galax,

Virginia,

Mecklenberg

County

Grove, and Fiddlers'
Grove. It was there that he met the early
whom he
Green Grass Cloggers,
encouraged, feeling that they danced
with the right kind of unconventional,
cut-loose spirit. He became a mentor to

(N.C.),

Union

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

them and taught them his steps, which
they have since shared with other
dancers across the country.
Dancers of Willard's generation still
dance at fiddlers conventions, usually
off to the side of the stage. They can be a
tremendous resource and inspiration, as
Willard has been, to people who wish to
to

addition

music, he quit dancing when he
turned 80. He says, "I've seen the time
when I could move my feet as smooth as
anybody." To people wanting to learn to
dance, he offers this advice: "Watch a lot
of folks (dancing). You'll have to learn it
yourself. That's exactly what I did. You

dance

can watch

to

you've got to learn

the old-time way. In
his unique steps, Willard
likes to share his philosophies of dance
and life, and a visit to his home includes
more than just talk about old-time music
and dance and toymaking. He is a caring
individual who is brimming full of "oldtime mountain wisdom" and advice to
share with the younger generation. He
warns of the evils of alcohol and gives the

learn

Although Willard still loves good old-

time

advice that his father once gave to him:
"Anything that you can't stay ahead of,
don't fool with it, and if you go
anywhere, go by yourself and there
won't be nobody tellin' tales."

to

a

music

me,

or

I

can watch

you, but

Listen
yourself.
lot of good music. The old-time
is

it

the best there is.

It

gets

in

your

feet."
an

Note: Willard Watson is also featured in
article about toymakers in Foxfire 6

(Anchor Press /Doubleday,
NY, 1980).

Garden

City,

�Workshop
OLD MAN ADAMS'S TUNE
Standard tuning
is a

John Kennedy

downbow

and

is an

Pawnee, OK

upbow (standard violin notation).

repeat

repeat

70s from Pawnee, Oklahoma. He learned a lot of his music from "old man Adams" of Cleveland,
Oklahoma, who was an old man when John was just a boy. Adams was originally from the Arkansas Ozarks, and John's repertoire
and style of playing are consequently different from other fiddlers in the area. Before he died, Adams made a point of teaching John
Brad Leftwich
this tune and told him "don't ever forget it."-a

fiddler

in his

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gerrard

is

Alice

John Kennedy

Tim Donnelly, 1987

�GOD GAVE NOAH
THE RAINBOW SIGN

Old Noah planted him

a

vineyard don't you

a

vineyard don't you

see?

Old Noah planted him
see?

Poor

Noah drank

old

a little wine

don't you

see?

Poor old Noah drank a little wine don't you
see?
Poor old

Noah drank more wine,

McNutt

Alice Gerrard, and Andy Cahan.
Jim Nelson of Chicago requested the
words to this song, so we are including it
in this issue's workshop. Tommy crosstuned his fiddle AEAE) when he played
the song. He learned it from a 45-rpm
recording of the late Joe Stuart on
Blugras (sic) Records, BGC-004, out of
Princeton, W. Va. The Carter Family
recorded a 78 of the song on the
Conqueror label, and I know of no
reissue of their version. Tommy made
up the words to the third and fourth
verses in the following version. The
chords in parentheses are the variant
chords used in the Carter Family
version. The verse chords are the same as
the chorus chords since the tune is the

Old Noah planted him a vine,
And from this he made a little wine,
Hide me, oh, rock of ages cleft for me.

And he got higher than a Georgia pine,
Hide me, oh, rock of ages cleft for me.
Oh there's honey
Oh there's honey
Oh there's honey

in
in

that rock for me,
that rock don't you see?

in that rock,

Cleo

County 791 Rainbow Sign
Tommy Jarrell with Verlen Clifton,
Source:

Courtesy

Key of A

Hick Vermillion and Clell Jayne

Way up on the mountain top.
Hide me, oh, rock of ages cleft for me.
Repeat ist verse.

Alice Gerrard

same

Chorus:
A
God save Noah the rainbow sign don't you see
E

(A)

God gave Noah the rainbow sign don't you see?

A

A

(D)

God gave Noah the rainbow sign,
No more water but the fire next time.

Hide me, oh, rock

A
E
of ages cleft for me.

Poor old Lazarus poor as
Poor old Lazarus poor as
Poor old Lazarus poor as

I
I

don't you see
don't you see?

I,

When he died he had a home on high,
Hide me, oh, rock of ages cleft for me.
From east

to

west the fire might roll, hide thou

to

west the fire might roll, hide thou

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

American
of
Festival
Institution

Hide me, oh, rock of ages cleft for me.

Smithsonian

to west the fire might roll,
Lord have mercy on my poor soul.

From east

Courtesy

me,

Folklife

me,

From east

�A

SUMMER IN FAT CITY
by

Jenny Cleland Vittek

In the spring of 1971 I lived in the
country southwest of Ithaca, New York,
near a small town called Spencer. I was
sharing a house with Doug Dorschug and
we were both third-year students at
he on the G.I. bill, having
Cornell-served in Vietnam. In those years a
Cornell education included liberal (even
radical) doses of cultural revolution. My

and

by the

in

disarray

armed takeover of the

junior

years

were

invasion of Cambodia

and the tragedy at Kent State. My studies
were fun, including lots of literature and
art history, and music courses from Bach
but after a year of
to John Cage,
commuting to town from the country I
decided to take a leave of absence and
seek my fortune in the world. My plan
was to stay that summer in Spencer,
where I found a job finishing sheet rock
in a new house, and then to head for

California. As it turned out, I was to call
Ithaca home for the next six years.
played a variety of instruments as a
I

child, and had played guitar and sung
folksongs since junior high school, but
Doug introduced me to bluegrass and
old-time music. He had all the old Bill
Monroe and Flatt and Scruggs records,
and a tape of some very intriguing music
a band called
by some friends of his
the Busted Toe Mudthumpers who had
lived and played in Ithaca in the mid-60s.
In fact Doug had spent the summer of
'70 playing music with his friends, David
Hanni and John Coster, who had been
the guitar player in the Mudthumpers.
John loved to tell stories about the
band's eccentric fiddler George Dorian,
who had died tragically in a car accident;
his banjo-playing sidekick Walt Koken;
and the band's adventures from Ithaca to
Union Grove, North Carolina, and to
the streets of Berkeley, California. I lived
with them for a few weeks that August in

farmhouse outside Woodstock,
Vermont, and drank in my first tastes of
the counterculture that flourished there.
a

big

learned to bake bread and helped to
cook for the 10 or more people who
usually showed up at dinnertime, but I
especially enjoyed the music: original
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Vittek

an

Jenny

Sophomore
disrupted

ended

year

Courtesy

freshman

resulting from
student union.

Highwoods Stringband

songs which often had mystical themes,
with
three
country-style
arranged
guitars. One weekend John's friend who
played fiddle, Bill Welling, came to visit
from Hartford, Connecticut, and we all
Common
to
the
went
Craftsbury
Fiddlers Convention. After that I was
hooked on fiddle music; and back at
school in the fall, 1 borrowed a fiddle,
bought iooi Fiddle Tunes, and started
working on "Flowers of Edinburg" and
"Little Beggarman."
That winter Doug and I played some
music together. He had a Tandberg tape
recorder, and we experimented with
taping songs with piano, guitar, and
tambourine. Doug was playing guitar
with a bluegrass band in town called
Country Cooking, which included Russ
Barenberg on mandolin and John Miller
on electric bass. When John went home
for summer
vacation, they switched
Russ to guitar and Doug to bass, so we
had the bass at our house, and I began to
fool around with it. In fact, at a square
dance that summer I played bass so that
Doug and Russ could revert back to their
usual instruments. This was my first
paying musical job.

Our house in Spencer was near a
hippy commune called Dawes Hill,
located on some land bought by a few
Cornell students. A new friend who
built a yurt (a small round structure,
favored by the commune) on some land
near our house had an upright bass
which he kept at our house because of its
size and the vagaries of

humidity

in

a

temperature and

yurt. By the summer of '7

1

we had two basses, a piano, a banjo, a
fiddle, and a couple of guitars at our
house. Thus the stage was set for the

arrival of Fat City.
At this time a magician named Ricky
Jay was temporarily living in Ithaca. He

had traveled with the Mudthumpers,
and on one trip they were crossing into
Canada and were detained by the border
officials for lack of cash. The officials
were skeptical of Ricky's claim to be a
working magician until he made the

office's set of keys disappear,

and

re

appear when the officials let them cross.
Anyway, Ricky told us that he had
booked a job at the Salty Dog, a rockand-roll beer joint, for Walt Koken's
band from California called Fat City.
After George Dorian's death, Walt had

�studied judo in Ithaca and Japan, and
ended up back in the San Francisco area
where he took up the fiddle. The band
included Bob Potts, a San Francisco
native, on fiddle and Mac Benford,
originally from the Northeast, on banjo.
They had been on a musical pilgrimage
which had included a few fiddlers

conventions,

a

visit to Tommy Jarrell's

house, and a stop at the Smithsonian
Folk Festival in W ashington, D.C. There
they had played on the Mall near the
Washington Monument and captured
the attention of Ralph Rinzler, organizer
of the Festival.
As I recall, the band accepted our offer
of hospitality almost immediately after
their arrival in Ithaca. Their long weeks
on the road in Mac's old Ford panel
truck made our place in the country with
and
Dawes
Hill's large
pond nearby, look very
inviting. They stayed for almost two
weeks. The gig at the Salty Dog was a
success, I loved the music, and had the
same gut reaction to the band that many
a

garden,

swimming

people subsequently expressed to me
about the Highwoods Stringband:

I

wanted to take them home with me.
They seemed to personify the spirit of
those times: an innocent sexuality, a
benevolent craziness. I wanted to be part
and it reinforced my urge to explore
West Coast.
In time the 'Tat Boys" moved on to
Vermont, where Walt had a friend, and

of

it,

the

this proved to be a parting of their ways
for a while. Mac and Bob were ready to
go back home, but Walt was not, and
decided to stay in the East. A few weeks
after they left our place, he surprised us
by returning to Spencer. Doug and I

were happy to have him stay with us. We
played music many hours every day with
the intention of forming a band, and I
picked up the stand-up bass for the first
time. We played at the Spencer Picnic
Talent Contest and won the $50 first
our group's
prize playing "Ebenezer"
first music for money, and almost a

month's rent!

It wasn't too much later in the fall that
Walt went back to California to get his
family (Annie Cook and two children)
in his old Ford truck, and brought them
to live in Spencer. At that point we
started getting an occasional job in Ithaca
the
Busted
Toe Mudthumpers,
as
including playing on a live radio show
from a Cornell coffeehouse, "Bound for

Glory,"

and

the

first

tradition of jobs at
rant, a health-food
was back at school
since kindergarten
anyway. I
busy

of

a
continuing
Kosmos restau
establishment. Doug

the

and for the first
I

wasn't,

but

remember

I

.me
was

snowy

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

mornings

warm

keeping

around

the

wood cookstove. We were using Walt's
panel truck to haul firewood that we cut
with a two-man crosscut saw we found in
an abandoned barn. Walt and
helped a
I

shop at Dawes Hill,
we all went over and

little with building
and

sometimes
music

played
lamplight.

a

there

kerosene

the

by

Meanwhile Mac had relocated

in

rural

Maryland, not far from where Mike
Seeger and Alice Gerrard were living
then, and they had been getting together
to play some. We made plans to get the
full band together as the "Fat City Stringband" that spring with

a

trip to

Union

Grove, and Bob Potts was going to make
the trip east for the event. Also, Mike
Seeger enabled Ralph Rinzler to get in
touch with Mac, who as a Maryland
resident was eligible to play at the

Smithsonian

Maryland

was

Folk
the

Festival,

featured

state

since

that

year.
The trip to Union grove established a
pattern for the summer. The long drives
were broken up by occasional repair
stops in the two old panel trucks. We
would pull them up back to back and
stretch a tarp between the back doors.
Whoever missed out on a spot in a truck

slept on the ground, and we cooked for
ourselves on a Coleman stove since there
was no money for restaurants. We didn't
manage to win any prize money at Union
Grove, and it was cold and rainy, but we
did have fun meeting a group of dancers

the Green Grass Cloggers. One
night there was a big party in a tent with
called

Tommy Thompson, Bill Hicks, and
Malcolm Owen, who were playing with
the Fuzzy Mountain String Band.

a sound was beginning
emerge, "an awful big sound
wrote to my
amazing sound," as
In
those
days
nearly
everything
parents.
about the band was unusual: we were
from
outside the southern
young,
Appalachian region, and we had two
fiddles in the band. We were popular

From our band

to

I

with the old-timers everywhere, and we
won first place at the Marion, Virginia
fiddlers convention. From there we all
stayed a while with Mac, who had moved
to

the

Norfolk, Virginia. We spent days on
beach

and evenings

learning tunes

and working out some vocals.
The big event of the summer was the
week we worked at the Smithsonian
Folklife Festival. Our band's fee was
$500 for the week. As I wrote to my

parents,

"They

worked

us

very hard,

�workshops in the morning at 11:00
where we played for 20 minutes, then
other bands (including Ola Belle Reed's)
played. Then some days we did 1:00
p.m. shows, then square dances every
day at 5:00. Then we would eat dinner
on meal tickets at the National Art
Gallery cafeteria, then go to a party at the
house of someone at the festival.
we
Mike, Alice,
played music all night.
Hazel

Dickens were there and Rosalie

Sorrels and Utah Phillips and others
nice parties
Some days I went
around to museums when we weren't
for the air

conditioning."

working,
On the fourth of July we swept the
at
the
first annual
Fiddlers
prizes
Convention (looking back on it, it seems
that

odd

they

let

us,

a

hired

band,

compete). The next day the Washington

Post had a picture of the band on the first
page of the "Lifestyles" section, as well as
a picture of me playing bass on the inside
where "The Sprawling and Splashing
Festival Folk" article continued. We had

been

featured for 10
hour-long public TV

minutes on an
broadcast, and

to the Post, "the Fat City band
was the hit of that show too. They set in
motion foot-tapping, head-bobbing and

according

"Lee Highway Blues," since it captures
the feel of that summer when we spent so
many hours driving up and down 1-81
(which in Virginia follows the route of
the old Lee Highway). Walt's truck was
parked nearby, and to introduce the tune
he ran over and honked its horn.
About this time we learned that the
Smithsonian
wanted to do some
booking for us, including some tours

with the Smithsonian Folklife
Company. We were excited about the
prospect of real money, since at this
time,

as

I

wrote to my parents who were

sending me 1 00 per month, "the money
from one job usually runs out before we
reach

the

next."

But

the

Smithsonian

The judgement cautioned that "a
wanderer has no fixed abode; his home is
the road. Therefore he must take care to
remain upright and steadfast, so that he
sojourns only in the proper places,
associating only with good people. Then
he has good fortune and can go his way
unmolested." We had considered Fire
on the Mountain as a band name, but
Walt felt strongly that the name should
describe the type of music we played. He
also felt the name should appeal to as
many people and offend as few people as

possible. Finally when we couldn't use
he
Fat City
suggested
"Highwoods
Stringband." We all liked it, and it stuck.
Eventually Mac and Bob both moved to

new name

the Ithaca area, and the band's career was

City was used by a
Washington-area band that sometimes
backed up John Denver. We had been
thinking about different names for the

launched. Our music took us many
places, from Rio de Janeiro to Berne,
Switzerland, but I don't think any time
was more fun than that summer in Fat

people wanted us to find

since

a

Fat

band since Walt, Doug, and
the

Mudthumpers,
consulted
the
I

I

played

The Wanderer.
56,
image reads:
Fire on the Mountain:
The image of the wanderer.

hexagram

as

and at one point we
and
threw
Ching

L'ti

The

City.

Washington

Post,

Washington,

D.C.,

July

5,

1972.

that
would continue
hand-clapping
through the afternoon." Describing the
atmosphere at the festival, the article
concludes, "If they weren't all in motion,
you would think Norman Rockwell had

painted the
We went
the summer
into a new

whole happy scene."1
back to Ithaca and enjoyed
and the

ponds, and moved

house. Soon it was time for
Galax, the big fiddlers convention in
southwest Virginia. A letter to my
parents mentions meeting friends of Fat
City from California and the Mid-West,
and
think these included Bob Naess,
Wayne Erbsen, and Hank and Sandy
Bradley, who later visited us in Ithaca.
The band's sound was getting tighter by
then and we won fourth place old-time
band. Walt also won third in the fiddler
contest, making him the top old-time
fiddler there (since separate categories for
I

Link

bluegrass and old-time fiddle were not
created at Galax until 1974
Ed.) So we

Thompson/courtesy

Jack

were pretty pleased with ourselves by the
end of the summer of '72, but tired and
ready for a break.
Back in Ithaca, we were getting some
from Rounder Records
to make a tape for a record. Walt had
known Ken Irwin since the old Busted

Toe Mudthumpers days, and we knew it
would be helpful to have a record to sell.
In the

fall we made the tapes for

F ire on

Mountain. It was recorded outdoors
with two microphones, and more or less
mixed live. One of our favorite cuts was
the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Eric

encouragement

1971, Berkeley, Ca.
Walt Koken, Jack Link, Bob Potts

Fat City String Band, early
L-R: Mac Benford,

�Join us for the Best in Bluegrass
I||lyJ 22

23

'

'

R°thvoss Farm,
miles south of Hillsdale,
off of Route 22 near the
M.Y./MA./CT. border

24-

s

N.Y.,

Seldom Scene Hot Rize, Country
Gentlemen Nashville Bluegrass Band Tony Rice Unit
John Hartford Peter Rowan, Tony Trischka &amp; Skyline, Dry Branch
Fire Squad, Fiddlestyx, Walt Michael St Co., Good OT Persons, Bill Lowe,
Bill Monroe

Ham Branch

Informative workshops under a
separate tent with a sound stage;
full

range of food concessions;

showers; 24-hour security and

first

aid tent and staff; free rough

camping (for 3-day ticket holders);
gates open at noon on Thursday;
music begins at 1:00 a.m. Friday.
1

To

Admission at Gate:

Information

Sunday $16
Saturday $22 Weekend $45
Kids under 12 free; Dogs $20
(with proof of rabies vaccination.)

Tremont City, OH 45372
(513) 788-2556 (1:00-9:00 p.m.)

Friday $20

&amp; Advance Tickets:
Winterhawk
P.O. Box 161

Three-day camping tickets available until April 1st
for $35 and from April 1st through June 30th
for $40 each.

order tickets send payment along with a self-addressed stamped envelope. Make checks payable to Winterhawk.
Please DO NOT send cash. To charge tickets to your VISA or MasterCard call (513) 788-2556.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�HERE
&amp;

THERE
Litte Rock Area
by

David

Peterson

R.

cultural

educational

awareness,

standards,

political

activism,

David

attainment,

Peterson

The eminent Ozark folklorist Vance
Randolph once described his fellow
Arkansans as being "deliberately unpro
gressive." As measured by economic

number of large cities,
amusement parks, and industrial
complexes, Randolph's words still ring
the

Courtesy

and

true: many folks, both natives and recent
would wear the label
immigrants,

"unprogressive" proudly,

if they

what

all

it

meant. This seems

for the

preservation
traditional music.

Galax,

Branson,

or

Nashville in the state. We like it this way,
unobtrusive,
generally unspectacular,
but laid back, enjoyable music and
dancing.

above remarks
Notwithstanding
Arkansas'
character,
during
concerning
the recent modernization (e.g. paved
roads, rural electricity) and economic
expansion phase (about 1940-1970),
the traditional music thread got pretty
thin, and old-time dancing was almost
the

entirely

abandoned.

Fortunately,

Arkansas has had its own versions of
Sam
Queen and Bascom Lamar

Lunsford.
At

Mountain

View

in

the

Sesquicentennial

at

Conway, Ark., 1986

knew

the better
and enjoyment of

Indeed, Arkansas shares a rich musical
heritage with the rest of the South,
particularly the Southern Appalachians.
Arkansas has had its share of bands
ragtime, blues, stringband, bluegrass,
and
brass;
dancing
community
cotillions, quadrilles, reels, swing,
couple, jigging, modern
European
but
despite the best efforts of the
square;
Chamber of Commerce, we still have no

Dollywood,

The Petersons.

early

1960s, Jimmy Driftwood (of "Battle of
New Orleans" and "Tennessee Stud"
fame), John Opitz, Eddy Walker,
Wilbur Mills, and
Representative
others started working on the idea of a
folk center. The Ozark Folk Center
was finally completed in 1973, and was
incorporated into the Arkansas state
park system. The initial goals of the Folk
Center
offering a non-political and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

non-exploitative showcase

and learning

preservation of Ozark
have been
crafts, music, and dance
largely achieved (except for the political
part). For instance, all tunes on the
nightly programs must be at least 45
years old and meet the approval of
center

the

for

resident

scholar

and

Bill

folklorist

McNeil.
program at the Folk Center is
more than 140 performers
diverse
and includes a
appeared last year
growing list of workshops. Next year's
list includes: Championship Fiddling
Invitational (April 8, 9), Gospel

Jubilee, Dulcimer Weekend (April
22-24), String Band Jamboree

Qu^Y

Autoharp Weekend (Aug.
Folkdance Weekend (Sept.

26,
9,

State Old-Time Fiddle
Championship (Sept. 23, 24), Fiddle
10),

and Dance Jamboree (Oct.

SPBGMA

Fiddlers Association (founded

National

8, 9), and

Fiddle

1970s

in

the

Faril Simpson) meets

by
early
on the third Sunday of every month at
1:30 at the Lewis Science Center on the
campus of the University of Central
Arkansas in Conway. The idea of the
meetings is tune sharing, not polished
performance, but there are at least ten or
so fiddlers who are well worth listening
to. Faril is one of the few people I know
a

The

30),
27),

about anyone who shows up to play,
with dancing whenever anyone wants to.
It is a community gathering of the first
order, and is well attended.
Good old-time fiddling can be found
in most areas of the state. The central
Arkansas chapter of the Old-Time

has produced Mexican bluegrass
LPs in Spanish. I'm sure he has a few left

who
if

you are interested.

Two
other organizations with
unfettered enthusiasm for old-time

This year, the state fiddle contest was

music are the Rackensack Society of
Pulaski County (to distinguish it from
other Rackensacks) and the Arkansas

the open

Rackensack was founded more than 25

Championship (Oct 28-30).

expanded to include a junior
and senior division as well as
contest. This is in part an
the development
maintain

division

effort to
of good
young players like recent winners Tim

Crouch

times), Wayne
Massengale, Scotty Branscum, and
Bob Atchison.
(four

Other good bets in the Mountain
View area are Jimmy Driftwood's Friday
night programs at "the barn," and the
Saturday night shows downtown on the
square (inside during winter). The
programs on the square feature just

Country
years

ago

Fisher,

cartoonist

Dance

in
a

for

Little

Society
Rock

well-known
the

(ACDS).

by

Arkansas

George

political

Gazette.

(every first
monthly meetings
Monday at 7:30 at the Arkansas Arts

The

Center) are relaxed and of general good
quality. An audience highlight seems to
be the

traditional barnyard-animal-noise

maker. About 15
standard program

groups

play

on

a

outsiders are
welcome. Several regional groups,
including Lark in the Morning, the
and

�Williams Family,
Family,
at

in

and

the

Peterson

part, got their musical starts

Rackensack.
ACDS was founded about ten

The
years

Kelly,

ago by David Peterson,
and others. They dance

Neil

their

specialities: old-time

squares, contras,
clogging, English, polkas, waltzes, etc.,
every Friday night (God willing that the
termites are really dead) on a grand
wooden floor at the American Legion
Post on 33rd and Gum in North Little
Rock. On the first, third, and fifth
Friday nights, all dances are taught, out
siders are welcome
including string
band musicians, and one does not need
in
order to dance.
to be partnered
the Folk Dance
include
activities
Special
Festival at Mountain View, the gala
Twelfth Night celebration (an EnglishScottish festival in full costume) on the
first useful Saturday of the new year, a
clogging festival, about 30 programs and
dances for conventions and festivals, and
two performances for the
this year
Arkansas Opera Theatre.
Luckily, the ACDS has a solid core of
dance musicians: Ed Hale on hammered
dulcimer and concertina, Bill Beard on

L.D. Riddling on mandolin,
Grover Smith on bass, Kurt
Weideman on whatever we need, plus a
guitar,

of about ten others
who show up to play or dance depending
on the mood. The lead fiddlers are Ken
Blessing (about 65 years old) and Chris
Peterson (just turning 15). Chris placed
sixth in the old-time fiddle contest at
Mountain View two years ago. Ken is
not a flashy fiddler, but he lives up to his
name. Of the 400 or so dances he has
played for me, he was late exactly once

loose assortment

by

5

minutes. Like many old-time

fiddlers, he has great stamina, and once
we set the tempo he is steady as a rock
through a 15-minute Southern square or
rhythm experiments by other members
of the band. Recently, Ken was called on
to play several hours at a craft show and
then for an hour-long dance program.
During the dinner hour he played at a
retirement housing project. Later, he
finished off his day with a regular Friday
night dance of three hours.
For more information about activities
in central Arkansas contact: David R.
Peterson, 52 Ridge Drive, Greenbrier,
AR 72058, 501-679-2935.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�country. His playing preserves a large
repertoire of archaic 19th century solo
tunes as well as the smooth, bluesy
stylings of the Leonard Rutherford
tradition. His recent LP Clydeoscope
(County 788), a sampler of these varied
talents, has been enthusiastically
received by the old-time record audience
as one of the best offerings of 1987.
Bobby Fulcher will accompany Clyde on
banjo during the tour.
The Troxell Brothers, Ralph (fiddle)
and Clyde (banjo), have been knocking
out dance music together since child

hood, and they

are heirs to an

extensive

family musical heritage. Ralph remains
the most popular square dance fiddler
on the plateau, and Clyde also solos
on fretless banjo and mountain vocal
numbers.
Johnny Ray Hicks is the last active
member of Tennessee's ballad-singing
Hicks family, whose huge repertoire,

collected

in the

1970s, represents

a

land

mark in American folksong. His story-

songs include British and American
standards, local Cumberland ballads,
and original compositions, delivered in a
raw, powerful style that places him with
best of the classic a cappella
the
mountain singers. Also a fine raconteur
Johnny Ray will serve as emcee for the

Firm dates are April 2

D.C.

booklet.

documentary

All

the

performers
represented on the anthology.

The

Local sponsors will be able to provide
about individual
information
more
concerts. Further details can also be
obtained from the project director, Robert
Cogswell, Tennessee Arts Commission,
320 Sixth Ave., No., Suite 100, Nashville,
TN 37219, phone 615/741-1701.

tour

with other fine
along
from the area, will be

musicians,

tours

open

performances on March

with

1 1

and

three
March

Crossville, Tenn. (sponsored by
Cumberland County Playhouse),

12 in
the

followed

concerts

by

Morristown,

Tenn.

March

17

in

(The Rose
Rogersville,

Center), March 18 in
Tenn. (The Rose Center), March 19 in
Hiddenite, N.C. (The Hiddenite
Center), April 7 in Knoxville, Tenn.
(jubilee Community Council), April
13 in

and

Athens,
Dance

Ga.

(Athens Folk Music

Society), April 15 in
Montgomery, Ala. (Alabama State
Council on the Arts), and April 16 in

Huntsville,
Alabama

in

Ala.
(University
Huntsville).

of

The eastern leg is being added to the
original tour in response to interest by
presenters outside of the SAF region, and
all details for it have not been finalized.

Robert

Cogswell

tour concerts.

1 in Washington,
(National Council for the
Traditional Arts), April 23 in Dover,
Del. (Brandywine Friends of Folk
Music and the Delaware Agricultural
Museum), April 24 in St. Johnsbury,
Vt. (Catamount Arts), and April 25 in
Providence, R.I. (Brown University).

The tour coincides with the upcoming

release of another related record project
from Fulcher's work. The two-volume
set, slated to appear as County 786 and
787, will present an anthology of tradi
tional music from the Cumberland
Plateau, with a wide range of historic and
recent field recordings and a thorough

Cumberland Music Tour performers: front-Virgil Anderson; rear L-R: Johnny Ray Hicks,
Hershel Anderson, Ralph Troxell, Clyde Troxell, Clyde Davenport, Willard Anderson, 1987

The

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�hear, in the early to mid-60s, the likes of

Clarence Ashley, Dock Boggs, Kilby
Snow, Mississippi John Hurt, Son
House, Elizabeth Cotten, Ernest

and oh-so-many others. It
was the place where so many of the pop,

regularly

Joseph

past

10

twice

years.
a

They are held

month

Taulane. They

with
are

caller

about

to

change locations. For information call
1619) 282-6797 or 481-1974.
Drowsy Maggie's Folk Cafe features
mixture of old-time, Irish, and
a good
general folk stuff. It is located at 3 1st and
University, San Diego. Unfortunately,
the area's best folk club, the Old-Time
Cafe in Leucadia, is closing at the end of
January, but the folks who run it plan to
keep active by doing regular theater-type

concerts.

more musicians in
the area than those who work regularly
at music. For most it's a labor of love,
of much wider
but those
worthy
There are always

The Somewhat Sawyers
String Band (Ed Cormier, John
Wright, Ansel Grey, and Bob Zink);
Los Alacranes Mojados (the New Lost
exposure

are

City Ramblers of Mexican bands)
they not only play well, learn from the
old 78s, but they can explain it to us

Anglos; Tom "Tomcat" Courtney,
veteran West Texas bluesman who has
been playing regularly in the area for
about 20 years; and Sister Helen
Sanders &amp; Family, outstanding gospel
music in the old shouting style. Other

old-time musicians working

in

John

Curtiss

the

for

Lou

Kenny Hall ca. 1977

folk, and old-time musicians of today
got exposed to the music here on the
West Coast.
The other big happening here on the
Los Angeles-area old-time music scene is
that a group
of musicians
and
performers active in country music in
the '30s, '40s, and '50s have gotten
together to promote their sound, but,
maybe more important, just to get
together. It started with a party at the
home of Hank Penny. He called it a
"let's have a party
before we have to
have another funeral
party." The party
has led to other parties, some concerts
(including a sell-out crowd at Pasadena's
Arboretum) and general re-awakening
of interest in performing by many of
these one-time top country-music
artists. They include, along with Hank
Penny (great country singer-comedian
who started his career playing guitar at
fiddle contests in Atlanta for Fiddlin'

Courtesy

Virginia

Curtiss

Stoneman,

Carson), Doye O'Dell, Wesley

Marilyn Tuttle, Stuart
Hamblen, Cliffie Stone, Patsy
and

Montana,

and a host of others who
once worked the barn dance shows out

here ("Town Hall Party," 'Hometown
Jamboree," etc.). Lots of these people

would

be

great

at

folk

and

old-time

music festivals, but promoters rarely
think of the West Coast when it comes
to old-time music. Hank Penny can be
reached at 21710 Tuba St., Chatsworth,
CA 9 1 3 1 1 He can put you in touch with
most anyone else. If he can't, I can. I'm
Lou Curtiss (619) 282-7833.

the area

Reid, Tom and Judy
Carlstrom, Lee Birch, Fred Gerlach,
Ron Horvitz, Roger Belloni, Evie
Nathan, Dave Swarens and Vykki
Grey, Walt Richards, Ian Law, E. Z.
Marc, and Ron Jackson.
are

Bruce

The mayor of San Diego has just
declared this the "Year of the Arts" in
San Diego. I hope that includes folk and
old-time music. We'll see.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Virginia

I
guess the biggest news in southern
California for old-time fans is that Ed
Pearl plans to re-open the Ash Grove
in Los Angeles. The old Ash Grove was a
place where southern Californians could

Curtiss

Elsewhere in Southern California

Kirk McGee, Sam McGee,
at

and Patsy Montana

the 8th San Diego Folk Festival

�BENJAMIN FRANKLIN JARRELL
1933-1987
On December 20, 1987, B.F. (Benny)
Jarrell lost the relatively short battle he
had waged against throat cancer. He died

Benny Jarrell
man, and

a

a

gentleman,

in

family

missed."

home where he had
been cared for by his brother, Wayne,
and sister Ardena. It seemed as though a
musical chapter had ended when the
community lost this last active fiddler in
the Jarrell musical line, which extended
directly from the elder Ben to Tommy,
and with the changes inspired by the new
music called bluegrass, from Tommy to

peacefully

a

true friend. He will be sadly

his

―Alice

Gerrard

B.F., his youngest son.
B.F. started playing his father's fiddle
he was
13 and as his talent
he
was
influenced and
developed

when

by his uncfe, Oscar Jarrell,
"Uncle" Joe Johnson, Jim Eanes. Roy
Russell, and others. As was the case with
so many other young musicians during
this time, Benny was more interested in
learning bluegrass than old-time fiddle
styles.
He became a member of Jim Eanes'

encouraged

band in the early 1950s. At that time the
band
included Hubert Davis, Roy

Russell, Bill Bedsaul, and Arnold Terry.
In 1954 Benny and Roy Russell joined
up with Hack Johnson, Allen Shelton,
and Joe Phillips and played around the
Raleigh, N.C. area.
In the mid-70s B.F. recorded a fiddle
album for Heritage Records, Lady of the
Lake, now unfortunately out of print.
On this album he featured three tunes
that he had learned from his father:

"Breaking Up Christmas," "When
Sorrows Encompass Me Around," and
"Chilly Winds."
Besides his skill as a musician, B.F.
a great
talent as a disc jockey and
radio announcer. I had the privilege of
hearing him announce on local radio

had

several times in recent years and wish I
had taped it. That great tradition of the
a mixture
of goodcountry radio DJ
natured huckster, a certain amount of
shuck and jive, and droll country wit;
always in direct, personal touch with the
were all essential
local audience
elements of his style.
On

November

Hometown Opry
on

a

benefit

7,

members

of the

Airy, N.C. put
barbecue supper and
in Mt.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

concert to help raise money for some of
B.F.'s hospital bills. It was held in the
Toast community elementary school
cafeteria and gym with many local oldtime and bluegrass musicaians donating
their time and talents to performing as

well as cooking and serving supper.
More significant than the memory that
was raised was the demonstration of

affection that was shown that night. The
gym was packed, and the show went on
until after midnight. All thejarrells were

there,

including

B.F.'s

daughter,

Brittany, and his son, Dennis. During
the course of the evening, B.F. spoke
some heartfelt words from the stage
about what the event meant to him, and
about some of the changes he had under
gone during the course of the last few
battled his
years as he successfully
alcoholism and attempted to beat down
cancer.
wrote the following
Eanes
Jim
testimonial to his good friend and
musical partner.

"December 20, 1987, was a sad day I
will long remember, when I received a
telephone call to tell me that my long
time friend and fellow musician B.F.
(Benny) Jarrell had died.
"I

first

met

Benny

in

1951 when

I

offered him a job with my band, the
Shenandoah Valley Boys. He was a
versatile musician and played fiddle and
helping me to form a solid band
one that helped me in
during this time
career
musical
through the years.
my
bass,

There were many visitors to 734 S.
Franklin Road in Mount Airy, N.C.

Mostly they came to see Tommy Jarrell,

but nearly all of them met his son B.F. in
the process. Regardless of the pain B.F.
caused him, Tommy knew what a gifted
man his son was, and I only wish more of
those visitors could have had a chance to
see beyond the problems caused by
B.F.'s alcoholism.
Those who did discovered an
intelligent, talented, and generous man.
Like his sister Ardena and brother
W ayne, he was heir to the famous J arrell

hospitality, and could
host

be as

gracious

a

they come. Family was extremely
important to him, to the extent that
even a distant relative like myself was
made to feel snecial.
as

He had an active, inquiring mind. He
was fascinated by the history of the

American West; he read every book he
could find on the subject, and even made
a pilgrimage to some of the historic sites.

He also had a keen sense of humor. He
often had a joke to tell, and he loved to

completely deadpan,
spin out a story
every word and phrase heavy with sig
nificance. You never knew for sure when
was pulling your leg: sometimes a
story had no point or punchline, but he
told it as it if did, always with one eye on
you, scrutinizing your reaction.
he

He was a sensitive and perceptive
observer of human nature. He watched
people as intently as he listened to their
music. I always had the disquieting
feeling that he could see through people,

taking them apart

in

his

mind till he

�discovered what made them tick. If you
were putting on airs, he could make you
pretty uncomfortable; but if he liked
what he saw, he let you know it.
He was, of course, a skilled bluegrass
musician, but one who knew as much
(or more) about the local old-time
music

anyone

as

When

you

carefully.

played,

who

B.F.

He didn't miss

played

it.

listened

lick, and he
if you did.
significant than his
a

wouldn't hesitate to tell you

Even more
musical accomplishments are his victory

over

alcoholism and his philosophical
of the illness that overtook

acceptance

him just as his life appeared to be in
order. Both are a testimony to his inner
strength. After many long, bitter years
of searching, he found his self-respect
and earned our respect as well. He died

peace with family and friends, at peace
the world, and at peace with
himself.
at

with

―Brad

Leftwich

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Dixie

Bee-Liners and more recently the
Buzzard Brothers.
The music of Harold Hausenfluck is

When you say old-time music, please say
old-time country. Beethoven is old-

and XXII/ with Abe Horton: Sweet Sunny
South, and Cornbread, Molasses, and
Sassafras Tea, Rt. 3, Box 278, Galax, Va.
24333). He is also on several anthologies
and has a privately issued cassette tape of the
Buzzard Brothers which may be obtained by

'60s my grandmother up in
Highland County, Virginia, got me a
Victrola that played the discs. Well, I
never heard of a wind-up record player.
The only thing I knew was the wind-up
toys I had, and I said I want to see that
bird. So she had some of John Carson's
records in there and Henry Whitter, and
I think
there was one in there by Ernest
Stoneman, and Arthur Tanner. There
was an Eck Robertson record in that
collection, but a lot of it got busted and,
of course, I went the ways previously
mentioned until about 1 968, when a gal I
was in love with checked out some
records on her library card of Wade
Ward and different ones on Folkways,
and her dad had some of the old RCA
Vintage series, some of which had Uncle
Dave Macon and Mainer's Mountaineers.
And when I was on the West Coast
from '71 to '73 I heard stations kind of
like this one playing anything from bible

readily available on record (Heritage 043

writing

Audio,

Liberty

824

Broad,

Va. 23220. Watch for reviews
of his records and tapes in future issues of the

Richmond,

Old-Time Herald.

and
musical
Harold
Hausenfluck
compatriot Joe Shifflett came to the
Philadelphia area on April 24, 1987, to
give a set of two concerts and two
workshops at the Newlin Grist Mill in

Glen Mills, Pa. On the day of the first
concert, Harold and Joe visited the

WXPN radio studios

in

timey too.

So what
early

happened was back

in

the

thumpers to the bad boys, and this kind
of music was no exception. Anything
you never heard on the radio normally,

would hear on KRAB (Seattle,
Wash.) or KBOO (Portland, Oreg.) and
you

it was through them, you know, I found
out about these labels like County and
Rounder reissuing all this stuff. Also
back in the early '60s I had heard my
daddy talk about when he used to listen
to the Grand Ole Opry on WSM. So I
used to listen to that sometimes, and
there's where I heard people like the
Crook Brothers, the Fruit Jar Drinkers.
In
fact, the first clawhammer banjo
pickers I ever heard were Kirk McGee,

Brother

Stringbean, and
Louis Marshall Jones
is his name.
So that's kind of it in a
nutshell,
complete with, you know,
hitting fiddlers conventions.
Oswald,

Grandpa Jones

when you started attending
fiddlers conventions
was when you
started seeing live musicians.
EF: So that

Philadelphia,

playing live and talking with Emily Fine.
The following is excerpted from that

interview.

Our

thanks

to

Susan

Lamoreaux, who
Campbell
the
to
the
appearance,
sponsored
WXPN staff who facilitated the on-air
interview, to Maryanne Ferrell, who
transcribed the interview, and to Harold
and

Paul

Hausenfluck and Joe Shifflett.

EF: Tell me
Harold.

a

little bit about yourself,

Well, what do you want to know?

HH:

How did you get started play frig oldtime music, and how were you attracted
EF:

to

that,

rather

than

rock-and-roll

or

other kinds of country music?
HH: Well,

kinds

I

was attracted to those other

of music.

That's what I played
originally. I played country from the
'50s and '60s. I've played folk music of
that era like "Puff The Magic Dragon,"

bluegrass, and I've been exposed to
type of singing that you to
voice lessons for and I hated every
minute of it from the start; but I've
always been a diehard country musicfian.

Fajardo

etc. I've played the Beatles. I've played.
bluegrass too. I used to be into the

heavy

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Lincoln

well,
early
that
have

Abe Horton and Harold Hausenfluck,

1978

�HH: Right you are. See, I heard about
them through the liner notes on those
records out of the Library and I started
going to Galax, and you'll see on my

short

Sweet

teaching for nine years and I've taught

South album with Abe
called it an "eye opener. "And I
used to associate with anybody that was
an oldtimer, young or old. They'd say,
"Oh, I learned this tune from so-andso." So, you know, I figured since they
learned the tune from a certain oldtimer
they're bound to have some similarities.
Sunny

Horton,

We

all

I

surprised in my life as to how different it
was. And the oldtimers
some of them
were just almost to the point of being
nasty.
you know, like I didn't know
what 1 was doing. I wasn't doing nothing
right and I had to make up my mind: did
I
want to play like the mainstream of
people or did want to preserve the old
sounds, and I chose to preserve the old
sounds. Now I'm not perfect. I don't
claim to be perfect but I'm still trying.
1

Now,

if

you had to give some advice

somebody who was interested in
playing old-time music, what would you
to

say, in

a

paragraph?

Well, that depends on what kind of
old-time music they want. If they want to
play Beethoven.
HH:

EF:

Okay, old-time country music.

don't know. It's kind
nutshell. The general
feeling, I guess, would be to look around
and try to decipher what's old-time and
what's not and, you know, get some help
along the way, ask questions, and once
you find people that you like, try and
imitate them. I guess that answers the
HH: Okay, Well,
of hard to put in

I

a

question.
EF:

people

in

just one-shot

situations even

some of the simplest techniques, and it
was amazing. Different ones caught on to
it faster than others.
EF: It takes

a

How

do

you

go

about

teaching

somebody music or are you just going to
play and let people imitate you?
Well, I have never put on a
workshop by myself before. I have
participated with other people. So
don't really know what to do. Probably
HH:

I

what my approach will be is to just show
people my influences and explain how
the basic techniques are done, because
it's really kind of difficult to give even
the slightest amount of training in the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

this stuff strictly by ear. It's the only way
to learn it. There ain't no other way. So
that way, when they hear the little things
at the workshops they can listen to it
over and over again, being as their
cassette or reel or whatever they're

taping with

really does. And so what I like to
people who will come

HH:

It

do

to encourage

to these

workshops, that, if they're really
interested in learning these old styles

know, to bring their tape machines
it. It won't bother me in the
least. In fact, that's the only way I teach
my private students. If they don't have a
tape recorder, then they better find
something else to do because I'm not
going to teach them. Because you learn
that
and

I

tape

exact replica.

what
was
Harold,
your first
instrument? Was it fiddle or banjo?

EF:

No, believe it or not it was the
harmonica. Back around 1960 my daddy
learned me. He played straight. He didn't
play like when they take a G harp and
play it in the key of D, like when they
play the Fox Chase or the old trains and
everything else. He didn't do that. He
just played pretty much straightforward.
And then I learned on the guitar
accidentally just figured out that one
could play it in open tunings, and I used
bar chords playing rhythm. Later on I
HH:

is

is an

long time to learn.

have our individual sounds. You

can't help it. But boy, when I found the
same source for the tune that some of
these young people found, I was never so

EF:

of time
and
period
expect
I don't
care who they are
to
come close to imitating it. And I know
what I'm talking about because I've been

anybody,

�Aunt Lou McRae, she's the one that
straightened me out and told me what I
was doing wrong. Old Pappy Glen Smith

tried and tried and tried, but she showed
me that drop thumb. The first piece I
played when I got straightened out was
"Hey, the Bell Cow" or just called "Bell

Cow."
Then when

want to slow something
down I can do it either with picks or
without it. The oldtimers, a lot of them
did not use picks when they did this roll.
They didn't use chords. That chord
I do that style
stuff came later in life.
too, but the older the better as far as I'm
I

concerned. But every music has
and
respect that. I don't like
I

things but

I

its place
a

lot of

it.

respect

EF: Tell me about the band that you're
playing with now, the Buzzard Brothers,
and how that came to be.

My friend Joe Shifflett. He's the
remnants of what we used to have of the
Dixie Bee-Liners, now one of the Buzzard
That was Joe's idea for that
Brothers.
name. He'd been wanting to call the old
Dixie Bee-Liners the Buzzard Brothers

done

anything

spectacular

of

because

too many other irons in the fire. But the
group consists of Wiley Mayo playing

fiddle or banjo, Joe Shifflett playing
banjo and banjo and banjo and banjo,
Harold Hausenfluck playing fiddle and
banjo and singing to the top of his voice,
smoking pipes and drinking whiskey.
EF:

a

guitar in it.

Liners had

a

I

know the Dixie Bee-

couple of guitars. Do you

prefer this older style?

HH: Well, that was the old-time style,

fiddle

and

a

know what

banjo.

a

They didn't even

a guitar was in many parts of
the rural South. I like either one myself,
but the musicians must play the music
like it's supposed to be. And the main
thing with the Buzzard Brothers, we just

haven't found a guitar picker
and you know, we kind of like
timey style with just a fiddle
banjos. But I like the guitars; I

anyway;
the oldand

the

like it.

By the way, I also like a harmonica and
bass player. Why do you think I like
the Crook Brothers? Especially back
years ago. My goodness, that was one of
the most energetic bands I ever heard
come out of anywhere, opry, Grand Ole
Opry or no Grand Ole Opry. That was a
real tight, energetic band, and I had the
fortune last January of '86 to talk to Mr.
Herman Crook on the telephone and
he's still on the Opry. As of last week
he's 88 years old. He said he never took a
drink of beer or whiskey. He never
smoked or chewed tobacco. He never
cursed, but he's still a Crook.
a

HH:

wouldn't let him.

but

I

EF:

How come?

HH:

I

don't know.

sound of the name.
EF: But

you like

it

I

just didn't like the

now.

Well, we ain't the Bee-Liners
anymore so we had to come up with
something original and some of us
guess have a change in heart so I confess
publicly. Jesus says if I don't confess
publicly he ain't gonna confess me
before God, so I'm confessing. And all
HH:

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

know-where want ice water.

noticed that your band doesn't

I

have

Harold Hausenfluck and friends, and,
you know, be it dance tunes or the folk
songs or both. I want to do, you know, a
solo fiddle album, a solo banjo album, I
want to do a gospel album, an album of
nothing but folk songs and vocals. It's all
kinds of plans I have; but people in you-

Scott

two-finger method, not realizing
that it was a predecessor to bluegrass.
And then I learned the Creed Birchfield
lick back in 1984. So I can play three
styles of banjo: two ways of two-finger,
and clawhammer.
try this

.we were just kind of temporarily
that.
the Buzzard Brothers. We never really

Cathy

used the slide. I think that was around
'61 or '62. I don't remember. But I do
remember that December 31 of '62 I
learned that regular way of tuning a
guitar and learned a few chords. Then
my third instrument was the fiddle. I
started that in '68 and then the banjo in
'60, claw-hammer style, and I did that
wrong for four years, and in 1970 I
accidentally landed on that fingerpick
style that you just heard Joe Shifflett do.
I used
to try to play bluegrass a little bit
and I couldn't get the Scruggs style, so I'd

EF:

have

You've made two records and you
a

tape

for

sale

of

the

Buzzard

Brothers. Do you have any plans
another record?

for

HH: Oh, I have loads of plans, honey,
but being as I'm unemployed and don't
have the facilities like you and some
other folks that I know, I have no idea
when that will come out. That's one of
the reasons that I'm taping the show
here, and my concerts like I did in New
York and New Jersey last year. What I
think I'm gonna do is someday put those
on a record, like jam sessions, if I get

whole bunch
would really
like to do. I'd like to do my one-man
band; it's a multi-track recording I've
experimented with at home till my Teac
some good mixes. There's
of different albums that

a

I

broke. I'd like to do several albums with

Willard's Dancing Doll (Limberjack)

�W

P

it

This. IS

chance.

your
A

I

I
I

WHY?

Jv

f

by

re.c.ordmj&gt;.

ot

Tg
m

Kirkhuff

Tehile

I

Here is what The Old-Time Herald said about the cassette tape, The Fireman's Dance: "\ wish I had known
Jehile Kirkhuff...no ordinary fiddler. His tasteful use of trills and vibrato, his firm control of phrasing and
effortless movement through intricate passages set him above the crowd. The diversity of his repertoire is
also remarkable., .the sort of player who gives each tune the distinctive treatment it calls for. His taste and
craft are impressive...." (Winter 1987-88)

I

I
M

is what The Devils Box said about his record album Autumn Breeze: "...I was impressed (if not
somewhat amazed) with his ability. It is easy to see why he was so highly regarded both at contests and by
his students... some very inspired fiddling... musically rewarding as well as interesting...".

Here

I

YOU CAN MAIL ORDER

&amp;.

I

handling):

H
M

The Firemans Dance (cassette only)
$7.00
Autumn Breeze (record only)
$7.00

M

M

and/

M

M

(we pay postage

M

M

or

Send for our list of other cassette tapes of Jehile

then order the ones you like.

You will choose from 19 different cassette tapes.

a

Your

&amp;

F

F

fiappiness

is

/&gt;

Guarantees) tr money

R

refunded

j^7

We are a registered NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATION and your money helps us record
and videotape the remaining old-timers who still play in the grand old traditional way.
ORDER &amp; ENJOY...
Mail

NOW

to: The

c/o

Jehilt Kirkhuff Old-Time Music Fund

Ed St Geraldine Berbaum
B°X 39
4s

j

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

x

"

�clawing of the banjos! ine clogging 01
Uncle Harold
the feet!
any
suggestions glady accepted.

ASK?

musicians I have known
were actually capable of playing accurate
notably John
pitches on washtub bass
Hayward of T.C. Horseflies fame, who
would occasionally play it during his
tenure years ago with the Correct Tone
String Band. He said it required a lot
more concentration than a regular string
bass."
F.R. also inquires about the price of a
washtub bass. The price, F.R., is the
price of a (used) washtub and broom
exceptional

Signed, Clemantine
(of Brandy wine)

Uncle Harold

Uncle Harold senses, behind the
humor of the words of Clemantine's
letter, an honest quest for a better way to
endure festivals. Uncle Harold has
found himself, in his long and as-yetunpublished career as a festival-goer, on
A:

(minus the sweeping appartus).

sides of the fence. The nonmusician/ dancer is bored, resentful, and
both

not

having

time,

but

sometimes

it's

time.

good

a

musician/ dancer

is

trying to have

well-nigh

when

you're

The

good

L.F. of Boston, writes Uncle Harold

impossible

that the words of the following song
"were heard over the radio station
WFCR in Amherst, Mass. in the early
summer of 1973." The song was "sort of
spoken/ sung by a single male voice with

a

feeling

responsible for somebody else's failure
to get into the festival scene. Has anyone
there got suggestions
for the
out
alleviation of this problem? Write your

orchestration."

accompanying

uncle. Maybe we can clear this up before
the next festival season is upon us.

Uncle Harold knows it's not
song,

but

today's

he

is

aware

old-time

an

that

OK,

old-time
many

musicians

of
are
out

yesterday's folkies. Somewhere
there an ex-folkie may remember.... and

UNCLE HAROLD

if

had an inquiry

the price and availability of
Old Time Music, the magazine published
Dave Freeman of County
in England.
Records informs us that the cost for 4
issues is $12 surface and $18 air mail to
the U.S. County Sales, P.O. Box 191,
Floyd, VA 24091, handles the magazine,
and you may order from them at the

you do, write your uncle.

regarding

S.T.

of

Brunswick,

wants to

Ga.,

know where she can get a shirt "with
musical emblems on the back, like the
ones the Slate Mountain Ramblers are
wearing on your fall 1987 issue." Uncle

Harold thinks they're dandy shirts, and
has
our
intrepid editor-in-chief
forwarded your inquiry to Barbara
Poole, the Slate Mountain Ramblers'
bass player, granddaughter of Norman
Edmonds, and the artist who did the
embroidery on the shirts.

write to you in desperation. Never
Q?
did I think I would find myself writing to
an advice columnist, but....
I
love my significant other, a superb
I

musician,

but

note, sing

a

bar

I

myself cannot play

nor dance

old-time

a

a

step. The

music festivals we frequent
hold no interest for me, but as time goes
on, we frequent more and more of them.
Once there, my S.O. is known to
disappear for hours on end. I have tried

organizing alternative activities for
myself and others in my sad position
bridge parties (with snacks), scrabble
games, baby clothing exchanges, cock
fighting. Nothing really works. believe I
cannot stand this
may be going insane.
unrelieved sawing at the fiddle! The
I

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

above price. Single issues are available at
$3.00, and back or current issues are
available.

R.B. of York, Pa., asks Uncle Harold
that other notorious uncle of
Uncle Dave Macon,
old-time music
that is
would approve of turkey ham.
Citing Uncle Dave as a "champion of
ham," R.B. adds, "connotations could be
made from his preference, and I'm not
sure I care to think of all of them." Uncle
Harold, after considerable deliberation,
replies that Uncle Dave probably would
have made unprintable comments about
if he feels

And the phantom black beetle arrived
on the wings of a bat.
The grasshopper coachmen are harnessing
mice to my carriage.

And the four coachlamp fireflys were
put into place by the rat.
Farewell to the appleseed pavement
And moss covered roadways,
The tall mushroom castles and fairytale
children and all,
may never again chance to fly upon
I

Dragonfly wings,
Or wait where the morning sun shines
on the pine needle wall,
Or wait where the morning sun shines
on the pine needle wall-

anything that passes for ham these days.

F.R. of Onancock, Va., wants to
know "Is the gut bucket still used in oldtime music?" The answer is yes

the
standard
four-string
acoustic bass is more often used, as the
gut bucket (or washtub bass) is really
just a percussion instrument incapable
of
Uncle Harold's experience)
(in
providing accurate pitches, although
writes: "A few
Brad Leftwich

although

for Uncle Harold to
Send your
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, Va. 24333.

�I

wish to purchase

a

1-year subscription

to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

I

is

my check/money

wish to purchase

a

$16.00 (foreign)

order for $12.00

1-year subscription

to The Old-Time Herald.

Name

Address

Enclosed

I

is

my check/money

wish to purchase

a

order fro $12.00

1-year subscription

$16.00 (foreign)

to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

is

my check/money

order for $12.00

$16.00 (foreign)

Send to: The Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Harry and Jeanie West
West Durham Station

P.O. Box 17067

Durham, N.C.

27705

(919) 383-5750

Fine Musical Instruments for the Serious Musician

Rare Collectors Items
Antique, Vintage and Good Used Guitars, Mandolins,
Banjos, Fiddles, etc.

New Items
Appraisals
Free

&amp;

Handpicked High Quality

at Low "No Frills"

for

Prices

Insurance Purposes

Friendly Advice Anytime

CURRENT STOCK LIST 394 S.A.S.E.
2 YRS. SUBSCRIPTION
Including Instrument

S5.00

Finder's Service

�Sales

County

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL

STOCK

IN

^^READYFORSHIPMENTpH

N

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS

Pjj

NEW RELEASES
*CMF-01

THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
Vol 1" Reissue fo 1920s material
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
HARVEY SIMPSON "Flat Foot In The Ashes" Old-time fiddle LP by West Virginia fiddler
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroes best early 1950 s Decca material
CHICKEN CHOKERS "Shoot Your Radio" Newly recorded old-time music by this Boston-area band
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
Vol 2" Reissue of 1935-38 recordings
UNCLE DAVE MACON "Over The Mountain
w/booklet
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish
EMRY ARTHUR "I Am A Man Of Constant Sorrow" Reissue of 1920 s &amp; 30's recordings
RICK ABRAMS "Wild Goose" Newly recorded old-time banjo tunes and songs

1

OH- 191

AHR-004
*REB-853

ROU-0241

*SH-3759
*ROU-0233
OH-0183

I

Q4

Py
ID

HER-070
OH- 190

HER-071

M

yi
P^J
P%J

Ob

NASHVILLE

BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
old-time LP,
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent

7.00

FF-415

a. ROBIcfft THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
THE HORSEFUES "Human Fly" Old-time music by this New York string band
CONFLUENCE Hammer dulcimer music by Lee Spears and Christopher Deane
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 1940 s King material
fiddler
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950 s &amp; 60s
etc
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T. Michael Coleman,
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
music
LEFTWICH &amp; HIGGINBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time
HEEHAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing
TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music
UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule Fine 1920 s/30 s sides
JIMMIE RODGERS "Train Whistle Blues" Super reissue of train songs by Rodgers- import
Vol 2 Classic recordings with the North Carolina Ramblers
CHARLIE POOLE
DEE &amp; DELTA HICKS "Ballads And Banjo Music From The Tennessee Cumberland Plateau"
WINK THE OTHER EYE Old-time fiddle band music from Kentucky, 1920's/30's recordings
Vol 2 Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
SKILLET LICKERS
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carroll County, Virginia
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920's/30's
1938-41
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from
etc
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL with Mike Seeger, Brad Leftwich, Benny Jarrell,
VIRGIL ANDERSON "On The Tennessee Line" Old-time banjo from the upper Cumberland
SEEMS UKE ROMANCE TO ME Traditional fiddle tunes from Ohio
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American fiddle music from Mississippi
EDDENHAMMONS COLLECTION Historic set of traditional fiddle music
FLATT&amp; SCRUGGS "Songs Of The Carter Family" Fine 1960 LP with Maybelle Carter
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings" His classic sides from the 1950 s
LOUVIN BROTHERS "The Best Of" Features their top songs from the middle 1950s

7.00

*ROU-0239

*CCS-

1

10

"CO-788
"REB-850

*FF-352
MA-014

*CO-790
*HH- 19842
*TR-1

CO-545
AJA-5042
CO-509
CO-789
MS-45003
CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406

B^
PU
IJH
CT

HER-63

CO-777

GFS-901

AH-002

SOUNDA-001

P-13263

*CCS-108
"REB-852

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted

Ufl

PjLJ

1

'ROU-0242
FCOT-005

TH-1001
*HAT-3022
*CO-791

■^1

.$12.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
0.00
7.00
7.00

by an

asterisk

"

00

7-00
7-00

7.00

lifl
nB
By
i^BB

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7-00

'!

-V
7.00

$10.00

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

L^B

FU
1^1

7-00

'

7.00

7-

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
$10.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

LJB

")

On all ORDERS in U.S.A. please add $1.50 postage &amp; handling
CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $4.00 postage for first 1-3 LPs, $1.00 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

7

U

QH
H--

J

�Record

Reviews

Holiness Quartet, J. P. Nestor and Norman
the
Tenneva
El
Edmonds,
Watson,
the

Ramblers,

Shelor

Family

and

the

Tennessee Mountaineers.
Yes,

THE
BRISTOL
SESSIONS
Historic

Recordings

Jimmie

from Bristol,
the First

Recordings

Tennessee:

Featuring

by the Carter Family and

Rodgers,

Additional Artists.
(C.M.F. Records
anthology)

and

Oil

Twenty-One
-L;

two-record

This collection documents what Johnny
Cash (and lots of others) called "the single
most important event in the history of

country music." The fact that it may be
difficult (if not downright impossible)
for fans of Juice Newton or Alabama, to
comprehend this statement, doesn't make
it

any less true. That's another issue which

I

won't get into right now, thank you.
In

of 1927,

late July

talent

scout

and

field

Mr. Ralph Peer,
recorder for the

Victor
Machine Company,
Talking
traveled with two recording engineers to
Their
the
city of Bristol, Tennessee.
purpose was to discover new talent (and to

record

some

previously

contracted

performers such as E. V. Stoneman and
Henry Whitter) for the Victor company, a
pioneer in the newly born country music
recording industry. The work they did
in
some of the finest
there resulted
recorded performances of old-time music
from the so-called "golden age," to say
nothing of the discovery of two of country
music's most beloved acts, the Carter
Family and Jimmie Rodgers.
The four sides of this set contain 36
selections. Artists included, besides the
Carters and Rodgers, are E. V. Stoneman
and company (Irma Frost, Eck Dunford,
Kahle and Edna Brewer, Walter Mooney,
Bolen Frost, George Stoneman and Iver

Edwards), B. F. Shelton, Blind Alfred
Reed, Mr. and Mrs. J. W. Baker, the West
Virginia Coon Hunters, Henry Whitter,
the Johnson Brothers, Alfred Karnes, Dad
the
Bull
Blackard's
Moonshiners,

Moonshiners, and the Alcoa
Quartet. Whoops! That's only the first
record. Don't forget Ernest Phipps and his
Mountain

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

there

is an

astonishing variety here

what Charles Wolfe's liner notes call
"an almost perfect cross-section of early
country music." Here is everything from
solo fiddle or banjo to full string band or
male quartet, and from the sacred to the
profane. True aficionados will be familiar
with most of the material. Much of it has
been reissued before on various labels. But
who cares? It's wonderful to have it all
pulled together and put into historical
perspective for us in one stunning package.
It would be pointless to go into the
merits of the individual performances.
Suffice it to say that there are some great
ones. Some are classics. Everyone will have
favorites (my own are the white gospel
pieces of Phipps, Karnes, and Stoneman),
but any one of the four LP sides provides
great listening for fans of early

music.

commercial

Much

praise is due to
with
the release of this
connected
everyone
record, which sets a high standard of
excellence for future similar projects.

country

(Frank

Dalton)

To order: CMF Records,
East,

4

Nashville, TN 37203.

Music Square

�Indian" (finger-picked
here)
worthy pieces of music well

are

all

treated.

understand Mansfield's
sentimental grounds of
"Golden Slippers," his grandfather's
favorite tune, would have preferred to
other less shop-worn
hear some
selection on this record. To some extent
the same observation holds true for
"Whistling Rufus," although Bill's fullAlthough
inclusion

I

can

on

I

length delivery of the song is unusual.
This last comment aside, this is a fine
first record from a solid musician. Bill is
rumored to perform a fine version of
Wilmer Watts' classic "Bonnie Bess."
I'll be looking for it on a future record.
(Craig Johnson)

To order: Flying Cloud Records, Rt. 2,
Box 436, Madison, NC 27025

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Old-time music has meant a lot of
different things to lots of different
people throughout the years. The early
of

the

music

industry
witnessed the recording of many superb
fiddle bands, bands whose names are
practically legendary in the present day,
and it is this fiddle-band sound that has
come to define most of what is under
stood to be "old-time music" today.
But in the '20s and '30s, as in this
decade, there were other significant
musical currents in motion. The golden
age of string bands also saw the rise of the
country singer. Such singers as Jimmie
the
Carter
Family, Riley
Rodgers,
Puckett, and Dave Macon enjoyed great
popularity, and although Puckett and
Uncle Dave were often associated with
string bands, their music was not wholly
confined to the fiddle-band tradition.
years

The

country

aforementioned

among the

musicians

are

"star" singers of the period,

names well remembered today, but there
and
were
many others working
of
whom
are
but
most
recording
unfamiliar names to modern audiences.
A case in point is that of Emry Arthur, a

Kentuckian

tumultuous

whose

life

confirmed the title of Old Homestead
Records'
recent reissue of his
Am a Man of
recordings. Emry Arthur:
I

Constant Sorrow.

Arthur was

a strong, straightforward
steady
guitar player. His
singer
voice is reminiscent of Kelly Harrell's, a
little rough around the edges and all the
more memorable for it. As noted in
Charles Wolfe's introduction to the
album, his recordings are in some ways a
study in contrasts. Many of his songs are
old standards from his home country
around Monticello, Kentucky. Emry
the
first commercial
Arthur
made
recording of Dick Burnett's "Man of
Constant Sorrow" as well as committing to
wax a version of "Going Around This
World," another tune common to the
Wayne County area. His 1929 recording
of "The Wanderer," a duet with fellow
is
a
Kentuckian William Rexroat,

and

a

moving performance hearkening back to
early musical experience with his
rural
musicians.
other
and
family
Arthur's brothers accompany him on
several cuts; their harmonica and banjo
his

style

mirror

Emry's

insistent,

metronomic approach to backup.

There is another side to the coin.
Young singers today may feel a need to
perform only "traditional" material, but
Emry Arthur was out to make a career of
his

music

and

whatever he liked,
suited him. He did
apolis

that

clearly

performed

with anyone who

a

included

session in Indian
radio
a polished

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Frank Owens, singing harmony
Emry's lead. Their voices are very
dissimilar and one wonders whether
Arthur was making a deliberate attempt
to move his music uptown. Two of these
cuts, "I Shall Know By the Prints of the
Nails in His Hands" and "Where the
Gates Swing Outward Never," feature
massive accompaniment from a pipe
organ. The lightweight "Heave Ho the
Anchor" is one of those songs that is so
bad that it's almost good. Almost. "The
Heart of the City Has No Heart" is
another Tin Pan Alley product, but
Arthur gives it considerable life
perhaps his own migration to the urban
North gave him firsthand experience of

singer,
to

the subject.

Emry Arthur was a good singer. I have
not been bowled over by this record, but
have enjoyed it, and enjoyed it more
with each listening. Old Homestead has a
second volume of Emry Arthur in the
I

works. I'll be looking for it.
Also new from Old Homestead is
Frank
Welling and John McGhee,
Sacred

and

Sentimental,

Silly

Songs.

McGhee, both of whom
West
the Huntington,
recorded
extensively
Virginia area,
during the late '20s and early'30s. They
released over 250 sides, a huge output
Welling
hailed

and

from

for any duet.

Nonetheless, they

are not

known to modern audiences for
reasons ably discussed by Ivan Tribe in
his notes to the album.
Welling was a fairly refined singer, a
good Hawaiian guitar player, and a
well

whose recording career
stretched into the late '40s. McGhee had
backwoods voice, played solid
a more
harmonica player. Their work together
is competent and confident throughout
musician

this record.
In

common

release,
There

with
this record

the
is

not

Emry
a

Arthur

knockout.

some
nevertheless,
is,
very
interesting music here. John McGhee's
harmonica performance, "Beech Fork

tune that seems to be part
"Hop High Ladies" and part "Wild
Horse," is really a pleasure, and his "Life
Ain't
Worth Living When You're
Broke" and "Hard Luck Jim" come on
Special,"

a

a
double load of buckshot. "Old
Kentucky Dew" and "Sweet Adeline at

like

the Still," parodies of "Nellie Grey" and

"Sweet Adeline" respectively, concern
themselves with the production of illicit

liquor, always a subject close to the heart
of country recording artists. Frank and
Thelma
Welling's rendition of the
chestnut "School Days" is delivered with
an affection that is a delight to hear.
If you're the sort of listener who likes
your music with a rough edge, then you

may find Welling and McGhee not quite
cup of tea. Fans of smoother

your

sounds, brother duets, and later country

singers will probably find this record
more to their liking.
from
Old
but
not
least
Last
Homestead comes Riley Pucket: Old
Time Greats Volume 2. Puckett needs
little introduction. Although he is most

remembered

readily

brilliant

today

as

the

idiosyncratic guitar player
with the Skillet Lickers, he also enjoyed
career as a soloist that
a distinguished
ended only with his untimely death in
Frank
Like
1946.
Arthur,
Emry
Welling, and John McGhee, he did not
if

confine his music only to "traditional"
pieces. As an active full-time musician he
played and recorded the music he felt his
audiences wanted to hear.
This collection of Puckett songs is not
best

the

Volume

I've
1

but

heard (I'm partial to
it is still very good. The

man was an amazing singer. I'd listen to
him sing selections from the phone

book. Any Puckett cut

is

worth hearing,

but some are better than others; and if
this record has a few yawns in it, it also
has some real gems.

Out There," the oft-recorded
never-duplicated Puckett tour de

"Way
but

force, is here, as is his effortless "Preacher
and the Bear." "Short Life of Trouble," a
song also recorded by Burnett and
Rutherford, is mournful, restrained, and
In common with some other
Puckett songs, "The Cat Came
Back" features an oddly timed, twisty
chorus that he takes in easy stride. It's

beautiful.
Riley

great.
I

could

selections.

do
"Tie

Strings Again"

not

helped

accompaniment

without

some

of

Your

Apron

bit insipid,

and it's

Me
is

a

to

the

the accordian
by
that replaces Riley's

sterling guitar work. "Puckett's Blues," a
rendering of Handy's "St. Louis Blues"
sounds strained, and the duet, "Broken
is
pretty but not
Engagement,"
But
Riley turns in a
exceptional.
splendid performance of the otherwise
trivial "Renfro Valley Home," another
example of his rare ability to take a song
and make it uniquely his own, and "The
Boston Burglar" is worth the cost of the
album by itself.
John Morris' notes to this album are

interesting, dealing as they do with
various aspects of Riley Puckett's life
and music, but there is little information
about the specific songs featured on the
record. Who sings the duet with Riley? Is
the fiddler on "Wednesday Night Waltz"
Clayton McMichen? I'd like to know, as
I'm sure other listeners would also. It's a
small point in light of Old Homestead's

�continuing commitment to the release of
classic early country music, an endeavor
that

has

done

much

to

revive

the

memories of manv deservine if nearly
forgotten musicians. Hats off. (Craig
Johnson)
To order: Old Homestead Records, Box
100, Brighton, Michigan 48116

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�of these important field
recordings. One can only hope that they
sell well enough to encourage people to
continue releasing musical gems such as
these. (Kerry Blech)

presentation

To order: County Sales, P.O. Box 191,

Floyd, Va. 24091

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�turn, and half measure. On half of the
tunes the band bows out and Harvey
plays some old pieces unaccompanied

they were probably most often played
long ago, before the introduction of the
guitar or even the banjo.
Harvey's playing seems to be done all
C for D and G for A
in low tuning
which is convenient for a banjo player,
and also lends a soulful whine that is
as

especially

effective

on

old

unaccompanied tunes like "Green Corn,
"Pine
Mountain," "Old Sledge,"
"Comin' through the Rye," and "Camp
Chase."
"Flatfoot in the Ashes," the title cut,
has my vote for the "hit tune" of the
album. After waiting through one round
for Harvey to get cranked up, the band
joins in, providing charming support on
this fine dance tune.
Flatfoot in the Ashes is sure to delight
those who treasure the archaic old-time
style of fiddling and who like to hear
seldom-heard and unique tunes. This
album is attractive, too, another colorful
beauty from Augusta Heritage Records.
Its extensive liner notes are taken from a
1986 article by Jacqueline
Spring
Goodwin that appeared in Goldenseal
magazine: "Big Possums Stir Late." Both
the article's title and the band's name
for
wait
to
refer
long
Harvey's
recognition among West Virginia's oldhe proudly
As
time musicians.
announces in the Goldenseal interview,
"I'm one of the big possums now. They
It
is
stir late sometimes."
certainly
preferable that this recognition came
later

rather

than

never,

for

Harvey

overdue for the
Sampson
appreciation he deserves as a represent
ative performer of this roughly hewn but
poignantly beautiful mountain music.
(Gail Gillespie)
is

To

order:

Davis

26241

&amp;.

long

Augusta Heritage Center,
College, Elkin, WV

Elkins

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

CLEOFES ORTIZ

Violinista

de

Nuevo Mexico

My Mother-In-Law

Has Tightened My

Boots/Valse Ruiz//D-minor Quadrilla/
La Virgincita/Redondo en Do/La Cuna
en
Fa/El Tecolote/The Cowgirl

(schottische)/The Italian/Cuadrilla
Porfirio

Padilla/Cleo's

High

E

de

Quadrilla/The

�rilla/The

Waltz/The

Broom

Indian

Woman/Tampico Hermosa/La

Marcha

Novios/Cuatro

Los

de

Por

Cuatro/Valse Emiliano/Rosita/
Redondo
Polka

de

Leyba/Paloma

F/F Cuadrilla/Valse

in

Panos/La

Cuna

en

Blanca/
de

Los

Sol/Home Sweet

Home
Cleofes

Ortiz-fiddle;

Augustine

Chavez-

guitar; Jeanie McLerie-guitar

Cleofes was born in 1910 near
New Mexico. He began playing

Bernal,

local
dances at 14, having learned local dance
tunes from his cousin Emiliano Ortiz,
who also taught him music he had
learned in lumber camps. Family duties
halted his playing until about 10 years
when he resumed
playing for
ago
community functions. Cleo's playing is
clear and stately. He could easily be
playing for a dance in Europe, where
many of these dances originated. Cleo,
assisted by Jeanie McLerie and Ken
Keppler, taught his tunes and dances at
the "Festival of American Fiddle Tunes"
in Port Townsend,
Wa. in July 1987.
The tunes alone have an elegant beauty,
but it all fell into place with the dancers
moving to his notes. Cleo enjoyed the
other music presented at the festival as
well, but was a bit puzzled by the contra
dance and music played by Rodney
Miller. He came back into our room and
said, "All they play are caudrillas. Is that
all there are?" He breathed a little easier
Cleo
with
the waltzes and polkas.
a dying art, but an important
aspect of traditional music in America.
At least he has been seen and heard
outside of his native area and his gift
preserved on tape. (Kerry Blech)

represents

To

order:

UBIK Sound,
NM 87196

Box

4771,

Albuquerque,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�You have the music with

The OLD-TIME HERALD

...Now you can have the whole mountain with

The

Mountain

magazine dedicated to the life, politics and
culture of the mountains, and paying special attention
to the Appalachians.
And, you'll get exciting and informative news on
national and international events.
The Mountain is a magazine bound on fulfilling the
curiosity of its readers.
A

In

every

issue

you'll

Government and Politics

■Bnsiness

get

You'll also find out what today's best books are, and
about some great books of yesterday you may
have missed.

informative articles on:

learn

and Education
and Social Affairs
and Research

Economics

You'll meet the people of the mountains, learn about
the culture and find out what political issues have put
fire in the veins of the mountain society in regular

Science
International Affairs
Culture
HUMOR

FICTION
In
2

or

features

&amp;

POETRY

issue you'll get
short stories by the best

every
3

writers.

mountains.
known

well

and

"A Day

new

play and

it.

Novels

alternative

The

Mountain

for

some

Inns

and

offers

the best

an

inexpensive

reading of today.
Plus, in our travel section we'll tell you what the
hottest mountain vacation spots are.
We'll give you information on:

Events
Resorts,

Hiking Trails and

of

covering the politics

of the

In the Life..." of real people who live, work,
build the mountains.

You'll get articles on
Art-- the craftsmen, musicians, dancers and artists of
the Appalachians, plus interesting coverage of national
and international art, music and drama.
Satire like "The Intellectual Hillbilly" that tells in a
humorous and memorable way who we hillbillies really
are and separates the facts from the myths.

Humor that will keep you laughing long after you've

read

like:

"Fire on the Mountain"

Hotels

ALL THIS

subscribe

Campsites

to

AND MORE can
Mountain.

The

be

yours

when

you

send in your subscription today, we'll send
you our Premier issue so you don't miss a thing.
And

if

you

Yes. Please start my subscription to The Mountain with
won't miss out on a tiling.
your premier issue so
I

Just fill in the coupon and send
with your check or money order to:
Mountain
Circulation Dept.-OT

SQ

The
P.

O.

Galax,

Box

VA

1010

24333

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

check or money order for:
Enclosed
95_ One Year Charter Subscriber Price
Subscriber Price
7. 00-- Two Year Charter
is my

SI

(6

(12

Issues)
Issues)

Name

Address
City

State

(Please Print Clearly

Zip
in

Ink)

oth siak

�6th ANNUAL WESTERN PENNSYLVANIA BLUEGRASS
OLD-TIME MUSIC
&amp; DANCE FESTIVAL
Memorial Day Weekend, May 27-30, Friday
Sat.
Horseflies
Critton Hollow

Monday

Sat.
Sat. &amp; Sun.

Coal Country Cloggers
Sun.
Dave Krysty

Hot Rize

Mon.
John Hartford
Fri.
Heartbeats
Laurie Lewis

&lt;Sc

Brady's Run Park in Beaver, Pa.

Bill Monroe &amp; the Blue Grass Boys
Osborne Brothers
Sat.
Lawson
&lt;Sc
Sun.
Doyle
Quicksilver

Sun.

&amp;c

at

Sun.

Sat.

McLain Family Sat.
Delores Hensy Sat.
Beaver Creek
Sun.
&lt;

Grant St. String Band

Carroll County Ramblers

Sun.-Mon.

Mon.

Mon.
more to be announced

Over 25 Old-Time &amp; Bluegrass bands in all!
Plus: Learning

Workshops Daily

to Include:

Old-Time &amp;. Bluegrass Banjo
Old-Time &amp;. Bluegrass Fiddle
Old-Time &amp; Bluegrass Guitar
Upright Bass, Autoharp, Dobro, Mountain
&amp;. Hammered Dulcimer.

Basic &amp;l Advanced Square Dancing
Basic &amp;. Advanced Clogging
Basic &amp;. Advanced Contras
Basic Cajun Dancing

Nightly Square Dances:

Fri.

Sat.

Sun.

Heartbeats; caller TBA
Critton Hollow; caller-Larry Edelman
Horseflies; caller-Delores Hensy

Clogging Contest Sunday

CASH PRIZES

Solo, duet, &amp; team (by

age

groups)

Separate Children's Stage with special children's concerts daily.
PRICES: In advance $25 all

4

days &amp; $5 per vehicle for camping (good all 4 days)
16 FREE.

Children under
412-457-7980, Beaver Valley

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Bluegrass,

P.O. Box 584, Beaver, PA 15009

�FESTIVALS!

CONVENTIONS!
are
Just Around
Advertise

The Corner!
Your Event
In The

OLD-TIME
Reasonable

HERALD
Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333
for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Xo
L3
V.1

#3

BULK RATE
U.S. POSTAGE

PAID

Woodlawn, VA
24381
Permit

#4

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12150">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 1, Number 3 (Spring 1988)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12151">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12152">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 1, Number 3 (February-April 1988)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dykes Magic City Trio,” by Charles Wolfe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Don’t You Remember the Time - Samuel Carlton Feeny 1913-1987,” by Pat Conte&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“A Summer in Fat City,” by Jenny Cleland Vittek&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Benjamin Franklin Jarrell 1933-1987,” by Alice Gerrard &amp;amp; Brad Leftwich&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Harold Hausenfluck, Young Oldtimer,” by Emily Fine&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – BUY OR BYE!,” by Mac Benford&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Willard Watson: Old-Time Flatfoot Dancer,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Little Rock Area,” by David R. Peterson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – The Cumberland Music Tour,” by Robert Cogswell&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Some San Diego Old-Time Notes,” by Lou Curtiss&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12153">
                <text>1988</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2100">
        <name>1988</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5428">
        <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5513">
        <name>Benjamin Franklin Jarrell</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5464">
        <name>Brad Leftwich</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5417">
        <name>Charles Wolfe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5518">
        <name>David R. Peterson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5509">
        <name>Dykes Magic City Trio</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5516">
        <name>Emily Fine</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5515">
        <name>Harold Hausenfluck</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5512">
        <name>Jenny Cleland VIttek</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5520">
        <name>Lou Curtiss</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5517">
        <name>Mac Benford</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5511">
        <name>Pat Conte</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5474">
        <name>Phil Jamison</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5519">
        <name>Robert Cogswell</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5510">
        <name>Samuel Carlton Feeny</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1883">
        <name>Willard Watson</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2516" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3442">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/d6069641b6d6d579343099cc54a20b3f.pdf</src>
        <authentication>2e621bc051155aad7287bd055ce0cfeb</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12154">
                    <text>$3.50
THE

OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Fall

August-October

ROY HARPER
The Ways Of The Past
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1988

�Since 1980

The

international

only

Autoharpoholic"
network

magazine has created the

serious autoharpers

of

by

uniting

players in all fifty states and a dozen foreign countries. It has
bonded together into one unified community representatives from
all areas of the autoharp world:
casual players, professional
musicians, autoharp makers, retailers, autoharp
festivals, workshops, and contests.

clubs, teachers,

Today The Autoharpoholic is still the only complete source
of information on autoharps, autoharp music, and autoharp-related
events for players of all brands of instruments.
Reading The Autoharpoholic
always makes me smile...

DON'T TAKE OUR WORD FOR IT-

LOOK AT WHAT ALL THESE AUTOHARPOHOLICS

SAY:

M.

L., Artist's

Model, Florence,

ITALY.

Real person, Tokyo, JAPAN: The Autoharpoholic inspired me to dust off and tune my instrument here in Tokyo and give it a
go once more.
MARGARET BAKKER, Autoharp co-ordinator, Denver Area Autoharp and Zither Club, Lakewood, CO: The Autoharpoholic is timeless. I'll never ever get rid of any issue.
PETER BEDINO B ARBERIO, Autoharp luthier, Missoula, MT Thanks to this publication the autoharp is being restored to its
rightful status. It promotes the common interest.
CATHY BARTON &amp; DAVE PARA, Musicians, Boonville, MO: A subscription to The Autoharpoholic means being received into an ever-widening circle of musical friends.
BILL ALDACUSHION,

JOEL BAUMGARTEN, Real person, New Salem, ND: In catching up on back issues, I was like a little kid with cookies: Instead of eating one at a time, ate the whole
jar full.
STEVIE BECK, "Queen of the Autoharp," Autoharp teacher, Minneapolis, MN: If you're interested in autoharp, The Autoharpoholic is a must.
MARGO BLEVIN, Augusta Heritage Center, Elkins, WV: The Autoharpoholic replaces the back yard fence and pot luck dinners for all autoharp
players around the world.
BRYAN BOWERS, Musician, Seattle, WA: When I grow up, I'm still going to read The Autoharpoholic.
I

JANETTE CARTER, Musician,

If you
really like the autoharp, be sure to get this magazine.
Enjoy reading the magazine. May you enjoy a long and prosperous life in the field of unique American publications.
PATRICK COUTON, Musician, Nantes, FRANCE: The Autoharpoholic helps me not feel like an extraterrestrial in my own country.

BILL CLIFTON, Musician,
MIKE

FENTON,

WINFIELD

1

Hilton's, VA:

Mendota, VA:

987 International Autoharp Champion,

FROMM, Real person,

LINDSAY H AISLE

Musician,

Y,

Bridgewater,

Leander, TX:

Worcester, ENGLAND: I owe a great deal to the togetherness' that is The Autoharpoholic. Thanks a million.
use the lessons, the musical arrangements, and the articles, and it's nice to know so many of the authors.
A delightful labor of love, unique among music publications, it brings together the diverse world of
autoharp players.
VA:

I like and

HANCOCK, Ozark Folk Center, Mountain View, AR: The Autoharpoholic is the ultimate resource for planning autoharp workshops.
LEIGH ANN HARDCASTLE, Real person, Cleburne, TX: I learned to play through the magazine, my only contact with the
autoharp world. It's for everyone, not just the pros.
MIKE HERR, Real person, Beckley, W V: The best way I know to communicate with other
a real tool of the
harpers is through The Autoharpoholic
autoharp community.
MARY ANN JOHNSTON, Real person, Chester, WV: If you suffer from autoharp dependency, the best treatment is The
ELLIOTT

Autoharpoholic.

MARTHA KIKER, Charlotte Autoharp Club, Charlotte, NC: The Autoharpoholic continually renews my interest in the
autoharp.
PAUL LYLE, Slippery Fingers Autoharp Club, N. Highlands, CA: I feel a part of The Autoharpoholic, and that's how you want
people to feel: that they're important.
JOHN McCUTCHEON, Musician, Charlottesville, VA: The Autoharpoholic has been revolutionary:
It has
helped us learn about one another and created a family.
HELEN MILLER, Real Person, Danville, PA: I sure wouldn't want to miss out on my Autoharpoholic magazine... might as well cut off
my oxygen!
KAREN MUELLER, 986 International Autoharp Champion, Lawrence, KS: It lets you know who's doing what, where, when, and
maybe even why.
1

JERRY O'NEIL, Real person, Winfield, KS: I feel it has brought us all closer together, as well as providing volumes of information on a
unique instrument.
BONNIE PHIPPS, 1982 International Autoharp Champion, Denver, CO: Everything you ever wanted to know about
autoharps, but were afraid to ask.
BOB REDFORD, Walnut Valley Assoc., Winfield, KS: The Autoharpoholic has been instrumental in
producing tremendous participation in our International
HARVEY REID, Musician, Portsmouth, NH: Unless you're psychic, you need it.

Autoharp contest.

MARGO REPP, Real person, Puyallup, WA: The Autoharpoholic informs, educates, and provides a forum for those of us that share a love for this
unique instrument.
JEAN RITCHIE, Musician, Port Washington, NY: The Autoharpoholic is to autoharpers what Dulcimer
Player News is to dulcimer players. It gets people together.
ANITA ROESLER,

Flying Fingers Autoharp Club, Oklahoma City, OK: It puts us in touch with our own kind, without which some of the clubs would not have been started.
ROYS, Real person, Stevensville, MD: I enjoy the exchange of musical ideas and hearing from people who have become dear and treasured friends these last years.
TOM SCHROEDER, 1985 International Autoharp Champion, Kansas City, MO: The Autoharpoholic is the
only way to keep in touch with The Family.
JOHN SEBASTIAN, Musician, Woodstock, NY: The Autoharpoholic is the soundboard of a
I check in
to find out what's new.
EILEEN

community.

frequently

The Autoharpoholic is a Whole Earth Catalog, People Magazine, encyclopedia, and
party-line for all autoharpists.
MONTSERRAT SERRAMIA, Real person, Barcelona, SPAIN: Thanks to the music notation (tablature) in The
Autoharpoholic, I have learned to play any song on the autoharp.
PETER SMAKULA, Autoharp luthier, Cleveland, OH: If you're interested in autoharps, The
Autoharpoholic is the only game in town.
MIKE

SEEGER, Musician, Lexington,

VA:

WILL SMITH, Autoharp teacher/musician, Franklin, TN: Until I found The Autoharpoholic, I felt like a musical outcast. Glad to be a member of "Autoharooholics Unanimous"!
PATSY STONEMAN, Musician, Nashville, TN: What a welcome surprise to realize that there are so
many talented, interesting autoharp players in the world! Thank you.
BOB TAYLOR, Autoharp luthier, Upper Montclair, NJ: An international network,
ideas that
tuned to each
as well as to the instrument we all love.

sharing
keep people
other,
Musician/recording artist, Copper Hill, VA: The Autoharpoholic is a must just to keep up with what's going on in the autoharp world.
RON WALL, Autoharp teacher/musician, Goodlettsville, TN: It's my Telephone line' to all the
autoharp people.
NEAL WALTERS, Mill Run Dulcimer Band, Silver Spring, MD: I like its upright,
finely-tuned, no-holds-barred editorial policy and all the articles on key subjects.
BETTY WALDRON,

CLARK &amp; ELAINE WEISSMAN, California Traditional Music Society, Tarzana, CA: The
Autoharpoholic is musical shareware, a "computer bulletin board" for all autoharp lovers.
HOMER WELTY, Real person, Salem, OR:
really appreciate your seeing the need for such a periodical, getting it going, and doing such an excellent job with it.
CHARLES WHITMER, Autoharp teacher, Spring, TX: The Autoharpoholic was, and still is,
my main lifeline to the autoharp world.
LYNN WICK, El Dorado County Autoharp Club, Placerville, CA: Our club was made
possible only with the help of The Autoharpoholic, the only publication for all autoharpers.
I

KEITH YOUNG, Autoharp luthier,

Annandale, VA: A community of very talented people contribute to The Autoharpoholic
a family of 'harpers
a great idea!
helping 'harpers
MERLE &amp; ROSIE ZIMMERMAN, Real persons, Wichita, KS: No one else could have done what The
Autoharpoholic has done for autoharpers. It's top quality and real class!
All names and quotes used by permission.
are everywhere!"}
(And if you're still not convinced, there are plenty more...

"Autoharpoholics

WHAT ELSE
$1

IS

THERE TO SAY?

WE'RE ALL PART OF The

2.00/year (U.S.); $14.50 (Canada); $17.00 (Other foreign countries).
Check or Money order payable to i.a.d. Publications.

U.S. dollars.

i.a.d. Publications,

PO Box 504-T,

Brisbane, CA 94005.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Autoharooholic

TEAM.

WON'T YOU JOIN US?

"HARP-TO-IT!" SPECIAL OFFER
Subscribe before October 1, 1988, and get
your first issue (Fall '88) absolutely FREE!

�The OLD-TIME HERALD

Vol.

1

No.

5

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
P.O. Box 1362
Galax, VA 24333

703-236-7808
Editor
Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Brad Leftwich

Linda Higginbotham
Hilary Dirlam

Dance Editor
Phil Jamison

Advertising

Dale Morris
Michael Ayers

Administrative Consultant
Bobby Patterson

The Old-Time Herald

is

published quarterly

the first of August, November, February, and
May by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,

P.O.

Box

Subscription

1362,

VA

Galax,

rates payable

in

24333.

advance. One

$12.00 (foreign subscriptions $16.00
year
U.S.). Classified ads cost 35 cents per word,
minimum $5.00. Any grouping of letters or
is
counted as one word. All
numbers
classified ads must be received by the first of
the month, one month prior to publication.
Postage paid at Woodlawn, Virginia, second
class application pending. POSTMASTER:
Send address changes to the Old-Time
Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�From
The
Editor

Baker, Bill Monroe, Elizabeth
Cotten, and others.
Orginally from California, she moved
to the Washington, D.C. area where she

Kenny

married and raised her family. Alice has
living in Galax, Virginia, since
1981 where she is very involved in the
local music scene, being a member of the
and
Blue Ridge Music Association,
learning from and playing with several
traditional musicians. Alice plays guitar,
banjo, and fiddle, loves to sing, and
generally tries to keep up with the Oldbeen

This is our first anniversary issue, and
we'd like to thank all of you readers who
and
so supportive
have been

encouraging. We

are proud of the OldTime Herald and plan on continuing the
quality production we have set as a

Time Herald.

standard.

in
this issue a
two on the folks who
helped us put together our first issue.
Most of them continue to contribute
their time and talents to the Old-Time
Herald and we would like them to be

We

are

paragraph

including

or

recognized.

ALICE

David

Gahr

GERRARD

Alice

Gerrard

songwriter,

and

is

a

musician, singer,

editor-in-chief of the

Old-Time Herald. She has recorded
several LPs with such musicians as Hazel
Dickens, Tommy Jarrell, Mike Seeger,
Irene Herrmann, Jeanie McLerie, and
Alice co-directed the film,
others.
about North
&amp;
Fly
Wings
Sprout
Carolina fiddler Tommy Jarrell, and coproduced the album and booklet The
Old-Time Way on Heritage Records.
This LP, a study of three Galax-area

musicians,

was

chosen

to

be

the

on

Library of Congress Select List.
Alice has written articles on music and

musicians

for

magazines

and

newspapers, and record liner notes for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�LINDA

Alice

Gerrard

HIGGINBOTHAM

Linda Higginbotham was born in New
York City and got her first musical
training from her father, a Tin Pan Alley

Her
involvement
in
traditional music began at age 16 when
she met Miles Krassen, and has spanned

songwriter.

20
years through her move to
Bloomington, Indiana, where she was a
central figure in the old-time music and
dance community, to her retirement
from her five-year performing career as

banjo

player

with

Leftwich

&amp;_

Higginbotham. She has distinguished
herself as a performer and songwriter

several of her songs and original verses to
traditional tunes appear on Leftwich &amp;l
as well as
Higginbotham's two albums
through her energetic support and pro
motion of traditional old-time music. In
addition to articles in the Old-Time
Herald, her writing has appeared in Sing
Out!

Linda received a bachelor's degree in
studies in 1979, and has
religious
resumed
her academic career
recently
with her admission to the PhD program
in counseling
psychology at Indiana

University in Bloomington. Linda is an
associate editor of the Old-Time Herald.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�with
his
wife
Virginia,
children, and is employed
librarian.

and
as

a

three

school

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�folklore. Charles has contributed many

CHARLES

WOLFE

fine articles to the OTH.

Charles Wolfe,
a
native of the
Missouri Ozarks, has lived in the
Nashville area for over 15 years, has
published a number of books and

articles on country and folk music, and
has produced over 50 LPs on pop and
country music. His radio and television
documentaries have been seen on a
variety of nationwide formats over the
last 10 years, and he has been nominated
three times for Grammy awards for his
of traditional-music
productions
albums.
Charles has written several books on
country music: Grand Ole Opry: The
Early Years the first serious attempt to
piece together an accurate history of the

early Opry; Tennessee Strings: The Story of
Music in Tennessee; The
Country
Illustrated History of Country Music; and
Kentucky Country: Folk and Country Music
of Kentucky.

Most recently Charles has

collaborated with Grandpa Jones on his
autobiography, Everybody's Grandpa, and

a biography
of the late Lefty Frizzell. He
writes for a number of country music
periodicals, has written liner notes for
over
100 albums, and has written
booklets on pop music for the Time-Life
"Legendary Singers" series. Charles has
served as associate producer for the

PBS

television series "Southbound," the

summer replacement for "Austin City
Limits," and has done several bits on
NPR's "All Things Considered," often
commenting on folk or country music.
He teaches at Middle Tennessee State
where he is a cultural
University,
in
music and
historian
specializing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�music must have a real function.
Dancing is a good example. But, as Mac
says, more is needed. Grants, yes, they
would help a great deal, but I believe oldtime music must function as a part of the

Letters
The Old-Time Herald welcomes letters
They should be typed or neatly written, and
signed. They may be edited and we will print
them according to space available. The
opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect
those of the Old-Time Herald.

"Buy

or

"Issues

in

Mac

Bye" Response (See also,
Old-Time Music"):

Benford's

well-written

article

or maybe a
certainly struck a chord-discord. "Yeah, yeah yeah!" I shouted.
"Go
ahead, Mac!" I bellowed,
remembering when I used to scream,
"Pay the fiddler!" until I was hoarse. The
reactions I got were revealing: complete
agreement up to the point of a "strike,"
then nothing. Well, I eventually saw the
folly in forcing the issue, and I came to a
resolution of the dilemma. I'd like to
comment on this and Mac's article.

Yes!

needed.

Professional
I

musicians

are

agree with Mac's arguments

wholeheartedly,
modifications;
Cajun music
music that

a

with

few

a

that I consider
southern old-time

namely,
part of

is burgeoning,
not losing
ground. Also, I insist that old-time
music can work on stage if the stage isn't
too big.
But why, then, is old-time music in
trouble? This is difficult to admit. We
sow the seeds of our own destruction.
We react against the mainstream. We're

gourmet eaters; we go after the cream of
the crop, and when we find it we become

gourmands,

consuming

W e're liberal, which makes
to

ad
it

nauseam.
hard for us

connect with the conservative values

expressed
emotionally

by

the

music.

We're

phobic, afraid to bare our

larger society. How?
Here's my idea, my resolution. Along
with personal tragedy in my life came
insights into the power of music to touch
people so deeply that it seemed to

become

to

spread
responsibility
around; more than that, to give it back to
the public as carefully as I could, to for
the
as
well
as
gotten audiences
service-This
is
a
public
privileged.
doing something for somebody else in a
way that enables everybody to gain
something. The formula is so simple I
a

it

have trouble understanding why it isn't
happening everywhere: the local organi
zation hires a performer or band to do a
concert or dance and a couple of low-paying

is

a
am
now
card-carrying
yuppie.
Nostalgic, saccharine treatment of this
music is ultimately self-destructive and
does us all a disservice. Your magazine,
and Mac's fine exploration of these

points, came along at just the right time.
What he has written and you have
published needed to be said a long time
ago. Thanks for helping me clarify these
issues I've been trying to wrestle with for
all these years.
Peter Hartman

Richmond, VA

a

(yes, kids are a forgotten audience), or
even a prison; all this being funded by
local business. This is reaching out to the
public, and I can cite specific examples of
success with this plan if anybody wants.
The point is that everybody gains. This is
my resolutioin: to get this programmed
to ensure a dependable flow of "folk to
folks." You may have a different
resolution but I'm convinced that this is
absolutely essential to the survival of the

old-time music scene.

One more thing: these days
too much to expect to convert
our musical persuasion. On
hand, I believe that 40% of
American listening audience
willing to give us

an

I

think it's

people

to

would

be

the other
the entire

ear for at least 45

they just don't know it yet.
Let's give them our set, then let them go
minutes--

on with their lives. They'll be back; it's

worth a try.
And thank you, Mac,
little nervous.

for

getting

a

a lifestyle no longer worked.
At that time, old-time music as a way of
life and as an attitude toward current
events was a popular notion. So many

opposite of bluegrass fans.
To survive, I'm convinced that

music, the correct dress, and the proper

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

approach can be. Commercial success

not the equivalent of selling out, as I've
discovered. In the past months I've
learned that the music sounds just as
good and just as moving even though I

public service appearances, say,
nursing home, senior citizen center,
mental institution, elementary school
in

souls vocally (Mac touched on this),
us
men,
especially
preferring death
(from the neck up) to being seen in tears.
(How can you bring emotion to your
music? Hey-you weren't taken prisoner
by this music-you met it halfway).
And the word duty sends us packing
faster than the speed of light. How can
anyone tell us to remember to support
old-time music? Look at the bluegrass
audiences; I envy the loyalty those
musicians enjoy. On the other hand, this
is where Mac's reasoning falters a little
bit-he tried to compare apples and
We're
almost the exact
oranges.

old-time

the hands of time just
might turn back to the 1930s. Mac's
article lays this flawed notion to rest and
points out just how detrimental that

mannerisms,

Tracy Schwarz

Glover, VT

Mac Benford has articulated much of
what I've felt for 10 years now, but have
been unable to express. I left old-time
music in 1978, as well as the folklore
when the pressure to
profession,

conform to

enthusiasts thought that with the right

I
enjoy especially what seems to be
emerging as an editorial series. Mac
Benford's "Buy or Bye" I found myself

reacting to enough to prompt this letter.
I wish to share some of my observations

concerning actual or perceived hazards
to the continuation and prosperity of
old-time music.
I moved
to northern lower Michigan
three

years

northern upper
spent most of my life.

from

ago

Michigan, where

I

impressed by the presence in this
of two
groups of old-time
musicians. I realized that virtually no
interaction occurs between the two
was
area

I

groups. The younger group, formally
organized into a "folk society," routinely

schedules

out-of-town performers

on

nights that conflict with the older folks'
fiddle fests. These fiddle fests are

monthly, year-round events at various
township halls in the area. Only recently
have a very few of the folk society
members even ventured to one of these.
The fiddle fest goers do not attend
folk society doings either, I found. Don't
even mention it. The reason: politics.
Several prominent folk society members

music concerning current
present
social issues with a strong
and
political
To bring the point of
left or far-left slant.
the tune across, the

compositions range

from
witty, sarcastic, clever, and
poignant, to risque, offensive, biased,
and insulting to those who may not
happen to share those beliefs, much less
hold contrary opinions. This area of
Michigan is generally rural and bedrock

conservative.
To

associate,

intentionally

otherwise, old-time music

or

or

musicians

�with any particular political stance is
The
two
need never
be
deadly.
combined. I'm sure the phenomenon I

describe

is

not unusual to this area alone.

Old-time music cannot be carried on
only by people who are attracted to it as
an art form (which it is), as representing
a
simpler way of life (which it does)
philosophically consistent with back-to-

naturists, or, as above argued, a meeting
point for people strongly espousing a
certain political stance.
As Harold Hausenfluck pointed out,
it's old-time country music. At one time it
was just plain country music (before
Nashville neutered and gutted the whole
genre). Country music, then as now, has
to have mass appeal. Old-time country
music did and still does have mass appeal
if it can be

presented to the average Joe

Blow and Jane Doe. People get tired of
the sanitized, electric, orchestrated, slick
stuff.
One of the most effective large-scale
ways

of doing this

is

entertainment

to emphasize

the

aspect of music
and make them so. Have
activities for kids, close contact with
performers, and at the same time
minimize the rowdies.
family
festivals,

Planting the seed of appreciation for
this type of music in the young ones by
appealing to them as well as their parents
will be a real investment in the future of
old-time music. A wonderful job of

exactly this is done at the
Music Festival in Remus,
Michigan.
The strength of old-time country
music lies in its actual or potential mass
appeal. To quote Big Mon, "It's just
good music." Good music that gets
virtually no airplay on any but public
radio (at least in these parts).
I
wonder what Mac meant when he
wrote about repackaging old-time per
formance to appeal to a late '80s
audience.
doing

Wheatland

Steve Loring
Cadillac, MI

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�loved

any kind of
have heard him speak
of his younger days in the mid-late '30sand

he

mountain music.

playing
I

'40s when he and musician friends such

Raymond "Wendy" Wampler,
Vernon Frazier, and others would travel
as

across High Knob in his black '36 Ford
route to A. P. Carter's in Maces
Springs, Va. Dad also made music with
Kate Peters
Sturgill who lived in our
neighborhood of Josephine near
Norton, Va. Kate was a very popular
en

folksinger and ballad songwriter of the
area, and she is now honored alongside
Dock Boggs each year at the Dock Boggs
Festival featuring mostly old-time music
groups in Wise, Va.
Since my humble beginnings as a '40s'50s baby boomer, have come to realize
I

value and richness of my own
heritage and to take pride in the customs
and traditions which have been handed
down to me. The older I become, the
more I realize how much I cherish these
customs and the importance in
preserving these arts so they will never
become extinct.
the

Anna R. Breeding, Founder
Sugarcane Cloggers

Norton, VA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�read" to me. When the outdoor fiddlin'
season finally hits this year I'll be full of
the inspiration-distilled down from
your fine articles and photos. This
magazine is just what the old-time music
scene needed. It's like a good spring
tonic four times a year.
Jim Burns

Middlebury, VT
I
am delighted with your magazine.
The energy and intiative in producing
this magazine is commendable, and it has
been long-needed too.
I
was never a believer that true oldtime music dropped dead in its tracks in
1937; there are now and gratefully will
be new and present carriers of the torch.

Michael Meagher

N.Y.C., N.Y.

A slick magazine with soul.
we

some

had

old-time

I

only wish

music

Lafayette, but it's better to read about
than to forget it.

in
it

John Schwab
W. Lafayette, IN

The Daily Clog is heartened to know
that the Old-Time Herald is out there,
promoting the interests of old-time
music and dance fans such as myself and
the readers of the Daily Clog. The OldTime Herald hit the ground running with
its first issue, and subsequent issues have

increased

in

momentum. There has been

and almost scholarly
about old-time music, its
history, its present status, and even some
speculation on its future. The letters to
the editor are entertaining, informative,
and clearly evidence that there are a
whole lot more of us out there who care
what happens to the old-time music
scene. The Old-Time Herald consistently
gets the most knowledgeable people to
write for them, yet it's always in a style

thoughful
discussion

that's accessible to newcomers.

Julie Mangin, Editor
The Daily Clog

Silver Spring, MD

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�ROY HARPER:

Most people do not exactly consider
Nashville a mecca for old-time music. At
fiddle contests in Alabama, bluegrass
festivals in Virginia, and backstep dances
in
North Carolina,
"Nashville" has

become synonymous with everything
that old-time music stands against. Yet
when you get beyond Music Row
Nashville, and get to Nashville the town,
or

Nashville

the

community

of

different picture emerges.
Since as long ago as the 1920s the rolling
hills around Nashville have produced an
musicians,

a

stream

impressive

traditional

of

musicians, and over the years more than
were drawn into the
the Nashville
music
industry. It is still possible in Nashville
and its suburbs to find people who
toured with the Delmore Brothers,
played bass for Uncle Dave Macon,
jammed with Arthur Smith, picked with
the
original Coon Creek Girls, or
crossed bows with Fiddlin' Cowan
Powers. If you go out a little further from
a

few

of them

periphery

of

Nashville, down to Tullahoma or Tracy
City or Manchester or Dickson, you'll
find even more remnants of old-time
music and hear tales about an old-time

music culture that has existed, and still
exists today, in the very shadow of
Nashville's bizarre glamor. This is a story
about a part of that culture. It is about a

man that many people consider the best
old-time singer in the state: a lean, lanky,
easy-going man named Roy Harper.
Roy's commitment to the songs he
is
not superficial,
nor
is
it
sings
academic, nor is it a matter of family
heritage, nor is it a matter of aesthetics.
"I want you to tell people that I live in the
past," he said recently, "and that I dwell
on and thrive on memories of the past. If
I had
my way, we'd still be driving Model

Courtesy

Charles

Wolfe

A Fords and listening to Jimmie Rodgers
on the Victrola. "As a matter of fact, Roy

Ca.

THE

Aero Fleetwood
1948
cherry-red
Chevrolet, the one that looks just like it
came off the floor. (Roy is used to it
attracting attention, and likes to startle

young

WAYS

OF

by

Charles

1955

does have an impressive collection of
78s-Jimmie Rodgers as well as others
--that he does listen to and learn songs
from. And as a matter of fact, when Roy
shows up for a job, he does arrive in his

Wolfe

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

onlookers

by

proudly

announcing, "Two more payments and
its
mine.") Roy doesn't favor the
spangled coats on sale at Nashville's
Alamo, nor the 1960-chic flannel-shirtand-jeans

THE

PAST

mode

of

so

many

young

musicians. He dresses the way he
remembers the serious singers of the
1920s and 1930s dressing: well-polished
boots, dark coat, gambler's vest, floppy
bow tie or string tie, all topped off with a

�town about half-way between
Nashville and Chattanooga, in southcentral Tennessee. As a boy, Roy recalls
a

being fascinated with two things: music
and trains. He liked to climb up under
the trestle of the local railroad and brace
himself just a couple of feet from the
roadbed "so I could look right up into
the engine and see those drivers work."
By 1943 or so Roy began working as a
brakeman on different railroads in the

Southeast and the West, and he
continued with this career off and on
until 1959. During this time he did a lot
of singing, much of it in the rough-andtumble bars of the South and Southwest.
He

quickly

very

became

adept

at

the style of Jimmie Rodgers,
then dead only a decade but already a
legend among the old railroaders who
felt a special tie to his music.

imitating

Also

the

as

a schooling in
music heritage of
Tennessee.
He especially

a

boy, Roy got

string-band

southern

admired two local string bands, those of
W. B. Jacobs and Nathan Barger, who
won a local fame of sorts by playing on
the radio at nearby Chattanooga. Roy
also learned from the two most famous
old-time acts in the area: Uncle Dave
Macon, the banjo-playing star of the

early Grand Ole Opry,

and the Allen
Brothers, Lee and Austin, from nearby
Sewanee, who recorded prolifically their
repertoire of blues, rags, and hits like
"Salty Dog" in the late 1920s. He added
songs from both acts to his growing
repertoire, and found role models in
both for anyone wanting to become an

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

musician. "Once

a

recalls. "That was when the old highway
U.S. 41 went right through the center of
town, and everybody going down to
Chattanooga had to go right through
Manchester. Well, one night about dusk
a
sharp-looking car with New York
plates came up, and rounded the square
several times, and it was obvious they
were lost. Finally one of the men in the
car stuck his head out, and in one of
those rude, brash New York accents
shouted to Uncle Dave, 'Say old man,
can you direct us to the road to
Chattanooga?' And Uncle Dave looked
up and shouted back, 'Well, you didn't
have any trouble finding it in 1863!'"
Two local auction companies routinely
hired Uncle Dave to play for sales in the
Manchester area
a type
of musical
advertising that Roy would later do
himself. "Frank Patch was one of the
agents that worked with the auction

companies

back

the

in

1930s, recalls

Roy. "He told me that when he came
down for a job, Uncle Dave would worry
them to death wanting to have them hear
him try out new songs. They got to
where they would even stay in separate
hotels so Uncle Dave couldn't find their
room and come up late at night and
bother them to hear some new song he
was working up. But some of Uncle
Dave's jokes were too clever for city
folks anyway. He liked to tell one about
his brother Bob, and how much his
brother Bob loved music. 'Why the
other day,' he'd say, 'my brother Bob
was out working in the field and there
was a splinter over there on the fence,
and a wind came up and started hitting
that splinter, and Bob liked to have
laughed himself to death.' Folks who
haven't been around one of those old rail
fences and don't know what kind of a
sound they make then the wind causes
them to vibrate can't really appreciate

a horn), a Hoover bass
(i.e., washtub), and a washboard; they
sounded a little like those old Memphis
Jug Band records, and I found out that
they traveled as far south as Florida."
Roy was especially interested in this
sort of music, since his father had given
him a harmonica
his first instrument
when he was six. He was also starting
to work with the guitar and listened
when he could to the premier guitar
player around, another black musician
named Coaly Streeter. "He was another
Josh White on guitar," Roy remembers.
"He wasn't just a straight blues picker
he could work in all different styles,

kazoo attached to

including fingerpicking. He was from
down at Wartrace, but he was well
known in Shelby ville and Murfreesboro.
was a favorite of the upper crust
there, well-to-do white folks. They'd get
him to play for their card parties or card
games, and even for their rooster fights."
Some of the blues and guitar numbers in
Roy's repertoire can be traced,
He

indirectly, to Streeter.

As he traveled around the country as a
man in the early 1940s, Roy
continued to hone his style and enlarge

young
his

and

repertoire,

brakeman

on

the

to

Santa

work

Fe

and

as

a

other

lines. "Back then being a brakeman was
considered the third most dangerous job
"
he said. "But 1 did enjoy
in the country,
I
to
see a lot of country."
it, and
got
returned to
About
1945
Roy
Manchester and met a man who was to
have a lasting impact on his career:
guitarist and dobroist Blake Bynum.
Bynum was several years older than Roy
and had been born in the community of

that."

There were other local musicians
around Manchester that Roy recalls as
well. "There was a good black fiddle
band that used to hang out and play on
the square,
right in front of Basil
McMahon's store. They used a fiddle,
guitar, and a tater-bug mandolin and
liked to play things like 'St. Louis Blues.'
Then there were other groups that came
through on a sort of regular circuit,
setting up and playing for spare change.
remember another black string band that
featured a sort of rough guitar player,
who played in a high banjo tuning and

Wolfe

Griffin, Jimmie Rodgers, and Ernest
Tubb. "I guess you could call me a
dinosaur," he says, "one of the few
dinosaurs living who still has the nerve
to perform these old songs and take
them seriously."
Roy was born in 1925 in Manchester,

as

Charles

Lum and Abner's well-known "They
Cut Down the Old Pine Tree." Roy sings
these straight and true and sincere, in a
voice that sounds like a mixture of Rex

well

Courtesy

favorites like "The Prisoner's Dream," "I
Lost My Love in the Ohio Flood," and

as

I

made

bar-style

forefinger.

chords

They had

a

with

Yazoo

(a

Cogswell

Colorado," from old-time protest songs
like "Cotton Mill Blues" and "Roll
Down the Line" to venerable radio

entertainer

Uncle Dave was entertaining on the
courthouse square in Manchester," he

Robert

dark gray cowboy hat or his old railroad
cap. He's likely to come on stage carrying
an old ladder-back chair, take his seat,
adjust his guitar, organize his harmonica
rack, and then address his audience with
a quiet poise and dignity born of some
40-odd years in the business. His songs
range from ancient ballads like "The
Butcher's Boy" and "The Soldier and His
Lady" to cowboy songs like "Little Joe
the Wrangler" or "Rainbow on the Rio

his
large

On stage

at

the mall, Washington, D.C. June 1986

�Beech

Grove

a

miles

few

north

of

Manchester. He and his family moved to
Enid, Oklahoma, when he was a boy,
and then back to Tennessee when he was
a teenager.
He was a small man and
suffered from epilepsy, but he was
totally consumed by his music. He
married and had a family, but music
always seemed to take first place. "He
was amazing, the way he could learn
guitar pieces," recalls Roy. "Once back
in 1927 he saw SamandKirkMcGeeata
schoolhouse concert at a little town
called Noah. Sam did his version of his

'Buck
Dancer's Choice,'
speciality,
Blake watched him like a hawk, and in a

week he had

it

down to where he could

play it. Another time

I

remember him

1946 a lot of medium-sized towns
like Manchester were starting to get their
own radio stations, and since many of

Courtesy

Charles

Wolfe

listening to records by Blind Lemon
Jefferson and Blind Boy Fuller and Josh
White. One time I was at a friend's house
with Blake, and this friend played a
record of Josh White's 'Homeless and
Hungry Blues.' Blake loved it, and
listened to it twice, and then he went
home and came back next and played
along with the record, note for note."

Roy, Blake, and band

By

these were too small or too poor to
affiliate with one of the big networks,
there was a renaissance of sorts in the
kind of live, regional,
independent
programming that had characterized
broadcasting during its golden years of
the

1920s.

In

middle Tennessee

this

meant that there was now a place for uplocal string bands to ply
their trade in a series of new stations that

and-coming

began to flourish in the very shadow of

Nashville's giants, WSM and WLAC.
These new stations were at Manchester,
Tullahoma,

Cookeville,

Murfreesboro,

Dickson,

Crossville,

Springfield,

Clarksville, Fayetteville, and others. For
about ten years this informal circuit
provided work for the young bands who

hadn't made the big time, and for the
traditional bands whose older style and
repertoire was appealing to the people of
rural Tennessee if not to the slick talent

bosses

in

Nashville.

Blake Bynum had become a part of
this circuit. About 1944 he had formed a
radio band called the Sand Mountain
Boys; Chief Red Bone aka T ay lor J ones)
was a real Cherokee Indian who was a

fiddler and the front man; Jack Bailey
played the accordian; Marvin Wilson
played the five-string banjo. One day a
mutual friend named Clarence LeFevre
met Roy on the square in Manchester
and introduced him to Bynum. Blake
liked Roy's Jimmie Rodgers imitations,
and soon invited him to join the band as

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

their singer. Roy gave

his radio debut one hot

it a try

and made

afternoon

in

the

Manchester

station. As Roy
to
the
mike
to sing his first
stepped up
solo, a fly lit on his nose and proceeded
to make himself at home. Nervous to
cramped

start with, Roy now found himself trying
to sing, keep rhythm on the guitar, and
wriggle his nose to dislodge the fly. The
rest of the band members watched with a
strange combination of awe and hilarity.
Roy worked his way into the third
chorus of his song, and the fly worked
his way down to the end of Roy's nose.
By now both
Roy and Blake were

wondering about whether

it

was

possible

fly actually got into
Roy's mouth. Finally the last chorus
came, Roy hit his final chord, and made a
and
grab for the fly. He caught the fly
passed his audition.
to sing on key if

By

the

early

a

1950s,

the

Sand

Mountain Boys had become one of the

most popular radio bands in the area.
They were heard so much on mid-state
radio that Blake Bynum was able to copy

the booking technique pioneered by
Uncle Dave Macon back in the 1920s: he
would go up to area schoolhouses,
pretend that the band happened to be in
the area that afternoon, and ask the
principal if he could visit one of the
classes. In class, Blake would ask the kids
how many of them listened to the Sand
Mountain Boys on radio. A lot of hands
would immediately shoot up, and Blake
would look at the principal, who was

ca.

1970

usually impressed by this show of fame,
and start talking about a booking for the
school (the school would get a cut of the
gate). Kids would then run home and tell
their parents about the celebrities they
had met that day, and spread the word
about the upcoming schoolhouse show.
Since few of the regional radio stations
could afford a band full time, the band
would play only two or three days a week
at, say, the station in Cookeville; here
they would advertise their nearby dates

schoolhouse concerts, and "play
out" in that town's area for that week.
The next week they would move on to a
different town on their circuit, perhaps
30 to 40 miles away, and repeat the
procedure. Blake and Roy also got a lot

and

of work playing for auction companies.
Roy explains, "On the morning of the
auction, we would go into town, around
the courthouse, get on a wagon or maybe
a flat-bed
truck, and play some lively
music. When we had a crowd, we'd get
on the P. A. system and tell 'em to come
on out to the place, that there was a big
sale on. Then during the sale itself, we
would play during breaks, or when they
wanted to get some hot bids lined up in
the crowd. We would get a flat five
not much by modern
dollars a day
standards but a lot of people back then
were jealous of us for it."
In
1949 the Sand Mountain Boys
auditioned for the Grand Ole Opry;
unfortunately they chose the same week
that the Opry signed Hank Williams,

�seen their radio work pretty much dry
and were wondering about the
possibility of making records. Their
chance came when Ben McCloud, a
up,

found himself with an offer to
return to the railroad. Some friends told
him to go for the railroad job and its
pension and benefits; others said that if

former DJ whom Roy had known while
selling encyclopedias, came into some
money and decided to get into the record
business. In 1965 he set up a place called
Varsity Recording Studio on Church
Street in downtown Nashville and began
issuing singles under the Map Records
label, and LPs under the Varsity label. It

turned down the Opry shot now, he

he

would be giving up the golden ring.
Unable to decide, he flipped a coin; the

railroad won, and Roy went back to
being a brakeman. Ironically, though
Blake Bynum never returned for the
Opry audition, a year later Hank
Williams drove his Cadillac up to
Manchester to hunt out Blake to play in
band.
Blake
hid
Unimpressed,
behind the curtains of his cabin while
his

Williams walked around his yard calling
his name.

About

1959, Roy decided to retire
railroad for good and
embarked on a second career as a
from

the

traveling salesman. For a time he sold
door
to
then
door,
encyclopedias
worked for a photographer who restored
old photos, then for a company that
made home safes. A natural talker with a
healthy curiosity and a love of people,
Roy really began to hit his stride in this
work. Yarns he heard and things he
experienced helped him hone his ability

raconteur and a storyteller, and the
steady travel was an adequate substitute
for his old railroader's wanderlust. He
also had more time for music and the
chance to befriend other musicians and
learn new songs. He was attracted to
some of the veteran Opry performers in
as

a

the area, especially Sam and Kirk McGee
and Fiddlin' Arthur Smith, who in his
later years ran a music barn down south

Manchester.

Soon Ray was
these
men, jamming
performing
with them, and learning their songs.
"Sam and Kirk were two of the best men
on that Grand Ole Opry," Roy recalls.
of

with

WSM wouldn't let 'em play any
thing but the same three or four tunes
over and over
'Chittlin' Cookin'
none of that
Time,' 'Milk Cow Blues,'
that
Sam
could do.
flat-top
pickin'
great
They were on Hank Snow's Coca Cola
segment of the show, and I finally said to
Sam one day, 'Why don't you just flat
out do one of those guitar pieces like
'Drum
Watch' or 'Buck Dancer's
Choice?' The people would like it.' And
he tried it, and people did like it, and
Hank Snow got to where he wanted to
feature them each week doing an
"But

instrumental."

By the mid-1960s, Roy and Blake
were working mostly as a duet and had
been together about 20 years. They had

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was an

one of the
interesting company
few in Nashville geared to older forms of

and it would even
country music
tually record a number of good records
by fairly well known artists
including
the first sides cut by the Kendalls. In
1966 McCloud offered a record deal to
Blake and Roy, and the pair cut their first
"Hawaiian Wiggle," a guitar
single:
number featuring Blake, and "The Old
Hitching Post," an obscure western song
that Roy liked. On it Blake used an old
Weymann guitar that Roy had acquired;
the guitar meant a lot to Roy because it
was the same brand used by his idol
Jimmie Rodgers. "I had gotten it through
a local man named E. W. Anderson.
It
didn't have any kind of name on it, and
about 1930 he had sent it in to the
Gibson people to be fixed up. The

Gibson people did

a

fine job on it, and

note back saying that it was really a
beautiful instrument, but it wasn't one
of theirs. Then about 1956 when Mr.
Anderson died, a friend of mine got it
from his estate for me, and paid a whole
$35 for it. Blake used it on almost all of
the records we made, and it's now in a
sent

a

museum up

at

Manchester."

As he traveled around the South, Ro y
took copies of his new 45 single with
him, and managed to get it quite a bit of
radio airplay and jukebox distribution.
This led to a second Map single a few

for his retail sales

company, and then

offered Blake and Roy

a

contract to do

a

series of LPs on Pine Mountain. The first
of these, Very Countrified, came out in
1968, and it was in short time followed
by Echoes of the Past, Country as Can Be, a
gospel LP, Hear Them Again, and More
Old-Time Favorites. In the late 1970s,
Roy did a seventh Pine Mountain LP,
Sounds

effort.

of the 1920s and

1930s, as

a

solo

The Pine Mountain LPs not only
helped spread Roy's name around as a
fine singer, but crystalized his commit
ment to the old-time repertoire of the
and even more
Carters, Rodgers,
obscure singers like Buster Carter, and
Wilmer Watts, Blind Jack Mathis, Rex
Griffin, and others he heard on old 78s.
Unfortunately, about the time the Pine

Mountain LPs really began

to take off,
Blake Bynum got sick. He died on May

17, 1973. Roy's partner, mentor, and
friend of almost 30 years was gone, and
he suddenly found himself trying to
make it as a solo act.
He began to adapt. He had learned to

play the harmonica at an early age, and
a rack and began to

now he rigged up

accompany himself on harmonica as he
did solo spots.
(Though he didn't
become aware of it until years later, he
had learned to play the harmonica

backwards, and still does today; "when I
found out about it, I turned my harp
over and tried to play

it

right, but

I

can't.

months later, Roy's version of an old
Cowboy Copas song called "Doll of
Clay," backed with Blake's version of the
old fiddle tune "Carroll County Blues,"
which he called "You Guessed It." This
kicked up even more dust, and "Doll of
Clay" became a regional hit; it remains
one the favorites in Roy's repertoire
today. Two more singles on Map soon

followed ("Hobo Bill's Last
Ride"/"New Missouri Waltz," and
"Blake's
Chimes"/"Reflections of a
Fool"), and Roy and Blake began to
sense that there was a developing market
for their music on records.
In the fall of 1967 Roy found

himself
Barbourville, Kentucky, and looked
up gospel singer/ record company owner
in

A.

L.

Phipps.

career as

a

Phipps

had

begun

his

passionate fan of the Carter
13

Wolfe

music,

Family and the Carter-style music, and
had begun a record company called Pine
Mountain devoted to recording and
distributing this sort of music. Phipps
listened to Roy's singles, bought a stock

Charles

and while the Opry personnel asked the
to return later, they never did.
Roy, eternally nervous and insecure
about trying to make a living with his

band

�So

I
just play it the way I learned.") He
also had a big kazoo (a yazoo) he had

bought in 1938 for 39&lt;f ("it was the
deluxe model") that he mounts on the
side of his rack for variety.

Inc.

He
also found new musical
companions. One was veteran blackface
comedian and medicine-show veteran
Goober Buchanan, a fixture in middle
Tennessee since the 1930s and band

Wommack,

a

Music
Country
Courtesy

with fiddler
Billy
Woodbury, Tennessee

Gacesa

performing

Foundation,

leader who worked with Riley Puckett,
Lowe Stokes, and Slim Rhodes. Roy and
Goober did a series of appearances in the
late 1970s
including one at Renfro
in which they recreated some
Valley
of the classic rube skits from the
medicine show days. Roy also began
appearing with the Cove Hollow Boys, a
band from the Smithville area, and

began doing again about five years ago,
have proven irresistible to collectors of
folk art and, especially, to railroad buffs.
(Roy's train pictures are not of vague
generic trains on generic landscapes, but
of specific trains at specific locations.)
But the facet of Roy's work that has been
attracting the most attention recently has
been his remarkable recreations of the

put

Jimmie

out

Society,

the

by

the

Tennessee

Clarksville

Folklore

Fiddling

Contest, and the Cumberland Valley
reunion organization. He estimates that
his total discography includes about 110
recorded songs
probably a fourth of
his total repertoire. He often makes
custom cassettes from unissued master
tapes for fans and friends, so a complete
Harper discography might be almost
impossible. Roy is also one of the most
knowledgable singers around today, and

often prefaces his songs with remarkable

histories and backgrounds
more
testimony to how seriously Roy takes his

songs. "You can't sing
know it," he says.
For

the

last

10

it

if

years,

you don't

Roy

has

routinely won or placed in most of the
old-time singing categories at fiddling
contests in Tennessee and Alabama and
was one of a handful of Tennessee artists
to represent
the state at the 1986
Smithsonian
Festival of American
Folklife in Washington. He often works
with the Country Music Hall of Fame in
their folk music educational programs in
middle Tennessee, and has become a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Angelia

barber who used to play with Uncle
Dave Macon's son
Dorris. He often
works with younger dobro players like
Johnny Bellar, Fred Duggin, and Ricky
Rigney.
Some of these men are heard on some
of the newer records Roy has done since
leaving Pine Mountain. In 1987 he
released I Like Mountain Music on Old
Homestead, a set that got good reviews
and better sales, and included such items
as a topical ballad Roy wrote about the
flea market at Tullahoma, Tennessee, as
well as some rare ballads like "The
Murder of Tom Slaughter" and "I Lost
My Love in the Ohio Flood." Roy has
also contributed to anthology albums

Musicians Red Rector, Roy Harper, Riley Trammell, and Chuck Trammell teach an in-school
session for the Country Music Foundation's "Tennessee Traditions" educational program.

popular feature at the Country Music
Elderhostel classes held every summer in
Murfreesboro. His paintings, which he

Rodgers style; many Rodgers
fans say that nobody today sounds as

close to Rodgers
both in blue yodel
and in singing style
as Roy, and his
at
appearances
Rodgers festivals in
Texas, Nashville, and Mississippi have
won rave reviews and letters from fans
all over. One of his most prized ones
comes from Hoyt "Slim" Bryant
the
great guitar player who actually recorded
with Rodgers
who urges Roy to keep

up the good work and to keep Jimmie's
tradition alive. Roy keeps the letter in his

it out when he needs
some
impress
young whippersnapper,
and keeps doing his best to follow Slim
Bryant's admonition. That too is one of

guitar case, brings
to

the ways of the past.

�OLD-TIME

MUSIC

A

Scottish

Perspective
By

Allin Cottrell

born and raised in Scotland.
live in Burlington, North Carolina
and travel regularly to Fiddlers' Grove,
was
I

Cottrell

I

Now

Courtesy

Allin

the Mt. Airy Fiddlers Convention, Fries,
and other such festivities. I play guitar in
an old-time band, and very much enjoy

being part of the central North Carolina
old time 'scenes.' My initial reasons for
coming to the United States, and North

Willie Johnson, masterful player of Scottish pipemarches.

Carolina

in
were
not
particular,
primarily musical, but now that I'm here
old-time music and the friendships

associated with
keeping
miss

I

if

Doesn't

it

I

a

large

part

in

I

Scotland

have its own
Well, yes it does,
dear
reader, that an extended
hope,

traditional musical
but

play

know now what I'd
went "home" to live. Why?

me here.

life?

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

answer to this question may be of some
interest to you.
Scotland has a rich tradition of fiddle
music, for sure. And some elements of
American old-time music can be traced
back to Scotland. But back home,
15

Scottish

fiddling

has

over

the

years

double historical blow.
First, evangelism. The intense Scottish
brand of Calvinism anathematized

suffered

secular

a

music

resistance,

of

dance. There
course (signaled),

and

was
for

�instance, by the Shetland tune "De'il
Stick the Minister", a musical thumbing
of the nose at clerical intolerance). But
the anti-fiddling fervor of the religion
ists struck home hard enough to create a

sizeable gap

Second,
forces.

In the

in

the tradition.

co-option

Victorian

by
era in

"classical"
particular,

Scottish fiddle music was dangerously
corrupted by an "Italian" concept of
virtuosity (Paganini was the violin
superstar of the time). In the celebrated

Skinner one can hear a man
J. Scott
between a
on
the
edge
teetering
reinterbut legitimate
sophisticated
pretation of Scottish traditions, and a
"look at me!" bastardization which is all
effect and no soul. With the Victorians,
too, crept in a sticky sentimentality
which renders too many Scottish slow
airs totally indigestible (and an unwhole
some contrast with the many unsent
imental yet moving old American fiddle
waltzes).
It is a

testimony

to the staying power

of the tradition that a "roots" Scottish
fiddling survived all this. For one
Tom
example, listen to Tom Hughes
and
his
Border
Fiddle,
SpringHughes
thyme Records SPR 1005). But such
fiddling is harder to find over there. The
tradition does not have the same breadth
and

buoyancy

as

in

the

southeastern

States. "New" old tunes are found less by
meeting up with hitherto unknown
fiddlers in the mountains, or by dis
covering precious 78s in junk stores, and

more

by

collections.

combing

the

printed

There are, of course, few cases in
which traditional fiddle music has
remained totally immune to other kinds
of musical influence. But in the USA
these influences have, in general, had
much happier effect than in the case of
Scottish music and Victorian high-tech
sentimentality. Indeed, some of the most
appealing old-time string music resulted
from the meeting of roots fiddling with
such elements as black blues, ragtime,
and popular song. As witness, take the
Georgia Yellowhammers, or Narmour
and Smith, or the East Texas Serenaders,
or Charlie Poole on a good day. The case
of bluegrass is another matter. But
whatever one may think of bluegrass as a
musical form, it is evidently able to
coexist peacefully with old-time music,

bagpipes. Played with drive and verve
(rather than in the rather persnickety

style

often

found

formal

in

world-class music.
One of the best practitioners of this
art is Willie Johnson of Edinburgh. To
the great loss of posterity, and the shame
of Scottish folklorists, Willie has never
been professionally recorded. Perhaps
foul of an over-academic
he
fell

competitions), this

is

approach to folk music on the part of the

folklorists.

Willie

is

Shetlander by

a

birth, but he doesn't care so much for
traditional Shetland music as for the

mainland Scottish pipe marches, learned

partly from his mother, who worked in
Scotland, and partly from old records.
So one might say that he isn't a "true"
folk musician
just one of the best
damned fiddlers you ever heard. I
suspect that Willie would have been

recorded

in the

States.

So far as recordings go, Angus Grant

is

good on these pipe marches, although
Grant:
record
Highland
Angus

his

Fiddle,

Topic

12TS347)

uniform standard, with

a

fair

is

not

of

proportion

of saccharine airs. Ironically, one of the
best sources for recordings of wild,
driving, Scottish Highland fiddle is Cape
Breton island, where the music largely
escaped the influences mentioned above.
The Scottish settlers of Cape Breton left
before the hammer
the old country
blows fell.
Yes, I sometimes miss the cadences
of a well-played pipe
and rhythms

march. But American old-time fiddle has
I
mentioned
ample compensations.
earlier that some of the roots of old-time

fiddling are to be found in Scottish (or
more generally, Celtic) music. True, but
one should not make too much of this.
There are distinctive American sounds
that have little in common with Celtic

traditions.
Take fiddling in the key of C for
instance (God's key, as more than one
American fiddler of my acquaintance
has called it). To my knowledge, there
are no C tunes in the standard Scottish
repertoire, though there are some
hornpipes and other pieces in flat keys.
Where did the American tradition of C
tunes come from? To take Mississippi as
a case study, the County compilations of
Mississippi fiddling from the late '20s
and early '30s show that fiddling in the
key of C, with its gritty chordal sound
and wild E unisons, was widespread by
that time. But the older styles tapped on
Yam Potatoes (Mississippi
Great
Big
Department of Archives and History,
1985) show little evidence of this

only

one

C

in

piece

among

42

presumably representative selections. So
where, when, and how was the American
C tune

born? Perhaps "Uncle Harold"

could help?
And then

there

is

the

rag/country blues sound
music,

Scottish

obviously
tradition.

syncopations

in

country
old-time

quite foreign to the
There are "jazzy"

in

some

modern

mainstream Scottish pipe tunes, and the
to
Scottish music
funky
approach
offered by The Easy Club (eg. Chance or
Design, RELS 479) is well worth a listen,

but in neither case is the effect

at all

like

continued on page 32

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Allin

Courtesy

But enough of cultural history. What
about the actual sound of the music?
Scottish fiddling at its best has a
distinctive and beautiful sound,
particularly the Highland styles with
their characteristics modes, drones, and
ornamentation derived from the

Cottrell

without submerging the latter.

Tulloch,
Edinburgh-based
Bobby
fiddler, and friend of Willie Johnson.

Shetland

�AN
AFFAIR
OF THE

HEART
by

Alice Gerrard

Alice

Gerrard

with Dan Gellert

In
1986, two years prior to this
heard
Dan
Gellert
conversation,
perform in concert at the Kent State Folk
I

Festival. On stage all alone, he played at
various times banjo, fiddle, harmonica,
and guitar, and he

sang-beautifully. He
old-time music with
combined intensity and passion, and
with an almost naive enthusiasm and joy

played

classic

for what he was doing.

From an urban Jewish background,
Dan was born in New York City, living
there until he was five before moving
into the suburbs of Bergen County, New
Jersey.
Eventually he went to

Bloomington, Indiana, where

he

got

a

never-used degree in zoology from
Indiana University; then on to Elkhart,

Indiana, where he works as an electric
meter reader, and where he has made his

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

home for the past 18 years. He has never
lived in the South, nor visited there, for

that matter.
None of this is so very unusual until
the kind of
you hear Dan Gellert play
classic old-time music that is in the
present, yet takes you back; draws you
and puts you square into some other
place in the South
perhaps at a local

at
a
dance
in
Saturday night 75
or 100 years ago, when the old fiddlers,
singers, and banjo pickers were alive, or
younger and able to stay up half the night
(or even the whole night) and "never
play the same tune twice." In the best
sense, Dan has taken the music into
himself in a way that is rare and deep,
and only when he starts to play is this
depth fully appreciated. Brad Leftwich

entertainment,

or

someone's home on

a

it best in his review of Dan's
(Forked Deer, Marimac 9000) in
Old'Time Herald #3: "He plays the
classic southern mountain music with
skill, vitality, honesty, insight, taste, and

perhaps put
tape

above

all,

energy,

that

remain

faithful

defy

comprehension. He's living proof that a
determined person with enough talent
and perceptiveness can grasp the essence
of a traditional style of music from
recordings

and

to

it

without sacrificing self-expression...."
In general, the essence of classic oldtime music does not emerge in a person's

playing unless that
some
time with
musicians. The fact
exception made me

person

his

spent

powerfully curious
know something
background, feelings, and

to talk with him and to

about

has

master
traditional
that Dan is a rare

�attitudes

his

musical

particular

hanging around with them

with the

journey.
The following
is
edited from
conservations between Dan and myself,

old-timey crowd

Hilary Dirlam, and Kenny Jackson.

started learning and listening to
the stuff that they talked about.
There was a once-a-week half-hour
show on WBAI called the "Country
Music Show." One collector or another
of the great old 78s would come and play
them. I distinctly remember Loy Beaver,
and
probably Charlie Faurot, Rich
Nevins, and Frank Mare were on there
too. Tom Whitmore was the main host
of the show, and the others would take it
over once in a while, and play mostly old
78s, because those were the days when
they were just starting to reissue some of
I
the old stuff. I got into those old 78s
really loved them, and I have reels and
reels of tapes of those shows that I made.
I
didn't really care about my peer
group in junior high school at that point,
I
of course
was
and
going after
a
from
whole
different
acceptance
crowd. I think I had always felt like a real
social freak and thorough outcast, and I
had a general way of coping which made
me say, "Well, if I'm going to be a freak I
might as well do it." There wasn't a
hippie movement yet, so I couldn't be a
hippie, but I could become an old-time

(a

singer/song- writer)

well-known
is

pop

my first cousin,

and another
a

cousin, Lou Rogers, is doing
concept album for Linda Ronstadt

lot of music in my family.
mother,
Kay Gellert, played the
My
piano and she played us songs out of
Ruth Crawford Seeger's book, American
Folk Songs for Children, from the time we
were tiny people. That book was a
fixture on our piano. She always liked to
do music with children, and started out
music school for
a
little
doing
in
our
basement, with kids
preschoolers
banging on rhythm instruments, and she
sang them songs out of Seeger's book. I
so there's

took

a

listened to "folky" music from probably
I
was born, like the Weavers,
Peter Seeger, Woody Guthrie, Burl Ives,
remember being fascinated
Leadbelly
at a very
young age by Leadbelly's
before

real interest

a

doing;

My grandfather, George Steiner, was
from Hungary
a classical violinist and
composer who had studied with Zoltan
Kodaly and Bela Bartok (noted
Hungarian musicians and composers;
Bartok was the first to make extensive
field recordings of the traditional folk
music of his country and to draw upon it
in his own composition
ed.). In about
1921 he came to this country with a
I
think, with the
string quartet
intention of staying. Most of his living in
this country was made by writing music
for films and television. My uncle, Fred
Steiner, writes music for TV; the Perry
Mason theme was his, and he wrote most
of the background music for Star Trek.
He and several others were Academy
Award nominees for the film score for
The Color Purple. My great-aunt, Toni
Koves, plays the cimbalom (a Hungarian
gypsy dulcimer) and she tells the story of
how she once recorded a cimbalom track
for Igor Stravinsky, and he called her up
to tell her how great it was. Wendy

Waldman

people like Bob Bell,
Larry McBride, and Rick Schoenberg. I
in what

they were

I

Back in 1961 or 62 when

black, Kay five-string
copy of Pete Seeger's
instruction book and I got into playing
clawhammer banjo from that book. I
started with the book, but I listened to
Instrumental
Music of the Southern
I

a

new,

and

a

got

banjo

Appalachians

on

(TLP1007)

Tradition

that

great

Records

"Pateroller

and that
by Hobart Smith
album on Folkways that had Wade
Ward on one side and Roscoe Holcomb
on the other. I really liked their playing.

Song"

(FA2363

The Music of Roscoe Holcomb &amp;

Wade Ward

ed.) And those Old-time
I
Ashley's albums
loved Ashley's playing too. (Vol. I
FA2355 &amp;. Vol. II FA2359
ed.)
Music at Clarence

13, my

1

was about

We started going to hootenannies and

to

play

a

bunch

of

I

learn to play a tune on that fiddle."
I knew
that you tuned a violin GDAE.
Fine. And we had one disc at home that
my mother had gotten from the old
Harry Smith Anthology of American Folk
Music on Folkways Records. And that
disc happened to have "Sail Away
Ladies" by Uncle Bunt Stephens on it.

And I said, "That sounds real simple,
there's only about four notes in that
tune." And I sat down, and I remember I
picked the tune out on the mandolin and
said, "OK, those are the notes that are in
"
I started trying to learn to play it on
it.
I didn't think about it, I just
the fiddle
did it. I think that if any one thing taught
me how to play the fiddle, it was the fact
that I just happened to stumble across
It
a
tune.
was
that
particular
it
solo
fiddle
and
piece,
straightforward
just happened to be in standard tuning (I
would have been totally lost if it hadn't
been). It sounded accessible to me. The
notes were real plain. I latched on to a
certain hunk of that rhythm, and there
was something I did right in learning how
to bow it. I was just trying to imitate

Uncle

Bunt Stephens' playing and it
never occurred to me that I was listening
to some kind of a master, which I now
know he was. I can go back to that tune

mom took up the guitar.
I

got into them right away as a social thing.
I started
fooling around with the guitar
and the tenor banjo just on my own.
Mississippi John Hurt was accessible,
and Reverend Gary Davis lived in New
Y ork City and I tried to play that style of
guitar, and some ragtime. There were a
few people at the hootenannies who
were into the New Lost City Ramblers,
and old records and stuff, and I started
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I still
hear things in there that are
new. All of his stuff is just great studies

and
in

fiddle bowing.

remember

in about 1965 there was a
in New York City
series
of
concerts
great
held at the New School and sponsored
by the Friends of Old-Time Music, I
think. One concert was Fred McDowell
I

FA2355

12 or

able

musician.

I

singing.

Being

instruments sort of seemed like the thing
to do
but nobody could play the
fiddle, and it was pretty obvious from all
the old-time music records I'd been
listening to that the fiddle was a real
important instrument. We had this
violin at home that belonged to my
grandfather, so thought, "I'm going to

�and the Georgia Sea Island Singers, and
just threw me for a good loop.
Another was some Bahamian musicians:

that

Joseph Spence, Fred
several other people

MacQueen, and
just incredible.

The first concert in the series was the

McGee Brothers and Arthur Smith, and

Maybelle Carter. I remember loving that
first concert and thinking, "God, those

are the guys on the old

Roscoe Holcomb,

Alice

was
and

Gerrard

records
wow!
There they are!" I was already in love
with Uncle Dave Macon. He just blew
me away when I heard his records, the
energy and total joy of his music grabbed
me. Those Fruit Jar Drinkers sides
if
you have to say there was one greatest
band, that was probably it. There was
great spirit and drive to it. That first
concert had been sort of the roots of
commercial country music, and the
second concert was the deeper roots. It

Horton Barker,

group that called themselves the
Galax String Band, and it consisted of
three people: Fred Cockerham, Ernest
East, and Kyle Creed. They played in
different combinations of two and three,
but they didn't use a guitar, it was usually
two fiddles and a banjo. And the feeling
of the sound of the two fiddles playing
the way
together along with that banjo
those two fiddles were together
no
harmonies, it was just straight playing
the old tunes. There was something I
read once that somebody said about
some fiddler: "What he played it made
you feel like you were going up in an
elevator." Now that about describes my
feeling. It lifted me right up.
That was about my only contact with
actual traditional musicians, and that
was a little after I had started trying to
learn how to play. In learning the music I
just dove in and attempted it as best I
could, and even though I realize that
there's still stuff in there for me to learn,
I didn't
do too badly. It's sort of like the

With Brad Leftwich, 1988

a

bumblebee phenomenon: it's impossible
for
the bumblebee
to
but the
fly
bumblebee doesn't know that so the
bumblebee flies anyway. I said, "OK, I'm
just going to pursue that sound that

I

heard,

and

not

around

it in

circles

My

violinist

try

to

or

analyze

in any

fashion.

grandfather

go

never

understood quite what

I was
doing, but
his respect for it because I was
going back to the roots. He couldn't
figure out why 1 held the bow so funny,
but there was something that struck a
responsive chord in him to see me
listening to those field recordings. As
said, he had studied with Bartok, and
Bartok and been the first person ever to
take out the Edison machine to do field

he had

I

recordings of folk music, although John

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Lomax was doing it not long after. So
although my grandfather was not into
my music, he had respect for it and some
understanding of what I was doing. One
of the fiddles I use now was one that he
had hanging on his wall, and after he died
I
picked it up.
I
wasn't actually playing much with
anybody during this time. For a while I
met up with some guys in New York
Kenny Kosek, Andy May, and A1
Feldman. They called themselves the
Star Spangled String Band. Then, when I
went to school at Indiana University in
Bloomington, I met Reed Martin, who
was from that area, and he really turned
my banjo playing inside out. I thought,
"He's got that sound that I heard on Fred
Cockerham's
records that I'm not
getting. I realized that you had to keep
that thumb going all the time. I had been
using the thumb to support the index
finger, but I wanted that nice, rippling
notey style, and I latched right onto the
way Reed played. We did some playing
together and Reed had a big influence on
my banjo playing.
In some ways those times at college
went by in a fog. What is it they say? "If
you remember the '60s you weren't
involved enough." I got my degree, and
Jenny and I got married and we moved to
Elkhart. I never did pursue anything of
any import in terms of finding a career,
and I guess music kept me sane. I got
busy having a family and no money, or I
probably would have gone and visited
traditional musicians made the
pilgrimmage. But I do what I do, and I
enjoy it.
When
first moved to Elkhart I
I

played with a few bar bands, country and
western type music, and pseudo-bluegrass. I played fiddle and harmonica
mostly. I played the fiddle like I wanted
to play the fiddle and nobody seemed to
care too much, and I played old-time
music for my own enjoyment. Jenny and
I played
some, and not too long after we
moved to Elkhart I met DickTarrier and
we played some with him and Martha
Burns, and later on with Casey Morell.
As far as the future is concerned, it
would be nice if I could do more
traveling because I feel that this music
and these people are my family, and it's
all over the world. I think the important
thing is the social aspect of music and
how it brings people together. And that's
been so important to me. I probably
don't actually make a nickel on the few
music jobs that I do, when it comes
down to what I actually spend and the
time

I

put in. I've looked at it, and just

off the top of my head I figure that if I go
on the road I might be able to keep

myself and live day

to day, that sort of
thing, but even though I'm now divorced
I
still have to support a family, and I

don't

feel

there's

support a family
professionally. Also,

any way I could
and
play music
I'd have to develop

I
haven't
before
too
suppose
many years I'll be in a position where I'll
be able to afford being poor, and then
maybe I could try playing music for a
while for a living. But the important
thing is really not whether somebody is
paying me for it or not, it's whether I'm
doing it. It's a priority. I want to do it.
You asked me what it was about old-

as

a

performer

concentrated on.

ways that

in

I

�of

contacting

something

timeless,

something that reaches way back into the
past, and yet

Maybe

everything
disposable.

just as valid right now.
reaction
to the way
sort of
in this world

is

it's

a

is

suppose I could've gotten
into playing classical music, and I can see
for
that same quality in
searching
classical music, but I like things simpler
and more direct. You don't need such a
great carload of technical skills in order
to express great things in traditional
music. The whole idea is to say it as
simply as possible.
I
think the simplicity of old-time
music goes along with the way I'd ideally
I

like to live: uncluttered. In a way it's a
very conservative point of view. In ideal
political terms I think I'm probably an
anarchist, and maybe that goes along
with the idea of taking care of your own
self, making do, making your own

music, and having art that's accessible to
the people. It's real important to me that
the music is something that's accessible
that's one of the qualities that drew
old-time music. Sometimes
me
to
feelings in music are lost because there's
such a complexity of technique that's
like things stated really
being used.
simply and clearly. You just lay it right
down on the line and you don't make
fifteen circles around what you want to
I

say, you just say it.

Old-time

music is expressive, great
but you don't have to devote

music,
your life

developing tremendous
in order to play
technique
discipline
it: and although
you can develop the
technique as far as you want, you can
make very strong old-time music with
just a minimum of physical chops, notes
skill. I'm trying to think of examples
to
and

particular that come to mind, but I
think that often what
can't, because
seems to be simple on the surface turns
in

I

out to have layers and layers and layers
on it. Like I said about "Sail Away
Ladies": "Oh, that's simple, I can do
and 25 years later I'm still
that"
peeling layers off of it.

There are some very specific ways in
which I hear old-time music that are

important

it's important to
those sounds. Intonation

to me, and

me to try for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

C for

example, and each one has its own

use.

Tommy Jarrell's intonation, for
example, had so many subtleties to it.
The way those thirds sound is different
than they'd sound if there were frets on
an instrument, and that's what I like
fretless banjo: mainly that you
can get all those different shadings of
notes
intonations. All those different
things are on there, and sometimes I find
that my hands are not well-enough
controlled to always get those degrees
the way 1 hear them in my head.
I
Another thing is chord changes
like certain chord changes and there are
certain kinds of dissonances I like. I
dislike using the seven chord, period. It
has just too modern of a sound. I don't
hear a G chord out of A. In southernstyle music, I like the sound of the E
the five-chord-in "June Apple,"
chord
or "Old Joe Clark." I always tell people,
"There is no G chord in "Old Joe Clark."
I love
the dissonances; those blue notes
are what makes it.
about

a

Just over this last year I've become
aware of a feeling that old-time music is
starting to blossom in a new way.
There's a quality and an energy that's
going on that is so exciting. There seem
to be more

performances and bands who

have some real integrity, some real guts
to their music. Maybe it's a process of
winnowing out the people who are in it
for more of a passing kick, and that the
people who love the music are going to
get deeper into it and play and sing it
with more feeling. They will start to
develop the tradition and carry it on and
not have it be something that's static. You
can't put it back to what it was because
it's just taken off in a whole different

let that music become a part of
soak in
you in some fashion before you can even
begin to learn it. Growing up with it, it is
a part of you, but its being a part of you
from
come
doesn't necessarily
only
it. One can choose. One
something and pursue it. That's
did
immersed myself in oldwhat
time music and raised myself in it.

growing up with
can find
I

A lot of times I feel very strongly that I
want to go around and evangelize for the
old-time music that I love, and say,
"Hey, listen! This is great art, this stands

." But at some point if
with anything.
you even start talking too much about
the idea of art, you're missing the point.
You just have to do it and it has to speak
for itself. And the minute you start
placing it up on a pedestal, no matter
how much it means to you inside, if you
start putting on airs about it, you've
blown the whole importance of what
that music means.
It's a hard thing to get your love of this
music across, because it really comes
from inside of you. It's a very spiritual
sort of thing and I think it has to strike
some chord that goes way, way beyond

anything

rational--

it

transcends

anything that I can make sense of in any
rational way. There has to be some level
on which it's really an affair of the heart.
It's that experience of really being in love
of the feeling being the most import
ant thing.
There's the basic need that people
to find
have to create something
intimate connection with other people
and to somehow transcend their own
mortality. In traditional music, you're
carrying something on and you hope it
will keep on growing and living after
you're gone.

direction. It's become some thing totally

different, and it's not just part of a very
small community, and it's certainly not
part of an isolated community, so you're
going to have a more generalized
.one in
approach. It is a global village
which you've got people from Germany
and Japan who play pretty passable
American traditional music.
Once I went to California to a teaching
festival, and I really enjoyed that because
those people out there are a bunch of
they just latch on to you, and
sponges
like I had to teach; people
it wasn't
would come to me and say, "Oh could
you teach me to play the fiddle or
banjo?" And I just said, "No, I can't teach
you to do this, you have to listen, you
have to get crazy about it, and if you have
any questions come to me and I'll try to
answer them, but I can't just package this
and hand it to you. You have to let it

Gerrard

I

all those subtleties of
for example
intonation. There are so many degrees of

Alice

time music that got hold of me, and I
have a hard time saying what it is. What
really excites that passion is sometimes a
mystery to me, but there are certain
things that just touch me emotionally
certain sounds and certain ways of
expressing. I'm after a certain quality
that
perceive in the music, and it may
there's a certain
not be just one thing
group of feelings and perceptions of the
music. Certainly some of it is the feeling

�Alread}' committed to appear
J or the IBMA Fan Fest are-.

Monroe

Bill
Section with Illegible Text

tante$i
1988
3:00 PM until 1L00PM
Friday, Sept 23, 1988
Noon until 11.00 PM
Saturday, Sept 24, 1988
11:00 AM

until 4:00 PM

Wiseman
Emmylou Harris
Mac

j

j
j
i

Doyle Lawson &amp; Quicksilver
The Wayne Lewis Band
The Tony Rice Unit
J J). Crowe &amp; The New South

Indiana

John Hartford

The IBMA Bluegrass

Borderline

Raymond Fairchild

Crowe Brothers
Found

&amp; The
&amp;

and more yet

Owensboro, Kentucky

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to be

--Advance

3

day special @$15 each

confirmed!

23

Saturday September 24

Sunday September

Y

Km
The

uill be presenting
Bluegrass With Class,
a free program
featuring

ENCLOSED

5

S

IBMA

'

Do NOT send cash!

i

the

McLain F amity Band
with the Owensboro

INTERNATIONAL

BLUEGRASS MUSIC
ASSOCIATION
on

326

Sl Elizabeth Street

Owensboro, Kentucky 42301

Sunday. September 25.

