<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2528" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2528?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:52:59+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3455">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/0193a7cd75fdae9a65b7d8fe1a7bd978.pdf</src>
      <authentication>a03880fe56958d0a8181f19ff4fe7198</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12217">
                  <text>November 1991

Winter $4.50

January 1992

THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD

A MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Ramona
Jones

IN THIS ISSUE:
Photo
Galax
Essay
Banjo Tablature Tommy Jarrell,
Contradancing
Mike Seeger's Favorite Old-Time Fiddle Music
Part II
Gerry Milnes
and more!

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Everybody naturally wants
to hear the best music
4000
4001

4002

CANDY FROM STRANGERS
The Dixie Darlin's
SONGS OF THE JERSEY PINES AND SHORE
Merce Ridgway and the Pinehawkers
WHERE THE CRICKETS FIDDLE

4004
4005
6000
6020
8000
8001

8002
8003
8004
8005

9016

8.00

9017

8.00

9018

Albertson

Jim

4003

8.00

MOVING DAY

8.00

The Barbara Beeman Band
HOTEL PLACENTA
Ken Haferman and Rob Hunter
SONGS OF MERCE RIDGWAY, SR. (with booklet)
Merce Ridgway and The Pinehawkers

BALALAIKA RUSSE IN CONCERT
Balalaika Russe
CAJUN DANCE TONIGHT
The Bone Tones
THROW YOUR TIME AWAY

The Otis Brothers
LET IT ROLL!
John Cephas and Phil Wiggins
IN THE LAND OF CORN AND WINE
The Otis Brothers
RIGHTEOUS BLUES
Bill Ellis
WALKING BLUES
John Cephas and Phil Wiggins
CRYIN' WON'T MAKE ME STAY
Bob Guida
FORKED DEER
Dan Gellert and Shoofly
SONGS THAT SCARE ME

9019
8.00

9020
8.00
8.00

9021

8.00

9022

8.00

9023

8.00

9024

MIND BANDS
Andy Cahan

DOWN HOME RAG

9025

8.00

9026

8.00

9027

8.00

8.00

Vesta Johnson

GOING ACROSS THE RIVER TO HEAR
MY BANJO RING
Carlie Marion with Andy Cahan
COME ALL YOU WADDIES
Bob Bovee
TIMELY OLD TUNES FROM ILL-MO
AND BEYOND
EVOLUTION

8.00

of their first tape

TROXSONG

8.00

9100

9004
9005

9006
9007
9008
9009

9010
9011
9012
9013

9014

8.00

Uncle Willie and the Brandysnifters
WHEN THE YANKEES CAME DOWN
Major Contay and the Canebrake Rattlers
BEHIND THE TIMES
Bob Bovee and Gail Heil

8,00
8.00

STILL LAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS
The Lazy Aces String Band
OLD TIME FRIENDS (with booklet)

8.00

Produced by Ray Alden

IN THE HILLS OF HOME (with booklet)
Raymond Smith and Bob Cowan
TRADITIONAL FIDDLE MUSIC OF MISSOURI

Charlie Walden with Emily and Dennis Buckhannon
FLUKE HITS
The Fish Family Dance Band
FARMER'S FROLIC
The Ross County Farmers
A

SOUTHERN CATALOG

Joe LaRose
9015

8.00

THE WILDCATS
The Wildcats

ALL PRICES

WANinnwr;

9106

8.00

9109
9110

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

IN

46307

9111

8.00

9200

8.00

9600

8.00

9601

(219) 662-7305

MAKE ME

8.00
8.00

A

COWBOY AGAIN FOR

A

8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00
1.50

DAY

Cowboy song anthology
CHEVROLET SIX
Oscar Ford with McMichen, Stokes, Puckett
JOHNNYS GONE TO WAR
War song anthology
IT'LL NEVER HAPPEN

AGAIN

Old Time String Bands, Vol.

ARE POST PAID WITHIN THE U.S.A. NON U.S.A. ORDERS:
INDIANA RFSinFNTS MUST ADD 5% STATE SALES TAX.

P.O. BOX 447, CROWN POINT,

8.00

8.00

A JOYFUL NOISE, VOL. 1
Golden Age gospel anthology
A JOYFUL NOISE, VOL.2
9101
Golden Age gospel anthology
THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL.1
9104
Moonshine and temperance anthology
THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL. 2
9105
Moonshine and temperance anthology
9104-05 THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE (Booklet)
Annotations by W.K. McNeil

9108

8.00

8.00

Glen Smith

8.00

8.00

8.00

AUGUSTA HERITAGE SERIES

TUESDAY NIGHT LIVE
Old Time Music in Philadelphia
GOLN' DOWN THE COUNTRY
Steve Garcia and Matt Levine
GOING NOWHERE FAST (with booklet)

8.00

The Troxell Brothers
FEEL BAD SOMETIME
Tracy Schwarz, Peter Schwarz, Lee Blackwell
SALT &amp; GREASE
The Boiled Buzzards

9003

Pat Conte

8.00

(formerly C-03)

8.00

8.00

8.00

THE VOLO BOGTROTTERS

LOVE THEM DUCKS
Half Shaved

9001

8.00

GIRL

9002

9000

8.00

The Double Decker Stringband
BACKSIDE OF BUNCOMBE
The Volo Bogtrotters
TAKE ME AS I AM
Bruce Molsky and Bob Carlin

AHS#1 BOATIN' UP SANDY
Wilson Douglas
AHS#2 HANNAH AT THE SPRINGHOUSE
Melvin Wine
AHS#3 SAY OLD MAN

8.00

8.00

The Hl-Mo Boys

Re-issue
8.00

8.00

8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00

1

GOIN' UP TOWN

Old Time String Bands, Vol. 2
UP AGIN THE MOUNTAIN (with booklet)
Everett Pitt, ballad singer
FEAST HERE TONIGHT!
Rabbit In a Log (Skip Gorman and Rich Starkey)
THE RISKY BUSINESS BLUECRASS BAND
Risky Business Bluegrass Band

8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00

PLEASE ADD $1.50 PER CASSETTE FOR POSTAGE AND

Marimac Recordings

�THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
VOLUME

3,

NUMBER

2

FEATURES
LIVING

TRADITION

IN

12

An Interview with Gerry Milnes.
KEEPING

By

Dave Shombert

RAMONA JONES

UP WITH

16

Rachel Anne Goodman

By

SELECTED

LISTENING

I

Old-Time Fiddle Music.

21

By

Mike Seeger

"A

WONDERFUL

By

Alice Gerrard with Mark Sanderford
JARRELL'S

TOMMY

Part

TO BE

TIME

II.

By

FAMILY

IN

GALAX.

STORIES

..."

I

25

1830-1925

36

Nancy Dols Neithammer

COLUMNS
HERE

THERE

&amp;

LEGENDS-NO.

Darby
THE

&amp;

4

I

3

Tarlton.

DANCE

6

I

By

BEAT

Charles Wolfe
8

Contradancing: Preservation and Evolution.
AND

I

MEAN

BUSINESS.

ASK

HAROLD

UNCLE

ISSUES

OLD-TIME

IN

By Jeri
I

Goldstein

31

MUSIC

Voices from the Villages.

DesRosier

11

I

Promotion, Promotion.

By Mary

I

32

By Paul

Tyler

WORKSHOP
By Bob Smakula (page 35)
Tablature.
Bob
Carlin
Banjo
By
(page 43) and Paul Brown (page 44)
Fiddle Transcription. By Nancy Dols Neithammer (page 46)
A

Page 16.

Courtesy Patsy Weiler

Gathering of Luthiers.

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS

2

/

CLASSIFIED

Photo right: Highwoods Stringband at the Finger
Lakes Festival July 1991 page 20 Courtesy Mac
Benford.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

REVIEWS

42

/

49

�THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
The Old-Time Music Group,
1812 House Avenue

Inc.

Durham, NC 27707
EDITOR
Alice Gerrard
ASSOCIATE

EDITOR

Bill Hicks

CONTRIBUTING

EDITORS

Hilary Dirlam, Jeri Goldstein, Phil Jamison, Art

Menius,Bob Smakula
ADVISORY
BOARD
Ray Alden, Mac Benford, Hazel Dickens,

Bobby Fulcher, John Hartford,
Linda Higginbotham, Ramona Jones, Garrison
Keillor, Pete Kuykendall,
Brad Leftwich, W.

McNeil,

K.

Pete Sutherland, Charles Wolfe

ADVERTISING
Jack Bernhardt

STAFF
Gail Gillespie
OLD-TIME

MUSIC

BOARD

INC.

GROUP,
DIRECTORS

OF

Bob Cantwell, Alice Gerrard,

Jack Bernhardt,

Tom Hargrove,

Art Menius,

Jim

Watson,

Kathy World

No part of this magazine may be reproduced in
any form without written permission from the

publisher. Not responsible for loss or non-return
unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
The Old-

of

Time Herald.

The Old-Time

Herald

(ISSN

1040358) (USPS

published quarterly the first of Au
November,
gust,
February, and May by the OldTime Music Group, Inc., 1812 House Ave.,
002672)

is

Durham, NC 27707. Subscription rates payable
advance. One year $15 (foreign subscrip

in

tions

$18 U.S.). Classified ads cost 35 cents per

word, minimum of $5. Any grouping of letters or
numbers is counted as one word. All classified
ads must be received by the first of the month,
one month prior to publication. Second Class

postage paid

at

Durham, NC 27701.

Postmaster: Send change

of

address

to the Old-

Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717.

The Old-Time Music Group,

Inc., is

a

not-for-

profit, tax-exempt corporation under section 501
(c) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�included Jimmy Thompson, Bunt Stephens,
Andy Palmer, and Blind Joe Mangrum.
Kerry Blech

Seattle, WA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here &amp; There

by Art

Menius

Congratulations

Bluegrass Unlimited celebrated 25 years
of continuous publication with its July 1991
issue. Our own Alice Gerrard was an im
portant figure in the magazine's early years.
Veteran musician Patrick Sky has as

sumed

ownership and management

of

Chapel Hill, NC's Oxbow Music.
Staten Island, NY's Mandolin Brothers
are

celebrating their 20th anniversary dur

ing 1991
Ted Ehrhardt captured first place at the

PineCone's

Raleigh Fiddlers Convention
31. Ehrhardt, who has taken to

on

August
playing the accordion, may be relocating to
Washington.
The Autoharpoholic is celebrating 11
years of publication under the helm of
founder and editor Becky Blackley. INFO:
PO Box 504, Brisbane CA 94005.

Events
Tuesday at the Gandy Dancer Saloon at
1300 McHenry Street in Baltimore.
The Barn Folk Concerts (714-682-3621)
University of California-Riverside
will present the Blue Flame String Band
the

with Jody Stecher, Kate Brislin, Eric and
Suzy Thompson on 17 November.
Wickenburg, AZ Four Corners States

Bluegrass Festival and Fiddle Champion
ships are set for 8-10 November. INFO:
602-684-5204.
Contra and square dances are held regu
larly on Mondays at 8:00 in the Unitarian
Church, Charlotte, NC (234 N. Sharon
Amity). INFO: 704-372-5252.

Artists

Acoustic bluesman James "Son" Tho
mas, 64, underwent surgery to remove a
brain tumor on July 30. A fund for Thomas
has been established at the Center for the
Study of Southern Culture (University of
Mississippi, University, MS 38677)
with his $50,000 in medical bills.

this

year

Emmy nomina
composing "Ashokan

for

the theme

Farewell,"

song

for Ken Burns'

PBS

documentary,

successful

fabulously
The Civil

an

War.

Ungar and Molly Mason

also appeared on the PBS special, Songs of
the Civil War, which aired on August 17.
of

struggles
turing

a
musical about the
southern tenant farmers fea

Sweet Day,

Some

18

Si

songs by

Kahn, ran through

out May at Nashville's Tennessee
ing Arts Center.

Perform

Beth Weil, long-time Bay Area bassist
best known for her work with the Good Ole
Persons and Laurie Lewis &amp; Grant Street,

suffered

a

severe stroke

in

late June.

Al

to

help

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tivals during the summer and a square
dance callers competition each May.
Chicago's famed Old Town School of
Folk Music (909 W. Armitage; Chicago, IL
60614) offers an amazing array of classes,

ber

more

desiring

Karyn Cap

After

El

at

Kaleidoscope Records;
Cerrito, CA 94530. Those

information can contact

Kaleidoscope (415-234-4100).

brief hospital stay in September,
Grandpa Jones is doing well and is back
a

on the Opry. He would enjoy hearing from
his many fans. Write: Grandpa Jones, PO

Goodlettsville, TN 37072.
The Fiddle Puppets are recruiting male
dancers. Contact Eileen Carson at 301-268Box 853,

6840.
Barb Kuhns,

a

fiddler

from

Medway,

OH, played fiddle with a jug band, Aunt
Beanie's First Prize Beats, for an upcoming
Julia Reichert movie.

John McCutcheon's

new CD/cassette

Live at Wolf Trap has just been
the Rounder label.

released on

Thurs

VP, Barbara

Terry
The

month

P.O. Box 'O',

on

3.

good. An Elizabeth Weil Trust
Fund has been established. Contributions
is

banjo

Fletcher Bright has been installed as presi
dent of the Chattanooga Area Friends of
Folk Music, along with Bob Chuckrow,

grass

prognosis

clawhammer

including

days and Old-Time Ensemble on Wednes
days. Ralph Blizzard and John Lilly will
perform at the school on Sunday, Novem

though ini tially paralyzed on her right side,
she has recuperated to a degree, and the

can be sent in care of

The Baltimore Hoedown, featuring oldtime music and dance, takes place each

at

received

Jay Ungar

tion

meets

Middlebrooks, Secretary, and
Middlebrooks, Treasurer.
brand new South Carolina Blue&amp; Traditional
Music Association
on the second Thursday of each
Bill's Music Shop and Picking

at

Parlor (710 Meeting St., W. Columbia, SC

29169).
The New Mexico Folk Music &amp; Dance
Society sponsors contradances on the first
Saturday and second and fourth Fridays of
each month. For more information call their
new hotline number 505-266-2881

The Folk

Project sponsors

regular

concerts, and other traditional
music activities in northern New Jersey.
Call Larry Kaufman at 201-460-1280 for
details.
dances,

The

UW-Milwaukee Folk Center

Milwaukee,

in

WI

sponsors many workshops,
and classes. They send
out a newsletter of events. For information
write: UW-Milwaukee Folk Center,
music weekends,

Fine Arts-Music 130, PO Box 413, Mil

waukee,

Wl 53201.

Organizations

The Freight &amp; Salvage Coffee House in
Berkeley, CA has sent out a fund raising

The Del-Se-Nango Olde Tyme Fiddlers
Berlin, NY 13411), a non
profit organization formed to preserve,

appeal. The Freight,

a

forming venue

Bay Area, has

(RD #3, New

promote, and perpetuate old-time fiddling,
celebrated its 13th anniversary this Au
gust. The group sponsors two fiddlers fes

in the

long-standing per

consis

wide variety of music in
cluding old-time. The Freight is a non
profit, tax-exempt organization. Checks
tently hosted

made payable

a

to

the Freight and

Salvage

�can be sent to 1111 Addison St., Berkeley,
CA 94702. (The non-profit organization

name

is

The Berkeley Society for the

Preser

vation of Traditional Music.)
Section with Illegible Text

Northwest Folklife (305 Harrison

St.;

Seattle, WA 98109) has issued the 1991-92
Folklife Store Catalog, which includes oldtime, blues, and bluegrass recordings.
In addition to Bill Clifton's new CD,
Where the Rainbow Finds Its End, his Elf
Records has released Blue Ridge Mountain

compilation of Clifton's 1957Mercury, Starday, and Kapp recordings
featuring such artists as John Duffey, Ralph
Stanley, and Gordon T erry, and a reissue of
1961's Carter Family Album with Mike
Bluegrass,

a

58

Seeger,

Tommy Jackson, and Buddy

Spicher.

music on public radio station WMRA-FM

90.7

Madison

(James

University;

VA 22807). The program,

Harrisonburg,
which occasionally presents live old-time
music and often features artist interviews,
airs week nights from 9:00 p.m. until mid
night.

The Southern Arts Federation (1293
Peachtree St. NE, Suite 500; Atlanta, GA
30309) has published Musical Roots of the
South, a 24-page booklet available for $4.50.
From the U ni versity of Arizona Press comes
Allen Batteau's The Invention of Appal achia, described as carrying the thesis, de

veloped

in

Henry Shapiro's Appalachia

outsiders invented defi
nitions of mountain culture to fit their own
needs from 1920, when Shapiro stopped,
On Our Mind, that

to

up

the present. The Appalachian Center

Berea College (C.P.O. Box 2336, Berea,
KY 40404) has reprinted Coon Creek Girl,

at

Mac Benford and the

Woodshed All-

Stars should have their debut recording
completed soon.
Ramona Jones' first video, Country
Christmas Memories, is finished just in time
for the holidays. Included, is a Christmas

Lily May Ledford's 1980 autobiography.
Old-time, Celtic, bluegrass, and singer/
songwriter music co-exist on The Folk
Show, heard from 7:00 until 11:00 a.m.

the late
party with family and friends
Red Rector, Mac Wiseman, John Hartford,
and Earl Scruggs, among others. The tape
was produced and directed by North Caro
lina-based Ron Ruehl. Many will remem

Sheridan Rd., Evanston, IL 60208-2260).
Phoebe Potts presents Phoebe's Front
Porch: Bluegrass, Old Timey, and Appala
chian Tunes every Friday from 9:00 a.m.
until noon on WOZQ-FM 91.9 from Smith

TNN series
Mountain." (For info, or to

ber Ruehl as the creator of the
"Fire On the

order:PO Box 199, Ridgetop, TN 37152.)
The Missouri State Old Time Fiddlers

Association

(P.O. Box

7423,

Columbia,

MO 65205) has reissued on tape two re
cordings by significant Missouri fiddlers:
Kelly Jones' Authentic Old-Time Fiddle
Tunes and Rugged Road by Lyman Enloe.

co-operation with Marimac Record
ings, the Augusta Heritage Center (Davis
&amp; Elkins College; Elkins, WV 26241) has
issued its first two multi-volume antholo
gies of traditional music from West Vir
ginia. Produced by Gerry Milnes, the sets
In

distill the fruits of 15 years of field work.
Old-Time Banjo Anthology consists of two

cassettes,

while Folksongs and Ballads

every Sunday on WNUR-FM 89.3 (1905

College in Northampton, MA.
Complete information on the lively oldtime music scene in northeastern Ohio is
available in To Be Announced, a monthly
newsletter. For subscription informaton
write To Be Announced, PO Box
OH 44240.

New

The Wisconsin Folk Museum (100

S.

2nd

Mount Horeb, WI 53572) has issued a
reunion recording, Midwest Ramblin', by
1950s polka artists the Goose Island Ram

blers.

Radio,

Print,

&amp;

Television

Rachel Goodman, Jay Zehr, and Ben
Vorhies serve as hosts for Down Home, a

nightly program of old-time and bluegrass

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

856, Kent,

Beginnings

Redd Stewart, a member of Pee Wee
King's band during the 1940s and com
poser of such songs as "Tennessee Waltz"
and "Bonaparte's Retreat," and his wife
Darlene have established a $500 per se
mester scholarship for students

in the

blue-

grass, country, or sound technology pro
grams at South Plains College in Levelland,
TX.

Final

spans three tapes.
St.,

1

Notes

Lester, fiddler, barber, music teacher,
and luthier, died in Muscle Shoals, AL on
May 14 following a lengthy illness. Lester
A1

belonged for a number of years to the Dixie
Gentlemen and, more recently, the War
rior River Boys, in addition to touring with
Bill Monroe and Mac Wiseman. His ses
sion credits included such popular artists
as

Boz Scaggs,

Nelson.

Liza

Minelli, and Willie

�Legends--

Darby
by Charles

&amp;

No.

3

Tarlton

Wolfe

of the influence of blues in early
and
about
music,
country
everyone from Jimmie Rodgers
to Fiddlin' Arthur Smith has featured blues in their repertoire. But
when you look at performing style, few old-time performers
actually sound anything like the black country blues artists of the

Much

has been made

1920s. A notable exception is the team of Tom Darby and Jimmie
Tarlton, who recorded over sixty sides for three major labels in the
period from 1927 to 1933. They were best known for their twosided Columbia hit record of "Birmingham Jail" and "Columbus
Stockade Blues," one of the best-selling old-time records of the
1920s. Their style was built on Tom Darby's incredible lead singing
it was one of

and Jimmie Tarlton's superb slide guitar work, and

loosest, most soulful, most unpredictable sounds in classic
country music. Their repertoire was quirky, eclectic, and vast, and
in some ways summed up the best aspects of the old-time music
songbook.
Jimmie Tarlton, who seems to have been the dominant member
the

of the duo, was born in Orange County, South Carolina in 1892.
The son of sharecropper parents, he learned to play the fretless

banjo from his father, and to sing old ballads from his mother. By
the time he was twelve, he was playing the guitar in the open
tuning and slide style he had learned from black musicians in

Nobley

North and South Carolina and Georgia, where his family had
traveled seeking work. When he was seventeen he left home,
determined to try to make a living as a musician. He worked for a
time in textile mills in the Piedmont area of North Carolina, then
took off "busking," traveling around the country playing on street
at fairs, in bars, wherever he could find an audience. He
traveled widely from Oklahoma to California to New York, pick
ing up songs and musical styles on the way. During World War I,
he played his guitar in bars in New York and Hoboken, New Jersey.
In about 1922, when he was on the West Coast, he met the famed
Hawaiian guitarist Frank Ferrara. This was during the high point
in popularity of Hawaiian music, and Ferrara taught Jimmie how
to use a better slide, a piece of highly polished steel that allowed

courtesy

Robert

E.

corners,

Tom Darby (standing); and Jimmie Tarlton, ca. 1928

note with more dexterity. He also taught him a lot about
adapting old pop songs to the steel guitar's sound. By the mid19205, when he had returned to the South to settle around the

completely from musicians

Columbus, Georgia region, Jimmie had been exposed to a wider
range of musical styles than most of his fellow old-time musicians.

complex sense of rhythm. Darby's parents had
come from the mountains in north Georgia, and he was second
cousin to Skillet Lickers star, Riley Puckett. His grandfather and
some of his uncles were apparently full-blooded Cherokees, and
he recalled hearing his uncles play fiddle music at family gather

him

to

his own unique style.
with
another
up
guitarist from Columbus,
Tom Darby. Though Darby was about eight years older than
Tarlton; he had traveled very little and performed in public even
less; his guitar playing and singing style were adapted almost

He quickly set about
In 1927 he teamed

synthesizing them into

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

he had heard in and around Colum
a
Tarlton's
featured
bus.
singing
very strong blues component,
with
a
a harrowing falsetto,
tendency to improvise around
replete
the

melody, and

a

ings. A local talent scout persuaded Darby to team up with Tarlton,
got them an audition with Columbia records. Their first

and

�Columbia release,

a send-up on Florida land
speculators called
"Down On Florida On a Hog," coupled with "Birmingham Town,"
was cut on April 5, 1927, and sold well enough that Columbia's A
&amp; R man, Frank Walker, invited them back to the Atlanta sessions

had tried various comebacks before, even appearing for a time in
a medicine
show with Hank and Audrey Williams. This time

that fall.

