<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2523" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2523?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:53:59+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3449">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/dc8f069a0484dc78652e13d19ec29e51.pdf</src>
      <authentication>6a52fd39dfcd00c7296de51a9feffcbb</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12189">
                  <text>Summer $4.50

May- July 1990

THE

OLD-TIME
A

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Fiddlin'
Arthur Smith

Sen
Remembers
A

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Concerts

Camping

Contests
Dancing

The Appalachian
String Band
Music Festival

August 3-4-5, 1990
Camp Washington-Carver
Clifftop, West Virginia
featuring

Critton Hollow
Paw Paw, WV

Fiddle Puppets
Davidsonville, MD

The Red Hots
Winston-Salem, NC

Spring Gap Hellbenders
Lexington, V A

Tunesmith
New York City

Ebenezer String Band
Wallace, WV

Bing Brothers
Harmony, WV

Sponsored by the West Virginia Division

The Festival will sponsor three "traditional"

contests-old-time banjo, fiddle, and string band-

Traditional

plus one "nontraditional" string band contest. In
the traditional old time categories, highest scores
will go to traditional old time tunes played in a

Contest Registration
Bands and individuals who pre-register by July
1990 will be guaranteed an opportunity to

participate
To

in the

register

contests.

On an index card, write the

contestant's name, address, and contest category.
Use a separate card for each entry. Mail to
Contests, Appalachian String Band Music
Festival, Camp Washington-Carver,
Route 1, Box 5, Clifftop, WV 25831. You
will receive a confirmation, along with a schedule
of events, from the Festival office.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Band

1st

2nd

3rd

4th

5th

$750

$500

$300

$200

$100

$500

$300

$200

$500

$250

$175

$125

$75

$500

$250

$175

$125

$75

Saturday, Sunday

Nontraditional Band
Saturday

traditional old time style; in the nontraditional
category, bands are encouraged to apply
traditional string band instrumentation in a
creative manner to alternative tunes, techniques,
and influences. Bands may not enter both.

1,

Culture and History

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

I

of

Fiddle
Friday, Saturday

Ban)°
Saturday

How To Get There

1

Camp Washington-Carver is located adjacent
Babcock State Park, just off scenic Route 60 (the
Midland Trail) in Clifftop, WV, 52 miles from
Charleston and 48 miles from White Sulphur

1
to

you are traveling from the east, use the
Sam Black Church exit off 1-64.
Springs.

If

Free Concerts
Rough camping: $10/person
Parking: $2/car
Good food and showers available
For more

information: (304) 438-6429

�The OLD-TIME HERALD
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
1812 House Ave.

Durham, NC 27707

Editor
Alice Gerrard

Associate Editors
Hilary Dirlam
Phil Jamison
Bill Hicks

Advisory Board
Leftwich, Linda Higginbotham,
W.K. McNeil, MacBenford, Pete Suther
land, Ray Alden, Hazel Dickens, Pete
Kuykendall, John Hartford, Ramona
Jones, Charles Wolfe, Bobby Fulcher,
Brad

Garrison Keillor.

Advertising
Dale Morris, Amy Jones

Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
Board of Directors

Alice Gerrard, Margaret Martin, Bobby
Patterson, Kathy World, Jack Bernhardt,
Art Menius.
No part of this magazine may be repro

in any form without written per
mission from the publisher. Not respon
sible for loss or non-return of unsolicited
photos or manuscripts.
1987 The Old-Time Herald

duced

The Old-Time Herald (ISSN 1040358)

(USPS 002672) is published quarterly
the first of August, November, Febru
ary, and May by the Old-Time Music
Group, Inc. 1812 House Ave., Durham,
NC 27707. Subscription rates payable
in advance. One year
$15.00 (foreign
$18.00 U.S.). Classified
subscriptions
ads cost .50 cents per word, minimum of

$7.00.

Any

grouping of letters

or

numbers is counted as one word. All
classified ads must be received by the
first of the month, one month prior to
publication. Second Class postage paid
at Durham, NC 27701.

POSTMASTER: Send change of address

the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box
51812, Durham, NC 27717.

to

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.

is

a

not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation
under section 501(c) (3) of the Internal

Revenue Code.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�FROM
THE
EDITOR
now you have probably received
Old-Time Music Group, Inc. fundraising
letter. The OTMG, Inc. is the nonprofit, tax-exempt organization which
publishes th eOld-T ime Herald. The goals
By

the

of the

OTMG

To

are:

publish

articles

that

present

traditional American music and culture
from both historical and contemporary
perspectives;

To shape and give voice to the state

of the art through reviews;
To serve as a forum for issues that
concern both the status and form of oldtime music now and in the future;

To help

and serve as

interests

a

establish a network base
national focus for diverse
the

in

traditional

music

community.

the coming year the
will be looking into other
sources of funding but meanwhile we
hope that you will read the letter care

Throughout

OTMG

fully and respond as generously as you
can. As we stated in the letter, we need
funds for hard and software, a part-time

staff person, and for postage and printing
in connection with a major subscription
drive. Thanks for your support.

REGARDING

MAILING

AND

BACK ISSUES: It is important that you
send changes of address as far in advance

of

move

your

as

possible.

do not get forwarded. They
destroyed by the post office and

Magazines
are

returned to us along with notification of
address change. We can send you another
but there will be a delay. NEW SUB
SCRIBERS please allow 4-6 weeks for
delivery of your first issue.
At this time all back issues are avail
able. They cost $6.00 each including
postage and handling. Foreign (surface)
cost $7.00 each. Back issues at this time
are: vol.

1,

nos. 1-8; vol. 2, nos. 1-3.

AD RATES TO GO
recent meeting of the OldTime Music Group, Inc. the board of
directors voted to lower the classified ad
rates for the Old-Time Herald. New rates
go into effect as of the fall (AugustOctober) 1990 issue. The new rates will
be .35 cents per word, $5 minimum.
CLASSIFIED

DOWN.

At

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Southpaw Heard from:
Enjoyed the article on D wight Lamb
the [winter] OTH, but was amazed to
find no mention of the fact that he plays
left-handed (obvious from the photo on
p. 12). I know of a couple of fiddlers
(Claudio Buchwald, Joe Fallon) who
in

have had bass bar/sound post transplants
to accommodate their southpaw bowing;
others of us (yours truly included) just
play

conventionally

and "pass"

as

right-

handers; but Mr. Lamb appears to be
rare

bird

indeed

a

looks like he's
on a conventional
it

bowing backwards
right-handed fiddle! I'd sure like to hear
more about this unique facet of his
playing as well as of other southpaw
fiddlers.

Jim Rosenstock
OXOD Hill MD

[Thanks for pointing this out, and
to

address

Lamb.

question

your

He says

that

we

in order

called

Mr.

"naturally lefthanded," and learned to play on a standard
fiddle, strung up in standard fashion that
he plays "over the bass, backwards." If you
he

is

fiddler and you try this,
completely uncoordinated. Mr. Lamb
points out, however, that if you learn that
way to start out and you are naturally lefthanded the process works the same way as it
does for the right-handed fiddler. He said
are a right-handed

you feel

that he knows many good left-handed fiddlers
and only knows one or two who re-string
their

fiddles.]

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here

In the winter '89-'90 OTH we printed
the fiddle tablature to Ramona Jones'
"Valley Forge." We neglected to inform

readers as to where they could hear the
tune. Ramona informs us that her tape
Backporch Fiddlin' can be purchased for

$9.00 including postage from: Ramona
Jones, PO Box 199, Ridgetop, TN 37152.
We mistakenly printed

in

the winter

'89-'90 OTH that Historical and
Biograph Records are out of business

Arnold Caplin, presi
dent of Biograph Records, Inc., writes us
that "Biograph &amp;. Historical Records has
been in business for the past 25 years and
is still going strong. In addition to LPs
and cassettes we have been producing
compact discs dealing with traditional
and out of print.

blues, and classical music.
OTH apologizes for the error.

jazz,

."

The

7/13-7/15 Brandywine
Convention is actually

Mt.
held
about four miles south of the MasonDixon line in Fair Hill, Maryland. Thanks
The

Music

There

&amp;.

Additions &amp; Corrections

Uncle Dave Macon
Historical Marker Stolen
Charles Wolfe, author
historian has informed

made my summer.

It

1

Graham LP but to no

avail.

Fran and Skip Landt write from
Chicago: "Some of us have plans for an
lunchtime,

old-time

downtown Chicago

maybe

outdoor,
month,

starting

pending

in

or

May

in

jam

once

June

a

(de

at the Old Town
School of Folk Music has taken the lead
on this, and already has enthusiastic
folks from the School and from the
Chicago Barndance Company. Anyone
else, especially fiddle players, would be
most welcome. The location will depend
upon where people work and the jam
a

student

our

of course, be tunes rather than
songs." By the way, belated congratu
lations to Fran and Skip. Their daughter,

some maps."

the beat."

Sue Stude Lundy for calling this to
attention. She adds that "Fair Hill
doesn't have a post office and isn't on

to

This

Congratulations

Brand N ew Old Time Fiddle T unes,
the recording of original compositions
by the old-time Canadian-style fiddler

Joe Pancerzewski [reviewed in the
spring '89 OTH] was selected for in
clusion in the Library of Congress
American Folklife Center publication
American Folk Music &amp; Folklore Record
ings ig 88: A Selected List.

The Bill Sky Family recently received
notification that their cassette album
Let's Have An Old Time Revival (Hearth
&lt;Sc

Home #HH1101) has been placed

in

the permanent collection of the Library
of Congress in Washington, D.C. Since
March, 1989, the Bill Sky Family has
recorded for Heritage Records, of Galax,

Virginia.

Happenings

Bill Whelan writes from Dublin,
Ireland; "We had the Fiddle Puppets
they worked very hard
[over here]

and were very welcome. Kenny Hall
and his band were over again. I love to
hear Kenny. But the best old-time music

I

ever heard

will,

Ginny Alice Landt

was

a

surprise visit from

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

past

Clawhammers

is

"already moving to

the

spring
had

a

3

day

Chicago

intensive

workshop with Dwight Diller. You
old-time banjo players who are headed
Chicago way, contact the Landts c/ o the
Old Town School of Folk Music, 909
W. Armitage, Chicago, IL 60614, if you
want to try and set up a banjo workshop
gig-

exciting new radio series,
"Southern Songbirds: The Women
of Early Country Music" is finished
An

soon all across the
country. "Southern Songbirds" is in 13
parts, each focusing on the female
pioneers of country and old-time music.
Some of the artists profiled include
Wilma Lee Cooper, The Carter
Family, Matokie Slaughter, Ola Belle
Reed, Ramona Jones, and many more.
The producer of this the series is Rachel
she can be contacted
Goodman
through Appalshop, Inc., 306 Madison
St., Whitesburg, KY 41858 or call 606633-0108 for more information. Be sure
and

will

be

honoring famous old-time banjoist, song
ster, and entertainer Uncle Dave
Macon. The only state historical marker
in Tennessee devoted to a musician, it
was located near Kittrell, Tenn. in front
of the Coleman Cemetery where Uncle

Dave was buried. Inset into his tomb
stone was a photo of Uncle Dave which
was also taken. Dr. Wolfe is spearhead
ing a fund raising campaign to raise the
necessary $1025.00 needed to erect
another marker. All contributions to
this fund should be made out to the non
profit Tennessee Folklore Society and
mailed to: Tennessee Folklore Society,
c/o Dr. Charles Wolfe, Box 201

MTSU, Murfreesboro, TN 37132.

weather). Jan

the

upon

Wishinsky,

apparent

has resulted in the dis
appearance of the state historical marker

Jody Stecher and
a
Scottish fiddler Alasdair Fraser
a couple of
been
over
has
Jody
great gig.
times before and is always an inspiration.
have done just about everything possible
to get the Mark

music

vandalism

Bruce Molsky and his brilliant band,
Ricky, Mary Ann, and Audrey. That's
the kind of fiddlin' I've been preaching
for years over here.
Last night we had

and

us that

aired

Music Contest Brochure
The Folk Arts Program

of

the

Tennessee Arts Commission

announces the availability of a new folk
music publication- Fiddle and Old-Time
Music

Contests

in

Tennessee

is

an

in

formational brochure about the annual
events throughout the state where com
petitions are held in traditional country
music and dance. It was funded by a
grant from the Folk Arts Program of the

National Endowment for the Arts.

Fiddle and Old-Time Music Contests in
Tennessee provides an introduction to
T ennessee's tradition of stringband music
contests and a directory of information
about the 27 contests currently held in
the state. One section of the publication

explains how contests are organized
conducted. Another section deals
the history and tradition of fiddle
tests, which gained wide popularity

and

with

con
after

the Civil War and have in recent decades
embraced elements of more modern
country music styles alongside the "oldtime" sounds that preceded them. A
fold-out directory on the inside maps the
locations of current contests and gives
details on customary annual dates,
specific contest categories, prize money,

and call or write your local public radio

and contacts for further information.
Illustrations include rate historic graphics
and photos.
The publication is free, and can be
obtained upon request from the Folk
Arts Program, Tennessee Arts Com
mission, 320 Sixth Ave. No., Suite 100,

station and ask them to
Songbirds."

615/741-1701.

air

"Southern

Nashville,

TN

37243-0780,

phone

�There
in the

Digest.

is an

interview with Jim Watson

current

former

issue of The M andocrucian's

As many

member

of you know, Jim

is

a

of the Red Clay
now touring with

Ramblers. He is
Robin and Linda Williams

and

per

forming as one-half of the Durhambased duo, Pinky Wyoming and Duke

LaCrosse.

The following photo was sent to us by
Loyal Jones, director of the Appalachian
Center at Berea College in Kentucky. He
wrote: "The enclosed picture was sent to
me by Chester A. Nolan, who grew up
in Harlan County, Kentucky, and who
now lives in Madison Indiana. It is a
picture of fiddlers who came for a

fiddling contest at Berea College in 1917.
The contest was put on by Elijah
Franklin Disney, who went by the
name of Frank, and who was the principal
of the Berea Grade School. Mr. Nolan
who sent the picture is the first person
on the left in the front row. The man
who won the contest was none other
than Fiddling Doc Roberts, from
Madison County, who arrived too late to
have his picture made but who borrowed
Mr.

Nolan's

brand-new

Montgomery

Ward fiddle to win the contest."
Mr. Jones asks if any OTH readers can
identify any of the fiddlers in the photo.

Jones said that according to Nolan the
fiddlers are from Tennessee, Georgia,
Alabama, Virginia, and North Carolina.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Howard Vokes, "Pennsylvania's King
of Country Music" writes that his friend
"Big John" Trimble of Radio WRVA,
Richmond, Va., is looking for "live
taped shows/albums
Dominion Barndance so that
of

the

Old

he can use

them on his all night country shows
seven nights per week from midnight till
4:30 a.m. Anyone who can help him
should contact "Big John" T rimble, Radio
WRVA, Box 1516, Richmond, Va.
23212. Mr. Vokes writes that "John

plays plenty of bluegrass and old-time
artists on his all-night Truckers Country
Music Show. .he tells us that 90% of his
mail [is] for the old style of country
music.

Folk Notes

is

a

"bi-monthly publi

cation of San Diego Folk Heritage, Inc.,

dedicated

non-profit

organization
preserving and promoting the folk arts

California."

Southern

a

to
in

newsprint

In

it contains reviews, articles, and
information about local music and dance
events. Write 1112 Judy La., Cardiff,

format,

CA 92007.

The Music News from the
Chattanooga Area Friends of Folk
Music is a one-page letter sent to
members,

and

includes

local music events

items.

Write

as

well

P.O.

a

calendar of
brief news

as

Box

4527,

Chattanooga, TN 37405.

The Seattle Folklore Society "Flyer"

available to members. The Flyer
contains lots of local music and dance
news, and a calendar and information on
local music and dance events. Write the
Seattle Folklore Society, c/o 6556
is

Newsletters
In the interests of helping to promote
local grassroots events, and for the
benefit of those of you who may be
vacationing or taking trips to other parts
of the country, we like to occasionally
publish the names and addresses of
various local publications you might
want to obtain. These are publications of
not-for-profit organizations.
The Charlotte Folk Music Society
Magazine is available to members.
Published monthly it features profiles of
local and visiting performers, a calendar

music and dance events, and
more. Write to the Charlotte Folk Music
Society, PO Box 9007, Charlotte, NC

of local

28299.

Palatine Ave. North, Seattle, WA98103.
The New Mexico Folk Music &amp;
Dance Society ("Folkmads") publishes
and monthly calendar which
a "Notes"
they send out to members. It includes
information on local music and dance
events. Write to the New Mexico Folk
Music &amp; Dance Society, PO Box 4042 1
Albuquerque NM 87 196. H

�The Dance Beat
VISIT

A
by

Ruth Pershing

One hot Sunday afternoon in the late
spring I headed from my home in Alamance County, North Carolina, past
Raleigh toward Zebulon. I had met Algia

Mae Hinton and worked with her, her
son Willette and their cousin-in-law,
"Junior" Thomas, at various times before,
but I wanted to be with them at their
home, with the whole family. I was
looking for buck dancing and for the
people who do it. I was looking for the
living tradition that is at the root of
Broadway and jazz tap. I was after the
community of family dancing that got
Sandman Sims started and sent Buck and
Bubbles to Hollywood. But I was
searching for the steps and rhythms that
everyone could do, not just the few who
took it to the heights of film and stage.
My directions were vague; I knew I
had to turn left on a dirt road after a

church somewhere past Zebulon. That
could be just about anywhere. I stopped
at the nearest country store, one with

sparkling new pavement and

a

big sign.

knew Miss Algia Mae. It was not
before
1 was
long
driving down a winding,
dusty road to find the described three
mobile homes in a row. There were cars
parked randomly around the middle
trailer; it was obvious where to go.
Walking in the front door 1 was

They

all

confronted

by

a

row of people, young

courtesy

Folklife

Office,

N.C.

Arts

Council

and old and all shapes and sizes, dressed

Algia Mae Hinton, Eno Valley Elementary School,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Durham, N.C. May

5,

1982

in Sunday clothes having just come from
church. They sat shoulder to shoulder
on chairs and couches that lined the
perimeter of the room. They didn't
exactly look ready to jump up and dance.
There was an awkward silence which I
broke with a tentative "Hey everybody,
is this Algia Mae's?" Algie Mae's youngest daughter, Elgia, jumped in with a grin

recognized as her mother's, and proceeded to introduce me to every single
person there, one at a time. She told me
how each fit into the extended family
tree. Knowing that Algia Mae was the
youngest in a family of thirteen children,
that Elgia was the youngest of seven, and
that they almost all had families, too, I
knew I would never keep them all
1

�Some Steps From the Dancing

Abbreviations Used
Note: The following terms are used

in

various combinations

T

(circled) sequence repeats beginning here
(underlined) bears weight
flatlooted step
heel contacts floor and stays there
ball of foot contacts floor and stays there

Tap

ball of foot

beat

lift

hi

St
H

drop

slide
shuffle
f,

b

chug
cl

&lt;

b

contacts floor and

to

produce

the

of

Algia Mae Hinton

Step Notation
necessary step building blocks.

In

lifts up

from floor and let beat back down

from raised position let drop to floor
move in contact with floor

double contact of foot to floor (without weight), usually brushing slightly forward then back
directions: forward, back
a

more familiar term for slide

clap
may be left out for variation

accented beat

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

b

(weight bearing slide back)

�table,

a

few

scattered chairs and

a

lot of

open space. Light came from a single
bulb in each room. The walls were made

pressboard and the ply
wood floor sounded solid but resonant
underfoot.
Some of the young men who were first
of patchwork

to arrive started the balls rolling on the

pool table. The jukebox started rocking
and there were soft drinks all around.
There was no homemade entertainment
yet, but there would be. The singing
started first, with an older sister of Algia
Mae's; it came straight out of the gospel

tradition. The electric guitar and bass
had made it up from the kitchen below
and soon there were three or four voices.
After a few songs no one was holding

back. The harmonies provided an unusual
to the pool game in the
next room.
W illette was getting restless. After the
next song he rolled up the sleeves of his

accompaniment

tailored shirt and started
"slapping." In wing-tipped shoes, his feet
stepped alternately, keeping up a quick
even beat as he clapped lightly with flat
palms in the little space of time between
foot sounds. With this insistent rhythm,
Willette stepped around the room, en
ticing a critical mass of people into a
French

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(brush-step
covering

a

on the ball
lot of distance

of the
and

foot)
pumping

his arms as he moved, either in forward
or reverse. He had also picked up some

steps from a few more unlikely sources.
One he called the "Joe Louis" was just
that, a sort of boxing hop. Another he
called the "Curly Shuffle"
yes, you
guessed it right out of "The Three

Stooees."

