<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2590" public="1" featured="1" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2590?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:53:42+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3524">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/875e5369b291b7687345411ab2b91f0a.pdf</src>
      <authentication>3d74bee5fc51542586a1503223f0349f</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12501">
                  <text>THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC
2,

8,

VOLUME

2002

WINTER

NUMBER

A

$6.00

Banjo On Her
Knee: Part 1
APPALACHIAN WOMEN
AND AMERICA'S

Sense

Issues

In

ALSO

THIS ISSUE

IN

Old-Time

of

at

Music:
Place

Texas

Mt.

Contest

Dance Beat Here &amp; There Workshop
Expanded Holiday Reviews

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Rogers

School

Style-Problems?

Lynch

a

David

Preserving

Design:

The Albert Hash Memorial Band:

www.lynchgraphics.com
ynchgraphics.com

FIRST INSTRUMENT

Cover

A

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dear Friends,
Our thoughts are with you

during these difficult times
especially with those who lost

friends and loved ones
on
Sept. 11, 2001.

--The

Old-Time Herald

�COMING IN THE NEXT
ISSUE OF THE OTH
Women Banjo Players
Part

2

Del Na Sango Fiddlers

Volo Bogtrotters

Reviews /Dance Beat
&amp; More!

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.

51812/1812 House Avenue
Durham, NC 27707
Phone &amp; Fax: 919-402-8495

PO Box

E-mail:

oth@mindspring.com

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR

Alice Gerrard
ASSOCIATE EDITOR
William N. Hicks
CONTRIBUTING

EDITORS

Phil Jamison,

Bob Smakula, Bob Carlin, Gail
Gillespie, Tim Thompson
ADVISORY

BOARD

Ray Alden, Mac Benford, Hazel Dickens, Hilary
Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher, Ramona Jones, Garrison
Keillor, Pete Kuykendall, Brad Leftwich, W. K.
McNeil, Lee Smith, Pete Sutherland, Joe Thompson,

Charles Wolfe
OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP,

INC.

BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Sally Council, Nancy Gottovi, Charlie Gravel,

Sheppard,

Jim Watson, Kathy World,

David

Donald Zepp

ASSISTANT: Katherine Meehan

ADMINISTRATIVE

ADVERTISING:

Katherine Meehan

VOLUNTEERS: April McGreger, Andrea
Ford Summerlin

&amp;

Barry

COMPUTER CONSULTANT: Dan Peck
WEB SITE: Charlie Gravel

No part of this magazine may be reproduced in any
form without written permission from the publisher.
Not responsible for loss or non-return of unsolicited
photos or manuscripts. 2001 the Old-Time Herald. The
Old-Time Herald (ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672)

is

pub

lished quarterly the first of August, November, Febru
ary, and May by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc., 1812
House Ave., Durham, NC 27707. Subscription rates
payable
tions

in

advance. One year: $20 (foreign subscrip

Library/Institutional rate: one year:
$25. Classified ads cost 35 cents per word, minimum of
$5. Any grouping of letters or numbers is counted as
$25 U.S.).

one word. All classified
first of the month,

ads must be received by the

two months prior to publication.
paid at Durham, NC 27701 and

Periodical postage
additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send change of
address to the Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham,
NC 2771 7. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is a not-forprofit, tax-exempt corporation under section 501 (c) (3)
of the Internal Revenue Code.
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love of

old-time music. Old-time music grassroots, or home
grown music and dance shares origins, influences
and musical characteristics with roots musics through
out America. Our magazine, the Old-Time Herald, casts
a wide net, highlighting
the Southeastern tradition
while opening its pages to kindred and comparable
traditions and new directions. It provides enlightening
articles and in-depth reviews, opportunities for musi
cal learning and sharing, and a forum for addressing
the issues and questions that bear upon the field. Rec
ognizing that in roots music ideas and values of many
kinds commingle, we strive to represent our interests
democratically and to embody the best ideals of race,
gender, and generational balance in a context of free
and open discussion.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The

Old-Time Herald welcomes letters. They

should
with

a

be typed or neatly written and signed
return address given. If you send them

by email, be sure and include your return
address. We DO NOT print anonymous let
ters. Letters may be edited, and we will print

them according to space available. The opin
ions expressed do not necessarily reflect those
of the

Old-Time Herald.

�Mountaineers, The Hushpuppies, the Pied
mont Bogtrotters, Man Alive!, Old Blue,
Piedmont Polecats, the Landfill Ramblers,
the

Statesville Highballers and some that

make up a name on the spot. The Implica
tions and Reel Shady are two popular bands
that play more New England style. The danc
ers seem to love them all. We dance contras

and squares

depending on the caller.

Dancers expect more of the "tricks" when

but for a
they go to a dance weekend
local
dance
for
are
$5.00,
weekly
they
happy
to groove with the old-time. I must admit
that most contra dancers will go to ex

tremes to dance to Wild Asparagus and
other highly popular bands but there are
few of us who truly love old-time music.
Old-time bands can punch up tunes with
the basics you mentioned for playing a
a

dance, but to me (and I'm not the norm)
there's nothing like that old-time groove of

"Candy Girl"

or

"Sandy Boys" to put me

on another plane. Some change-up, some
medleys are good, but I wouldn't want to
see old-time try to imitate the avant garde
bands that take arhythmic flights of fancy
and tease the dancers with barely audible

portions of the tune, then kick them hard
squeal. Frankly, I feel manipulated.
I said, I'm not the norm, but I would
love to see more old-time music on the
for

a

As

than the dancers,

dance circuit. Thank goodness for all the
great musicians and callers in our area who
give their time, talent and energy to our

but they really love
to see their music

dances. It's

motion

great moment when the band,
the caller, and the dancers come together.
Old-time musicians may love the tune more
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

set the dancers in

and

they
they can tell
when the groove is
say

right

the dancers

float just
above the floor. This
kind of magic doesn't

begin

to

register on

a

squeal

scale.
Carol Thompson
Fiddle and Bow Country Dancers
Greensboro, NC

�Hootenanny holler
Purveyors of Folk
dog

-eat-

A

dog CD

Beyond

prices

Secure Online Shopping
reviews, sound clips, charts
drop on by we're always here

www. hootholler.com
accepting CDs

post your review

musc@hootholler com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�the translation to CD, and we all are well
aware that music which strikes emotional
in some people doesn't affect other
folks at all.
We have read many reviews of CDs in
this magazine, and most discuss the types
of music played, where the music came

chords

from and /or from whom

it was learned,
musicians, and fi
nally, whether the reviewer feels that the
musicians have accomplished their goal of
passing on the traditional music that they
have learned. The OTH normally reviews
CDs to inform readers of the music avail

the background

of the

able in this little corner of the music market

know what is out there.
know Bayou Seco presents a problem for
reviewers as we play quite obscure types of
American old-time music. This makes it
even more essential that a review include
what the music is, and where it comes
from. Concerning another of our CDs, one
of your reviewers told us that he felt un
comfortable reviewing music about which
he knew so little, but nonetheless, he did a
thoughtful and informative review.
I thank
Ms. Lee for her review and the
OTH for including our CD in the review
section (we are charter subscribers) Maybe
now the readers will have a better idea of
what music is on this CD and from whence
that
it comes. By the way, I understand
so that the readers
I

a jam at Clifftop this year of
people playing O'odham (Gu-achi) music
and some Spanish Colonial music. Perhaps
some of those folks would like to know that
those types of music are on this CD, played
bv the folks who collected them.

there was quite

Ken Keppeler and Jeanie McLerie,

Silver City, New Mexico

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was similarly fired. Also let go were other
members of the library staff. Two other
individuals involved with the new tourism

department "resigned."
According to HOF director Kyle Young,
this is part of a restructuring in which the
emphasis of the HOF will be more toward
glitzy, high profile efforts involving cur
rent hot stars. In doing so, it seems to be
that the HOF is abandoning its original
mission statement of preserving the his
and possibly com
tory of country music
its
status
as
a
promising
non-profit educa
tional institution. At present, there is only
one person really working in the library
and archives
a pleasant and well-trained
archivist, but one who knows little about
country music, or about the world class
archives they have there. She routinely
called on Ronnie or Bob Pinson for help in
finding things and answering queries from
researchers.
Which brings up a secondary effect of
this cold action. Bob Pinson [see OTH ar
ticles by Marshall Wyatt in vol. 6 nos. 4 and
5], the dean of country music discographers and legendary historian, an expert
who has through the years selflessly helped
many of us in our research, had been work
ing part time as he eases into retirement.
But now he says
and this is a quote

�"when they cut their ties with Ronnie, they
cut their ties with me." The great country

music discography manuscript, some 15
years in the making, was within a day's
work of completion. Bob begged Paul
to at least let
Ronnie help him finish this, but was turned
down. The manuscript was left sitting on

Kingsbury and Kyle Young

Ronnie's desk.

Its fate is

uncertain.

Staffers also fleel that The Journal of Coun
try Music will be changed from its present
form and stripped of any historical mate
rial, and turned into a slick, Garthian fan

magazine full of eye candy for the high
rollers who contribute to the HOF. Chris
Dickinson, who gave her heart and soul
into making the Journal a quality publica
tion that would attract scholars as well as
newsstand readers, feels crushed and

angry. She is planning to return to Chi
cago soon, where she earned her origi
nal reputation

as

a

tough, insightful

journalist.
a story about this
Tennessean, but it ran

We were able to plant
in the

Nashville's

The

Wednesday morning, amidst all the cover
age of the WTC disaster. Nonetheless, it
did alert some people in the music
community about what had transpired.
It turns out that the HOF Board of Direc
tors had not even told about

this

"new

vision" and change of direction, and some
of them were quite upset. They met in
emergency session last Thursday, but
Kyle Young was able to defer their

criticism by insisting they were trying
to "micro-manage."

The HOF powers are hoping that they
will weather this storm and protest and in
a week or so go back to business as usual. I

hope this does not happen, and several of
locally are trying to determine what
steps can be taken. Essentially, the Hall of

us

sitting on the world's finest archive of
country music, and not properly curating it.
Several of you have asked me if you
Fame

is

could write somebody. For now, you might
consider faxing your thoughts to either
Marty Stuart, the honorary board chair
man, or to Bruce Hinton, the actual chair
man of the board. Their fax numbers are:
Marty Stuart, c/o Rothbaum and Garner:
615-259-1107; Bruce Hinton: 615-880-7450.
Chris Skinker is putting together a fuller
list of addresses and we will forward it
later to those interested.
I'm not sure that much can be done to
reverse this situation, but I think we owe a

(continued

on next

page)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

debt to Ronnie Pugh and Bob Pinson for all
their good help over the years. We owe it to
them to at least try.
Charles Wolfe
Murfreesboro,

TN

�Norman

Blake's

laid back singing. The
versions
of "Man of Con
retro-bluegrass
stant Sorrow," the reworking of other field
recordings, and the inclusion of the early
Stanley Brothers "Angel Band" have refocused the image of country music away
from the dominant Nashville Sound, and to

wards the broad, open field of old-time music.
The film, Song Catcher
despite its issue

correctness

wooden

somewhat

and

has presented

some great

scriptwriting
old-style ballad singing. It took something
which was held dear to so few of us and
placed

it in

front of the movie-going public.

We can't begin to measure the positive
repercussions of this, but it sure feels good
to realize that our persistence and belief in
this excellent music has been
and

disseminated well beyond

recognized
its

previous

borders.
Finally, Jim Brown's "American Roots
Music" series which plays on four consecu
tive nights in October and November has
undertaken

to

create

down-home

a

broad encyclopedia

music including Cajun,
Norteno, Native American, gospel, blues,
old-time, bluegrass, and Nashville, along
with Lead Belly, Woody Guthrie, and the
folk revival. It is a survey of the 20th cen
tury seen through archival footage, told as
of

a

series of short stories and great music. As

usual with a PBS production, it focuses a lot
more on innovators and stars, and less on
back porch musicians than this writer
would have it, but the net effect is to bring
great awareness and respect for the vigor
ous spirit which flows through all these
traditions. In 1965, proposed a TV show
along these lines to CBS News. It was can
1

celled, because according

to a CBS

(continued

executive,
on page 16)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here &amp; There

Events
The Green Grass
21 at the

Cloggers celebrated

Reunion the weekend

their 30th

of Oct. 19-

Lake Eden Arts Festival in Black

Mountain, NC.
The 2002 Dewey Balfa Cajun and Cre
ole Heritage Week will be held Apr. 14-21.
Info:info@lafolkroo ts.org; LouisianaFolkRoots,
Inc., PO Box 389, Breaux Bridge, LA 70517.

14th Ralph Page Dance Legacy
Weekend will be held Jan. 18 at the Durham
The

campus of the University of New Hamp
shire. It will feature traditional and con
temporary contra dancing and square danc
ing, including many old favorites from the
New England dance repertoire. Info: 603-

659-7038/463-7771/664-2513;

New En

gland Dance Legacy Weekend, c/ o NEFF A,
1950 Mass. Ave., Cambridge, MA 02140.
The influence of German and Swiss

set

tlers on the arts and crafts of the Virginia

highlands is showcased in a new exhibit at
Ferrum College's Blue Ridge Institute &amp;
Museum, the State Center for Blue Ridge
Folklore. "The German Legacy in South
west Virginia Decorative Arts" runs

through March 2002. Admission is free.
Located on Route 40 on the campus of
Ferrum College, the Blue Ridge Institute &amp;
Museum includes gallery exhibits and a
living history farm museum. The galleries

-Jan. includes the NC Musicians Festival,
info:
Nov.
9,
NC,
Hickory,

acoustic_stage@w31ink.com; Storytelling
Festival at David Eccles Conference Cen
ter, Ogden, UT, Nov. 12-14, info:

www.weber.edu/storytelling;

Our State

Magazine, Jan. 4-5, Grove Park Inn,
Asheville, NC; w/ Doc Watson, Newberry
Opera House, Newberry, SC, Jan. 6, info:
www.newberryoperahouse.com, 803-2765179; school shows in Huntsville, AL, Feb.
Story, Trinity United Method

22; Tell Me

a

ist Church,

Huntsville, AL, Feb. 22-24, 256-

883-3200. For general info on David's schedule,

www.davidholt.com.
Paul &amp; Win Grace's performing sched
ule includes: Shelbina, MO Nov. 16, info:

call 828-628-1728 or

Wendy

Brumbaugh,

660-278-4221;

wendyb@marktwain.net; Columbia, MO
Nov. 30, Old-Time Country Dance, info:
Jim Thaxter, 573-874-2792, Kathy Gordon,
kgordon@coin.org;
info: 573-874-7465.

Columbia, MO Dec. 31,
Updates and general info

on the Grace Family can be found on their web
site:

www.gracefamilymusic.com.
A tribute to NC fiddler Red Wilson was
the highlight of the annual Music in the
Mountains Festival in September sponsored
by the Toe River Arts Council. Also per
forming at the festival were Trevor and
Travis Stuart, Rhonda Gouge, Bruce

open Mondays through Saturdays, 10
a.m. to 4:30 p.m., year-round; and Sundays,

Greene and Rob Levin, The Wisemans,
Clarence Green, Jr. &amp; Eric Ellis, and the

p.m., mid-May through mid- August.
For more information call 540-365-4416 or visit

River Arts

are

1

to 4:30

www.blueridgeinstitute.org.
The 2002 Portland (OR) Old-Time Gath
ering will be held Jan. 11-12 somewhere
around the Portland area and will include

concerts, jamming, workshops, square
dancing, song sessions, etc. Info:

www.bubbaguitar.com/festival.
Artists
Leela and Ellie Grace will be teaching
harmony and percussive dance at Berea

Dance Week in Berea, KY Dec. 26-31. Info:

Joe Tarter,

859-986-1986, www.berea.edu/

dance/ dancehome.htm.
general

info on Leela

For updates and
and Ellie Grace:

www.gracefamilymusic.com.

David Holt's touring schedule for Nov.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Burnsville Cloggers.

For info, on the Toe

Council, write PO Box 882,
Burnsville, NC 28714.
Fiddler Lee Stripling, son of Alabama
fiddler Charlie Stripling, was featured in a

an article on the Kee

family in the June Folk
of the Charlotte

the newsletter

Calendar,
Folk Society. Info: PO Box 36864, Charlotte,

NC 28236-6864; www.folksociety.org.
Bob Bovee and Gail Heil's tour sched
ule takes them to the Ozark Folk Center,

Mountain View, AR Nov. 2-3; Columbia,
MO Public Library Nov. 7; Bothy Folk Club,
Mankato, MN Nov. 10; Roselle, IL Public
Library Nov. 18; Chicago Bam Dance at the
Abbey Pub, Nov. 19; and First Night, Grand
Forks, ND, Dec. 31. Info: bobngail@means.net.
The Big

Medicine string band will

performing in Greensboro, NC Dec.
Down East Folklore Society Dance,

1;

be

the

Beau

fort, NC Feb. 15; on the WPAQ Merry-GoRound, Apr. 20 in Mt. Airy, NC. Info:

kenejackson@earthlink.net
Jody Stecher &amp; Kate Brislin were busy
in the fall with a series of concerts in Min
nesota for the Minnesota Bluegrass &amp; OldTime Music Assoc. The New Lost City Ram
blers also performed at a MBOTMA winter
concert early this month. Info, on MBOTMA
canbeformdatwww.minnesotabluegrass.org.
The Wolfe Bros, old-time string band
will perform in concert in Elkton, MD on Apr.
6. Info: 410-620-5280 or 800-246-3319.
In

In School &amp; On the Net
book of photographs by John Cohen

Print,
A

taken over the past 48 years, There Is No
has justbeen
Eye: John Cohen Photographs,

released by powerHouse publications. "The
book covers lots of old-time musicians and
puts them in the context of the American
cultural scene as I observed it," says John,
Info:

powerHouse Books,

180 Varick St.,

New York, NY 10014; 212-604-

June feature story in the Seattle Times. His

Ste. 1302,

daughter, Sherry Stripling, who is a staff
reporter for the Times, wrote the article.
Brad Leftwich performed at the 13th
Annual Harrietville Bluegrass &amp; Tradi

9074;

tional Country Music Convention in Aus
tralia in October.
The Kee Family and Ruth Kee Wherry

video segment that Alan Jabbour she
demonstrating Henry Reed bowing pat
at
online
is
now
terns
http:/,

were recipients of the 2001 Charlotte (NC)
Folk Society Heritage award in June. Fid
dler John D. Kee played with many bands
during the '40s and '50s including J.E.
Mainer and His Rambling Mountaineers
and The Tar Heel Cornshuckers. There is

memory.loc.gov/ammem/hrhtml,

hrjabbour.html. The Henry Reec
homepage is at http://memory.loc.gov
ammem/hrhtml.
WAMU-FM in Washington, DC, with

www.powerHouseBooks.com.

PineCone, the Piedmont Council of Tra
ditional Music (Raleigh, NC) web site is a1

http://www.pinecone.org/.
A

longtime history of old-time and bluegras:

�music programming, eliminated week day
bluegrass music programming in favor of NPR
news and talk line-up The stationis launching
web site at www.countrybluegrass.org,
which will broadcast country and bluea

grass music 24 hours a day.
Reel Times is a publication of the Austin
Friends of Traditional Music. It has listings
and notices of local music and dance events
in and around Austin, TX. Info: 512-305-

The NC string band Big Medicine has

new web site

at

There was a cover story on NC mandolinist Tony Williamson by Brian Stine in
the Sept. 13 issue of Triad Style. Info:

www.triadstyle.com/ cover.html.
The Mid Columbia Folklore Society in
Hood River, OR publishes a newsletter
where you can find information on local
events in that area. Info: PO Box 1623,

9838; aftm@egroups.com;

Hood River, .OR 97031;

aftm

www.gorge.net/community/mcfs.

www.main.org/
aftmhome.htm; POBox419608, Aus

tin, TX 78765.

folknik

is

a

publication

Fran

of the San

cisco Folk Music Club and is a good source
for many Bay Area music events. Info:

sffolk@aol.com; 415-661-2217; 885 Clayton
St., San Francisco, CA 94117.
OTH volunteer, volcanologist, and mu
sician, April McGreger has a new web page:

www.unc.edu/mcgreger/.
Dick

Kimmel's clawhammer banjo

tablature book Dick Kimmel- Fisliin Creek
Blues ClawhammerBanjo Tablatures was

a

www.bigmedmusic.com.

541-352-7550;

The Folk Project News letter contains all
sorts of information about what's happen
ing in acoustic music in and around New

York

New

and

Jersey.

