<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2540" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2540?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:52:42+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3468">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/986df201d840695df784f65f9aac53e3.pdf</src>
      <authentication>7f467773eafa42696f2f8dc335816db1</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12265">
                  <text>November 1993-January 1994

Winter

$5.00

THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Singers Ginny Hawker

&amp;

Kay Justice

ALSO IN THIS ISSUE!
Granny's Birthday: Ballad Singer
The Skillet
Buckdance, Flatfoot, or Clogging?
Issues In Old-Time Music
Workshop
&amp;
more!
Reviews

An Interview with Gid Tanner!

Dellie Norton
Lickers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�I
I

you can hear bill monroe &amp;
doc watson
making history
two

historic previously unreleased live recordings

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

27 track, 75 minute
from

collection

of live

performances

1956-1969.

Features Peter Rowan, Bill Keith, Tex Logan,
Del McCoury, many others.
compiled and annotated

by Ralph

Rinzler

sf 40063

recordings from 1963-1980.
Includes Memories of You, Kentucky Mandolin,
17 live duet

Midnight on the Stormy Deep, Feast Here Tonight,
and Watsons Blues.

compiled and annotated

by Ralph

Rinzler

sf 40064

Smithsonian
Folkways
you

can hear the world

For

ordering information

and

a

free catalog:

Smithsonian/Folkways Mail Order
414 Hungerford Drive, Suite 444
Rockville,

MD

20850

443-2314
(301) 443-1819

phone (301)
fax

(Visa and Mastercard accepted)

I

�THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD

VOLUME 4, NUMBER

2

FEATURES
GRANNY'S
By

BIRTHDAY/18

Sheila Kay Adams

GETTING

REAL

IT

Kay Justice

TIGHT/20

Ginny Hawker. By Hilary Dirlam

&amp;

AN INTERVIEW WITH GID TANNER/28

Edited by Dan Foster, Christy Palumbo, Charles Wolfe, and Alice Gerrard

COLUMNS
HERE

&amp;

By Art

THERE/4

Menius

LEGENDS

IN

MUSIC-NO.

OLD-TIME

9/8

The Skillet Lickers. By John Lilly
THE

DANCE

BEAT/14

Buckdance, Flatfoot,
ISSUES
Bascom Lamar Lunsford (dancing) and Bill
McElreath (banjo) Page 14. Courtesy Southern
Appalachian Photographic Archives, Mars Hill

IN

OLD-TIME

LETTERS/2

CLASSIFIED/35

REVIEWS/37

R:

Riley Puckett with Bert Layne (fiddle)

unidentified musicians, 1933. Courtesy

Charles Wolfe

Page

8.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

By Phil

Jamison

MUSIC/24

Cracks. By Bob Smakula (page 32)
By Hilary Dirlam (pages 33

Transcriptions.

DEPARTMENTS

and two

Clogging?

WORKSHOP

College, Mars Hill NC.

Photo

or

&amp; 34)

�THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
1812 House Avenue

Durham, NC 27707

EDITOR
Alice Gerrard

ASSOCIATE
Bill

EDITOR

Hicks

CONTRIBUTING

EDITORS

Hilary Dirlam, Jeri Goldstein, Phil Jamison,
John Lilly, Art Menius, Bob Smakula

BOARD

ADVISORY

Ray Alden, Mac Benford, Hazel Dickens,

Bobby Fulcher, John Hartford,
Linda Higginbotham, Ramona Jones,
Garrison Keillor, Pete Kuykendall,
Brad Leftwich, W.

K.

McNeil,

Pete Sutherland, Charles Wolfe

OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Jack Bernhardt, Bob Cantwell, Alice Gerrard,

Tom Hargrove, Art Menius, Lee Smith,
Jim Watson, Kathy World

ADVERTISING/STAFF
Julie Meloni, Sally Gregory,
Richard Morrison

Gail Gillespie,

No part of this magazine may be reproduced in
any form without written permission from the
publisher. Not responsible for loss or non-return
of

unsolicited photos

or

manuscripts.

1993

the

Old-Time Herald.
The Old-Time

Herald

1040358)

(ISSN

(USPS

002672) is published quarterly the first of Au
gust, November, February, and May by the OldTime Music Group, Inc., 1812 House Ave.,

Durham, NC 27707. Subscription rates payable
advance. One year-- $18 (foreign subscrip

in

tions--

year

$21 U.S.).
$21

Library/Institutional rate: one

Classified ads cos

1

35 cents per word,

minimum of $5. Any grouping of letters or num
bers is counted as one word. All classified ads
must be received by the first of the month, two
months prior to publication. Second Class post
age paid at Durham, NC 27701.
Postmaster: Send change
Time Herald,

of

address

to the Old-

P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC

The Old-Time

Music Group, Inc.,

is

a

27717.

not-for-

profit, tax-exempt corporation under section 501
(c) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�taking fiddle and banjo lessons from! En
joyed the articles, as our lessons have been
at their home in the Haw Orchard area.

1

play "drop
band fiddle.

thumb" banjo, and my hus
Cathy Waters

Abingdon,

VA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here &amp; There

Menius

by Art

Artists

schedule for Dec. includes dates

Agents

&amp;

The International Bluegrass Music Asso
ciation inducted Mac Wiseman and Jim &amp;
Jesse into its Hall of Honor. Jeff Wilkinson's

production of "The Hudson River in Song
and Story" finds Jay Ungar &amp; Molly Ma
son and Walt Michael &amp; Co., joining
Wilkinson for openings on November 6 in
Putnam

Valley, NY and November 7 in
NY.
Info: 914-831-6326.

Garrison,
Stephanie

P.

Ledgin, publisher

of the Tra

ditional MusicLine, has formed Traditional

MusicLine Entertainment

to

represent art

including John Kirk &amp; Trish Miller
and Mac Benford &amp; the Woodshed
ists

AlHStars. Fiddler Bill Christopherson and
guitarist James Reams will perform this
fall with John Herald, Dave Howard, and
John Cohen. In the midst of their most
successful year, the Fiddle Puppet Danc
ers have been

saddened by the worsening

condition of beloved dance partner and cocreator Amy Sarli, who suffers from Arte
riovenous Malformation. The Fiddle Pup
pet Dancers began a campaign in August
to raise money to fund the laser-assisted
neurosurgery needed to treat her condition.
Contributions,

payable

to the

Amy Sarli

Fund, may be sent to the Fiddle Puppet
Dancers (c/o Eileen Carson, 510 Tulip Rd.,
Annapolis, MD 21 403). The Virginia Foun

dation for the Humanities sponsored the
Piedmont Guitarists Tour featuring John

Daniel

and John
Rooster
Record re
legendary
Sisters
the
Delta
performed
cording artists,
a rare series of gigs with Bayou Seco dur
ing October in Las Vegas and Albuquer
que, NM. David Holt's touring schedule
for Nov., Dec., and Jan., includes dates in

Jackson,

Womack,

Cephas. The

TN, NC, MO, MA, and TX. For more

infor

mation contact High Windy Prod. 704-6281728. Cathy Fink &amp; Marcy Marxer's touring
Send items for inclusion in Here &amp; There to:
Here &amp;There, The Old-Time Herald, PO Box

51812, Durham, NC 27717.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in PA, NJ,
NY, MD and VA. Contact Barbara Simon
21 2-980-5920 for info.

Events
Old-Time Fiddlers Get Togethers at the
Boone County Historical Museum at
Nifong Park

in

Columbia, MO will take

place on November 1 9, December 9, Febru
ary 3, March 3 &amp; 17, April 7 &amp; 21, and May
5. For more information call Tom Prater at

314-443-8936. The Old-Time Herald admin
istered, booked, and programmed the Tra
ditional Music &amp; Dance Stage at the 1993
Merle Watson Festival in Wilkesboro, NC.
It was a huge success and we will be doing
the stage again at this year's festival on Apr
28-May
In

Print

1,

1994.

&amp; In

Following

School
the

monumental

Neil

Rosenberg edited collection Transforming
Tradition, this fall the University of Illi
nois Press (217-244-4689)
will publish: Trav
eling the High Way Home: Ralph Stanley
and the World of Traditional Bluegrass

Music by John Wright; Steven Tracy's Go
ing to Cincinnati: A History of Blues in the

Queen

City;

Athapaskan
in

The

Cooked Stovepipe:

Fiddle Music

and

Square

Northeast Alaska and North

Dancing
west Canada from Craig Mishler, and Pay
ing the Piper: Causes and Consequences of
Art Patronage edited by Judith Huggins
Balfe. The University of Missouri Cultural
Heritage Center, directed by Howard
Marshall, closed its doors on June 30, 1993.
Its Tradition newsletter has ceased publi
cation. The Traditional Arts Apprenticeship
Program and Missouri Performing
Traditions have moved to the University of
Missouri's Museum of Art &amp; Archaeology
as the Missouri Folk Arts Program. The US
Postal Service will honor The Carter Fam
ily with a stamp appearing this autumn.

The Women of Virginia Historic Trail

re

cently inducted Mother Maybelle Carter.
Thanks to Janet Stessl of Zither Newsletter

USA (312-631-2854), zithers had a prominent
place at July's Fretted Instrument Guild of
America convention in Chicago. Beginning
with its May/June issue Sing Out! (215865-5366) took on a new, larger look, intro
a 7

ducing

by 10 inch size with three columns

per page. Founded more than 40 years ago by
1993 Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award
recipient Pete Seeger and published by the

non-profit Sing Out! Corporation, Sing Out! is
folk and multicultural

the oldest continuing

music magazine.

Organizations
The

Old-Time Music Group, publishers

of the Old-Time Herald, has

adopted

a

new,

project called Old-Time
Music on the Radio (OTR). OTR "is open

self-supporting

everyone who wishes

to be

to

involved and

who has an interest in building a stronger
future for both traditional music and the
radio community." OTR recently published
its first

quarterly newsletter and

is

plan

ning an Old-Time Music &amp; Radio Confer
ence for Mt. Airy, NC on May 31-June 2,
1994. For more information contact John
Lilly of the Augusta Heritage Center at
304-636-1903. Barbara Lau has joined the
staff of the Southern Arts Federation (404874-7244) as Folk Arts Co-ordinator, work
ing with Folk Arts Program Director Peggy
Bulger. SAF assisted Arts International in a
June tour of a dozen folk artists to Australia.
Tour participants included Joe &amp; Odell

Thompson, the Gospel Christian Singers,
and the Badgett Sisters. The Florida State
Fiddlers Association (P.O. Box 713,
Micanopy, FL 32667) provides a quarterly
newsletter and sponsors the Florida State
Fiddlers Convention on the third weekend
of October.

Tne Sixth Annual

Folk

Alli

ance Conference happens in Boston, MA
on February 1 7-20, 1 994. For more informa
tion:

The

Folk

Alliance

(P.O.

Box 5010,

Chapel Hill, NC 27514). The Western Mu
sic Association (602-323-3311) presents its 5th
Music
Festival
in Tucson,
AZ
Annual Western

�on

November 11-14. Woodland Artists,

an

pub
Lexington,
newsletter announcing local events,
radio shows, dances, etc. Info: Woodland Art

arts organization

lishes

in

KY

a

ists, 125 Preston Ave., Lexington, KY 40502.

Recordings, Instruments,

&amp;

Labels

(301 -443-231 4)
and
the
Blue Grass
Bill
Monroe
released
1956-1969
and Bill
Live
Recordings
Boys:

Smithsonian/Folkways

Monroe &amp; Doc Watson: Live Duet Record
ings, 1963-1980. They feature completely
unreleased performances. The 75-minute
Bill Monroe CD was culled from concert,

session, and workshop tapes made by
collectors including Ralph Rinzler, who
contributes extensive liner notes. The many
Blue Grass Boys featured include Peter
jam

Rowan, Bill Keith, Tex Logan, Del McCoury,
Joe Stuart, and Bobby Hicks. The

and Watson release comes

live sets they performed

as

from
a

Monroe
several

duet from

1963 through 1966 and one 1980 perfor
mance. This 45-minute CD includes both

instrumentals and re-creations of Monroe
Brother performances. Smithsonian/Folk
ways has moved from Rounder to Koch

International for distribution. Paul
Grace
next

&amp;

Win

Family have completed their
I Hear The Music,

and

CD, In Dreams

in August. Their music will be
used in a musical play about the history of
Boone County, MO. Recent and upcoming

released

June Appal (606-633-01 08) releases include
Come All You Tenderhearted by Ginny

Hawker and Kay Justice, Seedtime on the
Cumberland Vol. II, and Music of Home
Crafts Days. Phil &amp; Gaye Johnson's Moun
tain Flower &amp; The Lost Broadcast, consist
made for the 1985
radio
"The Liberty Flyer"
series, has been
released on cassette and CD by Aster Pro

ing of live recordings

Copper Creek Records

ductions.

of

Roanoke, VA has released On Radio: Vol
umes One and Two, two CDs of Blue Sky
Boys transcriptions

from 1946 and 1947.

Alligator Records will
sic material

be

re-releasing clas

from the vaults of Trumpet

Records. Chicago's Delmark Records is
celebrating its 40th anniversary as a blues
label with

a

19-track compilation album.

On The Air

"The Northeast Folk Festival," a live
performance, acoustic music radio pro
gram, has expanded to two hours, 8:3010:30 pm, on the third Wednesday of each
month. During the past year traditional and

contemporary folk, blues, bluegrass, and
old-time guest artists have appeared on the
program,

which can be heard in parts of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

seven states and provinces over the North
east Network of Albany, NY's WAMC ra
dio. Folk Alliance members Anson Olds
and Paul Kleinwald play in the "Northeast
Folk Festival" house band which plays for
a
portion of each show in addition to the
guest performers. Olds hosts the show
which is produced by Storrs Olds for
ForestEdge Productions (Star Route 62, Box
27, Great Barrington, MA 01230).
88.7
Appalshop's radio station WMMT-FM
(306 Madison, Whitesburg, KY 41858) of
fers a diverse range of programming including
some old-time and bluegrass mu
sic. "The Cedar

Social,"

a

Cable Access St.

Paul program hosted by Pop Wagner and

Adam Granger, earned a Minnesota Com
munity Television Award for Best Perform
ing Arts Event in the professional category
for an

episode featuring Peter Ostroushko,

Dean MaGraw, and Kathy &amp; Leo Lara. In
addition to Tony Ellis, recent editions of
"All Things Considered" on U.S. National
Public Radio have featured Michael Doucet,
Lead Belly, and Ralph Stanley. The Lead
Belly story reported from the April 18 dedi

memorial at his grave site in
northwest Louisiana. The winter/spring

cation of

a

issue of the Lead Belly Letter (P.O. Box 6679,
Ithaca, NY 14851) contains details of the
event. Stanley turned up in, of all places,
the September 22 number of the Wall Street

"...
Horses Sing None of It!" is a
weekly folk-oriented public access cable
TV series produced and hosted bybanjoist
Ralph Litwin and is on Sammons Cable
Channel 3 Sundays at 7:30 pm. "Music

journal.

Masters &amp; Rhythm Kings" is the title of a
video documentary featuring Pappy Sherrill
&amp; the Hired Hand s, Florencio Baro &amp; Eri Okan,
Eddie Kirkland, and Neal Pattman. It will air
on Geoigia Public TV's 9-station network on

Nov. 13 at 9:00 pm. Old-time music makes up
about a third of the Folk Show broadcast
every Sunday from 3-6

pm

on CCSU-FM 90.5

Collins, CO. KCSU Lory Student Center,
Collins, CO 80522. The Hint Hils Special

in Ft.
Ft.

show on KANU -FM
a

91 .5

Lawrence KS plays
a newsletter.

variety of music. They put out

Hills Special, KANU 91.5 FM,
Broadcasting
Hall, Univ. Of
Kansas, Lawrence,
KS 66045.
Info:

Hint

Congratulations
NAIRD Indie winners include:
Gatemouth
tor);Cajun/Zydeco:

Brown's

No

LookingBack

Blues:
(Alliga

HomeMusic With Spirits

(Arhoolie) by the Savoy-Doucet Cajun Band;
Gospel:

The

Gospel Hummingbirds'

(continued

Steppin'

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Out (Blind Pig); String Music: Rambler
(Sugar Hill) by the Red Clay Ramblers. Doc
Watson, who records for Sugar Hill, was

inducted into the Independent Music Hall of
Fame. IBMA Award of Merit Winners for 1993

include Curly Ray Cline, Hazel Dickens, Jim
Eanes, and Charles R. Freeland. Courtie
Higgins celebrated his 70th birthday with an
"Eastern style" square dance at the

Williamsburg Grange Hall, Williamsburg,
MA. Bob Livingston was the caller.
Final Notes
Larry MacBride, 48, co-founder and
president of Marimac Recordings and a
member of the Volo Bogtrotters, died on
Crown Point, Indiana after a
August
2-month battle with cancer [see page 52],
"Boss" Sewell, legendary banjo stylist from
17 in

KY passed away in early July.
Mary Ruth Newell Morgan, 57, singer,
autoharpist, and instrument builder, died

Lexington,

of cancer on

August 17 in Chattanooga,
TN. She and her husband Tom, built and
repaired fine stringed instruments. Besides

designing and creating banjos, Mary hand
cut intricate mother-of-pearl inlays. With
their children, the Morgans toured and

recorded asafamily band, performingat more
than 100 schools through

programs.

artist-in-education

Bev Stiver writes in memory of Carole
Desjardins: "Our dear friend Carole, died

September 3, 1 993, one year to the day after
being diagnosed with brain cancer. She has
touched many of our lives. Over the years

hundreds

musicians, dancers,

of

and

friends have been fed Carole and Michael's
gourmet food, 'novelty7 desserts, Sunday
morning mimosas in stumble tumblers for
the weak of foot, and gourmet iced coffee
with maple syrup so we could party into
the night.
whether or not we could afford
to put

anything

in the

donation

jar.

Sum

mer festivals will never be quite the same!

Friends gathered to participate in a 'Cel
ebration of Carole's Life' on October 16 in
Schenectady, New York. They brought re
membrances, potluck, and music. Words of
support and encouragement may be sent to
Michael Slik

at

Box 422, RD5, Pangburn Rd.,

Schenectady, NY 12306."
Born in 1919 in the

community

of Laurel

Madison County, North Caro
lina, Tommy Hunter was an influential
fiddler recipient of many honors and
awards including the North Carolina Folk
Heritage Award in 1989. He recorded sev
eral albums: Orange Blossom Special (Pres
tige International 13026), Deep in Tradition
Branch

in

(June Appal), and Say Old Man (Ivy Creek
The Center for Appalachian Stud

ICR 201

ies at Mars Hill College

is the repository of
hiscollec ted tunes. Tommy Hunter
was a mentor to his young cousin Doug
Phillips, a Madison County fiddler, and

many of

passed on many of his tunes to him. Doug
wrote the following remembrance in honor
of "Tommy Hunter, Kind Friend, Family,
Teacher, Master Fiddler:
"Master Fiddler Tommy Hunter of Mars
Hill, North Carolina died August 20, 1993.
had the honor of learning some of his
tunes and style with his personal help.
I

I

spent many hours at his home over the past
few years, learning and discussing his fid
dling. Although he felt poorly most of the
time, he would always take time to show
me anything I asked of him on the fiddle.
His patience, kindness, and smooth fiddle
will be missed in Madison County, North
and far beyond. However, his
music and kind memories will live forever
in the mountains and valleys of western
North Carolina and elsewhere, and in the
hearts of all who knew and heard Tommy
play. count his death as a great loss of a
family member, true friend, and fellow

Carolina

I

musician. He was truly the
smoothest fiddler ever heard."
traditional

I

(continued

on page 51)

�SUPPORT THE FOLKS WHO ADVERTISE IN THE OLD-TIME
HERALD and tell them you saw their ad in our magazine.
PLEASE

Notice!

COMING!

As of October 1, 1993, subscription rates to the Old-Time
Herald increased to $18 for one year and $34 for two years.

Foreign rates increased to $21 for one year and $40 for two
years. Please subscribe and renew at the new rates. Note
special back issue offer on page 34. Back issues make a great
Holiday Gift
THE

OLD-TIME

Don't forget to order gift subscriptions for
your friends. They will enjoy the Old-Time
Herald year 'round. Use the gift subscrip
tion forms

to the

and return

right, along withthisform,

(Please Print)

Payment
Name (as

by: VISA
it

&amp; Times of KenFiddler
Jim Bowles by Jim
tucky

fax)

MasterCard d]

Check

O

I

And More
gift sub
scription of the Old-TimeHeraldto
the following people:
Yes!

-year $18

Q

2-years $34

LH

Foreign:

dl

Festival Guide 1994

(919) 490-6578

1

$21 &amp; $40 U.S.

Other

I

I

I

wish

to

give

a

Name
Address

appears on card)

Ad dress

City

State

Zip

State

Zip

State

Zip

The gift is from:

City, State, Zip

Credit Card Number

Expiration Date

Name
Address

Signature
Day Telephone

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&amp;

Nelson

FAX (919) 490-6578 (call on fax phone

to us.

Austin

The Life

Durham, NC 27717

to

of

by Bill Malone

ThreadgilTs

PO Box 51812

when ready

ISSUE OF

NEXT

Memories

THE OLD-TIME HERALD

HERALD

THE

IN

City
The gift

is

from:

Name
Address

City
The gift is from:

�Legends― No.

9

The Skillet Lickers

by John Lilly

"A

Iright, old gal, it's
to kill

a

good morning

hogs! The wind's from the

right place this mornin'. Lookin' for some
fellas down here to help me make some

music, too. Maybe they come in time, help
me kill these hogs, and have some fresh
meat. It's about to give out.
Yonder they
come now!"
"Hello, Gid!"
"Hello there, Lowe. Hey there, Fate! Yessir!
Thinkin' bout killin' hogs.
a-comin' down here aimin'

I

knowed you all's
to have some mu

along with some fresh meat."

sic

mornin'

this
"Mighty good
Gid.
cold.
Frost
around
It's
awful
mornin',
here, and you got a good drink around here
"Yeah!"

anywhere.

?"

"Alright, I've sure got that. You just take
a

good

Get

'n,

boys, and go put

a

fire on the pot.

some water lit."

"Sure!"
"Fine!"
Yeah!"
"I

like backbone!"

