<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2607" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2607?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:53:34+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3547">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/833e5b21b81dc7960aff4122bc0625a1.pdf</src>
      <authentication>d5670bdc51729c7c17babaab86ba2800</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12598">
                  <text>THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD
A

MAGAZINE

TO

DEDICATED

VOLUME 10, NUMBER

2

OLD-TIME

WINTER

MUSIC

2005

$7.25

LADDER-BRACED GUITARS:
ENDURING

LESTER
DANCE BEAT:

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

BUCKDANCER

THOMAS MAUPIN

McCUMBERS
WEST VIRGINIA

OF

OLD-TIME SOUND

AND LINDA
OF CALHOUN COUNTY,

MYSTERIES

ALSO

EXPANDED HOLIDAY REVIEWS,

WORKSHOP HERE &amp;THERE
AND MORE

THE

�NOW

reduced pricing

EVEN

MORE Radio

and

NO-OBLIGATION

a

&amp;

Satellite exposure, free website

XM

FREE CD

just for inquiring!

jjfll

You've probably already heard about the
best place to manufacture your disc
So c'mon
give us a call!

OASIS

You've more than likely already heard-- from your fellow
that Oasis
musicians, the BBB, and independent reviewers

CD MANUFACTURING

web oasisCD.com

offers the most reliable and innovative CD and DVD

tel (888) 296-2747, (540) 987-881
email info@oasisCD.com

manufacturing and marketing services.

time for you to give us

So isn't it

a

call?

BBB Sa^ng'SaJcSkd
Better Business
both

it

if

is

17

yOU'VG

FREE

may we

suggest what

It

1

Bn

Calls for

INCLUDED

it

MONEY-MAKING CD:
a Successful

Party. ..Without
Rl'.easethe Bank!
Breaking

C_D

p

^JSeCD7

that describes your situation,

if

Bureau and BBBonline.

"How to Have

the crucial task of getting people out there to
actually hear your music.

Because

calls for?

and enter code OH
(And if you want a free full-coior

Oasis.

catalog we'll throw that

WITH YOUR CD or DVD

PROJECT--

THE

OASIS TOP

XM

Galaris/Oasis CD-ROM

Distribution for your CD/DVD:

A

Full Year of

SoundScan,

OasisSampler

Satellite

with 14,000+ Music
Industry Contacts

Electronic Press
Kit Service and

Music-Career

Radio

iTunes Music Store

Exclusive Live

Airplay

in

too!)

TOOLS OF PROMOTION:

Your Music on an

Distributed to
Radio Nationwide

The

by

put your nGSCt 3nd soul into your
project. And you want the discs and packaging you send
out into the world to truly reflect (or even improve
upon) your original vision. And you need help with

W0 think

0

Software, Retail
Cases, Barcodes

FREE Website
with the features
musicians need!

Performance
Section with Illegible Text

Opportunities:

SATELLITE
RADiO

67:89

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

months free,
no obligation!

6

Section with Illegible Text
Section with Illegible

�THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD
VOLUME 10, NUMBER 2
WINTER 2005

COMING IN THE NEXT ISSUE
OF THE

OTH

Run of the Mill String Band

Whit Sizemore
Glen Ohrlin
Plus Reviews, Dance Beat &amp;
More!

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
1817 Chapel Hill Rd.

PO Box 51812/

Durham, NC 27707
Phone 919-419-1800
Fax: 919-419-1881
E-mail:

info@oldtimeherald.org

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR

Gail Gillespie
ASSOCIATE EDITOR
Bill

Hicks

CONTRIBUTING
Phil Jamison,

EDITORS

Bob Smakula, Tim Thompson

ADVISORY BOARD
Ray Alden, Mac Benford, Hazel Dickens, Hilary

Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher, Ramona Jones, Garrison Keil
lor, Pete Kuykendall, Brad Leftwich, Lee Smith, Pete
Sutherland, Joe Thompson, Charles Wolfe

MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS

OLD-TIME

Art Aylsworth, A. C. Bushnell, Sally Council, Alice
Gerrard, Phil Blank, Jim Watson, Bob Reed
LAYOUT: Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group
ADVERTISING DIRECTOR: Katherine Meehan

ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT: Meredith Hawley
VOLUNTEERS: Pan Riggs, Norbert Sarsfield
COMPUTER

CONSULTANT: Dan Peck

WEB SITE: Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group
FOUNDING EDITOR: Alice Gerrard

No part of this magazine may be reproduced in any
form without written permission from the publisher. Not

responsible for loss or non-return of unsolicited photos
manuscripts. 2005 the Old-Time Herald. The Old-Time
Herald (ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is published quar
terly the first of August, November, February, and May
by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc., Ill A Old Pittsboro
or

Road, Carrboro, NC 2751 0. Subscription rates payable in
Canada
advance. One year: $25 (foreign subscriptions--

Overseas $32). Library/Institutional rate:
$30. Classified ads cost 35 cents per word,
minimum of $5. Any grouping of letters or numbers is
counted as one word. All classified ads mustbe received
$30

U.S.;

one year:

by the first of the month, two months prior to

publica

tion. Periodical postage paid at Durham, NC 27701 and
additional mailing offices. Postmaster: Send change of

address
NC

to the Old-Time Herald, PO Box 51812, Durham,
27717. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is a not-

for-profit, tax-exempt corporation under section 501
(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

(c)

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love of

old-time music. Old-time music-grassroots, or home
grown music and dance-- shares origins, influences and
musical characteristics with roots musics throughout
America. Our magazine, the Old-Time Herald, casts a
wide net, highlighting the Southeastern tradition while
opening its pages to kindred and comparable traditions
It provides enlightening articles and
in-depth reviews, opportunities for musical learning
and sharing, and a forum for addressing the issues and
questions that bear upon the field. Recognizing that in
roots music ideas and values of many kinds commingle,

and new directions.

we strive to represent our interests democratically and to
embody the best ideals of race, gender, and generational
balance in a context of free and open discussion.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here &amp; There

Events

&amp;

Jams

18-21, The 17th Annual Har
and
Traditional
Bluegrass
Country Music Convention, will be held
at the Feathertop Chalet in Harriettville,
Victoria, along Australia's picturesque
Great Alpine Way. This year's guests in
clude West Virginians Bobby Taylor and
Andrew Dunlap on old-time fiddle, banjo
and guitar, as well as bluegrass and oldtime musicians from all over Australia."
On Nov.

rietville

Info:

harrietville@bluegrass.org.au.

where there's a "great springy wood floor
and good acoustics." Info: Barry Dupen
574-533-3836:
jbedupen@maplenet.net;

www.godancing.org.
Since 1981, the Old-time Music and
Dance Group of Blacksburg, VA has
presented some of the finest local square
dance callers and old-time bands. Dances
are held at the Old Blacksburg Middle
School in Blacksburg. Partners and square
dance experience are not necessary. On
5,

the

band

is

The

Ubiquitones

with fiddler Andy Edmonds and caller
Jaso Phillips; on Dec. 3, the band is the
Pilot Mountain Bobcats, with fiddler
Nancy Sluys and caller Beverly Smith.
Info:

http://

nrot.org/nrot/pp/dance_

schedule.php, or email
scott.nelson@mmal .com

Scott

Nelson,

Social
activist
and
writer
song
Kahn will be at the Workmen's
Circle
Coffehouse, 1762 Beacon St.,
MA on
Nov.
19.
Info:
Brookline,
Si

www.workmenscircleboston.org;
Lauren

Hennan

617-566-6281;

lauren@workmenscircleboston.org;
Kahn www.sikahn.com.

Si

Spend the weekend learning fiddle and

banjo tunes and picking up techniques at
the Suwannee Old-Time Music Camp
in Florida. Dec. 2-4. Instructors include
Chirps Smith-fiddle; Bruce Hutton- banjo,
old-time singing; Alice Gerrard-guitar,

old-time

singing;

Mary

Z.

Chuck

banjo;

Levy-beginning

fiddle. Reservations can be made through
ReserveAmerica.com or 1-800-326-3521
Info: 386-397-4478.

The Birmingham (AL) Friends
Time Music and Dance sponsors

of Olda

regular

session on the second Sim. of each
month, at various locations. Depending
jam

on who shows up, each session will have
two jams-- a slow one for beginners and

regular one for experienced players.
Bring your own chair and beverages.
Info: Gordon Graham: 205-591-1683, or
a

The Goshen Community Contra Dance
has some great dances coming. On Nov. 5,
Mike Clark of Kalamazoo, MI will call and
Dan Gellert and Debbie Posey of Elkhart,
IN, will play. On Dec. 3, Danika Murray
of Kalamazoo will call and Lucy Long and
Friends of Bowling Green, OFI, will play.
The dances are at the First United Meth
odist Church, in downtown Goshen, IN

Nov.

ning

Cox-begin

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

www.bamalong.com.
There's a regular old-time fiddle tune
jam every second Sat. from 9:30-11:30
AM at the Mill Race Farmers' Market, on

Second

St. and W.

Washington

in

Goshen,

warm weather, jams may be held
behind the Market at Wooden Music. Info:
IN.

In

574-533-9906,
Fritzi

holding

or

www.godancing.org.
Wisdom have begun
their regular old-time jam on

and

Bill

the first Fri. night of every month from
8-midnight. The jam is in Bryn Mawr,
PA, about 3 1/2 miles west of the Phila
delphia line. Old-time musicians at all
levels are welcome. Info: 610-527-7080 or

wawisdom@temple.edu.

Artists
Performance dates for old-time duo Bob
Bovee and Gail Heil include the Morris,
IL

Public Library on Nov.

4;

Urbana,

IL

Country Dance on Nov. 5; Spirit of the
Woods in Manistee, MI on Nov. 19, and
the Chicago Barn Dance on Nov. 21. Info:

bobngail@springgrove.coop
Bayou Seco will be playing at the High
Desert Brewing Company, Las Cruces,
NM on Nov. 10 from 8-11 PM; for Fid
dling Friends at Alotta Gelatto, Silver
City, NM at 12:15 PM on Nov. 12; and
in Deming, NM for the Fine Arts Friday
School Program at Martin Elementary at
PM on Nov, 18. They'll also play for the
Night Contra/Square Dance
at the Carillo Rec. Center, 7-11 PM. Info:
Ken Keppeler and Jeanie McLerie P.O.
1393, Silver City NM 88062; 505-534-0298;

2

Christmas

bayouseco@aol.com, www.cantos.org/
bayouseco.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Lonesome

Sisters (Sarah Hawker
have the following

and Debra Clifford),

performances coming up. On Nov. 11
at the Peeptoad Coffeehouse, Foster, RI.
On
Info: email info@fosteringarts.org.
Nov. 18 they open for Mike Marshall and
Darol Anger at the High Point Theater
in High Point, NC, 220 East Commerce
Avenue North, High Point, NC. Info: 336887-3001

Virginia-based singer Carol Elizabeth
has recently joined the Hopeful
Gospel Quartet with Robin and Linda
Williams and Garrison Keillor. She re
ports that singing harmony between

Jones

and Linda has been heavenly
(pardon the pun). Listen for the Hopefuls
on A Prairie Home Companion from time
to time and specifically on these dates:
Dec. 10, 2005 and January 21, 2006. Info:

Robin

cejones@rrlib.net, www.jonesbliss.com.
Fiddler Alan Jabbour will be teaching
at the John C. Campbell Folk School,
Brasstown, NC on Jan. 15-22. Alan,
along with banjo player Ken Perlman
plan

a

through
FL.

to

tour from Jan. 22
Feb. 2006 at sites from NC
Info:
www.kenperlman.com;

fiddle-banjo

www.alanjabbour.com.

Recordings,
Instruments

&amp;

Labels

Joe Newberry has recently released a
new solo CD, Two Hands. The mate
rial is divided between instrumentals
and vocals, and you can get a copy at
CD
Amazon,
www.joenewberry.com,
and
efolkmusic.com.
Sales,
Baby, County
En
Hillbillies-fiddler
The
Ebony
rique Prince, bassist Dave Colding, and
dulcimerist/banjoist Norris-- have a new

recording. Called I Thought You Knew,
the CD is available from the band's web

site, www.ebonyhillbillies.com.
Watch for the new Tom, Brad, and Alice
(Sauber, Leftwich, and Gerrard) record
ing, Carve that Possum, released in late
Sept. on the Copper Creek label. Info:

www.tombradalice.com.

There's a new CD with a compilation of
music by many of the old-time musicians
who have participated in Minnesota's
Includes
Bluff
Country
Gathering.
tunes and songs by Dan Gellert, Carl
Jones and Beverly Smith, Jimmy Triplett
and many others. Proceeds benefit the
festival. Info: Bob Bovee and Gail Heil,
or
www.boveeheil.com;
507-498-5452;
email bobngail@springgrove.coop.

Organization
Tony

Thomas has announced he, Rex

Henrique Prince, and Sule Greg
Wilson are forming a non-profit founEllis,

�dation of black traditional string band
musicians. The foundation will carry
out the work that coalesced around the
Black Banjo Gathering held last April
in

Boone,

sociation

NC. The group, The As
Black Traditional String

of

Players, Inc., plans to meet in early
2006, in New York. Info: Tony Thomas

Africans
blackbanjotony@hotmail.com.
and African Americans who wish to join
this effort can contact the group

at

black_

traditional_string_players@hotmail.com.
On the Air

&amp;

the Web

Frank Hoppe continues to spin a lot of
music CDs on his radio show
Bluegrass, Etc. on KCSN 88.5 FM, out of
Northridge, CA. The show, which airs ev
10:00 AM, is also
ery Sun. from 6:00 AM-streamed on line at www.kcsn.org, http:

old-time

//kcsn.org/listen/

Wisconsin Digital
Collections Center (UWDCC) announces
the addition of The Wisconsin Folksong
The
collection
Collection, 1937-1946.
consists of a searchable database, and
digitized audio and visual materials
from two major collections. Vocal music
predominates, but there are also some
instrumental
Info:
recordings.
http:
The

University

of

//digital.library.wisc.edu/1711.dl/Wis-

cFolkSong; Peter Gorman pgorman@libr
ary.wisc.edu; or Vicki L. Tobias, 608-2656381, vtobias@library.wisc.edu.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Congratulations
folk singer and retired Library
Congress folklore archivist Joe Hick
erson received the annual Excellence in
the Traditional Arts Award. Walt Michael,
Director of Common Ground on the Hill
On July

9,

of

at

McDaniel

MD, presented

College

in

the award

Westminster,

following the

afternoon performances at their annual
American Music &amp; Arts Festival at the
Info:
Carroll County Farm Museum.

www.commongroundonthehill.org.
This fall, old-time singer &amp; multi-in
strumentalist John Lilly won the 2005
HankFest Song Writing Contest, in which
the contestants vie to pen a song in the
style of Hank Williams. John's entry
was "Blue Highway." Info and an MP3
sound clip: http://www.hankfest.com/

gwitspage.htm.
The old-time contest winners from the
2005 Henry Reed Memorial Fiddlers Con
vention, Glyn Lyn, VA, June 10-11 were as
follows: Folk Song-Elizabeth LaPrelle,

Alvin Jones, Don Bennett; Harmonica-

Eddie Ogle, Kenny Johnston; Old-Time
Band-Durham Barnstormers, Katie &amp; the
Bubba Tones, Look Both Ways; Old Time
Banjo-Lucas Pasley, Carl Baron, Charlie
Pickford; Old-Time Banjo/Fiddle DuetMac Traynham &amp; Skip Slocum, Betty
Vornbrock &amp; Diane Jones, Corey Gal
breath &amp; Cindy Cook; Old-Time FiddleBetty Vornbrock, Jacob Bowen, Lucas

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Pasley; Old-Time Guitar-Rose Hale, Tina
Liza Jones, Billy Cornette.
16th Appalachian
The
String Band
Music Festival at Camp WashingtonCarver in Clifftop, WV, held Aug. 3-7,
awarded the following prizes: Fiddle-

Jimmy Triplett, Eric Merrill, Stephanie
Coleman; Youth Fiddle: Myra Morrison,
Isaac Akers, Maya Divitry; Senior Fiddle:
Speedy Tolliver, Dave Holmes, Skip
Ashby; Banjo: Mac Traynham, Nancy
Sluys, Adam Hurt; Youth Banjo: Frank
Evans, Joanna Hartness, Trinity Kronk;
Senior Banjo: Marvin Gaster, Pete Peter
son, Eugene Parsons; Traditional Bands:

Moonshine
Downward

Monsters,

Cliffhangers,

Non-Traditional
Dogs;
Bands: Red Stick Ramblers, Mando Ma
fia, The Hix; Youth Old-Time Fiat-Foot
Dance:
Haley McGuigan, Morganne
Criswell, Amanda Canfield Adult OldTime Fiat-Foot Dance: Gordy Hinners,
Andy Edmonstone, Ira Bernstein; Senior
Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance: Thomas Maupin, Mary Butner, Carole Benedick.

The following people won ribbons at the
2005 Old Fiddlers Convention at Galax,
VA, held Aug. 6-13. Fiddle: Jarred Nutter,

Bass, Jake Krack; Clawhammer
Banjo: Brian Fain, Alan Rutherford, Tina
Trianosky; Old-Time Bands: Old Time
Boys, Cabin Creek Boys, Southern Pride;
Youth Old-Time Fiddle: Joe Furtado,
Brooke Brammer.

David

Everyone had a fabulous time at the
Berkeley Old-Time Music Conven

2005

tion (Sept. 15-18), held in Berkeley,

CA.

Mike Seeger dueted with Kenny Hall,
the square dance went on for five rock
ing hours, and Jody Stecher and Kate
Brislin showed up unannounced at the
cabaret to share the stage with younger
players performing for the first time.
Winners of the string band contest were:
Thompson's String Ticklers; Hot &amp; So
ber String Band; with a third place tie
between Government Issue Orchestra

Squirrelly String Band. Winners re
ceived wooden nickels, redeemable at the
and

Berkeley Farmer's Market.
Winners of the State Fair of Virginia fid
dle and banjo contests, held at Strawberry
Hill, Richmond, VA on Sept. 25, 2005,
were as follows: Fiddle: Mark Campbell,

Bronwyn

Keith-Hynes,

Steve

Bachhu-

ber; Banjo winners were: Seth Swingle,
Jim Anderson, Steve Bachhuber.

In

Our Thoughts

Old-time musician Nancy Martin, of
Portland, Oregon was diagnosed last fall
with terminal cancer. Her husband Bill
has been taking time off of work in order
to be with her. You may send cards and
letters to them via the store Q is for Choir,
2510 SE Clinton, Portland, OR 97202.

Country music historian Charles Wolfe,
who was very ill this summer, is begin
ning to recover. His wife Mary Dean
reports that he is up and walking every
day, and that his spirits were boosted
by his recent designation as a professor
emeritus at Middle TN State University.
Well-wishers may send cards to his home
address: Charles Wolfe, 1210 Bond Court,

Murfreesboro, TN 37129.
Final Notes
Singer and banjo player Hedy West
passed away on July 3, at the age of 67.
Born in Cartersville, Georgia, her father,
Don West, was a well-known poet and
trade union organizer. Although her rep
ertoire included everything from ballads,
broadsides, industrial songs, and dance
tunes to original compositions, Hedy's
emphasis was always on traditional mu
sic, learned primarily from her maternal
grandmother in North Georgia. In 1959
she went to New York to study music
and drama and quickly became involved

folk movement there. Pete Seeger,
friend of her father's, had invited her

in the
a

to

participate

in

several

performances,

Out! hootenanny at
mid-'60s Hedy had
Hall.
the
By
Carnegie
performed at all the major folk festivals,
given concerts all over the country, and
made several recordings on labels such
as Vanguard and Folk-Legacy. In recent
years, cancer had affected her voice, and,
not wishing to play the banjo without be
ing able to sing, Hedy had retired from
performing. Though none of her original
albums are currently available on CD,
there are three tracks of her music on The
Original New Folks Anthology, available at

including

a

Sing

Amazon.com.

Kemp, 96, Tennessee's senior
master,
banjo
passed away on July 15. A
resident of the Defeated in Smith County,
he was known in recent decades as the
main living link to Uncle Dave Macon's
tradition of novelty songs, folk showman
ship, and old-time banjo tricks. In addi
tion to his music, he was a tobacco farmer,
Cordell

logger, and woodsman.
Cordell was born mto a musical tamuy
and took up banjo at a very early age.
His interest was accelerated by boyhood

to hear and meet Uncle
Dave Macon, who occasionally played
schoolhouse where
at
the
Defeated
Cordell would years later serve as jani
tor. Throughout his life, Cordell was no
toriously reluctant to travel too far from
home, declining an invitation to partici
pate in the 1986 Smithsonian Festival of
American Folklife. He nonetheless shared

opportunities

his talents

generously and influenced

a

�number of players who sought him out,
including Leroy Troy, John Hartford, and
Stephen Wade. He also passed his banjo
skills on to his grandson Shannon Kemp
of Defeated.
In the 1980s Cordell gained wider rec
ognition as the result of being featured
in Korine
and Dunlap's documentary
film The Uncle Dave Macon Program (aired
on

PBS

in

1981),

and

the Tennessee

on

Folklore Society's subsequent LP record

ing, Tennessee: The Folk Heritage, Vol. 2, The
Mountains (TFS-103). He performed at
the 1982 Knoxville World's Fair Folklife
Festival and was a regular favorite in
the early years of Murfreesboro's
an

Uncle Dave

nual
His

involvement

Macon

at

the

Days festival.

1990

and

1992

Tennessee Banjo Institutes at Cedars of
Lebanon State Park brought further expo
sure. Cordell and Leroy Troy performed
together at both the 1995 Folklorists in the
South Retreat at Red Boiling Springs and
at the 1996 International Marbles Festival
at Standing Stone State Park. In recent
years he held forth for local audiences in
regular jam sessions at Powell's Tire Store
in Defeated and at the annual Defeated
Creek Bluegrass Festival. He was the
subject of feature articles in the Nashville
in January, 2002, and in Banjo

Tennessean

Newsletter

in July, 2003.

Cordell Kemp was a well-loved and col
orful character who showed remarkable
vitality even in his 90s. In the last year of
his life, local friend Barclay Rhea produced
a
long overdue CD recording of his music,
and information about it is available on
line

at

http://sunset992001.tripod.com/

idl0.html.

