<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2507" public="1" featured="1" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2507?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:56:37+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3432">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/f8a1dbd5e3756bc39103c704c520e80a.pdf</src>
      <authentication>80ca1eaff48f1eaf465ef9a91c95f49d</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12111">
                  <text>$3.50

The OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Fall 1987

THE SLATE MOUNTAIN RAMBLERS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�NttTie mahs

I

ORIGINAL

MOUNTAIN MUSIC

703-728-3603--

--PHONE
BLUEGRA5S,

^1/N

FOLK, GOSPEL

AVAILABLE FOR:

&amp;

TRUCK SONGS

FESTIVALS.

GATHERINGS, HOMECOMINGS, REUNIONS

ETC.

GOOD CLEAN MUSICAL ENTERTAINMENT GUARANTEED
WE BUY

SELL

&amp;

BEST WISHES TO

TRADE QUAL ITY MUSICAL
AND SUPPLIES

INSTRUMENTS

ROUTE 100 NORTH

HiLLSVILLE, VA

THE OLD-TIME HERALD

24343

FROM

MUSICIANS!

THE OLD-TIME MUSICIANS
&amp; DANCERS

Send us your business card

OF SEATTLE

$30.00 we will print it as an ad in The
Old-Time Herald. Send cards with check or
money order to: The Old-Time Herald,
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333
For

JUNE APPAL RECORDINGS

Festivals!
Record Companies!
Instrument Makers!
Music Stores!
Others!
Get the word out!

Advertise in
THE OLD-TIME HERALD!

presents JA0051

WHOA MULE

by

LEE SEXTON

long-awaited premiere album by eastern Ken
tucky's finest master of the drop thumb banjo
the

Selections include

old-time solo versions of Cumberland Gap,
Shady Grove, Buck Creek, and Fox Chase, banjo with guitar and
bass on McCloud's Reel, Spinning Wheel, Eight more Miles to
Louisville, Lee Boy Blues, Nubbin Creek and more. Vocals on
John Henry and Whoa Mule, Whoa. Also, exciting double fiddle
work with long-time partner Marion Sumner on Caney Creek and
Grey Eagle.
Also

available from June Appal, recordings by Uncle Charlie
Osborne, I.D. Stamper, Dutch Cove String Band, Andrew Boarman, J. P. Fraley, Ralph Blizard, Ola Belie Reed, Lily May Ledford, Roan Mountain Hiiltoppers, David Holt, Jean Ritchie, and
the Metropolitan Blues All-k Stars, just to name a few!

Write

to The Old-Time Herald
P.O. Box 1362 for rate sheet.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

June Appal Recordings
Box 743

Whitesburg,

KY

41858

(606)633-0108

WRITE OR CALL FOR FREE CATALOG

�The OLD-TIME HERALD
Vol. 1 No. 1
Fall 1987

Published

by

The Old-Time Music Group
P.O. Box 1362
Galax, VA 24333

703-236-7808
Editor
Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Brad Leftwich

Linda Higginbotham
Hilary Dirlam

Bobby Patterson
Phil Jamison

No part of this magazine may be repro

duced

in any

mission

form without written per

from

the

publisher.

responsible for loss or non-return
unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
1987 The Old-Time Herald

The

Old-Time

Herald

is

Not
of

published

quarterly the first of August, November,
February, and May.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

LETTERS
The Old-Time Herald welcomes letters.
They should be typed or neatly written, and
signed. They may be edited and we will print
them according

I'm very anxious to see the Old-Time
Herald. I hope you will feature a lot of
our Asheville area musicians.

space available.

to

James Kennison
Swannanoa, NC

As people began to hear about The OldTime Herald, we began to get letters. Here
are a few:

While
Hartford's

I

was

Nashville

in

over
the final

this

past

at

John

weekend

touches to my latest
putting
album, he gave me a copy of your letter
to him
about the Old-Time Herald
magazine. So I'm writing to tell you I'm
for anyone or anything that will help
spread the word and get the attention of
people about old-time music. We sure
need all the help we can get, and I'd like
to be

a

subscriber to your magazine and
I can. Good luck

help out in any way that

with your magazine.

"The Banjo Man From Turkey Creek"
Elmer Bird, Hurricane, W.VA

Enclosed find $10.00 for a one year
subscription to the Old-Time Herald,
What other
old-time
music
good
publications, associations, or books can
you recommend to me?
Do
know the names and
you
addresses of persons who have any back

issues to sell of my old Cowboy Music
World
magazine that
formerly
published in the 1940s? I was known
then as Texas Frank.
I

I'm

also

trying

to

get

the

new

addresses of some of my old subscribers,
especially country &amp;t western radio
artists heard in the 1940s.
Keep up the good work!
Frank Karpinski

Flushing, NY

I'm

looking forward

to the

Old-Time

Herald!

Suggestion:

It

would

be great to have

a

"banjo camp." For example, 3, 5, or 7
days of nothing but classes/ workshops
for

banjo

players

with

opportunity
this as

a

I

go

a

great

concentrated
about promoting

to learn in

form. How would

experienced

What

teachers/players.

If any of our readers can help answer Mr.

Karpinski's questions, please write c/o the
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,
VA 24333.

a

Welcome

to the world of publishing.
forward
to your first issue. Best
Looking
of luck.

possible forum?

Don Summers
San Rafael, CA

Thanks for trying to establish a forum
that has great potential. Hats off to your
initiative in getting this underway!

The News

&amp;.

Lynchburg, VA

Best of luck with this endeavor. I look
forward to the first issue. Vive OldTime Herald!
Karen Philbeck

Rob Golan
Kittrell, NC

Great idea! I look forward to your
with
breath and
magazine
panting

frothing mouth.

Billy Cline
Daily Advance

Asheville, NC

It's a great idea, the time is right, and
we wish you great success. Hope your
magazine can be about people and music

while avoiding the superstar syndrome.

Pete &amp; Ellen Vigour

Armin Barnett
Seattle, WA

Crozet, VA

New magazine! Fine idea! Sign me up
a charter
subscription and let me
know if I can be of any sort of help.

Good luck in your efforts. Here's
hoping your venture has the success we

for

Hank Bradley

Seattle, WA

all

need if this music

is

going to fly.
Barb Shade
Batabia, OH

�THE SLATE MOUNTAIN RAMBLERS
by

Bill Mansfield

Barbara Poole,

Dan Williams

Richard Bowman

Alice Gerrard,

in
and Carroll Counties,
and Surry County, across the

Grayson

Virginia,
line in North Carolina, make up a small
portion of the Blue Ridge Mountains,
but this small portion has been a bastion
of traditional music for as long as
anyone can remember. The Slate
Mountain Ramblers hail from this

region and are proof that the traditional
old-time music for which the area is
famous is alive, well, and growing, for
they are a relatively young band and are
devoted to their music.
Consisting of Richard Bowman, Dan
Williams, Barbara Poole, and (most

Mansfield,

the

Slate

community function, the
members still get together to enjoy each
other's company and play music for
some

their own delight.
The band was ultimately the result of

Ray Chatfield's decision to move from
Colorado to Mount Airy, N.C. An
aspiring old-time banjo player, Ray

rightly figured that the best way to learn
old-time music was to live in an area
where it was part of the cultural
Mount
landscape. In the Galax, Va.
Airy region he was able to learn from the

old-timers in person and absorb some of
the atmosphere surrounding the music.
Ray did learn from and play with
these old masters, but longed to organize
a band
of his own and compete in the
fiddlers' conventions. Knowing of his
desire, Tommy Jarrell recommended
that Ray get in touch with Richard
Bowman, a fiddler from Ararat, Va. Ray
Dan
knew
Galax
guitarist
already
Williams as a result of the many music
sessions at Tommy's house, so with Dan
from
Slate
Buck
Stockton
and
Mountain providing the rhythm on the
guitar and bass respectively, Richard
playing the fiddle, and Ray the banjo,
the

Slate

playing
contests.
When

Mountain Ramblers began
fiddlers'
at
winning

and

Buck Stockton left to play
bluegrass gospel, Dan recruited Barbara
Poole ofLowgap, N.C. to play bass. Dan
and

about

Barbara
10

had

performed

years earlier

in

the

together
original

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gerrard

Bill

Ramblers are making music
that has been part of this region since it
was first settled. Formed five years ago,
the band has performed for square
dances, family reunions, local radio
shows, parties, concerts, and the many
fiddlers' conventions held in this part of
the country. Even when not playing for

Alice

recently)
Mountain

The Slate Mountain

Ramblers warming up

in

the Fries,

Va.,

YMCA (Old

Fries Theater) gym

Shady Mountain Ramblers. Richard,
too, was a "retired" musician, and the
three
of them really enjoyed this
renewed musical activity. The Slate
Mountain Ramblers became successful
contests and were soon in
at fiddlers'
house
demand
for
dances,
square
and
concerts.
parties,
After playing for four years, Ray Chatfield left the group to play with another
the
and
old-time
band,
remaining

members looked for a replacement.
After trying several different musicians,
they finally settled on Bill Mansfield,
who was living in Siloam, in southern
Surry County.
The Ramblers'
line-up
guitar, bass, and banjo is

combination

of
a

fiddle,

common

for string bands from this

ensemble plays in the
region.
driving, cohesive style that has come to
typify the so-called "Galax sound."
The

Though the Slate Mountain Ramblers
have their own unique "voice," the
sound of the band's old-time songs and
lively dance tunes can be compared to
the sound of their musical forebears: the
Shady Mountain Ramblers, the Pine
River Boys, and the Pine Ridge Boys and
Patsy (all of these bands have records
available on the Heritage label). As of
Mountain
the
Slate
this writing,
Ramblers can be heard on the 1985
record of the Galax Fiddlers' Convention.
The Slate Mountain Ramblers are a

music
of the active, ongoing
tradition of the Grayson-Carroll-Surry
County area; but the people that make
up this ensemble have not developed in
an isolated region, deprived of contact

part

mainstream

society. Barbara
to
admits
rock-and-roll;
liking
readily
both Dan and Richard enjoy country
and bluegrass music. Bill has eclectic
musical tastes, listening to everything
from classical music to rhythm-andblues. But when it comes to playing
music, the band members have chosen
music of their
to play the old-time
reainn.
They come from backgrounds where
making music was a family tradition,
of the band has
and each member
this musical
to
continue
chosen
actively
heritage. The use of traditional music in
the media has broadened their exposure
with

to it, but also reinforced their
to play the old-time music. The

decision

forces of

the folk revival have also influenced the
Slate Mountain Ramblers in varying
degrees, making them more aware of
their traditions and strengthening their
desire to learn.
In the following
section, the band

discuss

their
"musical
how
they came
biographies," describing
to play old-time music.

members

Richard Bowman
Richard
Va.

Bowman

There was music

was born in Ararat,
in

his

family, but

by

�the time Richard was born

to children),

the

(the youngest of
tradition was not an active

Though it was his cousin who got him
started playing old-time music, he had to
look outside the family to develop his
musical interests. Fortunately, Richard grew
up in an area where it was relatively easy to
one.

find traditional

musicians.
school, Richard worked with his
father on the family farm. Since he finished
While

in

Richcird has worked for
company near his home. With
school,

a

lumber

his wife
Barbara
and
their
daughter Marsha,
Richard lives on the Bowman family land in
Ararat.

weekend.

Tommy taught me a lot on the fiddle.
When
started playing
was used to

in straight, standard tuning. He
me
how to tune over in D and A. I
taught
had to learn to play over again! He would
sit down and show me the tunes. He'd
drag the bow slow, till I caught what he
was doing. Tommy wouldn't teach me

playing

one part of the tune

at

a

time. He'd play

second part. On and on, until could
follow him. Then he would play the tune
the

I

right and I'd keep up if I could. He had
lot of patience, and I mean a lot of it.

We

played

at

Blackberry

lot, and at Fancy Gap some, and
at
the
Hills ville VFW. We played a
up
lot on Sundays at family reunions.
Anybody that knew any of the band, if
they were having a reunion,, we'd always
go play. We went to the World's Fair
in Knoxville in 1984. We were there for
eieht davs.
I
learned a lot from the Pine River
Boys, I really did. But when Marsha

Ridge

I

I

a

came along,

a

a

I

quit playing for

a

year and

half.

Well, Ray Chatfield came here from
Colorado, and Tommy sent him up
here, and we got to playing. There was

Daddy played the banjo, and Mama
was the last
played the autoharp. But
kid in the family and he had quit playing
before I got old enough to listen. They
used to play a lot. Mama will play some
now if I get after her. But Daddy got to
where if he couldn't play perfect, he

and got him to play the guitar, and Buck
to play the bass. Buck lives
down at Slate Mountain and that's
where the name comes from. He got to
playing bluegrass gospel, so we got

I

wouldn't play

at all.

According

to

Stockton

Barbara Poole to play bass with us. We
still kept the name.

every

one around that used to hear him, he
used to play a lot.

to play at fiddlers' conventions,
I love
but it's always the trip home that gets
bothersome. I don't like to be put up on
the stage to play to people. I'd rather

I
worked in a saw mill during the
daytime and would coon-hunt at night.
Well, Jack Burns, my second cousin,
really got me involved with it. We coonhunted a whole lot and what time we
he picked the
weren't coon-hunting,
guitar. Jack played more old-time music

Alice

Gerrard

than he did anything and, well, I got to
where I liked the sound of old-time
music better. He had an autoharp that
none of them played, and would mess
with it some. I played hymns and slow
tunes till I got to where I could play
I

something.

I was
about 20 when I started fooling
with the fiddle. The first fiddle I ever had
my hands on was the one 1 learned to

from Cousin Jack. I learned
the fiddle the hard way, one note at a
time. I didn't know how to tune or any
thing, and J ack lost lots of sleep try ing to
get me to learn to play a few tunes. Then
I
got to listening to albums and learned
to play a little. When I got to where
could play a few tunes on the fiddle, then
when I wasn't playing with Jack would
beg Mama to play, and she would get the
autoharp out and play some. learned a
few tunes from her.
What really got me started was
Tommy Jarrell's birthday party. He
went over to the radio station WPAQ)
play.

I

got

it

I

I

I

and

played

there

that

number-one

day.

He

was

a

fiddler and a number-one
fellow on top of that. The way he played,
no one can play like that any more. I
used to go down to Tommy's and
he would sit and play and fool with me a
lot. Sometimes we would just sit and
talk,

not play

a

tune.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

fiddlers' convention coming up, and he
asked me if I wanted to go. Ray saw Dan

Richard Bowman

I

I

I

fine banjo player.)

We went on several trips. We played
the

summer.

square

In

dance

conventions during

winter we were playing

somewhere

a

different sound. It's

person that's playing.

I

think it's

they play and the way they
learned to play that makes a difference. I

we played at was in Stuart, Va. We went
down there and won third place. Then
got to playing with Dea and Melvin
Felts, in the Blue Sky Ramblers. Dea and
Melvin played the fiddle and banjo. We
played around at contests for a couple of
years. Then I got to playing with the Pine
River Boys.
I
played with the Pine River Boys
about four years, and I learned a lot from
them. Abe Horton was the banjo player
all the time
was playing with them, but
we'd switch around a little bit. Every
once in a while I'd get tired of playing the
fiddle or get aggravated trying to tune,
and I'd hand the fiddle to Abe. I would
let him fiddle and I would hold his banjo
and
make
out like
was playing.
Actually, Richard is a
(Editor's note

of the fiddlers'

Everybody's got
in the

the

1987

I played
with Cousin Jack for four or
five years. The first fiddlers' convention

all

play where the people can get around
you. I'd love to be sitting out some
where with the people around, maybe
two or three dancing. I enjoy that more
and it looks like the people enjoy it
more.

a

every

way

don't think it has anything to do with
where you are from.
For one thing,

you've got to hear the

music. If the fiddle is over everything
else, that's all you're going to hear. If
you're listening to a band and you can't
hear the banjo, then he'd just as well not
be there. You have to work together to
get the sound, because if you can't hear
it ain't there.
You got to be serious with your music
when you're playing, but you can't be
too serious. If you've got a good person
ality, plenty to eat, and are out to have a
if you can play at all, your
big time
music will be good.

it,

Dan Williams
Dan

Williams

was

born

in

1934

Alleghany County, N.C. At an early age

in

he

and his family moved to a farm near Piper's
Gap, Va. Dan and his wife, F aye, have
moved around the Grayson-Carroll County
area, finally settling in Piper's Gap close to
where he grew up. They have one married
daughter, Dede. Currently Dan works as a
bank courier.

�interested

Dan's aunts and uncle on his mother's
side were musical, playing the dulcimer or
guitar, but the most significant musical
influence of his early years came from out
side of his family. Dan has experience with
country and bluegrass music and enjoys

playing both kinds,

in it. If

could do

she could do it, then

Shady Mountain Ramblers first
record, Heritage 002.) That was just
about an every-weekend thing. We had
four square dances going: one week in
Sparta, one at Lowgap, one at the
Fairview Ruritan Club and one at
the

I

it.