"That's good liquor!"
"Boys, take a little drink. You

a

Hey,

it

a

to

depicted in at least 20 recorded skits by this
legendary stringband during the 1920s and
'30s, (like "Hog Killin' Day," above)
moonshining, bootlegging, hog killing, and
honey-gathering were all good occasions
to "play a little piece." Traditional tunes

and songs were used by this motley crew of
north Georgia musicians to soothe bees,

finalize agreements, or simply pass the
time while waiting for any of a wide range
of events to occur. Their instruments were

warmin' up, whaddya say we play
tune around here?"

a

little

"Aaaalright."
"What do you want to play, Riley?"
"Why don't we play that Mississippi

Sawyer?"
"Oh, yeah!"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

cross-section of

folk and popular music of the day, yet was
totally unique and inimitable.
The

individuals who

all came from north

made

up

this group

an area rich in

Georgia,
traditional music during the early part of
this century. In various combinations, they
played in bands together and in competi
tions against one another for a number of
years before radio and the fledgling re
cording industry brought them together
into

a

somewhat cohesive unit.

The first of these musicians

to gain

the

utilized

recording bearing the Columbia label.

been earning respect and a few odd dollars
around Atlanta as an entertaining vaude

handy, always in tune, and usually
to play a small sampling of a num
which
was available in its entirety on a
ber
always

mid- to
late-1920s,
an equally fantastic scenario was
being plaved out, Old-time fiddle contests
were being reviewed in the pages of the
Atlanta Constitution. New York recording
companies were stopping hillbillies on the
In

lar

the real world of Atlanta

in

hopes

of

in the

discovering the next popu
chicken farmer,
jazz-influenced auto

recording artist. And

blind balladeer,

a

a

mechanic, and

while the water's

years. Their music was

interest of Columbia Records was James
Gideon (Gid) Tanner. Born in 1884 (or 1885),
Gid was a chicken farmer by trade, but had

a

I

"Alright.

good piece, alright!"
it!" And so they did. In the
world
of the Skillet Lickers as
imaginary

street

want

little drink, Riley?"
"B'lieve do!"
Gid,

"That's

"Saw

an enigmatic banjo player
were making history.
The Skillet Lickers were arguably the
most influential old-time string band to

ever record. They were brought together
for the express purpose of making records
by

Columbia recording executive

Walker

in

1926,

Frank

and went on to cut over 100

tunes, songs, and skits over the next eight

ville-style comedian and fiddler. He was
often compared to-- and competed
Fiddlin' John Carson. When
against-Carson

was recorded by the Okeh com

pany in 1923 and became an instant suc
cess, Tanner was an obvious choice when
Columbia went fishing in Georgia for an
other rural celebrity.
Along with Gid Tanner on his first Co
lumbia recording session in New York on
March

7,

1924, was guitarist and singer,

George Riley Puckett. Accounts vary
whose idea

it

as to

was to include Puckett on these

important first sessions, but the combination
worked like magic. Riley, as he was known,
was born around 1890, and was acciden
tally blinded

at

the age of three months by
a minor

inappropriate medical treatment for

�eye irritation. As a teenager, he taught him
self to play the banjo, and later, the guitar.
By his adult years he was supporting him
self as a street singer.
This initial Tanner/Puckett recording
session marked Columbia's first venture
into the hillbilly music field They recorded
a total of 17 numbers, including a handful
of solos by each artist. (One of

these solos

by Puckett, "Rock All Our Babies T o Sleep,"
became the first recorded performance of

country singer, pre-dating
Jimmie Rod gersby three years.) These same
two individuals were invited back in Sep
tember of that year when they cut 37 more
sides. At this session, the emphasis shifted

yodeling by

a

traditional favorites such

as "Little

Brown

The Straw," and "You
Jug," "Turkey
Gotta Quit Kickin' My Dog Around ." From
In

the start, the band and its recordings seem

have been a very free-wheeling affair,
with musicians floating in and out of the
studio, and a bathtub full of gin keeping
the players in the proper mood. And this
mood, by their own account, was "hotter
than a firecracker lit at both ends!"
lhe sound the Skillet Lickers went tor
to

was raucous, aggressive, and deceptively
sophisticated. The primary instrumenta
tion consisted of Gid Tanner and Clayton

McMichen playing twin fiddles, Fate Norris
on banjo, and Riley Puckett playing guitar
and doing most of the singing. Tanner was
a very traditional fiddler in his early 40s

with

a straight ahead square-dance style of
playing, while McMichen was a very pro
gressive player in his mid-20s, who was

highly trained and tended to prefer "modem"
music. Much can be learned from listening to
the way in which these two contrasting musi
cians blended their fiddling together into a
full and unified sound. The guitar playing
and singing of Riley Puckett was seen

(continued

at

the

on next page)

Riley, who recorded 10 solo pieces, 10
songs with Gid as an uncredited accompa
nist, and at least one number which fea

to

tured Riley's banjo playing.
In

1925, Columbia

signed

a

hot young

fiddler who was on the rebound from an

unsuccessful association with Okeh
Records, and was looking to put his days as
an auto mechanic behind him. Clayton
McMichen, born in 1900, was only 25 years
old at the time, but was already a seasoned
and

a

dedicated

musician. He had orga

nized several bands by then, including one
which was known alternately as the Home
Town Boys, or the Lick The Skillet Band.
Columbia executive Frank Walker quickly
came up with the idea of putting together

a

the Tanner/

"super group" by matching
Puckett duo with Clayton McMichen.
The fourth memberofthis new band was
Fate Norris,

a

banjo player from the At

lanta talent pool about whom very little is
written. Given the seat-of-the-pants artist

selection process of thetime, it is difficult to
know whether Frank Walker chose Fate
based on his own instincts, or if Norris was
brought into the situation by one of the
other three artists.

Charles

Tanner and His Skillet Lickers with
the next releases were "Gid
Puckett";
Riley
Tanner and his Skillet Lickers with Riley
Puckett and Clayton McMichen." The ma
terial they recorded ranged from pop songs

Wolfe

The first Skillet Licker recording ses
sion
they adopted a variation on
was held in April
McMichen'sband name
1926 in Atlanta, which was to be the sight of
all the band's subsequent Columbia ses
sions. These first recordings were released

like "It's

a

Long Way To Tipperary" to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Courtesy

as "Gid

The Skillet Lickers in one of their earliest

Puckett

on

guitar

Conspicuous

in

publicity photos, about 1926. Gid Tanner

(L). Others are probably Doc Walsh (banjo)

his absence is Clayton

McMichen.

is on

fiddle, Riley

and Arthur Tanner (guitar).

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

time as the item of greatest interest to the

record-buying

public.

According

to

Riley didn't sing, it didn't
sell. Puckett's guitar playing was equally

McMichen,

inspiring

if

and

added dimensions

to

the

music that no other band could approach.
Most notably, he produced a deep, clear
tone on his bass strings which he utilized to
play imaginative, though occasionally ob
tuse, runs and fills. His playing technique
has been the subject of much debate over
the years, fueled by conflicting accounts by
other band members, acquaintances, and
witnesses. According to researcher Norman
Cohen, "It strikes me as remarkable that so

could have such differ

many musicians.
ent

views

on

how Puckett played.

.Can

we conclude no more than that he made his
bass runs with either his thumb or with one
or two fingers, picking either upwards or

downwards?

So it

seems, for the present."

For his part, Fate Norris added inestimably
to the rhythm of the band with his banjo

playing.
It is difficult

to say ho w many recordings
were actually made with this precise four

man line-up. As mentioned, the recording
sessions were loosely run, and many other

musicians eventually became part of the

Skillet Lickers. Among this group of musi
cians were some of the finest players in
Georgia. Perhaps the greatest of these was
Lowe

Stokes.

It

is

widely believed

that

Stokes' appearance at a north Georgia fid
dlers contest in 1925 was immortalized in
Stephen Vincent Benet's popular poem,
"The Mountain Whippoorwill."

After the

Columbia sessions, Stokes reput
edly played "lead" fiddle on the majority
of Skillet Lickers recordings. He was an
exceptionally gifted fiddler who was
equally at home with the traditional reper
first two

toire of Gid Tanner or the challenging tech

nique of Clayton McMichen.
Other important additions to the Skillet
Lickers'

Atlanta sessions included

Bert

Layne, Slim Bryant, and Arthur Tanner.
Layne was a fine fiddler and also brotherin-law to Clayton McMichen. Slim Bryant
was a talented multi-instrumentalist who
shared McMichen's leanings toward swing
music. Arthur Tanner was Gid's younger
brother who occasionally played second
guitar for the Skillet Lickers in addition to
recording some sides with Gid as The Tan
ner Boys. Additionally there were Georgia
fiddler Bill Helms; clarinetist

K. D.

Chattanooga fiddler-guitarist

Malone;

Claude

Davis; guitarists Gus Adams, Mike Whitten
and Hoke Rice; mandolinist Ted Hawkins;

and fiddler Bill Shore who claimed that "so
far

as

played

was concerned, anyone who
with him was a Skillet Licker

Gid

even John Carson!"
While recording was the catalyst that
brought the Skillet Lickers together, it was
live performances that kept them fed V arying conglomerations of the above men
tioned peripheral Skillet Lickers would
accompany an inexact combination of
"original" band members for extensive

tours throughout the South. Many of these
shows were billed as fiddling contests and
typically lasted for three days. The first
days were devoted to Skillet Lickers per

formances and in building up excitement
for the climactic fiddling contest on the
third day. Fiddler Bill Helms recalled some
details of these occasions. "Adults was a
quarter, children fifteen cents. We'd pick
up as high as $300-400 in one place. Hardly

anybody up there rode, less'n was
wagon. They'd

be

to hear us,

coming

in

a

down

mountains, on mules and
horses, wagons. Used lanterns in those
out of those

days, didn't have any electric light at all.
Old kerosene lanterns: you could see 'em
like little bugs at night coming way back

'cross those mountains there, coming down
there totin' those lanterns along, have it in
a
wagon with them, so they could see which
way they were going. I'd never seen noth
ing like that before."

According to researcher and author
Charles Wolfe, "When the Skillet Lickers
did their stage shows in the late 1920s, each
member had a wacky specialty: Gid Tan
ner could turn his head almost all the way
around and put three hen eggs in his mouth
and close it; banjoist Fate Norris had a oneman band contraption as well as a 'Talking
Doll' which would occasionally expecto
rate on by-standers crowding too close to

stage; Clayton McMichen did occa
sional blackface skits; and Bert Layne did a

the

wonderful 'old fogey' imitation." Although
much of this comedy was visual, the sense
of humor within the group played well on
record in the form of comedy skits. These
skits served several purposes. They sold
well as novelty records. "A Corn Licker

Georgia," a fourteen-part mini-se
ries on seven 78 r.p.m. records, has sold
over a million copies (according to liner
notes on a re-issue LP from Voyager Record
ings). Additionally, the skits functioned as
Still

In

advertisements

for

Skillet Lickers
short samples of

other

by featuring

recordings
tunes recorded elsewhere by the group.
They also might have served as comic relief

�for

a

group which survived

in

spite of

tremendous personal and musical differ

In fact, a large number of the skits
used the device of a fiddling contest to

ences.

showcase each of the individual talents

in

the group and to possibly find a construc
tive use for the substantial amount of com

petitiveness

which

the

band

members

shared.
Partially due to the growing differences
within thegroup,and partly becauseofthe

deepening economic depression through
Lickers dis
Considerable chaos en
sued. Over the next two or three years,
the Skillet

out the country,
banded in 1931.

there appeared to be a number of groups
performing live and on radio using the

name "Skillet Lickers." Norman Cohen
writes. "In 1931 at WLW (Cincinnati, Ohio)

photo showing McMichen, Slim Bryant,
Pat Perryman, and Johnny Barfield was
labelled (as) the Skillet Lickers. In October,
1932 at WCKY (Covington, Kentucky) the
band seemed to consist of McMichen,
a

Layne, Bryant, and Jack Donegan. But in
December of that year, at the national oldtime fiddling contest, a Skillet Lickers photo
showed Layne, McMichen, Bryant, and
Puckett." Meanwhile, Gid and Riley con
tinued to ply their trade as the Skillet Lickers
in Georgia and Alabama. To make matters
even more complicated, this same extended

family of musicians performed
corded in

a

and

re

dizzying array of configura

tions and under

(Ezra) Hawkins, and driver Dan Hornsby
who added some vocals. Cut in San Anto
nio, Texas, on March 29-30, 1934, these
sides featured a distinctly different sound

Gid Tanner died in 1960. Gordon even
tually became involved in a group with his
son Phil, also a fiddler. This group was

than the earlier Columbia recordings due
to Hawkins' mandolin work and the

later as Skillet Lickers

younger Tanner's unique fiddling style.
The absence of McMichen's modernizing
influence might also have been felt in the
choice of material which was recorded.
"Mississippi Sawyer," "BackUpand Push,"
"Ida Red," "Soldier's Joy," and a list of
other mountain music standards filled out
the two dozen musical numbers. Perhaps
fittingly, the last two recordings made by
the Skillet Lickers were

a

pair of skits called

"Prosperity and Politics," and "Practice
Night with the Skillet Lickers."
Gid Tanner's Skillet Lickers continued a
pattern of personal appearances and radio
shows for the next few years, but things
were clearly winding down. Gid, Riley,

and Gordon were playing

in

Birmingham,

Alabama when the band fell on hard times
and was reduced to playing for hand-outs
at the local farmer's market. Gordon per

suaded his father

to let him go back

home

initially known

Junior Skillet Lickers,
II. Gordon Tanner
in
1982.
Since
then, Phil Tan
passed away
ner has kept a Skillet Lickers band together,
now including a fourth generation of fid
dling Tanners; his son Russ, born in 1969.
as the

This group continues to perform around
north Georgia, and their recent recordings,
Skillet Licker Music 1955

1991; The Tanner
Cassette
C31 0) and Phil
(Global
Legacy
Village
Tanner's Skillet Lickers; The Tanner Legacy Now
(Global Village Cassette C311) were reviewed
in the OTH spring, 1993 (vol. 3, no. 7.)

Riley Puckett remained professionally
active in music until his death in 1946. His

tremendous singing and guitar playing
gave him entry into many performing situ
ations, and he was a band member, back
up musician, and solo entertainer in a vari
ety of settings

throughout those years. He

reportedly found
ence

a

particularly good audi

fields of Texas and Oklahoma,
frequently touring with his tent show.
Clayton McMichen quit using the Skillet
in the oil

to

Georgia. Both Tanners ended upbackon
the chicken farm and neither was musically

Lickers moniker and formed the Georgia

active for several years. During the early 1950s,
Gid and Gordon put together a Skillet Lickers

had an active career of recording for Decca
and broadcasting over several radio sta

band with some local musicians and played on
a radio show out of Athens,
Georgia as well as

tions, mostly in the Louisville, Kentucky

some regional appearances.

Wildcats

in 1932. This

area. McMichen

swing-styled band

continued

to

(continued

establish his
on next page)

long list of other names
both during and after the Skillet Lickers'
a

recording years. Among these were
McMichen's Hometown Band, McMichen's

Melody Men, the McMichen-Layne String
Orchestra, the Georgia Organ Grinders,
Lowe Stokes' North Georgians, the Geor
gia Wildcats, Fate Norris and the Tanner
Boys, Arthur Tanner and his Cornshuckers,

the Georgia Boys, and many duo combina
tions involving McMichen, Puckett, Tan
ner, Norris, Stokes, and others. Clayton
McMichen and Slim Bryant even toured

and recorded

some in 1931 with Jimmie
who
recorded
McMichen's "Peach
Rodgers,
Pickin' Time Down In Georgia."

1934, the Victor recording company, hav
survived
the depression, recorded the Skil
ing
let Lickers for its Bluebird label. In some ways
Wolfe

In

Charles

these were the most successful recordings the
group was to make, and yielded their best

Courtesy

selling record, "Down Yonder."
Personnel for this session included Gid

Tanner, his seventeen year-old fiddling son
Gordon Tanner, Riley Puckett, mandolinist

and

long-time Puckett associate Ted

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

L-R: Bert Layne, Lowe Stokes, Shorty Godwin,

Clayton McMichen, Claude Davis.

�dominance on the fiddle contest circuit by

winning

the national fiddle

championship

fewer than 18 times. During the 1960s,
he was "rediscovered" by the young audi
no

ence of the folk revival and came out of
musical retirement for a series of concerts
and interviews. He died in 1970.

Lowe Stokes

lost his right hand

in

a

bootlegging incident sometime in the late
'20s or early 1930s. In a remarkable feat of
rehabilitation, he fashioned a device onto
his prosthesis which enabled him to clamp
onto his fiddle bow, and he returned to
performing, actually rising to the level of
winning fiddle contests using his new con
traption. He retired to Oklahoma and
in 1983.

passed away

were, of course, no Billboard
for old-time records back in

charts
There

the 1920s, but there is abundant evi
dence that the companies and A &amp; R

men kept track of sales and acted ac
cordingly. One of the reasons the Skillet
Lickers recorded so often was that their
discs sold better than those of any other

string band In fact, in the annals of oldtime music only the sales of Jimmie
Rodgers and the Carter Family actually

exceeded those

of Gid Tanner and his

crew. The best selling

Columbia

record,

Lickers

Skillet

15074,

sold over

it

one of the

200,000

copies, making
highest selling (though not the highest
selling) entry in the Columbia catalogue.
Using sales figures from theColumbia files,

we can determine the 10 best selling Licker
discs, and these are printed below.
It is

always sobering

to

compare the

actual sales figures of an artist's reper
toire with those songs we think of as
important or memorable. Even today
this yields odd surprises.
for

Bill

Monroe,

instance, only shows up with two

charted singles in the modern Billboard
charts, and they are not "Uncle Pen" but
"Scotland" and "GottaTravelOn." Like
wise, some Skillet Lickers favorites of
modern fans never really were among
their top sellers; the fans of 1926 and
1927 preferred pieces like "Hand Me

Down My Walking Cane," which has
not even been reissued on the major
collections by County or Rounder. In
general, Columbia sales of old-time
music overall were at their highest in
1926, and

consistentlydeclined afterthat.

(Victor sales were similar.) Thus, most

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of the

biggest hits date from the 1926 and

1927 period.

Sometime soon
hope to compile a
more comprehensive list of actual oldtimebest-sellers. In the meantime, thanks

difficult to find an old-time musician
today who has not been influenced by the
Skillet Lickers, either directly or through
the many bands and musicians who have
walked in their footsteps. The Skillet Lickers
were among the first (relatively) organized
stringbands to record, and in so doing, they
set the tone for generations of musicians to
It is

Their repertoire and their unique
versions of standard melodies, are still in
very active use everywhere old-time fiddle
music is played Riley Puckett's pioneering
come.

use of bass notes and runs on guitar led the
way for countless future guitarists, includ
ing the renowned Doc Watson, who credits

Puckett

as a major influence. The multiple
fiddling style characteristic of the Skillet
Lickers can also be heard at any old-time
music gathering, and was re-popularized
during the 1970s by the success of the
High woods Stringband. The overall sense

recklessness

to the following for help with the project:
Harold Edwards, Dave Freeman,

Skillet Lickers' music
tone that predominated
traditional music circles during the 1970s,
with bands like the Corn Dodgers, Easy
Street, Plank Road, and many others enjoy

Michael Brooks, Tony Russell, and Tina

ing the

I

Lickers'

1.

Hits

Bully of the Town/Pass

15074

Co

Greatest

Around the Bottle (207,149

released

May 1926)
2. Co 15091

skits and

Co 15201 A Com Licker Still in Georgia,
released Dec. 192 7).
1 and 2 (160,693

Gotta Quit Kickin' My
Around /Turkey in the Straw

Co 15084

Dog

(83,939
5

Ya

released July 1926).

Co 15258 A Corn Licker Still in Georgia,
released June 1928).
3 and 4 (75,599
Co 15140

A

Georgia, Parts

1

Fiddler's Convention in
released
and 2(74,123

May 1927).
7.

Co 15108

Old Joe

Clark/Dance

8. Co

in Your Hand
a Bottle
released Dec. 1926).

15142

Southern Old

John

Henry/Wreck of the

97 (60,641

released May

1927).
9. Co

15170

The Old Grey Mare/Girl

Left Behind Me (54,335

released Aug.

1927).

Johnson's Old Gray Mule/
Uncle Bud (46,328 released Feb. 1928).
10. Co 15221

―Charles Wolfe

little too literally.
be written

about this legendary band and the lumi
naries who comprised it. Gid Tanner, Riley
Puckett, Clayton McMichen, and Lowe

Stokes could each be the subject of fascinat
ing study, and the field is wide open for

exist and were the basis for this writing.
These include Norman Cohen's article in

All

Night with
(70,451

a

practically any research at all regarding
banjoist Fate Norris. Surprisingly little has
been published on this influential group of
musicians, but a few excellent articles do

Parts
6.

comedy

Volumes can, and should,

Parts
4.

a

ing problems were launched over the years by
young pickers who took the Skillet Lickers'

Watermelon on the Vine/
Hand Me Down My Walking Cane
released Sept. 1926)
(181,675
3.

in the

and skits also set

"license to have fun" issued by
those early recordings. On a different note,
the stereotype of the irresponsible, lazy,
moonshining hillbilly was perhaps per
petuated by the Skillet Lickers' personae,
and one can only imagine how many drink

McCarthy.

Skillet

of

I

the Journal of American Folklore, July-Sept.,
1965 entitled "The Skillet Lickers: A Study
of

a

Hillbilly Stringband and

Its

Reper

toire"; several writings by Dr. Charles K.
Wolfe including liner notes to re-issue LPs
on

Rounder Records, and

sert booklet called

a

wonderful in

The Kickapoo Medicine

Show, and Richard Nevins' writings in The
Devil's Box and on liner notes for re-issue
LPs on County Records.