Info:

www.folkproject.org.
For

events

in and

around Albuquerque

NM, the FolkMADS Calendar and Notes is
your best bet. PO Box 40421, Albuquerque,

NM 87196-042; filatoff@cybermesa.com;

www.folkmads.org.

'

released in September by Mel Bay Publica

tions. This is the companion book for the

recording, Dick Kimmel -Fishin' Creek Blues
Copper Creek Records CC-0173. Info:
kirnmel@newulmtel.net; www.newulmtel.net/
-kimmel.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Recordings, Instruments

&amp;

Labels

The NC-based Hushpuppies have produced
CD, Hushpuppies

"

a

which was released in Au

gust Info: www.old97wrecords.com/
hushpuppies; stoutemt@wfu.edu.
Tom, Brad &amp; Alice have a new CD on
(continued

on page 16)

�Dance Beat

"Square Dancing"

in

Haywood County, North Carolina

by Phil Jamison

square dancing has long been

part of
Old-time
a

the cultural heritage of the

Appalachian Mountains, yet nowadays in
western North Carolina, as throughout the

Appalachian

region,

community-based

square dances are few and far between.

Haywood County, in particular, has his
torically been a square-dancing mecca.
Older dancers tell me that years ago, dances
were held six nights a week at various

20th centuries, square dancing was an inte
gral part of social life in the southern moun

tains Lack of paved roads meant that trans
portation was difficult and made for tight-

knit communities.

Dances, often called

shindigs, hoedowns, or frolics, were often
held whenever the community gathered
together. Dances took place at house par
ties during Christmas and other holidays,
at weddings, and after corn shuckings, barn

other "work
came
locals
which
the
at
together to
ings"
a
help
neighbor.
The typical story of these gatherings in

locations around the county. I've wondered
what happened to this vibrant dance com
munity and why these dances no longer

raisings, molasses making,

found elsewhere in the southern moun
tains, I know of none in Haywood or the
other counties in the Asheville area.

cludes a meal after the work followed by
music and dancing long into the night.
Sometimes dances were held in a schoolhouse or in an empty barn before the to
bacco was hung to dry but most often, they
took place in homes. With the furniture

exist. While community square dances can

be

summer months, there are still street

In tire

Waynesville, Hendersonville, and at
Shindig-on-the-Green in Asheville, but these
dances

in

done on pavement, which is a poor
substitute for a real dance floor. And though
some local dancers may attend, these street
dances mainly attract tourists and chil
are

dren, and

at

best only serve as

a

or

removed and the rug rolled back, the larg
est room would be cleared for dancing.
Musicians would sometimes be situated in

doorway, accommodating dancers in two
adjacent rooms. As many dancers as could
a

the space (sometimes four or more
couples) could dance. Sometimes only two
couples would dance, what one Yancey
County dancer remembers being called a
four-hand reel.
The most common form for the square
dances in this part of the country is called a
fit

big set or big ring,

involving many couples

large circular set. [See "Southern Appa
lachian Big Set Square Dancing," OTH vol.
3, no. 8, May 1993.] Many older dancers still
recall these house parties and barn dances
hi

a

from their youth.
The Grand Hotels
In the

early 1880s, the railroad came to

the mountains

of

western North Carolina,

reaching Asheville

in 1880, and

Haywood

later. The railroad
County
for
the
logging, but also for
region
opened
tourism. In 1884, the first passenger trains
a

few years

arrived in Haywood County, and an era of

demon

stration of the dancing that was once a big
part of the local mountain culture.
Western North Carolina is also known as
the birthplace of team clogging, a modern
tradition which grew out of the older moun
tain square dancing. Its creation came from
efforts to preserve the older dance form,
and ironically helped lead to the decline of
the community-based square dancing from

which

it

derived. The region's tourist in

Square dancing at Moody's Barn, Maggie
Valley, NC, 1940s.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Sam
courtesy

Joe

traditions.
House Dances and "Shindigs"
During the 19th and first decades of the

Queen

dustry from its start in the late 1880s to the
present day has acted as a catalyst and
influenced both of these mountain dance

�"grand hotels" began. The railroad compa
nies built large mountain inns in the 1890s
and early 1900s catering to tourists seeking
escape from the summer heat of the Deep
These resort hotels included the
Gordon Hotel (1890s), the Piedmont Inn
(1893), the White Sulphur Springs Hotel
(1897), Eagle's Nest Inn (1902), and the
Balsam Inn (1907). A number of these ho
South.

tels had dance pavilions and others had
large, wood floor ballrooms in which dances

were held

as part of the

the tourists.

entertainment for

musi

The hotels hired local

cians and dance callers, and invited local
dancers to join with the tourists to help lead
the square-dance

figures.
Queen

Albert Burnette, a dance caller and fox
hunter who was born in 1912 near the

dancers

ton.

He recalls

that the summer

the

at

in East

Joe

child watching

a

Can

people

cabins and danced in the eve
stayed
in
the
main building, and that young
nings
from
the cove would come to dance
people

courtesy

bers as

Wildwood Inn near his home

Sam

Haywood-Buncombe County line, remem

in

a child, he would
go
with his older brother and sister, and look
ing through the windows from the porch,

Soco Gap Square Dance Team at the Mountain

Dance and Music Festival, Asheville, NC, 1940s.

with the tourists. As

learned the dance figures. At home, he
practiced calling the figures to the cows,
pigs, sheep, and housedogs until he was
ready to call for other young people at local
barn dances. Albert recalls when he was 15
(around 1927), "A crowd of us young people
he

got together and we started having dances,
too, at whoever's barn was empty. A hay
loft made

good place, the only big build

a

We got there one night
ing we could find
and had the music there, but the caller didn't
come. so I called that square dance and I've

been calling them ever since."
One of the dance callers employed at the
Haywood County hotels was Sam Queen.

Queen was born

Sam Love

in

1888

in

Dellwood, just outside of Waynesville.
to his

According
"He farmed

grandson,

Joe Sam

Queen,

a little, but his main
occupa
tion was having a good time and entertain
ing himself and others."

According

to Joe Sam,

his grandfather

was the first to put together a team of
dancers to demonstrate the dance figures
for the hotel guests. At this time, the moun
tain square dances were done with a smooth

sliding step rather than the percussive
buckdance steps that dancers would use
when solo dancing. Sam Queen had learned
how to buckdance from his mother, who
was reputed to be able to dance with a cup
of

water on her head and not spill

a

drop,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and he had also learned footwork from an

African-American

dancer named John
Love. During the summer tourist season,
Sam Queen and his demonstration group
were kept busy as many as six nights

a

week leading dances at the various hotels
in and around Waynesville. Some of the
hotels continued the public dances yearround for the local dancers.
In June 1928, Bascom Lamar Lunsford
organized his first Mountain Dance and
Folk Festival in Asheville with the inten
tion of preserving and presenting the tradi
tional music and dance of the area. He

invited Sam Queen and his dancers to per
form square dances on the festival stage,
and the event was made into a contest.
Queen's group, which he named the Soco
Gap

Square

Dancers, competed

against

teams of dancers from Buncombe,
Henderson, and Swain Counties, and
Lunsford awarded a prize to the best
"square-dance team." (The Candler team
from Buncombe County won the title that
first year.)
The Depression Era
During the Great Depression, many of
the grand hotels in Haywood County closed
their doors as the summer tourist trade

dropped off. Some were taken over by the
military for use as hospitals for World War
I veterans, and others burned down.
By the
1940s, they were out-dated and old-fash
ioned and many never reopened for summer

business. Meanwhile, other public dance
venues had opened in Haywood County to
take their place. In 1932, under the WPA,
an armory was built in Waynesville, and

soon

hosted public dances called by Sam
Queen. The Saturday night dance at the
Waynesville Armory, which started out as
a summer dance for tourists,
grew in size
and kept going year round. Another dance
started up at the Canton YMCA. It was
there that Albert Burnette called dances on
Friday nights. And in 1935, dances began
it

held at the Moody Barn on the Moody
family's farm in Maggie Valley, making it
another popular place to square dance dur
ing the summer months.
to be

Post World War

II

Mountain square dancing continued in
Haywood County during World War II,
and after the war, other dance venues
opened up, including the Maggie Valley
Playhouse, a dance hall built in 1949 Arnold
Ferguson, a Haywood County dancer, born
in

1935 near

Waynesville, recalls

a

time

during the 1950s when there were still re
gional dances six nights a week. On Mon
days there was

a

dance at the Maggie Val

ley Playhouse, Tuesday nights at the Ameri
can Legion in Sylva, Wednesday nights
back at the Maggie Valley Playhouse,

Thursday nights at Birdtown, which is be
tween Cherokee and Bryson City in Swain
County, Friday nights at the Piedmont Inn
(continued

on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in Waynesville or the Cherokee High
School, and Saturday nights either at the
Waynesville Armory or once again at the
Maggie Valley Playhouse. Other dances
took place at Waynesville's Gordon Hotel
and the Masonic Lodge in Cherokee. In the
summer months, the dance floors would

overflow with tourists, many from Florida,
joining with the local dancers.
Sam Queen was the caller at many ot
these dances and he would bring along his
Soco Gap Square Dance Team to put on
dance exhibitions. Bill Phillips' band from
Canton often provided the music. The in

strumentation

at this time

included fiddle,

pedal steel, electric guitar, acoustic guitar,
upright bass, and sometimes banjo or man
dolin. Popular dance tunes of this era in
"
cluded "Down Yonder, "Under the Double
Eagle," "Alabama Jubilee," "Steel Guitar
Rag," "Black Mountain Rag," and old-time
fiddle times such as "Lost Indian," "John

"Paddy on the Turnpike,"

Henry,"
"Grey Eagle."

participation.

While these same factors led to the de
cline of community-based old-time square

dancing throughout the country, in the
Asheville area, there was another contrib
uting factor. Its decline was a consequence
of Bascom Lamar Lunsford's efforts to pre
serve the mountain music and dance
through his Mountain Dance and Folk Fes
tival. Although Sam Queen had presented
square-dance exhibitions for years through
out the mountains, it was at Lunsford's
festival in 1928 that square dancing was
first done for competition. The contests at
his festival spawned other square dance

competitions on Saturday nights through
out the region hosted by the various dance
groups in their home counties. At these

competitions and in subsequent years at
Lunsford's festival, the dance form be
gan to evolve as the groups tried to outdo
each other.

and
ers

Over the years, as teams competed, danc
began to add footwork throughout the

Arnold remembers attending other
dances in the region as well. These include
Saturday night dances at the Saddle Club
in Hendersonville, and dances at the Pavil

dance figures.
Albert Burnette recalls his own Cham
pion YMCA square-dance team. "They've
changed things a whole lot. Back then we

ion at Lake Lure and at the Farmers' Ball in

didn't clog, no clogging. Every once in a
while you'd find a man who would clog

Swannanoa.
The dances at the Waynesville Armory
ended in the mid-1950s, when a fire de
stroyed the wooden dance floor and it was
replaced with concrete. Although Sam Queen
remained active as a caller into the 1960s, the
number of dances in the area began to decline,
and by the end of thel970s they had for the

most part completely disappeared.
Re-defining "Square Dancing"
What happened to this rich tradition of
mountain square dancing and why did it
die out after decades of vitality? I have
interviewed many dancers who were ac
tive during those heydays of square danc
ing, and I've heard a number of answers.

According to Jackie Hyatt, whose husband
danced with Soco Gap and who herself
was a "square dancer" with the Sylva team,

popularity of the Texas two-step
local dance halls is what put an end to

the rise in
at

square dancing. Joe Sam Queen suggested
that with the coming of rock-and-roll,

com

munity socialization became more strati
fied by age group, thus inhibiting the pass
ing on of traditions to the next generation.

may have also con
tributed to the break-up of formerly tightknit local dance communities, and certainly

Better transportation

just a little, but not much. What we had,
.when you
sort of, was a flatfoot dance
"
were holding up waiting on the next figure

1940s, as the music became ampli
fied, "square dancers" started wearing taps
on their shoes, and by the 1950s the teams
were competing in matching outfits, more
In the

often reflecting western, rather than Appa

lachian styles.
What had started

out as community-

association with
based dancing held
workings or harvest time, had now gone
beyond demonstration and exhibition at
tourist hotels, to become a competitive form
of dance. This was the beginning of compe
tition team "clogging," though it wasn't
known by that name yet.
Arnold Ferguson believes that the mes
sages of competition and exhibition that
are conveyed by clogging teams have had
in

negative impact on community partici
pation in dance. He says, "They are telling
the audience: You have to be trained to do
this, you have to be young
They should
be telling the audience that you can dance,
a

too. You don't have to do the fancy footwork.

You don't have

the lure and addiction to

to wear the clogging taps."
Other dancers have concurred that team
clogging hurt the popularity of commu

conducive

nity square dancing, and "changed things."

to

television was not
community interaction or

�It is ironic that Lunsford's efforts at preser
vation may have in fact helped change and
eventually terminate the mountain squaredance tradition he was attempting to pro

tect. The changes brought to it by putting it
on stage parallel similar changes that oc
curred with the commercialization of oldtime mountain music and fostered the

de

bluegrass music. Mountain
square dancing became entertainment for
a
passive audience, with an emphasis on
exhibition and competition, rather than the
community-based participatory event it
of

velopment

had been historically.
(Jver the years, the tourist industry has

continued

to

thrive in western North Caro

lina, providing musicians and dance groups
with venues and audiences, thus helping

keep the local mountain-style team clog
ging alive as performance. Even though
nowadays they are more often referred to
to

"doggers," the name
common usage,
dancers on the current
have ever danced at a
as

still in

"square dancer" is
though few of the
teams are likely to

community-based

square dance. When I mention to people
that I am doing research on "old-time square
dancing," they assume that I am referring
to square-dance teams with costumes and
taps performing in competition. This has
become the local "square dance" tradition.
While many of the older dancers recall

participating in community-based square
dancing in their youth, this is no longer
what the words "square dance" mean to
many in western North Carolina.
Information for this article was gathered

from interviews with the following people
during August and September, 2001 Albert
Burnette, Elmer Chandler, Arnold and Inez

Ferguson, James and Jackie Hyatt, Dan
Lane, Evelyn Moody, and Joe Sam Queen.

Additional sources:
Farlow,

Betsy,

Dan Lane, and Duane

Oliver. Haywood Homes and History.
Hazelwood, NC: Betsy Farlow, 1993.
Haywood County Heritage
lina,

Vol.

1.

NC:

Waynesville,

North Caro

Haywood

County Genealogical Society, 1994.
Jones, Loyal. Minstrel of the Appalachians.
Boone, NC: Appalachian Consortium Press,
1984.
Our House

to the

White House.

tary film. Dir. Lawson

Ruehl.

S.

Documen

Warren and Ron

NC Department of Cultural Re

sources, Raleigh, NC, 1982.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Whisnant, David E. "Finding the Way
Between the Old and the New: The Moun
tain Dance and Folk Festival and Bascom
Lamar Lunsford's Work as a Citizen." Com
munities

In

Motion. Ed. Susan Eike Spalding

and Jane Harris Woodside. Westport, CT:
Greenwood Press, 1995. 91-109.
Phil Jamison
caller,

is

an

and flatfoot

old-time musician, dance
dancer.

He

is

assistant

director of the Swannanoa Gathering at War
ren Wilson College in Asheville, NC.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Band

The Albert Hash Memorial
a

Preserving

by Chip

On

Sense

Place

at Mt.

Rogers School

Bailey

any Saturday night, there is a
place that Diane, my wife of 27
can go to forget the
worries of the workweek. This

years, and

I

place is the Carter Fold in Hiltons, Virginia.
The Fold is a true jewel in the crown of oldtime music. Managed by Janette Carter,

daughter of

of

A. P. and Sara of the

original

Carter Family, Janette is assisted by her
brother Joe, her son and daughter, Dale Jett
and Rita Forrester, and a host of volun
teers. I usually use their 7:30 pm start time
my pocket watch, because Janette is
so prompt that you know it must be exactly
7:30 when she steps up to the mike with
to set

in arms and says: "Good

evening
autoharp
ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the oldwe're glad to see this
time music show
number out tonight." The Fold is run with

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

much precision, but also the good-natured,
nurturing heart of Janette Carter comes
through in everything that is done once
you enter her doors. She is a "granny" to
everyone regardless of age. Janette must
hug every child and caution them not to
run down the steep sloped aisles or to leap
over the log benches so artfully covered
with different colors and sizes of shag car
pet samples. The smell of popcorn and hot
dogs fills the air. I look forward to the fried
apple pies made by Dale's daughter. The

building itself

not much more than a tin
roofed barn carved into the hillside on the
is

original property owned and farmed by
A. P.

Carter.

The Fold music

and

dance

building stands right next door to the coun
try store originally built and run by A.P.
The store now houses the Original Carter

Family Museum. The museum is always
open during the performance times each

Saturday night. The A.P. Carter Store origi
nally served as the center of this Virginia
of Poor V alley or Maces Springs
you want to be real specific. Much of the
Carter Family's music started on the front
porch and within the walls of this store and

community
if

you cannot help but feel their presence.

Some of my favorite old-time music
groups are featured here at the Carter Fold
on

a

regular

basis. Janette tries to give

talented groups (ones that can keep good
time) at least a once-a-year booking. Some
preferred bands are seen more than once a
year, especially if they possess a good fid
dler. The crowd is a real dance crowd and
the music and flatfooting are contagious
(continued

on next page)

�Albert Hash

ca.

1982

later returned to their seats

watch the remainder of

to

the show and had time

relax,

enjoy

to

refresh

the

and (even some
brave souls) to practice their

Audrey

Hash

Ham

ments,

to

especially

passers-through from out

of

quench their curios
have
heard from friends
about
what
they
ity
its
Fold
and
about the
reputation. Some of
state who just stop

to

my favorite groups have been The Farmer's
Daughters with Riley Baugus, The

Konnarock Critters, The Wolfe Brothers,
The Wayne Henderson Band, GregHooven
&amp; Galax Way, and The Whitetop Mountain
Band. Janette brings a mix of both bluegrass
and old-time bands alternating each week.

Another benefit of attending any Satur

day night at the Carter Fold is that you
never know who will show up and want to
play immediately after the intermission.
We have seen everyone from Bill Clifton,
Stella Parton, Johnny Cash and J une Carter,
and Mike Seeger, to local "wannabes." At

flatfooting, waltzing,
two-stepping.
Returning

teaching
morning,

job
I

to my

on

and

college

Monday

couldn't get this

band and their teacher off
my mind. I teach business
and education classes and work with pro
spective teachers. I was fascinated with the

school could have an old-time
music program instead of the standard
fact that

a

orchestra or marching band that you some
times find in some larger public school
give the school a call
and asked to speak to Emily Spencer. When
I
spoke with Emily, I explained that I was

systems.

I

decided

to

interested in finding out how this old-time
music program came to be at the Mt. Rogers

School. Emily suggested that I come up,
visit her classes, and see first hand the work
she and the other volunteers were doing

a large
with
instrument
young people

with these Grayson County young folks.
I
pulled out the map to chart a course for
Grayson County. Looking at the map I
discovered that the best route and perhaps
the only route from my location in Bristol

Whitetop Mountain Band and great

was to go to Abingdon, Virginia and take
Highway 58 from Damascus into the Mt.
Rogers Recreation Area until I reached the
Whitetop Community. The hour and a half
trip took me through some of the most

one recent

group

of

post-intermission session,

cases and led by a blond-haired woman
took the stage with Janette's permission.
Their leader was their band teacher, Emily
Spencer, a prominent member of The

her own right.
the young folks as her

clawhammer banjoist
Emily introduced

students

in the

Band

in

II

Class at the Mt.