One young man known as Shorty,
dressed in a now rumpled white suit with
tie askance, went straight for the wall
when his turn came. It was not to avoid
dancing, though. With nose to the wall,
he put together a few short riffs. While
tapping the board in front of him with
one foot, he slid forward on the other
foot; shsh-thwap came the sound. An
insistent, catchy combination of these
made everyone smile. It drove Willette
right up the wall too, but his variation
was with his back to the wall. He grinned
at the white suited fellow with a friendly
challenge in his glance. They traded off
for a few rounds, then passed the turn on
to the next. A little girl darted into the
circle and received the most encourage
ment of all for her brief twist and few
stamps. This must be how they had all
begun.
Algia Mae was the last to dance. She
raised her head up as though looking at

learned from Beverly Cotten when they
did school programs together.

vocabulary of sounds was exten
used every surface of the
bottoms of her shoes to slide, tap, touch,
Her

sive.

She

scuff, slap, and stamp, changing weight
imperceptibly from foot to foot all the
while. Some patterns were long, some
short. There were teasing silences thrown
in; Algia Mae then caught again, making
it spare to the point of disappearing as
she moved into a slow twist, using hips
a circle, and watching
everyone watching her over her shoulder.
At just the right quiet moment, she let go
a sudden cascade
of syncopation. Then

and all, turning in

continued

on

page 44

Council

a

clearly worn path, across an open field to
a small frame building backed up against
some trees. Other folks drove along the
road and lots of children ran up to the
building, darting around in the field on
the way. The building was plain, with a
small porch across the front and two
doors flanked symmetrically by two
windows. Inside there was simply one
long narrow room on each side. The
right-hand room had a pool table as its
centerpiece. There was a bar and a
refrigerator along the back wall. The lefthand room housed a juke box, a metal

Arts

I

a

N.C.

simply "Let's go!"

Wondering where we were headed,
followed Elgia out behind the trailer
few hundred yards up a hill along

Office,

wall-to-wall textured carpet. Her greet

ing was

pattern of keeping time. Even as turns
traded the beat continued on. If no one
took the next turn right away, Willette
or Algia Mae nodded to someone new as
everyone else egged them on.
No two people danced alike. The
more creative and original a step or lick,
the more reaction it drew from the circle,
and it served as a challenge to the next in
the middle. There were similarities be
tween dancers, especially in rhythm or
pattern of syncopation, but each person
had a step repertoire entirely their own,
however small or big it was. It struck me
then
how could a person learn to dance
if not by imitation? This aesthetic seemed
one to transmit in oral tra
a difficult
dition.
Each of the people who danced had a
unique basic pattern they returned to
over and over, a kind of time step,
though shorter in length than most tap
time steps. Willette's was a flatfooted
syncopated rhythm in groups of three
beats. He also did a series of "flaps"

guitar playing of a tune called simply
"Buck Dance." It is quite a show piece,
one she told me she had put together
while courting when she was young. I
could hear the tune in her feet. Every
subtlety of accent and timing was there.
Her feet remained close to the floor and
moved little. T o tell exactly what she was
doing, you would have had to kneel right
down on the ground and watch from just
a few inches away.
She did a couple of steps whose names
I
knew. One step she called "shoveling
coal, like my daddy used to do." I never
did figure out whether her daddy
shoveled coal or taught her that step.
Another step was like one I had seen in
the mountains called "wring the chicken's
neck," done with much twisting in the
ankles. I also recognized the familiar
"buck and wing," and some two-footed
chugs, which Algie Mae said she had

Folklife

and two small children arrived, "Mama"
came in to the living room. Algia Mae let
loose her teasing grin and cut a step or
two, even though she was in bare feet on

continuous

courtesy

ation. Elgia telephoned her brother
Willette, chiding him for not getting
there sooner, and just after he, his wife,

for them, each with their own

Manley,

I

I

Roger

I

near the door. One at a time, each person
in the circle had their turn buck dancing
in the middle, while the others slapped

someone watching from above, waiting
a cue. Her face was in an almost-smile
into the middle, still
as she moved
slapping. She began with a rhythm
knew well, one she used in performance
to her own solo
as an accompaniment
for

by

I

I

Mae her son Willie Earl and his cousin
plugged in an electric guitar and bass in
the adjoining kitchen.
heard the familiar
had heard before,
style
picking
piedmont
this time coming from the next gener

a

loose circle. Thinking would just watch
at first,
found myself sorely mistaken.
Willette gave me no choice. I was drawn
away from my comfortable leaning post

Algia Mae Hinton

photo

straight. They each greeted me and shook
hands, somewhat formally.
I was
hoping to see at least one familiar
face soon, and as we waited for Algia

�BANJOS IN THE DAYS OF COMPACT DISCS
by

Mike Fitch

The 36-year-old cabinet-maker sifts
through some tools on his workbench as
he patiently waits for my final question.
He seems at home here in his large and
slightly cluttered one-room workshop in
Blacksburg, Virginia. He is a somewhat

cherubic-looking man,

a

bit short and

a

stocky, wearing two flannel shirts
over a yellow T-shirt, a pair of jeans, and

bit

brown workboots. He adjusts his faded

red cap, which reads
the front, as my

PEACHTREE across

long-winded query
finally reaches its point: "Did you ever
regret that you didn't settle down to a
nine-to-five kind of job, or take another
direction, or do you think you pretty
much found your calling, making these,
playing when you can?"
I like
to just
"Oh, I don't know.
kinda have it as my extra hobby," says
Mac Traynham. He speaks slowly in a
slight southern drawl, forming his words
with care. "I feel at home in old-time
music. I identify with what old-time
music represents to me, which is rural
mountain culture, the best parts of it, of
the early days. I like to identify with the
ways of rural people that are independent

and self-sufficient. The music helps me
to feel like I'm a part of an ongoing
tradition of holding fast to roots, and to

things that have not been improved
upon in the modern evolution of things."
He smiles fondly, contemplating his long

time hobby of playing and making banjos.
T o someone such as myself who wasn't
raised in Appalachia, and who is not
familiar with banjo music, the banjo is a
strange instrument, perhaps first heard
of in the tune "Oh Susannah," and only
caught in glimpses later in life in comic
strips like "Snuffy Smith," or on Saturday

broadcasts

of "Hee-Haw." Certain
questions would inevitably come to mind.
Why is it half drum and half guitar? Why
does that one string start a little bit
higher up the fretboard than the other
four?
A look

at the history of the banjo
clear
some of the mystery.
helps
Compton's Encyclopedia states that the

to

"African stringed
instrument," and was "brought to
America by the first Negro slaves." Once
in America, according to Funk and
Wagnall's New Encyclopedia (vol. 3,
1983), the banjo appeared in a variety of
banjo originated

as an

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

designs, orginally featuring fretless necks
and four strings with the body sometimes
fashioned from gourds. A fifth shorter

string appeared by 1840

being popularized by
Walker Sweeney, who

as

the banjo was

men

like Joel

credited by
many as being the creator of the modern
version of the instrument. After the
Civil War, large-scale manufacturing of
banjos began, introducing frets to the
fingerboard by 1890. The banjo has now
is

reached a fairly static stage of develop
ment, the most common banjos featuring
five strings, frets, and a circular body
covered with a tight "drumhead." Mac
Traynham has hand-crafted over two
dozen five-string banjos.
Mac

was

born on May 6,

1954,

in

Suffolk, Virginia. His aunt, who is a
geneologist, has determined that he is of
Scots-Irish and French-English descent.
His family on both sides is deeply rooted
in Virginia, possibly from as far back as
the 17th century.

Traynham's first musical influences
appeared early in life. He describes his
father (a Presbyterian minister) as being
a folk
musician, while his mother (a
teacher) had some classical training. His
close proximity to his father's church
and his regular presence at Sunday family
gatherings helped to strengthen his trad
itional values, which ramain intact to
day. For example, he indicates a
great respect for his relatives, especially

this

his maternal grandfather, a hard-working
dairy farmer who he cites as a role
model. His only disagreements with his

grandfather involve the fact that Mac

is

the more conservative of the two: "He's
not as much of an old-timer as I wish he
was," he says with

a

laugh.

During his school years, Traynham
learned to play a variety of instruments:
piccolo, flute, piano, harmonica, and
guitar. By the time he started college he
was primarily playing guitar, and had
started learning banjo. His interest in the
banjo was sparked by seeing it played on

�the Grand Ole Opry TV broadcasts in
the '60s, and later at local bluegrass
conventions. In 1974 Mac visited the

famous Galax Old Fiddlers Convention
for the first time, and was inspired

enough

by

the

to

performances

hire

a

friend to build him a banjo, and began to
take a more serious interest in old-time
and bluegrass music.
Via LP reissues of old 78 recordings,
Traynham became familiar with oldtime music greats such as the Carter
Family, the Delmore Brothers, the Blue
Sky Boys, the Skillet Lickers, Charlie
Poole, Uncle Dave Macon, and Charlie
Monroe. He also listened to Bill
Monroe's Blue Grass Boys, the Stanley
Brothers, and others who defined the
bluegrass style, but as time went on he
concentrated more and more on learning
to

old-time

play

performs
different

music. Today
locally with a number

he

of

musicians. He and his wife,
Jenny, (the Southern Mountain Melody
Makers) recorded an album of duet
singing, When the Roses Bloom in Dixie
land
[Heritage 058, reviewed in the
winter '89 OTH].

Mac has been making his living pri
marily as a woodworker since about
1979. The first instrument he built was a

dulcimer to give

friend

a wedding
friends
who
by
present.
built banjos and guitars, he pursued his
interest in making instruments by visiting
master craftsmen such as the late Kyle
Creed, a Galax, Virginia banjo maker

to

a

as

Later inspired

player; Albert Hash, a Grayson
County, Virginia fiddler and fiddle
maker; and Wayne Henderson, a guitarist
and guitar builder also from Grayson
County. In 1978 Mac was commissioned
and

friend to build his first banjo, and
by
has been making them ever since.
Currently he makes about two banjos a
year. He earns his living making custom
a

cabinets and furniture

in his

Blacksburg

shop.

"That banjo, like 1 say, is made
from scratch, that's the truth."
As

I

set up the tape recorder

in

Mac

Traynham's shop for our second dis
cussion, he points out a song that is
coming from a small radio tuned to
WPAQ740 AM, a station from Mount
Airy, North Carolina. The reception is
scratchy, but he doesn't seem to mind; a
woman is playing on a banjo that he
made for her several years ago. "Now
you can say that you heard one of Mac
Traynham's banjos on the radio," he
says.
He later brings out a banjo that he has
been working on for a long time: one that
isn't for sale. It is only fitting that a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Southern Mountain Melody Makers (Mac

craftsman should

be the one to enjoy his
best work, and this banjo is beautifully
made. The detail is flawless, the sound is
bright and clear, and 1 can't help won

dering, how did he do

it?

Each instrument can take from 30 to

38 working hours to complete,

depend

ing on how intricate it is. After noting
any specific requests from the customer,
his first step in making a banjo is forming
the neck. He begins by using a band saw
to "rough cut" the profile of the neck

from a 36" x 2" x 2.5" block of bird's-eye
maple, walnut, or cherry. Once the side
profile has been sawn, the neck is re
inforced by a steel bar that is embedded
lengthwise in a groove made using a table
saw. Then, the top surface of the neck
where the fretboard and peg head will
eventually be is sanded flat.
The next step is to glue on a peg-head
overlay usually consisting of a thin piece
of ebony or rosewood. He later forms
this part of the banjo in a shape that is a
derivative of traditional styles, with the
pegs pointed straight towards the back of
the instrument. The only major differ
ence between a peg head from the turn of
the century and a Mac Traynham peg
head is that the former featured wooden
friction pegs, while the latter has factory-

produced geared metal pegs.
Once the peg head assembly is at
tached, a long, thin strip of ebony is
carefully measured and slotted for frets
before being glued lengthwise to the
neck to form a durable fretboard. Now

&amp;.

Jenny Traynham)

that various

neck pieces have been put

together, a tedious process of shaping
and finishing begins. He uses a band saw,

draw knife, spoke shave, rasp, file, and

in successive steps in order to
create the desired shape and texture.
One of Traynham's trademarks is a

sandpaper

decorative

groove

which

is

carved

lengthwise along the back of the neck
during this finishing stage.
The neck is then left alone for a while
as the pot (the round wooden hoop that
forms the body of the banjo) is made.
Using a perfectly circular bending iron
used by the late Kyle Creed, Mac forms
the pot gradually by layering thin strips
inside

of one another. This process
involves boiling strips of wood measuring
approximately 38-40" long by 1/8 to
3/16" thick by 2 to 3" wide. The strips
become very flexible, and are thus
wrapped around the circular outside
surface of the heated bending iron. When
dry, the bent strips are cut to fit into a
circular form and glued to each other
layer by layer. Once it has reached a

thickness

of approximately

is

turned until

3/4",

the

perfectly round
and smooth. A decorative wooden "cap"
is then glued to the bottom of the pot.
Once the hoop is formed, 20 or 24
pot

it is

holes are drilled evenly spaced around
the circumference of the pot in order to
accomodate hardware that will pull the
drumhead tight. A metal tension hoop,
to which the metal hooks will attach,
must then be purchased, or made by

�is sanded flat
before glueing on the peghead overlay.

area.

Next, lengths of fret wire are epoxied
into the slots previously cut into the

photo

by

Bill

Price

fingerboard.

is

done with

Once the hardware has been attached
to the pot, and the "drumhead" has been
stretched over a circular tune ring and
secured to the pot, the neck and body of

Traynham
by
photo

photo

The top surface of the peghead

additional

Final shaping of the banjo neck
a wood
file and elbow grease.

Mac

Price

by

Bill

Price
Bill

by
photo

order for the peghead to be wide enough,
wood or "ears" are glued to
either side of the neckpiece in the peghead

In

A band saw is used to cut out the

according
peghead overlay.

shape

to

layout

lines

peghead
on

the

of playing, something's buzzing," he says.
"I'll have to figure out where that is, and
do something to adjust for it." But for
now, the only thing left to do to this

banjo

is

to play it. H

the banjo are carefully assembled. The
final steps in the process involve "setting
up" the strings on the instrument. Mac
uses elkhorn to make both the long nut
at the seam between the peg head and
fretboard, and the small nut for the next
short G-string that starts at the fifth fret
on the neck. After tuning pegs, tailpiece,

a wooden
bridge
approximately the center of
the drumhead, and is adjusted as the

and strings are attached,
is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Price

finishing for himself

Bill

he is

features one that was hand-made by Kyle
Creed.
Returning to the fretboard, the next
step is to make any decorative inlays that
are required. Thin pieces of abalone
clam shell are shaped into designs from
patterns, and are then carefully embedded
into the ebony surface of the fretboard.

is tuned. At last, a banjo is born!
Mac picks up his newly-made banjo.
He has been setting up the strings during
our conversation, and now the instrument
is finished and tuned.
But he doesn't
completely rule out the possibility of a
few future adjustments. "I may play
tonight, and find that at a certain intensity

banjo

by

excellent banjo

at

M ike Fitch

is from Baltimore, Md., and
civil engineering at Virginia
Tech in Blacksburg, V a. He plays guitar
and harmonica as a hobby.
is

a

senior

photo

hand if it is not of the 11" standard
diameter. Mac prefers an unplated brass
tension hoop because it is more trad
itional. It is also hard to find, but the

placed

in

Holes for tuning pegs
by using

a

drill press.

are

drilled precisely

�Bobby McMillon

BLUE RIDGE STORY TELLER

by

Hilary Dirlam

just continued on with it. It didn't die
out. You wouldn't think it in this day
and time, but the Appalachians weren't
really a Bible belt at one time. Now
'
people like to think: W ell, if only it was
like the good old days back when every
body went to church,' but it never was
like that. There were fewer churches

back

then,

and

more

individualistic

thinking people. Lots of our ancestors

photo

by

Michael

Hopson

came here to get away from organized
religion.

L-Marina

Hollar, R-Bobby McMillon, Jan. 1990, Burnsville, N.C., Yancey Nursing Home.

Bobby McMillon, 38 years old, has lived
most of his life in Lenoir, North Carolina, in
the foothills of the Blue Ridge. Coming from
a long line of mountain people well-versed in
the art of making words live (I'm seventh or

eighth generation,"

he

says),

he is

himself

gifted storyteller and ballad singer.
At times working in a furniture factory

a

or

substitute teaching, Bobby has nonetheless
maintained his lifelong vision of bringing
the past to life for others as clearly as the past

H.D.

lives for him

Talking with a born storyteller is a
fascinating experience. A factual state
ment, half-finished, gives way to a
description of a childhood experience,
which free-associates into an anecdote
about a long-dead relative, somehow
gently transforming into a discussion of
regional pronunciations or versions of
ballads. Bobby Macmillon, quiet-spoken
and mild-mannered, filled up lots of tape
for me. But was afraid that what he had
said was too rambling, that we hadn't
1

gotten enough hard information, that
there was too much theorizing, that the
interview had gone in concentric circles
rather than in nice, modern, easily
digestible straight lines. I should have
had more faith. Bobby covered every
so well, in fact, that it
thing nicely
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

seems unnecessary for me to interpose a
lot of my own words into this article. A
storyteller can surely tell his own story.
And if in talking Bobby lets one thought
lead into another organically
well, one
of the greatest storytellers of the 20th
century, James Joyce, became world
famous for doing just that. Perhaps it's
no accident that Bobby sees his Celtic
identity as being one of the most
important aspects of his choice of

avocation.
"There's a theory I believe," says
Bobby, "that southern mountain people
have retained their Celtic heritage. They
have such an independent nature that it's
almost mystical. Two guys might be
fighting and one of 'em see a pretty
woman walk past, and the other would
kill him while he was looking. Celts can
be deterred from their purpose easily
because they're dreamers, but they're
among the fiercest fighters that ever was;
it's born in 'em to fight, just for the sheer
fun of it. If there ain't a good reason for a
fight, they do it just to have a big time.
"When the first priests and monks

were preaching Christianity in northern
Europe the clergy were just about the
only ones that could read and write. The
culture of the common people was al
ready thousands of years old, and they

"My daddy's people were Scots-Irish.
The story goes that five brothers came
over with their mother from Ireland, and
they brought some Irish 'taters with
them. They landed in either Charleston,

or V irginia. At least one
of the brothers settled in North Carolina.
His oldest son was my great-grandfather.
There's not many generations between

South Carolina,

me and Ireland, because my grandfather
was born when his father was 71.1 used
to think that 7 1 was a might old to have a
child without some suspicions to it, but

my aunt has a picture of both of them
together, and there ain't no doubt.
During the whole 19th century there was
only two generations of my family born.

"Well, my great-granddaddy was born
in

North Carolina

in

1829. He had some

brothers that migrated to east Tennessee,
up above Newport. That's wild country
up in there, and that's where a lot of wild
tales was told to me; tales about hunting,
and bear tales. It was almost like a
frontier up until the beginning of this
century, and it's still a strange kind of
law they've got in that part of the world.

people with the Scots-Irish back
became Republicans and the
with
the land became Democrats,
people
so when the War between the States
broke out there was a violent clash.
Dellie Norton still calls it the war between
the Democrats and the Republicans.
"My great-grandfather and my grand

The

ground

father on my daddy's side were preachers
in the Primitive Baptist Church. The oldtimers had a beautiful way of putting

words together. When my grandfather
preached it was like he was making the
story live. If he was telling a story from
the Old Testament, he would begin,

�He
'Well, one time the Old King.
used to tell his children little stories.

