<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2628" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2628?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:54:32+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3567">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/99949cca80ed43722a50e527c793b274.pdf</src>
      <authentication>ef0587631515315adf82879ee2419dbb</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12705">
                  <text>A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC
Volume 11, NUMBER 11 JUNE
JULY 2 O O 9
7 5 O

Lily May Ledford:
Carthy
Sisco's

Coon Creek

Girl

road
Rugged
in Old-Time
Trends
Part 1
Banjo Playing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�IB

Mi:sici&gt;isPAf(;H

3W

1

Section with Illegible Text

MUSIC

RESOURCE

lues

I

BANJO

Best

of

DOBRO

Bluegrass

Book/CD

00690636

$24.95

Country

FIDDLE

*"

F°'K*

GUITAR

MAHDOLIM

MORE'i

2

Bluegrass Guitar
Classics

5-String Banjo
Book/CD

00699529

Guitar Book/CD

00695358

Hal Leonard Mandolin
Method Book/CD

00695355

00695102

$7.95

$14.95

Bluegrass and

Folk

$12.95

$14.95

&gt;.

I

Easy Songs for

Parlor Guitar

Mandolin

Book/CD

Book or Book/CD

|j

00695865
00695866

i|
j

i

V
B

$14.95

00699611

$6.95
$14.95

JBmm m

m r

00699796

Ragtime Guitar
Book/CD

$19.95

Earl

Scruggs and the

5-String Banjo
Book or Book/CD

00695764
00695765

$19.95
$34.95

The Ultimate

Banjo

Songbook
Book/2 CDs

00699565

$24.95

MilCIr mmmmwm
1
800 637 2852 KlUilll
II
&lt;11
WWW.MUSICDISPATCH.COM
MON.-FRI. 9AM-9PM, SAT. &amp; SUN. 9AM-5PM CST

Wmw&lt;z\Y(y

II

1

k

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

^31

�AUGUSTA

HERITAGE CENTER
Davis

&amp;

Elkins College, Elkins, WV

CONCERTS, CLASSES, DANCES, &amp; FESTIVAL

Cajun/Creole Week
Early Country Music Week
Blues Week
Guitar Week
Irish Week
Bluegrass Week
Swing Week
Roots &amp; Rhythm
Discover Augusta Week
Old-Time Week
Vocal Week
Dance Week

July
July
July
July
July
July
July
July
July

5-10
5-10
1
1

Joe Newberry

2-1 7
2-1 7

October Old-Time Week
Old-Time Fiddlers' Reunion

Oct. 25-Nov.
Oct. 30-Nov.

bass

Laura Boosinger

beg. banjo

int. banjo

Mac Benford adv. banjo
Chance McCoy beg. fiddle
Dave Bing int. fiddle

26-31
26-31
26-31
26-31
August 2-9
August 2-9
August 2-9

August 7-9

Coordinator

Sharon Gilchrist
Cathy Barton

19-24

Augusta Festival

Section with Illegible Text

Old-Time Week

Rafe Stefanini
Clay Buckner
Dave Para int

int. fiddle
adv. fiddle

guitar

Robin Kessinger
Mike Compton

adv. flat pick guitar

mandolin

Oct Old-Time
Gerry Milnes

1

Coordinator

Bernard Cyrus guest master artist
Erynn Marshall beg.-int. fiddle
Dave Bing int.-adv. fiddle
James Bryan int.-adv. fiddle
Carl

1

Week

Jones

guitar styles

MacTraynham-beg,int.banjo
Riley B^gUS int adv.banjo

augustaheritage. com

augusta@augustaheritage.com

304-637-1209

Now available from our online store at

www.augustaheritage.com/store.html
NEW

Augusta Master Series film:

Bernard Cyrus
Ancient Sounds &amp; Wild Orchids

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

West Virginia
Wild

and Wonderful

�THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD

A

DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME

MAGAZINE

MUSIC

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
PO Box 61679
Durham, NC 27715
Phone and fax: (919) 286-2041

E-mail: info@oIdtimeherald.org

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Sarah Bryan

BUSINESS DIRECTOR
Ruth Eckles
SENIOR ADVISORY EDITOR
Gail Gillespie

ADVERTISING DIRECTOR
Ruth Eckles
CONTRIBUTING EDITORS
Hicks, Phil Jamison, Bob Smakula,
Tim Thompson, Clare Milliner, Walt Koken
Bill

COPY EDITORS
Pan Riggs and Norbert Sarsfield
ART DIRECTOR
Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group

INTERN
Israel Tockman

COMPUTER CONSULTANT
Dan Peck

FOUNDING EDITOR
Alice Gerrard
ADVISORY BOARD
Ray Alden, Mac Benford, Hazel Dickens, Hilary
Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher, Ramona Jones, Garrison
Keillor, Pete Kuykendall, Brad Leftwich, Lee Smith,
Pete Sutherland, Joe Thompson
OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Art Aylsworth,

A. C. Bushnell, Sally Council, Gail
Gillespie, Alice Gerrard, Phil Blank, Jim Watson

No part of this magazine may be reproduced in any
form without written permission from the publisher. Not
responsible for loss or non-re turn of unsolicited photos or
manuscrip\s.2(XJ7\he01d-TimeHei-ald.'TheOld-TimeHe}-ald
(ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is published bimonthly the
first of August, October, December, February, April and
June by tire Old-Time Music Group, Inc., 1817 Chapel Hill
Road, Durham, NC 27707-1105. Subscription rates payable
in advance. One year: $28 (foreign subscriptions
Canada
$35 U.S.; Overseas $38). Library /Institutional rate: one
year: $35. Periodical postage paid at Durham, NC 27701
and additional mailing offices. Postmaster Send change
of address to the Old-Time Herald, PO Box 51812, Durham,
NC 27717-1812. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is a notfor-profit, tax-exempt corporation under section 501 (c) (3)
of the Internal Revenue Code.

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love of

old-time music. Old-time music grassroots, or home
grown music and dance shares origins, influences and
musical characteristics with roots musics throughout
America. Our magazine, the Old-Time Herald, casts a
wide net, highlighting the Southeastern tradition while
opening its pages to kindred and comparable traditions
and new directions. It provides enlightening articles and
in-depth reviews, opportunities for musical learning
and sharing, and a forum for addressing the issues and
questions that bear upon the field.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Letters
John Henry and Pecos Bill
Reading John Garst's article about the
origin of John Henry was great fun. I
still have not come to a conclusion as to
where and when and, really, if John Hen
ry was indeed a real person. Hopefully,
in a way, we may never really know, as
I feel
it might detract from the legend.
Of course he was more real than Pecos
Bill, and others mentioned in the article.
I
have several versions of the ballad of
John Henry, and enjoy all of them.
Mr.
Garst mentions finding no old
songs of Pecos Bill. When I read that,
I went
to my catalog of CDs, and sure
enough I found one. It is on a CD from

Living Era (AJA5421), and according to
the liner notes, the Sons Of The Pioneers
recorded the song "Pecos Bill" for RCA
Featured on
Victor December 1, 1947.
the recording are Roy Rogers, Bob No
lan, Tim Spencer, Lloyd Perryman, Ken

Carson, Hugh Farr, Karl Farr, Pat Brady,
and Shug Fisher. The notes credit Lange
and Daniel as songwriters, but I could
not find references as to their full names.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The song chronicles the exploits of Pecos
Bill much as I found on the CMT website.

hope this lays to rest the notion of no
old songs of Pecos Bill.
I

Gerald Reese,
Wilton, Iowa

�New releases from

June Appal Recordings

New June Appal
releases are now
available through
your preferred
digital music store!

Appalshop Films and June Appal
Recordings are available at

appalshop.org/store
at

phone

or by

800-545-7467.

Join us at Seedtime on Thursday,
1
for the world premiere of

June\

1

Appalshop's newest film From Wood
to Singing Guitar and a performance
by its subject, Wayne Henderson.

KENTUCKY

COUNCIL!

Kentucky*
Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�MENZIES

STRINGED INSTRUMENTS

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

�outstanding country, bluegrass, and oldtime players in the state. Kenny Sears, an
Opry staff fiddler and the leader of the
Time Jumpers western swing band, has
been an long-time devotee of Jean's fid
dles, and at the award event, he showed
off their tone by playing a Beethoven

concerto

and

rangement

Howdy

ar

Forrester's

of 'Say Old Man.'"

Final Notes
Surry County, North Carolina, musician
"Sleepy" Jenkins died on May 2.
"H. O. is the heir to the great legacy of

cluding Gurney Thomas, Clyde Moody,
Joe Jofmson, and the Easter Brothers. He
was a regular fiddler on WPAQ radio in
Mount Airy. In the 1950s, he became an
ordained Pentecostal Holiness minister,
and he started performing gospel and
bluegrass gospel music.
In later years H. O. continued to perform
with regional musicians, including Kirk
Sutphin and Paul Brown. He was always
happy to talk about his family's music
and his own musical career, and to play a
tune on his grandfather's instrument.
Mark Freed

H. O.

the Jenkins Family string band, and he

maintains the legacy with care, affection,
and respect,"

wrote Kinney Rorrer in the

October-November 2006 issue

of the Old-

Time Herald.
A

fourth-generation

musician,

H.

O.

traveled with his family's band when he
was just five years old, entertaining audi
ences with his dancing while his grand
father, father, and aunt played fiddle,
guitar, and banjo. H. O.'s grandfather,
banjo player Frank Jenkins, made several
recordings in the 1920s that are prized by

many modern old-time musicians and
H. O.'s father, Oscar,
record collectors.
made a couple of recordings with Tom
my Jarrell and Fred Cockerham. Oscar,
Tommy, and Fred all played fiddle and
banjo, and the recordings feature the
three of them swapping instruments and
performing with fiddle and two banjos.
H. O.'s father

encouraged him

to

learn

play both fiddle and banjo. "H. O.
recalls vividly the days when he was
too small to hold the banjo on his lap,"
Rorrer wrote. "He would sit on the bed
and hold the banjo beside him as his dad
showed him how to play 'Don't Let Your
Deal Go Down.'" By the time he was six
years old, he was learning to play fiddle,
and by age 14, he was performing with
Cactus Murray and the San Antonio
Cowboys at regional theaters. As a teen
ager he went on tours with the group and
performed at tent shows and theaters.
to

In the

1940s, H. O.

performed

on radio

programs with Virgil William "Smokey"
Graves and the Blue Star Boys, play
ing traditional fiddle tunes and modern
country songs. The group also played
house dances, tobacco warehouses, and
hotels. While raising his family, H. O.
played with musicians close to home, in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Edwin Stripling died in Seattle on
April 20, 2009, after a brief battle with
cancer. He was 87 years old.
Lee

Lee grew up in Kennedy, Alabama, and
was the second son of legendary fiddler
Charlie Stripling, who recorded over 40
tunes in the late 1920s and early 1930s
with his brother Ira on guitar as the Strip

ling Brothers. "Kennedy Rag," "The Lost
Child," "The Big Footed Man In The San
dy Lot," "California Blues," and "Wolves
Howling" all come from Charlie. When
Lee was eight years old, he and his older
brother Robert became Charlie's princi

fiddle contests, danc
es, concerts,
pass-the-hat barbeque
gigs. Charlie was a cotton sharecropper
at this time, having lost everything as the
Depression was starting, and the small
amounts of hard cash from music were

pal

accompanists

at

and

vital to supporting the family.
At age 17, after nine years

band, Lee Stripling and his CCC Ram
blers, turning away from his dad's tunes
to focus on his new love: Western swing
music. He went directly from the CCC
into the service at the start of WWII and
was stationed in the Northwest, where
he continued to form bands and play for
dances in his off hours.
After the war, he married Lucille, a
Northwest gal, settled in Seattle and
all but quit playing music. In the mid
1980s,

after retiring

from his

day job,

gradually began playing with the lo
cal old-time community and, in 1999,
started playing out professionally again
with several groups of middle-aged
youths accompanying him. He recorded

soon

by Swing Cat Records), played numer
ous dances, concerts, and clubs, taught
twice at the Festival of American Fid

dle Tunes,

performed at MerleFest, the
Portland Old Time Gathering, and the
Berkeley Old Time Music Convention,
and toured in Alabama three times. With
Robert, he was featured on the cover of
Old-Time Herald in the summer of
2001, and a documentary film about his
the

Winging My Way Back Home-- The
Stripling Fiddle Legacy, is in the works.
Lee played at least four fiddle tunes in
his hospital bed the day before he died,
and two weeks earlier played an after
noon gig before joining in at our local
life,

bar jam

session later that evening.

We all revered him as

a fiddler and singer
with great tone, pulse, and heart, not to
mention his fine guitar and mandolin ac
companiment. He eagerly shared his vast
and broad repertoire, which included his
dad's tunes, Western swing songs, early
pop songs, swing music from the 1940s,
gospel quartets, and a number of tunes
he learned more recently from younger
fiddlers. But the main thing we're saying
to each other now is that Lee was a true

gentleman, an infinitely generous human
who encouraged and inspired everyone
around him. In party sessions, he would so
politely ask everyone in the circle to start a
tune, and was especially excited to get the
youngest children joining in. He remem
bered everyone's name and favorite tune,
and always had something nice to say, or
a

backing
up Charlie on mandolin, Lee joined
the CCC and promptly started his own

he

four CDs (the last to be released

a twinkle-eyed smile.
epitomized growing old gracefully.

corny old joke, and

He

addition to Robert and sisters Elsie
Mordecai, Christine Johnson, Sarah Jo
In

Duke, Rubye Ball, and Jean Gaston, and
his large network of friends, Lee is sur
vived by his two daughters, Carol and

Sherry Stripling, who also became part
of our music community over the last de
cade. They can receive mail at Lee's ad
dress: 810 NW 107th St., Seattle, WA 98177.
In lieu of flowers, Lee's daughters ask
that donations

be

made

to the Lee

Strip

ling Young Fiddlers' Scholarship, which
will provide tuition and room and board
at Centrum's Festival of American Fiddle

Tunes (see www.centrum.org). A wealth
of information about Lee can be found at
his website,

www.leestripling.com.

Here's to you, Lee Stripling,

q#

WB Reid

�COUNTRY MUSIC HALL OF FAME EXHIBIT
SPOTLIGHTS JOHN HARTFORD'S LEGACY
By Philip F.

Newman

a riverboat rolling along the mighty
that
kept
Mississippi— the waterway
him
her
currents
back
to
year after
drawing

Like

year— the storied legacy of John Hartford's
music and life continues to build steam.
In

the eight years since he lost his 21-

year battle with non-Hodgkin's Lympho
ma in 2001, Hartford's fans, friends, and

family

spearheaded

by

his

children,

Katie and Jamie
have endeavored to
keep his memory alive and introduce his
artistry to new generations.
This

the

year,

momentum

gear, when, on January 24,
Country Music Hall of Fame

hit
&amp;

(countrymusichalloffame.com)
a

one-year artist spotlight

high

Nashville's
Museum
opened

exhibit

fo

cused on Hartford.

Titled John Hartford: Ever Smiling Ever
Gentle On My Mind, the exhibit shines
as a touching tribute to the man who
blended a deep love for traditional folk

bluegrass with a flair
inventiveness, popularizing
and

for

modern

terms

like

"newgrass" and "retrograss" in the lexi
which
of Americana. The exhibit

con

is also an insightful
fans
who are mostly
younger

runs through 2009
for

primer
unfamiliar with Hartford's 1967 smashhit "Gentle On My Mind," his regular
spot on The Smothers Brothers Comedy
Hour, and even his robust contributions
to the O Brother Where Art Thou

soundtrack
Many

film and

in 2000.

of his

fellow artists

in

country,

bluegrass, and folk have long appreciated

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Hartford's talents. Sam Bush, Bela Fleck,
Howard, Mark O'Connor, and
others
continue to incorporate his
many
tunes, and his insights, into their work.

Mark

Born in 1937 and reared in

St.

Louis along

the river, John always remained connected
to the water. He was a licensed captain

who piloted many a boat, and he built Iris
home along the Cumberland River near
Nashville with a back-porch view that sim
ulated the feel of standing in a pilot house.
One of Hartford's heroes, Mark Twain,
once told the St. Louis Dispatch, "For the
majority of us, the past is a regret, the fu
ture an experiment." In Hartford's case,
that assertion was only half true. The past

was

a

success

marked by an adventur

ous childhood along the river, a rise to
musical acumen, the torrent of Grammywinning "Gentle On My Mind," followed
by

mainstream commercial accolades.
future was most definitely

But the
an

experiment.

As "Gentle On My Mind" took its place

among country /folk's most recorded
songs, Hartford parlayed the financial
independence he gained from its success
into the freedom to explore new musical
frontiers. His landmark record, Aereoplain (1971) documented his work with

progressive new audience, making every
song a cult favorite and every live perfor

mance the stuff of legend. As Bush put it,
"Without Aereo-plain, there would be no
'newgrass' music."
"Dad has always had sort of an under
ground following, but the hall of fame spot

light will help folks who didn't know what
he did after the Smothers Brothers learn

more about him," son Jamie Hartford says.
"He broke a lot of ground [with his] oneman show, dancing on a piece of plywood
wJiile he played the fiddle or the banjo."

While Hartford sought

pay tribute

to

greats

always maintained

a

to

emulate and

like Ed Haley,

he

distinctive sound

and an air of humble gratitude.
Once, as he guided a riverboat

along,

trademark bowler hat and
vest, John remarked, "I don't know how I
came to sound like Jofm Hartford. I think
style is created by limitations, and I think I
do the best I can with what little I've got.
I would
say that my life in music has been
a steady thing of trying to teach my hands
and my feet and my mouth to reproduce

wearing

his

sounds that I hear in my head."
That "steady thing" is now on display

the

Nashville, and it remains alive in the
sounds of his recordings and in the mem
in

Vassar

ories of those who are keeping Hartford's

Tut

legacy steaming along.

Clements, Norman Blake, and
Taylor. Rooted firmly in tradition
but sprouting at the top with hippie hair,
the group's instrumental mastery and
free-wheeling style bridged a musical
gap between traditional bluegrass and a

Philip

F.

Newman

public-relations

is

a

writer, editor, and
based in

professional

Franklin, Tennessee.