18 when she showed me
chords on it. She would tell me
when to change from one chord to
another to make it sound right. She
would holler, "Change! Change!" as the
ballad or whatever I was singing would
change.
1
tried to follow a lot of tunes by
Charlie Monroe and a whole lot by the
Carter Family. We listened to a lot of
radio back then. There wasn't any TV.
They had some music from Waterloo,
Iowa; Del Rio, Texas; that barn dance

was about

I

three

but prefers to play old-

time music.

couldn't even play the radio,
but my mom,
can remember her
playing the dulcimer. She could play
"The Wildwood Flower," "The Johnson
My dad

1

Boys," and she had one that she called
"Little Mohee." They were all simple
tunes. At night, if she wasn't too tired,
she'd pick a little. When you live on a
farm and are raising a bunch of kids, you
don't have too much time for music.
This retired school teacher, a man
named Omar C. Cox, used to teach in
the White Top area of Grayson County,
O.C., we called him, had a large farm,
and he decided that he wanted to be
close to his farm, but he didn't want to
live by himself (he didn't have any
family). And he asked Daddy if he could
board with us.

that

they

have

in

Wheeling,

Hillsville.
At the square dance they really liked
music and that's what we

old-time

played. The majority of your bluegrass
pickers will tell you that people can't
round and square dance to bluegrass.

They've got to have the old-time beat for
people to dance to.
Now, you can't play a square dance

West

and

Virginia; and the Grand Ole Opry.
So I started with Talmadge Smith
playing the fiddle and he said, "I'll teach
you a little bit of different tunes on the
guitar." Talmadge taught me quite a bit.
We got to playing with Charles Hawks.
Charles played the bluegrass banjo, and
we were making music! You'd call it
bluegrass. I played a little bit with James
Lindsey's band, the Mountain Ramblers,
was never a
at square
dances, but
member, just kind of a fill-in.
After I got married,
the
music

a

fiddlers' convention too. Y ou have
to go to the other. We

to give up one

have

played

early

convention, then gone
and

then come

convention
But

that's

back

at

a

to play
to the

fiddlers'

dance,
fiddlers'

a

to see if we'd won anything.

pretty

after seven years
quit.

I

nerve-wracking.

just got tired of

it

So
and

Dan was not completely idle after his
second musical retirement. He played music
"
with different musicians just for fun."

I

Me and Tommy (Jarrell
ed.) and
ed.) played some at
(Creed
different places. I thought the world of
both of them; Luther Davis and Fred
Cockerham, too. I loved to play with
them because they were true old-time
Kyle

musicians.

This younger generation, they were
born and raised with the rock group and

that's what they are interested in. A lot
of what they call old-time music is cut
up and jumbled up. The tune is not
turned like it's supposed to be. They
don't play it on out in the melody; it's
cut short. They have found a different
technique. It's kind of hard to explain.
But some younger musicians have really
picked up the old-time tunes and have

Alice

Gerrard

really played them. My nephews, James
and Joey, are in their 20s and they are

Dan Williams

the fiddle, the banjo, and
guitar. That's where my sister
learned to play the guitar. He would take
his banjo and tell my sister when she
was supposed to change chords. And she
picked it up, just like that.
I
got to listening to him and her, just
the banjo and the guitar, and I was
the
house
forever
around
going
humming what had heard them playing
He played

some

I

the

night

before.

That's

where

I

got

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1987

stopped. went 10 years and didn't play
nothing with nobody. Then Whit
Sizemore came and asked me if I'd play
I

the

guitar

with

him

as

a

fill-in.

So

hanging
good.

on

to

old-time

music

pretty

I'm very finicky about my music.
You take a good, strong fiddle, with a
good banjo right behind him mocking
that fiddle, and then good drive on the
guitar, making some good runs too; the
guitar carries the time and the basscarries the rhythm. That's good old-time

music.

I

played one square dance with Whit at
the Fairview Ruritan Club, and after
played that one dance the other guitar
player quit. So I played with Whit and
the
Mountain
his
band,
Shady
Ramblers, for seven years. (Editor's
Dan played guitar and sang on
note

I

Barabara Poole
Barbara Poole is part of the musical
Edmonds Family of Galax, Va. Her grand
father, Norman Edmonds, recorded two
classics of old-time music back in 192 7
("Black-Eyed Susie" and "Train on the
Island," both reissued on County 535). Both

�Uncle Wade was known for the Buck
Mountain Band. That's what we were

of her parents played, and her younger
brother Jimmy was a child prodigy, playing
the fiddle by age five. W ith such a musical
household, Barbara could not help but play
music. Her parents urged her to take up a

then. I played with them about
seven or eight years, I reckon, mostly on
back

Saturdays

Mark

Sanderford

and folk festivals with her grandfather and
as part of Wade Ward's Buck Mountain
Band.
Barbara and her husband Ronald live in
L owgap,
N.C. with their three children:
Ronnie, Sharon, and Jimmy Dean.

Norman Edmonds
I

learned how to square dance before

ever learned how to play.

was fun. My

It

remember
family would help me.
the
"Chase
the
Eight,"
learning
"Figure
Squirrel," and the "Paul Jones." "The
Golden Gate" was my favorite. The kids
would have their circle and they would
dance and the grownups would have
I

theirs.

Daddy always wanted us kids to learn
instruments and they always had
them around. I tried to play the guitar,
the mandolin, and others.
I was
playing before got out of high
school, probably about 15 or 16 years
old. "Uncle" Wade Ward was the one
that coaxed me into it. Jimmy was
already playing with him and Uncle
Wade wanted me to play the bass.
Daddy already had a bass, and Uncle
Wade kept coaxing me to play, so Mama
started working with me. Daddy helped
me, too. He showed me the chords, and
if I got out of rhythm, he'd look at me
hard. Mama started me out, helping me
with some of the slow ones
maybe
"Little Brown Jug"
something slow,
till I could get my rhythm. I'd watch
Mama; she'd play real slow, and when
she'd change, then I'd change. We
played "John Hardy" till I wore it out. I'd
watch Mama change, till
got to
changing on my own.
Growing up playing with Uncle W ade
was really special. It was just like a picnic
all the time. He was all the time making
me laugh. When he talked about food, it
would make your mouth water. He was
all the time talking about going some
where and eating cornbread.
He had two black derbies. He'd wear
one and make me wear the other one and
the

Alice

Gerrard

I

with

youngest

Dean

son,

Jimmy

1987

There were fiddlers on the Edmonds
side as far back as anyone can remember.
Jimmy just always had it. Daddy, he
plays, but not like Jimmy or Grandpa.
From what I understand, my greatgrandpa played the fiddle, so it's come
down.
I
remember when I was little, Mama
would go play with Grandpa at fiddlers'
conventions and was too little to go.
I

I

remember

Grandpa
playing "Black"Golden
Susie,"
Eyed
Slippers," "Sweet
Little

Julie,"

"Ship

in

the

Clouds,"

"Hawks and Eagles," and "Fortune." I
grew up on "Fortune." Those are the
tunes
think of when I think of
Grandpa.
Anytime someone would ask him to
play, he'd play. For square dances, as
long as anyone would dance, Grandpa
would play. It used to tickle me, as long
I

anybody was picking up their feet, he
wouldn't quit. He played for the
as

fiddlers' convention
wasn't able to.

at

Galax

till

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

he

I

looked pathetic

in it. I'd try to forget it
home, but he'd never let
him
had
and
a
special
He
never
my
relationship.
forgot
birthday. He was one of a kind.
I

and leave
me.
Me

it at

I

Parsons'

for

We'd

Auction

out

anywhere.
Played every Saturday when there was a
sale. We played at fiddlers' conventions,
and if somebody wanted us to play for a
square dance or at people's homes, we
would. Sometimes someone would call
up and just want the Edmonds famiy and
we'd go play, like the Christmas party at
the Moose Lodge in Galax. It was just
and Mama and
me, Jimmy,
Patsy,
We
would
Daddy.
play around the
house, too. But now you can't hardly get
us together any more, and I miss it.
I
saw Whit Sizemore one day (after
Wade Ward's death), and he had started
playing for square dances at Fairview. I
wasn't playing very much and he said
they needed someone to play the bass
with them. I went over there one night
and just started playing the bass with
them. I played with them for about a
year, but after got married and Ronald
started driving a truck, I just didn't have
time for it anymore. Audine Lineberry
took my place.
After I quit Whit I didn't play much
anymore for about 10 years. But I went
to a fiddlers' convention one night and
Dan, Richard, and Ray were standing in
line and I started talking with Dan. Their
bass player didn't show up and they

Company.

musical instrument, and the activities of her
family introduced her to such well-known
old-time musicians as Wade Ward, Glenn
and
Charlie Higgins.
Barbara
Smith,
at
conventions
performed
many fiddlers'

go

I

asked

me if

wouldn't

I

be

interested

in

playing the bass with them. Well, I
could play
didn't even know if
I

anymore

or not.

I

had to

borrow

a

bass,

The next week at the
Vaughan School Fiddlers' Convention
we won first, and I knew playing bass is
where I wanted to be.
like music you
In old-time music,
can dance to. I like a sound where it's
and

we

won!

I

your feet still. A good
bass
that can blend in good
backup,
with a guitar, then you've got a good
foundation that's hard to beat. And then
when the fiddle and banjo blend right in
hard

to

keep

a

unique sound. I love to
music when it's played
sort of peppy and it's got good musicians
listen to Tommy
behind it. When
and
Creed
it's hard to
Kyle
Jarrell
there,

hear

that's

a

old-time

I

beat the sound that Tommy and Kyle
had.
If our generation doesn't keep oldtime music, it will eventually fade out,
and that'd be a shame. It's too special to
just die. I've heard some get out and sort
of mutilate it, and that breaks my heart.
It hurts me to see how they have messed
up the old-time music; it takes away
from it, to me. They think they are

�They sang songs like "The Preacher and
the Bear," "Black-Eyed Daisy," "Little
Brown Jug," "Red Wing," "Old Dan
Tucker," and things like that. They
probably developed my musical tastes.
all kinds of music growing up
I heard
in Raleigh. When I was about four or
five my parents took me to a Jerry Lee
Lewis concert. fell asleep. reckon that
I

I

indication of my interests.

was an

didn't really take an active interest in
music until I was 1 1 or 12. Ma took us to
see a western and in the sound track of
the movie, somebody was playing a jews'
asked, "What's that?" and she
harp.
explained what it was. Then she told us
that she used to play one when she was a
little girl.
Well, the next day my younger
brother went out and got one and Ma
showed us how to play it. He never
did.
learned to play it, but
About the same time, I discovered the
"Flatt
and
Scruggs TV Show" on
Saturday afternoons. I spent a lot of time
trying to play along on the jews' harp
I

I

I

with Lester and Earl.
I

didn't know anything about music,

but really liked the idea of being able to
make my own.
mean, listened to the
radio and enjoyed rock-and-roll, but I
never felt like that was real music. It
seemed to me that they were putting on,
acting, not really being themselves. And
the music on the radio changed all the
time. There was a new Top Ten every
week. The music that my mother and
I

Mark

Sanderford

I

L-R: Wade Ward,
The Buck Mountain Band
Frances Edmonds, fiddle-Jimmy Edmonds.

playing old-time music and in their way,
I
guess they are. But a lot of it is too fast
to dance to, or with singing, too slow.
It's not old-time, the way I grew up with
love fiddlers' conventions. love the
and
night atmosphere,
people are
gathering around you and you know
you're sounding good. For me, it's just
like being on a high, when you know you
are sounding good and everybody is
when they get out there
tickled

helped develop his preference for old-time

I

time.
and
having a good
dancing
I
the
older
love
to
see
Especially
people.
an old person have a good time. You
know they are the ones that handed it

down to us.

'

music. Mansfield has been more affected by
revival than the other
the folk music
members of the band. It was to the revival
that he turned to find out more about
traditional music when he had exhausted his
sources at home.

Bill Mansfield

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

grandfather sang was more constant.
When I heard Flatt and Scruggs play
"
"Old Dan Tucker or "Going Down the
Road Feeling Bad," some of the music I
heard at home, it just struck something
in me. It made more sense.
My oldest brother came down home
from college with a harmonica. Well,
thought of all those stories about

I

in
the
kitchen,
sitting
singing, patting his foot, and playing the

Grandaddy

harmonica, and

I'm the
the band.

closest thing to

a

foreigner

in

They

Barbara's, Dan's, or Richard's.
the
father
mother's
played

My

but

decided to learn to play

high school some people found out
could play the jews' harp and the
mouth harp and asked me if would be
interested in joining their band. I
thought it would be like the Foggy
Mountain Boys and so I said, "Sure!"
But it turned out to be an old-time
band. Jim Collier, the organizer of the
In

were all born right
around Galax and have lived here all of
their lives. Their musical roots are a lot
deeper than mine, too. Old-time music
was in my family but not as intense as it

harmonica,

I

it.

that

is in

Bill Mansfield, the newest and youngest
member of the Slate Mountain Ramblers
was born and raised in Raleigh, N.C. At an
early age, Bill started learning songs and
tunes from his mother and grandfather, who

Poole,

were from rural Chatham County, N.C.
homemade
music
introduction
to
This

it.
I

Barbara Edmonds

I

I

don't

recollections of him playing.

have
I

many

know he

played "Golden Slippers," "Swing Low,
Sweet Chariot," and "I'm Going Down
the Road Feeling Bad." But mostly I
remember him and my mother singing.

I

I

band, played knock-down-style banjo,
and that was the first time I'd ever seen a
banjo up close. The sound really excited
me and I spent a lot of time at Collier's

house listening to him play. Jim also
introduced me to recordings by Doc
Watson,
George Pegram, Roscoe
Holcomb, and people like that.

�decided to learn the banjo. So got a
banjo and an Earl Scruggs

of banjo playing, and returned
of times to visit with Surry

instruction book, and tried to learn to

musicians

had to take my banjo
play.
over to Jim's house to get him to tune it
for me. I'd try to play it till I knocked it

East, and Benton Flippen.
In 1979 I was lucky enough

to get

Cockerham.

quit my

I

I

cheap

was awful.

I

I

Earnest

Tommy,

Fred,

couple
County

a

grant from the National Endowment for
the Arts to study banjo with Fred

out of tune, then take it back. I couldn't
play Scruggs style and I couldn't even
make noise trying to frail, but I kept
wrestling with it.

was so excited

I

I

job and spent about six months traveling
up to Fred's trying to "catch his tunes,"

Jim went off to college

as he

at Appalachian
Boone. While he was up there
he got up with Arnold Watson, an oldtime two-finger banjo player who is also
older
brother.
Watson's
Doc
Jim
introduced me to Arnold and his banjo
really like Arnold's playing
playing.
could make music
and discovered that
style, and
playing finger-and-thumb

State,

a

would say. Jim Collier and Barry

Poss did much to get me started on the
banjo, but it was Fred who really taught
me to play.
wnen tne grant ran out, i needed to
get a job, but instead of going to work,
went to back to school.
got a student
workship that enabled me to start

in

I

I

I

I

working towards my master's degree in
folklore at U.N.C. Studying folklore
broadened my appreciation of
traditional cultures. It has helped me to
better to understand the culture that I'm

lot of time doing it.
spent
About two years later, in 1973, got a
summer job working on a ferry boat. It
turned out to be in the middle of
nowhere, so I spent all my spare time in
the bunk house playing the banjo and
a

1

part of and

culture
After

got to where

I
could frail.
around
for a couple of years
played
and in 1975 went to the Union Grove
ran into
Fiddlers' Convention. There
im Collier, and once again he helped me
J
out. He was playing fiddle with Barry

in

proud of the rural
North Carolina.
to

Luther Davis of Galax, Va.

be

by

from

a

Willard Gayheart
photo by Alice Gerrard

finished graduate school, got
working with North Carolina's
worked at a
Visiting Artist program.
of
community colleges before I
couple

I

I

I

job

a

I

I

got

the

chance

work

to

at

Surry

Community College in Dobson. While I
ran into the Slate
was working up here
I

Mountain

Ramblers

at

fiddlers'

Andy Griffith
Theater, and other places. I liked their
music and was very flattered and pleased
when they asked me to make music with
them. But to tell the truth, they are such

conventions,

at

the

Roger

Manley

fun people that I'd enjoy hanging out
with them even if they didn't play a note.

Bill Mansfield

1984

and Sharon Poss, who were part of the

Mountain

String Band, out of
Durham.
really liked the way the banjo
and the fiddle worked together in their
band. So
hung out with them. When
Fuzzy

I

I

they left the convention to go visit with
Tommy Jarrell and Fred Cockerham, I
managed to tag along.
At Fred Cockerham's house
got to
hear Tommy and Fred up close. I was
devastated by their music. The banjo
and fiddle had a sound of being so
intertwined that you couldn't tell where
one stopped and the other started. The
I

The Slate Mountain Ramblers are an
interesting band, not only for the music
that they play, but for the reasons that
they play old-time music. Though they
have all been exposed to other musical

manifestations

of

20th-century

they have chosen to maintain
traditional musical expression of

America,
the

Autoharp player, Kilby Snow
of Galax Va.

by

Willard Gayheart

their particular part of America.