Darby and Tarlton sides on the Old Timey label. But it was late;
Jimmie died in 1979, Darby in 1971, both after barely tasting the
fruits of their new careers.

Thus

it

was that on November 10, 1927, the pair once again

recorded, this time doing "Birmingham Jail" and "Columbus Stock
ade Blues." Both songs had traditional roots, but both had been

substantially
today

it is

reworked by the singers

to the

point where even

not clear how much they had created and how much they
In later years Tarlton liked to tell that he wrote

had borrowed.

"Birmingham Jail" in 1925 when he had been given an 85-day
sentence in the Birmingham jail for moonshining. He was allowed
to keep his guitar, he said, and as he sat in his cell
thinking of his girl
friend Bessie, he created the song. The guards and warden were so
impressed that they got a pardon for Jimmie, and in 1937, when the
city dedicated a new jail, Tarlton was asked to return for the
ceremonies. All of which showed, if nothing else, just how popular
this first record had become. It sold almost 200,000 copies for
Columbia, making it one of the very highest selling entries in their
Old Familiar Tunes catalogue. Both singers would have been rich
had they taken royalties on the song, but Darby talked Tarlton into
a
taking a flat fee for their work
lump sum of $75 each.

Though "Columbus" became a country standard and was
repopularized by Jimmie Davis in the 1940s, and by Willie Nelson
and Danny Davis in the 1960s, in the 1920s Columbia thought
"Birmingham Jail" was the bigger hit. They encouraged Tarlton to
come up with two sequels, "Birmingham Jail No. 2" (in 1928) and
"New Birmingham Jail" (in 1930). The former, backed by "Lone
some Railroad," became the team's second-best-selling record.
Their other Columbia hits included two down-and-dirty country
blues pieces, "Travelling Yodel Blues" and "Heavy Hearted Blues,"
a bizarre,
uptempo version of the Victorian chestnut "After the
Ball," an old Civil War song, "Rainbow Division," an uptempo

guitar instrumental

called "Birmingham Rag," and an intense,
almost rhythm-and-blues-like "Sweet Sarah." These lesser hits
sold between 15,000 and 40,000 copies each. Other records, which
did not sell as well but which became favorites with later fans,
included "My Little Blue Heaven" (derived from the Gene Austin
"Captain Won't Let Me Go Home," "Lowe Bonnie," "Ft.
Benning Blues," and "The Weaver's Blues." By late 1929, the team
was having contract disagreements with Columbia, and in April
hit),

1930 did their last session for the firm.

In the

next few years, each

man did separate sessions (Tarlton for Columbia, Darby for Vic
tor), and got back together for two unsuccessful sessions in 1932
and 1933. But the magic was gone and the glory days were over.
The team had traveled with some of the
the music

best-known figures

in

from the Skillet Lickers to the Delmore Brothers to the

Dixon Brothers
but the new slick harmony sounds of the mid19305 made the free-wheeling Darby and Tarlton sound obsolete.
By 1935 both men were retired. By 1935 both men were retired.
Then, in the 1960s they were "discovered" by young enthusiasts
of the folk revival movement. Tarlton was discovered in Phenix
City, Alabama, and made a brief comeback that included stints at
folk clubs around the country, and a new solo LP on the Testament
label. (It remains an astounding album even today, showing that
Tarlton had lost little of his skill and creativity.) A year earlier Tom
Darby had also been "discovered," but only a few concerts were

scheduled featuring the reunited team.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

It

was learned that Tarlton

appeared to presage better things, though, and soon he was ap
pearing at the Newport Folk Festival, and seeing a reissue of the old

Though many sing songs from the Darby and Tarlton repertoire
today, there are few young performers who actually try to sound
like them, as opposed to the dozens of young acts who sound like
the Delmores or Blue Sky Boys. Perhaps they were too original, too
difficult to copy, too complex to fit into neat little tabs. They have
been woefully neglected by the reissue industry, and very little of
their work is readily available. But their music remains potent and
soulful, full of the raw vitality that so many unsung greats brought
to our

culture.

Dr. Charles

Wolfe teaches

Middle

at

Tennessee

State University

in

cultural historian specializing in music
and folklore. He has been nominated three times for Grammy Awards for
his productions of traditional music albums.
Murfreesboro, TN, where

[Thanks
Emory

to

Ward

he is

a

Robert Nobley for some of his additions and comments.
first visited Tom Darby at his home in

and Nobley

in 1962. They met Tarlton the
following July.
Note: A 2-CD set of "white blues" reissues including everyone from
Frank Hutchison to Darby and Tarlton will be forthcoming on the

Columbus, GA

Columbia Legacy Series

ed.J

�The Dance Beat

Contradancing
Preservation

by

Evolution

and

Mary DesRosiers

Towers. Not really, though, for
matter where you dance today, your
dancing has its roots in the same soil.
Just when the term "contradance" came
the Trump

no

into common usage is
It

certainly

is

somewhat

of

a

mystery.
from

French:"stemming

"contre," across from, and "danse." The
French and English, when enjoying a respite
from declaring war on each other, most cer
tainly swapped dances, and, as noted

in

Twenty Four Early American Country Dances,
Cotillions and Reels, by James E. Morrison, by
the late

1

7th

century the French were calling

their version of the English country dances

"contredanses." These may have included
circles as well as line dances for awhile, but
by the time of the American Revolution, line
dances were all the rage, as were the French

Wood engraving

by

Randy Miller

from A Time To
Press, 1977

Dance

by

Richard Nevell, St. Martin's

dancing masters who taught them. Today
the terms "contra" and country dance can be
synonymous in some parts of the country, a
nomenclature further muddled by the New
Hampshire variant "contry dance" which
started dancing in the

was still in use when

I

early 1970s.
or

contradancing
Writing,
conference with

talking,
is

a

bit like

about
holding

a

the eight blind men
seen the elephant: there are as many

press

who've
definitions

of what

contradancing is all
about as there are people who do it. And, as
the numbers of dancers around the coun
try increase, so do the hypotheses about
where this stuff comes from and why we

do

it.

"Write about dancing?" scoffed a friend
when told her about this article.

of mine

I

waste. People should spend their
time dancing, not talking about it." She is,
"What

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

like me, one of an increasingly endangered

species around these parts: a New Hamp
shire native. She's been dancing since her
parents brought her to a Saturday town hall
a toddler, and now she runs one of
those dances. As far as she's concerned,
there have always been dances in that town
hall, and probably always will be. Folks

dance as

come, music

is

played, dances are danced,

kids fall asleep under the piano, the stars
come out
the whole scene is a comforting

constant

in her

life. She

is as far

removed

from the world of dawn dances and dance

camps as Nelson, New Hampshire

is

from

It's interesting to note that the French
dancing masters also introduced cotillions,
but these were more popular in the big
houses of Virginia and the southern colonies
than in New England. Why, we can only
speculate; but these for-couple dances gave
us the square dance tradition so well pre
served in the southern Appalachians. The
extreme isolation of southern communites

was perfect for the intact preservation of
some of these dances as well as many of
John Playford's circles, lovingly and ener

getically transformed into Kentucky running
sets and Big Circles.- In Grady McWhiney's

�Cracker Culture

[Tuscaloosa, Alabama 1988]

was noted that a traveler in the Georgia
territory recalled the dance prompter an
nouncing: "Gentlemen, lead your partners.
Them that's got on shoes and no stockings
will dance the Virginny reel; them that's
it

the most isolated areas all this was

incorpo

kets were the way folks got their minimum

rated into the dance canon. The traditional

requirement of dancing. In those days, the
kitchen was the biggest room in the house,
so, with the fiddler perched in the sink or
atop the kitchen table, people would

English, Scottish, and Irish reels and jigs
were changing, and in some cases disap
pearing altogether. Newt Tolman, a music
collector and writer from my neck of the
woods, complained
tween 1900 and 1930, the old dance music
fell so out of favor as to be unheard in New
Hampshire, once the center of traditonal
music activity. "During that whole time,"

cities. Perhaps especially in the cities, where
rooms for dancing are prohibitively priced
nowadays, and the dance community tends
to be small. The living room is the biggest
place to dance these days, or the deck, or
even the garage. The lively Quebequois

he writes in Quick Tunes and Good Times,

hold

country dance. It was a time of
intense change in America, however, and
the masters increasingly lost ground to the
upstart callers. In 1883, the masters orga
nized: calling themselves the American
National Associations of Masters of Danc
a

ing. They were too late, though. By the turn
of the century, waltzes and two-steps had
on in the cities, and in the

caught
country,
folks staunchly defended their right to call
their own dances.
As the young nation spread westward,
dancing. The new frontier devel

so did its

oped

dance

a

all

style

its

own:

an

amalgamation
quadrilles and cotil
lions brought by miners and farmers from
the South (dances which, by this time, had
of the

been influenced by African music) and
contra and ballroom dances from the in

dustrialized

North.

Combined with

a

healthy dose of improvisation on the part
of the
the

fiddler/ caller, and

the high spirits of
in the new

hardy folks who settled

western

territories, cowboy
dancing
became a whole new dance form.
or

It

for

was

at

this point that the music played

country dancing went through some

radical evolution. The emigraton of Afri

can-Americans

from their rural homes

in

the South to the factories and the mills of

introduced many city dwellers
tonalities and syncopations of the

the North
to the

blues, and later, jazz. "Popular" music was
becoming more and more accessible, and
the craze for penny song sheets introduced
whole new populations of Americans to
patriotic songs and swing music. Except

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

often through the night and into

the morning. I've been to many such house
dances over the years, and I'm happy to say
the custom is alive and well, even in the

calling, or prompting, emerged. We can
only imagine the chagrin of the dancing
masters who, up to this time, had made
their students totally dependent upon their
teachings, through dancing schools and
memorization. The radical concept of the
"laity" being able to minister to the danc
ers must have been shocking indeed. Why,
any rube who could scratch out a tune on
the fiddle, and bellow out the figures could

dance

somewhere be

shoes nor stockings will dance
down."
The days of the dancing masters were
numbered, however. Sometime around the
end of the Civil War, the popular custom of
got on nairy
the scamper

that

"I

almost never got to play any of the fine old
melodies had learned in my younger days.
Nor was anyone else playing them. We
could never find any musicians who knew
them or callers who would use them.
Square-dance music, to New England dance
enthusiasts, and to the world at large,
seemed to be irrevocably represented by
tunes like 'Darling Nellie Gray,' 'Redwing,'
I

and Polish polkas."
Tolman and his kin were responsible for
holding the line against hit parade tunes.

Together with Kay Gilbert, he published
The Nelson Music Collection, which can still
be seen at many sessions around the coun
try, and he inspired many young musicians
to become acquainted with the old reels,
jigs, hornpipes, and slow airs to which our
dances were originally done.
Several revivals of contradancing oc
curred

in the early part of the 20th century.
Ford
Henry
imported Benjamin Lovett from
Boston to teach dancing and deportment to

bewildered citizens of Dearborn, Michi
gan and started a revival for the old-time
the

music and its practitioners. (See OTH FebApr. 1991). At about the same time, caller
Ralph Page was contributing a regular

monthly column on dances and dance gos
sip to Yankee magazine, published in Dublin,
New Hampshire. Page's ruminations in the
pages of Yankee were expanded into a book,

The Country Dance Book, full of earthy hu
mor, real and mythical dance history, and

instructions and music to many oldtime dances. Doing research in the old
Yankees of the 1930s and 1940s showed me
that on weekends there were some dozen
town hall dances in New Hampshire, and
as many in Vermont and Massachusetts.
Page had a serious revival on his hands if
you keep in mind that some of his dances
were not revivals at all but continuations of
dances begun in colonial times.
When the halls were not available or the
dancers too few in a rural community, jun
the

community

in

Lowell, Massachusetts, just

south of where live calls such gatherings
"soirees." They are supported mostly by
the older French-speaking people in the
neighborhood, and plied with coffee and
I

good cooking, the folks shake a leg all
night
usually in the blue light of the om
nipresent t.v.
In Ralph Page's heydey he, along with
Duke Miller, another local favorite, did an
even balance of squares and contras in the
course of an evening. But then the balance
began to shift. Sometime in the 1960s west
dancing was having a surge of
popularity in New Hampshire. It didn't
catch on with most old-time dancers be
cause of the recorded music. Whether it's
"Darling Nellie Gray" or "Money In Both
Pockets," we've always liked our music
ern square

live. But club square dancing was quite
popular with some, and a rift appeared in
the dance community.
Caller Dudley Laufman

explained
in

to me

of Canterbury
how this caused a change

both the dancers' style and the callers'.

"Sometime

in the

beginning

of the

seven

ties, and other callers were shying away
from the old quadrilles because there was
I

some feeling that they reflected the squaredance world and all that represented. It's a
pity we reacted so strongly, because at
some dances squares just disappeared, and
they really are an important part of the
New England dance tradition." Page, Duke
Miller, and younger callers Tony Parkes
and Todd Whittemore retained a loyalty to

quadrilles, but, by and large, folks in
doing mostly contras at an
dance.
As our dancing moves
evening's
into the '90s, we're still arguing about how
it should be done.
The two camps we're separating into
the

the North were

(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

these days seem to consist of those who
don't mind dong the old, tried and true
dances that their parents and grandparents
did, and those who favor newer, more

"challenging" dances. Eight beat swings!
Two beat allemandes! More gypsies and
heys! Double swings! Dances where you
have to change your shirt after each figure.
predict that folks will tire of all the frenetic
activity, and the pendulum will swing the
I

other way. We will, as one local Old Boy
put it "just get damn tired of thinking so

godawful hard

all

night."

this way."

Different sections of the country are go
ing to find their country dancing influenced
by their local culture: Lloyd Shaw could
not ignore the cowboys, dancers in the

Midwest cannot ignore the hambo. It's all
part of that peculiar elephant that dancers
love to argue about. In my corner of the
globe, we're lucky to be the recipients of

some pretty precious gifts. As John
McCutcheon sings, it's "water from an
other time": our music and our dancing are
echoes of something real, the rhythms folks

have an ongoing argument with a good
is also a fine dance musician.
He says that dancing and music need to
"evolve." That the incorporation of swing-

lived and worked by. So, no matter
whereyou live, no matter how you dance,

dance moves into old-time contradancing
is an inevitability to be dealt with, as surely
as short skirts were dealt with in the 1920s.

Mary DesRosiers is a New Hampshire native
who has been involved in traditional music and

1

friend who

purist when I
dance band to provide

He accuses me of being

want the piano in

a

a

steady beat beneath the melody, and
when
want to be courtesy turned, not
twirled. He says the condition of art, like
a

I

nature is change, growth,
and response to new input; and that stasis
is the death rattle of the dancing we love so
well. Well maybe, say, but there's a lot to
that of human

I

be said

for

doing Moneymusk

after the

break, just because "we've always done

it

keep dancing!

dance for over 20 years. She is a dance caller and
teacher, and an adjunct faculty member in the

education

department

at

Antioch

New

En

gland Graduate School. She is a founder of the
Monadnock Folklore Society, and choreogra
pher for the Nelson Village Dancers, a traditional
dance performance group. In addition to her
dance activities she

is a

producer for New Hamp

shire Public Radio, and has worked on several

NPR projects, including the nationally broad
cast Valley Folk and New England Almanac.
She lives in

Harrisville, New Hampshire.

�And

by Jeri

I

Mean Business

Goldstein

that you have your promotional
packet all set, let's put it to good use.

Now

tour mailing

to all

those on your list. I've

Your sample press release can be used by
the promoter in a general mailing to local
media lists, including radio and print me

down by tour: fall tour, spring
summer
tour. A yearly mailing to
tour,
on
the
list often ensures that your
everyone
fans know what you are up to. You'll be
surprised at how dedicated people can be.

tion about your gig and include it.
press release is well written, and

They like hearing from you. A mailing
helps people feel a part of something. You
can use this mailing in either post card
form or flyer form. Your mailings keep

dia. Many papers have free calendar list
ings: they will pull out pertinent informa
If

if

your
they

have room for it, the papers will sometimes
use it as is. Radio stations have a
"What's Happening Around Town"
or

Calendar"

"Community

broken

Ask your promoter or local contact for a
list of two or three local papers and radio

stations that are friendly to the kind of
music you are doing. Call them two to
three weeks prior to the gig and try to line
up a pre-concert interview. You'll want to
send them your new press kit, photo, and
your latest recording if you have one, for
possible review. Let the writer or radio
show host know that there will be guest
tickets waiting for them at the concert.
Being so enticing, you may even get a con
cert review out of your efforts, and another
to ad d to

your publicity packet.
mailing list is an essential
ingredient to any artist's promotion. Set
ting out a simple sheet of paper at your
concerts and asking people to sign up with
name, address, and zip code can help build
great piece

Developing

inform

them of important issues about
which you are concerned, and sell your
products through the mail. I have gener
ated between one-half to three-quarters of
my artist's audience in certain towns sim
ply with a post card to our mailing list. It is
direct mail at its finest, exactly targeting

your audience.
If you have a video available,
many or

strong following over the years. As you
build your tours, send a regional or full-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

using

it

to

attract local tv and cable entertainment
calendars. Some stations will even make
up a Public Service Announcement (PSA)
for the organizationif it's a not-for-profit

group.

a

a

interested

As you begin to work with the

promot

know that you
will try to be available to them to help with
the promotion. Find out exactly what they
ers of your concerts, let them

expect

to do to

promote your appearance.
you see that their promotion doesn't
meet your expectations, you might try sug
If

send the
your own interviews and press.
promoters an information sheet that they
need to fill out and return to me. Included
on this sheet is space for them to list local
media personnel with phone numbers and
I

important happening and will often make
an extra effort to at least give the event

them abreast of your touring schedule, let
them know when new releases are due out,

are

hands. Developing a good relationship with
the promoter can assure you of getting the
media information you'll need to arrange

promoter has made. If we both contact the
media, they take it as a sign of something

Promotion

ganizations

gesting some of the above. If a promoter is
reluctant to do a great deal of outreach, you
may have to take matters into your own

addresses of at least three papers and three
radio stations with show host names and
numbers. This way, I can call at my leisure
and follow up any preliminary efforts the

Promotion

segment pro

grammed throughout the week. They can
pull information from the press release and
include it in this calendar-type listing. Send
one of your black and white photos along
with the press release and it might be in
cluded as a feature. Many papers are using
color for the entertainment sections. Sup
ply one of these papers with a color slide,
and you have a good chance of getting on
the cover.

it

some kind of coverage.
Ticket give-aways and recording give
aways are usually coordinated with local
radio stations involved in helping to pro
mote the show along with the record com
pany. These efforts help to broaden the
artist's audience and perhaps reach a num

ber of people

who would otherwise

not

have concerned themselves with the event.
Finally in the list of ideas is the paid ad.
Most smaller promoters try to steer away
from paying for advertising

since it is so
costly. Sometimes you might suggest that
the promoter share a cooperative ad with
the artist's record company, local record

distributor,

or

even

with

the

artist.

De

pending on the market for the particular
event, paid advertising may be a very im
portant tool not to be totally ignored.
Promotion can be incredibly hard work
as
or

well as half the fun of putting on
festival. Don't forget to ask

cluded

a

to

concert
be

in

local organization newsletters
and list your itinerary in as many regional
in

(continued

on page 56)

�Living

with

Gerry

Milnes

Dave Shombert

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

short

A

biographical

note

jacket of his recent book

on

the

describes

Gerry Milnes as a "farmer, writer,
square-dance fiddler, and staff folklorist at the Augusta Heritage Center at Davis
and Elkins College" in West Virginia. All of that
is true, but I don't think it goes far enough.
Some other descriptions that come to mind are
banjo player, guitar player, and singer. Also,
student, teacher, and organizer. Did I mention

builder and engineer? The problem, of course,
is that one or two paragraphs on a book jacket
can't even begin to convey how much or how
well Gerry Milnes has integrated traditionial
music and craft into his life.
I

first met Gerry at the Augusta Workshops in
had nearly worn out my tape player

1986.

I

to his version of Cletus Johnson' s ba njo
tune, "Shavin' A Dead Man." Now here was in
his banjo class, not really knowing what my

listening

1

expectations were but certainly not expecting
that he would be able to teach us this complex
tune

in

just

a

couple of hours. He did, and

to

this

day it's one of my favorites. Since then, I've
been back for a lot more banjo tunes, a few
fiddle tunes, and many hours of friendship.

After reading several articles that he wrote
about other people, decided it was time for the
I

shoe to be on the other foot.

Milnes

Gerry grew up in Pennsylvania and southern
New Jersey, an area not known for old-time
music. However, music was an important part

Gerry

by

Interview

of the Milnes

family's life.
"My parents were from rural Pennsylvania,
and country music was what appealed to them.
think my mother knew every song Hank Wil
liams ever sang.
got started playing music
I

courtesy

An

In Tradition:

I

�mostly because of my older brother Frank,
who played guitar and fiddle, and a cousin
named Tom Gray who lived in Newark,
Delaware. He played five-string banjo and
provided some of the motivation there.
When
was first learning the guitar, at
about nine years old, a guy who had a real
nice Martin guitar came courting one of my
sisters. He left it at the house, and used to
sneak it out of the case once in a while. So
1

I

a real
good instrument right at
which probably helped. When
was twelve years old, my older brother
I

got

to

play

the start,

I

gave me a banjo for my birthday and
started playing a three-finger banjo style.
All through high school and for a few years

afterward,

I

played

a

lot of

I

Scruggs style

banjo.