�So Why Old Time?
That's the question that propels this feature length
documentary forward
Why, in the 21st Century, do so many people across the
world build their lives around songs that were considered
"old" 100 years ago?
After

a

year of traveling through

Appalachia to create this film,
Horse Archer Productions

brings you into the world of Old
Time music to share in the
community and fellowship that
defines this culture.

Shot entirely in HD against the
backdrop of the oldest

mountains in the world, this
takes you from house jams
large festivals, from front
porches to the backwoods,

film
to

from up in the hills to just down
the road to bring you the
passion of this music.

Special features include extended performances, crew
interviews, and more.

WWW.

WHY

You can order online or

order by mail:

OLD

TIME

.COM

contact Horse Archer Productions

info@horsearcherproductions.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

�TRENDS IN OLD-TIME
FIVE-STRING BANJO PLAYING, PART

I

by Ray Alden

"There are more things in heaven and
earth, Horatio, than are dreamt of in

your philosophy.

"

William Shakespeare, Act

Ray Alden

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Fred Cockerham

1

scene

5

of Hamlet
fl

�encapsulate from

to

attempt

Anyto

tip

toe all the ways in which old-time

five-string banjo is played today, or pre
dict precisely the direction in which it will
headed, is likely to be as frustrating as
to forecast which clothing will be
in voeue or what Popular musical stvle
will be the rage ten years from now. In

be

trying

one respect, old-time banjo players stand
apart from most other fad-driven inter
ests in that they have a noticeable fidel
ity to the past. This is in part because of
the realization that older musicians had

already found solutions for many of the
rhythmic puzzles of the five-string banjo.
Nonetheless, creative people will always
find a way to produce new techniques

express themselves in ways that
stamp on their playing, reflecting
put
abilities, personalities, and the milieu in
which they learned. Perhaps this tug-ofwar characterizes most artistic human
endeavors: on one side an adherence
to tradition, on the other new, creative
ideas coming from inventive individu
so as to
a

als. In this article, the goal is to explore
both sides of the coin, mostly through in
terviews with a variety of old-time fivestring banjo players.
Most of the musicians found at festi
vals can best be described through this

observation by Mike Seeger, one of the
founders of the New Lost City Ramblers,
primogenitors of
old-time music:

old-time

Whereas
played

by

a

revival of interest in
music

used

to

be

rural and small-town

people,
agriculture, and

in
mostly involved
sometimes in the mines and mills, it is
now played by a few thousand people who

have

a

common urban-based experience.

Their occupations can include carpentry,
computer programming, law practice,

education,

car-washing,

and

so

forth.

Probably five and no more than ten musi
cians make their full-time living playing
old-time music, depending on your defi"
nitions of "old-time" and "a living.
At tne resnvais, tne two preuominant
styles of playing old-time five-string ban
jo are

the

so-called clawhammer

(or

trail

two- or three-finger pick
ing style. For those unfamiliar with these
terms, the clawhammer style is primarily
a down-picking
style. The hand assumes
a

claw-like shape whereby the nail (using
somewhat stiff finger) down-strikes the

of the hand,
driven by the momentum of a combina
tion of wrist and elbow. The old-time
two- or three-finger picking style consists

Ray

a

a

Alden

ing) style and

banjo strings using power

of an

up-picking motion by the fingers,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Andy

Norcross

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is also the technique used in the
Scruggs style for bluegrass banjo, how
ever not as standardized. In both styles
motion is
of playing, a down-picking
used bv the thumb.
Even a casual observer at the Appala
chian String Band Festival (Clifftop) in
West Virginia or the Mount Airy Fid
dler's Convention in North Carolina,

which

each of which encompasses a large sam
pling of old-time banjo players, would
notice that the vast majority of old-time
banjo players use the so-called claw

hammer style, whereas a minority play
in a two- or three-finger picking style.
However, to make these observations
the sole basis that encircles all the trends

old-time five-string banjo playing to
day would be to miss the fine points and
the crafty ways in which some players
form tangents to this circle, while oth
ers sometimes travel in peripheral arcs
along the circumference.

in

The Past as Prologue:
Roots of the Clawhammer Style
"Where did you come from, where
did you go, Cotton-Eyed Joe?"
In

West Africa, dried, hollowed-out cal

abashes made both useful utensils and
harp- or lute-type musical instruments,
such as the kora, xalam, ngoni or the goje
(a traditional fiddle). It was a small step
for resourceful African-Americans mu
sicians to adapt these forms to that of a
banjo-like instrument, with animal hide
stretched over the gourd, as shown in a
famous American folk painting from the
1790s of a plantation marriage ceremony.
Numerous craftsmen and musicians dur
ing the 18th and 19th century reconfigured
that instrument into what became the

modern banjo. Greg Adams and Shlomo
Pestcoe recently discovered a 1736 New
York Weekly Journal making reference to
a
"banger" being played by a black mu
sician at a "Pinkster" celebration in New
York at springtime. Current research by
people such as Ulf Jagfors and Daniel

Laemouahuma

Jatta

into

a

Senegalese-

Gambian jola lute known as the akonting
has furthered our understanding of the
close relationship of African instruments
to

that

the

banjo. The general consensus is
banjo itself came to be more

the

widespread

throughout

the

American

South circa 1840-50 because of minstrel
performers traveling in shows and cir
cuses. The American Civil War, which
caused soldiers to travel far beyond their

�local communities, cemented an experi
ence with the banjo for many.

classic example of the traveling min

A

strel was Dan Emmett who, in 1843, after
exposure to the banjo from a man named

Ferguson

during

a

stint with

a

Cincin

nati circus, started his Virginia Minstrels
troupe. This happened soon after white

musicians
Thomas

Joel Walker Sweeney
Rice first incorporated a

and

vari

ety of African-American music into their
acts. Although Joel Walker Sweeney was
at first

identified

as

having invented the

fifth string of the banjo and Dan Emmett
having written the song "Dixie," it

and Timothy Twiss have either issued re
cordings or can be heard at events such as
the Early Banjo Gathering in Sharpsburg,
Maryland. If you were to hear this style,

would certainly be apparent that the
mountain clawhammer style
developed from the down-stroke style,
most likely from a combination of mu
it

from Sweeney as saying that if Sweeney
added anything, it was the fourth (bass)
string. While Dan Emmett performed
in the

mostly
in England,

celebrity

group's

gave

numerous other minstrel troupes
that toured throughout the country, in
cluding the South. Dan Emmett's long
career of performing continued for 52
years, ending finally in 1895. Bing Cros
by portrayed Emmett in the 1943 Para
rise to

mount film Dixie. Regrettably, although
the minstrel era may have made the ban

jo

it

popular,

and

typecasts

to this

also produced racist lyrics
that have afflicted America

date.

Along with the banjo came the main
style in which it was played, the so-called
In fact, one trend in
down-stroke style.
old-time banjo is to play this style using
replicas of minstrel banjos, by musicians
who learned from books such as Brigg's
Banjo Instructor, Frank Converse's Banjo In
structor and Buckley's Complete New Banjo
Method. Current banjo players who use
the down-stroke style such as Joe Ayers,
Clarke Buehling, Greg Adams, Bill Gay,

Bob Winans, Bob Flesher, Carl

Anderton

sicians who heard the banjo at minstrel
shows and those having direct contact
with the music of African- Americans.

book

Student's Home Study for Five-String Banjo.
Further, John Copeland and George Col
lins founded a group called the Ameri

"This banjo can do things that the gui
tar can't do. You can get these needle

points of time, needle points like

can Banjo Fraternity,

a

melody

to

his How

them."

Pete Seeger, in an interview with
Mark Fields, Beacon, NY, August 2003
It is well known that two men can be
credited directly with the nationwide re
vival of interest in the five-string banjo,

beginning from the mid-

to

late

1940s:

Pete Seeger and Earl Scruggs. In terms
of young, urban five-string players who
came to play in the old-time style, Pete
Seeger was the central influential musi
cian who employed that technique and
inspired others to do the same. However,

to develop a knee-jerk reaction that Earl
Scruggs was responsible only for an in
terest in the bluegrass style would not
take into account the number of current
Southern old-time five-string banjo play
ers who began playing the banjo only
because of their initial interest in the

bluegrass banjo style. What one hears of
old-time banjo playing today is the result
of many streams that came to be blended
into a larger river.
Materializing just atter tne impact
in

Bill

Monroe's

ot

Blue-

grass Boys in the South was Pete Seeger's

publication

of 100

copies of How

to

Play

the Five-String Banjo in 1948. Over sub
sequent years, new editions were pub
lished and an LP record from Folkways
became available. The book used a com
bination of music notation on the top and
tablature on the bottom to show what

BRACKET

PIECE

FOR

2

FLANGE
PIECE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

strings

simultaneously using let
middle to represent what ac

to fret,

ters in the

to

is

1949. However, neither the instruction
books nor the banjo group set off the ex
plosion of interest that Pete Seeger and

constellation among them... you' re
hearing a lot of notes but somehow
a

a

which began

sue Five Stringer newsletters regularly by

there's thousands of
star in the sky..
stars out there, but you can pick out

there's

Although the earliest banjo instruc
tion book found was published in 1848,
five-string banjo instruction books con

tinued appearing in the 20th century up
to Frank Bradbury's 1926 Modern Meth
ods for Banjo and William Smith's 1939

The revival of the five-string banjo:
Pete Seeger and Earl Scruggs

Scruggs playing

TAIL

to

"basic strum,"

ing numerous urban folk musicians in
the North to learn the five-string banjo,
raises the question, ivhy that particular

Northeast and some times

the

songs that use the techniques
"hammering on,"
"double thumbing," and "pulling off."
That Seeger's banjo book became the
spark that set off a banjo boom, trigger
of the

Southern

as

seems clear today that virtually all those
facets of blackface minstrelsy came di
rectly from African-American sources.
Classical banjo player Paul Caldwell
cited an old Virginia judge who learned

devoted

index finger, B
tion the hand applies (I
hand brush, T
thumb). Chapters are

tually

to

Play the Five-String Banjo

generated.

Why

even

Seeger's book

and not the other books or groups? The

recent book Tribes, which explores how
individuals like Barack Obama or bands
such as the Grateful Dead can mobilize

group of like-minded indi
viduals, might give us clues. Pete Seeger
entered the late 1940s and early 1950s
with a passionate commitment to a vi
sion and a social awareness. His timing,
and

involve

the

after

a

Great Depression

and

WWII,

resonated with many people. Expressing
his foresights through an honest sound
ing and charismatic folk music, Seeger
drew people, many by then queasy of

endless "spoon-moon-June" pop songs
of little significance to the arduous pe

riods America had just been through, to
his ideas and to the five-string banjo.
How Seeger came to have a social

awareness and learn

play the banjo
which
occasion
personal journey
that
of
musicians
younger
ally parallels
playing today. Pete Seeger, born in 1919,
was the third son of classically trained
musicians Charles and Constance Seeger.
In many ways, Pete's views were shaped
by those of his father. Charles grew up in
was

to

a

New York well-to-do and apart from the
hoi-polloi. He was educated at Harvard
and his thoughts might have remained

solely in the ivory tower to set the stage
for modern ethnomusicology but for the
influence of economist Carlton Parker.
Parker was on the faculty at the Uni
versity of California in Berkeley during
Charles Seeger's tenure from 1912 to
1919. After Parker challenged Charles
Seeger's world view at a faculty meet-

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ing he drove him south where, between
Fresno and Bakersfield, Seeger could see

migrant workers
Juaquin valley, the source of
nearly 25% of the United States' agri
In 1919, because of
cultural products.
the poor

conditions

of

in the San

his

World War

to

outspoken opposition

Seeger departed for New York while
Parker wrote his classic study about the
Industrial Workers of the World, The Ca
I,

sual Laborer and Other Essays.
While this set the stage for Pete's future

political outlook, which would be fused
with his musical abilities, it was Pete's
independent nature and to some extent
solitary upbringing that fixed his course
to the five-string banjo. Both Charles and
Constance wanted Pete to have music

lessons with theory on the piano
violin, but,

as

Whistles,
banged on.

didn't want

just having fun...
notes was as boring
by

Perhaps

came to be blended into his larger river
of music were evident. Pete included
pop songs from those days such as Ger
shwin's "Blue Skies," as well as classical
pieces he must have heard at home many
times such as Edvard Grieg's "Anitra's
Dance" and Bach's "Jesu, Joy of Man's

Desiring."
troduction
Off Suite

to

In
to

LP,

a
a

somewhat prophetic in
book notating The Goofing

Pete wrote;

For we are in the process of

anything that made music
1

Got Rhythm" and "Night and Day" in
five-piece jazz band. In 1955,
when Pete recorded his Folkways LP The
Goofing Off Suite, the many streams that
"I

the school's

Pete said:

The

numbers.

or the

Wonderful." In 1932 Pete entered the
Avon Old Farms School where teacher
Charles Langmuir let Pete borrow his
four-string tenor banjo. It wasn't long be
fore Pete was playing pop tunes such as

to

study,

idea

feeling something

was

of reading

me as

"

I

ing you luck.
1936 was a year

painting

would

building

up

new musical tradition out of the many
old ones, and the creative musicianship
of many people is needed. Here's wish
a

I

be

better than nothing, Pete's parents gave
him a ukulele at age 8 as he listened to

wind-up gramophone records of songs
such as George and Ira Gershwin's "'S

nexus

formed

in

which

a

musical

between Charles Seeger

and Pete that lead in

a

straight line

five-string banjo. Fifteen years

to the

earlier,

Charles and Constance traveled as far
south as North Carolina to "bring mu
sic to the poor people of America, who
didn't have any music." A result was not
North Carolina sponsoring Bach Festi
vals; quite to the contrary, natives initiat
ed Charles into what they could do with
the fiddle and banjo. Years later Charles

joined
part of

the Composer's
Collective, as
New York's progressive Degeyter

Clubs, along with Aaron Copland. Origi
nally the Composer's Collective thought
of folk music as "defeatist melancholy
and

sion

triviality, "but

worsened

deeper, there was

warmed up

to

as

and

the Great

folklorists

Depres

delved

of heart that

change
America's "true" music.
a

summer of 1936, after graduat
Avon,
17-year-old Pete heard field
ing
recordings of five-string banjo music at
his father's house, but couldn't make his
tenor banjo reproduce that sound. See
ing this, Charles packed Pete up and
brought him to the 9th annual Folk Song
and Dance Festival in Asheville, North
Carolina. There, Pete said, he "discov
ered there was some good music in my
country I had never heard on the radio.
The words to the songs had all the meat
of life in them. Their humor had bite, it
was not trivial. Their tragedy was real,
In the

not sentimental."
At the

Asheville festival, banjoists

mantha Bumgarner

Sa-

and Bascom Lamar

�provided Pete with some

Lunsford
the initial

secrets

of

unlock the ringing

to

sound of the five-string banjo. In his
book How to Play the Five-String Banjo,
Pete introduces a regional style called
the basic strum in which the index fin
ger picks up on the first string, followed
by the hand brushing down across the

strings.
this into

thumb

In the
a

next chapter, Pete finalizes

three-part action by adding the

to pick on the fifth, high-pitched
drone string, thus giving the five-string
its ringing sound and, if done succes

sively just right, provides the timing
give

a

"bum-titty,

bum-titty"

to

rhythm.

One might visualize the right hand coor

dinating this rhythm
ger, first note)

as hump

(index fin

(brush)
ty (thumb,
fifth string). When I asked Pete about this
style, he told me that he was not exactly
sure where he learned it. Pete did recall
that Bascom Lamar Lunsford showed
him a two-finger picking style where the
thumb stays rooted on the fifth string but
tit

the index finger, which in some picking
styles stays rooted on the first string, also

inward to pick the second and
third strings as well. In our interview,
Pete mentioned that his early teaching to
banjo students played a role in his use of
techniques such as the elementary strum,
which seemed an ideal way to introduce
moves

the

five-string banjo.

It

was this tech

nique that he taught one of his students,
the then nine-year-old Eric Weissburg.
A few chapters later in his book, Pete
introduces another right-hand rhythmic
method called trailing, mentioned as be
ing taught to him by Rufus Crisp of Al
len, Kentucky. Allen is in southeastern
Floyd County, 50 miles northwest of
Hazard, Kentucky, passing through the
small towns of Hindman and Martin.
Pete mentions other names he had heard
such as "framing" and "rapping" for this
right-hand technique learned from Crisp.
Frailing was a technique much more
widespread throughout the South than

style he learned in Asheville, and
closer to the minstrel stroke-style. The
the

main difference between frailing and the

basic strum is that the index finger picks
doiun using a fingernail on the first string,
after which the thumb quickly pulls up
on the fifth string immediately following
the brush. The term "clawhammer" is not

mentioned
to

in Pete's book. This style adds
of dropping the

frailing the technique

thumb

strings below the fifth string.
technique is briefly mentioned in

This
How

to

Play the Five-String Banjo,

to

appear

ing only in one instance in Pete's tablature, as far as

I

can see.

Rufus Crisp was cousm-m-law to Margot Mayo, a founder of the American
Square Dance Group, based on 13th street
in New York City, and close to where

Pete had moved in 1939. Mayo, having
come from the rural South, noted that
"the very nature of city life, its very lack

community feeling and community
consciousness, banished many of the
time-honored traditions on which the
of

American way of life had been built." In
establishing the American Square Dance
Group, Mayo hoped to re-introduce a so
cial and democratic dance to the city in
which callers and "those-in-the-know"
would guide a novice through, with
no need for prior expertise. Pete Seeger
learned about Rufus Crisp from Mayo.
January 1941, returning from a trip in
which he paid a visit to Rufus Crisp in
Kentucky, Pete wrote a little article for
In

Promenade, the newsletter for the Ameri
can Square Dance Group. He wrote:
that

explained

I

and

I

but

I

I

was just passing by,

was just stopping by for

played

the banjo

would like very much
if

I

could.

much

in

yours.

I

now,

"Why
last few

a

bit

a

moment,

myself and

to

hear him play,

I

haven't played

years... let's see
.hmm..
.you've got a fret on
your banjo.
the

don't like 'em myself.

