<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2588" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2588?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:54:50+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3523">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/f3a037b0c9f3a6aa86ed79d9d5d7daa3.pdf</src>
      <authentication>f2be714adf5194a5dfe0a61fbc288604</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12490">
                  <text>THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD

A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED
VOLUME

7,

John Hartford--

Reminiscences
by MIKE SEEGER,

VASSAR CLEMENTS,
BOB CARLIN AND OTHERS
Walk

A

Through Felts Park

DANCE

BEAT--

The Squeal Index:
Can Old-Time Bands

Make

the

It on

Contra Dance Scene?
by JOYCE GAUTHEN

ALSO

IN

THIS ISSUE

Reviews
Here

&amp;

There

Workshop

Cover Design:

David Lynch

www.lynchgraphics.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

NUMBER

9

TO

FALL

OLD-TIME MUSIC
2001

$6.00

�Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

Registration, Pricing,

www. Florida

Info:

Rhapsody

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

org

Section with Illegible Text

$299 before Aug 25
$349 before Nov 1 2
$399 after

�THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD
VOLUME 8, NUMBER

1

AUGUST-OCTOBER 2001

COMING IN THE NEXT
ISSUE OF THE OTH
Women Banjo Players
Del Na Sango Fiddlers

Albert Hash Memorial Band

Reviews /Dance Beat
&amp;

More

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�THE
HERALD

OLD-TIME

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.

51812/1812 House Avenue
Durham, NC 27707
Phone &amp; Fax: 919-402-8495

PO Box

E-mail:

oth@mindspring.com

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR

Alice Gerrard
ASSOCIATE EDITOR

William

N.

CONTRIBUTING

Hicks
EDITORS

Bob Smakula, Bob Carlin, Gail

Phil Jamison,

Gillespie, Tim Thompson
ADVISORY

BOARD

Ray Alden, Mac Benford, Hazel Dickens, Hilary

Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher, John Hartford,
Ramona Jones, Garrison Keillor, Pete Kuykendall,
Brad Leftwich, W. K. McNeil,
Lee Smith, Pete Sutherland, Charles Wolfe
OLD-TIME MUSIC

GROUP,

INC.

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Sally Council, Nancy Gottovi, Charlie Gravel,

David

Sheppard, Joe Thompson, Jim Watson, Kathy World,
Donald Zepp
ASSISTANT: Katherine Meehan

ADMINISTRATIVE

ADVERTISING:
VOLUNTEERS:

Katherine Meehan

April McGreger, Andrea

&amp;

Barry

Ford Summerlin
COMPUTER CONSULTANT: Dan Peck
WEB SITE: Charlie Gravel

No part of this magazine may be reproduced in any
form without written permission from the publisher.

Not responsible for loss or non-return of unsolicited
2001 the Old-Time Herald. The
photos or manuscripts.
Old-Time Herald (ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is

pub

lished quarterly the first of August, November, Febru
ary, and May by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc., 1812
House Ave., Durham, NC 27707. Subscription rates
payable in advance. One year: $20 (foreign subscrip
tions

$25 U.S.).

Library/Institutional

rate: one year:

$25. Classified ads cost 35 cents per word, minimum of
$5. Any grouping of letters or numbers is counted as

one word. All classified

ads must be received by the

first of the month, two months prior to publication.
Periodical postage paid at Durham, NC 27701 and

additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send change of
address to the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham,
NC 2771 7. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is a not-forprofit, tax-exempt corporation under section 501 (c) (3)
of the Internal

Revenue Code.

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love of

old-time music. Old-time music grassroots, or home
grown music and dance shares origins, influences
and musical characteristics with roots musics through
out America. Our magazine, the Old-Time Herald, casts
wide net, highlighting the Southeastern tradition
while opening its pages to kindred and comparable
traditions and new directions. It provides enlightening
a

articles and in-depth reviews, opportunities for musi
cal learning and sharing, and a forum for addressing
the issues and questions that bear upon the field. Rec
ognizing that in roots music ideas and values of many
kinds commingle, we strive to represent our interests
democratically and to embody the best ideals of race,
gender, and generational balance in a context of free
and open discussion.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�joking reference to his cell phone and Palm
Pilot. Later, when I asked him about the
remark, he said, "Part of my desire to put
this old music on the map is giving it some
meaning in the present. And I want people
to see the fact that

I

use

a

cell phone and

a

Palm Pilot, because they do too." Bruce
Molsky's got it right. Let's hope that the
next hit film featuring bluegrass gets itright, too, and uses the music as a positive
touchstone in the lives of modern people.
Michael Scully

Austin, TX

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Real Story
sure am enjoying the latest issue of OTH
(summer 2001), especially the new notori
ety I'm getting from Tom Jenkins' song
"The Story John Cohen Told Me." Since
songwriting is one of my many satellite
I

activities (better than just spacing out), I've
churned out yet another version of "One
Little Story the Crow Told Me," carefully
crafted and laboriously revised (for 1 0 min
utes) in

a

manner.
gether
tour

a

truly professional songwriting
look forward to slapping to

25-city North American contest
old popular face-off format

the

in

where

I

I

can pit my version against that of
we'll just sit back and

Mr. Jenkins, and then

watch that old money roll in.
Answer

to The Story John

Cohen Told Me

Tracy Schwarz
The Old-Time Herald came the other day
I
opened up the pages and what'd it say

Imagine my surprise if you possibly can
It wasn't John or Tom who named the
band.
Chorus:

Haw, Haw,
It wasn't John
Haw, Haw
I

or

Tom who named the band

am the man!

man from Indiana told it in a song
He broke the news, we had it all wrong

Now

a

Memories can fail

at an

And the truth hits like

a

awful fast pace
wet squirrel in the

face.

repeat chorus
I ran
to my archives, I ran to my tapes
Couldn't find what happened in '58
"Historians differ" Ira Mullins said
So I'll have to believe what I have read.

So

repeat chorus
Early this morning came

a

knock on my

door
25
"It

reporters and they all wanted more
won't hurt a bit," I said with aplomb

"To tell you the truth, man, this

repeat chorus and end

is the

bomb\"

it.

Thank you OTH and thank you Tom
Jenkins. You've made my day.
Tracy Schwarz

Tanner, WV

�Here &amp; There

Events

upcoming dances featuring guest fiddlers

The First Annual
&amp;

Dahlonega Bluegrass
Folkways Festival will be held Sept. 14

resort R-Ranch in the Mountains,
near Dahlonega, GA. Artists will include
Doc Watson, Rhonda Vincent &amp; the Rage,
16 at the

The Lynn Morris Band The Mark Newton
Band, Ralph Blizard &amp; the New Southern

Ramblers, Ryan Holladay Doyle Lawson &amp;
Quicksilver, Ralph Stanley &amp; the Clinch
Mountain Boys, The Nashville Bluegrass
Band, and others. There will be workshops

harmony singing, longbow fiddle, blue
grass banjo, flatfoot dancing, and old-time
banjo among others. There will also be
presentations about mountain folkways,
music, crafts, and customs. Info: 877-628
in

Dahlonega, GA 30533;

8674; PO Box 1415,

706-867-6710;

folkways@alltell.net;

September 22.
The Hunterdon Folk Exchange will hold
its 17th Annual Old-Time Fiddle Contest
at Howell Living History Farm in
Hopewell, N.J., easy driving distance for

Aug. 25

folks in NY, eastern PA, Phila., Delaware,
etc.
Info:
Chuck
Winch
MD,

www.virtue.nu/

cwinch@blast.net;

wilkins winch.
The Ozarks Celebration Festival and
Fiddlers Green will take place Aug. 25- 26
on tire SMSU campus, Springfield, MO. Info:

http://ozarksstudies.smsu.edu

or

contact

tobinbushman@smsu.edu.
Old-Time Music &amp; Dance Weekend in

Tobin Bushman

at

Mentone, AL will take place Aug. 17-19. Info:
JanSharpe, BCDSregqueen@hotmail.com; 205
595-9189.

www.folkwayscenter.org.
The Genesee Country Village

Tim Foss on August 25 and Lee Guthrie on

Museum

The 7th Annual

Mumford, NY will celebrate their 25th
Anniversary this year with the Fiddlers Fair on
Aug. 18-19 as part of the celebration. Info: 716

tains" Storytelling

&amp;

in

Oct. 11-13 at

"Voice of the Moun
Festival will be held

WVU Jackson's Mill

WV. Info: 1-800-287-8206

in central

or Bob

McWhorter,
mcwhort@earthlink.net.
A new musical saw festival will be held

538-6822; www.geneseecountryvillage.org.
The 2001 Hardanger Fiddle Assoc. of

304-269-2219

America

Richmond, VA Aug. 18 at Dogwood
Dell, in the picnic shelter. "The music will
be varied, weird, homemade, and probably

Annual Workshops

will take
9-12
at
St.
Olaf
place Aug.
College,
Northfield, MN. Info: www.hfaa.org.
On Sept.

15

the

Rockbridge Mountain

Music and Dance Convention

in

non-competitive way
sic and dance of the

to celebrate the mu
region and to cap off

the festival season.
The first major event of Louisiana Folk

non-profit organization dedicated
to nurturing the unique folkways and cul
tural resources in Louisiana, was the Dewey
Balfa Cajun and Creole Heritage Week at
Lake Fausse Pointe on Apr. 22-27. Featured
performers included Walter Mouton, Geno
Delafose, Steve Riley, Preston Frank, Savoy-Doucet Band, Boozoo Chavis, and Balfa
Toujours. Christine Balfa is the executive
director of Louisiana Folk Roots. You can
get information on the organization by
Roots,

in

way, way fun." Info: sawfest@yahoo.com.

Buena

Vista, VA will pay tribute to Mike Seeger,
who started the festival 15 years ago as a

a

or

The West

Harmony Annual Singing

Convention

at

877-295-2395

or PO Box 1234,

the Pleasant Ridge First
Baptist Church in Gore Springs, MS will
take place Aug. 18-19. Info: Chiquita Walls,

Oxford, MS

38655.
The 26th

NationalOldTimecountry Music

Festival will be held Aug. 27-Sept.

2 in

Avoca,

IA. Info: Bob Everhart, PO Box 492, Anita, IA

50020;

www.oldtimemusic.bigstep.com.

The 4th Annual Harvest Music Festival

southeast celebration of rhythm and
Americana") will take place Sept. 28-30 in
("a

Fairburn, GA. Info: 404-659-0919;
www, tdawgsproductions.com.
Still Dancing dance weekend in Black

contacting PO Box 389, Breaux Bridge, LA

Mountain, NC will be held Labor Day week
end with callers Cis Hinkle and Keith
Cornett.
Info:
Lchasel@aol.com;

70517;337-332-0967;christine@lafolkroots.org;

www.stilldancing.com.

www.lafolkroots.org.
The Lanesboro Barn Dance (Lanesboro,
MN) is now in its seventh season with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Artists
The Possum Haw Cloggers are looking
dancers in the Austin, TX area who are

for

interested in hoedown style square dance,
traditional Appalachian style clogging,
flatfooting, buck dancing, and running sets.
Info:

Cheryl

Dehut

512-259-1190;

dehut@fmp.com.
Old-time musicians performing at the
Charlie Poole VI Festival in May included
Doug Rorrer and His Towne Creek Boys

and Larry Sigmon and Barbara Poole.
Bob Bovee and Gail Heil's tour sched
ule includes the

following dates: Augusta
Old-Time
Week, Elkins, WV Aug.
Heritage
Wild
West
5-11;
Days in Viroqua, WI Aug.
18-19; Minnesota State Fair in St. Paul, MN
with Pop Wagner Aug. 23-24; Great River
Folk Festival in La Crosse, WI Aug. 26;
Nature Center Pioneer Days in Austin, MN
Sept. 15; Rails and Trails Festival in
Marysville,

dezvous

KS Sept. 29-30; Big

in Albert Lea,

Art Center in

Island Ren

MN Oct. 6-7 Heyde

Chippewa Falls,

WI on Oct.

public libraries in Mendota, IL Oct.
23, Morris, IL Oct. 25, Mokena, IL Oct. 27
and Columbia, MO Nov. 7. They will also
19, and

performing at the Ozark Folk Center in
Mountain View, AR for the Western Music
Festival Nov. 2-3 along with Pop Wagner,
Liz Masterson, and Sean Blackburn.
be

Cathy Fink, Marcy Marxer, Becky Hall,
Joyce Samples, and Kay Justice took part
in the recent Avon Breast Cancer three-day
walk. According to Cathy in thanking all
the folks who helped raise money "it was a
remarkable weekend and we collectively

raised over $6,250 for the cause."

Alan Jabbour, Larry Edelman, Bruce
Molsky, Paul Brown, and Beverly Smith
are among those who will be featured at the
Rocky Mountain Fiddle Camp near Denver,

www.RMFiddle.com.
Sisters will be perform
ing around California's Bay Area between
Nov. 7-10. Info: Irene Herrmann,
herrmann@cats.ucsc.edu; 831-459-9432.

CO Aug. 12-26. Info:

The Harmony

The

performing schedule

for

Bob

&amp;

Sheila Everhart includes Red Oak, IA Formtain Square Park Music Show Aug. 9; Anita,
IA Oak Tree Opry Aug. 10; Braddyville, IA

Aug. 11; Farnhamville, IA Old Settlers Day
Aug. 18; Lewis, IA Hitchcock House Un
derground RR Day Aug. 19; Avoca, IA 26th
National Old Time Country &amp; Bluegrass

Festival, Pottawattamie Fairgrounds Aug.
27-Sept.

2;

Anita, IA Hall of Fame Mini-

Festival Sept 21-23. They will be on tour in
England and Ireland Sept. 27-Nov. 12, and
in Denmark, Germany, Holland, Belgium,

�France, Switzerland, Austria, and the Czech
Republic from Nov. 14-Feb. 3, 2002. Info:

bobeverhart@yahoo.com.
T om, Brad &amp; Alice, include
Delaware Valley Old-Time &amp; Bluegrasss
Festival Sept. 1; Wheatland Music Festival,

Fall dates for

the

Remus,

ville,

MI

Sept 7-9; Laurel Theater Knox

TN Oct.

26;

Folkways Center,

Dahlonega, GA Oct. 27-28; concert and
dance in Birmingham, AL Nov. 2-3. Info:

www.bradleftwich.com.

Susan Cook and Marion Boatwright of
Weasel Creek String Band have opened
Weasel's Old-Time Music Dining &amp; Dance
the

where one can listen to old
time music, blues, country, and bluegrass
music three nights a week and square and
contra dance two nights a week. Info:
in Brevard, NC

www.weaselsoldtime.com; 828-885-2377.
The Herald

Angels will be performing at
FOOTMAD festival Sept. 21-22 near
Beckwith, WV. Info: www.footmad.org/
the

venue/fm/FCP.html.
Performances for Paul &amp; Win Grace in
clude Hartsburg, MO Aug. 14, info 888518-9961; Colorado, western Kansas tour
Aug. 22-Sept. 9, info Paul &amp; 573-443-2819;
Columbia, MO Boone Co. Heritage Festi
val Sept. 16, info 573-874-7466; Columbia,
MO Courthouse Square Sept. 30, info 573

Kennett, MO community con
info 573-888-6396; St. Louis,
MO, Focal Point Nov. 3, info 314-781-4200.
Check for updates on their web site
874-6386;

cert Oct.

4,

www.folkfire.org/ graces.
Jones and Leva will be performing in Wales,
England and Scotland in August. In the fall,
performances are scheduled from Pennsylva
nia to Tennessee, www.jonesandleva.com/;
duo@jonesandleva.com.

Dick Kimmel's schedule for Aug. and
Sept. include Mankato, MN Ribfest Aug.
17, Minnesota State Fair Aug. 23-24, Brown
Seed Co. Fest, Prescott, WI Aug. 25, Lake
Superior Music Fest Bayfield, WI Sept. 2,
Turkey Days Post Race Picnic, Worthington,

MN Sept. 15,Riverfest,NewUlm,MNSept.
Info: kirnmel@newulmtel.net;

16.

507-359-1163;

www.newulmtel.net.
Performances for Leela and Ellie Grace
include LaCrosse, WI, Great River Folk
Festival Aug. 25-26, info 608-784-3033,
grff@juno.com; Mountain View, AR Ozark
Folk Center Sept. 7-8, info 870- 269-3280;

Boone

Co.

Heritage Festival, Columbia,

MO Sept. 16, info www.ci.columbia.mo.us;
Berea, KY Dec. 26-31, info 859-986-1986,

www.berea.edu/dance/dancehome.htm.
(continued

on next page)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Updates

schedule can be found

to their

at

Rafe Stefanini has two new web sites,

www.folkfire.org/ graces.
In

Print,

School

In

&amp;

one for his luthier business and the other for his

music business: www.stefaniniviolins.com;

On the Net

northern Michi
know
about music
area
who
want
to
gan
events and other happenings, the Hiawatha
Music Non-Profit Co-op publishes, "ir
regularly," a newsletter. Info: PO Box 414,
For those of you in the

MI

Marquette,

49855;

906-226-85

75;

www.portup.com/hiawatha;
hiawatha@portup.com.
Society publishes

newsletter.

Info:

PO

Box 346, Athens, GA 30603. They also have
a web site at www.uga.edu/folkdance.
The

is

folknik

a

of the San

publication

Francisco Folk Music Club and is chock full
of news about events in the SF Bay Area
and environs.

Francisco

Info: 885 Clayton St., San

CA

94117;

415-661-2217;

www.sffmc.org.
Joyce Cauthen's book, IV; th Fiddle and
Well-Rosined Bow: AHistoiy of Old-Time

Alabama (reviewed in OTH
vol. 2 no. 5) has been issued in paperback in
May by the University of Alabama Press.
in

Fiddling

Charles Wolfe wrote: "This

is a

major piece

It be
American music scholarship.
longs on the bookshelf of every old-time
music fan." Info: www.uapress.ua.edu;
205-348-9534.

of

Bluegrass banjoist Murphy Henry pub
lishes a newsletter, Women in Bluegrass,
which contains articles, issues, and items
of particular interest to women. Info: PO
Box 2498,
Winchester, VA 22604;

nmhenry@visuallink.com.
The Charlotte Folk Society Newsletter
lists music events of interest to those in the
Charlotte, NC area. Info: Charlotte Folk Soci
ety, PO Box 36864, Charlotte, NC 28236-6864;

704-563-7080; phubicki@carolina.rr.com.
in

There have been several articles recently
North Carolina publications about the

North Carolina Music and Community
Project, The project uses traditional music
as a way to connect schools with communi
ties and communities with schools, and
involves teachers as well as students.
Dwight Rogers, banjoist and associate pro
fessor of education at UNC Chapel Hill,
NC is co-director of the project. For info on

contact
project
dlrogers@email.unc.edu.

the

Dwight

at

you want to find out what's happening
(including old-time and bluegrass music) in
If

southwestern VA go

virginiablueridge.org
of events. This will
detailed
listing of events
monthly
to

and click on calendar

give you

a

www.rafestefanini.com.
If you need to find resources on South
west Virginia history, genealogy, or folklife,
the Southwest Virginia Heritage Guide is
now online at www.virginiaheritage.org.

The site provides
ing of

a

county-by-county list

museums, archives, historical societ

genealogical repositories, walking/

ies,

The Athens (GA) Folk Music &amp; Dance
a

and contact numbers.

driving tours, and landmark structures

in

Southwest Virginia.
"Mugwumps Online has started a cen
tralized Stolen Instrument list. Several
other, existing stolen lists have joined with
Mugwumps to produce one place where
people can post or check about stolen in

struments. The consolidated list can be
found at www.mugwumps.stolen.html.
Some listings for camps, contests, and
dances can be found at the website link

http://oldjoebobclark.homestead.com/
Clndr_Txt.html.
Recordings, Instruments &amp; Labels
Emily Spencer, banjo player and singer
from Whitetop, VA took a high school string
band from Mt. Rogers High School to an
Appalachian Conference at the Snowshoe
Resort in West Virginia back in March. The
young folks had a wonderful time playing
the old-time string music for all the folks
until they realized that one of Emily's in
struments, a hand made fiddle, was miss
ing.

It

was made by Audrey Hash (daugh

ter of the late Albert Hash),

and

has

it

a

carved headpiece (a woman's head). You
can contact Emily at ESPENR@tcia.net.
Fiddler and scholar Lisa Ornstein has
started a fiddle program for 4th graders at
the Fort Kent Elementary School in
Aroostook County, ME for the 2001-2 school

year, and has put out an appeal for dona
tions of half or 3/4-size fiddles. If any of
you know of or have fiddles of this size,
please contact Lisa Ornstein, Director

Acadian Archives /Archives Acadiennes,

University

of Maine at Fort Kent; 25

Pleas

ant St., Fort Kent, ME 04743; 207-834-7536;

ornstein@maine.edu.
A new CD by Man Alive! (Joe Thrift,
Nancy Sluys, David Long, and Bill Sluys)
Ever What You Want, is out on the Yodelay

Hee label.

Info:

Nancy Sluys,

Minglewood Rd., Westfield,
www.bobvillemusic.com.

197

NC 27053;

Banjo player Dave Landreth (formerly
of the

Allen Street String Band)

is

currently

�at

work on

CD. Featured guests include

a

Chirps Smith, Fred

Garry Harrison,

Steve Rosen,

Campeau,

Egan, and Jim Nelson.

It

Geoff Seitz, Pat
will be available

sometime later this year.
Bruce Molsky has a new video on Home
spun Tapes: Southern Old Time Fiddle
Tour: An In-Depth Lesson in Traditional
Info:

Styles.

www.homespuntapes.com.

The new CD by James Reams and the

Barnstormers, Barnstormin',
on

Creek

Copper

is

available

Records

Info:
540-563-5937.
www.jamesreams.com;
Rafe Stefanini's new CD, Glory on the
Big String, has been issued on County
Records.
T wo new Copper Creek releases include
old-time music: the new Wolfe Bros. CD:
2001, An Old-Time Odyssey, and Bill and
Libby Hicks' new CD, South ofNoivhere.

(www.coppercreekrec.com).

The

Deering Banjo Company has relo

cated to 3733 Kenora Dr., Spring Valley,
CA 91977-1829. Phone and fax numbers
are still the same.

James Leva's new CD on Copper Creek
Memory Theatre, was released in

of

the

U.S."