Harvey Chell, old-time fiddler, passed
away on July 25. Born in 1927 and raised
on a farm near Sisseton, South Dakota,
he took up fiddle at age nine. He started
playing for dances as a teenager with his
cousin on accordion. Their band, the Scan
dinavian Stringbusters, played for Polish
and Norwegian house parties. Harvey
recalled these parties sometimes lasting
till dawn, when he would walk home to a
full days work in the fields. Both Canadi
an fiddling and his Swedish /Norwegian
musical heritage influenced his unique

style with its "trilling" ornamentation.

wonderful composer whose tunes

contests and jams in the region,
also co-authored several fiddle
tunes with the great Canadian fiddler and
close, personal friend Calvin Vollrath.

played
Harvey

Old-Time
Craig
Sterry
Remembering:
Fiddle Tunes, which contains 34 tunes, [re
viewed in OTH, vol. 9, no. 1. We are for
tunate to have this musical record of such
a fine fiddler. He will be greatly missed.
—Alice

Folklife Program,
Tennessee Arts Commission

activist
Helen Bonchek Schneyer, 84, passed
away on July 16, in Plainfield, Vermont.
Singing alone, or accompanying herself
on piano, Helen moved audiences with
her strong and vibrant voice, and de
lighted them with her outrageous sense

of humor.

collector

and

folk

Her large,

wide-ranging rep
ertoire included everything from mining

sentimental Victorian numbers,
songs
and the occasional song by a contempo
rary songwriter. Over her 60-year career
Helen performed with many well-known
folk artists including Woody Guthrie, Pete
Seeger, and the Almanac Singers. Until 10
years ago, she made regular appearances
on Garrison Keillor's Prairie Home Com
panion. She had a number of albums on
to

and other labels and her
Ballads, Broadsides and Hymns
remains one of Folk-Legacy's top sellers.

Folk-Legacy
album

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at

In 1946 Harvey
moved to Montana
where he met his wife, Jo, who became his
piano accompanist. During the 1950s with
the popularity of rock 'n' roll and worsen
ing arthritis, he put down his fiddle for 15
years, but fortunately he took it up again
and never laid it down. Though his hands
and neck were crippled by arthritis, he
was a true and authentic old-time fiddler.
Like many traditional fiddlers, Harvey
had a wide-ranging interest in different
kinds of fiddle music from old waltzes
and rare schottisches and two-steps, to
swing, rags, and polkas, as well as tunes
that he composed. He made one CD, re
corded in his living room by his friend

— Robert Cogswell

Performer,

A

are still

Gerrard

Craig Sterry

Frank Benjamin Proffitt, 58, of Todd,
North Carolina died August 7, 2005. He
was born in Watauga County in 1946. He
was an accomplished musician, playing
the banjo, guitar and dulcimer.
Frank, was a gift to all of us who love tra
ditional music a talented musician who
proudly played the music of his family, a
delightful storyteller, and a humble, gen
erous friend. His father, Frank Proffitt, Sr.,

became nationally known as a folk singer
in the 1940s through folk song collectors
Frank and Anne Warner. His father's ver
sion of "Tom Dooley" was later made into

popular hit by the Kingston Trio. Frank
Jr.'s mother was Bessie Hicks, daughter of
early dulcimer builder Nathan Hicks of
Beech Mountain, NC. His uncle was sto
ryteller Ray Hicks, and he counted among
his cousins
builder /musician Stanley
Hicks, dulcimer player Nettie Presnell,
and storyteller Orville Hicks.
Frank often gave concerts at the Ap
State
University Mountain
palachian
a

Dulcimer

Workshop.

A

big,

handsome

man, and entirely at home with the music,
he was a charming performer of Appala
chian traditional songs, tunes and tales.
He was blessed with a clear singing voice,
and

played his mountain dulcimer and

fretless banjo with an exciting rhythm. His
speech, phrases, and stories retained evi
dence of his family's 18th century North
Carolina/Tennessee mountain roots. Over
the years, Frank was a popular member of
the North Carolina's Visiting Artists pro
gram, and his performances there and at
the Smithsonian

Folklife Festival allowed

him to reach and delight audiences of all
aves.
The dulcimer and banjo world has lost
one of its finest ambassadors. May Frank
rest in peace with those he loved and ad
mired. He's most likely sitting in heaven
right now playing the old tunes, singing
the old ballads, and telling the old tales
with his father and mother, his grandpar
ents, and other members of the extended
family.
—Lois

Hornbostel

Tammy

Sawyer

Pioneer bluegrass musician Michell Burt
"Bea" Lilly, 83, passed away on Sep
tember 18. Bea, with his brother Everett,
known as the Lilly Brothers, were one of
the foremost brother duets in country and
bluegrass music. The brothers grew up
in Clear Creek, West Virginia. Beginning
in the late

1930s, they carried their sing

ing and playing to audiences around the
world. Early in 1952, Tex Logan persuaded
both Everett and Bea to join him in Boston,
where with the addition of Don Stover on

banjo, they took bluegrass sounds to New
England. Initially they worked at WCOP
Boston on the Hayloft Jamboree and then
at various clubs, mostly notably a long
stint at the Hillbilly Ranch. They recorded
some material for Event Records in 1956
and 1957 (later released on County) and
albums for Folkways and Prestige Inter
national, the latter being cut and mar
keted in the era of the urban folk revival.
An album

of live recordings from 1960,
released in Japan, was some of the first
bluegrass to be sold in that country. With
the exception of a few brief periods such
as Everett's second stint with Flatt and
Scruggs in 1958-59 and Don Stover's tour
with some other bands, the Lilly Brothers
and Stover worked constantly in the Bos

ton area from 1952 until January 1970. The
impact and legacy that Bea and Everett
Lilly had on the music community in the
Northeast is immense and set the stage
for

what continues

to be

a

vibrant music

scene. More information can be found at
http
www.countryworks.com
full.asp?KEY=LILLY

artist_

—Gerry

Katz

�Linda

Gunderson

Dance Beat

Maupin: "When I'm a-dancing"

Thomas
By Linda

Gunderson

Tennessee dancer
describes himself as

Thomas

Maupin,

who

"self-taught buckdancer
ivith a flatfoot style," has hoofed his way to
numerous state and national prizes. In re
cent years his snappy flatfooting has thrilled
crowds at events such as the Museum of
Appalachia's Fall Homecoming in Tennessee
and the Appalachian String Band Festival in
a

and each danced in their
own way. "I was just a little ole skinny
of which I still am," Thomas laugh
boy
admitted.
Basketball coach Rush Jr.
ingly
ers and sisters,

(Taylor) encouraged him to dance a little
whenever they met in the hallway,

jig

the

to

to

encourage
youngster
develop
something uniquely his own. But there is

Thomas Maupin, 66, was

one brother, now gone, who holds a spe
cial place in his heart. "Ollie B.," whom
Thomas regarded as almost a twin, "was
four years older than me. He and I shared
the same rhythm. We had different steps,
I loved
to dance with
but we favored
him. I could almost trade licks with him."
Like Thomas, his brother Ollie B. was also

or
barn dance
somewhere.
"And my mom's side-- my mom didn't
dance, but she had rhythm-- her people
were dancers." His grandmother Will
lived with them, and he hears tunes

dancer. Instead of making noise, he had a
purpose to his steps. And we have danced
together in competitions. I think maybe
one year he beat me in the Nationals."
About that contest, Thomas recalls tell
ing Ollie that he was "not going to let

s basic humility and
with
his
country upbringing, but
shyness go
he is absolutely passionate about dance: "I love
old-time music. It's got my rhythm. I am that

West

Virginia. Maupin'

band when I'm a-dancing.

his

From
Tennessee,

boyhood

"

days

in

central

surrounded by dance. On his dad's side,
relatives often danced at a Saturday night

hoedown

now that he remembers her dancing to
barefoot on the floor. "I can hear her heel
step now," he mused when describing her
smooth, straight up dance style. "I think
I
got a double dose," he recalled. "I can
see some of my family members now, es
old country
pecially on my dad's side
men. Clay Underwood, an old bent-over
man, had the same rhythm style that I've
got, but different steps. I can see where
I

developed from, but my steps

are me.

connection with them, but every
buckdancer has their individual style and
There's

a

individual steps."

Thomas came from

a

family of ten broth

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"a

self-taught

up. 'Hey, you give

going

it all

to

and

buckdancer,

a

good

it all you've got. I'm
I've got.'" His brother

give
Ollie "gave me his shoes, before he passed
along and I dance in 'em. His is a little
it's a little hard for me to fill his
big
shoes, being they're a little bigger."
Thomas recalls that he won his first com

petition in 1954. "I had square danced, but
back then the competition wasn't like it is
now. This was just a talent deal that came
through and several of the older people
asked me to sign up for it. I had no idea of

winning, but the audience
8

is

what won

it

got to appear on TV, Channel
His mother Mabel never
in Nashville."

for me, and

I

typ
got to see him dance in competition
ically, when he won the talent show at six
teen, she was home caring for the family.
Besides her ten children, she raised sev
eral grandchildren. She died in 1964, and

Thomas remembers the community com
ing out to honor the woman who raised
so many children. When she was failing,
he overheard her tell the preacher, "He's
a good boy." Thomas paused with a catch
in his throat, "I miss that I never got to
look into her eyes while I was doing my

best step."
His coon dog story reveals something of
Maupin's kind temperament and person
al values. "I used to coon hunt a lot, and
I
really enjoy that. I still do a little bit of
it, but at 66 years old, you can't run over
the

25."

woods like you did when you was
Remembering

his

favorite hunting

raised this old dog from a
he
'til
was
15 years old. His name
puppy
was Mac. I'd talk to him in the woods,
dog, he says,

"I

and I really believe he could understand
me." When he went out hunting, Thomas
remembers that he "used to get the can of

a Pepsi
Cola, get some
crackers I'd put in my pocket, and I'd
walk to the top of this hill and set down.
By the time I got to the top of this hill I'd
be sort of hungry and thirsty, so I'd set
down and listen for him. And Mac would
come by me and I'd hug him and pat him.
And I told him, I said, 'Well, when you die
"
When
son, this'll be the hill you're on.'
old Mac eventually died, "[I] carried him
up there, and carried a shovel with me.
And I buried him to where we had had a

sardines, I'd get

�might strive to perfect."
Thomas remembers that his parents
"had a good name. I never heard my dad
cuss, and maybe he didn't have time to
cuss, because he was a-working all the
time. As my kids came along, I wanted
to be the kind of person that they would
want to call Dad. And then my grandkids
want them to have
are part of me, and
good memories."
Thomas' dancing is identifiable from
a distance
his stance and his zigzag of
bends at the major joints are unmistak
able. He also has certain upper body
moves that contribute to his style. "My
brother Ollie that I was talking about had
that. My younger sister Carlene has that.
I'm a shy person in some ways. I want to
present my dance the best that I can. I'm
a little bit afraid that I may not be good
even with dance." But once he
enough
starts dancing, "it's a feeling that just goes
all over your body. The confidence comes
then. I'm comfortable in my dance, once I
get into it." He believes the Lord gave him
I

the gift to dance. "Oh, yeah. He can take it
away from me." Thomas takes pride in his
ability to perform, but he acknowledges
softly, "I know where it came from." He

"I think I was born to dance. I
strive to make my dance as smooth and

explains,

as graceful as
as 'swanfuT
want it to flow from one step
step. You almost have to be

it

can be.

I

other
a dancer
to
experience that feeling. Buckdancing lives
within you, and your interpretation of the
to the

rhythm and the timing and the feeling of

the music. I've been asked to dance in
groups, but being that I was a self-taught
individual dancer to start with, I guess I'd
just rather keep it that way."
About the connection between dance
and music, he responds: "Dancing is
music. You make music with your feet.

And I'm definitely listening. One ear is al
ways on the music; the other ear is always
where the sound of myself is. You've got
to be right where the music is, so you
can be part of that band." Banjo player
Rebekah Weiler appreciates this, saying,
"When he dances, there is an energy that
I
pick up on that only makes me push my
playing harder." Maupin continued, "I
love old-time music. It's got my rhythm.
am that band when I'm a-dancing. I am
that tune." With certain signature songs,
like "Alabama jubilee," Thomas can't
wait to get his shoes on. "That's one of
my favorites. And when I'm a-dancing
without the music, most of the time I'm
a-singing that song in my mind. I try to
put it together to make it sound like [the
1

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to see Deacon Jones
when bp rattles bis bonps.'"
Although he can dance to up-tempo
tunes, he doesn't like to get to the point of
being out of sync with himself. Treasured
old-time banjo playing friend Curtis
Hicks, leader of the Old Time Strings
band, knows the upper moderate speeds

words] 'You ought

lot of good times." Mac "was my friend,
and I spent a lot of nights with him in the
woods. I hunted a lot by myself. That's a
good place to be alone, and sit down and
think and get your thoughts together. You
can think what kind of person that you
might want to be, or your goals that you

where Thomas is most comfortable. "I've
watched him when he'd be a-dancing to
my music. His feet were keeping time to
every lick I hit. I love to watch him dance,
and I love to play behind him." Longtime
friend

and

fiddler

Summertown

Terry

Pierce

of

the

Bluegrass Reunion Band
compares Maupin's timing to a tuner
needle exactly on pitch, adding, "With the
first down stroke of the bow, my arm and
his legs connect. The second beat I give to
him."

but Athens,
"I like to dance anywhere
Alabama [Tennessee Valley Old Time Fid
dlers Convention], is a little different. No
taps. You dance with a straight up form,
your hands to your sides, and you don't
went to
move around. The first time
I

Clifftop [Appalachian String Band Music
Festival in West Virginia],
really didn't
know what they called mountain flatfoot.
So, when
signed up to dance in competi
tion, I drew out the number 20 which was
I

I

the last dancer." After he had seen a cou
ple of dancers perform, "I went and told

my wife, I said, 'That's my dance! Come
to find out, it was Ira Bernstein and Phil

Jamison judging. Ira invited me to come
to his workshop that night, to show the
audience that he and I were similar but
different."
Thomas was an aircraft worker for 41
years,

stopped

and

after

dancing

marrying

in

competitively

1961
for

he
15

years. "At one time 7,000 people worked at
AVCO in Nashville. They had a lot of mu
sicians there. They would play at lunch,
and I'd go to the cafeteria and dance." He
recalls that "my boss took me up to the
president's office and I carried my board
and my shoes. We went in and I danced
he had never seen anything like
for him
this. So that was a pretty good honor for
me, to get to dance for the president of

big company like that." Around 1975,
when his two daughters were old enough
to date, the family started camping. There
was live music, which gave Thomas the
chance to get back into dancing. He found
that he appreciated it more than when he
a

was younger. One of his special memo

ries is dancing with his young fan, Brent
Herron. They competed in the same age
group, although Brent was about 12 at the
time and Thomas was around 50. "Well,
I
got a first. Brent got a second. I went
and told Brent, said, 'Brent, I really don't
know whether I beat you or not/ but
said, 'being you're young and I'm old, I'm
going to take this anyway.'"
Thomas would like his dance tradition to
continue, and has certain dancer friends
I

I

�"When we climbed on stage, they were
standing us to show on TV. He was next to
me, this little boy, and I said, 'Can you do
this without the music?' He said, 'Yeah.'
'Can you do it with the music?' 'Yeah.'
Well we did it both ways and (with a qua

None of Maupin's awards are on display
country home. Instead, they fill a
ten-drawer high boy cabinet. Thomas
doesn't deny the thrill of winning, but
losing makes him search his mind for a
way to improve his dancing. "I'm still
looking inside for what's me." And he
reflects, "I've been fortunate to win a lot
of contests, but them trophies don't mean
a thing if you don't have the audience ap
proval. If they don't think you're a winner,
you're really not a winner." Maupin never
considered himself an entertainer because
he danced for the sheer pleasure it gave
him. "I love to dance. I could dance by

over me: right here, that's where I'm sup
posed to be." At Smithville 2005, Kevin
shared that he felt his own style needed to
be spontaneous, saying, "When you hear

can look 'em in the eye, and do my best or
try my best. That's made me keep a-trying, keep a-trying, and I'm still learning.

who

share

ing. They're

his

rhythm

part of his

style

and

tim

extended family.

Seventeen-year-old Kevin Twilley, son

of

Danny Twilley, rhythm guitarist, is one he
has taken under his wing since Kevin was

small. "I have asked him to learn to do
my dance, and carry it to a higher level."
When they were billed as the young and
the old at

Smithville, Thomas remembers,

Linda

Gunderson

he
ver in his voice) he looked up at me
and something came
was like my boy

Thomas Maupin with his grandson Daniel,
Museum of Appalachia in 2004.

the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at

the beat, you know exactly what to do."
According to his mother, at the age of six

seven he could imitate Maupin's dance
moves with jaw-dropping accuracy, and
Kevin remembers thinking to himself,
that's what you're going
"What he does
to do." Inspired by Thomas, Kevin started
winning dance competitions when he was
eight years old. The difference in their
ages is not a factor in their unique friend
ship. Kevin enjoys spending time with
him, talking as easily with him as he does
with his teenage friends. He described
Thomas as having a "youthful soul."
Another dancer Maupin has mentored is
Danny Bell. "I was the first dancer around
here to carry a board, because I want to
hear. Well, before the competition, we's
or

under the trees a-dancing, and this
little boy about eight years old was out
all out

dancing and jumping around with us."
That evening, before the dance competi
tion, "Danny was leaning on the stage,
looking me in the eye, laughing. Well, I
looked at him and you know I was danc
I
ing to him. When we went off the stage,
asked him if he had a board to dance on.
No, he didn't have one. I gave him my
board to take home and dance on. We
became friends over the years, and he de
veloped into a terrific dancer. He danced
as a regular on the Opry while he was go
ing to college." Danny, who always calls

Thomas

Mr.

Maupin,

is "a

person that has

carried on, and we can dance similarly.
He's got good steps, a good style."

in his

myself, you know. But then I started see
ing people responding to it, fascinated by
the steps." If people like his dancing, "I

Still trying to learn." In July 2005, Thomas
won the senior division first place Na
tional Champion Buckdancing award. He
then came on stage, captivating the crowd
at Uncle Dave Macon Days by dancing
without music. It was his way of proving
to himself and the audience that he was
he had, and that his
solo instrument.
As Maupin has gotten older, he observes
that "at 66, you're not on your way up.
You're on your way out. I'm trying to
put more in my dance, I guess, than I
ever have. Because I try to express myself
through my dancing but I know in a
short time that I can't do this. I get tired
after I get home. I'm high when I'm here,

everything

it

giving

dance could be

and

I

a

can hurt tomorrow.' About his wife

Beulah, to whom he has been married for
44 years, he says, "I've got a wife that
really don't mind me going a lot. I think
she understands." I asked what it meant
to have his story told. "Well. You know,
being one of ten kids, and really not being
as

educated

as

I

should

in

book learning,

that's a way I would get to leave a part
of me, and what I've accomplished, here.
Maybe a hundred years from now, some
one can pick this book up and look at it,
and relate to who Thomas Maupin was.
He considers it an honor, "'cause we see

people that come through this
when they're gone, they're
gone. I would like for my kids and my
grandkids and other people to read
about the little part that I had in this
bie world.""
so many

world,

that

Linda Gunderson, artist and free-lance writer

in
Clinton, Tennessee, manages the dance
wagon stage at the Museum of Appalachia in
Norris, Tennessee.

OWj

A

video of Thomas

r1^4^aancing

at

the

Maupin

Appalachian

String Band Festival at is on
the Old-Time Herald web site:

www.oldtimeherald.org

�Ladder-braced Guitars and the Enduring
Mysteries of the Old-Time Sound
Margolies

the 1930s, black and white Southern rural
all tended to play the same

musicians

type of guitars-inexpensive, ladderbraced guitars by a variety of makers,

many of which are now forgotten.
Listen to old-time guitar players such as
Frank Hutchison, Dick Justice, Marshall
Nations, Ira Stripling, Luke Brandon,
Henry Whitter, Shell W. Smith all played
cheap ladder-braced guitars. Blues greats

Lemon Jefferson, Blind Willie
Johnson, Blind Blake, Son House, Charlie
Patton, Barbeque Bob, Skip James, Charlie
Jordan, Furry Lewis, and Henry Thomas
all played very similar guitars built by
companies such as Oscar Schmidt or Lyon
like

Blind

and Healy. Ira Stripling paid $6.00 for a
guitar ordered from the Baltimore Whole

while Charlie Monroe paid
$3.00 in Rosine, Kentucky, for his first
guitar. Ernest Stoneman played a memo
rable, large-bodied Galiano Auditorium
model. Ed Kincaid, who played with Fiddim' John Carson before 1922, played a
12-string Stella. Carson's later partner, his
daughter Rosa Lee Carson, better known
as Moonshine Kate, played a small-bod
ied, six-string Stella. Swing a cat and you
will hit an old-time master playing a lad
der-braced guitar. Swing a bit wider and
very commonly you will find the masters
who played these same cheap guitars
until they could afford to trade up
gi
ants like Jimmie Rodgers, Seven Foot
Dilly, Zeke Morris, and Mother Maybelle
sale House,

Carter, to name

a

braced

are

few.

col
defenders,
Many
contemporary
lectors, players, and builders of ladderguitars

certain

these

instru

ments are vital to achieving the old-time
sound. They insist it is the specific
construction of the guitar a technique
extraordinarily uncommon in contem

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ladder-bracing is a method of strength
ening the thin top of a flat-top guitar with
braces arranged perpendicular to the grain
of the top (see diagram for comparison
of the different bracing methods). Lad
der-bracing was once the normal method
for both mass-produced
of production
and

expensive guitars. Today these old

instruments have a reputation for being
short-lived, problematic and even ornery.
Structurally speaking, X-bracing is supe
rior because it takes into consideration the
rotational torque that the bridge exerts on
the top. The older style of ladder bracing
addresses only upward and downward
pressure and can be weaker, less resilient,
and less blasting. The strings on a guitar
are about 3/8" to 1/2" above the top and
thev continually pull on the bridge and
saddle, which in turn causes
the top to want to roll toward

Cambio

of the guitars. From the 1890s into at least

flaws, hold secrets that musicians now covet.