I

filed all of

'em off my banjo. ..you get better tone that
way." So Rufus went into the next room

and brought out his own instrument.

must remind ourselves that Pete
spent only one afternoon with Crisp and,
despite Pete's having a close view of
We

Crisp's advanced right-hand techniques,
Crisp could not have revolutionized
Pete's playing style all by itself. As most
banjo players have found, it is a long pro
cess of listening and trying to duplicate

TUNING
BUTTON
chonghoce

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

sound that will eventually shape a musi
cian's style. Nonetheless, Pete did men
tion that he learned quite a bit just from
that one afternoon with Rufus Crisp. Pete
had access to field recordings of South
ern playing from two sources; first at
his fathers' house where Ruth Crawford

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Seeger,

Charles' second

wife, was me
of

Con

thodically transcribing Library
gress recordings for the father-and-son

folklorist team of John and Alan Lomax.
Secondly, Pete listened intently to com
mercial 78 rpm recordings of five-string
banjo players such as Uncle Dave Macon,
Lily May Ledford, and Buell Kazee. As
David Dunaway wrote about Pete;
The

practically

seventeen-year-old

could find,
putting his thumb on the edge to slow
them in to a growl. He played the disks
over and over until he got the hang of it.
obliterated

what records

he

This took several years.

Doris Kimble of Laurel Fork, Virginia,
me he used a similar technique to learn
Charlie Poole 78 rpm records. Today,
time musicians use software on their

told
from
old-

com

puters such as the Amazing Slow-Down
to slow down digitally transferred re
cordings, and have their hands free.

er

Personal Note
I write this, I cannot help but be tickled
of the parallels that undoubtedly
some
by
many five-string banjo players came across
if they traveled south to make connections
with musicians who played the old time
five-string banjo style. For some of us,
it was as if being transported to another
country, another culture. For me person

As

having spent a year in Italy as a boy,
reminded me of the old style hospitality
one found in parts of Europe. Just before
Pete left Rufus and Lula Crisp's home,
ally,
it

they treated him to a meal and Pete wrote;
"Man Alive, I'm telling you, it was a feast,
three kinds of potatoes, turnip greens, hot
cornbread, hot biscuits, gravy, buttermilk,
fried pork, and best of all, fried apples."
In 1969 I traveled south to try to learn
some of the banjo techniques of Fred Cockerham in Low Gap, North Carolina. Before
I left, Eva Cockerham, Fred's wife, invited
me for dinner with them, and I later wrote
in an article

can serve up

for Sing Out! Magazine, "Eva
a storm of mountain cooking;

crowder peas, pinto beans, yellow squash,
creamy mashed potatoes, fried chicken and
homemade biscuits sopped in gravy."
The number of old-time musicians who
visited Tommy Jarrell in nearby Toast,
North Carolina, all have clear memories
of how the day began: lively talk with
Tommy in the kitchen as he put pinto
beans into a large pot with a hunk of fat
(which he called "western chicken") to

mid-afternoon meal one
would share with him. That music would
prepare for the

take place later was just another part of

the way you enjoyed each other. The

ex

perience was much more than learning
it was a lesson in
a bunch of techniques;
how life itself should be lived.
A Pete

Seeger Parallel

question that arose was, was Pete
Seeger unique or could there have been
other ways people could discover the ban
jo? What follows is the story of a young
person that in many ways parallels Pete
Seeger's story, but of someone who knew
nothing of Pete nor his book, who came in
dependently upon the banjo. In the 1990s,
at age fifteen, Andy Norcross began freight
hopping trains from his home in San Jose,
California. Andy at the time was involved
A

Coast punk scene. Some 55
years earlier, after Pete Seeger made his
first trip out West with Woody Guthrie,
in the West

Pete had learned some of the freight hop
ping tricks and set out in 1940 across the

country to interact with Americans from
different parts of the country. His father
Charles warned: "There's a Sheriff just
this side of Scottsboro, Alabama, that's

retired and lives next to a cemetery. He
sits on his front porch and takes potshots
at the hoboes riding the rails." Not dis
suaded, Pete went out and did not return
until a broken banjo neck prevented earn
ing enough pocket change to stay afloat

financially. Beyond the comparison of the
two men with freight hopping, there were
other parallels, namely social concerns,
and

building and playing the banjo.

s story began with a 19-year-old
friend who had ridden freight trains
from Oakland to Portland years before.

Andy

The pair talked about

attending a punk
outside
festival just
Eugene, Oregon, and

freight hop. Andy, who
appear cool, told his friend that
he had ridden trains before. When they
got on the train at Oakland however, the
train "pulled slack." Pulling slack occurs
when the locomotive makes its starting
traveling

wanted

by

a

to

pull and successively jolts each car so that
the entire train expands by as much as 30
feet. The expanding shock wave of this

action gives an ever-louder approaching
sound at your location on the train. An
dy's startled reaction gave away his inex

perience to his friend. Nonetheless, Andy
soon learned where to get off in advance
at train hubs to switch trains and where
to

find the hidden spots in cars to get out

wind.
Andy ended up staying for nearly
two months near Eugene at an Earth
First tree camp where activists, many
of the

�from the punk movement, had gone up
250-year-old fir trees to prevent them

being brought down in a clear-cut log
ging operation. Rules prevent any tree
within 300 feet of someone from being
felled. The activists had put platforms

far up in the trees and would stay there
for a month at a time. The Forest Service

was stationed close, not only to intercept
ropes enabling food to be sent up, but
also to climb up to pepper-spray activ
ists or use powerful floodlights and blast
modern country music at them all week
to wear them down. Andy would sneak
in the
to the

middle of the night to get food up
activists in the tree tops.

Andy kept traveling and later, in 1999,
while at the World Trade Organization
protests in Seattle, Andy met a 60-yearold fellow named Carl. While spending
nights at a Food Not Bombs campsite,
from which during the day they fanned

out to give food to homeless people, Carl
showed Andy his bluegrass banjo. Andy
was able to play some train songs on his

traveling guitar, but the banjo was new
to him. Carl, who said his old Gibson
arch-top was once owned by Ralph Stan

ley, insisted Andy first learn the old-time
banjo style. As Emily Miller wrote;
On the musical surface, punk and oldtime seemed

have

to

little

common.

in

On the level of attitude and motivation,
the similarities are abundant.
Punks' aversion to the 'mainstream' and
its do-it-yourself attitude transferred
easily to old-time music, which is filled

however,

with people who just do it all themselves,
attracting little attention from the main
stream.

And

it

stresses

participation

rather than performance.

After swapping his guitar tor a cheap
banjo, Andy learned to fix it while rid
ing trains, using his all-in-one Leatherman tool. Following in the footsteps that
Rufus Crisp mentioned to Pete Seeger,
Andy told me "the best repair I ever did
on the banjo was tear out the frets." After

Andy used

a

friend's shop

to

make his

two great-playing but "butt-ugly"
banjos, Don Minerly of Portland showed
him how to make better banjos, and to
gether they produced the Arrow line of
first

banjos. Years after freight hopping down
to Asheville, North Carolina, with oldtime banjo player Gabrielle McRae and

her sisters, Andy now has his own shop
to build his Acme banjo. This is yet an

other parallel to Pete Seeger. After John
D'Angelico built Pete the first long-neck
banjo in Greenwich Village, Pete took it
upon himself to build one, from cocobolo

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

wood fitted onto

an old Vega

Tubaphone

rim, that he plays to this day. Andy can
be heard playing one of his fretless ban
jos on Light and Hitch,

a

homemade CD

recorded by Joe "Bass" Dejarnette.

Sophisticated Styles from the South
In

1946,

World

after

just
and

War

II,

Stu

Jamieson
Margot Mayo carried a
95-pound recording lathe down to Rufus
Crisp's home in Kentucky. Rufus, seeing
someone interested again, began play
ing steadily. The next summer, Forrest
"Woody"

Wachtel,

another member

of

the American Square Dance Group, spent
the entire summer with Crisp learning

techniques, showing them
Jamieson upon his return. John Cohen,
one of the founders of the New Lost City
Ramblers, learned from Woody Wachtel.
The time was just about to become ripe for
the forthcoming urban folk boom, along
with a large-scale interest in the old-time
five-string banjo style. Should you go to
an old-time music festival and observe
the hand-arm motion of most five-string

his

renewed

to

banjo players, you will see them holding
their right hand in basically the same way
as

Jamieson describes

as that of Crisp:
First was his use of unmoving curled
fingers and a still wrist; the only rotary
motion that took place was in his elbow

compares to a stiffer technique used by
other nearby players. Jamieson describes
this rhythm as more a "bump- ting-chunkthan
the
bump-ting-chunk-ting"
ting,
"bum-tit-ty, bum-tit-ty" described earlier.
Fred Cockerham, who also grew up in
the Round Peak area at the same time as
Tommy, used a technique he observed
from Charlie Lowe, considered to be the
master old time five-string banjo player
of the area. Fred called this technique

"double-noting" and

for years

I

was con

exactly what he meant. I fi
nally realized that instead of just hitting
a note and let it sound out for its given
fused

as to

length of time, Fred would often rapidly
strike down again on that note before go
ing on to the next one. So while a fiddle
is dragging its bow and holding a note,
Fred could double up on the note and fit
it in yet another time. This can add an
exciting sound to a tune. One extreme
can be heard

of this

example

in Fred's

playing of the tune "Ruben." That tune
has a bluesy sound in which some notes

held by the fiddle for quite awhile as
compared to most rapid-fire fiddle tunes.
Fred would often slide up on the first
string of his fretless banjo until he reached
are

the same length as the fifth string (hence
both first and fifth strings would be play
ing the same note). He would then alter
nately strike each string rapidly, using

joint. This was the source of his power
the pull of gravity on forearm, wrist and

his index finger and thumb, to get mul
tiples of that single note as the fiddle was

hand added

steadily bowing

muscular force driv
ing his forearm forward.
to

the

Jamieson mentions that Crisp's thumb
remained flexible and could curl and un
curl as they hit the strings in this other
wise rigid pattern. My memory of Tommy
Jarrell's hand motion used in his claw
hammer style is that his thumb remained
uncurled even as he drop-thumbed be
yond the fifth string, a motion which
helped him produce rock-solid timing on
the banjo and achieve his ideal of making
the music "steady as a clock."
Apparently Crisp also used some tricks

it as a

long note.

Other Early Urban
Old-Time Banjo Players
There was not an overabundance of
urban pioneers of the banjo in the 1940s.

One of the early musicians to play the
banjo was Tom Paley, one of the three
founders of the New Lost City Ramblers.
The other two founders, John Cohen and
Mike Seeger, also began to play the banjo
in more or less the same period. Tom Paley wrote to me about how he began the

and sweeping arm motions, producing
fancy flourishes, possibly learned from
medicine show banjo players. I did not
find these types of techniques used in
the Round Peak section of North Caro

banjo and who influenced him:
When
first started playing guitar
and banjo (a few months
1945)
(January
later), the folk musicians with zvhose

lina, where Tommy Jarrell grew up, nor
in the nearby Blue Ridge mountains that
form a northern boundary to the area. If
one listens to Rufus playing "Shot Little
Lula" from the recordings made by Ja
mieson and Mayo now in the Library of
Congress, you can hear him put a "double
shuffle" rhythm into his playing which he

Seeger, Woody Guthrie, Leadbelly, Burl
Ives, and Josh White. Of those, the only

1

music

I

was

most familiar

were

Pete

one who played a lot of banjo was Pete
Seeger, so he was the main (and almost

only)

influence

Perhaps
tar,
at

a

on

banjo-playing.

my

year before

had begun going

I

started on
to

gui

square-dances
the Furriers Union hall. A few of the
I

�regulars there played guitar and one,

Joe

brush-thumb-brush-thumb

a

six-beat

pretty good on
"Prof" Jafee,
the banjo, but pretty much in the Pete

repeated pattern. I'm not certain, but I
think it was "Prof" Jafee who told me that

Seeger mode. I got a couple of tips from
him, but Pete was still my main model.
Sometime in late 1944 or early 1945, 1

for "frailing" the only difference was that
the "PICK" note was picked downward

was

also

around with my radio and
accidentally came across a 'country mu
sic' program broadcast on WAAT, New
Jersey. I heard the familiar sound of Pete
was fooling

Seeger playing 'Cindy' (from the Asch
album 'Folksay') and stayed tuned

to the

program. They played a few more num
bers from that album and 1 was hooked.
I

began

listening regularly

gram, which ivas

(I

nearly every day.

to

that

pro

for several hours
believe it was called

on

'The Hometown Frolic."). Most of what
they broadcast was the popular coun
try music

peal

to me,

of the day, which didn't ap
but they did sometimes play

some numbers

Pete Seeger

or

Woody
Guthrie. They also played songs by some
others I hadn't previously heard like the
by

Carter Family, Mainer's Mountaineers,
Gid Tanner's Skillet Tickers, and Uncle
Uncle Dave's banjo play

Dave Macon.

ing knocked me out, but it was some
time before I could begin to get any grip
on it, so, for some time after I got my

first banjo

(a

cheap old one that cost me

$5), Pete Seeger was still my only model
for banjo-picking.
I didn't
yet have
I

a

record-player,

but

eventually got hold of an old turnta

ble

that

could attach

I

to

my radio and

started prowling around some shops on
6th Avenue that dealt in used records,
gradually collecting a small selection of

few tips like that, I was
entirely self-taught, based entirely on
listening, mainly to records, but some
times to live performances. Gradually,
I
moved from basing my playing on
Pete's to trying to imitate the styles of
a

old time players like Uncle Dave Macon

and

Wade

Ward.

also

1

began

experi

menting with various three-finger (and
some two-finger) up-picking styles, but
I

never made any serious attempt

at

imi

tating Earl Scruggs or other bluegrass
banjo-pickers; though I was certainly
impressed
I

their

by

wasn't what

I

it

virtuosity,

start going occasionally

did

just

was looking for.
the

to

ASDG square-dances and I met Woody
Wachtel, Joe Bossom, and Stu Jamieson,
but, though I may have learned a few

"

and two on On the Great Divide: "The

In

Congress, so
too,

I

and heard

began listening to those,
some other great banjo

pickers, like Wade Ward.

"Pretty Polly"
Love

of Polly

"Little

the NLCR.

one-beat note picked
PICKdownward on the fifth string:

brush-thumb

PICK-brush-thumb

PICK-brush- thumb
tern for numbers
the

a

four-beat pat

4/4 time. For
3/4 time, one just doubled
PICK"brush-thumb"
part:

numbers

in

2/4

or

in

brush- thumb -brush- thumb-- PICKbrush- thumb-brush-thumb-- -PICK-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and Jack
I

1,

Monroe" and
was

was doing and got about 50% of it and
was able to use it here and there with
Later on while

friends Peter and Polly Gott
North Carolina

I

their

George

neighbor

got

a

on

Art of Field Recording

many-volume

Digital label. While

the Dust
pro
fessor of art at the University of Iowa,
he was a founding member of the Iowa
Friends of Old Time Music and the Fid
dler's Picnic. His recordings are part of
Electra's Folk Banjo Styles and Meadowland's LP of traditional fiddle and banjo
duets with Iowa City fiddler A1 Murphy.
His publications include two instruction
books: Old-Time Mountain Banjo and Art
of the Mountain Banjo. Art Rosenbaum
writes of his learning to play:
to

a

first from hear
ing my working-class grandmother and
my middle-class father singing at home,
then from listening to the Almanac
my
Singers' 78s of labor union songs
first exposure, through Pete Seeger' s
playing, to the five-string banjo. Wliile
in high school I icon a $25 first prize for
painting in the Junior Student Division
I

became

kid folkie,

a

of the Art Exhibit at the Indiana State
Fair and spent the money on a Stadiumbrand banjo and learned the basics from

Pete

Seeger'

How

s

to

Five-

the

Play

String Banjo.

However, after seeing Pete Seeger in a
1956 concert at Columbia University and
hearing his version of Pete Steele's Coal
Creek March Art followed Pete's advice
of "don't learn from me, learn from the
folks I learned from." Very soon after this

advice Art began making his first field
recordings in 1956.

still like his style

the best. Way back in the '60s I tried my
to figure out on my own what he

(picked upward with the index finger),
a
one-beat downward brush with the
a

Rural Delivery No.

Satchel." My inspiration

Initially, my banjo-picking
using the "Pete Seeger strum," a repeat
ed pattern consisting of a two-beat note

middle finger and

on

clearly Ralph Stanley,
best

ivas all done

playing. He has produced and
annotated over twenty LPs, recently the

is

September 1945, I started at CCNY.
Eventually, I discovered that the library
there had records from the Library of

various

style" while accompanying
(Hawker's)
singing.
Ginny's
Art Rosenbaum, born in 1938, came
bit after Tom Paley but was yet an

other early urban pioneer of old-time

learned banjo in a different way, in a
style sometimes referred to as "Schwarz
Style." When I asked Tracy about that
style, he wrote to me:

Schwarz-style" really is. I can think of
three NLCR (New Lost City Ramblers)
recordings that best display this style:

by

a

used some

banjo

is a

old-time musicians
(Macon, the Carters, Tanner, Monroe
Brothers, Dixon Brothers, Mainers, etc).
records

a

combination of many influences.
Tracy Schwarz, later to replace Tom
Paley in the New Lost City Ramblers,

kind of murky at
My banjo history
this stage of life. I'm not at all sure what

I

slack-key

songs or tunes from them, they weren't
a serious
influence on my playing. I'd
overall,
that,
my banjo-picking isn't
say
really based on any one model, but

don't even have

I

of what I had learned on banjo to work
out playing guitar in "Appalachian

with the middle finger, instead of upward
with the index finger.

Aside from

save my life and

to

working banjo). Ultimately

visiting my
in

Western

crash course in

Landers'

two-

finger style of picking that intrigued me
by its similarity with Scruggs picking,
yet easy application to old-time songs.
'70s
the
mid
Sometime after that
I was
kidnapped by Cajun ac
which
hastened
cordion,
my loss of banjo
a
can't
do
(I
Scruggs roll now
ability

Ray Alden is
past 38 years,

a

banjo player who,
has

over

the

old-time music
Virginia, West Vir

collected

North

Carolina,
ginia, Kentucky, and Tennessee. In addition,
he has befriended many of the younger banjo
players in the old-time music revival. Cur

from

rently

he has

been, along with other

collec

part of the
Field Recorders' Collective. See their website
tors, issuing field

at

continued: Part

II

of "Trends

in

Old-

Five-String Banjo Playing" will appear
the next issue of the Old-Time Herald.