I

feel like my grandfather was never com
pletely convinced- that the world was
round; it was a hot topic in the early
1900s. The Bible talks about 'the four
corners of the earth,' and some people
reasoned that if there's four corners, it

couldn't

be

round.

"On my mother's side, my people was
mostly German. They were wonderful
carpenters; some of my ancestors would
amaze present-day carpenters. Back then
they could do things by sight that today's
carpenters have to measure for. There

Thomases on my mother's side, too.
They were Welsh, little short people,
was

jokers and full of meanness

good

meanness, you know. They was kind of

like elves.

"It's

that

mixture

of Celtic

and

Germanic that gives mountain people
their character. Mountain people have a
real high intelligence. I recall a story
about a smart person from outside the
mountains coming in, thinking what
quaint people he's talking to, when in
reality they're laughing at him for some
absurdity he's doing. Mountain people
will lead you to believe they're thinking
one thing when they're really thinking

something else.
"There's something almost like a
psychic grapevine among mountain
people. Some folks might think it's being
nosy, but it ain't that they're being nosy,
they're just sort of concerned about

what's going on. It's hard to keep any
thing secret in the mountains. You could
stump your toe at the foot of the holler,
and there might be a dozen houses all the
way up to the head of the holler, and the
news could be up there before you
would. The stereotype is that women are
big gossipers, but really, everybody
gossips.
"Those older, more conservative areas,
they used to be real clannish, and always
fighting amongst theirselves, usually over
women. That's what most of the feuds
were about. Hardly anytime did anyone
from the outside have trouble or get shot
at in a feud area. If you minded your own

business the people would
you
is

be as

good to

as

gold.
"The first thing I can remember hearing
dogs barking. It had a music all its own.

Almost everybody had hounds, off in
the hollers. Seems like I can still see the
moonlight come up over the ridges, and
down in the hollers, that lonesome
barking.

"Later on I would hear my family tell
about things that had happened to them;
hunting accidents, and things that had
happened to people they knew. I was just

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fascinated, especially

when they would

and tales
about haints, and tales about ghosts and
bear

tell scarey stories;

tales,

witches.
"My father's sister married Ike Hopson
from Green Mountain. He told wonder
ful stories. A boy would come up the
creek to visit a girl, and a bunch of guys
would waylay him, throw rocks at him,
and make noises outside while he was in
there talking to the girl. It was wonderful
to hear about life back then. He made

everything

so clear.

"My daddy's oldest brother married a
Phillips from Cosby, Tennessee. May
knew
Mamaw, we called her
Phillips
scads and scads of songs, and she taught
them all to me as I come up. She was a
base-born child and had two half

brothers. Till she was five she had no
father to speak of. A gypsy woman told
her mother that she was going to marry
an old grey-bearded man who would
come walking over the hill, with a cane.
She told the gypsy, 'Y ou're crazy!' At the

Seems like
see

the

I

can still

moonlight

come up over the
ridges, and down in
the hollers, that lonesome barking.
time she was engaged to
Esau

Mantooth.

He

was

a

man named

supposed

to

meet her on the train, but he got sick,
and there wasn't no way to wire ahead.
She thought that he had done her like the
other man
you know how some men
and found out later that he'd been
are
sick. Somebody she knowed up in Cosby
brought this old man to see her. And he
come walking over the hill, with a cane,
and he had a grey beard. She married
him. His wife had died and he had lots of

children. He was a strange old feller.
He'd been in the War between the
States, and he always used to say them
'go-devils' was biting him. It was pro
bably nerve endings, or shell-shock. He
was real irritable and wouldn't allow a
lot of singing, so she used to get together
with her cousins and they'd go up the
holler and sing to theirselves.
"When she was twelve years old,
things got so bad at home that she went
out as a hired girl, working for other
people for room and board. She learned
lots of songs from the people she lived
with.

"She died in 1980, and part of me has

never got over it yet. I was in closer
contact with her than with anybody, and
learned more ballads from her than from

anyone else.
"My Grandmother McMillon's people
was W illiamsons, and in that family they
were always singing about everything.

My dad's sister Flo can sing, and she used
to play the guitar. My dad doesn't know
many old songs, but he knew some, and

sometimes he would sing them. He knew
'William Hall,' which is a version of
'Pretty Fair Miss.' My grandmother sang
one she called 'Seaport Town' that she

learned from her uncle. There was a
merchant who had two sons and 'a
daughter dear,' and the two sons

murdered the daughter's sweetheart, and

I guess the song is in
Cecil Sharpe's book, if anyone wanted to
get all the words.
"When I was a small child, we knew a
couple that lived a few miles down the
road from here, under Brushy Mountain.
They were Brookshires. The wife, she
was always singing when I was little. By

got killed in the end.

the time I was a teenager, I realized the
songs she had been singing were old
songs and ballads. I learned a lot from
her. Her brother was a bard, you might

who wrote songs about local
happenings, like murders. One of his
say,

songs is in the North Carolina Folklore
Collection [Duke University Press], in
the ballad volume. It's called 'The Blockaders' Trail.'
"As a small child I wasn't that inter
ested in music, but I liked it if it had a
story, I reckon. I remember 'You ain't

Nothin' But

a

Hounddog.'

I

could just

imagine someone calling someone else a
hounddog! I remember someone picking
'Wildwood Flower.' That was one of the
first tunes I liked. I remember Johnny
Cash's 'Ballad of a T eenage Queen.' That
had a good story.
"I never liked singing in school, hardly.
The words and the tune had to go
together for me, and I hated for pretty
words to have a bad tune. In school,
some of them did. I didn't like minor
[key] tunes as a child. There was one
song in church called 'Windham' that
had words that went, 'Broad is the road
.' I think that's
that leads to death.
it
what turned me against minor tunes
was so depressing. I must have been 16
or 17 before I started to see the beauty in
those tunes. People would get together
and sing a few times a year, and I began to
realize how beautiful the tunes were, the
little ornamentations. And so many of
the ballads were in the same minor.
"My grandfather had a place up in

Mitchell County, up

in

the mountains,

�Kona, and he had a 'talking machine.' 1
would play those records whenever we
went up there and I remember listening
to 'River of Jordan,' 'When the Roses
Bloom Again,' 'Little Log Cabin in the
and
1 still remember the records
Lane'.
the titles. I started listening to them
when I was around nine or ten, but it
wasn't till I was twelve I realized that a lot
of these songs were much older than I
thought even though I knew what
in

appealed to me was not what

I

thought

their actual age was, but that they had the
feeling of something real old, a deeper
feeling. Then I realized that people around
home were singing these same songs, in
slightly different versions. It was like the
door flew open.

"One thing
sadness,

I

their

know why.
ness,

but

I'd

that

liked about the songs was
their poignancy, I don't

always hunted for happi
sadness had a certain

sweetness. guess was something I had
been looking for in life to give it meaning.
I

it

in the dumps. There is something
the quality of their music that I've
never got anywhere else to this day.
Nobody that ever lived sung as good as
Sarah Carter.
"The next day at the festival I seen my
name up on the paper to perform again.
'Why'd you put my name back up?' I

down

town. His name was Ralph Ellison, but
they called him 'Smiley' because he
didn't have no teeth. I learned a lot of old
ballads from him. He learned his songs
directly from his father. The first time I
heard 'Four nights Drunk' was from
him, and he was kind of high, so when he
sang the drunk man's part it really come
across that way. I always sing that part,'
c'mere little wifey
.' as if I'm drunk.
Then I throw my voice into a falsetto for
the wife's part."

in

asked. They told me they had gotten
more requests for me than for anyone
else. 'Be sure you tell them stories in
between the songs,' they said."
For the next four years Bobby worked
at the Broyhill furniture factory, singing

attending Caldwell
College for a couple of
years, and not enjoying it, Bobby went to
Fiddlers Grove and met Jean Schilling,
who had a dulcimer shop in Cosby,
Tennessee with her husband. She invited
him to a festival in Cosby, as she was
interested in hearing the songs Bobby
knew that were from her community.
In

1973,

after

Community

Bobby went, got up on stage, and sang

ballad,

first

telling

its

story.

on weekends and holidays. He met Dan
Patterson in Chapel Hill, and sang him a
version of 'Love Has Brought Me To
Despair' that he had learned from
Mamaw Phillips. He visited Janette
Carter in Virginia, and, with other
western North Carolina ballad singers,

went

a

"Joe

that
there are different versions. In the
beginning I had thought that there was

The shining glory of the ballads

song, and

Council

a

is

that knew

Arts

just one original version of
that I might find somebody
the original version.

began to ask everybody I seen for
songs they knew. It was about two years
later, merely by accident, that I run
across the Frank Brown collection of

Office,

N.C.

"I

Folklife
Bill

discovering for myself something about
ballads and folklore, researching it on
my own. I would overlook it so much
that it just soaked in.
was a sophomore in high
"When
school, my English teacher introduced
me to Cratis Williams at Appalachian
State up at Boone. She knew that I liked
old songs and had taken a folklore class. I
took him some of the songs I had. I was

Boyarsky,

began

by

I

courtesy

I

through it
I
had learned from the family.

Williams was the first contact I
outside
of my old life. That was in
had
1968. just continued on learning songs
from people. As a teenager I became
acquainted with a feller from up near
Boone, near Meat Camp and Potters"Dr.

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

photo

I

already putting them into a little journal,
because it had dawned on me what a
precarious existence balladry was in when
I come
along, and I thought I better write
stuff down. Well, Dr. Williams was just
tickled to death, and he showed me how
to document a song, to write down who
sang it. He said, 'Someday these songs
are going to mean a lot to you in a way
you probably don't see now.' I had no
idea what he meant. I had no picture of
myself then standing up in front of
people singing.

to

Washington

sing

for

the

In 1978 Bobby applied for, and
received, an appointment as artist in
residence in the town of St. Pauls in
Robeson County, south of Fayetteville.
The time he spent in the schools helped
turn him into a storyteller. "I had those
kids for 50 minutes at a time, six hours a
day. I went into the classrooms in the
elementary schools for two or three
weeks, then to the high school for other
liked to kill myself
kinds of projects.
I
thought, 'I'll just tell them
singing.
I

began to look
and saw that there were songs

North Carolina folklore.

to

Bicentennial.

The late Stanley Hicks playing one of his
homemade fretless banjos.

Dawson

he

was

the

sheriff of

went into Haywood County,
to break up a liquor still, and instead him

Newport
and

the

revenue

officers

divided the

liquor amongst them. Sandy John Sutton,
who was my Mamaw Phillips' grand
father, owned that still, and he stood up
on the mountain watching the sheriff
and the revenue officers. He shot and
killed Joe Dawson because of that. W ell,
the Republicans in Newport didn't want
that song sung, and they got an ordinance
passed that made it against the law to sing
it."

told that story (of course it all had
a very long time before), and
also sang a Carter Family song; Janette
Carter was there and it was a real thrill
"I

happened

meeting her. The Carter Family had
always been an inspiration to me, espe
cially their religious music, when I was

some tales to mix

in

with it.'"

mid-'70s Bobby

had also met
and spent time with Stanley Hicks from
Beech Mountain, and had learned lots of
old stories and tales from him. "I began
telling Jack Tales and Booger tales to the
kids. I told some of them a little different
from what you might hear from Stanley
Hicks. I had been seeing myself as just a
passer-on of the tradition, not as a mover
In the

or

a

creative person.

I

was telling stories

the same as I had heard them. But I began
to see that there had to be some kind of
plan if the tradition was going to stay
not making it literary
alive
always

keeping

it

down-to-earth.

iust tell the bare bones.

I

But I didn't
began to tell

whatever come to me, to use the tales as a
tool to describe the mountain way of life.
When I tell the Big T oe Story, I tell about
this old house we lived in, a log house
with a downstairs and a loft. I tell about
the fireplace, with hooks to put pots and
kettles on. I tell about beans
looking
them over, washing them, soaking them,
I just wanted
them to know, I wanted to
that
capture
feeling."
Over the years Bobby has gone on to
work as artist-in-residence at many

continued on page 43

�FIDDLIN' ARTHUR SMITH:

Pretty Girls Than One" will be played as
long as there are fiddlers to play them.

1898 in
County, Tennessee, and a
young lady named Nettie Jewel Baker
Arthur was born April 10,

Humphreys

came into his life at

a very early age. They
played together as babies. As Arthur
entered his teens, learning from the old

fiddlers in middle Tennessee, Nettie
accompanied him on guitar. His father,
who was accidently electrocuted while
working for the phone company in 906,
had been a fiddler. Arthur inherited his
fiddle and learned on it. Nettie sold
chickens to help buy the next one. They
were married in 1914 when Arthur was
sixteen and Nettie was fifteen; it was a
marriage that endured for 57 years. The
Smith household was blessed with thir
teen children, six girls and seven boys.
All survived to adulthood and most of
them became musicians. First born was
LaVonne in 1916 (she died in Chat
tanooga onjanuary 8, 1990). In the early
1

'30s she played piano with her father and
the Dixieliners at the Grand Ole Opry
and on their one-room school house
tours. Three little girls came and then, in
1922, Ernest was born. The eldest son
would become a close companion for the
rest of his father's life. They would play
square dances, schools and the Grand
Ole Opry together. At every opportunity
they would get together and play, often
for eight or ten hours at a time. During

those marathon sessions they
sometimes write songs together.

would

courtesy

Charies

Woite

Today, after a long career in engineer
ing, Ernest has moved with his wife

Arthur Smith (seated) with the Bailes Brothers 1943

A Son
by

Remembers
James Kennison

Fiddlin' Arthur Smith was King of the
Fiddlers. When he died in February
1971, Roy Acuff bestowed that title on

him in an eulogy from the Grand Ole
Opry stage. In my opinion he was the
best of his time and probably of all time.
His style is still influencing young fiddlers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

second- and third-hand, and the fiddle
tunes he wrote or popularized are present
at every festival and fiddling contest.
"Blackberry Blossom," "Red Apple Rag,"
"Florida Blues," "Pig in the Pen,"
"Peacock Rag," "Sugar Tree Stomp,"
"Beautiful Brown Eyes," and "More

Annabel to the mountains of western
North Carolina near Mars Hill. On their
living room wall is a painting of Arthur

Smith with a fiddle under his chin, and
you can feel Arthur's presence in the
room. "Arthur Smith was not only my
father but the best friend I ever had,"
Ernest says.
"I guess there has never been a father
or son any closer than we were. As I grew
older and became more involved in
music, we were inseparable. We would
go to square dances when I was about
twelve and he would tell folks, 'Now my
son is just not old enough to stand up

here and play for forty-five minutes a set,
so we're going to have a little break.' The
dancers would go out and smoke and
then we would start again."
In his teens Arthur learned from the
old fiddlers in Humphreys and Dickson
Counties, especially Jim and Grady
Stringer. In that area where he grew up

several fiddlers played in a long bowing
style with complex noting. Arthur seems
to have perfected that style and made it
his own; in the same way Earl Scruggs,

�Old Judge' talking about paw paws."
Early in 1932 Arthur and Homer
broke up their act and Arthur joined
Sam and Kirk McGee to form the Dixieliners. They first played on the Opry in
May 1932. The McGees were incredible
instrumentalists and Ernest looked
forward to every chance to play with

them.

"I used to get the biggest thrill of my
life to see Sam and Kirk come by and
watch Sam set up the bells he played on. 1

learned some guitar from Sam. It got so,
when they came in the house, Sam would
just bring his guitar in because he knew
would want to play."
Ernest became an excellent guitarist
and, considering the teachers he had,
that is not surprising. Arthur Smith
played guitar and banjo very well, and.
Ernest's first lessons were from his
father, who taught him how to play
behind a fiddle.
"In 1932, when I was ten years old, we

I

moved back to Dickson and had a great
Tommie Pinkerton, who played
and sang beautifully.
guess she
got me started. But Alton Delmore
I

aunt,
guitar
really
is the

1

I credit with teaching
me what
know.
a
teacher.
He
He
was
guitar
great
showed me the chord transitions
how
to go from one chord to another. Young
musicians have trouble determining
when to change chords and when you are
playing with other people that is very

man

photo

by

LaVonne

Brown,

courtesy

Ernest

Smith

I

Arthur Smith

at

the Jefferson Inn, Detroit, MI 1945

later, would listen to the three-fingered
in the North Carolina
mountains and then take it beyond where
anyone else had gone. By the early '20s

banjo being played

Arthur had established a reputation as a
fiddler, but he had a lot of mouths to
feed and there wasn't much money in
fiddling. He went to work in 1925 for
the North Carolina and St. Louis Rail
road, known as the Dixie Line. First he
cut cross ties, then was promoted to
lineman and finally to the maintenance
crew. Wherever Arthur's work took
him his fiddle went along. Soon he met

Harry Stone, another Dixie Line
employee, who was working as a part-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

time announcer for radio station WSM.
Stone arranged for Arthur to be heard by
George D. Hay, the "Solemn Old Judge,"
who was looking for talent for the brand

new Grand Ole Opry. Arthur became
one of the earliest performers on the
Opry, in 1927, playing solo at first but

soon joined

by his cousin, Homer Smith,
on guitar. The Grand Ole Opry became a

familar place to Ernest Smith.
"1 spent
a lot of time
at the Opry. I
remember as a very young boy going
with Dad to the old tabernacle building.
That was across the river. I can see it in
my mind; all the chairs and seats and
sawdust on the floor and the 'Solemn

important."
In 1934 Arthur started touring with
the Delmore Brothers and the following
year he went with Alton and Rabon to a
Delmore recording session in New
Orleans. When A. and R. man Eli Oberstein heard Arthur play he decided to
record

him

as

a

lead

with

also,

the

Delmore Brothers backing him up.
Arthur first recorded "Blackberry

Blossom" and "Red Apple Rag" at that
session. For Ernest it was the beginning
of a life-long friendship with the
Delmores. He recalls one occasion when
he played a show with Alton.
"It was in

1941 and

I

was still in high

school. They had a show in Greeneville,
Tennessee, and Rabon was sick. They
told

me

to

be

around

for

they were

coming through to pick me up.

It was a
big picnic with ten or fifteen bands. We
were there all day long. Of course I knew

lot of the Delmores' songs. I had
listened to them and sang with them
a

when they came by the house. I took
Alton's guitar and he played Rabon's
tenor guitar. After the close of the day
and they got paid, my Dad stood up for

and I got my cut just like Rabon
would have. That was the most money I
had ever seen, something like seventyme

�five dollars in one-dollar bills.
It's so unfortunate those two boys
died so young. They always seemed to
have a rough time getting along with the
management of the Opry. Being a native
Tennessean, I don't rejoice in saying
something against my state, but when the
Grand Ole Opry started I think they had
in mind keeping it so all the performers
were from Tennessee. They were for
many years. Alton and Rabon were from
Alabama and I think there was a certain
amount of prejudice."
In 1 938 Arthur Smith also had trouble
with the Opry management. David Stone
had been staging fiddling contests with
the leading fiddlers of the day. They
don't seem to have been real contests for
the winners were often predetermined.
The Delmores went to one such show in

western Tennessee, and Arthur was
supposed to join them but he never got
there. Stone suspended Arthur from the

Opry for four weeks for missing the
show. During the suspension Stone found
several fiddlers to play with the Delmores
and asked Alton to pick one who would
get a guest shot on the Grand Ole Opry.