(502)684-9025
TICKETS:
Three day advance
(available until September
Three day tickets

at the

12,

or gate)

Children under age

will be admitted bee

accompanied

by

12

$15

1988)

September

$20

gate

Daily tickets (advance

to.-

IBMA Fan Fest

Tourist Commission
'

25

'
Make Check or Money Order pa) able

Owensboro Datiess County

Sxmohonx Orchestra
beginning at 5:30 PM

Dave Evans

Lost

"a?

Friday September

Curiy Seckler, Willis Spears,
&amp; The Nashville Grass

The Boys from

cur

(h.

Traver Hollow
Randall Hylton
Josh Graves &amp; Kenny Baker

on the Banks of
the Ohio in

DURLV)

--Advance daily tickets @J7 each

The Dry Branch Fire Squad

Jerry Douglas

\vii

uty

change.^

Jesse

Paul Adkins &amp;

will be held in
beautiful English Park

of catastrophe

and The Virginia Boys

Sunday, Sept 25, 1988

Fan Fest 1988

i

bluegrass music, in the
or severe need. All Fan Fest
to

performers are donating their time to appear.
Because of their generositv in this regard, this
schedule and performing roster is subject to

mountain Boys
&amp;

Fund, an independent foundation created by IBMA
to act as a safety' net to assist those who have given

event

Ralph Stanley
and The Clinch

Jim

f
eiAUPmsTotn*
1

their professional lives

and The Blue Grass Boys

Section with Illegible Text

The IBMA Bluegrass Fan Fest is a benefit event for
IBMA and the International Bluegrass Music Trust

$7
if

responsible, ticket buying adult

Owensboro,
Kentucky

�The Dance Beat

The Green

Grass
Cloggers
Phil Jamison

Diane

DuVernet

by

Union Grove, N.C. 1973

previous issues, "The Dance Beat" has
focused on dance in days gone by, and on the
old-timers.
This
column
is
about
a
In

contemporary group that has had a unique
influence on the tradition of old-time dance.

The Green Grass Cloggers are a
of dancers from North Carolina
perhaps, have had more influence
dance scene nationwide than any

group
who,
on the

other
single clogging group. Since 1971, they
have traveled, performed, and taught
their unique style of dance far beyond
the
reaches
of
the
to
Southeast,
thousands of people across the United
States and around the world, and they
have influenced and inspired many with
whom they have come in contact The
importance of this group comes from
their creative combination of tradition
and innovation. With great respect and
reverence for the styles and attitudes of
traditional dancers, the Green Grass
Cloggers have "grandfathered" a whole
new style and approach to clogging that
is now a tradition in itself.
In the spring of 1971, Dudley Culp
went to the Fiddlers Convention at
Union Grove, North Carolina.
In
addition to hearing old-time fiddling, he
saw cloggers and old-time buck dancers
and he became infatuated with their
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

dancing. That fall he and Toni Jordan
went to Harper Van Hoy's Autumn
Square-Up at Fiddlers' Grove. At this
festival, which features a competition for
traditional clogging groups, they learned
a few steps from some
of the dancers.
They also met Willard Watson, a tradi
tional dancer from Deep Gap, North
who was to have a big
Carolina,
influence on the Green Grass Cloggers
(see Old-Time Herald, Vol. 1, No. 3).
Inspired by what they had seen and
learned, and encouraged
by Willard,
Dudley and Toni returned to Greenville,
North Carolina, and started a squaredance and clogging class at East Carolina
University. From this group, the original
Green Grass Cloggers formed. Several
members of the group had recollections
or
other family
of grandparents
members flat-footing or buck dancing,
and though they knew little about it
themselves,
they shared an intense
interest in learning how to dance the oldtime way.
Born out of ignorance, the direction
taken by the early ureen urass Cloggers
came from a lack of knowledge of the
traditions of clogging. A unique style of

innovative

stepping

and

choregraphy

resulted. Since they had seen traditional

groups at Fiddlers' Grove dance with 16
dancers, that is the number the group
decided to start out with. Dudley
that it would be
though,
thought,
interesting to arrange the dancers in two
square formations (four couples in each
set), rather than in the traditional big
circle sets that he had seen. At times the
two squares would dance independently,
and at times they would join together for
a big set.
Rather than using the usual
"circle-up four" figures common to
traditional clogging teams, the Green
Grass Cloggers combined their steps
with western square-dance figures that
they learned from a caller named Betty
Casey.
These young dancers were eager to
learn new steps wherever they could.
Many steps were learned from the older
dancers whom they met at festivals and
fiddlers conventions. Besides Willard
Watson, these included Hansel Aldridge
of

Mecklinburg

County

and

Robert

Dotson of Sugar Grove. They visited

these dancers at their homes to learn
more, becoming the first group to
"collect" steps from various regions. Out
of this,
an eclectic
style of dance
rather
than
a
regional one. At
developed,
fiddlers conventions they could be seen

�late at night, dancing on homemade
dancing boards to the sounds of the oldtime fiddle music. They became friends
with the musicians, and as their musical
awareness grew, they used their dancing
feet as a rhythmic accompaniment to the
music. Green Grass Clogger Wynn
Dinson christened his dancing board a

"Step-A-Tune,"

as

that

is

what

the

dancers did when the fiddlers played.
The name stuck, and now dancers across
the country refer to these dancing boards
as

"step-a-tunes."

old-t imers stressed the
importance of dancing to live, rather
than recorded music. This kept the
group's dancing fresh and spontaneous
and closely linked to old-time music
The

both

in

rhythm

and

their love for music,

doggers

picked
learned to play.
T

up

Driven by
number of the

spirit.
a

instruments

and

raditionally there were no standard

names for clogging steps. As the
Green Grass Cloggers learned new ones,
they named them. Sometimes a step was
named after whoever invented it or
taught it to the group. Steps used in their
ized

first routines included the "Basic," the
"Earl," the "Eddie," the "Indian," the
"Grand Square Kick," and "Karen's
Kick." These steps were combined with
dance figures to create an exciting new
style of team dancing that combined
elements of both traditional and modern

"precision" clogging. (Precision clogging
a
style that was developed in the
1950s. It is often done in lines, as
opposed to traditional big circle figures,
and all the dancers execute the same step
at the same time.) As with traditional
is

clogging groups, the formations used by
the Green Grass Cloggers were from
traditional sources. The steps, however,
were

synchronized

clogging,

designed

in

as

precision

the
was
and
choregraphy
the
to
interest
audience,

making use of fast-paced figures in short
(three minute), energetic routines.
From the start, the attitude of the
dancers was to have fun, rather than to
be

concerned

with

the

competitive

aspects of team dancing. They had
learned from the old-timers that there is
no "right" or "wrong" way to dance, as
long as it is in time with the music. These
older dancers encouraged innovation as
an expression of individuality, and were
the
to
sf'ct
opposed
increasingly

standardization

and

uniformity

of

clogging steps, styles, and costumes that
they saw around them. They inspired the
Green Grass Cloggers to make up their
own steps, but mainly to enjoy dancing.
This attitude,
combined with the
dynamic

choregraphy of the routines,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

made

for

captivated

exciting performances that
audiences with an infectious

spirit.

In their first year, the Green Grass
Cloggers performed at benefits near
their home in Pitt County. The following

spring, the group made its first road trip
when they traveled to the Union Grove

Fiddlers Convention and performed in
exhibition for an audience of thousands.
In contrast to the clean-cut appearance
and carefully matched outfits of the
other clogging groups, the Green Grass
Cloggers, dressed in faded blue jeans and
calico dresses of all different colors,
presenting a scruffy, long-haired look.
Earl liked to wear a fireman's hat while
dancing. Doug wore a derby. This was a
that encouraged individual
group
expression among its dancers. Instead of
the crinolines usually associated with
the
Green Grass Clogger
cloggers,
women wore brightly-colored slips. The
women's black tights, black shoes, and
black leather square-dance belts became
trademarks of their costumes.

When they were first seen,

by

the

clogging world their lively, free-spirited
dancing must have seemed as radical as
their
While traditional
appearance.
cloggers keep their feet close to the floor,
the Green Grass Cloggers used headhigh kicks and other unconventional
steps, giving them a definitely original
and uninhibited look.
The next year (1972), they returned
to the Square-Up at Fiddlers' Grove to
compete in the traditional category of
the dance contest. In spite of their long
haired "hippie" appearance, they won

first place with their high-spirited dancing,
and though they were very popular with
the audience, their winning shook some

people up. Perhaps they were seen as a
threat to the traditions of organized
group clogging. In subsequent years,
contest rules became stricter. The Green

Grass

Cloggers did not fit the new
standards, so they quit competing.
In 1973, the Green Grass Cloggers
made their first appearance at Bascom
Lamar Lunsford's Mountain Dance and
Folk Festival in Asheville. Once again
they were received by an enthusiastic
crowd who stood on their chairs to get a
better
view
of this
new
clogging
phenomenon, and once again, they did
not fit the standardized categories of the
Instead of being
dance competition.
in the contest, however, they
were given a special award. They must
have made an impression on the other
dancers, because the following year
several of the local traditional groups
were seen imitating some of their steps.
By 1974, the Green Grass Cloggers

judged

had an

established reputation and they

received offers to perform at folk
festivals outside their home state. These
included the Philadelphia Folk Festival
(1974-78), the National Folk Festival

(1975-76) and the Great Hudson River
Revival (1977-78). At these northern

festivals, in addition to performing, the
cloggers conducted teaching workshops
at which as many as 3,000 people at one
time learned the basics of clogging,
Green Grass Clogger-style. As a result of
this, clogging groups began to spring up
all around the country. Many of them
had never seen traditional clogging and
had only the Green Grass Cloggers as
their source and inspiration. These
groups in turn taught others. Before long
there were dancers in parts of the
country who had never heard of the
Green Grass Cloggers, but who knew the
"Earl," the "Indian," and other steps,
believing these to be traditional clogging
steps. As they continued to spread
through the "folk-process," these steps
have now become part of the clogging
tradition.
In
1977, half of the Green Grass
Cloggers decided to form a full-time,
professional touring group. They hit the

�Wagner
Ron

Philadelphia Folk Festival 1976
L-R
Rodney Sutton, Toni Jordan Williams,
Culp.

road in their old converted school bus,

"Skillet" (named after the 1920s North
Georgia fiddle band, the Skillet Lickers),
presenting old-time music and clogging
in places where people had never heard
of it before. The "road team" relocated
in
1980
to
Asheville.
They have

continued

to

travel

and

perform and

spread their exuberant style of clogging
across the United States. In recent years
have
traveled
to
11
they
foreign
countries, from South America to

Singapore.

After 10 years of year-round touring,
are no longer
out on the road full time. The Asheville
group, as well as the "home team" still in
Greenville, continued to dance and
perform or. a part-time basis.
Organized group clogging is a 60-yearold traditior that was born at the first
Mountain C tnce and Folk Festival at
Asheville
928 (see Old-Time Herald,
Vol. 1, No
When the Green Grass
Cloggers first appeared in 1971, they
were looked at as a radical aberration
from tradition. By now, after 17 years,
their style of clogging has become a
tradition in its own right. It is a tradition
that has spread far from its source in
North Carolina to groups all across the
country and as far away as Japan, where
the Corn Creek
dance
Cloggers
"
"Indians" and "Earls,
and wear
the Green Grass Cloggers

i

imitation
costumes

Green

Grass

Cloggers
(complete with black tights

and belts).

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(front):
Dudley

There are many clues to identify the

influence of the Green Grass Cloggers.
The most obvious is the use of high kicks

and the other steps and the use of
western square-dance formations. In
general, their steps all start with the right
foot stepping on the first beat of
the music, rather than the left as many
cloggers do.
In their search for good, affordable,
leather-soled shoes, the women in the
group went to second-hand stores where
they found stocky-heeled, orthopedic
shoes, or "granny shoes," as they called
them. These shoes added to the old-time
look of the costume that appealed to the
group.
Today, dancers across the
can
be seen wearing this type of
country
shoe for dancing
a tradition started by
dancers unable to afford good new
shoes! These shoes, the lack of
crinolines, and the characteristic style
of dance are all signs of the influence the
Green Grass Cloggers have had on other
dance groups.
It will be interesting to see what longterm effect these innovations have on the
clogging world in the future. Many of
the
steps are here to stay. More
important though, is the attitude toward
dance spread by the Green Grass
Cloggers. In this age of mass media
where local traditions are rapidly dis

appearing,

these

are

attempts

to

standardize clogging steps and make all
dancers
conform. There are many
continued on page 39

�Issues in Old-Time Music

Anyone who has been involved in an
old-time music recording project is all
too aware of the tremendous time,
effort, and expense required to produce
It usually takes six
a finished recording.
months to a year and costs between
$5,000 and $10,000. Big corporations

federal bucks don't pay for this. The
musicians and the small record labels do.
Their only hope of breaking even (or
making next month's rent) is by selling
copies of their records and tapes.
Home taping-- the practice of
recording an album or cassette onto a
blank tape without paying for it or
is stealing. Home
getting permission-taping is no different than lifting a copy
or two from the concession stand.
don't mean to preach. I feel like
I
Jimmy Swaggart. I have sinned! I've got a
pretty good tape collection at home and I
feel a little guilty about it. But the more
I've learned about the music business-how
and
seriously its future is
or

Patterson

Bobby

In

the

spring

issue

of the

Old-Time

Herald, Mac Benford wrote "Buy or Bye!"
an article to which the OTH has had a great
deal of response. Mac raised several issues,
and one that seems to us to be of great
importance is the issue of unauthorized
dubbing of LPs onto tape. The following
letters are ones we received recently, and
several reprints from other sources. We feel
that they express the concerns of many

including the Old-Time Herald--

ed.

threatened by expanding technology, the
more serious I've become about
establishing a few personal guidelines for
"What's Fair in Home Taping." I'd like
to share these with my fellow old-time
music lovers.
1.

Buy the tape if it's available.
not, buy the album and then tape

2. If
it.

3.

the

Or, ask the record
artist) to issue the

want in cassette version.

through the magazine and
couldn't find anything that didn't
interest me. The most exciting thing for
me was to find out where to get some of
the records I have been listening to on
"dubbed" tapes. I hated the idea of
Lord knows there's
"pirating" records-little enough money in traditional music
but there was no place I knew of
as it is-that sold the records or even knew where
to write for them. I mention this not to
display great virtue, but rather to inspire
your potential advertisers, because I
know for a fact that lots of other oldtime music fans feel just the same way.
read

1

Jack Phillips

Los

In

Alamitos, CA.

response to Mac Benford's article

in

Here! Here! I strongly
agree with everything Mac had to say
about the responsibilities of performers
to be as professional as possible in their
presentation of old-time music, and the
equal responsibilities of the music lovers
to support their efforts financially. He
brought up one point that I would like to
the last issue--

elaborate

on--

home taping.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

company (not
recording you

however, a record is out of print
nearly impossible to find, I don't
think it hurts anyone to tape it for home
use. This includes older and unreissued
recordings.
4- If,

or

also see no harm in taping radio
programs, TV shows, or live
5.

I

performances.

Likewise for making up

special tapes, one cut at a time off of
several different records. Each of these
probably violates somebody's copyright
technically, but I don't think it does a lot
of damage. What is doing damage is
people taping records instead of buying
them.
I would
like to see record companies
release cassette versions of every album
they release. I also feel they should print
more information on the liner sleeves,
and always use the highest-quality tape.
But for them to do this, they need to
know that people will actually buy them,
so they can live to record another day.
Let's

record

support the musicians and the

combined

companies.

Through

our

music will be
heard for generations to come.
I will step
off my soap box now. I just
want to thank Mac Benford for his
stimulating article and thank the Old-Time
efforts,

the

Herald for being

a

forum for these

topics.

John Lilly

Asheville, NC
It's a request that I get often. "Hey
Emily? Do you have the new record by
So-and-So? When can I come over and

tape it?"
You can't. And this

is

something

I

feel

strongly about. I would like to explain
why, because I'd like to see my reasoning
catch on.
A performer makes a record album.
The record is then sold. Part of the
money then goes (or is supposed to,
anyway) back to the artist, and part to"
the record company. Royalties go to

songwriters and/or arrangers.

But what happens when a person buys
record and then lets 30 or 40 of his
closest friends make cassettes of it?
Simple. Sony (or Maxell or TDK or
some other firm) pockets the money,

a

not the artist, nor the
writer/arranger, nor the recording
no

and

one--

company--

gets

a

dime. And, no doubt,

the tape pirate (which is what he or she
is) gripes about how few good albums
there are, or complains because some
recording artist isn't touring anymore

can't
afford it. And
he
because
at
the
back
meanwhile,
tape deck, certain
enterprising people who taped the
original record are now making second-

generation tapes for their friends.
I
know records are more expensive.
it's

But--

worth

it,

not only for the

technical sound-quality reasons, but also
--most

want

to

because if you
importantly-have this music available on

record, somebody has to pay for it. And
don't think that the record companies
are just rolling in money and couldn't
possibly be hurt by your taping. Those
or
firms that make old-time albums-blues, or spoken words, or bluegrass--

in a tiny and uncertain
their
and
market,
profits are thin. If sales
drop as costs rise, they have to hike up

are

working

the price of the
in part, to the

product. And that

is

due,

And it is
who
who
like
records,
me,
buy
people
are subsidizing those of you who steal
them on tape.
So, for whatever it's worth, here are
my rules. I do not allow taping of avail
able records unless the person making
the tape is dying for a certain album-and demonstrates
know how that feels-that he or she will purchase the record by
showing me proof of having ordered it.
will also sometimes allow taping of one
song or tune by a singer or picker who
needs to learn it. I make tapes for myself,
tape pirates.

I

I

�for car travel. And I will let some people
tape items from my out-of-print records.
You can't copy my concert tapes
I
either.
believe that unauthorized
copying of such tapes hurts record sales,
because people will listen to those tapes
rather than records. I also believe that
can
be
hurt
14th
performers
by
generation, fuzzy, distorted tapes of their
work made on off nights or during
experimental sets.
I'm selfish. I want to have the best
artists and recordings available to me

and that's only going to happen if we all
become more conscious of who we are
ripping off when we pirate tape records
or tapes. In the end we hurt ourselves.

Emily Friedman

Chicago,

small, independent record industry. The
people who engineer the records, who
drive the trucks, who run the ware
houses, who press the albums, who
answer the phones, who design the
jackets, who distribute them to your
local stores
all those people are hurt
time
someone
every
bootlegs a record or
tape. This handful of small companies is
the voice of democracy in the recording
industry. Without them there wouldn't
be alternative music in your stores, your
radio, your life. Please do what you can
to stem the tide of this illegal and

unethical trend. It can, literally, make
the difference between someone being

able to work or not. Between having this
music available or not.

John McCutcheon
Charlottesville, VA

IL

(Reprint: "Why You Can't Tape My
Vol. g, No. 2, Spring 1983,
Records",
Come for to Sing, a quarterly journal
published in Chicago; used with permission
ed.)

We've all been hearing a lot the past
couple of years or so about the arrival of

audio tape (DAT) on the U.S.
market. The debate surrounding DATs
availability has centered on the issue of
home taping and its affect on the
recording industry. There has been talk
about notches being introduced
to
prevent home taping of pre-recorded
LPs, tapes, and CDs, banning the format
altogether, and a variety of ways to curb
potentially catastrophic financial losses
to the industry. Home taping has been an
digital

years: audio cassettes
introduced a whole new way for people
to customize their listening and, let's face
save money by copying someone
it,
else's album. Technology isn't going to
stop this practice. Legislation won't do
it. The spectre of Michael Jackson not
being able to afford any more cosmetic
surgery won't do it. I'm convinced

issue

for

there's only one way to curb this growing

phenomenon: education.
Most

of the people who release
every year are little-known
artists on small, independent record
labels. People like us depend on what
little real income we are able to generate
from album sales to do our work. Our
sales figures, even for those of us who
sell relatively well, would be a joke to
any major label. Every album taped is
another album not sold in the stores. If
artists have poor sales, a store will not
stock their albums, making it even
harder for people to find their work. The
of home taping absolutely
practice
jeopardizes not only the musicians
involved, but the very survival of the
albums

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

from

the Appalseed
Productions Newsletter December, 1987.)

(Reprinted

Mac Benford's article "Buy or Bye!"
an

insightful

and

is

thought-provoking

look at current attitudes among old-time
music enthusiasts, especially regarding
the commercial side of the music. Mac
brought up a number of issues that
warrant further thought and discussion.
I would
like to air a few thoughts on the
of
subject
dubbing records of old-time
music onto cassette tapes.
Any critical look at this issue must
take historical precedence into account.
It is a simple fact that old-time music

enthusiasts,

especially

musicians

wanting to learn how to play, have been
trading tapes among themselves since at
least the 1960s. My sense is that much of
the music traded through this network
has been field recordings made in the

homes of traditional musicians,

or

at

festivals and conventions. Because of the
relative scarcity of institutional folk
music archives, and inaccessibility of
many archives that do collect traditional
southern music, this informal network
of tape archives is essential for many
enthusiasts who want to study the music
or learn tunes or playing techniques. As
long as the musicians who are being
recorded (or their heirs) voice no
objections to their playing being dubbed
onto tapes for others, this kind of tape

dubbing is to be encouraged.
However, the dubbing of a record
onto a tape for distribution to one's
friends is a far different matter. As Mac
stated in his article, dubbing a record
album is, in effect, taking the music for

one's

own

use

without

fairly

the artists.
Given the
most
musicians
have
to
budget
try to live

compensating

this is taking money out of the
pockets of those who need it most.
Copying records onto tapes has an
equally detrimental effect on record
companies. Old-time music is definitely

within,

least in terms of
among the general
There is a relatively small
audience of potential buyers; so small
that most record companies would never
even consider issuing old-time music on
their
labels. Yet, old-time music
"fringe"

music,

popular
public.

appeal

enthusiasts

at

have

been

lucky

like County,
Heritage,
Rounder, Old Homestead, Arhoolie,
(and others), are headed by individuals
who issue albums of old-time music even
though these records have for years been
mainly break-even ventures. Dubbing
albums onto tape can tip the balance

companies

from a break-even to a losing
proposition. We cannot expect these
companies to consistently take losses on
their issues of old-time music.

Indeed, the past few years have seen a
marked decrease in the number of
reissue albums of string band music
from the 1920s and 30s, as well as in the
recording of current old-time music.
The lesson here is for us all to think
carefully next time we start to dub a
record album for friends. Instead of
copying the tape, let's buy the record. It
will result in compensation to the artists
who play the music and will send a signal
to record companies that there will be a
market for albums of old-time music
among its fans.

Wayne Martin

Durham, NC

Mac Benford's article "Buy or Bye!" in
1988 issue of the Old-Time
Herald is one of the most refreshing,
the spring

accurate, and best-written pieces on old-

time music that I've ever read. I am glad
to see it coming from an actual old-time

musician, and one who has presented his
music with good taste and cannot be
accused of trying to "commercialize" the
music.
Over the past four or five years we
have witnessed a disturbing trend that
has
seen old-time
music virtually
the
from
marketplace. As
disappear
recently as the early and mid-1970s
there seemed to be a very healthy and
active old-time "scene" that included
shows and festivals on many college

informal and semiprofessional bands in many large and
medium-sized cities and towns of the
Southeast (and elsewhere), and believe

campuses,

�it or not
an actual bin labeled "OldTime Music" in many of the better
record shops. While there are still a great
many people who love and play old-time
music now, everything seems to have

gone

underground

today:

as

a

manufacturer and distributor of oldtime music on LP County Records finds
it almost impossible to get any but the
very largest or most sophisticated record
shops to carry any old-time records,
whether they be classics like Uncle Dave
Macon and Gid Tanner, or upcoming
new groups.
As Benford points
out, many of
today's old-time music fans seem to have
a
hangup with "commercialization" to
the point where they reject buying a
record, preferring to tape a friend's
(perhaps with the feeling that this is
somehow closer to a folk-like trans
mission of the music). With a little

broader

vision

these

potential

supporters of the music might realize

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

that the tiny companies that still issue
old-time music are not hype-crazed

monster corporations but are more akin
to
the
small,
highly individualistic
craftsperson who plies a trade as much as
a labor of love as for financial reward and
can be proud of an honest day's work.

old-time

realize just
today's
how their "votes" counted at sales
counters we would see the issuance of a
lot more worthy projects on LP that
simply will not come out in today's
climate. As a producer of records for
over 20 years, let me put it in actual
figures:
many of today's beautifully
old-time LPs, with neat
packaged
booklets, etc., barely hit 1,000 sales
they either just break even, or in many
cases
lose some
for
their
money
producers (grants sometimes make up
the difference). If these same records
If

fans

sold just 1,800 or 2,000 copies, costs
would be regained relatively quickly (in
most cases) and many more projects

could

and would be undertaken. The
results: more exposure for the music, a
little money earned for the musicians
themselves, and the preservation of
sounds that will bring enjoyment to
future as well as today's musicians and

listeners.

there anyone who is not glad that
musicians of the past like G. B.
Grayson, Charlie Poole, and Burnett &amp;
Rutherford were preserved on phono
graph records, albeit "commercially"
Is

great

recorded?

Dave Freeman

County Records

�HERE

was

seven days

&amp;

This, unfortunately,

Old-Time Music in the
Philadephia Area
Keith Brand

Philadelphia keeps
traditional music

a

steady pace

is

as far

concerned. The

major events for this area are ones that
have been here for many years: the
Philadelphia Folk Festival and the

Brandywine

Mountain

Music

at

one time

Convention. Brandywine,

that featured
largest festival
primarily old-time music, has been held
here in the Philadelphia area for 13
the

years. This vear the festival is slated for
the third weekend in July. It should be
noted that the Brandywine Friends of

Old-Time Music

do produce a number
old-time and bluegrass
musicians throughout the year. The
now
Philadelphia Folk Festival,
celebrating its 21st year, is a much more
eclectic festival, featuring Irish, folk,
blues, and Cajun music. Recently the
Folksong Society, which produces the
summer folk festival, has promoted a
spring old-time and bluegrass music
festival. This year the concert featured

of concerts

by

Branch

Fire Squad, Doc
The Wildcats, and the
Hotmud Family.
Dry

Watson,

demise

The

of

the

Tuesday-night
House has
changed the focus of the old-time
musicians in the Philadelphia area. It has
been supplanted by a Thursday and
Saturday-night contra dance at Summit
dance

at

International

Church, and a Fridaydance in Lambertville,
New
Jersey, where you can occasionally find
Philadelphia-area musicians and callers.
Out in the southern part of Chester
County (about an hour and a half drive
south of Philadelphia) is a once-a-month
dance in Cochranville. Set up in an old
Presbyterian
night

school,

elementary
occasionally
guests, and

is

features
a

and old.

the dance
out-of-town

nice mixture

of young

The major old-time event of the recent
past

was

the

Chokers concert

a

is

the

exception

rather than the norm, and there are not
many places for Philadelphia-area oldtime musicians to play. An interesting
new development was a recent concert
by a relatively new band from the area

called

as

by the

released new albums and over 300 people
attended the concert.

THERE

by

local radio station
folk music
week. Both bands had just

sponsored

WXPN-FM, which features

Horseflies/Chicken

and dance. This event

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Germantown

Alley

Cats,

Ramblers.

Bob

playing vintage ragtime and blues. They
managed to secure a job at one of the
more eclectic clubs in Philadelphia called
Bacchanal, and I hope that bodes well
for other kinds of off-beat music.
Even with a lack of venues,
Philadelphia has more than it's share of
musicians. Both the Heartbeats and the
Wildcats boast members culled from
the Philadelphia area. There are other
bands that perform occasionally, such as
the Sly Dogs, the Deadbeats, and the

Forge

Carlin,

Mountain
from

Philadelphia, also
sometimes with Bruce

performs
Molsky. Needless

to say,

although

we

scattered over a large metropolitan
area, Philadelphia is still fertile ground
for young old-time musicians.
are

�Mole in the Ground, Men without
the
Frets, the Foremost Lickers,
Mother Pluckers, and many groups of
the Red Nubbins and his Friends
type. While they vary in quality, bands
at the dances are always good and often

excellent.
The dances include both squares and
contras, and are always walked through
beforehand and usually called through'
out. They have an excellent group of
callers, including Jim Borzym, Paul
Ford, Linda Hart, Pat Mahaffee, Bill

Meek,

Tony

Sudkamp,
Watkins,

Scarimbolo, Bill
Paul Tyler, Paul

and Eric

Zorn.

guitar. The
plays banjo
center has become a home for the oldtime music community,
emphasizing

Miller,

and

music playing, teaching, and partici
pation. On the second and subsequent
Fridays of each month, the Adler Center
has several jams (including old-time and
bluegrass) followed by an open stage.
They have an excellent concert series,
old-time musicians.
often
featuring
Their annual Traditional Music Awards
for Midwest senior musicians began in
1983 with an award to Pappy Taylor,
and since then have recognized (among
others) lesser-known people such as
Reverend Jim Howie (a circuit-riding
preacher who plays autoharp) and Don
Adams (long-time barn-dance caller).
Old-time jams tend to blossom when
the weather gets warmer. A several-year

tradition

is

the
the
by

sponsored
Chicago Folklore

Fiddlers

Picnic

University
Society.

of

This

is

usually held on a Saturday in May. The
picnic and jam take place on one of the
grassy quadrangles of the university,
bordered by Gothic-inspired, gargoyled
buildings. The event and the setting draw
a wide range of players and listeners; it's

Skip
Courtesy

Dance Company publishes a two-month
calendar of dances, workshops, and
dance-related events.
Another center for old-time music is
in
the Adler Cultural Center
Libertyville, Illinois, northwest of
Chicago. Doug Miller, who directs the
programs, is a strong proponent of oldtime music. He plays guitar, fiddle, and
autoharp; his wife, Bonnie Issacson-

Landt

The Barn Dance Company welcomes
visiting bands and callers; groups
planning to travel in this direction and
wanting to get on the schedule may call
Mark at (312) 342-5474. The Barn

L-R: Garry Harrison, Pappy Taylor 1983

players.
Beginning

School

Wednesday of every month, and is often
preceded by a jam. With summer comes
the

held

Company,

open,

and

has been small but very
includes some very good

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the

at

home

of Bill

Sudkamp, including jamming
outdoor dance.
While not strictly

and

an

old-time festival,
the
University of Chicago Folk
Festival, started in 1960, has a strong
component of old-time music. For years
a

signature

an

festival was the
Through
also
the festival

act of the

New Lost City Ramblers.
this association,
attracted some rare treats,
appearance
early concert
Boggs, the unique banjo

such
by

player

as

an

Dock
and

recording artist, rediscovered when
Mike Seeger found his name in a
More
telephone directory.
Virginia
recently, the festival has brought in Brad

Leftwich
the

and

Linda Higginbotham,

Whitstein

Benton

in January

Dewan. This

Dance

of the Barn

annual picnic

Wednesday

month, headed by Jim

began

open barn dance, with
sponsoring
new players invited to play in the band
along with experienced musicians
another activity of the Chicago Barn
Dance Company. It is the first
an

Enroe,
Smokey

a

Music

Folk

of

an excellent place for people
any level.
A new old-time jam has recently been
started at the Abbey Pub on one
at

May, the Old Town

this

Waldron.
perhaps
usually

is

Valley

Brothers, Lyman
Flippen and the
Boys,

and

Betty

The weekend festival is held

or early February, and
to spite the cold weather
the occasion for some very hot

in

sessions on Saturday and Sunday
afternoon.
and
Several clubs
organizations
of folk music,
performances
sponsor

jam

including

Tradition

music.

old-time

Aural

Chicago has a varied
schedule of concerts each year including
groups like Rich Kir by and Tom
in

Paul and Win, and
Critton Hollow String Band. In

Bledsoe,

the
the

Folklore
Society (Aurora), Hogeye Music
(Evanston), and the Old Plank Road
suburbs,

Fox

the

Valley

(Brookfield) also have series including
old-time performers. Clubs like No
Exit, The Listening Post, Montclaire

Coffeehouse,

and

book
Chicago)
related acts,

Orphans

some
as

do

(all

old-time

in

and

Fitzgerald's

(Berwyn), Friendship Concert Hall
Prospect), Two Way Street
(Mt.
(Downers Grove), and Washington
Stret Mercantile (Oregon). The Rock
Valley Folk Festival, a festival held
each July in Rockford, is an excellent,
small, friendly weekend festival that
often includes old-time music acts. The
Fox

Valley

larger,

Folklore

Festival is a
weekend

very-high-quality

festival in early September that includes
old-time acts and is very popular with
the Chicago folk community. There are
numerous one-day community festivals,
usually free and low-budget although

some are quite large, that include or
feature old-time crafts and music; for

�Americana Day, held each
Carpentersville, Illinois, draws
about 10,000 people.
example,

June

in

The Chicago area has many music
stores, but few are interested in folk
music and only one emphasizes old-time
music. Hogeye Music in Evanston
("fifty years behind the times") has an
excellent selection of records and books,
and high quality new and used acoustic

instruments.
Strummer,

Different

The

new store at
School of Folk Music,
selection of records but
holdings in the broader
a

the Old Town
has a smaller

good eclectic
area of folk

an
excellent section of
instructional books, and new and used
acoustic instruments.
The Old Town School of Folk
Music, founded in 1957, offers
excellent classes and private instruction
in
most acoustic folk instruments,

music,

including

guitar,

harmonica,

and

classes,

banjo,

autoharp.
bluegrass

including
bring

fiddle,

Ensemble
and

blues

students
together
different instruments to work

ensemble,
playing

out and perform arrangements of pieces.
A twice-monthly coffeehouse on Friday

coordinated by Mark Dvorak
includes a feature performer or group,
nights
and

open

gives

students

extremely
audience.

and

to

time

others

responsive,

Vicki

and

stage

Moss

both
with

to
an

supportive

coordinates

a

for

large
growing program
young
children and their parents, and there is

Any such listening inevitably leaves
out important musicians and other key
individuals that don't fit into any par
ticular niche. For example, the Lake
Town Buskers is an exciting band with

evening

Jim Hirsch, executive director, is a
superb finger-picking guitar player
lapsed into administration, and Michael
Miles, program director, is an excellent

an

to

range from old-time to jug
with Colin McCoy

swing,

(fiddle), Barb Silverman (washboard),
and fiddle),
Bob Stehlniki (washtub bass extraor
dinaire). Schools in Chicago and the
suburbs
have
old-time
experienced
music early this year from All Jump
Up, a b and including Jenny
Armstrong (fiddle, banjo), Barb
Silverman (guitar, washboard), and
Eric Mohring (mandolin

eclectic banjo and guitar player. A new
addition to the staff is Paul Tyler,
museum curator, an old-time music
specialist who plays guitar and fiddle and

responsible for the school's library
museum collections. Others on the
staff especially interested in old-time are
Mark Dvorak (banjo), Jim Dewan
(guitar and mandolin), Gus Friedlander
is

and

Paul Tyler (fiddle, mandolin,
accordian) through a program
sponsored by Urban Gateways. Ron

Michele Kaminski
clogging), Vicki Moss

(banjo and guitar),

(fiddle,

eclectic

band

Brown,

(clogging), and Skip and Fran Landt
(harmonica and banjo; autoharp).

a

fiddler and guitar player, has

excellent collection and extensive
of old-time
music
and
knowledge
an

blues recordings before 1935;
is willing
to trade for
similar material. Laura Gloger in Hyde
Park maintains an eclectic list of folk
country

he

sometimes

activities/information

throughout

the

resource for the
of
University
Chicago Folk Festival.
Lois Lubin compiles a monthly listing
of folk music/ dance events in the
Chicago area that is published by Aural
area

and

Tradition

is

a

and

major

sent

each

month

to

members. Dave Reynolds of the Old
Plank Road group, and Shinobu Sato
of the Listening
Post have been
especially encouraging of young talent
and open to booking old-time groups.

Ann,

Tom,

University

of Chicago Fiddlers Picnic

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1987

and

Kathy

Jones

in

have an old-time
band
and
teach
old-time banjo
family
and guitar. Don and Jenny Floyd of

Lombard,
Landt

programs

throughout the school's
on the pleasures
of

Most

Skip

emphasis

music."

classes include a "second half" in which
students from different classes get
together to do several songs.

Courtesy

an

"homemade

Illinois,

Illiana Bluegrass Society
the
sometimes book old-time acts for shows
in
Crete, Illinois.
Finally, a major
resources for all folk activities in the
northern Illinois: Juul Ulven, who
continued on page 39

�won't

ASK

swear

spelling, either. It
in tablature, as
well as a little record with tuning and
some tunes.
Uncle Harold will continue this
research
are there any readers who
know anything that can help S. B.? One
to the

contained some tunes

?

Uncle Harold

last

go to your local library,

suggestion

college or university library, if there's
one near you. If you library is on-line
with a state library system, you have a
huge number of books available to you
and can get them through interlibrary loan. Librarians are also very
helpful types and might steer you
towards what you need.
or

Uncle Harold received the following
communique recently: "This may sound
like a sobering question, but what do
before
about 'Whiskey
you know

mean the tune. It is played
to the point of over-indulgence by oldtime musicians across the country, but
I've never met anyone who can tell me its
asked Frazier Moss, an
origins. When
older fiddler from Tennessee, he said he
learned it from a younger fiddler in
recent years. Where did it come from?"

Breakfast?'

I

I

Siened,
Boozy in Boise

What
of Hope, Indiana, writes, "I
steel guitar and also a
Hawaiian
play
Dobro, which are really the same
For some time I have
instrument.
been looking for music published in
tablature (or diagram method) for the
Hawaiian guitar. ..."
S.B.
a

A. Your intrepid uncle spent a little
time in his helpful local music store,

through their music book
catalogues, including Oak Publication's
list of books. Total books and literature
on Hawaiian guitar: one book, publisher
Guitar
Hawaiian
entitled
unknown,
leafing

Method

Note

System

Book

i,

by

Manoloff (no first name given). There

a book two. Mel Bay
thousand instruments")
didn't list a Hawaiian guitar book.
Neither did Oak. Uncle Harold,

didn't appear to be
("man

of

a

reaching far, far back into his memory
banks, remembers seeing a book (an
Oak publication, he thinks, but would
not swear to it) with a title something
like Slack Key Guitar (another name for
Hawaiian guitar, since it involves open

tunings, in which strings are tuned
down, or "slacked"). The book was
written by Keola Beamer. Your uncle
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

an

interesting

question;.

And believe it or not, your uncle was
unable to come up with any definitive
answer!

Lots

of people came

up with

vague theories as yet unproven or undisproven. Well, it seems to be a fairly
new tune, and not Irish; although Cathy
Sky did tell Uncle Harold she'd heard it a
lot in Ireland, but she looked it up in
O'Neill's and it wasn't there. Uncle
Harold doesn't think it sounds Irish,
anyway.
His friend George Schissler knows a
lot about tunes, and has his enormous
record and tape collection cross-indexed
as to tunes. He told Uncle Harold that
"Whiskey before Breakfast" appeared
on nine records in his collection, all by
the
for
musicians,
except
younger
Missouri fiddle album I'm Old But I'm
Awfully Tough, on which the tune is
this was apparently
played by Troy Lee
recorded in the '60s. Lee says he learned
tune from "Canadian fiddlers."
the
George found, also, that it was recorded
in the '50s by Tommy Jackson on the
album Swing Your Partner
Square
Dances Without Calls. In the liner notes
Jackson attributes the tune to Canadian
fiddler Andy Dejarlis who wrote
"Peacock Rag" and "Red Apple Rag."
George told me that John McCutcheon
31

says in the liner notes to his album How
Can
Keep from Singing that he learned
I

tune

the

from

Ben

of

Hensley,

Speedwell, Tennessee.

really know where
"It just sort of
appeared in the early '70s," he told
Uncle Harold. "People came back one
year from Weiser playing it." He also
said it might be from Texas, and a lot of
fiddlers had learned it from Benny
Kerry Blech didn

it

was

from,

t

either.

Thomasson.

End of trail. Not Irish
but is it
Canadian? Is it from Texas? If it's a new
tune, who wrote it? Anyone out there
know? Relieve your uncle of his burden
of ignorance.

O.

Jr., of Mooresville, N.C.,
large can of worms by wanting to
"Are there official criteria to

E.,

opens
know,

a

Dance'

'Buck

distinguish

and

'Clogging?'"

Uncle

Harold

turned

to

the

unflaggingly helpful Phil Jamison for his

opinion on this matter. As with so many
questions on traditional subjects, it
is
cut-and-dried
there
no
appears

answer. Phil writes, "There are as many
differing opinions on this question as
there are dance styles. A fine line is hard
to draw. Generally, buck dance refers to
an older individual style; clogging to
newer styles and group dancing. Contest
differ
rules
widely to account for
personal and regional style and tastes."
He

goes

on

to

say,

"There

is

perhaps there should not be,
standard."

a

no,

and

universal

Phil wants you
yes, you, the OTH
reader, to write him, care of his column
"The Dance Beat," with your ideas and
opinions on the difference between buck
"How about
and
dance
clogging.

hoedowning? Flatfooting? Jigging? Buckand-wing?

Step

dancing?"

Somebody give that boy

a

he

writes.

set of taps!

Lewisville, N. C., wants to
about reissues of the songs of
"Little Jimmy (who?), the Boy Wonder,
who toured with his dad during the '20s
and '30s, and claimed to know by heart
more than 200 songs, among them the
'Chewing Gum Song' and Tvly Little
Rooster.'" D. M. has heard the
mysterious Little Jimmy on WPAQjs
"Blue Ridge Echoes" program.
D. M.,

know

Thanks to Gary Reid at County
Records! He was a mine of information.
He told Uncle Harold that Little Jimmy
was the son of Asher Sizemore. He was
in Manchester, Kentucky, and they

born

�did indeed tour in the '20s and '30s, as
Asher Sizemore and Little Jimmy. And,
Old Homestead
yes! There is a record
has a record of a radio show broadcast
(1937). The record is Songs of the Soil,
OCHS 163. Little Jimmy was nine years
old then.

Skip Landt from Chicago writes:

"I'd

about folks who play, or

like to hear

used to play, mouthharp in an old-time
style; records or tapes, information
about players, bands, performances, or
whatever. Let's not let them be for
gotten! Skip Landt, Old Town School of
Folk
909 West Armitage,
Music,

Chicago,

IL

60614.

The other evening your uncle

was

sitting on his front porch when up rolled
a large, black
car with tinted windows.
Two metallic-suited individuals, bald,
with blue skin got out. They came right
up to Uncle Harold and greeted him in
an unrecognizable foreign tongue, and
handed him an envelope containing

following letter:
"Dear Uncle Harold,
the

My good friend Eoj Nezi, points out
that while you conduct an interesting
column, you can't lleps for naebs. 'Einna
Emitgar' is a real popular enut in these
traps, but too many folks leave off the A
trap.

Best wishes from the other side,
Elcnu Dlorah"

drove off down the
Harold could swear the

As

they

Uncle

road
car's

wheels weren't touching the pavement
but you know your uncle
he tends to
have

a

vivid imagination.

the tune is "Einna Emitgar." Your
was slack. In this universe many
people leave off the C part. There you have
Yes,

uncle

it in

a

llehstun.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�OLD-TIME MUSIC
ON THE RADIO
by

Our calls for information about where
old-time music on the air have
been
We
heard
from
productive.
to find

Emily Fine

KCAW

carries

special

programs

featuring old-time music, including the

Alaska Folk Festival, the Border Folk
Festival, and others. Traditional artists,
in both commercial and field recordings,

Tennessee to
California and Massachusetts. Most are
public radio stations, either community
or affiliated with National Public Radio,
and many are associated with a college or
university.

and contemporary/ revival/ professional
old-time musicians are featured.
Raven Radio, KCAW, 104:7 FM, 102
B Lincoln St., P.O. Box 520, Sitka,

many areas, the only folk music on
is on NPR affiliates or on
other widely syndicated shows such as A

central California:

stations

from Memphis,

In

the radio dial

Praire

Home Companion, its
replacement Good Evening, Our Front
Porch, or Mountain Stage. Whatever

these shows' merits, they can't be said to
play old-time music in any consistent
way. We focus here on stations and
programs that do play it consistently.
Commercial stations that play any
old-time music are few and far between,
even though more radio stations have a
"country" format than any other format.
Those that play old-time music are either

mavericks or are located in regions with
an
unusually strong local musical
tradition, such as the Galax-Mount Airy
area. (See OTH #2 for information on
radio there.)

Since radio can create, as well as serve,
audience, it's particularly important
to the survival of old-time music to
discover the varying niches that it can fit
into in a radio station's programming.
Here are some examples of that variety:
KCAW-FM, 104.7 FM, Sitka,
Alaska:
Raven Radio, a community-access,
American Public Radio
NPR
and
affiliate reaching Southeast Alaska, does
seem to play old-time music regularly.
program director,
Jake Schumacher,
reports that "Pickin' in the Wind", on
Fridays from 6:15-- 8:00 p.m., programs
old-time and bluegrass together, while
"Folkus" mixes old-time music with
music
general folk and traditional
Thursdays 10 a.m. --12 noon. One might
also hear some old-time music sprinkled
in the country-western shows "Country
4:00 p.m., or
Bummin'", Sat. 1:30-"Lullabies, Legends, and Lies", Fri. 8:30
an

--10:00 p.m.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Alaska 99835. Phone (907) 747-5877.

various

KUSP-FM,

frequencies,

88.9 FM, Santa Cruz, Monterey and
counties.
90.3 FM, in the West Santa Clara

San Benito

valley,

89.9

FM,

in

the

Palo

Colorado

canyon,
91.7 FM, on the Big Sur coast, and on
various cable systems.

Community

commerical

supported,

non-

station KUSP carries the
usual NPR news programs. Chris Jong's
"Monday Afternoon Folk Show", 1-3
p.m., frequently features old-time music
on record, tapes of field recordings, and
live

performers,

as

well

as

"other

and
in-the-tradition
folk
traditional
songs and dance tunes" from all over.
This show is part of the folk/ ethnic slot
1-3 p.m. weekdays. A live show of
acoustic music, "The New Feed and Seed
Hour", Sunday
p.m., broadcast
from the feed store in Santa Cruz, is
sandwiched between an acoustic and an
music show.
Per
electric
country
formers travelling in the vicinity and
wishing to appear on the live show
should contact John Sandidge at KUSP.
KUSP, P.O. Box 423, Santa Cruz, CA

3-4

95061. (408) 476-2800.

KJAA, 1510 AM, Mesa, Arizona:
In the Phoenix, Arizona, area, one can
tune in to A1 Ferguson's program, "The
History of Country Music", airing 12
6 p.m. Saturdays and Sundays.
noon
He features early country music from the
Carter Family andjimmie Rodgers on, as
well as C&amp;lW, western swing, bluegrass,
and local Arizona artists. A radio veteran
from stations in Kansas, Ohio and
Indiana, A1 can be reached at KJAA, 65
E. First Ave., Mesa, AZ 85202. Request

phone line (602) 969-6200.
WLFH, 1230 AM, Little Falls, NY:
Starting in January, 1986, "Acoustic
Country," Sunday 10:30 p.m.-- 12 mid
night, features, folk, bluegrass, "moun
tain," "hillbilly," and old-time country
music, on this station in upstate New
York, "Country 123." The host, J. R.
Hornyak, an avid old-time music fan,
produces the show in his home studio.
He occasionally plays 78-rpm records
not available on LP reissue albums, as
well as new releases, and plays a "feature
yodel tune" every single show. To
write
"Acoustic
the
contact
show,
205
Radio,
Country," WLFH-AM
Gordon Ave., Sherrill, NY 13461.

89.9

WEVL-FM,
Tennessee:

FM,

12,600-watt,

This

Memphis,

full-fledged

volunteer-run community radio station

carries a wide variety of short programs,
in what is called "block programming."
In this particular circumstance, old-time

music flourishes! Station manager Judy
Dorsey hosts the "Old-Time Country
on
Hour"
from 3-4
Music
p.m.
Wednesdays,
featuring real old-time
music, "southern string bands, white
boys singing the blues, comic songs, and
fiddle favorites from the '20s and '30s."
A large number of other programs play a
few pieces of old-time music each week.
a
For
program schedule and more
write or call WEVL-FM
Box 40952, Memphis, TN

information,
90,

P.O.

38174. (901) 278-3845.

is falling out of
radio
even in non-commercial
circles. The trend is towards a stream
lined presentation, appealing to a less
specialized audience, and better suited

Block programming

favor

Old-time
listening.
other demanding
is
bound to suffer. So it's
important to support radio that bucks
the trends and plays what you want to

for

background

music,
music,

hear.

along

with

�County

Sales

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
W
READY FOR SHIPMENT

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
NEW RELEASES
CO-786

*CCS-109
BRI-010
ROU-021 3
CCLP-0103
JA-051
ROU-0175
CO-412

*TQ-5055
AT-103

"CCS-111

QS-5031

FCOT-001
CO-787
"CMF-011
OH- 191

*REB-853

*SH-3759
*ROU-0233
HER-070

*ROU-0242

FCOT-005
*FF-415
"HAT-3022
"CO-791

'CCS-110
*CO-788
*REB-850
"FF-352
*JA-014
"CO-790
*HH-

TR-l

19842

CO-545
CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406
HER-63

CO-777

GFS-901
AH-002
SOUNDA-001
*REB-852

GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent fields recordings of the Cumberland Plateau area
w/booklet
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings
Vol. 2" Great reissue of his classic
950's recordings
VIRGINIA TRADITIONS
EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO Great old-time w/Roy Hall,

7.50
7.50

1

Tommy Magness, etc
CHOKERS &amp; FLIES "Old Time Music" Fine recent material by the Chicken Chokers &amp; Horseflies
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Singles Collection" Neat reissue of obscure 50's/60's cuts -some unissued
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo LP by this Kentucky musician
JAMES BRYAN "Lookout Blues" Fine old-time fiddle, featuring Norman &amp; Nancy Blake
DOC ROBERTS "Old Time Tunes" Great reissue of his tunes from the 1920 s &amp; 30's
NO STRINGS ATTACHED "Dulcimer Dimensions" Fine hammer dulcimer by this Virginia
group
POSSUM (IP A GUM STOMP Commercial &amp; field recordings of Alabama fiddlers

FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "You Can Feel It In Your Soul" Classic gospel from the 950's
DOC WATSON "Out In The Country" Fine live recordings from the 1960 s
OLD HOLLOW STRINGBAND Old-time music from North Carolina
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN -TRADITIONAL MUSIC FROM THE CUMBERLAND PLATEAU -Vol.
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
Vol 1" Reissue fo 1920s material
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroe's best early 1950s Decca material
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish -w/booklet
NASHVILLE BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent old-time LP
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike
Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930 s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 1940 s King material
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscojlre" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this
Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T. Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTWICH &amp; HIGGINBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
HEE HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel
singing

S

7.50
7.50

1

TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music

UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine I920's/30's sides
SKILLET LICKERS
Vol 2 "Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carroll County, Virginia
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920's/30's
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 1938-41
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL with Mike Seeger, Brad Leftwich,
Benny Jarrell, etc
VIRGIL ANDERSON "On The Tennessee Line" Old-time banjo from the upper Cumberland
SEEMS LIKE ROMANCE TO ME Traditional fiddle tunes from Ohio
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American fiddle music from Mississippi
EDDEN HAMMONS COLLECTION Historic set of traditional fiddle music
LOUVIN BROTHERS "The Best OF' Features their top songs from the middle 1950s

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted
On all ORDERS

in

by an

(ISA. please add $2.00 postage

&amp;

asterisk

"

handling

")

CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $5.00 postage for first -3 LPs, $1.50 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00

7
2

50

7.50
$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
$10.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
$10.00
7.50

�Record
TRADITIONAL
MUSIC FROM
THE

CUMBERLAND
PLATEAU
VOLUME Is
GETTIN'

UP THE
STAIRS

County 786

Skippin'

Snow/The

the Frost
and
French Waltz/Me and My
Had a Little Falling Out/

through

Old Wife
Sleepin' Lulu/Candy

Gal/Cumberlin'
Land/Gettin' up the Stairs/Wild Goose
Chase/Zollie's Retreat/Rattlin' down
the Acorns/Johnny Booger/The Corn
Song/Wild Bill Jones/Man of Constant
Sorrow/The

Pea Fowl.

Clyde Troxell, The Rocky Toppers, Bessford
Hicks, Clyde Davenport, Lay Jones, Retta
Spradlin.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Reviews

�contributes

Virgil's

three

songs

to

defies

music

side.

the

adequate

He is a capable and lively
singer who accompanies his songs with
inventive, tasteful banjo playing. His
music was early influenced by the
Bertram Brothers, black musicians of

description.

considerable note in the Plateau, and
displays a very bluesy and spontaneous
character. "Bye Bye Blues" and "Goin
around the World" are classic Virgil,
and "Ain't it Awful," with son Willard
Anderson on guitar, is remarkable
a
song that combines the bop of Chuck
Berry and the unpredictability of John
Lee

Hooker

in

a

banjo

performance

from the Kentucky Mountains.
Most of the music on these records
was recorded in the 1970s and '80s by
Bobby Fulcher and Barry Poss; but the
opening cuts of side two, three hot fiddle
tunes by the late John Sharp of Fentress

County, Tennessee, were recorded in
1949 on a home disc cutting machine by
Sergeant Alvin York, World War hero
and lifetime resident of the Cumberland
I

Plateau. These discs suffer from the
usual fidelity problems associated with
vintage recordings, but such problems
are trivial in light of Sharp's magnificent
performances.
"Sharps
Hornpipe,"
"Five Miles out of Town," and "Three
and
Way Hornpipe" are articulate

electrifying.

The record closes with three songs
from Dee Hicks. All are interesting but
my favorite is "Old Bangum," Dee's
version of the "Wild Hog in the Woods"
story with an unusual set of closing
verses that expand the plot of the story.

These are two very satisfying albums,
good introductions to the music of the
Cumberland Plateau and good listening
throughout. They are accompanied by

extensive and informative booklets with

photographs,

maps,

notes,

and

biographical sketches of the musicians.
County's commitment to this series is
and the latest
highly commendable,
additions, like their predecessors, will
not disappoint. (Craig Johnson)
To Order: County

Records, P.O. Box

191, Floyd, VA 24019

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�A treasure is the homemade disc of Joe
Lee. Lee, raised in Alabama, had moved

Georgia in 1916, where he
legendary status as a mentor to
Lowe Stokes,
Georgia's finest
McMichen, and Bill Shores.
called Lee "the best old-time
to

ever heard,"

after

and

hearing

variations

it

is

attained
some of

Clayton

and

(Kerry Blech)
To order: Brierfield Ironworks Park,
Route 1, Box 147, Brierfield, AL 35035

Lee's

rhythm

allows
Skillet
Perhaps, but I hear the influence of J. W.
Day's "Wild Wagoner" here, and it was
recorded a dozen years before Lee's
Be that as it may, Lee was

a

strone and influential fiddler.

Hamilton, "the champion fiddler
Alabama," presents his signature
tune, perhaps one he learned from
Georgia musicians, as Cauthen opines,
or one he may have taught them, as
Charles Wolfe said in his liner notes to
the Georgia Yellow Hammers album
(Rounder 1032). Hamilton's version of
his breakdown is significantly different
from Andrew Baxter's or that of Dilly
and the Dill Pickles, so he should have
Y. Z.

of

it

after

accompanying waltz

himself.

is a

His

nice change of

pace for the record.
The Johnson Family Band deserve an
article of their own someday. Their
string band sides show why they were
Sand Mountain favorites for years. Jess
Moore kicks off side two with a fine
"Smoke above the Clouds," a popular

piece from the Chattanooga/Georgia
border area. He's followed by Noah
Lacy's "Citico," which I believe is from
the same general area, both tunes having
been recorded on 78s by the Skillet
Lickers circle of musicians.
Many of the fiddlers on side two play
that
are
newer
than
those
styles
presented here. The ubiquitous presence
of Arthur Smith can be felt throughout.
Many of these fiddlers, when the old
music became
less
popular
among
dancers, turned to pop, country western
and swing, and some put their fiddles
down for years. All kept their love for
the old tunes and styles, though.
The accompanying 24-page booklet is
well researched and gives us a glimpse of
Alabama history, the evolution of oldtime music in that state, and the fiddler's

social

status.

interesting

I

in Alabama, expected sometime
1988 (University of Alabama Press,
Box 2877,
Tuscaloosa, AL 35487.

Cauthen
"Wagoner."
that it was the source for the
Lickers' version of the tune.

named

eagerly await publication of Joyce
With
forthcoming book,
Fiddle and Well-Rosined Bow: Old-time
and

Cauthen's

Stokes
fiddler I
hard to doubt it

on

home disc.

excellent. 1 wholeheartedly recommend
this album to fiddling fans worldwide

Two particularly
sections document the

presence of black fiddlers and the role of
contests, the latter of which created the
"brag" fiddler. Also in the booklet are
biographies of the musicians, culled
from personal
interviews, secondary
interviews, and newspapers and letters
of a bygone era. The photographs are
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Fiddling
in

�music shows. "Carolina Mountain Fox
Chase," "Sugar Hill/Forked Deer," and
"Hop High Ladies" were very enjoyable
takes its traditional
voice in the string-band setting, backing
up the fiddle. The medieval a cappella
treatment of "Johnny Booker" felt out of
place.
This record appears to be a showcase for
many of Rick's musical friends around the
country as well as for this well-traveled
musician. Old-rime music fans should
enjoy the pieces of old-time playing that
make up the majority of this disk, but the
"folk" music and eclectic numbers will be
of less interest. (Kerry Blech)
to me as the banjo

To

order: Heritage Records, Rt.
278, Galax, VA 24333.

3,

Box

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Bill

Christophersen-fiddle,

pitch

pipe/

Debra
Given-piano, guitar, maternal
instinct /Vicky Gould-accordian, discord,
raven tresses/Tom Phillips-fiddle, despair,
mediation services

The liner notes tell us the Fish Family

playing since 1983 at contra
the northeast". I
mention this only because I would have
that
been
guessed
they've
playing
together a lot longer than that. They have
a wonderful
seamless, non
rhythm-stop, no-fail, that made me think they'd
been together a lot longer. They play
southern old-time,
Irish,
Canadian,
Cajun, and original tunes, all with good
humor. The tunes in their medleys are
well-chosen, their harmonies (with two
fiddles and accordian there are lots of
possibilities) sound great, and they must
be fun to dance to. I especially enjoy
Debra Given's piano playing. She's right
on the money rhythmically, and has a
real New England sound. Who played
triangle on the "Port Arthur Waltz"?
The liner notes include suggestions for
dances to go along with the tunes. It
might have been a good idea for times to
have been included with the tunes so a
caller would have a better idea which
selections to use for what dances,
though.
Dancers without live bands, musicians
wanting to learn tunes for dances, people
who enjoy listening to old-time music in
the northern style
order this tape
from Marimac! The Fish Family will give
you what you want. (Hilary Dirlam)
has been

dances

"throughout

To order: Marimac Recordings,
Box 5, Little Ferry, NJ 07643

P.O.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�TENNESSEE

BANJO

INSTITUTE
Lebanon, Tennessee
NOVEMBER 10th,
11th &amp; 12th.
A
GATHERING OF
HISTORIC
WORLD CLASS PROFESSIONALS

STUDENTS FOR:

&amp;

WORKSHOPS;

CONCERTS; LECTURES; EXHIBITS;
FILMS &amp; FUN!

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Advertise
In The

OLD-TIME
Reasonable

HERALD
Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333
for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12155">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 1, Number 5 (Fall 1988)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12156">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12157">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 1, Number 5 (August-October 1988)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Roy Harper: The Ways of the Past,” by Charles Wolfe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old-Time Music a Scottish Perspective,” by Allin Cottrell&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“An Affair of the Heart,” by Alice Gerrard with Dan Gellert&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Old-Time Music in the Philadelphia Area,” by Keith Brand&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Good Old Times in Chicago &amp;amp; Northern Illinois,” by Skip Landt&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – The Green Grass Cloggers,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old-Time Music On The Radio,” by Emily Fine&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Ode to Byard Fiddler,” by David Holt&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12158">
                <text>1988</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2100">
        <name>1988</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5428">
        <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5522">
        <name>Allin Cottrell</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5417">
        <name>Charles Wolfe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5523">
        <name>Dan Gellert</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5453">
        <name>David Holt</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5516">
        <name>Emily Fine</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5524">
        <name>Keith Brand</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5474">
        <name>Phil Jamison</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5521">
        <name>Roy Harper</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5525">
        <name>Skip Landt</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5526">
        <name>The Green Grass Cloggers</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2517" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3443">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/7243437e1ea7a81c1b750e191df4410c.pdf</src>
        <authentication>5fba4ffdbe4451cf95041b14517d5fbb</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12159">
                    <text>Winter $3.50

November 1988

January 1989

THE

OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

BRUCE MOLSKY
Going For The Intangible
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The Micanope Music and Dance Camp
December 27* 1988 January 1, 1989
This winter celebrate Yuletide and the
New Year like never before!
Come to Central Florida to Camp Ocala
in Ocala National Forest for the time of your life
Singing, dancing, making music and having fun!
The Staff

Critton Hollow String Band, Larry Edelman, Cathy Fink, Matt
Gordon and Rodney Sutton (from the Fiddle Puppets), Cis
Hinkle, Gumbo Limbo, Marcy Marxer, Gerry Milnes, Tammy
Murray, Millie Ortego, Tracy Schwarz, Tom Staley, T.J.
Wangerman, Bob Willoughby and Kevin Wimmer
This all-star lineup will be offering

Classes and
Workshops

Squares, contras, clogging, Cajun, swing, polka, waltz, two-step,
calling, old-time string band, old time fiddle, Cajun fiddle, oldtime banjo, Cajun accordion, vocal harmonies, children's music
and songs, mandolin and improvisation

Special workshops for swing fiddle, rhythm guitar and
performance
A student showcase

Dancing every night
The hottest and most fun "dress up" New Year's Eve party and
AT T. NIGHT DANCE anyone has ever been to!

For More

Information

complete brochure, fill out and return this to:
Micanope Music and Dance Camp, P.O. Box 12135, Gainesville, FL
32604 or call (904) 495-2243.
and

a

Name(s)

Address

City
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

State

MICANOPE
MUSIC &amp; DANCE CAMP

Zip

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
FEATURES
GOING FOR THE INTANGIBLE:
A Conversation with Bruce Molsky
by

OLD-TIME MUSIC IN JAPAN
A Small But Fanatic Following
by

6

Craig Johnson

11

Mike Miller

ERNEST THOMPSON

A Pioneer Country Recording Artist
by

Issues In Old-Time Music/Dance Beat
Community Dances In The Eighties: Dare To Be Square
by

18

Kirk Sutphin

21

Phil Jamison

Workshop

Paul Brown

27

Here &amp; There EASTERN MONTANA AND NORTHERN

WYOMING

by

13

Phil Jamison

CHARLOTTE,
by

Joe M arlin

NORTH CAROLINA

OLD-TIME MUSIC AROUND MINNESOTA
by

Ask

15

Riggs
17

Bob Bovee

Uncle Harold

Old-Time Musicians
Heritage Award

25
to

Receive North Carolina Folk

Bluegrass Category for Grammy Awards

33
10

FROM THE EDITOR

2

LETTERS

2

CLASSIFIED

26

RECORD, CASSETTE TAPE &amp; VIDEO REVIEWS

29

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I was
thrilled at the tribute to Carlton
Freeny. (Vol. I, No. 3)1 grew up in Leake
County, Miss, and knew some of the
musical Freeny family. I have been away
from Leake County a long time but I
often think of people I knew there and
am so glad to see that one of them,
Carlton Freeny, was recognized as the
major talent he was.

Vera Floyd
Tunica, MS

I

think Allin Cottrell

mentions

is

"distinctive

right when he

American

sounds." The black influence, which

doesn't

mention,

difference.

is

(I suspect
as
well,

influence

a

he

obvious

the

Native American
which I can't

substantiate.)

But there are certain Scottish sounds
fiddlisms that he has mis-identified
as American. There are dozens of firsttunes in the Scottish
class
"C"
repertoire. One of them, "The Braes of
and

Auchertyre,"
ancestor

is

clearly the prototype or

of "Billy in the Lowground."

"The
Bonnie Lass of
Another,
Fisherrow," which can be heard on
Angus Chisholm's (Shanachie) album,
has the "jazzy syncopations" that not
in modern pipe tunes, but
always been in Scottish dance
music. This tune, which appeared in
printed tune collections as early as 17(jl
is not only in "C" but has the 12 3-123
of the "Dill
1
2 rhythmic structure

only appear
have

Pickle Rag" (or Scruggs picking) built
right into the melody. This is the same

Reader Comment:
The full color cover of the Heartbeats
makes one wish they were available on
record or tape. The interviews were
great. Your record reviews are the most
valuable part of your magazine for me.
The reviewers really know good oldtime music. Please don't stop. In future
issues
would really like to see
interviews or stories on the Horseflies,
Bruce Molsky, Pete Sutherland, Ernie
Carpenter, or whatever you folks can
come up with, just keep it coming!
I

James McClure
Denham Springs, LA

pulse that players like Tommy Jarrell
used so effectively, only the Scottish
fiddler (such as still exists in Cape
Breton) would do it with vigorous single
bows.
If the full story of American music is
ever told I think we will find much more
black influence on old-time string music
than is generally acknowledged, and a
surprising amount of European, British,
and the "Celtic" influence on black
traditions. also think that the influence
of Irish fiddle on American fiddle styles
has been greatly underestimated. There
are still older musicians in various parts
I

of Ireland

drony

style

mountain

who play
very

in

a

players.

and

simple

reminiscent

Older

of

our

Irish

collections also reveal

a music similar to
what we think of as old-time.
Your magazine seems totally devoid of

or snobbery.
any factionalism
Congratulations. When OTH hits my
mailbox just drop everything and read
I

it

cover to cover. Can't help

it.

�article on Hank Bradley (OTH
No. 2) left out one important and
central fact: Hank's music really sounds
good and is thoroughly enjoyable.
The

Vol.

i

Jody Stecher
San

Bravo

Dan

Gellert!

Francisco, CA

Thanks

for

inspiring philosophies and perspectives.
If any of you missed this interview,
check it out. Dan succinctly put into
words what a lot of old-time musicians
might not have been able to do. To me its
refreshing and moving to occasionally
hear someone so clearly express these
feelings in spoken words when we could
just as easily go have another fiddle tune
instead. Thank you Old- Time Herald
too.
Evo Bluestein
Fresno, CA

Thanks for the respect shown Fiddlin'
Sid Harkreader. (Reprint Vol. 1 No. 4).
He worked for and with my grandfather,

Uncle

Dave Macon, during his early
musical career days and I continued to
visit with him in his home. He enjoyed
telling those early days (late 20s, 30s)
travelling stories. A lot of early day
country music history has been lost.
You
had
a
very interesting and
informative letter about shaped notes in

Vol. 1 No. 3. This led me to inquire
about just what shaped notes was all
about, and so far no old-timer has been
able to explain
how they worked,
although most all are familiar with them.
Maybe there is someone who could give
us an article in the Old-Time Herald that
could be historical, educational, and a
one lesson do-it-yourself starter.
Dave Macon

II

Section with Illegible Text

do have some very interesting
such as the one about Roy
in
your latest issue. I also enjoyed
Harper
the poem David Holt wrote about Byard
Ray. The pictures of the OTH staff were
You

articles

interesting and it was very interesting to
learn a little something about each one.
However, there is one thing would like
I

know, and that is which one of your
staff would you pick to send down to
Bledsoe to talk with me about old-time
music and the people who played it?
the
same
we
Would
be
speaking
language when we were talking about
to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

some of the old-time bands like the
Carolina
North
Cooper Boys, the
Georgia Yellowhammers, the Carolina
Tarheels,
Hoyt Ming and the Pep
Walker's
Corbin Ramblers,
Steppers,
Alex Hood and His Railroad Boys to
name only a few. Then, individuals like
B.F. Shelton, Alfred G. Karnes, Dock
Boggs, and many more. Which of your
rather young looking staff members

would

you want to hold this
conservation with me?
Yours for old-time music for ever and

ever.
Ed Ward

Bledsoe,

KY

After an already nostalgic day of
dancing with old and new Green Grass
Cloggers at the Sourwood Festival in
Black Mountain, North Carolina,
came
home to find the latest issue of the OldTime Herald in my mailbox. There was
Phil Jamison's article on the history of
the Green Grass Cloggers, bringing back
wonderful memories of times gone by.
I

I'd like to

commend Phil on

a

job well

let all our friends out there
know that even though no longer on the
road full-time, the GGC's are alive and

done,

and

kicking.
I

also enjoyed David Holt's poem in
to the late Byard Ray.
played
with Byard for years and he was
the finest musicians I ever knew,
willing to take the time to show a
fiddler or banjo player one of his

tribute
music
one of
always
novice
tunes.

I

Karen Philbeck
Asheville, NC

�time music as something that existed
"back in the 20s and 30s" gives the
impression that this type of music is a
museum piece. People still play it, but to
Mr. Ward if there is any deviation at all
from those he perceives as the old

masters, what is played is no longer oldtime music. These imitators, as he calls
them, do not have a feel for the music
and "cannot relate to what old-time
music is all about." What Ward fails to

understand

in his zeal for

authenticity is
essentially derivative and
exhibits influences from many sources.
Uncle Dave, Charlie Poole, Gid Tanner,
etc. were popular musicians in their day
to
and did not confine themselves
playing a music that they perceived as
traditional or defined as unchanging.
that all music

is

They played within

a

tradition that was

evolving and their music was altered to

reflect a changing world. Certainly Mr.
Ward would agree that what these great
performers of the 20s and 30s played
was different than the old-time music
nlaved bv their grandfathers.
Old-time music is clearly an under
ground music in our society and will cer
tainly

stay

that

way,

however,

it

is

neither moribund nor static. Witness
such interesting groups as the Putnam

County Horseflies

or the Heartbreakers
(sic) who play within the boundaries of
the old-time traditions but who are not
compelled to simply repeat what others
have accomplished before them. What
these groups have done with old-time
music may not please everyone but what
they do is part of a natural cultural

process and, in fact, a healthy one, for it
confirms the vitality and charm of this
great music.

Richard Straw

Radford, VA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�response to the "Buy or Bye." have
discovered that the best audiences for
old-time music are the very young and
the

I

the very old, and

tainment

I

aim

situations.
that old-time

at

family enter

agree with Steve
music has mass
Loring
appeal, and with Tracy Schwarz that you
just have to give people a chance to hear
it.
Steve Loring also mentioned the
polarization between the younger folk
I

society and the older set.

think it's
ironic that the older set who are carrying
on the old-time traditions in one way or
another are thought of as outmoded or
conservative by the younger "folkies."
thought folk music was that which is
passed along from the old to the young.
But some people have to get all their folk
music from records I guess, or "name"
I

I

acts.
Pat

Walke

Preston, IA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�GOING FOR THE INTANGIBLE:
A

Conservation
with
Bruce Molsky
by

met Bruce Molsky the other night,"
friend of mine between tunes one
evening last year. "What a fiddler, what a
banjo player. And a really nice guy. Man,
people like that are hard to take."
Facetious comments aside, I think that is
a
good short description of Bruce
Molsky and his music.
Throughout the years I've played oldtime music I've focused my attention
primarily on 78 rpm records. It's been
"I

said

a

my own peculiar shortcoming to know
more about people who have been dead
for 40 years than about the many great
musicians of my own generation. So,
when Bruce and Audrey Molsky moved

Washington, D.C. from Atlanta
didn't really understand why so many
musicians around town were so excited
to

I

about the new faces.

Now that I've heard them play
understand.
Bruce Molsky was born and raised
the Bronx. Old-time music was not
tradition

musicians
exposures

I

in
a

his family.
Like many
of his generation his first
to traditional
music came

in

through the medium of records.
He first

old-time

recognized and began playing
music while a student at

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Cornell University in the early 1970s.
He was a founding member of the
Correctones, a band of considerable

influence

at

that

time

and

well

remembered today. Around this time

also
began
conventions,

attending

and

these

he

fiddlers

travels

down

south contributed to his decision to
move to Lexington, Virginia, in 1976.
In Lexington Bruce played with Ace
Weems and the Fat Meat Boys as well as
with most of the other musicians in that
hotbed of fiddling. Although very fond
of Lexington in particular and Virginia
in general, career concerns took him and

Audrey to Atlanta in the early eighties,
where they remained until the summer
of 1987.
Bruce
currently
plays with the
Hellbenders along with fiddler James
Leva, banjo player David Winston,

guitarist Mary Winston, and bass player
Dave Grant. He is also working in a duo
with Bob Carlin. Bruce has performed at
festivals throughout the country, for the
Smithsonian Institution, and in Europe.
He is a remarkable fiddler. At one
in the interview that follows he
refers to the music of two other fiddlers,

point

calling

it

"so

lively,

so happy,

and

so

Craig Johnson

reflective." This holds true for his own
playing. Bruce plays some of the hottest
music I've ever heard, but the fire comes
from
nor
from
not
alone,
speed
incessantly repeated rhythmic patterns,
on and
concentration
but from
a
attention to his playing equalled only by
Another fine
his
own enthusiasm.
although very different musician has said
of him, "That guy always plays right out
there on the edge."
There is a dual quality to his music. At

times, especially when playing for dances
with the Hellbenders, the rhythm of the
band takes on a pulse reminiscent of the
more progressive sounds of bands like
the "Horseflies" or the "Heartbeats." But
I've played music with him in more
informal settings, when he plays dozens
of my more obscure favorites from 78s
with an attention to source nuance and
detail that is almost scary.
And he really is a nice guy.
is
of this
article
The remainder
composed of an edited interview with
Bruce Molsky that was done in early
August, 1988. We'd ordered out for
pizza and sampled some aquavit, both of
which conjured up reminiscences of
playing

in

Italy

a

few years back,

and

�eventually

remembered to turn on the

I

tape recorder.

I
am curious about how people
ended up playing what they play. This
isn't
music
something everyone's

CJ:

playing.
BM: I've been thinking about that a lot. I
was second guessing all your questions
before you got here. What's this guy
going to ask you? He's going to ask you
why you play the music, and I was going
love the music-- want
to say, "Because
to know why?" And
was going to tell
about
love the music,
all
you
why
which is the most important thing for
me, because it's old-time music, and it's
so different from most other kinds of
music you hear played around, definitely
different from popular music. So much
of pop music seems like it was designed
I

I

I

the marketing men beforehand. By
nature it's designed to beat the listener
it's designed to be liked,
over the head

by

therefore you like it.
Old-time music isn't that way, oldtime music is something that's beautiful
in and of itself, and if you're sensitive
and

and care about listening, then
you get to hear something that's innately
beautiful. I think that's what attracted
me to it. You can't be passive about it,
you have to pay attention.
I
started off with folk music, sixties
folk music. It didn't have a lot of nuance
to it, but I really liked the message and it

enough

kid.

I

was

in, especially when I was a
10 or 11 years old when my

sister bought me

a

Owen

sucked me

Doc Watson record.

year of guitar lessons that didn't
work out. They tried to teach me
classical guitar and I just didn't like it.
And then my sister bought me this Doc
Watson record, and I fell in love with it.
I'd never heard anything like it before,
a

I
started getting into bluegrass
music. I got Bill Monroe records, got to
see Ralph Stanley one time, Bill Monroe
another time.

Blanton

I'd had

Tommy Jarrell and Fred Cockerham

and

I

BM: They had concerts at the YMCA on
23rd Street. We're not talking about a
big turnout. When you're 13 years old
places still look really big to you, but this
place looked small to me then. But I used
to go there. I saw Curly Ray Cline
playing with Ralph Stanley, saw Tex

discovered

old-time

I

music. I was going to Cornell, and I
wanted to be a bluegrass guitar player.
talked to somebody who said they knew
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

played the banjo before I played the
fiddle.
picked up the banjo in 1973.
played bluegrass for about a month, and
then I got a copy of How to Play the FiveString Banjo by Pete Seeger, and was
learning to play stuff like "The Merry
Golden Tree," and
could play some
melodic things, but that was all I knew
existed. But early in 1974 somebody had
one of the County releases of Tommy
I

playing with Bill Monroe. I
thought that stuff was the best. It was
I

I

I

Jarrell and Fred Cockerham, and heard
Fred playing "Roustabout." I'd never
heard that style of music before, and that
I
was
it.
was
thought
pretty
accomplished-- I could dink and tink
with the best of them, but I heard that
and I didn't know what he was doing,
and it was like "I have to have this." I was
I

I

just sold.
gave up everything melodic,
right out the window, and it was love at
forsook everything.
first sight.
I

I

I

Logan

Eventually

primitive, really endearing style that
couldn't figure out, but really liked it.
His name was Danny Kornblum, and it
turned out to be old-time music. played
in a band with him. We were called The
Fall Creek Boys, and that eventually
grew into the Correctones.

I

CJ: Was that music hard to find in New
York City?

great.

this bluegrass fiddler and would I like to
meet him? I played with him for maybe
two months, and he played this raw,

I

piled into the car and went to
year-- the first time I went,
1974. It opened my eyes. We stopped in
Lexington on the way down, because
somebody knew Mata Maguire. She had

We

all

Galax that

the

White Column Inn

at

that time, and

apartment right above it. There were
all these musicians down there. It was
really exciting. People were just moving
an

�you embraced the culture and embraced
the people, that you could somehow
understand the music better. I tried my
best to be a local. I worked in the carpet
mill down there and learned a lot about a
culture I knew nothing about before.
The music was so beautiful, surely the
people themselves must be beautiful. Of

into Lexington, and it was starting to
build up a lot of steam.
eventually
moved down there.
I

What was the Galax convention like

CJ:
at

that time?

BM: First of all, there weren't a third the
amount of people that go now. It was
really spacious.

know

I
found out they were just
people. But there were some really
beautiful aspects to that way of life, not

course,

lot of the old
died, but I think

I

a

local players have
maybe they were a little less reluctant to
come out then than they have been the

only among the farms, but with the
factory people. There's something about
the constancy of life there, things don't
change that much, and people don't
strive for the kinds of changes we strive
for in the cities. It really reflects in the
music. When music evolves in a place
like that it may not be that diverse, but
what's there is really beautiful, it's as
much as it can be.
When I first became involved with
old-time music I thought it was a
tangible, definable thing that you could
only learn by experience. So I associated
this mystique with it. It's not what you
do, it's not the mechanics of playing the
instrument, it's what's behind all that.

easier
was
an
It
years.
I met Tommy Jarrell for the
atmosphere.
first time. He was hanging out with his
friends, leaning up against the pickup
few

last

stuff. It was a
truck, talking about
whole lot more like just going to the
park.

I
remember some of the young string
bands. Swamproot came to Galax and I
was totally impressed by Sandy Stark
who were playing
Bob Naess,
and
I
still
can
Bill
Stepp's
playing
"Ways of the World." It set me on fire.*

at

together

remember

that

time.

them

CM: Did you move to Lexington soon

It's the heart.

after that?

BM: In 1976. Much to the dismay of my
decided the only way to learn
family.
this music was to live in the mountains.
and lived in squalor for a
So I went
while just outside of Lexington. A place
called the "Chicken Farm". A1 Tharp
and David Winston and Brad Leftwich
lived there.

Who were some of the people
you've played with or listened to who

CJ:

I

CJ: I was living in Michigan back then
and we kept hearing about Lexington
and all the music that was going on there.
It was almost a legendary place.
was magical, for me. The White
Column Inn was the focal point of every
thing that was happening. Mata Maguire,

BM:

It

all the
she'd really take people in
wayward, lost children of the music
and make them feel at
crowd there
home. The White Column became more

Fiddler W. M. Stepp from Lakeville,
in
was
recorded
1937 at
Ky.,
and
Alan
Salyersville, Ky. by
Elizabeth Lomax for the Library of
Congress. Luther Strong (referred to
later) from Dalesbury, Ky., was also
recorded at this time in Hazard, Ky.
by the Lomaxes. Strong and Stepp's
performances

of such times as "Glory

Meetinghouse," "Hog-Eyed
Man" and "Last of Callahan", are
at

the

classics

in the

beautiful old Kentucky

style of solo fiddling

with

tunings and lonesome sound.

its

open
ed.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

had "the heart?"

BM: Tommy had
a bar or a place to hang out, it
became a home for all the music around
there. There were certain designated
nights when they'd hire a band for the
door money and everyone would come
and dance and just boogie. It was just like
going to a high school dance, except that
it was great music. Plank Road String
Band had just gotten together. James
Leva and I were playing together, we
weren't called the Fat Meat Boys then.
We had various combinations of people
it was more like a musician's pool in
the
beginning, before it split into
distinctive bands. You could pretty
much play with everybody, everybody
played the same Top Ten. There was no
problem with repertoire, if Tommy and

than just

Fred played it it was fine with us.
A lot of it was being single, I think.
There were a lot of hormones going on at
that time. Music and hormones go

together.

in Lexington for a few
put five or six years into
Lexington. I'd go back again, even
though it's changed a lot. People have
gotten married, the White Column's
gone, and the scene's a little more staid
than it used to be. But there's still good
music down there.
I
really thought, at that time, that if

So

years.

stayed

I

I

guess

I

they had was this
out

came

it,

Fred had it. What

incredible spirit that

of their music,

so lively,

so

reflective.
I've been thinking about my favorite
and so

happy

fiddle bands lately. I love the Carter
and
Son. When old-time
Brothers
music's good it has a real power behind
it, and it's not necessarily a power that's
caused by people banging really hard on
their instruments or playing fast. It's
power that comes out of the spirit
behind it. With the Carter Brothers it
manifests itself in their phrasing, and the
fact that they were so incredibly tight
with each other. The fiddlers lost each
other in different parts every once in a
while, but that didn't have anything to
do with it. That's totally forgivable in
this kind of music. It's almost like it

doesn't matter.
I

love Buddy Thomas's

fiddling

the

same way. It's really sweet and pretty,
but there's so much force and impact

behind

it.

What would you suggest to people
who are trying to reach, in their own
playing, the spirit you sense in old-time

CJ:

music?

BM: Perhaps people know me because
of the mechanics of my playing, but if my
playing is good, that's not the reason

�why. I've taught a lot of fiddle lessons
over the years and it's been the hardest
thing to get across. It's easy to show
people what to do, but it's hard to make
them feel it. That's why people who are
learning to play get frustrated. They can
do everything I tell them to do, but they
can't understand why it's not coming out
the way they want it to sound. Some of it
is mechanics, some of it is nuances, or a
different sense of time or melody. But
there are all these intangibles.
have
to
You
just
keep
paying

attention, and there's no substitute for
listening a lot. Listen to everything you

well as something else. There's
something to learn from every piece of
music. I've got tapes and records of
people I don't really like that much, but
I've learned a lot from them. I won't tell
you who they are.
When you first

begin to learn an
it's the only way to

and

learn, you imitate somebody.

it

was just

a

all

to.

When I learned to play the banjo the
first clawhammer-style banjo player I
heard was Wade Ward. I walked into a
record store in Ithaca and bought the
Folkways album Uncle Wade. (Folkways
He played

"Mississippi Sawyers,"

liked

it.
I
played that
recording endlessly. It was the only thing
I
listened to. I wanted to get it note for
note.
That's
another
to
approach
if
the
do
to
you've got
learning,
patience
it.
sat at the top of a stairwell in a

and

I

really

I

dormitory

at

Cornell,

somebody

I

the

recorder

tape

much

when

I

was

learning to play.
I

BM: Exactly. It's like "I'll tape this now
and listen to it later." All I mean is, don't
let the tape recorder be a substitute for
something more beneficial, namely:
experience it now, pay attention, and
listen.
I

go to teach

at

Ashokan next

week one of my main foci
going to be
"A few things learned right, not a lot of
I'd
rather
things learned halfway."
people come away with one or two tunes
solid than a whole bunch of tunes they
think they're going to work on for the
next six months. If they have one or two
good tunes under their belts, when they
hear something else from somebody or
from a record, they'll have something
they can apply. They have a better idea of
what the rules and criteria are. You have
to be a detail person when you're a
musician. You can't broad brush
learning to play music. You have to learn
the details.
wasn't sure what to expect of your
playing before I heard you. I thought
perhaps you would really rock and roll
the tunes,
mostly because so many
people liked your playing that I
suspected an appeal of that sort. I've
heard you play in situations where you
seemed to be taking a lot of chances,
stretching the limits of the music and
hanging it over the edge. But I've also
heard in your playing a great fidelity to
the original sources. How does that
CJ:

those things I've listened to and learned.
What comes out of your instrument
reflects all those things you've listened

2380).

you

is

You pick

combination of

play.

see

that the people you want to learn from
can be pretty receptive until you're past
the point of their good graces.
I'll tell you another thing. I never used

When

your favorite fiddler and try to get all his
licks down. I did that with Tommy
Jarrell. And then you find out that
there's somebody else who's interesting
to you. For me that was Luther Strong. I
learned that Library of Congress tape
inside out. After that it was a progression
of people, Benton Flippen, and Marcus
Martin, and all these different people
over a period of 15 years.
I
always felt, until four or five years
ago, like an imitator. All of a sudden I
woke up one morning and realized I had
my own style of playing, long after every
one had told me that I already had. I
realized

aspire

If

think that the tape recorder some
times excuses you from having to listen.

it as

instrument,

to

doing something you like, stop them and
say, "What are you doing?" Don't do it
in Carnegie Hall, but there are times to
ask. I was almost belligerent about that
when
was learning to play. You find

CJ:

can get your hands on, even if you don't

like

There's another thing for people who

playing

"Mississippi Sawyers" until they literally

threw me out.

I

have learned

and then said,

a tune
very carefully
don't like this about this

"I

like this
don't like this part,
better." Then, at least,
everytime you digress from the source
you've replaced it with something that
think the result is
you think is as valid.
better. You end up producing something
of more quality.
don't like filling up
measures with a lot of stuff. I'm sure I
end up doing it plenty of times, but try

tune,
other

I

1

part

I

I

I

not to be mechanical

CJ:

BM:

all.

at

How do you feel about performing?

like performing.
never did until
few
was always
just
years ago.
intimidated by it. But have come to like
I

I

a

I

I

I've learned a real good lesson since we
moved to Washington. In Atlanta there
wasn't that much old-time music to
to
speak of, or much opportunity
it.

but since coming
perform,
I've
had
a
lot
Washington

I

I

I

burnt out.
CJ:

What

are

you

doing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

these

days,

musically?

I

work?

BM: When I learn a tune I try to learn it
as close to the original as I can. That's the
only link I have to the past, and the past
is my source. Anything I do to a tune to
change it, or allow it to change, comes
after I learn the tune. have my own bow
licks, things I do to tunes, chances I take,
but they're all based on that meat of the
tune. That's why I feel like I'm playing
pretty traditionally. To learn a tune is to
learn it from the source and learn it how
it

of

opportunities.
got so excited, having
been in drought for so many years, that I
said yes to everything. And I overdid it,
and it became a burden. It's hard to
strike a balance. Right now I'm kind of
I

with Bob Carlin

BM: Recovering: I'm doing the
Hellbenders, and I'm doing the Bob
Carlin-Bruce Molsky show, and I'm

with Audrey at home,
enjoy tremendously. It's playing
with her at home that keeps the other
stuff in perspective. It's what made me
realize the other night that I was getting
burnt out.

doing
which

music

I

I

was going for that intangible, but
didn't realize how serious or far away it
was at that point. I figured if
kept
working at it, if I just kept working at
that one tune, that I could get there and
all the other tunes would make sense.

to

goes.

with Audrey Molsky

�As far as getting out and playing, it's
Hellbenders and Bob. For me they

the

serve completely different functions, the
Hellbenders is real primal, real
community spirit and it brings me back
to the time I lived in Lexington. People
keep telling us we're a "Lexingtonsounding" band. I don't know what that
lived there, but
is, I didn't know when
if we are, then fine.
When
play with Bob it's different.
lot more thought out, a little
are
a
Things
bit more arranged, they're a little more
heady, I guess. Also, playing in a twoinstrument format, you have to make
things count, you can't hide behind
I

I

anybody, and the counterpoint of the
two instruments becomes a lot more
important. We're starting to be very
musically reactive to each other. We
made this recording, which Pm really

proud of, and we'll be putting it out in
some form soon. It's got a good cross
section of not only fiddle and banjo, but
double banjo, fiddle and guitar, and
vocals. I like it.
I
don't know if the Hellbenders will
ever record. The Hellbenders is another
thing
community music gone berserk.
We've had some really great times
playing at Brandywine and some of the
other festivals.
My whole life has revovled around the
friends I've made in this music, and it's
governed everything I've done in my free
don't know what my
time, just about.
social life would be without the music. I
guess that makes me kind of narrow, but
like that niche.
I

I

CJ:

I

look

at

what other people do with

their spare time, and

doing those things.
BM:

Y

eah,

I

I

can't see myself

can't do it, it's fine for them,

but
CJ: You know

party,

is

if

there's going to be

a

anyone going to play?

BM: Yeah, right if they aren't going to
play, what are they going to do? You
mean they're going to stand around in a
room, they're going to talk? I'm no good
at talkine. I'd rather Dlav.
My cousin, who came to see us play at
Croton, asked me why I go to all these
festivals.
was trying to explain to her
how much the music meant to me, how
much the people meant to me, that
without them I would be really lost. She
didn't bat an eye. She said, "This is your
extended family, isn't it."
And
had to say, "Yeah". H
1

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Craig Johnson, writer, old-time musician
and member of the Double Decker String
Band, is based in Silver Spring, MD.

Bruce Molsky can be heard on the

following recordings:
with David Winston
Records
XXXIII)
(Heritage
Visits

The

Young

with

Fogies

Alden (Heritage Records 056)
A

Tribute

to

Tommy

(Heritage Records 063)
A.

Ray

Jarrell

Robic and the Exertions

with

Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, Chester

Macmillian,

Dan

and

Newhall

(Flying Fish 415)
Banging and Sawing

with

Bob

Carlin (Rounder 0197)

with the Green
Through the Ears
Grass Cloggers (Rounder 0228)
and

on

Galax

several

recording of the

Old-Time

Convention.

Fiddlers

�OLD TIME MUSIC
IN JAPAN A

SMALL BUT

FANATIC
FOLLOWING
by

Mike Miller

Sumio Inoue has been playing oldmusic

time

for

Convention
native
spent a
States.

for

only seven

years, and
four, but he
managed to capture ninth place in the
fiddle contest at the Galax Old Fiddlers

fiddle

just

in

the

past

1986.

Not

bad

for

a

of Yokohama, Japan, who has
total of four years in the United

Sumio is one of some 30 active oldtime musicians in Japan, by one player's
count. Most of them, plus about 40 fans,
packed into

a decrepit former hotel for
"Old-Time Party" last October in
Maya, a mountaintop resort high above

an

the port city of Kobe in western Japan.

"Old-time music is our lifestyle," said
Kazuo Sato, a guitar and banjo player
who first became interested in the music
through records of Clarence Ashley and
the

Newport Folk Festivals.

The all-night get-together in Maya was

the fourth annual autumn romp for
Japan's small but devoted old-time
scene. Its organizers, including banjo
player Fliromasa Kase, have also held an
annual old-time festival in Toyko for the
past seven years, which attracts about

100 devotees.
"This is the Galax of the Far East," said
Hiromasa. The 12 hours of festivities

incorporated banjo, fiddle, and clogging
contests; sets by a dozen bands with
names like Happy Pea, Southern Train,
and Heart of Round Peak; a spirited
performance by the four-woman team of
the

Corn

Creek

Cloggers;

square
routines;
and innumerable jam sessions within the
decaying confines of the hotel. ("Don't
go out after dark, or you may meet
snake," the festival program warned.)
Western music has long been popular
a

Mike

Miller

dance; some antic pantomime

Happy

Pea String

Band, Old-Time Party, Maya, Japan, Oct 10, 1987

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

Japan, and the country sees

a

constant

stream of pop performers like Madonna,
Michael Jackson, Ray Charles, and Mick

�Bluegrass also has an ardent
following, on a smaller scale. Scarcely a
weekend passes without a
summer
bluegrass festival somewhere in Japan,
and at least one homegrown group,
Bluegrass 45, has toured the U.S.
Old-time music, on the other hand,
seems to enjoy about the same market
share as in the U.S. Asked which

Ramblers.

Jagger.

American

traditional
played

musicians

and

have

local devotees name Jean Ritchie,
Grandpa Jones, Mike Seeger, and Alice
Gerrard
they can't think of any
others.
Sumio Inoue came to the music by
degrees. He started out playing guitar in
the style of the Beatles and the Eagles,
drifted into the music of David
Bromberg and eventually met some
the

musicians

bluegrass and
mandolin and
Kenny Hall on

who

in

Japanese

circles

as

help of Pete Seeger's instruction book.
was attracted to banjo "mountain
minor" tuning because it reminded him
of the Japanese shamisen, a traditional

He

three-string fretless instrument.
"My father sang Japanese folk songs,"

Kazuo said, "I tried to play the shamisen,
but it was very difficult."
had
He stuck to the banjo. "After
been married for one year my wife asked
me why I always played the same tune. I
said 'no, they're different tunes.'"
Hiromasa Kase says the inspiration to
play banjo struck him suddenly as a

played

old-time. He took up
discovered the music of
Kenny's Philo record (out

I

ed.).

of print

known

old-time

"Bosco," has made several trips to the
States. "One summer 1 went to more
than 10 festivals," he said. He has taken
fiddle workshops at Augusta, attended
Galax
three times, and looked up
Tommy Jarrell twice.
Kazuo Sato got his first guitar when
the American folk music boom hit
Japan, and he was soon playing the music
of the Kingston Trio and Peter, Paul, and
Mary. He later took up banjo with the

in Japan in the past 10 to 15 years,

Japanese

Koske,

American

teenage student when he was sitting by
the river near Toyko. He took some
money he'd saved from his bicycle milk
delivery route, hopped a train into

found

it's that good."

of
Valerie
Mindel,
formerly
California's Any Old Time String Band
and currently a journalist in Hong Kong,
"There

agreed.

I

was

at

four

the

in

morning, when we'd been playing more
and more obscure tunes all night. I
turned to say something to the fellow
next to me and realized that for all the
tunes we had in common, we couldn't
talk to each other. He didn't speak
didn't speak Japanese. And
English.
somehow it didn't matter."
Some of the Japanese old-time
I

musicians, like their American counter

Pete Seeger-style
Toyko,
long-neck banjo in a music store. He also
taught himself to play with the help of
and

setting. "You're playing these obscure
tunes and the place falls away. When you
finally do remember, it's shocking at
times
there you are in the Maya
Gakusei Center."
Second place went to Rob Craighurst
for his version of "Lowery's Quadrille."
Rob was teaching English in the Osaka
area at the time but has since returned
home to Charlottesville, Virginia. "The
music was just like all the great music in
it's not a copy. It's
American music
like if someone says 'Your Japanese is
very good,' that means it's not really very
good. Well, we wouldn't tell them.
'Your old-time music is really good'

a

Seeger book and eventually
discovered some other musical styles.
heard the music of Doc
"When
Watson I thought, 'This is my music,"'
he said. "Then I heard a clawhammer
banjo record of the County label and
thought, 'This is my banjo sound.'"
of the Japanese old-time
Many
musicians travel to the U.S. whenever
the

I

I

like to branch out into other
musical styles once in a while. Koske
Takaki, for instance, has been trying to
play some Cajun music, but he has found
a familiar problem. "All the tunes sound
the same," he said. H
parts,

Michael Miller
based

in

is a correspondent currently
Hong Kong.

Mike

Miller

they get the chance, to attend festivals or

Sumio Inoue, 9th place winner
Fiddlers Convention, Old-Time
Japan, Oct. 10, 1987

at

1986 Galax
Party,

Maya,

He also came across the Echoes of the
Ozarks anthologies of old tunes on the
County label (Vol. i &amp; 2, County 518,

ed.), which presented him with a
problem that might face the average
American who decided to take up
Japanese koto music. "I couldn't under
stand it," he said. "Every tune sounded
519

like the same tune."

Fiddler

Koske

Takaki,

who studies

Kyoto, shifted gradually
from Bob Dylan to Woody Guthrie, the
acupuncture

in

Carter Family, and the New Lost City
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

look up traditional musicians. Sumio
he
some
trouble
had
Inoue
says
communicating at first with some oldtimers he called on in the Ozarks.
"They thought I was strange," he said.
"Then I got out my mandolin and played
the same tunes they played. Afterward
we became very close friends. I now have
very many good musician friends in

America."
Four

westerners,

all

Americans,

most recent Old-Time
Party in Maya. Two of them played in
the fiddle contest, and the Japanese
hosts, possibly out of politeness,
awarded them first and second places.
The top prize went to Jon Goman, a
Detroit native who teaches English in
Toyko, for his rendition of "Grand
Picnic."
Jon says the familiarity of the music
the strangeness of the
overpowers

attended

the

Meanwhile,

in

Kong
The

old-time

music

Hong
scene

in

small to the point of
near visibility, but it does have a

Hong Kong

is

monthly square and contra dance,
complete with caller and live band.
It's on the second Tuesday of each
month at the Fringe Club, a
community arts center near the
British colony's central business
district on Hong Kong island. For

information

contact

Valerie

Mindel, A3, 2/F, Hillgrove, 18
Cape Drive, Chung Horn Kok,
Hong Kong, phone 5-8130079.

�Old Time and Bluegrass

Music!

Three great acts
each month.

Aicy
JnCMETCH'N OPI2&gt;K

Our Fourth
Year!

prodi^LioDS

J

\^J

jr H

here Stars Are Bern

Join us for a night of family fun.
Third Saturday night of each month at 8 o'clock.
Andy Griffith Playhouse, Rockford Street, Mount Airy, N.C.
Directors: Frank Bode, Paul Brown, Verlen Clifton
For information: 919-789-4876

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�them considered to be typical old-time
music. In addition to traditional music
derived from other regions and cultures,
we have our own cowboy music, poetry,
and lore which have been enjoying a

tremendous resurgence in popularity
and (finally) respectability over the past
few years. (This recent surge in respect
ability and popularity mimics the same
phenomenon that occurred in

Appalachian music 30 years ago.)
oldest

the

Probably

Appalachian-style
eastern Montana
indeed.

old-time
is

a

music

rare
of the

very

Since the demise

in

thing

Ain't

Gotta Clue String Band with banjo
player Steven Hollander's emigration
to Utah, Doug Ezell and Stan Slater
(fiddle and guitar, respectively) can still
be heard occasionally
about Billings,
sometimes joined by itenerant banjo and
dobro

Dilloff.

Dick

player

"Dobro

Dick"

most well-

and

estabilished of traditional music organ

izations

are

Wyoming

Associations.
in

the

Montana and
Fiddlers

Old-Time

recent, untimely death, Forsythe rancher

Harold

attention

Sprague.
is

defined

Once

again,

little

paid to the usually sharply

borders

between

swing,

and the

old-time, and old pop tunes,
old-time fiddler needs to be well

armed

with

bluegrass,

waltzes, polkas,

and

other

slow tunes or face disapproval from the
dancing old-timers. Nonetheless, the
atmosphere is warm and friendly, and

new musicians are always welcomed.
Each July members from all Montana
Fiddlers districts meet in Poulson on
beautiful Flathead Lake for the annual

Montana Old Time Fiddlers
Contest. Really less a contest and more

of a large, extended
contest
seems, for many, to
family,
take a back seat to the jam sessions and
an

reunion

annual

the

social gatherings in the camping areas.
some outstanding fiddle
can
be
heard in the contest with
playing
styles ranging from contest style, to
Scandinavian-influenced polkas, to the
more loose and free-flowing old-time.
This year's entrants ranged in age from 6

Nonetheless,

to 91,

with such standouts as

Seitz,

Gary

Bebee,

Fred

Candice
Buckley,

Chell, Tari Conroy, Jim
McMillan, Mike Williams, and Ben
Harvey

Setran.

While
musicians
including
Missoula

Parlor

Montana has more
interested in old-time music,

western

Catfish John Tisdale in
and Mike Williams and his
Pickers in Helena, true

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Montana

and

northern

Wyoming can tune in each Saturday
night to KEMC radio's "Strings and
Things". Beaming over public radio's

(each region comprising an area as large
as
in
some eastern states)
where,
addition to jamming, an open stage is
always available so that music can be
provided for the listeners and dancers,
many of them septugenarian ranchers.
Frequent fixtures at these jam sessions
are Jim Southworth and his band, The

Mike McKara, fiddler maker Ben
Setran, Fred and Jeannie Buckley
and six-year old, third-generation
fiddler, Taylor Buckley, and, until his

Yellowstone Festival. While more of a
performance and less of an opportunity
to jam, musical styles include cowboy,
Native American, Scandinavian, and
western and eastern old-time. This year's
most popular performers were Harvey
Chell, The Buckley Family, cowboy
Val Geissler
and
artists
Dwayne
Dickinson, and old-time string band
performers Stan Slater and Doug Ezell.
Fans of traditional music throughout
eastern

Each month every district
a regular jam session

the state holds

Uncalled Four, Harvey andJoChell,

each summer in Billings one can
examples of all types of traditional
music from our region at the Western
Center's
Heritage
Heritage of the
Late

hear

second-largest area

in

the nation,

hosts

Stan

L-R: Stan

Slater and Doug Ezell play all
varieties
of traditional
music;
but,
because it's their favorite, they tend to

Slater, Doug Ezell

focus much attention on old-time styles
music. And live performances are

of

Recently, folks interested in the
expressions of western traditions have
focused a lot of time and energy on
cowboy music and poerty. Two major

events

each

Cowboy

Gathering
Montana,

Historical

the

year

and

Poetry
August

in

and

the

Montana

Music

Big Timber,

in

Buffalo Bill
springtime

Center's

Cowboy Music and Poetry Festival

in

both very
Cody,
Wyoming
with
from
around
our
popular
people
region and elsewhere. Nationally known
(many locally grown) artists such as
are

Glen Orlin, Hal Cannon, Wally
McCrae, and Val Geissler have joined
with regionally famous poets and singers

Ralston,
George Shawver,
Dwayne Dickinson, Baxter Black,

J.K.

and others to present wild
poems, songs, and "true

collections of
stories"

that

portray all aspects of cowboys and
cowgirls lives, both past and present.
While many picture Montana and
Wyoming as cattle ranching country,
sheep ranching is very prominent in the
area as well.
Many of the region's
original sheep ranchers were Scottish
immigrants who brought with them an
affection for pipe and drum music, and
Caledonian societies are still quite
prominent throughout the region with
many small towns having a pipe and
drum corps and traditional Scottish
dancers.
In
Billings,
weekly
piping
sessions as well as weekly Scottish
country dances are held, the pipers led

Jim (Mc) Morrison and Elizabeth
and the dancers by Bob
(Mc)Mackin, Linda (Mc)Christensen,
and Ken (Mc)Taylor.
by

(Mc)Adcock,

occassionally

broadcast

national

whenever

musicians

come
regional
through town.
Thus, as you can see, even though the
participants in old-time music are
relatively few in number and widely
separated by the miles in this sparsely
or

populated country, there is no lack of
enthusiasm for traditional styles of
music.
Those
the

who are interested in hearing
Montana style of fiddling, cowboy

music, and poetry might want to obtain
two albums produced by the Montana

Folklife Project: "When the Work's
All Done This Fall" and "If You
Can't Dance to it, It's Not Old-Time

Fiddle." (OTH Vol.
Reviews

1
No. 4 -Record
ed.) Contact the Montana

Folklife Project, Montana Arts
Council, 35 South Last Chance
Gulch, Helena, MT 59620.

�Charlotte,
North Carolina
by Joe

Marlin Riggs

When Ivan Stiles, World Champion
Autoharpist, came from Pennsylvania to
appear at the 7th Annual CFMS-Latta
Folk Music Festival, he said it best:
"Charlotte is a hotbed of old-time and
folk music opportunities."
The driveshaft of the old-time music
engine hereabouts is the Charlotte Folk
Music Society (CFMS). Founded by
Marilyn Price (704-846-1899) eight
years ago, the CFMS consistently keeps
its

music

concert

in

or

the public eye through a
other activity each month.

Sumio Seo, in
598-9158) is
Kik er, in charge of monthly
events (704-333meetings/special

charge of concerts (704one vice-president; Bob

9762),

is

the

other

vice-president.

Within the last year and a half, CFMS
has directly sponsored these concerts
and special performers for the people of
the area: the Jones Brothers and the
Log Cabin Boys; John McCutcheon;
Jean

Ritchie;

the Gospel

Christian

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Singers;

Bryan

Mike Seeger; Jim Magill;
Bowers; Danny Doyle in

concert for the Irish Children's Society;

Saunie

Wood,

Trimble;

Hornbostel

Gerald

storyteller;

Patrick
&amp;

Sky;

Lois

Owens;

Ray

Windfall; Jon &amp;. Karen Singleton;
the Nashville
Bluegrass Band; Joe
Cline &amp; Friends; the Critton Hollow
String Band; Ivan Stiles; Tony

Blanton,

and

many,

dedicated and talented

many
local

and

other

area

musicians. These events are always open
and
well advertised
the public,
through the efforts of CFMS

to

Promotions

Director

(704-547-4286).
and never

CFMS

They

Ken
are

Sanford

often

free,

outrageously priced.
also publishes a monthly

newsletter, the CFMS Magazine, which

comes with the $15/year dues. The Mag
is usually 24 pages of photos, features,
announcements, and calendar events.
The editor of the CFMS magazine, joe

�Mariin

Riggs

(704-338-9929),

the

welcomes any calendar events, articles,
announcements, leads for features, or
complete stories on old-time music, folk
music, bluegrass, personalities in the

field, or other aspects of interest to
readers. These may be sent to CFMS,
P.O. Box 9007, Charlotte, NC 28299.
CFMS sponsors,
along with the

Mecklenburg
Department,

County

Paw,

performers,

W.V.,
and

Parks

the

in

music

series,

6468)

has also

IBM,

Charlotte (704-

an

Kohl (704-552-5155) of
CFMs President, planning and
coordinating long-range and short-range
goals and activities. Floyd Ellington

Folk

of coordinating

Dancers

is

has the enormous task
the many requests for
playing honorariums around the area,
lining up players and times for CFMS
members to go into the community to
perform. For these many concerts

Riggs

(704-376-3181),

(704-364-543

3);

Cloggers (704-

Country

Scottish

Country

(704-399-8060), and St.
Luke's Cloggers (704-523-7981). The

Charlotte American Folk Dance and the
Charlotte Country Dancers have live

CFMS receives substantial donations,
which are in turn used to pay for concert
performers, special events, and the
monthly magazine. CFMS is a registered

music.

I was
unable to reach the others to
find out whether or not they have live
music at their dances. To find this out,

non-profit organization, and no player at
the honorariums
receives any
remuneration. Membership of CFMS

you can try calling the numbers listed
above.
Lew Herman (704-336-2980)
is
librarian at the Main Library of the

about 500.

Public

Library

of

Charlotte-

Mecklenburg County. Lew is compiling
an archival collection of recorded music
from
North
and
Carolina
South
Carolina from the 1920s through the
present

time. Lew says,

"For

a

while,

Charlotte was the bluegrass recording
capital of the U.S. Performers such as
Lester Flatt, Mac Wiseman, Don Reno,
the Osborne Brothers, and Grandpa
Jones all made their way to Charlotte."
Lew is also researching the recording
studios of Charlotte, of which there are
several.

Whitey &amp; Hogan, of the Original
Briarhoppers, may be seen frequently

Riggs

he
interests
as
demonstrated music
filled
on
and partially-filled water
played
glasses, an empty shampoo tube, and a
drinking straw; played "Comin' Around

(disposable) tree

Jessica

and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Jam

563-0918); Charlotte

552-8903);

many picking and singing
the area, were absent this
of illness in the family.
from Shelby, N.C., who
bills himself as the Lazy Acres Racket
Maker, was a hit with all ages and

a

Dance

Dancers

who have won
awards around
year because
Tony Blanton

even did some tunes on the
more conventional Uke-Lin. Festival
organizer and manager Joe Cline (704376-1887), works hard all year to line
up and bring the best to the people of
this area in the true spirit of traditional
family entertainment.
The Fall Folklife Festival is held at

Old-Time

(704-536-9564); Charlotte
International Folk Dancers (704-

Seals, Maggie's Fancy, Down-Home
Folks, Magpie, and many other CFMS
performing bands contributed to the
successful festival this year. One of the
favorites acts, Floyd &amp; Ruby Kirby,

Mountain" on

Night

Carolina Stompers

grass with the fantastic dobro of Rick
Wesson. The versatile Bob &amp; Jean

leaf;

Sunday

Bluegrass Jam, which meets most
weeks in different locations.
There is plenty of dancing going on
around Charlotte, too, with at least six
regular concerns: Charlotte American

the world. Lee Ward &amp; Southern
Express played their top-notch blue-

the

affiliated

Martha Kiker (704-333-9762)
coordinating. Corine Waterman
(704-553-1619) coordinates the

and

co-sponsored, along with
David Holt. David has been at

at

are

fiddle, banjo, guitar, recorder and lap
dulcimer.
Autoharp enthusiasts are
welcome at the Autoharp Club, which
meets each first Sunday from 4-6 p.m. at
CPCC (1201
Elizabeth Ave.), with

Shirley

stands

(most

(6-9 p.m.), Bryant Building,
Central Piedmont Community College
(CPCC, 704-342-6623), led by Marilyn
Price. This is a for-credit class, as are the
other usual offerings from CPCC in

the Mint for the past two years.

Magpie

activities

Class

annual country
in
Bill
brought
Monroe and several others over the past
year. The Mint Museum (704-333-

Jessica

CFMS Festival,

Other

with or somehow related to CFMS) are

Uptown Charlotte, and

372-9664) sponsors

were the featured
Stiles delivered

at

in

Singers. Spirit Square

Ivan

DeMasi Twins on Stage

October.

March '88 was held the CFMS-Spirit
Square Concert with the Nashville
Bluegrass Band and the Gospel Christian

autoharp workshops in old-time
and Celtic music in addition to his
performances. From New York, via
Nashville where they had performed at
Fan Fair, came the fabulous DeMasi
Twins, two brothers who play and sing
old-time and original material around

1988

each

in

two

The

Plantation

Folk Festival

an annual, free, open-tothe-public Folk Music Festival in June
at the beautiful, historic Latta Plantation
located near Huntersville, NC. This year
the Critton Hollow String Band from

Paw

Latta

Ralph Blizard has appeared there, and
there is always plenty of old-time music
and country dancing amidst the mules,
blacksmithing, candle-dippers, quilters,
and other colonial artisans. October,
1988, also marks the first of the Fall

Tony Blanton, the Lazy Acres Racket Maker,
tuning up his glasses at CFMS Festival, 1988

around the area; they are neighbors and
often cut each other's grass. They make
frequent appearances at local schools as
well as performing on the road. The
Briarhoppers enjoy the longest

unbroken

history of performing
together, dating back to the mid- 1930s.
Charlotte is, indeed "a hotbed of oldtime music" with a long and honorable
history. The tradition of music we love

keeps CFMS alive, and CFMS tries hard
to return

the favor.

�(For a complimentary issue of the
Magazine, for membership info, or for
information in general, contact Marilyn
Price (704-846-1899), 2501 AlexaRd.,
Charlotte, N.C. 28226. Other members
be
contacted directly through
may
numbers listed in the article.)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�"I

heard Ernest Thompson play all over

this

country."

--Cecil Shelton,

82, singer &amp; guitarist,
Stokes County North Carolina

Ernest Errott Thompson, born in
1892 in Forsyth County near WinstonSalem, was a well-known singer and

musical

communities

figure

in

numerous

native North
Carolina and in Virginia. He recorded 34
sides for Columbia in 1924, beginning

with

"Are You

in

his

from

Dixie" and "The

Wreck of the Southern Old 97" that
April.
His parents were James A. and Mary

was
a
Thompson.
James
carpenter of considerable skill and built
the family house. He was also a great
singer, according to Ernest's sister
Agnes, now a resident of a nursing home
in Winston-Salem, North Carolina.
"Music? Daddy brought home a guitar
one time when we were just little folks.
He said, 'The one who learns to play it
can have it.' So Ernest said, 'Well, I'll
'
learn to play it. And he's the one that got

Spaugh

it."

courtesy

Kirk

Sutphin

In later years, when Ernest acquired
another guitar, he taught Agnes how to
play on that older guitar.
Agnes, now in her 80s, is an energetic
woman whose memories of Ernest and
their music are keen and accurate. She

ERNEST THOMPSON
A

Pioneer Country
Recording Artist
by

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Kirk Sutphin

recalls
their father having an early
cylinder phonograph, "a Thomas Edison
with a big horn, you know." She points
out that Ernest learned many songs from
the cylinder
records. But his voice
acquired the unique pitch and tone for
which he became known from an

accident in early childhood. Agnes's
version of the story stems from her
mother's telling of the incident:
Une time he got burned real bad

when he was a little fella. He was just at
the walking stage when we were hogkilling one day. He caught afire. Mother
was in the basement when she heard him
scream. She ran upstairs and grabbed a
bucket of water. She knocked Ernest
down from throwing water on him,
putting out the fire. He was just a little
fella then. Wore dresses like all children
did then. He had scars on his face, and he
breathed enough fumes and heat that it
scorched his throat and voice-box. The
fire changed
his voice to a certain
extent."
in
about
Then,
1910, a second
monumental accident occurred when
young Ernest was at a sawmilling job. As
oxen were being used to drag logs away
from a cutting area, splinters from the
cutting operation flew into his eyes.

�Ernest completely lost his sight as a
result of inadequate medical treatment
after this accident.
For two years he attended the North
Carolina School for the Blind in Raleigh,
learning to make mattresses and brooms,
tune pianos, and read and write Braille.
Agnes
attitude

comments

on

her

brother's

that time: "The only time I
heard him complain, he said to me,
'Agnes, you know it's terrible not to be
able to see the flowers and the little
birds. But I have seen them. know what
they look like.' Anything special that
would come up, I'd explain it to him and
tell him what it looked like. And he'd
listen. He never, never forgot a voice. If
you went to see him one time, he could
tell you who you were."
at

1

Ernest soon lost interest in trying to
make a living on the skills he had picked
up at the school, and he turned instead to
skill
on
his
many
developing
instruments. He became known for his

As a glance at his discography will
Ernest knew and performed
show,
scores of songs, many of which Agnes
still sings. Although she doesn't recall
"How Are You Going to Wet Your
Whistle," she does mention that "Yield
Not to Temptation" and "The Baggage
Coach Ahead" were two of his favorite

sones.
At times, Ernest would be joined by
Connie and her sister Beulah,
both of whom were good singers. In

Many older people still carry
memories of this pleasant, outgoing
musician. They recall his traditional

like "Little Rosewood Casket,"
Tin Pan Alley songs such as "Sylvester
Johnson Lee," religious pieces like
and
to
"Life's
Heaven,"
Railway
instrumental tunes like "Mississippi
Sawyer" and "Sparrow Bird Waltz" (the
forerunner of Eddie Arnold's "Cattle

songs

his niece

Call").

1924 Ernest was joined by Connie on his
second trip to New York to make
records for Columbia. At this session, to
his harmonica and guitar backup, she
recorded "In the Shadow of the Pine,"
the Southern
"Underneath
Moon,"

Henry Whitter,
Fiddling John Carson, Gid Tanner, and
Riley Puckett. Unfortunately, none of
Thompson's music has been reissued to
date, and is available only through

Made It Twice as Nice
Paradise," and "You're as Welcome
the Flowers in Mav."
"They

as
as

Ernest Thompson was

early recording artists

a

peer to such

as

collectors.
Ernest died in 1961, and lies today at
Fraternity Church of the Brethern near

Winston-Salem.

His

tombstone bears

expertise on guitar and harmonica, and
usually
played and sang with a
harmonica holder around his neck. He
became an accomplished banjo, fiddle,
and piano player as well. By his sister's
description, "he was one-man band
almost. He sometimes even used his feet
to beat a drum. Cymbals, too. He played

them

all

at

one time."

or so, Agnes and Ernest
string band that had some

About 1918
played

in

a

eight neighborhood members, including
their niece Connie Faw (who would later

make recordings with Ernest using her
married name, Connie Sides). Agnes
recalls this group, which they called the
Dixie Band, visiting neighbors' houses to
made
our own
"We
music.
make

entertainment.

People would come out

and sit on their porches while we played,
and they'd serve refreshments for us."
Ernest played the fiddle for dances
He
and performed in local schools.

played on the streets for his living on
fairly regular basis for

at

a

least 30 years.

Agnes describes these scenes vividly: "A
lot of times when he'd be out there
playing, people would gather around

During the war years, the First
World War, a lot of soldiers would
come home on leave. Quite a few of
them would sing with Ernest on the side

him.

He'd sing

'It's

a
Long Way to
like
these songs
All those people who
pay him for singing.
That's the way he made a living." But,
she adds, Ernest was seldom allowed to
perform in front of a store. He was
forced by the merchants to play in alley
ways or places where business could not

be

interrupted.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Kirk

Sutphin

all

courtesy

walk.

Tipperary' and
'Smile Awhile.'
listened would

Ernest, seated; with nephew Frank Pinnix

�the

inscription.

BUT NOW

I

1

ONCE WAS BLIND,

SEE.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ernest Thompson Discography

Columbia
130

Are You from Dixie/
Wreck of the Southern Old
97

145

Jesse James/

147

Lightning Express
How Are You Going to Wet
Your Whistle/Little Brown
Jug

158
168
169
190

206

216

Life's Railway to Heaven/
Yield Not to Temptation
Don't Put a Tax on the
Beautiful Girls/Frankie Baker
Kiss Waltz/Sparrow Bird
Waltz
Red Wing/Snow Deer

(banjo) Coon Crap Game/
Chicken Roost Behind
the Moon
In the

Baggage Coach

Ahead/The Little
Rosewood Casket
15000
(note:

Alexander's Ragtime Band/
The Mississippi Dippy Dip
15000
this began Columbia's

Hillbilly Series on which Charlie Poole,
and
other popular
Gid Tanner,

musicians also issued recordings.)
15001
Weeping Willow Tree/
Sylvester Johnson Lee
At a Georgia Camp
15002

Meeting/Silly

Bill

The Old-Time Religion/
I'm Going down to Japan

15007

5009

Harmony

Columbia

189

Climbing up the Golden Stairs/Mississippi
Sawyer
15006
5109 Columbia
Harmony
Whistling Rufus (banjo) When You're All
In, Down, Out
Harmony 5134
They Made It Twice as
Nice as Paradise/You're Welcome as the
Flowers In May (with Connie Sides)
In the
Harmony 5 135 Columbia 15009
Shadow of the Pine/LJnderneath the
Southern Moon with (Connie Sides).

Kirk Sutphin is an accomplished fiddle
and banjo player who makes his home in
Walkertown, N.C. A former member of the

Old Hollow String Band, he currently plays
music with Ted Prillaman &amp; the Virginia
Ramblers,
works as

Kinney Rorrer,
a

surveyor.

and others.

He

�The Dance Beat

Dances

Community

Issues In Old-Time Music

in the Eighties:
In

this

combined
columns

of the OTH we have
"Dance Beat" and "Issues"

issue
the

to reflect
the concern that many
dancers and musicians alike feel regarding
current trends within the dance community.
Phil Jamison is the editor of the OTH
"Dance Beat" column, and is an active
musician, dancer, and caller. He is a
member of the Green Grass C loggers
and makes his home in Asheville, N.C.

With the resurgence of interest

time music and dance

in

the

in

Dare

To Be Square!
by

Phil Jamison

old-

1970s, new

community dances began to appear
across the country. These were not like
the old, local ones held at VFW's and
grange halls, but they often started up in
college towns, cities, and other places
where groups of people interested in old
time music got together.
For many
people, old-time music and dance fit
right in with other folk music tastes,
back-to-the-land ideals and interest in
the old-time ways. Old-time music and
other varieties of traditional music went
hand-in-hand with homemade bread,
food co-ops, and thoughts of log cabins

and living off the land.
When
there
was

dance, local
to dance as
well as play, and there was a general sense
of a community of people who were
having fun and who enjoyed being
together. The dances called were mostly
traditional
in
New
squares,
except
England where contras were a regional
style. (In a contra dance, the dancers
stand in lines opposite partners, as
opposed to a square formation.) Over
the years things have changed.
The
biggest change has been in peoples'
attitudes toward dancing, and this has
appeared in many different manifest
ations. Contras are still the popular
dance form in New England, but now
"contra-mania" has swept across the rest
of the country and in most places has just
about completely taken over, to the
exclusion of squares. The music that is
used
to
accompany contra dances,
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Cathy

Scott

musicians would come out

usually Northern fiddle styles with piano

back-up, has replaced the Southern
sound at many dances.
stringband
Attendance at dance events is increasing
and new weekly dances are springing up
all over. That may seem encouraging,
except that many old-time musicians and
dancers have been alienated by the
contra invasion on their scene, so they
no longer attend. Many dances now have
a
strict New England contra dance

orientation and square dance musicians
and callers are no longer welcome. Gone,
also, is a large part of the cooperative
community spirit that existed ten years
ago, replaced by
the dance floor.

a

different attitude on

my travels around the country this
mentioned this to a
summer,
number of people to see what extent it
In

past
was

place

I

nationwide phenomenon.

a
I

went

I

was besieged

by

Every

veteran

�old-time musicians, callers, and dancers
who had more than a few words to say
about the situation. What is contramania all about and how has it affected
the old-time music and dance scene?
come down on contras, I
Before
should say that I enjoy dancing them,
especially when they are mixed in among
squares, circles, and couple dances in the
also call some
course of an evening.
contras, having learned my first ones out
of self-defense when I found that could
not call at certain dances as strictly a
square caller.
What is contra-mania: Has your local
dance succumbed to it yet? Here is the
test: Step up to the caller's microphone
I

I

I

and say, "Find a partner for the next
dance." Then look out over the dance
floor. Are people forming squares with
an occasional hand raised where another
couple is needed, or are they all lined up
like iron filings as if the floor had
instantly became a magnetic field?
Through the years, as contras have
taken over, I've wondered what their big
attraction was. Perhaps they are the
result of people's search for novelty and
an alternative to squares. Or, maybe they
are a superior dance form. They do have
certain advantages over squares.
From a caller's point of view, contras
to call than squares. The
are easier
constant vigilance of a square caller is
not needed. Once the dance is started,
the caller can cease calling and let the
dancers continue on their own. The

timing

of the prompting

important,
straightforward and
is

but it is more
simpler than square calling. Square
calling depends more on a caller's
personal style, which may take years to
develop. The timing of squares is not
always spelled out by the phrasing of the
music, but is left up to the caller's
can
contras
In
instincts.
contrast,
literally be read right out of a book and
called. Collections of recently composed
and other favorite contras are available

print, enabling new callers to develop
repertoires of dances almost
overnight. New callers are not exposed
to many square callers, and squares are
in

huge

not as accessible in print, so they are not
as familiar with them.
Because of the variable length of
contra lines, contra callers never have to
coax dancers out onto the floor to fill out
a definite number of couples as required
for

a square.
Basically, contra callers are in demand
and popular with the swelling numbers
of people at dances. The demands and
desires of dancers certainly influence a
caller's choice of dance and there are a
number of reasons why dancers like

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

contras. For some of the newer dancers,
that

is

all

know.

they

The

have seen

predictable,

and

all

they

repetitious

nature of contras can be appealing.
Dancers like to be able to continue on
their own after a few times through

without continuous prompting. The
repetition with the phrasing of the music
allows dancers to become mesmerized by
the movement as in waltzes and other
couple dances. Dancers seem to prefer
the long sets now in style so that they can

other people as
as many
Due to the lengthened sets,
contras in which everyone is active have
become popular so that no one has to
wait their turn to dance. Finally, some
dancers dislike squares because they
have had a boring or bad experience with
them in the past. It is a challenge for
callers to develop into good square
callers when they're never given the
chance or encouragement to call them.
dance

with

possible.

Contra-mania has many implications
those of us involved in old-time
music. Many old-time musicians who
play southern-style dance music have
from community
alienated
become
dances due to the preference for contra
dance music. Contras require a more
restrained and controlled music than
for

squares

more regularly phrased, like

marching

music.

Contra

Northern fiddle tunes
In

the

past,

I

have

are

a

dances and
good match.

seen

old-time

off by inflexible
turned
musical demands and lack of under
standing on the part of some contra
callers. When allowed to play, some oldthat they
are
feel
time musicians
and
raw
to
bridle
spirit
energy
required
of their music to match the tamer tempo
of the contra figures. The need to
conform to this required tempo and tune
structure has driven many fine musicians

musicians

away.

suggested to me that the
music
Northern
usually used for contras
is
friendlier, and "more
cleaner,
A musician

palatable to Yuppie ears" than the less
tame

Southern

old-time

string

band

closer to "new age" music?
There are problems on the dance
floor, too. Many veteran dancers who
prefer squares and southern music have
been alienated by the fanaticism of avid
contra dancers. To some people it is
merely a question of taste in music and
dance, but in many places the relaxed
spirit of the square dance seems to have
been replaced by an intense competitive
feeling. This has a detrimental effect on
community spirit and especially affects
newcomers. At large dances, newcomers

sound.

Is it

�and

out-of-town visitors find

difficult

it

a partner to dance with.
They are
ignored and passed over by the
"in" crowd who don't want to risk being
stuck with a novice partner, who
perhaps can't swing well. Often those
who are the most obnoxious in this
respect are those who recently overcame
the newcomer stigma themselves.
It's like a pecking order. When a
dance is announced, all experienced
dancers rush to get an experienced
partner and then crowd into the set in
the middle of the floor. Bob Dalsemer
"Center Set
calls this condition

to get

often

the rush, newcomers get
Syndrome."
passed over, left to dance with other
novices in a side set. It is hard for them to

Old Homestead Records
100 Brighton, Michigan 481 16

Box

Phone 313-227-1997

Write For A Free Catalog Of Old-Time
Music!
Order Direct $7.00 ea. plus $1.00 per
order postage.
CS-170 Sam &amp;. Kirk McGee "Old-Time
Songs &amp;. Guitar Tunes"
CS-

1

72

1

CS-173

Elrnest Stoneman "Early Old-Time

CS-174

Recordings" Vol. 2
Riley Puckett "Old-Time Greats"

Vol.2
CS-

1

7 5

experience, being isolated from the
seasoned dancers, until they realize the
importance of being in the center set and
push to get there themselves. Center Set
Syndrome creates a snobbish clique that
effectively blocks out many newcomers
and

makes

them

exclusive set.
Newcomers

feel

left

of the

out

will often also find that

the regulars have

booked themselves two

three dancing partners in advance.
These habits may have come from an
eagerness to dance, but the unfriendly
message to newcomers is quite different.
With the formation of long contra lines,
a single dance may last 20 or .30 minutes
which adds to the time pressure of
finding a dance partner. It's a long wait
With
these
until
the
next
dance.
concerns people don't take time to talk
and socialize except during the break.
This is a far cry from the enthusiastic
or

community

spirit

atmosphere of dances

relaxed

and

10 years

ago.

So why are so many people into contra
dancing these days? Some like the exer
cise and physical challenge. They love it
when the music is slightly too fast for the
figures and they have to run to keep up.
They charge down the hall and back,
losing all sense of the timing of the music

and the grace of contra dancing. Other
people come to dances to socialize. It's a
good, safe alternative to singles bars. In a

long contra line, you get to dance with

huge numbers of people without fear of
to the brevity of the
interactions. Many dancers use swings as
an opportunity to flirt safely, though not

commitment, due

subtly.

These

confusing

or

newcomers.

superficial looks can
distressing, especially

Notice

be
to

few
attend
dances.
some
hope
couples
people still come out to dance because
love old-time
music,
actually
they
though I'm afraid that they're a minority
these days. The folk music boom is over
and most contra dancers could care less
that

very

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Welling
mental

In

gain

Ernest Sroneman "Early Old-Time
Recordings" Vol.

CS-176

&lt;Sl

Big Slim

McGee "Sacred, Senti
Silly Songs

(St.

"Sunny

Side of the

Mountain"
CS-177
CS-178

"West Virginia Hills"
Anthology
Vol. 2
The Dixon Brothers "Early
Sacred Songs" Vol. 4

CS-179

The Dixon Brothers
"Fisherman's Luck"

CS-181

Chris Bouchillon
"Original Talking Blues"
Claude Casey &lt;Sc The Pine
State Playboys

CS-182
CS-183

Uncle Dave Macon
"Over the Mountain"

CS-190

Emry Arthur
"Man of Constant Sorrow"

WE SPECIALIZE

Of"
IN

entertained.

Their

demands

often

include, "Show me something new that
I've never seen before." Musicians and
callers are forced to resort to gimmicks
to keep them satisfied.
would like to see more squares called
and danced. Dare to be square! They
I

enormous

have

potential

that

is

not

being used. They spontaneity of patter
calling in squares can make them fun and
With the
less serious than contras.
caller's ability to alter a dance at will, the
musicians, and dancers all
caller,
function together as one organism. The
caller remains involved throughout the
dance as a link between the musicians
and the dancers. The music can be less
structured and livelier, reflecting the
excitement of the often unpredictable
calls. Because of this freer form, dancers
remain attentive and more tuned in to
the calls and music. While it can be
exhilarating in a contra dance to become
mesmerized by the figures on the dance
it
excludes the caller and
floor,

musicians, except as accompanists.
While long contra lines may appear to

Dykes Magic City Trio
"Old-Time Fiddle Band"
RR3010 Clint Howard Doc Watson

CS-191

"Favorites

if hired to play. This same split carries
over to many weekend and week-long
dance events. The dancers have become
consumers and they want to be

OLD-TIME MUSIC!

about traditional music or the traditions
of the dance.
I
don't feel that contra-mania is the
cause of all this, though perhaps it didn't
help. It is more of a symptom or an
have
indicator of a trend. As a caller,
been forced to call more contras if I want
an audience. It is not that uncommon for
callers to hear "boos" from the dance
floor at the suggestion of doing more
than just a token square in an evening.
I

A consumer attitude has developed at
dances that separates the musicians from
the dancers and hurts community spirit
in general. Musicians who used to attend
weekly dances, no longer feel like a part
of the community and now only show up

unify all the dancers on the floor, I feel
that they do not bring people together
individually as well as squares or shorter
contra sets. Dancers in the long lines do
get to interact with more people, but
each contact is short and superficial.
Squares and short contra sets allow
dancers, even newcomers, more time
dancing with a more intimate group. Due
to their shorter length, time-wise, every
one has more chances during an evening
to get into dance sets and this reduces the
frantic fear of getting stuck on the side
lines for 30 minutes during a long
dancer. Maybe there is a reason why,
traditionally, contra sets included only
six

to

eight

couples.

With the exper

dancers split into many smaller
sets, a phenomenon like Center Set
Syndrome does not occur.
Many dancers approach dancing from
an academic point of view rather than
the heart. This is not surprising since
ienced

educated, but it
college
them, and they get more
concerned with the intellectual challenge
of the dances than just the uninhibited
joy of dancing. They dance to the called
figures, but not to the feel and the beat of
the music. They become uncomfortable
if they aren't kept moving at all times and
they have a fear of being inactive. In trad
itional, visiting-couple squares, as well as
traditional contras, dancers spend part
of their time being inactive, waiting for
many

restricts

are

�their turn to do the figures. Fear of being
inactive may just be another aspect of the
fast pace of the modern world, or as I
have suggested, it may come from a too-

intellectual

approach

to

dancing.

Dancers prefer contras in which every
one is active, in order to avoid being
inactive as in a traditional square or
contra. A parallel situation, though I
doubt many contra dancers would want
to identify with it, is "western" club-style
square dancing, where everyone is kept
active, and the figures are so complicated
dancers are required to take lessons to
dance:
heart.

Dancing from the head, not the

have

I

again. They need to remain related and

reinforce

seen

the old-time

music and

dance scene grow and change in the last
decade and I wonder what it will be like
10 years from now. One of the main
purposes of old-time music has always
been
The
dance scene is
dancing.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

each

other.

community will emerge
from
can
get
away

A

stronger

when dancers
a

consumer

orientation and musicians can feel like
more than just employees.
Dance callers need to be responsive to
the desires of the musicians, as well as
the dancers, and be a link between the
two. Don't be a slave to contra-mania,
but dare to call squares and get some of

southern style old-time musicians
involved again. I've always thought that
the

the music

if

Maybe we need workshops to teach
people the art of inactivity. Aside from
serving an important function in the
dance, being inactive is a great time to
shuffle your feet to the music, swing
your partner an extra time, listen to and
enjoy the music, or, believe-it-or-not,
simply enjoy watching other people
dance.
I

would like to see it
booming, but
include the old-time music scene once

is

"just

right,"

and

really

moves the dancers, the figures become
secondary. Dances don't always have to
be

complicated,

challenging,

or

new.

Give dancers the chance to loosen up
with fun and simple dances.
to have
an
urge dancers
open
attitude. Try squares as well as contras,
and be open to the old and familiar as
well as the novel. Relax and enjoy being
inactive at times and let the music move
your feet. Take off your "thinking cap?"
once in a while and dance from the heart
as well as the head. Don't take the music
for granted, but enjoy it as much as the
complexity of the dance figures. I would
hate to see live music become replaced
I

records as has happened in "western"
club-style square dancing. And let's
welcome newcomers. Remember, we
by

all there once, too. Dance with
them and help them become better
dancers through interaction. This will
also help the spirit at your community
dance.

were

Old-time musicians need to get out to

the dances and be heard.

Learn to be

a

good dance musician by working with
the caller and knowing the appropriate

dance tunes in your repertoire. It's
different than just jamming at home, but

can be just as satisfying. Make them
want to get out on the floor and "shake a
leg." Try dancing when you aren't
playing. The dance crowd will listen
more when you do play, and it will give
it

a
better understanding of how
dances work and how your music fits in.

you

some of the comments
observations presented here do not
apply everywhere and certainly not to
everyone involved in the music and
dance scene.
hope that old-time music
and dance continue to thrive and that
traditional square dancing can exist
alongside contra dancing to the benefit
of both. T raditional music and dance are
important, not just because they are old
I

am aware that

and

I

continued on base

1 5

�ASK

?

Uncle Harold

C.B., of Ambler, Pa. recommends
looking for Hawaiian steel guitar books

flea markets and other old book
sources. Below is a reproduction of the
cover, of one he found at his local flea
market. "Good luck to all ye who
search," he says.
D.S. of Medway, Oh. writes, "There
are two types of Hawaiian guitar. There
is the slack key style, in which a guitar is
tuned to open tunings and played in a
more or less conventional style. There is
a
Hawaiian
the
steel
also
guitar,
invention. It is played flat on one's lap,
usually with a metal bar, and with a
at

raised nut so the bar doesn't rattle the
strings against the frets. I'm pretty sure
this second type is what S.B. is referring
to." D.S. goes on to say that Oak

Publications' The Dobro Book, by Stacy
Phillips, contains some tablature for

Hawaiian guitar. There are also two steel
guitar organizations, both of which are
sources of tablature. Their names and
addresses are:

The Hawaiian Steel Guitar
Association (HSGA), Box 3156,

Bellingham, WA 98227; Steel Guitar
International (SGI), P.O. Box 2413, St.
Louis,

MO

organizations
newsletter.
haunting

63114. Both of these
publish a quarterly

Finally, he too, advises
local flea markets, auctions,

etc.

F.M. of Covington, Ga., kindly
responds to D.M.'s query in OTH #5.
He says, "If you'd care to put D.M. in
touch with me I have a complete
collection of the Asher Sizemore &amp;
Little Jimmie, Bluebird 78s (six

in all),
make tapes from 78s for
people." Your uncle approves such a
offer
especially since he
generous
believes that none of these titles are

and

I

do

currently

available on reissue. If D.M.,

of Lewisville wishes to contact F.M., he
should write Uncle Harold who will

forward the request.
In the last issue of the OTH, S.B. of

In., asked your uncle about
music in tablature or diagram method
for Hawaiian steel guitar. Helpful and
readers have written
knowledgeable
your uncle, S.B. Here's what they say:

Hope,

J. A. of Cumming, Ga., wants you to
get in touch with him. He says he can get

you a copy of Nick Manoloff's Hawaiian
steel guitar book, published in 1937, and
containing both tablature and music
notation. "No Vol. II has ever been
published," he writes. S.B., if you write
your uncle he will put you in touch with
J.A.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

L.H. of Richmond,

Calif, writes:

"Slack-key guitar style is not the same as
Hawaiian (steel) or Dobro. True, both
are based on guitar tunings to open
chords, but slack-key is a finger-picked
style using a thumb rocking on alternate
bass notes and chords and melody on the
higher strings; not played with a bar as
steel
and
some Dobros. So Keola
Beamer's book won't be much help for

learning steel-type Hawaiian guitar, nor
will the other two slack-key instruction
books I know of-- Raymond K. Kane
Hawaiian Slack Key Guitar by Reri Tava
Jobe, privately published, 1978; Leonard
Kwan

Slack

Key

Instruction

Book

with

Dennis Ladd, Honolulu,
Tradewinds Recording, 1980."
tablature

by

L.H. goes on to say, "The House of
Music Hawaii and South Pacific Record
and
1978 (1365
Tape Catalog for

Colburn St., Honolulu,
three
books
under

HI

96817) lists

'Instruction:

Hawaiian Steel Guitar.' These are: Mel
Bay

Steel

Guitar

Method

by

Roger

Filiberto, Vol. 1; Belwin Hawaiian Guitar
Course by Alfred L. Greathouse, in four
books; and Nick Manoloff: Album of
Favorite Hawaiian Guitar Solos. Other
categories in this listing include
'Hawaiian Slack Key Guitar' (see above)
and 'Hawaiian Pedal Steel Guitar.' If the
House of Music is still there (in 1980,
the last time I was home, it was in the Ala
Moano shopping center), one could
write for a newer catalog."
Thus properly informed that there are
distinctions between slack key and
Hawaiian guitar, your uncle thanks L.H.
for a most properly researched reply,
and hopes that S.B. will be able to follow
up on the information that our good

readers have supplied.

Seattle,

M.T.,

Wa.,

has

instituted

whole new category of
inquiry-- the Old-Time Mystery. M.T.'s
mysteries are a sub-category-- the Joe

what

may

be

a

Mysteries. Here they are:
1. Did Uncle Joe ever see the devil?
2. Where did Cotton-Eyed Joe come
from?

3. Where did he go?
Uncle Harold immediately thought of
#4: Does Uncle Joe's horse ride double?
And of course, #5. Did Uncle Joe ever go

to meeting? Uncle Harold, strange to say,
does not have the answers to these
tantalizing and cosmic questions right at
hand. He is therefore, polling you, his
loyal fans and correctors, for your
answers, the best of which will be
published in a further column.

Readers of this column will recall

a

Uncle Dave
about
the
to
Macon's
probable reaction
invention of (so-called) turkey ham.
Your Uncle Harold has received a
communication from Dave Macon II,
Uncle Dave's grandson.
"I read with interest your column on
Uncle Dave and ham," he writes. "Uncle
Dave was,
feel, an expert on three
things: country ham, Jack Daniels, and
the 'Ban-ja.' When eating on the road, it
was not unusual to hear him say, 'This
reader

inquiry

I

�from the wrong end ot the
it was shoulder. Each tall
meaning
hog.'
he
would fatten one hog for each
member ot the household, plus one for
guests, for a total ot 12. The smoke
house was located far enough trom the
house so that it would not catch on tire if
the house should burn."
Uncle Harold wonders what Uncle
Dave's comments on aerobic exercise,
low-cholesterol diets, and stress
ham came

management might have beenl

Corrections

comments

on

further

and

Before

"Whiskey

Breakfast" (the tune, not

the practice
Uncle Harold has no comment on the
practice. He recently attended a fiddlers

where he observed quite a
number of his readers engaging in lots of

convention

dubious before-breakfast pursuits.)

apologies

Anyway,

to

I

irresponsible maunderings. On the same

subject, George sends along
him

by

a letter sent
Lynn Russworm of Elmira,
Lynn writes: "Andy Dejarlis

Ontario.
has 'Whiskey Before Breakfast' on an LP
Backwoods Fiddle Tunes (London
EBX

4118).

Dejarlis

is

listed

as

the

writer. Victor Pasowisky, one of the best
fiddlers in Canada, says Andy claimed
authorship of the tune, but Victor feels it
on
some old
was
based
probably
traditional tune that Andy reworked."

comment on this: "It's
possible Dejarlis had reworked a
traditional tune but since he composed
many other tunes, unless evidence is
George's

found to the contrary, there is no reason
to believe that Andy didn't compose
'Whiskey Before Breakfast.'"
Well, young friends, there you have it
in

a

unwieldy nutshell.

large and

Is

the

book closed on this tune? Will evidence
to the contrary be found? Is the tune
itself worth all these words? Learn it and
decide for yourselves.

Uncle Harold
communications
"Farewell

Rounder album, Banging

has received two
on the subject of
Trion." The first comes

from Bob Carlin, and he says "Although
lames Brvan not 'Brvant'f mieht have
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the
his

He
on
my

and Sawing."

Some further history comes from
Joyce Cauthen: "According to James
Bryan, he learned "Farewell Trion" (and
many other fine tunes) when he was a
child from Mack Blalock of Mentone,
Ala., on Lookout Mountain. Mack and
the rest of the fiddling Blalock brothers
learned it from their great-uncle Joe
Blalock (born 1854), who composed it
upon returning to Alabama after getting
laid off from a mill in Trion, Ga. James
added a third part to the tune. James first
recorded the tune (on Old Homestead
90009) when he was 19 years old and
playing with Rual Yarborough and the

Dixiemen. I

George

Schissler. Uncle Harold has had the
batteries in his hearing aid recharged.
George writes, "'Peacock Rag' and 'Red
Apple Rag' were both compositions of
not Andy
Arthur
Smith,
Fiddling
The
Tommy Jackson LP which
Dejarlis.
contains 'Whiskey Before Breakfast'
also has two other tunes which are
attributed to Andy Dejarlis but they are
not 'Peacock Rag' or 'Red Apple Rag.'
hope this clears up any confusion your
readers might have experienced." Well,
least that clears up your uncle's
at

to

been pulling my leg, he denies writing
rune "Farewell Trion" and credits
source as being fiddler Mack Blalock.
and I along with Norman Blake
the
tune
for
recorded
guitar,

�We hardly hear this tune anymore,
but with the right fiddler and a good

Valley Forge
from

Ramona

Mark Jones
Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

solid backup,

it can be great for dances.
As with any banjo tablature from me,
strongly recommend that you set to

I

work on this piece only after you've
heard the recording. The tablature is just
a guide to get you past mysterious places
on your way to making music.
A banjo can really sound horrible on a
highly melodic tune such as this one. My
way of going at this tune is to hang onto

the

really

important

melody

"landmarks" and otherwise to take
advantage of the banjo's most wonder
ful qualities: resonance, percussion, and
tone. Let the fiddle take the lead with
melody, and avoid clutter in your banjo
picking.

As
always, your comments or
questions are welcome, care of the Old

Time Herald.

Paul Brown

�Sales

County

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
READY FOR SHIPMENT

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
NEW RELEASES
ROU-0237

"CO-505

CO-786

"CCS- 109

BRI-010
*CCLP-C101

"ROU-0213
"CCLP-0103

JA-051
ROU-0175
CO-412

AT-103

*CCS-

111

FCOT-001
CO-787
CMF-011
OH- 191

'REB-853

*SH-3759
'ROU-0233
HER-070
"ROU-0242
FCOT-005

J

FF-415
HAT-3022
*CO-791

CCS-110

CO-788
REB-850
'FF-352

JA-014

LH
KJ
UV

*CO-790
*HH-19842
'TR-l
"CO-545
*CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406
HER-63
CO -777

GFS-901
AH-002
SOUNDA-001

REB-852

LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BANJO COLLECTION Superset of 1937 -46 field recordings by John Lomax....
CHARLIE POOLE "Volume 1" Available again with new cover
classic old time recordings
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent fields recordings of the Cumberland Plateau area- w/booklet
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings
Vol. 2" Great reissue of his classic 1950s recordings
VIRGINIA TRADITIONS
EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO Great oldtime w/Roy Hall, etc
STANLEY BROTHERS "Shadows Of The Past" Great collection of live recordings 1956- 1962
CHOKERS &amp; FLIES "Old Time Music" Fine recent material by the Chicken Chokers &amp; Horseflies
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Singles Collection" Neat reissue of obscure 50's/60's cuts
some unissued
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo LP by this Kentucky musician
JAMES BRYAN "Lookout Blues" Fine old-time fiddle, featuring Norman &amp; Nancy Blake
DOC ROBERTS "Old Time Tunes" Great reissue of his tunes from the 1920 s &amp; 30's
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial &amp; field recordings of Alabama fiddlers

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00

FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "You Can Feel It In Your Soul" Classic gospel from the 1950s
OLD HOLLOW STRINGBAND Old-time music from North Carolina
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN -TRADITIONAL MUSIC FROM THE CUMBERLAND PLATEAU -Vol.
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
"
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
Vol
Reissue of 1920s material
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroe's best early 1950s Decca material
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish -w/booklet
NASHVILLE BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent old-time LP
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine leissue of the 1930s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collect ion of their 1940 s King material
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTW1CH &amp; HIGGINBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
HEW HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing

7.50
7.50

1

TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music

.UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine i92G's/30's sides
SKILLET LiCKERS
Vol 2 Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carroll Countv, Virginia
R1DIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920's/30's
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 928-41
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL w.th Mike Seeger, Brad Leftwich, Benny Jarrell, etc
VIRGIL ANDERSON "On The Tennessee Line" Old-time banjo from the upper Cumberland
SEEMS LIKE ROMANCE TO ME Traditional fiddle tunes from Ohio
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American fiddle music from Mississippi
EDDEN HAMMONS COLLECTION Historic set of traditional fiddle music
"
LOOVIN BROTHERS "The Best Of
Features their top songs from the middle 1950's
1

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted

Lfl

2

by an

asterisk

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
$10.00
7.50

$7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

$7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
$10.00
7.50

P^J

"

")

On all ORDERS in (J.S.A. please add $2.00 postage &amp; handling
CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $5.00 postage for first -3 LPs, $1.50 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in CI.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPT.H, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001
1

$7.50

Ql

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

A
Southern

Christmas

Here is one of the most
beautiful Christmas instrumental

tapes you will ever hear.
Don Pedi on lap dulcimer and
Patrick Sky on banjo and guitar
give

a

some

refreshing

new touch to

of the favorite traditional

Christmas tunes. A must for
traditional music lovers. There's
a few old favorites: Silent Might,
We Three Kings, etc. finished off
by shaped note hymns and odd
tunes from different sources
in the South. Soothing and
wonderful, this tape was the best
selling tape in North Carolina.
Send

S7 9b plus
$1.00 shipping.
Allow a lew

weeks lor slock
variations.

Skylark

Productions
P.O. Box

Asheville.
28816

16767
NC

�are
of which
original and
beautifully written. (Dale Morris)
To order: Old Homestead Records, Box

many

THE

DIXON
BROTHERS,
VOLUME IV

Old Homestead

179

Fisherman's

Luck/She

Me/Time

for Me to

Tickles

Go/After

the

Ball/

At Twilight Old Pal of Yesterday/Call
Me back Pal of Mine/Little Bessie/Dark

5/Two

Gambler-Part

Eyes/Ramblin'

Little Boys/Greenback Dollar /Never Be

Sweethearts

Again/The Girl

Danville/How

Can

Happy /The Old
Only a Dream

a

I

Broke

Left in
Man Be

Brew/T'was

Home

Dixon-guitar and vocal;
Dixon-slide guitar and vocal.

Dorsey

During

recording

1930s

the

companies

country

focused

Howard

music
their

interest upon singing groups. Many
duets came into prominence during this
period. These groups were often family
acts, especially brother combinations.
the
The names
of the Delmores,
Monroes, and the Blue Sky Boys (Bill
and Earl Bolick) were perhaps the best
known. This LP presents a lesser-known
brother duet, the Dixon Brothers.
The Dixons
Dorsey and Howard
hailed from the Darlington, S.C., area.
They did not travel widely but did
appear on Charlotte's WBT Saturday
Night Barn Dance. Both also played for a
while with Wade Mainer and the Sons of
the

Mountaineers.

This LP, the Fourth volume of Dixon
Brothers reissues on Old Homestead,
includes 16 songs chosen from their
earliest and most rare recordings. Some
of the numbers are original songs written
by Dorsey. The group's use of slide

guitar was patterned after the sound of
the earlier duo Darby and Tarlton.
Considering the age and rarity of the 78s,
the

recording quality is very satisfactory.
Dixon Brothers were not a
polished vocal duo. The lead singing and
The

the slide guitar are adequate and even
good on some selections, but on some
songs the harmony singing is weak.
There are some nice renditions on this
LP,

however.

I

especially liked 'Two

Little Boys," "Fisherman's Luck," "She
Tickles Me," "Greenback Dollar," and
"Dark Eyes."
of the Dixon
The real strength

Brothers
recordings
themselves.
Most of
consists of well-chosen,

the
songs
their material

is

obscure songs,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

100 Brighton,

MI

48116

�around. His three selections here show
he
dominates contests. He is
exceedingly exciting, pulling off some
times unexpected turns, and is always

why

tasteful.

I

hope his cuts are

a

forthcoming Henderson

LP.

mountain

the

Seymour

and

dulcimer

preview of

a

Reynolds

in

play
traditional

mode, a pleasant relief from the deluge
of "new age" dulcimer recordings. This is
how it's supposed to sound.
previously had heard everyone on
this LP except for Ray Norton. His
singing was a pleasant revelation. His
songs were multiple-tracked, allowing
him to sing his own harmonies.
All in all, this album is a fine
representation of the diversified music
one can find in North Carolina and
I

Virginia. (Kerry Blech)
To order: Flying Cloud Records, Rt.
Box 436, Madison, NC 27025

2

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Congress in 1937 to harness the power
of the Columbia River system through
dams. Much of rural
hydroelectric
Washington and Oregon at that time was
still unelectrified.
The cheap hydro

allowed
the
power
public power
movement to flourish in the Northwest.
BPA hired Woody Guthrie in 1941 to
write songs to promote this movement.

Several songs were written for a movie,
7 he Columbia, that finally was issued in
1949. Woody was required at times
during his employment to produce a
song a day. Even a prolific writer like

Woody couldn't keep
turning

began

previously,
although

in

like

they

up that pace, so he

songs he had written
"Hard

would

Travelin',"
be

modified

slightly.