Time
in

as

www.fieldrecorder.com
To be

perhaps--

recordings

�\j
1

/I

1

1

I

1

1

1

wi

\m

1ST KYLE CREED BANJO SHOW
Saturday, September 12th, 2009, llam-lOpm
Stringbean Coffee Shop
215 South Main St.

I

1

1

1)/

I

II

11

IN

GALAX, VIRGINIA

We're trying to get all the banjos Kyle

made together. If banjos are not able
to be

there in person,

a

picture and

description (such as banjo number,
year made, scale length) would be
great. Also, remember to include the
story on how you got your Kyle banjo.
These materials will be on display at
the show.

Sponsored by:

Kevin Fore of Round Peak Banjos,
Lowgap, NC,
Bobby Patterson of The Heritage Shop
&amp;? Heritage Records, Woodlawn,
VA,
The Old-Time Herald, Durham, NC

information contact Kevin Fore at (336) 352-4342, or roundpeakmusic Section with Illegible Text
send banjo information to Kevin Fore, 6824 West Pine Street, Lowgap, NC 27024

For more
or

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�LILY MAY LEDFORD:

COON CREEK GIRL

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

of

Cari

Norris

By Richard Matteson

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

May Ledford was born on March 17, 1917, on a ten
ant farm in a remote area of Kentucky called Red River
Gorge. "I was the seventh child of a family of ten boys and
four girls," wrote Lily May in her autobiography. "Four
died shortly after birth, leaving ten of us and an orphaned cousin."
When not helping out on the farm, the Ledford children fought
over the family banjo, which was made out of green hickory with a

Lily

stretched groundhog-hide head.
"I was about seven years of age at this time and I was dying to get
my hands on that banjo," she recalled, "but my brothers, who were
always fighting for possession of it all the time, would hang it clear
to the top of the wall. And of course as soon as they were out of the
house I would drag a table up to the wall and put a chair on it and
take the banjo, and get away up on a hill and behind a big rock to
escape Mama and the chores, and play 'til it was time for the boys
to come home."
She learned songs from her older brother Kelly, who took the
family banjo with him when he went to work in the mines in Pike
County. Her grandfather, Will Ledford, born on December 13, 1836,
in Harlan, Kentucky, was a well-known left-handed old-time fid
dler. Her father was also an accomplished musician, playing banjo,
guitar, and fiddle, as well as hymns on the pump organ.
Lily's father, Daw "White" Ledford, was the eighth of ten chil
dren, born on Nov 23, 1882. He was the fourth generation of Ledfords born in Kentucky. He married Stella May Tackett about 1907.
White Ledford was a gifted musician who fiddled such tunes as
"Lop-eared Mule," "What'll I Do With the Baby-O," "Arkansas
Traveler," and "Stoney Point," tunes learned from his father.
then he would tune m the old chorded style (A tuning), recalled
Lily May, "and play 'Old Hen She Cackled,' 'Callahan,' and 'Hic
cup Oh Lordy.'" Although Lily May played the banjo, she excelled
a playing the fiddle. Her first fiddle bow was made from a willow
switch and a generous portion of the tail of Ole Maudie, her grand
father's white mare. "I wore his tail nearly out," recalled Lily May,
"from that bow tearing up and having to make another one."
"Then Papa would take the banjo and tune it up in E tuning and
using what is now called the frail style he would pick 'John Henry,'
and make it sound so lonesome you would about cry," she said.
A few of his other pieces were "Little Corey," "Train Off the Track
(Reuben's Train)" "Georgie Allen," "John Hardy," "Old Joe Clark,"
"Sourwood Mountain," "Here Rattler Here," "Free Little Bird,"
"Little Birdie," "Walk Johnnie Booker," "Darlin' Six Months Ain't
Long," "Hawk Got a Chicken and Gone," "Cripple Creek," and
"Spanish Fandango."
These were the songs that Lily May listened to in the 1920s, many
of which had been kicking around the Red River Gorge region for
years. Her mother, Stella May, knew some of the old ballads, in
cluding "Barbara Allen," "The Soldier and the Lady," The Brown
Girl," "Omie Wise," "Little Benny," "The Thorny Desert" and a reli
gious song called "The White Pilgrim."

�On the Radio: John Lair
May, by her own account, was
dreamy child who would rather be
"drawing pictures and painting with col
ors" or playing the fiddle than doing her
chores or studying. She wasn't afraid of
hard work but her natural talent led her
to music. An accomplished fiddler by the
time she was fourteen, she had formed a
band called the Red River Ramblers with
her brother Coyen and sister Rosie, plus
Lily

a

Morgan Skid more on gui
Another neighbor had a phonograph,
and Lily May learned country songs by

her neighbor
tar.

the Skillet Lickers, the Carter Family, Jimmie Rodgers, and the Delmore Brothers.
The Red River Ramblers either walked
or were taken to nearby fiddle contests,

usually winning the band competitions,
and

Coyen and Lily May taking turns

winning the fiddle contests. They also
played square dances and occasionally
busked near the Natural Bridge. "We'd

pass the hat," said Lily May. "Sometimes
it'd come back with as much as 50 cents or
a dollar. Sometimes we'd lose the hat."

Around 1935 relatives of guitarist Mor
gan Skidmore were so taken with the
Ramblers that they moved the group
into

their home

in

Rochester,

Indiana.

They arranged "auditions at radio sta
tions in Indianapolis, Fort Wayne, and

finally WLS Chicago, where Mr. John
Lair was music librarian and managed
talent on the side."
John Lair was born on July 1, 1894, in
Rockcastle County, Kentucky. His fa
ther was a farmer and Lair attended a
one-room school before going on to fin
ish high school in the county seat town
of Mount Vernon. After Army service in
World War I, he worked in a variety of
jobs that included teaching school and

editing

a

small-town newspaper. Work

insurance claims adjuster brought
him to Chicago in the late 1920s, where
he became interested in radio.
He was able to find work for early Ken
tucky country music performers such as
as an

Lair

Collection,
Berea College Southern Appalachian

Red Foley and the duo of Karl and Harty
on the WLS National Barn Dance, and

eventually was employed by WLS

Archive

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

John Lair in the 1930s while at WLS.

as

a

producer, emcee, and music librarian.
As Lair became interested in discovering
the real-life events upon which old songs
were based, he began accumulating a
large sheet music collection and gained a
reputation as an authority on folk music.
John Lair "seemed immensely pleased"
with the Ramblers, but "said he only had
and that was
room for one performer"

�Archive
Appalachian

Southern
College
Berea
Collection,
Lair

Lair in the 1930s while at WLS, with fan mail for him and the performers associated

Lily May. At that time WLS Barn Dance
was one of the most popular radio shows
in the country, featuring such groups
as Lulu Belle and Scotty Wiseman, the
Hoosier Hotshots, the Prairie Ramblers,
Patsy Montana and the Girls of the Gold
en West, and Red Foley. Lair still had to
convince WLS program director Howard

Safford to hire Lily May, so he arranged
a fiddle contest several weeks later near

home Mt. Vernon, Kentucky, and
Howard agreed to attend.
"I won easily," recalled Lily May, "and
Mr. Safford was so pleased he offered me
a contract that day." John Lair had already
advised Lily May not to sign with the

his

WLS Barn Dance, as he had other plans
for her. He was planning his own barn

dance and offered her

a

five-year con

tract. Since she was only 19, Lily May's
parents agreed to sign the five-year con
tract Lair offered

if he

promised

to let her

stay with his wife and family and pro
vide transportation to the station.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with him.

Being from Kentucky, Lair "talked like us,"
said Lily May. "I trusted him." He sent her
five dollars to seal the deal and to help with
the cost of coming to Chicago, where he

a regular spot on the Na
tional Barn Dance. To help pay for her trip
to Chicago, Lily May's father sold a hog,
and she took a job digging ditches in the
gorge. The men wanted to sign her on as a
water bov but dieeine ditches paid more.
When Lily May moved to Chicago to ap
pear on WLS in 1936, John Lair was her
business manager, protector, and advisor.
She stayed with the Lairs, then moved
into a room nearby, which she rented
from his minister. Not only was Lair plan
ning to include Lily May in his own future
Barn Dance radio show in Cincinnati, but

had landed her

he

wanted

to

organize

an

all-girl string

band around

her. For his efforts

her work and

building her career, Lair re

finding

ceived 20% of what Lily made.
"One day Mr. Lair asked me if I ever
fooled around with a five-string banjo,"

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Archive

Appalachian
Southern
College
Berea
Collection,

Ledford

WLS program magazine,

Stand By!, October,

recalled Lily May. "I told him I used to
long ago, [so] he borrowed Scotty Wise
man's banjo and I tuned it up and picked
'John

Henry.'

Mr.

Lair

and

everybody

gathered around and cheered me on. I
played several pieces and Mr. Lair said,
'You stay on that banjo from now on.'"
On Lair's

suggestion she purchased her

Vega, and made friends with
Ernie Newton, the Hilltoppers, George
Goebel, and Patsy Montana and the Girls
of the Golden West. John Lair loved the
first banjo,

a

traditional

culture he knew so well in
Kentucky. Wary of how Lily May would
adjust to the city life in Chicago he ad
vised, "Stay a mountain girl, just like you
were when you came here. Be genuine
and plain at all times."
Lily May became a popular performer
on WLS National Barn Dance after her
debut in September 1936. Lair continued

promote her mountain girl image, from
the twang of her voice to her wholesome
good looks. Stand By! Magazine told her
to

fans even more about her mountain home

In 1937 Stand By! started a
comic strip entitled Lily May, Mountain
Gal, which depicted her much as her

and lifestyle.

Dogpatch counterpart Daisy Mae
1934 L'il Abner strip:

in the

well-endowed but

barefoot, with beautiful hair.
Lily May's first band at WLS was called
the Pine Mountain Merry Makers, and

featured Lily on banjo with Red Foley
and Girls of the Golden West Dolly and
Millie Good. Lily May finally got her
own apartment, and sent for her sister

10, 1936.

Rosie to join her in Chicago. The two sis
ters

performed together sometimes.

In the fall of 1937 John Lair joined forces
with Red Foley, Duke of Paducah Whitey

Ford, and Chicago advertising executive
Freeman Keyes to launch the Renfro Val
ley Barn Dance, which broadcast from
Cincinnati over WLW. The Renfro Valley
Barn Dance was named after John and
Lula Renfro, the first settlers in Lair's Ken
tucky home area in Rockcastle County.
Lily May, Dolly and Millie Good, and Red
Foley were some of the stars that moved
with Lair to Cincinnati, and he also added
the Duke of Paducah and A'nt Idy (with
Little Clifford) to his show. Lair was trying
to recreate the music found in his Kentucky
homeland instead of the Western and cow
boy trends that had recently become popu
lar on the WLS Barn Dance.

Coon Creek Girls
In Cincinnati Lily May and Rosie met the
two girls Lair wanted them to play with:
guitarist and mandolinist Ester KoeJiler, a
contest winner from Ohio, and fiddler and
bass player Evelyn Lange, another contest

winner from Wisconsin. The girls practiced
for

a

while, and picked the song "You Are

Flower Blooming in the Wildwood" as
a theme.
They changed Ester's name to
Violet and Evelyn's name to Daisy, so they
would all have names of flowers.
They decided to call themselves "The
Wildwood Flowers," but John Lair had a
a

different idea. He said "What about

a

more

�Archive

Appalachian
Southern
College
Berea
Collection,
Ledford

The Coon Creek Girls: Esther

Violet" Koehler, Charlotte
and "Daisy" Lange, Cincinnati 1937-1938.

country name: The Coon Creek Girls?" Even
though none of the girls came from Coon
Creek, they became the Coon Creek Girls
"so that people will know at once what kind
of music they're going to heai;" said Lair.

The group made its broadcast debut on
October 9, 1937. "As far as I know, we
were the first all-girl string band," re
called Lily May, now nicknamed Banjo
Pickin' Girl. After the Coon Creek Girls
started performing, "we

began to catch on like
wildfire," Ledford said.
"We were writing songs
and

writing

"Rosie"Ledford, Lily May Ledford, Evelyn

later that year. Lair included the Coon
Creek Girls and Red Foley on the festival
roster. On March 27, 1938, the Ohio Val
ley Folk Festival, sponsored by WCKY,
was held in the Cincinnati Music Hall.
The Library of Congress dispatched Alan
Lomax to record the event. The Coon

Creek Girls made important connections
with Lunsford and Lomax, who would
help them later in the year to land an in
vitation to perform at the
White House.
According to a Wash
ington Post report, with
an

poetry

and answering our fan
mail
we
got bushel
baskets of mail. People

were lining up for our
show.
started
They
babies
after
us
naming
and farm animals after us."
While the girls were busy performing
and doing various radio shows, another
important old-time player entered the

picture. John Lair met banjoist Bascom La
mar Lunford at a folk festival in Asheville,
North Carolina. When Lunsford attended
the National

Folk Festival in Chicago in

1937 he visited with Lair in Chicago. Lair

was attending because he was appointed
to the Board of the National Folk Festival
by director Gertrude Knott as "a student
of the

of folk music." Lair asked

origins
Lunsford to find

talent for WLW and
teach square dancing to various clubs in
the Ohio valley. Lunsford also performed
on WLW's Saturday night concerts.
Knott asked Lair and Lunsford to orga
nize the Ohio Valley Folk Festival to find
talent for the next National Folk Festival,
which was to be held in Washington, DC,

Above
Lair

John Lair and Bascom Lamar Lunsford.

Collection, Berea College Southern Appalachian Archive

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

accompanying

of the band,

photo

"These Ken

mountain
tucky
girls
make up one of the win
ning teams from the Ohio

Festival held in
Cincinnati in preparation
for the National Festival. Each plays all
Valley

four instruments in the picture and sings
ballads known in their families for gen
erations."

In early May the National Folk Festival
was held for the first time, at Constitution
Hall in Washington, DC. The Coon Creek
Girls and Robert Day, accompanied by

John Lair, made the trip, financed by a
mere $92 from the Ohio Valley Festival.
The Coon Creek Girls played on

WCKY as well as WLW, which now
featured other groups like "Hugh
Cross's great band, Novelty Aces,
Merle Travis, and Range Riders." The
Renfro Valley Barn Dance was moved
briefly to Dayton, Ohio, as Lair was
preparing for the move to Renfro Val

Kentucky, by building a large per
formance complex there with partners
Whitey Ford and Red Foley.
ley,

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Norris
Cari
of
courtesy

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

First Record, and
a Visit to The White House
In late May 1938, Lair went the girls
and A'nt Idy Harper to record their first

session

with Vocalion Records under
Uncle Art Satherley. They recorded nine
songs, including "Little Birdie," "Pretty
Polly" and two of John Lair's songs. At
this session they also recorded the song
that Lily May was identified with: "Banjo

Pickin'Girl." The Girls also backed two
songs by A'nt Idy Harper.
Through Lunsford, who knew the First
Lady Eleanor Roosevelt from the 1933
White Top Festival, and Alan Lomax,
the Girls were extended an invitation
to perform at a White House concert for
President and Mrs. Roosevelt in honor
of King George VI and Queen Elizabeth,
who were to visit in June 1939.
Mrs. Roosevelt decided the concert
would show a cross-section of American
music. Bascom Lamar Lunsford and his
square dancing group was invited, along
with Marian Anderson, opera baritone
Lawrence Tibbet, pop singer Kate Smith,
Alan Lomax, and the Coon Creek Girls.
Members of local black churches formed
gospel choir to sing spirituals.
John Lair was not invited, but he and
his wife accompanied the Coon Creek
Girls to Washington to attend this pres
tigious event. After arriving several days
before the June 8 performance, Lily May
recalled, "The day of the concert we went
over for an early rehearsal. We went
through the material we were going to
a

do that night.

gentleman came

A

distinguished
to the

looking

door and listened

for a while. Then he asked how long I'd
been playing and I said, "I've been play
ing a long time." He said he played a
little and asked if he could play with us.
Then he said, 'I'll get my fiddle.'"
/\rter getting nis ncicue ne introduced
himself as Cactus Jack, so that's what I
called him. We went to another room.

He would play a tune then I'd play one.
Then we'd both play one together. This
went on for quite some time. We barely
made it out in time for the show." Later
John Lair told Lily May that Cactus Jack
was in fact Vice President John Nance
Garner, a pretty fair country fiddler.
Each performer was scheduled to do three
songs, plus the Coon Creek Girls would
play fiddle tunes for Lunsford's square
dance group. On the evening of June 8,
1939, limousines began to deliver members
of Washington, DC, High society to the East
Room of tire White House. Security was

�tight. John Lair, who

wasn't

invited,

fol

lowed the Girls' limousine with his wife in
their

car.

The only way he could get in was
fiddle for the Girls.

to carry the bass

on Renfro Valley he was boss,"
explained Lily May. "So here we were,
the stars, with him behind us toting the
"Well,

big bass fiddle. Security stopped him and
searched the pockets of the case, shook
the bass fiddle and looked inside the fid

decided

dle. They finally

in, but they
"We were

to let Mr.

Lair

turned his wife away."
ushered up there while Alan

Lomax was playing Iris final song, 'Old
Chisolm Trail,"' said Lily May. "We ran
out there and lit right in to 'How Many
Biscuits Can You Eat.' That was the song
they told us Mrs. Roosevelt wanted. I
glanced out of the corner of my eye and
right down there they were. .the King and
Queen in the front row. Why they were so
close you could have spit on 'em."
Lily May continued, "The king had rath
er

a

long-faced, dour, deadpan look, and

he worried me

little. Then as I glanced
him
down, caught
patting his foot, ever
so little, and I knew we had him."
The Coon Creek Girls played another
FDR favorite, "Get Along Miss Cindy"
a

I

as

well

as

an

English ballad, "The Sol

dier and the Lady," in honor of the royal
couple. They also played "Buffalo Gals"
for Lunsford's square dance group from

North Carolina.