Alton picked a young fellow from
Maynardville, Tennessee named Roy

Acuff. Roy was not a great fiddler but
Alton saw something else in him. The
story was told that Arthur had depended
on some people to drive him to the show
that day, but they stopped for some
moonshine and he couldn't get them to
know
go any farther. Ernest doesn't
whether that story is true but he doesn't

there. Dad didn't stay long. He
went up to West Virginia and played
with the Bailes Brothers. I went to Detroit
and got involved in music up there. I was
playing at a big place called the Jefferson
Inn with the York Brothers. George
York had to go into the service and I
took his place. Leslie and I played to
with
gether and we finally got in touch
Dad and he came up to Detroit and spent
a couple of years up there. Around 1947
Dad went out to Hollywood with Jimmy
Wakely. He stayed out there about three
years, lived in Jimmy Wakely's house
and worked in fourteen movies with
him. He used to watch his movies and
his
laugh about riding a horse and taking

were

gun out and shooting it."
Arthur came back to Nashville in
1951 and dropped out of music for

awhile. He went to work with his brother
In 1962 Arthur and
as a carpenter.
Ernest recorded an album together for
Starday. About that time Mike Seeger
brought Arthur and the McGee Brothers
together and recorded Arthur and the
Dixieliners for the first time on a Folk
ways album. In 1965 Arthur and the
McGees went to the Newport Folk Fest

ival and received a thunderous welcome.
Ernest moved down to Louisville in
1968 and went to work at the General
Electric Appliance Park. Arthur was
working with his friend Gordon Terry.
Ernest recalls those last days: "Gordon
Terry had a place near Loretto,
Tennessee, called Terry Town. It was a

simulated western town with stage-coach
rides, an old saloon and all the buildings
would have. Dad was
a western town

week
playing there for square dances on

ends and taking care of the place. [People]
started breaking in and stealing his
fiddles, including the one in the painting,

I
just became overwhelmed with
grief for him down there; so one snowy
stuff
day I called and told him to get his
One
of
I was coming after him.
for
ready

and

my brothers and I went down and got
him. I bought a little house at Lake

Dreamland, outside Louisville, and we
relocated him there. About two weeks
after Dad left there, Terry Town burned

It was about a year after
that he became ill. We had a big party at
in
my house on the day after Christmas
1970. People came down from Michigan
and we played nearly all night. Ten days
later I came in and slapped Dad on the
back and he said it hurt. We took him to
the doctor and they ran tests. At first
they thought he had tuberculosis, but it

to the ground.

turned out to be lung cancer. He made
the decision himself, onjanuary 28th, to
have surgery; but it was too late. He died

exactly a month later."
Ernest is not always happy with what
is written about his father. Sometimes it
sounds as though the writers are talking
about a different Arthur Smith than the
one he knew. He also feels the country
music establishment in Nashville has

continued on page 44

think that is the real reason Arthur
missed the show.
"I've never heard my Dad say anything
about why he left the Opry. He wouldn't
talk about it. I have to depend on what
that he did
my oldest sister [told] me

not want to participate in those
fraudulent, prejudged contests. My Dad

a straight man and contrary to what I
have read, he was not an aggressive man.
He was not ill-tempered or hard to get
along with. I never saw him get mad at
anybody. It hurt him a great deal to leave
under those circumstances after thirteen
years on the Opry."
He did leave and traveled around the
country for the next few years. Ernest
left home too.
"When I got out of high school in
1942, I had a couple of jobs in Chicago
and then decided to come back to Nash
ville. At that time Daddy was playing

Carlisle, Johnny Wright and Jack Anglin
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Charles
courtesy

with Smilin' Eddie Hill in Knoxville at
WNOX. I joined them there and we
played together for a time. They had
some good musicians at WNOX at that
time. Cowboy Copas, Chet Atkins, Bill

Wolfe

was

The Dixieliners:

the Opry's finest string band. Sam McGee, Arthur Smith, Kirk McGee,

1936

�Issues In Old-Time Music

of ideas and points of view, some of which
Points of view
be
controversial.
may
expressed in this column are not necessarily

Hey look. Joe Wilson and his 25member banjo-picking board run a big
folk festival, and they run it their way.
Fine. Great. The buck stops with Joe.
That conceded, Joe Wilson offers some

those of the

pretty

The Issues In Old-Time Music column
was established as a forum for the expression

Old-Time Herald.

[To those of you who are new

or

recent

way back in the spring '89 OTH
Mac Ben ford wrote an article in this column
An Account of
entitled "Folklorists &amp;Us

subscribers,

Our Curious &amp; Changing Relationship," in
which he expressed some very real concerns
concerns not only of his but a great many
others as well. We received a lot of response
which we printed in subsequent issues. In the

last (spring) OTH we printed an extensive
response to Mac from joe Wilson of the
National Council for the Traditional Arts
entitled "Confessions of a Folklorists."
Because it is apparent that the subject is of
such concern to musicians as well as non-

musicians, and that these issues have a
bearing on the future of old-time music
and in the spirit of continuing dialogue, the
debate continues. We received too many
excellent letters to go into one issue, so these
are a few of them.]

remember ole Joe,

"Hey Bob, do ya
from Mrs. Fraiser's 2nd grade?"
"Well dang, I shur do, Bob, mean as a
snake he uz, gave that woman pure-tee
fits. She used to crack his knuckles oncet
but hit didn't do much good I
a week,
don't reckon. What ever happened to
that ole boy?"
"Well, last I heard, he'd gone up to
ork, supposed to be makin' a lotta
money, but the other day I seen an article
by him in that there fiddle magazine, and
hit said he uz in Washington running

New

Y

some big folk fester."
"You mean he's writing
Lan, that ole boy

including probably 90 percent
represents
of this magazine's readership.
First, the "issue" of professionalism.
Or rather, it seems to be some sort of
"issue" for Joe, but I never thought of it
that way. There are certainly many won
derful "amateur" musicians, but except
for a few recluses (Glen Gould types)
and a few with religious scruples, most
good musicians do or at least have played
on stage at least locally, or in a contest, or
at some festival. Usually when you play
you get paid something. So in a reason
able sense, most good musicians are at

least part-time professionals. Joe
audaciously cites Tommy Jarrell

actually, all his citations are audacious,
and carefully designed to shift all of oldtime music's indisputable heros over to
his camp. But T ommy was a professional
in this basic sense, and in another sense
too: he was a great performer. That's
why Tommy made records (another

symptom of professionalism), and that's
why he played all the national gigs he

wanted in the '70s and '80s. Yes indeed,
"
ommy was "authentic, an example of a
distinct regional culture and all that
but at least equally, and probably more
importantly in terms of getting the work,
T ommy J arrell was a spell-binding enter
tainer who could not only play but tell a
good story and put together a perfect set.
And Tommy damn well knew it. Sure,
the silly west-coast band Joe cites
couldn't compete with Tommy, but

T

could many other equally
"authentic" oldtimers. The point is,
people who play big festivals mostly
when
have to be skilled performers
neither

now,

Bub?

couldn't hardly talk."

tell you, that article was slick
sorry, Miss Emmy, 1 didn't see
you thar. Anyways, hit was so slick I felt
kindly sorry for this feller Mac he uz
kicking around. Ole Joe, he's moved a
fer piece from this ole holler. An you
know what's funny? He's dyed his hair
"Bob,

as

in his effort
of
a
OTH,
Folklorist,"
("Confessions
Feb. 1990) to not merely defend his
festival leadership, but absolutely crush
and pulverize Mac Benford and all he

tortured logic

I

owl

red."

"Dyed his hair! What'd he go an do
that for?"
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

they're not, disasters often ensue. One of
Wilson's jobs is to decide who,
among the authentic elect, can cope with

Joe

the road and the big stage. Some people
play great at home, but don't like looking
at 10,000 people, or can never get in
tune, or play nothing but waltzes, or pass
out in the dressing room. Some people,
like Tommy Jarrell, are professionals.

T ommy was also in the perfect position
to embark on a performing career when
the opportunity arose. He was retired,
with a good pension and state health

insurance, in good health, his kids were
long grown, his wife had passed away.
Tommy had no good reason not to take
off to some festival whenever he wanted.
And he didn't have to worry too much
about the money: as long as his expenses
were covered he could play the nicest,
and only the nicest venues. And this
wonderful situation, of course, was only
what he deserved.
Other musicians, when they are at
different stages in their lives, face tougher
choices when confronted with the pro

fessional

Joe offers us
farmer
perhaps, but
hog

opportunity.

Kenny Baker

mainly full-time professional fiddler for
in defense
35 years
of, what, hair
dressing? But he misunderstands Kenny's
remark 1 think. Music is an inner fire,
and for some people, even when they are
young, married, parents, family and
community members with all the implied
responsibilities, they simply must follow
their talent. If you want to be the best
fiddler you can be, there is just nothing
better than touring with a good, working
band. I know. This is obviously the
choice Kenny Baker made as a young
man, and it took courage. Why courage?
Because going out on the road has a big
down side for someone with a family and

community.

Professional musicians

just like everyone else

just

as

fast.

Unless they happen

become stars (not necessarily
of talent,

are

the years fly by

to say the least),

a

to

function

most pro

fessional musicians don't do much for
their older years

they don't build up

collect

big royalties
pensions,
(does Bill Monroe have a dental plan?).
Though I know nothing about Kenny
Baker's personal life, a lot of professional
musicians pay the price of the road in
the spouse gets damn tired
lost family
of sitting at home with the babies and
dealing with the fan belt and the electric
the hogs?
bill, the sick mother-in-law,
A lot of musicians who burn to play go
up in flames eventually, and they all run
the risk. And I suspect, Joe, that's what
Kenny Baker's wistful remark about the
fat

fiddling barber

or

is all

about.

The point, though, is that people who
decide to try and live the professional life
on the road are making a choice of the
heart. That kind of choice deserves

demands
respect. I don't equate respect
with a booking at the National Folk
Festival, and 1 don't think Mac Benford
does either. But Highwoods wasn't that
silly, Quixotic west-coast band. The
Highwoods band went out there because

�they loved playing and
they stayed out there
because they were very
woods didn't live on

performing, and

long time
good at it. Highfor

a

grants,

they just

looked forward to those nice civilized
folk festival audiences as a reward for the
all-night rides, semis in snowstorms,
biker mudslings, and bluegrass bars.
And after

a while,
they got burned out.
But in the process Highwoods played a
lot of magical sets
know because
sometimes I had to follow them and
I

certainly T ommy was talking about them
too, in his quoted remarks, whether he
cited them by name to Joe or not (and
who would know?). Highwoods helped
build the old-time music audience, and
thus helped make Tommy Jarrell's
musical career possible. Joe does a great
disservice to Mac and Walt and Bob and
real people who were
Jenny and Doug
out there for a decade making the music
they loved when they could have been
building safe careers when he brushes

astute quotes from both emphasizing
families playing music because they liked
it, and on playing real feelings of the
moment, and the fallacies of imitations.
Then Mike Seeger's illuminating the
spectra of those beaming banjo belles;
but surpassing them all is the continuing
Issues furor, in the honored tradition of
Bashing, not to be outdone by such
feeble Anglo-Saxon customs as boxing
and rugby and football. Salutes to Mr.
Benford and Mr. Stecher and Mr. W ilson
for amusing and edifying us all at once.
Keep it up boys, never say die, I'm
betting on the guy with the brown shoelaces. Just tell the truth, keep it clean, and
when you're done you're all invited to
my house for a tune and a drink. Oldtime music issues resemble particle
physics, where you learn the details by

walloping the subject and watching what
comes flying out.

it.

Hank Bradley

Seattle, WA

They paid their

dues.

When

read Mac's original piece last
saw that mainly what he was

I

spring, I
doing was putting bands like Highwoods
(and my old bands) in some kind of
historical perspective. What 1 felt,
learning tunes from Tommy Jarrell and

Hammons and Frank George and
Dave Milefsky and all the rest in the early
'70s, was a deep and personal sense of
membership in the tradition. remember

think you are

bad way when you
by one Joe
Wilson
one page would be plenty. It's
a crime to give that amount of space to
I

publish

7

and

in

1/3

a

pages

one dude.

C.

Burl

Lowry

Owensboro,

KY

1

saying to myself, one day back then, "I
am a fiddler." I've tried, through the
years, to keep the faith. It's a physical
skill, after all, like carpentry. Fiddle
players share an ear, no matter where
they're from. In trying to draw a fundamental class distinction, with the "folk"
middleon one side and the, what?
elite hippie, yuppie, cultureless
wunderkind on the other, Joe goes too
far. Kenny Baker and Tommy Jarrell and
Mac Benford all loved "the music."
When he dyed his hair red, maybe the
ole boy stopped loving tunes in favor of
distinctions. His piece reminds me of the
time I played fiddle at a dry wedding
reception, but that's another story.
class

Bill Hicks

Associate Editor, OTH
Silk Hope, NC

As much as I disagree with Mac Benford's notions of where old-time music
is headed, he is to be commended for
trying to keep the current discussion on
the level of issues, rather than a sordid
squabble over who didn't hire whose
revival band 15 years ago. Herewith a
modest contribution of my own on a

matter of principle.
As much as I agree with most of what
Joe Wilson had to say (I even live on
Pipers Gap Road!), I fear he has fallen
prey to a bit of folkie romanticism when

describes old-time music as the property of the "lower classes." Take, for
example, the son of a small-town restaurant owner, an honors graduate of a
state university, the youngest graduate of
his law school, and the youngest ever to
pass the Bar Examination of his state. He
he

successful State's Attorney, whose
now teaches in Switzerland. Now
make him an old-time fiddler. One more
urban folkie? Not really: it was Price
Goodson, born in Galax, who recorded
with DaCosta Woltz in 1927.
As Joe doubtless knows when he isn't
trying to make a point, old-time music is
was

son

Cheers for the spring edition, unsurpassed

in

Baker

and

fine folklore.

Tom

Hunter

First

the

articles,

Etta

with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

miners, millhands, and such,
this society includes a substantial middle
class. Lawyers like Goodson and Bascom
Lamar Lunsford, doctors like Humphrey
farmers,

Bate and W.K. Lloyd, businessmen like
Frank Blevins and Claude Slagle, and
even a few good barbers like Byrd Moore

and Gid Tanner. What's more, country
people in general, and old-time musicians
in particular, are an intelligent and enter-

prising lot with a great deal of upward
mobility. If you drive down Pipers Gap
Road today, you will see a stretch of
suburbia/ exurbia pretty typical of any
where in the country. There are only two
log houses between here and the Blue

Ridge Parkway, both recently built and
out of my price range. Not a tarpaper
shack in the whole 10-mile stretch.
I'm

them aside as myopic middleclass
romantics. Just like Kenny Baker, they
went out there and did

part of the complex culture of a complex
society. Despite its solid foundation of

sure,

as

I

say,

that Joe

knows

better, but some of the people whose
view of this area is limited to the horse
pens in Felts Park don't seem to. When
they do get out in the countryside to
meet the local musicians, it is with a set
of preconceptions and expectations that
are not only misleading but likely to give
offense. This is nothing new here: I am
reminded of the story, told to me as true

many Carroll Countians, about the
old man who took a walk along the Blue
Ridge Parkway when it first opened, to
watch the cars go by. One, with out-ofstate plates, pulled over near him, and a
woman leaned out the window and called,
"Say, old man, where are all the hillbillies?" "Up in Pennsylvania," the fellow
by

shot back, "teaching school."

John Coffey

Galax, VA

It's time people stopped using the
term "revival musician." All performers
of old-time music in the twentieth century are revival musicians. Most of the
styles of American folk music that
interest us now were developed in the

nineteenth century and continuously
expanded, syncretized, and notably

changed ever since. That is what the folk
process means. All the famous folk
artists we know about are revivalists. All
of them had repertoires that included
popular as well as more formal musical
traditions.
never knew an old-time
I

banjo picker who didn't play marches
and compose tunes. Buell Kazee was
trained as a classical singer. He would
have been definitely classified as a revivalist if that had been widely know about
him.

�Revivalist is actually being used to
describe people who were not born in
the right place. Those who use the term
would flunk every Blindfold Test if they
were forced simply to hear the music and
make a judgment about its authenticity.

Revivalist

is

a

mistaken and pernicious

term and we should stop using it. We
don't refer to pianists who specialize in

Mozart

as

revivalists.

We are only

interested to know if they are exceptional.
Similarly people who specialize in oldtime music and do it well are no more or
less

revivalists

than the people they
learned from. If their music is well done
and accurately expressed, it doesn't make
any difference where they were born.

Mike Seeger is defined as a revivalist
because he wasn't born in Kentucky. But
he has contributed more (in every way)
to the existence of old-time music than

anyone anywhere

and

he

has

paid

a

heavy price because of the people who
insist on using revivalist as a pejorative
term.

But I want to say how grateful I am to
the OTH for printing Joe Wilson's dia

tribe.

It

expresses

beautifully

the

bureaucratic mind in the folk music
establishment. There is too much in his
piece to critique in detail, but I think it
important to sink his notion that T ommy

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Jarrell and Dewey Balfa somehow get
extra points for doing their non-musician
vocations. He should be appalled that a
man like Dewey Balfa spent his time
driving a bus or operating a furniture
store. People like Balfa and other great
musicians should have been plying their

trades

as professional
musicians and
Wilson should have figured out what he
could do to bring that about instead of
chiding Mac Benford because he wants
to be a working musician.

There are dozens of projects that could
have helped to make our great folk
artists available to American audiences. I
have been involved in one small attempt
which suggests that folk artists have a
real function in our society, not only as
entertainers but as educators. For some
years I have hosted a Resident Folk
Artist program at my university. Folk

artists come for a semester, teach two
courses (one a small seminar), and spend
time in the community
with no charge
to schools and other non-profit groups.
The rationale is that since that RFA
program is sponsored jointly by the Folk
Arts section of NEA and the university
(that's federal and state money) the

schools ought

to get the

artists

at

no

charge. The RFA gets top professor
grade pay. Most of them are natural

teachers

and as prestigious as any
Ph.D
no one ever falls asleep in their
classes. It is an NEA Model Program and
the artists have included Kenny Hall,
Bessie Jones, Lydia Mendoza, Richard
Hagopian, Jean Ritchie, and Dewey Balfa.
Both the university and the community
have been tremendously appreciative.
The idea of residencies for artists is
not a new or radical conception. With
the kind of joint sponsorship that I have
had, schools, towns, and many other
institutions could be playing a major role
in

keeping the traditional arts alive and
in our society. And while
see

viable

nothing wrong

I

in

paying

special

attention to national treasures like Balfa
and Jarrell, the recipients of those pro
grams should include all artists of com
petence, not just those who have been
kept sanitized from an inaccurate and

poisonous label.
Gene Bluestein
California State University, Fresno, CA

continued on page 43

�Rolling River

FIDDLE

cross-tuned
Key of

A

from John Lusk band
Altamonl: Black Stringband Music From
The Library of Congress --ROUNDER 0238

COMMENTS:
fingers are low
shown in the KEY)

FIDDLETAB
(as

(L) or high (H)

position.

PLAY THE NOTES AS IF YOU
WERE IN STANDARD TUNING

MUSIC NOTATION

(notation indicates fingering---not always the melody)
Unusual fingerings are indicated with #s above notes.
1st PART

Measures

1

&amp; 3;

John Lusk plays this:

instead

of

the

open strings

I've indicated.

Measure

Try the easy (open)
way first, then his way.
(It's more difficult, but
it sounds great!)

2:

the first beat, he sometimes bars the high strings with his first finger (as in the C phrase
of the 2nd PART).
Note that the 3rd finger shifts up to the little finger position to allow the pinky to play a C#.
On

2nd

PART
I've labeled this as three phrases (A..., B..„ C...) which are played in sequence four times. For
know you've rushed out to purchase), keep in
those playing along with the recording (which
mind that the first time through the tune, they leave out the C... phrase on the first repeat.
I

The liner notes state that Grubble &amp;c Lusk kept their instruments tuned at the old pre-steel string
frequency, which was 1 &amp;. 1/2 steps lower than today's standard, (i.e. G tuning would be in the key of E.)
You might like to tune on down St help the Rolling River keep on rolling along.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

---

Carl

Jones

�BOWING
WORKSHOP
by

Brad Leftwich

Review.