Woody Guthrie fan, you
without this album. Many
of these songs appear on a commercial
recording for the first time. Even those
If you are

a

can hardly do

that are more familiar have some lyrical
variance.
There is some irony involved in the
release of this album, however. It was
produced to coincide with the 50th
anniversary of the BPA, an organization
that Woody approved of in the '40s
because it was helping the people.
During the 1 970s, specifically during the
term

of

then-Administrator

Donald

Hodel, now a member of the Reagan
cabinet, BPA strong-armed the public
power utilities of the Pacific Northwest
by threatening to cut off their power
supply. BPA mistakenly believed
nuclear energy was the wave of the
future. Its power manager, Bernard
Goldhammer, came up with a plan that
called for more than 20 new nuclear
plants by the end of the century to meet
what it anticipated were the region's
needs. This was power that
energy
wasn't needed or wanted. Construction
on five plants was begun in the '70s
two have indefinitely been put into
mothballs and two more were

terminated,

the

causing

municipal bond default

largest

history, a debt
the Northwest will be paying off long
into the 21st century. As Catherine
Wyndham put it, "Woody must be
spinning in his grave like a hydro turbine
generator.' (Kerry Blech)
in

To order: Rounder Records, One Camp

Street, Cambridge, MA 02140.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�CASSETTE
TAPES

Think of old-time music and one is
likely to think of dance bands, claw
hammer banjo, and the mountains of the

South. That is certainly
of it, but as recent letters to this

Appalachian
part

"old-time
music"
magazine indicate,
stands for many discrete if related
musics ranging from the eclectic yet

traditionally
modern

Traditional Ballads and Songs from the
Eastern Ramapos (Field Recordings of
Everett Pitt Made by Anne Lutz)
Marimac 9200
The Tinker's Story /The Farmer's Curst

Wife/Hushabye/Lovely Jimmy/Lord

Lover /Young Edmund/Jimmy Randal/
Lord Beekman/Mary of the Wild
Frog

Mouse/The

and the

Bold Soldier/The

Merry Brown Field/

Sheffield Apprentice/The Boston
Burglar/The Butcher Boy /Springfield
Mountain/An American Frigate/The
The

Cumberland/The Little Iron Monitor/
Gone to Kansas/Give an Honest Irish
Lad a Chance/The Day Fought Dwyer/
I

The Backwoodsman
IN THE

HILLS OF HOME

Raymond Smith and Bob Cowan
Marimac 9010
Bring

Won't

Back Those Good Old Days/I
Go back to Tennessee/In the

Hills

of

Home/Lowe's
Song/Tribute

Crawdad
Bailey /Berryville

Tune/The
to

DeFord

Jail/Gotta See Your
Mama Every Night/What Would You
Give in Exchange/The Harmonica
Blues/Vanishing Red Men, Vanishing
Freedoms/Berryville Jail-Old Joe
Clark/Run, Johnny, Run/There's a
Mansion Over There/Jesus is with Me/
The Old Rugged Cross/John Henry
FARMER'S
FROLIC
The Ross County Farmers
Marimac 9013

Green Corn/Darling
Here Tonight/Gray
Eagle/Log Cabin/The Old Coon Dog/
Webb's Tune/Come Thy Fount of
in

the

Honey/Feast

Blessing/Gonna See My Mama/
Life/Shortning Bread/Casey
Jones/Dixie Blues /Midnight on the
Every

Beautiful

Stormy Deep/Uncle Joe/Tomahawk/
Sugar Barrel/Stand,
Boys, Stand/

Chillicothe

Two-Step/Chum's

Hornpipe/Please Come Back, Little Pal/
Uncle Mitt/Evening Shade
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

through

of

all

reinforce the point,
recent releases of three
very different "old-time musics" from
Marimac Recordings.
Certain areas in the southern
mountains have gained reputations as
places where the unaccompanied ballads
have survived in spite of the vicissitudes
of time and culture. Western North
Carolina, central West Virginia, and the
Cumberland Plateau come immediately
to mind along with the singing of Dillard
recordings. As

MOUNTAIN:

Sally

sounds

stripes of
early commercial county, to the most
archaic and unusual performances, lost
forever but for wax, steel disc, or wire

UP AGIN
THE

Moor/The

instrumented

bands,

here

are

if to

three

Chandler
and
the
Doug Wallin,
Hammons family, and the Hicks family
But
does New Jersey
respectively.
suggest itself to you as a hotbed of
traditional singing? Well, perhaps not a
hotbed, but as this tape, Up Agin the
Mountain, demonstrates, the old ballads
were alive and well in the 1940s within
50 miles of New York City in the singing
of Everett Pitt, born and raised in the
Ramapo Mountains of Northern New

Jersey.
Everett

Pitt

discs

wire in the forties

and

was

recorded on home
by

Anne

whose notes and transcriptions
comprise a booklet accompanying this
tape. Pitt was a steady, competent singer,
his songs the ballads and broadsides
Lutz,

handed down to him by family and
friends, and sung for amusement at
home and at social gatherings.
There are some very good songs here;
in fact, nearly every one is worthy of

attention, and students and singers of
ballads will want this tape. Neverthe
less, these songs are somewhat out of
context. I wish I could hear Pitt sing
these around some kitchen stove with
good conversation interspersed between
songs, for the cumulative effect of these
songs, following as they do one upon
another, can be numbing. So get this

tape, but take it a bit at a time so as to
better appreciate each selection. Among
the many fine songs here I particularly
like Pitt's "The Backwoodsman," "The
a song dating
Merry Brown Field"
and his 'The
perhaps to the 1500s
Frog and the Mouse," an old standard to
be sure, but bearing here an interesting

chorus and distinctive melody.

Raymond Smith and Bob Cowan,
both of Oklahoma, are featured on In the
Hills of Home, Marimac 9010. They grew
up in musical families, and it is in the
context of home and family that their
music continues to flourish. The
selections on this tape, recorded
LaRose
attempt

between

1981

and

by

Joe

1986,

type of documentation, a
record of the Smith and
Cowan families' tradition of musicmaking today."
Ray Smith, who was born in 1910,
grew up listening to his father's fiddle
and French harp as well as Jimmie
Rodgers records, and playing music with
his brother Earl. "I Won't Go Back to
Tennessee" is a piece from those early
days, a harmonica and vocal number
learned from his father and a song long in
the Smith family.
Likewise, his
"Berryville Jail" is an old song recounting
events from the nineteenth century. Ray
plays it on guitar and sings in his relaxed,
effective style.
Bob Cowan, who has played with Ray
Smith since the 1940s, plays guitar and
mandolin and sings with a similar ease
and assurance. His "Jesus is With Me,"
backed by Smith on banjo and recorded
"a

close-to-true

�live in his church,

is

heartfelt.

quiet, steady, and

Throughout this tape both
Cowan and Smith demonstrate that they
are fine old-time singers, comfortable

with and fond of the songs they were
raised on.
Both Ray Smith and Bob Cowan have

composed
appear

songs,

on

and

several
highlight

of

this

which
tape.

Smith's "Bring Back Those Good (Did
a
wistful if
Days" is contemplative,
questioning look at the "fond happy
days of yore." Bob Cowan's "In the Hills
of Home" is a recitation set against a
sweeping lonely melody. Bob's love for
his
home country in the eastern
Oklahoma hills is evident in every line of
the song; his words evoke a clear picture
of places, seasons, and a way of life. like
I

the original songs on this tape. They are
straightforward and meaningful, honest

songs soulfully delivered.
Earl Smith, Ray's brother, plays two
fiddle tunes of particular interest on this
His
"Berryville Jail" melody,
tape.
different from Ray's, and "Old Joe
Clark" are slippery, wailing pieces, very
nice fiddling indeed.
Also present on this tape on three cuts
is the late Lowe Stokes, an outstanding
fiddler who played with the Skillet
Lickers during the heyday of that band
and with many other groups afterward.
Lowe, who moved to Oklahoma in the
forties, was a long-time neighbor of
Smith and Cowan. During his last years,
after a long hiatus, Lowe took up the
fiddle again, and it was with Ray and Bob
that he often
played. As may be
imagined, his playing is not up to the
standards of his youth when he led some
of the hottest fiddle bands in the
country, but it's still Lowe Stokes, and
that counts for a lot. "Lowe's Tune," a
piece he learned in the old Georgia days,

performance here.
Like the Everett Pitt recordings, this is
a
tape of home music, a collection of
informal performances that, for the
most part, were never recorded with a
mass audience in mind. Many good
is

his best

records

traditional

of

composed of just such.
doesn't knock

I

music

are

like this tape,

me out, perhaps
because, as in the case of Everett Pitt, it's
removed from its natural habitat. Again
would wish for some ideal kitchen or
porch where could sit back and listen to
and the
the songs,
the stories,
reminiscences that Ray Smith and Bob
Cowan must possess in abundance.
Until then,
have this tape.
but

it

I

I

I

Out in Chillicothe, Ohio, there's a
fiddler named Lonnie Seymour who
formed a band called the Ross County
Farmers back in 1947. The Ross County
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Farmers played for radio audiences,
dances, and community events in the
Chillicothe area until they disbanded
during the days when television began to
wipe out such archaic institutions as
square dancing and live radio.
The year 1983 witnessed the rebirth
of the Ross County Farmers. Of the old

Lonnie

personnel,

only

Lonnie

Seymour

Seymour

remains, accompanied by Tony Ellis on
banjo and Jeff Goehring on guitar.
Farmer's Frolic, another Marimac release,
presents 23 of their tunes and songs.
is

an

interesting

fiddler. He plays lots of old tunes from
his part of the country in a style that
combines the music of the old-timers he
heard in his youth with the more uptown
sounds of Arthur Smith, one of his
favorite fiddlers. His pace is generally
and
furious,
although this tape is
composed of home recordings, Lonnie's

drive

overwhelming

lifts

these

plane of energy and
performances
emotion beyond that of many more-laidto

a

back home sessions.
Tony Ellis, a native of North Carolina
and noted musician from the great early
years of bluegrass,
provides a fine
to Seymour's fiddling. His
banjo parts seem to dance in and around
the fiddle
line, punctuating some
passages, underlining others. Bluegrass
banjo and old-time fiddle can be a
fortuitious combination, as when Kyle
Creed and Bobby Patterson recorded
together for the old Mountain label, and
Seymour and Ellis prove the point again.
Jeff Goehring plays guitar on these
cuts. He is a terrific old-time fiddler
himself and has been tireless in his search
and
for
encouragement of old-time
music in Ohio. His backup work is

complement

consistently good,

a

firm foundation on

which Seymour and Ellis build the tunes.
This tape is not without faults. There
are tuning and intonation problems here
and there and at times the music moves
so fast as to teeter on the edge of disaster,
although a real smashup never occurs.
But for all that, it really jumps, jumps to
the beat of "Sugar Barrel," "Tomahawk,"
"Sally in the Green Corn," and glides

through "Chillocothe Two-Step." The
vocal numbers are good, understated
performances well paced and cleanly
done. missed the Ross County Farmers
when they came east a year or so ago.
a
This tape has me contemplating
I

pilgrimage to Ohio.

hate records and tapes
Postscript:
without notes. want to know about the
people listen to, and find artful covers
without information a maddening waste
of potentially informative surfaces. The
I

I

I

I

Marimac

covers

can

hardly

be

termed

artful, but they bristle with information.
Up Agin the Mountain and In the Hills of
Home are both accompanied
by
booklets, and every available inch of
"Farmer's Frolic" is taken up with notes.
like it. (Craig Johnson)
I

To Order: Marimac Recordings,
Box 5, Little Ferry, NJ 07643

P.O.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

continued, from page 24
and have historic value, but because they
are alive and fun and fill a social need.

Community

dances will remain strong

and vital if we learn to understand each
other and come to them with an open
attitude, and especially if the dancers,
callers, and old-time musicians can come

together as one strong community again.
Now, find a partner for the next dance.
and the
to
Bob
Dalsemer
Thanks
multitude of other callers, musicians, and
dancers

while

I

who

lent me

their

ears and

was thinking about all this

ideas
P.J.

�THE

HERALD

OLD-TIME

A

"The Old-Time

far so good, no wasted
collectible and read cover to cover

up the

good work."
John Hartford, Madison, TN

"The Old-Time Herald can help bring the national oldtime music community together
It will
make sure this
music continues into the future."

REVIEWS

it's

had always hoped for something

like this and I'm glad

I

I

to the

PHOTOS

I wish
to become a subscriber to
The Old-Time Herald for one year.
My check for $12.00 is enclosed.

(Foreign subscriptions $16 U.S.)
The OLD-TIME HERALD, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA.

I

here. My grandfather would be proud."
David Ramsey Macon, Greenbrier, TN

Dedicated

DANCE BEAT

YES!

I

David Holt, Fairvlew, NC
"I

ISSUES IN OLD-TIME MUSIC
ASK? UNCLE HAROLD HERE AND THERE

HISTORICAL AND CONTEMPORARY ARTICLES

Herald-so
a

INTERESTING!

QUARTERLY MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO
THE SUPPORT AND PROMOTION OF
OLD-TIME MUSIC.

What readers are saying:
space, every issue
at our house. Keep

INSIGHTFUL!

PROVOCATIVE!

INFORMATIVE!

Name

24333
j

Address (or P.O. Box)
j

of

memory
old-time musicians
Who have passed on-

all the

And to those who are carrying

it

City

on

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

State

Zip
i

�IS

CHRISTMAS
ALMOST HERE...

a better gift than a subscription to The Old-Time Herald magazine. This
offers
quarterly publication
interesting stories and articles that cover every aspect of old-time
album
reviews, historical features-including in-depth looks at the best bands
music-dances,

and what could be

and musicians of today and yesterday.

Subscriptions are only $12 (U.S.) and information forms are on page 27. Order the
Old-Time Herald for your friends today and give them a little bit of Christmas all year long.
(Foreign subscriptions $16.00 U.S.)

THE OLD-TIME HERALD

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

P.O. Box

1362, Galax, Virginia 24333

�PHOTO BONUS

KELLY LUNDY
reads
THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
Kelly
Emmett
County
Grayson
guitarist,

heard singing and playing guitar with his father,
Lundy, on Emmett W. Lundy, Fiddle Tunes From Grayson

can

be

Virginia; String 802, 1977, United Kingdom. Kelly, from
County, Virginia, is an accomplished fiddle and banjo player,
and singer.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12160">
                <text>&lt;i style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;&lt;span&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 6 (Winter 1988-1989)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12161">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12162">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 6 (November 1988-1989)&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;“Going for the Intangible: A Conversation with Bruce Molsky,” by Craig Johnson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old-Time Music in Japan A Small but Fanatic Following,” by Mike Miller&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Ernest Thompson A Pioneer Country Recording Artist,” by Kirk Sutphin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music/Dance Beat – Community Dances In The Eighties: Dare To Be Square,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Eastern Montana and Northern Wyoming,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Charlotte, North Carolina,” by Joe Marlin Riggs&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Old-Time Music Around Minnesota,” by Bob Bovee&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12163">
                <text>1988</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="12546">
                <text>1989</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2100">
        <name>1988</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="971">
        <name>1989</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5533">
        <name>Bob Bovee</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5527">
        <name>Bruce Molsky</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5528">
        <name>Craig Johnson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5530">
        <name>Ernest Thompson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5532">
        <name>Joe Marlin Riggs</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5531">
        <name>Kirk Sutphin</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5529">
        <name>Mike Miller</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5474">
        <name>Phil Jamison</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2518" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3444">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/71b9537d08e5adb20508dddfa58cd5d1.pdf</src>
        <authentication>3b36edd89c355a2a36b694776de044f1</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12164">
                    <text>Spring $3.50

February

April 1989

THE

OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

SHEILA ADAMS BARNHILL

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Section with Illegible Text

are
Just Around
Advertise

The Corner!

Your
In The

Event

OLD-TIME HERALD
Reasonable

Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333
for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The OLD-TIME HERALD
Vol. 1 No. 7
The Old-Time Music Group' Inc.
P.O. Box 1362
Galax, VA 24333

703-236-7808
Editor

Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Brad Leftwich
Linda Higginbotham
Hilary Dirlam

Dance Editor
Phil Jamison

Advertising
Dale Morris
Ann Erwin

Administrative Consultant
Bobby Patterson

No

part

of

this

magazine

may

be

reproduced in any form without written
permission from the publisher. Not
responsible for loss or non-return of
unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
1987 The Old-Time Herald
The Old-Time Herald (ISSN 1040358)

(USPS 002672) is published quarterly
the first of August,
November,

February, and May by the Old-Time
Music Group, Inc., P.O. Box 1362,
Galax, VA 24333. Subscription rates
$12.00
payable in advance. One year

(foreign subscriptions $16.00 U.S.).
Classified ads cost 35 cents per word,
minimum $5.00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All classified ads must be received
by the first of the month, one month
Second Class
prior to publication.
at
VA 24381.
Woodlawn,
postage paid

POSTMASTER:

Send
of
Change
address to the Old-Time Herald, P.O.

Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333.

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. is

a

not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation

under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal
Revenue Code.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�FROM
THE
EDITOR
New Rates
May
Beginning

as of

1

the

with

summer

(May-July) issue of the Old-Time

Herald, we reluctantly must raise
our rates to keep up with rising
costs of production. The new rates
will be: One year- $15.00; One

issue- $4.50.

Foreign-

$18.00

U.S.
We will charge $6.00 for each
back issue, which includes postage

and handling. All the new rates will
apply as of May 1, 1989.
We will be sending our
advertisers a new rate sheet (sizes
will remain the same) as soon as

possible. We encourage potential

advertisers to request our rate
sheets. We have very reasonable
rates, a sizeable mailing list, and a
very specific market.

We will be raising our classified

ad rates to .50&lt;f

per word,

$7.00

advertiser
who has already paid for a two- or

minimum.

Note:

Any

four-time discount rate extending
beyond the May issue will not be

charged extra. All display or
classified ads to go in the Summer
(May July) OTH will be charged
the new rates.

The BIG news

is

that we have

received our tax exempt status.
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
publishers of the Old-Time Herald,
is now formally a non-profit, tax
exempt organization under section
501(c) (3) of the Internal Revenue
Code.

As we continue to develop the
organization and its magazine, the
Old-Time Herald, we will be doing
fund raising from time to time.
Your contributions and gifts to the
Old-Time Music Group, Inc., will

now be tax deductible. We hope
you will join us in our efforts to

music
the old-time
the
of
voice
community through
the old-time music community

serve

the Old-Time Herald.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�played fiddle.

I

could close my eyes and

hear "Step Back Cindy." Lordy,

like only yesterday.
The article was

it

well-written

seems
and

I

could almost hear his voice. Thanks OldTime Herald! Keep up the good work and
I appreciate
the jogging of my memory.
And to Bruce-using the famous
words of Tommy Jarrell-"Keep
playin' hell out'n it!"
Sheila Adams Barnhill
Mars Hill, NC

think you do a wonderful job of
promoting old-time music and keeping
discussions concerning our music alive. I
enjoyed reading the different views on
1

"home-taping"

of friends'

sure that this is

Netherlands too.

a

albums.

problem here

Be

in the

Harry Vogel
Hoogezand, Holland

As winter approaches, the thought of
enduring the cold, bleak days without
my OTH chills me even now. Please
check my subscription and send my
beloved OTH as soon as possible.

Don Talley

Greenville, SC

The magazine
is
wonderfully
informative and the production has beer
would like to see
superb. One thing
I

listing of some of the smallei
old-time music conventions. I realize
that many small communities might nol
be able to afford an ad, but there shoulc
be some other way to encourage them tc
send information. Also, it would be nice
to have some sort of coverage or photo
essays on the conventions.
more of

is

Philip F. Gura
Chapel Hill, NC

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�the front of the hall, leaving the back of
the hall for the "beginners." The worst
offenders are the ones who show up at
the dance fashion-ably late so they won't
have to do "boring dances with

beginners" early in the evening. They are
the same ones who try to rationalize their
way out of paying full admission price to
the dance with, "It's not fair to charge me
the full price when I've already missed
half the dance."
On the positive side, however, I have
noticed the "community" atmosphere at
a

lot

of

the

Morgantown,
and

to some

dances,

W.V.
extent

particularly in
Kent, Ohio,
Pittsburgh and

and
in

Cleveland where the caller and band
members from one dance are dancing at
the next one.

John D. Patrick
Pittsburgh, PA

to Phil J. for his article on
Be Square." I too, have lost a
to
"Daring
lot of interest in the square/ contra dance
scene due to the narrowminded and

Cheers

competitiveness

at

dances, especially

in

the D.C. area. Dance "police" seem to be

increasing in numbers and one often
needs a license to dance! I too, enjoy a
good square for many reasons, one being
that I'm allowed time to hang back, and
swing, relax, watch others, and enjoy the
music. Here's to the resurrection and
preservation of a good old southern
square.
Joan Kaminkow
Randallstown, MD
I
was real interested in the "Dance
Beat" column of the Winter issue. I
personally enjoy the square dances best
for all the reasons Phil mentioned. I can

at ease and relaxed doing these
dances. It would be a great loss not to
have squares at festivals and gatherings.
Keep encouraging squares, Phil.

feel more

Marshall Hulslander

Mansfield, PA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�livingroom floors across the country.
(Mac played in just such a band not too
The
many
years back,
remember?)
strength of old-time music lies in its
community,

not in its stars! A day job

honorable tradition
old-time
(and
necessity)
among
musicians, though these days that job is
more likely to be in business or
computers than in farming or
moonshining!
The record-taping
issue deserves
has always been an

further scrutiny. Mac and others call it
--but traditional music can't
"stealing"
be stolen, only passed on. We don't own
the music
--it owns
us! In my 16 years'
involvement in old-time music, I've
bought hundreds of records (including
five of Mac's), but the most valuable
music, knowledge, and experiences came
for free
--generously shared by other
musicians whose only desire was to
further the music. I, too, hope to pass on
as much of "my" music as I can. If that
means occasionally taping a few records
to spur a friend's developing interest, so
be it. Don't worry, Mac-a tape dub is
not

a

complete

produced,

substitute

intelligently

a well
annotated

for

record. If they like the tape, they'll want
to get the record, and to see you perform
next
time
in
town. And
you're
order
more
than ice
hopefully, they'll
water.
Jim

Rosenstock

Oxon Hill, MD

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�An
Interview

found myself for the first time in a
community in which singing was as
common and almost as universal a
.The fact has been
practice as speaking.
forgotten that singing is one form of
I

expression that can be practised without
.In an ideal
any preliminary training.
society every child in his earliest years
would as a matter of course develop this

inborn capacity and learn to sing the
songs his forefathers sang in the same
natural and unselfconscious way in
which he now learns his mother tongue

And
things

it

was precisely this ideal state of

that

found

I

mountains.

existing

in

the

Cecil Sharp
English Folk Songs from the
Southern Appalachians

Sodom is a small rural community in
corner
of Madison
northwest
and
mountainous
a
relatively
County,
remote area in northwestern North

Taylor

Barnhill

the

With
SHEILA ADAMS

BARNHILL

Carolina.

It is a

Hilary Dirlam

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

an

ancient

preserve these antique, yet vivid, stories
of lords,
ladies, castles,
treachery,
and humorous
infidelity,
magic,
happenings sung in a musical style that
had become outmoded by the time of
Mozart.
Travel down any dirt road anywhere
in Madison County today, and you'll see
four-wheel drive vehicles and satellite
dishes outside people's houses. The
amazing thing

come

to

not that "progress" has
County; it is that
inroads of mass media,
is

Madison

despite the
interstates, and
by

region where

tradition of music has been
the vestiges of an art that
preserved
with the invention of
to
die
out
began
movable type.
The inaccessibility of Madison
small communities
(until
County's
and
the fierce pride and
recently)
independence of the Scots-Irish families
inhabiting them have no doubt helped to
oral

Ingle's

Supermarkets,

the old music is still very much alive. The

�following interview with Sheila Adams
Barnhill might have been done with any
one of a number of younger Madison
County musicians. There are the other
ballad singers, as well as banjo players
and fiddlers, who share Sheila's heritage,
and who feel a strong sense of preserving
something very precious and very old.

lot of times, 'How
do you learn the tunes
the music that
it's so foreign
goes with the words
"I've been asked

sounding!' When

a

certain songs,
south in the winter.
They know where they're supposed to
go, because of instinct."
I

hear

it's like birds flying

Sheila Adams Barnhill identifies
herself as a seventh-generation ballad
singer. Looking at an enormous sheet of

cardboard on which is written part of
Sheila's family tree (for the benefit of
people who can't keep it in their heads),
one can see that the tradition of music in
Shelia's family indeed goes back at least
that far, probably farther. And an oral
tradition that embodies family history
between three and four hundred years
old is in itself noteworthy. (See inside
back cover.)
"James Shelton

Died

Born Essex County,

Bermuda,
England.
1668," is
written at the top of the tree.
"I have always had a dream of going to
Scotland and Ireland and England,"
Sheila says. "I feel like that's home just
as
much as Sodom is." Sheila is
descended from James Shelton, whose
son settled in V irginia in the late seven
teenth or early eighteenth century, on
both her mother's and father's side of
the family.
Sheila can claim kinship with many of
the ballad singers, fiddlers, and banjo
players who have made their homes in
Madison County during the last 150
years, and perhaps farther back than

her songs from him.

The Wallins are descended from the
Shelton branch of the family. William

"Duck" Shelton, an early nineteenth
century Madison County character, is
remembered today not only for being a

ballad singer but also for supposedly dis
covering a silver mine and dying without
ever revealing where it was. It has
remained undiscovered to this day.
Duck Shelton fathered at least three
children who sang ballads: Cassander,

"Granny Banks." Granny
Banks sang for Cecil Sharp, who came to
Rosa,

and

Madison County in the early twentieth
century to collect songs. Rosa Shelton
married a Wallin, and her five sons

Jess ("Pap"), Bose, Tom, and
were all ballad singers. Mitch
also sang for Cecil Sharp, and played the

Doug,
Mitch

fiddle.
During

the Civil War,
Madison
County was sharply divided between
Confederate and Union loyalties, with

men fighting for each side, and was the
site of many skirmishes and two out
right massacres.
Bose Wallin was the father of Rachel,
who played the fiddle and was the
mother of Byard Ray, perhaps the best
known of Madison County's fiddlers.
Byard, one of the people who taught
Sheila the banjo, was a tremendous
influence on the younger generation of

Madison County traditional musicians.

Byard died last year.
Sheila feels the musical energy in her
family, and in herself, is partly a result of
the
but
also
environment,
"partly
genetic. I've had a whole lot of people tell
me that I sine a whole lot like Dellie did

when she was young

the voice is the
same. Byard said he picked the fiddle up
at four years old and could play it. That's
like saying the first ballad I learned, I
already knew. It's hard to believe. Maybe

some of
and

it is

the

intimidated

listening

other

to it all

thing

is

your life
not being

by it!"

Sheila's Life
Sheila grew up in the community of
among the members of her
family, in a remote corner of
County. "My mother (Neple
Adams) was a public school
teacher
she taught for 36 years. My
father (Ervin Adams) was a pipefitter.
He was gone during the week, so I grew
up in a basically single-parent family.
That was how society was over home
the women stayed home and raised the
kids while the men had to leave to find
work, unless they farmed. I went to a

Sodom,
extended
Madison
Norton

little

community school

in

Laurel.

"When I was 10, I started piano
lessons. Mama felt like, to be cultured,
you had to have a musical background.
The piano teacher told Mama it was just
a waste
of time because I was totally
tone-deaf. I hated the piano. I hated all
those little notes on lines that told you
there was just one specific way you could
play the song. I wanted to play it how I
heard it. But you don't play by ear if
you're going to be a 'professional'
musician; you play by notes. And do you
know, I completely dropped it from my
mind.
"The ballads and the fiddle music were
always there, though. It was like any-

that.
Chandlers, Wallins, Nortons,
Sheltons
these descendents of settlers

from

the

British

Isles

have

married,

intermarried, lived their lives, and made
music in this remote section of North
Carolina for a long time. Sheila shares
the musical heritage of them all.
Drew Norton was the great-grand
father of Dellie and Berzilla, sisters born
before the turn of the century, both
ballad singers from whom Sheila learned
many of her ballads.

Kooert

father standing up in church and singing,
the singing has been a part of the
Wallin family for years and years." Cas
Wallin, born in 1903, still sings and
plays the banjo. Sheila learned many of

Amberg

"The
Wallins, now, they're all
musicians," says Sheila. "Both of my
grandmothers were Wallins. Dellie says
she can remember my grandmother's

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

photo

by

so

Dellie Norton

�took it for granted. I
remember when I was a little girl up at
Dellie's, standing around up at the milk
gap. The cows would always come down
there in the morning and at night, to be
milked. It was a frosty morning in the
else,

thing

fall.

I

this real clear memory of
sitting on a little three-legged

have

I

Dellie
stool, milking.

was

It

cold enough

to

where you could see the steam coming
off the warm milk. And Dellie laid her
head against the cow and she was singing
'Young Emily.' Back then her voice was
very strong. She lived up in a holler, way
back against the foot of the gigantic
mountains. Even now, 30 years later,
whenever I sing 'Young Emily,' that's the
the
memory that comes back to me
smell of the warm milk, and the cow's
tail

swishing, and Dellie's voice, echoing

over.
"I was like anyone else growing up in
a lot of stuff was going on
the sixties
all over that we knew of because ofTV I
was in Dellie's barn when President
Kennedy was assassinated. I can still
and
remember that awful feeling,
Granny starting to cry. That really
all

because you never saw
That
was something you did
Granny cry.
in private.
well,
"Growing up around Dellie
you knew just what was expected of you.
You knew what you could and couldn't

impressed

me,

do, and that the punishment

would

be

swift, and there'd be no nagging. I'd be
out with mv cousins, and we'd be
chasing the guineas, or a new litter of
pups, and here she'd come around the
side of the shed with that little green
broom switch' they
a 'keen
switch
we'd scatter like
and
it
called
chickens! We knew if she got hold of
your bony little legs, that switch would
mark you for a week. It didn't make us
hate her though, oh Lord no! It made us
respect her. The minute my voice gets
harsh with my kids, Dellie says, 'Don't
it'll make 'em
foolish.
you're gonna get after 'em,
do
don't just sit around and threaten

talk to 'em like that
If

it!'

got interested in rock
bands: Steppenwolf, Led Zeppelin, The
all the hard rock. On the other
Who
"As

hand,

a

teenager,

I

liked Judy Collins

I

and James

remember the first time I heard
She blew me away! And at
Mitchell.
Joni
the same time, in the summer, going up
to sit on Dellie's porch and listening to
Taylor.

I

her sing 'Young Emily.'

huge class of 16! had
a grade, turned 1 7 in
March and graduated in May.
"For some reason, in my community,
there had been a lot of young women
"I

graduated in

a

I

been moved ahead

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

who

had

Teacher's

Asheville

to

gone

College

Normal

during

the

Depression. Mama went through on a
scholarship. People had always assumed
that I would go because of my mother. It
wasn't ever really verbalized but it was
'Be a teacher.'
always understood
"So I went off to Western Carolina

WCU

University."
about

is

Cullowhee,

in

south

miles

50

of

Sheila's

an
was
"It
interesting
community.
experience for a girl who'd grown up in
Sodom Laurel. After I'd been there

about four weeks, a girl down the hall
took a flying leap out the window. She
landed in some bushes and broke her leg.
My father came and got me that
weekend. Then I started at Mars Hill

College." Mars Hill is in Madison
County, much nearer to Sheila's home.

"I started in mid-January, got married to
Steve Rice in April, went to summer

school,

Melanie

had

November."

in

now 18.
Sheila's daughter Melanie
'Then Steve and I separated and I
went back to Sodom to live. I was out of
school a year. I went back the following
summer and went straight through. You
have to remember, all the strong people
is

in

my life were

Dellie and my

women

and it was more or less under
stood, 'so what if you have a kid, that's a
kind of a handicap, but it's no reason to

mother

down and quit. The women were the
ones who got up in the morning and built
'

sit

the fire, went to the spring, broke the ice,
put the water in the bucket, and carried it
to the house. Also, it was the late sixties,
early seventies, and Women's Lib came
along. All that stuff like, 'I'm a woman
and I can do anything.'
"Around 1970 there was a revitalization of traditional music. There was
the Bascom Lamar Lunsford Festival.
Mars Hill was interested in keeping trad
itional music alive, too, and Warren
Wilson College had a lot of ballad
workshops. Artus Moser lived in that
I
think he had
and
community
something to do with it. Anyway, the old

people would

go

places and sing.

I

was 17

would drive them, and I'd
stand around in the lobby and smoke
cigarettes and wish it was over, so I could
get back to a party or something.
it
I was nineteen,
"Then one night
I took
was after Melanie was born
them to a workshop
everyone sitting
around in a circle. One person would

or 18 and

I

sing, then the next one, and so on, and
they had just the right number of chairs.
But for some reason, one of the ballad

singers

didn't

show

Dellie and
between them. I

up.

Berzilla insisted that
said, 'Well, I can't do that,
any of these old songs!'
I

sit

I

don't know

Dellie said,

'Yeah, you do. You know every one that
You just don't know that you
I know.
know them.' And when it came time for
Dellie to sing she reached over and put
her hand on my knee and said, 'This is
my great niece here. She's a little nervous
about doin' this 'cause she's never done
it before. If everyone will look around at
the person next to them, you'll see that
they're all grey-haired, with a lot of
wrinkles. And if somebody doesn't learn

the songs, they'll be gone.' That's when I
started singing. I was really scared. I
forgot the ballad right in the middle.
They had to tell me where I was, and
prod me a little bit. I managed to get
through it. I was in a nervous sweat. But
while I was sitting there I thought, 'Yeah,
all these people in their 70s and 80s, and
this music is more important to make
this is mine.'
than Led Zeppelin
"It was like I was possessed. I wanted
to

learn

every

ballad

I'd

ever

within three weeks! I'm sure
the

of Dellie

out

hell

and

I

heard

worried

all

of 'em

during that time. It had clicked in my
mind
they were all going to die, and
else
was learning the ballads,
nobody

nobody but me. It had skipped my
mother's generation because of World

II. The boys left to fight, and the
to work in plants. My mother
left
girls
had worked for three years in Mobile,
Alabama, and she was ashamed of being
a hillbilly
they said she talked funny.
So her generation tried to get away from

War

it."

After Sheila graduated
Hill, she began teaching

school

in

from

Mars

elementary

Madison County. She began

going to fiddlers conventions and other
music festivals, taking Melanie with her.
"Dellie thought that taking Melanie to
music festivals was just wonderful,
because she was meeting all these good
people and hearing all this good music.
But my parents were afraid that I might
lose custody of Melanie at any moment!
In the

mountains, it's hard to get away

from that parental control thing, even
now. Eventually I got married again, and
had two little boys."
Besides teaching full time in Madison

County
Suspension

School's

High

Program

and

In-School

being

a

wife

Sheila is an active
performer. She has recorded one tape
and
and

mother,

plans

featured
Asheville

to

do

another,

performer

at

and

this

was

a

year's

Mountain Music and Dance

Festival.
Sheila still lives in Madison County, in
the less remote Big Ivy Community.
Dellie, who celebrated her 90th birthday
in October, still lives in Sodom. "I don't
get back there as much as I should," says

�Sheila. "Since Dellie was
1
have to look at her

in the

hospital,

weighing

106

pounds. She is 90 years old and frail.
When she gets up to walk, she reaches
out and puts her hand on my arm
and
have known Dellie as this big-bodied,
I

Robert

Amberg

robust, laughing person of my child
hood, who was my friend for 30 years.
And she insists that I bring 'those pretty
little boys,' as she calls them. After 15
minutes, they're in all her knick-knacks,
chasing her cats, and she's really unable
to deal with all their energy.'
There was a time when Sheila thought
seriously of leaving her home. A serious
relationship might have taken her to
Alaska. She even flew up there, to see
what it was like. "Alaska was a beautiful
place, and I fell in love with it; but when I
was on the plane home 1 realized I

The Ballads
"The interesting thing about Sodom
the women ended up being the
is,
keepers of the ballads. Now in England,
it's my understanding that the men were
the ones who sang the ballads. Dellie
learned the majority of the ones she
knew from her father. But in Dellie's
generation, the logging companies came
in, along with the railroads, and the men
went and stayed at the logging camps for
two or three weeks at a time. Dellie says
that's when she started singing
when
she was there by herself with the kids.
The women filtered out the racier
ballads, the ones about raping and
pillaging. They were left behind. It's like
Dellie says, every once in a while you like
for the women not to be raped, not to be
stabbed. The ones she was most apt to
learn were the ones where the woman
didn't get the raw deal, and the ones that
make the man look like a fool! I think
Women's Lib must have been going on
even back then. Even in 'Little Mathey
Groves,' Lord Dan'l gets cuckolded. His
wife picks up somebody off the street
and takes him home. In 'Four Nights
Drunk' the man's a fool! The woman has
a lover, but she manages to convince this
old drunk that she's innocent. Also the
ballads that have survived are ones that
have a lot of action. It makes for a better

story.
"Dellie says that a lot of people picture
it that they only sang at quiltings and
things like that. But really, people would
be sitting on the porch in the evenings,

and someone would just break out and
start singing. That must have been one of
the most wonderful things in the world
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

photo

by

couldn't leave my mountains. What if
something was to happen to Dellie? I
wouldn't be able to get back in time! I
guess you could say my heart is rooted
here, about 450 feet deep."

Berzilla and Aunt Zip

no

microphone,

no

audience, just

singing because you wanted to sing."
Sheila knows about 40 ballads, al
though there are still more to learn. Her
great-aunt Berzilla insisted, when she
knew she wouldn't be around much
longer, that Sheila tape her songs. Sheila
wanted to go on learning them in the
traditional way. "I'm not going to live
forever," was Berzilla's response.
"There's no way you're gonna learn all of
them. Buy you a tape recorder."
Sheila still hasn't learned all of Inez's
died in 1981) songs
(Chandler
either, although she has them on tape
too. "Every once in a while I'll get a fire
in my heart and I'll say, 'I'm

gonna learn
these songs. Then I'll plug the tape
recorder up, and I hear Inez sitting there;
all

in my ear I can hear her slapping her leg,
and laughing, and carrying on. It's still

too painful."

When questioned about the age of her
ballads, Sheila says some of them are
older than others, but there's no real way
of dating them. "Some of them you can
tell are real old, like 'Lord Thomas and
Fair

Ellender'

and

'Little

Mathey

because they have lords and
ladies in them. A ballad like 'Pretty Saro'
one of the prettiest I know
has a
verse that says, 'When I first came to this
.' As far as ballads go
country in 1849.
that's a relatively young one. 'Black is the
Color of my True Love's Hair'
there's
one verse in it that says, 'I'll go to the
.' The
Clyde for to mourn and weep.
Clyde (river) is in England, isn't it? That
tells me the ballad is from England, but
at the same time, there's no knowing
how old it really is. Tour Nights Drunk'

Groves,

now there's a version from the British
Isles called 'My Good Man.' So it's an
old one, but the way I learned it there's a
verse that has a zipper on a flour sack. So
that verse is pretty new. But some people
sing it with buttons instead of a zipper.
Then there's ballads like 'Omie Wise'
that was an incident that happened at the
beginning of this century. Cas Wallin
says some of these ballads are over 200
years old. He thinks that's old. But in
actuality, I think some of them are a
thousand years old. I'm sure some of
them date at least back to the thirteen

fourteen hundreds.
'There's one really incredible ballad
that Dellie taught me years ago. Dellie

and

says the name of it is 'My Mother Called
Me when She Were Dying.' It's got all
these wonderful highs and lows, and the
words are really neat. But it's not one I
do on stage. It's one to sing on the porch.
I've learned quite a few from Berzilla that
are the same way. I think as you perform,
you learn what pleases the audiences.
But for people to learn what the ballads
are, they've got to hear them from
beginning to end, whether it's four

verses or eighteen. When I'm perform
ing, I'm singing a lot of the time for
people who have to be educated into
sitting and listening to the words and
most of the time I've got 45 minutes to
it in. Sometimes
I'm right in the
middle of a ballad, and I realize people in
the audience are talking, getting up,
moving around. It's really hard for me.

do

It's not

I start
thinking, 'Oh
am in the middle of 'Little
Groves' and they're starting to

a

panic, but

Lord! Here

Mathey

I

continued on page 31

�THE

whose subtle and complex
clawhammer style has graced several
festivals and County LPs. The institute

Virginia,

also

BANJO

Gerrard

INSTITUTE

for

most unusual and exciting settings
the music, though, was an event that
occurred in middle Tennessee from
November 10 to 12. Over a hectic three
day period 120 students of the fivestring banjo met with some 37
of the instrument —
"instructors"
instructors who were in reality some of
the biggest names in old-time, bluegrass,
minstrel, and even classical banjo styles.
Set in the relaxed atmosphere of Cedars
of Lebanon State Park and sponsored by
that ranged from the National
a cast
Endowment for the Arts to the Gibson
Guitar
Company, the three-day
marathon went under the name of the
Tennessee Banjo Institute, and it created
an entirely new event in the annals of
old-time music.
Cedars of Lebanon State Park, located
halfway between the middle Tennessee
towns of Murfreesboro and Lebanon,
was a symbolically appropriate place to
celebrate the five-string banjo. A few
miles southeast of the mark was the
home of early Opry star Uncle Dave
Macon; a few miles north was the home
of Lee Allen, of the old-time Allen
Brothers, who first recorded "Salty Dog"
back in the 1920s. One county to the
east was the home of Lester Flatt, and to
the west is the town of Madison, home of
luminaries like Earl Scruggs and John
Hartford. The sense of tradition was
strong as banjo players (many of whom
were "students" in name only) from
across the country trooped through the
autumn leaves from cabin to cabin
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

McPeake.

Minstrel-style

Bob

tutoring

and

workshops.

'It's kind of a banjo players' heaven,"
said Dick Tingling, a fisherman from
Alaska who probably came about as far
as any student. "We're getting blisters on
our ears. There are jams here in the
evening until about three in the morning.
Then our classes start in at eight."

Another student, Tom Lyons, a
computer expert from Minnesota,
echoed this enthusiasm. "We're playing

with the current top banjo players in the
world. And they're great, so open and

helpful."
Old-time playing styles were among
the best represented at the institute.
Traditional stars included Clyde
Davenport, the Kentucky pupil of the
legendary Burnett and Rutherford; his
relative Clyde Troxell, whose music has
been featured on the recent County
Traditional Music from the
Cumberland Plateau; Omer Forster, the
unusual two-finger stylist from west
Tennessee whose tune "Flowery Girls"
has become popular with many young
pickers; Odell Thompson, the black
banjoist from the Piedmont country
whose music with his two brothers Nate
and Joe reflects one of the last examples
of black string band music; Will Keys,
from Washington County, Tennessee,
whose distinctive, driving two-finger
style was one of the surprise highlights of
the entire three days; Carlie Marion, a
stellar exemplar of the clawhammer style
from Elkin, North Carolina; Andy
Cahan, a master of several traditional
clawhammer and finger-picking styles;
and Matokie Slaughter, from Pulaski,
record

set

a

expertise on nineteenth-

considerable

attending

Winans,

"classical" banjo and member of the
driving old-time Arkansas band, the
Skirtlifters; and Dan Sinclair, a devotee
of Fred Van Eps and stellar ragtime
performer. Bob Carlin also shared his

by

sessions

experts

well-known
scholar whose recent New World LP
recreated an authentic minstrel band;
Clark Buehling, a respected student of

Charles Wolfe

Alice

live old-time music
the community
from
all
the
way
range
dance to the occasional club. One of the

like John

included

Matokie Slaughter from Pulaski, Va., 1985

for

known

nationally

Hartford, Mike
Seeger, ArtRosenbaum, and Bob Car lin,
as well as Uncle Dave Macon stylist and
Haw" veteran
"Hee
Troy.
Leroy
Bluegrass faculty members included
Distinguished Professor Snuffy Jenkins
and Professors Bill Keith, Eddie Adcock,
Doug Dillard, Allen Munde, Tony
Trischka, Peter Wernick, and Curtis

TENNESSEE

The venues

featured

performers

century playing styles.
Students attended
topics

on
workshops
like Round Peak Clawhammer,

Melodic

Clawhammer,

2-Finger

Traditional, Banjo Novelty, Old-Time
Tuning, Uncle Dave, Fretless Banjo, and
One-Man Shows. Lectures were offered
on bluegrass social and music structures,
the physical development of the banjo
market, and early Grayson County
banjoist Manly Reece. The institute

headquarters

building

offered

an

instrument exchange, a record booth
(manned by Larry McBride of Marimac
Recordings), an instrument repair table
(manned by Marty Lanham), and a
media station that showed a variety of
vintage videotapes loaned to the institute
by various collectors.
Perhaps the most exciting (and most

visible) part of the institute was a free
public concert featuring most of the
dubbed "Banjo
was
This
faculty.

Meltdown"

and

held

was

in

an

auditorium at nearby Middle Tennessee
State University. It might well have been

the biggest gathering of banjo players in
history, especially considering the
variety of styles represented. "Y ou could

compare

it

to

Woodstock," commented

master of ceremonies Jay Orr. For over
four hours, a capacity audience of over a
thousand watched a series of sets built
around minstrel, classical, ragtime, oldtime, bluegrass, and progressive banjo
styles.
Backstage was a wild scene of jamming
and visiting and confusion over who
it all

worked

creation

of the

would play what. Somehow
out.

The inspiration

and

continued on page 21

�Marimac
"Deep

Recordings
old-time music"

in

$7.00

4002
4003
4004

The Dixie Darlin's: elements of folk, pop, and folk/rock
CANDY FROM STRANGERS
Merce Ridgway: regional music from the Pine Barrens
SONGS OF THE JERSEY PINES AND SHORE
WHERE THE CRICKETS FIDDLE
Jim Albertson: songs for kids, grown-ups and other wildlife
The Barbara Beeman Band: vintage pop, folk/rock, blues-- Ruth Etting influenced vocals
MOVING DAY
Ken Haferman &amp; Rob Hunter: spans the '60s folk revival-- Kenny Kosek on fiddle
HOTEL PLACENTA

8000

THROW

The Otis Brothers: Pat Conte, Bob Guida, Louis Kromm-- sanctified, blues
YOUR TIME AWAY
.John Cephas &amp; Phil Wiggins: great vocals, solid guitar, hot harmonica-- acoustic blues
.The Otis Brothers: Pat &amp; Bob back with more blues recreations
IN THE LAND OF CORN AND WINE
Bill Ellis: new face in the blues-revival scene-- goes to the heart of country blues
RIGHTEOUS BLUES
WALKING BLUES
John Cephas &amp; Phil Wiggins: Handy Award winning bluesmen-- all new program
CRYIN' WON'T MAKE ME STAY
Bob Guida: electric and acoustic blues featuring Bob's strong vocals

7.00

8001

LET

4000
4001

8002
8003
8004
8005
9000
9001

9002
9003
9004
9005
9006
9007
9008
9009
9010
9011

9012
9013
9014
9015
9016
9017
9018
9019
9020
9021

9100
9101

9104
9105

9104-05
9106
9108
9109
9110
9111

IT

ROLL!

7.00

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

Shoofly: highlights Dan's great fiddling and banjo playing
Conte: recreations of classic blues and old time recordings
Half Shaved: Bill Garbus, Bob Bell, Larry MacBride, Margaret Ann Martin
Philadelphia old-time scene of the early 1980s: party atmosphere
Steve Garcia with Matt Levine: 1930s style country-- upbeat banjo
GOIN' DOWN THE COUNTRY
Uncle Willie &amp; the Brandy Snifters: the old-time spirit lives!
GOING NOWHERE FAST
WHEN THE YANKEES CAME DOWN
Major Contay &amp; the Canebrake Rattlers: live performances
Bob Bovee &amp; Gail Heil: nice vocal duets, great old country songs
BEHIND THE TIMES
STILL LAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS
Lazy Aces String Band: high level playing and singing
OLD TIME FRIENDS
Ray Alden with 34 of his old-time friends-- surveys today's scene
IN THE HILLS OF HOME
Raymond Smith &amp; Bob Cowan-- an Oklahoma community's music
Charlie Walden: waltzs &amp; hornpipes, as well as reels
TRADITIONAL FIDDLE MUSIC OF MISSOURI
Fish Family Dance Band: contra dance music with zest and drive
FLUKE HITS
FARMER'S FROLIC
Ross County Farmers: Lonnie Seymour's unique Ohio fiddle tunes are featured
CATALOG
A SOUTHERN
Joe LaRose: wonderful adaptations of the old-time sound
.Carol Elizabeth Jones, Stefan Senders, Rafe Stefanini: great vocals, hot instrumental
THE WILDCATS
BANDS
MIND
Andy Cahan: multi-tracked performances of tunes and songs
Vesta Johnson: tunes from Missouri-- some familiar, some rare
DOWN HOME RAG
GOING ACROSS THE RIVER TO HEAR MY BANJO RING. .Carlie Marion, Andy Cahan: banjo-fiddle duets
Bob Bovee: cowboy songs Bob has learned from family and friends
COME ALL YOU WADDIES
TIMELY OLD TUNES FROM ILL-MO AND BEYOND
Geoff Seitz, Curtis Buckhannon, Jim Nelson
EVOLUTION GIRL
Double Decker Stringband: Craig Johnson, Bruce Hutton, John Beam

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.50
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.50
7.50
7.00

old-time gospel sides from the Golden Age

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

FORKED DEER
SONGS THAT SCARE
LOVE THEM DUCKS
TUESDAY NITE LIVE

JOYFUL NOISE,
A JOYFUL
NOISE,
THE COLD-WATER
THE COLD-WATER
THE COLD-WATER
A

Gellert

Dan

VOL.
VOL.

and

Pat

ME

1

more

string bands, duets, shape note, and solo gospel sides
Golden Age recordings of moonshine and temperance songs
PLEDGE, VOL.
more moonshine and temperance-- pro and con
PLEDGE, VOL. 2
PLEDGE
annotations by W.K. McNeil 16 pages of facts and info
(booklet)
MAKE ME A COWBOY AGAIN FOR A DAY
songs of the West from Golden Age sides
CHEVROLET SIX
Oscar Ford: all his known sides-- with McMichen, Stokes, Puckett, Grace
war songs (Civil-W.W.I) from Golden Age sides bands, duets, solos
JOHNNY'S GONE TO WAR
IT'LL NEVER HAPPEN AGAIN
first in a series of old-time string band compilations from Golden Age
GOIN' UP TOWN.,
more string bands-- Cherokee Ramblers, Georgia Crackers, Grinnel Giggers, Cofer Bros
AGIN THE

2

quartets,

1

home-cut and wire recordings

9200

UP

9600

FEAST HERE TONIGHT!

C-0I
C-02
C-03
C-04
C-05
C-06
C-07
C-08

COWBOY TOUR
1935 GRAND CANYON
VOLO BOGTROTTERS
STAND BAYOU
DUETO CHUBASCO

Keep

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

MOUNTAIN

Everett Pitt-- N.J.

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

1.50

7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00
7.00

1940s

7.50

with "inovations

7.00

Council for Traditional Arts
COWBOY BAND
live fiftieth anniversary concert in 1985
Chicago area old time band features Illinois &amp; Indiana fiddle tunes
Cajun dance music and song from popular Cleveland band
Linda O'Hagan, Peter McCracken: Mexican songs, nice duet singing
IN GOOD
COMPANY
Allen Street String Band: includes tunes from Illinois and some nice originals
THE PRIDE OF GLENCOE
Lotus Dickey: a great singer, fiddler from Indiana, with friends
MOUNTAIN MUSIC
The Kimbies: featuring Taylor Kimble's fiddling backed by the family's great sound

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
8.00

Rabbit

in

THE
THE
THE

asking for

MARINAC

descriptions

and

cassettes

a

Log
from

at your

Gorman,

(Skip

the

tour presented

local dealer,

full listings of all selections
PRICES

ALL

ARE

POST

P.O.

PAID

or

IN

Box 5

Little Ferry, NJ
U.S.A.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Rich Starkey):
by

the

of

older

write for our catalog

and

THE

artists

U.S.A.

07643

on

bluegrass,

Nat'I.

each

which

cassette.

contains

�own Governor Roy Romer has declared
square dancing and fiddle music to be

HERE

Music

2

Teri

has

its

associations
dances on

like

the
downs.

and

Colorado

ranks 47th in per capita
the arts, yet it is home to
for
funding
such world-class music events as the

Aspen Music Festival and the Teluride

Festivals.
Jazz/Bluegrass
scenery seems to serve

Its
as

a

majestic
magnet in

attracting artists, even if it may lack the
strength to hold them all here.
There were traditional western square
dances held in grange halls till about the
early '60s. Today, much of the livemusic square and contra dancing is done
in these same halls.
Most old-time music here gets played
in connection with the area's traditional
dancing. To me this seems perfectly
natural. The Colorado Area Friends of

Old

Time

Music

(CFOOTMAD)

is

a

also

dances that are part of the
Colorado heritage. There are senior
fiddlers and dance callers who have pro
vided a wealth of information on the old
days of the Colorado dances, both on the
ranch and in the city. There is an inter
esting mix of tunes and dances, found

Rasmusson

ups

and
and

with southern influences, Scottish flair,
and Spanish color. Many of the grange

Colorado,

in

geography,

&amp;

play

Saur on fiddle and piano (plus guests).

things.

party

Colorado
Eric Levin

Old-time squares and contras are in Ft.
Collins the first Saturday of each month.
Advanced contras are on the second

his

of

Midwestern dance styles,
include cowboy, Hispanic,

THERE

by

CFOOTMAD dances are a blend of New
England, English, Canadian, and

some

&amp;

favorite

Dance

and
member

of the

also dances held in the Fort Collins City
Park with Friends of Traditional Dance.

in
a

Colorado used to hold

regular basis and were first

and
Scottish
by
English
organized
ranchers. Why, even the cowboy danced
the "White Cockade" country dance as
well as a Spanish-style polka. Black
smiths were known to be dance callers
and made up some pattern calls that
describe their profession and life on the
ranch. There was always live music until
sometime in the 1950s, when the
portable record player and single mike
stand was seen on the stage instead of the

band.

CFOOTMAD brought back the livemusic

dances

on

Colorado. Dances

a

regular

basis

for

are held the first and

third Fridays of each month at an old
grange hall, 95th and Isabelle Rd. (east of
Boulder), and the second and fourth

Fridays at Daniel's Community Center,
13th and Simms in Lakewood (part of
Phone Donna
Denver
the
area).
McGinnis at 303-758-4046. There are

Saturday with Eric Levine and Rodney

Phone Randy Lumb at 303-493-8947
for
or Eric Levine at 303-493-6341

information.
The music varies from set bands, to

semi-set bands, to open stage. Banjoist

Ray Chatfield was here most of the
winter, and together with fiddlers Dave
Brown, Anita Dolan, and Eric Levine,
with Mike Woods on banjo and Steve
Burnside on guitar, provided music for
the Boulder dances. Teri Rasmusson,
who runs this dance as well as many
other events, is usually found playing
niano.

audiences have enjoyed a
of concert/dances with local
performers as well as nationally known
artists. Many touring musicians and
on the
dancers have commented
Colorado

number

hospitality and success they experienced
while visiting and performing out here.
The local old-time bands that play for
the dances on

a

regular basis are great.

and
Some fiddlers,
players,
guitar
banjoists have played and even placed at
the Old-Time Fiddlers Convention in
Galax, Virginia. Ray Chatfield, now

living
force

in
in

Galax, Virginia, was

a

driving

the early CFOOTMAD dances.

Rose Sinclair, now in Philadelphia and
performing with the Heartbeats, got her
start calling and playing for dances at the
Left Hand Grange Hall in Niwot,

Dance
twomonth calendar listing these dances and
most relevant music events. For its
newsletter, Attic Windows, write Mark
national

Country

and

Song

Society. CFOOTMAD puts out

Turbin,

5117

Williams

a

Trail

Fork

#202, Boulder, CO 80301.

Since pioneer days, dances have been
in helping people express the
was
vital for survival in early
that
spirit
America, and which continues to be vital
life today.
for a rich and peaceful
Travelers today will be quite pleased to

important

discover that, yes, there
old-time dance scene

Mississippi
California.

and
Dance

is a

slightly
in

live-music,

west
the

of

the

east
great

of

Wild

West has undergone some changes since
this country was first settled, but never

theless we are dancing! CFOOTMAD is
heading into its 10th year with a recent

Ken

Horwege

celebration by callers, musicians,
volunteers, and dancers past and
present. CFOOTMAD forges a western
link to the rest of the live-music dances

going around

the

country. Colorado's

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Boulder-area dance

at

grange hall,

1988

�Colorado. She wrote her action-packed
square dance for the eruption of Mt. St.
Helens while living in Colorado.

Of course the dances serve as a public
focal point for the music, but there is
old-time music apart from this; you just
have to know where to look. Bluegrass
music is easier to find in Colorado than
old-time music. Hot Rize from Boulder
and Niwot appear with their pals Red
Knuckles and the T rail Blazers (when the
Blazers can make the drive down from

Wyoming, Montana).

from the front range area of the
Mountains are Bonnie Carol,
Sense, Doug Berch, Tim and
O'Brien, Bonnie Phipps, a group
of women called the Mother Folkers (the
most carefully pronounced name in
show business today), and the legendary

Also
Rocky
Horse
Molly

Washboard Chaz.
Ralph's Top Service
features

and

a

in

Restaurant

one

has

The James

evening.

Denver

in

bluegrass jam twice a month,
Fort Collins, Avogadro's
every

Tuesday

Boulder

in

has

a

fine Irish jam session on Tuesdays, at
which you might hear many old-time
tunes played along with the more
traditional Irish fare. Wednesday
evenings there is a session of Celtic

music

are

at
Heatly's Tea
Downing St. Old-time
sometimes held in local

is a

folk club and music school

Denver

in

House, 226
sessions
homes.

There

called

the

S.

Swallow

Hill

Association

in

St., Denver
Hill offers

(303-777-1003).

Denver

at

1905

Music

S.

Pearl

Swallow

concert series and
a varied
music lessons. They have featured artists
such as J ean Redpath, Bill Stains, and the
Battle Field Band, as well as local artists.
They are a good contact for touring
performers. Swallow Hill also publishes
a newsletter.
There are several new organizations

that have sprung up over the last few
years that are now busy planning their
winter bluegrass events and summer oldDenver's 13th
time fiddle contests.
annual Storytelling Convention will be

held

in

March,

featuring

special guest

Gail Haley and others (303-556-2717).
Each year square dancers gather in
Colorado in honor of the famed caller
and collector of dances, Lloyd Shaw. His
book, Cowboy Dances, written in the
1930s, tells the tale of dancers arriving
on the great plains from almost every
state in the Union.

No mention of Colorado's
dance/ music events would be complete

our "Moon
two
or
three times a
held
Festivals,"
year in the old mining town of Gold Hill,

without

mentioning

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

above Boulder. There is a Harvest, a
Planters, and an occasional Frozen Moon
festival. Started in 1979 by old-time
banjoist Dan Wiengast and guitarist
Alan Ehrlich, the festivals have been
getting bigger every year. They started
out quite eclectic,
featuring mostly
music, and have since evolved (or
devolved, depending on your point of
view) into more of a dance event. There
still, however, a good and growing
amount of old-time music. It is usually a
three-day event, with accommodations,
great food, and workshops. Contact
Donna Scott, 2341 Eudora St., Denver,
is

CO 80207, (303-444-7406).
CFOOTMAD would like to invite
and
callers,
traveling
performers,
dancers to add Colorado to their

itineraries.
Rasmusson

80544

Please
at

contact

(303-652-3306),

McGinnis

Teri

P.O. Box 537, Niwot, CO
at

or

Donna

303-758-4046

for

information and booking arrangements.
We hope that folks visiting Colorado
will be sure to take in some of our
traditional music along with our
mountains.

�Gerarra
Alice

Odell Thompson

"Filipino Baby." A banjo orchestra on the
porch might include Jeff

screened-in

Furman, Debbie Fried, Rob Morrison
and Barbara Groh. Carl Jones and
Andy Cahan might be working up a new

of traditional children's music or
talking about mixing a tape for a local
set

continued

on

page

2

1

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�"There are

a lot

of good fiddlers and

a lot

of bad ones. But if one gets to where he thinks
he's better than the other one, why he's
wrong. There's always somebody gonna
cover up on him. Play for yourself, and if a
fellow don't like it, just let him walk off."
Otis Burris

OTIS BURRIS

Fiddling around the Galax, Virginia,
area by those who learned to play prior
to the 1920s had a very specific sound
and character. "The old Galax musicians
struck a remarkable balance between the
and
the complex.
.many
simple

seemingly

melodies

simple

were

through evocative, weaving
strings of notes and subtle changes in
bow direction; ends (and beginnings) of
phases are clearly punctuated Tunes
played by fiddlers of this era have a
feeling of completeness, as though they
could be played unaccompanied without
sounding barren" (the "Old-Time Way"
booklet by Alice Gerrard and Andy
Cahan, Heritage Records, 1986). The
style can be heard in the playing of local
fiddlers like Emmett Lundy, Kahle
Brewer, Parlie Parsons, Luther Davis,
and Charlie Higgins, among others.
This older Galax sound fascinates me
because of its beauty, and because it
yet
belongs to the past and to tradition

expressed

the same time it is timeless. It suggests
way of life and sense of identity that we,
in our restlessness and uprootedness,
at
a

sometimes long for.
I

am also drawn

to the early

sounds of bluegrass
Monroe, the Stanley

music
Brothers.

soulful
Bill

And
when I heard Otis Burris play the fiddle,
and as I came to listen more to the old
Galax fiddle styles, I was struck by how
much of the old regional style was in
Otis's fiddling, and yet how strongly he
was
identified with the emerging
"bluegrass in overdrive" sound of the
early to mid-1960s. Otis's music reflects

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Linda

regionally and in areas outside the south
where southerners migrated in large
numbers. Times had changed radically,
and Otis joined other musicians of the
period in the search for something
familiar but which spoke to them in the
context of those changes.
Otis was born in 1917 and raised in
the beautiful mountain area around Elk
Creek in western Grayson County,
Virginia, in a large family of three sisters
and five brothers. His father, James, and
his mother,
Nonnie May (Roberts),
farmed and were both musicians. There
was a lot of music on both sides of the
family. Otis recalls:

Higginbotham

a transition period between old-time and
a fascinating period
bluegrass music
in
traditional musical history, both

1987

Galax Breakdown Fiddler
by

Alice Gerrard

�"Grandmother Burris, she had one of
these old pedal organs. I've seen Uncle

Paul pedal that organ with them old big
four-buckle overshoes on. I don't see
how he got his feet in there. My aunt
Annie, she could chord any tune on the
organ.
there

They'd play for flatfoot dances

at the house, and she backed my
Jaddy up. Uncle Bill Bourne played the
banjo. He made the banjo himself, killed
.and
a big groundhog, tanned that hide.

you had to be right up at
damp you couldn't hear

when it got
He'd hold it

it, or
it.

over an old lamp and let the heat get to
the head till it dried out. He was an old

two-finger type. There
wasn't no such a thing as a pick at that
time. They done it all with their natural
fingers.
"My daddy was a fiddle player, and my
mother, she played some hymns on the
fiddle. That's all she played, but she
played those good. My daddy, he'd get
up many of a morning and build the
fires. Then he'd get his fiddle out and
he'd go to playing. After he played what
he wanted to play he'd go feed and
mother'd get breakfast.
"Daddy retuned the fiddle; he'd call it
two high
the "Cripple Creek" key
basses. He played many of a tune with
me standing there keeping time with
claw-hammer,

broomcorn

straws

just

beat

the

strings easy, you know. And I finally got
to where I'd split a chair bottom, hickory
splits, and sand them off and use them
because they were limber, and they
wouldn't hurt the fiddle. When daddy
was on the fine strings
and that just made it

I

was on the bass,

sound like there
instruments.
different
were two
"Daddy played 'Waves on the Ocean'

and

Tineywoods

Girl.'

He

played

Girl' out of this world. I
play that but I've just about

'Pineywoods
used to

forgotten, and I'll tell you why. These
musicians anymore, they want
something to fly. Well, you can't fly with
tune like that. It's got a different
a
rhythm to it, and a different pitch alto

gether around. It's a tune that wants to
be noted out. And Daddy would do that.
"Dad didn't want me fooling with his
fiddle, but if I could slip and get it when

gone, I would, and I'd get around
and play a little. He was the biggest in
fluence because I was there all the time,
and his tunes naturally fell to me. And
there was old man Thomas Adams. He
was a farmer and he could play T winkle
Little Star' the best I've ever listened at. I
learned that tune from him. My daddy
sold his fiddle and when he sold it, Lord,
I
cried. I was around 12 or 15, and I
would go down to Mr. Adams and he let
me play his once in a while, tried to learn
he was

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

me some

different things.

I

went down

there many of a time on a rainy day when
it rained us out on the farm, to listen to
Mr. Adams play that fiddle. I thought
old man Adams was a better fiddler than
my daddy. Daddy done a lot of shuffling
with the bow. He said that's where part
of the notes come from. But old man

Adams used his fingers a-notin'. Most of
the old-timers hardly ever used but four

inches of bow. If they were to see
a long bow they'd say it
was popular stuff. And I got into running
a long bow. I used to be pretty good the
way my daddy was, shuffling the bow,
but it seemed like I got to where I could
note real good and I just went to using a
end to end if you can do
straight bow

or five

somebody use

it."
It is

interesting that to Otis, the term

or "straight bow" means
"long
using the bow from end to end, getting
many notes with the left hand on one
bow stroke
generally a more modern
Emmett
Lundy (according to
technique.
his son, Kelly) and Kahle Brewer, both
of the old school of Galax fiddling,
defined "long bow" as the long bow
stroke that delineated the beginnings of
phrases and gave the old style one of its
most significant characteristics. Other
wise, the old style used many more small
bow strokes with a lilting rhythm, a
"swing," as Kahle Brewer calls it. This
may be the shuffle that Otis refers to
not the shuffle as popularly associated
with, for example, Tommy Jackson. It is
interesting that Thomas Adams, about
the same age as Otis's father, used the
more modern technique, and that Otis
was drawn to this much as he was later
drawn to Arthur Smith's fiddling.
In 1926, when Otis was nine, he
attended his first fiddlers convention at
courthouse in
the Independence
Independence, Virginia.
"My daddy took me, and old man
Thomas Adams was there, and he got the
ribbon that night. There was a Poole
there from Briarpatch Mountain, and he

bow"

played a tune called
Volunteers.' My daddy,

'Kentucky

he

tried

and

tried to play that, and one night he was
laying in the bed asleep, and he dreamed
that tune. And got up and lit the old
lamp, and mama said, 'Have you gone
crazy?' And he said, TJo, I want to show
you something.' And he picked up that

fiddle

and

went to playing

'Kentucky

Volunteers.'"

Otis has always had a reputation as a
flatfoot dancer. He continued to
dance until he was about 47 or 48,

fine

winning

ribbons

year

after

year

fiddlers conventions.
"My daddy was good dancer and

it

at

just

ran in our family. I was a flattooter and i
danced all over the country. My daddy
and a bunch of them played for sales and

danced at them barefooted. Back then
shoes were hard to get, and on the 8th of
May you started going barefooted.
I

Fiddlers
the
"At
Independence
Convention my daddy bought me a pair

of sandals to dance in. I was embarrassed
and didn't want to dance, but he had
bought me that pair of shoes and I knew I
had to do something. If I didn't, why I'd
he didn't
pay for it when I got home
I was
And
for
shoes
nothing.
get the

embarrassed so bad I danced a-cryin'.
"They didn't dance back then like the;
do now, and they didn't dance so fast as
they do now. They didn't have that
they danced with
kicking in there
their feet, and they just might' nigh
noted it out. I could dance the notes with
my feet, but now this going around and
throwing one leg up and skipping across,
that isn't flatfoot dancing. Old man
now he was a foot
Emmett Smith
dancer. I mean, you could just hear him
make the notes with his feet. He danced
in those old-timey button shoes, and
what I mean, he tickled the floor. Just
looking at his body dancing, why, he
wasn't slinging his body all over, and he
had just as steady a head as we're sitting
here, but that smile was out there and
them legs were tickling the floor. Now
you don't see that no more. That was the
way I flatfooted. I used my legs."
Otis helped his father on the farm,
worked at a sawmill, and had some
schooling. In about 1934, when he was
about 17, the family moved to another
farm in the Carson ville community west
of Galax. Otis was married for the first
time at 18, had two children, and
worked both at sawmill work and in the
furniture factories around Galax. He was
to marry twice more, the last time to
Cora Lee Boyer in 1964.
He continued to play the fiddle and
was very influenced by a new sound he
was hearing via the new radios, a sound
that excited him and stirred his

imagination.
In 1932, when Fiddling Arthur Smith

first played on the Grand Ole Opry Otis

Smith's extensive touring prior
throughout the small
Appalachian mountain towns with Sam
and Kirk McGee and the Delmore

was

15.

to

1938

Brothers,

and his recordings

with these

musicians, were to affect the fiddling in
these areas enormously. Otis was drawn
to the sound of Fiddling Arthur Smith
the hard-driving, fast, improvisa-

as were
tional, and often bluesy style
many other young fiddlers at this time.
"TTie first time I ever listened to

�Arthur Smith was on the Grand Ole
Opry He was playing with Sam and Kirk
McGee, and there was something there I
fell for. My ears just took it. I think he
was a great fiddler. He had great, long
fingers, and he could reach all over a
fiddle, and he had some great notes with
him, and a good bow too. It sounded
different, and just put a new tune in your
head. There was a swing he had that just
hit me and it still does. You got tired of
these old. .tunes that I'd been used to.
"He was at the schoolhouse one time
in Galax with Uncle Dave (Macon) and
Sam and Kirk McGee, and I walked
about seven miles to see him. His fiddle

looked like

it had been glued all over; I
guess he'd played it in a many of a rain,
but what was in that thing! I went back in
the room where they were tuning and
talked to him just a minute. That was the
only time I ever got to say 'howdy' to

Arthur Smith."

'different,'

was

to define

never

but

Rainwater,

really

beyond calling it
attempted
.Howdy Forrester,
'country fiddling'.
who both watched and listened to Smith
it

superb critical sense, says: 'The
I
remember is that Arthur did
thing
more with his fingering than with the
bow.'"
It has often been said by the older
fiddlers in the area that a certain fiddler
would "get a lot of notes with the bow,"
with

a

and this was a widespread characteristic
of the old style of fiddling. In observing
the older fiddlers, and in listening to

recordings of them,

it

is

clear that this

does not mean simply one note to one

but
rather many
bow
stroke,
combinations and uses of the bow:

the Navy and was stationed in the
Philippines, often playing aboard ship
for the officers and crew, singing songs

and playing tunes with a guitar player
from Mt. Airy, N.C. He was put in the
orchestra for 14 weeks. "They set up
sheet music in front of me and I didn't
know a note in the book and still don't.
sat there in the middle and just sawed

I

'em. I made out like I was
the
music but I was a-goin' by
reading
ear.
After his discharge from the Navy,

Charles

Wolfe

noted

his

book,
Tennessee Strings, that a "number of
modern fiddling scholars give Smith
credit for popularizing the 'long bow'

technique

throughout

in

the

South, and

even today, Arthur Smith's tunes and
Arthur Smith's style can be heard at
the
Southeast.
contests throughout
Smith's fiddling influence, combined
with Sam's guitar prowess, made the
Dixieliners one of the most important

string bands in country

of
Knoxville 1977).

(University

music history"

Tennessee

Press,

And in the notes to "Fiddlin' Arthur
Smith &amp; His Dixieliners" (County 546
and 547), Wolfe and Barry Poss said,
"Smith is often faster, more aggressive,
more daring than many.
.shapers of
modern fiddling. Arthur knew his style
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

with

Otis returned to Galax. There he played
in several bands, most notably the Blue
Ridge Buddies, with Kelly Lundy, Larry
Richardson, Ernest Joines, and Ivery
Melton; and with the Dean Brothers,
Ernest and Henry, two guitar players and
singers. It was when he started playing
with the Blue Ridge Buddies that he
stopped retaining his fiddle as he had
been used to doing.
"At one time I tuned the fiddle up; I
played with high basses for years, but
when I went to playing in a band they
weren't tuning and running keys up, so I
didn't."
The period after World War II and on
into the 1950s was a time of much
musical foment. Lester Flatt and Earl
Scruggs had joined Bill Monroe in 1945,
and along with Chubby Wise and Cedric

crystalized

the

known

become

sound that
as

bluegrass

music.

In 1959, academician and folk music
collector Alan Lomax recorded the
Mountain Ramblers as part of a series on
Atlantic Records. From Galax, the band
featured James Lindsey on mandolin,
Eldridge Montgomery on guitar and
tenor vocals, Thurman Pugh on bass and

Charles Hawks on banjo,
Cullen Galyean on fiddle. This
recording, now out of print, remains a
classic example of the early mountain
bluegrass genre.
In talking with Otis, James Lindsey,
lead vocals,
and

Kelly

getting more than one note by varying
the pressure of the bow while it is going
in one direction so that it sounds like
separate bow strokes; dipping the bow
across the strings to pick up more than
one note; and other subtle ways of using
the bow. But it rarely seems to include
the style of bowing that utilizes getting
many notes with the left hand on one
bow stroke. "Doing more with the
fingering than with the bow" is a more
modern style and one that Otis absorbed
into his playing while retaining many
elements of the old Galax bowing style.
During World War II Otis served in

along

was

Lundy,*

and

Eldridge

their
feelings about this new music that was
taking hold of their imaginations as they
were in their late teens to early thirties.
James: "I can remember when I first
started hearing bluegrass music on the
radio.
"It was a completely different sound
when Bill Monroe came to the Opry. We
had got an old battery radio and saved
the batteries for Saturday night and the
Grand Ole Opry, and I'd get my mother
and daddy to let me stay up till 1 1:15 to
hear Bill. His theme was 'Try the Walrite
Way.' He had Art Wooten and Clyde
Moody, and he didn't use a banjo then.
His singing was what struck me. Back in
those days there wasn't much high
singing. Bill had the first really high tenor

Montgomery,

they

expressed

like that that was sung. I'd never heard
anything like it, the high harmony, and I
thought it was beautiful. And they were
smoother and slicker and more
professional sounding than other groups
at the time, which
would draw your
attention, and he did songs we'd never
heard before. Then, when Lester Flatt
and
Earl
Scruggs joined him, that
marked a big change in the sound of his
music
that was the starting of the
bluegrass sound. And the last thing that
really tied the bluegrass sound to it was
the mandolin slap that Bill developed
an off-beat rhythm with the other music."
Kelly: "I loved it. I was more or less at
that age when I needed to change from

*Kelly Lundy is the son of Emmett
Lundy, whose recording, "Emmett W.

Lundy, Fiddle Tunes from Grayson County,
Virginia, represents some of the best of
the classic Galax sound in fiddling and

string-band music. Kelly played guitar
and

1941.

sang

on

this

recording,

made

in

�music to the newer type that
Of
course, 1 still loved that old-time music, I
was raised up and played it, but I wanted
to progress a little bit more and to kind
of keep up with the times I guess. It was a
faster type of music, and to me it was a
little more like I wanted to do."
Otis: "We got those old battery radios
and we got to listening to the Grand Ole
Opry. They were playing tunes on there
that we'd never heard, and it seemed like
I couldn't
tunes
I had an ear for those
the
field
in
out
I'd
be
them.
maybe
forget
hoeing corn, pickin' along, and the first
thing I knew, why the words or something'd come along, and I'd go back

the

old

came in. Our ages were ready for that.

all the way in and try to
play it. The music had more of a push to
it, and the more you played it the more
you wanted to. You didn't wear just one
tune out, you'd try to find another one,
and the more you found, the more you
wanted to play. It had a sound that just
hit. And it wasn't only me, it just hit
everybody. I reckon it was what I was

home humming

come from
know. The
dancing,
was
of
altogether
bluegrass
rhythm
different, and I had it in my feet just the

looking
flatfoot

for.

If

it

I

didn't
don't

same as they had it.
"My father said, 'Well,

just by ear, and what you

James

the old did

Lindsey

I just don't see
how you do it, it's so much faster, and
how you get the notes you get.' I says,
'Well, it seems to me it comes just like

like.'

stuff."
Eldridge Montgomery, from Carroll
County, Virginia, grew up with old-time
remembers being most
and
music
confused by the concept of taking
instrumental breaks, something that was
entirely new to him.
In 1949, Otis, along with many others
from southwestern V irginia, went north

Washington Baltimore -southern
Pennsylvania area to work. Through
to the

Ernest Dean, who had already gone
north, Otis got a job at the Edgewood
Arsenal near Bel Air, Maryland.
Otis stayed in the area about three
years, living and working at various jobs.
He continued to play music with people
like Porter Church and Bob Goff, and
with other transplants from his home
area such as the Dean Brothers and
Sonny Miller, among others. He playea
often at the country music parks that
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

"The old people enjoyed it in a way;
they thought it was a little bit speedy, but
they went along with it and some tried to
play it, and some didn't. They'd say,
There ain't no tune there.' It was fast,
and a lot of them had played so slow
along till they just couldn't get that fast

Being

Otis Burris

Personal
Reminiscence
A

by
I

a

whale of

denizen of Fort Bragg,

I

Mountain Ramblers at the
infrequent fiddlers conventions.
My first was at Cool Spring, N.C.,
where I, the shy Californian, was
happy to find that you could walk
the

Hank Bradley

owe Otis Burris

a

had little spare time, so was limited
to weekend contacts with Otis and

a

lot,

so will try to tell the truth, shame
the Devil, and still not get any of us

too much trouble. In those days
of 1964 and '65 I was still new to
the fiddle and to his way of playing
it, so could not then (and certainly
not now) give a precise and poetic
descriDtion of exactly how it went
in

and
Anyway, there are
why.
superb records and tapes from
those days. Photographs too. I'll
have to stick to my own
experiences of trying to learn it for
myself.

right up to Otis and James Lindsey
and Charles Hawks and talk with
these gods (I'd heard the Lomax

recordings

of

the

Mountain

Ramblers on Atlantic, and anyone
on

a

record those days was

at

least

canonized), and they would smile
and converse and crack jokes just
like real people! They were tickled
that a stranger from California
would want to try on their music,
and made encouraging noises at my
desperate attempts. So Otis
became my principal model and
the Ramblers the favorite band.

�flourished in the area: Whippoorwill
Sunset Park,
Lake, Watermelon Park

and New
River Ranch.
(Neil
Rosenberg's book, B luegrass a History,*
is an interesting and informative source
that provides a more complete picture of
what was happening in the BaltimoreWashington area at this time.)

anybody played as good a fiddle, or as
solid a fiddle
breakdown, breakneck
like Otis did, and we all
fiddling
worked together real hard. Eldridge
a
and
played
good solid rhythm,

Thurman got to double-timing his bass:
Charles' banjo playing was solid
nobody was worried about whether he
was heard or not, we played for the band.
We didn't take breaks, we just played

Gerrard

Otis returned to Galax in 1952 and in
1962 he joined the Mountain Ramblers.
Thus began a musical relationship that
was to define both the Ramblers' and
Otis's sound, settings standard by which
many others would measure and be
measured. According to James Lindsey:
1 d
heard him a few times, and after
he came back from up north, he was
downtown and we were
boarding
playing on the radio station in Hillsville.
We'd had to let our other fiddle player
go, so we were without a fiddle player.
We'd started to Hillsville and we saw
Otis come out of the boarding house. 1
hollered at him and asked him if he
wanted to go with us. He went and got
his fiddle,
and that started it. We
practiced a couple of nights a week, and
we got pretty darn good. We were
learning together; we had a good, solid
band already, and we got more solid
played with,

I

Alice

behind him than any band he'd ever
guess. And we never had

New
River Ranch,
late
1950s;
w/guitar; Mack Magaha w/fiddle

(*can be obtained through County Sales,
P.O. Box igi, Floyd, VA. 24091)

This was like rooting for the
with the best average. Otis
and the Mountain Rambler
team

juggernaught seemed to win all the
prizes for 200 miles around Galax,
and there was no finer feeling than
to arrive at a convention, listen to
the parking lot, and pick out that

wonderful

Mountain

Rambler
sound to head for. They stood so
close together that we choreo
graphed

a

of

parody

a

Rambler

session with interlocked arms and
legs and instruments. I remember
Otis mostly dressed in slacks and

white shirt and
an

a

tie,

a

thin black

American

in public, so
other friends at the
beginning of the Musical Freak
epoch, and such a mighty player as
to inspire my private manifesto of
'never trust a musician under 30.'
His music hooked me most with
its power,
which the Ramblers
helped
greatly. I have always
wondered if that drive came partly
because Otis and Eldridge

one;

unlike

my

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Montgomery (and maybe more of
them) were terrific flatfoot dancers
as well as players. He was not your
dainty hornpipe artist, in fact once
in that P.T.A. meeting costume he
played a tune so bluesy it
physically scared me. I learned the
tunes he played; their skeletons
were simple, you could even write
them (God forbid!) down. Only

I did to catch
the essence of
decorations and styling that
brought them to life and shouted

Red

more of
Certainly

Smiley

blank slate than now.
a fiddlers
convention it would replay tunes
I'd heard, in good styling, never
twice the same. However, if I tried
to work out a tune by selecting a
a

for days after

section of this memory and playing
it

exactly

on

the

fiddle,

the

intrusion of detailed inquiry and
the mechanics of playing would

try as

drive

the

crude approximation to play
by rote. Some stuff you learn right
away, some sinks in over time.
Otis gave me no lessons, but did
say that if you're going to play the
fiddle, do so, never mind being
bashful. Certainly he would play
tunes for examples. He once
offered to trade me his shorter
fingers for my longer ones, which
I'd cheerfully
have done. Mine
danced with wishful thinking to
their own uncertain sounds, while
his made real music.

"Virginia!," he was so many jumps

ahead as to be out of sight. We
could blather till dawn about short
bow, long bow, shuffles, old-time
bluegrass; great for spectator talk,

but Otis just did it. He might have
said "playing a little after Arthur

Smith," which

I

don't remember;

have said "playing after the
Devil, and please how do I start?"
I
had no cassette machine of
course, and had to try to learn by
I'd

Rapt Attention method. My
24-year-old mind was quicker and
the

only

away
a

the replay

and

leave

�"Richmond." And the influence of
Arthur Smith is very apparent in his
playing of such tunes as "Red Apple
Rag," or "Wednesday Night Waltz" with
its more bluesy, sliding chords.
Those were exciting, formative years.
They were also pretty wild. Otis drank
heavily, and there are countless stories of
his ability to drink and yet remain able to

straight through. On stage, Otis'd draw
that fiddle bow back, he'd start right
slow, and he'd lean way back, and when
and that
he come forward, he'd hit it
would really sell the crowd.
mean, he
was contagious. He's a legend around
I

here. We got to winning everything we
were going to, and everybody got to
talking about Otis Burris, you know, and

play; of competitors trying to get him
drunk and thus supposedly eliminate the

where'd he come from. And after we
won the first convention down here in
Galax, we started going to about all the
conventions we could find. And we were
winning about everywhere we went.

competition.
Hard

hunted you up, and when Otis started
playing there'd be a hundred people
standing around back in those days
listening, you know. And we knew that
anywhere we went with him we had a
.and
chance of winning something.
liked
and
liked
Otis,
really
people really
our band."

Otis played regularly with the
Ramblers until 1967. Together they
created a sound that featured the fiddle
as the lead instrument, playing the old
dance tunes of the area and the newer
pieces Otis had learned from Arthur
Smith: "Red Apple Rag," "Blackberry
"
and others. They played the
Blossom,
tunes with fiddle lead; Scruggs-style,
rock-solid
driving banjo support;
bass
and
rhythm,
mandolin, guitar,
steady yet pushing the fiddle ever so
slightly; and no breaks. The band played
the current bluegrass songs as well. The
fact that bluegrass music is played in
many different keys, with the music
accommodating the singer, gave more

furious, yet solid, fiddle-tune sound.
And this was the sound that was

recorded by County Records in 1966 on
see
Virginia Breakdown (County 705
No. 6). They
review in OTH Vol.
recorded four tunes by Otis and the
Mountain Ramblers: "Fortune," "Red
Apple Rag," "Richmond," and "Sail
1

Away Ladies." The interplay of the fastbut-perfect fiddle passages with Charles
Hawks' driving, three-finger banjo, all
backed by heavy, solid rhythm, is truly

inspirational.
The

fact

that

instrumental breaks

they
is

didn't

interesting

take
in light

of the fact that breaks helped to define
the difference between old-time and
bluegrass music. This may have been a

function of several
convention/comnetition

things:
rules,

the
which

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and

hard

drinking

eventually took their toll on Otis' health
a
band musician,
as
and reliability
causing him and the Mountain Ramblers
to part ways amicably in 1967. Although
Otis continued to play sporadically, by
the late '70s and early '80s he had sold
his fiddle and quit altogether. His health
was deteriorating, a broken hip left him
unable to dance, and a bout with
pneumonia rendered him frail and bent.
In 1986 James Lindsey stopped by to
'sit Otis and asked him if he'd ever feel
like playing again. When Otis expressed
interest, James brought him a fiddle to
use. "I called him every two or three
weeks and I asked him if he'd messed
with it any. No, he hadn't. Well, along
about November I said, 'Let's go down
Thursday and see if Otis can play a
fiddle.' And he hit that thing two or
three times going to tuning, and I found
out his hearing wasn't gone. And he
started out on 'Red Apple Rag' and I
seen then he could still play."
Several of us have been playing with
him now for over a year; the group has
evolved into Otis Burris &amp;c Fortune, and
includes Eldridge Montgomery, James
Lindsey, Alice Gerrard, and Wendell

"You felt like you were somebody
everybody knew you and everybody

flexibility to the songs and the singers as
well. All the Mountain Ramblers wrote
format
the
and
bluegrass
songs,
provided an outlet for their songs.
But the sound that the band became
especially known for was a fast and

living

Cockerham.
in
band
feature fiddle
at
the
Galax
and
which,
competition
Fiddlers Convention, did not separate
bluegrass and old-time as categories until
1963; and the fact that Otis' s fiddling
had such drive and vitality,
always
building in intensity to his signature
flourish, that breaking the
ending

tended

to

momentum

anticlimatic. But

would
I

think

have

it

been

was primarily

due to the fact that all the Mountain
Ramblers were strongly rooted in the
traditional old-time string-band sound
of the area, a tradition that did not
encompass instrumental breaks. These
musicians were the first generation
moving from old-time to bluegrass.

In the music they played, one can hear
direct link to the old-time fiddle styles
in Otis's choice of notes,
of the area
his sweeping, lyrical passages, his use of
"
the bow. Listen to him play "Fortune,
"Pretty Little Girl," "Chicken Reel," or
a

�Otis has been battling his alcoholism
determinedly and has not touched liquor
for over a year. He is currently waging
all
a war we
the war against cancer

have high hopes he will win as well. He's
very tough.

"1 just don't like to be around where
liquor is, but if I am it doesn't bother me
because I just set my head to quit, and I
quit. And I'm going to stay away from

it."

To watch Otis play is truly amazing.
has slowed him, and illness and
drinking have left him weighing 85
pounds. To see him one wouldn't think

Age

a fiddle, much less play one.
this small, slight man puts
down his cane and draws the bow to
sound the long, beginning chord of
"Fortune," the band can feel the edge

he

could lift

But when

and

prepares

to "grab

a

D chord

and

hang on," as Bill Monroe used to say.
There is much power, still, in his
fiddling, and when he is in front of an
to be
audience some deep urge to win
takes over, and he is often
the best
inspired. Otis likes the rhythm of the
band to drive his fiddling, to push him,
and he remains free to play with the
endless and beautiful chains of notes
bringing back the old and meshing with
the new. H
1
wish to thank Cora Lee Burris for her
help in looking over this article and making

corrections when necessary, and Wayne
Martin for his musical insights and support.
A. G.

the

Alice Gerrard
OTH.

is a

musician and editor of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Issues In Old-Time Music

&amp; US

FOLKLORISTS

Account of Our Curious
Changing Relationship

An

&amp;

With More Personal Reminiscences
by

Mac Benford

Points of view expressed in this column
those of the Old-Time

are not necessarily

Herald.

Well,

here's

the

player again with just

outspoken
a

banjo
few more things

to get off his chest. I must say, I was
tickled to find out how much dust I'd
raised with my last article. Naturally, I
appreciated all the agreement, but I kind

of wish that more people who disagreed
a different angle on the problem
had seen fit to put pen to paper. It's my
firm conviction that before we complain
about the lack of respect given to oldtime music by the world outside, all of us
inside the cozy old-time-music scene

too long. This is the rift I referred to in
my earlier piece (Vol. 1, No. 3), existing
between younger musicians and the folk
lore establishment. At issue, of course, is
the
"authenticity" of the current

generation of old-time musicians.
Unfortunately, the division has grown

so deep that the lack of respect each side
now holds for the other may have a
disastrous effect on the future of old-

time music.
In the course of gathering material for
this article, I heard many stories, ranging
from the amusing to the infuriating,
reflecting the current attitude of the

folklorists

toward

so-called

"revivalists." These I will leave to be
retold by those who are entitled to claim
them as personal experiences. As a
peacemaker, I want to focus on the
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gay
Willard
by
drawing
Pencil

should think about what we can do as
musicians and supporters to help secure
the music's future. It seemed that stirring
up a little controversy among us might
start things rolling in the right direction.
This time I'm hoping to find a way of
a
and
ending
dispute
resolving a
controversy that has been going on far

heart

or had

positive. So I would like to begin with
my own first-hand knowledge of a time
not so long ago when the relationship
was far different from what it is today.
When I was first drawn into the world
of old-time music, right around 1960, it

felt like one big family with
many different approaches. On the one
hand, of course, were the folks primarily

certainly

interested

playing old-time music
tunes and mastering the
learning
various styles. In nearly equal numbers,
in

the

however,

were

people

interested

in

acquiring information

about the music
and the lore associated with it. They
studied the rural, southern culture out of
which the music came. They collected
and traded the old 78 rpm records from
the
and

1920s, compiling lists of personnel
session dates. They tried to track

down and make contact with old-time
musicians from the earlier era. Some
even focused on the instruments made
used back in the original "golden
Though I may be using the term
loosely, all these people were basically
folkorists. We were all bound together
by our common fascination with and
commitment to old-time country music.
There was a bond of mutual
dependence as well. Most of us younger
musicians had had the poor fortune to be
separated by age and geography from the
older southern musicians whose music
we had come to prize. The record
collections and field trips of these
amateur folklorists were a necessary
source of knowledge and material for us
musicians. We, in turn, supplied one of
the few sources of appreciation and use
and

age."

�for the hard-won information they were
accumulating.
It was,
in fact, quite common for
people in the old-time-music scene in
those days to be both musicians and
folklorists. Most of the collectors picked

some

or banjo. Most of the
regularly pillaged second
hand stores for old records and at least
dreamed of trips to locate and study with
older musicians.
The dominant role models for the
whole scene were the New Lost City
Ramblers, who combined expertise as
musicians and folklorists. Their
performance style was based on their
extensive knowledge of old-time music
recorded in the '20s and '30s. In
addition to their own performances, the
concerts, films, and records that they
produced of older musicians still stand
as shining examples of what folklore can
be. Another influential group of the late
'60s, the Hollow Rock Stringband,
brought to life music gathered through

guitar

musicians

the

meticulous

fieldwork

of

their

fiddler, Alan Jabbour.
For a long while most of the scholar
ship, like the music, took place on a
and that's
strictly amateur basis
amateur in the very best sense of the
word: one who undertakes an activity
out of love. Little information about
old-time music found its way into print.
Much of what did was published in
record-collecting journals. Most of these
folklorists of old-time music operated
far outside official academic circles. Of
course there had been some serious

academic

interest

in

traditional

Appalachian music for some time, but it
had focused primarily on song texts
Child ballads and British broadsides.
The rich variety of instrumental styles
and
that
whole body of material

captured on records in the '20s and '30s,
which exhibits the influence of the
minstrel show, blues, and early jazz
in
short, much of what we now think of as
old-time music
was considered
commercial hillbilly music, far too
to
be
impure
worthy of serious,
academic attention.
In the late
1960s, however, these
attitudes began to change. Arguments
appeared in the Journal of American
Folklore that the point at which country
music began as a commercial enterprise
provided a fertile and legitimate field for

folklore
folklore

scholarship. When UCLA's
and
mythology department
agreed to provide a permanent home for

the impressive
collection of John
Edwards (an Australian hilly billy-record collector killed in an automobile
accident), it seemed to convey official

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

academic acknowledgement of old-time
music.
Many amateur folklorists now began
enrolling in academic programs to earn
credentials for what they had already
been doing for love. As the folk boom of
the
'60s gathered momentum,
the
campuses of colleges and universities
across the country became meeting
grounds for the academic world and oldtime musicians.
Folk festivals, growing each year in
size and number,
were advised and
directed by folklorists with and without
academic degrees. The decade brought
an increased interest in our country's
roots, and soon government, from the
federal level right on down, began to feel
that the study and preservation of our
traditions was a proper governmental
function. The study of what we call oldtime music, once just a hobby like stamp
collecting, had now become a field of
serious academic pursuit, a position of
influence in the entertainment world,
and

even

a

respected

and

well-paid

summer of 1972, we had been chosen to

become part of the Smithsonian's
Touring Performance Service; we were
picked to represent old-time music on a
U.S. State Department tour of Latin
America; and we had become a favorite
at most of the major folk festivals.
Best of all, at these performances we
were presented by the authorities to the

group

of

congregation

knowledgeable

traditional-music
lovers as being a
continuation
of one of the great
"living
musical traditions of our country."
"Authentic" was a word often used to
describe the qualities they felt our music
had captured. "Revivalists," of course,
was also used, but at the time it was a
label we could be quite comfortable
with. We were proud to be bringing new
life to a traditional musical form that

seemed on the wane, and we took this
role quite seriously. I mention all this
not to brag about past successes, but to
show the overwhelmingly
positive
influence that official support had on the
whole scene.

profession.

Without a stamp of approval we
received from the folklorists, we would
have been unable to tour the country full
time as we did. Having played festivals
like the National Folk Festival and the
Smithsonian Festival of American

without the overwhelmingly positive
reception we got from the folklore
community. Many of these people were
not academically trained, and many
lacked official degrees and credentials.
They were, however, the recognized
authorities on American traditional
music, and they occupied positions of
influence on festival boards, grants
arts councils,
and
committees,
foundations.
also
maintained
They

Folklife,

This was the situation when my most
notable musical venture, the Highwoods
Stringband, first got rolling. The timing
couldn't have been better. Quite simply,
I doubt
whether we would have made it

strong ties with the musical
which they had been a part.

circles of

experts

genuinely

These

seemed

excited by our music and felt that our
of traditional
unique combination

had somehow captured the
true spirit of old-time music in a fresh,
new way. (Ironically, one of the strong
features
of our approach
was
to
downplay the folklore and emphasize the
entertainment value of the music.) The
folklorists supported us with their
their suggestions,
and
compliments,
their sources for new material. Most
importantly, however, they used their

elements

influence to help us gain access to those
prime performance situations that are so
necessary to the continuation of the
music in this day and age.
The support we received was so active
that in just three years after Highwoods
had teamed up to try our luck at the
southern fiddler's conventions in the

it

was

educational

easier

to get hired

institutions,

by

civic

organizations, and folk clubs, where we
were treated with respect and decently
paid. The numerous small dances and
bar gigs

necessary to fill out our touring

schedule were made more bearable by
the thought that there was always some
prestigious job to look forward to. The
approval from the folklorists, which had
been enthusiastically seconded by the
older southern audiences we
many
played for, was a source of immeasurable
help to our spirits through the numerous
rough

spots

that

life

"on

the

road"

inevitably brings.
Being presented as a legitimate
continuation of the string-band tradition
took an enormous burden from our
shoulders as well. Unlike today's bands,
we were never faced with the dilemma of
having to modernize the music to

capture a larger audience. Huge crowds
were paying to hear us play as close to the
roots as we could without becoming
imitators. The folklorists contrived
events that attracted
that kind of
audience. Our best chance for success

in sticking to straight traditional
music, and that suited us just fine! We
appeared side by side with the great oldtime musicians of previous generations.
There was no attempt to conceal the
obvious differences in age and backlay

�ground, but as musicians playing in the
same tradition, we were presented as
equals. The message was there for all to
old-time music was not just
grasp
some quaint relic from the past, but was
still a valid and exciting form of musical
expression in the present.
The message seemed to spread like
wildfire. This was a period of explosive
growth for old-time music, constituting
what has been called a "second golden
like the
bands
age." Having young

Highwoods and our contemporaries, the
Red Clay Ramblers and the Hot Mud
Family, present old-time music on stage
made it instantly accessible and timely
something

the

audiences could

young

relate to. I'm sure the success we all were
beginning to have must have inspired
other bands to take a shot at it. Even in
the South,
"revival"
bands had an
influence at least equal to neighbors and
kin in drawing people into old-time
music. Soon there was at least one oldtime band in every town we played in all
across the country. The number of

excellent

musicians

multiplied

before

our eyes, and it was at this exciting time
that many of today's finest old-time
musicians got their start.
With more listeners and players of

old-time

music, there were more
performance opportunities on all levels.
Bars
and
clubs began to feature
traditional music. Several festivals
started up to feature old-time music.

"SOUNDS

OF
SOUTH"

Conference

at

Chapel Hill

"Sounds

of

THE

UNC

the

South," a
conference on the collecting and
collections of Southern traditional
music, is scheduled for April 6-8 a
the University of North Carolina
at Chapel Hill. The conference will
celebrate
the opening
of the
Southern Folklife Collection in its
new facilities in Wilson Library.
Conference programs will assess
the history, present situation, and
future of the collecting and
archiving of Southern traditional

music

and will examine the role
work has played in under
standing Southern culture.
Conference topics cover histor

this

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Regular

community

dances

were

initiated and many continue to this day.
Record companies began producing
records of younger bands and older
musicians as well. The old 78 rpm
records, once rare collectors items, were
now made widely available through
reissue on LP disks so that appreciation
of the music's roots could grow along
with its current popularity. A good case
could be made that old-time music today
is still running on the energy that was
generated in those few years of the early
1970s. I think if every one could recall
those days as clearly as I do, I could rest
my case right here. To me, it stands as a
treatment to just how much can be
achieved when folklorists and musicians
work together. Think about it!
Sometime around 1975 we heard that
the
federal government planned to
become more actively involved in
funding traditional arts. There was talk
of establishing a national folklife center,
and certain Congressional
bills were
passed. Traditional arts were given more
emphasis in the National Endowment
for the Arts. The National Folk Festival
Association became the National

Council for the Traditional Arts and
began coordinating the operation of all
federally

funded

folk

festivals

government-sponsored

tours.

and
I

remember an evening spent with the
prospective director of the new NCTA,
providing input regarding the particular

ical influences that shaped the
documentation of Southern tradi
tional music; demographic, social,
and technological changes that will
affect future documentation;

perspectives of national repositories,
field collectors, record collectors and

sector folk
lorists; the outlook for new releases
of documentary
and
recordings;
archival issues and concerns. Confer
ence participants
represent the
diverse groups that have contri
buted to the documentation of
Southern folk music.
producers,

Besides
discussions,
feature

and public

and panel
conference will

papers
the

several special events. A
concert by traditional artists will take
palce at the Arts Center in Carrboro
on
On
7Friday
night,
April
a
Saturday,
special session will
and
celebrate
examine,
discuss,
contributions of the Chapel Hill

encountered by full time
traditional
musicians. With the
touring
nation's revived interest in its cultural
roots and all the opportunities promised
problems

the upcoming
bicentennial
by
celebration, was it any wonder that we
had unlimited hopes for our band's

success and for the future growth of oldtime music?

Well, we couldn't have been more off
mark. Now, for the first time,
folklorists were accountable to the U.S.
taxpayers. What had been very wellthe

informed but nevertheless
highly
subjective individual decisions now had
to be justified as proper use of the public
funds. With the folk boom of the 1960s
still looming large in the back of
everyone's mind, the big fear seemed to
be that the taxpayer's money would be
used to advance the careers of groups
like Peter, Paul, and Mary
or worse
yet, heaven forbid, some "radical" like Pete
Seeger. What was needed was a set of

clear, absolute guidelines that would
help separate the Kingston Trio from
Frank Proffit
even though they both
"Tom
Dooley." But how could the
sang

obvious

differences

performance
so they could

be

even untrained

in

of

style

described and defined
used and understood by

be

people?

complex, subjective
problem areas could be avoided if one
could determine the authenticity of a
Clearly

many

work of art by applying certain tests to

string band revival of the 1960s and
'70s. Tours of the Southern Folklife
Collection, which includes the John
Edwards Memorial Collection, will

also

be

conducted

during

three-day event.

"Sounds

of

South"

the

the
is

sponsored by the Curriculum in
Folklore and the Academic Affairs
Library at U.N.C.
Chapel Hill and
the Folklife Section of the North

Carolina Arts Council.
he conference is open to all
interested persons. For information,
contact Folklife Section, N.C. Arts
1

Council,

Resources,

Dept.

919/733-7897;

Folklife

of

Raleigh

Collection,

or

Cultural

27611;

Southern

Manuscripts

Dept., University of North Carolina,
CB# 3926, Wilson Library, Chapel
Hill, NC 27599-3926; 919/962-

1345.

�betrayal. The number of jobs available to
us began rapidly to decrease. With the
"boogie-bluegrass" festivals of the latter
1970s as the biggest job we could look
forward to, the various compromises
that being a full-time
and sacrifices
demands
became less and
band
touring
less worth making. Finally, in 1978,
without enough good reasons to keep us
together, the Highwoods Stringband

disbanded.

The loss of one band was not all that

the artist instead of to the work itself.
The problem was now greatly simplified
traditional art was whatever was

authentic traditional
artist. The official guidelines that were
established can be boiled down to two
produced

by

an

simple criteria: was the folk artist born
into the culture of which his or her
tradition was an integral part; and was
the tradition passed to him or her
through oral transmission? These guide
lines seem designed to avoid rather than
with complex and subtle
deal
distinctions. Anyone born outside the
culture was labeled as merely a "young,
urban revivalist." Unfortunately, these
simplified criteria seemed to lead to a
very simplistic, black/ white approach in
applying them. Anyone who could read
certificate and a map was now
a birth
capable of making the "correct"
The volumes
of written
decision.
material and the required years of
academic training seemed to be more
often employed in justifying this
simplified approach rather than making
it capable of more subtle distinctions.
This approach to authenticity, of
course, had been around for awhile, held
academic
by the more conservative
folklorists who have had difficulty
fitting us into their concept of traditional

culture.

Now,

as

a

matter

of

became the official
strictly adhered to, universally
policy
applied. Not all folklorists felt complete
agreement with this policy, but no one

convenience,

it

seemed willing to jeopardize his or her
newly won position of authority by
challenging it. Soon, any event that
featured a "revival" performer found it
difficult to qualify for the considerable
funding now available.
The Highwoods Stringband, like most
other young bands of the time, found
ourselves on the wrong side of the line.
We were now denied access to those
large festival audiences we had played a
part in creating. Instead of support, we
now had to deal with a feeling of
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

disastrous to the overall old-time music
scene. However, the folklorists' with
holding of support from the "revivalists"
also had a disastrous effect on the growth
and spread of old-time music. Of course,
folklorists respond by saying that as
"scientists" their job is not to support

anything, but to examine and accurately
record what is going on. This pose of
nonintrusive observer I find
detached,
to be total nonsense. Folklorists have
absolute control over the best and most

performance

appropriate
available

situations

musicians

old-time

to

and

audiences. As long as they maintain their
stranglehold on this crucial means of
transmitting the music, they wield an
overwhelming influence and have an
enormous impact on the direction and

vitality of the music.
The official version of old-time music
that is now presented at major events is
played almost exclusively by older

southern musicians. Inevitably,

as

time

toll, the skill and number of
these musicians is decreasing.
The
impression made on youthful audiences
across the country is that this musical
form is entirely of another place and
time. As such, it may not have the
necessary energy or compelling artistry
to leap across the age/culture gap.
Meanwhile, younger musicians, denied
official support and approval, face
takes

its

severely

limited

performance

opportunities. Few novice musicians are
being attracted to old-time music, and
many experienced musicians are turning
away or giving up in frustration. Some of
the best old-time musicians of our
generation are finding their only hope of
economic success lies in emphasizing
their ties with the avant-garde rather
than their musical roots. Thus, the music
they pass along has less and less to do

with tradition.

Having decided that the so-called
"revivalists" are not an authentic part of
the tradition, the folklorists are now
using

their

considerable
to
power
much as possible from the

exclude us as
vital process of passing the music along.
To me, this appears to be a violation of
one of the basic principles of correct

scientific

behavior.

They

are

manipulating the events to fit their ideas
of what old-time music ought to be.
In addition to the obvious economic
consequences, the widening gap between

folklorists and musicians is having subtle
but equally
negative,
psychological,
effects. Naturally resentful for the lack
of respect they now receive, the younger

musicians

with

respond

a

similar

lowering of their opinion of the whole
field of folklore. Though a visit to
Tommy Jariell or Fred Cocker ham is
still something to be boasted of, younger
musicians no longer dream of making
new contacts. The body of fascinating
and valuable material that has now been
collected by the folklorists is largely
most younger old-time
by
musicians, who no longer show any
inclination to contribute to that body
themselves.
In spite of the disrespect in which
academic folklore is held, some younger
musicians seem strongly driven to seek
ignored

By
developing an
approval.
exaggeratedly conservative approach

its

trying to sound exactly like the
players of 50 years ago, they seem to
think they can disguise the realities of
their true age and upbringing. These
musicians, often identifying the tunes in
their repertoires as being from Gid
Tanner or Melvin Wine, for example,
are in fact strangely reluctant to reveal
that most likely they learned the tune
from a fellow "revivalist." (This attitude
might cause folklorists much confusion
Some younger
in
years to come.)
musicians even feel that adopting the
lifestyles of older southern musicians
will convey a sort of authenticity, and so
they move South, wear bib overalls,
chew Red Man, and drink white liquor.
is
for
the tradition
respect
Deep
to
its
but
essential
survival,
absolutely
mere imitation in any form is not going
to give the music the strength it needs to
survive.
The infuriating thing is that several of
the positions held by the folklorists seem
far
removed from reality.
equally
Regardless of what the folklorists feel is
proper, we are the ones through which
the tradition is now flowing. We are the
link between its past and its future and
there is no other. If old-time music is
played in the 21st century, it will be
because of us and this will be as true in

and

the rural

Just

South
as

folklorists'

as

claim
is

anywhere else.

from

far

that

reality

is

the

what

we

are

not authentic old-time
no longer any way by

passing along
music. There is
which even the most trained ears can
distinguish the best players and singers
of our generation with those of the ones
gone before.

�humiliating stereotypes of the minstrel
show. The cultural functions, attitudes,
and relationships have totally reversed
yet the tradition survives.

Finally, it seems that the cultural
criteria used by folklorists describe a
world that simply does not exist in real
life anymore. People can no longer be
born into culturally distinct, isolated
geographic areas. They just don't exist.
We are now all part of the homogenized
blend, like it or not. Even in the South,
where regional awareness and pride run
cultural
actual
the
extremely
deep,
in
blurred.
is
Likewise,
being
uniqueness
this age of modern communication and
mass media, the kind of pure oral

transmission required

by

folklorists

The

impossibility.

near

is

are

having on events

Now

have

I

in

always

the real world.
believed that

a

tradition
very definition,
is,
by
something that survives down through
the ages. Traditions persist through time
lessons may be
so that valuable
symbolically conveyed from one era to
another. One of the important functions
of a tradition is to combat the natural
and
human
feeling of isolation
human
activity
insignificance by putting
in a comforting context of continuity.
Thus,

through

spirit

can

a

the

tradition,

human

live on and transcend the
inevitable death of the individual or even
the demise of a culture. A tradition

serves a unifying function for a culture in
preserving elements of a previous time
often long gone and lost, but for the
that is held in common high
tradition
esteem.
In
linking their criteria for
authenticity to the culture of the pre
a culture clearly on
war, rural South
have
folklorists
the
wane
the
attempted to describe a tradition that is
doomed to extinction. It seems to me
that

the

folklorists have confused this

study of a dying culture with that of a
insist on
If
they
living tradition.
their
present policy, in all
continuing
National Council for
name
the
honesty,
the Traditional Arts should be changed
to National Council for Dying Cultures.
As a clawhammer banjo player, I

considered myself part of a tradition that
has continued unbroken from West
African village, to Virginia plantation, to
Philadelphia minstrel show, to Ohio
Valley medicine wagon, to Surry County
farmhouse to New England college
dormitory. To my way of thinking, that
most recent cultural leap
nor less

is

no greater

appropriate than the preceding

ones. The significant thing is that the
tradition lives on and carries with it
something of all the different cultures
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with

their

"archaic,"

isolated past began to be less cherished.

At the same time, for many middle-class
youths around the country just emerging
from the Eisenhower years, that same

old-fashioned southern culture offered a
wisdom and an
certain valuable
attractive "grittiness" that was easier to

a

its

ties

the

South,

their own bland
than
value placed on the
As
the
surroundings.

cherish

folklorists,

however, seem oblivious to how far
removed their official positions seem
from observable reality, and remain
unaware of the effect that these positions

it makes perfect sense that for
inhabitants of the post war, rural

To me
the

and banjo players that have gone before.
I
hope to add a little something of myself
to the

tradition that in the 21st century
clawhammer banjo music in

will see
space.
If

I

would

poetic for
compare tradition

may wax

moment,

a

1

water

with

from a spring high in the mountain,
seeking its way to the sea. Always
searching for the path of least resist
ance, its progress cannot be denied. Like
must adapt and
a
tradition
water,
accommodate to the changing landscape
of history through which it must flow.
As long as the valuable link with its
source is maintained and cherished, its
essence remains intact. As long as its
progress is not impeded, the valuable
continuity is preserved.
Folklorists have made much of the

between

distinction

and

"process"

"product" and have insisted that it is the
former to which any tests for

authenticity must be applied. By process
they refer to the complex set of attitudes
that link the artist, his art, his activity,

culture. These interrelated
his
attitudes may be summed up simply as
and

deep

reverence for the past.

It

is

this

reverence that sets boundaries and limits
on individual artistic endeavor, so that
serves to enhance the
creativity
tradition, not break from it. It is this
reverence for the past that ensures the
continuity and unification that a

tradition supplies. For
the degree of reverence

a

tradition,

it is

for the past that

offers the path of least resistance.
The slave-quarter culture that saw the
original development of American banjo
playing, thankfully, is gone. Yet the
tradition continues. To the African
recently arrived in this country in the
early 18th century, banjo music must
have represented a cherished link with

noble tribal heritage. To a black
American 250 years later, banjo music is
his

probably

a

cruel

reminder

of

the

tradition decreased with one group and
increased with the other, at some point
the balance shifted. In retrospect we can
see that the"revivalists" who offered

themselves

so

eagerly

as

conduits

became the path of least resistance, and
the tradition clearly and indisputably did
flow to them.
time is the
If
survival
through
distinguishing feature of a tradition, it is
in fact the "product" of traditional artists
that offers the means of its survival. The
work of traditional art stands as the sum

total of many conscious
unconscious artistic decisions

and

that
reflect the cultural attitude of the artist.
be it an object
It is only the work of art
like a basket or woodcarving with a

concrete existence, or something as
ephemeral as a tune or dance that is
that exists
subject to repetition
through time, broadcasting its message
from

the

past

into

the

future.

It

is

enormously interesting and informative
to

examine

the

various

factors

that

influence the artist and his function in
the long run,
In
his
community.
however, it is only those factors encoded
into the product that will endure and
comprise the tradition. The folklorists
must stop disregarding the product and
develop some criteria for judging the
authenticity of works of traditional art.
Recently, to make their point about
"revivalists," defenders of the official
folklore policy have used a comparison
one made by
between two quilts
Amish women from Ohio and the other
made from a kit by a well-to-do New
Yorker. In the example, the quilts are
identical in design and execution, and yet
they are labeled as distinctly different
due to the vast difference in the cultural
contexts from which they came. This is
an

infuriating

obviously

agrument,

difficult

seemingly
by

not

only

refute, but
inference insulting to the
to

New York quilter. One quilter may have
learned her skills in childhood by her
mother's side, while the other gained her

�knowledge from a book. One may have
incorporated a piece of her own wedding

into her quilt, while the other
chose pieces from a mail-order craft
But
these distinctions
of
supplier.
personal significance will disappear in
only a few generations, and over the
course of time the piece will become
simply an identical shape of white in the
identical place in the pattern, sewed with
identically painstaking tiny, even
stitches. If the two quilts are in fact
identical, they will necessarily be sending
an identical
artistic message into the
future. This by no means indicates that
the New Yorker is a member of the
Amish community. It does, however,
mean that they are both equally valuable
contributors to the quilting tradition. If
the quilts reveal some subtle differences
that may be perceived by the senses, then
it is these differences that will have to
form the basis for any distinctions
dress

society. They could work to ensure that
there is cultural "space" in which a
tradition could operate. In presenting
the music of this generation of old-time
musicians as a valid part of the tradition,
they would be not only testifying to the
music's relevance in the present, but
ensuring its continuation into the future.
There have been some encouraging
moves in the right direction. The recent
Tennessee Banjo Institute (see p.
featured younger and older players as
equals, side by side, with no musical
distinctions made, based on the culture
of their origins. This apparently was

possible

by

careful

wording

and

targeting of their funding proposals. A
few years ago, there was actually a

drawn.
Just so, we

old-time musicians of the

younger generations are not claiming to
be mountaineers. We are not necessarily
preserving the rural southern culture of
days gone by. We are, however, asking
the
accepted for what we are
we
of
the
tradition
inheritors
legitimate
call old-time music. As musicians, we
to be

ask to be judged by our music, not our

birthplaces. Being deeply involved with
traditional music, we seek to reestablish
the alliance with the folklorists who
share our involvement.
Having
committed ourselves to this music that
affected us,
respect, but the
has

so

we

ask

not

only

opportunity

to

contribute to the tradition's continuing
an
currently
vitality,
opportunity
limited by the folklorists.
Here, right before the folklorists' eyes,
the tradition is successfully making one
of those rare, cross-cultural leaps that
reveal its true strength. The various
cultural dynamics at work in this
transition would seem to be exactly the
kind of thing which would make folklore
such a fascinating field of study. Yet up
to now, this whole area has been ignored,

consciously or unconsciously, by the
world of folklore. If they act before it is
too late, they are in a perfect position to
gather valuable firsthand information on

complex processes at work.
Cooperation between the folklorists and
the

younger musicians would be vital to the
success of this study.
With a new approach and fresh
could become
folklorists
attitudes,
active advocates for living traditions in
today's culture. They could continually
remind the public of all the vital
functions a tradition provides within e
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

meeting

North

under the sponsorship
Carolina Arts Council

of the

during

which folklorists and musicians came
together to establish some common
ground and communication between the
two groups. I should also mention that
the Brandywine Festival has for many
years

provided

opportunities
performers.

for

prime performance
numerous younger

Of course, the situation is not going to
change overnight, and time is slipping
away. I urge everyone on both sides of

dispute to do what they can to re
establish the natural connection between
these two approaches to old-time music.
Everyone would clearly stand to gain.
Most important, of course, is the benefit
to the tradition itself. I am sure that
the

when the best players and singers of the
current generation of old-time musicians
are given the recognition and respect that
is their due, and the access to the wide
audience that official support from the

folklorists

can provide, the power and
beauty of the tradition in their capable
hands will reach out and touch enough
souls to ensure its survival.
So, that's about all I have to say. It's
time for me to quit writing and go back
to picking the banjo, fl

�The Dance Beat

Traditional
Dance
and

courtesy

David

R.

Peterson

Old'-Time
Religion

Square

dance near Hardy,

Ark. from Arkansas

- A

Guide

to

the State

part of the

(1941)

"Writer's Project" of the WPA.

by

David

R.

Peterson

the warm months, way back in the
early days of the Arkansas Country
In

Society (1978-81), we danced
outdoors at the Young Men's Business
Association Park in Conway. In many
ways it was idyllic: a semi-private open
air pavilion, free rent, the smell of fresh
cut grass or blossoming trees wafting in
on sweet southern breezes, a somewhat
reliable string band with occasional twin
fiddling, old-time squares, contras, reels,
Dance

and big circle dances, and dancers who

actually thought their caller knew a lot.
We were certainly no threat to the peace
and quiet of the neighborhood. I was
somewhat surprised, then, when the
park supervisor told me he was getting
complaints about "public dancing."
There have been ordinances in Conway
banning "public dancing," but at the
time I was unaware of them, and they
probably were not the gist of the

complaint. Nothing came of it, we just
dismissed the complainer as an old biddy
killjoy.

A few years later, Gerald, one of our
regular guitar players, told us he had

found religion and therefore would not
playing with the band in the future.
Now Gerald, though gentle spirited and
be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

over 40, definitely was not an old biddy
killjoy. Over the years it finally dawned
on me that old-time religion, dance, and
music certainly have had an influence on
each other, and the topic is worth
share
a
(We currently
discussing.

with

Baptist
facility, quite amiably,
church; we dance on Friday and
Saturday and they have services on
Sunday and Wednesday.) It is even
possible that some religious criticism of
the Dast has been valid.
As a religious target in the past, social
a

the

dancing would probably
midrange of the amusements (abuses):
rank

in

drinking, gambling, card
adultery,
playing, Sunday baseball, fiddling,
mixed swimming, smoking and chewing,

pleasure driving, horse racing, circuses,
and theaters, to name a few. Scripture
itself is ambivalent about dancing, but
since the activity is naturally titillating,

especially to the overwhelmingly male
clergy, dancing was common sermon
fodder and also the subject of a consi
derable amount of religious literature.
Some anti-dance books are well written,
informative, and at times amusing; par

ticularly

when

viewed

from

a

significantly different time and culture.
My favorites are: Dancing as a Christian
Rev. George C.
Amusement,
by
Heckman, D.D. (Presbyterian Board of
Publication, 1879); Modern Dancing: In

Light of Scripture

W.

Gardner,

and Facts, by Rev. W.

D.D.

Book

(Baptist

Concern, 1893); and Five Reasons Why

Methodists Don't Dance, by Rev. Franklin
F. Lewis (The Glad Tidings Publishing

Co.,

In

1921).

1921, the Methodists

were re-examining their stand on dance.
Eventually, the Methodist Church
became a supporter of folk dance and
music, first publishing The World of Fun,
a set of records and a manual of dance

instructions,

in

Heckmann

1946.

dismisses

plausible defenses of
dancing was promoted
scripture,

promotes
polite

that dancing

graceful

the most
dancing: that

or
is

tolerated in
healthful and

movements

manners, and that

it is an

and

innocent

amusement.

Quite the opposite,
found dancing to produce
dire physical effects, particularly for
women: "great bodily debility, undue
excitement and reactive prostration of

Heckmann

nervous system, poisoning and
obstruction of the lungs and throat,
often resulting in hemorrhages and
consumption, palpitation and other
of the heart,
diseases
frequent
the

headaches, with their trains of evils, and
internal injuries of various kinds." He
claims to have witnessed "six cases of
sudden death by dancing" in the last six

months. As to innocence, "The rules of
this social amusement will allow a man

�guilty of every crime which should make
women loathe him and banish him from
all respectable company to take liberties

prayer,

with the person of his wife and sister and
which under no other
circumstances than marriage would be
permitted to the man of purest morals or

daughter

dancing was no "innocent
rather it "effectively
dissipates serious thought, while it
promotes lightness and frivolity." He
apparently thought his lifelong battle
against dancing had been worthwhile:
"The author has been more or less
troubled with dancing in all his
Gardner,

amusement,"

churches, but

private and prompt
effort and faithful preaching on the
subject, he has been enabled to stop the
pernicious practice without exclusions."
As to the consequences
of dancing,
Gardner was none too subtle. Speaking
of a revival he said,
by

Among the anxious a lovely lady
presented herself again and again
for

prayer. But she was
passionately fond of dancing, and

special

her pleasure-loving
prevailed upon her to

dancers? Not one."
Lest musicians become too sanguine,
be reminded that they were often put in
the same hot hopper as the dancers.

Josiah Combs, who
Christian University
described attitudes
follows:

was "too late," God had given her
up. In a few days she died in
hopeless despair!

even

Commission"

quotes

a

a

fashionable ball in an adjoining
neighborhood. For the time being

in

years,

Kentucky

as

folk-song

is

the

"minstrel" himself, that

Highland

itinerant,

wandering,

shiftless

fiddler, or banjo picker, who
makes a specialty of seeking out all
"parties" and dances. The attitude
of the church, as well as of other
classes.
.(has) been expressed in
the figure of speech.
."As thick
as fiddlers in hell!".
.Time was
when he was highly respected,
before he discarded the traditional
folk-song for the "quick and
devilish" tunes and various other
types of songs, frivolous, vulgar,
etc....
Not that most of his
repertory is indecent, but rather
that the average Highlander takes
into account the personal equation
as he muses: "I can't hear what that
feller is playing for thinking about
what he is." One Highlander put it
this way: "Every time one of them
fellers comes into the community,

"Christian

of St. Louis, Missouri,
which claims to have found "that threefifths of the fallen women of that city
attribute their fall to promiscuous (i.e.

neither brains nor good morals to be a
good dancer. As the love of one increases
the love of the other decreases. How many

her convictions were stifled, and
on return to the revival next day,
she declined coming forward for

the

against

understand their licentious tendency.
are the aggressors, while innocent girls
and unsuspecting young men are the
and thus
multitudes of
sufferers;
virtuous youths are being led into this
vortex of corruption and sin every year."

He

Texas

with the
hurled by the church

anathemas

The modern dances that Gardner
referred to were the "German waltz and
French round dances," but he also noted
that square dances were essentially
licentious," and "naturally lead. .to the
violation of the Seventh Command
ment." If dancing was a sin, "the leaders
in these voluptuous dances, (who) well

at

many

taught
for

associated

Closely

mixed) dancing."
Besides the immorality and
immodesty of the dance, Gardner, in his
blow, quotes, "It requires
sharpest

friends

attend

shunned her religious

proposed prayer with her, but she
persistently refused, saying, that it

closest friendship."
The substance of Gardner's book was
first preached in Maysville, Kentucky, in
1849, and it was widely circulated in
tract form over the next 44 years. To

and

friends. The meeting closed with
sixty baptisms. In a short time this
young lady was seized with a fever
from which she never recovered.
Her pious friends visited her and

I

go

straight

home

to

my

daughter!"
In the long run, the waltz and other
round dances, and certainly the square
dance, have not been a significant threat
to society. Still, there was some validity
to
the religious criticism.
Personal
modesty could be threatened and dances
could be crude. During his many years of
collecting, the noted Ozark folklorist
Vance Randolph assembled a 35-page
monograph, Ribaldery at Ozark Dances,
of vulgar and obscene dance calls and
tune names.
In
H.
A.
an
earlier
example,

of the best men and women are skillful

Wittington, an immigrant from
Massachusetts, found that the women in
Little Rock in 1827 fit the rough frontier

town.

Of

part of the
have
not much to
community,
say, as there are five grown girls in
the township and they are as ugly
as sin and as mean as the devil.
the

female

Courtesy

David

R.

Peterson

I

from Arkansas-

A Guide to the State

(1941)-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

part of the "Writer's Project"

of the WPA.

a famous place for parties. I
been to three since I have
been here, where they have a violin
.The men get
and dance all night.
drunk and generally have a fight
before they get home.
If the girls feel a tick biting them

It is

have

�at

a

the

party, and even if they are on

floor

dancing,

immediately stop and unpin and
scratch themselves until they find
it.

No tale of an old-time square dance
seems complete without a drunken
brawl. The association of liquor and
dancing is overstated but not invalid. In

1920s Randolph observed, 'The
Ozark women do not drink in public,
the

but the young men usually have a jug of
whiskey out in the dark where the horses
are tied, and drinks are free to anybody

who

wants

them.

There

is

a

certain

amount of clandestine love-making

which the hillman elegantly designates

'tom-cattin"

and

occasionally

with the Peterson Family Band, and
a
has
he
book,
recently written

Money Musk or
Virginia Reel, and wondered what
people could find to admire in
old-fashioned

they

as

party
drunken riot, but
a

breaks up at dawn in a
on the whole I think there is less drunk
enness and sexual irregularity than at
most college dances."

partner approached to claim my
promised hand, I felt my cheeks
glow

a

little

sometimes.

.the

was
climax
of my confusion
reached when, folded in his warm
embrace, and giddy with the whirl,
a strange sweet thrill would shake
me from head to foot, leaving me
weak and almost powerless, and
for
to
depend
obliged
really
support upon the arm which
and
I grew bolder,
encircled me.
from being able to return shy
glances at first, was soon able to
meet more daring ones, until the
waltz became to me and whoever
danced with me, one lingering,
sweet, and purely sensual pleasure,
where heart beat against heart,

hand was held in hand,

and eyes

looked burning words which lips
dare not speak.

Courtesy

David

R.

Peterson

Certainly the preaching of men like
Gardner kept some people out of the
dance hall, but in a curious way they
sometimes made "dance" more alluring
than it would naturally have been. This
last quote, from Dancing by one Major
E.
Penn of Eureka
W.
Springs,
Arkansas, is a good example.

Arkansas Country Dances.

those "slow dances." But in the soft
floating of the waltz I found a
strange pleasure, rather difficult to
describe. The mere anticipation
fluttered my pulse, and when my

the "risque' ballroom scene around Hot Springs, Ark.
Archives, Little Rock, Ark.

will, however, venture to lay bare
young girl's heart and mind, by
giving my own experience in the
days when I waltzed. In those days I
cared little for Polka or
Varsovienne, and still less for the
I

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at

the turn of the century. Old State

David. Peterson grew up

in the

upper

mid-west and attended traditional
dances in Southern Wisconsin as a
teenager. He teaches mathematics at
the University of Central Arkansas at
Conway, plays hammered dulcimer

�ROBERTS

KENNY

201.

Bluebonnet BL
guitar,

yodels,
cassette/album

Songs,

14

harmonica,
postpaid. Bluebonnet
Worth, Texas 76101

Box

CLAWHAMMER BANJO

$10.00

281,

Ft.

CAMPS,

WORKSHOPS, PRIVATE LESSONS:
Your

area

or

Two

mine.

decades

teaching experience. Emphasis on banjowith-drive. Free brochure. DWIGHT
DILLER, P.O. Box 148, Hillsboro, WV

24946

304-653-4397.

GENEROUS
return

of 1914

REWARD offered

for

Heinrich Roth violin,

1774 Stradivarius copy, with two bows
case, and mint GTR banjo. No
questions asked. Contact Box 19180A,
ETSU, Johnson City, TN 37614 The
Roth violin is reddish-brown matte
finish with two gouges on face with
unusual wide carved chin-rest; one of the
bows is marked "Hill," the other is plain.
The GTR banjo is mint condition with
wreath pearl inlay; no 5th string capo or
Keith pegs. If you have information
concerning these instruments, contact
Richard Blaustein at the above address.
and

MARTIN GUITARS,

DOBROS,

FLATIRON MANDOLINS
Find out
we're
the
world's
why
largest fretted

instruments

ELDERLY

store. Free
INSTRUMENTS

Washington,

POB

catalog.

1100

N.

14210-AV34,

Lansing, Mi. 48901 (517) 372-7890.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Workshop

These movements refer to those from
the
knee
down.
No upper body

description

is

included

in the

notation.

ABBREVIATIONS:

NOTATED

SOME

STEPS
OF FLATFOOTERS
FROM MABRY MILL,
IN PATRICK COUNTY,

VIRGINIA
by

H

weight transfers to HEEL.

B

weight transfers to BALL of foot.

S

weight transfers by
foot.

a

STEP on flat of

weight centered over flat of foot,
drags backward and forward or

CH

foot

CHUGS back and forth.
B-CH

a certain kind of chug that begins
foot flat on floor and ends with
weight on ball of foot. The BALLCHUG is accomplished by pulling,
snapping, or popping the ball of the foot
backward. It is a small movement with
foot remaining directly beneath the
knee.

with

Tina Hicks

A language or a system of notation is a
very valuable tool to have while learning
new dance steps. The following system is
not intended as an all-encompassing,

universal, or preferred system. It is a
simple system to describe the mechanics
of the steps I find interesting enough to
want to remember. The ideal system
would enable us to better describe and
record the steps found in the many
different styles (as much as the written
word allows.)
The following notated steps are not
intended as a substitute for a visit to
Mabry Mill (see OTH Vol. 1 No. 4) and
holding Luther Boyd's hand. Perhaps
these notes will inspire you to go from
there and experience them first-hand.
You might recognize a step from one of
the dancers notated here.
Stylistically, these dancers resemble
one another only in posture and in the
fact that their footwork is close to the
floor. Otherwise, they execute each
movement in a manner characteristic
only to themselves.

description of left foot motion

R

description of right foot motion

foot leaves

the

floor

in

forward brush, the heel strikes the floor.
In a backward brush, the ball strikes the
floor.

a tiny
movement that begins by
picking the foot up from the floor,
flexing the ankle, and, from that flexed

TT

eee

a

1

&lt;Sc

eee

a 2 &amp;c

eee

a

3 &amp;.

eee

a

by

a

Because they are the tiniest moves
Luther does not end up
forward,
teetering off the edge of the dance board;
actually, he covers very little space.
Here

is

William Hall's main step:

step.

Fwd in

a

FORWARD motion

Bwd in

a

BACKWARD motion
from

Tina Hicks

dancer, caller, and folk
She lives in Blacksburg,
member of the Green Grass
is a

culture researcher.

vocal method of counting out a triplet
before the beat, as in the Tennessee
Walking Step.
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The interesting thing about this step is
that the chugs are all forward in motion
and do not alternate back and forth.

ankle again thereby raising the toe and
ball. The TOE TAP is usually followed

4, is

Read the notation from left to right.
The bottom line gives the beat of the
music and each corresponding move
ment is found above it on the line
according to which foot the dancer uses.

that is done even closer to the floor than
Hoy's. He also sneaks in at least one
triplet sound. He ends the measure with
a
small brush forward followed by a
chug, but his timing here is much
Luther uses
than
different
Hoy's.
different knee action to produce the
different timing.
Here is one of Luther Boyd's break
steps. It begins with weight on the left
foot:

position, lowering the toe and ball
portion of foot to quickly strike the
floor once and immediately flex the

Time designations: &amp;.al&amp;a2&amp;a3&amp;.
a 4 divides
the time into four parts.
&amp;.

followd by a chug.
Within that same framework, Luther
Boyd does a similar step (not notated).
His step, however, involves footwork

the

direction indicated and BRUSHES the
floor on the way out. It involves no
weight change. The follow up to a
forward brush in one fluid motion is a
leg extension with ankle flexed. In a

Here is one step of Hoy Hayden
Mt. Airy, N.C.:

Key to Dance Notation
L

one

BR

Hoy gives his sideways traveling step
even and symmetrical look and
sound. His feet rock from heel to ball
directly beneath him and he ends the
measure with a small brush forward,
an

Va,

and

is

a

Cloggers of Asheville, N.C.
For the first four beats, Hoy does his
step traveling sideways left to right. For
the next four beats, he travels sideways
right to left, and so on.

�ASK

D.P. from San Jose, wrote Uncle
Harold, an awfully long time ago about
some tunes. Your uncle hasn't forgotten
you, D.P. Here's the information you
wanted. The indefatigable Kerry Blech
tells us that "Yellow Barber" is also
known as "Arthur Barrie" (or Berry,
etc.). It is, he says,
Barry, Berrie,
a
regional tune from
"apparently

?

Uncle Harold

Ohio."
northern Kentucky/southern
The version most people know comes
Puss
from
(Kitty
Buddy Thomas
Rounder 0032). Whom Buddy Thomas
learned it from must remain unanswered
here, as we hasten on to tune #2.

known recording (of
Vocalion 5021 by
the Hillbillies in the late 1930s, "Kerry
tells us. The Hillbillies also recorded as
A1 Hopkins and His Buckle Busters. The
tune has also been recorded by Fred
'The

earliest

Texas Gals")

was on

Cockerham,

Tommy

Jarrell,

Doc

Watson, and Rafe Brady.
Tune #3 "Shenandoah Falls," was
tracked down for Uncle Harold by Pete
Sutherland, after Uncle Harold had
tracked down Pete Sutherland.
"'Shenandoah Falls' I learned from
Californian Carol Robinson, and taught
to the rest of the universe," writes Pete.
No. 5,
followers have kindly
Vol.

In

omitted

1

bio

a

on

taithtul
we
out,
pointed

as

many

Harold--

Uncle

a

serious omission to be sure, and one we
rectify here to the best of our ability.
The editors found it difficult to garner
any facts about Uncle Harold. He can be
reached only at a post office box in a
large, midwestern city, and we forward
all his mail there.
man so free with his opinions he
is strangly reticent about the facts of his
life. Here is what he told us.
For

"I

a

was

a

foundling and

I

am

uncertain

of my exact age. I'm old enough to merit
everyone's respect, however. I have
lived all over the United States, working
at more jobs than I care to mention. I
quit school as soon as I could, but I have
always read a lot and consider myself to
be no mean armchair psychologist. I've
suffered from shyness all my life and am
not too evident at festivals and fiddlers
conventions except in the darkness, late
at night, at the very edge of an occasional
jam

session.

I've

been

all

my life, having
decided early on to leave the business of
marriage to people with a less developed
sense of humor.
I
hate almost everything about the
1980s except that I like being able to
bake a potato in eight minutes. I detest
the

single

phrase "senior citizens" and prefer

the term "old."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

wish I'd lied and said I wrote it." Tuttut, Pete. Y our uncle would have known.
"Some think it's a corruption of Kenny
Baker's 'Shenandoah Breakdown,' Pete
continues. "I don't know where Carol
I lost my address book."
Robinson is
Tune #4, alas, will not be tracked
down for you this time. Uncle Harold
will maintain a certain reputation for
slackness by throwing open to his
adoring readers the question of the
origin, age, and meaning of the title of
the tune "Sheep Shell Corn."
"I

Jon Levitow, (1 1415 Waterford St.,
Brentwood, CA 90049) tells Uncle
Harold, "I'm looking for a tone ring for

open-backed Slingerland banjo
about 50 years old, outside diameter 10
3/4 inches. In case you have the tone
ring he's looking for, and need to get rid
an

of

it

in

a

hurry, you can phone Jon

at

213-472-0646.

of "Whiskey Before
the origins
Breakfast" raises its ugly head yet again.
(Uncle Harold

is

script, The Tune

working on

a

movie

that Wouldn't Die")

Uncle Harold thanks Stephen Green
of)

question.
published

this burning
for reviving
He tells us that the tune was
in

After

commendably

a

lengthy

discussion of how the tune might have

made its way from Canada to the U.S.
(or just possibly from the U.S. to
is there no rest for the humble
Canada
researcher?) Mr. Green ends with a last
tantalizing statement: There's just one
in
catch, though, I forgot to mention
the printed collection of Canadian Fiddle
Tunes from the Red River Valley, every
tune is labelled in the upper right hand
corner, "Andy de Jarlis." Every tune,
that is, except one. "Whiskey Before

Breakfast"

says

"Arr.

by

Jarlis.'"

Just when you

thought

it

Canadian

Red River Valley in

1958

Tunes from the
a

collection

of tunes attributed to Andy de Jarlis.

de

Andy

was over.

B. B., Orange Co., N. C., writes
Uncle Harold with the following two
questions:

First, "Why do so many banjo players
lose their hair?"
Your uncle has noticed that this
condition does, in fact, persist in a
certain number of banjo players, but has

noticed,

his

to

that

astonishment,

it

seems to afflict only males of the species
(unless, of course female banjo players
similarly afflicted wear wigs; Uncle
Harold wouldn't be surprised). Anyway,
your uncle postulates that this condition
must be genetically linked, rather than

socially transmitted, and is not to be
considered an occupational hazard.
On to B. B.'s second question: "Who
originally recorded 'Rock Candy
Mountain' and Thinking Tonight of my
Blue Eyes'?" Good question. Maybe a
balding banjo player
answer, B.B.

David

R.

will write in the

Peterson, of Greenbriar,

comprehensive reply to Phil
Jamison's request for illumination on
the difference between contest buck
dancing and contest clogging. Quoting
Frank X. Bonner's monograph Clogging

Ark., sent

a

and the Southern Appalachians,

he gives

a

definition that, in your uncle's humble
opinion, should end all discussion on
the subject. "It is step dancing by

Just when you thought it was safe to
read this column again, the question of

(sort

"Everywhere you look," Mr. Green tells
"you find ways of linking "WBB"
directly or indirectly to Andy de Jarlis."

us,

a

single

individual in a totally freestyle mode."
Uncle Harold likes this definition
because it includes breakdancing.
Oh, one more thing. Mr. Peterson
includes the complete set of rules for a
buck-and-wing event for the Mid-Fair
Clogging Championship in Memphis,
Tennessee. Readers might be interested
in rule 7:

Girls must wear skirts. (Boys

may not.)

continued on page 40

�RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
N
READY FOR SHIPMENT

Sales

County

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
NEW RELEASES
ROU-0262

FRESH OLD-TIME STRING BAND MUSIC Collected or performed and recorded by Mike Seeger
BUZZARD ROCK STRING BAND "I've Got The Blues For My Kentucky Home" w/Harry Bickel, etc
"
Live At New River Ranch" Great live concert from 1956
LOUVIN BROTHERS
many top songs
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" New old-time music by this West Virginia group
VIRGINIA TRADITIONS: Southwest Virginia Blues With Dock Boggs, Carter Family, Byrd Moore, etc
SPROUTS OF GRASS "I Like Mountain Music" Bluegrass and old-time music from Washington band
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BANJO COLLECTION Super set of 1937 -46 field recordings by John Lomax....
"
classic old time recordings
CHARLIE POOLE "Volume 1 Available again with new cover
w/booklet
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent fields recording of the Cumberland Plateau area
Vol. 2" Great reissue of his classic 1950s recordings
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings
VIRGINIA TRADITIONS -EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO Great oldtimew/Roy Hall, etc
CHOKERS &amp; FLIES "Old Time Music" Fine recent material by the Chicken Chokers &amp; Horseflies
some unissued
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Singles Collections" Neat reissue of obscure 50's/60's cuts
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo LP by this Kentucky musician

"JA-054

"CCLP-0105

*FF-468
'BRI-008
RB-1001

ROU-0237
"CO-505

CO-786

*CCS-109
"BRI-010

"ROU-0213
"CCLP-0103
"JA-051

JAMES BRYAN "Looked Blues" Fine old-time fiddle, featuring Norman &amp; Nancy Blake
DOC ROBERTS "Old Time Tunes" Great reissue of his tunes from the 1920 s &amp; 30's
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial &amp; field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "You Can Feel It In Your Soul" Classic gospel from the 1950 s
OLD HOLLOW STR1NGBAND Old-time music from North Carolina
Vol.
TRADITIONAL MUSIC FROM THE CUMBERLAND PLATEAU
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
Vol 1" Reissue of 1920s material
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroes best early 1950s Decca material
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
w/booklet
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish
NASHVILLE BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent old-time LP
A. ROB1C &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930 s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 940's King material
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950 s &amp; 60 s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTWICH &amp; HIGGINBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
HEE HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing
TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music
UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine 1920's/30's sides
Vol 2 Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
SKILLET LICKERS
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carrol County, Virginia
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920's/30's
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 1928-41

"ROU-0175
CO-412
AT- 103

"CCS-111

FCOT-001
CO-787
"CMF-011

1

OH-191

"REB-853

"SH-3759
"ROU-0233
HER-070
"ROU-0242
FCOT-005
"FF-415

"HAT-3022
*CO*-791
*CCS-

1

10

1

"CO-788
"REB-850
"FF-352
"JA-014

"CO-790
*HH"TR-1

19842

CO-545

"CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406

7.50
7.50
7
7

S

.50
.50

8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50

7

2
1

.50

7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
2.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

$10.00

7.50
7.50
7

.50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50

NEW COMPACT DISCS
RCA-CD-8416
RCA-CD-8417

RAGGED BUT RIGHT "Great Country String Bands Of The 1930's" w/Skillet Lickers,
Mainers, etc
ARE YOU FROM DIXIE "Brother Duets Of The 1930's" w/Biue Sky Boys, Monroe Bros.. Allen Bros

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted

by an

asterisk

"

")

On all ORDERS in (ISA. please add $2.00 postage &amp; handling
FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $5.00 postage for first -3 LPs, $1.50 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPT.H, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001

CANADIAN

&amp;

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

$11.00
$11.00

�Reviews

Record
Artists

here, but
and

record

Mr. Kane.

companies

please send records and tapes for
review to The Old-Time Herald,
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333.

CT 06069

Powder River
(Folk Legacy 76)
with Greg Schaub, Tom Carter and Hal

Cannon.

Texas Gals and Pike's Peak/The Bravest

Dying

Ranger/The

Indian/ Peeler Creek and the Clayhole

(waltzes)/Yodeling Cowboy/Done
Gone/Cowboy's Soliloquy/Hale's

Rag/Home Brew Rag/Powder
River/Texas Waggoner/Maid of
Gal
Down
Argenta/Brownskin
Road/If Your Saddle is Good
Tight/New Lost Train Blues

the

and

For me, moving to the Northwest had
cons. I felt bad about moving
further from the Blue Ridge and away
its pros and

from my many musical compatriots
the
was

in

South, East, and Midwest. A plus
getting to know some of the

singers and musicians who
dwell on the Pacific side of the country.
One whom I had heard about for years is
Ron Kane. I only get to see Ron about
twice a year, but he has become one of
my heroes. Ron and his musical partner,
Skip Gorman recorded this LP in 1977,
released in 1981. I think it is a gem and
want to tell the world about it.
Thematically, it is about the cowboy,
although it speaks more generally about
times that have passed to never come
again. Ron has the perfect voice to

excellent

convey the feelings of loneliness that the
range riders felt. His interpretation of
"Bravest
Cowboy"
Tommy Jarrell's
sends chills up and down my spine every
time

I

hear it.

Ron also is a crisp, clear fiddler. Every
note he chooses belongs to the tune—

there is no indecision.
Hearing
"Homebrew Rag" on the radio made me

want to get this album. Everything else
here is of the same quality. I don't mean
to slight Skip or the other fine musicians
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

just had to tell you all about

(Kerry Blech)

To order: Folk Legacy Records, Sharon,

RON KANE AND SKIP GORMAN

Cowboy/The

I

�about cowboys, Mexican songs, fiddle
tunes, and recent "folk" compositions,
of the latter
some
being original.
Musically, they borrow from all these
genres.
The singing here is polished, and some
of the finest old-time cowboy singers,
such as Carl Sprague and Jules Allen,
were smooth singers, too. Horse Sense,
however, makes it all a bit too pretty and
"folky" for my taste. I want to hear more
grit, singing that I can believe. Hank
Williams said to sing country you have
to have smelled a lot of mule manure. To
sing cowboy songs.
My favorite cut

on

the

album

is

Bishop's original "Aluminum Miners,"

a

fine tribute to those who eke out a living
picking up cans along the highway. It's

very singable, and I wouldn't necessarily
expect it to sound old-time. So it is with
the other folk-style compositions like
"South Coast" and Utah Phillips' "The
Goodnight-Loving Trail," though I'd
expect more intensity even in the singing
of these.
John Nielson is a fiddler who has a fine
command of his instrument, yet needs to
decide on the appropriate approach for
each song. It's as if he's absorbed oldtime, bluegrass, contest, and western

swing fiddling, and chooses to use

it all

indiscriminately.
The most traditional-sounding
numbers are the square-dance tune
Pony" and the southern
"Spotted
mountain song "Bravest Cowboy," sung
uncertain

harmony. "Sadie Brown,"
Rodgers song, which
I'd guess Horse Sense picked up from
Jack Elliot, features some nice yodeling
by Bishop. Also included are the western
fiddle contest standard "Comin' down
from Denver," two familiar Mexican
fiddle pieces ("Cielito Lindo," with
vocals, and "Jesusita and Chihuahua")
and a couple of real old-time cowboy
in

the raggy Jimmie

songs.

I
understand that Justin Bishop is a
folklorist, which makes it all the more
mysterious to me that the liner notes are
essentially nil. There's a laudatory
couple of paragraphs written by "Red
Knuckles," but nary a word about the
musicians' background or song sources.

certainly like to know more about
them, where they learned the music, and
their ideas on what they're presenting.
I'd

Folk audiences will probably like this
record much more than old-time fans
looking for traditional western music. If
you want real cowboy music, search out
recordings by Glenn Ohrlin, Steve
Cormier, or Jules Allen. Horse Sense
does provide an impression of the
breadth of music from and about the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

West, and I expect they will provide us
some top-rate western music farther
down the trail. This first effort still
seems to be a little green (Bob Bovee)

To order: Kicking Mule Records, P.O.
Box 158, Alderpoint, CA 95411

�zation should pay much more attention
to details and information if it is serious
about preserving its state's folklife. 1
want to know more about each musician
when and where he or she was born,
who their musical influences were, with
whom they share stylistic similarities. 1
want to know more about the songs and
tunes: where similar pieces can be found,
the history of the piece. I'd appreciate a
discography. Many of these folks have
recorded excellent albums of their own. I
I like
them, where else can I hear them?
These are all duties of a producer of a
record of folklife. (Kerry Blech)
To

order:

Elderberry

Records,
of

Culture

Department
Cultural
The
Charleston, WV 25305.

Virgina

History,

West
and

Center,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�an urban audience in the days before
there was such a thing as Tin Pan Alley.
Banjos, fiddles, guitars, and other "oldinstruments were played by
time"
clusters of college seniors, reigning

and

royalty

toast-of-the-town operatic

divas.

Some modern old-time players tend
songs they've learned off 78
from older players together
into the general hopper of old-time
music. No distinction is made between
songs written by rural residents from
songs written about rural residents. One
to place the
reissues or

band

that

has

made

its

bid

turn-of-the-century
the Skirtlifters.

is

Somewhere

in

Dixie

is

for

the

repertoire

popular

an

excellent

compilation of the kinds of music that
were heard on the popular stage of the
turn-of-the century: Rags, marches,
the whole nine yards. The
galops
music is entertaining and is played with a
verve and fidelity that shows these
players really understand the original
tunes.

The tape emphasizes the performance
and repertoire of the heyday of the banjo
and as such could not be in better hands
than those of Clarke Beuhling. Clarke, a
of the
American Banjo
member

Fraternity, is equally adept at the older
"stroke" (clawhammer) style and the
"classic" (three-finger) style. Among the
snappier of the offerings here are "On
the Mill Dam," "To the Front," and "The
Wild West (Galop)," the last of which
itself by having what
distinguishes
sounds like a nine-foot bullwhip
snapped across the mike! These tunes are

well placed on the tape
they open or
close the side leaving the listener with a

good "up."
There are several tunes offered here
that are pretty ear-opening for any one
interested in sources of old-time music.
A good example of the link between old
time three-finger style (a' la Frank
Jenkins or Charlie Poole) and the later
bluegrass style is the tune "Cotton
whose rapid syncopations
Pickens,"
prefigure the playing of Flint Hill's
favorite son by quite a few years. There's
also a real nice banjo duet on "Down
Georgia," whose last section bears a
striking resemblance to the B part of the
fiddle tune "Carve that Possum."

Though heavily banjo centered, the
tape greatly benefits from the playing of

fiddler

Standouts

Hawk

here

(Brian)

Hubbard.

Hubbard's
"The Wounded

include

vibrant version of
Hoosier" (complete with military-style
field drum tatoo), "Getting Upstairs/
Sandy
Boys," and "Pond Creek
Bottom." Hawk is a wonderful fiddler,
and it's a pity there isn't more of him on
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the tape.

My major problem with the tape was
inconsistent quality of the recording.
It ranged from sparkling studio clarity
like the
aforementioned
on tunes
the

"Wounded

Hoosier"

and

"Getting

mixed pieces
like "Somewhere in Dixie" and "Going
around This World." The wildly variant

Upstairs"

to fuzzy,

badly

quality of the recording robs the tape of
the strong presence that the sequencing
works so hard to build.
The tape, however, only gives a slight
idea of the vigorous performance quality
of the band in concert.
Putting aside any feeling about the

potential

lecherosity

implies, Somewhere

in

the band name
Dixie emerges as a

fine collection of '80s pop music.
1880s, that is. (Hank Sapoznik)
To

order:

Box

Harrison, AR 72601

163

Delmar

Rte.

�THE DIXIE DEWDROP: ON THE
TOP

WITH UNCLE DAVE MACON
Performed by Ralph P. Martin and
Gilles Malkine
Skylark Productions
The Dixie Bee Line/Whoah Mule/The
Old Plank Road/The Bible is True/Saro

Jane/ Walk Tom Wilson/Keep My
Skillet Good and Greasy/ Gwine Back to

Dixie/From

Earth

to

Heaven/My

Carolina Home/Rabbit in the Pea Patch
had

I

some

trepidations

about

reviewing this tape. When it came in the
mail I thought it was a reissue of Uncle
Dave Macon sides. "Hot dog!" I said, and
headed for the tape player. A closer
inspection revealed something quite
different: a selection of songs from a
recent play about Uncle Dave. I don't
subscribe to the notion that the only
good music in this world spins at 78
revolutions per minute, but Uncle Dave
has been one of my long-time favorites, a
man whose music has been often copied
if seldom equaled. His exuberant style is
compelling, but can sound forced in the
hands and mouths of others who are,
after all, not Uncle Dave. So, right or
wrong, I pressed "Play" and prepared to
be

disappointed.

was not in the cards.
The musicians had clearly studied Uncle
Dave's moves, his rolls and flourishes.
The singing was good, brassy like the old

Disappointment

man's own, and

a

banjo-guitar punched

out the familiar old Sam McGee bass
runs with confidence. "Hey," I said,
reaching for the cassette box, "who are

these guys?"
There wasn't much information. The
tape was a recording of the original score
of The Dixie Dewdrop, a play "written by
R. Santinelli and Patrick Sky, directed
by Aron Trager." The musicians were
Ralph P. Martin and Gilles Malkine. I
wanted to know more, and at length I
managed to get in contact with Patrick
Sky.
The Dixie Dewdrop was produced a few
years back in an off-Broadway theater in
New York. It got "decent" reviews and
ran for five weeks. Like many plays, it
succumbed to the enormous costs

associated
especially

with theater productions,
New York. Considerable
research into Uncle Dave's music and
career provided the raw material for the
play, and the music was honed to
reproduce the Macon sound. Ralph
Martin and Gilles Malkine, both from
the New Y ork area, acted the parts and
performed the music. One of the by
products of the play is a cassette tape of
the score that had been made available to
theater patrons at the performance.
in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

It's a good tape. Martin and Malkine
must have labored to replicate Uncle
Dave's music, but they sound comfort
able with it, not over-studied or stilted.

The
are
delivered with
songs
enthusiasm. "The Dixie Bee Line,"
"Whoah Mule," and "Saro Jane" are
particularly

strong,

and

"Walk

Tom

Wilson" is a delight. I play it repeatedly.
The second side of the tape doesn't

shine as brightly as Side A. "From Earth
seems
to
Heaven"
and
ponderous
"Rabbit in the Pea Patch" is a bit muddy
in the mix. But "Keep My Skillet Good
and Greasy" is jaunty and "Gwine Back
to Dixie" is always welcome.
Malkine
can
sound
Martin
and
Sam
like
Uncle
Dave
and
impressively
McGee, but more importantly, they
bring to these songs their own energies
and enthusiasm. The result is not more
but
fine
of the
mimicry
past,
performances in the present. (Craig

Johnson)
To order: Skylark Productions, Inc., 55

Maple

28806.