"When
Lancaster

was about 21 and living in
met
County (Pennsylvania),
some fiddlers from there and from York
County. got a fiddle and started trying it.
preferred the old-time fiddle style right
I

I

I

I

away, and I've never really played any
bluegrass fiddle. Also, around that time,
got my first open-back banjo and started
learning the clawhammer style."
On any instrument, Gerry learned to

I

around Baltimore somewhere.

remember
festival
going
thinking that was
to
listen
to
going
bluegrass music. found
him in the parkting lot playing hornpipes
and old-time tunes, and wound up spend
ing most of the weekend listening to him.
I

to that

I

I

I

That was around the time that

was trying
to sort out what kind of music
liked to
was
play;
playing bluegrass banjo a lot,
but liked the old-time fiddle too."
I

I

I

1

was curious about whether the fiddle
music that Gerry heard around his home
was any different from southern old-time
styles. "The tunes were a little different.
Luther Criswell played all the standard
old-time tunes, along with some tunes that
I

were from York County; there was one he
played that I liked a lot called "Muddy
Creek." There were a lot of people around
there who had come from the South, and
natives, but it seemed like all

lot who were

people who played music just got all
mixed in together. So there really wasn't
that much difference in the style."
the

Gerry started traveling south

musicians and hang out

at

to

visit other

festivals around

from.

cians, and

always

a

parking lot music going on.
fiddlers picnic there every year,

lot of

They had a
and that's wherelfirstmetLutherCriswell.
Also Jerry Lundy (Emmett Lundy's grand
son) and a fiddle player named Sonny Miller
were always there. They also had a fidder's
picnic every

year

at

Lenape,

Chester

in

was involved with the Brandywine
think it was at the first bluefolks, and
"I

I

grass festival that they put on that met this
fiddler named Red Hartnatt. He was from
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

I

they'd play a tune or sing a song at the drop
a hat. Their music was
impressive, but
was also impressed by the kind of people
of

I

they were."
After a year or so in Huttonsville, Gerry
and Mary Alice bought some land in
Webster County, near the town of Birch
River. To say that it was remote is sort of
like saying West Virginia is "hilly." They
had to ford Skyles Creek three times just to
it, and once they got there they had
no electricity and no building save for an
get to

empty granary. "For the first few years,
didn't get out to play music much because
there was so much work to do. We actually
stayed in Huttonsville for a while after we
bought the place, and built the house over

1

that first year. Building with hand tools is a
real challenge. had done some restoration
left Pennsylvania, and
carpentry before
that helped. We moved there permanently
in the spring of 1977, and started building
the rest of the place."

Two children were born while they were

liked the area and the people I
met. By 1975, Mary Alice and were look
ing for a place to start a home and West
Virginia was real enticing. Land was cheap,
the music was good, and the people were

there; Lydia, now 13, and Jesse, now 10.
Despite the hard work and occasional hard

friendly.

seven years without a telephone, and nine
years without electricity. "We were iso
lated, and sometimes we were waterbound
or icebound for a week or two. It was hard

I

I

introduced

had

me

the

"Dwight
Hammons family, and that was the start of
a long succession of old-time
musicians
that

went

I

to

met. When we first came here, we
Randolph County and inside a

to

couple of months

I

had met

a

lot of

old-time

banjo players right around there. We lived
near a little town called Huttonsville, and
met Currence

County.

Both those guys were typical old-timers;
they had a great outlook about life, and

I

"One of the first musicians

play more by watching and listening than
by taking lessons. I asked him who some of
the first fiddlers were that he had learned

vania; they had most of the major bluegrass
bands there on weekends, and there was

a lot of them are
gone now.
"Cletus Johnson was a big influence on
me, both his playing and his personality,
and the same with Currence Hammonds.

1

1970.

know
got
was Dwight Diller, and he introduced me
to some other West Virginia folks. I made a
lot of trips down here to visit older musi

"There was a fellow named Luther
Criswell who played a lot around York
County. I went to a lot of events at a place
called Sunset Park in West Grove, Pennsyl

there. Most. of these people were 75 years
old and up, and

Hammonds there. Just

a

I

mile

away was Mill Creek, where Cletus John
son and his brother Arthur D. Johnson
lived. Woody Simmons lives in Mill Creek,
and Dona Gum and Russell Higgins were

ship, the family has fond memories of the
experience. Mary Alice recalls that they
lived for "four years without a refrigerator,

work, but we enjoyed it. We got a lot of help
from neighbors, older folks who were still

living simple, rural lifestyles. They appre
ciated what we were doing, and they were
a lot of
support. When we needed to know
how to do something, they were always
glad to be able to help us. It was what we
wanted at the time; think we each wanted
I

separately before we met each other."
(continued on next pnge)
it

�hadn't known about until moved there.
"I spent more time with Ernie than the
rest of them, because he was the one lived
closest to. Ernie has some real subtle things
I

I

in

playing that

his

I

came to appreciate

quite lot, and even though I've learned a
lot of his repertoire, there are some things
a

he does that

I

haven't quite learned

to

do

might surprise some (it did me) to
learn that during most of this period, when
he was learning many new tunes and styles
It

on both banjo and fiddle, Gerry did not use
a tape recorder. I asked if he thought that

better musician. "I felt for
had made him
was going to
a long time, especially when
a whole
it
made
that
Ernie Carpenter's place,
in my
fiddle
with
a
lot more sense to go
just
what
he
to
hand. It made me pay attention
more
the
tunes
was playing, and it made

courtesy

Gerry

Milnes

a

I

personal somehow. The visits became a lot
more special because of that. think it's the
I

to go, if you're learning music from an
old-timer and the music has become a real

way

Livestock were added over the years,
and the sheep herd grew to about 50 head.
Electricity was eventually obtained from

part of that person;

I've been lucky enough to accompany
Gerry on a few visits to older musicians,
and on those occasions

to

the music, really; they became some of his
closest friends. He just enjoyed their com

met
"Not long after we moved there
I was
playing at a dance
I

Braxton County and he walked in. Some
knew he was a fiddle player the
how,
minute saw him. We got to talking and he
in

I

I

house, and pretty
was going out there regularly. I
soon
found out that Ernie was not only a good
fiddle player, he knew a lot of the old tunes
me over

to

his

I

that French Carpenter played, tunes that
lot

of

a

people thought were gone when
met John Johnson, who lived

French died.

I

started spending
in Braxton County, and
also met
more time with Melvin Wine.
Sarah
and
Singleton
Harvey Sampson
I

I

around then; Melvin encouraged me to go
met John
visit her. In Webster County,

musicians

around there that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

pany so much."
Gerry's involvement with the Augusta
workshops began in 1977, and by 1981 he
was an instructor on a regular basis, teach
ing week-long classes in either fiddle or
banjo. That continued until 1987, when OldTime Week made its debut with Gerry as
coordinator. For those who haven't at
tended, Old-Time Week includes classes in

fiddle, banjo, guitar, mandolin, autoharp,
vocals, and a few others. One of Gerry's
highest priorities during the week is for
students

I

to be

exposed

as

much as possible

older musicians; each day includes a
visit from a different "old master," which
to

so far has

I

Christian, Jimmy Dowdle, and Alf Hall. So
it seemed like there was a whole bevy of
old-time

was struck by how
part of their world.

struck me about Gerry and the older musi
cians he met was the friendship that
developed between them. It went beyond

de

Ernie Carpenter.

invited

I

much he seemed to be a
Neither the age difference nor the fact that
he had come from outside their community
ever seemed to even be noticed. Mary Alice
confirmed this: "One thing that has always

those hills, there was a computer
whose energy source was water from a
West Virginia creek turning an alternator

Eventually the demands of the farm

learn

I

in

clined to the point where Gerry was able
spend more time on music.

to

tion."

vided for more sophisticated appliances.
Personally, I've always found a strange
satisfaction in sitting here in the Washing
ton suburbs and knowing that somewhere,

from an old Plymouth.

you're able

tunes without having to deal with a tape
think it's a much better situa
recorder,

Skyles Creek via a water turbine and 12volt automobile alternator which powered
the lights; DC to AC conversion was pro

up

if

included Ernie Carpenter, Melvin

Wine, Wilson Douglas, Sarah Singleton, J.
P. Fraley, and others too numerous to men

tion.

Furthermore,

opportunity

to

get about as close

source as it's now possible

Old-Time

Week

to

the

to

get.
1988 Gerry signed on as Staff FolklorAugusta. This required leaving Birch

In

ist at

River and moving

and probably never will."

Ernie Carpenter

instructors are nearly all younger genera
tion members who have spent much time
with other older musicians. Since many of
the latter are now gone, his week is an

to

Elkins,

a

decision that

did not come easily, but it has enabled him
to accomplish more than would have been

possible otherwise. A major part of the job
has been to establish and administer the
Folk Arts Apprenticeship Program, in
which younger generation musicians or
craftspeople are paired up with older gen
eration masters for a period of study lasting
year. "We have 27

up to

a

to

basketmaking,

apprenticeships

funded through the program so far, in
volving everything from old-time fiddling

blacksmithing,

stonecutting, banjo playing, tatting, weav
ing, and more. Some of the master artist/
apprentice combinations have been Melvin
Wine/John Gallagher (fiddle), Dare
Crawford /Benn Carr (stonecutting), Clyde
Case/Gene Hall (basketmaking), and Sarah
Singleton/Teresa Hamm (fiddle)."
In
to

continuing the program, Gerry hopes

extend his search for master artists to

other areas of the state. His motivation is
partly desire to see the folk arts perpetu
ated and partly to honor those who have
kept them alive. "Maybe the best thing to
come out of the program so far, aside from
the fact that there's a lot of learning going
on,

is

that people who are designated

as

master artists are given some recognition.
When people have practiced some sort of
folk art all their lives, they should be hon
ored for the fact that they stayed with it and
kept it alive. This program is a way of

doing that."
Although Gerry has won his share of
fiddle and banjo contests at places like
Glenville and Vandalia, found him reluc
tant to talk about those events but eager to
express his opinion about contests in gen
eral. "Contests are a way of getting people
I

together, but think they do a lot of harm to
traditional music. Fiddle players play what
they think the judges want to hear, not
necessarily what's good about the music.
People then equate best and good with
showy or dazzling, and pretty soon some
of the old tunes are being forgotten and the
wrong sorts of things are being pushed to
the front. There are some contests where
the categories that the fiddlers are judged
I

on are good for the music, such as the new

�one

at

Clifftop."

The list of recordings and articles that
Gerry Milnes has produced is impressive
but not surprising, considering his dedica
tion to the preservation of traditional arts.

project that began back in Birch River

A

col

recently culminated in a book/ cassette
lection of Appalachian rhymes, riddles,
songs, entitled Granny Will Your Dog
[see review p. 52], On the cassette,
songs are sung
Sonja Bird and

the

Bite

the

alternately by nine-year old
old-timer Homer Fleming,

both from near Birch River. The book

tains the words

and

to the

con

songs, accompanied by

delightful illustrations

of

Kimberly

Bulken Root. You'll probably find it in the
children's section of your local bookstore,
but don't be misled;

bought it for my
mother for Christmas and she loved it.
Gerry is a regular contributor to Goldenseal,
a

magazine about

all

I

aspects of West Vir

ginia tradition and history, and has produced

numerous recordings of other West Vir
ginia musicians, e.g., Ernie Carpenter's Elk
(Augusta Heritage Records 001
Melvin Wine's Hannah At the Springhouse
River Blues

(Marimac Augusta Heritage Series #2), and
the recent Banjo Anthology (Marimac Au
gusta Heritage Series #4 and #5). Hecanbe
heard, along with other West Virginia mu

sicians, on Banjo Legacy (Augusta Heritage
Records 006) and on several of the Music
from Augusta tapes (SCS 510 and 705). He

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

has also produced one recording of his own,
Old Time Music (Oxbow Productions 001).

recommend

1

these recordings for some
of the best traditional music from West Vir
all

ginia. Better yet, go

to

Augusta next summer

and hear him in person. While you're there,
get him to teach you"Shavin' A Dead Man;"
it's not as hard as it

sounds.

Dave Shombert plays old-time banjo and is a
veteran of the Augusta Workshops. He and his
wife Ellen live near Washington, D. C., but are
currently planning their escape.

�Keeping Up With Ramona Jones
Anne Goodman

by Rachel

came Ramona's radio idol.
"
The first ever heard her

Saturday night, and the dance

a

floor

the

at

Carter

Fold

Family

in

I

Hiltons, Virginia is crowded with
moving their feet to a brisk
version of "Mississippi Sawyer."
Hun
dreds of folks have come out on this chilly
January night to hear Ramona Jones play
the fiddle. After 54 years as a professional

musician, Ramona's love of old-time
hasn't diminished one bit. Her
dedication to the music shows in the way
she introduces each tune as if it were an old
friend. To understand her journey from
is

gone.
Ramona was born and raised

is all

rural

in the

over the Kentucky line. She remembers
watching her father, Homer Riggins, play
the

down

to

WHAS

Louisville and be on my

in

early radio program one time?' Well,
scared to death and thrilled to death

I

was

at the

same time. My brother drove me down
remember she said, 'Be sure
there, and
and tell me what you're going to play.' So
I

He would leave the fiddle on the table

and her band opened up the door of radio

in

evenings after returning

the

try

to

play.

The

first tune he ever

taught me was "Bile Them Cabbage Down."
was about five.
always

That was when

knew that

I

I

wanted

I

to be

a

fiddler,

I

just

always knew that's what wanted to do."
Ramona Jones reached high-school age
in the heyday of the live country radio barn
dance shows. Stations such as WLS in Chi
I

cago and WHAS in Louisville
music shows often supporting

live

had
10

or

20

different acts; from cowboy fiddlers to child
accordionists. Some artists like Sunshine
Sue Workman had their own programs.
Sue Workman, whose show always opened
with "You Are My Sunshine," quickly be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

told her

I

I

1

I

Frequent appearances with Sunshine Sue

show business for Ramona Jones at an early
age. Looking back, she says she's amazed
her parents let her go on the road at such

a

young age.
"One day
was sitting in algebra class,
and my teacher came in land] said 'you're
I

wanted on the telephone
you have a call
from Richmond, Virginia.'
thought, 'Me?'
had never traveled
you know, because
and
didn't know where Richmond, Vir
ginia was. And it was Sunshine Sue calling
to see if
was interested in moving to
I

I

I

I

Richmond, Virginia
1

was

a

senior

eighteen,
and

1

I

to

I

I

that

fiddle

when he'd leave for work, andl'dpickitup
and

I

was going to play 'Ragtime
Annie,' but when got on the air was so
scared that played 'Soldier's Joy.'"

from the coal mines, and she vowed
she would learn to play someday.
"

they would have amateur contests.
would always enter if could. So entered
Sunshine Sue's contest several times, and
won. Then she told me, 'Could you come

but

of Prairie Creek, Indiana, just

community

high

and

pioneer fiddler on the
to glimpse a part of

country music history that today

in

well. Pee Wee King was there with a band,
Cousin Emmy was there with her band
doing early morning radio programs. Well,
they came to a lot of the little high schools

music

to

was

school and playing in amateur contests all
around my little community. Now she was
on radio WHAS in Louisville, and there
were a lot of other entertainers there as

It'speople

Indiana farm girl
Grand Ole Opry

wrote
I

work with her. And

that time. But the day was
left school and went with her,
at

I

I

rode across country on

a

bus. And she

my

mom the sweetest

letter;

she

will certainly try to keep her in
will support her all the way in
school,
finishing her senior year.' But I'll have to
tell you this,
never did get a diploma.
said,

'I

I

I

tried to continue school, but Sue had
early morning programs; she had a noon
time program, she'd come to school and
"I

get me at noon, and then they did personal

appearances at night. So I was really get
ting run down. was losing weight, wasn't
getting enough sleep, and almost had a
nervous breakdown trying to do all she
wanted me to do, because that was number
I

I

I

I

one with me."
In about 1940, Ramona moved with the
whole radio cast to WLW in Cincinnati,
Ohio, which at the time was broadcasting
an unheard-of 500,000 watts of power. The

signal reached most of the eastern United
States and into Canada. There, Ramona

became close friends with Joe Maphis.
When the young Ramona would forget a
musical introduction, Joe would discreetly
play the first few notes on his mandolin to
remind her. Ramona was playing mando
lin and fiddle in a trio with Sunshine Sue
and another singer as the Happy Valley
Singers. The show was the "Boone County
Jamboree" later to be named"The Renfro
Valley Barn Dance" by its promoter, John

dreamy theme song called
Happy Valley" that opened ev
show.
Other
musicians in the cast at the
ery
time included TheGirls of theGolden West,
Lair. They had

"Home

a

in

Pee Wee King,

Kincaid.

Merle Travis and Bradley
Merle Travis became a lifelong

friend of Ramona and Grandpa Jones, and
a big influence on Ramona's music.
It
was Joe Maphis who introduced her to the
had

world's youngest old man, Grandpa Jones,

�take off, and Ramona was accompanying
him both on stage at the Opry, on tour, and
on several of his big hit recordings. She

played bass on "Here Rattler Here," a song
that was a huge success when King records
released it in the 1940s. Ramona and
a farm
15 miles out of
town and settled into the thriving country
music scene of the time to become the
island of old-time music within a sea of
orchestral arrangement. Ramona can be
credited with helping maintain the old-

Grandpa bought

time flavorofGrandpa Jones' music. During
the early 1950s, when Grandpa was about
to break into the big time, he was recording
for RCA Victor and was being asked to

record all kinds of topical or comic songs.
Ramona persuaded him to stick to the tra

ditional roots of their music. She would
help him with harmony vocals, and help
work out traditional material. As a result,
Grandpa

decided

to

concentrate on the

banjo, an instrument which later became
his trademark, winning him entry into the

country music hall of fame.
Ramona Jones' repertoire of traditional
fiddle tunes still constitutes a big part of the
Jones' Opry performance.

In

between clas

sic Granpa Jones numbers, Ramona cuts
loose on a lively version of "Bill Cheatem."

When

I

met Ramona back-stage

at the

Opry,

courtesy

Ramona

Jones

she was the quintessential hostess, intro
ducing me to the other performers in
between working out the set list with

Ramona Jones

who was singing

in a trio at the

time. Ramona

married

the family started coming
were
number one. And if had
along, they

began to play the mandolin regularly on
his early recordings, and in 1942 Ramona
and Grandpa were married.

already loved show business be
fore got married didn' marry real young,
was twenty-three. So
married when
knew
the music and being
loved
already
on the stage. Of course, then when
got
I

I

had

I

1

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

quit show business

to

them,

I

think

I

to

take care of

would have."

quitting was not Ramona's
the late 1940s, Grandpa and

However,
style.

t

I

1

and

I

had

"I

ca. 1951

1

By

Ramona Jones moved to Nashville, Ten
nessee to be on WSM's Grand Ole Opry.

Grandpa's career was beginning to really

Grandpa.

1

noted there were nearly as many
milling around back

female performers

stage as there were men. Ramona has her
own memories of being a woman on the
Opry. Forty-five years ago when she made
her first Grand Ole Opry appearance, the
sight of a woman fiddler leading a band
was a rare thing indeed.
"When
first became aware of show
I

business, and country music, and hillbilly
music, there were not as many women in it
then.
remember on the Opry, you could
name on your fingers how many ladies
1

there were singing on the Opry
maybe
three or four. Minnie Pearl has been there
las

long as] I've been

(continued

on next page)

there, but

it

has

�changed a lot. More women are getting into the country field,
especially on the Opry. I can still remember when there was a dress
code
you had to wear high heels and a dress. guess things have
changed a little since then."
However, appearing on the Opry wasn't enough for Ramona
Jones. In the late 1950s, she decided to form her own band rather
than accompany Grandpa on his rigorous touring schedule. The
logical choice of band members were her children Elisa, Marsha,
Mark, and Eloise. T ogether, they opened an old-time music venue
the Grandpa Jones Dinner Theater in Mountain View, Arkansas.
The Jones family became a major part of the traditional music scene
I

was there that she met Cathy Barton and Dave Para, a
who
shared her interest in old-time music and collaborated
couple
with her on recording projects. This move helped Ramona step out
there.

on

It

her

own as

musician

a

her

in

own

separately from her husband.

right,

defining herself

"People used to say to me, 'You're going out on stage without
Grandpa?' They had never seen me do that too much. Of course I
always knew that loved it and always knew that could. We all
know who the star is in our family, it's Grandpa; but we all like to
do our own thing even so. tell my children even today, We have
I

I

I

Jones

'

I

Ramona

to do a good job, because they know Grandpa can do it, but they
don't know we can.' Sometimes families just want to go into show

business and they haven't done their homework, and so tell them
we always have to do a good job. We have to prove ourselves. We
still do.

courtesy

I

"

Playing old-time music professionally over the years has cer
tainly had its ups and downs for Ramona
Jones. There have been times she felt no one
was interested in the music she loved so
much. At one point the all-male musicians
union in Washington, D.C. made her take a

Ramona Riggins (Jones),

8

years old, Prairie Creek, Indiana

music test to prove that she could play the
fiddle. While she says times have improved
since those days, the business isn't what it
once was.
"The business has changed so much.

In

our day, you would go to a radio station
and perform weeks and weeks and weeks
till you would become popular, then you
would start booking out around that area.

was not records, it was just radio. And
now it's all done on the strength of records.
Is there anybody that cares about the music
It

much as they care about the money?
That's what bothers me. Grandpa and just
as

I

Jones

like music. Grandpa went to a radio station
the other day and said,
just want to play,
'

Ramona

I

don't care what you pay me.' That's what's
not happening today."
Although Ramona has seen interest in
traditional music rise and fall over the years,
she sounds optimistic about the small, but

enthusiastic audience the music
attracting.
"I love

it,

and

old-time music.

I

is

currently

will always support the
And I've learned that

people really love it, they still love it, they
just don't know where to find it. And once
they learn, 'Oh, this is gonna be old-time

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

I

Working with Sunshine Sue. L-R: Sunshine Sue, Ramona, Jane Allen,

country music,' they'll come. We have big
crowds. And what pleases me more is to
have young people come. College kids
come and they like it. They don't know
that they like

it

until they come and see

it,

and then they like

it.

ca.

1942

They love

it!

