<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2874" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2874?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-19T22:51:51+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3834">
      <src>https://www.southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/5e3c019411944c4cc6c06b465102f4f3.pdf</src>
      <authentication>0541767c6543d4bdebc40d05503d7a4a</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="14020">
                  <text>��VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

FEATURES
"The Preacher and The Bear": Not a Folk Song, But a Song of the Folk/6

By Ted Olson

Rhythm and Genes: The Moonshining and Old-Time Music
of Southwest Virginia's Boyd Family /8

By Malcolm Smith

Dark-Natured Songs: The Bare Family Legacy/ 18

By Derek Piotr and Jackie Hedstrom

A )IAGAZIXE DEDICATED TO OLD·TDIE m;s1c
The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
POBox 61679
Durham, NC 27715
Phone and fax: (919) 286-2041
E-mail: info@oldtimeherald.org
www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Sarah Bryan
BUSINESS DIRECTOR
Peter Honig
SENIOR ADVISORY EDITOR
Gail Gillespie
CONTRIBUTI G EDITORS
Phil Jamison, Bob Smakula,
Clare Milliner, Walt Koken
ART DIRECTOR
Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group
FOUNDING EDITOR
Alice Gerrard
OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Art Aylsworth, Sally Council,
Gail Gillespie, Jim Watson

COLUMNS
HERE &amp; THERE/3
ATTIC/42

DEPARTMENTS
November 2021
No part of this magazine may be reproduced
in any form without written permission from
the publisher. Not responsible for loss or non­
return of unsolicited photos or manuscripts.©
2015 the Old-Time Herald.The Old-Time Herald
(ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is published
quarterly by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
POBox 61679, Durham, NC 27715. Subscrip­
tion rates payable in advance. One year:
$26 (foreign subscriptions--Canada $35US;
overseas $39US). Periodical postage rate paid
at Durham, NC 27715 and additional mailing
offices. Postmaster: Send change of address to
the Old-Time Herald, POBox 61679, Durham,
NC 27715. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is
a not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation under
section 501 (c) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code.

CLASSIFIEDS/25
REVIEWS/26

Cover: LenaBare Turbyfill. Photo courtesy of Elizabeth Gv,yn
Cover design by Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group, Greensboro, NC
Printed at Sutherland Printing, Montezuma, IA, www.sutherlandprinting.com

The Old-1ime Music Group, lnc. celebrates the love
of old-time music. Old-time music-grassroots or
home grown music and dance-shares origins, influ­
ences and musical characteristics with roots musics
throughout America. Our magazine, the Old-Time
Herald, casts a wide net, highlighting the Southeast­
ern tradition while opening its pages to kindred
and comparable traditions and new directions. It
provides enlightening articles and in-depth reviews,
opportunities for musical learning and sharing, and
a forum for addressing the issues and questions that
bear upon the field.

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 1

���there several times. He was married to
Lizzie, who is a native of England. This
circumstance occasionally resulted in
"friendly" discussions of old stereotypes
between the two countries.
He was devoted to his children and
grandchildren. He was very proud about
his grandson Tucker's learning to play
the violin through the Suzuki method.
Bill eagerly helped teach him and
participated in lessons and performed
concerts with him.
Bill played his last performance with
the Mound City Slickers on January
31, 2020. After that he was unable to
play, but insisted he would be back
playing again in a few weeks. Sadly
he wasn't able. His family, friends,
and the entire St. Louis old-time music
population grieve his passing. He will
be remembered for his fiddling and
love of old-time music, and for being a
gracious, kind, thoughtful, fun-loving,
and dedicated man, a true bonheddwyr.
Lindell Blackford

Our dear friend, and board member and
treasurer of the Old-Time Music Group,
Inc., for many years, Kathy World,
died of liver complications on July 3,
2020. Kathy was from around Orchard
Park, ew York, but came to Durham,
orth Carolina, in 1967 to attend Duke
Women's College, where she graduated
in 1972. She stayed on and lived here in
Durham for the rest of her life. That's
where I got to know her after I moved
here in 1989.
The first thing was her light-up-the­
room smile and the second was her
name-WORLD-wow! I don't remember
how I first met her but she was working
for Sugar Hill Records as office manager
and director of accounting and royalties,
and I believe I met her through that
connection. Kathy loved music. She was
a member of the St. Matthews Church
Choir in Hillsborough, North Carolina.
She especially loved singers Mollie
O'Brien and Robert Earl Keen, whom she
met through her work at Sugar Hill.
When I decided to get serious about
organizing the Old-Time Music Group
as a non-profit, we of course needed
a treasurer, and Kathy volunteered. I
remember many a board meeting with
president Art Menius rocking back and
forth in the rocking chair, various dogs
milling around, Ann Berry taking drink
orders, and Kathy passing around her
neat and precise reports of expenditures,
4

income, and the like, and trying to make
a bunch of us artist types understand the
ins and outs of the financial aspects to all
this organization-to say nothing of non­
profit-something I certainly had never
thought much about. Kathy was the
treasurer for years. (I'd have to go back
and see for how long, but I'd say at least
10 years.) It was a thankless job, and she
did it so well and with such good humor.
Kathy was a bookworm; she loved
books, especially mysteries, and she
knew books. She started a mystery book
club when she was working at the Gothic
Bookshop at Duke. Her other jobs down
through the years mostly involved books,
and I remember when my grandkids
would come and visit for a week or
so, one of the highlights of their visits
(besides swimming in the Eno River)
was going to the Gothic where she was
working, and she'd let them pick out a
book to take home. She was an advocate
for letting kids read what they wanted­
we had a minor set-to over that one time.
She and the kids won.
She was a knitter, and we had a small
knitting group that met every other week to
knit, but even more, to gab, gossip, and help
each other out with problems like health
insurance, taxes, grandkid/kid stuff, and a
myriad of other small and big life issues-­
and sometimes knitting problems.
Kathy's parents had passed years ago,
she had no siblings, never married and
had no children. Her family was her vast
community of friends, with whom she
was generous and loving, and by whom
she was loved back. She was friend,
godmother, traveling companion, helper,
and advisor to many, and we miss her.
Alice Gerrard

Sometimes our lives become loosely
entwined with remarkable people, human
beings who possess incredible talents,
minds, ideas, and actions. Often we fail
to recognize how important they are to
our lives. They bring a joy of artistry and
spontaneity that our lives sorely need to
be rich and fulfilling. And then, without
warning, they are gone.
The first time I met Mike Ramsey, I
had driven an hour into Kansas City
to peruse the local banjo supply at Old
Town Music, a long-gone acoustic music
store run by a great banjo player and his
mother. For me, this was like a trip to a
library where you could touch and feel
all the old books that the world had to
offer. Here was a jungle of open-backed

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

banjos from some of the world's greatest
masters. As I was demonstrating my
limited tune knowledge on a variety
of exquisitely designed instruments, I
noticed a guy in a pair of overhauls and
a flannel shirt, with wildly curly hair,
watching me. He made me nervous, so I
bleated out a weak. "Howdy," to see if l
could unnerve him
To my dismay, he headed straight
towards me. I knew he didn't work in the
store, so I was wondering what in the hell
this guy wanted. "Sa�;" he said, "I noticed
you were looking at a lot of banjos. Which
ones here do you fa,·or?" he asked.
I hesitated. W hat business was it of
his? "Well, if I had to say," I cautiously
replied, 'Tm kind of partial to this Mike
Ramsey 'Woody' model."
"Right answer!" declared the stranger
gleefully as he stuck his hand at me for
me to shake. "I'm �ike Ramsey." Damn.
I was speechless. Standing right there
with my banjo-building hero and not a
penny to my sorry ass. I wanted to buy
that Woody 12" cherry banjo right there,
from the maker, and live happily ever
after. Well, in a way I did....
A couple years later, in 2007, having
never saved enough to own a Mike
Ramsey Woody banjo, I got up the nerve
to attend one of his infamous banjo­
building workshops near Appomattox,
Virginia, at the 4H Camp. It was spring
and quite cold, as I can remember, but
the eight or so of us locked away in the
temporary woodshop Mike set up at the
camp didn't notice. These many years
later, I refer to it in my memory as a
weekend of guys, whiskey, power tools,
and eventually banjos. Mike was not
only a master banjo builder, having built
over 2,000 banjos in his first ten years in
the business, but also an inspirational
and remarkable teacher. In three days
he helped each of us build, inlay, finish,
and play a quality banjo, largely from
scratch and hardware. When each of
us knew we had just ruined our project
and took it to Mike with tears, he just
laughed and said, "The thing about
wood is, it forgives you!" He would take
our partially built instrument to the belt
sander, fix our wounded wood, and send
us on our merry way.
After getting to know Mike at the banjo
building fling, I decided I'd write an
article about him for the Old Time Herald.
W hat I learned about him was pretty
amazing. Born in 1949, Mike first heard
old-time music when he was in college,
a business major at the University of

�Tennessee. Originally from Roanoke,
Virginia, Mike had heard the music of
the mountains most of his life, but never
really listened until a moment in college
when he, with his guitar, walked into a
jam that he happened to pass at an old
church in Knoxville. Inside were two
fiddlers and two banjo players who
showed him the chords to "Liberty,"
and off he went. "I was mesmerized,"
Mike told me. Soon he was traveling to
old-time music festivals across the South
soaking up music from some of the great
players of the time. "It changed who I
was, forever," said Mike.
After college, Mike went to work in the
corporate world as a manager for Proctor
&amp; Gamble. He soon realized he wasn't cut
out for supervising hundreds of people
and toeing the corporate line. "They just
couldn't stuff me into that jar," Mike told
me. In 1983, Mike started a small hardwood
lumber business in Ohio, learning about
wood just as he was learning about old­
time music. He took banjo lessons and in
1986, won his first banjo contest. That same
year, with the help and encouragement of
friends, he built his first banjo. When he
held it in his hands, his life changed once
again. Having ordered a banjo from Kyle
Creed, the legendary builder from Galax,
Mike was so disappointed when he found
out Creed had died before finishing his
banjo that he set out on his own quest: to
build the perfect banjo. The one that Kyle
would have built.
Soon, banjo making consumed much
of his spare time and began to eat
into his business time. In 1992 he met
banjo builder Bart Reiter who became
a tremendous supporter, advising him
about his work and helping him set up a
production shop. In 1995, in Appomattox,
his banjo shop was complete and his
business Chanterelle Banjos was born.
Mike started off by putting a beautiful
rendition of Saturn in the headstocks of
his banjos, and built them to sound deep
and throaty like Kyle Creed's instruments.
Before long, he was building banjos at a
record pace and his banjos were featured
in high-end music shops from New York
to Portland, Oregon.
Mike was an innovator in many ways.
One was the speed at which he could
produce a quality, hand-crafted banjo. At
one point he was able to produce a banjo
a day, unheard of by most small builders.
Another of his great innovations was the
banjo head or skin itself. Mike, like many
builders, was always searching and
experimenting for that authentic sound,

that mysterious Kyle Creed plunk. In
the early 2000s he was approached by
a company that made timpani drum
heads, and was experimenting with a
new synthetic head they called Fiberskyn
(because of its resemblance in sound to
skin heads, but without the hassle of
using real skins, which took great care
and skill to fit and maintain). Mike loved
the idea and was one of the first banjo
builders to use the fiber heads, which
have now become standard among open­
back banjo builders.
Mike was also known as a character. He
liked whiskey, Volkswagens, cooking,
and collecting guns, among other things.
He was kind and generous, fun-loving,
and an endearing friend. He was also
wild as hell.
About a year after my story about Mike
appeared in the Old Time Herald, I was at
my home in Lawrence, Kansas, when the
phone rang early on a Saturday morning.
It was Mike. "What are you doing right
now?" he asked.
"Thinking about breakfast," I answered
honestly.
"I need you to come get me at the
airport," he said. "I'm at the Kansas City
Airport. We have a mission." I tried to
explain to my wife why I had to spend
the day driving to Kansas City to go on
a mission with a banjo builder I barely
knew, but she finally just shrugged and
waved me away. I picked Mike up and
he handed me a banjo case to put in the
back of the truck. Other than the banjo,
his only luggage was a backpack.
"What's up?" I nearly begged,
wondering what I had gotten myself into.
Mike jumped into the truck and pulled
a wad of papers out of his front pocket.
"Your mission is to find this place." He
handed me a piece of paper that had an
address in some rural northern Missouri
town I'd never heard of.
"OK," I said trying to decipher his
MapQuest printed directions. "I bought
me a VW Bug on Ebay, he told me, "and
you're going to help me find it." After a
couple of hours driving, we pulled into a
strange farm with a small house but two
huge barns. A tall, slender fellow with
a cowboy hat met us in the drive. He
brought us into the house, and filled two
huge bowls with some of the best and
hottest chili I had ever tasted. Turns out
he was an international chili competition
winner and was preparing for the Tulsa
chili cook-off. Go figure.
We had discovered a Missouri anomaly:
a VW ranch. We headed out to the first

barn and the fellow raised the door to
reveal several VWs in varying states of
disrepair. Except one. Mike got in the
small black bug, shoved some cash at
the guy through the window and yelled,
"Follow me!" as he left in a haze of dust.
I followed him out of the drive and onto
a road, knowing full well that Mike had
no idea where he was or where he was
going. It was clear, however, that he
was looking for something. And then
he found it. In the middle of nowhere,
northern Missouri, Mike had somehow
led us to a biker bar.
He came over to the truck and took
out his backpack, which seemed to only
contain a fiddle case. He handed me the
banjo in the case and smiled, saying,
"Let's go have some fun. Bikers love old­
time music!" I wasn't so sure.
Once inside the bar, Mike was holding
court. Soon, he handed me the banjo
case and said, "Here." I opened the
case to find a brand-new Mike Ramsey
12" Woody with a beautiful inlay in the
scoop, a "peace banjo" identical to the
one I have tattooed on my right knee. I
tuned the banjo up and we proceeded to
play the day away in that bar. Finally, at
about 6 pm, Mike leaned over to me and
whispered, "Time to go." I figured he'd
finally had enough. As we got out to the
parking lot, he asked, "How'd you like
your new banjo?" I couldn't believe it he had remembered that day in the store.
I finally owned a real Woody. I pleaded
with Mike to go home with me and
rest up before he drove back to North
Carolina, where he was living. "Gotta
go!" he proclaimed, and drove out of
my life, only to be seen as a glimpse at a
festival or concert here or there.
Mike Ramsey was a wild genius. He
was an innovator, a master craftsman,
and a lover of humans. He had his flaws,
as we all do. He made some mad, but
many more happy. He made the world
he lived in a better place because of the
joy he got from hearing people play his
banjos. He is survived by two beautiful
and incredible daughters, Sarah Rovnak
and Rachael Kearns, and by his sister
Gayle Brown and brother Kevin Ramsey.
He is also survived by a worldwide
community of old-time musicians who
often tell stories about him around
campfires, high in the mountains
late at night, or play dance music on
plunk.y banjos early in the morning. His
thousands of banjos live on!
Malcolm Smith

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WW .OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 5
W

ef

��n June 1984, newly hired as a ranger
by the National Park Service, I was
assigned to work fo r the Blue Ridge
Parkway near Blowing Rock, l'\orth
Carolina. My vocation that summer
was to provide interpretation of the
Blue Ridge region's cultural and natural
history alongside one the world's most
scenic roads, while my avocation involved
learning local music traditions. From
everything I had read and heard while
growing up during the 1960s and 1970s
in Washington, DC-then an active
outpost of the national urban folk music
revival-this section of the Blue Ridge had
long harbored one of the most vital and
certainly one of the best-known traditional
music communities in the US, having
nurtured leading folk music practitioners
(Doc Watson, Clarence Ashley, and many
others) and having contributed popular
ballads (such as "Tom Dooley"/ "Tom
Dula" and "The Ballad of Frankie Silver"),
songs (including "The Coo-Coo Bird"),
and tunes ("Doc's Guitar" as one example)
to the American folk music songbag.
Upon arriving in the Blue Ridge, an
aspiring musician and a wannabe folk
music scholar, I yearned to immerse
myself in that local music tradition, which
certain established scholars and revivalist
musicians had depicted as being an intact
bastion of Appalachian music created
by people possessing a strong sense of
place that was relatively unaffected by
the commercialism inundating virtually
everywhere else. Commercial interests
were certainly evident in much of the
music where I grew up-whether on
records, over the radio, or in concert.
And so, driven by earnestness and no
small measure of naivete, I pursued my
endeavor that summer, and as it happened
that endeavor did not go according to plan.
I rented an older but tidy trailer on a small
mountain farm owned by a local family, but
I wasn't there much. I was either working
or I was driving hither and yon to meet
local musicians (including the luthiers
and old-time banjo players Clifford Glenn
and Stanley Hicks, as well as the family
of the late singer-banjoist Frank Proffitt,
Sr.), attend jam sessions, or perform in
folk music competitions (such as at the
High Country Fair in nearby Boone). And
what did I learn from my immersion in the
local music culture? The most immediate
lesson: the value of carrying a spare tire
(driving up and down paved, gravel, and

I

dirt roads can be tough on tires, and I had a
flat within my first week). Another lesson:
to keep one's mind open, as it soon became
clear to me that my view of rural Blue Ridge
music was clouded by a facade of urban
romanticization constructed from highly
selective listening to regional recordings of
what I thought to be bona fide traditional
music. As it turned out, in the Blue Ridge
(as in most places across America, whether
rural or urban), traditional, popular, and
elite musics were inextricably mixed­
so much so that before long I began to
question the validity of categories and
genres when appreciating music.
That insight was reinforced to me that
summer when I almost met Doc Watson,
who lived close to where I was renting. My
landlord and her family, longtime friends
of the Watsons, often conversed with me
about Doc and his magical music, and they
unsuccessfully tried to arrange for me to
visit him at his house. Doc's wife Rosa Lee
issued an invitation, but Doc was on tour
much of that summer, and I decided not
to bother him or his family. The more my
landlord's family talked about Doc and the
more I listened to some recordings by Doc
I had purchased that summer, the more I
realized that that master musician-so
often described in the media as a folk
musician�was in fact uncategorizable.
Indeed, Doc loved all kinds of music:
traditional ballads, songs, and tunes, of
course, but also sacred music, country and
rockabilly songs, blues and jazz classics,
and various pop and rock songs.
But the most emphatic lesson for me
happened almost imperceptibly. During
one of those conversations about Doc's
music my landlord changed the subject.
Volunteering that her favorite song
was "The Preacher and The Bear," she
wondered if I knew it-and if so, would
I sing and play it for her and her family?
(Previously I had shared with them
some songs I had learned from records.)
Alas, in my effort to study Appalachia's
collective repertoire of traditional music,
I had never before encountered a song or
ballad bearing that title. My landlord said
that she had learned "The Preacher and
The Bear" from her parents and had heard
it sung by others in that area all her life.
A few days later I consulted several folk
music songbooks and albums in the library
at the local university (a logical place to go to
locate information in that pre-Internet era),
but I found no mention of such a song. I

began to half-imagine I had stumbled upon
an undocumented piece of Appalachian
music that had somehow eluded the
grasp of Frank Warner or Alan Lomax.
Then I located and thumbed through a
definitive source of information on that
area's traditional music, The Frank C. Brown
Collection of Narth Carolina Folklore, which
included the following description about
"The Preacher and The Bear": "While there
can be no doubt about the minstrel origin
of this song, the varying texts . . . would
indicate some folk influence." Mystery
solved ...or maybe not. I became puzzled
at the process by which a minstrel song had
become deeply entrenched in the cultural
experience of a rural population living far
from the sort of environment that supported
mainstream mass-market entertainment.
The reason for the dissemination of "The
Preacher and The Bear" became obvious to
me upon reading somewhere in that same
library that the song had been covered by
many popular recording acts, from the
1940s R&amp;B group the Jubalaires to country
star Jerry Reed, and that all the cover ver­
sions were based on a single recording of
that song from 1905, published the previous
year by Joe Arzonia (a pseudonym for Ar­
thur Longbrake) and adapted from a late­
nineteenth-century pop song. That first
recording, released on cylinder by the Edi­
son company, featured Arthur Collins ("the
King of the Ragtime Singers") singing "The
Preacher and The Bear" with orchestral ac­
companiment. Collins' original version of
the song, obviously far from traditional in
its stylistic arrangement, was an immediate
and massive hit. W hether it stemmed from
a traditional, popular, or elite source (or
some combination of all three), that com­
mercially published and recorded piece of
music was transported into the collective
repertoire of people of every imaginable
location, including the Blue Ridge commu­
nity where I was then living ...in one of the
more geographically isolated locations in
the eastern US.
Music is powerful and can connect people
to each other and to the broader world.
"The Preacher and The Bear''-while hardly
the type of song I was seeking to learn and
perform that summer-brought me closer
to understanding and appreciating the
real cultural values of my host family and
their community. Those kind folks not only
provided me with housing, but also shared
with me the song that had changed their
lives and would ultimately change mine.

r!/

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 7

���It's a beautiful early spring afternoon
in Southwest Virginia and I'm deep in
Franklin County. One of the thjngs that
everyone seems to know about Franklin
County (named for Benjamin Franklin)
is that the writer Sherwood Anderson
once dubbed it "the wettest county in
the world." I am on Boyd land, just off
Dry Hill Road. The Boyds have owned,
farmed, and worked land in this county
since the earEest European settlers came
to thls part of Virginia. They have also
contributed substantially to its legendary
status since the Great Moonshlne
Conspiracy of the early 1930s, and to its
renown as one of the great sources of old­
time mountain-made music in the world.
As I waited near a beautiful pond on
the Boyd property, an old, battered red
flatbed truck approached, hauling its ca­
pacity in large, round hay bales. Out of
the driver's side popped Jimmy Boyd,
wearing a well-worn moonshiner's hat
and a flannel shirt draped loosely over
a t-shirt from an old-time music festi­
val. He grabbed my hand, momentarily
crushing it in his, and smiled. Grand­
children climbed in and out of the truck,
and then his son Stacy jumped in and
took over Jimmy's chores while we
grabbed chairs to sit down by the pond.
For the next two hours I was in the pres­
ence of living folklore: moonshine his­
torian, storyteller, banjoist, and band
leader Jimmy Boyd.
Jimmy's earliest memories of growing
up in Franklin County are of two things
that have greatly influenced his life. One
is of men making shlne along the creek
banks and hollers, and the second is of
hearing old-time music at corn shuck­
ings, parties, and in his own home.
"The two have always just seemed to
go together somehow in my life," said
Jimmy. He vividly remembers being
carried on his father's hlp down a
long, winding path through the woods
near hls earliest home, and seeing men
standing around a still. "The thlng I
remember the most is the sweet smell of
that corn cooking. Back then, those men
made it right- little or no sugar, almost
all grain. It smelled so good."
The moonshlne really came first.
Jimmy's older brother Billy, whom he
looked up to, became involved in working
with and for the local moonshiners in his
teens. In the years between Prohibition
and World War II, jobs were scarce, so
many families in Franklin County were
involved in the moonshining business.
One estimate in the Roanoke Times was
10

that 90% of Franklin County's population
was somehow involved in its shine
production and export business in the
'20s and '30s. With so many households
reliant on it for their income, the tradition
was hard to suppress. Some of the best
moonshine runners from the area became
racecar drivers. Others, like Jimmy and
his brother, joined the tradition and
learned the trade of Franklin County
whlskey production at young ages.

l was about 12 years old, and my
brother Billy was about eight years
older. When he left home at about 16, he
didn't go to the factory, he went down in
the holler to make whiskey. He got with
some old-timers who really knew how
to make whiskey. He would make good,
clean whiskey.
He got me going. I made my first real
batch when I was 20, soon as l was
big enough to haul a 100-pound bag of
sugar. But back in those days we didn't
use any sugar on the first run. It was
pure grain, no sugar. We would save
back the backwash from that first run, the
grain and the yeast, add some barley malt
and a little sugar and the yeast would
go again, and that'd be our second run,
the first sugar. You could do that four
times. Cornmeal and barley malt, and
sometimes d ry meal. That made the best
whiskey. Some folks around here now
just make sugar whiskey. That is awful
stuff, and not good for you. Some people
would want that first all-grain run, some
preferred the first sugar. It was all good.
He remembers the thrill of heading
down to the first barrel of corn mash
that he fermented.