Crescent,

West Asheville,

NC

�continued from page 33
Anybody wanting the other ten rules

write their uncle, and he'll send
them. Dignity must be unheld in this day
can

and age.

Uncle

Harold

has

it

on

good

authority that D.M., of Lewisville, N.C.
would be well advised to communicate

with Frank Mare, (4176 N. Dearing
Street, Covington, GA, 30209). Frank,
who may not remember Uncle Harold's
appearance on his radio show in New
York many years ago, tells us that he's
got a complete collection of the Asher
Sizemore and Little Jimmy Bluebird 78s.
He makes tapes for people, too. Your
uncle thanks you, Frank.

Uncle Harold

has heard from

a

very

(Somehow that
far-flung nephew.
sounds strange. Your uncle only means
that he's a distant relative.) J.E.B., of

Laidon, Essex, England, wants to know
where Ridgel's Fountain Citians are
from. Their recordings for Vocalion, in
1929, include "Knick Knack Song,"
"Bald Headed End of a Broom," "Little
Birdie," and "Hallelulia to the Lamb."

Uncle Harold doesn't, oddly enough,
know the answer to this one. He bets

someone among the million-odd readers

of the OTH knows, though. Tell your
uncle.

Send your

for

Uncle Harold to

P.O. Box 1362, Galax, Va. 24333.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�PHOTO BONUS

VIRGIL &amp; MABEL ANDERSON
read
THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
Virgil's unique two-finger style of banjo picking can be heard on
County Records 777, On the Tennessee Line, and County 787 Vol 2,
Traditional Music from the Cumberland Plateau "Five Miles Out of
Town/' He and Mabel make their home in Wildcat Rock City close to
the Green Ford of the "Wild River," near Rocky Branch, Kentucky.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12165">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 1, Number 7 (Spring 1989)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12166">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12167">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 1, Number 7 (February-April 1989)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“An Interview with Sheila Adams Barnhill,” by Hilary Dirlam&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Tennessee Banjo Institute,” by Chris Wolfe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Otis Burris - Galax Breakdown Fiddler,” by Alice Gerrard with “A Personal Reminiscence,” by Hank Bradley&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music: Folklorists &amp;amp; Us – An Account of Our Curious &amp;amp; Changing Relationship,” by Mac Benford&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Traditional Dance &amp;amp; Old-Time Religion,” by David R. Peterson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Colorado,” by Eric Levine &amp;amp; Teri Rasmusson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Old-Time Music in the Piedmont,” by Joe Newberry&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Some Notated Steps of Flatfooters from Mabry Mill, in Patrick County, Virginia,” by Tina Hicks&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12168">
                <text>1989</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="971">
        <name>1989</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5428">
        <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5535">
        <name>Chris Wolfe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5518">
        <name>David R. Peterson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5539">
        <name>Eric Levine</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5431">
        <name>Hank Bradley</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5476">
        <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5517">
        <name>Mac Benford</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5537">
        <name>Otis Burris</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5534">
        <name>Shelia Adams Barnhill</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5540">
        <name>Teri Rasmusson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5536">
        <name>The Tennessee Banjo Institute</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2519" public="1" featured="1">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3445">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/b452abc38b3be95c0e3d4968bd963a0d.pdf</src>
        <authentication>8ecc466718b6db433e50048ac46e702b</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12169">
                    <text>Summer

$4.50

May-Jult

THE

HERALD

OLD-TIME
A

MAGAZINE

JOE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

DEDICATED

NATE

THOMPSON

OLD-TIME
TO

MUSIC

ODELL

1989

�16th

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Annual

Brandywine
mountain
convention

music

'89

JULY 14-16

PLEASANT VIEW STABLES KIRK ROAD
FAIR HILL, MARYLAND

"Sail Away Ladies"
WOMEN

IN OLD

TIME MUSIC

featuring

PATSY MONTANA
SAVOY-DOUCET CAJUN BAND
CRITTON HOLLOW
J. P. and ANNADEENE FRALEY
ETTA BAKER
DRY BRANCH FIRE SQUAD
THE HEARTBEATS
KENTUCKY WARBLERS
CATHY FINK and MARCY MARXER
BUD and DAVID REED
THE DIXIE HUMMINGBIRDS
Sound by Southard Audio
Friday night square dance featuring the Rural Rhythm Stringband with caller Pete LaBerge; Saturday
afternoon dance workshop and dance with The Heartbeats; Free camping in the rough; Music concessions;
Crafts;

Food;

Acres

Dance

7:30-11:30

of

the

finest

Musicians

time

old

in

the

World!

TICKETS
Friday
Saturday

Weekend

Children

under

advance

stage

A.M.-5:00 P.M

14.00

Ticket

33.00

free

12

Citizens

Senior
No

6.00
15.00

Noon-Midnight
10:00

Sunday

P.M

area;

Newark,

DE

1/2 price

ticket sales;
hr.

24

and

No

security;

Elkton,

pets

or

Motels

No

drugs;

available

alcohol
in

in

nearby

MD.

Presented

by

the

Brandywine Friends

of

Old

Time

dedicated to
organization
preserving and presenting traditional American folk
Music,

a

non-profit

music.

For

more

information,

call

(302

475-3454

or

write

Bo*

3504,

Greenville,

DE

19807

�The OLD-TIME HERALD
Vol. 1 No. 8
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
Rt. 2, Box A-l

Woodlawn, VA 24381

703-236-7808
Editor

Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Brad Leftwich

Linda Higginbotham

Hilary Dirlam

Dance Editor
Phil Jamison

Advertising
Dale Morris
Ann Erwin

Administrative Consultant
Bobby Patterson

No

part

of

this

magazine

may

be

reproduced in any form without written
permission from the publisher. Not
responsible for loss or non-return of
unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
1987 The Old-Time Herald
The Old-Time Herald (ISSN 1040358)
(USPS 002672) is published quarterly
the first of August,
November,
February, and May by the Old-Time
Music Group, Inc. Rt. 2 Box A-l,
Woodlawn, VA 24381. Subscription
rates payable in advance. One year

$15.00

(foreign subscriptions $18.00
U.S.). Classified ads cost .50 cents per
word, minimum of $7.00. Any
of letters or numbers is
grouping
counted as one word. All classified ads
must be received by the first of the
month, one month prior to publication.

Second

Class

postage

Woodlawn, VA 24381.

paid

at

POSTMASTER: Send change of address
to the Old'Time Herald, P.O. Box
1362, Galax, VA 24333.
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. is a
not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation
under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal
Revenue Code.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Letters
The

Old-Time Herald welcomes

They should
signed. They

letters.

be typed or neatly written,
may be edited and we will

and

print
available. The

them according to space
opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect

those of the

Old-Time Herald.

Sorry-It seems to me that I should by now
have received my 1st quarterly edition of

glorious and much
periodical. Woe, there is

your

a

anticipated
pestilence

upon this land and yea verily it has not
come! There is much wailing and
gnashing of teeth!
John Carr

Boulder, CO
[We

received

a

number

of

letters

whereabouts of the
inquiring
spring OTH. We apologize for getting it
out late-about

the

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�On the Other Hand

...

It's good to see that some things never

change, such
sage Harold

as

the spectacle of elder

working
[Hausenfluck]
cantankerous and
(We've
got a rocker
reserved for you on the porch, Harold.) I

overtime at
judgemental.

being

us "young folks" are just getting
too comfortable with the notion of "o-t"
music as an evolving style. Thanks for
straightening us out, Harold.

guess

recognizably different from any styles
being played anywhere today. Old-timey
will continue to be a very small back

water

the

in

just hope that some of it will be good
tunes that make you want to
and most
to cry,
to laugh,
importantly, that make you want to
learn to play them, in whatever fashion
suits you. Only then will old-time music
live on.
I

music:
dance,

Rich Ganns

to us.

Tony Goldenberg
Carol Sword
Seattle, WA
find the controversy over "what is
old-timey," and "where do these
I

youngsters get off claiming they play old
time music" all very stimulating, but it's
nothing new. Throughout history, every

craft, and skill, and art form has had its
preservers and its innovators, and they
ALWAYS argue. It's a fact of life. 'The
old ways are the best" is a sentiment that
sounds through the ages. The funny
thing is that both kinds of practitioners
are crucial to the survival of tradition.
The preservers strive to duplicate the
techniques of their predecessors in order
to keep the history and tradition current.
The innovators apply outside influences
to
the traditional
and techniques
methods and keep the craft from
stagnating by attracting new blood. Of
course they are usually loathed by the
preservers since their goals are
essentially antithetical. But, in the big
the preservers
change the
picture,

tradition because they are imperfect
copyists, and the innovators don't have a
tremendous impact either, because they
do not diverge all that much, or, if they
tend not to be linked,
do,
they
historically, with the tradition. Besides,
both groups are a minority; most of the

practitioners are just average people
without extraordinary talents, who keep
alive simply by
the tradition
participating.
In

100

majority

years, I
of old-time

predict that the
music will sound

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

like.

Daniel Steinberg
Menlo Park, CA

Houghton, MI
We be fans of the "popcorn" fiddle
style and respect the talents of its prac
titioners. We also recognize the elastic
yet sealed inner circle in any arts scene,
old-time music not excepted.
With regard to Harold Hausenfluck's
opinions, well, it sounds like sour grapes

mainstream

music. And people will
still be arguing over what it should sound

contemporary

When
friends',

I
I

saw
was

the winter

issue

at

a

delighted to see Bruce

picture and article, and the
old-time music in Japan.
about
piece

Molsky's

Barbara Panter

Tucker, GA

�Nancy

Kalow

Walter W illiams and W. M. Stepp. It is a
tension that helps propel their music
along and creates an underlying sense of
anticipation for the listener. Both men
fine singers though they have
are
different vocal styles. Joe's voice is
smooth, Odell's keen and penetrating.

Joe

and

cousins and were raised on farms in
northeastern Orange County in the
piedmont of North Carolina. Family
tradition has it that the family lived in
neighboring Parson County before the

Odell

Civil War.

Thompson
By

That the banjo first developed

Wayne Martin

as

an

African-American

tradition, or that
scores of white musicians from Dan
Emmett to Leonard Rutherford to Bill
Monroe have been influenced by black
fiddlers,

banjo players and guitarists

is

common knowledge among most old-time
music enthusiasts. Historical

not the case with Joe and Odell
Simply stated they play
some of the most compelling old-time
dance tunes to be heard today. Hearing
them render a piece like "Old Corn
Liquor" or "Hook and Line" is
convincing proof that a well-played

Such

once

size.

in

black

communities

throughout the South. Yet, to actually
hear string band music played by black

musicians

today

is

rare

indeed.

black communities during
early years of this century, and
accelerating after World War II, fiddle

Beginning

in

the

banjo music has been increasingly
replaced by other styles of dance music.
Black fiddle and banjo players are now
few in number, and those musicians who
are still active are often advanced in age
and past their prime.
and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

duet is music enough to
set of dancers. Their tunes are

fiddle-banjo
inspire

thrived

is

Thompson.

evidence taken from both written
sources and from oral accounts is
fiddle and banjo music
convincing

a

power, that they seem to
expand to fill a room, no matter what its
full

so

of

good old-time musicians,
Odell work together as a close
team.
Joe's
patterned bowing and
judicious selection of melody notes is
supported in kind by Odell's infrequent
Like many

Joe and

use of double-thumbing and his ability
out the special
to
rhythmic
bring
character of each of their tunes. A
tension exists in their playing which is
reminiscent of the banjo-fiddle interplay
in the music
of masters like Fred

Cockerham

and

Tommy

They alternate the singing of verses in a
and
way that builds excitement
momentum in their music as well as adds
variety to the repeated strains of fiddle
tunes.
Joe and Odell play mainly regional
dance tunes, including more commonly
played tunes like "Molly Put the Kettle
On" and "Soldiers Joy" as well as nowrare pieces like "Pumpkin Pie," "Ryro's
House," "Donna's Got A Rambling
Mind" and the aforementioned "Old
Corn Liquor." Blues songs like "Careless
a
few
Love" and
religious
pieces
including "Lights In the Valley" and
"Will the Circle Be Unbroken" round
out their repertoire.
Joe, born December 9, 1918, and
Odell, born August 9, 1911, are first-

Jarrell,

or

JOE: All the Thompsons come from
Leesburg, Person County. A man called
Walter Thompson had so many slaves,
said he give them his name, that's where
we got the Thompsons from. And he had
so much land and stuff, he gave them all a
place up the road and right now it's
called Thompson Road down there in
Leesburg. That's where they came out
from.
Joe and

Odell's fathers, John Arch and

Walther
1

were born in the
Thompson,
88o's. Their childhoods were spent on the

farm where they learned how to grow
tobacco, corn, wheat, and other crops that
brought some income to the family. Along
with an older brother Jake,

they were share-

cropping for white farmers by the turn of the
While working on shares, the
century.
brothers came into frequent
Thompson
contact with white farm workers who played
string band music.

JOE:

Big

white

folks

kept

a

lot

of

colored people around them all the time,
in the kitchen, and in the field, and
everywhere. They were into everything,

all through the house; this is the way they
were raised up. A white man would have
four or five houses and he'd have black
people in them, they were working a

half-crop, half-shares.

�blues!

JOE: My brother, two years above me,
he had learned to play the banjo and my
daddy said, "Boy, you're going to be a
good banjo player. Next week 1 want you
to take that banjo and sit here and just
claw-hammer. I don't want you to put
that left hand on nothing." He made that
boy play two weeks exactly, never played

especially the music of

tune, just done this [makes
clawhammer motion with right hand] till
he [father] was satisfied. Then when
a

the

important influence
of white tradition upon John Arch and his
brother's music. Yet it seems that numerous
black fiddle and banjo players were active in
Joe

acknowledges

the area as well,

and that the Thompsons

were also influenced

by

them.

JOE: There was a fellow they called Imp
Wright. Now he was black. My daddy

said that man was something else on the

fiddle. He could make it whistle.
And Johnny Wade was a heavy banjo
player. He used to sit by the tobacco
barn every night. He'd be curing tobacco
and sit out there and you could hear him
clean across the country. That man
could play it too! My uncle Jake said
"that's the only man I dread
Johnny

Wade."

ODELL: He played the clawhammer

style, played the same tunes that we play.
My daddy played with him and I played
with him when I was young.

John Arch learned to play both fiddle and
banjo; Walter and Jake concentrated on the
banjo. As they became more skilled with
their music,

their reputation spread among

surrounding communities. They began to
play at dances for blacks and whites, but
with either group were usually careful to stop
before midnight on Saturday. Joe remembers
hearing his father tell about an experience
that occurred one night when they broke their
rule and played past twelve o'clock.

JOE: My daddy, and his brother, great
day in the morning, they were good, too!
Once in a while my daddy would take a
drink, then he wasn't too steady. But
when that dude was level, he was tough.
He said they used to play for the white
folks every Saturday night. And he said
he played one Sunday morning, until 3
o'clock, him and Jake, for some big-time
white folks. He said they had done drunk
whiskey and played the banjo and fiddle
and called a set. And they stopped and
sat down and the ashes and coals came
out of the fireplace by themselves. And
Jake said "time for us to go home." And
my daddy would never allow us to play
on Sunday.
With music-making so prevalent in the
family, Joe and Odell became interesed in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Nate went back to playing he was gone!
I
couldn't do nothing; I wasn't but
five or six years old. And I got to getting
my daddy's fiddle and he said, "Boy,
you're gonna tear my fiddle up, you
leave it alone."
My mama's first cousin was over one
day and my mama was talking about
Nate playing the banjo and said "and this
boy here wants a fiddle." He said, "Well
Rosie, I've got one I'm going to give him.
Let him come after it." So I walked and
got that fiddle and put it in a sack and
came back home. And me and my
brother looked at it and he said, "It's a
good fiddle, ain't it." And it needed two
strings. I said, "I know where some
strings are. Let's go get them out of the
screen door." We got a pair of pliers and
we pulled them strings out. And I put
them on and got to messing. In a couple
of days I had learned "Hook and Line,"
and when my daddy came in that
evening, my mother told my brother,
"show him what you can do." So he got
to playing the banjo and I got to playing
the fiddle. And he said, "God durn boy,
you playing that thing, ain't you." Then
he got his fiddle down and me and him
both were messing. And a couple of days
later he gave me his fiddle. And from
that day on, I've come to where I am
now.
I was only
And we were playing sets
seven years old. We had straight chairs

Although
some

tunes,

on fiddle
Joe concentrated
blues impressed him as well,
a

local man named

Tom Jake.

JOE: See, everywhere back in those days
they carried guitars, they toted banjos,
and they walked a whole lot. And way
about 11:00 at night, you'd hear him
coming in playing that "Careless Love."
Boy, I'm telling you he was playing up
that music too. It was beautiful. I sure
did like to hear him sing "Dig that grave
with a silver spade, and lower him down

with

a

golden chain."

The music heard at community dances
reflected the popularity of both fiddle music
and blues during the 1920s and '30s.
Guitars provided accompaniment for fiddles
and banjos during square dances, and were
played solo for dancers who wanted to hear
blues and rags for the slow drags, two-steps
or buck

dances.

JOE: Fiddles and banjos would play for
the square dances. Then the square
dancers would take a break and while
they were taking a break they'd call the
guitars in there and they'd play for the

Black-Bottom,

and

Charleston,

Breakaway
two-stepping and
kind of stuff.

ODELL:
and banjos

Liquor" or

all

and

that

sometimes the fiddles
would get to playing "Corn
something like that and I'd

And

take that old guitar and bass along. My
brother, he would do the same thing.
Sounded good in there, too.
The banjo style heard at dances seems
have mainly been clawhammer, at least
the black community.

to

in

my feet and my brother's feet
couldn't touch the floor. And we was
and

running them folks, man,

ODELL: Back then

a

half

an

hour.

sold chewing gum.
could sell packs of chewing gum and
turn all the money in and get a premium
fiddle or turn half the money in and keep
the other half. So I turned all the money
in and got me a premium fiddle. Joe's
I

I

got me started and I played the
fiddle for several years. And I could hit a
tune a little on the banjo.
Then I went and took up the guitar.
My brother had a guitar, and so I bought
and me and him got started
a guitar
playing together. I'm telling you right
now, every guitar player was full of the
daddy

Gerrard

it.

playing at a young age. Joe's older brother
Nate also showed a talent for music, which
John Arch tried to encourage.

Alice

Our fathers were working for crop
with the Pittards and the Tinnins back
down there near Cedar Grove in East
Orange County. Sharecropping tobacco,
that was the main crop. They would play
music, the white folks; that's where they
(John Arch, Walter and Jake) got it
from. These are the ones they said they
learned from. I don't know whether they
made music together or not. .but they
had to do it right smart together to learn

Odell with wife, Susie; Joe, 1988

�ODELL: When

I

remember what

was first old enough to
banjo was, that was the

were

they

way

a

clawhammer

playing

style.

the

it

They

called

"thumping" the banjo. I didn't
nothing about picking no banjo.

it

know

JOE: I think, more or less, the white
folks mostly played picking. All the
black
people I know of played

clawhammer.

ODELL: There used

to be a lot of banjo
players back there then, a gob of banjo
players. My mama's sister used to play
the banjo. She used to play that "Every
Man Gets in Tough Luck Sometimes."
Long tall Willie Crisp, he used to play a
banjo. Dick Bratcher, Charles White,
daddy Walt Thompson, Dink
my
oh man, there used
Roberts over here
to be several banjo players. My mama's
brother, he was a banjo player. He used
to play a tune that I've been trying to
I can't
think of
get that tune in my
"Shake That Buffalo."
mind

JOE: They [the older generation of
banjo players] took the frets out of their
they said you could get along
banjos
better, play better music that way. My
brother, the first couple of banjos he
played, my daddy had taken the frets out
of them. But when he got his own banjo,
he didn't take them out. He found out he
didn't have to do it.

ODELL:

think they used a lot of Black
cheap strings. But let me
say this though; you don't get strings like
they had back then. Looks to me like
strings back then would just last, and last
a long time. But you can get and put a set
of strings on today, and if you play very
much, those strings will soon go dead.
I

Bill

Boyarsky

Diamonds

Apparently, fiddlers were somewhat more
scarce than banjo players. Joe patterned his
playing after his father, though there were
differences in the styles of father and son.

JOE:
light,

was always
My daddy,
he couldn't half hear me. Said I
need a heavy bow. Now for a
he

said

I

would
whole lot of folks, it [bowing] don't
make much difference. But most white
people like to hear that bow shuffle. But
black people, it don't bother them. To
hear it, that's all they want.
a musician must
I'll tell you though

learn that music

is

a

smooth thing. The

smoother you get it, the better it is. You
see, it's a whole lot like a garden with

rows in it. If you tear that garden up with
a hoe, it'll go level, but if you try to go
across that row. .your music will do the
same way. You have got to take
advantage of it and learn how to make it
go

smooth.

Joe,

Odell,

and

Nate

played

music

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dink Roberts 1976

throughout

the

1930s.

Yet

because

of

black community, and
choices
they themselves
through personal
made, their music-making began to slow

changing tastes

in the

down as World War

II

approached.

ODELL: I got to where I didn't like the
blues, that's how come I quit the guitar.
You go off playing the guitar sometimes
and looks like you get all dissatisfied and
all that. And with the blues it'll just wind
up you leaving your old lady or falling
out with your girlfriend and all that kind
of stuff. That's what the blues is. The
blues is the blues!
And when we came out of service,
everybody had TV's and radios and
things. Everywhere you went, people
already had all the music they wanted to
hear, you see. As far as going around
playing, we went for almost 20 years not

playing nothing.
JOE: Dances were slowing up in '38,
'39, and '40. A little bit of dancing was
going on but it was breaking off sharply
then. Back in those days the guitars got
to coming out, then piccolos
[juke
boxes]. And changing over to rock and
roll, that's the biggest thing that stopped
it all.

Nate moved away
Work was slow and

in the early 1950s.
he needed to keep

his family going. He couldn't get a job in
this area. He moved to Philadelphia; he
went to work in a place where you make

automobile parts.

1970s, Joe and Odell were
folklore graduate student from
the University of North Carolina who was
In

the early

visited

by a

researching
traditions.

African-American

music

�ODELL: And then what caused

us to go

again
Kip Lornell came
through seeking this old-time music. He
talked us into going back to playing. And
when I was young, I would strike a tune
on a banjo every now and then. I could
play by ear and could follow most any
tune. So it wasn't no trouble for me to
get back onto the banjo. And I've found I
get more kick and more fun out of the
banjo than anything else.

Band.

work

to

JOE: He found my sister and said, do
you have a brother that plays a fiddle?
And she brought him over where I was.
And that day, that's what got us started
back. He didn't turn us loose until he
told us we could do it, until he got us
going. And he really did bring us through
it.

Although their music

making music also.
were

gaining

By

the

national

the

mid-1980s they
recognition

by

accepting invitations to perform at the
Festival of American Fiddle Tunes, the
National Folk Festival, the Chicago Folk
Festival and the Tennessee Banjo Institute.
The audiences that have acclaimed them in
recent years are white; recognition within
community has been harder
especially
among younger blacks.
gain,
their own

behind

it

yourself and use

by

future.

However future generations may value
their music, they look with pride at the music
they have made over the past 60 years and
continue to derive great satisfaction from
playing the old-time tunes. As Joe explains:

When the bow is right, the strings are
right, the room sounds good, then you

can enjoy it. I enjoy it so myself it makes
me feel good. I can play my own self
happy. I have to holler sometimes, when
get to playing
that's right."

you

good,

know.

So

NOTE:

The quotations contained in this
article were synthesized from interviews
conducted in August and December, 1988
with assistance from Alice Gerrard. A
cassette tape of Joe and Odell's music has
been recorded

early

27302,

or,

be

available

in the

write

For

Joe
information
268, M ebane, NC
Odell Thompson, Rt 5 Box 115,

spring.

Thompson,

and will

Rt.

4

Box

M ebane, NC 27302

W.M.

to

JOE: Young folks like rock and roll
music better than the square dance
music. But I tell you what, folks are
beginning to ask me questions: "Look
here man, where'd you go last weekend?"
And I said we played in a festival. They
began trying to find out more and more.
And it's getting around in the
neighborhood more, you know.
So this is coming back now, but see,
what's going to hurt, especially with
blacks, ain't nobody trying to learn this.
And you don't learn this stuff overnight.
Music is a gift, but you got to work it out.
It ain't going to work itself out. You got
to get

not embraced

revivalist
interest
urban,
of young,
that
their
the
tunes
musicians,
possibility
and style of playing may survive into the

I

Odell re-entered

public arena
with appearances
at regional
festivals.
Though living in Philadelphia, Nate's
interest was re-awakened by Joe and Odell's
enthusiasm for playing, and he began
Joe and

is

their community as fully these days as when
they were younger, Joe and Odell see, in the

it.

North Carolinian Wayne Martin is a fiddler
and works for the Folklife Section of the
North Carolina Arts Council. He makes his
home

in

Durham,

N.C.J

I

mean, it's a gift, but you just got to work
it, you just got to work it.

expect they really got it now. I wouldn't
doubt it. They learned, got up there on
stage and won the prize. They did so
good they named the band the Jo-Dell
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gerrard

are

dead now, nobody is playing the music
around this whole community, for miles
and miles, but Joe and myself. We are
trying to carry it on as long as we can,
you see. But we ain't no babies.
A bunch we trained that time we were
in Seattle, Washington [at the Festival of
American Fiddle Tunes], that bunch, I

Alice

ODELL: All of these old people

�BIG

my

first

Big

Shaped-note singing is not really
foreign to traditional music followers,
but most

the later seven-shape
method. Southern Harmony is similar to
also distinctly
but
Sacred Harp,
different. Many of the similarities result
from the fact that the men responsible
for the two styles were brothers-in-law.
William "Singin' Billy" Walker was
born in South Carolina in 1809, and in
1835 released the first edition of The
Southern Harmony and Musical

1988

22,

familiar with the Sacred

are

style,

Harp

SINGIN'
May

attended

and

comings

Singin' in 1987.

or

Companion. The story goes that, even
though he had been assisted by Benjamin
Franklin White, Walker took full credit

book.
the
Feeling
White
proceeded
wronged,
sufficiently
to leave South Carolina for Georgia and
compile his own book. In 1884 the
Sacred Harp was first published.
for

compiling

Both

Southern

and

Harmony

Sacred

based on a scale system
containing four shapes, Faw (a triangle),
Sol (a circle) Law (a square) and Mi (a
diamond). An octave is then represented
Harp

by

are

faw-sol-law-faw-sol-law-mi-faw.

From its infancy in the late 1700s, this
style of unaccompanied vocal music has
been called "fasola singing."
The differences in style and present
ation between the two are subtle.
Southern Harmony is sung more slowly
than Sacred Harp, and the former

concentrates

Ray

Bowman

on three-part
harmony
while the revised versions of the later
favor four parts. The striking thing to
note is that Southern Harmony had a
real run of popularity for a while.
During its three original printings, The

The courtroom

at

By

pleasant atmosphere compared to the
cool, slow drizzle outside on this fourth
Sunday of May. Since 1983, this date has
been set aside in Benton, Kentucky, as
a

Big Singin'.

of
western
corner
in
the
far
Lake
Kentucky
of the commonwealth, has long been a
bastion of Southern Harmony singing. It
may well be the last stronghold of this
particular style of shaped-note singing. If
of the area,
I speak with some familiarity
Marshall

County,

on the shores

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Musical

in

the

early

part

of

this

is

Sunday in May. There are
stories about the railroads having to run
special trains to accomodate the influx of
singers and onlookers. Recent crowds
have been considerably smaller, but the
event continues to draw its faithful
followers from around the country and
Of this year's
the world.
around
gathering, one participant had come
from Great Britain and still another from
the fourth

because

I

grew

up

there,

hearing

incredible crowds that
would flock to the courthouse each year
stories

of

the

and of how many
of
my relatives had parti
generations
cipated both as singers and leaders. At
that time, however, caring little about
my heritage, I wouldn't have been caught
dead there! My, how times and attitudes
have changed.
Some 35 years after being born in
Benton and about 18 years after leaving
here to attend college and start a
for

and

evidenced by the stories told
of the population of the city of Benton
swelling by the thousands each year on
century

Ray Bowman
it's

Harmony

Companion sold around 600,000 copies,
Its
William Walker.
to
according

popularity

Marshall County Courthouse filled with singers and listeners

courtroom of
The second-floor
Marshall County's courthouse provided

Southern

the

singing,

profession,

I

finally realized my short

Sweden.
On this day, as is the custom, there are
two sessions, one in the morning and one
after lunch, or "dinner" as my fellow
Marshall countians usually refer to the
midday meal. During the early years of
this festival it was customary to observe

�"dinner on the ground" or picnic-style
lunches on the courthouse lawn. With
the coming of fast food, co the area, that
practice began dying -6ut, but some still
choose the traditional ways (with the
addition of the non-traditional cooler
here and there, but for food and mild
beverage only). Even with the inter
mittent showers, some hearty souls took
to the benches in front of the stately old

courthouse for their repast.
The combined attendance might well
be 400 or better, though no one really
counts. The numbers don't really matter

long as the singing's good. Suffice it to
that
the relatively
spacious
courtroom was filled to capacity, with
many being forced to stand around the
perimeter of the room. I've been to many
a folk festival and concert and most of
them take on the feeling of a reunion
when performers and fans mingle to
renew old friendships and establish new
ones. The atmosphere was the same at
this event, albeit somewhat more sedate
given the nature of music to be enjoyed.
As the singing session begins, the man
who calls things to order and serves as
as

that in

a

bit.

the leaders
are
designated beforehand, and each leads
two selections. Leaders seldom use pitch
pipes or even the more traditional tuning
fork to establish pitch, choosing rather

Customarily,

their own
also, who defer
"pitch" the song.
pitched for each
"lead," and "bass,"
to trust

ear.

to

There are those
other leaders to

When

the

song

is

part, called "treble,"
the leader begins the

tune, directing with stately up-and-down
and side-by-side motions, calling out the
rests with such statements as "down,
the
The first time through,
left."
syllables assigned to the shapes are sung.
Then the leader announces "by the line,"
a signal for the words to be sung the next
time through. What results is a stirring,
antique sound that has been described as

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ray

Harmony and Musical Companion.

being like anything from

monk's chant
accompaniment.

all

a bagpipe to a
done without

of Southern
original singers
learned
to
Harmony
sing shape by
attending old-time singing schools. An
The

abbreviated version of one of the schools
on October 17, 1987, at
the University of Kentucky's Memorial
Hall to commemorate the latest reissue
of the book, [see review, p. 38] Dr.
Wilcox was also responsible for the
editing of this edition and was present to
conduct the school and the short singing
that followed. Honored guests of the day
were some of the Benton singers, the
very people responsible for taking the
tradition of Big Singin' into its 105th
was recreated

around the country, Big Singin' may be
around to be enjoyed by many
generations to come.
Singer /songwriter multi-instrumentalist
Ray Bowman is a native Kentuckian who
divides his time between organizing and
leading shapea-ncte sings, solo performing
and playing guitar,
blues and ballads,
mandolin and fiddle with the Frankfortbased Bald Knob String Band.

year.

The new Southern Harmony edition

handsomely
volume and
Press

of

Recordings

available
President,
of

is

bound

is

a

red-and-gold

available from University

Kentucky

in

Lexington.

of the Benton Singers are
through Dr. Ray Mofield,

Society for the Preservation
Southern Harmony Singing, Inc.,

Benton, KY 42025.

According to a plaque at the court
house, placed there by the National
Music Council as part of the country's
Bicentennial Celebration, Big Singin' is
the "oldest indigenous musical tradition
in the U.S." With the publishing of new
books and the interest of young shapednote singers in Marshall County and

Bowman

attend, the music is ready to begin. Faith
ful singers gently cradle copies of the
1939 reprint of Southern Harmony
published as part of the WPA writers
program. Others use the 1966 version,
also out of print, which was edited by
Dr. Glenn C. Wilcox. Original copies of
the manuscript still exist, but few are
willing to risk bringing out such a prized
possession. This year, for the first time
since the 1966 edition was sold out, new
copies are being sold and used. More on

Glenn C. Wilcox conducts an abbreviated version of an old-fashioned singing school at the
University of Kentucky to commemorate the publication of the 1987 facsimile edition of The Southern

Dr.

Ray

moderator for the afternoon is Dr. Ray
Mofield of Benton, president of the
Society for the Preservation of Southern
Harmony.
Following the reading of letters and
telegrams from well-wishers unable to

Bowman

say

Mrs. O.D. McKendree
Southern

holds

Harmony reprint.

a

copy of the 1966

�folk

HERE
&amp;

THERE
IN &amp;
By

AROUND D.C.
Julianne

Mangin

D.C. metropolitan
(which includes the suburbs of
Maryland and northern Virginia) has a
population that is as culturally diverse as
The Washington,

area

one might expect of the capital of the
United States. Residents of this area who
are devotees of just about any traditional
music, dance, or folklore are likely to
find it here in the D.C. area.
The Folklore Society of Greater
Washington (FSGW), which was

founded in the 1960s, "is a non-profit,
educational organization dedicated to
preserving and promoting traditional

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the Washington,
D.C.
area."
is
Membership
open
metropolitan
to all, even beyond the D.C. area, and
includes a subscription to their monthly
art

in

newsletter. Members are either admitted
free to FSGW events, or are admitted at
reduced rates. The FSGW Newsletter's
main function is to inform members
about traditional programs occurring in
the D.C. area and is not limited to those
programs sponsored by FSGW itself.
FSGW sponsors an annual festival at
Glen Echo Park in early June every
year, which is intended to present to the
residents of the D.C. area the many folk
traditions practiced within the region.

Past

festivals

traditions from

have

included

folk

the globe, not
the least of which are the traditions of
the southern Appalachian Mountains.
all over

Two other programs that FSGW
sponsors are a "Get-Away" every
October and the Chesapeake Dance
Weekend every April. Appalachian
old-time music and dance (both clogging
and square dance) are regularly featured
at

these events.
Glen Echo Park in Glen Echo, Md.,

is

of miles outside
Washington D.C.'s northwest quadrant.
Its history
begins in the late 19th

just

a

couple

century, when

it

was built to serve as

a

National Chautauqua Center, a cultural
and educational movement of the late
19th and early 20th century. From the
turn of the century to 1968, Glen Echo
was an amusement park with many

attractions,

including

rides

and

a

ballroom.
Although the music played at the
ballroom was predominatly "big band"

music, the first square dance was called
there in 1948 by Ralph Case. Since
1971, Glen Echo Park has been run
under the auspices of the National Park

Service,

which

makes

the

facility

various cultural
During warm weather (the
ballroom is unheated), Glen Echo's
Spanish Ballroom is the site of both a
available
activities.

for

use

in

dance, sponsored by
a
and
FSGW,
Friday-night dance,
sponsored by the Dance Committee
(not affiliated with FSGW). The dances
continue in warmer quarters during the

Sunday-night

fall, winter, and early spring.

Both dances feature a
Appalachian squares, New

mix

of

England
squares, and contra dances. The evening
usually ends with a waltz. The Sundaynight dance is considered to be the more
advanced of the two, with little teaching,

�short walk-throughs, and consequently,
more time spent dancing. Dancers in the
D.C. area are especially enamored of
New England contra dances. If you really
want to dance to southern old-time
music, the best place to go is Capt.
White's Oyster Bar and Clog Palace.
Since January 1985, the venue for
listening and clogging to old-time music
has been Capt. White's Oyster Bar (and
Clog Palace) in Silver Spring, Md. An
arrangement with the restaurant
management allows the use of the dining
room for these weekly gatherings. All other
details such as booking
organizational
informal

sound systems,
for
and
admission,
paying the band
collecting
are the responsibility of the Daily Clog. In
addition to being the driving force behind

bands,

the

arranging

Clog

Palace,

the

Daily

Clog

is

a

newsletter concerned with old-time music
and dance. It contains articles and a
calendar of old-time events in the D.C. area
and beyond.

Every Thursday night, with the arrival of
the musicians and dancers, Capt. White's
In
the
the
becomes
Clog Palace.
of
the
hub
it
is
D.C.
area,
Washington,
most of the old-time music and dance
activity. Starting around 9:00 p.m. and

continuing after midnight, the Clog PaLce
features an old-time string band playing
music for free-style clogging. Although the

Clog Palace patrons' interests include other
forms of traditional music, on Thursday
nights they have come to expect an evening
of hard-driving southern old-time music
suitable for clogging. Among its many
unusual features, the Clog Palace is the
only place known to have clogging on a
regular basis beneath a revolving disco hall
with multi-colored reflected lights.
The D.C. area has several established
string bands that appear at the Clog Palace.
They include the Double Decker String
Band, featuring Craig Johnson on fiddle,
Bruce Hutton on banjo and John Beam
on guitar. Of the local active bands, Double
Decker has been together the longest. Their
repertoire includes dance tunes and vocal
numbers that allow Craig to demonstrate
his talents both in fiddle and in song.
Steve Hickman is a popular local
fiddler who plays in a band called
Fiddlestyx, with John Devine on guitar
and Jim Bieneman on bass. Steve also
plays fiddle and dances with the Fiddle
Puppets, a remarkable dance team that
presents clogging, step dance, tap dance,
hamboning, and more. The other members
of the group include Rodney Sutton and
Eileen Carson (both formerly of the
Green Grass Cloggers), Amy Sarli, and

Matt Gordon.

Roustabout is another local string band
Chris Romaine on fiddle, Lars

with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Hanslin

on banjo, and various local guitar

players. When Craig Johnson plays guitar
with Roustabout, it creates an opportunity
for the musicians to switch instruments.
With Lars covering rhythm guitar, Chris
and Craig switch between fiddle and banjo.
Chris Romaine, known mostly for his
fiddle playing, has a considerable talent for
playing clawhammer banjo as well.
Bruce and Audrey Molsky have made
their home in the D.C. area for the past
couple of years, and play at the Clog Palace
from time to time. Rob Caruthers,
another local fiddler, also plays frequently
at

the Clog Palace.
Other active old-time

bands

include,

Goin' Crazy (Claudio Buchwald, Pete
McClurkin, John O'Loughlin, and Jim
and
Hambone Sweets
Bieneman),

(Karen Collins, Fred Feinstein,

Pete

WAMU (88.5 FM)

has the most
week for folk,
acoustic, and bluegrass music in the D.C.
area. It is part of American University,
which is in northwest D.C., but it's
broadcast range includes all of D.C. as well

broadcasting

hours

per

"open band" nights, it is still a place where
musicians and dancers meet and socialize.
This makes it a perfect place to find out

who's having a jam session at their house
during the coming weekend.
As in any urban area, there are
radio stations as there are exits

as

many

on

the

Capital Beltway.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Grass

10 years at festivals, fairs, and other events.
Other teams in the area are the Turkeys
the

Dick Spottswood,

the host, plays a wide
music. He is especially
knowledgeable about vintage old-time and
Cajun music, and includes both frequently

of folk

variety

in his play list. Each

show

is

devoted

in part

announcing traditional music and dance
events in the area.
WETA (90.9 FM) broadcasts out of
to

northern

whose

While the Clog Palace does not have any

that the Green

on the Run, the Stump Jumpers, and

outlying areas in Maryland and Virginia.
you are looking for hard-core southern
old-time music, your best bet is on
Sundays from 11:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.

play-

various bands, one can see that there are
quite a few musicians playing in more than
one band. This is perhaps a sign of how

and shoes

[Cloggers] made popular. The Footloose
Cloggers have been performing for over

as

old-time musicians in this area can't have
enough opportunities to get together and

O'Loughlin, and Sid
Nethery). By looking at the rosters of the
John

costumes tend to be the old-timey

clothes

If

Virginia, and its mainstay is
classical music. However, on Saturday
nights from 7:30 p.m. to 1:00 a.m.,
Mary Cliff is the host of "Traditions,"
which features folk and acoustic music.
of
announcements
She
also makes
upcoming traditional programs.
The D.C. area has several clogging teams

McClurkin,

their

performances

are

modeled

after

those of the Green Grass Cloggers. They
always perform to live, old-time music, and

Contacts:

Folklore Society of Greater Washington
P.O. Box 5693, Friendship Pleights
Station
Washington, D.C. 20016

Telephone Hotline (703) 281-2228
The Dance Committee
P.O. Box 1811
Washington, D.C. 20013
Dance Hotline: (301) 270-1678

Capital Area Bluegrass &amp; Old-Time Music

Association (CABOMA)

Boone, membership chair
7579 Woodstown Drive
Springfield, VA 22153
is
a
This
bluegrass
predominatly
They
sponsor picking
organization.
sessions and an annual festival at Glen
Bill

Echo Park.

Cranberry Cloggers.

The Deer Creek Fiddlers
Convention in Westminister, Md. some
40 miles north of D.C., is a competition for
both old-time and bluegrass musicians. It is
held twice in the summer, once in June, and

again in August, at the Carroll County
Farm
Museum. The D.C. area is
represented among the entrants as well as
Maryland, Pennsylvania, and Delware.

Fiddlehead Music

&amp;.

Dance Week

is

relatively new dance camp that is based in
This year, its third,
Md.
Baltimore,
some
fine
Fiddlehead featured
very
a

musicians, dancers, and callers on its staff:
The Horseflies, the Fiddle Puppets, Larry
the Critton
and
Hollow
Edelman,
Stringband, to name just a few. It is a

wonderful camp that is just packed with
activities for the old-time music and dance
fan.

The Daily Clog
Published and edited by Julie Mangin
95 E. Wayne Avenue, Apt. 312
Silver Spring, MD 20901

(301) 495-0082
$6.00 per year for

12 issues

A free sample of the newsletter

is

avail-able

upon request.
The House of Musical Traditions
7040 Carroll Avenue

Takoma Park, MD 20912

(301) 270-909
If

0

you are new to the D.C.

area,

this

is

where to go to tap into the traditional
music and dance scene.
Trina Royar

Fiddlehead Music &amp;. Dance Week
3139 Abell Avenue

MD 21218
(301) 235-2924
Baltimore,

�heritage. The following is a survey of the
many and varied old-time music activities
and festivals happening in the area. It
should be noted that many events which
include old-time music are not always

outside the region, so it may
persistent traveller to find the
smaller music gatherings in the mountains.
Those who do find their way up the
winding roads to the square dances,
concerts, and festivals will be treated to a
some of the best old-time music this side of
publicized
take

a

the Blue Ridge.
Much of the music that gets played
around here still gets played in living rooms
the
winter, and front porches in
summer. If you're lucky, you might hear
the fiddle king of the south, Marion
Sumner, as he plays a local dance or
teaches a lesson at his home in Isom,
Kentucky. A native of Hazard, Marion has
been a side man for Jim and Jesse, Kitty
in

Wells, Chet Atkins, and Kenny Baker,

and appeared on the Mid-day Merry-Go-

Round

at

WNOX

in

Knoxville

for

a

number of years. He learned extensively
from Arthur Smith and can spend hours
playing tunes he learned from Smith. A
long-standing tradition in the mountains is

Carcassonne Community Center

square dance
every

third

near

Saturday,

Blackey, Kentucky,
usually with the

Recordings

the

Appal

Cumberland Valley Boys. Lee Sexton,

talented two-finger-style banjo picker,
in Linefork, Kentucky and plays for
dances and festivals with his son, Phil
(bass, vocals) and guitar player Dennis

June

a

courtesy

lives

as the Lee Sexton Band. Lee
Sexton's uncle Morgan Sexton, has been
the area's most hidden treasure. With a
style reminiscent of Roscoe Holcomb, he
sings old ballads and accompanies himself
on the banjo with a haunting, two-finger
picking style that is literally untouched by
modern influences. At 78, he has retired

from coal mining, and has released his first
album on the June Appal label. Founded
as

the Mountain Musicians Cooperative in

1972,

June
Appal Recordings in
Whitesburg, Kentucky, produces firsttime recordings of traditional musicians
from the southern mountains. The record
company is part of Appalshop, a media
and presenting center which includes a
film
theater, radio station,
gallery,
company, and theater company, with the
goal of preserving Appalachian culture.
Weekday evening concerts in the theater
have included musicians ranging from Jim
Costa to Robin and Linda Williams.
Also, on every fourth Thursday, there is a
live broadcast

of the

Bluegrass Express

Show on Appalshop's
Live Radio
community radio station, WMMT-FM.
88.7, with three bluegrass or old-time
bands

each

show.

Bands

interested

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

Dennis

White,

White,

Morgan Sexton

appearing should call 606-633-0108

and

Webb.
In the summertime
there are several
festivals in eastern Kentucky that are well

hold

annual

their

music

festival

in

ask for Jim

September, with open stage one night and
many old-time greats in attendance. To the

worth attending. The Hindman Family
Folk Week has been in existence for over
a decade and offers participants a small and
intimate setting for learning and hearing
old-time music. Located at the Hindman

Seedtime on the Cumberland Festival

Settlement School
the

festival

Hindman, Kentucky,
workshops in
fiddle,
clogging,
banjo,

storytelling,
families

participants,
to

combine

here's
have

a

daily

and singing.

dulcimer,

whole

in

offers

as

It

is

well

so, for those

geared toward

individual
wondering how
as

and

children,
fun way to vacation. Past festivals

festival-going

included

Jamison,

John

Marion Sumner.

Ritchie,
McCutcheon,

Jean

Phil
and

Up at the Carter Caves
State Park, J.P. and Annadeen Fraley

south,

Whitesburg,

in

the

third

annual

place at Appalshop, with four
music
of
and workshops. The festival,
days
will take

also Appalshop's
20th anniversary
celebration, June 1-4, will bring together
Hazel Dickens, Nimrod Workman,
the Reel World String Band, Whit

Sizemore

and the Shady Mtn.
Ramblers, Wade Mainer, Ray Hicks,
Ethel Kathe-Austin, and many other
fine musicians.

Over

the

mountain

in

southwestern

Virginia, Janette and Joe Carter present
old-time and bluegrass music at the Carter
Fold every Saturday night in Hiltons, near
Gate City. The museum and concert hall
were begun by Janette to honor the

�The Best

1

n

Traditional

Bluegrass Music on

COPPER CREEK RECORDS
♦CCLP-O101 STANLEY BROTHERS "Shadows Of The Past" Great live recordings of concert dates from the
1950's

&amp;

CCEP-0102

$7.00

60's

JOHNSON

MOUNTAIN

BOYS

Extended play 45rpm

12"

disc

of

1979/1980

their early

$5.00

recordings
*CCLP-0103 FLATT

&amp;

SCRUGGS

unissued cuts

$7.00

*CCLP-0105 LOUVIN
their top songs
*CCLP-0106 RENO
band
To fans of the

BROTHERS

*CCSS 1-3
*CCSS 1-4
*CCSS 2-2
*CCSS 2-3
*CCSS 2-4

*CCSS 3-1
*CCSS 3-2

"Live At New River Ranch" Super live show from April of 1956-many of

$7.00
&amp;

SMILEY

"A

Day

Stanley Brothers, there

In

is a

The Country" Fine live recording with the classic Reno

fine series of live recordings which are available

as

&amp;

Smiley
$7.00

follows:

Send orders to:
New River Ranch-Rising Sun, Maryland
Copper Creek Records
May 15, 1960 New River Ranch-Rising Sun, Maryland
New
River
P.O. Box 3161
1955
Sun,
Maryland
Ranch-Rising
July 3,
October 16, 1966 Bean Blossom, Indiana
Roanoke, VA 24015
May 28, 1961 Oak Leaf Park-Luray, Virginia
703-563-5937
July 8, 1956 Shipp's Park-Morrisville, Virginia
Ash
California
1962
Grove-Hollywood,
August 30,
Add $1.50 for shipping
Paris, Virginia
August 5, 1956 Silver Creek Ranch
August 29, 1962 Ash Grove-Hollywood, California
(Above albums are available on cassette as noted by an asterisk "*")

*CCSS-1-1 May 21, 1961
*CCSS 1-2

"Singles Collection" Neat reissue of rare 1950's/1960's singles plus several

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

PLACE

YOUR
AD
HERE

Write the Old-Time Herald for our
reasonable ad rates P*0* Box 1362
Galax, VA 24333*

�"THE BLOND-HAIRED

KID

WHO CAN REALLY FIDDLE."
By

Sixteen-year-old

smiled

Timothy

Anne Donley

Donley

and

shrugged his shoulders,
trying to explain what old-time country
music means to him. "It's something that
fits with my life. They say that music is
an expression of your soul, and I feel that
this is the type of music that expresses
the way I feel the best. It just fits with my
lifestyle perfectly. No other style of
music that I've heard can fit so closely
with me
it just doesn't agree with me
as well."
Some old-timers such as Enoch

Rutherford, J. P. and Annadeen Fraley,
Ivan Weddell, and the Roan Mountain
Hilltoppers have played with Timothy at

fiddlers
conventions and elsewhere.
Giving pointers, teaching tunes, and
handing out encouragement, they have
been heard to say, is important to

encourage youngsters to carry on the
tradition of old-time country music.
But before a youngster, or anyone, can
decide to take up old-time music, they
first have to hear it, know that it exists.
Timothy thinks he first heard it at
Fiddlers' Grove, North Carolina, when
he was nine years old. He was running
around jamming with his washboard and
stick, and occasionally with his half-size
violin whenever anyone wanted to play
"Bile Them Cabbage Down" or "Old
Blue." He won second runner-up in the
Junior Bluegrass Fiddle Division that
year, 1981. The ribbon still hangs in his
room next to others he has won since in

the Junior
competitions.

Old-Time

Fiddle

violin at the age of
learning from Charlotte Lille in
West Germany. His father, Clark, who
plays classical violin and Scottish and
Irish tunes, was doing scientific research
at
a
Max Planck Institute in Bad
Nauheim. His mother Anne was
teaching piano to Timothy and his new
found German kindergarten friends.
"You have to learn music," Frau Lille
in
would
her
say
lightly accented
"like
a
language. First you hear
English,
it. Then you speak it." She taught him in
a modified
Suzuki method, her love of
the
music and of children
always
apparent, and one of the tunes he learned
He had started the

to play and like was

Robert Schumann's

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Anne

Donley

four,

�"Merry Farmer." The melody of this
short piece is like the first part of
"Redwing," which he did not play until
10 years later.
Back in the states,

Timothy's violin
Hardy Roberts,
oral
tradition,
introducing sight-reading along the way.
teacher became Mary
who continued
the
life

Mary's

is

music,

and

she

opens the window for
variety of musical styles
and cultures. It was she who introduced
Timothy to bluegrass music, teaching
him "Bile Them Cabbage Down" and
"Old Blue." When she saw how much he
loved the bluegrass, Mary urged his
parents to take him to Fiddlers' Grove to
hear more of it, live.
When Mary
moved to another

enthusiastically
her students to

a

county, and the Donley's sought

a

new

teacher, Sonny Mead was recommended.
had just started teaching Timothy,
tantalizing him with "The Maiden's Prayer"
and "Orange Blossom Special," when
Mead's own bluegrass band, Heights of
Grass, suddenly hit a peak of popularity.
His teaching time dwindled to once every
several months.
Someone suggested Harold Hausenfluck
as a teacher. Harold dazzled Timothy with
some old-time tunes on the fiddle, handed
him a bunch of cassette tapes of music of
He

down. But now, three years later, "it's a
little easier. It's just something that you get
used to after awhile. When you walk
through an area long enough, you get to
know where every little thing is in that area.
And it's the same way with music. You're
always learning new stuff with music. It's
like walking around your area
you're
going to see new things that you never saw
before."
Timothy admits that in the beginning,
old-time tunes was a little
learning
frustrating. "When you're first starting
out, you have nothing to go on. You're
starting from scratch." Now, he says, he's
learned some of the often-used
progressions of notes, the bowings "that
have a characteristic sound," the nuances
"that are common in music, and now when
I hear those in a piece, I don't have to slow
I can just hear
it right
right up. When you're
first starting out, you don't know all that
stuff. So you have to sit down and figure
out the piece note for note, and when you
hear all these different bowings, you have

it

(the tape) down;

away

and pick

it

to figure out how to do that. You can't
expect to play well overnight, so it can be

frustrating."
After he had learned a tune or two, then
Harold helped him. "He set me straight on
it later on
made it sound more old-

"real

time."

music, and pointing out some things about
cross-key tuning and such to Timothy.
But the turning point came when
sometime later Harold tuned the family

Harold, an accomplished fiddler, banjo
picker, and guitar player, says he enjoys
playing banjo to Timothy's fiddle. They
have performed in public for students in
schools and libraries, and for adult groups,
as
well as just jamming with friends.

old-timers
you won't hear this on
the radio, son," advising him to "listen,
listen, and listen" to old-time country

piano and gave Timothy
record. And one day

a

Sometimes

they combine forces with a
team. Referring to the progress
Timothy has made since he first met him,
Harold
"Timothy's made some
says,
significant ground since the beginning. He
has the old-time sound of the southern

clogging

mountains."
Probably the best way to learn, Timothy
to
is
The fiddlers
just
jam.

says,

conventions

provide good opportunities

for doing so. "If you're lucky, you can meet

some old-timers who can show you a few
things. Sometimes it's hard to get them to
show you. Some old-timers are very
modest about their playing. And others are
very old and not in good health, and it's
hard to get them when they're feeling just
right."

The more you're around the music, the
better you play, he thinks. "You need to
hear it a lot. That's the good thing about
fiddlers conventions
you get a variety of
styles. On the one hand, it's good to stick
to one particular style and get good at that.
On the other hand, it's good to expose
yourself to a lot of different styles. It makes
your playing more interesting. Sometimes
you'll hear little licks from other fiddlers'
styles that you'll like, and add

a

little bit to

your playing."
Many of today's teenagers like rock and
roll. What made it different for Timothy?
For one thing, he says, he never heard rock
and roll at home, just classical and folk, and
the music of other countries.
"I never really felt like I was going against
the grain," he said, "because all my friends
had their hobbies. Besides, all my friends
seem to like my old-time music. I've never

copy of his latest
1985, when

in

was 13, he sat listening to
Harold's second album and something
clicked. Things fell into place, and he knew
he liked the sound. He knew he really liked
the sound.
Liked it enough
to
do
about
it.
something

Timothy

Looking back on

it

all,

Timothy says,

"I'd always

but
play
first.

play

played by ear, pretty much,"
listening to the tapes and learning to
the tunes was "a lot of work to learn at
It takes a lot of patience to learn to
an instrument. It took a lot of self-

discipline.
work on

I

really had to sit down and
the time if I wanted to get

it all

anywhere."

Timothy still learns new tunes much the
same way, listening to a tape, and slowing it
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Anne

catch every note, and phrase, and nuance.
"Music's something that if you don't like
to do it, you can't do it, but if you want to
do it hard enough, you probably can."
Whenever he's not around live music,

Donley

Following a tip from Harold, Timothy
recorded the cassette tapes onto a reel-toreel recorder, then slowed down the tape to

Timothy,

Richmond

at

a

Joe

Shiflett on banjo, Harold Hausenfluck on banjo, at Maymont Park in
1987, with
July 4th celebration. Pockets of people were everywhere listening to various things.

age 15,

�met anyone who didn't like it. I was raised
in an environment where there weren't a
whole lot of other children my age around
to associate
with, so I've always been
somewhat independent.
Some of my
friends have even expressed an interest in
learning it, although they've never pursued
that interest."
Timothy laments that more teenagers
and youngsters are not hearing the music
or playing it. "I'd dearly like it if some other
young people would take it up. The way
the old-time
music is played in the

mountains

very hard to find nowadays.

is

It's kind of like

wagon-building: it's

an

old

thing, it's just not done much anymore."
Most people, he finds, generally respond

"The old-time music is
found that seems to
to
for a little while
I've ever met. It's part of
background in America. I've

well to the music.
one type of music
at least
appeal
almost everybody

everybody's

I've

playing in downtown Richmond,
[Va.], before, and had these people who
look like they're fresh out of a punk rock
and roll band come up and start listening
for awhile. They left after about 10 minutes
been

or so, but they

obviously enjoyed it or they
wouldn't have stayed. It's something that
appeals to all backgrounds, even if it's justa
few people who really want to learn how to
do it. It's like everybody would like to see
an old wagon going down the road, but
how many people do you know who'd
really want to drive that wagon and fix that
wagon?"
The very age of the music itself "might
be part of the reason I like it. Even before I
picked up the fiddle, I got interested in
antiques, old things. If I can get the money

always
history

I'd

like

been

to collect

antiques.
history, area
feel like this kind of

interested

especially.

I

I've

in

a

it

ones
have
at
fiddlers
you
because these people know
the music; that's what they came to hear."
Audiences who sit and politely listen and

living antique. The way you're
even though you have a

style that's unique

to you,

are

Timothy,

the

conventions,

and

therefore is new
basically doesn't sound
a whole lot different from the way it did

then clap are boring to play for, he says. He
likes an audience to clap during the piece,
to get involved, to hoot and holler. "That
helps give you a better stage presence." He
compares it to talking with a person who is

back in the time of the Civil War, if you
learned from old recordings or old people.
It interests me a lot that it's an old style; it's
carrying on a tradition."
"I'm somewhat of a purist," Timothy

kind and cheerful and who responds to
you. That, he says, brings you out more
than talking with someone who just stares
Audiences who are
at you and listens.
closed are harder to play for, he finds.

continues. If someone says he's going to
play old-time, Timothy expects it to be in
the style of the music played generations
ago, recognizing that the rural North and
rural South had different traditions. "I play
southern music, mostly Virginia music."
He enjoys different styles, and some of
them, he says, like the double thumbing on

"Each audience has its own personality,
just like people do." He knows that some
audiences have been trained, or warned

beforehand, not to be overt, not to whistle

the banjo, and more full chords, are newer
styles that developed from the older ones.
"But I'd like to see more people get
interested in the old style. It's like the

or shout. "But that's what makes

difference between driving an old Model T,
and putting an old Model T body over

void? You like to

your Volkswagon."
Finding people to play music with has
not been easy for Timothy
in
his
hometown. In the last year a small group

before various audiences, he
states that he can see how a professional
musician who plays the same tunes over
and over again could get burned out, and
then not play as well.
Some fiddle tunes, he says, are best for
the fiddle alone, such as "Yew Piney
Mountain." And he enjoys playing those.
But best of all is jamming with other
musicians. "I like to have a group of people
to play with. And it helps your playing. It
helps your sense of timing. It can get boring
if you play by yourself too much. Playing
with other people is never boring, and
encourages you to keep in practice. That's a

brought

together

through

he says.

"Playing
keep the lights on!

auditorium. Who
taking

several

accidental meetings has begun meeting on a
regular basis to jam. They have been
invited to play at local celebrations, a state
convention, and other special programs.
"It's not a serious band," acknowledges

Timothy, although it may be heading that
way. But for performances, they selected
the Virginia
the
name,
Whistle-Pigs.
("Catch that whistle-pig, catch him by the
tail
ground-hog!")
The

character

of an

audience,

it."

it

for me,"

closed auditorium,
They always darken the
wants to play to a black
see how the audience is
in

Although

a

he

has

enjoyed his

appearances

good place to learn your tunes, too,
because they'll know tunes you don't
know. Of course they'll take off and play
them, and if you play with them, and play it

notes

Timothy, can affect your playing. "Some
it's very much fun to play for.
audiences
Others
it's not. Of course, the best kind

long enough, you'll know it."
The Virginia Whistle-Pigs jam as often
as possible.
The group came together
without any planning, and consists of men
who are older than Timothy, ranging in age
from their late 20s to their 60s. Richard
Miller (guitar, mandolin, fiddle) was the
first one in. A relative of his was a class
mate of Timothy's and told him her uncle
played his kind of music. Bob Blackwell
(banjo, guitar, mandolin, French harp) was
eating lunch in a shopping mall when his
grown daughter rushed in to tell him that a
boy scout in the scout event at the mall was

Donley

it,

is

Anne

for

music

playing
different

age

15,

1987, with school children

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at

a

country-wide school festival.

fiddling his kind of music. Ralph
Richardson (banjo, autoharp) was at a
fiddlers convention in Buena Vista when
he met Timothy. Guy Ward had come to a
wedding reception where Ralph and
Timothy were playing music for a friend of
Ralph's. It was Guy who eventually came
up with the name "Whistle-Pigs" and
Timothy threw in the "Virginia." Harold

�and others join this group from time to
time.

Timothy's father, Clark, finds it
fascinating to have watched the develop
ment of the group and the self-confidence
of each player that Timothy has helped to
build. 'That's one of the gifts Timothy
has," Clark says, "letting them each shine in
their own light, helping them grow from
excessively shy and modest to playing well
and with confidence in public."
Ideally, Timothy says he would like to
learn a new tune every other day, but life
rarely permits this. He enjoys some slow
tunes that are slow and flowing, like "Sweet
Sunny South," but relishes the faster

square-dance tunes with fairly interesting
bow-work, such as the G version of "Lost
Indian" and "Yew Piney Mountain."
It is the bow-work, Timothy says, that
he thinks is a big difference
between
classical and old-time country music. 'In
classical

a lot of special effects
are done
with the left hand, trills, and things of that
sort. In old-time music, a lot of the special
effects you get with your right hand, the

way you maneuver your bow."
like
to
learn
several
other
He'd
instruments, and has experimented with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the lap dulcimer,

banjo, mandolin, guitar,
fiddle is a fun
autoharp.
instrument to play. I don't know if it's my
favorite or not. But since it's the only one
and

"The

I've ever played

well,

I

like

it. It's

best to

one instrument before you go
trying another, and I still have some finetuning to do on my fiddle playing. In all but
a few exceptions, when you find somebody
who is fairly famous on a particular
instrument, a master of the instrument,
that instrument is usually the one they play
the most often, or the only one they've ever
played." He says other people have told
him that big callouses can develop from
playing fretted instruments and tends "to
knock their fiddle-playing a little out of
tune."
master

Although Timothy says his heart is in
old-time country music, he thinks "You're
better off if you can like other kinds of
music than if you just like one kind. It's
nice to be able to appreciate what other

people like and recognize that

of everyday life, the way it was in the past.
And I hope that more people will become
interested in keeping alive this wonderful
form of American music."

it is a totally
different style, and that there are people
out there who are devoted as much, or
more, than you are to your own style."
Timothy says he would like to see oldtime country music "become more a part

free-lance writer whose
nationally and
locally in Virginia. She and her husband came
to
know and enjoy old-time fiddle music
through their son, Timothy who is known
Anne

articles

Donley

have

is

been

a

published

as Timothy, Tim, Timmy, and that
blond haired kid who can really fiddle. Thanks
to
Timothy, they have experienced fiddle

alternately

conventions
Kentucky.

in

Virginia, North Carolina, and

�Issues In Old-Time Music
of view expressed in this column
those of the Old-Time

Points

are not necessarily

Herald.

The following

letters

Mac Benford's article

We present them

are

in

in

response

the last

as an Issues

to

OTH.

column

in

the spirit of continuing the dialogue on this
subject which is of concern to us all.

I

enjoyed reading your recent article

in

the
Old-Time Herald entitled
"Folklorists &amp;. Us." Although I am a
folklorist, I think you have brought out
some good points. In many ways,
revivalists are in no man's land as far as
most arts council classification systems
would like to see some kind of
go.
category for revivalists at the National
Endowment for the Arts. And at many
folklife festivals
would like to see a
stage for revivalists. I was at a folk
I

I

festival

in

England where they had two

areas:
one labeled
separate
stage
"traditional music" and one labeled
"folk music revivalists," and it worked
very well. They faced the situation head
on and everyone was happy.
I would
also like, however, to express
some thoughts on a few of your
comments about folklorists. do not see
the riff between old-time musicians and
folklorists as being as big as you believe.
I

are still musicians
wear the revivalist banner with
pride. At the American Folklore Society
1.

Many folklorists

and

rooms are filled with
conferences,
Sacred Harp Singers, old-time music
players, and other kinds of dance bands
and singers. Top people in folklore, such
as Joe Hickerson,
Alan Jabbour, and
Bess Lomax Hawes, continue to enjoy
performing, if only to special audiences.
Both Gary Stanton and I, folklorists at
the

S.C.,

McKissick
play

Museum

fiddle

music

in

for

Columbia,
dances

in

Columbia.

Many folklorists, especially
public sector folklorists, are enthusiastic
about people taking an interest in
learning traditional music.

You identify the problem but you do
not offer any solutions except that
must somehow "develop
folklorists
some criteria for judging the authenticity
of works of traditional art." How? In a
sense, we folklorists acknowledged our
ignorance long ago and stated explicity
that we could never really understand,
for example, the fiddle music of the
2.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

North

Carolina

music

of

blues
The only
honest way to present
responsible,
traditional music of a region to the
public is to research that region and if
possible to present musicians with roots
in that region. If you could come up with
a better criteria, 1 would enjoy hearing
about it.
a

Delta

farmer or
guitarist.

the

I believe you
are overly generous in
estimating the influence of folklorists.
When I was living in Nashville through
the seventies, music clubs, folk societies,
and especially colleges and universities
featured many old-time groups. Folk

3.

festivals were packed to the brim with
people, mainly students, and major
auditoriums were sold out to hear oldtime music. You're right, it was a great
time, and I loved it too. Folklorists had
no control over these events, however,
and I doubt college activities offices have
ever been controlled by folklorists. The
sad truth is that students today are not as
interested in hearing old-time music, so
it's not performed much. Do you really
believe a handful of folklorists caused
students to change their musical tastes?
4.

For

me,

folklorists,

and

I

think

honesty

is

most

for

important.

Currently, the artists-in-education,

and

touring artists rosters in many state arts
councils are filled with musicians who
make absurd claims as to the nature of
their music: a classical violinist will call

himself an authentic North Carolina
mountain fiddler, an opera singer will
sing
"songs as sung by mountain
women," or a transplanted novice banjo
player will claim his slick style represents
a local style. Because some schools will
hire these people assuming they are
educating their students about local

music,

I

consider
and

these

artists

will do what

I can to
unscrupulous,
expose them. If I went to Norway to hear
Norwegian fiddle music I would hope
someone there would do the same. On
the other hand, if a revivalist identifies
himself or herself in an honest manner,
have no problem at all.
5. I have found that most of the best
fiddlers, or basketmakers, or traditional
I

I

singers do not have the "city smarts" to

promote their products,

or they

their

are so

rural
have
the
skills
don't
community they
necessary to interact with the larger
public. Because I want to support the
best, I feel good about helping these
people to be seen and heard. The fact is,
we get very little money from the
National Endowment for the Arts for
concerts. It seems to me that revivalists
would gladly step aside and make room

deeply

ingrained

in

the performers on whose cultural
coat tails they have been riding.
for

Are

6.

traditions?

folklorists

manipulating

have no desire to stamp out
revivalists or to influence their impact
on American music. If playing old-time
music became the rage in Columbia,
I

South Carolina,

I

would

be

clubs

delighted.

If

started inviting talented revival
old-time bands to play, it would be great.
If the Highwoods Stringband reunited and

I
would see them; I
were
fantastic in the
thought they
seventies. But with our precious few
dollars I would rather hire a senior

came

to

town,

fiddler who grew up in a fiddling
tradition instead of a revivalist. To be
honest with you, I think if a revivalist
fiddler abandons playing the fiddle
because there's no longer money in it,
chances are that he or she only had a
superficial interest anyway.
7.

An interesting concept that

with

other

folklorists,

I,

like

along
to

�born and raised all over the country, and
many of them learned their music the
old-time traditional way, by listening
and watching, but they continue to learn
music the new-time traditional way
and tape
TV,
through records,
recorders. It doesn't seem to bother
If
makes them
them a bit.
that
"revivalists" and somehow tainted, I
don't think they give a damn. They
respect the music, and if they learned a
from someone like Earl Collins,
they may like to play it as close to the
way they heard it from him as possible.
On the other hand, they'll pick up a tune
from a whippersnapper like Tom Sauber
because they like the way he plays, and
they like the tune. That's all that really
tune

is that a person, apart from
upbringing, might be truly attracted in a
deep way to the culture of another
region. In other words, a person who
grew up in New York City might always
feel out of place there but find himself
completely at home in the cultural world
of Madison County, North Carolina. He

contemplate

might immediately feel at ease with the
people, the attitudes, the music, the
speech, and the living patterns. I happen
to believe there are, on rare occasions,

people like that, and I would go so far as
to call someone like that traditional if
their affinity to Madison County
continued for a number of years. If there
was only a way to separate them from the
hordes of people who are working out
some kind of romantic idealism (I'm
probably one of them), back to the earth
desire, or other philosophical trip, it
would be nice. Without having a looking
glass into people minds, folklorists have
to do the best they can. No doubt, some
phonies are hired by folklorists and
some very real traditional artists are not
hired. The system is imperfect but I
know of no better one.

Drew Beisswenger

Columbia, SC
note to Mac's
certainly not
"necessarily
preserving the rural
southern culture of days gone by."
While that culture fostered many good
traits, say candor, or self-reliance, if you
weren't a white male you were pretty
well out of luck. Even dear old Tommy
Jarrell who I feel may have re-thought
some of his ideas about society through
contact with his new, younger friends,
still used to make occasional comments
about blacks which, while reflective of a
I

just wanted to add

thoughtful article. We

a

are

lifetime of socially and legally sanctioned
racial segregation, still used to make me
And concerning the
uncomfortable.
"infuriating argument" comparing the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Amish-made

revivalist's

and

New

the

it's

quilts,

York

especially

maddening if you live near an Amish
do. While honest and
community as
hard-working, the Amish men rule with
I

iron

hand, and the scope of their
lives is limited by endless
chores and pregnancies. A friend of mine
has a quilt shop and has told me that
sometimes the Amish women around
here earn as little as $1.00 an hour for
their quilting work. If that's the process
it takes to get a traditional product, I'd
rather have the New Yorker's quilt. At
least she was free to choose her materials
and pattern (while of course displaying
her good taste in making her choices
an

women's

traditional ones).
Thanks

for

all

the

hard

work

in

producing the magazine. I enjoyed the
interview with Sheila
hope we can all
live well and long enough to have faces as

beautiful

as her

aunts'.

Jenny Cleland Vittek
New Wilmington, PA
I

am sending along

year's

subscription.

1

5

00 for another

I'm not quite sure

when my old one expires, but I don't
want to take the chance of missing the
next issue and all the comments on Mac
Benford's latest article.
I
have enjoyed Mac's pieces mainly
because it gives me an insight into the
times
and
era
of the Highwoods
Stringband. I was living out of the
country during the golden old-time
revival period, and missed seeing some
of my favorite recorded bands preform.
Now I'm beginning to see one side of
how the old-time music business
operates, where the lines are drawn, and
where philosophy and dogma start
getting in the way of the music.
I never did really
understand the fuss
about "revivalist" and "authentic, pure,
traditional" musicians. I play with a lot
of old-timers in California who were

matters.
can't comment with any authority on
hold the folklorists have or don't
have on providing support through
I

the

festivals and performance opportunities.
what

If

Mac

says

is

true,

it's

a

sad

commentary on the future of our music.
have been associated
The two groups
with, Centrum's Fiddle Tunes in Port
I

Townsend,

Washington,

and

the

California Traditional Music Society's
New Year's Camp and Summer Solstice

Folk Music and Dance Festival in the Los
Angeles area, seem to try to balance the
younger musicians with some of the
great old-timers still around. It just
seems obvious to me that this mix is
essential to keeping the music alive,
exciting, and accessible to the public.

If

they ever see are old men and women
past their prime, it will be like going to
the California
the zoo and viewing
Condors. An interesting species to be
sure, but unable to adapt and change,
all

therefore doomed to remain a
curiosity, protected in a controlled
environment, finally to be stuffed and
mounted in a diorama depicting the oldtime California.
and

I don't
know what the answer is, and
I'm not even sure about the question.
But I've thought about a few things I can
do to help make sure the kind of music,
the people, and the musicians that are
important to me survive and prosper in

this age of the compact disc, the reduced
budget, and the extending universe:

Support live concerts and festivals.
Let the festival promoters know
would like to
what kind of musicians
1.

2.

I

see.

After
3.

make
4.

(even
don't

Send them

letter. It can't hurt.
all, we buy the tickets.
Buy tapes and records, and don't
too many copies for friends.
Support the local dance groups
if they have closed bands and I

night).

get

to

a

play

southern

tunes

all

�addresses
and

and record lists (like County
Marimac) available for friends and

"outsiders" who can't get this music at
the local record store.
6. Be available for local, non-paying
performances that bring the music to the
public. If they don't hear it, if they don't
recognize it, if they don't know it's
available, when will they ever come and
pay?
7. Practice, play,
enjoy, enjoy, enjoy.

jam,

learn,
Ira

teach,
Gwin

Commerce, CA

Kyles, Oscars, Franks, Burls,

Freds,

ad

infinitum, deserved more than we could
ever provide. It is this point, the idea of
honoring those people who continued to

play the old tunes the old way and from
whom we learned, that Mac Benford fails
to address in his otherwise superb article

"Folklorists and Us.

."

member of the
"folklore establishment" (I have also
heard "folklore gestapo"). Just after I
escaped high school, while helping two
brothers build a house near my home in
Sewanee, Tennessee, I heard their father,
Emmett King, play old-time music on
I

am

a

card-carrying

fiddle and banjo. I had records of
Grandpa Jones and Stringbean, and as
good as they were, I knew that Emmett
King was special; neither he nor the
music he played was quite like what I was
listening to on records. It's like the
difference between a "real" quarter and
one of these laminated things we have
today; each is worth 25 cents, but.
During this same time, I was asked by my
father to arrange some sort of enter
the

Bands have personalities. The band I
used to be a part of, the Fuzzed Out
er,
Fuzzy Mountain Stringband, was once
described by a lady in West Virginia as
"that bunch who sat around playing
music with long faces and no smiles."
She was right. I guess our band's
personality was one of grave respect
(almost to a fault) for the old-time tunes
we played. But more so, we were trying,
with our seriousness and long faces, to

honor as best we could the traditional
musicians from whom we learned the
tunes. Those people, the Tommys,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tainment

for

National

a

Science

Foundation meeting held in Sewanee.
What I did was get Hamper McBee to
come
tell

in and

sing

a

bunch of songs and
I knew some

some yarns. Even then

I had to
present those scientists
the real thing; the thought of me doing a
bad job of playing Emmet King's banjo

how that

music never crossed my mind.
As a folklorist, one of my goals

is

to

showcase artists and arts that have clear
identities with specific places or groups
(familial, occupational, religious, etc.).

good artists who have these
are old; one of the best
braiders of traditional northern Nevada
buckaroo rawhide horse gear is 39 years
old. Nor does it mean that such artists
a
are simply replicating
stagnant art
braider
this same rawhide
form;

And not

all

connections

continually

tries

new

ideas

and

new

patterns. But he stretches the traditional
boundaries only because he understands
the tradition so well from within. As is
true of most folk artists, he can also
articulate the infinite complexities of his
tradition better than any outside

folklorist.

continued on page 27

�The Dance Beat

the

Arts

to

serve an apprenticeship

to Learn to Call

with

elder caller Jerry Goodwin of Baden, Pa
Parts of this article are taken from his forth
coming book on square dancing and calling.
He offers some good advice for anyone
wishing to call square dances. We'll have
more

on

Beats."

How

do

dance calling
Phil Jamison
I

go about

in

future

learning

Traditional

"Dance

to

Square Dances!

call

square dances?

This question is asked over and over
by those who have never called a
dance but would like to try, by square
dance callers who want to sharpen their
skills or experiment with a different
style, or by contra callers who would like
to try their hand at squares. Well, there
isn't just one way to learn how to call
squares, as surely as there isn't just one
way to learn how to do anything. The
best way for you to learn to call squares
may not be the best way for another. In
lot of different
hopes that you
learning activities
will pick and choose the ones that meet
this article, I'll suggest

a

in the

your needs.

caller
Becoming an accomplished
involves acquiring and developing a lot
of
skills,
abilities,
knowledge and
attitudes. I'm not trying to scare anyone

off from wanting to learn to call dances;
on the contrary, I'm trying to make
learning more accessible. Although I
don't think it's very useful to get bogged
down by too many details when you're
first starting to call, I do think it's useful
to see the big picture, to understand that
there is a great deal of depth to this art.
So before we talk about how to learn,
let's take a look at what you'll have to
learn as we review some of the more
important attributes of the square dance
caller.

Attributes of the square dance caller.

There are some abilities and skills
a caller needs. Certain basic abilities
seem to come naturally, while others can
learned. Regardless, we can all
be
improve on some of these basic abilities:
memory, sense of rhythm, good pitch, a
pleasant voice, vocal expression, strong
projection, and clear speech.
There are a lot of skills involved in
calling squares. As you try calling, the
that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ways

11

a
dance caller,
is
Edelman
Larry
musician and teacher currently residing in
He has taught square
M d.
Baltimore,
dance callers' workshops throughout the
country. In 19 87 he received a Fellowship in
Folk Arts from the Pennsylvania Council on

1989

By

skills that you'll need to work on will
become apparent (if not to you, to
others, so don't forget to ask for friendly
feedback). Some of the basic skills are:
knowing how to dance; good rhythm,
of the calls;
and
phrasing
timing
accentuating the calls properly; teaching
the dances well; notating dances so you
them;
collect and remember
can
the
"fit"
to
dance
the
right
choosing
dancers, the music and the movement;
teaching the dances well; working well
with the musicians and various styles of
music. Some of the more advanced skills
are: teaching the dances well; planning
dance programs; improvising "breaks";
using sound systems; teaching the dances
noticed how
You
well.
may have
strongly I believe that developing good
teaching skills is very important: every

important as calling!
An accomplished square dance caller
needs to have a great deal of knowledge.
There are some basic things to know,
bit as

figures and terminology;
understanding dance music; the parts
and structure of a square dance; having a
adequate repertoire of dances; etc. There
are some more detailed things that you
will eventually want to know as well:
including:

distinctions

between

calling

styles

(prompting, patter and singing); regional
differences; background and history;
dance sources, etc.

Edelman

Larry

This brings us to the area of attitudes
which appears last on this list, but
certainly not least. There are several
attitudes that are important, but one that

think is the most crucial. That is the
attitude of FUN!; that we're all here to
enjoy ourselves and to help each other
feel good. This includes the whole

I

community of people at the dance: the
dancers, the musicians and callers. If we

callers always keep this in mind and
think of our job as helping to nurture the
fun factor, all the other positive attitudes
as

should

come

naturally;

courtesy,

good humor,

patience, tolerance,
enthusiasm.

and

So we see, there is a great depth to the
of square dance calling. It's like
learning to play the fiddle in that the
more you learn, the more you realize
how much there is to learn. Fortunately,
like playing the fiddle, learning to call
can be fun and there are plenty of ways to
dive into the learning process.
art

Some suggestions on how to learn to
call square dances.
In this section I'm going to suggest a
variety of methods that I've used as I've
learned to call and
callers to learn.

activities
learning

I

I've helped other
all of these
of whether you're

as

recommend

regardless
New England, Southern or
Western squares. At first, I tried to put

suggestions in order of
importance, but that didn't really work
think they're all important.
because
to some suggestions
attracted
be
You'll
these

I

more than others based on your interests
and how much calling experience you
might already have. So for now, let's just

say that the first three are essential, and
the others are important. You should

�pick and choose the ones that are avail
able to you, that address those aspects of
interested in
which
you're
calling

wealth of traditions and knowledge that
might otherwise be lost.

developing,

proverb:

that

and that sound like ways
like to learn. Remember, in

you
starting out, keep it all as simple,
active, and as fun as possible!

as

Dance

One of the best (and most
important) ways to learn how to call is to
dance. Besides, it's about as much fun as
you can stand to have! This is where you
1.

can learn all the figures and

terminology,
understand dance styles, feel connected

to the music, listen to other callers, learn
new dances, etc. Y ou should try to dance
to a variety of callers and bands.

Learn
teachers

2.

from

other

callers

and

Learning to call is like
you need to
learning to play music
listen to others do it. Go to community
dance events. You many want to ask the
caller and band for permission to tape
record them. Tape the whole night, not
just the calls, so that you might learn
something about teaching as well. Listen
to the calls the next day, write them
down in a notebook, dance to them, try
to call along with them. If you don't tape
at a dance event, dance most of the time,
but sit out some so you can jot down
notes, watch, listen, and try to call along.
Choose good role models and imitate.
As you start calling you'll synthesize all
of these influences with your natural
artistic tendencies and your own style
will emerge. You can learn a lot from
your peers who have been calling a bit
longer than you. But don't just go to
dances in town, also seek out rural
dances in outlying areas, in granges, fire
here's
halls and community centers
where you're likely to find traditional
callers with a wealth of experience who
primary sources of figure calling. It's
also at these type of events that you can
are

experience the joy of real community
dancing.

You may want to enlist another caller
a teacher. If there is a caller you really
like who is willing to share his or her
as

and experience, ask for some
guidance. Keep your eye out for callers'
workshops with teachers who you like.
Don't be shy when asking experienced
callers for help in learning. I've found
that callers and musicians most often
appreciate a sincere interest in their art
and are very happy to share. You may
want to consider a sort of "apprentice
ship" with a traditional caller whose style
appeals to you. I have been involved in
such apprenticeships with elder callers

talents

and they are very rewarding
they can
give you an opportunity to learn calling
(and a whole lot more) and can give the
master an opportunity to pass along a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

3.

Practice
"I

remember,

Remember

hear and
I do
and

I

I

forget,

I

the old
see and I

understand." The

only way to really learn to call is to do it
over and over and over again. Here's
where there is a small hurdle
you can
only practice by yourself to a limited
extent. You can learn to memorize a
dance and the calls and try calling to
music by yourself, but you need to
practice with dancers to good live music.
So you may need to find or create a good
situation in which to do this. Try having
a small
party. Invite some friends over
and (after bribing them with food and
beverages) ask them if they'd dance a
square as you call. Better yet, start a
weekly get-together where those who are
interested can try their hand at calling
and playing. These get-togethers might
take place at someone's home or you
might try a local pub. For example,
Pittsburgh, Pa. and Seattle, Wash, both
have Monday night dance parties with an

open stage for callers and musicians.
recommend using live
I
strongly
music, but if you don't have any avail
able, that's no reason to quit. Try using
recordings of your favorite tunes. Some
times it's hard to find good recorded
music for square dancing, but there is
some out there. You may want to ask
some local players to tape a good long
dance tune or two for you. But if at all
possible, use live music. Once you're on
the road to being able to call and have
some confidence, you might want to try
a guest slot at a regular dance, if the caller
is amenable. Remember, keep it simple
and fun. Make sure that you're able to
teach the dance well and can call it
without reading it from note cards!
Whenever you practice, ask dancers,
other callers and musicians for gentle,
constructive feedback.
The
4. Tape record yourself calling
harder
than
recording
tape
only thing

is listening to it afterwards!
You'll learn a lot about your voice, your
timing and phrasing, your confidence,
how well you knew the dance, etc. Try
dancing to your own calling. Those of
you into higher tech methods might
want to video tape the dancers and see
how well they danced to your calls and
how much fun they had. Taping can
really be instructive, but try to avoid

yourself

taking
5.

yourself, too seriously.

it, or

books

Read

listen

and

to

Hundreds of books have

recordings

been published about square dancing in
the past 50 years. Although many are out
of print, they can still be found. Some of

of
wealth
include good
tips on calling, but the real worth is in the
repertoire which is sometimes from a
specific region. These are also good
sources for information about dancing
in particular locations or time periods.
Make sure that you read through the
dances which appear in books with a
critical eye. Sometimes the dances are
sometimes
not
they're
very
good,

books contain
information. They may
these

a

notated incorrectly or incompletely, and
sometimes they just don't translate well
to today's dancing world or your dance
community. I've often found that in a
collection containing 100 or so dances,
there may be only 4 or

5

that

I

think are

addition to the older books,
plenty of recently published

any good. In

there are

books that are good sources of calling
instruction, repertoire, and commentary
on dance and calling style.
As with books, there are hundreds of
square dance recordings, both old and
new. It's sometimes hard to find material
you want to use, but it can be worthwhile
just to hear a lot of different callers. Be

careful about being overly influenced by
recordings and listen critically. A record
may have been recorded without dancers
so the tempo may be too slow or too fast.
It may be of a very different style from
that which

is

called and danced

in

your

�or

community

it

may

contain

a

bad

dance.

To find older records and books, try
and
university,
public,
and
used
record
libraries,
organization
book stores, flea markets, and garage
sales. Try not to be discouraged if you
don't find any at first. If you keep at it
they'll surface sooner or later. Some
good sources for new books, records,
and tapes will be listed at the end of this
article.

looking

in

This
of the music
suggestion could just as well have
appeared at the top of the list. Y ou need
to feel the music that you'll be calling to.
View yourself (the caller) as a member of
the band, the vocalist. I won't go as far as
saying that all callers need to be
musicians. But I will say that playing
music will help you to understand how

6.

Become part

calling and music work together. And
it's never too late to learn. If you don't
play, then you need to be a very avid and
active listener. Whatever activities you
choose, listening or playing, you need to
become connected with the music to
which you'll be calling.
a
7. Develop
system for writing
As
down dances that you collect

you call more, you'll be collecting more
dances and will need a way to keep them
all straight. You may want to develop a
system for writing down not only the
calls, but other information such as the
title, notation on timing and phrasing,
notes on teaching, the author, where you
learned it, etc. Callers all have their own
unique design for notating dances. You
might ask a few callers if you can look at
their cards as models to help you
develop the system that meets your
needs.

callers' collective
Several communities and regions have
These
callers' collectives.
organized
8.

Develop

groups

can

a

be

to

useful as they create
practice calling, give

opportunities
each other feedback, share repertoire,
sponsor workshops, organize dances,
etc.

9. Go to dance camps
week-long dance camp
go for an

A
is a

weekend

or

great place to

intensive learning experience.

You can really get a lot of things out of it!
At many of the fine programs available
you can reap the benefits of instruction
and practice at a callers' workshop while
expanding your repertoire at dance
workshops and evening parties. You can
learn about regional styles of dance,
participate in dance music workshops,
dance your fool feet off, meet some fine
people, and have a great time. There are
dance camps all over the country. You
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

find

can

about

out

these

events

in

periodicals such as the Country Dance
and Song Society Newsletter, the OldTime Herald, Sing Out! etc. The weekend
camps are too numerous to mention, but
some of the week-long camps are listed
at the end of this article. You can contact
each camp and request to be put on their

mailing list.

or

unpublished

otherwise little-known

dances or dance lore. You may find
primary sources in traditional callers,
dancers, and musicians at rural and

dances and secondary
sources in older books and recordings,
museums, and libraries. Three excellent
sources are the Library of Congress, the
Lloyd Shaw Foundation Archives, and
the Country Dance and Song Society
Library (not presently available to the
public). You may also want to try your
local historical organizations.

community

Don't take

it

so

seriously

square dance
caller takes a lot of work. It's an awful big
responsibility to help people have a good
time. It's good to remind ourselves that

Becoming

a

competent

this to have fun. Sometimes I
think that callers get too serious because

we

do

get to dance or play music as
much when we call. If you find this
happening to you, don't be alarmed, it's

we don't

natural. Just make sure you take time to
put on your own dancing shoes or play
some tunes and have some fun!

Here

are

(July-August)

Davis &amp;. Elkins College
100 Sycamore Street
Elkins, WV 26241-3996
Christmas Country Dance School

(December)

c/

Take the time to
10. Do research
search! Some of my most rewarding
learning has been through "discovering"

11.

Some Week-Long Dance Programs:
Augusta Heritage Arts Workshops

some sources for books,

records and tapes:
Country Dance and Song Society (CDSS)
17 New South St.
Northampton, MA 01060

(413) 584-9913

Legacy Books

Box 494

Hatboro, PA 19040
Hands Four
Box A
Bedford, MA 01730

(617) 643-4039

Lloyd Shaw Foundation
5506 Coal Ave., SE

Albuquerque, NM 87108

(505) 255-2661
Silo/ Alcazar

P.O. Box 429
Waterbury, VT 05676

(802) 244-8657

Andy's Front Hall
P.O. Box 307
Voorheesville, NY 12186

(518) 765-4193

o Berea

College

CPO 287;
Berea, KY

40404

Country Dance and Song Society
Pinewoods (July- August)
17 New South St.
Northampton, MA 01060

at

Festival of American Fiddle Tunes (July)
Folk Dance and Music
International
Festival (August)

c/

o

Centrum

Box 1158
Port Townsend,

WA 98368

Fiddle and Dance Workshop

at

Ashokan

(July- August)
Rd 1-Box 489
West Hurley, NY 12491

Fiddlehead Music and Dance Week Qune)
3139 Abell Avenue
Baltimore, MD 21218
John C. Campbell Folk School

(Year-round)

NC 28902

Brasstown,

Kentucky Summer Dance School 0une)
c/o Kentucky Heritage Institute for the
Traditional Arts
P.O. Box

4128

Frankfort, KY 40603
Lady of the Lake Summer Dance and

Music Week Qune)
c/o Spokane Folklore Society
P.O. Box 141

Spokane, WA 99219

Mendocino Country Dance Camp Quly)
c/ o Bay Area CDS
Box 22165
San Francisco, CA 94122
Micanope Music and Dance Camp
(December)

P.O. Box 12135

Gainesville,

FL

32604

�Festivals!
We will include a festival listing once a
year. Next year's listing will be in the
spring 1990 (Feb-Apr) issue and will
cover Feb. 1990 through Jan. 1991. We
can only list your festival or

convention

if you send us the information. Please
note our format and try to include as
as
much information
possible. The
deadline for receiving 1990 festival
information will be Dec. 1, 1989.

not associated with the Rockbridge Mtn.
Music &amp; Dance Conv. in Sept.

room $63, nearby camping
Box 1158, Port Townsend,

June 17, 18 Ala. Folklife Fest.
Park, downtown Birmingham

Fiddle Workshops
New
Breton,
Newfoundland,
Camp
Mexican, New England, Virginia, West
Virginia, North Carolina and Cajun
Write for reg. form.
styles

Lynn
$5

Write or call for
weekend, $3 per day
info., ethnic food
Joyce Cauthen, 205-

822-0505

Write

Birmingham

2164 Shady Brook
Country Dance Soc.,
La., Birmingham, Ala. 35226
String

bands, gospel, blues, dancing, fiddle &amp;.
Part of a larger
sacred harp workshops
street fair-type
lots
of kids
fest.,

activities, crafts.

June 16,
May

Mtn. Fest.

19-21-Black

Rockmont, Black Mtn., N.C.
Bunkhouse

Camp
$32 for

camp, avail.
Write for prices, good food on site
B.M.F. PO Box 216, Black Mtn. N.C.
Lots of
28711
704-669-4546
Child care avail.
dancing, esp. contras
$1.50/hr., swimming, crafts area.
3

days

May

&amp;.

Folklife Fest.

26-29-Northwest

Seattle Center, Seattle, Wa.
Free
Ethnic food, write for accom. info.
Kerry Coughlin, NFF, 305 Harrison St.,
Seattle Wa. 98109
206-684-7300
dance
&amp;
music
Dancing,
workshops

Lots of kid's activities,
instrument auction.

June 1-4 -Seedtime

on the

musical

Cumber land

Appalshop Center, Whitesburg, Ky.
Write for info.
$20 for festival

Appalshop,

306

Madison St.,
606-633-

41815

Whitesburg, Ky.
0108
Evening concerts, banjo, fiddle,
storytelling workshops, open stage
Appalshop films, theater presentations,
crafts, no kid's activities.

June

2,

Airy Fiddlers Conv.
Park, Mt. Airy, N.C.

3-Mt.

Veteran's
Refundable

contestant

on site, festival food
3 19

fee

Camping

Mrs. Jack Jones,

W. Oakdale, Mt. Airy, N.C. 27030.

Contest,
registration

non-stop
a

jamming
must. Do it now.

Pre

Vista Old-Time
Music Fest.
Glen Maury Park, Buena
Write for info.
Vista, Va.
$2 per day
Greg Taylor, Parks &amp; Recreation
Mgr., Glen Maury Park, 2039 Sycamore
This is
Ave., Buena Vista, VA 24416

June

9-11-Buena

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Fiddlers Conv.

Vaughan School ball park on Rt. 94
Va.
between Fries &amp;. Ivanhoe,
Refundable contestant fee
Camping,
festival food
Write United Citizen's
Civic

Va.

24350

Ivanhoe,
No pre-registration

League,

206-385-3102

in

July

Annual Uncle Dave

8-10-11th

Macon
Days
Murfreesboro,

"fine

camping,
Gloria

write for

Lots

day.

June 23,

Co. Fiddlers

24-Grayson

Elk Creek

Conv.

School ball park, Elk

Refundable
Creek, Va. 24326
contestant fee
Festival food, camping
No pre
Contest, jamming
registration fee necessary.

2-Fiddlehead '89 Music
Millsted Camp near
Fallston, Md.
$85 deposit, $295 for
the full week includes room &amp;. board
3139 Abell Ave.,
Veggie menu too

June

25-July

&amp; Dance Week

Baltimore, Md. 21218

301-235-2924

Workshops, dances, Music includes
old-time,
swing

June

northeastern, Cajun,
Write for reg. form.

blues,

2-Battleground Fest

30-July

Tippecanoe Battleground, Battleground,
Write for info. DaveSamuelson
Inc.
c/o Battleground Historical Assoc., Box
317225, Battleground, IN 47920

567-2147

Open

jamming,

stage,

concerts, primarily old-time music.
July

of American Fiddle
Fort Worden State Park, Port

2-9-Festival

Tunes

Townsend,
workshop

Wa.

Room

$150
&amp;.

for

board

1-week

$155,

info.

1333,

under shade trees.

of jamming

July 14,

Weiser Fiddle Contest
Write for info
Weiser
Chamber of Commerce, 8 E. Idaho St.,
Contest, jamming
Weiser, Id. 83672
Supposed to be hot, over 100° every

accom.
Box

Contest, prizes, motorless parade, crafts,

necessary.
Id.

PO

Nearby

nearby

615Murfreesboro, Tn. 37133-1333
Old-time string band and
893-3766
individual contests, clogging contest
bicycle race.

Weiser,

square,

Refundable

foods,"

Wilson,

Contest, jamming

June 19-25

Public
Tn.

contestant fee, free for others
restaurants,

17-Vaughan

Centrum,

Wa. 98368

Fiddlers Conv.

15-Pulaski

Pulaski/Dublin
Refundable

Fairgrounds

contestant

Old-Time

&amp;

Convention,

PO Box

Festival

fee

Write Pulaski

food, camping on site

Fiddlers

Bluegrass

1391, Pulaski, Va.

24301
Contest, jamming
registration necessary.
July

No pre-

Heritage
Davis &amp; Elkins
Write for costs
College, Elkins, W.V.
On-site rooms, cafeteria food, nearby
Write for catalog &amp; reg. form
camping
Augusta Heritage Center, Box DM,
Davis &amp;. Elkins College, Elkins, W.V.
9-Aug.

11-Augusta

Workshops (ongoing)

25241

bluegrass,
more,

July
Week

Workshops

in

Cajun, zydeco,
11-17-Appalachian

old-time,

blues, vocal,
Family Folk

Hindman Settlement School,
Forks of Troublesome Creek, Hindman,
Write for costs
On-site room &amp;
Ky.

board, write for info
Workshops in
music
&amp;.
dance, evening
Appalachian
concerts, beginners encouraged Write

Hindman Settlement School, Hindman,
606-785-5475
Ky. 41822
Ongoing
kid's activities, ages 4-12.

21-23-Hiawatha Music Fest.
July
Tourist Park, Marquette, Mich.
15 in
adv. for weekend inch camping
PO
Box 414, Marquette, MI 49855
Workshops, concerts, jamming
Hot &amp; cold showers cost
Healthy food

�25,

"laid

back,"

festival,

large

swimming, fishing.
Aug. 3-5 Asheville Mountain Music

&amp;.

Wolfe

Thomas

Fest.

Dance

Auditorium, Asheville Civic Center,
Thurs. $5, Fri. $6, Sat.
Asheville, N.C.
In N.C. 1Write for accom. info.
$7

800-548-1300, others 1-800-257-1300,
write

Ward,

Jackie

of

Chamber

AA

1010, Asheville,
Commerce,
Contest (invitation
N.C., 28802
only), western N.C. traditional bands,
Box

PO

Festival has been going

dancing, more
since mid-1920s.

Aug.

Ashe County Fiddlers Conv.
W. Jefferson in Ashe Co.

5

Just outside

contestant

Refundable

Park

fee

Write
Camping on site, festival food
Box 127 W. Jefferson, N.C. 28694
No pre-registration.
Contest, jamming
Valley Festival
State
Park,
Ferrisburg,
Kingsland Bay
Vt.
$30 for weekend Nearby motels,
camping, S.A.S.E. for list of accom.
Champlain Valley Fest., Box 163,

Aug.

4-6-Champlain

802-849-6968

Fairfax, Vt. 05454
Lots of old-time

other

and

music,

Wonderful kid's activities,

dancing

hands-on stuff, kids area, crafts.
Aug. 9-12- Galax Old Fiddlers Conv.
Felts

Park,

refunded

Galax,

contestant

Va.
fee

Partially

On-site

camping, festival food, nearby motels
PO Box 655,
(may be filled already)
Contest, non-stop
Galax, Va. 24333
You must pre-register!
jamming

Aug. 26,

27-Santa

Fe

Fiddle

&amp;.

Banjo

Rodeo Grounds,
On-site camping
Santa Fa, N.M.
Workshops, concert, contest, lots of
Call Hayswood Martin, 505jamming
471-3462 Contest prizes, belt buckles,
children's contest divisions.
Contest

Santa

Fe

Mountain City Old-Time
Aug. 26
Mountain City,
Conv.
Fiddlers
(only)
Refundable contestant fee Write
Tn.
for

info

John

Muse,

Box

121,

Mountain City, Tn., 37683. Frank
Sexton (615) 727-8112
Mountain
9-Rockbridge
Sept. 8,
Music

&amp;.

Dance Conv.

Glen Maury

$3 admission,
Park, Buena Vista, Va.
On site camping,
$2 camping per night
Open stage, open mike for
good food

musicians

contras,

and

dancers,

flexible

squares

and

programming

RMMDC, PO Box 1592, Lexington, Va.

24450.
2
Sept. 8-10 Wheatland Music Fest.
mi. outside of Remus, Mich, on farm
Write or call for info. Wheatland Music
517Org., Box 22, Remus, MI 49340
Concerts,
967-8879
Healthy food

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

workshops.
Oct.
7-Bascom Lamar Lunsford Fest.
Mars Hill College Campus, Mars Hill,
N.C.
Daytime activities free, evening
concert $4
Nearby camping &amp; motels,

Street dance, ballad
swap, jamming, evening concert Write
BLL Festival, Mars Hill College, Mars
Liz Shaw, 704-689Hill, N.C. 28754
Great kids activities ongoing
1228
throughout the day, craft demonstrations,
traditional mountain food.
write

info.

for

Oct.
Museum

37828

12-15-Tennessee

Fall

of Appalachia,

615-494-7680

Homecoming
Norris,

TN

A mixture of

old-time, bluegrass, &amp; folk music, formal
Motels &amp;
&amp; informal stages, crafts
Farm
museum,
nearby
camping

extensive

collection

of

musical

instruments.

28-Blue Ridge Folklife Festival
Ferrum College Campus, Ferrum, Va.
Nearest public camping is 15 miles
$3
Roddy Moore,
away at Philpott Lake
Blue Ridge Institute, Ferrum, Va. 24088
Lots of traditional music,
703-365-4416
folklife events, food.

Oct.

�Workshop

By

RYA'S

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Paul Brown

RYA'S HOUSE
Key to

HOUSE

Symbols

T-Thumb

other

I-Index or

fin

downstroke

ger(s)
H-Hammer

string (mean

V-Accent

ing this is your melo
dy note within the
chord)
Now here's

a

real

old

time banjo &amp; fiddle tune
There's
for dancing.
plenty of work for the
thumb string, but the
thumb never drops to the

lower strings,

there

and

are no pull-offs for the
left hand. The one hammer

that's

is really
roll up the neck
with your left fingers.
This kind of banjo pick
more of

marked
a

ing is so much fun that
you could do it all day
and all night.
It reminds
us that the banjo was once
as much

a

drum as

a

stringed

instrument
The fingering
is fairly simple, but you
may

have to

practice awhile

with your right hand, which
repeatedly plays chords al
ternating with the thumb

string.
The

"BRUSH"

figures

should take the time of 1
quarter note (the notes
without double flags at the
bottom)
Eighth notes have

flags.
The

theses

figure in paren
marked

"A"

at the

beginning starts the tune
off and is used again when
Fig
you repeat Part A.
ures marked "B" in paren

theses replace the "A"
ure when you enter or
peat Part B.

fig

re

You'll understand ev
erything quickly when you

hear the recording or see
and hear Odell play.

continued on page 39

�Section with Illegible Text

five
summer weeks of the
best in old-time music,
dance, crafts, and
folklore!

Concerts, dances and
more than 90 hands-on

classes, including:
OLD-TIME BANJO
with

Joe Herrmann, Joe Fallon,

Gerry Milnes

OLD TIME FIDDLE
with

Gerry Milnes, Judy Hyman,

Pete Sutherland, Bill

Wellington

MANDOLIN

with

Jody Stecher, Niles Hokkanen

MOUNTAIN DULCIMER
with

Larkin Bryant, Lorraine Lee

OLD-TIME WEEK
All instruments, with

Melvin Wine, Wilson
Douglas, Gerry Milnes,
Bruce Greene, Mark
Graham, The Wildcats
&amp; more!

PLUS

Bluegrass, Cajun

Music, French-Canadian

Fiddle,

&amp;

much more!

July 9-Aug. 13
HERITAGE
Box OT

AUGUSTA
ARTS WORKSHOPS
Davis &amp; Elkins College

Elkins, WV 26241

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
W
READY FOR SHIPMENT

Sales

County

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
NEW RELEASES
ROU-0262

FRESH OLD-TIME STRING BAND MC1SIC Collected or performed and recorded by Mike Seeger
BUZZARD ROCK STRING BAND "I've Got The Blues For My Kentucky Home" w/Harry Bickel, etc
"
Live At New River Ranch" Great live concert from 1956
LOUV1N BROTHERS
many top songs
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" New old-time music by this West Virginia group
VIRGINIA TRADITIONS: Southwest Virginia Blues With Dock Boggs, Carter Family, Byrd Moore, etc
SPROUTS OF GRASS "I Like Mountain Music" Bluegrass and old-time music from Washington band
46 field recordings by John Lomax.
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BANJO COLLECTION Super set of 937
"
classic old time recordings
CHARLIE POOLE "Volume 1 Available again with new cover
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent fields recording of the Cumberland Plateau area- w/booklet
Vol. 2" Great reissue of his classic 1950s recordings
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings
VIRGINIA TRADITIONS -EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO Great oldtimew/Roy Hall, etc
CHOKERS &amp; FLIES "Old Time Music" Fine recent material by the Chicken Chokers &amp; Horseflies
some unissued
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Singles Collections" Neat reissue of obscure 50's/60's cuts
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo LP by this Kentucky musician

'JA-054

"CCLP-0105

*FF-468
*BRI-008
RB-1001

ROU-0237

1

'CO-505
CO-786

"CCS- 109

BRI-010
ROU-0213
'CCLP-0103
"JA-051

JAMES BRYAN "Looked Blues" Fine old-time fiddle, featuring Norman &amp; Nancy Blake
DOC ROBERTS "Old Time Tunes" Great reissue of his tunes from the 1920s &amp; 30s
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial &amp; field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "You Can Feel It In Your Soul" Classic gospel from the 1950 s
OLD HOLLOW STRINGBAND Old-time music from North Carolina
Vol.
TRADITIONAL MUSIC FROM THE CUMBERLAND PLATEAU
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
Vol 1" Reissue of 1920s material
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroes best early 1950 s Decca material
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish -w/booklet
NASHVILLE BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent old-time LP
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 940's King material
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTW1CH &amp; H1GGINBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
HEE HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing
TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music
UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine 1920's/30's sides
SKILLET LICKERS
Vol 2 Old- time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carrol County, Virginia
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920's/30's
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 928-41

'ROU-0175
CO-412
AT-103
"CCS-111

FCOT-001
CO-787
'CMF-01

1

1

OH- 191

"REB-853

'SH-3759
*ROU-0233
HER-070

'ROU-0242
FCOT-005
"FF-415
*HAT

-3022

*CO*-791
"CCS-110

1

'CO-788

*REB-850
*FF-352
"JA-014

'CO-790
*HH- 19842
*TR-1

CO-545

♦CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406

1

2

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50

7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
1 2.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

$10.00

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

NEW COMPACT DISCS
RCA-CD-8416
RCA-CD-8417

RAGGED BUT RIGHT 'Great Country String Bands Of The 1930's" w/Skillet Lickers,
Mainers, etc
ARE YOU FROM DIXIE "Brother Duets Of The 1930's" w/Blue
Sky Boys, Monroe Bros., Allen Bros

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted by an asterisk
On all ORDERS

in

(ISA please

add $2.00

postage

&amp;

I

"

")

handling

CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $5.00 postage for first 1 -3 LPs, $1.50 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

$11.00
$11.00

I

J

�Reviews
(featuring Rafe Stefanini); Boston City Limits
(featuring Hiro Arita); Jeff Staley; Fingers &amp;
Richard Collins, John
Co. (Gary Payne,
Collins, Diana Collins, and Pat Francis); and
Americans
Willard
Theo
With
Elsey.

Artists and record companies
please send records and tapes for
review to The Old-Time Herald,
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333.

Gay heart,

Bluegrass
Music by International Visitors
Galax, VA.
(Heritage Records 067)

to

Give Me the Roses/Polly Put the Kettle

On/Border Ride/Somebody Loves You
Darlin'/Chilly Winds/When the Wagon
Was New/Four-Cent
Cotton/Honey
Mule-Crowd (sic) Creek/When the Band

Playing Dixie/Another Broken
Does Your Dog
Heart/Granny
Bite/Valley of Peace/Train on the
is

Island/Sockeye/High

on

a

Blues/Joke

Mountain/
on the

Puppy /Purple Robe/Oh Mary Don't You

Weep/St. Anne's Reel/Kitty and I/June
Apple/A Bad Old Lonesome Night/Year
of Jubilo/Don't Come Home Drunk/Blue

Cabin

Home/Kookaburra

Country

Baptism' /Fannie

Hill/Florida Blues/Rochester

Schottische/Sheep Shell Corn by the
Rattlin' of His Horn/ Rock the Cradle

Joe/Shady

Grove/

Chinquipin

Hunting/Mississippi Sawyer

Theo Lissenberg; Mike Fenton; the Steamboat
Entertainers (Magnus Norman, Bert Lundin,
Mikael Nilsson, Ola Karlsson, Bjorn Forsberg,
and Karl Dalland). Schara Band (featuring
Theiler and Tom Lochbrunner); the
Mountain Boys (Kazuhiro
Inaba, Kazutaka Akaki, Kentaro Kinoshita,
and
Toshiki
Imai,
Shimamura,
Tatsuya
Gerard

New

commended

be

Mountain &amp;

(Jaybird)/01d

Bloomingdale,

This is an album that had to be done.
Mike Fenton and Bobby Patterson are to

Old Time,

Ridge

Bobby Lundy,

Margaret Dobbs, Dale Dobbs, Stefan Senders,
Carol Elizabeth Reynolds, Howie Tamower,
Ruthie Domfeld, Chris Jones, Eric Leven son,
Ronnie Higgins, Larry Lindseyjames Lindsey,
Wendell Cockerham, Thurman Pugh, Tommy
Jarrell, Paul Brown, Jack Hirschom.

GALAX
INTER
NATIONAL

Tennessee

Bob

Smiling

Hiroyuki Satoh); Pete Parish; Judy Jones; Rod
Jones; the Rhythm Godzilla (Koske T akaki,
Ken Inoue, and Kazumi Inoue); Betty Baking

Plate &amp; the Bull Mountain Bakers (Esben
Jacobsen, Knud Pederson, Bente Prior, Steen
Orsted, Jette Prior, Finn Alfred Larsen, and
Carsten Holm; Mike Preston; The Wildcats

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

for

completing

this

project. The logistics seem incredible. They
had to coordinate musicians from Britain,
the
Netherlands,
Japan, Denmark, and
Switzerland, come up with tapes from
each group, and assemble biographies.
They deserve blue ribbons right there. If
the balance of recordings relating to a

Sweden,

the

Australia,

Italy,

U.S.,

performer seems old, just
particular
consider the above-mentioned problems.
Pete Parish was the first
foreigner
recorded here to visit the Galax Fiddlers
convention, attending

in

1969. He opened

floodgate. Many of these artists have won
ribbons at Galax, beginning with Mike
Fenton in 1972, showing the quality of
old-time music and bluegrass played
outside the U.S.A. The draw of this music
wsa so great that several of these musicians
--including Pete Parish, Rafe Stefanini,
Hiro Arita, and Ken and Kazumi Inoue-have moved to the U.S. I met several of
these musicians on their early trips to
Galax and other festivals and am very
a

to see their
accomplishments
displayed on this two-record set.
While the sound quality varies, the
musicianship is consistently high, and a

pleased

stylistic balance is attained. The
is
almost all strong, featuring
mountain ballads, Carter Family favorites,
lush
bluegrass harmonies, and peppy
vocals on old-time fiddle tunes. Perhaps it
will
well these
how
many
surprise
musicians sing American traditional songs,
especially those whose first language is not
nice,

singing

English.
especially
impressed by the
in the New
musicians
Japanese bluegrass
Smiling Mountain Boys and by Hiro
Arita's hot, hot banjo playing. Rafe
Stefanini's old-time fiddling is also
I

was

something to watch for.
It

is

interesting

to

try

to

guess

the

influences of many of the musicians. It is
obvious that many of the old-time bands
spent
bands

a

lot of time poring over 78s of classic
like the Skillet Lickers and the

Georgia Yellow Hammers, while others
seem to have learned from first hand
contact with older musicians at fiddlers

conventions on their summer sojourns to
America or from field recordings. Others
apparently picked up their stylizations
from younger old-time musicians like
Plank Road, Ace Weems and the Fat Meat
Boys, or the Any Old Time String Band.
Regardless of where they learned their
music, they all play with spirit and love of
the musical
forms. There should be
something in this set for almost any fan of
old-time, mountain, and bluegrass music.
(Kerry Blech)
To order: Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box
278, Galax, VA 24333

�Other members play jug, bones, fiddle,
was
and
Jim
banjo. The engineer

Rooney; his presence is a link to the
1960s folk revival particularly the jug
band revival, an acknowledged influence
on the band.

The selections include some standards
of the genre ("Titanic" and "What's the
Matter with the Mill?" from Koerner,
Ray, and Glover, and "K. C. Moon"
from the Jim Kweskin Jug Band, but it is

mixed bag. The band features numbers
classic blues vein
"Crazy Blues"
and "Empty Boudoir Blues," sung by Jill
Klein; Jimmie Rodgers' "The Women
Make a Fool out of Me"; and a Helen
Humes jazz ballad, "Mound Bayou."
Like many of the '60s jug bands, the
band does not usually stick to the older
styles in its arrangements of the songs,
but tries out different things. For
example, "Don't You Love Your Daddy
No More" has a Dan Hicks-like harmony
chorus, and "Blue Moon of Kentucky" is
a

in the

given

a

Calypso

treatment.

Instrumentally, the band draws from the
backgrounds of its members for a
but tasteful
somewhat conventional
mixture of blues, bluegrass, and swing.
The prevailing attitude is good-timey.
(Joe La Rose)
To order: Rounder Records, One Camp
St.

Cambridge, MA 02140

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�is a vocal-oriented
band,
strong singing of Sylvia
DeLaney, who has won numerous blue
ribbons in folksong at fiddlers conventions
in North Carolina and Virginia. A lot of
their material comes from the British Isles,
a fact I find surprising for a North Carolina
band, but this really isn't an old-time band.
Two of the three instrumentals feature

Appalwood

featuring

the

some pyrotechnic guitar leads by guests
Gerald Anderson and Wayne Henderson.
A slow waltz rounds out the instrumental
display.
has done a fine job in
that suits their style of
material
selecting
solid but not flashy instrumental work
backing solid vocals. This is the type of
record that should garner a lot of airplay on
radio stations that feature folk music rather
than hard-core old-time music. (Kerry

Appalwood

Blech)
To order: Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box
280, Galax, VA 24333

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Dock Boggs and Roscoe Holcomb. He's
head and shoulders over the majority of
the banjo players you'll hear at any given

festival.
There are three guitar players noted:
Carol Elizabeth, Rafe, and Jim Miller
(guest musician). I'm not sure who's
playing what when, but it's all very
capable and some of it is-- well, slick.
One or more of those three really has
his/her chops down.
Rafe has leaped over cultural barriers
to the point that he's fluent in old-time
musical idioms and can probably outfiddle 99 out of 100 American-born
fiddlers. I hear a lot of Bruce Molsky and
Benton Flippin in his playing. Rafe has
command of his technical skills; he's an
excellent fiddler on the brink of
becoming one of the all-time greats.
There's occasional stiffness in tunes such
as "Say Darlin' Say" and "Strong Little
Girl," but this is nit-picking in view of
the overall strength of his playing. He is
absolutely brilliant on the "Eighth of
January" and "Grigsby's Hornpipe."
The Wildcats repertoire is varied and
interesting, again representing the
panoramic scope of old-time music
today. They're partial to the more
modern sound of the Mt. Airy/Galax
the Camp Creek
area "big bands"-Boys, the Smokey Valley Boys, the Pine
but although
Ridge Boys and Patsy-that's
not
do
it
well,
my favorite
they
material on the tape. I love it when they
get off the beaten path with numbers like

"Maggie Walker," with powerful
harmony singing (Stefan leading), clean
Dock Boggs banjo picking, and tight
lead-in

January"

and
a

ending;
la

or

Possum

"Eighth

of

Hunters, with
kind of stop-time

inspired fiddling and a
punctuation on the low part that's
exciting without having the forced,
festival jam-session sound that things
like that sometimes lead to.
The shining star of the whole tape,
"On Top of Old Smokey" (no, it's a
completely different version) has an
instrumental
a
lead-in,
outstanding
melodic doubling of banjo and guitar
that's so tight they sound like one
instrument, compelling vocals, and a

sense of rhythm so strong it grabs you by
the lapels and shoves you against the wall
with every beat.
I'm hoping the Wildcats don't follow
the classic old-time band pattern of
getting on each other's nerves and
splitting up. Maybe living hundreds of
miles apart will preserve them. If so,
expect to see a lot more of them in years
to

come.

the meantime, if you've been saving
your pennies for something special, this
In

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

cassette

recording
Leftwich)

gets

of

my vote for the best
the past year. (Brad

To order: Marimac Recordings,
Box 5, Little Ferry, N.J. 07643

P.O.

�shows what a hot
mandolist can do with old-time fiddle
tunes. He's right on the melodic money.
Seitz's
bowing is classic, old-time
Missouri style, before the old-timers
started listening to Texas contest-style
players. It is relentlessly rhythmic on
the hoedowns, with occasional slurs and
syncopation to grab your attention.
Geoff shows his technical command

Buckhannon

with sweet playing on some of the songs.
Their program is nicely varied too,
the sound is immediately
although
identifiable as Ill-Mo, similar to the
styles of the Indian Creek Delta Boys and
Four of the
the Volo Bogtrotters.
numbers come from R.P. Christenson's
collection The Old Time Fiddler's
Repertory. A couple of selections come
from Missouri fiddler, Frank Reed, who
one of my personal favorites.
was
Another four tunes were garnered from
that wonderful source, the Indian Creek
Delta Boys.
A nice

touch on the mix

is

that the

fiddler and mandolin are (mostly) in
different channels, so those playing this
tape on a stereo system can adjust the
balance to their liking. I first listened to it
on a monaural system, and being a
fiddler, I wanted more fiddle than
mandolin. I now am contented. I

enjoyed this band and
await
their next offering. (Kerry
eagerly

thoroughly
Blech)

To order: Marimac Recordings,
Box 5, Little Ferry, NJ 07643.

P.O.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�TRADITIONAL FIDDLE MUSIC
OF MISSOURI: Charlie Walden
with Emily and Dennis Buckhannon
The

Irish Cobbler/Long John/Mother's
Waltz/Tune
in
C/Stars and Stripes
Waltz/Ned Kendall's Hornpipe and
Constitution Hornpipe /Vee Latty's Bb
Waltz/Rosebud Hornpipe/Casey's OldTime Waltz/Jesse's Quadrille/Irish Reel/
Opera Reel/Smith's Reel/Bill Powell's
Waltz/Carrollton County Breakdown/
Spotted Pony/Zack Wheat's Piece/
Johnny Don't Come Home Drunk/Bill

Caton's Hornpipe or Jeff City

Charlie Walden- fiddle; Emily Buckhannonpiano; Dennis Buckhannon- guitar.
This tape of Missouri dance tunes is a
wonderful introduction to the rich heritage
of old-time music from Missouri. Charlie
Walden fiddles 20 rare and beautiful
regional tunes with Emily and Dennis
Louis
area
Buckhannon
of the St.
providing piano and guitar backup. The
strong,

silvery

fiddling

Buckhannons'
accompaniment

as

glides

steady,

over, the

striding

one toe-tapper follows

another.
The tunes come from many sources.
Some are from older fiddlers like Cyril
Stinnett, a celebrated former National
Champion or from R. P. Christeson,

whose Old-Time Fiddlers' Repertory
(University of Missouri Press, 1973) is a

reminiscent of the Riendeau family of
upper New England. Is this because of a
common French connection? Missouri was
an ethnic crossroads by the end of the 19th
when
the early
Scotch-Irish,
century
and
French were joined by
Blacks,
Eastern Europeans, and
Germans,
Scandinavians. This rich cultural stew
seems to have produced a more varied
musical
tradition
than
one finds in
southern mountains.
several respects, the music here
bit
more "civilized"
than

In
a

is

also

the

rambunctious

southern stringband music
with which I am more familiar. Written
sources in the form of song books were
important vehicles for transmission, and
Missouri fiddlers often composed their
own tunes, which implies that the folks
there were able to read and write music. An

important effect of this is to preserve
and highly
"complete"
complicated
versions of tunes
and
to
limit
at least to the point at which
still identifiable to its composer.
Another difference is that the fiddle
remains in the standard (EADG) tuning
and the fiddler plays in more keys,
including Bb and F, sometimes employing
higher positions up the neck. All of these

improvisation,

a

tune

is

some more
things
suggest
familiarity with musical theory.

academic

Finally, and most importantly,
Walden's Missouri fiddle tunes are quite
simply beautiful. He is one of the most

Bible to many midwestern musicians.
Other
tunes are from recordings of

fiddlers I have ever heard in
the power and sensitivity of his playing.
While I ordinarily can't stand vibrato,
having associated it with the pretentious
styles that are eating away at traditional
mountain fiddling here in the East, Charlie
uses the technique with such artistry and
feeling that it does what it is supposed to
on his exquisite waltzes,
do, especially
and tonal
adding emotional
intensity
brilliance to the ends of phrases. Here,

breakdowns.
While I had not heard of most of these

truly,

Columbia

and Jefferson City
radio
of
the
1920s
and
30s:
Vee
performers
Latty, George Morris (the Fiddlin' Sheriff)
and Bill Caton, a legendary black hornpipe
fiddler from Tebbetts. The tunes form a
with a different
real dance repertoire,
rhythmic pattern for each kind of dance.
There are quadrilles, jigs, hornpipes, and
waltzes as well as the familiar 4/ 4 reels and

pieces, parts of certain tunes had a familiar
ring that was hard to place. Maybe it is only
the steady beat of the piano, but I think that
many of the selections have a flavor
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

extraordinary

is danceable music that is at once
both pretty and beautiful. (Gail Gillespie)

To order: Marimac Recordings,
Box 5, Little Ferry, NY 07643

P.O.

�folklorists' efforts, are sponsoring annual
gatherings of cowboy singers and poets, the
best known of these perhaps being the
gathering at Elko, Nevada. Folklorist Hal
Cannon has published an anthology of
cowboy poetry and has produced a fine
film
of one
of
these
documentary
gatherings.

A few individuals stand out to me as
stalwarts of cowboy song and lore, who
have toured regularly for years singing
range songs and reciting the best of cowboy
poetry. I have seen three of these gentlemen
perform often over the past 18 or so years:
Glenn
Ohrlin
of Mountain
View,
Arkansas; Steve Cormier, currently of
Santa Rosa, New Mexico; and the subject
of this review, Bob Bovee, a native

Nebraskan, currently living
Minnesota.

in

Rushford,

Of the 20 pieces Bob performs on this
tape, many are what could be considered
cowboy standards. He says that these are
the songs his audiences want to hear, but
have had a hard time finding recordings of.
He has done his loyal fans, and those
destined to be his new fans, a fine service.
Bob performs most of the songs solo,
the old-time way, not like the "Holly
wood" Cowboy" groups like the Sons of
the Pioneers might gussy them up. He has
the correct voice for this approach, that
broad Nebraskan accent, which adds to the
air of authenticity. He provides strong but
spare accompaniment on guitar, frailed
banjo, and the french harp (harmonica).
His musical partner, Gail Heil, accompan
ies him on fiddle on a few cuts and sings
harmony on one.

Bob came by many of these songs via his
his Grandma Mason and Uncle
family
Herman Lienemann. Others he gathered
from singers he has met over the years.
Bob's cowboy repertoire runs the gamut
from nostalgia for the range to the tragedies
on the trail, giving a realistic portrayal.
Some songs are sad, others are quite
humorous. The liner notes are quite
detailed, as Bob gives us his personal
sources for the material and also adds some
well-researched historical details.
Bob Bovee has long been one of my
favorite cowboy singers, and I happily give

strong recommendation that people
purchase this tape. If you find that this one
does tickle your musical senses, I'd also
suggest: Bob Bovee and Gail Heil Behind the
Times (cassette, Marimac
9007), Bob
Bovee and Gail Heil Fcrr Old Time's Sake
(album, Train on the Island-12, P.O. Box
9701, Minneapolis, MN 55440), Bob
Bovee The Roundup (album, Train on the
Island-6), Make Me a Cowboy Again for a
Day (cassette, anthology of cowboy songs
from 78s, Marimac 9106) (Kerry Blech)
a

To order: Marimac Recordings, P.O. Box
5, Little Ferry, NY 07643
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�played two of the tunes Joe picked up.
Other sources are the Nelson Brothers
of North
and
Jimmy Hendrickson

from
and Bill Smith
Saskatchewan. Some of Joe's anecdotes
are
downright charming too. He
mentions that "Corn on the Cob" is "an
awful lot like 'Logger's Breakdown" as
recorded by Don Messer, but also adds

Dakota,

that

a

Texas friend of his had heard Eck

Robertson and Eck's dad play it in Texas
in the '20s. Yes, the commentary is
are the interesting
that
grace some pages, but
photographs
it is the music that is the reason people

delightful
will

as

book.

this

want

These

are

"Northern-style" tunes, from the upper
Midwest. They have lots of notes and
interesting, challenging twists. Many
tunes go up into second and third
position and five
is definitely not

are in flat

keys, so this

book for beginning
and
intermediate
think
I
musicians will enjoy these
a

fiddlers.
advanced
tunes, though. They are dance tunes and
Joe P. has been playing dances for 60
years, so we know they work. For "ear"
musicians, seven of these tunes can be
heard played by Joe on three different
Voyager albums. It's too bad a sound
sheet wasn't included with the book, but
that probably would have driven the
price up. As it is, the folks at Voyager
have again done a commendable job in
adding to their catalogue of regional
fiddling which appears on records, tapes
and in book form. (Kerry Blech)
order:
Voyager Recordings and
Publications, 424 35th Avenue, Seattle,
To

WA 98122

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

continued from page 28
one of these
things as you try to
learn "Rya's House." And
by all means, don't dis

PLEASE do

miss this outwardly sim

ple piece before you've
it. It's a real blue

heard

ribbon number that brings

out the best in the oldtime clawhammer banjo.

-Paul Brown
Discography:

Rounder

2016

"Ain't Gonna Rain
More:

An

No

Historical Sur

vey of Pre-Blues &amp; Blues
in Piedmont North Carolina."

�Dear Old

Time

Herald

Readers:

are invited to a very special festival, on Memorial Day Weekend,
Friday-Monday, at the beautiful Brady's Run Park, in the Beaver Valley,
You

26-29,

May
in

Western

PA.

The

offer

We
a

warm,

Beaver Valley festival combines bluegrass, old time music, and squaredancing.
wide range of acoustic music from very traditional to very progressive, in
friendly, and fun-filled environment.
a

This years performers include Mike Seeger, David Grisman, The Horseflies, New
Grass Revival, The Heartbeats, Coal Country Cloggers, The Nashville Bluegrass Band,
Peter Rowan, Ralph Stanley &amp; Clinch Mountain Boys, The Boiled Buzzard String Band,
Del McCurry and Dixie Pals, Dave Krysty &amp; Bill Lemons,
Larry Sparks S Lonesome
There will be over 25 bluegrass,
Ramblers, Beaver Creek, and The Reno Brothers.
old time string bands, and solo traditional music acts throughout the four days.
The excellent

this festival
There

main

special.

stage entertainment

is

just one of the many things that

be workshops in autoharp, old time
dulcimer, beginning /advanced clogging,
The
bluegrass fiddle, banjo, mandolin, and guitar.
have a chance to ask questions and learn from many
&amp;

will

hammered

banjo,

old

time

fiddle,

make

mountain

beginning/advanced squaredancing,
workshops are informal and you
nationally known performers.

There is a special children's stage with concerts and activities
(some of us big kids particularly enjoy these concerts)!

throughout the day

There are nightly squaredances (some contras) with hot bands and callers, including
The floor is cement (sorry, right
Horseflies and Heartbeats, in a large ice arena.
shoes will help), but very large, so there is plenty of room to move around in.
There
are some clogging platforms.
The

There

will

be

dance

performances

by

The

There is excellent, healthy food available
dinners.
Vegetarian meals are also available.

Fiddle
at

Puppets and Coal Country Cloggers.

reasonable prices,

including

full

sit-down

The campground is beautiful, with streams, a lake, and marked hiking trails.
are two separate areas; pickers circle where the all night jam sessions around
the campfires flourish, and sleepy hollow, where there are children's playgrounds, and
more isolation. All relatively close to the stages and workshop areas, and ice arena
that offers hot showers and flush toilets.

There

There's arts S crafts, highly visible 24-hour security, and nice motels in the
We are only 20 minutes
from the
price ranges nearby for you non-campers.
Pittsburgh Airport and a limited, free shuttle service is available to and from the airport.
Super-saver rates to Pittsburgh are quite reasonable.
modest

under

The advance ticket
16 are free.

price

7091

all

four

days,

including

camping,

is

only $30,

children

a free
brochure describing the 7th Annual Beaver Valley Festival, write Beaver
Festival, P.O. Box 584, Beaver, PA, 15009, or call Randy &amp; Susie at (412) 457days, (412) 457-7980 evenings.

For

Valley

for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�THE

HERALD

OLD-TIME

PROVOCATIVE!

INFORMATIVE!
A

"The Old-Time Herald-so far so good, no wasted
space, every issue a collectible and read cover to cover

house. Keep

up the

INTERESTING!

QUARTERLY MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO
THE SUPPORT AND PROMOTION OF
OLD-TIME MUSIC.

What readers are saying:

at our

INSIGHTFUL!

HISTORICAL AND CONTEMPORARY ARTICLES
REVIEWS

good work."
John Hartford, Madison, TN

"The Old-Time Herald can help bring the national oldtime music community together
It will make sure this
music continues into the future."

"□"yes]"
I

Dedicated

to the memory of
the old-time musicians
Who have passed onAnd to those who are carrying it on
all

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ISSUES IN OLD-TIME MUSIC
ASK? UNCLE HAROLD HERE AND THERE

I

check

for $15.00 is

enclosed.

I

j

had always hoped for something like this and I'm glad
it's here. My grandfather would be proud."
David Ramsey Macon, Greenbrier, TN

PHOTOS

wish to become a subscriber to
The Old-Time Herald for one year.
My

I

David Holt, Fairvlew, NC
"I

DANCE BEAT

(Foreign subscriptions $18 U.S.)
The OLD-TIME HERALD, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA.

Name

I-I

City

I

24333

State

Zip

1
i
i

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12170">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 1, Number 8 (Summer 1989)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12171">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12172">
                <text>&lt;br /&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 8 (May-July 1989)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Joe &amp;amp; Odell Thompson,” by Wayne Martin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Big Singin’ – May 22, 1988,” by Ray Bowman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘The Blond-Haired Kid Who Can Really Fiddle’,” by Anne Donley&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – 11 Ways to Learn to Call Traditional Square Dances,” by Larry Edelman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – In &amp;amp; Around D.C.,” by Julianne Mangin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Kentucky/Virginia Borderlands,” by Rachel Anne Goodman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12173">
                <text>1989</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="971">
        <name>1989</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5545">
        <name>Anne Donley</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5541">
        <name>Joe Thompson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5547">
        <name>Julianne Mangin</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5546">
        <name>Larry Edelman</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5542">
        <name>Odell Thompson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5548">
        <name>Rachel Anne Goodman</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5544">
        <name>Ray Bowman</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5543">
        <name>Wayne Martin</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2520" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3446">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/ff6d4fedb838f9825899bb82587be4dd.pdf</src>
        <authentication>e72927b88d3c5f372c26cf890370d2f3</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12174">
                    <text>1989

August-October

Fall $4.50
THE

HERALD

OLD-TIME

A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

"WAY OUT WEST"

Cowboy Songs
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&amp;

Singers

�FALL AND WINTER
JOHN

C.

1989 MUSIC

1-800-562-2440

WINTER DANCE WEEK

LABOR DAY FAMILY
MUSIC &amp; DANCE WEEKEND
September

December

January

1,

1990

ASPARAGUS

a
four member band from Western
Is
with George
Marshall, Anne Percival, David
Cantienl, and Kerry Elkln playing a variety of traditional New
England dance music; music that has Its roots in the British Isles
and Canada. Using their unique blend of instruments, creativity and skills, they
offer a sensitive and powerful performance. On their recent tours. Wild
Asparagus has been highly successful in bringing their music to dances and
concerts throughout the United States. The musicians arc Ann Percival on piano,
accordian, synthesizer, Dave Canticni on oboe, flute, fife, and recorder, Kerry

WILD

Massachusetts

LARRY EPELMAN: Larry specializes in southern and northern dance
styles. He calls, plays guitar &amp; mandolin for dances and leads workshops.

KAREN BILLINGS:

to

This year's Winter Dance Week features the outstanding contra band WILD
ASPARAGUS, and a superb staff of musicians and callers. Make plans to join
the fun of dances, instrument and dance workshops, calling instruction and the
special experience of the John C. Campbell Folk School.

STAFF

PETE SUTHERLAND:

26

1989

1-4,

This special weekend emphasizes family participation. Parents and children
have joint and separate activities including dancing of contras, squares, and cir
cles, playpartics, crafts, and instrument workshops. The carefully selected staTf
generously gives its time, knowledge, and experience to make this family
weekend the finest in America. Live music is used throughout live weekend.

guitar player, he provides

DANCE

&amp;
CAMPBELL FOLK SCHOOL

fantastic fiddler, METAMORA member, piano
music &amp; leads instrument workshops.

a

&amp;

Elkin on fiddle, and George Marshall on concertina, bones, and bodhran. George
teaches and calls New England style contras. Ann and George work as a team to
teach a wide range of couple dancing including swing/jitterbug, and Swedish
couple dances. Members of Wild Asparagus have been on staff at many festivals,
dance weeks, and special events. Wild Asparagus has recorded an album on its
own label.

pianist, singer, and versatile dance caller, Karen will

lead calling and music making sessions. She also plays autoharp.

PHIL JAMISON:

Phil is a member of the Green Grass Cloggcrs and a
caller. He calls squares, circles, &amp; contras and leaches clogging. He
will lead instrument workshops in banjo, guitar and fiddle.

seasoned

STAFF

MARTHA OWEN:

one of the Folk School's resident artists, Martha
is a
storyteller and leaches playparty games. Sire will lead activities including crafts

STEVE IIICKMAN:

JULIA McCRORY: Julia plays fiddle, mandolin, recorder

BOB WILLOUGIIBY: Bob is a Tennessee musician, he plays piano
in blues, swing, and southern styles.

superb fiddler of any style and hambonc specialist.

for children.

will lead instrument workshops for adults and children, and
tivities. Julia is a member of FAR HORIZONS.

BRUCE

GREENE:

much sought

after as

a
a

cello. She
lead children's ac
and

FRANK HALL:

fiddler with a great repertoire of Kentucky tunes &amp;
dance musician, Bruce plays for dances and leads

a

RODNEY SUTTON:

WORKSHOPS

TIM CAPE:

Fiddle, piano, mandolin, recorder, banjo, guitar, squares, contras, clogging,
buckdancing; play party games, song swaps; music, dance and crafts for chil

is

a

dren.

Cathy
a

is an

experienced dance caller,

all styles.

member of the FIDDLE PUPPETS, dogger!

fiddler and

SCOTT RUSSELL:

guitar

versatile step dancer, dogger, fiddler and caller.

CATHY ANDERSON:

workshops.

&amp;

a

member of CATTY WAMPAS.

Atlanta caller, guitarist &amp; member of CATTYWAMPAS.

LAURA SIMS: northern

and southern styles dance caller.

WORKSHOPS
buckdancc, rapper dancing; fiddle, piano, guitar,
mandolin, oilier dance instruments; gospel singing, caller's workshop, hambonc.
Swing, jitterbug, clogging,

MUSIC AND DANCE AT THE FOLK SCHOOL
For more than 50 years,

music

dance has been an integral part of the educational and recreational
today as one of the cornerstone institutions in the current

programs at the John C. Camp
national popularity of country
dancing and folk music. It is a long-standing member of the Country Dance and Song Society of America. Blending the comraderie
of a dance or music camp with the Folk School
experience makes dancing or making music in Brasstown a memorable and unique
time. The Folk School experience is a combination of elements:
bell

Folk

and

School. The School exists

residential

instructors living in close proximity in our well-furnished house dorms and eating at our
develop sound friendships away from the program meeting area.
The dance floor. The Folk School's community room has one of the country's finest dance floors. Made of beautiful oak hard
wood, it is ideal for dancing.
The setting. Located in the rural Western North Carolina mountains, the charm of woods, hills, and fields provide an isolation that
draws students together.
That "purposeful energy" created by our long history of dedicated personalities: founders, students, teachers and staff.
The Folk School is also well-known for its courses in traditional crafts and self-sufficiency skills. Weekend, one, and two week cours

Tin

Keith House

es are

campus.

dining room

Students

are

able

and

to

offered throughout the year.

For registration and course information call or write the
John C. Campbell Folk School
Rt. 1 Box 14A
Brasstown, NC 28902

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1-800-562-2440

or

(704)

837-2775

�The OLD-TIME HERALD

Vol. 2 No. 1
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
Rt. 2 Box A-l
Woodlawn, VA 24381

Editor
Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Hilary Dirlam
Brad

Leftwich

Phil Jamison

Contributors
Gail

Gillespie, Linda
Brown, Hank
Sapoznik, Molly Tenenbaum, Lome
Greenwood, Patricia Hall, Craig
Johnson, Bob Bovee, Joyce Cauthen,
Dale Morris, Pete Sutherland, Patsy
Weiler, Charles K. Wolfe.
Blech,

Kerry

Paul

Higginbotham,

Advertising

Dale Morris, Ann Simpson

Old-Time Music Group, Inc.:
Board of Directors
Alice Gerrard, Margaret Martin, Bobby

Patterson, Hilary Dirlam, Kathy World,
Jack Bernhardt.

Advisory Board
Brad Leftwich, Linda Higginbotham

No

of

part

this

in any

be
may
magazine
form without written

reproduced
permission from the publisher. Not
responsible for loss or non-return of
unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
1987 The Old-Time Herald
The Old-Time Herald (ISSN 1040358)
(USPS 002672) is published quarterly
the first of August,
November,
February, and May by the Old-Time
Music Group, Inc. Rt. 2 Box A-l,
Woodlawn, VA 24381. Subscription
rates payable in advance. One year

(foreign subscriptions $18.00
U.S.). Classified ads cost .50 cents per
word, minimum of $7.00. Any

$15.00

is
letters or numbers
one word. All classified ads
must be received by the first of the
month, one month prior to publication.

of

grouping

counted

Second

as

Class

postage

Woodlawn, VA 24381.

paid

at

POSTMASTER: Send change of address
to the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box
1362, Galax, VA 24333.
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. is a not-forprofit, tax-exempt corporation under section 501(c)
(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�FROM
THE

EDITOR
On

April

9,

1989,

the

Old-Time

Music Group,

Inc., publishers of the
Old-Time Herald held a meeting in
Chapel Hill, N.C. The purpose was to
meet and talk with other magazine

publishers
share

and interested persons, to
from their
and benefit
and experience. The "Sounds

ideas,

knowledge

of the South" conference afforded us the
opportunity to talk with many at the
and to invite several to be

conference,

part of our meeting on the 9th.
Weary, yet energized by the many
sounds and ideas we had all heard and
partaken of over the three days, these
friends came to the OTMG meeting on
Sunday and generously shared their

time,

expertise, and ideas,

that helping

THANK

recognizing

one can only help us all.
YOU Pete and Kitsy

Archie
Green,
Tony
Russell, Margaret Martin, Mike Seeger,
Ann Kimsey, Mac Benford, Mark Moss,

Kuykendall,
and Sandy

Hobgood, who kindly

let us

use his home and kitchen.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Of

course

there

will

differences between
folklore and the

the

ist.

Richie

Stearns

promising me
OK if

be

always

student

of

musician/conservation

best

stated

it,

sympathetic tones, "It's
you want to become a folklorist.
in

We'll come and dust you off once

in

a

while."
Peter Schwarz

Cambridge,

MA

I am primarily an old-time,
two-finger
My main early influence was
banjoist.

Art Rosenbaum. I've always appreciated
his eclecticism of styles (not just Galax

clawhammer style), the fieldwork

he has

done, and the pioneer role he took in
developing melodic style. I still get ideas
from his melodic variations: five or six
versions of "Old Joe Clark." He also, in
his two fine albums, convincingly shows
the old-time banjo can stand alone as a
lead instrument. Whatever adjective, or
title, or box people want to put his style
in, he's one of the best.
Howard Bursen represents northern

melodic

old-time

banjo

(my

Wonderful, dazzling stuff.
really sounds like that in person

distinction).
And he
too.

Ken Perlman has laid groundwork for
accurate tablature transcription of banjo
by developing and refining a previously
random tab system that everyone did
just a little differently. He's now putting
music from other cultures into melodic
clawhammer format.
Interview these guys and add even
more ingredients to the semantic stew.

Steve Loring
Cadillac, MI

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�HERE &amp; THERE
We would like to thank Louis Wild of

Commerce,

Ga.

for sending

us the sad

news of the death of Lawrence Eller of
fine old-time singer
Wild wrote: "He
died this month [Dec. 1, 1988] and will

Hiawassee, Ga.,

a

missed

by

old-time music enthusiasts.

that left no toe
banjo
untapping. His wife, Ruby, and he had
that rare ability to look you in the eye,
take you by the arm, and touch your
heart. 'We feel we've just known you
had

a

always;

flowers.'"

you're

Andy

Andrews,

located

the

in

Pennsylvania/Delaware area, writes us
that they have performed a lot locally
."
"We are excited about our progress.

Mr.

and banjo player.
be
He

and

welcome

as

as

May

Hank Edenborn writes us that he has
started a small record company called
White Oak Records to primarily feature
the music of Don Stover. He writes that
Don recorded an album recently with
Red Rector, Art Stamper, Tom Gray,
Herb Applin, and Roger Williams, and it
includes a lot of old-time songs. [We will
be reviewing this album in a future issue
of the OTH1

weekly radio show
on Sundays at 9 pm over KSDS fm 88.3
in San Diego, Calif. He plays "old-time
rags,
jazz, blues, early swing, gospel,
vaudeville, and hot dance music."
Lou Curtiss has

a

The OTH receives

many newsletters

from various organizations, record
companies, etc. From time to time we'd
like to mention a few of them for your
interest. We recently received a copy of
the Yazoo Review, from Yazoo Records,
Inc., PO Box 810, Newton, NJ 07860. It
contains in-depth reviews of records,
tapes, compact discs, and books, with
information and prices. It
ordering
focuses on blues.
Old-Time Country, the University of
Mississippi, Center for the Study of
Southern Culture, University, MS
38677, is a nicely put together
newsletter edited by W. K. McNeil. It
contains articles, photos, and reviews.
A
newsletter of the
1-page
Birmingham Country Dance Society,
2169 Shady brook Lane, Birmingham,
AL 35266, focuses on music and dance
happenings in the Birmingham area.
To
Be
Announced is an Ohio
Newsletter: PO Box 156, Brady Lake,
It prints articles on regional
OH 442
music and musicians, and has reviews
1

1

conference
in
the
Appalachians" was held at Johnson City,
Tenn. The event was sponsored by the
Center for Appalachian Studies of East
Tennessee State University. During the
on

On April 27-29,

"Old-Time

1989,

a

Dancing

three
conference,
day
demonstrates,
lectures,

workshops,
and

films

covered topics including old-time square
dancing, buckdancing, flatfooting, and
clogging, and the Black and Cherokee
dance traditions. Aside from being
informative, the conference offered a
great chance to meet others interested in
Appalachian dance, and to share ideas
and information.
The tentative date for next year's
conference is March, 1990. For details
contact:

Susan

Spalding,

Center

for

Appalachian Studies and Services, Box
19180 A, Johnson City, TN 376140002 (615-929-5348).
For all of you in Iowa, don't forget the
14th Old-Time Country Music Contest
&amp; Festival (and Pioneer Exposition of
Arts &amp; Crafts) on Aug. 30 at the
Pottawattamie County Fairgrounds in
Avoca, Iowa. Write PO Box 438,

Walnut, IA 51577 for information.

and listings of events.

April 6-8, 1989, a "conference
celebration of southern traditional
music," 'Sounds of the South,' was held
On

The Plywood Cattle Co., consisting of
Dan Brown, George Huhn, A1 Walton,
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and

on the campus of the University of
North Carolina at Chapel Hill. It was
sponsored by the University of North
Carolina and the North Carolina Arts
Council, and marked the official

opening of the Southern Folklife
Collection at UNC. "One of the nation's
folk

largest

music

SFC

the

archives,

extensive

contains

holdings of sound
research
and
materials,
recordings
combining the John Edwards Memorial
Collection, with its more than 14,000
rare 78-rpm discs, and several other
special collections."
was
The Conference
a
three-day
marathon of mainly fascinating
presentations and panel discussions with
such experts as Norm Cohen, Archie
Green, Dan Patterson, Bess Hawes, Dave
Freeman, Ken Irwin, Billy Altman, Bill
Malone, Paul Oliver, Worth Long,
Helen Lewis, Bill Ivey, Guy and Candie
Carawan, and many others there to offer

their

opinions,

expertise,

and

perspectives.

There was a concert on Friday night
Wade and Julia Mainer, Doug
Wallin, Etta Baker, Mike Seeger,
Tommy Thompson, and others.
On Saturday a historic and important
presentation and panel discussion took
place entitled "The Chapel Hill/Durham
String Band Revival Retrospective."
were
Alan
There
by
presentations
of the
American Folklife
Jabbour
Center, and founding member of the
Hollow Rock String Band; by Tom
with

Carter,
and

Mountain

Conway,

old-time

folklorist,

member

former

of

Band;

String

folklorist,

in
participant
"scene." After

and

the

were comments by

musician,
the

and

who
observer

Fuzzy

Cece
was a

by

of

the

presentation there
Blanton Owen, Hazel

Dickens, Alice Gerrard, Mac Benford,
Archie Green, Bertram Levy, and others.
was initiated by Dan
Patterson, chairman of the folklore
curriculum at UNC, and George Holt
and Wayne Martin of the Folklife
Section of the North Carolina Arts
Council. The retrospective was the first
The retrospective

time that the string band "revival"

continued on page 43

has

�THE

OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Will

Be

at the

GALAX

OLD FIDDLER'S

CONVENTION

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Come See Us!

�"WAY OUT WEST:"
Cowboy Songs
&amp; Singers
by

Bob Bovee

"Windy Bill" and they'll still probably
request "Cool Water" or "San Antonio
Rose," thinking they have a handle on
the genre. You might do better in a
working-class bar in the West where
or

they still recall and sing the real cowboy

songs. Generally, however, the concepts
of "country-western" (which is mostly
neither country nor western anymore)
and "western swing" throw a blanket of
confusion
that
obscures the more
traditional music that has emerged from
our West. The fact that little authentic

courtesy

Bob

Bovee

cowboy music has been available on
easily accessible commercial recordings,

Montana sheepherder

The

West, and cowboys

in

particular,

have given us our most widespread and
influential American mythology. The
real history of the frontier provided a
basis; the media from the 1800s to the

have reflected, refracted,
embroidered, and exaggerated it. What
most people know about the West is a
result of the dime novel tradition that
extends through the movies, television,

present

and

Hollywood-cowboy songs. Even

those who know

a

for

lot about the reality,

colored their perceptions.
Likewise, cowboy music is one of
America's best-known and least under
stood musical
forms. Traveling in
encountered
the "cowboy
Europe,
the myth has

I

clubs"

clientele

in

Germany
dressed

where the German
in
western
style,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

1904

including boots, ten-gallon hats and sixguns. The appropriate music to them
was anything from Hank Williams to the
Kingston Trio or bluegrass. The same

was true of the Belgian cabbie
spurs in his taxi on his way
show at his local folk club. If it
or banjo and was American, it

who wore

to see my
had guitar
fit his idea

cowboy music. And probably the
requested song that our string
band, attired in western clothes, received
the
streets of Germany
on
was
of

most

"Bonanza," which they all knew from the
TV show.
Even in our own country, if I mention

traditional

cowboy

songs,

people

are

most likely to think I mean Sons of the
Pioneers material. Sing them a few of the
old-timers like "Little Joe the Wrangler"

especially

lately,

compounds

the

problem.
Overworked and underpaid, cowboys

followed

trade that was dirty,
dangerous, and often lonely. There was
plenty of time in the bunkhouse or
around the campfire for singing and
swapping "big windies." The debate over
whether punchers really sang to the
cattle while night herding has raged for
years. I'm convinced they did, both to
soothe the cattle by making the human
presence known and to make the
cowboy's own time pass more quickly; it
was also a good way to stay awake. Harry
Stephens made up 'The Night Herding
Song" around 1909 while cowboy ing in
a

Another cowpuncher said
that in the days of the long trail drives
one of the first things a trail boss would
Wyoming.

ask a prospective
could sing.

puncher

was

if

he

In the old days the cowboys brought
with them music from the many regions
or cultures from which they sprang.
They sang old ballads and folksongs,

popular

songs

especially

the

�sentimental

ones
hymns, and, of
course, they played dance tunes. Fiddle,
harmonica, and banjo are the

instruments mostly mentioned

in

early

accounts; the guitar began to be popular

the West, as in the South, sometime
after 1900. Jack Thorp was a pioneer
collector of cowboy songs. A puncher
in

himself,

Thorp

decided

many real cowboy songs

to

gather

as

could, and
in 1889-90
he rode 1,500 miles on
horse-back collecting them. He carried
his banjo-mandolin with him and traded
songs wherever he went, hearing more
songs sung that weren't
cowboy
numbers than the ones that were. His
publication in 1908 of the slender

songbook Songs of

as he

the Cowboys was the

first of its kind and included several of
Thorp's original compositions, though
he gave himself no credit for them at that
time. His most famous original

is

"Little

Wrangler," which is now usually
considered a traditional piece.
Jack
Thorp was not alone in
composing songs of the range life in
those days. New songs about the cowboy

Joe the

had been composed and old ones
rewritten since at least the early 1870s.
These songs generally told of the work,
humorous adventures
tragic deaths,
(either actual or at least believable like
'The Zebra Dun" or The Horse
Wrangler," or fanciful like TyingKnots
in the
Devil's Tail"), outlaws, and
cowboy religious numbers, like The
life

Great

Roundup"

or

The Hell-Bound

Train." Many songs started out as poems
printed in newspapers, stock journals, or
slim volumes of poetry. Some punchers
would merely recite them, while others
might set them to music, often to an
older well-known tune. The names of
many of these western poets have been
lost to us, but among those we are aware
of are Charles "Badger" Clark, Henry
Herbert Knibbs, Curley Fletcher, D.J.

O'Malley,

and

Larry

New Jersey, and Richmond,
recorded extensively
They
throughout the South using portable
recording equipment, but western field
and, of course, that's
trips were fewer
where the cowboy music was.
Camden,
Indiana.

Victor Records led the way in
recording western music, first with its
recordings of Texan Carl T. Sprague
who had traveled to Camden to make
records for them in 1925. Sales of his
"When the Work's All Done This Fall"
are reported to be around 900,000
copies, proving there was a market for
cowboy music. Sprague grew up near
Houston, Texas, working on a ranch and

learning songs from his uncles and other
in the area. His recordings of
the
are
songs
straightforward and
traditional, even though his singing was
rather polished. The fiddlers he used on
some cuts sound more like violinists
than old-time players, but the real focus
is on the singing. In all, Sprague cut 32
songs on 78 rpm discs between 1925 and
1929, mostly cowboy numbers, and was

cowboys

again recorded in the early 1970s by
Folk Variety Records (later Bear Family)

of W est Germany. T wo full albums were
released from these later tapes. Among
the other western pieces that Sprague
recorded are the familiar "Bury Me Not
on the Lone Prairie," "Following the
Cow Trail" (better known as Trail to

Mexico"), "Cowboy's Love Song" ("Red
River Valley"),

The

and the less famous

Mormon Cowboy," The Last
Longhorn," and "Rounded Up in

Glory," among others.
The success of Carl Sprague was a
signal to the Victor company to record

numerous

other

cowboy

artists.

Foremost of these was Jules Verne Allen
whose recordings rank as some of the
finest ever made of old-time western
songs. Allen was born in Texas in 1883,
worked as a cowboy from 1893 to 1907
from Mexico to Montana, and also rode
in rodeos and wild west shows. Some
times billing himself as The Original
Singing Cowboy," Allen first recorded
for Victor in El Paso in April 1928, then
again the next year at Victor sessions in
and Los Angeles. His 22
issued sides were mostly cowboy or
western pieces, including great versions
of "Little Joe the Wrangler," "Home on
the Range," "Punchin' the Dough" (a
poem by Henry Herbert Knibbs that
Allen set to music), and more. In the
1930s Allen also published his book

Hollywood

Lore
Cowboy
(Naylor Co., 1933)
containing many of the numbers he had
collected and recorded over the years.
Harry McClintock is best known for
his hobo songs like "Big Rock Candy
Mountain," "Hallelujah, I'm a Bum,"

The Bum Song." His old 78s also
featured some fine western numbers that
he had picked up in his years of traveling
across the West (as well as most of the
rest of the world!). At 13 sessions for
Victor from 1928 to 1931, he waxed
excellent renditions of the outlaw
ballads "Jesse James" and "Sam Bass,"
cowboy songs The Old Chisholm
Old Paint," "Billy
Trail,"
"Goodby
Venero," The Texas Rangers," "Get
Along Little Dogies," and his own
hilarious additions to the western
and

songbag: "The Trusty
(sometimes called "The
Fireman"),
Shear

the

and

Sheep

Lariat,"
Cowboy

"When It's Time to
in Old Montana."