Rogers Combined School in the Whitetop
Community of Grayson County, Virginia.
The Band was called the Albert Hash Me
morial Band. The class, led by Emily, pro
to strike up two good old-time tunes
that got the audience up and flatfooting
with taps jingling and clacking on the con
crete dance floor in front of the small stage.
A huge applause was heard when they

ceeded

were finished. The students returned their
well-worn instruments to their proper cases
and marched out of the Fold building into

parking lot to deposit them into their
waiting school bus. It had taken them over
the

two hours

to

make this journey

in

this

dusty Grayson County school bus. They
Emily Spencer (guitar) with students.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

beautiful country I have found and the
mountain stream that followed my course
determined the path of Highway 58. The
stream's route demanded one switchback
curve after another. Even though the road
was difficult, the natural beauty of this
region made up for it.
came to the Whitetop community
for final directions at a
I asked
small country store, I found that the Mt.
Rogers Combined School was only a few
Soon

I

and when

hundred yards ahead on the right.
Arriving at the school, I found

a neat,
clean brick and stone building that had a
friendly feel about it and seemed to offer its

welcome

to

strangers like myself. On en

tering the school building I obeyed the sign
on the entrance door and headed immedi
a
I found
the
led
me
to
who
prin
friendly secretary
cipal. She was Ms. Pat Weaver, principal
since Ms. Wilma Testerman had retired

ately

to

the school office. Here

from this position after 55 years. I also met
Ms. Testerman and they both proceeded to
tell me the story of how the Albert Hash

Memorial Band had come to be in Grayson
County. Ms. Weaver told me that she had
only 90 students in this combined school

encompassing grades K-12. The high school
graduation ceremony was slated for the
next week with only three in the graduat
ing class. I was invited to return for the
ceremony if time allowed. Ms. Weaver led
me down the tile floored halls across the
gym and finally into the band room. Here
was introduced to Emily Spencer. It was
just about time for the 10:30 bell to sound
the beginning of the Band II class.
I

Folding chairs encircled the band room

�until she moved
with her husband
to

in this

Lan

nearby

sing, North Caro
to live. The
task was handed
to

Spencer,
Justin Finley, guitar, Jacob Ham, fiddle.

and music stands were placed strategically
front of each chair. Instrument cases lay

in

every corner and stacked against the
wall. Over on one side was leaning an old
bass that looked like it had been through
in

WWII, but I later realized it had a wonder
ful deep rich sound, and of course in music

that's what matters most.

was told that
of
the
instruments
were
purchased
many
with funds approved by the School Board
through the Rural Challenge Grant for
I

which they qualified. The principal had
also informed me that there were 18 stu
dents in the two band classes, which is a
significant percentage of the 90 students in
this small school.
Emily began to tell me the history of the
band program. Albert Hash, a local fiddler
and fiddle maker who lived most of his life

a

As

students were at
being able to

cer, a fine oldtime fiddler, and

Trish Miller

brother-in-law to Albert Hash. After much
work and many trips to talk to the school
board, Emily finally convinced them of the
need for an old-time music program at the
school and also a need to offer academic
credit to grades eight through twelve for
band. The school board agreed to allow

banjo,

guitar,

on

individual. Sometimes

they would lead
solo
or duet singing
gospel song,
session. Emily was very patient with the

into

or

a

lum for credit in

environment.

the fall of 1999,
and Emily and

wasn't long un

the

to my truck and

in

It

had to return

my

case.

Tonya Ham

Emily had asked
if I would like to join the class in some
songs, and she didn't have to ask me twice.

year

instruction

a tune with them, I started to
I fiddled
realize (as a college teacher) the value of
immersion as Emily's chosen method of
teaching. The children learn from her and
from each other and are reinforced by fam
ily members who also play and sing on

As

important

understand
Grayson

Robyn Coe

it only takes a few min
utes in Emily's, class to come to the realiza
tion that these students bring the love of
this type of music from home. It is in

grained

I

a

learning

retrieve
fiddle

just fin
ished their first

have

in their

comfortable

til

students

Carrie Greer

fiddle, and bass. Emily led the class through
each old-time tune, pausing occasionally
to make some specific instruction to an

their

County home, and

memories

as

well

as

those

of their

parents, uncles, aunts, and grand
parents who played and talked about this
same music, which is still very much alive

nights and weekends. It is a family tradi
tion for many in Grayson County. Emily
handed out detailed sheets of a form of
tablature that she has designed to make

it

easy for her students to learn new tunes.
Most students were encouraged to learn to
play by ear and to experiment with impro

visation whenever
ended with

possible. This class

group flatfooting session out
on the gym floor with Emily providing the
banjo licks to keep time with their steps.
Soon the younger students in Band class
a

I

arrived.

found them to be equally capable.
I
joined the faculty table for lunch on this
Tuesday. The meal was enjoyable as was

so

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

off

school curricu

County has a tremendous old-time music
heritage. I was amazed at how many oldtime musicians actually call Grayson

artfully started by her father, had always
assisted Albert. Albert Hash died in Janu
ary 1983, not long after the volunteer pro
gram at Mt. Rogers Combined School
started up. It was now left up to Audrey to
carry on the work of her father. Audrey
continued as a volunteer for many years

switch

students and it
was apparent
that they felt

that

respected for his intricate carving and se
lection of quality wood. Albert had started
volunteering his time years before at the
local volunteer fire department to pass on
his knowledge of old-time music to all. His
daughter, Audrey Hash Ham, who now
continues the tradition of fiddle building

the

Emily three years' probational status to
teach these classes part-time and to issue
band credit to the participating students.
The band was officially placed into the

to

it in

how

Thornton Spen

It is

community, officially started

help

but notice

diversified

and learning.

1982. Albert was not only well known for
his fiddling abilities, but the quality and
sound of the instruments he built. He was

couldn't

friend, and wife of

of

in this

joined

I

Emily's Band II
advanced class, I

Emily
family

successful

Allison Blevins, banjo, Crystal Hamm, guitar.

Vir

ginia.

lina

down

region of

Southwest

the

I

conversation with Emily and other fac

ulty members about the importance of the
Albert Hash Memorial Band and how each
Martha Spencer (Emily's daughter),
Hamm, guitar.

banjo;

Joe

person involved with the school wishes it
to survive the bureaucracy of the public
(continued

on page 52)

�A Banjo on Her Knee -- Part

I:

Appalachian Women and America's First Intrument
by

Susan A. Eacker and Geoff Eacker

article titled "In Praise of BanjoPicking Women" published over 10
an

In

years ago in the pages of the Old-Time
Herald, Mike Seeger noted that in his

fieldwork with "old-timers"

in the

South

women's history, I was intrigued by the
idea of uncovering some of these invisible
banjo women. Geoff makes 5-string banjos
and plays clawhammer style, but most of
our record collection and our knowledge
centered around male banjo players. It was
only after we began our research that we
learned that most of these men had learned
to play from a female relative. This list is

partial account includes
Ralph Stanley learned to
play clawhammer style from his mother,
Lucy Smith Stanley. "Grandpa" Louis
Jones took his first trailing lessons from

exhaustive but

a

the following:

Cynthia

May Carver,

a.k.a.

"Cousin

Emmy," from Lamb, Kentucky. Northwest
ern North Carolina banjoist Clarence "T om"

Ashley (who popularized the tune "The
Coo-Coo"), learned to play clawhammer

Charles
courtesy

fore the turn of the 20th century Seeger
went on to ask, "Why do we not have
accounts of this either visually or in the
literature?" This article is a long overdue
affirmation of Seeger's findings and a re
sponse to his question. Since I teach

Wolfe

ern mountains, he had been told that their
fathers and mothers played the banjo be

Samantha Bumgarner (banjo) and Eva Davis (fiddle).

older sister Hettie. And Earl
two
older sisters, Eula Mae and
Scruggs'
both
played the banjo and surely
Ruby,
their
taught
younger brother a tune or two.
The fact that so many well-known oldfrom his

time male musicians

influenced by

have been inspired

female

in the family
should force us to rethink the ways in
which banjo music in Appalachia has been

and

a

promulgated -and preserved.

While

this

might strike a sour note with some, the
evidence suggests that it was women who
have historically kept old-time music
especially banjo and ballads alive in the
hills and hollers of the Southern moun
tains. (As case m point, consider the tact
that when British ballad collectors Cecil
Sharp and Maude Karpeles made their

banjo in 1905 (at the age of eight) from his
Aunts Ary and Daisy. National Heritage
Fellow and banjo player Morgan Sexton of

foray into Eastern Kentucky, Western North
Carolina and the Virginias in 1916-17, ap

Linefork, Kentucky, got his first lessons

lected and later compiled

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

proximately

75% of the 968 tunes they
as English

col

Folk

Songs from the Southern Appalachians were

sung to them by women.)
Historical evidence and photographs
clearly document the fact that middle-class
women in the Northeast were swept up in
the banjo craze of the late 19th century.
With the advent of mass-produced instru
ments by S. S. Stewart, Fairbanks, and Cole,
banjo manufacturers in the 19th century
consciously and successfully shifted the
cultural appeal of the instrument away
from its association with the oftentimes
bawdy minstrel or medicine show and into
the hands of those middle-class women
and men who could afford a store-bought
banjo constructed with elaborately en
graved metal rims, inlayed ivory and
mother-of-pearl fretboards and heads, and
intricately carved heel stocks. Banjo clubs

men and women sprang up in Ivy
League colleges. In 1893, the famed artist
Mary Cassat even used the image of the
for

�pluck the dulcimer,
to

erroneously thought

have come from Great

Britain.

(Kentuckian

Jean Ritchie, singularly

responsible for popular
izing the dulcimer dur
ing the folk revival, told

us in an informal inter
view that her family

by A. C. Fairbanks,

considered the banjo
"low instrument.")

means.

But if Cecil Sharp and
other "ballad catchers"
had strayed from the

Yet, the common folk in southern Appalachia had surely been picking the banjo

settlement schools and
small towns that served

long before this mass appeal began. How
the banjo got to the Southern mountains is

as

still

a

matter of speculation.

In fact,

the

topic has inspired the literary equivalent of
"dueling banjos." Some banjo scholars
claim that the down-stroke style of playing
was picked up by mountain whites di
rectly from slaves. Others see the Civil
War
which brought together blacks and

whites in both grey and blue as the mode
of transmission. In addition, the minstrel
show, especially as it traveled down the
tributaries of the Ohio into Eastern Ken
tucky and Western Virginia in the early
19th century, probably exposed many
Appalachians to the instrument.

ru

ral

The fact that 19th-century

Appalachian
women banjo players have remained in
visible may be because mountain women
and men were largely isolated and on the
bottom rung of the economic ladder. As
social historians can attest, the marginalized
leave few records, which may help to an

swer Seeger's question of why such ac
counts are hard to come by. When "our

contemporary ancestors"

(as they were
called by outsiders) were "discovered" in
the mountains in the early part of the last
century, part of their supposed quaintness
lay in their musical culture. Ballad collec

tors like Cecil Sharp and Maud Karpeles,
Olive Dame Campbell, and the numerous
women who started rural settlement
schools like Hindman and Pine Mountain
in Southeastern Kentucky, were keen on
establishing a Celtic connection between
Appalachians and their Northern Euro
pean ancestors. To this end, they sought
after unaccompanied ballads with British

bloodlines. The banjo was not a link in their
musical canon and mountain men and
women were discouraged from playing
this

indigenous instrument, while encouraged

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

headquarters

a

for

their

fieldwork, they
would have found the
banjo being picked in
mountains
as
the
as

sprightly
seng!

And

Wolfe

Whyte Lay die"

was given its name in
obvious reference to its intended users
white, sophisticated women and men of

spring gin
if

Charles

the early 20th century, the

you dig

into
manuscript and photo

enough

deep

courtesy

"

to

collections,

graphic
scrutinize

liner notes,

and listen to field and

commercial recordings
and oral recollections,
the sound of women
banjo pickers still reso
nates through the years,
as far

back as the late

19th century.

African- American
Elizabeth
banjoist
"Babe" Reid,

born in

North Carolina in 1910
and cousin to Etta
Baker, learned to play
from her mother, Mattie
Moore. The latter was

certainly

frailing the

banjo before the 20th
century. Hobart Smith
of Virginia once told an
interviewer that he

Gerrard

which depicted "the modern woman" of
the late 19th century as a genteel young
mother strumming her instrument while
her attentive daughter gazes over her shoul
der. Ironically, what had originally been an
instrument invented by slaves along the
Eastern seaboard now was a signifier for
white, liberated women of middle-class
America. Even the most popular model of

learned to play the banjo
in

1904

seven

at the age

of

and that his

mother and father both
plaved before he was

Alice

banjo in her painting "The Banjo Lesson,"

Photo top: Unknown woman playing banjo, 1913.
Photo bottom, Aunt Jenny Wilson, ca. 1970, Logan Co., WV.

born. Other late 19th and early 20th-cen
tury female frailers include Gertrude Evans

Calhoun County, West Virginia, (who
died in the late 1920s at an advanced age)
who taught famed fiddler French Carpen
of

ter

how

to

play several tunes, including

"Walkin' in the Parlor." Virginia Myrtle
Wilson ("Aunt Jennie"), born in 1900 in
Logan County, West Virginia, learned to

play banjo at the age of nine. She was
taught to frail by an older woman named
(continued

on

next page)

�Delpha Maynard, who according

to

Wil

son, "could play the banjer and dance just

wanted to be just like
conversation with us, Eastern
Kentucky fiddle player J. P. Fraley, at the
time 77 years of age, remembered that his
mother played the banjo. Both Stella Wag
oner Kimble, born in 1892 in Sparta, North
like anything and

her."

In

I

a

Carolina, and her older sister Pearl Wag
oner, played a two-finger old-time banjo
style typically found in Western North
Carolina. Ada Lee Stump Boarman played
the banjo, according to her son Andy

Boarman, who was born in 1901 in Berke
ley County, West Virginia, and who made
and played mountain banjo. Kelly Clay
Sears, born in 1907 in Chatham County,

April 1924 recording was made only one
month after OKeh records had produced
tracks by Fiddlin' John Carson and his

Virginia Reelers, considered the first "hill
billy" recordings to be commercially mar
keted in the United States. Thus not only
should Bumgarner be considered the first
"banjo-pickin' person" to record and reach
mass audience, but one of the earliest
Southern mountain musicians to make it to
the studio as well.
Samantha Bumgarner was born in the
Western mountains of Jackson County,
a

North Carolina, in 1880. Apparently, her
father forbid her to touch the fiddle but she

would "sneak out and play" it anyway. By
the age of 15 she had become an accom

banjo before the turn of the last century).
Apparently, her father didn't mind that his
daughter had taken up the banjo, for he

eventually bought her

a

manufactured

model. Bumgarner played at the first Moun
tain Dance and Folk Festival in Asheville,
North Carolina in 1928, an event organized

musician and Appalachian musicolo
gist Bascom Lamar Lunsford. It was here in
1936 that 16-year-old Pete Seeger would
hear his first five-string clawhammer banjo,
being played by Samantha Bumgarner no
less. Seeger, of course, went on to become
the country's most influential promoter of
the five-string banjo during the folk revival
by

movement

of the late 1950s and early 60s.

Surely, Samantha deserves some credit for
being his initial musical muse. Although

North Carolina, learned his first banjo tune,
"Catfish," at the age of nine from his mother.
Finally, a poster titled "250 Years of Old-

plished banjo player, picking on a home
made instrument made from "a gourd with
a cat's hide stretched over it and strings

Time Music Around Galax, Virginia," (pur
chased at the Blue Ridge Institute of Ferrum
College in Virginia) details the names, dates

made of cotton thread waxed with beeswax."

Bumgarner was obviously an inspiration
for other women in the Southern moun

(Note that she was playing her homemade

tains, who would emerge

she

never

received

critical

a

acclaim,

decade later

as

as well as the instru
played by musicians in the area.
Among the more than two hundred names
listed are many women, the earliest a banjo
player named Julia Reece Green (18421911), is credited with playing the banjo
and the accordion.
Another reason for the historical invis
ibility of banjo women is no doubt related

of birth and death,

ments

to the

fact that

it

was

women

at

one time considered

improper
play an instrument
associated not just with men, but with im
morality. For if the fiddle was once consid
ered "the devil's box," the banjo was cer
tainly a son of Satan. One woman identi
for

to

fied in this study was told by her father that
"nice girls don't play the banjo." Appala

chian women banjo players in the past
were also stymied by the additional bur
den of not playing in public, either prefer

ring or being coerced into picking the in
strument in the privacy of their homes or

front porches.

women

in the

Still, by the 1920s, some
Southern mountains came

down off their porches and began

to

play in

public.

Samantha Bumgarner was probably the

Cynthia May Carver (Cousin Emmy), from the

Cousin Emmy Song Book.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Charles
courtesy

traveled to New York City where she re
corded 10 songs for Columbia Phonograph
Company, playing frailing-style banjo on
six of the tunes, including "Shout Lou" and
"Fly Around My Pretty Little Miss." Her

Wolfe

first Appalachian banjo player of either sex
to cut a commercial record. In 1924 she

�Virtually all of the women banjo players
who came to national attention in the 1930s
were from Kentucky. For women in the

music provided
mountains, marriage
the only viable alternative to an isolated
and inevitable hard-scrapple existence.
or

Three women in particular Cynthia May
Carver ("Cousin Emmy"), Lily May Ledford,
and Laverne Williamson ("Molly O'Day")
all chose music as their mode of escape.

Cynthia May Carver (1903-1980) was
born in Lamb, Kentucky to a sharecropping family that raised tobacco. As early as
age eight, Cynthia worked in the fields,
staking, stripping and curing Kentucky's
principal cash crop. Although the work
was arduous, young Cynthia entertained

her family in the fields by crooning, clown
ing around, and creating musical skits. She

once told an interviewer that she "thankjed]
God that He gave me the talent and the

"
good common sense to get out of there
Like Samantha Bumgarner, her first instru
ment was the fiddle, and in 1936 she be
came the first woman to win the National
Old Fiddlers contest in Louisville, Ken
tucky. While she became proficient play

was captured on
celluloid when she
did two movies in

Hollywood: Swing
in

the Saddle (1944)

and

the

Second

Greatest Sex (1955).
In

folklorist

1947,

in

Alan Lomax

cluded her on his
field recording Ken
tucky Mountain Bal
lads. On the collec

tion

she

played

and

banjo

sang

"Pretty Little Miss
Out in the Garden,"
as well as "I Wish I
was

a

Single Girl

Again." During the
1960s, her musical
career was resur
rected when she
toured Europe with
the New Lost City

Ramblers.

Like

Cynthia

May Carver, Lily
May Ledford (1 9 1 7-

ing 15 instruments, including the saw, she
began her career in West Virginia as a

1985) was also born

banjoist with Frankie Moore's Log Cabin
Boys in the mid-1930s. By 1938 she had
formed her own band, called the Kin Folks,
and toured in a Cadillac with four other
women players. Cousin Emmy's banjo
playing has been described as a hard, fast-

so

driving eastern Kentucky trailing style. Her
stage presence was apparently electric, as
she danced, strutted, and strummed just as
she had in the tobacco fields years ago.
Even over the radio, her dynamic

style

surged over the airwaves. Playing on
WWV A

in Wheeling, West Virginia in 1937,
she caught the attention of a young Louis
Jones, later known as Grandpa Jones. In his
autobiography, Everybody's Grandpa, Jones
stated that "her five-string picking fasci

nated me to the extent that

I

would follow

her around the studio to watch and listen.

worried her so much that she finally said,
"
He
'Okay, I'll show you how it's done.'
went on to note that it was "sad that such
people are hardly ever mentioned in books
I

on country music by these so-called experts.

"

Cousin Emmy and her banjo not only
caught the ears of Grandpa Jones, but those
of over 2.5 million listeners as well when
she was hired by radio station KMOX in St.
Louis, Missouri in 1941. Her visual presence

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gerrard

tainers.

Alice

some of the nation's most popular enter

Lily May Ledford at the Newport Folk Festival, 1968.

remote region of Kentucky, in an area
inaccessible that it was called "Pinch'em-Tight" holler, located in the Red River
Gorge in the east-central part of the state.

in

a

11 siblings fought over the family
crafted
out of green hickory with a
banjo,
groundhog-hide head. Apparently, it was

All of her

her mother who didn't approve of Lily
May's banjo picking. As she noted in her
Coon Creek Girl, by the age
had
"learned to steal out the
she
eight
and
hide
banjo
way up on a hill behind a

autobiography
of

big rock where Mama couldn't hear me
and where I pretended not to hear her
hollering for me to do chores."
At the age of 19, Lily May stole away for
good, leaving the hills for the highway
north. After winning a fiddle contest in
Kentucky, she caught the attention of pro
moter John Lair, who wanted her as a regu
lar on his radio show in Chicago.
Lair

would become Lily May's manager
throughout

her career with the Coon Creek

Girls, the first commercially successful allfemale Appalachian string band in the
United States, which lasted from 1936 until
the breakup of the Coon Creek Girls in
1957. According to Ledford, Lair, the con

summate image-maker, tried to control all
aspects of Lily May's public persona. "In

the long old-fashioned dress and high top
lace shoes that Mr. Lair had me wear, I felt
like an old lady and not

at all

pretty. Mr.

discouraged my buying clothes, curl
ing my hair, going in for make-up or im
proving my English." Like many of her
female predecessors, Lily May preferred
the fiddle, yet Lair also insisted that she
"stay on that banjo from now on and let the
fiddle be incidental, for we've plenty of
good fiddlers, but that banjo is what you'll
make it on." Ledford replied that she would
"rather fiddle" because she didn't "know
Lair

many banjo songs." Even though she lost
that battle, she had her own ways of sub
verting Lair's attempts to control her. In
spite of his instructions, Lily May "did a
and would not wear my
little fixing up
hair pulled back in a bun except on stage."
Lily May bought a Whyte Laydie and soon
developed the same hard-driving Eastern-

Kentucky trailing style that had character
ized the music of Cousin Emmy. Whether
that distinctive style was intact from the
time she played as a young girl in the gorge
whether she was inspired by Cousin
Emmy is hard to tell. Regardless, she took
to the instrument with the same fervor as
she played fiddle. She not only learned
or

(continued

on next page)

�many banjo tunes but modified them in
proto-feminist fashion, taking an old stan

regular radio pro
gram in Beckley,
West
Virginia,

sponsored

by

"With

Pepper.