Fortunately, most of the Skillet Lickers
recordings were re-issued on LPs during
(continued

on page 51)

�Newsletter Published
Conference, Survey in the

OTR

Works

Old-Time

Music on the Radio (OTR), a
the Old-Time Music
Group,

project of

Inc.,

recently published its first organiza

tional newsletter and sent

it

1,000 radio programmers,

musicians, arts

out

to

nearly

organizations, record companies, and supporters
of traditional music. The four-page
quarterly publication introduced many
readers to the efforts of OTR, its steering
committee members, and the issues which
confront the music and broadcast commu
nities today. It also served as a fundraising
tool to facilitate the full range of activities
which OTR has undertaken, including sta

tistical research, lobbying efforts, and con
ference organizing.
Response to the initial OTR Newsletter
was enthusiastic and an

encouraging num

ber of readers have also participated in the

fundraising aspect with contributions rang
ing from $20 to $50 coming in from across
the country. A radio programmer from
Australia recently became the first interna
tional contributor.
Plans for the 1994 Old-Time Music and
Radio Conference, to be held in Mt.Airy,
NC, May 31-June 2, 1994 are fast taking
shape. Keynote addresses by Dr. Charles

Wolfe and author Diana Rapaport have
been confirmed, as well as numerous panel
discussions on radio and music issues, perfor
mances and workshops by top traditional
K.

a radio station tour by WPAQ, plus
many surprises. A final conference schedule
will be solidified by mid-November.

musicians,

A

national survey of radio stations

is

being prepared by OTR. This question
naire will be sent to hundreds of broadcast
ers and will yield valuable information

concerning the availability

of

old-time

music on radio today. Among the most
anticipated results of the survey will be a
comprehensive reference list of program
mers who currently air old-time music,
which will be made available to record
companies and musicians who wish to sup
ply these broadcasters with recordings.
Anyone wishing more information about
OTR, the OTR Neivsletter, the 1994 OldTime Music and Radio Conference, or the

upcoming radio survey should contact
OTR, c/o John Lilly, PO Box 3014, Elkins,
WV, 26241.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The Dance Beat

"A

Jubilant Spirit Within Me.

Buckdance, Flatfoot,
by Phil

..."

Clogging?

or

Jamison

are many terms used to refer to
the percussive step dancing that ac

There

Appalachian fiddle
music. "Clogging," "Buckdance," "Flatfoot
dancing," and "Buck and Wing" dancing
are the most common names used here in
western North Carolina. In eastern Ken

companies southern

tucky, I've heard
(it's what you do

it

called "Hoe-downing"

the end of the day when
in the
Ozarks,
you put your hoe down), and
am told, it is commonly called "Jigging."
at

Folklife Collection in Chapel Hill. By the
end of the project, we had filmed over 40
North Carolina dancers ranging in age from

Most were in their 70s and 80s.
When we filmed these older dancers, I
was curious what they called it, so I asked

50 to 85.

them, "What are the differences between
Clogging, Buckdancing and Flatfoot danc

heard an interesting assortment of
answers to the question. Here isa sampling
ing?"

I

I

the years that traveled and performed
with the Green Grass Cloggers, when asked
In

I

question, the answer was
We
were
easy.
Clogging. The answer was
there
in
the
name of the group. My
right
the "What

is it?"

favorite place to dance though, has always
been on a dance board in the dark, late at
night, letting my feet dance out the tune
along with the fiddle and banjo, concen
trating only on the percussive sound of my
feet as an

accompaniment

am told that what

I

do

is

music.

to the

Buckdancing,

"What do you call it?"
"Its just

dancin.

I

get

up and do my thing.

I

don't know what

I

do."

I

Clogging, and that do Flatfoot steps with
some Charleston mixed in. This analysis

of what they said.
"A dogger, he mostly

aroused my curiosity about just what the
differences really are between these names
and dance styles. It is a question that no two
dancers can seem to agree on, so decided
to take it to the source and ask some danc
ers of the older generation.
This last year, I received a grant from the
North Carolina Arts Council to videotape
traditional dancers in western North Caro

and down," Pat Maney, age 65, of Bryson
City, explained it. "He don't cover no big

I

lina. The goal was to document the old
dance styles of this area while there are still

dancers who know them, the videos to be
stored in the archives of the Southern

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

stands straight up

flatfooter] he'll bend
over and straighten back up and dance all
area like

around.

I

do, and

There's

[a

no

dance as "basically the same thing." She
says, however, "Clogging is a faster dance.

They're a lot of steps different from the oldtime Buckdance."
Out near Brasstown, in Hayesville, there
store right in the middle of town called

is a

the Peoples Store.

It

is

one of those incred

ibly over-stuffed general stores that prob
ably has one of everything that was ever
made. It is more of a museum and hang-out
for the locals than a serious retail business.
My first time there, I noticed among all the
other stuff, a pair of tap shoes that had been
painted silver. They belong to the owner,

Wayne Phillips, who is a buckdancer. He
says, "a Buckdance is one that you take up"

not

I

"Buckdancing, you get your feet up high.
Hatfooting you don't do it, you hold them
do wn on the floor. Clogging and Buckdance
are in the category of the same thing, but
Hatfooting is an altogether different thing."
On the other hand, Ora Watson, an 82year-old fiddler and dancer, also of Sugar
Grove, classifies Buckdance and Hatfoot

difference

in

Buckdancing and Clogging, same thing.
Now when I was growing up, that was
what everybody
called it. It was
Buckdancing." He says that he first heard it
called Clogging "somewhere close to 1940.
That's about when they tried to change the
name of it."
Robert Dotson, of Sugar Grove says,

as an

individual. "No two people will do

It's more or less keeping
the same step.
time with the music." He also says Tap

dancing and Clogging, which "came in in
the '50s, have a pattern and that's a step
that they learn and they go through that
routine over and over." Hatfooting "is on
the order of the Buckdance."
Buck Buchanan,

an active 66-year-old
who lives near Morganton says,
"What we call Clogging is where you keep
time with the music." He differentiates
between the modern "show-time Clog" and
the "old-time mountain Clog," which is

dancer

�what he calls his own dancing: part
Flatfooting and part Buckdancing.
"Hatfooting, you don't move, you don't

1939. He says of cloggers, "most of them
[are] doing about the same thing, but they

all on the toes.

other words, you could just about set a
cup of coffee on the top of your head. In the
Buckdance, you're moving pretty good,
your feet's going pretty high, they're going
higher off the floor.
Crossing that leg,

dancing with one foot, the rest of it will be
Actually you've got the Clog
walking.
and the Hatfoot and the Buck and W ing are
all three different dances. A Hatfoot dancer

body

that

and the toe both." The Buck and Wing is
"on the toes most of the time." Cloggers,

hardly see anything moving but your feet.
In

the family of the Buckdance.
It's
less
like
a
The
'Buckmore or
Tap dance.
Wing,' now that's shuffling your feet all
is

move their feet, they get their feet higher to
start with. And most of them will only be

is

actually going

to be

dancing on the heel

over the floor, but you're keeping time."
Ruth Mosteller, a 61 -year-old dancer,
who lives with her fiddler husband in an

"they sling one leg around and they shake
more." Buckdance is "more of a Hatfoot."
Kyle Edwards of Maggie Valley, one of
the dancers featured in Mike Seeger's Talk-

ancient log house in Jackson County, calls

ingFeet, says, "Abuckdancer,

in

my opinion,

is

A

clogger

is

clogger uses his heel, too."

different.

A

And he ac

knowledges, "You will get different an
swers anywhere in the country and every
is entitled to their opinion;
don't
want to take nothing away from anybody."
Jim Cooper is a 64-year-old dancer who
lives in Cherokee. His mother was of ScotchI

Irish descent and his father, a renowned
dancer in his own day, was Cherokee. He
and others point out the Cherokee Indian
influence in Buckdancing. "There's a lot of
the same rhythm in the Indian dances that
we have here, especially in the war dances,
the faster dances. The beat is very similar to

(continued

on next page)

her energetic dancing "Clogging," though
she says, "a lot of the old people just called

Buckdancing. But really a lot of our steps
now is partly of the Buckdance, but we still
call it Clogging now. A lot of the steps was
it

from Buckdancing. That's what they called
dancing we did here." She also points

all

out, "We all did the Charleston as we grew
up. a lot of [the Buckdance] is Charleston,

we can

and

Buckdancing,

do

some steps

with

and the Charleston is

the

actu

ally the same steps."

Eighty-five-year-old Biss Honeycutt of
Yancy County keeps his definitions simple:
"Buckdancing is what the old people would
and
do." He says that Clogging
"The
are
different.
Buckdancing
steps are
different altogether," and "doggers, they
wear taps on their shoes." [Dancers did not
wear taps on their shoes in this area until
the 1940s. My guess is that their arrival
NC

followed the amplification of the music, so
reason to

you have good leather-soled

if

Square-dance
Howell, who
call

is no

Mars

wear taps
shoes.]

amplified, there

is 81

College,

not

Robert "Chief"
years old now, used to

caller,

many of the dances

in

Hill

is

Mars

music

Hill,

that the dancers could hear their feet. When

the Maggie

Another

Haywood

County dancer

Photographic
Appalachian

and Wing."

Archives,

Valley area. He says that a "Buckand Wing"
dancer will keep his "feet not off the floor,
only high enough just to hit, as long as it's
in step with the music. Cloggers pick their
feet up. Its more of a stomping dance. Hatfoot and Buckdance are the same as Buck
I

Southern

spoke with is 75-year-old John Reeves. His
uncle was Sam Queen, legendary dancer,
caller, and leader of the Soco Gap Square

King George and Queen Elizabeth of
England at the Roosevelt White House in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Courtesy

Dancers. John Reeves danced with Soco Gap
and went with them when they performed for

Beulah Caldwell, Maggie Valley, NC

�that that we do in square dancing, and our
mountain culture and our Indian culture

have always been intertwined." As for the
name, he explains that "buck" means male
Indian and that's where the name
Buckdance comes from.

Perhaps the true spirit of Buckdancing is
best expressed by Pauline Zimmerman, of
Madison County, a Flatfoot dancer who
incorporates

the Charleston

in

her

foot

work and describes

it
simply as "a jubilant
within
me.
spirit
my own style of dancing."
So there you have it. The old-time dance

experts have spoken. In case the distinctions
between the dance styles are now as clear
as mud, here is some information about the
origins of the names and the dances to lend
an historical perspective with which to help

answer the question.

Like Clog dancing,

The word "Clog" was originally used to
describe the English step dance that is per

wooden-soled shoes to a horn
pipe. English Clog dancing was introduced
in this country early in the nineteenth cen
tury, and reached the height of its popular
formed

South, "Jig" became used as a general term
for solo dancing, and plantation owners

included on the

minstrel show stages. Clog dancing was
not restricted to whites. An ad for a circus
in New York City in 1808 included in its
billing

a

"Young African" who "will

too found its way to

scribe the dancing of blacks in New Or
leans (though it was probably not the Irish
Jig that was being done). Throughout the

in

ity in the mid-1 800s, being

it

the minstrel shows. As early as the 1830s,
the word "Jig" was also being used to de

entered their slaves in "jigging contests"
against other slaves.
Another later use of the word "Jig," was
in connection with the small carnivals that
traveled by truck and toured throughout

ex

hibit many steps of Hornpipe, on Horse
back, in full speed, without losing the mea

the South

in the early 1900s and up into the
1920s. At these shows, the black entertain
ers performed in a tent called the Jig Top,

sure of the music."
The "Jig," a step dance of Irish origin,
was imported with Irish immigrants and
became popular at roughly the same time.

featuring a minstrel-type show complete
with music, comedy, dancing, and some
times Cakewalks.
The word "buck" was used in the 1800s,
to refer to [and

dehumanize] maleslaves.lt

was also used as
is

a

term for male Indians.

thought that the word

It

"Buckdancing"

was originally used, depending on the lo
cation, to refer to the dancing of African-

Americans

or

American Indians.

clear whether or not

it

It is

un

referred to just male

dancing.
The "Pigeon Wing" was a plantation
dance, popular among slaves throughout
the South and as far west as Texas, where it
was called the "Chicken

Wing."

An ex-

Courtesy

Southern

Appalachian

Photographic

Archives,

Mars

Hill

College,

Mars

Hill,

NC

slave from Virginia described it as dancers
flapping their arms and legs around and
dancing with a stiff neck, like a bird. The
Buckdance and the Pigeon Wing were later
combined in minstrel shows and billed as

Bill

McElreath (dancing) and Bascom Lamar Lunsford (with banjo), Asheville, NC

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the Buck and Wing. Other "authentic"

Af

rican-American dances perfor. red in min
strel shows had names such as the
"Virginny Breakdown," the "Alabama
Kick-Up," the "Tennessee Double-Shuffle,"
and the "Louisiana Toe-and-Heel."
the early 1800s newly arrived Irish
immigrants and freed slaves co-existed in
In

the slums of New York City. There blacks
learned the Irish Jig and the English Clog
dance, merging them with African-American dances, and starting the eventual evo
lution in to Tap dance. Jig and Clog dancing
involve dancing in hard-soled shoes on a

wooden floor

in order to make a percussive
sound. Marshall and Jean Stearns, in their

book jazz Dance, state that "the African
style is often flat-footed and favors gliding,

dragging, or shuffling steps" because it
was danced barefoot on the ground. The
fusion of these African-American dances
with the English Clog and the Irish Jig may also

account for the divergence of American Clog

�dance from its British roots. Asa feature of
traveling minstrel shows these dances were
seen throughout the country.
A more recent dance that found its way into
the mountains to become blended with the
Buckdance

older

styles

is

the Charleston.

Pauline Zimmerman says that she learned
it up while
it from a friend who picked
South
relatives
in
Carolina
in the
visiting
late 1920s. She and many other dancers in
the region have incorporated some Charles
ton steps in their dancing.
It is believed that the Charleston, as seen
the

on

evolved

screen

Hollywood

in

the

1920s,

dance of African origin,
which was popular in Charleston and Sa
from

a

vannah just after the turn of the century.

It

became known to white audiences in
1923, when it was featured in an all-black
musical comedy on Broadway called
Runnin' Wild. The original version of the
dance, known as the Jay-Bird, has been
described as "the simple twisting of the
first

lazy sort of way." That
rhythm
much
how
the
step looks as danced
pretty

feet, to
is

in

a

first year, the dance

contest was billed

as

The following two years
(1936 and 1937), they called it "Flatfoot
dance." In later years, they just called it

"Clog dance."

"Dance." Maybe they couldn't make up
their minds what to call it.
Here in Asheville, the Asheville Citizen-

schools

as

physical education. The Clog Dance Book
(1921), presents a number of Clog dance
routines to teach children. With sugges

someone else.

Lunsford, the festival's founder, liked

doing his

to

stressing
supposed pure ScotchIrish ethnic roots. Other references found
in the newspaper include: "danced a jig"

bill

its

it,

I

(1937), "clogging" (1938), "buck and wing"
(1940), "clog dancing" (1940), "old-time
buckdance" (194 7), "flatfoot and backstep
dancer" (1948). I assume that these terms
were in common usage and used inter
changeably at the time they appeared in
doubt that the reporters
print, though
could distinguish one from another or de
I

them.

fine
As

Who

knows when they first

for group

I

own steps. When precision

thus

moving

Buckdancing

away from traditional
evolving into modern

and

dogging.
In

Flatfoot dance the feet stay close to the

floor, and the steps tend to have more of a
sliding nature rather than being up on the

toes. What I think of as Clogging steps
often tend to have (though I wish there was
a better
word for it) a stomping feel to
them. They are heavier on the heels and
harder on the knees as the body weight
tends to go up and down more. In both

Buckdance and Hatfoot dance, the dancers
(continued

when the Soco Gap Square-Dance Team
is how they were billed in the pro
gram) were invited to perform at the White

Bibliography
Cassidy, Frederick
nary

of American

G.

Regional English.

Waltz Clog," and "Dixie,"
they appear to be based on adaptations of
minstrel show routines rather than on
southern Appalachian dance. I don't know

House for the King and Queen of England,
it has been said that the Queen commented,

Duke, Jerry. Clog Dance

"That's just like our clogging,"

lachians.

how widely it was taught, but perhaps the
word "Clog" was introduced in some lo

it.

cales via this curriculum.

year and at
I've searched

while all these tributaries were feed
into
the Southern dance tradition, what
ing
did the people back in the mountains call
it? If you lived in an isolated mountain
community, before the advent of radio and
phonograph records in the 1920s, and you
only knew of one kind of music and one
kind of dance, no qualifiers were needed.
So

Would there be any reason
any
thing other than just "dance"?
Most of the old-timers around here seem
to call it

to

have grown up calling

Flatfoot dancing.

In

it Buckdancing or
reference to mountain

dancing, the earliest use of the word "Clog"
that

I

have found

in

print was at the first

Galax Fiddlers Convention

in

1935. That

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

press picked up the term and
I

and

popularized

doubt that this was the case since

already

in

the

it

the Washington and
Asheville newspaper accounts of the White
House performance and nowhere do I see
both

it? It is not

is

now almost universally called Clogging.
My guess is that it is the result of the
standardization of steps and names by the
national clogging organizations that have
emerged since the 970s. Most of the people
who learned to dance in the first part of this
1

seem

to

prefer

in the

San Francisco, CA:
Publishing Company, 1984.

Appa
Duke

Emery, Lynne Fauley. Black Dance
1619 to Today. Princeton, NJ:
Princeton Book Company, 1988.

From

Frost, Helen. The Clog Dance Book.
NY: A.S. Barnes and Co, 1921.

clear why

the name changed over the years to what

century

sity Press, 1985.

was

Asheville the previous
print
Galax several years before that.
in

the word "clogging."
So, what do you call

(ed.) Dictio

Cambridge, MA: Harvard Univer

(that

"Irish

on page 51)

did not find the

today.
my search,
term "clogging team" in print until 1950.
There is one other story in connection
with this that I should mention. In 1939,
In

or her

dance teams started up in the 1950s, danc
ers began to synchronize their footwork,

tions for "character" costumes and panto
mimes, and titles such as "Rastus," "Liza
Jane,"

As

The first square dance teams starting in the
late 1920s were made up of buckdancers,
who kept a beat together with each dancer

to

in use

in

it to

describe the dancing. In 1930, the
to "mountain folk dances."
refers
paper
That seems to be how Bascom Lamar

words

moted by the Teachers College of

taught

teach

doggers perform sequences of steps that
have been choreographed and memorized.

dancing, what Lunsford
referred to as "folk dancers," had by 1938,
become "square dance teams," a name still

to be

to

annual Moun

on the

Times has reported

since by now it has become a part of the
local Buckdance style.
Also in the 1920s, Clogging was pro

University

impossible

tain Dance and Folk Festival many times
over the years, with writers using various

came into use in this area?

bia

is

they say, "Its caught, not taught!"
Group dancing is usually called Clog
ging, and "precision," or "modern,"

by mountain dancers today. Many dancers
do the step, but do not know its origin,

Colum

Buckdance, Flatfooting, and Clogging. I
think of Buckdancing as individual free
style dancing. No two dancers look the
same or do the same steps. By definition, it

calling

it

Buckdancing or Flatfooting.
Now, to go out on a limb, here is my
opinion regarding the differences between

Krause, Rhett. "Step Dancing on the
Boston Stage 1841 -1 869." Country Dance
and Song, vol. 22, (June 1992): p. 1-19.

Seeger, Mike. TalkingFeet. Berkeley,
CA: North Atlantic Books, 1992.
Stearns, Marshall and Jean. ]azz
Dance. New York: MacMillan Com
pany, 1968.

�Granny's
by Sheila Kay

Birthday

Adams

turned 93 years old yes
terday. And I made that same
journey that I've been making

Granny

for as long as

I

can remember.

Most of the road has been paved now but
there's about 1/4 of a mile that is exactly as
The stream
my mind stored it as a child

bounces and sings over to the left of the
road and the buckeye trees reach out to
touch each other overhead, casting a cool
shade in the summer But this is fall, and
buckeyes lose their leaves early on, so
they're pretty much bare now.
There's always a crowd gathered to cel
ebrate Granny's birth, each face as dear to
me as one of Granny's old quilts, each

stitched together by the
a piece
her
love. And the laughter!
thread
of
strong
and
cousins
My
gather in the kitchen and
I'm caught up again
just like always.
person

I

time when we talked of
we all had one then. Granny

There was

a

babies
would move around, weaving between

stretched out legs, smiling, talking, offer
ing advice.
ever give mine for loose
"Only thing
bowels was watered down blackberry juice.
I

."
tighten 'em right up.
6 days old you've
'un
is
a
young
got to turn 'em up by the heels and shake
'em good. It keeps 'em from getting liver
."
growed.
And every pair of mother's eyes goes to
and Granny laughs.
one of their own.
"Oh, don't worry about none of Granny's

It'll

"When

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

young'uns.

I

shook ever one of 'em. Shook

A

of life." We're all of an age to start

Before babies,
love.

we talked

of men and

I

please, ain't they? I'll
out
one way and then
have
figured
the
they'll do right
opposite. So I've come
to this way of thinking.
."

something

to try an'

'em

Every face is waiting, waiting for the
answer from Granny. Each heart holding
its breath, each mind holding a picture of a
special man that it yearns toward.
"I figure, if truth be known, THEY feel
about the same way about us!"
Disappointment registers first, then a

starts

and soon

we're all roaring

laughter, slapping our thighs. The

men peep into the room, eyes round and
curious, only to shake their heads and turn
away. One of them mutters "Women!" which
only makes us laugh that much harder.
And before that, there was talk of shav
ing our legs.
"If

thinking
toward menopause. We talk about who
a hysterectomy, and there are some
familiar faces that are no longer there
Marthie, Granny's daughter, died of can
cer two years ago. I miss her. Dean is living
in Florida and couldn't get off work to get

has had

"Love's one of them mysteries, reckon.
And them men.
Lord, Lord. They are

giggle

only by her and Delphie

The talk this year turned to "the change

collective sigh of relief goes round the

room.

with

secret known
Gunter.

'em good too."

God had meant us to be slicker than

!"
glass, why he'd a made us that way.
And talk of first periods and dolls and

to shoot marbles, with a demon
stration right there outside the kitchen door.
And lessons on how to play set-back,
Granny's favorite card game. But she never

how best

taught us how to cheat. Oh now, that was

a

here in time. Melanie, my daughter, has a
big test the next day and couldn't get away
from college.
There's even talk of grandchildren now.
Jane has a granddaughter that she's rais
ing. Dean has two grandchildren. While
Jane talks, my eyes move around the room,
touching each face gently, and finally lock

with my cousin Sue's. Sue is 16 days older
than me, and her Ashley is 2 months
younger than my Melanie. They'll be 20
years old soon. Sue smiles and nods at me.

won't be long before we're grandmoth
smile back and nod.
think she's beautiful.
It

ers. Time passes.

I

I

"We'll grandmother together, just like
we've done everything else," I say. She
crosses the room and puts her arms around me
I rest my head back
against her. And for a
moment my eyes blur with hot tears.
"Yes, we will," she says and rubs my
head, smoothing back my hair.
The gathering starts to move into the

and

other room where Granny sits. Pictures are
taken, hugs are shared, and then it's over.