Chittendon.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Bob
courtesy

Fortunately, in the early years of
commercially recorded country music,
the record companies captured some
fine authentic western
music and
released it on 78 rpm discs. Considering
the amount of hillbilly music put on
record, however, cowboy music was
under-recorded. The major record
companies had studios in northern and
New York, Chicago,
eastern cities

Bovee

Clark's poem The Glory Trail" became
the song "High Chin Bob" and was
collected and printed by folklorist John
Lomax as an anonymous composition
until its true origin was discovered.
Practically the same thing happened to
Curley Fletcher's "Strawberry Roan,"
one of the most widespread range songs.

�both

unusual for
unaccompanied
commercial releases. A scattering of
other cowboys similarly waxed a few
cuts each: Paul Hamblin, Arthur Miles,
Jack Webb, J.D. Farley, Frank Wheeler,
Monroe Lamb, and Peg Moreland.
Small amounts of cowboy music were
issued by other commercial record
companies as well. Charles Nabell, who
recorded on OKeh, may have been the
first to cut a cowboy record. Edward L.
The Texas Cowboy," had
Crain,
releases on Columbia and Crown in the
thirties; Ken Maynard, the western film

star, on Columbia; Marc Williams on
Brunswick and Decca; and John White
for the American Record Company.
southern
Many of the well-known

country

singers

featured

some

in
traditional cowboy
their
songs
repertoires and recordings. Fiddlin'John
Carson recorded a convincing version of
"When the Work's All Done This Fall,"
which he entitled The Dixie Cowboy,"
on OKeh. Aulton Ray cut the same piece
using the same title. Bradley Kincaid's
numbers included The Cowboy's

Dream," "Bury Me Out on the Prairie,"
and
"Red River Valley."
And the
classically-trained Vernon Dalhart, who
tried any country song he could find, did
"I'd Like to Be in T exas for the
in

the Spring,"

Roundup

The Cowboy's Lament,"

courtesy

Bob

Bovee

and "Burv Me Not on the Lone Prairie."

Although "Mac" most likely learned
these numbers as he worked and busked
around the West, he probably usedjohn
Lomax's Cowboy Songs to fill out and
standardize

at

least

a

few of them. It's

surprising how many early cowboy
singers latched onto this book and
considered it the Bible of western music.
Among the others who recorded
cowboy pieces for V ictor were the T exas
fiddle-guitar duet the Cartwright
Brothers, whose eight sides include the
classic version of "Texas Rangers" and
an excellent cut of "The Dying Ranger."
In total, however, they recorded only 14
sides (the eight on Victor and six on
Columbia); eight of these were western
numbers, most of the rest were fiddle
tunes. Billie Maxwell, perhaps the only
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

traditional cowboy
that early period, did only six

woman
songs
sides:

to

in

record

beautiful

two-part "Billy
Arizona Girl I Left
Your
"Where
Sweetheart
Behind,"
Waits for You, Jack" ("Cowboy Jack"),
The Haunted Hunter," and the unique
song that is probably her masterpiece,
The Cowboy's Wife." My personal
favorite cowboy singer, Powder River
Jack Lee, cut just four numbers with his
wife Kitty. His exciting "Powder River,"
"Let 'Er Buck," and Tyin' Knots in the
a

Venero,"

'The

Devil's Tail," are unbeatable, and he did
a fine version of "Windy Bill," which he
called The Old Black Steer." Most
traditional of all are the two pieces by

Dick Devall, "Out on the Lone Star Cow
Trail," and Tom Sherman's Barroom,"

What we do find in these recordings
of western singers, southeastern singers
and city-billies doing traditional western
songs, is a tremendous overlap or
repetition of material. There are literally
dozens of versions of the best-known
songs like "Red River Valley," and
"When the Work's All Done This Fall."
Seeing the popularity of the style and
subjects of these songs, but lacking the
resources to keep providing fresh
material from folk sources, country and
city-billy songwriters began to crank out
"cowboy" songs. Carson Robison as
early as 1929 was penning numbers like

"Goin' Back to Texas"
and the song
rush was on. In most cases, these were
romantic compositions, in the sense that
they lauded the beauty of the range, the
freedom of cowboy life, and the virtues

of faithful

ponies and pals. There was
little of the real life tragedy and drudgery
or the keen sense of humor expressed in

such traditional cowboy songs

as

The

Gol-Darned Wheel" or "Zebra Dun."
Throughout the thirties and forties it
was mostly these pseudo-cowboy songs
that predominated
very little in the
of
old-time
western
music making it
way
onto

records

during that period.

"cowboy" singers tended to

be

The

in the

slicker and more popular style of Gene

�Southwest, Slim Critchlow
B.

George

German

were influential to

than

one

a

would

in Utah, and
South Dakota,
much greater extent
in

imagine. George
German's radio show could be heard all
over the Dakotas, Nebraska, Iowa,
Minnesota and eastern Montana and, as
a result, he sold thousands of songbooks

the mail. Typical of many
radio performers across the
country is Jack Hodges, who now lives in
Wisconsin and began his radio work in
Texas in 1933. He also played on

through

cowboy

Wisconsin

radio
stations, singing
western numbers such as
"Message from Home Sweet Home," and
"Cowboy Jack," as well as popular
cowboy songs of the thirties and other
country music. Jack never recorded
commercially, never became famous
except locally, but like many other radio
performers, he helped keep the old-time
cowboy songs in circulation.
Field recordings of cowboy music

traditional

some

preserved

fine

cowboy

performers, especially the Library of
Congress Cowboy Songs, Ballads and
Cattle Calls from Texas produced from
recordings made mostly by John Lomax
during the years 1946 and 1948 of real

old-time

These

punchers.

unaccompanied,

as

are

cowboy songs had

most commonly been sung before the
1920s, plus one exceptional cut with
fiddle, Jess Morris'
"Goodbye Old
Paint," my choice as the quintessential

cowboy recording. Western artist Harry
is featured on a double LP on
Folkways called The Cowboy: His Songs,
Ballads and Brag Talk (Folkways FH
5723) and, though not exactly a field
recording, it's an authentic collection of
songs he learned from punchers done in
their raw style. Three 1970s albums by
the Arizona Friends of Folklore (Cowboy

Jackson

Songs;

Cowboy

Songs

2;

In

an

Arizona

offer more field recordings.
Similarly, the Montana Folklife Project
Town)

produced When

the Work's All Done This
Fall in 1982 with songs and poems by

Montana cowboys.

There have been several albums in the
last 25 years by Glenn Ohrlin, a former
rodeo rider who now runs a small ranch
in Stone County, Arkansas. Glenn is the
best cowboy singer still around and has a
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

repertoire collected over the past

50-some
deadpan

years. His slow drawl
can
humor
capture

and

any
do the

audience, and his recordings
Of the LPs he's made, I believe
Wild
Buckaroo (Rounder 0158) is
only
still available. He's also on Just Something
same.

My Uncle Told Me (Rounder 0141), a
collection of bawdy songs by various
performers. Glenn's book The HellBound Train (University of Illinois Press,
1973) is one of the finest compilations
of cowboy songs ever printed
and a

lot of fun to read, too.
A couple of other westerners whose
recordings ought not to be missed are
Slim
Critchlow and Van Holyoak.
Critchlow's LP Crooked Trail to Holbrook
(Arhoolie 5007) offers a fine selection
of western songs, some not so common,

sung in a relaxed though professional
style. He was a big influence on some of
the west coast traditional folk singers
like Larry Hanks, who does a convincing
job on cowboy numbers himself. Van

Holyoak, who was killed in a highway
accident in about 1980, performed a
cappella songs and poems. He was an
Arizonan with a well-honed sense of
humor and a winning manner that comes
across on his only album Tioga Jim

(Rounder 0108).
Steve Cormier has cowboyed
Kansas and New Mexico for the last

in
10

two releases, Black Bart,
(out of print) and Zebra Dun (Make
Sense Records 01), offer mainly oldtime cowboy songs done with a fine,
rough-edged delivery. The Deseret
String Band folks from out in Utah, and
or 12 years. His

their

offshoots

the

Bunkhouse

Orchestra and the duo Ron Kane and
Skip Gorman, are marvelous performers
of western material. Kane and Gorman's
Powder River (Folk Legacy 76) and The

like

Marty

Robbins

in an

and Tex Ritter,
attempt to make cowboy
palatable to the general
without regard to the

perhaps
music more
and
public,
integrity of the music itself.
Recently, cowboy poetry and song
gatherings across the West have begun to
create new interest in country music, and
there

are

recordings
recordings
LPs

and,

many new performers and
out there. (Most of the
are self-produced tapes and
therefore, hard to obtain.)

Support for the music has also come
from organizations like the National
Council for the Traditional Arts which
sponsored a concert tour in 1983 called
"The
Old
Punchers Reunion."
(Recordings from their performances
have

been released

on

cassette

as

The

Cowboy Tour available from the National

Council for the Traditional Arts, 806
15th St., N.W., Ste. 400, Washington,
D.C.
20005) with cowboys Glenn
Ohrlin, Kenny Trowbridge, Everett
Brisendine, Brownie Ford, Duff Severe,
Karin Haleamau, Johnny Whelan, and
fiddler Junior Daugherty. Whelan, a
Hispanic cowboy from the Southwest,
does songs from the Mexican tradition;
Karin Haleamau performs paniola
two sorts
(Hawaiian cowboy) music
of cowboy songs we often forget and that
are difficult to find on recordings.
For the old time enthusiasts who want
to add some good cowboy music to their
collection, I'll suggest a few records for

starters. If you could find the now outof-print RCA Vintage Series LP
Authentic Cowboys and Their Western
Folksongs, my personal favorite, you'd
get a fine sampling of Victor's cowboy
from
1925-30. For currently
78s
available releases, look for these: Cowboy

continued on page 43

Deseret String Band (Shanachie 79041)
are two superb LPs of mostly traditional

western numbers [see OTH Vol. 1, No.
7 for review of Powder River],
Horse Sense is a duo from Colorado
that has released
three albums on
Kicking Mule (KM 329, 338, 340)
featuring lots of traditional western
music. Although not always old-time in
their approach,

especially on their Hills

(KM 340) which is recorded
with a symphony orchestra and not
intended to sound traditional, Horse
Sense is closer to the real thing than
singers like Chris Ledoux. The many
recordings of rodeo champion Ledoux
include modern country-western music
as well as traditional cowboy songs, all
using Nashville studio backup. This has
been a common treatment of the music
of Mexico

for at least the last 30 years by singers

Bovee

music alive through part of this time.
Jules Verne Allen began broadcasts of
cowboy music in the mid-twenties, and
singers like Romaine Loudermilk in the

large

Bob

Patsy

Montana, and Stuart Hamblen, to name
but a few. Until the folk revival in the
1950s, very little traditional cowboy
music was again issued commercially.
Radio helped keep authentic western

Courtesy

the Sons of the Pioneers,

Autry,

Glenn Ohrlin

in

1963

or

1964

�CHARLES

BRIDGE BUILDER

K.

WOLFE
Through

by

Patsy B. Weiler

noted author,
professor, and folklorist Charles K.
Wolfe has journeyed down many
bumpy, rut-filled back roads in search of
a

the

story.

years,

1,200 hours
with the likes of black

He has taped more than

of

interviews

harmonica player Deford Bailey;
Alcyone Bate, daughter of Dr.

of the library?"
Wolfe will tell you quickly
folks wear cotton and denim,
tie is something alien to his
But recently Wolfe got
fancier than a teenager going

his kind of
and

a

dress

neck.

slicked up
to his first

Saturday night dance (and was probably
just as nervous) for a trip that led straight
to

the Tennessee

Wolfe,

who

professor
University
and

at

in

credits

supportive

has

governor's mansion.
been

an

English

Middle Tennessee State
Murfreesboro since 1970
for
the school
"being

of

[his]

somewhat

unorthodox methods of research," was
selected along with nine other

Tennesseans to receive one of the 1988
Governor's Awards in the Arts.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

K.
Charles
Courtesy

Acuff; bluegrass great Earl Scruggs; and
Sam and Kirk McGee.
Although he has been nominated
three times for a Grammy Award, twice
for his work as a producer of the folk
music albums, Laugh Your Blues Away
1 980),
an album of Uncle Dave Macon
music and Tennessee: The Folk Heritage
1 982
and most recently in 1 988 for his
liner notes on the double LP Album, The
Wolfe has spent
Bristol
Sessions,
countless hours ferreting out priceless
nuggets of history from many obscure
old-timers whose stories would have
never been recorded without his tireless
work. This prodigious writer can be
likened to a bridge builder. His
structures are not massive monsters of
suspended steel, rather they are like
gently arching wooden foot bridges that
beckon his readers to take a relaxing
stroll across the gulf of time and become
reacquainted with their heritage.
Once, while reflecting on the mass
appeal he strives for in his books, Wolfe
said, "What good is a book if nobody
if it only stays on the shelves
reads it

Wolfe

Humphrey Bate, dubbed "the Dean of
the
Opry" by Grand Ole Opry
announcer "Judge" George D. Hay; Roy

Wolfe doing one of his many field interviews with Arch (L) and Dorris (R) Macon, sons of the
legendary Uncle Dave Macon, 1970.

Dr.

Presented every two years by the
Tennessee Arts Commission, the awards

recognize

both

individuals

and

organizations for their outstanding
contributions to the arts in Tennessee.
Wolfe received his honor for career
achievement and was presented a handblown glass vase designed by Richard
Jolley and engraved with a Tennessee
bass.
Accompanied to the private ceremony

by his wife, Mary Dean, and two teenage
daughters, Stacey and Cindy, Wolfe said

with the state's
was
happy
acknowledgement of the folk arts.
"Obviously, I was pleased that the
state recognized traditional music and
the traditional arts on the same plane as
the novels of the Pulitizer Prize award
winner Peter Taylor, and the Knoxville
Symphony," said Wolfe.
At home, sitting inside his study,
which is decorated with floor-to-ceiling
shelves that buldge and overflow with
books, tapes, memorabilia, and old
photos, Wolfe reflected about his big
he

night in his typical light-hearted manner.
"The ceremony was held outdoors on

patio area, and a storm was starting to
blow up. It was windy and you could see
the clouds starting to gather. And since I
was the last one on the list to be
a

I
was
getting a little
recognized,
nervous," the moustached Wolfe said

with a big grin.
True to form,

when the spotlight
finally shone on Wolfe, he shared it with
thousands of talented people tucked
away in the "hills and hollers" all over

Southeast.
accepting the award, he said:
"I feel like I should be accepting this
on behalf of several generations of ballad
the

In

makers, fiddlers,

banjo players, Sacred

Harp singers, bluesmen, and storytellers
people who comprise one of the

richest repositories of traditional culture
in the United
States, people whose
generosity and spirit have made my work
in documenting and celebrating them a
real joy.
"If

it

is

true that Tennessee's

most

�famous

export

is

music,

then

wellspring of that music must lie

in

the
our

folk music and folk culture. I am moved
and inspired to see this folk culture
honored alongside our more formal arts.
is
"As we all know, creativity
a
mysterious and inexorable force, and it
surfaces in many ways. Some of our
state's artists find their way to schools
and books to seek outlets for their
genius. Others make tradition their
school, and channel their individual
talent into a complex structure of
unwritten rules and informal learning. It

for
is these artists that I most revere
their quiet dedication, their rich spirit,
and their unassuming mastery."
The Missouri native, who calls himself
"the son of Ozark Mountain hillbillies,"
is

a

nationally recognized authority on

the roots of country music, and said one
of the greatest joys he has had in doing
research in this field was that it presented
the opportunity to do something never

done.

been exciting for me to
find things not found before, then figure
out how to best communicate them in a
"It's always

a
manner (which)
broad, public
audience can understand and appreciate.
It's almost like fresh-baked bread or

getting an adrenalin rush. Even today I'll
do an interview and take pages of notes
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and I can hardly
said Wolfe.

Wolfe,

who

wait to start writing,"

admittedly

has

a

penchant for gadgets and unusual items,
took a break from discussing his work to
reach and grab his good friend, "Buzz"
Buzzard, who roosts in the writer's
study, off the top of
piled on his desk.

a

stack of materials

buzzard's

Opry:

books,
The

most

unusual,

somewhat dazed facial expression set off
by a shock of green rubber hair, Wolfe
continued, saying, "I met the most
talented and wonderful people that had
just been forgotten for the most part and
never had been interviewed. And they
really wanted to tell their story and were
most grateful when you took the time to

record it."
Once described by folklorist and
music historian Kip Lornell as "an
octopus with a tentacle in a little bit of
everything," Wolfe loves to travel,

enjoys science fiction, and browses at
flea markets and junk shops.
He shares his home with two "tuxedo"
cats (dark fur with white paws and
chests), Blackie and Mack, enjoys
dabbling in photography, plays "a little"
piano, ukulele and banjo, and has an
outstanding old baseball card collection
many of them autographed.

Early

numerous articles and
including Grand Ole
years

1925-35 (1975);

Tennessee Strings: The Story of Country
Music in Tennessee (1977) and Kentucky
Music of
Folk and Country
Country:
Kentucky (1982).
In

1985, he edited and wrote a
introduction to the reprint

lengthly

While pointing out the small, black

rubber

He has written

several

edition

of God Bless

the

Narratives from Tennessee.
Wolfe has also edited

Devil:

WPA

the

auto

Ole
Opry
performers Alton Delmore and Grandpa
Jones.
The talented
folklorist has done
extensive writing for the Time-Life

biographies

of

Grand

the
Music Co., RCA-Victor,
Smithsonian Institution, and the

Franklin Mint.
Wolfe loves the down-home sounds
of traditional music and has served in
advisory capacities for the Uncle Dave
Macon Days Old-Time Music and
Dance Festival In Murfreesboro and last

National Banjo Institute and
Meltdown Concert in Lebanon,
Tennessee.
His book Tennessee Strings was made
into an original stage production during
1987 at Jim Crabtree's Cumberland
County Playhouse in Crossville, Tenn.
Wolfe, who is only in his mid-40s, has
year's
Banjo

�Wolfe
K.
Charles
courtesy
Fleischauer.

Carl

Wolfe backstage

Dr.

assisted in
public

also

numerous

documentaries

at the Grand

the production
of
radio and television
and
has
produced

Rounder Records, the
Congress, and Tennessee
Library
Folklore Society Records.
the
Tennessee
Folklore
Also
at
Society he has been the group's longtime
albums

and oversees the
continued publication of its publication,
the Bulletin.

secretary-editor

Newsweek magazine, in its Jan. 2, 1989
edition, saluted his chapter on early
radio development in country music in

book

Music

the

Country:

and

the

Musicians, published by Abbeville Press
in New York.
Currently he is on leave from his
teaching duties at MTSU, where he also
contributes to the school's summer
elderhostel program, to work full time
this spring on some writing projects
including the revision of his Grand Ole

Opry

book

accomplishment

reassessing
of

the

black

pioneer

folklorist Thomas W. Talley and a book
on southern gospel music called Rocking
on the Waves.
On July 8, 1989, Dr. Wolfe was
honored with the 1989 Heritage Award.
This award, presented by the Uncle
Dave Macon Days Festival,

is

given for

"dedication to the preservation and
advancement of old-time music and/ or
dance."

Wolfe

story

is

to

always searching for

tell

correspondence.
Charles

Middle Tennessee State University, Box
201, Murfreesboro, Tenn., 37132. pi

for

of

the

Ole Opry with Grandpa Jones

K.

and

His

Wolfe,

a

good

welcomes

address is Dr.
Dept. of English,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Patsy

Weiler
and

is

time mother

to

Tenn.,

lives

Murfreesboro,
free-lance writer and fullan active yyear old. She has
in

a

director for the Uncle
Dave Macon Days Old-Time Music &amp;
Dance Festival for several years. Weiler is a
been

the publicity

correspondent for the Nashville Banner and
has written for Banjo Newsletter, Steppin'
Time, and The Tennessee Conservationist.

�HE JOHNSON FAMILY
STRING BAND
"FAMOUS" ON SAND

MOUNTAIN

by

Joyce Cauthen

When we think of famous old-time
fiddlers, names like Eck Robertson, Gid
Tanner, Clayton McMichen, Bunt
Stephens, Fiddlin' John Carson, come to
mind. While such fiddlers are important
because their commercial recordings
influenced vast numbers of old-time
fiddlers across the country, we know

were
unrecorded
many
were well-known
and
influential in their own regions. Among
them were the Johnsons of Sand
Mountain. Johnsons provided the fiddle
that

there

fiddlers

and

who

broomstraws

for

early

dances on

Sand Mt. and in the 1920s developed
into a popular string band whose music,
and public
via radio
performances,

reached audiences across northeastern
Alabama until the early 60s.

1854, William Johnson, his wife,
children left Cobb County,
Georgia, with the intention of settling in
the Arkansas Ozarks. After spending
one night on the plateau known as Sand
Mountain, however, they decided to
travel no farther. They bought a large
section of government land near what is
now the city of Albertville, and helped
establish the community of Hustleville
In

and

five

so named because those living there
to hustle to survive. Into the new
home went a family fiddle that had been

Courtesy

Guy

and

Byron

Johnson

had

The Johnson Family String Band ca. 1920. Standing are Ras Johnson and his wife Ella; seated from the
left are Adous, Dan, and "H" Johnson. The guitar, mandolin, and two fiddles were made by Adous

Johnson.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

damaged when water swept through
their wagon as the Johnsons forded Big
Wills Creek at the base of Sand

Mountain.
During the Civil War the Johnsons
remained on Sand Mountain, where
divided loyalties turned neighbor against
neighbor, and at the close of the war they
welcomed the flood of settlers from
Tennessee, Georgia, and the Carolinas
who came to establish small farms on the
fertile land. By this time two of William
Johnson's sons had acquired a workable
fiddle and were playing at the square
dances that followed the log rollings and
house raisings taking place all over Sand

�Mountain. There the two, George M.
and William S. Johnson, would take
turns playing fiddle and beating straws,
thus providing all the melody and
rhythm the dancers needed.
For the rest of their lives the two

brothers continued to play music and to
encourage others to do so. William's
grandnephews remember him as an old
man who would walk up and down the
dirt road in front of the house playing
the fiddle and singing. Though he could
play jigs and reels, his favorite tune was

"Murillo's Lesson,"

an

anthem from The

Sacred Harp.

George Johnson delighted in playing
fiddle, beating straws and buckdancing. He continued to host great
of musicians and to
gatherings
buckdance until his death at 84 in 1936.
With his wife, Elizabeth, he raised nine
children, six of whom became the
"Famous Johnson Band." Their first son,
W.H., born in 1879, became a fiddler.
The next son, John, born in 1883,
learned to play the banjo. By 1900 a
small Johnson family band was
established and expanded as the other
sons matured. Adous joined, the band
with the first string bass in north
Alabama, which he played with a bow.
Soon afterward came Ras on the guitar
and Leo and Dan on fiddle. In 1916
when Ras married Ella Greene, who
played mandolin, piano, and sang with
the Greene family band, the Johnson
band was expanded to include her.
However, it was diminished by the death
of John in the flu epidemic of 1918. The
the

band remained without

a

banjo player

until the late 40s when they invited Burt
Stewart to play with them on the radio.

Entertaining Sand Mountain

Sand Mountain in the 1920s was dotted
with small farms, and other than a few

teachers,
bankers, and
mechanics, people worked at home. They
their
mail
and
voted in
received
communities with names like Friendship,
Red Apple, Harmony, Flat Rock, Solitude,
Jay Bird, and Double Bridges. And they

storekeepers,

news of illness,
death, rainfall,
marriages, visits, and other happenings to a
weekly newspaper, the Sand Mountain
Banner. A look at the Banner during that
period shows that though the people on
Sand Mountain were isolated from those in
the valleys and from each other during the
week as they worked on their farms, on the
sent

weekend they gathered at all-day singings
and church meetings, oratorical contests,
benefits for the needy, spelling bees from
the

Blue-Back

Speller,

"Virginia

reels"

Business

and
sponsored by
Professional Women, fiddle conventions,
high school football games and student
the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

plays, box suppers,

and picnics at Pierce
Lake (which had a special sheltered walk
from the ladies's dressing room to the
water so men could not "ogle").

The Johnson family band was likely to
be at many of these gatherings. Almost
every issue of the Banner mentioned their
appearance at a church entertainment,
picnic, land auction, dance, or fiddlers
convention. They performed at similar
events off Sand Mountain, such as the

on Lookout Mountain sponsored
the Modern Woodmen of America,
"
who advertised in the Dekalb Republican,

picnic
by

"Fried Chicken, cold drink
stands,
watermelons and the best of all, one of the
best bands in this section will furnish music
that's the Johnson band of Albertville.
you have never heard this band, you
don't know what you've missed."
The Johnson band was popular because
it had something to offer everyone. First, it
If

�was an old-time string band with a guitar,
bass, mandolin, and three fiddlers who
could play the old break-downs they had
learned from their father and uncle and the

other old-timers of Sand Mountain. W. A.
Bryan of Boaz, who often listened to them
and to the much-recorded Skillet Licker
band of Georgia, said that thejohnsons ran
"a very close second" to the Skillet Lickers
in their renditions of old-time tunes, and
that no band could beat them at "Sally
Gooden" and "Leather Breeches."
They were a gospel quartet, as well, with
four of the members stepping forward to
sing and play hymns beloved by older
people in the audience. Also Ella, joined by
Leo's wife Elma, could croon the latest
tunes that the young moderns of Sand
Mountain listened to on their phono
graphs. The varied program, tied together
by

Ras

patter,

Johnson's homey and humorous
audiences feeling thoroughly

left

entertained.
The Johnsons

traveled

to

the fiddlers

conventions that were held at every cross
roads community around Sand Mountain
Nixon's Chapel, Sardis, High Point,
Hartselle, Crossville, Geraldine, Boaz, the
D.A.R. School in Grant, and many others.
Bryon and Guy Johnson, sons of Ras and
Adous, recall that the Johnson band quite
often carried away the $10 first prize for
best band while Leo Johnson would bring
home a prize of seven dollars or a gold
watch for being judged best fiddler. At
times the band performed at the contests
rather than compete in them. For instance,
at a fiddlers convention held in 1924 at the
City School Building in Albertville, the
that 'The Famous
Banner announced
JOHNSON BAND will have charge of the

followed by single
exercises,
fiddling, banjo, bands, etc."
The band's most consistent and bestpaying jobs came from auction companies:
the J. W. Oliver Auction Company of
opening

the J. P.
Collinsville,
Company of Albertville,

Wheeler

Auction

McMinnville,

Auction
King
and the Clark-

Company

Tennessee.

settlers

of

From

from
the

these
area,
tracts of land,

the

original
companies bought large
subdivided them into lots, and auctioned
them off to homebuilders. Every week fullpage advertisements appeared in area news
papers inviting everyone, "especially the
ladies," to auctions which offered free
barbecue, prizes, twin auctioneers, fiddle
contests, and band concerts, most often by
"FAMOUS
the
JOHNSON STRING
BAND," though occasionally the ClarkWheeler Company would hire Uncle Dave
Macon and Sam McGee. After one auction
the Gadsden Evening Star wrote, 'The
famous Johnson string band of Albertville
furnished music and it attracted much
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

attention for

it is

rated

as a

really first class

downs they played so well, they played

bass in the back seat with its neck sticking
out the front right window and the rest of
the Johnson band and their instruments
arranged uncomfortably around it. In this
manner they journeyed to Auburn to play

tunes:
"Murillo's
and popular
hymns
Lesson," with "What a Friend We Have in
Jesus" as an introduction, "Holy Manna,"
"Daisies Won't Tell," "Silver Moon," and
"Everbody Works but Father." The latter
tune was a comical number that had been
used on the minstrel stage and had been
published as sheet music around the turn
of the century. In it Ras, joined by Leo on

OKeh.

the chorus, complained that "Everybody
works 'round our house, but our old

musical organization."

1926 thejohnsons began to travel the
hilly, unpaved roads and unbridged rivers
of North Alabama in their new Ford, the
In

on the radio and to Atlanta to record for

The Johnsons on the Air
When Alabama's first full-power radio
station began broadcasting from Auburn
late in 1925, its management urged all
Alabama communities to send performers
to represent them on the air. It is not
surprising that the merchants of Marshall
County selected the Johnsons. The Sand
Mountain Banner announced that business
men of Guntersville, Albertville, and Boaz
had contributed from 25 cents to two
dollars apiece to pay the expenses on the
Johnsons' trip to Auburn and noted that
only one out of the 59 citizens approached
had refused to contribute.
Thus the Johnsons drove two hundred
miles to perform on WAPI. Few on Sand

Mountain owned radio sets, and Guy and
Byron Johnson recalled being driven 5Vz
miles through a heavy storm to the home
of Lon Brown. They joined a roomful of
neighbors who had come to hear the
broadcast. Apparently Mr. Brown had the
type of "radi-ow" described in a Freed-

Eisemann

advertisement

in

the

Banner:

"Squeals like a cat, fights like the neighbors
in Hogan's Alley, and demands a burglar's
kit and 'overtime' to keep it in order."
After tinkering with the large horn speaker,
he gave up and plugged in earphones,
meaning that everyone had to take turns
listening. Lucky was the person wearing the
headset when the first string band to play
on the only radio station in Alabama
struck up "Dixie."
In

Almost Recording Artists
1928 the Johnsons had

opportunity
auditioning

an

their fame. After
in Gadsden, they were asked to
to expand

make records for OKeh. They signed a
three-year contract under the direction of
Polk Brockman, an important figure in the
recording of country music. If was he, an
Atlanta record dealer, who had convinced
Ralph Peer of OKeh to first record Fiddlin'
John Carson in 1923. The success of that
experiment had led to the recording of the
Skillet Lickers and many other fiddle
bands of the twenties and thirties.
on August 1, 1928, the
In Atlanta,
Johnsons recorded at least five tunes and
possibly more. According to information
on file at the Country Music Foundation,
instead of recording the old-time break

man,"

to

the

accompaniment

of

three

fiddlers (two doing rhythmic bowing
behind one lead fiddle), a guitar, and

Adous' bowed bass playing a rhythmic
counter-melodv.
with
left Atlanta
The
Johnsons
assurances that "Everybody Works but
Father" would be released and that arrange
ments would be made for the band to play
WSM in Nashville, the "Grand Old
Opry" station. However, for some reason
that the Johnsons never understood, the
records were not released. According to
on

Bryon and Guy Johnson, the family was
not interested in pursuing the matter. On
the way home from Atlanta, while the

band

discussed

members

future

engagements, Dan had firmly stated that he
"wasn't fixing to go nowhere." Forty-seven
years later, in an article in the MarshallDekalb

Monitor

News

Leader,

Adous

explained the decision: "I guess what kept
us from becoming famous except on Sand
Mountain was the fact that we stayed in the
Albertville area. Daddy didn't want us to
leave home, and we really didn't want to
leave either. Our family has always been
very close, and keeping our family ties was
more important than money or fame."

Good Times At Home

Those who knew
know that Adous

the Johnsons well
not simply
was
of
success in
the
band's
lack
rationalizing
recording. E. C. Littlejohn recalled that the

Johnsons were "close-knit." Their home in
Hustleville was in a "sockfoot": "You go
down in there and you'd go down to the
end and turn around to get out. All that
lived down in there were the Johnsons.
They didn't have to mix with other people
to have fun; they just enjoyed their family."
Byron and Guy Johnson recalled that one

brother seldom went anywhere without
the other four. When they went to the
bank each spring to borrow money for

seed, all five would sign the loan in hand
writing so similar that it seemed that one
had signed for all.
And though they could have entertained
welcomed
themselves
they
happily,
company. Ras's daughter-in-law, Ruth

Johnson, remembered that the yard "was
covered every Saturday and Sunday
just
gangs of people from town." In addition to

�the Johnsons
were
musicians,
being
gamesmen. They enjoyed rook, croquet,
checkers, marbles, and horseshoes, and
they worked to develop their skills in them.
According to Byron Johnson, "The only

thing they were serious about was killing
time." To the Johnsons, raising a crop was

second a rv
Music was at the center of activities at
the Johnson gatherings. George Johnson
was

in

the

habit

of inviting

any

good

country musicians he met to stay and live
with the Johnsons, and many took him up
on his offer. During the twenties and
thirties, Clayton McMichen, Gid Tanner,
Fate Norris, Lowe Stokes, Earl Johnson
(no kin), and Arthur Smith, among others,
came to stay in Hustleville and play under
the big trees beside the Johnson family

home.
Sometimes the professional musicians
would stay the whole week between
performances and during these visits, little
farmwork was done. Instead, there was
almost continuous music with breaks for
games and food, vast quantities of it.
Visitors may have found one fault with the
hospitality: the Johnsons were tee-totallers
who did not allow their guests to drink on
the premises. Yet fiddlers came, drawn by
the good humor, food, and music at the

Johnson home.

Saturday Nights with the Johnsons
The Johnson Band continued to

perform until 1962. During the 1950s, the
music
when
of old-time
dark
days
television and rock and roll were taking
their toll on the fiddler's popularity, the
folks on Sand Mountain still enjoyed the
Johnsons' show on radio station WABUFM, followed by a dance at the National
Guard Armory.

The "Sand Mountain Jamboree" would
of 'Turkey in the
a rendering
Straw" by the Johnson brothers joined by
Burt Stewart playing clawhammer-style
banjo. The next number would perhaps be
modern tune like "Drifting and
a more
Dreaming," sung by Ella, Elma, and Elma's
daughter, Imogene. Announcer Jesse Culp
would then deliver some earnest words of
shopping advice from sponsors like J. B.
Roberts &amp; Sons Clothing Store in
Albertville (a supplier of Star Brand

rushed to the hospital, Ras explained the
problem to the listeners. By the time Dan
was delivered to the hospital, the parking
lot was filled with anxious friends and fans
of the Johnsons. Dan never recovered and
died two years later. With this the band
attempted to retire, but were dissuaded by

open with

numbers of requests that they
continue the radio program.
Adous and Ras Johnson, Fiddle
large

Makers

Even after the Johnsons grew too old to
keep up their active performance schedule,
some of them continued their involvement
in another form of music-making. Adous
had begun making fiddles in 1925. He first
repaired the old family fiddle, which had
been damaged in the Johnsons' move to
Alabama in 1854. Before gluing it together,
he
studied the instrument's
internal
construction with the idea of making
another. A maple tree behind the Johnson
home became his first hand-made fiddle,
shaped by a pocket knife and thinned with
a
curved pane of window glass. Uncle
William strung it up before the first coat of
varnish was applied and it is almost certain
that he played "Murillo's Lesson" on it.
Over the years Adous acquired more

Shoes), Hunter's Community Store, or the
Truck &amp; Tractor
Sand Mountain
Company, while the band softly played an
perhaps "Anytime
appropriate tune
You're Feeling Lonely" or "Chicken Reel."
Each program would be a race with the
clock, the band trying to honor all requests
mailed in during the week, before rushing
off to play for a hall full of dancers at the
Armory. There would be hoedown tunes
like "Flop-Eared
Mule," "Eighth of
January," "Paddy on the Turnpike," "Black

Mountain

Rag," "Sally Gooden,"
"Flatwoods," and "John's Got a Wooden
Leg," to which the guests in the studio
added whoops, hand-clapping, and footstomping. There would be sacred tunes
such as "Shall We Gather at the River,"
"Hide Me, Rock of Ages," and "Where the

"Murillo's

precise measuring and cutting tools and
began to order fine German woods after he
had depleted the maple tree population on
the Johnson land. Later he took one of his
fiddles to Professor T. M. Thomason, a
in Birmingham,
who
violin instructor
of
a
a
him
with
blueprint
provided
Stradivarius violin and some trade secrets
about the internal workings of violins. He
got other pointers from fiddlers. Once
Clayton McMichen was asked to try out a
fiddle that Adous was completing. After

As

playing

Soul Never Dies," and there were swing
tunes like "Coconut Grove" and 'In the

Mood."
Occasionally

a

number would be cut

short with a laugh because "H," 80 years
old and hard of hearing, was playing out of
tune. In 1950 a more serious interruption
occurred. Near the end of the broadcast,
Dan,

having just finished playing Uncle

William's

favorite

Lesson," suffered

a

tune,
stroke.

he

was

it

for

a

moment,

McMichen

pocket knife and, to the
opened
of those present, began
astonishment
carving on the neck. He stopped only when
the fiddle suited him, then told the maker,
"Y ou need to cut it out more here," advice
Adous followed on future
that
his

courtesy

Guy

and

Byron

Johnson

instruments.
As Adous

Earl Johnson holding fiddle made for him by Adous Johnson (plaid shirt). Behind them stand Ras,
"H," and Leo Johnson, ca. 1950.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

received requests for more
fiddles than he could make, he pressed his
brother Ras into service and the two men
continued to make the instruments until
Adous was 90 years old and had completed
200 fiddles. Some of them had been given
to well-known fiddlers like Earl Johnson;
others were purchased by lovers of oldtime fiddling who never learned to play
them. Adous, who kept careful records of
the outcome of his checker games, kept no
of his
record of the purchasers

instruments.
In 1979, the Alabama state legislature
honored the two brothers with House
Resolution 21, which commended them
for offering "the best of Alabama's native

�in
designing and
manufacturing fine-quality violins." On
the occasion, Ras told a reporter, "We had

craftsmanship

the dream, that maybe by making these
fiddles that our name would live after we
were dead and gone and people would
remember the Johnson fiddle." Adous'
son, Guy, who has recently returned to
Albertville, continues to make violins.
Though the Johnson band is now silent,
for its music and
it is still remembered
hand-made fiddles. Its long tenure as Sand
Mountain's leading band is due in large
part to the type of people who live there.
An article in the Birmingham Post Herald
noted the "unshakeable sense of place," the
"healthy respect for tradition," and the
"powerful community identity" among the
residents of Sand Mountain. The Johnson
family, who had provided music for social
gatherings since the settlement of Sand

Guy
courtesy

Up a Gum Stump: Commercial,
Home, and Field Recordings of Alabama
Fiddlers, an album and illustrated booklet

Johnson

Mountain, was vital in developing that
sense of community.
Music by the Johnson family was
captured on home disc recordings in 1949.
Two of the tunes, "Katy Hill" and "Bile
them Cabbage Down," are featured on
Possum

available from most distributors of oldtime music [see review, OTH Vol. 1 No.
Tapes of the "Saturday Night
5].

copy of "Everybody
Jamboree"
Works but Father" are archived in the
media center of the Country Music Hall
of Fame, Nashville, TN.
and

a

This article was largely excerpted from
With Fiddle and Well-Rosined Bow:

Old-Time Fiddling
published
Press.

In

by

the

the book,

in

Alabama, recently
of Alabama

University

author Joyce Cauthen

history of fiddling in Alabama
from the early 18 oos through World War II,
traces

the

detail the fiddler's roles in their
describing
communities and the social gatherings to
which they were vital. Based on extensive
interviews and newspaper reports from
in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Johnson family band as they appeared in the 1950s. Back row: Leo and W. H. Johnson, fiddles;
Burt Stewart, banjo; Ras Johnson, guitar; and Adous Johnson, bass. On the front row are Ella Johnson,
Elma Johnson, and Imogene Pledger, daughter of Leo and Elma Johnson.

earlier days, the book focuses on local
fiddlers who were "stars" only to their own
families and communities, and also contains
biographies of better-known (or "brag"
fiddlers) such as Charlie Stripling, Y. Z.
Hamilton, Joe Lee, D. Dix Hollis, Fiddlin'
"

"

Monkey Brown, and the
Johnson Family Band.
Many vintage photos of fiddlers and
string bands are featured in the book, as
Tom Freeman,

well.
The author has also produced an album
of old-time fiddling in Alabama (reviewed
in OTH Vol. i, No. 4); which includes two
home recordings of the Johnson Family

Band. Possum Up

Commercial,

and

Alabama Fiddlers.

a

Gum Stump: Home,

Field

Recordings

of

�JAM SESSION

Issues in Old-Time Music

ETIQUETTE:
Observations
and Confessions

by

Craig Johnson

The Issues In Old-Time Music column
was established as a forum for the expression
of ideas and points of view, some of which
Points
be
controversial.
of view
may
expressed in this column are not necessarily
those of the Old-Time Herald.

few years ago at a music camp,
session
of jam
discussions
of
the
course
were
held
during
etiquette
A

several
a

week-long

workshop

in

string-band

and that
offensive and overly picky
these people were invariably the ones
who would have benefited most from
attention to the topics under discussion.
It's

not

pleasant

might be a
and those

describe

admit that you
festival pariah,
to
are too strong
to

session jinx,
terms

anyone.

But

a

we

have all, I
of blunders,

made our share
and if a recitation of them can help
others to avoid the pitfalls in which we
have from time to time landed, then
perhaps we should grit our teeth, grab
our mirrors, and get it over with.
imagine,

Imagine yourself in Glenville, West
Virginia, a dozen or so years ago. On a
relatively quiet corner, away from the
hordes who are gathered beneath the big
tree behind the bank, stands an old man
with a fiddle. A handful of people are
listening intently to him, and eventually
a guy with a banjo strikes a few tentative
notes before he joins in. It's good music,
a
weird, archaic fiddle melody under
pinned by restrained but solid banjo
work. Everyone is enjoying it, including

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Linda

Higginbotham

playing. One of the participants in the
workshop told me about them. He felt
they were invaluable, for although he
was not entirely new to session playing
there were many aspects of playing in a
group that he had never considered. He
did indicate, however, that some of the
people in the group did not enjoy these
discussions, that they considered them
a young man with a shiny new fiddle case
who has just arrived.
The old man finishes his tune, and is in
the process of choosing another one,
when the kid with the fiddle jumps in.
"Do you know 'Soldier's Joy'?" he
asks, and without waiting for an answer
launches into his own rendition of it. His

as
his
commendable
questionable. Nonetheless,
as is often the way with people, the old
man politely tries to play along, even
though he is cross-tuned and has never,
his
in
all
attempted
many
years,

energy

is

intonation

"Soldier's

as

is

Joy"

in

the

Eventually, mercifully,

it is

of

"A."

key
over. The old

man turns back to the banjo player (who
has been trying to re-tune to "D" all the
while) and they have just about settled
on another tune when the kid wades into
reckless
a
at
the Waterfall"
"Over

tempo. He's really tearing it up. It's
exciting, after all, to play music with a
real old-time fiddler. But when he looks

up the old man

is

walking away, and the

has
interested group of onlookers
he
is
left
and
vanished,
only
completely
with a vague and disquieting feeling that
he must have done something wrong,

but what was it?
What indeed?

you've played

If

sessions

in

can

probably
identify several breaches of good session
many

jam

you

by this unfortunate
man.
Perhaps you yourself have
young
been guilty of them or other session
transgressions, although none of us like

etiquette committed

admitting it.
This session-wrecking kid was me.
The episode went a long way toward
ruining my weekend at Glenville.
alternately blamed myself and others for
the cold reception I'd received, and for a

I

long time afterward

jam sessions.

I

was very leery of

Playing in sessions is perhaps the most
important thing a novice musician can
do. Sessions are part of the heart and

�soul of old-time music, an opportunity
with other players a thing of
beauty, a chance to learn firsthand the
like dynamics,
of words
meanings
intonation, rhythm, and spirit.
to create

However, the apparent spontaneity and
of a good session are
camaraderie
deceptive. Jam sessions have rules, be
they unwritten, and knowing what they
will make it more pleasant for every
one, veterans and novices alike.
are

Some
obvious.

session

are

problems

fairly

perennial session
Tuning
bugbear. The other night I played tunes
with another fiddler, two banjo players,
and two guitarists. At any given moment
thirty strings could have been vibrating
in that given
room, but thirty more
strings could not cover up the sound of
that was
fifth
one
banjo
string
tuned
instru
flat.
Badly
considerably
ments can turn a music session into a
dissonant, rhythmic nightmare. Get a
note from someone in the session before
you join it, slip off somewhere, and try
to tune up to it. If you haven't been
is

for

playing

a

long

very

you

can

ask

someone for help with tuning. Most
people would rather spend a few minutes

helping you tune than listen to you play
out of tune for the next hour.

Volume

another

is

important

consideration. Old-time music tends
toward an orchestral sound, especially in
sessions. The instruments work together
to create a powerful, rolling sound that
showcases no single instrument or
musician. Your guitar runs may be rivals
of Riley Puckett's, your fiddling may

shake up Ed Haley, but you're not much
of a session player if you insist on
drowning out everyone around you. If
it's only

yourself you want to hear you
as

well stay home.

might just
It's always important to listen to what
you're trying to play, not only so you'll
play in tune, and make fewer mistakes,
but so you'll know what you're aiming
for. Are you keeping time with the rest
of the group? Is what you're playing in
keeping with the spirit of the session, or
does it tend to throw things off and
diminish the quality of the music?
The sensitive session player, whether a
beginner or a veteran of many festivals,
attends to these basics. If you play in
tune, keep the beat, and blend in with
other players you are more likely to be

welcome

in

You

will

a

session.

nevertheless,

not,

be

sessions. Jam sessions are,
on the surface, democratic events, but in
welcome
many

in all

cases

this

is

mere

appearance.

Sessions usually have leaders, and not all
sessions are really open to all players.

The reasons why this

is

so usually

go

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

beyond simple snobbish behavior.
If you walk around the fields at the
Brandywine or Mt. Airy fiddlers
conventions, or through the stables at
Galax, you'll see dozens of jam sessions.
Outwardly they will be quite similar, just
groups of people playing music, but

these

seemingly

homo-geneous

gatherings can be very different. In one
stall a fiddler and a banjo player are
playing tunes from the Round Peak area
of North Carolina, spare and furious
tunes that derive their energy from the
between
the
two
interplay
crisp
instruments. Down in the field a huge
jam session has formed, literally dozens
of musicians with instruments of every
kind, and the sound it produces is as
powerful as a freight train. Across the
way half a dozen people are calling out
titles of 78 RPM records and playing the
selections with a fidelity to the source
recordings that falls short only in its lack
of scratches.
The mega-session is clearly open to all.
more
The other two are probably
private, at least in terms of participation.
If you want to play in them, or in any
other session, the best way to ascertain
whether you're welcome or not is to
listen, show interest, and wait for an
invitation. For better or for worse, most
people will not refuse you if you invite
yourself, but they may not be happy
about it, and you'll know.
Last year at Mt. Airy two friends sat
down together on Saturday morning to
play a handful of their favorite tunes,
squirrelly, crooked tunes they'd worked
up together years before when they had
lived in the same town. They'd hardly
begun when a loud voice exclaimed
"Here's a jam," and three guitar players
thin air and
as
if from
appeared
immediately began to wail away with
little regard for minor details like tuning,
tempo, or style. The two friends felt a
strong upwelling wave of homicide in
their hearts, but being the sort of people
who never act on such impulses they

pressed on, hoping against hope that the
barbarians would get bored, get the
message, and get lost. They got louder,
and at last the friends gave up, resolving
to try again later, or perhaps next year.
The cold shoulder one occasionally
receives usually doesn't have any real
malice behind it. The people who come
to festivals have often traveled great
distances for an opportunity to visit and
play music with friends they may see but
once or twice a year. They bring with
them memories of good sessions past as
well as hopes for a hot set of tunes this
time around, and if, at times, they
jealously guard their music, one should
remember that we have all done the same
thing.

It's always safest to play in sessions
where people are playing the tunes you
know at a level of skill roughly equal to
yourown. For beginners trying to break
into session playing this is an excellent
rule by which to be guided, but as you
progress you'll want more challenges.
There is no reason why you shouldn't
play in sessions with more advanced
players, but you should not station
yourself at the center of things. Get off
toward the edge of the group, play
quietly, listen to unfamiliar tunes before
attempting them, and you'll probably
find yourself more welcomed to the
session than better players who muscle
into the middle without really taking the
time to get the feel of things. You'll also
learn a lot more.
If you are welcomed to a session, you
should try to remain welcome. Nothing

helps so much as open eyes and ears, and
an ego kept in low gear. I know fiddlers,
competent, talented fiddlers, who are

nevertheless

seldom

welcomed

to

and
who don't seem to
sessions,
understand why. There's nothing wrong
with their musicianship, but it seems as if
they pay no attention to the dynamics of
sessions, and their arrival is usually
regarded as a wrench thrown into the
works
of an otherwise
well-tuned

�machine.
Some helpful hints: pay attention to
what key people are playing in. If asked to
pick a tune, choose one in the key the
banjos are tuned for. If it seems like things
are ripe for a change, give people time to
retune, then stick with that new key for a

while. If you constantly switch keys and
wade right into the tunes, you'll leave
players, many of whom will leave after
two or three
repetitions of this

treatment.
Like everyone else

in

the world, you

may enjoy being at center stage, but be
willing to share the stage with others.
Don't attempt to call all the tunes, or

with a partner heavily
orchestrated numbers that leave every

perform

one else out in the cold waiting for a
chance to play something straight
forward. This is the kiss of death to
many sessions.

Show

consideration

for

the

people

who are playing in a session with you.
We all know tunes that aren't widely
played, and we've all put considerable
work and love into those tunes. They
should be played in sessions, but
perhaps not one right after another. A
mix of standards along with the crooked
and the obscure will make for a more

members of the
loose as well as
group,
experience the challenges and pleasures

satisfying session for
chance

a

all

to cut

of new tunes.

thought

Equal

tempo.

T

should

be

given

to

ailor the speed of tunes to the

level

experience

of

most

group

qualities of the
tune
being played. A hot tune
particular
is not always a fast one; bulldozers move
slowly but not much stops them and
they generally get where they're going.
Certain instruments have become
subjects of controversy around sessions.
Old-time music has been played on a
wide variety of instruments throughout
a long and colorful life, stretching from
distant recollections of the early nine
teenth century on up to the present time;
but nowadays the fiddle, banjo, and

members,

and

to

the

guitar have become the core instruments
of old-time bands. The hammered and

mountain

dulcimers,

pennywhistles,

bones, spoons, washtub
autoharps,
basses, and even the conventional standviewed by some
be
bass may
up

musicians as particularly undesirable in
certain sessions. Such an attitude is
unfair to those musicians who have
worked long and hard on these instru
ments,

but

it

is

an

attitude

that

is

undoubtedly here to stay.
Some years ago, at a time and place
that shall remain unidentified, a group of
musicians were playing some bluesy
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of controversial
Players
instruments would do well to wait for an
invitation to play (as should players of
any instrument), and those who object
:o such instruments should do so openly
ind as uncritically as possible.
The ubiquitous cassette tape recorder
deserves mention in any discussion of
good session etiquette. Taping is a
wonderful way to preserve inspiring per
formances and unfamiliar tunes, but it
can also be highly intrusive. While not
so critical an issue in jam sessions as at
concerts and workshops, the continuous

fiddle tunes a la Narmour
Smith, the Nations Brothers, and
John Hatcher. From out of the darkness
with a hammered
a
guy
appeared

issue.

fiddles.

so.

clicking of tape recorders, as well as
repeated requests for tune names, are
definitely annoying. Quite apart from
these distractions, it is only common
courtesy to ask other players whether
they mind being taped or, as is becoming

There was a long, apprehensive pause
among the session players. One of them

Taping should be done

Mississippi
and

dulcimer. He stood at the edge of the
enchanted by the
group, obviously
music and eager to join in, something
every player there hoped would never
Not a very open-minded
happen.
attitude, perhaps, certainly not
The
but understandable.
charitable,
hammered dulcimer just didn't seem the
sort of instrument that would
the
slippery, wailing
complement
"This

is

great,"

said

the

dulcimer

player, "I'll go tune up," and quickly
tuning one string he retreated out of
earshot to adjust the other two dozen or

looked up, and with an evil and selfsatisfied smile whispered, "Everyone
tune down half a step," something they
accomplished in short order, and the
poor dulcimer player found himself still
out of tune upon his return.
It's a good story, if not

the

most

forthright way to handle the situation. I
think that honesty among all concerned
would go a long way toward defusing this

increasingly
as

possible. At

common,
a

videotaped.

unobtrusively
party last year someone
as

asked me if I minded being taped. I
didn't mind, and said so, but I certainly
did mind when the guy planted himself
between me and the folks I was playing
with, armed to the teeth with stereo
microphones, surveying my every move
with an eagerness more common to
carrion fowl than musicians.

continued on page 29

�Musical Trip Through
SOUTHERN ONTARIO
A

Lorne Greenwood

by

"we've

Comedy
no old-time or even any kind of country.
But I happened to have read in the local
press some months ago that Cathy Fink
was to appear on a Sunday afternoon and
entertain for just $10.00 admission.
(The usual minimum evening admission

in

way

Toronto?

And what about Toronto's big folk
festival, Mariposa, with its commitment
to "the

preservation

and

promotion of

traditional and contemporary folk arts?"
After its heyday on Toronto Islands in
the 1970s did it not come to the verge of
collapsing?

Mariposa has so far survived with the
help of government arts agencies and
corporate donors, and it continues to

hold its annual festival each June at the
Molson Brewery Park in Barrie, just an
hour's drive north of Toronto.
folk music
Although contemporary
seems to predominate, the traditional

maintained a foothold.
Artistic director,. Richard Flohil will
direct the Mariposa festival for 1989
29th year. In the December-January,
1989 edition of Mariposa Notes, Richard
is quoted as saying: "My parameters of
has at least

what music is 'folk' are wider than those
of the traditionalists. My involvement in
at a variety of
other kinds of music

and
eclectic,
my own
idiosyncratic musical tastes have given

levels
me

a

breadth of musical awareness that's

he goes on to
will
traditional
be
say:
performers. There will be a blues tent
again; people will get to dance a whole
lot; the Folk Play area will be there again;
in fact I think it's a marvellous part of the
festival." Not exactly a haven for the
traditionalists, but apparently not yet a

quite rare." Nevertheless,
"Yes,

there

closed door, either.
I was
surprised recently, while riding
the Toronto subway, to note amongst
the ad displays that the home of the
Toronto Symphony, Roy Thomson
Hall, now has it all. "Pop Music," it read,
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Symphony
Family Entertainment." But
it

all

In the upstairs
east annex on the
Chrysler stage you could have heard oldtime fiddlers Tom McQueston and Sam

McVanel (ages 85 and 80 respectively)

playing the music they normally play for
the square dances sponsored by the

Callers

Canadian

Olde

Association.

No other music seems to

Tyme

to most events is $22.50, which gets you
into the second level balcony.) Perhaps

Cathy

under

in

got

Family

Entertainment for which she would well
qualify,

but we all know she performs

old-time music as well. Good family
entertainment it would have been, and
I'm sorry I missed it.
Did I say no haven? Had you attended
the world's largest indoor agricultural
fair and equestrian event, the 50th Royal
Agricultural Winter Fair and Horse

as the Royal) at
Toronto's Exhibition Place November 9
20, you might have observed nothing
else but old-time music and dance on the
five entertainment stages. Whether your

Greenwood

And were there not more empty than
seats at prestigious Massey
Hall when Hank Snow performed there
in the
1960s, after I had taken up
residence just north of the city? And was
this not just about the last attempt to
promote old-time country music in a big

occupied

got

Lome

for old-time music and
or so I
area-Toronto
dance,
one
big megalopolis of
thought. Just
three million people, and as many cars it
seemed, struggling to get from some
where to somewhere else.

haven

this

Show (known simply

interest had been animals, food, or
flowers, you would have come upon at
least one of these stages scattered across
the Royal's 27 acres of the most densely
populated indoor farmyard in the world.
For example, had you been sauntering
in the stable between the rows of prize
Charolais and Limousin cattle, you
could have heard the jigs and reels of
Tom Anderson and his Lime Ridge
Fiddlers playing from the Cow Palace
stage. This was meant to entertain the
cattlemen as well as the visitors. The

cattlemen were so impressed that they

these fine fiddlers to play for
their wind-up shindig. The fragrance in
invited

the stable was as one would expect in
spite of the green carpeting along the
main aisles but, as always, healthy and

lasting.

While wandering through the flower

garden

area

Canada's

fiddlers

you

North

could

American

Graham

and

have

heard

champion

Eleanour

playing the Bob Wills
"Faded Love" and "Maiden's
Prayer" from the Flower stage. You
could also have heard the Townsends'
sensational twin-fiddle version of Ervin

Townsend
favorites

Rouse's "Orange Blossom Special."

courtesy

No

Tom McQueston and Sam McVanel playing for
the Buttonville dance.

have

dance

the

that

lilt

musicians produce, and

it is

these

fine

seldom that

anyone over the age of 60 can beat them
But that, and the
in a fiddle contest.
Heritage Award that Tom recently

received for his contribution to old-time

another story.
upstairs west annex on the
Foodland stage, you could have seen
of old-time square
demonstrations
dancing, or heard Steve Fuller and his
string band Back Up and Push playing a
variety of traditional music in somewhat
the style of Norman and Nancy Blake.
Also on the Foodland stage were
fiddling,
In

is

the

competitions

in

old-time

square

dancing, calling, and fiddling.
And to give Royal significance to this
Royal event, and hopefully to our oldtime music and dance, Princess Anne,

the avid horsewoman, was in attendance
on her special day. Also in attendance
was the Queen's Canadian representative,
Jeanne Sauve, and the Queen's Ontario

representative, Lincoln Alexander. And
yes, they couldn't help but observe the
good old-time entertainment. And yes, the
Princess did return my handwave (and
And I personally
else's).
everybody

�held

Lincoln Alexander purposely
linger at the Foodland stage during his
guided tour, just to hear Tom and Sam
play their hoedown medley of "Victory
Hornpipe/Mist on the Mountain." Since
observed

been

heard

single location,
depending on the schedule. You can catch
this Royal event any November on about
the same dates. Further information can
the Royal Agricultural
be had from
at

a

Winter Fair,. Exhibition Place, Toronto,
Ontario, M6K 3C3.

Old-time fiddlers in this area will tell
you that they played for old-time dances in
community halls all over Toronto into the
1950s
dances

when

it

all

Toronto

in

disappeared.
are

now

Such
almost

confined to a few recreation centers,
attended mostly by older people where the
music is recorded and provided by a live
caller. These are usually sponsored by the
local boards of education and the parks
and recreation departments. In July and
August square dancing takes place in the

parks to live music. As late as last year you
could have danced in Kew Gardens to the
music of Eleanour Townsend, Bobby
Brown (of the Cape Breton Symphony
fiddle band), and legendary caller-fiddlercomposer Jack Hayes. Jack is currently
recovering from a slight stroke, but his
fighting spirit still has him calling and

fiddline.
Perhaps out of concern for what was
happening in Toronto, the Canadian
Callers
Olde
Square Dance
Tyme
Association was formed in 1954 to
promote old-time squre dancing. It
sponsors a dance on the third Saturday
of every month at the old Womens
from
Institute Hall in Buttonville

September to May,

as

well as large spring
oronto in May

and fall dances in Metro T

and

November.

Fiddlers

Tom

and Sam McVanel provide
the music, which is so popular that some
will come just for the music. The dance

McQueston

program is usually three square dances
(one set), then two other dances such as
the Jersey, French Minuet, the Roberts,
Gay Gordons, Military Schottishe, Navy
Two-step, and the usual polkas, waltzes,
etc., then back to three square dances
again, and so on.

Old-time square dancers also have a
barrel of fun on the second Friday of
every month from September through
May at the Vellore Community Hall
the
towns of
situated between

Woodbridge
Road.

and Maple on the Weston
was built in the mid

The hall

1800s and

is

supported by huge hand-

hewn timbers which are just above your
head when you are down in the basement

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

summer

months.

The

Anderson as president, meets the second
month in the
of every
Wednesday
Nobleton arena. In attendance each month

the various performers appeared on all of
the stages in turn, any one of them could

have

the

during

Nobleton and District Old-Time
Fiddlers Association, with Tom

enjoying the refreshment break (for
which the ladies provide). The live music
is provided by two sets of twin fiddlers,
who spell each other off about twice
Johnny Cole
during the evening
pairing off with Tommy Anderson, and
Sam McVanel pairing off with Tom
As
with Buttonville,
McQueston.
several callers take their turn at the mike.
Norm Gibson, is the driving force behind
this one. Norm has been collecting fiddle
tunes since the 1930s and seems to have
he has been
them all. Consequently,
frequently consulted by fiddlers of all
ranks, including Graham Townsend and
the late Don Messer, to ferret out a lost or
which he does without
rare tune
thought of remuneration. "My reward
comes

from hearing them played again,"

Norm says. For his contribution to the
world of fiddle music Norm was recently
honored with the Heritage Award, a sort of
Fiddlers Hall of Fame.
The town of Dundalk, Ontario, is the
home of traditional step-dance and square
dance competitions where, on the last
weekend of June each year, contestants of
all levels vie for the Canadian champion
ships in the various classes. Winners are
usually invited to appear on the Tommy
Hunter national television show. This
event is sponsored by the Dundalk Service
Club, and is now in its 33rd year.

Appalachian style clogging has found its
north to add to the long-existing
Ottawa Valley style step-dancing of the
clog, jig, and reel. Sandy Maclntyre of the
Canadian Country Cloggers will teach
way

either style.

In this

area we also have the

River Road Cloggers led by Joan Smith and
the Ontario Rhythm Cloggers led by Sylvia
Hunka. The latter was the first group to
come to my attention when appearing at
the same event on Canada Day several
years ago.

Old-time fiddle music is kept very much
in southern Ontario by the fiddle
associations which meet monthly on a
year-round basis, and the fiddle contests
alive

are 35 to 40 fiddlers and over 100 fans, all
of whom put a dollar in the pot for a night
of great entertainment. Each fiddler plays
two tunes after selecting his accompanist,
usually piano or guitar, or both. There is
also a break for a square dance or two, and
if time permits you might also hear a
harmonica solo, an old-time country song,
and
see Jean
Howard Edgerton
or
demonstrate Applachian clogging to the
fiddling of St. Anne's Reel. Coffee and
cookies are available all evening for a

quarter.
In similar vein, the Niagra and District
Fiddlers Association meets at Grantham

High School in St. Catherines on the 1st
Wednesday of each month; theHamilton-

Wentworth

Association

at

Knights

of

Hall in Hamilton on the 3rd
Tuesday; the Port Perry Association at the
Legion Hall in Port Perry on the 4th

Columbus

the
Bond Head
and
Bond Head Community
Hall on the 4th Tuesday. The dates
purposely do not conflict so that fiddlers
and fans can attend them all in any given
month.
Besides the regular monthly meetings,
the various fiddle associations take turns
sponsoring an all-day Saturday Social
where the fiddling begins shortly after
lunch and continues through the evening,
with only a break for supper. The travel by
chartered bus to attend one of these socials
is itself a fun-filled event, with lots of oldtime fiddle music along the way.
In addition to the fiddle associations
which function all year round, there are the
fiddle contests which continue year after
year during the summer months, with an
occasional smaller contest during the
winter as part of a winter carnival. While
there will always be a certain amount of
unfavorable comment with respect to the
judging of any event, there is no doubt that
fiddle contests provide the impetus for the
development of our great fiddlers. The 12
and under class of yesteryear, such as the
Schreyer, Woods, and Reid families, to
name a few, are among Canada's top
fiddlers; and Suzanne Tellier, just a little
girl when I accompanied her on piano at
contests some years ago, placed fourth in
the Grand National at Nashville in 1988.
Selburne, Ontario, known locally as
Fiddleville, is the home of the Canadian
Championship fiddle competitions. The

Wednesday;
Association

in the

weekend in August 1989 will mark the
39th such annual event.lt is sponsored by
the Shelburne Rotary Club, and if you
first

�want to be on its mailing list you have only
to
write to Ken Gamble, Executive
Secretary, National Fiddle Contest, Box
27, Shelburne, Ontario, LON ISO.
Two weeks prior to the Shelburne
contest you will find fiddlers and stepdancers competing at scenic Bobcageon on
the Trent Canal waterways, the fiddlers
honing their skills in preparation for

Shelburne. The Chamber

of Commerce

provides accommodation

information,

and writing

a

note to Mary Stockdale, Box

119, Bobcageon, Ontario, KOM 1 AO, will
get you on the mailing list. This one is 20
years old in 1989.
Another favorite with fiddlers and stepis
the
dancers
Drayton Agricultural
This
Society's Old Tyme Jamboree.
contest, 19 years old in 1989, is held on the

August. It continues to be a
indicated
by
increasing
attendance figures. For information on this
weekend
as
favorite

last

in

one you can write to Mrs. Randy Petznick,
RR #2, Drayton, Ontario, NOG 1P0. Be
forewarned, however, that there are always
a lot
of competitors in the step-dance
few dyed-in-the-wool
fiddlers tend to find this a bit of a drag.
Nevertheless, the step dancing is enjoyable
and the little tots are a joy to behold.
Besides, you will hear some great fiddling
from the fiddler who must play the clog,

competitions

and

jig, and reel for

a

them and make the changes

of the three rhythms without a break.
On the second weekend in July the
Rotary Club of Fergus-Elora sponsors the
Fergus Old-Time Fiddle and Step-Dance
Contest. Named after one of its Scots
founders, Adam Fergusson, the town of
Fergus has a unique heritage of Scottish
culture and history, retaining much of its
architectural charm and Scottish character.
Information on this contest, now in its
10th year, is available from Merv Woods
of the fiddling Woods family, Box 307,
Fergus, Ontario, N1M 3E2.
If you're into bluegrass festivals, the big
one in these parts is Bluegrass Canada, held

Toronto

on the Temagami River. You
might want to attend his River Valley
festival, and can read more about it in an
article

published

in

the January,

edition of Bluegrass Unlimited.

Regular

old-time

country

1989

music

programs on radio and television are
almost nonexistent in this area. If you have
the patience to listen long and hard you
might catch the occasional tune. An

exception

is

AM

station

CHOW,

Welland, Ontario, which carries a 30minute
program of fiddle music on
Sundays from 6:30 to 7:00 p.m. at 1470
on the dial, hosted by "Canada's polka
king," accordionist Walter Ostanek of St.
Catherines. Several area FM stations carry
regular folk programs, but most of it is of
the contemporary variety. The Ryerson
at 99. 1 on the dial
carries folk and blues programs most of the
on Saturdays,
and "the Tommy
day
Hunter Show" on Channel 5, Toronto,
will sometimes throw in a bit of the
traditional on Saturdays at 7:00 p.m. Even

College station, CJRT,

contemporary country music seems to be
having its problems surviving. Long-time
country music station CFGM just recently
moved from 1320 to 640 on the AM dial
in an attempt to increase its failing numbers
rating by saturating the Toronto market
with its 50,000 watts.
In reporting on old-time music in such a
large community it is difficult to cover all
the nooks and crannies where you might
stumble on traditional music and dance. I
did find, however, that if you were to visit
the Timothy Eaton Secondary School in
the Scarborough area of Metro Toronto on

Monday and Wednesdays evenings, you
would find chamoion fiddler Eleanour

a class of 20 would-be
fiddlers of all adult ages. And if you were to
9:30 p.m.,
stay for the two hours 7:30
you would probably hear the beautiful
strain of Graham Townsend' s "Debbie's
Waltz" emanating from 20 fiddles
enough to moisten the eyes. You might
even find Graham playing the guitar

Townsend teaching

accompaniment and convince him to play
a tune on the fiddle, as the students did
during the last class before Christmas.
A few miles north in the town

of

Newmarket, you could catch
fiddler/composer Webb Acheson
teaching

a

Heights

class of 20 students in Huron

Secondary

School

any

Webb is the
Wednesday
evening.
composer of "Allen's Reel," a popular
album tune, which is also included in
Mel

Bay's

Contest

Fiddling

Book

as

"Alfie's Hornpipe."
If you like jamming you should know
that every Saturday afternoon at the
Country Music Store, 2203 Danforth
Avenue, Toronto, Ontario M4C 1K3,
you will find any number of old-time
musicians making music on fiddles,
guitars, banjos, mandolins, accordions,
and harmonicas, depending on who
turns up. Since one of this store's
specialties is music from the Canadian
Maritime Provinces in the form of
albums and tapes, you are likely to find a
few Canadian maritimers behind the
instruments. A few years ago cameras
homed in on this event to produce a

entitled "Music on the
program
Danforth" for viewing on Ontario's
educational television network which
blankets Ontario.
continued on page 42

always on the first weekend in June at
Carlisle, Ontario, just north of Hamilton,
and now in its 18th year. Court Weaver
holds this in his own Courtcliffe Park and
has always
engaged enough traditional
performers to make it enjoyable for the
old-time buffs. It was there that I first met
the late Charlie Monroe and the still-active

Greenwood

Snuffy Jenkins back in the 1970s. It was
there that I also attended my first fiddle
workshop, this one conducted by the great
Kenny Baker.

courtesy

the sheer love of the music and is
carving out his own bluegrass park in the
wilderness about 275 miles north of

Lome

I
would be remiss to mention Tony
DeBoer, if only because he resides in this
area. Tony is a great promoter of bluegrass

for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Left to Right: Howard Mulvihill, vice-president Heritage Club; Walter Ostanek, president; Tom
McQueston receiving award; Tom Anderson, president Nobleton Fiddle Assoc.; Lome Greenwood,
friend and accompanist for Tom McQueston at presentation for Hertiage Club.

�JAMES KESTERSON'S

The Dance Beat

Blue Ridge

Dancers

Mountain

Stepping Between
Tradition &amp; Precision

Traditional clogging is not hard to find
in

around

and

Asheville,

North
by

Carolina. Throughout the year cloggers
are featured entertainment at local night
spots, festivals, car sales, and
conventions. In the summer months
people from
during tourist season,
outside the mountains see cloggers
perform at the weekly "Shindig-On The
Green" and at many other outdoor
events. The predominant style of the
local clogging teams is traditional bigcircle, free-style clogging, in which the
dancers execute square dance figures as
they dance to traditional mountain
music.
In my travels to other parts of the
country, I have come across many
doggers who dance a different style,

called

"precision,"

"contemporary"
style,

seen

as

"modern,"

Phil Jamison

or

clogging. This newer
with
on "Hee-Haw"

in hot-pants, has in the
last 20 years spread all across the United

routines consist of lines rather than
square-dance figures, and the dancers
execute their steps all together in
memorized sequences to recordings of
current pop or country

"Nine-To-Five,"

songs such as,

"Elvira," or 'That Old-

Time Rock and Roll."
As a result, I have met young doggers
who do not realize that clogging has any
connection with fiddle music or that it is
possible, or even desirable, to dance to
live music. That is something that they
have never experienced. The emphasis is
on

competition rather than

any of the

social aspects of dance.

am not an enthusiast of this
form of clogging, as I saw more and more
became curious as to how it
of it,

While

I

I

evolved from traditional clogging. When
I
asked dancers, instructors, and even
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Bob

States. Like modern club-style square
dancing, it is a standardized form of
traditional dance that is taught and
promoted by national organizations. It
differs from traditional clogging in a
number of ways. Modern precision

Lindsey

doggers dressed

James Kesterson's Blue Ridge Mountain Dancers

at

the Mountain Dance and Folk Festival, Asheville,

N.C., 1968

leaders of some of the clogging organi
zations, I found out that they did not
know the answer.
I
had heard locally that the first
precision group back in the 1950s was
James Kesterson's Blue Ridge Mountain

from nearby Henderson
County, so I went out to Hendersonville
and looked them up. I visited them on

Dancers
their

weekly

practice

night

at

Kesterson's house, where they rehearse
on

a

huge

floor

dance

which

is

a

permanent feature of his living room. I
was surprised to see that the Blue Ridge
Mountain Dancers are not what I would
call a precision clogging group. Much of
their

footwork

is

they do open up to

freestyle,
a

and

while

precision line for

a

finale, most of their choregraphy
consists of traditional mountain square

dance figures. Though they rehearse
without music, they perform only to live
traditional mountain music, not to
recorded pop or country.
Born in 1937, James Kesterson grew
up in a family of traditional dancers in
Henderson County. His banjo-playing
grandmother had told him of dancing
with

a

glass of water on her head and not

spilling a drop, and of old-time cabin and
barn raisings when, after the foundation
floor had been laid, a dance,
and
sometimes lasting two days and two
nights, would be held to test the floor
before proceeding with the building.
Learning from his brother and friends,
Alex and Johnnie Houston, James began
dancing at the age of 11. At that time
most of the schools in his area sponsored
smooth-style square dance teams, but

�not clogging groups. In the 1950s he
danced with the Houston Brothers in the
North Carolina Cloggers, which he says
was the very first group to end their
routines in a line, though the footwork

free-style, i.e. not synchronized.

was still

The

danced

group

with

locally

eight

couples, and traveled with four to
perform at county fairs across the
country. They were also featured on a
Grand Old Opry television program
filmed in the mid-fifties (which in recent
years has been re-released
name, "Classic Country").

under the

In 1959, Kesterson enlisted a group of
high-school students and formed his
own clogging team, the Hendersonville
Cloggers. After competing and winning
first place at the Asheville Dance and
Folk Festival in 1962, Bascom Lamar
Lunsford renamed them the Blue Ridge
Mountain Dancers and featured them in

the

film,

"Music Makers

of the

Blue

Ridge."

Ridge Mountain Dancers
traditional
figures with extra
performed
flair and showiness. Having borrowed
The

Blue

the idea of

a

finale line from the North

Cloggers, Kesterson thought
that it would look more polished to have
all the dancers coordinate their steps. So,
to
the
local
in
marked contrast
Carolina

traditional groups, their free-styling
dancers would suddenly line up for a
finale of synchronized stepping. With
their flamboyant style, they dominated
the dance competition at the Asheville
festival throughout the 1960s. Because
other groups were
discouraged from entering, so one year
Kesterson was asked to organize and
bring three different teams to the festival
they won so often,

"Annie Get Your Gun," at a tent theater
in Maggie Valley. As usual the group
ended its routine with a precision line
sequence of steps and a bow. The show's
New York choregrapher instructed them
to put the line in the middle of the

routine

as

a

false finale.

It

had

a

great

effect on the audience, so the group kept
that feature in their routines.
Following a performance in New
York's Central Park one summer, the
Blue Ridge Mountain Dancers were
offered an extended engagement to
dance at Radio City Music Hall, but they
had to decline because most of the
dancers had to get home to high school.
There's no telling the influence the
Rockettes might have had on the group if
they had been able to stay and perform
for vice versa!.
Other tours in the 1960s included

performances at the first Smithsonian
Institution Festival of American Folklife
in -Washington,
D.C., the New York
World's Fair (1964), Montreal's Expo
(1967), and the Olympic Games in
Mexico City (1968).
In the early 1970s, Kesterson and his
wife, Arlene, ran a school of traditional
music and dance in Hendersonville. At
their "Folkway Center" they offered
classes in banjo, fiddle, guitar, mandolin,
clogging,

and

square dancing,

and

on

weekend nights throughout the summer
they presented programs of mountain
music and dance at their outdoor
amphitheater.

After more than 10 years of inactivity,
James Kesterson has reformed his Blue

Ridge Mountain Dancers as an active
dance team. The current group includes

some of the same dancers who were part
of it 25 years ago when they were highschool students. He hopes that his son,
daughter, and granddaughter will keep
alive his style of clogging in the future.
The Blue Ridge Mountain Dancers,
while not a precision clogging group by
today's standards, can be seen as a link

between

traditional

and

precision

clogging styles. They dance with four to
eight couples in routines based on
traditional square-dance figures, except
when they open up to a line of
synchronized stepping, as Kesterson
says, "to finish up a set of figures in a
polished manner."
Kesterson s view of the newer modern

precision clogging is that the footwork is
a cross between tap, clogging, buckdance
forms, and the routines are
one
finale line after another with
simply
no other dance figures involved. He does
and other

not

approve

of

the

numerous

allow
that he feels
competitions
promoters to make money from
dancers. Each one seems to try to
proclaim itself as the ultimate top-ofthe-line contest, using such names as
"World,"
"National," "International,"
or "Universal." Though it may be an
the
1989 Hee Haw
extreme
case,
International Clogging Championship,
charged an entry fee of $45 per dancer!
The contemporary precision clogging
scene which Kesterson rejected has
flourished and grown now to include
instructors and groups in almost all 50
states.

It is especially strong in Georgia,
Florida, and Texas. Since 1980, clogging
as
the
such
and
Hoedown

organizations

Clogging

National

Council

just to fill out the competition. In 1970,

perhaps

to

traditional

encourage

groups,

the

the

more

festival

committee decided to ban all forms of
precision clogging from the competition.
The Blue Ridge Mountain Dancers have
not performed there since that time.
During the 1960's, besides being a
perennial crowd pleaser at the Asheville
Festival, Kesterson took his dance team
to perform all over the country, traveling

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Phil

to the fiddling of Clayton McMichen,
backed up by Doc Watson, Mike and
Pete Seeger, and others.
While James was off at Newport in
1964, part of his group stayed home to
perform in a production of the musical

Jamison

miles with as many as 28 kids
many
packed into two matching VW buses. In
1964 and 1965, at the height of the folk
music revival, they were invited to
perform at the Newport Folk Festival on
the same billing as Bob Dylan, Joan Baez,
and Peter, Paul, and Mary. They danced

James Kesterson with daughter

Kim and granddaughter Ashley.

�NORTH GEORGIA
FOLK FESTIVAL

Sandy Creek Park, Athens, Georgia
October 7, 1989 (rain date Oct. 8) 1-9 P.M.

BLUES

Cecil Barfield, Neil Patman

BLUEGRASS

Foxfire Boys, In Cahoots

STRINGBANDS

The Skillet Lickers, Mabel Cawthorn

SPIRITUALS

Southside Community Choir of Gainesville (shape note)

HOWARD FINSTER

SPECIAL GUESTS
and 15 of Georgia's best folk artists and craftspeople;

also featuring Storytellers, the Bullfrog Cloggers, The Augusta Irish Dancers,
with Ash Raymond and Art Rosenbaum, Masters of the Ceremonies.

Admission: $6 for adults, $3 for seniors and children 7-12, Children under

7 free.

is produced by the Clarke County Cultural Services Division, The Athens Folk Music &amp; Dance
the
Clarke County Department of Parks and is supported in part by the Georgia Council for the
and
Society,
Arts through appropriations from the Georgia General Assembly and the National Endowment for the Arts.

This program

For information write or call The North Georgia Folk Festival, Clarke County Courthouse,
325 E. Washington St., Athens, Ga. 30601, 404-354-2670.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

CLASSIFIED
The Old-Time Herald will accept
classified ads at the cost of .50 cents per
word, minimum $7.00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the
first of the month, 2 months prior to

publication.

1989 SOUTHERN FOLK DIRECTORY
Lists folk music, dance and storytelling
activities in the South (Delaware to Texas),
plus nationally distributed resources. 224
pages with over 800 listing of associations,
instruments builders
and
performers,
much more! $12.95 plus $1.00 shipping
and 5% GA sales tax. Folk Publications,
PO Box 168-C, Tucker, GA 30085. 404-

564-4709.
SUBSCRIBE NOW to our monthly used
and vintage instrument list with hundreds
of quality instruments at down-to-earth
prices.
$4.00/year ($8.00 foreign).
Current issue free on request. ELDERLY

INSTRUMENTS 1100 N. Washington,
14210-AZ34, Lansing MI 48901.

POB

517-372-7890.

WANTED: Paramount Newsreel footage

White Top, Virginia on August 12,
showing the Frank Blevins Band
performing for Mrs. Eleanor Roosevelt.
Marshall Wyatt, 240 Precita Avenue, San
shot
1933

at

Francisco, CA 94110. 415-826-1208.

RECORDS FOR SALE Folk, bluegrass,
blues, Irish, stringband and country. Send
to 1st purchase) to: Don's
Recycled Records, Box 1353, Park Ridge,

$1.00 (credited
IL

60068.

KYLE
Rt.

1,

CREED BANJO 12" top quality,
Box 48, Galax VA 24333. 703-236-

5629.

FLATIRON,

STELLING,
MARTIN,
GIBSON, STIVER, GUILD, DEERING,
TAYLOR, REITER, KENTUCKY, much
more,

in

stock

now

at

the

best

prices.

World's largest fretted instruments store.
Free catalogs.
ELDERLY
INSTRU
MENTS 1100 N. Washington, POB

14210-BA34, Lansing,
372-7890.

MI

48901. 517-

FOR SALE: 1928 Paramount C banjo pot:
"Piano volume,
harp quality tone."

$350.00. Gail Gillespie, 919-929-6218.

BLUEGRASS
INSTRUMENTS, new,

FINE

OLD-TIME
used,

vintage.

friendly advice. All correspond
ence answered promptly and in depth.
Or, 919-383-5750. 45&lt;t S.A.S.E. brings
current listing. Subscriptions with extra
services $5.00. Harry &lt;Sl Jeanie West,
3815 Tremont Dr., Durham, North
Carolina 27705.
Free,

Fiddler with FlattSIMS
team
(1949-52). Musical tapes,
Scruggs
video.
instructional books, &amp;. tapes
Free brochure. Benny Sims, 318 Swanee
Dr., Johnson City, TN 37601 (615)

BENNY

282-1219.

COUNTRY MUSIC CLASSIC TAPES:
Old time string bands, bluegrass, gospel.
1920s- 1960s. Send $1.00 for catalog.

Bussard, 6610 Cherry
Frederick, MD 21701.

Joe

Hill

Dr.,

�THE COUNTRY MUSIC FOUNDATION:
Showcase For Old-Time Music
Patricia Hall

courtesy

the

Country

Music

Foundation

by

A panel

from the CMF's Grand Ole Opry Exhibit.

record-collector Bob Pinson,
educator Angelia Gacesa, and folklorist
assumed their
Seemann
Charlie
When

positions

at

the

Country

Music

Foundation (in 1973, 1976, and 1981,
respectively) each had an interest in
traditional music. But none likely could
have predicted how much traditional and
old-time country music might figure in
the programs
they would plan and
implement at the CMF.
in
Chartered
1964, the Country
Music Foundation is the world's largest
and most active research and exhibition
center dedicated to a form of popular
music. Located in Nashville, the CMF
has gained international recognition for
its Country Music Hall of Fame and
Museum; its Library and Media Center;

educational and
and its publications,
outreach programs, museum store, and
mail-order

service.
its

Although

statement

mission

decrees that the foundation

is

"dedicated

preservation and presentation of
country music in its historical depth, its
stylistic complexity, and its cultural
to the

integrity," the image many have of the
Country Music Foundation is that it

showcases
music

and

contemporary country
honors primarily current

only

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

country

fact, during its
operation the Country

music stars.

nearly 25 years of

In

Music Foundation has built a trained
staff who, as part of their other duties,
diligently research, collect, and interpret
the styles and repertoires commonly
referred to as "traditional" and "oldtime" in order to tell the complete story
of country music's evolution.

How

does

the

CMF

showcase

music?
Namely,
traditional
country
through its museum exhibits, on- and
off-site programs, collecting policies,

merchandise lines. Rumors to the
the
Country Music
contrary,
Foundation enthusiastically embraces
traditional and old-time music and, in
fact, has recruited numerous old-time
and

live program
be
to
an
of
genre: early
important
interpreters

musicians

country music.

"Although

it

may not be

reflected

in

every single exhibit or program, we are
extremely committed to old-time forms

music,"
says Charlie
country
and one-half
seven
for
who
Seemann,
foundation's
as
the
served
has
years
and
for
collections
director
deputy
of

research. He cites the Grand Ole Opry
exhibit, mounted in 1986, in which oldartifacts such as Uncle Dave
time

Macon's banjo and DeFord Bailey's
megaphone appear alongside newer
items, such as Dolly Parton's and Porter
Waggoner's matching stage costumes
and Marty Robbins' guitar. Likewise,
the foundation's Country Music in the
Movies exhibit incorporates historical
like A1
of old-timers
film footage
Hopkins and the Hillbillies, and artifacts
such as Roy Acuff's fiddle along-side the
modern mechanical bull that appeared in
the movie Urban Cowboy.
In the Country Music Foundation's
the
permanent museum collections,
artifacts
3,000
range
approximately
from Emmylou Harris's customized
Gibson J 200 inlaid guitar to Hank
Williams' painted necktie. Scattered
among the many contemporary artifacts
(all of which are catalogued and housed
according to strict museum conservation
standards) are Fiddlin' John Carson's

fiddle, Moonshine Kate's guitar, and
Riley Puckett's pipe. While stressing
that the foundation's collecting efforts
of country
all
areas
music,
span
Seemann admits that staff members keep
an especially keen eye out for anything

historical connection to the
older string bands, old-time comedians,
and early solo performers.
Artifacts and exhibits may be the most
publicly visible reflection of the CMF's
commitment to older forms of country
music. Old-time music is prominent in
that has

a

other CMF program areas
Working with teachers,

folklorists,

and

outside

as

well.
CMF staff

consultants,

CMF Head of Education Angelia Gacesa
has developed a series of unrivalled in-

school

programs

showcasing

the

With
traditional
Tennessee
the
from
support
grant
Humanities Council, Tennessee Arts
Commission, and the National
Endowment for the Arts, Gacesa has
mounted several kinds of in-school
residencies around the state, in which
traditional musicians and dancers, and
folklorists, presented old-time music
children.
dance to school-age
and
Performers such as McDonald Craig,
music

of Tennessee.

Moss, and Roy Harper, and
dancers such as Robert Spicer and
Carmack Griggs not only performed,
but invited children to participate in
their particular art form.
Frazier

�Recently, Gacesa has taken
concept one step further by

statewide

presenting

this
also

in-service

Tennessee educators on
the topic "Tennessee Traditions in the
Classroom." The workshops, which
featured CMF staff and outside
folklorists,
helped
equip individual
teachers with skills and background to
incorporate traditional culture
in their
including old-time music
classroom curricula.
The varied educational offerings of
the CMF also include six "Suitcase
Series" traveling kits (containing
workshops

to

teachers' guides and actual curricula)
that teachers can borrow to teach about
country music's rich heritage. And,
CMF educational staff regularly oversee
field trips to the Country Music Hall of
Fame and Museum and historic RCA

Studio B (administered by the CMF as a
historic site), in which students can have
hands-on experiences as they learn about

country music's roots. Both the kits and
the tours teach about the old-time styles
and performers that preceded some of
the
forms
of
more
contemporary
country music.

The Foundation Press, overseen by
director
for
CMF
program
deputy
development Kyle Y oung, publishes the
Journal of Country Music, a quarterly
newsletter, books on country music, and
In all
the Official Country Calendar.

CMF's publications, the historical roots
of country music as well as older musical
styles and repertoires are regularly
featured. Recent articles in the Journal
include "Belle of the Barn Dance:
Reminiscing with Lula Belle Wiseman
Staney," "Take me Back to Renfro
Valley," and "Leaving Home: Charlie
Poole's Early Years." Well-known
authors such as Nolan Porterfield,
Charles Wolfe, and Bill Malone are
CMF Press contributors, assuring that
country music's historical legacy is not

only well-documented but eloquently
written.
The Country Music Foundation also
has its own record label, Foundation
Records, which, among its titles, has
issued Just Me and My Guitar (an album
of early Hank Williams demos) and,
most recently, the Grammy-nominated
Bristol

Sessions

(featuring

the

released country music. The CMF's 78
is
now 90 percent
rpm collection

complete.
In addition to 140,000 recordings of
all kinds,
the CMF Library boasts
thousands of books, periodicals, photo
graphs,
songbooks, sheet music,
recording contracts, documents, films,
and videotapes. The library serves 600
800 visiting researchers annually. A
good number of these are scholars of
music
or
those
historical country

researching

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of its ongoing and upcoming

all

In

activities,

the Country
Music
Foundation continues to serve the cause
of old-time music. CMF staff members,
CMF

and

Bill

director,

have

Ivey,

cultivated relationships with historical
performers of country music and have
conducted in-depth oral histories with
many of them for the foundation's
archives. Soliciting artifact donations
from old-time and traditional musicians
continues to be a priority. Future
exhibits that will highlight country
music's many historical forms are being
discussed. And just published is an
volume
elegant pictorial/historical
entitled Country: The Music and the
Musicians, cooperatively published by
the CMF Press and Abbeville Press.
for

fan (or

practitioner of)
vacation or business
trip brings you to the Nashville area, a
visit to the Country Music Foundation is
So,

any

old-time music, if

in

certainly

a

order. If research

is

your

make an advance appointment to
use the CMF Library. One thing is
certain: If old-time music is your forte,
you'll not want to miss the Country
aim,

Music Foundation.

H

For more information
and the services

CMF

contact:

The

concerning the
it
provides,

Country

Music

Music Square East,
4
Foundation,
Nashville, TN 37203. (615) 256-1639.

Carter

Family, Jimmie Rodgers, and others).
For the reseacher and scholar of oldtime and traditional music, the Country
Music Foundation Library and Media
Center is the finest and most compre
hensive facilty of its kind. Principal
researcher Bob Pinson has seen to it that
the CMF sound collection
acquires
pristine copies of any commercially

old-time

particular

a

musician. Foundation staff are available
to assist visiting researchers, who make
arrangements ahead of time to use the
facilities.

Patricia

Hall

is

a

folklorist

educational consultant living

in

and

Nashville,

her
and
7enn.
Aside
from
folklore
consultant work, Patty is co-editor of a book
entitled Folklife and Museums, and she
presents specialized workshops that she has
designed on folklore and folklife. She serves

of several museums and
and plays old-time banjo,
writes songs, and sings.
on

the

boards

organizations,

�Workshop
by

Paul Brown

SWEET LITTLE JULIE

North Carolina. Norm
charming dance tune which used to be fairly popular in southwest Virginia and northwest
it's
been heard a lot more
Edmonds and the Old Timers would often play it on their WBOB radio program in the 1950s. This season
Mt.
Va.
and
from
and
N.C., have been
Chatfield
Galax,
Airy,
Backstep,
than in recent years, partly because Greg Hooven, Ray
fiddlers
conventions.
of
it
at
out
the
fire
playing
I've shown two different ways to play the top part. One of them involves using the fifth string for the downbeat about halfway
the first string at the
through, and fretting the first string at the seventh fret to take advantage of a nice percussive effect. Fretting
but
works
the
follow
note
doesn't
the
fret
earlier:
very well on the
the
seventh
melody,
exactly
third fret has a similar effect as using
effect
a lot.
this
of
use
used
to
music
type
to
the
flowing along. Tommy Jarrell
keep
banjo
[Cornbread &amp;
Remember, this is only an example of how the piece might be played. Check the recordings by Harold and Abe
on
this
than
it
rather
who
drawing.
relying entirely
plays
Molasses, Heritage Records HRC XXIII] and try to find someone
I'd like to hear from anyone who knows of other recordings of this tune. Drop me a line at the Old-Time Herald if you get the
chance.
Here's

a

quarter

note

eighth
Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

note.

�ASK
?

HAM. Uncle Harold, in his
or to
selfless pursuit of pleasing his vast public
no matter how much he questions

Uncle Harold

aforementioned subject:
your column in OTH #6 (Nov. 88Jan. 89) there was mention made of
Uncle Dave Macon's appetite for and
expertise concerning country ham, and
in particular, smoked ham. This, plus
the great anecdote about Uncle Dave
dealing with road food reminded me of
an Uncle Dave story I heard years ago
from Carl Story, the bluegrass/gospel

their taste
passes on the following
slice of information from Frank Orsini
on the
"In

sinapr.

"Carl and his band were playing in
Albany, N.Y. back in the '70s and I was a
member of the local band that opened
the show. Somehow, during backstage
conversation, we got into talking about
Uncle Dave, and Carl remembered in his
youth touring as part of a country show
with the 'Dixie Dewdrop' himself. He
said that among Uncle Dave's luggage
was one particular suitcase that was

unusually heavy
enough so to be a
source of annoyance and curiosity for

travelers. Pressed for an
explanation Uncle Dave replied: 'Well, I
keep my clothes and shoes and all in
these other suitcases, but in this one here
fellow

his

I

P.

D.,

know:

Augusta, Maine, wants

to

Uncle Harold a real live
folklorist, or did someone just dig up a
photograph of an old goat to decorate a
sharp-witted and authoritative question
"Is

and answer column? Just curious." In
P.S., P.D. mentions a desire to see
profile of your uncle in the next OTH

a
a

issue.

Well. Uncle Harold, while grateful to
considered sharp-witted, must
be
confess to being a little vain about his
physical

appearance.

He

has

been

considered moderately handsome by the
ladies, and believes he presents a kindly

most assuredly human face to the
world. So, P.D., your uncle
does not disown you, not in the least.
But he does wonder about the more
fragile egos of some folklorists, and of
other old folks who, he feels quite
certain, will not take kindly to your
equating them collectively with old
and

old-time

goats.
it makes U ncle
As for a profile shot
Harold think of those unpleasant posters
on the post office wall. You must rest
content with a frontal presentation, P.D.

For some reason, Uncle Harold's
readers continue to evince an unhealthy
interest in
(in his humble opinion)
Uncle Dave Macon's relationship with
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

carry my

L.N.

smoked hams!'"

of Las

Vegas,

precision clogger

and

Nevada,

is

a

wants to know

about "any free-style, clogging, buck
dancing, and mountain figure video
for
instruction
tapes available
purchase."

Uncle Harold

is

find out that there

glad, somehow,
are

doggers

in

to
Las

Vegas. He hopes L.N.'s dance activities
will be enriched
following
by the

information:

Feet,"

"Talking

documentary mountain dance video,

a

is

available from Flower Films. The films
made by Mike Seeger and Ruth
Pershing, who is also working on an
with
dance
instructional
booklet,
tablature to go along with the video. It's
was

teaching tape per se, but contains
fine examples of different
mountain dancers. "Talking Feet,"
Flower Films, 10341 San Pablo Ave., El
Cerrito, CA 94530.
Burton Edwards of Maggie Valley, has
made at least one instructional tape on
clogging. Uncle Harold doesn't know
any more about it except an address: Rt.
1, Box 676 Maggie Valley, NC 28751.
not

a

many

K.T., of Jackson, Tennessee, writes:
"Recently,

Lizard Lick,

old-time

a

local group

music, presented
one of the most beautiful tunes I've ever
heard. They said it was 'Wings of a

performing

a Cajun waltz tune they learned
from Eddie Ragsdale of Louisiana, when
they were with him in Arkansas a few
years ago. I would like to know the
history and any other information about
this beautiful number, and where the
words and music can be found. I also
wonder if the words 'My dreams of you
will never come true' are part of this
song."
Uncle Harold is a little puzzled, K.T.
After a helpful conversation with Barry
Ancelet, he now knows that there is a
song called "Les Ailes des Hirondelles"

Dove,'

referring to swallows rather than
doves. The song is not a waltz; Barry
obligingly sang a few bars over the phone
to your uncle, and we agreed that it
it was in 2/4 time. The
on Rounder's album
be
found
can
song
the
Southwest Prairies,
Music
from
Cajun
and
performed by Eduis Naquin,

sounded like

More
recorded by Ralph Rinzler.
found
versions
can
be
by
contemporary
Ricard, and Beausoliel, on
Zachary
Arhoolie.
Uncle Harold,
As for the words.
not wanting to run up the Old- T ime
Herald's already stupendous phone bill
by taking lame dictation in French (his
transcribing is lame, not Barry Ancelet's
speaking) refers you to Barry Ancelet for

words, further information, etc.
Barry Ancelet, 15 Rue des Babineaux,
Scott, La. 70583.

B.B., of Rushford, MN, inquires
about the identities of the musicians in
the ad taken out in the February 1988
North
the
National
by
Geographic
Carolina Department of Tourism. "If
you haven't seen it," he writes, "it's a
photo (2-page) of old-time musicians.
fiddlers,

guitarists,

banjo

pickers,

a

mandolin player, and a dulcimer player."
Good question. Your uncle has seen
the photo in question and wishes he had

it's a great picture. He
framed copy
knew one of the musicians in the picture,
Sheila Barnhill (see OTH Vol. 1, No. 7
for more on Sheila). She steered Uncle
Harold to Ms. Robin Mullican, who
works for the ad agency in Raleigh, N.C.,
that arranged for the photo. She writes,
a

"The musicians in the ad are: top row (1
Shaw, Arvil Scott, Rita Scott,

to r) Lynn

Verlen Clifton, Carroll Best, Betty
Smith. Seated (1 to r) Sheila Barnhill,
Grover Sutton, Quay Smathers, Liz
Shaw, Nettie Presnell.
You'll notice that this leaves you, B.B.,
the fun of matching up the people with
the

instruments.

D.M.,

Fullerton,

information on

a

78 record

continued on page 43

CA,

wants

he used to

�County
S

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS

am

H

NEW RELEASES

HJ
PU
PU

'ROCl-0262
*JA-054
'CCLP-0105
*FF-468
*BRI-008

Qfl

♦ROU-0237
"CO-505
CO-786

FRESH OLD-TIME STRING BAND MUSIC Collected or performed and recorded by Mike Seeger
BUZZARD ROCK STRING BAND "I've Got The Blues For My Kentucky Home" w/Harry Bickel, etc
"
Live At New River Ranch" Great live concert from 1956
LOUVIN BROTHERS
many top songs
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" New old-time music by this West Virginia group
VIRGINIATRADITIONS:SouthwestVirginia Blues With Dock Boggs, Carter Family, Byrd Moore, etc
SPROUTS OF GRASS "I Like Mountain Music" Bluegrass and old-time music from Washington band
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BANJO COLLECTION Super set of 1937 -46 field recordings by John Lomax...
classic old time recordings
CHARLIE POOLE "Volume 1" Available again with new cover
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent fields recording of the Cumberland Plateau area -w/booklet
Vol. 2" Great reissue of his classic 1950 s recordings
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings
VIRGINIA TRADITIONS -EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO Great oldtimew/Roy Hall, etc
CHOKERS &amp; FLIES "Old Time Music" Fine recent material by the Chicken Chokers &amp; Horseflies
some unissued
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Singles Collections" Neat reissue of obscure 50's/60's cuts
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo LP by this Kentucky musician

RB- 1001

*CCS- 109

*BRI-010
*ROU-O213
"CCLP-0103
*JA-051

JAMES BRYAN "Looked Blues" Fine old-time fiddle, featuring Norman &amp; Nancy Blake
DOC ROBERTS "Old Time Tunes" Great reissue of his tunes from the 1920s &amp; 30's
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial &amp; field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "You Can Feel It In Your Soul" Classic gospel from the 1950s
OLD HOLLOW STRINGBAND Old-time music from North Carolina
Vol.
TRADITIONAL MUSIC FROM THE CUMBERLAND PLATEAU
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2 -LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
Vol 1" Reissue of 1920s material
DYKES "MAGIC CITY" TRIO "String Band Classics
BILL MONROE "In The Pines" Stunning collection of Monroe's best early 1950s Decca material
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Doc's latest, fine effort with Jerry Douglas, Mark O'Connor, etc
TONY RICE &amp; NORMAN BLAKE "Blake &amp; Rice" Just out! Excellent LP by these two top guitarists
w/booklet
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis and Roscoe Parish
NASHVILLE BLUEGRASS BAND "To Be His Child" Excellent collection of traditional BG gospel
BILL MANSFIELD &amp; THE CAROLINA MOCKINGBIRDS "Root Hog or Die" Recent old-time LP
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 940's King material
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumentals" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTWICH &amp; HIGG1NBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
HEE HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing
TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music
UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine 1920's/30's sides
Vol 2 Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
SKILLET LICKERS
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carrol County, Virginia
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T T oddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 920's/30's
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 928-4

*ROU-O175

CO-412

P^J
P^J

AT- 103

*CCS-111

FCOT-001
CO-787
CMF-011
OH- 191

*REB-853

*SH-3759
*ROU-0233
HER-070
*ROU-0242
FCOT-005
*FF-415

*HAT-3022
*CO*-791

yP

P^J

'CCS-110
*CO-788
*REB-850
*FF-352

1

"JA-014

"CO-790
*HH-

19842

*TR-1

CO-545

*CO-526
HER-22

CO-548
CO-406

pfl

Sales

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
READY FOR SHIPMENT

1

1

7
S

.50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50

7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
$10.00

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7

.50

NEW COMPACT DISCS
RCA-CD-8416
RCA-CD-8417

RAGGED BUT RIGHT "Great Country String Bands Of The 1930's" w/Skillet Lickers, Mainers, etc
ARE YOU FROM DIXIE "Brother Duets Of The 1930's" w/Blue Sky Boys, Monroe Bros., Allen Bros

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted

PU

1

2

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00

On all ORDERS

in

CI.SA. please add $2.00

by an

postage

asterisk
&amp;

"

handling

")

CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $5.00 postage for first -3 LPs, $1.50 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

$11.00
$11.00

�Reviews
and

Artists and record companies
please send records and tapes for
review to The Old-Time Herald,
P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC
27717. Do not send to individual
reviewers.

NOTE:

We now list addresses and phone
numbers of record companies whose records we
review regularly, at the end of the Review section. If
you don't see an ordering address at the end of a
review, check the last page of the Review section.
Other phone numbers and addresses (if available)
will be included with the ordering address at the
end of each review. If you do not want us to include
your phone number please let us know when you
send us the item for review. Record companies
please keep us updated and/or corrected as to
phone numbers and addresses.

FRESH
OLDTIME
STRING
BAND MUSIC
Rounder 0262

Boatman/Mabel/Black Jack Davey/Billy in
Waynesboro/Poor Black Sheep/East Tennessee
Blues-Goin'
Broeck
and
Mollie/
Crazy /Ten
Cotton-Eye Joe/Port Fat Makes My Chicken Tan/
Wagnerd/ Wedding Waltz

Collected or performed by Mike Seeger with the Agents
of Terra, Norman, and Nancy Blake, Paul Brown,
James Bryan, Gil Carter, the Horseflies, Alan Jabbour,
Tom Kelly, Don Mussel, the Stepping Stones, and Kirk
Sutphin.

Because Mike Seeger blends so well with the
musicians he has chosen to record, this album is
not your typical "solo act with friends" endeavor.
not even appear on three of the
On the other hand, because of his
presence on most cuts, the album is not exactly an
anthology. It is a nicely put together collection of
cuts by a number of excellent old-time musicians.
or
the
the
album,
quality
Throughout
instrumental musicianship is uniformly high. The
vocals are weak in places, but generally, they are
adequate. The overall sound quality of the album is
Seeger

does

selections.

very

good.

One

exception

is

"East

Tennessee

Blues/Goin' Crazy," on which the recording
equipment seems overwhelmed by the big band
sound and there is too much echo.
Although a variety of instruments are used on
the first four selections on Side A, the sound of
these cuts is a familiar northern or Celtic-flavored
are
all
but the
old-time.
well-done,
They
instrumentals on "Blackjack Davey" (by Norman

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Nancy Blake, James Bryan, and Seeger) are
especially fine. However, my favorite cut on Side
A, and probably the whole album, is "Poor Black
Sheep." It is an exceptionally stellar banjo/fiddle
duet. Paul Brown shines, as usual (I wish more of
his banjo playing would make it into the recording
studio), and Mike has no trouble keeping up with
him on fiddle. Finishing off this side was The
Stepping Stones' "East Tennessee Blues/Goin'
Crazy," a medley which starts off with a ragtime
number and crescendos into Dixieland.
My favorite cut on Side B was "Cotton-Eye Joe"
by The Agents of Terra. This number really works
the intrumentation,
the vocals, the Latin
rhythms, everything. The Agents of Terra have
rarely recorded, and, because they combine the
talents of musicians from several different bands,
they are rarely heard at all. This is too bad, as they
are an excellent band, not exactly an old-time band
(even in a progressive sense), but a good acoustic
band playing beautiful music using old-time
instruments and tunes. In more of an old-time
vein, their performances of "Wedding Waltz," a
lovely waltz composed by Tara Nevins, was also a
highlight. The twin fiddles of Nevins and Jeb
Puryear entwine as only fiddles can on waltzes.
The most unusual selections on the album were
"Pork
Fat
Makes
Chicken Tan" and
My
"Wagnerd," performed by the Horseflies with
others. These selections are most notable for their

harmonic experimentation. "Pork Fat" is dark and
laid-back (and goes on a little too long, as does
"Ten Broek and Molly," the first cut on Side B).
"Wagnerd" is cool and even and reminiscent of
modern jazz.
I will not touch on every
cut, but suffice it to say
there are no real duds on the albums. Despite the
variety of people and instrumentations, it all holds
together surprisingly well. The use of the cello or
instruments
on
several
cuts
was
cello-like
especially nice. The cello has been used to great
effect in old-time music throughout its history, and
it seems as if it deserves more attention. It is also
worth noting that, although Mike makes a
conscious, concerted effort to use many different
types of instruments, the album does not have an
esneriallv forced oualitv.
A final comment
on the liner notes. Those
written for the tunes are quite nice, however, those
describing the album's development are rather
misleading. Mike gives the impression that he is
breaking ground with this album and that one will
hear something "new." Truly, there is nothing here
that I have not been hearing for many years, both
live and on record, although it might be new for
Mike. I would say that Mike is following, rather

than establishing, a trend in producing this album.
The majority of the cuts on it are typical of what
you have been hearing on performing stages and at
high-quality dances all over the country for quite
some time. I would recommend this album to

anyone wanting a well-played and cleanly-recorded
sampling of a variety of styles currently available in
the old-time scene. (Linda Higginbotham)

�when they want to.)
One of the many things that makes this album so
satisfying is the playing that effectively links

together

electronics

seemingly

disparate

elements

of

and acoustics. But because there is no
evidence of the cavalier use of any "new"
instruments like the synthesizer, we are never
forced to endure its presence for its own sake. The

music has an organic quality further enhanced by a
strone ensemble feel.
Having made the point about the ensemble
playing, I feel it necessary to point out the
contributions of two of the band members (though
not at the expense of any of the others). Banjoist
Richie Stearns, member of the late proto-primitive
string band "Bubba George," has, in his own quiet
way, made one of the most original statements in
banjo playing today. He has effectively straddled
that boundary of the African heritage of old-time

clawhammer playing and its contemporary version
of reggae and ska into a unique synthesis. Just listen
to his backing fills on "I Live where Its Gray" and
"Link of Chain." Stearns also contributes vocals on
"Hush Little Baby" and "Bluesman's Daughter,"
which are both ethereal and mesmerizing.
Fiddler Judy Hyman has garnered a welldeserved reputation of being one of the most
skilled and tasteful fiddlers in the old-time scene.
Her sure and centered attack on her instrument has
allowed her the luxury of exploring the wide
variety of styles the band has embarked on. Hyman
comes by her strong sense of eclecticism honestly;
she is the daughter of famed jazz pianist Dick
Hyman, a musician who never let seeming disparity
of styles stand in the way of brilliant inter
pretations. In many ways her fiddle playing

represents the quantum leap the band has made as a
whole; don't judge the music by the instruments
judge

being played

it by

the music being made.

groundbreaking content, this
recording may not be to everyone's taste. That is
too bad. Old-time music has, by its very nature,
always relied on that subtle mix of music passed
down from older players blended with the
firsthand experience of the young. In that respect
what they are doing is not that different than the
Because

of

its

synthesis of players of the "golden era" like Charlie
Poole, Clayton McMichen, or even Fiddling John
Carson. Not that the inventive and challenging
fusion that the Horseflies have produced on this
recent album needs precedent to justify it. Far from
ir

Human

Fly

is

then

not

so

broken, as being refitted for
(Hank Sapoznik)

much rules being
new generation.

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�in the mines" and gave him silicosis of the lung. This
made him "not much of a hand to sing," as he

explained to Dennis White who nonetheless admired
not only his banjo picking but also his voice, "sweet,
forceful, and haunting all at the same time." White's
respect for the man is evident in the sensitive
recording and presentation of this collection.
While one can imagine more power behind the
voice and more drive to the banjo picking, Sexton
remains in command of his vocal line, with its
subtleties of ornamentation and phrasing, and of his
exquisitely crafted banjo settings in six or seven of the
flavorful mountain tunings. In his notes Mike Seeger
comments that Sexton's singing style harks back to
the freedom of unaccompanied traditional singing; it
is true that in songs like "Omie Wise" Sexton uses the
rubato device of lingering on unstressed beats, but
usually his voice follows a set banjo line more than
Pete Steele or Buell Kazee did when they sang ballads
to their banjo playing.
The LP version of this

recording comes with a
biographical notes,
containing extensive
annotations of the songs, and texts. I do not have these
in the cassette format there is a condensed
at hand
leaflet. Texts and notes would be helpful in the
appreciation of Sexton's repertoire, which apparently
comes entirely from oral tradition. It ranges from
ballads of British origin like 'In London City Where I
Did Dwell" ('The Butcher's Boy") and "Old Grey
Beard," and native American ballads like "Omie

booklet

Wise," through folk lyrics like "Little Sparrow," to
"Old Aunt Jenny," a lively piece out of the black and
minstrel traditions. While most of his playing is in
either the thumb-lead or index-lead style of two-finger
picking, Sexton does a lovely job of frailing a bit of
"John Henry," like "Last of Callahan," played as a
banjo solo. He is joined on the fiddle by his nephew,
Lee "Boy" Sexton (who can be heard on his own June

Appeal release, Whoa Mule JA 0051) for
tunes, "Hook and Line" and "Jenny Get
Morgan Sexton might have been more
described as a "traditional mountain singer
than

two frolic
Around."
accurately
and banjo-

"ballad

singer," especially given the
five-string banjo in his work;
"ballad
usually
suggests unaccompanied
singer"
singers like Almeda Riddle and Horton Barker whose
song bags were rich in the "big" British ballads (there
is no Child ballad in this collection). No matter, we
have in this recording an intimate and resonant visit
picker"

of

importance

with

a

the

fine folk artist. (Art Rosenbaum)

Available

as

album or cassette.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Robert Blizard, who played banjo and fiddle, and
from Dudley Vance, Charlie Bowman, and John
Dykes, among others. Ralph also obviously
listened (a lot) to Arthur Smith. Tomes can and
should be written about Smith's influence on
southern fiddling, but young Ralph surely took
Smith's repertoire and bluesy, long-bow style to
heart. When I first heard Ralph about six years ago
Arthur Smith had risen from the grave. But
I felt
Blizard is his own man. He has made those tunes his
own and is a strong, natural singer. Ralph's band,
the Ramblers, are rock solid as they provide the
strong rhythmic underpinnings that allow Ralph to
improvise. They never seem to fall behind when
Ralph goes into an eccentric flow of notes, such as
in "Hell Among the Yearlings." Not only are the
Ramblers strong pickers but they also possess fine
voices, enabling them to sing harmony with Ralph
well as take the lead. John Lilly is one of my alltime favorite singers and really shows his stuff on
Jimmie Rodgers' "No Hard Times." This is a very
strong effort through and through. Ralph Blizard is
a prized musician and a special person. We are very
lucky to have his music. Now 'scuse me while I take
another ride on the "Blizard Train." (Kerry Blech)
as

Available

as

album or cassette.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�removed
music
living
and its
rooms, porches, dances, potlucks
isolation shows. "Fire on the Mountain" is
vigorous and exciting, but it only reminds us of the
real thing without actually being it. I can see how a
talented musician, full of ideas and instruments,
couldn't help but want to see what he can do all by
himself, but this means that these numbers are
without the bumps, lumps, hitches, tension,
and
amazement
of actual
smoke,
people
miraculously playing together.
Despite its faults, this is a fine tape. Cahan is a
careful researcher, and he finds his music in places
that others don't always look. He has attentively
and lovingly learned from old-timers, Earnest East
as well as Roscoe Parish and Luther Davis, and
his own
from this basis he has developed
absolutely pure and enthralling banjo sound, and
his own very lovely style of fiddling, which
combines smoothness and clarity with rhythm and
drive. (Molly Tenenbaum)
studio, on

from

the

a

tape,

real

life

a speaker;
of old-time

in

it is far

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Stewart's flailing sounds like snare drum. Barbara
Magone is perhaps the best Cape Breton-style
backup pianist on the planet, but it sounded like a
quite a musical struggle at times between her and
Irisher Connolly. I feel all parties would be better
served if the normal accompanists were allowed to
back up the featured performers. The jams might
be fun at the concert, but serve no purpose on a
recording.
This tape probably is an excellent souvenir for
those who attended the concerts, but it is less
interesting to the casual listener at home. I would
recommend, if the listener is interested in the styles
presented here, purchase of albums by these
with their regular bands and
performers,
accompanists. (Kerry Blech)
To order:

National

Council

806 15th Street,
Washington, DC 20005
Arts,

for

the Traditional

NW -Suite

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

400,

�provided by Bert's son, Arthur, on guitar (who
also plays his dad's tunes on fiddle), by banjoist
Kirk Sutphin (who plays second fiddle on "Birdie"
and "Flop-Eared Mule"). Paul Brown does the
banjo work on "Duck's Eyeball," "Fly Around,"
"Mama's
Little Baby" (similar to "Rochester
Schottische"), and "Love Somebody" ("Soldier's
Joy"). Like many other musicians, Bert has some
different titles for his melodies than those that
many people know. "Sister Ann" is the same

Hillbillies' "Bug in the Tater,"
sounds more like "Salt
Road" sounds a lot like
and "Rocky
"Angeline the Baker," for instance. Ideally, it
would have been a wonderful event had some field
recordist "discovered" Bert some 20 or 40 years
ago when his playing was stronger, but I can't
complain about his playing today. He manages a
minute or two at a crack of strong bowing, accurate
can just
intonation, and interesting phrasing.
imagine how great he must have sounded 40 years
ago. And what a charming personality! This tape
pulls the listener into a homey setting, surrounded
tale.
by quality musicians, with the occasional
What more can one ask for? (Kerry Blech)
the

melody

as

"Sandy
River,"

River

Belles"

I

To

order:

Kirk

Sutphin,

5650

Davis

Road,

Walkertown, NC 27051

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�fiddle

Clay's

would

style

"Northern-Urban-Ultra-Rhythm"

fall

that

into
if

you
mean. He leaves some melody notes
out occasionally, but compensates with extra bow
strokes. This is a very popular style among young
urban devotees of string band music and tends to
generate excitement at dances and at festivals.
Guitarist Evers is steady, tending more to old-time
style backup than the more prevalent bluegrass
style. Verick's fretless banjo is a bit more of an

know what

type,

I

to me. Perhaps it is undermixed, but I just
can't tell what he's doing. He doesn't get in the way,
just "bubbles' away in the background.
Riness has prepared a nice 16-page booklet to
accompany the tape that describes how he came to
old-time music and gives some background on
each of the tunes. He does a nice job on tracking
down the sources, even if they are not the sources
from which he learned. For instance, he lists

enigma

Burnett, Taylor, and Moore as the original source
for "Knoxville Rag" and Melvin Robinette as the
composer and player of "Last Days in Georgia,"
but he

learned

both

from

Matt Haney

(a

fine

Minneapolis fiddler). His playing thus becomes a
tribute to his contemporaries and secondary
a value judgement on
I don't want to make
this approach, it's just not the way I would do it.
Riness and friends are a good representation of

sources.

what I would call "new-timey string-band music."
After all, old-time music has never been static, so
why shouldn't a musician play it as he or she feels
it? My tastes run to the more traditional styles, but

found nothing offensive in Riness' playing.
A good portion of this tape is taken up by
traditional songs done in a more
somewhat
contemporary manner. Riness has a very good
voice and he is an exceptional guitarist. It just ain't
old-time. Some of his vocalizations remind me of
fellow Midwest folk singer Greg Brown, and other
pieces resound of Ry Cooder. This is quality
company, but Riley Puckett, Earl Johnson, or G.B.
Grayson it isn't. A friend of Clay's suggested to me
that Riness' motives may be that he does not want
to alienate his established fans and perhaps wants
to gently introduce them to string-band music. If
that is so, I commend him for the effort to broaden
the base of old-time music support.
All in all, this was an entertaining recording.
hope Clay sticks with it and gets around to hear
what old-time musicians are doing in other parts of
the country, and listens to those 78s he cites in his
notes. It will be interesting to hear what he turns
out. (Kerry Blech)
Toorder: Weary Wolf Records, Coon Valley, WI
1

1

54623 (608) 452-3433

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Video/Film
LILY MAY LEDFORD

Appalshop Films, for Kentucky
Television's Headwaters series

Educational

Color/28 minutes
It had to happen. We now have old-time music
videos. Appalshop, a group that has made many
fine films investigating social issues in Appalachia,
films
about old-time
occasionally
produces
Appalachian music. This film, celebrating the life
and
of Lily May Ledford,
music
appeared
originally on Kentucky Educational Television's

series, and is now available as a
May, the original banjo rickin
videotape.
Girl" is remembered in interviews with friends,
neighbors and relatives, old film clips and lots of
music.
Headwaters

Lily

Ledford

was the lead singer and
for the Coon Creek Girls, country
music's first all-woman act. This, in itself was
revolutionary. Before the arrival of the Coon
Creek Girls, the women performers of commercial
Lily

May

spokesperson

country music of the 1930s were usually singers of
dainty love songs, who, if they even held a guitar,
as a prop while men did the real
it mainly
playing. The Coon Creek Girls, on the other hand,
sang lustily about fighting, drinking, and hard
all
and
were
gutsy
competent,
traveling,
instrumentalists. Decked out in calico ruffles, but
rooted to the ground with serious mountain clod
hoppers, the four became beloved regulars on
Kentucky's Renfro Valley Barndance radio show.
They were best known for energetic tunes and
cheerful ditties such as "Sowin' on the Mountain,"
"How Many Biscuits Can You Eat," "Jim Along
Josie," and of course, "Banjo Pickin' Girl."
Although the band's personnel changed over the
years, Lily May and her sister Rosie were always
pivotal members of the group. The two were

used

discovered by John Lair, a Kentuckian who, in
1936, was producing a country radio show out of
Chicago on WLS. That summer, knowing that
there were many fine musicians back in his home
region, he put on a talent show near Mt. Vernon,
Kentucky. Lily May and her sister, who had grown
up

in

the

Red

River

Gorge

area

of

40s. John Lair, their manager, apparently
decided that conforming to the tastes of the day
their
urban
would
by
improve
acceptance
audiences. Partly, this concession to popular
musical style is evident in the smooth, close
harmonies and cute endings, but it is especially
obvious in the non-verbal things that show up only
the
constant
on
film,
particularly
smiling.
Performers, and especially women wearing work
boots, were expected to smile and sing
simultaneously! It is in connection with this that
the Coon Creek Girls made their major adaptation
to the demands of performers: Lily May switched
from her main instrument, the fiddle, to the banjo
at Lair's suggestion. Although one of their most
famous publicity photos shows Lily May with her
fiddle cradled against her shoulder, the banjo was
the instrument that she played with the Coon
early

Eastern

Kentucky, playing and singing at local church
gatherings and dances, entered. After winning a
this talent contest,
in
Lily May made
prize
on
WLS's National
Barndance,
appearances
playing both fiddle and banjo. She became so
popular, that she was taken on as a regular act, and
even inspired a cartoon ad series for Pinex (cough
syrup). The ads, done in comic strip format,
featured "Lily May the Mountain Gal," a plucky,
calico-dressed fiddler from Pinchemetite Holler,
whose wit and spirit prevail through various trials
and tribulations, and who inevitably beats the man
in fiddler's contests. Lily May's success gave John
Lair the idea of an all-woman act. The Coon Creek
Girls, consisting of Lily May on banjo, her sister
Rosie on guitar, Violet Koehler on bass and Daisy
Lange on mandolin, were the hit of the National
Barn Dance, Lair's new Renfro Valley Barn Dance
program from Kentucky, and in 1939 appeared in

at a performance before the King and
Queen of England.
The music is what ties this film together, linking
reminiscences of musical cronies and neighbors
with film clips of Kentucky square dances and
Coon Creek Girls performances. It is interesting to
note that, to our ears, the sound and the style of the
Coon Creek Girls is distinctly that of the late 30s,

Washington

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Creek Girls. Without taking away from her banjo
playing, which was lively and well suited to the
group's sound, suspect that logistics played a part
in this switch. It is a much easier prospect to smile,
I

sing and play the banjo that it is to smile, sing and
fiddle. At any rate, in this film, one sees two quite
distinct musical forms in action: the high, giddy,
commercial sound of the Coon Creek Girls' "How
Many Biscuits Can You Eat?" and the mournful,
low sound of an earlier day when Lily May plays
tunes like "White Oak Mountain" and "Pretty

Polly."

There is plenty of music in this film, largely
uninterrupted, and the camera angles itself help
fully for those who appreciate a good view of
nimble fingers in action. My favorite musical
interlude is one in which Lily May, accompanied
by Alice Gerrard and Mike Seeger, rips off a truly
amazing rendition of "Cacklin' Hen." What is most
incredible is the contrast between her fiery fiddling
and her relaxed attitude. In fact, my only real

problem with this film is that there is so little of
Lily May's fiddling, which was her first love and
which is just as outstanding as her banjo playing.
The stories and memories of her friends and
family reveal that Lily May Ledford was a truly
remarkable woman. According to her daughter,
Barbara, at one time in her life, in the 1950s, she
quit performing and took up writing, sitting at the
kitchen table, filling many notebooks. Then she
burned the entire project. When her daughter
asked about this, Lily May simply said that the
writing had been "just feelings." Ironically, her
favorite music, when singing for her own pleasure,
was sad songs like '"Two Little Orphans" and "I
Have No Mother Now."
For those interested in the history of commercial
country recordings and early radio, the segments
with John Lair, the Coon Creek Girls' "living
room" performance and one clip of the Renfro
Valley Barn Dance from the 50s should be pure
of friends, neighbors
Remembrances
delight.
Morgan and Nellie Skidmore, and especially of her
daughter Barbara Greenlief, put her music and life
in social context. Lily May died in 1985, after a
long illness, back in her home in the Red River
Gorge region of Kentucky. The reflections of
young woman performers like Sue Massek,
however, illustrate Lily May's profound and
continuing impact on today's old-time musicians.
This influence can only be strengthened
and
broadened with the help of videotapes such as this.
(Gail Gillespie)

�Available for sale and rental

3/4" Videotape,

in

16mm color film,

and !/" VHS

order: Earthworm Films, P.O. Box 40477,
Albuquerque, NM 87196 (505) 262-0166

To

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

recorded by Brunswick for the
Supertone label (available then through
was

Sears). The record number was 207 1; on
the other side was "Rabbit in a Pea
Patch." It also appears on the Conqueror
label (7251) with "She'll Be Comin'

Round the Mountain" on the flip side.

told your uncle that the Pickard
family also apparently recorded the song
under an alias, the Pleasant Family. This
record, probably pressed by Paramount
for the Broadway label (number 8149),
had "Get away from That Window" on
the other side.
This is by no means exhaustive on the
D.M.
Bussard knows
Joe
subject,
everything, though. And whiie you're at
it, you can ask him about that other 78,
the one by Lulu Belle and Scotty, on
which they perform "Wampus Cat."
Uncle Harold's head is reeling with
he's going to
labels, numbers, aliases

Joe

take

a

nap.

Ed the Fiddler, of West Chester,
PA, wonders why so many old-time
musicians dress "so rustically." After
observing that it is, after all, 1989, he
suggests, somewhat paradoxically, that a
three-piece suit "like the Dykes Magic
City Trio" would be appropriate. "The
ladies, of course," he writes, "would
have more leeway in their style but a nice
business suit would be appropriate."
(with padded shoulders for the Power
Look?-UH). "Also ladies should always
."
perform seated with their legs crossed.
Ed continues. Never one to be at a loss for
words for long, your uncle wonders about
the new style of bass-playing which would
need to be created for 'lady" bass players.
and drummers
And piano players.
Uncle Harold refers his readers to the
cover of OTH Vol. 1, No. 3, for the Dykes
Magic City Look.

Send your
P.O.

Box

27717.

UNCLE HAROLD

from

p.

31

one side of which was a song
own it
called "Down to Arkansas." He believes
it was performed by the Pickard Family.
Let your uncle steer you, D.M., to Joe
Bussard. Not only does he have all the
information you might ever want, he
also owns actual recordings of the song.
Moreover, for a very modest fee (see his
ad in the OTH classifieds) he will tape
them all for you.
"Down in Arkansas" was recorded
many times by the Pickard Family, in the
late 20s and early 30s. In particular, it

for

Uncle Harold to

51812,

Durham,

NC

�I

wish to purchase

a

1-year subscription

to The Old-Time Herald for

Address
Enclosed

I

is

my check/money

wish to purchase

a

order for $15.00

1-year subscription

$18.00 (foreign)

to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

I

is my

check/money order for $15.00

wish to purchase

a

1-year subscription

$18.00 (foreign)

to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

is

my check/money

order for $15.00

$18.00 (foreign)

Send to: The Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717

Section with Illegible Text

is a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

wonderful gift

to give.

�THE

HERALD

OLD-TIME

INFORMATIVE!

PROVOCATIVE!

INSIGHTFUL!

INTERESTING!

A QUARTERLY MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO
THE SUPPORT AND PROMOTION OF

OLD-TIME MUSIC.
What readers are saying:
"The Old-Time

ISSUES IN OLD-TIME MUSIC
HISTORICAL AND CONTEMPORARY ARTICLES
ASK? UNCLE HAROLD HERE AND THERE
REVIEWS
DANCE BEAT PHOTOS

Herald-so

space, every issue
at our house. Keep

a

tar so good, no wasted
collectible and read cover to cover

up the

good work,"
John Hartford, Madison, TN

"The Old-Time Herald can help bring the national oldIt will
make sure this
time music community together
music continues into the future."

I""

had always hoped for something like this and I'm glad
it's here. My grandfather would be proud."
David Ramsey Macon, Greenbrier, TN

Dedicated

to the

memory of

the old-time musicians
Who have passed onAnd to those who are carrying It on
all

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a subscriber to
I wish to become
The Old-Time Herald for one year.

My

I

check

for $15.00 is

enclosed.

I
I

David Holt, Fairview, NC
"I

DYES!"

I

(Foreign subscriptions $18 U.S.)
OLD-TIME
The
HERALD, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717

Name

I-I

City

j

j

State

Zip

j
i
i

�PHOTO BONUS

Snuffy Jenkins &amp; Pappy Sherrill
read
THE
OLD-TIME

HERALD

Fiddler Pappy Sherrill and banjo player Snuffy Jenkins, have
been together for 50 years as professional musicians and
entertainers, and as friends. Jenkins' early Bluebird recordings are
considered by many historians to be among the first commercial
recordings using his unique three-finger style of banjo playing. His
Snuffy Jenkins Festival in Columbia, S.C. is an annual event. You
can bear Snuffy and Pappy on Rounder Records 0005 &amp; 0059.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12175">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 2, Number 1 (Fall 1989)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12176">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12177">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;; Volume 2, Number 1 (August-October 1989)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘Way Out West:’ Cowboy Songs &amp;amp; Singers,” by Bob Bovee&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Charles K. Wolfe – Bridge Builder,” by Patsy B. Weiler&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Johnson Family String Band: ‘Famous’ on Sand Mountain,” by Joyce Cauthen&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“A Musical Trip Through Southern Ontario,” by Lorrie Greenwood&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Country Music Foundation: Showcase for Old-Time Music,” by Patricia Hall&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – Jam Session Etiquette: Observations and Confessions,” by Craig Johnson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – James Kesterson’s Blue Ridge Mountain Dancers – Stepping between Tradition &amp;amp; Precision,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12178">
                <text>1989</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="971">
        <name>1989</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5533">
        <name>Bob Bovee</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5549">
        <name>Charles K. Wolfe</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5551">
        <name>Johnson Family String Band</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="3510">
        <name>Joyce Cauthen</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5552">
        <name>Lorrie Greenwood</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5550">
        <name>Patsy B. Weiler</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2521" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3447">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/49fafc52340b573d36131d4c4286585c.pdf</src>
        <authentication>121de4cdd89fee11b79f38637783c64a</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12179">
                    <text>November 1989

January 1990

^|OLD'TIME
A

Winter $4.50

-the

HERALH^

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

DWIGHT LAMB
A Western Iowa Fiddler
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�IT'S GONNA BE ANOTHER HOT WINTER
THIS YEAR!

k
V

DECEMBER 27,

I

989

JANUARY

GET READY FOR THE

FLORIDA

IN

I

I

990

2nd ANNUAL...

MICANOPE
MUSIC &amp; DANCE CAMP
The Second Annual
is right around the

Micanope Music

corner

Dance Camp

&amp;

start making your plans
to be the best ever.

so

This year's staff promises

today!

Keep the space cleared on your vacation calendar
and don't

miss the hottest event in the country this

KAREN

BILLINGS

PETE SUTHERLAND

RALPH BLIZARD
THE NEW SOUTHERN

RAMBLERS

j

GUMBO LIMBO
MILLIE ORTEGO

winter!

L.

J.SLAVI

N

BILL WELLINGTON

CLASSES

WORKSHOPS

&amp;

INCLODE:

KEVIN WIMMER
FRED

FIDDLE

(Old-time, Cajun, Swing, Applachian Longbow)

OLD-TIME
GUITAR

T. J.

PARK

WANGERMAN

THE ALTER-EGO STRING

BANJO

(Old-time, Cajun, Hawaiian)

BAND

TONY MARCUS

CAJUN ACCORDION

THE NATION S FINEST PERFORMERS
AND INSTROCTORS!

HAMMERED

Also. ..dances every night, constant jam

MANDOLIN

DULCIMER

OLD-TIME STRING BAND
SINGING
DANCE

(Individual Vocals

and

sessions,

3taff concerts, student showcase and dance,
an unforgettable New Year's Eve party. ..pi us all

Harmony)

(Squares, Contras, Swing, Cajun, Zydeco, Clogging

the other madness

that happens every year at Micanope!

MUSIC IMPROVISATION
DANCE CALLING

STORYTELLING
AUTOHARP
MUSICAL SAW

Registration includes

all

workshops, dances, concerts,

New Year's Eve

Party, cabin/tent space

meals. The Micanope Music &amp; Dance Camp is held in the heart of Ocala National Forest in
north central Florida. The weather is beautiful, the location is excellent and a good time is

and

guaranteed!

So, don't miss it. ..sign up now while space is still available!

FOR
BILL

PAINE, DIRECTOR

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

MORE INFORMATION CONTACT:

P.0.B0X12135

GAINESVILLE,

FL

32604

(904)495-2243

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Vol.

2

No.

2

FEATURES
100 ESSENTIAL OLD-TIME ALBUMS
by

D

WIGHT LAMB
An Interview

by

A

WESTERN IOWA FIDDLER

David A.

Bob Carlin with

Wayne Martin

accompanying article

by

14

Alice Gerrard &amp;
16

REMEMBERING KAHLE BREWER
by

10

B rose

WHIP THE DEVIL AROUND THE STUMP
The Story of the Helton Brothers
by

6

Kerry Blech

18

Craig Johnson

COLUMNS
Here &amp; There

3

The Dance Beat
Starting
by

a

Community Dance

4

Toni Williams

Workshop
20

Bowing Workshop
by

Brad Leftwich

"Valley Forge" fiddle tablature
Carl Jones

22

Ask Uncle Harold

23

by

Issues In Old-Time Music
Response to "Dare To Be Square" &amp; More Response to "Folklorists
&amp;.

Us"

24

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS

2

CLASSIFIED

28

REVIEWS

31

POETRY

by

Molly Tenenbaum

William

L.

Ward

9

13

�LETTERS
The

Old-Time Herald welcomes

letters.

They should be typed or neatly written, and
signed. They may be edited and we will print
them according to space available.
The
opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect
those of the Old-Time Herald.

From Other Countries:
Living north of your border, we find

ourselves somewhat isolated from the
American old-time music scene. came
1

friend's
home in Virginia last May. The articles
across

your

magazine

at

our

were extremely interesting and inform
ative and I found myself glued to its

pages one evening, or should I say well
into the morning. I'm looking forward
to your next issues over the coming year.

Arnie Naiman &amp;. Kathy Reid-Naiman
Aurora, Ontario, Canada

am interested in the music of Wade
Mainer, the Dixon Bros., Roy Hall, the
Morris Bros., and Jack &amp;. Curly Shelton
especially the Morris Brothers. I believe
that they are one of the most important
country duets. We must find out the
essentials of their music. The Morris
Brothers were most influential in early
bluegrass music. I would like to see an
article or up-to-date interview with the
I

Morris Brothers.

Tokuharu Takabayaski
Saitama, Japan

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�that could broaden their musical inter
ests to incorporate several forms of

Appalachian music." The band also
includes Bill Ellis, Larry Nager, and

&amp;

Here

There

Newsletters
Steppin'

lication

The North American Folk Music
and Dance Alliance (Folk Alliance)

The Blue Ridge Music Association,

In Time

by the

is a quarterly pub
Old-Time Music and

Dance Foundation, Inc.,

a non-profit
organization dedicated to the "preserva
tion, promotion, education and docu
mentation of traditional forms of Amer
ican music and dance." Jacky Christian
is the editor of the newsletter, and the
first issue which the OTH received con
tained an article on old-time fiddler,

Charlie Acuff,

and one on Joe

Hood,

old-time buck dancer, as well as other
items of interest. Write PO Box 381,
Madison, TN 37 1 16-0381 for information.
The Austin Friends of Traditional

Music publishes a newsletter, the Reel
Times, which contains information about
local music and dance events. Write to
AFTM, PO Box 49608, Austin, TX

78765.

is

Ray Sponaugle.

The Center for Southern Folklore
non-profit organization which "doc

a

uments the people and traditions of the
South." Their quarterly newsletter is
mailed free of charge to Center members
and supporters. For information write
the Center for Southern Folklore, 1216
Peabody Ave., PO Box 40105, Mem
phis, TN 38104.
From Pittsburgh, Pa. comes the Coal

newsletter published
the
Coal
by
non-profit
Country Tra
ditions, Inc., an organization "dedicated
to promoting and preserving traditional
American folk culture, especially that of
Western Pennsylvania and the Appal
achian Mountain Region." Dean Ben
jamin is the editor of the newsletter

Country Crier,

a

which publishes schedules of local events.

Write to PO Box 99191, Pittsburgh, PA
15233-4191 for information.
If you find yourself in Hong Kong, or

live there, or wish you were there

the

Hong Kong Folk Society publishes

a

newsletter, Singaround, with listings of
local event and radio programs. V alerie
Mindel (formerly of the west coastbased Any Old Time String Band) designs
and edits this attractive publication. For
more information write Sue Ellis, c/o
Hong Kong Society, GPO Box 4370,
Hong Kong.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

volunteer organization located in Galax,
Va., publishes a quarterly newsletter
which contains articles on local music
and dance events taking place in that
section of the Blue Ridge and neighbor
a

ing North Carolina Write to: BRMA
Newsletter, c/o DeaFelts, Rt 2 Box 487,
Hillsville, VA 24343, for information.

Happenings
you live in or near Berkeley, Ca., or
if you are going to spend time there you
may want to get on the mailing list for
If

the Freight &amp;. Salvage

Coffee House.

non-profit arts organization
and according to their flier they are the
"oldest acoustic music club in the Bay
Area, and the only full-time club on the
F &amp;. S is

a

W est Coast dedicated to preservingtraditional
music as well as acting as a forum for
new musical talent." Some folks who
have performed there include: Doc

Ira

Bernstein, Evo

Watson,

Sl Jimmy Blues-

tein, Lily May Ledford, Jody Stecher,
Kate Brislin, Eric Thompson,

Suzy

Thompson, Alan Senauke,

and many
also hosts an old-time jam.
Write 1111 Addison St., Berkeley, CA

others.

F

94702

or call

&lt;Sc

S

415-548-7603.

Blacksburg, Va. hosts

a

coffee

new

house, Gabriel's Psaltery, located in
Christ Episcopal Church on the corner
of Church and Jackson Streets. Part of
"ongoing outreach project," they are
open from 7:30-1 1 pm on the first Sun
day of each month, spring through fall.
an

Performers have included the Moun
tain Boomers, Jim Costa, Tina Hicks,
and
or

Mike Seeger. Call 703-552-2411

watch for local publicity.
Tony Ellis (whose record,

Dixie

was reviewed in the Fall 1989
OTH) has formed a new band, Tony
Ellis &amp; the Appalachian Travelers.
Based in Ohio, Tony writes about the

Banner,

group: "Having grown up in the moun
tains of western North Carolina and
southwest Virginia, I have been around
many forms of music indigenous to the
Appalachian region. After years of play
ing either bluegrass, old time, or folk, I

became interested in developing

a

group

stated in a letter of May 13, 1989: "Folk
music is still considered an unimportant
art form compared to 'serious' classical
music forms." The Folk Alliance "plans
to focus the collective power of hundreds
of folk organizations and thousands of
folk afficionados" to impact on the
established arts community to help cor
rect these false impressions. Their steer
ing committee includes (among others)
Margo Blevin (Augusta Heritage Arts
Workshop, Elkins, WV); Mark Moss
(The Sing Out Corporation, Bethlehem,
PA) Sonny Thomas (Fiddle Sc Bow
Society, Winston-Salem, NC); and Clark
and Elaine Weissman (California

Traditional Music Society, Tarzana, CA).
Anyone who wants information about
the Folk Alliance can contact Folk Alliance,
c/o Clark &amp;. Elaine Weissman, 4401
Trancas PL, Tarzana, CA 91356.

Congratulations

to fiddler

Jerry Lundy

player, Sue Stude, who
were married in Elkton, Md. on August
17. Jerry has played with Ted Lundy 's
Southern Mountain Boys, Bob Paisley's
Southern Grass, Fertile Dirt, Country
Ham, and others. We trust he and Sue
will make beautiful music together.
and autoharp

Two more legendary musicians have
passed away
significant losses to the
musical community. Bradly Kincaid
died on Sept. 24 1989, and Dennis
McGeeonOct. 2, 1989. Kincaid reached
thousands of folks through his early

recordings and renditions of traditional
songs; Dennis McGee was the famed
Cajun fiddler whose beautiful 1928
recordings with Ernest Fruge and Sady
Courville (reissued on Morningstar
Records) were some of the finest exam
ples of the Cajun fiddle duet tradition.
Dennis was very influential on many

including Michael Doucet,
founder of the group, Beausoleil, and
fiddlers

Jeanie McLerie,
Bayou Seco.
On Oct.

Foundation
inducted

1

1,

in

current

member

of

1989 the Country Music
Nashville, Tennessee,

Curly Fox and Texas Ruby
into the Walkway of Stars at the Coun
try Music Hall of Fame and Museum.
The husband and wife team performed
for 25 years before her death in 1936,
and Curly continues to be known for his
fiddle playing.

�The Dance
STARTING

A

COMMUNITY
DANCE
by

Toni Williams

Lexington,

Virginia, once enjoyed a
center for uniquely good
reputation
old-time music during the mid-to-late
1970s. It is curious that a regular dance
did not spawn from that scene, as fre
quently happens in such a community.
The passing years saw the dispersal of
many key musicians from the Lexington
area, and those who remained developed
careers, families,
responsibilities
resulting in a further curtailing of musi
cal events.
The first Rockbridge Mountain Music
as

and

a

Dance Convention

in

neighboring

Buena Vista, with two days and nights of
inspired music and square dancing, pro
vided the spark to start up a regular
mountain dance in our community. I
remember milling with a group of local
friends, tired but fired up from the
night's dance, wondering how we might
make square dancing happen for us.
That was the beginning, three years ago,
and my experiences as a part of that
group have given me some tips to pass on
to those who would like to start dancing
in

their community.

Planning.

The first step is to get a lot of help.
Invite anyone you and others can think
of who is eager to start dancing. It
requires quite a bit of planning to start
up and you want to avoid having too
much fall on one or two persons, as often
is
is

the case in group situations. Diversity
another key point in the planning, for

if your initial group consists of people
with a range of professions and acquain
tances you will have more connections

within the community.

Our group, which we called the Rock
bridge Rounders, was made up of eight
people, including a computer owner
(very handy for mailings), the parent of a
pupil at the school where we ended up
having the dances, and two aspiring
callers. All the members were capable
and eager, and we made good use of all
our resources.
The first task was to find

a

place to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Beat

dance, and everyone asked around. The
ideal hall would have a wooden floor and
lights that weren't too bright, of a size to
accomodate at least several sets but not
so big that it would swallow up those sets
it's better to fill up a small space than
to rattle around in an overly large one. It
should be centrally located, as many
people may not care to drive too far. We
were fortunate to obtain a school cafete
in Lexington for free, but had to
forego the ideal flooring and lighting.
We've stayed at this location all three
ria

years.

Many schools, if willing at all, require
janitor to be on duty during the dance,
and the overtime salary must be paid by
the dancers. Check into community cen
ters, civic organizations, and churches as
well, but it's likely that a hall will be your
a

first expense.

Next you must engage musicians.
Chances are that within your group are
some who are or who know musicians,
and they may be happy to help get things
started at first. But you'll want to avoid
asking the same musicians repeatedly,
for they may tire of playing for little or
nothing. Budding musicians would prob
ably be thrilled to play in such a comfor
table setting where they could get in a lot
of practice.
The Rounders had two semi-experienced
callers who were willing to revive their
rusty dances. While uncomfortable with
the responsibility of an entire evening of
calling, sharing it worked well. Eventu
ally a third new caller joined the two to
further ease the job.
Beginning dances offer an ideal, relaxed,
and unthreatening setting for new callers
to practice and polish their skills. We
usually have these local callers lead the
dance one month, and the next month
we bring in a more experienced caller
from out of town. Ask around in your
community about people who call, either
open-mike session might be a good way
to attract potential callers. Check with
dancers in neighboring communities for
the names of established and hopeful
callers too. I've found that experienced
callers are usually eager to help another
group get started by leading a dance or
two for a modest fee.
You'll probably want some sort of
sound system, unless you are striving for
just a couple of sets in a more intimate,

quiet setting. Beyond that, the caller and
musicians need amplification. Once again

our contacts helped us obtain free use of
a system for the first two years.
If you

can't piece together a system through
people you know then you'll have to buy
or rent one. I know of one group where
the original

six

founders each contrib

uted money to buy their system, and
today they occasionally rent it out to
help stay in the black.
Jobs
Once you've gotten the hall, musi
cians, caller, and sound system lined up,
you're ready to hold a dance. Here are
the jobs that need attention:
1
Write a press release for all the local
papers. Radio stations will announce the
happenings too
pay special attention
to those that air an old-time or bluegrass
show. Put up flyers or posters around
town, and you may want to try direct
mailings. For us, flyers through the mail
and newspaper releases brought in the
most people.
2. One or more people can work on
scheduling the musicians and callers. It's
helpful if the person knows some musi
cians and/ or the music well, as they can

coordinate

players whose

styles

and

energies mesh with each other and with
the caller's preferences. Scheduling well
in advance,
perhaps even getting the
whole year lined up, will reward you
with a comfortable sense of security.
3. Someone needs to open up the hall
early, set up a table, and have change
available.
4. You'll need a person to collect
money at the door. We have shared this
job among committee members, and
have also tried the occasional non-dancing
friend, or an older, responsible child. All
have been satisfactory.
5 We have one appointed person who
brings a cooler full of iced soft drinks
and box juices. Throughout the evening
dancers enjoy the refreshments and pay
on the honor system. We avoid providing
any other snacks as this would require

more planning and clean-up.
6. Unless you're paying a maintenance
person, you'll need to clean up and move
any furniture back. Many hands make
light work for these jobs. Take special
care with the clean-up since you'll be
using the facility again and again.
7. Your group will need a leader to

�steer the meetings and generally hold
things together. We elected a chairper
son, and try to re-elect each year to avoid

burn-out. You may want

vice-chair

a

person to assist with the duties.
8. Someone should be in charge of the
hence a treasurer.
money
9. You may feel the need for someone
to take notes of meetings and to keep

paperwork

straight, and if so you'll
appoint or elect a secretary.
Now you can see why I said that it
would take a lot of help to put on a
dance. But don't be intimidated. You
won't necessarily be bogged down with
details and bureaucratic paperwork, but
things will run more smoothly if the
group is organized and everyone has spe
cific tasks.

Other Considerations
How much are musicians and callers
paid? It depends entirely on the individ
ual and their interest in and support of
the dance effort. If your kitty allows it, a
token of 1 0.00 or so to each local musi
cian will show appreciation and allow
them to defray the cost of gas and/or
sitters. If you've hired a big name or
professional group though, you can
expect to be charged a substantially

higher fee. We get experienced callers
fairly close communities, for approxi
mately $60.00, but it will cost more if
they have to travel farther or have a pro

fessional reputation.
Scheduling should

very

carefully worked

low due to the large

number

Christmas activities. Instead, we hold
pot luck dinner and dance

home of

at

of
a

the large

pleasant alternative.
And don't schedule dances during school
breaks if you draw heavily from the col
a

friend,

I have seen
instances where the parents came just so
their children could dance. When child
ren are too young to pay attention, fol
low directions, or know their left from
right, it may disrupt the flow and enjoy
ment of the dances. We had a lot of kids
dancing without realizing that they were
inhibiting a more progressed and com
petent leve of dance until a guest caller
point it out. Personally, I prefer dancing
with adults, after working to plan a
dance and make my own babysitting

arrangements I'm not thrilled to find my

corner or contra neighbor a five-year-old
with left-right confusion.
This is a tricky question, and some
will be tied regardless of how it is
handled. Your group may benefit from
determining the direction it wants to go
in its dancing and how children fit into it.
What we did was to add a note to parents
on our flyers stating our policy when the
new season started in September. It

diplomatically

a

lege community.
You may not be able to use your hall
year around if it's at a school, which is
one reason why we don't hold dances
during the summer. Also, we feel that we
can use a break from planning, and that
attendance would be sporadic in the

busy summertime. Some groups con
tinue to hold dances during the summer,
perhaps in an outdoor pavilion or park
setting.
An issue that is likely to surface is that
of children at dances. Many of us have
children, quite a few of which are brought
along to dances. Often the kids attempt

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

said

ceived the dances
we

encouraged

that

as an

we

had

con

adult activity, so

children to form their

own seperate sets with parents helping
them. Several dances throughout the
everning would invite children to join
the whole group. This policy has worked
fairly well.

Another group

know of has the first
evening devoted to
children's dances. Then all the children
half hour
are

be

Check with the neighboring com
munity dances, if any, so that you don't
conflict with them. Generally one dance
a month is manageable, and stick to the
same night each month if possible, such
as the second Friday or last Saturday.
We avoid having a dance during
December, as attendance tends to Jse
out.

to join the adult dances, and

I

of the

taken across the street to the home of

babysitter. Such a convenient arrange
ment is probably difficult to come by,
a

however.
Then there's the possibility that unat
tended children may cause damage to the
hall or injury to themselves. In one dance
setting at a school,, the children fre
quently played in the hallway or lobby
while the adults danced inside. After an

unknown someone(s) knocked over a
glass display case, incurring several
hundred dollars worth of damage that
the group was responsible for, it didn't
too

take

long for

developed.
The question

a

set

policy

of money

to

arises,

be

and

how to build up a kitty so there will be
extra funds to maybe buy that sound

system,

or

to use in an

emergency,

or

special band and caller. We haven't
really found the answer. Being a rela
tively new group in a smallish commun
ity, we still are not on sound financial
ground. Use local talent frequently and
the expenses will be smaller, but don't
neglect to liven up your dances occa
sionally with the freshness of out-oftown callers and musicians. Don't be
slack on publicity, since the more people
that attend, the better the take (and the
hire

a

more fun). Word of mouth

is one of the
best devices, and be sure to invite new

friends and neighbors who may be seek
ing a way to meet people. You may con
sider raising money with a special concert.
One may wonder how a core of regu
lar dancers is formed. This evolves with
time and time alone. Until you've put in
that time, you'll see many one-timers
who've come to check it out, and at the
next dance there'll be new people doing
the same. Maybe just a few of those will
become regulars, and it may seem that
you'll never get beyond teaching the
grand right and left. But you will. Even
tually you'll have developed a group of
regulars, or core, that enjoys and inspires
each other and can assist in guiding new
comers. These are the ones to call upon
too when your committee is in need of
new blood.
One of the first things

I

did when our
a line to

group was forming was to drop
the neighboring dance groups,

telling
them about us and our first dance. A
short time later I received a phone call
from one of these dancers. "I just wanted
to tell you not to get

discouraged," she

advised in a friendly tone. Evidently she
knew the trials of getting started, for
there are ups and downs. There have
been times when we've all felt like throw
ing in the towel, or when I've felt person
ally responsible to the band for a poor
turnout. But these downs have been

countered

by the ups of

a

full and

exhi

larating dancing to good musicians and

the friendships that go hand in hand. So
above all, hang in there, and just do it!|
Toni Williams
Va.

is a

librarian in Glasgow,

�Holidays!

Happy

Biograph 6002: Unissued 78s
1930s field recordings of the Ward
circle of string band musicians from the

From time to time we are going to ask
reviewers (and others) to submit their lists of
"essential old-time albums. "For those people
starting an old-time music library, or casting

ters

about for additions, or looking for gifts, such
a list can be helpful. The first reviewer to
hazard a list is the reliable Kerry Blech, a
knowledgeable and long-time enthusiast and

It'll Never Happen Again/Goin'
(cassette only) Marimac
Uptown
Re-issues
of 78 rpm records
9110,9111:
of novelty string bands. (Winter '88)

player of old-time music-

Continue

musicians

support old-time music and
not taping
avail
buying

to

by

able recordings.

(Recordings reviewed in the OTH will
in parentheses.)
ed.

note the issue

100

Anthology

of

and (Camp Creek Boys)

patronize

American Folk Music

County 709,
"Through the

312:

This

Mt.

Elzic's Farewell

Kanawha 301:
French Carpenter was the premier fiddler
of Clay County, W.V. Recorded in
9.

1960s.

Ernie Carpenter "Elk River Blues"
Augusta Heritage 003: Recorded in
the mid-1980s; a strong, representative
West Virginia fiddler. (Winter '88)
Briar
1
Earl Collins "That's Earl"
4204: A great Oklahoma fiddler who
migrated to California. Excellent record
10.

1

Dykes Magic City Trio

Old

recordings

from 78s of an exciting east Tennessee
string band. (Spring '88)

Fields Ward's Buck Mountain Band
Historical 8001, and The Bogtrot-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Library of Congress L 65-66: Legendary
Marlinton, W.V. family of fiddlers, banjo
recorded in the
players, and singers
field.
West
Edden Hammons Collection
University Press: 1940s field
recordings of Hammons' 19th-century
18.

Virginia

fiddle style. (Spring '88)

19. Tommy Jarrell "June Apple"
Mountain 302; Joke on the Puppy
Mountain 310; Sail Away Ladies
County 756; Picking on Tommy's
Porch County 778; Rainbow Sign
County 791; Old-time fiddling guru
from Mt. Airy, N.C. (County 791, Fall

accompaniment by T om Sauber.
Clyde Davenport "Clydeoscope"

Southern Broad

20. Da Costa W oltz's

County 524: Popular 1920s
string band featuring Ben Jarrell (Tom
my's daddy) and Frank Jenkins.
casters

21. Earl Johnson
"Red Hot
Breakdown"
County 543: One of the
most exciting Georgia
bands to record in the 1920s.

wildest,

string

22. Bradley Kincaid "Favorite OldTime Songs" Vol. 2 Old Homestead

155: Smooth singer of story songs. A
radio favorite in the 1930s, these are
some of his 78s.
23.