After the White House concert the Coon
Creek Girls reached new heights of popu
larity, and were even booked by a New
York agent to do

a

two-week show open

ing for Orson Wells' play "The Green God
dess" in Pittsburgh. This odd combination

happened

in the same year Wells

his flying saucer hoax on the radio.

pulled

Move to Renfro Valley Kentucky,
"where time stands still"
By

November

1939

and

Lair

completed

construction was
moved the Ren

fro Valley Barn Dance Show to its final
home in Renfro Valley, Kentucky. On the
grounds he built cabins, a restaurant (the

lodge) with Southern home-style meals,
a souvenir
shop, a candy kitchen, a barn
for performances, and a country store.
Not everyone in the Renfro Valley Barn
Dance Show wanted to move to a remote
area in Kentucky. Lair's original partners
Red Foley and Whitey Ford didn't stay
long. They sold their interests and went
back to WLS Chicago. Another star, A'nt
Idy, wouldn't go at first, and then only
stayed a short while.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The original Coon Creek Girls split up.
Daisy and Violet went with the Callahan

Brothers, Howdy Forester, and Georgia
Slim to Tulsa and then to Dallas. Accord
ing to Daisy, they were ready for a taste
of

"big

city

meanwhile,
sister

to

life."

added

Lily

their act,

"Black-eyed Susie"

a

May and

Rosie,

younger Ledford

Minnie (stage name

"Susie" for short),
and continued as the Coon Creek Girls.
To replace some of the talent he lost, Lair
hired two of the best musicians and co
or

medians

of the Barn Dance era, Homer
and Jethro.
From the first Saturday night the ven
ture was a moderate success. In spite of

dire

predictions and

onset of winter,

Lair

moving

at the

the crowds

got bigger
and bigger. Radio experts who had held
that

miles

people wouldn't drive

a

hundred

more to see a barn dance out
in the country were amazed. All winter
long the crowds kept coming from great
or

distances, and when spring brought ide
al traveling weather, all roads seemed to
lead to Renfro Valley. License plates from
as many as fifteen different states were
found on a single Saturday night.
Lair's dream had come true, much to the

appreciation of the audience members who
filled tire auditorium, and the many thou

sands of radio listeners. Lair served as em

cee and guided tire program, song by song,
week by week, as it was broadcast on radio

station WHAS in Louisville. After the de

parture of partners Red Foley and Whitey
Ford, Lair now controlled every facet of tire
performers' professional lives
"John Lair, once he moved to Renfro
Valley," said Lily's daughter Barbara
Greenlief in a 1996 interview, "had them
sign contracts that they couldn't record
anything unless he said so; they couldn't
talk to other people, they couldn't make
the contracts
any other deals. mean he
were just he owned them."
The barn could comfortably hold about
I

Some weekends thousands
would flock to the small valley. The two
scheduled shows on a Saturday night
could not accommodate everyone. "They
800 people.

(Shorty Hobbs and Little Elder Long)
and the Homer and Jethro team simply
tore up the stage encore after encore,"
recalled Lily May. "Crowds started flock
ing in the barn at 5:00 or 6:00 and they

were doing shows 'til the roosters were
crowing at daybreak."
In the early days of Renfro, John Lair
had his shows broadcast on national ra
dio every day of the week. The programs
were the only shows to come directly

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Archive
College

Southern

Appalachian

Molly O'Day.

Berea

Holden, and Ernie Lee; (middle) Shorty Hobbs, Red
Herron; (front) Little Eller Long (Beth Cremer),
Ruby and Ruth (Hilgerson) and the Travis Twins,

Collection,

WHAS studios, February 3, 1943, in Louisville.
are (back) Slim Miller, Lynn Davis, Jack
Holden, Brownie Reynolds, Jerry Behrens,Fai rley

Pictured

Lair

John Lair with Renfro Valley Barn Dance cast in

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Archive

Appalachian
Southern
College
Berea
Collection,
Ledford

Coon Creek Girls on stage at the barn theater in Renfro
Valley, early 1940s, l-r Minnie "Black Eyed
Susan" Ledford, Lily May Ledford, Charlotte "Rosie" Ledford, Bertha
Amburgey.

from

a

real

community

and

presented

mostly by actual residents of that com
munity. There was no regular broadcast

ing studio. All shows were performed at
the barn, old log schoolhouse, and the
lodge. Lily May Ledford and the Coon
Creek Girls had their own half-hour
weekly radio show at the little Redbud
school. After World War II began, the

"Sunday Gatherin'" was broadcast with
John Lair's song "Take me Back to Renfro
Valley" as the theme.
During this time, Lily May married
Curt Pearson after a four-month court
ship, and they lived in Curt's parents'
house. Hoping to save a marriage that
quickly became troubled,
Lily May
and Curt had

a

child, Benjamin Joseph

("Benny Joe") on May 16, 1943. Their
union did not last, as Curt took no inter
est in Lily and his son,

going out

while frequently

night. "When Benny Joe
was nine moths old I took my baby and
fled to friends and my sister Rosie's 'til
a divorce could be
brought about," said
at

Lily May in her autobiography.

"She

was the main act

ley, you know,"

at Renfro Val
said Barbara Greenlief,

"whenever she performed, or whenever
they performed, they were the main act.
It was a
being able to hold the audience in
your hand kind of thing. And so, I think
she loved the music, but I think even
more than that, she loved that capturing
the

audience and knowing that she had

the power to do that, you know. That just

really was wonderful for her, because she
couldn't do it any other time."
Lily kept working and bought a house in
Mount Vernon. "I was finding life hard in

many ways by now," said Lily May. While
her brothers went overseas to fight in the
struggled to keep the Coon
Creek Girls going. "For several years the
Coon Creek act was touch and go, being
shattered again and again by pregnancies
or illnesses. We were losing prestige and
fading from the radio little by little."
War, Lily May

Around 1946 Lily May "remarried a
returning soldier who had sung bass in
a
gospel quartet." Glenn Pennington be
came the father of her next three children,

�Archive

Appalachian
Southern
College
Berea
Collection,
Ledford

Lily May Ledford, and Charlotte

"Rosie" Ledford

Barbara, Jimmy and Bobby. Glenn

even

tually became the Master of Ceremonies
(emcee) at Renfro Valley and managed
several touring groups.
Barbara Greenlief recalled, "The only
time Mom was truly happy was when
she was playing, or when she was going
to play, and when she was
collaborating
with people about the next show."
Lily May appeared by herself in the
Alan Lomax ballad opera "The Martins

and the Coys" in 1944. A once-in-a-lifetime cast featured Will Geer, Woody
Guthrie, Burl Ives, Lily May Ledford,

Pete

Seeger, Fiddlin' Arthur Smith,
Hally Wood. In the early 1950s
Lily May was again featured this time
with the Coon Creek Girls in Lomax's
mountain ballad opera "The Old Chisholm Trail" in New York. This time
Cisco Houston and Wade Mainer and
his Mountaineers were added to the
and

star-studded line-up.
mid-1950s

was quickly re
placing radio as America's top form of
By

the

TV

entertainment. Sponsors

began pulling

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at

Renfro Valley, early 1950s.

out of the Renfro Valley Barn Dance. "An
unhappiness had set in," recalled Lily
May, "and we yearned for the first great

plenty of shows, hun
dreds of thousands of paying guests, the
horse races, ball games and mule races
(which I rode once for fun)."
One of the last big shows the Coon Creek
Girls did was Sunshine Sue's Old Domin
ion Barn Dance, which went to Broadway in
1944-45. Needing a banjo player, Sunshine
Sue hired Lily May, and the Girls headed to
New York where they shared the bill with
Flatt and Scruggs' Foggy Mountain
Boys
and met Ralph Rinzler, who was there at
tending Columbia University.
years of Renfro,

Coon Creek Girls Leave Renfro Valley
1957

Glenn

Pennington was very
busy with his car dealership. After he
In

left the show, Rosie and Lily May
finally
called it quits. The Coon Creek Girls dis

banded

after nearly 20 years at Renfro
with
John Lair. Lily May remained
Valley

active in her children's

lives but was

lost without her music outlet. Things at
home were hard for her, and she felt it
necessary to leave her husband to help
her son. "I divorced when my youngest
(Bobby) was 13 and his need of special

education brought

us to

Lexington, Ken

tucky," she said.
Early in 1968, Lily May was paid a visit
by her old friend and now festival orga
nizer Ralph Rinzler, who invited her and
her sisters to play the July 1968 National
Folk Festival in Newport, Rhode Island.

Susie had broken an arm, but Lily and
Rosie went and found they were very en

thusiastically received by the mostly col
lege-age audience. This was a very differ
ent experience for the sisters, as Renfro
audiences had been mostly composed of
"older folks and farm boys and girls."

According

to Cari

Norris,

At this point, college kids were
taking
an interest in folk traditions and were

interested
This

in

second phase
in

learning how

festival marked
in

the

to

play

it.

beginning of

a

Lily May's career, one

which she graduated rightfully from

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Archive

Appalachian
Southern
College
Berea
Collection,

Ledford

Lily May Ledford at the Berea College Celebration of Traditional Music, 1979.

status of 'hillbilly entertainer' to
'traditional artist.' Charles Faurot and
Dave Freeman from County Records
the

western tour with the Red Clay Ram
while in Seattle, re-

blers in 1979, and

Lexington, recorded the sisters,
and released an album. Mamaw played

:orded an album for Voyager Records,
which was later released on the Greenas Banjo Pickin' Girl. She
nays label

few of the festivals with her sisters,
but Rosie became ill, and Susie moved

:o,

came

to

a

to

Mamaw

Florida.

took

to

the

stage

solo, and though uncertain at first
about going it alone, found that she
could indeed handle
In order

to

it, and with style.
the pace a little and

slow

'rest,' she began telling stories between
songs, and this feature of her perform
ing

later years

in

became an integral

part of her artistry.

"Mamaw

came

to

be

recognized

and

appreciated for her true artistry," said
granddaughter Cari Norris. "She knew
it and
felt it
without slick emcees,
without hokey costumes, just direct and
by doing it the way she wanted."
After the 1968 Newport Festival, Lily
May played the Smithsonian Festival
1971

Festival"

blayed the Mariposa Festival in Toronand festivals, colleges, and universi-

:ies

throughout Kentucky.

Cari Norris says,
Early in 1979 Loyal Jones received

a

National Endowment for
grant
the Arts for Mamaw to do a five-month
residency there, giving banjo and fiddle
workshops, convocations, and ballad
and story classes. During this time, an
hour-long radio broadcast featuring in
terviews and stories with Lily May, and
from the

early and late recordings, was narrated
by Ellesa Clay High and broadcast on

Later Life

in

a

and the "Man and His World
in Montreal in 1972. She did

National Public Radio.

Additionally, with part of

the

grant
College published an
of Mamaw's longer auto

Berea

money,
edited form

biography, which she worked on dur
ing the late '70s. Though slowed by
diabetes and rheumatoid arthritis, this
was clearly a joyous conclusion to a
long career in old-time music. Ma
maw continued to perform until 1983,

�she would literally rock and sing to me
for hours before bedtime. I absorbed a
lot of her songs that way and especially
the feel, inflection and emotional tone of

those songs in a very intimate way. Later,
when I did start playing and singing, as a
teenager, that music was still very much
in my being. ..I learned from her in the
sense that her singing and talking and
playing became part of me because I ex

perienced

Archive
Appalachian

Southern
College
Berea
Collection,
Ledford

ill with lung cancer.
1985, shortly before her death, she
was awarded the highest honor given to
traditional artists in this country, the

thologies from Rounder Records (Banjo
Pickin' Girl) and a Time Life Country
and Western Classics boxed set called

John Lair spent the rest of his years in
the home he had built for himself and

Coon Creek Girls. Gems: Lily May Led
ford is a new release available on June

the music he loved at Renfro Valley. He
remained at the helm and surprisingly

Appal. This striking collection of songs,
instrumental and stories showcases her
natural talent and honest humor.

ivhen she became

In

National Heritage Award.

active up until his death at the age of 91
in 1985. The Renfro Valley Barn Dance

The Women (TLCW02)

contain rare and

previously unissued selections from the

Lily May's children were all given the gift
of music by their parents. J.P. Pennington

still thriving, just off 1-75 at exit 62,
filling their newly rebuilt entertain
ment complex with a variety of events,
year round. (For information call 1-800765-7464.) Today the New Coon Creek

was a founding member of the liighly suc
cessful country-pop group Exile, which
had a number-one hit in 1978. His original
songs have been recorded by such groups

Girls,

as

is

formed in the late 1970s, are
carrying on the tradition. Lily May al
lowed the use of the name and helped

the group by
on playing.

giving

it

songs and tips

or tne ^.oon v-reex uiris
available on a re-issue LP from Old
Homestead entitled Early Radio Fa
vorites (OHCS-142). Avid fans and col
lectors might locate out-of-print issues

Kecorcungs

are

featuring Lily May and Rosie Ledford
(County 712) or a solo recording by Lily
May on Voyager recorded

in 1979.

An

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Alabama. Another son, Bob Pennington,
played drums and keyboards in the Renfro
Valley Band. Her daughter,

Barbara

Ann

Greenlief of Nicholasville, has performed
with a traditional music group. Lily May
Ledford's

Louisville,

granddaughter, Cari Norris of
Kentucky plays clawhammer

style on Lily May's banjo.
Cari has felt Lily May's guiding spirit
the most in a way that only can be under

stood through family ties.
I didn't
play with her, but I spent
of time with her as a small child

a

hurt either!
Her playing is very much a part of
my banjo playing. She had an incred
ibly strong sense of steady rhythm and
_

Lily May Ledford. early 1980s

often at an early age. We

it so

deep connection from the
beginning.. .things like that are a mystery,
but my ears were very receptive to her
music and the musicality of her speech...
She was also very affectionate, funny,
and warm with me-- of course that didn't
also shared

also patted her foot forcefully along
with the playing-- that rhythm is some

where

I
hope. Also, she
feel
for the essential
really great
melody-- she didn't add what didn't
need to be there-- her music was direct-

had

in my

playing,

a

-she often went for emotional content
over fancy licks-- I really appreciate
that about her, and hope I picked up

some of that. Also, she had a very com
plex sense of rhythm --that's a very
difficult thing to explain-- but I think
African influences are present in her
I have
I think
something
feel for that too.
Lily May Ledford toured the West and
Canada in 1976 as part of the Old-Time
Music Festival organized by John Oil
man and Mike Seeger. (Other perform

playing, and
of

a

ers
and

included
drum

lot
and

and John Jackson.

a

fife

Lily

May wrote of this experience, "Boys and
girls came to the stage saying, 'You're so
traditional so traditional.' How did
they know? It was very evident they felt
my old-fashioned

music deeply and I
could hardly keep from crying right on
stage sometimes. "Qg

L. Matteson Jr. is a
feature writer
and writes
WorldWideBluegrass.com
old-time and bluegrass books for Mel Bay
Publications including his last book, Bluegrass Picker's Tunebook. Matteson also
does paintings of old-time songs, which can
be viewed at MattesonArt.com.

Richard

for

Note: The quotes
a

Balfa Brothers,

the

trio,

in this

article are from Led

ford's unpublished autobiography, courtesy
of Cari Norris.

�CARTHY SISCO'S RUGGED ROAD:

FIDDLING THROUGH THE HARD TIMES
By Jeanie Murphy

I met
Carthy Sisco at a Washington
Time Fiddlers' Christmas party. A thin,
small-framed man, somewhat reticent until I
got to know him later, Carthy started in on

1987

InOld

his fiddle, and I found myself playing banjo
behind a cascade of bouncing, shuffling notes
that had a rhythmic economy, transforming
familiar tunes in new and wonderful ways.
Besides standards like "St. Anne's Reel" and

"Whiskey before Breakfast," Carthy seemed
to have an endless supply of tunes I'd never
heard before
wild gallops in G that had me
going up and down most of the banjo neck to
find the notes, punchy rags in C, squirrelly
little D tunes that seemed to fold in on them
selves, including one that started in F and
then went to D (Ron Hughey's "F and D"),
others entirely in F, others in B flat. I couldn't
make anything of his waltzes at that time,

some lugubrious, others with (for me) bewil
dering shifts of kev.
Local fiddler, guitarist, and proponent of
West Virginia tunes (originally from that
state) Jim Ketterman had been playing with
Carthy for some time. I began playing pretty
regularly with Jim and Carthy, driving over
to the small house in the woods of Gig Har
bor, where Carthy and his wife, Mary Beth,
had moved in 1974. It's old Craftsman style,

bright yellow, surrounded by lush
a broad
expanse of lawn,
which Carthy always keeps trimmed. Mary
painted
forest

a

but with

Beth passed away in 2005.
We would always go into the music room,
where fiddle contest trophies, stacks of tapes,
Mary Lou's considerable science fiction col

lection, and instruments, some made by Car
thy, all jostled up against one another. A wall
was dedicated to a huge bank of music ap
pliances, including a reel-to-reel tape player
and turntable for an astounding collection of
LPs, 78s, and tapes. (CDs are now creeping
in as well.) Carthy is always learning new
tunes, mostlv from this extensive librarv.
He has recorded one tape (no longer avail
able, but we hope to re-master it) and a CD for

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Robin

Wilson

Voyager
Carthy Sisco Rugged Road VRCD
362. In addition, he has appeared on various
WOTFA recordings made by the indefatiga
ble Stuart Williams, who also features him in
his wonderful book on Washington old-time
fiddlers, Roses in Winter.
Carthy

at his

87th birthday party.

�Carthy's Early Years
With his rhythmic
a

banjoist's dream of

playing,
a

fiddler.