�Dellie Norton, Sodom, NC

R:

Someone says, "Well, I reckon we better
..." I look at Granny., She looks tired.

go.

It's time to go.
As I bend to hold her, her arms go around

my neck. I'm startled by her strength. She

holds me

a
long time.
love you, Sealy. You're my own."

"I

"I know
Granny, I know. I love you too.
You're one of my own, you old rubber
necked chicken. You're gonna live forever,
reckon."
I

She pulls back, arms locked around my
neck.
"You always was the one with the smart
mouth. Should've whupped the infernal
hell out'n you four times a day.
..."

laugh and bury my face in her shoulder,
breathing in the smell of her.
And then leave. From inside the house
I

I

hear her say to someone, "Well,
we'll do it again next year.
..."
I

I

hope so, Gran,

I

I

guess

hope so

--October 4th, 1991

On

Tuesday, September 14th,
1993, somewhere around 2:00
in the morning, my Granny,

Dellie

Chandler

Norton,

passed away. We were planning yet an
other birthday party. She died quietly and
without too much of a fuss, just like she
would've wanted it. She also died with

home where she wanted

dignity,

at

be.

April of this year,

In

to

Granny buried
went to be with

her baby daughter, Mary.
Granny and as we sat there, me on the
I

couch, her in her chair, mere inches sepa
rating our knees, looked into her face, so
still and ravaged with her grief. I leaned
across and touched her hand.
"I

love you, Gran." I said.
closed her hand over mine and

She

smiled.

"I

know you do, Sealy.

I

know you

do."
She turned her head slightly and gazed
out the window. "I want you to promise
me something, will ye?" Her eyes came
back to rest on my face.
"If I can, Granny." I said, my eyes hold
ing hers.
She studied me silently and
heart quiet.

I

waited, my

want you to sing my song, that one
turned 90, at my
funeral." she said finally.
"I

you wrote fer me when
"Oh Lord

Granny,

I

I

don't know

if

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

can

David

Holt

I

I don't know that
would be
..."
any kind of shape to do that.
Her grip tightened on my hand, "Oh,
you'll figure some way to manage it."

do that or not.

I

softly

in

We sat frozen, my hand in hers for

a

long

time.

thinking of something else. I pulled my
hand from hers and leaned back into the
She focused back on me and said, "Of
course you'll do it. They never was any

I

again, eyes
"I'll

her.

couch.

want you to stay for the whole
she said, eyes still holding mine.
too,"
thing,
"What do you mean, the whole thing?"
asked, my heart becoming heavy.
"I mean the whole
thing, start to finish.
mean the whole thing.
..."
Her voice
trailed off and she stared out the window
"And

I

to

She smiled and absently patted my hand.
sat there until I figure she had gone on to

do

far
it,

away.
Granny,

I

doubt."
And

I

promise,"

I

said

did.

I

sang "Granny's Song"
I

at

climbed the

hill above the Catholic Church there in
Sodom to the graveyard, and sat as they
I

laid her
I

I

the end of her funeral service,

in

the ground.

(continued

on page 51)

�It Real Tight:

Getting
Kay

by

Justice

&amp;

Ginny Hawker

Hilary Dirlam

"It's like you find the other half of

your voice in the universe."― Ginny
Hawker

love of

it.

People can

Kay Justice

Gerry

Milnes

Courtesy

identify with that."

Ginny

for the

Hawker

"We're just regular people who do
music

Photo

R:

Ginny (L), Kay

and Kay are both right. Their voices

almost eerily, with

a

fit

together

hair-raising interlock that must be

heard to be believed. At the same time,

a
large part of
their appeal is a down-home quality which turns an
audience into friends as well as admirers.
Ginny Hawker was born in central Virginia, Kay Justice in West
Virginia coal country. In an odd sort of balance, they've traded

Ginny

states; Ginny makes her home near Glenville, West Virginia and
his career as
Kay lives in Abingdon, Virginia. Kay's father began
Music
worker.
was
a
construction
father
a coal miner, and Ginny's
for
both
families.
of
life
was an important part

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(R) ca.

1987

Both of Kay's

grandmothers played music. "My grandmother

Justice played banjo, but didn't know that in her lifetime. If had,
have taken her my banjo and handed it to her to see what
I would
she knew. After she died, one of her sisters told me that when they
were children working out in the fields all of a sudden they'd miss
I

I

be under a tree
my grandmother, whose name was Ed na, a nd she'd
dulcimer."
the
Kay's
playing the banjo. Her brother Everett played

other grandmother was an organist in church. "Once they were
having a special church service, asking different members of the
congregation what they'd like to hear, and I piped up and asked for
"Up From the Grave He Arose"

and

it

wasn't even Easter! Even

�liked the more modal sounds," says Kay, although she
readily admits to "Teddy Bears' Picnic" being the first memorable
song of her life. It wasn't until high school, in fact, that Kay was
introduced to traditional music. She had gone to a convention, and
"there were some kids playing guitar and singing. It had never
occurred to me that kids my age could do that. It was exciting!"
then

I

"Daddy and his
brothers had a ra
dio show when
was

I

baby. They

a

ordered little com
edy skits from a

The next year, in her first year of nursing school, Kay bought a
guitar and a Peter Paul and Mary songbook. "I learned everything

place in Chicago to

in it,

songs.

and became aware of my other idol, Joan Baez. Pete Seeger,
and Ian and Sylvia.
all those folksingers
that was the first kind
of

music

did."

I

between

perform

remember

I

seeing them sing
front of the

After several years in Roanoke, going to school and then work

at

phones

in

micro
the re

ing, Kay moved to Wise, Virginia, for further schooling at Clinch
Valley Community College. It was there she first heard old-time

unions."

music.

singing at family
gatherings, learn

Appalachian Seminar taught by Helen
Lewis. When I think back on all the people heard! I saw Roscoe
Holcomb play, and Sarah Carter.
Ralph Stanley came with his
group, Jean Ritchie came over and performed, and Norman and
Nancy Blake, and Tracy and Eloise Schwarz. Tracy had just come
back from Louisiana and was all excited about Cajun music; it was
"I

signed up for

an

I

kind of

new thing for him.

Ginny

eventually began

ing

from

aunts

and

cousins,
uncles.

She and one of her
at

home

the car,

prac

sisters sang

heard shape-note singing for the
first time
the whole thing was amazing, and was hooked."
Kay lived in Wise from 1970-77. She bought old-time records,
got a banjo and a Mel Bay's book, Learn HowTo Play the Clawhammer

and

didn't know you weren't supposed to play everything out
Banjo.
of chords. I knew it didn't sound right! Later got another book and
found out about double-C tuning, which certainly helped, and
taught myself drop-thumb. I also took some banjo lessons at

Ginny and her sis
ter, with two other

a

I

I

"I

I

Augusta." Kay also found a singing partner, Evelyn Hamilton,
and they began playing locally, learning material from records
(Alice [Gerrard] and Hazel's [Dickens] grey album, Hazel &amp; Alice
(Rounder 0027), Doc Watson, Jean Ritchie, and the Carter Family).
Kay played guitar and Evelyn, autoharp.
They went to festivals in West Virginia, and played a lot at the
Jubilee Center in Knoxville. After moving to Abingdon, Kay began
playing bluegrass, too, with the Wolf Hill Bluegrass Ensemble.
"We performed regionally for a couple of years
did some of the
most miserable club dates I've ever played, playing all night for
eight dollars a piece, playing for a percentage of the door, and there
was no door
but got some stage poise and learned how to work
with other musicians."
In 198,2 Kay went back to school, and didn't
play out, but did
experiment with a couple of other instruments. "I got an autoharp,
which liked because could play some melody on it, and also had
the hammer dulcimer fever. got one, and played it for at least a
I

I

I

I

week and

a

half!"

1983, Kay went up to Augusta for the Festival and loved it. "I
heard Ginny for the first time, but didn't meet her that year.
In

Mutual friends kept saying, Tou two ought to meet, you'd sound
great together!"'

Ginny Hawker grew up on Virginia's eastern shore where her
family moved from central Virginia shortly after she was born.
Ginny credits her father's singing and Hawker family reunions in
Pittsylvania County as being her early musical inspirations. Ben,
Ginny's father, had sung Primitive Baptist hymns in his youth, and
had "happened onto" harmony with his brother, Ray. "He and
Uncle Ray were just walking along the road singing and he started
to sing another note that 'sounded right' with Uncle Ray's note.
Uncle Ray said, 'What was that you did?' and he said, 'I don't know
what it was,' and Uncle Ray said/Do it again!'

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in

harmony

ticing
parts.
As

teenager,

a

formed

girls,

a

quartet. Ginny's in
terest in harmony

continued.

"I

worked all the parts
out painstakingly
so we

never hit the

same note. We had
a
guy who played
the piano like Fats

Domino

Rock'n'Roll

early
was

Ginny and Kay― 1st grade school photos

in. We did

coming

songs like TJnchained Melody' and 'The Wayward Wind'." The
which never had a name
quartet
sang for Kiwanis Clubs and
and
did
a
few
radio
Rotarians,
commercials, including one for a
furniture store.

Graduation from high school, college, and marriage and chil
dren, occupied Ginny for some years. She sang to her children,
though, and directed a children's church choir in Florida, where
she had moved after her marriage. Fourteen years later, in 1977,
after a move back up north and work in graphic arts, Ginny
rediscovered her love of music. A trip to West Virginia to look for
land led to an invitation to the West Virginia Folk Festival in
Glenville. "The music just grabbed me, and
never went back.
When got to West Virginia, it was like I could finally take a deep
breath. don't intend ever to move attain.
I

I

I

went to some bluegrass music festivals, but they really turned me
off; the late '70s were rough at those festivals. The Folk Festival in
Glenville was just what I wanted. I remember sitting on the tailgate of a
"I

pickup, listening to Gerry Milnes play the fiddle. was just amazed! We
didn't know each other, but I said to him,' can't imagine what it must
I

I

(continued on next page)

�early jobs were spinoffs from Augusta and our exposure there,"
Ginny said. Their first formal performance together was in a house
concert at Margo's. They have continued an active relationship
with the Augusta program, teaching singing every year during
Vocal and Old-Time Weeks.
During the following two years Ginny and Kay had what Kay
modestly refers to as "fortunate experiences," including perfor
mances at Piccolo Spoletto in Charleston, South Carolina, the

L-R: "Three

Generations

of Southern

Chicago Folk Festival, and the Smithsonian in Washington, D. C.
On the other hand, "when we first got together, we would drive
200 miles for a plate of pancakes," Kay said. "Everybody goes

Singing." Heidi Christopher,

through that and it's good experience."
In December 1988, Kay and Ginny recorded their first album,
reviewed in OTH
Pathway to West Virginia [Pathway Productions
we
were
so
"We
vol 2 no. 2]
thought we could do
inexperienced
22 songs on Satur
We
recorded
it
ourselves.
so we produced
it
15
The
on
Sunday."
songs that made it onto
day and mixed them
well
that
so
the final tape were received
Ginny was able to put
herself through college with the proceeds after the tape expenses
were paid off. Their second album, Signs and Wonders, was pro

Photo

by David

Gahr.

Design

by DaleAppleman

Ginny, Ben Hawker.

music like that.' His answer was, 1 can't imagine what it
would be like not to play it!"'
Ginny was also listening to groups like Crosby Stills and Nash,
and other singers who did harmony. "I liked Janis Joplin, too
the
singers who had a kind of rough edge." Then a friend played
out."
was
else
Hnzel &amp; Alice album for her, and "everything
wiped

be like to play

duced by June Appal [JA0060 reviewed in OTH vol. 2 no. 7]. "We
had played the Berea festival," said Kay, "and Dennis White asked
if we'd record. That was in October 1990. We recorded the album
in

two days again the following March!"

Ginny's husband, Tracy Schwarz, played on Signs and Wonders,
and on their most recent recording, Come All You Tenderhearted
see review page 37.
[June Appal
Over the years Ginny and Kay have evolved an efficient system
for choosing new material and practicing. They've had to. They
live five hours apart, and Kay's job as a nurse anesthetist is
of both time and energy. In the beginning they got
twice a month, when it took longer to work songs
about
together
out. "Now we know what to expect from each other's voices," said
Ginny. "We can listen to a song and know how we'd do it, then
come together and firm it up. We kind of work backwards. Some
people perform songs and become familiar with them, then record

demanding

them. We learn the material, then record

it,

then perform it." "It's

1984, Ginny signed up for vocal week at Augusta after finding
out that Hazel Dickens was teaching songwriting there. "I was

function of our geography," Kay adds.
How do singers choose songs? How do they practice? How do
they choose parts? What makes them agree, disagree, find the right
balance, and when they lock in and it's right, how do they know it?
Ginny and Kay responded the way they sing, their words so

whole scene, and thought about going home,"
Ginny says, but by the end of the week she realized she had found
her true calling. "I sent [director] Margo Blevins a tape of Daddy
thought he'd be a good
singing, and told her in a letter that
instructor. Next year Daddy and taught Primitive Baptist and

bluegrass

In

terrified

of the

I

I

community gospel.

went back to Augusta, people kept telling me, Tou
"When
have to meet Kay you've got to hear her!' Outside one night there
she was, her hands in her pockets, singing oneballad after another.
I

I

was in awe of anyone who could remember all those lyrics!"
In 1986 Ginny and Kay gave their first performance, "a nursing

home concert in Glenville for a captive audience," Kay describes it.
"I had just driven up that day, and we sat on the tailgate of my truck
and worked up 10 or 12 songs that we sort of knew together."
Ginny added, "After that, we just took off. The two of us couldn't
sing together enough."
Ginny and Kay stress the importance of the support of the
our
Augusta Program and Margo Blevins in particular. "Most of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

intertwined that I've treated them here as one person.
"We sing traditional southern Appalachian music. We'll always
do some Primitive Baptist songs, Carter Family songs, and other
stuff particularly from this region. We certainly borrow from early

there's some early Stanley Brothers on our new al
but that's as far as we'll go.
bum
"One of us hears a song we like, at a festival or on a recording,
and whoever it is will call the other and say 'I've got a really great
as much as
song!' We like to learn songs directly from the source,

we can. Whoever finds the song gets to sing lead or harmony,
whichever part they want. Sometimes, though, we have to do it
in fact, we'll have to compromise
strictly based on our ranges
and do the part we didn't want because it suits our rangebetter. We

one of us may not have liked it, or we
have scrapped a few songs
it out to our satisfaction; they might be perfectly
n't
work
could
just
beautiful songs, but just not work for us. It's easier for us to do the
material we like because there are just two of us.
"Our harmonies are a combination of a straight-on voice hold-

�ing steady, and the other voice sliding onto notes. There's a lot of
switching parts; it's one of the fun things we do. We can do any
kind of harmony we want. That's the thing you have in duet

singing that you don't have in trio singing. Nobody ever says
'you'reon my note!' The harmony singer doesn't have to stay in the
tenor or baritone range. We just experiment
especially with the
older modal songs
and when it works, it's a physical feeling.
We've been working up material when it finally clicked, and we
would just cry from the emotional release of that sound. We've
made ourselves cry, the two of us sitting in a room alone. There's
been some songs we wanted to record and every time we'd try it
in the studio, we couldn't get past the second line without crying
so we haven't recorded them yet.
"It can start out being the words that are so emotional, but as the
harmony goes from a harder sounding chord, with more tension,
to a sweet sound
you don't even know what the words are

anymore.
"Idon't thinkeither of us would say we have sweet voices, but
the way the chords change is a sweet sound.
"When we practice, first there's the shopping ritual! Then the
ritualistic making of the set list. Sometimes we have to remind
ourselves that even though we've been doing a song for four or
may seem hackneyed to us, it's new material
for other folks. We put a lot of thought into it even if we're only
doing four songs. Do we want to leave it emotionally intense, or
kind of cheering? Many times we end with that intensity. We
don't really like to do encores
quality rather than quantity.
"One of the nicest places we've played was the Castle in San
Francisco. Everyone there loves singing, and there's no sound
five years, and

it

system. Interaction with the audience is so important, and
you're physically removed from the audi
ence, like at some of the really large festi
vals, you're way up there and all they can
see are your feet! We don't get stage fright
any more. Now it's excitement rather than
fear. We really want to get the music out
it's more like 'Oh, we've got this
just listen to the words!'

there

great new song

"People don't think of us as superstars.
we're
We're not professional musicians
there
isn't
much
just
approachable. Also,
duet singing going on out there, especially
strong female singing, with a cutting edge,
like we do. We kind of fill the Hazel and

Alice void. We keep
and

it

fun, too, not

people can feel that

and

a job,
hear it. We

haven't performed so much that we'veburned
ourselves out, or the people who listen to us."
I asked
Ginny and Kay if there was any
thing they'd like to do they haven't done yet.
"We'd like to 'cross the pond' to the
British Isles. It's just a pipe dream now, and
it would take a commitment, and it would
a lot of other things. We'd like to
in the South, too. We can go
more
perform
to California and draw a crowd, but here in

preclude

mountains bluegrass really
hold and old-time singing doesn't.

the southern
has

a

It's sad to see so

many people, especially
children, who don't know their own music.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

if

But when
it, it

peoplehearthe music being doneby someone who really loves

makes

an

impression."

Hilary Dirlam is an old-time musician living in Madison County, North
Carolina. Her recent recordings include two with Doug Phillips: Seven
Days at the Sawmill (SC-001), and 'Wagoner' &amp; Other Madison

County Fiddle Tunes (SC-002).

�Issues In Old-Time Music

The

letters were sent

following

to

the

Old-Time

Herald recently. They are reprinted in slightly
edited versions here with permission of the
writers.
thoughts
us. ―ed.

To:

have comments,

If you
on

any

of these

suggestions,

issues, please write

to

Alan Jabbour, Director
American Folklife Center

of this, and then

to

know exactly

what these funding restrictions say. I'm
hoping you can help with this. Without in
any way diminishing the work of folklor
ists and administrators who have helped

Library of Congress

Washington D.C.

preserve
Dear Mr. Jabbour,

a

the notion

am writing with several concerns. I am
hoping you can convey my thoughts to the
I

National Endowment for the Arts, and
thank you for your kind attention.

I

heritage of
of

unquestioned value,

geographical

purity today
serve an idea well, but reality
poorly. Many musicians know very well
that the masters they studied with listened
to the radio, learned tunes from travelers,

appears

to

am one of many thousands of musi
cians who has benefited from [festivals,

and composed vigorously. Tune borrow
ing, like love, knows no boundaries. How

teaching camps, etc.] There are a scarce
number of events specifically organized to
teach musicians to play traditional music,
and those that exist are excellent events
and community treasures. It is therefore
with great concern that note a tendency
toward the absence of women faculty. Many
years there are some women, but men tend
to greatly outnumber them.
Prior generations produced fewer
women instrumentalists, but rather than
overlook the ones that do exist, we should
redouble efforts to include them, and en

to

I

I

courage younger players as well. In dis
cussing this issue informally around one
festival in particular, encountered the ar
I

gument that the staff must be "grantable,"
i.e., born into their musical environment
and therefore eligible for NEA funding. I
and many others would appreciate
The Issues

verification

Old-Time Music column

in

was

a

column are not necessarily those of the Old-

Time Herald.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Equal Opportunity guidelines!
I must
quickly add I'm bothered by the
concept of quotas, but it's also easy for me

many other women to see that the
obvious needs doing. Habits are uncon
scious and blanket life with a thick dust of
innocence. All the more reason why NEA
and

funding guidelines need to be given a spring
cleaning in light of current needs, and they
need to be made public.
Cathie Whitesides

Waltz" enjoys with southern fiddlers. Or
the rage among older players I met at Mt.

Seattle, WA

defined
standard of geographical and musical pu
rity leaves out all the players who've given
their lives to traditional music, but had the
misfortune to be born in Barstow, or the
Bronx. But it hits women doubly hard,
since they have only recently entered tradi

Unfortunately, adhering

to

a major way. Older players
who've grown up in relative musical isola
tion will always be treasured as primary
believe a way could be
resources, but
found to acknowledge the considerable
contributions of younger players, many of
whom received NEA funds to pursue their
music in the first place. What does this
I

do if not teach and

perform? For these players the criterion
could be excellence, not pedigree, and tra
ditional music would be enriched thereby.
There are many hundreds of women
at

Dear

Cathie,

a

tional music in

to

4, 1993

August

Airy this year for Jay Ungar's "Ashokan
Farewell."

study qualify them

forum for theexpression of ideas
and points of view, some of which may be
controversial. Points of view expressed in this
established as

explain the great esteem "Westphalia

successful women practitioners of their
instruments up there in the lights. For a
federally funded teaching event this is un
acceptable. Such rosters would not meet
of

these events year after year,

participants
learning to play, and observing the absence

[Your letter] prompted such a variety of
reflections in my own mind that I fear I
won't be able to organize them all in a
useful way. But let me try.
First I should tell you that I can affect the
NEA only through friendly advice and

persuasion, as a colleague and well-wisher.
Neither nor the American Folklife Center
I

has any

additional sway there.

I

will share

copy of this letter with Dan Sheehy, Di
rector of the Folk Arts Program at the Arts

a

Endowmnent, along with

a
copy of yours.
know he will be sympathetic with the con
cerns you have voiced Y our specific questions
I

about the policies of the Folk Arts Program
should be addressed directly to him.
Having said that, do want to acknowl
I

edge

a

certain responsibility for

a

set of

ideas your letter challenges. I was Director of
the Arts Endowment's Folk Arts Program from
1974 till 1976.

It

was the inaugural era for the

�program. Nancy Hanks was Chairman, the
Endowment was growing, and the agency
was lit up with the energy of cultural pio
neers (for so we imagined ourselves, and

perhaps we were). As we set up the guide
lines for the new program of grants in
support of folk arts, we were conscious of
the smallness of our budget, the largeness
of the cultural needs our program repre
sented, and the importance of our sym
bolic first actions.
Especially, we were conscious that we
were citizens who had loved and learned
from folk artists; it was they whom we had
evoked when we called so passionately for
a
program to serve them. It would have
been unseemly for us, the lovers and learn
ers, to shift the focus to

ourselves, and

it

would have been horrible to have been
even to have seemed anxious to be first

or

the

at

trough.