EmmettLundy

field recordings

fiddler. As

far as

of
I

String 802: 1940s
legendary Galax
know this is out of
a

ing and

print.

12.

24. Uncle Dave Macon
County 521
and 545; Vetco 101, 105, and 108: The
first star of the Grand Ole Opry. Great

County 788: Recent recordings of a
great fiddle and banjo player from Mon
ticello, Ky. (Winter '88)

Earnest East, The Pine Ridge
County 718 and Her
Boys &amp;. Patsy
itage 29: A powerhouse Mt. Airy, N.C.
13.

string band with great vocals.
14. East Texas Serenaders
County
410: Golden age recordings of rags and
blues by an influential string band.
15.

'87)
age

Mountain

ia/Kentucky fiddler. (Summer '89)
1 7 Hammons Family "Shaking Down"
the Acorns
Rounder 0018, and

'87)

was one of the finest
string bands ever to record.

2. The Old-Time Way
Heritage 70:
Luther Davis, Roscoe Parish, Leone Par
ish; field recordings of Galax area musi
cians who played in '19th-century styles,'
made over the course of 20 years. (Fall

4.

Camp Creek Boys

8.

Airy/Galax band

(please

Homestead 191: Golden

Burnett and Rutherford "Ram

Years"

Folkways 2951, 2952, 2953: This is a
3-box set, two records each, assembled
by Harry Smith from 78s. It contains a
variety of traditional music styles as well
as old-time music.

3.

Pine Breeze 005 003 Field recordings
from the 1970s of East Tennessee fiddlers,
including Blaine Smith and Eldia Barbee.
Might be out of print.

from Monticello, Ky.

This list contains reissues of 78 rpm
records and field recordings of older
master musicians. I find these records to
be a good starting point for the serious
old-time music fan. A few of these titles
may be out of print but are well worth
the search. Most should be available at
local record stores. If you can't find
them, ask your record dealer to order the
titles for you. These records can also be
purchased via mail order from several

1

The Field-Traditional Fiddle
Music From Southeast Tennessee/ A
Bottle of Wine and a Ginger Cake
In

6.

Rounder 1 004:
78s of exciting fiddle-banjo- vocals duets

Kerry Blech

OTH advertisers).

Va. area.

5.

7.

ALBUMS

well-known sources

Galax/Independence,

bling Reckless Hobo"

ESSENTIAL OLD-TIME
by

and

The Bristol Sessions

CMF-011:

2-LP set of 1927 Victor recordings in

Tenn./Va.

including Carter
Family. Tenneva Ramblers, etc. (Spring,
Bristol,
'88)
16. Ed

Haley "Parkersburg Landing

Rounder 1010: Late 1940s home
recordings of a legendary West Virginc.

banjo playing and singing.
25. Eck Robertson
Sonyatone 201:
Complete 78 recordings of legendary
and influential Texas fiddler.
26. Skillet Lickers
County 506, 526;
Vetco 107; Rounder 1023; Best known
of Georgia string bands that recorded in
1920s. Had champion fiddlers Clayton
McMichen and Lowe Stokes.
27.

Appalachia

Vol.

The Old Traditions

&amp; 2 Home Made Music 001,
002: Recent field recordings made by
Mike Y ates of singers, fiddlers, and banjoists in the Blue Ridge Mountains.
28.

1

Round the Heart

Vols. 1-3

of Old Galax
Countv 533, 534, 535: Vin-

�tage 78s and field recordings of some of

Galax's finest musicians. (Winter '89)
29. Any record with Wade Ward on
it (Folkways mostly); great banjo player

from Independence, Va. "Uncle Wade,"

Folkways 2330

one.

is

30. A1 Hopkins and the Hillbillies
County 405: 78 reissues of string band
originally from Galax, Va. A bit more

urbane than other bands.

31. Fields Ward
the Lone Prairie"

"Bury Me Not on

Rounder 0036: 1970s

recordings of the great Virginia singer.
32. Roane County Ramblers
County
403: Golden age recordings of exciting
Tennessee string band featuring fiddler
Jimmy McCarroll.
33. Leake County Revelers
County
532: The most popular Mississippi string
band to record in the 1920s.
34. Grayson &amp;

Whitter

County 513,

Fiddlin' Arthur Smith Vols. 1 &amp;
County 546, 547: Great and influential
Tennessee fiddler backed by the Delmore Brothers.
45.
2

Riley

35.

a

must.

Buddy Thomas "Kitty Puss"

Rounder 0032: 1970s recordings of the
great northern Kentucky fiddler.
36. Kessinger Brothers
County 536:
78 reissue of great West Virginia fiddler
Clark Kessinger.

Hell Broke Loose In Georgia/Georgia Fiddle Bands Vol. 2 County
514, 544: Anthologies of Georgia string
37.

bands from the 1920s.

Ridin' In An Old Model T-County 548: 78 reissues anthology of
blues, rags, etc. performed by string
48.

bands. (Fall '87)

West Virginia Hills/Home in
West Virginia Old Homestead 141,
49.

177: Vintage 78 performances by
iety of West Virginia artists.
50. Virgil Anderson
County
Great Kentucky banjo player and

1

&amp; 2 County 507, 527: Anthologies of
classic old-time fiddling from the 1920s.
39. Old

Time String Band Classics

County 531: Anthology of classic

1

920s

string bands.

Fiddlers Convention in Moun
tain City County 525: Anthology of
40.

1920s string bands.

4

1

Rounder

1

03

7

Kentucky string band and solo perfor
mances from the 1920s and 30s. Selected
by Charles Wolfe.

Doc Roberts
Davis Unlimited
33015 and County 412: Non-pareil
42.

western Kentucky
'20s and '30s.

fiddler

recorded

in

43. Wonderful World of Old Time
Fiddlers Vols. 1 &amp;. 2 Vetco 104, 106:
Anthologies of classic old-time fiddlers

from 78 recordings.

var

My Dog Got
New World Records 226: Anthol
ogy of a variety of old-time music.

The Watson Family Folkways
2366 and Rounder 129: 1960s record
ings of Doc Watson, Gaither Carlton,
Arnold Watson, Rosa Lee Watson, etc;
66.

instrumental
67 Old Time Music at Clarence Ash
ley's Vols. 1 &amp; 2 Folkways 2355,

great singing and

69.

1970s.

Clawhammer Banjo/More.
Vol. 3 County 701, 717, 757: Record
52.

ings from the

1960s and 1970s.

Music of Grayson &amp;. Carroll
Counties/Band Music From...
53.

3832: String bands,
solo performance field
recordings recorded in Virginia in the
1960s.

Folkways

3811,

bluegrass

and

68.

Rounder 0028:

High Atmosphere

mountain music.

ful

Holcomb and Wade

Roscoe

Ward

Folkways

2363:

Classic

and

influential recording of one of Kentucky's
finest singers and banjo players, and the
legendary Virginia banjo player, Wade
Ward.
70. Roscoe Holcomb "High Lone
some Sound"/"Close To Home"
Folkways 2368, 2347: Great soaring

Visits Heritage 33: Ray Alden's
recordings of old master musicians and
young whippersnappers. (Spring '88)

vocals and passionate banjo picking.
71- Stripling Brothers
County 401:
Some of the greatest fiddling put on
from Alabama.
78

55. Omer Forster
Davis Unlimited
33037. Great Tennessee banjo player.

Folkways 2317: Field recording anthol

56. Smokey Valley Boys
Rounder
0029: Champion Mt. Airy string band
recorded in the 1970s, featuring fiddler
Benton Flippen.

Franklin

George "Music For
Kanawha
Fiddle, Banjo, Bagpipes"
307: Influential West Virginian, re
corded in 1960s.

58. Van

Kidwell "Midnight Ride"

Vetco 502, 506: Exciting Kentucky fiddler
backed by the Hot Mud Family.
59.

Rufus Crisp

Folkways 2342: Unique
Kentucky banjo player and singer recorded
in

the 1940s.

60. Dock Boggs "Original Records"
Folkways RBF 654: 1920s recordings
of powerful Virginia banjoist and singer.

from
popular all-women string band
1940s featuring Lily May Ledford.
(Winter '89)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

65. That's My Rabbit,

in

County

505, 509, 516, 540: Classic '20s and
'30s performances by great showman,
from Spray,

64.

John Cohen's field recordings of power

Ashby

61.

picker

Anthology

music and early bluegrass.

727, 745,
773: Northern Virginia fiddler recorded

recordings. (Winter '89)

Charlie Poole and the North
Carolina Ramblers V ols. 1 -4 County
and banjo

World

of old-time

2359: features Doc Watson, Clarence
Ashley, Clint Howard, and Fred Price.

vocal

44.

singer,
N.C.

New

777:

57.

Kentucky Country

a

54.

38. Old Time Fiddle Classics Vol.

Home

and
225:

It

51. John

Carolina music

Records

culled from 78s.

Banjo Picking Girl Rounder 1029:
Anthology of women in country music

ist, recent

B.

exciting

Hills

63.

47.

Gray

son's

157, 165: G.

Old

New World
Records 245: Anthology containing large
variety of old-time music.

New
Going Down the Valley
World Records 236: Anthology of a var
iety of old-time music.

fiddling and powerful
singing make these 78 reissues of North

Old Homestead

Puckett

Homestead
114, 174; County 411; Roots 701: 78s
of legendary Georgia vocalist also wellknown for his "fancy" guitar work.
46.

62. Oh My Little Darlin'

Coon Creek Girls "Early Radio
Favorites"
Old Homestead 142: First

Mountain Music of Kentucky

72.
ogy.

73. Fiddle Band Music From Ken
tucky Vols. 1-3 Morning Star 45003,
45004, 45005: Rare Gennett 78s of
string bands, banjo, and fiddle.

Great

74-

Big

Yam Potatoes

Mississippi Dept. of Archives and His
tory 002: Library of Congress field
recordings from the late 1970s of great
fiddling from Mississippi. (Spring '88)
75.

Traditional Fiddle Music

sissippi

Vols.

1

&amp;

2

of

Mis

528,
'20s and

County

529: Fiddle bands recorded
'30s.

in

I'm Old But Awfully Tough
Missouri Friends of the Folk Arts 1001:
1970s field recordings of fiddlers and
singers from Missouri.
76.

N ashville-Ear ly String Bands V ols.
2
County 541, 542: Reissues of
78s of Uncle Dave Macon, McGee Bros.,
Binkley Bros., Theron Hale, etc.
7 7
1

&amp;

�78. Seems Like Romance To Me
Gambier Folklore Society 901: 1980s
field recordings of Ohio fiddlers. (Win
ter '88)

Old Five String Heritage 39:
Anthology of younger banjo players.
80. Old Originals Vols. 1 &amp; 2
Rounder 0057, 0058: 1970s field record
79.

fiddle music from
ings
southwest V irginia made by Tom Carter
and Blanton Owen.
of banjo

and

81. Old Time Fiddlers Rerpertory
Univ. of Missouri Press: Recordings
from '40s and '50s of fiddling, featuring
Bob Walters, Bill Driver, and others.
82. Echoes of the Ozarks Vols. 1-3
County 518, 519, 520: Reissues of 78
recordings featuring Pope's Arkansas
Mountaineers, Carter Bros. &lt;Sc Son, Bob
Larkin, etc.

Tennessee Strings

Rounder 1033:
Anthology of Tennessee string band
music from 78s as selected by Charles
Wolfe.
83.

84. Texas

Farewell

85. American Fiddle Tunes
Library
of Congress L62: Field recordings selected

annotated

86.

E.

0026:

C.

by

Alan Jabbour.

and Orna Ball

Great singers

from the 1970s.

Rounder

from Rugby,

Va.

Blue Sky Boys County 752:
Influential brother duet from the '30s.
87.
88.

Whence bluegrass sprang
and mandolin playing.

great singing

Fine Times At Our House
Folkways 3809: Anthology of 1960s
field recordings of Indiana fiddlers and
singers, including John Summers.
97.

Time Southern Dance Music
Vols. 1-3-- Old Timey 100, 101, 102:
98. Old

Reissue anthology of 78 recordings of
string bands.

99. Benny Thomasson
County 724:
Great Texas fiddler who "invented" modern

contest-style fiddling

from late 1960s.

Melvin Wine "Cold Frosty
Morning" Poplar LP1: 1970s record
100.

ing

of great

Braxton

fiddler.

County,

W.

V.

Fiddlin' John Carson

Rounder

1003: Great Georgia showman sings and
fiddles solo and fronts a wild string band
from the 1920s.

Delmore Brothers County 402:
'30s recordings of hot Alabama brother
duet.

Traditional Music from the Cumber
land Plateau, Vol. 1. "Gettin' Up the
Stairs" County 786; Vol. 2 "Five Miles
Out of Town"
County 787; Field re
cordings of Kentucky and Tennessee
musicians such as John Sharp, Clyde
Ralph and Clyde
and much more. (Fall '88).

Davenport,

90.

Traditions
recordings

6000 and 6002:

Country Turtle

Bluesy brother duet
singing, playing, and social commentary.
Rounder 1007:
91. Frank Hutchison
Great West Virginia singer and guitarist
recorded from 78s.
92. Sam And Kirk McGee
stead: Guitar leads, banjo,

Old Home

fiddle, fun
Tennessee brothers

songs from these
who were early Grand Ole Opry main
stays.

Red Fox Chasers
County 510:
1920 recordings of Low Gap, N.C. string
band noted for fine singing.

93.

94. Blind Alfred Reed

Rounder 1001:

West Virginia fiddler and vocalist of
1920s noted for commentary on social
issues.

95. Doc Watson, Clint Howard, Fred

Price "Old Timey Concert"

Van

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The following are addresses and/or
if and where you
can get hold of the recordings listed
above:
Augusta Heritage Center, Davis &amp;.
Elkins College, Elkins, WV 26241-3996.

information regarding

Records

Folkways

Roundup

Records (address below) has an inventory
of all available Folkways albums. When
these are gone the only ones that will be
reissued are the better selling ones. Write
Roundup for a catalog. However, all the
rest of the Folkways titles (1500 or so)

available

are

cassette

demand through
operation, and will
on

tape

a

be

recorded from the original masters. For
more information, or for a catalog, write
Smithsonian Folkways Recordings, 416
Hungerford Dr., Suite 320, Rockville,
MD 20850, or call 301-443-2314.

Historical

Since this article was first assembled, a
number of excellent recordings have
been issued. Most have been reviewed in
the OTH, but several deserve special
mention here as addenda, rather than
pushing some other worthy recording
out of the above "100"
K.B.

89.

Dixon Brothers

HAPPY LISTENING!

and

Biograph

are

out of

business and out of print. County has

County 517: Reissue

anthology of Texas fiddling on 78.

and

107/108: Concert from the 1960s
great fiddling, singing and guitar picking.
96. Monroe Brothers "Feast Here
Tonight" RCA Bluebird (out of print):
guard

Possum Up
'88)

Carlie

Troxell,

A Gum Stump
Alabama
103: Commercial and field
of Alabama fiddlers. (Fall

Marion

&amp;

Andy

Cahan

"Going Across the River to Hear My
Marimac 9018; Old-time
Banjo Ring"
banjo and fiddle from Elkin, N.C.; recent

recording.
Library of Congress Banjo Collection
Rounder 0237: Field recordings made
from 1937-1946.

Southwest Virginia Blues

Blue Ridge

Institute 008: Reissues, etc., featuring
Dock Boggs, Carter Family, and others.
Dix Freeman and the Toe-Nail Gap
String Band "Step Back" Spudchucker Recordings: Round Peak String
Band Music featuring Freeman's fretless
banjo. (Fall '89)
Melvin Wine "Hannah at the Spring
House"
Marimac AHS2: West Virginia
fiddler from Braxton County.

some of the albums, but very few, and
none of the ones listed here.
Pine Breeze: Last known address for
this label (and it is probably out of busi
ness) was Pine Breeze Center, Hamilton
Ave., Chattanooga, TN 37405.

Mountain

Record Co.

is handled by the Heritage
Mountain 312 is still in

print.

Kanawha

out of business. County
some of their records
including #301. You may be able to
order Kanawha 307 by writing Frank
George, Rt. 5, Walton Star Route,
is

has the rights to

Spencer, WV 25276.
Briar has been leased and business is
in the process of re-negotiation. Probably
not available.

Library of Congress catalog is avail
able. Write Library of Congress, Archive

of

Folk

Culture,

M/B/RS

Washington, D.C. 20540.

String

Division,

was an English label and

is

out

of print.

Vetco albums are out of print.
Home Made Music albums are pro

bably out of print
County Records has
some of them in stock.
Davis Unlimited's Stephen Davis
(also the editor of the Devil's Box) writes
that he will supply cassette copies of
recordings to interested readers if they

will supply the cassette and pay the pos
tage. Write to him c/o The Devil's Box,
1524 Washington, Emporia, KS

66901-5524.

Morning Star,
Records,

37

is a

division of Shanachie

Clinton, Newton, NJ
07860. #73 will be re-issued on CD and
cassette, hopefully, by December. No
E.

more of the albums are being pressed.

continued on page 44

�OTIS BURRIS
1917--

1989

Galax, Virginia, lost another
musician and friend on Sept. 20,
1989 when Otis Burris passed away
at his home in Galax.
Known for his fast and beautiful
breakdown fiddling, his trademark

tune was the old "Fortune," which
was recorded along with several
others on the classic County re
cording, Virginia Breakdown (County
705). A member of the Galax
band, the Mountain Ramblers, from
1962-'67, he helped crystallize the
driving fiddle-tune sound of that
band, winning countless ribbons
for both his fiddling and his flat-

foot dancing.
Otis had a great influence on
younger fiddlers who came into

contact with him during the 1960s.

One of these, Hank Bradley, elo
quently expressed his feelings about
Otis in his "Personal Reminiscence,"
published in the Spring 1989 OldTime Herald: "Otis gave me no les
sons, but did say that if you're
going to play the fiddle, do so,
never mind being bashful.
He
once offered to trade me his shorter fingers for my longer
ones, which I'd cheerfully have
done. Mine danced with wishful
thinking to their own uncertain
sounds, while his made real music."
--Alice

Gerrard

We would especially like to thank
John Currie for his donation of a copy
machine to the Old-Time Music Group,
Inc. John is a musician who lives in Jack
sonville, N.C.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Introduction
Some of the most vibrant and perva
sive traditional arts are born and perpet
uated in regions that act as "crossroads;"

"cultural conduits" where diverse eth

nic, occupational, or social groups and
their traditions interact. Iowa enjoys

such

a

status.

Scandinavians

are the

second largest

ethnic group in Iowa, followed in sheer

numbers by German-Americans. There
fore, although one can speak of a shift in

southern-to-northern

and

eastern-to-

western traditions in Iowa, a core of
Germanic and Scandinavian peoples have
provided a stable presence in agricultu
rally

subsistence-based communities

throughout Iowa for well over a century.
Dwight Lamb is a 55-year old Postal
Service employee and fiddler/ accordionist
from Onawa, Iowa. The following inter
view, transcribed and edited from taped
conversations with Dwight and his
accompanist, Elvin Campbell, contains
indications of the influences that helped
to shape Lamb's repertoire and style.
Dwight learned to play the accordion
from his maternal grandfather, acquiring
a

Dwight

Lamb

A

encounter

David A.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

friendship

deepened his appreciation and under
standing of the intricacies of the regional
style. Finally, radio and recordings have

Interview
by

subsequent

ters

FIDDLER
An

and

with master fiddler "Uncle" Bob Wal

Iowa

Western

large repertoire of Danish traditional

dance tunes from him in the process.
Though Dwight no longer remembers
the specific titles of many of the Danish
tunes and refers to them generically as
the "6/8 Danish tunes," one favorite he
calls "The Feens Polka." Family tradition
holds that "Feens" is an island off the
coast of Denmark.
From his father Dwight was exposed
to the hornpipes, hoedowns, and other
tunes typical of fiddlers' repertoires in
the upper midwest. Dwight's later

Brose

supplemented the knowledge which Dwight
has received from the primary sources of
family and community.

It is his great enthusiasm and attention
to stylistic detail which has made Dwight,
or "Red," as many of his friends know
him, one of the truly respected and

fiddlers of the upper mid
west. There can be little doubt that
"Uncle" Bob Walters' fiddle legacy lives
on in Dwight Lamb, or that Dwight him
self will continue to act as a master for
the transmission of skills and repertoire
to the younger fiddlers he encounters.

influential

�"I was born at Moorehead, Iowa, over
here in 1934 and then my folks moved in
'37 and we lived here (Onawa, Iowa) til
'48, eleven years, and then we moved
back to Moorehead for a few years. My
dad's brother had a farm over there and
he was sick and he couldn't farm and my
dad went back over there, farmed that
place for him for about four years 'til he
got his health back. And then we moved
over here to Onawa, Iowa, in '53 and
we've lived here ever since. My dad died
in 1980, my mother's still alive. Dad was

pretty good fiddle player and he was
Elvin and my best fan when we made our
records. He'd go out and peddle them
things. He'd drive all over the country
selling our records"
a

Dwight's first musical influences came
from within his home and immediate family.
When discussing his musical experiences, he
always pay homage to his maternal
grandfather.
will

"Yeah

buttonbox

sir,

instrument.

was

my

first

would have been 12 when
my grandfather on my mother's side
moved in with my parents in 1946. And
he

played

I

he'd play

every

night ya'

know, and dad would too. And I don't
was intrigued by that accordion
know,
I

and that's what

I

started first. And he

(grandfather) encouraged me and helped
me

a

lot

he was about the best

accor

dion player I ever heard.
"Most of his repertoire was Danish
but then he learned a lot of the older
tunes like they play around here now,
like the hornpipes: "Fisher's Hornpipe,"
and "Rickett's Hornpipe," "Soldier's Joy,"
"Turkey in the Straw," and "Listen to the
Mockingbird" and all those types of things
he played that he learned after he got
over here to the U.S. but I've sure for
gotten a lot of them over the years, too. I
always thought when I was younger that
I'd record them just to keep them, so I
don't forget them. Didn't do it 'cause I
thought, 'Well, I'll never forget 'em,' but
you do."

Denmark. He was from Hjoring in north
ern Denmark. When he came over here
his name was Chris Christensen like
about 100,000 other Christensens that
came over here, so he changed his name
to Jerup: there was a town in Denmark

"My grandad used to play for neigh
we lived over in

borhood dances. When
the hills,

a lot of times in the winter we'd
maybe get snowed in for a week, you
know, before the maintainers and stuff
would get out and open the roads. We'd
walk to the neighbors and the kids would
play games and different things, and the
parents would dance. And my grandad
and my dad would play for the dances
and once in a while they'd hook me into
playing a few numbers, but I wasn't that
anxious."

right near where he was from by that
name.
"His father was a violinist. He played a
lot of weddings and dances and he always
went by 'the fiddler from Jerup,' so my
grandfather took the name of Jerup to

keep from being confused and getting all
his mail and everything else mixed up
with everybody else.
"A friend that had grown up with him
over there in Hjoring, Denmark, hap

pened to settle in Turin,

I

Supplementing

don't know

but he did, and he wrote to my
grandad that there was work over here
and grandad had been wanting to come
to this country anyway, so he took the
boat to New York and took the train to
Turin. So he was back over there (Den
mark) after he came here the first time.
I'm not sure what year he did go back. I
why

assume

it

toire from many local and regional radio
stations during the early years of "country
music" broadcasts.

"My dad was born over here

head, Iowa. He's

a

year

I

or '95. He
think before he

went back."
The influence of Dwight's grandfather
which came through the immediate homeplace was further enhanced by community
events held at private homes in and about the

Lamb's northwestern Iowa community:

of my life

as

grew up."

I

'40s and early '50s. Shenandoah, Iowa,
boasted two country music stations which
held a large stable of local and regional
talent. Station KM A of Shenandoah pre
sented

a

large Saturday night concert held

public at the City Auditorium in
Iowa. A second, KFNF,
would sponsor performances with simul
taneous live broadcasts, including fiddle
contests. A Shenandoah resident, Connie
Gibson, wrote regular articles for a popular
journal, The Mountain Broadcast And
Prairie Recorder, during the later 1940s
and early 1950s. For her January, 19 47
entry, Ms. Gibson listed the following as
before the

Council Bluffs,

many Scandinavians and other
Europeans, Dwight's maternal grandfather
came to Iowa with financial sponsorship
from relatives in "the old country," returning
later for his wife and family.

"He came over from Denmark in 1893.
He had some friends over here in Turin,
Iowa. It's a town of about 50 people

Lamb

performers on KMA's "Corn Belt Jamboree:"
Lou Black is MC and the audience

courtesy

Dwight

now, but I suppose maybe at the biggest
it might have been 150. They helped him
get over here and he got a job and saved

photo

up

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Moore

a

Western Iowa was a regional center for
live country music broadcasts in the 1930s,

Like

enough money to go back and get his
wife and the oldest boy. The rest of the
family, like my mother, was born in this
country, but the oldest boy was born in

at

fiddler player and I do
say he was a pretty good one. He played a
lot of the old tunes. He learned most of
his off the radio ya' know, like I did to
start with. He loved that old-time music.
Like I say, my grandfather was with us
and we always had an organ and after
supper we always had music. My mom
would play second for either my dad or
my grandad 'til I got started playing and
then she'd play for all three of us. Some
times we'd just sit around and play alone
but we always had music, some music,
every night. And it was just kind of a part

probably was 1894

was over here

initial musical tradi

the

tions which Dwight received from his mater
nal grandfather were the influences from his
own father's music. Dwight's father was a
fiddler, and learned a great deal of his reper

Grandfather Chris Jerup, taken

in

1939

is

continually

kept

in

stitches

by

his dry humor. The musical end of
the show leaves nothing to be

desired.

Morgan
harmony

Folk

songs

by

Jimmy

yodels and sparkling
by

the

West Sisters

Classical Westerns
inimitable style

are

in

his

own

presented

by

�'That
Woodin

Smiling
real

Chap'

Steve

toe-tapping accor

dions by Jerry Fronek, many of
the
them his own compositions
serious and quietly presented sacred
songs and grand old hymns of The
Goodwill Trio, made up of Zeke
and Joanne Williams with daugh
ter

Victoria Lee, blending their
in sweet harmony. The

voices

Hawaiian music from the guitar of
Wayne Van Home, waft you right
to those sunny isles, and then
you're brought back to earth by
the side splitting comedy of Elmer
(Fred Warren) Axelbender, followed
by the cleverly arranged Western

songs of Uncle Zeke and his Ram
bling Cowboys.

The above excerpts from Ms. Gibson's
submission to The Mountain Broadcast

And Prairie Recorder give the reader a
sense of the entertainment popular to regional
audiences in the upper midwest. The per
formers represented many country music

genres popular during the post World War
II years,
including Hawaiian influenced
steel guitar (dobro) pieces, gospel music,
folk songs, western music by the West Sisters
and Uncle Zeke and His Rambling Cowboys,
and the accordian music long popular to
midwestern audiences via old world roots in
Europe and Scandinavia. A Ithough no fiddles
or fiddlers were mentioned in this particular
submission by Connie Gibson, the role of
local fiddlers on KMA and KFNF cannot
be overstated. Dwight Lamb fondly recalls
the

fidding

he heard

during his youth.

"Shenandoah was probably the broad
casting capitol of Iowa. They had two
radio stations there, KMA and KFNF.
One of them was owned by Earl May and

raised across the river
Nebraska, and then when

them times. I played a couple concerts
down there since then. Of course, when I
was a kid radio was a big thing. Every
station probably had four or five musi
cians. And that was a sad thing when that
ended. But the record industry took care
of that, you know. And I can't, in a way, I
don't understand that. 'Course there's a
lot of money there in them records for
them radio guys. But, you'd have thought
some of the local musicians unions would
have fought that a little harder and tried
to keep a few of the local musicians. But I
suppose they didn't have the power or
the money to fight one of those big
recording companies. They sent them
the records, I'm sure they sent them free.
So why should they hire local musicians
when they can get this music, you know,
the big names free. It's a sad thing for the
little musicians. It forced a lot of them
out of work I'm sure."

fiddling was really his life.

through

his

inclusion

Old-Time

in

If he

hap

pened to think of a fiddle tune that he'd
heard the night before he'd wheel his
horses back in and run in and practice
the tune until he was satisfied with it so
he didn't forget it. They didn't have the
advantages we got today
tape recorders
and sheet music and everything. When
they heard a tune they had to try to
remember that thing and learn it. That's
kinda' the way I started out, and Elvin
too. Hear a tune and you'd hope you'll
hear it again before too long. If you
didn't you might write in a request to the
radio and ask them to play it again and
then you had it stored in your head 'til
you could learn it."

Usually supplementing the music that one

Christeson's The
Repertory.

Decatur,

knew him he
was retired from radio and he lived in
Takema, which is 16 miles south of
there. He played; and he farmed until the
bad drought there in the '30s when a lot
of farmers went broke, and he went
broke farmin'. Then he started fiddlin'
over the radio down in Shenandoah, and
in Lincoln, Nebraska, and finally wound
up in the last 10 years or so playing
Grand Island, Nebraska, until records
took over and they took all the live talent
off most all the radio stations. Then he
retired and moved back to Takema. But
his heart really wasn't in his farming

hears at home are the musicians from the
community who leave lasting impressions.
For Dwight Lamb, the most influential
community musician was "Uncle Bob
Walters, no doubt known to many OTH

readers

in
I

R.P.

Fiddler's

"(Walters) was quite the fiddle player.
He died in 1960. I think I knew him for
about six years. He's the one that really
got me started fiddlin'. He had a reper
toire that I think was unequalled in all
he could play anything
types of music
wanted
from
ballroom to square
you
dances to quadrilles. He was born and

to define Western Iowa (and
own) fiddle style, Dwight responds:

When asked
his

"Well, for one thing, I think we play
faster than, say Texas, because we dance
faster. If you get down and watch the
Missouri square dancers, the way I play

was by Henry Fields. Henry
Fields used to put on some big fiddlin'
contests on KFNF and they both had a
lot of live talent. The Everly Brothers
and their folks were there for years.
There's a lot of them that ended up in
Nashville and started right there in She

the other

nandoah. They had their 60th anniver
KMA-- 1925 to 1985. July 20th
of '85 is when we (Dwight with Elvin)
won that open contest down there. And

sary at

Henry Fields I assume came on the air
earlier or about the same time. Anybody

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

David

A.

Brose

in and play if they

by

welcome to come

went down there. I know my grandad
went down, someone took him down
years ago and he played on the accor
dion. And then my dad went down and
fiddled on the radio station there. If you
came, they'd put you on. Of course they
had their studio musicians, they always
had someone to back you up, ya' know. I
was never fortunate enough to get in on

photo

was

Dwight Lamb

&amp;.

Elvin Campbell

�that "Lantern in the Ditch" would be just
about the right speed for the square

dancers down in Missouri. A good peppy
square dance, and they jig (clog) as they
dance. Y ou know, if they're not swinging
their partner they're standin' there while
the others are, and they're jiggin'. I really
enjoy them square dances down there.
So many of the square dances anymore,
they use records you know, and the sing
ing calls. W ell, that isn't old-time square
dance. If you see the oldtimers square
dance it's a sight, you know, they really
put on a show and they enjoy it. But 1
think we play faster, we're not worried
about how many notes we put in and we
don't worry about a lot of double stops,
especially in our hoedowns. The Texas
fiddlers they slow it down more and see
how many notes they can roll out of
there, and a lot of double stops and
things that we don't do. I don't know,
some of that Texas music that I listen to,
well, you can take "Forked Deer" or any
of them, "Sally Johnson," they play it so
slow, in order to get that many notes and
that much variation
the variation they
get, you couldn't play it up to square
dance time. It's good listenin'
I enjoy
listenin' to Texas fiddlin', but I never
liked it well enough that I thought I
wanted to taint my style by trying to play
that. 'Cause it could ruin you. I think it
could. I don't know, that's just my opin
ion. You'd get to where you'd lose some
of your bow licks. I worked too many
years to try to figure that out."
the

Lest we forget the all important second to
fiddler we shouldn't close without some

from Dwight Lamb's guitar
accompanist and friend of 20 years, Elvin
remarks

Campbell.

"Most of my life I've been around
music. Tried to be. My main instrument
was fiddle when I started out when I was
eight years old. I did try to play some
I know how
to,
guitar about that time
you know, had an idea how to. But when
I got to be
13, 14 years old I found out
that girls wore skirts, you know, so I quit
fiddling. I never picked up a fiddle 'til the
day I met Dwight in 1965. And that's a
lot of years that I didn't pick it up. And I
thought I could play. I got hold of a
fiddle and I couldn't even scratch out a
tune. Period. I got with Dwight and
started play in' backup guitar again. Well,
I played
guitar before I met him, but I
was playin' lead guitar in the band, ya'
know. In a Western band. Well, Coun
try and Western band. We played Tremont (Nebraska) and Omaha. I didn't
do no swing stuff. Just regular old coun
try music stuff, full band with a singer.
And that's what I done for years. And
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

when

finally,

I

started

the reason I'd
Dwight's two, three, four
Tryin' to learn them tunes
forgot 'em. And I forgot
again, that'

fiddle

playin'

s

run up here to

times

a

week.

again 'cause I
how to play.
Period. Then I started comin' up here
with a bluegrass band, playin' bluegrass
and that kinda' old-time bluegrass
there's a difference. And it'll kinda' ruin
ya' in

a

way. And

1

like bluegrass music,

old-time bluegrass, good bluegrass. I
don't like this contemporary bluegrass.
don't like it at all. learned a lot from Bill
Monroe, and Jim and Jesse. That's the
I

I

kind of bluegrass that I like. I played a lot
of stuff in the old band that I didn't like
to play. But I got to learn to like them. I
used to have to play lead guitar to "Up
the Lazy River," "Five Foot Two," and all
that stuff. Well, you take that "Five
Foot," that's a long time. That's a way
years. That come out before I was even
born, I think. And they played that back
in Chicago in the '20s ya' see. They did
the Charleston to it." M

David A. Brose was born into a musical
central Ohio family in 195 1. His mother,
Betty, was a fiddler and his father, Albert,
an accomplished button accordionist of
Germanic heritage. He has authored several
documentary record albums, and more than
fifty radio vignettes broadcasts. Currently,
he is Director of Community Arts and Cul
tural Heritage Programs at the Iowa Arts
Council.
"I

wish

to

thank Mary A.

Z

wolinski, Cul

tural

Heritage Coordinator/Iowa Arts
Council, for her help in the transcription of
interviews utilized for this article, and for
the team fieldwork which we conducted with
Dwight and Elvin at Dwight's northwestern
Iowa home"
D.B.

[We hope to have transcriptions of
some of Mr. Lamb's tunes in a future
issue.]

�WHIP THE DEVIL
AROUND THE STUMP
THE STORY
of

the

HELTON BROTHERS

by

Bob

Carlin

is dedicated to Charity Gates,
who kept her memories of Osey Helton alive
B.C.
all these years

This article

Among

Collection

fans of Appalachian fiddling,
many geographic areas are legendary for
producing large crops of master fiddlers.
Galax, Virginia; Mt. Airy, North Carol
ina; Salyersville, Kentucky; and Atlanta,
Georgia are just a few of those areas that
are well-documented centers of old-time
fiddling. An area that has never been

Lamar

Lunstord

fully acknowledged or had its particular
fiddle style examined is western North
Carolina/Eastern Tennessee. This over

Hill

Photo

Archives,

Bascom

sight will be remedied in an upcoming
album/booklet package featuring fiddlers
from that region such as Manco Sneed,
Dedrick Harris, Marcus Martin, Bill
Hensley, and Osey Helton. Of all these
musicians, Osey Helton and his brother
Ernest were probably the most active

their part in the Carolina-Tennessee fid
dling tradition.
The major source of the pool of tunes
and techniques common to the fiddlers
mentioned above is possibly Bob Taylor,
the fiddling governor of Tennessee. It
should be noted that Robert Love Tay
lor (1850-1912) was also mentor to the

young John Carson of Georgia and so
loosely ties Carson to his fiddling neigh
bors

to

the

north.

mation on Taylor's

(For

more

relationship

infor

with

John Carson, see Fiddlin' Georgia Crazy
by Gene Wiggins). Dedrick "J.D." Har
ris, like Carson (according to Marcus

Martin) fiddled for Taylor on the cam

paign trail. John Carson and J.D. Harris
do share some unusual tunes in their

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

endeavor to gather together information
on the Heltons and paint a picture of

Mars

professionally, making numerous per
sonal appearances, radio broadcasts, and
commercial records. This article will
Ernest &amp; Osey Helton, Asheville Citizen-Times,

repertoires. When Harris relocated to
Western Carolina from Tennessee, he
exerted an influence on Marcus Martin,
teaching the younger fiddler tunes like
"Lady Hamilton," and "Polly Put the

Kettle On." Since these tunes as well as
Taylor's "Turkey Buzzard" were also
played by Osey Helton, and we know of
Harris' and Helton's acquiantance, we
can assume that at least some of Taylor's

influence, however indirect, was felt on
Helton as well.
Osey (Ozie/Hosea) Helton, born on
May 12, 1879, was the third of seven or
eight children of Matt, a full-blooded
Cherokee, and Laura Helton, of Irish

Aug. 4, 1940

descent. His brother,
approximately 1893,
of the brood. When
months old, he and

Ernest,
was the

born

in

youngest

Ernest was four
siblings were
their
dying parents. The Hel
given up by
ton children were raised by an old gen
tleman who had fought in the Civil and
Spanish- American Wars.
Osey and his brothers lived in a number
of locations around east Tennessee, but,
by 1921, the Helton siblings had settled
in the

ville,

his

Asheville area. While in Ashe
family worked as masons,

the

painters, carpenters, and plasterers. Osey
also made fiddles. Only one of the other
Helton brothers, Marion, played music.

�Osey and Ernest performed in the
with their niece Costine daughter
of their sister Fanny), who was a clog
dancer. After moving to Asheville, they
often appeared at Bascom Lamar Luns
ford's Mountain Dance and Folk Festi
val. The Helton's Old Time Stringband,
sponsored by Chesterfield Meals, played
1920s

on

W

WNC-Asheville

(Wonderful

Western North Carolina), beginning one
month after the station went on the air in
February, 1927. Ernest also played with
Jimmy Rodgers, who moved to Ashe
ville in the winter of 1927, backing the
singer on guitar. James Sievers, of the
Tennessee Ramblers, reports seeing the
Heltons at the Old-Time Fiddlers Con
vention at Market Hall, Knoxville, in the
1930s.
In November
or December,
1924,
possibly at several recording sessions,
Osey, Ernest, and Dedrick Harris recorded
sides which were issued by Broadway

Records on commercial 78-rpm records.
These recordings, which are extremely
rare (I know of only one or two copies of
each issued record), feature Osey on
solo fiddle and Ernest accompanying
Dedrick Harris on the banjo. Four sides
were of Osey, two sides were of banjo
and fiddles and one side, "Lone and
Sad," featured Harris' singing accompan
ied by Ernest Helton. Ernest basically
chorded behind Harris on their two fid
dle/banjo duets but showed off his clas
sically influenced three-finger style on
"Lone and Sad." He would later record
"Lone and Sad" for Robert W. Gordon
of the Library of Congress in the 1940s.

"Rocky Road to Dublin," another solo
Osey, was part of the repertoire of
Robert Allen Sisson. Born in Polk County,
Tennessee, and raised in the same general
area as John Carson (Gilmer County,

of

the radio research project). As Robert

Gordon had done earlier, while

in

Ashe

ville they used Bascom Lamar Lunsford
as their local contact and recorded Ern
est Helton. At the Asheville festival,

recorded

musical highlights including
Martin and the Helton Brothers. Osey's
fiddling was much changed from record
ings of 1 5 years before. In his sixties and,
according to his wife, in poor health,
these recordings contain the power of his
earlier playing but lack the melodic and
rhythmic complexity of his earlier Ern
est did most of the talking, which out the
impression given by contemporthat Osey
was quiet and Ernest gregarious.

addition to the recording sessions
above, and in the discography, there is
the possibility that one more of Helton
Brothers recordings do exist, widow
insists that the brothers traveled Chapel
Hill to record for Jan Phillip Schinhan
In

around the same time that the Lomax
recordings were There is a strong possi
bility that Schina German musician

stranded in this country at
World War II, did record
the end of 1939 or the
However, it is uncertain if

the outbreak

Ernest and

at

beginning of
any discs cut

this time survive.
Osey met his wife Charity Buchanan

father's house when Helton, Bill
Hensley, and Samantha Bumgarner were
invited the Buchanan home on Grass
hopper Branch (now called Cagel Branch
Road) in Sylva, North Carolina. They in
1935, when Charity was 23, and made
their home in Asheville. The couple had
sons, Osey Charles (O.C.), and Jerry.
Osey Sr. contracted cancer, the couple
at her

Buchanan homeplace outside Sylva.
Osey died on March 2, 1942. Although
she and was widowed a second time,
Charity still has vivid memories of the
quiet man won her heart with his music
some 50 ago.
By 1926, Ernest had married, but was
to the

by

1

94

1

He was last

directory
Avenue. B
ity

in

listed

1941

in the

Ashec

living on Lamb

as

Although Osey played over 1 00 tunes,
the following are the ones remembered
his

wife, Charity,

fiddler

Harry

and

Cagle:

by Sylva, N.C.
Grey Eagle in

C/Tennessee Wagoneer/8th of January/
Snowbird on the Ashbank/John Hen
ry/Dusty Miller/Old Joe ("Did You

Ever the Devil, Uncle Joe")/ Soldier's
/Ducks on the Millpond/Run Nigger

Joy

Sawyer/ Turkey Buz

Run/Mississippi

Cotton/Cripple

zard/Bagging

Creek/Turkey the Straw/Booger Man
("Whip the Devil Around the Stump"
Going to the W edding Sally Ann/Billy
in the Lowland/Nellie You and I Were
Young, Maggie/Bury Beneath the Wee

pin'

Yonder/Ala

Willow Tree/Down

bama Jubilee/Liza J ane/ Cindy /Polly Put
the Kettle On/Sourwood Mountain/

racklin' Hen/ Shoot That Turkey Buz
[Discography on page 28]

zard.

of infer
Fiddle From

The following were sources
for this article:

A

Study

In

Western North Carolina (UNC Chapel
Hill, Music Department), 1940 thesis,
David Parker Bennett; Guthrie T. Meade;

continued on page 44

by

Georgia), Sisson (Aug. 31, 1873-Sept.
22, 1951) recorded his version on Feb.
25, 1925 in New York City for the Edi
son Company. Ernest Helton and J.D.
Harris each recorded one side during
OKeh's Asheville sessions in late August
of 1925. These records were released by
December of that year. (For more infor
mation on the OKeh recording session,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Charity
courtesy

Lomax (assistant-in-charge of the Archive
of Folk Culture), Jerome Wisner (the
first chief engineer of the newly estab
lished recording laboratory), and Joseph

Gates

see Old Time Music #31, winter '78/'79).
In 1941, the Library of Congress sent
their brand new sound truck on a trip
into the Appalachian mountains. They
record musicians at the Asheville Folk
Festival and the Galax Fiddlers Conven
tion. To involve the different divisions
of the Library and to achieve their var
ious goals, the Library sent along Alan

The circumstances under which this unusual photo was taken are unknown.
Although the
Helton Brothers were partly of Native American descent, this
photo was taken as a publicity
photo and as such does not necessarily reflect Cherokee traditional culture.

�The southern end of the Blue Ridge
Mountains, ranging west from Asheville into southeastern Tennessee and
spilling down into North Georgia, is a
large area encompassing many com
munities with strong traditions of
music-making. Blues guitar picking,
two- and three-fingered as well as
clawhammer banjo playing, harmon
ica blowing, shape note singing, and
old-time fiddling are just some of the
many styles of music that have long

histories in the region. Yet because of
the influential work of a few individ
uals, the region is known by those
from outside the area mainly for two
traditions
ballad singing and dancing.
The former reputation is based in
large part on the work of ballad hunt
ers from the early years of this cen
tury. Englishman Cecil Sharp, who

roamed the area between 1916 and
1918, was particularly influential in
establishing the association of ballad
singing with this section of the Blue
Ridge. His monumental work, English
Folksongs from the Southern Appalach
ians, remains one of the outstanding
works in the field of folklore scholar
ship and includes many versions of

ballads from singers in western North

Carolina

and

Tennessee.
followed up and

eastern

Sharp's work was
added to by others, notably Bascom
Lamar Lunsford, a native of the region
who collected folksongs and presented

singers in the Mountain Dance and
Folk Festival, first held in its earliest
form in 1928 and continuing to this
day.
As the title of the festival implies,
Lunsford also had a great interest in
dance. He initiated a competition
between local dance teams that was
often the climactic stage event of the

festival. Square dance stage routines,
team clogging, and even the modern
precision clogging steps were devel
opments that evolved in large part out
of the interest generated by the
Mountain Dance and Folk Festival.
Given the richness of the ballad and
dance traditions, it is not surprising
that old-time fiddle music of the
region was quite remarkable as well.

Good traditional fiddljjig was appre
ciated by Lunsford and he presented
annually such exemplary musicians as
Marcus Martin, Fiddlin' Bill Hensley,
Cymanthia Bumgarner, Manco Sneed,
and Osey Helton. In fact, for a number
of years the fiddle contest staged
between Fiddlin' Bill Hensley and
Osey Helton rivaled the dance com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

popularity, as the two
out playing the wonderful
old C version of "Gray Eagle." Today
musicians who remember that annual
event still debate who was the best
fiddler. Fortunately, in large measure
because of their exposure through the
Mountain Dance and Folk Festival,
the playing of all this music was doc
umented, mainly in the 1940s and
'50s.
Yet, while there are singers like
Doug Wallin who continue to trea
sure the old ballads, and flatfoot
dancers from the area who can exe
cute the buck and wing step, the older
regional styles of fiddling seem to
have been replaced almost completely
by more modern styles and newer
in

petition
battled

it

In the

fiddling

of the Old Masters

one hears a beauty
and complexity*..*
repertoires. For instance, the regional
version of "Gray Eagle," always played
as the opening tune of Lunsford' s fes

tival, has given way to the more com
mon rendition of the piece in the key
of A. Gone also are tunes like "Whip
The Devil Around The Stump," "Rocky
Road To Dublin," "Booth Shot Lin
coln," and "Newport Breakdown," as
well as those beautiful and distinctive
in the key of G but
the
flatted
seventh note
employing

pieces played

"Lady

Hamilton,"

"Georgia

Belles," "Polly Put The Kettle On,"
and "Snowbird On The Ashbank."
It is not only repertoire that has
been lost. This older generation of

employed techniques that
demonstrate a sophistication that is
fiddlers

truly staggering. Yet these older tech
niques have not been carried on in the
music of succeeding generations of

fiddlers, whose playing reflects more
modern tastes. In the fiddling of the
old masters

complexity

ings of notes,

one hears
in
a

a

beauty and

bowing, subtle shad
moving between scales

within tunes, the use of gapped scales,

scales where the 3rd and 7th
notes are somewhat flatted. In listen
ing to this music there is a need to
divest oneself of classic notions of
conformity to intervals based on a
tempered piano scale, and the belief
and

that the right way to play a note is
"dead on the head" rather than a little
above or below. David Parker Ben
nett recognized this in 1940 when he
wrote his masters thesis under the
auspices of the music department at
the University of North Carolina at
Chapel Hill. In researching the thesis

entitled "A Study in Fiddle Tunes
from Western North Carolina," Ben
nett visited the Avery Creek com
munity near Asheville to listen to the
playing of Fiddlin' Bill Hensley. For
this thesis he wrote:

When

heard Fiddlin' Bill
first time, I was
instantly attracted by his lively
but the
spirited manner
tunes themselves, I must con
fess, left me rather bewildered.
The intervals and rhythms sounded
strange and were hard for me to
understand at first hearing. I
was conscious of the scraping of
his bow and the imperfections
of his technique which I judged
according to standards that I
play

I

for the

was used to

After listening many

times to the playing of these
tunes, transcribing eighteen of
them, analyzing them, and trac
ing, in a small way, their back
ground and history, I have found
them to be even more interest
than I had imagined they
would be, both from a musical
as well as a cultural point of
ing

view.

Astutely, Bennett concluded his intro
duction with the observation that
"the bowing and fingering technique
of Bill Hensley takes a lifetime devo

tion to acquire, and the number of
tunes he plays by ear requires a prodi
gious memory."

Though the older-generation fid
dlers of the area are linked through
repertoire and technique, each had
his own individual style as well. Bill
Hensley 's tunes were rendered with a
hard-edged, almost wild urgency that
is exciting, if sometimes unsettling, to
listeners today. Clean sweeps of the

bow and

a

clear even pulse were the

trademarks of Marcus Martin's style
while intricate melody lines and com
plex phrasing identify Manco Sneed's
playing, and spare emotional fiddling
characterizes Osey Helton's style.

Connecting the playing of

all

these

musicians was a fiddler of legendary
reputation, J. Dedrick Harris. Accord
ing to Marcus Martin, Harris was
born in Tennessee and played regu-

�many more. He could
also play soft and sweet tunes
that were just for listening. Such

many,

tunes

Eagle,' 'Lady
With the
Girls In the Morning,' and others.
Often when visiting my fam
as

'Gray

Hamilton,'

'Home

'Uncle Dedrick' would

ily,

sponsor a Fiddlers Convention.
[Bjefore the contest would begin
he would entertain the crowd
by tuning the fiddle in

had learned from a
and playing the tune
Dream' that the black
him.
Once the

a

way he

black man

'Darkey's

man taught
fiddle was
he placed it on his

ca.

1940

Mars

Hill

Photo

Archives,

Bascom

Lamar

Fiddlin' Bill Hensley

Lunsford

Collection

tuned and
chest (he held the fiddle down
on his chest and not under his
chin) and drew the bow across
the strings, silence would fall
upon the crowd as the strains of
'Darkey's Dream' came from
the fiddle.

ca.

1940

courtesy

Marcus Martin

in

Fortunately, Harris did participate
two recording sessions and saw

records of his music released on both
the OKeh and Broadway labels. Also,
his legacy lives on in the playing of
Marcus Martin, Fiddlin' Bill, Manco
Sneed and Osey Helton, all of whom
learned some of their most striking
pieces from Harris. According to fiddler
Harry Cagle, Harris was living in
North Georgia at the end of his life.
He probably died in the late 1930s.
Thanks to those individuals who
organized field and commercial record
ing

sessions, there

is

documentation

of the magnificient artistry of Harris
and his contemporaries. That is for
tunate, for there are only a few fiddlers,

Osey Helton

ca.

1940

larly with Bob Taylor while he was
running for governor of the state in
the late 1800s. By the 1920s Harris
had moved to Whitter and later to

Andrews, North Carolina, where he
competed regularly in and even staged
fiddlers conventions. Glenn Massey,
an amateur collector
and musician
born in 1915 in Waynesville, North
Carolina remembered Harris and wrote
about him after his death:
Out of the mountains he came,
this man with his fiddle. He was
known far and wide as the "King
of the Mountain Fiddlers'.

.He

could play square dance tunes
like 'Sally Gooden,' 'Cumber
land Gap,' 'Booger Man' and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ross Brown in North Georgia
Cagle in Sylva, North
Carolina, who include regional tunes
in their repertoires. However, research
continues to be done and perhaps
other players or newly-discovered
home recordings will surface. As more
is learned about the fiddle traditions
of the area, and the information made
accessible to the public, perhaps the
repertoire and playing techniques of
old-time fiddlers from the southern

such

as

and

Harry

end of the Blue Ridge will garner
more attention from researchers and
musicians alike. Then, perhaps, the
region will come to be known and

appreciated for the exceptional qual
ity of its old-time fiddling as well as

for its fine ballad singing

and

tradi

tional dancing.

Alice Gerrard

Wayne Martin

�I

remember the first time

Brewer.

was

I

met Kahle

rainy night, torrentially
so, and the creeks and rivers around
Galax, Virginia, looked like they might
get out of their banks if it kept up much
longer. The stars and moon were lost
beyond the clouds, and the winding Vir
ginia back roads, so foreign to city
dwellers like myself, were forbidding.
We crept along in the van, noses nearly
pressed against the windshield, looking
for a mailbox, and when at last we spied
It

a

turned down across a narrow culvert
bridge almost awash in the swift water of
a branch, Up a lane we trundled, and out
in the dark a light came into view deli
neating a neat frame house. A dog began
to bark, and out onto the porch stepped
an elderly man, compact and sturdy des
pite his years. He hushed the dog with a
few words, and beckoning to us said,
"Come on in. Come on in."
During the next five years I heard that
welcome many times, and Kahle and
Edna Brewer's home above Meadow
Creek became one of my favorite places
in all the world. It was a place of good
music, good conversation, and good
friends. Kahle's death on August 12,
1989, has closed the door on a part of

photo

by

Alice

Gerrard

it,

Kahle Brewer,

REMEMBERING
KAHLE BREWER

that, but I remember it all.
Lee Kahle Brewer was born in 1904
near Fries, Virginia. When he was five
years old his father died suddenly during

influenza epidemic. Following his
father's death he was brought up in part

1989

by

Craig Johnson

an

by his

may

grandparents, a circumstance that
have shaped his repertoire and

musicianship.

"I

was raised by old

peo

I heard
him say, "I grew up inter
ested in the things they were interested
in. They listened to me play and made
me work at it till I got it right."
Kahle s was a musical tamuy, and he
began playing at an early age. He tried to
play the fiddle his father had made
shortly before his death. "I'd try to get
that fiddle where they kept it way up in a
big old dresser, but they were all afraid
I'd drop it or break it because I was so
small. But I wouldn't have broken it for
the world. That was my dad's fiddle."
Though there were obstacles in his path
he would not be stopped, and he soon
became a fine fiddle and banjo player.
During his late teens and early twenties
he was particularly inspired by three
local musicians. Bill Frost, Ernest
Stoneman's father-in-law, made a lasting
impression. Kahle particularly admired
Frost's ability to put all the notes into his

ple"

playing on complicated pieces
without losing steadiness and rhythm.
banjo

Hampton, a near neighbor of his
grandparents, was a good fiddler, partic
ularly on waltzes and slow pieces. Kahle

Joe

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was very fond of playing waltzes and
dle accompaniment to songs, and

fid
cre

dited Joe Hampton's early impact on his
playing.
Perhaps the strongest impression was
left by Emmett Lundy. Lundy is familiar
to

modern listeners through his Library

of Congress recordings made when he
was an old man in the early

1940s, but

Kahle had known him since the early
'20s. "That man could play all night, I
mean all night, and not repeat a tune.
Old tunes, Irish tunes, not just dance
tunes." The Lundy influence was marked
in Kahle's playing, particularly
in the
tunes
and
he
way
punctuated the
paced
beginnings and ending of phrases. Kahle's
admiration of him was deep and sincere.
If I asked him about a tune, sooner or
later he would say, "You should have
heard Mr. Lundy play that."

It was through Emmett Lundy, indi
rectly, that Kahle came to record with
Ernest Stoneman during several sessions
in 1926 and 1927. Stoneman and Lundy

had recorded together early in 1926, but
Lundy was not satisfied with the records
that came out of this session and deter
mined not to make more recordings.

Ernest Stoneman then asked Lundy to
recommend another fiddler. Lundy sug

gested Joe Hampton, but when approached
was not interested either. He did,
however, suggest that Stoneman contact
a promising young fiddler named Kahle

Joe

Brewer.

It

was an

exciting prospect for

Kahle and he quickly determined to join
Stoneman in the band he was then

forming.

Throughout the better part of 1926
and 1927 Kahle played with the Stone
man gorup, "The Blue Ridge Corn-

shuckers"

as they styled themselves. The
band had a somewhat flexible lineup, but
the core musicians were Ernest Stone
man playing guitar, harmonica, and sing
ing, Bill Frost's son Bolen playing banjo,
and Kahle Brewer on fiddle. They tra
veled to New York for their first record
ing session. For a young man raised in
rural Virginia, New York was an almost
overwhelming experience. "At first I was
afraid to step off the sidewalk for fear I'd
get run over," Kahle recalled. His reluc
tance didn't last long. During their stay
he spent most of his free time exploring
the city.
The Blue Ridge Cornshuckers played
frequently in and around Galax at that

time. In 1926 they traveled to Mountain
City, Tennessee to compete in a fiddlers
convention. "At the end of the fiddling

�competition the contest was tied between
G.B. Grayson and Kahle Brewer. Each
was required to play additional selec
tions in order that the tie might be
broken. In the end Grayson took the
first prize and Kahle second. While
Kahle never said that he should have
gotten the first over Grayson he was
known to remark that they had to give
the contest to the older fiddler and local
favorite. Regardless, it was an incident
he recalled with justifiable pride.
December of 1926 Kahle Brewer mar
ried Edna Boyer at her parents' home in
Fries. Kahle continued to play with the
Stoneman band, but it became increasingly
In

apparent that there wasn't much of a living
a musician,
especially if one
wanted to stay close to home. Nonetheless,
in July of 1927 Kahle and Edna traveled to
Bristol, Tennessee for another Stoneman
session, in this case the now famous
Bristol sessions that witnessed the first
recordings of Jimmy Rogers and the
Carter Family, as well as sterling perform
ances from the likes of Alfred Karnes
and Blind Alfred Reed (reviewed in the
Spring '88 OTH). During the course of
several days the Stoneman "band," now
considerably enlarged over the usual
to be made as

Stoneman/Brewer/Frost
numerous selections.

unit, recorded
Edna Brewer sang

on many of these sides, although it is
hard to hear her because she was so far
from the microphone. Kahle played the
fiddle and also sang. His tenor can be
heard on "Tell Mother I Will Meet Her,"
and during a skit record, "The Old Time
Corn Shuckin'," he played a brief but
brilliant "Mississippi Sawyer." The voice
that was supposed to be Kahle's on this
record was in fact that of Uncle Eck

In 1970 Kahle and Edna traveled to
Washington, D.C. for the Smithsonian
Folklife Festival where Kahle performed
with Wade and Fields Ward. With this
exception their music stayed mostly at

home, and maybe that's where Kahle liked
it

best.

met the Brewers in 1984. I began to
make tha long drive from Washington,
D.C. to Galax every month or so to try to
learn some of Kahle's music, and Kahle
and Edna made me more then welcome
from the very first visit. Those were
good times. We talked a lot about the
old days, because I wall full of questions
about them, but we talked as much or
more about the present, because Kahle
and Edna didn't dwell on the past in spite
of their respect for it. Kahle and I drove
all over Grayson County visiting the old
homesites of local musicians, his birth
place at Rural Home, and numerous
I

wherein were buried many
musicians he had heard and I had heard
of. I remember Edna's wonderful meals.

graveyards

"We're just having scraps," she'd say,
but that wasn't the truth. What food:

cornbread and beans, pickled peppers
and onions, and watermellon cold from
the spring out back.
Kahle's fiddling was the icing on the
cake. His playing had much of the old
Emmett Lundy sound in it, but Kahle put
his own stamp on everything he played. He
put rolling sequences of many notes on
single bow strokes, and his use of chords
high and low on the neck was mind-

with my slow grasp of simple
never showed it.

things

he

Late in the evening on the days I visited
we'd play the waltzes, songs, and airs that
were Kahle's favorites. Of such selections
he often said "That's where the real music

We played "Old Kentucky
Home," "Shenandoah," "Dakota Girl," and
the sweet and sorrowful "When I Grow
Too Old to Dream." At these times Kahle
would leave the melody to someone else
is." It truly was.

and play the beautiful harmony

accompan

iments he'd recorded some sixty years
before. Those were wonderful nights.
Kahle Brewer was not the sort of man to
draw attention to himself. He was always

modest about his considerable talents,

although I'm sure he knew he was some
thing special underneath it all. He had a
quick and sometimes sly sense of humor,
and was generous to a fault. He was impa
tient with his own playing, frustrated that at
his age he could no longer play with the fire
and precision he'd taken for granted in
younger days. None of the friends who
came to visit and play music with him
shared those feelings. To us, listening to
him was listening to

a

master.

won't have any more evenings of music
with Kahle, but I remember him waving
good-bye from the porch as we headed
I

down the lane, waving and smiling just like
he would when we came back the next
time.

boggling. W ith each visit I heard something
new in his tunes that I had missed before.
He was a patient and perceptive teacher,
and although I must have frustrated him

Dunford whose unusual and somewhat
comic speech was a favorite of session
organizer Ralph Peer. This historic re
cording session was Kahle's last trip to a
studio. He and Edna had a family on the
way, and shortly after the Bristol trip he
left Stoneman to devote himself full time
to

steadier work and his familv.

During the years that followed Kahle
learned the business of excavation and
heavy equipment operation. He and his son
Earl ran their own company for many
years. Edna became a teacher and is fondly
remembered by many former students

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Kerry
by

taught Kahle to read notes and the other

points of "scientific music" as he called it.
Kahle took correspondence courses in music
from the Stamps-Baxter school as well.

photo

they were joined by Kahle's brother Straley,
a fine banjo player, and Edna, a pianist with
an extensive knowledge of music theory,

Blech

throughout the Galax area.
Both of them continued to play music at
home for family and friends. Sometimes

�Workshop
BOWING
WORKSHOP
by

Brad Leftunch

is the first of a series of work
shops on the heart and soul of old-time
fiddle-playing: bowing. The series will
start with the most basic of bow licks
and work up to the most complex ones 1
know. Keep a few things in mind as you

This

work on your bowine:

Bowing is an art and a skill, and it
requires attention and patience to develop.
Don't just go for the notes of a tune and
it
hope the bowing will work itself out

won't, not unless you've already mas
tered your bow.

Except for when you're first learn
new one, most bow licks shouldn't
be hard. (1 only know a couple that are
genuinely hard, and I don't use them
very often.) If your bowing feels like
ing

a

work and has felt that way for years,
you're probably doing something wrong.
Your bow shouldn't fight you, it should
work for you. Good bowing feels good;
in the words of the late Oklahoma
fiddler Tom Fuller, "almost like the tune
is playing itself." You're just along for
the ride.

Bowing is like penmanship. It has a
flow and a rhythm to it. It's not random
scribbling, but an orderly system whose
parts all fit together. In penmanship you
learn to make your letters, then you put
the letters together into words and sent
ences. In bowing, you learn your licks,
then you put the licks together into

phrases and tunes.
One last thing: Beginning fiddlers
are often eager to develop their own
styles and worry that if they try to learn

someone

else's licks they'll end up
sounding like clones. Don't worry, you
won't. These are not just my bow licks.
Traditional old-time fiddlers all over the
South and beyond use a lot of the same
licks, but they never sound quite the
same. Just ask yourself: Does your hand
writing look like anyone else's?

Downbowing

Much, if not most, of traditional
Southern fiddling can be loosely charac
terized by what I call "downbowing."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Different fiddlers talk about it in differ
ent terms, and some don't talk about it
at all, but once you know what you're
looking for, you'll recognize it instantly.
Tommy Jarrell called it "pulling your
bow," and Violet Hensley likens it to
handwriting (see below). Aside from the
characteristic bow licks I'll be presenting

there are three basic features to
1
You begin phrases with
a downbow
stroke (pulling your bow
arm away from the fiddle), 2) you end
phrases with an upbow (so you can
begin the next one with a downbow),
and 3) in a series of sawstrokes, the beat
falls on a downbow. More on that later.
I
suspect that downbowing is so

group (that is, on the first space after
each solid vertical line). The arrows
show which direction your bow should
be going at any particular time. When
the arrow goes down, your bow goes
down. When the arrow goes up, so does
your bow.
Sawstrokes look like this:

here,

downbowing:

common

and

widespread for the same

reasons that clawhammer and other downpicking banjo styles are: it makes it eas
ier to get a strong, rhythmic sound.

Basic Licks
Tunes are made up of phrases. Some
short, some are long, but they all
have three parts: a beginning, a middle,
and an end. So I group bow licks roughly
are

according to those three functions
(there's some overlap). Let's start in the
middle.

Middle Licks
movement

The most basic bow

just back and forth, in even
strokes, like a saw that's why some
people call them "sawstrokes." The
is

important thing to keep in mind with
sawstrokes is that you should pull your
bow; don't push it. That is, on the beat
(where you tap your foot), you should
start a downbow, pulling your bow arm

from the fiddle. There are four
bow strokes for every tap of your foot,
and you should make sure that when
ever your foot goes down, your bow
goes down, too. Violet Hensley, "the
away

Whittling
Arkansas,

Fiddler"

describes

from

it

as

if

Yellville,

you were

making a series of small letter
sive handwriting. "Don't write

e's in

cur

them

backwards" she says, "or it'll sound like
'whoop-a whoop-a whoop-a'" (for more
on Violet Hensley, see Sing Out! vol. 32
no. 4

The drawings that follow show the
timing of the bowstrokes. The vertical
lines divide the time up into groups of
four spaces. There's room for one note
of a tune in each of the spaces between
the lines. The beat
where your foot
falls on the first space of each
taps

(See box opposite page)

simple but effective. While it's not
fanciest pattern, with the appro
priate beginning and ending licks you
It's

the

a lot of tunes like this. In fact, a
number of fiddlers in the Ozarks depend
heavily on the sawstroke as their basic
bow stroke, and they sound pretty good
with it.
Ending Licks Most ending licks get
your bow going up at the end of a phrase
so that you can begin the next phrase
with a downbow. Here are two of the
most common, each tagged on to the end
of a series of sawstrokes. Since some
bowstrokes are longer than others, in
the following drawings some arrows go
through two or more spaces. When that
happens, it means the bowstroke is held
as long as it would have taken to play the
same number of short strokes. Remember,
there may or may not actually be that
it
many notes on a long bowstroke
the
of
the
tune
but
on
melody
depends
the bowstroke is held the same length as
if there were.
The first ending lick charges right up
to the end of a phrase and puts what
would have been three sawstrokes
together onto one last long upbow:

can play

(See box opposite page)

Notice that the ending lick finishes

up

halfway between beat 4 and beat 1 and
that there are a couple of extra saw
strokes to take up the slack before you
start over again.

The next ending lick starts winding
things up a little earlier, combining the
original sawstrokes into longer upbows
in two places:
Again, a couple of extra sawstrokes lead
back into the first beat of the next
phrase.

�Beginning Licks If you take those
two extra sawstrokes that come after
either ending lick, along with the first
sawstroke of the next phrase (the one

that starts

beat 1), and replace all
one long downbow, then
you've got the most common beginning

three
lick.

on

with

It

looks like this:

(See box opposite)

Now is the time to grab yourself by
the collar and look at what you're doing on
the beginning lick. The natural instinct
of four out of five people is to put the
equivalent of only two sawstrokes on
the first downbow and to start up when
they tap their foot on the first beat. That
leaves you pushing your bow on the
beat. Note that the arrow on the begin
ning lick extends through the first beat,
so that your bow should still be going
down when you tap your foot. Say to

yourself as you bow: "Down-down-down
up down up down up down up down
up-up down up- up, down-down-down
up down up down up down up down
up-up down up- up." Your foot taps on
the italicized words.
The beginning lick

works just the
same no matter which of the two ending
licks you use.
Shortening Bread Now let's look
at how these licks might work in a tune

like "Shortening Bread":

Shortening

Bread

(The notation I've used above needs some explanation. It's like tablature for fretted instruments, but since fiddles do not have
frets, the numbers refer to fingers rather than frets. I'm assuming that anyone trying to figure this out knows where to put his or her
fingers in any given key to get the correct notes. Your index finger is 1, your longest finger is 2, your ring finger is 3, and your little
finger is 4. The spaces between the horizontal lines represent the strings, with the highest on top. The tuning is given at the left of the
first set of lines. Since this is the first time I've tried this out on a wide audience, I'd appreciate feedback, in the form of letters to the
editor, on whether it works or not).

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Valley Forge

FIDDLE

cross-tuned

Key

A

NOTE:

of

From:

2nd time through B parts, Ramona uses
the open lower string in the indicated

examples:

Ll

to

hi,

HI

to

H2,

whole-step
cross
in
in

A
G

Jones

HI

instead

of

measure.

first three fingers have
low (L) and high (H) positions,
open string to LI,
half-step

FIDDLETAB

To

Ramona

Back Porch Fiddlin'
Volume I

A

tune:

raise

G

G

D

A

lower

E
A

G

D

A

E

&amp;
&amp;

D

E

to uz,
open string
H2 to H3,

Hi

strings
A E
(high) strings

(low)
&gt;

A

E

&gt;

G

D

G

All

to HI,

a

s

All 3's

whole step

a

1

2's

high

lou/ on

high on
lou/

E
A

strings
strings

whole step

D

people prefer the lower sound &amp; less tension of the G tuning.
is playing the same phrase on the high and low
One advantage of cross-tuning
as Ramona does on the B part of this tune.
strings w/same fingering
Some

If you play the fiddle &amp; haven't tried cross-tuning
It's
be your start in this old and rich tradition.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

yet.

I

really

--Carl

will
Valley Forge
sound.
wonderful

hope
a

Jones

�ASK Uncle

Harold

force his opinions on his legion of ador
ing fans.

The words of this song are racist. And
your uncle is aware of the school of
thought that doesn't believe in changing
words because of authenticity and histor
ical value and all that. It's probably the
same school of thought that calls it picky
to point out that the banjo originated as
an African instrument, or that the word
"mankind" excludes half the human
.You know who you are, and
race, or.
I'll bet a Susan B. Anthony dollar you'll
be writing an irate letter to your uncle
before he can say "Samantha Bumgarner."
All this is a way of introducing verses
that your uncle has changed in order to
(and in the tradition of a fine old-time
band of North Carolina fame) protect
the innocent.

Rich
And
Poor
And

Many, many moons ago, your uncle

the words to a
a request for
song called "Ham Beats All Meat." T.
W. of Las Vegas, Nev., heard the song
"at a jam in Malibu." The person who
sang it "only knew two lines, sort of,"
writes T. W., who is "dying" to know
the rest of them.
Thus begins an unfascinating odyssey,
T. W. Uncle Harold questioned friends
and relations both face to face and long
distance. All they knew were two lines,
sort of. Everyone remembered the chorus:

received

Ham beats all
Always good
Ham beats all
Always ready

Your uncle won't bore you with the
story of his search for a recording of this
unmemorable song. Suffice it to say that
one of his favorite nephews, tired of his
old uncle's pestering, located the song
on the County reissue, Old Time String
Band Classics (County 531). It's per
formed by Dr. Humphrey Bates and His
Possum Hunters. It is identified as a
minstrel song, and after listening to it,
Uncle Harold isn't surprised that nobody
can remember the verses. At the risk of
forcing his opinions on his legions of
adoring fans, Uncle Harold will now

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

meat,
and sweet.

meat,
for to eat.

Rich folks in the dining room
Eating that mutton and lamb;
Poor folks in the kitchen
Going for the good sweet ham.
Ham beats all meat,
Always good and sweet.
Ham beats all meat,

Ham beats all meat,
Always good and sweet.
Ham beats all meat,

Always ready for to eat.

folks go to the butcher shop
buy that old cow meat;
folks go to the smokehouse
grab that ham 'at's sweet.

Always ready for to eat.
P.R., of Harrisonburg, Va., writes
a friend of his (a seven-year old and
"an astute collector of folk songs") has
the following question about a recent
that

song: "Why," she asks, "would he want
the nights to pass quicker if he goes
courting every night?"
First, your uncle has no idea what
song this comes from. (Yes, I know I
ended with a preposition. Keep your
shirts on.) Second, your uncle has no
idea why the "he" in this song wants the
nights to pass quicker. He agrees with
little Emily that on the face of it, this
attitude makes no sense. Perhaps the fel

low has mixed feelings about his rela
tionship. (You may understand this later
in life, Emily.) Much more possible,
however, is a simple but glaring inconsist
ency on the part of the lyricist. One of
the reasons Uncle Harold values children
is their terrifying ability to spot things
like this, as well as their terrifying inability
to keep quiet about them. Kind of like
your uncle.

Texas, wants

W. G., of Houston,

to

Martinez, with
Reyes del Albuquerque
playing trad
itional Mexican folk music. Let your
uncle steer you to a fellow Texan, W. G.,
for information on Roberto Martinez.
find

a

tape of Roberto

Write Juan Tejeda

at

the

Guadalupe

Cultural Arts Center, 1330 Guadalupe
St., San Antonio, Texas, 78207-5519.
Mr. Tejeda is the Xicano Music Director
there and can probably help you find
what you want.

Your uncle was tearing our what few
"If only
hairs he has left the other day
we had an ongoing trivia quiz
something
we could continue over several issues of
the OTH, with well-thought out and
witty questions," I said.
Oddly enough, the words were scarely
out of Uncle Harold's mouth when one
of his many couriers appeared, carrying

large envelope upon which was written
"Old-Time Music Trivia Quiz." Inside, a

a

"answers to come after"

terse message

fiendish set of questions.
There will be six questions per issue. In
addition, your uncle has chosen two
bonus questions from the set. These are:
1. Where did Cotton-Eyed Joe come
from? Where did he go?
2. Who made up these trivia questions?
The bonus questions can be answered
introduced

a

any time and your answers may make
the difference between winning and losing.

Keeping this
six questions:

in

mind, here are the first

1. Name three fiddlers who played
with the North Carolina Ramblers.
was Henry Reed's home
2. What

town?

Who won "World Champion Guitar
Player" at Union Grove in 1966?
3.

continued

on

page 44

�Issues In Old-Time Music
Issues column we offer more of the
discussion
on-going
concerning two articles
that appeared previously in the OTH. One,
"Folklorists &amp; Us," by Mac Benford (Spring
'8g OTH elicited so much response that the
Issues column in the Summer '89 OTH consisted of nothing but responses to that article.
W e have since received several more interest
In this

ing and thoughtful
so once

letters on that subject and
the spirit of continuing

again,
dialogue (and possible enlightenment), we
print further response here. The second arti
in

cle, "Dare to be Square," by Phil Jamison
(Winter '88, '89 OTH), also stirred up a
fair amount of furor.
Since that November when "Dare To Be
Square" appeared in the OTH I have found
myself in discussions of contras and squares
wherever I go. I am glad that the article
stirred people up enough to talk about it and
by now I have heard many opinions voiced
on both sides of the issue. In the following
letter, Robert Reed makes some good points.
Phil Jamison

Open letter to Phil Jamison:
sympathize with your sense of loss of
the spirit of old time country dancing,
and of the wild, unruly, and truly ener
getic music that travels hand in hand
with it. This phenomenon has occurred
in Portland as it has in so many other
I

towns, punctuated this month by the
indefinite termination of the Stumptown
Cloggers Old-time Country Dance, the
traditional monthly square dance venue
in our schedule of community dances. It
has fallen from favor and is no longer
able to support itself financially.

There are, however, several points in
your article, "Dare to be Square!" re
printed in the spring issue of the Bay
Area Country Dancer, with which I take
issue.
If squares are more difficult to call
than contras, it is more likely due to the
improvisational skills needed to lead
interesting breaks than it is the vigilance
required over sets in the hall. There are
just as many heads to confuse with

malunderstood calls, just

to

look for breakdowns

as

many places
flow, and

in the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

generally greater consequences from these
breakdowns. Where fumbling in a square
may affect three other couples, similar
breakdowns in a contra line may affect

30 couples or more! Where free phras
ing in squares allows the caller the flexi
bility to slow his calls so people can catch
up, the contra caller's only respite is to
stop the dance and start over. And
though a contra will proceed at some
point without calls as is part of its tradi
tion, callers must still maintain their
vigil, ready to resume calling at the first

sign of trouble.

Good contra calling, just like good

square dance calling, requires the style
developed over years. Contras might be
called out of a book, but the results usu
ally reveal the minimal effort of the
endeavor. As with squares, contras have
a wide range of difficulty,
and leading a
typical mix of dancers through a range of
such dances requires a practical skill not
attainable overnight. The accessibility of
dances, whether read from a book or

acquired through personal experience,

has little to do with the ability to deliver
them in an intelligible and exciting manner.
Predictability and repetition of form,

not strictly the domain of contra dances,
nevertheless is an appeal. As with its
antecedent English and Irish forms,
avoiding the constant calls in contra
dance reduces it to its basic elements
music and social motion. From this base,
opportunities for flirtation and individ
ual

embellishment

are

legion.

Repetition is an element of both forms,
and unpredictability
is an option for
either form. Each

patterns, repeated

is

composed of simple

in

endless variations.

squares is apparent on sev
from the repetition of basic
allemandes and swings to the repetition
of figures around a visiting-couple dance.
The unpredictability of a contra- medley
especially if comprising a sequence with
frequent unforgiving figures, can equal
that of most square dance breaks
and
require the constant calling favored in
squares.
No point on this spectrum is any bet

Repetition

in

eral levels,

ter than

another, but every point has

a

different appeal. One of the strong appeals
for contra dancers is the chance to meet
people where, in a single dance, you
can interact with a greater proportion of
the hall than with a similar time spent
square dancing. Population and popular
ity have led to the formation of artificial
communities. Outside of small, rural
groups, the attendees of local dances
many only see each other at those dan
ces, so there is a natural tendency to
make the contact as broad as possible.
Besides that, contras are open ended,
and with sufficient attention, it is possi
ble to join in the middle of a dance, while
it is very difficult to form a new square
mid-dance. In this sense the contra form
can appear more inviting.
No form is without its side effects. An
apparent one for contra dances is the
musical style. Contras require regular
phrasing in order to synchronize the

couples up and down the line, especially
in multiple progression or odd forma
tion (like Becket) dances. Your cheap
shot about palatability to Yuppie ears
aside, northern dance music, even with
its demands for phrasing and tempo, has
plenty of room for excitement and sur
prise. Ensemble playing, use of dynamics

and tune changes can lead even a hall full
of contra dancers into wild whoops and
cheers. But it is more controlled, and I
share your appreciation for the wild
flights of fancy in southern fiddle tunes,
and the exciting, careening sense of loss
of control that they can engender in a
dance. It dismays me that the popularity

of one form should require a shrivelling
interest in the other.
Nor are problems on the dance floor
limited to contras. Competitiveness is a
natural outgrowth of increased popula
tion densities, and the unfortunate ten
dency is for people to carry this aspect of
their lives onto any dance floor. I have
seen as much trouble finding a square in
modern times as I've seen in the compe
tition for partners and positions in the
center line. Though there is no center
line, I've been at enough recent square
dances in several communities to notice
the rush to the upper central portion of
the hall, and the desire to find three
other "good" or "fun" couples
and
heard the call, "Move down, we've paid
for the whole hall," when there were
nothing but squares on the floor. These
are not attributes solely of the contra
dance scene. Problems of crowding in
the top center of the hall and booking
multiple dances ahead can happen at any
dance, square or contra, and we should
be

working together to combat the prob

lems, not blaming them on one form or
the other.

�Regarding the length of dances,

I

have

had more trouble with overly long square

dances than

I

ever have had with corres

ponding contras. In particular, I've seen
callers string together a pair of long tips,
each with multiple breaks, stretching a
single square as long as 35 minutes. And
unlike contras, where you can always
join in

the end,

long square truly
In one such
square dance, called early in the evening,
I walked in to find nearly
as many people
waiting at the sides as were dancing. If it
had been a contra dance, many of these
new arrivals would have been able to
start dancing long before the caller
allowed them.
I share
your concerns about the care
lessness of dancers in modern times. We
have our share of "experienced" dancers
who couldn't care less about phrasing
about dancing
because they are too
preoccupied with flirting or showing off.
I can think of ways that both contras and
squares might have promoted such behavior,
at

a

excludes the rest of the hall.

I don't understand
what that has to
do with being forced to call more contra

but

dances. The dance caller is the modern
equivalent of the dancing master, and

should have the fortitude to persevere
insofar as he is able to demonstrate he
has something to offer. After all, the
dancers are there, not simply because of
the form, but for the enjoyment of it.
Your logic seems somehow disconnected.
I have witnessed grumbling about square
dances, though never any outright "boos."
But there are callers, Larry Edelman and
Dolores Heagy for example, who can
inspire a devout contra audience to
nay, to demand more squares!
prefer
And let's face it, people's tastes change.
It may well be that for many larger com
munities in the late '80s, there are no

boring squares, only boring square dancer
callers. But not every square dance caller
is a Larry Edelman, and learning those
skills in an era of dwindling interest

could be real tough.
I haven't
seen the dancers' need for
novelty as you suggest, but I have the
demand for thrill. I've seen that demand
satisfied by traditional figures, whether

"Cheat or Swing" or "Rory
O'More;" "Texas Star" or "Lady of the
Lake." And I've heard that thrill expressed
by dancers recognizing an old favorite in
the midst of a medley of tunes.
Let's examine the issue of "inactivity."
This is somewhat of a misnomer because
if you are truly inactive, you are not
dancing and thus not part of the dance.
Even in visiting-couple squares, "inac
they

be

tive" couples traditionally are occupied

with buck dancing and attentiveness to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the visiting couple, or sometimes follow
ing the actives in a double progressive
square. Both contras and squares rely on
the interweaving of person with person
and couple with couple. The designated
inactive couple still has a responsibility
to dance in and around the actives. This
need for motion comes more from the
desire to maintain the flow of a dance
and to dance with people than from any

overintellectualization
viewpoint,

or

academic

or fear of

inactivity.
Admittedly, there is an element of
boredom apparent in people who have
yet to learn that inactivity does not imply
inattention and lack of participation.
Also, contra dance composers have felt a
need over the last hundred years to con
vert triples into duples and create sym
metric dances in order to be more inclu

sive of dancers, and to ease the transition
of inactive to active dancers, especially in
the presence of long lines. But the key
word is flow, not fear
and emphasis on
flow itself stems from styles of the 17th

century:

academic.

very

It's fine to be

traditional,

not

very

nostalgic of the good old

days when dances were small and oldtime music was king. But as with any
tradition, the history of country dance is
an evolving story. It would be a sorry

turn of events for old-time musicians
and callers to bemoan a new fad (e.g.
"contra-mania") and go off to die in the
corner with tales of gloom and doom.
Sure, dancers should maintain an open
attitude, but callers and musicians must
keep their vitality, and find ways to pres

ent the tradition which captures a dancer's
interest. I would be among the first to

lament the loss of old-time dances, but it
is not
sufficient to shout, "Dancers,
don't be bored!"

Robert Reed
West Linn, OR

On Folkorists

Us

Response
There is a clear message in Mac Benford's article that he is mourning the
passing of string band music as a source
of income. It reminds me of a comment

�made by a 'crinoline' clogger here in the
Midwest who claimed to speak for the
traditional activity of clogging, that "there
are places where people make a living at
it." Are there really? Were there ever? Is
access to big audiences what old-time
music is all about? Is access to govern
ment funding for the arts the crucial
issue in its survival?
I don't believe
that even in the heyday
of the old-time country music recording
era the music was more than marginal
economic activity for the people con
cerned. Even the superstars. And I know

how well-supported

groups

such

as

Highwoods and Green Grass [Cloggers]
weren't. Sure, we can all look back to the
days of our youth when we could live on
nothing and dedicate ourselves to our
art, and some wonderfully talented peo
ple were able to take it on the road and
enrich the lives of thousands or millions
Some still do, but Benford
of others.
is asking that the government support them.
His big concern about folklorists is that
they hold the purse strings for federal
grants. Now if that isn't an attitude out
of the '60s, what is?
In an interesting antique essay on 'folk
song,' H.E. Krehbiel has written: "Folk
song is not popular song in the sense in
which the word is most frequently used,
but the song of the folk; not only the
song admired of the people but
music which
created by the people
has come into existence without the
influence of conscious art, as a spon
taneous utterance, filled with character
istic expression of the feelings of a peo
It would seem to be a paradox,
ple.

moreover, that heavy-hearted song should
be paired almost universally with singu
larly boisterous and energetic dances;
but the reason for this becomes plain
when it is remembered that a measured
and decorous mode of popular amuse
ment is the general expression of equable
popular life, while wild and desperate
gaiety is frequently the sign of reaction

from suffering."
We might consider
life

was

that disordered
characteristic of the

popular
rural south (and many other parts of the

U .S. in the early string band music days,
and in the cities and campuses in the

early days of the revival. During both of

those periods, perhaps, old-time music
had that 'folk' connection with the feel
ings of the people. And everyone admits

loves the fact that it started (and
mostly stayed) in the living rooms and
porches and local Grange Halls and
a
fiddlers conventions
passionate
avocation that bound together two
generations separated by a third. But
even the marginal economic returns were
and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

due to the fact that

it

'fit' in with how

people were feeling. Bands like Highwoods and their audiences found the
music to be

a

connection

to an internal

source of energy that made

us feel hap
pier about life during times of great polit

ical and social

What

turmoil.
to propose

is that for
the
nature
of
society
large,
popular life
has changed and maybe young players
are just not drawn to the music because
they're not! And it's not due to lack of
exposure to the best of the revivalists,
but to a general change in the tone of
I

want

at

American society.

Sure, there are still us old-time junkies
who can't live without the sound of
banjo and fiddle music, and step-dancing
feet. But we are a small group of friends.
We can't imagine how anyone could
resist the society of folks like us and the
kind of energy we want to project through
the music, and the ways we associate to
pursue it, but from the perspective of
middle America I can assure you that
lots of folks are immune to that. That is
not to say that popular life

Numb might be

a

is

'equable.'

better word. But folks

happy to stay home with their VCRs,
and if they do pull the needle out of their
eye long enough to go out, it's just to sit
are

down somewhere else. Sure, they might
go to watch a band which develops a
good show, with good music, costumes,
jokes, historical information, etc., but
that band is pursuing a commercial activ
is not really related to what folk
lorists are pledged to support.
Wouldn't it be horrible if we all quit
playing just because nobody would pay
us for it? I'd love to think that old-time
musicians and dancers are less trained by

ity that

the commercialism of American
society than lots of others, but Benford
seems to be saying, 'Wasn't it great when
they paid us lots of money to do this, and
oh how awful those folklorists are to
take that support away."
That's not what it was (and is) all
about. The old-time musicians I know
make music to live, not to make a living.
How can we begrudge the old folk the
"considerable funding now available?"
The old-timers deserve the limelight in
events the folklorists stage because they
made their music what it was even when
nobody paid them for it. I don't argue

that folklorists are right to shut revival
ists out, but only that it shouldn't be an
issue that creates so much resentment.
The kind of folklorists Benford des

cribes are academics, bureaucrats. They
don't "owe" us anything. (And fortu
nately, they're not all like that either.)

Some day our generation may "earn"
their attention (if that's so all-fired

but only by pursuing the
meaning someone who is reviving that
spirit of energy and community that
people need to make their own good
times rather than seeing them as a com
modity which is bought and sold. And if
large numbers of people don't respond,
well, that's because society has changed,

important)

not because we don't get to share the

stage.

lived for long in
surely been put off at
Appalachia
some time by the aggressive "marketing"
of folk culture, and yet this is a natural

Anyone who

has

has

extension

of government support of
for
folk arts. From farming to
programs
social welfare to the arts, a constituency
will grow up to utilize any resource made
available. Folklorists have the difficult
task of applying funds to the preserva
tion of folk arts, not individual artists
but I doubt they ever have much trou
ble getting older traditional musicians to
participate in their events just because
they can't pay them much.

believe old-time music must survive,
will, in living rooms and community
dances and weekend field parties, because
that's what kind of an avocation it really
I

if it

is.

Susan Brown

Johnston, IA
Drew Beisswenger states in his infurating letter (p. 20, summer '89 OTH) that

have "stated explicity that"
"could
never really understand the
they
music of the North Carolina farmer or
the blues music of a Delta guitarist."
This is just what I've always suspected:
Folklorists can't understand this music,
plenty of regular people can!
"revivalists." What
I resent the word
you call a Japanese, a Bombay Parsee, or
Maori (or an American) who takes up
does well at European art music? I'll tell

folklorists

"a musician." I feel that no less
should be shown to the skilled old-time
practitioner who was not born to the
tradition.

what:

"Who's conducting the symphony
tonight?"

"Seiji Ozawa, revivalist conductor!"
"Revivalist" is another way of saying
would ask folklorists,
"illegitimate."
ethnomusicologists, and other empowered
bureaucrats whether they enquire about
the birthplace and ethnic origins of jazz
musicians, rock musicians, classical, or
any other kind of musicians before deter
mining their worth? I also wonder if
some of them love and enjoy traditional
I

music (I have a signed confession that
they don't understand it) as much as I do,

�because if they did how could they
reduce the old-time musician and his
music to status of "cultural artifact?"
"Who's playing the dance tonight?"
"Oh, Wade Ward, Cultural Artifact,

along with Uncle Charlie Higgins,
Regional Symbol."
I feel that old-time
music has musical
worth (and possibly spiritual worth)
that goes beyond its value as a cultural
artifact.

If the letter from South Carolina
angered me, Blanton Owen's thoughts

depressed me. His letter was well thought
and deeply felt but maybe there can be

such

a thing as too much humility. I keep
thinking about the choice between pre
senting Hamper McBee ("authentic"
"good") versus Blanton himself ("inauthentic" "bad") doing a bad job imita
ting Emmet King's banjo music.* Those
may have been the true choices in that

and I agree that
particular situation
mere imitation is inauthentic (and bor
but if Blanton is presenting this as
ing)
a

typical choice (i.e. solid
outsider youngster doing
of imitating oldtimers good

blueprint

or

local versus
bad

job

music) then

I

have some alternate scena

rios to offer:
a. Youngster does good job doing oldtimers good music.
b. Youngster does good job doing oldtimers bad music.
c. Youngster does bad job doing oldtimers bad music.
d. Oldtimer does bad job doing young
sters bad music.
e. Oldtimer does good or bad job doing
youngsters good job of doing another
old-timer's good job of doing yet another
old-timers's bad job of good music.
f. Oldtimer does good job of doing good
job of doing that very same oldtimer's
good music.

Youngster (who is actually 45 years
but could be 20) has internalized the music
to such an extent that his performance is
g.

imitation

an

at all.

These seven scenarios, funny as they
are all based on real situations we've all
seen.
As Blanton so skillfully pointed out,
all the older musicians who have inspired
us learned from someone else. They've
all, to some extent, put their own indi
vidual stamp on the music no less than
Blanton's adventurous rawhide braider.
Emmet King, no doubt, was no original
beginning. He learned it somewhere and
eventually personalized it, I imagine. We
are, many of us, capable of the same.

Blanton, I have enjoyed your music
I don't think
its worth less because

and

you didn't learn

it at

your parent's knee.

For me, the way to honor the

oldtimers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

from whom we learned, is to embody the
music, proudly and without excuses, to
sing and play wholeheartedely, giving
our best.

Jody Stecher
San Francisco,

CA

*See Blanton Owen's letter, p. 22, Summer
'89 OTH; "What I did was get Hamper
McBee [a traditional singer] to
sing a
bunch of songs.
The thought of me
doing a bad job of playing Emmet King's

old-time banjo and fiddle player
from T ennessee who influenced Blanton
when he started playing] banjo music
never crossed my mind ..."

a common
goal.
believe once the big picture

help them attain

is seen
the small distinctions will tend to melt
away. I believe the turning point is near
when first, second, and third generation
I

traditional musicians, dancers, and story
tellers can all be presented on stage the
way they get together off stage.
I
hope I'll be around to take part in
this new direction. I'm tired of the old
one.

Tracy Schwarz
Berkeley Springs, WV

[an

Mac Benford has done it again. He
inched out onto the tightrope and gave a
command performance regarding folklorists vs. so-called folk-revivalists. He
got carried away a little bit toward the
end, but someone's got to do the job and
who better than Mac?
Several thoughts trouble me: I can't
help but think we're seeing a sort of dis
crimination
yes, discrimination, based
only on origin of birth. (If only I'd lied
back in '57, I'll bet you a month's supply
of old strings I could have passed for
traditional.) And how quickly the folk-

Please address ALL cor
or items to: Old-Time
Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, N.C.
new address.

respondence and/

us how it
Guru," to "this is how it's gonna
be, ol' Guru, 'cause we got the bucks
now." It's weird. The old masters gave
freely of their music to both collectors
and musicians because they recognized
the importance of the moment. I doubt if
they looked forward to watching us
squabble over which disciple was the
true follower. And I doubt if they expected
to feel like "monkeys in a cage" when

they were brought to presentations away

from home either. Something's wrong.
Seems like people are being pried apart,
even though the exceptions are in danger
of overruling the rule. New rules are
needed, or, hey! maybe no rules at all.
Perhaps the basis for the whole prob
Eastern

in

philosophy,

spe
as

I

tries to look at the big
picture; you know, the univeral con
sciousness and all that. If we grope in an
it,

easterly direction, perhaps us Westerners
will

realize

people

instead

our policies are separating
(viz. "informant to collector"
of "person to person"), rather

bringing them together. What's
music's greatest impact anyway? It brings
people together. Any policy or thing that
stands between them seems unnatural,
unhealthy, and it appears pathetically
counterproductive when the academics
alienate the very people they need to
than

be forwarded
limited time, but 3rd
and 4th class mail is not forwarded.

27717. First class mail will

is, Oh

cialization.
understand

expressed in this column are not necessarily
those of the Old-Time Herald.

PLEASE TAKE NOTE: We have
moved to Durham, N.C., and we have a

lorist's tune changed from "tell

lem lies in western scholarship,

The Issues In Old-Time Music column
was established as a forum for the expression
of ideas and points of view some of which
be
controversial.
Points
may
of view

from Galax for

a

Because we have kept our Galax box in
order to hold 3rd and 4th class mail, we
will get

it

eventually,

much longer.

but

it

will take

�Classified
The Old-Time Herald will accept
classified ads at the cost of .50 cents per
word, minimum $7. 00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the
first of the month, 2 months prior to

publication.

BLUEGRASS &amp; OLD-TIME
INSTRUMENTS, new, used, vintage.
FINE

friendly advice. All correspond
promptly and in depth.
Or, 919-383-5750. 451 S.A.S.E. brings
Free,

ence answered

current listing. Subscriptions with extra

services $5.00. Harry
Jeanie West,
3815 Tremont Dr., Durham, North
Carolina 27705.
Fiddler with FlattSIMS
Scruggs team (1949-52). Musical tapes,
video.
instructional books, &amp;. tapes
Free brochure. Benny Sims, 318 Swanee
Dr., Johnson City, TN 37601 (615)

BENNY

282-1219.

COUNTRY MUSIC CLASSIC TAPES:
Old time string bands, bluegrass, gospel.
1920s- 1960s. Send $1.00 for catalog.

Bussard, 6610 Cherry
Frederick, MD 21701.

Joe

Hill

Dr.,

STELLING, MARTIN,
GIBSON, STIVER, GUILD, DEERING,
REITER, KENTUCKY, much more, in
stock now at the best prices. World's
largest fretted instruments store. Free

FLATIRON,

discount

ELDERLY

catalogs.

INSTRUMENTS 100 N. Washington,
POB 14210-BE34, Lansing, MI 48901
(517) 372-7890.
1

DEERING,

GIBSON,

STELLING,

DOBRO,

MARTIN,

FLATIRON,

TAYLOR, GUILD, WILDWOOD,
Find out why we're the world's largest
fretted instruments store. Free catalog.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.

Washington, POB 14210-BC34, Lans
ing, MI 48901 (517) 372-7890.

hawaiian guitar, 1 920 Vega Little W onder
banjo mandolin, several banjo ukes, sev
eral Vega Tubaphone tenor banjos 10
15/16" and 11 13/16" rims, and more.
Send S.A.S.E. for list to: SMAKULA
FRETTED INSTRUMENTS, P.O. Box
882, Elkins, WV 26241. Phone: (304)

636-6710.

FOR SALE: 1955
Martin 0-18 guitar, 1939 Gibson L-37
small black archtop guitar, Kalamazoo

989 SOUTHERN FOLK DIRECTOR YLists folk music, dance and storytelling

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

activities

Texas),

performers, instru

ment builders and much more! $12.95
plus $1.00 shipping and 5% GA sales
tax. FOLK PUBLICATIONS, PO Box

168-C, Tucker, GA 30085. 404-564-

4709.
SQUARE DANCE CLASSICS: cassette
with 10 complete old time singing calls

1

INSTRUMENTS

ings of associations,

in

plus

the

South

nationally

(Delaware

to

distributed

resources, 224 pages with over 800 list

Dalsemer plus 23 page booklet
with instructions, music, chords. Ala
bama Jubliee, Down Y onder, J ust Because,
etc., $16 postpaid. TRADITIONAL
by Bob

CALLER PRODUCTIONS, 3029 Guil
ford Ave., Baltimore, MD 21218

�THE HOLIDAYS
ARE ALMOST HERE.

and what could be better than

a

holiday gift subscription to

THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
.the nicest way to wish your special friends
all the best throughout the year.
This quarterly publication offers interesting stories and articles that cover every aspect of old-time music
dance, record, tape, video, and book reviews, historical features
including in-depth looks at the bands and
musicians of today and yesterday.
The Old-Time Herald will send a "Season's Greetings" card to your friends telling them about your gift, and
we will sign the card with your name or nickname. Just fill out the Holiday Gift Subscription blanks on p. 43,
and return with your check or money order payable to the Old-Time Herald: P.O. Box 51812, Durham, N.C.

27717.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Sales

County
M

W

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
READY FOR SHIPMENT

W

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
MEMBER OF
Section with Illegible Text
INTERNATIONAL

BLUEGRASS

MUSIC

ASSOCIATION

NEW RELEASES

■Q

GREY- 101

FC-007
*ROCJ-0237
"CCLP-0107

'BSR-1001

CO-756

AT- 103

Lfl
HU
LJV

BC
PQ

ELD-003
ELD-004
"JA-051
"CCS- 110

CO-513
CO-41

1

'ROU-0236
OH-184

*BR1-010

■H
WJ

Kj
■U!

LB

OT-128
CO-717
CO-516
"CMF-01

1

CO-519
HER-063

CO-786
CO-787

OH- 198

CO-511

"CO-506
MARLG-8901

CO-403

AH-002
OT-112
HER-070
"FF-415

FF-480

HER-067
"JA-055

MA-056
CO-533
"CO-734

FF-468

UB

MRDB-0105
"AJA-5058
*ROU-O122

CO-548

MASTERS OF TRADITIONAL MISSOURI FIDDLING Lovely 2-LP set with huge booklet
VIRGINIA-CAROLINA SAMPLER Featuring Lonnie Austin, Jim Scancarelli, Wayne Henderson, etc
46 field recordings by John Lomax
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BANJO COLLECTION Super set of 1937
CARTER FAMILY "Diamonds In The Rough" Lovely issue of 1941 Border Radio transcriptions
BLGE SKY BOYS "There'll Come A Time" Excellent reissue of early 1936 recordings
TOMMY JARRELL "Sail Away Ladies" One of his best LPs- great old time fiddle
POSSGMGP A GUM STGMP Commercial and field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
FRENCH MITCHELL "First Fiddle" Fine fiddle LP by 71 year old West Virginian
87" Lovely 2-LP set of West Virginia musicians
THE MUSIC NEVER DIES"AVandalia Sampler 1977
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo/fiddle LP by this Kentucky musician
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Excellent reissue of their classic 1940s King sides

30
GRAYSON &amp; WHITTER Lovely set of songs and ballads from 1927
RILEY PGCKETT "Waitin' For The Evening Mail" Great reissue of Puckett's 1930s recordings
BLGE SKY BOYS "In Concert 1964" Super live concert from University of Illinois
Vol 3" Fine reissue of early 1920s recordings
GNCLE DAVE MACON "Hillbilly Blues
EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO With Tommy Magness, Roy Hall, Roanoke Entertainers, etc
PIONEERS OF CAJGN ACCORDION 1926 -36 With Joe Falcon, Amade Ardoin, Amade Breaux, etc
Vol 2 Featuring Tommy Jarrell, Oscar Wright, Fred Cockerham, etc
CLAWHAMMER BANJO
CHARLIE POOLE &amp; THE NORTH CAROLINA RAMBLERS -Vol 3 Great old-time recordings
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
Vol 2 Features Arkansas string bands of 1927 -30
ECHOES OF THE OZARKS
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, Andy Cahan, Brad Leftwich, etc
GETTIN' GP THE STAIRS Recent field recordings with Clyde Troxell, Clyde Davenport, etc
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN More field recordings with Virgil Anderson, Dee Hicks, etc
GID TANNER &amp; HIS SKILLET LICKERS "Early Classic String Bands" from 1934 recordings
MOUNTAIN BLGES Reissue with Sam McGee, JimmieTarlton, Dock Boggs, Doc Roberts, etc
SKILLET LICKERS Old-time tunes recorded form 1927 thru 1931
Clayton McMichen, etc
LGLG BELLE &amp; SCOTT Y "Tender Memories Recalled" From early 1950s radio shows- nice
ROANE COUNTY RAMBLERS Their complete recordings of 1928-29
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American Fiddle Music From Mississippi -with booklet
1932 recordings
JIMMY TARLTON &amp; TOM DARBY Fine reissue of 1927
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis, Roscoe Parish, w/booklet
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
WALT MICHAEL &amp; COMPANY "Step Stone" Features hammered dulcimer, fiddle etc
GALAX INTERNATIONAL 2-LP set featuring Mike Fenton, Kazuhiro Inaba, etc
MORGAN SEXTON "Rock Dust" Traditional Appalachian ballads with banjo &amp; fiddle
RALPH BLIZARD &amp; THE NEW SOUTHERN RAMBLERS "Blizard Train" OT fiddle from Tennessee
Vol 1 Featuring the music of Ernest Stoneman
ROUND THE HEART OF OLD GALAX
Galax Style" (Cassette only)
BONNIE RUSSELL/RUSSELL FAMILY "Mountain Dulcimer
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" Recent old-time music by this West Virginia group
MILL RUN DULCIMER BAND "You've Been A Friend To Me" Old-time, traditional, sentimental music
32 sessions
JIMMIE RODGERS "My Old Pal" Reissue of 18 songs from 1927
Import
NORMAN BLAKE/RISING FAWN STRING ENSEMBLE Featuring Nancy Blake, James Bryan
RIDIN' IN A OLD MODEL T Features Dixie Ramblers, Rector Trio, Ray Brothers, etc

(Above albums available on cassette as noted

■Q

by an

asterisk

"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
2.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
$10.00
7.50
7.50
$12.50
7.50

LA

||^l

1

P^l
H

$7.50

1

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
0.00

$7.50

7.50

|i^

")

to 3 LPs, add $3.00 for 4 or more LPs
&amp; HANDLING: USA ORDERS: Please add $2.00 for first
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Please add $5.00 postage and handling charges for up to 3 LPs,
then $1.50 for each additional LP. MINIMUM FOREIGN order is 2 items.
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES. DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

POSTAGE

$15.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
8.00
$15.00
7.50
7.50

QB
QB

�Reviews
on clarity and articulation
words
clearly pronounced, instrumental parts distinct; a

Artists and record companies

emphasis

ROUND THE

strongly syncopated internal rhythm; a tendency
to play tunes in G that are commonly done else
where in other keys. Overall, though, it is one of
those things that is just a lot easier to recognize
than to define. It mostly takes a lot of listening, and
there is no better place to begin than with these
three records, which nicely document the whole
range of Galax styles.
Volume i covers a pretty broad spectrum in
itself, being dedicated to the music of Ernest
Stoneman and the entourage of family, friends,
and neighbors with whom he recorded in the
1920s. Stoneman's repertoire covered most of the
traditional
types characteristic of Galax music
songs like "John Hardy" and "Buffalo Gals,"
nineteenth-century sentimental songs like "The
Old Hickory Cane," religious pieces, and dance
tunes. The solo pieces, especially "Sweet Bunch Of
Violets" show the peculiar sense of meter that
Stoneman shared with Fields Ward and other local
mixtures of three, four, and five (and
singers
other) beat measures that almost leave you won

please
send records and tapes for review to The
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Dur
ham, NC 27717- Do not send to indi
vidual reviewers.

HEART OF

OLD GALAX

Volume

1

Featuring Ernest Stoneman, County

2

Featuring the Ward Family, County

3

County 535

533

Volume
534

Volume

The Old Hickory Cane/Two

Little

More Goodbyes/John
There's A Light Lit Up

Orphans/No

Hardy/Barney McCoy/
In Galilee/Lonesome Road
Blues/Flop Eared Mule/Tell Mother Will Meet
Her/Buffalo Gals/I Am Resolved/Sweet Bunch
Of Violets/Too Late/New River Train: Ernest
Stoneman and others. Sugar Hill/Lost Indian/My
Only Sweetheart/Jackie Munroe/ A Married Man's
Blues/Ain't That Trouble In Mind/Way Down In
North Carolina/Die In The Field Of Battle/Skip
To My Lou/The Raging Sea/Jimmy Sutton/
Sweet William/ Watch and Pray: Crockett, Perline,
1

Fields, Samp, and Wade Ward and others.
I've Got A Bulldog: The Sweet Brothers and Ernest
Stoneman/ Train On The Island: John Preston N ester

Norman Edmonds/ Fox Chase: Wade Ward/
Ducks On The Millpond: Emmett, Kelly, and Geedy
Lundy/Yankee Doodle: The Pipers Gap Ramblers
and

Piney Woods Girl: The Sweet Brothers and Ernest
Stoneman/Black Eyed Susie: J. P. N ester and Norman
Edmonds /Waves On The Ocean: Emmett and Kelly
Lundy/Say Darling Say: The Sweet Brothers and Ern
est Stoneman/Old Dad: John Rector/Chilly Winds:
Ward Wade/ I Ain't Nobody's Darling: The Pipers
Gap Ramblers/ Mississippi Sawyer:
and Geedy Lundy.

Emmett,

Kelly,

For many years now, County Records has
devoted a part of its reissue catalog to collections
of music from specific regions. The state of Texas
got one volume several years ago, the state of Mis
sissippi three, and so on. This regional collection
devotes three volumes to the music of one small
town in Virginia.
Obviously there is something about Galax music,
though, as W ayne Martin's liner notes point out, it
is not very easy to say exactly what. The Galax style
is hard to pin down
geographically; it extends
through Grayson and Carroll Counties, as far
south as Mount Airy, N.C., north into parts of
West Virginia, and merges almost indistinguishably with other Virginia regional styles to the east
and west. It is hard to pin down technically, includ
ing clawhammer and finger-picked banjo, singlestring and double-stopped fiddle, and so on. There
are however, a few common features: a strong

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

dering if they understood 4/4 time until you hear
them do a dance tune straight. "Flop Eared Mule,"
speaking of dance tunes, is quintessentially Galax
not too fast, played in G, with the fiddle doing
most of the decoration, the banjo emphasizing the

syncopated beats,
bass line. There

and the guitar holding down the

also some fine family singing by
the Stonemans, Frosts, and Brewers, with their
Broadman Hymnals and Irma Frost's wonderful
reedy, wheezy organ on "No More Goodbyes" and
"I

is

Am Resolved."

2, featuring the Ward Family, relies
heavily on field recordings, since the Wards
recorded very little commercially. The dearth of
available Ward material in proportion to their
importance is evident from the fact that 7 of the 2
cuts on Volume 2 have been reissued on LP before.
It would have been nice, considering this, to have
had something from W ade's 1 929 Buck Mountain
Band sessions for OKeh, far better performances
than the nervous, jumpy "Trouble In Mind" by
Crockett and his Boys. (The Galax musicians seem
to have had a problem with the OKeh engineers in
Winston-Salem in the fall of 1927; both Fields
Ward and Walter Hanks remembered the session
as uncomfortable and musically unsatisfactory.)
This is nitpicking however. Some of the Wards'
finest performances are presented here, including
Wade's marvelous "Married Man's Blues," recorded
in 1925 and never issued before, two of Crockett
and Linie's unaccompanied ballad duets, and the
Bogtrotters' unequalled rendition of "Jimmy Sut
ton." Once again, as with Stoneman, the range of
material is impressive: dance tunes, ballads, hymns,
and what Fields used to call "tear-jerkers," a genre
often neglected by younger musicians.
Volume 3 is a miscellany of other local musi
cians. It is a little disappointing that 9 of the 14 cuts
have been reissued before, and two of those
remaining are of Wade Ward, who was well
represented on Volume 2. A number of important
Galax musicians don't appear at all. There is no
Henry Whitter, no John Rector (the banjo player),
no DaCosta Woltz (he was the mayor of Galax for
heaven's sake). None of this, though, detracts
if every
from the excellence of the performances
record ever pressed had a Wade Ward or an
Emmett Lundy cut on it, it would be hard to
complain. Besides, the hair-raising "Old Dad" by

Volume

1

John Rector (the fiddler) is worth the price of the
record, and a revelation to those of us who only
heard him in his later years. It is also a delight to
have cuts of the J. P. Nester-Norman Edmonds
duets that don't sound like they were recorded
from half a mile away. Only those of us who have
spent almost 30 years trying to hear this music
through a haze of scratch and distortion will fully

appreciate the job that County has consistently
done in providing clean sound without sacrificing
fidelity. Their high quality over the years has
spoiled us to the point that it was almost an after
thought to have mentioned it at all.
This would not be a proper scholarly review if I
didn't cavil and whine a little at the liner notes, so
here goes: The first Moose Lodge
sponsored
Galax Fiddlers Convention was not until April of
1935. Fields Ward moved to Maryland in 1947,
and was active musically throughout the '70s. Nester and Edmonds' "Train On The Island" isn't in
D. There are several other equally momentous
mistakes, but the experts will have more fun find
ing them themselves, and nobody else will care a
whole lot. None of them detract from the overall
excellence of W ayne Martin's set of mini-essays cn
Galax music, nicely balanced between specific
details on individual musicians and general com
ments on the uniqueness of the Galax regional
style.
In

summary,

if Galax

music were

a

school, this

set of records would be the core curriculum. It is
musician's
an essential part of every old-time

record library. (John Coffey)

�preferring their waltzes at least "some percent
Cajun if we can help it," and to giving everything
they sing "an atmosphere of both bluegrass and
some kind of old-time music." Having a variety of
inspirations is not rare, but the degree to which
Stecher and Brislin have integrated these styles and
made a style of their own is quite rare. It is impos
sible to separate out the different sounds on this
record; though it is true, for example, that Kate
and Jody have combined some of the sharp quali
ties of bluegrass with the rounder tones of old-time
music, the mixture is too subtle to be pulled apart
in this way. So, the Cajun flavor of the waltz ("Ala
bama W altz") is not just a style imposed on a song;
rather, the sound is utterly convincing, and it
seems as if this is just the way the waltz was born to
go-

Both vocals and instrumental are of the very
highest order. They especially show each other off
in the medleys of songs and tunes. In "Alabama
W altz/ W olves Howling" the unabashed sentiment
of the song is well-balanced by two versions of the
tune. Often, medleys will seem "artistic," as if they
are straining to create a mood or atmosphere
but this piece is no strain. Even the shift from slow
3/ 4 time to a lively hoedown does not seem
unnatural or forced.
"Hard Times/Dusty Miller" also does a good
job of blending two separate pieces of music. In

this case the tune comments on the song: "Hard
is Stephen's Foster's hopeful plea for hard
times to "come again no more," but "Dusty Miller"
is a dark, wailing sort of tune.
Though this version
is from J. A. Brown, the tune is well known also
because John Carson linked it with the song "Hard
Time a Comin'." Thus the medley associates Fos
ter's song with Carson's more pessimistic view.
Stecher and Brislin are not afraid to pour emotion
into their singing and playing, yet the tension
between optimism and pessimism in this medley
softens the sentiment, makes it both heart-rending
and bearable.
There are more strengths to this album than the
medleys. Here are some of my favorite moments.
In "Those Two Blue Eyes," Jody's bell-like guitar
gets bluesy, and the vocal floats expressively above
it. In. "Will You Miss Me," the duo shows that
they are unafraid to perform a well-known song,
and that they are well able to sustain a slow and
lingering pace. "Red Rocking Chair" is also a much
performed song, but here Kate and Jody sing it as I
have never heard it sung before: moody and slow,

Times"

accompanied

by a droning, banjo-like guitar part.
Of "Love Farewell," Stecher says that he recon
structed it from a fragment "only a few seconds
long and of uncertain origin, that I heard on an old
tape lent to me by John Cohen." This reconstruc
tion sounds old and true, not at all "written" or
overdone. The banjo's marchy rhythm accentuates
the mood of farewell, and the words contain all the
emotion of parting, but both are understated, so
that the feeling seems to be called from inside
oneself. As those who have attended their concerts
know, The Carter Family's "Orphan Child" is one
of Kate and Jody's favorite songs. Here on the
record, with harmonies and banjo and guitar, the

song sounds fully as rich and present as I have
heard in sound live.
In fact, the fine recording quality of the album
makes the songs sound good as live. Too often I
have heard recordings that just don't sound as
good as I know the musicians really are. I have been
disappointed so often that I sometimes wonder if
modern old-time music is suited to recording at all.
"A Song That Will Linger" erases my doubts. It
can be done, and done wonderfully well.
There is much to learn from this record about
singing and playing, and I know I will be listening
to it over and over for years, both to learn what I
can, and because the music on it just sounds so

good. (Molly Tenenbaum)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�4:00

in the morning, but they sound awtully
(strangely awful?) sitting in one's living
room in the middle of the day.
My favorite cut on the album is '"Bob's Fare
well.'" It seems to suit Joe's fiddling just right, not
too surprising considering he wrote this beguiling
modal number. But it is hard to pick a best cut.
There are a couple of ending problems here and
at

strange

there, and the above-mentioned vocal intrusions,
but, basically, all the tunes are similarly paced,
similarly styled, and similarly well played.
I don't
recommend this album to readers look

ing for a traditional old-time sound.
highly
recommend this album to fans of the Red Hots
(who undoubtedly already have it since it has been
I

out

at

least

a

year) and to fans of the festival-scene

sound, in general. You won't
(Linda Higginbotham)
To order: Joe Thrift, Rt.

N.C., 28676.

1,

be

disappointed.

Box 664, State Road,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�in the same key. The Prayers LP was
in

a

more diverse manner,

get solo passages,

as

marking

programmed

both Harry andjeanie
a

distinct contrast

to

singing. Robert Shelton, in his
book, The Face of Folk Music, lists Harry andjeanie
West among a distinguished group of "'performing
specialists'" of the 1940s and '50s "folk arrival."
They seem to have dropped out of sight for a while,
except for their long-time fans. Perhaps they are
due to be "rediscovered" by today's fans of close
harmony singing. While neither of these albums
will knock your socks off, they are both solid
their

harmony

efforts and are good entry points in learning to
appreciate the Wests. (Kerry Blech)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�of the band as well as some biographical informa
tion on the members. Most of the information is
about Lily May, the best known Coon Creek Girl.
This reissue of the Coon Creek Girls will please

people interested in old-time songs and singing
styles, and banjo enthusiasts will enjoy the playing
of Lily May Ledford. (Bill Mansfield)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�patchwork of African-American music, brightly
packaged and accompanied by a comprehensive,
scholarly booklet by folklorist Glenn Hinson. The
pamphlet, which is 25 pages long, describes the
music and performers presented on the album and
is illustrated with rare old and new photographs. It
alone is worth the price of the record. As you might

guess from the title, the selections represent both
the secular and the sacred sides of black musical
tradition. Appropriately enough, the Devil's music
and the Lord's music are kept physically apart. On
one side of the record, there are the "worldly" rags
and reels of secular life
tunes that were meant to
be danced and partied to
while on the other side
of the record are the songs of praise that electrified
religious gatherings in black communities all across
North Carolina. Through it all can be heard a
distinctive Afro-American touch: the music,

whether played on banjo, guitar, fiddle, harmon
ica, bones, or human voice is treated with a sense of
whimsical improvisation, interesting syncopation,
and above all, a highly developed sense of group
participation.
Side one, the "secular" part of the picture, fea
tures the reels, guitar rags and harmonica novelties
that were part of the entertainment at house parties
and "frolics" of pre- 1940 black communities in
North Carolina. Though I imagine that, by now,
most fans of old-time string band music are aware
of the impact of black traditions on their music, it
really is hard to overemphasize the profundity of
this influence. Threads of Afro and Anglo origin
appear to be so tightly intertwined that the tangle is

impossible
the banjo

old-time

to separate. In the first place, there
itself, certainly a crucial instrument
music, which is of course African

is
in

deriving from a skin-and-gourd arrangement the
slaves called a "banjar." Then, using a European
instrument, the violin, black fiddlers borrowed
tunes from Anglo-Celtic tradition, playing for
both black and white dances. Teaming up with
banjo pickers, slave fiddlers must have worked out
a few hot fiddle-banjo duets. Back and forth,
and round and round, the borrowing took place, so

quite

that, eventually, entirely new musical forms were
created, woven out of threads from both cultures,
but ending up as a colorful fabric pleasing to
everyone.
This recording, even though it was originally put
together to add a sound dimension to a 1978
museum exhibit celebrating the black presence in
North Carolina, stands alone quite successfully.
Though you cannot see these people singing, clap
ping, smiling, and playing or dancing, it is easy to
imagine the whole picture through the rich sound
portraits presented here. Even though the sound
quality is top notch, the spontaneity of playing and
singing makes you never forget that these are field
recordings. The songs were taped "live" in homes
and churches across the state, from the swampy
low country of Columbus County westward to the
foothills of the Blue Ridge in Caldwell County. For
the most part it is community music, played for the
shared enjoyment of family and friends and not

usually performed on a stage for strangers. For this
reason, you get the feeling that you have been
allowed into the private world of these people.
There is a sense of having been given permission to
enjoy something very special that was once a takenfor-granted part of everyday life. Cora Phillips,
whose exquisite slide-guitar rendering for John
Henry graces side one, expresses this well, remem
bering that back before radio, the phonograph and
TV, "music just filled the whole day."
Eight-Hand Sets and Holy Steps should be a wel
come addition to the record collection of anyone
interested in the roots of traditional southern
music. Readers of OTH will be especially inter
ested in the music of Joe and Odell Thompson,
cousins from rural Orange County north of Chapel

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Hill, who play dance tunes together on fiddle and
banjo. Just a few years ago, there used to be a small
handful of black fiddlers and banjo players in
North Carolina, but today, Joe and Odell are about
the only surviving examples of this once common
combination. Here they play two examples of their
"frolic" repertoire: "Georgia Buck" and "Going
Downtown." Trading the verses, they use the
words as rhythmic punctuation for the driving fid
dle and banjo. Odell's piercing tenor contrasts
nicely with Joe's more mellow baritone and it is
easy to imagine their voices and instruments
amidst the shuffle and din of several eight-hand
sets of dancers.
One thing that struck me about the dance and
house party music in particular was the touching
similarity of its role in both black and white rural
communities. An old photograph in the accom
panying booklet shows a group of black Granville
Countians hard at work shucking an enormous
mountain of corn. According to Joe and Odell,
they were probably anticipating an evening of
dance and music at the end of the work. I was
reminded of stories told by Tommy Jarrell and
others about playing music all night after barnraisings, corn-shuckings, and bean stringings and
thought of the floater phrase that appears in
"Suzannanah Gals"
"can't stay here if you can't
shuck corn." In both black and white communi
ties, a big dance party with fiddle and banjo music
was a fit reward for the completion of a huge,
arduous task.
Some musical highlights for me were: Thomas
Burt's eerie vocal and guitar rendition, on side two
(the "sacred" side) of "Lord, What Shall I Do?
With its gripping evocation of death, Burt's per
formance is testimony that tunes like Dock Boggs'
"Oh Death" and "Drunkard's Lone Child" had to
have been inspired by the playing and singing of
black musicians. Elizabeth "Babe" Reid's banjo
playing and her cousin Cora Phillips' guitar playing
are also interesting from our perspective. On "John

Henry, "they demonstrate the sparkling possibili
ties of clawhammer banjo and knife guitar. Other
enjoyable cuts are the tunes finger-picked on the
guitar. Sometimes considered women's music, this
was a style, which used an alternating thumb bass
underlying a treble played by one or two fingers. It
was a pre-blues way of playing favored by rural
blacks who took up the guitar in the early years of
the century, and, while not exclusively female
(Percy Lassiter and Elester Anderson use a similar
technique), seems to have had a special appeal to
women. Here, Algia Mae Hinton plays "Sweet
Home," "Buckdance," "Honeybabe," and "Chicken,
Lord, Lord" in this charmingly syncopated style,
her voice quietly riding on the ripple of guitar
notes.
The music on Eight-Hand Sets and Holy Steps
should have a ring of familiarity to players of oldtime string band music. It is easy to see here the

inspiration of many elements that

are now

inex

tricably part of the music we love: improvisation
and flexibility with a tune's verses; syncopation
that adds excitement to straight Anglo tune-lines;
instruments and techniques like the clawhammer
banjo playing, alternate-thumb/fingerpicking, and
the many ways of bending and sliding notes on a
stringed instrument so that they cry out with the
emotion of the human voice. This is exciting, vital
music, full of the intensity that folk traditions can
have when they still have value and meaning within
their communities, but it is also music with a qualifv of rimelessness that rnnHniies fn have universal
appeal

as

well.

(Gail Gillespie)

To order: Museum of History-Gift Shop,
Jones St., Raleigh, NC 27611

109

E.

�ings of country music commercially issued between
1923 and 1940. They will have the complete (or

so) recordings of the great masters such as
Macon, the Carter Family, Hutchison, Burnett and
Rutherford, the Skillet Lickers, Charlie Poole, Jimmie
Rodgers, Grayson and Whitter, and Eck Robertson,
as well as solidly representative samplings of the best
recordings by regional artists from the Ozarks, Missis
sippi, Texas, North Georgia, Kentucky, and Galax.
nearly

some ways, the exemplary 1987 collection, The
compiled by The Country Music
Foundation, stands as a coda to an era of reissue
rediscovery of the commercially recorded country
music of the 1920s and the Depression. The
continuing availability of these LPs (many long
since out of print and now as unavailable as the 78s
they reissued) is another matter, of course, as is the
occasional inexplicable gap in what compilers
chose to issue (where is Fiddlin' John Carson?).
Many thousands of sides of pre-war country 78s
remain unissued on LP, some of them music of
secondary but genuine interest which falls into two
types: second-rate work by great musicians, or highly
interesting material or performances by musicians of
lesser intrinsic interest. John Morris's Old Homestead
label appears to have appointed itself the champion of
both types, continuing vigorously to put forth LP
reissues of often obscure sides of musicians even as
the LP as a commodity continues its slide to oblivion.
Among the most intriguing of Old Homestead's ongo
ing projects has been the reissue of radio transcrip
In

Bristol Sessions,

tions made by the Carter Family in Del Rio, Texas,
between 1938 and 1942 for broadcast by the illegal
radio stations operating beyond FCC jurisdiction
across the Rio Grande. About 200 titles recorded on
aluminum discs by the Carters escaped being hauled
away to Mexico as salvage and nailed to the roofs of
buildings as shingles, a fate which apparently befell
great numbers of such radio recordings by other
artists.

The definitive

scholarly reissue of this material
the first LP of the John Edwards Memor
ial Foundation in 1973, The Carter Family on Border

appeared

as

101), complete with 60-page booklet,
photos, song notations, and 23 choice
titles skimmed from the 200 surviving radio trans
criptions. Four years later, Morris's Old Homestead
began its task of selectively reissuing further material
Radio (JEMF

discography,

from the original cache.
How valuable one will find the '"border radio" work
of the Carters will probably depend on one's fondness
for the group's commercial work on Decca (19361938), which immediately precedes the radio trans
criptions in the Family's chronology. Personally, we
have always preferred the Carter recordings of their
first Victor period 1927-1934) to any of their later
work. In those dawning days the group possessed a

just-born vigor, moving their songs along

at an

intoxi

cating pace and with a looser and wilder sound and
soul, as well as a youthful daring to gamble. Not only
were Sara's and Maybelle's voices younger and higher
in pitch, the group was willing to award an occasional
lead to A.P.'s charmingly wobbly solo voice. May belle

experimented with finger-picked guitar leads as well as
the occasional steel guitar lead, and Sara frequently
yodeled with adandon. Their material bit close to the
folk bone: "John Hardy," "Wild wood Flower," "Lit
master
tle Moses," "Engine 143," "Western Hobo"
pieces beyond naming. And was there ever an oldtime side to make one's hair tingle on the back of the
neck as does "Single Girl, Married Girl?"
In contrast,
by the Decca years the family had

found

seldom

a

comfortable format from which they were
background or

to stray again: A. P. well in the

missing altogether, May belle thumping a stately tempo
on the bass strings, and Sara dominating the lead in a
voice grown low and somewhat masculine (it is the
Sara of the Decca period that Mike Craver emulates so
well). To be sure, the Family produced more than
their share of masterpieces on Decca
"No Depres

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

sion (In Heaven)," "Hello Stranger," "You Are My
but these are nuggets
Flower," "Coal Miner's Blues"
among a body of less-than-inspiring cowboy genre
pieces or composed hearts-and-flowers. When John
Cohen asked people of East Kentucky what they
thought of the Carter Family, the reply he received
was, "They tuned their guitars too low." The com
ment could have well been directed at the Decca
material.

�Apparently, by 1938 Sara's and May belle's child
ren had begun appearing on the Family's shows, and
although Janette, Joe, Anita, June, and Helen Carter
never appeared on the Family's commercial record
ings, the schoolhouse stage in those days sometimes
held eight rather than three Carters. Five titles on this
album document the precosity of the Carter kids.
Helen, who in recent years has taken over the late
Maybelle's guitar role in the Family's appearances
with Johnny Cash, was already being groomed for this
role 50 years ago. At the age of 12, she pounds out an
instrumental version of Trankie and Johnny" in per
fect Maybelle style, and adds two autoharpaccompanied solos that remind us of many of the kid
performers recorded by the Lomaxes for the Library
of Congress. Helen, Anita, and June sing an all-toobrief ""Beautiful Brown Eyes' in an unselfconsciously
off-key trio. Janette in her solo of 'Nobody's Darling'

appears to be experimenting with a professional deliv
ery complete with country-western sob-in-the-throat.
Again, the sound quality is atrocious: 'Sinking In
the Lonesome Sea' sounds as though the ET were

being played at the bottom of a rain barrel. But the
original discs were intended neither for high sound
fidelity nor for repeated playings 50 years after they
were cut. Carter fans and students will treasure even
these echoes of a Carter Family the commercial
recordings never fully revealed.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�I don't know
why, in the 15 years this album has
been available, I never got it. Perhaps I spent most
of my energies purchasing pure fiddle records,
whatever. I remember seeing this band at the
National Folk Festival in 1972 and enjoying them
immensely. I knew that Asa Martin had played
guitar for Doc Roberts and had been on a record
ing and performing duet with James Roberts,
Doc's son. I knew Asa had done vaudeville and
that the Cumberland Rangers had done radio regu
larly for about 15 years. Asa even told me he had
courted Maybelle Carter in their youth. Why
hadn't I picked up this record before? It was my
great loss. This is an excellent record of laid back,
traditional old-time string band music from Ken

tucky. Martin's voice

is

warm and inviting. His

stage experience is evident as he stops singing and
talks to his audience. His material is geared to
please, with sentimental numbers and novelty
songs. An ace in the hole is fiddler Jim Gaskin,
raised in Monticello, Kentucky, where he followed

Leonard Rutherford around. Rutherford's style
rubbed off too, as evident in "Rutherford's Reel,"
which, in fact, is a rare old-time jig. An informative
20-page booklet, prepared by the producers, Guthrie
Meade and Mark Wilson, is included. I heartily
recommend this, with no restrictions. It should
bring
Blech)

a

smile to your face

as it

did to mine.
mine (Kerry

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Wilson Douglas' music, like that of so many
really fine traditional fiddlers, seems simpler at
first hearing than it really is. Although his smooth
and rolling style, with its heart-wrenchingly bit
tersweet tone has a more direct approach rythmi
cally than Tommy Jarrell's, Mr. Douglas is defi
nitely in the same league when it comes to those
indefinable little nuances that transform the ordi
nary into the extraordinary. Somehow he manages
to create a sound that is at once both the most
joyous and the most lonesome tone I have ever
heard come out of a fiddle. Because of his seem
ingly straightforward attack, however, his first
a great influence on younger fiddlers
who began to play in the 1970s. At West Virginia
festivals like Glenville and Vandalia Gathering, he
attracted and continues to attract small clutches of
fiddle disciples, but the subtleties of his playing
have always remained elusive. Although it is not
technically difficult to fiddle the same notes he
plays, coming up with the sound that Wilson Dou
glas coaxes from a fiddle is quite another matter
the product of a fortuitous combination of living in
an area saturated with extraordinary musicians,
obsessively hard work, and no small dose of

recording had

genius.
The Right Hand Fork Of Rush's Creek showcases
the variety of techniques and styles of which Wil
son is a master. "Cotton-Eyed Joe," "West Fork
Gals," and "Walking in the Parlor" are classic
dance tunes that roll along with effortless grace,
inspired by the fiddling of his grandmother Mor
ris, who taught him his first pieces. And, inciden
tally, if you have never heard the "real" "West
Fork Gals," Wilson Douglas' version is bound to
give you a new view of this powerful, stately tune,
which has all too often been transformed into
triviality in the hands of the less gifted. "Little
Rose," "Elzic's Farewell," "Camp Chase," "Shelvin' Rock." "Old Christmas Morning," and "Tem
perance Reel" are tunes that he learned under the
kindly but demanding tutelage of French Carpen
ter, Clay County's legenary master fiddler. This is
solo music that is archaic in both tuning and struc
ture and few, if any, musically inclined people in
Wilson's generation (b. 1922) ever went to the
effort of learning such tunes. W ilson was not typi
cal though. Becoming hypnotized by the sound of

Carpenter's ancient, twisty music, he literally
apprenticed himself to the old man, who lived near
the Douglas homeplace on Rush's Creek. Since
Wilson was distantly related to French through his
grandfather, many of these tunes were passed in
the spirit of bequeathing family heirlooms. Mr.
Carpenter had a heart condition which lent a sense
of urgency to the process, but Wilson was an
enthusiastically driven apprentice. In the liner
notes from the record, he describes his obsession,
which had an intensity that gives new meaning to
the old saw about genius being 1/10 inspiration
and 9/10 perspiration: "I'd work six days a week,
up to 2 o'clock in the morning with the fiddle.
Well, I'd come home and I'd go to bed and that
fiddle tune would keep pushing me; I couldn't
sleep, I could just almost put my finger on it. And
I've got up at 4 o'clock in the morning and played
that tune. And after I got it, I'd go to bed." You can
hear this all-consuming passion in every note the

man plays.
While his grandmother and French Carpenter
were probably his primary influences, Ed Haley,
the famous blind fiddler from Kentucky, was also
frequently in the area, staying for a week or so at a
neighbor's farmhouse. Wilson would ride his
rickety old bike the 1 2 miles to the neighbor's farm
and he and other admirers would keep Haley play
ing until the wee hours, dropping coins into his hat
for each tune. Douglas' "Forked Buck" is reminis
cent of Ed Haley's magnificent and ornate playing.
After so many years, it is really exciting to have a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

crisp new recording of Wilson Douglas to latch on
to. After being tantalized for so long with the one
recording and having had to make do with scratchy,

garbled home recordings, Wilson Douglas' many
admirers should rejoice at the release of Boatin' Up
Sandy. It is a tape recording, on the Marimac label,
produced by the Augusta Heritage Series, and it
has, packed into its miniature tape-label format,
liner notes that are nearly as comprehensive as
those on the Rounder recording. Unlike some
other more taciturn musicians, Wilson Douglas,
an articulate and expressive person, has thought a
lot about what the music means to him and the

importance of being able to inspire and teach oth
ers. On this recording the tunes are interspersed
with his comments, spoken in his distinctive,

husky voice (he lost his vocal chords years ago to
cancer). The liner notes, also largely in his own
words, give some idea of what a wonderful story
teller he

is

and add

immeasureably

to the

under

standing of the role of music in the lives of rural
West Virginians.
Several of the tunes on the new recording also
appeared on the 1975 record, but they often have
been given new twists. Partially, this is because he
has a new band, and, in part, some tunes have been
changed. "Paddy on the (Turn)Pike" is played here
in the standard "G" tuning, for example, which
gives it a different character from the cross-tuned
"A" version on the earlier recording. The new
band has a different style, as well, On the earlier
recording Speedy Tolliver's finger-picked banjo
and Douglas Meade's bluegrass-tinged
backup
really drove things along, but the new band, with
Kim Johnson's more gentle clawhammer banjo
and Mark Payne's solidly adept guitar, gives a
satisfying, more intimate sound. The recording
quality is a bit different, too. The older recording
had a brassy
hollowness, while the new one
sounds closer at hand, and a bit more mellow. It's
hard to say if this is really a qualitative difference
I like
both in different wa vs.
Other highlights are a great new version of "Blue
Eyed Miss," also known as "Suzannanah Gal," a
poignantly beautiful rendition of Ed Haley's "Coo
Coo's Nest," and a couple of surprises in the form
of a rag and a hornpipe: "Red Apple Rag," learned
from Chubby Wise and "Ann's Hornpipe, "from a
North Carolina fiddler. Several previously unre
corded tunes from French Carpenter are also
included: "Pretty Little Shoes," "Boatin' Up Sandy,"
and the haunting "Mouth of Stinson." An amazing
solo rendition of the Carpenter family's "Little
Rose" rounds out the first side of the tape. My
candidate for a "hit tune," however, would proba
bly be Wilson's version of Ed Haley's "Morning
Flower," a cheerful "A" tune to which Mr. Haley
once sang the words: "Go little children, go and go.
Down in the valley where the flowers grow."
sum, I couldn't recommend both the record
the tape more highly. These recordings are
absolute essentials in any old-time music fan's col
lection. Finally, since he has such a great way with
words, I'd like to end by paraphrasing a bit of
In

and

Mr. Douglas himself once gave another
musician: "He's a devil of a fiddler. I don't mean

praise

maybe!" (Gail Gillespie)

�DANCE AROUND
YOUR BONES

IN

The Laketown
Buskers
Real Time [no number]

Colin McCoy fiddle, guitar,
piano, kazoo; Eric Mohring
Barbara Silverman
guitar,
Bob Stelnicki
washtub bass,
Leavin'

saw, banjo, harmonica,
mandolin, fiddle, kazoo;
washboard, lead kazoo;
bones, spoons,

kazoo.

Home/ Ain't No Sin/Miller's Reel-Fisher's

Hornpipe/ Green Grow the Lilacs/Blues My Naughty
Sweetie Gives To Me/St. Louis Blues/You Rascal
You/Shake, Rattle, and Roll/Why Don't You Do
Right/Hesitation Blues/East T ennessee Blues /Ride
An Old
Dixie

Paint/Tennessee

Local/ Are You From

We first heard The Laketown

Buskers almost

ten years ago on "A Prairie Home Companion," in
the days before that show turned to Nashville for

One-time Minneapolis jug band patriarch
and bassist Bob Stelnicki had moved to Chicago
and founded a new hokum-skiffle band with a fine
fiddler in Colin McCoy and a stunning vocalist in
its talent.

Barbara Silverman. We eagerly bought the
Buskers' 1981 debut album Rolling Along (Vetco
520), and it found a place among those of our
albums which never strayed too far from our
turntable. In this cassette, the Buskers return with
a new
mandolinist and a new level of sophistica
tion in combining not only blues, breakdowns,
and hillbilly, but also some jazz and a bit of 1950s
rock 'n roll, all within the format of a fiddlemandolin band spiced with hokum stop-time
rhythm breaks on bones, washtub, spoons, and
rubbered. Unlike some revival hokum bands
whose insistent jollity yields a mushy ensemble
sound and covers sloppy picking, the Buskers play
crisp and clean instrumentals, with McCoy's
rosin-sizzling fiddle medleys notable. Silverman's
vocal prowess has grown impressively as she has
expanded her repertoire to include material from
W. C. Handy ("St. Louis Blue"), Benny Goodman
("Why Don't You Do Right"), and Tennessee
Ernie Ford ("Tennessee Local"). These perfor
mances, along with "Ain't No Sin," are the tape's
and, yes, these unlikely titles sound
showtoppers
just great with a skiffle back-up behind Silver
man's big, sexy delivery. The Buskers lack an
inspired male vocalist to complement Silverman
and consequently are just okay on the hillbilly
sides ("Are You From Dixie," "Leavin' Home").
But when McCoy cuts loose on his fiddle breaks
and Silverman struts her smoky, sultry stuff on the
jazz-flavored sides, you'll dance around in your
bones, too. (Jon and Marcia Pankake)
To order:

Chicago,

Barbara Silverman,
IL

60618

4019

N. Oakley,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Love Song of You/Sunriy Home in Dixie/ Chicken
Reel/Black Eyed Susie/Old Home Town/My

Father's

House/ Arkansas Traveller/June

Apple/Curtains of Night/Twinkle Little Star/
Highest Mountain/Sally Ann/I'llJustTakeltOut
In Love/First Whippoorwill/What a Friend We
Have

In Jesus.
Otis Burris, who passed away on Sept. 20, 1989,
is no stranger to these pages, as he was featured in
the February- April 989 OTH. Otis' fiddle style is
transitional, caught somewhere between the old
Galax styles and what could be called a new
1

style. Arthur Smith obviously was a
major contributor to Otis' style, but the regional
phrasing and musical turns never deserted him.
Otis in turn has influenced countless other fiddlers.
I suspect
that most of the local Galax area bluegrass
fiddlers who learned while Otis was dominating
fiddlers conventions in the '50s and '60s took a lot
of what Otis was offering. He influenced fiddlers as
far away as California (namely Hank Bradley, see
OTH, Winter '87-'88) who had the great fortune
to hear him with the Mountain
Ramblers at

bluegrass

fiddlers conventions

in Virginia and North Caro
lina or who heard him on record. Otis' health was
bad and he didn't play between the late 1970s and

1986. James Lindsey then assembled some past
and present members of the Mountain Ramblers,
and others, as a vehicle for Otis' wonderful
fiddling. Otis was equally adept at backing up
songs in a creative manner, or pushing dancers
around the floor at a square dance, or locking up a
blue ribbon with a terrifying breakdown. Here he
gets to back up the marvelous singing of Eldridge
Montgomery on seven numbers. Alice Gerrard
sings a strong harmony to Eldridge's leads. In fact,
they sound as if they have been harmonizing
together for years and years. Lindsey (on mandolin)
and banjoist Wendell Cockerham get to stretch
out some too, with occasional tasteful solos and
fills. The band treats us to some Galax area
standards, like a relaxed ''Sunny Home in Dixie,"
"Twinkle Little Star," and "Sally Ann." I was a
little disappointed in their version of "Chicken
Reel," as when I saw them in 1988 they were doing
a little
gimmick that hooked me
starting very
slowly and relentlessly increasing the tempo until
anyone still attempting to flatfoot would risk a
compound fracture. This version is a more trad
itional style tempo. Otis has sounded better in his
illustrious career, but I feel that can be excused
because he began treatment for cancer immediately
after this recording session. His fiddling on this
tape is still strong and creative; it only pales in
comparison with his own best efforts. This is a tape
representing the early days of bluegrass, when the
only things differentiating it from old-time music
were harmony singing. It was great when the
Mountain Ramblers did it and it's great when Otis
Burris and Fortune do it. (Kerry Blech)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�I

wish to purchase

a

1-year subscription to The Old-Time Herald for

Address
Enclosed

I

is

my check/money

wish to purchase

a

$18.00 (foreign)

order for $15.00

1-year subscription to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

I

is

my check/money

wish to purchase

a

$18.00 (foreign)

order for $15.00

1-year subscription to The Old-Time Herald for

Address

Enclosed

is

my check/money

$18.00 (foreign)

order for $15.00

Send to: The Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717

THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
is a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

wonderful gift

to give.

�Aulcimer
far

A

Christmas

A cassette album by Wayne
Seymour and Fred Reynolds

featuring ckJcimer. guitar, flute, bass, and
other instruments
13 tines and carols hdude "Stent bight",
"Joy to the World", "The Frst NoweT, "God
Rest Ye Merry, Gentlemen" 9 others.
$8.00 plus $150 sh^^png &amp; hancfcrg.
NC

residents add

J.

40

sales tax

ftr:

Ti&amp;ga"
Flyin' Cloud Records
Doug Rorrer
Rt 2, Box 436

Madson, NC 27025

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�HOLIDAY PHOTO BONUS

From the Kitchen of Ivery Kimble
Convention goers enjoy Ivery Kimble's Rum Cake at Galax, 1989. (Back L-R): Melvin Felts, A.C. Overton, Ray
Alden, Carol Sword, Dea Felts. (Seated L-R): Ivery Kimble, John Hatton, Wayne Martin.
Singer and guitar player Ivery Kimble's recordings with her family, the Kimbles of Laurel Fork, Virginia, are
documented on an LP, Eight Miles Apart and on a cassette tape recording, Mountain Music by the Kimble Family,
reviewed in the Spring '89 Old-Time Herald. A new tape with Ivery, her brother, Doris, Ray Alden, and Dave Spilkia,
is due out early next year. Ivery is currently a member of the Blue Sky Ramblers old-time band.
Ivery's Rum Cake
1
1
1

lA
V4

4

cup chopped pecans &amp; walnuts
18Vi oz. pkg. yellow cake mix
3 VI oz.

pkg. vanilla instant pudding &amp; pie filling

cup vegetable oil
cup dark rum
eggs

cup cold water.
Beat cake mix for 2 minutes at medium speed. Preheat over to 325°, grease and flour 10" tube or 12-cup bundt pan.
Sprinkle nuts over bottom of pan, mix all cake ingredients together. Pour batter over nuts, bake 1 hour, cool, and
invert on serving plate. Prick top, drizzle and smooth glaze evenly over top and sides. Allow cake to absorb glaze. Repeat
till glaze is used up.
Glaze: lA lb. butter or margarine; lA cup water; 1 cup granulated sugar; Vi cup dark rum.
Melt butter in saucepan, stir in water and sugar. Boil 5 minutes, stirring constantly. Remove from heat, stir in rum.
Note: If using cake mix with pudding already in mix, omit instant pudding, use only 3 eggs and only 1/3 cup oil.
P.S. I bake my cake at 350 instead of 325. All stoves are different.
Vi

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12180">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 2, Number 2 (Winter 1989-1990)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12181">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12182">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 2, Number 2 (November 1989-January 1990)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“100 Essential Old-Time Albums,” by Kerry Blech&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dwight Lamb – A Western Iowa Fiddler,” an interview by Davd A. Brose&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Whip the Devil Around the Stump – The Story of the Helton Brothers,” by Bob Carlin with accompanying article by Alice Gerrard &amp;amp; Wayne Martin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Remembering Kahle Brewer,” by Craig Johnson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Starting a Community Dance,” by Toni Williams&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Bowing Workshop,” by Brad Leftwich&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘Valley Forge’ fiddle tablature,” by Carl Jones&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12183">
                <text>1989</text>
              </elementText>
              <elementText elementTextId="12547">
                <text>1990</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="967">
        <name>1980s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="971">
        <name>1989</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2159">
        <name>1990</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="999">
        <name>1990s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5428">
        <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5556">
        <name>Bob Carlin</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5559">
        <name>Carl Jones</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5528">
        <name>Craig Johnson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5554">
        <name>David A. Brose</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5553">
        <name>Dwight Lamb</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5555">
        <name>Helton Brothers</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5557">
        <name>Kahle Brewer</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5433">
        <name>Kerry Blech</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5558">
        <name>Toni Williams</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5543">
        <name>Wayne Martin</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2522" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3448">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/abe3011726c0ea8eb56500f6a7f0ca2a.pdf</src>
        <authentication>60bac5331a8b80c9c6a63247bc02c11a</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12184">
                    <text>February

April

1990

Spring $4.50
THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
A

MAGAZINE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

DEDICATED

TO

OLD-TIME

Etta Baker
One Dime Blues

MUSIC

�FESTIVALS!

CONVENTIONS!
are
Just Around
Advertise

The Corner!
Your Event
In The

OLD-TIME HERALD
Reasonable

Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717
for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

^OT.D-TIME HERALp^
A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Vol. 2, No.

3

FEATURES
IN THE BRITISH ISLES
by Joan Kaminkow

7

ONE DIME BLUES
An Interview with Etta Baker
by

IN PRAISE OF BANJO PICKING
by

9

Lesley Williams

WOMEN

"MUSIC IS ABOUT FEELINGS"
An Interview with Tommy Hunter
by

13

Mike Seeger

17

Hilary Dirlam

FESTIVAL GUIDE, 1989

21

COLUMNS
The Dance Beat
Oscar Roberson

"Lean Mean Clogging Machine"

Workshop

Paul Brown

Issues In Old-Time Music
Confessions of a Folklorist
by

5

Phil Jamison

by

16

25

Joe Wilson

Ask Uncle Harold

32

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS

2

CLASSIFIED

32

REVIEWS

35

�Letters

The Old-Time Herald welcomes letters.
They should be typed or neatly written, and
signed. They may be edited and we will print
them according to space available.
The
opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect
those of the Old-Time Herald.

Hold The

Cake--

Add More Rum
One little thing you might want to
correct: we used ½ cup of rum in the
cake instead of ¼. It won't hurt a thing,
but using ½ cup in the cake will make
everybody happier hal! or taste more
rum, of course. It's ½ cup for the cake
and ½ cup also for the glaze. [See back
cover OTH vol. 2, no. 2 for recipe.]
Ivery Kimble
Laurel Fork, VA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Score

1

For Harold

this note with respect to
I am writing
the letter written by Harold Hausenfluck
(vol. 1 no. 7) and to the comments that
have followed. In this letter Harold gives

about how old-time country
being interpreted today.
I have had the good fortune of knowing
Harold personally for the last 4 years. I
am familiar with his musical talents and
his knowledge in the field of old-time
country music. He has been a major

his views

music

is

inspiration to me and my studies of this
music.

As far as I am concerned, Harold is an
absolute genius in this field and he
totally devotes himself to it. He truly
does have an "encyclopedic" memory of
the history of original performers and
recordings. He can also take the style of
an old-timer and play it almost exactly

like the original. I have never met anyone
with a talent this exceptional.
I have great respect for Harold's playing
ability, his knowledge and his authenticity
of style. If anyone deserves listening to,
he does. His only fault (if it is a fault) is
that he is a perfectionist.
In your "Ask Uncle Harold" column,

how about
Hausenfluck

asking

Uncle

Harold

he's real!!!

Susan Campbell
Bryn Mawr, PA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

heroes from the past, and no one should
expect to. Musicians generally accept
this marginal existence as coming with
the territory. The point I was trying to
make from my personal experience was
that

a

full-time performing old-time band

such a marginal operation at best, that
even a small bit of support, say one or
two prestigious jobs out of 52 weekends,
is

can make an enormous
I'm very well aware

difference.
of the limited

funds that folklorists have to work with
and the difficult choices they must wrestle
with. The problem is that they persist in
seeing the issue in terms of whether it is
us or the old-timers who more needs or
deserves their money. This unfortunate
point of view casts the two generations
of musicians as rivals. Obviously the
funds available are woefully inadequate
as an economic assistance program or a
system of rewards. I'm simply suggesting
that folklorists could get more value for
their dollar if they made their choices
based on what would best strengthen the

continuation of the tradition.
I
certainly agree that 'living rooms,
and community dances, and weekend
field parties' are where old-time music is
most at home and I hope with all my
heart that it continues to flourish on that
level. The difficult point I've been trying
to raise in both my articles is that the
world has changed in such a way that the
a tradition even on an
amateur level is increasingly dependent
on some degree of success on a profes
sional level. I don't mean necessarily that

continuation of

people should

be

able

to

depend on

music as their sole means of support. I
mean simply that musicians must be
willing and able to pursue such profes
sional activities as performing, recording,

touring,

teaching,

etc.

With

the

community of old-time music lovers no

longer bounded by geographic areas or
kinship groups, but atomized through
out the country, access to the avenues of
mass

communication

keep the musicians and
touch with each other.

performances, and TV
today's equivalent of

necessary to
their audience in
Records, festival
appearances are
what the house
is

the barn dance, and the street
corner show were to a century ago. The
means of performance are equally
appropriate to their times. The big
difference of course, is that today's means
entail much greater overhead.
It's obvious that the current lack of
party,

performance opportunities for old-time
music is a reflection of the general decline
of interest in things traditional among
the American public at large. Who can
the cause and which
the effect? What seems clear is that these

say for sure which

is

things work like a spiral and that the
current direction is downwards. We can
either do what can be done to reverse the
trend or we can allow it to run down to
the point where old-time music on a
professional level is no longer even a
remote possibility. I'm afraid I don't see
anything built into the system which
would make the present trend auto
matically reverse direction at a certain
point like

pendulum.
are my points again in a
nutshell: 1) the current generation of
old-time musicians is an indispensable
So

a

here

link in the chain of the tradition; 2) some
degree of commercial success is necessary
for the survival of old-time music; and 3)
acceptance of points 1 and 2 by the
public sector folklorists would be of
great benefit to the continuation of the

music we love. No regrets, no resentment,
no jealously, no greed, no blame, no
wishful thinking. I hope I have stated it
clearly enough this time so that you all
may respond to the IDEAS and not get
thrown off the track by what you presume

my ATTITUDE to be.
Those of you who disagree with me,
please take a survey among all the old-

time musicians you know, young and
old. See how many were originally in
spired to embrace old-time music by a
performance or record or other form of
commercial musical activity. If it's not a
clear majority, then I'm dead wrong and
I'll gladly shut my trap. If you have data
to

show that

as

new people are

many

being drawn to the music as back when
the Fuzzys, the Hot Muds, the Gyppos,
the Chokers, the Swamp Roots, the
Corklifters, the Red Clays, et al, were
barnstorming around the country, please
share it and take a load off my mind. If
you have a plan to ensure the survival of
music into the future which does not

include

us

love to hear

so-called
it

'revivalists,'

I'd

and be able to put my

concerns at rest.
Those of you who do agree with me,
please don't get so caught up in the
controversy over the role of folklorists
that you forget what

I

said in my first

OTH article. It would be great to have
some help from the folklore establish
ment but it is ultimately our responsibility,
as old-time musicians and old-time music
lovers to make sure the music has the
commercial success it needs to keep
going. Please, no bashing of folklorists
they are our natural allies, and the trad
ition needs us to be working together
once again.
Mac Benford

Trumansburg, NY

�The Dance Beat

OSCAR ROBERSON
"Lean Mean Clogging Machine''
by

Jamison

Phil

The

dance music

is

almost non-stop

at

the summer fiddlers conventions in North
Carolina. Bands line up backstage for the
contest and come out one after the other
to play their best tune. Out in front of
the stage dancers of all ages, sizes, shapes,
and abilities, take advantage of the endless
supply of dance music.
With sheets of plywood and home
made clogging boards laid out on the
ground, each dancer is on an individualsized dance floor. Some people jump up
from the audience to 'cut a rug' for only
a few tunes, while others seem to be out

there dancing all day and all night with an
endless supply of energy. The dancers
are fun to watch. Especially so are the
older buck dancers, whose styles and
repertoire of steps have not been stand
ardized through lessons or workshops,
but have evolved over a lifetime of
dancing.
One dancer in particular always attracts
bit of attention. Over by the
a good
speakers at the side of the stage, he is one
of those who never seems to tire. Some
times he shares his clogging board with
others, but often he is out there all alone.
He has a repertoire of steps to match his

endless energy and sometimes he looks
as though he is thinking up new steps as
he dances. All of a sudden he'll leap into
the air and click his heels or swing a leg in
a high kick over his head.
His attire is as unusual as his unique
dance style. Decked out in an old-time
outfit with suspenders and a hat that
reads 'Whatever' across the front, he is
hard to miss. His name is Oscar Rober■on, and if they gave out awards for
originality and endurance at these events,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

would win every time.
Oscar is living proof that you're never
too old to start clogging. At age 76 he is a
relative newcomer to the dance scene. In
his youth the only dancing he did was
ballroom dancing. It was not until 1982,
at age 69, that he started to learn clogging
steps. In an interesting twist on the
passing along of a traditional dance form,
Oscar learned, not from his father,
but from his son, Greg, who has been a
member of the Green Grass Cloggers for
he

many years.