What

I

can have come across is that

always hope
old-time country music can have some
class to it. We always feel we should look
our best and present it in a way that would
I

�Grandpa Jones
Appalachian Christmas
Christmas

time's

a-comin', and

and Ramona Jones and their

Grandpa

family are busy wrapping up a big holi
day surprise for the children of Appalachia.

Grandpa,

along with his helpers,

Ramona, the Jones family, Ruth McLain
of the McLain family, and John Hart

Jones

ford, will perform at a benefit concert
for the Save the Children Federation.
The show will take place on Novem

Admission

is $8 for

adults, $4

courtesy

Berea, Ky.

Ramona

ber 16 at 7:30 p.m. in the Phelps Stokes
Building on the Berea College campus,

children and college students, plus
the donation of a toy.
Proceeds from the event will be used
to buy toys for the Appalachian chldren.
Any extra money will be donated to the
Save the Children Federation.
Save the Children has roots that run
for

L-R: Chris

Riggins,

Jack Gainey, Ramona

Riggins (Jones), and

Bob

Riggins

deep in the Appalachian mountains,
having organized there in 1932 during
the depths of the Depression to help the
children of unemployed coal miners.
"Since our children are grown, we

want to do something special for chil
dren at Christmas," said Ramona.
"We're all very excited to have an

op

portunity to help provide gifts for the
Appalachian children during the holi
days. We have

a

lot of

long-timefans

Jones

from this part of the country who are
very special to us and we hope they'll be
able to come to the show."
you would like to help in this very
special holiday event, but are unable to

40403.

courtesy

attend, donations may be sent to: Save
the Children, Grandpa Jones Appala
chian Christmas, Box 319, Berea, KY

Ramona

If

Grandpa Joners, Mary Klick entertaining for service men

L-R: Ramona,

in Korea,

1951

--Patsy B. Weiler

accepted by all. Old-time music can have a lot of class if presented
right way. Why not play it for the president?"
Ramona Jones has recently moved from Arkansas back to her
farm in Ridgetop, Tennessee near Nashville. Although she no
longer runs the Dinner Theater in Mountain View, she and Grandpa
still appear regularly on the Opry and at old-time and bluegrass
festivals around the country. Ramona Jones can also be seen and

be

right--

L-R: Ruth McLain,

Patsy
courtesy

Ron

Wall, Alisa Jones Wall

Ramona'

s

daughter, Ramona, Larry Sledge, Mark Jones (Ramona's son). July 1991,
Murfreesboro Tn. Ramona was the recipient of the 1991 Uncle Dave Macon

Heritage Award.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Brown

Photo at

on next page)

Sonny

(continued

Weiler

in the

�Hee Haw program
band. Hier current band
includes her daughter Alisa Jones Wall on
hammered dulcimer, Ruth McLain formerly
of the McLain Family Band on guitar, and
son Mark on banjo. After a lifetime of
playing the fiddle, Ramona is still an avid
heard

on

television's

with the fiddle

collector of old songs and tunes, and regu
larly packs

a

tape recorder

around

with

her. Unlike many old-time fiddlers, Ramona
Jones never set down her music for other

pursuits. And as far as she can tell, she
never will.
"I'd just like people to know what a hard

had and how you can over
come all that by trying. And think you can

childhood

I

I

find one thing in your life that means a lot
to you, to me it was music. And if you just

keep working and working,
tainly open up a lot of doors,
work hard."

Rachel Anne Goodman

is a

it

if

will

cer

you just

writer, free-lance

producer, and musician living in
Staunton, Va. This article was taken from in
radio

terviews done for "The Southern Songbirds"
public radio series about women in old-time and
early country

music.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�and Tracy Schwarz in 1963 and 1964 at
Eck's home in Amarillo, Texas. Eck was the
first traditional fiddler to be recorded back

those discs remain as some of

in 1922 and

Selected

the finest examples of classic Arkansas/
Texas fiddling. His deliberate bowing ar
ticulates clearly the accents and phrases of

Listening

tune without resorting to patterned
rhythms. This recording has a great variety
of tunes and tunings. Hopefully, the
a

Fiddle

Old-Time

Music

Sonyatone recording of all of his Victor 78s
will be re-released; it has his classic playing
of "Sallie Goodin" on it.

Mike Seeger

by

Fiddling John Carson,
led, the Rooster's

is

have asked old-time
fiddlers I've met where

When

they have learned, most of
them will talk of first learn

ing from someone in their family or nearby
community and then searching out, some

great effort, some of the older
fiddlers of their region. For most of us
these days the process is quite different.
Now fiddlers learn from people their own
times

at

age, sometimes in fiddle classes, and much
less from fiddlers of the older generation.
Over the past 65 or so years,

a

new

element has changed the transmission or
learning process of fiddle music: the me
chanical recording process. It is now
possible

to

learn tunes from

never met from

a

a

fiddler you

thousand miles

or fifty

away. It is possible to learn it
exactly, not just from hearing it once as
you might have in those older "days.
Over the past several years, beginning
fiddle players have asked me to suggest a
years

record or two that they could buy that
would help them learn both the essence of
southern fiddling as well as some nice
tunes in particular. This has led to this list
is selected from the hundreds of

which

recordings of fiddle music that are pres
ently available.
Style is a major component of southern
fiddling: it's not strictly the tune you play
you play it bow it mostly
that's important. So think it's a very good

but how

I

idea for any fiddler in this day and time to
educate his or her ears to the range of

sounds that exists on the instrument as the
fiddler starts to learn. And then perhaps if
they find a sound that particularly appeals
them, they can focus in on that one, and
listen to it a whole lot and get it in their
to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

minds. For me, listening

pleasure, and
it's the only way to learn the language. You
can't learn the language unless you hear it
spoken first. The greater your experience,
the richer your fiddling will be.
This is a collection, then, that
suggest
should be at the core of any contemporary
fiddler's collection. These recordings have
been selected to represent some of the more
stylistically influential or representative fid
is a

dlers

and

a few
regional
broad
fairly
range of style.

string-bands,
a

southern style.
definitely
have limited the list to a certain number of
currently available recordings. Consider this

The emphasis

on

is

I

vital, necessary part of your learning ex
perience, at a cost less than a trip to a festival,
a $100 investment that will be with
you for
a

long as you have a record player and can
play the fiddle. For those of you who have a
ings

in the

am listing the record
approximate order that would
I

I

purchase them.
Great Big Yam Potatoes.
partment of Archives and

(Mississippi De

History AH 002.
Distributed by Southern Culture records,
University of Mississippi, University, MS
396 77) For the number of tunes, fiddlers
and variety of older, homey playing styles
this could be my favorite single fiddling
record. Ten fiddlers play 42 tunes from

Mississippi largely solo, recorded in the
1930s by collectors for the Library of Con
gress.
American Fiddle Tunes from the Archive of
Folk Song. Library of Congress L62. An ex
cellent survey of traditional fiddling from

over the U.S. Edited by fiddler, Alan
Jabbour. Excellent notes.
all

Eck

Robertson.

(County 202)

19

tunes,

played solo, recorded by me, John Cohen,

in this

singer/
record

collection. Some rare

fiddle-accompanied singing

are included here,
with
other
droll
along
many
performances.

(no other instruments)

loose, anti-technical approach to
fiddling
completely different from Eck
Robertson's.

To me his

is

Arthur Smith

Fiddlin' Arthur Smith and

Dixieliners, Volume 1. (County 546)
Tennessean Arthur Smith evolved his driv
his

ing

bowing

in

style

the

early

twentieth-century and through his record
ings, his broadcasts on the Grand Ole Opry,

and his touring, was the most influential
fiddler in the southeast during the 1930s
and 1940s. He also

composed

a

lot of his

tunes and songs, some of which would
now be considered strictly traditional. He

backed on these recordings
Delmore Brothers.
is

as

very limited budget,

of

examples

I

collections, and

included

Cack

(Rounder

Crow.

Going
1003) Carson was the first country
fiddler to record and his first 1923
ing

I

The Old Hen
to

Tommy Jarrell was
to

a

by

the

friend and mentor

many of us, and was probably the most

influential of the neo-traditional fiddlers of
the 1970s and '80s.

In his fiddling Jarrell's
strongest element was his subtle, rhythmic
bowing.
His favorite recording of his music was
Mountain 302, june Apple, with Kyle Creed,
banjo, Bobby Patterson, guitar, and Audine

Lineberry, string bass. If you want to focus
clearly on his fiddling, get his solo record
ing, County 756, Sail Away Ladies. It will
help you pick up his bowing style.
My personal favorites for listening are
his three recordings with Fred Cockerham
and Oscar Jenkins, which also include a
few of his best solos. Of these, I'd suggest
County 723, Back Home In the Blue Ridge.

County

is

currently re-editing the best of

these three into

a

CD/ cassette edition which

will then be my choice.
Altamont
Black
Stringband

(continued

on next page)

Music,

�(Rounder 0238) African- Americansundoubtedly played fiddle music soon after they
were brought here in the early 1600s. They
were the first to play banjo and fiddle to
gether in this country, probably also in the
same century. Their role in the develop
ment of both style and tunes has been very

important in southern fiddling, yet black
fiddlers have rarely been recorded, com
pared to Anglo Americans. Judging from
the few recordings that have been made,
there's a lot of variety amongst black fid
dlers. Two black Tennessee fiddlers are

anywhere. Backup is varied from tune to
tune and consists of piano, guitar, electric
guitar, and bowed cello. Notes on each
tune are spoken by collector/ fiddler R. P.
Christeson at the beginning of each track,
and feel intrusive. For those of you who can
read music, there is a companion booklet

"Old Time Fiddlers' Repertory 245 Tradi
tional Tunes, collected by R. P. Christeson.
(.University of Missouri Press, PO Box 7088,
Columbia, MO 65205-7088.)
Way Down South in Dixie.

(Morning Star

musicians on two discs outline the
diversity of the remarkable revitalization
of rural string-band music. Excellent notes
by the musicians and clever cover art by
producer/banjoist Ray Alden. Some of
these musicians are deserving of a Na
tional Endowment for the Arts National
Heritage Fellowship Award. Melvin Wine
at the Springhouse. (Marimac AHS
Wine has a wonderful repertoire of
unusual tunes from his native West Vir
ginia which he plays with subtlety and

Hannah
2)

vitality. He is the recipient of a 1991 Na
tional Heritage Fellowship Award. He uses
several tunings and is occasionally backed

tunes are interesting and unusual. They are

45005). Volume 3 of another regional col
lection, this one from Kentucky. There is
great variety of style and instrumentation
all the way from fiddle/ vocal solos to a sixpiece band. The other two volumes in this

on this tape by guitar and banjo. At age 82
he continues to play at gatherings, work

not difficult but their essence

set are also superb.

shops, and festivals, mostly

represented here, one accompanied by fretless banjo and the other by banjo and guitar.
Both banjo pickers are outstanding. The
is

elusive. The

part,

The Balfa

WHERE TO ORDER

Music.

Southern Culture Records, University of
Mississippi, University MS 39677.
Folklife Center, Library of Congress, Wash

at random with great
variation.
These
dynamic
gems suggest to
us some of the great black music that has
gone before. Available in all three formats.
to

seemingly

ington D. C. 20540.
County Sales, PO Box 91, Floyd VA 24091.
Rounder Records (Roundup), One Camp

Dennis McGee with Sady Courville and
Ernest Fruge. (Morning Star 45002) Before
the advent of accordions or the rural popu

Cambridge MA 02140.
Morning Star Records, 37
St.,

larity of guitars, fiddle duets with no other

Newton

backup were frequent musical fare. These
classic Cajun fiddle duets are amongst the

NJ

E.

Clinton

St.,

07860.

University of Missouri Press,
Columbia MO 65205-7088.
Swallow Records, Drawer

finest imaginable. They are strictly twenti
eth- century melodies and style, with many
subtle rhythmic variations and passionate

PO Box 7088,

10, Ville Platte

LA 70586.

Heritage Records,

Rt. 3 Box 278,

Galax VA

24333.

delivery.
(County 505) This was the most sedate,
close-knit old-time string band on 78 rpm
records. Fiddler Posey Rorer had a digni
fied yet loose country sound which was
well suited to Poole's songs which ranged
from traditional songs such as "Whitehouse
Blues" to popular songs of the 1920s. They

recorded mostly songs.
G.B. Grayson and Henry Whitter. (County
513) G.B. Grayson was a soulful player of
songs and tunes. He took his time and had

expressive, full-bodied tone. His play
ing was more raw and rugged than
Rorer' s more "backwoods." This LP in
cludes theoriginal recording of "Handsome
an

Molly."
Old Time Fiddlers' Repertory.

41

unusual

traditional quadrilles, breakdowns, waltzes,
schottisches, and other tunes recorded by
midwestern fiddlers in the 1940s and '50s.
The

styles of playing are definitely
midwestern, smooth and vigorous, some
times ornate, by some of the best fiddlers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

home

Brothers Play Traditional Cajun
LP 6011) This is the earli

(Swallow

est of the Balfa Brothers LP

a

revival of the music

(Rounder
1005) This group revolved around fiddler
Clayton McMichen and guitarist/ singer,
Riley Puckett. They recorded widely in the
and early 1930s. McMichen's
was
smooth, rhythmic,
fiddling
superb
and flowing, and was technically sophisti
cated. The group sound was loose, but not
late

1920s

ragged. Their tunes are quite accessible but
their essence is at times elusive. The
Highwoods Stringband was much influ
enced by this group.
As
was making up this list, I realized
that most of the fiddlers
was including
were no longer living. So, I've made up a
I

I

in their

home area of

southwestern Louisiana. The emphasis
on the fiddle
sometimes two-fiddle

is

sound and older songs, yet with a more
contemporary bowing style than, for in
stance, Dennis McGee. Dewey Balfa was a
National Heritage Fellowhsip recipient in
the early 1980s and

is

still one of the most

influential of old-time Cajun fiddlers.
788.) Davenport

Gid Tanner and his Skillet Tickers

recordings (late

1960s) and is my favorite. The Balfa Broth
ers were one of the first groups to bring
Cajun music to the city and also encourage

Clyde Davenport

Charlie Poole and the North Carolina Ram
blers.

in his

state.

tunes of Gribble, Lusk, &amp; York seem to roll
repetitively with minor variations. Those
of Frazier and Patterson bounce from part

Clydeoscope. (County

undoubtedly one

is

of the

finest old-time musicians of any time. His

fiddling is smooth, reedy, and soulful. His
repertoire of south central Kentucky tunes
is unusual and engaging. He is fully de
serving of a National Heritage Fellowhship
Award and hope he receives one soon.
I

Well, that's it.
expect
you will ask
"What about the Camp Creek Boys, Benny
Thomasson, Doc Roberts, Earl Johnson,
I

"

John Dykes, A1 Hopkins, Ed Haley, etc.
This list is, of course, a personal selection,

some suggestions to help you start a collec
tion of old-time fiddle music. I'd encourage
you to go well beyond the 17 albums listed

special section of fiddlers that are still ac

here. The Old -Time Herald has two previous
longer lists (November '89 and November

tive.

'90)

The Young Fogies.

(Heritage Records 056)

in

which, along with the record reviews
each issue will help you expand your

you can afford only two recordings, this
should be one of them. It documents most

library of recordings.

of the good and influential neo-traditional
fiddle bands of the 1960s through the early

is a co-founder of the New Lost
and a well-known performer
Ramblers,
City
and collector of old-time music.

If

1980s. Forty-one tracks by more than

a

hundred

Mike Seeger

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gruhn

Guitars Inc.

410

Broadway
Nashville, Tennessee 37203

615-256-2033

We buy used Guitars, Mandoins and Banjos.
Send SASE (or our inventory Sot of used and vintage
Written appraisals: Send dear front and bock view photos, serial
numbers, and description of any details or defects not apparent in
photos for each instrument to be appraised, plus $15 per

instrument.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�"A Wonderful

Time To Be In

Galax..."
by

Alice Gerrard with Mark Sanderford

hard

"It's

to

describe what kind

of world it was in Galax in the

late '60s and early '70s.

It

was

a
wonderful time to be in
was in college at the time and
began coming up to Galax in the summers,
and I found myself in a community of

Galax.

I

wonderful people and fabulous musicians.
I mean,
think about who was there at the
conventions: Wade Ward, Sonny Miller,
George Pegram, Uncle Norman Edmonds,
Albert Hash, Clark Kessinger, 'West Vir

ginia' Glenn Smith and Glen Smith from
Hillsville, Hubert Caldwell, Ivor Melton,
Talmadge Smith and Happy Smith.
can't remember half of them!

All Galax photos
Mark Sanderford

also among the first musicians

to

make

County

fiddler

that old Galax lilt, the
complex bowing, the unexpected twists
and turns of noting and phrasing that ex

emplified the old style in combination
with an intensity and drive that make him
an exciting musician to play with and listen

Norman

Edmonds on the cover of one of the Galax
Fiddler's Convention albums was taken by

to.

Mark has

Mark Sanderford
a

photographer.

is a

left-handed fiddler

His fine old-time

I

but there

was scary. And A.

L.

was so good,

W ood and the

in

music composition

lina; his parents were professional people.

His grandfather, Walter Seltz, was a
clawhammer banjo player from Mt. Gilead,

their prime, but still in it. Otis Burris, for
example. Back in 1967, that man could play
a fiddle.
When he was playing with The
it

degree

sity, and is currently a Ph.D. candidate in
biology at Wake Forest University. Mark is
originally from Morganton, North Caro

fid

were wonderful musicians everywhere
a
lot of them maybe getting near the end of

Mountain Ramblers.

a

from the University of Illinois, was a trum
pet player in college, has a Master's degree
in biology from Appalachian State Univer

and many of the photos in The First
Years
Forty
of The Old Fiddlers Convention by
Herman K. Williams are his.
Mark,

and

can think

I

of, one can hear

often uncredited, in books, on record jack
ets, and even T-shirts. A wonderful photo

Carroll

courtesy of

dling, more than anyone else's

recordings."
Mark Sanderford's photos of the Galax,
V irginia-area musicians have been printed,

of

by/

North Carolina. Mark never heard heard
him play and only became interested in

old-time music in high school when he
heard "Uncle Charlie" Higgins, Wade

it

Ward, and Dale Poe playing "Blackberry
Blossom" on a borrowed Galax Fiddlers

Smoky

Ridge Boys, and the Buck Mountain Band,
and the Whitetop Mountain Boys, and on

Convention album.

In

college

at

Davidson,

was great.
"I think
must have figured then that I
was in a unique place at a unique time, and

North Carolina, he met Mark Wingate, a
talented musician, who "showed me how
to string up the fiddle my Aunt Viola had

that may be why

given me. (At the time, she was under the
impression it was a violin, you understand
Mark [Wingate] could play a fiddle, and a
mandolin, and a guitar, and he had a whole
bunch of records, including some 78s of
some really good stuff. Well, he showed

and on.

It

I

everybody,

bu

1

I

took so many pictures of

look

1

those pictures now
took them.
In a way, it
at

I

Gillespie

and I'm so glad
was the end of an era because some of the

representatives

of that

generation of musi

cians who learned to play before records
and radios came in, and were part of that
line of musicians

going back

Lundy and Green Leonard.

to

Emmett

They were

Photo opposite: Norman Edmonds of Hillsville,
Va„ 1967

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gail

older musicians like Uncle Wade IWard]
and Uncle Charlie [Higgins] were the last
Mark Sanderford, 1991

dling reflects the many years he lived in
Grayson and Carroll Counties absorbing
the music of the area and learning from his
musical friends, especially from Norman
Edmonds of Hillsville, Virginia. In his fid

me how to work that fiddle.

I

strung

it

up backwards, left handed.
intentionally
didn't learn how to read music with the
I

wanted to learn how to play like all
great old-time musicians did
by
ear. Later, when I got to going to fiddlers
conventions
realized you could spot
thing.

I

the

I

(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddle players a mile
held
the bow right, and
mean,
away.
they
sounded
so
well, didn't want
they
pretty

classically-trained
1

I

sound like that!"
Freshmen weren't
Davidson College in
decided to walk
Mooresville Fiddlers
to

allowed

to

have cars

at

1967, so the two Marks
the

miles

10

to

the

Convention which was
held in the spring, one week after the Union
Grove Fiddlers Convention.
J. E. Mainer
was there, and Leake Caudill, and A. L.
Wood and the Smoky Ridge Boys, and many
others. The young Jimmy Edmonds was
there as well.

Mark, fascinated

by

the

fiddler, took pictures of him

eight-year-old
and talked with Jimmy's father, Harry
Edmonds, offering to send him copies of the
photos.
"I sent him some pictures and Frances
wrote me thanking me for the pictures and
inviting me up to visit and go to some of the
conventions around Galax. ended up go
I

ing to

a

lot of the local

conventions that year

including the Galax Convention.
I

Now here

was, new to this music and new

to

the

Virginia mountains and the Edmonds took
was part of the family. During
this time [19671, their house was kind of a

me in like

I

there'd al
meeting place for musicians
ways be someone coming in on Saturdays
sitting around
playing and talking about
music. And Harry would take me to see the
other musicians around the area, so most of
the pictures
have taken of these people,
owe to the Edmonds
without them, never
would have had the opportunity. just can't
say enough about Frances and Harry
Edmonds. They've done so much for me
personally and for old-time music. Besides
having children who turned out to be won
derful musicians
Patsy [Bowers], Barbara
and
[Poole],
Jimmy
they've done a lot to
like
me
from
outside of Galax to
help people
I

I

I

I

feel

at

home."

Harry Edmonds took Mark over to visit
legendary Galax fiddler, Charlie Higgins,
and he took photos and talked with him.
the

"That was in August, and by October he
was dead. He was 89 years old at that time.

believe, without a doubt,
my opinion
that Charlie Higgins was one of the greatest

In

1

Upper left: Otis Burris in the flatfoot competition
Galax Fiddlers Convention ca. 1970. Otis

at the

won many first place ribbons for his dancing as
well as for his fiddling.
Lower left: Buddy Pendleton

1970

at the

(holding fiddle)
Galax Fiddlers Convention.

ca.

�musicians
Whenever
time,

just start grinning, and thinking,
world did he figure out to do it

I

'How

ever play music of any kind.
hear one of his tunes for the first

to
I

in the

that way?' His relatives have told me since
about how much he loved his music, and

how he loved to flatfoot. He could play half
the night, get up and flatfoot awhile and
then sit down and play some more.
they'd
to playing and just play all night.
only

get

I

see him once, but
anything for that.
to

got

I

wouldn't

take

"But those early years in Galax just
wouldn't have been the same for me with
out Uncle Wade Ward.