Traditional
the years,

music has changed over
continue to change.

and will

The Slate Mountain Ramblers,
collectively and individually ensure that
the traditional music of the southern
Blue Ridge will live

on.|

Fred played the tune, kept the
rhythm going, and varied the tune was
way

what
I

I

had been

got

Barry,

looking for.
who

is

a

real

Cockerham-style banjo player,
me

to

good
show

everything he knew about that kind

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Jammin' with Uncle Tommy"
by

Willard Gayheart

�LOGO
CONTEST!!!
We are looking for a logo that
symbolizes what the Old-Time Herald is
all

about. Send your ideas/ original art

work/graphics/to: Logo Contest, c/o

the Old-Time Herald P.O. Box 1362,
Galax, Va. 24333. We will choose a
winning entry and the winner will
receive a lifetime subscription to the the
Old-Time Herald.
Entries should be received by us no
later than December 1, 1987. Entries are
not returnable.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Issues In Old-Time Music
Linda Higginbotham

by

OLD-TIME MUSIC CIRCA 1987
acquainted with the
of old-time music played
today is aware that there is a variety of
forms coming under its heading. Adding
to this confusion is the fact that although
old-time music in some form is widely
it
is
still overshadowed,
played,
especially on the commercial level, by
bluegrass, folk, and other related genres.
Because of this, it is frequently included
under those headings although it is quite
distinct. There is much that could and
should be written about how old-time
music is different from other acoustic

American genres, including popular old-

Anyone

time music. Its special quality also has a
peculiar life to it. It isn't just very old; it
is very old and still vital, still capable of
touching our souls. This deep vitality
gives it the power of a primordial womb
from which new types of music may

abundance

Gerrard

genres; however, for the purposes of this
article, I am going to assume that the
average reader has some concept of these
The issue

Alice

differences.

I

wish to address concerns
old-time music itself.

the trends within

as American
culture has grown
infinitely more complex over the past 50
years, so has the domain of old-time
music. What is called old-time music
today includes the old traditional music
and forms that are closely tied to it, yet
different. The following article is an
attempt to describe, in very broad terms,
what is happening in old-time music

Just

today.

My motives for undertaking such a
task are several. First of all, the various
trends within old-time music are not

getting

the

Second,

by
as

music

recognition they deserve.
not looking at old-time

music

within

distinctions can and should

which

spring, depending on the
needs of the times. Classic old-time
music itself cannot be replaced. If it dies
out, some aspects of its form may
continue in other music but its essence
will be lost.
Classic old-time music is subtle, not
flashy. It exhibits a controlled energy
that is not forced, no matter how fast or
intense the playing becomes. The music
has a continuous flow to it and follows

continually

Bert Dickens,

Ennice, NC

closely

1986

forms of old-time music can also be seen
as traditions of their own.
What makes classic old-time music
recognizable is hard to define. It has a
timeless quality, a depth, which sets it
apart. It is a depth that results from the
gentle shaping of the music over many

generations,

by

countless musicians.

Its

form does change but it does so slowly
so slowly that at any particular time it
remains relatively unaffected by current
trends. This makes it in some ways more
akin to the pure traditional music of a
than
to
most
land
other
foreign

some

internal

rhythmic

structure, even among the more melodic
players. Classic musicians tend to play in
small groups, taking turns if many
musicians are present. They prefer to
play with others adept in the same style
and derive immense delight from the
discovery of a new classic player. Classic
musicians often have smaller repertoires
than other old-time musicians and seem
to derive more satisfaction from playing
the same tunes again and again, refining
them over the years.
In order to become a classic old-time
player it is usually necessary to learn
from another classic old-time player or
players. This relationship frequently

be made, we

run the risk of losing the purity of the

older

motive
music,

traditional forms. The third
is to help people new to old-time
or

involved, get

who
an

are

only

introduction

marginally
to what is

going on.

The domain of old-time music can be
roughly divided into two catergories,

I
call classic and popular. In
addition to these two groups, mention
a third eclectic category.
The music in
this category has stylistically stepped
outside the bounds of old-time music
but often draws upon it as a source of
inspiration and material and so is
mentioned here.

which

I

Alice

I
mean what is often
By classic,
referred to as traditional old-time music.
have chosen to describe this category as
classic or classic traditional, rather than
simply traditional, because the popular

Gerrard

Classic Old-Time Music

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

John Rector, Chester McMillian,
Dale Morris Galax, VA
1983
L-R:

Whit

Sizemore,

Frank

Bode,

�discussed here (there are undoubtedly
other forms too) have all been around
for over 15 years and are still going
strong. I call them festival, front porch,
and collector old-time music. I did not
divide classic old-time music into sub

of time.
Certainly professional
the motive
are
not
considerations
behind learning to play any kind of oldtime music.

Because popular forms of old-time
reflect prevailing taste they are

music

groups because the similarities between

classic

Higginbotham

Mt. Airy, NC Fiddlers'

Convention 1987

well

provide

an

enduring

inspiration, purity, depth,
seemingly against all odds,

as

Higginbotham
Linda

Rorrer,
1987

guitar-Doug

old-time
kind

of

source

of

American

Winston, fiddleWinston

L-R:

banjo-David

James

Leva, guitar-Mary

1987

Popular Old-Time Music

popular
rarely

as

traditions do perform, but
professionals over a long period

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Linda

Higginbotham

any form

L-R:

fiddle-Andy Cahan, banjo-Brett
1987
Riggs, guitar-Paul Sutphin

seem

types

relatively enduring. The three
of popular
old-time music

is

the
Often
all
band or jam session will
pause and lay emphases at the same time,
in a manner that is rarely heard in classic
old-time music. The clawhammer banjo
players usually double-time their fifth
string and the fiddlers use a lot of fast,
short bow strokes, both of which
contribute to the energetic sound of the
music. Often the fiddlers will heavily
emphasize the beginning of a phrase, and
the banjo players employ a distinctive
"chunk" to their strum. Bands in festival
old-time music almost always use a bass.
Although they have learned to play
differently, the first players of this style
drew much of their inspiration from

(then)

anticipations.
in

a

classic

living

dance

musicians

Tommy Jarrell and Fred
Cockerham. The first bands in this style
such

as

(Highwoods,

Plank

Road,

etc.)

drew

twin-fiddle, fast-paced,
good-time sound of the Skillet Lickers.
Now, the tradition has taken on a life of
heavily

bound to die out or change over time
much more quickly than classic old-time
music. Y et if we compare them to trends
in
commercial American music, they

It

Festival music is usually played fast.
This speed, along with a certain density
of texture, contributes to its energy.
Classic old-time music can also be
played fast but it has a different feeling.
There is a characteristic jazzy phrasing to
festival old-time music that manifests
itself in more dramatic pauses, stresses,

instruments

culture.

Popular old-time music encompasses
of old-time music that is not
classic traditional and yet is not so
different from it that it has become
another type of music altogether. It may
display influences from other genres
such as rock-and-roll, folk, jazz, and
classical music, but it still remains
recognizable as a form of old-time
music. Like classic old-time music,
old-time
music
is
not
popular
commercial but amateur music, played
simply for the love of it. Of course bands
and individuals in both the classic and

am calling

immediate appeal.

and

access

and vitality,
in

Rorrer

banjo-

particular

to
perceptiveness,
musicians and a
classic traditional
willingness to learn from them. Because
of this, it may not be for everyone. The
musicians who do go this way find it
immensely rewarding; and they also
as

Kinney

Sutphin,

Higginbotham

their

fiddle-Kirk

L-R:

Linda

within

I

festivals play in its
widely heard at at
least three major old-time festivals
Brandywine, Mount Airy, and Galax. Of
course other forms of old-time music
can be heard at these festivals too, but
this music is particularly evident due to
the many people playing it and its

perpetuation.

a

strengths and weaknesses.
Learning to play classic
music
a
certain
requires

Festival Old-Time Music.

central importance

Although

working

festival and front porch styles.

type of music "festival" old-time
music due to its particular energy and
good-time feelings, and because of the

this contact.

classic old-time players
particular way of playing,
this is not to say they don't develop their
own sound. Each musician is quite
individual and classic players sound at
least as different from each other and
their mentors as musicians of any other
style. But they make their contributions
to the tradition almost unconsciously, as
natural outgrowth
of the music
a

their

this

players, even after they are adept, will
often make a great effort to spend time
with
other classic players, deriving
needed support and inspiration from

must learn

outweigh

players

differences for the purposes of this
article. However, will later refer to two
old-time music:
of classic
types
a
more melodically
hornpipey"
a more
oriented style, and "dance"
in
which
oriented
style,
rhythmically
some ways parallel the split between
I

Linda

occurs on a somewhat regular basis,
almost like an apprenticeship. The art of
classic old-time playing is, in large part,
contained in right-hand technique. This
makes it difficult for the novice to figure
things out properly from a recording.
Beyond this problem, there is another
difficulty. Unlike older players and oldtime players of the past, all younger
(under 50 years old) musicians today
have been heavily influenced by other
genres prior to, or along with, their first
exposure to old-time music. The result
is that while it is not impossible for a
person under 50 to be a classic player, it
requires a more conscious effort. The
players of today who attempt to learn
"on their own" will probably play a form
of popular
old-time music. Classic

on

the

own, with the players mainly learning
from, playing with, and listening to each
other (and recordings). The style is
transmitted through the close contact
that these players have with each other,
its

�for festival music

over great distances

although it spreads
represents a close

network of players.
People who are attracted to festival
old-time music find it more accessible
than classic old-time music. It fits in
better with their total musical
background. While this style of playing

lead

to

ways

a

beat which easily
draws people. It is continuing to develop
and attract new musicians and possibly
may even become as enduring a musical
form as bluegrass. Certainly this is a
movement to watch. Because of its close
association with festivals and partying
there has been a tendency not to take it

seriously

or

in many players the sense that
they have made something of their own,
there is a recognizable consistency to it.
In this sense, although festival music is
not a classic tradition, it has become a
popular tradition with a tremendous

power of its own.
Festival old-time
radiates fun. It has
ment and infectious

as a

music
an

positively
obvious excite

musical genre. But

1

believe

attitude is beginning to change.
Festival musicians' connection to oldtime music is of a different nature than
but their
the
classic traditionalists'
music is no less worthy of respect; and
the importance their music holds in
their lives is often equally great.
that

Front Porch Old-time Music. This
a

large,

diffuse

musical

event

outside

community

plays

and

repertoire

for

much front porch music comes from a
group of musicians who were them
selves inspired by classic hornpipey
fiddlers such as Charlie Fliggins and
Henry Reed, and various West Virginia
musicians. These precursors of front
porch players appreciated the simple
beauty of the old melodies and the
craftsmanship which went into making
the tunes more than they did a driving
rhythm. They followed their classic
sources of inspiration more closely then
do current front porch players.
In the late '60s and early '70s this prefront porch group was very influential.
Their records (for example, the Hollow
and the Fuzzy
Rock
Stringband

Mountain Stringband) and instructional

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Krider,

Erb, fiddle-Sumio
1987
Seo, guitar-Shirley Kohl

front porch music fulfills
aspects that classic
traditional music played in the past
(while classic musicians in many areas
play in relative isolation from their
communities) and is often associated
with a regular local dance.
Front porch musicians have several

perpetuation,

of the social

many

things in common. For one thing, their
repertoire (either directly or indirectly)
is

influenced

less

by

the

and

music or classic dance
and modal tunes are
The influences brought
folk (and sometimes
than

aforementioned

books. Their music has a
rhythmic feel to it than festival

records

jazz

and

music, and Irish
often preferred.
to bear on

it are

classical) rather
rock-and-roll (as with

festival music). There is more use of
folk
such
as
other
instruments,
hammered and lap dulcimers. It is often

course, some very
players in this group who
of

qualities associated

This is an

to imitate it.

One thing collectors share is a very
large repertoire. While classic musicians

lovingly rework

a slowly evolving body
festival players are most
likely to learn whatever tune is currently
hot, collectors are constantly on the
look-out for "new" old tunes. They are
most likely to get their music from
either 78s or new or old
recordings
but they also learn
field recordings
tunes from other old-time musicians.
Collectors are often players of
exceptional talent with the ability to

of tunes

Higginbotham

guitar-Mercedes

dulcimer-Anna

are

changes

extremely important group and one
quite different from the previous two.
Unlike front porch and festival music,
collector old-time music does not bring
other musical influences to bear on
classic old-time music but rather strives

Linda

L-R: guitar-Gail Bloomer, banjo-Steve

chord

Collector Old-Time Music.

is

Griffith,

are,

or

carry on many of the

its

in

lilt, and pretty or unusual

with
classic traditional hornpipey
music. However, the real strength of this
movement currently lies not in its most
talented members, but in its average
players. It is available to just about
anyone who has always wanted to take
up an instrument and it allows virtually
everyone to participate in an activity
which
brings
people together and
provides a dimension of creativity in
their lives.

if
community
organized dancing is
involved. Because of the strong role the

local

a

lines

accomplished

movement,

music because these players display a
more relaxed attitude in their pursuit of
old-time music than the classic and
festival players and because its roots
stem more from a "listening" than a
"dance" form of classic old-time music.
(Through a twist of fate, however, this
music now has a strong association with
dances in many areas.)

inspiration

valued.
There

their

representatives of which can be found in
every corner of the United States. I have
called this music "front porch" old-time

The

melody

simple, wholesome,
In addition to being

natural lifestyle.
attracted to the music and in keeping
with the kind of lifestyle they wished to
create, many people were starting up
square and contra dances in places
where country dancing had all but died
out; these dances used, of course, live
music.
Many present-day front porch players
have slight contact with other forms of
old-time music or even front porch
players outside their area. They learn
tunes from local front porch players as
well as from written music, tablature,
and recordings. Many of the people who
take up this music do so more for social
contact than musical expression. Their
music is very community oriented and
they are more likely to attend a festival

fulfills

played with

(for example, those by Miles
were
Krassen and Art Rosenbaum)
some of the first to reach a large
audience. They struck a chord in many
people who were at that time looking for

books

and

many different musicians.
classic or festival musicians
take new tunes and
will generally
incorporate them into their own style of
playing, a collector will attempt to play a
tune in a manner similar to the original
source.
There are two sides to collector oldtime music. One stresses the collecting
of old 78s. Much of the old-time music
these musicians copy was recorded for

emulate
Whereas

commercial purposes in the past.
collector old-time music

way,

incorporate

trends

popular

In

this

may

into

but they are trends
which were popular some 50 years ago.
Frequently this vintage music, along
with old-fashioned dress, is used for
performing purposes. Because of its

traditional music,

novelty, the vintage approach has often
come to typify modern presentation of
old-time music to the general public.
On the other side

whose

interests

noncommercial

are

lie

tune wizards

more

with

such
as
recordings
of Congress recordings and
Library
archival
sources as well as
other
field
recordings. They
contemporary

�also learn from other living musicians,

traditional

classic

including
When they

from

learn

do

players.
classic

musicians

to
remain
they
prefer
somewhat removed, learning versions of

tunes but not internalizing a particular
traditional style to the extent that they
embody it the way a classic player does.
of these musicians have the
Many
versatility to play with old-time
musicians of any type. This, along with
their
enormous
and
ever-growing
repertoires, makes them perennially
popular with all old-time players.
Without the contribution of the oldtime collectors, the stock of available
tunes would be drastically reduced.
Their versatility, musical talent, and
numerous
inspired
repertoire have
people in old-time music, and their
dedication has been a sustaining force in
the music for many years.

Eclectic Old-Time Music
Basically, two types of musicians
compose this category. On the one hand
are musicians who have more or less
consciously taken some aspect of oldtime music and blended it with another
form of music to create a new genre or
their own original music. On the other
are musicians who play many types of
music including some form of old-time
music.

almost impossible to perform
without adopting a certain element of
would say that most
eclecticism, and
old-time performers do. In general, the
more commercial the old-time act, the
more eclectic the band (or performer)
needs to be, with the most successful
being either totally eclectic or crossing
It

is

I

over

into

some

other

roll" old-time music for want of

a better
some very talented
musicians in this group, many of whom
are
Stylistically, their
quite young.
music has much in common with rockand-roll, but it is played on traditional

word.