It was the springtime. You start up
that holler to that still, and you can
smell it fermenting, and that smell gets
mixed with the honeysuckle smells and
those flowers - that's fun. We enjoyed
our work. A lot of that moonshine we
made didn't stay around here. A lot of it
was headed up to the cihJ folk up north.
There was a division of labor roles
involved in the process.

At first, I was just the labor at the
still site. Tt was my job to help make the
moonshine, ferment the mash and then
cook it. Most of the time you had your
distillers and then you had someone
around who did your furnishings. A
fellow that done your furnishings, he

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, '\;LP.,,1BER 2

would bring you your grain, and when
you were done, he would pick up the
whisketJ and he would distribute it.
Stacy Boyd, Jimmy's oldest son,
remembers being a small child when
his father was making whiskey at a
still site on the other side of a ridge
near their home.

Our job, when Daddy was shining
and we were playing in the yard, was
to watch the cars going up the only
road near our house. We were supposed
to count how many people were in the
car when it went up the road, and then
count how many were in it when it came
back down. If there was less people in
that car [when it came back], we had
to run over the ridge and tell Daddy,
because it was probably a revenue agent
being dropped off to find the still.
Over the years, Jimmy has had hls share
of run-ins with local law enforcement
and has served a total of nearly a year of
jailtime for hls hobby. "We had to be real
careful, back in those days," he said. "A
lot of times my wife wouldn't even know
where I was working at. Sometimes the
people paying us wouldn't know."
The life of a moonshiner in Franklin
County had many risks. Jimmy recalls
getting caught and spending time in city
and county jails.

I had been pulling three months and
some days in the Rocky Mount jail. The
old sheriff, he took a liking to us, because
moonshiners are goad people overall. They'll
pay you every cent thetJ owe you, and they
are just as honest as days are long. Most
of them are. EvenJ now and then you'll get
someone who wants to turn the next fellow
in to get some money, you know.
We had a year to pull, and [the sher­
iff] made a trustee out of me and then
said, 'Boys, how would you all like to go
home?' Well, that sounded good to me!
So, he said, "I'll tell you what, if you
paint my jail inside and you get it done,
I'll see that you go home."
We stood around there a day or two,
and then he came by one day and looked
at it and said, "Well, boys, I got some
good news and I got some bad news. I'll
tell you the good news first," he said.
"You can go home. But the bad news is
you got to pay your fine."
Jimmy and hls partner owed nearly
$1,200 in fines for moonshining.

�Well, my buddy, he called his wife and
she paid his fine, and then he said 'Tm
going to come get you out tomorrow." So,
he did, he went and got the money and
paid my fine so I could get out. 1 had
so many kids and I'd been in there three
months, I had to get out.
Jimmy laughed and then recounted the
story of how he and his partner got caught.

See we had tlris still set up, and we were
making whiskey to sell. We had what you
called the old pots, and they held about
800 gallons apiece, and we had four of
them set up. They were what you called
submarine-type pots. We could make 20
cases of whiskey out of each one of them.
And we had done run one of them and
filled 20 cases of liquor that day.
Getting ready to cap the second one that
day, the old boy that was helping me, he
was putting the whisket; out into jugs.
Well, I looked down there towards the road
and I seen somebody jerk his head back be­
hind a tree. I said, "We'd better go!" And
so we hit the holler. We went straight into
the holler, right straight away from him.
Dumbest thing we could ever do. We went
about 75 or 50 yards up that holler and
there was a fence down across there. Well,
we run right up against that fence, and
there was five or six of them on the outside
and three or four on the inside, and they
had us up against that fence.
When I went in that morning, I had on
a pair of tennis shoes, so 1 was ready to
run. When they all gathered around us
right there, I was going to break and run
across the branch. Well, when 1 jumped
across the branch, I sunk into the mud
about that deep!" [Jimmy motioned to­
wards his elbow.] And one of them ABC
bosses jumped on my back! And, well, I
knew I wasn't getting out of this, so I just
gave up.
They put handcuffs on us, and took us
back to the still site. They read us our rights.
Then they asked us, "Ifwe take those hand­
cuffs off are you all going to run?" And I
said, "I don't reckon. It's no use." So, they
took the handcuffs offof us, and, we had put
some soda pops down in the branch to cool
and some of them got soft drinks.
Well, they got to laughing and chop­
ping the still up, and laughing and a­
chopping, and a-busting the jugs up.
Well, I caught them all five or six yards
away from me, and I hit that hill a-run­
ning. I had to go straight up a hill.
Shooting! You've never heard such
shooting! They probably shot 25 times.

And there didn't but one take offafter me.
He was just right on my heels going up
that hill. When I got on top, I was a little
bit ahead of him and I got out front of him
about eight or ten yards. Can you imag­
ine running all the way to the top of that
hill over yonder? You're going to be out
of breath! I wasn't but about 25 years old
at the time. I was in good shape.
Well, we both got down to a rock
wall going out through the woods, and
jumped it. Finally, we came to this little
dirt road going off down the woods that
hardly anybody travelled, and I hit that
little old dirt road and had got about from
here to that dirt pile yonder ahead of him.
[Jimmy pointed at a small dirt pile about
four yards away.] And I looked back to see
if he had gained any on me.
He hollered, "Look back you SOB, I've
got a good notion to blow your head off" I
didn't say nothing, I just kept a-hauling it.
Well, I went up there and went through an
old farmhouse yard and got over there and
hit that hill, and I lost him. But we went
aboutfive miles and we come out in Henry.
Right in the little town of Henry. I come
out on the right-hand side of the road about
a hundred yards, and he come out right in
the middle of town. I don't know if he was
following me or what, but he didn't catch
me that day.
I stopped at a man's house, and asked
him if he'd take me to a certain place and
he said, "Well, I'm in my bed trying to get
some rest." And then he looks at his wife
and says, "Take this man where he needs
to go." So l got clean away from them.
Now that boy, the one who got caught
with me, he was just 18 years old. He was
just a young'un. They tried him. And I'm
pretty sure when they tried him, he told
them who I was, but they weren't in no
hurry to come and get me. It was three
months before they came and got me.
By that time, me and a buddy were
making liquor somewhere else, and I
lived in a house just down the road
here. The house set on one side of a little
creek and it had a walkway going off of
the porch to a spring house over on the
other side of the creek. And we had may­
be 160 cases of liquor packed into that
little spring house. See, sometimes when
you're making whiskey, it'll sell good for
maybe three or four weeks and you'll get
rid of every drop you made and more,
and then again, you may have to hold it
for several weeks.
At that time, it was cold, dead winter.
We had it packed up in there. One
evening I had been down to Ferrum

with my whole family, and l was coming
home and looked over in my yard, and
there was a bunch of state troopers and
deputy cars, about a dozen or so sitting
in my yard. So I just went on by, I
drove right past them. And someone
recognized my car and they tore out
after me. Well, here they come, chasing
after me down the road for about two
miles. Now I didn't try to outrun them,
because I had the whole family with me.
Oh, I wanted to jump out of that car and
run so bad, I could hardly stand it. But I
decided I'd just stay with it.
When they stopped me, 1 just sat there
and they come up there to me. There was
the nicest young fellow, his name was
Bob Johnson and he was a United States
Marshal. They sent a Marshal after me.
He arrested me and read me my rights
and got me in the car with him, and told
me all about the reasons he was after me.
And you know, that man stuck with me
like glue. I don't know why he took a
liking to me. When I went down there, he
was just the nicest fellow you have ever
seen. Later on, he become a preacher. And
now he plays old-time music! He sure
does. I've played some with him!
Anyway, we had about a half-inch
of snow on the ground. And it was all
over that walkway going to that spring
house. They put me in jail that night and
the next morning this old fellow come
over and bailed me out. 1 went home.
All night long I'd been worrying, afraid
they were going to find all those cases of
liquor. All our profit was packed up in
that spring house. So, when I come home
next morning, I went and looked at their
tracks. Well, they had been all around
the house, looked in every window,
looked in every door. You could see their
tracks. But there wasn't a single track
going down that slippery walkway to
the spring house. That was in 1972.
One of the things that I was most curious
to find out from Jimmy was what he saw
as the relationship between moonshine
and old-time music. He believes they go
hand-in-hand, because,

They're both about having fun,
dancing, and having a party. But they're
also both something you can make
yourself Self-made fun! But moonshine,
it settles your nerves and you're more
carefree when you take a drink.
I'd known a woman that used to come
around. Her name was Brana Bennett.
She told me one day, after the Dry Hill

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15,

UMBER 2 11

��that I've ever sat down and played with.
When you would sit down to play with
that man and he'd start a tune, it would
just lift you up, and take you along with
it. His music would do that to you! He
put everything in such an easy gait that
it was a lot easier to play.

Ole Time Sound, with a large ensemble
of players from their Friday-night get­
togethers at the request of their fans and
dancers. The lineup for their first record­
ing included Jimmy Boyd and his brother
Billy on banjo, Murphy Shively on fiddle,
along with Carl Scott also on fiddle and
some guitar, Monroe Boyd on guitar (no
relation to Jimmy and Billy), and Kenney
Ferguson on bass. It was recorded on the
Outlet Records label in Ferrum, Virginia.

In about 1980, Jimmy had a body shop
on Dry Hill Road. Every Friday night, he
would brush the shop out with a broom
Well, we were going strong after that.
and water the floor down to get rid of the
We played at the Rocky Mount Armory
metal dust, and all the musicians in the
and the VFW and the American Legion.
Dry Hill area of Franklin County would
come pouring into the shop.
-------,------=�·-=-·
They would play until one or
two o'clock in the morning, with
lots of dancers joining in. Jimmy
recalled that the area got its name
from a little one-room school that
used to be in the area. He said
that you had to walk half a mile
down from the school house to a
little spring to get water, so they
named it the Dry Hill School.

Well, one day a bunch of us were
gathered over there, and in those
days we didn't have fancy-tuning
instruments like they do now, we
had a pitchfork, so it would take
us a while to get tuned up to play.
Well one day this old boy who
lived over there got his banjo all
tuned up and was sitting there
waiting on the rest of us. Now, he
was a good clawhammer player.
All of a sudden he says to us,
"You all drag around too much. Hurry
up and tune up. If you don't hurry up
and get tuned, I'm calling you all the
Dry Hill Draggers." And that name
stuck for over 40 years!
Right away, the Draggers became known
across Southwest Virginia as a dancer's
band. "There were oodles and oodles of
dancers that would come from miles and
miles to dance with us. They'd come from
all over Virginia and North Carolina and
West Virginia. We never advertised. All
those dancers knew we were such a good
dance band that they'd figure out where
we'd be playing next and call each other
and there they'd be when we showed up."
In 1982, a band for just two years, the Dry
Hill Draggers were invited to Knoxville,
Tennessee, to represent Virginia music at
the World's Fair.
The dance following grew and grew.
The Dry Hill Draggers recorded their
first record, Knocking Around with the

We played all over Roanoke and Vinton
and Stuart. Now, there were certain
places that had a really good dance floor.
And when you played there, you could
bet you'd have a big crowd. If you've
got a cement floor, it just didn't come
across like a good hardwood floor. One
of the best places, I guess, was over at
the American Legion building in Stu­
art, Virginia. They had a good hardwood
floor and it was upstairs. It would give,
you know. You could be downstairs
when they were dancing and look up and
see that floor just a-going up and down.
The Dry Hill Draggers began to be in
demand.

We went to all the festivals and
did some travelling. We went up to
New York at least three times, and to
New Jersey. One old boy, he was very
wealthy, invited us up to play at his
big dance party in New York. He had
about a 100-foot-square white tent.
There were 25 or 30 tables covered in

white tablecloths under it, everything
was snow white. And off to the side was
a huge wooden dance floor. We had a
great time playing there.
A year after the World's Fair, in 1983,
Jimmy took the band into the studio to
lay down a second album, There Will
Come a Time, featuring the same lineup
as their first LP. In 1985, the Draggers
recorded their third LP, Budded Roses. By
that time the band's lineup had changed,
as it always did over the years. Carl Scott
had taken over the primary fiddler position, along with Roy Hambrick.
They also both played some gui­
tar on the recording, along with
Monroe Boyd. Jimmy still held
down the rhythm on his banjo, and
Cordell Pinkard played the upright
bass. Roy Hambrick was also fea­
tured on vocals on four songs.
Shortly after the release of Bud­
ded Roses, the Draggers went into
the studio again to record their
fourth album, A Daisy for You. The
album was titled after a song that
Roy Hambrick had penned spe­
cifically for the album. If featured
the same lineup as their previous
release, with Carl Scott and Ham­
brick sharing fiddle duties, while
Jimmy drove the band with his
signature banjo sound. Two years
later, in 1989, the Draggers put out
a cassette entitled Yellow Cat. Once
again, Jimmy Boyd played banjo,
Carl Scott played fiddle, Monroe
Boyd played rhythm guitar, and Cordell
Pinkard was on bass. For this recording,
George Hayden replaced Roy Hambrick
on lead guitar and vocals.
Then tragedy struck the band. Carl
Scott, one of the original fiddle play­
ers who was with the band for its first
10 years, would have his life drastically
changed in one instant.

One day we played at the fire station
in Ferrum. It was a fundraiser for the
fire department. That evening we had
to go straight to Stuart and play a
dance over there.
We got over there to the Stuart Ameri­
can Legion and started playing. And
then we got word that Carl's wife and
daughter had been killed in a car acci­
dent. It also disabled his son. Well, after
that, Carl quit playing with us. He did
keep playing, though. He joined a church
and got away from the type of music we
played. He wanted to do better, I reek-

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 13

�on, and he got to playing a lot of gospel
music, and he's real good at it. We're
still good buddies. It'll be 31 years this
May since he lost part of his family. We
went to Ferrum school together. We've
always been friends and always will be.
About the same time, George Hayden,
who had joined the band in 1989,
succumbed to cancer. With Carl gone from
the band, and no one to match Jimmy's
hard-driving banjo rhythm, the band went
looking for a new fiddler - and they found
one. It was the legendary fiddler Benton
Flippen. For the next four years, from
1990 to 1994, Benton's pounding, rhythmic
fiddle would match Jimmy's banjo.

We had played with Benton some before.
remember one year when Benton, Carl,
and the bass player and l went down to
the Union Grove Festival and won it,
first place. We had played some with
Benton at festivals. At that time, around
1990, his band had done got old, and
some of them had quit playing, and he
was just playing with this one, here and
yonder, you know. So, l called him one
day and said, "Why don't you just come
and play with us." And Benton thought
for a minute and said, "I believe I will."
And then he stayed for four years.
From Mount Airy, North Carolina,
Benton Flippen started playing music in
1938 at the age of 18. He was a powerful
fiddler who followed in the footsteps
of his mentor, Esker Hutchins, a highly
respected local fiddler and banjo player.
In the 1970s Benton gained national
renown with his band the Smokey
Valley Boys, who won nearly every
fiddle contest in the Appalachians. He,
like Jimmy Boyd, was a strong rhythmic
musician and was known for his unusual
finger patterns and powerful slides. In
1990 he was awarded the orth Carolina
Heritage Award. "He was a lot of fun to
play with. We loved our time with him."
Unfortunately, the band did not record
a commercial album during their years
with Benton, but there are some record­
ings of them made by Paul Brown, and a
few recordings they made while guests on
WPAQ radio's Saturday Merry Go Round.
After Benton Flippen's 1994 departure
from the band, the Draggers would re­
cord two cassettes. The first was entitled
Pallet on Your Floor, and the second was
Don't Get Trouble in Your Mind. These
two recordings featured a young fid­
dler named Chris Prillaman and one of
14

Jimmy's sons, Jamie Boyd. Jamie had
taken an interest in his dad's music and
with his brother Stacy had been attend­
ing many of the Draggers' appearances
at dances and festivals. W hen he was
about 13, Jamie was with his dad at the
Galax Old Fiddler's Convention, and af­
ter watching the banjo competition said,
"Daddy, next year I'm going to enter
the competition up here." According to
Jimmy, he not only entered but placed in
the competition that featured some of the
best banjo players in the world. Jimmy
began to use Jamie as a second banjo and
at times he would fill in for Jimmy.
Chris Prillaman is another testament
to the old-time music gene. His great­
grandfather, a bootlegger and fiddler
known as James Walker "Peg" Hatcher,
was famous in Franklin County. The
"Peg" nickname came from his fiddle
peg. He was recorded by music collectors
from the Smithsonian, and his music
appeared on several collections of
Virginia fiddle music. Chris's father and
grandfather were also musicians.
Chris had been listening to the Dry
Hill Draggers since he was very young,
going to garage parties and dances with
his dad and grandfather. W hen he was
14 years old, his father became seriously
ill. During that time, and as his father's
health deteriorated, Chris was taken
by friends to music events to help lift
his spirits. Chris was just getting very
interested in music, so his grandfather
took him to learn to play banjo from
Jimmy Boyd. He became a dancer, and
loved to dance to Benton Flippen's
fiddling when he was with the Draggers.
Soon, Jimmy had him learning fiddle,
and as he dealt with his father's death,
he became more and more immersed in
the music of Franklin County.
"l have to credit Jimmy with just about
everything I know about music," Chris
told me.

He was interested in learning to fiddle
and so was I. So we'd go off together
and learn to play. He would always
have that fiddle with him, and he'd tell
me, get my fiddle out and fool with that
thing. Pretty soon I was playing along
with Jimmy's banjo. At first, I was just
screeching and scratching along, and
Jimmy would play so hard that he'd
just carry me along. I learned to fiddle
followi11g him on the banjo!
Chris inherited his great-grandfather
Peg's old fiddle, and started to play on

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTTMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

it as often as he could. He jumped in and
soon was playing up to the Draggers'
hard-driving dance speed. Jimmy began
to invite Chris up on stage to play with
the band and he loved the attention the
audience gave him.

Jimmy just carried me along, and before
I knew it, I was a Dry Hill Dragger. He
made me feel confident because he could
use that banjo to just pick you up and
carry you along! When the Draggers got
behind you, you just went with them.
Chris remembered the heyday of the
band in the 1990s.

You'd look out there in the audience
and there would be a sea of white hair.
Everyone of those old folks would be
dancing their hearts out to the band.
It was so much fun. Tt was almost
embarrassing, though, because I was
just following them along, I had no idea
how to lead on the fiddle.
Slowly, Jimmy started playing less with
the band, encouraging his son Jamie to
take over the role of banjo player and of
driving the band's sound. "Sometimes
it's hard to tell on a recording if it was
me or Jamie playing the banjo," Jimmy
said. "He developed a dance lick on that
banjo that sounds a lot like mine."
Chris and Jamie Boyd began to learn
tunes together, trying to keep the
Draggers' dance tempo and driving
rhythm going.
Soon, the Draggers
were younger, with new guitarists and
vocalists joining them, but retaining
Jimmy's sound and influence. Sometimes
Jimmy would double up on banjo with
Jamie, and sometimes they would invite
Billy Woods, another local fiddler, to join
them for a twin-fiddle, twin-banjo sound.
Playing old-time music was not the
only skill Chris Prillaman learned from
Jimmy Boyd.
After his dad died, Chris started spend­
ing a lot of time with the Boyd family,
staying at their farm for long periods of
time. Jimmy would take him hunting and
fishing, and soon Chris was asking Jimmy
to show him how to make shine. Both of
Chris's great-grandfathers had been in­
dicted in the Moonshine Conspiracy, and
making shine was another genetic imprint
Chris wanted to follow.