Molly

dard "Going 'Round the World," for ex
ample, and changing the lead-in line from
banjo pickin' girl"

to "I'll be a

banjo

pickin' girl." She is purported to have writ
ten 40 new verses to the song, with lines

Chattanooga and from

I'm goin' to

a

part of her
life in

day
if

I

don't

tucky,

every

Ken

and

her

hard-driving

notion.

Tennessee, don't you try

frailing style closely

resembled that

and follow me.
Like Cousin Emmy,

Lily May Ledford
was "rediscovered" during the urban folk

Lily May

of

Ledford,

whom she had ob

heard

music revival. At the invitation of Ralph
Rinzler, she performed at the Newport
Folk Festival in 1968 and toured with the

viously

Red Clay Ramblers in 1979. Shortly before

Molly O'Day and

her death in 1985 she was

bestowed the

through the radio.

Between
the

1946-51,

Cumberland

National Heritage Award.
Molly O'Day was born Laverne
W illiamson in 1 923 in Mc V eigh, Kentucky,

Mountain Folks re
corded 36 sides for
Columbia Records.

near the West Virginia border, in a holler
so far back in the hills, as she once quipped,

In his

to

sledgehammer,

and the

ried

mail."

the

with a
groundhogs car

break daylight

"that you had

Like

the

banjo-playing

women before her, she left her home in the
hills at a young age, after writing to ask a
musician in Bluefield, West Virginia named
Lynn Davis if he needed a female singer.
Laverne had already made a musical name
for herself on a nearby radio station in
Williamson, West Virginia, where she

played guitar in a string band that in
cluded her two brothers one on banjo
and the other fiddle. When Lynn Davis
went to visit Laverne in her "little log
cabin" in Eastern Kentucky, she was just

1

7

heard

a

a

Art Satherly, the legendary

producer for

Columbia, considered O'Day "the greatest
female country singer ever."

Yet Molly was not only a great Appala
chian singer, but a great banjo player as
well. One of her most popular recordings,
the old ballad "Poor Ellen Smith" gives
aural evidence not just of her vocal ability
but her frailing banjo technique. Accord
ing to Lynn Davis, at one time in London,

Kentucky, she even beat the legendary Earl
Scruggs in a banjo contest:
Earl Scruggs, you know, he never did

cause

she

was

it

a banjowas be

girl. Well, if you
know Earl, he seldom ever smiles
very sober. Well Molly would get out
and she'd just about go berserk pickin'

I

girls

Lynn Davis &amp; Molly O'Day, 1950, shortly after their conversion and
move to Huntington, WV.

music
Country,
scholar Charles K.
Wolfe claims that

pickin' contest. He said

lot about

her, you know,
how she was singin'. And had two

I

book Kentucky

care about her beatin' him in

Davis told us that:

years old.

Wolfe

a

the banjo style and

Charles

there on to Cuba.
I'm goin' cross the ocean
take

quickly picked up
songs that had been

like the following:
I'm goin' to

Dr

courtesy

a

sort of cowboy band; a West
And one of the girls got

ern type.

married and the other was going
home. So she wrote me and asked if I

a

the banjo 'cause she really put on

a

would like

show. She would talk with her eyes

went

and she just put in on.

to have a girl singer. So I
seen her in the little log cabin.
When she walked outlturned flips. .So
to

(Scruggs was contacted about this ap
parent indignity, after an article concern

mother
Her
and
we
talked
awhile.
and dad
she
can't go at
mother said, "Now
seventeen without her brother goes
her brothers came out and her

with her." So

I

ing our research ran in the Huntington HeraldDispatcli. He denied the veracity of the story.)

Laverne Williamson and Lynn Davis
were married in 1941, just before Laverne

hired her and her

brother [fiddler "Skeets" Williamson]
Molly and her band, The Cumberland
Mountain Folks, which included her

brother Skeets and Lynn Davis, began

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

turned 18. The marriage lasted until her
death in 1987, but Molly O'Day's career
was short lived, after she suffered a ner
vous breakdown in 1949 and turned her

back on secular songs and the music busi
ness. After her 1951 recording session, she

never appeared in public performances,
unless it was in front of the congregation
pastored by then Reverend Lynn Davis.
Lynn Davis explained to us Molly's rea
sons for quitting the business as follows:
"She didn't want to be bothered with it. We
even got a call from
.Hootenany. They
called us to be on that
[They offered us]
.We
didn't go back
thousands of dollars.
her
career was
into it at all." Even though
brief, Molly O'Day's voice and banjo play
ing were kept alive by Lynn Davis (until his
recent death) through his daily radio pro
gram called "Hymns from the Hills" in
Huntington, West Virginia, where Molly
and Lynn lived most of their married life.
While Cousin Emmy, Molly O'Day and Lily
May Ledford all managed to achieve some
fame, there are countless other women banjoists who still remain relatively obscure.
In the next segment of this article

readers will be introduced

to

OTH

some of these

banjo women, perhaps for the first time.
Given the growing popularity of a new

generation of banjo women

like Alison

Brown, Emily Erwin of the Dixie Chicks,
their foremothers, past
and Gillian Welch
and present, certainly deserve their rightful

(continued

on page 52)

�Issues

In

Old-Time Music

Texas Contest Styleby

Problems?

Roger Koch

with an introduction by Vivian Williams

readers who may not be familiar
of Western fiddle con

"danceability," "tone," and "fiddling ability."
The original intent of the fiddle associa

tests that prompted the following article,
here is some background. Fiddle contests

tions and of the contests was to perpetuate
pioneer dance fiddling. The categories on
the score sheet seem to be appropriate for
that purpose, if indeed a contest can itself
be a viable way to perpetuate dance fid
dling. But historical trends in fiddling have
moved the style of fiddling heard at West
ern contests in a different direction. Start
ing in 1964, great Texas and Oklahomastyle fiddlers such as Byron Berline,
Herman Johnson, Dick Barrett, and Benny
Thomasson introduced to contests in the
Northwest and far West an elaborate style
which goes back at least to the early 20th

Forwith the context

in the West are

usually highly organized
affairs. Each state fiddle association has its
official state contest, and these contests
along with several others sponsored by
private groups and civic organizations are
"certified." Certification is sought after
because it gives the contest greater prestige
and attracts more top contestants. If the
contest sufficiently conforms to the struc
ture of the National Oldtime Fiddle Con
test at Weiser, Idaho, and if it applies to the
Weiser contest and receives certification,
the current champions of each division of
these local and regional contests are en

titled to play in a special evening program
at Weiser in which trophies are awarded

entertainment

for

value, costuming,

and

"fancy fiddling."

contrast, the regular contest divisions
ignore showmanship and forbid "trick and
fancy fiddling." Just what constitutes trick
and fancy fiddling is a controversial issue
In

that elicits lively debate at the judges' meet
ing preceding the Weiser contest each year.
Each contest round consists of

a

hoedown,

waltz, and an old-time dance tune which
neither a hoedown nor a waltz usually
a
rag, polka, two-step, jig, or schottische.
Because the contest has become so huge
over 300 fiddlers
a time limit of four min
utes is now enforced, with points deducted
for overtime. The judges are themselves
a

is

fiddlers, and are sequestered in

a

separate

room where they can't see the contestants,
but hear only the fiddling, not the announce
ments, or the applause. The score sheet

includes the categories "rhythm

&amp;

timing,"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

century

a

Robertson's

great
1923

example

is

Eck

of "Sally
Goodin." This type of playing was further
developed specifically to win contests, par
ticularly in Texas, rather than to make ef
fective dance music. Benny Thomasson in
particular has described how he added
new variations to the old-time tunes that he

recording

played in order to impress the judges (see
the Benny
Thomasson web site at
www.halcyon.com/petimar.bennyhom.htm).
The resulting style of fiddling is very effective

winning contests.
Once the above mentioned fiddlers and
their successors began to dominate the
championship division at Weiser, ambi
tious contestants started learning their style
and repertoire both because they liked it
and to increase their chances of winning.
Contest judges are often chosen from the
at

ranks of the top fiddlers, including younger
ones who may not be particularly familiar
with or appreciative of types of fiddling

outside of the "contest style" which they
have learned. Many of them value the

technical difficulty of a tune above its au
thenticity or its suitability for old-time danc
ing, and score accordingly. Thus, over the
years a self-perpetuating cycle has been set
up, which has led to some of the problems

commented on

in the

following article.

V. W.

have just enjoyed some of the most
gorgeous, lush, fiddle music I have ever
heard. My 22-year-old violinist daughter
I

was playing Texas-style tunes while I pre
pared supper in our kitchen. She threw in

some ending variations on the "Beaumont
Rag" which she worked out during a re
cent trip to Tuscany. Really nice stuff! Sev
eral months ago I was listening to her play
the Tchaikovsky

Violin Concerto in

cital at her university.

a

re

That was the one

wrote for the best-known vio
linist of the day, Leopold Auer, who
but of
promptly declared it unplayable
course, it proved to be otherwise. Never
theless, it is a most challenging piece in the
classical repertoire.
So what does this have to do with the
topic of many fewer fiddlers entering con
T chaikovsky

tests in my state and in many others? It is
simply that this great Texas contest style
has choked out most others. And for the

audiences it is too much of a good thing.
Remember the old adage, "A little bit of
anything is good, but too much of anything
is bad." So it is with Texas contest style.
Audiences are wowed with the perfor
mances of the first few young fiddlers in a
contest, but soon become numbed with the
repetitious style, and all the tunes begin
sound the same. This is not unique
(continued

on next

to
to

page)

�also true of lengthy perfor
mances of Celtic jigs and reels, hot bluegrass, avant garde jazz, etc. Audiences ac
tually become bored with all the repetition.

Texas

it

is

A little bit is great, but

enough

is

enough,

music and have progressed through a good
deal of violin training including the popu
lar Suzuki method of teaching. And what is
wrong with this? For openers, it has almost
created its own "classical" form of contest

simply too darn much!
We have just finished our annual state
fiddle contest, which worked out okay

competition, with player after player play
ing many of the same breakdowns, waltzes,

not losing money and having around 50
contestants. Not bad. Unless you consider

ion

and too much

is

that a few years ago we had around 100
entrants and made good money for our
state organization. Who or what is the cul

prit for this decrease in activity? The an
swer is simple: Texas style fiddling and the

entrants who play

it.

Many of them read

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and tunes of choice in
as

heard on

a

a

note for note fash
or from a

recording

written transcription of the piece. The con
testants have turned into a group of note
for noters

and "tape apes" as our friend

Paul Anastasio describes them. The contest

rules and judges have inadvertently cre
ated an entire population of Mark O'Connor

clones. The fiddler who plays the piece
closest to the original is often declared the
winner. What happened to originality, in

novation, and improvisation? These were
the qualities which made the young Mark
O'Connor such a great young contestant,
and continue to serve him as he pursues
higher and higher musical goals.
And the rules that the sponsoring orga

nizations have set up also cause problems.
Undoubtedly they had good reasoning
behind them, but the rule makers had no
prescient abilities to predict future out
comes of their rules. In effectively eliminat

(string plucking), cross tun
ing, imposing short, strict time limits, etc.,
they have eliminated originality and inno
vation. Many great old tunes including
ing pizzicato

"Black Mountain Rag," "Mocking Bird,"
and "Orange Blossom" were earlier writ
ten for and used in contests. Nothing like
or performed ever
contest rules com
many
again according
mittees. And woe be to the fiddler who

these can be created
to

might enter playing any other style: Appa
lachian, Ozark, New England, Northwest
ern, Canadian, Celtic, Cajun, etc. The judges
will quickly eliminate their entry from most
upper level competitions.
So what is the big deal? Just learn to play
Texas style right? No! This is exactly why
our entries have dropped. Most of the cur
rent group of Texas contest-style competi
tors is comparatively young. Most have

been taught to play that style since they
were kids. Countless other fiddlers learned
to play other styles as youngsters. And
most fiddlers who took up the instrument
later in life do not want to learn to play
Texas contest style. And for good reason.
Texas contest style is good for one thing
and one thing only: winning fiddle con
tests. The national contests are a dead end!
The world does not beat a path to the door
of the winners and there is nowhere else to

use your highly developed skills. Dance
halls do not want this nearly undanceable

music and people do not want to pay to
hear it played in concerts. A few aficiona
dos pat the winner's back and then it is all
over, period. For this reason, Texas contest
style appears to be on a course of eventual
self-destruction, and it is taking away some
contests

at the

same time.

addition, there is the pervasive prob
lem of the attitude of too many entrants
In

toward competition

winning

at all

costs

and the pressure placed on some young

fiddlers by overly aggressive parents
similar to the problems on some youth
athletic fields. These attitudes have taken
much of the fun out of contest fiddling. This
hasn't helped either.

Other forms of old-time fiddling have
been forced out of these contests. A huge

chunk of historic Americana is in danger of
being lost. Great old-time fiddlers have
been shamed into closing their cases and
putting them on the shelf because they
don't produce the pure tone and fast finger
runs that these young contestants do Thank
goodness for a few pockets of true old-time

fiddling, especially in the Southeast.
Fiddle camps, which often teach wideranging regional and ethnic styles of play
ing dance music have prospered. In con
trast, fiddle contests appear to be slowly

disappearing from the scene. Perhaps the

promoters of these contests in the U.S.
should take a page from the success of the
fiddle camps. Place the Texas contest-style
competitors in their own separate divi
sions where they can still be big winners,
and open new classes of competition in
other old-time and ethnic areas. Let's make the
contests more interesting for the fans and more
fun for more fiddlers. The non-Texas contest-

style fiddlers will love it, the audiences will love
dam sure will love it.
it, and
I

Roger Koch is a state director for the Montana
State Old-Time Fiddlers Association. Vivian

Williams

is a

Recordings

in

fiddler and co-owner of Voyager
Seattle, Washington.

For the

Holidays

Give

OTH Gift Subscriptions to
Your Friends and to Your

Local Library

For your Holiday

from the

pleasure recipes (right) are

Cousin Emmy Song Book. Courtesy

Charles Wolfe.

�Recipe for Cousin Emmy's
Sour Cream Cake
1

cup of sour cream

2 whole
1

1
1

1/2
1

cup

of

eggs
sugar

teaspoon of soda
teaspoon of baking

powder

teaspoon salt
teaspoon vanilla

ingredients together and bake
350 degrees for about 45 minutes.
Mix

all

In

a

moderate

oven

about

Recipe for Cousin Emmy's
Christmas Relish
12 green mango

peppers
onions
12 targe
12 red mango peppers
targe stalk of celery

1
1

1/2

2

1

Enough vinegar to cover

tablespoon celery seed
tablespoon mustard seed
cup

salt

cups sugar

ail ingredients.

No water.

Grind peppers and onions together through food chopper.
scalding water for five minutes. Drain thoroughly. Dice in small
large stalk of celery. Cook in vinegar for five minutes.
Add

all

two minutes.

the
It

is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

other

ingredients

to

Put

pieces

celery and vinegar and cook

now ready for the jars white hot.

in

for

�Workshop

Engelhardt Basses
Smakula

by Bob

make them like
they used to. In many cases that is true,
say they don't

They

but

a

musical instrument company in Elk

Grove Village, Illinois has been manufac
turing their bass viols and cellos using
molds, patterns and techniques that have

been around since before World War II.
The Engelhardt bass story really starts
with the Kay Guitar Manufacturing Com
pany. Making mostly student grade gui
tars, banjos and mandolins, they brought

their laminated musical instrument con
struction techniques to a larger scale by

developing

their bass and cello line in the

late 1930s.
1969, the formerly prosperous Kay
Company suffered from the same market
In

crash that affected many musical instru
ment companies. Kay was forced intobankruptcy. Seeing a vacant market niche, the

partners in the Engelhardt-Link Corpora
tion made a successful bid at Kay's liquida
tion auction and acquired the entire Kay
bass and cello manufacturing operation.
They did not acquire the rights to the Kay

name it went to a company that eventu
ally used the Kay trademark on imported
guitars, and Engelhardt was chosen as the
name

continuation

for this

of

a

30-year

tradition of manufacturing basses and cellos.

have always been curious about differ
ent methods of manufacturing. I love to
take plant tours. From dairies to automo
I

bile factories,

I

love to see how things are

processed and assembled. When
chance
spring

to tour
I

took

I

had

a

the Engelhardt plant this

it.

modest 50' by 120' brick-faced build
the manufacturer of the biggest
housed
ing
instrument in old-time music. There was
wood dust everywhere and a huge amount
A

of clutter.

It

was just like being

in

my own shop.

manufacturing process starts with
lumber and specialty plywood. They
The

outsource the pressing of the tops and backs
to a company that specializes in shaped
wood lamination. Engelhardt makes ev

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Photos below: Stack of Engelhardt basses ready
for stringing; gluing back to sides; stack of rims
and backs; cellos ready for finish. Photos by Bob
Smakula.

erything else but the tuners and strings.
When the wood comes in it is processed
into parts. The maple necks are cut from
large planks. The neck blanks take their

form using saws and a huge wood shaper.
corner and end
All of the interior parts
all fol
and
the
bass
bars
blocks, linings,

low similar procedures. The sides are cut
from plywood about 3/32" thick. After dip
ping these pieces in water, they are put on
hotbending forms to take their shape. When
it

comes time

the

to

to see

spread glue, you get

half-century-old forms being put

to

good use. There are forms for most of the
gluing operations. I especially liked the

swivel-mounted unit that they use

to

glue

the entire rim assembly at once. It is big,
heavy, and did the job efficiently. Their use
of animal hide glue was

good

to see.

I

have

always thought that hide glue, when used
properly, is as strong as the more modern

polyvinyl glues and contributes

to

an

instrument's

tone. After gluing the parts
head to the spray
the
instruments
together,
booth for several coats of lacquer. The last
step on the "assembly line" is fitting the

sound post and bridge, as well as slotting
the nut. Stringing the instruments up to get
a few quick notes of satisfaction is neces(continued

on page 52)

�Classifieds
Musical Instruments
WORLD'S

Equipment

LARGEST SELECTION-- New-

Used-Vintage

banjos, mandolins,

guitars,

archtops, wood &amp; metal body Dobros, Nation
als. Mandolin Brothers, 629 Forest Ave., Staten
Island, NY 10310. Free Catalog. 718-981-3226.
Call for no-charge

evaluation

of your

vintage

Odd sized Fiberskyn banjo heads, Many sizes
from 10" to 12 1/8", $18 to $20. Gut banjo strings
$15. Everest banjo cases for 11" and 12" rims $95
plus shipping. Smakula Fretted Instruments, P0
Box 882, Elkins, WV 26241; 304-636-6710.

fretted instruments.

Misc.

INSTRUMENTS FOR SALE; GUITARS:1936
Martin 0-17 $1,500; 1937 Martin R-18, arch top
with F holes $1,200; 1920 Weyman Guitar Banjo

WHY

$1,250; BANJOS: 1900 Fairbanks Electric$2,000;
1880 Buckbee fretless, Gut strung, eagle brackets
$650; MANDOLINS; Gibson F-2 $1,600; 1993
Stiver A model $1,500. And more. Bob Smakula,

Salem,

Smakula Fretted Instruments, PO Box 882, Elkins,
WV 26241, 304-636-6710, email: smakula@meer.net.

ads at the cost of 35 cents per word,

Recordings, Books, Instruction
WHEN THE CACTUS IS IN BLOOM, the new
recording from Bob Bovee and Gail Heil on
Copper Creek features old-time cowboy songs,
Ozark tunes, and more. To order (CD only), send
$15.00 plus $2.00 shipping to Bob Bovee &amp; Gail
Heil, 18287 Gap Dr., Spring Grove, MN 55974.
CLOSE TO THE HEART, the latest from West

Virginia singer, Bob Heyer. "Sincere, heartfelt
and

old-time

well performed

ballads and

blues". ..County Sales. CD $16 postpaid. Table
Rock Music, 501 National

OLD-TIME

Road, Wheeling,

WV

www.clawhammer.com/

26003. bheyei@ovis.net,
tablerock.