There

are

instruments

(along

with

some

interesting additions) and uses many
old-time tunes. These rock-and-rollers
also play festival old-time music and
exert a considerable influence on it. In
some ways the rock-and-roll old-time
music that they play can be seen as a
further extension of their festival music.
Eclectic old-time music has made, and
has the potential to make, tremendous

contributions

the old-time
to
movement. The high visibility of the
many performers involved makes them
ideal spokespeople for old-time music
even if they play little old-time music
themselves. On a musical level they
often serve as sources of inspiration for
popular old-time musicians and, of
course, they make other kinds of music
besides old-time for us to appreciate.

In

Conclusion

Obviously, many people do not
neatly fit into one category or another;
some partake of several and others
change their styles over time. The
musicians from the different categories

play together, even sometimes in the
same bands. But I believe all the trends

mentioned do exist and can be meaning
fully identified. This article is not the
word but rather one of the first
words in an attempt to develop a
last

consistent

and

which represents

respectful
all

language

forms of old-time

music. I have begun work on an article
on festival old-time music and hope to
do articles on the other trends as well.
The
article(s) will be based on
information and quotes I receive from

musicians themselves.
There are people who say there is no
real old-time
music but (what I've
called) classic old-time. There are others
who claim that popular old-time music
is classic old-time music and there is no
difference. Some even claim this about
eclectic old-time music. All of these
views represent a genuine love of the
music. One seeks the continued survival
of classic old-time music; the others,
respect for new forms.
Old-time music, if it is to survive and
flourish, needs all of its forms. It is like a
rope which is composed of several
strands. Each strand contributes to the
strength of the braid. We need classic
old-time music because it is the soul and
the source; we need festival music for
the energy and life it has brought; we
need front porch old-time music for the
broad base of support it has created; we
need collector old-time music for its
and
we need
invaluable repertoire;
eclectic old-time music to gain respect
and recognition in the larger sphere.
Most important, we need all this music
because it has brought some element of

indefinable joy into our often-routine
existence, and that is what old-time
music

is all

Comments

about.
on

the column and suggestions

"Issues" may be sent to Linda
Higginbotham, c/o The Old-Time Herald,

for

future

P.O. Box 1362, Galax,

VA

24333.

more

commercially viable type of music, be it
bluegrass, folk, country, or rock-androll.
A few eclectic performers have had
considerable experience with some form
of old-time music, others only marginal
contact. In either case, their position as
performers makes them important.
When they affirm their connection to
old-time music in loving and respectful

shot

in

the arm to the

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gerrard

a

whole movement.
Unfortunately, it
sometimes happens that old-time music
is presented
as
something backward,
something to go beyond, by people
seeking to appear more accomplished.
Not all people in this category are fulltime professional performers. One of
the
most interesting and exciting
movements in eclectic old-time music is
based in upstate New York and consists
mostly of nonprofessional or semiprofessional musicians.
call it "rock-and-

Alice

terms, they give

Banjo-Enoch Rutherford,

fiddle-Tim Donley

1987

�The Dance Beat
by

Phil Jamison

THE KENTUCKY RUNNING SET
This account,

one evening after dark,
on the porch of one of the largest houses
of the Pine Mountain School, with only
one dim lantern to light up the scene. But
the moon streamed fitfully in, lighting up
the mountain peaks in the background
and, casting its mysterious light over the
It

was danced,

heels, drag their feet lazily on the floor, or
do a hoe-down step or two, i.e., a heeland-toe shuffle, or clog-dance step.
When music was used at dances, it
consisted of unaccompanied fiddle or
fiddle with banjo. Throughout the dance,
onlookers as well as the dancers would
reinforce the rhythm of the music by

alternately stamping and
is
done in various
ways, but the usual method is to stamp
with the right foot on the strong accent
"patting,"

i.e.,

clapping.

"Patting"

and

clap the hands on the weak one, the

head
his
back,
executant
throwing
inclining his body to the left and
emphasizing the movements of the feet
and hands so that the rhythm may be seen
as

well

as

hear.

The fiddler and the banjo-player each
have an assistant, a "beater," who, sitting
at
right angles to the instrumentalist,
"beats" the strings between the bridge and
the player's left hand with two pencil-like
These sticks,
sticks.
wooden
being
flexible, strike all the strings

simultaneously

and

this

produces

a

drone effect which, if the
"beater" is deft in his movements and
skillfully varies his rhythms, adds depth
to the tunes and gives material aid to the
dancers.
The players in Kentucky generally
managed, notwithstanding the melodic

rhythmical

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of
Book

V

In 1987, there are still some local and
indigenous dances to be found around
the country. In future issues of the Old

Time Herald, I will feature some of these
as well as cover other topics relating to
traditional dance and clogging (or "hoedowning," as Sharp says it was called). I
welcome ideas, comments, and
contributions to this column from any

interested

Hanlon Mountain Team;
Appalachian Photographic
Mars Hill College

Southern
Archives

poverty of the tunes, to play them with
such force and adandonment that they
made excellent accompaniment to the
The dancers set the tempo,
dance.
varying it from moment to moment at
their pleasure, and these variations it is
the duty of the player to follow as though
he were accompanying a song.

influence.

The dancers often improvised stepvariations of their own, e.g. kick up their

Part

Dance

years ago.

exaggerate
proceedings, seemed
wildness and the break-neck speed of the

dancers as they whirled through the mazes
of the dance. There was no music, only
and
the stampings
clappings of the
onlookers, but when one of the emotional
and this
crises of the dance was reached
the
times
several
during
happened
the air seemed literally to
performance
pulsate with the rhythm of the "patters"
and the tramp of the dancers' feet, while,
over and above it all, penetrating through
the din, floated the even, falsetto tones of
and
the
unexcitedly
Caller,
calmly
reciting his directions.
(The dancers held their bodies) erect,
motionless, with every limb loose and
This reposeful carriage,
relaxed.
together with the swift, gliding move
ment, gave to the dancers an impersonal,
detached appearance, as though they were
moving in a dream or under hypnotic

in

Country
Sharp's
(London: Novelle and Co. Ltd., 1918),
provides an interesting eyewitness view
of the dances of Eastern Kentucky of 70

the

to

printed

The

This is what Cecil J. Sharp reported
seeing when he traveled to the southern

Appalachian Mountains in 1917, in
search of traditional songs and ballads.
Sharp's theory was that the Kentucky
running set he observed was related to

folk dances of his native England,
which had been lost from the traditional
culture there. According to Sharp, these
dances were brought to America
sometime in the 18th century by
immigrants from northern England and
Scotland. They remained close to their
pure form due to the isolation of the
settlers in the mountains.
As Sharp described it, the dances were
done with four (or more) couples in a
square (or circular set). Each figure is
initiated by the first couple as they dance
their way from one couple to the next
around the set. When the first couple
reaches the fourth, the second couple
proceeds to the third, initiating a chain
all
of dance figures until
reaction
the
A
few
of
it.
have
done
couples
the

figures that Sharp mentions by name
are: "Shoot The Owl," "Bird In The
Cage," "Wild Goose Chase," "Going
Down Town," "Chase The Squirrel,"
and the "California Show Basket."

observers,

dancers,

or

musicians,

readers. Write to me c/o

the Old-Time Herald,
Galax, VA 24333.

P.O. Box

1362,

�BLACK STRING BANDS:
A FEW NOTES ON A LOST CAUSE
by

Charles Wolfe

People loved Arnold so well all through
Kentucky there; if he was playinga guitar,
they'd

go

up

gang

around

him

till

he

would get tired and then maybe he'd go

admired him so much
train.
never forgot a lot of things he would
say. There's things in my music, you
know, that comes from Arnold Schultz
use in a lot of my music. In
runs that
fiddle piece or a breakdown,
a
following
he used a pick and could just run from
one chord to another the prettiest you've
ever heard.

catch
that

a

1

I

1

to say, Arnold Schultz's band
never made it into a recording studio
at least playing the kind of oldeither

Needless

Monroe remembers.

time breakdowns

this one from blueQuotes
grass and old-time musicians are by no
means atypical. For 10 years I have been

such

Fiddle-Leonard Bowles, banjo-Irvin Cook, Martinsville,
Courtesy Blue Ridge Institute, Ferrum College

different version of this article
originally appeared in the March 1978
(A

Devil's Box)

Dorris Macon, the guitar-playing son
Uncle Dave
banjoist
legendary
the
to
tell
used
story of the first
Macon,
time he went to make records with his
famous father. It was in April 1930, at
of

the

old

St.

James

Hotel in Knoxville,
Vocalin Records

for

where producers
had gathered to make records of East
Tennessee acts. Musicians from as far
north as Kentucky and as far south as
Alabama had come up to the session,
which was being conducted by a man
named C.F. Lyons, who had come from

company's main office in Chicago.
assistant was well-known tiddler
Lowe Stokes, the Georgian who had
become a mainstay of the era's most

interviewing at length older country
musicians and folk musicians from the
1920s and 1930s about that misty

VA

borderland

and the "record man" Lyons
came out of his office to listen. The band
played on for four or five minutes before
Lyons waved his arms and stopped
them. "Sorry," he said. "Can't use you,"
and at this the musicians quietly walked
back down the stairs. Uncle Dave had
been enjoying it, though, and said, "Cap,
why not give the boys a chance?" "No,"
said Lyons. "That music doesn't sound
like anything I've ever heard," and
walked away. Years later Dorris, when
asked what kind of music it was, would
recall: "It was good dance music. And
that old man was the loudest fiddle
player I ever heard."

before,

What Uncle

Dave

Dorris

and

had

the
His

witnessed

popular string band, The Skillet Lickers.
"People sat on benches in the hallway
waiting for a chance to audition,"
recalled Dorris. "Pap didn't have to, of
course, but he liked to sit and watch the
others. So we sat there all one morning
watching them come and go." Just
before noon, after all the other acts had
gone, a group of four or five black men

black string band. One of Dorris
Macon's better known colleagues, bluegrass patriarch Bill Monroe, has a story
almost as good:

appeared. 'The leader was an old man
who played the fiddle, and he had a
skinny white beard." The band began
playing a tune Dorris had never heard

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was

typical
probably
encounter between the new mass media
and one of the most potent but leastknown examples of traditional music:
a

the

ever seen this
think
The first time
this square dance
man Arnold Schultz
I

was

at

I

Rosine, Kentucky, and Arnold and

two more colored fellows come up there
and played for the dance. They had a
guitar, banjo, and fiddle. Arnold played
the guitar, but he could also play the
fiddle

as

numbers like "Sally Gooden."

wherein

traditional

American folk music was somehow
transformed into commercial country
music; many, many of them mention
bands such as Arnold Schultz's string
band, and point to them as influences, as
models, as colleagues. They point to a
genre of American music that most
scholars have ignored, and that most
members of the general public do not
even know existed: a genre that DeFord
Bailey, the famous harmonica player of
the early Grand Ole Opry, defined for
me as "black hillbilly music." "Sure," he
said, "black hillbilly music. Everybody

around me grew up playin' that. Fiddles
and banjos and guitars; they weren't
playin' no blues then. It was black
hillbilly music."
For
years the emphasis of those
studying black American folk music has
the
been directed to religious music
first really respectable music to study; to

the first commercially successful
brand of music; or to blues. Y et do these
three forms really account for all of the
rich variety of black music found in folk
tradition, or just the most visible ones?
What about the rural fife-and-drum
jazz

tradition, which has lingered unnoticed
Tennessee until this present
in
generation? What about the tradition of
black non-blues secular song? And what
about the tradition of rural string band
music? To explore these aspects of black
music requires

a

great deal more musical

�archaeology, but might in the end yield
results as fruitful as those coming from
jazz, blues, and religious music studies.
Black string band music as a genre has
often been wrongly associated with
blues; while many string bands played
some blues, many others did not, and
played in repertoires and styles that
seem related to, and yet distinct from,
the styles and repertoires of white string
bands. It is -certain that the string band
tradition existed before the blues
as
a
some
older
genre;
emerged
musicians

I

have

interviewed

have

suggested that when the blues became so
intensely popular shortly after the turn
of the century, and when it emerged as
virtually the only form of rural black
music to gain access to mass media, it
virtually swamped the older forms, and
these forms were driven even further

into the backwaters of the rural South.
to
There
continued
flourish,
they

unheralded and undocumented by the
and by the commercial record
companies.
even
there
are
Oddly
enough,
band
of
a
strong string
suggestions
tradition in New Orleans, the alleged

scholars

home of jazz.
early

as

the

1

I

have found a reference, as
a black fiddler who

840s, to

been trained "in New Orleans,
where they know how to teach the fine
music." One of the first New Orleans
featured six black
in
1806,
balls,
whom
most
of
musicians,
played
fiddles; a directory of some 217 jazz
musicians who worked in the Story ville
district from 1898-1917 reveals more
fiddlers in these early bands than
had

trumpeters, banjoists, or saxophonists.
Early photos of New Orleans jazz bands

often show, in addition to a guitar or
banjo, one or more fiddles; and many
leaders of brass bands, such as Lorenzo
Tio, Sr., also led smaller string bands for
quieter parties. It is not surprising that
writer George
Washington Cable,
describing black New Orleans music as
early as 1886, claimed that the fiddle,
not the banjo, was the truly favored
instrument of the Negro.
For the record, there are numerous

instances

of

acknowledging
Muddy

origins.

blues

musicians

string-band ties and
Waters early in 1942

sang on several records by Son Sims, a
Mississippi fiddler, possibly the same
fiddler that performed with Charlie
Sam
10
Paton some
years before.
Chatman, of the Mississippi Sheiks, had
a father who fiddled tunes like "Turkey
in the Straw," as did Honey boy Edwards
and Brownie McGhee. Skipjames, Fred

McDowell,
remember

and Gatemouth Brown all
attending country dances

where the music was not blues, but
string band music. James (Butch) Cage,
who accompanied blues singers on his
fiddle, even held the fiddle to his chest as
he played, like older white fiddlers, and
remembered a number of older black
Mississippi fiddlers. Even W.C. Handy
devotes a passage in his autobiography
to remembering his Grandpa Brewer,
who had played fiddle for dances since
slavery days, making extra money and
delighting crowds in Alabama with
fiddle music accompanied by "beating
the straws": having a young boy take
knitting sticks and beat on his fiddle

as he played.
Handy's Uncle
White was even more of a showman,
and would sing and play such numbers
as "Sally Got a Meatskin Laid Away"
while stomping his feet to provide a

strings

rhythm.
The scanty references in print to rural
black music before the Civil War also
string band
suggest a flourishing
tradition. Dena Epstein's book Sinful

Tunes and Spirituals contains numerous
references. As early as 1774, a

such

diary describes a Southern plantation
party where "a great number of young
people met together with a fiddle and
banjo played by two Negroes." In the
prewar South, black string bands are
found consisting of banjos and flutes;
and
fiddles,
banjos,
triangles; twin
fiddles with a fife; and others. In the
1840s in North Carolina, a black band is

described
Cover of piano sheet music, copyright 1890
Courtesy Andy Cahan

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Kunkel Bros., St. Louis, MO

as

consisting of two fiddles,

a

triangle, and castanets.
Another important source for early
black traditional music is the life
histories collected from former slaves in
flute,

a

banjo,

a

the 1930s by the Depression-era

WPA

�project. Historian Bob Winans has
listed references to music in these, and
has found something like 205 references
to fiddle playing, 106 mentions of banjo
playing, but only 15 references to guitar
playing. This suggests again that the

instrument

often

so

associated

black music and blues

with

the guitar

the scene. Most
recalled black life
before or during the Civil War
remembered string bands as simple
the same
duos
fiddle-and-banjo
instrumentation that defined early white
string band music. Without much
doubt, the fiddle was the favorite
instrument of both white and black rural
was

latecomer

a

slaves

former

musicians

in

to

who

the 1800s.