Jimmy got me started, and I worked
hard at it. l had it in my blood. The first
liquor 1 ever made was with Jimmy. I
wanted to make some so bad. When I was

�a little boy, my cousin's grandpa had two
pot stills and me and my cousin snuck up
on Dry Hill Road and there was a big rm­
derground still site. It just fascinated me.
Finally, I got all the stuff together to try
to make my own shine, and I begged Jim­
my to shaw me, to help me. Well, we got
together and made a batch together. It was
a good time. The smell and the work and
everything, I was hooked on making it.
Chris perfected his style of distilling
based on what he'd learned from Jimmy
and other local elders who remembered
the old ways of making liquor, who
knew the traditional styles of both corn
liquor and fruit brandies. In 2015, Chris
bought a warehouse in Rocky Mount and
started the first legal liquor distillery in
the wettest county in America. However,
after experimenting with town water in
Rocky Mount, he decided to move his
distillery out of town to take advantage
of Franklin County's pure spring waters.
He then opened a tasting room in Rocky
Mount, right next to the Harvester
Center, a popular music venue.
The Twin Creeks distillery features
a fiddle on their mason jar labels and
prides itself in carrying on the traditions
of the area, making shine as close to the
old recipes as state regulations will al­
low. Genetics and tradition, the Boyd
family way.
Stacy Boyd, another of Jimmy's sons,
had first become aware of old-time
music at the age of 10, when his father
started playing the banjo. He loved to
accompany his dad to the Draggers'
parties and performances and was soon
learning to dance with the band. "I loved
going places with my dad," he told me.
"It was so much fun, always." He start­
ed out in the early 1990s trying to learn
the upright bass because he wanted to
join in on his dad's fun. In 1987, he met
Vickie Sutphin, a member of the musi­
cal Spangler family from around Laurel
Fork, Virginia. Vickie's uncle Arnold
Spangler had helped found and played
fiddle for the Laurel Fork Ramblers, a
well-known string band in the area. Ge­
netics at it again. Vickie and Stacy met
at a Dry Hill Draggers dance. She had
been following the Draggers, dancing to
them whenever she could. She has be­
come the historian of the band and still
attends every performance.
When their son Jared was born, Stacy
began to take a real interest in playing
the bass. He played on stage with the
Draggers at the Galax Old Fiddler's Con-

vention, and then started playing regu­
larly with the Draggers. At this time,
Chris Prillaman, whom Stacy had known
since they were boys, was fiddling, and
Stacy's brother Jamie was playing banjo
most of the time. Jimmy would make
an occasional appearance with the band,
doubling on banjo.
"I felt like I had the rhythm. I would
study what Cordell was doing in the
band, and one day the bass started to
come to me," said Stacy. About this
time, another childhood friend joined
the band, Jason Hambrick. Jason had
learned guitar and singing from his
father, Roy Hambrick, who had been
with the Draggers for two recordings.
Jason could play the guitar well and had
learned his father's singing repertoire.
"Jimmy had encouraged me all along.
He knew I had it in my genes," Jason told
me. When his father passed away, Jason
began to take a real interest in keeping
his father's legacy with the band alive,
and Jimmy and the other band members
welcomed his talent.
After a long dry spell, and a few years
of slowing down their appearances, the
Dry Hill Draggers went back into the re­
cording studio. By 2006, the new genera­
tion of Draggers emerged. Stacy Boyd
was on bass, Jason Hambrick on guitar
and vocals, Chris Prillaman on fiddle
along with Billy Woods, and Jamie Boyd
primarily on banjo, with Jimmy Boyd
joining them occasionally. They went to
the recording studio again in 2009 and
recorded their first CD, Take a Drink on
Me. After nearly 30 years, the musical
torch had been passed.
Over the next few years, the Draggers
kept the torch going, playing at festi­
vals and dances throughout Southwest
Virginia and "holding court" as they
always did in the campgrounds of the
Galax Convention. For the big festivals
Jimmy would join them, but spent less
time accompanying them at dances and
smaller venues. 2011 found them in the
studio again, recording a 30th anniver­
sary CD. This concept album had the
younger Draggers going back to rere­
cord some of the Draggers' earlier songs
and tunes. The CD features Jason Ham­
brick honoring his father 's memory by
singing "A Daisy for You," a song that
his father had penned and recorded
during his years with the Draggers. In
2013, the Dry Hill Draggers released
their tenth recording, Dreaming of a Little
Cabin, with the same configuration as on
the 2009 and 2011 CDs.

BanjoFactory.com

'31"' 19th CCIIIUT) SI} le
Tack-head &amp; Frede,, Gourd ;ind
Woo&lt;kn Shell Banjo5

Like roots mu ic'?
Th�-n why not play a real roots banjo"?

Vintage
Jnstruments
Since 1974
Acoustic Fretted Instruments
Philadelphia
215-545-1100
www.vintage-instruments.com

We have spent a long
time working on new
packaging for our
John Pearse® Strings .
Not new color covers or
boxes. You might not
even see the change
but the packaging
provides better
protection
from the moment
they are born.
You will notice
John Pearse� Strings
lasting longer!
Just the best strings.
Now even better.

BREEZY RIDGE lnsts. Ltd.
www.jpstrings.corn 610.691.3302

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15,

UMBER 2 15

��In the late 2000s the band began to
change again. Jamie Boyd and fiddler Bil­
ly Woods left the band. Stacy and Vickie
Boyd had been devoting much of their
time to raising their son Jared. Although
Jared had been around old-time music all
of his life, he hadn't taken much interest
in playing music. "To be honest, around
2007, when I was 11, my parents decided I
would learn to play music. They enrolled
me in the Junior Appalachian Musicians
(JAM) program at the Blue Ridge Music
Center," said Jared.

I went there once a week to learn
banjo from Ray Chatfield. For the first
year, my parents made me practice 30
minutes a day on the banjo. I wasn't all
that excited about it.
After about a year, I realized I had it
in my genes, in my blood. We'd go over
to see my grandpa Jimmy once a month,
and he would give me lessons. He got
me excited about it. I started realizing
I had the Spanglers on one side and
the Boyds on the other, and there was
no way I could avoid playing. It took a
while. I told myself maybe my parents
will give up on me.
After a few years, I started to going
to festivals and competing in banjo
contests, and I realized I was start­
ing to get pretty good. By the time
I was in high school, I was loving
playing banjo.
In 2013, Jared applied for and received
a Virginia Folk.life Program award to
study under his grandpa, learning both
clawhammer banjo and stories of the
moonshine culture.
Jared formed his own bands through
high school and began winning most of
the banjo contests in the area. In 2010 he
played in a band called Old Grass that
was made up of former JAM graduates.
His peers and his teachers recognized
that Jared had exceptional timing. Some
of the professional musicians in the area,
like Mac Traynham in Floyd County and
fiddler Eddie Bond in Grayson County,
took an interest in Jared and began to
teach him local tunes.

Since I learned a lot from Ray Chat­
field, I play a more melodic style. I didn't
really play my grandpa's style, but I
felt like I got his sense of rhythm. Like
grandpa, I didn't drop-thumb at all, but

I started studying the playing of Kyle
Creed and his style seemed to have more
of what l was wanting. Somewhere
along the line, I taught myself to drop
my thumb like the Round Peak players
do. That upped my style.
Then, at the same time, Eddie Bond of
the New Ballard's Branch Bogtrotters
took an interest in my playing. And I
got to learn to play with him. After that,
people started asking me to fill in with
their bands and I gained confidence.
Jared was encouraged by his father to
play on stage with the Draggers. In 2017,
Jamie Boyd, Jared's uncle, decided to
leave the Draggers. Since they had dates
planned, Jared filled in for Jamie on the
banjo. After those dates were finished,
the band - Chris Prillaman, Jason
Hambrick, Stacy Boyd, and Jared Boyd
- decided to continue playing together.
"The defining character of the band had
been the banjo. W hen I took over, the
banjo sound of my grandpa and uncle
had been consistent, but my style is very
different. So we decided to continue the
Boyd family tradition, but to change the
name of the band."
The Twin Creek Stringband honors
their history by playing fast, hard-driv­
ing dance music. It's named for the con­
fluence of creeks near Rocky Mount and
for Chris's distillery. "It was hard for me
to keep up at first," said Jared. "At first,
Chris was used to being pushed by the
banjo. All of a sudden, they were hav­
ing to bring me along with them. But we
worked it out."
In 2020, the Twin Creeks Stringband
recorded their first CD, Lee Highway Blues.
It was very well received by old-time
radio shows and is selling well through
County Sales and other outlets. The 40year tradition of the Boyd family's music
and moonshine continues to provide fun
and dancing across Southwest Virginia.
These days Jimmy spends his time
enjoying his grandkids, telling stories,
and making an occasional appearance
with Twin Creeks at festivals. Every
year he totes a large submarine pot still
over to the Virginia Folklife Festival
at Ferrum College and demonstrates
for appreciative crowds the Southwest
Virginia art of moonshining. It's in his
heart and in his blood, and, like old-time
rhythm, it's in his genes.

ef

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15,

UMBER 2 17

��DARK-NATURED SONGS:
THE BARE FAMILY LEGACY
By Derek Piotr and Jackie Hedstrom

Listening to field recordings can be an experience of intimacy and distance at the same time: intimacy because we
hear the unedited sound of music just the way the artist made it, usually in a personal environment like their house
or porch; and distance because, in most cases, we listen to field recordings divorced from their cultural context.
Musician Derek Piotr became captivated by a 1939 recording of North Carolina singer Lena Bare Turbyfill (19051968), and this led him to learn as much as he could about her music. In the process, he became friends with many
members of the Bare family- including Lena's grand-niece Jackie Hedstrom, a genealogist and the co-author of this
article - who hai e shared not only family music, but memories of Lena and the other singers whose voices were
captured in those 1939 field recordings. The following article brings together both Derek's experience as a listener and
researcher, and Jackie's experience as a member of the musical Bare family lineage. -editor
1

Jackie:

The Bares were descended from the
Hicks family, who had been among the
earliest settlers in the Watauga-Avery
orth Carolina
County area of the
mountains. Old Sammy Hicks had made
his way to that isolated area just prior to
the Revolutionary War. He was a Loyal­
ist, and learned to live off the land and in
caves as he evaded the local Patriots. For
several generations the Hicks, Harmon,
Ward, and Presnell families intermingled
and married. They gained reputations
for being great storytellers, musicians,
and naturalists.
Derek:

I first heard the singing of Lena Bare
Turbyfill in December of 2019. I had been
researching traditional Appalachian
balladry for a project of my own, and
had downloaded some compilations of
Appalachian singing from the Library
of Congress. Up until this point, I had
mostly made electronic or classical music,
so I intended to do some deep-immersion
listening to provide me with context for
folk-based material for my new project.
Lena Bare Turbyfill was featured on the
Library of Congress' Anglo-American
Ballads, Volume 2 collection, singing a
song called "Bolakins (Lamkin)." At the
time, I had no idea what any of this meant,
but Lena's character, clarity of mind,
precision, warmth, and assuredness all
struck me as I listened to the recording.
I later came to find that "Bolakins" is
a variant of "Lamkin," one of the oldest
Scottish ballads still in circulation. The
song has been transmuted into such
unusual titles as "Squire Relantman" and
"Bold Ankin," and has been covered by
the likes of Steeleye Span and featured
(as "Long Lankin") on the Adult Swim
program The Shivering Truth as recently
as 2018.

Lena's recording was made by folklorist
Herbert Halpert during his 1939 travels
through the South. Contacting the
American Folklife Center of the Library
of Congress, I learned that Lena had, in
fact, recorded 30 songs when Herbert
Halpert visited North Carolina that year.
What's more, her sisters Sabra and Lloyd,
her father Frank Bare, and her sister-in­
law Ethel Bare, also sang for Halpert.
When Halpert interviewed Lena on
April 12th of that year, she explained that
she had learned "Bolakins" from her
mother, who taught it to her when she
was only five years old. Lena learned the
song by singing it with her sisters during
the day, and by singing it back to their
mother at nighttime. Her mother, Mary
Melissa "Molly" Bare, died when Lena
was only seven. The content of "Bolakins"
is bloody and shocking - one line goes,
"We'll stick her little baby full of needles
and pins" - and I was intrigued by the
juxtaposition of the quality and warmth
of Lena's singing with the cruelty of the
ballad. Even more curious to me was the
fact that it had been taught to her at such
an early age.
The ballad singer and storyteller
Bobby McMillon shared with me more
of Herbert Halpert's 1939 recordings,
including recordings of Samuel Harmon
and his family in Maryville, Tennessee.
The most poignant inclusion in these files,
however, was a collection of recordings of
Lena's eldest sister, Sabra Bare Hampton.
Sabra was born in Elk Park, North
Carolina, and moved to Morganton, in
neighboring Burke County, when Lena
was still young. This is where Halpert
met her and recorded her, about a week
after his visit with Lena. Sabra was about
fifteen years older than Lena, so she had
undoubtedly spent more time learning
songs from their parents. Songs that
Sabra sang for Halpert included a version

of "Bolakins," which Sabra referred to as
"Bolenkin"; "The House Carpenter"; a
delightfully strange take on "Partridge
in a Pear Tree"; and "Lily Schull."
Halpert also made a recording of Lena
and Lloyd singing "Lily Schull." They
reported that they had learned the song
from Sabra, who had learned it around
1913 from a man from Tennessee named
Glenn Crosswhite. In that ballad, about
a murder that took place at the turn of
the 20th century, the victim is not merely
killed, but her body also "shamefully
burned." I was fascinated that these
merciless tunes were seemingly staples
within the family.
Jackie:

Derek wonders why so many of the
Bare family songs are dark-natured.
The truth is, the Bares' own lives were
hard, and perhaps like parents who
told children the gruesome Grimms'
Fairy Tales to prepare them emotionally
for life's hardships, my grandmothers
taught their daughters and sons ballads
of dark, dreadful deeds.
Molly Presnell Bare (1876 - c. 1910)
- mother of Lena, Lloyd, and Sabra was the eldest child of Elizabeth Hicks.
According to family stories, her father
was Harmon Presnell. Her parents
were never married, and Harmon left
Elizabeth when Molly was just an infant.
Elizabeth soon married William Vance,
and Molly grew up using the Vance
surname. Elizabeth and William had
at least two children together, Vica and
William. She had another son as well,
Thomas, whose birth may have been the
cause of the couple's divorce.
By the turn of the 20th century, Molly
had married Frank Bare and settled in
the Cranberry township of what is now

THE OLD-TlME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 19

�8ER..NUNZIO

Sbi=�

UPTOWN
MUS 1 C

�

ii,
;:o
C

i L...____

...J

Sabra Bare Hampton with grandsons
Stanley and Steve Curtis, c.1951; Lloyd
Bare Bragg Hagie; Nicola "Nicky"
Turbyfill Pritchard

ilppaku:hian
Tu1dl£r
i/lbert
'HaJJh

The Last Leaf
on the Tree

Go to: www.alberthash.com
To order a signed copy from the
author, with a free Howard Rains
portrait of Albert and a reduced rate
two CD set of Albert's music from
The Field Recorders Collective.

20

Avery County, near Elk Park, North
Carolina. Frank Bare, who was older
than Molly, was running - figuratively,
from a troubled past, and literally, from
a disgruntled first wife who had been
holding a shotgun filled with buckshot
when he left his previous home in Peaks
Creek in Ashe County. He had experience
in mining, and probably got work at the
Cranberry Ironworks near Elk Park.
According to the 1900 Mitchell County
Census, 33-year-old Frank and 24-year­
old Molly had been married for eight
years. Of the seven children Molly had
given birth to by then, only four were
living: Arthur, eight years old; Sabra,
seven; Jesse, three; and Edgar, one.
At the time of the 1910 census, Molly
and Frank Bare were still living in the
Cranberry. Molly had birthed five more
children: Lee, eleven; Helton, seven;
Lena, five; Lloyd, three; and Martha,
two months. Within the year, their oldest
daughter Sabra would marry Harrison
Hampton. Another year later, Molly and
Sabra would be pregnant at the same
time - but both mother and daughter
contracted German measles during
their pregnancies. Sabra and her child,
Mae, survived, though Mae was born

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

suffering from measles. Molly and her
unborn child passed from the disease.
Frank Bare must have felt incapable
of taking care of his younger daughters
without Molly. Sabra and Harrison took
the two youngest daughters into their
family. I'm not sure why, but Frank chose
to allow a family traveling west to take
Lena with them. Perhaps he didn't want
to burden Sabra more, or he may have
just been in shock. Lena had conflicts
with this foster family; the Nesbaums,
who were Catholic, tried to convince her
to join their church. But even as a young
girl she knew her mind, and had no wish
to be converted. Ultimately she ran away,
and returned to North Carolina. Despite
their clashes, the foster family had given
her some opportunities. Lena had learned
to become a skilled seamstress. She had a
natural talent for sewing, and was said
to be able to look at a dress in the Sears
Catalogue and construct it without any
pattern to guide her.

Derek:

I was soon fortunate to be connected to
Carlos Hicks, Lena's grandson, and his
wife Dianne (daughter of famous Jack

�Tales storyteller Marshall Ward), his sis­
ter Rayna, and other family members.
They in turn introduced me to Lena's
icola "Nicky"
last living daughter,
Pritchard, who was still living in Elk
Park, only about 500 feet away from
Lena's old homestead. In July of 2020,
I traveled to North Carolina from my
home in Connecticut, and icky had me
over for a visit.
Nicky and I had had a few tentative
phone calls with poor cellphone service
before I came for this visit, and she had
gradually begun warming to my inter­
est in the family. But when I stepped
through the door of her home and saw
her face-to-face, I experienced one of
those precious, rare instant rapports, in
which there are no walls or trepidation.
We laughed, we selfied. We held hands
while she listened to old recordings with
me, and while she herself sang.
Nicky remembered Bolakins enough
to sing it for me and consented to be
recorded. Her version was a perfect
match to her mother's rendition,
although it had been more than sixty
years since she'd heard her mother 's
voice. W hen she had finished, I played
Lena's recording off my laptop, which
left Nicky in tears.

Jackie:
The 1920s brought huge changes in
these families' lives. Sabra's husband
Harrison and his only sibling, brother
Henry, decided to sell the small tract of
land that had been passed down to them
from their mother's family. I suspect
their reasoning was that the property
wasn't large enough to support their
families, and the economy was booming.
They decided to look for work in the
coalmines of West Virginia. Taking their
widowed, invalid mother, they moved
to Clifftop, West Virginia. Frank, Lena,
Lloyd, and Martha soon joined them
there. Both Lena and Lloyd married
their first husbands in Clifftop. Lena
married George Turbyfill, whose sister
was married to her brother Jesse.
The family had no idea what a terrible
mistake they had made when they
sold out and left North Carolina. First,
Harrison came down with pneumonia
- or more likely, black lung disease,
from breathing the coal dust. Since the
family would have been living in the
coal mining village, they were probably
turned out of their home as soon as
George became unable to work. Then

Nicky Pritchard listening to recordings with Derek Piotr.
THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 21

�We still
make things.

-

JOHN C. CAMPBELL
FOLK SCHOOL

folkschool.org • 1·800-F'OLK·SCH
BRASSTOWN • NORTH CAROLINA

22

the Great Depression hit. Employment
opportunities dried up. Frank Bare
and his younger daughters returned to
Cranberry Township, North Carolina.
Around this time, Frank started
inflating his age. He reported himself
on the 1930 census as being 75 years old,
when he was actually only 62. He liked
to tell everyone that he had fought in the
Civil War, even though he was born in
1867. (I suspect that he hero-worshiped
his mother's husband, who had in fact
been killed in the War in 1863.) As he got
older, he exaggerated his age even more
- so much so that, when he remarried
late in life, newspaper articles would
be written about the 100-year-old who
fathered a child, and eventually about
his death at the supposed age of 105.
Lloyd Bare Bragg returned to Avery
County as a widow, having lost her
husband after only a year of marriage.
She made her home as a servant for the
Bowick family. George and Lena Bare
Turbyfill returned to rent a farm near
the Turbyfill homeplace on Elk River.
George had served in World War I, and
had been declared disabled due to "shell
shock." Nowadays he would have been
diagnosed as suffering from PTSD.
Harrison Hampton, knowing the family
had no land to return to in Avery County,
found a position as a tenant farmer in
Prince Edward County, Virginia. For a
couple of years this position provided
well for the family. My mother Leola,
their sixth child, remembered that farm
as the best place they ever lived. For
the first time she could remember, the
family had plenty to eat. Unfortunately,
a problem arose that caused them to
move again, right at the worst of the
Depression. They returned to Avery
County, where they rented a small house
near George and Lena's home.
With no work to be had, Harrison
and his older sons John and Os hoboed
around the country trying to find
employment, and making it easier
for Sabra to feed the family at home.
Sabra had learned from her mother and
grandmother how to cultivate the land
and to grow crops in the limited growing
season of the mountains. She had also
learned to forage for wild plants, berries,
and nuts, and to use wild herbs and
plants for medicinal purposes. But even
with all of Sabra's knowledge, more than
likely my mom and some of her siblings
would have starved to death during this
time if it had not been for the generous
nature of George Turbyfill. George

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

received a small pension from his World
War I disability. Each month he would go
and purchase the basic foodstuffs, which
he would then divide up, parceling it out
between his family and the families of
his and his wife's sisters.
My uncle Os Hampton was a favorite
uncle for all of us nieces and nephews. He
was fun-loving. I remember him greeting
every one of his sisters with a kiss on the
cheek and telling each that she was always
his favorite, even if he had just told a sister
standing next to him the same thing. He
had served in the Army during World
War II, and was injured in the Battle of
the Bulge. He told stories of how he was
knocked from his hospital cot because of
nearby bombs exploding. While in the
MASH unit doctors discharged him, telling
him to go home and get his affairs in order,
that he only had a couple of months left. I
don't know what his injuries were, but he
lived until July 1973. Os never married.
He was a great flirt and women found
him extremely attractive, but anytime one
started getting too serious, he would tell
her that his doctors had told him he only
had two months to live. Whenever my
grandmother Sabra scolded him for his
womanizing, he would remind her that the
doctors told him to get his affairs in order.
Derek:
Jackie has told me that she remembers
her grandmother Sabra well. She also
knew her uncle Oscar "Os" Hampton,
who can be heard singing along with
Sabra on many of the Halpert reels, and
who taught Jackie one Child Ballad,
"Our Goodman." Child Ballad 274 is
a humorous folk song, often used as a
campfire or play-party song, and one
that's more familiar in Southern string
band music as "Three Nights Drunk"
or "Three Nights' Experience." The
song describes a wife's efforts to explain
away the evidence of her infidelity. Her
husband returns home inebriated night
after night, and each time finds his wife's
lover's belongings around his home: a
horse in the stable, a pair of boots, a hat
on the hat-rack. The wife explains them
away as familiar household sights that
he is too drunk to recognize. Finally he
asks her to explain the "head upon the
pillow, where my head ought to be," and
she responds that it is simply a cabbage
head her mother had sent her. "I've been
around this world, forty years or more,"
replies the husband, "but a moustache on
a cabbage head I've never seen before."
Jackie remembers hearing Os creating

�different voices for the characters of the
ballad, so when she performed the song
over the phone for me, she made sure to
change the register of her voice for the
wife and the woebegone husband.
Jackie:
In his old age, Frank Bare remarried,
to a girl who was younger than all
of his daughters and many of his
granddaughters. Not long afterwards,
she became pregnant. By this time Frank
was claiming to be close to 100 years old.
A charismatic character, he loved being
the center of attention. He often told tall
tales, and flirted with the ladies. When I
talk to any of my older cousins who had
the opportunity to know him, all I hear is
how much they loved him.
Derek:
Speaking on the phone one day with
Nicky, I mentioned that Jackie knew
"Three Nights' Experience." This
prompted Nicky to recall fragments of
that song, and she sang it over the phone
to me. She recalled other songs, too,
that Sabra had sung, once I had sung
them back to her, such as "The House
Carpenter" and "Paper of Pins".