Uncle Wade was

still playing at the conventions and he was
still playing well. He was also playing at the

Parsons Auction Company auctions on Sat
urdays with the Buck Mountain Band

Patsy, Barbara, and Frances
Since he played with the
was around him a lot. Uncle
Edmonds,
Wade was one of the warmest and most
wonderful people I've ever met. Anytime
think back on those days,
think of Uncle
Wade and his voice and his playing, and
[Jimmy,

Edmonds].

I

I

I

Mountain Band

The Buck

Edmonds,

at the

Galax Fiddlers Convention

ca.

1968. L-R: Wade Ward, Patsy

Barbara Edmonds, Frances Edmonds. Jimmy Edmonds

is

playing

the fiddle.

just how much fun it was to be around him.
"And Albert Hash
the integrity, and
and
talent
that
man represented.
character,

He wasn't just

great man, which think he
good man. You know, there
are people in this world you feel honored to
have known, and Albert Hash was one feel
that way about. There's a phrase they use in
was, he was

a

I

a

I

mountains: 'I'm proud to know you.'
known Albert Hash

the

W ell, I'm proud to have

and

Uncle

Wade

plenty of others

there

and, really,

are

feel the same way about

I

from around there
remarkable individu
als. Right now you can go up there and talk
to

some of these people for

half an hour

a

and get more of real lasting value out of it
than you'll get from any number of college

courses
"I

able

could mention.

I

envisioned that some day
to

I

would be

fiddle, but at that
just loved the music and loved them

time

I

and

all

get out and play

could

I

think

a

to

do was

take

to

when think about
pictures
the music heard but was unable to record!
(But was going to school and didn't have
or the money for it.
the equipment
knew
was in a time and a place
Anyway,
wanted to preserve, and I knew
was
surrounded by great people. There wasn't
of them. And

I

I

The Kimble Family,

Laurel Fork, Va., 1976. L-R: Stella Kimble, Taylor Kimble, Pearl Richardson,

Stella's sister.

I

I

I

I

I

could do for them in return for all

anything
the enjoyment
I

I

was getting out of being

around them, but thought if could take
pictures of them and give them the pictures,
I

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

maybe

I

could repay them for some of the
was having. also was

wonderful times
interested

in

I

I

seeing just how good
could get to be.

a

pho

tographer
"Another thing that really helped knit it
all together was that
had found some
had been looking
thing that apparently
I

I

1

for but had never found

anywhere else, and

senseof community. People knew
who they were and they knew their neigh
bors and 'most everybody else in town
and
that wasa

they had

a

feeling of their place in the
a feeling of
responsibility

community and
(continued

on next page)

�other. And they had a sense of
continuity
you know, a sense of being
of
the
part
history of the place. And you
some
of
that when you live there
two
get
houses down from where lived in Galax
was the house Crockett Ward and his wife
lived in. Down the road, within walking
for each

I

distance, was the two-room house Eck
Dunford built for himself and lived in
until he died. And you think about some
one like Jimmy Edmonds as a kid learning
to play 'Arkansas Traveller'
he could
think about the fact that he was playing the
same tune that his grandfather played,
and his great-grandfather, on back for

erations
of

it

continuity

to be

a

gen

wonderful sense
of
a tradition and
part

gives you

a

culture that isn't self-destructing as so
many other cultures are now. Everywhere
else the idea seems to be to destroy and
a

Albert Hash

ca.

1978

in his

workshop

in the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

basement of his home, Mouth of Wilson, Va.

to

change everything,

tear

it

down and

build something new
to 'progress'
to
move along, to find the next thing, and not
Wade

Left:

Frances
1967

Ward

&amp;

Edmonds,

or '68 near

Galax,

Va.

Right: Audine
Lineberry, ca. 1969 at
Galax Fiddlers Con
vention

Below

Rufus

left:

Quesin berry,
Woodlawn, Va.

only forget the past but destroy anything
that might remind you of it.
"You know, think the musicians from
I

southwestern Virginia
Below
Pegram
Fiddlers
1971

right:
at

the

George
Galax

Convention,

cause they get to be

communities and

musicians. There's

a
a
a

are really lucky, be
part of both their local

sort of

community of
feeling of community

among musicians, too. Well, it's more like
a
which is why,
feeling of family.
the
Galax
Fiddlers
Convention
suppose,
feels
much
so
like
a
always
family reunion.
You know, you get to see people again that
you haven't seen in a year, and play the
same old tunes.
And when someone you
are used to

seeing and hearing every year
has died, well, the musicians feel that.
That's why never could understand people
I

who wouldn't come back
(continued

on page 30)

to

a

convention

I

�Kitty Snow

ca.

1970, Galax, Va.

Thornton Spencer (fiddle), and Flurry Dow (banjo), Spencer's Store, Mt. Rogers, Va.,

Below: Charlie Higgins, Fairview, Va., 1967

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Stella

Right:

Kimble,

Below:

ca. 1971

Corbett

Stamper,
Whitetop,
ca.

1980

Va.,

ca.

1979

�'Sally Ann,' and it wasn't bad!
don't know who
the fellow was. But that's the
kind of place it was
every
To this day

I

body played something, and
even the people who didn't
play anymore,

used to play
was a very mu

something!
sical community.
It

is, really.

And

it

still

There's such younger

around
Hooven, Richard

players

as

Greg
Bowman,

and James Burris
really great
not to mention the
players.

older

ones

[Rutherford].
know.
on

like
But

Enoch
I

don't

I'm afraid from here

people are just going

to

watch television. Everything
is a spectator event nowadays.
Back then you'd sit down on
the front porch and try to pick

something.
"I know that

these pic
tures mean more to me than
they will to anybody else, be
cause I can still hear the voices
all

and the music from those days.
I'd really like, someday, to
get them together in a book,
and write down what every

was
saying and
you know, let the ones
that are alive speak for them
selves and fill in what
can

body

doing

I

remember, and what every
one else can remember about
the ones who have passed on."

In 1972 Mark
moved to
Galax where he got a job as a
teacher in the public schools.

He took

a lot
of pleasure in
"becoming a part of the com
munity, and giving something
back to the community"
through teaching the children.

He stayed
Charlie Higgins, Fairview, Va., 1967

because they didn't like the judging! What's
that got to do with anything?
"Back when first got to Galax, it seemed
I

like

in the county could play an
remember going to one auc
tion sale and this fellow was standing
there
he had just walked over from across

everybody

instrument.

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the street and was

watching the sale going

in the

area until

re

cently, when he left to pursue
his Ph.D. degree.
When he has time, he
comes back to visit and play music with his
friends he wants to move back to south

on, and Wade Ward handed him his fiddle
and said, 'Here, play us a tune.' And the

western Virginia eventually. "The
communities and the culture of southwest

guy said, 'I don't know what to play.'
Uncle Wade told him, 'well, play Sally
Ann
there's not a man alive that can't
play Sally Ann.' So the fellow played

Virginia may be homogenized out of exist
ence eventually, but until the feeling of
community is gone, want to come back and
enjoy it while it lasts."
I

�Ask Uncle Harold

continue with the fascinating sub
ject of throat singing from the last

To
OTH, here

is further, and, Uncle Harold
feels, definitive information. Perhaps K.B.,
who originally inquired about the origin of
"dappling," as it's called here, will follow

up on some of these leads. Dr. Charles
Wolfe says that he recorded an interview

with Dick Burnett of Burnett

Rutherford,
in the early 1970s.
In that interview Dick
Burnett talked about the noises he makes
on the

&amp;

recording of "Ladies On the Steam

boat," and which were referred to
last Uncle Harold column.

According

to

Wolfe,

in

the

Burnett told him

that he learned the technique, "dappling,"
from a Mississippi Choctaw Indian in about

1915 while they were in a traveling medi
cine show. Burnett took the technique a

step further by dappling and at the same
time

keeping up

a

rhythm on the banjo.

Burnett showed Charles how

it

was done

humming and manipulating his adam's

by

apple with his index finger. Burnett also
told Wolfe that when he was younger he
used to sing the first verse of the song "A
Flower From the Fields of Alabam"'
then

would "dapple" the second verse. Ac
cording to him he recorded this version of
the song (probably for Gennett Records),
although they never released it. The pro
ducer evidently thought

it

was too strange

and when he questioned Burnett about the
"dappling," Burnett told him, "that's my
humanaphone." Sections of this interview
(ca. 1974) were

published

of Old Time Music out of
G. B. of

in an

early issue

England.

Dania, Fla., writes: "I'm looking

description of the dance or play party
game 'Twistification'. There's a brief de
scription in Joyce Cauthen's With Fiddleand
for

a

Well-Rosined

Bow on page 209, but it's not
I've
seen the dance mentioned in
complete.
several other books, but no details."

Uncle Harold went straight to Joyce
Cauthen for clarification and details. Her
impression of "Twistification" is that it's

Mitchell

B. Garrett (University of Alabama
Press). His description of "Twistification"
is in part: ".
boy swinging girl and vice
first
on
one
arm and then the other."
versa,
Do any readers have other (or more de
tailed) information about "Twistification?"
Let your uncle know.

Clemmons, N.C. has written Uncle

J.B. of

Harold

a

letter about banjos with four

spot a misplaced modifier with the best of
them.)
Question #1 .Where might find books
or plans on traditional instrument construc
I

tion?
The first thought that occurs to me is that
to our instrument expert

you could write

Smakula in care of the Old-Time Herald.
addition to this the Elderly Instruments

Bob
In

folks put out a dandy catalogue listing all
kinds of literature on traditional instru
ment construction. Their address is 11 00 N

Washington,

#2.

Question

heads available

Lansing MI,

Are
to fit

there tone rings or
rims constructed

to

Again, I suggest you write to Bob. An
other Bob and banjo expert, Bob Carlin,who
knows a lot about this very subject, sug
gests that you write the Stewart McDonald
Company.
Question

#3. Did folks make smaller
more portable banjos for ease of traveling?
Sort of, says Bob Carlin. He says that

people did indeed make smaller banjos,
for traveling purposes. Smaller
banjos were made because they sounded in
a
higher register an octave or whatever
above standard banjo tuning. And, of
but not

course, there were "ladies' banjos," con
structed for smaller hands.
Question #4. J.B. would like to know the

age and origin of his old open-back banjo,
with "The Windsor 'POPULAR' Model, A.
O.

Windsor, Maker, Birimingham" on the

Horse and Buggy Days

(continued

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

14210,

less than the standard 11" diameter?

name plate.

Hatchet Creek, by

PO Box

48901

nothing more than a Grand Right and Left.
She got her information from a book called
on

sepa

rate questions. (The letter has four separate
questions, not banjos. Uncle Harold can

You can start by contacting Jim Bollman
on page 56)

�Issues

Voices
by

In

Old-Time Music

From

the

Villages

Paul Tyler

On May
and 18, 1991, a group of folklorists, performers, promoters, and others interested in and associated with the urban folk revival of the 1950s
and '60s met on the campus of Indiana University in Bloomington, Indiana for two days of lectures and panel discussions. The symposium was
sponsored by Indiana University's Folklore Institute and was held in honor of Richard Reuss, a recently deceased alumnus of the Indiana University
Folklore department who had a special interest in the folk revival. The event was unusual and heartening both in its focus and in its inclusion of live
17

music

in the evenings as part of its official
program.
Over the next couple of issues we will be publishing an article or two based on John Cohen's (of New Lost City Ramblers fame) keynote address
at this conference. John's talk, the one which most pertained to traditional music, was
fascinating, informative, and touched on a number of issues
associated with old-time music.

to

With its historical perspective on the whole issue of the "revivalist" movement the OTH feels that these exerpts will be of interest, and help readers
how the movement bears very directly on the present old-time music community.
We begin the series with an overview of the conference by Paul Tyler, a folklorist, musician, and caller
Linda Higginbotham and
from Chicago.

better understand

Alice Gerrard

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

are

some stimulating springtime

Herecomments

from the pen of Israel

G.

Young: "Reverend Gary Davis and his side
kick Barry Kornfeld, made a hit at Boston's

Golden Vanity recently. Despite all the re
newed interest in the Reverend, no LP of
his work is available today. A lucky few
can hear the tapes Fred Gerlach has been

making.
"Joe Hickerson, Indiana U's embattled
scholar, writes that folk music has reached
the Ivory T ower and can be heard live a t the
Quiet Answer Coffee Shop in Bloomington,
on

week-ends.

"Folksinging seems to be moving from
living room concert hall and hootenanny to the Coffee House and Night
Club. ..But it is getting difficult to hear
folksinging for fun today, as anyone ca
pable of leading a group finds it almost
impossible to resist the commercial possi
the

bilities folksinging offers now.
till the sun

I

can't wait

shines on Washington Square

when Roger Sprung will again lead his
."
banjo-laden troops through the park.
As you may have already guessed, these
words were written many years ago. They
appeared in the column "Frets and Frails"
in

Sing

Out!

as

the

New York-based

�folksong magazine began its 10th year of
publication in 1960.
Before he left for Sweden, his home for
the last 18 years,

Izzy Young was

a

keen

the

traditional artists they learned from,

but also tried to bring some degree of fame
and fortune to their teachers. While less

idealistic, groups like the Limeliters and
their ilk were much more commercially
successful and brought traditional music
to a much broader audience.
Record producer and writer Dave

observer of the personalities, performances,
and politics that percolated through the
Greenwich Village folk scene of the late
fifties and early sixties. As proprietor of the
Folklore Center
a most
important Village
hangout and as a concert promoter, he
was also an influential force on the urban
folk music revival that gained much of its
momentum from what was happening

Samuelson, formerly of Evanston, Illinois,
summarized the artistic quandary repre
sented by these two key groups. He
emphasized that popular renditions and
traditional versions of folksongs, though

Bleecker Streets and

stylistically different, are both valid musi-

around MacDougaland

Washington Square. Pop music histori
ans usually remember Izzy as the promoter
in

responsible

for Bob

Dylan's first appear

concert (as opposed to a coffee
house) stage. It was a box office flop.
ance on

a

Izzy Young's introduction to things folk
was through Margot Mayo's American
Square Dance Group in New Y ork City back
in the 40s and 50s. Now busy publishing a
Swedish folklore magazine and calling onenight stands in Sweden, Izzy took time off
for a return to the United States this past

spring

to take part in

ing of folk music

a spectacular gather
luminaries includ ing both

cal

(Samuelson

expressions.

and

conference organizer Ron Cohen are cur
rently arranging a massive reissue on the
Bear Family label of the Almanac Singers,
the Weavers, and other long out-of-print
recordings of the World War II era.) OTH
readers doubtless have their own prefer
ences. And, like this reporter, most would
have been more in tune with John Cohen's
memoir of how a big-city dweller discov
ered traditional music makers tucked away
in the rural nooks and crannies of America,
and

less

impressed

by

the

aggrandize

ments and profit margins realized by Dr.

those who stood before the spotlights and
those who worked behind the scenes. Spon
sored by the Indiana University Folklore
Institute, the Richard Reuss Memorial Folk

Gottlieb.

Music conference brought to the fore a num
ber of the artistic controversies and
ideological debates that enlivened the

tional artists. Popular performers, such as

folksong revival during the Eisenhower and
Kennedy eras. As many of the conference's
formal presentations assumed the character
of personal stories, it became clear that the
values and issues that shaped the folk music
world back in its supposed heyday are still
close to the hearts of many.
Epitomizing one major controversy was,

Caught up in this issue are the tougher
questions of the ownership of songs from
oral tradition and the treatment of tradi
the Kingston T rio, readily copyrighted and
received royalties on their arrangements
of traditional material. No one, not even
the traditional singers from whom the
songs were collected, could legally own
the songs. But the issue was muddied
when a group made a hit, and conse

the one hand, Lou Gottlieb of the
Limeliters, the ultimate of populizers. On

money, with a recording of
known traditional source.
Joe Hickerson, current head of the
Archive of Folk Culture at the Library of
Congress, illustrated the most famous case

the other hand, there was John Cohen of the

of this type by

on

New Lost City Ramblers,

group that regu
rural singers
left
the
to
seek
out
larly
cjty
and musicians who knew old songs and
a

tunes. These so-called "purists" not only
strove to stay close to the spirit and style of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

quently
a

a

lot of

song from

a

showing how "Tom Dula"
ballad from Frank Proffitt's family
traveled by
tradition in North Carolina
Frank
Warner to
of
collector
way
song
a

Washington. There
(continued

it

was warmly received

on next page)

�song movement led by the Almanac Sing

'30sand '40s. America's pervasive
Marxophobia has made Reuss' landmark
ers in the

work unpublishable for the last two de
cades, and has inhibited any honest

appraisal of the role of the Communist
Party in the labor
or

movement

in

particular

American cultural life in general.
At the Reuss conference Irwin Silber,

a

former editor of Sing Out! and its precur
sor, the Party-sponsored People's Songs, was
a compelling apologist for the aims that led

instru

the CP to embrace folk music as an

ment

social justice and progressive
Bernie
Asbell, the People's Songs'
politics.
for

Chicago representative during the Henry
Wallace presidential campaign of 1 948, and
David Dunaway, Pete Seeger'sbiographer,
both called for a critical reevaluation of the
tactics and doctrines employed during the
Party's highwater

days and the ensuing

dark night of McCarthyism.

Much more happened during those two

May days in Bloomington than can be re
counted here. John Pankake of Minneapolis,

founding editor of the sagacious fanzine,
The Little Sandy Review, and Old Town
School of Folk Music co-founder Frank
Hamilton were among those who reported
on local music scenes in the provinces out
side of Greenwich Village. Mimi Farina,
Bob

Gibson, Dick Weissman, and Pat Sky

gave personal accounts of their lives and
times as performers and songwriters. Os
car Brand sang

a

Chandler gave

a

how

a

portrait of Leadbelly. Len
most moving account of

conservatory-trained musician from

the urban north found his

calling

as

a

song

writer while participating in civil rights
marches in the south. Barry Hansen, a.k.a.
Dr.

Demento (who has

lore), donned

an

top hat and

M.A.

in

Folk

tails to host

a

that featured

a

Friday night Hootenanny
fine set by Cohen joined by Bloomington's
Brad Leftwich, Linda Higginbotham, and
by folk song enthusiasts

federal

gov

he had no legal claim to the song, was hotly

ernment, centered around impresario Alan
Lomax, then head of the Folk Song Archive

debated once again at the Bloomington
conference. The question was also raised as

Library of Congress. The song next
made its way to Greenwich Village where
it was performed in a
bluegrass version by

had since his arrangement was substan
tially borrowed by the Kingston Trio.

in the

at the

Roger Sprung and friends in the weekly
Washington Square jam sessions. Their dis
tinctive bluegrass rendition was picked up

to

what claim Roger Sprung might have

Bob Herring. Izzy Young got back to his
roots by calling a Saturday night dance that

featured

variety of figures from the so-

a

called Kentucky RunningSet. Fiddlingwas
supplied by John Bealle and Bert Feintuch,
while Neil Rosenberg added some tasteful

three-finger banjo licks, and Joe Hickerson
and Rich Remsburg sat in on guitar.
The whole history of the American folk

and adapted by the Kingston Trio, whose
recording of "Tom Dooley" reached the

Another source of contention resurrected
at the conference was the role politics played
in the ascent of the folk music revival. This
issue was the concern of the late Richard
Reuss, whose 1971 doctoral dissertation,

top of the pop charts in 1958. The question
whether Frank Proffi tt should have been

American Folklore and Left-Wing Politics, ex
plored the involvement of the Left and the

sic Conference.

Communist Party with

(continued

of

compensated

as the

source, even though

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the folk and

protest

music revival will be more thoroughly

documented

as

a

result of Wasn't that

Time? The Richard Reus

publish the

s

Memorial Folk

Plans are being

proceedings

on page 56)

of the

a

Mu

made

to

conference,

�Workshop

A

Gathering

by Bob

Smakula

instruments are the main

Handmade

stay of old-time musicians. From our
Martin guitars to our Kyle Creed banjos we

couldn't have fun without them. This past
June 27-30, one of the largest gatherings of
stringed instrument makers and repair
persons was held in Easton, Pennsylvania.
Sponsored by The Association of String
Instrument Artisans (ASIA), it was a fourday event for luthiers from around the
world. Participants were able to learn and
share information in lectures and in the
exhibit hall. The lecture hall featured speak
ers

prominent

in

field

the

and

luthiery
many
repair people spoke
about their work
among them Bob Tay
lor of Taylor Guitars, who spoke on using
computer operated milling machines to
speed up guitar making and ensure uni
of
formity; John Hall, president
Rickenbacker Guitars, who has a keen in
makers

and

terest in EPA regulations related

to

Luthiers

of

finishing

systems for musical instruments, shared
his latest findings with us. All instrument

makers will be affected by environmental
laws. We need to change gracefully to newer

products and techniques that will not harm
the environment and which will ultimately
produce better instruments.
The Memorial Gymnasium at Lafayette
College was the exhibit hall where over 50
booths were set up. Piles of spruce and
rosewood, mother of pearl blanks for in
lays, sandpaper (I get very excited about

unrecognizable floral blobs that decorate
many instruments.
Eric Schoenberg, of Schoenberg Guitars,
exhibited his wares. Eric, a master guitar
ist, collaborated with the Martin Guitar

Company

to

produce the "Schoenberg So

loist." These guitars are based on the 1924
to 1932 Martin OM series, and their mate

selected by Eric. The
T. J. Thompson.
The rest of the construction is done by
rials are especially

tops are voiced by luthier
Martin Guitars.
For you

old-time musicians living on the

edge, try out an electric five-string violin
made by the Ithaca Guitarworks. Eric Aceto
has

designed

a

very practical electric violin

that sounds and feels right. Dan Hoffman
is the fretted instrument specialist at Ithaca

Guitarworks. Besides building his favorite
ten-stringed mandolins, he is using fresh
ideas in guitar building.
The most interesting instrument for oldtime musicians was the Bart Reiter 12- inch
banjo. Bart has had plenty of inquiries about
banjos with a 1 2-inch rim. Finally, last win
ter he

finished the prototype.

you read this, they should be
Banjo dealers

everywhere.