Much of this tradition was still highly
visible in the 1920s when commercial

recording

companies

String Band, featuring mandolin, guitar,
and cello, and recorded several
fascinating sides for Columbia, while
Nap Hayes and Matthew Prater (The
Blue Boys) recorded folk variants of
Scott Joplin's rags using mandolin and
guitar. Black "hoedown" music was
recorded by James Cole (probably from
Indiana), and by the spectacular square
dance band headed by fiddler John
Lusk. This latter band, recorded by the
Library of Congress in 1946, played for
years in rural Tennessee just a few miles
from the birthplace of bluegrass star
Lester Flatt, and featured the "prebluegrass" banjo styles of the late

Murphy Gribble.
Some regions seemed to

be

hotbeds

black string bands, or at least for
those that got recorded. East Tennessee
for

to

began

Southern music. Unfortu
nately, the record companies segregated

document

into separate series, one
whites and the other for
designed
blacks. White rural music included
fiddle bands, banjo tunes, sentimental
songs, and a few religious pieces; black
music series were dominated by country
blues, gospel, preachers like Rev. Gates,
music

this

for

and

a

few vaundeville

a

Still, this miniscule sample contains
some tantalizing bits. A handful of
records from the late 1920s shows white
and black musicians playing together,
several years before jazz's first
"integrated" session. Jim Booker played
with
white
banjoist
"Grey
Eagle"

Marion

Leonard Bowles, Martinsville, VA
Courtesy Blue Ridge institute, Ferrum
College

Tennessee Chocolate Drops," and in its
hillbilly series, "The Tennessee Trio."
Most people today, though, recognize

band as the genesis of Martin,
Bogan, and Armstrong, and it was based
around the fiddle of Howard Armstrong
and the guitar of Carl Martin. More
doing over
prolific in their recordings
18
sides for the Old American
was the
Recording Company in 1931
mandolin player/
band headed
by
fiddler Joe McClain and guitarist Joe
Evans, called "The Two Poor Boys."
They did thing like "Old Hen Cackle"
this

"Sourwood Mountain" as well
novelty pieces like "Take

as
a

City, a 1928 Columbia
session
yielded a great "Lindy,
recording
Lindy" by the Proximity String Quartet,

composed of two white

and two black

musicians, and a 1927 session in Bristol
saw
a
collaboration
between white
Paul
and black
Johnson
guitarist
harmonica player El Watson for Victor
Records.

growing

up near

Tennessee,
defined another

Carthage,

just east of Nashville,
center for black string
McGee, one of Uncle
and a mainstay of the

band music. Kirk

Dave's sidekicks
early Grand Ole
dozen black fiddlers

Victor. Andrew Baxter, an AfroCherokee fiddler born in Northwest
Georgia in 1870, played regularly with
for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

unusual.
bands from that area was a black band
known to most white musicians as "the
Armstrong Boys." They actually did get
to
record at Macon's session for
Vocalion, with fiddle, banjo, and guitar,
doing two distinctive local pieces, "Vine
Street Drag" and "Knox County
Stomp." The record company issued the
78 in its race series calling the band "The

The kind of music Grand Ole Opry
star DeFord
learned while
Bailey

for Taylor's
in
1927, and a black
Kentucky Boys
harmonica stylist recorded with the
white Johnson Brothers that same year

white Georgia fiddlers, and played lead
the Georgia
Yellow
Hammers'
popular 1928 recording of "G Rag."
Other recordings reflect a complex
school of rural black ragtime; Dallas
musician Coley Jones formed the Dallas

Macon

Johnson

Underwood

on

Dorris

band

Knoxville was not that
One of the best-remembered
at

That
Both were
Baby."
apparently from Knoxville, and both
sold their records on dozens of dimestore labels to old-time fans who
probably never knew the team was
black. A popular fixture at the old
fairgrounds in Knoxville was a third
black string band, this one headed by
singer and piano player Leola Manning.
Yet a fourth group was centered in
nearby Loudin, and headed by singer
Will Bennett, who managed to record a
driving version of "Railroad Bill" at the
St. James Hotel session. Further east, in

was
full

string band.

The

blues and
Look
at

numbers. Black

minded, but
equipment
woefully inadequate for recording

one.

remembered

and

bands playing something other than
blues didn't fit into either sterotype, and
so few of them were recorded. Thus
today we are left with only a pathetic
handful of recordings representing this
tradition in its flowering: there are
perhaps as many as 50 commercial
prewar recordings that really reflect it, as
opposed to some 20,000 prewar records
of blues and gospel music. In the 1930s,
when the Library of Congress got into
the field, recorders were more opentheir

was

DeFord Bailey
Early 1930s
Courtesy Country Music Foundation,
Nashville, TN

Opry, knew over a
and banjo players in the hills near his
home at Franklin,
south
of
just

Nashville. John Work, a leader at
Nashville's Fisk University and himself
a noted
black scholar, was perhaps the
first scholar in the country to recognize
the

strength

of the black

string band

�tradition
both in this area and in
Alabama. His letters show that he knew
this music was not blues and not gospel,
but a genuine third type based on fiddle
and banjo songs, and that it was dying

it could be documented.
Work
himself recorded two fine
Nashville bands: One was James Kelly's
Nashville Washboard Band, which used

out faster than

Courthouse Square in
featuring pieces like "Old
"
"Soldier's
Joe," "Round Dice Reel,
Joy," and others. Another was the
fiddle-banjo duo of Nathan Frazier and
Frank Patterson
dynamic performers
who offered distinctive versions of
unusual songs like "Texas Traveler" and
to

on

play

Nashville,

as

Lornell

"Indian and the Woodchuck." As late

recorded James
Campbell's Nashville Street band,
featuring the fiddling of Beauford Clay,
one of Kirk McGee's friends from
Williamson
County. With the
exception of the latter, none of this

Kip

1962 Chris Strachwitz

John Lawson Tyree, Franklin County, VA

material is readily available to the
public, though plans are underway to
reissue some of it on a forthcoming
series by Rounder Records.
A complete
survey of the small
recorded heritage of black string bands
would also have to include numerous
other influential men or groups: the
Mississippi Sheiks, the one black string

band that really found commercial
success on early records and who
introduced "Sittin' on Top of the

World";

Weaver,

Sylvester

the

Louisville guitarist whose "Guitar Rag"
was the source for the Western swing
classic

"Steel

Guitar

Rag";

Peg

Leg

Howell and his Gang, the fine Atlantic
band

that featured

unpredictable

fiddling

the wild and

of

Eddie

Endres

area

own, but backedJimmieRodgersonone
session; and Oscar Woods, the
Shreveport guitarist who backed Jimmie
"You are My Sunshine" Davis on some
of his rowdier sides. Each deserves a
story to itself. And, to be sure, deserving
of a story are the few rare glimpse of this

tradition still alive, as researchers like
Kip Lornell and CeCe Conway have
discovered.

The study of black string band music
still
in
its
but
even
infancy,
preliminary investigations have posed
some potent questions: Is (was) there a
is

string band repertoire distinct
the white
one? Is there an
identifiable black fiddle style? Have
there been characteristic and distinctive
black instrumental combinations? Have
black

from

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Clifford

Anthony and recorded a dozen sides for
Columbia; Clifford Hayes and his
Louisville Jug Band, who not only made
hits for Columbia and Victor on their

Josh Thomas, Hollins, VA ca. 1975
Courtesy Blue Ridge Institute, Ferrum College

geographical

features

combinations

(do

affected

these

fiddle-banjo

combinations seem more common in
guitar combinations in
the
How really
deep
South)?
the mountains,

representative of the music were these
recording sessions? How were the bands

recorded related to other quasiblues forms such as the jug or wash
board band, the vaudeville or medicine
show tradition, or even the tradition of
that

the black non-blues songsters like Henry
Thomas, Luke Jordan, and Jim Jackson?

How were they related to various black
formal composers like Gussie Davis,
Scott Joplin, or even W.C. Handy? Until

scattered bits of evidence about this
are collected,
collated, put in
proper context, and studied, we can only
and wonder
guess at the answers
the

music

about what we have lost.

�When

I

began thinking about writing

knew two things about
music: First, he had
spent some years in Kentucky learning
music from traditional musicians there.
Second, whenever we played music
together Bruce always knew lots of tunes
tunes with
I had
never heard before-wonderful names and rhythms that
this

article,

Bruce

I

Greene's

tripped me up. In fact, Bruce knows
more about old-time Kentucky fiddling
than just about anyone else.
How did it happen? What does it
mean in the musical scheme of things?
How does Bruce Greene feel about being
one of the only people left to embody an
entire musical tradition?
Bruce was born in New York City on
January 10, 1951. His family moved to
Wyckoff, New Jersey when Bruce was a
year and a half old. He lived in New
Jersey until he went away to college.

came out of a
father
"My
homesteading family from Washington
state,"

says Bruce. "There

was

a

romance attached to the farm life

lot of
that

steered me toward folk music in some
on his
grandfather
ways." Bruce's
father's side was a singing master, and
mother listened to records of
his
classical music and Broadway shows. He
remembers that his uncle Bruce had
what he describes as a "one-man band,
with a tenor banjo with Christmas tree
lights in it," and some other

instruments.

"1 took piano lessons when I was a kid,
hated it. My parents insisted that I take
some kind of music lessons so I switched
over to guitar. They told me if I didn't
I

lessons I couldn't play
was a real ultimatum. I used
to carry the guitar upstairs and sort of
bang it against the bannisters to see if it
would break. I made a point of
take

guitar

Alice

Gerrard

baseball.

1987

Bruce Greene,
Kentucky Fiddler
by

Hilary Dirlam

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

It

everything I learned about
reading music."
Bruce remembers going to square
dances at the local Grange Hall with his
a "funky
parents. There was live band
New
band;
any
type
England
instrument they could get ahold of
and accordian, a tenor banjo, a piano.
just like all the early '50s records. It was
a
great scene!" After Bruce started
learning fiddle music he ran into some of
the tunes he had heard that band play.
"When I was about 12 a cousin of
mine came to visit. She was some kind of
a beatnik
played guitar and sang Joan
Baez songs. That got me and my sisters
inspired; we wanted to be just like her."
Bruce admits to having listened to Peter,
forgetting

Paul,

and

Mary;

Ian

and

Sylvia;

Eric

Anderson; and Jesse Colin Young. "I'd
hear little bits of bluegrass

Flatt and

�Scruggs

I

liked that

awful lot but

an

had no idea where to find it."

When his

family moved from Wyckoff to Tenafly
heard more folk music. "I was
of
by
Library
Congress
intrigued
he

of traditional Southern
music." Bruce heard the New Lost City
Ramblers and found them inspiring. He
got a banjo and started out trying to play
bluegrass, but switched to old-time as
soon as he heard it.
Bruce got a fiddle when he was 18, but
"I didn't have any idea what to do." He
had never seen anyone play. "I just tried
to get as many notes into every bow
stroke as I could." Bruce remembers
meeting someone from Tennessee
around that time who told him it took
10 years to learn how to play the fiddle.

recordings

it was 10 years
"I guess he was right
before I felt like I was playing fiddle
not just tunes."
Bruce realized that he wanted to learn
more about fiddle music. After a year at

"real old-time fiddler.
suspicious of me; he
couldn't understand my New Jersey
accent, and whenever I said anything
he'd turn to his wife and ask, 'What'd he
say? What'd he say?'"

Sammy
Sammy

Dyer,

a

was

Sammy Dyer had learned fiddle tunes
from his father and had also learned
tunes from the radio. He knew unusual
versions of old-time tunes and had a
strong bowing style. "Sammy was the
kind of guy folklorists love; he knew a
little bit of a lot of folk traditions: string
He claimed he
games, kid's games.
couldn't read or write and he had an

incredible memory."

Bruce Greene learned "Jim Shank"
from Sammy Dyer. Another tune, "Sow
in the Tater Patch," escaped Sammy's

memory. "We spent

a long time trying
this tune he could almost
He knew we could find
remember.
someone out there who could remember

to

turn

up

College in Washington State,
decided to become a student at
Western Kentucky University, one of a
handful of places offering an under
graduate degree in folklore. By this time,
he

prejudices yet."

Bruce's first school project was to
research Henry Bandy, a turn-of-thecentury Kentucky fiddler. Henry Bandy
had been quite well known
"a
showman"
and he was the excuse
Henry Bandy

ca.

1903

of

I

I

music."
The first musician Bruce met was
Casey Russell, a banjo player who lived
just across the border in Lafayette,
Tennessee. "He had been crippled with
polio, and ended up running a photog
raphy studio with a little back room
where he sold musical instuments.
Walking into the studio was like going
back into the 1880s. He had one of those
cameras where you throw a big black
hood over your head, and faded old
backdrops for people to stand in front of
Grecian
columns
it
was

incredible."
Casey Russell

in

turn sent Bruce to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

called 'Sleeping in a Corncob Bed' which
turned out to be a version of
'Sugar in
the Gourd". He also played 'Scott's
Return.'"
Another old-time fiddler in the area
was Pat Kingerey, who had learned from
his uncle. "Pat Kingerey was real sick,
too. Every time I went to see him, he'd

drag himself out of bed to play me

a

few

her

Toes,'

(probably

and
a

'Shamrock

schottische

originally)."

I

knock on doors, and find older
musicians. This was what really wanted
to do. Coming from an academic back
ground, I thought if you wanted to learn
something you had to go to school.
What really wanted to learn was fiddle

was important to him for
to learn them. He played a tune

It

Shoddy'

had

Bruce needed to start meeting members
the
of traditional
community
musicians.
Kentucky
"Working on this
research project made it easier to go out,

me.

Between

learned there was
more to fiddling than "just running the
bow back and forth. I was totally
infatuated with the fiddle. tried to play
everything I heard; I hadn't formed any
Bruce,

for

someone

more tunes. He had a real understanding
of what I was trying to do. It was
important to him, too. He knew lots of
tunes that nobody else knew: 'Whittlin'
Wood,' Tittle Daisy,' 'Sal's Got Mud

Clark
Bruce

says

"George Booker." "Dr. Humphrey,"
"Scott's Return," and "Folding Down
the Sheets" (the Kentucky name being
"Hanging Out the Sheets").
Milo Biggins was the last fiddler who
knew these tunes. His health was very
bad. "He could only play for a few
minutes at a time; his fingers would lock
up so he could just play little snatches of
tunes for me. He was like a lot of the old
he'd go home and think about
people
the tunes; try to come up with new ones

found someone
who did."
In short order, Bruce found a number
of older fiddlers
Chester
nearby;
Huffman and Sammy Walker from
Barren County, John Rountree and Elzie
Estes from Warren County, Jim Bowles
from Monroe County, Gusty Wallace
from
Metcalfe County,
and
Milo
Biggins, also from Barren County.
"He knew a lot of neat old tunes,
many of which had been brought into
the area around 1900 by a guy named
John Gregory, originally from Virginia.
He brought this great storehouse
of
Virginia tunes. Suddenly the whole face
of southern
music
had
Kentucky
it,

and

we

finally

Harry Flippen

changed."

Bruce never heard him fiddle of
course, but, from hearing others who
had learned from him, thinks that the
tunes and the style of playing are similar
to those of fiddlers like Emmett Lundy
of Galax,
He
mentions
Virginia.

Most
of
the
western
Kentucky
fiddlers Bruce met were retired farmers,
although Milo Biggins had a shoe repair
shop "full of ancient machines." Bruce
gradually came to identify with these old
fiddlers. "Because of the music I wasn't
an outsider; I was one of them."
At this point, Bruce was learning
tunes, not consciously learning style. "I
tried to make it sound like them. I don't
know how much my bowing style came
from them. Most of the fiddlers used a
vigorous bowing style, lots of energy put
into each note. Open tunings had been a
tradition, but were mostly no longer
used."
Bruce's first five years in Kentucky
were spent in the central and southern
part of the state, although he began to
run into fiddlers from eastern Kentucky
and was learning more about that style.
"I was
interested in how the fiddlers
controlled the ways they got notes
the
way they changed direction, being able
to stop the bow dead in either direction,

stopping and starting in the same
direction. I started noticing that some
classical techniques were similar, but
these

fiddlers had never had classical
training. For me, it was a whole different
idea of bow control. The fiddlers were
more connected to the old style in
eastern Kentucky, less influenced by
outside music, more connected to the
past generations."

�from
Western
Bruce
graduated
Kentucky University in 1974, bought a
farm with some friends, and kept on
learning tunes. Around this time he met

I

copied.

"I

I

found out that
Salyer, from

I

1

a

light bulb had gone off in my head

'That's it!'
what I always imagined
fiddle playing should be like. I was
seeing what I had been hearing in my
head for years. It was like a genetic

Milo Biggins

ca.

1972-73

memory."

John Salyer's sons were happy to let
Bruce listen to the tapes, and to show
him some of the tunes themselves.

some of John Salyer's
favorites had been well-known tunes

Although

and

"Wagoner"

Ground"

"Billy

he also

had never heard

the

in

Low

he says.

a couple of bands with
brother Doug in college, and now
plays with the Swinging Bridges band in
Celo. Though he hasn't made a career of
performing, many of the tunes he
in
from
the
old
fiddlers
learned
Kentucky have made their way through
him out into the wider world of younger

Bruce played in

played tunes Bruce

anyone else play: "Gilda
"Indian Ate the
"Duck
River,"
Roy,"
Woodchuck," and "Featherbed," as well
as tunes named for the fiddlers who had
"Bill
Brown," "Jeff
played them:

his

Sturgeon," and "Brad Walters."

"John Salyer played in the 'hoedown'

old-time musicians. Bruce hopes to have
audience in the future for his
a wider

simple and straightforward
bowing. He also played what consider
the old Virginia style, more complicated
and stately. His bowing is still the best
style

I

playing, too.
"There's a lot more to old-time music
than people give it credit for," Bruce
says. "Most of what we've learned is
only the remnants of a huge tradition. By
the time anyone realized it was dying
out, there wasn't a whole lot left of it.
At one time old-time music was taken
very seriously. It was like classical folk
music. They had techniques and ways of
approaching music. They didn't just
pass down the tunes, they learned ways
of playing them." Bruce sees himself as

I've ever seen or heard."

is still learning from the Salyer
eleven years, still visiting
after
family
"The
occasionally, and learning tunes.