If you missed the first bowing
workshop, recommend you have a look
at OTH vol. 2, no. 2. It explains my
approach to bowing and, more important, how to understand the way I write
I

out the bow licks and tunes in this series.
I'll also be referring to licks that were
explained in more detail last time.

Downbowing, as I call it, is a style very
loosely characterized by beginning phrases
on downbow strokes, ending phrases on
upbows (so you can start the next phrase
on a downbow), and playing your sawstrokes so that your bow is going down
on the beat. Downbowing also uses
certain characteristic bow licks that I'll
be showing you in this series of work
shops. These are guidelines rather than
rules, but it's worth sticking close to
them until you know what you're doing.
divide bow licks into three groups:
for the beginning of a phrase, for the
middle of a phrase, and for the end of a
phrase. Last time I covered "sawstrokes,"
lick consisting of even bowa middle
strokes moving down and up like a saw
(with the beat falling on a downbow); a
beginning lick consisting of a long

the names to learn the bowing
patterns, then don't worry about them
any more.

use

The 3/3

ending. Next to the basic
ending, possibly the most common ending
lick in downbowing is the 3/3 ending. In
the illustration I've added two sawstrokes
between each ending so that you can
practice them continuously, without
stopping and starting.
In

the

3/3 ending, you

pull your bow

down for the equilavent of three notes,
and push it back up through three more.
This is trickier than it sounds, because
although the lick starts down on the
beat, your bow actually changes direction

and starts back up slightly before the next
tap of your foot. Your natural tendency
is going to be to wait and start back up on

next beat, so watch what you're
doing carefully. Count it while you play
the

it:

down-two-three

up-two-three;

the

The long sawstroke.
is

just

a

A

long saw-stroke

regular sawstroke twice as slow,

which means there
on each

downbow

upbow twice
sawstroke.

as

is room for two notes
and two more on each
many as on the regular

This is pretty straightforward until
you start noting with your left hand.
Some bowstrokes may have two short
notes on them, while others may have
only one long note. It should make no
difference to your bow arm, which should
keep going down and up, like a machine,
in even bowstrokes regardless of what
the notes are doing.

"Great Big Taters in Sandy Land."
This is a tune that builds on the same
licks we covered in "Shortening Bread"
last time, adding only the 3/3 ending and
the long sawstroke.
The bowing pattern for the low part is

italicized words are where you tap your
foot.

broken down

with the beginning lick, goes
several sawstrokes, starts to
wind up the phrase with a basic ending,
then finishes it off with 3/3 ending. So it
actually strings together two different
ending licks in the same phrase.
The pattern for the high part is simpler,
consisting only of a beginning lick, some
long sawstrokes, and the 3/3 ending.

Notice that the beginning lick

in

the

illustration.

accompanying

1

downbow the length of three sawstrokes;

and two ending licks. The first ending
lick was a short downbow, followed by a

long upbow the length of three saw
strokes. The second ending lick was of

the pattern, down up-up down up- up,
where each "up-up" represents an upbow
that is twice as long as each downbow,
and the beat falls on the italicized words.

occurs to me somewhat belatedly
would be a good idea to name all
of these licks for convenient reference in
future workshops. With that in mind,
It

that

it

I'll call ending lick #1 the "basic ending,"
because it's so common, and ending lick
#2 will be the "syncopated ending,"
because it emphasizes the off-beat (that's
what "syncopated" means). You'll run

into

a

number of other syncopated licks

down the line, and making sure you
really have this ending down pat will pay
dividends later. I'm not going to bother
renaming the beginning lick; it's fairly
standard,

and

any

other licks you see

beginning a phrase will usually be middle
licks moonlighting as beginning licks.
Remember that most of these names

ones I've made up. If you start talking
about syncopated endings or some other
such ridiculous thing to anyone who
hasn't seen this series of workshops,
they're liable to think you're nuts. Just
are

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

It

starts

through

is

a

little

different here. That's because we're attach
ing it to a long sawstroke instead of a
regular sawstroke.

In

the illustration

it

goes through four spaces, not three as it
did when we attached it to regular

sawstrokes.

Here's the whole tune, in the key of G:
One last comment: In the second beat

�of the first phrase of the low part, the
same note (a "3") is written twice on the
same string on the same bowstroke. This
is because they should sound like two
separate notes. The way this is done is by
bearing down on the bow and pushing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a little more energy on the second of
the two notes. Note that your bow does

with
not

stop and start;

a

it

continues to move

the same direction, just with
more
little
pressure and energy on the

smoothly

in

second note. H

and banjo
is a fiddler
Plank
Road
the
member
of
player, former
String Band and Leftwich &amp; H igginbotham.
He is on the advisory board of the OTH.
Brad

Leftwich

�BUYING

USED GUITAR

A
by

MARTIN D-28 $500. It sure caught
my eye in the classified ad newspaper.
Used 70s D-28s sell between $800 and
$900. I figured I could get a good deal. I
made a quick phone call and learned that

the guitar was in good condition, it had a
hardshell case, and I would have to drive
about an hour to see it.
An hour later I was unlatching a
familiar blue A.B.S. plastic guitar case.
My first glance said, "looks good." I
looked a little closer and saw that the
bridge was lifting. No big deal. I then
checked the back. There were two cracks
there and two more cracks on the sides. I
tuned it up and played my seven blue-

grass guitar licks. The string height was
almost twice as high as I am used to. The
neck needed to be reset and the frets
were worn and needed to be replaced.
Out of habit I looked inside using a
mirror and a small light. I had been
burned on a guitar deal once. It was a

1928 00-40H, and someone had cus
tomized the braces with a screwdriver

a pair of pliers. I didn't find that out
until I got home and gave the guitar a
good going over.
The top braces of the D-28 were fine
but the back braces were all loose. If it
was going to be fixed properly, the back
would have to come off. At least then the
back and side cracks would be easier to
repair. It was time to step back to see
what the $500 wonder guitar would
really cost.
$35
Bridge removal and reglue
Neck reset
$125
Refret
$150

and

Remove back, fix cracks
reglue braces, replace back and

$300
binding, touch up finish
New strings
$5
Total repairs
$615
Yikes! This guitar could have cost
more than $1 100
$200 to $300 more
than the average price from a dealer. I left
with that guitar but for much less than
$500. It had never been worked on and
my thoughts were to prevent it from
falling prey to an incompetent repair
person. The person with the handy screw
driver and pliers would never lay hands
on this one again.
So what do you look for when you
buy a used guitar? The first and foremost
consideration is sound. This is a sub
jective topic and

I

can only

recommend

tone that fits the
to play. After
want
music
of
you
type
listening to the guitar, examine it for

finding

a

guitar with

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

structural

Bob Smakula

corrected with
or

that may be
few minor adjustments,

problems
a

worse, may lead to expensive repair

bills.

guitar. Is there excessive
too easy to play or do you
need hydraulic assisted fingers? String
height is determined by several factors.
Nut height, saddle height, neck curvature
and neck angle all make one guitar's
action better or worse than another's.
String height can be changed to suit any
playing style. My opinion of ideal string
height for a steel string guitar (measured
from the top of the fret to the bottom of
the string at the 12th fret) is l/16"at the
high E gradually increasing to 3/32" at
Play the
buzzing? Is

it

the low E.
If the

instrument of choice feels hard

to play, sight down the neck. If the neck
looks like the cross-section of a dinner

plate, then the neck should be straight
ened with a heated neck press.
String height at the nut can be checked
by pressing down on a string in front of
the second fret. There should be clear
ance of about the thickness of a piece of
paper between the bottom of the string
and the top of the fret. Too much
clearance translates into a guitar that is
hard to play. No clearance means the
string will buzz when played open. If you
have checked these things and the string
height is still too high, look at the saddle
(the bone or synthetic piece on the
bridge that the strings go over). If the
saddle is tall, more than 1/16" higher
than the bridge, it can be lowered. If it is
close to the top of the bridge then a neck
reset might be in order. A neck reset
entails removing the neck from the body
and changing the angle where the neck
attaches to the body.
The gauge of strings can make a
difference in action. Light gauge strings
are easier to fret than medium or heavy
strings. Check the frets. Frets wear out
when strings are pressed down on them.
The worn area is lower than the fret in
front of it and causes the string to buzz.
Loose or uneven frets are another source

the mistaken notion that it might
hurt the sound of their beloved
instrument. Cracks will get worse over
time. I have seen instruments deteriorate
to an unusable condition because of
had

neglect.
A lifting bridge is another problem
that when corrected early can save you
from big repair bills. Look at the edge of
the bridge farthest away from the neck.
A gap between the top of the guitar and
the bottom of the bridge tells you that
the bridge should be removed, old glue
and finish scraped off the gluing surface,

and the bridge reglued.
Be sure to check the

interior

con

struction. You may not be able to detect
a loose brace or even a missing brace, but
a glance
through the sound hole may
reveal something obviously wrong like
gobs of auto body putty. Some bad
repair jobs are nearly impossible to
correct. Sometimes the most obvious
things pass us by. Look at the hardware
and make sure it is all there. Screws from
tuners can work themselves loose and
fall out.

you are gazing at and
good condition and only
needs some adjustment, don't buy it just
If the

guitar

longing for

is in

Find

out

problems

are

yet.

the guitar and its
cost. I strongly
to
going

what

recommend that before you purchase
used

Bob Smakula has been a fretted instru
ment builder, repairman, and dealer for 16
years. He is an active old-time musician as
well, playing fiddle in the Able Brothers and
Stand Bayou bands. Formerly from Cleve
land, Ohio, he now lives in Elkins, West

Virginia, where he operates
Smakula Fretted Instruments.

his

business,

of string buzzes.

important to check for cracks,
glue joint separations and loose binding.
These troubles will only get worse with
It

is

time. Cracks are always easier (read less
costly) to repair when they are fresh.
Dirt and instrument polish work their
way into cracks and make the repair job
harder. I have known people who refused
to have crack work done because they

an

guitar, you take it to a
professional repair person. Most of the
time estimates are free and you can get a
good idea of any problems that could
cause a nightmare of future repair bills.
Keep these points in mind when buying
used
a
guitar and you can count on years
of enjoyable playing with your purchase.

older,

GET RESULTS

Advertise YOUR used instrument
in an

Old-Time Herald Classified.

�55th ANNUAL

CONVENTION

OLD FIDDLERS'
Sponsored

by

Galax Moose Lodge *733
TO BE HELD AT

FELTS PARK

GALAX, VA

WEDNESDAY, THURSDAY, FRIDAY

AUGUST

8-9-10-1

Beginning 7:00 each night

*12,500.00

IN

&amp;

ALCOHOL

ABSOLUTELY

&amp;

1, 1990
12:00 noon Saturday

AND RIBBONS

LAWS
NO

SATURDAY

CASH PRIZES

PLUS TROPHIES

DRUG

&amp;

WILL

DOGS

ON

BE

ENFORCED

GROUNDS

SEND ALL CORRESPONDENCE TO OLD FIDDLERS CONVENTION. P.O. BOX 655, GALAX, VA 24333.
FOR ENTRY BLANK AND/OR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, CONTACT THE FOLLOWING:
For General Information, contact Oscar Hall, Phone 703-236-6355

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Pre-registration required

by July 25, 1990

�IBMA WORLD OF BLUEGRASS 1990

Sept.25-28/Owensboro,
It's

a

panels and Exhibit Halls and established
section in the Showroom Lounge! And.
as always, the 1990 Trade Show will feature the
most provocative and focused set of workshops and
tobacco

Bluegrass

a

Homecoming

Owensboro, Kentucky!
your Bluegrass
is your Business or
your Love, you need
to be in Owensboro on
September 25-28, 1990
when the Bluegrass
Community comes together
in

at

a

September

World

of

earth lor

bluegrass business meeting.

advance (until 8/24/1990) charges

in

of S95

attending or S185 for an exhibit booth with the $300
to $600 most such events demand, and realize that we
charge artists only $50 for a showcase fee. which at

banquet, plus the Fan Fest!
Until August 24, 1990 the space fee for each exhibit
booth is an outrageous bargain at only $185 ($300
after 8/24/90), which includes admission to all Trade
Show activities including the showcases, awards,
seminars, and meals. Further savings can be realized
by obtaining a Trade Show exhibit booth and vending
space at the Fan Fest as a package. Contact IBMA for

many events runs in excess of $400, you can appre
ciate the tremendous, low cost opportunity the IBMA
World of Bluegrass Trade Show provides.

involvement,

to

Whatever your bluegrass
people you need to meet will be

Attend:

the

in

Owensboro for the IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990. It
will be the one stop place to make bookings, to hear
and meet in the comfort of the Executive Inn's Show
room Lounge the talent that will give your event the

Awards Program

more info.
Just compare our prices
scope, scale and quality!

galaxy on September 25 through 30, 1990 for
the IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990 Trade Show
and the IBMA Bluegrass Fan Fest. The Execu
tive Inn Rivermont will be the host for our
trade show, which will incorporate exhibi

tors displaying a vast array of bluegrass
related products and services, showcases
by established acts and the best of the new
generation of bluegrass talent, seminars

workshops where bluegrass people can
discuss the opportunities and problems fac
and

industry and learn

ing our

for

leaders

in

all

of our field, along with three lunch
eon meals and a very special banquet.

aspects

See history made first hand when IBMA presents its
initial Awards Program on Thursday night, Sep
tember 27! For the first time ever, bluegrass music
will
the

have an awards presentation based on voting
nominees' peers and colleagues, the Individual

and Organizational

Members

of IBMA.

by

and tabulated

independent accounting firm. It will be a
moment that will live through time just like the first
bluegrass festival and the first IBMA Trade Show. The
first time only happens once: BE THERE!
by an

How can

it

be any

better than

897, you're sure to ask

if

you

were one of the more than 720 people who had the
time of their bluegrass lives at Owensboro
last year. Try this: The Exhibit Hall, which
sold out a month early in '89, has been
j
expanded to provide 100 booths without
moving

it

from the main section ot the Execu

tive Inn. Plus, it will feature all night, in-room
security. We've kept the Trade Show at four days
so as to eliminate all conflicts with the Fan Fest and to
present the seminars in more digestible form. While

maintaining the evening format for the talent showcases
on Tuesday and Wednesday, we've added the Awards Sho*
following the banquet on Thursday and retained the
three fantastic showcase luncheons! That also means
that 1990 attendees will have four meals to enjoy, in
addition to morning coffee and donuts in the Exhibit
Hall. Non-smokers will be happy that we've eliminated

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to examine the latest in bluegrass related
products and services, to put faces with those famil
iar telephone voices, to attend three luncheon
meals and a sumptuous banquet Thursday evening,
and to experience first hand the historic Awards
Show. You'll come away from Owensboro with a
wealth of ideas, information, contacts, and good
times.

business,

Why you need

to

be

Bluegrass 1990 and the IBMA Bluegrass Fan Fest.
Discounts of up to 35% will be made available to those
using American to attend either event. In cooperation
with Owensboro's Livingstone Travel, full informa
tion about how to obtain these rates, including a spe
cial 800 number which must be used for ordering, will
be

trade event,

a not to be squandered
opportunity to
display your products and services to the people who
make bluegrass music happen. The IBMA World of
Bluegrass 1990 Trade Show is where you can sell your
band, product, or service to the targeted market you

need to reach, while making vital new business con
tacts and matching faces with voices you've known

is an opportunity on a scale
never before possible for personal, face to face expo
sure of your bluegrass related business. Whether per
former, luthier, talent agent, promoter, magazine,
radio syndicator, instrument supplier, camping
equipment or RV dealer, record manufacturer, whole
saler, studio, or whatever kind of bluegrass related
business-- you need to have a booth at the IBMA
World of Bluegrass 1990. The low booth fees, which
include registration for the entire event, make it the

over the telephone. This

When:

of

available

by July

.1.

Accommodations: A block of rooms at western Ken
tucky's finest hotel, the Executive Inn Rivermont of
Owensboro, is being held for IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990 attendees. Participants and exhibitors
may reserve rooms by writing to The Executive Inn
Rivermont (One Executive Boulevard: Owensboro. KY
42301) or by calling 800-626-1936 (In Kentucky use
(800) 482-8480). For information about other lodging
in the Owensboro
area contact the Owensboro
Daviess County Tourist Commission at 502-926-1100.

Bluegrass
bluegrass music's finest

bluegrass advertising bargain

any event of similar

of

Exhibit: The IBMA World of

Show will

1990 Trade

to

Travel: American Airlines and American Eagle, now
serving both Owensboro and Evansville, IN, have
been selected the official airlines for the IBMA World

to discuss your problems with your peers, to
learn the best ways to conduct events and bluegrass

edge,

Owensboro, Kentucky, the home of the
International Bluegrass Music Association,
will be the center of the bluegrass music

any year.

Registration for attendees opens at 10:00 AM on
Tuesday. September 25. 1990. Exhibitors
can set up between 10:00 AM and

IBMA

2:00 PM on Tuesday, Sep
tember 25. Panels begin Tuesday
afternoon: show_

Bringing the Bluegrass

Community Together for
Bluegrass Homecoming!

cases Tuesday night.

a

INTERNATIONAL
BLUEGRASS MUSIC

ASSOCIATION

IBMA WORLD OF BLUEGRASS
326 Sai

nt El

izabeth Street

Owensboro,

KY

1990 TRADE SHOW

42301

502-684-9025

calendar because September 25-28, 1990 will be the time for you to take part in bluegrass history,
whether as exhibitor or attendee, at the IBMA World of Bluegrass 1990 Trade Show, where the bluegrass music
community comes home.
Mark your

THIS ADVERTISING

SUPPORTED BY OWENSBORO

by

Registration for participants is only
$95 ($130 after 8/24/90) for individuals and just $170
($210 after 8/24/90) for couples, and that includes
admission to the showcases. Exhibit Hall, the Awards
Show, and seminars, along with three lunches and a

for

Why you need

If

August 24. 1990!

Bluegrass Trade Show is the greatest bargain on
a program
of its scale and scope! If you compare

our 1990

Friday. September 28, 1990.

you are considering attending or exhibiting,
just call or write IBMA for more information.
Notice the lantastic savings available to those who act
How:

commitment

a

Awards Show happens on Thursday night.
27. Formal Trade Show activities conclude

at 1:30 PM on

the art trade

Bluegrass
1990 Trade Show!
at the First IBMA

The IBMA

to presenting a state ol
show, while keeping the fees at a level
bluegrass people can afford. As a result, the IBMA

IBMA has

for the
IBMA World of
History

the

in

non-smoking

panels ever presented

If

Be a part ot

Kentucky

DAVIESS COUNTY TOURIST COMMISSION

�GRIBBLE, LUSK, AND YORK:
RECORDING A BLACK TENNESSEE
STRIN GB AND
Robert

by

1946 and 1949, Stu Jamieson, Margot
Mayo, and others went south to record
traditional music and dance calls. The
In

following

is

Jamieson's

eyewitness account

of the recording of the Gribble, Lusk, and
York band
resulting in some of the very
few recordings of black string-band music.
On

the

released Rounder album,
Black Stringband Music, we

newly

Altamont

can hear wonderful examples of their fas
cinating and beautiful music. We are grate

Tennessee Folklore Society and to
Stu Jamieson for allowing us to reprint this
version of his account of a historic and

ful

to the

fortuitous recording session

ed.

In 1892,
my maternal grandfather,
William Wallace Simpson, fresh from

his

home

in

the

Cumberlands

of

Tennessee, inspired by the call to preach
the Gospel, carried his beloved Bible and
banjo across northern China. At the

farther reaches of remote Kansu Province,
on the Tibetan border, he found his

harvest and began bringing in the sheaves.
He used his banjo to gather crowds, in
the same way the wandering buskers and
medicine shows did back in rural
Tennessee, and then he preached to
them. His banjo and singing charmed
Han Chinese,
and

Salar and Hui Moslems,

Tibetans alike, and

lished

a

he

soon estab

thriving group of missions. He

met and married

a

Swedish missionary

lady, raised a family, and taught them the
old songs. My mother, born and raised
in a Moslem town, learned his songs and
hymns, and came to accompany him on
autoharp and portable folding organ.