MANDOLIN INSTRUMENTALS

Little River Stomp by the Buckhannon

Bros. 25

minutes long. CDs $15.00, cassettes
$10.00 plus $1.00 shipping. Make check payable
to Dennis Buckhannon. Write: The Buckhannon
Bros., PO Box 6165, St. Charles, MO 63302-6165.
tunes,

73

PRIVATE COLLECTION SALE: BACK ISSUES

-OTH, OT Country, 78Q, Living Blues,

Juke Blues,

Detroit Blues, others. CDs, box sets, LPs, videos,

books

All musical genres. Everything new or

mint condition.

Prices reasonable/negotiable.

Free list. Raffi Dokmeci, 58-47 210 Street, Bayside,
NY 11364. (718) 428-4601.

FLATFOOTING
TIONAL VIDEO by
27

steps, beginning

WORKSHOP

INSTRUC

Bernstein. 1-3/4 hours,
advanced. Easy to follow.

Ira
to

Each step clearly broken down and taught. Also
includes 3 performed pieces. Step manual and 2

different concert performance videos also avail
able. Inquire: 179 Flint St.,

Asheville, NC 28801.

828-255-9393; IraTenToe@aol.com.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

BE IN PAIN? Bodywork for musicians,
singers and dancers. Gentle, non-intrusive, yet
powerful and lasting. Nancy Crooks, Winston-

NC;

www.handspringbod5rwork.com.

336-722-3350.
The

Old-Time Herald will accept classified
minimum

$5.00. Any grouping of letters or numbers is
counted as one word. All ads must be received
by the first of the month,
publication.

6

weeks

prior

to

�Reviews

Breton fiddler Theresa MacLellan's
or the slippery minor "Moc
Carswell"
"Captain
casin Two-Step" from Joe Robichaud of New
Hampshire are captivating in a way thatbrushes
of

The Art of

Traditional
Fiddle

Cape

aside all regional bias. It's just great, well-played,
beautiful traditional fiddle music. There are cuts
where feel the fiddler steps past the bounds of

Various Artists

I

taste, but those are personal evaluations. We
can't all like the same things, but we can all

Rounder 1592

Greene: Hunky Dory /Theresa MacLellan:
Captain Cars well /jerry Holland: New Market

Alva

Reel/ Snake Chapman: Rock Andy /Buddy Tho
mas: Yellow Barber/Jim Woodward: Midnight/
Gerry Robichaud: Bouctouche Reel/St. Anne's

probably find much to like on this recording.
Wilson has devoted much time and effort to
preserving the music of Kentucky and Missouri,
so it's no

surprise that these two states contrib

ute ten and eight selections
album. The Northern styles

I

respectively to the
mentioned above,

Reel /Theresa Morrison: Inganess Medley//im
Herd: Dance All Night With a Gal With a Hole in

Canadian and New England, provide ten more.
Though the majority of the cuts are available on

Her

other CDs of the North American Traditions

Cooper: Bostony /Fred
Art Galbraith: Lay
Waltz/
Stoneking: Blackberry
YourGood Money Down/ Joe Robichaud: Mocca
sin Two-Step/Rm/ Hilt: Portsmouth Winder/
Howe Teague: Wabash Foxtrot//oe Cormier: Clay
Pipe Medley /Darley Fulks: Snowstorm//oe
Maclean: Nancy Graham Townsend: Lucy
Campbell/ Walker Street /Violet Hensley: Uncle

Stocking/Roger

Billy Stamper: Martha Campbell /Lonnie
Robertson: Lonnie's Breakdown/Lnrri/ Riendeau:

Henry

Pied du Mouton /Harold Zimmerman: Crow

Le

Call

/Dwight Lamb: The Hiram Allen Tune/
Annadene's Waltz /Carl MacKenzie:

J.P.Fraley:

Robert Cormack, Aberdeen Medley

Wilson Dou

glas: Old Christmas Morning /George Hawkins:
Rat's Gone to Rest /Ray Curboiu: Pig Ankle Blues/
Alton Jones: Milk Cow Blues/Paul Smith: Devil

Groundhog/Bob Holt: Rattlesnake

Eat the

Rounder's North Ameri

Here's one of the latest

in

can Traditions series,

CD that gives us

a variety
fiddle music once common through
out the U.S. and Canada. Producer Mark Wilson's

of

styles

a

of

field recordings span nearly 30 years of his quest
to

document the disappearing sound

of

genuine
folk fiddle. Not every aspect can be covered in
only one disc, of course, but there is a wealth of music
here that entices the listener to dig for more.
Clocking in at something over 70 minutes, the
CD certainly gives you your

tunes.

I

money's worth

must admit, with some shame, that

I

of

am

not generally inclined toward Northeastern
fiddle styles. Still, I found myself thoroughly

enjoying the pieces included here.

Tire

stateliness

Please send all items for review to: OTH,
PO Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717. DO
NOT send items to individual reviewers.
The OTH does not return

unsolicited mate

review. We do not guarantee that
we will review unsolicited material.
rial for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

se

few come from out-of-print albums and
ries,
seven more have never before been issued.
a

Certainly one of the most influential players
collection, one who has inspired countless
fiddlers who have followed, is Buddy Thomas.
His "Yellow Barber" is one of the tunes most
copied, but nobody plays it like Buddy. Wilson
in this

Douglas, the only West Virginian included, is
another of the more widely known fiddlers on
this CD and his "Old Christmas Morning" is a
typically crooked West Virginia tune. Bob Holt's
piece was recorded live at a Missouri square
dance. Though lacking somewhat in sound qual
ity, it provides us with a perfect example of old
time fiddle in its natural surroundings. The

power of Holt's fiddling, the command of Lonnie
Robertson, the fine lilt of northern players like
Jerry Holland and Joe MacLean, the primitive
and expressive style of Alva Greene's "Hunky
Dory" accompanied only by fiddlesticks are
magical moments, pure enjoyment that leaves
me awestruck at the same time. Every cut de
serves praise, but there are too many for that.
There are a couple others I feel I need to mention.
Jim

Woodward plays the highly unusual bluesy
tune he learned from black fiddler

"Midnight,"

a

Jim Booker

who recorded

in

the

1920s with

Taylor's Kentucky Boys, and this link to black
music is evident in other cuts, too. Dwight Lamb,
an Iowa fiddler who would place himself with
the Missouri camp, plays "The Hiram Allen
Tune," the sort of throwback that reminds us of
a time when Northern and Southern fiddle styles
had more in common.
Mark Wilson has done

a

magnificent

job

put

ting together this recording and I can imagine
him agonizing over his countless hours of tapes
to make the choices of what to include. The notes
for

the whole

introduction

album

should

be

exemplary, but the
mandatory reading for

are

anyone who takes up fiddle playing, who listens
to fiddle recordings, who wants to know what
fiddle music is for anyone who thinks they do
already. The album profile supplied to review
ers by Rounder with the CD paraphrases some
of these notes: "The armies of violin instructors,
the PBS

documentaries, the simplified tune col

lections have managed, through the best of in
tentions, to obscure from our notice the contours
thatmake genuine folk violin playing truly evoca
tive. There are many CDs on the market today
that claim to represent 'traditional fiddling' in

some fashion or other, but most of these stand at
several layers of interpretive remove from the
pungent music presented here." Amen. If you
want the real thing as an excellent introduction
to traditional fiddle, a collection of superb and
mostly rare tunes to learn from, or just a great
album of fiddle music for listening, I'd be hard
put to think of a better choice than this CD. We
all owe our deep gratitude to Mark Wilson and
Rounder

for

offering the North American Tradi

tions series and helping to

document this price

less heritage.
BOB BOVEE

�Happy Rolling Cowboy/I'm Getting Ready to Go/
Low Down Dog/Rotten Lettuce/Bonaparte's Re
treat/Bad Boy/Random Canyon/ You Got to Find
Me/Lazy Bones/Nova/Coldest Woman/Year
of Jublio/Sweet Lucy /Impossible Groove /Syn
Must

ergy /Robbin' Banks/Slurf Song/Everything

Go/Goodbye

to

Booze/She's More

to Be

Pitied

inspiration came from "Grandpa Jones, Charlie
Poole, Little Richard, The New Lost City Ram
blers, Robert Graves, Lenny Bruce, Donald Duck,

electric bands augmented with percussion and
wind instruments. Notable performances include
Stampfel and Weber's bellowed and honked

various roots and herbs, and everything else."
He also stated that Weber's musical influences
included the guitar techniques of Elizabeth

deconstruction

Cotten and were developed
Bamba" for

level

18

by

playing

"La

continuous hours. Their simulta

"Bonaparte's Retreat," a hal
of jug band music expressed
on "Low Down Dog" ("Don't you know I'm
and
from DaNang/I just wanna let it hang.
of

lucinogenic vision

of "Baltimore Fire" that was filtered
bong water to produce Nova. The
uniquely bent (as opposed to twisted) composi
tions of Michael "Snock" Hurley and the late

a

version

musicianship on this recording
from
ranges
abysmal to unspeakably brilliant.
But that's not the point. The songwriting runs
the gamut from sophomorically scatological to
incomprehensible to inspired genius. But that's

neous expression of reverence and irreverence
for American musical traditions alienated folk
music aficionados, enthralled people who were
and confused

Jeffrey Frederick are featured prominently. Songs
such as "You Got to Find Me" and "Robbin'

not the point, either. What is the point? Indeed,
"what made my hamburger disappear?"

evolved into

Banks" receive energetic, strutting performances

The

of

The core of the Holy Modal Rounders is

a

duo

and Steve

consisting

of Peter

Weber

1942). The Holy Modal Rounders (Pres

(b.

Stampfel

(b. 1938)

tige-Folklore 14031) and The Holy Modal Round
ers/Two (Prestige 7410) were some of the earliest
(1963-64) recorded efforts of post-war urban
musicians who immersed themselves

in

tradi

able

to

decipher their sociopolitical message,
everyone else. The Rounders

a
loosely knit multi-generational
musical and artistic community that, after 40
years of American cultural upheaval, is still true

to its anarchistic vision of the relationship between
popular culture and serious individual expression.
A recent discussion on rec.music.country .old-time

evoked the descriptors of "garbage," "genius,"
and "mental enema" for their music, suggesting
the continued vitality of their vision. "Life is

tional rural and early commercial country music
of the 1920s and 1930s, but chose neither to alter

short, art

the music to obtain commercial

Heritage series, is a re-issue of characteristic
material from mid-career and recent recordings

did

the Kingston

Trio)

acceptance

(as

nor duplicate vintage
(as did the New Lost

recorded performances
City Ramblers). Instead, they chose to re-create,
to the best of their imperfect technical abilities,
the "feel" of the old recordings

as

interpreted
through their own experience. This allowed
Stampfel to state with conviction that his musical

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

long."
part of the Rounder

The present collection,

including Alleged

in Their Own

ney, Have Moicy, Spiders

in

Time, Long Jour
Moonlight, Peter
Going Nowhere Fast,
the

Stampfel and the Bottlecaps,
and Too Much Fun. Configurations range from

raucous Weber-Stampfel duets and Luke Faustpowered banjo/jug bands to loose-jointed

through

that accentuate

the

nose-thumbing joyousness

material. Hurley and Frederick
display expressive baritone voices and stilettosharp satirical songwriting skills. Hurley's child
like, Cajun-spiced chronicle of the progress of a
communal meal through the communards is
worth the price of admission. Listeners who
of their subject

have dismissed the Holy Modal Rounders on
musical grounds may wish to seek out solo
material from these artists.
The recordings were digitized

at

24-bit

reso

lution from the original master sources. The
resulting sound quality is uniformly excellent,
exceeding the quality of the original issues. The
CD packaging includes an essay by John Swenson
(co-producer of Going Nowhere Fast) offering
of the Rounders' place

humorous appraisal

(continued

a

in

on next page)

�the pantheon of eccentric American creative art

ists, as well as vignettes that strain credibility.

Then-and-now portraits of the protagonists and
unreconstructed hard-core hippie art complete
the package.
This collection is an excellent introduction
of

work that

to

ignored by nearly
unique body
everyone, with the exception of people who
have made a self-motivated journey to the roots
of 20th-century popular musical culture. Many
OTH readers who have made this journey have
inadvertently stumbled upon the Holy Modal
a

is

Rounders, and have been drawn inexplicably
into their musical world. "You don't know, but
da guru do.
STEVE SENDEROFF

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�vocals; Win Grace: autoharps, piano accordion,

pi

ano, vocals; Leela Grace: banjo, harmony vocals; Ellie
Grace: mandolin, harmony vocals; Cathy Barton and

Dave Para: harmony vocals; David Horner, Jr.: snare
drum; Hideaway Chorus: Ron Gurul, Beth Horner,
David Horner, Sr., John Frederick Horner, Julie

Owens, Leela and Ellie Grace
Roses

Prince

of

Charlie/Nellie

Mine/Hideaway/Wildwood

of

Bly/Child

Flower/High At

mosphere/Chicken Song/Shady Grove/Ways
of the World/I Sit Beside the Fire/Durang's
Hornpipe/Little Dutch Girl/My Name Is Mor
gan, But It Ain't J.P. /Cowboy's Sweetheart/
Wait for the Wagon/Come Thou Fount/Wreck of
the

Number Nine/Ida Red /Farewell My Friends

This CD, Paul and Win Grace's sixth recording,
of their last duet effort, Fifty Miles of

reminds me

Elbow Room, recorded

back

to

back in 1987. They are
their old instrumental combinations and

to much more traditional material. Their
vocals and harmonies have matured and are as

back

strong as ever. Old-time music fans will enjoy
the fiddle tunes and the old songs.
The quality of the recording is excellent. The
mix is professionally done and sounds great.
The liner notes are extensive. Paul and Win have
documented their sources very well.
The material ranges from a Bonnie Prince
Charlie tune, "The Roses of Prince Charlie" to
old standards like "Nellie Bly" which has the

classic Paul and Win sound from years ago, to
more modem material by the likes of Bill Staines and
Robin and Linda Williams, and humorous songs

Old-time music fans will love "Shady Grove,"
from the Volo Bogtrotters.
Paul and Win play for old-time dances in their
neck of the woods in Missouri. It's a strong,
exciting string-band sound.
the major version

Paul and Win always have
such as

"I

Sit

Beside the Fire,"

a
a

few surprises,
J.R.R. Tolkien

poem, from the Fellowship of the Ring, set to music
by Don Leady. Win sings lead and plays
autoharp. Paul sings harmony and plays guitar.
One of my favorite cuts on this CD is "Durang's

Hornpipe"/ "Little Dutch Girl" because

of Paul's

fine fiddling. Win started out on piano as a child and
she accompanies him in the contra dance style here.

After hearing all the Patsy Montana wannabes
in yodeling contests over the years, I wasn't

when she was

17. Cathy Barton and Dave Para
add their harmonies to those of the Grace family

and the sound will make the hair stand up on

your neck.
There is much more traditional material on
this recording than there has been on their last
two CDs with their daughters Leela and Ellie.

Paul and Win have that uncanny ability to find
songs and tunes and get them worked up into

good solid musical performances.
It's fun to listen to Win play accordion. I've
known these folks for years (is it decades al
ready?) and when I first saw them perform, Win
was the only person I knew who was playing
piano accordion in a folk or old-time group.
Here in the upper Midwest, accordions are used
in polka bands or by solo performers who play
old songs in family settings. Win was using it for

looking forward to another version of
"Cowboy's Sweetheart" but Paul adds a har
mony yodel and the whole song moves along in
a
stately way. Win's accordion is perfect on this

melody and bass

country swing-style song.
Paul &amp; Win have been playing Little House

of

really

on

music now and then over the years.
"Wait for the Wagon" is a very old song that
actually goes back to the pre-Civil War minstrel
the Prairie

era. Paul's lead

singing

is

perfect

taken into

a

in

old-time fiddle tunes. Her

smooth and natural; her
clean
autoharp style
pinch, thumb-lead or
cross-picked. I like her autoharp backup, a kind
are

is a

mandolin-style chop. Paul's performances on
guitar, fiddle and mandolin are seasoned and
sure. His fiddling is strong and rhythmic. You
get it all with Paul and Win
great singing and
wonderful instrumentals.

for this song.

parlor with Paul's
fiddle and Win's accordion, which sounds like
an old foot-pumped reed organ, on another of my

We are

accordion leads

rural

favorites "Come Thou Font of Every Blessing."
"Farewell My Friends" was written by Ellie

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

PAT WALKE

11990 Barnes Chapel Rd, Columbia
MO 65201-8857; 573-443-2819; pgrace@coin.org;
To order:

www.folkfire.org/graces
(continued

on next page)

�"Ducks on the Pond" and "Julie Ann Johnson"

Gandydancer
Jim Martin

Productions,
JMP201

Gerry Millies: fiddle, banjo, guitar, jaw harp, vocals;
Dave Bing: fiddle, banjo, mandolin, guitar, vocals;
Ron Mullenex: banjo, mandolin, vocals; Mark Payne:
banjo, guitar, vocals; Jim Martin: bass

Shaking Down the Acorns/New Money-Cherry
River Rag/Walkin' in the Parlor/Jo Bones/
Greenbrier River/The T wo Sisters Hell Up Coal

Holler/Bully

the

of

Boozefighters/Ducks

Town/Crazy
on the

Pond/Julie Ann

Johnson/The Federal Soldier/Big
Picked Up

A

Hammer and

Head/Trouble

On

My

I

Creek/
Scioto/I

Knocked Him

in the

Mind/Jenny

Get

Around/Piney Mountain/John Henry/Come
All You Lonesome Ramblers Sourwood Moun
tain/Dusty Miller/Little Pink/I'd Rather Be An
Old-Time Christian
what the heck

Around

second could just be forgotten. There is an a
cappella piece called "The Booze Fighters," a
version of The Fruit Jar Guzzlers' "Kentucky
Bootlegger" but quite different. Nearly all of the
selections are traditional music, always presented
in a way that is respectful of the sources. Through

styles differ in a way that is subtle and hard to
describe. Both are smooth and rhythmic, both
are rich in unison strings and double stops, but

just right; instruments don't drown out voices
and vice versa. Jim Martin deserves special men

still identifiably different. They fit together perfectly
and never more so than on this particular number.

of the

If the two-fiddle sound is a hallmark, it's by
no means the band's only strength. Fully half of
the selections on this disc are vocals. Gerry sings

lead on most, with Dave, Ron, and Mark provid
ing close harmony, but the others take the lead
often enough to make it clear that this is not a
band that relies on one person for the vocals.
Gerry's version of "Walkin' in the Parlor" was
collected from fellow West Virginian Jim Knicely
and includes

a

clever dig

at

industrialist

J.D.