Bruce

I went
up to visit Grover Salyer
started talking in depth about all the
different lines of fiddle musicians there
had been in Magoffin County. In one
hollow there was one style, in the next
hollow another gang with their own
style. These lines of musicians could

last time

Gustace Wallace ("Gusty") 1972

he

probably
Music
fiddler

be

traced

back

down

was
passed
to the next,

consciously tried

to

and

to play

I

it

Virginia...

from one
think they
the way the

generation before had. They would talk
about how so-and-so did play it right
and so-and-so didn't play it right."
During
Bruce

his

began

last years in
to slow down

Kentucky,
his

tune

collecting.

then I knew Guthrie Meade and
John Harrod, who were also doing a lot
of collecting, and I still had lists of
people to visit. But had begun to feel
"By

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

'Oh, didn't you know? So-and-

Bruce moved from Kentucky to Celo,
North Carolina in the late '70s. For
some time family life has occupied most
of his time; but also during these years
his reputation as a regional stylist has
been growing. Bruce has taught at the
Augusta Heritage Workshop in Elkins,
West Virginia, and the Swannanoa OldTime School in Swannanoa, North
Carolina. In the last couple of years
Bruce has played at the Toe River and
Black
Mountain Festivals,
both in
western North Carolina. This summer
Bruce got first place in the Senior Fiddle
Division at the Fiddlers' Grove Contest.
He
has
mixed feelings about this.
"Contests make me nervous; it isn't fun
"
to play music when you feel like that,

Magoffin County. got to go to his son
Grover's house and listen to the tapes....
When finally heard his fiddling, it was
like

I

irrelevant."

couldn't get that

off my mind. Eventually
fiddler was John
the

I

so just passed away.' The idea of staying
in Kentucky began to seem too painful.
And I didn't know what to do with the
stuff I'd learned. There was no one to
to
seem
with.
It
share
it
began

told Bruce about a fiddler he had spent
time with long ago. He was the best
fiddler Charlie Strong had ever heard.
to
be
fiddler
hadn't
wanted
The
recorded; his sons had convinced him
finally, but had to promise never to let
the tapes be

would knock

I'd hear

old man named Charlie Strong who

an

had been gone, many
had known had died.
on somebody's door and

"During the time
of the old fiddlers

isolated.

I had
learned zillions of tunes,
but didn't feel like it was doing me any

I
started slowing down and
spending more time with fewer people."
In 1976 Bruce took a short-term job
and realized for the
at the Smithsonian
first time that there was an old-time

good.

having become part of that tradition
as much as is possible, now that a lot of
the traditional culture surrounding the
music has been so radically transformed,

music "scene." "It freaked me out! I
wasn't used to anyone else being into
this kind of music. I felt like a curiosity; I
realized

would

I

had

experienced something

I

never be able to share." Bruce

describes

himself

"judgemental"
purist. I made

at
it

as

being

the point.
was a real
hard for myself. I had a
I

chip on my shoulder." What changed
his attitude was going back to Kentucky.

transformed.

"A person who learned it the way I did
pretty rare. just happened to be lucky
enough to get in on the last of it. I threw
myself into this dying culture; couldn't
separate it from the music. Tradition
isn't being handed down the way it once
was because a lot of the traditional
culture is gone. The rules aren't the same
is

I

I

anymore.

�"Anyone who wants to learn these
tunes now, as they once were played,
will have to learn them from younger
people like me. At some point the
people who have invested all the time
and energy into learning a tradition will
be the only ones who are a direct line to
the old tradition.
'The main point is: Is the music going
to die out or is it going to live? And if it is
going to live, what are we going to do to
encourage it? The only people I really

want to be accepted by are the people
got the music from, and I feel like I've
gotten that. I'm one of them as far as I'm

I

concerned."
Bruce

sees

the

music

as

a

real

connection to the past. "The age we live
in, most people don't care much about
the past.

The thing that got me deeply

involved in this music was a connection
to something really ancient. If you throw
yourself into it, you can connect to the
whole flow of history.

I

think the music

essence of where
a

lot of the appeal

passing on their history and the way they
felt about life. Grover Salyer always says
his father was very aware that the music

that he was
was his, but not only his
also the man passing it on from one
generation to another, and he felt keenly

a caretaker of
ancient and carefully cultivated
music. I think people in this age need
that kind of connection and assurance
that the things we love will continue.
"I'm after the qualities in the music
that make it timeless. There is an essence
of it that's still there, no matter how
much culture changes on the surface.
That's what I'm after."

the

responsibility of being

this

Bruce has just completed recording a
cassette tape of his music: Vintage Tunes
From Kentucky. It will be reviewed in the
Nov. issue of The Old-Time Herald.

Alice

Gerrard

has something of the
we came from. That's

that it has for people. The old traditional
people understood this. Even in the old
days they called the music 'old-time
music' because it bonded them to the
past. It was a way of preserving and

L-R: Don Pedi, guitar-Pat

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Sky, fiddle-Bruce

Greene

1987

�ance

on

biggest

those rare sunny

event

The

days.

Seattle is the
Folklife Festival, held

Northwest

in

a
over the Memorial Day weekend
blowout. It's free and
four-day
Center
Seattle
sometimes
grueling.

(home of the 1962 World's Fair) is the
site, and as many as 16 stages are going at
once from 11:00 A.M. until midnight.
One stage is devoted to string bands, one
to old time fiddlers, there are three or
four dance areas, workshops,
panel

countless jams.
the second biggest event

discussions,
I'd say

Schrader.Tony Goldenberg, Stu
Williams, Phil and Vivian Williams,
Gallaher, Kevin Wimmer,
Jerry
Paul Elliott, Gary Lee Moore, Sheila
Blech, Liza Constable, Rich Levine,
Jerry Mitchell, Mike Schway, yours

NMT presents national acts like Cathy
Fink, the Horseflies, Hot Rize,
Ralph Stanley, Dewey Balfa, Bob
Brozman, and Pop Wagner to name a
few who have appeared in the past year.

The University
Bistro, 4135
University Way, has been having some
old-time music about once a month.

truly, or any number of others. We've
even tracked down some old-timers who
have migrated here, like Lee Stripling
from Alabama, the fiddling son of the
legendary Charlie Stripling. Lee likes
to saw one off with friends and visitors.

it's been Hank Bradley and
friends. Mike Seeger appeared there a
while ago. The Seattle Folklore

Lately

Society

has

a

monthly coffeehouse with

The Washington Old-Time Fiddlers
Association, mostly contest-style

and

is

the

Festival of American Fiddle Tunes

at

Wash, held the week of
July 4. Master fiddlers are brought in
from around the country to teach and
demonstrate their various styles. Tutors
are
available and there are several
concerts. The big fiddle contest happens
in Weiser, Idaho about the middle of
June and I'm told there's some mindboggling music in the campgrounds.
Port Townsend,

Kerry

Blech

I

in
the
Bluegrass festivals abound
and
it's
a
Northwest,
always pretty good
bet to find some old-time music at those

events.

as
a

it

particularly
town of

is a

you were still on the Piedmont.

Seattle, there's a couple of
ways to find out what's going on. One is
to pick up a free copy of Victory Music
in

and

try

to

decipher

their

calendar. Another is to pick up a copy of
the Seattle Folklore Society flyer, which
also has a monthly calendar. There are
some sure-bet locales for old-time
action, though. Murphy's Pub, 2110
N. 45th, while usually offering Celtic
music, occasionally has some old-time,
but every Saturday at noon it is the
venue for "Sandy Bradley's Pot Luck,"
over
a
live radio show syndicated
National Public Radio. Sandy's cohorts
in crime are the Canote Twins, who lay
down some raucous fiddle music when
so moved. They usually have two guest
acts per show and often feature "name"

old-time musicians. Another sure bet is
5213
the
New Melody Tavern,
Ballard Ave. Every Monday night there

FREE square and contra dance, and
if you are so inclined, you can sit in with
the band or sign up to guest-call a figure
or two. Tuesdays at the NMT usually
have an old-time music jam session,
though first Tuesdays are given over to
step dancing. Thursdays at the NMT
find a bluegrass jam. The other nights
feature fine local and regional acoustic
music, and a couple of times a month the
is

Port

periodic

who upped and relocated to
Washington some time ago. You'd think

Review

plays "Wolves A-Howling"
Festival of American Fiddle

of Darrington,
town
of Seattle, holds a monthly

Tarheels

When

Lee Stripling, son of Charlie Stripling,

The

northeast
well
as
old-time
jam
It
is
sessions.
bluegrass
interesting place because

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddlers,
puts on many shows and
usually shows up in force at the
numerous fiddling competitions.
with
the
familiar
not
that
I'm
know there are
Portland scene but
some monthly dances there, and every
Sunday night at the East Avenue
Tavern an old time jam and clogging
session materializes. All in all, there's a

a

at

the

Tunes,

in

an

appearance

one rainy

Friday night.

Seattle is big on dances, mostly
contras. The Ballard Eagles is the
home of the regular Thursday night
There are enough monthly
dance.
dances that your month gets pretty busy.
of social
Lots
events,
weddings,
brunches, and benefits occur, so there is
to
no
of opportunity
lack
play
informally or listen. There aren't many
bands with permanent personnel up
here any more due to parental and job
obligations. Some bands have broken up
because personnel have moved away.
Some of the longer-lived bands one
might encounter at dances are Flash in

the Pan, The Mudflat Ramblers, and
Sandy Bradley and the Small

Wonder String Band. There

are

quite

few musicians, regulars on the scene,

who pop up in numerous bands and in
odd combinations. It's likely that in any
given month you'll get a chance to dance
to

Armin Barnett, Bill Meyer, David

C

a

h n

N

a

n

cy

K

a t z

M

oily

Tenenbaum, Laurie Andres, Jack
Link, Roy Marshall, Chrissie
McPhadden, Hank Bradley, Tony
Mates,

Old-Time Notes
from Music Citv

great variety of music. This past year
ethnic music, but Tom

Paley put

A1

Hart,

Barry

old-time community
Come up and see us

sometime.

Townsend, Washington

has seen mostly

a

large and friendly
in the Northwest.

Schultz,

Candy Goldman, Steve Nelson, Jim
Newberry, Mark Graham, Warren
Argo, a Canote or two, Sue Perkins,
Frank Blade, Sue Truman, Bertram
Levy, Howie and Lori Meltzer, Erin

Patty Hall

by

Is there an old-time music scene in
Nashville? To ask the question is usually
." or a
to get a hedging "well, not really.
bemused ".
maybe there is, but you

really have to look for it."
The fact is, there is old-time music in
Music City. You might have to dig
deeply into the Sunday "Showcase" to
find the clubs that offer it; you may have
to drop in and read the bulletin board at
places like Gruhn Guitars down on
Lower Broad; you might have to call up
folks like John Hartford, Frazier

Moss,

Jacky

Christian

or

Anne

Romaine,
usually know where
there is some old-time picking going on.
Though it's not a full-blown "scene," as
may be the case on either coast or in
who

university

old-time music
home in the Mid-South.
hottest old-time bands
these days is the
town
towns,

definitely has a
One of the
around

Stillhouse Reelers. The Reelers, who
have performed in this area for years,
have weathered several hiatuses and
have recently regrouped. With new
energy, they are taking the area by

Andrew Smith, Mike
storm.
DeFosche, Brooke Allen, and Paul
Ritscher offer up stunningly tight
renditions

Carter
of Charlie Poole,
and various other Depression-

Family,
era tunes.

Dressed

in

1930s

Sunday

Best, the talented Reelers are a visual
treat as well. Most recently they played

�the
to

Tennessee Crafts Fair, and according

guitarist/business

Smith,

manager

interested in engagements anywhere
in the country."
May 6 marked an important night for
old-time musicians and their fans in
Nashville. It was the third annual
"are

Tribute

Rodgers

Jimmie

concert,

American Lung
Association and hosted by Nashville's
Bluebird Cafe. The show's roster was
filled with country luminaries and other
sponsored

the

by

not so well know, but equally talented
rising stars and traditional musicians.
Among the old-time performers was

McDonald Craig,

the riveting,

one-of-

renders

who

a-kind singer
Jimmie
Rodgers' songs just like the Blue Yodeler
himself sang them. To see and hear Craig
perform is a haunting experience, so

uncannily

similar

Rodgers'. Craig

is

a

mention for their efforts in occasionally
booking old-time acts. Among them: the
Bluebird Cafe, the Station Inn, the

Sutler,

the

Corner,

and

An

lovers

event
look

Boardwalk,

Douglas

12th and Porter.
that

all

forward

traditional-music
to

each

year

Tennessee Grassroots Days. Held
in
last weekend
September

is

the
in

Centennial Park, this free
unique Tennessee festival.
Offering both music and folklife
demonstrations, Grassroots Days has
enjoyed a 12-year history of growth,
support, and record attendance, despite
dwindling financial support. Regardless
of finances, Tennessee Grassroots Days
has not missed a year.
Nashville's
event

is

a

In

selecting

performers

and

festival staff have relied
flexible definition of what
a
on
constitutes "grassroots culture." As a
result there are delightful surprises every
year at Grassroots Days that confirm
that folklife isn't just old, quaint, and

demonstrators,

rural,

urban,

hard

but

also

ongoing, evolving,
contemporary, and refreshingly
to

is

categorize.
about

information

For

more

Tennessee

Grassroots Days (or to make a much
appreciated financial contribution to the
festival), write to Anne Romaine,
Director, Southern Folk Cultural
Revival

Project,

339

Valeria

Street,

Nashville, TN 37211 (615-331-0602).

Alas, we are out of space for this issue.

his style to
is
warm entertainer, an

engaging storyteller, and continues to be
the star attraction at many old-time

music

gatherings

Southeast.

throughout

the

Also on the bill that night was oldballadeer
Roy Harper, from
Manchester, Tn. Harper usually drives
to gigs in his shiny red 1948 Chevy
Fleetline, dressed nattily in black suit,
white shirt, and bow tie. With lots of
personal commentary on the virtues of
the "good old tunes," he presents his
old-time ballads with accompaniment
and
one of his many
on
guitar
A
former railroadman
harmonicas.
himself, Roy feels a special closeness to
Jimmie Rodgers' material, and at the last
two Rodgers benefits his performances
time

inspired standing ovations.
Along with McDonald Craig, Frazier
Moss, and other traditional musicians,

Roy Harper was featured this past year
in
the Country Music Foundation's

"Tennessee Traditions" Artists-in-theSchool's
Coming up for
program.
Harper will be performances at another
Rodgers tribute concert in
Jimmie
Prairieville, Texas; the Smithville Fiddle

Convention (July 3-4);

and at special
programs for senior citizens, held every
two weeks throughout the summer at

is

a

club that specializes

in

old-

local and
can find

musicians
regular work and where Nashvillians can
always find old-time music. There are,
however, some local clubs worthy of
touring

old-time

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Clark

lacks

time/folk music, where both

Thomas

Middle Tennessee State University.
In a town that devotes its attention
primarily to commercial music (country
and rock) it is difficult to find places to
play (if you're an old-time musician) or
places to listen (if you are an
appreciater). What Nashville (still!)

Reelers L-R (standing) Paul Ritscher, Andrew Smith, Mike
(sitting) Brooke Allen

The Stillhouse

DeFosche

�McMillian

To those of you who may be muttering,
"How can she write a column on oldtime music and not mention.
.etc.,
etc." I offer the assurance that this is but
the first installment of what we hope will

occasional exchanges on MiddleTennessee old-time music. For that to
happen, however, we need your input. If
be

you have any news to share, or if you are
festival director,
an area club owner,
old-time
or
musician, please
folklorist,
add me to your mailing list. Send your
and
announcements (pictures
news
we'll try to use them) to Patty Hall,
too
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,
VA 24333. Till next time, keep on with
the good old music.

Gerrard

Alice Gerrard

Nell Smith, singer, Galax, VA

with

exception

its

is

no

well-deserved

reputation for being one of the centers
of classic old-time music. Fiddlers'
conventions abound, and old-time
for
musicians are in demand
pig
pickins', birthday parties, and other
social occasions. Since 1984, an organi
the

called

Association

Blue Ridge Music

has held

monthly meetings
Recreation Center on the
first Thursday of each month, and has
managed with very few exceptions to
sponsor monthly performances of local
old-time and bluegrass music on the first
Saturday of each month. Conceived of
in

the Galax

and

organized

by

a

group

of

local

musicians, the BRMA (an entirely
volunteer organization) presents older

musicians; those
visible and
as
well
as those
at
home,
play mostly
who are better known; and individual
musicians as well as bands. Some of the
musicians who have performed at the
as

well

as

younger

musicians who may

BRMA shows

be less

are the late

Rafe Brady,

fiddler from Laurel Fork,
a
Galax bluegrass
Va.; Borderline,
group; clawhammer banjo player Bertie
Dickens of Ennice, N.C., youngest (at
85 of the famous Caudill family of oldtime musicians; James Lindsey and the
Mountain Ramblers, still going
strong, whose former members include
such great bluegrass musicians as Otis
the legendary

Burris,
Hawks,
black

Galyean, Charles
others; the Foddrells, a

Cullen

and

country

Stuart,

Va.;

Lovell,

and

together

or

blues

duo

from

near

Evelyn Farmer, Jessie
Dorothy Hess, who play
individually

all

fine

singers and guitar players; Nell Smith,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Fancy

Gap

Lantern

is

held

at

Ruben's Red

on Saturday nights from

8:00-

This dance features old-time
music and is also worth checking out.