Mudthumper Music
Keeping the Tradition Alive

New!

The Milliner - Koken Collection of American Fiddle Tunes
Updates:

2nd Revised Edition

Artist, Key, and Tuning indices have been combined, making it easier to find tunes by a spe­
cific key or tuning by any particular artist.
Biographical information is expanded and updated, in some cases because the artist is no
longer with us
All errors have been corrected

Dance All Night - The Highwoods Stringband Story
DVD by Larry Edelman

Back in Stock!

Highwoods Stringband, Feed Your Babies Onions
CD compilation of original Rounder recordings

The Original Fat City String Band-CD

Mac, Bob, and Walt reunited in 1999

Fire on the Mountain, An American Odyssey

.....·n.

&amp;,,91- -..

Box 791

..

Kennett

Square

PA 19348

Walt Koken's personal memoir of his Highwoods days
And more at:

www.mudthumper.com

THE UNIVERSITY OF
TENNESSEE PRESS

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 23

�Jackie:

Eventually, Harrison and Sabra
moved their family down to the lower
countryside in Burke County, where he
contracted to tenant farm, and later got a
state job driving a bus for the prison. The
middle-born children found employment
in their mid-teens, either working in
dairies or helping keep house for other
people. This relieved their parents of
having to provide room and board for so
many children, especially as many of the
older daughters left their own children
with their parents to raise.
Derek:

In Sabra's recordings, made at the farm
where she'd settled in Burke County, you
can hear the sound of chicks chirping
throughout much of the singing. Nicky
vividly remembered the time she spent
there as a young person. "That was not a
short or easy trip, from Morganton over to
us in Elk Park," she told me. "The roads
were not paved and gas was expensive, so
it was a very special occasion when Aunt
Sabra would visit. And I was always her
favorite, so when it came time to choose
one of us to have a sleep-over on the farm,
I was always her first pick."
Jackie:

All the women who recorded songs for
Halpert endured hardships in their lives.
My grandmother, Sabra Hampton, spent
nearly a decade mostly as a single parent,
trying to keep her own children and those
of her older daughters fed and clothed.
My mother remembered a time when her
mother and all the girls in the household
had to share a single pair of shoes and one
coat among the five of them.
Sometime in the early 1950s Sabra was
diagnosed with cancer of the mouth and
tongue. She underwent surgery to have
part of her tongue removed. I could never
remember hearing Sabra's natural voice,
as it had sounded before her surgery,
until Derek shared her recording with
me. It moved me to tears. Unfortunately,
Sabra's cancer returned in the late 1960s.
Through all her pain, Sabra retained the
same joyful spirit up until just a few
weeks before her death in 1970 at the age
of 72. Her husband Harrison Hampton
died one month later - according to
doctors, of pneumonia, but our family
knew it was from a broken heart. For all
the hardships Sabra suffered, she passed
along to her children and her younger
siblings the joy of singing, of storytelling,
and of laughter.
�.;

Lena was a gifted artist and singer, and
though I never met her, I know from my
mother's stories that she had a beautiful
spirit. She learned the old songs from
her mother Molly and her older sister
Sabra. The older women in the family
also taught Lena about nature and how
to forage from the woods. Unfortunately,
Lena only lived to the age of 63. In talking
to her descendants, and remembering the
affection my mother had for her, I know
she was a remarkable, generous woman.
Lloyd Bare (Bragg Hicks Hagie) was
a warm, loving, joyful woman. She
suffered the death of three husbands and
a son, and it's remarkable how she could
endure that pain and still be so filled
with laughter. She was a great jokester,
and as a child l loved visiting her house
on our trips back to Avery County. She
covered her walls with plats with silly
sayings, and loved laughing with us
kids over them. She made her living as a
servant of the Bowick family during the
hard Depression years, but eventually
remarried. She had a number of children,
but insisted on living in her own home
until the end. Once, a few years before
passing, she fell in her home and
couldn't get up. She called the county's
emergency service and reported her
problem to them, and told them where
they could find her hidden key. She then
warned them that if they messed up her
new front door, she would come after
them with her shotgun. She lived a long
life, dying at the age of 95.
Nicky Turbyfill Pritchard was my mom's
favorite cousin. She was more like a
sister to my mom. Several years younger
than my mom, she came to live with her
to help with my older siblings when my
mother lost her first husband. Nicky,
still young and innocent, also joined my
mom in working at Whippoorwill Dairy.
My mom often laughed about how one
morning, as the vet was examining the
cattle, he mentioned that he needed to
take one of the cows' temperature. Nicky
turned and asked my mom if she could
go to watch the vet; she said she wanted
to see how he would get the cow to open
her mouth for the thermometer. Nicky
was back in no time, and as red as a beet
with embarrassment.
Nicky loved nature. She loved
gardening, and she knew more about
natural remedies than anyone I knew.
Whenever we got to visit, whether at my
family farm in Morganton, or at her home
in Elk Park, we would most often find
ourselves wandering through the forest.

THE OLD-IDIT HERALD WWW.OLDIDITHERALD.ORG \'OU!ME 15, :S:t.:\fBER 2

It never failed that she would point out
to us that this plant was good to make
a tea for stomach ailments, or this one
was good for treating something else. I
loved to listen to her, because it made me
remember how my grandmother would
do the same when I was a child. Nicky
was one of the sweetest souls I ever knew.
I loved her as dearly as if she were an
aunt rather than a cousin once-removed.
In later years, due to both of our health
issues, I didn't speak with her much. But
the times that I did, it was like we just
picked up our conversation where we
had last left off. We just got each other.
The Bare women who shared their songs
with Mr. Halpert in 1939 had already
led difficult lives, but they had an inner
strength that allowed them to face those
hardships head-on. They filled their
homes with love, laughter, storytelling,
and singing. Their descendants carry on
those same traits.
Derek:

Nicky and I spent many months
discussing every topic under the sun­
love, loss, flora and fauna, religion,
nature, history, science-and she slowly
began remembering more songs. Over
eight months she came affectionately to
refer to me as a "songcatcher," and sang
versions of more songs, including "Pretty
Polly" and "Frankie and Johnny." Nicky
passed away in March of 2021, at the
age of 86. The loss was a crushing blow
to me, but I was so glad that during the
final chapter of her life I was able to help
stir memories of her past and celebrate
them with her.
For me, it has been life-changing not onJy to
get to know these recordings, but to connect
with the living descendants of the singers.
Their memories place the recordings in
context, illuminating the world in which
the singers lived. The songs are a lasting
document of cultural heritage, and of the
enduring beauty of mountain tradition.e(
Derek Piotr is a folklorist, performer, and
composer based in New England. He recently
curated a collection of field recordings, Last
Wisps of the Old Ways: North Carolina
Mountain Singing, for the label Death Is
Not the End.
Jackie Hedstrom is a retired librarian, who
supervised the local history collection at
the High Point (NC) Public Library for 18
years. A writer of science fiction/fantasy and
historical fiction, she is currently working on
a novel about the Bare family's experience
during the Civil War.

��Reviews

The Harry Smith B-Sides

Dust-to-Digital

Disc One

Dick Justice: One Cold December Day/
Ne/stone's Hawaiians: Village School
I Clarence Ashley: Old John Hardy/ Coley
Jones: The Elder He's My Man/ Bill &amp; Belle
Reed: You Shall Be Free / Buell Kazee: The
Wagoner's Lad/ Buell Kazee: The Butcher's
Boy / Chubby Parker &amp; His Old-Time Banjo:
Down on the Farm / Uncle Eck Dunford:
Angeline, the Baker/ Burnett and Rutherford:
All Night Long Blues / Buster Carter and
Preston Young: It Won't Hurt No More /
Carolina Tar Heels: You Are a Little Too Small
I Grayson &amp; Whitter: Rose Conley / Kelly
Harrell: My Wife, She Has Gone and Left Me
I Edward L Crain: Cowboy's Home Sweet
Home / Kelly Harrell: Henry Clay Beattie/
Carter Family: Bring Me Back My Blue-Eyed
Boy/ Williamson Brothers &amp; Curry: Warfield
I Frank Hutchison: Stackalee/ Charlie Poole
with the North Carolina Ramblers: Monkey on
a String/ Mississippi John Hurt: Nobody's
Dirty Business
Disc Two

William &amp; Versey Smith: Everybody Help
the Boys Corne Home / Carter Family:
I'm Thinking Tonight of My Blue Eyes /
Furry Lewis: Kassie Jones / The Bentley
Boys: Henhouse Blues / The Masked Mar­
vel: Screarnin' and Hollerin' the Blues
I Carolina Tar Heels: Back to Mexico /
Uncle Bunt Stephens: Louisburg Blues /
J. W. Day: Marthis Campbell / Prince Al­
bert Hunt's Texas Ramblers: Waltz of Ros­
es / Delma Lachney and Blind Uncle Gas­
pard: Le Bebe et le Garnbleur (The Baby
and the Gambler)/ Andrew &amp; Jim Baxter:
Forty Drops / A.C. "Eck" Robertson and
Family: Amarillo Waltz / Hoyt Ming
and His Pep-Steppers: Old Red / Henry
Thomas: Bull-Doze Blues / Jim Jackson: I
Heard the Voice of a Pork Chop / Colum­
bus Fruge: Bayou Teche I Joseph Falcon:
Aimer et Perdre (To Love and Lose) /
Breaux Freres: T'As Vole Mon Chapeau
(You Have Stolen My Hat) / Cincinnati
Jug Band: George Street Stomp / Frank
Cloutier and the Victoria Cafe Orchestra:
Moonshiner's Dance Part Two / Rev J M
Gates: Oh Death Where Is Thy Sting / Rev
J M Gates: Must Be Born Again
26

Disc Three

Alabama Sacred Harp Singers: Present Joys
I Alabama Sacred Harp Singers: Rocky
Road / Middle Georgia Singing Convention
No.I: I Arn Going Home / Sister Mary
Nelson: The Royal Telephone / Memphis
Sanctified Singers: The Great Reaping
Day / Elders Mclntorsh and Edwards: The
Latter Rain ls Fall/ Rev Moses Mason: Go
Wash in the Beautiful Stream / Bascom
Lamar Lunsford: Stepstone / Blind Willie
Johnson: You're Going to Need Someone
on Your Bond / Carter Family: God Gave
Noah the Rainbow Sign / Ernest Phipps
&amp; His Holiness Singers: A Little Talk with
Jesus / Rev FW McGee: Nothing to Do in
Hell / Rev D.C. Rice and His Sanctified
Congregation: He's Got His Eyes on You
I Clarence Ashley: Dark Holler Blues /
Buell Kazee: Darling Cora/ Cannon's Jug
Stampers: Madison Street Rag/ E. Segura
&amp; D. Herbert: Far Away from Horne
Blues / Richard "Rabbit" Brown: I'm Not
Jealous/ Dock Boggs: Down South Blues
I Bascom Lamar Lunsford: Mountain Dew
Disc Four

Mr &amp; Mrs Ernest V Stoneman: The Road to
Washington / Stoneman Family: Too Late/
Memphis Jug Band: I Packed My Suitcase,
Started to the Train / Carter Family: The
Storms Are on the Ocean / Joseph Falcon &amp;
Cleoma Breaux: Fe Fe Ponchaux/ Blind Lem­
on Jefferson: Shuckin' Sugar Blues / Sleepy
John Estes and Yank Rachell: Sweet Marna /
Ramblin' Thomas: Rarnblin' Man/ Cannon's
Jug Stampers: Riley's Wagon / Dock Boggs:
Sammie, Where Have You Been So Long
I Julius Daniels: My Marnrna Was a Sailor
I Blind Lemon Jefferson: Lemon's Worried
Blues/ Blind Lemon Jefferson: 'Lectric Chair
Blues / Joseph Falcon &amp; Cleoma Breaux: Elle
M'a Oublie (She Has Forgotten Me) /
Uncle Dave Macon: Rise When the Rooster
Crows/ Uncle Dave Macon: I'm the Child
to Fight/ Mississippi John Hurt: Blue Har­
vest Blues / Memphis Jug Band: Memphis
Yo Yo Blues/ J.P. Nestor: Black-Eyed Susie
I Ken Maynard: The Cowboy's Lament /
Henry Thomas: Texas Worried Blues
"People got folk song happy for awhile,"
Merle Travis recalled when interviewed
in 1979. Capitol's Cliffie Stone asked him
to record an album full of them. Travis
replied, "Bradley Kincaid and Burl Ives
have sung every folk song that I ever heard
of." Not one to take "No" for an answer,
Stone said: "Write some." Thus were born
"Dark as a Dungeon" and "Sixteen Tons."
That was 1946. Fast-forward a half-dozen
years to 1952. A nascent folk boom of sorts

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

had briefly made pop stars of the Weavers,
whose prettified versions of "On Top of
Old Smoky" and "Goodnight Irene" were
hits before the group was blacklisted
amidst the post-War Red Scare. The
paranoid notion that within every urban
folk singer lurked a subversive froze the
blossoming folk boom, but in some ways
it also signaled a creative time-out.
In 1952, also the year the Weavers
were blacklisted, Folkways released
the Anthology of American Folk Music. It
was a six-LP set of 84 songs and tunes
commercially recorded between 1926
and 1934 and arranged thematically:
Ballads, Social Music, and Songs. The
LP set had debuted in 1948, and while
Folkways marketed heavily to libraries,
its releases also made it into middle-class
homes at the dawn of the hi-fi era. (The
Anthology of American Folk Music wasn't a
trivial purchase: it retailed for $25, about
$245 today.) One can only speculate at
the reception it got among Truman-era
buyers hoping for something soothingly
Weavers-like. But it proved to be a
Pandora's box for their children, who
transformed bits of its contents into
staples of the '60s folk boom.
Harry Smith was the wizard behind this,
an artist, occultist and compulsive collector
who may have foreseen the Anthology's
latent potential, or may simply have been
desperate for cash as he sold a chunk of
his record collection to Folkways founder
Moe Asch. Whatever his motivation,
Smith oversaw both the programing and
the packaging of the Anthology, with hints
of his occultist inclinations appearing in
the art work and a quirky sense of humor
displayed in the tabloid headline-like song
summaries he penned.
Smith explained his criteria for selecting
songs to John Cohen: "The thing that was
the most exotic-whether it happened to
be the words or melodies or the timbre
of the instruments-that's really what
selected those things." Elsewhere in
Cohen's interview with Smith, he says:
"They were selected to be the ones that
would be popular among musicologists,
or possibly with people who would want
to sing them, and maybe would improve
the version." Seemingly contradictory in
recalling his motivations, Smith's sense
of purpose appeared sharply focused to
Moe Asch, who told Cohen: "He knew
what he was doing ...Harry understood
the content of the records. He knew
their relationship to folk music, their
relationship to English literature, and
their relationship to the world."

�But what was their relationship to their
B-sides? If Smith carefully compiled his
Anthology along thematic lines (Ballads,
Social Music, and Songs), wouldn't a
collection made by simply turning over
84 records render a musical hodgepodge
untethered from any thematic mooring?
John Cohen, who, along with collector
Robert
obley, suggested the B-sides
concept to Dust-to-Digital, didn't think so.
What was on the other sides? Lots of
things. Smith chose "Henry Lee" by
Dick Justice to simultaneously open his
Anthology and the Ballad section of it.
Cohen quotes him calling it "not a good
record," but a lyrically solid American
variant of a venerable Child ballad, so
he led with it. It's likely neither Justice
nor the Brunswick label were conscious
of this synchronicity, but the B-side of
Henry Lee, "One Cold December Day,"
is yet another Child ballad variant, this
of the vaguely necrophile "Lady Alice."
At the same time it's also one of the
earlier recorded versions (1929) of "In
the Pines." Other surprises follow: The
B-side of Clarence Ashley's "The House
Carpenter" (another Child ballad) was
"Old John Hardy," sung on the Anthology
by the Carter Family, who made the
earlier recording. Buell Kazee, who
recorded "John Hardy" before either of
them, inhabits tracks six and seven on
the first CD with "The Butcher's Boy"
and "The Wagoner's Lad," the same
songs in the same spots they held on the
original Anthology, since the songs were
originally issued on the same 78!
ot everything is a mirror image.
Burnett &amp; Rutherford's rowdy "All
Night Long Blues," the B-side of the
Anthology's ballad "Willie Moore," could
not be more delightfully different. But
the G. B. Grayson B-side of "Ommie
Wise" hews close to the ballad tree with
the much-covered "Rose Conley." The
B-side of Uncle Bunt Stephens' "Sail
Away Lady" may not equal the show­
stopper with which Smith opened the
Social Music section of his Anthology,
but "Louisburg Blues" offers its own
mournful, meditative charm.
It was in the context of Social Music
that Smith introduced the first of seven
Cajun recordings on his Anthology, this
at a time when Cajun music surely was
even deeper terra incognita to Truman-era
folk LP buyers than African American jug
bands, Appalachian string bands, guitar
evangelists, and rail-riding songsters.
Perhaps to display a familiar chestnut
reworked (and sung in Cajun French),

Smith put the Breaux Freres singing "Home
Sweet Home" on his Anthology. But to
buyers of the 78 in 1934 that surely would
have been the B-side in the conventional
sense: the more dance-worthy "T'as Vole
Mon Chapeau" ("You Have Stolen My
Hat'') appears here, a variant of the Cajun
evergreen "Hippy Ti Yo."
Nearly all the artists on Smith's Anthology
hailed from the greater South, with one
notable upper Midwestern exception,
St. Paul's Frank Cloutier &amp; Victoria
Cafe Orchestra. The Anthology offered
"Moonshiner's Dance Part One," with
Smith citing among the songs in its medley
"Over the Waves." That popular waltz
actually opens "Moonshiner's Dance Part
Two," making one wonder if this boozy
waltz medley wasn't the side of the record
Smith meant for listeners to hear all along.
On this B-sides set we get it, complete with
shouted asides that were a popular part of
generations of polka records.
Controversially, Dust-to-Digital opted
to delete three B-sides on account of racist
language, though the descriptions in the
accompanying 144-page book remain.
The handsomely designed, image-rich
book includes brief song commentary by
a host of authorities of varied stripes. The
four-CD, 81-tune box set offers a wide
range of vernacular African American
and Anglo-American music by such
legends as Charlie Poole, Charley Patton,
Uncle Dave Macon, Mississippi John
Hurt, etc. Audio engineer Michael Graves
has done a superb job of restoration and
mastering, bringing sounds of a now­
distant era into sharp focus. While it's
unlikely the B-sides will have an impact
equal to the original Anthology, it's a
worthy complement to it.
MARK HUMPHREY
To order: dust-digital.corn
Kentucky Fiddlers Home Recordings:
Volume 1-Fleming and Bath Counties

Field Recorders Collective FRC 732

Alfred Bailey &amp; Carlton Rmvlings: Martha
Campbell / George Lee Hawkins: New Money

/ Money Musk/ Unnamed tune/ Randall's

Hornpipe / Arthur Berry/ Unnamed tune /
Miller's Reel/ Paddy on the Turnpike/ Tom
Riley: Lardner's Reel / High Level Hornpipe
/ Greek Melody / Henry York: Liza Jane /
Going to Charleston Early in the Morning
/ Diamond T / Walking in the Parlor /
Oliver Gray: Mouth of Buchanan / Sid Stone:
Leather Britches / Fisher's Hornpipe /
Brickyard Joe / Warner Walton: Cumberland
Gap / Constitution Hornpipe / Alexander
Waltz/ Flannery's Dream/ Opera Reel