Oscar's home is in Robersonville,
North Carolina (pop. 2500), a town
founded by his grandfather, George, in
the eastern part of the state. Until he
general and
farm supply store. Greg was bitten by the
clogging bug before his dad, learning
with the Green Grass Cloggers in nearby
Greenville. On visits home he would
dance for his family, and eventually,
Oscar asked to be taught a step. After
learning a few steps, Oscar began to
show up when the Green Grass Cloggers
performed locally and he started hitting
local music festivals, including the annual
Green Grass Cloggers Day.
Oscar says,
Green Grass Cloggers Day was
observed in Greenville one day
each year and I attended and learned
to clog. Since then I have clogged
100,000 miles and plan to double

retired,

he ran the family

that.
I

do only freestyle, no precision

or team dances. I'm not

altogether

sure about the differences between
buck, flatfoot and clog. At Charlotte
(N.C.) I won the buck contest, but

Union Grove, 1987

courtesy Oscar Roberson

don't remember what I did. Free
style covers most everything.
Raymond Fairchild said that I
clogged like it should be done, said

was the real thing. He's from
Maggie Valley, Clogging Capitol of
the World. Should I argue with
I

him?

have won

a few clogging prizes,
plan to win more. I need to
brush up on what the judges expect.
I think my
steps are too wild for
them, but as long as I get a good,
great, crowd response, I'll keep
I

but

I

Doinc.

Chip Summey, an Asheville in
structor and judge, said that I was a
'real showman.' He said 'really,
really great showman.' Of course
he wasn't making me mad with
statements like that.
At the Mt. Airy clog contest, I

a curtain
call. Called back to
quiet the crowd. Never saw that
before, but I didn't place in the top
four.
Each year Oscar heads out in his
camper van to attend about 35 festivals
across the southeast. I wonder at how

got

�many different places he is mistaken for
He stays in Florida during the
a local.
winter months where he dances at clog
competitions, workshops, and fiddle and
bluegrass festivals. He speaks highly of
the Strawberry Festival and Plant City,
Florida, which lasts for ten days and has
lots of good music and some clogging.
His favorite music events are in his home
state of North Carolina. They include
the fiddlers conventions at Mt. Airy,
Galax and Union Grove.
Wherever he goes, Oscar entertains
the crowd and inspires others to dance.
He has made friends and fans across the
country. Always equipped with four or
five clogging boards, (he owns ten) he
welcomes other dancers to join in.
He says, "There's always room for
everyone, especially pretty girls."
I
asked Oscar to share his thoughts
about music, dance and life in general.
This is what he said.
I
favor old-time clawhammer
banjo music and I like long pieces
(15 minutes). I like many bands:
Doodle and the Golden River Boys,
Dry Hill Draggers. I'd rather hear
old-time. There are some good
bluegrass tunes, but old-time is
better, played fast.
When the string music gives out,
I clog
to country and rock. Good
rock music ain't all that bad, and
the younger groups are using mostly
rock-type music. I still use clog
steps, which puts me way ahead of
the other young people who are
just "hunching."
The old saying, "Every day is
like Christmas," applies to me,

especially if

I

am in the

vicinity of

think "old-time" music,
but I don't think "old-time" any
thing else. I think "young-time"
and look to the future.
Why not?), a
Quid non, (Latin
music.

I

favorite quote by Sir Humphrey
Gilbert. On all my hats wear the
phrase, "Whatever," and on my t1

shirts

1

have, "Lean Mean Clogging

Machine."

I've made more money since
stopped work in the market. While
you're working you don't have
time to make money. You're too

I

a living.
you can cope with change, you
can stay young. If you can't, you

busy making
If

doomed to become old and
complaining. Pay the 75 cents for
coffee and enjoy it. Not much you
are

can do about it.

reach 100 years, I plan
"How To" book and live
out my older years from the sales.

When

to write

I

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

But

Dizzy Dean says, "If you've
ain't braggin'."
retired at 50 and have been
as

done
I

it, it

swinging free ever since

at

an

accelerated pace. Plan to live to

be

100. Might not make it, but I'll
come closer with a plan.
A good health rule is: Find an
exercise that you like and stick
with it. I've got mine, clogging. I
also hike, walk, rock-climb, bicycle,

white-water kayak. Hope that

and

I

don't sound too much like a human
dynamo, but you either use it or
lose it.
My engine runs on sweat. It's
cheap fuel, but it's hard to come
by

I

have very good oints and exercise
j

(clogging) keeps them that way.

I

can kick higher than my head and

when the band plays a Twist, I
shine.
I seem
to have unlimited endur
ance and can dance from noon til
midnight, with a short supper break.
I have
a good raw diet, and lungs
that hold plenty of oxygen. W atermelon is high on my summer diet
and I believe that it's a super health
food. Lots of water, sugar, and
vitamin A.
I'm looking forward to a great
season in Florida. I know many
people at all the festivals and have
more fun than any one person

should have.

The bluegrass bands don't care
much for doggers, but the oldtime bands love it. Many men and
about all women want to learn to
clog and that is fine with me. Also,
kids like to dance by the hundreds
and that's also great with me.
Let's hope that Oscar continues his
quest and inspires many others to dance;
after all, you are never too old to start.

�If

you

travel

eastwards

across

the

Atlantic Ocean for 3,000 miles, you'll
come to a land mass known as the British
Isles. They say that a few hundred years

or so ago, a lot of folks from the British
Isles went to America and took their
traditional music and dance with them,
thus playing a role in the development of
today's traditional Appalachian clogging
and old-time music c. If you travel back to
the British Isles and spend some time

there, you'll get to see and hear some of
that influential music and dance and find
out for yourself how things came to be.
You'll also see how American old-time
music's sound, look, and feel are slowly
making their way back from the United
States.

for

photo

by Joan

Kaminkow

In Great Britain, folk clubs are a very
popular venue for music, song, poetry,
or monologue. Although most folk clubs
feature professional or semi-professional
performers, many offer regular singarounds where the individual can con
tribute to the evening with his or her
own special talents. These clubs range
from the strictly traditional, featuring
unaccompanied ballads, chanties, etc.,
to an anything-goes type of atmosphere
where one may find the odd saxophone
or a dirty ditty from English music hall
tradition. In either case, songs sung at
folk clubs often contain a chorus where
the crowd loudly joins in. Although
most folk clubs are held in pubs, a pub,
whether it hosts a folk club or not, may
feature evenings devoted to get-togethers

1988 Edale Bluegrass Festival

musicians.

Folk festivals in Great Britain provide
another outlet for amateur or professional
performers, and often provide a special
area, pub, or room for the festival-goer
to join in some type of organized music
sessions. Popular instruments at these
sessions include melodeon, penny whistle,
bodrhan, guitar, fiddle, and accordion,
and it is often here that one may find the
original English, Irish, or Scottish
versions of many songs or tunes of oldtime notoriety. "Soldier's Joy" and
"Fisher's Hornpipe" come to mind as
two of the most traditional tunes often
heard.

Most people in these folk music circles
what bluegrass is, but haven't
a
situation
heard of old-time music
resembling that in the States. There are
many bluegrass clubs and a few yearly

know

festivals.

Bluegrass

audiences

are

enthusiastic and widespread. However,
if one travels around a bit and looks hard
enough, old-time sounds will be found.
From north to south, there are little
pockets of people interested in, if not
dedicated, impassioned, or even hooked
on, the sounds of old-time music. Their
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

IN THE BRITISH ISLES
by

Joan Kaminkow

access to the music, of course, is limited,
so they crave information, new tunes, or

knowledgeable American. There doesn't
a band
devoted entirely to
playing old-time music, probably due to
a

seem to be
the

distances

separating

interested

musicians. Because of the limited access
to old-time music, many of those who
perform it use a standard or limited
repertoire of tunes. However, the ded
icated musician will delve deeper and
pursue further material and instruction.
For example, in 1988 two British
musicians eagerly attended old-time
music

week

the Augusta Heritage
Elkins, W. Va., learning
from such old-time music greats as
Matokie Slaughter, Bruce Greene, and

Workshops

at

in

Melvin Wine.

As far as Appalachian-style clogging
goes, it is a lot easier to find than oldtime music. In the Midlands there is
Chesterfield's Feet First, a large, well-

known group, originally taught by the
Feet First Cloggers from Pennsylvania.
With regular performances at many of
the folk festivals, this group appears to
be the most popular and influential of
the British/American-style
clogging
groups. In the South, there's a group
called the Broken Ankles, taught by a
fellow group member who lived in the
United States for two years. Other groups
like Touch- wood or Roughshod are
scattered throughout the country. The
number of people interested in this
dance style is definitely strong, evidenced
by the 150 or so people who attended
the 1988 weekend workshop hosted by
Feet First, or by the 988 Sidmouth Folk
Festival where the clogging workshops,
led by the Wild Goose Chase Cloggers
from Minnesota, seemed to be the best
attended. Many American-style cloggers
1

continued on page 42

�one-room cabin, living

in that same

on the wages of hard labor,
ing work

basket factory, in
in Gary steel
His wife left about 1960,
in

construction,
mills.

later

a

and

divorced

photo

by

David

B.

Sutton

they
never remarried.

FOLK MUSICIAN
LOTUS DICKEY
DIES AT AGE 77
by Teri

It is

Klassen

unclear now who will fiddle

the 3 a.m. set at Bloomington's all
night old-time dances.
Or who will keep young musicians
awake with endless tales of long

trips, and who will break into song
as soon as eat or breathe.
Quentin Lotus Dickey, who did
all of that and performed at folk

concerts,

schools,

festivals

and

dance camps across the country,
died Thanksgiving night at Orange

County Hospital. He was 77.
Dickey was born and lived in
Muncie as a boy until his parents
moved to a cabin on top of a
southern Indiana hill on Grease
Gravy Road. The spot is just south
of Paoli, about 50 miles south of
Bloomington. Much of Dickey's
life was spent raising eight children

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

includ

and

Dickey

Music was important in his family
when he was a child. But his lifelong
passion for writing songs, in spare
moments at work in the garden or
at night while his children fought
in their beds upstairs, brought little
recognition until he was in his late
60s. The road to folk-world pro

minence led first to Bloomington.
An Indiana University folklorist
who "discovered" Dickey in 1981
and often performed with him said

years did not seem to have
reduced his musical endurance.
"He used to call me at any hour
of the night if he'd thought of a
song, and he would sing as much as
he had composed to me over the
phone and ask me if I liked it and of
course I always did," said folklorist
Nancy McEntire. "He would still
be playing when people one third
the

Dickey made a few trips to Nash
ville, Tenn., in the 1960s to try to
sell his songs. Country singer Ronny
Shaw put "God Made Woman for

the Man" on

45. But not until

a

was retired did he get

Dickey
ional recognition.

nat

McEntire and Massachusetts folk
lorist Dillon Bustin, who studied
in Bloomington and once lived in
Orange County had much to do
with introducing Dickey to the
folk-music world in 1981. Bustin
arranged for Dickey to give a concert
at the Library of Congress in W ashington, D.C. "From then on it was
stream of concerts and
a steady
festivals all over the country,"
McEntire said, including the National
Folk Festival in 1984.
Friends of the family and Dickey's
children said the years since his
music gained recognition have been
the happiest of his life. The day
before he died, in some pain, Dickey
asked his children to pray for his
death. As the words of a gospel
song he wrote indicate, he said he
was not afraid to go.

his age had given in to exhaustion
and fallen asleep."
He finger-picked guitar, and used
it usually as a backup to singing or
fiddling. His fiddle-playing and the
shuffle dance-step he did were gener

Ever onward on my way I'll go.
I'll follow his command.

I'll trust in him.

He'll guide me right

I

know.

I'm standing on his promise

ally in the old-time hoedown style.
his songs covered a broad

in the hollow of his hand
As ever onward on my way
I'll go. m

But

range of styles and topics.

There are novelty songs, ballads,
biblical and gospel songs, lullabies,
blues, and many love songs, some
playful, some tender, some sensuous,

some haunting. His voice moved
easily from bass notes to falsetto,

untrained, unaffected and true to
the mood of lyrics and melody.

(published

permission

by

of the

Bloomington Herald Times, con
densed from
on

an

11/25/89.)

article appearing

�Blues

OneDime

An Interview
with Etta Baker

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

that if they started me out with the best,
I'd be hooked. They were right.
The term fieldwork belies what a
recording session with Etta Baker is
really like. The setting alone lends itself

Lesley Williams

descriptions which seem just a little
romanticized. Her home of 43 years in
Morganton, North Carolina, is surround
ed by an impeccably manicured lawn
where a stray leaf would not dare to
settle, and a hedge which looks like it was
trimmed with barber's shears. The inside
of her house is as fertile as the outside,
with houseplants in virtually every room.
A cageful of finches chatters away in the
kitchen, taking every opportunity to get
in on recording sessions. Etta herself is a
person of tremendous warmth. Regard
less of how long she's known them, Etta
treats everyone like an old friend. When
first meeting and talking with Etta, you
suspect that you are with a very special
person. When you hear her play, you are

to

sure of it.
Etta is a master of the finger-picking
style of guitar known as Piedmont blues.

With her two- and three-fingered picking
style, Etta creates music not unlike her
self: subtle, gentle, and strong; accessible

by Jon

Zachary,

courtesy

Folklife

Office,

N.C.

Arts

Council

but complex;

photo

by

As

a
folklore intern for the
North Carolina Arts Council's Folklife
Section, one of my first fieldwork exper
iences has been recording guitarist Etta
Baker. I think the office's rationale was

fundamentally

beautiful.

Etta's muse is not confined to music.
Asked how her father, Boone Reid,
made his living, Etta Baker responds that
he was a farmer, hunter and log cutter.
Then she adds, 'He mostly enjoyed life.'
Judging by the spirit which she brings to
everything she does, Boone seems to
have taught his daughter well.

1913 in Caldwell County,
Carolina, Etta grew up in an

Born in

North

environment with music. She recalls that

a child she would wake up to the smell
of breakfast cooking and the sound of

as

her father's guitar. Evenings often drew
to a close with the Reid family playing
music late into the night. Music was in
the bloodlines: her grandfather was a

banjo player; her father played not only
guitar, but banjo and fiddle as well;

�harmonica and Jew's harp were

her

mother's instruments. All six of her
brothers and sisters played instruments,
as did aunts, uncles and cousins. Not
surprisingly, Etta tried as early as possible
to get in on the act. When she was three

years old and still too small to hold the
instrument, she would place her father's
guitar in the middle of the bed and try to
pluck out chords. Her father finally

bought her a small guitar of her own.
Etta also learned to play fiddle, piano
and banjo at

a

young age.

courtesy

Etta

Baker

When she grew older, Etta would
perform 'around the settlement' with
her family. Corn shuckings, entertain
ments, dances there was always a
community social event at which they
could play. The Piedmont music scene in
which Etta grew up was noteworthy in its
degree of racial integration. Etta grew up
playing with white and black musicians,
and for integrated audiences in social
settings as well. As folklorists Glenn
Hinson and Bruce Bastion have noted,
the level of interaction was such that
musicians drew freely upon both Europeon and African-American traditions,
resulting in a Piedmont musical style and
repertoire that was shared by both blacks
and whites. Blacks and whites were inter
woven not only in the fabric of their

L-R Elizabeth

fun.'
It

and

big midnight dinners.

It

home. But she was and is different,
observing, 'I'm happy to be out there."

At any rate she did decide to settle down,
and she and Lee were married in 1936.
Although she played around town
some with Lee and her family, Etta's
playing activities had to yield to other
demands. In 1936, the first of Etta's and

Lee's nine children, twins Darlene and
Irene, were born. For the first eight or
nine years of their marriage, the family
lived in Lenoir, where Lee worked as a
mechanic. The Bakers then moved to
Morganton in order to take advantage of
Lee took a job in
a better school system.
a
furniture factory and in 1949, Etta
went to work at Skyland Textiles. The

of family and job curtailed
Etta's playing in the '40s and early '50s.
"A lot of times I wanted to go on, on the
road, you know, playing my music but it
was hard to do that and raise a family,
and hold on to my job."
Lee's objections also kept Etta from
playing out. "He just didn't want me to
be gone away from home but he loved
my music," she recalls, "and I said well, if
I mean to make home and stick with the
family I got to listen." Though he was a
talented piano player himself, Lee wasn't

demands

was

seemed only natural that Etta, Cora,
Babe would all marry musicians.

Cora married Theopolis 'The' Phillips,
a guitar and banjo player whose brother
A1 also played guitar. Babe married Fred
Reid, a triple threat on banjo, guitar and
harmonica. Etta herself married a piano
player, Lee Baker. Lee lived not far from

Etta, and played at entertainments. Along
with his good looks and his dancing skill,

particularly interested

Etta cites Lee's love of music as the thing
that attracted her to him. 'He loved
music and he was nice looking and he
was just a really nice guy. He was real
good. But it was a long time before
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Moore, Etta, Cora Phillips,

could make up my mind I wanted to
settle down so it [courting] went on for
maybe five or six years.' Maybe this was
because of her independent nature, or
maybe it was her love of travel. Etta says
that most women at this time didn't play
out much, preferring to stay right around

music but in other aspects of their lives.
Etta's own family can claim Irish and
Native American lineages, as well as
African- American.
As a young woman, Etta would 'play
out' with her sister Cora on guitar, her
father on banjo and herself on violin.
She performed with her cousins, notably
Elizabeth 'Babe' Reid, also an accom
plished guitar and banjo player. It is the
gatherings of her own extended family
that Etta recalls most fondly. 'There was
enough of us that we would get started
playing and play every night at one's
house, you know, a different one's house,
for a week. We would get to playing
music and cook at night just like through
the day

"Babe"

1

in going out on
the road. "He just wasn't too much for

wanting to leave

home to

go

anywhere."

Music continued to be a part of her life,
however. Etta played at home in the
evening after work with the children
listening or joining in.

ca.

1924

Although she was not playing in public,
happy coincidence gained Mrs. Baker a
wide audience. In 1956, while vacationing
one weekend at the Moses Cone Mansion
in Blowing Rock, in the North Carolina
mountains, Lee and Etta met a man from
New York who was playing guitar. Lee
told the man that if he wanted to hear

someone really play the guitar,

he

should

hear his wife play. The man then sur
rendered his guitar to Etta and was so
impressed with the results that one week
later he came to her home to record her.
The man was Paul Clayton, and the
recordings he made along with Liam
Clancy and Diane Hamilton became Instru
mental Music of the Southern Appalachians
(Traditions 1007)- Boone, Cora, and
The are also featured on this acclaimed

album.

Though the album provided no infor
mation about any of the artists it featured,
Etta's performance on it made her legend
ary in certain circles. Her performance of
"One Dime Blues" established a standard

among

younger urban musicians who

were the main buyers of the record and
who studied each cut. If you could
achieve the level of finger-picking on the
album, then you were "one diming it."
Presumably it was this album which
provided the impetus to get Etta to begin
playing out again locally in 1958.
In 1967, Lee died of complications
from a stroke he had suffered three years
earlier. His death was sudden, after a
period where Etta gave him physical

therapy and he had made considerable

progress. Etta was and

is

philosophical

think that's why I work
so hard, like I do today. It keeps my
mind on what I'm doing. I don't have
time to think back, well, the years that
about the loss.

we

"I

worked together

in

the

yard

and

�around.

I

to

try

stay away

blurs the tune.

from that

because it's not helping me any. I done
for him what I could do when he was
living and I try to look at it the best I can
through a sensible way. It was time from

and to get

him to go and he didn't have to suffer

anymore."
In 1972, Etta, Babe, Cora, The, and
Fred were all featured on the album
Music from the Hills of Caldwell County

(Physical PR 12-001)*.

In

1973, tran

scripts of Etta's playing also appeared in
Happy Traum's Finger-Picking Styles for

Guitar. 1973 was also the year Etta
left her job at the mill. "One day I just got
the

thinking about it. It was time to leave
there and do something else." That "some
thing else" was to reach a larger audience
with her music. Her performances in the
years since she left the mill include
appearances a the 1980 World's Fair in

984 National Folk Festival
well as concerts in West
Virginia, Kentucky, Ohio, Virginia, and
New Jersey and around North Carolina.
"I guess I've played less right around in
my own hometown than I have anywhere,"
she comments. Along with Cora, Etta
was honored with a North Carolina
Folklore Society Brown-Hudson Award
1

at

as

Wolf Trap,

in 1982, and in 1988 she received
North Carolina Folk Heritage Award.

a

Etta's current repertoire consists mostly
of finger-picked, pre-blues rags and break

downs, hymns, popular tunes, and blues

played

on

the

six

string

guitar.

Her

oldest, those she
learned from her father. These include
"Carolina Breakdown," "Bully of the
Town," "Dew Drops," "Crow Jane," and
favorite tunes

are the

"Railroad Bill." "Lost John" she learned
from her mother. Etta picked up tunes
from commercial recordings. She and
Cora learned "St. Louis Blues" together
by listening to their uncle's victrola. She
also learned a number of tunes from her
"One
in-laws, The and Alfred Phillips
Dime Blues," and "Going Down The
Road Feeling Bad" among them.
Etta has also written tunes of her own.
She tells of hearing chords in her sleep at
the 1980 World's Fair, then getting up in
the middle of the night to work them out
on Cora's guitar. At a performance the
following day, she told the crowd that
she had composed a tune, but that she
had not yet named it. "Play it," they said,
"and we'll name it." "Knoxville Rag" was
the result.
Whatever the source, Etta imbues all
the tunes she plays with her own distinct

ive style. Her playing is characterized by
distinct lines and a delicate touch. Clarity
is something she strives for in her playing.
"I want my music to be clear and not hit a
string that's not necessary because that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Y ou want to keep it clear
clear sound it's the best to

always play without picks. I don't care
for picks. I have a bunch of them but I
hardly ever use them because you can't
separate the sound.
Etta prefers to use flat wound strings
when she plays for herself, and a light
gauge steel in performance. She plays a
Takamine guitar and often uses a Silvertone amp when she is not playing acous
tically. On one side of the guitar, built
into the wood of the body, is a 3-band
equalizer and her pickup is on the tailniece.
It's

to

Knoxville, the

a

important to Etta that she makes

each tune that she plays her own. "As far

playing other people's tunes, that's
theirs. That's not my music. Now I play
'Careless Love,' which other people plays
it too, but I've got my own way of doing
it. I don't try to play like nobody else."
Etta rarely sings, feeling that her guitar
can say all that needs to be said. She
leaves the singing to daughter Dorothy,
who accompanies her on hymns from
time to time. Once in a great while she
can be talked into singing some blues.
Etta finds playing the blues an uplifting
pastime. "It's something you get out of
the
the blues that'll make you happy
as

song

is

made of someone in distress and

trouble and that didn't happen to you."

Most of the Caldwell County musicians
that Etta grew up with are gone now.
The, Al, and Fred have passed away.
Cora has been slowed by surgery, but
Etta says that Babe is still going and
playing strong. Etta is concerned that the
venues in which she originally played
and learned her music are now gone. She
recognizes that the traditions are not
being passed along the way they once
were. For Lee and Etta, music-making
was a family event. All of their children

learned to play an instrument or sing.
Etta regrets that the same thing is not
true for her grandchildren, but recognizes
the obstacles to their musical instruction.
"Children don't teach grandchildren to
play. Don't have time. I think all of that's
going down the drain." She seems to
wish that her grandchildren could be
immersed in music from the start the
way that she was, but also knows that not
all of them may have an interest. "You
just don't hear anybody starting with the

kids, you know, while they're real young.
See, what they want to do, you can't
force a kid to do something if it's not in
him to want to. Because they'll start it
after you pay a lot into it and he's ready

�to quit and do what he feels like doing.
It's best to find out what's in him before

you start with him."
While Etta laments

that

the

corn

shuckings and house parties where most
of her music used to be heard are no
more, she has had no problems with the
shift from the community social event to
"

the concert or festival stage. W ell, I just
can't tell any difference myself 'cause
anywhere I sit down with my guitar it
just seems like it just comes natural."
The music is the important thing to Etta,
who doesn't make a lot of demands
about where she plays, or with whom.
Ask her who she likes to play with and
she'll give you a list as long as your arm,
naming old-time musicians who play in a
variety of styles. For listening, Chet

Atkins

is

Etta

is

her favorite.

also

an

artist

in

the garden.

Around the side and back of the house
vegetable garden and fruit trees.
more produce than she can
but loves to share her
use,
possibly
harvest with friends and neighbors. She
can give growing tips on any number of
fruit, vegetable, and houseplant varieties.
Not content to give up her gardening in
the cold weather, Etta constructed a
hothouse in her backyard where onions,
are

a

Etta cans

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

celery, lettuce and turnips are thriving.
Her thorough knowledge of plants is
augmented by a knowledge of herbal
remedies. Each fall she travels further up
into the mountains to gather star root,
ginseng, yellowroot, and other herbs she
uses to make her own medicines.
In order to pursue all of her interests,
Etta operates at an energy level that

people

a

fraction of her age

are

hard

pressed to match. She arises between
5:00 and 5:30 each day to attend to her
gardening and housekeeping. She appre
ciates the flexibility that playing concerts
gives her, allowing that the winter slow
down in her performance schedule will
give her a chance to catch up on jobs
around the house. "I have to work real
I'm not going away anywhere
hard
now
'cause I've caught up with all
right
my contracts for now. I can get started
now and I'm cleaning up outside. I have
all my paint ready and I'm going to clean
my panelling, so I can do that, quit when
I get
ready and I enjoy doing it." One
recent visit found her just having de
scended from the roof, where she had
been repairing and painting an eave.
Another arrival found her getting ready
to split the remains of a recently felled

tree for use in
her woodburning stove. Etta's muse is a

forty-year-old

magnolia

restless one.

Etta satisfies that restless muse with
lots of appearances at festivals in and
around North Carolina. Among the stages
she played this year are JazzCharlotte,
"Seedtime on the Cumberland" at
Appalshop, and the "Sounds of the
South" conference in Chapel Hill. The
best part of playing the folk-festival
circuit for Etta is the wide variety of
people she encounters. Etta loves the
fact that she has made so many friends
through her music. "I always love to
meet different people. I love to meet the
ones 1 met years ago, and so it just goes
on and on like that. I don't meet any
strangers. 1 might meet someone I've
never seen before but it's still no stranger.
So, when I see a new face, that's just a
added friend."
The flexibility and friends that come
with her musical lifestyle mean a lot to
Etta, but not as much as her independence.
She informed me that she was far too
young to get married again. "I'm not old
enough for the second time," she laughed.
When asked how old one had to be she
replied, "You have to be one hundred
and four. Then you might be old enough
for the second time but I'm not quite
there."
"Oh, my God, I wouldn't tie myself
down no more, not for nobody. I got

friends. But when

I

get ready to go, you

stay here. I may see you years later.
really care for people. I love people but
not good enough to settle down anymore.
I just
couldn't go through with it any
more." Nine children, 24 years at the

I

mill, three years caring for her invalid
husband so much of Etta's life was
spent looking after others. When Lee
died, Etta thought about all the playing
opportunities she had forgone. "After
Lee passed I started giving up on what I
had lost out on for the past years," she
recollects. Instead of looking to a past of
lost chances, Etta looked to a future that
she could devote to her own interests, a
future full of music. "I've done most of
my traveling after [Lee] passed," she
notes. "I appreciate the years that I had
someone that I cared for but that's over.
I'm ready to do for Etta now. I love
Etta."
"I believe I'd cry if I had to get married

again. In fact, I know I would, if I tried to
live long enough to cry. I couldn't stand
it, ooh, no. The first one I had I loved
him dear enough to go along with what
he asked and what he thought was the
best for me to do, but I'll never lay my
guitar down for nobody else."

*Both the Tradition and Physical albums
out of print. Current efforts are

are

underway

to

Etta's music.

produce

a

recording

of

Lesley Williams is an intern with the
Folklife Section of the North Carolina Arts

Council. She lives in Raleigh.

PLEASE TAKE NOTE: We have
moved to Durham, N.C., and we have a
Please address ALL cor
or items to: Old-Time
P.O.
Box
Durham, N.C.
51812,
Herald,
new address.

respondence and/

27717. First class mail will

be

forwarded

from Galax for a limited time, but 3rd
and 4th class mail is not forwarded.

�When one thinks of the banjo
today what generally comes to mind is a
picture of a man in an ensemble playing
serious, often jazz-like music based on a
style initiated by the most influential and
widely imitated banjoist of all time, Earl
Scruggs. This style is barely 50 years old
and has involved a long evolution since

IN PRAISE
OF

gourd instrument that came here
from Africa in the 17 th and 18th

the

centuries.

1

hat

instrument was handmade

from whatever organic materials would
have been available. The sound was quiet

often solo but soon after Africans
brought here as slaves they no
doubt began producing music differently
and in different combinations than they
had in their homeland.
We know very little about the music
from this era since few writers thought

and

were

or everyday music was
worth writing about. It was only after
Anglo-American people began playing

that vernacular

the instrument

in the early

1800s that

some writers began taking note. What
we do have are a few travelers' accounts
and artists' drawings and paintings from
around 1800. And they show only AfroAmerican men (no women) solo or in
ensembles, with the banjo. Similarly,
until the late 1800s, drawings, photos,
and written accounts all suggest that only
Euro-American men played the banjo.
Around the turn of the century, however,
one begins to see photographs of women,
either holding the instrument in a dreamy
pose in a formal drawing room setting,
or, perhaps a little later, with a formally
arranged string orchestra.

whether AfroI have often wondered
American women picked the banjo. I
feel that when Elizabeth Cotten played
the banj o around 900 she was probably
1

I have talked
with many Anglo-American old-timers
in the mountains who tell me that their
fathers and mothers picked the banjo
before the turn of the century. Why,
then, do we not have accounts of this
either visually or in literature? I believe

because it was not
is primarily
considered dignified for a woman to be
seen with a banjo, which was then con
sidered a rollicking party and dance
instrument. And when the banjo became
more dignified and classicalized in the
late 1800s, we begin to see evidence of

Jones

not the first to do so. And

what had been going on to some extent
all along. I have known a number of
women who picked the banjo in the early
Elizabeth Cotten, Hattie Stone1900s
man and Sara Boggs (Dock's wife) to
name but a few. Their styles varied from
the quiet to the lively and raucous. Often
their picking was solo or as accompani-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

Loyal

this

Lily May Ledford

BANJO-PICKING WOMEN
by

Mike Seeger

�ment to an old-time song.
As mountain string bands developed
in the early 1900s they consisted mostly
of men, in public at least. Again, 1
suspect this was because it was "frolic"
or party music and it could get pretty
rowdy. The banjo at this time was giving
way to the guitar as support to the fiddle,
and was less suited than the guitar to the
new hillbilly songs. But in the 1930s the
banjo sometimes took on a new role
within performing string bands in a style
based on the old Kentucky rapping or
frailing stroke. This type of banjo lead

communicated unmistakeable excitement
with its strong, driving melodic breaks,
using

a

banjo picking in the late 1960s. I have a
number of tapes made of her in the '50s,
'60s, and early '70s which I expect to edit
into a couple of LPs.
he next generation younger, Lily
May Ledford was also from Kentucky,
and at least as well known and nearly as
influential as Cousin Emmy. Her touch
was stronger and more percussive than
I

Cousin Emmy's and to me the excitement

and drive of her playing could parallel
that of Earl Scruggs's early recordings.
She was the instrumental mainstay of the

Coon Creek Girls,
band

organized

an

all-woman string

by John

Lair

in

the

1930s. John Lair had also been

a

formative

influence with Cousin Emmy (and would
soon be with the Amburgey Sisters as
well). The Coon Creek Girls played
mostly at Lair's Renfro Valley Barn
Dance and recorded a few nice 78s in the
1930s. Lily May also played fiddle and
guitar, and sang. Her stage presence was
energetic and in later years, reflective
and regal. She was a big influence on me
and on my brother, Pete. Some of my
earliest remembrances of banjo picking
were some handcut radio transcriptions
of the Coon Creek Girls playing "Cindy"
and "How Many Biscuits Can You Eat"

guitar and string bass for rhythmic

support. As far as I can tell from early
recordings and recent interviews, this
style was initiated and played by women,
all of them from Kentucky. Some of the
groups consisted solely of women and
many of the best known players were
encouraged and managed by promoter
John Lair.

Certainly Cousin Emmy was the first
probably the most influential of
these banjo-picking country entertainers
to establish herself. Born and raised in
western Kentucky just after the turn of
and

the century,

she came from

a

family of

musicians. She was without a doubt the
most energetic old-time music performer
have ever seen. She often led

1

a

large

troupe of musicians and dancers in the
rough and tumble thirties, sang in a clear
limber voice, and played more than a
dozen instruments. Her image was one of
brash banjo picking woman. Her rapping
style was fast and smooth and she could
also play the picking, or chord style on
slower songs. She was a spirited musician,
tall, blonde, and charismatic. She played
of songs on the banjo, from
a variety
"Old Timbrook" ("Molly and Tenno doubt learned from her
brooks"
a

family) to pieces of English ballads such

"Scat Tom Kitty Puss," or tum-of-thecentury sentimental songs such as "Little
Joe." She played a variety of radio stations
and shows throughout the South and
Mid-west in the 1930s and 1940s. As a
result, the range of her impact on other
as

she

recorded

Music

very

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Country

unfortunately

little. Her Decca album has never been
re-issued. Her Folkways album with the
New Lost City Ramblers (FTS 3 1 0 1 5) is
still in print and is a good example of her

courtesy

but

Foundation

banjo pickers was, I believe, considerable.
For instance, while she was in Wheeling
West Virginia, one of her banjo students
was the now legendary Grandpa Jones.
Her Decca 78s of the mid-forties intro
duced her to an urban audience as well.
In the 1950s she appeared in a number of
second-or third-rate Hollywood films,

Cousin Emmy

�Queen of England at the
White House in 1939. Those recordings
and some of the best 78s by the Coon
Creek Girls are on Old Homestead 142.
It's an excellent LP and a good repre
sentation of them at their best. They
recorded again in the 1960s (County
712) and Lily May recorded a solo LP in
the 1980s (Greenhays 712).
After these two pioneer Kentucky
banjo picking women there were several
others from a still younger generation.
Molly O'Day's banjo-picking style was
in a sense a mixture of Cousin Emmy's
smooth sound and Lily May's percussive,
for the King and

punchy rhythm. She leaned more towards
the country music of the 1940s so her
banjo picking was a smaller part of her

song using a picked, not rapped 5-string
probably played by her husband
banjo,
Lynn.
There were several other banjo-picking
women that were active in the 1940s and
'50s. Jean Chapel (Mattie O'Neal), one
of the Amburgey (Amber) sisters was
from Neon, Kentucky, and first learned
banjo from her father, and by watching
herself in a mirror to get the hang of it.
She plays a variety of instruments and
still plays music, mostly as a rock and
roll entertainer. She has written a number
of country hit songs. She recorded my
favorite of her songs about 1952, "You
Can't Live With 'Em (And You Can't
Live Without 'Em)" with her sisters,
Martha Carson and Bertha Woodruff.
She played a driving clawhammer-style
banjo and sang lead on the song. It's been
re-issued on Library of Congress issue

repertoire than songs that used Hawaiian
guitar. Like Cousin Emmy she was a
beautiful singer and had old songs such
as "Barbara Allen" in her repertoire.
Some of her best gospel songs recorded
in the 1940s have been re-issued on Old
Homestead 101, including four examples

of her banjo picking at its best. Two LPs
of more recently recorded gospel songs,
some with banjo, are on Old Homestead
312 and 313. My favorite of hers, "Poor
Ellen Smith," is not to my knowledge
re-issued. She appears on two other Old
Homestead LPs playing old-time banjo
rhythm behind brother Skeets William
son's fiddling on one. On the other,
mostly a nice selection of re-issues of her
best 1940s recordings, there is only one

LBC 7.

Another good player about whom

1

have been unable to learn anything was
Katy Hill (Helen Osborne). She played
faster and with a harder sound than any
of the players I've written about here
she had that driving Kentucky sound.

She played briefly with Charlie Monroe
in the 1940s and appears on two LPs of
his radio shows, County 538 and 539.
As with all of these banjo-picking women
it is a pity that she didn't record more.
No discussion of banjo-picking women
can be complete without Olabelle Reed.
Her North Carolina banjo-picking style
is different from the players
I
have
mentioned above, who were all from
Kentucky. Her style is less driving and is
a hybrid
of clawhammer and western
North Carolina "up-and-down" picking.
She was influenced by players in her
native North Carolina but also, I'm sure,
by the recordings of the women mentioned
above. In the 1960s she began to con
centrate on her songwriting and is best
known for songs such as "High on the
Mountain," and "Only the Leading Role
Will Do." She can be heard on Rounder

0021 and 0077.

Sometimes when

I
see Doily Parton
think that some part
of this older banjo tradition is continuing.
But among most modern players their
mountain music identity becomes diluted
as they reach for ever larger audiences.
And it was the commitment to country
identity that was one of the strongest
elements in the music of the older banjo-

courtesy

Country

Music

Foundation

picking the banjo

Molly O'Day

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

picking entertainers.

An exception to
this is the playing and stage presence of
Roni Stoneman; her drive and sense of
humor remind me of Cousin Emmy. But
both Parton and Stoneman play in Earl

continued on page 43

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Flyin' Cloud

Records

Doug Rorror
Rt. 2, Box 436
Madison, NC 27025
FC-001

OLD HOLLOW

STRINGBAND

Old time

music from North Carolina
CASS $8.00

FC-007

VARIOUS ARTISTS
Virginia Carolina Sampler
Lonnie Austin, Wayne
Henderson, others
CASS $8.00

FC-010

CONTEST FAVORITES
Wayne Henderson, Robin

Kessinger (guitar)
LP or CASS

$8.00

Please include $1.50 handling for US
residents; Canadian residents $4.00.
NC residents add 5% sales tax.

�"MUSIC
IS

ABOUT
FEELINGS"
An Interview

with

Tommy Hunter
Hilary Dirlam

courtesy

Tommy

Hunter

by

I

asked Tommy Hunter why he
felt a musician might turn to the fiddle
rather than another instrument. "It's just
something in that person," he told me. "I
think he's born with that in him." Tommy
Hunter could have been talking about
himself. Having decided upon the fiddle
at the age of seven, he's never looked
back. "The fiddle was it," he says.
Tommy Hunter was born in 1919 in
the community of Laurel Branch in
Madison County, North Carolina. "When
I was growing up we lived in a log cabin
on my grandfather's farm. We didn't

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have electricity; we used oil lamps. We
got most of our food from the garden. If
you didn't have food to put away for the
winter
well, you had it rough.
"My daddy and grandfather were both
carpenters. They had a sawmill at one

time, too. That brought in some money.
There were never a lot of jobs in Madison
County, but society had changed and
you needed more money than before
when you could get all you needed from
the earth.

"We used
it was
then

to
a

walk

to

school

back

two-room schoolhouse.

was only six months out of the
I could get
I read everything
then.
year
back
hands
on
then,
especially
my
Western magazines."
Tommy's family is descended from
the Scotch-Irish people who settled in
the mountains of western North Carolina
around two hundred years ago. "Those
Scotch and Irish people must have liked
these highlands because a lot of them
settled here," says Tommy, adding "I've
got some Indian blood too, which I'm

School

proud of."

Tommy's family heritage also includes

�in the key of G."

Tommy Hunter's father, Roswell Gar
land Hunter, born in 1898, played the
five-string banjo with the band. "There

usually a banjo player around
back then [in the early '20sJ. It didn't
that's
really get popular till the '50s
when it come in. My daddy played in two
styles. He played in the two-finger style
some. It's not what you call clawhammer
or drop-thumb style, it's smoother. It's
also more complicated than it looks
because it gets every note. He could also
play a three-finger style. It's not Scruggs
style. He played similar to Van Epps, a
classical banjo style, using all his fingers,
but he olaved traditional, not classical.
"He also made the first set of picks
that was probably ever made. He wanted
to pick the strings up with his fingernails,
but they were too soft and they broke.
Well, back then you could go to the
store and buy a can of milk for a nickle.
He cut picks out of one of them just like
his fingernails. Then he made one for his
thumb, and after he got used to playing
with them he never had to worry about
wasn't

breaking his nails."
Tommy says there was one radio in
Laurel Branch when he was a small boy.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

When Tommy was about 20, just
before World War II, he got his first job
playing out, on his own, without other

radio.

little store, hardly bigger than
this kitchen. People would crowd in on
neighbors and friends of
Friday nights
and listen to the Grand Ole
the family
Opry."
"Back then fiddle players used gut
strings that would have to be retuned all
the time because each time you played
they'd get jerked out of tune. Then
a

members of his family band. "One morn
ing I got up early, caught a bus, and went
to Asheville. I went to WWNC (an
Asheville radio station still sponsoring a
live traditional music show). The Morris
Brothers was playing there then. I asked
them for a job, and stayed with them for
about a year. They were mainly singers,
and I was their fiddler. We played every
day on the radio. Then World War II

they'd play on those old hard-wound
steel strings. It was tough, but they could
play on them almost as smooth as gut.
Sometimes you'd see a fiddle player
whose bow didn't have more than 20

came along."

Tommy went first to Ireland, where he
heard Irish music for the first time. "It

hairs on it. A lot of times there was no

helped me understand a lot not play
like them, but to understand the music.
My battalion had an orchestra, and I
played guitar in it. We played popular
music of the day; 'In the Mood,' and

money to buy a good fiddle bow. The
itself might be good but it is

fiddle

amazing to me how they could handle the
with those
and sound good
music
terrible steel strings and just a few hairs
on the bow!"
Tommy's grandfather's fiddle was

already ancient when he started playing
it. Legend has it that the fiddle had been
hidden in a rock crevice during the Civil
War to keep the Yankees from stealing
it. Tommy's uncle still has Uncle Jim's
fiddle, and Tommy says it still sounds
good, although "you can see where a
little mouse went in there and built him a
nest."
Tommy began learning by listening.
"My grandfather didn't sit me down and
play for me to learn from, I just had to
get it when he played. I used to slip his

fiddle out and play it or try to play
it
and put it back without him noticing.
It think he knew, though. I was always
afraid I'd get quarreled at about his
fiddle, but that never happened. If I got

to hear him play a tune two or three
times I got to where I could whistle a
little of it. When I got to hear him play
the same tune again, I could get it on the
fiddle."
T ommy was playing in his family band

songs like that. I wrote a letter home to
the folks saying not to worry about me, I
was playing in an orchestra. I thought
that would make them feel better."
Tommy sent his fiddle back home,
though, when his battalion was sent to
North Africa. From there he went to
Anzio Beach. It was four years before he
returned to the mountains of western
North Carolina.
Tommy then married, and worked in
construction and as a radio and T.V.
repairman.

He

though. Mostly

never
he

stopped playing,
played with his family

band.
In

1961

Tommy Hunter's Carolina

String Band, as it was then called, traveled
New Jersey to make a record for

to

Prestige International (No. 13026). The
Hunter Brothers, another configuration
of Tommy's family band, played at the

the age of twelve, and got his first
fiddle as a teenager, up in Virginia. "We
moved up to southern Virginia for a few
at

years, and I made friends up there. One
of them had a fiddle, and I had a shotgun.
it for that fiddle. Some days I
I traded
didn't play; I had duties, school and all,
and doing chores for my parents.
days I had to go into the fields and
But most of the time I got to play
wanted to. "While Tommy was

Some
work.
when I
still

a

teenager, he went to a fiddlers convention
at the
Marshall schoolhouse (several
miles from his home). "Fiddlin' Bill
Hensley and some of the other old
fiddlers from all around was there. They
had a good show, and that was one thing
that spurred me on and made me try
harder."

Hunter

music isn't so strong in the generation
after me. The heritage has gotten lost in
the shuffle, I think."
Uncle Jim's Band, as it was called then,
played for various get-togethers all over
Madison County, including square dances
for which they got paid, "which made
"
them professionals, says T ommy Dances
back then were often held in peoples
houses. "They would walk in from all
directions. The house would be full, and
there would be people standing out in
the yard
just to hear them play. It
doesn't happen that way anymore. T oday
it has to be on a stage, and formal. But
back then, people would dance in the
living room, if the foundation was strong
enough. They'd move the furniture out,
and folks would get up and buck dance
all night. Fiddlin' Jim's most-requested
tune was 'Sally Goodin,' which he played

remember when my uncle got

Tommy

existed for nearly a hundred years now.
"Everyone in my family could sing or
dance or play an instrument, although

"I

He had

courtesy

rich musical tradition. His grandfather,
James Wylie Hunter, and his great-uncle,
Jess Hunter, were both fiddlers. "They
called my grandfather Fiddlin' Jim, Singin'
he could do it all. I've
Jim, Dancin' Jim
never heard one to this day that could
outdo him. He could just make you
stand up and take notice."
Tommy figures that in one incarnation
or another (with older members dropping
out and being replaced by younger
musicians) the Hunter family band has
a

Tommy's parents, Roswell Garland Hunter
Bailey Hunter ca. 1915

&amp;.

Orla

�Philadelphia Folk Festival

in the mid'50s. "Obray Ramsey, one of my brothers,
and I went; it was the biggest festival I
ever played in. Judy Collins, Theodore
Bickel and Mississippi John Hurt were

there. I just loved his guitar playing. I
went over and listened to him play, but 1
never did introduce myself. He wouldn't
have known who I was, anyway! Every
body had a little program set, 15 or 20
minutes. I remember we played 'Buffalo
Gals,' and the last tune was 'Billy in the

Lowground.' People really seemed to
like it. believe that was the farthest Pve
ever traveled to perform.
Tommy met Manco Sneed once, in
1

the early '60s.
I had heard about Manco Sneed tor

a

long time. People told me he lived in
Cherokee, and I kept hoping I'd see him.
One day I was driving through Cherokee
and I thought 'If I'm ever going to get to
see him it's going to be now.' 1 got
directions at the service station, and
found where he lived. He lived in a little
cabin, and he was sitting outside on the
porch. I said, 'I've heard a lot about you;
I'd love to hear you play,' and I got my
fiddle out and handed it to him. He laid
my fiddle up on his arm and said, 'This is
isn't it?' I guess he was
a factory fiddle,
used to playing a homemade fiddle. He
was a very friendly person. He played for
about half an hour. 'Lady Hamilton'
he played that, and 'Paddy on the Turn
pike,' and 'Three Forks of the Big Sandy.'
That was the only time I ever saw him.
And I was always glad I stopped. Some
times you just have to make things
happen, and that's what I done."
started
In the early '70s, Tommy
playing with the Hornpipers, including
Mack Snodderly on twin fiddle and
Carroll Best on banjo. In 1986 Tommy
began putting in occasional appearances
with the Carroll Best Band, although ill
health is now preventing him from playing
much.
In 1 976 T ommy recorded an album of
his tunes, Deep in Tradition, for June
Appal, accompanied by J ohn McCutcheon.
Tommy has received numerous awards
for his fiddling, including at least eight
from the Asheville Folk Festival and
several for his contributions to the
Bascom Lamar Lunsford Festival in Mars
Hill. He received the Appalachian

Consortium award

1971, played

in

grandfather

was

took

'Sandy

River,'"

lot to learn

says
right."

Tommy.
Tommy's grandfather and his great uncle
"It

a

it

great early influences on
Tommy's style, playing different styles
and tunes. "My grandfather used the
bow, moved with every note. One tune
he
he played was 'Bonaparte's Retreat'
called it 'The Downfall of Paris.' I learned
it as best I could, and I wouldn't change it
for the world." Tommy feels strongly
about his own fiddle playing, emphasizing
the fact that he has worked hard to
develop his own style, regardless of his
great love and respect for his early
influences. "I didn't copy anybody," he
states, going on to say that if someone
had wanted to, it would have been
impossible before the advent of tape
were

also

recorders. "When my grandfather took a
notion to play and he played when he

wanted to, not when somebody else
wanted him to I had to listen and get
those tunes. He never did set me down
and go over them with me."
Tommy feels that his own style can be
defined by his distinctive phrasing and
where he places ornamentation in his
tunes. And although he has adapted his
grandfather's style, "smoothing it out,"
as he says, Tommy feels that his use of
the shuffle also helps to define his style.
"Back then fiddlers shuffled all the time,
that's what put the spirit in it! I make a
lot of my notes using the bow rather than
noting them." Another thing distinguish
ing T ommy 's playing is that it is as much
for listening as it is for dancing. Each

in

in

Tommy

Mountain Magic Festival

Hunter

the Festival of American Folklife for the
Bicentennial, and was given an award as a
Master of Old-Time Music at the 1980

W aynesville,

In 1989, Tommy Hunter received the
North Carolina Folk Heritage award.

"The

first tune

I

learned

from my

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Courtesy

North Carolina.

for Prestige in the early '60s. L-R: Obray
Ramsey, George Fisher, Tommy, (sister) Nan Fisher.

Recording

�tune

is

well

your wits about you!"
"Crossing the Shannon"

thought out, with much

("Tommy
Hunter's Reel #2") was written in about
fifteen minutes. "1 never changed a note
but it took me awhile to
after I wrote it

to details. Each tune is
distinctive, set off by Tommy's precise
and beautiful noting, phrasing, and bowing

attention

patterns. Difficult to describe in words,
it is as if he is able to pick out the core or
heart of each tune and communicate that
to the listener; this is where his technical
ability is directed.
Another important factor defining
Tommy's style is the tunes themselves.
Although he has a repertoire of several

hundred

tunes and songs,

get the notes right

including

in the key of G. He played
"
other tunes in E, too. One tune, "Horse
shoe Bend," Tommy plays cross-tuned
in A; another, "Cluck Old Hen" (again,
no relation to the better-known version
of this tune in A) is played in "Bonaparte's
Retreat" tuning with the G-string tuned
down to D.
"My grandfather could play for I don't
know how long without playing the same
tune starting with 'Nancy Rowland,'
'Sandy River,' 'Cumberland Gap,' (which
he called 'Roaring Branch'). I guess I play
most of the ones he played. He played
I don't
one called the 'Jersey Quickstep'
recall that one
and other two-steps. He
'
'
played W agoner "T ennessee Wagoner
called
and one
'Kentucky Wagoner.'"
Tommy says he has always liked the
keys of G and C, although he likes A for
volume. He pays great attention to tone.
"When you set up a fiddle, it takes a
while for it to settle in, to where the
vibrations are right. When you play,
you're creating a tremendous amount of
vibration. Sometimes I want to tune the
fiddle way down, to where it sounds
right for my mood. I don't tune it down

courtesy

Tommy

Hunter

standards, the tunes closest to his heart
and the ones he plays most often are the
40 some tunes he learned from his greatuncle and his grandfather.
"The way they played back then, they
didn't think so much about what key
they were in. They were after a certain

sound." Tommy says that one of his
grandfather's tunes, "Ryestraw" (no
relation to the "Ryestraw" in A and D)

Tommy &amp; Nina Hunter

ca.

1941

was played

to any particular spot."

Over the years, Tommy has written
fiddle tunes, as well as learning tunes
from other fiddlers. "I started writing
tunes back in my teens. What started me
out was that I liked variations, but not
too many, and not too great. I listened to
lots of different styles of fiddling and got
the sounds in my head. I have been able
in
to remember those different sounds
the music business you've got to have a
and that helped me
good memory!
with
my
style
regard to writing
develop
my tunes, and helped me remember
them." Some of Tommy's tunes can be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

had to practice."

don't know where the tunes that
write come from. I hear a lot of sounds.
"I

I
1

always have music going on in my head,
unless something else 1 absolutely have
to think about is going on. And some of
the sounds sort of take hold. I guess
that's the best way to describe it."
Tommy has spent time at fiddlers
conventions, both as a contestant and as
a judge. "I have won several first places,"
Tommy says, "but there's a contest
circuit type fiddling and I never have
gotten into it. The style doesn't have
anything to do with old-time fiddling. I
didn't want to sit there all winter and
practice one tune so I could go out and
win something in the spring. That just
wasn't my thing, so I didn't do it. I
wanted to be free to play whatever I
wanted
'Turkey in the Straw' or what
ever!"

fiddlers conventions
Tennessee, and for
several years at Fiddlers Grove. "I don't
really like contest judging, but some

Tommy judged
Mars

in

Hill,

at

in

body had to do it. There are a lot of
musicians who want to play in competition
and you can't have a competition without
judges. I always tried to pick out the ones

courtesy

Tommy

Hunter

I

ca.

1946

heard on his June Appal recording; others
are in the music archive at Mars Hill

College. Some

are currently played by
other fiddlers in the area.
When write a tune sometimes get
the first part all at once, and then I have
sometimes
to hunt for the second part
that will match the first part. When I
wrote 'Tommy Hunter's Reel' 1 had
heard 'Rutland's Reel,' which is a fine
tune. I wanted to write something on
I tried
that order but not really like it
to write something to suit me." "Tommy
1

1

Hunter's Reel" is a hauntingly beautiful
four-part tune, moving from D through
C and ending in A minor. "Y ou' ve got to
be sharp to play it
you've got to have

thought should win, and tried to live

with my feelings about it."
Tommy's feelings about traditional
music go very deep; music, he says, is
ultimately about feelings. "Nobody can
write fiddle music down. This doctor
over at Mars Hill College, he wrote down
the notes. But you can't write down
someone's feelings. If you learn it from
notes you're just playing what the other
person plays. Y ou're not putting anything
individual into it. I think I've had feelings
that maybe the music was inside me
before I ever played, before I knew what
I was trying to do. It was already there. I
don't know why I love those old tunes
but I do. I've played other
their sounds
kinds of music, and I could have gone on
to another newer kind of fiddling. But
over the years I've stuck with my base, so
to speak. My first priority has been those
old tunes. And that's why I believe I've
earned the right to be called an old-time
fiddler."
wish to thank Wayne Martin for his
assistance in preparing this
H.D.
article.
I

technical

Hilary Dirlam
editor of the

is

OTH.

a

musician, and associate

�FESTIVAL

GUIDE,

1989

Seed catalogs, W-2 forms, and valentines are hitting the mailbox, so our thoughts naturally turn to which fiddlers conventions we
can cram into our calendar this year. Everybody has their own must-do events, but for a look at what else is around for 1990, we
offer this selection of festivals, competitions, and camps. So shake out the sleeping bags, count the tent shakes, cozy up the fireplace,
find a great old-time event missing from this list, drop us a line and we 11 include it next
in
and
1990 weekends. If
pencil

your

you

year.

Bear in mind that dates can change due to flooding, earthquakes, and other catastrophes, so check betore you loaa up tne
doesn t indicate this, please check to
Winnebago. Bear in mind, also, that some competitions require pre-registration. If publicity
because
for
to
find
you didn t pre-register.
competition
make sure. Don't drive a long distance, only
yourself ineligible

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�and the Augusta Heritage Center host many concerts, workshops, etc., throughout the spring
on all events.
for
information
them
Write
and summer.

NOTE: Both the Ozark Folk Center

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�bers."

Issues In Old-Time Music
off that young urban musician tag.
acronym is YURM and he could
brand himself and others for life. Second,
nothing could be further from the truth.
The few folklorists who ever think about
it like revival musicians almost as much
It may seem
as they like themselves.
rival the
could
that
any group
impossible
revival in admiring itself, but they do.
Mac's account of folkie travails in the
to lay

The

The Issues In Old-Time Music column
was established as a forum for the expression
of ideas and points of view, some of which
Points of view
controversial.
be
may
expressed in this column are not necessarily
those of the Old-Time Herald.

a culprit for changes
eroded professional opportunities in

late '70s tries to find

Confessions Of
Folklorist
by

that

A

old-time music. He offers folklorists as
the evildoers in his scenario in a mental
process that is reminiscent of the pulp

Joe Wilson
to introduce myself.
devil incarnate, the folklorist who

Please allow me
I'm the

stopped the annual booking of the High
woods Stringband at that ultimate status
conferring event, the National Folk Fes
tival.
Moreover, I'm not born again;
that was fourteen years ago and I'm to
tally unrepentant and absolutely certain
was the right thing to do.

it

My first confession is that I'm not re
ally a folklorist. Folklorists are members
of an academic discipline, and I'm terribly
undisciplined, no good at university de
partmental politics, and a failure at con
I
go through entire
ceptual thinking.
I have
days without defining anything.
been reading books written by folklorists
for over thirty years and dabbling in their
pond, but I've never loitered at a univer
sity long enough for them to invite me to
engage in that rite of passage where mor
tarboards are worn and sheep hides dis
tributed, with the participants becoming
what one of my mountain friends calls
"talking doctors." I think they'd let me
be a folklorist if I would submit my head
for two or three years of probing and
stuffing, but there's a part of me that
prefers being the red-headed stepchild in
the family.
Nobody expects much of
there's
so
always a chance you can
you,
offer

a

happy surprise.

Moreover, I have become important to
folklorists because I can be counted on to
buy almost any new book about folklore.
Due to the small sales of most folklore
books, this gives me an enormous lever
age. Who would risk offending a happy
and gullible steady customer?
Mac Benford believes that young urban
revivalist musicians have a problem with
folklorists. I feel I should first urge him

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

mystery where one begins to suspect the
poor butler on the third page.
Mac mentions me by job in 1976, "the
prospective director of the NCTA," and
The "input"
recalls "providing input."
was that Mac and others thought the or

ganization that employs me should be
come a booking agency for Highwoods

and other performing groups. Mac said,
"We just want to earn our living at this
the way Gid and Riley and those guys
did." I was dumbfounded, so taken aback
that the phrase has

remained intact

in my

memory.

What stunned me was that Mac didn't
that Gid was a chicken farmer,

know

McMichen

an

automobile mechanic, and

did a blind man's act on the
street with a tin cup. They didn't make a
living from being the Skillet Lickers.
Mac had assimilated the sound from those
old 78s, but the players of that music re

that Riley

mained as remote

as if

they had lived on

They'd be
come a romantic vision, cheery fellows
who tootled about the South making a
good living playing old-time music.
Has any old-time musician ever earned
the other side of the moon.

a

living

playing

instrumental

thought

I

it a

funny comment then,

The
but now it seems almost profound.
new set of values says that it is better to
be a professional artist than a good barber

music?

One can point to the Carter Family,

the

Mainers, Uncle Dave, Jimmie Rodgers,
Fiddling John, and a few others, but their
living came from vocals or showman
ship.
When folk arts apprenticeships were
invented a few years back, Kathy James
wondered if it might be a good idea for
the young learners to also learn the trades
"The people
of their master teachers.
who are learning from Dewey (Balfa)
should learn to drive a school bus, and
those Tommy (Jarrell) is teaching should
learn how to scrape a gravel road and
make moonshine," she said. "We'd have
great music and lots of bright young bar

who is the best fiddler in town. Is it? I
asked the opinion of former Kentucky
coal miner and present Tennessee hog and
cattle farmer and very fine fiddler Kenny
Baker. "Put me down on the side of good
barbers," Kenny said.

My second confession is that I was not
I
didn't say,
totally candid with Mac.
in
country music
"Mac, professionalism
and you're no
is a crooning game
I
liked Highwoods and had
crooner."
heard them a lot, and I knew Mac was no

I'd spent some
crooner.
years in
a
bit
time
work
of
Nashville, including

ing for Marty Robbins, so I knew about
the right song and right voice formula,
but I figured Mac had a better friend than

me who could tell him the hard truth.
I'll admit that Mac is better in the vo
cal department than me, and I have a
record of me and others that proves it.
I
sing people think I'm having
severe gastric distress. If I continue, they
Mac's career as a
fear it is terminal.
crooner snagged on the fact that he sounds
more like me than he does Marty Robbins.
What Mac s article in the spring issue
of the OTH makes clear is that his better

Whenever

friend didn't tell him the hard truth about
his crooning abilities. More to the point,
Mac is still singing the same "song" he

did when he visited me in 1976. He is
saying that folklorists have not helped
him and other tradition borrowers become

professional musicians.

In my case he is
right. We have very different ideas of
what my job is.
He says that being booked on the Na

tional and Smithsonian festivals helped
He believes I
his group obtain jobs.
should plan the National Folk Festival
with an eye to providing those selected
with entries for their resumes and clip
pings for their press kits. But the option
is more mine than his, and that is not
what
It

choose to do with my life.
borders on the busny-tailea side ot

I

the paranoid to say that government folk
lorists shut down the '60s-'70s boomlet
In Mac's telling the
in old-time music.
two or three minuscule efforts the gov
ernment began in the direction of folk arts
in the

1970s were staffed by enforcers for

political right who were fearful that
government funds would be used to sup
the

port "radicals." In fact, the old-time mu
sic boomlet closed down on cue with the
rest of what has been called "the great
folk music scare of the sixties." There

came

a

day

when people who had been

�generally supportive were not

as

inter

ested as they had been. There are morn
ings when the nation gets up and changes
its mind.

Mac seems to think that lots of gov
ernment money is being spent on folk
music, and he is concerned about getting
his part. I'm going to be helpful and give
him directions on how to get some.
Follow the Capital Beltway west until
you come to the Big Rock Candy Moun
tain

exit.

Go past the champagne foun

tain and trickling whiskey creek and the
yard where the roast pigs are running
about squealing to be eaten. Back your
truck up to the money elevator and tell
the guy with the white beard and red suit

'er up. While he is indulging you,
climb to the top of the tank and look for
folklorists cavorting in the national trea
to fill

sury in the manner of

Scrooge McDuck.

Don't worry if you can't see them. The
lack of any evidence is half of the enjoy
The other half is
ment of an illusion.
slicing it so thin that no one recognizes it

baloney.
Most of the "government" money
spent on folk music goes to revival per
formers. Every year I see twenty or more
brochures which show the touring per
formers that regional and state arts agen
cies are supporting.
Virtually all are
from the revival. I have never been con
cerned to the point of counting, but it is
It is
at least 90 percent, perhaps more.
the same with folk music in the schools
programs. Revival performers can cope
with the bureaucracy, and they get all the
jobs. Nor does the situation differ when
park and recreation departments hire folk
Almost ALL the public
musicians.
money I see being spent on folk music
goes to revival performers.
The National Endowment for the Arts
(NEA) is the source of much of the
as

"government" money spent this way by
state and regional arts agencies. It is not
much in relative terms; the Federal gov

ernment spends a miserly
budget on music of all
funds remain pegged at
were when Ronald Reagan

portion of its
kinds.
These
the

level they

came to office.
Yet in many states more than half of the
state arts budget comes as a block grant
from the NEA. The block grant is not
all. The last time I saw an accounting,
more than half of the states were getting
virtually all of their folk arts budget from
NEA program funds.
Regional associations of state arts

agencies (the Western Arts Association,

Southern Arts Federation, and others) get
most of their operating funds from NEA
block grants, and then, like the states,
solicit additional NEA funds for programs
such as folk arts.

They are also like the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

states in expending virtually all their folk
on

and

performance support
touring
revival artists who can cope with yearand-a-half-in-advance application deadlines
and procedures that require skills in
accounting, press agentry, and futurism.
So it is a fiction to say that the revival is
wronged in the distribution of
public funding for the arts.
The only place where this imbalance is
given any attention is the NEA's tiny
Folk Arts Program where there's some
being

concern with originality and the pressures
on folk communities. But even the little
Folk Arts operation has an apprenticeship
program which, though it also puts some
funding into the hands of the master
teachers,

is

mainly

a

fits revival artists.

program that bene

Mac categorizes some folk festivals as
"government" festivals. The three festi
vals that he mentions by name, The Na
tional Folk Festival, The Festival of

American
Mountain

Folklife, and the Brandywine
Festival, are like most other

being funded by a variety of
sources, public and private. Anyone who
thinks the "government" will fund more
than a small portion of a festival is a re
cent arrival, newly fallen off the turnip
wagon, or perhaps a Rip Van Winkle.
You didn't hear about the election of
Carter, Reagan, or Bush, Mac?
Okay,

festivals

in

hunker down here and I'll tell you about
triple whammy that hit the old smoke

a

weed-and-have-free-music bunch.
While I'm getting Mac straightened
out about funding, I'll deny his assertion
that my employer, the National Council
the

for

Traditional

Arts

(NCTA),

is

"coordinating government tours and festi
vals." We've organized fifteen national
tours in the last ten years, paying our
way with whatever federal, state, local and
private grants we could attract, and with a
lot of local sponsor and box office in
come. The biggest source of funds for us
and the local sponsors is, of course, the
box office. I know of eleven other orga
nizations that have tried folk music tour
ing in this period. We're notable because
we are still

in

the game after the others

quit.
but

Why did they drop out? I'm not sure,
I think
it was because it was so terri

bly easy. The profits were huge, border
ing on the astronomical, and they possi
bly grew weary of spending them. Some

people can't stand
The NCTA is

a life of ease.
private non-profit or

up to
a

ganization and no one has ever told me
where a government festival is that

I

Tell me where they are,
Mac, and I'll go there and coordinate as
hard as I can. Uh, one more thing, Mac.
You say the NCTA may become the
could coordinate.

"National Council for Dying Cultures"
because we prefer traditional to revival,

now book may not
have the vitality to hold audiences, that
you are denied access to audiences you
helped to create.
The total audience for the 1974-76
National Folk Festivals, the last three
which had Highwoods in a starring role,
The
ranged from 12,700 to 17,400.
the artists

that

1987-89
123,000

we

Nationals

to

165,000.

had audiences of
So if the National

dying, the wake

is really big!
and genres of mu
other
groups
Many
sic were involved, but if you want credit
for the size of the earlier audiences, you
can have it. Uh, would it be fair for me
to attribute the tenfold increase in the re

cent audience

to your absence?
Okay,
won't do that. But don't get the
big head about what you did for the Na
tional Folk Festival. It was even bigger

okay,

I

today in 1936, before either of us
was born.
Mac sometimes invents positions lor
I
can't
folklorists, then bops them.
than

imagine any folklorist claiming to be a
do know
dispassionate scientist. But
some that despise all folk music and feel
I

that

the hair on the tip of the tail of
folk studies that tries to wag
Most of the 1,100
whole animal.
it is

the dog of

the

members of the American Folklore Soci
ety have nothing at all to do with folk
music.
They know little or nothing
about it, and are likely to remain
disinterested. Those interested in it to the
point of doing any serious work in music
the exact number
is fifty or less
depending upon how seriously one defines
"serious."

Ethnomusicologists

are

more

con

cerned with folk music than folklorists
and are increasingly a presence in arts or
though
ganizations all over the country
I don't
know anyone of that persuasion
who is much interested in old-time mu
sic. A real steel belted six ply folklorist
teaches at the university level, does re
search, feels some pressure to publish,
and hopes for a sabbatical every seven

in order to do something interest
ing. People who have skills in the field
but are employed off campus are known

years

The
two confusing jargon terms.
most common one is public sector folk
lorist. How does that grab you? Univer
sities are more likely to be "public sec
tor" than not, but jargon does not need to
make sense. The term academic sector
by

folklorist

is an

obvious corollary, but

is

not used.

The second harebrained term is applied

folklorist and supposedly separates the
workaday person from the theoretical
folklorist (though no one uses that term).

�sometimes exact mental revenge

I

by

thinking of my campus-bound colleagues
unapplied folklorists.
There have been some terminology
Until recently people who
changes.
worked off campus, especially those
without advanced degrees, were called
as

folklorists.

amateur

retrograde

in my

Being somewhat

thinking,

I

better than the others and if

I

like that one
ever give up

my red-headed stepchild tag and promote
myself to folklorist, that's the kind I want

like being associated with wellintentioned potential bunglers. Eric Hoffer observed that those who could claim
least credit for themselves were quick to
claim all credit for their race, nation, or
region. He could have added profession.
An exaggerated
emphasis upon the
his
of
profession is a refuge
importance
to be.

I

marginally competent,

for the

a

claim for the eternal sophomores

I

tional

Folk

a

do.

Folklorists have been ambivalent
about folk festivals from their begin
nings. The first multi-ethnic festival was
More
the first National, held in 1934.
than a half century later it seems a won
drous affair, a roster of legendary folk
performers presented by a dozen of the

most productive collectors and folklorists
of the time. But the earliest report on it
in the Journal of American Folklore drips
What good could come of
suspicion.
this?

Here's
never been

a
a

there's
major confession:
time when folklorists were a

majority of the programming committee
that selects artists for the National Folk
Festival. The people who serve on that
committee, including folklorists, have
this in common: most are revival musi
cians. Our chairman is a banjoist who
has been a member of the Board for 19
He is a lawyer with a pro bono
years.
account for the NCTA, and his service
has to be measured in the thousands of
hours. He is also a bit of a wag, and
once commented that revival musicians
had developed two ways of thinking about
"One group wouldn't think
the festival:
of booking

themselves

on

it,

suggested a sharpened re
self-appointed national trea

status

benefactor of old-time music,
receiving applications and delegations,
giving grants and interviews. He'd not be
sitting in the corner glowering, smoke
coming out of his ears, worrying about
what

I

in the

had, he'd

If he

They never performed on
recall a comment from one
of them: "This festival is reserved for
some very special people; but for them it
would not be worth the effort."
it.

Another

and

the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

Festival

in

an

especially

pushy way: "Tell him that if we ever do
change our policy, he'll have to go to the
back of a very long line."
So I urge any of you who have been
irritated at folklorists to recognize that
they have not wronged you. A few of our
profession may
pedagogic brethren
like folk music, but most are no more
in that

likely

to

promote its performance than an
is likely to promote better

entomologist

treatment for fleas.

All

is

programming

of

course

hell else could it
discriminatory.
be? Some are chosen and others are left
What

in

unpicked on the vine for the bugs. Is that
fair? Of course not. If you must have a
group to blame for being left on the vine
with bugs chewing on your backside, feel
free to resent red headed stepchildren.
the Na
Here's another confession:
tional Folk Festival never stopped book
ing
or

revivalists.

Revivalists of one kind

another have been booked on all

festivals.

51

But Mac is right, there was

major policy change and it amounted
more than withdrawing the automatic
nual invitation to

Highwoods.

a

to

an
Basically,

it was a decision to put a much greater
emphasis upon the traditional, to get as

close

to the

original

as

possible,

sent the rare rather than

the

to

this
his

He is not. A British
critic calls him "execrable scum, a copy
machine, a hand linked to an eye without
passing through a brain."
There's a perfectly fine replica of the
in
Park
Parthenon in Centennial
that
was
The
Tennessee.
Nashville,
glory

workshops, managing stages, organizing
segments of
the festival.

Is

for

considerable skill?

it just happened.
Two of these volunteers would have to be
considered among the finest banjoists
performing. Five of them were fieldworkers for the festival, and all worked on
it in one capacity or another: leading

joists of the Board,

sure, a mediocre revival banjoist who had
been trying to book himself on the Na

Scholars sometimes suspect the rest of
commercializing the good and pure.
Mac was
Too often we are innocent.
amazed to find all those old-time bands
imitating Highwoods around the country.
That was clearly a missed opportunity.
He should have developed franchise sales,

McHighwoods plan.

have issued to his fakes.
dabbler admired and revered

perts

sponse

us of

now be

gree

to

work force.

a

that defies detection by respected
specialists. One could make a scrapbook
of the certificates of authencity that ex

other group can't think of anything else."
At one point in the early '80s there
were seven banjoists on the NCTA Board,
all but one performing in old-time styles.
No one planned to have that many ban-

pre

common

place.

Are we the only arts presenters who
prefer originals? Are we singular in pre
ferring the rare? If anyone can confirm
that we are, I promise to call a meeting of
our programming committee that will be
devoted to self criticism in the Maoist

style, followed by flagellation and mass
resignation.
There's a German painter, recently re
leased from a prison term for forgery,
who can imitate the style of any of a half
dozen famous European painters to a de

Greece is beautifully kept on a manicured
green, the columns all standing and the
Yet few come to see this
roof intact.
exercise in civic pride. But there's no
want for visitors at the site of the ancient
wreck in Athens. Standing on that hill
side one is awed by concepts that arose
from tribalism. How on earth did hardscrabble farmers, open boat fishermen,
and keepers of sheep and goats conceive
and create at an architectural level that has
dazzled men for more than two thousand
One feels affinity, sympathy, a
years?
closeness. Is it possible to feel close to a
concrete company and architectural copy

cats in Nashville?
Yes, we know that traditional arts ex
ist along a continuum, that even the most
traditional artist has made choices that re
flect an evolving. So why do we prefer
the less evolved? There are at least three
good reasons. One is justice. The most
original artists in our world of art tend to
be hidden from view. You can see every
thing else labelled folk
see the originals.

Second, this

is

but

it is

hard to

where we are needed.

The rest of the great array of artists la
belled folk tend to take good care of
themselves. There are, of course, com
plaints from artists who try to work as
folk professionals, but they are much like
the complaints one hears from other pro

fessional

musicians

which

is

to

say

they are reasonable complaints but there
is no special case for advocacy in them.

Third, virtually all presentations that
labelled folk have dropped the less
evolved in favor of artists who are of the
All
revival or, more likely, popular.
pressure on those who present is to make
are

everything look and sound like everything
else. "Purist" is the common pejorative
In more than
for anyone who resists.
like this, I
work
of
doing
thirty years
can't recall anyone ever asking for more
but only
purity. Everyone wants less
until they get it. Then the event looks
like all the rest and is boring and dies
without anyone noticing.
The revivalists found at the National
in recent years have most often been
Asians, Africans, and performers of vari
ous minority arts: American Indian

�dancers, klezmer musicians, and more.
Revivalism is easier for our programming
committee to accept when the originals
are very distant or very rare.

Are we

in

We hold to a
consistent?
We are.
slightly higher standard of authencity in
selecting Anglo-American and AfricanAmerican artists than we do when the
artists are from the Pacific Rim, Africa,
America.
troubled by all this? Not much.
Consistency is a trait as overrated as vir
ginity and nearly as useless.
Whenever anyone suggests that all the
very different people who wear the labels
folk, traditional or even old-time should
start pulling in the same direction, you
can be certain that that person is either
terribly idealistic or as dumb as a shovel.
I
think it is fine for us all to go off in
different directions; I choose what to do
with my life, and have no suggestions
or Latin

Am

I

about what you do with yours.
I've noticed that some from the oldtime revival no longer come to the Na
tional Folk Festival and I think that is
okay. I'm reminded of boyhood experi
ences with old field baseball.
My

That violates

precepts that most educated

Americans revere

much as they do
Here the race is not to the

motherhood.

as

swiftest, nor honors

student that

to the

raised his hand most often.

The one who

has worked hardest is not automatically
promoted, and the brightest is not neces

sarily considered the best. Here there's a
terrible perversion of conventional Amer
icanism, and the Social Register is used
for

doggie paper.

What seems to irritate people most is
our denial of the central religious tenet of
the intellectual portion of the great
American middle class. Their religion is
art and we
art can be

deny that access to an area of

bought.

There's no difficulty in buying your
way into most arts circles. If you wish
to be punk, you buy a tube of wax, put
your hair into five spikes, and spray them
with green paint.
You buy skin-tight
black vinyl pants, a red vest, three chains,
pointy toe boots, a safety pin for your
ear, an electronic keyboard, and five punk
records. You've paid your money and you
are punk from the first day. No one will
ever question it.
Some try to buy being folk with an
other uniform: DeKalb Corn or John

younger cousin Mattress owned all of our
team's equipment and held it hostage to
Captains didn't
being chosen captain.
have much to do, but Mattress considered
it an honor, and if not chosen he slowly
gathered up bat, ball, and mitt, all our
equipment, and trudged home, the epit
ome of spurned rectitude.
(His public
nickname was a bowdlerizing of Mattress
Ass, given in honor of his habit of aris

Deere cap, overalls, clodhopper shoes,
faded shirt, open-back banjo or factory
fiddle, and all of Tommy Jarrell's records.
You put on the uniform, buy a road atlas
detailed enough to show Galax or Mount
The gentle folks
Airy, and go there.
thereabouts will accept any waif that
wanders in, and musical ones are espe

ing late.)

cially treasured.

terrible thing, and the
only good that ever comes from it is song
writing royalties, self understanding, and
second marriages. It is especially hard on
folkies because they are so sensitive.

Rejection

is a

A long line of

folkies were upset with

before Mac came along. A few years
back the Old Time Herald's associate edi
tor, Brad Leftwich, opined in an Ohio
folkie rag that Howard Sacks and me were
using processes similar to Nazism in se
Does
lecting artists for the National.
us

imagine that we open program
committee meetings with a session of
goose stepping and seig heiling? Are all
negative pejoratives equal in his view?
Brad

Back in the '60s an Alabama Kluxer rag
called me a Communist for what I still
think was relatively good work, but no
one else has linked my name to Nazism.
But I'm not terribly offended by such
brickbats. They're a lefthanded rave re
view, and I treasure them.
I suppose we
seem terribly perverse

because it is not only the sound that is
being judged, but the family tree -past
and future
of the people making it.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

harmless process. If one is
dissatisfied with the family fate gave him,
it is okay to adopt another.
But fairness
demands that one be more than a young
cuckoo. Do you know the ingrate habits
of that bird that Tom Ashley sang about?
The cuckoo lays its eggs in the nests of
It

seems

a

other birds and they unwittingly raise its
young. The noisy and aggressive young

cuckoo often pushes

its

nestmates

the

natural offspring of its adoptive parents
over the side, out of the nest, and to
A hard corollary?
death.
Yes, it is
very hard and applicable only to a few.
But there really are ethical considerations

learning traditional skills and combin
ing them with non-traditional skills (such
in

self advertising) and going into
competition with traditional people.
Those sensitive enough to wish to
avoid young cuckoo habits could start by
not squawking about there being a few
places reserved for the originals of our
as

world of art, for the carriers of tradition.
They could also organize their thinking
and rely less on imagination in locating
their place in this world of art.

revivalist tendency to invent
impossibly romantic theory about folk
music, pass it back and forth as a formu
lation from anonymous folklorists, then
at an appropriate moment, to do a skin
There's

a

an

head baseball bat attack upon the theory
and folklorists

in general.
good example is the "isolated
mountain community" theory for the de
velopment and continuation of style in
old-time music. "They're all gone now!"
we hear from Mac and others, suddenly
there are no isolated places or people.
Any old retrograde geezer chugging down
the interstate is a last gasp ahead of the
actuary and probably can't hold a crowd
with his performance standards. There's a
self serving summary:
"They're dead,

A

we're it."
Yet I've never met a person who knew
their butt from third base in this area of

study

who thought that

isolation

had

much to do with the origin of style or its
continuation over time. Yes, I know that
many have speculated about it in print,

including some of the bigger windbags of
and I hold to what I just
folk music
said.

Among those otten explained by
physical isolation theory are my old
The
friends Stanley* and Ray Hicks.
supposed impenetrability of the Beech and

Wolf Scratch mountains have been de
scribed in magazines and newspapers that

range from The New Yorker to surburban
shoppers. Johnny Carson has had to en

dure repeated refusals to come chat from

both.
But Stanley

has a house on top of a
mountain because he wanted one there.
He keeps to his daddy's traditions because
he feels they are good. He made tires at a
factory at Radford, Virginia, during World
War II. He worked for several years at a
chicken processing operation in Burling
He
ton, N.C., far from the mountains.
worked for another food processing

in upstate New York. Isolated?
Ray has left less often, but to attribute
his great storytelling skills to isolation is

operation

idiocy.

Mac believes that isolation once kept

people distinct, but that it has ended and
He
that blob culture now takes over.
says, "People can no longer be born into
culturally distinct isolated geographic ar
eas. They just don't exist. We are now
all part of the homogenized blend, like it
In these and other comments
or not."
Mac reveals himself as a evangelist for
the

plasticus

His family

boobus americanus cult.
his community became

and

culturally mainstream, and Mac found the
water terribly tepid and perhaps even a bit
polluted. That is evidence of good taste,
but Mac is over his head in the main-

�stream and can't imagine other fluids such
as duck soup, sheep nanny tea, and home
brew with raisins.
The punk rocker with the five green
spikes on his head and the safety pin in
his ear agrees with Mac, and is running as
fast as he can from his perception. I pre
dict that he will eventually be found at
the mourner's bench in Mac's church, be
ing forgiven and sent forth wearing a

DeKalb Corn cap.

Mac is sometimes wonderfully evan

He says, "...we are the ones
which
(sic) the tradition is now
through
We
are
the link between its past
flowing.

gelical.

and its future and there is no other.

If

old-time music is played in the 21st cen
tury, it will be because of us and this will
be as true in the rural South as anywhere
else."

Jeez, old friend, I hate to rain on your
parade, but I think it is also flowing
through the Indians of the sub-arctic and I
their grandchildren
The
do in yours.
continuing
Athabascan Indians of the interior and
north of Alaska received mail only twice
have

more

faith

it

in

than

I

year during the 1920s and 1930s, but
they could send furs to Sears Roebuck and

a

they could receive crank-up phonographs,
records, fiddles and guitars. Now they
have a great fiddler's convention every
November, flying into Fairbanks from
the upriver and downriver Yukon villages,
some from north of the arctic circle in
Alaska, and others from Canada's most

remote reaches.
The tune heard most often from the
stage in the cozy Fairbanks Eagle's Hall
is More Pretty Girls Than One derived
from the 1930s Arthur Smith recording.
The recorded repertoire of Mainer's
Mountaineers is also well known. These
and other early hillbilly items are mixed
with old tunes from the early fur trade.
The fiddlers from Arctic Village and Old
Crow (Canada) clog their feet in the Que
bec manner and the Old Crow guitar
players clog along with the fiddler.
The second most common tune is The
Red River Jig, a favorite dance and tune

of the fur trade. It is well known among
Mitchif Indian fiddlers of North Dakota's
Turtle Mountain Reservation, descendants
of the Cree and Chippewa who were the
foot soldiers of the fur trade. Athabascan
Indian old-time fiddlers also play some

Scottish tunes from Hudson Bay
employees of long ago, a few French

tunes, and lots of items from 1920s-toHank Williams country music. The last
of the great North American primeval
hunting tribes, they neither sow or
gather, fish are for dogs, and men hunt
and eat meat. They are among the several
groups of "no others" the tradition is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

beautiful moment well
worth remembering, but surely not wor
The past is an
thy of fixative worship.
inescapable guide to the future, but it

flowing through, but don't worry about
slighting them. They've not heard about
Highwoods or any other revival bands, so

passed, perhaps

you're even.
Mac and I inhabit two very different
worlds of old-time music. His consists
largely of revivalists and a few old-timers
who inspired them, now almost all de

ceased.

He sees

need not be more than that.
Moreover, men are most ridiculous
whenever they try to appear to be what
The resulting incon
they cannot be.

revivalists everywhere,

the burnt corkers of the last century, the
perpetrators of the urban old-time music
scare of twenty years ago, and their pre
sent followers, whom he imagines will
carry it to the future. He sees its creative
peaks as those times when it almost be
came commercially viable.
My world of old-time music has many
players in a variety of traditional forms in
many places and is in a state of robust
health. No one worries about commer
cializing it, and the '50s and '80s seem as

important

as

the '20s and '60s.

see re

I

vivalists too, and there are some good
musicians among them, but they just

nor

don't seem that all-fired important

numerous

in a

qualitative sense.

I'd

guess

there are more really good old-time fid
dlers playing right now in the State of
Missouri than there have been good re
vival fiddlers in the entire country in this
century.
The largest group of "no others' the
stringband tradition is flowing through is
has

always flowed

same group
through. They may pick up a
item from popular performance,
vival, or the church, but they
their own and they can digest
what the great musicologist
the

it

nonfolk
the

make
a

re
it

lot of

Charles

Seeger called "nonfolkness." The folk
have swallowed whole genres of popular
On the
music without even burping.
other hand the nonfolk have
with folkness. They spend

a

a

tough time

a

lot of time

attributing and apologizing, classicizing
(only Round Peak style is real old time!),
and worrying about non-acceptance. The
highest goal is to create a sound indistin

guishable from one made by an old farmer
sixty years ago. It seems a paltry goal.
Old farmers tend to approve, but they
would approve even more if the goal was
to improve the sound.
In one of my favorite Homer and
Jethro routines, Homer stuck with a chord
too long, and Jethro protested. "You need
to get around more on that thing, go up
and down the neck like Chet Atkins," he
said. "You seem hung up in one place."
"Chet and them other guys are looking
for it," Homer responded. "I've found it"
Getting stuck in one place is as dan
Close
gerous for styles as for tunes.
the
best
black
is
a
creative
hole,
imitation
that the artist can create amounts to
nothing more than a moment already

gruity is a basis for comedy in cultures
that range from the tribal to the very so
men dressed as women,
phisticated:
women imitating the work movements of
men, white men in blackface, black men

whiteface.
There's a comment in the Bible about
it being easier for a camel to go through
the eye of a needle than for a rich man to
enter heaven. Thus far I've been able to
with the
avoid close relationships
wealthy, but I'm sure they think that ter

in

Are there any wealthy re
vivalists who would like to discuss the
discrimination inherent in being left out

ribly unfair.

and off the stage of the Na
tional Folk Festival? I'd like to talk to
But for a change just to those
them.
concerned with being left out of heaven.
Those worried about being left off the
National Folk Festival should pray.
Can we get really honest with each

of heaven

other and admit that old-time is a part of
folk music and thus the property of the

lower classes? Yes, I know that in this
great republic it is considered terribly un
patriotic to admit that there is more than
middle
one class even though its name

presuppose the existence of upper and

But I think I have the
lower classes.
I come
from a family in one of
right.
those lower classes, born in a two room
house at the head of an Appalachian hol
low, no electricity, no running water.
My mother was nineteen when I was
born, and I was a second son. She sang
ballads she'd learned from her grandmother
and my dad was the tenor in a gospel

harmonica player.
a good
Among the uncles, aunts, and cousins
there were fiddlers, banjoists, and gui

quartet and

tarists.
Mac speaks of having "...had the poor
fortune to be separated by age and
geography from the older southern musi
cians." Age is not an important factor in
his separation from the culture, and
region matters very little. Most of the
really good traditional musicians I meet
are younger than he is, and sweat stained
people exist everywhere and always have.
Only a pedant would ask that they be
defined. They do not remain fixed in time

performing arts museums, and they
define tradition as they move with it,
Sometimes they let old things die, and
as

that is okay if
to

die.

it is

time for that old thing

�Items from folk culture may have
value after death. There are a few people
in every age who learn from dry bones in
glass cases, from the shadows of what
once was on film, from field recordings
and the reports of

scholars housed

in

communication.

We are not the only people who have
struggle with these issues. My friend
Jill was for a time lawyer for the Mu
seum of New Mexico. One of the Mu
seum's sites is the ancient Palace of the
Governors in Santa Fe. For generations
Indians from various pueblos have sat in
the plaza at the front of the Palace, sell
ing handmade jewelry. A few years ago
to

non-Indian makers of handmade jewelry
wished to sell from that site. But the
Museum said this public place was re
served for an Indian tradition. There was
lawsuit and the Museum won its case of

a

Indian arts advocacy.

There's much glib generalizing nowa
days about what is called "cultural con

servation," but the term precedes any real

process or definition. It is a catch phrase
created for grants committees and budget
planners and reflects the flimsiness of
sloganeering, the petty posturing of ap
plicants and boosters. When our most
respected public institutions are asked to
preserve, they still must respond with
embalming. We've learned how to pickle
King Tut and how to keep the right
amount of humidity around the stuff he
had, and that is progress. Perhaps in the
next century we will get beyond
mummification and imitation and become
as adept at easing the transitions of life as
we are those of death.
I find it ironic that Mac does not know
how fortunate he was to be born in the

suspicious
saying he

middle class.

I'm

even

that he is pulling our crank in

admired older southern moun

tain culture. He never became part of that
culture, and he could have. If he had by
now spent twenty-five years on the
Piper's Gap road near Galax, he'd be
nearly indistinguishable from other

Grayson County residents.

good pickle by squirting vinegar on
cumber, it has to soak awhile.

mu

seums and archives. But the cemeteries
of a culture are always distant from its
birthing places, and there's not much

great American

You have to be more, stay longer,
and absorb some of what caused the cre
You can't make a
ation of the artistry.

style.

But learning

a

hundred and fifty tunes in a style does not
open a culture. Do the brass band mem
bers in the New Orleans 7th Ward wel

come the white boy jazzmen from Omaha
as long lost brothers whenever they blow
into town, knowing many of the same
tunes? Do plains Indians give barbeques
to honor the Boy Scouts who have be
come expert in rendering Indian dances?
They do not. Folk and tribal people
tend to be cordial, but brotherhood is
more than a hundred and fifty tunes in a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

find

it

as

playing

a

cu

bizarre that Mac sees his banjo
part of handed-off tool epi

logue that extends to west Africa through
the 19th century blackface minstrels. The
banjo did come from Africa, but it had
been evolving on these shores for two
centuries before the minstrels took it up.
They claimed that their songs and tunes
came from slaves. Performers who had
never been south of Baltimore concocted
stories about visits to plantations. And
of course there was not a word of truth in
the stories. They drew upon their Anglo
Irish

and

musical precepts, performed

items from a broad range of European
folk traditions, and wrote thousands of
the common popular solution.
others
So why a claim of African ancestry for
In most cases even the
their music?
banjo had come to the burnt cork boys
via southern whites, so why this false
claim that was to be repeated for a
Why so much insecurity
generation?
about who they were and their creations?
The political essence ot revivalism is

found

in

populism,

an

assumption that

superiority of an earlier age.
points
It looks backward and longs for a lost
to the

agrarian Eden when the laborer had good
prospects, the farmer had abundance, there
were no beggars, people sang around a

flawless common
a nearly
endowment of rich resources was held in
campfire, and

lands, minerals, and culture. It says that
we have but to throw off the present er
rors (Mac's Eisenhower years) and become
unified to regain this lost Eden.
It stems from an ancient urban belief
that virtue and quality is first given to

basic people; that the veneers of civiliza
tion mask more than they reveal, that
open spaces and hard work build character.
It

is

found

in

many

cultures

and

is

The star blazed over the most
humble abode in Bethlehem, a stable, the

timeless.

were poverty-stricken, poor
shepherds were given the honor of
welcoming, while wise men had to travel

couple

far and pay tribute.

What did the burnt cork boys give the
African American for his banjo? They
gave him unmitigated hell and beat him
over the head with it for most of a cen
They portrayed him on stage and in
more akin to apes
a subhuman
find
other images as
To
people.
mean as theirs, one must see illustrations
made during the first European witch
tury.

print as
than to

burning mania or in Julius Streicher's
ghoulish Der Sturmer of the 1930s.
Mac's view of art is totally concerned

with object and item; they send out mes
sages and are separable from their cre
ators. So a fine copy is as good as an

original, and banjos and quilts are encoded
with information from the past. This is
object worship.
Mac says that in gathering material for
his article, he found stories "ranging from
the amusing to the infuriating, reflecting
the current attitude of the folklorists to
Well, I
wards so-called 'revivalists.'"
but I
the
for
stories
folklorists,
tell
can't
few anecdotes of my own. I came
job after years of interacting with
serious collectors and learners who took

have

a

to my

re
pride in accuracy, and had considerable
truth.
the
for
gard
first week at the NCTA
I was in my
when I noticed the record, picture, and
press release burble for Marie. She was

a Vogue model with a fiddle.
The burble said that she was a fiddler but

beautiful,

classically trained and could "fiddle the

socks off most old time fiddlers." I've
had a long acquaintance with old time
fiddlers. I met Charlie Bowman, Arthur

Smith,

Pappy

Kessinger

and

Clark
McMichen,
If
Benny Thomasson.

Marie could fiddle their socks off, she had
I
to be great.
put the record on the
turntable with considerable anticipation.
Early in the first side it became obvious
that either the old time fiddlers in Marie's
neighborhood were in a terribly weakened
condition or her burble writer was deaf.
Other disappointments followed. An
audition cassette from a band on the coast
found its way to my desk and I found it
amazing. These folks were playing tunes
from a Tommy Jarrell album in the same
order that they appeared on Side 1 of the
knew the order because I'd
I
record.

helped choose
in the

putting
later

a

it,

cutting up the tape and

paper leader.

manager-performer

A few days

telephoned me.

Here's how I recall what was said.
"Yes, Ma'am, I did get your cassette
and it is very nice. You're coming along
fine, getting a good string band sound, so
keep on doing it."
"So you'll hire us for the National
Folk Festival?"
"Well, Ma'am, we hire just one oldIt is not an
time band for the festival.

old-time festival

or

country music festi

val, we have to cover lots of bases, many
very different ethnic and regional musics,
and we're planning to hire Tommy Jarrell
this year and I know you would not want
to

compete with him...."

(interrupting) "Why not? You call it a
national festival, but it looks very skewed
to the east to me. You need to hire some
people from out here, get some regional
balance."
"Are

you telling me that your band

�wants to compete with Tommy, playing
his music?"

He doesn't own the
"Oh, come on.
He got it from somebody too,
It is an international music
didn't he?
now, not just a little localized sound. He

music.

may be a link in a chain, but we are too,
and a link beyond him. You need to have
a broader program, you've had bands from

that little area for years, now you need to
represent the places it has spread to."
"Do you think I'll be able to find a
Monterrey Jack cheesemaker in West

Virginia?"
"I

"If

don't understand."
everything is from

everywhere and

has to be equally represented, I'll need to
find a Monterrey Jack cheesemaker from
West Virginia for our crafts and foodways
area."

think you'll be able to do it, and
you know what you can do with it when
you do." (Hangs up).
"I

Clog dance salespersons are

as

ubiqui

tous and necessary to the clatter and bang
business as frilly skirts and pubescence.
The one that called in the fall of 1978
came on like he was King Kong and we
the keeper of the banana tree. A deluge of
adjectives described the dancer's costumes
and the names of respected people who
admired them came in a torrential gush.
When there was time to get in a word
edgeways, I asked: "What kind of band
supplies your music?"
"Band?" he asked, his voice rising in
outrage. "Do you think I'd be so unpro
fessional as to use a BAND? They get
out of time, they're difficult to work
with, and our routines are very precise.
We use recordings, good recordings, we
are not the kind of group that would use a

BAND."
"But dancers get out of time at least as
"We
often as musicians," I protested.
could do that in reverse and put a band on
stage and let them play and project slide
That might work
pictures of dancers.
even better, people like live music and
we'd have less than half as many people
on for a moment, de
I talked
to pay...."

veloping the idea, and heard him mutter,
"I don't believe this!
just before a click
announced that my ruminating further
"

would amount to a soliloquy.
They were a young couple from the
New York City area and I believe he was
the fiddler and she the banjoist, and they
were sure that a lack of social connection
had prevented their being booked on the
This was the
National Folk Festival.
third time they had applied, and they had
come by to argue a point without asking
was the proper one to argue.
"We don't believe you need a codger
connection to play this music well," she
if

it

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"I know that some others feel that
you have to mess around with those old
people, but we can't see how it helps

said.

musically."

"We just
He was even more explicit:
don't think that you need to associate
with a bunch of unwashed old geezers to
sing and play these tunes. We feel it is a
better use of our time to rely on record
ings and people we can relate to in other

ways."

I
get to be the hero in most of my
stories, and this time I really did rise to
the occasion. I quoted Hank Williams to
"... needs to
them, his dictum that one
have walked in the row and smelled mule
farts to sing hillbilly songs." An uneasy
disquiet settled on the room and they soon
excused themselves, citing another ap
pointment. Of course I'm not absolutely
certain that mule farts help a lot, but who

am

I

to

argue with Hank?

few
months before his
A
Thomas
Jefferson
death,
(Tommy) Jarrell
visited Gambier, Ohio, in the company of
his good friend and fellow musician Andy
He and I
Cahan to perform a concert.
Howard
and
beside
Judy Sacks'
lingered
barn while the others went into their fine
old farmhouse.
Tommy was feeling his
years, and we reminisced about old friends
and all night sessions of some fifteen
years before. He said that most people of
his years were lonely, but he never had
been, the musical visitors still came al
most every day, and sometime two or
three groups in a single day.
you know who did that," he
he gave the names, one after
list of the less-than-a-dozen
him available to all the rest,

recorded his music and put

"But now

said.

Then

the other,

a

who made
those who

it in the

hands

of players everywhere, those who took
him west and north to concerts and festi
vals, those who made his movie, all who
gave something important back to this
most generous man. I don't think he for

The names ended and
anyone.
"Not a
Tommy paused for a moment.
would
have
thing
happened
goddamn
got

without them," he said.

The originals of our world of art need
Some who
do-gooders.
were a friend to Tommy may bristle at
that term, but I think it a good one. The
particular set of do-gooders with whom I
the support of

associated amount

to a Board of
and some
five
employees,
twenty-seven,
There's no
three hundred volunteers.
members, no mailing list, not even a
statement of purpose beyond what non
profit incorporation requires. No one in
the group is very wealthy or especially
famous, and we have no guarantees, no

am

continued on page 43
31

I

�CLASSIFIED
The Old-Time Herald will accept
classified ads at the cost of .50 cents per
word, minimum $7 00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the
first of the month, 2 months prior to

publication.

SUBSCRIBE

Old time string bands, bluegrass, gospel.
1920s-1960s. Send $1.00 for catalog.
Joe Bussard, 6610 Cherry Hill Dr.,
Frederick, MD 21701.

282-1219.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

our

Mi.

48901 (517) 372-7890.

DISCOUNT

10,000 titles.
blues, jazz, old time
country, and much more, listed by
category of music and by artist. ELDERLY
INSTRUMENTS 1 100 N. Washington,
folk,

POB 14210-BG34,

(517)372-7890.

ence answered promptly and in depth.
Or,

919-383-5750.

45&lt;f

S.A.S.E. brings

current listing. Subscriptions with extra
services $5.00. Harry &amp;c Jeanie West,
3815 Tremont Dr., Durham, North

Carolina 27705.

RECORDS, CASSETTES, COMPACT

DISCS! NEW FREE
CATALOG with over

BLUEGRASS &amp; OLD-TIME
INSTRUMENTS, new, used, vintage.
Free, friendly advice. All correspond

FINE

monthly

prices. $4.00/year ($8.00
overseas). Current issue free on request.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.
Washington, POB 14210-BG34, Lansing,

ELDERLY
Fiddler with FlattSIMS
Scruggs team (1949-52). Musical tapes,
video.
instructional books, &amp;. tapes
Free brochure. Benny Sims, 318 Swanee
Dr., Johnson City, TN 37601 (615)

BENNY

to

to-earth

Bluegrass,

COUNTRY MUSIC CLASSIC TAPES:

NOW

used and vintage instrument list with
hundreds of quality instruments at down-

Lansing, Mi. 48901

INSTRUMENTS. Send

for

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION
NEW-USED-VINTAGE guitars, banjos,

mandolins, archtops, wood &amp; metal
body Dobros, Nationals. Mandolin
Brothers, 629 Forest Ave. Staten Island,
NY 10310. FREE CATALOG
718981-3226. Call for no-charge evaluation
of your vintage fretted instruments.

THE

MANDOCRUCIAN'S DIGEST

discount catalog of acoustic
instruments and accessories. Flatiron,

America's only MANDOLIN publication!

Deering, Shubb, Martin, Stelling, Reiter,
Stiver, Wild wood, and much more.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.

styles.

our

free

Washington, POB 14210-BG34, Lansing,
Mi.

48901 (517)372-7890.

Interviews,

instruction,

Quarterly

$14.00).

reviews.

All

$10/year (foreign

Sample-$3.00. NILES
HOKKANEN, POBx 1935-H, Martinsburg, WV 25401.

�P

Everybody naturally wants
to hear the best music
4000
t

CANDY FROM STRANGERS
The Dixie Dartin's

t

PINES AND SHORE

4001

SONGS

4002

Merce Ridgway and the Pinehawkers
WHERE THE CRICKETS FIDDLE

I

Jim

OF THE JERSEY

7.00

9019

7.00

9020

7.00

Albertson

9021

4003

MOVING DAY

7.00

4004

Beeman Band
HOTEL PLACENTA
Ken Haferman and Rob Hunter

7.00

BALALAIKA RUSSE IN CONCERT

7.00

9022

The Barbara

I
I

6000
j_

Balalaika Russe

9024

8000

THROW YOUR TIME AWAY

8001

The Otis Brothers
LET IT ROLL!

8003

RIGHTEOUS

8004

WALKING BLUES

8005

|i

9000
9001

9002
9003
9004

I

I

9005
9006
9007
9008
9009

I

9010
I
1

9011

9012

t

7.00

7.00

9013
9014

9015
9016

T

9017
It

2

9600
7.00
9601

7.00

A

C-02

THE 1935

7.50
C-04
7.00
C-05

7.00
C-08

THE WILDCATS
The Wildcats

7.00
C-09

MIND -BANDS

7.00

Andy Cahan

C-10

DOWN HOME RAG

7.00

C-ll

Vesta Johnson

GOIN' UP TOWN

P. O.

BOX 447, CROWN POINT,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

IN

46307

7.00

3
g

g
g
S
3

(219) 769-6217

3

g
g
5
3

7.50
7.00
7.00

g
gS

3
S(

3
7.50

Produced by the National Council for Traditional Arts

GRAND CANYON COWBOY BAND

Reunion concert, Prescott Hall Museum
STAND BAYOU
Stand Bayou Cajun Band
DUETO CHUBASCO
Linda O'Hagen, Peter McCracken, David Cahn

7.50
7.50

7.50

GOOD COMPANY

7.50

The Allen Street String Band
THE PRIDE OF GLENCOE
Lotus Dickey and friends

8.00

IN

g
g
g3

ft
7.00
7.00

Old Time String Bands, Vol. 2
UP AGIN THE MOUNTAIN (with booklet)
Everett Pitt, ballad singer
FEAST HERE TONIGHT!
Rabbit In a Log (Skip Gorman and Rich Starkey)
THE RISKY BUSINESS BLUEGRASS BAND
Risky Business Bluegrass Band
THE COWBOY TOUR (with booklet)

C-07

SOUTHERN CATALOG

1.50

1

C-01

C-06

The Ross County Farmers

7.00

Also Available through Marimac

7.50

7.00

by W.K. McNeil
MAKE ME A COWBOY AGAIN FOR A DAY
Cowboy song anthology
CHEVROLET SIX
Oscar Ford with McMichen, Stokes, Puckett
JOHNNY'S GONE TO WAR
War song anthology
IT'LL NEVER HAPPEN AGAIN

MOUNTAIN MUSIC

8.00

The Kimble Family
THE FIRST TIME
Lotus Dickey and Friends

8.00

DANCE AROUND IN YOUR BONES

8.00

Laketown Buskers
8.00
UNCLE HENRY'S FAVORITES
Jim Childress, Pete Vigour, Ellen Vigour, Mark Bcall
8.00
JACK KNIFE AND THE SHARPS
Jack Knife and the Sharps
PLEASE ADD $1.50 PER CASSETTE FOR POSTAGE AND

GOING ACROSS THE RIVER TO HEAR
7.00
C-12
MY BANJO RING
Carlic Marion with Andy Cahan
NON U.S.A. ORDERS:
ALL PRICES ARE POST PAID WITHIN THE U.S.A.
HANDLING. INDIANA RESIDENTS MUST ADD 5% STATE SALES TAX. Marimar
9018

2

7.50

Dance Band
FARMER'S FROLIC
The Fish Family

Joe LaRose

f

9200

7.00

7.00

Golden Age gospel anthology

Old Time String Bands, Vol.
9111

FLUKE HITS

7.00

5

g
gS

7.00

7.00

JOYFUL NOISE, VOL. 1
Golden Age gospel anthology
A JOYFUL NOISE, VOL.2

A

g

7.00

9110

in Philadelphia
GOIN' DOWN THE COUNTRY
Steve Garcia and Matt Levine
GOING NOWHERE FAST (with booklet)
Uncle Willie and the Brandysnifters
WHEN THE YANKEES CAME DOWN
Major Contay and the Canebrake Rattlers
BEHIND THE TIMES
Bob Bovee and Gail Heil
STILL LAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS
The Lazy Aces String Band
OLD TIME FRIENDS (with booklet)
Produced by Ray Alden
IN THE HILLS OF HOME (with booklet)
Raymond Smith and Bob Cowan
TRADITIONAL FIDDLE MUSIC OF MISSOURI
Charlie Walden with Emily and Dennis Buckhannon

(formerly C-03)

ft

&lt;2

9109

TUESDAY NIGHT LIVE

7.00

3

7.00

7.00
7.00

7.00

Annotations

9108

LOVE THEM DUCKS
Half Shaved

7.00

g
g2

9106
7.00

Conte

3

7.00

7.00

Old Time Music

j.

I

BLUES

BACKSIDE OF BUNCOMBE

The Volo Bogtrotters
TAKE ME AS I AM
Bruce Molsky and Bob Carlin
THE VOLO BOGTROTTERS

gS

7.00
7.00

EVOLUTION GIRL
The Double Decker Stringband

of their first tape

7.00

THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL.1
Moonshine and temperance anthology
9105 THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL. 2
Moonshine and temperance anthology
9104-05 THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE (Booklet)
9104

John Cephas and Phil Wiggins
CRYIN' WON'T MAKE ME STAY
Bob Guida
FORKED DEER
Dan Gellert and Shoofly
SONGS THAT SCARE ME
Pat

i

f

9101

Bill Ellis

I

I

7.00

7.00

I

I

9100

7.00

8002

The Ill-Mo Boys

Re-issue

7.00

John Cephas and Phil Wiggins
IN THE LAND OF CORN AND WINE
The Otis Brothers

I

I

9023

COME ALL YOU WADDIES
Bob Bovee
TIMELY OLD TUNES FROM ILL-MO
AND BEYOND

1

Recordings

g
3
3

g
g
3
3

g
g

3
ft

g
g
g
3
3
g
g5
3
3
2

�Sales

County
53
EH
EH
mJ

/tV
W"\- yAw

INTERNATIONAL

FC-007
*ROU-0237
'CCLP-0107
*BSR-1001

CO-756

AT-103

ELD-003
ELD-004

JB

■E
■U

*JA-051
"CCS-110

CO-513
CO-411

"ROU-0236
OH-184
*BR1-010

OT-128
CO-717
CO-516
*CMF-011

CO-519
HER-063

^B
PU
^JB
L^^B

PL|

LJfl

CO-786
CO-787
OH-198

CO-511

"CO-506
MARLU-8901

CO-403
AH-002
OT-112
HER-070
"FF-415

FF-480

PJ
UP

HER-067
*JA-055
*JA-056
CO-533
*CO-734
FF-468
MRDB-0105
"AJA-5058
*ROU-0122

CO-548

BLUEGRASS

MUSIC

^JB

H

HJ

ACCEPTED

ASSOCIATION

NEW RELEASES
MASTERS OF TRADITIONAL MISSOURI FIDDLING Lovely 2-LP set with huge booklet
VIRGINIA-CAROLINA SAMPLER Featuring Lonnie Austin, Jim Scancarelli, Wayne Henderson, etc
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BANJO COLLECTION Super set of 1937-46 field recordings by John Lomax
CARTER FAMILY "Diamonds In The Rough" Lovely issue of 1941 Border Radio transcriptions
BLUE SKY BOYS "There'll Come A Time" Excellent reissue of early 1936 recordings
TOMMY JARRELL "Sail Away Ladies" One of his best LPs
great old time fiddle
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial and field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
FRENCH MITCHELL "First Fiddle" Fine fiddle LP by 71 year old West Virginian
THE MUSIC NEVER DIES"AVandalia Sampler 1977 -87" Lovely 2-LP set of West Virginia musicians
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo/fiddle LP by this Kentucky musician
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Excellent reissue of their classic 1940 s King sides

30
WHITTER Lovely set of songs and ballads from 1927
"Waitin' For The Evening Mail" Great reissue of Puckett's 1930 s recordings
BLUE SKY BOYS "In Concert 1964" Super live concert from University of Illinois
Vol 3" Fine reissue of early 1920s recordings
UNCLE DAVE MACON "Hillbilly Blues
EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO With Tommy Magness, Roy Hall, Roanoke Entertainers, etc
PIONEERS OF CAJUN ACCORDION 1926 -36 With Joe Falcon, Amade Ardoin, Amade Breaux, etc
Vol 2 Featuring Tommy Jarrell, Oscar Wright, Fred Cockerham, etc
CLAWHAMMER BANJO
Vol 3 Great old-time recordings
CHARLIE POOLE &amp; THE NORTH CAROLINA RAMBLERS
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
Vol 2 Features Arkansas string bands of 1927 -30
ECHOES OF THE OZARKS
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, Andy Cahan, Brad Leftwich, etc
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent field recordings with Clyde Troxell, Clyde Davenport, etc
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN More field recordings with Virgil Anderson, Dee Hicks, etc
GID TANNER &amp; HIS SKILLET LICKERS "Early Classic String Bands" from 1934 recordings
MOUNTAIN BLUES Reissue with Sam McGee, Jimmie Tarlton, Dock Boggs, Doc Roberts, etc

GRAYSON

&amp;

5.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
8.00
$15.00
7.50
7.50

SKILLET LICKERS Old-time tunes recorded form 1927 thru 1931
Clayton McMichen, etc
nice
LULU BELLE &amp; SCOTT Y "Tender Memories Recalled" From early 1950 s radio shows
ROANE COUNTY RAMBLERS Their complete recordings of 1928-29
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American Fiddle Music From Mississippi -with booklet
JIMMY TARLTON &amp; TOM DARBY Fine reissue of 1927 -1932 recordings
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis, Roscoe Parish, w/booklet
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
WALT MICHAEL &amp; COMPANY "Step Stone" Features hammered dulcimer, fiddle etc
GALAX INTERNATIONAL 2-LP set featuring Mike Fenton, Kazuhiro Inaba, etc
MORGAN SEXTON "Rock Dust" Traditional Appalachian ballads with banjo &amp; fiddle
RALPH BLIZARD &amp; THE NEW SOUTHERN RAMBLERS "Blizard Train" OT fiddle from Tennessee
ROUND THE HEART OF OLD GALAX
Vol 1 Featuring the music of Ernest Stoneman
BONNIE RUSSELL/RUSSELL FAMILY "Mountain Dulcimer
Galax Style" (Cassette only)
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" Recent old-time music by this West Virginia group
MILL RUN DULCIMER BAND "You've Been A Friend To Me" Old-time, traditional, sentimental music
JIMMIE RODGERS "My Old Pal" Reissue of 18 songs from 1927
32 sessions
Import
NORMAN BLAKE/RISING FAWN STRING ENSEMBLE Featuring Nancy Blake, James Bryan
RIDIN' IN A OLD MODEL T Features Dixie Ramblers, Rector Trio, Ray Brothers, etc
by an

asterisk

"

$7.50

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

1A.

5

7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00

$7.50

7.50
7.50
$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

1^1

1^4

LX
LJH

B^J
IJ|

$7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50

$7.50

UB

$7.50

UBl

8.00

$10.00

7.50
7.50
$12.50
7.50

$7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

$10.00
7.50
7.50

L|^H

B^
LJ|

")

to 3 LPs, add $3.00 for 4 or more LPs
&amp; HANDLING: USA ORDERS: Please add $2.00 for first
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Please add $5.00 postage and handling charges for up to 3 LPs,
then $1.50 for each additional LP. MINIMUM FOREIGN order is 2 items.
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

POSTAGE

WQ

1

RILEY PUCKETT

(Above albums available on cassette as noted

■Q

H
H

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
MEMBER OF

GREY- 101

[Tl

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
W
READY FOR SHIPMENT

fJB

jTjA

�Reviews
Artists and record companies
please
send records and tapes for review to The
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Dur
ham, NC 27717. Do not send to indi
vidual reviewers.

Davidson's banjo tends

to lack

cohesion

and drive,

while the guitar of Brooke Moyer is too quiet and
undefined to provide the foundation the band
needs. "Cotton-Eyed Joe," a fiddle/banjo duet,
manages to express some energy through sheer
will-power, but speed and dynamics can never
make up for a basic lack of flow to the music, and
the effect sounds forced. Caleb Finch sounds like a
talented musician but he plays too many notes, too
quickly, without benefit of a coherent style. On
slower numbers, such as "Jack of Diamonds," he
gets a pretty melodic sound, but the faster numbers
are quite stiff.

However, according to the title, the major focus
of this album is the singing, and there are some fine
vocals here. I prefer Moyer's style, but I think both
Brooke Moyer and Eric Davidson show a lot of

SONGS OF
OLD TIME
AMERICA
Iron

talent. (Linda Higginbotham)

Mountain

To

order: Peach Bottom Records, 10153 1/2
Riverside Drive, #314, Toluca Lake, CA 91602.

String
Band
Brooke
banjo

Moyer-vocals, guitar;
Caleb Finch-fiddle.

Eric Davidson-vocals,

Dixie/Jack of Diamonds/John

Henry /Weeping

Willow/Cotton-Eyed Joe/Constant Sorrow/
Walking Cane/Devil's Curst Wife/FDR/ White
house Blues/Pretty Fair Miss/Lazarus

This old-time band from California was complete
unknown to me when their album arrived at my
door; I had no preconceptions about their music.
Unfortunately, everything that is wrong with this
album tends to leap out on its first cut, '"Dixie," and
it took me a while to regroup and listen further. I
am glad that I did. Needless to say, I have mixed
feelings about this band.
was able to
Eric Davidson is the only member
glean any information on. He evidently spent time
recording Wade Ward and other traditional artists
for Folkways Records. This fact, along with the
choice of material on the album and general tone of
it, lead me to believe this is a band with strong
traditional sympathies. However, this has not
translated into a direct, gutsy, traditional sound.
Perhaps folky-sounding old-time best describes
their music.
One of the best things on the album is the singing
of Brooke Moyer. On both harmony and lead, her
voice has an honest, straight-forward quality that
enlivens even a well- worn favorite like "Weeping
Willow." (Eric's harmony on this cut is also nice.)
Brooke sings with a genuine feel for both traditional
ly

I

old-time

(as on "John Henry") and early bluegrass
(as on "Lazarus") styles. Her harmonies are espec
ially nice. She knows when "less is more" and often

remains on the same note to great effect. Her
choice of notes on the a cappella "Pretty Fair Miss"
is wonderful. With the dearth of good traditional
vocalists performing, Brooke is a welcome addition
to the performing circuit.
Eric Davidson is, in some ways, a more accom
plished singer than Moyer. But he has not overcome
(or perhaps chooses to include) an affectedness in
his singing which makes his vocals sound too much

like folksinging for my old-time taste. Be that as it
may, Eric is a good singer, and the singing on this
album ranks high among old-time bands in general.
Overall, the instrumental are competent but
uninspired. This band does not deliver the punch
that characterizes old-time music at its best.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�artistry, lacked the energy of the Skillet Lickers or
the moving sentiment of the Carters; and Roberts'
more limited touring activities surely lessened his
chances of stardom in the emerging country music
system. He retired to playing local dances while
fiddlers like Clayton McMichen and Arthur Smith
were furthering the modernization of southern
fiddling. In the 18 years before his death in 1978

Roberts was visited by folklorists and was gratified
by a renewed interest in his music.
A discography of the nearly 80 sides Roberts
recorded is provided, along with notes on the tunes
included on the present set. The notes are inform
ative when they pin down a title like "Way Down
South" as being the Kerry Mills ragtime piece
"Whistlin' Rufus." (Roberts' son James explained
the name change: "A lot of the recording executives
couldn't tell one fiddle tune from another, and the
fiddlers soon figured this out. When some studio
boss rejected a tune because he had already cut a
version on that label, a lot of fiddlers just changed
the name of the tunes and went on and recorded
what they liked.") But Wolfe is less helpful when
he fails to spot "The Devil in Georgia" as "Tee
totaler," associating it incorrectly with the "Stony
Point" ("Pigtown Fling") tune family; or when he
calls "Deer Walk" a "rarer localized eastern Kentucky
tune"
it is actually the well-known "Forked Deer."
As a link between older fiddle styles and modern
fiddling, and as a stylist in his own right, Doc
Roberts has his place in the story of southern
fiddling. His work is well served by this wellpresented and interestingly annotated collection.
(Art Rosenbaum)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Car/Easy Rider/Old Master's Run Away/Buck
Dancer's Choice/Charming Bill/No One Else Can
Take Your Place/If Could Hear My Mother Pray
I

Again
Sam and Kirk McGee from Williamson County,
Tennessee, hooked up with Uncle Dave Macon in
1925 and began to broadcast on Nashville's first
radio station. As members of Uncle Dave Macon's
Fruit Jar Drinkers, and as charter members of The
Grand Ole Opry, the brothers helped shape the
history of country music as it began its metamor
phosis from local and family entertainment to
become a staple of the national mass media.
This welcome reissue from Old Homestead
documents the comparatively little-known career
the McGees enjoyed apart from Macon and the
Opry and the Dixieliners, as recording artists in
their own right. Their discography is brief but
startlingly good. Even if they had never appeared
with Macon or on the Opry, and these sides,
recorded between 1926 and 1934, were the only
legacy we had from the McGees, we would still
honor them as giants of old-time music.
On first hearing, the solos and duets of Sam and
Kirk sound quaint. Unlike contemporaries such as

Jimmie Rodgers, the Carter Family, the Mainers
and Monroes, Arthur Smith, or even such obscure
bands as The Roane County Ramblers, the McGees
weren't shaping their music progressively and
moving it toward some future destiny as bluegrass,
swing, or country. Their performing style and
repertoire appear to have jelled sometime around
1915, in that fascinating and unrecorded postragtime era when many kinds of 19th-century
music were merging, dying, and giving birth to the
new musics of the twentieth century. The brothers
continued to play much the same music for the
next half-century and attracted no disciples or
imitators until their discovery by folk revivalists
in the late '50s. None of the songs on this album,
for instance, were picked up from the McGees by
later musicians in the way that the blue yodels of
Rodgers continued to be sung by honkytonkers in
the 1940s, or that Monroe and Carter songs live on
in the bluegrass tradition. The McGees' "Salty Dog
Blues," with its raggy, irregular rhythm and minor
key, could not be played by a bluegrass band in the
way that the Morris Brothers' slicker version can
It just sits there in all its idiosyncratic
pure and unredeemable old-time.
The great beauty and value of the McGee
Brothers solos and duets lies precisely in their

be 'grassed.

loveliness,

quaintness.

of old-time

them we can clearly hear the making
music out of its component nine

In

teenth-century parts ragtime piano, parlor guitar,
sentimental songbook balladry, vaudeville and

popular tunes, minstrel show and blues, cylinder
recordings, fiddle tunes, and Anglo-American
ballads. Often, the brothers will nakedly juxtapose
quite separate traditions: the misnamed "Knoxville
Blues" actually consists of a pair of guitar solos, a
waltz right out of the genteel parlor tradition of
picked displays in Sevastopol or fandango open
tunings, and a driving blues break from the newer
black guitar tradition. "No One Else Can Take
Your Place," a duet by Kirk and his relative Blythe
Poteet, links a sob-drenched stanza in 1890s 3/4
time with an insouciantly syncopated boop-a-doop

1920s chorus.
As performers, the brothers delved into a greater
spectrum of older musical traditions than did any
other old-time greats, yet, curiously, each brother
seems to have chosen different traditions within
which to specialize. Kirk preferred sentimental
songbook tearjerkers, yet was the more effective
blues singer of the brothers. Sam's history of
learning blues licks from black players is well
known, yet unlike other blues-oriented guitarists
such as Frank Hutchison, Sam could also play with
delicacy, a touch very much in debt to parlor guitar

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and piano music. His "Franklin Blues" (which will
appear on a promised volume two), for example,
has nothing to do with the blues, but must certainly

as a piano instru
mental.
Most listeners will find Sam's guitar displays the
album's highlights: here are "Railroad Blues" and
"Buckdancer's Choice" in all their glory, the
tantalizing snatch of the "Amos Johnson Rag"
tossed off as a punchline at the end of "The Ship
Without a Sail," and the glorious "Easy Rider"
probably the
accompanied on the banjo-guitar
greatest performance of raggy picking on old-time
records, socked out with all of Mr. Sam's show
manship and comedic gusto.
The sound transfer is decent: the McGee solos
and duets first appeared on Vocalion and Gennett
78s, discs often of marginal sound quality even
when found in mint condition. Collectors will
welcome the opportunity to replace their aged
tapes of these masterpieces. Charles Wolfe's excel
lent notes, based on his interviews with Sam and
Kirk, provide much valuable insight into the
diverse traditions which lie behind the music of the
McGees. No old-time music collection can be
without this record. As Uncle Dave would say,
we'll
"Hallo, folks, talk about hot air and wind
give you something real now, right from Tennessee.

have had an earlier incarnation

Let's go!"

(Jon

and Marcia Pankake)

�North, she made songs that were bitterly auto
biographical. In 1939, a few years after leaving
Kentucky, she recorded for the Library of Congress
traditional and of her
a great body of songs, both
own authorship, as well as much narrative material
on her life. It is from these recordings that this LP
was compiled. This collection stresses her protest
included are two religious songs but none
songs

of the secular folk songs and ballads that she
recorded. The editors acknowledge that this choice
does perpetuate the unbalanced view of Aunt
Molly as a mountain-grown radical. On the other
hand, since it does focus on the power of her
achievement as a maker and singer of songs of

life-and-death struggle, it etches her clearly as a
monumental figure in this idiom. And this album,

which has been out for a few years but deserves a
wider audience, will remind lovers of "old-time
music" that such music served (and still serves
today, viz. the bluegrass, hymns, and union songs
today during the Pittston coal strike) not only as
and dance music,
of political and social

entertainment, self-expression,
but also

as

an

instrument

action.

Alan Lomax recorded and interviewed Aunt
Molly for the Library of Congress, and his appraisal
of her art is prominent on the front of this record's
jacket, underneath a stark photo of the singer:
"Aunt Molly Jackson and Texas Gladden were the
finest traditional singers I met in the United States

Her songs of protest can only be matched by
those of Woody Guthrie, but they were more
we
passionate than his and they cut deeper." While
have the jacket in hand, let's turn it over. Another
photo shows Aunt Molly in full mountain getsun bonnet, long dotted dress, apron, smoking
up
but sitting not in a rocking chair
a corn-cob pipe
but in a swivel chair in front of a typewriter, an
ironic image of the hillbilly lady ready to do battle
with the city slickers on their own terms. Or rather
on her terms, as she could use the language as
cuttingly as anyone. Also on the back of the jacket
is

her

recollection of having

had to use

a

gun to get

food from the commissary to feed children of
in
striking miners: "'Well,' I said, I'll see you
they're
I have to feed some children,
ninety days
they have to eat now, and I'll pay you,
starving
don't worry.' He says, 'Aunt Molly Jackson, don t
I
you offer to walk out with them groceries.'
reached under my arm and I pulled my pistol and I
walked out backwards and said, 'Martin, if you
God knows
try to take this grub away from me,
1

that if they electrocute me for it tomorrow, I'll
shoot you six times in a minute." Strong stuff, this,

and its end-jus tifies-the-means attitude poses some
serious moral questions. But the story, as well as
the best of Aunt Molly's songs, came out of a
more
period of incredibly bitter strife. And, as one
sentence from the jacket informs us, "over 70,000
men were killed in the coal mines of Kentucky
the
during Aunt Molly's adulthood." (I'll miss
footgraphic and informational power of the
square LP jackets when they're all replaced by
those little oblong plastic boxes.)
Also provocative is Aunt Molly's "Holiness
Church Monologue" where she states that some
services were more orgies than religious meetings,
but it is clear that her bitterness comes from a
sermon about her praying in jail couldn't the
preacher tell those were not tears of religious
emotion but of rage against the mine operators
who had her framed as a "dangerous element"
when she was trying to get the miners to "stand
together to get a decent wage to keep their children

from Qfarvina?*'

Aunt Molly Jackson's protest songs are the heart
and soul of this album. They are sung unaccompanied,
in the rubato tight-throated intense style of the
Kentucky mountains. (I find her voice thrilling,
much better suited to the irony and anger of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

protest then the smoother voices that gave us the
topical songs of the 1 960s But her voice belongs to
When Alan Lomax played her
a rural sensibility.
singing over the radio in the 1940s, he reported
that kids from Brooklyn said she sounded like a cat
yowling, while their counterparts in Oklahoma
said it was the most beautiful music they had heard
on the radio!) Most often the songs here are
reworkings of older models, as is the first cut
"Hard Times in Coleman's Mines" which uses the
"Hard Times in
Jail" format as a vehicle for a
song that Aunt Molly actually sang outside the
mines of Bell County to urge the miners to come
out on strike. "I Love Coal Miners, I Do is set to
the "New River T rain" structure and was composed
on her first trip North, when she was singing to
solicit contributions to the miners' cause; it is part
homesick lament, part abbreviated life history to
introduce her to her new public: "Christmas Eve
on the East Side" is

a

bitter comment on living in

a
New York without "gas or electric to make
cup of tea," and complaining that "starvation and
misery is all that is free for poor struggling masses
like you and like me." While self-pity and left-wing
rhetoric do not entirely rob this song of its impact,
Aunt Molly's strongest songs come from her
Kentucky experiences. "Fare Thee Well Old Ely

it is based on the Civil
Branch" is one of her best
War song "Fare You Well, My Darling" and
perhaps also "Old Joe Clark" (suggesting that those
and is sung with
two folk songs are related)

masterful phrasing and intensity fitting to the
sardonic words "I'd rather be in Pineville jail with
Than to be in old
my back all covered with lice
Hughes's coal mines digging coal at Hughes's
price." "Join the C.I.O." "I Am a Union Woman")

or
set to the tune of "Lay the Lily Low
"Jackard," the same melody that Florence Reese
used for her great song of the Kentucky labor
struggles, "Which Side Are Y ou On?" Aunt Molly's
song underscores her repeated assertion that her
radicalization came not from outside influences
but from her own experiences.
The booklet of notes to this LP contains excerpts
from John Greenway's 1953 book American Folk
songs of Protest as well as comments by the editors
is

life, especially her conflicts and
personality changes after she had to leave her home
for the North. Texts for the songs are given, but not
for the spoken narratives; this would have been
useful, as well as notes on the songs, their traditional
models, and the circumstances of their composition.
Listeners are referred to the Library of Congress
issues for half a dozen traditional songs sung by
Aunt Molly Jackson. As she recorded several
hundred songs for the Library of Congress, we can
hope that Rounder one day is able to do so as they
album
say they hope to here, and release another
presenting other aspects of her repertoire. (Folk
ways 5457 The Songs and Stories of Aunt Moll
Jackson presents Aunt Molly telling her stories, but
on Aunt Molly's

y

the songs

are

sung

by

John

Greenway.) But

certainly concur that this kind of collection was
first priority, presenting the searing protest songs
of a great American voice. (Art Rosenbaum)

I

a

�families and communities. All shaped their music

to its mature form during the decade of the 1940s.
And all three had a poet's gift to apply the
techniques and emotion of hymn singing to secular

music, revealing to us the bitter, hard-times feelings
that underlie the often banal or sentimental lyrics
of the non-traditional material they performed.
Like Emily Dickinson, they liked a look of agony
because they knew it was true.
In contrast to Williams' meteoric rise and fall,
and to Monroe's honored longevity, Molly O'Day's
career was both modest and brief, spanning scarcely

more than

a decade.
She became a professional
1939, spent the war years scuffling
between radio stations throughout the rural South,
and recorded 36 sides for Columbia between 1946
and 1951. By 1950 she had begun turning away
from show business toward a life devoted to her
church, and, stricken by tuberculosis, she retired
in 1952. She was just 29.
To consider Molly O'Day's career is inevitably
to raise the specter of gender roles in professional
country music. In some ways, her career seems like
a restless
search to establish a female image that
would permit country audiences to accept her
music. At 16, La Verne Williamson began her
career as "Mountain Fern," a rustic comedienne in
hairbow, polka dots and high-topped shoes. By
1941 she had metamorphosed into the glamorous
"Dixie Lee," clad in fringed leather skirt, western
shirt, and cowboy boots and hat. By the mid- 1 940s
La Verne had chosen her final nom de plume of
Molly O'Day, and performed in crinolines and
ruffled gingham with a Hedy Lamarr gardenia in

singer

in

her hair.

One imagines with difficulty how she would
continued her music into the 1950s and
1960s. Could she have fronted her own band like
Bill Monroe and entered the competitive bluegrass
and park show circuit? Many of her Columbia
sides, such as "Traveling the Highway Home" (Co
20890), prove she had the moxie to dominate a
crack hillbilly band at full throttle, but the bluegrass scene of the '50s and '60s, with its comic drag
interludes and boob jokes, was hardly hospitable
to women. On the other hand, had she followed
Hank Williams to Nashville and a glitzy career on
the Opry she would most likely have been forced
have

into

a

Patsy Cline mold

a

honky-tonk chantoosie

torching out the hurtin' songs. Neither choice
seems satisfying; no alternative seems imaginable.
The Soul of Molly O'Day is in fact a field
recorded in Molly's home
recording done in 96
in Chesapeake,
Ohio, with Molly on banjo and
lead vocal, accompanied on guitar and vocal
harmony by her husband Lynn Davis. These
1

1

recordings first appeared on a Rem LP, subsequently
reissued in the 1960s on the Starday and Pine
Mountain labels. Something of a "last sessions" for
Molly, these sides sound relaxed and comfortable,
a loving husband and wife singing old-time gospel
songs together in their living room, not too
different from stuff Charles Faurot and Mike
Seeger were collecting and issuing on County and
Folkways in those years.
Only 38-years-old, Molly had by this time
undergone lung surgery for her tuberculosis, and
some of the power and urgency was understandably
gone from her singing. Yet her voice was still solid
and moving, and we are treated to more of her
galloping Kentucky banjo here than we are

to hearing on her Columbia 78s.
"Coming Down From God," "Traveling the High
way Home," and "When the Angels Rolled the
Stone Away," especially, rekindle the old pentecostal fires that once raged just below the surface of
the Columbia 78s, and Molly's solo on "I'll Face
Nobody's Record But Mine" provides as moving a
last testament as we could want from this great and
unjustly neglected singer. This record will nicely

accustomed

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

supplement Old Homestead's 1975 reissue album

of many of Molly's Columbia masterpieces (A
Sacred Collection: Molly O'Day With the Cumberland
Mountain Folks, Old Homestead OHCS-101). The
"Volume One" implies a forthcoming Volume
Two which will presumably reissue Molly's final
home-recorded sessions of 967-68, once available
on a local Cincinnati label but long since out of
print. With Molly's recorded legacy so scantily out
of proportion to her stature in old-time music,
every O'Day disc is of course a precious document.
Molly O'Day died of cancer in 1987, neglected
but by no means forgotten. Many who attended
1

last summer's Zimmerman, Minnesota, bluegrass
festival felt the weekend's high point was Laurie
Lewis's solo at the women's music workshop of
Molly's old hit, "Teardrops Falling in the Snow."
Laurie introduced the song as a tribute to Molly
and proceeded to perform it stunningly, seemingly
inspired by the moment, by the good talk of
women's contributions to country music, by some
memories and feelings the song evoked for her as
woman and performer. At song's end, Laurie was
in tears, as were many in the audience. As we say,
by no means forgotten. (Jon and Marcia Pankake)

�PEACH BOTTOM RECORDS

&amp;

CHASE MUSIC GROUP

PROUDLY PRESENT
THE LATEST ALBUM FROM THE WORLD RENOWNED

IRON MOUNTAIN
STRING RAND
"SONGS OF OLD TIME AMERICA"
FEATURING SUCH
CLASSIC OLD TIME
SONGS AS:

'JOHN HENRY

THE DEVILS
CURSED WIFE
WHITEHOUSE BLUES

DIXIE

TO ORDER RECORDS OR

CASSETTES

SEND $9.00 PLUS $2.00 (POSTAGE

&amp;

HANDLING). CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS
ADD 6.5% SALES TAX.
TO:

PEACH BOTTOM RECORDS
C/O CHASE MUSIC GROUP
RO. BOX

11178

GLENDALE, CA 91206

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�tunes didn't appeal to me. Whether it's from a
violin orchestra or from a synthesizer, violin-styled
music just doesn't blend well with any form of
traditional country music.
West Virginia native David Morris is certainly a
talented autoharpist, and this cassette will appeal
to autoharp fans, and also to people who enjoy
music that is relaxing and peaceful. If you get a
chance to see David Morris in person, request him
to sing some of those old Stanley Brothers songs.
(Dale Morris)
To order: KidTown

Ivydale, WV 25113.

DAVID
MORRIS

AUTOHARPIST
KidTown
Traditional 2FR-88
David

Buddy Griffin-fiddle,
Morris-autoharp
guitar, mandolin; Sadie Faircloth-synthesizer

bass,

97 /Little Rosewood
the
Mockingbird/Where
River Shannon Flows/Home Sweet Home/Mary

Old Kentucky

Casket/Listen

Home/Old

to

of the W ild Moor
I

the

/Blues/ Over the W aves/J

ust As

Am

The first time I saw David Morris was in 1 97 5 at
the old Carter Family store in Hiltons, Virginia.
The Red Clay Ramblers were playing, and during
intermission Morris sang a couple of songs with his
guitar as backup. His stirring rendition of a Carter
Stanley song literally brought goose bumps to this

listener.

This cassette of 10 instrumentals offers a different
view of Morris' talents. He is an accomplished
autoharp player. He is creative, and he gets a lot out
of an autoharp, utilizing all of the instrument.
Almost all selections are traditional ones and slow

paced in tempo. I thought "Just As I Am," "Over
the Waves," and "Old Kentucky Home" were the
top tunes. This is a well-recorded and well-played
collection of music. The backup musicians do an
admirable job with some very nice mandolin
playing by Buddy Griffin.
On the negative side, there are only 10 numbers
presented, and the use of a synthesizer on some

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Traditional,

Box 77, Rt. 16,

�what to do with 'Fine Times at Our
tune which inconveniently crosses octaves
and puts impossible notes in impossible places.
Mullenex has turned the tune into a banjo show
piece, placing all the melody on the high strings,

wondered

House,'

a

and amazingly managing to play all the notes by
virtue of a lot of thumb and some quick lefthand
work. However, 1 find myself listening more to the

maneuvers than to the music, and instead of
hearing a whole tune, I hear a percussive sound of
closed strings, and the bumpy sounds of so many
hammer-ons and pull-offs. miss the ringing, open
strings that are such a distinctive feature of the
banjo. These distractions occur in varying degrees
on some of the other tunes as well: 'Falls of
Richmond' 'Big Scioto,' 'Lost Indian.'
On other pieces, the melodic technique is blended
well into the whole tune. "Roses in the Morning," a
Clyde Davenport tune, is particularly beautiful.
There is a pleasant contrast between melodic
sections and non-melodic sections, and because
the tune is generally not as complicated as 'Fine
it
Times at Our House,' the prestidigitations
requires are not as distracting. "Calloway" is also
beautiful, a slow and moody banjo piece in which
precise playing combines with open strings for
some lovely effects.
Mullenex also plays some fiddle and some
mandolin. On "Cumberland Gap" he dubs the
fiddle and banjo together to get a sawing, hurdygurdy sort of sound. "Silver Lake," from Mose
Coffman, offers some fine old-time mandolin
playing: the tune has a slightly midwestem sound,
both sturdy and delicate, and Mullenex handles
triplets and other ornaments without letting them
disturb the tune's steady stride.
Despite the temptations of tape and electronics.
the
Mullenex avoids too much overdubbing
back-up guitar work is very capably done by Tom
King. This tape keeps to a solo and duet sound,
which is well-recorded, so that the sound of each
instrument is rich and full.
Given the space available on the cassette insert,
this tape includes quite a bit of information about
the sources of the tunes. Still, a few more notes
would have been helpful. I would have liked to
know more about the banjo tunings used, and
about George Landers, the source given for "Rolling
1

Mills.'

This tape offers some very good music, and
Mullenex is to be commended for drawing such a
variety successfully together, and for playing so
well (Molly Tenenbaum)
order: Bluestone Productions,
299A, Bluefield, VA 24605

To

Rt.

2,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Box

�While some argue that the look of
Appalachian clogging is bound to change

to Great Britain, others
it returns
work hard to capture the American oldtime look and feel.
In the British Isles, dance appears to
play an inferior role. It is often found last
on the bill at festivals, and there are
usually limited funds available for dance
performances. Many dance groups per
form for free and at festivals often seem
as

be worked harder than musicians,
although most dancers appear to take it
in stride and give their all. Summer folk
festivals are the most popular performing
venues for traditional or folk dance

to

groups, or "sides," and often present
such dances as the Morris, Garland,
English Clog, Long Sword, or Raper
Sword.The Sidmouth Folk Festival, Broadstairs Folk Week, and the fairly new
Harrow Festival have more emphasis on
dance than most other festivals. However,
the Tylde Festival in Lancashire does
feature a regular English clog dance
contest. Appalachian-style clogging has
recently created a great amount of interest

enthusiasm,

and

performances

and

are

workshops

well

and

attended.

American-style square dances

are

also

and can often

in

increasing
popularity,
be found at festivals along with barn
dances, ceilidhs, dancer's dances (for the
more experienced dancer), as well as the
highly popular "late-night extra!" Most
of these dances consist of circles, squares,
longway sets, and polkas. These are done
to the music of a traditional-style dance

band, which invariably features a melodeon and a variety of other instruments,
often including saxophones, keyboards,
fiddles, guitars, and bass. A recent
addition to the scene are bands that are
markedly louder and have more of a
rock/funk factor. Although the sedate

country dancing still
bands like King Edward the II,
Moth, the Oyster Band, or Gas
V seem to be making their mark in
of new-wave dance bands.

and genteel English

exists,
Tiger

Mark
an era

In

October

of

1988 the Horseflies

went to the British Isles for a whirlwind
tour. Although the band played in various
rock clubs, they also reached some folk
audiences. Despite their recent addition
of percussion

and

synthesizer,

"folk"

audiences seemed to appreciate The Horse
flies' talents and were even moved to
leave their chairs and head for the dance
floor, unable to remain quietly seated.
Jim Courza is a performer from Amer
ica who currently makes his home in the

United Kingdom. Many of his songs and
tunes come from the Appalachians, and
played on the hammered dulcimer, can
be heard at many folk clubs and festivals
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

throughout

the

country.

Sara

Gray,

another American artist making her home
in

the United

Kingdom performs fre

quently and receives widespread recog
nition for her talents. The success of
these performers in addition to the excite
ment created by a visiting Appalachian
clogging group proves that there is a
strong interest and support for this style
of American music and dance.
So, whether you're interested in re
searching roots, or observing the current

British interest in American old-time
music and Appalachian-style clogging,
or even in performing yourself, if you
make the trek to the British Isles, you'll
be on fertile ground.
For more information there are two
good sources: write for the Folk Directory
put out by the English Folk Song and
Dance Society, Cecil Sharp House, 2
Regent's Park Rd., London NW1 7 AY;
and Festival Guide, Folk Festival Guide
'89, 8 Donaldson Rd., Shooters Hill,
London SE 183JY. Send for U.S. prices.*

�FIDDLE &amp; DANCE
at Ashokan!
This summer Fiddle &amp; Dance returns to
Ashokan, a secluded camp in New York's
Catskill Mountains. Come join us for classes
and workshops in music or dancing plus

plenty of jamming, dancing, delicious food,

swimming and canoeing.
CLOGGING
CALLING

CONTRAS

SQUARES

STEP DANCE

SET DANCE

SWING JITTERBUG
COUPLE DANCES
TWO-STEP FIDDLE BANJO GUITAR

MANDOLIN

ACCORDIAN

PIPES

STORYTELLING
SINGING
BAND CLASSES
AND MORE

PIANO

SOUTHERN WEEK
July 29

Aug

5

Old Time, Appalachian &amp; Cajun
Dewey Balfa, Ralph Blizard, Paul Brown,
Ginny Hawker, Gordy Hinners, Phil Jamison,
John Krumm, John Lily, Sharon Leahy,
Millie Ortego, Tracy Schwarz &amp; more.

CELTIC WEEK
August 5 II

Irish, Scottish

&amp;

Cape Breton

Harvey Beaton, Tony Cuffe, James Kelly,
Carl MacKenzie, John McGann, Hamish Moore,
Chris Norman, Joe &amp; Siobhan O'Donovan,
John Whelan, Barbara MacDonald
Magone, George Marshall, Laura Scott &amp; more.

Ed Pearlman,

WESTERN

&amp;

Aug

SWING WEEK
18

12

Swing, Country

&amp;

Western

Iliro Arita, Junior Daugherty, Dixie Doughboys,
Matt Glaser, John Krumm, Molly Mason,
George Marshall, John McGann, Pam McKeever,
Kathleen Myers, Ann Percival, Jay Ungar &amp; more.

TEACHERS PLAYSHOP
August 22 25
Music, dance, songs, games, storytelling,
rhythm, movement and building self-esteem.
For teachers, parents, performers, day care
workers, librarians and all who love to work
Peter and Mary Alice Amidon,
with children.
Mary Cay Brass, Leslie Elias, John Krumm,
David Levine &amp; Sam Moffat.

NORTHERN WEEK
Aug 26

Sept

1

New England, French Canadian &amp; Swedish
Peter Barnes, Pierre Chartrand, Nick Hawes,
David Kaynor, Stephane Landry, Mary Lea,
George Marshall, Molly Mason, Bob McQuQlen,
Lisa Omstein, Leif Stinnerbon, Jay Ungar,

Wild Asparagus

and more.

Call or Write for complete brochure:

FIDDLE

&amp;

DANCE

RD 1, Box 489,
West Hurley, NY 12491

914-338-2996

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�FESTIVALS!

CONVENTIONS!
are
Just Around
Advertise

The Corner!
Your Event
In The

OLD-TIME HERALD
Reasonable

Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717

for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�X0

L3
V2
#3

Etta Baker
Gardener,
Herbalist,
Mother of 9,
Blues Guitarist
Extraordinaire...

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12185">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 2, Number 3 (Spring 1990)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12186">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12187">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 2, Number 3 (February-April 1990)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“In the British Isles,” by Joan Kaminkow&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“One Dime Blues – An Interview with Etta Baker,” by Lesley Williams&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“In Praise of Banjo Picking Women,” by Mike Seeger&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘Music is About Feelings’ An Interview with Tommy Hunter,” by Hilary Dirlam&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Oscar Roberson - “Lean Mean Clogging Machine,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop,” Paul Brown&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – Confessions of a Folklorist,” by Joe WIlson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12188">
                <text>1990</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="2159">
        <name>1990</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="999">
        <name>1990s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5561">
        <name>Etta Baker</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5476">
        <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5560">
        <name>Joan Kaminkow</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5566">
        <name>Joe Wilson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5562">
        <name>Lesley Williams</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5563">
        <name>Mike Seeger</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5565">
        <name>Oscar Roberson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5415">
        <name>Paul Brown</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5474">
        <name>Phil Jamison</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5564">
        <name>Tommy Hunter</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
  <item itemId="2523" public="1" featured="0">
    <fileContainer>
      <file fileId="3449">
        <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/dc8f069a0484dc78652e13d19ec29e51.pdf</src>
        <authentication>6a52fd39dfcd00c7296de51a9feffcbb</authentication>
        <elementSetContainer>
          <elementSet elementSetId="4">
            <name>PDF Text</name>
            <description/>
            <elementContainer>
              <element elementId="92">
                <name>Text</name>
                <description/>
                <elementTextContainer>
                  <elementText elementTextId="12189">
                    <text>Summer $4.50

May- July 1990

THE

OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Fiddlin'
Arthur Smith

Sen
Remembers
A

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Concerts

Camping

Contests
Dancing

The Appalachian
String Band
Music Festival

August 3-4-5, 1990
Camp Washington-Carver
Clifftop, West Virginia
featuring

Critton Hollow
Paw Paw, WV

Fiddle Puppets
Davidsonville, MD

The Red Hots
Winston-Salem, NC

Spring Gap Hellbenders
Lexington, V A

Tunesmith
New York City

Ebenezer String Band
Wallace, WV

Bing Brothers
Harmony, WV

Sponsored by the West Virginia Division

The Festival will sponsor three "traditional"

contests-old-time banjo, fiddle, and string band-

Traditional

plus one "nontraditional" string band contest. In
the traditional old time categories, highest scores
will go to traditional old time tunes played in a

Contest Registration
Bands and individuals who pre-register by July
1990 will be guaranteed an opportunity to

participate
To

in the

register

contests.

On an index card, write the

contestant's name, address, and contest category.
Use a separate card for each entry. Mail to
Contests, Appalachian String Band Music
Festival, Camp Washington-Carver,
Route 1, Box 5, Clifftop, WV 25831. You
will receive a confirmation, along with a schedule
of events, from the Festival office.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Band

1st

2nd

3rd

4th

5th

$750

$500

$300

$200

$100

$500

$300

$200

$500

$250

$175

$125

$75

$500

$250

$175

$125

$75

Saturday, Sunday

Nontraditional Band
Saturday

traditional old time style; in the nontraditional
category, bands are encouraged to apply
traditional string band instrumentation in a
creative manner to alternative tunes, techniques,
and influences. Bands may not enter both.

1,

Culture and History

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

I

of

Fiddle
Friday, Saturday

Ban)°
Saturday

How To Get There

1

Camp Washington-Carver is located adjacent
Babcock State Park, just off scenic Route 60 (the
Midland Trail) in Clifftop, WV, 52 miles from
Charleston and 48 miles from White Sulphur

1
to

you are traveling from the east, use the
Sam Black Church exit off 1-64.
Springs.

If

Free Concerts
Rough camping: $10/person
Parking: $2/car
Good food and showers available
For more

information: (304) 438-6429

�The OLD-TIME HERALD
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
1812 House Ave.

Durham, NC 27707

Editor
Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Hilary Dirlam
Phil Jamison
Bill Hicks

Advisory Board
Leftwich, Linda Higginbotham,
W.K. McNeil, MacBenford, Pete Suther
land, Ray Alden, Hazel Dickens, Pete
Kuykendall, John Hartford, Ramona
Jones, Charles Wolfe, Bobby Fulcher,
Brad

Garrison Keillor.

Advertising
Dale Morris, Amy Jones

Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
Board of Directors

Alice Gerrard, Margaret Martin, Bobby
Patterson, Kathy World, Jack Bernhardt,
Art Menius.
No part of this magazine may be repro

in any form without written per
mission from the publisher. Not respon
sible for loss or non-return of unsolicited
photos or manuscripts.
1987 The Old-Time Herald

duced

The Old-Time Herald (ISSN 1040358)

(USPS 002672) is published quarterly
the first of August, November, Febru
ary, and May by the Old-Time Music
Group, Inc. 1812 House Ave., Durham,
NC 27707. Subscription rates payable
in advance. One year
$15.00 (foreign
$18.00 U.S.). Classified
subscriptions
ads cost .50 cents per word, minimum of

$7.00.

Any

grouping of letters

or

numbers is counted as one word. All
classified ads must be received by the
first of the month, one month prior to
publication. Second Class postage paid
at Durham, NC 27701.

POSTMASTER: Send change of address

the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box
51812, Durham, NC 27717.

to

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.

is

a

not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation
under section 501(c) (3) of the Internal

Revenue Code.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�FROM
THE
EDITOR
now you have probably received
Old-Time Music Group, Inc. fundraising
letter. The OTMG, Inc. is the nonprofit, tax-exempt organization which
publishes th eOld-T ime Herald. The goals
By

the

of the

OTMG

To

are:

publish

articles

that

present

traditional American music and culture
from both historical and contemporary
perspectives;

To shape and give voice to the state

of the art through reviews;
To serve as a forum for issues that
concern both the status and form of oldtime music now and in the future;

To help

and serve as

interests

a

establish a network base
national focus for diverse
the

in

traditional

music

community.

the coming year the
will be looking into other
sources of funding but meanwhile we
hope that you will read the letter care

Throughout

OTMG

fully and respond as generously as you
can. As we stated in the letter, we need
funds for hard and software, a part-time

staff person, and for postage and printing
in connection with a major subscription
drive. Thanks for your support.

REGARDING

MAILING

AND

BACK ISSUES: It is important that you
send changes of address as far in advance

of

move

your

as

possible.

do not get forwarded. They
destroyed by the post office and

Magazines
are

returned to us along with notification of
address change. We can send you another
but there will be a delay. NEW SUB
SCRIBERS please allow 4-6 weeks for
delivery of your first issue.
At this time all back issues are avail
able. They cost $6.00 each including
postage and handling. Foreign (surface)
cost $7.00 each. Back issues at this time
are: vol.

1,

nos. 1-8; vol. 2, nos. 1-3.

AD RATES TO GO
recent meeting of the OldTime Music Group, Inc. the board of
directors voted to lower the classified ad
rates for the Old-Time Herald. New rates
go into effect as of the fall (AugustOctober) 1990 issue. The new rates will
be .35 cents per word, $5 minimum.
CLASSIFIED

DOWN.

At

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Southpaw Heard from:
Enjoyed the article on D wight Lamb
the [winter] OTH, but was amazed to
find no mention of the fact that he plays
left-handed (obvious from the photo on
p. 12). I know of a couple of fiddlers
(Claudio Buchwald, Joe Fallon) who
in

have had bass bar/sound post transplants
to accommodate their southpaw bowing;
others of us (yours truly included) just
play

conventionally

and "pass"

as

right-

handers; but Mr. Lamb appears to be
rare

bird

indeed

a

looks like he's
on a conventional
it

bowing backwards
right-handed fiddle! I'd sure like to hear
more about this unique facet of his
playing as well as of other southpaw
fiddlers.

Jim Rosenstock
OXOD Hill MD

[Thanks for pointing this out, and
to

address

Lamb.

question

your

He says

that

we

in order

called

Mr.

"naturally lefthanded," and learned to play on a standard
fiddle, strung up in standard fashion that
he plays "over the bass, backwards." If you
he

is

fiddler and you try this,
completely uncoordinated. Mr. Lamb
points out, however, that if you learn that
way to start out and you are naturally lefthanded the process works the same way as it
does for the right-handed fiddler. He said
are a right-handed

you feel

that he knows many good left-handed fiddlers
and only knows one or two who re-string
their

fiddles.]