12:00

P.M.

About 25 miles away

unaccompanied

an

songwriter

from

the

and

singer
Galax

area;

the

local bluegrass group
features Buddy
which occasionally
Pendleton on fiddle; Clint Howard

Highlanders,

a

and the Blue Ridge Mountain Boys
These
from Mountain City, Tenn.
are just a sampling of some of the fine
musicians
and
old-time
bluegrass
presented by the BRMA. The
Association puts out a quarterly
newsletter and if anyone wishes
information on the shows, meetings,
newsletter, or any other aspect of the
organization, they can write to: BRMA,
P.O. Box 1241, Galax, VA 24333.
There are several very active local
dances with callers and live music. They
feature regional dances such as "Lady
'Round the Lady, Gent Don't Go...,"
"Georgia Alabama," and "Chase the
Squirrel." These are interspersed with
flatfoot dancing, "Paul Jones," waltzes
(which are not exactly danced in classic
waltz step), and other opportunities for
individuals or couples to show off their

expertise.

A

highlight

at

the

dance (for this writer) is
when Tom Norman plays "Backstep
Cindy" on claw-hammer banjo while
Jay Burris flatfoots. The dances tend to
be informal, and beginners needn't be
nervous about not knowing the figures.
You will be pushed and pulled along
with great good humor until you catch

Independence

on.

Two

dances

Mountain

feature

the

Shady

Ramblers, an old-time
band consisting of Whit Sizemore on
fiddle
(occasionally fiddler Greg
Hooven fills in if Whit has to work),
Tom Norman on banjo, and Chester

there

in Sparta, N.C.,
another weekly old-time music
taking place on Monday nights

is

event
from 6:00-9:00

P.M.

at

the

County Senior Center
old-time

Alleghany
classes

and guitar

in

for

fiddle, banjo,
folks ages 16 to 99. Cleo Reeves
Thornton Spencer
teaches
guitar,
teaches fiddle, and Emily Spencer
teaches clawhammer banjo. Most oldtime music lovers are probably familiar
with the work of Thornton and Emily

Gerrard

the Blue Ridge, and the Galax area

zation

1986

old-time music throughout

is

excellent

Alice

There

Alice

the Blue Ridge
by

An

guitar.

1

Around

In &amp;

on

dance band with the additional bonus of
including Tom Norman, one of the
finest traditional singers anywhere, the
Shady Mountain Ramblers have been
playing for the Independence and Fancy
Gap dances for years. Friday nights from
12:00 P.M. the dance is at the
8:00
Fancy Gap School off of Rt. 52 in
Fancy Gap, Va. The Fancy Gap dance
will resume in September after the
cafeteria is renovated. On Saturday
nights from 8:00- 2:00 P.M. the dance is
VFW building
at the Independence
off of Rt. 58 in Independence, Va. Ifyou
like dancing and old-time music, you
couldn't find a better combination than
these dances with music by the Shady
Mountain Ramblers. Another dance in

L-R:

Homer

Cleo Reeves

Reeves,

Brad

Bedsaul,

1987

through their work with the late Albert
Hash in the Whitetop Mountain Band.

People may not be so familiar with Cleo
Reeves (although they may have heard
of his younger brother, Del Reeves of

on
the
Grand Ole Opry,
"Girl
Billboard," fame). Cleo and another

brother, Homer, play guitar duets and
sing songs reminiscent of early Jimmy
Rodgers and Delmore Brothers.
For Thornton and Emily, the idea of
old-time music in a class
teaching
situation started with occasional private
lessons, and the subsequent realization,
as Thornton
said, that "when there's

�only one person that can't play, they're
pretty self-conscious, but if there're a
bunch, they're not." Thornton and
Audrey Hash
along with
Emily,

Albert

Miller,

Rutherford,

Enoch

Hash,

Flurry Dowe, started
holding classes in the Mount Rogers,
Va. firehouse near their home. (They
and

subsequently

received

National

Endowment for the Arts funding for this
project.) About a month later they
received an inquiry from the Wilkes
Community College Continuing
Education program, resulting in their

teaching old-time music classes in West
Jefferson, N.C. Through the interest and
encouragement of Gene Carpenter, an
older banjo student, guitar player, and
Gerrard

singer, Thornton and Emily approached

College, which
Community
sponsor the classes in Sparta as
well as West Jefferson.
The old-time music classes are held in
three rooms on the second floor of the
Alleghany Senior Center in Sparta. In
one room Cleo Reeves teaches guitar.
Porter Fender, a distinguished elderly
gentleman, often plays old-time fiddle
tunes for the class so that guitar students
Wilkes

Alice

agreed to

Thornton Spencer (2nd from left, seated)

and

fiddlers, Sparta, NC

1987

can learn to play backup. Porter learned
to play the fiddle years ago, moved to
Akron to work in the rubber plants,
took up his fiddle again upon retire
ment, and returned to the Blue Ridge.

to each class. Cleo is
helped out by his older brother,
Homer. In another room, Emily takes
one banjo student at a time into a corner
and works with him or her while the
others help each other and practice
tunes in another end of the room. In a
third room Thornton can be found
playing a tune with the fiddle students,
or perhaps
talking with them about
making fiddles or filling bows. When he
thinks a student is ready, he gets them to
a
tune by themselves,
always
play
He comes faithfully

Alice

Gerrard

also

Emily Spencer (seated

encouraging, always supportive.
Sometime before nine o clock, Enoch
Rutherford gets out his banjo, Carol

far

right) and banjo players, Sparta, NC

1987

Holcomb

her guitar, and various others
their fiddles, and the jam session begins.
Sometimes a few play and others listen
or flatfoot to the music, other times

everyone

Richard

joins

in.

Nichols,

so

often

bluegrass

guitar

Every
a

player, and his dad, Oscar Nichols, an
old-time banjo player, will drop by and
play along with those who want to play.

traditional

Older

musicians

are

to attend the sessions as
possible, to play with the
students, show them things, and
provide a first-hand connection to older
traditions.
The old-time music classes provide an

encouraged
often

as

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

encouraging and supportive atmosphere
which to learn. As anyone knows who
has tried to learn to play old-time music,
this is a crucial element in developing a
person's self-confidence as a musician.
Thornton and Emily guess that several
hundred students have passed through
the classes in one way or another. Some
have become extremely proficient; all
have incorporated old-time music into
in

their lives to some degree. To all, it has
provided great joy and enrichment.

Anyone who is interested in more
information about the classes in both
West Jefferson and Sparta can call
Wilkes Community College at 919667-7136. For information about the
Sparta classes, call Carol Irwin at 919-

372-4640

or

372-8840.

�GET YOUR SUBSCRIPTIONS NOW!
For Yourself &amp; Your Friends!
Become a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald. Special rates apply until Sept.
subscription will be $12.00.

wish to buy

subscription to the Old-Time Herald for

a

(Foreign subscriptions

is

a

1

enclosed

$12.00

$10.00

friend

a

1987. After Sept.

$10.00

wish to become a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald for one year
Sept. 1 please enclose $12.00)
1

I

1,

one-year
(After

is

enclosed.

add $4.00)

Name
Mailing Address
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333)
(Send check or money order payable to the Old-Time Herald,

GET YOUR SUBSCRIPTIONS NOW!
Your Friends!
For Yourself
Become a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald. Special rates apply until Sept.
subscription will be $12.00.
Sept.

1

wish to buy

1

subscription to the Old-Time Herald for

a

(Foreign subscriptions

add

is

one-year

a

1

enclosed

$12.00

$10.00

friend

a

1987. After Sept.

$10.00

a Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald for one year
please enclose $12.00)

wish to become

I

1,

(After
enclosed.

is

$4.00)

Name
Mailing Address
VA 24333)
(Send check or money order payable to the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,

GET YOUR SUBSCRIPTIONS NOW!
For Yourself &amp; Your Friends!

Become a Charter Subscriber
subscription will be $12.00.
I

wish to become

Sept.
I

1

a

to the Old-Time

Herald.

Special

rates apply

until Sept.

1,

1987. After Sept.

$10.00

Charter Subscriber to the Old-Time Herald for one year

is

1

enclosed

a

one-year
(After

please enclose $12.00)

wish to buy

a

subscription to the Old-Time Herald for

a

$10.00

friend

(Foreign subscriptions

add

$12.00

$4.00)

Name
Mailing Address

(Send check

or

money order payable to the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA 24333)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

enclosed.

�County

S

■J

Ln
HJ

"HAT-3022
*CO-791
*CCS-110
"CMF-009
"CO-788
"REB-850
*FF-352
MA-014
"CO-790
"TR-5055

*HH-19842
*SOW-7811

CO-545
AJA-5042
CO-509
OH-167

CO-789
MS-45003
CO-526
HER-22

ROU-0057
CO-548
FF-251

CO-406
CO-737
HER-39
CO-712
CCS-

1

02

HER-63

CO-777
ROU-0058
GFS-901
AH-002
AHR-001
YODEL-01

AHR-003

SOUNDA-001

C2T-40149
ROU-0201
*GJ-19861
P-l 3263

"CCS-108
"REB-852
"KING-864

HJ

Kj

CARTER FAMILY "Collection Of Favorites" Fine reissue of the 1930s Decca material
TOMMY JARRELL "Rainbow Sign" Lovely album featuring his last recordings
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Great collection of their 1940s King material
LOUV1N BROTHERS "Radio Favorites 1951 -57" Super LP of early radio broadcasts
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Clydeoscope" Rare and beautiful fiddle tunes by this Kentucky fiddler
BILL MONROE "Classic Bluegrass Instrumental" Great sides from 1950s &amp; 60s
DOC &amp; MERLE WATSON "Pickin' The Blues" Featuring Sam Bush, T. Michael Coleman, etc
JOHN McCUTCHEON "The Wind That Shakes The Barley" Hammer dulcimer album
LEFTWICH &amp; H1GG1NBOTHAM "No One To Bring Home Tonight" Fine, spirited old-time music
NO STRINGS ATTACHED "Dulcimer Dimensions" Dulcimer LP by this popular Roanoke band
HEE HAW GOSPEL QUARTET "Second Edition" Fine down-home gospel singing
JERRY READ SMITH "The Strayaway Child" Much acclaimed hammer dulcimer album

$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.75
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00

TRAPEZOID Hammer dulcimer music
UNCLE DAVE MACON with the FRUIT JAR DRINKERS "Go Long Mule" Fine 1920's/30's sides
JIMMIE RODGERS "Train Whistle Blues" Super reissue of train songs by Rodgers- Import
Vol 2 Classic recordings with the North Carolina Ramblers
CHARLIE POOLE
VERNON DALHART "The Wreck OfThe Old 97" with Carson Robison &amp; Adelyne Hood
DEE &amp; DELTA HICKS "Ballads And Banjo Music From The Tennessee Cumberland Plateau"
WINK THE OTHER EYE Old-time fiddle band music from Kentucky, 1920s/30's recordings
Vol 2 Old-time fiddle tunes and songs from North Georgia
SKILLET UCKERS
EIGHT MILES APART Old-Time music from Patrick and Carroll County, Virginia
Vol 1 Old-time instrumental music recorded in North Carolina and Virginia
OLD ORIGINALS
RIDIN' IN AN OLD MODEL T Toddles, wobbles, rags, and blues from the 1920 s/30's
HOTMUD FAMILY "Meat And Potatoes And Stuff Like That" w/TJLundy on fiddle
ROY HALL &amp; THE BLUE RIDGE ENTERTAINERS Classic pre-bluegrass recordings from 1938-41
RAY &amp; INA PATTERSON "Songs Of Childhood &amp; Home" Lovely mandolin/guitar duet singing
OLD FIVE-STRING Clawhammer banjo solos by Bobby Fulcher, Paul Brown, Andy Cahan, etc
COON CREEK GIRLS Wonderful late 1960s recordings by this popular female string band
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Blue Ridge Cabin Home" Super reissue of the middle 1950 s recordings
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL with Mike Seeger, Brad Leftwich, Benny Jarrell, etc
VIRGIL ANDERSON "On The Tennessee Line" Old-time banjo from the upper Cumberland
Vol 2 More old-time instrumental music from North Carolina &amp; Virginia
OLD ORIGINALS
SEEMS LIKE ROMANCE TO ME Traditional fiddle tunes from Ohio
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American fiddle music from Mississippi
FIDDUNG JOHN JOHNSON Old-time fiddle music from Clay County, West Virginia
CRITTON HOLLOW STRING BAND Traditional music from Paw Paw, West Virginia
ELK RIVER BLUES Traditional fiddle tunes from Braxton County, West Virginia
EDDEN HAMMONS COLLECTION Historic set of traditional fiddle music
BOB WILLS "The Golden Era" Recent 2-LP set of his fine Columbia recordings
TONY RICE "Me &amp; My Guitar" With Sam Bush, Jerry Douglas, Bobby Hicks, Vassar Clements
GRANDPA JONES "Gospel Live From Hee Haw" More fine gospel music w/Grandpa&amp; company
FLATT &amp; SCRUGGS "Songs Of The Carter Family" Fine 1960 LP with Maybelle Carter
MAC WISEMAN "Early Dot Recordings" His classic sides from the 1950's
LOUVIN BROTHERS "The Best Of' Features their top songs from the middle 1950s
STANLEY BROTHERS "Country Folk Music Spotlight" Fine bluegrass LP from 1963

$7.00
$7.00

(Above albums are available on cassette as noted by an asterisk

I*TR-1
[■H

H

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS

Qa
PQ

Sales

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
W
READY FOR SHIPMENT

$10.00

$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
0.00

KJ

^JK

M
1^1
rTB

1

$10.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00
$7.00

[g|

"

")

On all ORDERS in U.S. A please add $1.50 postage &amp; handling
CANADIAN &amp; FOREIGN ORDERS: Add $4.00 postage for first 1-3 LPs, $1.00 each additional LP
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

LJH

LJH

�Record
Artists and record companies-please
send records and tapes for review to The
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 1363, Galax,
VA 24333.

Reviews

songs, one sacred
number, and a fine fiddle-banjo duet to
round things out.
The album is not without its faults,
but I wish to take issue with another

couple of old-time

who dismissed these
performances as "average old-time

reviewer

Black-Eyed

Susan
Robert Sykes
&amp; The Surry

County Boys
Susan

Black-Eyed

Heritage 057 (Heritage Records, Rt. 3,
Box 278, Galax, VA 24333)

I

Don't

Love

Nobody/Paddy

the

on

Turnpike/Old Crossroads/Old Joe
Clark/Sweet Bunch of Daisies/
Honeysuckle/Cumberland Gap/
Willow Garden/Cacklin' Hen/Susan
a
Friend/Peacock
Anna
Gal/What

Rag/Robert's

Serenade/Black-Eyed

Susan

Robert
mandolin
and

Sykes-fiddle/Verlen
and

vocals/Frank

CliftonBode-guitar

vocals/Paul Brown-banjo

A few years

ago

after attending the

Airy Fiddlers' Convention in
North Carolina, my wife and went on a
tour of local radio station WPAQ.
There we heard some wonderful tapes of

Mount

I

bluegrass and old-time musicians
recorded live on WPAQJs "Merry-Goarea

Round" show, and it was then that first
got to hear and appreciate the fiddling of
Robert Sykes. I had seen Robert sitting
in at sessions with his friend, the late
Tommy Jarrell, at the Galax Fiddlers'
Convention, but on those occasions the
center of attention was almost always
I

the

dynamic Tommy.

Robert began playing as a teenager in
the late '20s, and continued making
music with family members, friends,
and neighbors on up into the early '50s,
when he laid his fiddle down for 25
with
In
the late
the
'70s,
years.
of Tommy Jarrell and
he
took
it up again. And now,
others,
happily for us, Heritage Records has

encouragement

an
album containing
released
14
examples of Robert's playing. With the

help of singer and guitarist Frank Bode,

Paul
and
Brown,
Verlen Clifton, Sykes
presents a good sampling of some of his
favorite fiddle tunes, together with a

banjo-picker

mandolinist

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddling." This is solid Mount Airy-style
music of the kind that has
band
maintained my interest in old-time
music over the years, and kept me
the
500-plus miles from
traveling
to
events like the Mount
Pennsylvania
Airy and Galax fiddlers' conventions
every summer.
Most of the tunes here are standards,
strongly associated with this part of the
country. The band works well together
on such warhorses as "I Don't Love
Nobody," "Cacklin' Hen," "Old Joe
Clark" and "Susan Anna Gal." Sykes'
fiddling is at its best on faster break
down tunes like these, where his years of
playing at dances, parties, and schoolbreakings in Surry County leave him in
good standing as a fine dance fiddler.