Each fellowship

award

is

$10,000. For info on how to submit a nomi
nation call 202-682-5428 or write National
Heritage Fellowships, Folk &amp; Traditional
Arts, NEA,

Nancy

Hanks Center,

Pennsylvania Ave. NW,

Rm.

270,

1100

Wash

20506-0001.
ington
Senator Bill Frist of Tennessee has agreed
to become a member of the 2003 Birthplace
of
Country Music Alliance and
Smithsonian Folklife Festival Advisory
Council. The Council will advise and offer
general direction to the Smithsonian 2003
Folklife Festival and the Curatorial Com
mittee, which is responsible for develop
ing the festival program, based upon the
theme of the musical heritage of the heart
of Appalachia. The Smithsonian Folklife
Festival is held annually in Washington
DC

DC on the Capital Mall between the Wash
ington Monument and the Capital Build
ing. The Festival is held the last week of

June and the first week of July.
You can join the Rhythm Bones

Society

(mantra "may your bones be with you")by
contacting them at 1060 Lower Brow Rd.

Records,

(like the name!), Signal Mountain, TN 37377

July.888-438-2448;www.coppercreekrec.com.

for info.

North Carolina Cen
University
ter for the Study of the American South
explores" regional traditions and identity
"
in a rapidly changing world.
and pub
lishes a newsletter, Southern Voices. Info:
CB#3355, 03 Manning Hall, UNC Chapel
The

of

Hill, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-3355; 919-962dir.
at
5565;
Harry L. Watson,

hwatson@email.unc.edu.

There are lots of fiddle contests in Mis
souri. The Missouri State Old-Time Fid
dlers Assoc. puts out a newsletter /calen
dar listing them. MSOTFA, PO Box 7423,
Columbia, MO 65205.
The Bill Monroe Foundation is sponsor
ing a ribbon cutting and bluegrass show
near Rosine, KY. Monroe's boyhood home
has been restored by the Foundation.
Among those appearing at the show will be
Ralph Stanley &amp; The Clinch Mountain Boys,
Karl Shiflett &amp; Big Country Show, and
others including appearances by various
Blue Grass Boys.

lowships

National Heritage Fel
must be postmarked no

for

for 2002

later than Oct.

PM

&amp;

Sessions
old-time jam every Tues. at 8
Red and Black Cafe in Portland,

is an

at the

Oregon, S.E. 22nd and Division St. Info: Dickel
Bros.,503-235-9678;dickelbrothers@excite.com.
There is an Irish and old-time music jam
at O'Niell's Pub, 321 1 Central NE in Albu

querque, NM on Sundays. Info: 256-0564.
The old-time jam formerly held in Moun
tain View, CA has moved. It is now being
held

at

The Bean Scene, 186

Sunnyvale

7:30-10:30

S

Murphy St.,

on the 1st and 3rd Mondays,
PM.
Info: 408-243-7001;

Paul@Barnettfamily.org.
Mark Brissenden notes that there is no
formal Colorado Old-Time Fiddlers As
sociation, but there are regular old-time
jams in Boulder, on Tues. and Wed. nights,
and there's an afternoon beginner's jam the
last Sunday of the month in Denver. For
jam and dance info: Mark at 303-449-4319;

markb@glosa.com; http:/ /cfootmad.org.
In

Our

Thoughts

WV fiddler Melvin Wine, 92, suffered a
heart attack on June 12. The doctors veri
fied that there was damage to his heart. He
was taken to the hospital and remained
(continued on next page)

Organizations

Nominations

Jams
There

1,

2001.

Individuals nomi

nated "should be worthy of national recog

nition and must be actively engaged in
preserving the folk and traditional arts
and must be citizens or permanent residents

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

alert

and

spunky throughout

the

entire

ordeal. Back home, he appreciates hearing
from his friends. Melvin Wine, HC 36, Box

Copen, WV 26615.
Robert Stripling of the Stripling Bros.
(Robert and Lee) recently underwent sur
gery for an aneurism and is recovering
7,

nicely. Cards and letters may be sent to him

Willa

Robert Stripling, 412
Gardendale, AL 35071.
at:

Lane,

the same in the '90s as he had in the '50s. He
once said, 'I speak from my heart and I play
Richard Harrington,
from my heart.'"

Washington Post May 13, 2001.
Bay Area Cajun accordionist

1

at

Congratulations
Among the recipients of the 2001 Na
tional Heritage Fellowships are Hazel
Dickens, traditional singer and songwriter
from Montcalm, WV and Washington, DC,

Eddie

Pennington,

thumbpicking-style

guitarist from Princeton, KY, Joe Wilson,
folklorist, advocate, and presenter from
Silver Spring, MD and Trade, TN, Wilson
"Boozoo" Chavis, Creole zydeco accordi

onist from Lake Charles, LA. Presented by
the National Endowment for the Arts, the
awards will be presented in late Sept. in

Washington, DC.
Paul and Win Grace are celebrating their
25th

wedding anniversary.

West Virginia fiddler Glen Smith died
5. Betty Vornbrock wrote that Glen
was always very sharing with his music,
on Apr.

enjoyed attending the festivals and
contests around West Virginia. He was
born in Woodlawn, VA in 1923, and moved
to Elizabeth, WV in the '60s. Musical events
and

in West

Virginia will miss his presence,

and his driving mastery of the fiddle.
Joe Wilson reports that Lou Ella Menard,

wife of Cajun musician, D. L. Menard and
"earth mother and loving friend of all waifs
and fans who found their way to her door,"
added, "we predict a
improvement in the quality
of the coffee served in Paradise." Friends
died on Apr.

taking the simple and embroidering

7.

Joe

considerable

it in

completely natural sounding way.
Danny's way of embellishing the tunes is
a

exactly like Danny himself: stylish, but not
flashy, elegant, full of power and grace.
Danny was incredibly generous with his
music and I know that all of us feel grateful
to

have experienced that generosity."
Bobby Fulcher writes: "Bob Douglas,

one of the last fiddlers from the golden age
of

old-time music, died

see on May

2 at

Dayton, Tennes

in

age 101.

Although

he has

many fans of old-time
music, he was a great exemplar of the re
gional fiddling style made famous by the
Skillet Lickers, a vessel for his father's as
tounding 19th-century sound and style,
remained obscure

to

and an adaptive, creative,

Final Notes

Danny

Poullard died on Apr. 27 at the age of 63.
Suzy Thompson wrote: "After nearly two
decades of playing music with Danny
have remained fascinated by the way he
ornamented Cajun tunes. He was a master

wonderful mu

sician, who found steady work as a fiddler
from 1923 to 2001.
"Robert McKinley Douglas was born in
a tenant house in Sequatchie College, TN in
1900. His father, Tom Douglas, was known

throughout southeastern Tennessee as an
unbeatable fiddler, and he recruited Bob as
accompanist in 1917. Their lengthy music
tours, always afoot, covered the southern
end of Walden's Ridge, the Sequatchie
Valley, and the Cumberland Plateau in
Tennessee.
"His radio appearances must have num
bered above a thousand broadcasts, maybe
several thousand, as he was a daily fixture
an

on the Chattanooga

airways for decades,

accordionist
Chavis
died
on May 5 at
Wilson "Boozoo"

couple years in the early 1930s, a
full-time performer on Atlanta's WSB with
the Tennessee Firecrackers and Bill Gatin's
Jug Band. In 1928, he recorded for RCA
Victor with the Allen Brothers. He took

the age of 70. The son of tenant

Curly Fox along on the White Owl Medi

may write to D.L. at Route

1,

Box

9,

Erath,

LA 70533.

Lake Charles, LA zydeco

farmers,

Chavis learned accordion from his father.
He started performing in a family rim dance
hall in the late 1940s. Along with Clifton

Chenier he "provided a bridge between
the older Creole music called Ta la' and the
Chavis
harder zydeco that rules today.

played hard accordion, maintaining a
stripped-down sound that could ride a onechord vamp to exhaustion. Some thought it
archaic, and Chavis did sound pretty much

and, for

a

cine Show, Curly's first job in music, and
toured with Clayton McMichen and Carl

Cotner. In 1942, he hired and recorded
with teenagers Charlie and Ira Loudermilk,
who later, as the Louvin Brothers, became
the most influential male duet in country

history. In 1975, he won the
Smithsonian Institution's National Fiddle
music

(continued

on page 52)

�John Hartford

Reminiscences

—

edited by David Potorti and Alice Gerrard from interviews by David Potorti
wanted

to do this

record [Wild Hog

in

the

Red Brush] was really interesting to me
we all sat in a circle, and he would have

each musician take a song and arrange it
themselves. One song was mine, the next
was the mandolin player's, the bass
he said doit anyway you want to
when you look at the bass player
and nod your head, that means he drops

player's
do

it

out.

you can have him drop out, or look

someone else and have him drop out,

or

down to one instrument
yourself,
no instruments, or whatever you want

or

at

Rosenbaum

or go

to

do. That was the most interesting thing I've
ever recorded.
walked away from that

John Hartford passed away on June 4 after

a

Park,

State

Lebanon

of

Cedars

Institute,

Banjo

At

the

Tenne

e

Margo

Newmark

I

Back when

he

got

out

of the

Glen

supporters back in 1987 when we were first
getting started. He was always encouraging

Randy Scruggs played bass on that Steam
Powered Aereo Plain. And then I think we'd

and helpful,

go out, me, and him and Tut and

and his music and his spirit will

Following are reminiscences from some of his
Ronnie

friends: fiddler Vassar Clements,
McCoury of Del McCoury
Josh Graves,

and musician

's

band, dobro player

recording engineer
Mike Seeger.

We

s

Lachot,

Bob Carlin, who

member of the Hartford String Band

was

a

the

time

letter.

of John's

death

wrote

him

a

at

final

A.G.

meant a lot to me; we were the
closest of friends, in fact, probably
the closest friend. Even though we weren't
together all that much, we knew in our
hearts how much we cared for each other.

He

We always have, ever since I met him. He
was a jewel out of all jewels. One of a kind,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Norman,

bass player somewhere
around, he played, and if there wasn't, we
just played ourselves. But that was so dif
ferent that records companies didn't know
and

be with us.

always

if

taught

it to

is if

I

did

it.

Cause

me.

don't think he ever had an idle moment.
He was doing something or thinking about

Campbell thing in California, and he came
down here and put this band together, me
and Tut (Taylor) and Norman (Blake), and

lymphoma.

something like that again
he
I

John was on the advisory board of the OldTime Herald and was one of the original

long battle with non-Hodgkins

thinking, wow, this is really something
special. The only way I could be a part of

there was

a

which way to take it.
But now, today, it
still stands. It was so different that it still
stands. People listen to it and play the
music. They say it's one of the best things
they ever heard, the most different.
The other day I got cold chills trying to
play (at the funeral), knowing that John
wasn't there with me. That was one of the

hardest things

or

going out

to eat, he

at his

would order

and then he'd sit there and sketch you.
had some great caricatures that he drew of

I

Scruggs, Benny Martin, Vassar
Clements. They're really funny, and it's
really his view on somebody. He had such
Earl

an eye and an ear for things. One time at

a

jam session

we always had them at Larry
Perkins' house he walked over to the
house, and he said, "You walk on the down

beat." And he had written this whole rea
son why, you know.

I

thought, "This guy

is

really something."
He had such an impact on people. He
was just so different of an entertainer and a
character.

If

everybody

in

a

room says yes,

John would say no, and have a lengthy
reason why. You just don't come across
told some
people like him every day.
that
think
that
he
was
the most
people
musician
and
creative, original
composer
in this town. There's a lot of original guys
here, but not many who can play all the
I

to do.

Vassar Clements

We got in the

something constantly. Playing music
house,

studio, and the way we

1

(continued on next page)

�instruments and have such
style on the instrument.

distinctive

a

knew immediately what
love Bird,

Ronnie McCoury

really play

I

love trying
it

on

a

to

was. He said,

it

"I

play that stuff. Can't

fiddle but

I

try

anyway."
Wes Lachot

I

I

thought John was a great songwriter, and
loved his singing. He's a genius when it

comes

to

songs and writing stuff, you know.

Met him back in the days of the Glenn

was with Flatt and
know him then. He (and
Earl) were close friends, I know we'd go to
Earl's home and have a pickin' and John
would come, and a bunch of us would get

Campbell show,
Scruggs and got

I

to

together and sit there and play. He sure
idolized Earl.
I lost
my leg a year or so ago. The week
that I come home he called and wanted to
know if I wanted him to come over and
entertain me, and cheer me up. I said, "John,
I don't
feel like having company right now
but I'll call you when I'm fittin'." So I called
him in about three weeks, and him and a
bunch of guys come over and set and

played, and
on tape

1

I

played with them.

wouldn't take nothing

I

got that
for it.

Josh Graves

Did you know he was buried in a Batman
cape? Somehow it got thrown into his
clothes that were intended for the funeral
home, and they mistakenly dressed him in

What got to me with John was after he
started working as a soloist, because of his
ability to entertain people, to be in touch

two weeks before he passed. He lived on
the Cumberland River, and he was on the
porch there. And it was a point where he
was barely able to talk, and had no use of

with people closely, without screaming and
yelling at them, but by being almost

his hands, or very little use of his hands, he
could walk a hundred feet. Whatever he

Buddah-like quiet. Whimsically playing a
few different twists on the Scruggs style,
one where he riffs with his voice, chromati
cally, another where he played double time.
Some new ideas that nobody else was do
ing at the time, which to me were major
evolutions within the basically bluegrass

said,

It's

his

totally idiosyncratic,
style.
just
unique imagination at work in a very mu
sical way. And in a way that was also
accessible to people for entertainment.
Then, when he started dancing, I re
member seeing him once in Charlotte [NC]
where he had the 4x8 sheet of plywood
wired with pickups, and he had a flanger
on it. And he'd dance over to different
parts of the board to get different tones,
and basically play music just with his feet,
using the different tones of the different
places on the board with the flanger, the
he'd be

and he had

play
phase shifter. And of course,
ing his fiddle or riffing. And then he had a
wireless microphone where he could go
out into the audience and he would riff
with his voice and ask people to sing along,
to mock what he was doing. It was a new

he just did it

twist to "Sing along with me." And then
he'd get progressively more and more dif
ficult, until it became totally impossible for

the cape. And when Iris wife saw it, she decided
to

leave him in

it,

cause

it

seemed so John.

The day I met him, he went into the
bathroom and came back ten minutes later,

written two songs. And he
them
both for me, and they were
played
That's how prolific he was,
both good.

obsessively Like

he did

every

thing. And they were fumry, they were
well-crafted, they were in different keys,
and he was already able to perform them in
his relaxed, funny style two or three min
utes after he had written them. And appar
ently his mind was able to handle both of
those things at once. That's just the kind of
guy he was, he was one of a kind.
John was a real intellectual, he had a lot
of varied interests. I'm sure you've heard
the stories of him trying to play Ornette

almost anybody to follow him, but he did it
in such a way that people laughed at it
rather than feeling like they had failed. I
think that's an incredible gift to be able to
do that in such an

engaging way.
And then of course, he's gone through
all these different investigations of differ
ent ways of playing music with people. He
can have that way of being on stage and
being quiet, with maybe just him and Roy
Huskey, Jr. And then of course with the

Coleman and crazy jazz players. I remem
ber him working on weird out-of-tune crazy

String Band, he was exploring different
ways of arranging string-band music. And

folk scales and stuff. He liked to push the
boundaries. Somehow he managed to do

his

that while sliding under the wire of being
that was a real juggling act.
traditional
[He played] his version of Ornette

Coleman. One day we were riding along
and
happened to have in the cassette
player some Charlie Parker stuff, and he
1

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

very hard worker. He told me how he did
things, and he really worked at it.
I wanted
to tell just a little bit about the
day that we went down to visit him about

newest recording, which

is basically
while
he's
him telling stories
playing fiddle
tunes that are dedicated to some of his
mentors. He's just gone through all these
different investigations of ways to musi
cally entertain people with his whimsy and
craft, which he actually did work hard for
and organized. He was a hard worker, a

you could barely understand the
whisper, (so) everything was to the point.
Gillian Welch and David Rawlings were
there, and his agent, Keith Case at some
point was there, and Bruce Molsky came in
for a while. And what he did, was to ask
each person to play a little bit. And he
asked Bruce to play about five or ten tunes,
by name, in a certain way, and then dis
cussed them a little bit, or had a comment
about each one. And then he asked me to
play particular pieces, which showed that
he knew my repertoire. Gillian and David
played for a little while, and there was
some discussion there. He beckoned to a

neighbor or somebody to bring his newest,
yet unreleased CD out, and we listened to
it. My sense of all this was that he was
having an afternoon's entertainment, just
as it

would have been, but the only way

that he could play was to play the CD. He

was entertaining us in yet another way.
And there was a fellow there who had
been there for several days, whose name I
can't remember, that John had had a long
time relationship with, in a mentor situa
tion, where John was trying to help this
fellow with his fiddling. The fellow was
from Pennsylvania. And so he listened,
and he had a couple of comments, and
evidently he had been doing this all along,
and that's a side of John that I'd never seen
before. He'd had some suggestions for me
that have been useful for me.
And in a sense, he was a mentor to me,
too, even though he was younger, and
since

I

in that

also have lymphoma, he is a mentor
sense, too, because I have seen over

the past three years what he's gone through.
It's a long, slow moving, chronic illness

that's dealt with by chemotherapy. And of
course as you know he's been dealing with
it for 20-25 years. Almost 20 years ago we

festival, and he said, "Well, I just
had an operation, what do you think about
that?" We talked briefly, and then some
were

at a

guy, hippie-ish, came up and presented
him with a hash pipe. And John was giving
I don't
that kind of thing up at the time
think he'd mind if we said that, he was kind

�giving up that end of things and he
thanked him in a very polite way. People
had a way of being very personal with
John. Even up to wanting to help him with
his illness in a most insistent way. They
of

really, really cared in

very personal way.
many ideas and so much
energy, that sometimes it could get almost
aggravating, because he was on some other
level. I remember when we were recording
He had

a

so

Retrograss he'd be sitting on the couch there,
very tired, but he'd be coming out with all
"We should do this, we should
these ideas
do that, or we could do that." And you'd
just have to say, well, at some point you
have to stop and actually do it. Or pick out
one of the possibilities. Some of the things
are just totally

impossible.

There were no fights. That was the most

amazing

thing

about working

with

Retrograss. There was a way of working
which is very rare in a group that I've ever
been part of. If there were things to be
done, there would be a way to figure out
how to do this in the best possible way. I
had trouble with some of the chords, some
of the simple chords, I couldn't follow some
of the things, because I'm kind of a funny
old-time musician. And John and David's

sensibilities

of

improvisation

are far

be

yond my understanding. And so when

it

just couldn't do it,
way to let me know that

became evident that

I

they figured out a
in the easiest terms. And as far as deciding
what had to be done, well, it was done in an
easy way, and everybody got along. It was

amazing occasional group.

an
I

had this idea about

a

Midwestern sen

Guthrie and Roger
Miller and John had, that's just unique. I
mentioned this to John once and he said,
sibility that Woody

"Oh, Roger Miller was a hero of mine." In
fact, one of the things he said he wanted to
do about a year ago was to put out a whole
album of him doing Roger Miller songs
with Buddy Emmons.
John was

a

wonderful man, and critics

didn't always understand him because he
was always doing something that they
weren't used to. I think people have begun
to catch up with him a little bit, but never
that he was
a good sign
always moving ahead, he was still moving
ahead. And I think people will probably
have mixed feelings towards this thing (on
his new CD) where he chants his thanks to
his mentors
well, now that he's gone,
they probably won't be as rough on him.

quite, and that's

But that's the

way

it is.

He was sitting on the couch once, and we

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

were talking about Ed Haley, and there
was a mandolin handy, and he picked up
the mandolin and started playing it like
Mrs. Haley. He had that ability to be so

musical he could play other people's music
too. He mocked Stringbean on one song on
Retrograss where he played clawhammer

banjo. And so forth and so on. You un
doubtedly heard the recording Good Old
Boys? When he did some banjo break on
"Billy the Kid," just went off on
somewhere, I just thought that was

fling

a

tremen

dous. To me, those are Hartford moments.
Mike Seeger

John Hartford

General Delivery
St Louis, MO.
June 18, 2001

Dear John:

you're probably piloting the
other favorite steamboat
some
Twilight
of yours, with a round-the-clock jam ses
By this time,
or

sion on one of the decks. I'm sure that
Benny Martin, Ed Haley, Monroe and many
of your other favorite musicians have joined
you in playing endless fiddle tunes. I'll bet

you've even organized

a

contest
Arthur

with Clayton McMichen,
and Howdy Forrester battling

it

or

two,

Smith,

out for the

grand prize.
You'd be happy to hear that your book
about the legendary West Virginia fiddler,
The Search For Ed Haley Volume One, is near
is finishing the

completion. Grey Larson

musical transcriptions of Ed's extant home
recordings, and your co-author Brandon
Kirk has given your wife, Marie, a copy of
the manuscript to engage a publisher Y our
tribute to the fiddlers back home in Mis
souri from who you learned to play,
Hamilton Ironworks, will be issued by
Rounder Records at summer's end.
It shouldn't surprise you that you've left
a

gap that will be hard to fill. There aren't

many performers with your clout to carry
traditional fiddle tunes to the audience

outside of the

The Old T ime Herald's

reader

ship. Who else besides you would have
gotten fiddling onto the soundtrack of O
Brother Where Art Thou? or the tunes of Ed

Haley onto bfuegrass festival and concert
stages? Who else will have the resources,
let alone the committment, to invest 10
years into researching Haley and his mileu?
Luckily, everyone who has known you
will carry a bit of your enthusiasm, your

:uriosity, your love of tradition, and your
gift of melody with them throughout ev
i
erything that they tackle. In the coming
years, lovers of old-time music, players of

&lt;

fiddle, and the greater public beyond
te circle will benefit from your
investigations and performances. Whether
we realize it or not, we all owe you a debt
the

our immedia

of

gratitude.
All my affection,
Bob Carlin

�AUGUST

31

-SEPTEMBER

2

Tribute to

Qrandpa Jones Concerts with Ramona Jones
and the Jones Family

SEPTEMBER 14-15

American Music Series

Concert featuring "Spider" John Koemer

OCTOBER 19-20

American Music Series

Acadian Weekend featuring Nezpique, an
authentic Cajun ensemble representing the
French music of Louisiana, and Linda Breitag
playing Quebecois fiddle traditions
The Ozark Folk Center

is

an

Arkansas State Park

with the mission of preserving and interpreting the
music, dance, crafts and cultural traditions of the Ozarks.