Carthy
I

is

like to

is due to his clawhammerfather.
Born on August 17, 1921,
playing
in Carroll County, Arkansas, to George
and Mary Sisco, Carthy comes from a
background common in the Ozarks. His
father was born in Tennessee in 1889,
and later migrated to the better farmland
of Arkansas while still a child. Carthy's
mother, Mary Wright, came from an Eng
lish family and was born in 1901.
Settlers like Carthy's parents came to
the northwest corner of Arkansas as ear
ly as the 1820s because of all the "free"
land available. (Native Americans in
the area had been previously decimated
from European diseases and displaced
through an all-too-familiar series of duplicitous treaties and shifting alliances.)
Even today, many Siscos still live in the

think

area

this

around Berryville,

which

remains

the Carroll County seat.
Carthy's family had an 80-acre hill farm

tomatoes about 12 miles south
of Berryville. Life wasn't easy. Tomatoes
were the family's cash crop, but profit was
minimal. The Siscos would put out eight
to ten acres of tomatoes and then sell them
to nearby factories that canned them.
Carthy was the third oldest in a fam
ily with eleven children in all. Children
did much of the work and were hired
out to others
dropping plants off at
marker crosses in the field, then plant
of corn and

ing, thinning the plants, and eventually
plowing up the ground again. Carthy
notes that for all this hard work, his
family never seemed to make any kind
of profit, a deciding factor in his later
migration to the West Coast.
Carthy's Musical Beginnings

spite of all the hard work of running
farm, Carthy's father still had time for
music. While George Sisco mostly played
clawhammer style, he also did some twofinger picking that Carthy calls "fingertipping." He recalls that his father had a
"Silverline" (probably a Silvertone) from
Sears-Roebuck. These banjos were made
by contractors who worked for Sears, so
two people could order a banjo, but each
would be different when they arrived, a
point that fascinates Carthy. George Sisco
got one with 39 brackets and a fairly large
skin head. Carthy remembers the excite
ment of going with his father to the post
office to pick it up. His father didn't have
In

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

case, so he kept

it in a

instrument finally met

flour sack. The

its end years later

when some of his sons left it under a tree
and someone backed over it with a car.
All eleven children played something, or,
as Carthy puts it, were always "thumping
around." Banjo player Clarke Buehling
has told me that he used to play with Car
thy's siblings, A.J. and Troy, at music par
ties near Fayetteville at Round Mountain.
He notes

that A.J. picked a banjo with
but like a two-finger style.

three fingers

Troy played guitar and mandolin.
Because he was the first boy, Carthy says
his father started taking him to dances at

age three. As soon as the playing began,
Carthy would fall asleep to his father's
banjo and the fiddling of a man named

Delton Hitson.

At five, Carthy began making and

play

ing cornstalk fiddles, continuing until he
was about seven. He would saw across
the stalk and hum the tune while he

"played." But at seven, Carthy decided
that he wanted to play the banjo. His
father taught him to play clawhammer
style, and Carthy tried to play a few fid
dle tunes on it.
Carthy remembers his father playing
"Turkey in the Straw" and a song called
"Old Aunt Kate," something about "old
Aunt Kate she jumped in the bed and I
jumped in behind her." (It looks like this
version was not the more sanitized one
found in Ruth Seeger's American Folk
Songs for Children, but probably some
thing like the rowdier versions collected

Vance Randolph.) He also played
"Going Across the Sea" and "The Blue
bells of Scotland." This seems to be the
familiar "Across the Sea" or "Going'
Across the Sea" that was often played on
banjo and sung (notably by Uncle Dave
Macon among many others). It has been
found commonly in the repertoire of mu
sicians from eastern Kentucky and Ten
nessee, and, according to Mark Wilson,
was often found in Ozark regions where
Tennessee settlers had migrated, as had
Carthv's father.
Carthy adds that his father played for
himself, not for the children. Not only
this, but Carthy remembers that he want
ed to be able to get more of the notes in
a tune. With no other teachers of banjo
available, he has said, "I got frustrated
with the banjo
I couldn't
do what I
wanted to with it." This was all the more
provoking because someone who played
the style of banjo that Carthy liked lived
by

nearby.

Some

neighboring

brothers

Ramseys
just three to four miles
away played fiddle and finger-picked
banjo together. The banjo-playing broth
er had a three-finger style that Carthy
liked and has described as "...what Earl
Scruggs got the credit for. They were do
ing that way back when I was a kid. Some
the

old guys back in the hills there. Probably
never got 15 miles away from home all
their life."

The theme of isolation and frustration
looms large when Carthy talks about his
childhood. The Ramseys were not only
distant but disinclined to be gregarious.
Carthy associates this with other con

sequences

of

isolation, noting that win

ters were so bad that after trying to get
to school twice, he had to give up. The

were rough, and most people
didn't have cars. Much of Carthy's early
roads
life

sounds bleak, and

he has

little ap

parent nostalgia
People didn't get
much
to
together
play, he explains. The
small farms were so scattered that music
gatherings were rare.
Frustrated with the banjo and his inabil
for it.

to learn tunes, Carthy turned to the
fiddle. In one version of the story, he says
he (or his father) traded an old wagon for
a fiddle from the
Ramseys. In another ver
old phonograph with a
he
traded
an
sion,
schoolmate for his fiddle. In yet another
version, Iris father and three men had de
cided to can their own tomatoes and run
a
cannery. They wanted a boiler and went
to a store for one. When they got there,
they saw tlrree fiddles hanging on the
wall. Carthy's father got him the "best" of
the three for $5. Carthy was ten. He still

ity

has this fiddle, made in Germany.
Carthy's father did help him start

to

learn tunes, but Carthy doesn't remem
ber who first showed him how to tune

fiddle. He speculates that it must
have been a musical friend named Delton Hitson. He remembers making a little
chair out of a tomato crate for himself so
that he could sit on it to practice. He also

his

liked to sit outside on the family's well

cover and play.
Carthy's first tune on the fiddle was
"Coal Creek Mine." He only remembers
that it was about a disaster with some
one named Floyd Collins or someone

trapped in a mine somewhere and that he
heard it sung. From Carthy's description,
we think this is probably "The Death of
Floyd Collins," a song about a spelunker,
rather than "Coal Creek March" about

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the 1890 coal mining war in Anderson
County, Tennessee. Collins, a Kentuckian, was trapped in Sand Cave from Janu
ary 30 to February 16, 1925. Perhaps this
tune, which Carthy has now forgotten,
is related to Manon Campbell's "Coal
Creek," which Manon also learned to

play as

a

boy.

also transferred the four or five
banjo tunes he knew over to fiddle, along
with a tune called "Green Corn" ("Green
corn, green corn, get along John"). I think
it's important that even back then, Car
thy could take a tune from banjo or a
song he had heard and fit it to the fiddle.
He

This quality still

a
"Recording King," that he ordered
from the Montgomery Ward catalogue.
This seems to have been a big deal, a
new, modern sound to Carthy, who had

tar,

grown up on just fiddle and banjo.
In addition,
Carthy heard some re
corded music. Someone obtained a pho
nograph, so the family bought records
from Sears Roebuck, three for a dollar. In
the Sisco family, the children were giv
en turns choosing what records to buy.
Carthy says his first choice was Bill and
Charlie Monroe.
The Dances

shows up today when

learns tunes. No matter what the
source, he makes a tune his own, espe
cially through his rhythmic bowing shuf
fles. Often, these rhythms rejuvenate the
tune and offer a wonderful new vision
of it. Those of us who have played with
him have come to call this process "Carhe

thyizing." For example, Carthy greatly
admires Kenny Baker as a musician and
has learned many of his tunes, but it is as
if he has put them in an Ozarkian Peabody's Wayback Machine, making them
"old-time." I have wondered if Carthy
ever got over his early hunger for tunes,

watching him always learning and com

ing out with new tunes we have never
heard before.
Carthy describes the tunes he later
learned as a boy as "easy" or "standard"
tunes such as "Turkey in the Straw" or

"Soldier's Joy." Often, he says he would
just learn part of a tune, not the whole
thing. He would try to remember as
much of it as he could as soon as he got
home he would take his fiddle out but
usually he would only remember two to
three bars. He might hear the tune again
and get the rest, or he might never hear

could be years before he would get
the whole tune. And even then, old tunes
weren't popular with many at the time, so
it. It

for learning were scarce.
older
sisters played guitar and
Carthy's

opportunities

banjo to back him up, and the three of
them would sometimes play with a boy

named Claude Hitson (Delton's cousin),
who was only four years older than Car
thy. They would perform for very oc
casional school shows or for families
Carthy tells of one family that even got

out of bed late at night to hear him and
Claude play. The two of them had ridden
on horseback over to the house about
three miles away, Carthy riding behind
as he always did with Claude. Carthy es

pecially remembers Claude Hitson's gui

However, Carthy did have one great
venue for playing, and that was lo
cal dances. To this day, Carthy calls his
style "hoe-down" from hearing and later
playing tunes at dances. It informs his ac
cents, style, and speed. Once Carthy got
of an age to play, he says he knew so few
tunes that he would repeat them a lot

dances went late, which they usually
did. No one minded, and dancers would
often request the same tune repeatedly.
if

(Carthy laughs about this today.) Every
danced squares, though he
remembers an occasional two-step. Back
then he didn't know any waltzes, though
they're a favorite with him now. Dances
were simpler, and there were no official
callers. Instead, he told interviewer Stu
art Williams, someone in the square "just
hollered out what move you were sup
posed to do, 'circle eight,' maybe 'chase
one mostly

the rabbit'."

One notorious dance was called "Chase
Squirrel." Dance caller Bill Martin

the

suggests that this dance might have been
something like this:
Chase The Rabbit, Chase The Squirrel
First couple out to the right
1

Chase the rabbit, chase the squirrel,
chase that pretty girl around the world
3. Chase the possum, chase the coon,
chase that big boy around the room
2.

4.
5.

Circle four and away you go
Break it up with a dosey-doe

6. On to the

next

repeat with third and

fourth couples

On
the

the

second

part,

the

man

chases

lady through the standing couple,
around lady, then around standing man.
The lady in part 3 chases the man around
the same route." Many other versions of
this dance are cited elsewhere.
This dance was finally outlawed because
people would dance in a line, with the

�one on the end often getting hurt as the

line

whipped around, especially if people
were drinking, something that was pretty
common.

addition, almost every coat
hanging up had a revolver in it, making
things pretty rowdy. Still, Carthy saw a
gun pulled only once at a dance and never
saw one fired. The gun incident occurred
In

Fourth of July dance
a
picnic with
an open stage set up for dancing. About
a dozen men
grabbed the offender. With
at

and carried

a claw hammer in his back
And
he placed it pretty good. ..I
pocket.

guess he had

a

reputation of using

it if

they were musicians like Carthy.
Often the dances were in someone's

home, with the furniture moved out of a
couple of rooms and a square set up in

each room. Floors were rough and wood
en, not suitable for too many fancy moves.
At some dances, they would charge the
"gents" 10 cents a set to help pay for the
music. Musicians could make up to 25
cents ana get tree armies.
Dancers were charged
by the set rather than for
the

whole

Carthy Joins the CCC

out to California, like so many at that time.
But he quickly found that no one was hir
ing. With the little money he still had from

when he was 16, Carthy joined
Civilian Conservation Corps, lying
about his age so that he could get in.
(Fie was supposed to be at least 17.) The
checks he sent back home were crucial for
his family. Carthy clearly loved his life at
In 1937,

the

the camp and sees

it as one of his
happiest
times. Along with hard work and a good

wage, food was plentiful and appetizing.
Carthy made many good friends during
these years, and he has kept in touch with

them. After work, they would gather to
have some fun. Carthy and the other mu
sicians would gather around the piano to

had come back from California with what
seemed like a lot of money so he headed

his CCC work, he took the bus north to
stay with his sister Opal, who had mar
ried

logger and was living near SedroWoolley, a tiny town northeast of Seattle
where there was a small community from
Arkansas. But logging was the main oc
cupation there, and Carthy didn't feel he
a

was cut out to be

some

showed

up

invited

family's house,
Carthy,

pines and then,

even

didn't want
was finally
but he and

to.

he

persuaded,

ria-nr'/n

l-\i

VAfctJ.

I

l_' LI

F
L

play for the

Fhinrrn
LJl L1

LgO

n-rtl

no
OU

into him, was gratifyingly sick, and then
sobered up. The dance was going on at

high speed when the other fiddler arrived.

Siscos hosted dances for

a

bit

at

their house but quit after three of them

because

of the

man

a

rowdiness. The fighting
typically over whose

that broke out was

turn it was to dance next. Carthy remem
bers one man named George Williams

who built a small building to get three
squares inside instead of just one per
room so that the community could have
regular square dances. Carthy says that
Williams was "a pretty good size fellow

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

play the few tunes they knew and learn
each others' tunes. Some young men had

brought instruments, including Carthy
who had his fiddle. However, they all
had only about a dozen tunes in com
mon. They formed a makeshift band of
piano, guitars, and fiddles.
In addition, Carthy remembers that
they
could get the Grand Ole Opry on the ra
dio from about 8 pm until midnight. He

recalls

hearing the Skillet Lickers, the
Fruit Jar Drinkers, and Roy Acuff, among
others. Bob Wills as well as Arthur Smith
were some of his favorites on radio sta
tion KVO in Tulsa. Radio was a spe
cial treat since at home Carthy's family
couldn't afford the battery for their own.

it

he

back home

late in 1945 to

a

world. He went

to

the
Carthy and friends at the CCC camp.

bad that someone went to get another fid
dler. This took a few hours, however, and
Carthy had a lot of strong coffee poured

The

to

Carthy made

way there, and then they
all got drunk. Carthy at
to

it

Returning Home

Iris

bought a gallon
wine for a dollar on tire

tempted

sold

and

friends
of

the end

at

worked with at the Puget
Sound Naval Shipyard.

Carthy

some of

year

Philip

managed to acquire a new
fiddle. He later brought
that fiddle home with him

s

come

though

a

of the war, in Japan. There,
he did some trading and

insisting
who was

teenager,

a

play,

Carthy'

logger.

ed. He spent about
and a half in the

dancers

at

a

Instead, he ended up signing up for
Boeing's training program. He would
end up spending about 37 years at the
shipyards in Bremerton, working in the
aircraft sheet metal shop, except for the
time of his service in World
War II, when he was draft

memorable

one

For

dance,

time in the CCC

Carthy's

homeowner.

by the

now

after

ended, he was faced with the pretty bleak
job prospects of the 1930s. Sharecroppers

evening and

were specifically

that

Soon

he'd need to." Nevertheless, after about
three or four dances the drinking and
fighting shut things down there as well.

a

the drinking and fights, dances were of
ten frowned upon by the community, and
children were not usually brought unless

Coming West

changed
work at

shipyards, got married,

raised a family.
says that there wasn t much time for
and

between the duties

sic

work. And he has

of

He

mu

family life and

lot to say about how
intrusion of the television

the

a

growing
pushed out the music and stopped

all the

jamming. As he told Stuart Williams,
Then television come along, you know,
and that kind of took over everything. ..you
didn't have any place to practice. ..[with
the] television going.
into the bedroom

go

saw

a

little

Once
or

in

a

while I'd

somewhere

But there wasn't

bit.

a

and
lot of

tunes to learn, you know, on the radio
was all country-western... I really wanted
more of the hoedown, bluegrass....[P]
eople started just hanging their fiddles
up on the nail on the wall as ornaments.
It

seemed like

a

time when if somebody

�heard you playing the fiddle they'd ride
you out of town on a rail. That's about the
time the electric guitars were coming in.
he picked up an

Abandoning the fiddle,

old guitar for $180 from a "hock shop"
and started playing. He had been a Jim

my Rogers fan and learned lots of his
songs, and he also liked Ernest Tubb and
learned some of his material. And he was

learning songs off the radio. But, he says,
decided after a while that that wasn't
really what he wanted.
Instead, Carthy and his wife starting
dancing squares with the Square &amp; Folk
Dance Federation of Washington in the

he

1950s. This was the first time Carthy had

actually danced at square dances rather
than playing for them. He got interested
in singing calls but found that they were
taking him farther away from fiddle mu
sic. Dance callers were "what run fid
dling out" he has said, since

convenient

for callers to buy

it

was more

records and

practice how

to call with them rather
than use live musicians. The Federation

Wilson

still uses records to this day.
As Carthy describes the 1950s and '60s,
you feel how difficult a time it was for

Weldon

him, especially for him to find the mu
sic he loved. He seems to see his life as

The Washington Old-Time Fiddlers
and the Old-Time Music Revival
For Carthy, the early 1970s were the be
ginning of a new life in music due to the

Old-Time Fiddlers Associa
Carthy remembers that
who
lived in Bremerton,
Hanson,
Joe
took him to WOTFA meetings when he
joined District 5 in 1971. Joe would invite
Washington

Robin

and

peaks and valleys of musical depriva
tion or abundance. Like Ozark fiddler
Bob Holt, he says he almost gave up
music at this time.

Carthy on my front porch with his latest
fiddle in the white (not yet varnished)
that he wanted to try out with me. Car
thy is especially proud of the second fid
dle he made of beautiful burl maple.

use these much. Rather, he learns mostly
from recordings, which he plays repeat
edly to get a tune.
Carthy also taped radio shows in the
early '70s that were playing the kind of
music he liked. Buck Ritchie on KVI in

Records and Radio

Tacoma, especially early in the morning,
and Seattle's KRAB radio show Fiddler
KRAB, on Monday night with host Frank
Ferrell, were two of his favorites, along
with KRAB's bluegrass on Saturday
nights. He also played on Fiddler KRAB
with local fiddler Ole Winn and others.

tion (WOTFA).

basement after
everyone
jam
the WOTFA meeting. Mark O'Connor's
to

in

his

mother brought him to these jams when
he was about 12. Although Carthy never
had much to do with fiddle contests un
til joining WOTFA, he entered some and
won trophies, but adds that he didn't
like the emphasis on Texas tunes, which
wouldn't work for square dancing, a pri
mary requirement in a tune for Carthy.
At those early Bremerton WOTFA meet
ings Carthy made close friends with oth
er transplanted Arkansas natives. One,

Henry Mitchell, got Carthy interested in
fiddle making. I still remember coming
home one year in a typical state of ex
haustion from Fiddle Tunes, and seeing

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Carthy's formidable (if somewhat dat

ed) personal recording studio reveals his

interest in other peoples' record
ings. He says he started his collection in
the 1960s with the advent of the WOTFA
shows at the Bremerton High School. His
LPs include almost every Kenny Baker
album ever made, along with others by
avid

Bob Wills, Carl Storey and Jim and Jesse,

Curly Ray Cline, Vernon Derrick, a stack
of Texas Shorty singles, Jim Evans, Mack
Gant, E. J. Hopkins, Joe Greene, Tommy
Jarrell, Charlie Moore &amp; the Dixie Part
ners, Lazy Harold Donaldson, Mark

O'Connor, Dwanye Youngblood, Benny
Martin, Dudley Hill, Tommy Jackson,
and many, many more. Though Carthy
has some fiddle tune books, he doesn't

The Accident
After retirement, Carthy lived an active

life playing at many different gatherings.
But in 1 992, after an evening rehearsal with

Folklife Festival performance, he
home, stepped out of his truck,
and crossed the road to pick up his mail.
He was hit by a teenager who was driving
his car with the lights off for fun.
us for

a

arrived

Carthy was in a two-week coma and al
most died. He then spent three months

�Wilson
Weldon
and

Robin

at a convalescent home, where he quickly
became a favorite. When he finally made
it back to his own home, he had forgotten

most of his fiddle tunes and had to relearn
them. While some said his playing was dif
ferent, I found that if anything it was even
better. He could recognize a tune as one he
had known, and he said it was easy to learn
it over again but hard for him to remember.
Seeing him recover his playing at the age
of 71 was a wonder for all of us.