Alfred Bailey; George Lee Hawkins; Carlton
Rawlings; Tom Riley; Sid Stone; Warner Walton;
Henry York
It has been nearly a quarter-century
since Rounder's Traditional Fiddle Tunes of
Kentucky: Up the Ohio and Licking Rivers was
released, featuring field recordings made
between 1972 and 1995. For most of us,
this was the first time we heard the music
of Alfred Bailey and George Lee Hawkins.
The liner notes mention older fiddlers from
whom some of the tunes were learned Tom Riley, Carlton Rawlings, and others but as far as most people knew, there were
no other recordings of these fiddlers, all
from Fleming and Bath County. Jeff Todd
Titon's book places these two counties in
the Northeast Kentucky tradition, whose
tunes are characterized by being "elaborate
with long melodic lines" and "little or
no ornamentation"; and this is a good
description of many of the tunes here.
John Harrod made available to the
Field Recorders' Collective some tapes
given him by Warner Walton, and we
are now privileged to hear recordings
of some of these older fiddlers in their
prime years. Imagine, for a moment, that
the only recording of Lowe Stokes is his
Brandywine concert in 1983. (FRC 723)
Could we have guessed what he might
have sounded like in 1927 with the
Skillet Lickers? That is like what we have
here, and it is not only good music, but
a wonderful work of scholarship. (Check
out the notes to the tunes, available on
the FRC website.)
One of the things I learned was the
important role of written music in the
Kentucky tradition. Even if a fiddler
could not read music, he often heard a
tune played by somebody who could.
Tom Riley learned "Money Musk"
straight out of Cole's 1000 Fiddle Tunes
and taught it to George Lee Hawkins, who
changed a few notes. Also from Cole's
are "Lardner's Reel," "Constitution
Hornpipe," and "Opera Reel." By the
way, "High Level Hornpipe" is in B flat;

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 27

�Kentucky fiddlers did not always play in
the sharp keys. (Titon also points this out
as something often found in Northeast
Kentucky fiddling.)
You probably know "Martha Campbell"
directly or indirectly from the Doc Roberts
recording. Wonderful though that is, here
is a recording of two excellent fiddlers
playing it, taking turns leading and
seconding. As Harrod says in the liner
notes, "This is one of the greatest fiddle
duets of all time. They're still arguing in
the Kentucky corner of heaven over who
played the best Martha Campbell, but
until I get there and find out, I'm going
with this one." That is only the first of
25 tracks on this CD. And the others are
wonderful too! Please buy this CD; you
need it in your collection!
PETE PETERSON

Teodar Jackson
African-American Fiddling
from Texas

Field Recorders' Collective FRC728

Old AuntJessie/ Blood Red Rose/ Ain't
Gonna Marry / Drunkard's Hiccups /
Early Morning Blues/ Eighth ofJanuary
/ Golden Slippers / Lost John / Mama
Don't Allow / W hoa Mule / Out and
Down / Right Key / See See Rider /
Stavin' Chain / Sun Gonna Shine In My
Back Door / Poor Rabbit / Train Tune /
West Texas Blues/ Alley Blues
By now, all readers of the 0TH are prob­
ably aware of the crucial role that Black
musicians played in the creation of what
we think of today as "old-time music."
Yet there are very few non-contemporary
(and not too many contemporary either!)
recorded examples of Black old-time fid­
dling. In the 1920s, when the music was
first recorded, the record companies seg­
regated the music, in order to perpetuate
systemic and persistent racism (and of
course with an eye towards profits). They
classified what we of think of today as
old-time music as "White" music and is­
sued these recordings in their "Hillbilly"
or "Country" series, for White consum28

ers. Black musicians' recordings were is­
sued in the "Race" category. There are
a few, but only a very few, exceptions to
this. Thus, the handful of Black musicians
who made recordings with W hites (such
asJim Booker and Amede Ardoin) ended
up in the "Hillbilly" series, while Black
fiddlers including James Cole and Eddie
Anthony (who recorded both fiddle tunes
and blues) ended up in the "Race" series.
Blues recordings (i.e., recordings of
Black musicians) of the '20s and '30s
tended to be either in jazz band settings,
which typically did not include fiddles
(as they were unable to compete with
horns' volume), or by solo singers accom­
panying themselves on guitar. T here are,
of course, exceptions to this (Mississippi
Sheiks, Peg Leg Howell with Eddie An­
thony, James Cole and Tommy Bradley,
and a few others), but on the whole, very
few Black fiddlers were recorded com­
mercially during the 1920s and 1930s. We
have relatively few field recordings of
Black fiddle music from the pre-War era,
and recordings of Black old-time fiddle
music after World War II are even rarer.
FiddlersJames "Butch" Cage, from Mis­
sissippi, and Joe T hompson, from North
Carolina, are the most famous examples,
because they both performed outside
their communities and their recordings
were released commercially. In fact,
Teodar Jackson was supposed to play
at Newport in 1966 but had a heart at­
tack and couldn't make the trip, so they
brought Butch Cage instead, and that's
why we've known about Butch Cage but
not about TeodarJackson.
It is true that by the 1950s and '60s there
weren't many Black fiddlers still active,
but who knows how many Black fiddlers
may have still been playing in the pre­
War era, whose music will never be
heard? It is a miracle that we have the
recordings on this CD, of musicians from
Central Texas whose playing is as strong
as any I've encountered.
Most of the recordings on this wonderful
CD were made by folklorist Tary Owens
in the mid-1960s, when he was a student
at University of Texas. A few of the songs
were recorded by George Lyon at a live
college coffeehouse performance. About
10 years ago, I visited the archives at the
University of Texas at Austin, and digi­
tized the Tary Owens recordings; I had
to promise not to disseminate the record­
ings, but I did leave a copy there which
was found some years later by Howard
Rains. The aural quality on this CD is
much, much better. One thing puzzles

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

me, though; my recordings include other
excellent pieces that I would have thought
worth issuing. Perhaps there will be a
Volume 2 someday!
T he material here ranges from old
familiar melodies (often played in
unexpected ways) to blues songs sung
in the style of Mance Lipscomb (a friend
and associate of Jackson's) to old-time
songs like the "Eighth of January,"
"Golden Slippers," and (one of my
favorites) "Drunken Hiccoughs."
Teodar Jackson's grandfather migrated
to Texas from Mississippi in the mid
1800s, and "Old Aunt Jessie" sounds
very Mississipi-ish to me. It's in the
key of C, with phrases repeated for an
indeterminate number of times, foot­
stomping, and percussive guitar backup.
Think Narmour &amp; Smith, or Ming's
Pep Steppers. The fiddle is tuned about
a step low and the words are hard to
understand, at least for me; those factors
lend this piece a mood of mystery.
"Drunkard's Hiccups" is another
standout, an unusual treatment with a
fabulous dance beat, with more foot­
stomping and the percussive guitar
style. "Lost John" is not the usual tune
associated with that title; it's actually
"Someday Baby," a tune widely recorded
(including by Fred McDowell, Sleepy
John Estes, Big Maceo, and Charles
Brown). Similarly, "Mama Don't Allow"
is not the song I think of when I hear that
title; it's actually "My Babe," a huge hit
written by Willie Dixon for Little Walter
and recorded by many others, and based
on "This Train Is Bound for Glory."
In "Whoa Mule," the foot-stomping
becomes a gallop while the fiddle makes
noises like a mule. Again, this is an
outstanding version of an old chestnut.
"Ride Your Pony" surely is related to the
song by that name that I've heard from
various Louisiana Creole musicians, as
well as to the hit song by Allen Toussaint
that was recorded by many New Orleans
artists starting with Lee Dorsey. The way
Teodar Jackson sings it, you just know
he's lived this song, trying to work with
a recalcitrant mule.
There are some guitar pieces here as
well. I especially liked the fast-paced E
blues instrumental "Out and Down."
Be sure to check out Dan Foster 's excellent
notes, a treasure trove of information (with
photos) about rural BlackAmerican fiddling
and Texas fiddling (on the Field Recorders'
Collective website). We owe our most
heartfelt thanks to the late Tary Owens and
George Lyon for making these recordings,

�and to the Field Recorders' Collective for
making them available, more than 50 years
later. Very highly recommended.
Suzy THOMPSON
To order: fieldrecorder.org
H.K. Silvey
Fiddling from Ozark County, Missouri

Field Recorders' Collective 729

Wake Up Little Susan / Uncle Herm's
Hornpipe / Coming Down from Denver
/ Ragtime Annie / Sugar in the Gourd
/ Hummingbird Reel / Billy in the Low
Ground / Flop-Eared Mule / Eighth
of January / Black Mountain Rag /
Lonesome Indian / Old Time Dry and
Dusty / Liberty / Hooker's Hornpipe /
Oklahoma Rooster / St Joe's Hornpipe
/ Snowshoes / Dance Around Molly /
Kingdom Come / Shepherd's Waltz /
Tennessee Waggoner / Cotton Eyed Joe
/ Fire on the Mountain / Red Apple Rag
/ Ball and Chain Hornpipe / Soldier's
Joy I Old Fort Smith / Rachel / Tom &amp;
Jerry / Twinkle Little Star
For those interested in rounding out
their knowledge of Ozark fiddling, this
recording of H. K. Silvey should be of
great interest. Born in 1933, H. K. Silvey
is one of the last of his generation of
Ozark fiddlers. His biography reads like
a prototype of an old-time fiddler: born
on a farm in Ozark County, Missouri,
grew up hearing his uncle Jess playing
for dances and house parties and learned
to back him up on guitar, then secretly
learned to play on his uncle's fiddle
and subsequently joined said uncle and
other locals to play at dances and parties.
Went to work as an airplane mechanic
(like another old-time fiddler, Jimmy
McCown) and traveled in the course of
his job to other states where he played in
fiddle contests and with country bands.
Went back to farming and local fiddling
after he returned home in 1973.
These home recordings were made by
Jim Nelson in 2016; he first met H. K.
around 20 years before that. In addition
to his many field recordings, Jim Nelson

is well known for his backup guitar
playing, which can also be heard on the
Field Recorders' Collective Bob Holt
CD and on various YouTube videos
including some great ones featuring
fiddler Rhys Jones. His guitar always
supports, never intrudes. On this CD,
Nathan McAlister on banjo stays very
much in the background, also supporting
the fiddle in a delicate yet strong way.
Dance fiddling requires something
extra that is not required for playing on
the back porch or at a party or in a fiddle
contest or for listeners. The dancers
rely on-nay, they demand-rhythmic
drive from the fiddler. It's got to be the
right tempo and has got to have enough
momentum for the dancers to be able to
keep moving. H.K. plays his tunes with a
strong rhythmic propulsion that derives
from the single-note bowing. I would
have loved to experience H. K. and his
uncle Jess fiddling together! That must
have been quite a powerhouse.
Like most Midwestern fiddlers, Silvey
favors tunes with complex melodies
rather than the rhythm-centered fiddling
of Round Peak (and many other areas).
These elaborate, notey tunes demand a
rigorous left-hand accuracy, and speed
too. His fiddling retains a feeling of
rural country fiddling - not too smooth
and definitely not bluegrassy sounding.
An occasional "dwell" or extra beat at
the end of a section of a tune, like on
"Billy In the Lowground" and "Hooker's
Hornpipe," contributes to the old-time
feeling of these tunes.
H. K. Silvey's accuracy in his bowing
is truly impressive. The clarity of his
playing (and of this recording) means
that this CD could serve as a great tutorial
for someone who wants to explore and
gain deeper knowledge of old-time fiddle
bowing. This is not long-bow, it's almost
all separate notes, at a pretty good clip,
yet not at all choppy. Compare Silvey's
"Uncle Herm's Hornpipe" with John
Ashby's version, which is much smoother,
with more slurred notes, more akin to the
playing of a bluegrass fiddler. The crunch
of the bow attack on Silvey's version sets
each note in relief. Ashby's is like taking a
fast elevator. Silvey's is like taking the stairs.
All the tunes here (30 of them!) are
in standard tuning except for "Black
Mountain Rag," which is in the traditional
Calico. Here are many standards like
"Ragtime Annie," "Sugar in the Gourd,"
"Billy in the Lowground," "Eighth of
January," "Fire In the Mountain" (with
irregular B part, ending with a nice

flourish), and two tunes that I associate
with Texas contest repertoire, "Tom &amp;
Jerry" and "Twinkle Little Star." There
is only one waltz, "Shepherd's Waltz,"
which is played at a pretty good clip,
definitely for dancing.
There are a couple of tunes which are
new to me: "Wake Up Little Susan"
(which is neither the familiar cross­
tuned "Wake Up Susan" nor the Everly
Brothers' song), and "Ball and Chain
Hornpipe." After the latter, there's a bit of
dialogue in which H. K. says he probably
learned that tune from Stoneking (which
could be either Fred or Lee). It's really
nice to hear his speaking voice!
I always love to hear different
interpretations of Arthur Smith, and
Silvey plays "Red Apple Rag" in his own
style, emphasizing the notey melody
and without much "ragging" of the
rhythm, although he does sometimes get
in a few of those characteristic Arthur
Smith slidey notes. But on the whole,
his fiddling seems not much influenced
by blues or ragtime, more in the reel and
hornpipe vein (the up-tempo kind of
Midwestern hornpipe, not the dotted­
note Celtic kind). In this respect, it's kind
of square. But for me, the excitement
of the elaborate melodies and the quick
but not rushed tempos make up for the
absence of the blues.
Some of us older people had the
opportunity to visit with old-time mu­
sicians of H.K. Silvey's generation - musi­
cians who grew up in rural environments
without television and whose communities
still made their own music - conditions
which are hard if not impossible to find
today. Many thanks to Jim elson for hav­
ing the foresight to make these (and other)
home recordings. We all owe a huge debt to
Field Recorders' Collective for making this
and so much other music available!
Suzy THOMPSON
To order: www.fieldrecorder.org

Note to Artists and Record Companies
Please send all material for review to the
0TH (PO Box 61679, Durham, NC 27715).
Please do not send to individual reviewers.
What gets reviewed is determined at the
discretion of the 0TH according to space
available, balance of old and new, and
compatibility with our mission. We cannot
review everything that comes in nor
guarantee that because we received it we
will review it. We do not return materials to
the sender. Thanks!

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALO.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 29

�Molsky's Mountain Drifters
Closing the Gap

There's A Bright Side Somewhere / Grey
Eagle / The Little Carpenter / Fortune
/ Spring Of '65 / Closing The Gap / The
Graf Spee / Sweet Bride / Hog Trough
Reel/ Cumberland Gap/ All Gone Now/
Shooting Creek/ Let Me Fall/ K.C. Moan
/ I Get My Whiskey From Rockingham/
Greenback Dollar
I'll never forget the first time I heard
"Pop Goes the Weasel" in a collection of
archival Edden Hammons tunes. That
tune got me thinking about the origins of
the old-time fiddle repertory as a whole­
after all, it's not a tune I would expect to
hear from a West Virginia mountaineer
born in the 19th century. But that was
before it slowly dawned on me that old­
time tunes had to come from somewhere,
and if not composed within the tradition,
then where did they come from? Once
you think about it, it becomes obvious.
Depending on geography, one can hear
the echoes of global foundations in our
old-time fiddle music, as well as popular
music, minstrel pieces, broadsheets,
and cowboy ballads in the songs. But
today, there seems to be a kind of heavy
inertia that mandates a certain sound
and a predetermined set of music that
is defined as "old-time." Of course there
are complexities to this concept (if indeed
it exists) that are best debated elsewhere,
since this is a review of the latest album
from Molsky's Mountain Drifters.
My point is this. The frequent injection
of new tunes and obscure old material
into the old-time repertory is a good
thing. And no one does it better than
this trio. Their second album, Closing the
Gap, bravely and boldly continues down
the path they pioneered with their self­
titled first record. Fiddler Bruce Molsky
seems to relish the idea of bringing new
material into the fold. He has stated that
he wants the band's music to point to the
future of traditional, rural music. "I was
looking for a new voice," says Molsky,
"A new avenue of expression using old
30

time mountain music as the jumping-off
point, but not being constrained by hard
core traditionalism." It's not the first
time, for he already has under his belt
some side projects that fuse Scandi-trad,
Celtic, and other world musics onto an
old-time foundation.
Along with Bruce Molsky, the Drifters
are made up of Allison de Groot on banjo
and Stash Wyslouch on guitar, solid and
inventive pickers and vocalists who do a
stellar job of both supporting and inspir­
ing the veteran fiddler. Molsky was a Vis­
iting Scholar at the American Roots Mu­
sic Program at Boston's Berk.lee College
of Music when he first met Allison, who
grew up in Winnipeg, Canada. Boston­
based Stash Wyslouch got his start as a
guitarist in metal bands, and he brings a
wild energy to the band, pushing the en­
velope with innovative rhythms and tun­
ings. His bass runs fill in the bottom end
of the mix with a complexity that makes
me forget there is no bass player here.
The album opens with "There's a Bright
Side Somewhere," a wistful old piece
that eerily foreshadows the momentous
and devastating events that were soon to
come in the spring of 2020. Some of my
favorite tracks include "Sweet Bride,"
an old-sounding waltz composed by
Northern English singer Kate Rushy,
who is a superstar in the world of Celtic
folk music. The album's title track, made
by Allison, is a growling, raging modal
reel that would sit just as well in an
Irish pub session as in a dark hollow
somewhere in North Carolina. This
record contains a fair share of joyful,
impeccable harmonies as well as the red­
hot barn burners we would expect from
a trio of this caliber.
"The Little Carpenter" is an old ballad
that's reinvigorated by the injection of
Stash's unusual strum pattern. Molsky
previously recorded this one with
Mozaik, and it was also covered by
the New Lost City Ramblers as well as
Uncle Earl. The first known recording
was made in 1937 by a blind fiddler
named Jim Howard in Harlan, Kentucky,
recorded by Alan and Elizabeth Lomax.
But this one goes WAY back. The first
publication I could find was in William
Henry Long's Dictionary of Isle of Wight
Dialect (England) from 1886 and titled
"The Little Cappender." W. H. Long was
from a West Wight farming family and
the songs he includes in his Dictionary
were apparently "collected from the
mouths of the peasantry" on the island in
the early part of the nineteenth century.

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

"The Graf Spee," a four-part reel,
comes directly from the contemporary
Irish session world. On the surface
it is often thought to be named for a
famous German battleship from WWI,
for indeed the ship did bear the same
moniker, but for scholars who love to
dig below the surface, the tune's title
has a deeper story. No other tunes in the
Irish repertoire are named after modern
battleships, and its unique occurrence
was odd enough to arouse the interest of
researchers such as Brendan Breathnach
and Matt Seattle. They found the same
tune in the Gunn Book (Fermanagh,
1865) as "The Grand Spy." This was in
all likelihood a corruption of a still older
title, "Grant of Strathspey," composed
by Scotsman Robert Bremner (c. 171389). Bremmer published the earliest
collection of specifically Scottish dance
music around 1760. The title honors
the Grant family, who long controlled a
portion of the River Spey in the Scottish
Highlands. Castle Grant on Speyside
was the main residence of the clan from
1693. Over the years, the tune morphed
from a strathspey into a reel, gained a
fourth part, and changed its title.
What a perfect metaphor for the
evolution of the music we love. From the
Scottish Highlands to the Isle of Wight,
from a metal guitarist to "Pop Goes the
Weasel," our music thrives on cross­
fertilization. The proof is on this record
for all to hear.
STUART MASON

To order: mountaindrifters.com
Erynn Marshall and Carl Jones
Old Tin

Halloween Wedding March / Old Tin
/ Curly Tail / Turkey Scratch / Cause
My Sweet Love Ain't Around / Waltz Of
Old Memories / Southern Special/ Fos­
ters Favorite - Mr Barwick's/ Prayer of the
Donkey / Tulse Hill Days/ Colored Aris­
tocracy/ Reno Blues/ The Oaks They Do
Entwine / Bill Cheatham - John Riley The
Shepherd / Half A Century Waltz / The
Turning Tide

�A couple months before the proverbial
excrement hit the fan, in March of 2020,
Erynn Marshall and Carl Jones released a
lovely duo album titled Old Tin. The record's
name comes from Carl's song therein of
the same title, a song touting the virtues of
that old metal box that we all have, sitting
somewhere on a shelf, cradling bits of
flotsam and jetsam that evoke the emotions
of bygone days. That old tin is a perfect
metaphor for this collection of music.
When the smoke settled in the summer
of 2020, folk musicians found ourselves
looking at a calendar full of crossed-out
tours, camps, and festival dates. These
are events that we all look forward to,
where we renew ongoing friendships and
revive our stoke by drinking at the well
of the old-time tradition. Not to mention
the critical income we derive from these
events. Most of us had to stay home and
make lemonade from the lemons of 2020.
Looking back, we now see that it wasn't
all bad. We renewed our relationships
with our spouses, our pets, our homes,
and our neighbors. In Erynn's case, she
says that their garden was bountiful,
and the canning of salsa, pears, peaches,
and hot sauce filled them with a sense
of accomplishment. They had so much,
they were able to give some of it away.
What's better than finding a big bag
of fresh cooking greens on your front
bench, shared by a mystery neighbor? It
happened to me in 2020.
The simple joys of a kitchen garden in
summer are evoked by the music on this
album. In a nod to the communal nature
of the old-time community, keys and
tunings are provided in the liner notes, as
well as notes on the provenance of each
piece. Sources include a blend of choice
original works with plenty of obscure
trad stuff, and a Hank Williams song
that sits comfortably in the mix. One
of my favorites is "Southern Special,"
sung by Carl, a piece composed by Cecil
Campbell and performed by him and the
Tennessee Ramblers, who recorded with
RCA from 1934-1951. For me, this and a
few others sung by Carl seem to channel
the glory days of Norman Blake and the
Rising Fawn String Ensemble. Perhaps
I shouldn't be surprised, for back in the
1980s, Carl played mandolin with James
Bryan and Norman and Nancy Blake as
part of the Ensemble. As for the fiddle
tunes, they are impeccable in both curation
and execution. The discerning listener
will detect satisfying bits of the lonely
Appalachian sound, the Celtic lilt, parlor
melodies, and modem barn burners.