Rockefeller. Dave sings lead on "Jo Bones,"
learned from Maggie Hammons. Mark sings "I
Picked Up A Hammer and Knocked Him in the

railroad worker, someone who "danced" all day
with tools made by the Gandy Manufacturing

Head," a Don Stover piece, in the tongue-incheek humorous style that Stover personified.
Ron does a plaintive rendition of "The Federal
Soldier" and "Come All You Lonesome Ram

Co. Today, it means five of West Virginia's finest
musicians, each well known for his individual

blers," with nice harmony by Mark on the latter.
The four combine for the nicest rendition of "The

talent, now combined to make a whole that
seems greater than the sum of its parts.
This all started in 1997 when Ron Mullenex

Two Sisters" I've heard in

issued

friends Gerry Milires, Dave Bing, and Mark Payne
for help with that tape. Not exactly the first time

"Piney Mountain," written some years back by
Craig Johnson of the Double Decker String Band
Based on the life of an ex-fiddler who Craig met
at Galax one year, this piece shows how power

these guys had played together
they've all been
on the West Virginia music scene for 30 years or

and contrived wordsmi thing that

Gandydancer--

is that?

the turn of the last century, the word meant

a

a

new tape, Sugar in My Coffee (JMP 0040,
Productions). Ron enlisted long-time

Jim Martin

a
long time, reminis
cent of the late Kilby Snow's version.
The most compelling vocal on this disc is

ful

a

song can be when

it

lacks the preaching tone
is so

common

struc

so. Making Ron's tape brought the realization of
how well, and in how many ways, they fit to

in

gether. Not long afterwards, Jim Martin joined
in on bass. They were a big hit at several concerts

sage. We can only hope that more people will
record some of Craig's material, and hope that

and dances. Now, after

they do as good

a

few festival appear

recent tour of England, they have
released their first CD.
ances and

a

It's risky to say who plays what in this band.
Instruments get traded around quite a bit. But
one very prominent feature, maybe the defining
one, is the smooth, fluid twin-fiddle sound of

Gerry and Dave together. That sound kicks things
off with the first two selections. Ron and Mark

provide clawhammer banjo and guitar, respec
tively, on those cuts and on most of the other

two-fiddle pieces. Nearly all of those are West
Virginia tunes, including some well-known ones
like "Shakin' Down the Acorns" and some notso-well-known ones like Henry Reed's "Hell Up
Coal Holler." There's

also one called "Crazy
only as a "hot new tune"

identified
without naming the source, leaving us to won
der if the boys made this one up themselves.
Creek,"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and the second the straight-vanilla version that
we all learned in Banjo 101. I've heard the first

appear as a medley, with the latter played at the
upbeat tempo that has come to be standard for
this tune at festivals. Personally, I prefer the
more laid-back pace of the Emmett Lundy origi
nal, but this has the Gandydancer stamp all over
it. If I had to pick a favorite of the twin-fiddle
selections, it would be the "New Money-Cherry
River Rag" medley. Gerry and Dave's fiddle

today's songwriting. It is simple
ture and in the bare-naked honesty

a

job as Gandydancer

in its

of its

mes

does with

"Piney Mountain."
Ron and Mark do the lion's share of banjo
playing on this disc, and they complement each
other well. Ron is well known for his clockwork

clawhammer playing, and it contrasts nicely
with Mark's more aggressive, edge-of-bluegrass
fingerstyle, strongly reminiscent of Don Stover's
playing. The two are tastefully blended together
"Big Scioto." But Dave plays banjo on "Jo
Bones" and Gerry on "Little Pink," so there is
plenty here for banjo enthusiasts.
in

There's
There's

a

a

lot more

to

like about

this disc.

wonderful tune called "Greenbrier

River" that Gerry learned from Dena Knicely,
wife of Jim Knicely, that she attributes to an old
black fiddler she knew when she was a child.
a
medley of two versions of "Sourwood
Mountain," the first a relatively uncommon one

There's

and

before,

I

like it so much that

I

wish the

out, the rhythms are rock-steady and the mix

is

tion for his superb engineering. Brief discussion
tunes is included in the liner notes, which

do not require

magnifying glass and

halogen
multiinstrumentalists, with deep connections to tra
ditional sources, doing a wide range of material.
lamp

to

a

read. This

is a

versatile band

a

of

DAVE SHOMBERT

To order: Jim Martin
St.

Productions, PO Box 152,

Albans, WV 25177. $15.00

$1.50 shipping.

�read most of the liner notes, which are primarily
Japanese. I almost fell for the "brothers" gag

in

and I'm left wondering what other old-time
humor may have escaped my notice. One excep
tion to the Japanese notes is that for the fiddle
tunes there are names listed in English. In fact,
this list of sources reads like a folklorist hand
book to southern fiddling: five from West Vir

ginia; three from Mississippi; two from North
Carolina; one from Virginia; one from Tennes
see; and one from Kentucky. The only thing

missing was the more boisterous and ragged
influence of the North Georgia string bands.
Most of the fiddlers cited have been dead for
some time, implying hours of diligent study of
source material, which is probably not a bad
way to learn the music whether you live hal fway
around the world or not. In addition, the fiddle
and banjo tunings are provided in English.
The solo vocalist has a pleasing voice well

suited

to the

material, but not particularly pow

erful by old-time, bluegrass, or gospel standards.

Having near complete ignorance of traditional
Japanese music, I am unable to determine if the
five Japanese songs are traditional or more mod
ern compositions. The liner notes were not help
ful in figuring this out.
Included at the end of the CD are two bonus

bootleg tracks with John Herrmann on banjo
and vocals. The only problem is that they sound
like bootleg recordings. Otherwise, there is a
generous amount of high quality material and
the
the

production is excellent; more importantly,
musicianship is superb.
ED NORMAN

To Order:

Billiken, 1735 Old Mocks ville Road,
Statesville, NC 28625; billiken@statesville.net

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�band accompaniment and these are probably
the only commercially recorded examples of
white Holiness singing. Phipps was a preacher
in the Free Holiness Pentecostal Church and the
exuberance of that sect is evident in the record
ings, especially the second session where they

were billed

Phipps and His Holiness

as Ernest

Singers. These cuts have four singers with fiddles,

banjo, guitar, mandolin, and piano, along with
hand clapping on some numbers that makes you
feel you're in the midst of a revival. This is

definitely ragged but right gospel music.
McVay and Johnson were members of Ernest
Phipps' band who went off on their own to
record for Columbia Records. Their single 1928
release is the pairing "Ain't Going to Lay My
Armor Down" and "I'll Be Ready When the
"
Bridegroom Comes, Pentecostal standards sung
to the

accompaniment

some
music available.
tar, and is

of the

of fiddle, banjo and gui
finest string-band gospel

The CD has acceptable sound quality, and the

brief notes we've come
ment.

If

to

expect from Docu

fan of old-time gospel music

you're
already
a

and don't

wouldn't expect you

have these recordings, I
to hesitate a minute before

ordering this CD. And if you're not religiously
inclined, you should check this out to under
stand the power of this music. It's not hard to see
why those revivals gain so many converts.
BOB BOVEE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�festivals sound homogenous. To bring the argu
ment down to earth (without casting aspersions
upon superbly skilled, dedicated musicians!), it
seems everyone has

twelve-inch pot banjo,

a

favorite selection is "Silver Dagger," a stately,
mournful vocal duet flavored with droning but
ton accordion. The deeply moving vocal perfor
mance is utterly without calculated affect or

plays very cleanly over the neck, "chucks" a lot,
and listens to the same recordings. Perhaps our
musical community needs a dose of "real musi
diversity," as advertised in a prominent Penn
sylvania college radio station call-letter an
nouncement. The Old Crow Medicine Show

irony, and raised the hair on the back of my neck.
Chad Crumm employed two microphones, a
DAT machine, and a living room to make the

cal

appears

to

recognize neither artificial stylistic

recording. It has the feel of a well-made field
recording with all the clarity and balance neces
sary to convey the musical and emotional con
tent. No post-recording processing or mixing is
apparent, and the slightly primitive sound en
hances the impact of the material.
The CD cover features a moody dichromatic

divisions within traditional music nor modern
stylistic trends within old-time music, and is will
ing to provide this diversity with a vengeance.
Eutaiu, named for a city in Alabama on the
Tombigbee River that served as a rest stop for
the band after busking in New Orleans, is an
attempt to re-create and capture the raucous
musical anarchy produced by a rural string band

sitting

in

front of

a

image

microphone during an early
as opposed to an at

reproduce faithfully all of the musical
of an old recording. Eutaw may not
all readers of the OTH. The musical
to
appeal
approach of The Old Crow Medicine Show bears
more than a passing resemblance to that of the
Holy Modal Rounders, punk-folk chameleons
to

nuances

possibly the Fugs. While com
petent, none of the band members is an instru
mental virtuoso. Issues of in tona tion and precise

Cordelia's Dad,

or

rhythmic underpinning) and "Down South
a knife-edge between ragged
and
cacophony. But the Old Crows
intensity
have managed to assimilate the ethos of rural
string-band music to the degree that identifica
tar

Blues" balance on

is

superfluous. "All songs

traditional, arranged by OCMS" will suffice.
The first three cuts on this CD reminded me
why

I

became involved with this music

ago. The initial hearing was like having

20
a

of

years

cornu

copia of Americana emptied on my head. "Raise
a

Ruckus," "Tear

It

Down," and "Hesitation

Blues" are vocal driven, in-your-face evocations
of the raunchiest efforts of artists such as Charlie

Poole, The Chatmon Family, and Uncle Dave
Macon, presented with the hard-edged uncom
promising commitment of true believers. The

inclusion of ragged slide guitar in "Raise a
Ruckus" and the weaving of "Pig Ankle Rag"
around the lyrics of "Tear It Down" are delight
ful touches. The performance of kazoo-intensive
"Cocaine Habit" (Take a Whiff On Me) so per
fectly captures the rural jug band sound that

wondered

I

wife put a copy of one of my
Origin Jazz Library records on the turntable and
changed the source behind my back. "Shack #9,"
if my

recorded live at a farmers market, is a tribute
the West Tennessee tobacco industry. It's

to

an

eerily accurate evocation of the pre-song patter
and headlong frontal musical attack found on
Charlie Bowman and His Brothers' "Moonshiner

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

man in

a

field withwith an approach

members watching

a

pilot for

a

new cartoon. See

the projector light? That's Walt with the smirk
on his face," and is a comment on the transfor

mation by media corporations of traditional and
popular culture into inoffensive consumer prod
ucts. Unfortunately, credits for individual per
formers are not given for each track. A web site

www.crowmedicine.com

ensemble interplay are secondary to the genera
tion of excitement and explosive kinetic energy.
Manic, shouted, jug-band tinged versions of
"Boll Weevil" (powered by insistent banjo-gui

tion of their sources

of

ing storm at his back. The above-mentioned
Crow told me, "The photo on the inside [of the
CD insert] is of Walt Disney and his Board

1920s recording session,
tempt

and His Money" routine (Columbia 15387-D),
and makes me believe that Eutaiu is a pale image
of The Old Crow Medicine Show's live act. My

is

interesting, but

only tangentially informative.
Give this recording a listen. These guys rock.
STEVE SENDEROFF

To

Order:

Oakview

Old

Crow

Drive

Medicine

Nashville,

Show,
TN

crowmedicine@yahoo.com; 615-868-9457

381

37207;

�The Rough Deal

distinguish

instrumental

all of the

and

vocal

lines. The lyrics come through clearly; in only a
few places do any of the words get lost in the mix.

Stringband

The notes are brief. They list the selections, give
production credits and (more or less) identify

Unidentified
label CD 2001

the musicians.

(62:18)

We are told

who plays fiddle,

who plays banjo, who plays guitar, and who
sings but not on which selection. Since the

always play the same instru
ments, you can always tell who is playing, but
never who is singing.
The Rough Deal Stringband is not an Ameri
can string band, but you wouldn't know it from
the sound of the music. Although Tim Rogers is
band members

Tim Rogers: fiddle, vocals; Ben Keogh: guitar, vocals;
Bill Whelan: 5-string banjo

Cotton Eyed Joe/Wild

Bill

Jones/Buffalo Girls/

Cruel Willie/Raleigh and Spencer/Happy Hol
low/Tennessee Stud /Sail Away Ladies Greasy

Rabbit/Been All Around The
World/Rock of Ages/Grey Cat/Icy Mountain/
Old Dan Tucker/Boll Weevil/Booth/Sandy
String-Rooshin

Boys/Hard Times
instrumentation throughout this album of
old-time string-band music is simple and
straightforward; a fiddle carries the melody

from the United States,

flatpicked

a

guitar bass line while

a

clawhammer banjo provides backup and coun
terpoint melody. Such a formula could become
tiresome repeated for more than an hour over 18
selections, but these musicians keep the music
fresh and enjoyable by the use of subtle changes
in approach from selection to selection, i.e., a
solo fiddle introduces the selection, "Icy Moun
tain," and lays out the theme The banjo then

enters and the two instruments

restate the
duet until the guitar joins them and
adds a melody in counterpoint. On the selection
"Hard Times," the banjo opens with the melody
line, which it turns over to the fiddle, which then
melody

in

carries the melody gently behind the vocal and
between the verses. There are a

in the breaks

couple

of

selections,

"Happy Hollow"

in

par

ticular, which go on long enough and without
enough variation to not entirely avoid being

repetitious. This is a minor matter, however.
The Rough Deal Stringband's approach to
performance emphasizes the music rather than
the musicians
tar

there are no flashy banjo or gui
solos on this album. Some of the songs are

performed slower than usual. "Old Dan Tucker"
is taken at a relaxed pace with a gentle swing. It
approach they use to good effect. Twothirds of the selections are vocals. The songs

is an

include familiar pieces, such

as

"Tennessee Stud,"

"Wild Bill Jones," "Cotton Eyed Joe," and "Old
Dan Tucker." There are also less well-known

selections. "Cruel Willie"
the familiar

is

a

song dealing with
'em" theme

"love 'em and leave

in this case, a woman gets the upper
hand rather abruptly. The singing is good
even if occasionally a little thin on the higher

except that,

notes.

But this is not

really old-time

accompaniment

a

singer's album; this is
music with vocal

string-band

not the other way around.

The recording quality is good and the balance
is excellent. Every selection on this CD has a

clear transparency that makes

it

possible

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

is

an Irish

band

of

They have also produced a very enjoyable CD that
a pleasure to listen to selection after selection.

The

above

this

musicians who, while
not born to the U.S. old-time music tradition,
have come to love it and have made it theirs.

composed primarily

A.V.
(no ordering information)

is

SHIRK

�approach to rhythm guitar playing, his intense
lead singing, and his keen, almost mystical sense
of vocal harmony. This compilation of his work
Folkways from 1964

for

to 1983

includes

a

com

plete reissue (with six previously unissued cuts
from the original sessions) of Folkways LP F2408,
Bluegrass, fondly remembered by many as an
important item in their early bluegrass curricu
lum, and an album that, with the passage of

from the sessions eventually came to the atten
tion of Folkways majordomo Moe Asch and the

album was ultimately completed with the addi
tion of eight cuts produced by the young team of
Peter Siegel and David Grisman. That session
featured Bill Keith, another young turk in the

bluegrass revolution beginning just then to take
shape, and bassist Fred Weisz. Keith's note for
note melodic approach to banjo is in marked

time, continues to grow in importance. It's high
time these recordings were made widely avail

contrast

able again, and Smithsonian/Folkways has done an
exemplary job of packaging this reissued material.

also nice

By the time of that

original 1964 album, Allen
had already participated in historically impor
tant, artistically outstanding, and commercially

successful

recordings

as

a

member

of

The

Osborne Brothers and Red Allen. The vocal trios
featuring Red, along with Sonny and Bobby
Osborne in that band were revolutionary for
their time, featuring as they

sometimes did their

"high lead" vocal harmonies. As these Folkways
recordings remind us, Red was a fierce and

powerful rhythm guitarist

in the style

defined

in early Monroe-style blueof the time, as well as a lead singer

bythebest guitarists

grass bands
with a rich, expressive style.
Equally important in the minds

of many to the
bluegrass was the work of Red's
early recording and performing partner, Tennessean Frank Wakefield, the man whom David
Grisman is fond of saying "split the bluegrass
mandolin atom." Red and Frank also shared an

evolution

of

uncanny feel for harmony vocals, much in evi
dence here. Checkout, for instance, their version
of "All the Good Times Are Past and Gone";

to Kuykendall's more traditional
Scruggs-based style. Both have their charms; it's
to be

reminded what

a

fine harmony

in
singer Kuykendall
strumental interplay with Wakefield on the
instrumentals "Catnip," and (especially) Frank's
signature tune "New Camptown Races" is a
was back then. Keith's

harbinger

of

a

newgrass revolution brewing.

Predictably enough, given their strongly in

dividualistic personalities, Red and Frank's part
nership was not to last long, dissolving later the
same year the Folkways album was recorded.
Red Allen then moved on to participate in an
other legendary and seminal band that included
J.D. Crowe and Doyle Lawson, to substitute for
time for an ailing Lester Flatt in The Foggy
Mountain Boys, and to perform and record with
his four talented sons, as well as performing with
various versions of Red Allen &amp; The Kentuckians.
Allen returned to record several more albums
with Folkways during the late 1970s and early
1980s. It is from these albums that the remaining
10 cuts on the present compilation are drawn.
There are several outstanding performances
a

among the remaining

10

cuts, including

a

wild

trio featuring Red, Curly Seckler, and Red's son
Harley on Flatt &amp; Scruggs' "I'm Waiting to Hear

Red's tenor singing on this cut takes listeners to
a rarified musical
atmosphere where the soul of

You Call Me Darling," another hair raising trio
on John Duffey's "Victim to the Tomb" featuring

man never dies and true believers are born. For

Red, Harley, and Kathy Chiavola. Other fine
vocal performances backed by all-star bands
brought together in the studio for each album
are also included. These are all particularly wel

all his

revolutionary innovations on mandolin,

Wakefield, whose lead voice
also has

a

is thin and

reedy,

firm grasp of harmony. Frank and Red

knew how

to

harmonize together

in

a

particu

larly supportive way. I've never heard Frank

sound nearly
these

as

good singing with anyone

cutswithRedAllen,butitisfar from

as on
a

one

way street; Frank's sympathetic harmonizing
enhances Red's performances as well. As project
producer Mark Yacovone remarks in his liner
notes: "One of bluegrass music's mysteries is
why some voices blend well and others don't,"
referring not only to Red and Frank but also to
the vocal contributions of bassist Tom Morgan
and banjo player Pete Kuykendall,
eight of the cuts from 1964.

featured on

The genesis of the original Folkways

record

ing, in fact, as the excellent liner notes explain,

was

an

attempt by sometime

producer

Kuykendall to document the version of Red
Allen &amp; The Kentuckians that included him and
Morgan for

a

rack jobber's special LP to be sold

drugstores and the like. The repertoire for the
project, Kuykendall says in the liner notes, was
largely drawn from a songbook of traditional
in

songs produced by Bill Clifton. The material

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

come, given the dearth of available Red Allen
material available today, but it is the stuff featur
ing Frank Wakefield that makes this compila
tion essential. Rebel Records is reportedly about
to

of Red Allen mate
Melodeon, County, and Rebel sessions,

release two albums' worth

rial from

which will be highly appreciated by fans and
students of early bluegrass. Sadly, the Osborne
Brothers and Red Allen material is not available
domestically, and hasn't been for years, making
this reissue all the more welcome.
RANDY PITTS

�doctrine

of celibacy. From their peak in the mid
1800s of about 6,000 members, their member

much information on the Shakers, their music
and their lifestyle along with considerable detail

ship gradually dwindled to practically nothing.
There are apparently a few still living, however.

about the circumstances of the recordings. The
booklet does not, however, give a clear overall

One Web site on Shakers tells us that there are

picture

seven Shaker women living today in New En
gland although "today" isn't identified and this
information may be out of date.
Disk
of this two-CD set consists of record
in 1960 (when more Shakers were
made
ings
available) of Shaker women performing 36 songs.
The second CD contains nine more performances
along with recorded interviews of Shaker women
made in 1960, 1972, and 1980. The music, which
is quite lovely, is also apt to be unfamiliar to

ing to readers not already well informed about
them. It is obvious that the Shakers represented

1

most listeners ("Simple Gifts" is not on this
album). The Shakers, like so many others, freely
used melodies of their own as well as any other
good tunes they could find laying around, but
the words were usually written by Shakers them

selves

guide them and

express their joy in
their faith. These songs were a vital part of
Shaker life and worship; it has been estimated
that there are as many as 10,000 Shaker songs
surviving in many song books and manuscripts
but many have never been published. The book
let that accompanies this album explains that
most of the music on it is later than the better
known mid-1 9th century Shaker music. Some of
to

to

the performances,

and

ticed

a

by accomplished
non-professional singers, are

if

while others

are

are also severa

d

1

ing combination

interested
music
much

in

accompanied on organ. There
uets for the unusual but engag
of piano

Shaker

any sort

of

prac

cappella

and organ.

music
for

that

or

Anyone

lovely sacred

matter

will

find

enjoy in these recordings.
This is not an easy album to just sit and enjoy,
however. Part of this album is drawn from a
to

reconstruction of a 1959 seminar on Shakers in
which Shaker music and lectures on Shaker life
were offered to the public. Later material is
presented in a similar format. Buta format which
is

suitable

for

seminars and lectures

is far

from

CD. Tracks containing the music also
include spoken introductions to the songs. These

ideal for

a

introductions certainly contain valuable infor
mation, but people who simply want to hear the
music are not likely to enjoy the constant spoken
particularly since the introduc

interruptions

tions are also transcribed verbatim in the

pro

gram notes. The lectures and interviews also

present problems. It is certainly good to be able
to hear the voices of the Shakers themselves
describing their lives and music. But, after an
initial hearing, few people are likely to return to
them for entertainment and this material would
be much more accessible to students in printed
transcription. All in all, one gets the distinct

impression that the producers of this album did
not have

a

clear idea of whom they expected to
in it and how such people might

be interested

want

to

The
of the

use

it.

extensive booklet contains the text

songs

as well as

of all

several articles that provide

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of the Shakers and is likely to be

confus

project considered their lives to be happy,
rewarding, and productive. But there are also
in this

numerous references to the Shakers diminish
ing in numbers and nowhere in the booklet, or
the recorded interviews for that matter, is the
reader given the slightest clue as to why this
happening. Nothing whatever is said about their
beliefs that made it impossible for the Shakers to
generate new members or why outsiders might
have been reluctant to join these happy people.
For all the booklet tells the reader, the Shakers

may be shrinking because their members are

gradually emigrating to Australia or being ab
ducted by aliens.
Physically, the album is quite well done, the
packaging consists of a slipcase containing a
two-CD case and the attractive booklet, which
has more than 70 pages of articles, photographs
and other illustrations. The sound quality var
ies, as you would expect from recordings made
under different circumstances. One or two of the

performances, which sprang spontaneously in
the course of the interviews, leave a little to be
desired, but in general, the sound is clear and
enjoyable.
A.V.