Call or write:
The Ozark Folk Center
P.O.

Section with Illegible Text

_

Bon 500

Uisit at

Mountain lliew,

HR

72560

800-26^-3655
uiiuuj.Dzarkfolkcenter.coni

Music and dance concerts, workshops, seminars and contests.
Fiddle, banjo, guitar, autoharp, hammer and mountain dulcimer events.
Concert tributes to Jimmie Rodgers, Merle Travis, Jimmy Driftwood,
Grandpa Jones and other music legends.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Dance Beat

The Squeal Index:
Can Old-Time Bands Make

by Joyce

It

on the

Contra-Dance Scene?

Cauthen, Susan Davis, and Scott Russell

before old-time musi

could be part of the dance scene. Before

did much singing, they mainly
sat around in circles and played tunes. At

long old-time musicians-who in general
cared more about tunes than the dance
were sharing the dance schedule with bands

in the '70s,

cians
Back

least that's what we did here in Alabama
and

Georgia. We weren't invited to do
many stage performances, as normal audi
ences didn't want to hear one tune after

that in general cared more about the dance
than the tunes. The latter day contra bands

another, especially since they all sounded
alike. Even our spouses and children
wouldn't stick around long to listen. But,
loving the music as we did, old-time musi
cians wanted someone to share it with and
before long, we realized that we were des
tined to play for country dances. Most of
the fiddle tunes we played were dance
tunes and there were folks out there who
wanted to dance. It was perfect so perfect
that if we didn't have country dance groups
where we lived, we organized them. We
formed dance bands, gave ourselves goofy

which they,

names, practiced, played for dances, re
ceived our applause, went home and prac
ticed some more.
It was just like it ought to be. Baby
boomers were dancing to the same music
with the same spirit that their ancestors
had, maybe. There was one difference. By
this time contra

dancing had enjoyed a
revival across the nation, becoming popu
lar in places where it had never lived be
fore. But it didn't matter; dancing contras
to southern old-time string music was tre
mendous fun. Contras were easy to call,
quick to teach and that was great because
we got to play more tunes in one evening.
Fast forward to the '90s. The emergence

some very creative New England contra-dance bands showed musicians of per
suasions other than old-time that they too
of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

developed

a

repertoire of musical devices
well as their detractors, call

as

"cheap tricks," designed to elicit cheers
from the dancers. These include medleys

combining tunes that are wildly different
in key and character, long passages played
by one instrument until the rest of the band
comes in with a bang, chords sustained to
create tension then released to spark pan
demonium, abundant use of syncopation,
dynamics, and daring pauses. Their tunes
old-time, Celtic, New
England, Eastern-European or of some

can be traditional

other exotic origin, with snippets of Ameri
can

television theme songs and golden-

oldie rock

'n' roll

tunes thrown in, played

on an ever-changing array of instruments,
perhaps fiddle, keyboard, bass, rainsticks,
bongos, or a full drum trap.
The dancers eat it up. They greet each
new trick with cheers and throw them
selves into the dance even more exuber
antly than before. Though some find the
music distracting and manipulative, many

others find

great fun. They recognize the
tricks and feel that they are in on the joke.
it

They clamor for more. They begin to prefer
these dramatic bands to those who simply
strive to play good tunes well. As a result,
today many of those booking dance bands
employ a squeal index and a band that
doesn't make 'em shout gets a low rating.
In

dance communities

where

old-time

musicians are not involved

in the

dance

they may find their bands

organization,
booked less frequently at regular dances,
never invited to dance weekends and feel
ing like second-class citizens in general.
Many old-time musicians have simply

given up on the contra dance scene; how
ever they should take heart in knowing

a still
plenty of contra danc
who enjoy their music. The
Birmingham Country Dance Society books
only old-time bands for its dance weekend

that there are
ers out there

and always reaches its capacity of 300 within
a week or two of
sending out the fliers. That

weekend has showcased

a
large number of
southern
old-time
bands
straight-ahead
that have figured out how to play for contra-dances without sacrificing the integrity
of the music. These bands employ a few

tricks, but not cheap ones.
In the following pages, we'll talk about
some of the "tricks" some essential, some
that old-time bands might want
optional
to consider if they wish to hold their own in
the contra dance world.
The essential "trick" is to master abso

lutely and unequivocally, the basics of play
ing for a dance. These are playing with
distinct phrase and undeniable pulse, work
ing effectively and co-existing happily with

callers, being sensitive to the tempo needs
of the dancers, playing AABB tunes, being
flexible and good natured about tune

choices, and being friendly, cooperative,
and happy to be there.
The basic elements of dance music
pulse and phrase have to be present all
(continued on next page)

�night long

to

The pulse

is

struments

sustain good contra dancing.
provided by the rhythm in
a steady downbeat supplied

by bass notes (guitar or bass) and a reliable,
tasty upbeat to give lift (the strum of the
guitar). Dancers' feet go down on the down
beat (that's the easy part) but what goes
down has got to come up, or it isn't danc
ing. Fortunately, old-time music excels in
the pulse category and a good old-time

band carries the crowd along with its music.
Strong phrasing is what gives shape to
the dance (as well as the music), and makes
contra dance choreography work. Among
other things, this means that those groove
tunes that we love to play with one or two
chords and four or five melody notes may
flop as contra-dance tunes and probably
should be saved for a square or a free-style
clogging number later.
Tempo is important. Contra dances can
be danced to a fairly wide range of tempos
if the music has the necessary pulse and
phrasing. Vary tempos from selection to
selection, having some blazing fast tunes
and some that hold up well at a slower

pace. Setting the tempo

sponsibility

but

it is

is the

caller's re

perfectly permissible
know

for the band leader to let the caller

that they have more than one speed and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

more than one mood and would relish the
opportunity to fit their tunes to the needs of
the dance. Start the dance with a strong

four-beat shuffle that indicates the tempo,
then keep an eye on the dancers to see if the
pace you've set is a good one. If you see
them running to finish a figure, not making
it to their places in time or if you see their

tongues hanging out, you may want to
slow down. If you see dragging feet and
exaggerated movements, you'll know to
heist it up a bit. When you've been given
the signal to stop, you can signify the end of
the tune by retarding, you can put a tag to
hard, percussive out.
Medleys are just about mandatory these
days (unless you are Ralph Blizard and can
improvise all night). Changing tunes dur
ing the course of one long contra dance not
it, or

you can do

a

only makes the music more interesting for
the dancers but for the players as well. It's

difficult

to put together good medleys in
the heat of the dance; most of us need to

plan and practice them. In doing so, we
should pair tunes that not only go together
musically but also have an emotional effect
on the dance. Use the first tune to "set up"
the second tune so that the energy level

rises. Good key changes made in the right
direction can certainly uplift the dancers.

Banjo players can drop out to retune, then
come in at the beginning of the second

tune. If they don't want to do that, they can
use key-change medleys as justification for
that second banjo they've been wanting.
In medleys the duration of each tune
does not always have to be 50/50. Use

simple techniques to highlight the change
such as blocking the chords (striking the
chord with one big downstroke at the be
ginning of the phrase, leaving a "space"
before the next chord), taking a breath" (a
slight pause) between tunes, or occasion
ally starting the second tune with a brief

melody solo. Make sure the tempo stays
the same for both tunes and that both tunes
have that strong pulse that drives the danc
ers down the hall, and right back up again.
The band usually chooses when to change
tunes, though you can ask the caller to cue

you. Try to time the change by watching a
couple, so that the new tune coincides with
a new top couple entering the dance. It's

possible

that the caller will not want

a

square, however, and its best
to clarify that before the dance starts.
A tune list filled with a variety of tunes

medley

for

a

you play well hoedowns, marches, reels,
polkas, rags, and more than two romantic
waltzes is essential. Among them should

a few driving tunes, some smooth, some
sweet, some stately. You'll definitely want
to have a few modal tunes on there. Take a
good look at the chords of the tunes on
your list. Chord structure reveals how tunes
are different from each other and dancers

be

relate

want

much as they do melody. You'll
make sure you have enough inter

it as

to

est and variety in this respect

Before selecting a tune or medley to play
a dance, ask the caller about the figures
in that dance. Find out where the balances
are, so you will know to choose tunes with
good strong downbeats at those points.
for

Inquire about the mood of the dance. Is it
bouncy, marchy, sultry, or hoe-downish?
Take that into consideration as well as the
key and mood of the tune you played right
before this one in order to avoid redundan

you've chosen the tune, go only
where it takes you and take the dancers
with you. Improvisations should be spon
taneous, used sparingly, and should grow
cies. Once

organically out of the tune and the tradition.
Ways to add zest include rhythm drop
outs, which are effective when done well
and when the melody instruments can carry
the dance. Also, a banjo or fiddle solo gets
attention. A two-fiddle band can add vari
ety by playing harmonies sometimes and

�doubling other times. Guitarists can use
different voicing of the chords (the "ar
thritic" A, for example). They can play
runs, walks, and leading tones to the next
chord. Strums can be played percussively
or deadened. The bass player can use runs,
single notes, leading tones, slapping and
bowing. Most of these tricks show up one
time or another on the old 78s from the
golden age of string-band music. They are
fun to do in moderation and they add
interest to the music for the dancers.
Even when you've pulled all the tricks
out of the bag, you may still not register on
the squeal scale. One real problem for old-

time bands today is the "big box" venues
that have become common in some com

as contra dances have come to
attract large numbers of dancers, in some
places hundreds at one dance. Many dance
groups, especially in cities, have outgrown
the cozy, friendly dance halls they started

munities

in and have

moved

to

hollow gyms and

other large spaces. It's just plain hard to fill
some of these halls with sound from a
handful of acoustic instruments. That's one
of the

ably

reasons that dancers respond notice
electrified, wind or brass instru

to

ments, and drums.
These

large, urban dances also foster

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

competitive nature, both for the dancers
and for bands that may be attracted by the
relatively large take at the door. Traveling

bands need these gigs

to

pay the bills. This

competition can lead to an escalating array
of musical tricks and gimmicks, which puts
traditional bands at a disadvantage. If you
want to play these venues, look at ways to
make your sound bigger and richer, such
as adding more instruments (second fiddle,
bass, mandolin are good
choices). Work to get the most possible
from sound reinforcement
use quality

harmonica,

pick-ups and microphones and come early
to work with the sound technician for a
thorough sound check. If you have good
rapport with the dance group's leaders,
encourage them to consider acoustic treat
ments of the hall if possible and sound
system improvements, if needed. All the
musicians and the dancers who play that
hall would benefit.

Another alternative is to not play the
big boxes but instead seek out dances at
smaller, warmer halls, where old-time
music feels right at home. Alternative
smaller dances are beginning to sprout up
in lots of towns, organized by dancers
who prefer a more traditional dance
with a community/participatory feel.

A third

dances

alternative

is

not to play for

perfectly reasonable
in many country
climate
response
dance groups today. However, we, the
authors, plan to hang in there. The magic of
contra dancing is what happens when the
music, the dance, and the dancers come
together in unity, just like what happens in
a
really good old-time jam. To us, the joy
that comes when we hit upon just the right
tune and the dancers are loving the mu
sic
and loving us for making it is worth
at all.

That's

a

to the

the effort that

it

takes to make

it

on the

contra scene.
Note: For more tips on playing for dances,
see Phil Jamison's excellent article, "Make
'Em Want to Dance" published in the OldTime Herald, fall 1991.

Joyce Cauthen

is a

founder of the Birmingham

Country Dance Society and member of the Red
Mountain White Trash string band. Susan
Davis and Scott Russell have been dancing,
calling, organizing, and playing for dances in
Atlanta, GA,for over 20 years.

�IN

MEMORIAM

BENNY MARTIN, SR.
1928

2001

Premier Country
and Bluegrass Fiddler
and a Good Friend

SUPER-SENSITIVE MUSICAL STRING

CO.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�award had been drawn from differentparts
of the

old-time music world

broadcast

ing (Ralph Epperson, 1994), academia/
publishing (Dr. Charles Wolfe, 1996) and

performance (Wade and Julia Mainer, 1998).
For 2001, the OTR Steering Committee
chose to honor a pioneer in the recording
business, Dave Freeman of County Records,
whose decades of dedication to document
ing and recording old-time music, and
making it available to fans via the County
Sales distribution system has been a critical
factor in keeping the music alive. For those
in the audience with a sense of history, it
was more than fitting and appropriate that
Dave would be presented the award by his
longtime friend (and fellow recipient) Ralph

Epperson.

Following the award ceremony, the
music picked up again with a set by the
Mando Mafia, from Charlottesville, Vir
ginia, and the evening closed out with the
Toast String Stretchers, featuring the one
and only Benton Flippen. It was a long day
and evening for conference attendees, but
they were back strong the next morning for
tour of the WPAQ studios before return
ing to the Griffith Playhouse for a seminar
a

on broadcasting

issues, led by Ralph and
Kelly Epperson. The final "working" ses
sion on Thursday afternoon gave everyone
chance

thoughts and opinions
what was good,
what was not quite so good, and what they
would like to see in future conferences.
Having received a lot of worthwhile input,
the OTR Steering Committee decided to
a

about

to air their

conference

the

begin initial planning to hold the confer
ence again on its normal two-year sched

ule, tentatively set for June 3-5, 2003 in Mount
Airy. T o keep track of tire latest OTR news, visit
tire

web site

at

otr, or keep an

www.brairdywiirefriends.org/
eye out for reports in the Old-

Time Herald.
A closing note of thanks
the confer
ence could not have been held without the
financial support of the North Carolina

Council, the North American Folk
and Dance Alliance and the
Brandywine Friends of Old-Time Music.
The hard work of Surry Arts Council Direc
Arts

Music

tor Tanya Rees and her staff is also vital to
the continued existence of the conference.

The OTR Steering Committee expresses
their gratitude to these organizations for
their assistance, and we look forward to
working with them again as we look to

ward 2003.
John Lupton, Chairman

OTR Steering Committee

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Felts Park

A Walk Through

Memories from the '95 and '96 Galax Fiddlers Conventions

Nancy Sluys

by

I turn off Route 58 onto Main
Street in Galax, Virginia, my
heart quickens its beat as the
shabby old banner comes into

As

view announcing "The Old Fiddlers Con
vention." The traffic slows and impatiently
enter Felts Park
for over
60 years have gathered to share their tunes.
I

have to wait in line

to

hallowed ground where fiddlers
The line moves slowly but
the gate.

A

I

finally get

to

friendly Moose Lodge member

approaches with "the book" to check my
name off and attach my armband. The anxi
ety mounts as I wonder if our favorite
spaces are available. They are and we

you really want to
now it's time to

find everyone. The same folks are all here
but of course in different locations from

playing a fiddle tune by himself.
He will spend most of the next week in that

in front

walk down the first aisle near

our camp and pass "The Droolers" camp. I
quietly rearrange the individual letters of

non
land

1

The yellow canopy of the Court
house Ramblers comes into view. Great! I
know where to go later for some midnight
fun and craziness, hosted by Mark Rose
and friends.
mark.

As

see

a

I

turn the corner onto the next row,

green van

Benton Flippen

is

sitting

to

play with him.
run into a lively
A tew rows down
session fronted by Eddie Bond, playing a

I

strong fiddle and singing in a clear voice.
." rises
"Got them lonesome road blues.
from the circle, surrounded by banjos, gui
tars, and a bass. The Roan Mountain
Hilltoppers are just another row over, sur

rounded by musicians old and young.
Janice shouts to me "get your banjer!" Ev
eryone is welcome to play in the Birchfield

Photos: Benton Flippen (center), Eddie Bond
(top right), Bum's Family (Southern Pride-

camp no matter how many banjos there
are! They welcome everyone into their jam

bottom right).

to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

share their family tunes.

Sterngold

their sign on the ground into some
sense word and walk on to the next

position, greeting friends who come by

Susan

years past.

I

Susan

Sterngold

to be had if

Susan

always space

be here. Our tarp is up and

Sterngold

quickly park the camper and set up our

camp. It's amazing how swiftly the park
fills up on Sunday morning but there is

At this point I am right around the corner
from "the Big Yeller Tent." As I wander
over to the back, Susan Gleason is hosting
a radio show that will run all week in the
afternoons, inviting musicians from the

�campground to bring their friends and play.
At the moment a band called The Picknicks
is playing. They are from the Netherlands

Mountain Bobcats, Greg Hooven.

and came all the way just to attend the
world's largest and oldest fiddlers conven

in line.

Photos top

Scotland, England, and Japan.
Back at camp, I notice that Earl White,
Wendy, and Peter Fraisinet and his nephew

ramp for the past 26 years as I prepare for
my two minutes of fame.
Across this same stage have walked the
greats of old-time music. With the rock
Sterngold

notice as the tunes get hotter.
We are invited to Susan Sterngold's camp
for dinner. As we walk down the paved
track, we notice other friends have taken

to

resemble the old

a

lot of the old-time

camp,

hang out these days.

to

The back corner where Bobville used to be

Susan

Sterngold

is now taken over by Billville presided over
by Kill-Bassa-Bill and his Road Show They
had no idea that Bobville even existed when

they named Billville. Funny how traditions
change, yet stay the same.

to

a

in for

a

in for

the week. Steve from Colorado moves into

Sterngold

our camp. The dancing boards at the edge
of our tarp are starting to see some use. The

Susan

"Hog Man," dressed in his usual red outfit,
lays down some fine flatfootin' steps as the
Bobcats heat up the night with good old
"John Brown's Dream." By the end of the

swarm of bees.
and the

a crowd has gathered,
some
some
dancing. Money changes
listening,
hands as CDs and tapes leave in the pock

Hooven

little bit of

hive into

tune quite

ets of

people wishing

to

bring

a

the music home. I'm getting hungry and I
don't feel like cooking so I head over to the

midway

to

check out the food choices.

I

detour past the instrument vendors to say
"hi" to my old friend Blaine who is always
set up

couple
ments

at

the end of the row. He's got

a

of really nice Martins, but instru
are not in my budget this year. Fur

ther down, there

is a

very hot swing jam

going on involving musicians young and
old. Across the way, John Hatton points out
the latest in old-time CDs to an avid bunch of
music collectors.
I continue
towards the food but notice a
little way off a huge crowd hovering around

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

you are camped next to, it's usually good.
Friday dawns and a certain excitement
fills the air as bands start to gather to

prac

Randy Johnson will be our stand-in as he
has been for the past three years. As the day
goes on the tunes get hotter. Finally six
o'clock rolls around and the contest has

few days on their way

family reunion. Joe Thrift comes

take a little rest as the strains of
Hill"
waft over from the bluegrass
"Katy
across
the way. The level of musi
camp
had
gotten so much better over
cianship
the years that no matter what kind of music

tice for the band contest. Our usual guitar
player, Allin Cottrell, is out of town so

As the week goes on the energy builds.
More folks show up. Jim Miller and Tara

Nevins come

steady beat of Dennis' guitar, "Sally Ann"
jumps out of my banjo without a hitch.
On my way back to camp, I pass Mary
Edna's Soup Kitchen with the wooden In
dian keeping guard. The sign says the soup
will be done later so I'll have to come back
if I want some of her fine stew. Back in

stalls since that's where

seem

Susan

up residence along the back fence. We pass
the camps of Phil and Sarah, Tina and Liza,
Stephanie and her dad, Billy and Betty. The

musicians

I feel warmed
up enough to get
run into Dennis and we warm up

greets us as we climb the ramp to the stage.
My heart beats quickly as it has on this

Mack have arrived. We make room for
them in our camp. We sit down later and
have a little jam session. The cars whiz by
us from behind the fence but we don't

starting

I

with "Mississippi Sawyer" before settling
on "Sally Ann" for the contest. The line has
shortened to a comfortable length and we
enter the Yeller Tent. MC, Harold Mitchell,

Throughout the week, I also meet
musicians from Australia, New Zealand,

is

Bill Birchfield, Pilot

few tunes

tion.

back fence

to bottom:

like

a

I

realize that it's Greg
Ballard's Branch

Bogtrotters. They are whipping the bee
a
frenzy with powerful, awesome
in direct competition a few
and
sounds;
Arnie
Solomon, Greg Wilson
yards away,
and a few others are locked together in an
up-tempo, jazz oriented bluegrass jam. A
loud announcement from the stage cuts
through the din, "clawhammer banjo play
ers come into the tent!" I'd better get my

dinner and my banjo and get ready. With
Greek sandwich in hand, I head off to
connect with Dennis Hall who will back

a

away

as

likes of the Ballard's

Branch Bogtrotters,
Mountain Hilltoppers, Southern
Pride, Special K and the Moon Pies, the
New Pilot Mountaineers, the Corn Family,
the Slate Mountain Ramblers and all the
the Roan

other great ones.
Our moment has come and we play our
it sounds clean and tight. The

tune. To us

monitors are amazingly good and we can
every note. The crowd roars their
approval and it is up to the judges to decide
now. We leave the stage with excitement
hear

still lingering and head over to the annual
Burris Bar-be-que. After filling our faces

I

don't think Richard

all

week, just fiddling

the legendary

tune.

has left his chair

like all my favorite bands have waited until
later to play. We are surrounded by the

with pork and all the fixins, we are ready
for some jamming. James Burris grabs his
fiddle and starts into a blazing version of

me up on the guitar. As I return with my
banjo, Richard and Barbara Bowman call
me over for

a
good long warm-up session
we settle on "Mississippi Sawyer" for our
tune and take up our place in line. It seems

begun. After

musicians come and go. After

a

Otis Burris' "Fortune" and

(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

we all jump on the beat.

Bill and

Semones beat out stereo bass lines
Burris and

I

Terry
as Joey

trade banjo licks. Rob Burris,

lays down a steady guitar beat as Mike
Sizemore accentuates with the mandolin.
Soon the crowd is so thick I feel like we are

playing in a cave. After two hours of fren
zied playing we all need a break. Bill and I
head back to the camper intending to go to
bed.
Back in our neighborhood there is a big
wild jam hosted by the New Pilot Moun
taineers with Steve Mason on fiddle, Nick

McMillian on banjo, and Rick Davidson
and Beth Hartness on guitars. Many others
joining in but it is too dark to see their
faces. Greg Hooven passes by and tells me
to get my banjo. We sit down in our camp
and Earl and Wendy join us for some eerie
are

late night

modal tunes.