"Prayer of the Donkey" is an old poem
that was put to music by Carl Jones. It's
the kind of song that catches your ear
from afar at first, and reveals ever-deeper
layers of emotion as you peel back the
onion. The original poem version of this
song can be found on the web-based me­
dia collection of Smithsonian Folkways,
translated into English from the original
French in 1947. Writer Carmen Bernos de
Gasztold endured the German occupa­
tion of her homeland during WWII while
working in a factory and supporting her
widowed mother until her mother died
as well. Her difficult life is reflected in the
words of these verses, which shine a light
on universal themes------especially for wom­
en------even as they describe the hard life of
a lowly donkey. Tears welled up as I read
the words of the original poem, words that
survive intact in Carl's new song.
Sad music has always been an integral
part of the folk tradition. It reminds us
to appreciate daily the simple joys of
life. Raising a garden, the laughter of
children, the ring of a fiddle and a banjo.
These are the things that make life worth
living. From listening to this beautiful
recording, I'm pretty sure that Erynn and
Carl know what I'm talking about.
STUART MASON
To order: dittyville.corn

Hard Drive
Random Access Mash

Intuitions / Goin' Up Caney / Smith's Reel
/ Big Spike Hammer / Combination Rag
/ Brandywine / Bravest Cowboy / Alma
Waltz I Missouri Road / Where Is My
Sailor Boy? / Katy Hill / Bob Wills Stomp
"Hard Drive is a hard-driving aural
modern traditional old time authentic
mille1mial bluegrass collective made
up of Tatiana Hargreaves, Aaron Tacke,
Sonya Badigian, and Nokosee Fields."
The band's succinct description of
themselves provides a choice entree
into a survey of their 2019 self-released
recording. It is a solid record and well
worth seeking out if you want to get a

sense of what younger folks are doing
with the music here in the first quarter of
the 21st century.
Random Access Mash lives up to its
name as a mashup of a wide array of
tunes, songs, sources, and outlooks that
fit comfortably in the contemporary
and traditional old-time and bluegrass
scenes. Though this review appears
in the Old Time Herald, R.A.M. is, no
doubt, a bluegrass recording. Despite
the occasional view that bluegrass and
old-time music are like oil and water,
the genres are closely linked and old­
time music played a significant role in
the foundation of most first-generation
bluegrass musicians. As bluegrass grew
in popularity, the genre provided its own
inspiration and the significance of old­
time began to wane.
There have been groups such as the
New Lost City Ramblers, Dry Branch Fire
Squad, Hazel Dickens and Alice Gerrard,
the Strange Creek Singers, Jody Stecher
and Kate Brislin, and others, who have
come up with innovative ways to blend the
genres from within the old-time umbrella.
Hard Drive manages to combine their
sources in such a way that they sound
like a bluegrass band that is creating a
setlist from pre-1940 sources rather than
covering the Stanley Brothers or the
Lonesome River Band. In that, they are in
leagues with groups such as the Nashville
Bluegrass Band, an outfit that not only
plays Bill Monroe tunes but includes
gospel, blues, and traditional fiddle tunes
into their repertoire. (NBB and Hard
Drive both have good recordings of the
standard sacred number, "Gospel Plow.")
One could make a case that if you really
wanted to create a "traditional" bluegrass
band, your best approach would be to
go to the sounds, sources, and styles that
provided foundations and inspiration for
early bluegrass.
Hard Drive has done a mighty fine job
of collecting pre-WWII songs and tunes
that work well in a bluegrass band set­
ting. Their recording includes pieces from
the East Texas Serenaders ("Combination
Rag"), Bob Wills, Mississippi Mudstep­
pers ("Alma Waltz"), and the Monroe
Brothers ("Where is My Sailor Boy"), that
evoke their original recordings while sit­
ting comfortably as bluegrass pieces.
Music from bluegrass pioneers such as
Bill Monroe ("Goin' Up Caney"), Kenny
Baker ("Brandywine"), and the Osborne
Brothers, also find a home in the collec­
tion. As a collective, Hard Drive has the
chops to take the music on and do it jus-

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTTMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15,

UMBER 2 31

�tice. They are all very fine players, which
is a foundational requirement to play
bluegrass with authority. Additionally, as
individuals and as a group, they have a
solid rhythmic feel for bluegrass. This can
be a sticking point for some who try to
cross genres. As a self-defined collective,
the band sounds like a unit rather than a
hotshot leader with a bunch of hired guns
as side musicians. Tatiana Hargreaves
provides the lead instrumentation that is
hot but not overwhelming. Aaron Tacke's
excellent open banjo rolls evoke the play­
ing of progressive/ traditional/blue­
grass/ old-time picker Don Stover. Bass
player Nokosee Fields does a solid job on
the upright playing with a good bluegrass
feel, as well as with the bowing heard on
"Alma Waltz" and "Combination Rag."
Rhythm guitarist Sonya Badigian anchors
the proceedings with her first-rate play­
ing. Badigian and Hargreaves provide
soulful, flat-affect singing that evokes the
Carter Family with an obvious Hazel and
Alice influence. Laying back and playing
or singing it straight is not an easy feat in
our post-Mariah Carey world.
All that said, there is a little more
going on here than just a handful of
young folks playing tunes. Bill Monroe
was a genius singer, songwriter,
instrumentalist, and band leader but he
was also a world-class eccentric. The
old-time and bluegrass music world is
full of quirky characters and understated
humor has long tradition in the revival
since the '50s, as have surrealists and
avant garde musicians such as Henry
Flynt, the influential Holy Modal
Rounders and more recent groups such
as the Horseflies. It is not clear what of
the left-of-center aspects of the recording
are absurdist or humorous. I'll leave
that to the listener to make that call. The
package, with design by fiddler and artist
Sally Jablonsky, looks like it was done
in 1989 at a Kinko's paste-up table in a
classic indie poster style. The recording
itself veers off into the ether at multiple
points with dial-up buzz, Jake Lowe's
Casio Cowboy interlude, and New Age­
style guided meditations to open and
close the recording; and the "RCA Era Bill
Monroe Meets The Horseflies" version of
Katy Hill needs to be heard widely. All
that said, having no manifesto from the
artists, you'll have to make of it what
you will. It is nice to see a group that has
clearly spent some time listening to true­
vine music take some risks, get creative,
and poke some fingerpick-clad digits in
our eyes. Peculiar IS traditional.
32

Despite the title, Random Access Mash,
is not mashy at all, and though there is
some random in there, the music and
the design make a coherent package. In
the end, it is a fairly earnest, straight­
ahead, traditional offering of bluegrass
and old-time music that should appeal
to the hard-shell traditionalists as well as
those who are out in front, leaning into
the wind.
JOHN FABKE
To order: hard-drive.bandcamp.com
Scott Prouty
Shaking Down the Acorns

@ Scott

ra
•

Prouty 9

•

re
ra

a
m

@

•
•

@:J
•
•
@
@
•
� Shaking Down the.Acorns AD

�-ai
�
Old Time Tiki Parlour 016

Little Boy Walking Down the Road / Flying
Indian / Owl Hoot / Shaking Down the
Acorns I Icy Mountain / Roaring River /
Three Forks of Reedy / Fisher 's Hornpipe
/ Shannon Reel / Don't Drink Nothing But
Com I A Virginia March / Humpback Mule
/ Muddy Lane / Shag Poke / Puncheon
Floor / This Old Tm Pan's Got a Hole in the
Bottom Of It / Lovely Jane / Shelvin' Rock
/ Oyster Girl / Wild Horse / Liquor Seller
/ Joe Politte Tune in D and F / Fine Tunes at
Our House / Stump Tailed Dolly
MULTIPLE CHOICE TEST
This CD /DVD set by Scott Prouty is:
(a) An eclectic survey of fiddle music
learned from people Prouty knew
personally, or from recordings
(b) An instructional DVD demonstrating
bowing and fingering techniques with
liner notes discussing tunings
(c) A collection of jambuster tunes that
sound best on solo fiddle (or banjo), often
modified from the source recording,
discussed fully in the liner notes
(d) All of the above.
ANSWER:d

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, 1':UMBER 2

Let's take these sequentially. Scott
Prouty has been playing fiddle and banjo
for a long time, introduced to music by
his parents, Clarke and Sheila Prouty,
and nurtured by summers spent at the
Augusta Heritage Center in the heart of
West Virginia. There he got to meet and
learn from such traditional fiddlers as
Melvin Wine (whose portrait is hanging
on the wall of his dwelling and visible
in the DVD), Leland Hall, and members
of the Hammons family. He has also
listened carefully to old field recordings.
This CD/DVD set is not only very
enjoyable listening, but also a wonderful
teaching tool, especially if you are a fiddler.
It is one thing to play the notes, but the
secret of sounding good lies in the bowing.
By watching this DVD, one can see in which
direction the bow is moving to sound any
given note. Prouty first learned these
bowing methods (which are not intuitive)
from watching the older fiddlers, and then
was able to generalize those methods to
make a tune learned from a recording sound
like something learned directly from the
fiddler. Yes, you can saw your way through
almost any tune, but, as the saying goes, the
devil is in the details. There's a reason the
fiddle is called "the devil's box."
Why did I call these "jarnbuster tunes?"
Prouty's own words: "These are not tunes
I usually play in jams." Instead, these are
tunes reserved, he says, for solo playing.
Often, the source was also a solo fiddle
recording, such as the opening track, Blind
Bill Day's "Little Boy Working on the
Road." As is often the case, the tune is pretty
crooked. That alone does not make the tune
best for solo fiddle; most of us can play
"Newcastle" (the tune that Henry Reed
called "Texas") in a jam without any sense
of its weirdness. What Prouty has done,
however, is often to alter the tune and make
it uniquely his, carefully documenting the
original source, who he learned it from, and
how he and others have changed it, even
sometimes tuning a half-step low.
About half these tunes are from West
Virginia. Of the rest, many are from
elsewhere in Appalachia, such as the
Kimble Family's "Don't Drink Noth­
ing but Corn." He also included tunes
from the Midwest, "Oyster Girl" from
Bob Walters via Dwight Lamb, and even
one from the Gaspe region of Quebec
One warning:the names of tunes are not
often what you expect. "Fishers Horn­
pipe" from Harvey Sampson is not thL
tune in Cole's, and "Icy Mountain" is n
the one played by Ward Jarvis. Howe, er
"Three Forks of Reedy" is pretty muc.

�the Jarvis version (compare FRC 402)
and "Wild Horse" is pretty recognizable,
but a lot more crooked than the one usu­
ally played in jams. For all the reasons
mentioned above, this is another enjoy­
able contribution from the Tiki Parlour.
Thanks, Scott!
PETE PETERSON
To order: oldtimetikiparlour.com

Jake Blount
Spider Tales

Free Dirt Records DIRT-CO-0097

Goodbye, Honey, You Call That Gone /
Roustabout / Where Did You Sleep Last
Night / Old-Timey Grey Eagle / Move
Daniel / Blackbird Says to the Crow /
Brown Skin Baby / English Chicken /
Rocky Road to Dublin / The Angels Done
Bowed Down / Beyond this Wall / Boll
Weevil / Done Gone / Mad Mama's Blues

When was the last time a largely old-time
music album made a year-end Top Ten
list at such prestigious publications as The
New Yorker and the UK's The Guardian?
It's likely safe to say "Never." The critical
acclaim lavished on Jake Blount's May
2020 release Spider Tales would be the envy
of a debut album in any genre. (Blount
previously released an EP and a couple of
band projects, but this is the first full-scale
album under his name.) How did this one
rise from the sequestered old-time niche
to such wide notice?
Blount is an exceptional old-time banjo
player, a skill rewarded by winning the
2020 Steve Martin Banjo Prize and first
place in banjo at the 2019 Appalachian
String Band Music Festival. He's also a
fine fiddler and a good singer. On Spider
Tales he's joined by other young talents,
most notably fiddler Tatiana Hargreaves.
The two have great musical rapport, loose
but never sloppy, whether playing twin
fiddles or banjo and fiddle. There's terrific
energy between Blount and Hargreaves,
and that kicks up a polyrhythmic
notch when Nie Gareiss joins them on
"feet," as he does on three tracks. He's a
terrific percussionist! Thanks to expert
engineering by Joseph DeJamette, the
music barrels across with a very live,

CONNECT. DONATE. AliceGerrardFilm.com

Your donations are tax deductible thanks to our 501 (c)(3) fiscal sponsor,
the Southern Documentary Fund.

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 33

�in-your-face feeling. It's simply a great­
sounding, well recorded album.
In the album notes, Blount, who is Black,
writes of Spider Tales in African folklore
and calls the 14 tracks on his album (half
with vocals, half wholly instrumental)
"Spider Tales in their own right, passed
down largely amongst the same people..."
Most of the songs and tunes on Spider Tales
come from Black sources; three are from
North Carolina Cherokee fiddlers Man­
co Sneed and brothers Osey and Ernest
Helton. Blount spotlights the often-over­
looked African American and indigenous
roots of many fiddle and banjo tunes. He
also offers up a ring shout ("Move, Dan­
iel"), a spiritual ("The Angels Done Bowed
Down"), and a disparate couple of blues:
the vitriolic "Mad Mama's Blues," which
comes from 1920s "classic blues" vocal­
ist Josie Miles, and "Where Did You Sleep
Last Night," the much-covered Lead Belly
variant of "In the Pines."
For a good-time blast, the rollicking
"Rocky Road to Dublin," with the fiddles
of Blount and Hargreaves driven forward
by Rachel Eddy on guitar, Jeff Claus on
banjo-uke, and Haselden Ciaccio on
bass, takes the blue ribbon. For a more
astringent (but no less danceable) dose of
off-kilter ear candy, the spare-sounding
banjo-fiddle duet "English Chicken" is a
winner. Of Blount's vocals, "Brown Skin
Baby," which showcases just him and
his fiddle, may be the most engaging.
Anyone hoping to play along will find
fiddle and banjo tunings in the liner
notes. Spider Tales is a musical success
from creative young artists bringing fresh
perspectives to the old-time tradition.
MARK HUMPHREY
To order: jakeblount.com

Tricia Spencer &amp; Howard Rains
T he Old Texas Fiddle Vol. Ill

Tiki Parlour Recordings 015

Campbells are Coming / John Booker
/ Gold Rush / The Blind Man / Lost
Indian / Get Your Boots / Marg Williams
Cotillion / United States Marine March /
Lea Ray Wolf Chase (1,027 Dogs) / Cattle
in the Canebrake / Clear the Track / Billy
34

In The Lowground / Old Crippled John
/ Great Big Taters In The Sandy Land /
Go Home With The Girls In T he Morning
/ Where The Dogwoods Blossom, on the
Dogwood Trail, In Anderson County,
Texas, Where I Was Born / Mace Bell's
Civil War March / West Texas Blues /
Winding Sheets / Darkness on the Delta
/ Where is My Gray Horse?
T he subtitle displayed not on the package
but on the CD's readout is Little Tunes
from the Big State. T hat neatly summarizes
a good-natured sense of humility and
humor that pervades this set, from the
performances to the commentary and
artwork in the 16-page booklet. "Little
Tunes" isn't a dismissive description but
rather one of scale: tunes that are hand­
hewn and devoid of grand aspirations.
Fiddlers Tricia Spencer and Howard
Rains have been together, musically
and personally, since 2012. This final
installment in what Spencer calls their
"Texas trilogy" is both homage to past
tradition bearers and reflection of what
Spencer deems "our combined distinct
styles of fiddling ...a very specific
sound that is made when our fiddles
sing together." Twin fiddle is a Texas
tradition most popularly associated with
the Western swing sound of the Texas
Playboys led by Bob Wills, albeit a style
with Hispanic roots.
Kansas native
Spencer brings a different twin fiddle
tradition to the dance, that of Midwestern
Scandinavian fiddlers. She writes of
working to "hone my seconding skills and
revive a tradition that has been largely lost
to the old-time world." So while Texans
were the sources of the tunes here, the
performances unapologetically blur lines
of regional stylistic purity.
That might also be said of many of
the 21 tunes played in this generous
(70 minutes) collection. It opens with
"Campbells Are Coming," a tune
stereotypically Scottish if e'er one was.
Yet this version's source is a recording
of Austin fiddler J. W. Whatley, whose
portrait is affectionately if whimsically
rendered in pen and ink by Spencer in
the booklet, which also offers a brief
Whatley bio, complete with a couple
of wonderful anecdotes. The booklet's
art and commentary are integral to the
experience here: there are even fiddle
and banjo tuning details for anyone
aspiring to play the tunes. (Spencer &amp;
Rains are accompanied by their cohorts
in the Skeleton Keys-Brendan Doyle,
banjo, Nancy Hartness, guitar, Charlie

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

Hartness, ukulele, Emily Mann, bass,
and Joseph Dejarnette, bass-on "Where
Is My Gray Horse?")
"Recorded live in Howard and Tricia's
living room" is a production note that
explains the relaxed albeit professional
feel of these performances. Credit goes
to Joseph DeJarnette for recording,
mixing and mastering them so they don't
sound like field recordings. Even if the
performances weren't delightful (they
are), the booklet's insights into the lives
of the ofttimes eccentric Texas fiddlers
are worth the price of admission. One of
them, poet-fiddler Alton Mead, deserves
the last word here: "You carry the tunes
in your head and play them from your
heart, then you're an old fiddler."
MARK HUMPHREY
To order: oldtimetik.iparlour.com

Lone Pinon

Nuevas Acequias, Rfo
Viejo: Traditional Music of
Northern New Mexico

El Pajaro Carpintero (polka) / La Entre­
ga de las Canciones / Indita de Cochin
(Indita) / Mascando Chfclete / Upside­
down Varceliana (Varsoviana) / El Ro­
deo / Antonito / El Hermitano (Cutilios)
/ Once-Ochenta-y-Uno (Pasodoble) /
La Julia (Polka) / El Talean / La Polka
Suazo / Chotis de la Burra Orejona (Pol­
ka/Chotfs) / Munequita Linda (Swing/
Foxtrot) / El Valse de Agua Frfa (Valse)
J Rio de la Vaca (Polka) / Casa de Ado­
be (Canci6n ranchera) / Valse Arag6n
(Valse) / La Polka Montana (Polka) /
Capullito de Aleli (Swing/Foxtrot) / La
Cuna de Amores/La Estrella de Abiquiu
(Cunas) / La Suegra / El Templado (Pol­
ka/Valse) / El Valse de la Grama (Valse)
/ Cuadrilla de Pecos / El Tecolotito (Cua­
drillas) / La Despedida (Polka / Decima)
Lone Pinon's fourth album explores
the rich variety of regional music
found in Northern New Mexico, music
with far-reaching global roots. Aside
from some guest vocalists, Lone Pinon
is essentially a duo on this album,
but a duo of multi-instrumentalists.

��other hackneyed favorites, "Live simply"
and "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." Maybe
I need a new philosophical vocabulary.
onetheless, variety is a good thing
when it comes to old-time music. And
the recent release Stony Run from Ken
and Brad Kolodner is oozing with variety.
From trad standards to new classic folk
songs to lush originals, the repertory found
here is both dependable and enjoyable.
The arrangements include barn-burning
twin-fiddle ragers, mellow meditations on
hammered dulcimer, and bluegrass settings
with solos on the breaks and three-part
harmony vocals. But what really shines on
this record are the pieces that feature Brad's
gourd banjo and Ken's hammered mbira,
two instruments that combine to invoke the
deepest roots of American mountain music,
far away on the continent of Africa.
The what, you say? Hammered mbira?
(Unconsciously, my brain immediately
translated this to "hammered on beer"
the first time I heard it. W hich to me,
makes the instrument a perfect fit for an
old-time jam.) If you're a long-time fan of
the father-son Kolodner team, you may
be aware of Ken's unique instrument
already. After all, they have been playing
together for ten years, released three
previous studio albums, and the younger
Brad has already placed four times among
the banjo finalists at the prestigious
Clifftop fiddle contest. Ken's tune "Swift
House" won Best Instrumental at Clifftop
in 2018, and their quartet won the Neo­
Trad Band Contest at Clifftop in 2019. The
duo teamed up with well-known fiddler
Rachel Eddy on this record, who also
plays guitar and sings on a few tracks.
These guys are on a roll.
Ken Kolodner 's hammered mbira is
a hybrid critter designed and built by
Portland, Oregon-based luthier Don
MacClane. It uses hammered dulcimer
technique but features African-style metal
thumb piano keys instead of strings.
Perhaps better known over here as a
thumb piano, the original mbira came from
the Shona people of Zimbabwe, according
to Ken. He says the hammered mbira is
laid out like the hammered dulcimer but
has metal rods instead of strings. Players
use a variety of hammers to bring out
different tonal qualities. On this record,
there are times when Ken's mbira sounds
to me like a piano. (He also uses a muting
technique on his normal hammered
dulcimer for faster tunes, wruch greatly
reduces the unwanted dissonance that
results from the long decay of the ringing
double-course strings.)
36

The hammering patterns of the ham­
mered dulcimer and hammered mbira are
identical, making it easy for Ken to shift
between the two instruments. Hammered
mbiras are usually smaJ!er and more rug­
ged than hammered dulcimers, and be­
cause of the nature of the steel rods, they
tend to stay in tune. Their rods vibrate
according to their length rather than ten­
sion, so the mbira tuning is less sensitive
to changing environments. I can see the
attraction of the hammered mbira. W hen
I owned one of Sam Rizetta's big, beau­
tiful hammered dulcimers for a number
of years, I sometimes felt the fatigue of
a furniture mover and the frustration of
a piano tuner when I came to a jam or a
rehearsal with it. But beyond these advan­
tages, the thing just sounds good when
the tune is right. Listen to "Shakin' Down
the Acorns" or "Black Eyed Susie" on
this record and you'll know what I mean.
Ken's mbira and Brad's gourd banjo com­
bine to transport the listener to a distant,
dusty crossroads across the sea, where a
couple of dudes sit in the shade of a thom­
bush, making ancient music that touches
a place inside of us that some of us didn't
even know was there.
And if that's not your cup of tea, don't
worry. The next track on this record will
take you down another lovely musical
backroad. Because variety is the spice of life.