Todd

old photographs

courtesy

at

musicians throughout the South or
a
glance at a cover of reissued old-time
recordings reveals the striking uniformity

An unknown cowboy singer with unknown
guitar poses in a WIBU ((Poynette, WI) radio
promotional shot from the 1930s. The call let

the radio station stood for "Wind is
Being Used," since the station was originally
powered by a wind generator.
ters for

the neck. Steel strings exacer
bate these forces on the top of
the guitar because they require
more tension than gut strings.
This inherent structural weak
ness explains why old ladder-

braced guitars end up looking
so many aging old-time
musicians, with a big bulging
belly at the bridge. According

like

to Philip F. Gura, C.F. Martin
started
using his structur

ally superior X-bracing in his
guitars back in the 1850s. Al
though exceptional in his day
this manner of bracing would
come to set the standard for

makers. X-bracing,
once used only by the finest
makers such as Martin or the
Larson Brothers, is now the
standard bracing on guitars
from the cheapest imported
all future

model

ones.

to the

Cambio

1920s and 30s? A look

of

guitars that provides a sound
unlike any other. The design and building
of these old guitars, despite some inherent

porary

Todd

cheaply made guitars the key to
elusive sound of the golden era
old-time string bands as recorded in the
that
Were

courtesy

By Dan

most expensive

In this

photo from the late 1800s, the guitar was probably ladder-braced.

�Structure, style,

or

soul?

You might be thinking: well hold on a
minute, how those guitars were played
just might have had something to do
with the sound. Even a fine guitar can
sound like the Devil himself in the wrong
hands, while a good musician can make a
mediocre instrument sound great. It goes
without saying that a nice instrument in
the hands of a master is something else
altogether. Listen to Riley Puckett, Byrd
Moore, Sam McGee, Frank Hutchinson,
Roy Harvey, Leonard Copeland, or any
number of other great hillbilly guitar
ists, and there is no doubt that the sound,
drive, and feel comes from their hands
and soul as much as it does from any
instrument. Listen to Mother Maybelle
Carter, who played a cheap, ladderbraced Stella on her first sessions in
Bristol. Her sound is proof positive that at
heart it is the unmatched magnificence of
the player that matters, even if the specific
tonal quality of the guitar is special. There
is a long list of many other almost supernaturally good old-time guitar players.
Whatever guitar they played, their sound
was as unique as their genius and skill.
Genius does not come with an instrument
as a case does, and it does not come from
ladder bracing either.
It is often difficult to discern a guitarist's
technique, let alone tell the exact instru
ment they played. Alfred Karnes had a
singular sound to be sure, but he achieved
it on an expensive and rare Gibson harp
guitar. Nobody knows for sure how Ri
ley Puckett got his sound, even though

Guitar Bracing

Typical Ladder Braced
Parlor Guitar

we can hear the results and see in photo
graphs the type of guitar he played. Hav

ing heard so many contradictory descrip
tions of Puckett's technique, Norm Co
hen concluded 30 years ago
in the JEMF Quarterly that
we will never know much
about Puckett's playing be
yond that he "made his bass
runs with either his thumb
or with one or two fingers,
picking either upwards or

Ladder Braced
Stella Concert Guitar

downwards."

We

can

modern X-braced ones. But he believes
that the playing mattered much more.
Seeger believes we have to consider sev
eral elements of the music all at once, in
cluding things as basic as flatpick vs. fin
ger picks, playing technique, standard vs.
resonator guitar, room acoustics, and most
especially recording method, including
the recorder EQ and microphone type.
Seeger adds, "and even if it the sound

was unique, why try to reproduce it pre
cisely? I love to listen to the old 78s and
treasure the way they sound, but I'm not
am going to try to reproduce the
like to have an almost
contemporary sound. The songs they
deserve to be played again and
sure

I

same thing again.

I

played

again, but the sound they had was par
ticular to the time they were recorded."
Virginia fiddler Mark Campbell, who
has a passion for the old way of sounding
and playing, also downplays the signifi
cance of cheap ladder-braced guitars to

achieve

the

old-time

sound.

Campbell

thinks the reason old-time music sounds
different today is simply that few people

nowadays play quite like Riley Puckett or
Moonshine Kate did. Also people nowa

days do not hear or play the chords in
old-time fiddle tunes the same way they
did back in the 1920s and 30s and earlier.
The old chords once used to accompany
tunes are not always the obvious ones,
and their use has been lost or forgotten in
manv cases.
"Economics had everything to do with
it," says 'The Amazing' Jim Lloyd, oldtime musician and barber from Rural

"People played the
ladder-braced
guitars because
ubiquitous
who could af
were
Anyone
cheap.
they
Retreat,

Virginia.

ford an expensive guitar would buy one,
was that simple. Professional musicians

it

not

even know for sure whether
he used finger picks, thumb
picks, or no picks. Could it
matter, then, what kind of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Cambio
Todd

styles using at least
different guitars of vari
ous construction and origin,
thinks the old ladder-braced
guitar
20

guitars

sounds

definitely produce
distinct from more

courtesy

Braced Guitar

courtesy

X

Todd

Cambio

bracing his guitar had?
The style of playing and
the recording method also
had a huge effect on the way
music sounded.
old-time
Mike Seeger, who is record
ing an album of old-time

Old photo of a man with guitar, whiskey and rifle. The guitarist
holds what looks like a Stella guitar.

�across the South all insisted on finer in
struments." Jim Lloyd tells the story of
Maybelle Carter replacing her broken
Stella when her husband Eck demanded
"the best damn guitar money could buy"
in a store in Kingsport, Tennessee. Her
Gibson L-5 cost over $300.00 when a 1930
Model A Ford Coupe cost $495.00. Eck
threw Maybelle's Stella in the river. So
much for treasured old Stellas!
Built for Sound
That all said, we are still left with the fact
that so many musical giants did play very
similar ladder-braced guitars that are rare
or unknown today. The sheer similarity of
the instruments used in recording in the
golden era must have contributed to the

it

seems so important.

Next I asked a wide array of old-time
musicians what they thought of ladderbraced guitars in old-time music, how
they would describe the essence of the
sound of the old guitars, and similar
questions. Since people tend to be pas
sionate about their instruments I assumed
I would
find a few partisans. But I was
surprised how many people professed
to have not the foggiest idea about those
common ladder-braced guitars, let alone
a
strong opinion about their role, even
though they could easily rattle off the
names of a half-dozen of their favorite
pickers who played them. Many musi
cians responded to me roughly the same
way as did so many historians, collectors,
and luthiers
they did not have any clue
what I was talking about. A musician in
Seattle with an enormous repertoire of
obscure and great old-time tunes and
great skill on all instruments including
the guitar (he plays a modern Martin), a
guy I expected would understand the es
sence of old guitars in the music, told me
"I don't know a ladder-braced guitar from
a
teenager with braces."
Others who were familiar with ladderbraced guitars had not spent much time
thinking about them. A bevy of profes
sional historians of guitars and country
music told me they had not spent much
time considering why people played

cheaply
sounded

made

guitars

or

what

they

On the other end of the
spectrum, collectors tend not to collect
cheap guitars and luthiers over the last
half-century tend not to spend time fixing
like.

them up. Why invest money in repairing
an old guitar that lacks adornment or a
pedigree and would not be easy to sell?
Collectors tended to be more interested
in the rarer, finer, better-made guitars like
Martin and Gibson, not the catalog gui

in huge numbers. Inexpen
ladder-braced instruments tended
not to last in playable condition and were
treasured less by collectors for a variety of
reasons. Such instruments, which usually
require a certain amount of reengineering
to be playable, are seldom seen in vintage
guitar shops today. Martin and Gibson
put their names on the headstock early,
while many ladder-braced makers did

tars bought

sive

not. Rather they put them in paper la
bels or burned them into the center strip
(Montgomery Wards' higher end models
featured burned brand names of "Wind
sor" of "Thornward"). Often cheaper gui
tars had no label at all, so some sleuthing
is required to figure out the maker. Now
they are more often hanged unstrung as

decoration

in any

number of quasi-Irish

pubs, stores, and pawnshops throughout
Ask a old-time guitar player
the U.S.
who likes old instruments and they can
recount finding a cool old ladder-braced

courtesy

Todd

Cambio

recognizable sound of vintage old-time
music. It seems worthwhile to investigate
how much of the old-time sound came
from those instruments: to see exactly
what kind of guitars were played, where
they came from, and how and why their
sound differed from higher-end instru
ments. Robert C. Hartman, who wrote a
book on the magnificent Larson guitars
(some of which were ladder-braced),
notes that an "instrument has to have
the sound built into it to sound superb."
It is striking how few people seem to have
thought about what elements of construc
tion made the old guitars sound the way

they do, even though

Here are five old ladder-braced six-strings, l to r: an unknown parlor guitar from the late 1800s, a fancy late 1800s F. Schwarzer Echo parlor
concert guitar from the 1920s, and an Oscar Schmidt
a
Lyon and Healy guitar from the early 1900s, an Oscar Schmidt made Galiano
made Stella grand concert guitar from the 1920s.

guitar,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�or

neglected

die. Mark Campbell bought an old ladder-

braced parlor guitar that hung for years
on the wall of a pizza parlor in Richmond,
Virginia and had the bracing replaced
with X-bracing. Jim Lloyd once bought a
1934 Kalamazoo ladder-braced guitar for
$26 in pieces in a bag in Statesville, NC
and X-braced it to make it playable.

Finding Ladder-Braced Guitar Lovers
Thus, the fine vintage instruments that
make their way to prominent display
and use today are not the common instru
ments that once pounded out rhythms
or picked out elaborate bass runs on the

embarked on a
old 78s. Still intrigued,
mission to find ladder-braced guitar en
thusiasts, and eventually found people
who believe they have learned the secrets
I

sound. We owe them a great deal,
not least because they have unraveled the
inner history and secrets of a style and
a sound
that has virtually disappeared.
Maybe they are even bringing it back.
Sound may be hard to describe, but
differences in it are not hard to detect
of its

you are knowledgeable and discrimi
nating. Mike Seeger calls the sound of
a
ladder-braced guitar "a nice boomy,
if

not sophisticated and
like
an
[x-braced] Martin has."
tight light
Neil Harpe, who has written a history of
Stella guitars and who specializes in sell
ing them, says that ladder-braced Stella
guitars "can be described as sounding
woody, loud, throaty and nasal" while

homey

sound,

ladder-braced

"Gibson-made

Kalama

zoo guitars have a distinctively different
sound than their X-braced Gibson breth
ren
more open sounding and woody."
Todd Cambio, a Madison, Wisconsin

guitar builder who specializes in building
highly coveted Fraulini guitars based ex

actly on early ladder-braced instruments,
values the ladder-braced guitars for their
"sinewy punch."
However this sound might be described,
the perfection of the guitar within the
in groups with an
string band setting
ideal sound such as the Leake County
Revelers or the Roane County Ram
blers
makes it seem like the guitar might
well always have been a part of old-time
southern music. It turns out, though, that
about every other instrument in a string
band is more old-time than are the steel
string, ladder-braced guitars we think of
as the rhythmic backbone of old-time mu
sic. The guitar's place in old-time music
is itself not very old-time. It is partly this
relative newness that makes the rapid and
wide spread of ladder-braced guitars so
interesting. The new instrument helped
forge the classic old-time sound.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

A late arrival,

a

dramatic entrance

The guitar has a particular role in oldtime music, and that role developed at
the very end of the 19th century. The main
reason why ladder-braced guitars became
so central to old-time music is that they
were cheap and readily available. The
definitive history of these guitars in early

Southern music remains to be written. If
the fiddle is ancient and the banjo has old,
deep roots in early New World African
slave cultures and a long gestation in
the United States during the 1800s, the
guitars we hear in old-time music are

transfer from polite parlor cul
young
ture of the North and the genteel South to
the country during the 1890s.
Guitars were found in the South early,
but they were uncommon and used for
parlor or European music. Where these
instruments came from exactly and how
a

they spread during the antebellum period
is not well known. They did get scattered
around the South in haphazard fashion
and appear fleetingly in accounts through
out the nineteenth century. In 1852, the
Southern Literary Messenger published an
account of music in the "Old Days of the
Old Dominion" on Pine Fork Plantation
in which a banjo beat out a guitar in a

musical showdown and an observer re
marked "that the banjo was infinitely the
these foreign guitars
best of the two
and notions were a disgrace to the ris
ing generation." In 1857 Charles McKay,
traveling on the Mississippi River, wrote
a verse remarking on "the slaves rejoic
ing
happier than the free/with guitar

a burst of revelry!"
Very
early string bands also seem to have uti
lized guitars in limited ways. Mike Seeger
cites Lafcadio Hearn's descriptions of

and banjo, and

New Orleans bands with guitar, banjo,
and fiddle and another with guitar, bass,
and fiddle before the Civil War. But this
type of ensemble was a rare occurrence. In
1875, Edward King toured the South and
reported hearing black musi
cians playing guitar and banjo
together in Palatka, Florida.
Despites these anecdotes, gui
tars remained expensive and
rare oddities.
The

guitar

tars became widespread only in the early
20th century. In her book on Alabama old-

fiddling, Joyce Cauthen describes
few fiddlers' conventions in Ala
bama allowed guitars well into the 20th
century. Historian, Bill C. Malone noted
that Hobart Smith of Saltville, Virginia,
time

how

a guitar until after World War
Seeger recounts mountain musicians he
met who did not even see a guitar until
the 1930s.

did not see
I.

Ironically, the guitars used so widely
when old-time Southern music was first
commercially recorded were heavily mar

commodities

and built
and
Northern
by European immigrants
craftsmen and sold through the quintes

keted

sential

commercial

designed

institutions

mail

like

and
The
and

Sears
Roebuck and Montgomery Ward.
South was awash in cheap six-

order catalog companies

twelve-string models. Many were made

Oscar Schmidt Company under
names that still resound with authority
to guitarists today: Stella, Bruno, Galiano,
Other companies that
and Sovereign.
made ladder-braced guitars were Lyon
and Healy (Lakeside), Valco, Washburn,
Harmony, Larson Brothers (Regal and
Maurer), Stahl, Bay State, Weymann,

by the

Tonk

Brothers,

and

B&amp;J

(Buegeleisen

the Harvard.

Mike Seeger has a "Bradley
Kincaid" model guitar which he describes
as "a real mail order brand." This guitar is
"basically like all the other cheap guitars
from the 1930s," he says, and he likes the
tone for exactly that reason. Sears started
selling the Bradley Kincaid Houn' Dog
model in 1929. Sometimes guitars were

even given away

prizes. For example,
boost its
the
Louisville
Courier-Journal
readership,
gave away ladder-braced guitars with
as

in the late 1890s, in an effort to

really burst into

popularity in the South during
the Gilded Age as a product of
industrialization, mass produc
tion, and modern marketing
and distribution. While there
obviously was variation de

pending

on

&amp;

Jacobson). More were made by a flurry
that churned out cheap
of companies
The
guitars.
guitars were sold under a
stunning variety of brand names, rang
ing from Toreador, Juanita, and Rossini to

one's position

in

instruments

as

Cambio

some indelicate

life and location, the common
people of the South adopted

mass-produced

soon as they appeared. These
market forces had a huge
cultural effect and they trans
formed southern music. Gui

Todd

in

unloved, forgotten, seemingly born to

courtesy

guitar

state

group of men from the early 1900s with what appear to be
two new ladder-braced guitars, probably catalog guitars made

A

in

Chicago.

�for the concert size version. By 1908, Sears
had dropped its prices significantly. You

subscriptions (alongside a choice of free
accordions, mandolins, and banjos, sets of

could buy a steel-string, spruce-top guitar
with poplar back and sides for only $1.89,
or a similar instrument (the "Serenata")
stained to look like oak for $2.45. The
highest dollar guitar Sears sold that year
was $28.15.

Tales, loads of coal,
machines,
sewing
pocket watches, and
sheet music collections).
These ladder-braced guitars were made
cheaply and sold extensively to white
and black musicians
the
throughout
South via catalogs and dealers around
the turn of the last century. In addition to
the Sears and Ward's catalogs (also later
the, door-to-door by traveling salesmen,
and offered in general stores. Neil Harpe
notes that Stellas were played very widely
because they were easily acquired: "the
Oscar Schmidt Company had traveling
salesmen who distributed far and wide to
businesses such as furniture stores, Mom
even gasoline
&amp; Pop country stores
The Leatherstocking

Workmanship, wood, and wizardry
makers started to churn
out instruments for these new markets
When

the beginning of the 20th century, they
followed accepted, timeworn techniques
of building instruments. The vast ma
at

jority of builders (both big factories and
small shops) built ladder-braced guitars.
It

Montgomery Ward and Compa

ny offered nine different guitars such as
the Columbian Standard or Concert, the
Kenwood, or the Windsor made of woods

braced guitars ranging in price, wood, and
degree of ornamentation, often described
in the catalog only by model name or
number. Only the highest priced guitars
were described by maker. In 1897, Sears

time.

Even the cheap guitars often were
solidly made, although there was quite a
bit of variation depending on brand. Lar
son Brothers built ladder-braced guitars
"under tension," which meant that had
slightly arched backs and tops, and their

recommended using only gut and silk
wound strings, and would not guaran
tee any instrument
a

few years

strung with steel. But
it was pushing steel-

string instruments aggressively. In 1897,
you could buy a "Spanish guitar" made
in America, with birch back and sides, for
$3.95. An oak guitar with an antique fin
ish ran $5.95, while the "Collegian" mod

featured quartered, figured sycamore,
imitation rosewood and mahogany, an
imitation cherry neck, and ebonized fin
el

ger board for $6.45. The Washburn guitars
were significantly more, from $22 to $27

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

that although

wood. The 1897 Sears catalog claimed that
they selected only 12 models from a possi
ble 1000 guitars, and noted that "the most
expert workmen only are employed. The
skilled artisans are amongst the highest
salaried workmen in the world." It is im
possible to conflate the mass-production
of the late nineteenth with the machinemade imported products of our current

like maple, cedar, oak, or rosewood. Pric
es ranged from $4.50 to $26.00. Sears and
Roebuck had a wider variety of ladder-

within

should be remembered

mass produced in factories in the indus
trial North, the catalog guitars were still
handmade by craftsman, and the guitars
were made of solid and not laminated

stations!"
In 1895

guitar

historian

Hartman believes the models

built with high-quality materials "would
stand up against any X-braced guitar
made from that period or even now."
Neil Harpe argues that "the design of the
Stella and Sovereign guitars... was the
prime reason for their superior tone and
volume. These guitars had only three
R top braces, positioned m such a way to
take maximum advantage of the ladIf
f

der-braced configuration."
However it was configured, ladder
bracing in those mass-produced guitars
allowed for a unique, distinct tone. They

often louder, looser, and, to many,
they just sound better. X-bracing is stron
ger, but it lacks the character of the older
way. Mike Seeger thinks "guitar makers
are now doing a better job making in
struments than ever before, but they just
don't sound the same. The wood is not the
Guitar builder
same, it lacks the age."
Todd Cambio has identified several other
are

aspects of the old ladder-braced

guitars
made up to the 1930s that distinguished
them and gave them their vital sound. In

new Fraulini Angelina (R)
six-string (patterned after a 1920s Stella grand
concert model) and a circa 1910 Montgomery
Todd

Cambio with

a

Ward catalog guitar(L), made by Lyon and Healy

in

Chicago.

building only ladder-braced guitars he
jokingly describes his task as "rebuilding
the Titanic." Besides the loud, certain tone
available from the ladder bracing, Cambio
thinks the shorter scale lengths and small
er bodies of the old six strings gave them
the unique snappy sound you hear on the
old recordings, as did the radiused backs
used in old Stellas. Also, makers of the
early 20th century all used hide glue in as

sembly, which has disappeared in all but
the highest end guitars today. "The rise in
popularity of modern 'parlor' guitars and
the methods of modern manufacturing are
creating many smaller, short-scale guitars,
but they are X-braced and they just don't

sound right," says Cambio.
Perhaps the most distinctive aspect of
the old instruments was the use of do
mestic woods. The low-end makers of
the past used domestic woods that were
ignored by Martin and Gibson.
Higher-end guitar makers often chose
more exotic woods such as mahogany,
often

rosewood, and ebony, or difficult-to-work
woods like maple. In contrast, brands like
Stella featured lower grades of wood as

a

cost-cutting measure. It happens that do
mestic woods like oak, basswood, poplar,
and birch have excellent and unique tonal
characteristics. These have been all but
ignored by makers since the age of the
ladder-braced builders, but Cambio has
returned to using these materials in order
to make guitars as close as possible to the
vintage ones. Fraulini guitars are made
with the precise dimensions of the old
Stellas. They are ladder-braced, have radi
used backs, and are made with hide-glue
and sustainably harvested domestic hard
woods like Wisconsin white oak. Cambio
thinks by using old methods and old tech
niques he has captured the elusive sound
of those old guitars.

Whether ladder-braced guitars are in
deed the secret to the old-time sound, or
if it is after all just old-fashioned skill,
practice, and inspiration, one sure thing
is that players today can once again test
their mettle against instruments built in
the old-time way like those once sold
so cheaply throughout the South. "Now
Martins and Gibsons sound fantastic,
but they don't sound like they're coming
unhinged," Todd Cambio says. "Martins
have a beautiful even tone that 75% of
guitar makers are trying to copy, while
the rest of them are trying to capture the
beauty of a Gibson's bass. But that's not
what you hear on the great old record
ings, you hear a punch, a snap and drive,
and the only place your going to get that
is a ladder-braced instrument baby!"

Dan Margolies is a historian, banjo player,
and beekeeper in Norfolk, Virginia. He can be
reached at dsmargolies@verizon.net.