Accessory manufactur
ers were also present.
Fishman T ransducers displayed their electric

pickups for guitars and
banjos. Fishman now of

new types of sandpaper), and rows and
rows of the finest, modern stringed instru
ments available were on display. Marty
Lanham of Nashville Guitars, exhibited a

fers an acoustic blender, a
device that is mounted in
a guitar and combines
sig

000-size steel-string flat top guitar. It was
everything in, a guitar and more. The
peghead ornament featured multi-colored
scrimshaw mallard ducks made of old pi
ano keys
a nice
diversion from the

and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

nals of both

a
microphone
transducer
The newest competitor
a

in the

accessory market

is

the Cipriani Bridge System.

Tom Cipriani

is a

serious

time
Reiter

By the
at Bart

acoustic guitar player who has never been
satisfied with the intonation of the stan
dard guitar. His device is a saddle for
acoustic guitars that is fully adjustable for
intonation. My first reaction was that the
saddle would have no positive effect and
might only change the tone in a negative
way, but after playing T om Cipriani's Guild
guitar quickly changed my mind.
We all know that there are thousands of
I

people with varying degrees of skill doing
work on musical instruments. To help stan
dardize their skill levels, ASIA and
'91 sponsored the first luthier's
written test designed to tell if you
really do work on instruments. Though I
don't think the luthier's exam has had a
dramatic effect on the instrument industry,
it is an important
step in creating a certified
luthier's program. Did take the test? You

Symposium
exam

a

I

bet! Did

I

pass? Of course!

sound like all work and no
play for us fret geeks? Nah
Symposium
'91 also sponsored the second Bart Reiter Me
morial String Changing Contest. The
So does this

is to change the strings on a stan
dard six- string guitar as fast as possible. A
new record was set at two minutes, fifty-five
(continued on page 56)

challenge

�Stories

Tommy Jarrell's Family
1830-1925
Part

II

by

Nancy Dols Neithammer

[There are many sto
ries like the ones be
low

each

with

its

characters

and

regioal flavors.

We

own

feel certai that any
one who has spent
time with old master

musicians,

in

any

part of the country,
has heard similar sto
ries

stories

to be

re

membered, cherished,
and
on.
passed
Jarrell
the

"oral

ans."

of

histori

Ray

these

was

best

Alden

Tommy

among

courtesy

ed.J

First Automobiles, Telephones
[Things] started changing when the automobile began to come
know the first automobile lever saw, by
around, y'know. 1916]
the
rode
to
fair
down
here in it, me an' Julie an' Maggie an'
gosh,
1

I

I

my daddy. He brought us to the fair down here at Mt. Airy. We
got in that car, he called a taxi, y'know, from Mt. Airy, it's a damn
T-model Ford. ILaughs] We had that thing loaded down pretty

good, too, 'cause my daddy was

a

big man.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

An' we come down

to the fair in that thing.
never will forget how that thing
looked comin' up the road.
could see it, could see it for about a
quarter of a mile a-comin', y'know. An' if hadn't a-knowed what
it was, it'd scared me to death.
wasn't but 'bout twelve, fourteen

here

I

I

I

I

I

guess, somewhere along there. Why

I'd have run
have been by myself, hadn't have never knowed nothin'
about no automobile, seen that thing comin' up the road like that.
I'd have took off to the woods.

years old then,
if I'd

I

�We'd been readin' about it, y'know, an' hearin' about the auto
mobile an' everything. Never had saw one. [NDN: Did you get a
newspaper?] Yeah. An' then they had some telephones up there
then, y'know. Ol' man Austin Snow down there where my daddy
an' him run

a store
together, they had a telephone, y'know. [NDN:
When did you first get telephones?] Well, that happened 'long
about nineteen-ten, twelve, somewhere along there, y'know.
don't believe we had no telephones all 'round up there when that

I

Allen Brothers' trial happened over at Hills ville [in
1912]. Don' t believe there was any telephones through that country
Yeah. A lotta water poured over
then, they come later than that
the dam since then, ain't they?

[shootou

t

at the

Well, next day we had us a big poker game out down the old
house where my folks, where we'd moved from. An', had plenty
of liquor, y'know.
don't know what the money loaned Uncle
Charlie, he didn't know a damn thing about playin' poker an' he'd
just throw it in there, y'know. I'd give him some more. Didn't keep
no account of it. Didn't care.
Well, they'sa-gonna have a dance down thereat FrazierGolding's
that night, Claude's uncle. So told Dave [Jarrell, Uncle Charlie's
son], says, "Dave," I says, "you an' Claude come on down there."
says, "I'm goin' down here by Cliff Stewart's store an' get me
somethin' to eat." Fred went with Dave an' Uncle Charlie on back
out there to the house. said, "Claude, come on down there [to the
dance]." "No," he says, "What the hell'd want to go down there?"
He says, "There won' t be no girls down there but my first cousins
what'd want to be a-dancin' with them for?" said, "Well, come
on, we'll all have a good time." No, he didn't believe he'd come.
Claude was the cause of it- they didn't want Dave t'take the
banjo down there, y'know. All of us drunk, that's what was the
matter with the whole business. Claude an' Uncle Charlie didn't
want to go, an' they didn't want Dave to take the banjo down there.
I

I

I

I

I

I

I

Learning To Make Whiskey
Tommy learned

to make

ivhiskey

by

matching and helping his father's

brother, Charlie Jarrell.

Daddy, when was a-growin' up, didn't make no whiskey much,
went out to Oregon out yonder. [Ben Jarrell went to Oregon
in 1918 to make whiskey, and
spent three years there, including a
and
a
half
in
was
around,
year
jail.]
helped Uncle Charlie a whole
lot, carryin' meal an' stuff t'the place, y'know, an' around with his
boys. An' just watched him, an' mean' Dave, one of his boys, made
I

til he

I

I

ever made. We made a pretty good turnout, too.
never
My daddy
taught me that. taught him how to make sugar
the first

whiskey

I

I

I

I

think that's what

it started over, over the
banjo.
Fred was after Dave to take the banjo an' go down there, y'know,
an' him an' Uncle Charlie got into it, Fred an' Uncle Charlie. An'
I

Uncle Charlie

hit Fred

over the head with

a

double-barrelled

shotgun. The little Joyce boy come runnin' down to the store where
was a-eatin' me some sardines, pork an' beans, or somethin'

whiskey.

1

In

Tight With Uncle Charlie
1920 Tommy made a six-month trip to South Dakota

another.
to

make whiskey

for Wiley Ferris, an ex-North Carolinian there who was dissatisfied with
the local supply. Soon after Tommy returned from this trip, he
got into a
serious fight with his Uncle Charlie.

night with Uncle Charlie, me an' Fred [Jarrell,
Tommy's younger brother], the night that my daddy an' all of 'em
moved to M t. Airy down here. We'd had a little trouble once before,
he was a'gonna jump on a third cousin of mine, Uncle Charlie was,
We stayed

all

him an' Aaron McKinney, an'

told him,
said, "By god now, if
Aaron an' IGrover?] want to fight, all right, Uncle Charlie, but you
can just stand back an' let 'em alone." Well, he didn't like that,
y'know. But, ,we was friendly an' all like that. had a bunch of
whiskey up there that me an' Claude [Golding] had made, y'know,
I

I

I

an'

I

didn't want

to go off an'

leave

it

up there. So, we stayed all night

with Uncle Charlie.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

He says,

"Tommy, you better go up yonder." Says,
"Uncle Charlie's done hit Fred over the head with a shotgun."
Well, Iwenton up there. Pretty drunk. Well, Claude Golding an'
Dave Jarrell had Fred out there in the yard, a-holdin' him Iback],

when

got up there.
just went on, by gosh, to the damn door up
there, y'know, an' turned the damn knob of the door an' was gonna
go in an', hell, Uncle Charlie's didn't un-[latch], he had a thumb
latch.

I

I

I

don't know whether he'd seen me a-comin'
he was in there. An' hell,

or

what

was just mad,
anyhow,
an' drunk too. just shoved the door like that an' busted the thumb
latch off of it, y'know, an' went on in.

happened.

But

I

I

An' the next thing

I

knowed,

me over the head right there.

I

come

to,

An' when

I

I

recollect somebody hit
come to myself I had

Uncle Charlie down with his head nearly in the fire. Hittin' him
with a damn 38 pistol. Tryin' to hit his head. Here come Dave, an'
(continued

on next page)

�Claude, an' Fred, an' Aunt Susan, all come in there an' got ahold of
me an' got me off of him, y'know. He stepped from behind the door
there when
pushed the door open, he was standin' there an'

I

I

reckon he had his knife in his hand an' he hit me right up there in the
top of the head
you can feel a little sunk place right there now. An'
he come right down over my ear right there an' then right across the
side of my neck right there, got a hell of a gash in there. Ain't no
scar there now, but there used to be.
Well, didn't know was cut. Uncle Charlie hid. I set down in
I

I

I

Charlie Joyce's lap, he was settin' in a chair. An' he said, "Good god
almighty," said, "Tommy, your neck's cut." Well, took my hand
an' reached up there just like that, y'know, an' there was all blood,
just full of blood when it come out. Boy, you talk about gettin' mad,
I

I'm that mad then, sure

enough.

I

went to huntin' for him.

I

couldn't

find him.
Well, got started an' got out away from the house about a
hundred or a hundred an' fifty yards an' the further got away from
the house the madder
I'll kill him."
got. said, "I'll just go back
An' went back an' searched that house from one end to the other
I

I

I

I

I

never did find him. An' never thought, they had a little bitty
ol' room, it was just big enough to have a phone in, an' somebody
an'

standin'
I

I

1

in

found out later on that's where he was at, an'
look in that, y'know. Now I'm glad
didn't,

there. An'

never thought

to

I

I

y'know.
Well, next day, he went an' took out a whole bunch of warrants
Me for breakin' an' enterin' his house, an'
don't
know what all. think they had about three or four apiece for us.
for me an' Fred.

I

1

Well, ol' man Tom Golding, Claude's daddy, was the cause of it
though, 'cause Fate Scott told me he was there next mornin' when

Tom come down there an' told Uncle Charlie, "See, if you
don't take out a warrant for them damn boys," says, "I'm goin'
t'take out one for you." That's what Fate Scott told me that Tom
ol' man

Golding told Uncle Charlie.
Well, that night

I

went on down there

to

Frazier Golding's an'

played the fiddle, y'know. An' that gash opened, an' the blood run
all down my back, back here on my clothes an' everythin'. Well,
Frank Haynes an' Dave
Dave went on t'the dance down there
they kept on

at

me, by gosh, to go over there an' get Miss Norman

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

sew that gash up in my neck there. "Why," said, "Hell, it'll be
they just kept on, an' finally went with 'em on over
there to Miss Norman's, widow woman. An' she didn't have no
to

I

all right." An'

I

chimney on her lamp. Just had a lamp, didn't have no chimney on
it, an' y'know, it didn' t make much of a light, an' she was pretty old,
too. Well, she took her dang needle an' a thread an' she took two
stitches in my neck right there. Well, it was awful sore.
When we left next day, found out he'd gone take out them
warrants, well, we made a dive for Virginia, y'know. Well, we
went up there an' stayed all night with Julie or Maggie, one, that
night. Next day, it got to hurtin' me so that went to Dr. Fulk, lived
I

there in Lambsburg. He said, "Who sewed that up?"
said, "Ol'
Miss Norman." He said, "Well, she done a good job, but," said,
"she sort of puckered it,"
two knots, y'know, had started on it
"but," he says, "I ain't gonna bust them stitches out." Says, "There'll
be two knots on there for a while but they'll eventually go away."
Well, they did. You don't see no sign of no knots there now. You
I

might could, if you look right close you might see a little of the scar,
don't think so. He said, "Now, let me tell you somethin'." He
said, "If that there knife had a-went ju-u-st a fraction of a inch
but

I

further," said, "then all the doctors in the world been standin' right
there couldn't have done nothin' for you." Said, "It'd cut that
jugular vein right there an' you'd a-bled to death." Says, "I'll tell
you what you do now til that gets well," says, "you be awful
careful. Don't you jump no ditches an' don't you fall down." Said,
"You be careful an' walk around right easy." He says, "Cause that
thing's liable to bust loose just any time."
Well, we dodged around,
an' Wes McCraw

I

don't know, four, five, or six months,
warrants, and Adkin

an' John had part of the

Johnson had the other part. An' they was Republicans. Well, Bert
Hutchins run a store up there an' Daddy traded with him, we all
traded with him, an' Daddy got Bert to talk to Adkin Johnson to get
the warrants took up. John an' Wes, by god, they left, 'cause we
was good friends, me an' them was. 'Course, Daddy an' their
daddy had that terrible fight that time, y'know, Bonus McCraw an'
my daddy. That was John an' Wes' daddy. Well, John an' Wes, one
of 'em was a-workin' in Ohio, an' the other'n was a-workin' in
West Virginia, an' one of 'em was constable an' the other'n was

a

�deputy sheriff. Well, they took them damn warrants with 'em an'
left here, y'know. An' the ones that Adkin Johnson had, Daddy got
Bert Hutchins, talked to him to get the warrants, an' they had to see
ol' man [Newt Boyles?], an' the whole business cost fourteen
dollars an' somethin', to get 'em all took up, y'know, an' evervthin'.
Daddy tried

to

get me to give up, me an' Fred give up an' stand

Tommy an' give up," said, "I'll get a damn
Get
said, "No, you won't get us out of
good lawyer.
you out."
that." I said, "I busted in his door." I couldn't turn it an' busted in,
a

trial, says, "Go on,

I

I

recollect that. When

it wasn't open,
just give it a shove, like that,
was
stout
then.
I
said, "We've all been a-makin'
y'know.
pretty
there
an'
liquor up
every thin', an'," I said, "he took out warrants for
us an', by god, I'll take out some for him an' we'll all go to the damn
I

I

I

said, "Hell no, ain't a-gonna give up." So we got
settled for fourteen dollars an' somethin'.
[NDN: Did you ever get to be friends with Uncle Charlie again
after that?] Oh yeah, yeah. He stayed overnight with me after that.
When lived down at the Bunker place. think after me an' Nina
married we went to see him.

penitentiary."

I

I

it all

I

I

[NDN: And did Uncle Charlie ever apologize or anything?] No,
never was mentioned. Uncle Charlie, well, he was a good fellow
when he was sober, but he was mean as the devil when he was adrinkin'. What Daddy said was that Charlie always has been mean
it

when he was a-drinkin'. But
would have saw my wife, y'know,
as hell

out for the best,

I

at

last.

Visit

to

reckon,

if

that hadn't happened, never
worked out. It all worked

I

there, old Aunt Creesie Ward, was his sister. An' ol' man Frank an'
her would talk about brother Zack bein' such a good fiddler. An'
I'd heard other people say so, so decided while was
up there that
close to him I'd go up there an' hear him play some.
wanted to
I

I

learn

to play "Billy in the Lowground" an' "Leather Britches."
asked my brother-in-law, Charlie Lyons, said, "Charlie, you
know where ol' man Zack Payne lives?" He said, -Yeah." "Well,"
says, "How about goin' with me up there?"
says, "I want to get
I

fiddle some for me." He says, "Ain't a bit of use in
"He
won't play." He said, "I been up there an' tried
goin', says,
best
'im
my
t'get
to'play an'," said, "he won't play." "Well," says,
"I
I'm
guess
gonna go try 'im anyhow." "Well," he says, "there an't
'im to play the
"

I

bit of use, but I'll go with you up there."
So me an' him an' Fred went up there- Fred was with us,
my
brother Fred. Ol' Zack, he was out there grazin' his horse, he was

I

had

I

1

I

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tune."

it in there, it'd come
unglued back here
neck, y'know, an' the fingerboard was layin' right down on
the fiddle, it would've been layin' on it, but he had 'im a pine
splinter, a pine stick, stuck under the fingerboard to hold it up off
the fiddle. An' he had 'im a piece of copper down on the neck about

that far. Well, there where he'd been a-notin' on that copper, it
a new
penny, y'know. It told on him, y'know.
"Aw," he says, "I don't never fool with that thing no more," says,

looked just like

it

it

tuned [GDAE].

I

I

Well, he wanted me t'play a tune or two first. Well, run the [G]
string up [to A] an' played "Sally Ann" or somethin', somethin'
I love
t'play. An' gave it t'him, an' by gosh he tuned it an' he
I

I

I

played.
Well, he played "Billy in the Lowground" and he played "Leather
Britches." Then he played "Devil in the Strawstack." An' he

changed his fiddle a little bit an' he played "Flatwoods" [GDAD
tuning]. That was the last tune he played, an' learned "Devil in the
Strawstack" an' "Flatwoods."
never did learn "Billy in the
nor
"Leather
Britches," an' I don't know 'em til
Lowground"
I

today.
Soon as he got them played, well, we didn't stay around long, we
left. But had them two tunes in my head. I got home,
got down
I

I

there t'my sister's, played 'em. 'Course didn't play 'em good to
start with, but I had 'em there, an' got so could play 'em pretty
I

I

I

I

good. He was a big man, Zack Payne was. guess he'd weighed
over 200 pounds when saw 'im. He was six foot tall or better
guess. [NDN: Did you ever get to hear him play again?] Uh-uh.
I

1

How Tommy Met His Wife, Nina Lowe
Another neighbor

up the

mountain

in

Virginia, Charlie Barnett Lowe,

friend of Tommy's family; Charlie and Tommy's Uncle Dave
Turney used to foxhunt together. (This is not the same Charlie Lowe as
in the earlier story about
Tommy playing for his first dance.)
zoas

I

a

I

a

it.

at the

I

half-pint bottle full, some of that liquor that I'd made over
there at Fred Lowe's. It was good whiskey, too- as good as ever been
made, reckon. got him t'take a couple little shots of that, y'know.
Then waited til it had time to take effect on him. We talked on a
I

My gosh, he went an' got
Well, when he brought

I

Told 'im he was my grandpa.
talked to 'im a little bit, an' says,
"Mr. Payne, do you ever take a drink?" "Well," he says, "I've been
known to." says, "Well, got a little drink right here in my pocket."
I

their grandpa. You go get that fiddle an' play them boys

I

shade of a apple tree, had him a rope long as from here
across to the road over yonder. An' that horse was a-grazin' all
around him, him a-settin' in the shade of that apple tree.

walked up an' told 'im well, Charlie told 'im who we was,
believe, my brother-in law. "Yeah," he said, he knowed Rufe Jarrell.

I

up there, t'hear 'im play some. He didn't much want t'do it. He just
put me off, y'know. She said, "Zack," says, "You go get that fiddle
an' play them boys a tune." Says, "I've danced a-many a reel with

He was the best fiddler ever heard
on his tunes, now. "Course,
now, he couldn't play my tunes because he was a old fiddler, you
know. never heared him try "Sally Ann" nor nothin' like that.

in the

I

I

I

a

sittin'

that apple tree. Went on down there. He told his wife who we was,
y'know. "Lordy mercy yes," says, "I know Rufe Jarrell." An' then
mentioned about him gettin' his fiddle an' playin', what come

I

I

I

I

was in perfect tune. An' that was the way he
see you don't never play
said, "Yeah,
none," I says, "I can tell by lookin' on the neck of the fiddle you
don't never play none." He sorta grinned a little bit, y'know
he
knowed I'd caught up with him.

Well, was a-dodgin' the law up in Virginia an' was stayin' with
my sister up there, Julie. An' ol' man Zack lived about, oh, it wasn't
a mile, I'd
say it was a half a mile or three quarters. An' I'd heard so
much talk about him playin' the fiddle. My closest neighbor up

I

I

had

Zack Payne

I

I

"It's tore up." Well,

I

it all

I

gave him another drink.
"Now," says, "I come up here, I want to learn 'Leather Britches'
an' 'Billy in the Lowground.'" "Aw, honey," he says, "I can't
play
no fiddle," says, "I don't never fool with it no more." "Well," says,
"Let's go down to the house, I want to see your fiddle." "Well," he
said, "we'll go down t'the house." So we went on t'the house. He
was settin' about twenty-five, thirty yards from the house, under
little bit.

an'

a

went up there [Charlie Barnett Lowe's] to make some whiskey
stayed there an' boarded there. Glen Hawks an' Charlie, my

wife's daddy, they wanted some whiskey made, an' Troy Rippey,
my brother-in-law, that married Nina's oldest sister, they all went

(continued

on next page)

�an' wanted some whiskey made. An', Fred Lowe was
make
it for 'em, an' Fred backed out.
don't know whether
gonna
he got scared or what. Well, me an' Fred [Jarrell] was on the dodge,
we was up there in Virginia, dodgin' the law, an' Fred Lowe told

in Hillsville, Virginia.
(Eleven years earlier, in 1912, this same court
house had been the scene of a controversial shoot-out at the Allen

Glen Hawks, says, "Why don't you get Tommy an' Fred to make
you some whiskey?" See, I'd done made some for Fred Lowe. He

that the Aliens shot up, y'know. We got Sandy Combs to carry us
in a T-model Ford, a 1916 Ford T-model, had a ol' brass radiator on

knowed

it.

in

together

I

knowed how

I

make

to

it. So

that's how

it

brothers' trial.)
Got married

come around.

Well, we went up there, an' we boarded there at Charlie's. First
time ever seen my wife. Went up there one Sunday, went to work
next day. Stayed there an' made the whiskey, an' when we got
I

honeymoon nor nothin' like that. We went an' stayed all night
with Uncle Dave Turney an' went by Uncle Charlie's, but don't
think we stayed all night with him. [NDN: So you wouldn't have
a
wedding dance or anything special like that?] Once in a while
I

t

they would, y'know. But we didn't. We just got married an' come
wasn't nobody but the preacher an' think
the clerk of the court was there, the one we got the license from.
What about when you got up there to Uncle
[B. F. Jarrell:

on back home. There

1

I

1

to liking each other.
never will forget
we was a-hoein' corn, by god, when asked
her about gettin' married. I told her, I said, "Nina, we'll get
married, if you want to. But," says, "I'll tell you right now, make

know, got

I

I

I

whiskey,

play poker, an'

go to

I

dances,

make music, an',"

I
says,
don't know whether I'll ever quit that or not. But," says, "If you
think we can get along, now, we'll get married
an' if you don't
think we can, right now's the time to say somethin'." "Well, " she
says, "I believe we'd get along all right." Now that's the way it
I

I

I

"I

1

Tommy and Nina's Wedding

a

kind of

a

serenade

or

they used to call that
there
around
Low
serenade
Well,
folks, but they
up
Gap?]
they'd
never did me. They get up an' sometimes they'd ride the man on
a rail,
put him on a rail an' tote him around the house.
They'd
shoot an' cut up an' carry on, an' wouldn't let 'em sleep, y'know.
it

didn't do me thataway. Well, believe they did sort of
some
bells a little bit or somethin' another that night we got
ring
married, but it wasn't no big serenade nor nothin'.
How Tommy Lost Part of His Thumb
But they

I

Tommy and Nina lived with her parents during 1924,
resulted

at the

I

Charlie's, didn't they have somethin' like
somethin'?] Uh-uh. [BFJ: Well, what was

tire first year of
that
had
an
accident that
September of
year Tommy
the loss of part of his left thumb.

their marriage.

happened.
Tommy and Nina were married December 27 1923,

Muddiest time ever you've seen. Wasn't no such a thing as a
it was all just oT red mud, y'know. An' it had

kind of unusual, didn't people usually have a big party when they
No, not up there they didn't. We didn't have no

We'd go up there an' stay a week ar two, an' come back home.
Wouldn' be long, he'd send us word or come after us, one, to come
on back up there. We'd go back.
was about two years after first went up there til we got married.
Fred talked to her more than did. was all the time havin' to play
the fiddle, you know. Fred was a'dancin' with her an' a-talkin' to
her, course he wasn't a-courtin' her or nothin'. An', we just, you

Hillsville, the one

got married?]