STUART MASON
To order: kenandbradkolodner.bandcamp.com

Stephen Wade

A Storyteller's Story:
Sources of Banjo Dancing

Patuxent Music Patuxent CD-333

Banjo Serenade / Market Square / Another
Man Done Gone / Peachbottom Creek John Henry / The Far-Famed Fairy Tale Of
Fenelia / Station Will Be Changed After A
While / Leather Britches / Railroad Blues /
Rhode Island Reel / East Virginia / Hobart
Smith On Music - Cumberland Gap / Voice
Of America Broadcast / Snow Camp / Old
Paint / How Ruby Played / Up Jumped
The Devil / Tales And Yarns / Wolves
Howling / Ray Nordstrand's Introduction
At Orchestra Hall / Chicago

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15,

UMBER 2

"The banjo is a world of sound," Mr.
Wade informs us at the start of this
musical autobiography. This 2019 album
commemorates the 40th anniversary of
the 1979 debut of his one-man show
Banjo Dancing. "It was a show largely
of spoken word pieces accompanied
by the instrument," Wade says, in a
YouTube video promoting this album.
"I sometimes sang and sometimes
danced." It was a surprise hit that ran for
years. Looking back, Wade shares music
that informed Banjo Dancing and other
chapters in his musical life, along with
discursive reflections and recollections in
the 44-page booklet that accompanies the
65-minute, 20-track CD.
The opener, "Banjo Serenade," sets
the pace. Wade offers a Whitmanesque
description of the instrument's attributes
spoken over a banjo tune learned from
Hobart Smith, "Chatham Hill Serenade."
He next sings and plays "Market
Square," a song learned from Fleming
Brown, Wade's teacher at Chicago's Old
Town School of Folk Music, who was
in turn greatly influenced by Hobart
Smith. Anyone who has read his book
The Beautiful Music All Around Us knows
Wade is all about connections, and that
applies to the way he's programmed
this album. Skipping through its tracks,
there are comic recitations, banjo solos,
and songs all held together by the glue
of Wade's associations. Some are from
his Banjo Dancing repertoire, while
others are versions of field recordings
celebrated in his book The Beautiful
Music All Around Us, and still others
tunes on which musical friends join
him. Those friends include Tom Mindte,
who plays mandolin on a fine version
of "Wolves Howling," and the late Tom
Paley, who fiddles on a 2006 recording
of "Leather Britches." Most delightful
is Doc Hopkins weaving anecdotes with
musical history in a 1982 interview­
performance for the Voice of America,
which finds Wade in top form playing
several vintage banjo tunes backed by
Hopkins' guitar. Another connection in
action: Hopkins was Fleming Brown's
teacher, so Wade's musical grandfather.
You would expect anyone who built a
one-man show around the banjo to be
a master of that instrument, and Wade
doesn't disappoint. He's fluent in several
styles, and showcases four in rus terrific
medley "Peachbottom Creek/John Henry."
We get examples of Wade Ward, Snuffy
Jenkins, Earl Scruggs, and, when he plays
bottleneck, Dock Walsh and Gus Cannon.

�Wade is an unlikely if enthusiastic
vaudeville revivalist: he gives his all to
the odd alliterative 19th century recitation
"The Far-Famed Fairy Tale of Fenelia"
and kindred quaint works, though the
best of his banjo-backed monologues is
his own "Chicago," a loving tribute to his
native city recorded at a 1987 benefit for
the Old Town School of Folk Music. It's
there we clearly hear why Banjo Dancing
was a long-running hit. Anyone who
may have experienced it will want this,
and there's plenty besides for the rest of
us to enjoy in the way Wade has crafted
this expansive career retrospective.
MARK HUMPHREY

To order: pxrec.com

Eliza Meyer

Hello Stranger

Hello Stranger/ Darlin' Corey/ Workin' Girl
Blues / When I Stop Dreaming/ Leaning on
theEverlastingArms/ Our Town/ Send Me
the Pillow that You Dream On/ The Cuckoo
/ Aragon Mill / When My Blue Moon Tums
to Gold Again/ Hills of Home
An old-time m with an emphasis on
singing! What a great idea, and well­
executed with Eliza Meyer's debut CD.
This is not purely an old-time CD; but there
is enough old-time music on it that a review
in the Old-Time Herald is appropriate.
Her instrumental skills are there, shown
by clean, rhythmic clawhamrner banjo
playing on "Darlin' Corey" and "The
Cuckoo," but every cut here demonstrates
that this is a singing CD.
To my ears, the character of Meyer's voice,
which has a lot of vibrato and breathiness,
comes more from the Dolly Parton and
Allison Krauss tradition than the Carter
Family. It is distinctive and enjoyable both
in her solo work and with others. W here
does her vocal style come from? Listening
to a lot of people, including not just country
and old-time singers, but also opera. Yes,
she has taken classical voice lessons, but so
did Vernon Dalhart!
Listen to the title track, "Hello Stranger."
A lot of Meyer's influences are apparent

in this arrangement. The first recording
was by the Carter Family in 1937 (who
learned it from Lesley Riddle), but Hazel
Dickens and Alice Gerrard worked out
their version in the early 1970s, You can
hear echoes of both recordings here, and
maybe Emmylou Harris as well!
Hazel and Alice are big influences; Meyer
covers Hazel's "Working Girl Blues" and
"Hills of Home." The first is sung as a solo,
and the second has Sam Gleaves and Kay
Justice doing harmony vocals. Not exact
copies of the Rounder recordings, but what
would be the sense of doing that?
Her producers, Cathy Fink and Liam
Purcell (who also appear on the CD)
knew, either consciously or instinctively,
that two voices with vibrato do not sound
good together but pairing Meyer with
someone who sings straight would be
synergistic. (Think of the way Charlie
Louvin allowed Ira's tenor to shine). As an
example, she and Alice Gerrard do justice
to the Louvin Brothers' "When I Stop
Dreaming," an excellent example of a sad,
self-pitying love song. Meyer has chosen
a number of duets from the honky-tonk
tradition, that one, "Send Me the Pillow
That You Dream On," and "When My
Blue Moon Tums to Gold Again" (which
I first heard on a Jim and Jesse vinyl).
Marshall Wilborn adds excellent bass to a
number of tracks and the versatile Marcy
Marxer adds mandolin, electric mandolin,
or nylon-string guitar in places.
Other often-recorded standards are Si
Kahn's "Aragon Mill," Iris DeMent's
"Our Town," and the hymn "Leaning
on the Everlasting Arms," done in three­
part harmony. "Aragon Mill" is sung
in the "modem" pattern of verses, two
verses together, followed by the "weave
and spin" refrain, and not the way it was
originally written. (For a discussion of
the evolution of "Aragon Mill, see the
Old-Time Herald vol. 12, no. 7, Oct-Nov
2010.) "Our Town" sounds much like the
original recording (and less, for instance,
like Kate Brislin and Jody Stecher's duet
version), but is distinctively Meyer.
The liner notes list the songs' authors
and who plays what. These are
wonderful to have, but I wish Meyer
had told more about her sources. Yes,
"Darling Corey" is traditional, but did
she go all the way back to B. F. Shelton's
recording, as Pete Seeger did, or is it from
some intermediate source? Questions
like this did not keep me from enjoying
Eliza Meyer's CD wholeheartedly!
PETE PETERSON

To order: elizameyermusic.com

Lost Gander / Going Across the Sea/
Cotton Eyed Joe - Sand Lake/ Hangman
/ Started Out in Town / Money / Six Foot
Under / Buck Dancer's Choice / Shag
Poke / Wave the Ocean / The Ballad of
Jonas Byham/ Melvin Wine's Uncle Pen
I'll begin this review by taking a wild
guess that Quarantine Happy Hour was
responsible for growing the reputation
of the Horsenecks by leaps and bounds.
Or was it just me? Because the Facebook
phenomenon of QHH introduced me to
the wonderful music of Gabrielle Macrae
and Barry Southern of Portland, Oregon.
Begun on April 6, 2020, by the duo,
QHH was an online concert series with
a different artist featured every day. As
of this writing, that's roughly 442 shows,
give or take a few. They even took it on
the road to Weiser, Idaho, where they
broadcast to the world from a tailgate
at Stickerville. The series was a lifeline
for the old-time community, putting
tips in our pockets, and it became a
place to come together every day, enjoy
the excellent music, and have fun in the
comments thread.
But I digress. We are here to discuss the
third album from the Horsenecks, released
in December of 2020 on Tiki Parlour
Recordings. Surely, they've taken on the
mission of Foghorn in making kick-ass
fiddle and three-finger banjo the defining
sound of the Portland old-time scene.
This became crystal clear to me when I
stumbled on a video of the duo playing
on stage with Kevin Sandri and Brian
Bagnonas, the former Foghorn rhythm
section, and raising the roof in the process.
But while fiddle tunes are the heart and
soul of this music, and the Horsenecks
bring their tunes with gusto, they have
so much more to offer on this recording.
All tracks on this record are compelling,
but Gabrielle's originals stand out by
being rooted in tradition and touching on
a personal level. The title track is a case
in point, where high lonesome banjo and

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 37

�Don Leister Violins
Richmond, Virginia
1--

Expert Violin
&amp; Bass Repair
Bow Rehairing

www.donleister.com

Our latest 2 CD set: Tunes from the Aurora
Violin Manuscripts, with quadrilles, waltzes,
polkas, and other dance music played in the
Aurora Colony of 19th century Oregon.
Many more CDs of old time fiddle music.
Books of dance tunes from 19th century
manuscripts compiled in the pioneer West.
Books of newly composed fiddle tunes.
Free downloadable field recordings of
traditional fiddlers from the Pacific Northwest
and elsewhere.

Voyager Recordings

www.voyagerrecords.com
Vintage Guitars
5-String Banjos
4-String Banjos
Mandolins
Ukuleles
Harp-Guitars
Hawaiian. Steel.
a Resonator Guitars
♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦♦

INTER MOUNTAIN
GUITAR 6 BANJO

fiddle play behind harmonies as good as
any, and a melody and a story that could
have erupted from the ground of a Kentucky
meadow like fiddleheads in the spring.
The duo managed to keep this playlist
endlessly interesting with a diversity of
instruments, sources, and arrangements.
''Buck Dancer's Choice" sounds at first like
solo fingerstyle guitar, but wait-is that the
lively patting of leather on wood by the feet
of a buckdancer as well? The liner notes are
detailed and thorough, and from them we
learn that some of the settings arose from
the inspirations of both archival sources
and modern covers of the same piece. Extra
points allotted here for going beyond the
archives and throwing in their own modem
take on the older stuff. We find references
to the obscure and the notorious, including
Frank Proffitt, the Kershaw Brothers, Sam
McGee, Dwight Lamb, Alan Lomax, Tun
O'Brien, Taj Mahal, and Melvin Wine.
What's not to love on that list?
In some ways, the Horsenecks span the
Atlantic with a reputation that has grown
on both sides of the pond. Barry Southern
came from Liverpool originally, while
Gabrielle comes from Oregon and honed
her chops by living for a time in North
Carolina. Every town that has a thriving
trad scene always has a few artists who
are the foundation of the community, and
the Horsenecks have proven to be a part
of that in Portland. We have them to thank
as well for keeping the flame alive online
during the dark days of the lockdown.
STUART MASON
To order: horsenecks.net

Reverend Gary Davis
See What the Lord Has Done for Me:
Rare and Unissued Recordings

712 E. 100 S. ♦ Salt Lake City. Utah 84102
tel. 801.322.4682 ♦ fax 801.355.4023
guitar a ndbanjo@earth Ii nk. net
www.guitarandbanjo.com

&lt;14utum�it\9
CLJSTOM SEWING

Custom made instrument case covers,
gig bags &amp; bass cases
Sturdy weatherproof construction
of cordura nylon and
high-quality foam
Heat-shield thermal lining
Any size, shape instrument
or equipment
Personalized quilted artwork
- We7/ cover your axe!

Betty Vornbrock

715 Peacock.Dr. Hillsville, Va 24343
276-766-3134 autwind@embarqmail.com

3,,

Stefan Grossman's Guitar Workshop
SGGW161/2/3

Disc One

Come on Brother, Let's Go Round the Wall/
I Belong to the Band/ The Old Ship of Zion/
Save Up Your Money, John D Rockefeller
Put the Panic On/ Blow Gabriel/ Tis So
Sweet to Trust in Jesus/ Don't Move My
Bed 'Till the Holy Ghost Come/ Great
Change Since I Been Born

THE OLD-TL\IE HERALD WW\\'.OLDU\IEHERALD.ORG \'OLU\ff 15, :\:U\1BER 2

Disc Two

Home (When Shadows Fall)/ Penitentiary
Blues/ Let's Go Down to Betty's/ Hard
Walking Blues/ Chicken You Can't Roost
too High/ Pray For the Lights to Go
Out/ Florida Blues/ Little Boy, Little Boy,
Who Made Your Britches/ Walkin' the
Dog/ St James infirmary/ Tie Me to Your
Apron Strings Again/ Yes Sir, That's My
Baby Now/ Old Fashioned Love/ God's
Gonna Separate/ See What the Lord Has
Done for Me

Disc Three

Down Home Rag/ Dill Pickles Rag/
That'll Never Happen No More/ Piece
Without Words/ You Want a Good Man,
Treat a Good Man Right/ Don't Let My
Baby Catch You Here/ I Wonder W hat's
Become of Sally/ Crucifixion/ Hesita­
tion Blues/ Cincinnati Flow Rag/ Joy to
Know/ St. James Infirmary
The story behind these recordings, made
in guitarist Ernie Dawkins' Pittsburgh
home between 1968 and 1970, is the
story of a young guitar fanatic's passion
leading him to a wonderful friendship
with his mentor, Gary Davis. That they're
only now seeing release, 51 years after
they were recorded, and 49 years since
Davis passed, might seem odd, until
you look through the man's vast back
catalogue, including countless hours of
posthumous live and studio recordings.
But then these sessions were never meant
for commercial release; instead, they are
evidence of Davis' willingness to share
himself through his music.
Dawkins-already enamored with folk
music in all its forms, and something of a
budding guitarist, enthralled with Davis
in particular-left Pittsburgh in 1965, the
day after he graduated high school, and
set out for New York City. It didn't take
long before he figured out Davis lived in
Queens, found his number, and called
him up about lessons. Before long, the
smell of cigars and Annie Davis' cooking
gave Dawkins the feeling of a newfound
home. A move back to Pittsburgh for
college allowed him to bring Davis down
for festivals-which led to Davis staying
in town for an extra week here and there
at the Dawkins home, which is how the
music in this collection came to be.
And let's be clear, these recordings­
slow, loose, spontaneous-are not the
place to begin if you're trying to sift
through Davis' ever-growing back
catalogue. (I suggest the compilation of
his earliest recordings on Yazoo and two

�early 1960s Bluesville LPs, Harlem Street
Singer and A Little More Faith.) His earlier
work shows a solo guitarist like no other.
Steeped in ragtime as much as gospel, he
borrowed from tunes across spectrums,
focusing on the sacred, but not afraid of
the profane. His voice, a gruff extension
of his guitar, warned and celebrated, as
he jumped from screams to moans. He
punctuated phrases with "Good God"
and "Talk to me," expressions that
certainly got him attention as a New
York City street busker in the 1950s.
His guitar playing was otherworldly,
uncopiable. He spun melodies on high
strings while running bass licks down
the low ones. All the while he picked in
intricate patterns with only his thumb
and index finger. It seemed impossible,
and even on record, it was spellbinding.
T hat a younger generation of white
folk musicians from Dawkins to Jorma
Kaukonen had their entire worlds altered
by him makes complete sense upon one
listen to his earlier work. He could wear
out a banjo or a harmonica too.
Even to someone already familiar with
his work, the tracks here add quite a bit
to what we know of his varied repertoire.
Besides the sacred songs for which he's
best known, we also treated to songs about
the economic "corn" panic of 1873 ("Save
Up Your Money, John D. Rockefeller Put
the Panic On"), period pop ("Home,
When the Shadows Fall"), a humorous
tale of a party gone wrong ("Let's Go
Down to Betty's"), and bawdy versions
of tunes covered in a variety of styles
("Little Boy, Little Boy, Who Made Your
Britches?"), among other nuggets. To be
critical, his playing here lacks the energy
of earlier recordings, and flubbed notes
appear here and there. His pacing is slow
and his voice, while still powerful, is not
nearly as commanding as he is known for.
Whether this is the sound of a man only
two years away from death or the relaxed
atmosphere of the home environment
isn't clear. What this set does allow for,
for those interested, is a perfect place to
study his licks, due to the pacing and the
space he leaves between notes. It also
demonstrates how Davis was a walking,
talking repository of music history as well
as a one-man orchestra. Stick with this set
long enough and become immersed in the
music, all the while recognizing you're
in the aural company of one of the most
distinctive, brilliant guitarists that 20thcentury America produced.
BRUCE MILLER

To order: guitarvideos.com

Tony Russell

Rural Rhythm: The Story of Old-Time
Country Music in 78 Records

Oxford University Press, 2021. xvii, 315 pp.

Tony Russell has documented and interpreted
a range of American vernacular music
traditions for over half a century. Readers
of the Old-Time Herald will recognize
him as a (or, in the opinion of many, the)
leading scholar of country music's early
years-the pre-World War II period
generally considered the Golden Age
of recorded old-time music. Russell
compiled the monumental reference book

Country Music Records: A Discography,

1921-1942 (2004), and he wrote the award­

winning essay collection Country Music
Originals: The Legends and the Lost (2007);
additionally, he published and edited
the legendary magazine Old-Time Music
(between 1971 and 1989). Yet Russell
has long been committed to exploring
diverse music traditions, with his
publications broadly advancing collective
understanding of the recording legacies
of Black as well as white Americans. He
authored, for example, noted studies of
blues music, including Blacks, Whites and
Blues (1970) and The Penguin Guide to Blues
Recordings (2006).
Russell has maintained unfailingly
high standards in his research, writing,
editing, and cultural advocacy, and
it would not be hyperbole to refer to
him as a national--or more properly,
since he lives and works in the UK, an
international-treasure. This reviewer­
having collaborated with Russell on
three Bear Family Records boxed sets
of old-time music-witnessed his work
being positively received both locally
where the featured music traditions had
originated as well as globally among far­
flung communities of old-time music
aficionados. Russell's latest offering to
music fans worldwide-Rural Rhythm:

The Story of Old-Time Country Music in
78 Records-is a (if not the) definitive
general interest (as opposed to academic)
book exploring the canon of prewar old­
time recordings. Rural Rhythm vividly

portrays the various people involved
in the making of 78 rpm recordings
while analyzing those recordings in
terms of theme, style, repertoire, and
performance, and while assessing their
historical and more recent reception.
The premise of Rural Rhythm is to offer
a curated list of old-time recordings from
the period 1923-1940. Readers might
be forgiven if they are wary of lists, as
conventional and social media outlets
regularly offer various and sundry lists­
generally with little or no curation--on
every imaginable topic (usually as guilty­
pleasure entertainment or as a ruse for
targeting ads to unwitting readers). And
even those music industry lists that are
intended to be received with a measure of
respect-halls of fame, registries, Rolling
Stone magazine's all-time greatest lists­
are fundamentally shaped by cultural
politics and group-think. But Russell's list
of old-time recordings in Rural Rhythm is,
simply and profoundly, the work of one
person uninfluenced by considerations
other than the opportunity to articulate
what he has learned from a lifetime
listening to and studying old-time music;
it is the work of one who has the depth
and breadth of familiarity with old-time
music recordings to compel us to take this
list seriously and to learn from its claims.
All of the recordings celebrated in Rural
Rhythm were products of commercial
enterprise, recorded in various locations
(rural and urban, South and North) in
both makeshift and established studios
and originally released to the general
public on shellac discs to be listened to by
their purchasers on home phonographs
(and, from the mid-1930s onward, on
All the recordings were
jukeboxes).
originally released on the common
commercial format of that era-discs
played at 78 rpm-and Russell settled
upon that number, 78, as determining the
number of old-time recordings he would
select to include and interpret in his book.
And what a remarkable list of recordings
it is! Starting off predictably with one of
the two sides recorded by Fiddlin' John
Carson in Atlanta during June 1923the OKeh release often credited with
launching the genre of commercial country
music-Russell's list takes in recordings
by acts ranging from the inevitable (such
as the Hill Billies, the band that gave the
genre of country music its early nickname
of "hillbilly music"; and Vernon Dalhart,
who recorded voluminously under several
pseudonyms), to the overlooked (including
Smith's Sacred Singers, an important