�A

Musical Marriage:

Lester and Linda McCumbers
of Calhoun County, West Virginia

By Kim Johnson

and Malinda McCumbers

have
each other their whole lives.
They were married in December 1937 at
the age of sixteen. "Linda had the whole
world to pick from, and she picked me,"
Lester said. "We walked across the hill
about five miles to Joe McClung's house.
He was a Methodist preacher who lived on
Mill Fork, and we got married in the road

house, then walked back."
"That walk back was our honeymoon,"

in front of his

added. "My dad and Lester's dad
hitch-hiked over to Grantsville to get our
wedding license. We set up housekeeping on
Mount Run, and have lived here ever since."
Linda

Kim

Johnson

Lester
known

Lester and Linda McCumbers

at home in

2004

Lester McCumbers, son of Henry Franklin
and Myrtle McCumbers, was born August
15, 1921 on Big Run in southern Calhoun
who
Everyone
County, West Virginia.
knows Malinda McCumbers calls her Linda.
She was born on August 3, 1921 on Mount
Run in Calhoun County, the daughter of
Galry and Ada [Cottrell] McCumbers.
All the children from the area walked
together to attend the Beech Grove
School at Nicut. When Lester and

Linda finished school there, their
formal education was over. In order
to attend high school they would
have had to walk about ten miles to
Orma to catch a bus, then ride about
twenty miles on into Grantsville to

the high school. Not very many stu
dents from the area went on to high
school because at that time even the
children were needed to help their
families with the farm work in order
to

survive.

collection

We

had to walk over a mile to
the school, and before school

each
of us girls had a cow to milk,"
Linda recalled. "While we were
at school Dad would take the
horse and pull some logs up
into the yard, and after school

McCumbers

family

started

I

Lester McCumbers in 1941

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

every

morning,

was out we'd have to go home and cut
them into firewood. If dad was gone we'd

to go up on the hill and get the fod
der down for the horse and cows to eat.
We'd have to tie ropes around it and drag
it all the way down the hill."
"My mother did her washing on a wash
board, and we would help her with all
that work every week. She'd build a big
fire outside to heat the water in a big iron
pot," said Linda. "We'd put lye in the
water and boil all the white clothes in it.
Since Dad had a well, we didn't have to
carry water from the creek like a lot of
other people. We had to work almost all
the time just to get by."
Often the dirt roads would be impass
able. "Sometimes when the mail carrier
came through the country from Villanova
on the Elk River over to Servia and on
to Orma the mud would be up past the
horse's knees. Almost nobody had a car or
truck. If you weren't lucky enough to have
a horse, you had to walk everywhere you

have

went," Lester remembered. "One time
when I was a boy I walked with my dad a
couple of miles around the road to a little
store. There had been a big snow, and it
took us about four hours to get there and
The snow was up to our belts, so
wet and heavy it was hard to walk in."

back.

�"Anybody born in the last 30 or 40 years
can't imagine the things people had to en
dure to survive back when we were growing
up. And it wasn't just a few people who had
it rough," said Lester. "It was everybody. A
people didn't have much of anything,
the conveniences came along

lot of

when

and

later, they were really appreciated."
"We got electricity sometime in the 1950s.
Back before that we had a battery radio that
to my dad," Lester recalled.
"Sometimes on Saturday nights we'd string
up the antenna wire high in a tree and listen

had belonged

to the

Grand Ole Opry."

Today Lester and Linda McCumbers
have a large close-knit family of 9 children,
20 great-grandchildren,
great-great-grandchildren. Sing
ing, dancing, and playing music have al
25

grandchildren,

and

10

ways been a large part of the McCumbers
family's life. Their son Bill is a guitar play
er and singer, while his brother Tim plays
both guitar and bass. Their daughter Joan
and

son-in-law Paul Cottrell have

called

High Mountain

a

band

Bluegrass. Roger

played the banjo and also sang. Beatrice,
Joan and Tammy are all enthusiastic danc
ers, and Tammy sings as well.
As a young girl, Linda often sang in
church with her twin sister India. The
girls also sang at literaries, which were

family

gatherings at the schoolhouse where the
students recited poetry and demonstrated
their scholastic skills at grammar and
arithmetic. After the recitations were over
the singing and dancing would begin.
"The girls at the school begged me to
show them how to dance," said Linda.
"I was always a pretty good dancer, and
India was too. We'd all go around to the
outhouses behind the schoolhouse be

popular fiddler for dances in the area. He
would come to visit Lester and Linda and
stay for weeks at a time. John Cottrell was
an early influence on Lester's fiddling,
and Lester plays several of his tunes to
day, including "Yew Piney Mountain,"
"Sourwood
"Mother
Flanagan," and
Mountain." Lester still plays the fiddle

that belonged to Tohn Cottrell.
There was always music in the McCum
bers' home, and before radio and television,
that music was homemade. Linda's father
Galry was a good singer and an agile backstep dancer. He played the banjo in the
clawhammer style and also the jews harp.
Linda's mother Ada [Cottrell] McCumbers
often sang old ballads while tending to the
children and doing other household chores.
Ada's sisters Sarah [Cottrell] Schoolcraft
and Phoebe [Cottrell] Parsons were also
singers, and as a little girl Linda learned
such songs as "Pretty Polly" and "Barb'ry
Allen" from them.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

McCumbers

cause it was fun to dance on the wooden
floors in there."
Linda's grandfather John Cottrell was a
John Cottrell, daughter Phoebe, and wife Malinda. Photo dated about 1923.

Phoebe

[Cottrell]

Parsons

Linda's aunt.

is

remembers hearing her aunt
Parsons singing "Cherry River
Line" and playing "Walking in the Par
lor" energetically on her banjo. Phoebe
Linda

Phoebe

was well-known all over West Virginia for
her banjo playing, singing, dancing, and
colorful personality. She also liked to beat
the fiddlesticks by using slender sticks or
sometimes knitting needles to tap out a

rhythm on the strings of a fiddle as the
fiddler played and tried to keep his fin
gers out of the way. Phoebe passed away
in 2001 at the age of ninety-three.
Phoebe's brother Noah Cottrell had a
reputation as a good banjo player, fiddler
and singer. He liked to play the banjo and
sing "Old Rattler" and "Johnny Booger."
Both Phoebe and Noah were popular per

formers
as

at

traditional music festivals such
Gathering and the West

the Vandalia

Virginia Folk Festival
Linda McCumbers

voice and

an

at

Glenville.
has

a
powerful
singing
style. She
original

has sung since she was a little girl. "I've
always liked to sing the old songs that my

mother used to sing," said Linda. "I sing
the words the way I feel them, and I don't
try to copy anybody."
Linda doesn't read music at all, and
learned to sing by ear. She watched her

older brother Bernard play his guitar, and
learned to play it herself to follow her
singing. As well as old-time ballads, Lin
da

learned many hymns from her mother

Ada, and sings some of her favorites to
this day, including "Oh Those Tombs,"
"Purple Robe," and "Shake My Mother's
Hand For Me."
Most people usually regard Linda as The
Singer and Lester as The Fiddler. But Lester

�bedsteads, and other household

chairs,

goods for people," said Lester. "He made
his own foot-powered turning lathe that
he used to turn out the legs for the furni
ture. In those days there were no furniture

stores, and household furnishings had to

be

homemade

or

done without."

Henry Franklin McCumbers, known as
Bub in the community, was a farmer. "My
dad did a little blacksmithing too and
made some of his own tools. He made
himself one of the turning lathes that
he'd seen his father use," Lester said. "He
made some little chisels and used them
on the lathe, and he could turn out some
of the prettiest knobs on chairs ever seen.
He'd also shave down axe handles that he
sold or traded for things he needed. He
made a froe that he used to rive out fence
palings and boards that were so smooth
they looked like they had been planed."
Once when Bub was a young man, he
was splitting firewood in the side yard

when he accidentally chopped off his left
thumb with the axe. Since there were no
available doctors in the area at the time
within walking distance, Bub stuck the
thumb back on, and wrapped up his
hand in a rag. Eventually the thumb re

attached on its own, and although

it

back crooked, he had good use of

grew

McCumbers

family

collection

the
rest of his life.
"My dad worked in the lumber camps
on the Williams River," recalled Lester.
"He used a crosscut saw to cut the trees
down, then ball-hooted them off the high
mountains there along the Williams and
it

Rivers." According to Lester,
ball-hooting trees involved cutting the
tree down, peeling off the bark, then
Cranberry

Lester's father Henry Franklin McCumbers.
Most people in the community called him
"Bub." You can see his crooked thumb on his
left hand where he cut it off.

strong singer in his own right, and when
they sing together the harmonies have a
pure and intensely mountain sound.
is a

Lester decided he wanted a guitar
when he was about fourteen years old.
He worked cutting brush and hoeing

corn for farmers in the area until he got

enough money

to

send off for

a

mail-or

der guitar from the Alden's catalog. Dur
ing the 1950s Lester played guitar with

local fiddlers such as French Carpenter,
Ward Jarvis, and Harvey Sampson for

dances and various community events. At
age 83 Lester is still a solid guitar player
today, and frequently surprises people
with his rendition of "Blue Yodel #1" ["T
For Texas"]. "My dad played the fiddle a
little, and when he found out that I was
interested in playing the fiddle too, he
made me one," Lester said. "My niece in
Parkersburg has that fiddle today."
"My dad lived in Clay County when he
was a boy. His father Thomas McCumbers
was a carpenter in that area who made

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

working the log with a cant hook to start
it sliding down the mountain. The peeled
logs were very slick, and they would
zoom down the mountainsides very fast.
This was usually done on slopes that were
too steep for horses to be used to skid the
logs down.
"My dad raised wheat when I was a boy.
We hauled our wheat over to Flatwoods
to the wheat mill to get it ground," re
membered Lester. "We had gristmills
around home, but there were no wheat
mills. The wheat mill separated the grain

out into the bran, the flour, and the shorts,
stuff from the heart of the
a red-looking
wheat. A lot of people fed the shorts to
their hogs, but we used it to make some
bread once, and it was some of the best
bread ever ate."
As a young man Lester worked at vari
ous jobs to support his family. He worked
in a rock quarry near Grantsville trim
ming up rocks to be used in buildings. He
worked on different construction crews,
helping to build the Minnora School and
I

the Grantsville rubber plant. At one time,
Lester carried the mail on horseback from

Nicut

to

Rosedale.

Linda remembered that whenever another
came up, she and Lester's mother
Myrtle would take turns carrying the
mail in his place. "I'd carry the mail for
one week and Myrtle would watch the
kids for me, then she'd carry it the next

job

week," said Linda. "We had to go over a
mile down to the store to pick up the mail,
then deliver it up Mount Run and on over
to Rosedale. The mailbags were heavy
and made out of canvas. We rode an old
big horse that would just clop along never
going too fast, and the rain would soak
you or the snow would just about freeze
you to death. At every house we had to
get off the horse to see if there was mail

boxes
coming in."
in the

to go out or

deliver anything

Lester also worked on road crews clear
ing the snowy and icy roads in winter.
Instead of the truck spreading salt on the
road like today, he had to ride in the back
of a dump truck and throw out a mixture
of salt and cinders by the shovelful. It
was cold and hard work. At dinnertime
the men would build a fire by the side of
the road to get warm and try to heat up
their food. "We'd build up a big fire and
cut a stick to hold sandwiches and heat
them up that way," said Lester. "I'd take

ham sandwiches made from home-killed
hog meat. That was real good when it got
heated up on the fire. Ham meat and bis
cuits made the best sandwiches because
it was easier to stab the stick through the
middle of a biscuit to hold over the fire."
Lester worked on several different tim
ber crews helping cut timber for sawmills.
The trees had to be cut down, stripped of
bark, and then skidded down the hills. He
used the two-man crosscut saw on some
of these jobs, and on others used a oneman power saw that weighed about 75
pounds. It was heavy work carrying that
saw through the hills and over the ridges

being cut, sawing with
and
then
carrying it back on the
day,
return trip.
The sawmills usually ran two big circular
saws to cut the logs into boards. "They'd
saw till noon with one blade, then switch
it off and I'd sharpen the dulled one to
use the next day. The crosscut saws used
by the timber crews also had to be kept
sharpened," Lester said, "and sometimes
there'd be 20-30 men in a crew. The saws
got dull pretty fast especially if the logs
were dirty, and they were muddy most
of the time from being skidded down the
to get to the trees
it all

hills."

"Timbering is hazardous work. The
saws are dangerous to work with if you
don't pay attention to what you're doing.
There's always a chance of a falling limb
or tree crippling or killing you. Some of
my good friends got killed working in the
timber, but I never did get hurt too bad,
just

a

few scrapes here and there.

�sang and played guitar in the group. Their
son Bill also played guitar and sang with

the group occasionally at festivals.
For four years in the mid-1960s the band
now known as Lester McCumbers &amp; The

Sandy Valley Boys
WSPZ in Spencer,
as WVRC today].
were live on the

hosted

a

radio show on

West Virginia [known
The 30-minute shows

every Saturday af
sponsored by Lynch's
Market and the Millstone Garage, among
others. Sometimes other area musicians
such as John and Dave Morris from Ivydale, West Virginia would drop in and
ternoon

McCumbers

family

collection

plav on the show.
"That radio show was just like being at
Lester and Linda's home. They were very
open with it, and everybody was wel
come to come in and play a tune or two,"
said John Morris. "One time I when I was
there Noah Cottrell was playing 'Johnny
Booger' with the banjo behind his head.
I
don't guess he thought about how the
radio listeners wouldn't be able to see his

Bernard McCumbers, Lester McCumbers, Dwayne McCumbers (holding Darrell's
daughter Colleen), and Darrell McCumbers on a fishing trip in 1967.

Left to right]:

"Whenever

I
got a day off, I'd usually
fishing, sanging [hunting ginseng], or
maybe go hunting for a bee tree," Lester
remembered. "I used to do quite a bit of
sanging in my younger days. Back then
you could sell it to about any store in the
country. If you wanted to trade for some
store goods like coffee or sugar, they'd
give you a little more for the sang than if
they bought it from you outright."
"After I quit trying to work anyplace, I'd
fish almost every weekend, and through
the week sometimes too. I've caught a
lot of muskies, they're pretty good to eat
if you catch them at about 30 inches or

go

so," said Lester. "But the best fish to eat
is walleye, and Elk River used to be full
of them."

Another lifelong interest of Lester's has
been the old style of mountain fiddling,
and playing the fiddle has always been
a
big part of his life. He has a rhythmic
and driving style of playing the fiddle.
Everything about Lester's music is his
own, from how he cradles the fiddle in
the crook of his elbow to the way he bows
and the notes he chooses. Lester's fiddling
and singing is a reflection of his whole life
with its many challenges, joys, and sor
rows. "I just don't feel right if I don't play
a

tune or two every day," he said. "Music

just gives me

a

whole lot of satisfaction

deep down in my heart."

never set out to copy anybody
playing the fiddle. I came up with what
"I've

I've got on my own," said Lester. "I've al
ways tried to play the fiddle or sing a song
to suit myself and the way I feel it. I'd hear
different fiddlers play tunes, and if I liked

a certain piece I'd try to play it in my own
way, but nobody actually showed me any
thing on the fiddle."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

When

Lester

first

started

playing the
what he calls the
GDGD. Some fiddlers

fiddle, he tuned

it

in

natural key of
tune their fiddles to AEAE and call this
the high key, but Lester likes the lower
tones of the G tuning. Lester also tunes
his fiddle to GDAE and calls this tuning
the chord key because he can sing or play
in any chord from there.
Linda remembered a time in the late
1950s when she entered a talent show
with Lester. "One time they were hav
ing a talent contest in the movie theater
at Orma. Whoever won the big prize

got to play on television on Channel 4 at
Oak Hill. I went down with Lester and
we signed up to play. I sang "Don't This
Road Look Rough and Rocky," Lester
played the fiddle, with me, and we won.
They gave us two prizes. For some reason
we didn't actually get to play on TV, but
the other prize made up for that. It was a
pretty good-sized stuffed monkey about
a foot tall, and I gave it to my little baby

grand-daughter.
In

cians,

"

early 1960s Lester and Linda
a band with other local musi
and were known as Glen Gainer

the

played

in

&amp; The Sandy Valley Boys. They primarily
played traditional bluegrass and country
songs with an occasional fiddle tune here
and there. The group was very popular
and performed at various music festivals
and other events in the area. The band
made a 45 rpm recording of the old-time
fiddle tune "Blue-Eyed Girl" and the bal

lad "Willy Roy" for Blue Hill Records

air

at 3:30 and

in

Charleston, West Virginia.
About 1964 Lester and Linda's oldest
son Roger, who sang and played the banjo
in both bluegrass and clawhammer styles,
joined the band. Son-in-law Paul Cottrell

trick banjo playing."
The radio shows were very popular at
the time, and Lester has one surviving re
cording of a show that features the band's

performance of such bluegrass standards
as "Little Glass Of Wine," "Ruby," "Wor
ried Man Blues," "Doin' My Time," "Bear
Tracks," "Girl In The Blue Velvet Band,"
and "Ragtime Annie."
Lester McCumbers &amp; The Sandy Valley

Boys were also featured performers at
various music festivals from the late 1960s
through the early 1990s, including ap
pearances at the Morris Family Old Time
Music Festivals, the Pipestem Festival, the
Black Walnut Festival at Spencer, and at
the Aunt Minnie's Farm Bluegrass Festi
vals near Stumptown, West Virginia.
When Roger McCumbers was diagnosed
with heart disease in the mid-1990s, the

Sandy Valley Boys performed less fre
quently as his condition worsened. After
Roger tragically passed away in 1998 at
the age of 48, they didn't play as a band

anymore. It was a sad time for the family,
and Roger's absence will always be felt.
In 1995 Lester started playing with Car
roll Hardway, a clawhammer style banjo
player from Braxton County. They played
at several music events such as the Au
gusta Heritage Workshops, the Stonewall
Jackson Jubilee, and the Glenville Folk
Festival until Carroll's death in 2002.
Lester and Linda McCumbers are still
very active at many traditional music

throughout West Virginia.
They have been popular additions to the
Old-Time Week events at the Augusta
Heritage Center during the summer, as
well as the annual Fiddler's Reunion held
each October in Elkins. Although they
were unable to attend, Lester and Linda
were honored to be invited to perform at
gatherings

the Smithsonian Folklife Festival in
ington, DC in June 2003.

Wash

�An almost steady stream of people from
across the country are continually

all

making the journey

to

Calhoun County

to

seek out Lester and Linda at their home,

fascinated
Fiddler

away

music and lifestyle.
Doherty came from as far
Donegal, Ireland just to record
by their

Liz
as

their music and visit with them.
Erynn Marshall from Toronto, Canada
interviewed Lester and Linda at length
for her master's thesis
in preparation
entitled Music in the Air Somewhere:
The Shifting Borders of West Virginia's
Fiddle and Song Traditions, which was
published in May 2003.
In August 2003, Lester and Linda were

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Karen

Heyd

featured prominently in an interview for
the Pittsburgh Post Gazette and left a

Lester McCumbers at the Appalachian String Band Festival, Clifftop, WV in 2004.

lasting impression on Martha Rial, pho
tographer for the paper. "Both Lester and
Linda are such an inspiration. They have
so much to teach musicians and music
lovers about perseverance and the joys
of living. They never forgot where they

came from, and I like that."
Lester and Linda both look forward to
playing and singing every year at the West
Virginia Folk Festival in Glenville. Lester
has won the first place blue ribbon in the
Senior Fiddle Contest there since 2001.
His version of "Yew Piney Mountain"
won the blue ribbon for Senior Honors in
the 2002 and 2003 fiddle contests, and first
place over all at the Appalachian String
Band Festival at Clifftop, West Virginia.
This year, resting on laurels, Lester gave a

special Appalachian Master performance
in the big lodge at Clifftop.
"Anytime you go into Calhoun County
and ask who plays the old-time music, the
first answer you'd get would be Lester
and Linda McCumbers," said fiddler John
Morris. "I like their music because it is
basically straight-forward and hard-driv
ing. The singing and playing go together
in a natural way that nobody can imitate.
There's nothing practiced or slickly pol
ished about Linda's singing, she just puts
it out there. And Lester doesn't use any
trills or fancy fiddle licks either. It's just

clean, pure, and intense old-time fiddling.
Their music has an edge to it, and the old

style of music and singing is imbedded in
their soul and being."
Lester and Linda McCumbers have al

ways played music and sung songs for
entertainment and relaxation at home;
a mixture of traditional
ballads, gospel,
bluegrass, old-time fiddle tunes, and
country songs. After a lifetime of making
music, they still love it all.
Kim Johnson lives in Clendenin, West Vir
ginia, where she was born and raised. She has
been longtime participant in West Virginia's
musical events, and played clawhammer banjo
for many years with fiddler Wilson Douglas.

Discography:
corded

"Old

Timey,"

a

CD re

2002
and

featuring twenty-six
Linda McCumbers'
old-time fiddle tunes and songs has
recently been released.
in

Lester

of

Thanks to Goldenseal magazine for per
to allow us to adapt this article

mission
from

a

version which appeared

in

Spring 2004 issue of their magazine.
gm
---^Additional
*'4l4

photos

and

audio clips are on the
Old-Time Herald web site:

www.oldtimeherald.org

the

�can have a Goodtime!

Anyone, Anywhere...

j|

I

Wayne
(Rice

hiking
W

Janet wr

Mount

Deering V

BacheCor

on the

Oregon.

shore

l

A

f

DEERING DVT
NEW with 2 section
All about

of\.

Curacao,
Caribbean

Ryan

Wy dfofkaday
Br of Camden,
Tennessee

Goodtime Bar
&amp;

Learn to Play the Banj
with Just 2 Fingers
DVD only $4.95
i

"

From the mountains

the Goodtime

to

the

banjo easily

prairies,

to

travels the

the oceans, white with

"fruited

flam

and

foam...

beyond!

and
Playability, tone,
quality craftsmanship
are

having

important
a

for

a

real

Goodtime. And

Goodtime doesn't have

to be

expensive!

Made in the U.S.A.
For

a

Free,

New Color Catalog contact the Deering Banjo Company at...

DEERING, The Great American Banjo Company
3733 Kenora Dr., Spring Valley, CA 91977
(800) 845-7791
(619) 464-8252
Find a dealer near you online at www.deeringbanjos.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Workshop

Replacing the Deteriorated
Pickguard on a Gibson L-3 Guitar
By Bob Smakula

flammability, there are fewer and fewer
suppliers of the original type of celluloid.
You'll have to scout around through the
luthier's catalogues to see what non-flam
mable celluloid substitutes are currently
available.
The first step I take in making a new pickguard is to trace it onto the new material
and saw out the basic shape with a bandsaw.

oldest plastic in existence is prob
celluloid. A peculiar mix of cot
ton, nitric acid and camphor, Celluloid™
was developed and patented around 1870
as a substitute for the already dwindling
supplies of ivory and tortoise shell.
Players of old-time music on antique
musical instruments often get the oppor
tunity to admire the artistry of the early
manufacturers of this amazing, multi-purpose
product. Ivoroid bindings on banjos
and guitars, imitation tortoise shell pickguards on mandolins and guitars, and
even an occasional fret board all were
made out of this miracle invention of 135

Theably

I

temDlates.
Once the trimmed blank is attached to
the proper template, I then use my router
with a pattern following bit to get the ex
act shape (Picture B). The ball bearing on
the cutter rests on the template allowing
the high-speed cutter to trim the celluloid
to the

template's shape.