SHIRK

�Perusal of the liner notes indicates that Eriksen
does have a deep emotional commitment to his
material, and has wound a skein of personal
mythology around it.
The recording, made live using single point
microphone techniques without overdubbing
and minimal sonic processing, is warm and clear.

transmits the eerie impression that you are
sitting knee-to-knee with the performer in a
dimly lit kitchen while he shares his deepest
musical thoughts with you. A very striking
It

monochromatic image of
on the neck of

position
mountain banjo
ing. A

a

left hand in playing

a

Proffitt-Glenn

style

highlight of the CD packag
web site (www.eyelovemusic.com) pro
is a

vides links

to Tim's other musical activities. This
recording may not have broad appeal to OTH
readers steeped in string-band music and old
78s, but it is fascinating!
STEVE SENDEROFF

To Order:

West

Appleseed Recordings, PO Box 2593,

Chester,

PA

19380;

610-701-5755;

www.appleseedrec.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Sam McGee: guitar vocal, banjo-guitar; KirkMcGee:
fiddle, mandolin, banjo; Mazy Todd: fiddle; Uncle

here, though some tasty picking shines through.
Anyway, the band sound is charming, particu

Dave Macon: banjo (one track)

larly on "C-h-i-c-k-e-n"
You Open the Door?"

Buck Dancer's

Choice/The Franklin Blues/In

A

Could Only Blot Out the
Past/Knoxville Blues/Old Master's Runaway/

Cool Shady

Nook/If

I

Charming Bill/A Flower From My Angel
Mother's Grave /C-h-i-c-k-e-n Spells Chicken/
Salty Dog Blues/Rufus Blossom/Ragged Jim/
Someone Else May Be There While I'm Gone/
Hannah Won't You Open the Door?/My Family
Has Been A Crooked Set/The Tramp/Easy
Rider/Chevrolet Car/As Willie and Mary
Strolled by the Seashore/The Ship Without A

Sail/Brown's Ferry Blues/Railroad Blues
Sam McGee (1894-1975) has the distinction of
being the first guitar soloist in country music. He
was born near Franklin, Tennessee, into a rich
musical environment. His father and other rela

tives fiddled, and Sam started out on the banjo.
16 he got his first guitar and began

At age

exploring

it

as

a

solo instrument, melding ideas

from the African- American railroad hands who
took lunch breaks

at his

father's general store,

and parlor guitar as practiced by a local Franklin
doctor, John Merritt. Sam and his brother Kirk

also absorbed ragtime from player pianos at
cafes and dance halls, as well as ballads and old
songs from their mother.
Sam took up with Uncle Dave Macon in 1925,
accompanied him to New York for

and in 1926

recording sessions with Vocalion. These ses
sions gave us the outstanding solo pieces "Buck
Dancer's Choice," "The Franklin Blues," and
"Knoxville

Blues"

(with spoken

interjections

from Uncle Dave), and the sentimental songs
(vocal with guitar) "In A Cool Shady Nook" and
"If I Could Only Blot Out the Past." Charles
Wolfe tells us that McGee's laying down these
sides was on the initiative of the recording engi
neer, Jack Kapp, who heard Sam sitting around
picking between sessions. Sam was reluctant,

saying he "didn't think he was good enough,"
but happily Kapp had his way.
The 1926 guitar pieces display
fast, clean,

wonderfully
melodious picking. We can clearly

hear both the railroad hands and the parlor in
McGee's stylings. It's a pity he recorded so few

pieces

of this sort at the time. He

more stellar solos

in

another story).

Chicago

would cut two

this first stage of his career
in the folk revival of the
was
"rediscovered"
(he
1950s and went on to record LPs, but that's
the

In

in 1928 he

recorded

unstoppable "Easy Rider" on the banjo-gui

tar, and in

Richmond, Indiana,

in 1934

"Railroad

Blues." The latter became his signature piece,
and rightly so, as it showcases both his good

humor and his impeccable hot licks.
The balance of this reissue is made up of a
band session from 1927: the McGee Brothers,
featuring Kirk on fiddle, mandolin and banjo,
on guitar and vocals, with appearances
from Mazy Todd (fiddle) and Uncle Dave on
banjo. Sam's guitar is mostly in the background
Sam

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Thanks

to

Document

and

"Hannah Won't

for

making this fine

music available again.
ALLIN COTTRELL

and

NANCY CROOKS

�displays the more common styles and repertoire
associated in general with Anglo-American
square-dance fiddling. The fiddlers on the third
volume, most of whom were born and live in
Taney and Ozark Counties (Missouri) on the

Traditional
Fiddle Music of

theOzarks
Volume Three:
Down

in

the

Missouri-Arkansas border,

Border

Counties
Various Artists

Rounder 0437
Beeler Kate: Lee

Jim

Blues/Old

Joe

in

Breakdown/Finley

Dischord/Pretty

Creek

Polly/

Cluckin' Hen/Tar-Ria Waltz /Alton Jones: Jeff
City /Uncle Joe, Will Your Horse Pack Double/

Sadie/Mama Blues /Delaware County Blues/
Milk Cow Blues/Lost Indian/Jim Herd: Knock
Around the Kitchen/Twinkle Little Star/Ten
nessee Gray Eagle-T ennessee W agoner Betty Lou
Waltz: Hold Old Bald While I Dance With Josie/
Durang's Hornpipe/Noel Scott: The Branson

Rag/Rabbit,

Where's

Come Down

the

Last

Your Mammy?/Sally
Middle/Old Judge Parker/
Train Home/Hawk's Got a Chicken and

Flew in the Woods/Jess Silvey: Wake Up Susan/
Johnny, Pass the Jug /H.K. Silvey: Home Brew

Rag/Clark Waltz/Broke Down Gambler/Old
St. Joe/Old Fort Smith /Bill Conley: Goodbye,
My Honey, I'm Gone

These two collections, volumes two and three
a

trilogy

in

general, play

in

quite energetic tempos, and utilize brisk, em
phatic, bow strokes. In the process, the melody is

of

documentary recordings

of

of

contem

Ozark fiddling, present some fine ex
amples of a vital, if under represented, tradition
of Anglo-American folk music. Until these re

porary

cordings were made a few years ago and re
leased late last year, only scant attention by
folklorists and collectors had been paid to
most ot the record
fiddling in the region, and then,
were available
musicians
made
of
regional
ings
in folklife ar
them
those
who
found
to
only
or were lucky enough to obtain copies of
locally distributed so-called vanity LPs and tapes
made by local fiddlers. I, for one, am glad the

chives,

situation has changed.
For these CDs (and Volume

One Along

the

Eastern Crescent, Rounder 0435), producers Mark
Wilson and Gordon McCann have attempted to

stripped to the basics and broken into distinct
phrases that Wilson describes as "riffs." In any
case, this style, as it has evolved (or not, as the
case may well be), is well suited for the old-time
square dancing done

in the area.

Although the above generalizations do have
was struck by the vast differences in
approaches to playing in the styles I heard on
merit,

I

to fea
somewhat smoother playing and more re
laxed tempos on the hoedown pieces, there is a
great variety to be heard on both volumes, from
relatively simple and "archaic" melodies and

each disc. While Volume Two did seem
ture

triguing. Beeler also makes frequent use of the
AEAC# tuning, which brings an added intensity
to the tunes he plays, in particular "Cluckin'
was glad to see that some ex
Hen." Finally,

rhythmic structures to some that might be con
sidered highly sophisticated. All of this, it seems,
may be as much a reflection of the fiercely indi
vidualistic nature of Ozark folks and fiddlers as

amples of Alton Jones's fiddling have finally
made it onto CD for the world to hear. Though
his style shows the influence of his former neigh

else. Age apparently

anything

is not

factor

a

here. For example, on the second volume, Bill
Graves, born in 1919, employs one of the most
rustic and bare-bones styles I've ever encoun
tered, rendering the melody down to its most
basic components, using jagged bow strokes
that closely follow the irregularities of the tune
as he plays. Art Galbraith, born in 1909, on the
in a very smooth and almost
manner
that
elevates his music from the
genteel
dance floor to the parlor.
On Volume Three, Noel Boggs, in his late 40s
and the youngest fiddler included in this collec

com

plex, blues tunes. Bill Conley, another relative
youngster, plays in a style reminiscent of Bob
Holt's, while H.K. Silvey, who plays a mean
hoedown, puts his contest and bluegrass experi
ence to good use in the process. For me, this wide

pre-ragtime era"
in

ing

detail
of

in his

(a

notion that Wilson explores

extensive notes), while the play

the fiddlers

just

to

north

of

this

area

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

known hoedowns in A. Ray Curbow and Lacey
Hartje, neither of whom I'd heard play before,
are especially proficient when playing fiddle
rags. Bill Mustain, who unfortunately passed
away before this set was released, plays a good

version
niscent

of

"Willott's Hornpipe"

in

a

style remi

fact not surprising,
Stoneking,
because he grew up in close proximity to Fred
of Fred

a

found
Beeler's "riffing" approach especially in

and his father, Lee. On Volume Three,
Jim

I

of

does

worth the price
a

nice and very

what he calls "The Old-Time

Eighth of January" (mistakenly called "Lost In
dian" here), a tune quite similar to one Bob Holt
calls "The 9th of January."
a

These recordings were made over a period of
of years, in a rather scattershot manner

couple

as the
all the

producers' schedules allowed, and have
strengths and weaknesses one might ex

result. On the plus side, there is a great
of fiddlers, who for the most part ha ve
never been heard outside of regional events, or
pect as

a

in

by-track description of these CDs, there are a
few standouts here. On Volume Two, Dean
Johnston does a fine job on his spirited versions
of "Frisky Jim" and "Turkey Knob," two well-

counters "an urbanized dance music that dis
plays a high degree of black influence from the

unusual version

cially on "Rabbit, Where's Y our Mammy"; while
Alton Jones, in his mid-80s, utilizes a lot of lefthand slurs and favors more melodically

of "Sadie" is, for me,

of the set in itself. He also

sampling

eral musical characteristics can be noted in each

musicians, Wilson points out in his notes, there
is a marked difference in the playing and reper
toires of those in the Southern area (south and
west of Springfield, Missouri), where one en

rendering

tion, plays in a rough and ready hoedown style
one might associate with an older player, espe

variety of tunes and styles adds to the overall
appeal of these recordings.
While space considerations prohibit a track-

collections. On Volume Two, the com
mon musical bond is best described in terms of
shuffle bowing, more relaxed tempos and the
constant use of drones. Within this group of

bor, Lonnie Robertson, his playing is truly
unique. His bowing tends to be a bit more eco
nomical and his tempos more laid back. His

other hand, played

use geography as a basis to classify the musi
cians and playing styles they recorded, a diffi
cult task at best. Nonetheless, some overall gen
of these

I

some cases, their own communities. It is good
some well-deserved recog
nition. On the other hand, this approach, with
constraints imposed by time and distance, means
to see these folks get

that by necessity we may not always get the best
performances, and some folks may be over

looked

all

together.

have been nice

to hear

In
a

this instance, it would

bit more of Gary Johnston,

Bill Conley, all fine fiddlers
represented by but one cut apiece. But I'm not
going to complain. Maybe we can look forward
to more of them in the future. In the meantime,
these collections come highly recommended.

Leonard Smith, and

JIM

NELSON

�Mississippi Break-

savor." Well, here are the other three tunes they

down/'Possum on the Rail/The Last Shot Got
Him/Rufus Rastus/Ri/ Bros.: Honeysuckle

recorded, two waltzes and "Moonlight Clog."
The last of these is a four-part schottische that
dancers around where live would find irresistible.

Possum Hunters:

Mississippi

Waltz/Choctaw County Rag/Jake Leg Wobble/
Friday Night Waltz/Tuscaloosa Waltz/Missis
sippi Echoes /Home Town Waltz/ Winona Rag/
Got the Jake Leg Too/The Folks Back Home/
Mumford Bean b His Itawambians: Slow Time
Waltz/Flow Rain Waltz /Gene Clardy &amp; Stan
C/emmfs: Sleeping Time Waltz/BlackMustache/

Harvest Home Waltz/Moonlight
&amp; Curtis:

Clog /Milner
Evening Shade Waltz /Northeast Texas

Volume two

of

Document's Mississippi

String

Bands gives further evidence of the eccentricity
and diverseness of fiddle music from the Mag

nolia State. Although much of the music on this
release has been reissued previously (for ex
ample, on County's two-volume Mississippi
String Bands, among others), Document contin
ues its "complete" works approach and includes
many sides not available on other reissues.
The four sides by the Mississippi Possum

Hunters show the slippery, raggy side of Missis
sippi old-time on "The Last Shot Got Him" and
"Rufus Rastus." They switched fiddlers to record
the hoedowns "Possum on the Rail" and "Mis
sissippi Breakdown," sounding like a different
band. These cuts make you wish the band had
recorded more in both styles; they are absolute

classics.
Will Ray, fiddling with his brother Vardman
on guitar, treats us to some beautiful waltzes

played at real, as opposed to contest, waltz tempo.
I'm particularly fond of the elusive "Home Town
Waltz," but all the others are also excellent and
rare tunes. Will Ray had as fine a grasp of the
raggy and bluesy pieces as anyone, and few old-

time numbers are as quirky

Wobble."

as his

"Jake Leg

and a
unforgettable recording
dancer's nightmare! The Rays provide the only
vocals on the CD with the other song about the
It's an

crippling effects

of Jamaica

Ginger ("jake"), "Got

the Jake Leg Too," and their sentimental
sition "The Folks Back Home."
The greatest

compo

disappointments on this release

are the only two sides recorded by Mumford
Bean and His Itawambians. I figured such a

delightful

band name should

foretell

equally

compelling performances, but, once again, I'm
wrong. Bean, the fiddler who was only 12 or 13
at the time of these recordings, and his band
from Itawamba County waxed the two waltzes
with less than perfect intonation. These are not
awful sides; don't cringe or fast forward past
1

them, but they are definitely not up

standards of the rest
volume.

of the

to the

high

performances on this

Gene Clardy, one of the older fiddlers from
to record from what understand, is

Mississippi

1

have taught the tremendous Willie
Narmour to fiddle. After hearing one cut of
Clardy and guitarist Stan Clements on the County
reissue, Kerry Blech in his OTH review stated "I
said

to

surely wish we had more of his playing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

I

Finally, we come

to

Milner and Curtis and the

Magnolia Ramblers. Luke Milner and Luke
Curtis double fiddle the steppy "Evening Shade
Waltz" and "Northeast Texas," the latter an
"Wagoner," from a very
a worthy conclusion.
often complain about the sound quality on

infectious version

of

rare 78 bringing the CD to
I

CDs from Document, but I find this one to be
generally acceptable. There is, of course, some

surface noise, but not enough to distract most
old-time fans from this fabulous music. Tony
Russell's notes are well written and present a lot
think
of information in the small space allowed.
this will be among my favorite CDs for awhile.
I

BOB BOVEE

�quite nice, thank you.

I

expected

the musical

Now, calling
someone the "best" is a subjective practice, of
course, but any objective judge would have to
rate Mr. Stokes at or near the top in the fiddling
quality

to be

exceptional

all along.

field. Comparing apples and oranges, though, is
much easier (and less argumentative) than com
paring old-time fiddlers, so for now, let's just say
that Lowe's mark on the recording industry was
and is my favorite.
To learn about

Lowe's life,

I

suggest finding

a

copy of Old Time Music magazine no. 39, spring
1984, and reading Joe LaRose's interview

with

Lowe, or pick up this CD and read T ony Russell's
excellent six-panel biography and discussion of

Lowe's role

in the

(another panel

is

evolution

of

old-time music

taken up by Tony's discograthis CD and another by the

phy pertinent to
cover art). One of the points that Russell raises in
these notes is the origin of Stokes' (and his

compatriots in the Skillet Lickers and permuta
tions) recorded repertoire. It was already estab
lished that he was a highly esteemed North
Georgia traditional fiddler, gaining something
of a national reputation by being the model for
Stephen Vincent Benet's famous poem "The
Mountain Whippoorwill, or How Hill-Billy Jim

Won the Great Fiddlers Prize," which recounts,
using pseudonyms, how the youngish Stokes

bested the famous Fiddlin' John Carson
1924 Atlanta fiddlers' convention.

at the

Stokes and his partner in many bands, Clayton
McMichen, tried to read the winds of change (in
musical terms) and selected material to record
according to what they thought would sell well,

optimally bringing them fortune and fame. For
Stokes, at least, that meant recording popular
tunes and songs from his own and slightly ear
lier eras. Russell writes in the notes that six of the
tunes Stokes has "on this CD that can be traced
to

published sheet-music

riod 1911-20."

I

all

imagine that

a

come from the pe
similar analysis of

the Skillet Lickers may turn up similar percent
ages, for "Tin Pan Alley" seemed to be a recur
ring source

many
recording musicians
of that era, like Charlie Poole, Roy Harvey, those
in North Georgia, and many others. And frankly,
despite our most romantic notions about very
of the

for

quite consistent with those percentages. Russell
makes a case for Stokes being an agen t of change,
in a sense, as his young Turk fiddling wrested
the championship away from Carson's old guard;

Stokes and two

Stokes and company may also have been in the
vanguard in looking to more contemporary

Blues," and "Wagon Yard." April 1930, though,
brought Lowe back into the studio with Riley

material to record, rather than relying on older,
more traditional songs and tunes.

Puckett on the flattop as they tore through a
couple of Lowe's stellar breakdown tunes, "Katy
Hill" (which he called "Sally Johnson" here) and
his extra-beat version of "Billy in the Low
Ground." These two contain some of the finest

Stokes' first recordings as leader, Halloween
"Home Brew Rag" and "Unexplained

1927's

feature the jazzy clarinet of Stranger
Malone, with Hoke Rice on vocals, and though
Stokes does get in some memorable licks, he
seemed more to feature the others. A year later,
he waxed another pair, "Wave That Frame"
Blues,"

(with

a

rather unique melody, used again

a

year

vast majority of many we hold dear as "purist"

later by the Georgia Yellow Hammers for Bud
Landress's song "Rip Van Winkle Blues") and

musicians held similar material

the Clayton McMichen vocal "Take Me To the

old, rare, traditional music,

I

imagine

that the

as a significant
repertoires. Paul Wells of the
Center for Popular Music made a presentation at
a Tennessee
Folkore Society meeting in 1996
his
concerning
analysis of home recordings of

proportion

of their

fiddler Tommy Magness (who was raised not far
from the Stokes homeplace). His preliminary
figures show that about 15% of those tunes were
traceable to British or Irish origin, around 26%
derived

from 19th and 20th-century popular
music, and the remainder consisted of fiddle
tunes of American origin from the 19th and 20th

centuries,
tunes

in

as

well

as

then-recently-composed
that idiom but obviously more commer

cially oriented. Lowe Stokes' music

on this CD is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Land of Jazz," featuring some hot guitar-picking
by Perry Bechtel.
It

wasn't until Stokes' third session,

in

Octo

ber 1929 with guitarist Mike Whitten, that he
finally recorded music that was more "old-fash

under his own name, with "Katy Did"
(again, a rather unique melody-line, gorgeously
rendered by Stokes in C and A minor John
ioned"

Bert Layne

of his SL

cronies, McMichen and

put down some more

contempo

rary sounds with "Chesapeake
Bay,"
"Everybody's Doing It," "Left All Alone Again

old-time fiddling ever captured on shellac. That
same month, Lowe did another North Georgian
session, again taking the more modern route
with "Bone Dry Blues" and "It Just Suits Me,"
featuring Dan Hornsby's fluid lead vocals; but
a studio
group called the Pot
Lickers for some late 1930 sessions that pro
duced several rollicking old-time string-band
he also assembled

sides, after moving to the Brunswick label (all
previous sides had been for Columbia, also home
to the Skillet Lickers of that era). Tony Russell
depicts this session
cash

as

Brunswick's attempt

to

on the popularity of the more rustic
recordings of the Skillet Lickers. Stokes' fiddling
in

Lowland") and

is up front and in the lead, with Bert Layne's
fiddle tagging close behind, Arthur Tanner on
tenor banjo, and either Hoke Rice or Claude
Davis on guitar.

his lilting "Take Me Back to Georgia," also in the
key of C. A couple days later, though, his North

Essentially the same personnel waxed a couple
sides at that same session under the band name

Carson used the minor melody portion as
of his

recording

Georgians

band,

of "Billy in the

featuring

many of the Skillet Licker

three fiddles,

recordings

a

part

like

including

"The Swamp Rooters."