She married a Scots Canadian missionary,
and had two sons, who were sung to by
both parents and grandfather.
We came to the States when I was still
a small
boy, and moved from place to

place

as

my father preached and raised
for the

mission.

late '30s
City, near

In the

money
we located in New York
mission headquarters, where my parents
felt we would get the best high school
education. By sheer luck I ran across
Margot Mayo's American Square Dance
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

S.

Jamieson

and joined. Margot, born in
but
of the Floyd County, Kentucky
exas,
Mayo clan, had a call to revive urban

Group,
T

interest in square dances, playparties,
and folk music. W ith her encouragement
I bought
a banjo in a hock shop for ten
and set out to sound like
bucks
Grandpa, for I had a call to do that.
During World War II I was stationed
at two army bases in the South for about
18 months. After a stint in combat in
Europe I was discharged just in time for
a
the Group's 1945 Christmas party
joyful reunion for all Margot's kids who
had survived. Margot had just gotten
discharged from the W ACs, and like me,
wasn't quite ready for a return to
humdrum civilian life. We agreed to
pool our mustering-out pay and go for

a

long collecting trip in Appalachia. Our
goals were rather novel at the time, and

gathered us some raised eyebrows and
we would not only clearly
catcalls
record the calls of square dance callers,
and note down their meanings, we would
record tunings and techniques of all the
instrumentalists we would meet. In those
days, the prevailing sentiment of most

"experts" was that a
hapless imitation violinist,
deficient in "proper" technique, and
tunings were a way of avoiding having to
learn fingerings in several keys. (What a
delightful revenge we had when informing
them, upon our return, that Rufus Crisp
had learned 18 different fingering patterns

classically-trained
fiddler was

a

to use for his 18

different tunings!) So

Margot bought a good laboratory re
cording lathe and had it put in a case to
render it portable (if anything that
weighed 95 pounds could be considered
portable). I bought a rugged '38 Olds
coupe and had the engine rebuilt by

Lindbergh's old mechanic. My cousin
Gartley got me in the RCA recording
studios where the engineers gave me
lessons on recording on a studio lathe.
Margot recruited Freyda Simon to act as

music transcriber, note taker, and general
assistant. We crammed everything into
the coupe and headed south.
After many weeks in the Smokies and

with the Mayo clan in East Kentucky,
where we struck gold with wonderful
recordings of Margot's cousin Rufus
Crisp, we turned south again. We headed
for my great-aunt Oneida Petit's place in
Campaign, T ennessee, in the Cumberlands
a station on the L&amp;N line.
Aunt Oneida was a high matriarch of

considerable Simpson clan, and had
recording local people in no time.
Somehow, with no telephone and no car,
the
us

she got word

out

and

sent us off to

various locations. One morning she
announced that we were to go to the
store down by the depot to record the

best square dance band in that part of the
state. The store, owned by a cousin, had
electricity; aside from the depot, the sole
exception to kerosene power. We felt
that we had enough dance band sides
already, and our meager store of blank

recording disks was down pretty low,
but we acquiesced meekly. One couldn't
hurt such a generous and helpful soul.
We discussed it privately later, deciding

to cut only one or two disks, and restrict
those to any unusual tunes.
Right after an early supper we hauled
our equipment down to the store. It was

long shed near the tracks, and looked as
though it had been built by the railroad
it had a longroofed
planked porch
along one wall. Inside, it had the usual
a

deep-shady,

late-day, slanting-sunlit

appearance of all country stores in that
long-gone time and place. No sign of
electric lights. I approached the man
behind the old wooden counter, con
scious of the stares of the loafers sitting
on coke boxes or standing around, and
introduced myself. He was dressed in the
ubiquitous uniform of that time and
grey
place for non-field workers
whipcord trousers and faded blue work
shirt. His handshake seemed reluctant
and cool, but then I was a stranger, even
and talked funny. He
if a cousin

showed me where
cord, so

I

hauled

to plug in my

extension

our equipment and
worked I heard him talking
in

it up. As I
to Margot and Freyda; he was grumbling
about the disruption we represented to

set

�routine and working hours.
took it he was dragooned into becoming
studio proprietor by Aunt
a recording
Oneida. chuckled to myself and ignored
the rest until that crackling, lightninghis normal

1

I

striking word "nigger" turned on all my
alarms, and stood the hair on the back of
my neck upright. It was a word that
always put the three of us into silence
neutral, tight-lipped silence. We were

intruders, in that sad, bad,
confused, anguished still-newly-defeated
Ol' South. We had met living ex-slaves
strangers,

confederate
and ex-slave-owners,
veterans, a lady whose first horse was
confiscated by Yankee soldiers. 1 knew
the family stories of my own great
grandfather who had ridden with Jeb
Stuart (but who had freed his slaves
before going). It was a place where
memories of battles, glories, defeats,
confiscations, occupations,

and

person in whom they took great pride,
who was entirely honest, upright and
trustworthy; gentle, kind, and loyal, who
was bound for heaven without doubt
yet where everyone else's favorite dark
person was greatly to be feared, and had

controlled

by dirty and

despicable

means beyond description, merely to
keep the lid on and keep the blood
thirsty savages at bay. We had read all
too many newspaper accounts of

mysterious whippings

lynchings,

and

deaths. Margot and I knew the South
firsthand from our Army days; we had
heard stories about colored and Yankeetalking GIs being arrested by country
sheriffs, put on chain gangs for hitch
hiking, and the like. Freyda, though not
familiar with the South, was not less
she had heard the bad
fearful than us
stories but was just beginning to meet the
good people and hear the other side. As
for me, in the midst of killing and
avoiding being killed, I had learned to
control unreasoning fear, to go on despite
but here, in my own land, among my
kind and kin, that word raised the same
chills that the sounds of ricochets and
"incoming mail" had in Europe. Margot
finally got him turned off by shopping
for a pack of cigarettes; making him
bring out every brand in turn, finally
choosing her usual. We went out and
huddled quietly on the porch, venting
our feelings with whispered army-style

curse-besprinkled talk.

It

had hit us all

at

recording artists appeared to
be colored. Had Aunt Oneida mentioned
once
it?

our

We

couldn't

recall.

I

ladies.
People came and went, more men than
so
women, and fewer went than came
we soon had a respectable group leaning
against the walls, sitting on the few
chairs, barrels, sacks, and bins. My cousin
came over to me, and asked about the
recording machine. I went on about how
we did things, about the need for absolute
silence once I started the recording. He
said he'd make sure of that, and I
thanked him. He suddenly stood and
went to the door, calling something like:
"C'mon in, boys, yew come in now."
He waved his hand towards the store's
innards and repeated his welcoming call,

beloved

dead were ever fresh and strong, even in
the hearts of those who were not yet
like all my living kin.
born at the time
It was a strange land where every white
person seemed to have a favorite dark

to be

strategies, and decided to keep things as
short and trouble-free as possible. We
crept inconspicuously back inside.
chickened out by squatting over the
equipment, leaving social congress to the

We talked

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dozens of fascinated
eyes focused on the
whirling disk, swung
to the dark figures
of the band, then
back.
and was answered by a stirring among
the onlookers and deep soft voices saying

things. Finally, three
figures entered, same uniforms on, but
softmore weathered, if possible
brimmed old fedora hats hiding faces
bent towards the floor. Dark hands
clutched musical instruments; the band
was indisputably "colored." The first
figure was solidly built, with a burly

indistinguishable

medium height; he
old factory-made banjo with a
time-browned skin head. A figure of
medium build held a cheap guitar; in the
rear a man with a slighter frame and
quicker movements than the other two

frame,

held

of just over

an

carried a good-looking fiddle.
"We're all ready fer yew; c'mon set
down," said my cousin, pushing forward
two upended coke boxes, then scurrying
to the rear of the store and returning
with a third. The black men moved
uncertainly into the center of the room,
into the pool of light thrown down by a
naked bulb under a coolie-hat shade
hanging on a long cord, and paused,

looked hesitatingly

at

us,

then bobbed

heads, hats shading their faces. I
found my tongue and said, "Howdy" and
introduced ourselves. They nodded again,

their

saying "evenin' suh," "Ma'am" and Miss
then sat on the small narrow ends of the
boxes. The onlookers fell silent, and we
could hear the store clock ticking faintly.

They took

a

long time tuning up;

as

they did I moved our one microphone in
front of the banjo picker, who was in the
middle, and asked the other two to move
so as to make a semicircle around the
microphone. I squatted over the lathe
and settled the heavy earphones over my
not one
ears, puzzling about their hats

other soul present was wearing a hat. I
worried for them, expecting a reprimand
about disrespect, and then it hit me

were not making themselves at
I recall thinking how surrealistic it
was; they were the point of the whole
affair, the guests of honor, as it were, but
were pretending they were not really
there.
they

home!

The fiddle began a rhythmic sawing,
still tuning, the guitar hit the same beat a
few strokes, then all lapsed into anarchical
tuning. This was repeated several times,
the banjo joining once or twice for a
couple beats, then the sound fell apart
again. As

I

write this

1

understand suddenly

there was no caller to start them going
with his lead-in call, like: "All join hands
and circle to the South, let a little

moonshine

in

without warning,

yore
it all

mouth."

Then,

came together and

there was music.

This was before the rise of bluegrass,
with its instruments taking turns on
solos; all bands played the melody in
strict unison. In America the fiddle had
come first, playing all alone for dances. It
concentrated on playing the tune, adding
sliding two-note "double-stop" sounds
of
and often intricate embroiderings
vocal-style decorations. The banjo joined
later, constrained by its right-hand
patterns to playing the strong melody
notes, hinting at the others with its off
beat clang chunk-a chords, rhythmically
reiterated thumb string notes, gratuitous
non-melodic notes filling in the spaces.
But it followed the melody, and stayed
with it; the melody was its guideline.
Later, when guitars joined in they used
bass note-chord patterns too, sometimes
playing a run of bass notes to change
from one chord to another, but they too
stayed strictly on the beat. In this tradition
the tune was the twin rails that led the
bands around the tracks; the crossties of
the beat were spaced evenly.
What we heard this time was so
different it was almost disorienting. The
fiddle did not always lead the melody,
but passed it to the banjo, like runners
passing the baton. Half the time the

melody was played by the banjo, the
fiddle moaning low rhythmic chords,

�bit ot
as

disappointment nanging

in tne air

people filed out, nodding and saying

to us on the

hushed and shy goodnights
way out as

at

a

soon.
In

my

lovely party ending

exuberance

and

all

too

gratitude

I

would
drive them home. There was immediate
silence, then rumbling demurring from
announced

the

to

band

that

I

I surely didn't have to do that,
they'd be alright, they'd be home in no
time, and the like. My cousin stood
stock still a few moments, his eyes wide
and his lips clenched. Then he beckoned
me over close and whispered fiercely in
my ear, "Folks 'round here don't do that,

the band:

courtesy

Charles

Wolfe

'tain't right." When

over and over. Suddenly, at the second
part of the tune, the fiddle would leap
into an upper octave, with a wild cry, and
take over the burden of the tune. The
banjo would then play a loose and free

polyphonic obligato around

a

rudi

mentary suggestion of the melody, ranging
far away melodically,
omitting strong

downbeats, dancing a different step
and this was most radical
rhythmically
of all for

not

banjo

downbeats

and

upbeats
sudden startling
Even when

gaps

the

hitting all the
there were

and

banjo

hesitations.

took

over

the

lower-octave half of the tune, and its
wildness was somewhat subdued by the
demands of melody, it produced a rolling
syncopation like a jazz beat. Down below
all, the guitar produced steady deep
heartbeats, like the throb of a great
engine in the bowels of a ship, laying
down the full chords that defined the
threshing floor upon which fiddle and
banjo leaped and soared.

We cut disk after disk, the band
becoming real professionals at it after we
had them start

tune, stop at a signal
from me, then resume the unheard but
perfectly-kept beat. The onlookers were
perfect; never an interruption or noise
while the cutting head was down on the
disk. All eyes focused on me as 1 started
every cut, as though I was part of some
strange act on stage in a night club. It was
with smoky air, a
a night club in a way
darkened room with stage lights, musi
cians, and enthusiastic applause. Margot
and Freyda sat near the pool of light,
staring at their notes; Margot's head
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

as

she squinted past the smoke

from the ubiquitous butt set at the edge
of a broad smile. Unlike any night club
I'd ever been in, the audience was
absolutely still during the acts; almost
breathless. I came to feel that all shared
my strong sense of satisfaction in every
good recording done; I could hear the
breaths let out each time 1 lifted the head
from the groove at the end. The pro
prietor opened the doors in between

recording, and people would go
outside for fresh air, and new faces
would crowd in. When I called that all
was ready, after checking with the band,
he closed the doors and called for silence
and there was instant silence. Dozens
of fascinated eyes focused on the whirling

each

disk, swung to the dark figures of the
band, then back. As I handed each
finished record to Freyda, Margot would
slap

a

temporary label on

it,

checking the

name of the tune carefully with the band
members. And what names, as different
"Smoke Behind the
as their tunes

Clouds," "Running Through the Whiteoaks," "Old Sage Friend," "Broke-Legged

Chicken," "Altamont"

(a nearby town).
"Rolling River," that
on like the mighty
Mississippi, and one that took us a long
time to realize was a version of the

And what tunes
rolled on and

"Tennessee Wagoner."
Shortly before ten, a very late hour tor
those who rose before cockcrow, Margot
spoke quietly to the band, who nodded
to her. She announced that we were
stopping for the night and would finish
up tomorrow evening. One could sense a

stub

a

niggers with razors alius raisin'
hell, and they'll catch you fer shore." I
didn't reply. "Hit's only three miles,

thereabouts, anyway."

take them at least an
take me long. Don't
I'll
in
the
car. Nobody's even
worry,
stay
hen that

hour!

cocked

maintained

young

T

John Lusk ca. 1960

I

born silence he went on, "besides, they
don't want any white folks pokin' 'round
in Dogtown; there's a lotta them mean

It

d

won't

gonna see me!"
"Hell, they'll know; they don't have
cars like yore's."
"I'm going; it's the least I can do."
He shook his head and I went back to

the band
they were gone. I rushed out
the door and found them just setting off
down the dirt road. Again they held
back, but 1 finally got them in the Olds
coupe. The guitarist and fiddler crouched
on the little jump seats in back, huddled
over and wrapped around their instru
ments; the more substantial banjo picker,
Murphy Gribble, sat in front with me.
There was silence as we started off, but I

broke

it by

asking directions

as we hit the

main highway.

In minutes a chorus of bass voices
called to me to slow down, then directed
me to stop at a little cabin on the left. It

the usual faded wooden share
croppers shack seen all over the South

was
a

box about

16

by 24,

set

on

four

knee-high corner posts, peaked tin roof
running fore-and-aft, little veranda across
the front. We all struggled out so the
fiddler could get out, and the guitar
player said he could just as easily walk
from here. I persuaded him back in, and
we drove another half-mile and let him
off at a similar house.
Soon afterwards, we turned off on a
dirt road, winding around between the
tall pines. After a few shacks passed by
we got onto a track through the sandy

soil; just two old wagon ruts smoothed
down by a recent rain, possibly that
evening. The heavy car pulled hard, but

smoothly, through

the

sparse

woods,

�passing a couple of shacks. Then, when
the lights picked out another, the deep
voice next to me softly suggested a stop.
As he got out, he thanked me profusely
as the others had, and said his goodnights.

The second recording session was a
repeat of the first, but with more on
lookers, and the band seemed more at
ease. They made sure they filled the disks
right up to the end; like Rufus Crisp
before them they made sure nothing of
the government disk was wasted. Unlike
Rufus, who had to import verses to
prolong a short song, all they had to do
was keep playing the same tune, eyes
fixed on the lathe, and stop when there
was a half inch left. When they misjudged
I
turned the volume down and faded
them out. When they couldn't think of
tunes, the audience prompted them, but
they finally ran out of their repertory.
Margot and then tried hard to get them
to record a "sukey jump," for they had
told us about playing for black occasions
such as kitchen dances, weddings, etc.,
when they played "sukey jumps" as well
as square dance tunes. They told us we
didn't want that old stuff, and declined
I

so

stubbornly

give

up.

Even

and
a

insistently
few

in

we had to

audience

the

joined in the pleading; again there was
keen disappointment when the session
ended.
On the road to Nashville a couple of
days later we got a jolt from the radio
that made me pull the car over to the
roadside and park half in the ditch. It was
a
string band with a fast-driving
syncopated sound wherein each in

strument took jazz-like solos. The banjo
had a syncopated sound, but all the beats
were there. We knew that from the
voices this band had to be white, but the
resemblance was uncanny
the same
mixed measures, but no brushes, and the
picker's left hand went all over the neck.
At a cafe juke box we heard them again,
and found out about Bill Monroe's new
country music sensations, the Blue Grass
Boys with Earl Scruggs. The bluegrass
era was just dawning.

Two-and-a-half years later

to go back to Campaign

at

I

decided

Easter break.

I

lights, and wash machine, and told me

that my arguments had convinced her it
was reasonably safe to have the stuff

around. When I told her we wanted to
record the band again, but this time I was
determined to drive them to and from,

she acceded and offered the use of her
house as recording studio. Somehow she
got the word out without leaving the
house, for she told us next morning the
band would be ready that evening.
I drove
alone, so as to have room in
the car. It was quite easy to find Albert
I merely
York's place
stopped at the
first cabin in Rocky Ford and asked. He
led me to John Lusk's cabin, in turn, and
the two guided me along the labyrinth of
trails to Murphy Gribble's place. They
did seem genuinely pleased to see me,
almost as much as I was to see them.
Because of the recordings their reputation
had increased and people hired them

from

all the

surrounding counties, both

cafe juke box
we heard them again,
and found out about
Bill Monroe's new
At

a

country music sen
sations, the Blue

Grass Boys with Earl
Scruggs. The bluegrass era was just

dawning.

melodic or harmonic relationship to the
fiddle's melody, but skipped around the
melody, following its trends up and
down

black and white. They looked about the
same, except that Murphy Gribble's eyes
were getting cloudy from cataracts, and
their faces a bit more lined.
Aunt Oneida invited them in cordially,
took their hats and seated them on

chairs,

brought

them lemonade

buttermilk. This time Bob

and
the

sleeping bags.

they

ran

recorder

and I did the interviewing.
When I told them that what was urgently
needed, for the sake of future scholars

said.