Unfortunately, the chemical composition
celluloid makes it very flammable, and

after 80 years or so, it is not very stable.
Thus, the focus of this workshop: a 1923
Gibson L-3 guitar with a decomposing fake

tortoise shell celluloid pickguard. Look at
the broken area of the pickguard (Picture
A). The crystalline look to the plastic is a
sure sign of

a

decomposing celluloid pickguard
it off the instrument. Although

take

is to
it is

original part of the guitar or mando
lin, the pickguard can do major damage if
not removed. Replacing the pickguard is
the best thing to do. The hardest thing in
an

making a replacement pickguard is find
ing appropriate material. Because of its

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

use for this ap

ing thick super glue and hold the bar in
place with strong spring clamps (Picture C).

use double-sided tape to stick the

of

ish under the pickguard, and sometimes a
guitar case that has a chemical burn in the
pickguard area. This particular Gibson L3 has only been living in its gig bag for
about four years, but the deteriorating cel
luloid pickguard has already discolored
the interior fabric. I have one guitar case
that actually has such a chemical burn
that has worked itself entirely through the
case from the inside out.
The first thing to do when you notice

I

1/8" thick and 3/8"
plication
wide. I cut them to length with a hacksaw
and then glue the bar to the celluloid us
are about

pickguard blank to a template. Every time
I
get an instrument with a slightly differ
ent pickguard shape, I copy it with 1/4"
thick Plexiglas. Over the last 30 years of
restoring instruments for a living, I have
accumulated a good library of pickguard

years ago.

decomposition. When cellu
loid reaches this state, it "sweats" a weak
nitric acid. Besides the obvious broken
pickguard, you will often notice corrod
ing strings, a change in the color of the fin

The carbon fiber bars

Before
glue any of the
and attachment pieces to
I round
the edges slightly
plastic. None of the plastic
in has a shiny surface. For
1

reinforcement

the pickguard,
and polish the
I can
buy these
use a
this job
type of sandpaper called Micromesh and
wet sand starting with a 3,600 grit and go
ing through progressively finer grits to the
finest they offer at 24,000. The final polish
is

There were several ways of attaching the
old pickguards, depending on the year of
manufacture. The pickguard attachment
system on this early '20s Gibson L-3 is the
most common. The pickguard is attached
to the fretboard with a short 3/32" steel
rod that fits into a hole in the side of the
fretboard and a matching hole in the edge
of the pickguard. There is also a mounting
bracket that attaches the pickguard to the
side of the guitar (Picture D). To connect
the bracket to the new pickguard, I make
a small trapezoidal block of ebony, drill a
hole in it and cut threads in the hole that
match the stem on the pickguard bracket.
I use
thick super glue to attach the ebony
block to the pickguard.

I

done with Masters Own violin polish.
After its initial shaping, the pickguard

is a bit floppy. The original L-3 pickguard
has an extra layer of celluloid with a steel
rod inserted in a channel glued to the
bottom of the straight edge that is closest
to the strings. In this modern day, I have
found carbon fiber bars that are made for
neck reinforcement work as well if not
better than the original method. If nothing
else, it is easier to work with the carbon
fiber bar.

The last step is to screw the pickguard
bracket on the guitar, step back and ad
mire your new, safer pickguard. Well,
maybe the very last step is to dispose
of the unstable plastic. As cool as it is to
have an artifact like that around, it really
is dangerous. Go ahead, throw it out!
Bob

Smakula

is

a

musician

and resident

of

Randolph Co., WV. He is the proprietor of
Smakula Fretted Instruments, specializing in
the restoration and sales of vintage stringed

instruments.

�Classifieds
Recordings, Books, Instruction
WHEN THE CACTUS

IS IN BLOOM, the
new recording from Bob Bovee and Gail
Heil on Copper Creek features old-time
cowboy songs, Ozark tunes, and more.
To order (CD only), send $15.00 plus $2.00
shipping to Bob Bovee &amp; Gail Heil, 18287
Gap Dr., Spring Grove, MN 55974.

FLATFOOTING WORKSHOP INSTRUC
TIONAL VIDEO by Ira Bernstein. 1-3/4

hours, 27 steps, beginning to advanced.
Easy to follow. Each step clearly bro
ken down and taught. Also includes
3 performed
pieces. Step manual and
two different concert performance vid
eos also available. Inquire: 179 Flint
St., Asheville, NC 28801. 828-255-9393;
IraTenToe@aol.com.

MANDOLIN

OLD-TIME
MENTALS

Little

Stomp by the
Bros. 25 tunes, 73 minutes

Buckhannon
long.
$1.00

CDs $15.00, cassettes $10.00 plus
shipping. Make check payable to

NEW FROM TRI-AGLE-FAR RECORDS:
TR708
Ohio State
"Curly Herdman,
TR709
"Glen Smith
Champion";
Mountain State Fiddler"; TR710
"Big
Howdy Forrester and Georgia "Slim"
Rutland, Twin Fiddling Country Style.
$14.95
Ken

PPD or all three for $40. Write:

Davidson,

P.O.

Box

OH 45401.

4112,

Dayton,

FOR SALE: 78 Auction list (37c SASE) Set
sale lists: 78 $2.00*, LP $2.00*, CD $2.00,
Cassette $2.00 ^refundable with purchas
es). Lots of bargains. DISC COLLECTOR,
P.O. BOX 315, CHESWOLD, DE 19936

Musical Instruments
OLD

GIBSON

1937

L-00,

VG

more

GUITARS FOR SALE:
cond.; 1946-47 LG-2,
1952 LG-2, Exc. Cond. For
VG

cond.;
info and

photos,

contact John

at

duckshoes@gmail.com.
INSTRUMENTS

FOR SALE: GUITARS;
1956 Martin 000-18; 1961 Gibson J-50;
1967 Martin D-28; 1937 Gibson L-75 16"

archtop with round sound hole; BANJOS;
1870s fretless; New Saga SS-10 openback-a
modern inexpensive openback banjo that
looks and sounds right! Only $375; 1890
S.S. Stewart Thoroughbred with carved
heel; 1963 Gibson RB-170; MANDOLINS;
1978 Alverez F-5 copy; Breedlove Quartz
$800; BANJO UKES; Several from $150 to
$450; UPRIGHT BASSES; $500 to $2,000;
Get the details at Smakula Fretted Instru
ment's web site; www.smakula.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

&amp;

fr-RlSE WHfin tHE

Dennis Buckhannon. Write: The Buckhan

non Bros., PO Box 6165, St. Charles, MO

63302-6165.
THEPICKINPARLOR.COM.
We
are
old-time all of the time. Deering, Mor
gan Monroe, Blueridge, Kentucky, and
more; as well as an extensive selection
of instructional
books, videos, period
songbooks, and accessories. The Pickin'
Parlor, 203 West 2nd Street, Park Rapids,
MN 56470. 1-800-721-7464
WORLD'S

RECORDINGS:
Cassettes,
CDs, Videos, and Books. Featuring Ap
palachian Banjo &amp; Fiddle music, Storytell
ing, Ballads &amp; Bluegrass. Visit us on the
web. www.ivycreek.com.
CREEK

IVY

INSTRU-

River

SELECTION--

LARGEST

New-Used- Vintage guitars, banjos, man
dolins, archtops, wood &amp; metal body
Dobros,

Nationals.

Mandolin

629 Forest Ave., Staten Island,

Free Catalog. 718-981-3226.

charge evaluation

instruments.

of your

Brothers,
NY 10310.

Call

for no-

vintage fretted

WILL FIELDING

802.464.3260

www.fieldingbanjos.com

DUSTY STRINGS ACOUSTIC MUSIC
SHOP in Seattle stocks fine new and
used instruments: guitars by Martin,

Collings, Taylor, Huss &amp; Dalton, Goodall,
Dell'Arte, Eastman, and Gitane; banjos
by Deering, Huss &amp; Dalton, Ramsey,
Lee, Vega, and Goldtone; mandolins by
Collings, Weber, Eastman, and Mid-Mis
souri. Call toll-free 866-634-1662 or email

musicshop@dustystrings.com.

Equipment
REMO RENAISSANCE BANJO HEADS
and
odd size Fiberskyn banjo heads,
Most sizes from 10" to 12 1/8", $19 to $21,
16" calf skin heads, $24; Gut 5 string ban

strings $17, TKL banjo cases for 11" &amp;
12" rims $95 plus shipping. Smakula Fret
ted Instruments, PO Box 882, Elkins, WV
26241, 304-636-6710, www.smakula.com

Announcing the first CD from

jo

The

Old-Time Herald

fied ads

at

the cost

zvill

accept classi

of 50 cents per word,

Any grouping of letters
numbers is counted as one word. All ads
must be received by the first of the month, 6

minimum $8.00.

or

weeks prior

Please

to

publication.

Have you moved?

know, as the post office
will not forward your magazine. It's
quick and easy on our website
let us

www.oldtimeherald.org

Up

Waking

Tillie

Randy Johnson, Pete Peterson
and Kellie Allen
Also featuring Susan Stemgold, Mike Resnick,
Steve Senderoff and Peter Szego

Groundhog Day
Chubby Dragon 1010

21 Songs

&amp;

Tunes

To order, send $15 post-paid to
Box 503, Riegelsville, PA 18077
or

order online

at

www.wakinguptillie.com

�than an alternating thumb. Tuned a little
lower than standard, usually, she plays
guitar otherwise tuned conventionally or
in G-tuning "shape." Her banjo is always
G, but again, tuned down a little bit.
For those of us who like to read infor
mational notes, there are plenty here, in
six point type. John Ullman, Cotton's
manager, wrote an extensive biography,
and Mike Seeger, who acted as recordist,
did the song notes, which are succinct but
cogent. I recommend a magnifying glass:
if you're old enough to remember Libba
from the sixties, you probably don't see

Reviews

Shake Sugaree

Elizabeth Cotton

Smithsonian Folkways
SFW401 47 2004
Take Me Back to

Baltimore/Washington

Chase/
Going Away/Fox
Ontario Blues/Fare You Well, My Darling/
Blues/I'm

Untitled-George Buck/Mama, Nobody's
Here but the Baby/Look and Live, My
Brother /Jesus Lifted Me/Jesus is Tender
ly Calling/Buck Dance /Ruben /Oh, Miss

Lube Gal /Can't Get

a

Letter from Down

Road/Shoot That Buffalo/Boatman
Dance/Hallelujah, it is Done/Holy Ghost,
Unchain My Name/Little Brown Jug/
Delia/Ball the Jack/Till We Meet Again/
the

When the Train Comes Along
This

is

Folkways

an

enhanced CD reissue of a
vinyl album, Elizabeth Gotten,

Volume 2: Shake Sugaree. She was a sprat
of about 73 at the time, and the mid-'60s
was a heady time for her. Having done
unskilled work all her life, including for
the Seeger family, Elizabeth Cotten found
fame and modest fortune during the Folk

a
primary exemplar of turn-ofthe-century Piedmont musical style.
This CD brings to light some ten pieces
not released on the vinyl, and I am glad of
that, even if some of it is fragmentary. Be
cause of renewed efforts to document Af
rican-American banjo styles as far back as
we can, it is well to have even a few more
examples from such a fine player, who

Scare as

lived her early life just as blues was con
densing into a major vernacular form. The
music she played is readily classifiable as
"old-time" under anybody's definition.
As everybody
knows, Mrs. Cotten

played the guitar and banjo upside down,
unrestrung, lefthanded. It has always
been unclear to me whether she was one
lefthanded people
of those extremely
who couldn't do things any other way,
like Albert King or Coco Montoya, or
if she simply learned to play that way.
In any case, her personal style on the
would call "classic
instrument is what
Piedmont"-distinct, repeated melodic
I

passages played

against

an

alternating

bass. As such this is not very different
from most other Piedmont style players
of her time, or for that matter, players
like Merle Travis or Sam McGee. As Mike
Seeger points out, it is very much "parlor
ragtime," the only caveat being that her
bass line is an alternating finger, rather

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

much better than I do.
Several of the pieces here resemble ones
we all know and love, but Libba is Libba,
and I won't quibble over whether we
should call these variations on old tunes,
or originals. Suffice to say, "Washington
"St.
Louis Tickle,"
Blues" resembles
"Look and Live, My Brother" resembles
"Grandfather's Clock," and the piece she
calls "Delia" resembles "Creole Belle."
Whether Libba's playing was unusual
for her day and time is hard to say. I
suspect it was, even in the black com
munity around Chapel Hill, North Caro
lina, where she came from. Her technique
included barre chords, unusual in itself
among country players from any com
munity; and she was known to use more
than just the thumb and first finger of
her picking hand, also an anomaly in
southern guitar playing. What is more,
she is comfortable in 3/4 time and makes
liberal use of minor chords, but little use
of modes or of the variable "blue note"
otherwise so common in African derived
musics. These Euro-American features of
her playing would seem to confound a

notion of her learning entirely within the

black community of her youth; rather, to
me, they indicate exposure to a variety
of

players, styles and technical regimens

over time.

All that being said, what is the music
like? Not technically demanding, apart
from being played backwards and upside
down, its simplicity borders on the stark.
It is

late,
of
ly

clean, delicate, well recorded, articu

unassuming,

a

near perfect example

what Piedmont style

recommended

for the

is all

about. High

serious student.

ANDY COHEN

�My Gal," so the Jug Stompers break into a
chorus of that song. This is typical: when
the band strays from the straight jug band
sound, they lean toward music favored by
Robert Crumb's old band, The Cheap Suit

Serenaders, even going so

far

as to

add

clarinet to "Georgia Pines" and the "Caro
lina Shout-House Rent Rag" medley. I
enjoyed the jug/ fiddle duet that kicks off

"House Rent Rag."
The two Cannon Jug Stompers songs,
"Money Never Runs Out" and "Going
to Germany," follow the originals very
closely, and are well done. "Rooster on a
Limb," the title cut, features some impres
sive non-verbal expression in the form of
mouth music. The Carolina Jug Stomp
ers even made me respect Ray Charles'
"Busted."
All four members

contribute to an en
semble sound, but Ron Cole's bluesy fid
dle and W.B. Reid's plunky banjo-guitar
stand out in the mix. Luke Faust's jug pro

vides the bass line and Randy Johnson's
mandolin give us a subtle treble rhythm.
The Carolina Jug Stompers make music
eminently suitable for listening while you
pop open a cold one. Since this review
won't be published until winter, it's also
nice for listening while you pop open a
warm one.
LYLE LOFGREN

To order:

(phone

&amp;

Old 97 Wrecords,
fax),

336-275-7286

www.old97wrecords.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The Roots of the Narcocorrido
Various Artists

Corrido De Heraclio Bernal/ Mariano
Resendez/Nieves Hernandez/Corrido De
El

De
Mier/Los Tequileros/Contrabando
El
Paso /Con trabando De El Paso /La
Cocaina/La Marihuana /Corrido De Juan
Garica/Garcia y Zamarripa/Los Pateros/

Corrido Del Hampa, Part I/ Corrido Del
Part II /La Canela/Por Morfina
Hampa,
Part I/Por Morfina y Cocaina
y Cocaina,
-Part

II/E1

Contrabandista

Contrabandista-

Part

II/Carga

Part I/El
Blanca/El

Profugo/Corrido De Juan Meneses/ Francisco

Martinez/Tragedia De Los Cargadores/La

Arhoolie 7053, 2004
Mariachi Guadalajara;
Timoteo Cantu &amp; Jesus Maya; Los Satelites; Pena &amp;
Luis Hernan
Tijerina; Jesus Maya &amp; Timoteo Cantu;
dez &amp; Leonardo Sifuentes; Pilar Arcos; Trio GarnicaAscencio; Los Pinguinos Del Norte; Los Hermanos
Chavarria; Los Alegres de Teran; Flore s &amp; Duran;
Manuel C. Valde z&amp; Juan Gonzalez; Juan Gaytan &amp;
Las Hermanas Guer
Frank Cantu; Los Cuatesones;
Dueto

Adan

&amp;

Eva

rero with Jimmy Morgan's conjunto; Juan Gaytan &amp;
Felix Solis; Frank Cantu with Conjunto Topo Chico;
Los Cuatesones;

Cadena/El Rey De Pipa

Roja

with

Los Montenos

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

For the past few

decades

in

Mexico and

the Mexican-American communities
in the United States, a particular form
of the sturdy traditional corrido (ballad)
has become wildly popular again. These
are the narcocorridos, ballads of smug
in

glers, bootleggers, bandits, gamblers,
drug traffickers, and of the pleasures and

dangers of narcotics and the underworld.
Corridos celebrating bandits and rebels
were very popular in the late 19th and
early 20th centuries, and nowadays the
narcocorridos have become ubiquitous.
Flip on your local Mexican radio station
and you will hear one. It is a living and
fascinating tradition. The form has been
vital for centuries and can be set in a va
riety of musical styles including mariachi,
norteno, duet, and banda. Typically, the
narcocorridos tell true or should-be-true
stories of underworld heroes, rebels, in
justice, violence and death, breathing rich
musical life into a cast of captivating char
acters. Now, a new Arhoolie collection of
early recorded narcocorridos by a wide
variety of excellent classic-era performers
provides a nice selection of narcocorridos

that prefigured the current craze.
The form of the corrido typically starts
with a date and an invitation to listen to
the story and ends with a closing farewell

moral. For instance, Flores y Duran's
"Corrido del hampa (Ballad of the Un
derworld)" starts "I am going to sing

or

ballad/please listen carefully/about
loose women/addicts and criminals" and
concludes "here ends the ballad about
the vices that can't be/put an end to in
Ciudad Juarez." This collection provides
of these styles and top
a good sampling
ics. We have narcocorridos on the under
world, livestock rustlers like the famous
a

Juan Garcia,

smugglers

of

Ceylonese cin

namon (really), and of course of the joys
and sorrows of drugs in songs like ""Los
Tequileros," "La Marihuana," and "Por
Morfina

y

Cocaina."

recorded by great
Cantu, Los Alegres
de Teran, Los Pinguinos Del Norte, Pena
and Tijerina, and Los Hermanos Chavar
ria among many others, share much with
old-time music. This is ideal music for
fans of old-time bad man ballads, bandit
The

narcocorridos

groups like Maya

y

songs, murder ballads, drinking songs,
or prison songs. The spirit is much the
same, the cadence and internal morality
of the stories

is

similar, and the tragedy,

violence, and extremes are siren call. The
lyrics carry a similar power and dark
attraction.

Here is Pilar Arcos

on

"La

Cocaina (Cocaine)" recorded in 1927:
"Oh unfaithful lover, I return to you,/
crazed with exaltation. /And in my fatal
delirium /I sunk the knife, directly into
his heart.". And, perhaps most impor-

�tantly, the music is great too. The older
in particular feature excellent

recordings

musicianship in differently arrayed string
bands or conjuntos, with tight, edgy and
ideal harmony singing.
This Arhoolie collection is a typically
fine production. The extensive 39 page

by James Nicolopulos introduce
and explain the meaning and significance
of each narcocorrido, and the lyrics are
provided in both Spanish and English.
Whether you have read Elijah Wald's
great book Narcocorrido and want to ex
plore further, or you just want to hear
some great songs, this one is well worth

notes

a

listen.

DAN MARGOLIES

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�the

MoJern-Jiij hillklhj

refuses

to

Jie.„

1

KENNY HALL and the
Sweets) Mill String Band
They're back!

recordings from 1972

The original

now re-issued on

S16

CD

each includes first-class

(California residents add $1.28 per
US $19 each

postage
CD

sales tax)

outside United States

Visa/Mastercard accepted
Please include card number and expiration

Make checks payable

Bay
1741

date

to:

Records

Alcatraz Avenue, Berkeley, CA 94703
email:
No

■See

mcogan3bayrec.com
phone orders please

ij

all

frj

-fctlin

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

�Texas/Think
Pretend

What

of

You're

Done/

You've

Mine/Farewell

to

Whis

key-Butcher's Row /High on a Mountain/
Southbound/Always Late/Rutabaga Boogie/
The Earl's Chair/ Another Night/Sunny
Slopes/Sweet Dreams/Big Sandy River/
Sweet Sunny South/Don't Come to Me/
You're the Song /Road to Lisdoonvarna/
Little Beggarman
Originally recorded

in 1976 and

released

by Bay Records, this was the first record
ing of the Good Ol' Persons, a San Fran

cisco Bay area band. Its members have
moved on to other bands, professions
and pursuits. I suppose the main ques

tion here is: How does a recording of a
now non-existent band made almost 30
years ago stand up today? Is it still worth
buying and listening to? The answer is

emphatic "Yes!" The musicianship,
recording skill, and sheer spirit of this
recording have kept it relevant. By us
ing clawhammer rather than three-finger
banjo, featuring hammered dulcimer on
a
couple of numbers, including some
contemporary originals, and having an
80 percent female band, the Good OT Per
an

sons were quite innovative for the mid'70s. The band members had clearly done

their homework, listening to and learning
the best that traditional country and clas
sic bluegrass had to offer. Credited on the

album as well as "Trad," are Carter Stan
ley, Ola Belle Reed, Doc Watson, and Lefty
Frizzell, among others.
Laurie Lewis has gone on to IBMA

awards and a Grammy, and performed
with the likes of Ralph Stanley and Linda
Ronstadt, as well as with her own group,
the Grant Street Band. Back in 1976 she
was clearly already a phenomenal musi
cian. Her vocals, perfectly rooted in tradi
tional bluegrass, are rich and emotional.