We were also aware of the tendency of
many people to associate the idea of "folk
arts" with

popular figures like Pete Seeger,
popular groups like Peter, Paul, and Mary,
popular movements like the spread of con
temporary crafts, or popular trends like the
burgeoning interest in antiques and "col
lectibles." That was a big problem, we
thought, at the popular level. So was the
tendency of people not to associate "folk"
with the panoply of American ethnic
groups. Folk arts to many did not include
American Indian arts, or African American

become more multicultural. By that I don't
mean what many people mean when they
say "multicultural" nowadays. I mean that
American culture is more comfortable with

arts, or the arts of Eastern European and

its

Asian ethnic groups.
At the level of elite arts, we had other
big problems: the tendency of the arts

establishment

to

associate"folk"with

untutored art and generally with the lowering
of or lack of standards. Through such a lens,
"folk" was antithetical to the quest for excel
lence. Indeed, this year a cultural pundit has
made national headlines by attacking the Na
tional Endowment for the Arts for exactly this
sin: lowering standards and funding all sorts

things (folk arts examples were cited)
which sacrificed excellence for the sake of

of

"diversity." As
ments,

it

the current com
were transported back

read

I

was as if

I

artsy esthetes of my youth in the
fifties; but no, it was a writer being taken
very seriously by the New York Times this
to the

year.

Despite the tenacity of such objections to
funding folk arts, I have to say that America
has greatly changed in the generation since
we established those guidelines. Despite
the old establishment

voices like the pundit I
is that America has

just alluded to, the fact

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

plural nature, and individuals don't feel

that choosing one art requires them to

re

ject another. Hardly anyone know thinks
that liking French cuisine requires dislik
ing Thai food, or that to love Bach you must
scorn old-time fiddling. To someone who
I

grew up in that other world a scant two
generations ago, the change is astonishing.
There have been other changes as well.
When
was attending old-time fiddlers
conventions during the 1960s in North
I

Carolina, Virginia, and West Virginia, it
was obvious who were native practitioners
and who had only recently taken up oldtime music. One could tell at a glance, or
from hearing

a

lick or two. But in the

suc

ceeding generation the easy distinctions
haveblurred. Young outsiders have settled
in the region, and regional musicians have
moved to urban areas in the northeast and
midwest. Bands have crossed the old social
boundaries with ease and good cheer. In fact,
music has done what it always does when it
has a spark in it: it has crossed and ultimately
redefined the cultural boundaries.
(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Indeed, the idea that
can be classified

in

a
a

"revival musician"

separate category

from a "traditional" musician is regarded
by most academic folklorists as dubious at
best. One of the paradoxes of the long and
often unproductive debate about whether
revival artists should get funded is this: the
academic folklorists tend to look at the
issue in a way not dissimilar from theyoung

musical devotees; it is the public-program
cultural specialists who adopt a conserva
tive (old-fashioned, the academics would
say) definition of traditionality. Yet the
devotees passionately believe they are be
ing excluded because of academic folklor
ists.
if you believe (as I do) that
process, not just a product, you
will surely agree that the importance of the
process gets lost when people focus too

What is more,

culture

is

a

much on the individual artist's personal
credentials. Years ago a debate was organized
at an American Folklore Society meeting on
the question whether revival performers

should

be

permitted

at

folk festivals.

I

argued

that the premise was false, since it assumed
that the individual performer was para

festival should really re
was
the cultural reality of
argued,

mount. What
flect,

I

a

young people like me visiting old-timers
like Henry Reed We shouldn't be choosing
bet ween him or me on the stage. If I were to
appear as a fiddler at a festival side by side
with my mentor, that would be true to the
cultural reality we both had participated
in, and therefore good.
To all these issues your letter adds an

important contemporary cultural issue. It
is a fact that, till the present generation,
most fiddlers have been men. The fiddle
was never exclusively a man's instrument,
but it has come perilously close to that in
many cultural traditions. This generation
has brought a revolution: thousands of

women

are taking up the

fiddle, and some

are among the finest artists in their cultural

tradition. And these women range in social
background from urbane cosmopolites to

down-homers from the farm and ethnic
enclave. There
the
for

is no

better cultural index of

significance of the cultural revolution
women in America than their accom

plishments

on the

fiddle

in this

generation.

That being the case, you are right that if
women fiddlers are not adequately fea

festival, something is amiss. And
don't accept the premise that feature
artists should always be "traditional," and
that "traditional" means having learned it
back home as a kid generations ago, I would
tured
since

at a

I

�say there is no excuse whatever for not featuring fine women
in a festival today. Like you, I'd worry about turning

fiddlers

right thing into a quota; every festival has its special
human variables, and recruiting arts and teachers is a kind of
the

juggling act anyway. But the overall pattern of public presen
tation should do justice to the importance of women in these
traditional arts today.
would welcome any further comments you or [other
I
readers] might have.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Alan Jabbour

�"GidTanner's
Are In Town.
An

Interview with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Skillet Tickers
...!"

Gid

Tanner--

1959

When

we first started getting
music there

into old-time

was an informal network of tape
collectors and we'd swap open reel
tapes with each other, fill up a tape
with old 78s, and interviews. At
that time, since there was no place

to

publish any of this material,

kept circulating
was easier to run off

around--

just

it
it

tape copy

a

than to transcribe the material.

Section with Illegibl

must have one or two hundred
interviews that came to me that
way. At first, this was the way we

learned about the music.
This is, as far as we know, the

only interview ever done with Gid
Tanner. This tape has been in cir
culation for a long time among the

underground

of collectors--

but

never published or transcribed. It
was done on an early open reel
recording by the Huffs, one of

whom was apparently

a

local ra

dio personality.
I'm pretty sure that

it

was Willard

Johnson [of Uncle Willie and the
see review OTH
Brandysnifters-vol. 3 no. 8] who discovered the
tape and put it into circulation. I
think that's how I got it.
―Charles Wolfe

�zoos accessed and transcribed for the OTH by Dan Foster and Christy Palumbo, with introductions by Dan Foster, Christy
Charles Wolfe. Edited by Alice Gerrard, Dan
and
Charles
Palumbo,
Wolfe, with occasional clarifications and annotations in italics and brackets by
and
Foster,
Christy Palumbo.]

[The

following interview

This

is a

transcription of an interview with Gid Tanner, recorded in Dacula, Georgia in 1959. Interviewers were Oscar and Fred Huff.
interview was located among materials at the American History Center at the University of Texas at Austin, where it was placed

The copy of the

Willard Johnson in 1963.
Roger Abrahams of the UT English Department to whom it was originally given by
Comments made by Fred and Oscar Huff are attributed to both as O/F. One of the two did most of the questioning, but we are uncertain which
Gid Tanner is GT.― ―Dan Foster and Christy Palumbo

Gid, How you doin'?
GT:

Hello

erable

O/F:

Well I'm doin' just tol
well-I
ain't gettin'

GT:

I

used to.

I

had

a

mighty good dog too. He's hard to fool,
believe me. Yessir, I can just go out the back
door, with a shotgun on my shoulder, and
he'll tree squirrels just as long as I tote that
old double barrel shotgun. Yes, sir,
go
I

and I'd go out
another one, a rabbit gun.
the back door with that on my shoulder.
He'd turn brush piles bottoms side up
wards, and he'd have a rabbit a goin' in
high gear. Yes sir, he sure is a good un'. Y'
know a while back I decided I'd fool him.
Took a notion I'd go fishin'. And went out
I

behind the house, got the longest pole
and come back around there, he
thought I was going to beat the hound out
of him!
thought I'd draw me up a good
thar
I

had

I

with

us, how old were you

making records?

Well, let's see, 14.

about

along so fast though. Can't get

out and run rabbits like

Tell

first started
20

I

when you

wasn't

so old.

Lickers

would have made him 38

was in

1924

which

or 39 years old.]

Did you just start out by yourself,
Gid, or did you organize your own band?
and got
GT:
got up my own band.
O/F:

I

I

boy that makes fiddles. [This was Gordon
Tanner who became known as a good fiddle
maker later on. Many in Georgia remem
ber him more as fiddle maker than a fid
dler.] I wish you all would see him and
a

these fiddles he's got. He wouldn't take
$500. He's got four made. They look like
store bought fiddles. They don't look like
no hand-made fiddles. He made 'em with
kids. He's got two boys
and two girls and he made a fiddle apiece
his hands.

for his

is.

it fixed and it wasn't worth fixin'.
come back home and worked it over

asked $250 for that old fiddle
laying in there. It's a Stainer. [Prob
Steiner]
And that old fiddle of mine
ably
have.
let my boy
Lord, he wouldn't sell that

hisself and

I

of mine

[Gid makes

I

at all.

fiddle, no way

reference here

a

to

the Kimble

Atlanta. They may have
recorded there but at any rate the 1934 record

House

a

hotel

in

the hotel.]
ing "Kimble House" was named after
O/F: Gid, where was you born, was you

born here in Dacula?
GT: No, about 16 miles from here, down
what they call the Thomas Bridge right on
this same road, Appalachia

stayed there until

River,

come above

and

I

My grandmother had
stayed there with her.

500 acres of land, I
She died and that land was sold.
me

for 'em.

it

have

But he

something. [His first recording

the Skillet

it to

by

I

got out,

Lawrenceville, up here. Bought
150 acres of land and didn't

place,
sold that.
keep that but one year and
went to Atlanta, thought there wasn't no
a

fishing, y'
know. drawed up that water and looked
around for old Bill, he was down beside the
car, scratchin' up worms, just as hard as he
could.
O/F: Talkin' about them dogs, reminds

One of [his] boys plays a guitar and you
can't lose him and he's just 15 years old. He

called

me of that song [skit] that you all put out
"Possum Hunt on Stump House

O/F: You still use the fiddle you always
did? The original fiddle or have you got

hunting. When asked if he still hunted possum,
Gid related that he fell in a hole and broke some

Mountain." Tell me who was doing the

another one now?

ribs

dog calling in there?
GT:
was doin' part of

GT: ain't got the one first learned how
on, but my boy has. It's a good one, believe
me. The fiddle that I've got's been worked

anymore. Asked his weight, Gid responded that he
weighed about 240 lbs, and that he was 75 years old

cool drink of water before I'd go
I

I

can

play any kind of music he and his

daddy plays. And like somebody to fol
low me when
play anyhow. Yes, sir, I
I

I

mean backing up.

I

it.

Photo Left: Record catalogue from 1926

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

need in me stayin' out in the country-went to town. left there and stayed about

over. My first wife's (I've been married
twice) uncle he got that fiddle and he took

I

I

a

year.
[Here

I

I

a

he talked about

couple

of

grandson's bird-

years earlier and doesn't hunt

on the previous 6th of June.--

O/F:

his

DF &amp; CP]

Who was the original group you
(continued on next page)

�had

in

the Skillet Lickers?

by

ourselves

and

time or two

a

made records.

I

got

I

made

a

little

"I'm
lived at
song up about where
Satisfied". And I started singin' that when
first started out, and had a whole lot of
15
'em made and sold them things 10
cents a piece. got some money out of the
I

he was a blind man.
GT: Riley Puckett
it. We's the first
we
started
Me and Riley,

ones. We went to New York

No, my voice ain't

GT

Who were they, what were their names?

a

I

I

Antone, Texas with me [thel934 Bluebird Ses
sion for Victor] He helped me cut all them 23
numbers. "DownYonder," "Backupand Push"

["Satisfied" was not his first recording. His
first was the series with Gid and Riley Puckett

and "Soldier's Joy," "Flop Eared Mule."
O/F: What company was that?

made

band then [Gordon Tanner]

First thing was Bluebird, then
tor got to handle it and took it over.
O/F: You were on Columbia too.
GT:

GT I'm on four or five different compa
nies. Yeah, at Columbia, they treat me
mighty nice. made a lot of money with
I

them. We recorded about twice

year, and
I'd
recordin'.
$500
every
get $1000
get
dollars out of them, recording twice a year

O/F:

3

as

a

dialogue

you recorded?
GT:

No,

kept 'em and kept 'em.

I

I

bet

I

hundred of each kind of a record that
made. And folks would come in "Oh, I

had
I

a

That's

O/F:
GT:

It

shame.

a

they put medicine

sugar and

in his eyes

lead

so

strong

it

put

I

used

what

stick together. Let one be like the head
leader. It's hard to do.
O/F: Who was that fella in the band that

here

a

woman?

O/F: That was you? We was listening to
["Cotton Eyed Joe"] the other night at

home. Was
GT:
O/F:

it

Riley doing the singing?

Oh yeah.
Then this

person with the keen

voice would say, "Cotton eyed Joe, Cotton
eyed Joe." Come in there with that "Cotton
eyed Joe" just once or twice.
GT:
O/F:

Oh no.

Come on, Gid.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have one of every one [I] ever made.
know. Well, that's

Just tryin' to keep 'em. you

ought to. Some of them'd be behind about
whatever we did. It's hard to get a band to

sounded so much like
GT: That was me.

to

I

O/F:
a

ought to've done.
Jimmie Rodgers
while ago. Tell us about your asso

reckon

I

You mentioned

ciation with Jimmie.
GT: Well, never stayed with him much.
I

He lived

a

We'd meet

long ways from us you know.
in Atlanta and that brother of

mine that plays the guitar, him and Jimmie
stayed together. They was buddies. [I'm
pretty sure that the brother was Arthur Tanner
who recorded for Columbia and Paramount.
good singer and
own
his
right.]

Arthur Tanner was

a

ing character in
O/F: From what

1

interest

hear, and what I've

been able to gather, of Jimmie, he was quite
mean was he, or would you
a character,
I

call him

a

sometimes.

Lowe Stokes played the fiddle and
you played the fiddle. And now what did
McMichen do, did he play the fiddle?
GT: Yeah, he'd fiddle or guitar, either
one.
O/F: And your leadin' singer was Riley
though, he did most of the singing on those
records.
GT: He'd take the lead-off.
have read somewhere that
O/F: Now,
he was left-handed. Was he a left-handed

guitar picker?
GT: No sir.
O/F: had heard that he was
I

a

left-handed

guitar picker. I'm glad to get that cleared

I know
I've seen two or three
said
he was a left-handed
where
they
places

up, because

guitar picker.
GT Nosir,heplayedjustlikeanybodyelse.
O/F: Was he born blind?
GT No, he wasn't born blind He had the
sore eyes and they put medicine in his eyes,
sugar and lead, so strong it put 'em out.

'em out."

I

got that kind of money. We have to get up
some money, them things cost money. Kept
on, we never did get out like we really

home wherever he went. Every

I

sure is. They just got my records.

1

at

O/F:

And, when did Lowe Stokes and

me
suits, there wasn't but about two of us
and Lowe Stokes. We got our suits and they
shine like silk. We'd got to play a while.
and think it was McMichen, said we ain't

He sure did. Yeah, he just made

out of the way

Do you have all your records that

O/F:

Fate Norris and that group start with you,
and Clayton McMichen?
hadn't played much till we got
GT:

get on the road, make some money, get
tuxedo suits.
got ready to get the tuxedo

good bit then,

Gid's name alone. He sang it
a man and a woman.]

between

cents.

them We all decided we'd play, you know,
we got to playin', making big hits and then

a

body was glad to see him in a way too y'
know. When a fella'll drink, he'll sort of get

all. That's been 15 years ago.

record?

never did record no records

I

Well he rambled

GT:

two or three cents

a

Jimmie?
GT: No,
with him.

any with

record

himself

want to get a few of these." One fella lived
way below Atlanta, got 25. They never have
brought 'em back. Just took them. They ought
to've brought 'em back when they played 'em

we got
Me and Riley
We got a cent and a half apiece.

you ever

Did

didn't he?

y' know. They just paid me.
O/F: Now in addition to the $500, you
got a certain percentage on your records
that was sold off of that recording. Y ou got

GT:

Why, yes.

fied" zuas released on Columbia 15016 and was
the second recording, a solo, released under

a

I

"Satis

"Hen Cackle."

GT:

O/F:

1924 and released on Columbia 110

in

"Buckin' Mule" and

Vic

man,

a

I

other words.
O/F:

thing. Yes sir. sang part of it like
part of it like a woman, you know.

went to San

GT: He was any way you wanted him.
He'd stay sober. And he'd stay drunk. When
he got ready, he'd go to drinkin'.
O/F: He just had a mind of his own in

drunk or.

[This story confirms what other people have
said about the cause of Puckett' s blindness.]
Was he from around here?

O/F:

GT: Not so far.

This Clayton McMichen, he must
have been a character too.
GT: Yes, he was.
O/F: After Clayton played with you and
O/F:

the Skillet Lickers, when did he form the

Wildcats, or Georgia Wildcats?.
GT: Yeh, he tore loose from me and got
a band of his own. The Wildcats.
O/F: Well Gid, how old were you when
you first learned to play the fiddle?
GT

I

got

a

fiddle willed to me

I

was

14

years old when I got my fiddle.
O/F: Well, did it take you long to learn to

master that thing, or did you learn how to
play

it

pretty quick?

GT: Pretty quick.

Didn't take long.

�guess you've got to have a knack
your people, or did your
daddy play the fiddle or.
O/F:

I

for it. Were any of
GT: No.

Now

O/F:

though,

is

all of

your sons are musicians

that right?

O/F: They can't get no Gid Tanner

sawin'

How many children do

you have, Gid?
GT: Five boys.
O/F: Now you said you made several trips

to

New

[in 1925] to make

York

were recording for Victor

at

recordings. You
that time?

O/F: And in that one
on as

many records

time.

Is

as

meeting you'd put
they wanted

Gid,

Now

I

know that every year,

or

every few years they have this Old Time
Fiddlers Convention in Atlanta. Do you
still participate

in that

every year?

I

noticed

on your mantle in there a while ago that
you have a certificate for the best old-time

fiddler of 1955, certificate signed by Gover
nor Griffin at that time. Is that the last time

at

that

that right?

That's right.
O/F: Well now on that "Corn Licker Still
in Georgia," did y'all have that made up,
what y'all were gonna say, or was that
GT:

made up on the spur of the moment?
GT: Oh, yeah we had to study on it right
smart.
O/F: Who wrote that, did you have any
part in writin' that?

O/F:

I

fiddler
time you was. John Carson. You remember
John Carson, Fiddlin' John they called him?
GT: Yeah, me and him was two of the
first ones that ever

music.

I

broadcast this old-time
picture of me and him

got an old

yonder somewhere. [A copy of that
was
used on the Skillet Lickers Rounder
picture
now

re-issue LP Work Don't Bother Me.]
O/F: Well know back during when Gene
I

was

running

for

Governor,

back in

"Old Earl Johnson, he's

about as old as

I

am, he's

do that thing. He'd go just like he could
catch 'em under his hat.

like Earl Scruggs."

to

pickin' the banjo

when's the last time you seen

GT: I seen him a year or two ago. He had
come by.
stopped down there at the
barber shop. My oldest boy had a nice

barbshop downtown. He just walked

you know, said he thought he might get
shave. I said if that ain't McMichen.
What

I

got

a

kick out of

in
a

especially,

Gid, was that "Johnson's Old Grey Mule."
Who was the mule on that?
GT:
O/F:

at

I's the
I

mule.

know you started off that, could

you do that for us?
GT: Well, it' sort of hard to do. I'd have
to have a fiddle.
O/F: You made those sounds with your
fiddle didn't you?
Me and Fate Norris we
GT: Oh, yeah

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

played two weeks ago down

[the] Madison Theater.
O/F:

In

other words,

if

a

fellow come by

carry you some
Is that right?

up and

here, pick you

GT: That's right.
O/F: Tightening up your bow there, huh?
GT: Yeah, I don't never let it stay tight
all the time.

tunes his fiddle and
several
tunes:
"Cumberland Gap,"
plays
[At this point Gid

"Rock the Cradle Lucy," "Rubber Dolly,"
"Sally Goodin," and others.)
GT: Oh

ain't played anything

in a long
he's
about
as old
Old Earl Johnson,

time

I

am, he's gone to pickin' the banjo like
Earl Scruggs. Boy, he gits down at it too.

as

I

He live here?

O/F:

town, but

up there in Lawrenceville now,
right close to the shoe store.
[Earl Johnson of Earl Johnson and Elis Clod
hoppers who recorded for Okeh and Bluebird.
He was

put out

during these election years?
Oh yeah.
Did you ever fiddle

GT:
O/F:

with Gene

GT:

I

played with him some, but not on

no tours.
O/F:

Well,

on

this "Slow Buck,"

you

remember that one don't you?

Five-hundred and sixty-five pieces

put on

I

I

in?

played

don't know. Played in lots of 'em.
How did you travel back then? By
train or did you go by car, or how did you
travel back in those days.
GT:

Talmadge?

a character-County

a record.
played that "Get
Home
Cindy" up in 'A'. A lot of
Along
now
didn't used to play in 'A'
pieces
much. But a lot a dances, now they want to
play in 'A' and get a lot of sound out of it.
O/F: Gid, how many states have you
I

the '30s, Fiddlin' John played. Did you ever
fool around with any of the candidates

apparently quite

reissue of him called Red Hot Break

a

down, now out of print.]
O/F: How many songs did you say you
recorded?
GT:

[The above story confirms the fact that they
used a written script.]

O/F:

go play, huh?
GT: Yeh, I

he lives

gone

O/F: Well,

over four, five years.

it

GT: He did live right here in

whiskey. Boy, we'd have it hid in the stump
hole. Old Fate Norris, cut down a bee-tree
and he'd buzz like a bee, yeah he could sure

McMichen?

ain't had

I

you to go somewhere and play, you'll still

I

stories, they already had the story and you
just acted it out then?
GT: Yeah, me and McMichen and Lowe
Stokes, we all had a part in makin' that

How long have you had that fiddle,

O/F: You said you did go off and play
sometime when people come by and want

in

Talmadge

step

could
jump waist
two before he'd hit

He
or

Gid?

know there was another old-time
from Atlanta, playing about the

No, was just the head of the band.
You didn't make up any of the
O/F:
GT:

O/F:

a

where, you're available.

you participated in it?
GT: Time or two since then.

Columbia.

GT:

high and hit
the floor.

GT:

O/F:

Hawkins.

GT: Ted

brayin'.

Play a little, yeah. Some of 'em just
hard to beat.

(laughter)

How did you do that whistlin',
with your mouth, or. ...?
GT Yeah, he did done the hollerin', the
O/F:

I

GT:

on it?

put that thing over. He'd whistle, you know,
like a mule, whistlin' when he.