1

in

the most general way, with that

chopping, stop-and-start syncopated,

complex rhythmic tapestry he wove. (He
spoke of it as "broke-legged rhythm,"
later.) Then, when the low part came in,
the rhythm steadied to a repeated, less
free pattern, sending out the low portion
of the melody in what surely would be
if it
called a bluegrass-influenced style
weren't for its greater antiquity. When
he said it was the
old folks played, he claimed
absolutely no credit for originating any

questioned off-mike,
way the

thing. Modesty, or truth?
We got the others to do the same,

greatly encouraged by his success, and so
laid bare the bones of their musical
structure. They played the notes of their
instruments, to il'ustrate their tunings,
and told of the two keys in which they
played

the "high key," and the "flat

Only the banjo seemed to use
scordata [other than standard for the
instrument] tunings, and only two wellknown ones at that. Their antiquity is
key."

strongly suggested by the fact that their
pitch was at the old low frequency that
abounded before the advent of
diamond-drawn steel strings many decades

suggested they play

a

few

tunes and warm up first. They were
relieved at this postponement of disaster,
and launched into a series of the old
tunes
each preceded by a long retuning

a

modern banjoist's

Murphy Gribble's A
being
tuned down one and one-half tones; the
same with the ubiquitous G tuning,
which was detuned to E. When Gribble
came into Aunt Oneida's parlor, he
spotted my recent acquisition, a fancy #7
Whyte Laydie, and his eyes shone, so I
handed it to him. He wanted to use it for
the recording, and when
said "of
course," he tuned it down instantly.
C

and musicians, was their individual
separate sounds, they looked panicky.
They hadn't ever played alone since
Murphy came home from W orld W ar I,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gribble to fly solo first, and turned on
the wire recorder. There was a long, long
pause, then he said, "Alright, but I'm
gonna make a bobble of it," and he
picked a nervous series of notes at the
basic beat rhythm, then over 40 years of
habit took over and he knocked us flat
with his intricate polyphonic obligato to the
fiddle's lead in the high part of
"Altamont." It seemed to bear no direct

before; what would be

asked my fiancee', Gloria, to come along
and meet her future kin. We invited my
roommate, Bob Opdahl, who rounded
up a wire recorder, and his fiancee,
Viola, and we all crammed into my '33
Chevy four door and drove straight
through, except for a few hours on a
snowy Virginia mountainside in cold
Campaign had changed; Aunt Oneida
had permitted the power lines to cross
her place, and even had electricity in her
home. She showed us her radio, electric

session. Finally we prevailed on Murphy

was

I

Thus the G tuning became eBEF#b,
instead of the modern gDGBd. His other
tuning was lowered from the popular
gCGcd to eAEab.
W ith Aunt Oneida's warm hospitality,
our obvious enjoyment, everyone's relief
at the successful solos, even joy at a job
well done
they broke spontaneously
into a sukey jump, "C.C. Rider." Not the
well-known blues of the same name, it
had a similar melodic structure, but was
a

happier sound, to

a

saucy swing beat.

�We were fascinated, and asked for more,
but they seemed appalled and firmly
declined to play any more. I have often
wondered about it; was this a private

music to be kept from the prying whites?
Plantation songs and ditties, spirituals,
had all
jazz. blues, rhythm-and-blues,
been ruthlessly appropriated and
exploited and watered down by white

society; perhaps only the sukey jumps

were left to be kept pure for those who

loved them.
They're all gone now, and their music
with them
as a living tradition. Ever
since first finding them I have alerted

scholars and collectors

to

find

more;

must sadly conclude
the last handful of
survivors of a magnificent black musical
tradition that has gone forever. Except
for some licks reprocessed by Uncle
Dave Macon, and in these serendipitous
recordings, one cannot hear any examples
of what must be an old style rooted in the
yearning hearts of slaves, possibly as old
as the Republic. One cannot go anywhere
today, on the face of this earth, and hear
that music played by live musicians of
any color.* Another endangered musical
species has died, almost unnoticed. H
none ever have.
that they were

[This
"Gribble,

article

was exerpted from
Lusk and York: Recording a

Tennessee

Black

I

Stringband"

in

Vol.

of the Tennessee Folklore
Society Bulletin, summer, 1987, published
by the Tennessee Folklore Society,
LIII

No.

2

Middle Tennessee State

University,

Murfreesboro, 37132.]

In the

there was

summer '89 issue of the OTH
an

article on black string band

musicians Joe &lt;Sl Odell Thompson from
the North Carolina piedmont. Their

recent tape

on

Global

Village was

spring '90 issue of the
OTH. Their music is reminiscent of the
music discussed in the above article.

reviewed

in the

S. (Stu) Jamieson plays banjo and
teaching banjo and square dancing."
Jamieson worked as an electronics engineer

Robert

"loves

and retired in 1989. He and his family have
traveled extensively, and now that he is
retired

he

and his wife plan on living on

sailboat.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

�GRAYSON
Old-Time

Section with Illegible Text

(annual)
&amp;

COUNTY

Bluearass

FIDDLER'S
CONVENTION

Section with Illegible Text

ELK CREEK SCHOOL BALL PARK
5

Elk Creek, Virginia
PM SATURDAY, JUNE 30, 1990

PM FRIDAY, JUNE 29
4
ALWAYS HELD LAST WEEKEND

$2,100

IN

JUNE

CASH plus Rosettes

REGISTER TIL SHOW TIME Bands &amp; Individuals REFUND TO PERFORMERS
No Electrical Instruments Allowed
ALL AWARDS WILL BE MADE SATURDAY NIGHT
by the Elk Creek Volunteer Fire Department
Grayson V.F.W. Post No. 7726, Independence, VA.

Sponsored

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&amp;

�CLASSIFIED
will
The Old-Time Herald
accept
classified ads at the cost of .50 cents per
word, minimum $7.00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the
first of the month, 2 months prior to

publication.

Musical Instruments
INSTRUMENTS FOR SALE 1923 Vega
Regent original five string banjo, $650,
Guitars; 1975 Guild D-50 $675, 1938

L-37, 000 size black archtop
holes $500, LoPrinzi LR-50,
1956 Martin 2-15 mandolin
$650,
Fancy
$550, Cajun Accordion by Jumall $500,
Banjo Ukes $75-$100, Good Fiddle
bows $75-$200. And more, send SASE
for list. Bob Smakula, Smakula Fretted
Instruments, P.O. Box 882, Elkins, WV

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION
NEW-USED-VINTAGE guitars, banjos,

mandolins, archtops, wood &amp;c metal
body Dobros, Nationals. Mandolin
Brothers, 629 Forest Ave., Staten Island,
718NY 10310. FREE CATALOG
98 -3226. Call for no-charge evaluation
of your vintage fretted instruments.
1

Fiddle, banjo, guitar instruction, tunebooks, recordings, free catalogs, Captain
Fiddle, 4 Elm Court, Newmarket, NH

03857. 603-659-2658.

F

INSTRUCTIONAL BOOKS, VIDEOS,
CASSETTES,

discount

much

and

catalogs.

more.

Free

ELDERLY

INSTRUMENTS, 100 N. Washington,
POB 14210-BJ34, Lansing, MI. 48901
(517) 372-7890.
1

26241. 304-636-6710.

STELLING, MARTIN,
GIBSON, STIVER, GUILD, DEERING,
REITER, KENTUCKY, much more, in

FLATIRON,
stock now

at

the best prices. Free dis

count catalogs. ELDERLY INSTRU
MENTS 1100 N. Washington, POB
14210-BJ34, Lansing, MI 48901 (517)

Fiddler with FlattSIMS
team
(1949-52). Musical tapes,
Scruggs
video.
instructional books, &lt;Sl tapes
Free brochure. Benny Sims, 318 Swanee
Dr., Johnson City, TN 37601 (615)

BENNY

282-1219.

372-7890.

SQUARE DANCE CLASSICS: cassette
SUBSCRIBE

NOW

to

our

monthly

used and vintage instrument list with
hundreds of quality instruments at
down-to-earth prices. $4.00/ year ($8.00
overseas). Current issue free on request.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.
Washington, POB 14210-BJ34, Lansing,
MI

48901 (517) 372-7890.

BLUEGRASS &amp; OLD-TIME
INSTRUMENTS, new, used, vintage.
Free, friendly advice. All correspond

FINE

ence answered promptly and

919-383-5750.

in

depth.

S.A.S.E. brings
current listing. Subscriptions with extra
services $5.00. Harry &amp;. Jeanie West,
3815 Tremont Dr., Durham, North
Or,

45&lt;t

Carolina 27705.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with 10 complete old time singing calls
by Bob

with

Dalsemer plus 23 page booklet

instructions,

music,

chords.

"Alabama Jubilee," "Down Yonder," "Just
"
1 6 postpaid. T raditional
Because, etc.
Caller Productions, 3029 Guilford Ave.

Baltimore, MD 21218.

A

delightful

collection of 100 irresistable dance tunes

in Old-Time, Celtic, and New England
styles. Challenging tunes, Zesty music!!
Book: $12.95, Tape: $8.95, add $2.00
shipping; CA residents ad 6.25% tax.
Order from Daniel Engle, Box 123,

Upper Lake, CA 95485.

Books

Instruction

Gibson
with

TUNES FROM HOME

Tapes

THE MANDOCRUCIAN'S DIGEST
America's only MANDOLIN publication!

Interviews, instruction, reviews. All
$10/year (foreign
styles. Quarterly

Sample-$3.00. NILES
HOKKANEN, POBx 1935-H, Martinsburg, WV 25401.
$14.00).

COUNTRY MUSIC CLASSIC TAPES:
Old time string bands, bluegrass, gospel.
1920s- 1960s. Send $1.00 for catalog.
Joe Bussard, 6610 Cherry Hill Dr.,
Frederick, MD 21701.

Personals
CHURLISH,

insenitive,

financially in

secure SWM musician, 35 (looks 35)
160 lbs. seeks heiress (29-39) with severe
rescue tendencies and low-esteem, for
grumbling, sulking and crabbing

(alternate Thursdays only). My interests
include eating, sleeping and myself. No
personal growth/fitness/socially con

cerned types need apply. My sign is Stop
if yours is Yield. Write C/O the OLDTIME HERALD.

�Sales

County

H
□j
M
Pu

/TylBMK

T

INTERNATIONAL

BLUEGRASS

MUSIC

ASSOCIATION

NEW RELEASES
MASTERS OF TRADITIONAL MISSOURI FIDDLING Lovely 2-LP set with huge booklet
$15.00
VIRGINIA-CAROLINA SAMPLER Featuring Lonnie Austin, Jim Scancarelli, Wayne Henderson, etc
7.50
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BAN JO COLLECTION Super set of 1937 -46 field recordings by John Lomax..
7.50
CARTER FAMILY "Diamonds In The Rough" Lovely issue of 1941 Border Radio transcriptions
7.50
BLUE SKY BOYS "There'll Come ATime" Excellent reissue of early 1936 recordings
7.50
TOMMY JARRELL "Sail Away Ladies" One of his best LPs
7.50
great old time fiddle
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial and field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
8.00
FRENCH MITCHELL "First Fiddle" Fine fiddle LP by 71 year old West Virginian
$8.00
THE MUSIC NEVER DIES"AVandalia Sampler 1977
87" Lovely 2-LP set of West Virginia musicians
$15.00
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo/fiddle LP by this Kentucky musician
7.50
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Excellent reissue of their classic 1940s King sides
7.50

FC-007
*ROU-0237
*CCLP-0107

*BSR-1001

CO-756

AT- 103

UW

K

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
MEMBER OF

GREY- 101

KJ

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
READY FOR SHIPMENT

ELD-003
ELD-004
*JA-051
"CCS-110

GRAYSON &amp; WHITTER Lovely set of songs and ballads from 1927
30
RILEY PUCKETT "Waitin' For The Evening Mail" Great reissue of Puckett's 1930 s recordings
BLUE SKY BOYS "In Concert 1964" Super live concert from University of Illinois
UNCLE DAVE MACON "Hillbilly Blues
Vol 3" Fine reissue of early 1920s recordings
EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO With Tommy Magness, Roy Hall, Roanoke Entertainers, etc
PIONEERS OF CAJUN ACCORDION 1926
36 With Joe Falcon, Amade Ardoin, Amade Breaux, etc
CLAWHAMMER BANJO
Vol 2 Featuring Tommy Jarrell, Oscar Wright, Fred Cockerham, etc
CHARLIE POOLE &amp; THE NORTH CAROLINA RAMBLERS -Vol 3 Great old-time recordings
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
ECHOES OF THE OZARKS
Vol 2 Features Arkansas string bands of 1927
30

CO-411

"ROU-0236
OH- 184

'BRI-010
OT- 128

CO-717
CO-516
*CMF-011

CO-519
HER-063

A TRIBUTE

CO-786
CO-787

OH- 198

CO-511

*CO-506
MARLU-8901

CO-403
AH-002
OT-112

HER-070
*FF-415

FF-480

HER-067
*JA-055

\JA-056
CO-533

*CO-734
FF-468
MRDB-0105
*AJA-5058
*ROU-O122

CO-548

TO TOMMY JARRELL With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, Andy Cahan, Brad Leftwich, etc
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent field recordings with Clyde Troxell, Clyde Davenport, etc
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN More field recordings with Virgil Anderson, Dee Hicks, etc
GID TANNER &amp; HIS SKILLET L1CKERS "Early Classic String Bands" from 1934
recordings
MOUNTAIN BLUES Reissue with Sam McGee, JimmieTarlton, Dock Boggs, Doc Roberts, etc
SKILLET LICKERS Old-time tunes recorded form 1927 thru 1931 -Clayton McMichen, etc
LULU BELLE &amp; SCOTT Y "Tender Memories Recalled" From early 1950s radio shows
nice
ROANE COUNTY RAMBLERS Their complete recordings of 1928
29
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American Fiddle Music From Mississippi
with booklet
JIMMY TARLTON &amp; TOM DARBY Fine reissue of 1927
1932 recordings
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis, Roscoe Parish, w/booklet
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" Mike
Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
WALT MICHAEL &amp; COMPANY "Step Stone" Features hammered dulcimer, fiddle etc
GALAX INTERNATIONAL 2-LP set featuring Mike Fenton, Kazuhiro Inaba, etc
MORGAN SEXTON "Rock Dust" Traditional Appalachian ballads with banjo &amp; fiddle
RALPH BLIZARD &amp; THE NEW SOUTHERN RAMBLERS "Blizard Train" OT fiddle from Tennessee
ROUND THE HEART OF OLD GALAX
Vol
Featuring the music of Ernest Stoneman
BONNIE RUSSELL/RUSSELL FAMILY "Mountain Dulcimer
Galax Style" (Cassette only)
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" Recent old-time music by this West Virginia
group
MILL RUN DULCIMER BAND "You've Been A Friend To Me" Old-time, traditional, sentimental music
JIMMIE RODGERS "My Old Pal" Reissue of 18 songs from 1927
32 sessions
Import
NORMAN BLAKE/RISING FAWN STRING ENSEMBLE Featuring Nancy Blake, James Bryan
R1DIN' IN A OLD MODEL T Features Dixie Ramblers, Rector Trio,
Ray Brothers, etc

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
7.50
0.00
7.50
7.50
$12.50
1

7

by an

asterisk

50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

1

(Above albums available on cassette as noted

Ui

1

0

LJB

00

7.50
7.50

"

")

ICO-513
POSTAGE

&amp; HANDLING: USA ORDERS: Please add $2.00 for first
to 3 LPs, add $3.00 for 4 or more LPs
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Please add $5.00 postage and handling charges for up to 3 LPs,
then $1.50 for each additional LP. MINIMUM FOREIGN order is 2 items.
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

H

�Reviews

ALTAMONT:

rolling,

Black

Stringband

Rounder CD 02381
Frazier-banjo

&amp; vocal; Frank Patterson-fiddle

(1942).

Dan Tucker/Old

Cow Died/Bile Them Cabbage
Black Sheep/Eighth of January/
Corrinne/Texas Traveller

Down/Po

Murph Gribble-banjo;
guitar

John Lusk- fiddle; Albert York-

(1946/ 1949).

Rolling

as it

gets.

John Lusk was born in 1886 near Campaign, in

Music From
the Library
of Congress
Nathan

the pristine magic of banjo and fiddle sets

in and it's as good

River/Old

Sage

Blossom/Pateroller'll Catch
Sea/Cincinnati/ Altamont

Fri

Apple

You/ Across

The

This is the recording that finally convinced me to
purchase a CD player. Industry experts have
preached of the demise of LPs for years, but it
looks like it's finally coming to pass. Many "musthave" recordings seem to be released on CD (or
tape) only, no LPs. Sigh, I love LPs, and the liner
notes. To its credit, Rounder has made space in this

package for some excellent writing by Charles
Wolfe, whose essay on black old-time music
graced the OTH pages in fall '87- There is some
irony in this being my first CD purchase. Frazier &amp;.
Patterson were captured on a glass disk recorder by
John Work and the Lusk ensemble was recorded
by Margot Mayo, StuJamieson, et.al. on a portable
disk cutting machine and a wire recorder. There is a
lot (I mean "a lot") of surface noises, hiss, etc. Bob
Carlin, who produced this set, chose to let the
noise remain when it was within the same range as
the music so that little of the music would be lost.
Extensive equalization has been done. I am quite
used to the noise on 78s or on aluminum disks, but
other listeners may be repulsed by the sound
quality on this CD. I feel that it is well worth the
effort to try to listen to this incredible disk. Frank
Patterson was born near Nashville in about 1880
and learned his fiddling from older black musicians
in what his son termed a "breakdown style," not
blues. Nathan Frazier was a noted street musician
and singer who lived in Nashville at the time they
were recorded. He was known for banjo tricks
similar to Uncle Dave Macon's. His playing sounds
like a clawhammer style. On some selections his
instrument sounds fretless, although that could be
produced by noting with his fingernails and sliding,
a
technique sometimes used by Kyle Creed.
Patterson and Frazier are tuned considerably below
standard pitch, which gives the music a whole
different feel, and matches perfectly Frazier's low
growly voice. The program is nicely balanced
between relatively well-known pieces like "Dan
Tucker" and "Eighth of January" (reminiscent of a
version from Dr. Humphrey Bates' Possum
Hunters), and unique numbers like "Old Cow
Died" and "Po Black Sheep." Frazier's banjo work
is featured on "Bile Them Cabbage" and "Corrinne."
"Texas Traveller" appears to be a melding of
"Cumberland Gap"and "Dubuque' (I think it's
played in the key of "D"). There's a rough-hewn
quality about their playing, but when they get

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

south-central Tennessee. He played the fiddle that
had been his grandfather's, a slave who had been
sent to New Orleans to learn to play in the 1840s.
Albert York was Lusk's half brother. Gribble,
whom Wolfe speculates might have been older
than Lusk, was Lusk's brother-in-law. This family
band was known as the best dance band in their
region, a reputation this recording will only further
(see Robert Jamieson's article in this issue). Much
of their repertoire will be familiar to the student of
music originating in the Sequatchie Valley or
Cumberland Plateau. "Cincinnati" has been recorded by Blaine Smith (on the Pine Breeze label)
and "Old Sage Friend" (as "Old Sage Fields") and
"Apple Blossom" have been collected from Kentucky fiddler Jim Bowles. The Lusk band also
recorded many old-time standards like "Eighth of
January," "Across the Sea," "Billy in the Lowground," "Fire On the Mountain" (as "Sambo"),
and "Run Nigger Run" (as "Pateroller'll Catch
You"), not all heard here. But you've never heard
these tunes as this band played them. The banjo
(picked in an early three-finger style) and fiddle are
especially on "Rolling River,"
random pattern of parts. The rhythm is
rock-solid and pulses with energy while the fiddle
and banjo trade off melody and backup. All three
musicians feed off each other. The Lusk band, like
Frazier and Patterson, is tuned below pitch, which
is very much evident on what I feel is the best cut
on the disk, "Altamont," where the band plays
together, then the banjo plays the tune alone, then
the fiddle alone. The low notes make the earth
tremble beneath my feet. Lusk, Gribble, and York
have produced music that has moved me like no
other. I could get corny and say that it has changed
my life, but these three musicians have changed the
way I listen to and play old-time music. Perhaps
they'll do that for you. Many thanks must go out
for creating this recording. First, to John Work,
Margot Mayo, StuJamieson, and their helpers for
making the original recordings. Second, to Rounder
Records for releasing this and other fine vintage
material from the Library of Congress archives.
Third, to Charles Wofle for his research, scholarship, and writing. Finally, to Bob Carlin for his
vision in producing this. An old-time music fan
who loves archaic playing and can grasp the music
beyond the noise will own a treasure with this
recording. (Kerry Blech) Also available on cassette

amazingly

which has

and

LP.)