Her fiddle playing

combines a polished
the traditional en
that
this
music
what it is. Her
makes
ergy
three-part tune "Sunny Slopes" is a show
case for her fine fiddling.
Kathy Kallick still lives in the Bay Area,
delivery

as

well

as

and still performs her originals with the
Kathy Kallick Band. Her vocals, to my ear,

have

a country
edge, perfectly applied
what she sings. Listen to her straightahead original, "Don't Come to Me" for
a flawless
delivery. The song also features
some stellar three-part yodeling. "Sweet
Dreams," with a newly-written verse, also
showcases her talents. Her bass playing is
simple and right on.
This album wouldn't be what it is with
out Paul Shelasky's mandolin playing.
According to the liner notes he's still

to

playing bluegrass in the Bay Area. He's
just plain awesome on the mandolin,
and like Lewis and Kallick, manages to
be totally in the tradition while adding
his own creativity to what he does. Listen
to the opening tune, "Texas", where he
plays

a

mandolin harmony

to

Lewis' lead

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

fiddle. He's also doing the second har
mony part on the fiddle. Wow. Dorothy
Baxter's guitar playing also deserves a lis

ten. Her backup runs are unobtrusive and
just right. She fingerpicks "Southbound"
beautifully, and she trades blazing flatpicked breaks with the fiddle on the Baker
tune "Big Sandy River." Though Barbara
Mendelsohn's banjo isn't featured a lot
on this album, she's a melodic clawham
mer player who somehow manages to do
great bluegrass backup and the occasional

break ("Little Beggarman").

The recording engineering also deserves
some recognition. Working with the tech
nology of 1976 the engineer, Mike Cogan,
was skilled and tasteful, and the CD still
sounds great today. The album includes
the original liner notes as well as a 2005
update. We should all be grateful that Bay
Records has made this recording available

again.
HILARY DIRLAM

Laurie Lewis, Spruce and Maple
Music, P.O. Box 9417, Berkeley CA 94709-

To order:

0417;

www.laurielewis.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

lockstep with guitarist Greg as long as
anybody in the Philadelphia area remem

in

bers. Her

unusually fluid, expressive

technically polished

presentation

is

and

per

fectly complemented by Greg's uncanny
sense of rhythmic consistency. Multi-in
strumentalist Paul holds down the banjo
and mandolin chair with the effortless,
unobtrusive virtuosity exhibited by the
best sidemen. Past rhythm sections have
been augmented with the banjo-ukulele
of Margaret Sidlick, but in this incarnation
of the band, the bottom end is anchored
by Tom Shaffer, who puts out some of the
most melodious, in-the-pocket bass play
ing this reviewer has heard. The overall

sound of the ensemble

is

unusually ho

lines are clearly dis
cernible due to these long-time musical
friends' precision and sensitive interplay.
Far from offering "traditional" chamber
music, the band generates excitement by

mogenous, but

all

a diverse program with con
idiomatic
playing born of care
vincingly
ful study of the source material.
The material comes from all over the
Arizona,
Georgia,
Kentucky,
map-Alabama, and North Carolina. Palmer's
versatility is highlighted, for she is able
to play with commanding authority on
squirrelly rags, heart-melting waltzes,
and hot dance tunes. Happily, none of
the chosen dance tempos exhibit the
frantic intensity that a less accomplished
musician may inadvertently project. Con

presenting

figurations range from outstanding solo
fiddle work on "Big Indian Hornpipe"
and a soulful fiddle-banjo duet (a mov
ing rendition of Ed Haley's "Dunbar") to
various warmly-voiced full band adapta
tions of tunes that have become standards
among dedicated collectors, but could
benefit from greater exposure to the oldtime music community. Excellent perfor
mances include two sumptuously played
waltzes. Especially noteworthy is a read

"Annadeene's Waltz,"
J. P. Fraley's
accompanied by two guitars and bowed
ing of

bass. This arrangement produces a gentle
archaic sound perfectly in keeping with
the intended loving tribute. Enjoyable

up-tempo numbers include the Stripling

Brothers' "Possum Hollow," featuring ex
citing fiddle and mandolin interplay, and
a

finger-busting medley

of

F

tunes includ

ing one of this author's favorites,

"Little

River Stomp." In addition to historical
sources, Greg and Palmer have sought

traditional
still-active
material
from
musicians, thus bringing more obscure
music to larger audiences. Unique to this
recording is a tune from North Carolina
banjoist Marvin Gaster with the unusual

title of "The Old Doctor that Fell into the
Well." This selection, arranged for the full

band, features Paul's percolating fretless
banjo against Palmer's energetic fiddling.
Though they mostly focus on instrumentals here, the band presents two songs.

This reviewer particularly enjoyed Paul's

tongue-knotting rendition

of Oscar Ford's

"Hideaway."
The warmth and clarity of the overall
sound is particularly noteworthy. Stereo
imaging and equalization are highly
accurate

and

very little

if

any

artificial

reverberation is evident. The sound of the
banjo is especially well captured and bal
anced with the ensemble. The recording
engineer's use of simple mic techniques
allowed the musicians to play in real-time
in a semicircle, a set-up that is most effec
tive with musicians who have long expe

rience playing together. The result is one
of the best sounding studio recordings of
an old-time string band that this reviewer
has heard.
The insert booklet contains artistically

of the band, in
formative program notes, instrument
tunings, and full performance credits.
The graphic design of the tray labels is
outstanding. This recording should be of
interest to all members of the old-time
music community, and I am happy to give
it my strongest recommendation.

composed photographs

STEVE SENDEROFF

To order:

www.stylographrecords.com

�While there are a couple toward the
end that could have used a little editing,
on the whole this CD represents a refresh

iar.

ingly direct approach

to

old-time music.

The core of the Ramblers are Meghan
Merker and Jim Griffith, with "Dobro
Dick" Dillof and E. Bruce Stanger at the
periphery. They may not be known to
some of this magazine's readers, because
they are from the Western contingent that
doesn't usually show up at Clifftop. Let
me introduce them: Big Jim on banjo and

"baritone bellow" used to teach Folklore at
University of Arizona in Tucson, and
was Arizona's Public Folklorist for many
years. With his wife Loma he founded
"Tucson Meet Yourself," America's most
ethnically diverse folk festival; and he
the

regularly comments

on

Borderlands cul

ture for Tucson

TV. Meghan Merker, on
"tenor bellow," fiddles and occasionally
plays guitar. She makes her living tending
web sites, designing books, scripting the
music for Sing Out! and drawing those
little pictures you see in that magazine.
She also raises horses, all 98 pounds of
her. Dobro Dick writes short stories, plays

music, pulls Jim's leg a lot, and pans for
gold in grizzly country. As for Stanger,
don't let his grasp of Shakespeare fool
he's a working cowpoke.
you
This straight ahead, home-style produc
tion samples the large repertoires and
easy competencies of people who have
played together for years, when and as
they could. They behave like the farmers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and railroaders who engendered these
songs in the first place, and though Jim's
vocals sometimes slop over the sides of
the bucket he carries tunes in, they get to
where he's going with them.
The CD opens with a rendition of "Shortnin' Bread," fiddle and banjo generating a
lot of high-carb calories. Following this
is "Leadbelly's
Fare Thee Well," which
sounds a lot like "Danville Girl," but in

4/4 time.

If

Mississippi John Hurt had

played the banjo, it would sound like this
version of "Louis Collins." "When the An
gels Rolled the Stone Away" is an old-time
version of "Every Time I Feel The Spirit,"
with descant singing that reminds me of
the Chuck Wagon Gang. Another gospel
number, "The Lord Shines His Light on
Me' is just two voices and a banjo, stark

and loud.
"Poor Boy," another version of "Danville
Girl" that turns into "Gallis Pole" toward
the end, has just a taste of the Dobro on
it, turning it wonderfully lyrical. "Blue
Goose," from the song bag of Rufus Crisp
by way of Stu Jamieson, reverts to Jim
on his banjo with Meghan on fiddle. The

next song, "Job," which is kind of

a

talk

ing gospel number in the "Poor Howard."

family, is clearly of African- American ori
gin. It appears in the Golden Gate Quartet
catalog (where Doyle Lawson has also

a number of
arrangements), and
member of the "I'm On My Way" song
set that did double duty during the '60s as
a gospel and a freedom song.

swiped
is

a

"Dobro Dick's" playing makes "Lonely
Tombs" sparkle, along with that Chuck
Wagon Gang descant singing. Jim's ver
sion of "House of the Rising Sun," done
more animalistically than the Animals
could ever manage, is a mountain ver
sion, copped from Clarence Ashley in

medicine show days. Jim sings it in
tight voice, and on the next cut roars
through "Shoot That Turkey Buzzard" fit
to bring out the entire vulture population
of Hinkley, Ohio (uh, where the buzzards
go every spring, for reasons of their own).
"Big John Henry" (or "Been All Around
This World") may be the only truly com
mon tune on the CD: Meg fiddles and Jim
banjos, with another tip of the hat to the
his
a

redoubtable Mr. Jamieson. The words,
however, don't come from any version of
the song I ever heard.

"Rambing Hobo" is flat stellar. It's deep
and rifflike structure might reflect
some black influence, despite being fil
key

tered through several mountain players
and Jim's allegedly faulty memory. "Lost
John" is the one we're familiar with, with
its heels fore and aft, though the nicely

crooked "Starry
monly known

Crown" is more com
"Chased Old Satan

as

Round The Stump."
"Going Across The Sea" is yet another
tune whose survival hinged on Stu Jamieson's 1940s forays into Franklin County.
it wasn't de rigeur to go
collecting old-time stuff from black musi

Back in aught-46,

cians like Gribble, Lusk and York, but the

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

folklorists who looked dourly down on
it would give a new five
c ent piece for a second chance. "Frankie
Stu for doing

and Albert," once again from John Hurt,

stands out

in its

fiddle/banjo instrumen

"There is Strength in The Lord'
sounds like it leapt out of the Missouri
Hymnal, while the Dobro punctuates the
Ola Belle Reed song "I Believe." Jim was
born to do "Wild Bill Jones," having that
same silicosis-like quality to his vocaliz

tation.

ing as Dock Boggs.

make of it what you
You heard it here-will. As a certain reviewer for this maga
zine has been known to say, "old-time
music isn't pretty." This isn't. On the other
hand, it's beautiful.
ANDY COHEN
To

order: Meghan Merker

gamblergraphics@smtel.com

�And the Tin Pan

Bended

would be known for the rest of
a folksinger, I would have slit
my wrists." He started wanting to play a
ukulele and sing jazz, and had the luck to
be doing it when the "Big Folk Scare" of
17 that

and the Story Ended
Dave Van Ronk

I

my life as

the 60s hit. He was

Smithsonian Folkways

SFW40156, 2004

Down

South
Been
a
Blues/You've
Good Old Wagon/Don't You Leave Me
Here/Did You Hear John Hurt?/Green,
Green Rocky Road/Jelly Jelly/Nobody
Knows You (When You're Down and

Meatball/Buckets of Rain/
Sometime (Whatcha Gonna Do)/Sportin'
Out)/One
Life

Blues/ Ace

in

the

Hole/St.

James

Infirmary /Thank You/ Urge for Going
Dave Van Ronk credited Pete Seeger
with inventing his profession, that of
the Urban Folksinger. He opposed this
to the folks who were known as pristine
folk musicians, celebrated for their near
ness to tradition, and lionized for their
authenticity. Van Ronk never had any
patience with this way of thinking In his
own words, "If you told me at the age of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

subsequently called

blues singer, and any
folksinger,
number of pejoratives, but what remains
of him is this: a legendary left wing wag
who, booted from high school, read sci fi
for fun and history for serious; comported
himself as a poster child for bad habits;
called his scratchy honk a singing voice;
and played guitar like nobody's business.
Not only did he learn to stand on his own
two feet, he helped any number of people,
myself included, to stand on theirs. If Pete
Seeger invented Ronk's profession, Ronk
invented mine.
This concert was performed for David
Eisen's Institute of Musical Traditions in
front of about a hundred people, on the
day Dave found out he had cancer in his
guts. You'd never know it. He sang and
a

a

talked, talked and sang his way through
his usual bridal bouquet ('old, new, bor

rowed, blue') of carefully personalized
arrangements of 78-based material. I
doubt he cared much which book it was
catalogued into, Rust or DG &amp;R. He was
out to draw the folks in, and draw them in
went into the hospital shortly
after that, and just as shortly, expired.
Wouldn't you know it, not long after he

he did. He

died, the municipal powers that be named
the street he lived on after him: his block
of

MacDougal

is

now called Dave van

Ronk Street. Ronk speaks to The Street, and
the music that floats down it, raucous or
sweet. There is much of both on this CD.
I've heard him do most of these cuts at
one time or another, either on record or
live. My favorites are still "Sportin' Life

Blues" (Brownie McGhee), "Down South
Blues" (Scrapper Blackwell), "Don't You
Leave Me Here" (Jelly Roll Morton) and
"Did You Hear John Hurt" (Tom Paxton).
His control is superb, his palette of tone
colors lush, his execution flawless and his
taste was, well, tasty. Of Paxton's John
Hurt song, which has been done some
what more mellifluously by Doc Watson,
he said that he had known any number of
old timers, but John Hurt was the sweet
est of them, wouldn't say a bad word
about anybody, even if they deserved it.
For all his excesses, Ronk aspired to that
kind of patience, and a high level of craft,
even while he was a searing critic of the
social system that produced the likes of
Scrapper Blackwell and John Hurt.

So no, this is not exactly nostalgic fiddle
music, and it's not downhome blues ei
ther. It's Dave Van Ronk at his distilled
best, coming to you at a hundred proof.
Good enough for me.

ANDY COHEN

�Alabama Fiddler

however, that a few years after his grand
father's passing in 1961 he quit playing
altogether for "there wasn't anyone
around who knew the old tunes." (Sound
familiar?) Then, in the '70s, his visits to
Horsepens 40 and other festivals got him
going again. His children have followed
in the family's musical footsteps, and his
cousin Jackie Burgess is an accomplished

Jerry Rogers

fiddler as well.
no label

Alabama Skip Step/Boatin' Up Sandy/
to
the
Everybody
Punching /Booth
Lincoln /Lost
Indian /Turkey
in
Shot
the Straw/Jack
Wilson/Piney Woods/

Clark/Fisher's
Hornpipe/ Abe's Retreat from Bull Run/
Girl
Left Behind Me/Williams Fork/
Deep Gap/Flop-Eared Mule
Bad

Days

Comin'/Joe

I

On

this

Alabama

Students of style are bound to recognize
unmistakable West Virginia/East Ken
tucky flavor informing the playing of this
deep southerner. It is not so surprising that
some of Jerry's favorite repertoire is from
West Virginia
it turns out that grandpa
Benny was a coal-miner from that region.
an

CD,

sixty-years-young

central

old-style fiddler Jerry Rogers
gives us a no-frills picture of a musical
life influenced in equal parts by family
tradition and keeping his ears open to the
best of the old-time revival. Jerry was for

tunate to have an apprenticeship with his
grandfather Benny, a "next-door neighbor
and a great musician," and the youngster
was a regular on guitar and second fiddle
at family pickin' sessions and occasional
dance gigs. Jerry told me in an interview,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

love that lonesome stuff the best," he
says simply. The majority of pieces on Al

banjo-playing
partner Monroe Thommasson, another early influence. One
of the handful of original pieces here is
"Bad Days A-Comin'," which Rogers
composed based on the singing of a black
coal-mining ex-con and friend. It is as

lonesome

as any West-by-God Virginia
fiddling you've heard.
As noted, this is a bare-bones recording
and package, and the combo of close mi
crophone placement in a studio with no
added reverb might strike some as a bit

chilly-sounding. Me,

Fiddler are

cross-tuned

at

unaccompanied fiddle,

various

touch

pitches

a

nice

and Rogers brings out their stark
beauty. He also puts his own stamp on the
old chestnuts such as "Joe Clark," Ernie
Left Behind," and
Carpenter's "Gal
I

renders

a

plumper-than-usual low-tuned

"Turkey In the Straw." There are indeed
a
few pieces from Jerry's grandfather,

including "Everybody to the Punching,"
a cousin to "Briarpicker Brown" for sure,
and a nice adaptation of a "Greenfields of
America" variant called "Williams Fork."
The Kentucky tune "Jack Wilson" appears

courtesy of grandpa Benny's finger-style

sort of like the

oc

ing to.
PETE SUTHERLAND

"I

abama

I

casional grunts and heavy breathing that
come through
sounds like a guy who's
his
telling you
story, and it's worth listen

To

order:

The

Old-Time

Music

Store

www.oldtimemusic.com/storeindex.php

�Austin, Texas

in the

1990s.

David Algeo

Smith, also from the Chicago area, has
been fiddling on the streets of New York,
Zurich, Bangkok and numerous places in
between for 20 years or so. His first CD
was Thais to Irish, a solo album combin

ing traditional Thai, Irish and American
violin melodies.
The three distinct musical backgrounds
combine to give TBSB what one fan has
called a sound that is "teethgrindingly,
quintessentially American." I don't know
about "teethgrinding," but I will support
the "quintessential American" part. Selec
tions include old-time fiddle standards
played everywhere in the U.S. like "Red

Haired Boy," "Leather Breeches, "Sally
Ann," "Blackberry Blossom," "Liberty,"
"Arkansas Traveler," and "Wagoner."
As these tunes are played widely, they
are also interpreted in a variety of ways.

ThisBigStringBand's
inspiration is the
style favored at southern festivals. They
do so with some authority, considering
Smith was the fifth place winner in the
2002 Appalachian String Band Festival
(Clifftop) fiddle contest, and his admitted
fiddle heroes include Tommy Jarrell, Mel-

vin Wine, and John Hartford.
While the tunes on the CD are pretty
standard, the performances are excep
tional. Purists may bridle at the thought

Suzuki violin training, but
good old-time music owe it
to themselves to pay some attention to
TBSB's music. About the "teethgrind
ing" description: don't expect any sweet
sounding easy listening elevator violin
music. This music has drive and one had
better buckle one's seatbelt. On the whole
the music sparkles technically yet at the
same time is danceable and full of tasteful
variation. Marks and Noel seem to bring
out the old-time spirit in Smith's playing,
which sounds entirely different than the
music he plays on his first album.
Several tunes stand out as particularly
"Leather
Breeches"
interesting.
skips
along like a sewing machine needle
and includes
variations that make a
nice distinction between the coarse and
fine strains. "Blackberry Blossom" fea
tures clean, clear fiddling, in contrast to
many other selections with more double
of

Smith's

lovers

of

stops.

One

minor

quibble:

"Jimmy

in

the Swamp" may not have been the best
tune to follow on the heels of "Blackberry

Blossom," because its slower pace, less
interesting melody, and fewer variations
render it lackluster in comparison. On
par with "Blackberry Blossom" though

"Paddy on the Turnpike," and "Wag
oner." The banjo on "Over the Waterfall"
and "Frosty Morning" offers the ear a
refreshing change of musical pace from
the fiddle lead.
While banjo and fiddle solos on this al
bum are excellent, the band's strength is
how the instruments work together. Noel
are

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and Smith are so well synchronized it is
hard to tell who is playing what. What I
had originally thought was a second fid
dle was really Noel's banjo picking. This
works becaue Marks' guitar provides the
matrix necessary for the banjo and fiddle

melodic subtleties to flourish.
It's a quality production: Steve Wagner
at Riverside Studio has succeeded in pre
senting TBSB's natural acoustic sound,
and one can hear the delicate interaction
between the musicians in the final mix,
and Kris Kim designed an attractive cover
depicting the band with jute string. Per

haps the major weakness of this album is
its lack of liner notes. While tune histories
for they can be
may not be necessary
found
elsewhere band
information
would be welcome. The band now has an

informative website.
Overall, this recording should be of in
terest to beginners who wish to become
familiar with the old-time fiddle rep
ertoire, people who want to hear some
musical variations, and finally, those who
just want to hear some interesting and
energetic old-time music.
SHARON GRAF
To

order:

60506;

329

Spruce

Street,

Aurora,

www.thisbigstringband.com

IL

�Dorian mode, in contrast to Jean Ritchie's
bouncy major key version. Another fine
solo, by Bill,
ton," and

I

is "Low Road to Charles
thank them for pointing me

earlier Pennsylvania version of this
song, which I'd previously only known as
"Spring of '65" from the Folkways Moun
tain Music of Kentucky album.
Adding other voices necessarily adds
some restrictions: rhythm needs to be
more predictable (although not necessar
ily regular), and rules of harmony limit
the available modes. TMPSKGQ compen
to an

sate by applying a number of different
harmonic styles. They use Gospel Quartet

style fairly often, as well as something like
British Pub style. Some harmonies remind
me of the Copper Family of England-maybe it's Bill Kimmons' fine bass voice.
In fact, two of the songs, "Red-Haired
Mary" and "Mercian Tittery-Ary-A" (or

"Eggs and Marrowbones") are directly
Irish, presumably due to Will Farming's
influence-he's originally from Ireland.
TMPSKGQ do not use bluegrass or Sa
cred Harp harmonies, and when they

explore non-traditional material (such as
Lotus Dickey's "Blue on Monday"), both
rhythm and harmony are reminiscent of
uptown groups like Lambert, Hendricks
&amp; Ross. They also include Dickey's "Pair
in a Paradise" (this song's refrain became

the album title), "Carry My Burden,"
and "David Loved Bathsheba." I'm only
familiar with Dickey from his traditional

fiddle tunes, so I don't know how closely
their renditions follow his intentions.
Though a strict traditionalist might ob
ject when the trio deviates from American
old-time singing traditions, an openminded listener will find a lot to like
here.
LYLE LOFGREN

To

order:

Soup

Kitchen,

550 Anderson

Heights Road, Charleston
rhk.katcandu@verzon.net

WV

25314;

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�used a little more sparingly. I found the
original "The Longest Night" to be overly
long (almost 6 minutes). I would have

liked to hear "Stranger Stop and Cast an

without the added distraction of the
vocals having been recorded in a stairwell.
The lyrics are taken from grave epitaphs,
which is a great idea, and the background
instruments (including accordion drone)
work well. But the stairwell adds a tinny
ambiance.
Eye"

The dobro is used to great advantage
on this recording. I especially enjoyed
the "languid" (the Sisters' description)

arrangement

of

Fiddlin'Arthur

Smith's

"Paris Waltz" with the dobro and fiddle
trading licks. The dobro and fiddle co

a
sizzling version of "Greasy
Coat."
A few of the selections might have ben
efited from a less crowded (to my ear) ar

operate for

rangement. As good as the musicians are,
everything playing all the time is a little
distracting to my ear. For some reason, the
fiddle is mixed a little low. The dobro and
banjo both have more presence. I listened
to the CD on a couple of different sound
systems in case the problem was my
speakers, but the mix remained the same.
A few more words on the original song

Him". The lyrics were in
friend, a Nicaraguan survi
vor of the war there, whose son is now
"Could

it

spired by

Be
a

fighting in Iraq. This is a powerful song,
and includes a verse in Spanish. It's my
favorite song on the CD, and I encourage
the Stairwell Sisters to keep writing and
recording songs with the same relevance
and emotional impact; a great direction
for the envelope to be pushed.
HILARY DIRLAM
To

order: PO Box 3408, Oakland CA 94609,

www.stairwellsisters.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The Dusky Meadow
Donald MacLellan and Doug MacPhee

Rounder 821

61

-7044-2

Donald MacLellan: violin; Dour MacPhee: piano

Carswell-The Drunken Piper/
Marchioness of Tullybardine/Niel
Gow's Lamentation for James Morey/
The
Duchess of Hamilton-The
Hon.
Captain

The

Mrs. Maule

of Panmure/Lady Georgina
Campbell-Captain Byng-Loch Earn/ A. F.
Irving-Captain Campbell-Craig o' Barns/
Sandy is my Darling-Mr. John Stewart of

Grantully-MacKinnon's Rant/The Road
to

Skye-Off

to

Donnybrook- Whiskey JigGarden/Sir Alexander
Don-The Ewie with the Crooked Horn/
Johnnie's Made a Waddin' O't'Country
Hall-Miss
Charters /Compliments
to
Armabelle-Dusky Meadow /Sandy Cam
eron-The Marquis of Tullybardine-Sandy
Duff/The Honey Maid-Pretty Bess-Key
West/ Killiecrankie-Gaelic
Air/ Welcome
The Flower in the

to

your

Feet

Agam-Fight

about

the

Fireside/The White Crow-Blind Norry's;
of
Mari
Marquis
Queensberry/Miss

Oliphant-The Duke of Gordon's
Birthday-Don Side/Cross of InvernessMuschats Cairn/Dr. Shaw-The Strong
Man o' Drum-Jamie Russell/The Breem
Dog-Sandy Skinner-The Spinnin' Wheel/
anne

O

Dear!