Finally,

around

3:30 AM my fingers can take no more and
of sleep.
I turn in for a few hours

While sipping coffee on Saturday we all
comment on how fast the week has gone
by. After

a
lazy morning of recuperation
we tune our instruments and shake the
cobwebs out. The Bobcats have been asked,
once again, to play for the dance contest.

is set up next to the stage as one
80
or
so dancers come out and show
one,
by
their steps for one time through a tune

The band

(with four potatoes and a double tag, of
course!). We alternate a few similar tunes
keep things interesting while maintain
ing the same tempo and feeling for each
dancer. Some come up with fancy new
to

steps but
ers that

it is

the traditional flatfoot

win here.

It

danc

takes about an hour and

half to get through the dancers and by
then we are ready for a break before the
Saturday night climax.
a

The old-time bands play second on

Sat

urday night, which gives us a chance to rest
up from the dance contest. Around 10 PM
Randy shows up and we're ready to do it
all again. This time (by request) we choose
"Sally Arm." We have not played this tune
as a band in a contest before and I'm a bit
nervous; since it is such an important stan
dard in this area it had better be played
right! The roar of the crowd at the end

proved that we had done a good job.
The awards ceremony is a little different
than it used to be. Instead of calling the
winners one by one, they call everyone
down in alphabetical order and when ev
eryone is there, they announce the placings.
It reminds me of the Miss America Pageant
as it gets down to the last final places. We
showed well this year with the band taking

�seventh place and third place clawhammer
banjo going to me. The prizes, however, are
not the most important things about this
fiddlers convention. The people, friends,
cultures, camaraderie, tunes, and history
what really count.
After the awards some people pack up
and go home. We return to our camp for
that last jam session, because if you go
home or to bed then it is over. The air is
buzzing with energy as we all get in one
last tune or two. David Bass and David
are

Long are holding court

at the

Ramblers tent. David Bass

is

Courthouse

out of control,

breathing fire and clogging while playing
lightning versions of times to see how many
he can get in before dawn. Phil Levy, Brian
Grim, Stephanie McKinnan, Jason Sypher,
and Jerry Asid wander off to the ball field

home. As we head down the mountain, the
magic and tunes are running around in my
head, and my thoughts turn to next year,
there's no place I'd rather be the second

week in August.

(land of the midnight sun) to treat the cops
and drunks to their final jam. In our camp,

Nancy Sluys

there were no guitar plavers to be found so

member

Joe, Greg, and

I

manned our fiddles while

Jacki Spector and Bill laid down the beat
with the banjo and bass. Just before dawn,

we slip into bed,
in the

a

few lingering tunes waft
as we drift off to

camper window

sleep. The next morning the convention is
over and all that is left is packing all that

muddy stuff into the truck and heading

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

a

banjo and fiddle player
Mountain Bobcats and

of the Pilot

Man Alive!. She lives

in

Pilot Mountain, NC.

�Musical

of the Heart

Affairs

Part Two: Banjo Stories

by Gail

Gillespie

second in a multi part
series of old-time musical instru
is the

This

— the first

ment autobiographies
was about guitars and this one is
about banjos. What follows here is a collec
tion of the banjo stories of folks know who
I

As with the guitar
piece, I've made no real attempt to be com
prehensive though I am fortunate to live in

play old-time music.

guitar that was in the last installment of
this article, was typical, admitting he was
at a loss to write in the same way about the
banjos he has owned. Though the banjo is
his primary instrument and he has several,
including a fine sounding new one by Kevin

Enoch, Joe was

at a

loss

to

speak of them

with the same warm fondness he had shown

toward his guitars. When he responded

to

my questionnaire about guitars and ban
jos, he added a note at the bottom, "It's
funny that I didn't even write about banjos.

guess they are more of a tool to me." Bob
Carlin, also best known as a banjo player,
I

an area with a lot of old-time music year
round. With North Carolina and neighbor

ing Virginia's many summer fiddlers con
ventions, music workshops, concerts,

dances, and house parties, it has been easy
to locate banjo players to talk to about their
instruments. Some I spoke with face to face
while others communicated with on the
phone or through Internet news groups
and list serves concerned with old-time
music and musical instruments. To give
some structure to my interviews and keep
I

things on track, used
tried to get people

a

I

questionnaire.

In it,

think back about

to

I

how they got their first banjos, their rea
sons for choosing a particular instrument,
and to talk about the relationship between
instrument choice, style, and tone. Though
I've interjected my own thoughts here and
there, the centerpieces of this article are the
statements from the banjo players them

cences,
it

was

the

their own words.
I

I

to

first began

to

collect reminis

was disappointed with how hard
find people

individual banjos

willing
in

to

remember

their lives in the

same way they were able to with guitars.
Durham banjo player Joe Newberry, who

wrote

a

touching reminiscence of his first

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gillespie

in

When

Gail

selves

Four banjos: L-R: Fairbanks, Dobson, and two Riley Baugus banjos.

�said pretty much the same thing. He has
only had a few banjos in his life, lately
playing either a Bart Reiter with an internal

resonator

or

a

Depression-era resonator

Gibson RB-1, but he really didn't have much
to say about them.

affection in the same way as a guitar. Ban
jos are just different beasts. After all, the
late Jenes Cottrell, of West Virginia made
banjo tone rings from automobile torque
talk about a real music ma
converters.

players openly refer to a banjo as a tool. Bill
Dillof described himself as a "cynical, busi
nesslike collector of rare instruments," who
rarely feels an emotional bond with any

I

I

found that when people could be ca

joled to talk about banjos at all,

it

in the

tone ring?

Is

was rarely

unobtainium

of

replacing plastic with animal hide.
thicker, heavier bridge. Stuff the
Try
machine with old socks.
These questions bring up another qual
ity of banjos that differentiates them in our
minds from guitars and fiddles. Banjos can

Bollman.
Jim
of
collection

the

from
Philip

or try

Courtesy

a

spun? What is the formula for the alloy that
the tone ring is made of? Is the head a high,

easily (sometimes too easily) bro
components and switched
from instrument to instrument using tools
you can find around the house and parts
from the local hardware store. This means
you can have combinations in almost infi

juncture of the neck and rim? What is the
gear ratio of the tuning pegs? Does it have

nite variety. Like cars, you can have "parts
banjos," old instruments from which parts
are robbed to make up complete new ones.

product designer and Boston area banjo
player, collector, and historian who once

be pretty

ken down into

medium,
low-crown, how many inches
does it project above the stretcher band?
What is the height of the strings above the
or

a

long or short scale, etc. etc. Ed Britt is

a

good many banjos are hybrids made up
of old tenor pots which have had new fivestring necks made for them. A banjo, with

designed high-end banjos for the Ome Banjo
Company in Colorado. Recently, Ed wrote

replaceable metal gewgaws holding
together various strips and shreds of wood
and animal skin is therefore as much an

that parodies the banjo players' powerful
fascination with improving the tone of a

A

all its

assemblage

as it is

a

single entity. When

some banjos can be composites of parts
from several other banjos or even made
from parts of other machines, it is hard to
think of a banjo as a single discrete item
much less a warm, fuzzy object of our

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

post to Internet list serve group Banjo-L

banjo through tinkering. The owner of
large-headed banjo had complained that

sounded too much like
Ed gave the

a

a

it

"moose fart," and

following helpful suggestions:

"Have you thought about replacing the
bridge with one made of mystically en

lightened pachysandra wood? Have you

bearing surfaces,

featuring

varying diameters,

randomly

43

a

holes

spaced

across the tonally active surface. The hole
size and spacing is empirically determined

Gura,

bright and piercing? Try loosening the head

case-

with circumferentially

double-undercut inner edge and

a

angle. Tone too warm and fuzzy? Torque
down on those brackets and tighten the
head. Install a thinner bridge. Tone too

use the pink

have added one of those new centrifugally

hardened

the tone ring cast or

special bridge, or crank on those
coordinator rods to achieve a better neck

to

cast tone rings of heavy cryogenically modified

without invoking mechanical images, cali
brations, and measurements. It would seem
that the things most people want to know
about a banjo could be expressed math
ematically or diagrammatically How many
brackets does it have? Is there a bracket
band or does it have a shoes and plate
configuration? How many holes are there

particular banjo, using each one as a "tool
to get a particular sound." Others find it
hard to resist the practical urge to modify
their musical tools, forever picking up a
screwdriver or wrench to tighten, loosen,
or replace various parts. V olume not knock
ing down bystanders? Try a new type of
head, try

under the head, but be sure

and not the yellow kind. On my own banjo

chine!

an

Banjos present
interesting paradox
because, while attachment to a particular
instrument is certainly an emotional mat
ter, you nevertheless have this thing which
is, at its heart, a machine-like assemblage of
hardware. Abanjo maybe made up of guts,
skin, and wood, but in its modern form
with its nearly infinite points of adjustment
it has taken on the soul of a machine. In fact,
some very skilled and well-known banjo

considered a set of extra heavy Tefloncoated titanium strings? You could also try
three to four inches of fiberglass insulation

through the state-of-the-art holographic
computer simulation, on a wide-band biphasic wireless up-link. Try it. It worked

wonders

on my banjo."
Just because the banjo brings out the
urge to tinker, and can be a hodgepodge of

various other banjos, machines, and house
hold appliances, is not to say that banjos
don't stir passionate views. Far from it. As
anyone who looks at a week's worth of
posts to Banjo-L knows, a heated discus
sion is sure to follow any flat declaration
that such and such

a

brand or maker of

only possible instrument for a
particular style be it clawhammer, min
strel style, or bluegrass. Typically, though,
lively discussions crop up not just about
the best brand or maker of banjo, but around
banjo

is the

selecting the right banjo accessories: heads,
tone rings, bridges, tuners, tail pieces, fine
tuners, railroad spikes. Still, as with oldtime guitar, there appear to be several very
vocal camps of banjo playing, each of which
leans to a particular sound and toward a
certain kind of banjo, banjo guru, or banjo
It was through such a line of thought

maker.
that

was, in the end, able to get people
talking about their banjos. The question
became, "What kind of banjo is it that gives
I

you thatparticular, elusive sound you want,
and how has that changed or not changed
over the years?" The following are a few of
the banjo stories people gave me.
First Banjos

Since I am a geographer by training, I
have noticed regional patterns in the types
of banjos people have had access to, espe
cially when just starting out. Because where
you live controls the kind of banjos that are
around as well as the kind you'd get if your
wishes came true, the following banjo sto
ries are organized according

ing

to

fiddlers conventions

to

place. Go
attract

that

had
people from all over the country,
been sort of aware of all this for some time,
I

(continued

on next

page)

�grew up in a poor area outside
Bloomington, Indiana where millions of
dollars could not buy a decent instrument.
"I

Good quality stringed instruments just
never made it up the creeks and out the

where the musicians lived.
banjo players there that I found were
placed Kentuckians and Hoosiers
played mail order banjos with the
ridges

to

The

dis
who
frets

By contrast, the type of banjo Reed came

across when he moved to the urban Balti
more area were of a more elevated class:
"When I first moved there in 1960 1 was

shocked by the instruments
I

had access to the

that people

workshop

in

started dragging
the family garage,
that
home anything
caught my eye. Old car
so

t became struck
by it anew when putting
this article together. Though old-time banjo

bu

players are part of a larger community of
old-time musicians linked by the conven
tions, camps, and festivals, and connected
by electronic communication, where we
live or grew up still seems to have some
bearing on the banjos we first played Thus,
even today, with ever greater ease of travel
and with daily connection with other likeminded folks through electronic mail, banjo
regions still seem to break down along
certain lines: urban versus rural, East ver
sus West and North versus South.
Because he has owned, collected and
played banjos since the early '60s and has
lived in two places with a very different
array of banjo choices, Reed Martin's story
a
good place to start. Reed, a highly
respected banjoist who has the rare ability
to play with both sensitivity and power,
grew up in Monroe County, Indiana and
then moved to the Baltimore area in the

is

early '60s. He has had a great many banjos,
plain and fancy, come through his hands
over the years, and his account shows how
where you live can make a huge difference
in what banjos you come across. Here he
talks about the kinds of banjos he found in
Indiana versus those he came across in the

Baltimore-Washington, D.C.

area:

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

because families there had money and ac
cess to instrument companies in the big
cities. Growing up in the hills of Indiana,
there was not extra money and the only
instrument company was Sears. In the Bal
timore-DC area in the 1960s, really good
guitars and banjos would turn up in the

newspapers and

yanked out."

threw out.

parts, outboard engines, old sleds, bicycles,
etc. were everywhere in Baltimore County,

I

at

yard sales.

"My first 'real' banjo was a Thompson
and O'Dell Artist model I found in T owson,

had gone into a garage
look at a 1929 boattail MG
and, there hanging on the wall was this
very nice 1890s banjo. I didn't get the MG
but I came out of that garage with this
banjo. While I was getting the Thompson

Maryland
there

to

in 1963.

take

a

1

�and O'Dell in playable shape,

I

drove back

visit my older sister. A
Bloomington
friend of hers there played a little knock
down style banjo and he had a little barnto

lady found lying
North Caro
road
in
Hill,
Chapel
gravel

red painted fretless that
in

a

a

actually learned my first
little red fretless before
licks
on
that
banjo
I
out
how
to
install a calfskin head
figured
lina in 1931.

I

on the

Thompson-O'Dell. Later, played
[the Thompson-O'Dell] in lots of contests
I

was my regular banjo from 19651969. Around that time, I stumbled upon
my next working instrument, a J.B. Schall.
I was
working in the Kensington, Mary
land Post Office when a large box burst
open and spilled out the parts to four or
and

it

five old banjos. I hand delivered the stuff to
the address and, in the end, bought every
thing in the process. The banjos had once

been the property of 'Banjo Bill' Bowers, a
deceased classical player. I got a banjo to
gether from the parts and played it until I
put together the Vega I play now."
Though I was born and raised in the
Deep South, my own banjo experience is
similar to Reed's in rural southern Indiana.
In the

Cush Holston for

a

University

of Florida

folklore class), played in a unique finger
style on some sort of budget resonator
banjo.
If

you lived in the Deep South and had

a

little more money, then what you did was
trot down to the local music store and head

straight for the rack of Gibsons, not taboo
in the 1960s or even the 1970s for old-time
music. We had all seen album cover photos
Boggs, Wade Ward, and Clarence
Ashley holding Gibsons, so there was cer
tainly no stigma attached to using a resona
tor banjo. Eric Muller, Gainesville author
of a mid -'70s Mel Bay book on frailing, and
banjo player with the 34th Street
Laundromat Band, got an enviably strong,
clear sound on his Gibson Mastertone.
of Dock

When he took up the banjo in the early
1970s, Dwight Rogers, who had taken les
sons from Eric, went to the local music
store and bought for his first banjo a Japa
nese copy of Eric's Gibson Mastertone, an
Aria, or Alvarez. He learned to play
clawhammer on that banjo and its brash

loudness taught him not
In this

to fear

the South at that time, what we had were
the simple old open backs, Gibsons, and

wanna-be Gibsons. What we rarely
were the fine open-back Boston banjos
the turn of the century of the sort that
was able to find in the Baltimore-DC

saw
from

Reed
area:

the Fairbanks, Cole, and Vega

masterpieces
ideal old-time banjos
among banjo players elsewhere.
Brett Riggs (Maryville, Tennessee, re
cently moved to Carrboro, NC-banjo and
banjo uke with the New Dixie Entertain
that

became

the

ers) also grew up in the South. He still plays
one of the simple old attic-type banjos he
first got, never "graduating" to one of the
a new hand made
old-time banjo:
"Although I like the big, fat, bass-y banjo
sound that's now popular with players
working the new, custom-made banjos, I
still prefer the edge that comes from some

Boston aristocrats or to

those old turn-of-the-century instru
ments with light, spun-over rims. My fa
vorite banjos are Dobsons, although they're
of

a

mixed lot.

I

play on an old lightweight

mistakes.

small college town, as elsewhere in

(continued

on next page)

Florida Panhandle and in north cen

tral Florida in the '60s, banjos came in two

general types: Gibsons or non-Gibsons. The
non-Gibsons, which we sometimes called
"attic banjos," often had no identifiable
label whatsoever, unless they were from
the mail-order companies and had logos
such as Kay, Harmony, or Silvertone. The
older no-name banjos had lightweight,
metal-clad rims and walnut necks that

sometimes had

a

along the juncture

strange V-shaped

slot

of the neck and

pot.

Now I know they were probably budget
models from the turn of the century made
by companies like Buckbee, Dobson, and
Stewart, but at the time we just thought of
them as attic or garage banjos. One of my
earliest banjos, which I still have, is one of
this humble breed. A ratty no-namer with
thin veneer of
unreliable
frets,
fingerboard,
ebony for
and a greasy calfskin head, it literally came
from a friend's grandmother's attic some
where in Louisiana. When I arrived at the
University of Florida in Gainesville in the
mid-1960s some of my friends had other
similar simple banjos for old-time music
that were typical of what we could get hold
of at that place and time. Lawrence Hetrick,
who now lives and teaches in Atlanta, was
lucky to find a plainbut elegant S.S. Stewart
Orchestra model and the late Marty
Schuman (who recorded Florida fiddler

friction violin style pegs,

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Debbie

Spiegelman

a

Allen Hart (L) with Whyte Laydie#7 from 1901, Kerry Blech (R).

�Dobson that I found in derelict condition in
a music store and then reconditioned as a
fretless. It is set up with very high action
(5/8" over the fingerboard
is

of

at

the rim) and

In its

early days
very lively and punchy.
reincarnation, it was blessed by Saint

few times and each time I was there I grew
more attracted to an old Dobson hanging
on the wall. Next to it was inscribed a nick
name, The Great Echo. Since it was in my
price range, I found myself writing a check
and walking out of the store with my first

Thomas of Toast (AKA Tommy Jarrell)
who performed with it at the 1982 World's
Fair in Knoxville. Its geared tuners were a

banjo.

special Christmas present from Andy

to old records and trying to
tunes
and I'd often play it to
figure out
unwind before going to bed. Even though
it was no Whyte Laydie, I grew fond of the

Cahan, who was frustrated over my inces

sant tweaking of its old Champion pegs.
I've looked for years for its match in a
fretted banjo, but I guess that's asking too
much."
The other banjo Brett loves to play

Dobson

"[That]

learned
while listening
to

play on.

was the banjo that
I

remember holding

I

it

a

few times and off to

Cool! After two or three shots of this

ex

physics and geometry, to my
periment
one
of the BBs went through the
horror,
skin head between the first and second
in

string and left a hole about the size of a
dime. Vivid to this day is what my dad said
as he examined the damage. When I told
him that my finger had made the hole
while playing it, he said 'Well, go ahead
and keep playing.'

So,

I

have been, ever

since."

Great Echo."

Allen Hart (Seattle, Washington-banjo

illus

around the strings

the wall, glass door and finally to rest end
ing up on the coffee table in front of me.

Home-Made Banjos of the South

trates another type common in the South
and in backwater, poor areas: the low-end

resonator model. Here Brett talks about his

pleasure,

guilty

Depression

a

era

Kalamazoo:
think that few banjo players are ever
happy with the way their own instrument's
sound banjos, though subtle as spike ham
"I

mers, are incredibly moody, and their own
ers more so. I see lots of banjo jockeying,
folks looking for the elusive sound that's

just right. I've got an old Kalamazoo with a
flat-backed resonator that bought here in
1

from a co-worker of Mike
were just hanging out, play
We
Bryant's.
when
this guy walks up with the
tunes,
ing
if anyone wanted to buy it.
and
asked
banjo
It had belonged to his father but he said

Bradley

Tennessee

Paula

that the family was keeping the Martin Dremember their dad by. The price was
right, so I snatched it up before it fell into
the

wrong hands.

It

turned

out to be

a

for the banjo that Benton

Flippen
ringer
plays. Paul Brown got interested in it and
we made a deal. Later, when I was un
happy with my current fretted banjo (an
other Dobson), Paul sold it back to me. So,
just like a dollar goes from hand to hand, a
banjo goes from man to man. I really like
the Kalamazoo because
is

cool.

It is

it is so

very loud, with

a

ugly that

it

really round
love to pull it

sound that is very old-time. I
out in a conclave of old Tubaphones and
Silver Bells."

Sarah Peterson, who plays with several

bands in the Greensboro, North
Carolina area, lived out in California while
she was learning to play the banjo. She now
string

banjo hand-made by Mike Ramsey,
but like Brett she was originally caught up

plays

a

Dobson banjo-one that had
its way out west:
"While I was living in California, I'd
been to Marc Silber's shop in Berkeley a
in the

spell of

a

somehow found

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

28 to

Woody Simmons and Paula Bradley. Banjo

by Kyle Creed.

with Hart and Blech) grew up out west in
California and had the good fortune to be
a musical family. The first banjo
with which he became intimately ac
quainted belonged to his father a decent

born into

quality
similar

turn-of-the-century instrument,
Dobsons described by Brett

to the

and Sarah:
"The year was 1957 and there was al
ways old-time music around the house for
my dad played the banjo and the guitar.
One day that summer I was left alone for a

Before

I

move

to

people who started

playing the banjo in other parts of the coun
try and to a few who learned to play with
high quality banjos from the famous Bos
ton makers, I need to talk a little about

home-made

or

custom-made banjos. Ban

ancestry, and before com
mercial companies came along in the 19th
century, were originally home made out of
local woods and animal hides. In the South

jos are of African

especially, there were still folks making

them this way in the '60s and '70s when a
lot of us were out looking for banjos. Some
were plain and rustic, such as the folksy

while and finished playing outside with
my BB rifle and had come in to sit down on
looked
the couch to rest. As I sat there
across the room at the Washburn banjo my
dad had at the time and thought how neat
it would be to bounce a BB off the head of

western North Carolina, while others
sported modern amenities like plastic

proceeded to explore. The first shot hit
middle of the skin head, bounced

heads, metal rims and brackets, such as
those made by Kyle Creed who lived

1

it.

I

the

walnut and groundhog hide instruments
made by Frank Profitt and others in north

�outside Galax, Virginia. The Creed banjos,
associated

as

they were with

of

player
became highly
sought after by young clawhammer banjo
players in the '70s and deserve a few sto
ries. His banjos also inspired a crop of
younger banjo makers who began manu
facturing them in the late '70s and '80s.
Using Creed's pot specifications, some
makers like David Forbes, Mike Ramsey,
and Kevin Enoch even combined the best
of both worlds
melding a Southern
its simple tone ring
with
clawhammer pot
head
the
fine fit, finish, and
and large
with
a

great skill and influence,

the gorgeous northern-made

fancy inlay of
banjos of the turn of the century.