tight,

a

�Two of the originals on the album are mistakes.
"Things Are Funny" features Nancy on the singlerow accordion. Her artless performance on this
instrument

is in

striking contrast

to her

undoubted

skills with the mandolin and cello. The instrumental
melody of this piece is reminiscent of the Cajun
song "Chere Mom," but for anyone able to detect
the Cajun allusion the Blake piece seems quite
insipid in comparison. Also, unusually, the arrange
ment of this song is inept, with the accordion
masking Nancy's somewhat indistinct singing. The
solo 5-string fiddle piece, "Mahnuknuk," is wellplayed, for sure, but musically negligible, and its
insistent chromatic figure quickly becomes annoying.
The sound quality is excellent throughout; these
musicians have beautiful instruments and have
spared no pains to record them properly. The
balance is also well done, with a sufficient emphasis
on Nancy's leads while the other players come
through clearly too.
At its best this music is relaxed, spacious, and

played precisely and sensitively, if not
passionately. Fans of the Blakes, and aficionados of
new acoustic music in general, will probably be
very pleased with the album. Mandolin enthusiasts
will be attracted by Nancy Blake's crystal clear
playing of the instrument. Hard-core old-time nuts
may be less positive, depending on their attitude to
"pretty" music. (Allin Cottrell)
lucid,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�version (for the full purple version, the prurient
listener is pointed to Glenn's rendition on "Just
Something My Uncle Told Me," Rounder 0141).
"Punchin' the Dough" sings the praises of the
hands who feed the cowboys
"When you crawl
from your roll and the ground it is froze/ Who biles
the coffee that thaws out your nose?"
not as
macho a position but just as critical to the outfit; a
nice perspective. A 12-page booklet is enclosed
with photos and drawings by Glenn, with the lyrics
and song-notes. His anecdotes are very similar to
what you might hear Glenn utter at one of his
concerts. If you can't get enough of this man, look
for his book, "The Hell Bound Train," published
by the University of Illinois Press in 1974, or look
for his earlier albums, "The Hell Bound Train" on
Puritan and "Cowboy Songs" on Philo. I must say
that Glenn Ohrlin might not suit everyman's taste,
but he's the pork in my chile verde. (Kerry Blech)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�These two sets of Woody Guthrie's songs are
re-issues. Alan Lomax recorded Guthrie for the
Library of Congress in March, 1940. The recordings, in the same form as we have here, were issued
on three records by Elektra in the mid-1960s.
RCA Victor recorded Woody on April 26, 1940
and released six 78s in July, 1940. RCA issued
them (with two additional selections) on an LP in
1964. Somehow this important music went out-ofprint. Many books and articles chronicle Guthrie's
won't delve too deeply into it here, but I
life, so
will mention that he came out of the OklahomaTexas Dust Bowl during the Great Depression of
the 1930s and found himself a singing radio star in
California and later in New York. Woody had a
firm foundation in the traditional music of his
home area. He knew the songs and the dance tunes.
He performed some of these pieces and used many
of the old melodies as the starting point for his
compositions that illustrated the human condition
I

of the Depression. The "Dust Bowl Ballads" collec
tion is about as clear a picture as you'll find of that
era. He captured the heartbreak and the despair
and also found the faint glimmer of hope (as in
"Dust Can't Kill Me"). It was the embers of hope
that Woody hoped to fan into a prairie fire. He was
so moved by the film version of Steinbeck's "The
Grapes of Wrath" that he composed a tribute to it
"Tom Joad"
that told the entire plot. Woody
also tried to elevate the hero (to the Okie victims of
the Depression) and robber, Pretty Boy Floyd, to a
mythical Robin Hood status. Apparently Woody
didn't have much clout with the authorities as
Floyd was later gunned down in a Columbiana
County, Ohio farm pasture. Woody had a way
with words. This is shown quite clearly in his
conversations with Alan Lomax on the Library of

Congress set. He is in good voice on both records.
An unfortunate problem (as some might see it) is
the duplication of songs on these two releases.
Nine of the thirteen selections on Dust Bowl Ballads
can be found on the L. of C. collection. ("Worried
Man Blues" on the L. of C. set also was on the
Columbia River Collection," Rounder 1036, reviewed
in the winter '88/'89
OTH). To the die-hard
Guthrie fan, this poses no problem. That fan will
want to compare versions, for Woody ad-libbed
quite a lot. The curious might want to see how

Gutherie, constrained in a professional recording
studio (actually, it's hard to conceive of Woody
being constrained anywhere) stacks ups against the
more informal setting of the Department of Interior
studio, with Alan Lomax's prompting and a bottle.

Both sets are of high quality, showing Woody as
the singer and composer of legend. Those who
know him only as the inspiration for a couple of
generations of urban folk singers will be amazed at
how well he sings and plays guitar and harmonica
(one thing Bob Dylan did not learn from Guthrie).
In fact, Woody steps out on harmonica on three L.
of C. numbers, "Lost Train Blues," "Railroad
Blues," and "Beaumont Rag." I'd like to say that he
gave DeFord Bailey

a run for his money,
but that
stretching it a little. He was quite a
competent harmonica player, though. It astounds
me that Woody's pleasant (and culturally
important) music was unobtainable (for the most
part) for a while. These two sets, along with the

would

be

Columbia

River Collection,

towards
Blech)
way

correcting

have gone a long, long
that situation. (Kerry

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�which the words don't justity.
And so the tape goes, one inconsistency after
another. The cheerful banjo version of "Little
Birdie" is a relief after "Bluejacket." Mullin's style
is reminiscent
of Grandpa Jones
lots of fullness,
and then the tape reverts to a
ringing, and energy
discouraging "hokey folky" style with "Elmer and
the Bear."
It seems that this material might do better in a
live concert than on a tape. The Mullins follow
some precepts often used in arranging a concert set:
they vary their style and tempo, choose tunes of

different

natures, and use dramatic pauses and
tone of voice (as in "The Farmer's
Cursed Wife," where Deb Mullins imitates the
voice of the farmer, the Devil, all the little devils.
and the farmer's wife too). These techniques might
work well when a band has the audience firmly in
hand, but a listener coming at this tape cold might
find it unsettling that no consistent style or genre is
established.
One style that this tape would have done well to
represent more fully is Moon's Travis-style quitar
picking. His playing on "Wayfaring Stranger" and
"Nine Pound Hammer" has lots of life and spunk,
and he manages subtle variations without disturbing
the tunes' main structure. The strongest songs on
this tape are the straight-ahead duets, those
mentioned above, as well as "Who Will Sing,"
"Clinch Mountain Home," "Beautiful Life," and
"Sweetest Gift." Unfortunately, on several of
these, the harmony is mixed to be louder than the
melody, so that the overall sound is out of balance.
In general, this tape is plagued by production
problems. First, the list of songs on the insert is
neither complete nor in order, and though the
small print says to see the label for sequence, it's
more trouble than one wants to take to turn off the
changes

in

tape, take

it

out of the player, and read the label to

see the name of the song. The insert and label offer
very little information
they don't say who's
playing what instruments, or who wrote the songs
that were

obviously written, such

as "Bluejacket"
echo has been used for
dramatic effect, but instead of heightening the
drama it suggests that the performance can't speak
for itself. This echo problem is at its worst on "The
Girl I Left Behind," a soulful unaccompanied
version of "Maggie Walker Blues." The echo of one
line comes back to haunt the next, and there is also
some sort of mournful sound effect in the back
ground that probably is supposed to sound like
crickets, but instead sounds like the squeak of a
rubber bath toy. (Molly Tenenbaum)
To order: The Mullins Family, P.O. Box 35,
Drasco, AR 72530

and "Death W ind.

"

A lot of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�most

rhythmic support. "John Henry," "Chilly
Winds," and "Wild Bill Jones" were my favorites.
Greg has really grasped the essentials of the style he
plays and knows how to express himself in it. He

draws his bluesy double-stops out till just the right
moment and with just the right cocky inflection.

His bowing, tone
is dominant and in control.
quality, and use of dynamics are excellent. My least
favorite cut was probably "Fall On My Knees."
Here Greg's own limitations and the limitations of
this style, which sometimes sacrifices rhythmic
subtleties, were most apparent.
Greg models his vocal performance on Fred
Cockerham as well as his fiddling. As a fiddler,
Greg revels in the driving uptown swagger he found
He

Fred's fiddling. But while the connection to Fred
obvious, and the style pure, the music seems
honestly Greg. In his singing, Greg seems to imitate
rather than incorporate. He also has intonation
problems. These things combine to make his
singing less appealing than his fiddling. Riley
Baugus' harmonies are nicely sung, but only faintly
heard.
Considering the style employed by Greg, one
would expect a driving banjo such as that provided
by Kyle Creed (accompanying Fred on his 78s of
in
is

"Pretty Little Gal" and "Breaking Up Christmas")
Andy Cahan (backing up Ernest East). Ray
Chatfield on banjo performs very ably but does not
provide the rhythmic oompff of the afore
mentioned masters, nor does he sound like Fred
Cockerham. The banjo's weaknesses were probably
more noticeable because of the low volume level of
or

and guitar in the mix.
general, the mix could be improved. Although
tend to prefer traditional old-time music played
without the safety net of a bass, I have heard basses
put to good use, especially with the slicker style
employed here, and Barbara Poole is an excellent
bass player. But on this tape, the bass, along with a

the mandolin
In

I

liberal use of slapping, is ust too present. Likewise,
Riley Baugus is an excellent guitar player, but the
sound of his guitar is too absent. The mandolin of
Verlin Clifton, varies from too soft to about right.
When the mandolin is about right, as on "Fire on
the Mountain," the band sound is greatly enhanced.
it
By the way, Verlin chords his mandolin and uses
solely as a rhythm instrument. This fits well with
Greg's playing and is a good addition to the band.
Obviously, the overall sound of this tape can be
improved by adjusting the levels on your stereo or,
j

even better, listening to
deck which drastically

it

on

a

alters

car

stereo

the

or

other

bass/treble

dimension.
The recording levels, perhaps a lack of "jelling
time" for the band, and the unforgiving nature of
the recording studio combine to make this tape not
expected after hearing Greg live. It
quite what
lacks some of the excitement that he is capable of
generating in person. However, it is still a very fine
tape, a wonderful example of the "uptown" trad
itional sound, and, for those who haven't heard
him, an excellent opportunity to listen to a young
fir1r11#r who ic likelv rn hernme an imnortant force
in the old-time scene (Linda Higginbotham)
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�My biggest problem with this collection concerns
to originality. A sticker inside the book
states that no plagiarism is intended. I don't doubt
Daniel Engle's sincerity, and of course with this
number of tunes it is a large task to check them all
for excessive similarity with extant pieces. Noneits claim

theless, in any future editions he should temper his
claims with respect to "It's None of Your Damn
Business" and "Maggy in the Kitchen." The distinctive A parts of these pieces are virtually identical to
traditional fiddle tunes "Texas Quickstep" and J.
Scott Skinner's "Timour the Tartar" respectively.
"The Weary Traveller" sounds like a combination
of chunks of well known Irish reels, though I can't
name them offhand. Listeners familiar with
different dance music traditions might be able to
detect other examples. But my problem is not so
identifiable
the occasional
much "plagiarism"
as a pervasive sense of deja vu. New tunes
phrase

seeking a place in the repertoire surely have to
justify themselves with a certain distinctiveness.
On that criterion, it seems to me, this collection
falls short. (True, there are plenty of cases of crosssimilarity amongst traditional tunes, but that's a bit
different from putting out a book under your own
name and inviting people to spend money on it.)
The intended market for this book is presumably
made up of dance musicians (contra in particular).
Players who typically learn pieces from written
music, and who are looking for new tunes to spice
up their sets, may wish to give Daniel Engle's

repertoire a try. (And people more familiar than
myself with the existing printed collections will be
better able to tell when they are getting the real
and to steer clear of the pastiches.) For
such users of the book, the tape may be a useful
means of screening the tunes; one can easily tell

McCoy,

which might be interesting to follow up without
having to sight-read the whole collection. Note that
this is not, and is not intended to be, a tape that one
plays for listening pleasure; it is strictly an adjunct
to the book. The tunes are played well enough to
get a reasonable idea of each (although I wonder
why he doubled the tune on fiddle and mandolin,
when a single lead would have made the melodies
clearer.) But aside from the fact that each tune is
only played once there are some tuning problems
which render parts of the tape less than euphonious.

(Allin Cottrell)
To order: Daniel Engle,
Lake, CA 94385.

P.

O.

Box

123,

Upper

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Old

World

Violins, lnc.
Fine Violins, Violas and Cellos

handmade
by

in

our

nationally

workshop
known

European and American

makers-

Peter White
Kenneth B. Keppeler
Wladyslaw Stopka
New and used classical

&amp;

instruments
Inexpensive student
models
folk

Complete repair &amp; restora
(same-day service on

tion

bow rehairing available)

(505) 268-3885
305-A San Pedro NE
Albuquerque, NM 87108
Mon-Fri 9-6pm, Sat 10-4pm

0)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

j

�FORTUNES
Joel Mabus
Fossil 187 (lp)
Folk and old-time music.
To order: Fossil Records,
Lansing, Ml

Box 4754,

PO

East

48826-4754

JUST IN TIME
Beayer Creek Band

Butler Records BR 806 (lp)
Traditional bluegrass; seven original songs.
To order: Butler Records, 1086 Meandering Creek,
Uniontown, OH 44685.

DUSTY MILLER
Dusty Miller
June Appal JA0057 (lp)
Solid bluegrass with an up-to-date sound of the
soft-edge variety.
To order: June Appal, 306 Madison St., Whitesburg, KY

41858.

REMEMBERING MAMA
Dorothy Hess

Frontier Productions LP- 1205 (lp)
Mostly old-time familiar songs and one rare one.
With autoharp, guitar, and bass.
To order: Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box 278, Galax,
VA 24333.

BLUEGRASS ON THE

MOUNTAIN

Benny Sims &amp; E.C. Miller

Stereo 0089 (cassette)
Traditional bluegrass with fiddler Benny Sims,
banjoist E.C. Miller, and others.
To order: Benny Sims, 318 Swanee Dr., Johnson
City, TN 37643.

Fish Records,
1304 W.
Chicago, IL 60614 (312) 528-5455
Mastercard accepted).

Flying

WOUNDED HEARTS/MENDED
SOULS
The Foxfire Boys

Schubert,
(Visa &lt;Sc

Foxfire Records (cassette)
Fine singing and playing from this Georgia blue-

Artists and record companies
please
send records and tapes for review to The
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717. Do not send to individual reviewers.
Arhoolie Records, 10341

San Pablo Ave.,
Cerrito, CA 94530
County Records /County Sales, P.O. Box 191,
Floyd, VA 24091 (703) 745-2001 (Visa &amp;

El

Section with Illegible Text

grass band.
To order: Foxfire Records, Rabun Gap, GA 30568.

Mastercard accepted.)

Rounder Records/Roundup,

One

Camp

St.,

MA 02140 (617) 661-6308 (Visa &amp;
1-800-44-DISCS.
Mastercard accepted

Cambridge,

June Appal Recordings/ Appalshop 306 Madison
545-SHOP
St., Whitesburg, KY 41858 (1-800)
outside Ky. (606) 633-0108 in Ky. (Visa &amp;.
Mastercard accepted.)

Heritage Records, Rt. 3, Box 278,
(703) 236-9249 (no credit cards.)
Flyin' Cloud Records, Rt.
NC 27025 (919) 427-3336.
Old Homestead

2,

Galax, VA 24333

Box 436, Madison,

Records, Box 100, Brighton,

MI

48116
Marimac Recordings, PO Box 447, Crown Point,
46307 (219) 769-6217.

IN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Uncle Harold

is

on vacation this

quarter at the Harmonic Convergence
Fiddlers Convention and will return in
the next issue. He hopes you are all
working hard on the answers to the
Trivia Quiz that was published in the last
two issues (the last installment will be

printed

in

the summer

OTH).

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

A VISIT from p. 8

drummer danced her first
and rejoined the circle.
once
again
step
The circle of buck dancers broke up
for a while. The pool game started again,
and Willie Earl and his cousin went back
the masterful

afternoon continued
alternation of gospel singing,
guitar playing, shooting pool, and buck
had hoped Junior Thomas
dancing.
would come by. He could have added his
bottle blowing to the afternoon's activity,
but that would have to wait until another
time. When the time came for me to
leave, the houseparty showed no signs of
to their guitars. The

on with this
I

abating.
that was

I

really didn't want to miss all
come later, but I knew I

to

would return.
And I have returned quite a few times.
Each visit is more comfortable than the
last. That first time I was reluctant to be
more than an observer, but now Willette
won't let me be there without dancing.
The children seem less shy, too, each
time I go back. But Algia Mae is always
the same Algia Mae. Each time I visit, 1
ask how she's doing. Each time her
answer comes back, "Like a peach ain't
never been picked."
Algia Mae's buck dancing can been seen
on the video

produced

by

documentary, "Talking Feet,"
Mike Seeger and Ruth Pershing.

The video is available from Flower Films,
10341 San Pablo Ave., El Cerrito CA
94530, or from Ruth Pershing, PO Box 252,

Saxapahaw NC 27340.
Algia Mae's music can be heard on
Eight-Hand Sets and Holy Steps, reviewed
in the winter '8g-'go OTH.
Ruth Pershing has been researching and
teaching southern flatfooting and buck
dancing for the past 10 years. She is currently
working toward her middle school teaching
certification in math and science, while
working at the Southern Folklife Collection
and WUNC Public Radio in Chapel Hill,

N.C.

�17th Annual

Brandywine
mountain
music

I

July 13, 14, 15

Galax Old Time Bands:

The Next Generation

Featuring

The Scotty East-Mac Snow Old Time Band
Kirk Sutphin, Kinney Rorrer and Bob Carlin
Greg Hooven and Backstep
Jody Stecher and Kate Brislin
Mike Seeger
Ralph Blizzard and the New Southern Ramblers
John Cohen
Mac Benford &amp; the Woodshed Allstars
featuring Pete Sutherland
Double Decker
The Legendary Dixie Hummingbirds
Three days of concerts, workshops &amp; dance. Friday dance featuring the Rural
Rhythm String Band with caller Pete LaBerge. Clogging/Flatfoot demonstration &amp;
instruction with the New Southern Ramblers plus a square dance on Saturday
afternoon 4:30 6:00 PM. Free camping in the rough; Music concessions; crafts;
food; acres of the finest old time musicians in the world!
Presented by the Brandywine Friends of Old Time Music, a non-profit organization
dedicated to preserving and presenting traditional American folk music. For more
information call (302) 475-3454 or write Box 3672, Greenville, DE 19807.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

convention

Pleasant View Stables
on Kirk Road

I
I

Fair Hill, Maryland

1

Tickets
Friday Dance 7:30-11:30

$6.00

Saturday Noon Midnight
Sunday 10:00 AM 5:00 PM
Weekend ticket
Camping &amp; parking free

29.00

13.00
12.00

Senior Citizens $3.00 per day discount
Children under 12 free
No advance ticket sales; 24 hour security
No pets or drugs; No alcohol in the stage area;
Motels available in nearby Newark, DE &amp;
Elkton, MD
Information: (302) 475-3454

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

XO

,L3

V.2

#4

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12190">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 2, Number 4 (Summer 1990)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12191">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12192">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 2, Number 4 (May-July 1990)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Banjos in the Days of Compact DIscs,” by Mike Fitch&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Bobby McMillon: Blue Ridge Story Teller,” by Hilary Dirlam&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Fiddlin’ Arthur Smith, A Son Remembers,” by James Kennison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Gribble, Lusk, and York: Recording a Black Tennessee Stringband,” by Robert S. Jamieson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – A Visit,” by Ruth Pershing&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – ‘Rolling River’,” tablature by Carl Jones&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Bowing Workshop,” by Brad Leftwich&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Buying a Used Guitar,” by Bob Smakula&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12193">
              <text>1990</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="2159">
      <name>1990</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="999">
      <name>1990s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2299">
      <name>Arthur Smith</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5572">
      <name>Bob Smakula</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5568">
      <name>Bobby McMillon</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5464">
      <name>Brad Leftwich</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5559">
      <name>Carl Jones</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5476">
      <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5569">
      <name>James Kennison</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5567">
      <name>Mike Fitch</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5570">
      <name>Robert S. Jamieson</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5571">
      <name>Ruth Pershing</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5490">
      <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