I

O/F:

GT

Went in

a

car mostly--

Chevrolets,

I

GT: Oh yeah.
O/F:
says "Hey boy, I thought you
could dance." And he says, "Well, I can

drove Chevrolets

dance." And somebody says "Well, why
don't you bust loose there a litle bit." Now
who was doin' the talkin' in that one?

Was there enough of you that you had to
take two cars or would you just pile up in
one car and try to go?

GT: That was

McMichen

Did anybody actually dance? Who
was doin' the dancin'?

[more] than

I

have any

other kind.
O/F:

GT:

Would you need more than one car?

Sometimes we'd

pile

up

in

one.

Most

O/F:

(continued

on next page)

�of the time, [if there were] lots of us, we'd
have two.
O/F: Well, did you

have

a

manager then

that would go on ahead, make these show
dates for you, or did y'all just get out and
start and go from one town to the other?

GT

The other way.
really ought to
I've
had
manager.
managers several
You
can
make
places.
money thataway.
O/F: Where they can go in advance, and

have

a

make these arrangements for you.
what part or the road, where to
go and where to stop. Yeah, sure.
O/F:
Back then the roads weren't too
were they? Traveled a lot of
either,
good
roads
didn't you?
muddy
GT:

GT: Yeah, sure did. Yes sir, everthing's
came to the better looks like, ain't it?

Well, it was good old days back then.
Oh, yeah, sure were. Yes sir.
O/F:
imagine y'all really got a lot of fun
O/F:
GT:

I

out of that. Even if you couldn't make too

much money, you still got
GT: Oh

a

lot of fun out of it.

kick out of

it.
yeah, got
Back then you made pretty good
money though didn't you Gid?
a

O/F:

Yeah, we made pretty well.

GT:

recol

I

lect once when we started out to go to play
in North Carolina, and
got way over at

Franklin, Georgia. Y'all know where that's
guess. We got over there just before

at,

I

sundown. The fella sellin' our records says,
"Boys,
there

at

I

want y'all to put on and play

it

up

thecourthouse tonight. says, "Well
I

it's night right now." He said, "I'll just tie
skillets all over this truck here, and they to go
rattlin', make all the fuss you want to goin'

through town, tell 'em 'Gid Tanner"
Lickers'

in

town.' We took

in

s

Skillet

S97 that night.

Why did y all call yourselves the

O/F:

Skillet Lickers, now?
GT Well, just 'cause webeat nearly every
body we run up with. Yeah, we licked 'em out
pretty clean nearly everywhere we went.
O/F:
bet you did
What do you think
about the music today, Gid? What do you
think about this rock 'n' roll music? Elvis
I

Presley. How do you like Elvis?
GT: Well, like it pretty well.
I

It

takes all

kind of music to get along anyhow. But my
type of fiddlin', it don't call for that. It sure

don't.
O/F: Well, Gid of all theseartists that you
have ever heard, who was your favorite of
them all, that's famous?
GT: Riley Puckett. He could sing any
thing he wanted to. He could sing in the
second pitch all the time.
O/F: Did he use a thumb-pick? Did he
(continued on page 52)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Your wife and children, are they well?

The Drunkard's

You used to treat them strange

Dream

kinder to them now?
How came this happy change?
But are you

I

had

a

dream,

a

warning dream,

That heaven sent to me;
It warned me of a drunkard's curse
Of

I

woe and misery.

heard them say, "Poor thing, she's dead;

wretched life;
have broke her heart,
'Who lived a drunkard's wife."

She lived

a

For grief and pain

I

had

a

dream,

a

warning dream,

That heaven sent to me;
It warned me of a drunkard's curse,
Of woe and misery.
It

warned me of

And made

a

a

drunkard's curse,

man of me.

This song, as the liner notes state, "Was famil
iar in the 19th century.
throughout the

mountains. This rendition

is

based on the ver

sion by the Stanley Brothers of Virginia.

The arrows incorporated into the song transcription indicate vocal "slides."
Nothing can take the place of listening to, and learning from the actual singing of

song. As with any traditonal music anything on paper
never the road itself ―H. D.

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

merely

a

guidepost,

."

�God

Weary Prodigal

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Come

calling me prodigal,

is

"Come without delay."
Hear, O hear him calling,

Calling now for thee.
Oh, you wandered so far from his pres
ence-come today;
Hear his loving voice calling still.
CHO: Calling now for thee
Oh, weary prodigal come.

Calling now for thee
Oh, weary prodigal come.
Patient, loving, and tenderly still the father

pleads,
(etc.)
Hear, oh hear
while
the spirit
return
Oh,

in

mercy inter

cedes
Hear his loving voice.

Come, there's bread

(etc.)

in the

hose of the fa

ther, and to spare,
(etc.)
Hear, oh hear.
Lo,

the table is spread

and

the

feast

is

waiting there;
Hear.

(etc.)

Learned from the
West Virginia.

Melvin Wine family of Copen,

�Classified

Musical

Instruments

VINTAGE BANJOS, GUITARS, MANDOLINS
FOR SALE. Send SASE for list to: Ray Alden, 24
1

MARTIN

GUITARS

INSTRU

ELDERLY

&amp;

MENTS. Get the best from the world's largest
Martin guitar dealer. Free discoun tea talog. ELD
ERLY INSTRUMENTS,

1100

N. Washington,

Quakerbridge Road, Croton, NY 10520.

INSTRUMENTS FOR SALE; 1911 Tubaphone
banjo, flowerpot, refinished, EC $2,200, 1920

Vega Whyte Lay die #2, banjo $1,800, 1973 Vega
Folk Wonder long neck banjo $650, 1987 Martin
D-28 guitar, $1,050, 1972 Martin 00-18 guitar,
$1,000, 1968 Gibson J-50 guitar $650, and more.
SendSASE for list. Smakula Fretted Instruments,
PO Box 882, Elkins, WV 26241, Phone:

304-636-

6710.

WORLD'S

Recordings, Books

Daniel Engle, PO

mandolins,

archtops, wood &amp; metal body Dobros, Nation
als. Mandolin Brothers, 629 Forest Ave., Staten
Island NY 10310. FREE CATALOG-(718) 9813226. Call for no-charge evaluadon of your

vin

tage fretted instruments.

BOOKS AND VIDEOS! NEW FREE DISCOUNT
CATALOG with thousands of instruction and
song books for the acoustic musician. ELDERLY

INSTRUMENTS, 1100 N. Washington, POB
14210-DA34, Lansing, MI 48901 (517) 372-7890.

SPECIAL OFFER, TWO TAPES WITH BOOK
LET FOR THE PRICE OF ONE. Both volumes,
Family, (see review page 41) for
$12.75 postpaid. Ray Alden, 124 Quakerbridge
Road, Croton, NY, 10520.

BLUEGRASS

OLD-TIME

&amp;

in

ct

COMPACT DISCS!

CASSETTES,

NEW FREE DISCOUNT CATALOG with over
0,000 titles. Bluegrass, folk, blues, jazz, old time
country, and much more, listed by category of
music and by artist. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS,
1

Lan

POB 14210- DA34,

Washington,

AT LAST! New recording by MAC BENFORD
celebrating his FIRST HALF-CENTURY featur
ing WOODSHED ALL-STARS. Cassette only.

$10.00 ppd. Mac Benford, 4029 Buck Hill Rd.,
Trumansburg, NY 14886.

(704) 279-8644.

WARRING CATS

NOW to our monthly used and
vintage instrument list with hundreds of quality
instruments at down-to-earth prices. $5.00/
year ($10.00 overseas). Current issue free on
request. ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.
SUBSCRIBE

Washington, POB 14210-DA34,

MI

Lansing,

48901 (517)372-7890.

FLATIRON,
ZEIDLER,

RICH

Bruce

Molsky

on

fiddle,

with DIRK POWELL and AUDREY MOLSKY.

old-time fiddle tunes.
Yodel-Ay-Hee! Cassette only. $11.00
postpaid to Bruce Molsky, 227 N. Greenbrier St.,
Arlington, VA 22203-1325.
Solo and accompanied

New

on

FINE AS FROG'S HAIR

Newest recording (cas

sette) by the ILL-MO BOYS featuring Geoff Seitz,
Jim Nelson, and Curtis Buckhannon (and
&amp;

TAYLOR,

STELLING,

NATIONAL,

MARTIN,

GIBSON,

friends).

25

fun-filled selections. $10 ppd.

Nelson, 403 N Draper, Champaign,

IL

Jim

61821.

BREEDLOVE, STIVER, GUILD, DEERING,REITER,

COLLINGS, SANTA CRUZ, much more, in stock
now at the best prices. Free discount catalogs.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS,
ton, POB 14210-DA34,

1100 N.

Lansing,

Washing

MI 48901

(517)

372-7890.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ODD-SIZE

FYBERSKIN

BANJO HEADS,

in

stock; 101/8", 101/2", 109/16" and 1011/16" 10
3/4" 10 13/16" $18.00 each, 11 13/16" and 12"
$20.00 each. Add $3.00 per order for shipping.

Custom size orders welcome. Smakula Fretted
Instrumen

ts,

PO Box 882, Elkins WV 26241, phone

(304) 636-6710.

The

Old-Time Herald will accept classified

grouping of letters
RECORDS,

INSTRU

depth. SASE &amp; 52 brings current listing.
Subscriptions with extra services $5.00. Harry &amp;
Jeanie West, POB 321, Granite Quarry NC 28072.
and

Cobb CA 95426-

Equipment

the cost of 35 cents per word,

1100 N.

MENTS, new, used, vintage. Free, friendly ad
vice. All correspondence answered promptly

1401,

The Kimble

sing, MI 48901 (517) 372-7890.
FINE

Box

1401.

SELECTION-- NEW-

LARGEST

USED-VINTAGE-guitars, banjos,

1

Zesty music! Book: $12.95, Tape: $8.98, add $2.00
shipping; CA residents add 6% tax. Order from

POB 14210-DA34, Lansing, MI 48901 (517) 3727890.

#3

TUNES FROM HOME A delightful collection
of 00 irresistible dance tunes in Old-Time, Celtic,
and New England styles. Challenging tunes,

LOOKING FOR RECORDINGS by Charlie Her
ald &amp; The Roundup Rangers, Dickinson's Melody
Mustangs. Also Fred Kirby. Ken Sabean, 11

Skeena St, Halifax,
2V7.

Nova Scotia, Canada B3N

word. All ads must
month,

2

or
be

months prior

numbers
received
to

ads at

minimum $5.00. Any
is

counted

as one

by the first of the

publication.

�RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
FU
READY FOR SHIPMENT

Sales

County

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
old-time MUSIC RECORDS
MEMBerof

I

i
j

INTtRMATIONAL M.UCORASS

MUSIC

ASSOCIATION

ACCEPTEID^^^^^^^^-C^/

MEW RELEASES
CC-0120
CO-2702

CCS-112
CC-0121
CO-3501
ROAN-1

BLUE SKY BOYS "On Radio" Great 1946 radio from Georgia

TOMMY J ARRELL-FRED COCKERHAM

1

10

HER-044

J

I

J

I

J

I
J

I

j

I

1

I
1

I
1

I
1

I
1
I

J

1

ROU-0304
OH-336
CO-2703
SH-2204

AH-002
MSOTFA-103
YAZ-512

OH-114
JA-065
REB-4302
CMF-009
CO-505
SMM-102
HER-052
AT-101
NG-002

ROU-1056

I

SHAN-6001

I
1
J

MAR-9029
VG-100

1

Section with Illegible Text

set of 1925

30 recordings

UNCLE DAVE MACON
TOMMY JARRELL "Joke

"Hall of Fame" 16 cuts of 1927
On The Puppy" now on cassette

etc

1934 material

N/

etc

I

CHARLIE MONROE "Vintage Radio 1944" Featuring Lester Flatt, etc
LOUVIN BROTHERS "Radio Favorites 1951 57" Now on CD excellent disc
Great collection of 1925
1930 recordings
CHARLIE POOLE Vol
MAC &amp; JENNY TRAYNHAM "The Sweetest Way Home" Pleasant old-time duets
OLD FIVE STRING Vol 2 Super compilation of 16 old-time banjo tunes
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Fine set of traditional fiddle music from Alabama
1

WAYNE ERBSEN "Southern Mountain Classics" Nice old-time instrumentals

1927 -28" His earliest recordings
SUNNY SIDE OF LIFE Nice video highlight of the Carter Fold in Hiltons, VA
NORMAN &amp; NANCY BLAKE "Just Gimme Something I'm Used To" Recent old-time
TOMMY HUNTER "Say Old Man Can You Play The Fiddle" NC old-time fiddline
ORIGINAL ORCHARD GRASS BAND Old-time mountain dance music from Virginia
LOTUS DICKEY "Fiddle Tunes From Orange Co.. IN" Excellent 2-Cass set
CHUCK WAGON GANG Neat B &amp; W footage from 1962 with Rose &amp;. Anna, etc
"First Sessions

$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00

N/A

$13.00
$13.00

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

$10.00

8.00

N/A

8.00

N/A

$9.00

8.00

8.00
8.00

$8.00
$8.00

$10.00i
8.00
8.00
8.00
8.00

N/A

album only

$12.50

video only

$25.00

N/A

$13.00

album only

N/A

$8.00

8.00
8.00
8.00

$13.00

$8.00

$13.00

N/A
N/A
N/A

9.00
8.00
8.00
8.00

album only

$12.50

N/A

$13.00
$13.00

video only

$13.00

N/A
N/A
N/A

video only

to 3 items, add $3.00 for 4 or more items
&amp;. HANDLING: USA ORDERS: Please add $2.00 for first
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Please add $5.00 postage and handling charges for up to 3 items,
then $1.50 for each additional item. MINIMUM FOREIGN order is 2 items.
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPT. H, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

POSTAGE

A

album only
v

"My Home" Wonderful old-time banjo and fiddle
MADDOX BROS. &amp; ROSE 27 songs taken from old 4-Star material-great
WILL KEYS "Evergreen" Fine old-time two-finger banjoist from Tennessee
MASTERS OF THE FOLK VIOLIN with Baker, Krauss, Doucet, etc. now on CD
KENNY BAKER "Master Fiddler" Stunning 20 song set of Kenny's bset work
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Nice set of fiddle music from Mississippi

JIMMIE RODGERS

$20.00
$13.00

$13.00

Bagpipes Great
The Jailhouse, etc

CYRIL STINNETT "Grey Eagle In C" Excellent old-time Missouri fiddling
TIMES AIN'T LIKE THEY USED TO BE Super 70 minute video w/ J. Rodgers,
SAM RIZZETTA "When You &amp;. Were Young, Maggie" Nice hammered dulcimer
Vol 2 Nice set of late 1920's &amp; early 1930's songs
ECHOES OF THE OZARKS
Vol 1" Good collection of 1930's songs
RILEY PUCKETT "Old-time Greats
WADE &amp; JULIA MAINER "In The Land Of A Melody" Fine recent recordings

CS

8.00
8.00

N/A

fine old-time

In

CD

$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00
$13.00

N/A

GLEN SMITH "Four Miles To Cumberland" Old-time West Virginia fiddling
set w/ C. Poole, F. Hutchison, Darby /Tarlton,

WHITE COUNTRY BLUES 2-CD

TONY ELLIS

CLOUD-006
ARH-334
CO-2705

FCM-5
CO-5 19

CHARLIE POOLE "Old-Time Songs" Great

FRANKLIN GEORGE "Traditional Music For Banjo" Fiddle
DOC WATSON "Portrait" Classic 1975 set w/Shady Grove.

FF-620
ARH-391

IRC-201
JRM-002

nice

JODY STECHER &amp; KATE BRISLIN "Our Town" Lovely set of traditional music
CLYDE DAVENPORT "Puncheon Camps" Excellent old-time fiddle &amp;. banjo
PETE CASSELL "The Blind Minstel" Soulful 1940's country

AC-002

I

1

"Best Banjo &amp; Fiddle Duets" 21 songs

CARTER FAMILY "Clinch Mountain Treasures" Great 20-song set of 1940 cuts
BLUE SKY BOYS "On Radio
Vol 2" More radio
good notes by Bill Bolick

CBS-47466
MCA-10546

I

many new songs

$8.00

8.00

$8.00

$25.00

8.00
8.00
8.00

$16.00
$25.00

I

1

I

J

jL Section with Illegib

�Reviews

Come

either.

All

You

It

sounds

all

new and very old

at the

same

time.

Tender

The Dock Boggs song, "Prayer of a Miner's
Child," does the same thing, touching on the
earlier version, but making something new.

hearted
Traditional

hear some of the Boggs's banjo in
Though
Schwarz's guitar part, and some of Boggs's vo
cal toughness in the singing, this version is more
I

Southern
Singing

than an imitation.

(I

should note here that

I

think

Ginny doing the singing, but am not sure. The
notes are not very clear about who sings what.)
if

I

often limit myself by thinking that Holcomb
Boggs or someone has already made the de
finitive version of a song, but these songs and
others on Come All You Tenderhearted remind me
that a song can have any number of definitive
versions. Whoever knows a song and loves it

Justice

Ginny Hawker

s

or

June Appal 0069 CD
Ginny Hawker-lead and harmony vocals; Kny Jus
tice-lead and harmony vocals, rhythm guitar; Tracy

well, who dwells

Schwarz-lead guitar, fiddle, harmony vocals; Donnie

worth listening

Mike

Seeger-harmony
Williams-harmony vocals.

Flawn

vocals;

The Touch of Her Hand/ Weary Prodigal, Come/
Sweet Sunny South /The Drunkard's Dream/
The Unquiet Grave/ Here in the
on the Hill/Come All You

Vineyard/Cabin
Tenderhearted/
Prayer of a Miner's Child /Deep Settled Peace/
Dark and Stormy/West Virginia, My Home/
Raindrop Waltz/O

Sing

to Me of

Heaven.

you want some singing to make your hair
stand straight up on your head, you've got it.
Ginny Hawker and Kay Justice sing directly
If

about the most important things: home, place,
love, death, heaven. Though there's a range of
Carter Family songs, hymns, a Child
musichere-each performance
a Hazel Dickens
song-realizes what is universal in each song. In its
instrumental arrangement, in its vocal phrasings
and harmonies, in its number of voices, (this
ballad,

record offers solo, duet, and full chorus), each
performance finds the song's central emotion,
often

a

tender

or

sorrowful one. Sometimes,

"Sweet Sunny South," the interpretation

unexpected.
I

thought

is

as in
quite

in its

every line and corner, as
can make a version

Hawker and Justice do,
to.

many singing and har
mony styles, and perhaps this ease allows them
to hear and eliminate some of the many possi
They are

bilities

at

ease

in

song before they choose what their
own version will be. "The Touch of Her Hand"
in

a

has the Carter Family sound, while other pieces
echo the Stanley Brothers or the Blue Sky Boys.
unhurried,
with lots
"OSing to Me of Heaven" is
that
relax
into
notes
finally
long-held
sliding
chords, while "Weary Prodigal Come," also a
gospel song has a completely different sound,

of

solo-sung verse, and a chorus in tow
one
voices,
singing long slow notes while the
other sings faster, rhythmic ones. Yet it isn't as if
the record is a survey of styles. Hawker and
with

a

Justice seem to have solved the problem of hear
ing and loving many different styles, a problem
that often makes an unsatisfying potluck out of

music performance. Hawker and Justice have
chosen the songs they love the best, the songs
that touch them. They have obviously listened to
a

great deal of traditional music, and this listen
ing guides their choices; at the same time, they
are expert enough to make whatever choices
a

they wish to, so that what comes out sounds like
itself, and all the songs together make not an
mixture, but a genre of their own.

illplanned

1

had heard enough

versions

of

"Sweet Sunny South" to last me forever, but this
one renews the song for me. With Kay singing,
and Tracy Schwarz on a big and deep-sounding
guitar, the song is sad and bluesy, but the big

voice and the big guitar make it a tough and
strong kind of sadness. The album notes say that
this version is inspired by both Roscoe Holcomb
but it's not in imitation of
and Mike Seeger--

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

This genre of Hawker and Justice contains
many religious songs. "Herein the Vineyard," is
lovely, an a cappella hymn both stark and sweet,
and harmony
with phrasing absolutely matched,
a
unison, and to a dis
moving close, through
tance again. The song takes plenty of time, and
the way the voices pass so slowly but repeatedly
through the various harmonies gives a listener

in

the harmony will come, and we anticipate it, but
even when it comes we're not quite ready, the
skin prickles, we hold our breath until the reso
lution. Music, like faith or fear or other religious

feeling, can rub a listener raw, and so remove the
skin that usually protects us from close contact
with essentials. These songs do that. Perhaps it's
the directness of the voices, perhaps the subjects
death, in "The Unquiet Grave,"
"West Virginia, My Home," the comforts
of community in "Here in the Vineyard,"

of the songs--

home

I

Kaywith Illegible Text
Section

with Tracy Schwarz

Scott-dobro;

chills. We know when the moment of tension

in

the age-old dream of a heaven beyond the suf
of life on earth; perhaps it's that many of
the songs are old, and show that people have

ferings

been thinking about the same questions for gen
erations, and haven't solved them. Whatever the
reason, the music of Hawker and Justice, as all
the best music can, gives us a way to approach

things that are otherwise so big and incompre
hensible we cannot begin to touch them.
In

spite of all this seriousness, Come All You

Tenderhearted

is just

voices rise and swell
them
a

is

plain good listening.
in

of

pleasure,

prickling, standing

on end,

pure pleasure--

pleasure

of hair

harmony,
blood rush

The

and to hear

a

smoothing down again.
MOLLY TENENBAUM

�Round Town Gals/Top of Cork Road/Arkansas
Traveller/Nancy Ann/Ricketfs Hornpipe/Bill
Cheatham/Grey Eagle/Mississippi Sawyer.

beautiful moments, but can almost hear which
is doing the backup trying to decide
I

ever fiddler

play chordal double stops, drones, or
a little distracting to hear the think
harmony.
ing inside the music. Nevertheless, both these

whether

to

It's

This album was first released on the Kanawha
label in 1967, and was some of the first West
Indiana music made available

Virginia

to a

wide

didn't run into it until the late '70s,
bu then it was some of the best banjo playing I'd
heard, the right hand continuously rolling, the
melody notes popping out. At the time had ears
only for the banjo; now that this CD is out, I'm
happy to pay more attnetion to all of Frank
audience.