Especially noteworthy are the unique
treatments given to "Black-Eyed Susan"
(which becomes a whole different tune
in

the

key

of

A),

and

"Robert's

version of "Clinch
Serenade"
(a
does
Mountain
Sykes
Back-Step").
another exceptional job on "Paddy on
the Turnpike" (a version similar to that
who learned
played by Tommy Jarrell-it
from whom?). On "Cumberland
Gap," Paul Brown's clawhammer work
sets off Robert's playing nicely in the
traditional mountain pairing of fiddle
and banjo, while more recent influences
can be heard in Sykes' rendition of
Arthur Smith's "Peacock Rag."
most part, WPAQ's Lew
Heritage Records' Bobby
Patterson have done a good job of
mixing and mastering the cuts on the
album. In a couple of instances tunes
begin with annoying fade-ins (somewhat
abrupt on "Cacklin' Hen), and "Willow
For

Bode

the

and

Garden"
problems
seem to
but these

forgiven.

has

some

recording-level

start. Levels in general
fluctuate a bit here and there,
minor technical flaws are easily
All but two of the album's cuts
from live radio performances.
at the

are taken
The exceptions are "What a Friend" and
"Cumberland Gap."
I
that you buy this
recommend

record, put it on a cassette tape, and play
while you're driving to the fiddlers'
conventions this summer. It'll put you
in the proper mood. (Frank Dalton)
it

�dance to fiddlers Sam Avery and Sam
Green as they tear through "Silk and
Satin" and "Mulberry Gap." Barnicle
was an important figure in the history of
field collecting and Smyth's discovery
allows us to appreciate even more of her
work. (Kerry Blech)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�South in those earliest days of recorded
country music. By presenting a wide
range of examples from a geographical
area covering eight different states, and a
time period spanning 10 years (19281937), the album makes its point well.
These musicians were playing music
that was modern for its time and place,
expanding and updating a rich musical
heritage handed down to them from an

earlier time. The record jacket, one of
County's slickest, shows four musicians
grouped around a spanking-new Ford
automobile, with not a mule or bell-cow
in sight. The influence of jazz, blues, and
swing music on these bands is obvious
after even the most casual listening. Tin
Pan Alley and ragtime have also left their

mark, and the fact that not all Southern
to
the
limited
bands were

string

fiddle-tune

becomes

traditional
quite clear as we listen
nerformances on this record.
fare

to

the

two

Ramblers released
sides in 1937, and they
close the album. Their
and
open
"Franklin County" Blues and "Ridin' in
an Old Model T" are highlighted by the
jaunty fiddling of blind musician Ed
Rickard (an Alabama state champion in
1936), and some choice bass playing
Fiddler Ben
from Wally
Wimbly.
The

Dixie

commercial

his group, the Grinnell
Wolfe's notes for
Charles
Giggers (see
the derivation of the band's name),
perform two tunes influenced by classic
piano ragtime. "Duck Shoes Rag" and

Tinnon

and

"Plow Boy Hop" were recorded by this
in 1930. (The latter tune
is still current in their home state under
"Tennessee
the title "Kansas Rag").
River Bottom Blues," done by Mike

Missouri group

Shaw's Alabama Entertainers, features
fiddle and kazoo. One's appreciation of
this performance may well depend on
one's opinion of the kazoo as a musical

instrument.

At

any

Wolfe

rate,

speculates that this obscure band may
have been composed of black musicians.
The Freeny Harmonizers, in a threeman version of a larger band that some
and
horns
included
times
drums,
recorded "Podunk Toddle" in 1935.
The

from

tune, actually

around

a

medley

Leake

of pieces

County,

Mississippi, features fiddling by Ira Ellis,
the band's part-time trumpet player! In
the case of the Scottdale String Band, a
group hailing from the Atlanta suburb
the lead
of Scottdale,
Georgia,
instrument was usually the banjomandolin. On "Waiting For the Robert

Lee," the sound of that instrument
predominates, despite the addition of a
E.

fiddle.
The

earliest

recording

in

this

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in
1928
was
done
collection
by
McLaughlin's Melody Makers, whose

"Dill Pickles Rag" may be the most "old-

fashioned" sounding piece on the
the
album.
swingiest is
Perhaps
"Skyland Rag," done by the Rector Trio
at their only recording session, in 1930.
Fiddler Pender Rector was one of the
most innovative players in the Asheville,
N.C., area, and if the rest of the material

recorded
included here,

he

is
it

as good as the piece
deserves to be heard on

future reissues.
fine mandolin
Two

Mountain

Toddle"

Rag," are

rags,

"Stone

"Mandolin
Walker's Corbin
and

played by
Ramblers and H.M. Barnes' Blue Ridge
Ramblers respectively. The well-known
"Stone Rag" is here too, in a spirited

version
by
recorded in

Maddux

the

1935.

Virginia musician
some hot fiddling

Family,
West
Jess Johnston does
Legendary

on "Killin' Blues,"
the
equally legendary
accompanied by
Byrd Moore on guitar. (Johnston was
also an accomplished guitarist. Listen to
Old Time Mountain Guitar
County

is from Will
from
Vardaman
Ray, brothers
Mississippi who usually performed as
part of a five-piece band (there were
Their
1930
other brothers.)
three
Will's
feature
a
duo
as
recordings
graceful, eccentric fiddling and
Vardaman's guitar back-up. (The tune
given here has been released before on
Traditional Fiddle Music of Mississippi,

523). "Jake Leg Wobble"
and

Vol.

2

County 528.)
sounds like there's

a lot to absorb
is. Fourteen
there
here,
some of them
solid performances,
superb, are offered up from 12 different
bands. The notes are filled with detailed
information about the musicians and the
music they played. Although most of the
performers on this album were fairly
obscure, and many released only a
handful of commercial recordings, the
music presented here is exciting and
vital. It is music that was not as well
documented as it should have been, but
which has to be heard before we can
draw an accurate picture of the history
of old-time string music in the South.
Ridin' in an Old Model T is another

If it

that's because

example

of

County

Records'

praiseworthy efforts at turning out fine
anthologies of early commercial country
music. (Frank Dalton)

�notes are very brief and do not give
credits concerning the singers or tune
sources. All selections are cleanly played
and recorded, and the result is a tight,
bouncy sound. "Polecat Blues" and
"Looking for Money" stand out as

highlights.
Although all the musicians are very
proficient, the harmonica work of Mark

Graham

is

contributions

exceptional.

His

add significantly to the
overall sound of the band.
On the whole, the stronger half of this

album is by the Tompkins County
Horseflies. The four-member band has a

unique

sound:

their

creative

combination of other musical influences
with Southern string band music can be
readily heard. The outcome is a tight,
"together" sound with a distinctive
rhythm.

The Flies present eight selections, two
of which are songs. Their liner notes are
more complete, with references to the

singers and to tune sources. Jeff Claus
sings lead to Richie Stearns, harmony on
"Zion," a Jamaican reggae number they
learned from The Ethiopians. Richie
also adds his own "Slow Falling Star"
with Judy Hyman on harmony. Other
standouts are "Benton's Dream" and
"Bloomington Breakdown." The dance
floor beckons on these two tunes, for
the music quickly gets into your feet.
This album by the Chokers and Flies
has some strong merits; however, if you
are an old-time purist, straight and true,
you may not care for it. Traditionalists
do not want the heritage to be lost in a

progressive

movement.

Their

dedication and respect for the legacy of
old-time music are qualities of the
highest order. On the other hand, this
progressive sound has a way of appealing
to a newer and younger audience. This
music often bridges a gap between oldtime and other styles of music. Let us
hope this newer audience will grow to
appreciate both the new sound and the
foundation from which it came. (Dale

Morris)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�and

Tommy

Jarrell

head

up

a

Creek
distinguished
Boys grew up during the 1920s when
old-time string music was part of
everyday life. This recording saves for us
the music of a great band that was
carrying on a tradition of an earlier time.
Recorded by Charles Faurot in the
mid-1960s, the album captures some of
the finest old-time music ever recorded.
Faurot used only two microphones in
his recording, one for the fiddle and one
for the banjo, with the accompanying
guitars and mandolin gathered in close.
This process was a success; the sound
quality is good, and it shows that an
expensive studio isn't necessarily
list.

The

Camp

essential.

Freeman of County Records
provides some very interesting liner
notes, not only about the band, but also
about old-time music in general. He
comments briefly yet accurately on the
history of the area and its music. For
anyone new to old-time music, this
album makes an ideal starting point
not only musically, but also historically.
The full and lively sound of the Camp
Creek Boys won them many prizes at
area fiddlers conventions. In fact, they
often had to compete in the same band
category with bluegrass bands. It is
interesting to note that it was only in
1971 that the Galax convention created
for old-time bands.
a separate category
This intense competition helped the
Camp Creek Boys maintain the clear,
on this
driving style demonstrated
album.
There are 12 tunes on this LP. All are
traditional, yet tunes like "Fortune,"
"Let Me Fall," "Fall on My Knees," and
Dave

"Cider Mill" are rarely heard outside the
Mount Airy-Galax region. Two of the
selections, "Old Joe Clark" and

"Soldier's Joy," feature the duet picking
of Fred Cockerham and Kyle Creed. To

this day many enthusiasts list Fred and
Kyle as the best when discussing oldtime fiddling and clawhammer banjo
respectively. Kyle, Fred, and Ernest East

capably switch about throughout the
album. Kyle fiddles on two numbers,
Fred plays fretless banjo on two, and
Ernest fiddles on two (one with Fred),
and he plays guitar on yet another tune.

accompaniment of Paul Sutphin
Collins on guitars, and
Verlen Clifton on mandolin add
significantly to the overall sound of the

The
and

Camp

Ronald

Creek

Boys. Part-time

member

Roscoe Russell of Galax also plays guitar
on one selection. Other highlights are
the strong singing of Paul Sutphin on
"Let Me Fall" and "Lonesome Road
Blues," and Fred's distinctive vocals on

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Fall on My Knees," "June

Apple," and

"Cotton-Eyed Joe."

of the Camp Creek Boys
presented here have passed on. Fred,
Kyle, and Ronald Collins are gone, but
the memories and their music remain.
They left a legacy of the highest quality,
and old-time music is certainly richer for

Three

their contributions. (Dale Morris)

�information

about

the

tunes,

the

repertoires of the musicians, and stories
of their lives in their own words. It is
illustrated with photographs from the
present day and the distant past, and is
altogether as interesting as the record.
There are problems with this record
that listeners will undoubtedly note.
The sound quality is highly variable
since all the recordings were made at the
under
musicians
homes of 'the

circumstances not conducive to studio
perfection. Likewise, the musicians were
no

longer

"in

their prime" when these

recordings were made, and the effects of
age on technical facility are sometimes
noticeable. None of this bothers me.
What comes through so clearly here is a
great and emotional music, cultivated
and nourished by three fine musicians,
throughout the best part of a hundred
years. (Craig Johnson)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�OLD-TIME MUSIC ON THE RADIO
Emily

by

J.

Fine

Early country music by transitional
figures like Jimmie Rodgers, the Carter

Fiddlin' Arthur

and

Family,
played

once

in

a

long

Smith is
while on

2-hour blue
"Sunnyside,"
grass and country music show aired on
WXPN's

Saturdays.

WHYY-FM,

91 FM,

Philadelphia, PA.
Old-time music

topics featured
Boy
"Country

in

one of the many
depth on Bob Carlin's

Rock-and-Roll,"

P.M. on

2:00-4:00

is

Sat.

this National Public

Radio station.
Carlin, a noted
record
producer, and
performer,

of Old-Time
Friends
Music, Goldstein is a primary influence
of the
on the thematic orientation

Brandywine

Brandwine

Mountain

Music

Convention each year.

Tell us where you can hear old-time
on the radio! A listing may be
compiled for inclusion in a future issue.
Write to the Old-Time Herald and
include the following information: the

music

station's call letters, frequency, location,
affiliation (university, NPR, etc.), the
shows which feature old-time music,
times, and hosts. An address and phone
number for the station would be helpful
in confirming this information.

of the radio series "Our
Musical Heritage", looks at facets of
"roots music," with special attention to
music of the southeastern United States
and to new releases on LP and CD.

producer

WXPN-FM, 88.9 FM,
Philadelphia, PA.
hours

Thirty-two

music

can

be

supported,
community

a

week

of

folk

found on this listener-

non-commercial,

station

affiliated

University of Pennsylvania.

with the
Listen for

old-time music as part of the multi-genre
traditional folk and acoustic music
show, "Homegrown," M-F 9:00 A.M.12:00 noon, and especially featured on
Emily Fine's Tuesday 'Homegrown."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

WXDR-FM, 91.3 FM,
Newark, DE
Five

hours of mixed old-time,
and country
bluegrass,

traditional
music,

along with a bit of Cajun and
swing, are broadcast every
on
WXDR. Alice Sebrell's
Porch Blue Ridge," Sat. 9:00-

Western
weekend
"Back

"Fiddle Workshop"
by

11:00 A.M., and Carl Goldstein's "Fire
on the Mountain," Sat.
P.M.,

11:00

Willard Gayheart

A.M.-2:00

contain about one quarter old-time

music.

As chairman

of the board the

This is our first issue and we would
like to hear from you: What do you
think of the magazine? What kinds of
articles, columns, etc. would you like
to see in future issues? Write to us at
P.O. Box 1362, Galax, VA., and let
us hear your voice.
Do any of you have questions and
know where to go for the
answers? Who originally recorded
'Candy Girl'? "What kind of strings
do you put on a banjo ukelele?" "How
can I play clawhammer banjo if my
fingernail keeps breaking?" It takes a
special person to be able to answer all
these and many, many more obscure
questions, as well as many more
common. We have found the perfect
person in "Uncle Harold" who, with
the help of other knowledgeable
folks, will try and answer your
questions. Please direct questions to
"Ask Uncle Harold", c/o The OldTime Herald, P.O. Box 1362, Galax,
VA 24333.

don't

�V

Your Best Source for:
Harmonica
Fiddle
Guitar
Dulcimer
Blues Old-time Banjo
American Folk &amp; Celtic Music

recordings in print, many with
tablature books available if you want to learn the
pieces. We also have Teaching tapes for beginning
advanced
and
dulcimer,
guitar,
banjo, beginning
banjo, and dulcimer.
We

have

over

150

Kicking Mule records have been featured in the
Nature Company and Wireless Catalogs, and three of
our dulcimer albums were Book of the Month Club
"Alternate Recording Selections."
Current new releases include Indie winning The Hills
Horse
of Mexico hv America's favorite cowboy duo
Sense; and If This Ain't Genius by the Cranberry
Lake Jug Band
Ask

for

a

free

copy
of

the

of

best

our
in

page illustrated
Folk Music
48

Kicking Mule Records, Inc
POB 158-OT
Alderpoint, Ca 95411
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

catalog

�BRI

RECORDS

VIRGINIA TRADITIONS SERIES
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI
BRI

001 Non-Blues Secular Black Music
002 Ballads From British Traditions
003 Western Piedmont Blues
004 Native Virginia Ballads and Songs
005 Blue Ridge Piano Styles
006 Tidewater Blues
007 Virginia Work Songs

Prepaid orders only. Add

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1.00 per album for shipping and handling.

money order
Blue Ridge Institute
Ferrum College
Ferrum, VA 24088

Check

$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$7.98
$9.98

or

to:

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

XO
'L3
V.1
#1

HULK RATE
U.S. POSTAGE

PAID

Woodlawn,
24381
Permit

VA
#4

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12112">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 1, Number 1 (Fall 1987)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12113">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12114">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 1, Number 1 (Fall 1987)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Featured articles:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Slate Mountain Ramblers,” by Bill Mansfield, Barbara Poole, Alice Gerrard, Dan Williams, and Richard Bowman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Black String Bands: A Few Notes on a Lost Cause,” by Charles Wolfe&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Bruce Greene, Kentucky Fiddler,” by Hilary Dirlam&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12115">
              <text>1987</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="967">
      <name>1980s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1296">
      <name>1987</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5428">
      <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5469">
      <name>Barbara Poole</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5468">
      <name>Bill Mansfield</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5475">
      <name>Bruce Green</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5417">
      <name>Charles Wolfe</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5470">
      <name>Dan Williams</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5476">
      <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5471">
      <name>Richard Bowman</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5472">
      <name>Slate Mountain Ramblers</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