Carthy and Local Musicians
Carthy performed for many years at Se
attle's Folklife Festival. Before we got to
gether as his band (Carthy and the Sisco
Kids), you could see him constantly sur
rounded by admirers and other players.
He has led jams in Seattle, Puyallup, and
other local areas as well. In addition, until
this year Carthy would drive up for a day
to the The Festival of American Fiddle

Tunes

Carthy's Tunes
If you ask Carthy about whose fiddling he
likes, he cites an impressive list. Of course,

Kenny Baker

is

number one, but he also loves

playing of Lyman

Enloe, Joe Greene,
Baker (fonner fiddler

the

Byron Berline, Billy
Monroe and Del McCoury), Arthur
Smith, Texas Shorty, Ron Hughey, Tommy
Jackson, Benny Martin, Blaine Sprouse, and
Dick Barrett. There's a definite preference
for Bill

for

a

rather notey, bluegrass sound. Yet Car
up turning these tunes into Ozark

thy ends

old-time shuffles that beg to be danced to. He
notes that fiddlers play slower now than they
did in Arkansas.

While

Carthy

tunes such
has some

as

plays

"Turkey

well-known

many
in the

Straw," he also

uncommon ones such

as

"Frieda,"

"White Horse Breakdown," "Coker Creek,"

"Rugged

Road,"

"Louisville,"

"Morning

Glory Waltz," "Cowhide Boots," and what he
now calls "Carthy's Waltz" (but used to call
"God Only Knows Who'll Take Her Home,"
because he crafted the tune from a rumba
with that name that he heard on

a

jukebox).

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

in Port Townsend,
Washington,
where he has twice been a faculty mem
ber and taught his tunes to many people.
This year, Robin Wilson and Ginger
Weaver organized a wonderful party for

birthday. Robin

Carthy's eighty-seventh

has been doing some research on Carthy's
genealogy and found he had an ancestor

who lived until the age of 107, so we can
hope he will be around for many more
years. We played away the afternoon in
the shade of a huge big leaf maple, near
an old rusted basketball hoop. If Carthy
of a tune, someone would
start one, and then Carthy would jump
right in. When we couldn't remember
"Cricket on the Hearth," though, Carthy
came up with it. Carthy said something

couldn't think

about having memory problems, and I
responded with some platitude about
how memories can come and go, back
and forth. Carthy cocked his head and
eyed me. "Trouble is, it don't go forth,"
he said. Robin gave a little speech, which
she later emailed to me:

[0]ne

is

not an artist,

contribute anything

to

nor does one

one's art, if such

great
mility.

talent

balanced

not

is

These

two

qualities

rally and beautifully
Carthy. For Carthy,
about

the

music.

come

hu

ivith

natu

just

together

in

always been
then, again, if

it has

And

people could be characterized
of music, Carthy is certainly
lovely waltz of a man.

by
a

types

lovely,

To me, it's the epitome of Carthy that as
we played together, he suddenly came
out with a "Cumberland Gap" we had
never heard before. It was a compel
ling version, with a Carthy twist. Luck

I
got it recorded, and Jim Ketterman
emailed me that night to ask for it. Two
days later Jim was teaching it at a WOTFA class. The tunes keep bubbling up,
fresh streams of music, no matter any
fading memories.
At 87, having passed through many

ily,

vicissitudes, Carthy represents

the great

vibrant oral tradition,
through a truly difficult and sterile time
for practitioners of old-time music, to a
new revival. He has been one of those
somehow marked to carry the tunes, or
even more, a way of thinking and play
ing tunes. His example gives me hope
as I watch new people still finding him
transition, from

a

and his tunes, carrying them and a bit
of Carthy himself on into a mysterious

musical future. (yf

jeanie Murphy
even fiddle.

She

plays
is

banjo
an

and sometimes

English

instructor/

professor (depends on the school) and lives in
Port Townsend, where she tries to hike and
play music as much as possible.

�MOUNTAIN
HORN

FESTIVAL

JULY

BIG

10, 11, &amp; 12 2009
5tli Annual

Johnson County Fairgrounds
Buffalo, Wyoming
Hluograss, Folk, Old-Timey
Acoustic Americana, Western
and Traditional Music

The Steel Drivers

Featuring

Steve Smith

Hard Road
Special Consensus
The (xreencards
The Jalan Crossland Band
Long Road Home
Bill Evans &amp; Megan Lynch
The Wi vos
Flexigrass
Anne &amp; Pete Sihley
The Teka Brock Band
Jeff Troxel
D. Michael Thomas
&amp;

Tickets and Info at www.BigHornMountainFestival.com
Advance Tickets.' 3 Day $75 Friday $30 Saturday $40 Sunday $20
At The /ate." 3 Day $85
Friday $35
Saturday $45 Sunday $25
Kids 12 and Under Free (with an adult)

Mandolin and Banjo State Championships, (tuitar &amp; Fiddle Contests,
Instrument Raffles, Band Scramble, Food, Beverage &amp; raft Vendors,
Workshops, Pancake Breakfast, RY &amp; Tent Camping, Jams, Beautiful Scenery,
&amp;

and Some of the

Contact us

at:

Friendliest People Around!

Info@BigHornMountainFestival.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Reviews
Art of Field
2:

creasingly populated landscapes is noth
ing less than a testament to the stubborn

Recording, Volume
American

ness of the folk form.
Fortunately, Lance Ledbetter's Dust to
Digital label has seen fit to restore much
of this music in the form of assorted boxed
sets. And the attention to packaging has
been such that the collections are less like

50 Years ot

Traditional Music

Documented

bv Art

Rosenbaum

CDs than they are recently excavated trea

through screens, cleaned
lovingly preserved. The first set of
four CDs came embossed in one of Rosenbaum's paintings and included some 100
sures,

shaken

and

Dust

pages of notes about the performers and
their tire songs, photos by Art's wife Mar-

to Digital

For

years, the published body of Art
Rosenbaum's field recordings has lan
guished out of print. Though there was

stack of LPs on the Flyright label, find
ing them is next to impossible. There
were further blues albums of Scrapper
Blackwell, Shirley Griffith, and others
a

on Prestige

/Bluesway, the dazzling

Old

go, and various other drawings and paint
ings Rosenbaum has done over the years.
Even the disc sleeves were spattered in art.

The second set repeats the formula and, if
anything, is better than the first. Certain
artists are revisited, and like that first
lection, there is a survey disc and an

cappella, and one not. But to listen
collection in its entirety is to get a
glimpse of this country's vast array of bal
disc

a

to this

Smokey Joe Miller and Uncle John Pat
terson on Folkways. Acquiring copies
of any of them has been tough. Even the
1984 Folkways overview of his musical
documentation from North Georgia, Folk
Visions and Voices, which was a book as
well as a collection of recordings, has
been tricky to come by. This dilemma
did much to obscure Rosenbaum's im
portance, which is in addition to being

lads, fiddle tunes, Cajun two-steps,

sic all over the US, as played by people
who learned from family and neighbors,
regardless of virtuosity or song type.
In other words, it didn't matter to him
whether it was Shetland fiddle tune or a
Mexican ranchero, as long as it had been
that is, as long as
passed around orally
it breathed. Along the way, he developed
his own cast of characters, such as black

banjo player Jake Staggers, gospel duo
Doc and Lucy Barnes, and North Geor
gia old-time duo the Eller Brothers. He
also managed to snap up tunes played
by people others had recorded, such as
the deep Georgia blues drones of Cecil
Barfield, the accordion and fiddle of Io
wa's Dwight Lamb, and banjo songsters
Ola Belle Reed and Buell Kazee. And he's
still finding artists. His recent

discovery

North Georgia ballad singer Mary
Lomax must be the most important find
anyone's made in decades. That singers
like her continue to exist in what are in
of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

en

gospel. However, the other two
CDs are devoted to ballads and songs, one
tire CD of

Time Banjo in America for Kicking Mule,
and an album of Gordon Tanner with

an excellent painter, teacher, writer, and
musician in documenting folk mu

col

deep
blues, near-African banjo workouts, and
intense, congregation-driven gospel. There
are some surprises here too. Doc and Lucy
Barnes, realizing Rosenbaum's desire to

document

as many styles as he can, agree,
against their religious beliefs, to oblige him
with secular work songs and hokum tunes.
Blues harmonic player Neal Patman, better
known for his uptown work with an elec
tric band, plays some of the most downhome solo harp ever heard. Not focusing
on particular artists or styles serves the
music better as well, as it better demon
strates the variety of material Rosenbaum
found, often in the same county. Notions
of what "old-time" is become expanded as

gospel standby "Walk With Me" me gets
hijacked by furious steel guitar in a Florida
Pentecostal church; or as guitar-driven bal
lads reach heights of goose bump-giving
awe in the hands of Asher, Kentucky, shop

keeper Bert Hare. While examples of great
fiddling, deep Delta blues and raw COGIC
(Church of God in Christ) gospel can be
found on myriad other collections, no
where is there anything as fully alive as the
music presented here, due to the fact that

Rosenbaum's

collecting is ongoing. This
compilation then is less a dreary reminder
of what we've lost in this country than a
notion of what might still lurk outside our
doors,
To

if

we simply bother

to

order: www.dust-digital.com

listen.
Bruce Miller

j

'

�31st Annual

Hiawatha
Traditional Music Festival
July 17-19, 2009

Marquette Tourist Park

Marquette, Mich.

Tangled Roots, The Stairwell Sisters,
Josh White Jr., Pat Donohue,
Lucy Kaplansky, Rhythm In Shoes,
Cafe' Accordion, Feufollet,
Mamadou Diabate,
The Derrell Syria Project.
(contracts pending, subject

to

change)

Dances, workshops,
arts and crafts,
lovely campground,
family atmosphere,
organized children's and teens'
activities and music
Adult weekend

advance ticket: $50

For other ticket prices,

camping information
and all Hiawatha

Music Co-op info,

please visit
WWW

Hiawathamusic.

org

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Evening at WPAQ. 1984
&amp; the Smokey Valley Boys

An

Benton Flippen

Dewey Balfa was one, and Benton Flippen
another.

is

his

I

am not sure what

fiddling but

heard

it

got

to

it is

about

me the instant

I

and the intensity of feeling that his
playing inspires has not lessened with the
years. Although he has slowed down (he is
it

now 89) he still plays wonderful music and
I
urge you to go listen to him (and watch
those big hands!) any chance you get.

when Benton was
peak of his powers, with a backup
band that is as good as it gets: the late
Paul Sutphin on guitar, with Frank Bode
adding a second rhythm guitar (who
needs bass?), Verlen Clifton's under
stated locomotive rhythm mandolin, and
Paul Brown playing beautiful banjo.
This CD was recorded

at the

5-String Productions

5SP08004

Benton Flippen: fiddle; Paul Sutphin: guitar;
Verlen Clifton: mandolin; Frank Bode: guitar;
Paul Brown: banjo

Rachel

Step Back Cindy

Redbird

Sittin' On Top Of The World
Sugar Tree
Pole
Cat
Blues
Go
Home
Stomp

Durham's Bull
the Hearth

Blues

Cricket on
Fiddler's Dream
Florida
June Apple

Katy Hill

Country Baptizing

Mississippi Sawyer
Let Me Fall

Sail

Sally Ann

Away Ladies
Susan Anna

Cotton Eyed Joe

Gal

tant and influential older-generation fid
dlers still alive and playing today. He has

lived his whole life in Western North Car

olina, near Galax, Virginia, that hotbed of
old-time music that has been producing
major fiddle and banjo players for gen
erations. Although he has not recorded

extensively, he has had an enormous in
fluence on succeeding generations of fid
dlers who have been drawn to his bluesy,

slide-y, syncopated, and hard-driving
fiddle style
the kind of fiddling that I
think of as being on the cusp between

bluegrass and old-time, like Otis Burris.
But in addition to being a powerhouse
dance fiddler Benton has also developed
a unique personal
style that makes his

fiddling instantly identifiable.
Part of this style has to do with the left
hand; Benton doesn't use his little finger
at all and so some of the other fingers
do double duty. He doesn't use finger
ing that any classically-trained violin
ist would recognize.
His giant hands
all
the
over
get
fingerboard, producing
a

minimum

physical exertion. Indeed, he

is

not

of

giv

en to any kind of scenery-chewing, but
lets the fiddle do the talking. I couldn't

begin
but

to tell

it is

you what his bow arm does

amazingly propulsive.

love his fiddling best of any living
fiddler. There are a few fiddlers whose
I

playing nearly always moves me tears:

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is just

fantastic.

Even

a

are

classic renditions of many of Benton's sig
nature tunes, including "Pole Cat Blues,"
"Step Back Cindy," and his uniquely odd

(yet completely recognizable and acces
sible) versions of standards like "Durham's
Bull," "Cricket on the Hearth," "June Ap
ple," "Redbird,"

Benton Flippen is one of the most impor

amazing sounds with

The music here

non-dancer will kick up the heels. Here

"Katy Hill," "Sally Ann,"

When you hear his versions of these
well-known tunes, pretty soon you forget
any other versions you used to know. Also
a few Arthur Smith tunes and some
songs:
etc.

"Sittin' on Top of tire World," "Old Country
Baptizing." Paul Sutphin did most of the
lead singing, with hannony vocals by Ver
len Clifton, and Frank Bode lets loose with a
beautiful "Sittin' On Top of the World."
The CD comes in a handsome cardboard
fold-out case with minimal plastic. Paul
Brown has provided excellent liner notes
which are packed with information and
which are respectful without being too dry.
Nuff said. Buy this CD when you get
bummed out about the state of the world,
this music will take you to another, better

place. My personal recommendation is to

alternate

it

with any reissue of the Mem
it works for me!
Suzy Rothfield Thompson

phis Jug Band. Hey,
To order:

www.5-strine.com

Note to Artists and Record Companies
Please send all material for review to
the OTH (PO Box 61679, Durham, NC
27715). Please do not send to individual

reviewers. What gets reviewed is deter
mined at the discretion of the OTH ac
cording to space available, balance of old

and new, and compatibility with our mis
sion. We cannot review everything that

comes in nor guarantee that because we
received it we will review it. We do not
return materials to the sender. Thanks!

�Section with Illegible Text

2009 Best Destination
Event of the Year

Rhythm

September 18-20, 2009
Tickets $40
Patty Loveless

Webb Wilder

The Dan Tyminski Band
Peter Rowan Bluegrass Band
many, many, more.
Dr.

Dog

Scythian
&amp;

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&amp;Roots

Reunion
wfmmmmmmggt,
J
celebrating

Bristoljgj&amp;

f musical heritage...

�who becomes popular is going
followed by imitators, and this imita

A performer
to be

tion can take

couple of directions, both
Bluegrass, in the form
of progressive bluegrass, became baroque,
with fancy chords and intricate decora
tions that detracted artistically because they
added no meaning to the music Jimmie
a

of them decadent.

Rodgers combined blues, yodeling, and a
relaxed Texas style of singing that became
immensely popular, spawning so many im
itators that it was a major contribution to the

country-Western genre. But Rodgers was
not just another member of the folk sing
ing his songs into a microphone. He was a
performer, and he created

a

persona

to sell

performances. His immediate followers,
such as Gene Autry and Kenneth Houchins,
his

found no effective way to add to what he'd
already created. They projected the same im
age, with songs that were direct imitations, a
different form of decadence. Autry found a
second way to become a much-loved cliche:
he moved west and became a wealthy sing
ing movie cowboy, trading Rodgers and his
music for hat, chaps, and spurs.

Kenneth Houchins had as good a voice
Autry' s, he knew as many hackneyed
guitar chords, and, in my opinion, was
a better
yodeler. And, although he also
dressed in a cowboy outfit, he never hit
the big time. He recorded the songs on
this album for the Starr Piano Company
of Richmond, Indiana. Most of them
were sold by Kresge's on the low-priced
Champion label. Since it was the middle
of the Great Depression, they were not
runaway sellers, even at bargain prices.
Houchins billed himself as the Yodeling
as

Drifter in order to signal that he sang like
Jimmie Rodgers. He actually did quite
a bit
of drifting, although of the type
required of a professional musician. He
appeared sporadically on barn-dance
type programs broadcast by radio sta
tions throughout the Midwest, including
a

couple of stints with WLS in Chicago.

This work usually involved
the

week

to

short tours

small-town

during
high
school auditoriums in the area. In addi
tion, he spent some time touring with
traveling shows in the South and East.
He was even on television for awhile in
1950s, in the Quad Cities (Il
linois
Iowa) area. Tony Russell, who
wrote the notes to the CD, found no trace
of what Houchins did between 1951 and
the early

his death, age 78, in 1990.