What

can

the

Matter

Be-Irish

Jig/The Shakins o'the Pocky-Miss Christy

Nicholson/Miss Whitefoord-The Isle of
Skye-Put me in the Big Chest/Morag's
Wedding-Craig o' Barns /Pigeon on the
Gate-Finlay's Favorite-Muileann Dubh/

Johnny

Pringle-Money Musk/I'll Gang
MacDonald's

nae mair to yon Town-Lord

Reel-The

Perrie Werrie-The

Bear in

Buckwheat-A Dhomhnuill

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the

�form, and another fine grouping of reels
beginning with an elaborate version of
"Lord MacDonald's." The more I listened
the more I found myself responding to

Cape Breton Tradition

Hugh Allan "Buddy" MacMaster was
born October 18, 1924 in Timmins, On
tario, where his father was employed as
a miner. When he was
young, his family
moved back to Cape Breton and he grew
up in the small community of Judique.

Donald MacLellan's musical world.
Accompaniment is by pianist Doug
MacPhee. I first heard MacPhee in the
1970s accompanying John Campbell and
Carl MacKenzie on their Rounder LP's,
and on several of his own LP's of solo
piano. He had spent much of his time be
tween 1955 and 1968 in Toronto, frequent
ly playing music with Donald MacLellan.

The rapport that this generated is appar
ent on most of this CD although once
or twice it sounds as if MacLellan has

launched

into something MacPhee was
an occupational hazard in

not expecting
a

tradition where the fiddlers themselves

often have no idea of what they will be
playing after they start the first tune.
I
like MacPhee's
uncluttered chord
sense. He uses minors where required by
the melody, and, when in minor keys, the
relative major chord (i.e. a C major chord
in A minor tunes) where appropriate. He
also makes judicious use of minors to
vary the accompaniment, as in the third
and fourth measures in each part of "Key

West", while still supporting the melody
and the basic harmonic structure of the

tune. His sense of economy works quite
well on the strathspeys where he provides
a solid foundation, while MacLellan's vio
lin dances through the dotted rhythms,
triplets and other ornamentation.
I also like
the way MacPhee often jumps
into the melody with his right hand,
usually in unison with the violin but oc
casionally an octave lower. I am aware
that this style is not universally admired,
but where the players are really together it
certainly gives the music added boost.
The notes, in keeping with Mark Wil
son's desire to let the players speak for
themselves, consist of a fairly long auto
biographical statement from MacLellan,
which I found fascinating, and a shorter
statement from MacPhee (who will no
doubt have an opportunity to expand it
for his own projected disc in this series).
Wilson adds closing comments, offering

perspective on the accomplishments of
the musicians and discussion of the im
pact of published Scots tune collections
centuries. Al
though known composers are identified,
I miss
Rounder's usual detailed notes on
the tunes and their sources. The cover art
from

the

18th

and

19th

strikes me as a little drab but there is a
very nice color photograph of MacLellan
on the rear of the notes booklet. There are
black and white snapshots reproduced

throughout.

The sound is good quality field recording.
The balance between the violin and piano is
good, with tire violin slightly up front. To me
it sounded best with a
slight treble boost. The
review disc had no noticeable problems.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

At age

found his father's violin

he

11

in

trunk and began to teach himself to
play, learning from local players and early
recordings of Cape Breton music, which
were just beginning to appear. With the
advent of improved roads and automo
biles, he began to meet and learn from a
larger body of accomplished players from
a

outside of his immediate area. It probably
helped that his parents acquired a piano
at a time when they were not common,
and a succession of his sisters learned to
play well enough to accompany visiting
fiddlers. In the late 1940s he learned to
read music and began to build his reputa
tion as an outstanding dance musician.
Like Donald MacLellan, MacMaster has
included tunes from the late 18th and
early 19th century. Both
based on strathspey/reel

play

medleys

combinations,

and longer

medleys starting with a march
There is a fine A minor set, the
"Highlander's Farewell" and an A major
set, the "Miller of Drone" which ends with
two A minor reels. He also plays two sets
or an air.

beginning with clogs ("The Real Thing,"
while listed as a hornpipe is functionally
equivalent to a clog) and a waltz /jigs set.
His choice of tunes includes compositions
from contemporary Cape Breton, Ameri
can, English and Scots composers.

His sound is distinct and quite recogniz
able. As he explains:
"I
guess I do sound a little different
from the other players here.
I
suppose

formed my own style from listening to
different players and trying to pick what I
liked, trying to do what the better players
I

were doing...

tried to play kind of lively
and sweet, to put some expression in the
1

music."

Lively the music most certainly is. Sweet
does not mean saccharine but rather that
his tone has warmth and fullness as well
as bite. Like all the great players in his tra
dition he is a master of rhythm, phrasing
and ornamentation. His strathpeys leave
no doubt that this was originally a dance
form. The reels float along in overdrive.
This is highly approachable music.
All of the

excellent

strathspey/ reel medleys have

tunes

but

the

playing

on

the

"Highlander's Farewell" and the "Miller

of Drone" sets is

notes

suggest

particularly choice. The

that

"Miller

of

Drone"

may be the source for the well-known
southwestern tune "Grey Eagle," and that
many Cape Breton musicians believe that
"Christie Campbell," which opens a high
bass tuning set, is a local variant of the
same melody.

The "Hughie and Janet's March", an E
minor set, brackets two classic 19th cen
tury tunes; "The Warlock" (a strathspey
misidentified as a reel) and "Tarbolton
Lodge," a Scots reel also quite popular
with Irish musicians, with two excellent

modern compositions.

MacMaster

is

in

top form from start to finish, especially on
the two reels. The same is true of the three
reels from the "Little John's Hame" set,
with the strangely named "Scourdiness,"
a standout
composition as well.

Although MacMaster

as

a

is

highly regarded

player of jigs, those on this CD are

something

of

a

mixed bag. The superior

tunes like "Rosewood" and "Judique"
come off quite well. I also liked the two
David Greenberg tunes; "Buddy's De
tour" and "Francis Xavier Kennedy," but
the other two tunes in that set seem a bit

listless. The "Nicole Fakoory"
nice lift and also offers

a

set has

a

greater variety of

tonality than normally encountered in the
"all tunes on the same tonic" tradition.
"Happy-Go-Lucky Clog," a challenging
piece, is a Cape Breton favorite. The re
maining two tunes in the set, "Saratoga,"
and "Irish American," are infrequently
played gems from One Thousand Fiddle
Tunes. "The Bell Piano," my favorite Cape
Breton strathspey, was a request from
series editor Mark Wilson. MacMaster
complied and kept going for the six excel
lent reels that follow. TTie CD concludes
strongly with "The Grey Seal's Lament,"
a modern
Scottish air, followed by two
18th century strathspeys, whose similar
ity challenges the listener's ear, and two
traditional reels.
Buddy MacMaster has been severely un
der-recorded. Despite his prominence as
a dance musician, he seems to have been
passed over by the local and regional la

bels such as Celtic and Rodeo in the 1950s
and 1960s and by Rounder during Mark
Wilson's foray into Cape Breton in the
1970s. To the best of my knowledge, his
output to date consists of two LPs, which

may still be available on cassette or CD, a
CD, The Judique Flyer, from the late 1990s
and this project. I hope there will be more
in the future.
Piano accompaniment is by Buddy's daugh
Mary Elizabeth MacMaster Maclnnis. She

ter,

plays in a contemporary style, which I
associate with players like the late John
Morris Rankin (who accompanied MacMaster on his two LPs). Her rhythmic
drive on the dance tunes is excellent. She
plays well on the airs a difficult task
because the slow tunes generally tend to

be

rather free flowing and often lack

a

predictable rhythmic pulse.
have difficulty with some of her chord
choices. She makes frequent use of chord
substitutions, such as replacing a major
chord with its relative minor chord. This
is a common technique, which most ac
1

companists do instinctively from time

to

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

time. When

occurs at the beginning of a
of Drone," however,
"Miller
phrase,
it can confuse the tonality of the piece. A
more exotic example of substitution oc
curs when a tonic minor chord, like the
E minor in "Tarbolton Lodge," is
replaced
with what sounds like a VI chord (C ma
it

as in

jor)

during the 5th measure of the second

part. Sometimes
a

tenuous

her bass runs have only
to the expected

relationship

harmony.
I think
this reflects an attempt to mod
ernize the music by adding complex
ity to the underlying harmonic structure.
None of these techniques are intrinsically
wrong, but too often it seems that the ac
companiment is fighting with the lead
rather than supporting it. At some point a
multiplicity of chords starts to clutter the

sound of what is, after all, pretty straight
forward music.
The recorded sound is quite good, with
nice presence and balance between the
instruments. As I listened to it, it sounded
fine at flat settings or with a little treble
boost. There were no errors in the review
CD.
The packaging

is nice, with good color
photos of MacMaster on the front and a
scenic view on the rear of the insert (for
which I could not find an identification)
and black and white photos scattered
throughout the booklet. The notes consist
of an autobiographical narrative by MacMaster detailing his upbringing and mu
sical life, which like most such narratives,
offer a glimpse into times and circum
stances which almost unimaginable to
us today. There is additional commentary
by producer Burt Feintuch and detailed
notes on the tunes and their sources by

Cape Breton tune expert

Paul Cranford

and Feintuch.

TIM WOODBRIDGE

�Bluegrass at the Roots-- 1961
The Lilly Brothers &amp; Don Stover

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
SFW CD 40158

Bea Lilly: vocals, guitar
lin; Don Stover: banjo,

Everett Lilly, vocals, mando
Herb Hooven: fiddle,

vocals;

string bass; Mike Seeger: string bass
In

My

Soldier

Dear

Old
Southern Home/
the Stormy Sea/Forgotten
Boy /Down on the Banks of the

Midnight

on

Ohio/Where

Is

My Sailor Boy?/Sinner/

You Better Get Ready/What Would You
Give in Exchange?/Oh, Hide You in the

Blood /Little Annie /'Neath That Cold
Grey Tomb of Stone/Barbara Ellen/The
Fox and the Hounds/John Hardy/Old
Joe

Clark/Salt

River/Cornbread

and

'Lasses and Sassafras Tea/The Waves on
the Sea

/Saints

Go

Marching

In

The Lilly Brothers and Don Stover stand
among the early pioneering acts in
bluegrass music, and stylistically, rep
resent one of the clearest links between
bluegrass and old-time music. For a
tall

variety of reasons, however, they aren't

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

nearly as widely recognized as other performers
of their generation. Early on, they
made quite a sensation as part of banjo

picker Red Belcher's Kentucky Ridge
Runners. After Belcher's death, Everett
spent some time playing mandolin with
Lester Flatt and Earl Scruggs. When the
brothers regrouped in 1952, they settled
in Boston where they teamed up with two

immensely talented sidemen

Tex Logan

on fiddle, and Don Stover on banjo. They
played a club there called the Hillbilly
Ranch for the next two decades until 1970,
when they all but retired from profes

sional musical activity.
One reason for their relative obscurity is
that they were pretty much a regional act,
sticking close to their base of operation

Northeast. In addition, they made
few
very
recordings over the years three
singles in the late 1940s as part of Red
Belcher's group; two more in 1956-57 on
Event, a small label out of Maine; these
recordings for Folkways in 1961; and two
LPs for Prestige in 1962 and 1964. These
later recordings were marketed towards
the folk music market and that, too, may
have played a role in reinforcing the Lil
ly's lack of wide spread success, at least
in the

among blue-collar bluegrass and country
music fans.
Despite the fact that this Folkways LP
never found its way into the mass market
place during the 1960s folk revival, the
music it contains ranks among the finest
bluegrass and brother duet singing ever

make that distinction here be
cause that same distinction is made on the

recorded.

I

CD. The first eight tracks are performed in
the
the style of the brother duet tradition
Blue Sky Boys and especially the Monroe

Brothers

from which they drew much of

their approach and repertoire. The

broth

delivery is every bit as intense and
satisfying as the originals themselves. The
tracks featuring Don Stover on banjo and
vocals (and sometimes Herb Hooven on
the fiddle) are solid bluegrass and make
ers'

up and take notice. The Lil
lys, unlike most of their contemporaries,
chose their songs, for the most part, from

one stand

pre-World War II sources. The material
may be atypical, but it works very well in
this context. Think the Blue Sky Boys with
bluegrass backing. Although this album
may have missed its mark when first is
sued nearly 45 years ago, we are extreme

fortunate that Smithsonian-Folkways
it available
hopefully widely
available
once again. If you're going to
buy one bluegrass album this week, this is
ly

has made

the one to get.

JIM

NELSON

�may not be as well known, but they fit
squarely into that tradition. Born in 1930,

they began playing together while young
children. By the time they were teenag
ers, they could be heard on the radio in
Little Rock, Arkansas. Soon after World
War II their family moved to southern
California. There Floyd and Lloyd carried
on with their musical activities, playing
live shows and their own radio show in
Pasadena. Through a family friend they
met T. Texas Tyler, who helped them se
cure a record deal with 4-Star Records, a
label based in California that specialized
in country music. It was around this time
that Chris Strachwitz, who later would
found Arhoolie Records, first heard the
Twins on the radio. In 1979 Strachwitz as

sembled an

LP

consisting of material from

Floyd and Lloyd's 78s on the 4-Star label.
This eventually led to his meeting them in

person and an

LP of

newly recorded ma

terial. This CD is made up of songs and
tunes from both of those LPs.
As a long time fan of these boys, I was
happy to see this material reissued. There
just is no such thing as too much good
duet singing.
The Armstrong
Twins
were steeped in the "brother duet" close
tradition and accompanied
harmony
themselves on guitar and mandolin, but
they definitely had their own sound, one
that reflected the past, but was current at

the same time. It was a sound with which
people could readily identify. Not sur
prisingly, they were quite popular among
folks like themselves, southern working
people who had migrated to California
in hopes of finding a better life. Draw
ing from numerous sources, they sang
old standbys like "Sparkling Blue Eyes,"
a
song popularized by Wade Mainer
and Zeke Morris in the mid-1930s; they
included songs that were to become old
standbys such as "Mother's Only Sleep
ing," a hit for both Bill Monroe and his
brother Charlie; and they played material
such as "It's Never Too Late," a Stanley
Brothers song that was then brand new.
The brothers also were hearing what
was going on around them, and were
not afraid to incorporate some of those
newer sounds into their music. Some of
that newer, honky-tonk country sound (as
popularized by another California group,
the Maddox Brothers and Rose) was incor

porated into songs like "Mandolin Boogie,"
"Three Miles South of Cash," and "Beetle With
Boogie Woogie Beat."
The material taken from the 1979 reunion
session shows the twins to be in great
form, with their chops intact. Ironically,
tire

these songs actually sound a bit more on
the "old-time" side of things even though

the brothers had augmented their sound
with a resophonic guitar and string bass.
A hearty thanks to Arhoolie Records for
making the music of this fine duet avail
able once again.

JIM

NELSON

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Orpheus Supertones

For the

finest recordings of Old
recorded live in natural

Time Music,

STEREO, CATCH THE 'TONES, CLARE AND

Walt, and the Highwoods Live on
MM-0020

Orpheus Supertones
Bound to Have a Little Fun

MM-0030

Clare Milliner

MM-0050

Just Tunes
The Original

MM-0055.... Highwoods

&amp; Walt

Koken

Fat City String

Stringband

All CD's

$15.00
Mud

DDd.

thumper

IJos 791

Kennett Square
Music

PA 19348

http://wwvv.niiidthumpcr.com

For
6

1

bookings:
0-268-02 7
1

wkoken@comcast.net

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Coat/John

of

Badenyon/ MacKinnon's

Other Rant/Hamish

the Carpenter /Back

Change House/The Beaton Fam
Graham's/Port
Recording/Todd
St.
Lucie/Totar's Hornpipe/The Stone
Frigate/The Laird O'Thrums/Hoch Hey
Johnny Lad/Sir Reginald MacDonald/
Traditional Laddie/Lady Dorothy Stew
art Murray/The Glasgow Gaelic Club/
Bert/Duke of Gordon/West Mabou/Joys
of Mabou Mines/Anna Mae's
of the
ily

of traditional
strathspeys and reels is hard to beat for
sheer musical content.
If the spirit of Donald
Angus Beaton
hovers benignly over this collection,
the presence of his son Kinnon is very
much in evidence throughout. He plays
four sets with his wife Betty on piano,
including one with their daughter Allison
step dancing, and an additional set on
which their daughter Andrea joins them

accompanied by Elizabeth Beaton. His
duet with Glen Graham is a high energy
set of reels that just stomps, reflecting the
ease of two fine fiddlers who have played
together many times. There is a nice touch
on the wonderfully named "The Night
the Goats Came Home," where the sec
ond time through they play in octaves.
The two remaining cuts, with four
fiddles and two pianos, may require a
suspension of judgment until you actu

sound" tracks with all four fiddlers and
two pianos. Eight of the 16 tracks include

Maclntyre's March set begins and ends
with two Donald Angus Beaton tunes,
bracketing two strathspeys and two reels.
The group, entirely under control, just
keeps picking up energy. By the time they

everywhere. Finally, his set

on fiddle.

summer of 2000, Smithsonian/
Folkways recorded several notable Cape
Breton fiddlers and accompanists in live
performances at dance and concert ven
ues, including four cuts by Kinnon and
In

the

Betty

Beaton (SFW CD 40491, The Heart

Of Cape Breton: Fiddle Music Recorded Live

Along the Ceilidh Trail; reviewed by Lyle
Lofgren in the Fall 2002 issue of OTH).
This excellent follow up offers a focused
look at music of the extended family of

Donald Angus (1912-1982) and Elizabeth
Beaton, which, in the words of producer
Bert Feintuch, "documents
a
powerful
tradition of music...
rooted in place and
in a continuing family tradition".
The Beatons, and Elizabeth Beaton's
family, the MacEachens, settled in the
Mabou region of Inverness County, Cape
Breton, in the early 19th century. Mabou
remained a Gaelic society well into the
20th century, and with Inverness County
generally, is still a stronghold of some of
the most traditional Scots and Scots de
rived fiddle music to be heard anywhere.
During his lifetime, Donald Angus
Beaton was highly regarded as a dance
fiddler and as composer of some 50 or
more tunes, 9 of which appear on this
collection. Regrettably, he left very little
in the way of recorded legacy other than
The Beatons of Mabou, Rounder 7011, a

wonderful LP that offered strong support
for the proposition that there was indeed
distinct

Mabou or "old-time" Cape
Breton style with 18th century roots. After
his death a tribute LP (and cassette) was
produced from a number of mostly rough
taped sources.
A number of the tracks appearing here
are the clearest example of his solo play
ing I have heard. The listener is imme
diately confronted with a style where
the phrasing is more angular than most
which
while
contemporary
playing,
retaining a strong rhythmic pulse, lacks
the sharp elbows. The sound itself is
noticeably different with a hint of sour
ness in the intonation and ringing notes,
particularly on the strathspeys. It is prob
ably no coincidence that Donald Angus
numbered pipers among his immediate
ancestors. His ornamentation
is
also
subtly different, somehow fitting into the
flow of the melody, almost as part of it.
And, of course, there is his strong bowing,
a trait he shared with
great dance fiddlers
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

He also leads the two "wall of

one of his tunes.
Having had the pleasure of attending
a dance
some years ago where Kinnon
could do no wrong, I once felt that he

fiddler who played better than he
recorded. His playing here pretty much
puts that notion to rest. His playing
throughout is lively, with a pinch of raw
sugar in his tone, somewhat reminiscent
of Buddy MacMaster. His two jig med
leys are textbook examples of the kind of
was

a

swing that can never be accurately set out
musical notation. The Brig O'Balatar
set is a classic medley of C tunes, with the
distinctive sound that key seems to give
to tunes that take advantage of the way
the notes fall on the fiddle neck. The Joan
Boes set is another fine collection of tunes,
marked by exemplary interplay between
the fiddle and piano, finishing with two
excellent reels, the last by Kinnon.
The grandchildren
acquit themselves
well. Andrea Beaton has not yet attained
the subtlety of her father 's playing but she
has excellent technique, her sound is clean
and her rhythmic pulse is what it takes to
drive the dancers. Both of her solo sets
contain good tunes. Her set with her par
ents suggests where her playing might be
going in a few years.
Her older cousins, Glen Graham and
each contribute
Rodney MacDonald,
in

two solo sets and one together. Both are
skilled players with their own recordings.
Glen has, perhaps, a bit of Donald Angus'
sound. His Mary Ann MacDougall's set
is a wonderful collection of tunes, start
ing with an A major march, followed by
a
strathspey and three reels in A minor
and concluding with an A major reel. His
playing has wonderful bite, especially on
the low strings on the A minor tunes. The
final reel, from Donald Angus Beaton, has
an extra measure in the first part and, re
lieving the tension of the A minor tunes, is

forty seconds of pure joy. His second set,
while not as spectacular, is a very solid
mixture of classic and original tunes.