I

t

I

George's music.
Now there is more

pay attention to as well,
since the CD includes more times than the origi
nal record:

to

Parlor," "Soldier's

in the

"Walking

Left Behind," "Fine Times at Our
Joy," "Girl
House," "Old Joe Clark,:" and "Bill Cheatham"
I

praise for being thinking musi
since
cians,
thinking about it as they play it is
men deserve

probably how they got so good: Summers has a
lovely toneand often takes surprising turns with
a
melody, while George has a steadiness and a
slightly plainer style. The long fiddle-duet med
ley beginning with "Forked Deer" and ending
with "Arkansas Traveller" (clearly a studio-made

medley, since each tune fades completely out
before the next comes in) does contain some
lovely moments, but it sounds messy, like what
is, two excellent players becoming familiar
with each other's playing. The "Wake Up Su
san" medley is more successful, perhaps be
it

have all been selected from the original tapes to
be added to this CD. "Rickett's Hornpipe," the

cause the guitar holds the two fiddles together,
and the medley is just two times long, so that the

banjo solo on the original LP, has been removed
from the CD, but is replaced with a full band
version, John Summers on fiddle, George on

two fiddles

banjo, and Pat Dunford on guitar. The solo
"Rickett's" has not been abandoned, however; it
is to be

released

The

CD.

a Comity clawhammer banjo
tune edited away has been

on

only
"Cumberland Gap"; too bad, but the rest of the
wouldn't quibble
music here is so good that
I

When the LP first appeared, there was very
little other traditional instrumental music out to
it

to, so of

More obviously stunning is the combination
Summers's fiddling with George'sbanjo play
wouldn't have expected Summers's
ing.
of

I

smooth, controlled fiddling

course

it

sounded good. Now

to go

ripping-along banjo style, but

it

with George's
does. Franklin

Summers on fiddle
duets in oldbanjo-fiddle
great
time music. Some moments even remind me of
the same combination
Burnett and Rutherford

George

on banjo and John

make one

over that one time.

compare

don't have to follow each other
through every extravaganza. "Wake Up Susan"
truly soars.

of

of the

smoothness with forward motion.

that many other recordings exist, this record still
sounds good. Frank George's playing is very
dif feren t from the other Wes t V irginia music I've

This CD also presents some of George's bag
pipe playing, and though I am not as fond of
those cuts as I am of the others, I think they are

seems more direct, less twisty
and moody, more down to earth. still especially
like the solo banjo pieces: George's style takes
the exact middle between rhythm and melody,
and the tunes have quite a punch. One of them,
"Nancy Ann," I've never heard anywhere else.

an

now heard

it

I

On

the other cuts here where George plays

banjo, he is either in

a

duet with John Summers

fiddle ("Walking in the Parlor") or with Sum
mers on fiddle and Dunford on guitar. In each of
these combinations, the banjo is just right, blend
on

and carrying the beat. Although George
does no "chucking," his attack on the strings
really pops the notes out. His tone is beautiful,
his notes sound good
clear and a little thick
under Summers's smooth fiddle notes.
ing

"Old Molly Hare" features George's fine

fid

dling accompanied by Dunford's banjo. This
tune begins the CD and is an excellent choice for
that job: it's lively, and the two play well to
gether. "Walking in the Parlor," with Summers
on fiddle and George on banjo, has a similar feel,
can see why Pat Dunford, who knew both
so
I

men,

thought

to

bring George and Summers

together.
Though the two do have similar ideas about
don't think the fiddle
melody and phrasing,
duets are the strongest pieces here. They contain
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

important inclusion, because they show what
of a musician Franklin George is: talented,

kind

with wide-ranging interests.
Thanks to County for making this importantand
wonderful recording available. What first heard in
the '70s I can now hear and love better in the '90s.
I

MOLLY TENENBAUM

�Touch
Reel,

Me There, Miss Thompson's, Dinky's
Rock-a-Bye Baby/Waynesboro, RedHeaded Irishman/DNA Bourrees/Blind Fiddler,

awhile, but
straight
then different instru

Sandy Boys/Québec Reels: Bedeau de l'Enfer,
Caribou, Fireside, Lévis Beaulieu/Uillean Pipes

ments start drifting in
and more percussion

Barbara Allen, Pis Phliuch, Maids of
Mitchellstown/Old Man Old Woman/Friends,

Set:

Don &amp; Kelly's

Waltz/Martian's

Farewell.

it

play

relatively

for

starts building, then
all of

are

sudden you

a

listening

to

Afri

can polyrhythmic elec
I

don't think there is

in

this

country,

nay,

a

band quite like the 'Billies

in

the

world.

Theyare

one of

tric

guitars playing

a

beautiful, ethereal

the

hottest and most popular contra dance bands
being based in the Bay Area.
What they do is start with traditional dance
music from around North America and add a

version

on the West Coast,

Then they reel the lis
tener back in. Several

few numbers from Europe. Then they add
multicultural input and a sorcerer's cookbook.
The stew they derive seems to always be interesting,
if not always recognizable. Their musical
styles are as diverse as their source material. Ray

also

comes from

a

country music and folksong back

of this

of the band

are

tune.

members

excellent

(all may be,
don't ever recall

singers
but

I

hearing Daniel sing),
but we only get a
of short

couple

ex

ground; Paul has played in bluegrass, old time,
and Irish bands (he also tours with Kevin Burke,

amples. Ray warbles

Mark Graham, and Sandy Silva);
Kevin has been
active in the Irish and Québecois scenes; and

"The Blind

Daniel,

he must be

well,

encountered Daniel
the midst of

at

a

the Martian.

Brandywine

I

first

Festival

in

hot session of Kentucky fiddle
tunes, and he was blowing a mean flute! One of
their strong points is their skill at arranging. I've
a

had the pleasure and good fortune to watch the
evolution of some of the arrangements heard

here over the past several years, as most of the
'Billies are frequenters of the Festival of Ameri
Fiddle Times, which is one of my normal
haunts, and they occassionally play dances in
Seattle, my home. It seems to me that the Irish
can

and Quebec repertoire has not been tampered
with as much as some of the other material, but
that might be my view since I am much more
familiar with the old-time styles and the French

music. Most of the old-time

tunes go through
alien
introductions
before hitting
slow,
lengthy,
the familiar strains, then veer off into terra incog
nita. A lot of cultural purists will probably feel
aghast at the treatment given some of their fa

vorite times, but the Martians have so much
style and so much musicianship that they can
pull it off without offending too many. One of
the things
detest most in my life are cheap
musical tricks many bands use to goose dancers
into screaming. feel that the power of the music
and traditional rhythm alone should provide
I

I

the impetus to dance. Well, the Hillbillies use all
of the tricks I've

ever heard and have pulled

quite a few new ones on me, but I don't seem to
mind so much when they do it, because, like I
said earlier, they have a lot of style. I'll give you
an example from this album. They play the fine
"Old Man Old Woman," from Louis
Boudreault, the Quebec fiddler. This time en
joyed some popularity in the old-time scene in
time,

the

1970s

due

the

Bay

Label

Jody Steelier recording on
and because the Highwoods

to an old

Stringband performed

it

on occasion.

The

Hillbillies

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

nice

rendition

of

Fiddler"

before they launch
into "Sandy Boys"
Kevin sings his
own short composi
tion, "Friends," which
and

has one of my all-time
favorite lines: "As my

body grows wider, my
hair it grows thin/the
seasons pass quicker,
my head starts to swim/well

I've learned to take

sight of a friend /the moment we
meet up, my heart says 'Amen.'"
The liner notes are informational and entertain

refuge

in the

ing, with anecdotes and some musiciology con
cerning the material. The Hillbillies impart their

sense
nently

of fun with

music and the music

danceable.

everyone's taste, but

Granted,
I

it

sure like

may

is

emi

not suit

it.
KERRY BLECH

Hillbillies from Mars,
Mountain View CA 94040
To order:

301

Monroe

Dr,

�fine, sweet, close harmony singers. Bill Bolick's

extensive liner notes describe in minute detail
some of their jobs that followed World War II.
He tells how they added

person

comedy

of "Uncle Josh," and often

to the act in the

performed

as

trio with fiddler and singer Curly Parker. None
of this was available to us until these recordings.
a

In

the late '40s, the Bolicks and Parker recorded
for airing over several

15-minute transcriptions

Georgia radio stations. They normally recorded
a whole
week's worth of daily shows in one
mammoth session, and on occasion recorded 10
shows! They had to struggle to appear fresh for
each show, but pulled

it

off. They also ate up an

enormous volume of material in this manner, so
they constantly solicited new material, often
receiving

it in the

form of lyrics only, or having

someonehum what they thought was themelody
to

them. The result was that they have here on

airshots a bundle of songs they never
recorded elsewhere. Many titles will be familiar
to you, but most of these songs have a particular
these

twist due

to the way the Bolicks learned them.
also
did
instant arrangements so that they
They

could feature their distinctive harmonies. Curly
Parker's fine,

if

not outstanding, fiddling was
Bill Bolick states

also prominently displayed.

that he felt (probably properly) that the audience

much preferred the singing to the fiddle tunes
and that they quite often turned the tunes into

songs by interjecting whatever floating verses
they could recall. Unfortunately, there is little of
that here. These CDs take the form of the old
radio shows, with opening and theme, closing
and theme, comedy bits, banter, and advertise
ments along with the music. Some deft editing
has been done so that the

smoothly.

This is

a

performances segue
wonderful collection from

one of the golden eras of radio history and we
to arise at daybreak to enjoy it.

don't even have

KERRY BLECH

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�"Boys In Blue" are not that obviously from the
Civil War; they're more likely from the SpanishAmerican War). "Napoleon Crossing the Rhine"

fine. The ones that didn't, can't. That's one of the
core mysteries

traditional music,

of

or

maybe

any kind of music.

According to the notes, only half of the 23
pieces in Peterson's cassette were learned di
rectly from recordings. Like some other "or

instrumental

is an
a

I

intend

to

steal

as

soon

as

I

get

chance: no fancy mandolin chords or tremolo.

foundland dogs to existing tunes: "Darling
Newfie Gray," "Sedentary Newfie," and "Get a

"Darling Nellie Gray" and "The Fox" are given
complete versions, and sound good. On the
down side, several of the pieces, such as "Maple
On the Hill" or "Sweet Sunny South," are not as
exciting as on mountain versions 0- E. Mainer
and DaCosta Woltz's Southern Broadcasters,

Newf." This last one, done to the Lone Ranger
theme from the "William Tell Overture" ("get a

respectively).
noticed that

Newf, get a Newf, get a Newf, Newf, Newf")
should be banned; it ran through my head one
whole day like a singing beer commercial.
suppose the folk process of winnowing the wheat
from the chaff has to start with raw material.

closer

phan" musicians, Pete makes extensive use of
sheet music. He also includes three of his own
compositions, all of which set words about Ne w-

I

Still,

I

doubt

these songs will catch on with

if

anyone but the most rabid

Newfoundland dog

fanciers.
Can
the

I

Sleep

Your Barn Tonight Mister? is not

In

solo cassette you might expect from the
other musicians are involved,

to

comparing these recordings,
and Dave are singing much
the middle of their vocal ranges than
In

I

Jim

previously wrote that the High
Lonesome Sound is not absolutely essential for
good traditional singing. To clarify that idea,
though, the Sound should at least be Lonesome.
the old singers.

1

other words, when singing these songs of loss,
you need to find some aspect of your voice that
can express the distress of that loss without just
In

breaking down and bawling. Singing smoothly
in the middle of your range doesn't meet the

with various instrumental and vocal combina

artistic requirements of the songs.
Both of these cassettes come up short when

tions. All the performances are well prepared
and presented with a parlor rather than stage-

compared with the artists who inspired the per
formers. Charlie Poole, Pete Peterson's muse,

performance feel. Pete has learned Poole's banjo
style well, plus a reasonably skilled parlor 5string style (V ess Ossman et al.). was surprised
that, despite the paeans to Poole's influence in

even

sources,

tunes are actually learned
the notes, only 3
from Charlie's records. The rest reflect a consid

Dear"

cover. At least

15

I

of the

erable eclecticism, from the previously men
tioned parlor pieces, through Newf songs to

at his most incoherent, had a way of grab
bing you by the throat and making you listen. So
did the Blue Sky Boys, one of Jim and Dave's

best, with such songs as "Katie
Banks of the Ohio." Or rather,
the Blue Sky Boys took you by the lily-white
hand and led you to a mysterious musical place
at their

or "On the

en

that changed you, at least for the duration of the
song. I don't pretend to know the source of the

joyed "What Have You Done" (a version of
"East Virginia"), "Little Brown Hand" (a piece

magic of either Charlie Poole or the Blue Sky
Boys. All know is that, although Pete Peterson

and the parloresque "Sailing
Down the Chesapeake Bay." Also, Martha Burns'

and Jim

Homer and Jethro ("Sink the Bismark").

I

worth learning),

voice

is

excellent

on

"Don't

Be In A Hurry To

Go." I'd like to hear more of her.
Jim Tucker and

Dave Trowbridge, although
a Brothers Act, with all

they're not brothers, are
that the term

implies: close thirds harmony;

mandolin-and-guitar instrumentation; 19 th cen
tury sentimental parlor songs; and the possibil
ity that you'll doze off if you're trying to recover
from a prime rib dinner. A glance at the song list

should immediately tell you if you will find this
cassette of interest to you, but have a word of
warning: they have been looking at sheet music,
I

and they are not constrained by the old 78 RPM
record limit. "Annie Dear I'm Called Away," for
example, runs for 3 minutes and 50 seconds.

Those extra 50 seconds, from sheet music, seem

like an eternity. I believe that the old 3-minute
limit greatly improved the works of some of the
more prolix 19th century composers.
Still, they do some very nice Brothers Songs:
"Aunt Dinah's Quilting Party" is a favorite of
mine, no matter what. "Boys In Blue" is not that

definitive Grayson &amp; Whitter
version (but watch out for alternative possibili
ties when you're writing notes, Dave! Those
far off from the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

the

Dave obviously all have their hearts in
rightplace, when listen to them, mine isn't.
&amp;

I

LYLE LOFGREN

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

room for its own preoccupations. Besides the
traditional amalgam of song and tune we've

come
of
as

to anticipate from the duo, a good helping
contemporary material is stirred into this pot
well. Are you curious yellow? Well, quit

b not as if
biting your nails-they're whipping
into "Girl from Ipanema" or something. They, in

a
great song and
prove themselves very adept at accommodating
the newer material in their musical home base-that golden little spot on the musical map where
old-time and bluegrass are constantly crossing

fact, display an eagle eye for

paths, sometimes even strolling hand in hand.
There's a smattering of just about every other
one of their musical interests peeping through in
one guise or another, from Cajun to Cape Breton,
but those with a taste for a well-penned song

might find this set particularly endearing.
The album's sublime moments are many, but
I'll touch on just a few of them. A traditional
song, "Going to the West" opens the show and
wastes no time sweeping you into its sweet

melancholy. The open, airy arrangement with a
pair of simple guitars and voices has a meticu
lous economy to it which effectively leans to
wards poignant understatement. (This charac
teristic surfaces on some of the other material
also.)

Kate's voice is heard first, floating sus
a dreamy cloud over the bubble of guitar

pended,

notes below. Jody soon joins in on the chorus, and if
you haven't got a good case of goose bumps by this
time, you're probably not listening.
"Old Country Stomp" is a spunky rambling
Our

medley of songs with guitar and banjo which
drones hypnotically. "Roving on Last Winter's
Night" is a traditional nugget brought into light
here-its rendition just might melt your heart.

Town

Jody
Stecher

Of the contemporary

&amp;

"Our

KateBrislin
Rounder

behold. The song

guitar, banjo

jody;

Stecher-vo-

cals, guitar, mandolin, fiddle.

GoingTo the West/Home/Old Country Stomp/
In Between Dreams/The
Showerhead Reel, The

is

DeMent's

powerful airing of
a small
town's
treatment here couldn't be much

to

the

emotions wrapped up
Its

a

in

mance forges an absolutely exquisite 5 minutes
and 29 seconds worth of music. had the plea
sure of hearing Iris do her version of it recently
I

but I'm spoiled by Jody and Kate's take on it.
This is not to belittle Iris DeMent in any way (on
the contrary,
of

Late/The Bramble and the Rose/Our Town/

truly worth

Is

Stealing/Curtains

of

Night/Queen

of the Earth and Child of the Stars,

Last Winters

Night/Henry

and

chine/Won't You Come and Sing
Virginia, there

is

Roving On

the True

Ma

for Me.

old-time music

or

the

West Coast for that mat

ter― Jody Stecher and Kate Brislin.
Our Tenon is Jody and Kate's third album

together. As their

feel her

to be

last release, Blue Lightning,
had some surprises on it, this one, too, makes

among the minority

musical moments
between. Jody and

are

but it's just that
such as this are few and far

lending

an ear),

Ka te's

version seems

a

genius

design; like some antique Swiss clock where
every cog and spring has a vital importance, all
notes seem carefully chosen

on

West Coast. Here's some solid proof, lest you
need be reminded, from two of the idiom's finest

practitioners― East

I

country songwriters going today who

Twisted Arm, Big John MacNeil/Too Late, Too

Yes,

Iris

finely cut jewel, arrest

better; all of the stars are in place, so to speak-the union of song, arrangement, and perfor

Kate Brislin-vocals,

Twilight

a

ing

demise.

CD 0304

material,

shines like

Town"

ate effect.

The song itself

to

create

possesses

a

deliber

all

of the

quali ties needed to become a classic folk standard.
The one song of the group which has been

noticeably covered

is

Barbara

Keith's

"The

Bramble

and the Rose." And boy, has it been
covered, by this duo and countless others.
even heard a few sparrows singing it
think

I

1

outside my window the other day. The album's

�liner notes acknowledge this, having an air of
justification about them concerning its presence
among the lot. Upon listening to it here, however, its
re-recording reveals a new depth which in the end
needs no excuses. It has such an obvious meta

phorical bent for them, having become so multilayered over time that it seems like their signa
ture piece of sorts. The bramble and the rose,
Jody the fleeting mercurial and Kate the stable
rock

it is their

So

work so well
bring

valentine.

whatmakes the music
with

of Stecher and Brislin

my ears? For one thing, they each
them to the duo complementary
to

musical qualities like two essential pieces of a
puzzle. They then proceed to create a musical
atmosphere which is heavily steeped in the meth
ods an inspiration that so much classic old-time
has to offer. Be it a tradi

and early bluegrass

tional favorite or

a

solid composition from

a

recent songwriter as demonstrated here, one can
hear the echoes
filtering down

of so

many traditional influences

through the music, ingrained
upon the couples' sensibilities. There are certain
heartstrings of mine which are commonly only
pulled when hear some of the classic old-time
I

singing of groups such as the Carter Family and
the Louvin Brothers, certain nuances that touch
me

in a very singular way, and
felt
same nerves being triggered here.
But perhaps their ultimate gift lies not in faithful
reproduction of these traditional lessons from

emotionally

some

I

of those

the past, but more so in their ability to expand
personalize upon them as well. In the liner

and

notes

there appears a madcap little fable by
songwriter Mark Simos which touches upon the
subject of alchemy. That got me thinking about
the

phenomena of transformation

that can be

heard in some of this recording here: what's
needed is a good knowledge and understanding
of your roots,

the ability to internalize

it,

and

good dose of intuition, grace, and perhaps a
bit of magic to take it forward into a new personal
ization without ruffling the integrity of the original.
then

a

That, my friends, is musical alchemy.
Good advantage is taken of the CD

here

format

almost an hour of music with no filler, en

lightening notes, and the sound

is

sparkling clear.
DAVE ALLEN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Family here: not only Ernest
determined delivery of tune and

Stoneman
Stoneman's

lyric on his old recordings,
of the

understanding

but his Family's

commercial need

to

mod

ernize the songs into a presentation acceptable
to the new audiences. "You Don't Think About
Me When I'm Gone" (which Stoneman would have
called "Black Dog Blues") and "Blue Ridge Moun
tain Blues" owe an even more direct debt to Pop

Stoneman. You could do worse than copy him.
I've been complaining about a modern oldtime music trend away from singing, so have to
applaud that 17 of the 19 pieces here are sung.
The critic in me, though, notes that every one of
these uses a solo-verse- with-trio-chorus arrange
ment. The balance between giving us familiar
material and surprises could have been tilted a
I

little more towards the surprise side. Although
there are no electric instruments, a lot of the

composed songs

are in the older

Nashville Coun

try-Western tradition, when the protagonist was
abandoned but didn't know why (nowadays,
the male C&amp;W singer discovers that his goodhearted true love left him because he's a hardlivin' loser who cheats on her).
The backup players on these five recording

sessions do
It

is

good, solid job.
to predict what the next gen
traditional music fanatics will choose
a

impossible

eration of

as the objects

of their

affection, so we have

a

responsibility to preserve as much of the music
commend Rounder for publishing
as we can.
1

this album.
LYLE LOFGREN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�(Clarence

Ashley's

is

in

Dorian

mode);

in

Mixolydian, "The Cruel Sea/' along with a dem
onstration of Mixolydian harmony on the dulci
mer; in Dorian, her version of "Barbara Ellen."