Rafe Stefanini, who began to play the
banjo in the 1970s in Italy, had first bought
an Arthur Smith banjo in

a

Brooklyn pawn

and still are my banjo heroes and I wanted
that big bass-y sound that I heard from

"

Blanton Owen, who played a Creed banjo.
Paula Bradley (Lee, Massachusetts
gui
tar and banjo uke with the Rhythm Rats),
lived in Cincinnati, Ohio, but spent a lot of
time

at

southern fiddlers conventions while

she was learning to play old-time music.
She also lucked into a Kyle Creed banjo:
"
I don't remember the exact
year I got it,
but banjo was the first instrument on which
I
played old-time music, and like many

folks, I was particularly drawn to Round
Peak music and the wonderfully percus
sive sound of that banjo style. I was fortu
nate while learning to have a couple of
people lend me banjos, but the time had

come to get my own. Whitt Mead, one of
my early banjo influences and teachers,
had a [fretless] Kyle Creed banjo that I
loved, [and] I wanted one too. I was able to
purchase one locally in Cincinnati from
someone who had one and didn't particu

while, I realized that I wasn't thrilled
with the sound. Then [around] 1985, while
at the West Virginia Folk Festival in
after

a

Gail

Gillespie

Glenville,

Marianne Kovatch w/ fretless banjo made

by

Riley Baugus.

I

heard that Woody Simmons,

the West Virginia fiddler, had a Kyle Creed
banjo for sale. The following fall, during a

visit with my mother, who was living in
West Virginia, I called Woody to see if he

He did! My mom and I went to
played that banjo (fretted, with a

still had

it.

see him,

I

12-inch pot and a tone ring), loved it and it
became mine. The funny thing was that
Whitt had been trying to teach me to play
tunes that he played on the fiddle so we
could play together. One that he liked was

Gail

Gillespie

"Fisher's Hornpipe," but

Tolly Tollefson w/Dobson, neck made by Brett
Riggs.

shop, but after a trip
ginia, ended up with

to

southwestern Vir

Kyle Creed banjo:
"I swapped the Smith banjo for a 12inch-pot Kyle Creed, from which I'll never
part. It's particularly dear to me because, of
course, Kyle Creed made it. I think it really
a

did shape my sound. It's exactly what I was
looking for at the time, when I was listen

ing almost exclusively

to

Fred

Kyle,
Cockerham, and Tommy Jarrell. They were

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

it

was not one of

my favorites on the fretless banjo, and I had
tried to avoid playing it at all costs. After
Woody and I finished our banjo business,
we sat down to play some music. He
tuned my new
reached for his fiddle,
"How about
and
he
said
banjo expectantly,
I

that Fisher's Hornpipe?
"This Kyle Creed banjo has definitely
influenced the way I play. It is set up with

high action,

and is best played

over the

over the pot. In
fact, I can't play any other style on it but
it just doesn't feel or sound
Round Peak

fretboard

as

opposed

plays a fine fretless banjo of this deeprimmed type with an ebony fingerboard
and tobacco leaf inlay. Tolly Tollefson, fid
dler, bass, and guitar player with Old Blue
and the New Southern Broadcasters has

to

right."
There's another style of banjo made by
Kyle Creed that has also been influential on
contemporary banjo players and makers.

Cockerham, Kyle made
fretless banjo using a very archaic, slotted

a

similar fretted banjo also made by Riley
Baugus. Both of these banjos have the de
it's a big fat
sirable deep, booming sound
lush sound with a percussive, quick decay

to
that lends itself magnificently
clawhammer playing both for solo or group
settings.

Folk-Era Banjos

Regardless of where we were living

had an 11-

larly like it. As it turned out,
inch pot and absolutely no tone ring and
it

peghead style, one of his trademark Formica
fingerboards but most importantly, an un
usually deep pot with no tone ring. This is
the banjo Fred played on the Jenkins, Jarrell
and Cockerham County Record series in
the late '60s that was so inspirational to so
many of us. In recent years, North Carolina
banjo player Riley Baugus has been mak
ing banjos based upon this model. Marianne
Kovatch, of Greensboro, North Carolina

at

the time the banjo bug struck, quite
us began playing on banjos that had their
a

lot of

origin during the folk music revival of the
late '50s and '60s. Pete Seeger's long-necked
Vega banjo was the inspiration for banjo
players of popular groups such as the
Kingston Trio, Brothers Four, and
Limeliters. Soon, other musical instrument
companies like Gibson as well as those
producing budget brands such as Kay,

Silvertone, and Framus began to make ban
with elongated necks. Ode, an innova
tive new company out in Colorado, also
made wonderful sounding long-necked
banjos with aluminum rims. Bill Dillof (Lee,

jos

Massachusetts-banjo, fiddle, guitar with
the Canebrake Rattlers and Dave Rice)

de

scribed his first banjo, which seems to have
been one of these holdovers from the '60s
folk music revival:
"Mine was a Gibson RB-0 long neck,
which I received as a gift in 1971 It was my
only banjo for about six years and I played
everything on it that I was later to play on
more traditional banjos. I only set it aside

when

joined

I

the

still have

it

Canebrake
and

it

Rattlers.

has great sound,

Though
it just didn't have that vintage look to match
our music. Kevin Enoch is currently build
ing me a replacement neck for it based on a
custom RB-0 playedby Uncle Dave Macon."
Bob Carlin (Lexington, North Carolina)
also started with one of these extended
I

neck folk era banjos. Bob grew up in the

For his friend Fred
a

(continued on next page)

�New York City area and started playing
the banjo in the '70s. Bob wrote that he only
a few banjos but the one he learned

owned

a Framus long-neck.
Resonator Banjos
Kenny Jackson (Fayetteville, North Caro
lina-fiddle, banjo, guitar with the Rhythm
Rats and Big Medicine) began his old-time
music career in Bloomington, Indiana a
decade or so after Reed Martin. By that

on was

time banjos
to get.

price ranges were easier

in all

Kenny began his relationship with

a flirtation with bluegrass in
decade was considered the
"dark years" of Gibson and many compa
nies began to copy their banjos, some with
more success than others. This era also
produced an abundance of foreign made

the banjo with
the '70s. This

Gibson knock off banjos that were afford
able for people just starting to play the
banjo. Kenny wrote:
"The first banjo

I

ever owned was

a

had tuned my ukelele up like a banjo, and
except for a New Lost City Ramblers con

banjos more recently. Kirk Sutphin, of
Walkertown, North Carolina, who is

had never seen anyone play a banjo
in person. My first banjo was a Gibson RB-

equally

cert,

I

resonator. I knew wanted a
Gibson because that was what Earl Scruggs
played and the RB-100 was their cheapest
model. My brother took me to Roger
Sprung's apartment in New York, where
Roger had the various Gibson models sit
ting around on stuffed chairs. The reason
wound up going to the store was because I
felt that Roger charged too much for the
case! He wanted $195 for the banjo and case
100 that had

a

I

I

I was able to
get everything for about
dollars less at the music store. That was

and
30

certainly a lot of money for a teenager in
1963
practically my entire earnings from
a summer job."
Resonator banjos were not just the choice
of people who wanted to play bluegrass
like Earl Scruggs. Many Southern old-time
banjo players have preferred them, both
for playing in string bands or for solo work.
Gilmer Woodruff (who used to play with
Benton Flippen and Smokey Valley Boys
and with Ernest East and the Pine Ridge
Boys) and Will Keys, of Gray, Tennessee,
legendary solo finger-style old-time picker,
like the sound of
Woodruff played

banjo with

a

a

resonator.

plain, low-end Style 1
and
Will
has
Gibson
always played a Para
a

Gail

Gillespie

mount. The Paramount is not a common
choice, because they were almost exclu
sively made as four-string banjos Will's
Paramounts were made in the 1920s, when

neck in the proper position rather than
make a new neck for it. In the early '90s, he
made a neck from scratch for a second

Kirk Sutphin with the Frank Jenkins 1928
Gibson RB-1 at the Allegheny fiddlers

Convention, 2000.

Japanese-made Vega resonator model that
bought from David Molk in Bloomington,
Indiana in 1976. think chose it because 1.
1

I

1

it

was cheap;

it

2.

plectrum and tenor banjos outnumbered
five-string banjos by about ten to one. On
the banjo for which he is best known, Will
simply installed a fifth string peg along the

sounded and played

it for
3. I wanted
reasonably
Scruggs style playing."
Another banjo player who was origi
nally taken by the lure of bluegrass and
banjos with resonators was California oldtime banjo player Steve Goldfield. Steve
grew up near New York City:

well, and

Paramount but then removed it when he
found an original plectrum neck, to which
he added a fifth string as he had done with
his first Paramount. He's gotten used to the
thin neck and it just didn't seem right to
have all that space below the fifth string
peg. Will has really bonded with these
way that no one else has Though
banjos
make
loud jazz and Dixieland banjos
they
is

a

and are highly prized as such, Paramounts

don't project well as clawhammer banjos.
Will, however, playing in a unique two-

New

finger style, makes his sing with a rich bell
like tone that recalls the celluloid label
inside his banjo's pot: "Paramount: Piano

port Folk Festival LP (incidentally, the first
LP I ever bought). I was 16 years old and

Volume Harp Quality Tone."
Others have gravitated to resonator

bought my first banjo in 1963 from my
local music store. was determined to get a
"I

I

banjo after

I

heard Earl Scruggs on

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

adept at clawhammer and
fingerpicking styles, came by his current
main banjo in an interesting way. Kirk has
long favored the music and repertoire of

his family and home region, the CarolinaVirginia western Piedmont sound, and two

favorite bands are local groups that
recorded in the late '20s and '30s: DaCosta
Woltz's Southern Broadcasters and Frank
Jenkins Pilot Mountaineers. In the first
of his

band, Frank Jenkins of Dobson, NC played
banjo; in the second, his son Oscar Jenkins
was the banjoist. Kirk collects a lot of thingsantique cars, banjos, guitars, recordings,
and photographs. In one photograph of
Oscar Jenkins that he saw, Kirk noticed
that instead of the usual 1950s RB-250,
Oscar was holding an older banjo, one that

belonged to his father Frank. For some
reason, this banjo, a late '20s resonator
Gibson RB-1, had been sent back to the
company in Kalamazoo for repairs and in
the process Gibson had replaced its origi
nal curlicue silk-screened "The Gibson"
with the more modern 1950s style squaredoff "Gibson" logo. It looked a little strange
and out of place on the old-style fiddleshaped peghead of the RB-1 and Kirknever
had

forgot it. A few years ago, Kirk heard that
H.O. Jenkins of Dobson, NC, who is Oscar's
son, was selling two banjos, one of which
turned out to be a 1950s style "flyswatter"
peghead RB-250-the nice Mastertone banjo

that Oscar Jenkins is shown with on the
covers and liner notes of the series of re
cordings with Fred Cockerham and T ommy
Jarrell. Opening up the other beat-up case
Kirk found a simple old, non-Mastertone
RB-1. He was overjoyed when he saw that
its "The Gibson" logo had been removed
and replaced with the rectilinear style

"Gibson" popular in the 1950s. This, then,
was one of the banjos Frank Jenkins had

played with the Southern Broadcasters and
the very banjo that Oscar Jenkins had played
with Jenkins Pilot Mountaineers. Of course,
Kirk bought that banjo on the spot and has

been playing

it for

a

few years now. It's

easy
goosebumps as Kirk brings it
back to life on the old Jenkins tunes like
"Baptist Shout" and "Home Sweet Home"
to get

and he's become so bonded

uses

it

for

to it that he

everything from parties to dances

and fiddlers

conventions.

Cole, Fairbanks, and Vega: Tubaphones
and Whyte Ladies
Folks that lived in the urban East as well
as the

West Coast sometimes had the good

�fancy wood marquetry, mother of pearl
and ivory, were the physical embodiment
of
its

movement to elevate the banjo beyond
humble roots in the rural South. Some

a

time in the 1960s or '70s, these beautifully
crafted instruments, made with elaborate,
ever improving and patented tone rings,

came to be the Holy Grail of old-time ban
jos. Though people like Reed Martin were
few years earlier, Art
Rosenbaum's 1968 book on old-time banjo
playing, Old-Time Mountain Banjo was in
fluential. In the second appendix, "What

buying such banjos

a

Kind of Banjo Should You Have?,"
Rosenbaum recommended buying a good
old instrument rather a new one. While $50
could purchase a modern mass-produced
banjo, he wrote, $200 could net a "really
superb old Stewart," and still a little more
an early Fairbanks, Cole, or Paramount.
Though he discouraged buying a banjo for
its appearance alone, he felt that such ban
jos that have superb sound and "are both
beautiful works in both detail and overall
a joy to own and play. Though
decoration could be carried too
far he maintained that it is "decidedly in
spiring to own and play a handsome in
strument."

lines" were
he felt that

One banjo player so inspired was Hank
Schwartz, a fine clawhammer banjo player
now living in California. Hank first heard
banjo playing in New York City as a teen
ager in the late '50s. There he met Woody

Wachtel, a mellow character, who played
an ancient fretless five-string in a style he'd
learned from Rufus Crisp of Allen, Ken
tucky. After hearing Woody play, Hank
left for college in Baltimore desperately
wanting his own banjo. Hank describes

how he got that first instrument:
"Woody gave me the names of some
good Baltimore friends of his and I soon
was a regular at the old-time music gather
ings in the little carriage house of Myron
Edelman and Lisa Chiera. [At that time] I
found a banjo that had belonged to the
owner of a shoe store who'd played classi
cal music on it. It was a pristine Fairbanks
#2, still strung with gut when I purchased
it from the shoe store owner's estate for
$75. They had been asking $90 but I was a
relatively poor student and they graciously
took pity on me. When I asked Mike Seeger,
who was at that time a regular at Baltimore
music gatherings, whether that was a good

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

instrument, he said he figured that

it

would

sometime in the '60s.

had

resonator,
came from
bluegrass style, and
Sears-Roebuck and it appeared to be of
Asian manufacture. My mother must have

do fine."

I

Allen Hart wound up with another Boston-made beauty of the gilded age, a Why te
Laydie, one of the most sought-after banjos
among old-time banjo players all over the
country.
"I have played many banjos over the
years, but for the power, tone and quick
response, my all time favorite banjo is my

It

think

a

it

thought that he was inspired enough by
hearing the theme for the Beverly Hillbil
lies TV show to want to learn bluegrass
banjo. Of course, he never touched it.
dragged it out of the basement when

I

I

started to play in the mid-'70s, yanked the

plywood resonator off the back, stuffed a
sock in there, made a case out of 3/8 inch

Whyte Laydie #7. Even after three banjo
cases, two skin heads and a relationship of
25 years with this banjo I still love it."
Banjo player Chris Battis, who lives in

plywood that looked like
small animal and

I

for a
a coffin
took
was in business.
I

northern California and who spent many
years in Colorado, found a refined Yankee
banjo in a western city:
"I've always been

a

serial monogamist

instruments are concerned and
have rarely owned more than one banjo at
as far as

time. For the longest time, however, my
main banjo was a gorgeous 1923 Vega #3
Tubaphone that I found in Denver in un
a

used condition for about $300. Later, in
1973, 1 sold it for $500 when I was living in

Nashville and needed the money

so that

I

could move back to Colorado. Guess it
seemed like a good idea at the time."
Not everyone who lived in the urban
Northeast immediately came across supe
rior quality banjos at bargain prices. Ken
Perlman, the well-known and highly skilled

melodic banjo picker began Iris musical career
with a funky imported instrument before find
ing his way to

a

Gillespie

to

hybrid of higher quality:

managed to do pretty well with a
Japanese cheapie, though I do remember
began to go
feeling embarrassed when
around to sessions because it seemed as
"I

I

though everyone else had Whyte Laydies,
Tubaphones, Orpheums and such while I
had this nasty no-name thing. But, I held to
it for several years until the tension hoop
actually stretched out so that putting ten
sion on it actually caused plastic heads to
break immediately. My next move was to
get a pseudo Whyte Laydie conversion. It
was actually a Little Wonder pot with a
modern Whyte Laydie style tone ring from
Mike Allison in Providence, Rhode Island.
I
played it for a number of years and it was
actually the banjo I played on the Melodic
Clawhammer recording that Bob Carlin pro
duced."
Anothernortheasterner, Rusty Neithammer,
who lives in the Philadelphia area, also began
with a low-end instrument before gravitat
banjo of more aristocratic lineage:
"My first banjo was actually a birthday
present from my mother to my father,

ing to

a

Gail

find quite elegant "Boston" ban
the Cole, Fairbanks and Vega
made
by
jos
companies in the 19th and early 20th centu
ries. These gilded lilies, decorated with

fortune

Pat Gill: 1910-23 Fairbanks Vega.

that thing

everywhere

for

few years, and

a

wore deep ruts in the fingerboard behind
the first and second frets.
"After a few years, I decided that 'real'
banjos had pegs that went straight back,
not out of the side of the peghead as they
did on the Sears banjo. After college and

having saved up some money, I ran into
my next banjo at a music shop in Zionsville,

Pennsylvania. It was made by Paul King
and was supposed to be a (loose) copy of a
nice sweet sound,
properly shaped peghead and nice Planet
pegs that went straight back. After a few

Fairbanks Electric.

It

has

a

a

years with this banjo, I decided that my
fingers were too fat for the narrow neck

needed
and fingerboard and that
a wide neck and board."
with
thing
I

some

About seven

or eight years ago, Rusty's
to him by way of Greg
came
next banjo

(continued

on next

page)

�and upward evolutionary course towards
the acquisition of more finely made and

Hooven. Though Greg grew up in Galax,
Virginia, for years people like Roger Sprung
had been trucking in fancy banjos from the
New York area to sell at his booth at the
Galax Fiddlers Convention. Perhaps

more expensive instruments,

Rusty's next banjo was one of these. Rusty
describes it:

lush ringing tone but have developed a
taste for what Karen Linn has called that
"half barbaric twang." The right banjos to
get a staccato plunk are often spartan look
low end and budget
ing contraptions
commercial instruments as well as catch as

"My nextbanjo was a 1914 or so Fairbanks
No. 2 Special, mostly all original parts, and
the neck is nice and wide, and of course the

pegs go straight back. The fifth string is
also not a Planet. It is the banjo I play today
and I'm really happy with it, although at
I

feel the third and fourth strings can

weak sounding. My only tone
adjustment devices to modify the banjo's
sound are a custom bridge made by Jim
deCava and a dirty paper towel stuffed in
the edge of the neck where it joins the rim,
as I was wearing away the wood so that the
a

bit

ends of the frets stuck out and were beating
up my thumb."

some of us a particular banjo has
made an indelible mark on our playing,
shaping the kind of tone we want to hear.
Though today she mostly plays a beautiful
looking and sounding new banjo made by
For

Kevin

Enoch,

Molly Tenenbaum,

attle, Washington had the
about her old Tubaphone:
"My

T ubaphone

has

a

1

following

of

Se

to say

927 'V egaphone'

reproduction neck made in the
I think,
1970s,
by Doug Unger. The
early
flower pot inlay on the peghead is the
loveliest I have ever seen The large round
piece of shell has a pinkish-gold glow to it.
There's a star inlaid in the heel that only I
ever see. I love having such a pretty secret.
pot with

It

a

"My Tubaphone taught me how to play.
I ever
had that cared

was the first banjo

how I hit its strings. It didn't respond easily
at all. I had to push hard, at particular
angles. I had to find ways to make the
strings pop out from under my fingers. I've
always felt that this banjo wasn't loud
enough. I've envied all the loud banjo play
the ones that splink and
ers I've heard
splank like popcorn over the top of every
thing even in large sessions. I've tried ev
heads,
erything to make my banjo louder
strings, bridges, tail pieces. But I'm not a
banjo set-up expert and I gave up. I do
know that the strings have to be just so: 11,
23, 16, 20, 13. It's still not very loud but, boy,
do I have control over the tone. I realize

that the tone cuts through the other instru
in a subtle way. It's deep and rich

ments

and no other instrument has
that competes

with

isn't as necessary as

it.
I

So

a

tonal quality

maybe volume

once thought

it

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was.

Gillespie

be

Gail

times

devolution-

lookout for simpler
ary banjoists
and more primitive banjos. Such people
are no longer completely enamored of a
are on the

Will Keys, 1992, at the Mt. Airy Fiddlers

Convention. 1920s Paramount with neck made

from the pot of a Depression-era
budget brand instrument. Like Brett Riggs,
Chris admires both its straightforward
made

looks and sound:

by Will.