I

It

at

rained all day the day before.
[NDN: Did you have a big party afterward, though?] No. Troy
Rippey an' his wife was there, an' Nina's sister, when we got back
from gettin' married, they was there. [NDN: Well, wasn't that

done, why, we left.
Wasn't long til Charlie sent after us to come back up there. had
my fiddle along, you know. By gosh, every time we'd come home,
he'd send after us, or come after us. know that was a year before
me an' Nina got married. We helped him make a crop up there.
Why, when we'd be up there, we'd work just like the rest of 'em.

known Nina about two years 'fore we ever got married.

courthouse, up there

sand clay road then,

I

I'd

in the

courthouse

in

In

They caught

fellow with sixteen gallons of whiskey, an' then
it was my whiskey an'
was in the car an'
had a case over here in Dobson court. went over
a

he told the law that

everythin'

an'

I

I

I

my father-in-law, Charlie Barnett Lowe, an' my
wife's uncle, he had a Ford Roadster. An' he come by up there at
there

to trial an'

Charlie's an' got me.
I didn't want to
bring no whiskey down here, but nothin'd do
them but we had to bring some. So Charlie, or Fate, one, had a ol'
Army canteen, that held a quart, y'know, what they had in World
War I? So he filled that up. An' brought it with us. Just before we

Dobson Courthouse over yonder, right close to the Allison
someone was once hanged in a lynching],
we hid that there quart canteen out there in the woods, in the
leaves.
got

to

tree over there [where

Moncus

Went on out

to the courthouse, an' the lawyer told me, he says,
can
"Tommy, you
go on back home." This was on a Monday, says,
"Your case won't be tried til Thursday." They'd made a calendar

they hadn'tbeena-doin' that, y'know. Anybody had
case in court, you had to go an' stay there til the thing was over.
But they improved that, they had everbody's cases docketed for a
certain day.

courtesy

Ardena

Jarrell

of the court

Tommy Jarrell and Nina Lowe Jarrell

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

come on back home, we stopped up here at my daddy's,
supper, an' had to have a tune, y'know. Well, had a banjo

So we

an' eat

I

did, an'

an' Charlie, they got to

there,
somebody
daddy
y'know, makin' music. An' we left there,
or

I

guess

it

playin',

was around

�nine or ten o'clock.
An' we got up yonder, do you know where that there water
wheel is, a-goin' up old 52, a-goin' up the mountain? Where that
Blue Ridge Tavern is, there's

a water wheel there. Well, there used
double branches [streams] there that run across the road, that

to be

was before the road was ever paved, it was just an old dirt an'
mountain road. An' I'd been a-ridin' on the outside, an' Charlie,
he'd been a-ridin' in the middle. An' so, we got out there an' got us
a drink of water- the ol' water run
right out of the mountain there,
an' drink the rest of the liquor we had in that canteen.
Charlie said to me, he says, "Tommy, let me ride on the outside,"
says, "I want to chew me some tobaccer." So got in the middle. In
that roadster, now. An' they had a top on 'em,
don't know

y'know-

1

I

whether you recollect seein' a Ford Roadster or not. They had a top
on 'em kind of like an old buggy. It had a little ol' short brace
up
there about that long. was sittin' in the middle an' we got on up
I

to the

got tired of sittin' kinda cooped up like
reached out an' got ahold of each one of them

top of the mountain,

this, y'know. So

I

I

I

[braces].
An' just before we got down to Fancy Gap Church, after we
turned to the left an' we got to the top of the mountain, we was a-

singin' "Amazing Grace, "or "Let Me Fall," one,
which it was now. Got to a little ol' hill, it was just

don't know

I

a

little down

grade. All the lights they had was magneto lights, y'know, didn't
have battery lights like you got now on your cars. If you wasn't aracin' your motor, you didn't have no light at all. Well, when we
topped that little ol' hill, started down the [grade], he pushed his
gas lever up an' just about cut his motor off, an' the lights just about

went out.

machine had ditched

in under it. An' it was the dryest, dustiest
was in September. He got over to the left-hand
side of the road, an' the road was crowned up, y'know, like that, an'
that made the top lean over a little more. That root stickin' out [of

time you ever saw,

the bank! there,

it

it

caught my [left] thumb right again' that brace,

y'know.

[brace] piece

was

a

had ahold of. My thumb kept it from it, reckon.
little piece of skin, just about half as wide as my
I

I

thumbnail there, an' just about
in

under there.

as thick as my thumbnail, hangin'
held it up 'tween me an' the starlight, an' it

I

went around an' around like that. said to my daddy-in-law,
"Charlie, knocked my thumb off." He said, "Surely not!"

I

1

I

"Yeah, looky there."

An'

he jerked out his

said,
says,

I

handkerchief an' he

around there, y'know.
wrapped
We turned around an' went to Hillsville. An' Fate like to wrecked
that car, three or four times a-goin' from there to Hillsville. Itwa'n't
it

but eight miles to Hillsville, an' it was about fifteen to Mt. Airy,
y'know. So we went to Hillsville. Charlie knowed ol' Doctor

Nuckolls. An' we stopped there

in front of his office. Charlie
says,
wait right here, an'," says, "I'll go down an' wake him up."
went to havin'
By that time, that thing went to hurtin' an'
chills, kindly, y'know. it bled a-right smart. said to Charlie, said,
"I wish we hadn't a-drinked all that
whiskey down yonder a while

"Y ou all

I

I

ago,"

1

says,

"I

need

a

I

drink right now." He run his hand in his
an' he jerked out a little ol' red half-

inside coat pocket right quick,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

he'd had

it

it all

day

in

That ol' dust an' everything had ground all in there, amongst
them leaders an' everything, y'know. An' the damn rascal, he went
to scrubbin' on that with a rag, y'know. Never numbed it nor
nothin'. An' I said to him, "Listen here, doc," says, "I can stand a
I

whole lot. An'"

says, "that's a-hurtin'." He says, "You mean that's
hurtin'?"
says, "You know damn well it's a-hurtin'!"
says,
"Can't you do somethin' about that?" He sorta laughed, "Yeah,"
he says, "I'll fix that up." So he got his ol' needle, y'know, an' he
I

I

I

shot two or three shots around on it, smoked him a cigarette. He
says, "Has it quit hurtin' now?" says, "Yeah." An' then he washed
it an' cleaned it
up. It didn't hurt, 'cause it was numb, y'know.
Well, told him, said, "Now, I'll have to have me some whiskey
in the mornin',
been a-drinkin' pretty heavy." "Well, now," he
"if
was
says,
you wouldn't drink no whiskey til that thing heals
I

I

I

I

I

1

up right there." He didn't tell me not to, he says, "If

I

wouldn't."

was you

I

Well, went on home, y'know, an' got me a little doze of sleep.
waked up Ot m-boom, m-boom, m-boom. Well,
think to
myself, can't stand that. got up an' poured me a snuff glass just
about full of whiskey. An' downed 'er. An' then, just as soon as
the whiskey had time to act, why it just eased off, y'know. Well,
was tickled to death,
was sayin', "Well,
found the remedy for
I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

I

that, now."

Well, just as soon as that there whiskey died in there, it went to
hurtin' again, y'know. An' went in there, an' poured me out
about the same amount again. An' my god, that was the last
I

I

drinked, by god, for over a year. It sure did hurt then. reckon that
there first [drink] revived that numbin' medicine up a little bit,
y'know. An' it was all gone, that last one took. An' my god, you
I

I

talk about hurtin', I never slept a dang wink that night. Ever' time
my heart would beat it was right in the end of that, y'know. If I'd

listened

to him, hadn't a-drinked none, it wouldn't a-hurt me so
bad, but... thought about it afterward, think, "He oughta told me
not to drink one," which guess I'd a-drinked it anyhow.
I

They had double glasses up there for windshields, didn't have
a solid
glass like them cars now, they had two, a top one an' a
bottom one. Well, [that root) pulled back hard enough again' the
top glass til it broke it out. An' never knocked the paint off of the

right

he had

his pocket there, y'know. So I turned that up an' I drinked about
half of it. Well, by the time the doctor got up there, I'd got all right,
y'know. I wasn't havin' no chills.

I

An' there was an ol' root just like my ol' leg right there, stickin'
out [of the bank] on the left hand side of the road. An' the road

It

Nobody knowed

pint bottle full.

I

I

I'll tell you though, that happened in September an' it was a
year
'fore that ever healed up right there. My wife made me a little stall
an' I'd pack it full of cotton.
had a string tied around my wrist, to
I

hold

it

An' I'd have to clean that thumb ever' night an'
The first year worked for the highway commission,

on there.

mornin'.

I

I

wore that stall that whole year. Well, don't know how long wore
it now,
might've wore that thing for two years. It was awful
couldn't
tender,
[stand?] for nobody to, even somebody want to
to
it
point
you,
just run all over me, just like a chill, y'know....
I

I

I

I

That [accident!

happened after was married. Well, let's see,
this happened in '24. That fall, that's when
that thing got knocked off. An' also, in September, sometime in
September, don't know if it was after I got my thumb knocked off,
or whether it was before. My wife's mother died. An' then, on
Christmas mornin', [her father] died. That's all the difference there
was in their deaths. From September til December 1 924
got married

I

I

in '23, an'

I

After Nina's parents died, Tommy and Nina moved to Mt. Any and lived
with Tommy's parents for about a year. Their daughter Ardena was born
there on February 27, 1925, and on April 1st, Tommy went to work
for the

North Carolina State Highway Commission, the beginning of

(continued

on next page)

a

41-year

�career maintaining local roadways.

Section with Illegibl

Many of the stories of Tommy's middle and later years are told by peopli
who knew him, rather than by Tommy himself. Tommy and Nina had two
more children, Clarence Wayne (Wayne), (1927and Benjamin Franklir,
(B. F. or Benny), (1933-1987).
personality [see article about

Tommy retired

in

B. F.

was

B. F. in

bluegrass fiddler and local radic
Spring '88 OTH],
a

1966 and began playing more music again, around
His wife Nina died in February, 1967. In 1968.

home and with friends.

period of mourning, Tommy was playing again, and his fame began
spread to the old-time music community outside his local area. Ht

after
to

a

recorded, with Fred Cockerham and Oscar Jenkins, for County Records,
This led to many appearances at festivals and concerts all over the U.S.,
and further recordings for County and other labels. Although Tommy
never entered fiddle contests, he received numerous awards, including the

National Heritage Fellowship Award from the National Endowment for
the Arts, which he received

fiddle

is

a
few years before his death in 1985. Tommy's
now part of the Smithsonian collection in Washington, D.C.

Special thanks

to my

husband, Rusty Neithammer,

to

Alice Gerrard,

courtesy

Ardena

Jarrell

Moncus

Bill Hicks, Sheila

Rear L-R: Benjamin Franklin Jarrell, Tommy, Wayne Jarrell. Front L-R:
Nina Lowe Jarrell, Ardena Jarrell Moncus ca. 1951

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Core, Carlos Surratt, Ray Alden, and especially to
Tommy Jarrell and his family and friends for wonderful hospitality and

fine times.

Nancy Dols Neithammer was raised
California, and

is an

in the

San Francisco Bay Area of

old-time fiddler, and computer programmer. After

four years of graduate work in etlmomusicology, a trip to the east coast
in 1980 to go to festivals and visit older
fiddlers extended into a two-year

stay

in

Mt. Airy and Winston-Salem, North Carolina, visiting Tommy
musicians in the area. She now lives in Media,

Jarrell and other

Pennsylvania,
fiddle, banjo,

&amp;

near Philadelphia, with her husband Rusty who plays
guitar), and 5-year-old son Jeffrey Thomas (Jeff).

�Workshop

Rockingham

Cindy

banjo tablature from the playing of Tommy jarrell

transcribed and taught

Tommy Jarrell's outstanding fiddle
playing has tended to overshadow
his playing of the 5-string banjo,
which was no less accomplished.

thumb as the third measure and ends with a first-string hammer-on from the open string to the
second fret. The first ending features a hammer-on from the open second string to the second
fret, which is the same pitch as the open first string. Tommy repeats this measure at the
beginning of the second ending, tagging the A part with the same figure that occurs at the
beginning of measure 2.
Part B starts with an A minor chord, which is noted first and third strings at the second fret
The first
(I use my first finger on the third string and my second finger on the first string).
measure has a pull-off from the chord to the open third string. Keep the second finger on the first
string for this pull-off. The pull-off is repeated in measure two and is followed by a melody/
drop-thumb on the open first and second strings. Measure 3 has the quick hammer-on found
throughout Part A. Measure 4 ends the same way as measure 2. Measure 5 is the same as measure
1. Measure 6 starts like measure 2, with a pull-off, and ends with the hammer-on found in the
endings of part A. Measure 7 starts with the same quick hammer-on on the first string found in
measure 3, followed by a normal hammer-on on the same string. An open string pull-off begins
the first ending. An open string pull-off is a pull-off on an unstruck string. Noting the first string
on the second fret using your second finger of your left hand, pull the finger off after striking the
open second string. A drop-thumb figure used in measure 2 and 4 follows. The second ending
echoes the seventh measure and the first half of the first ending.

Tommy started music on the banjo,

seconding

his Uncle Charlie Jarrell's

fiddling.
Tommy's version of "Rockingham
Cindy" is transcribed from his banjo
album, Come and Go With Me (County
748). Tommy plays

it in

the key of C.

play with a fiddler, who
would play the tune in the key of D,
you will have to tune your banjo up
two pitches or put a capo on the
In

order

to

second fret.
lar

The parts of this tune are of irregu
length. Rather than the normal

16-bar A and

parts, "Rockingham

B

Cindy" has parts of sixteen and onehalf measures, with the half measures

occurring

after

second

the

Bob Carlin is

a
performer, a teacher of traditional music, and
included Tommy Jarrell and Fred Cockerham.

time

through each part.
Many of Tommy's characteristic
banjo techniques are found in this
particular tune. For instance, he uses
a

lot of

hammer-ons

and pull-offs.

hammer-ons
majority
uses
are
Tommy
quick hammer-ons
The
as

the

of

grace notes.
Part A starts with

"Galax lick." This

combination

of

a

a

is

variation on the
usually some

brush across the

third, second, and first strings using

your melody

finger,

a

by Bob Carlin

slide on the

first string from the second to the
fifth fret, followed by a plucked
thumb or fifth string. Tommy does a

quick hammer-on, followed by three
5th-string notes. The second measure
starts with the same quick hammeron. The third measure starts with an
open first string played by the melody
finger with a drop thumb on the open

second string. The second, fourth, and
sixth measures are the same; first and
fifth measures the same. The seventh
measure starts with the same drop

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

recording artist, whose initial influences

uA1984-arr: Bob Carlin /courtesy Ridge Runner Home Lessons

�Workshop

Bunch

Old

of

Keys

banjo tablature from the playing of Tommy Jarrell

transcribed and taught

spent the best part of 1980 and 1981
intensively studying banjo with Tommy

Although he could play a fretted banjo
with fine results, Tommy preferred a fretless. The fret positions I've marked here are
therefore only approximate, since he liked

I

Jarrell on an NEA Folk Arts

Apprentice

ship grant. A number of other people did
similar work with Tommy at around the
same time, on both banjo and fiddle. Each
of us probably remembers a little differ

nothing more than to get what he called
"that whine" into his picking
a whine
which often came in part from producing
quarter-tone and smaller intervals. Ex

ently what Tommy did and that's good,
because he seldom played a tune exactly
the same way twice, and because there

amples of this can be found in the slide in
the first measure of Part A and the "5-4"

was so much

figures

to his music that each younger
who
learned
from him would tend
person
to find his or her own important elements.
like getting together with some of this
crew from time to time, and hearing how
Tommy's influence lives on in their music.
I

We all learned

a

lot from

the same fun-

loving, generous, and articulate teacher,
and we all sound different from one an
other today, yet similar

to

identifiable ways.

Tommy

in

certain

in the same part.
As you approach the first "5-4" figure

Part A, you may want

I

of two

phrases from that dav.
Tommy's banjo picking was every bit as
remarkable as his fiddling for many of the
same reasons that apply to his fiddle play

in

gently slide as

marked. Tommy often did this, damping
strings somewhat and thereby achieving
both a hint of the notes he was seeking and
a percussive effect at the same time
through
the right hand as it struck the strings.

includes two significant "trade
mark" techniques of Tommy's. The first is
Part

his

comes from an October
1980 session which recorded at Tommy's
home. I've shown alternative treatments
This tablature

to

use

B

of the

drop thumb

to

the

open

second string (it appears twice in the first
measure and then again in the third) in
stead of using the fifth string. This gave his
right hand something of a rolling appear
ance, and his playing an unusual sound,
since he relied less on the fifth string than

same time, he performed the

do many other pickers. Sometimes he would
drop this thumb to the third or even the

melody, set out a clear rhythmic line, and
accompanied himself by keeping open

fourth string. The second technique is the
figure marked "roll." Instead of sliding up

ing. All

at the

strings vibrating. While was learning from
him, and listening to many other pickers,
no one else seemed to quite come close. For
I

a

while

I

wondered

if

my

impressions

his banjo picking were colored
the sheer force of his presence

of

unduly by
combined

with his accessibility and heartwarming
listen to my old tapes
hospitality. As
these days,
hear clearly that Tommy's
I

I

banjo picking was as first thought, only
even more so: outstanding in its own right.
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

string, Tommy would often very lightly
roll the index, middle, and ring fingers up
a

the string in rapid succession. This didn't
sound like a series of hammers; it was no
where near so blunt or obvious. Nor did it
sound like a slide, although you might think
it would. It has its own distinctive
percus
sive/melodic sound, this time the

percussive effect coming

as

left hand as the right.
A lot of this is remarkably

much from the

delicate stuff,

at its

by

Paul Brown

best when the banjo

with

a

fiddle

is

picked alone or

which of course,

is

how

Tommy learned his music as a boy. But this
style of playing holds up surprisingly well
a
larger group too, though it doesn't
have the sharp, staccato clarity in a full
band, of say, Kyle Creed's playing.
It would be
virtually impossible to write

in

down

everything

significant about

Tommy's playing of this or any other tune.
Small but important details such as hand
and finger positions and angles are best
shown in person. Maybe I'll see some of
you
In

at

workshops over the coming years.

if you have any questions
comments about these tablatures, con

the meantime,

or

tact me in care of The Old-Time Herald and
I'll try to help you out. Listen
carefully to
available recordings, and look for more of
these tabs in future issues of the Herald.
Now.
as Tommy would say, "Let's

have

a

good tune for our own use!"

Paul Brown, from Pilot Mountain, N.C., started

playing clawhammer banjo zuhen
years old. He was the operations

news director

at

he was

ten

manager and

WPAQ inMt. Airy, N.C.,and

booked the live music show, "The Merry-GoRound." He is currently production manager
at

WFDD public radio and hosts "Across the

Blue Ridge." Paul co-founded the Hometown
Opry in Mt. Airy, N.C. along with Frank Bodie
and Verlen Clifton. He plays fiddle and banjo,
has played with many local musicians, cur

rently performs with theToast String Stretchers
and solo at workshops and concerts throughout
the country. He is working on independent

recording and music documentation projects,
and was the first prize old-time banjo winner
at the Clifftop, W. Va. contest this
past sum
mer.

�I=Index finger

T=Thumb

P=Pull

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

sl=slide

�Workshop

Tommy learned "Old Bunch of Keys" "Up on the mountain [near Fancy Gap, Virginia] from my daddy-in-law [Charlie Barnett Lowe],
an' John Rector, an' Fred Flawkes, an' some of 'em." "Old Bunch of Keys" is played in AEAE tuning. The transcription is written as it
sounds, so you have to remember to adjust your fingering for notes on the two lower strings. Tommy uses the open strings of this tuning
to great advantage, with lots of bow-rocking (described below).
recording of "Old Bunch of Keys," Tommy plays the low part of the tune 3, 4, or 5 times through before going back to the high
a number of tunes he
played like this, and when he played with Charlie Lowe they had a system for communicating
when to change parts.
"Well, we'd go on the high part twice y'know, but we played the low part a long time 'fore we'd go on the high part. We'd just keep
playin' that [low part] til one of us wanted to change an' then we'd punch a knee. We'd sit [facing each other] with our knees together.
An' then if took a notion to go on the high part, all had to do is [bump knees], an' if he did, why, he'd do the same thing to me. An'
we knowed exactly what the other one was gonna do thataway. In place of raising the fiddle up, that's what we'd do, y'know. 'Course
when Lawrence [Lowe] got to playing with us, we couldn't do that, we had to raise my fiddle up when we'd go to go on the high part.
Uncle Charlie and Daddy both [signaled by raising the fiddle] all the time. That's when knowed when they was a-gonna change, y'know.
They played like that, played the low part of it maybe over half a dozen or a dozen times 'fore they'd play the high part, an' just go over
On this

part. There were

I

I

I

the high part twice."
"Old Bunch of Keys" uses

a lowered seventh
degree of the scale, between G natural and G#. The third degree of the scale (C#) is played
shaded by sliding into the note from below and by a subtle technique which will try to describe. Instead of
playing the C# on the A string with an open E harmony note, Tommy's second finger stops both the A and E strings (C# on the A string
with G# on the E string). Although the G# note is not really sounded clearly, Tommy brushes it and gets a soft scratch that adds to the
rhythm and flavor of the tune. These places are marked in the transcription with the note head in parenthesis, but as always, listening
to the recording is essential.
One ot the hallmarks of Tommy's fiddling is the way he rocked the bow to hit notes on the other strings, providing a harmonic and
rhythmic accompaniment to the tune melody. The bridge on his fiddle was cut fairly flat to make this bow-rocking "easy on your arm,"
as Tommy put it. The transcription includes

pretty close

to C#,

but

is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

both the melody and the harmonic/rhyth
mic accompaniment notes, as well as the

bowings. Again, listening to the recording
will help to sort out which notes are melody
and which notes are accompaniment.
To
to the

make

it

match the transcription
transcribed the tune as it

to

easy

recording,

I

played through the first time, and added
few of the variations Tommy puts in later
is

the end. (There are many other subtle

tions

throughout

the

tune.)

a

at

varia

Although

Tommy played many of the same tunes all
his life, he was always experimenting with
new ways to play them. This version of "Old
Bunch of Keys" is from Tommy's first record,
made in the late 1960s with Fred Cockerham
and Oscar Jenkins; on the tapes I madeof T ommy
playing this tune in the early 1 980s, he played

somewhat differently.