Rodney MacDonald's day jobs include
Nova Scotia legislature where he
also serves as Minister for Tourism and
Culture. He contributes two fine sets, the
first in E minor and E major accompanied
by Betty Beaton, and the second, a collec
tion of jigs on which he also step dances,
the

ally hear them.

It's

worth

it.

The Sandy

hit the reels, they're

freewheeling on the
downgrade, remembering the brakes just

they come to the end. The Stumpie set,
with two Scots strathspeys followed by
three Mabou reels, works up the same
head of steam before arriving at the sta
tion. This is great stuff.
The three pianists are each, in her own
style, right there with the fiddlers. Betty
Beaton does the lion's share of the work,
including a nice solo piano set, opening
with the old Scots air "Coilsfield House,"
followed by one of Kinnon's tunes and
concluding with "Fraser's Jig" from the
late Dan Hughie MacEachern. Her play
as

ing throughout demonstrates an unerring
chord sense and the ability to adjust her
accompaniment as the rhythmic patterns
and tunes vary.

Elizabeth Beaton represents an older
style that emphasizes cello like patterns in
the left hand and a very percussive sound.
She also plays some right hand melody, as
on Rodney MacDonald's

jig medley. Her
daughter Mary Graham's style is some
where between the two with a good chord
sense and a right hand tending toward the
syncopated chord style presently fashion

able in Cape Breton.
The notes and tune notes are excellent.
Bert Feintuch's essay, amplified
with
quotes from the participants, is as good
a short
introduction to this music and
culture as I have seen. The tune notes in
dicate known composers and some infor
mation about the provenance of the tunes.
I'm not crazy about the cover design, but
there is a nice picture of the players on the
back of the notes booklet, and black and
white pictures scattered throughout. The

recording was done in Cape Breton by
people obviously familiar with the music.
The engineers captured a bright and natu
ral sound, something like hearing the mu
sic in a living room with hardwood floors
and high ceilings. The balance between
the fiddle(s) and piano(s) is generally
good. The volume levels are reasonably
consistent from track to track.
This is an excellent portrait of a family's
music. Recommended.
TIM WOODBRIDGE

�The Protocols
Hank Sapoznik

YOZ 002 CD

&amp;

The Youngers of Zion

Henry "Hank" Sapoznik: tenor guitar, vocals; Mar
lene "Cookie" Segelstein: violin; Mark "Doctor"
Rubin: bass, tuba

Kolomeykes/Khusidls/Dem

Milner's

Trern/Sheree/Theme from Swee Toch Nee
Tea Time Radio Hour/Donia Medley/Ikh
Border Bay Mayn Vayb/Dobridens/
Freylekhs; Hora; Serbas; Kotsk; Zhok/
Bin

a

Skotchne/Sher;

A Gite

Nakht

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�clawhammer banjo in the first two tunes,
which are actually blended together as a
medley even though there are two track
numbers. The second of the tunes is titled
"A Freilach for Rick Abrams," which is
appropriate since Rick was such a fine
and influential clawhammer player in the
area until his untimely death several years
ago from cancer. Another great strength
of this album is the Yiddish vocals, which
are strong and very well done. Annette

sings the earthy ballad "Mayn Rue Plats"
("My Resting Place") with heartfelt pain.
The song is grounded very well by Lou
Ann's bass playing. The nylon string
guitar shows its value with the "Oriental
Melodies," which then lets the clawham

mer banjo take it again in the second ver
sion of the tunes. Again, Annette really
gets to show what she is made of with
the "Isador's Doina" where she positively
makes her violin sing.
A

couple of quibbles: there are two tunes

that just don't seem to fit and are more
along the lines of an old Israeli folk music
album than an Old World Klezmer one.
Another interesting observation is the

weakness of English language singing.
That didn't blow it for me though, and
you may like more variety in
I

do. All in all,

I

a

CD than

would say this disc has

a

good music in its favor. If you want
to broaden your definition
of old-time
music or if you just like to hear clawham
mer banjo in another setting, this album
would be a good one to hear what is hap
pening to Klezmer music as it grows with
respect to its roots.
lot of

DAN LEVENSON
To

order:

916-484-1176;

www.freilachmakers.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�one who just learned that string bands are
cool. And, anyhow, as you might expect,
the tune annotations have all the standard
discographical information, so who could
ask for more?
So, if this disc fits your collection needs,

or maybe you want to indoctrinate some
one, or even if you just want to have all
these numbers in good sound in one
place; in the words of Uncle Dave, "folks
it's a good one." And
buy this record

maybe if they sell a few, they'll do some
more high quality reissues of less avail
able stuff.

TIM WOODBRIDGE

order: Sanctuary Classics, PO Box 32698,
London W14; www.sanctuaryclassics.com
To

County, Rounder and Old Timey LPs and
were desperately in need of a life. But,
alas, it was not to be. In the meantime we
are now truly in the midst of a golden age
of reissues such as this. More to the point,

almost everything, if not everything, on
this excellent disc can be found among
the many releases from County, Yazoo,
Bear

Rounder,

Sony/Legacy,

Family,

Document, BACM etc. that many of you
(and you know who you are) have been

ingesting

as fast as

they come out.

perhaps out of a sense of fiscal sanity
or because you occasionally think of other
things, you have not fully feasted at the
banquet, you might do well to compare
what you presently have with the list
ing at the head of this review. Certainly
newcomers to this kind of blood lust
might want to jump right in, secure in the
If,

knowledge that you can quit

at any time.
There's not much point in going through

a

detailed

analysis

of

the

individual

tracks, all of which are classics re-mas
tered in excellent sound (even DaCosta
Woltz). There's a strange cover with a
bunch of rustic looking musicians pick
ing in the foreground and a small glacier
or a big pile of snow in the
background.
There are ads inside the folder for other
re-issues the folks at Living Era think you
might like. Tony Russell's notes have a

slightly hokey tinge, which may be ex
cused on the grounds that the intended
audience was not necessarily you astute
folks reading this but more likely some

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�"Forgotten Soldier Boys." And "Seven
Come Eleven," probably the best perfor
mance here, might appeal to celebrants

hokum, rags and blues persuasion.
a
pretty hot ukulele player
and it's unfortunate that his 1926 record
ings of "Memphis Blues" and "12th Street
Rag" with guitarist William Carola were
not included.
of the

Marvin was

TIM WOODBRIDGE

order: British Archive of Country Mu
sic, http: /bacm.users.btopenworld.com;
or write BACM c/o Greenacres, 451 Folkstone Road, Dover, Kent, CT17 9JX, UK
To

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Music and the Making of
James Campbell

and
race,
class,
gender af
fected New South Atlantans' enthusiasm
for these three music events. Campbell's
approach follows a strong thread in

history

Books
a

New South

Gavin

University of North Carolina Press
Chapel Hill and London, 2004.
a New South focuses
musical events that were
held in early 20th century Atlanta: the At
lanta Music Festival Association's annual
performances featuring the New York
Metropolitan Opera Company; the Col
ored Music Festival; and the Georgia
Old-Time Fiddlers
Convention. While these
events provide the structure for Gavin
James Campbell's book, it is important to
note at the outset that the book only curso
rily discusses the music performed or the
performers, or any aesthetic analysis of
the music. Why? As the author explains,
"Such remarkablv widesnrpad intprpst in
opera, spirituals, and old-time fiddling
at a particular historical moment cannot
be explained solely as evidence of their
aesthetic power. We must be attentive
to the ways audiences found these par
ticular forms of music useful in engaging
the broader cultural currents that moved
through the South and America."
Few would deny that social and cultural
forces both shape and influence the popu
larity of given forms of music, and this
book is largely taken up with discussions
of how the holy trinity of modern social

Music and the Making of
on three major

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

modern academic treatments of music in
the humanities
historical and cultural
context takes precedence over substan
tive discussion of the music itself. So let
the reader be warned. You will not find
much in this book about the songs, per
formers, or style of presentation at these
festivals. It is also worth noting that on
the subject of class the book is addition
it focuses primarily on how
ally limited
middle and upper class Atlantans viewed

these musical events rather than focusing

on the working classes, who, in the case of
the Fiddlers' Convention, actually created
the music.
In the
chapter on the Metropolitan

annual weeklong Atlanta en
gagement that began in 1910, Campbell
Opera's

focuses on issues of gender.
debates about women's chang
ing societal roles, the enervating influ
ence of city life on southern manhood,
and the supposedly feminizing influence
of classical music as affecting Atlantans
sometimes bemused but often troubled
reaction to the opera season. Setting the
documentary standard for the rest of the
book, the chapter on opera relies heavily
on published sources, especially news
papers, but provides few manuscript
sources to assess reaction to the perfor
primarily
He sees

mances. In my view, this is a rather thin
set of sources on which to base a work of
cultural history.
Black Atlantans were barred from the
and
Campbell
opera's performances,
examines an event meant to counter this
snub
the Colored Music Festival (19101917). Largely the brainchild of the First
Congregation Church's Reverend Henry
Hugh Proctor, the festival celebrated the
highest attainments of musical culture
by African Americans, featuring classical
performances as well as highly arranged
versions of the traditional spirituals.
Proctor, a Fisk and Yale alumni, not only
wanted to raise the cultural bar among
members of his own race but also sought
to show white Atlanta the sophistication
of black culture and the tremendous
achievements made since emancipation.
Campbell argues that whites largely
viewed the Colored Music Festival
through preconceived notions about the
spirituals and the people and culture that

produced them. White newspapers and
other observers emphasized the slave
songs at the expense of the classical per
formances, indulging their nostalgia for
the antebellum South, the "Old-Time Ne
gro," and the supposedly superior race re
lations of the slavery regime. This chapter
is an excellent example of where Camp
bell should have given the reader a better
picture of the performers and material
they presented. We get no sense of how

�many artists performed classical pieces
versus predominantly spirituals, such as
the Fisk Jubilee Singers. As Campbell al
lows, blacks themselves were ambivalent
about the spirituals and this would have
strengthened his argument.
Campbell next turns to the Georgia OldTime Fiddlers' Convention, founded in
1913, although he actually spends nearly
the

first half of this

the

evolution

chian culture

of
in

chapter discussing
ideas about Appala

the late 19th and early

centuries. Campbell leans heavily
folkloric and historical literature that
ties the interest in mountain culture at

20th
on

the time to racial

ideology. Attacking the

widely-held notion that mountain whites

were morally bankrupt and culturally de

graded, folklorists, writers, and regional
publicists asserted that Appalachian folk
were in fact an independent, upright, and
sturdy breed. This rehabilitation of moun
tain people and their world reasserted
the superiority of Anglo-Saxon culture
in the one place where it had been kept
or so the folklorists
"pure"
thought.
Much of Campbell's discussion summa
rizes the fine work of previous scholars
such as David Whisnant All That Is Na
tive and Fine. 1983). There is no doubt that
many elites held such racial views, but
Campbell marshals very little direct evi
dence that white middle and upper-class
Atlantans actually read Anglo-Saxon ide
ology into the Old Time Fiddlers' Contest.
Campbell essentially appropriates the
views of national and international cul
tural arbiters such as Cecil Sharpe, Hor
ace Kephart, and William Goodell Frost
and lets them serve as the introduction
to the Atlanta story. We are left to connect
the dots
to assume that culture and ide
ology flows from the top down and that
Atlantans would toe the line of national
racial thinkers.
have my doubts. In fact,
Whisnant and others recognized that the
motives of culture workers on the ground
1

varied greatly.
My frustration in this regard is summed

image on page 110, which
shows a woman sitting outdoors across
from a fiddler and is captioned: "One
of the many folklorists who scoured the
mountains to collect and preserve old
ballads, at left, records a fiddler." Since
this image is from the Annabel Morris
Buchanan papers, I assume that the image
is probably from Virginia. If so, the fieldworker might well be Buchanan or, more
to the point, one of the many local people
(especially teachers) who did field work
in their own communities for the large
collecting projects. We know almost noth
ing about these local people or why they
collected folksong material. The image
reveals something else that they were
not totally absorbed by collecting strictly
British ballads, as is often alleged.
Campbell also makes several secondary
up

by

the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

arguments to explain upper and middleclass Atlantans interest in the fiddle con
tests. He argues that elite and middle-class
whites saw the event as a way to forge
solidarity with working-class whites, and,
for men, as a way to fight the "feminiza
tion" of middle-class urban culture
in
cluding enervating music such as opera.
Campbell's evidence about racial solidar
another photo tells
ity is in fact negative
the tale. A remarkable image on page 125
shows Fiddlin' John Carson being evicted

from company housing during the Fulton
Bag and Cotton Mills strike. This is just
one of many incidents that Campbell cur
sorily mentions to show why elites felt the
need to mend fences with the "wool-hat"
boys and John Carson's crowd. But did
some city elites cutting loose at the Geor
gia Old-Time Fiddlers'

Convention really

imply a coming together of whites of all
classes in Atlanta? Campbell's book cer
tainly doesn't answer that question. Nor
does it provide much in the way of a guide
to the artists and what was performed at
the Fiddlers Convention. A much better
work on both the class politics of old-time
music in Georgia and the Fiddlers Con
vention is Gene Wiggins' Fiddlin' Georgia
Crazy (University of Illinois Press, 1987).
It is a shame that scholars
investigat
ing the history of music are increasingly
unable (or at least not disposed) to pro
duce works that are historically rigorous,
theoretically important, and actually pay
attention to the music itself. No doubt the
increasing specialization of academe is
partially responsible for this trend. The
author of the work at hand might well
respond that he explicitly claims to be in
vestigating the cultural trends that made
these events relevant and compelling to
Atlantans
not the music. I believe, how
ever, that these larger cultural ideas and
beliefs cannot be easily separated from
the actual music and the performances
in fact, these cultural ideas were in my
view clearly shaped by them.
GREGG KIMBALL

�some of this detail as you go along learn
a tune or two,
some of this kind of
detail may be critical. But even when you
get to your first tune, "Spotted Pony," you
get essentially a brush chord followed by
a drone string pick-up through the tune,
and what follows are essentially a series
of scale exercises, presented in the same
manner. On any instrument, this kind of
meticulous exercise will no doubt im
prove technical skill, but I guess I would
encourage the beginner to skim through
the introduction, learn how to read the
tab, and go ahead and try some the tunes,
starting with "Angeline the Baker" on
p. 60. If they don't work out so well, go
back and read some more of the introduc
tory material. My puritan ancestors (and
ing

Dan?) might balk at this pandering to in
stant gratification, but people that want to

play the banjo want to make some noise.
If they don't get the chance pretty
quickly,
not the desired
they may just give up

outcome.

most characteristic tech
hammer-ons,
pull-offs, and
slides, don't show up until page 95. Mas
Some

of

the

niques--

tering the basics is critical, but I tend to
think of these moves as basics, even for

beginners. The photographs in the intro
ductory material seem to do the job, and
the advice to use a mirror is a good trick,
but the pictures are muddy, and low con
trast, which doesn't help. Levenson pro
vides some general historical background
in the introductory material, but nothing
on the individual tunes.
On the positive side,

when we finally

Sink Collection" (p.
all
of
the
various technical
99)-pulling
skills together-find that Levenson's ar
get to the "Kitchen
I

rangements are very close to those I have
worked out on my own for some of these

basic tunes.

I

like the idea of

providing

separate fiddle tracks on the CDs for the
beginner to play along with. This is a re
alistic and traditional aural environment
to provide for the neophyte settings to
exercise his or her developing skills.
TIM THOMPSON

To

Order:

Mel

Bay Publications,

#4

In

dustrial Drive, Pacific, MO 63069, 2003,
(636)257-3970, www.melbay.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Wonderful old-Time Holiday Gifts
Anyone who wants to hear the best of traditional southern music needs to have any and all of these great
CDs. They're beautifully edited and presented, and the music is absolutely the real stuff.
--Bruce Molsky
produced by the Field Recorders' Collective give you the opportunity to explore some lesser-known
but important old-time musicians. Listen to Jimmy Wheeler, a tremendous fiddler from Portsmouth, Ohio who
influenced the playing of Buddy Thomas. Enjoy Cecil Plum was a great West Virginia fiddler who migrated to
Ohio. John Cohen's discovery of Banjo Bill Cornett is of major importance on the order of Roscoe Holcomb.

Releases

The 20 CDs

Each CD, carefully mastered for the best sound quality and culled for the best tracks, is the result of many
years of recorded visits to the musicians. Your support for the Collective not only keeps this an archival work
progress, but also benefits the immediate family of any musician with whom we are in contact.

in

[Fred Cockerham's
New

"Willie My Darling" is of skin-tingling beauty,
J banjo work on
and his playing on "Round Town Gals" borders on the ethereal.
Kevin Donleavy, review in the Old Time Herald
FRC is

making available some great music heretofore
to us mere mortals.
Buddy McClure

unobtainable

The Field Recorders Collective makes
a

staggering amount of beautiful and

inspiring music available to everyone. It's
a treasure trove of musical delights.
This
collection is a blessing!
Gellert
Rayna

The Banjo Bill Cornett
definitely on the

CD is

collective

short list of required

"

listening for any
student of old-time
might even recommend it as
exemplary recording of a traditional
Dan Gellert
singer/banjoist.
banjo.

I

THE

The 2004
Fred

Releases:

Cockerham

101), Band

(FRC

in

Transition: The Camp

Creek Boys &amp;The Smokey Valley Boys (FRC102),The
Roan Mountain Hilltoppers (FRC201), Four West Virginia

musicians (FRC202), Norman Edmonds, Vol.

Recorders'

Norman Edmonds, Vol.

1

(FRC301

(FRC302), Jimmy Wheeler

(FRC401), Ward Jarvis (FRC402), Marcus Martin (FRC501),
Charlie Higgins &amp; Wade Ward (FRC502)

The 2005

Releases:

Clyde Davenport vol.

Field

2

(FRC103), Clyde Davenport vol.
2 (FRC104), Ola Belle Reed (FRC203), Ernie Carpenter
(FRC204), Buddy Thomas (FRC303), Banjo Bill Cornett
(FRC304), Lonnie Seymour (FRC403), Cecil Plum
(FRC404), Santford Kelly (FRC503), Sidna and Fulton
Myers (FRC504)
To

Buy the full 2004 and

1

2005 ten-CD sets:

ONLY

I

$125

PER SET

This discount gives you almost

two free

CDs in each set.

order via US mail, send a check made payable to the Field Recorder's Collective to the address below.
each CD or $1 25 per one ten-CD set, PLUS $4 for US domestic priority mail (any quantity up to twenty).

he

$1 5

T

For

other options and more information, please visit our website: www.fieldrecorder.com

Please note our new Web site address

Field Recorders' Collective, 124 Quaker Bridge Road, Croton, NY 10520

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Field

Recorders'
Collective

�YOU READ THE BOOK.
YOU SAW THE DOCUMENTARY.

NOW HEAR THE MUSIC!
"I

ENVISIONED MYSELF

RECORDING FOR FOLKWAYS

RECORDS. THAT WAS THE
I

I

DM

LABEL THAT PUT OUT ALL
THE GREAT RECORDS."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

BOB DYLAN,

CHRONICLES'

SPEAKS

p.15

ABOUT FOLKWAYS
'

MY LIFE HAD NEVER BEEN THE SAME SINCE
I'D FIRST HEARD

HEARD HIM

IT

WOODY...WHEN

WAS LIKE

FIRST

I

MILLION MEGATON

A

BOMB WAS DROPPED.''
CHRONICLES

BOB DYLAN,

_

1"

WOODY GUTHRIE'S

p.ZZ9

'

'

r

5?R'V

i

THE ASCH RECORDINGS VOL. I-4' CONTAINS

W Lwi-jjTI-

THE

SONGS "JESUS CHRIST," "TALKING COLUMDIA," "PASTURES OF PLENTY"
AND "I9I3 MASSACRE," AS FEATURED IN THE MARTIN SCORSESE FILM
NO DIRECTION

HOME.'

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
WWW.FOLKWAYS.SI.EOU

and

WWW.SMITHSONIANGLOBALSOUND.ORG
ALL

EXCERPTS

FROM

DYLAN PHOTOGRAPH

BOB

DYLAN'S

BY DIANA

CHRONICLES:

VOL.

ONE'; PUBLISHED

DAVIES. GUTHRIE PHOTOGRAPH

BY

COURTESY

SIMON

&amp; SCHUSTER;

2004

BY BOB

DYLAN.

WOOBY GUTHRIE FOUNDATION &amp; ARCHIVES.

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12599">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 10, Number 2 (Winter 2005)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12600">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12601">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 10, Number 2 (Winter 2005)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Ladder-Braced Guitars: The Enduring Mysteries of the Old-Time Sound,” by Dan Margolies&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“A Musical Marriage: Lester &amp;amp; Linda McCumbers of Calhoun County, West Virginia,” by Kim Johnson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dance Beat – Thomas Maupin: ‘When I’m a-Dancing,” by Linda Gunderson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Replacing the Pickguard on a Gibson L-3,” by Bob Smakula&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Hedy West; Cordell Kemp; Helen Bonchek Schneyer; Harvey Chell; Frank Benjamin Proffitt; and Michell Burt “Bea” Lilly;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12602">
              <text>2005</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2781">
      <name>2005</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5572">
      <name>Bob Smakula</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6149">
      <name>Cordell Kemp</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5506">
      <name>Dan Margolies</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6152">
      <name>Frank Benjamin Proffitt</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6151">
      <name>Harvey Chell</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6148">
      <name>Hedy West</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6150">
      <name>Helen Bonchek Schneyer</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6145">
      <name>Lester McCumbers</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5940">
      <name>Linda Gunderson</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6146">
      <name>Linda McCumbers</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6153">
      <name>Michell Burt “Bea” Lilly</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6147">
      <name>Thomas Maupin</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