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here

In the winter '89-'90 OTH we printed
the fiddle tablature to Ramona Jones'
"Valley Forge." We neglected to inform

readers as to where they could hear the
tune. Ramona informs us that her tape
Backporch Fiddlin' can be purchased for

$9.00 including postage from: Ramona
Jones, PO Box 199, Ridgetop, TN 37152.
We mistakenly printed

in

the winter

'89-'90 OTH that Historical and
Biograph Records are out of business

Arnold Caplin, presi
dent of Biograph Records, Inc., writes us
that "Biograph &amp;. Historical Records has
been in business for the past 25 years and
is still going strong. In addition to LPs
and cassettes we have been producing
compact discs dealing with traditional
and out of print.

blues, and classical music.
OTH apologizes for the error.

jazz,

."

The

7/13-7/15 Brandywine
Convention is actually

Mt.
held
about four miles south of the MasonDixon line in Fair Hill, Maryland. Thanks
The

Music

There

&amp;.

Additions &amp; Corrections

Uncle Dave Macon
Historical Marker Stolen
Charles Wolfe, author
historian has informed

made my summer.

It

1

Graham LP but to no

avail.

Fran and Skip Landt write from
Chicago: "Some of us have plans for an
lunchtime,

old-time

downtown Chicago

maybe

outdoor,
month,

starting

pending

in

or

May

in

jam

once

June

a

(de

at the Old Town
School of Folk Music has taken the lead
on this, and already has enthusiastic
folks from the School and from the
Chicago Barndance Company. Anyone
else, especially fiddle players, would be
most welcome. The location will depend
upon where people work and the jam
a

student

our

of course, be tunes rather than
songs." By the way, belated congratu
lations to Fran and Skip. Their daughter,

some maps."

the beat."

Sue Stude Lundy for calling this to
attention. She adds that "Fair Hill
doesn't have a post office and isn't on

to

This

Congratulations

Brand N ew Old Time Fiddle T unes,
the recording of original compositions
by the old-time Canadian-style fiddler

Joe Pancerzewski [reviewed in the
spring '89 OTH] was selected for in
clusion in the Library of Congress
American Folklife Center publication
American Folk Music &amp; Folklore Record
ings ig 88: A Selected List.

The Bill Sky Family recently received
notification that their cassette album
Let's Have An Old Time Revival (Hearth
&lt;Sc

Home #HH1101) has been placed

in

the permanent collection of the Library
of Congress in Washington, D.C. Since
March, 1989, the Bill Sky Family has
recorded for Heritage Records, of Galax,

Virginia.

Happenings

Bill Whelan writes from Dublin,
Ireland; "We had the Fiddle Puppets
they worked very hard
[over here]

and were very welcome. Kenny Hall
and his band were over again. I love to
hear Kenny. But the best old-time music

I

ever heard

will,

Ginny Alice Landt

was

a

surprise visit from

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

past

Clawhammers

is

"already moving to

the

spring
had

a

3

day

Chicago

intensive

workshop with Dwight Diller. You
old-time banjo players who are headed
Chicago way, contact the Landts c/ o the
Old Town School of Folk Music, 909
W. Armitage, Chicago, IL 60614, if you
want to try and set up a banjo workshop
gig-

exciting new radio series,
"Southern Songbirds: The Women
of Early Country Music" is finished
An

soon all across the
country. "Southern Songbirds" is in 13
parts, each focusing on the female
pioneers of country and old-time music.
Some of the artists profiled include
Wilma Lee Cooper, The Carter
Family, Matokie Slaughter, Ola Belle
Reed, Ramona Jones, and many more.
The producer of this the series is Rachel
she can be contacted
Goodman
through Appalshop, Inc., 306 Madison
St., Whitesburg, KY 41858 or call 606633-0108 for more information. Be sure
and

will

be

honoring famous old-time banjoist, song
ster, and entertainer Uncle Dave
Macon. The only state historical marker
in Tennessee devoted to a musician, it
was located near Kittrell, Tenn. in front
of the Coleman Cemetery where Uncle

Dave was buried. Inset into his tomb
stone was a photo of Uncle Dave which
was also taken. Dr. Wolfe is spearhead
ing a fund raising campaign to raise the
necessary $1025.00 needed to erect
another marker. All contributions to
this fund should be made out to the non
profit Tennessee Folklore Society and
mailed to: Tennessee Folklore Society,
c/o Dr. Charles Wolfe, Box 201

MTSU, Murfreesboro, TN 37132.

weather). Jan

the

upon

Wishinsky,

apparent

has resulted in the dis
appearance of the state historical marker

Jody Stecher and
a
Scottish fiddler Alasdair Fraser
a couple of
been
over
has
Jody
great gig.
times before and is always an inspiration.
have done just about everything possible
to get the Mark

music

vandalism

Bruce Molsky and his brilliant band,
Ricky, Mary Ann, and Audrey. That's
the kind of fiddlin' I've been preaching
for years over here.
Last night we had

and

us that

aired

Music Contest Brochure
The Folk Arts Program

of

the

Tennessee Arts Commission

announces the availability of a new folk
music publication- Fiddle and Old-Time
Music

Contests

in

Tennessee

is

an

in

formational brochure about the annual
events throughout the state where com
petitions are held in traditional country
music and dance. It was funded by a
grant from the Folk Arts Program of the

National Endowment for the Arts.

Fiddle and Old-Time Music Contests in
Tennessee provides an introduction to
T ennessee's tradition of stringband music
contests and a directory of information
about the 27 contests currently held in
the state. One section of the publication

explains how contests are organized
conducted. Another section deals
the history and tradition of fiddle
tests, which gained wide popularity

and

with

con
after

the Civil War and have in recent decades
embraced elements of more modern
country music styles alongside the "oldtime" sounds that preceded them. A
fold-out directory on the inside maps the
locations of current contests and gives
details on customary annual dates,
specific contest categories, prize money,

and call or write your local public radio

and contacts for further information.
Illustrations include rate historic graphics
and photos.
The publication is free, and can be
obtained upon request from the Folk
Arts Program, Tennessee Arts Com
mission, 320 Sixth Ave. No., Suite 100,

station and ask them to
Songbirds."

615/741-1701.

air

"Southern

Nashville,

TN

37243-0780,

phone

�There
in the

Digest.

is an

interview with Jim Watson

current

former

issue of The M andocrucian's

As many

member

of you know, Jim

is

a

of the Red Clay
now touring with

Ramblers. He is
Robin and Linda Williams

and

per

forming as one-half of the Durhambased duo, Pinky Wyoming and Duke

LaCrosse.

The following photo was sent to us by
Loyal Jones, director of the Appalachian
Center at Berea College in Kentucky. He
wrote: "The enclosed picture was sent to
me by Chester A. Nolan, who grew up
in Harlan County, Kentucky, and who
now lives in Madison Indiana. It is a
picture of fiddlers who came for a

fiddling contest at Berea College in 1917.
The contest was put on by Elijah
Franklin Disney, who went by the
name of Frank, and who was the principal
of the Berea Grade School. Mr. Nolan
who sent the picture is the first person
on the left in the front row. The man
who won the contest was none other
than Fiddling Doc Roberts, from
Madison County, who arrived too late to
have his picture made but who borrowed
Mr.

Nolan's

brand-new

Montgomery

Ward fiddle to win the contest."
Mr. Jones asks if any OTH readers can
identify any of the fiddlers in the photo.

Jones said that according to Nolan the
fiddlers are from Tennessee, Georgia,
Alabama, Virginia, and North Carolina.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Howard Vokes, "Pennsylvania's King
of Country Music" writes that his friend
"Big John" Trimble of Radio WRVA,
Richmond, Va., is looking for "live
taped shows/albums
Dominion Barndance so that
of

the

Old

he can use

them on his all night country shows
seven nights per week from midnight till
4:30 a.m. Anyone who can help him
should contact "Big John" T rimble, Radio
WRVA, Box 1516, Richmond, Va.
23212. Mr. Vokes writes that "John

plays plenty of bluegrass and old-time
artists on his all-night Truckers Country
Music Show. .he tells us that 90% of his
mail [is] for the old style of country
music.

Folk Notes

is

a

"bi-monthly publi

cation of San Diego Folk Heritage, Inc.,

dedicated

non-profit

organization
preserving and promoting the folk arts

California."

Southern

a

to
in

newsprint

In

it contains reviews, articles, and
information about local music and dance
events. Write 1112 Judy La., Cardiff,

format,

CA 92007.

The Music News from the
Chattanooga Area Friends of Folk
Music is a one-page letter sent to
members,

and

includes

local music events

items.

Write

as

well

P.O.

a

calendar of
brief news

as

Box

4527,

Chattanooga, TN 37405.

The Seattle Folklore Society "Flyer"

available to members. The Flyer
contains lots of local music and dance
news, and a calendar and information on
local music and dance events. Write the
Seattle Folklore Society, c/o 6556
is

Newsletters
In the interests of helping to promote
local grassroots events, and for the
benefit of those of you who may be
vacationing or taking trips to other parts
of the country, we like to occasionally
publish the names and addresses of
various local publications you might
want to obtain. These are publications of
not-for-profit organizations.
The Charlotte Folk Music Society
Magazine is available to members.
Published monthly it features profiles of
local and visiting performers, a calendar

music and dance events, and
more. Write to the Charlotte Folk Music
Society, PO Box 9007, Charlotte, NC

of local

28299.

Palatine Ave. North, Seattle, WA98103.
The New Mexico Folk Music &amp;
Dance Society ("Folkmads") publishes
and monthly calendar which
a "Notes"
they send out to members. It includes
information on local music and dance
events. Write to the New Mexico Folk
Music &amp; Dance Society, PO Box 4042 1
Albuquerque NM 87 196. H

�The Dance Beat
VISIT

A
by

Ruth Pershing

One hot Sunday afternoon in the late
spring I headed from my home in Alamance County, North Carolina, past
Raleigh toward Zebulon. I had met Algia

Mae Hinton and worked with her, her
son Willette and their cousin-in-law,
"Junior" Thomas, at various times before,
but I wanted to be with them at their
home, with the whole family. I was
looking for buck dancing and for the
people who do it. I was looking for the
living tradition that is at the root of
Broadway and jazz tap. I was after the
community of family dancing that got
Sandman Sims started and sent Buck and
Bubbles to Hollywood. But I was
searching for the steps and rhythms that
everyone could do, not just the few who
took it to the heights of film and stage.
My directions were vague; I knew I
had to turn left on a dirt road after a

church somewhere past Zebulon. That
could be just about anywhere. I stopped
at the nearest country store, one with

sparkling new pavement and

a

big sign.

knew Miss Algia Mae. It was not
before
1 was
long
driving down a winding,
dusty road to find the described three
mobile homes in a row. There were cars
parked randomly around the middle
trailer; it was obvious where to go.
Walking in the front door 1 was

They

all

confronted

by

a

row of people, young

courtesy

Folklife

Office,

N.C.

Arts

Council

and old and all shapes and sizes, dressed

Algia Mae Hinton, Eno Valley Elementary School,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Durham, N.C. May

5,

1982

in Sunday clothes having just come from
church. They sat shoulder to shoulder
on chairs and couches that lined the
perimeter of the room. They didn't
exactly look ready to jump up and dance.
There was an awkward silence which I
broke with a tentative "Hey everybody,
is this Algia Mae's?" Algie Mae's youngest daughter, Elgia, jumped in with a grin

recognized as her mother's, and proceeded to introduce me to every single
person there, one at a time. She told me
how each fit into the extended family
tree. Knowing that Algia Mae was the
youngest in a family of thirteen children,
that Elgia was the youngest of seven, and
that they almost all had families, too, I
knew I would never keep them all
1

�Some Steps From the Dancing

Abbreviations Used
Note: The following terms are used

in

various combinations

T

(circled) sequence repeats beginning here
(underlined) bears weight
flatlooted step
heel contacts floor and stays there
ball of foot contacts floor and stays there

Tap

ball of foot

beat

lift

hi

St
H

drop

slide
shuffle
f,

b

chug
cl

&lt;

b

contacts floor and

to

produce

the

of

Algia Mae Hinton

Step Notation
necessary step building blocks.

In

lifts up

from floor and let beat back down

from raised position let drop to floor
move in contact with floor

double contact of foot to floor (without weight), usually brushing slightly forward then back
directions: forward, back
a

more familiar term for slide

clap
may be left out for variation

accented beat

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

b

(weight bearing slide back)

�table,

a

few

scattered chairs and

a

lot of

open space. Light came from a single
bulb in each room. The walls were made

pressboard and the ply
wood floor sounded solid but resonant
underfoot.
Some of the young men who were first
of patchwork

to arrive started the balls rolling on the

pool table. The jukebox started rocking
and there were soft drinks all around.
There was no homemade entertainment
yet, but there would be. The singing
started first, with an older sister of Algia
Mae's; it came straight out of the gospel

tradition. The electric guitar and bass
had made it up from the kitchen below
and soon there were three or four voices.
After a few songs no one was holding

back. The harmonies provided an unusual
to the pool game in the
next room.
W illette was getting restless. After the
next song he rolled up the sleeves of his

accompaniment

tailored shirt and started
"slapping." In wing-tipped shoes, his feet
stepped alternately, keeping up a quick
even beat as he clapped lightly with flat
palms in the little space of time between
foot sounds. With this insistent rhythm,
Willette stepped around the room, en
ticing a critical mass of people into a
French

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(brush-step
covering

a

on the ball
lot of distance

of the
and

foot)
pumping

his arms as he moved, either in forward
or reverse. He had also picked up some

steps from a few more unlikely sources.
One he called the "Joe Louis" was just
that, a sort of boxing hop. Another he
called the "Curly Shuffle"
yes, you
guessed it right out of "The Three

Stooees."

One young man known as Shorty,
dressed in a now rumpled white suit with
tie askance, went straight for the wall
when his turn came. It was not to avoid
dancing, though. With nose to the wall,
he put together a few short riffs. While
tapping the board in front of him with
one foot, he slid forward on the other
foot; shsh-thwap came the sound. An
insistent, catchy combination of these
made everyone smile. It drove Willette
right up the wall too, but his variation
was with his back to the wall. He grinned
at the white suited fellow with a friendly
challenge in his glance. They traded off
for a few rounds, then passed the turn on
to the next. A little girl darted into the
circle and received the most encourage
ment of all for her brief twist and few
stamps. This must be how they had all
begun.
Algia Mae was the last to dance. She
raised her head up as though looking at

learned from Beverly Cotten when they
did school programs together.

vocabulary of sounds was exten
used every surface of the
bottoms of her shoes to slide, tap, touch,
Her

sive.

She

scuff, slap, and stamp, changing weight
imperceptibly from foot to foot all the
while. Some patterns were long, some
short. There were teasing silences thrown
in; Algia Mae then caught again, making
it spare to the point of disappearing as
she moved into a slow twist, using hips
a circle, and watching
everyone watching her over her shoulder.
At just the right quiet moment, she let go
a sudden cascade
of syncopation. Then

and all, turning in

continued

on

page 44

Council

a

clearly worn path, across an open field to
a small frame building backed up against
some trees. Other folks drove along the
road and lots of children ran up to the
building, darting around in the field on
the way. The building was plain, with a
small porch across the front and two
doors flanked symmetrically by two
windows. Inside there was simply one
long narrow room on each side. The
right-hand room had a pool table as its
centerpiece. There was a bar and a
refrigerator along the back wall. The lefthand room housed a juke box, a metal

Arts

I

a

N.C.

simply "Let's go!"

Wondering where we were headed,
followed Elgia out behind the trailer
few hundred yards up a hill along

Office,

wall-to-wall textured carpet. Her greet

ing was

pattern of keeping time. Even as turns
traded the beat continued on. If no one
took the next turn right away, Willette
or Algia Mae nodded to someone new as
everyone else egged them on.
No two people danced alike. The
more creative and original a step or lick,
the more reaction it drew from the circle,
and it served as a challenge to the next in
the middle. There were similarities be
tween dancers, especially in rhythm or
pattern of syncopation, but each person
had a step repertoire entirely their own,
however small or big it was. It struck me
then
how could a person learn to dance
if not by imitation? This aesthetic seemed
one to transmit in oral tra
a difficult
dition.
Each of the people who danced had a
unique basic pattern they returned to
over and over, a kind of time step,
though shorter in length than most tap
time steps. Willette's was a flatfooted
syncopated rhythm in groups of three
beats. He also did a series of "flaps"

guitar playing of a tune called simply
"Buck Dance." It is quite a show piece,
one she told me she had put together
while courting when she was young. I
could hear the tune in her feet. Every
subtlety of accent and timing was there.
Her feet remained close to the floor and
moved little. T o tell exactly what she was
doing, you would have had to kneel right
down on the ground and watch from just
a few inches away.
She did a couple of steps whose names
I
knew. One step she called "shoveling
coal, like my daddy used to do." I never
did figure out whether her daddy
shoveled coal or taught her that step.
Another step was like one I had seen in
the mountains called "wring the chicken's
neck," done with much twisting in the
ankles. I also recognized the familiar
"buck and wing," and some two-footed
chugs, which Algie Mae said she had

Folklife

and two small children arrived, "Mama"
came in to the living room. Algia Mae let
loose her teasing grin and cut a step or
two, even though she was in bare feet on

continuous

courtesy

ation. Elgia telephoned her brother
Willette, chiding him for not getting
there sooner, and just after he, his wife,

for them, each with their own

Manley,

I

I

Roger

I

near the door. One at a time, each person
in the circle had their turn buck dancing
in the middle, while the others slapped

someone watching from above, waiting
a cue. Her face was in an almost-smile
into the middle, still
as she moved
slapping. She began with a rhythm
knew well, one she used in performance
to her own solo
as an accompaniment
for

by

I

I

Mae her son Willie Earl and his cousin
plugged in an electric guitar and bass in
the adjoining kitchen.
heard the familiar
had heard before,
style
picking
piedmont
this time coming from the next gener

a

loose circle. Thinking would just watch
at first,
found myself sorely mistaken.
Willette gave me no choice. I was drawn
away from my comfortable leaning post

Algia Mae Hinton

photo

straight. They each greeted me and shook
hands, somewhat formally.
I was
hoping to see at least one familiar
face soon, and as we waited for Algia

�BANJOS IN THE DAYS OF COMPACT DISCS
by

Mike Fitch

The 36-year-old cabinet-maker sifts
through some tools on his workbench as
he patiently waits for my final question.
He seems at home here in his large and
slightly cluttered one-room workshop in
Blacksburg, Virginia. He is a somewhat

cherubic-looking man,

a

bit short and

a

stocky, wearing two flannel shirts
over a yellow T-shirt, a pair of jeans, and

bit

brown workboots. He adjusts his faded

red cap, which reads
the front, as my

PEACHTREE across

long-winded query
finally reaches its point: "Did you ever
regret that you didn't settle down to a
nine-to-five kind of job, or take another
direction, or do you think you pretty
much found your calling, making these,
playing when you can?"
I like
to just
"Oh, I don't know.
kinda have it as my extra hobby," says
Mac Traynham. He speaks slowly in a
slight southern drawl, forming his words
with care. "I feel at home in old-time
music. I identify with what old-time
music represents to me, which is rural
mountain culture, the best parts of it, of
the early days. I like to identify with the
ways of rural people that are independent

and self-sufficient. The music helps me
to feel like I'm a part of an ongoing
tradition of holding fast to roots, and to

things that have not been improved
upon in the modern evolution of things."
He smiles fondly, contemplating his long

time hobby of playing and making banjos.
T o someone such as myself who wasn't
raised in Appalachia, and who is not
familiar with banjo music, the banjo is a
strange instrument, perhaps first heard
of in the tune "Oh Susannah," and only
caught in glimpses later in life in comic
strips like "Snuffy Smith," or on Saturday

broadcasts

of "Hee-Haw." Certain
questions would inevitably come to mind.
Why is it half drum and half guitar? Why
does that one string start a little bit
higher up the fretboard than the other
four?
A look

at the history of the banjo
clear
some of the mystery.
helps
Compton's Encyclopedia states that the

to

"African stringed
instrument," and was "brought to
America by the first Negro slaves." Once
in America, according to Funk and
Wagnall's New Encyclopedia (vol. 3,
1983), the banjo appeared in a variety of
banjo originated

as an

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

designs, orginally featuring fretless necks
and four strings with the body sometimes
fashioned from gourds. A fifth shorter

string appeared by 1840

being popularized by
Walker Sweeney, who

as

the banjo was

men

like Joel

credited by
many as being the creator of the modern
version of the instrument. After the
Civil War, large-scale manufacturing of
banjos began, introducing frets to the
fingerboard by 1890. The banjo has now
is

reached a fairly static stage of develop
ment, the most common banjos featuring
five strings, frets, and a circular body
covered with a tight "drumhead." Mac
Traynham has hand-crafted over two
dozen five-string banjos.
Mac

was

born on May 6,

1954,

in

Suffolk, Virginia. His aunt, who is a
geneologist, has determined that he is of
Scots-Irish and French-English descent.
His family on both sides is deeply rooted
in Virginia, possibly from as far back as
the 17th century.

Traynham's first musical influences
appeared early in life. He describes his
father (a Presbyterian minister) as being
a folk
musician, while his mother (a
teacher) had some classical training. His
close proximity to his father's church
and his regular presence at Sunday family
gatherings helped to strengthen his trad
itional values, which ramain intact to
day. For example, he indicates a
great respect for his relatives, especially

this

his maternal grandfather, a hard-working
dairy farmer who he cites as a role
model. His only disagreements with his

grandfather involve the fact that Mac

is

the more conservative of the two: "He's
not as much of an old-timer as I wish he
was," he says with

a

laugh.

During his school years, Traynham
learned to play a variety of instruments:
piccolo, flute, piano, harmonica, and
guitar. By the time he started college he
was primarily playing guitar, and had
started learning banjo. His interest in the
banjo was sparked by seeing it played on

�the Grand Ole Opry TV broadcasts in
the '60s, and later at local bluegrass
conventions. In 1974 Mac visited the

famous Galax Old Fiddlers Convention
for the first time, and was inspired

enough

by

the

to

performances

hire

a

friend to build him a banjo, and began to
take a more serious interest in old-time
and bluegrass music.
Via LP reissues of old 78 recordings,
Traynham became familiar with oldtime music greats such as the Carter
Family, the Delmore Brothers, the Blue
Sky Boys, the Skillet Lickers, Charlie
Poole, Uncle Dave Macon, and Charlie
Monroe. He also listened to Bill
Monroe's Blue Grass Boys, the Stanley
Brothers, and others who defined the
bluegrass style, but as time went on he
concentrated more and more on learning
to

old-time

play

performs
different

music. Today
locally with a number

he

of

musicians. He and his wife,
Jenny, (the Southern Mountain Melody
Makers) recorded an album of duet
singing, When the Roses Bloom in Dixie
land
[Heritage 058, reviewed in the
winter '89 OTH].

Mac has been making his living pri
marily as a woodworker since about
1979. The first instrument he built was a

dulcimer to give

friend

a wedding
friends
who
by
present.
built banjos and guitars, he pursued his
interest in making instruments by visiting
master craftsmen such as the late Kyle
Creed, a Galax, Virginia banjo maker

to

a

as

Later inspired

player; Albert Hash, a Grayson
County, Virginia fiddler and fiddle
maker; and Wayne Henderson, a guitarist
and guitar builder also from Grayson
County. In 1978 Mac was commissioned
and

friend to build his first banjo, and
by
has been making them ever since.
Currently he makes about two banjos a
year. He earns his living making custom
a

cabinets and furniture

in his

Blacksburg

shop.

"That banjo, like 1 say, is made
from scratch, that's the truth."
As

I

set up the tape recorder

in

Mac

Traynham's shop for our second dis
cussion, he points out a song that is
coming from a small radio tuned to
WPAQ740 AM, a station from Mount
Airy, North Carolina. The reception is
scratchy, but he doesn't seem to mind; a
woman is playing on a banjo that he
made for her several years ago. "Now
you can say that you heard one of Mac
Traynham's banjos on the radio," he
says.
He later brings out a banjo that he has
been working on for a long time: one that
isn't for sale. It is only fitting that a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Southern Mountain Melody Makers (Mac

craftsman should

be the one to enjoy his
best work, and this banjo is beautifully
made. The detail is flawless, the sound is
bright and clear, and 1 can't help won

dering, how did he do

it?

Each instrument can take from 30 to

38 working hours to complete,

depend

ing on how intricate it is. After noting
any specific requests from the customer,
his first step in making a banjo is forming
the neck. He begins by using a band saw
to "rough cut" the profile of the neck

from a 36" x 2" x 2.5" block of bird's-eye
maple, walnut, or cherry. Once the side
profile has been sawn, the neck is re
inforced by a steel bar that is embedded
lengthwise in a groove made using a table
saw. Then, the top surface of the neck
where the fretboard and peg head will
eventually be is sanded flat.
The next step is to glue on a peg-head
overlay usually consisting of a thin piece
of ebony or rosewood. He later forms
this part of the banjo in a shape that is a
derivative of traditional styles, with the
pegs pointed straight towards the back of
the instrument. The only major differ
ence between a peg head from the turn of
the century and a Mac Traynham peg
head is that the former featured wooden
friction pegs, while the latter has factory-

produced geared metal pegs.
Once the peg head assembly is at
tached, a long, thin strip of ebony is
carefully measured and slotted for frets
before being glued lengthwise to the
neck to form a durable fretboard. Now

&amp;.

Jenny Traynham)

that various

neck pieces have been put

together, a tedious process of shaping
and finishing begins. He uses a band saw,

draw knife, spoke shave, rasp, file, and

in successive steps in order to
create the desired shape and texture.
One of Traynham's trademarks is a

sandpaper

decorative

groove

which

is

carved

lengthwise along the back of the neck
during this finishing stage.
The neck is then left alone for a while
as the pot (the round wooden hoop that
forms the body of the banjo) is made.
Using a perfectly circular bending iron
used by the late Kyle Creed, Mac forms
the pot gradually by layering thin strips
inside

of one another. This process
involves boiling strips of wood measuring
approximately 38-40" long by 1/8 to
3/16" thick by 2 to 3" wide. The strips
become very flexible, and are thus
wrapped around the circular outside
surface of the heated bending iron. When
dry, the bent strips are cut to fit into a
circular form and glued to each other
layer by layer. Once it has reached a

thickness

of approximately

is

turned until

3/4",

the

perfectly round
and smooth. A decorative wooden "cap"
is then glued to the bottom of the pot.
Once the hoop is formed, 20 or 24
pot

it is

holes are drilled evenly spaced around
the circumference of the pot in order to
accomodate hardware that will pull the
drumhead tight. A metal tension hoop,
to which the metal hooks will attach,
must then be purchased, or made by

�is sanded flat
before glueing on the peghead overlay.

area.

Next, lengths of fret wire are epoxied
into the slots previously cut into the

photo

by

Bill

Price

fingerboard.

is

done with

Once the hardware has been attached
to the pot, and the "drumhead" has been
stretched over a circular tune ring and
secured to the pot, the neck and body of

Traynham
by
photo

photo

The top surface of the peghead

additional

Final shaping of the banjo neck
a wood
file and elbow grease.

Mac

Price

by

Bill

Price
Bill

by
photo

order for the peghead to be wide enough,
wood or "ears" are glued to
either side of the neckpiece in the peghead

In

A band saw is used to cut out the

according
peghead overlay.

shape

to

layout

lines

peghead
on

the

of playing, something's buzzing," he says.
"I'll have to figure out where that is, and
do something to adjust for it." But for
now, the only thing left to do to this

banjo

is

to play it. H

the banjo are carefully assembled. The
final steps in the process involve "setting
up" the strings on the instrument. Mac
uses elkhorn to make both the long nut
at the seam between the peg head and
fretboard, and the small nut for the next
short G-string that starts at the fifth fret
on the neck. After tuning pegs, tailpiece,

a wooden
bridge
approximately the center of
the drumhead, and is adjusted as the

and strings are attached,
is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Price

finishing for himself

Bill

he is

features one that was hand-made by Kyle
Creed.
Returning to the fretboard, the next
step is to make any decorative inlays that
are required. Thin pieces of abalone
clam shell are shaped into designs from
patterns, and are then carefully embedded
into the ebony surface of the fretboard.

is tuned. At last, a banjo is born!
Mac picks up his newly-made banjo.
He has been setting up the strings during
our conversation, and now the instrument
is finished and tuned.
But he doesn't
completely rule out the possibility of a
few future adjustments. "I may play
tonight, and find that at a certain intensity

banjo

by

excellent banjo

at

M ike Fitch

is from Baltimore, Md., and
civil engineering at Virginia
Tech in Blacksburg, V a. He plays guitar
and harmonica as a hobby.
is

a

senior

photo

hand if it is not of the 11" standard
diameter. Mac prefers an unplated brass
tension hoop because it is more trad
itional. It is also hard to find, but the

placed

in

Holes for tuning pegs
by using

a

drill press.

are

drilled precisely

�Bobby McMillon

BLUE RIDGE STORY TELLER

by

Hilary Dirlam

just continued on with it. It didn't die
out. You wouldn't think it in this day
and time, but the Appalachians weren't
really a Bible belt at one time. Now
'
people like to think: W ell, if only it was
like the good old days back when every
body went to church,' but it never was
like that. There were fewer churches

back

then,

and

more

individualistic

thinking people. Lots of our ancestors

photo

by

Michael

Hopson

came here to get away from organized
religion.

L-Marina

Hollar, R-Bobby McMillon, Jan. 1990, Burnsville, N.C., Yancey Nursing Home.

Bobby McMillon, 38 years old, has lived
most of his life in Lenoir, North Carolina, in
the foothills of the Blue Ridge. Coming from
a long line of mountain people well-versed in
the art of making words live (I'm seventh or

eighth generation,"

he

says),

he is

himself

gifted storyteller and ballad singer.
At times working in a furniture factory

a

or

substitute teaching, Bobby has nonetheless
maintained his lifelong vision of bringing
the past to life for others as clearly as the past

H.D.

lives for him

Talking with a born storyteller is a
fascinating experience. A factual state
ment, half-finished, gives way to a
description of a childhood experience,
which free-associates into an anecdote
about a long-dead relative, somehow
gently transforming into a discussion of
regional pronunciations or versions of
ballads. Bobby Macmillon, quiet-spoken
and mild-mannered, filled up lots of tape
for me. But was afraid that what he had
said was too rambling, that we hadn't
1

gotten enough hard information, that
there was too much theorizing, that the
interview had gone in concentric circles
rather than in nice, modern, easily
digestible straight lines. I should have
had more faith. Bobby covered every
so well, in fact, that it
thing nicely
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

seems unnecessary for me to interpose a
lot of my own words into this article. A
storyteller can surely tell his own story.
And if in talking Bobby lets one thought
lead into another organically
well, one
of the greatest storytellers of the 20th
century, James Joyce, became world
famous for doing just that. Perhaps it's
no accident that Bobby sees his Celtic
identity as being one of the most
important aspects of his choice of

avocation.
"There's a theory I believe," says
Bobby, "that southern mountain people
have retained their Celtic heritage. They
have such an independent nature that it's
almost mystical. Two guys might be
fighting and one of 'em see a pretty
woman walk past, and the other would
kill him while he was looking. Celts can
be deterred from their purpose easily
because they're dreamers, but they're
among the fiercest fighters that ever was;
it's born in 'em to fight, just for the sheer
fun of it. If there ain't a good reason for a
fight, they do it just to have a big time.
"When the first priests and monks

were preaching Christianity in northern
Europe the clergy were just about the
only ones that could read and write. The
culture of the common people was al
ready thousands of years old, and they

"My daddy's people were Scots-Irish.
The story goes that five brothers came
over with their mother from Ireland, and
they brought some Irish 'taters with
them. They landed in either Charleston,

or V irginia. At least one
of the brothers settled in North Carolina.
His oldest son was my great-grandfather.
There's not many generations between

South Carolina,

me and Ireland, because my grandfather
was born when his father was 71.1 used
to think that 7 1 was a might old to have a
child without some suspicions to it, but

my aunt has a picture of both of them
together, and there ain't no doubt.
During the whole 19th century there was
only two generations of my family born.

"Well, my great-granddaddy was born
in

North Carolina

in

1829. He had some

brothers that migrated to east Tennessee,
up above Newport. That's wild country
up in there, and that's where a lot of wild
tales was told to me; tales about hunting,
and bear tales. It was almost like a
frontier up until the beginning of this
century, and it's still a strange kind of
law they've got in that part of the world.

people with the Scots-Irish back
became Republicans and the
with
the land became Democrats,
people
so when the War between the States
broke out there was a violent clash.
Dellie Norton still calls it the war between
the Democrats and the Republicans.
"My great-grandfather and my grand

The

ground

father on my daddy's side were preachers
in the Primitive Baptist Church. The oldtimers had a beautiful way of putting

words together. When my grandfather
preached it was like he was making the
story live. If he was telling a story from
the Old Testament, he would begin,

�He
'Well, one time the Old King.
used to tell his children little stories.

I

feel like my grandfather was never com
pletely convinced- that the world was
round; it was a hot topic in the early
1900s. The Bible talks about 'the four
corners of the earth,' and some people
reasoned that if there's four corners, it

couldn't

be

round.

"On my mother's side, my people was
mostly German. They were wonderful
carpenters; some of my ancestors would
amaze present-day carpenters. Back then
they could do things by sight that today's
carpenters have to measure for. There

Thomases on my mother's side, too.
They were Welsh, little short people,
was

jokers and full of meanness

good

meanness, you know. They was kind of

like elves.

"It's

that

mixture

of Celtic

and

Germanic that gives mountain people
their character. Mountain people have a
real high intelligence. I recall a story
about a smart person from outside the
mountains coming in, thinking what
quaint people he's talking to, when in
reality they're laughing at him for some
absurdity he's doing. Mountain people
will lead you to believe they're thinking
one thing when they're really thinking

something else.
"There's something almost like a
psychic grapevine among mountain
people. Some folks might think it's being
nosy, but it ain't that they're being nosy,
they're just sort of concerned about

what's going on. It's hard to keep any
thing secret in the mountains. You could
stump your toe at the foot of the holler,
and there might be a dozen houses all the
way up to the head of the holler, and the
news could be up there before you
would. The stereotype is that women are
big gossipers, but really, everybody
gossips.
"Those older, more conservative areas,
they used to be real clannish, and always
fighting amongst theirselves, usually over
women. That's what most of the feuds
were about. Hardly anytime did anyone
from the outside have trouble or get shot
at in a feud area. If you minded your own

business the people would
you
is

be as

good to

as

gold.
"The first thing I can remember hearing
dogs barking. It had a music all its own.

Almost everybody had hounds, off in
the hollers. Seems like I can still see the
moonlight come up over the ridges, and
down in the hollers, that lonesome
barking.

"Later on I would hear my family tell
about things that had happened to them;
hunting accidents, and things that had
happened to people they knew. I was just

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fascinated, especially

when they would

and tales
about haints, and tales about ghosts and
bear

tell scarey stories;

tales,

witches.
"My father's sister married Ike Hopson
from Green Mountain. He told wonder
ful stories. A boy would come up the
creek to visit a girl, and a bunch of guys
would waylay him, throw rocks at him,
and make noises outside while he was in
there talking to the girl. It was wonderful
to hear about life back then. He made

everything

so clear.

"My daddy's oldest brother married a
Phillips from Cosby, Tennessee. May
knew
Mamaw, we called her
Phillips
scads and scads of songs, and she taught
them all to me as I come up. She was a
base-born child and had two half

brothers. Till she was five she had no
father to speak of. A gypsy woman told
her mother that she was going to marry
an old grey-bearded man who would
come walking over the hill, with a cane.
She told the gypsy, 'Y ou're crazy!' At the

Seems like
see

the

I

can still

moonlight

come up over the
ridges, and down in
the hollers, that lonesome barking.
time she was engaged to
Esau

Mantooth.

He

was

a

man named

supposed

to

meet her on the train, but he got sick,
and there wasn't no way to wire ahead.
She thought that he had done her like the
other man
you know how some men
and found out later that he'd been
are
sick. Somebody she knowed up in Cosby
brought this old man to see her. And he
come walking over the hill, with a cane,
and he had a grey beard. She married
him. His wife had died and he had lots of

children. He was a strange old feller.
He'd been in the War between the
States, and he always used to say them
'go-devils' was biting him. It was pro
bably nerve endings, or shell-shock. He
was real irritable and wouldn't allow a
lot of singing, so she used to get together
with her cousins and they'd go up the
holler and sing to theirselves.
"When she was twelve years old,
things got so bad at home that she went
out as a hired girl, working for other
people for room and board. She learned
lots of songs from the people she lived
with.

"She died in 1980, and part of me has

never got over it yet. I was in closer
contact with her than with anybody, and
learned more ballads from her than from

anyone else.
"My Grandmother McMillon's people
was W illiamsons, and in that family they
were always singing about everything.

My dad's sister Flo can sing, and she used
to play the guitar. My dad doesn't know
many old songs, but he knew some, and

sometimes he would sing them. He knew
'William Hall,' which is a version of
'Pretty Fair Miss.' My grandmother sang
one she called 'Seaport Town' that she

learned from her uncle. There was a
merchant who had two sons and 'a
daughter dear,' and the two sons

murdered the daughter's sweetheart, and

I guess the song is in
Cecil Sharpe's book, if anyone wanted to
get all the words.
"When I was a small child, we knew a
couple that lived a few miles down the
road from here, under Brushy Mountain.
They were Brookshires. The wife, she
was always singing when I was little. By

got killed in the end.

the time I was a teenager, I realized the
songs she had been singing were old
songs and ballads. I learned a lot from
her. Her brother was a bard, you might

who wrote songs about local
happenings, like murders. One of his
say,

songs is in the North Carolina Folklore
Collection [Duke University Press], in
the ballad volume. It's called 'The Blockaders' Trail.'
"As a small child I wasn't that inter
ested in music, but I liked it if it had a
story, I reckon. I remember 'You ain't

Nothin' But

a

Hounddog.'

I

could just

imagine someone calling someone else a
hounddog! I remember someone picking
'Wildwood Flower.' That was one of the
first tunes I liked. I remember Johnny
Cash's 'Ballad of a T eenage Queen.' That
had a good story.
"I never liked singing in school, hardly.
The words and the tune had to go
together for me, and I hated for pretty
words to have a bad tune. In school,
some of them did. I didn't like minor
[key] tunes as a child. There was one
song in church called 'Windham' that
had words that went, 'Broad is the road
.' I think that's
that leads to death.
it
what turned me against minor tunes
was so depressing. I must have been 16
or 17 before I started to see the beauty in
those tunes. People would get together
and sing a few times a year, and I began to
realize how beautiful the tunes were, the
little ornamentations. And so many of
the ballads were in the same minor.
"My grandfather had a place up in

Mitchell County, up

in

the mountains,

�Kona, and he had a 'talking machine.' 1
would play those records whenever we
went up there and I remember listening
to 'River of Jordan,' 'When the Roses
Bloom Again,' 'Little Log Cabin in the
and
1 still remember the records
Lane'.
the titles. I started listening to them
when I was around nine or ten, but it
wasn't till I was twelve I realized that a lot
of these songs were much older than I
thought even though I knew what
in

appealed to me was not what

I

thought

their actual age was, but that they had the
feeling of something real old, a deeper
feeling. Then I realized that people around
home were singing these same songs, in
slightly different versions. It was like the
door flew open.

"One thing
sadness,

I

their

know why.
ness,

but

I'd

that

liked about the songs was
their poignancy, I don't

always hunted for happi
sadness had a certain

sweetness. guess was something I had
been looking for in life to give it meaning.
I

it

in the dumps. There is something
the quality of their music that I've
never got anywhere else to this day.
Nobody that ever lived sung as good as
Sarah Carter.
"The next day at the festival I seen my
name up on the paper to perform again.
'Why'd you put my name back up?' I

down

town. His name was Ralph Ellison, but
they called him 'Smiley' because he
didn't have no teeth. I learned a lot of old
ballads from him. He learned his songs
directly from his father. The first time I
heard 'Four nights Drunk' was from
him, and he was kind of high, so when he
sang the drunk man's part it really come
across that way. I always sing that part,'
c'mere little wifey
.' as if I'm drunk.
Then I throw my voice into a falsetto for
the wife's part."

in

asked. They told me they had gotten
more requests for me than for anyone
else. 'Be sure you tell them stories in
between the songs,' they said."
For the next four years Bobby worked
at the Broyhill furniture factory, singing

attending Caldwell
College for a couple of
years, and not enjoying it, Bobby went to
Fiddlers Grove and met Jean Schilling,
who had a dulcimer shop in Cosby,
Tennessee with her husband. She invited
him to a festival in Cosby, as she was
interested in hearing the songs Bobby
knew that were from her community.
In

1973,

after

Community

Bobby went, got up on stage, and sang

ballad,

first

telling

its

story.

on weekends and holidays. He met Dan
Patterson in Chapel Hill, and sang him a
version of 'Love Has Brought Me To
Despair' that he had learned from
Mamaw Phillips. He visited Janette
Carter in Virginia, and, with other
western North Carolina ballad singers,

went

a

"Joe

that
there are different versions. In the
beginning I had thought that there was

The shining glory of the ballads

song, and

Council

a

is

that knew

Arts

just one original version of
that I might find somebody
the original version.

began to ask everybody I seen for
songs they knew. It was about two years
later, merely by accident, that I run
across the Frank Brown collection of

Office,

N.C.

"I

Folklife
Bill

discovering for myself something about
ballads and folklore, researching it on
my own. I would overlook it so much
that it just soaked in.
was a sophomore in high
"When
school, my English teacher introduced
me to Cratis Williams at Appalachian
State up at Boone. She knew that I liked
old songs and had taken a folklore class. I
took him some of the songs I had. I was

Boyarsky,

began

by

I

courtesy

I

through it
I
had learned from the family.

Williams was the first contact I
outside
of my old life. That was in
had
1968. just continued on learning songs
from people. As a teenager I became
acquainted with a feller from up near
Boone, near Meat Camp and Potters"Dr.

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

photo

I

already putting them into a little journal,
because it had dawned on me what a
precarious existence balladry was in when
I come
along, and I thought I better write
stuff down. Well, Dr. Williams was just
tickled to death, and he showed me how
to document a song, to write down who
sang it. He said, 'Someday these songs
are going to mean a lot to you in a way
you probably don't see now.' I had no
idea what he meant. I had no picture of
myself then standing up in front of
people singing.

to

Washington

sing

for

the

In 1978 Bobby applied for, and
received, an appointment as artist in
residence in the town of St. Pauls in
Robeson County, south of Fayetteville.
The time he spent in the schools helped
turn him into a storyteller. "I had those
kids for 50 minutes at a time, six hours a
day. I went into the classrooms in the
elementary schools for two or three
weeks, then to the high school for other
liked to kill myself
kinds of projects.
I
thought, 'I'll just tell them
singing.
I

began to look
and saw that there were songs

North Carolina folklore.

to

Bicentennial.

The late Stanley Hicks playing one of his
homemade fretless banjos.

Dawson

he

was

the

sheriff of

went into Haywood County,
to break up a liquor still, and instead him

Newport
and

the

revenue

officers

divided the

liquor amongst them. Sandy John Sutton,
who was my Mamaw Phillips' grand
father, owned that still, and he stood up
on the mountain watching the sheriff
and the revenue officers. He shot and
killed Joe Dawson because of that. W ell,
the Republicans in Newport didn't want
that song sung, and they got an ordinance
passed that made it against the law to sing
it."

told that story (of course it all had
a very long time before), and
also sang a Carter Family song; Janette
Carter was there and it was a real thrill
"I

happened

meeting her. The Carter Family had
always been an inspiration to me, espe
cially their religious music, when I was

some tales to mix

in

with it.'"

mid-'70s Bobby

had also met
and spent time with Stanley Hicks from
Beech Mountain, and had learned lots of
old stories and tales from him. "I began
telling Jack Tales and Booger tales to the
kids. I told some of them a little different
from what you might hear from Stanley
Hicks. I had been seeing myself as just a
passer-on of the tradition, not as a mover
In the

or

a

creative person.

I

was telling stories

the same as I had heard them. But I began
to see that there had to be some kind of
plan if the tradition was going to stay
not making it literary
alive
always

keeping

it

down-to-earth.

iust tell the bare bones.

I

But I didn't
began to tell

whatever come to me, to use the tales as a
tool to describe the mountain way of life.
When I tell the Big T oe Story, I tell about
this old house we lived in, a log house
with a downstairs and a loft. I tell about
the fireplace, with hooks to put pots and
kettles on. I tell about beans
looking
them over, washing them, soaking them,
I just wanted
them to know, I wanted to
that
capture
feeling."
Over the years Bobby has gone on to
work as artist-in-residence at many

continued on page 43

�FIDDLIN' ARTHUR SMITH:

Pretty Girls Than One" will be played as
long as there are fiddlers to play them.

1898 in
County, Tennessee, and a
young lady named Nettie Jewel Baker
Arthur was born April 10,

Humphreys

came into his life at

a very early age. They
played together as babies. As Arthur
entered his teens, learning from the old

fiddlers in middle Tennessee, Nettie
accompanied him on guitar. His father,
who was accidently electrocuted while
working for the phone company in 906,
had been a fiddler. Arthur inherited his
fiddle and learned on it. Nettie sold
chickens to help buy the next one. They
were married in 1914 when Arthur was
sixteen and Nettie was fifteen; it was a
marriage that endured for 57 years. The
Smith household was blessed with thir
teen children, six girls and seven boys.
All survived to adulthood and most of
them became musicians. First born was
LaVonne in 1916 (she died in Chat
tanooga onjanuary 8, 1990). In the early
1

'30s she played piano with her father and
the Dixieliners at the Grand Ole Opry
and on their one-room school house
tours. Three little girls came and then, in
1922, Ernest was born. The eldest son
would become a close companion for the
rest of his father's life. They would play
square dances, schools and the Grand
Ole Opry together. At every opportunity
they would get together and play, often
for eight or ten hours at a time. During

those marathon sessions they
sometimes write songs together.

would

courtesy

Charies

Woite

Today, after a long career in engineer
ing, Ernest has moved with his wife

Arthur Smith (seated) with the Bailes Brothers 1943

A Son
by

Remembers
James Kennison

Fiddlin' Arthur Smith was King of the
Fiddlers. When he died in February
1971, Roy Acuff bestowed that title on

him in an eulogy from the Grand Ole
Opry stage. In my opinion he was the
best of his time and probably of all time.
His style is still influencing young fiddlers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

second- and third-hand, and the fiddle
tunes he wrote or popularized are present
at every festival and fiddling contest.
"Blackberry Blossom," "Red Apple Rag,"
"Florida Blues," "Pig in the Pen,"
"Peacock Rag," "Sugar Tree Stomp,"
"Beautiful Brown Eyes," and "More

Annabel to the mountains of western
North Carolina near Mars Hill. On their
living room wall is a painting of Arthur

Smith with a fiddle under his chin, and
you can feel Arthur's presence in the
room. "Arthur Smith was not only my
father but the best friend I ever had,"
Ernest says.
"I guess there has never been a father
or son any closer than we were. As I grew
older and became more involved in
music, we were inseparable. We would
go to square dances when I was about
twelve and he would tell folks, 'Now my
son is just not old enough to stand up

here and play for forty-five minutes a set,
so we're going to have a little break.' The
dancers would go out and smoke and
then we would start again."
In his teens Arthur learned from the
old fiddlers in Humphreys and Dickson
Counties, especially Jim and Grady
Stringer. In that area where he grew up

several fiddlers played in a long bowing
style with complex noting. Arthur seems
to have perfected that style and made it
his own; in the same way Earl Scruggs,

�Old Judge' talking about paw paws."
Early in 1932 Arthur and Homer
broke up their act and Arthur joined
Sam and Kirk McGee to form the Dixieliners. They first played on the Opry in
May 1932. The McGees were incredible
instrumentalists and Ernest looked
forward to every chance to play with

them.

"I used to get the biggest thrill of my
life to see Sam and Kirk come by and
watch Sam set up the bells he played on. 1

learned some guitar from Sam. It got so,
when they came in the house, Sam would
just bring his guitar in because he knew
would want to play."
Ernest became an excellent guitarist
and, considering the teachers he had,
that is not surprising. Arthur Smith
played guitar and banjo very well, and.
Ernest's first lessons were from his
father, who taught him how to play
behind a fiddle.
"In 1932, when I was ten years old, we

I

moved back to Dickson and had a great
Tommie Pinkerton, who played
and sang beautifully.
guess she
got me started. But Alton Delmore
I

aunt,
guitar
really
is the

1

I credit with teaching
me what
know.
a
teacher.
He
He
was
guitar
great
showed me the chord transitions
how
to go from one chord to another. Young
musicians have trouble determining
when to change chords and when you are
playing with other people that is very

man

photo

by

LaVonne

Brown,

courtesy

Ernest

Smith

I

Arthur Smith

at

the Jefferson Inn, Detroit, MI 1945

later, would listen to the three-fingered
in the North Carolina
mountains and then take it beyond where
anyone else had gone. By the early '20s

banjo being played

Arthur had established a reputation as a
fiddler, but he had a lot of mouths to
feed and there wasn't much money in
fiddling. He went to work in 1925 for
the North Carolina and St. Louis Rail
road, known as the Dixie Line. First he
cut cross ties, then was promoted to
lineman and finally to the maintenance
crew. Wherever Arthur's work took
him his fiddle went along. Soon he met

Harry Stone, another Dixie Line
employee, who was working as a part-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

time announcer for radio station WSM.
Stone arranged for Arthur to be heard by
George D. Hay, the "Solemn Old Judge,"
who was looking for talent for the brand

new Grand Ole Opry. Arthur became
one of the earliest performers on the
Opry, in 1927, playing solo at first but

soon joined

by his cousin, Homer Smith,
on guitar. The Grand Ole Opry became a

familar place to Ernest Smith.
"1 spent
a lot of time
at the Opry. I
remember as a very young boy going
with Dad to the old tabernacle building.
That was across the river. I can see it in
my mind; all the chairs and seats and
sawdust on the floor and the 'Solemn

important."
In 1934 Arthur started touring with
the Delmore Brothers and the following
year he went with Alton and Rabon to a
Delmore recording session in New
Orleans. When A. and R. man Eli Oberstein heard Arthur play he decided to
record

him

as

a

lead

with

also,

the

Delmore Brothers backing him up.
Arthur first recorded "Blackberry

Blossom" and "Red Apple Rag" at that
session. For Ernest it was the beginning
of a life-long friendship with the
Delmores. He recalls one occasion when
he played a show with Alton.
"It was in

1941 and

I

was still in high

school. They had a show in Greeneville,
Tennessee, and Rabon was sick. They
told

me

to

be

around

for

they were

coming through to pick me up.

It was a
big picnic with ten or fifteen bands. We
were there all day long. Of course I knew

lot of the Delmores' songs. I had
listened to them and sang with them
a

when they came by the house. I took
Alton's guitar and he played Rabon's
tenor guitar. After the close of the day
and they got paid, my Dad stood up for

and I got my cut just like Rabon
would have. That was the most money I
had ever seen, something like seventyme

�five dollars in one-dollar bills.
It's so unfortunate those two boys
died so young. They always seemed to
have a rough time getting along with the
management of the Opry. Being a native
Tennessean, I don't rejoice in saying
something against my state, but when the
Grand Ole Opry started I think they had
in mind keeping it so all the performers
were from Tennessee. They were for
many years. Alton and Rabon were from
Alabama and I think there was a certain
amount of prejudice."
In 1 938 Arthur Smith also had trouble
with the Opry management. David Stone
had been staging fiddling contests with
the leading fiddlers of the day. They
don't seem to have been real contests for
the winners were often predetermined.
The Delmores went to one such show in

western Tennessee, and Arthur was
supposed to join them but he never got
there. Stone suspended Arthur from the

Opry for four weeks for missing the
show. During the suspension Stone found
several fiddlers to play with the Delmores
and asked Alton to pick one who would
get a guest shot on the Grand Ole Opry.

Alton picked a young fellow from
Maynardville, Tennessee named Roy

Acuff. Roy was not a great fiddler but
Alton saw something else in him. The
story was told that Arthur had depended
on some people to drive him to the show
that day, but they stopped for some
moonshine and he couldn't get them to
know
go any farther. Ernest doesn't
whether that story is true but he doesn't

there. Dad didn't stay long. He
went up to West Virginia and played
with the Bailes Brothers. I went to Detroit
and got involved in music up there. I was
playing at a big place called the Jefferson
Inn with the York Brothers. George
York had to go into the service and I
took his place. Leslie and I played to
with
gether and we finally got in touch
Dad and he came up to Detroit and spent
a couple of years up there. Around 1947
Dad went out to Hollywood with Jimmy
Wakely. He stayed out there about three
years, lived in Jimmy Wakely's house
and worked in fourteen movies with
him. He used to watch his movies and
his
laugh about riding a horse and taking

were

gun out and shooting it."
Arthur came back to Nashville in
1951 and dropped out of music for

awhile. He went to work with his brother
In 1962 Arthur and
as a carpenter.
Ernest recorded an album together for
Starday. About that time Mike Seeger
brought Arthur and the McGee Brothers
together and recorded Arthur and the
Dixieliners for the first time on a Folk
ways album. In 1965 Arthur and the
McGees went to the Newport Folk Fest

ival and received a thunderous welcome.
Ernest moved down to Louisville in
1968 and went to work at the General
Electric Appliance Park. Arthur was
working with his friend Gordon Terry.
Ernest recalls those last days: "Gordon
Terry had a place near Loretto,
Tennessee, called Terry Town. It was a

simulated western town with stage-coach
rides, an old saloon and all the buildings
would have. Dad was
a western town

week
playing there for square dances on

ends and taking care of the place. [People]
started breaking in and stealing his
fiddles, including the one in the painting,

I
just became overwhelmed with
grief for him down there; so one snowy
stuff
day I called and told him to get his
One
of
I was coming after him.
for
ready

and

my brothers and I went down and got
him. I bought a little house at Lake

Dreamland, outside Louisville, and we
relocated him there. About two weeks
after Dad left there, Terry Town burned

It was about a year after
that he became ill. We had a big party at
in
my house on the day after Christmas
1970. People came down from Michigan
and we played nearly all night. Ten days
later I came in and slapped Dad on the
back and he said it hurt. We took him to
the doctor and they ran tests. At first
they thought he had tuberculosis, but it

to the ground.

turned out to be lung cancer. He made
the decision himself, onjanuary 28th, to
have surgery; but it was too late. He died

exactly a month later."
Ernest is not always happy with what
is written about his father. Sometimes it
sounds as though the writers are talking
about a different Arthur Smith than the
one he knew. He also feels the country
music establishment in Nashville has

continued on page 44

think that is the real reason Arthur
missed the show.
"I've never heard my Dad say anything
about why he left the Opry. He wouldn't
talk about it. I have to depend on what
that he did
my oldest sister [told] me

not want to participate in those
fraudulent, prejudged contests. My Dad

a straight man and contrary to what I
have read, he was not an aggressive man.
He was not ill-tempered or hard to get
along with. I never saw him get mad at
anybody. It hurt him a great deal to leave
under those circumstances after thirteen
years on the Opry."
He did leave and traveled around the
country for the next few years. Ernest
left home too.
"When I got out of high school in
1942, I had a couple of jobs in Chicago
and then decided to come back to Nash
ville. At that time Daddy was playing

Carlisle, Johnny Wright and Jack Anglin
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Charles
courtesy

with Smilin' Eddie Hill in Knoxville at
WNOX. I joined them there and we
played together for a time. They had
some good musicians at WNOX at that
time. Cowboy Copas, Chet Atkins, Bill

Wolfe

was

The Dixieliners:

the Opry's finest string band. Sam McGee, Arthur Smith, Kirk McGee,

1936

�Issues In Old-Time Music

of ideas and points of view, some of which
Points of view
be
controversial.
may
expressed in this column are not necessarily

Hey look. Joe Wilson and his 25member banjo-picking board run a big
folk festival, and they run it their way.
Fine. Great. The buck stops with Joe.
That conceded, Joe Wilson offers some

those of the

pretty

The Issues In Old-Time Music column
was established as a forum for the expression

Old-Time Herald.

[To those of you who are new

or

recent

way back in the spring '89 OTH
Mac Ben ford wrote an article in this column
An Account of
entitled "Folklorists &amp;Us

subscribers,

Our Curious &amp; Changing Relationship," in
which he expressed some very real concerns
concerns not only of his but a great many
others as well. We received a lot of response
which we printed in subsequent issues. In the

last (spring) OTH we printed an extensive
response to Mac from joe Wilson of the
National Council for the Traditional Arts
entitled "Confessions of a Folklorists."
Because it is apparent that the subject is of
such concern to musicians as well as non-

musicians, and that these issues have a
bearing on the future of old-time music
and in the spirit of continuing dialogue, the
debate continues. We received too many
excellent letters to go into one issue, so these
are a few of them.]

remember ole Joe,

"Hey Bob, do ya
from Mrs. Fraiser's 2nd grade?"
"Well dang, I shur do, Bob, mean as a
snake he uz, gave that woman pure-tee
fits. She used to crack his knuckles oncet
but hit didn't do much good I
a week,
don't reckon. What ever happened to
that ole boy?"
"Well, last I heard, he'd gone up to
ork, supposed to be makin' a lotta
money, but the other day I seen an article
by him in that there fiddle magazine, and
hit said he uz in Washington running

New

Y

some big folk fester."
"You mean he's writing
Lan, that ole boy

including probably 90 percent
represents
of this magazine's readership.
First, the "issue" of professionalism.
Or rather, it seems to be some sort of
"issue" for Joe, but I never thought of it
that way. There are certainly many won
derful "amateur" musicians, but except
for a few recluses (Glen Gould types)
and a few with religious scruples, most
good musicians do or at least have played
on stage at least locally, or in a contest, or
at some festival. Usually when you play
you get paid something. So in a reason
able sense, most good musicians are at

least part-time professionals. Joe
audaciously cites Tommy Jarrell

actually, all his citations are audacious,
and carefully designed to shift all of oldtime music's indisputable heros over to
his camp. But T ommy was a professional
in this basic sense, and in another sense
too: he was a great performer. That's
why Tommy made records (another

symptom of professionalism), and that's
why he played all the national gigs he

wanted in the '70s and '80s. Yes indeed,
"
ommy was "authentic, an example of a
distinct regional culture and all that
but at least equally, and probably more
importantly in terms of getting the work,
T ommy J arrell was a spell-binding enter
tainer who could not only play but tell a
good story and put together a perfect set.
And Tommy damn well knew it. Sure,
the silly west-coast band Joe cites
couldn't compete with Tommy, but

T

could many other equally
"authentic" oldtimers. The point is,
people who play big festivals mostly
when
have to be skilled performers
neither

now,

Bub?

couldn't hardly talk."

tell you, that article was slick
sorry, Miss Emmy, 1 didn't see
you thar. Anyways, hit was so slick I felt
kindly sorry for this feller Mac he uz
kicking around. Ole Joe, he's moved a
fer piece from this ole holler. An you
know what's funny? He's dyed his hair
"Bob,

as

in his effort
of
a
OTH,
Folklorist,"
("Confessions
Feb. 1990) to not merely defend his
festival leadership, but absolutely crush
and pulverize Mac Benford and all he

tortured logic

I

owl

red."

"Dyed his hair! What'd he go an do
that for?"
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

they're not, disasters often ensue. One of
Wilson's jobs is to decide who,
among the authentic elect, can cope with

Joe

the road and the big stage. Some people
play great at home, but don't like looking
at 10,000 people, or can never get in
tune, or play nothing but waltzes, or pass
out in the dressing room. Some people,
like Tommy Jarrell, are professionals.

T ommy was also in the perfect position
to embark on a performing career when
the opportunity arose. He was retired,
with a good pension and state health

insurance, in good health, his kids were
long grown, his wife had passed away.
Tommy had no good reason not to take
off to some festival whenever he wanted.
And he didn't have to worry too much
about the money: as long as his expenses
were covered he could play the nicest,
and only the nicest venues. And this
wonderful situation, of course, was only
what he deserved.
Other musicians, when they are at
different stages in their lives, face tougher
choices when confronted with the pro

fessional

Joe offers us
farmer
perhaps, but
hog

opportunity.

Kenny Baker

mainly full-time professional fiddler for
in defense
35 years
of, what, hair
dressing? But he misunderstands Kenny's
remark 1 think. Music is an inner fire,
and for some people, even when they are
young, married, parents, family and
community members with all the implied
responsibilities, they simply must follow
their talent. If you want to be the best
fiddler you can be, there is just nothing
better than touring with a good, working
band. I know. This is obviously the
choice Kenny Baker made as a young
man, and it took courage. Why courage?
Because going out on the road has a big
down side for someone with a family and

community.

Professional musicians

just like everyone else

just

as

fast.

Unless they happen

become stars (not necessarily
of talent,

are

the years fly by

to say the least),

a

to

function

most pro

fessional musicians don't do much for
their older years

they don't build up

collect

big royalties
pensions,
(does Bill Monroe have a dental plan?).
Though I know nothing about Kenny
Baker's personal life, a lot of professional
musicians pay the price of the road in
the spouse gets damn tired
lost family
of sitting at home with the babies and
dealing with the fan belt and the electric
the hogs?
bill, the sick mother-in-law,
A lot of musicians who burn to play go
up in flames eventually, and they all run
the risk. And I suspect, Joe, that's what
Kenny Baker's wistful remark about the
fat

fiddling barber

or

is all

about.

The point, though, is that people who
decide to try and live the professional life
on the road are making a choice of the
heart. That kind of choice deserves

demands
respect. I don't equate respect
with a booking at the National Folk
Festival, and 1 don't think Mac Benford
does either. But Highwoods wasn't that
silly, Quixotic west-coast band. The
Highwoods band went out there because

�they loved playing and
they stayed out there
because they were very
woods didn't live on

performing, and

long time
good at it. Highfor

a

grants,

they just

looked forward to those nice civilized
folk festival audiences as a reward for the
all-night rides, semis in snowstorms,
biker mudslings, and bluegrass bars.
And after

a while,
they got burned out.
But in the process Highwoods played a
lot of magical sets
know because
sometimes I had to follow them and
I

certainly T ommy was talking about them
too, in his quoted remarks, whether he
cited them by name to Joe or not (and
who would know?). Highwoods helped
build the old-time music audience, and
thus helped make Tommy Jarrell's
musical career possible. Joe does a great
disservice to Mac and Walt and Bob and
real people who were
Jenny and Doug
out there for a decade making the music
they loved when they could have been
building safe careers when he brushes

astute quotes from both emphasizing
families playing music because they liked
it, and on playing real feelings of the
moment, and the fallacies of imitations.
Then Mike Seeger's illuminating the
spectra of those beaming banjo belles;
but surpassing them all is the continuing
Issues furor, in the honored tradition of
Bashing, not to be outdone by such
feeble Anglo-Saxon customs as boxing
and rugby and football. Salutes to Mr.
Benford and Mr. Stecher and Mr. W ilson
for amusing and edifying us all at once.
Keep it up boys, never say die, I'm
betting on the guy with the brown shoelaces. Just tell the truth, keep it clean, and
when you're done you're all invited to
my house for a tune and a drink. Oldtime music issues resemble particle
physics, where you learn the details by

walloping the subject and watching what
comes flying out.

it.

Hank Bradley

Seattle, WA

They paid their

dues.

When

read Mac's original piece last
saw that mainly what he was

I

spring, I
doing was putting bands like Highwoods
(and my old bands) in some kind of
historical perspective. What 1 felt,
learning tunes from Tommy Jarrell and

Hammons and Frank George and
Dave Milefsky and all the rest in the early
'70s, was a deep and personal sense of
membership in the tradition. remember

think you are

bad way when you
by one Joe
Wilson
one page would be plenty. It's
a crime to give that amount of space to
I

publish

7

and

in

1/3

a

pages

one dude.

C.

Burl

Lowry

Owensboro,

KY

1

saying to myself, one day back then, "I
am a fiddler." I've tried, through the
years, to keep the faith. It's a physical
skill, after all, like carpentry. Fiddle
players share an ear, no matter where
they're from. In trying to draw a fundamental class distinction, with the "folk"
middleon one side and the, what?
elite hippie, yuppie, cultureless
wunderkind on the other, Joe goes too
far. Kenny Baker and Tommy Jarrell and
Mac Benford all loved "the music."
When he dyed his hair red, maybe the
ole boy stopped loving tunes in favor of
distinctions. His piece reminds me of the
time I played fiddle at a dry wedding
reception, but that's another story.
class

Bill Hicks

Associate Editor, OTH
Silk Hope, NC

As much as I disagree with Mac Benford's notions of where old-time music
is headed, he is to be commended for
trying to keep the current discussion on
the level of issues, rather than a sordid
squabble over who didn't hire whose
revival band 15 years ago. Herewith a
modest contribution of my own on a

matter of principle.
As much as I agree with most of what
Joe Wilson had to say (I even live on
Pipers Gap Road!), I fear he has fallen
prey to a bit of folkie romanticism when

describes old-time music as the property of the "lower classes." Take, for
example, the son of a small-town restaurant owner, an honors graduate of a
state university, the youngest graduate of
his law school, and the youngest ever to
pass the Bar Examination of his state. He
he

successful State's Attorney, whose
now teaches in Switzerland. Now
make him an old-time fiddler. One more
urban folkie? Not really: it was Price
Goodson, born in Galax, who recorded
with DaCosta Woltz in 1927.
As Joe doubtless knows when he isn't
trying to make a point, old-time music is
was

son

Cheers for the spring edition, unsurpassed

in

Baker

and

fine folklore.

Tom

Hunter

First

the

articles,

Etta

with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

miners, millhands, and such,
this society includes a substantial middle
class. Lawyers like Goodson and Bascom
Lamar Lunsford, doctors like Humphrey
farmers,

Bate and W.K. Lloyd, businessmen like
Frank Blevins and Claude Slagle, and
even a few good barbers like Byrd Moore

and Gid Tanner. What's more, country
people in general, and old-time musicians
in particular, are an intelligent and enter-

prising lot with a great deal of upward
mobility. If you drive down Pipers Gap
Road today, you will see a stretch of
suburbia/ exurbia pretty typical of any
where in the country. There are only two
log houses between here and the Blue

Ridge Parkway, both recently built and
out of my price range. Not a tarpaper
shack in the whole 10-mile stretch.
I'm

them aside as myopic middleclass
romantics. Just like Kenny Baker, they
went out there and did

part of the complex culture of a complex
society. Despite its solid foundation of

sure,

as

I

say,

that Joe

knows

better, but some of the people whose
view of this area is limited to the horse
pens in Felts Park don't seem to. When
they do get out in the countryside to
meet the local musicians, it is with a set
of preconceptions and expectations that
are not only misleading but likely to give
offense. This is nothing new here: I am
reminded of the story, told to me as true

many Carroll Countians, about the
old man who took a walk along the Blue
Ridge Parkway when it first opened, to
watch the cars go by. One, with out-ofstate plates, pulled over near him, and a
woman leaned out the window and called,
"Say, old man, where are all the hillbillies?" "Up in Pennsylvania," the fellow
by

shot back, "teaching school."

John Coffey

Galax, VA

It's time people stopped using the
term "revival musician." All performers
of old-time music in the twentieth century are revival musicians. Most of the
styles of American folk music that
interest us now were developed in the

nineteenth century and continuously
expanded, syncretized, and notably

changed ever since. That is what the folk
process means. All the famous folk
artists we know about are revivalists. All
of them had repertoires that included
popular as well as more formal musical
traditions.
never knew an old-time
I

banjo picker who didn't play marches
and compose tunes. Buell Kazee was
trained as a classical singer. He would
have been definitely classified as a revivalist if that had been widely know about
him.

�Revivalist is actually being used to
describe people who were not born in
the right place. Those who use the term
would flunk every Blindfold Test if they
were forced simply to hear the music and
make a judgment about its authenticity.

Revivalist

is

a

mistaken and pernicious

term and we should stop using it. We
don't refer to pianists who specialize in

Mozart

as

revivalists.

We are only

interested to know if they are exceptional.
Similarly people who specialize in oldtime music and do it well are no more or
less

revivalists

than the people they
learned from. If their music is well done
and accurately expressed, it doesn't make
any difference where they were born.

Mike Seeger is defined as a revivalist
because he wasn't born in Kentucky. But
he has contributed more (in every way)
to the existence of old-time music than

anyone anywhere

and

he

has

paid

a

heavy price because of the people who
insist on using revivalist as a pejorative
term.

But I want to say how grateful I am to
the OTH for printing Joe Wilson's dia

tribe.

It

expresses

beautifully

the

bureaucratic mind in the folk music
establishment. There is too much in his
piece to critique in detail, but I think it
important to sink his notion that T ommy

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Jarrell and Dewey Balfa somehow get
extra points for doing their non-musician
vocations. He should be appalled that a
man like Dewey Balfa spent his time
driving a bus or operating a furniture
store. People like Balfa and other great
musicians should have been plying their

trades

as professional
musicians and
Wilson should have figured out what he
could do to bring that about instead of
chiding Mac Benford because he wants
to be a working musician.

There are dozens of projects that could
have helped to make our great folk
artists available to American audiences. I
have been involved in one small attempt
which suggests that folk artists have a
real function in our society, not only as
entertainers but as educators. For some
years I have hosted a Resident Folk
Artist program at my university. Folk

artists come for a semester, teach two
courses (one a small seminar), and spend
time in the community
with no charge
to schools and other non-profit groups.
The rationale is that since that RFA
program is sponsored jointly by the Folk
Arts section of NEA and the university
(that's federal and state money) the

schools ought

to get the

artists

at

no

charge. The RFA gets top professor
grade pay. Most of them are natural

teachers

and as prestigious as any
Ph.D
no one ever falls asleep in their
classes. It is an NEA Model Program and
the artists have included Kenny Hall,
Bessie Jones, Lydia Mendoza, Richard
Hagopian, Jean Ritchie, and Dewey Balfa.
Both the university and the community
have been tremendously appreciative.
The idea of residencies for artists is
not a new or radical conception. With
the kind of joint sponsorship that I have
had, schools, towns, and many other
institutions could be playing a major role
in

keeping the traditional arts alive and
in our society. And while
see

viable

nothing wrong

I

in

paying

special

attention to national treasures like Balfa
and Jarrell, the recipients of those pro
grams should include all artists of com
petence, not just those who have been
kept sanitized from an inaccurate and

poisonous label.
Gene Bluestein
California State University, Fresno, CA

continued on page 43

�Rolling River

FIDDLE

cross-tuned
Key of

A

from John Lusk band
Altamonl: Black Stringband Music From
The Library of Congress --ROUNDER 0238

COMMENTS:
fingers are low
shown in the KEY)

FIDDLETAB
(as

(L) or high (H)

position.

PLAY THE NOTES AS IF YOU
WERE IN STANDARD TUNING

MUSIC NOTATION

(notation indicates fingering---not always the melody)
Unusual fingerings are indicated with #s above notes.
1st PART

Measures

1

&amp; 3;

John Lusk plays this:

instead

of

the

open strings

I've indicated.

Measure

Try the easy (open)
way first, then his way.
(It's more difficult, but
it sounds great!)

2:

the first beat, he sometimes bars the high strings with his first finger (as in the C phrase
of the 2nd PART).
Note that the 3rd finger shifts up to the little finger position to allow the pinky to play a C#.
On

2nd

PART
I've labeled this as three phrases (A..., B..„ C...) which are played in sequence four times. For
know you've rushed out to purchase), keep in
those playing along with the recording (which
mind that the first time through the tune, they leave out the C... phrase on the first repeat.
I

The liner notes state that Grubble &amp;c Lusk kept their instruments tuned at the old pre-steel string
frequency, which was 1 &amp;. 1/2 steps lower than today's standard, (i.e. G tuning would be in the key of E.)
You might like to tune on down St help the Rolling River keep on rolling along.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

---

Carl

Jones

�BOWING
WORKSHOP
by

Brad Leftwich

Review.

If you missed the first bowing
workshop, recommend you have a look
at OTH vol. 2, no. 2. It explains my
approach to bowing and, more important, how to understand the way I write
I

out the bow licks and tunes in this series.
I'll also be referring to licks that were
explained in more detail last time.

Downbowing, as I call it, is a style very
loosely characterized by beginning phrases
on downbow strokes, ending phrases on
upbows (so you can start the next phrase
on a downbow), and playing your sawstrokes so that your bow is going down
on the beat. Downbowing also uses
certain characteristic bow licks that I'll
be showing you in this series of work
shops. These are guidelines rather than
rules, but it's worth sticking close to
them until you know what you're doing.
divide bow licks into three groups:
for the beginning of a phrase, for the
middle of a phrase, and for the end of a
phrase. Last time I covered "sawstrokes,"
lick consisting of even bowa middle
strokes moving down and up like a saw
(with the beat falling on a downbow); a
beginning lick consisting of a long

the names to learn the bowing
patterns, then don't worry about them
any more.

use

The 3/3

ending. Next to the basic
ending, possibly the most common ending
lick in downbowing is the 3/3 ending. In
the illustration I've added two sawstrokes
between each ending so that you can
practice them continuously, without
stopping and starting.
In

the

3/3 ending, you

pull your bow

down for the equilavent of three notes,
and push it back up through three more.
This is trickier than it sounds, because
although the lick starts down on the
beat, your bow actually changes direction

and starts back up slightly before the next
tap of your foot. Your natural tendency
is going to be to wait and start back up on

next beat, so watch what you're
doing carefully. Count it while you play
the

it:

down-two-three

up-two-three;

the

The long sawstroke.
is

just

a

A

long saw-stroke

regular sawstroke twice as slow,

which means there
on each

downbow

upbow twice
sawstroke.

as

is room for two notes
and two more on each
many as on the regular

This is pretty straightforward until
you start noting with your left hand.
Some bowstrokes may have two short
notes on them, while others may have
only one long note. It should make no
difference to your bow arm, which should
keep going down and up, like a machine,
in even bowstrokes regardless of what
the notes are doing.

"Great Big Taters in Sandy Land."
This is a tune that builds on the same
licks we covered in "Shortening Bread"
last time, adding only the 3/3 ending and
the long sawstroke.
The bowing pattern for the low part is

italicized words are where you tap your
foot.

broken down

with the beginning lick, goes
several sawstrokes, starts to
wind up the phrase with a basic ending,
then finishes it off with 3/3 ending. So it
actually strings together two different
ending licks in the same phrase.
The pattern for the high part is simpler,
consisting only of a beginning lick, some
long sawstrokes, and the 3/3 ending.

Notice that the beginning lick

in

the

illustration.

accompanying

1

downbow the length of three sawstrokes;

and two ending licks. The first ending
lick was a short downbow, followed by a

long upbow the length of three saw
strokes. The second ending lick was of

the pattern, down up-up down up- up,
where each "up-up" represents an upbow
that is twice as long as each downbow,
and the beat falls on the italicized words.

occurs to me somewhat belatedly
would be a good idea to name all
of these licks for convenient reference in
future workshops. With that in mind,
It

that

it

I'll call ending lick #1 the "basic ending,"
because it's so common, and ending lick
#2 will be the "syncopated ending,"
because it emphasizes the off-beat (that's
what "syncopated" means). You'll run

into

a

number of other syncopated licks

down the line, and making sure you
really have this ending down pat will pay
dividends later. I'm not going to bother
renaming the beginning lick; it's fairly
standard,

and

any

other licks you see

beginning a phrase will usually be middle
licks moonlighting as beginning licks.
Remember that most of these names

ones I've made up. If you start talking
about syncopated endings or some other
such ridiculous thing to anyone who
hasn't seen this series of workshops,
they're liable to think you're nuts. Just
are

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

It

starts

through

is

a

little

different here. That's because we're attach
ing it to a long sawstroke instead of a
regular sawstroke.

In

the illustration

it

goes through four spaces, not three as it
did when we attached it to regular

sawstrokes.

Here's the whole tune, in the key of G:
One last comment: In the second beat

�of the first phrase of the low part, the
same note (a "3") is written twice on the
same string on the same bowstroke. This
is because they should sound like two
separate notes. The way this is done is by
bearing down on the bow and pushing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a little more energy on the second of
the two notes. Note that your bow does

with
not

stop and start;

a

it

continues to move

the same direction, just with
more
little
pressure and energy on the

smoothly

in

second note. H

and banjo
is a fiddler
Plank
Road
the
member
of
player, former
String Band and Leftwich &amp; H igginbotham.
He is on the advisory board of the OTH.
Brad

Leftwich

�BUYING

USED GUITAR

A
by

MARTIN D-28 $500. It sure caught
my eye in the classified ad newspaper.
Used 70s D-28s sell between $800 and
$900. I figured I could get a good deal. I
made a quick phone call and learned that

the guitar was in good condition, it had a
hardshell case, and I would have to drive
about an hour to see it.
An hour later I was unlatching a
familiar blue A.B.S. plastic guitar case.
My first glance said, "looks good." I
looked a little closer and saw that the
bridge was lifting. No big deal. I then
checked the back. There were two cracks
there and two more cracks on the sides. I
tuned it up and played my seven blue-

grass guitar licks. The string height was
almost twice as high as I am used to. The
neck needed to be reset and the frets
were worn and needed to be replaced.
Out of habit I looked inside using a
mirror and a small light. I had been
burned on a guitar deal once. It was a

1928 00-40H, and someone had cus
tomized the braces with a screwdriver

a pair of pliers. I didn't find that out
until I got home and gave the guitar a
good going over.
The top braces of the D-28 were fine
but the back braces were all loose. If it
was going to be fixed properly, the back
would have to come off. At least then the
back and side cracks would be easier to
repair. It was time to step back to see
what the $500 wonder guitar would
really cost.
$35
Bridge removal and reglue
Neck reset
$125
Refret
$150

and

Remove back, fix cracks
reglue braces, replace back and

$300
binding, touch up finish
New strings
$5
Total repairs
$615
Yikes! This guitar could have cost
more than $1 100
$200 to $300 more
than the average price from a dealer. I left
with that guitar but for much less than
$500. It had never been worked on and
my thoughts were to prevent it from
falling prey to an incompetent repair
person. The person with the handy screw
driver and pliers would never lay hands
on this one again.
So what do you look for when you
buy a used guitar? The first and foremost
consideration is sound. This is a sub
jective topic and

I

can only

recommend

tone that fits the
to play. After
want
music
of
you
type
listening to the guitar, examine it for

finding

a

guitar with

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

structural

Bob Smakula

corrected with
or

that may be
few minor adjustments,

problems
a

worse, may lead to expensive repair

bills.

guitar. Is there excessive
too easy to play or do you
need hydraulic assisted fingers? String
height is determined by several factors.
Nut height, saddle height, neck curvature
and neck angle all make one guitar's
action better or worse than another's.
String height can be changed to suit any
playing style. My opinion of ideal string
height for a steel string guitar (measured
from the top of the fret to the bottom of
the string at the 12th fret) is l/16"at the
high E gradually increasing to 3/32" at
Play the
buzzing? Is

it

the low E.
If the

instrument of choice feels hard

to play, sight down the neck. If the neck
looks like the cross-section of a dinner

plate, then the neck should be straight
ened with a heated neck press.
String height at the nut can be checked
by pressing down on a string in front of
the second fret. There should be clear
ance of about the thickness of a piece of
paper between the bottom of the string
and the top of the fret. Too much
clearance translates into a guitar that is
hard to play. No clearance means the
string will buzz when played open. If you
have checked these things and the string
height is still too high, look at the saddle
(the bone or synthetic piece on the
bridge that the strings go over). If the
saddle is tall, more than 1/16" higher
than the bridge, it can be lowered. If it is
close to the top of the bridge then a neck
reset might be in order. A neck reset
entails removing the neck from the body
and changing the angle where the neck
attaches to the body.
The gauge of strings can make a
difference in action. Light gauge strings
are easier to fret than medium or heavy
strings. Check the frets. Frets wear out
when strings are pressed down on them.
The worn area is lower than the fret in
front of it and causes the string to buzz.
Loose or uneven frets are another source

the mistaken notion that it might
hurt the sound of their beloved
instrument. Cracks will get worse over
time. I have seen instruments deteriorate
to an unusable condition because of
had

neglect.
A lifting bridge is another problem
that when corrected early can save you
from big repair bills. Look at the edge of
the bridge farthest away from the neck.
A gap between the top of the guitar and
the bottom of the bridge tells you that
the bridge should be removed, old glue
and finish scraped off the gluing surface,

and the bridge reglued.
Be sure to check the

interior

con

struction. You may not be able to detect
a loose brace or even a missing brace, but
a glance
through the sound hole may
reveal something obviously wrong like
gobs of auto body putty. Some bad
repair jobs are nearly impossible to
correct. Sometimes the most obvious
things pass us by. Look at the hardware
and make sure it is all there. Screws from
tuners can work themselves loose and
fall out.

you are gazing at and
good condition and only
needs some adjustment, don't buy it just
If the

guitar

longing for

is in

Find

out

problems

are

yet.

the guitar and its
cost. I strongly
to
going

what

recommend that before you purchase
used

Bob Smakula has been a fretted instru
ment builder, repairman, and dealer for 16
years. He is an active old-time musician as
well, playing fiddle in the Able Brothers and
Stand Bayou bands. Formerly from Cleve
land, Ohio, he now lives in Elkins, West

Virginia, where he operates
Smakula Fretted Instruments.

his

business,

of string buzzes.

important to check for cracks,
glue joint separations and loose binding.
These troubles will only get worse with
It

is

time. Cracks are always easier (read less
costly) to repair when they are fresh.
Dirt and instrument polish work their
way into cracks and make the repair job
harder. I have known people who refused
to have crack work done because they

an

guitar, you take it to a
professional repair person. Most of the
time estimates are free and you can get a
good idea of any problems that could
cause a nightmare of future repair bills.
Keep these points in mind when buying
used
a
guitar and you can count on years
of enjoyable playing with your purchase.

older,

GET RESULTS

Advertise YOUR used instrument
in an

Old-Time Herald Classified.

�55th ANNUAL

CONVENTION

OLD FIDDLERS'
Sponsored

by

Galax Moose Lodge *733
TO BE HELD AT

FELTS PARK

GALAX, VA

WEDNESDAY, THURSDAY, FRIDAY

AUGUST

8-9-10-1

Beginning 7:00 each night

*12,500.00

IN

&amp;

ALCOHOL

ABSOLUTELY

&amp;

1, 1990
12:00 noon Saturday

AND RIBBONS

LAWS
NO

SATURDAY

CASH PRIZES

PLUS TROPHIES

DRUG

&amp;

WILL

DOGS

ON

BE

ENFORCED

GROUNDS

SEND ALL CORRESPONDENCE TO OLD FIDDLERS CONVENTION. P.O. BOX 655, GALAX, VA 24333.
FOR ENTRY BLANK AND/OR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, CONTACT THE FOLLOWING:
For General Information, contact Oscar Hall, Phone 703-236-6355

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Pre-registration required

by July 25, 1990

�IBMA WORLD OF BLUEGRASS 1990

Sept.25-28/Owensboro,
It's

a

panels and Exhibit Halls and established
section in the Showroom Lounge! And.
as always, the 1990 Trade Show will feature the
most provocative and focused set of workshops and
tobacco

Bluegrass

a

Homecoming

Owensboro, Kentucky!
your Bluegrass
is your Business or
your Love, you need
to be in Owensboro on
September 25-28, 1990
when the Bluegrass
Community comes together
in

at

a

September

World

of

earth lor

bluegrass business meeting.

advance (until 8/24/1990) charges

in

of S95

attending or S185 for an exhibit booth with the $300
to $600 most such events demand, and realize that we
charge artists only $50 for a showcase fee. which at

banquet, plus the Fan Fest!
Until August 24, 1990 the space fee for each exhibit
booth is an outrageous bargain at only $185 ($300
after 8/24/90), which includes admission to all Trade
Show activities including the showcases, awards,
seminars, and meals. Further savings can be realized
by obtaining a Trade Show exhibit booth and vending
space at the Fan Fest as a package. Contact IBMA for

many events runs in excess of $400, you can appre
ciate the tremendous, low cost opportunity the IBMA
World of Bluegrass Trade Show provides.

involvement,

to

Whatever your bluegrass
people you need to meet will be

Attend:

the

in

Owensboro for the IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990. It
will be the one stop place to make bookings, to hear
and meet in the comfort of the Executive Inn's Show
room Lounge the talent that will give your event the

Awards Program

more info.
Just compare our prices
scope, scale and quality!

galaxy on September 25 through 30, 1990 for
the IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990 Trade Show
and the IBMA Bluegrass Fan Fest. The Execu
tive Inn Rivermont will be the host for our
trade show, which will incorporate exhibi

tors displaying a vast array of bluegrass
related products and services, showcases
by established acts and the best of the new
generation of bluegrass talent, seminars

workshops where bluegrass people can
discuss the opportunities and problems fac
and

industry and learn

ing our

for

leaders

in

all

of our field, along with three lunch
eon meals and a very special banquet.

aspects

See history made first hand when IBMA presents its
initial Awards Program on Thursday night, Sep
tember 27! For the first time ever, bluegrass music
will
the

have an awards presentation based on voting
nominees' peers and colleagues, the Individual

and Organizational

Members

of IBMA.

by

and tabulated

independent accounting firm. It will be a
moment that will live through time just like the first
bluegrass festival and the first IBMA Trade Show. The
first time only happens once: BE THERE!
by an

How can

it

be any

better than

897, you're sure to ask

if

you

were one of the more than 720 people who had the
time of their bluegrass lives at Owensboro
last year. Try this: The Exhibit Hall, which
sold out a month early in '89, has been
j
expanded to provide 100 booths without
moving

it

from the main section ot the Execu

tive Inn. Plus, it will feature all night, in-room
security. We've kept the Trade Show at four days
so as to eliminate all conflicts with the Fan Fest and to
present the seminars in more digestible form. While

maintaining the evening format for the talent showcases
on Tuesday and Wednesday, we've added the Awards Sho*
following the banquet on Thursday and retained the
three fantastic showcase luncheons! That also means
that 1990 attendees will have four meals to enjoy, in
addition to morning coffee and donuts in the Exhibit
Hall. Non-smokers will be happy that we've eliminated

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to examine the latest in bluegrass related
products and services, to put faces with those famil
iar telephone voices, to attend three luncheon
meals and a sumptuous banquet Thursday evening,
and to experience first hand the historic Awards
Show. You'll come away from Owensboro with a
wealth of ideas, information, contacts, and good
times.

business,

Why you need

to

be

Bluegrass 1990 and the IBMA Bluegrass Fan Fest.
Discounts of up to 35% will be made available to those
using American to attend either event. In cooperation
with Owensboro's Livingstone Travel, full informa
tion about how to obtain these rates, including a spe
cial 800 number which must be used for ordering, will
be

trade event,

a not to be squandered
opportunity to
display your products and services to the people who
make bluegrass music happen. The IBMA World of
Bluegrass 1990 Trade Show is where you can sell your
band, product, or service to the targeted market you

need to reach, while making vital new business con
tacts and matching faces with voices you've known

is an opportunity on a scale
never before possible for personal, face to face expo
sure of your bluegrass related business. Whether per
former, luthier, talent agent, promoter, magazine,
radio syndicator, instrument supplier, camping
equipment or RV dealer, record manufacturer, whole
saler, studio, or whatever kind of bluegrass related
business-- you need to have a booth at the IBMA
World of Bluegrass 1990. The low booth fees, which
include registration for the entire event, make it the

over the telephone. This

When:

of

available

by July

.1.

Accommodations: A block of rooms at western Ken
tucky's finest hotel, the Executive Inn Rivermont of
Owensboro, is being held for IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990 attendees. Participants and exhibitors
may reserve rooms by writing to The Executive Inn
Rivermont (One Executive Boulevard: Owensboro. KY
42301) or by calling 800-626-1936 (In Kentucky use
(800) 482-8480). For information about other lodging
in the Owensboro
area contact the Owensboro
Daviess County Tourist Commission at 502-926-1100.

Bluegrass
bluegrass music's finest

bluegrass advertising bargain

any event of similar

of

Exhibit: The IBMA World of

Show will

1990 Trade

to

Travel: American Airlines and American Eagle, now
serving both Owensboro and Evansville, IN, have
been selected the official airlines for the IBMA World

to discuss your problems with your peers, to
learn the best ways to conduct events and bluegrass

edge,

Owensboro, Kentucky, the home of the
International Bluegrass Music Association,
will be the center of the bluegrass music

any year.

Registration for attendees opens at 10:00 AM on
Tuesday. September 25. 1990. Exhibitors
can set up between 10:00 AM and

IBMA

2:00 PM on Tuesday, Sep
tember 25. Panels begin Tuesday
afternoon: show_

Bringing the Bluegrass

Community Together for
Bluegrass Homecoming!

cases Tuesday night.

a

INTERNATIONAL
BLUEGRASS MUSIC

ASSOCIATION

IBMA WORLD OF BLUEGRASS
326 Sai

nt El

izabeth Street

Owensboro,

KY

1990 TRADE SHOW

42301

502-684-9025

calendar because September 25-28, 1990 will be the time for you to take part in bluegrass history,
whether as exhibitor or attendee, at the IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990 Trade Show, where the bluegrass music
community comes home.
Mark your

THIS ADVERTISING

SUPPORTED BY OWENSBORO

by

Registration for participants is only
$95 ($130 after 8/24/90) for individuals and just $170
($210 after 8/24/90) for couples, and that includes
admission to the showcases. Exhibit Hall, the Awards
Show, and seminars, along with three lunches and a

for

Why you need

If

August 24. 1990!

Bluegrass Trade Show is the greatest bargain on
a program
of its scale and scope! If you compare

our 1990

Friday. September 28, 1990.

you are considering attending or exhibiting,
just call or write IBMA for more information.
Notice the lantastic savings available to those who act
How:

commitment

a

Awards Show happens on Thursday night.
27. Formal Trade Show activities conclude

at 1:30 PM on

the art trade

Bluegrass
1990 Trade Show!
at the First IBMA

The IBMA

to presenting a state ol
show, while keeping the fees at a level
bluegrass people can afford. As a result, the IBMA

IBMA has

for the
IBMA World of
History

the

in

non-smoking

panels ever presented

If

Be a part ot

Kentucky

DAVIESS COUNTY TOURIST COMMISSION

�GRIBBLE, LUSK, AND YORK:
RECORDING A BLACK TENNESSEE
STRIN GB AND
Robert

by

1946 and 1949, Stu Jamieson, Margot
Mayo, and others went south to record
traditional music and dance calls. The
In

following

is

Jamieson's

eyewitness account

of the recording of the Gribble, Lusk, and
York band
resulting in some of the very
few recordings of black string-band music.
On

the

released Rounder album,
Black Stringband Music, we

newly

Altamont

can hear wonderful examples of their fas
cinating and beautiful music. We are grate

Tennessee Folklore Society and to
Stu Jamieson for allowing us to reprint this
version of his account of a historic and

ful

to the

fortuitous recording session

ed.

In 1892,
my maternal grandfather,
William Wallace Simpson, fresh from

his

home

in

the

Cumberlands

of

Tennessee, inspired by the call to preach
the Gospel, carried his beloved Bible and
banjo across northern China. At the

farther reaches of remote Kansu Province,
on the Tibetan border, he found his

harvest and began bringing in the sheaves.
He used his banjo to gather crowds, in
the same way the wandering buskers and
medicine shows did back in rural
Tennessee, and then he preached to
them. His banjo and singing charmed
Han Chinese,
and

Salar and Hui Moslems,

Tibetans alike, and

lished

a

he

soon estab

thriving group of missions. He

met and married

a

Swedish missionary

lady, raised a family, and taught them the
old songs. My mother, born and raised
in a Moslem town, learned his songs and
hymns, and came to accompany him on
autoharp and portable folding organ.

She married a Scots Canadian missionary,
and had two sons, who were sung to by
both parents and grandfather.
We came to the States when I was still
a small
boy, and moved from place to

place

as

my father preached and raised
for the

mission.

late '30s
City, near

In the

money
we located in New York
mission headquarters, where my parents
felt we would get the best high school
education. By sheer luck I ran across
Margot Mayo's American Square Dance
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

S.

Jamieson

and joined. Margot, born in
but
of the Floyd County, Kentucky
exas,
Mayo clan, had a call to revive urban

Group,
T

interest in square dances, playparties,
and folk music. W ith her encouragement
I bought
a banjo in a hock shop for ten
and set out to sound like
bucks
Grandpa, for I had a call to do that.
During World War II I was stationed
at two army bases in the South for about
18 months. After a stint in combat in
Europe I was discharged just in time for
a
the Group's 1945 Christmas party
joyful reunion for all Margot's kids who
had survived. Margot had just gotten
discharged from the W ACs, and like me,
wasn't quite ready for a return to
humdrum civilian life. We agreed to
pool our mustering-out pay and go for

a

long collecting trip in Appalachia. Our
goals were rather novel at the time, and

gathered us some raised eyebrows and
we would not only clearly
catcalls
record the calls of square dance callers,
and note down their meanings, we would
record tunings and techniques of all the
instrumentalists we would meet. In those
days, the prevailing sentiment of most

"experts" was that a
hapless imitation violinist,
deficient in "proper" technique, and
tunings were a way of avoiding having to
learn fingerings in several keys. (What a
delightful revenge we had when informing
them, upon our return, that Rufus Crisp
had learned 18 different fingering patterns

classically-trained
fiddler was

a

to use for his 18

different tunings!) So

Margot bought a good laboratory re
cording lathe and had it put in a case to
render it portable (if anything that
weighed 95 pounds could be considered
portable). I bought a rugged '38 Olds
coupe and had the engine rebuilt by

Lindbergh's old mechanic. My cousin
Gartley got me in the RCA recording
studios where the engineers gave me
lessons on recording on a studio lathe.
Margot recruited Freyda Simon to act as

music transcriber, note taker, and general
assistant. We crammed everything into
the coupe and headed south.
After many weeks in the Smokies and

with the Mayo clan in East Kentucky,
where we struck gold with wonderful
recordings of Margot's cousin Rufus
Crisp, we turned south again. We headed
for my great-aunt Oneida Petit's place in
Campaign, T ennessee, in the Cumberlands
a station on the L&amp;N line.
Aunt Oneida was a high matriarch of

considerable Simpson clan, and had
recording local people in no time.
Somehow, with no telephone and no car,
the
us

she got word

out

and

sent us off to

various locations. One morning she
announced that we were to go to the
store down by the depot to record the

best square dance band in that part of the
state. The store, owned by a cousin, had
electricity; aside from the depot, the sole
exception to kerosene power. We felt
that we had enough dance band sides
already, and our meager store of blank

recording disks was down pretty low,
but we acquiesced meekly. One couldn't
hurt such a generous and helpful soul.
We discussed it privately later, deciding

to cut only one or two disks, and restrict
those to any unusual tunes.
Right after an early supper we hauled
our equipment down to the store. It was

long shed near the tracks, and looked as
though it had been built by the railroad
it had a longroofed
planked porch
along one wall. Inside, it had the usual
a

deep-shady,

late-day, slanting-sunlit

appearance of all country stores in that
long-gone time and place. No sign of
electric lights. I approached the man
behind the old wooden counter, con
scious of the stares of the loafers sitting
on coke boxes or standing around, and
introduced myself. He was dressed in the
ubiquitous uniform of that time and
grey
place for non-field workers
whipcord trousers and faded blue work
shirt. His handshake seemed reluctant
and cool, but then I was a stranger, even
and talked funny. He
if a cousin

showed me where
cord, so

I

hauled

to plug in my

extension

our equipment and
worked I heard him talking
in

it up. As I
to Margot and Freyda; he was grumbling
about the disruption we represented to

set

�routine and working hours.
took it he was dragooned into becoming
studio proprietor by Aunt
a recording
Oneida. chuckled to myself and ignored
the rest until that crackling, lightninghis normal

1

I

striking word "nigger" turned on all my
alarms, and stood the hair on the back of
my neck upright. It was a word that
always put the three of us into silence
neutral, tight-lipped silence. We were

intruders, in that sad, bad,
confused, anguished still-newly-defeated
Ol' South. We had met living ex-slaves
strangers,

confederate
and ex-slave-owners,
veterans, a lady whose first horse was
confiscated by Yankee soldiers. 1 knew
the family stories of my own great
grandfather who had ridden with Jeb
Stuart (but who had freed his slaves
before going). It was a place where
memories of battles, glories, defeats,
confiscations, occupations,

and

person in whom they took great pride,
who was entirely honest, upright and
trustworthy; gentle, kind, and loyal, who
was bound for heaven without doubt
yet where everyone else's favorite dark
person was greatly to be feared, and had

controlled

by dirty and

despicable

means beyond description, merely to
keep the lid on and keep the blood
thirsty savages at bay. We had read all
too many newspaper accounts of

mysterious whippings

lynchings,

and

deaths. Margot and I knew the South
firsthand from our Army days; we had
heard stories about colored and Yankeetalking GIs being arrested by country
sheriffs, put on chain gangs for hitch
hiking, and the like. Freyda, though not
familiar with the South, was not less
she had heard the bad
fearful than us
stories but was just beginning to meet the
good people and hear the other side. As
for me, in the midst of killing and
avoiding being killed, I had learned to
control unreasoning fear, to go on despite
but here, in my own land, among my
kind and kin, that word raised the same
chills that the sounds of ricochets and
"incoming mail" had in Europe. Margot
finally got him turned off by shopping
for a pack of cigarettes; making him
bring out every brand in turn, finally
choosing her usual. We went out and
huddled quietly on the porch, venting
our feelings with whispered army-style

curse-besprinkled talk.

It

had hit us all

at

recording artists appeared to
be colored. Had Aunt Oneida mentioned
once
it?

our

We

couldn't

recall.

I

ladies.
People came and went, more men than
so
women, and fewer went than came
we soon had a respectable group leaning
against the walls, sitting on the few
chairs, barrels, sacks, and bins. My cousin
came over to me, and asked about the
recording machine. I went on about how
we did things, about the need for absolute
silence once I started the recording. He
said he'd make sure of that, and I
thanked him. He suddenly stood and
went to the door, calling something like:
"C'mon in, boys, yew come in now."
He waved his hand towards the store's
innards and repeated his welcoming call,

beloved

dead were ever fresh and strong, even in
the hearts of those who were not yet
like all my living kin.
born at the time
It was a strange land where every white
person seemed to have a favorite dark

to be

strategies, and decided to keep things as
short and trouble-free as possible. We
crept inconspicuously back inside.
chickened out by squatting over the
equipment, leaving social congress to the

We talked

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dozens of fascinated
eyes focused on the
whirling disk, swung
to the dark figures
of the band, then
back.
and was answered by a stirring among
the onlookers and deep soft voices saying

things. Finally, three
figures entered, same uniforms on, but
softmore weathered, if possible
brimmed old fedora hats hiding faces
bent towards the floor. Dark hands
clutched musical instruments; the band
was indisputably "colored." The first
figure was solidly built, with a burly

indistinguishable

medium height; he
old factory-made banjo with a
time-browned skin head. A figure of
medium build held a cheap guitar; in the
rear a man with a slighter frame and
quicker movements than the other two

frame,

held

of just over

an

carried a good-looking fiddle.
"We're all ready fer yew; c'mon set
down," said my cousin, pushing forward
two upended coke boxes, then scurrying
to the rear of the store and returning
with a third. The black men moved
uncertainly into the center of the room,
into the pool of light thrown down by a
naked bulb under a coolie-hat shade
hanging on a long cord, and paused,

looked hesitatingly

at

us,

then bobbed

heads, hats shading their faces. I
found my tongue and said, "Howdy" and
introduced ourselves. They nodded again,

their

saying "evenin' suh," "Ma'am" and Miss
then sat on the small narrow ends of the
boxes. The onlookers fell silent, and we
could hear the store clock ticking faintly.

They took

a

long time tuning up;

as

they did I moved our one microphone in
front of the banjo picker, who was in the
middle, and asked the other two to move
so as to make a semicircle around the
microphone. I squatted over the lathe
and settled the heavy earphones over my
not one
ears, puzzling about their hats

other soul present was wearing a hat. I
worried for them, expecting a reprimand
about disrespect, and then it hit me

were not making themselves at
I recall thinking how surrealistic it
was; they were the point of the whole
affair, the guests of honor, as it were, but
were pretending they were not really
there.
they

home!

The fiddle began a rhythmic sawing,
still tuning, the guitar hit the same beat a
few strokes, then all lapsed into anarchical
tuning. This was repeated several times,
the banjo joining once or twice for a
couple beats, then the sound fell apart
again. As

I

write this

1

understand suddenly

there was no caller to start them going
with his lead-in call, like: "All join hands
and circle to the South, let a little

moonshine

in

without warning,

yore
it all

mouth."

Then,

came together and

there was music.

This was before the rise of bluegrass,
with its instruments taking turns on
solos; all bands played the melody in
strict unison. In America the fiddle had
come first, playing all alone for dances. It
concentrated on playing the tune, adding
sliding two-note "double-stop" sounds
of
and often intricate embroiderings
vocal-style decorations. The banjo joined
later, constrained by its right-hand
patterns to playing the strong melody
notes, hinting at the others with its off
beat clang chunk-a chords, rhythmically
reiterated thumb string notes, gratuitous
non-melodic notes filling in the spaces.
But it followed the melody, and stayed
with it; the melody was its guideline.
Later, when guitars joined in they used
bass note-chord patterns too, sometimes
playing a run of bass notes to change
from one chord to another, but they too
stayed strictly on the beat. In this tradition
the tune was the twin rails that led the
bands around the tracks; the crossties of
the beat were spaced evenly.
What we heard this time was so
different it was almost disorienting. The
fiddle did not always lead the melody,
but passed it to the banjo, like runners
passing the baton. Half the time the

melody was played by the banjo, the
fiddle moaning low rhythmic chords,

�bit ot
as

disappointment nanging

in tne air

people filed out, nodding and saying

to us on the

hushed and shy goodnights
way out as

at

a

soon.
In

my

lovely party ending

exuberance

and

all

too

gratitude

I

would
drive them home. There was immediate
silence, then rumbling demurring from
announced

the

to

band

that

I

I surely didn't have to do that,
they'd be alright, they'd be home in no
time, and the like. My cousin stood
stock still a few moments, his eyes wide
and his lips clenched. Then he beckoned
me over close and whispered fiercely in
my ear, "Folks 'round here don't do that,

the band:

courtesy

Charles

Wolfe

'tain't right." When

over and over. Suddenly, at the second
part of the tune, the fiddle would leap
into an upper octave, with a wild cry, and
take over the burden of the tune. The
banjo would then play a loose and free

polyphonic obligato around

a

rudi

mentary suggestion of the melody, ranging
far away melodically,
omitting strong

downbeats, dancing a different step
and this was most radical
rhythmically
of all for

not

banjo

downbeats

and

upbeats
sudden startling
Even when

gaps

the

hitting all the
there were

and

banjo

hesitations.

took

over

the

lower-octave half of the tune, and its
wildness was somewhat subdued by the
demands of melody, it produced a rolling
syncopation like a jazz beat. Down below
all, the guitar produced steady deep
heartbeats, like the throb of a great
engine in the bowels of a ship, laying
down the full chords that defined the
threshing floor upon which fiddle and
banjo leaped and soared.

We cut disk after disk, the band
becoming real professionals at it after we
had them start

tune, stop at a signal
from me, then resume the unheard but
perfectly-kept beat. The onlookers were
perfect; never an interruption or noise
while the cutting head was down on the
disk. All eyes focused on me as 1 started
every cut, as though I was part of some
strange act on stage in a night club. It was
with smoky air, a
a night club in a way
darkened room with stage lights, musi
cians, and enthusiastic applause. Margot
and Freyda sat near the pool of light,
staring at their notes; Margot's head
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

as

she squinted past the smoke

from the ubiquitous butt set at the edge
of a broad smile. Unlike any night club
I'd ever been in, the audience was
absolutely still during the acts; almost
breathless. I came to feel that all shared
my strong sense of satisfaction in every
good recording done; I could hear the
breaths let out each time 1 lifted the head
from the groove at the end. The pro
prietor opened the doors in between

recording, and people would go
outside for fresh air, and new faces
would crowd in. When I called that all
was ready, after checking with the band,
he closed the doors and called for silence
and there was instant silence. Dozens
of fascinated eyes focused on the whirling

each

disk, swung to the dark figures of the
band, then back. As I handed each
finished record to Freyda, Margot would
slap

a

temporary label on

it,

checking the

name of the tune carefully with the band
members. And what names, as different
"Smoke Behind the
as their tunes

Clouds," "Running Through the Whiteoaks," "Old Sage Friend," "Broke-Legged

Chicken," "Altamont"

(a nearby town).
"Rolling River," that
on like the mighty
Mississippi, and one that took us a long
time to realize was a version of the

And what tunes
rolled on and

"Tennessee Wagoner."
Shortly before ten, a very late hour tor
those who rose before cockcrow, Margot
spoke quietly to the band, who nodded
to her. She announced that we were
stopping for the night and would finish
up tomorrow evening. One could sense a

stub

a

niggers with razors alius raisin'
hell, and they'll catch you fer shore." I
didn't reply. "Hit's only three miles,

thereabouts, anyway."

take them at least an
take me long. Don't
I'll
in
the
car. Nobody's even
worry,
stay
hen that

hour!

cocked

maintained

young

T

John Lusk ca. 1960

I

born silence he went on, "besides, they
don't want any white folks pokin' 'round
in Dogtown; there's a lotta them mean

It

d

won't

gonna see me!"
"Hell, they'll know; they don't have
cars like yore's."
"I'm going; it's the least I can do."
He shook his head and I went back to

the band
they were gone. I rushed out
the door and found them just setting off
down the dirt road. Again they held
back, but 1 finally got them in the Olds
coupe. The guitarist and fiddler crouched
on the little jump seats in back, huddled
over and wrapped around their instru
ments; the more substantial banjo picker,
Murphy Gribble, sat in front with me.
There was silence as we started off, but I

broke

it by

asking directions

as we hit the

main highway.

In minutes a chorus of bass voices
called to me to slow down, then directed
me to stop at a little cabin on the left. It

the usual faded wooden share
croppers shack seen all over the South

was
a

box about

16

by 24,

set

on

four

knee-high corner posts, peaked tin roof
running fore-and-aft, little veranda across
the front. We all struggled out so the
fiddler could get out, and the guitar
player said he could just as easily walk
from here. I persuaded him back in, and
we drove another half-mile and let him
off at a similar house.
Soon afterwards, we turned off on a
dirt road, winding around between the
tall pines. After a few shacks passed by
we got onto a track through the sandy

soil; just two old wagon ruts smoothed
down by a recent rain, possibly that
evening. The heavy car pulled hard, but

smoothly, through

the

sparse

woods,

�passing a couple of shacks. Then, when
the lights picked out another, the deep
voice next to me softly suggested a stop.
As he got out, he thanked me profusely
as the others had, and said his goodnights.

The second recording session was a
repeat of the first, but with more on
lookers, and the band seemed more at
ease. They made sure they filled the disks
right up to the end; like Rufus Crisp
before them they made sure nothing of
the government disk was wasted. Unlike
Rufus, who had to import verses to
prolong a short song, all they had to do
was keep playing the same tune, eyes
fixed on the lathe, and stop when there
was a half inch left. When they misjudged
I
turned the volume down and faded
them out. When they couldn't think of
tunes, the audience prompted them, but
they finally ran out of their repertory.
Margot and then tried hard to get them
to record a "sukey jump," for they had
told us about playing for black occasions
such as kitchen dances, weddings, etc.,
when they played "sukey jumps" as well
as square dance tunes. They told us we
didn't want that old stuff, and declined
I

so

stubbornly

give

up.

Even

and
a

insistently
few

in

we had to

audience

the

joined in the pleading; again there was
keen disappointment when the session
ended.
On the road to Nashville a couple of
days later we got a jolt from the radio
that made me pull the car over to the
roadside and park half in the ditch. It was
a
string band with a fast-driving
syncopated sound wherein each in

strument took jazz-like solos. The banjo
had a syncopated sound, but all the beats
were there. We knew that from the
voices this band had to be white, but the
resemblance was uncanny
the same
mixed measures, but no brushes, and the
picker's left hand went all over the neck.
At a cafe juke box we heard them again,
and found out about Bill Monroe's new
country music sensations, the Blue Grass
Boys with Earl Scruggs. The bluegrass
era was just dawning.

Two-and-a-half years later

to go back to Campaign

at

I

decided

Easter break.

I

lights, and wash machine, and told me

that my arguments had convinced her it
was reasonably safe to have the stuff

around. When I told her we wanted to
record the band again, but this time I was
determined to drive them to and from,

she acceded and offered the use of her
house as recording studio. Somehow she
got the word out without leaving the
house, for she told us next morning the
band would be ready that evening.
I drove
alone, so as to have room in
the car. It was quite easy to find Albert
I merely
York's place
stopped at the
first cabin in Rocky Ford and asked. He
led me to John Lusk's cabin, in turn, and
the two guided me along the labyrinth of
trails to Murphy Gribble's place. They
did seem genuinely pleased to see me,
almost as much as I was to see them.
Because of the recordings their reputation
had increased and people hired them

from

all the

surrounding counties, both

cafe juke box
we heard them again,
and found out about
Bill Monroe's new
At

a

country music sen
sations, the Blue

Grass Boys with Earl
Scruggs. The bluegrass era was just

dawning.

melodic or harmonic relationship to the
fiddle's melody, but skipped around the
melody, following its trends up and
down

black and white. They looked about the
same, except that Murphy Gribble's eyes
were getting cloudy from cataracts, and
their faces a bit more lined.
Aunt Oneida invited them in cordially,
took their hats and seated them on

chairs,

brought

them lemonade

buttermilk. This time Bob

and
the

sleeping bags.

they

ran

recorder

and I did the interviewing.
When I told them that what was urgently
needed, for the sake of future scholars

said.

1

in

the most general way, with that

chopping, stop-and-start syncopated,

complex rhythmic tapestry he wove. (He
spoke of it as "broke-legged rhythm,"
later.) Then, when the low part came in,
the rhythm steadied to a repeated, less
free pattern, sending out the low portion
of the melody in what surely would be
if it
called a bluegrass-influenced style
weren't for its greater antiquity. When
he said it was the
old folks played, he claimed
absolutely no credit for originating any

questioned off-mike,
way the

thing. Modesty, or truth?
We got the others to do the same,

greatly encouraged by his success, and so
laid bare the bones of their musical
structure. They played the notes of their
instruments, to il'ustrate their tunings,
and told of the two keys in which they
played

the "high key," and the "flat

Only the banjo seemed to use
scordata [other than standard for the
instrument] tunings, and only two wellknown ones at that. Their antiquity is
key."

strongly suggested by the fact that their
pitch was at the old low frequency that
abounded before the advent of
diamond-drawn steel strings many decades

suggested they play

a

few

tunes and warm up first. They were
relieved at this postponement of disaster,
and launched into a series of the old
tunes
each preceded by a long retuning

a

modern banjoist's

Murphy Gribble's A
being
tuned down one and one-half tones; the
same with the ubiquitous G tuning,
which was detuned to E. When Gribble
came into Aunt Oneida's parlor, he
spotted my recent acquisition, a fancy #7
Whyte Laydie, and his eyes shone, so I
handed it to him. He wanted to use it for
the recording, and when
said "of
course," he tuned it down instantly.
C

and musicians, was their individual
separate sounds, they looked panicky.
They hadn't ever played alone since
Murphy came home from W orld W ar I,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gribble to fly solo first, and turned on
the wire recorder. There was a long, long
pause, then he said, "Alright, but I'm
gonna make a bobble of it," and he
picked a nervous series of notes at the
basic beat rhythm, then over 40 years of
habit took over and he knocked us flat
with his intricate polyphonic obligato to the
fiddle's lead in the high part of
"Altamont." It seemed to bear no direct

before; what would be

asked my fiancee', Gloria, to come along
and meet her future kin. We invited my
roommate, Bob Opdahl, who rounded
up a wire recorder, and his fiancee,
Viola, and we all crammed into my '33
Chevy four door and drove straight
through, except for a few hours on a
snowy Virginia mountainside in cold
Campaign had changed; Aunt Oneida
had permitted the power lines to cross
her place, and even had electricity in her
home. She showed us her radio, electric

session. Finally we prevailed on Murphy

was

I

Thus the G tuning became eBEF#b,
instead of the modern gDGBd. His other
tuning was lowered from the popular
gCGcd to eAEab.
W ith Aunt Oneida's warm hospitality,
our obvious enjoyment, everyone's relief
at the successful solos, even joy at a job
well done
they broke spontaneously
into a sukey jump, "C.C. Rider." Not the
well-known blues of the same name, it
had a similar melodic structure, but was
a

happier sound, to

a

saucy swing beat.

�We were fascinated, and asked for more,
but they seemed appalled and firmly
declined to play any more. I have often
wondered about it; was this a private

music to be kept from the prying whites?
Plantation songs and ditties, spirituals,
had all
jazz. blues, rhythm-and-blues,
been ruthlessly appropriated and
exploited and watered down by white

society; perhaps only the sukey jumps

were left to be kept pure for those who

loved them.
They're all gone now, and their music
with them
as a living tradition. Ever
since first finding them I have alerted

scholars and collectors

to

find

more;

must sadly conclude
the last handful of
survivors of a magnificent black musical
tradition that has gone forever. Except
for some licks reprocessed by Uncle
Dave Macon, and in these serendipitous
recordings, one cannot hear any examples
of what must be an old style rooted in the
yearning hearts of slaves, possibly as old
as the Republic. One cannot go anywhere
today, on the face of this earth, and hear
that music played by live musicians of
any color.* Another endangered musical
species has died, almost unnoticed. H
none ever have.
that they were

[This
"Gribble,

article

was exerpted from
Lusk and York: Recording a

Tennessee

Black

I

Stringband"

in

Vol.

of the Tennessee Folklore
Society Bulletin, summer, 1987, published
by the Tennessee Folklore Society,
LIII

No.

2

Middle Tennessee State

University,

Murfreesboro, 37132.]

In the

there was

summer '89 issue of the OTH
an

article on black string band

musicians Joe &lt;Sl Odell Thompson from
the North Carolina piedmont. Their

recent tape

on

Global

Village was

spring '90 issue of the
OTH. Their music is reminiscent of the
music discussed in the above article.

reviewed

in the

S. (Stu) Jamieson plays banjo and
teaching banjo and square dancing."
Jamieson worked as an electronics engineer

Robert

"loves

and retired in 1989. He and his family have
traveled extensively, and now that he is
retired

he

and his wife plan on living on

sailboat.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

�GRAYSON
Old-Time

Section with Illegible Text

(annual)
&amp;

COUNTY

Bluearass

FIDDLER'S
CONVENTION

Section with Illegible Text

ELK CREEK SCHOOL BALL PARK
5

Elk Creek, Virginia
PM SATURDAY, JUNE 30, 1990

PM FRIDAY, JUNE 29
4
ALWAYS HELD LAST WEEKEND

$2,100

IN

JUNE

CASH plus Rosettes

REGISTER TIL SHOW TIME Bands &amp; Individuals REFUND TO PERFORMERS
No Electrical Instruments Allowed
ALL AWARDS WILL BE MADE SATURDAY NIGHT
by the Elk Creek Volunteer Fire Department
Grayson V.F.W. Post No. 7726, Independence, VA.

Sponsored

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&amp;

�CLASSIFIED
will
The Old-Time Herald
accept
classified ads at the cost of .50 cents per
word, minimum $7.00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the
first of the month, 2 months prior to

publication.

Musical Instruments
INSTRUMENTS FOR SALE 1923 Vega
Regent original five string banjo, $650,
Guitars; 1975 Guild D-50 $675, 1938

L-37, 000 size black archtop
holes $500, LoPrinzi LR-50,
1956 Martin 2-15 mandolin
$650,
Fancy
$550, Cajun Accordion by Jumall $500,
Banjo Ukes $75-$100, Good Fiddle
bows $75-$200. And more, send SASE
for list. Bob Smakula, Smakula Fretted
Instruments, P.O. Box 882, Elkins, WV

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION
NEW-USED-VINTAGE guitars, banjos,

mandolins, archtops, wood &amp;c metal
body Dobros, Nationals. Mandolin
Brothers, 629 Forest Ave., Staten Island,
718NY 10310. FREE CATALOG
98 -3226. Call for no-charge evaluation
of your vintage fretted instruments.
1

Fiddle, banjo, guitar instruction, tunebooks, recordings, free catalogs, Captain
Fiddle, 4 Elm Court, Newmarket, NH

03857. 603-659-2658.

F

INSTRUCTIONAL BOOKS, VIDEOS,
CASSETTES,

discount

much

and

catalogs.

more.

Free

ELDERLY

INSTRUMENTS, 100 N. Washington,
POB 14210-BJ34, Lansing, MI. 48901
(517) 372-7890.
1

26241. 304-636-6710.

STELLING, MARTIN,
GIBSON, STIVER, GUILD, DEERING,
REITER, KENTUCKY, much more, in

FLATIRON,
stock now

at

the best prices. Free dis

count catalogs. ELDERLY INSTRU
MENTS 1100 N. Washington, POB
14210-BJ34, Lansing, MI 48901 (517)

Fiddler with FlattSIMS
team
(1949-52). Musical tapes,
Scruggs
video.
instructional books, &lt;Sl tapes
Free brochure. Benny Sims, 318 Swanee
Dr., Johnson City, TN 37601 (615)

BENNY

282-1219.

372-7890.

SQUARE DANCE CLASSICS: cassette
SUBSCRIBE

NOW

to

our

monthly

used and vintage instrument list with
hundreds of quality instruments at
down-to-earth prices. $4.00/ year ($8.00
overseas). Current issue free on request.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.
Washington, POB 14210-BJ34, Lansing,
MI

48901 (517) 372-7890.

BLUEGRASS &amp; OLD-TIME
INSTRUMENTS, new, used, vintage.
Free, friendly advice. All correspond

FINE

ence answered promptly and

919-383-5750.

in

depth.

S.A.S.E. brings
current listing. Subscriptions with extra
services $5.00. Harry &amp;. Jeanie West,
3815 Tremont Dr., Durham, North
Or,

45&lt;t

Carolina 27705.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with 10 complete old time singing calls
by Bob

with

Dalsemer plus 23 page booklet

instructions,

music,

chords.

"Alabama Jubilee," "Down Yonder," "Just
"
1 6 postpaid. T raditional
Because, etc.
Caller Productions, 3029 Guilford Ave.

Baltimore, MD 21218.

A

delightful

collection of 100 irresistable dance tunes

in Old-Time, Celtic, and New England
styles. Challenging tunes, Zesty music!!
Book: $12.95, Tape: $8.95, add $2.00
shipping; CA residents ad 6.25% tax.
Order from Daniel Engle, Box 123,

Upper Lake, CA 95485.

Books

Instruction

Gibson
with

TUNES FROM HOME

Tapes

THE MANDOCRUCIAN'S DIGEST
America's only MANDOLIN publication!

Interviews, instruction, reviews. All
$10/year (foreign
styles. Quarterly

Sample-$3.00. NILES
HOKKANEN, POBx 1935-H, Martinsburg, WV 25401.
$14.00).

COUNTRY MUSIC CLASSIC TAPES:
Old time string bands, bluegrass, gospel.
1920s- 1960s. Send $1.00 for catalog.
Joe Bussard, 6610 Cherry Hill Dr.,
Frederick, MD 21701.

Personals
CHURLISH,

insenitive,

financially in

secure SWM musician, 35 (looks 35)
160 lbs. seeks heiress (29-39) with severe
rescue tendencies and low-esteem, for
grumbling, sulking and crabbing

(alternate Thursdays only). My interests
include eating, sleeping and myself. No
personal growth/fitness/socially con

cerned types need apply. My sign is Stop
if yours is Yield. Write C/O the OLDTIME HERALD.

�Sales

County

H
□j
M
Pu

/TylBMK

T

INTERNATIONAL

BLUEGRASS

MUSIC

ASSOCIATION

NEW RELEASES
MASTERS OF TRADITIONAL MISSOURI FIDDLING Lovely 2-LP set with huge booklet
$15.00
VIRGINIA-CAROLINA SAMPLER Featuring Lonnie Austin, Jim Scancarelli, Wayne Henderson, etc
7.50
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BAN JO COLLECTION Super set of 1937 -46 field recordings by John Lomax..
7.50
CARTER FAMILY "Diamonds In The Rough" Lovely issue of 1941 Border Radio transcriptions
7.50
BLUE SKY BOYS "There'll Come ATime" Excellent reissue of early 1936 recordings
7.50
TOMMY JARRELL "Sail Away Ladies" One of his best LPs
7.50
great old time fiddle
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial and field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
8.00
FRENCH MITCHELL "First Fiddle" Fine fiddle LP by 71 year old West Virginian
$8.00
THE MUSIC NEVER DIES"AVandalia Sampler 1977
87" Lovely 2-LP set of West Virginia musicians
$15.00
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo/fiddle LP by this Kentucky musician
7.50
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Excellent reissue of their classic 1940s King sides
7.50

FC-007
*ROU-0237
*CCLP-0107

*BSR-1001

CO-756

AT- 103

UW

K

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
MEMBER OF

GREY- 101

KJ

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
READY FOR SHIPMENT

ELD-003
ELD-004
*JA-051
"CCS-110

GRAYSON &amp; WHITTER Lovely set of songs and ballads from 1927
30
RILEY PUCKETT "Waitin' For The Evening Mail" Great reissue of Puckett's 1930 s recordings
BLUE SKY BOYS "In Concert 1964" Super live concert from University of Illinois
UNCLE DAVE MACON "Hillbilly Blues
Vol 3" Fine reissue of early 1920s recordings
EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO With Tommy Magness, Roy Hall, Roanoke Entertainers, etc
PIONEERS OF CAJUN ACCORDION 1926
36 With Joe Falcon, Amade Ardoin, Amade Breaux, etc
CLAWHAMMER BANJO
Vol 2 Featuring Tommy Jarrell, Oscar Wright, Fred Cockerham, etc
CHARLIE POOLE &amp; THE NORTH CAROLINA RAMBLERS -Vol 3 Great old-time recordings
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
ECHOES OF THE OZARKS
Vol 2 Features Arkansas string bands of 1927
30

CO-411

"ROU-0236
OH- 184

'BRI-010
OT- 128

CO-717
CO-516
*CMF-011

CO-519
HER-063

A TRIBUTE

CO-786
CO-787

OH- 198

CO-511

*CO-506
MARLU-8901

CO-403
AH-002
OT-112

HER-070
*FF-415

FF-480

HER-067
*JA-055

\JA-056
CO-533

*CO-734
FF-468
MRDB-0105
*AJA-5058
*ROU-O122

CO-548

TO TOMMY JARRELL With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, Andy Cahan, Brad Leftwich, etc
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent field recordings with Clyde Troxell, Clyde Davenport, etc
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN More field recordings with Virgil Anderson, Dee Hicks, etc
GID TANNER &amp; HIS SKILLET L1CKERS "Early Classic String Bands" from 1934
recordings
MOUNTAIN BLUES Reissue with Sam McGee, JimmieTarlton, Dock Boggs, Doc Roberts, etc
SKILLET LICKERS Old-time tunes recorded form 1927 thru 1931 -Clayton McMichen, etc
LULU BELLE &amp; SCOTT Y "Tender Memories Recalled" From early 1950s radio shows
nice
ROANE COUNTY RAMBLERS Their complete recordings of 1928
29
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American Fiddle Music From Mississippi
with booklet
JIMMY TARLTON &amp; TOM DARBY Fine reissue of 1927
1932 recordings
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis, Roscoe Parish, w/booklet
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" Mike
Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
WALT MICHAEL &amp; COMPANY "Step Stone" Features hammered dulcimer, fiddle etc
GALAX INTERNATIONAL 2-LP set featuring Mike Fenton, Kazuhiro Inaba, etc
MORGAN SEXTON "Rock Dust" Traditional Appalachian ballads with banjo &amp; fiddle
RALPH BLIZARD &amp; THE NEW SOUTHERN RAMBLERS "Blizard Train" OT fiddle from Tennessee
ROUND THE HEART OF OLD GALAX
Vol
Featuring the music of Ernest Stoneman
BONNIE RUSSELL/RUSSELL FAMILY "Mountain Dulcimer
Galax Style" (Cassette only)
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" Recent old-time music by this West Virginia
group
MILL RUN DULCIMER BAND "You've Been A Friend To Me" Old-time, traditional, sentimental music
JIMMIE RODGERS "My Old Pal" Reissue of 18 songs from 1927
32 sessions
Import
NORMAN BLAKE/RISING FAWN STRING ENSEMBLE Featuring Nancy Blake, James Bryan
R1DIN' IN A OLD MODEL T Features Dixie Ramblers, Rector Trio,
Ray Brothers, etc

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
0.00
7.50
7.50
$12.50
1

7

by an

asterisk

50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

1

(Above albums available on cassette as noted

Ui

1

0

LJB

00

7.50
7.50

"

")

ICO-513
POSTAGE

&amp; HANDLING: USA ORDERS: Please add $2.00 for first
to 3 LPs, add $3.00 for 4 or more LPs
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Please add $5.00 postage and handling charges for up to 3 LPs,
then $1.50 for each additional LP. MINIMUM FOREIGN order is 2 items.
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

H

�Reviews

ALTAMONT:

rolling,

Black

Stringband

Rounder CD 02381
Frazier-banjo

&amp; vocal; Frank Patterson-fiddle

(1942).

Dan Tucker/Old

Cow Died/Bile Them Cabbage
Black Sheep/Eighth of January/
Corrinne/Texas Traveller

Down/Po

Murph Gribble-banjo;
guitar

John Lusk- fiddle; Albert York-

(1946/ 1949).

Rolling

as it

gets.

John Lusk was born in 1886 near Campaign, in

Music From
the Library
of Congress
Nathan

the pristine magic of banjo and fiddle sets

in and it's as good

River/Old

Sage

Blossom/Pateroller'll Catch
Sea/Cincinnati/ Altamont

Fri

Apple

You/ Across

The

This is the recording that finally convinced me to
purchase a CD player. Industry experts have
preached of the demise of LPs for years, but it
looks like it's finally coming to pass. Many "musthave" recordings seem to be released on CD (or
tape) only, no LPs. Sigh, I love LPs, and the liner
notes. To its credit, Rounder has made space in this

package for some excellent writing by Charles
Wolfe, whose essay on black old-time music
graced the OTH pages in fall '87- There is some
irony in this being my first CD purchase. Frazier &amp;.
Patterson were captured on a glass disk recorder by
John Work and the Lusk ensemble was recorded
by Margot Mayo, StuJamieson, et.al. on a portable
disk cutting machine and a wire recorder. There is a
lot (I mean "a lot") of surface noises, hiss, etc. Bob
Carlin, who produced this set, chose to let the
noise remain when it was within the same range as
the music so that little of the music would be lost.
Extensive equalization has been done. I am quite
used to the noise on 78s or on aluminum disks, but
other listeners may be repulsed by the sound
quality on this CD. I feel that it is well worth the
effort to try to listen to this incredible disk. Frank
Patterson was born near Nashville in about 1880
and learned his fiddling from older black musicians
in what his son termed a "breakdown style," not
blues. Nathan Frazier was a noted street musician
and singer who lived in Nashville at the time they
were recorded. He was known for banjo tricks
similar to Uncle Dave Macon's. His playing sounds
like a clawhammer style. On some selections his
instrument sounds fretless, although that could be
produced by noting with his fingernails and sliding,
a
technique sometimes used by Kyle Creed.
Patterson and Frazier are tuned considerably below
standard pitch, which gives the music a whole
different feel, and matches perfectly Frazier's low
growly voice. The program is nicely balanced
between relatively well-known pieces like "Dan
Tucker" and "Eighth of January" (reminiscent of a
version from Dr. Humphrey Bates' Possum
Hunters), and unique numbers like "Old Cow
Died" and "Po Black Sheep." Frazier's banjo work
is featured on "Bile Them Cabbage" and "Corrinne."
"Texas Traveller" appears to be a melding of
"Cumberland Gap"and "Dubuque' (I think it's
played in the key of "D"). There's a rough-hewn
quality about their playing, but when they get

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

south-central Tennessee. He played the fiddle that
had been his grandfather's, a slave who had been
sent to New Orleans to learn to play in the 1840s.
Albert York was Lusk's half brother. Gribble,
whom Wolfe speculates might have been older
than Lusk, was Lusk's brother-in-law. This family
band was known as the best dance band in their
region, a reputation this recording will only further
(see Robert Jamieson's article in this issue). Much
of their repertoire will be familiar to the student of
music originating in the Sequatchie Valley or
Cumberland Plateau. "Cincinnati" has been recorded by Blaine Smith (on the Pine Breeze label)
and "Old Sage Friend" (as "Old Sage Fields") and
"Apple Blossom" have been collected from Kentucky fiddler Jim Bowles. The Lusk band also
recorded many old-time standards like "Eighth of
January," "Across the Sea," "Billy in the Lowground," "Fire On the Mountain" (as "Sambo"),
and "Run Nigger Run" (as "Pateroller'll Catch
You"), not all heard here. But you've never heard
these tunes as this band played them. The banjo
(picked in an early three-finger style) and fiddle are
especially on "Rolling River,"
random pattern of parts. The rhythm is
rock-solid and pulses with energy while the fiddle
and banjo trade off melody and backup. All three
musicians feed off each other. The Lusk band, like
Frazier and Patterson, is tuned below pitch, which
is very much evident on what I feel is the best cut
on the disk, "Altamont," where the band plays
together, then the banjo plays the tune alone, then
the fiddle alone. The low notes make the earth
tremble beneath my feet. Lusk, Gribble, and York
have produced music that has moved me like no
other. I could get corny and say that it has changed
my life, but these three musicians have changed the
way I listen to and play old-time music. Perhaps
they'll do that for you. Many thanks must go out
for creating this recording. First, to John Work,
Margot Mayo, StuJamieson, and their helpers for
making the original recordings. Second, to Rounder
Records for releasing this and other fine vintage
material from the Library of Congress archives.
Third, to Charles Wofle for his research, scholarship, and writing. Finally, to Bob Carlin for his
vision in producing this. An old-time music fan
who loves archaic playing and can grasp the music
beyond the noise will own a treasure with this
recording. (Kerry Blech) Also available on cassette

amazingly

which has

and

LP.)

tight,

a

�Two of the originals on the album are mistakes.
"Things Are Funny" features Nancy on the singlerow accordion. Her artless performance on this
instrument

is in

striking contrast

to her

undoubted

skills with the mandolin and cello. The instrumental
melody of this piece is reminiscent of the Cajun
song "Chere Mom," but for anyone able to detect
the Cajun allusion the Blake piece seems quite
insipid in comparison. Also, unusually, the arrange
ment of this song is inept, with the accordion
masking Nancy's somewhat indistinct singing. The
solo 5-string fiddle piece, "Mahnuknuk," is wellplayed, for sure, but musically negligible, and its
insistent chromatic figure quickly becomes annoying.
The sound quality is excellent throughout; these
musicians have beautiful instruments and have
spared no pains to record them properly. The
balance is also well done, with a sufficient emphasis
on Nancy's leads while the other players come
through clearly too.
At its best this music is relaxed, spacious, and

played precisely and sensitively, if not
passionately. Fans of the Blakes, and aficionados of
new acoustic music in general, will probably be
very pleased with the album. Mandolin enthusiasts
will be attracted by Nancy Blake's crystal clear
playing of the instrument. Hard-core old-time nuts
may be less positive, depending on their attitude to
"pretty" music. (Allin Cottrell)
lucid,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�version (for the full purple version, the prurient
listener is pointed to Glenn's rendition on "Just
Something My Uncle Told Me," Rounder 0141).
"Punchin' the Dough" sings the praises of the
hands who feed the cowboys
"When you crawl
from your roll and the ground it is froze/ Who biles
the coffee that thaws out your nose?"
not as
macho a position but just as critical to the outfit; a
nice perspective. A 12-page booklet is enclosed
with photos and drawings by Glenn, with the lyrics
and song-notes. His anecdotes are very similar to
what you might hear Glenn utter at one of his
concerts. If you can't get enough of this man, look
for his book, "The Hell Bound Train," published
by the University of Illinois Press in 1974, or look
for his earlier albums, "The Hell Bound Train" on
Puritan and "Cowboy Songs" on Philo. I must say
that Glenn Ohrlin might not suit everyman's taste,
but he's the pork in my chile verde. (Kerry Blech)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�These two sets of Woody Guthrie's songs are
re-issues. Alan Lomax recorded Guthrie for the
Library of Congress in March, 1940. The recordings, in the same form as we have here, were issued
on three records by Elektra in the mid-1960s.
RCA Victor recorded Woody on April 26, 1940
and released six 78s in July, 1940. RCA issued
them (with two additional selections) on an LP in
1964. Somehow this important music went out-ofprint. Many books and articles chronicle Guthrie's
won't delve too deeply into it here, but I
life, so
will mention that he came out of the OklahomaTexas Dust Bowl during the Great Depression of
the 1930s and found himself a singing radio star in
California and later in New York. Woody had a
firm foundation in the traditional music of his
home area. He knew the songs and the dance tunes.
He performed some of these pieces and used many
of the old melodies as the starting point for his
compositions that illustrated the human condition
I

of the Depression. The "Dust Bowl Ballads" collec
tion is about as clear a picture as you'll find of that
era. He captured the heartbreak and the despair
and also found the faint glimmer of hope (as in
"Dust Can't Kill Me"). It was the embers of hope
that Woody hoped to fan into a prairie fire. He was
so moved by the film version of Steinbeck's "The
Grapes of Wrath" that he composed a tribute to it
"Tom Joad"
that told the entire plot. Woody
also tried to elevate the hero (to the Okie victims of
the Depression) and robber, Pretty Boy Floyd, to a
mythical Robin Hood status. Apparently Woody
didn't have much clout with the authorities as
Floyd was later gunned down in a Columbiana
County, Ohio farm pasture. Woody had a way
with words. This is shown quite clearly in his
conversations with Alan Lomax on the Library of

Congress set. He is in good voice on both records.
An unfortunate problem (as some might see it) is
the duplication of songs on these two releases.
Nine of the thirteen selections on Dust Bowl Ballads
can be found on the L. of C. collection. ("Worried
Man Blues" on the L. of C. set also was on the
Columbia River Collection," Rounder 1036, reviewed
in the winter '88/'89
OTH). To the die-hard
Guthrie fan, this poses no problem. That fan will
want to compare versions, for Woody ad-libbed
quite a lot. The curious might want to see how

Gutherie, constrained in a professional recording
studio (actually, it's hard to conceive of Woody
being constrained anywhere) stacks ups against the
more informal setting of the Department of Interior
studio, with Alan Lomax's prompting and a bottle.

Both sets are of high quality, showing Woody as
the singer and composer of legend. Those who
know him only as the inspiration for a couple of
generations of urban folk singers will be amazed at
how well he sings and plays guitar and harmonica
(one thing Bob Dylan did not learn from Guthrie).
In fact, Woody steps out on harmonica on three L.
of C. numbers, "Lost Train Blues," "Railroad
Blues," and "Beaumont Rag." I'd like to say that he
gave DeFord Bailey

a run for his money,
but that
stretching it a little. He was quite a
competent harmonica player, though. It astounds
me that Woody's pleasant (and culturally
important) music was unobtainable (for the most
part) for a while. These two sets, along with the

would

be

Columbia

River Collection,

towards
Blech)
way

correcting

have gone a long, long
that situation. (Kerry

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�which the words don't justity.
And so the tape goes, one inconsistency after
another. The cheerful banjo version of "Little
Birdie" is a relief after "Bluejacket." Mullin's style
is reminiscent
of Grandpa Jones
lots of fullness,
and then the tape reverts to a
ringing, and energy
discouraging "hokey folky" style with "Elmer and
the Bear."
It seems that this material might do better in a
live concert than on a tape. The Mullins follow
some precepts often used in arranging a concert set:
they vary their style and tempo, choose tunes of

different

natures, and use dramatic pauses and
tone of voice (as in "The Farmer's
Cursed Wife," where Deb Mullins imitates the
voice of the farmer, the Devil, all the little devils.
and the farmer's wife too). These techniques might
work well when a band has the audience firmly in
hand, but a listener coming at this tape cold might
find it unsettling that no consistent style or genre is
established.
One style that this tape would have done well to
represent more fully is Moon's Travis-style quitar
picking. His playing on "Wayfaring Stranger" and
"Nine Pound Hammer" has lots of life and spunk,
and he manages subtle variations without disturbing
the tunes' main structure. The strongest songs on
this tape are the straight-ahead duets, those
mentioned above, as well as "Who Will Sing,"
"Clinch Mountain Home," "Beautiful Life," and
"Sweetest Gift." Unfortunately, on several of
these, the harmony is mixed to be louder than the
melody, so that the overall sound is out of balance.
In general, this tape is plagued by production
problems. First, the list of songs on the insert is
neither complete nor in order, and though the
small print says to see the label for sequence, it's
more trouble than one wants to take to turn off the
changes

in

tape, take

it

out of the player, and read the label to

see the name of the song. The insert and label offer
very little information
they don't say who's
playing what instruments, or who wrote the songs
that were

obviously written, such

as "Bluejacket"
echo has been used for
dramatic effect, but instead of heightening the
drama it suggests that the performance can't speak
for itself. This echo problem is at its worst on "The
Girl I Left Behind," a soulful unaccompanied
version of "Maggie Walker Blues." The echo of one
line comes back to haunt the next, and there is also
some sort of mournful sound effect in the back
ground that probably is supposed to sound like
crickets, but instead sounds like the squeak of a
rubber bath toy. (Molly Tenenbaum)
To order: The Mullins Family, P.O. Box 35,
Drasco, AR 72530

and "Death W ind.

"

A lot of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�most

rhythmic support. "John Henry," "Chilly
Winds," and "Wild Bill Jones" were my favorites.
Greg has really grasped the essentials of the style he
plays and knows how to express himself in it. He

draws his bluesy double-stops out till just the right
moment and with just the right cocky inflection.

His bowing, tone
is dominant and in control.
quality, and use of dynamics are excellent. My least
favorite cut was probably "Fall On My Knees."
Here Greg's own limitations and the limitations of
this style, which sometimes sacrifices rhythmic
subtleties, were most apparent.
Greg models his vocal performance on Fred
Cockerham as well as his fiddling. As a fiddler,
Greg revels in the driving uptown swagger he found
He

Fred's fiddling. But while the connection to Fred
obvious, and the style pure, the music seems
honestly Greg. In his singing, Greg seems to imitate
rather than incorporate. He also has intonation
problems. These things combine to make his
singing less appealing than his fiddling. Riley
Baugus' harmonies are nicely sung, but only faintly
heard.
Considering the style employed by Greg, one
would expect a driving banjo such as that provided
by Kyle Creed (accompanying Fred on his 78s of
in
is

"Pretty Little Gal" and "Breaking Up Christmas")
Andy Cahan (backing up Ernest East). Ray
Chatfield on banjo performs very ably but does not
provide the rhythmic oompff of the afore
mentioned masters, nor does he sound like Fred
Cockerham. The banjo's weaknesses were probably
more noticeable because of the low volume level of
or

and guitar in the mix.
general, the mix could be improved. Although
tend to prefer traditional old-time music played
without the safety net of a bass, I have heard basses
put to good use, especially with the slicker style
employed here, and Barbara Poole is an excellent
bass player. But on this tape, the bass, along with a

the mandolin
In

I

liberal use of slapping, is ust too present. Likewise,
Riley Baugus is an excellent guitar player, but the
sound of his guitar is too absent. The mandolin of
Verlin Clifton, varies from too soft to about right.
When the mandolin is about right, as on "Fire on
the Mountain," the band sound is greatly enhanced.
it
By the way, Verlin chords his mandolin and uses
solely as a rhythm instrument. This fits well with
Greg's playing and is a good addition to the band.
Obviously, the overall sound of this tape can be
improved by adjusting the levels on your stereo or,
j

even better, listening to
deck which drastically

it

on

a

alters

car

stereo

the

or

other

bass/treble

dimension.
The recording levels, perhaps a lack of "jelling
time" for the band, and the unforgiving nature of
the recording studio combine to make this tape not
expected after hearing Greg live. It
quite what
lacks some of the excitement that he is capable of
generating in person. However, it is still a very fine
tape, a wonderful example of the "uptown" trad
itional sound, and, for those who haven't heard
him, an excellent opportunity to listen to a young
fir1r11#r who ic likelv rn hernme an imnortant force
in the old-time scene (Linda Higginbotham)
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�My biggest problem with this collection concerns
to originality. A sticker inside the book
states that no plagiarism is intended. I don't doubt
Daniel Engle's sincerity, and of course with this
number of tunes it is a large task to check them all
for excessive similarity with extant pieces. Noneits claim

theless, in any future editions he should temper his
claims with respect to "It's None of Your Damn
Business" and "Maggy in the Kitchen." The distinctive A parts of these pieces are virtually identical to
traditional fiddle tunes "Texas Quickstep" and J.
Scott Skinner's "Timour the Tartar" respectively.
"The Weary Traveller" sounds like a combination
of chunks of well known Irish reels, though I can't
name them offhand. Listeners familiar with
different dance music traditions might be able to
detect other examples. But my problem is not so
identifiable
the occasional
much "plagiarism"
as a pervasive sense of deja vu. New tunes
phrase

seeking a place in the repertoire surely have to
justify themselves with a certain distinctiveness.
On that criterion, it seems to me, this collection
falls short. (True, there are plenty of cases of crosssimilarity amongst traditional tunes, but that's a bit
different from putting out a book under your own
name and inviting people to spend money on it.)
The intended market for this book is presumably
made up of dance musicians (contra in particular).
Players who typically learn pieces from written
music, and who are looking for new tunes to spice
up their sets, may wish to give Daniel Engle's

repertoire a try. (And people more familiar than
myself with the existing printed collections will be
better able to tell when they are getting the real
and to steer clear of the pastiches.) For
such users of the book, the tape may be a useful
means of screening the tunes; one can easily tell

McCoy,

which might be interesting to follow up without
having to sight-read the whole collection. Note that
this is not, and is not intended to be, a tape that one
plays for listening pleasure; it is strictly an adjunct
to the book. The tunes are played well enough to
get a reasonable idea of each (although I wonder
why he doubled the tune on fiddle and mandolin,
when a single lead would have made the melodies
clearer.) But aside from the fact that each tune is
only played once there are some tuning problems
which render parts of the tape less than euphonious.

(Allin Cottrell)
To order: Daniel Engle,
Lake, CA 94385.

P.

O.

Box

123,

Upper

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Old

World

Violins, lnc.
Fine Violins, Violas and Cellos

handmade
by

in

our

nationally

workshop
known

European and American

makers-

Peter White
Kenneth B. Keppeler
Wladyslaw Stopka
New and used classical

&amp;

instruments
Inexpensive student
models
folk

Complete repair &amp; restora
(same-day service on

tion

bow rehairing available)

(505) 268-3885
305-A San Pedro NE
Albuquerque, NM 87108
Mon-Fri 9-6pm, Sat 10-4pm

0)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

j

�FORTUNES
Joel Mabus
Fossil 187 (lp)
Folk and old-time music.
To order: Fossil Records,
Lansing, Ml

Box 4754,

PO

East

48826-4754

JUST IN TIME
Beayer Creek Band

Butler Records BR 806 (lp)
Traditional bluegrass; seven original songs.
To order: Butler Records, 1086 Meandering Creek,
Uniontown, OH 44685.

DUSTY MILLER
Dusty Miller
June Appal JA0057 (lp)
Solid bluegrass with an up-to-date sound of the
soft-edge variety.
To order: June Appal, 306 Madison St., Whitesburg, KY

41858.

REMEMBERING MAMA
Dorothy Hess

Frontier Productions LP- 1205 (lp)
Mostly old-time familiar songs and one rare one.
With autoharp, guitar, and bass.
To order: Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box 278, Galax,
VA 24333.

BLUEGRASS ON THE

MOUNTAIN

Benny Sims &amp; E.C. Miller

Stereo 0089 (cassette)
Traditional bluegrass with fiddler Benny Sims,
banjoist E.C. Miller, and others.
To order: Benny Sims, 318 Swanee Dr., Johnson
City, TN 37643.

Fish Records,
1304 W.
Chicago, IL 60614 (312) 528-5455
Mastercard accepted).

Flying

WOUNDED HEARTS/MENDED
SOULS
The Foxfire Boys

Schubert,
(Visa &lt;Sc

Foxfire Records (cassette)
Fine singing and playing from this Georgia blue-

Artists and record companies
please
send records and tapes for review to The
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717. Do not send to individual reviewers.
Arhoolie Records, 10341

San Pablo Ave.,
Cerrito, CA 94530
County Records /County Sales, P.O. Box 191,
Floyd, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001 (Visa &amp;

El

Section with Illegible Text

grass band.
To order: Foxfire Records, Rabun Gap, GA 30568.

Mastercard accepted.)

Rounder Records/Roundup,

One

Camp

St.,

MA 02140 (617) 661-6308 (Visa &amp;
1-800-44-DISCS.
Mastercard accepted

Cambridge,

June Appal Recordings/ Appalshop 306 Madison
545-SHOP
St., Whitesburg, KY 41858 (1-800)
outside Ky. (606) 633-0108 in Ky. (Visa &amp;.
Mastercard accepted.)

Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box 278,
(703) 236-9249 (no credit cards.)
Flyin' Cloud Records, Rt.
NC 27025 (919) 427-3336.
Old Homestead

2,

Galax, VA 24333

Box 436, Madison,

Records, Box 100, Brighton,

MI

48116
Marimac Recordings, PO Box 447, Crown Point,
46307 (219) 769-6217.

IN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Uncle Harold

is

on vacation this

quarter at the Harmonic Convergence
Fiddlers Convention and will return in
the next issue. He hopes you are all
working hard on the answers to the
Trivia Quiz that was published in the last
two issues (the last installment will be

printed

in

the summer

OTH).

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

A VISIT from p. 8

drummer danced her first
and rejoined the circle.
once
again
step
The circle of buck dancers broke up
for a while. The pool game started again,
and Willie Earl and his cousin went back
the masterful

afternoon continued
alternation of gospel singing,
guitar playing, shooting pool, and buck
had hoped Junior Thomas
dancing.
would come by. He could have added his
bottle blowing to the afternoon's activity,
but that would have to wait until another
time. When the time came for me to
leave, the houseparty showed no signs of
to their guitars. The

on with this
I

abating.
that was

I

really didn't want to miss all
come later, but I knew I

to

would return.
And I have returned quite a few times.
Each visit is more comfortable than the
last. That first time I was reluctant to be
more than an observer, but now Willette
won't let me be there without dancing.
The children seem less shy, too, each
time I go back. But Algia Mae is always
the same Algia Mae. Each time I visit, 1
ask how she's doing. Each time her
answer comes back, "Like a peach ain't
never been picked."
Algia Mae's buck dancing can been seen
on the video

produced

by

documentary, "Talking Feet,"
Mike Seeger and Ruth Pershing.

The video is available from Flower Films,
10341 San Pablo Ave., El Cerrito CA
94530, or from Ruth Pershing, PO Box 252,

Saxapahaw NC 27340.
Algia Mae's music can be heard on
Eight-Hand Sets and Holy Steps, reviewed
in the winter '8g-'go OTH.
Ruth Pershing has been researching and
teaching southern flatfooting and buck
dancing for the past 10 years. She is currently
working toward her middle school teaching
certification in math and science, while
working at the Southern Folklife Collection
and WUNC Public Radio in Chapel Hill,

N.C.

�17th Annual

Brandywine
mountain
music

I

July 13, 14, 15

Galax Old Time Bands:

The Next Generation

Featuring

The Scotty East-Mac Snow Old Time Band
Kirk Sutphin, Kinney Rorrer and Bob Carlin
Greg Hooven and Backstep
Jody Stecher and Kate Brislin
Mike Seeger
Ralph Blizzard and the New Southern Ramblers
John Cohen
Mac Benford &amp; the Woodshed Allstars
featuring Pete Sutherland
Double Decker
The Legendary Dixie Hummingbirds
Three days of concerts, workshops &amp; dance. Friday dance featuring the Rural
Rhythm String Band with caller Pete LaBerge. Clogging/Flatfoot demonstration &amp;
instruction with the New Southern Ramblers plus a square dance on Saturday
afternoon 4:30 6:00 PM. Free camping in the rough; Music concessions; crafts;
food; acres of the finest old time musicians in the world!
Presented by the Brandywine Friends of Old Time Music, a non-profit organization
dedicated to preserving and presenting traditional American folk music. For more
information call (302) 475-3454 or write Box 3672, Greenville, DE 19807.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

convention

Pleasant View Stables
on Kirk Road

I
I

Fair Hill, Maryland

1

Tickets
Friday Dance 7:30-11:30

$6.00

Saturday Noon Midnight
Sunday 10:00 AM 5:00 PM
Weekend ticket
Camping &amp; parking free

29.00

13.00
12.00

Senior Citizens $3.00 per day discount
Children under 12 free
No advance ticket sales; 24 hour security
No pets or drugs; No alcohol in the stage area;
Motels available in nearby Newark, DE &amp;
Elkton, MD
Information: (302) 475-3454

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

XO

,L3

V.2

#4

�</text>
                  </elementText>
                </elementTextContainer>
              </element>
            </elementContainer>
          </elementSet>
        </elementSetContainer>
      </file>
    </fileContainer>
    <collection collectionId="65">
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="1">
          <name>Dublin Core</name>
          <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="50">
              <name>Title</name>
              <description>A name given to the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                  <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
            <element elementId="41">
              <name>Description</name>
              <description>An account of the resource</description>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                  <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </collection>
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12190">
                <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 2, Number 4 (Summer 1990)</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="49">
            <name>Subject</name>
            <description>The topic of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12191">
                <text>Old-time music</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12192">
                <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 2, Number 4 (May-July 1990)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Banjos in the Days of Compact DIscs,” by Mike Fitch&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Bobby McMillon: Blue Ridge Story Teller,” by Hilary Dirlam&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Fiddlin’ Arthur Smith, A Son Remembers,” by James Kennison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Gribble, Lusk, and York: Recording a Black Tennessee Stringband,” by Robert S. Jamieson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – A Visit,” by Ruth Pershing&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – ‘Rolling River’,” tablature by Carl Jones&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Bowing Workshop,” by Brad Leftwich&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Buying a Used Guitar,” by Bob Smakula&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="40">
            <name>Date</name>
            <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12193">
                <text>1990</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
    <tagContainer>
      <tag tagId="2159">
        <name>1990</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="999">
        <name>1990s</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="2299">
        <name>Arthur Smith</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5572">
        <name>Bob Smakula</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5568">
        <name>Bobby McMillon</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5464">
        <name>Brad Leftwich</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5559">
        <name>Carl Jones</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5476">
        <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5569">
        <name>James Kennison</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5567">
        <name>Mike Fitch</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="1417">
        <name>Old-Time Music</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5570">
        <name>Robert S. Jamieson</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5571">
        <name>Ruth Pershing</name>
      </tag>
      <tag tagId="5490">
        <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
      </tag>
    </tagContainer>
  </item>
</itemContainer>