"My present banjo and my all-time

No other banjo has evoked such strong
feeling for me. It was the Tubaphone that
made me a banjo player."
Reed Martin has played

a

number of

banjos over the years but always returns to
a Vega Tubaphone, on which he has kept
also

the resonator. This banjo story
reminder of how banjo necks and pots can
be separated and reunited.
is

a

"In 1971 a local older musician, Joe Winn,
gave me his old #9 Vega Tubaphone 5string. I had bought a "Vegaphone Artist"
tenor that was gold but with no engraving
back in 1964 for $25. When I tried to give J oe

Winn the tenor in trade, he said, "I don't
like the yellow color," so we traded necks.
I
got the 1923 original neck and I stuck it
into my 1923 original gold shell. I was

playing a lot of dances, so the resonator
stayed on to increase the volume and I got
used to having it on. Mostly these days I
play the Vega Tubaphone when I want to
play with power and clear notes. That's my
preference. I love to hear Dan Gellert play
the fretless banjo and I love to hear Ken
Perlman play intricate chromatic tunes, but
I knew
Pete Steele and Dorothy Rorrick

somehow

think of my style as an
blending both strength and
attempt
speed. This Vega #9 and I have reached a
mutual respect. It speaks best for me."
and

catch can home made banjos made out of
various handy objects like ham cans and
cigar boxes. Chris Battis describes his cur
rent favorite banjo, a Kalamazoo hybrid

I

at

Downward Mobility
As Bobby Smakula noted in his article
"Are We Not Banjo Players?" that appeared
in the last OTH, some banjo players have
taken another path in the search for tone

you might call

it a

downward path. Like

the music of Devo, their route has been devolutionary. Instead of taking the onward

vorite

is a

Gibson/Kalamazoo,

fa

their bot-

tom-of-the line instrument that they made
between 1935 and 1941 I'm not sure why I
bought it sight unseen on the Internet since
I
had a very nice Tubaphone. This
very homely child com
hose
New York or Boston
pared to one of
I
'uptown' jobs, but love it more than any

Kalamazoo

is

a

have ever owned. I used to
spend hours setting up my fancier banjos

instrument
to

get an

I

approximation

of the

old-time

was looking for, but the "Kazoo
sounded like an old record the very first
time I heard it. I now have it set up with

sound

I

medium strings, and
without its original resonator. To imagine
the sound, think Clarence Ashley. There's
that same 'pop' to its sound. It takes a bit
fairly high action,

more work to play than a Tubaphone, but
for the tone I do get, I could never go back
to one of those 'nice sounding' banjos. In all
fairness, my style used to be more orna

mented and playing the Kalamazoo has
broughtme back toamore unadorned sound."
In the end, whether they like a finely
crafted classy banjo, a plain and humble
instrument; an old mail-order banjo, or one
made by

with

a

a contemporary craftsman; a banjo
resonator or a banjo with a ground

hog hide head-many people emphasized
the feeling that it really isn't the banjo itself
that is responsible for the tone but some

thing within the player. While he was work
ing at the Smithsonian Institution Reed
Martin had an experience that illustrated
this truth. Somehow or other he had
stumbled into a storage area and come
across

a

battered banjo case with

a

dusty

(continued on page 52)

�Tone. Wayne Rogers has found a great
market niche in importing banjo parts and
assembling them here in the U.S. This year's

Workshop

editions of interest

to

old-time players

in

the full line of Gold Tone banjos includes
the Hoab model, named after Cyrus Hoab,

The NAMM Show 2001

old-time banjo player I somehow missed
lifetime love affair with the music.
Thisbanjo has a 13" tunable Remo drum for
an

in my

the rim assembly and a scale that positions
the bridge in the middle of the head. It is a

by Bob Smakula

good sounding banjo and an amazing low
list price of less than $600.

a

year the National

Association

of Music
Twice

Merchants (NAMM) hosts
an international music trade show. It is
possible for me to sneak out of snowy West
Virginia at the end of January now and
then to fly to Los Angeles for the winter
NAMM show. I will probably never attend
the summer show in Nashville, TN. The
summer is too busy with great old-time
music events.
Did arriving during the middle of a cold
wave and rolling blackouts dampen my
excitement ferreting out the small percent
age of cool string instruments and accesso
ries that are of interest to old-time musi
I was
cians? Nah.
planning to be inside
the whole day anyway.
The Anaheim Convention Center is huge.
Although I walked around for two and a
half days, I'm sure I missed a few things.
What follows are

a

few of my interesting

discoveries.
The last NAMM show

I

attended intro

duced me to the coated Elixir guitar strings
manufactured by Gore. Through research
and

development,

they have invented

a

newer Elixir string. The NanoWeb strings
are similar to the original, but have a thin
ner coating of plastic. This thinner coating
gives you a feel closer to a traditional string
and still offers the same grime protection. J.
D'Addario and Company, not wanting to
be left in the dust of coated string technol
ogy, came up with their own version of the
The EXP strings differ in that the
wire with which the string is wound is

Elixir.

plastic coated before winding on the core
wire. D'Addario claims this helps the string
last even longer then strings that are as
sembled, then coated. D'Addario also in

troduced

a

CD ROM that shows how that

company manufacturers their product. For
us gearheads it is a great way to see the
factory without traveling through rush hour
traffic to Farmingdale, NY. Y ou can contact
D'Addario or borrow one from your local

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

music dealer

you would like

if

peek.
year's cornucopia of acoustic gui
tar pickups, I did find one that was differ
a

In this

ent. Most manufacturers

of this genre of
use
a
to
reproduce the
pickup
piezo crystal
sound of your acoustic guitar. And truth be
known, I hate them. They sound crunchy
and thin. It annoys me that there are so

many great guitars that the minute you
plug them in they all sound like the cheap
est guitar you can buy.
The ray of sunshine in the annoying tone
of piezos is the Schertler Blue Stick. This

Swiss pickup maker has a bit of a different
way of doing things, and has come up with
an under the saddle pickup I can tolerate.
And yes, that is a high complement! Though
not completely transparent, it is a good
step in the right direction. The Blue Stick
unit includes a preamp and a volume con
trol that is all but invisible. When you
consider that other under-saddle pickups
do not include those controls, and that
installation is one of pickupland's most
the $225 for the pickup is quite

My tavorite novelty ot the Gold lone
booth was the "convertible." You could
change the banjo from a fretted to a fretless
fingerboard in a few minutes. Most players
I know don't mind
having more than one
and
actually prefer different rim/
banjo
tone ring configurations for fretted and
fretless. But you have to admire Wayne

Rogers' inventiveness.
The other banjo stop was Deering.
Deering is the current owner of the Vega
name and I always like to take a peek at
what's going on there. I was disappointed
to find their Vega banjos kind of boring. I

certainly don't want to slam a company I
admire so much, but their line that has been
associated with great banjos since 1904 con
sists really of well made utility instruments
resembling Vega's banjos from the 1960s. I
have always wondered why Deering
doesn't manufacture instruments that have
a closer resemblance to Vega's golden age
from 1904 through the 1920s. When you go
to any old-time festival, you see folks play
ing either original collector's items or mod

painless,
reasonable.

ern copies.

The AKG company had the best hospi
tality suite I found at the show. They also

the

had quite the assortment

of

high quality

microphones. asked my salesman about
affordable mics for guitar. He recom
I

mended the AKG C535AB At
of about $300 it is about

a street price
three times the

price of our old reliable Sure SM-57s and
SM-58s, but it is three times the micro
phone. Before you run out and buy one, do
note that you need phantom power for this
mic to operate.

course, checking out new accessories
is not the primary reason I head to the
NAMM show every few years. Though
dark beer and Austrian chocolates at the
AKG booth is almost enough for me to pop
$250 for a plane ticket, the instruments are
Of

the main attraction.
In

banjo land, my first stop was Gold

Though ferreting out openback banjos at
NAMM show is like looking for one

55-gallon drum of red
down
marbles, tracking
guitars is quite a
different story. They are everywhere.
So, what is new in acoustic guitars? Well

blue marble in

a

truthfully, not much. We are in the golden
age of quality guitars. Even the cheap gui
tars are made with a higher level of crafts
manship than ever.
now in full production
of their totally bolt-on neck. There is no
glue holding the neck to the guitar's body,
only bolts with precision shims to align the
Taylor Guitars

is

neck. With this system, a Taylor guitar
neck can be reset in less than a half-hour

neck/body joint hump that
might cause fret buzz. To see the system in
and there is no

detail, call Taylor and ask for their neck

video.
(continued on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The most interesting guitar I saw was the
Canadian made Garrison. Their market

concept is that guitars have too many pieces.
Gluing the braces to the tops and backs,
then gluing tops and backs to sides, then
truthfully time
routing for binding.
The
consuming.
engineers at Garrison have
a molded plastic bracing system
designed
that combines the braces and the binding
all in one. This enables the computer con
trolled laser-cut tops, backs, and sides to fit
in the recesses of the molded brace/bind
Radical? Yes!

ing unit for fast assembly.

Will

this

seriously challenge Martin,

Gibson, and Taylor? Nah. The design is for
serious entry to intermediate grade instru
ments with list prices from $350 for their
basic unit to $1,500 for the top of the line
with built in pickup. I only saw prototypes
and was impressed. I think Garrison's gui
tars will offer some serous competition to
the Asian made instruments

in the

same

price range.
While I can't make it to every trade show,
as a man serving a life sentence in the music

industry, every few years I need to check
out what the mainstream music world has
to offer.

allowed

And as the general public is not
attend the NAMM shows, it is

to

my duty to report to you on the quality of
modern instruments and who is giving

away the best chocolates.
For further

information contact the compa

nies direct

Elixir,

Gore

1-800-367-5533,

Music;

www.goremusic.com
J.

D'Addario

www.daddario.com

&amp; Co.;

Schertler; 1-508-778-4050, www.schertlerusa.com

AKG1-615-630-0499, www.akgacoustics.com
Gold Tone; 1-321-264-1970, www.goldtone.com

1-800-943-6782,
Guitars;
www.taylorguitars.com
Garrison Guitars;
1-709-745-6677,
Taylor

www.garrisonguitars.com

Bob

Smakula

is

a

musician

WV.

He

is

and resident
the proprietor

of

Randolph Co.,
of
Smakula Fretted Instruments, specializing in
the resotration and sales of vintage stringed

instruments.

�Classifieds
Musical Instruments

OLDTTME MANTX5L1N INSTRUMENT ALS

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION-- New-

Used-Vintage guitars, banjos, mandolins,
archtops, wood &amp; metal body Dobros, Na

tionals. Mandolin Brothers, 629 Forest Ave.,
Staten Island, NY 10310. Free Catalog. 718981-3226. Call for no-charge evaluation of

LittleRiverStompbythe Buckhannon Bros. 25
tunes, 73 minutes long. CDs $15.00, cas
settes $10.00 plus $1.00 shipping. Make

check payable

to

Dennis Buckhannon.

Write: The Buckhannon Bros., PO Box 6165,
St.

Charles, MO 63302-6165.

your vintage fretted instruments.

Equipment

Recordings, Books, Instruction

ODD SIZED FIBERSKYN banjo heads,
many sizes from 10" to 12 1/8", $18 to $20.
Gut banjo strings $15. Everest banjo cases

NEW CD: OLD BUNCH OF KEYS. John
Specker playing solo old-time fiddle and
singing. Reviewed OTH winter 2000/01,
page 40. $17.00 includes postage, to John
Specker, RD #1, Box 230, Chester, VT 05143.
For

11" and 12" rims $95
plus shipping.
Smakula Fretted Instruments, PO Box 882,
Elkins, WV 26241; 304-636-6710

for

bookings call 802-875-2321.

WHEN THE CACTUS IS IN BLOOM the
new recording from Bob Bovee and Gail
Heil on Copper Creek features old-time

cowboy songs, Ozark tunes, and more.

To

order (CD only), send $15.00 plus $2.00
shipping to Bob Bovee &amp; Gail
Heil, 18287 Gap Dr., Spring Grove, MN
55974.
CLOSE TO THE HEART, the latest from
West Virginia singer, Bob Heyer. "Sincere,
heartfelt and well performed old time bal
lads and blues"
County Sales. CD $16 post
Table
Rock
Music, 501 National Road,
paid.

Wheeling, WV 26003. bheyer@ovis.net,

www.clawhammer.com/tablerock.
FLATFOOTING

WORKSHOP

TIONAL VIDEO by

INSTRUC

Bernstein. 1-3/4
hours, 27 steps, beginning to advanced.
Easy to follow. Each step clearly broken
down and taught. Also includes 3 per
formed pieces. Step manual and 2 different
concert performance videos also available.
Ira

Inquire: 179 Flint St., Asheville, NC 28801.

828-255-9393; IraTenToe@aol.com.
AUCTION: play the good records of the
old original CARTER FAMILY- (Sarah, A. P.
Carter, Maybelle). Beautiful, rich, inspir
ing and "steeped in tradition". Pure and
authentic. World famous artists. Old 78's
and LP records.
List #2

(LPs).

Two lists. List #1 (78's),
Each

list SAE and

2-34&lt;t

stamps. Overseas welcome (include $4.00
postage for air mail). H. Fink, Box 156,
Johnson Creek, Wisconsin 53038. 1-920699-4908.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The

Old-Time Herald will accept classified

ads at the cost of 35 cents per ivord,

minimum

$5.00. Any grouping of letters or numbers is
counted as one word. All ads must be received
the

first of the month,
publication.
by

6

weeks

prior

to

�Reviews

two eminent scientists. Simultaneously instruc
tive and inspirational, it provides a portal to the

The New Lost
City Ramblers

universal corpus of chemical knowledge known
"the literature." By analogy, the personal
libraries of old-time music enthusiasts should
include the two CD set The New Lost City Ram

40 Years of

as

Concert

Recordings

Rounder

blers: Forty Years of Concert Performances.

821

The history of the NLCR is well known

610 481-2

American society
John Cohen: vocals, mandolin, guitar, kazoo, banjo,

banjo-guitar, triangle; Mike Seeger: vocals, fiddle,
mandolin, banjo-mandolin, banjo, autoharp, mouth
harp, jaw harp; Tom Paley: vocals, guitar, banjo,
kazoo; Tracy Schwarz: vocals, fiddle, guitar, button

accordion

Soldier's Joy/Down in the Willow Garden/
Brown's Ferry Blues/Too Tight Rag/Little
Birdie /Darling Corey /The Democratic Donkey
in

(Is

His Stall Again)/Poor

Ellen Smith/On

Some Foggy Mountain Top/Cackling Hen/The
Battleship Maine/Worried Man Blues/The Un
quiet Grave/Lady of

Carlisle/Groundhog/ Or

ange Blossom Special /East Virginia Blues/
Country Blues/Little Maggie/The Little Girl and
the Dreadful

Snake/Keep Movin'/Fortune/She

Tickles Me/The Arkansas Traveler/Saddle Up

Grey/Sally Goodin'/The Old Bell Cow/It's
to Leave You, Sweet Love/Dark Holler
Blues/Locks and Bolts/Wildwood Weed/Milk
the

Hard

'Em in the Evening

Blues/Madeline/Sourwood

Mountain/Black Bottom Strut/Jordan Is a Hard
Road to Travel/The Old Man at the Mill/Tom
Sherman's
(in

Bar

tro.)/ Turkey

Room/Turkey
the

in

the

in

Straw

Straw/Old Joe Clark/

Rabbit Chase/Poor Old Dirt Farmer/Tennessee
Blues/Gonna Lay Down My Old Guitar/I've

Always Been a Rambler/Baltimore Fire/Three
Men Went A-Hunting
Reagents for Organic Synthesis by Louis and Mary
Feiser is a 20- volume work found in the personal
libraries

Unlike

most practicing organic chemists.
textbook or an encyclopedia, it is an

of
a

essential reference,

present knowledge

a

compendium
of the field as

of past

and

perceived by

Please send all items for review

to:

OTH,

Durham, NC 27717. DO
NOT send items to individual reviewers.
The OTH does not return unsolicited mate
rial for review. We do not guarantee that
we will review unsolicited material.
PO

to

readers of the OTH. Notable accomplishments
include re-introducing urban mid-20th century

Box 51812,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to its rural

cultural anteced

ents and sowing the seeds that blossomed into a
still vibrant subculture. Perhaps more impor

recording techniques. Occasional ensemble raggedness contributes to the feeling of immediacy
and excitement. The differences in musical ap
proach shown by the original ensemble that

included Paley and the current line-up that in
cludes Schwarz are clearly discernible. The matu
ration of the Ramblers as a musical unit and the

growth of their interpretative powers are fasci
nating to witness. Sixteen tracks are previously
unreleased. A veritable treasure-trove

is presented!
Since the previously released tracks (some
appearing on the 1978 Flying Fish 2-LP set, 20

Years:

Concert Performances) may be familiar to

tantly, along with Bascom Lamar Lunsford and
Pete Seeger, they collectively and individually

OTH readers, this reviewer chooses to highlight
some of the newly released material. A perfor

defined the role of a practicing vernacular musician-folklorist who operates outside of academia.
The NLCR's deflation of academic ethno-musicological pomposity with excruciating puns,
controlled silliness, and sparkling, authentic old-

mance recorded

time musicianship motivated a multi-genera
tion urban audience to personalize and re-in

vigorate traditional rural culture. Although the
NLCR's penetration into mainstream conscious
ness was minimal at most, the band and its
audience influenced the nature of mainstream
culture with a very distinct stage whisper. But
most importantly, the NLCR was and remains
one hot little band, as evidenced by this

out

standing collection.
This recording is a generous 48-cut retrospec
tive of the Ramblers' live performance career,

ranging from a radio dub of "Soldier's Joy"
recorded in 1958 to "retrograss" experiments
with Bill Monroe's "Tennessee Blues" recorded
in 1999. NLCR archivist Mike Seeger provided
most of the material, which was assembled into
the present collection by Jon Pankake in collabo
ration with the Ramblers. The intent was

to

program that conveyed the unique,
joyous feel of a NLCR concert as well as to make
available alternate takes and new live material.
create

a

1995 ("Turkey

at

Symphony Space (NYC)

in the Straw,"

in

"Old Joe Clark,"

"Rabbit Chase," "Poor Old Dirt Farmer," "Gonna
Lay Down My Old Guitar," "I've Always Been a
Rambler," "Three Men Went A-Hunting") is
one of the gems of the collection. The Ramblers
are at the apex of their powers as interpreters of

traditional music. Mike Seeger demonstrates how
the lowly jaw harp can be used to deliver a
virtuoso performance of "Turkey in the Straw"
with a tongue-knotting patter-song vocal alter
nating seamlessly with the jaw harp's metallic
"Poor Old Dirt Farmer," composed
performed by Tracy Schwarz, is a stark

boinnnng.
and

lament accompanied by an ominously droning
DDAD-tuned fiddle. The song is indistinguish
able from traditional material, and the presenta
tion is a testament to Schwarz's uncanny skill at
assimilating diverse traditional musical genres.
Two interesting performances come from
concert at NYU. The Uncle Dave Macon

a

1972

chest

Hard Road to Travel" is given a
full-band
reading that threatens
supercharged
to flatten the audience, not unlike the aggressive
approach taken by post-modern old-time bands

nut "Jordan

Is a

such as the Old Crow Medicine

Show. Tom

The entire breadth of the NLCR

Ashley's "The Old Man at the Mill" receives a
deep, mysterious reading, as belies the enig

covered.

matic nature of the text. An unusual selection

repertoire is
classic
string band re
Examples
creations, solo ballad singing, Cajun music, jugband blues, re-interpretation of material from
of

cornerstone performers of traditional music such
as Dock Boggs, early commercial country music,
and newly-composed songs in traditional styles
are spiced with trademark near-surrealistic hu
mor concerning the travails of rural life in and
around the imaginary hamlet of New Lost City.
Most of the selections are intensely vocal-driven.
The raw energy of the earlier live performances
is

captured and enhanced by the primitive

was unearthed from
a

a

1963 performance at Knox

Blossom Special" is given
non
fiddle-indulgent "train blues"
good-time,

College

(IL): "Orange

treatment, complete with

a

running commen

tary on the Doppler effect. OTH readers who
truly hate OBS should give this a listen! Out

standing among the previously-issued material
is the side-splitting, rapid-fire "Arkansas Trav
eler" routine, which should take its place in the
pantheon of word-play inhabited by Abbott and
Costello's "Who's On First?"

�of the

Many

recordings were not made on

professional equipment,

and

a

progression

of

sound quality from earlier to later performances
is evident. This in no way interferes with the
enjoyment of this release. A carefully annotated
booklet

is

included containing full sources, per

sonnel, and recording details for each cut. Strik
ing band portraits and an illuminating essay by
veteran folk music commentator Jon Pankake
round out the packaging. Also included are an

extensive bibliography, filmography, and discography of Cohen, Paley, Seeger, and Schwarz,
as well as references to important documentary
musical collections produced

by them.

Concert Recordings is, in this

reviewer's opinion,

40 Years

of

marvelously entertaining and absolutely essen
tial listening for anyone interested in traditional

Americanmusic.Icannotrecommenditmore

highly.

STEVE SENDEROFF

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�sonic

space, and

are

voice. The selection

balanced with the

well

"Don't Let Your Deal Go

Down" from Fiddlin' John Carson and Moon
shine Kate exemplifies these characteristics, and
is one of the best versions of this song I've heard.
Fridley's control of her diction is unusually
precise. This allows her to achieve extremely
clear and expressive phrasing. The emotional
range of her singing is breathtaking. She is ca
pable of producing tender, childlike sotto voce

passages as well as the full-throated, snarling,
ancient sounds that echoed centuries ago from
isolated hollers in the Blue Ridge Mountains.
Her approach may be viewed as a musical blend
ing of raw power with warmth and mystery. She
says modestly, "My voice

somewhat cutting, which

is
I

naturally loud and
think is good for

country music."

Although Cary presents powerful unaccom
panied ballads (notably "Early, Early in the
Spring" from Rosa Lee Watson) and a moving,
primitive version of Frank Proffit's "Pretty Crow
ing Chicken" (accompanied by Jake Owen's idi
omatically perfect fretless banjo playing), this
reviewer is particularly impressed by the sensi
tive ensemble interplay shown in the early com
mercial country music selections. Flatt and
Scruggs' "Down the Road" receives a textbookperfect treatment, powered by the call and re
sponse of Cary's swooping voice and crackerjack Scruggs style banjo playing of Larry Perkins.
Cary and band are firmly in their element on

three Carter Family songs, which display a gentle
give and take between simple instrumental em
bellishments, lead, and harmony vocals. A pre
cise reading of "Banjo Picking Girl" is the appro
priate conclusion to this fine collection. As an
added non-vocal treat, Cary's trademark back
up guitar playing anchors Art Stamper's excit
ing reading of his tune "Bumblebee in the
"
Gourd. A second (possibly unintentional?) treat

unlisted bonus cut: the song "Gathering
Flowers" from Dillard Chandler, which also fea
is an

tures the expressive fiddling

of Art Stamper.