Unless you re a big Rodgers/ Autry
I had
to lis
fan, this CD is a little rich
ten to it in three sessions. Song author
ship

is

not listed, so

I

assume Houchins

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

himself wrote them. If not, they were
surely all written by the same person,
perhaps using an early version of the
"How to Write a Country Song" table
that circulated on the Internet a decade
ago, where any combination you choose
comes out sounding country. Houchins'

themes extend somewhat beyond what
Rodgers started, but they still involve

mainly cowboys, prison, and longing for
a mother, a lost love, heaven, and a lost
home. Houchins casts a broad home

sickness net, perhaps thinking of the
location of Kresge stores: he's homesick
for the Smoky Mountains, the Ohio Riv
er Valley, Louisiana, an Ozark Mountain
Home, and for the Blue Ridge. If that's
too specific, how about a farmhouse or a
ramshackle shack on a hill? As to melo
dies, the tunes are not all alike; but they
seem all alike, because they use similar
chord progressions and structure.
All but two of these numbers are sung
by Houchins accompanied by his guitar.
On two pieces, "Down in the Old Ohio
River Valley" and "Louisiana Moon," he's

joined by one Slim Cox, playing over
wrought violin and singing harmony, an
addition that demonstrates that the guitar
by itself is sufficient for this material.
LYLE LOFGREN
To order:

bacm.users.btopenworld.com

�Leaf &amp; String

Festival

A

celebration of traditional I
I
music, art &amp; literature

JUNE 12TH &amp; 13TH

2009

Two days of the Old-Time and
Bluegrass Bands

Tribute to the Blue Ridge Music
Makers Guild on Friday and
Master Musicians of the Crooked
Road on Saturday.
Local Artisan and Craft Vendors

"Authors on Grayson" book and
author event
Food, Dancing and lots of fun for
the entire family

Wayne Henderson

&lt;Sc

Jeff Little

Historic Rex Theater on
Friday night at 8:00. Tickets are

at the

$8.00

at the

door.

Saturday Night Square Dance at
7:00 p.m. featuring The Grayson

Highlands Band.

Free admission!

M

The Best Pick
In Virginia

M

276-238-8

www Visitgalax.

130

conj

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�the focus, and each of the players work in
concert with the others to serve the mu
sic, not

spotlight the musician

despite
some pretty stellar mu
sicians. Kevin Fore is talented enough
and smart enough to surround himself
with some of the best of the current crop
of players from around the central Blue
the presence

Ridge,

of

including

the

aforementioned

Benton Flippen (who's fiddling sounds
as strong as ever at 89) and Verlen Clif
ton, Mac Snow, Kirk Sutphin, Bobby Pat
terson, David Holt, Chester McMillian,
and Kevin's regular bandmates in South
ern Pride:

James Burris, Joey Burris, and

Terry Semones.
Fans of the music of Kyle Creed, Tom
my Jarrell, or Benton Flippen won't be
surprised by the selections that Fore has
chosen to record, but if his intention is,

record suggests, to con
tinue the traditions of these earlier mu
as the title of the

sicians, I suppose that it makes sense to
establish a baseline by recording some
of the best-loved tunes from their rep
ertoires. Old favorites like "Joke on the
Puppy," "Rockingham Cindy," "Fall On
My Knees," "Old Jimmy Sutton," "Roust
about," and "Sally Ann" are played with
an energy and bounce that shows a con
fidence in their sturdiness and timelessness. In the hands of these players, the
tunes breathe; they aren't treated as dusty

museum pieces, but as part of a living
tradition. One delightful surprise on this
record is the singing of Eddie Bond, of

Bond's voice lives some
where between those of Tommy Jarrell
and Hobart Smith, and I was shocked
Fries, Virginia.

to

learn that he is as young as he is.

His

voice lacks the artifice of many younger
singers, and fits in beautifully with Fore's
directly traditional banjo style, shining
particularly on "Let Me Fall."
In addition to being a wonderful banjo
player, Kevin Fore builds some wonder
ful banjos,

too.

All of the banjos played

on this record were either made by Kyle

Kevin's hand
made banjos can be seen on his website,
Creed or Kevin himself.

www.roundpeakbanjos.com.
This CD then is the product of hard
work, geography, and genetics. Kevin
plays clawhammer banjo in a way that
sounds exactly like himself while re
maining solidly within the Round Peak

style and paying homage to the musi
cians who came before him.
In other
words, Fore continues his tradition in
the best possible way, by adding to it.
The results are very good, sometimes,
even glorious.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

In this day and age of Bernie Madoff
ponzi schemes and late night infomercials

for "male enhancement" treatments that
haven't been evaluated by the FDA, Kevin

Fore's

CD Round Peak,

the

Tradition

Con

tinues delivers something even more oldfashioned than clawhammer banjo and
string band music: truth in advertising.
DOUG VAN GUNDY
To order:

www.roundpeakbanjos.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Big Foot" and
are

both

two-fiddle

"Blackberry Blossom"

complicated

unaccompanied

tunes, but "Brilliancy" (the
Robertson's "Brilliancy
is
a
different
sort of surprise.
Medley")
It's played slower than on the original,
and with a slightly different accenting,
which turns it into a schottische.
"Banjo Summit," a Rafe composition,
is inside the tradition of flashy bluegrass
banjo solos, but less hackneyed, and
much more interesting. I got the feeling
that Rafe was not standing completely
rigid while playing it. I couldn't even
first tune of Eck

picture him in a blue polyester suit and
a tan Stetson hat.
The only piece I found less than success
ful was Roscoe Holcomb's "Single Girl."
Holcomb's voice was unique, in that it
was intensely restrained while also be
ing strong and clear. His performances
expressed an emotion so powerful that

overrode all the internal and external
restraints that tried to hold it in. At least,
that was the artistic effect he achieved.
it

Rafe reproduces the banjo style very
well, but his voice sounds muffled com
pared with Holcomb's. Kelley Breiding
sings harmony on the chorus, which
helps, but the two of them still can't

equal Roscoe. Rafe and Breiding do a
much better job on "Columbus Stock
ade Blues," one of those pieces that, to
paraphrase Yogi Berra, nobody does

anymore because it's too popular. They

bring it to life very nicely.
Finally, I enjoyed "Lost Goose," a
waltz I'd never heard before, and one
that might be possible for a see-saw
fiddler like me to learn. Just when

I

was feeling good about the possiblility,

Rafe

and

Clelia added

a

seven

teenth mystery

track of complicated
two-fiddle playing that reminded me
I
was not in the presence of ordinary
talent. I had to cheat and ask what the
tune was. It turns out to be one Rafe

recorded solo on an earlier album, re
peated this time to show what can be
done with twin fiddles.
LYLE LOFGREN
To

order: www. cdbaby.com/cd/rafeclelia

�derful verse "Somebody said that's a
strange tattoo you have on the side of
your head /I said that's a blueprint left
the

by

coal,

a

little

more

and

I'd

be

and

dead."),
"Hilbilly Highway" from
Steve Earle's famous Guitar Town record.
Jones is a native of East Kentucky, and
several of the songs on Cataloochee re

region's coal mining heritage,
including the two just mentioned, and
an exquisite rendition of Jean Ritchie's
fer to the

"West Virginia Mine Disaster,"
with heartrending words and

a
a

ballad

cascad

cadence set off by Matt Brown's
lovelv fiddle arromnanimenf
ing

There are a couple of original songs
here as well. The title song refers to a
chapter of Appalachian history not of

ten enough discussed, the eviction of
mountain residents from their family
lands to make way for National Parks.
Jones' song takes place in the Cata
loochee Valley, a section of the Great
Smoky Mountains National Park nowa
days known best for its misty mornings
and reintroduced elk, but formerly a
busy mountain community. "I Wanna

Know How the Story Ends" is also an
original composition. Carol Elizabeth
has a talent for the verbal play of clas
sic country songs, and this one, with a

parrotheaditudinous melody,
clever song about wishing to skip
ahead through love's chapters for a pre
vaguely
is

a

view of the denouement.

My favorite songs in this collection are
somewhat older ones. The album

the

with

opens

iar from the

"I've

Endured,"

singing

of Ola

so

famil

Belle Reed.

While Reed's strong, stoic singing com
plemented the song's words, Jones' voice
conveys a vulnerability that gives a new
and affecting reading to the lyrics that I
found very special. Also quietly power
ful is "Too Late, Too Late," from Molly
O'Day and Lynn Davis, a song in the al
ways haunting "Dark Eyes" family sung
here as a duet with Paul Kovac. I also es
pecially liked Jones' other duet with Ko
vac, the Delmore Brothers' "I'm Gonna
Change My Way," to which Carol Eliza
beth has penned new lyrics to cool off the
original fire and brimstone.
In the liner notes, Carol Elizabeth
writes, "The songs I chose [for this al
bum] are traditional and original songs

that moved me, and to my mind, they
just go well together." I found that

they
and

together exceptionally well,
recommend this CD highly.

go
I

SARAH BRYAN
To order:

www.5-string.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

'

�Now That's

a

Good Tune:

Masters of Missouri Fiddling
Page book on 13 master
Missouri fiddlers, with 2 CDs

97

containing

49

fiddlers. $30

tunes of these
$4 s/h in U.S.

Voyager Recordings
424 35th Avenue, Seattle WA 98122
(206) 323-1112

www.voyagerrecords.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�in the rest of the band, and the tune

tinues

con

mented chords, you-name-it.

striding (rather than flat-out)
with
nice sardonic-sounding
some
pace,
vocals.
three-part
Inspired by Walter McNew's singing and
at a

fiddling, Chance's "Little Pink"

tragic. He backs himself up on

is

is

starkly

finger-picked in the key of B-flat,
to the darkness of the lyrics.
Burl Hammons' version of "Rocky Road
to Dublin" might be my favorite track. In
this version, fiddle, banjo uke, and foot
percussion work together to produce a
adding

deceptively simple groove. Meanwhile,
the tune moves seemingly effortlessly
between A modal and C. Kudos to Mark
Hellenberg and Matthew Olwell for their
relentless

rhythm; kudos

when

to

play

a

C

to

to

Chance for

play

C#

a

and

natural.

Everyone on the Appalachian String
kudos, in fact. Adam
note-for-note with the
fiddle, do tasteful harmonies, and pro
vide rhythmic backup, and knows when
Band deserves
Hurt can play

each. Danny Knicely provides sol
guitar backup with some interesting
up-and-down runs. Ralph Gordon is, as
always, a solid bass player, and Aimee
Curl's vocal harmonies are spare, un
Matthew
forced, and right on target.
Olwell's flatfoot percussion is heard
on two tunes. You can hear him better
to do

id

on the

aforementioned

"Rocky Road to

Dublin" than you can on "Jimmy John
son," with the big band sound. I'd like
to see him dance someday.
Chance plays a five-string fiddle. In the
hands of a lesser musician, or someone
who didn't understand old-time music,
this could have resulted in fiddling at
odds with the repertoire. This is NOT
the

case.

The

fifth

string is tastefully
used, enhancing and expanding on the
old-time sound. There's a full loweroctave A part in "Twin Sisters," for in
stance, and two and a half octaves available for his solo version of Ernie Car
penter's "Yew Piney Mountain," with
the fiddle tuned CGCGC. "Little Rose
Is Gone" is done as a fiddle and banjo
duet. With the fifth string of the fiddle

available, both instruments

are

do the tune in the same octave,

able to

resulting

almost Asian sound.
Chance does let himself go into fiddle

in an

technique-land

on the last track

of the

with

"Wednesday Night Waltz,"
making use of all strings, chromatic
notes, vibrato, tremolo, positions up the
neck, while the band backs him up using
CD,

the circle of fifths,

diminished cords, aug

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

a

end to CD.

HILARY DIRLAM
To order:

banjo

remembering when

The result

gloriously over-the-top last track,

great way

gut-string

a

a

'

www.appalachianstrineband.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a
good choice of tunes, although
There are
vocals are hit-and-miss.
some bonus tracks that some might find
humorous, others irritating.

and it's

the

To order:

aDaoaziz@eillesaDaD.com
JIM

WATSON

�gart or the Flat Duo Jets managed to get left
out has less to do with faulty editing than

it does with further
showing the region's
over-abundance of falent and importance

BRUCE MILLER
To order:

www.plcmc.org/novello_press

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Third Annual

Section with Illegible Text

of the

Song

Section with Illegible Text

Festival
Section with Illegible Text

JUNE 25

27,

2009

at Davis Valley Winery

II-81,

Groseclose, Virginia

Exit 54

ADVANCE TICKET PRICING GOOD THRU JUNE 16 '09

THURSDAY, JUNE 25

$20 advance $25 at the sate
Stage time: 3:00 pm 10:00 pm
Wayne Henderson
Carolina Travelers* Dan Tyminski Band
Farewell Drifters

I

FRIDAY, JUNE 26
$20 advance

$25 at

Stage time: 1:45

pm

the gate I

10:30 pm

Goose Creek Symphony

Michael Reno Harrell
Lou Reid &amp; Carolina

Hillbilly Gypsies
John Cowan Band

SATURDAY, JUNE 27

B| ^^E^^^$20

advance $25 at the gate
Stage time: 1:00 pm 10:00 pm
Jesse McReynolds 80th Birthday Celebration
Curly Seckler and Willis Spears
Bill

&amp;

Maggie Anderson

Big Country

Paul Williams

&amp;

Bluegrass

the Victory Trio
Moron Brothers

$55 advance $70 at the gate
Children under 12 FREE with
paying adult.

I

I

TICKETS
The Lincoln Theatre: (276) 783-6093
Davis Valley Winery: (276) 686-8855
Bank of Marion locations
AT GATE

PRICES

AFTER JUNE

EFFECT
2009

CAMPING
Davis Valley Winery: (276) 686-8855

Section with Illegible Text

Jammers and Parking Lot
Pickers WELCOME!

FOR MORE INFO

vrvsrw.songofthemountains.orcf
Be sure to visit the

Chilhowie,

IN

16.

NO COOLERS

pre-festival celebrations

VA

Sponsors

m

WBRF-98.1 FM

NO OUTSIDE ALCOHOL ALLOWED

in Rural Retreat, VA Sunday, June 2 1st,
in
June
Saltville, VA Tuesday, June 23th
22nd,
Monday,
Bryant Label Co.
&amp; in Marion, VA
Wednesday, June 24th!
Section with Illegible Text
WETS-89.5FM WAXM-93.5FM
WZVA-Z103.5FM
WMMT-88.7FM
WM EV-93.9FM
WETB-790AM
WORLDWIDEBLUEGRASS.COM
WMMY-106FM
WPAQ-740AM

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Talent lineup for Song of the Mountains live concerts subject to change."

�AMERICA

KEEPING

OLD &amp; WEIRD

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
FOLKWAYS.SI.EDU

888-F0LKWAYS

Save 20% through 2/28/09

on CD

or

800 410-9815

Orders with Code HERALDFW08

�Section with Illegible Text

New Releases for 2009
Below is just a sampling of our CDs and DVDs,
and to order anv of our offerings. We are now

please come to visit www.fieldrecorder.com
in

our sixth vear of producing

to hear sound samples
and
rare
old time music!
quality
I

The 2009 Releases: Shelor-Blackard Family (FRC1 12), Obray Ramsey &amp; Byard Ray (FRC1 13), Union Grovel 969 (FRC1 14), Dink Roberts
&amp; 2 (FRC211
&amp; 212), Dock Boggs 1966 (FRC312),
African American Banjo (FRC209), Ola Belle Reed Radio Shows (FRC21 0), Tommy Jarrell, Vol.
Walter Raleigh Babson (FRC313), Albert Hash (FRC411), Fiddling Van Kidwell (FRC41 2), Tennessee Banjo Addie Leffew &amp; Claude Wofenbarger
(FRC509), Nee Nlngy Band (FRC61 0); DVDs: Troxell Brothers (FRC1 003), Clyde Davenport (FRC1 004), Virgil Anderson (FRC1 005)
1

ALSO: Round

Peak Vol.

1

The Balfa

Brothers with Nathan Abshire, John
Summers, Texas Fiddle Bands P.T.
Bell, The Hurricane Ridgerunners, The

Renegades,

The Indian Creek

Chirps Smith, Berkeley

ALSO:

in

Delta Boys,

the 1960s

Esker Hutchins, The Ross County
Dennis McGee and Sady

Farmers,

2007

Courville, Aunt Jenny Wilson, Heywood
Blevins, Jeff Goehring.
DVDs: Hiram Stamper and the Roan

Mountain Hilltoppers.

ALSO: The Kimble and

Families,

Simon

Wagoner

St. Pierre,

Corbett

Stamper, John Hannah, Arnold

ALSO: Clyde Davenport,

1

Vol. 1, Ernie

1

2005

Carpenter, Banjo Bill Cornett, Lonnie
Seymour, Cecil Plum

ALSO: Band

in

Transition: The

Camp Creek Boys &amp; The Smokey
Valley Boys, The Roan Mountain
2004

Hilltoppers, Norman Edmonds Vol.
Wheeler, Marcus Martin

2, Jimmy

order via US mail, send a check made payable to the Field Recorder's Collective to the address
below. $1 5 each CD, $20 each DVD PLUS $5 for US domestic priority mail. Please check our Web

site for additional discs and discounted sets. We accept Paypal and credit cards on our Web site.

Field Recorders' Collective, 124 Quaker Bridge Road, Croton, NY 10520

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

d

M

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

To

The Field

Recorders'
Collective

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12706">
              <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 11, Number 11 (June-July 2009)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12707">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12708">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 11, Number 11 (June-July 2009)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Trends in Old-Time Banjo Playing Part 1,” by Ray Alden&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Lily May Ledford: Coon Creek Girl,” by Richard Matteson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Carthy Sisco’s Rugged Road: Fiddling Through Hard Times,” by Jeanie Murphy&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Here &amp;amp; There – Country Music Hall of Fame Exhibit Spotlights John Hartford’s Legacy,” by Philip F. Newman&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for H.O. “Sleepy” Jenkins; and Lee Edwin Stripling&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12709">
              <text>2009</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1591">
      <name>2009</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6330">
      <name>Carthy Sisco</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6333">
      <name>H.O. “Sleepy” Jenkins</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6331">
      <name>Jeanie Murphy</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1121">
      <name>Lee Edwin Stripling</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6328">
      <name>Lily May Ledford</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6332">
      <name>Philip F. Newman</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5588">
      <name>Ray Alden</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6329">
      <name>Richard Matteson</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