So even if this tran
showed
scription
everything Tommy was
is
doing (which totally impossible), it would
only show what he did one time he played it.
As Brad said in last month's bowing work
it

shop, "Don't take these tablatures and
transcriptions as the final word; rather, use
them as tools to help you understand what you
hear in the recordings."
--Nancy Dols

Neithammer

�Old
as

Bunch

played by Tommy Jarrell on County 713: Down to the Cider Mill

transcription

by

Nancy Dols Neithammer

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

Keys

�Reviews

A

ing" styles and voices we get to meet the Skillet
Lickers as individuals, from the genuinely slurred

Day

At

The

rural dialect of Gid Tanner to the more contrived
mountain speech of the more uptown Clayton
McMichen, his put-on "thars" and "haint's" con

County
Fair

trasting as well with the city talk of

straight man

Dan Hornsby, Columbia Records' assistant A &amp;
R man. Finally, we get to hear some great music,

ner,

Comedy

featuring

McMichen,

Clayton

Riley

Tan

Gid

Puckett,

and

others
Old

A Day At the County Fair (Part I and ID/Prohi
bition Yes or No! (Part
and ID/Taking the
I

Census (Part

and

I

II)

/Hog Killing Day

(Part

1

and II)/Jeremiah Hopkins Store at Sand Moun
tain (Part I and II)/ A Bee Hunt On Hill For Sartin

Creek (Part

ID/The Original Arkansas
and ID/Possum HuntOn Stump

and

I

TravelIer(Part
House Mountain (Part and ID/Prosperity and
Politics (Part and ID/Practice Night With the
I

I

I

Skillet Lickers (Part

1

How many old-time

fiddlers does

it

take

to

don't know the
light bulb? Sorry,
if I did, it might come off as a tenyear-old-passe kind of humor. Old-time music
screw

in

a

I

answer, but

has proven to have great staying power over the
years, but much topical and regional humor can
become dated. (In the early 1980s some young

California musicians complained that Gordon
Tanner's jokes to "Arkansas Traveller" "weren't
funny"; perhaps the realities of the sharecropping system reflected in "Don't look like you'll
a crop"
"well, we're just workin'
were too far removed from them,

make but half
on halves"

while the joys of "Nancy Rollin" remained as
close as their fiddles and bows.) What, then, is
the appeal of this collection of reissued 78 sides
from the 1920s and 1930s of the Skillet Lickers'

hastily pu t-together and rehearsed comedy skits,
interspersed with snatches of fiddle tunes and
snnvs?
The joys are considerable. First, while some of
the jokes fall flat, many are still funny, and the
skits are interesting as period pieces, giving us

fascinating glimpses into an earlier era when
change was coming into the rural south; and
sometimes the humor clicks in as relevant to
today's conditions. Second, through their "act

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

friends from the city.

accompaniment, "Prettiest Little Girl In the
County" and a wonderful dance tune, probably

elsewhere.
In his informative liner notes Charles Wolfe
points out that, besides being the most famous

bition

in

genre that was later to include the likes of Minnie
Pearl, Rod Brasfield, Grandpa Jones, The Duke
of Paducah, Archie Campbell, Homer and Jethro,
and others."

It

should

be

added that their com

edy style had its antecedents

in tent,

minstrel,

and medicine shows, and the "Toby and Susie"
dramas of earlier times. Gid Tanner's jokes, cos

tumes, and antic comedy style sparked the Skillet
Lickers' live shows
he announced his raggedy
to be his "summer suit
some'er mine,
some 'er somebody else's." Fiddler McMichen
did blackface routines and banjoist Fate Norris

outfit

and ID.

rings true and reflects the lives
Lickers and their

full-length sides,

tantalizingly short bits: some tunes the

string band of the 1920s, the Skillet Lickers "were
also among the first stars of country comedy
a

Homestead OHSC-145

it

of the Skillet

and some different arrangements and combina
tions of musicians in tunes they did record

in

Skillet Lickers never recorded

Country

sides, much of
and attitudes

A Day At the County Fair features some
authentic barker talk, but its highlights are two
songs sung by Tanner with just his fiddle for

albeit

Early

producers (Hornsby was also a pop-country
singer) and rural musicians was a real playing
out of the rube-versus-city slicker theme, and
while caricatures sometimes emerge on both

one-man band outfit; blind guitarist Riley
was more serious, and today Smokey
Joe Miller, who played with them says that Tan
ner and Puckett "contested for the honors of the
had

a

Puckett

night," with Gid's slapstick comedy contrasting
with Puckett's tear-jerking songs.
"A
in

Fiddlers' Convention

in Georgia," released
was the Skillet Lickers' first comedy

1927,

was followed by "ACorn Licker Still In
Georgia," so sucessful that there were several
sequels. Most of these have been heard on reis
record.

It

sue; but with the exception of "A Possum Hunt
on

Stump House Mountain," which was reis

sued on County 512, and an anthology of early
country comedy called "A Day In the Moun
tains," none of the cuts on the present collection

reissued previously. According to
Wolfe, it is unclear exactly who developed the
skits. Mac and Bert Layne claimed that they
has

been

improvised them, to be written in script form by
Columbia's Bill Brown, while Frank Walker re
called

that he and

Hornsby worked them

up:

"Then we would rehearse them as best we could

with the boys.
with only just an outline for
them to do. The skits were made up from things
they let drop." This collaboration of city record

of

plantation origin, "Little Black Foot." "Prohi
Yes

or

No"

has

Mac

countering

Hornsby's self-righteous advocacy of
tion with the observation that you "can't
nothin' from doin' somethin' it don't
do." Current warriors against other

Prohibi
prohibit
want to

people's

habits take heed Equally relevant today is "Tak
ing the Census" from 60 years ago, when it
seems folks were as wary as they were during
the 1990 census of what they viewed as govern
ment snooping into their lives. When asked if he
had a radio, Mac said he didn't, because "you
only get music over a radio occasionally and
"

and he proceeded to
you never get it like this
prove it with the strains of "Cotton-Eyed Joe"

claimed, you can only hear "in this
a
phonygraph record."
Thegraphic descriptions in "Hog Killing Day"
are not for the squeamish; the sound and word
"
A Bee Hunt On Hill For Sartin
pictures in
Creek" and "Possum Hunt On Stump House
Mountain" are equally vivid. The latter skit has
a
great rendition of "Billy In the Low Ground."
which,

he

cabin and on

Wolfe notes that Sand Mountain

Alabama was the scene
live

shows and

the

in

northeastern

of many Skillet Lickers

home

of

devoted fans.

"Jeremiah Hopkins Store on Sand Mountain"
has the boys selecting their favorite foods, to be
invited by the proprietor to "square up that bill
here music satisfies the
by playing a hot tune"

storekeeper as moonshine whiskey placates the
revenue officer or census taker in other skits.
This cut is also graced by one of the many good
tunes called "Soapsuds Over the Fence" and by
the line

crooked
at my

that
I

the road

run my batt'ry

to

Bear Waller

is

"so

downblowin' my horn

own tail light."

"The Original Arkansas Traveller" features
Mac as the country bumpkin trading quips with
city slicker Hornsby in the classic folk dialogue,
supposedly composed in the 1840s by Kentuckian Sanford

Faulkener. Once Hornsby shows

his stuff by playing the second part of the tune

�(though probably Lowe Stokes is playing), the
two fiddles join in a splendid unaccompanied
two-fiddle run-through of the piece.
After Stokes

and

Mac

had

left

the Skillet

Lickers, Gid reorganized the band, with his teen
age son Gordon on lead fiddle and mandolinist
Ted Hawkins, traveling out to San Antonio with

himself and Riley

for the

famous last session

in

1934, for Victor. Two comedy records from that
session wind up in this reissue. "Prosperity and

Politics"

is full of

upbeat comment

Deal and high praise for F. D.
things old tunes are renamed

becomes

"Old

Way,"

"Prettest

Finally,

in

Man

on the

New

R.; in the

Depression

spirit of
"Cacklin' Hen"
Get On Your

Little

Girl in the County" is
and "Goin' Down the
Breakdown,"
"Prosperity
Road Feelin' Bad" changes "bad" to "glad."

"Practice Night

at the

Skillet Lickers"

lazy husband gets his comeuppance and the
skit ends with the whole gang singing "Show Me
a

the Way to Go Home."
ART ROSENBAUM

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tar and

string band offerings balance the banjo

pieces. These range from the
of "Where the West Begins"

1930s
to

cowgirl swing

North Carolina

song writer Si Kahn's quietly angry "Coal Min
ing Woman."

New

on the Sugar Hill

release

are two Cathy

Fink originals. "Coming Home" looks through
the eyes of a military nurse back from Vietnam,
and "Sara McCutcheon" spins the lighthearted
tale of a feisty woman who smuggles herself out
of the

old-folks home.
TOM HANCHETT

Doggone
Time

My

Fink

Cathy

Sugar Hill
SH

3783

C

(CD/Cassette)
Where

the West

So

Begins/I'm

Lonesome

I

Could Cry/The Cuckoo/Sara

McCutcheon/
Cat's Got the Measles/Coal Mining Woman/
Monkey Medley: Repulse the Monkey-Monkey
Blues/The Midnight Prayerlight/The NoTell Hotel/When It's Darkness on the Delta/
CottonPatch Rag/Coming Home/Little Billy
Farm

Wilson-Shenandoah Falls/My Old Kentucky

Home.

Cathy Fink came out with Doggone My Time on
tiny Rooster Records 10 years back when she
was just starting her solo career. It is nice to see
it in

the

print

with additional material--

again--

on

widely-distributed Sugar Hill label.

The album's backbone is solo old-time banjo,
well played and well recorded Cathy pays care
ful attention to tradition with such
bubbling

instrumentals

as

"Little

Billy

Wilson"

and

"Shenandoah Falls."
She is not afraid to add her own ideas as well.
The album's stand-out song is a slow and heart
felt version of the Hank Williams country

standard

"I'm So

Lonesome

I

Could Cry," ac

only by the banjo. If Hank could
have heard this cut, he would have played it this

companied

way himself.
As in Cathy Fink's concerts,

a

variety

of

gui

�and full sound. Only once, on the title cut, do we
hear the sparseness of fiddle and banjo alone, but

"produced" manner we hear these days,
they are soon joined by the full band.
There are vocals on a few cuts, and they are
generally adequate, though less sparkling than
in the

the instrumental

work. The trio on "Ain't Gonna

Work Tomorrow"

is

very good, almost rising

to

the marvelous energy of the fiddling and picking;
on the other hand, the solo vocal on "God Delivers

Again" is rather listless and does little
the fervent message of the text.

to

deliver

This issue is well-recorded

by Bobby Patterson,
mainstay of the Galax music scene; would have
appreciated some notes on the tunes and the mu
sicians. But the fine music speaks for itself, and the
a

I

rolling "Nancy Blevins" is worth the price of the
cassette. It is good to know that younger local
musicians are rein vigora ting the great Galax-Mt.
Airy sound.
ART ROSENBAUM

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�music his own.
People who enjoy old-time music from the
"transitional" period will enjoy this record.
People who want to learn how to make songs
from other sources their own would also do well
to

5

listen

to this

record.

An article by Dr. Charles Wolfe, in vol 1, No.
of OTH details Roy Harper's life and music.

People interested in learning about this man
should consult that issue.
BILL

MANSFIELD

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�paintings and the text is just what the title says:
mountain rhymes, all of which are as silly and
obscure as any Mother Goose offering. It's avail
able with or without an accompanying cassette of
all of the tunes. The tape, too, is well

thought out

and well produced. The instrumentation

diverse

as

as could

is

about

be

traditionally
expected,
ranging from unaccompanied vocals to a full
bluegrass band. The music is credited to the
author. The vocals are alternately handled by
Sonja Bird, a nine-year-old, and Homer Fleming,
who sounds like an older gentleman.The singing
and

accompaniment

is

always competent, appro

priate, and well done. It's pleasant without being
saccharinely sweet or cute, and holds up after

repeated listenings

a

real plus for

a

children's

tape.

While all of the above comments

add up to

something that could easily become a classic
children's book, its real strengths hit me while
was attending a recent fiddlers convention. My
daughter interrupted dinner conversation to in

I

form us that the people

of

campsites
Despite
having spent all of her three-and-a-half years
with a banjo-playing dad, she never knew one
tune from another until Granny entered the pic
over were playing

a

couple

"Cluck Old

Hen."

ture. She's since been heard singing

"Old Dan

Tucker" almost as much as some Disney tunes.
I do
question why Milnes is listed as the author

when

mentions that

he collected the material
course this may be trivial. After
all, he has managed to recycle old-time music to
a whole new
generation.
he

for the book. Of

All told, Granny

Will Your Dog Bite is

highly

recommended, especially with the cassette,

for

way up. It makes a great gift
and should be available at local bookstores.
ages three and up

TOM MYLET

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�If you've only driven through Geor
interstate, or have been numbed by the
sterility and sameness of the urban and subur
ban landscape around Atlanta, you will be
amazed that such a world still exists (or existed,
since some of this fieldwork is almost 15 years
old) not far from the land of cloverleaf mazes,

encountered.

gia on the

malls, and glass skyscrapers. Not all that far
from Peachtree Street in miles, but a vast dis
tance

in

cultural time are the folks who inhabit

places with names like Screamersville, Welcome
Hill, Board town, and Dacula. And we are let into
these places with an endless and delightful array
bluesman Willie Hill got

of stories: such as how

his first Sears &amp; Roebuck guitar or about how he
"ruined" his friend Fred's dancing dog, or about

how guitar player and fiddler Joe Rakestraw
made up a song in an apocalyptic dream, or how
Uncle John Patterson gave "Down Yonder" its
name when he had

Decatur Street

to

"down yonder"

to go

replace

a

on

broken string on his

banjo during an Atlanta recording session.
Since there's never been a book quite like Folk
Visions mid Voices, it's
it.

It

easier task

is an

example,

for all the

not really

a

a

little hard
to say

to

what

characterize
it is

not. For

book's aesthetic virtues,
you'd have

song book

to

look

it is

else

where

for details of instrumental technique and
you'd really have to hear the music itself to get
any idea of how to play it. The book contains

over 100 songs and tunes, and with the exception
ballads of Maude Thacker, the lyrics are

of the

incidental. Beyond itsundeniablevalueaspleasant entertainment, however, what this book does
do

is

take

the world

into

us

music

these

of

makers, helping us get an understanding about
the vital role homemade music can have in

people's lives. Though
one state

albeit

it

focuses on one region

place that enjoyed, for

a

a

of

brief

it
moment, the recording industry's spotlight
be
most
interest
would
is a place that
imagine
ing to those who love old-time music, because
like many, many other rural places in America's
1

past, the North Georgia piedmont was

which the joy
thing

acting

of

a

place

in

music-making pervaded every

as

a

glue

that

held everything

together despite the unpredictable

vagaries

of

life.
GAIL GILLESPIE

To order:

University

of Georgia

Press, Athens,

GA 30602

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�the Whooping Cough,"

much of what

is here is

modern context. Nevertheless,
couldn't put this book down once had discov
ered it, driving everyone around me nuts by
reading from it for several days running. To
browse through Negro Folk Rhymes is to take a
not "usable" in

a

I

I

real voyage into the past century, with all the
good, bad, and strange elements laid out before
you as a whole landscape. While this sort of
is not

exactly everyone's cup of tea, feel
to anyone genuinely
interested in the complete background and de
velopment of fiddle and string-band music. For
me, the book held a wealth of small satisfactions,
not the least of which was that it cleared up a lot
thing

that

it

I

will appeal strongly

of puzzling "floater" verses, weird titles, and
seemingly nonsensical expressions. For example,
in the book's concluding
essay, "A Study in
Negro Folk Rhymes," Talley presents some "Ne

gro

Play Songs,"

with call-and-response and

simple musical notation. In one of these little
ditties, the repeated response to a series of dance
directions is the refrain: "Holly-Dink!," and the
5-note tune accompanying

passing resemblance

to

bears more than

it

the

tune

a

"Backstep

Cindy," still played by white banjo players and
fiddlers in rural northwestern North Carolina
and

went

southwestern Virginia.
on in my

head when

A
I

little light blulb

remembered

the

name North Carolina's octogenarian banjo player
Bertie Dickens calls her version of "Backstep
Cindy"
"Holly Ding." Another little discovery
was Talley's inclusion of "Susie Gal," still played
by Joe and Odell Thompson of Orange County,

North Carolina.

Generally speaking, then,

the right reader, Negro Folk Rhymes should

for

pro

vide hours of fascinating reading, shedding light
on some of the dim mysteries surrounding the
time and place from which the wonderful string-

bands of the early country recording era were
born and highlighting the powerful intercon

nections that existed between African-American
and European-American

string music.
GAIL GILLESPIE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�It's quite an enjoyable read, sometimes
thought-provoking, and 'very entertaining. I'll

reiterate, it would have been nice to have heard
some of the interesting people found between
the covers of Mr. Bronner's excellent book.
KERRY BLECH

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�MUSIC
COUNTRY
AUSTRALIAN

No other magazine covers the
length and breadth of country like
Timely feature articles,

SMITH

ON

THE

WAVE

COUNTRY?

FIRST

OF

ARE YOU
READY
FOR THE

the Journal of Country Music.

historical profiles, thought-

gl

provoking essays, in-depth
interviews, reviews of the

j/m

latest books and records
Published

by the

AM,

Country

RECENT

ISSUES

ANDREW

Music Foundation,
the world's

largest

popular music
research center

Written

JcpyhflH

aSsfirMfl

and most active

&lt;*■

by the most

fl

respected journalists
and historians covering

American music

"HOMEGROWN

MUSIC

HOUR"

Illustrated with rare
photographs from the
PMF QrrFivPQ

"For

graphic design,

quality of photos,

H

excellence of writing,
and breadth of country

H

Journal
of Country Music is

coverage,

the

hard to top.

Robert

_

"

K.

Music Book

(3

issues) $15, outside U.S., $20

one year (3 issues) $25
Please send me a list of back issues and contents (free)

I

Oermann

Individual, one year
Library,

H

I

1

Name
Address

Section with Illegible Text

SPOTTSWOOD'S

The Country

I

Subscribe to
the Journal of
Country Music

I

State

City

Payment:
My check for

is

Charge to my:

I

enclosed.
MasterCard

Discover

American Express
Exp. Date

Signature

ORR

ri

(minimi

fur

rrtaiw iinlprO

1

JAY

Clip and mail to: Journal of Country Music
4

Music Square East,
Or call toll-free:

Nashville, TN 37203

1-800-255-2357, ext.

#1

Tennessee residents call 615-256-1639

ISSUES

RECENT
th Illegible
Text

Zip

VISA

Acct

ON

DICK

YES, EM READY!

Sign me up for a subscription to the
Journal of Country Music

Section with Illegible Text
RECENT ISSUES

BOB ALLEN ON MUSIC ROW KINGPIN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

JIMMY BOWEN

RECENT ISSUES

MARK COLEMAN

ON

KEITH

WHITLEY

H

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

XO

L3
V-3

#2

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12218">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 3, Number 2 (Winter 1991-1992)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12219">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12220">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 3, Number 2 (November 1991-January 1992)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Living in Tradition – An Interview with Gerry Milnes,” by Dave Shombert&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Keeing Up with Ramona Jones,” by Rachel Anne Goodman&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Selected Listening – Old-Time Fiddle Music,” by Mike Seeger&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘A Wonderful Time To Be In Galax….,” by Alice Gerrard with Mark Sanderford&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Tommy Jarrell’s Family Stories 1830-1925,” Part 2. by Nancy Dols Neithammer&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Legends – No.3, Darby &amp;amp; Tarlton,” by Charles Wolfe&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Contradancing: Preservation and Evolution,” by Mary DesRosier&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“And I Mean Business… Promotion, Promotion,” by Jeri Goldstein&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – Voices from the Villages,” by Paul Tyler&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – A Gathering of Luthiers,” by Bob Smakula&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Banjo Tablature,” by Bob Carlin and Paul Brown&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Fiddle Transcription,” by Nancy Dols Neithammer&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” includes an obituary for Al Lester&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12221">
              <text>1991</text>
            </elementText>
            <elementText elementTextId="12549">
              <text>1992</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="999">
      <name>1990s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1526">
      <name>1991</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1530">
      <name>1992</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5700">
      <name>Al Lester</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5428">
      <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5556">
      <name>Bob Carlin</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5572">
      <name>Bob Smakula</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5417">
      <name>Charles Wolfe</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5603">
      <name>Darby &amp; Tarlton</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5582">
      <name>Dave Shombert</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5599">
      <name>Gerry Milnes</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5597">
      <name>Jeri Goldstein</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5601">
      <name>Mark Sanderford</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5604">
      <name>Marry DesRosier</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5563">
      <name>Mike Seeger</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5602">
      <name>Nancy Dols Neithammer</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5415">
      <name>Paul Brown</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5605">
      <name>Paul Tyler</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5548">
      <name>Rachel Anne Goodman</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5600">
      <name>Ramona Jones</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5490">
      <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5591">
      <name>Tommy Jarrell</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