Highly recommended.
STEVE SENDEROFF

To order: Juba

Records, PO Box

82, Bryson City,

NC 28713; http:/ /www.caryfridley.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�On

of

couple

a

selections

the guitar chords are

a

it

seems

as

though

little too modern for the

fiddling style and tune ("Statue Clog,"
stance). This isn't the case, however,

for

in

in the jig

medley composed by Miller, "Wayne Merril's
.". Here, both musicians are in the same
Jig
intense groove. In the first tune traditional chords
used

are

chords

in

in the

unexpected ways, the

5

minor

7

second tune kick the music into

high gear, and Miller really rocks out.
Airplang II was recorded 18 years ago. The

selection, a medley of traditional dance
tunes, begins with a non-rhythmic, dark synthe
sizer pad; from the first moment of the album, it
and their music
is clear that the musicians
have ventured into uncharted territory. They
were, in face, experimenting with new instru
ments, new timbres, new rhythms, new tunes,
first

new ideas. "Cattle in the Cane" is particularly
effective; the slow and ominous introduction
leads into a driving and jazzy rendition, com
plete with what sounds like an electric guitar
solo. This is great dance music. "Leather Britches
..." starts out with fiddle and harmonica sound
ing pretty traditional. During the course of the
tune, however, never swerving one iota from the

dance rhythm, blues, jazz, and Texas sock ar
rangements all make an appearance. The music
is

the

tight;

musicians are having fun. The

"PincushionPolka" incorporates barrelhouse piano
(I swear) echoes of Carl Stalling's cartoon music.
Airdance, finally, is an album of the contra
music of today. Four musicians join Miller on the
album, which fuses the best of the traditional

and

and the experimental into

a

unified form. Poten

jarring-or warring-styles (consider the
medley of Ralph Blizard's "Gypsy Stomp" and
Thelonious Monk's "In Walked Bud") co-exist
peacefully and effectively here. Some ideas that
tially

were interesting, but not in the best interest, let's
say, of dance music found on Airplang II, like
slow transitions between upbeat dance tunes,
(what are the dancers supposed to do?) have
been retired, while other innovations like taste
ful percussion have been included. Tune transi
tions may include modern chords but are in a
straight-ahead dance rhythm. The tunes are al

most

all newly composed. A couple of pieces
featuring mostly fiddle and percussion work

well. The final set of tunes ("Heather McCarthy
.")
arebeautifully arranged and executed, pairing fiddle
and mandolin in

a memorable way.
Great Meadows' stated goal is "to establish
New England contra as a genre of music as

recognizable national
as

some

of this

music

as Cajun

music." As good

is, and as

worthy

as this

don't think that's going to happen. I
goal is,
think the people who will buy this music and
I

to it will be mostly people who enjoy the
dancing and want to re-live memorable eve
nings on the dance floor, and people who want

listen

to

learn the tunes.

This

is

not

to

say that the

music isn't good; it certainly is. But the music
itself is drawn from too many identifiable sources
to be, so to speak, its own thing. Having said this,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

if I am proved wrong I'll be happy. And if contra
music does become popular on its own merits as
a
listening music, it will be in great measure

because
and

of

Rodney Miller's world class fiddling

musicianship.
HILARY DIRLAM

To

order: Great Meadow Music, PO Box

Westmoreland

NH 03467;
www.greatmeadowmusic.com

4,

603-399-8361;

�"

This is the clearest example
variations in bowing that Joe was capable
of, some subtleties that do not always come
across in the full band setting. One of the en
semble tracks where his bowing, especially the
highly syncopated low strain, is "Train 45." One
might also want to know that "Old Cat Died" is
quite similar to what is known further east in the
Blue Ridge as "Cousin Sally Brown." Their
memorable tune, "Rattle Trap," is part of that
"Flannery

's

Dream.

of the

"Fire in the

Mountain/Granny Will Your Dog

Bite" family of tunes, yet different. Their rendi
tion of "Shout Lulu," is absolutely the essence of

old-time string-band music.

It just does not get
you want some of the
finest ever traditional dance music to come from

any better than this.

If

the part of the country where the mountains of
Tennessee, Virginia, and North Carolina come
together, you won't go wrong with this record
ing. It's great.
KERRY BLECH

To order: Janice

Birchfield,

115

Holly Hill Road,

Roan Mountain, TN 37687; 423 725-3065

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Volume

I

presents

a

of

variety

singers

Rebecca King Jones, Lena Bourne Fish, Eleazar
Tillett and others, while Volume II, though it

includes some

of these, focuses on the music of
Frank Proffitt and his relations, the Hicks family,
including Buna Hicks, who plays an old dugout

fiddle made by her husband Roby Monroe Hicks.
When Frank Warner asks him to tell about his
life and his folks, Lee Monroe Presnell begins:
"I was 75 the 15th of last May. I've repre

sented, tried

to

represent,

the Old Primitive

Baptists for about 42 years. I'm a-getting feeble,
I'm a-getting old, but at the same time, I've got a
hope. I stay on the spurs of Beech Mountain,

where the

air is fresh and

healthy and the water

cool, and I'm glad that the good Lord has
blessed me and kept me till this present time,
is

and for what purpose

I

don't know, why I'm

."
here, but for some purpose.
And then there's a little call-and-response,
with Frank adding in, "It's a good reason," and

Presnell responding, "Yes sir, some good rea
son." This conversation, heard as it is here in the
middle of a collection of old folksongs songs
collected from elders whose way of life was
who remembered

passing,

songs from older

British traditions, who learned and made up
new songs but sang them in ways shaped by the
hills and customs of their own New World

munities

this

com

conversation implies something

besides religious faith.

It

implies that the pur

develop and pass on the arts and
pose
skills of one's people and region. This collection
of life is to

makes me feel that there might actually be an
answer to the impossibly huge question of why
we're here: to keep on singing.
However, the singing comes in fragments
lines and verses, but rarely a whole song. I was
irked by this until

I

read the explanation both in
T raditional

the CD booklet and in Anne Warner's

of the field

American Folksongs (transcriptions
in 1984 by

Syracuse Uni

recordings, published
versity Press). The material from 1940 was re
corded on a Wilcox Gay Recordio disk recorder,
which used acetate-coated paper disks. A spe
cially made Philco disk recorder was used for
the 1941-46 material. Thereafter, the Warners
used a reel-to-reel recorder, and could re-record
machine if a singer had to stop and
think. But with the earlier recorders, Anne says,
the Warners had to conserve disks:

or stop the

collector should record every
verse of a song, since a traditional singer may
make variations in the tune from stanza to stanza
It is good, too, to include some discussion of a
song, where it was learned, and what the singer
"Of course

knows

of its

money

to

a

history. However, we had very little
invest in this new overriding interest,
and we didn't have many disks at any given
time. So, in most instances in those early days,
we recorded only two or three verses of any
song, getting three songs

to

each side of

disk. This Frank did, just
tune. The words were up

to

have

a

small

put into my
notebooks all the words of all the songs. There
to

me, and

a

record of the
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was one advantage to this, since I took down the
words when I was with our singers and could

by Charles Meekins, of Kitty Hawk, NC. The
voices range from old and quavery to younger

verify a word that might be in doubt. This made
for a much more accurate record than is possible
in transcribing old recordings from an infor
mant who may not have spoken clearly."

and smoother, but every singer here
In the

is

very fine.

deliberate phrasings, the fallings and ris

ings of tone and breath, it's as

if

you can hear the

Full texts of the songs are available in Traditional

long life of the song in even the smallest por
tion another reason that, for general listening

American Folksongs or on the Appleseed website.
The songs themselves, well, they're beautiful,

purposes, the bits and fragments are not a problem.
It is a disservice to skip over the distinctive

and

except for Frank Proffitt and his son, Frank
who provide wonderful banjo, guitar, and
dulcimer
mainly unaccompanied: ballads, lyr

qualities

Jr.,

also be

ics, sentimental

and religious songs, and

lulla

bies and game-songs too. There is one fiddle
tune, an unusual one, "Been to the East," played

of every singer and song, yet it would
disservice to select one or two as high
lights. Every song its its own highlight. This
collection contains a huge amount of material,
a

(continued

on next page)

�and you'll just have to listen to it all yourself and
find your own favorites. For me, every one is a

favorite, and

I'm

long enough

to

already frantic that life isn't
dwell as deeply as should be

dwelt inside each.
The songs are arranged, according to Gerret

Warner, "in an order that we liked, in the way
that we might play new songs for friends, with
one surprise after another." Thus the effect is not
so much to showcase individual artists as to
create

a
populated and lively landscape of song.
Nevertheless, one singer stands out. Of course,

this man is Frank Proffitt.

It

was Frank Proffitt

who sang "Tom Dooley," which Alan Lomax
heard from Frank Warner and included, revised,
in his 1947

distressed

Folksong USA. (Although Proffitt was
and surprised when he heard the

Kingston Trio version come out of his radio one
day (he felt it mocked his own heritage and
culture), he later came to love sharing his music
with "the other world": "I so much desire to only
be a representative of my kind of people, neaver
just exault myself," he said in a letter to the
Warners. His voice is warm and compelling, his
to

are delightful, and his songs
sentimental (in the very best way)
little bit serious even when they're about

accompaniments
are sad, silly,

and

a

lazing around:
"I'm going to pick my banjo, I'm going to pick

my banjo,
I'm going to pick my banjo, pick it while I can.
it in the morning, Pick it in the evening,

Pick

I'm goin'
ised land."

to

pick my banjo right

Seems like an answer

to Lee

to the

prom

Monroe PresnelTs

"hope" that he's here for a reason. Frank Proffitt
discovered his reason, just as the Warners dis

covered theirs when they set out from New Y ork
City in 1938, car packed with "bags, hip-pocket
notebooks, camera, and guitar," not knowing
they were soon to find scores of lifelong friends
and a lifetime of love for folk music and the
people

it

comes from.

Jeff and Gerret Warner have been

meticulous

producers. These CDs come with marvelous
booklets of stories, photographs, and song notes.
David Glasser, Charlie Pilzer, and Matt Sandoski
of

Airshow have done

a

brilliant job

reduction, though in some songs quite
disk hiss remains. I'm glad that noise

of

noise

a

bit of

is

there,

because if it weren't, these field recordings would
sound too modern to to be true to themselves.
This is a collection of sweet gems and sad

marvels; of sentiments, harvests, labors, hun
gers, romances, murders, games, lullabies. Full
with praises and anxieties, with the transcend
ing voice in the physical throat, it's a beautiful
work, essential

to

my heart.
MOLLY TENENBAUM

To order:

Appleseed Recordings, P.O. Box. 2593

West Chester, PA 19380.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�old-time traditions of the Oregon Trail, the Wil
liams add their passionate performances and
deft sense of timing. Top it all off with sound

Waltzes

Vivian Williams

engineering by Phil Williams and the result is a
series of well-developed musical narratives and

Voyager
VRCD 351
(49:09)

Vivian Williams: fiddle; Phil Williams: guitar, bass
Sir John

MacDonald's

Waltz/Silver Wedding

Waltz/Whistler's Waltz/Saturday Waltz/
Stonetown Waltz/Emma/Keepsake Waltz/
Rebecca's Waltz/Fairweather Waltz/Fairy
Waltz/A

Waltz/Good

Waltz/
Dry River Waltz/Swedish Wedding Waltz/ A
Beautiful Night/ Anniversary Song
&amp; E

The Pacific

Northwest has

Neighbor

a

rich tradition of

fiddle and dance tunes. The musical traditions
brought to the area by pioneers included Appa
lachian, Celtic, and Scandinavian, which sim
mered in the musical melting pot that is old-time
music. New styles developed and were incorpo
rated, most notably Northwestern style fiddle.
As time and technology moved forward, the

acoustic world made way for the electric one and
much of that great, history-laden old-time music
was in danger of being lost. That will never be
the case since Vivian and Phil Williams make it
their goal to preserve the lush musical heritage
of the area.

The Williams are multi-talented musicians,
who weave the history of the area into their
musicianship, be it in studio or a live performance.
The couple has documented and performed
Northwest traditional music since their teens in
the 1950s. They have been instrumental in pre
serving the musical traditions of the Northwest
by helping found the Seattle Folklore Society,

Northwest Folklife, and the Washington OldTime Fiddlers Association, and by playing blueold-time music

festivals or square
dances. They also own and operate Voyager
Recordings &amp; Publications, which has released
recordings of more than 85 fiddlers and devel
oped the most extensive recorded archive of
grass

or

at

Northwest fiddle and old-time music in the country
Musically speaking, Vivian and Phil Williams
are superb talents. Vivian is a noted fiddler and
the 1999 National Senior Old-Time Fiddling
Champion (Weiser, ID). Furthermore, she is a
prolific and talented composer. Phil plays "just
about anything with strings on it." For the three

recordings, he ably handles guitar, mandolin,
banjo and bass, providing rhythm to Vivian's
fiddle. Phil also repairs and makes stringed in
struments, is a recording engineer, and a con
sultant

to the

Smithsonian on traditional music

region. Together, they are a well-versed,
considerable talent.
Much of the success of their music is built
in the

upon their understanding

of the

traditions of the

Pacific Northwest. To their familiarity with the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

successful examples of the style.
Each album offers a different perspective of
the music of their region. The best example of an
"at the dance" feel would be the aptly titled Live1.,
which captures the energy of their live perfor
mance. Culled from Malo Grange (near Repub
lic, WA) in October 1995, Fiddler's Inn in Seattle
in June

1995, and Echo Valley Ski Lodge (near

in April 1998. The album features
tunes. The diversity of style is telling jigs,

Chelan, WA)
19

waltzes, rags, blues times, fiddle tunes, mando
lin tunes, traditional songs and originals, four by
Vivian and one by Phil. The album is an example
of

what fun these two musicians bring

performances.
Dance Music of

Trail is as

much

a

of the

is a

collection

prosaic explanations of the early pioneers who
trekked the Oregon Trail. The album ties to
gether elements of minstrel tunes, British Isles,
country dance tunes, and polka.
The final offering,

Waltzes, is the gem of the
'solo' effort by Vivian Will
iams, Phil provides rhythm by way of guitar and
bass throughout the work. By focusing on some

three. Listed as

a

Vivian's favorite waltzes, a theme that truly
triumphs, fiddler Williams offers a well-chosen
sampling of the delicate genre as well as her
subtle mastery of both style and instrument. The
of

sixteen-song album includes traditional pieces
alongside three originals.
Straightforward, attractive artwork is the stan
dard for all three CDs. The liner notes differ in

extent

of detail

musicianship, thorough engineering, and
sense

of

from album

to

album, though

each contains either biographical details, fiddle

tunings, influences,

or

impetus for choosing the

piece. Particularly impressive is the inclusion of
suggested reading on Dance Music on the Oregon
Trail.

Vivian and Phil Williams have taken their
love relationship with the music of the Oregon
Trail and forged works that mesh masterful

a

firm

history.
KRISTIN

the Oregon

musical settling of the North
of America's most famil
tunes. The liner notes set the tone with the

narrative
west as it
iar

to their

GARAU

�medium-slow speed, wherein lies my main
complaint. Though a few waltzes are sprinkled
in, the prevailing sense is one of sameness, mak
ing me itch for some tempo variety, especially a
few peppy numbers. On the plus side, the guitar
playing is spare and solid, the mandolin adds
variety and texture, and the recording is clear
and balanced. Verne and Sandy seem equally
comfortable trading off lead and harmony. The
voices sound authentic, unpretentious, and com
petent. wanted to know more about this duo
I

from Iowa, but the notes offer only the song list,
several of which were written by Verne or Sandy,
and a short message (". We like these old songs
and we hope you do too.")
I'd recommend this recording for those with
an

interest

in

no-frills, slow country songs.
TONI WILLIAMS

To order: 110 Elm Ct.,

Decorah

IA 52101; 319-

382-4640

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Moon Waltz/Courtin' Days Waltz/Thirty-First
Street Blues/Picture No Artist Can Paint/ When
It's

in the

Springtime

Rockies/Texas Fair/Mis

sissippi Breakdown/Lazy Kate/Jungle Waltz

another release in Document's series of
"Complete Recorded Works in Chronological

Here

is

certainly is a well-deserved one.
The old County Records LP reissue of the Leake
County Revelers was always a favorite of mine,
every cut a standout, and I often asked why no
one had reissued all the recordings of this band.
had heard more of their cuts, some other LP
reissues and some on tapes or the original 78s,
Order" and

it

liked all

I

done

its

I

of the best

to 1930

The Revelers are probably the most prolific
recording artists among the Mississippi string
bands. Tony Russell, whose 1976 Old Time Music

magazine article on them provides the basis for
the liner notes of these CDs, calls the Leake
"
County Revelers "waltz kings of the Old South.
Indeed, their biggest selling release, one of the
best selling of all old-time 78s, was the coupling
"Wednesday Night Waltz" and "Good Night

Waltz." Looking at the song titles reveals seven
more waltzes, but quite a few of the other songs

waltzes, like "When

It's

Springtime

in

the Rockies," "My Wild Irish Rose," and "Memo
ries" (inexplicably another recording of the same

song LCR called "Memories Waltz"). This adds
a
up to 16 of 44 sides (if haven't lost count!).
I

lot of waltzes, and mostly rare ones.
Still, the prevalence of waltzes doesn't give
you the real idea of what the band is like. They

were not

a

raucous, hell-for-leather

outfit like

the Georgia bands (Skillet Lickers, Virginia Reelers, Earl Johnson, etc.), but generally more con

trolled and structured. Their versatility was one
of their strongest points, offering equally adept
of breakdowns, ragtime pieces, senti
mental songs, humorous ditties and fiddle blues.
Infectious square-dance tunes like "Saturday

renditions

Night Breakdown," "Monkey
"

Been

to the East,

Been

to the

in the Dog Cart,"

West,

"

and "Johnson

Gal" have become part of the standard reper
toire of the larger old-time community today,
and can be traced to these versions.

Will Gilmer was the fiddler. He could milk the

waltzes, make the breakdowns sail along, or cry
the blues. The mandolin of R.O. Mosely follows
the fiddle closely on most tunes; on other num
bers

held the lead, particularly the raggy cuts

it

like "Georgia Camp Meeting," "Bird in the
Brook," and "Beautiful Bells," the same tune
Ozark fiddler Bob Larkan called "Beautiful
"

The band was rounded out by the always
appropriate guitar foundation of Dallas Jones
and Jim Wolverton's banjo, the latter sometimes

Belle.

barely audible and
ful punchy

at

others providing

counterpoint

mend both volumes of this set to anyone who
loves and wants to understand southern tradi
tional music, for there are few bands that could
offer more

to

learn from than these guys. You

can't go wrong here. Mostly the sound quality is
good except on a few of the later cuts. These

BOB BOVEE

are

ings together in one glorious set!

are also

ers, but more than adequate, and always inter
esting, and definitely old-time. I have to recom

record

job and

numbers, but there

here that I've been missing. So
the Leake County Revelers 1927

of

dies, so it's easy to forget that this was a singing
band. They weren't the most memorable sing

included many
some gems
finally we have all

heard. County, of course, had

usual masterful

usually think of this band for its fine
wonderful, well-played melo

would be 78s from the Depression, ones rare
enough that it's probably difficult to find cleaner
copies to remaster. The liner notes, though brief,
are informative and well-written and, as always
with Document CDs, all available discographical
information is included.

I

and

I

instrumentals,

to the

a

delight

fiddle.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�evocations

simpler and more satisfying life,
listeners, ironically, through the agen
cies of those powerful capitalistic communica
tions forces, the Victor Talking Machine Com
came

of

a

to

pany (RCA) and radio. The Family, in fact,
reached its largest national audience through
performances on the notorious Mexican border

station, XERA, with broadcasts that were ac
companied by the tawdry smell of commerce

never-ending spiel for hair dyes, laxatives,
cold tonics, and baby chicks.
One finds no hostility toward the emerging
a

music of the Carter Family, even if
many modern fans have repaired to their music
through dissatisfaction with today's increasingly
order

in the

impersonal society. The Carters, in fact, adapted
to the new technological methods. For
instance, they comfortably employed them as
metaphors in their songs, usually to portray
timeless truths, as in "The Little Black Train,"

very well

Heaven," "Hello Central, Give
Me Heaven," and "Heaven's Radio." The musi
cal instruments that were basic to the Carter
were
the autoharp and guitar
Family sound
still recent innovations in the rural South when
"No

T elephone in

the Carters made their first records, as was the

mail-order

catalogue, with

its

tantalizing

of big-city life, that popularized such
items among those living back in the hills and
hollows of the region.
These seeming paradoxes really do not emerge
in the overview presented in this book, even
though the basic details of the Carters' lives are

glimpses

temptation to give the music a respectable pedi
gree (mercifully, though, Wolfe does not try to
link the Carters to some kind of shadowy Celtic
past). The Carters were from Appalachia, but
their style was non-specific southern rural. It is
hard to isolate any characteristic of their lives or

music that was substantially different from that
people anywhere in the South during
those years. Their repertoire probably included
songs that were popular in Appalachia, but most
were not native to the region, and they were
of rural

popular throughout the South (indeed, many
were popular in other parts of America). The
mythical Appalachia suggests ethnic and cul
tural purity, qualities that were absent from the
music of the Carter Family and from the eclectic
and hybrid body of styles and songs that

com

prised early country music.
We have to be careful, too, of how we use the
word "traditional." Except for a few items (like
"Black Jack David," "Sinking in the Lonesome
Sea," and "Never Let the Devil Get the Upper
Hand"), the Carter Family songs weren't very

old. Nor is there much evidence that the Carters
really grew up with these songs. As Wolfe notes,
a
large portion came from the late 19th-century

storehouse of Tin Pan Alley songs, or from turnof-the-century gospel music. A. P. Carter's quest
for usable songs took him into the realm of sheet
music, songsters, and hvmnals (we aren't told
whether he listened to phonograph records), or
into a dialogue with those who had access to

seems to encapsulate the limitation found in his
share Wolfe's fascina
overall interpretation.
tion with A P. Carter, find his singing charming,
and believe that too often he has been dismissed
as a quaint and lesser member of the trio. Wolfe
tries hard to elevate or resurrect A. P.'s reputa
tion, but he strains to establish him as a great
songwriter, an effort that leads to a curious and
unconvincing comparison with Duke Ellington.
I

Again and again Wolfe gives evidence that
Maybelle and Sara contributed to the shaping of
many of the songs, and of course emphasizes the
role played by the African American Lesley
Riddle who supplied songs to the Carters and
accompanied A. P. on song-hunting expeditions.
Wolfe nevertheless clings to the fiction that A. P.
was a major songwriter and, like a host of other
writers and critics, attributes songs to A. P. that
he obviously did not write. Despite Wolfe's ef
forts, we are left with the conclusion that we

already had. A. P. was not a great songwriter; he
was a great collector and arranger of song mate
rial, and all of us should be eternally grateful for
the songs that he collected or "worked up."
The song annotations are valuable compo
of the book, but their unevenness prevents
them from making the kind of contribution that
country and folk music fans and critics deserve.

nents

Carter Famil)' song sources provide an ongoing
realm of research for students of country music,
and we may never know the origins of all of their

such material. Of course, even the songs of the
1890s were beginning to sound quaint during

songs. Nevertheless, a comprehensive history of
their songs will tell us much about country mu
sic as a whole, and about its interrelationship

ion. Too often, Poor Valley and Maces Spring,
the locales in Southwestern Virginia that nour

the 1920s when modernism was

with other forms

the land.