If

you subscribe to this magazine, you should know
if you don' know them,
consider
this cassette even if
should
buying
you
you don't plan to buy a dulcimer.

about those modes, and,

t

LYLE LOFGREN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Deville/Wild

Hog in the Woods/Sinner's
Is A Mighty Wind/The Leav
Devil
Hymn/The
Me Come Home A Stranger/
Let
Train/Don't
ing
Across the Blue Mountains/Stone Wall Country.
Robin

harmonica,

Williams-guitar,

Williams-guitar, banjo, vocals; Jim
vocals; Kevin Manl-dobro, vocals.

vocals;

Linda

Watson-bass,

is a keeper. It was masterfully
recorded during live performances in Holland

This recording

1 992 and is
by far the strongest recording of them
I've heard. Overall, these are great song selections

in

and renditions with some fine instrumentation.
For those who are not
of Robin and Linda

familiar with the music

Williams,

it

cannot

be

catego

rized easily as old-time, bluegrass, folk, or country.
It does, however, contain elements of all these, and

could best be labeled as acoustic music.
Tliis recording,

to its

credit, has more of

rural sound than some of their earlier work.

a

In

have found Linda's singing to be
on certain songs. How
ever, this CD has more of an edge vocally, and
more of a powerful, true country (rural) sound.
Also, the addition of Kevin Maul on dobro is
the

past

I

sometimes too "folky"

a
great asset.
There really are some fine songs here: "Pan

simply

performed truly wonder
harmonica and strong har
mony vocals blending with Linda's strong lead.
Robin, Linda, and Jim Watson excel in the har
American Boogie"

is

fully with Robin's

mony singing

on th eir

original "Stone Wall Coun

try," which was written for the popular play by
the same name. "Across the Blue Mountains" is

also beautifully sung
duet style.
If

in an

you haven't bought

emotional
this

CD,

a

cappella

you really

should.
DALE MORRIS

Homestead Picking Parlor, 6625 Penn.
Ave., So., Minneapolis MN 55423. 1-800-497

To order:

3655

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Merle

chorus), steel guitar, piano, etc., most of itsparseand
some of it excellent. The focus is

Travis

all of it good--

1944

entirely on Merle Travis and his guitar.
The liner notes are hard to read because

1949

of small

print and sparse punctuation, but it's worth the
effort because there is so much real solid informa
tion here along with some well-informed opinions.
I
can't tell if the record company is called

Country Routes,

Merle Travis-guitar, vocals;
dion;
Slim Duncan-clarinet;

Billie Liebert-=accor

Johnny bond-guitar,
vocals; Jack Rivers-guitar; Shot Jackson-steel guitar;
Joe Strand-piano; Harold Hensley-guitar;
Cliffie
Stone, Andy Parker, Charlie Morgan-vocals.

RFD,

Harlequin,

or

Interstate

Music. All those names appear on the packag
ing, but try the address below. This seems to be
an international effort― originally broadcast in

California

and Tennessee,

Canada, manufactured

photographed

in

France, owned (I think)
by an English company, and the notes written in
San Diego, California by Lou Curtiss.
in

you've never heard Merle Travis this is a
great place to start. Try to imagine the middle
ground between Dave Macon and Chet Atkins.
If

That's All/You Tell Me Your Dream/Old Rat
For Texas/The Cat Came Back/Bye Bye
Blues./Lawdy What A Gal/I'm Thinking To

Try to imagine

Railroad Train/Roll
night of My Blue Eyes/Blue
On Mississippi/Groundhog/Petticoat
Fever/

vibes" than all the new age guitar albums of the

tler/T

last
Tikki/Sheik
Araby/Hominy
Vacancy/T
he
buy
Grits/Nobody/Travis
Stomp/No

Rikki Tikki

of

Cat Came Backfversion

to

the Outskir ts of

Temp

2)/I'm Gonna Move
Town/John Henry/Sweet

was pure pleasure. Merle
Travis' playing is so right, so skilled and down
right enjoyable, that as I read the list of 22 pieces,

Listening

I

to this CD

can recall each one in detail. There may be

younger

OTH readers

some

who don't know

Mr.

Travis' work or reputation, so the rest of you
please indulge me while say this isn't exactly
I

old-time music. It's "modern"

in the

1940s

sense.

These are radio transcriptions from the '40s re
mastered beautifully and never before available
to the

public.

The

context

is

professional

entertainment

and live and lively it is.
Every Merle Travis fan will want this. The liner
notes suggest that this is Merle Travis at his best
--live radio--

tend to agree. While
haven't heard his
entire recorded output, I've heard enough to
realize this is wilder, looser, slightly less techni
and

1

I

cally perfect than his studio records (at least one
of which was recorded at half speed, timed an

octave too low and played back double speed!),
but more relaxed and natural.
Travis plays both electric and acoustic

in the

same complex two-finger picking style. The elec
tric, naturally, has more sustain, but the music is
very much the same either way. The songs and
tunes range from traditional songs like "John
Henry" or "Groundhog" to pop standards of the
to Travis' own hit records like

AOs and earlier,

"No Vacancy," back to energetic renditions of
songs made famous by Jimmie Rodgers, The
Carter Family, The Delmore Brothers, and

Grandpa Jones. He also sings, of course, and
while he was never the master of vocals to the
extent he was master of the guitar, his timing on
some of these songs is just great. There is also,
from time to time, clarinet, accordion, other gui
tars, other singers (with the occasional animal

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

10

years combined. If that appeals to you,
You'll smile continuously

this recording.

for 46

minutes.
JODY STECHER

To

tahon.

better fingerpicking than you
Try to imagine more "good

knew was possible.

order:

Interstate Music Ltd.

PO

Box

Crawley, West Sussex, RH11 0LX England
through Down Home Music (see pg. 51).

74,
or

�To

order: Sheila

Kay

Mars Hill, NC 28754

beyond them somewhat

in the

manner of Garri

son Keillor and his Lake Wobegon tales, or Jean

Ritchie

in her

wonderful (but long out

of print)

rhetoric,

about dancing with her
grave. Another tale, about tire

as in the story

grandfather

on

a

grandfather, goes beyond local
tough Flannery Cf Connor edge.
Adams' deep, resonan t speaking voice carries
the tales well, and her singer's control of cadence

steeliness

of her

Riverside recording of her readings from Sing
Some of Adams'
ing Family of the Cumberlands.
stories may be reminiscences, but most of them

color to develop

betray the strong formal elements of the fiction
writer. She uses some traditional themes (the

and tone makes us want to hear her traditional

elaborates some
laconic jokes replete with punch lines (the woman
whose flour sack bustle ends up advertising
"hant"

of

"The Ghost Dog"),

"Fifty Pounds

of the Very Best"),

pulls our leg

with some black humor (two women wrestling
corpse out of its coffin to change its burial suit),

a

and only

occasionally resorts

to

a

bit of

writerly

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

ballad performances. Neither so tender and inti
mate as Jean Ritchie's stories, nor so artfully
written and spoken as Keillor's monologues,

Adams' stories nevertheless give us an Appala
chian wri ter's dream-filtered voice evoking older
times and rural people we outlanders can never
fully know through their music alone.
JON AND MARCIA PANKAKE

Adams,

P.O.

Box 1188,

�music that he so obviously loves and has made
part of himself. It's always fun to get with Bruce
ata fiddlers convention and play music. But this

tape to my mind, showcases the depth of his
playing― beautiful, thoughtful, from the heart―
taking some chances, making them work. The
old fiddlers would be proud.

Audrey and Dirk's guitar backup is excel
lent― on the money and tasty. Dirk's banjo is a
truly fine companion to Bruce's fiddle, inter
twining and rhythmic

as it

should be― this

is

one of the finest
in

a

while.

banjo/fiddle combos I've heard
Dirk gets an especially fine sound

from his banjo without all the gratuitous string
"clucking" that so often obscures the melody.
this tape. And
love the dedication:
I love
"This recording is dedicated to all who love oldI

time music, regardless of where they are from,
what tradition they were born into." Right

or

On!
ALICE GERRARD

To order:

Bruce Molsky, 227 N. Greenbrier St.,

Arlington VA 22203-9525

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�surgeon's dream)!

I

enjoyed

a

lot of the non-old-

time performers as well, like Said Hakmoun and
Brahim Fribgane (from Morocco) and the Jamaican
Mento band, although both of them had curtailed
segments that, forme, were spoiled by musicologist
Dena Epstein's voice-over. Some of the dassicplayers were spectacular and Bud Wachter'sjazzy

"Hun

garian Dance Fantasy" on tire 4-string was mindblowing. Mick Moloney, Seam us Egan, and James
Keane contributed a very hot Irish medley as well.
The bluegrass, newgrass, and progressive stuff did
not interest me too much, but I can see a reviewer in
a

A

bluegrass publication taking just tire opposite tack.
couple of the performances were pretentious,

some were dry andsoulless, butoverallitis quite an
entertaining and enlightening video. At two
this truly is a meltdown, though. Once
you've been through the tape, however, you will

hours,

know when

fast forward

to

to the"

good parts."
through the entire
tape on my first viewing (yes, admit that did
melt down),
made it all the way though the
second time, which treated me to the interesting
video montage at the end. On that first viewing,
felt that the old-time representation was a bit
light, but no w can see that it is a pretty balanced

Although

I

did not make

it

I

I

I

I

I

presentation of extremely divergent styles. Of
would have liked to see on the tape
course
many of the old-time players who were at the
Institute and did not play in the Meltdown con
I

cert or were not

selected

for the

video

people

like Charlie Acuff, Ray Alden, Virgil Anderson,
Joey Burris, Walker Calhoun, Clyde Davenport,

Banjo Meltdown

Various

Artists

at

the

Tennessee

Banjo

Institute
TBI,

Nov. 1992,

2

Girl

John Hartford

so-called "meltdown" concert. There are other
selections taped in a quieter room with no audi
ence, and Abner Jay was recorded in his outdoor

hours
I

Left Behind; Abner Jay: My

Last Name Is the Blues; Abner Jay, Bob Carlin,
Clarke Buehling, Bob Plescher: Hambone; Mike
Seeger:

Around the Cows; Mike Seeger,
Bruce Molsky: Sweet Sunny South;
Winston, Bruce Molsky: John Brown's
Ridin'

John Cohen,

David

Dream; Bob Black and Carroll Best: Hog Trough
Reel; David Holt Reel &amp; Rock; Wade and Julia
Mainer: Can't Sit Down; Leroy Troy: Keep Your
Skillet Good and Greasy; Pete Seeger: Sailing Up,

Sailing Down;

Clarke

Buehling:

Far

South;

Ed

Lowe and Tom Sauber: Sugar Hill; Phoeba Parsons:
Minnow On a Hook; John Jackson: Cindy; Will
Keys: Silver Bells; Rich Stearns and Tony Trischka:

and many more.

Rueben's Brain.

Tennessee Banjo Institute gathered a di
verse and motley crew of banjoists near
Murfreesboro, Tennessee in November 1992 for
The

concerts, workshops, jams, semi
nars, and a great time. The premise sounds
overwhelming; heard that it was. In addition to
several days

featuring fiddle, banjo, and PVC pipe from Ja
maica―
you conjure up an idea, it was probably
presented there. Most of this video depicts the

of

1

the "old-time" banjoists listed above were some
premiere bluegrass and progressive 5-

"log cabin" set. One of the best scenes is at

a

jam

party with Gerry Milnes fiddling to Phoeba
Parsons' flatfoot dancing. The camera work is
at the

very professionally done, using multiple cam
eras with excellent placement and crisp editing.
The sound is pretty good too, although the more

controlled segments are superior to the live con
cert mixes. Highlights, you ask? Wade and Julia
Mainer sing their hearts out. The Seeger, Cohen,
Molsky tribute to Da Costa Woltz's Southern
especially when Bruce
a little
in
slips
bluegrass double stop and Mike
Seeger looks bemused. Will Keys is phenomenal
as he picks the beautiful "Silver Bells" with his
inside out picking. Phoeba Parsons is as much of
a joy to watch playing banjo as she is to watch
Broadcasters

is fine too,

dancing. Perhaps it's worth the whole cost of the
tape (which is reasonable, by the way) to watch
Leroy Troy go through his Uncle Dave Macon
routine of swinging and tossing the banjo while
constantly playing. Yes, you can run the tape in
to see just where he is striking the

slow-motion
strings

to keep it going as he completes his gyra
would hate to see one of his workshops. Can

of tire

tions.

string pickers, classic banjoists, jazz players on
4-and 5-strings, an Arab duet, a Mento band

metal around?Whatanightmare(or an orthopoedic

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

you imagine

20 or 30

people swinging that heavy

Leonard Davidson, Tony Ellis, Willis Fields, Alan

Jabbour (who does appear in the ending mon
tage with Bertram Levy and Tommy Thomp
son), Stu Jamieson, Grandpa and Ramona Jones,

Cordell Kemp, Mary Jane Queen,
Clyde Troxell, Bob Winans.
.well you get the picture. This easily could have
become a series of tapes. Tthere is an enormous
Phil Kazee,

Art Rosenbaum,

amoun

t

of great music here, and there is sure to be
that will annoy or bore most everyone as

something
well. ThaT

s

why they have the fast-forward button

on VCRs. And remember, as Pat Cloud says on the
tape, "There's only one now, and it keeps going!"
KERRY BLECH

To order: TBI

Murfreesboro

Banjo Meltdown, Box 529, MTSU,
TN 37132

Artists and record
material for review

companies
to

the

please send

Old-Time Herald,

PO Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717. Do not
send

to

individual reviewers.

�Copper Creek Records, PO Box 3161, Roanoke
VA 24015.

Homespun Tapes, P.O. Box 694, Woodstock,
New York 12498. 1-800-33-TAPES or 914-2462550

June

Appal

Recordings, 306 Madison

St.,

KY 41858.

Whitesburg
Marimac Recordings, PO Box 447, Crown Point
IN 46307. (219) 662-7305.
Old Homestead Records, Box 100, Brighton MI
48116.

Rounder

Records/Roundup,

One Camp

St.,

Cambridge MA 02140. (617)661-6308. Visa
Mastercard accepted-1-800-44-DISCS.

&amp;

Shanachie Records/Yazoo PO Box 208, New
ton NJ 07860 (201)

579-7763.

Smithsonian/Folkways Mail Order
414 Hungerford

Dr. Ste.

444,

Rockville MD

20850; (301) 443-2314. All the Folkways record
ings can be ordered on cassette. If a request is in

stock they can fill an order right away. Other
wise it may take from 4-6 weeks.

Arhoolie/Down Home Music,
Ave.,

El

10341 San Pablo

Cerrito, CA 94530.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Friends

Old Time
In

Memory of Larry MacBride

Recordings, now under
the direction of Gail MacBride,

Marimac

and with the help of Fred Campeau, is
committed to carrying out the special

vision that Larry had when he started
the company. Marimac is now caught
up on orders, filling out new ones, fin
ishing projects that Larry had begun,
and looking forward to new projects
down the road. "Larry is our
inspiraton, says Gail, and with the
support of all our friends, we are work
ing hard to move forward. Your sup
port of Marimac

and

its

is

products
greatly appreciated."
to
Larry's vision and imagination
under
and
of
his
say nothing
patience
in advancing the talents of
standing
his fellow musicians was well known to
us all. Under

his leadership

Marimac

released some
projects, mostly on
cassette with CDs just starting to ap
pear during recent months. Marimac
produced reissues of 78s by artists too
obscure for the larger independent la
bels and the work of dozens of revival
80

old-timers, who often had no other outlet
for the commercial release of their art.
"Larry had a hard time saying no' to
people if he liked their music," writes

Andy Cohen, "and he liked a lot of
music." Cohen also supplies us with a
moving description of Larry's funeral,
attended by family, friends, and
Marimac artists from Wisconsin to New
York.

"Chirps Smith, fiddler for the Volo

Bogtrotters,

played

Campeau sang

a

a

hymn;

tune; Mitch

I

sang one of

Rev. Gary Davis' songs, and folks joined
in. Fred Campeau, the Volo who does

most of the routine work for Marimac
now, spoke briefly about what it was
like to work with Larry and to know

him. The service ended with a quartet
leading all of us in Down In The Valley

Then we all went back to
Larry's house, where we ate, played
tunes, and talked. As the folks dis
persed, late that night and the next day,
there was a sense of resolution about
To Pray.'

keeping Marimac going,

as

closely as

Larry's vision of it."
Bob Bell also writes us from New

possible

to

Jersey: "A celebration of Larry's life
and work was held Saturday, Sept. 18
the High Crest Lake Lodge in West
Milford, NJ. It was hosted by Claire
MacBride and longtime friends Lynn
and Larry Mandon. Many friends and
members of the old-time music com
munity were in attendance. Joe Wilson
and I said words in remembrance of

at

Larry. Ray Alden, Bill Dillof, Tim
Brown, and MajorContayand theCanebrake Rattlers provided musical trib

utes. As Larry would have liked, im
promptu music played by the musicians
present followed the formal tribute.
"An industrial

chemist, Larry had
recently quit his day job, leaving him
uninsured when illness struck. A fund
called Old Time Friends (P.O. Box 447;
Crown Point, IN 46307) has been estab
lished to help deal with the expenses of
his illness and passing. Contributions
may be made to Old Time Friends, PO
Box 447, Crown Point, IN 46307."

�I

NEW RELEASES

Continuing Traditions

VINTAGE WINE
fiddle tunes by master
fiddler and National Heritage Fellowship winner, Melvin
Wine, with backing by Kate Brett on banjo and Gerry
Milnes on guitar. 60 minutes, 28 tunes

THE OLD TIME FIDDLERS
OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND

A treasure of traditional Appalachian

Catalog Number AHS#6

$9.00

f

ON A COLD WINTER NIGHT
Tom Paley and his son, Ben Paley, present a fine collection
of traditional songs and fiddle tunes, including some duo-

style Swedish fiddling. Tom, originally a member of the
New Lost City Ramblers, has been entertaining audiences in
the US, England and Europe with his expert guitar fingerpicking and superb banjo playing. Ben has been playing fid
dle since age 6'/2. 60 minutes, 29 tunes
Catalog Number 9050C

$9.00

A musical journey to PEI where a fine old-time fiddling tra
dition will delight the listener with its hard-driving, yet lyri

cal and ornamental style backed by guitar and, in some
cases, Ken Perlman's banjo playing. You'll hear a variety of

lively jigs, reels, hornpipes and marches, as well as some
all recorded in
waltzes, strathspeys, set pieces and aires
PEI by Ken. A companion booklet written by Ken further
describes the artists and their music. 60 minutes, 47 tunes
Catalog Number 6501C with booklet

$9.00

All Marimac cassettes are high-quality chrome tapes copied
in real time using Dolby B noise reduction.

BEST SELLERS
J000C

FORKED DEER Dan Gellert

9005C

GOING NOWHERE FAST
Uncle Willie &amp; Brandy snifters

&amp;

9.00

Shoofly

9.00

STILL LAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS
Lazy Aces

9.00

FLUKE HITS The Fish Family Dance Band

9.00

FARMER'S FROLIC The Ross County Farmers

9.00

9015C

THE WILDCATS The Wildcats

9.00

9018C

GOING ACROSS THE RIVER TO HEAR MY
MY BANJO RING Carlie Marion &amp; Andy Cahan

9.00

9021C

EVOLUTION GIRL The Double Decker Stringband

9.00

9025C

TROXSONG The Troxell Brothers

9.00

9028C

SARO Matokie Slaughter &amp; The Back Creek Buddies

9.00

9029C/9030C

LOTUS DICKEY VOL.

9008C
9012C
9013C

1

9033C

EIGHT MILES FROM TOWN Pete Sutherland

9.00

RAMBLING AND WANDERING
9.00

FOR AN OLD TIME CALL

The Double Decker Stringband

9.00

Postage

&amp;

Handling, U.S.A.: Add $2.00

Postage

&amp;

Handling, Non-U. S.A.:

Indiana residents

9039C

PRAIRIE DOG Lynn "Chirps" Smith

9.00

9042C

TOUGH LUCK The Volo Bogtrotters

9.00

FINE DINING The Boiled Buzzards (cassette)

9.00

for 1-2

items. Add $3.00

Add $2.00 per item, minimum

must add 5% Sate Sales Tax.

Write for a full listing of over eighty

Copyright
© 2021
Section with Illegible
TextProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Marimac

cassettes

and CDs.

2

cassettes

&amp;

booklet

18.00

9043CD

FINE DINING The Boiled Buzzards (CD)

90440

THE ROUND PEAK BAND The Round Peak Band

9.00

9045C

COME OVER AND SEE ME SOMETIME
Bob Bovee &amp; Gail Heil

9.00

THUMPING ON

A

15.00

WELL ROPE

Allen Street String Band

9.00

9047C

1st 1/2 C. Mac Benford &amp; The

9048C

LIVING BLACK AND WHITE The Heartbeats

9.00

9053C

EARLY COUNTRY DUETS Jim

9.00

Woodshed All Stars

&amp; Dave

9.00

FINE AS FROG'S HAIR The ILL-MO Boys

9.00

9056C

THE RED MULES The Red Mules

9.00

6021

LOUISIANA AND YOU Tracy Schwartz

9.00

9.00

The Wandering Ramblers
J035C

THE KIMBLE FAMILY

&amp; 2

Lotus Dickey and friends
9031C

9036C/9037C

C

6500CD

MODAL CITIZENS Party of
MODAL CITIZENS Party of

8004C

WALKING BLUES John Cephas

6500C

for 3 or

order of

more items.
2

items.

3

(cassette)

3

(CD)
&amp; Phil

9.00
15.00

Wiggins

9.00

Marimac Recordings, Inc.
P.O. Box 447
Crown Point, Indiana 46307

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12266">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 4, Number 2 (Winter 1993-1994)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12267">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12268">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 4, Number 2 (November-January 1993-1994)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Granny’s Birthday,” by Sheila Kay Adams&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Getting it Real Tight – Kay Justice &amp;amp; Ginny Hawker,” by Hilary Dirlam&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“An Interview with Gid Tanner,” edited by Dan Foster, Christy Palumbo, Charles Wolfe, and Alice Gerrard&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There,” by Art Menius&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Legends in Old-Time Music – No.9 The Skillet Lickers,” by John Lilly&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Buckdance, Flatfoot, or Clogging?,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Cracks,” by Bob Smakula&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Transcriptions,” by Hilary Dirlam&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Larry MacBride; “Boss” Sewell; Mary Ruth Newell Morgan; Carole Desjardins; Tommy Hunter; and Tom King; &lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12269">
              <text>1993</text>
            </elementText>
            <elementText elementTextId="12550">
              <text>1994</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="5717">
      <name>“Boss” Sewell</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="999">
      <name>1990s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1539">
      <name>1993</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2892">
      <name>1994</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5428">
      <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5485">
      <name>Art Menius</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5572">
      <name>Bob Smakula</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5719">
      <name>Carole Desjardins</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5657">
      <name>Charles Wofle</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5656">
      <name>Christy Palumbo</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5649">
      <name>Dan Foster</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1405">
      <name>Gid Tanner</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5655">
      <name>Ginny Hawker</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5476">
      <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5624">
      <name>John Lilly</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5654">
      <name>Kay Justice</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5716">
      <name>Larry MacBride</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5718">
      <name>Mary Ruth Newell Morgan</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5474">
      <name>Phil Jamison</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5653">
      <name>Sheila Kay Adams</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5490">
      <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5658">
      <name>The Skillet Lickers</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5720">
      <name>Tom King</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5564">
      <name>Tommy Hunter</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