And

it is

(continued

these six cuts
on next page)

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

has just the right touch of religious
raucousness. The old and new honky-tonk se
lections leave this reviewer cold. I am of the
opinion that honky-tonk re-creators need to play
this style ferociously with instrumental and vo
Brothers

The

cal virtuosity

exceeding the original sources,

as

Country

epitomizedby the recordings of Wayne Hancock
or Big Sandy and His Fly-Rite Boys. Perhaps the

Stringband

Backstabbers exhibit this trait

Backstabbers

The recording

Run

tain Records

RMR001

Tom Parker: mandolin, guitar, vocals; Bob Hannan:

Tony Allen: fiddle, vocals;
guitar, autoharp,
Oliver
Thomson:
bass;
Bielefeld: accordion,
James
percussion; Burke Carroll: lap and pedal steel guitar,
vocals

Dobro; Sue McKay: banjo

Been All Around This World (Hang Me)/I Used
Love the Way You Walked (Until You Walked
Out Of My Life)/Just One Time/Old Plank

To

Road/Dark As

Dungeon/Sometimes She For
Cards/Never Will Marry/Gos

A

of

sip Song/Fraulein/Gathering

Every Day

I

Flowers/I'm Happy

Live/Starry Crown/Omie Wise
quintet from Toronto,
eclectic mixture of tradi

The Backstabbers,

Canada present
tional old-time standards, interpretations of preand post-war commercial country music hits,
and newly composed selections in the style of
late 1940s and 1950s shot-and-beer bar music of
the Williams-Frizell-Tubb

genre before Atkins/
art form. The

Nashville styling emasculated the
Backstabbers lack
an

a

accordionist,

full-time banjoist, but in
as was common in com

mercial country acts of the 1940s (for example,
later incarnations of the Carter Family).
This recording is an enthusiastic presentation
material much beloved by the band members
and its audience, but may have limited appeal to
of

authentic recreations

OTH readers seeking

or

exciting modern interpretations of traditional
and early commercial country music. While the
vocal and instrumental skill of all band mem
bers and guest musicians range from competent
to exceptional, their attempt to cover many sty

homogenous and incompat
exemplified in the open
All
ing Highwoods-influenced selection, "Been
listic bases leads

to

ible approaches. This is

Around This World." Allen's smooth, energetic

fiddling lacks the idiosyncratic rough edges one
finds adhering to traditional Appalachian fiddle
sounds, and Thomson's bass playing is of a
rhythmic and harmonic complexity inappropri
ate for the music. Calculated vocal mannerisms
mar Uncle Dave Macon's "Way Down the Old
a similar fashion. Merle Travis'
Dungeon" and Rose Maddox's "I'm
Happy Every Day Live" receive careful, melo
dious treatments that have more than a whiff of

Plank Road" in
"Dark As

a

I

a

folkie campfire,

of the guitar is lost as a result of muddiness in the
bass reproduction. Parker's mandolin is overly

prominent in its "rhythm-chop" role. suspect
these flaws may be a function of the final mixdown, rather than the musical skill of the en
semble. The final selection is an interesting, com
plicated arrangement of Doc Watson's "Omie
I

Wise" featuring sensitive solo fiddle, bass, and
Bob Hannan's mournful,

expressive vocal.
entertain

The CD package insert contains an

ing collage of band pictures, colorful portraits,

informative liner notes, and a brief essay con
cerning the jovs of making music among friends.
STEVE SENDEROFF

a

an

clude

show.

presumably using multiple close microphone
techniques. The overall band sound is warm and
the vocals are clear and well balanced, however,
some instrumental timbres are not well defined
within their sonic spaces and the chordal drone

Moun

gets/House

in their live

was done live in the studio,

in

a

non-pejorative sense

of the

term. However, "Starry Crown" from the Woodie

To Order: Run Mountain Records;

tom@thebackstabbers.org;

runmountain@hotmail.com;
www.tlTebackstabbers.org;

416-703-5949

�describe Ford and Morris.
Of the two musicians, Ford is much the more
appealing. His instincts were to entertain, and
he sings a variety of really funny songs with
as
clever topical lyrics (some or all of which
sume were his own) in an engaging wide vibrato
which might seem to label him as an older man
when he recorded, like Uncle Dave Macon or
Frank Stokes. On his earliest recordings, Ford's
I

fiddling has a sneaky, drawling quality associ
with the present-day fiddler Greg Canote.
On his late recording he is accompanied by a
host of musicians well known in Georgia through
I

ate

their

connection

to

the Skillet

Lickers:

Riley

Puckett, Lowe Stokes, Bert Layne, and Clayton
McMichen.
Ford was a brilliant lyricist. His words rush
out in

a
rapid-fire patter, telling complicated
funny stories with never a misplaced emphasis
in the way they scan the music. They remind me

the work of such great lyricists as David
McCarn and Chuck Berry. High points include
"Henry Ford's Model A," "Race Between a Ford

of

a Chevrolet"
(Ford seems pretty car-ob
sessed, perhaps another comparison with Mr.

and

Berry), and "Married Life Blues." "Married Life
Blues" is a wild one
the refrain changes with

every chorus and you end up with the "disap
pointed," "alkyholic," "jinx &amp; Maggie," and
"separation" blues, with the whole thing wind
ing up at

a

is the "The

Ku Klux Klan meeting. Also a keeper
Farmer's Dream," the first verse of

which offers up an eerie precursor to the premise
behind the "Beverly Hillbillies" TV show.

Unfortunately, Walter Morris's performances
are

nowhere near the caliber

of Ford's. While he

does perform some good songs, Morris's sing
ing has a heavy, braying quality, centered no
to the pitch of the instruments
him.
The oafish ethnic humor of
accompanying
"Crazy Coon" makes one glad that only the

ticeably sharp

chorus of the song, better known as "I Don't
Love Nobody" has survived. Truthfully, it is
hard to imagine anyone listening enthusiasti
cally over and over again

to the

Morris cuts.

you enjoy the type of song that Oscar Ford
specialized in, you should make an effort to hear
If

this CD, because he was one of the best at what
he did. Walter

Morris's music maybe more

of an

acquired taste.
JOHN M. MILLER

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The

recording,

was engineered

Tomlinson.
feel

of

a

It

of

excellent

sound quality,

by either Ray Alden or Barry
has the unadorned, immediate

growing

number

of

old-time music

digital technology with
recordings
esthetics from the dawn of recording: careful
that blend

oversingle point microphone placement, lack of
of
use
natural,
on
air
resonance,
dubs, emphasis
un-equalized vocal and instrumental tone, and

approach highlighting feel over per
fection. When superb musicians are recorded
under these conditions, stellar examples result.
The packaging includes shortbiographiesofband

an artistic

members and interesting annotations for the selec
tions. Recommended!
STEVE SENDEROFF

Bobville Music, 197 Minglewood Road,
Westfield, NC 27053; www.bobvillemusic.com

To Order:

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�revivalist virtuosi, including
Hammered

Dulcimer,

Bill

Spence

(The

Front Hall FHR 302, the

seminal recording made in 1973), Guy Carawan,
Mitzie Collins, Walt Michael, Malcom Dalglish,
and this recording by John McCutcheon.
"First generation" hammered dulcimer re
vivalists focused on the dance tune repertoire,
but their disciples rapidly expanded the musical
boundaries inhabited by the instrument. This
recording, a re-issue of 1977 June Appal mate
rial, was made early in this expansion process,
and still concentrates on the tunes. It is an early
effort from McCutcheon's long and distinguished
recording career, and nice to have in the CD
format. As such, it should have appeal to all
readers of the OTH. But readers, be forewarned!
The ensemble arrangements have the character

dulcimer accentuates

his expressive delivery.

Otis Pierce's mournful "Every Bush and Tree," a
song I'll always associate with the late Jim Ringer,

receives an equally expressive reading, with fine
harmonies provided by the "Morbid Pumper
nickel Choir." Properly strident harmonies and
emotionally powerful fiddling are featured on a
straightforward presentation of Carter Stanley's
moving "Who Will Sing For Me?"
The recording appears to have been made by
using close microphone techniques and over-

dubbing.

It

may have been state-of-the-art

'70s, but this reviewer

is

in the

disappointed by

its

limited dynamic range, brittleness, unclear sepa
ration between instrumental timbres, lack of
harmonic content, and resulting lack of acoustic

spaciousness and tonal depth. Even today, how

istic of carefully orchestrated parlor or chamberfolk music, and lack the bite and snarl associated

ever, accurate recording of the melodic percus
sion and hazy sustain of a hammered dulcimer

with traditional southern Appalachian stringband music. Nevertheless, fans of past and cur
rent hammered dulcimer powered bands such

is

as

Fennig's All Star String Band, Walt Michael
or

Trapezoid will find this disc

Company,
a must-have.
The instrumental selections

&amp;

to be

several

fall into

categories: arrangements of familiar tunes from
the repertoires of Appalachian old-time fiddlers
such as Albert Hash, Franklin George, J. P. Fraley,
and Henry Reed, music from Celtic sources such
as Turlough O'Carolan and Alan Stivell, wellknown Carter Family tunes, and obligatory ham
mered dulcimer arrangements of "Greensleeves"
and "Jesu, Joy of Man's Desiring." My favorite
selection

is a medley of "Sally in the Garden"
Fraley's "Wild Rose of the Mountain,"
delicate duet between McCutcheon's percus

and
a

J.

P.

sive dulcimer and Tina Liza Jones' subtle, legato
concertina playing. Also outstanding is a med
ley of "Sculley's Reel" (from Dudley Laufman)
and "Morrison's Jig," where sensitive guitar

accompaniment allows the singing, sustaining
qualities of the undamped hammered dulcimer
strings to shine. also enjoy the spirited reading
of the medley "St. Anne's Reel," "Cricket on the
Hearth," "Kitchen Girl," and "Mississippi Saw
yer," where a fiddle weaves in and out of an
I

array of counter-rhythms, flams and
paradiddles from the hammered dulcimer. am

endless

I

less pleased with McCutcheon's arrangement of
Bach's "Jesu." This reviewer prefers note-fornote transcriptions of Bach as done by guitarists
Christopher Parkening or Andres Segovia, and

doesn't like Bach impressions.
Other minor complaints concern occasional

intonation disagreements

occurring

between

fiddle, guitar, and hammered dulcimer on sev
eral selections, and intonation problems in the
hammered
The

vocal

McCutcheon

dulcimer itself

on

"Greensleeves."

selections work best
has

a

for

warm, melodious,

me.

gentle

voice. His signature composition "If Were a
"
Feather Bed sounds traditional in the sense that
I

Jean Ritchie songsounds traditional, and the gently
tinkling, melodic wind chime of the hammered

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

difficult using modern digital equipment and
high-end microphones, especially in a band con
text. The insert graphics contain a track list and
performers' credits, but individual musicians
are not identified on each track. The original LP
cover is reproduced as well as McCutcheon's
1977 notes,

penned

23

and his retrospective comments
years after the original release are

entertaining.
STEVE SENDEROFF

�electrified, leaves spaces

instrumental solos,
It's relaxed and
oriented towards 19th-century sentiments. Roy
and his associates appeared on local radio sta
for

yet is not hot like bluegrass.

tions throughout Tennessee,

schoolhouses.
achieved

As

far

as

1

as well as at area

can

tell,

he never

Opry status, but that probably

im

proved his ability to perform good music.
The notes to this CD contain no useful infor
mation about Roy. The Old Homestead web site
lists several earlier cassettes by him, but pro
vides little further information.
checked the
Internet, and ended up with mostly confusion.
There's a British rock performer named Roy
I

Harper, so that jammed up the search sources.
I

A

Recordings recommended that
check out Roy Harvey, of the old North Caro

database
lina

of Folk

Ramblers, who used

"Roy Harper" as a
1930s. Finally, I checked
back issues of OTH, and found a terrific article
about him by Charles Wolfe in the fall 1988 issue

pseudonym back

(vol.

in the

no. 5).

1,

The OTH article stresses Roy's knowledge of
traditional songs, but this CD concentrates on a

repertoire typical of his youth in the 1940s. That's
a bad
thing. In addition to the excellent
Rodgers covers ("Train Whistle Blues," "Cali
not

fornia Blues"),

his

singing/playing style

and

song selection brings up memories to me of the
Renfrow Valley radio shows of the early 1950s.
Johnny Bellar plays masterful slide guitar on
almost every piece. It may be related to micro
phone placement, but on some songs he sounds
like he's playing Hawaiian guitar (i.e., standard
guitar with the strings raised off the fingerboard
to allow use of a slide), while on others he

achieves

a

harsher Dobro (acoustic resonator
never mistake his
that produced on the shallower elec

guitar)

sound. You would

playing

for

tric steel

solid-body guitar.
There's some mandolin and autoharp here,
but not presented in great profusion. What we
have

is

a

lot of great singing, in

a

specific authen

style, with solid rhythm guitar
backing. And if you want to learn the best way to
play "My Wild Irish Rose" on slide guitar, this is
tic

Tennessee

the album to buy.
LYLE LOFGREN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�well, the elderly man playing the smaller

as

drum has

sort of a hop and wiggle that is great,
from
behind. The sounds they make
especially
evoke African music, and bring to mind the
village tupan-zurna music of the Balkans. There
is

a

a

short interview with Ed Young, who turns

out to be extremely articulate and the teasing
between the two brothers is charming.
The video ends with

very odd segment of

a

Son House, preaching a misogynistic rant about
true love and matrimony. Why did Alan Lomax

choose

to

include this?

It's

a

reminder that,

in

a

certain way, this film is about Alan Lomax as
much as it is about the musicians documented
here. I'm no

connoisseur

can see that

it

much

of film or

thought behind the staging

ments. This

is

video, but

I

was all done consciously, with
of the

not the lush color film of

seg
a

Les

Blank production; the black-and-white film al
lows for more dramatic play of light and shadow.
It's dated, of course, but for me that simply

evokes the earlier time when this film was shot
(nearly 35 years ago now!)
The 22-page booklet, with notes by Mark
Humphrey, is exemplary, chock full of all kinds
of interesting information, from biographical
material to Humphrey's own cogent observa

tions. As an example, his note
National steel guitars by Bukka
House is fascinating. Some of
own writings on the music and

on the use of

White and Son
Alan Lomax's

musicians are

also included, providing a bit of insight into one
of the central figures in the preservation of

American traditional music.
SUZY ROTHFIELD

THOMPSON

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�deal of affection in anecdotes spread through
out. The last three sections of the book consist of

collection of pictures of people with whom
Ramona has worked over the years, family mem
bers, and friends, several shortbiographies writ
ten by McNeil of some of the performers with
whom Ramona has been associated during her
career, and a discography compiled by McNeil
which provides details of recording sessions on
which Ramona played with Grandpa Jones or
was a featured performer. Ramona's story, as
a

presented here, in a casual, almost conversa
tional style, is a compelling one in itself, and one that
helps

fill in a

few gaps in country music history.
JIM

To order:

NELSON

Ramona Jones, PO Box 199, Ridgetop,

TN 37152

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Classic

County

Old-Time

3524

Then and Now
Re-issue of Texas string

BANDS INCLUDE:

Eck Robertson,
East Texas Serenaders,

Prince Albert Hunt,
Oscar &amp; Doc Harper,
The Lewis Brothers,
Solomon &amp; Hughes, and more

County

County

3525

2730

Performing with Rafe:
Dirk Powell
John Herrmann
Nikki Lee
Beverly Smith

Celia Stefanini
Woody Woodring

COUNTY
County Records

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

P.

0. Box 7405

Charlottesville,

Va

22906

www.countysales.com

�great holiday gift for fans and students of old-time music.

A

Discover

an

American treasure.

Fiddling Bob Douglas
Ain't Done

100 Years Old

Yet

This new video captures the

remarkable performances and
of legendary old-time
fiddler Bob Douglas in his 99th and
100th year of life. From studio

achievements

sessions to his unprecedented debut
as the first centenarian to perform on
The Grand Ole Opry, Bob shatters
the myth of aging with his

phenomenal fiddling, infectious
personality and his unabashed
insights. Bob performs 13 old-time
tunes including: "Monday Morning
Blues, "Jenny in the Cotton,
"

"

"Polly Put the Kettle On,
"Cacklin' Hen," "Durang's Hornpipe,"
"
"Wink The Other Eye,
"Liberty at The
"
Corn Likker Still,
"Sequatchie
"
"
Valley, "Sugar in The Gourd,
"

"

Robert McKinley Douglas

at the

age

of

"

historical photos and comments
Keillor, Charles Wolfe,
Charlie Louvin, Fletcher Bright,

got on there and he KICKED BUTT...he did the Opiy
proud at the age of 100."
"He

Charles Wolfe, Author/Country
"You

"

"Memphis Blues, "Oh My Lawd,
"Muddy Road to Ducktown, and
"Bob's Special. "The video includes

100.

from Garrison

Music Historian

Bobby Fulcher, John Hartford and

others.

don't use the words, 'why the old boy plays pretty

56 mins, professional

production

'

good fiddle to be a 1 00-years-old. He just plays good
fiddle period." Charlie Louvin, The Louvin Brothers
"Bob
The

could play

a

little fiddle. Jeez, could he play.
"
is top notch.

music on this video

Kerry Blech,

The Old-Time

I

HL

Coming soon!
"Fiddler of The Century"

^1Hh|

Herald

Bob Douglas
1900: Born in Sequatchie
Valley of TN. 1928: Won "All Southern
Fiddle Championship" against Clayton
McMichen, and Jess Young and recorded
with the Allen Brothers for RCA Victor.
1930: Toured with Curly Fox. 1939-1946:

An enhanced CD featuring
Bob Douglas recordings from

Produced

_

'it

selected
1930s -2001.

by

HT(0fe-CllCTiCN.S

Discovered and performed with the

Louvin Brothers. 1975: Won Smithsonian
Institute's National Fiddle Contest.
2000: Bob debuts at Grand Ole Opry.

order send $24.95 U.S.D.
check or money order to:
Hot Planet Productions
1802 Highland Avenue
Knoxville, TN 37916
To

Price includes shipping

in

the U.S.

Credit card orders call toll-free:

888-568-1468
e-mail: rogharb@bellsouth.net
HOT

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

PLANET

PRODUCTIONS

Bob Douglas with Bobby Fulcher (L) and Michael
at the Grand Ole Opry on May 5, 2000.

DeFosche

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12502">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 8, Number 2 (Winter 2001-2002)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12503">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12504">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 8, Number 2 (November 2001-January 2002)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Albert Hash Memorial Band,” by Chip Bailey&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“A Banjo On Her Knee – Part 1,” by Susan A. Eacker and Geoff Eacker&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dance Beat – ‘Square Dancing’ in Haywood County, North Carolina,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – Texas Contest Style - Problems?,” by Roger Koch with an introduction by Vivian Williams&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Engelhardt Basses,” by Bob Smakula&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12505">
              <text>2001</text>
            </elementText>
            <elementText elementTextId="12556">
              <text>2002</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2783">
      <name>2001</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1614">
      <name>2002</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5996">
      <name>Albert Hash Memorial Band</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5572">
      <name>Bob Smakula</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5997">
      <name>Chip Bailey</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5826">
      <name>Geoff Eacker</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5474">
      <name>Phil Jamison</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5999">
      <name>Roger Koch</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5998">
      <name>Susan A. Eacker</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6000">
      <name>Vivian Williams</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