Charles Wolfe

ished

their music, are
islands of cultural stasis surrounded

Stylistically, the Carter Famil v presented song
material in a fashion that also combined or fused

Carter Family, and perhaps there he will utilize
more fully the research done by Norm Cohen,

industrial world. Poor Val

Although their vocal har
mony very likely was rooted in the shape-note
singing schools, it was actually new to the moun
tains and to country music when the Family
popularized their style. Early recordings sug
gest that pioneer hillbilly groups tended to sing

our leading

portrayed

in

a

sensitive and comprehensive fash

the Carter Family and

presented

as

bv an encroaching

ley, for example, is described as providing "an
ideal situation for the preservation of the old

traditional music."

In

reality,

music had been taking shape

a

new form

of

region since
body of songs
and performing styles that combined elements
of both the Old and New South. Railroads and
at

in the

least the time of the Civil War,

a

mines had been reshaping Southwestern
Virginia, and encouraging a reformulation of its
culture, long before folklorists and A &amp; R men
coal

arrived with their pencils and recording equip
ment. It is misleading, then, for Wolfe to assert
that the Carters took "the old mountain music of
their fathers and mothers and cousins and uncles

sweeping across

old and new traits.

in

unison

or in

parallel octaves without har

mony. With the occasional exception of a duet
act such as Lester McFarland and Robert Gardner
(Mac and Bob),

whose harmony probably came

a

stressing the Appalachian origins or iden
tity of the Carter Family's music, or even in
arguing that the Carters were quintessentially

The sound that Maybelle and Sara achieved on
guitar and autoharp may evoke old-fashioned

"mountain"

feelings today, but

In

prey

to the

in

style and personality, Wolfe falls

romanticization that weallhavebeen

guilty of in our interpretations of early country
music. Most of us have been unable to resist the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

song sources, and the

impressive collection of songs and songbooks
compiled bv Gus Meade, now on deposit at the
Southern Collection at the University of North
Carolina in Chapel Hill.
The annotations are inconsistent in treatment.
Some songs receive comprehensive analysis. A
few, like "What Does the Deep Sea Say?" (for

which information exists

Meade archive),
Some remarks are
best: "Will You Miss Me When I'm

receive no discussion

in the

at all.

musings
person contemplating death.) Other
judgments are unsupported or unexplained. For
example, who are the "historians" who hold
Gussie Davis in great esteem, and who is the

mercial sources.

com

of the

mony that we value so highly, and which still
has echoes in bluegrass music, came largely

played the guitar like Maybelle did, with the
thumb playing the lead on the bass strings, and

and was learned by the Carters through

of

biography

Gone?" we are informed,

from the Carter Family and not from some an

to

student

a

curious

cient mountain vocal tradition. Instrumentally,
the Carters were also unique. No one earlier had

appealing

music. We are told that

from vaudeville or barbershop quartets, almost

general audience."

it

of

preparing

no one other than the Carter Family attempted
any kind of vocal blending. The hillbilly har

Much of the music they knew was not old at all,
was not indigenous to the Appalachian South,

and made

is

the fingers

supplying the rhythm on the treble.

it

was innovative when these

women popularized their style in the '20s.
Wolfe's discussion of A. P. Carter, a central
focus of his essay,

is

particularly shaky, and

it

of

view

at

of
of

a

corpse!"

is

"told from the point

(It is

instead the somber

a

person who described the tune of "I'm Thinking
Tonight of My Blue Eyes" as "the best known
melody in country music?" It could have been
any number of people, but they should have
been credited.
to

Given the full and informed analysis accorded
most songs, the mistakes made in other in

stances seem glaring in import. In some cases,
the mistake is made in the context of an effort to
bolster A. P.'s reputation as a songwriter. In

�discussing "Little Poplar Log House," Wolfe
speaks

of A. P.'s "familiar

images

of

home, hills,

and little cabin." The song, however, was writ
ten bv the Callahan Brothers. "You've Been a

written by the popular 19thcentury composer, Will S. Hays, is described as
"one of A. P.'s best works." "When the Spring
Friend

to

Me,"

time Comes Again," on the other hand, is cited
as a song that Sara learned from a neighbor, but
no mention

is

debtedness

to

made

of the

Stephen

C.

song's obvious in
Foster's "Gentle

Annie." The most surprising error involves "I'll
Be Home Some Day," described as one of A. P.'s
"original pieces," but which was instead the
brainchild

of

Georgia Tom Dorsey, the father

of

black gospel music. Wolfe misses an opportu
nity here to reaffirm the influence of black music
on both the Carter Family and country music,
and the chance to show how Dorsey's music

made

its

way into white music.

Although one can easily quarrel with many

of

the judgments and interpretations made in this
book, this collection remains the most important
set of old-time country music recordings made
in our time, and probably the most valuable

since the issuance in 1952 of the Harry Smith
of American Folk Music. The Smith

Anthology

Anthology, distributed by the prestigious Folk
ways label, introduced and made "respectable"
the Carter Family to the generation of listeners

caught up

in the folk

revival. The Bear Family set

probably will not exert such an influence, since
its

collections

are

aimed

at the

true believers,

those who are already fans and who have enough
money to afford their offerings. In the Shadoio of
Clinch Mountain, nevertheless,
of the

magnitude
wonderful family

contributions

reaffirms

the

made by this

of singers. But the Carters
should be stripped of romance and myth, and
should instead be valued for what they were
rural singers who tried to mix old and new

components into their style and repertoire. Far
beyond making them quaint, their imperfec
tions made them human. And think that most
of us love and listen to the Carter Family for that
I

reason.
BILL C. MALONE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�of

these selections.

marred by what

I

However, "Meg Grey"

is

refer to as "multitrack-itis,"

a

malady that causes talented, creative musicians
to put too much into a mix (distracting slide
guitar, found sounds) and produce music akin
to the disco-era mixed drinks I consumed at the
Lettuce Entertain You restaurant chain in Chi
cago during the early '70s.

Lamason displays

a

notable mastery of fourThe same attention

and six-course instruments.

to detail was devoted
to the CD packaging,
which contains striking impressionistic paint
ings of mandolins and dancers, a mouth-water
ing photograph of vintage Gibson mandolin
family instruments, and thoughtful notes that
illuminate tune sources and Chip's emotional
connection to the music. This reviewer will not

enter into

a

discussion of the relative validity of
ensembles versus live re

virtual multitracked

cordings. All Young might not be a festival
reveler's bottle of beer, but it may be someone's
cup of tea.
STEVE SENDEROFF

To Order: Chip

North

Lamason/ All Young Music, 1555

Bryan St.,
chessae@aol.com

Arlington,

VA

22201;

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Little

Pleasures

of Life

Bayou Seco
Zerx Records

Jeanie

McLerie:

lead

St

harmony vocals, 5-string

Keppeler/White fiddles; Ken Keppeler: 1 and 3-rozo
diatonic accordion, Keppeler fiddle, harmonica, vo
cal, and Thornbird fretless banjo; Scott Mathis: Gre
gory mandolin and mandola, vocal and harmony
vocals; Linda Askew: guitar, vihuela
Little Pleasures of Life/Cabibi to Cuba/Mabel's
Waltz/Git Along Little Dogies/Santa Rosa Pro
cessional/Going Away /MoonlightChotis; Chile

Verde/Linda's Valse Linda/Forky

Deer/

Mercredi Soir/Passe Reel de Marcantel; Polka
de Rapho/The Thing That Makes You Beautiful/

Cleo'sRedondo/CuadrillaJosefinita/TorodeOnce
Never being one to look at liner notes before
listening, assumed this was a Cajun band from
their name and at first hearing, was disappointed.
However, Bayou Seco states in the first sentence
of their liner notes that this CD is an eclectic mix
of 14 tunes from a number of different traditions
I

(Cajun, Norteno, old-time, cowboy, and TexMex) along with some original tunes. After reading
the notes, I was able to listen more fairly to
Little Pleasures of Life.

My personal preference in folk lnusic is for
tunes that make me want to stand up and dance
or to be moved by some powerful emotion. I did
did find a mellow, competent
ensemble that works well together. The music is
not find that here.

I

very melodic and pretty, mixed with more em
phasis on the high and mid-ranges and less on
the bass.
The vocals are steady and comfortable, with
Ms McLerie singing as well as any current Cajun
female singer, relaxed, and non-pretentious. The

band sound
ant, and

is predominantly of strings, pleas
without much variance in texture or

drive. The most dynamic cut is the "Mercredi
Soir Passe /Reel de Marcantel," which begins

with fiddle and harmonica, switches to voice
and harmonica, and ends with a pulsing reel.
"Forky Deer" is the 5-part version from
Tennessee fiddler Charlie Bowman. I enjoyed
hearing new parts to an old standard. The polka
"Chile Verde" is lively, with a nice bounce to it,
The

as is the "Polka de Rapho."
It is

obvious from the notes, which are suc
that the musicians love

cinct and informative,

the music they collect and play. What their CD
offers is exactly what it says, Little Pleasures of Life.
NIKKI LEE

Records, 725 Van Buren PI SE,
NM
87108; bayouseco@aol.com;
Albuquerque

To order: Zerx

mandowork@aol.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Ricky Skaggs and Tony Rice were two young
men with great promise when they teamed up to
make these recordings. This tribute to the roots

bluegrass is now a classic and has been reis
in newly re-mastered in 24-bit audio. They
had both been members of J.D. Crowe's New
of

sued

South,

a

trend setting bluegrass band

Ricky would go on

to be

a

top-40 country star

would explore the nuances

and Tony

in the '70s.

of

acoustic

string jazz.
Here the two get down to the soulful songs
with which both had probably grown up. They
trade leads with their voices and instruments, in
fully updating the duet format. Yes, there are

elements

bluegrass, but they do not run over
a point of
departure for
endless noodling. This is some of the most re
strained playing ever recorded by Rice. Skaggs'
mandolin is crisp, clean, and understated. On
of

the songs or use them for

"More Pretty Girls than One," Tony sings lead
and plays lead guitar while Ricky does some real

subtle guitar back up. When Tony gets down
vocally, Ricky, quietly eggs him on. On "Talk
about Suffering," they take
nail it cold.
This

is

it

on

a

cappella and

classic recording, not because these

a

are two of the most

important bluegrass artists
because they stripped

of the '70s and '80s, but

their music to its roots and sang it as soulfully as
anyone else had ever done. The one instrumen
tal,

"Tennessee Blues,

Monroe recorded
If

vou are

find this

a

a

"

is

the first instrumental

for RCA Victor on

October

7,

Bill

1940.

fan of the brother duets, you will

rewarding listening experience. The

one down side

when record

is that the LP

came out

at a

time

thought the 10 cuts
were better than the old standard of 12. This CD
only has a little over 27 minutes of music on it.
That is a shame.
companies

BOB BUCKINGHAM

Sugar Hill Records, Inc., PO Box 55300, Durham,
NC 27717-5300

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�place,

know what such jams feel and sound

I

like, and this photograph masterfully stirs those
old memories, helping me to recall the wonderful

music often heard

at just

such golden moments.

Conversely, a photograph on page 45 sum
marizes far better than the proverbial thousand
words ever could the ethos of the oft-heard term
it does a Christmas
OH tavern where the music,

"gig from hell," picturing as
in

a

Columbus,

provided by a band ensconced on a postage
stamp sized, tinsel trimmed stage, led by guitar
ist Bennie Fields, seems to serve primarily as
background noise for one of those deranged,
alcohol fuelled rituals such occasions often pro
duce. The fewer than fifteen patrons' attention is
largely focussed on two hot pants clad revelers

indeterminate age and sex, executing some
barroom variant of the frug, bird, or watusi
of

maybe

all three at once. Any
such a gig, or any fan,

played
a favorite band

to all its

musician who has
who has followed

regular gigs, has prob

ably experienced at least one such evening. Those
that haven't need only to see this photograph.

My temple aches as I gaze upon it. Suffice it to
say, no matter what music the band is playing,

images

of

mother and dad, the little old log cabin
the church

in the lane,

lonely mound
Paradise Lost

of clay

I

but

Of course,

or

gone from the minds of
that bar on that night.
might be

are long

the patrons in

mistaken

wildwood, that
other evocations of

in the

I

don't think so.

between those two extremes lies

lots of territory, and it is covered admirably by
Carl Fleischauer's hard edged black and white

photographs. Neil Rosenberg's text and their
combined captions provide enough historical
context to remind us what we're looking at. The
period covered by the photographs in this book
was the period of greatest growth in popularity
of the music. It documents the occasional colli
sion of cultures that is inevitable when the art of
minority subculture is taken up by some extent
by a mainstream middle class (for that, among
other things, is what happened to bluegrass
music during this time). Many of the photo
graphs are ironic, humorous, and filled with
a

pathos
band

same time, such as the image of a
energetically playing full tilt to a lone
at the

audience member,
sign exhorting her

winsome attempt

little girl sitting behind a
BEHIND ROPE," a
control a nonexistent crowd.

a

to "STAY
to

There are also many photos of bands of the day,
prominent and otherwise, in performance, a

many of
particular strength of Fleischauer's
these photos will be familiar to longtime readers
of Bluegrass Unlimited and similar publications.
A couple of my favorites in this category are of
two legendary southeast bands whose like will
not soon pass this way again: one, the Stoneman
Family, featuring featuring Patsy, Donna, and
Roni in white naugahyde go-go boots, fringed
vests and miniskirts; the other, the gospel group
The Lewis Family, the sisters' beehives at strict

attention and banjoist brother Little Roy beside
them in full cry. The Stonemans no longer per

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

form regularly as a group, but The Lewis Family
does, and Little Roy Lewis may be the hardest
in show business, now that James
Brown has slowed down, as this photo helps
document. Collectively, these photos serve to

working man

remind

us that perceptions of what constitutes
entertainment has always provided food
for thought in the bluegrass community.
The photographs are organized by six chapter
headings. The first, "Intensity," features photos
that illustrate either the interplay among band
members in action or the emotional exchange
art and

between the performers and their audiences.
"Destination," the second chapter focuses on
search for authentic blue-

the book's creators'

grass experience. This search is documented by
photos of performances and jam sessions in

all around America, as well as work
shops, stores, offices, and homes and businesses
of various artists, craftsmen, journalists, and
others who ply the bluegrass trade in one way or

venues

another

(J.D. Crowe's trailer, Esco Hankins'
record store, George Gruhn's repair shop, Bill
Monroe's old homeplace, and many more, in
cluding barber shop jams, festivals, and venues

well known and hardly known alike).
"Transactions" focuses on money changing
ventures, be it from instrument swapping, sell
ing records, ticket taking, tape recording

performances

for

live

recordings, broadcasting,

or

artist management.

"Community"

features photos that empha

size the extended family aspect of the bluegrass
scene, while "Family" emphasizes actual family
this chapter includes many outstand
groups
ing photos of family groups, from the aforemen
tioned Stoneman and Lewis clans to The
Saucemans to Red Allen and his sons (a great

shot of him, Greg, and a very young Harley
Allen), to Earl Scruggs and sons to Ralph Stanley
and his young daughters to Jim and Jesse to The
McClain Family to Clarence and Roland White,
and many more.
The final chapter, "The Monroe Myth," is
about Big Mon himself, William Smith Monroe,
as it inevitably must be. He appears here in
various photos to be alternately regal, remote,
engaging, folksy, adored, exasperated, and dis
engaged. Naturally enough, given co-author

Rosenberg's long, close professional relation
ship with The Father of Bluegrass, Monroe's role
in the growth of the music is emphasized, but
probably not out

of

proportion

to his

impor

tance, considering the number of greats who
apprenticed with him, many of whom are docu
mented in the photos, and considering his omni

present influence on the actual bluegrass scene
during the years documented here.
If you were involved in the bluegrass scene
during these years, a close examination of this
book is guaranteed to bring fond memories back
in a rush. If you weren't, and want to know what
it

was back like then, this

is an

ideal place

to

begin your exploration.
RANDY PITTS

�a
lovely modern com
position sung beautifully by Patty Loveless.

and Bobby McMillon, and

The Country Gentlemen On the Road

(and more)-

Country Gentlemen; Smithsonian Folkways CD
SFW 40133; reissue of this classic bluegrass band's
1963 Folkways LP plus excerpts from three live
concerts in 1961-1963.
Newport Folk Festival Best of Bluegrass 1959-66various artists; Vanguard 3-CDs 197/89-2; Van
guard 79586-2; 2700 Pennsylvania Ave., Santa

Monica, CA 90404; www.VanguardRecords; in
cludes Hylo Brown, Stanley Bros., Lester Flatt &amp;
Earl Scruggs;

Don Stover, Hazel

&amp;

Alice, Bill

Monroe, Lilly Bros, and Jim &amp; Jesse.
Up In the Woods-JohnReischman;CorvusRecords
CR006; PO box 19655, Centre Point Postal

Vancouver,

V5T

Out

604-251-7655;
shadow9@direct.ca; also distributed by Rounder
Records; some fine mandolin playing on origi
let,

BC,

4EZ;

nal ma terial with fine support from Todd Phillips.
Gabe Witcher, Jim Nunally, Dennis Caplinger,
Scott Nygaard, Nick Hornbuckle, Rob Ickes,
Kathy Kallick, and John Miller.

Barnstormin'- James Reams

&amp; The

Barnstormers;

Copper Creek CD 0195; "An eclectic mix of
bluegrass standards, novel instrumental, and
exciting new songs."
Folk Mountain Concert-78RFM; 78RPM1827;
ruralrecords@aol.com; 206-706-4534; www.y78rpm.com; some fine classic bluegrass from this
northwest band.
The

Rough

RGNET

Guide

1059;

to Bluegrass-various
artists;
No Problem Productions, 201-

433-3907; noprob@mindspring.com; a compila
tion of bluegrass artists' recordings and includes

Hazel Dickens, Country Gentlemen,
Stanley, and others.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ralph

�flLD-TIMt

FROM

j,

SLOW JAM FOR

OLD-TIME MUSIC
Back-up Practice Tracks for
14

Great Tunes

with Marcy Marxer, guitar; Cathy
Fink, banjo; Bruce Molsky, fiddle;

David Schatz, bass
CD

$19.95

Ideas, Advice and Music

two-video series

$49.95

$29.95 each video
SOUTHERN OLD-TIME
FIDDLE TOUR
And In-Depth Lesson in
Traditional Styles

taught by Bruce Molsky

SOUTHERN BANJO STYLES

taught by Mike Seeger
A two-video series $49.95

OLD-TIME FIDDLE
taught by Brad Leftwich

two-video series

$59.95

ESSENTIAL TECHNIQUES
FOR MANDOLIN
taught by Chris Thile

$29.95

From Old-Time to Bluegrass

taught by Ralph Stanley

LEARN TO PLAY

A

$39.95

Homespun

VIDeO

340-OT, WOODSTOCK, NY 12498

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

DOC'S GUITAR
Fingerpicking and Flatpicking
taught by Doc Watson $39.95
LEARN TO PLAY
CAJUN ACCORDION

taught by Dirk Powell
A two-video series
$49.95
$29.95 each video

Video One: $39.95; Video Two: $29.95

THE BANJO OF RALPH STANLEY

BOX

VOCAL TECHNIQUES
FOR OLD-TIME
MOUNTAIN MUSIC
taught by Cary Fridley $19.95

$29.95 each video

THE BANJO ACCORDING TO
JOHN HARTFORD
A

INSPIRATION
HOMESPUN VIDEO ■M

GUITAR STYLES OF
THE CARTER FAMILY

taught

by Mike

Seeger $29.95

FINGERSTYLE ARRANGEMENTS
FOR HYMNS, SPIRITUALS AND
SACRED SONGS
taught by Happy Traum
A

two-video series

$29.95

$29.95 each video

LEARN TO PLAY
CAJUN FIDDLE

LEARNING

taught

by Michael

Doucet

$39.95
TO ORDER

CALL 1-800-33-TAPES

(845) 246-2550

FAX (845)

FREE CATALOG

246-5282

$49.95

MOUNTAIN DULCIMER
taught by David Schnaufer
$39.95
ORDER ONLINE

www.homespuntapes.com

�Art

the
of

BluMjrass

The Bill Monroe

Reader
EDITED

BY

TOM EWING
"Excellent.
ing

intrigu
interviews

Especially
the

are

various

conducted with Monroe throughout
his career.
Swing's years with
Monroe

Blue Grass Boy] and
in-depth research add much to the
pieces as he corrects misinforma
[as

a

tion or expounds

upon the history."

Jonathan Colcord,
Country Standard Time

Available

cloth for $29.95

Also of interest

Bluegrass Odyssey

Pickin' on Peachtree

Documentary in Pictures
and Words, 1966-86
CARL FLEISCHIIAUER
AND NEIL V. ROSENBERG

A

"Striking photographs.

in

History of Country Music
in Atlanta Georgia
WAYNE W. DANIEL

A

Those pictures reflect

New

in

passion, commitment and simple pleasure of
performers and fans alike, supporting the notion
that a good weekend of bluegrass music can make
a believer of anyone."

paperback for $19.95

the

Richard Harrington, Washington Post
Available in cloth for $34.95

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ILLiNOiS

to

order, call (800) 545-4703

or

visit

www.press.uillinois.edu

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12491">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time&lt;/em&gt; Herald, Volume 8, Number 1 (Fall 2001)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12492">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12493">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 8, Number 1 (August-October 2001). Identified on cover as Volume 7, Number 9.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“John Hartford – Reminiscences,” by David Potori&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“A Walk Through Felts Park,” by Nancy Sluys&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Musical Affairs of the Heart – Banjo Stories,” by Gail Gillespie&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dance Beat – The Squeal Index – Can Old-Time Bands Make It On the Contra Dance Scene?,” by Joyce Cauthen&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old-Time Music on the Radio,” by John Lupton&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – The NAMM Show 2001,” by Bob Smakula&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Glen Smith; Lou Ella Menard; Wilson “Boozoo” Chavis; Danny Poullard; and Bob Douglas;&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12494">
              <text>2001</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2783">
      <name>2001</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2979">
      <name>Bob Douglas</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5572">
      <name>Bob Smakula</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5994">
      <name>Danny Poullard</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5989">
      <name>David Potori</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5672">
      <name>Gail Gillespie</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5991">
      <name>Glen Smith</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5988">
      <name>John Hartford</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5939">
      <name>John Lupton</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="3510">
      <name>Joyce Cauthen</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5992">
      <name>Lou Ella Menard</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5990">
      <name>Nancy Sluys</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5993">
      <name>Wilson “Boozoo” Chavis</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