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 39

�pioneering gospel act not yet inducted
into the Gospel Music Hall of Fame), to the
obscure (the Steelman Sisters, whose 1936
recording discussed in the book has not [as
of September 2021] been compiled onto an
album or posted online).
Rural Rhythm is revelatory for the way it
maps out and navigates the early years of
country music. For instance, while incor­
porating five recordings from Columbia
Records' fruitful yet overshadowed loca­
tion sessions held in Johnson City, Ten­
nessee, during October 1928 and October
1929 (the book's striking cover image is of
Byrd Moore &amp; His Hot Shots, an act close­
ly associated with those sessions), the list
of 78 recordings in Rural Rhythm passes
over all the releases from Victor Records'
ballyhooed-some would say excessively
hyped-1927 recording sessions in Bris­
tol, Tennessee/Virginia. (Jimmie Rodgers
and the Carter Family, who were "discov­
ered" at the so-called "Bristol sessions,"
made the list, but for later recordings that
Russell deemed more illustrative of the
distinctive artistry of those two legend­
ary acts.) The Bristol sessions may have
received an undue level of attention as
the alleged "Big Bang of Country Mu­
sic"-with Bristol being dubbed by gov­
ernment officials and tourism leaders as
the "Birthplace of Country Music" -but
Rural Rhythm quietly but radically retells
the country music creation narrative. Se­
lected recordings are presented chrono­
logically in the book, with 14 seminal
recordings predating the 1927 Bristol ses­
sions. Russell offers sufficient documen­
tary evidence to challenge any country
music origin story trying to claim that
the already flourishing commercial music
genre began in August 1927 at those loca­
tion sessions in Bristol.
To be sure, Russell's list of recordings
is strictly the skeletal structure for Ru­
ral Rhythm. The body (and indeed the
soul) of the book is Russell's interpreta­
tion-his insightful, deeply researched,
and frequently witty yet always respect­
ful expository prose in combination with
evocative illustrations. Discussion of each
recording combines nuanced assessment
of the significance and uniqueness of
that recording with salient biographi­
cal information gleaned from Rus­
sell's resourceful efforts at "old-time
archeology" -a phrase he himself uses
to describe his process of uncovering
the buried stories underlying century­
old recordings.
The recordings described in Rural
Rhythm are all extraordinary examples
40

of unselfconsciously revolutionary mu­
sic-making by rural and mostly amateur
musicians, and, inevitably, Russell's ac­
cessible, multi-layered analyses will
compel the reader to yearn to hear and
compare the recordings. In that sense,
Rural Rhythm can serve as "liner notes"
to accompany Russell's list of 78 record­
ings from old-time music's Golden Age.
The commercial "boxed set" incorporat­
ing these 78 recordings does not exist at
present, and in truth it may not be justifi­
able since many of the recordings already
appear on other CD compilations. While
he himself has access to these recordings
(within his own collection or via loans
through the network of collectors and
scholars), Russell ensures that those who
do not themselves possess copies of the
chosen recordings can nonetheless hear
most of them. In the headnote to each re­
cording featured in Rural Rhythm, Russell
indicates available versions on previously
released digital compilations and/or on
two free-access online platforms (Spo­
tify and YouTube). (And perhaps some
inspired reader will take the initiative to
create a Spotify playlist to match up with
Russell's book.)
Fans of old-time music will treasure
Rural Rhythm, as will the large and diverse
American roots music fanbase. But the
book-because it possesses the integrity
and authority to challenge widespread
but overly simplistic and limiting notions
regarding the early history of commercial
country music-deserves the broadest
possible readership.
To order: oup.corn

TED OLSON

Drew Beisswenger and Roy Andrade
with Scott Prouty

Appalachian Fiddle Music: Featuring
43 Fiddlers and 188 of Their Tunes

Mel Bay 30091

As the helpful introduction makes clear,
this is no ordinary tune book. It's likely to
spend as much time near your reading chair
or laptop as on your music stand. "While

THE OLD-IDlE HERALD WW\\.OLDTL\IEHERALD.ORG VOLC\IE 15 :S:L'MBER 2

we do not envision this book as primarily
for fiddlers wanting to learn tunes," the
authors write, "we recognize that fiddlers
can sometimes puzzle over what exactly
is happening in a particular passage
on a recording. We hope our detailed
transcriptions will help fiddlers unravel
some of these challenging passages." Like
the transcriptions by Liberty Rucker and
Alan Jabbour in Jabbour's Henry Reed
collection, Fiddle Tunes Illuminated, the
notated tunes in Appalachian Fiddle Music
are loaded with information about what's
happening in any given moment in a
particular fiddler's recorded version. If
this makes them more suitable for study
than for sight reading, that's in keeping
with the central argument of the book,
that the fiddlers included here represent
a sophisticated and complex tradition
of music that includes performances
for listening as well as for dancing and
intended for an audience appreciative of
subtleties of style and interpretation.
One limitation of some tune books is
that they put the emphasis on playing
notes rather than on discovering what's
actually happening in a tune, and this
volume can serve as a corrective as
well as a guide, especially for fiddlers
new to the tradition who approach it
by working through lists of tunes rather
than by paying attention to models. The
authors are clear in their insistence that
no transcription can catch everything
that's happening in a performance, and
in their respect for a tradition that has
relied on aural learning to pass along
not just the notes shaping a tune but the
possibilities for elaboration and variation
and transformation. (The annotations
call attention to similar tunes with
different titles and to differing versions
of the same tune, as well as to the
complications when very different tunes
share the same title.) They are also aware
of the variety of resources available to
a student of the music, from skeletal
versions of melodies in online and in
printed collections, to scholarly studies
and detailed transcriptions, to the
historical and field recordings that are
easily found on YouTube or in internet
archives (so easily that the authors have
not included the usual CD of examples).
Like the old Whole Earth Catalog, with its
promise of "access to tools," this book
allows you to figure out what you'd like
to do and then shows you where you'd
go to learn about how to do it. And the
authors provide plenty of information
to get you started, beginning with a

�historical and theoretical introduction
that also explains their procedures.
Lyrics, for example, are included only
by way of brief examples; they are,
the authors note, available elsewhere.
Offensive lyrics or references are
"generally avoided" because "We want
this book to be an excellent overview for
general readers; other scholarly works
deal more pointedly with this difficult
but important topic." Transcriptions
were prepared by Drew Beisswenger,
"with a fresh ear, typically slowing down
the tune to 20% speed and writing down
exactly what he heard to the best of his
ability." A concise, but detailed history
outlines the origins and characteristics
and community functions of the music.
At the end of the introductory section is a
map of the Southern Appalachians with
a dot for the location of each fiddler, and
this sets up the rest of the book, which
is organized by the state in which each
musician was most active.
Within the section for the state, each
fiddler is represented by a photo and
an anecdotal biography, highlighting
the musician's background, musical
education (most often from family
members
or
neighbors),
playing
experience and circumstances, day job,
and recording opportunities. These make

for good reading as well as demonstrating
how varied in their experiences, how
integrated into their communities, and
how dedicated to their art these musicians
were. The biographies are followed by a
selection of tunes, each with a headnote
summarizing its musical characteristics
and a more comprehensive footnote. The
annotations to the tunes acknowledge
where Beisswenger was unsure about
details such as the placement of bar lines
or where the other authors heard things
differently; they also provide information
on the source material, the primary scales
or modes at work, the tunings, variations,
the hjstory of the tunes (with suggestions
about where to find out more), and
comparative versions, some included
in the book and some not. And, not
infrequently, there are good stories about
the players or the tune's origins along
with the pleasure of the transcriber's
wit. "It's hard to know what to say about
this tune," he writes of Ed Haley's "Old
Sledge." "One almost needs mapmaking
skills to sort it out." Of Norman Edmonds'
"Train on the Island," he comments,
"Played in a syncopated tied-note style,
with sometimes-stark fifths, and with no
guitar backup, the tune has an unhinged
quality." This good-humored mock­
exasperation shifts easily into frank

admiration, as in his description of French
Carpenter's "Old Christmas Morning"
as "an extraordinary recording, and an
excellent example of an open-tuned old­
scale crooked tune with mysterious, likely
Old World elements."
This is a thoughtful, well-produced book
that will get better and better the more the
reader puts into it. Want to learn about
one of "the very few women to compete
in fiddlers conventions in the 1930s, and
one of even fewer to win"? The biography
of Emma Lee Dickerson of Kentucky will
tell you about her early success, her "fiery
and rhythmic approach to dance tunes that
belied her reserved nature," and how she
stopped fiddling at eighteen to raise her
family, then went back to the instrument
after thirty years, and it will point you
towards the Berea College archives where
her tunes are available online along with
an article, "Finding Emma Lee Dickerson,"
by Anna Roberts-Gevalt. Then there are
transcriptions and annotations for five
of her tunes. You could read about her,
explore that archive, pick a tune to learn
by ear, and check what you're hearing and
playing against what Beisswenger heard
and wrote down. Then you could pick up
your fiddle and try it again.
JORDAN SMITH

To order: melay.com

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 41

�Attic

BANDS, ENSEMBLES, GROUPS, AGGREGATIONS
By Paul F. Wells

G

iven the focus of the Old-Tim� Herald �n string band m�sic, it naturally has been appr�priate that in most of our visits
_
to the Attic we've spent the time looking at photos of fiddlers and players of other strmged mstruments-though we
have made a couple of digressions to look at images that feature flute players (Attic #5, 0TH 13/5) and accordionists (Attic
1116, 0TH 14/5). This time out we'll venture a bit further outside the realm of string bands to consider images of ensembles
that include a mix of string, woodwind, and brass instruments.
Without supporting contextual or ID information, it's difficult to know just what sort of music bands such as those
pictured here would have played; I'm going to make the assumption that most or all of them were dance bands, the sort
of groups that would have been termed "quadrille bands." Such groups provided the music for fairly formal, high-toned,
society affairs, occasions that warranted the printing of dance cards, like those we saw when we explored the history of the
"Portland Fancy" dance some time back (Attic #15, 0TH 14/4).

t

No. 33.

-

8 BU-11\\H,

1..·01 11'1.

TER:MS_

Q,.,.,...

Although we are not dealing with old­
time string bands whose repertoires were
filled with breakdowns and waltzes,
bands of the sort we are looking at most
likely included a few fiddle tunes­
reels, jigs, and hornpipes-along with
more contemporary types. In the era in
which most of these photos were taken,
dances such as schottisches, polkas, two­
steps, redowas, varsoviennes, mazurkas,
fox trots, and galops would have
dominated an evening's dance program.
Nevertheless-at least in New England­
older contras done to traditional fiddle
tunes such as "Money Musk," "Fisher's
Hornpipe," "Hull's Victory," and
"Petronella," were still to be found.
Musicians in these bands were generally
fairly sophisticated, musically literate
folks. That they dressed well is evident.
We've discussed the fact that fiddlers
tended to dress up for the occasion of
having their photo taken (Attic #12,
0TH 13/12), but if the musicians in these
bands were playing for society folk they
would have needed to look their spiffiest
during their performances, not just for
the sake of the photographer. While it is
unlikely that the musician in any of these
ensembles were full-time professionals42

From 8 I'. M. until 1 A M, f20. nnd $1 per hour nft•r 1 &gt;1.. lf.
.\11 additional chllrJ? C "ill lit' m11de for bnlid11y� 0111111
occa,,ion,. Special rates )\'iven t,1 -.t•roc, of C'luh,.

and c,1wns&lt;••·

All ordl'r• lel'l 111 A. ,J. SA:NTP.F.'s BnokRture, prompth· attcn,l('(I to,
E. Tn \YF.R.
I I/
"""· Bt'('HA.X \S- 1 f. '"'''fl�l')t,

that is, that music was the sole source
of their income-they took enough
pride in themselves to dress nicely, and
presumably were paid well enough to be
able to afford to do so.
There is a certain consistency to the
instrumentation, with combinations of
instruments that were well-distributed
across the sonic spectrum. Bands typical­
ly featured at least one fiddle, but often
two or even three, to carry the melody;
flute(s) and/or clarinet(s), or cornet(s) to
serve as auxiliary melody instruments or
to cover the alto range; a cello, trombone,
or some other brass instrument to supply
the tenor; and a string bass or ophicleide
to anchor the sound. Some scores for
quadrille bands included parts for key­
board instruments; sometimes one of the
free-reed keyboard instruments, such as
pump organ, melodeon, or seraphine was
specified as an alternative to piano. Only

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLLME 15, t\:UMBER 2

one of our photos includes a keyboard in­
strument; what looks like a pump organ
is on the far left in the back row of the
ensemble in our final image. One photo
includes a woman who has no evident
connection to any of the pictured instru­
ments. We can speculate that she might
have played an unseen keyboard instru­
ment. This would have been consistent
with gender roles of the era. Drums are
present in only one of our photos. All the
cellos pictured in our gallery are conven­
tional four-string instruments, unlike the
two- or three- string instruments often
seen in photos of more rough-and-tumble
ensembles (see Attic #4, 0TH 13/4). Most
of the fiddles are held in such a way that
we cannot tell if they are equipped with
chin rests or not. In those cases where the
lower bouts are visible the presence or ab­
sence of chin rests is pretty much equal!�
divided.

�.

.
l l;)depel;)deflee♦B0ll
MUSIC'

Promotional card for Iowa-based quadrille band,
date unknown; dance card, "The Order,"from dance
held in Jacksonville, Vermont, in 1890, music t,y
"Philharmonic Orchestra (note dances done to tra­
ditional tunes "Money Musk,""Speed the Plough,"
and "Chorus Jig" on the program); band scores for
"American Quickstep" and "Fisher's Hornpipe,"
from John W Moore, The American Collection of
Instrumental Music, vol. 1. Boston, 1856.

.

, Philharmonic Orchestra.:,' ..
(·

�

l

f,Oj�J;Gft

R. Q. WILCOX, /'r'J•rft,,.r

_4��GLEN J{OUSE,.;;
�-,�ACK$ONVILLE 1 'YT,,

Thursday

*

FISHERS' HORNPIPE.

-L

�ICi1r 1 -t�m

--­
fr

-=tr

Evening, July 3

1

:fftit Irm IJ � r ffi.

-&lt;

No. 1.

13. \� nlo: 11.ml Galvp.

AMERICAN

QUICKSTEP.

.......

'P

All images collection of Paul Wells

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 43

�As is often the case with images from the
0TH Attic, we lack location information
for several of them, but those that do have
an identifiable provenance come from the
Midwest. I suspect that at least a couple
of those from unknown locations are of
New England bands, though that may
simply be wishful thinking on the part of
this Yankee researcher. The images range
in date from the mid-1880s to perhaps
WWI. During this period the population
of the known towns was generally
between 5,000 and 10,000. These were not
big-city ensembles.
Our first image, of a quintet consisting of
two fiddles, cello, cornet, and flute, is the
product of the George W. Smith studio of
Elwood, Indiana. Elwood is roughly 50
miles northeast of Indianapolis, 30 miles
west of Muncie, and 75 miles southwest
of Ft. Wayne. It was the birthplace of
Wendell Wilkie, the Republican candidate
for president in 1940.
I have been unable to find any informa­
tion about the Smith studio beyond the
address: 108 ½ South Anderson St. This
is right in the heart of town; the address
currently is occupied by the Chamber of
Commerce. The image most likely is from
the late 19th or early 20th century. This is
around the time that Elwood's popula­
tion peaked at just under 13,000 (per 1900
census). The town has an unfortunate his­
tory of race relations. In the 1880s Elwood
was a "sundown town," meaning that
African Americans were not permitted in
the town after sundown. Despite this, a
few Black folks attempted to settle there,
but were driven out in 1897.
There is a strong family resemblance
among the musicians in our image.
Even though there is an obvious span
of ages, they conceivably could have all
been brothers. Or perhaps two or three
brothers and offspring. As is often the
case, we are left wondering about what
sort of music they played, and in what
venues. Given the size of the group, the
instrumental line-up, and the fact that
Elwood was a small town unlikely to
have supported much of a concert scene,
we might speculate that they were dance
musicians. The tape on the neck of the
cello-a device to help the player know
where to place his fingers--suggests
that our man was a player of limited
technical facility, i.e., someone who could
provide simple bass lines for dance tunes
but would not be capable of playing
demanding chamber music.

44

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, l\LMBER 2

�THE OLD-TfME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2 45

�Our second image features a quintet with a similar
instrumental line-up, though with a third fiddle­
or possibly a viola-in place of the cornet. The
instrument held by the seated man in the middle
of the front row looks as though it may be broader
across the lower bouts than a violin, but that could
just be a function of the angle at which it is held.
The photo comes from the studio of M. J. Wyatt &amp;
Company of Holdrege, Nebraska. It is noteworthy
that M. J. Wyatt was a woman! Mary Jane to be pre­
cise. It is also remarkable that we are able to date this
photo more precisely than usual. Ms. Wyatt plied her
trade in various places in Nebraska but was in Hold­
rege from only from 1886 to 1887. Holdrege is, like
Elwood, Indiana, a fairly small town. It was home
to just over 2,600 souls at the time of the 1890 census

46

and has never grown much beyond 5,500. It is in the
south-central part of the state, below the Platte River
(and the route of present-day I-80), roughly 35 miles
north of the Kansas border. It was established in 1883
and incorporated the following year. It was settled
primarily by Swedish immigrants. It is on the rail­
road line; Amtrak's California Zephyr passes stops
there on its route between Chicago and the San Fran­
cisco Bay Area.
We are again left to speculate on the type of
music these fellows would have played. Dances,
or some other form of popular music, again seems
most likely. We should perhaps marvel at the fact
that in a small, rural Midwestern city there were
enough performing opportunities to support such
a professional-looking ensemble.

THE OLD-TNE HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, :'\UMBER 2

�There is no photographer or studio identified for
the image of the ten people sitting on the steps of
a large building, but the original owner very kindly
wrote on the back: "Return to W. H. Odell, Normal,
Ill." Normal is in North-Central Illinois and is con­
joined with the larger municipality of Blooming­
ton. The two cities are roughly 140 miles southwest
of Chicago. In the 2010 census the Bloomington­
Normal metropolitan area was home to just under
130,000 people but in 1910, the approximate date of
our photo, Normal had only a little over 4,000 resi­
dents. The town is home to Illinois State University,
which began operations in 1857 as Illinois State Nor­
mal University. As its name implies, its original focus
was as a teacher training institution.
The same person who noted the town on the
back of the photo-presumably Mr. Odell-also
numbered each of the musicians and gave at least
partial identifications for six of them. In the left front,
holding the bass bow, with numeral "l" low on the
right leg of his trousers, is a man identified simply
as "Stout." In the second row, holding the ivory­
headed flute, is D. W. Livingston (#2); next to him,
with no evident musical role, is (I think) "Brammon"
(=3). The woman (#5) is Nellie Phillips. The first two
fiddlers in that row (#7 &amp; 9) are not identified, but

the one on the far right (#10) is Geo. Wilson. The
trombone player on the left in the back row (#4) is
not identified but the cornet player in the middle
of the row is our man W. H. Odell (#6). The second
cornet player (#8) is also unidentified. It's curious
that Mr. Odell did not provide names of all his band
mates. Nonetheless, I was able to find out a bit about
him and the ones he does name.
Cornet player Odell, whose full name was William
Henry Odell, was born in January 1875. According to
census records he was a banker; by 1930 he had risen
to be president of whatever institution employed
him. He registered for the WWI draft on September
12, 1918, just two months before the Armistice was
signed. He died in 1949.
Nellie Phillips was a bit older than Odell; she was
born in 1866 and passed away in 1927. She is listed
as a music teacher in the census of 1900, then as a
dress maker in 1910. George Wilson, the fiddler on
the far right, was probably born in 1880-there were
a couple of men by this name living in Normal in
the early 20th century. This George was a farmer. He
also registered for the draft on the same day as Odell,
a fact less curious when one realizes that this was
the date when registration for the final phase of the
Selective Service Act of 1917 occurred.

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, UMBER 2 47

�����Our final image, of an octet in front of a clapboard
house, is the most enigmatic of the lot. Other than a
note along the bottom edge of the mount stating that
it is "Compliments of Rev. H. A. Carpenter," (which
has been cropped for reasons of space) we have no
information about the who, when, or where of the
photo. This is the only one of our images in which
the musicians are posed with their instruments in
playing positions, and the only one in which music
stands are present. It is also the only one in which
a keyboard instrument-what looks like a common
reed organ-is present. The presence of both a
string bass and cello (or church bass?) is unusual.
We again see tape markers on the fingerboard of
the cello as we did in our first image. The clarinetist
has stashed a second instrument atop the organ,
presumably one in a different key.
The mustaches and glasses sported by several
of the players give them a European look. Many
German-born classical musicians were active in the

52

US in the early 20th century. Might these folks have
been recent immigrants, who brought European
musical training to their roles as community
entertainers? The instrumentation, though, is
generally in line with that of the other ensembles
pictured in our collection.
The musicians in our gallery probably would not
be regarded as "folk musicians" in the sense we
understand that term today. They may have played
a few fiddle tunes for dancers, but would have done
so in community halls or theaters rather than in
barns or bars, and in context with more fashionable,
up-to-date pieces. They were community musicians
who occupied middle ground between those who
played strictly by ear, and those who had received
training in the intricacies of art music. They were
active in an era, and in localities, in which the
influence of African American music was scarcely
felt. They were the musicians of Middle America of
the late 19th and early 20th centuries.

THE OLD-TIME HERALD WWW.OLDTIMEHERALD.ORG VOLUME 15, NUMBER 2

rt1

���</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="14021">
              <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 15, Number 2 (November 2021)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="14022">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="14023">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 15, Number 2 (November 2021)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include: &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘The Preacher and The Bear’: Not a Folk Song, But a Song of the Folk,” by Ted Olson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Rhythm and Genes: The Moonshining and Old-Time Music of Southwest Virginia’s Boyd Family,” by Malcolm Smith&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dark-Natured Songs: The Bare Family Legacy,” by Derek Piotr and Jackie Hedstrom&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Clyde Davenport; Bill Stewart; Kathy World; and Mike Ramsey&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1640">
      <name>2020s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6992">
      <name>2021</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6994">
      <name>Bare Family</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6998">
      <name>Bill Stewart</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6993">
      <name>Boyd Family</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6997">
      <name>Clyde Davenport</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6995">
      <name>Derek Piotr</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6996">
      <name>Jackie Hedstrom</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6999">
      <name>Kathy World</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5437">
      <name>Malcolm Smith</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6266">
      <name>Mike Ramsey</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5435">
      <name>Ted Olson</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
